[{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/495","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/detection-probability-bats-using-active-versus-passive-monitoring","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bioone.org\/journals\/Acta-Chiropterologica\/volume-21\/issue-1\/15081109ACC2019.21.1.017\/Detection-Probability-of-Bats-Using-Active-Versus-Passive-Monitoring\/10.3161\/15081109ACC2019.21.1.017.short","title":"Detection Probability of Bats Using Active Versus Passive Monitoring","description":"As technology has evolved, bat researchers have relied more heavily on using acoustic techniques to collect data on bat communities. Acoustic data can be collected actively, where the researcher is present at the sampling point and follows the bat with the detector, or passively, where the researcher is not present and the detector is set out by itself. Active sampling can yield longer, clearer calls, and is only conducted during part of the night (usually from sunset to about 02:00 hours) for short bouts (20 minutes). By contrast, passive sampling can yield lower quality calls, but procedures are easily repeatable and data can be used to measure temporal variation in activity throughout the night and detect individuals and species that are missed during active sampling. Researchers are increasingly attempting to monitor and compare bat communities over time, including sites where both active and passive sampling have occurred. However, these two techniques can yield different detection probabilities and the extent to which data collected using these two techniques can be compared is unclear. Thus, in July 2017 we simultaneously collected acoustic data actively and passively to compare detection probabilities of bats at the Savannah River Site, South Carolina, USA. Using Anabat Express detectors, we detected five species or species groups (Eptesicus fuscus\/Lasiurus cinereus, L. borealis\/L. seminolus, Perimyotis subflavus, Myotis austroriparius, and Nycticeius humeralis) using each method. Using single season occupancy modeling, we found that method (passive vs. active sampling) had a significant effect on detection probabilities of all species, and that passively sampling throughout the night yielded the highest detection probability for all species. As a result, if differences in detection probability are not taken into account, comparison of historical active datasets with current passive datasets could lead to different insights into habitat use by similar bat communities. Based on our findings, we recommend that researchers use passive sampling throughout the night when studying and monitoring bat communities.","author":["Loeb, S.","Teets, K.","Jachowski, D."],"organization":["Clemson University","US Forest Service"],"originationDate":"2019-10-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.158801000000","-81.091065000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/496","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/us-geological-survey-energy-wildlife-research-annual-report-2019","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.3133\/cir1458","title":"U.S. Geological Survey energy and wildlife research annual report for 2019","description":"Access to affordable and reliable energy remains a critical need for people and the economy. To satisfy society\u2019s demand for energy, the United States is expanding access to vast natural resources to produce electricity as well as petroleum and natural gas products. Development of our Nation\u2019s energy resources, however, often conflicts directly with the equally vast fish and wildlife resources, which contribute billions of dollars to the economy through harvest, recreation, and services to humans and agriculture. The effects of energy development on living resources include fragmentation of populations, degradation or loss of habitat, and mortality of birds, bats, fish, and other wildlife interacting with energy generation facilities. Thus, an expanding energy infrastructure results in new requirements for land and ocean conversion for project siting and operational decisions to minimize risk to fish and wildlife resources. U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) scientists partner with more than 150 Federal, State, and local government agencies; Tribal nations; academic institutions; and nongovernmental organizations to deliver timely and relevant information on pressing resource management issues. This report summarizes ongoing USGS research projects and publications related to the impacts of energy development on fish and wildlife resources, tools to assess those impacts, and solutions to avoid or minimize risk. This information helps decision makers balance development with stewardship of the Nation\u2019s fish and wildlife heritage.","author":["Khalil, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2019-09-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Fish","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Khalil2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/497","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-acoustic-deterrent-reduce-bat-mortalities-illinois-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/wsb.1025","title":"Evaluation of an Acoustic Deterrent to Reduce Bat Mortalities at an Illinois Wind Farm","description":"From 2014 to 2016, GE Renewable Energy and California Ridge Wind Energy tested an ultrasonic bat deterrent system during the autumn bat migration period at an operating wind farm in Illinois, USA. The deterrent system consisted of air\u2010jet ultrasonic emitters mounted on nacelles and towers in a different configuration each year. Each year we conducted a randomized block experiment to determine whether the acoustic deterrent reduced bat mortalities at the wind farm. Effectiveness was based on estimates of bat mortalities during 3\u2010day trials. The operation of the acoustic deterrent resulted in significant overall bat fatality reductions of 29.2% (SE\u2009=\u20097.5%) and 32.5% (SE\u2009=\u20096.8%) in 2014 and 2015, respectively. All\u2010bat fatality rates were not reduced in 2016; however, annual all\u2010bat effectiveness estimates were influenced by species composition. We analyzed deterrent effectiveness for eastern red (Lasiurus borealis), hoary (Lasiurus cinereus), and silver\u2010haired (Lasionycteris noctivagans) bats, the 3 species most commonly found during the carcass searches. Hoary bats were consistently deterred each year, but annual deterrent effectiveness varied for eastern red and silver\u2010haired bats.","author":["Skalski, J.","Townsend, R.","Kinzie, K.","Romano, W.","Coppinger, K.","Miller, M."],"organization":["Invenergy Canada","University of Washington","GE Wind Energy"],"originationDate":"2019-11-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.389965000000","-87.749908000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2026-11-11 11:27:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Romanoetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/498","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-visual-impact-onshore-wind-farms-landscape-indices-method-objectivizing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261917315854","title":"Predicting the visual impact of onshore wind farms via landscape indices: A method for objectivizing planning and decision processes","description":"Visual impact is one of the main factors influencing the acceptance of wind farms by the public and by the authorities. It therefore often sets the environmental and social limits of energy policy and energy use. However, the assessment of visual impacts is subjective, as is often pointed out by critics of the evaluation process. The study presented here for the first time uses accurately and objectively measurable landscape indices to directly predict the visual impact of onshore wind turbines. The method also for the first time evaluates map-based landscape indices in a panoramic simulation, and this provides a better match of visual preferences with landscape indices than the cartographic projection used until now. 400 respondents from four Central European countries (Austria, Germany, Poland and Czechia) provided an evaluation of their scenic perception of 32 different landscapes, in each case with and without wind turbines. At the same time, we analysed 12 indices characterizing the principal landscape components (relief, land cover and landscape pattern) on the basis of the 32 landscape photographs. These were further tested as predictors of visual impact. The most prominent predictors of visual impact were the Percentage of Industrial Area (including Commercial, Logistic and Mining Areas), Percentage of Forest Cover, Density of Technical Infrastructure, Number of Elevation Landmarks, and Elevation Variation. None of the three landscape pattern indices was statistically significant. On the basis of a regression model that is able to predict the potential visual impact in large areas of four Central European countries (over 830,000\u202fkm2), we present the general principles of an objectivized method for predicting the visual impact of onshore wind farms. The method makes an automatic assessment of the visual impact in large areas of entire regions or countries via a GIS analysis of Sentinel data and DEM data. This forms a good basis for both preventive evaluation and causal evaluation, and provides significant support for objectivizing the planning and decision process in order to mitigate negative environmental and social impacts of the use of wind energy.","author":["Sklenicka, P.","Zouhar, J."],"organization":["Czech University of Life Sciences Prague","University of Economics Prague"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/499","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-mediterranean-sea-status-perspectives","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/10\/10\/1512\/htm","title":"Marine Renewable Energy in the Mediterranean Sea: Status and Perspectives","description":"In this work, an extended overview of the marine renewable energy in the Mediterranean Sea is provided as regards current status, potential problems, challenges, and perspectives of development. An integrated and holistic approach is necessary for the economic viability and sustainability of marine renewable energy projects; this approach comprises three different frameworks, not always aligned, i.e., geotechnical\/engineering, socio-economic, and environmental\/ecological frameworks. In this context, the geomorphological, climatological, socio-economic, and environmental\/ecological particularities of the Mediterranean basin are discussed, as they constitute key issues of the spatial context in which marine renewable energy projects are to be implemented. General guidelines for the sustainable development of marine renewable energy in the Mediterranean are also provided.","author":["Soukissian, T.","Prospathopoulos, A.","Denaxa, D.","Karathanasi, F.","Sarantakos, K.","Iona, A.","Georgantas, K.","Mavrakos, S."],"organization":["Hellenic Centre for Marine Research (HCMR)","National Technical University of Athens"],"originationDate":"2017-09-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/500","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/port-fairy-pilot-wave-energy-project-environmental-management-plan","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bps.energy\/projects","title":"The Port Fairy Pilot Wave Energy Project Environmental Management Plan","description":"This Environmental Management Plan (EMP) details the environmental management requirements for the Port Fairy Pilot Wave Energy project.  This EMP includes:    The requirements for environmental management during the installation, operation and decommissioning activities;  The responsibilities for implementing this EMP; and  Project environmental controls and limits to ensure that project objectives and targets can be achieved with minimum impact on the environment.   The Environmental Risk Register forms the basis for this EMP. It includes information on all activities which may have an impact on the environment, expected risk levels and controls, and limits to manage these risks. The approval of this EMP by the Director, Major Projects and Environmental Approvals Department of The Victorian Department of Environment, Land, Water \u0026amp; Planning (DELWP), is a condition of CM Act consent for the installation, operation, and decommissioning of the wave energy generator. BioPower Systems Pty Ltd (BPS) has responsibility for the project in accordance with the requirements of this EMP.  BioWave Port Fairy Pilot Wave Energy Project","author":["BioPower Systems"],"organization":["BioPower Systems"],"originationDate":"2016-02-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["-38.398417000000","142.172667000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:19:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BPS_EMP_092016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/501","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/baseline-assessment-underwater-noise-ria-formosa","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X19308872","title":"Baseline assessment of underwater noise in the Ria Formosa","description":"The Ria Formosa is a sheltered large coastal lagoon located on the Atlantic South Coast of Portugal, that has been classified as a natural park since 1987. The lagoon hosts a diverse and abundant fish community and other species of commercial importance. Several economical activities are supported by shipping, and as such, vessel traffic within the Ria Formosa lagoon is very intense at some locations during particular seasons of the year, creating high levels of underwater noise. Recently, strong efforts are being made to turn the main inlet of the lagoon, the Faro-Olh\u00e3o Inlet, a testing site for small scale tidal stream turbines, which will bring an additional source of underwater noise. Underwater noise can be one of a number of factors causing habitat degradation, as it can perturb fish behavior and cause physiological damage. Therefore, in order to comply with underwater noise pollution regulations, tidal energy technology developers are very interested in minimising the introduction of acoustic energy in the environment during the operation of their devices. Under the scope of project SCORE, which involved the deployment and operation of a floating tidal energy converter, this paper presents and discusses the first baseline noise monitoring performed at Ria Formosa. The acoustic data were collected in two occasions over several days, one in the winter and the other in the summer, in 2017. The obtained analysis results highlight the potential impact of the intense boat traffic in Ria Formosa, and the wide range of sound levels introduced in that ecosystem, and the high diurnal and seasonal variability.","author":["Soares, C.","Pacheco, A.","Zabel, F.","Sequeira, C.","Gonz\u00e1lez-Gober\u00f1a, E."],"organization":["Marine Sensing and Acoustic Technologies (MarSensing)","University of Algarve"],"originationDate":"2020-01-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.972554000000","-7.870570000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 08:08:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/502","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-consistency-stream-tidal-energy-development-policy-nova-scotia-canada","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X1930048X","title":"Assessing the consistency of in-stream tidal energy development policy in Nova Scotia, Canada","description":"The provincial government of Nova Scotia, Canada, has provided numerous incentives for developing in-stream tidal energy projects since 2009. These incentives include co-operatively funding the development of the Fundy Ocean Research Centre for Energy with the Canadian federal government and industry partners, extensive funding of environmental impacts monitoring research for tidal energy projects, and offering direct financial incentives for tidal power produced and sold to the grid via feed-in tariffs. However, the provincial government has not treated all scales and types of tidal energy projects equally. Until recently, ambitious targets for hundreds of MW of tidal development by 2020\u20132025 led to tidal support policies focusing on large, utility-scale projects, with little evidence the tidal energy sector was prepared to pursue such projects in Nova Scotia or elsewhere. Some support was offered to smaller-scale, community-oriented tidal energy projects, but the rules and regulations for such projects were repeatedly changed (and sometimes revoked) between 2012 and 2018. Since the provincial legislature passed the revised Marine Renewable-electricity Act of 2018, a potentially more coherent and consistent tidal energy policy consensus appears to be forming in the province. This paper provides a review of the policies introduced, projects approved and canceled, and sectoral outlook for tidal energy development in Nova Scotia for the period 2009\u20132018.","author":["Carlson, J.","Adams, M."],"organization":["Queens University","Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2020-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.166454000000","-63.064104000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/503","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-deployments-physical-impact-guidelines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/publications.csiro.au\/rpr\/pub?pid=csiro:EP181064","title":"Wave Energy Deployments Physical Impact Guidelines","description":"Australia\u2019s wave energy resource has been assessed as being arguably the largest in the world, thereby providing a potential future renewable energy resource to Australia\u2019s renewable energy portfolio. The past decade has seen several wave energy prototypes trialled in the Australian ocean environment. However, the wave energy industry globally is in its infancy and faces a range of barriers to becoming financially viable. One challenge is the uncertainty of the consenting processes, particularly in regards to the environmental impact assessment for the development and operation of ocean energy facilities.  To support the development of the wave energy industry in Australia, this document addresses the limited evidence base and methodology for assessing impacts of wave energy extraction on the marine and coastal environment. In particular, this document provides best practice guidance on assessing the influence of arrays of Wave Energy Converters (WECs) on the hydrodynamic attributes of the surrounding ocean. These guidelines have been developed as part of the ARENA and CSIRO-funded Australian Wave Energy Atlas Project (AWavEA). A wave energy project cycle typically consists of four stages (Appendix B): Preliminary evaluation; Feasibility study; Project design; and Implementation and operation. The guidelines presented in this report aim to support preliminary assessments of the suitability of a proposed site to deployment of wave energy converters.","author":["Hemer, M.","McInnes, K.","Contardo, S.","Hoeke, R.","O\u0027Grady, J."],"organization":["Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)"],"originationDate":"2018-02-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["-32.203436000000","115.677581000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/McInnes_et_al_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/504","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/large-scale-water-related-innovative-renewable-energy-projects-habitats-birds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/kluwerlawonline.com\/journalarticle\/European%20Energy%20and%20Environmental%20Law%20Review\/27.1\/19817","title":"Large-scale Water-related Innovative Renewable Energy Projects and the Habitats and Birds Directives: Legal Issues and Solutions","description":"This article discusses two legal issues that relate to the conflict between the interest of protecting habitats and species under the Habitats and Birds Directives, versus the interest of promoting the use of innovative water-related renewable energy, with regard to the quota in the Renewable Energy Directive. These legal issues are: first, the possible conflict between the protection rules of the Habitats and Birds Directive on the one hand and the Renewable Energy Directive on the other hand, and second, the lack of integration between the Renewable Energy Directive and the derogation clauses of the Habitats and Birds Directives. Tidal stream energy is used as a case study to show the practical relevance of the legal issues for the large-scale deployment of innovative water-related renewable energy techniques. The final sections discuss solutions to the legal issues. These are first, the application of adaptive management in combination with mitigation or phased deployment, in order to deal with uncertainty, and second, the introduction of detailed renewable energy plans per Member State in order to increase integration between the Habitats and Birds Directives and the Renewable Energy Directive. The final sections also discuss the applicability of the findings of this article to other innovative water-related renewable energy sources such as wave energy and salinity gradient energy (blue energy).","author":["van Hees, S."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/505","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-monitoring-report-emec-ak-1000","sourceURL":"","title":"Environmental Monitoring Report EMEC AK-1000","description":"This document provides a summary of the activity on the turbine site over the summer period and details the finding of the environmental monitoring of the AK-1000 tidal turbine. Since recovering the turbine last year the device was prepared with a new set of rotor blades and was initially installed on May 9th.  Shortly afterwards the device was electrically connected to the subsea cable by diver intervention.  Over the course of the summer the team worked through a number of challenges in order to complete the commissioning of the turbine.  Table 1 lists the activity carried out over this period.","author":["Rigg, D."],"organization":["European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)"],"originationDate":"2019-09-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.128445000000","-2.803811000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:20:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EMEC-AK_EnvironmentalMonitoringReport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/506","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behavioral-responses-sub-adult-atlantic-sturgeon-acipenser-oxyrinchus-oxyrinchus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/scholarscompass.vcu.edu\/etd\/4866\/","title":"Behavioral responses of sub-adult Atlantic Sturgeon (Acipenser oxyrinchus oxyrinchus) to electromagnetic and magnetic fields under laboratory conditions","description":"This study sought to evaluate and quantify behavioral responses by sub-adult Atlantic Sturgeon to generated M\/EM fields under controlled (laboratory) conditions, based on the study objectives outlined below. The study was to attempt to emulate the EMF conditions that migratory fishes might encounter near proposed marine HV sources originating from the Virginia WEA. By designing, building, and testing an EMF generator capable of producing a range of fields comparable to fields that might be experienced by Atlantic Sturgeon under natural conditions and in the vicinity of HV cables the research team exposed experimental animals to generated EMFs and measure responses based on a suite of simple behaviors under control and EMF conditions. This is the first published study to experimentally evaluate the effects of M\/EM fields from submarine HV cables on Atlantic Sturgeon behavior. Results of the study suggest that, under laboratory conditions, the types and ranges of M\/EM fields to which Atlantic Sturgeon were exposed in the laboratory did not result in biologically relevant changes to simple behaviors in sub-adult individuals. Hence, these results are not consistent with the hypothesis that localized M\/EM fields from anthropogenic sources\u2014specifically benthic HV cables\u2014in coastal ocean habitats may negatively impact behavior of migrating or foraging wild Atlantic Sturgeon.","author":["McIntyre, A.","Janeski, T.","Garman, G.","Deloglos, C.","Filippas, A."],"organization":["Virginia Commonwealth University"],"originationDate":"2016-11-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/McIntyre-2016-EMF-Sturgeon.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/507","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-extactable-tidal-energy-effect-tidal-energy-turbine-deployment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s13131-015-0671-2","title":"The assessment of extactable tidal energy and the effect of tidal energy turbine deployment on the hydrodynamics in Zhoushan","description":"In this study, we construct one 2-dimensional tidal simulation, using an unstructured Finite Volume Coastal Ocean Model (FVCOM). In the 2-D model, we simulated the tidal turbines through adding additional bottom drag in the element where the tidal turbines reside. The additional bottom drag was calculated from the relationship of the bottom friction dissipation and the rated rotor efficiency of the tidal energy turbine. This study analyzed the effect of the tidal energy turbine to the hydrodynamic environment, and calculated the amount of the extractable tidal energy resource at the Guishan Hangmen Channel, considering the rotor wake effect.","author":["Liu, Q.","Li, B.","Hou, F.","Bao, X."],"organization":["National Marine Environment Forecasting Center China","Ocean University of China","University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2015-05-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.054146000000","122.156648000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Water Quality","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/508","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/scapa-flow-scale-site-environmental-description-2019","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.emec.org.uk\/facilities\/scale-test-sites\/","title":"Scapa Flow Scale Site Environmental Description 2019","description":"The function of this environmental description is as supporting documentation to inform consent and licensing applications for the Scapa Flow scale wave test site. In addition, the document can be used a reference material to inform potential developers coming to the European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) to test their prototype devices of the environment within which the scale test site is located. This document should be used by potential developers to inform them of their responsibilities towards the receiving environment. An initial examination of seasonal environmental sensitivities has been undertaken, based on present understanding of the environmental characteristics of the area. The description covers the character of the physical, biological and human environment as well as conservation areas situated in close proximity to the Scapa Flow test site. The following sections provide background and a detailed description of each important environmental characteristic.  For more on EMEC Scapa Flow, click here.","author":["European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)"],"organization":["European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.851783400000","-3.397386100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-17 10:37:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EMEC_2019.PDF"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/509","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/global-environmental-regulation-offshore-energy-production-searching-legal-standards","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/reel.12296","title":"Global environmental regulation of offshore energy production: Searching for legal standards in ocean governance","description":"The international environmental regulation of all types of energy generation activities at sea is first and foremost anchored to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS). However, both at the global and regional levels, UNCLOS is complemented by an array of evolving environmental agreements. These normative developments can put flesh on the bare bones of the general (due diligence) obligation of States to protect the marine environment with regard to offshore energy activities. Parallel to binding obligations under environmental agreements, there are a variety of non\u2010binding instruments, which can also play a key role in enriching the content of prevention obligations. Depending on their source, their form and the procedure by which they are adopted, these non\u2010binding pronouncements may become legally relevant as interpretative guidance or standard of proof that a State has exercised due diligence. In this context, the article posits that synergies among environmental instruments and the interaction of non\u2010binding instruments with binding rules of international law can fill the current legal gaps and strengthen the international legal standards for the regulation of this environmentally sensitive sector.","author":["Giannopoulos, N."],"organization":["Utrecht University"],"originationDate":"2019-06-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/510","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dynamic-linkage-between-renewable-energy-tourism-co2-emissions-economic-growth-foreign","sourceURL":"https:\/\/latinaer.springeropen.com\/articles\/10.1186\/s40503-019-0063-7","title":"The dynamic linkage between renewable energy, tourism, CO2 emissions, economic growth, foreign direct investment, and trade","description":"Because of the lack of econometric studies in relevance to the link between tourism and renewable energy, the goal of this study is to remedy this lack and to explore the causal relationships between renewable energy consumption, the number of tourist arrivals, the trade openness ratio, economic growth, foreign direct investment (FDI), and carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions for a panel of 22 Central and South American countries, spanning the period 1995\u20132010. The empirical findings document that the variables under investigation are cointegrated. Short-run Granger causality tests illustrate unidirectional causalities running from: (i) renewable energy to CO2 emissions and trade; (ii) tourism to trade and FDI; and (iii) economic growth to renewable energy and tourism. In the long run, there is evidence of bidirectional causality between renewable energy, tourism, FDI, trade, and emissions. Thus, renewable energy and tourism are in a strong long-run causal relationship. Moreover, long-run estimates for the whole panel and for the three income panel groups considered (Lower Middle, Upper Middle, High) highlight that tourism, renewable energy, and FDI contribute to the reduction of emissions, while trade and economic growth lead to higher carbon emissions. Therefore, attracting foreign direct investment, encouraging the use of renewable energy, and tourism development, particularly green tourism, are good policies for this region to combat climate change.","author":["Jebli, M.","Youssef, S.","Apergis, N."],"organization":["University of Jendouba","Manouba University","University of Piraeus"],"originationDate":"2019-02-19","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Recreation \u0026 Tourism","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/511","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-trust-public-participation-acceptability-renewable-energy-projects-netherlands","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618310363","title":"Effects of trust and public participation on acceptability of renewable energy projects in the Netherlands and China","description":"In order to mitigate climate change and its impacts, it is crucial to replace fossil fuels with renewable energy sources. The extent to which renewable energy projects can be implemented largely depends on public acceptability. We studied how public acceptability is influenced by people\u2019s trust in agents responsible for renewable energy projects and the influence that people have over decisions regarding these projects. As expected, higher trust and having influence over major decisions regarding the project led to higher project acceptability. Public acceptability was lowest when people had low trust in responsible agents and when people could only influence minor decisions regarding the project. We found a similar pattern of results in our samples in the Netherlands and China, providing initial evidence that trust in responsible agents and public influence over decisions may have similar effects on public acceptability of renewable energy projects across different countries and cultures.","author":["Perlaviciute, G.","Liu, L.","Bouman, T.","Steg, L."],"organization":["University of Groningen"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/512","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-unmanned-vehicles-detection-monitoring-marine-fauna","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X19300098","title":"A review of unmanned vehicles for the detection and monitoring of marine fauna","description":"Recent technology developments have turned present-day unmanned systems into realistic alternatives to traditional marine animal survey methods. Benefits include longer survey durations, improved mission safety, mission repeatability, and reduced operational costs. We review the present status of unmanned vehicles suitable for marine animal monitoring conducted in relation to industrial offshore activities, highlighting which systems are suitable for three main monitoring types: population, mitigation, and focal animal monitoring. We describe the technical requirements for each of these monitoring types and discuss the operational aspects. The selection of a specific sensor\/platform combination depends critically on the target species and its behaviour. The technical specifications of unmanned platforms and sensors also need to be selected based on the surrounding conditions of a particular offshore project, such as the area of interest, the survey requirements and operational constraints.","author":["Gillespie, D.","Verfuss, U.","Sinclair, R.","Aniceto, A.","Harris, D.","Fielding, S.","Jim\u00e9nez, G.","Johnston, P.","Sivertsen, A.","Solb\u00f8, S.","Storvold, R.","Biuw, M.","Wyatt, R."],"organization":["University of St Andrews","Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/513","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-wireless-control-system-underwater-fish-eye-camera-monitor-fish-test-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/OMAE\/proceedings-abstract\/OMAE2019\/58837\/V006T05A015\/1067861","title":"Development of Wireless Control System With Underwater Fish-Eye Camera to Monitor Fish at the Test Site of Marine Renewable Energy","description":"Environmental impact assessment is important when marine renewable energy device is installed. Fishermen concern the effect of device on local fish. To confirm the effect before and after installation of marine renewable energy device, we developed wireless monitoring system using an underwater fish eye camera. The camera system is composed of a dome-shaped fish eye lens, a container, and a float. Two thrusters are attached on the container to change the monitoring directions. In the current research, this system was developed to monitor underwater situation around device remotely and in real time. We tested to monitor a target and fish in a fish case at the site off Kamaishi city. The recorded video showed the target and fish. Effectiveness of this system was shown through the field test for real time monitoring around marine renewable energy device.","author":["Kitazawa, D.","Mizukami, Y.","Yoshida, T.","Zhou, J."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2019-11-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.264797000000","141.936992000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/514","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecological-effects-electricity-generation-storage-use","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.cabi.org\/bookshop\/book\/9781786392015\/","title":"Ecological Effects of Electricity Generation, Storage and Use","description":"This book reviews the past, present and future generation and use of electricity. While noting the importance of electricity to the well-being of people, it argues that all means of electricity generation have adverse ecological consequences. The ecological effects of all the main forms of electricity generation, storage and transmission are reviewed in 14 chapters. The chapters briefly cover the engineering and physics of each method of electricity generation followed by a description of the different ways in which the technology interacts with the natural world. Finally, sections consider the importance of these impacts and how they can be mitigated or avoided. A final chapter summarizes the issues and emphasizes that the only way to truly minimize the impacts of electricity generation is to reduce our consumption and transmission. Future efforts should continue to focus on increasing the efficiency of light production, refrigeration, electrical appliances and batteries.","author":["Henderson, P."],"organization":["Pisces Conservation Ltd."],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/515","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interaction-marine-renewable-energy-marine-organisms-active-acoustic-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/researchportal.bath.ac.uk\/en\/publications\/interaction-of-marine-renewable-energy-and-marine-organisms-activ","title":"Interaction of Marine Renewable Energy and Marine Organisms: Active Acoustic Assessment","description":"As of July 2019, there are 8.5 GW of UK offshore wind installed capacity, and the UK Government has estimated 20% of current UK electricity demand could be met with wave and tidal stream sources. Scotland is targeting the equivalent of 100% of gross annual electricity consumption from renewable sources by 2020, having achieved 74% as of 2018. However, with rapid development of marine renewable energy (MRE) including wind, wave and tidal stream energy devices, uncertainty remains surrounding the environmental and ecological effects of installing and operating devices and arrays. Concerns include disruption of migratory and foraging behavior, direct mortality from animal collision with underwater turbines, attraction of animals to structures or to prey attracted to or aggregating around structures, or conversely displacement from preferred habitat. Changes in behavior of fish species, in particular those which are common prey of seabirds and marine mammals, could lead to changes in foraging behavior of their predators as observed at offshore wind turbines. Regulators, developers and operators need to understand the environmental effects of installing and operating devices and arrays in the marine environment.","author":["Blondel, P.","Scott, B.","Williamson, B.","Fraser, S.","Nikora, V.","Chapman, J.","Couto, A."],"organization":["University of Bath"],"originationDate":"2019-09-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/516","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/utilizing-wave-power-green-energy-remote-bc-communities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/prism.ucalgary.ca\/handle\/1880\/108755","title":"Utilizing Wave Power as Green Energy for Remote BC Communities","description":"The west coast of Canada has an abundance of potential wave energy. Currently there are many off-grid communities that do not take advantage of this renewable energy source and instead rely on diesel generators to fulfil their electricity needs. This study examines the viability of integration of wave energy converters into off-grid communities to lessen the reliance on fossil fuels for electricity. Implementation of a singular wave energy converter in the Tlatlasikwala community of Bull Harbour was estimated to yield 31.6 megawatt hours of electricity a year or around 13.3% of the yearly demand. Analysis of the economic viability through calculating payback periods using the average cost of wave energy converters and the fuel savings from renewable energy generation over a 20-year project life noted a requirement of funding by grants to recover costs. Included is a review of the current and proposed environmental concerns regarding wave energy converters.","author":["Fischer, E."],"organization":["University of Calgary"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.917174000000","-127.933462000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/517","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/changes-relative-fish-density-around-deployed-tidal-turbine-during-water-activities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2071-1050\/11\/22\/6262","title":"Changes in Relative Fish Density Around a Deployed Tidal Turbine during on-Water Activities","description":"Global interest in mitigating climate change effects is a driver for the development of renewable energy sources. In-stream tidal power, a type of marine hydrokinetic (MHK) energy uses tidal currents to generate electricity and is one example of developing a renewable energy industry. Effects and impacts on fishes in areas of tidal power development are a consideration, and presently there are many unanswered questions in this field of research. Knowledge of how fish use these areas before and after device installation is essential to informing regulators for decision-making. We attempted a Before-After-Control-Impact (BACI) study design to compare an index of fish density near and away from an MHK tidal energy device deployed in Cobscook Bay, Maine. The index was mean volume backscattering strength (Sv) obtained from 24-hour stationary, down-looking hydroacoustic surveys. Data were collected several times per year at an \u201cimpact\u201d site within 50\u201375 m of a device and at a \u201ccontrol\u201d site approximately 1.6 km away, both before and after turbine installation in August 2012. Fish density was lowest in March surveys and highest in May surveys at both sites. One of four comparisons (August 2011\/before vs. 2012\/after) indicated an interaction of fish density with turbine installation. Operational status of the installed turbine and on-water activity disturbances (e.g., industry vessel and diving activities) varied at the impact site and possibly influenced results. Lower fish densities were observed during installation and maintenance periods than during normal device operation. The effects of construction activities must be separated from the effects of a deployed device to effectively implement a statistically rigorous assessment that could separate the effects of these different activities. This parsimonious approach and results were used for permit licensing by federal and state regulatory bodies at this site and others and can be used to consider regulatory adjustments during different phases of device operation and maintenance.","author":["Viehman, H.","Zydlewski, G.","Staines, G."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","University of Maine","Echoview Software"],"originationDate":"2019-11-08","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.907749000000","-67.039379000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/518","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-landscape-time-year-bat-wind-turbines-collision-risks","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10980-019-00927-3","title":"Influence of landscape and time of year on bat-wind turbines collision risks","description":"Context  Collisions with wind turbines threaten bat populations worldwide. Previous studies tried to assess the effects of landscape on mortalities. Yet, the count of carcasses found per species is low, leading to a low statistical power. Acoustic surveys collect large datasets (proxy for bat density); however, if bat vertical distribution is not accounted for, a key mechanism in collisions is missed.  Objectives  Our goal was to disentangle the effects of landscape on bat density and vertical distribution to produce recommendations for wind farm siting.  Methods  With a vertical array of two microphones, we monitored the acoustic activity and located the vertical distribution of more than 16 bat species on 48 wind masts in France and Belgium (\u0026gt;\u20098000 nights). We modelled bat density and vertical distribution for six species in function of distance to water, woodland and buildings, and in function of the topography at three different scales (200 m, 1000 m and 5000 m).  Results  The proportion of flights at heights with collision risk was maximum in spring and autumn and minimum in summer for three species. This effect was often antagonistic to the effect of bat density. The landscape had a stronger effect on bat density than on bat vertical distribution.  Conclusions  Positioning wind farms away from woodland should reduce the density and therefore the collision risks of low-flying species but should be inefficient for high-flying species. The effect of topography was stronger at large scales and complex, thus studying situations such as coastlines or mountain passes would provide more insight.","author":["Bas, Y.","Roemer, C.","Disca, T.","Coulon, A."],"organization":["Sorbonne University","Biotope","Montpellier 1 University"],"originationDate":"2019-10-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.496050000000","2.044889000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/519","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/landscape-factors-affecting-foraging-flight-altitudes-great-blue-heron-maine-relevance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu\/honors\/478\/","title":"Landscape Factors Affecting Foraging Flight Altitudes of Great Blue Heron in Maine; Relevance to Wind Energy Development","description":"In an attempt to increase alternative energy sources, there has been greater development of wind farms across the United States. This expanded development may pose a potential threat to birds that are flying overhead (EIA 2017, Leung and Yang 2011). More information is needed on the factors that affect a bird\u2019s behavior while flying and if the current policies and dimensions of wind turbines interfere with flight altitudes. We used data from GPS-marked great blue herons (Ardea herodias) in Maine to classify their flight altitudes relative to wind turbine height and assess different landscape factors that affect flight altitude. We found an altitude range of 1 m to 924 m, compared to a range of wind turbine heights in Maine from 24 m to 156 m, with 43% of observed flight altitudes falling within that range. We found elevation, speed, proximity to open water and wetlands, and the proportion of surrounding urban development and forest cover to have a positive effect on flight altitude. Slope had a negative effect on heron flight altitudes. Our results can help to better understand how the flying behavior of birds is affected by the surrounding landscape, and therefore how that behavior may be affected by human developments, such as constructed wind turbines.","author":["Dolinski, L."],"organization":["University of Maine"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.807012000000","-68.790278000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Shorebirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/520","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/changes-european-wind-energy-generation-potential-within-15-degc-warmer-world","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1748-9326\/aabf78","title":"Changes in European wind energy generation potential within a 1.5\u2009\u00b0C warmer world","description":"Global climate model simulations from the \u0027Half a degree Additional warming, Prognosis and Projected Impacts\u0027 (HAPPI) project were used to assess how wind power generation over Europe would change in a future world where global temperatures reach 1.5\u2009\u00b0C above pre-industrial levels. Comparing recent historical (2006\u20132015) and future 1.5\u2009\u00b0C forcing experiments highlights that the climate models demonstrate a northward shift in the Atlantic jet, leading to a significant (p\u2009\u0026lt;\u20090.01) increase in surface winds over the UK and Northern Europe and a significant (p\u2009\u0026lt;\u20090.05) reduction over Southern Europe. We use a wind turbine power model to transform daily near-surface (10 m) wind speeds into daily wind power output, accounting for sub-daily variability, the height of the turbine, and power losses due to transmission and distribution of electricity. To reduce regional model biases we use bias-corrected 10\u2009m wind speeds. We see an increase in power generation potential over much of Europe, with the greatest increase in load factor over the UK of around four percentage points. Increases in variability are seen over much of central and northern Europe with the largest seasonal change in summer. Focusing on the UK, we find that wind energy production during spring and autumn under 1.5\u2009\u00b0C forcing would become as productive as it is currently during the peak winter season. Similarly, summer winds would increase driving up wind generation to resemble levels currently seen in spring and autumn. We conclude that the potential for wind energy in Northern Europe may be greater than has been previously assumed, with likely increases even in a 1.5\u2009\u00b0C warmer world. While there is the potential for Southern Europe to see a reduction in their wind resource, these decreases are likely to be negligible.","author":["Hosking, J.","MacLeod, D.","Phillips, T.","Holmes, C.","Watson, P.","Shuckburgh, E.","Mitchell, D."],"organization":["Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)","University of Oxford","University of Bristol"],"originationDate":"2018-05-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/521","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-energy-facilities-grouse-systematic-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10336-019-01696-1","title":"The impact of wind energy facilities on grouse: a systematic review","description":"There is increasing concern about the impact of the current boom in wind energy facilities (WEF) and associated infrastructure on wildlife. However, the direct and indirect effects of these facilities on the mortality, occurrence and behaviour of rare and threatened species are poorly understood. We conducted a literature review to examine the potential impacts of WEF on grouse species. We studied whether grouse (1) collide with wind turbines, (2) show behavioural responses in relation to wind turbine developments, and (3) if there are documented effects of WEF on their population sizes or dynamics. Our review is based on 35 sources, including peer-reviewed articles as well as grey literature. Effects of wind turbine facilities on grouse have been studied for eight species. Five grouse species have been found to collide with wind turbines, in particular with the towers. Fifteen studies reported behavioural responses in relation to wind turbine facilities in grouse (seven species), including spatial avoidance, displacement of lekking or nesting sites, or the time invested in breeding vs. non-breeding behaviour. Grouse were affected at up to distances of 500 m by WEF infrastructure, with indications of effects also at bigger distances. In six cases, a local reduction in grouse abundance was reported in areas with wind turbines, which possibly affected population size. Due to the differences in study duration and design, we cannot provide general conclusions on the effects of WEF on grouse populations. We advise applying the precautionary principle by keeping grouse habitats free of wind energy developments, in particular where populations are small or locally threatened. Future studies should preferably apply a long-term before-after-control-impact design for multiple areas to allow for more general conclusions to be drawn on the effects of WEF on rare and threatened wildlife species.","author":["Braunisch, V.","Grunschachner-Berger, V.","Coppes, J.","Bollmann, K.","Storch, I.","Mollet, P.","Taubmann, J.","Suchant, R.","Nopp-Mayr, U."],"organization":["Forest Research Institute of Baden-Wuerttemberg","University of Bern","Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research (WSL)","University of Freiburg","Swiss Ornithological Institute","University of Natural Resources and Life Sciences"],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.508644000000","9.298220000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Collision","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/522","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-turbines-redheads-laguna-madre","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21415","title":"Impacts of wind turbines on redheads in the Laguna Madre","description":"Freshwater ponds adjacent to the Laguna Madre along the lower Texas coast provide an important and heavily used source of fresh water for the redhead (Aythya americana) throughout winter. A 267\u2010turbine wind farm was constructed within the core wintering area of the redhead on a private ranch along the western coast of the Laguna Madre, in 2010. Our objective was to investigate the effects of this wind farm on the habitat and potential displacement of redheads and their use of coastal ponds along the lower Texas coast. We conducted weekly aerial surveys to monitor coastal pond use by wintering redheads from mid\u2010October through mid\u2010March during pre\u2010construction (2000\u20132003) and post\u2010construction (2012\u20132014) of the wind farm. Pond availability and Palmer Drought Severity Index (PDSI) within the wind farm were significantly correlated during pre\u2010construction (n = 16, R2 = 0.53, P = 0.035) and post\u2010construction (n = 11, R2 = 0.64, P = 0.003). However, the number of ponds available at each PDSI level within the wind farm decreased during post\u2010construction (paired t = 3.2, n = 5, P = 0.033). The average number of redheads detected per survey on coastal ponds within the wind farm decreased by 77% from pre\u2010construction to post\u2010construction. Redhead abundance on ponds across the entire Laguna Madre increased by an average of 3.26 times between pre\u2010construction and post\u2010construction, partly due to increases in the continental redhead population. It appears that the wind farm has altered the use of coastal ponds by redheads during winter. Future wind farm placement along the lower Texas coast should consider coastal pond distribution and the dynamics of redhead use between coastal ponds and foraging areas in the Laguna Madre.","author":["Ballard, B.","Collins, D.","Lange, C."],"organization":["Texas A\u0026M University","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["26.717015000000","-97.432220000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/523","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-farms-potential-locations-flat-oyster-ostrea-edulis-restoration-dutch","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2071-1050\/10\/11\/3942","title":"Offshore Wind Farms as Potential Locations for Flat Oyster (Ostrea edulis) Restoration in the Dutch North Sea","description":"The \u201cDutch Energy Agreement\u201d motivates governments and industries to invest in renewable energy sources, of which offshore wind energy is one of the solutions to meet the agreed target of 16% of the total energy budget from renewable resources by 2023. An option for the multi-use of wind farms is nature-inclusive building, in which the design and construction of wind farms make use of the potential for co-design with oyster bed restoration. This can support the government\u2019s ambitions, for the Dutch North Sea, to achieve biodiversity goals, restore ecosystem functions, and enhance ecosystem services, including future seafood production. For the recovery of flat oyster (Ostrea edulis) beds, knowledge is required about the conditions under which active restoration of this species in the North Sea can be successfully implemented. This paper gives a framework and presents results to determine suitability of wind farms for flat oyster restoration, and provides recommendations for pilot studies. Our analysis showed that a number of wind farms in the Dutch section of the North Sea are suitable locations for development of flat oyster beds. Combining oyster restoration and oyster culture, as a protein source, is a viable option worth investigating.","author":["van Duren, L.","van der Have, T.","Kamermans, P.","Walles, B.","Kraan, M.","Kleissen, F.","Smaal, A.","Poelman, M."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","Deltares (NL)","Bureau Waardenburg bv"],"originationDate":"2018-10-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.212572000000","4.612594000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2026-06-05 08:16:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kamermans-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/524","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-power-desalination-plant-north-gran-canaria-island-wave-resource","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479718312052","title":"Wave energy to power a desalination plant in the north of Gran Canaria Island: Wave resource, socioeconomic and environmental assessment","description":"The Canary Islands are recognized as an area of particular interest to exploit and to promote the use of renewable energies as a way to reduce its energy dependence on fossil fuels and ultimately reach energy self-sufficiency and sustainability. A common major problem in mid-latitude small and remote islands is the low annual precipitation rate and the associated freshwater scarcity, leading to the installation of desalination plants powered by oil. In this context, the assessment of wave energy potential along with socioeconomic and environmental factors in a selected area at the north side of Gran Canaria Island shows that wave power availability is adequate for its exploitation and there are no sources of potential conflicts that prevent the installation of wave energy converters. In particular, the harvesting of wave energy to power existing seawater desalination plants, fully based in the use of oil, is considered as a viable, appealing and advantageous alternative over the direct injection to the electric network.","author":["Fern\u00e1ndez Prieto, L.","Rodr\u00edguez Rodr\u00edguez, G.","Schallenberg Rodr\u00edguez, J."],"organization":["Universidad de Las Palmas de Gran Canaria"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["28.189231000000","-15.541832000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/525","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysis-based-results-delineation-prearrangement-areas-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.e3s-conferences.org\/articles\/e3sconf\/abs\/2018\/26\/e3sconf_icacer2018_01009\/e3sconf_icacer2018_01009.html","title":"Analysis-based results on the delineation of prearrangement areas for marine renewable energy installations in the Western Black Sea Basin","description":"The selection of optimum places for installations and suitable solutions for the use of marine renewable energy requires a complex approach as well as a longer period of time and a spatial scale hydrodynamic characterization, which time-limited and local studies are incapable to provide. To that end, the complex monitoring and modelling approach on the evolution of large-scale marine and coastal processes in response to both direct and indirect human intervention and to natural phenomena variability is an increasingly important issue in the Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM) and MSP implementation, all over the world. The installation of wave\/currents devices within coastal and marine areas involves the knowledge of the physical, economic and social impact of the continuous modification of the marine hydrodynamics, due to the new changes induced in the marine climate. The present work adequately takes into account the combined results of Marine Spatial Planning Directive applications within Western Black Sea Basin (WBSB). The MSP approach allows the selection of efficient areas for the installation of marine waves and currents devices converters (WECs), in relation with the potential environmental impact of adjacent MPAs, taking into account the induced strong variability of renewable devices\/convertors on the coastal processes. Recommended areas for the installation of the above-mentioned devices within highly energetic areas asked for a proper response in order to develop a detailed delineation targeting a sustainable coastal protection.","author":["Rusu, L.","Mateescu, R.","Vlasceanu, E."],"organization":["National Institute for Marine Research and Development Constanta","Maritime University of Constanta","Dunarea de Jos University of Galati"],"originationDate":"2018-08-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.302194000000","29.270279000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/526","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-waves-morphodynamic-impacts-energy-extraction-tidal-stream-turbine-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118301794","title":"The influence of waves on morphodynamic impacts of energy extraction at a tidal stream turbine site in the Pentland Firth","description":"Extraction of energy from tidal streams has the potential to impact on the morphodynamics of areas such as sub-tidal sandbanks via alteration of hydrodynamics. Marine sediment transport is forced by both wave and tidal currents. Past work on tidal stream turbine impacts has largely ignored the contribution of waves. Here, a fully coupled hydrodynamic, spectral wave and sediment transport model is used to assess the importance of including waves in simulations of turbine impact on seabed morphodynamics. Assessment of this is important due to the additional expense of including waves in simulations. Focus is given to a sandbank in the Inner Sound of the Pentland Firth. It is found that inclusion of wave action alters hydrodynamics, although extent of alteration is dependant of wave direction. Magnitude of sediment transport is increased when waves are included in the simulations and this has implications for morphological and volumetric changes. Volumetric changes are substantially increased when wave action is included: the impact of including waves is greater than the impact of including tidal stream turbines. Therefore it is recommended that at tidal turbine array sites exposed to large swell or wind-seas, waves should be considered for inclusion in simulations of physical impact.","author":["Masters, I.","Fairley, I.","Karunarathna, H."],"organization":["Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.716121000000","-3.115007000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/527","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/galway-bay-marine-renewable-energy-test-site-foreshore-lease-application-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.housing.gov.ie\/sites\/default\/files\/foreshore-applications\/application-documents\/marine_institute-spiddal-environmental_report.pdf","title":"Galway Bay Marine and Renewable Energy Test Site Foreshore Lease Application Environmental Report","description":"As part of the implementation of the original Ocean Energy Strategy (2006), a \u00bc scale wave energy test site has been operational in Galway Bay for 10 years. This proposed foreshore lease application for the Galway Bay Marine and Renewable Energy Test Site (MARETS) is an evolution of the original test site and will provide enhanced research capabilities and test infrastructure. The upgrade of the test site is an integral component of Ireland\u2019s OREDP and will facilitate testing and validation of various ocean energy converters and prototypes in conditions that represent \u00bc scale of the open Atlantic Ocean environment.  The proposed development will provide a national cabled test facility, to which wave energy converters can be connected during testing phases, and where other marine technologies and componentry can be tested and evaluated. The experience gained from deployment at the test site will assist commercial scale wave energy production in the future at suitable locations around the Irish Coast.","author":["The Marine Institute"],"organization":["Irish Marine Institute","Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI)"],"originationDate":"2016-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.232665000000","-9.269599000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-07 06:19:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/marine_institute-spiddal-environmental_report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/528","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/coastal-protection-through-wave-farms-feasibility-assessment-using-numerical-wave","sourceURL":"https:\/\/search.informit.com.au\/documentSummary;dn=929988672227956;res=IELENG","title":"Coastal protection through wave farms: Feasibility assessment using numerical wave modelling and parametric study","description":"The Australian government has set a 23.5% target of renewable energy by the year 2020 as part of Australia\u0027s commitment to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions. CSIRO has recently produced an assessment of the ocean wave energy resource in Australia and identified the Southern Margin to be one of the most energetic areas worldwide suitable for the extraction of wave energy for electricity production. While most wave energy projects have been up to now based around single unit devices, recent projects and the long-term aim of this new industry includes deployment of multi-device wave farms, which introduces potential for such projects to provide additional benefits through coastal protection.  Port Fairy, located on the southern coast of Victoria, is home to a wave energy pilot project with BioPower Systems (BPS) having deployed their bioWAVE device at the end of 2015. In the recent years, Port Fairy has also been the subject of multiple high-level coastal processes studies in order to gain a better understanding of present and future coastal hazards.  This works aims to assess the potential for wave energy farms, comprising of a large number of wave energy converters (WEC) deployed in an array configuration, to provide coastal protection at the case study site of East Beach in Port Fairy. This assessment is performed using a modified version of an industry standard wave model (SWAN), which allows the incorporation of device-specific WEC characteristics to specify obstacle transmission. The SWAN model was calibrated against both nearshore (ADCP) and offshore (waverider buoys) wave records. The analysis investigated the influence of the number of WECs within the array on the reduction of the transmitted wave height in mild storm conditions, where WECs would be expected to operate.","author":["Flocard, F.","Hoeke, R."],"organization":["BioPower Systems","Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)"],"originationDate":"2017-06-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["-38.374136000000","142.261447000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/529","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-farm-impact-beach-modal-state","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025322715000171","title":"Wave farm impact on beach modal state","description":"The extraction of wave energy by the Wave Energy Converters (WECs) forming a wave farm results in a milder wave climate in its lee, which can have an impact on coastal processes. The objective of this work is to determine whether the beach morphology can be altered by the operation of the wave farm, and if so, to quantify this alteration. For this purpose, we examine how the farm affects the modal state of the beach with reference to a baseline (no farm) scenario. The modal state is defined based on an empirical classification that accounts for wave conditions, tidal regime and sediment size. As a beach typically goes through different modal states, we determine the percentages of time in an average year corresponding to each state in the baseline scenario, and how these percentages are altered by a wave farm as a function of its distance from the coast. This methodology is illustrated through a case study: Perranporth Beach (UK), an area of great potential for wave energy development. High-resolution numerical modelling is used, with two levels of grid refinement. We find that the wave farm has a relevant impact on the modal state of the system, which passes from wave-dominated to tide-dominated during significant periods of time. The sensitivity analysis, involving three cases with the farm at distances of 2\u00a0km, 4\u00a0km and 6\u00a0km from the beach, showed that the farm-to-coast distance plays a major role. Thus, the shift from a wave- to a tide-dominated beach is exacerbated in the case of the wave farm closest to the coastline, with the submarine bar vanishing over long periods of time. We conclude that the presence of the wave farm drastically alters the morphological response of the beach, and that this alteration is strongly dependent on the farm-to-coast distance.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Greaves, D.","Abanades, J."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2015-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.359933000000","-5.151258000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/530","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/coastal-defence-through-wave-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378383914001306","title":"Coastal defence through wave farms","description":"The possibility of using wave farms for coastal defence warrants investigation because wave energy is poised to become a major renewable in many countries over the next decades. The fundamental question in this regard is whether a wave farm can be used to reduce beach erosion under storm conditions. If the answer to this question is positive, then a wave farm can have coastal defence as a subsidiary function, in addition to its primary role of producing carbon-free energy. The objective of this work is to address this question by comparing the response of a beach in the face of a storm in two scenarios: with and without the wave farm. For this comparison a set of ad hoc impact indicators is developed: the bed level impact (BLI), beach face eroded area (FEA), non-dimensional erosion reduction (NER), and mean cumulative eroded area (CEA); and their values are determined by means of two coupled models: a high-resolution wave propagation model (SWAN) and a coastal processes model (XBeach). The study is conducted through a case study: Perranporth Beach (UK). Backed by a well-developed dune system, Perranporth has a bar between \u2212\u00a05\u00a0m and \u2212\u00a010\u00a0m. The results show that the wave farm reduces the eroded volume by as much as 50% and thus contributes effectively to coastal protection. This synergy between marine renewable energy and coastal defence may well contribute to improving the viability of wave farms through savings in conventional coastal protection.\u00a0","author":["Iglesias, G.","Greaves, D.","Abanades, J."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2014-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.359933000000","-5.151258000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/531","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-sprawl-blue-green-infrastructure-uk-perspective-issue-global-significance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1462901117312005","title":"From ocean sprawl to blue-green infrastructure \u2013 A UK perspective on an issue of global significance","description":"Artificial structures are proliferating in the marine environment, resulting in \u2018ocean sprawl\u2019. In light of the potential environmental impacts of this, such as habitat loss and alteration, it is becoming increasingly important to incorporate ecologically-sensitive design into artificial marine structures. The principles of eco-engineering and green infrastructure are embedded in urban planning practice for terrestrial and freshwater development projects. In marine planning, however, eco-engineering of blue-green infrastructure remains an emerging concept. This note provides a UK perspective on the progress towards uptake of eco-engineering approaches for enhancing biodiversity on artificial marine structures. We emphasise that, despite a clear \u2018policy pull\u2019 to incorporate biodiversity enhancements in marine structures, a range of proof-of-concept evidence that it is possible to achieve, and strong cross-sectoral stakeholder support, there are still few examples of truly and purposefully-designed blue-green artificial structures in the UK. We discuss the barriers that remain and propose a strategy towards effective implementation. Our strategy outlines a step-wise approach to: (1) strengthening the evidence base for what enhancements can be achieved in different scenarios; (2) improving clarity on the predicted benefits and associated costs of enhancements; (3) packaging the evidence in a useful form to support planning and decision-making; and (4) encouraging implementation as routine practice. Given that ocean sprawl is a growing problem globally, the perspective presented here provides valuable insight and lessons for other nations at their various states of progress towards this same goal.","author":["Thompson, R.","Hall, A.","Firth, L.","Hawkins, S.","Evans, A.","Ironside, J.","Moore, P."],"organization":["Aberystwyth University","Plymouth University","University of Southampton","The Marine Biological Association (MBA) of the UK","Bournemouth University","Edith Cowan University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/532","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/expected-shoreline-effect-marine-energy-farm-operating-close-sardinia-island","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2073-4441\/11\/11\/2303","title":"The Expected Shoreline Effect of a Marine Energy Farm Operating Close to Sardinia Island","description":"Coastal areas are defined by numerous opportunities and threats. Among them we can mention emerging renewable projects and on the other hand coastal erosion. In the present work, the impact of a generic wind\u2013wave farm on the nearshore waves and currents in the vicinity of the Porto Ferro inlet (northwest Sardinia) was assessed. Using a reanalysis wave dataset that covers a 40-year interval (1979\u20132018), the most relevant wave characteristics in the target area were identified. These can reach during winter a maximum value of 7.35 m for the significant wave height. As a next step, considering a modeling system that combines a wave model (simulating waves nearshore (SWAN)) and a surf model, the coastal impact of some generic marine energy farms defined by a transmission coefficient of 25% was assessed. According to the results corresponding to the reference sites and lines defined close to the shore, it becomes obvious that there is a clear attenuation in terms of significant wave heights, and as regards current velocities, although the general tendency for them to decrease, there are, however, some situations when the values of the nearshore current velocities can also decrease. Finally, we can mention that the presence of a marine energy farm seems to be beneficial for the beach stability in this particular coastal environment, and in some cases the transformation of the breaking waves from plunging to spilling is noticed.","author":["Rusu, E.","Onea, F."],"organization":["Dunarea de Jos University of Galati"],"originationDate":"2019-11-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.669884000000","8.137792000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Oneaetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/533","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/does-temporal-variability-limit-standardized-biological-monitoring-wave-tidal-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/marineenergyjournal.org\/imej\/article\/view\/16","title":"Does temporal variability limit standardized biological monitoring at wave and tidal energy sites?","description":"Commercial viability of Marine Renewable Energy (MRE) is progressing but no national or international monitoring standards have been established for wave or tidal energy sites. Standardized monitoring within and across MRE sectors is necessary to expedite project permitting\/consenting, detect environmental impacts, and enable comparison among sites and technologies. Acoustic backscatter from a bottom-deployed platform at a pilot wave energy site off Newport, Oregon was compared to data collected at a tidal turbine site in Admiralty Inlet, Washington. Metrics that describe fish and macrozooplankton densities and vertical distributions derived from acoustic backscattered energy were compared using wavelets and Autoregressive Moving Average models (ARMA). Average density and vertical distribution values significantly differed between sites. Metrics of density and location in the water column displayed diel (24 h) and tidal (12 h) cycles. Dispersion of animals in the water column varied at 64- and 128-h periods at both sites. Applicability of methods in both sectors suggests that a standard approach to biological monitoring is possible. Stationary acoustics and analytic methods presented here can be used to characterize pre-installation conditions and refine post-installation monitoring to site-specific characteristics to ensure cost-effective detection of impacts associated with MRE development.","author":["Horne, J.","Ward, E.","Gonzalez, S."],"organization":["University of Washington","Northwest Fisheries Science Center"],"originationDate":"2019-10-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.639704000000","-124.068936000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/534","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developments-understanding-red-throated-diver-responses-offshore-wind-farms-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780081026984000290","title":"Developments in understanding of red-throated diver responses to offshore wind farms in marine Special Protection Areas","description":"Strategic environmental impact surveys in the early part of the 21st century accurately quantified aggregations of red-throated divers Gavia stellata in marine areas around England for the first time. Simultaneously, these areas were then proposed for both Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) of international importance (sensu EU Birds Directive) for the species. Prior to or simultaneous with these proposals, several offshore wind farm (OWF) developments were proposed, consented and built within the MPAs. Providing scientific advice on development within these MPAs has often proven challenging, as initially the evidence base was restricted to measured effects at relatively few OWFs. Here we summarise the evolution of survey and analysis methods that have helped shape our current understanding of red-throated diver behavioural responses to OWFs and make some recommendations to address remaining evidence gaps.","author":["Caldow, R.","Allen, S.","Banks, A.","Frayling, T.","Kershaw, M.","Rowell, H."],"organization":["Natural England"],"originationDate":"2020-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/535","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/books.google.com\/books?hl=en\u0026id=Nu-yDwAAQBAJ\u0026pg=PA307#v=onepage\u0026q\u0026f=false","title":"Environmental Impacts of Renewable Energy","description":"This chapter summarizes the significance of renewable energy resources, their technological practices, positive and negative impacts. It also presents current energy scenario and future prospects. Projected demand of energy will increase drastically by 2030 as per findings of International Energy Agency (IEA). Renewable energy sources must be used at a massive scale, as a supplement to conventional energy sources, in order to fulfill the ever-increasing demand of energy. However, renewable forms of energy like solar, wind, hydropower, ocean, geothermal, and biofuels are not completely environment friendly, since they do have their impacts on biodiversity, soil, aquatic environments, marine life, air quality, and even human health. However, in comparison to the conventional sources of energy, their negative impacts on environment are quite meager, in most cases these sources of energy production proved to be carbon neutral and in some cases carbon negative. The chapter concludes that reliance on renewable forms of energy for power generation, will become indispensable for a sustainable future.","author":["Mazhar, N.","Zia, S."],"organization":["National University of Singapore"],"originationDate":"2019-09-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":["OTEC","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/536","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-wave-energy-farm-protecting-aquaculture-installation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/11\/8\/2109","title":"The Effect of a Wave Energy Farm Protecting an Aquaculture Installation","description":"This paper assesses the impact of a farm of wave energy converters on a nearby offshore aquaculture installation and on the nearshore dynamics. The coastal area targeted is Agu\u00e7adoura, located in the north of Portugal, where the world\u2019s first wave farm operated in 2008. The study is focused mainly on the evaluation of the sheltering effect provided by the wave farm to the aquaculture cages. Furthermore, the possible impact on the coastal wave climate of such an energy park is also evaluated. These objectives are accomplished by performing simulations, corresponding to the wave conditions, which are more often encountered in that coastal environment. The SWAN model (Simulating WAves Nearshore) was adopted for this. Various transmission scenarios are considered to account for the impact of different types of wave converter farms on the downwave conditions. The results show that such a wave energy park might have a clear positive impact on the wave conditions fish farm installed downwave and it might also have a beneficial influence on shoreline dynamics from the perspective of coastal protection.","author":["Rusu, E.","Soares, C.","Silva, D."],"organization":["Centre for Marine Technology and Engineering (CENTEC)","Dunarea de Jos University of Galati"],"originationDate":"2018-08-13","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.165481000000","-8.709160000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Water Quality","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-29 10:20:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/537","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/powering-blue-economy-exploring-opportunities-marine-renewable-energy-maritime-markets","sourceURL":"","title":"Powering the Blue Economy: Exploring Opportunities for Marine Renewable Energy in Maritime Markets","description":"The blue economy is an emerging sector that will require energy to allow many scientific and commercial endeavors to reach their potential. The U.S. Department of Energy\u2019s Water Power Technologies Office seeks to understand marine and coastal opportunities for which marine energy could fulfill those energy needs. This report documents the material gathered during a year-long fact-finding effort engaging users and developers, through literature review, workshops, interviews, and national lab analyses, as well as a Request for Information process. Each market was assessed by a set of common analyses: opportunity summary; application description and power requirements; market description, power options, and geographic relevance; marine energy potential value proposition; and path forward including research and development needs and potential partners. The major finding is that there are more markets with potential than anticipated, both for Power at Sea (including ocean observation and navigation, underwater vehicle charging, marine aquaculture, marine algae, and seawater mining), and Resilient Coastal Communities (including desalination, coastal resiliency and disaster recovery, and community-scale isolated power systems). The enabling attributes of marine energy resources include that they are abundant, geographically diverse, energy dense, predictable, and complementary to other energy sources. This report can help direct analysis and research and development efforts by government, scientists, developers, and other stakeholders to more deeply understand and meet specific technical and economic requirements to power emerging opportunities in the blue economy.","author":["Copping, A.","Geerlofs, S.","Gill, G.","Hume, D.","Jenne, D.","Gorton, A.","LiVecchi, A.","Green, R.","Spence, H.","Preus, R.","Robichaud, R.","Gore, S.","McShane, W.","Schmaus, C."],"organization":["US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2026-10-13 05:45:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/PoweringTheBlueEconomy_73355-v2.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/538","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tethys-knowledge-management-system-working-advance-marine-renewable-energy-industry","sourceURL":"https:\/\/marineenergyjournal.org\/imej\/article\/view\/37","title":"Tethys knowledge management system: Working to advance the marine renewable energy industry","description":"Development of the marine renewable energy (MRE) industry has been challenged by uncertainty about potential environmental effects, which has resulted in slowing of permitting\/consenting processes, and ultimately to constraints on the industry. These challenges result from a lack of sufficient devices in the water from which to learn, a dearth of quality monitoring data, and a lack of accessibility to information about these effects in general. This paper describes an ongoing process to improve understanding of the environmental effects of MRE through a public, online knowledge management system developed by the U.S. Department of Energy, known as Tethys (https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov). Tethys collects and curates relevant documents while supporting a diverse international community through intentional outreach and synthesis activities, many of which support an international collaboration under the IEA Ocean Energy System\u2019s Annex IV. After eight years of operation, Tethys is internationally recognized and viewed as a trusted broker of information, with over 50,000 visitors annually. Tethys has provided clarity around environmental effects during a critical time in the industry when deployments are increasing in size and frequency.","author":["Copping, A.","Whiting, J.","Freeman, M.","Woodbury, A."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Whiting-et-al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/539","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-hydro-environmental-impacts-tidal-range-renewable-energy-projects-coastal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.worldscientific.com\/doi\/pdf\/10.1142\/9789813204027_0055","title":"Modeling Hydro-environmental Impacts of Tidal Range Renewable Energy Projects in Coastal Waters","description":"Details are given of the growing worldwide interest in tidal renewable energy projects, including tidal stream devices and tidal range structures (i.e. barrages and lagoons), but the main emphasis in this chapter is on tidal range renewable energy structures. In investigating the hydro-environmental impacts of such tidal energy schemes, both for regional and far field effects, a 2D numerical model has been refined to predict the hydrodynamic impacts, including wake effects and flood risk and hazard impacts, and changes in the concentration distribution of conservative and nonconservative solutes, including primarily salinity, turbidity, fecal indicator organisms, and phosphorous and nitrogen levels. The model has been applied to a number of key sites and particularly in the Severn Estuary, UK, which has the second highest tidal range worldwide. The key schemes considered and reported herein include: (i) a series of lagoons along the North Wales coast and (ii) a barrage across the mouth of the Severn Estuary. The main findings are that: (i) two-way generation offers the best options for maintaining the current conditions in the region as closely as possible, (ii) boundary conditions need to be generated from the Continental Shelf, (iii) momentum conservation is crucial for turbine representation, (iv)lagoons interact with one another, reducing efficiency, (v) the design of turbine distribution is critical for optimum efficiency and minimal environmental change.","author":["Ahmadian, R.","Falconer, R.","Angeloudis, A."],"organization":["Cardiff University"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.455375000000","-3.067048000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Water Quality","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/540","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/resolving-conflicts-between-endangered-species-conservation-renewable-energy-siting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.jstor.org\/stable\/26775091","title":"Resolving Conflicts Between Endangered Species Conservation and Renewable Energy Siting: Wiggle Room for Renewables?","description":"Two federal policies\u2014the protection of endangered species, and the rapid creation of renewable energy infrastructure\u2014currently exist in significant legal tension. While both are important for the development of necessary sustainability, climate change induced by the continuous burning of carbon-based fuels likely poses a greater threat to endangered species than does the growth of commercial-scale renewable energy sites. This paper outlines several points of conflict between the two policies and subsequently considers the extent to which federal agencies responsible for renewable energy oversight and development possess \u201cwiggle room\u201d under the Endangered Species Act. A few recommendations for greater leeway are then offered.","author":["Badichek, G."],"organization":["Columbia University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/541","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ensuring-co-benefits-biodiversity-climate-change-sustainable-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98681-4_9","title":"Ensuring Co-benefits for Biodiversity, Climate Change and Sustainable Development","description":"Significant investments are required by Parties to the three Rio Conventions\u2014Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and the United Nations Convention to Combat Desertification (UNCCD), as well as the United Nations 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development (2030 Agenda), to meet the ambitious goals that countries have agreed to. When the development of national and subnational frameworks to meet global commitments are conducted in isolation, the opportunity is lost to: (1) leverage co-benefits from the same investment; (2) use resources more efficiently; and (3) ensure that one action does not negatively affect another policy priority. For example, investments in greenhouse gas reduction have the potential either to positively impact biodiversity and sustainable development, or to result in unintended negative consequences; chances of positive synergies are greatly increased by cooperation and joint policy, planning and implementation. The challenge now is to learn lessons from the vast and diverse number of approaches being tried around the world and to enhance co-benefits. This paper describes the major inter-linkages between global commitments for conservation and development. It demonstrates the importance of enhancing synergies among global agreements and avoiding unintended and negative consequences, particularly on biodiversity, by providing examples of best practices and describing some of the pitfalls that occur when implementation of one agreement does not explicitly seek to enhance co-benefits with other agreements. In conclusion, the paper presents the case for the central role of nature-based solutions in simultaneously attaining global commitments for biodiversity, climate change and sustainable development.","author":["Smith, R.","Wenzel, L.","Guevara, O.","Dudley, N.","Petrone-Mendoza, V.","Cadena, M.","Rhodes, A."],"organization":["International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN)","World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF)","Equilibrium Research","University of Queensland","Mexico - UNDP","Pronatura M\u00e9xico"],"originationDate":"2018-08-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/542","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fish-densities-associated-structural-elements-oil-gas-platforms-southern-california","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/contentone\/umrsmas\/bullmar\/2019\/00000095\/00000004\/art00009","title":"Fish densities associated with structural elements of oil and gas platforms in southern California","description":"There are thousands of offshore oil and gas platforms worldwide that will eventually become obsolete, and one popular decommissioning alternative is the \u0022rigs to reefs\u0022 conversion that designates all or a portion of the underwater infrastructure as an artificial reef, thereby reducing the burden of infrastructure removal. The unique architecture of each platform may influence the size and structure of the associated fish assemblage if different structural elements form distinct habitats for fishes. Using scuba survey data from 11 southern California platforms from 1995 to 2000, we examined fish assemblages associated with structural elements of the structure, including the major horizontal crossbeams outside of the jacket, vertical jacket legs, and horizontal crossbeams that span the jacket interior. Patterns of habitat association were examined among three depth zones: shallow (26 m); and between two life stages: young- of-the-year and non-young-of-the-year. Fish densities tended to be greatest along horizontal beams spanning the jacket interior, relative to either horizontal or vertical beams along the jacket exterior, indicating that the position of the habitat within the overall structure is an important characteristic affecting fish habitat use. Fish densities were also higher in transects centered directly over a vertical or horizontal beam relative to transects that did not contain a structural element. These results contribute to the understanding of fish habitat use on existing artificial reefs, and can inform platform decommissioning decisions as well as the design of new offshore structures intended to increase fish production.","author":["Schroeder, D.","Miller, R.","Love, M.","Nishimoto, M.","Meyer-Gutbrod, E.","Kui, L."],"organization":["University of California Santa Barbara","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2019-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.545801000000","-120.094692000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/543","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/coexistence-dilemmas-european-marine-spatial-planning-practices-case-marine-renewables","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421516303706","title":"Coexistence dilemmas in European marine spatial planning practices. The case of marine renewables and marine protected areas","description":"The question whether coexistence of marine renewable energy (MRE) projects and marine protected areas (MPAs) is a common spatial policy in Europe and how a number of factors can affect it, has been addressed by empirical research undertaken in eleven European marine areas. Policy drivers and objectives that are assumed to affect coexistence, such as the fulfillment of conservation objectives and the prioritization of other competing marine uses, were scored by experts and predictions were crosschecked with state practice. While in most areas MRE-MPA coexistence is not prohibited by law, practice indicates resistance towards it. Furthermore expert judgment demonstrated that a number of additional factors, such as the lack of suitable space for MRE projects and the uncertainty about the extent of damage by MRE to the MPA, might influence the intentions of the two major parties involved (i.e. the MRE developer and the MPA authority) to pursue or avoid coexistence. Based on these findings, the interactions of these two players are further interpreted, their policy implications are discussed, while the need towards efficient, fair and acceptable MRE-MPA coexistence is highlighted.","author":["Degraer, S.","Maes, F.","Kyriazi, Z."],"organization":["Ghent University","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/544","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/integration-wave-energy-other-marine-renewable-energy-sources-needs-coastal-societies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/full\/10.1177\/1759313116683962","title":"Integration of wave energy and other marine renewable energy sources with the needs of coastal societies","description":"Marine renewable energy has the potential to solve both the energy-security and coastal-protection problems affecting coastal societies. In this article, the potential benefits arising from the combination of marine renewable energy technologies with infrastructural needs for coastal protection and other local needs are analysed. Classifications of technologies are developed to inform future coastal planning. Explanations of the resources and technologies are presented in layperson\u2019s term. The threat of coastal inundation under climate-change scenarios is a major global issue. The investment in new infrastructure demanded by cities, ports and communities at risk of inundation could very substantially reduce the levelised cost of electricity from renewable sources, provided the infrastructure is designed with the dual purpose of power generation and coastal protection. Correspondingly, the sale of electricity from such infrastructure could defray the long-term cost of installing coastal protection. Furthermore, many marine renewable energy technologies provide a platform on which other forms of renewable energy generation could be mounted. It is noted that the complex geophysical and engineering issues arising from this opportunity must be assessed considering socio-economic factors.","author":["Manasseh, R.","McInnes, K.","Sannasiraj, S.","Sundar, V.","Jalihal, P."],"organization":["Swinburne University of Technology","Indian Institute of Technology Madras","Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)","National Institute of Ocean Technology"],"originationDate":"2017-01-19","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Ocean Current","OTEC","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/545","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/failure-mode-identification-end-life-scenarios-offshore-wind-turbines-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/8\/8\/8339","title":"Failure Mode Identification and End of Life Scenarios of Offshore Wind Turbines: A Review","description":"In 2007, the EU established challenging goals for all Member States with the aim of obtaining 20% of their energy consumption from renewables, and offshore wind is expected to be among the renewable energy sources contributing highly towards achieving this target. Currently wind turbines are designed for a 25-year service life with the possibility of operational extension. Extending their efficient operation and increasing the overall electricity production will significantly increase the return on investment (ROI) and decrease the levelized cost of electricity (LCOE), considering that Capital Expenditure (CAPEX) will be distributed over a larger production output. The aim of this paper is to perform a detailed failure mode identification throughout the service life of offshore wind turbines and review the three most relevant end of life (EOL) scenarios: life extension, repowering and decommissioning. Life extension is considered the most desirable EOL scenario due to its profitability. It is believed that combining good inspection, operations and maintenance (O\u0026M) strategies with the most up to date structural health monitoring and condition monitoring systems for detecting previously identified failure modes, will make life extension feasible. Nevertheless, for the cases where it is not feasible, other options such as repowering or decommissioning must be explored.","author":["Kolios, A.","Luengo, M."],"organization":["Cranfield University"],"originationDate":"2015-08-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-11 02:08:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/energies-08-08339.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/546","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-turbine-end-life-scenarios-service-life-extension-decommissioning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/books.google.com\/books?id=CuLWwQEACAAJ","title":"Offshore Wind Turbine End of Life Scenarios: Service Life Extension and Decommissioning","description":"Offshore Wind Turbine End of Life Scenarios: Service Life Extension and Decommissioning provides all the information required to make considered decisions on wind turbines and their lifespan. The book outlines a holistic approach to wind turbine assessment, reviewing relevant legislation and standards, outlining decision criteria and methods for techno economic assessment, and covering life extension, from design and inspection, to certification. Other sections discuss decommissioning, the requirements of certifying authorities and insurers, and environmental impact assessments. A series of case studies illustrate principles discussed, making this a unique and essential resource for anyone who assesses wind turbine assets.    Addresses this crucial topic, meeting the need for a consolidated source of information in the area  Includes case studies to illustrate methods proposed  Gives practical advice on technical considerations for wind turbine service life extension and decommissioning  Covers the requirements of external stakeholders, such as certification authorities, insurers and environmental agencies","author":["Kolios, A."],"organization":["Cranfield University"],"originationDate":"2021-03-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-02 08:22:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/547","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/experimental-numerical-investigation-wake-interactions-marine-hydrokinetic-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/12\/16\/3188","title":"Experimental and Numerical Investigation of Wake Interactions of Marine Hydrokinetic Turbines","description":"To study the performance and environmental impacts of marine hydrokinetic (MHK) turbine arrays, we carry out an investigation based on laboratory experiments and numerical models able to resolve the dynamics of turbulent wake interactions and their effects on the river bed. We investigate a scaled Sabella D10 mounted on a mobile bed for a single and two aligned turbines, measuring the flow velocity, the rotor angular velocity, and the scour on the sediment bed. Numerical simulations are performed using a detached-eddy simulation (DES) turbulence model coupled with the blade-element momentum (BEM) approach, which can capture the mean flow and resolve the dynamics of turbulent coherent structures in the wakes. The simulations show a good agreement on the velocity statistics obtained experimentally. Power and thrust coefficients for the downstream turbine show an average decrease and a larger variability due to the turbulent intensity produced by the upstream turbine, as compared to the single turbine case. Results of this investigation also provide a framework to assess the predictive capabilities, scope, and applicability of computational models parameterizing the turbines using BEM, for testing different turbine designs and siting strategies within the MHK array.  Click here for more about Sabella D10 tidal turbine at Ushant Island.","author":["Escauriaza, C.","Guala, M.","Musa, M.","Gotelli, C."],"organization":["Pontifical Catholic University of Chile","Marine Energy Research \u0026 Innovation Center (MERIC)","University of Minnesota"],"originationDate":"2019-08-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.437537100000","-5.059855700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2026-10-16 06:24:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/energies-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/548","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/vertical-distribution-juvenile-salmon-large-turbid-river","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fwspubs.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3996\/022019-JFWM-008","title":"Vertical Distribution of Juvenile Salmon in a Large Turbid River","description":"Very little is known about the vertical distribution of downstream-migrating juvenile Pacific salmon Oncorhynchus spp. in large rivers. This knowledge is important for understanding the potential interactions of fishes with in-river hydrokinetic devices, which harness a river\u0027s energy by spinning a turbine to produce electrical current without damming or impounding water. Currently, development projects for hydrokinetic devices are being considered in several rural Alaskan communities, including the Tanana River, near Nenana, AK. Therefore, the goal of this study was to determine the vertical distribution of juvenile Chinook salmon Oncorhynchus tshawytscha, coho salmon Oncorhynchus kisutch, and chum salmon Oncorhynchus keta, in the Tanana River, at a site (bottom depth ~8, channel width ~150 m) where future hydrokinetic turbines may be deployed. Using a suspended wing-less fyke net system during diurnal periods (0800-1800), juveniles of all three species were found at all depths of the water column and no significant differences in catch-per-unit-effort among four depth categories (surface, mid-water, deep water, bottom water) were found. The occurrence of juvenile salmon throughout the water column indicates that they may interact with hydrokinetic devices, regardless of the depth at which they are deployed. Future research should more comprehensively characterize fish distribution patterns and describe the outcomes of fish\/turbine interactions to inform practices aimed at reducing potentially deleterious impacts of hydrokinetic devices on juvenile Pacific salmon.","author":["Courtney, M.","Seitz, A.","Jump, S."],"organization":["University of Alaska Fairbanks"],"originationDate":"2019-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["64.936878200000","-150.566789000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/549","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measuring-hydraulic-effect-hydrokinetic-energy-extraction-tanana-river-alaska","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s40722-019-00142-x","title":"Measuring the hydraulic effect of hydrokinetic energy extraction in the Tanana River, Alaska","description":"During two field seasons, a 1.93\u00a0m diameter, open-center style, hydrokinetic device was deployed from a pontoon barge in the Tanana River, in Alaska. Near-surface velocity was roughly 1.7\u00a0m\/s and 2\u00a0m\/s at the deployment site during September 2014 and July 2015, respectively. Velocity and turbulence were measured in the vicinity of the turbine location using an acoustic Doppler velocimeter (ADV) and an acoustic Doppler current profiler in order to characterize the impact of the turbine on river hydraulics and turbulence. ADV measurements showed velocities being 97.8% recovered within 18.1 turbine diameters and fully recovered within 20.7 turbine diameters. ADV measurements also indicate a 520% increase in turbulence intensity at 2.6 turbine diameters downstream which appeared to resolve within 20.7 turbine diameters.","author":["Ravens, T.","Edgerly, E."],"organization":["University of Alaska Anchorage"],"originationDate":"2019-08-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["64.936878200000","-150.566789000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/550","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-ecology-biological-responses-wild-fishes-relative-hydropower-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/curve.carleton.ca\/3f747114-6a90-4b9c-90fd-31b91f2b902c","title":"The Spatial Ecology and Biological Responses of Wild Fishes Relative to Hydropower Development on the Winnipeg River","description":"Wild fish population are often impounded by hydropower dams, which can restrict migration and habitat requirements, while making fishes susceptible to deleterious harm from entrainment through spillways and turbines, stranding from dewatering, as well as hydrokinetic developments that are being proposed for installment within tailraces. With applying acoustic biotelemetry and using model selection, I investigated the spatial ecology and biological responses from Lake Sturgeon and Walleye relative to hydropower developments on a large river. The results in chapter 2 document the spatial ecology of wild fishes within a run-of-river impoundment. In chapter 3, biotelemetry was used to investigate the risk of impacts from hydrokinetic turbines on wild fishes. This information will help to enhance management for Lake Sturgeon and Walleye populations that are impounded due to hydropower developments, and help guide best practices for commercial operations for hydrokinetic turbines that are placed within tailraces of hydropower stations.","author":["Struthers, D."],"organization":["Carleton University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.125865000000","-96.026343000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/551","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-riverine-hydrokinetic-turbine-operations-relative-spatial-ecology-wild","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/24705357.2017.1287530","title":"Evaluating riverine hydrokinetic turbine operations relative to the spatial ecology of wild fishes","description":"Hydrokinetic turbines (HTs) are being proposed for placement in riverine landscapes around the globe. Here, we implanted 40 adult lake sturgeon and 40 adult walleye with acoustic telemetry transmitters to monitor their lateral and vertical space use at the Canadian Hydrokinetic Turbine Testing Centre (CHTTC) located in the Seven Sisters Generating station (GS) tailrace on the Winnipeg River, Manitoba. Specifically, we tested whether fish behaviour was influenced by the operation of HTs relative to control periods, and estimate the threat of HTs towards lake sturgeon and walleye across seasons. The behaviour and habitat use of both species was not influenced by HT operations. Greater numbers of walleye were present when the discharge rate was \u2265 950 m3s\u20131, which is \u2265 77 m3s\u20131 greater than the average discharge rate (873 m3s\u20131) measured during the study period. Given the patterns of seasonal residency, movement, and depth use, lake sturgeon appeared more prone to interacting with HTs during spring and early summer months (i.e. May and June), whereas risk to walleye would be highest throughout the summer and autumn months. In the vicinity of the acoustic receivers, available habitat (areas with large boulders, and transitions between swift flow in the channel and slacker water near the shoreline) was used significantly more often by walleye than lake sturgeon. Lake sturgeon utilized similar depths where HTs would be installed (i.e. \u2265 6.5 m), while walleye commonly occupied shallower depths at the HT testing centre making the former more susceptible to interactions with substrate-HT\u0027s. Collectively, these are some of the first field-based results on fish behaviour and ecology while a riverine-HT is in operation. The findings present useful information to help guide best practices for commercial scale HT operations within river systems where lake sturgeon and walleye reside.","author":["Enders, E.","Cooke, S.","Bibeau, E.","Struthers, D.","Gutowsky, L.","Smokorowski, K.","Watkinson, D."],"organization":["Carleton University","Fisheries and Oceans Canada","University of Manitoba"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.125865000000","-96.026343000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/552","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hydrokinetic-energy-conversion-systems-technology-status-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032114008624","title":"Hydrokinetic energy conversion systems: A technology status review","description":"Hydrokinetic energy conversion systems are the electromechanical devices that convert kinetic energy of river streams, tidal currents, man-made water channels or waves into electricity without using a special head and impoundment. This new technology became popular especially in the last two decades and needs to be well investigated. In this study, the hydrokinetic energy conversion systems were reviewed broadly. They have been categorized into two main groups as current and wave energy conversion devices. Their technology, working principles, environmental impacts, source potential, advantages, drawbacks and related issues were detailed.","author":["Yuce, M.","Muratoglu, A."],"organization":["University of Gaziantep","Batman University"],"originationDate":"2015-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/553","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/river-tidal-ocean-current-hydrokinetic-energy-technologies-status-future-opportunities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/acep.uaf.edu\/media\/172246\/2010_11_1_State_of_the_Art_Hydrokinetic_Final.pdf","title":"River, Tidal, and Ocean Current Hydrokinetic Energy Technologies: Status and Future Opportunities in Alaska","description":"This report outlines the status of hydrokinetic power generation technology, the expected trajectory of improvement over the next five years, and recommended actions the state can take to accelerate this technology field. The report is based on numerous sources as well as data collected by ACEP over the past year at a hydrokinetic research site in Nenana, Alaska. Turbines placed directly in river, ocean, or tidal current generate hydrokinetic power from the kinetic energy of moving water (current). The available hydrokinetic power is a function of the density of the water and the speed of the current cubed. The minimum current required to operate a hydrokinetic device is typically 2\u20134 knots (1\u20132 m\/s), but optimal currents are in the 5\u20137 knot (1.5\u20133.5 m\/s) range. The Alaska region contains about 40% of the total U.S. river energy resource, 90% of the total U.S. tidal energy resource, and 40% of the U.S. continental shelf wave energy resource. Hydrokinetic turbines have frequently been discussed as an option for generating power in communities located along Alaska\u2019s major river systems, and for tidal energy applications in Cook Inlet and coastal Southeast Alaska.\n\nChallenges to developing a commercial hydrokinetic industry in Alaska include determining the technological, operational, and economic viability of hydrokinetic turbines, meeting permitting requirements, and gaining stakeholder acceptance. Hydrokinetic technology can be affected by debris, sediment, frazil, and surface ice; river dynamics (turbulence, current velocity, channel stability); and the interaction of turbine operations with fish and marine mammals and their habitat. The question of turbineoperation impacts on the aquatic environment is one of the major issues that will determine stakeholder and permitting agency views toward this new technology. The 2010 hydrokinetic turbine demonstrations conducted at Ruby and Eagle were significantly adversely affected by in-river debris floating on the surface and neutrally buoyant debris. These experiences indicate that developing technology to mitigate debris problems will need to be a high priority for practical hydrokinetic power production.\n\nAlaska is well positioned to facilitate river and marine hydrokinetic technology (RMHT) as it transitions from emerging to developed technology over the next five to ten years, by building on current and planned national and state structures. These structures include the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation and Enforcement (BOEMRE, formerly the Minerals Management Service), the Department of Energy, and the Denali Commission, as well as Alaska state funding support for renewable energy projects and development of emerging technologies and research.","author":["Johnson, J.","Pride, D."],"organization":["Alaska Center for Energy and Power (ACEP)","Alaska Energy Authority"],"originationDate":"2010-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["65.105982000000","-151.450173000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Fish","Sediment Transport"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Johnson_Pride_2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/554","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/securing-just-space-small-scale-fisheries-blue-economy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2019.00171\/full","title":"Securing a Just Space for Small-Scale Fisheries in the Blue Economy","description":"The vast developmental opportunities offered by the world\u2019s coasts and oceans have attracted the attention of governments, private enterprises, philanthropic organizations, and international conservation organizations. High-profile dialogue and policy decisions on the future of the ocean are informed largely by economic and ecological research. Key insights from the social sciences raise concerns for food and nutrition security, livelihoods and social justice, but these have yet to gain traction with investors and the policy discourse on transforming ocean governance. The largest group of ocean-users \u2013 women and men who service, fish and trade from small-scale fisheries (SSF) \u2013 argue that they have been marginalized from the dialogue between international environmental and economic actors that is determining strategies for the future of the ocean. Blue Economy or Blue Growth initiatives see the ocean as the new economic frontier and imply an alignment with social objectives and SSF concerns. Deeper analysis reveals fundamental differences in ideologies, priorities and approaches. We argue that SSF are being subtly and overtly squeezed for geographic, political and economic space by larger scale economic and environmental conservation interests, jeopardizing the substantial benefits SSF provide through the livelihoods of millions of women and men, for the food security of around four billion consumers globally, and in the developing world, as a key source of micro-nutrients and protein for over a billion low-income consumers. Here, we bring insights from social science and SSF to explore how ocean governance might better account for social dimensions of fisheries.","author":["Cohen, P.","Allison, E.","Andrew, N.","Cinner, J.","Evans, L.","Fabinyi, M.","Garces, L.","Hall, S.","Hicks, C.","Hughes, T.","Jentoft, S.","Mills, D.","Masu, R.","Mbaru, E.","Ratner, B."],"organization":["WorldFish","James Cook University","University of Washington","University of Wollongong","University of Exeter","University of Technology Sydney","Lancaster University","Stanford University","The University of Troms\u00f8","Solomon Islands Ministry of Fisheries and Marine Resources","Kenya Marine \u0026 Fisheries Research Institute"],"originationDate":"2019-04-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Environmental Justice"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/555","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-acceptance-marine-renewable-energy-malaysia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421513009774","title":"Public Acceptance of Marine Renewable Energy in Malaysia","description":"Research and development (R\u0026D) on marine renewable energy (MRE) in Malaysia is still in its initial stage. It is crucial to know the level of acceptance of MRE among Malaysians in order to push the technology forward. A survey was conducted to investigate public acceptance of MRE in SS2, Petaling Jaya. In addition, a face-to-face interview was conducted to understand the concerns of an investor about investing in renewable energy (RE) projects. The results of analysis showed that 82.8% of the respondents support MRE implementation in Malaysia. However, 56.8% of the respondents are reluctant to pay for green electricity. The reason is directly linked to the NIMBYist (NIMBY= Not in My Backyard) attitudes of Malaysian citizens. They are unwilling to support green energy by involving themselves, participating or paying money. Furthermore, the interviewee, on behalf of investors, expressed some opinions on concerns about investment in RE projects. Several ministries and departments are suggested as being important in MRE development.","author":["Lam, W.","Lim, X."],"organization":["University of Malaya"],"originationDate":"2014-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["3.137018000000","101.597744000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/556","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/rapid-land-use-change-coastal-wind-farm-development-australian-policies-politics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0264837716305154","title":"Rapid land use change by coastal wind farm development: Australian policies, politics and planning","description":"The siting of both onshore and offshore wind farms has caused controversy in a number of countries, particularly in Europe, which currently has the world\u2019s largest array of offshore wind turbines. Like the rest of the world there has been a dramatic increase in wind farm development In Australia over the last two decades but none of this has occurred in the offshore environment. Australian wind farms are predominantly located onshore around the southern part of the continent where wind energy is high. This has specifically affected rural coasts where it has created planning and land use policy issues along with environmental impacts and associated public and political reaction. This paper examines the geographic spread, timing and concentration of Australian wind farms around the coast. It also examines the extent to which scientific knowledge on wind farm impacts is incorporated into different state and federal land use and environmental policy and legislative frameworks. The paper concludes that the rapidity in the expansion of the Australian wind energy sector has outpaced strategic land use planning resulting in a piece-meal and cumulative wind farm development on rural coasts.","author":["Harvey, N.","Dew, R.","Hender, S."],"organization":["University of Adelaide","James Cook University"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/557","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/strong-relative-preference-wind-turbines-united-states-among-those-who-live-near-them","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41560-019-0347-9","title":"A strong relative preference for wind turbines in the United States among those who live near them","description":"Studies on social acceptance of wind power projects typically evaluate wind power in isolation, or as a choice between wind and no wind. However, at a societal level, the choice is not limited to whether, how or where wind turbines should be sited, but whether society should generate electricity by wind or from some other source. Consequently, it is important to understand whether those living near local wind projects prefer them relative to other local power projects. Here, we show that approximately 90% of individuals in the United States who live within 8\u2009km of a wind turbine prefer their local wind project to a centralized power plant sited a similar distance away. Wind is also preferred three to one over solar among the approximately two-thirds who have a preference. These results are relatively consistent across states with different characteristics, suggesting a strong social preference for wind turbines among their neighbours.","author":["Firestone, J.","Kirk, H."],"organization":["University of Delaware"],"originationDate":"2019-03-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/558","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparison-damage-live-v-euthanized-atlantic-salmon-salmo-salar-smolts-passage-through","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/jfb.13596","title":"Comparison of damage to live v. euthanized Atlantic salmon Salmo salar smolts from passage through an Archimedean screw turbine","description":"This study assessed the usefulness of passing euthanized Atlantic salmon\u00a0Salmo salar\u00a0smolts through an Archimedean screw turbine to test for external damage, as compared with live, actively swimming smolts. Scale loss was the only observed effect. Severe scale loss was 5\u00b79 times more prevalent in euthanized turbine\u2010passed fish (45%) than the live fish (7\u00b76%). Additionally, distinctive patterns of scale loss, consistent with grinding between the turbine helices and housing trough, were observed in 35% of euthanized turbine\u2010passed smolts. This distinctive pattern of scale loss was not seen in live turbine\u2010passed smolts, nor in control groups (live and euthanized smolts released downstream of the turbine), which suggests that the altered behaviour of dead fish in turbine flows generates biased injury outcomes.","author":["Lucas, M.","Adams, C.","Brackley, R.","Thomas, R.","Bean, C."],"organization":["University of Glasgow","Durham University"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.248215000000","-2.667664000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/559","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/perceived-impacts-wind-farm-natural-gas-development-northern-pennsylvania","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/ruso.12022","title":"Perceived Impacts from Wind Farm and Natural Gas Development in Northern Pennsylvania","description":"This study examines the environmental, social, and economic impacts that landowners perceive from the simultaneous development of an industrial\u2010scale wind farm and extensive natural gas drilling in an area of northern Pennsylvania. A mail survey (N\u00a0= 1,028) reveals that the types of perceived impact from wind and natural gas are similar overall, although the perceived magnitude of positive and negative impacts is greater from natural gas drilling. Impact perception was found to explain a large portion of residents\u0027 overall attitudes toward the energy developments, and residents\u0027 place meanings for the area also explain some attitudinal variation. Additionally, factors such as place attachment and length and type of residency were found to have little or no effect on either the perception of impact or resident attitudes toward development.","author":["Jacquet, J.","Stedman, R."],"organization":["South Dakota State University","Cornell University"],"originationDate":"2013-09-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.492030000000","-77.778997000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/560","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/individual-preferences-regarding-environmental-offset-welfare-compensation-choice","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0921800916305936","title":"Individual preferences regarding environmental offset and welfare compensation: a choice experiment application to an offshore wind farm project","description":"This paper uses the choice experiment method to investigate the preferences of local communities with respect to various compensatory measures in connection with a development project. A survey was conducted among recreational users of the bay of Saint-Brieuc, where an offshore wind farm is currently planned. The goal is to identify the preferences of the bay\u0027s users with respect to various compensation possibilities: monetary compensation, investment in publicly owned assets, or the ecological restoration. Two multinomial logit (MNL) models and a latent class (LC) model are used to explore the preferences and some sources of heterogeneity within the community. The results of this study show that form of compensation is an important determinant of preferences and has an effect on the acceptability towards the compensation principle. More precisely, results shows that compensation is better accepted if it obeys the principle of strong sustainability, which includes ecological restoration for the gain of the population as a whole and which excludes monetary transactions, associated with the bribe effect. The study also highlights the naturalists\u0027 specific attitude for who compensation should be determined within a regulatory framework, one which imposes compensatory measures related to objectively determined ecological impacts.","author":["Carlier, A.","Levrel, H.","Kermagoret, C.","Dachary-Bernard, J."],"organization":["The French Research Institute for Exploitation of the Sea (IFREMER)","Centre International de Recherche sur Environnement et le D\u00e9veloppement (CIRED)"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.528943000000","-2.713154000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-16 04:48:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/561","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/local-socio-political-acceptance-wind-farms-germany","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0160791X1730101X","title":"Local and socio-political acceptance of wind farms in Germany","description":"In this study, we tested how attitudes toward the German energy transition, the perceived fairness of decision-making processes and their outcomes, the perceived risks and benefits of wind energy, and the trust in key actors (federal government, local government, large energy companies, and municipal utilities) affect both the general acceptance and local acceptance (acceptance of wind farms situated 500\u00a0m from the respondents\u0027 home) of wind farms in Germany. The respective data were gained from a representative random survey (n\u00a0=\u00a02.009) in Germany.\n\nThe findings show that most of the aforementioned predictors significantly influence the public acceptance of wind energy. Perceived risks and fairness become (more) important in the context of both general and local acceptance of onshore wind farms, while the general attitude toward the energy transition is of greater relevance in the context of the general acceptance of offshore wind farms. Furthermore, trust in large energy companies plays a mixed role concerning general and local acceptance. Our results provide valuable insights for understanding public reactions toward wind energy projects.","author":["Sonnenberg, M.","Ruddat, M."],"organization":["University of Stuttgart"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.095044000000","10.240182000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/562","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/exploring-wakes-large-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1742-6596\/753\/9\/092014\/meta","title":"Exploring the wakes of large offshore wind farms","description":"Offshore meteorological characteristics set specific conditions for the operation of offshore wind farms. One specific feature is low turbulence intensity which on the one hand reduces loads on turbines but on the other hand is the reason for much longer turbine and farm wakes than over land. The German Government is presently funding a research project called WIPAFF (WInd PArk Far Field) which heads for the analysis of properties and impacts of offshore wind park far fields. The focus is on the analysis of wind farm wakes, their interaction among each other and their regional climate impact. This is done by in-situ, extensive aircraft and satellite measurements and by operating meso-scale wind field models and an analytical wind farm model.","author":["Neumann, T.","Platis, A.","Siedersleben, S.","Bange, J.","Lampert, A.","Schulz-Stellenfeth, J.","Djath, B.","Emeis, S."],"organization":["Karlsruhe Institute of Technology","Technische Universit\u00e4t Braunschweig","University of T\u00fcbingen","Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ)","UL International GmbH (DEWI)"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.323366000000","7.046133000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/563","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/vertex-field-campaign-observations-near-ground-effects-wind-turbine-wakes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/full\/10.1080\/14685248.2019.1572161","title":"The VERTEX field campaign: observations of near-ground effects of wind turbine wakes","description":"Wind energy has been growing steadily in the U.S. and worldwide in the past decades. As wind farms are projected to increase in size and number, however, concerns are rising about possible undesirable effects of wind turbines near the Earth\u0027s surface. The literature is highly divided about what these effects could be, including warming, cooling, both, or neither. Only one mechanism, however, has been widely accepted (but never tested) to explain how wind turbines affect the lower boundary layer, namely that turbulence generated in wind turbine wakes enhances vertical mixing near the ground. Wakes are plume-like volumes downwind of wind turbines that are characterised by lower wind speeds and higher turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) than the undisturbed upwind flow. The few observational campaigns that have measured changes in near-surface properties by wind turbines have not provided an answer with respect to vertical mixing near the ground. To fill this knowledge gap, the VERTEX (VERTical Enhanced miXing) measurement campaign was conducted in August-October 2016 near a large wind turbine in coastal Delaware, using 15 surface flux towers, a 50-m meteorological tower, a radiometer, and two scanning lidars. During VERTEX, lidar scans and a wake detection algorithm were used to detect wake events and identify which sites were affected by the wake of the wind turbine. TKE, momentum and heat fluxes near the ground were compared between the sites below the wake and those outside of it. Preliminary findings based on two case studies (30 August and 20 September 2016) suggest a lack of enhancement of vertical mixing near the ground.","author":["Archer, C.","Oncley, S.","Wu, S.","Vasel-Be-Hagh, A.","Brodie, J.","Delgado, R.","St. Pe, A.","Semmer, S."],"organization":["University of Delaware","Tennessee Tech University","University of Maryland","National Center for Atmospheric Research"],"originationDate":"2019-01-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.916894000000","-116.750892000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/564","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/oklahomas-future-wind-energy-resources-their-relationship-central-plains-low-level-jet","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032119305829","title":"Oklahoma\u0027s future wind energy resources and their relationship with the Central Plains low-level jet","description":"Previous work has projected increases in wind speed\/wind power density (WPD) over the United States\u0027 South-Central Plains, which could be linked to future increases in frequency of the Central Plains Low-Level Jet (LLJ). This work serves to both update projections of this region\u0027s wind energy resources, and to assess the LLJ\u0027s importance for influencing these resources. Projected changes in several wind energy metrics (including ramp event frequency and cut-off frequency) were assessed specifically over the Oklahoma Panhandle. These projections were computed by using a climatological delta method to statistically downscale changes in near-surface wind speed from multiple climate models onto observations from the Oklahoma Mesonet. The results suggest a pattern of overall reductions in wind speed and WPD, slight reductions in ramp event frequency, and little change in cut-off frequency, with projected changes often being larger and of statistical significance at night and during summer and autumn. Highly distinguishable diurnal and seasonal variability in ramp event and cut-off frequency was found in this work, with these frequencies most notably maximizing during the day. This climatological variability is consistent with that seen in observations of these wind energy metrics. Regression of LLJ characteristics against wind energy metrics identified consistent and conceptually understandable links between increased LLJ frequency and decreased ramp event frequency in future decades. Such a result attests to a more stable and easier to manage future wind energy resource over the Oklahoma Panhandle.","author":["Wimhurst, J.","Greene, J."],"organization":["University of Oklahoma"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.733553000000","-101.293462000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/565","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/using-ecological-modelling-marine-spatial-planning-enhance-ecosystem-based-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X18300812","title":"Using ecological modelling in marine spatial planning to enhance ecosystem-based management","description":"Growing awareness of the role of marine spatial planning (MSP) in promoting sustainable development and ecosystem-based management highlights the need to use decision-support tools, and specifically ecological modelling tools, to consider the future impact of planning and management on the marine environment. However, how these tools can be incorporated into planning and their expected contribution is not always clear. Here, an Ecopath with Ecosim and Ecospace food-web model was used in a hypothetical planning process to examine the integration of food-web tools in specific stages of MSP. The model was used to examine spatial alternatives and management strategies for Orot Rabin coastal infrastructure facility in the Israeli Mediterranean coast, in an attempt to assess how such facilities might promote marine conservation. The results revealed the effect of different management protocols on the ecosystem, and provide the maximum allowable catch for sustaining the biomass of vulnerable fish species in the area, which can be used in MSP to address specific marine conservation goals. The model led to counterintuitive understandings regarding the management of the area. It demonstrated that intensive development under specific management strategies may promote conservation goals better than some management strategies directed towards ecological and recreational purposes. This study confirms the potential usefulness of food-web models for MSP; it specifies the stages and means by which planners can use models. Furthermore, it is suggested that tool\u0027s development should be planning-oriented and should include more applications to serve planners who aim to promote ecosystem-based management and marine conservation goals.","author":["Portman, M.","Shabtay, A.","Carmel, Y.","Ofir, E.","Gal, G."],"organization":["Technion Israel Institute for Technology"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["31.024162000000","34.810616000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/566","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mapping-benthic-habitat-conditions-seafloor-deposits-using-sediment-profile-imaging","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.onepetro.org\/conference-paper\/OTC-28878-MS","title":"Mapping Benthic Habitat Conditions and Seafloor Deposits Using Sediment Profile Imaging and a Semiautomated Image Processing System","description":"Sediment profile imaging (SPI) technology characterizes in situ physical, geochemical, and biological seafloor features. SPI was required by Mexico\u2019s Agency for Safety, Energy, and Environment in 2017 for environmental baseline surveys (EBS) of oil lease blocks in the southern Gulf of Mexico. Because of its ability to provide information on benthic community health and the distribution of very thin (down to the centimeter scale) layers of deposited materials, SPI technology is highly effective for mapping drill cuttings or drilling muds released around wellheads during exploration or production and documenting their ecological impacts. SPI technology has not been widely used in the oil and gas industry for EBS or other monitoring activities. A primary objective of this work is to improve the transparency and consistency of the SPI data generation and data management process.","author":["Jones, C.","Sackmann, B.","Revelas, E.","Thurlow, A."],"organization":["Integral Consulting Inc"],"originationDate":"2019-04-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/567","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-potential-emf-effects-fish-species-commercial-or-recreational-fishing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/espis.boem.gov\/final%20reports\/BOEM_2019-049.pdf","title":"Evaluation of Potential EMF Effects on Fish Species of Commercial or Recreational Fishing Importance in Southern New England","description":"The development of offshore wind technology along the Atlantic coast of the United States (U.S.) has raised public concern about the potential effects of electric and magnetic fields (EMF) from undersea power cables on commercially and recreationally important fish species. This white paper provides a summary of the currently available science that addresses the potential effects of EMF from undersea power cables associated with offshore wind energy projects on fish species of concern. This summary has been developed to help the commercial and recreational fishing communities who have concern about the effect of EMF on fish. The report summarizes what is currently known about EMF issues, addresses common concerns and misconceptions, and provides background information about EMF in the environment and the relevance of EMF to fish species of concern in the southern New England area.  Public concern revolves around the potential impacts on fishes from EMF generated by the undersea power cables associated with offshore wind energy projects. Concerns include: \u2022 Identification of species most and least likely to be affected by EMF; \u2022 Potential EMF impacts on different species groups (e.g., closer to the surface [pelagic] or closer to the seafloor [demersal]); \u2022 Potential EMF impacts on fishes during different life stages and behavioral activities (e.g., predation, mating, navigation); \u2022 Cumulative or long-term impacts from EMF; \u2022 Effectiveness of mitigation measures; \u2022 European experience regarding fish impacts from EMF offshore wind energy projects; and \u2022 Characterization of the existing ocean habitat regarding EMF levels.  The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) has completed multiple studies examining EMF issues and funded several field studies investigating the effects of EMF, the most recent of which include crab harvest and eel behavior. Other agencies and organizations worldwide also have funded studies and workshops to obtain additional data and understand the current level of knowledge regarding potential impacts on marine life from EMF. The current state of knowledge on this topic is summarized below.","author":["Olsen, K.","Snyder, D.","Bailey, W.","Palmquist, K.","Cotts, B."],"organization":["US Department of the Interior (DOI)","BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs"],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.824635600000","-70.979638600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","EMF","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Snyderetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/568","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-spatiotemporal-abundance-mobile-wildlife-highly-variable-environments-using","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ece3.4738","title":"Modeling spatiotemporal abundance of mobile wildlife in highly variable environments using boosted GAMLSS hurdle models","description":"Modeling organism distributions from survey data involves numerous statistical challenges, including accounting for zero\u2010inflation, overdispersion, and selection and incorporation of environmental covariates. In environments with high spatial and temporal variability, addressing these challenges often requires numerous assumptions regarding organism distributions and their relationships to biophysical features. These assumptions may limit the resolution or accuracy of predictions resulting from survey\u2010based distribution models. We propose an iterative modeling approach that incorporates a negative binomial hurdle, followed by modeling of the relationship of organism distribution and abundance to environmental covariates using generalized additive models (GAM) and generalized additive models for location, scale, and shape (GAMLSS). Our approach accounts for key features of survey data by separating binary (presence\u2010absence) from count (abundance) data, separately modeling the mean and dispersion of count data, and incorporating selection of appropriate covariates and response functions from a suite of potential covariates while avoiding overfitting. We apply our modeling approach to surveys of sea duck abundance and distribution in Nantucket Sound (Massachusetts, USA), which has been proposed as a location for offshore wind energy development. Our model results highlight the importance of spatiotemporal variation in this system, as well as identifying key habitat features including distance to shore, sediment grain size, and seafloor topographic variation. Our work provides a powerful, flexible, and highly repeatable modeling framework with minimal assumptions that can be broadly applied to the modeling of survey data with high spatiotemporal variability. Applying GAMLSS models to the count portion of survey data allows us to incorporate potential overdispersion, which can dramatically affect model results in highly dynamic systems. Our approach is particularly relevant to systems in which little a priori knowledge is available regarding relationships between organism distributions and biophysical features, since it incorporates simultaneous selection of covariates and their functional relationships with organism responses.","author":["Paton, P.","Allison, T.","McWilliams, S.","Osenkowski, J.","Smith, A.","Lamb, J.","Hofner, B.","Sadoti, G."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island","Friedrich\u2013Alexander University Erlangen\u2013N\u00fcrnberg","Rhode Island Department of Environmental Management","American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)","University of Nevada"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.514214000000","-70.411216000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Smith_et_al-2019-Ecology_and_Evolution.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/569","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fisheries-marine-renewable-energy-interactions-summary-report-scoping-workshop-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/scholar.google.com\/citations?view_op=view_citation\u0026hl=en\u0026user=xvzIWaoAAAAJ\u0026citation_for_view=xvzIWaoAAAAJ:eQOLeE2rZwMC","title":"Fisheries and marine renewable energy interactions: A summary report on a scoping workshop for the Marine Renewable Energy Knowledge Exchange Programme","description":"The Fisheries and Marine Renewable Energy Working Group (funded by MREKEP a Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) Knowledge Exchange programme), and co-ordinated by the Centre for Marine and Coastal Policy (MarCoPol), at Plymouth University, carried out an initial scoping exercise on the interactions of fisheries and marine renewable energy.  Through discussion and closer liaison, this working group aims to promote better understanding of the challenges in resolving interactions between fisheries and marine renewable energy focussing on measures to improve co-existence of the two sectors.  The key objectives of the group are:    To facilitate engagement between scientists, energy companies and fishing organisations and promote sharing of knowledge focussing on issues of common concern.  To develop best practice for quantifying ecological, social and economic impacts of displacement and design of mitigation measures for the whole life cycle of energy projects.  To reduce lead times for integration of novel science into best practice and ensure future research is appropriately scoped and focussed on resolving challenges faced by marine space users.","author":["Campbell, M.","Ashley, M.","Rodwell, L.","de Groot, J."],"organization":["Plymouth University","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"originationDate":"2012-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/570","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-risks-marine-mammal-populations-renewable-energy-devices-interim-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/266285973_Assessing_the_risks_to_marine_mammal_populations_from_renewable_energy_devices_an_interim_approach","title":"Assessing the risks to marine mammal populations from renewable energy devices: an interim approach","description":"The Joint Nature Conservation Committee, the Countryside Council for Wales and NERC Knowledge Exchange Programme commissioned a workshop to develop discussions on the risks from renewable energy devices to marine mammal populations (see Appendix I for the agenda and Appendix II for the list of participants). The Statutory Nature Conservation Bodies (SNCBs) have identified a need for a framework to enable the assessment of risk of impacts on marine mammal populations arising from disturbance and mortality caused by the installation and operation of marine renewables (offshore wind, wave and tidal). Up to the present date, consenting decisions involving considerations of impact to marine mammals have been made based on the premise that small scale individual wind farms or demonstration wave and tidal projects will not carry a risk to the Favourable Conservation Status (FCS) of populations nor to the integrity of Natura 2000 sites. In some cases, the risks to marine mammal populations posed by tidal stream projects have been reduced to acceptable limits by defining collision thresholds.  The SNCBs have advised the regulators that the evidence in this field is very limited and that it is becoming increasingly difficult to advise on new developments without a transparent, logical, repeatable and biologically relevant framework for assessing likely impacts and (if needed) managing the risk of impacts to marine mammal populations. Current advice to regulators and developers is based on limited evidence within a context of potential negative impacts on populations of marine mammals, particularly those that could arise from the cumulative effects of several large scale developments or multiple novel technologies combined with other ongoing pressures. The rapid expansion in the number and scale of offshore renewable developments combined with the precautionary principle required to assess likely impacts and the lack of a thorough understanding of the actual effects is resulting in consenting challenges that reinforce the need for an assessment framework. These challenges are likely to be most significant for developments within the range of small, semi-resident populations and for multiple developments with the potential to impact cumulatively on marine mammal populations. As a consequence SNCB advice to industry and regulators is likely to be provided on a very precautionary basis.  To progress this issue, a workshop was hosted to consider and assess the challenges that stakeholders are currently facing when having to determine and manage the risks of renewable energy devices to marine mammal populations. The aim of this workshop was to explore the development of a UK based framework, appropriate for assessing mortality and disturbance impacts 2 | Page on marine mammal populations, arising from the installation and operation of offshore renewables. The workshop gathered academics, regulators, nature conservation advisory bodies and industry to agree on an approach that is appropriate to the issues and populations of concern. In particular, the aim of the workshop was to reach agreement on the questions that need answering and their regulatory context, to identify and discuss the available data and assumptions, to discuss and identify the most appropriate modelling approaches and to explore the scenarios and levels of impact to be considered.","author":["Lusseau, D.","Harwood, J.","Hastie, G.","Thompson, P.","Smith, K.","Christiansen, F.","Mendes, S."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen","University of St Andrews","Countryside Council for Wales","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"originationDate":"2012-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lusseau_et_al_2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/571","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecosystem-service-mapping-severn-estuary-inner-bristol-channel","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ecosystemsknowledge.net\/sites\/default\/files\/wp-content\/uploads\/Ecosystem_service_mapping_in_the_Severn_estuary_and_inner_Bristol_Channel_Final_29_5.pdf","title":"Ecosystem service mapping in the Severn estuary and inner Bristol Channel","description":"This Natural Environment Research Council (NERC) Renewable Energy Knowledge Exchange funded project, conducted in partnership between Plymouth Marine Laboratory and the RSPB aimed to: Assess and map delivery of key ecosystem services (ES) within the greater Severn estuary and Bristol Channel (Figure 1).  Ecosystem services are the benefits people obtain from the natural environment. The habitats within the Severn estuary and inner Bristol Channel provide significant resources from cycling and storage of carbon through to flood prevention, income from recreational activities and inspiration for cultural activities. The outputs of the project provide a new set of ideas and material to aid better informed decision making in the greater Severn.  The scope of the project was to utilise the three month project period to take a broad scale approach to identify priority locations for the supply of key ES. Gaps in knowledge and barriers to assessment (limitations) were highlighted to aid future projects and target future research to support ES assessment in the Severn and inner Bristol Channel region. Identification of hotspots for key ES was intended to provide developers, regulators and other stakeholders with an insight into locations and importance of these sites and begin to provide a baseline to examine future benefits and dis-benefits from developments.  Project Objectives: 1. Identify and assess five key ES and related activities provided within the greater Severn Estuary, at least one of which should be a cultural service. 2. Map ES and related activities within a Geographical Information System. 3. Explore potential valuation approaches to add scales to the benefits of the services. 4. Communicate the findings to key stakeholders","author":["Ashley, M."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory","Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"originationDate":"2014-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.348443000000","-3.789002000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ashley_et_al_2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/572","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparative-life-cycle-assessment-hydro-nuclear-wind-power-china-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261919307664","title":"A comparative life-cycle assessment of hydro-, nuclear and wind power: A China study","description":"Energy sector is one of biggest contributors to the Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions. As a result, it has attracted considerable attention to reduce the GHG emissions of electricity production. Hydro-electric, nuclear and wind power are the top three clean energy in China. In this study, the environmental impacts of these three technologies are analyzed, assessed and compared via a life-cycle assessment approach. The entire life cycle, including the manufacturing, construction, operation and decommissioning stages is examined. Apart from global warming potential (GWP100) caused by GHG emissions, the environmental impacts assessed in this study also included acidification potential (AP), eutrophication potential (EP), photochemical ozone creation potential (POCP) and human toxicity potential (HTP). The results show that wind power technology has the most significant environmental impacts amongst these three clean energies, followed by nuclear power and hydropower. For example, in terms of global warming potential, wind power produces 28.6 \u00b1 3.2 g CO2-eq\/kWh of GWP100 throughout its life cycle, which is higher than that of nuclear power (12.4 \u00b1 1.5 g CO2-eq\/kWh) and hydropower (3.5 \u00b1 0.4 g CO2-eq\/kWh). In addition, this study revealed that the the manufacturing stage is the largest contributor of environmental impacts for wind and hydropower. By contrast, the decommissioning stage is most significant for nuclear power in terms of environmental impacts. The comparative life cycle assessment method proposed in this study provides useful tool for the future environmental assessment of electricity production technologies. Findings of this study provide useful inputs for the sustainable transformation of the energy sector.","author":["Wang, L.","Du, H.","Wang, Y.","Zuo, J.","Li, R.","Zhou, Z.","Bi, F.","Garvlehn, M."],"organization":["Tianjin University","University of Adelaide"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["31.758728000000","104.433101000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-11 10:49:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/573","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecological-efficiency-assessment-model-environmental-safety-management-wind-power","sourceURL":"https:\/\/content.sciendo.com\/view\/journals\/czoto\/1\/1\/article-p371.xml","title":"Ecological Efficiency Assessment Model for Environmental Safety Management of Wind Power Plant","description":"This study focuses on the evaluation of the benefits and ecological costs that occur in the life cycle of a wind power plant. The study constitutes an attempt to expand upon previously conducted research on the analysis of costs and benefits in the stages of production, operation and post-consumer management of wind turbines. The aim of the study adopted research methodology, analysis and assessment of the benefits and environmental impacts of the Vestas V90\/105m 2 MW wind turbine throughout its life cycle. Original assessment indicators of the benefits and ecological costs occurring throughout a wind power plant\u2019s life cycle for environmental safety management, were proposed and verified.","author":["Tomporowski, A.","Flizikowski, J.","Kruszelnicka, W.","Kasner, R.","Idzikowski, A."],"organization":["UTP University of Science and Technology in Bydgoszcz","Cz\u0119stochowa University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/574","type":["Document","Document\/Guidance"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/use-static-passive-acoustic-monitoring-pam-monitoring-cetaceans-marine-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nerc.ukri.org\/innovation\/activities\/energy\/offshore\/pam-guidance\/","title":"Use of Static Passive Acoustic Monitoring (PAM) for monitoring cetaceans at Marine Renewable Energy Installations (MREIs) for Marine Scotland","description":"This guidance document provides advice aimed at developers of marine renewable energy installations (MREIs) on the use of static passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) devices for monitoring vocalising cetaceans around MREIs. The document considers static passive acoustic monitoring (static PAM) for wind farms, tidal stream devices and wave energy converters. In UK waters, static PAM is most appropriate for monitoring small cetacean species such as harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) and dolphin species (such as bottlenose dolphins, Tursiops truncatus; common dolphins, Delphinus delphis; and white-beaked dolphins, Lagenorhynchus albirostris). Static PAM methods allow for continuous autonomous monitoring of small cetacean occurrence at MREI sites, and are thus one of the few approaches available to describe seasonal trends in habitat use, as well as direct measures of impact resultant from MREI activities. This document provides guidance on static PAM survey design, deployment and retrieval, and data analysis.","author":["Wilson, B.","Thompson, P.","Godley, B.","Witt, M.","Brookes, K.","Benjamins, S.","Pikesley, S.","Embling, C.","Graham, I.","Cheney, B."],"organization":["University of Exeter","Plymouth University","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","University of Aberdeen","Marine Scotland Science","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"originationDate":"2014-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.997610000000","-2.078499000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/emblingetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/575","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-acoustic-monitoring-wave-tidal-energy-sites-guidance-notes-regulators","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nerc.ukri.org\/innovation\/activities\/energy\/offshore\/underwater-acoustic-monitoring-guidance\/","title":"Underwater Acoustic Monitoring at Wave and Tidal Energy Sites: Guidance Notes for Regulators","description":"In April 2013 the European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) facilitated an underwater acoustic workshop for marine renewables regulators and their statutory environmental advisors. The driver for the workshop was the need for a greater appreciation amongst regulators of the key aspects of underwater acoustic data gathering. Specifically: what needs to be measured; how measurement should be undertaken; common pitfalls to avoid; and what to look for in a data gathering and analysis report.  This document has been prepared as a key output of that workshop, to provide high level guidance on the assessment of underwater acoustic measurement activities. It aims to enable regulators to have informed discussions with developers of marine energy converter systems (MECS) from the initial scoping stages and aid the assessment of monitoring activities.  Whilst this guideline relates specifically to the use of passive acoustic data gathering, in future there is likely to be a need for an equivalent guideline for the use of active acoustic techniques. Whereas passive acoustic (\u2018listening-in\u2019) techniques tend to be used to assess the sound output from devices and events, active acoustics (emitting sound and \u2018listening\u2019 for reflections) is being investigated as a monitoring tool, in particular to provide positioning and behavioural characteristics of objects.","author":["Lepper, P.","Robinson, S.","Humphrey, V.","Butler, M."],"organization":["National Physical Laboratory (NPL)","University of Southampton","European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)","Loughborough University","European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"originationDate":"2014-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lepperetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/576","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-tidal-consenting-position-paper-series-ornithological-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nerc.ukri.org\/innovation\/activities\/energy\/offshore\/ornithological-impacts\/","title":"Wave \u0026 Tidal Consenting Position Paper Series: Ornithological Impacts","description":"The potential ornithological impacts associated with the construction, operation and maintenance and decommissioning (together referred to as the \u2018project lifecycle\u2019) of wave and tidal energy devices (\u2018wave and tidal devices\u2019) have been identified and described in the Scottish Marine Renewables Strategic Environmental Assessment (\u2018the SEA\u2019) (Faber Maunsell \u0026amp; Metoc, 2007), the Scottish Natural Heritage (\u2018SNH\u2019) document \u201cGuidance on survey and monitoring in relation to marine renewables deployments in Scotland \u2013 Volume 4: Birds\u201d (Jackson \u0026amp; Whitfield, 2011) and by the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (\u2018RSPB\u2019) (McCluskie et al., 2013). These documents highlight the general impacts that may arise during the project lifecycle of wave and tidal devices and have informed the Environmental Impact Assessment (\u2018EIA\u2019) of projects that have been consented or await consent.  This paper builds upon current knowledge and available literature, drawing upon the experiences of those involved in the wave and tidal energy industry (gathered by telephone interviews with 11 stakeholders in industry, regulators and academia) in order to highlight key ornithological issues that have arisen during the development of wave and tidal devices and arrays. The aim of this paper is to provide a consolidated understanding of the current status of the ornithological issues facing the wave and tidal industry, highlight knowledge gaps and detail key experiences. Recommendations are also made for future research priorities and to aid the successful future deployment of wave and tidal devices","author":["Furness, R.","Hawkins, K.","Freeman, S.","Kirby, A.","McCall, R.","Edhou.se, E."],"organization":["T\u00dcV S\u00dcD","SMRU Consulting","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)","RenewableUK","Scottish Renewables"],"originationDate":"2013-10-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NERC_9.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/577","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-consenting-barriers-developing-floating-wind-farms-including-innovative","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nerc.ukri.org\/innovation\/activities\/energy\/offshore\/wind-farms\/","title":"Environmental and Consenting Barriers to Developing Floating Wind Farms Including Innovative Solutions","description":"The UK potentially has a significant opportunity to continue its leading role in offshore wind farm development by progressing with the commercialisation of floating wind. Floating foundations for wind turbines are seen as a solution to deploying in waters too deep for traditional foundations, or where the seabed is unsuitable for fixed foundations, and, a potential solution for accessing higher wind speeds further offshore remote from some stakeholder concerns. Demonstrator projects are in development in the UK and overseas waters, with the aim of deploying full scale commercial farms of floating wind farms in the near future.  Over the past five years, our understanding of the interactions between offshore renewable technologies (fixed wind turbines, wave and tidal devices) and environmental receptors has grown rapidly, and much of this information can be directly applied to predict the likely consequences of deploying floating wind structures offshore. However, there are also different and emerging environmental considerations specific to floating wind turbines, which need to be tackled, and early engagement over the issues will be beneficial for both industry and regulators especially where innovation, R\u0026amp;D is needed.  With this in mind, NERC, ARUP, the Carbon Trust, the ORE Catapult and the Scottish Government worked collaboratively to organise and deliver a workshop to identify environmental or consenting considerations which constitute barriers and risks to the industry, as well as identify innovative solutions.  The specific aims of the workshop were therefore to:  \u2022 Identify the main consenting and environmental risks\/barriers to the development of floating offshore wind farms at a demonstration and commercial scale \u2022 Identify the innovation and translational R\u0026amp;D needed to streamline and de risk planning, environmental consenting and post consent monitoring for floating wind,  This report summarises the outputs of the workshop and provides a synthesis of the information generated, with interpretation and recommendations for future action.","author":["Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"organization":["Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)","The Carbon Trust","Offshore Renewable Energy (ORE) Catapult","The Carbon Trust","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)","Offshore Renewable Energy (ORE) Catapult"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NERC_2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/578","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-renewable-energy-environmental-research-innovation-strategy-uk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.masts.ac.uk\/media\/36702\/ore-ri-strategy-plus-appendices-dec2018.pdf","title":"An Offshore Renewable Energy Environmental Research \u0026 Innovation Strategy for the UK","description":"The principal aim of developing this environmental R\u0026amp;I strategy for UK ORE, is to set out the high level environmental R\u0026amp;I priorities for the next five to ten years, together with measures for coordinating activity across the various funding organisations and key stakeholder interests, to ensure that the general direction of travel is towards developing a sustainable ORE industry. The strategy will make recommendations for improving communications with new funding programmes and between stakeholder groups, and for pro-actively developing a new strategic collaborative environmental R\u0026amp;I programme involving multiple partners, in order to support maintenance of targets for renewable electricity generation out to 2020 and beyond.  The strategy covers offshore wind (fixed and floating), wave and tidal (stream and range) energy and is focussed on drawing together all the recent and existing initiatives into a comprehensive strategy, and will illustrate how different initiatives complement one another. It is predicated on maximising the use of existing structures and processes (ie. Ocean Energy ORJIP (Offshore Renewables Joint Industry Programme), the Offshore Wind ORJIP, MEW (Marine Energy Wales), SPORRAN (Scottish Offshore Renewables Research Framework, now ScotMER \u2013 Scottish Marine Environmental Research), PRIMaRE (Peninsular Research Institute for Marine Renewable Energy) and using information sources such as outputs from recent workshops (eg. The ORE Supergen Hub workshops, Oct\/Nov 2017). Recommendations for finalising and implementing the strategy are set out in the final section of this document.","author":["Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"organization":["Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)","Marine Alliance for Science and Technology Scotland (MASTS)","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2019-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.316549000000","-2.041717000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NERC_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/579","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparing-environmental-effects-rance-severn-barrages","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.icevirtuallibrary.com\/doi\/full\/10.1680\/maen.2009.162.1.11","title":"Comparing environmental effects of Rance and Severn barrages","description":"This paper examines the similarities and contrasts between environmental and water quality changes caused by the 1966 tidal power barrage at La Rance in North Brittany, France and those expected to result from construction of a tidal power barrage in the Severn estuary in the UK. Over the 40-year period since the opening of La Rance, a great deal of knowledge has been accumulated concerning the operation of such schemes and the way water quality and ecosystems have altered. Knowledge gained from experiences at Rance is consequently of great benefit in predicting the effects of the proposed Severn barrage. The nature of the changes anticipated in the Severn estuary is thus unambiguous, but whether this would make the estuary better or worse is a matter of perception. As at Rance, it would be different.  Click here for more on the La Rance Tidal Barrage.","author":["Kirby, R.","Reti\u00e8re. C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2009-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.618688600000","-2.017955000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/580","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-tidal-consenting-position-paper-series-impacts-fish-shellfish-ecology","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nerc.ukri.org\/innovation\/activities\/energy\/offshore\/impacts-on-fish-and-shellfish-ecology\/","title":"Wave \u0026 Tidal Consenting Position Paper Series: Impacts on Fish and Shellfish Ecology","description":"This paper builds on the existing literature and the experiences gained by those involved in the wave and tidal energy industry (obtained through telephone interviews with eleven stakeholders in the regulatory and development sectors). The consensus from those interviewed is that effects of wave and tidal technologies on fish and shellfish ecology are generally considered less of a priority than effects on fisheries. However, fisheries impacts are not within the scope of this position paper and are therefore not discussed further.  The aim of this paper is to highlight key fish and shellfish issues and potential impacts that have arisen during the development of wave and tidal technologies, and to provide a consolidated understanding of the wave and tidal industry, knowledge gaps and key experiences.","author":["Blyth-Skyrme, R.","Hawkins, K.","Freeman, S.","Kirby, A.","McCall, R."],"organization":["T\u00dcV S\u00dcD","SMRU Consulting","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"originationDate":"2013-10-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Freeman_et_al_2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/581","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-research-development-leadership-ocean-energy-technologies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/10154003","title":"An assessment of research and development leadership in ocean energy technologies","description":"Japan is clearly the leader in ocean energy technologies. The United Kingdom also has had many ocean energy research projects, but unlike Japan, most of the British projects have not progressed from the feasibility study stage to the demonstration stage. Federally funded ocean energy research in the US was stopped because it was perceived the technologies could not compete with conventional sources of fuel. Despite the probable small market for ocean energy technologies, the short sighted viewpoint of the US government regarding funding of these technologies may be harmful to US economic competitiveness. The technologies may have important uses in other applications, such as offshore construction and oil and gas drilling. Discontinuing the research and development of these technologies may cause the US to lose knowledge and miss market opportunities. If the US wishes to maintain its knowledge base and a market presence for ocean energy technologies, it may wish to consider entering into a cooperative agreement with Japan and\/or the United Kingdom. Cooperative agreements are beneficial not only for technology transfer but also for cost-sharing.","author":["Bruch, V."],"organization":["Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"1994-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bruch_et_al_1994.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/582","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning-climate-uncertainty-irish-perspective","sourceURL":"https:\/\/irishgeography.ie\/index.php\/irishgeography\/article\/view\/1375","title":"Marine Spatial Planning in a Climate of Uncertainty - An Irish Perspective","description":"A \u20ac1.8bn \u2018blue economy\u2019 centred on shipping, commercial fishing, offshore energy extraction, and tourism, contributes approximately 1% toward Ireland\u2019s GDP. A suite of EU-level Directives, legislation, and national-level policies and strategies have been enacted to further expand upon this productivity while simultaneously reducing the risk of environmental damages. This paper examines the development and implementation of marine spatial planning in Ireland, and considers its functionality in the face of climate change impacts. Climate change will cause significant changes in the availability and reliable delivery of marine ecosystem services, particularly supporting and regulating services. It is important for policy makers and stakeholders to recognise the limits of planning when faced with the uncertain, complex nature of climate change. As such, marine spatial planning tools must be responsive, adaptive, and support larger responses that address the sources of climate change \u2013 greenhouse gas emissions \u2013 rather than responding to its impacts.","author":["Carr, L."],"organization":["National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.279589000000","-8.816055900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Carr2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/583","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/future-coastal-estuarine-modeling-findings-workshop","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1463500319301015","title":"The future of coastal and estuarine modeling: Findings from a workshop","description":"This paper summarizes the findings of a workshop convened in the United States in 2018 to discuss methods in coastal and estuarine modeling and to propose key areas of research and development needed to improve their accuracy and reliability. The focus of this paper is on physical processes, and we provide an overview of the current state-of-the-art based on presentations and discussions at the meeting, which revolved around the four primary themes of parameterizations, numerical methods, in-situ and remote-sensing measurements, and high-performance computing. A primary outcome of the workshop was agreement on the need to reduce subjectivity and improve reproducibility in modeling of physical processes in the coastal ocean. Reduction of subjectivity can be accomplished through development of standards for benchmarks, grid generation, and validation, and reproducibility can be improved through development of standards for input\/output, coupling and model nesting, and reporting. Subjectivity can also be reduced through more engagement with the applied mathematics and computer science communities to develop methods for robust parameter estimation and uncertainty quantification. Such engagement could be encouraged through more collaboration between the forward and inverse modeling communities and integration of more applied math and computer science into oceanography curricula. Another outcome of the workshop was agreement on the need to develop high-resolution models that scale on advanced HPC systems to resolve, rather than parameterize, processes with horizontal scales that range between the depth and the internal Rossby deformation scale. Unsurprisingly, more research is needed on parameterizations of processes at scales smaller than the depth, including parameterizations for drag (including bottom roughness, bedforms, vegetation and corals), wave breaking, and air\u2013sea interactions under strong wind conditions. Other topics that require significantly more work to better parameterize include nearshore wave modeling, sediment transport modeling, and morphodynamics. Finally, it was agreed that coastal models should be considered as key infrastructure needed to support research, just like laboratory facilities, field instrumentation, and research vessels. This will require a shift in the way proposals related to coastal ocean modeling are reviewed and funded.","author":["Zhang, Y.","Fringer, O.","Dawson, C.","He, R.","Ralston, D."],"organization":["Stanford University","University of Texas","North Carolina State University","Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/584","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/baseline-presence-effects-tidal-turbine-installation-operations-porpoise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.thejot.net\/article-preview\/?show_article_preview=1071","title":"Baseline Presence of and Effects of Tidal Turbine Installation and Operations on Harbour Porpoise in Minas Passage, Bay of Fundy, Canada","description":"Harbour porpoise echolocation activity within and outside of the FORCE tidal turbine demonstration area in Minas Passage of the upper Bay of Fundy, Nova Scotia, has been monitored by up to eight bottom-moored (30-80 m depth) C-POD click train detectors across 1,210 days between May 2011 and May 2018. Detections occurred on almost every day (98.9% of days), averaging 86.5% across C-PODs, at a median of seven detection positive minutes per day and for a maximum of 44 minutes per day, noting that porpoise detection probabilities using buoy-mounted C-PODs should be considered minimum estimates. No confirmed dolphin click detections were documented. A statistical (Generalized Additive Model using GEE, or GAM-GEE) approach with a logit link function confirmed porpoise presence varied significantly by time of year (peak period mid-June and a lower secondary peak early November), by tidal current speed and tidal height (preference for 0-2.5 m\/s ebb tides), by time of day (higher click activity at night), and across the lunar cycle. Seasonal and diel variability may be partly driven by prey accessibility. C-POD monitoring performance (termed Percent Time Lost) varied spatially and temporally. The Percent Time Lost was associated with non-biological sediment movement-related clicks causing the C-PODs maximum click detection memory buffer to be exceeded, notably during very high (e.g., spring tide) tidal speeds. The effects of these covariates were controlled for within the subsequent GAM-GEE modelling process to assess the effects of the installation and 130 days of operations of a 16 m diameter 2 MW OpenHydro tidal turbine. Importantly, despite the winter turbine deployment period, the C-POD data highlighted that porpoises were not excluded by turbine installation and operations over the mid-field study area, with click detections occurring on 98.5% of days, averaging 82% across C-PODs, with a median of three minutes per day. However, GAM-GEE modelling identified a significant decrease in porpoise click activity when the turbine was operational; this effect varied spatially, with a significant decrease in porpoise activity at the two sites closest (200-230 m) to the operating turbine berth of the five C-POD monitoring sites assessed. C-PODs at two sites that were more than a kilometre away did not show a significant turbine effect, while a third site, at 1,690 m from the turbine and in deeper water to the south, showed an increase in porpoise click detections.A longer time series of turbine deployment is believed required before robust conclusions can be drawn on turbine effects. Nevertheless, it was clear that after turbine removal, porpoise click activity rates returned to pre-installation baseline rates.","author":["Tollit, D.","Wood, J.","Booth, C.","Redden, A.","Joy, R.","Porskamp, P.","Boucher, T.","Oldreive, M."],"organization":["SMRU Consulting","Acadia Centre for Estuarine Research (ACER)","Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.316966000000","-64.167081000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/585","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/first-three-dimensional-tracks-bat-migration-reveal-large-amounts-individual","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ecy.2762","title":"First three-dimensional tracks of bat migration reveal large amounts of individual behavioral flexibility","description":"Animal migration has fascinated humans at least since Aristotle\u2019s time, but we only started to understand itsdetails thanks to the famous \u201carrow storks\u201d in the 19thcentury that returned to Europe with arrows in their bodies, providing the first clues of African wintering sites. Bird migration has received a large amount of attention since then, but knowledge about migration of other organisms, even small passerine birds, remains rudimentary (Bowlin et al. 2010).\n\nDocumenting individual migration altitudes is particularly important because of increasing densities of wind power turbines\u2014a major cause of migrating bat mortality (Voigt et al. 2012). Suitable GPS devices for these small animals have only recently been developed, are still relatively heavy, and require relocating the logger. This necessitates additional approaches to study individual three-dimensional movement.\n\nDevelopment of miniaturized barometric pressure radio transmitters (Sparrow Systems, Fisher, IL, USA) encouraged us to follow the three-dimensional paths of migrating noctules (Bowlin et al. 2015).\n\nIndividual migratory flights differed, both within and among individuals. This is similar to Swainson\u2019s thrushes, which show a large amount of variation intiming, duration, and altitude of individual tracks (Bowlin et al. 2015). This suggests that individuals make decisions to take advantage of wind, landscape, and navigational conditions or other, yet-unknown factors, to optimize their nightly flights. Our results once more confirm that the flexibility and behavioral repertoire of individuals in the wild are greater than we assume. More work is necessary to understand the threats and challenges common noctules and other migrating species encounter as they move across the landscape, particularly as over 40% of our observations were within the sweep range of most wind turbines inGermany.","author":["Wikelski, M.","O\u0027Mara, M.","Kranstauber, B.","Dechmann, D."],"organization":["Max Planck Institute for Ornithology","University of Konstanz","University of Zurich"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.000000000000","9.600000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/586","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-major-threats-challenges-global-bat-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nyaspubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/nyas.14045","title":"A review of the major threats and challenges to global bat conservation","description":"Bats are an ecologically and taxonomically diverse group accounting for roughly a fifth of mammalian diversity worldwide. Many of the threats bats face (e.g., habitat loss, bushmeat hunting, and climate change) reflect the conservation challenges of our era. However, compared to other mammals and birds, we know significantly less about the population status of most bat species, which makes prioritizing and planning conservation actions challenging. Over a third of bat species assessed by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) are considered threatened or data deficient, and well over half of the species have unknown or decreasing population trends. That equals 988 species, or 80% of bats assessed by IUCN, needing conservation or research attention. Delivering conservation to bat species will require sustained efforts to assess population status and trends and address data deficiencies. Successful bat conservation must integrate research and conservation to identify stressors and their solutions and to test the efficacy of actions to stabilize or increase populations. Global and regional networks that connect researchers, conservation practitioners, and local stakeholders to share knowledge, build capacity, and prioritize and coordinate research and conservation efforts, are vital to ensuring sustainable bat populations worldwide.","author":["Frick, W.","Kingston, T.","Flanders, J."],"organization":["University of California Santa Cruz","University of Bristol"],"originationDate":"2020-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/587","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/improving-policies-regulations-environmental-friendly-ocean-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/koreascience.or.kr\/article\/JAKO201426636276611.page","title":"Improving policies and regulations for environmental-friendly ocean renewable energy development in Korea","description":"A wide range of projects for ocean renewable energy are currently in development around the world and ocean energy industries continue to receive significant support from their governments. Surrounded by sea on three sides, Korea has potentially abundant renewable ocean energy resources, which include tidal current, tidal range, offshore wind power, osmotic pressure and ocean thermal energy. Numerous ocean renewable energy projects has been developed in Korea. Nevertheless, there are some concerns that those developments often select an environmentally unsuitable location and\/or there are very few existing information on those environmental effects. The purpose of this study is to improve supporting policies and regulation systems of ocean renewable energy development in Korea by reviewing and compiling government policies and environmental assessment systems related to ocean renewable energy development around the world. The study suggests several policy implications for its environmental-friendly development in Korea, including requirements of strategic environmental assessment for proactive and environmentally suitable site selection of ocean renewable energy development and continuous post-development environmental monitoring, and so on.","author":["Park, J.","Kim, T."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2014-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.820632000000","128.439875500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/588","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/investigation-existing-post-construction-mortality-monitoring-victorian-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ari.vic.gov.au\/__data\/assets\/pdf_file\/0024\/435309\/ARI-Technical-Report-302-Investigation-of-existing-post-construction-monitoring-at-Victorian-wind-farms.pdf","title":"Investigation of existing post-construction mortality monitoring at Victorian wind farms to assess its utility in estimating mortality rates","description":"Wind energy is a significant component of the Victorian government\u2019s commitment to renewable energy. Assessment of potential impacts on birds and bats due to collisions with turbines is now routinely undertaken at operating wind farms, and this includes post-construction mortality monitoring. Monitoring programs vary considerably between wind farms in their objectives and design, and in the intensity, frequency and duration of monitoring. Bird and bat carcasses that are found are documented and, to estimate the total numbers of mortalities that are likely to have occurred on a wind farm, correction factors are developed to factor in the level of sampling and site-specific detectability issues. However, despite many years of monitoring, the accuracy of such estimates remains unclear, and it is not yet known whether turbine collisions are having a significant impact on populations of birds and bats. Therefore, it is timely to conduct a review of the postconstruction mortality monitoring that has been undertaken to date, to assess what conclusions can be drawn from the available data, and to develop options for improvements in the future.  The specific aims of this review are:    to examine the existing post-construction mortality monitoring data to evaluate whether these data are adequate to estimate annual mortalities of birds and bats at wind farms;  to generate a list of all the species known to have been killed by collisions with turbines at wind farms;  to discuss possible approaches for assessing the cumulative and population-level impacts of multiple wind farms across the landscape;  to develop options for future post-construction monitoring for wind farms and to discuss their advantages and disadvantages; and  to identify key knowledge gaps that, if filled, would enable greater confidence in mortality assessments and in estimates of cumulative and population-level impacts.","author":["Smales, I.","Lumsden, L.","Moloney, P."],"organization":["Arthur Rylah Institute for Environmental Research"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Moloneyetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/589","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-science-based-approach-defining-key-species-birds-bats-concern-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ari.vic.gov.au\/__data\/assets\/pdf_file\/0015\/435300\/ARI-Technical-Report-301-Developing-a-science-based-approach-to-defining-key-species-of-concern-for-wind-farm-developments.pdf","title":"Developing a science-based approach to defining key species of birds and bats of concern for wind farm developments in Victoria","description":"Assessments of the potential effects of collisions with wind turbines by birds and bats are now a routine component of pre-approval planning processes for commercial-scale wind energy projects in Victoria. However, there is a lack of clear guidance on which species need to be included in these assessments.  The aim of this project was to provide a science-based approach to assist in decision-making regarding turbine collision risk for birds and bats in Victoria. There were two components to the project. First, it was necessary to decide which species should form the basis of the investigation, by deriving a list of \u2018species of interest\u2019 based on threatened species status. Second, it was necessary to develop an approach to determine which of those species may be at risk, at a Victorian population level, due to collisions with turbines, to enable a list of \u2018species of concern\u2019 to be compiled.","author":["Smales, I.","Lumsden, L.","Moloney, P."],"organization":["Arthur Rylah Institute for Environmental Research"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-36.961102000000","145.748930000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lumsdenetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/590","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/machine-learning-applied-wind-turbine-blades-impact-detection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/full\/10.1177\/0309524X19849859","title":"Machine learning applied to wind turbine blades impact detection","description":"The significant development of wind power generation worldwide brings, together with environmental benefits, wildlife concerns, especially for volant species vulnerability to interactions with wind energy facilities. For surveying such events, an automatic system for continuous monitoring of blade collisions is critical. An onboard multi-senor system capable of providing real-time collision detection using integrated vibration sensors is developed and successfully tested. However, to detect low signal-to-noise ratio impact can be challenging; hence, an advanced impact detection method has been developed and presented in this article. A robust automated detection algorithm based on support vector machine is proposed. After a preliminary signal pre-processing, geometric features specifically selected for their sensitivity to impact signals are extracted from raw vibration signal and energy distribution graph. The predictive model is formulated by training conventional support vector machine using extracted features for impact identification. Finally, the performance of the predictive model is evaluated by accuracy, precision, and recall. Results indicate a linear regression relationship between signal-to-noise ratio and model overall performance. The proposed method is much reliable on higher signal-to-noise ratio (SNR\u22656), but it shows to be ineffective at lower signal-to-noise ratio (SNR\u0026lt;2).","author":["Albertani, R.","Hu, C."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2020-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/591","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/testing-efficacy-bird-deterrents-wind-turbine-facilities-pilot-study-nova-scotia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ojs.library.dal.ca\/nsis\/article\/view\/nsis50-1dorey%2Cdickey%2Cwalker","title":"Testing efficacy of bird deterrents at wind turbine facilities: a pilot study in Nova Scotia, Canada","description":"Wind energy has become one of the fastest-growing renewable electricity sources globally, and this trend is expected to continue. However, wind turbines cause avian mortality when birds collide with these structures. Although regulatory agencies in many jurisdictions require post-construction bird mortality monitoring at turbine sites, resulting mortality estimates are often imprecise and under-reported. This uncertainty is often attributed to searcher inefficiencies or scavenger losses. Furthermore, data regarding the effectiveness of active bird mortality mitigation at these facilities are also lacking. This pilot study assessed mitigation effectiveness of visual and audio deterrents, using predator owl deterrent models and bioacoustic alarm and predator calls deployed at a wind turbine facility in Nova Scotia, Canada. These deterrents did not deter birds from wind turbines in statistically significant ways, in comparison to control sites. Whilst results were inconclusive, it would be prudent to continue assessing mitigative options to minimize impacts on birds, considering the expected growth of the wind energy sector in Canada.","author":["Walker, T.","Dorey, K.","Dicky, S."],"organization":["Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.779095000000","-63.815030000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/592","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-tidal-energy-converters-sediment-dynamics-tidal-channel","sourceURL":"https:\/\/espace.library.uq.edu.au\/view\/UQ:5ac15f1","title":"Influence of Tidal Energy Converters on sediment dynamics in tidal channel","description":"Tidal stream turbines are one of the most advanced marine renewable energy technologies. Nonetheless, the application of the technology faces considerable challenges, as uncertainties exist about the potential impacts of these devices on the marine environment. For instance, sediment dynamics have important implications to local fauna as well as turbine foundations, design and longevity. As a result, understanding of local sediment dynamics and its impact on the environment is an important element for site assessments. However, full-scale environment surveys of tidal farms are sparse and limited, as it is at early stage of development. An alternative to study the potential impacts on the sediment transport is numerical modelling. Nevertheless, validation of these models remains challenging as it is difficult to acquire the necessary sediment data from these high-energy sites.  Hydrodynamic case studies for tidal farms exist for modeller to compare their results and insuring their models behave accurately. However, no similar case study can be found for sediment transport around tidal farms. The aim of this work is to understand the general sediment behaviour around tidal farms as well as setting a benchmark study for future modelling analysis. A series of idealised simulations, using hydrodynamic and sediment transport of MIKE21 and MIKE3 flexible mesh, are developed to investigate processes and interaction of Tidal Energy Converters (TECs) in an artificial high energetic flow system under a range of conditions (two different grain sizes, two layouts of arrays).  Findings from this study show that the 3D depth averaged velocity (DAV) is very similar to the 2D velocity: resulting in little change in bed level, less than 3% regionally, when DAV is used for sediment transport rates. However, using the bottom velocity of the 3D model generates different sediment behaviour at the vicinity of tidal arrays.","author":["Auguste, C.","Nader, J.","Marsh, P.","Cossu, R."],"organization":["University of Tasmania","University of Queensland"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/593","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/optimisation-tidal-turbine-array-layouts-whilst-limiting-their-hydro-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007%2Fs40722-019-00145-8","title":"Optimisation of tidal turbine array layouts whilst limiting their hydro-environmental impact","description":"The economic viability of tidal energy projects will likely require large-scale deployment, with tens, or even hundreds, of turbines positioned in an array. There is limited published research available on the viability of large-scale deployments, which will depend on both the expected energy yield and potential adverse hydro-environmental impacts. This leads to the question of how best to position turbines in large-scale arrays for maximum energy capture with minimal associated hydro-environmental impacts. The primary aim of this research was the further development of an existing two-dimensional tidal flow model for optimising tidal turbine arrays relative to both power output and potential hydro-environmental impacts. Turbine impacts are simulated using a momentum sink approach and an optimisation algorithm was implemented, which determines an optimal array configuration for maximum energy capture, whilst employing spatial and environmental impact constraints. Application of the developed model to an idealised test case demonstrated that a staggered array is optimal, if one considers maximising power capture alone, while a fence layout was optimal, when considering both power output and associated impacts. In both the scenarios, the optimised configurations produced higher efficiencies than symmetrical inline arrays. To demonstrate the model\u2019s applicability to a real tidal environment, it was applied to a case study site; the Shannon Estuary, along the West Coast of Ireland. To the authors\u2019 knowledge, this is the first automated array optimisation model to incorporate hydro-environmental impact constraints with the aim of determining specific optimised array configurations with quantifiable efficiencies. The approach could be extremely useful for determining the economic viability of proposed arrays, enabling determination of \u2018environmentally acceptable\u2019 levels of tidal energy extraction, and thereby allowing the completion of realistic and accurate early stage cost\u2013benefit analyses for tidal energy projects. The model is therefore, potentially, a very valuable tool for tidal energy researchers, developers and planners.","author":["Nash, S.","Phoenix, A."],"organization":["National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.641720000000","-9.086860000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/595","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-powered-adaptable-monitoring-package-hardware-design-installation-deployment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/static1.squarespace.com\/static\/5aa9f94e5ffd209c73921fa3\/t\/5d8705c6d4e8684cb883343a\/1569129928565\/EWTEC2019_1528_Joslin_April.pdf","title":"The wave-powered adaptable monitoring package: hardware design, installation, and deployment","description":"In October, 2018 the BOLT Lifesaver, a BOLTclass wave energy converter developed by Fred. Olsen Ltd., was deployed at the US Navy\u2019s Wave Energy Test Site in Kane\u2019ohe, Hawaii. The Lifesaver is an autonomous system, with no cable to shore. For a full year prior to the deployment, researchers and industry partners at the University of Washington, University of Hawaii, Fred. Olsen Ltd., Sea Engineering, and WiBotic Inc. collaborated on the development of an autonomous wave-powered environmental monitoring system. The Lifesaver was instrumented with an Adaptable Monitoring Package (AMP), as well as an on board control computer and power handling system. The AMP instrumentation suite included stereo-optical cameras, an acoustic camera, a multibeam sonar, two hydrophones, and a demonstration unit from WiBotic that could allow for wireless recharging of an underwater vehicle. At full power, the instrumentation and recharge system draws 600 W of power, which is relatively high in oceanographic terms. As a first of its kind deployment, this system demonstrates the transformative potential of wave energy to power oceanographic instrumentation and extend the endurance of autonomous underwater vehicles.","author":["Stewart, A.","Joslin, J.","Cotter, E.","Murphy, P.","Gibbs, P.","Cross, P.","Polagye, B.","Cavagnaro, R.","Crisp, C.","Hjetland, E.","Rocheleau, A.","Waters, B."],"organization":["University of Washington","Sea Engineering Inc","Sea Engineering","Fred. Olsen Bolt Sea Power","University of Hawaii"],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["21.451660000000","-157.791110000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EWTEC2019_1528_Joslin_April.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/596","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-acceptance-offshore-wind-farms-netherlands-testing-adjusting-public-acceptance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/essay.utwente.nl\/79333\/","title":"Public Acceptance of Offshore Wind Farms in the Netherlands: Testing and Adjusting the Public Acceptance Models for a Better Wind of Change","description":"As part of the renewable energy transition, for the past few years, the Netherlands has been implementing wind farms as its resource, both onshore and offshore. The onshore wind farms so far gained shallow public acceptance with various issues such as overlooked locals\u2019 interests, unfairness sense and low trust to the government, and physical visibility, noise, and shadow of wind turbines. Previous studies showed that people possess a better acceptance of offshore wind farms in other countries. However, since offshore wind farms are newer and very different than the onshore ones, there is no research that specifically assesses the public acceptance of offshore wind farms in the Netherlands. This research aimed to fill that gap by examining the public acceptance using an existing framework provided by POLIMP, an organization founded by the European Union. This organization consists of several research institutions that put interest in social aspects of sustainable development, including renewable energy technology. They identified five possible influential elements which were public awareness, fairness sense, trust towards stakeholders, evaluation of costs, risks, and, benefits of a technology\/resource, and local context.  This research tested that framework and based on the analysis of it, came up with a new adjusted framework, customized specially for investigating the factors that influence public acceptance of offshore wind farms in the Netherlands. The data of this study were gathered with an online survey and analyzed quantitatively with correlation and regression methods. The results show that based on the existing framework, public\u2019s high level of awareness, positive evaluation of costs, risks, and benefits and local context fit influenced public acceptance of offshore wind farms in the Netherlands. The results from the new adjusted model reveal that knowledge about the needs of renewable energy and trust towards the researchers as the source of that knowledge is essential to influence public acceptance. Fairness sense, trust towards other involved stakeholders, and demographic characteristics did not give any positive influence to the public acceptance of offshore wind farms in the Netherlands.  It is recommended for the researchers to be open for interaction and communicate with the public to not just improve public\u2019s awareness but also their understanding regarding the knowledge about the needs and the technology of offshore wind farms. This awareness will lead the public to have a better evaluation of performance and regulations of offshore wind farms. It is also advised to pay great attention to the location of offshore wind farms. Not only regarding the view and sound impacts, but also the ecology impact related to biodiversity and the fishing industry.","author":["Dion, A."],"organization":["University of Twente"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.576540000000","4.777829000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/597","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/r-d-ocean-energy-review-research-development-ocean-energy-republic-ireland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mria.ie\/documents\/eab9e47fbd94a9101fff94623.pdf","title":"R and D and Ocean Energy: A review of Research and Development in Ocean Energy in the Republic of Ireland","description":"Ocean energy \u2013 wave and tidal generated electricity - is at the Research and Development, pre-commercial stage. Ireland has a significant effort underway in ocean energy R and D which represents a potential competitive advantage for the country particularly in light of other advantages such as the highly energy intensive wave resource, possible access to major markets through the Anglo Irish talks on electricity supply now underway and other factors.  This Paper records the views of the three key stakeholders in ocean energy R and D- Third Level institutions, Government Agencies and Industry. It sets out the boundaries to ocean energy at the present as discerned by these stakeholders and it identifies the five research priorities for the next few years: develop and grow the database; develop understanding of the economics of the industry; promote a series of projects to deal with practical engineering problems; continue to invest in infrastructure; and build the research effort into the environmental dimension to ocean energy. Overarching all of this is the need to provide funding for R and D in this (Government-determined) research priority area.","author":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"originationDate":"2012-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.127467000000","-7.608105000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRIA_8.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/598","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/non-financial-non-technical-barriers-development-ocean-energy-sector-ireland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mria.ie\/site\/assets\/files\/1016\/mria_study_on_non_technical_non_financial_obstacles_to_ocean_energy.pdf","title":"Non-Financial and Non-Technical Barriers to the Development of the Ocean Energy Sector in Ireland","description":"This is the latest in a series of Discussion Papers prepared and published by the Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA) with the generous support and encouragement of the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI). The illustration on the preceding page indicates the wide range of topics covered in recent years.  Ocean energy can be a major source of jobs and income in Ireland from around the late 2020\u2019s onwards as the tough engineering challenges involved in generating electricity reliably (and at a competitive cost) from wave and tidal energy convertor devices are overcome. Ireland has a substantial wave resource (and a tidal one too, in Northern Ireland), 3 excellent R\u0026amp;D facilities and supportive Government policies. We can become a global supply chain hub for ocean energy and a major exporter of offshore-generated electricity too.  The current challenge is to sustain policy-makers interest and support in this \u2018industry of tomorrow\u2019. One key to this for the MRIA is to help lay down the policy infrastructure to support and exploit the almost unique Irish opportunity in the future in ocean energy. Thus, the MRIA has dealt with the most obvious policy needs \u2013 finance, R\u0026amp;D, educational requirements etc \u2013 in our range of Discussion Papers to date.  This Paper deals with the non-engineering and technology and nonfinancial roadblocks to ocean energy. In particular, it focuses on the important area of insurance which we believe can be both an issue and an opportunity for Ireland. It seeks to raise awareness also of issues in areas as diverse as marine vessel operations and health and safety. Moreover, we update in this Paper, as has been the practice in recent Papers, the evidence for ocean energy\u2019s claim to be a major economic development opportunity.","author":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)","Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.127467000000","-7.608105000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRIA_7.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/599","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/opportunity-co-operation-collaboration-between-ireland-scotland-ocean-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mria.ie\/documents\/6e5ff0f36327685fbd176036c.pdf","title":"The Opportunity for Co-Operation and Collaboration between Ireland and Scotland in Ocean Energy","description":"Ireland, North and South, and Scotland are world leaders in the field of ocean energy and are endowed with substantial wave and tidal resources, excellent and growing Research and Development capacity and are home to many of the world\u2019s leading companies in this field. Historically, Scotland has been ahead of Ireland in developing ocean energy, principally because of the strong commitment of Scottish political leaders to winning a commanding position for Scotland in the industry. On the island of Ireland, Northern Ireland has made commendable progress in exploiting its tidal resource but the Republic of Ireland has been the laggard despite its world-beating wave resource and its significant R\u0026amp;D effort. The position is changing in the Republic with positive signs of Government support including a new Bill to transform the consenting system (\u2018planning permission\u2019) offshore while the Ocean Renewable Energy Development Plan is imminent.  Despite the progress, ocean energy in both Ireland and Scotland faces formidable challenges: the technology has a distance to travel before it reaches commercial ubiquity; the finance required to commercialise the technology is substantial; and there are significant issues of market access, particularly in Scotland, because, for example, wave and tidal resources tend to be distant from major grid capacity.  This Paper was drawn up to examine the scope for the various parties \u2013 particularly the Republic of Ireland and Scotland but also Northern Ireland\u2013 to work together. It is based on the views of a wide range of interests, mostly in Government and Industry, who expressed remarkably similar views regardless of geographical location. The Paper ends with a series of recommendations and suggests that these might form a series of work streams for the British Irish Council\u2019s Marine Energy Committee.","author":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)","Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI)"],"originationDate":"2013-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.073144000000","-2.164304000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRIA_6.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/600","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/maritime-infrastructure-development-priorities-support-irelands-future-ocean-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mria.ie\/documents\/c4a46712f4cf756fb277c60bc.pdf","title":"Maritime Infrastructure Development Priorities to Support Ireland\u0027s Future Ocean Energy Industry","description":"The past year has seen a turnaround in the fortunes of ocean energy in the Republic of Ireland with the publication in February of the Government\u2019s Ocean Renewable Energy Development Plan (OREDP). The new policy recognised that the growth of ocean energy would require investment in maritime infrastructure - ships and, in particular, port facilities.  The OREDP followed the track laid down by three reports commissioned by Government since 2009 on the topic of maritime infrastructure and ocean energy (Scotland has had four reports on the same topic since 2010!). Put simply, the maritime infrastructure issue has three related strands. First, ocean energy still has a journey ahead of it to achieve technical maturity. Second, in Ireland\u2019s case, any electricity generated from our bountiful west coast wave resource may need market opportunities, particularly in the export field, and these are not anticipated for some years to come. However, given that ocean energy becomes a reliable and (gradually) competitive source of electricity and that market opportunities are developed, then a major hurdle must be crossed: the actual capacity of Irish ports to support ocean energy. Ocean energy devices are large, ideally must be built (or at least assembled) close to deployment sites and will make significant demands on port facilities.  Ireland\u2019s wave energy resource is off the west coast. It should be possible to support the development of the resource, at least at the southern end of the west coast, from Shannon Foynes and Cork. Beyond a certain level of deployment, the much smaller ports to the north of County Clare would struggle to cope with developments off Mayo \u2013the most likely ocean energy location in the north-west - in particular.  This Paper analyses the issue, draws conclusions and make recommendations about a challenge which must be tackled if ocean energy is to develop at scale from around 2030 , a short time away in the notoriously long investment cycle times in energy and in maritime infrastructure.","author":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)","Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI)"],"originationDate":"2014-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.096174000000","-7.737229000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRIA_5.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/601","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/funding-development-ocean-energy-industry-ireland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mria.ie\/documents\/a524d9555b5a39944adbd8d7c.pdf","title":"Funding the Development of the Ocean Energy Industry in Ireland","description":"Ocean energy is an emerging technology which must overcome tough engineering challenges arising from its \u2018home\u2019 environment, the sea, before it can become a pervasive source of electricity. However, there is a remarkable convergence of opinion about the prospects for ocean energy and about its potential economic impact which serve to underpin the case for the Irish State\u2019s support for the sector. Ocean energy is not a niche opportunity. It could one day stand alongside or even surpass offshore wind as an energy source. Most important of all, it is a sector from which Ireland can benefit significantly in jobs and income terms: we have perhaps the best wave resource in the world, outstanding R\u0026amp;D facilities and a wide range of industrial competences suited to ocean energy development. A key obstacle on the pathway to this prize, however, is pre-commercial technology finance, particularly funding to support device and component developers in the middle ground from the key TRL 3 and upwards stages (to cTRL6) in the evolution of their projects.  Ocean energy has had an unusual financial journey so far. Although an emerging technology (and despite its overall economic promise), it has received relatively little State support globally compared to other forms of energy such as nuclear and solar. Indeed, policy instruments drove early ocean energy pioneers, although arguably not in Ireland, into the commercial financial sphere at a uniquely early stage with almost predictable adverse consequences. An important finding of this Paper is that the financial sector in Ireland is informed about energy, including ocean energy, but that there is little prospect of significant commercial financial support at this stage of tidal and, particularly, wave development.  Ocean energy policy in Ireland has developed well in recent years (exception: out of date laws governing consenting - \u2018planning permission\u2019 - of projects) with a fit-for-purpose policy framework (the \u2018OREDP\u2019) and funding increases ensuring that the industry and the supporting infrastructure continue to progress. However, a critical \u2018funding gap\u2019 has been identified and this Paper suggests how it might be filled (Pre Commercial Development Fund) within existing or proposed budget envelopes and it also outlines a way forward to meet future, probably post 2020, needs to fund early commercial ocean energy arrays.","author":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"originationDate":"2016-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.096174000000","-7.737229000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/mria_4.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/602","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-cost-benefit-analysis-offshore-wind-energy-under-climatic-conditions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S030626191831585X","title":"Life cycle cost-benefit analysis of offshore wind energy under the climatic conditions in Southeast Asia - Setting the bottom-line for deployment","description":"Offshore renewable energy resources are options to address a country\u2019s energy and climate objectives without having to occupy vast amount of land space. Offshore wind power production, among the various offshore renewable options, has gained popularity albeit its dependence on the deployment location\u2019s wind conditions, technical challenge in construction and grid connection, and potentially high capital cost. The wind conditions in Southeast Asia are generally much less favourable as compared to other parts of the world, but several economies in this region consider offshore wind energy as a long term solution to decarbonize the electricity sector and to diversify the source of electricity. There is thus a need to evaluate the true benefits of offshore wind energy under the region\u2019s suboptimal climatic conditions. In response, this study employs the life cycle analysis approach to conduct a cost-benefit analysis of offshore wind energy in the context of Southeast Asia. Findings from study suggest that the cost of offshore wind energy remains high at the moment for Southeast Asia. The findings further contribute to the debate on offshore wind energy by setting the bottom-line for deployment under unfavourable climatic conditions in the tropical region and world-wide. However, offshore wind farm could still represent a plausible option through technology innovation in wind turbine designs and reductions in the cost of wind turbine and submarine power cable. As suggested in this study, there is potential for the cost of offshore wind energy to reach parity against onshore renewables such as solar energy in the context of Southeast Asia.","author":["Liu, Y.","Nian, V.","Zhong, S."],"organization":["National University of Singapore"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["6.427749000000","107.723927000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/603","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/third-level-education-needs-ocean-energy-industry","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mria.ie\/documents\/92d05fb11cdab8d6531dd4cbb.pdf","title":"Third-Level Education Needs of the Ocean Energy Industry","description":"The island of Ireland faces an economically transformative opportunity in ocean energyenergy generated from waves and tides. The independent SQW report forecasts substantial income and job potential, particularly in the 2020\u2019s when ocean energy technology is likely to reach maturity and to be deployed on a commercial scale. The opportunity will be realised on two planes- enterprise (e.g. development of the supply chain in Ireland to support the industry not only here but elsewhere in Europe) and export (e.g. through interconnectors to the UK and elsewhere).  A key factor in determining Ireland\u2019s success in this challenging industry will be the quality and availability of appropriately skilled graduates from the Universities and the Institutes of Technology and other bodies, notably in engineering. This Paper presents the findings of a review of this issue by the Marine Renewables Industry Association with expert bodies and with those involved in the emerging ocean energy industry. The principal findings were:    There is substantial capacity in engineering education on the island  The supply of engineers is reasonable at present although shortages are discerned in the key field of electrical engineering and there is concern about the overall numbers entering the profession  The opportunities in ocean energy will be modest to 2015 at least but could be very significant in the 2020s  Ocean energy will principally require engineers with a robust, core degree in the traditional disciplines of civil, electrical and mechanical engineering.  Little value is attached by the ocean energy industry to the various \u2018energy engineering\u2019 qualifications increasingly on offer  Providing real experience of working in the tough offshore environment to engineers is a big challenge for ocean energy  The industry- and other experts- would like to see a Masters degree programme in ocean energy engineering which draws off the expertise in specific fields of individual colleges and which is designed in conjunction with the industry to the highest international standards \uf0b7 The MRIA will work with appropriate bodies to address the issues identified by this Paper.","author":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"originationDate":"2011-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.282264000000","-8.114790000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRIA_education.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/604","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning-needs-marine-renewables-emerging-technologies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mria.ie\/site\/assets\/files\/1016\/marine_spatial_planning_needs_of_marine_renewables_emerging_technologies.pdf","title":"Marine Spatial Planning Needs of Marine Renewables Emerging Technologies","description":"There has been a major change in Irish energy policy during the course of 2018. The recent ground-breaking support structure for renewables, known as RESS1, recognises for the first time that marine renewables have an important part to play in meeting Ireland\u2019s 2030 renewable energy targets. These, in turn, are predicated on a substantial step-up in the decarbonisation of the electricity generating system in particular. This will not be possible from terrestrial wind sources alone while solar energy will make some contribution. The other major change is the introduction and rapid implementation of a National Marine Planning Framework (NMPF), popularly known as Marine Spatial Planning2 (MSP), which is the subject of this Paper.  The NMPF\/MSP will influence the framework for all marine developments in future and will have a profound impact over time on all those involved with the sea.  A number of critical issues in marine spatial planning arise from the perspective of the marine renewables emerging technologies of wave, tidal and floating wind energy (and \u2018hybrids\u2019 of floating wind and wave) .... not to mention their mature relation, bottom-fixed offshore wind:  1. Zoning, or spatial allocation at sea for various activities, is likely to feature in some way in Irelands marine spatial plan and that is to be welcomed, provided it takes account of a number of core issues dealt with in this Paper.  2. There is undoubtedly going to be an issue with the potential visual impact of offshore wind in particular and one obvious policy possibility would be to introduce a buffer zone to exclude all marine renewables within a specified distance from the coast. We spell out the serious, negative consequences for marine renewable energy with an example of such an initiative. A buffer zone approach should be considered with great care and be locally site specific.  3. There is a need to establish structures which would make it easier to consult and engage with local stakeholders and those potentially impacted by marine renewables development - a long-term partnership in the broad sense is needed between marine renewables developers and other marine interests. 4. There are challenges to be tackled in the areas of data and, also, ports infrastructure. In addition, there is a critical issue for all engaged with the ocean: there is a hyper-urgent need to introduce modern offshore consenting legislation or our globally leading marine renewables energy resources will continue to lie fallow","author":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"originationDate":"2018-12-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.942733000000","-7.570730000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRIA_spatialplanning.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/605","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/risk-analysis-maintenance-ship-collisions-offshore-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/14786451.2017.1327437","title":"Risk analysis of maintenance ship collisions with offshore wind turbines","description":"A large number of offshore wind farms are planned to be built in remote deep-sea areas over the next five years. Though offshore wind sites are often located away from commercial ship traffic, the increased demand for repair or replacement services leads to high traffic densities of \u201cmaintenance ships\u201d. To date, the risk analysis of collision between maintenance ship vessels and offshore wind turbines has received very little attention. In this paper, we propose a methodology to evaluate and prioritise the collision risks associated with various kinds of ships used for carrying out maintenance tasks on different subassemblies of wind turbines in an offshore wind farm. It is also studied how the risks of ship collision with wind turbines are distributed between two main types of maintenance tasks, namely corrective and preventative. The proposed model is tested on an offshore wind turbine with seventeen components requiring five kinds of ships to perform the maintenance tasks. Our results indicate that collision risks are mostly associated with maintenance of few components of the wind turbine and in particular, those undergoing a corrective maintenance (replacement). Finally, several mitigation strategies are introduced to minimise the risk of maintenance ship collisions with offshore wind turbines.","author":["Presencia, C.","Shafiee, M."],"organization":["Cranfield University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Navigation"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/607","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-effects-wind-farming-local-weather-using-weather-research-forecasting-wrf","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-981-13-3338-5_21","title":"Modelling the Effects of Wind Farming on the Local Weather Using Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) Model","description":"Exploitation of wind energy is rapidly growing around the world with large wind farms being set-up for the generation of electricity. It is reported in the literature that while converting the wind\u2019s kinetic energy into electrical energy, the wind turbines may modify the transfer of energy, momentum and moisture within the atmospheric layers in the surroundings of the farms. In this work, an attempt is made to study whether the wind farm situated at Roches Noires (operational since January 2016), in the north-east part of the island of Mauritius, creates such changes within a sufficiently large space around the farm. The Weather Research and Forecasting (WRF) numerical model is employed for this endeavour due to the unavailability of measured weather data in regions close to the farm. The WRF model results are first validated with recorded meteorological data from several meteorological stations around the island and then simulations are carried out for the years 2015, 2016 and 2017. Analysis of results for two selected locations (one upstream and one downstream) around the Roches Noires wind farm demonstrates a slight decrease both in wind speed and precipitation, one year after installation of the farm.","author":["Dhunny, A.","Lollchund, M.","Jawaheer, B.","Cunden, T.","Chandrasekaran, N."],"organization":["University of Mauritius","Universit\u00e9 Des Mascareignes"],"originationDate":"2019-01-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["-20.277592000000","57.560491000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/608","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/harbour-porpoise-responses-pile-driving-diminish-over-time","sourceURL":"https:\/\/royalsocietypublishing.org\/doi\/full\/10.1098\/rsos.190335","title":"Harbour porpoise responses to pile-driving diminish over time","description":"Estimating impacts of offshore windfarm construction on marine mammals requires data on displacement in relation to different noise levels and sources. Using echolocation detectors and noise recorders, we investigated harbour porpoise behavioural responses to piling noise during the 10-month foundation installation of a North Sea windfarm. Current UK guidance assumes total displacement within 26 km of pile driving. By contrast, we recorded a 50% probability of response within 7.4 km (95% CI = 5.7\u20139.4) at the first location piled, decreasing to 1.3 km (95% CI = 0.2\u20132.8) by the final location; representing 28% (95% CI = 21\u201335) and 18% (95% CI = 13\u201323) displacement of individuals within 26 km. Distance proved as good a predictor of responses as audiogram-weighted received levels, presenting a more practicable variable for environmental assessments. Critically, acoustic deterrent device (ADD) use and vessel activity increased response levels. Policy and management to minimize impacts of renewables on cetaceans have concentrated on pile-driving noise. Our results highlight the need to consider trade-offs between efforts to reduce far-field behavioural disturbance and near-field injury through ADD use.","author":["Barton, T.","Thompson, P.","Merchant, N.","Graham, I.","Farcas, A.","Cheney, B.","Bono, S."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen","Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)"],"originationDate":"2019-06-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.055086000000","-3.313705000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/609","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sustainable-use-marine-resources-through-offshore-wind-mussel-farm-co-location","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0304380017302338","title":"Sustainable use of marine resources through offshore wind and mussel farm co-location","description":"Marine Spatial Planning\u00a0(MSP) can offer significant benefits in terms of economic conservation strategies, optimizing spatial planning and minimizing the impact on the environment. In this paper, we focused on the application of\u00a0multi-criteria evaluation\u00a0(MCE) technique for co-locating offshore wind farms and open-water mussel cultivation. An index of co-location sustainability (SI) was developed based on the application of MCE technique constructed with physical and biological parameters on the basis of remote-sensing data. The relevant physical factors considered were wind velocity, depth range, concerning the site location for energy production, and sea surface temperature anomaly. The biological variables used were Chlorofill-a (as a measurement of the productivity) and\u00a0Particle Organic Carbon(POC) concentration, in order to assess their influence on the probable benefits and complete the requirements of this management framework. This SI can be easily implemented to do a first order selection of the most promising areas to be more specifically studied in a second order approach based on local field data.","author":["Benassai, G.","Mariani, P.","Di Tullio, G.","Di Luccio, D.","Grieco, L."],"organization":["College of Charleston","Technical University of Denmark (DTU)","Parthenope University of Naples","Universita Politecnica Delle Marche"],"originationDate":"2018-01-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.614892000000","10.025344000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/610","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/co-location-opportunities-renewable-energies-aquaculture-facilities-canary-archipelago","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117309122","title":"Co-location opportunities for renewable energies and aquaculture facilities in the Canary Archipelago","description":"Integrated Offshore Management is a future challenge for the development of sustainable growth of marine economies. The progressive increase in worldwide demands for marine-based renewable energies combined with higher market demands for aquaculture-based food requires better knowledge on marine spatial planning tools that allow optimizing the use of this space for different purposes. That is the case of energy production and aquaculture activities, in which synergistic and competitive interactions must be thoroughly analyzed at an appropriate scale. The present study proposes a specific methodology that integrates several selection criteria responding simultaneously to the needs and limitations of marine aquaculture and renewable energy production, aiming to identify opportunities for the co-location of these activities. The methodology was implemented over 25 km of the coastal fringe of four islands of the Canary Archipelago, applying a multi-criteria approach based on independent probabilistic suitability and mapping analysis (time series of 20\u201330 years) for: (i) wind and wave energy production potential; (ii) structural requirements for aquaculture cages and energy devices; (iii) limits for operation and maintenance activities; (iv) feasibility to transport energy to the grid; and (v) biological requirements for eight species of fish. A stepwise procedure was carried out, including: 1) suitability for wave, wind and aquaculture activities, with spatial resolution of 0.01\u00b0 (0\u20131 probability scale); and 2) integrated co-location mapping, considering suitability for each activity. Opportunities for the co-location of wind and aquaculture farms were identified in the southeastern portion of the islands, while in Tenerife and Fuerteventura wave-wind devices co-location opportunities were identified. Thus, opportunities for marine aquaculture and renewable energy were demonstrated in the present case study applying a preliminary assessment of the potential exploitation of these resources.","author":["Gonzalez, J.","Guanche, R.","Guinda, X.","Juanes, J.","Weiss, C.","Ondiviela, B.","del Jesus, F."],"organization":["University of Cantabria","Plataforma Oce\u00e1nica de Canarias (PLOCAN)"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["28.657782000000","-15.250952000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/611","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/lessons-learned-marine-governance-case-studies-marine-spatial-planning-practice-us","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X17308990","title":"Lessons learned in marine governance: Case studies of marine spatial planning practice in the U.S.","description":"Marine spatial planning (MSP) is an approach to marine governance and the management of marine space requiring extensive stakeholder participation and interagency and inter-organizational cooperation. While a rich literature and set of practitioner guidance on MSP has developed, few studies include empirical research or identify lessons learned based on practitioner experience. The authors conducted three case studies of MSP in Washington, San Francisco Bay, and Rhode Island, U.S., including 50 practitioner and stakeholder interviews, to identify practitioners\u2019 lessons learned regarding stakeholder participation and inter-organizational cooperation. Findings were then shared with 43 practitioners at an MSP workshop to ensure lessons resonated with a broader practitioner community. The authors found that practitioners had learned the importance of using both formal and informal stakeholder participation methods; leveraging pre-existing relationships as a foundation for MSP; and setting and managing the expectations of both stakeholders and agency partners. Results point to the effectiveness of using pre-existing stakeholder forums to build informal authentic dialogue between participants, rather than establishing new advisory bodies to support MSP. Further, pre-existing groups and other pre-existing relationships and communication networks are an important source of social capital for MSP. Last, clear communication and transparency are important in setting and managing stakeholders\u2019 and agency partners\u2019 expectations for MSP. This paper concludes with recommendations for further empirical research into practitioners\u2019 MSP experience, particularly in the U.S., and for a new generation of practitioner guidance based on research and including practical strategies to help practitioners work within the real-world constraints of politics and budgets.","author":["McCann, J.","Smythe, T."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.153977100000","-124.514173100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Stakeholder Engagement","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/612","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/camera-technology-monitoring-marine-biodiversity-human-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/fee.1322","title":"Camera technology for monitoring marine biodiversity and human impact","description":"Human activities have fundamentally altered the marine environment, creating a need for effective management in one of Earth\u0027s most challenging habitats. Remote camera imagery has emerged as an essential tool for monitoring at all scales, from individuals to populations and communities up to entire marine ecosystems. Here we review the use of remote cameras to monitor the marine environment in relation to human activity, and consider emerging and potential future applications. Rapid technological advances in equipment and analytical tools influence where, why, and how remote camera imagery can be applied. We encourage the inclusion of cameras within multi\u2010method and multi\u2010sensor approaches to improve our understanding of ecosystems and help manage human activities and minimize impacts.","author":["Sheehan, E.","Votier, S.","Godley, B.","Witt, M.","Bicknell, A."],"organization":["University of Exeter","University of Plymouth"],"originationDate":"2016-10-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/613","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-sprawl-facilitates-dispersal-connectivity-protected-species","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41598-018-29575-4","title":"Ocean sprawl facilitates dispersal and connectivity of protected species","description":"Highly connected networks generally improve resilience in complex systems. We present a novel application of this paradigm and investigated the potential for anthropogenic structures in the ocean to enhance connectivity of a protected species threatened by human pressures and climate change. Biophysical dispersal models of a protected coral species simulated potential connectivity between oil and gas installations across the North Sea but also metapopulation outcomes for naturally occurring corals downstream. Network analyses illustrated how just a single generation of virtual larvae released from these installations could create a highly connected anthropogenic system, with larvae becoming competent to settle over a range of natural deep-sea, shelf and fjord coral ecosystems including a marine protected area. These results provide the first study showing that a system of anthropogenic structures can have international conservation significance by creating ecologically connected networks and by acting as stepping stones for cross-border interconnection to natural populations.","author":["Fox, A.","Roberts, J.","Ferris, J.","Henry, L.","Mayorga-Adame, C.","Polton, J.","McLellan, F.","McCabe, C.","Kutti, T."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh","National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","BMT","Institute of Marine Research (IMR)","University of North Carolina","ECAP Consultancy Group","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.518871000000","3.512337000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/614","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/automated-detection-tracking-marine-mammals-novel-sonar-tool-monitoring-effects-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/aqc.3103","title":"Automated detection and tracking of marine mammals: A novel sonar tool for monitoring effects of marine industry","description":"Many marine industries may pose acute risks to marine wildlife. For example, tidal turbines have the potential to injure or kill marine mammals through collisions with turbine blades. However, the quantification of collision risk is currently limited by a lack of suitable technologies to collect long\u2010term data on marine mammal behaviour around tidal turbines.\nSonar provides a potential means of tracking marine mammals around tidal turbines. However, its effectiveness for long\u2010term data collection is hindered by the large data volumes and the need for manual validation of detections. Therefore, the aim here was to develop and test automated classification algorithms for marine mammals in sonar data.\nData on the movements of harbour seals were collected in a tidally energetic environment using a high\u2010frequency multibeam sonar on a custom designed seabed\u2010mounted platform. The study area was monitored by observers to provide visual validation of seals and other targets detected by the sonar.\nSixty\u2010five confirmed seals and 96 other targets were detected by the sonar. Movement and shape parameters associated with each target were extracted and used to develop a series of classification algorithms. Kernel support vector machines were used to classify targets (seal vs. nonseal) and cross\u2010validation analyses were carried out to quantify classifier efficiency.\nThe best\u2010fit kernel support vector machine correctly classified all the confirmed seals but misclassified a small percentage of non\u2010seal targets (~8%) as seals. Shape and non\u2010spectral movement parameters were considered to be the most important in achieving successful classification.\nResults indicate that sonar is an effective method for detecting and tracking seals in tidal environments, and the automated classification approach developed here provides a key tool that could be applied to collecting long\u2010term behavioural data around anthropogenic activities such as tidal turbines.","author":["Gillespie, D.","Hastie, G.","Sparling, C.","Moss, S.","Wu, G.","Macaulay, J.","Evers, C.","Jepp, P.","Lee, A."],"organization":["University of St Andrews","SMRU Consulting","Bedford Institute of Oceanography"],"originationDate":"2019-09-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.445577000000","-2.791212000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/615","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/attitudes-us-wind-turbine-neighbors-analysis-nationwide-survey","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421519305683","title":"Attitudes of U.S. Wind Turbine Neighbors: Analysis of a Nationwide Survey","description":"Experts predict continuing deployment of wind turbines in the United States, which will create more interactions between turbines and surrounding communities. Policymakers can benefit from analyses of existing wind projects that enable them to better understand likely effects on residents around proposed projects. Our analysis of a randomly drawn, representative national survey of 1705 existing U.S. wind project neighbors provides previously unavailable detail about factors influencing the attitudes of these neighbors toward their local wind projects. Overall, we find positive-leaning attitudes, which improve over time as individuals self-select into communities near existing wind projects. Hearing wind turbines leads to less-positive attitudes, although living very near to turbines does not, nor does seeing wind turbines. In fact, our findings suggest complex relationships among nearby residents\u2019 attitudes, their perceptions about the particular fit of turbines within their landscape and community, and their perceptions of wind project impacts on property values. These findings\u2014along with the positive correlation between perceived planning-process fairness and attitude\u2014suggest areas of focus for wind project development that may influence social outcomes and acceptance of wind energy. The concluding discussion provides a number of policy and future research recommendations based on the research.","author":["Firestone, J.","Rand, J.","Hoen, B.","Lantz, E.","Wiser, R.","Elliot, D.","H\u00fcbner, G.","Pohl, J.","Haac, T.","Kaliski, K."],"organization":["Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory","University of Delaware","Portland State University","Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg","MSH Medical School Hamburg","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","Resource Systems Group Inc"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.924038400000","-77.045263600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/616","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/climatic-impacts-wind-power","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S254243511830446X","title":"Climatic Impacts of Wind Power","description":"We find that generating today\u0027s US electricity demand (0.5 TWe) with wind power would warm Continental US surface temperatures by 0.24\u00b0C. Warming arises, in part, from turbines redistributing heat by mixing the boundary layer. Modeled diurnal and seasonal temperature differences are roughly consistent with recent observations of warming at wind farms, reflecting a coherent mechanistic understanding for how wind turbines alter climate. The warming effect is: small compared with projections of 21st century warming, approximately equivalent to the reduced warming achieved by decarbonizing global electricity generation, and large compared with the reduced warming achieved by decarbonizing US electricity with wind. For the same generation rate, the climatic impacts from solar photovoltaic systems are about ten times smaller than wind systems. Wind\u0027s overall environmental impacts are surely less than fossil energy. Yet, as the energy system is decarbonized, decisions between wind and solar should be informed by estimates of their climate impacts.","author":["Miller, L.","Keith, D."],"organization":["Harvard University"],"originationDate":"2018-12-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.312640600000","-72.761774900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/617","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/challenges-decommissioning-offshore-wind-farms-overview-european-experience","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1742-6596\/1222\/1\/012035\/meta","title":"Challenges of decommissioning offshore wind farms: Overview of the European experience","description":"In the coming years, an important number of offshore wind turbines will reach the end of their initially planned service life. In a wind turbine end-of-life scenario, owners can decide between extending the life of the asset, repowering the site or decommissioning. This decision-making process is affected by important sources of uncertainty, especially in offshore environments. The limited experience makes the decommissioning procedure challenging, as it is still largely unexplored. This work assesses the current state of knowledge about the challenges surrounding the decommissioning process of an offshore wind farm. The four main challenges encountered are identified and analysed in detail, namely the regulatory framework, the overall planning of the process, the logistics and vessels\u0027 availability, and the environmental impacts confronted. Ultimately, this paper aims at stimulating the dialogue among stakeholders and raising the awareness of adequately regulating and preparing the upcoming decommissioning of offshore wind farms in Europe.","author":["Topham, E.","McMillan, D.","Gonzalez, E.","Jo\u00e3o, E."],"organization":["DNV GL","University of Strathclyde"],"originationDate":"2019-05-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-11 01:29:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Topham_2019_J._Phys.__Conf._Ser._1222_012035.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/618","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farms-icelandic-highlands-attitudes-local-residents-tourism-service-providers","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0264837719301590","title":"Wind farms in the Icelandic highlands: Attitudes of local residents and tourism service providers","description":"Over the last decades the harnessing of wind power has gained increasing popularity and is currently believed to be one of world\u2019s best environmental options in seeking to meet the international target of reducing greenhouse gas emissions by at least half by the year 2050. There is undeniably an abundance of wind resources in Iceland. But what impact would the harnessing of this power have on the country\u2019s growing tourism industry? This paper focuses on the dynamics existing between wind farming, residents and tourism. Its overall aim is to evaluate the attitudes of local residents and tourism service providers in Southern Iceland towards the country\u2019s first proposed wind farm, which is to be located at the edge of Iceland\u2019s Southern highlands, and to critically discuss the causal relationship between the landscape and these attitudes. An on-site questionnaire was distributed to residents in the municipalities adjacent to the proposed wind farm. Interviews were also conducted with residents and tourist service providers. The results indicate that the relationship between residents and the landscape of the proposed site is based on its use as highland pasture and the residents\u2019 romantic conception of the landscape, which for centuries has been characterized by wildness and remoteness. This conception seems to linger on despite gradually increasing hydropower production in the area. The associations made by tourist service providers with the area differ since they are selling a certain image, that of unspoilt nature and wilderness. Wind turbines would be a new and prominent presence in the Icelandic landscape likely to transform the area from its previous perceived wild and natural state. As such, social acceptance of the location of wind farms in the Icelandic highlands is more critical than in the case of more traditional ways of harnessing renewable energy.","author":["S\u00e6\u00fe\u00f3rsd\u00f3ttir, A.","\u00d3lafsd\u00f3ttir, R."],"organization":["University of Iceland"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["64.188325000000","-20.138278000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Recreation \u0026 Tourism","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/619","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/not-my-hiking-trail-acceptance-wind-farms-austrian-alps","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10098-019-01734-9","title":"Not in my hiking trail? Acceptance of wind farms in the Austrian Alps","description":"Large-scale wind power projects are one of the bearers of hope for a transition toward low-carbon electricity systems. The question of social acceptance of such projects near residential areas, or acceptance of the technology in general, has received significant attention in the scientific literature. Less attention has been placed on acceptability of wind farms in sparsely inhabited mountain areas; the focus of this paper therefore is on acceptance of wind farms in the Austrian Alps from the perspective of tourists and day trippers. We conducted a quantitative survey with visitors of alpine regions (n\u2009=\u2009137) in proximity to recently constructed wind farms and identified drivers of (non-)acceptance by means of bivariate correlations and multiple linear regressions. Results indicate a high acceptance of wind technology in general and fairly high acceptance for the existing projects. Acceptance levels, however, are slightly, but significantly lower when respondents were asked to rate acceptability of wind farms in the Alps in general. Perceived benefits and reliability of wind power is the strongest predictor variable for higher acceptance levels, while annoyance through visual impact and noise is the strongest predictor variable for lower acceptance levels. Interestingly, factors like degree of information, concern regarding environmental impacts, trust in decision makers and climate change concern do not significantly affect acceptance levels. At the moment, no major opposition to wind power can be identified among tourists. Policy makers therefore should emphasize benefits of wind farms, as respective perceptions are a main predictor for acceptance. Operators should take annoyance concerns seriously, as this factor is predominant in predicting non-acceptance.","author":["Brudermann, T.","Zaman, R.","Posch, A."],"organization":["University of Graz","Khulna University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.246304000000","15.169638000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Recreation \u0026 Tourism","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/620","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seeing-clearly-virtual-reality-tourist-reactions-offshore-wind-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421518305251","title":"Seeing clearly in a virtual reality: Tourist reactions to an offshore wind project","description":"Most research to elicit citizen\u0027s reactions to proposed windfarms use either no visuals (relying on text) or static representations (e.g., 2-D photos or drawings); we develop and test a virtual reality (VR) tool to determine whether increased information \u2013 in the form of VR \u2013 alters tourists\u2019 perceptions, attitudes, concerns and behaviors related to a proposed siting of wind turbines. Tourists using the VR were better at evaluating the impact of wind turbines on their experience and forecasting how their behavior may change. Also the VR caused respondents, on average, to have more negative reactions.","author":["Teisl, M.","Noblet, C.","Corey, R.","Giudice, N."],"organization":["University of Maine"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.764887000000","-69.313094000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Recreation \u0026 Tourism"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/621","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/advancing-relationship-between-renewable-energy-ecosystem-services-landscape-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2212041618300901","title":"Advancing the relationship between renewable energy and ecosystem services for landscape planning and design: A literature review","description":"The transition to a low carbon future is starting to affect landscapes around the world. In order for this landscape transformation to be sustainable, renewable energy technologies should not cause critical trade-offs between the provision of energy and that of other ecosystem services such as food production. This literature review advances the body of knowledge on sustainable energy transition with special focus on ecosystem services-based approaches and methods. Two key issues emerge from this review: only one sixth of the published applications on the relation between renewable energy and landscape make use of the ecosystem service framework. Secondly, the applications that do address ecosystem services for landscape planning and design lack efficient methods and spatial reference systems that accommodate both cultural and regulating ecosystem services. Future research efforts should be directed to further advancing the spatial reference systems, the use of participatory mapping and landscape visualizations tools for cultural ecosystem services and the elaboration of landscape design principles.","author":["Picchi, P.","van Lierop, M.","Geneletti, D.","Stremke, S."],"organization":["University of Trento","Technische Universitat Munchen","Wageningen University and Research Centre"],"originationDate":"2019-01-11","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/622","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-estimates-support-offshore-wind-energy-false-consensus-pluralistic-ignorance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421517306286","title":"Public estimates of support for offshore wind energy: False consensus, pluralistic ignorance, and partisan effects","description":"Meeting future energy demands will require large-scale implementation of renewable energy projects. If one of these energy sources\u2014offshore wind\u2014becomes a common sight off coastlines, consideration of local public opinion and action will be critical. Previous research from the social sciences has lacked depth in examining the underlying factors that shape public opinion towards offshore wind development. The current research brings a new perspective to the literature by showing that how members of the public perceive support among others relates to their own opinions of offshore wind energy. We report results from two surveys. The first focused on opinion formation relating to offshore wind in general among New England residents, while the second focused on a specific offshore wind project in Rhode Island. We find evidence that both supporters and opponents of offshore wind underestimate levels of support among others, indicating a pluralistic ignorance effect and false consensus effect, respectively. We also find distinct patterns of perceived support among self-identified Republicans and Democrats. The findings hold important implications for policymakers and developers in understanding the nature of public support and opposition for offshore wind energy, particularly with respect to individuals\u2019 willingness to publicly engage with offshore wind projects.","author":["Bidwell, D.","Sokoloski, R.","Markowitz, E."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts","University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.912730000000","-71.601357000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/623","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nonmarket-valuation-marine-resources-northeast-implications-recreational-fisheries","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.uri.edu\/oa_diss\/842\/","title":"Nonmarket Valuation of Marine Resources in the Northeast: Implications for Recreational Fisheries Management and Offshore Wind Energy Development","description":"Sound natural resource management considers the full range of costs and benefits of policy action. Understanding these implications as they pertain to nonmarket goods or externalities requires an accurate assessment of consumer preferences and behavior. The chapters of this dissertation ascertain this knowledge in the context of recreational Atlantic striped bass fishery management and offshore wind development in the northeast United States.  Atlantic striped bass are the most prominent and heavily targeted recreational species found along the coast from Maine to North Carolina. Yet due in part to heavy recreational fishing effort, the species may be currently overfished. Given this status, it is pertinent to explore the concurrent impacts of potential policy action on angler participation, angler welfare, and recreational fishing mortality such that efficient compromises between conservation and socioeconomic objectives of fisheries management can be made.  In Chapter 1, we evaluate the economic incentives faced by recreational striped bass anglers using data from a recently-administered recreational striped bass angler survey. We estimate angler preferences for and the nonmarket value of keeping and releasing small (22\u201d), medium (29\u201d), and trophy-sized (38\u201d) fish. We find that for each size-class, anglers prefer keeping to releasing striped bass and that the nonmarket value of Atlantic striped bass increases exponentially with catch size. Illuminating the tradeoffs made by recreational striped bass anglers, our results indicate that one harvestable trophy-sized fish can be exchanged for about two medium-sized or three small ones. Chapter 1 also sheds light on an important issue that arises when using discrete choice experiment data to evaluate angler preferences; namely, the influence of including versus excluding catch-and-release regulations on ensuing parameter estimates in models of angler utility. We find that failing to control for such regulations leads to counterintuitive estimates of the marginal utility of releasing striped bass. Finally, while choice experiment survey data is used extensively in the literature on recreational demand modeling, little attention has been paid to survey non-response bias on welfare estimates. We spearhead this issue using data collected from survey non-respondents during a telephone pre-screening interview.  In Chapter 2, we integrate the main results from Chapter 1 and historical catch data into an aggregate demand model to examine the broad effect of recreational striped bass fishing policies. We simulate the recreational Atlantic striped bass fishery and measure the relative effect of alternative sets of fishing regulations on angler welfare, angler participation, fishing mortality, and mature female fishing mortality. By comparing fishery outcomes across several recreational fishing policies, we assess policy-induced economic and biological tradeoffs that have yet to be considered jointly by managers of the fishery. We find that a wide range of economically efficient policies are available when the primary purpose of proposed policy action across the studied region is to control total recreational fishing mortality. When proposed management action is intended to curtail mature female recreational fishing mortality, however, proposed policy action that does not account for potential economic consequences can lead to inefficient outcomes, as exemplified by several of the policies analyzed lying inside the efficient frontier of welfare and female spawning stock removal volume. The findings in Chapter 2 illuminate the practicality of assessing angler behavioral responses as a means of selecting efficient regulations, particularly when fisheries managers seek to balance socioeconomic goals with multiple conservation objectives.  Chapter 3 of this dissertation, currently in review at Resource and Energy Economics, addresses one previously unanswered question related to offshore wind energy development: that is, to what extent do offshore wind farms (OSWFs) impact local tourism? We examine how the Block Island Wind Farm, the United States\u2019 first operational OSWF, has impacted the short-term housing rental market. Using data from AirBnb, we estimate a difference-in-differences model that compares rental activity in Block Island to that in three nearby tourist destinations in Southern New England before and after construction. Estimation results suggest that following its construction, the Block Island Wind Farm caused a significant increase in nightly reservations, occupancy rates, and monthly revenues for AirBnb properties in Block Island during the peaktourism months of July and August but had no effect in other months. The findings from this case study indicate that offshore wind farms can act as an attractive feature of a location, rather than a deterrent, and provide an important data point for the ongoing debate surrounding tourism impacts of OSWFs.","author":["Carr-Harris, A."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.173459000000","-71.557961000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/624","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/contributions-marine-infrastructures-marine-planning-protected-area-networking","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/aqc.2916","title":"Contributions of marine infrastructures to marine planning and protected area networking","description":"Marine infrastructures are becoming ubiquitous as a result of the increasing exploitation of resources in the nearshore environment. These infrastructures are frequently linked with habitat degradation, pollution, and the establishment and spread of alien species. As marine infrastructures are perceived as threats to marine ecosystems, they are typically disregarded in conservation planning schemes.\nHere, the presence of invertebrates and fish was surveyed in infrastructure areas with prohibited public access, as well as in nearby rocky reef areas that had no infrastructure and were open to the public.\nIt was found that species richness, Shannon diversity, and uniqueness of both fish and invertebrates were significantly higher in the infrastructure habitats than in the rocky reef habitats in most cases. Surprisingly, the findings show that the proportion of alien species was higher in the unprotected rocky reef habitats compared with that in the infrastructure habitats.\nThese counterintuitive findings suggest that marine infrastructures that limit unauthorized access to the surrounding territory may contribute to conservation if they are acknowledged and managed, according to their potential to provide a habitat for marine species. This suggests that these areas should be considered by planners as opportunities to enhance the connectivity of populations and to supplement marine protected areas in heavily impacted marine environments.","author":["Portman, M.","Shabtay, A.","Carmel, Y."],"organization":["Technion Israel Institute for Technology"],"originationDate":"2018-06-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.298515000000","34.746962000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/625","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measuring-waves-currents-european-marine-energy-centre-tidal-energy-test-site-campaign","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/8085001","title":"Measuring waves and currents at the European marine energy centre tidal energy test site: Campaign specification, measurement methodologies and data exploitation","description":"Improved understanding of the dynamics of tidal currents and ocean waves and the loads they impose on tidal turbines is a prerequisite for an economically viable tidal turbine industry. The dynamic environment effects machine design and reliability, has consequences on operations and maintenance and ultimately energy conversion rate. Over the course of a recently completed five year international collaborative project multiple, multi-instrument measurement campaigns were conducted to acquire information on the flow, and recently, the wave-field incident upon an operating commercial-scale tidal energy converter (TEC), the Alstom 1MW DEEPGEN IV. This article summarises the measurement campaign specification and methodology, introduces the project\u0027s technical reports and describes access to all of the acquired data. A new research project, FloWTurb: Response of Tidal Energy Converters to Combined Tidal Flow, Waves, and Turbulence has already incorporated \u201clessons-learned\u201d, which are summarised, into upcoming field measurements in the Pentland Firth and has funded a significant re-analysis of these existing data sets beyond the original project\u0027s scope. A selection of summarising results are introduced here, where the inclusion of ocean wave measurements and analysis allows the data to be exploited in new ways.","author":["Ingram, D.","Sellar, B.","Sutherland, D.","Venugopal, C."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2017-06-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.959105000000","-3.376339000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Sellar-et-al-2017-Oceans.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/626","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/situ-observations-simulations-coastal-wave-field-transformation-wave-energy-converters","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378383917304623","title":"In situ observations and simulations of coastal wave field transformation by wave energy converters","description":"Wave energy is a potential emerging contributor to future global low-emission energy needs. If wave energy is to become a significant part of renewable energy portfolios, then wave energy converters (WECs) will need to be installed in large numbers in array configurations. The environmental effects of wave energy extraction to date has relied on physical (i.e., tank) and numerical modelling studies.\nIn this study, a network of in situ wave measurement devices were deployed around an array of three submerged point absorber WECs, operating intermittently, each with a nominal 240\u202fkW peak capacity. The study site was 3\u202fkm offshore (in approximately 24\u202fm water depth) and the field campaign was conducted over approximately one year, with a primary goal of studying \u2018down-wave\u2019 effects of the WECs. The observations were used to calibrate and validate a numerical spectral wave model which can represent frequency-dependent absorption by WECs within the model. For the purpose of a straightforward analysis, we focus on a period when only one WEC was operating. Measurements show a decrease in wave height between locations up-wave and down-wave of the WEC, for the period with only one operating WEC. The numerical model demonstrates that the observed wave height attenuation is due to WEC absorption and exceeds the natural variability of wave height at the site. Impacts on the wave field are particularly strong directly down-wave (40\u202fm) of the WEC with reduction of the wind-sea wave height up to 20%.","author":["Hemer, M.","McInnes, K.","Contardo, S.","Hoeke, R.","Symonds, G.","O\u0027Grady, J."],"organization":["Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)","University of Western Australia"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-31.957089000000","115.738981000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/627","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/large-scale-impact-offshore-wind-farm-structures-pelagic-primary-productivity-southern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10750-018-3653-5","title":"The large-scale impact of offshore wind farm structures on pelagic primary productivity in the southern North Sea","description":"The increasing demand for renewable energy is projected to result in a 40-fold increase in offshore wind electricity in the European Union by 2030. Despite a great number of local impact studies for selected marine populations, the regional ecosystem impacts of offshore wind farm (OWF) structures are not yet well assessed nor understood. Our study investigates whether the accumulation of epifauna, dominated by the filter feeder Mytilus edulis (blue mussel), on turbine structures affects pelagic primary productivity and ecosystem functioning in the southern North Sea. We estimate the anthropogenically increased potential distribution based on the current projections of turbine locations and reported patterns of M. edulis settlement. This distribution is integrated through the Modular Coupling System for Shelves and Coasts to state-of-the-art hydrodynamic and ecosystem models. Our simulations reveal non-negligible potential changes in regional annual primary productivity of up to 8% within the OWF area, and induced maximal increases of the same magnitude in daily productivity also far from the wind farms. Our setup and modular coupling are effective tools for system scale studies of other environmental changes arising from large-scale offshore wind farming such as ocean physics and distributions of pelagic top predators.","author":["Zhang, W.","Slavik, K.","Lemmen, C.","Kerimoglu, O.","Klingbeil, K.","Wirtz, K."],"organization":["Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon","Sorbonne University","Leibniz Institute for Baltic Sea Research, Warnem\u00fcnde (IOW)","Universit\u00e4t of Hamburg"],"originationDate":"2018-05-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.960236000000","2.899200000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/628","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/turbines-effects-water-renewal-within-marine-tidal-stream-energy-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544219318080","title":"Turbines\u0027 effects on water renewal within a marine tidal stream energy site","description":"As tidal stream energy sites contribute to a significant part of water transport in coastal shelf seas, turbines\u2019 implementation may lead to system-wide changes of the hydrodynamic circulation with potential effects on marine water quality. These aspects were investigated in north-western coastal waters of Brittany (France, western Europe) by simulating the decay of a tracer concentration within a control domain surrounding the tidal stream energy site of the Fromveur Strait. Simplified simulations were adopted to analyse the sensitivity of tracer distribution to stream energy extraction. While this marine area showed important renewal capacity with a 50% loss of tracer concentration in less than three days, residual values were still present after two months. This result exhibited that the concentration decay could not be calibrated by simple exponential functions. The renewal of marine waters appeared furthermore dependent on tracer release time during a tidal cycle. A full energy-extraction scenario was finally simulated suggesting weak effects of turbines on the renewal capacity with changes in residence times below 5%. The spatio-temporal Eulerian evolution of the concentration revealed, however, local trapping areas in close correlation with the Lagrangian residual circulation that vanished after two months.","author":["Thi\u00e9bot, J.","Guillou, N.","Chapalain, G."],"organization":["Normandie Universit\u00e9"],"originationDate":"2019-12-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.374920000000","-4.834834000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/629","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-oil-production-platforms-potential-sources-larvae-coastal-shelf-regions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/contentone\/umrsmas\/bullmar\/2019\/00000095\/00000004\/art00004#expand\/collapse","title":"Offshore oil production platforms as potential sources of larvae to coastal shelf regions off southern California","description":"A diverse assemblage of adult reef fishes and invertebrates occurs at offshore oil production platforms in the Southern California Bight (SCB). Coincident with the initiation of the decommissioning of six platforms in the SCB, the goal of this study was to examine how a platform\u0027s geographical location plays a role in its potential contribution of larval recruits to natural areas. Using a three-dimensional biophysical model, we quantified the potential connectivity of larvae, particularly relevant to reef fishes, from three offshore platforms to four coastal shelf regions where the majority of rocky settlement habitat occurs in the SCB. The regions cover the shelves of the mainland coast and islands and offshore banks in the southern SCB. The main findings indicate that (1) the potential for larval subsidies from platforms in the southern SCB to populations in the northern SCB are greater than the potential for larval subsidies from platforms in the northern SCB to the southern SCB; (2) there is greater seasonal variability of potential connectivity from platforms to the mainland shelf region of the northern SCB than to the mainland shelf region of the southern SCB or shelves around islands and banks; and (3) there is consistency across years in the relative magnitude of potential connectivity from the platforms to the four shelf regions. We conclude that a platform\u0027s function as a larval source should be considered an ecological criterion when evaluating whether a platform is to be converted to an artificial reef and implementing marine spatial planning.","author":["Love, M.","Nishimoto, M.","Simons, R."],"organization":["University of California Santa Barbara"],"originationDate":"2019-10-04","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.222639000000","-119.836401000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Ecosystem Processes","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nishimoto-2019-Larval.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/630","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biodiversity-characterisation-fouling-communities-their-hydrodynamic-consequences","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/8559237","title":"Biodiversity Characterisation of Fouling Communities and Their Hydrodynamic Consequences on Marine Renewable Energy Infrastructure in the UK","description":"Generating electricity from marine energy is a globally important industry and forms a vital part of several nations\u0027 objectives to decarbonise energy production. In the UK, the resource-rich waters around Scotland have led to world-leading developments of facilities and supporting infrastructure used in deploying and testing wave and tidal energy technologies. A major concern to industries working in the marine environment is biofouling on submerged structures, including energy converters and measurement instrumentation. In this study, marine energy devices, infrastructure, and instrumentation were surveyed to characterise biofouling organisms. Fouling communities varied between deployment habitats; key organisms were identified allowing recommendations for scheduling device maintenance and preventing spread of invasive species. A method to measure biofouling impact on hydrodynamic response is described and applied to data from a wave-monitoring buoy deployed at a test site in Scotland. Results are discussed in relation to measurement accuracy of resources for power generation. Further applications are suggested for future testing in other scenarios including habitats use for extracting tidal energy.","author":["Want, A.","Harris, R.","Porter, J."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2018-12-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.945056000000","-3.546920000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/631","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-low-frequency-electromagnetic-field-behavior-bioenergetics-polychaete-hediste","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113619302740","title":"Effect of low frequency electromagnetic field on the behavior and bioenergetics of the polychaete Hediste diversicolor","description":"The aim of the present study was to determine the effect of an electromagnetic field (EMF) of value typically recorded in the vicinity of submarine cables (50\u202fHz, 1\u202fmT) on the behavior and bioenergetics of the polychaete Hediste diversicolor. No avoidance or attraction behavior to EMF was shown, but the burrowing activity of H. diversicolor was enhanced in EMF treatment, indicating a stimulating effect on bioturbation potential. The polychaete maintained a positive energy balance and high amount (85% of assimilated energy) of energy available for individual production (scope for growth) after exposure to EMF. Food consumption and respiration rates were not affected but ammonia excretion rate was significantly reduced in EMF-exposed animals compared to the control conditions (geomagnetic field). The mechanisms behind this effect remain, however, unclear. This is the first study demonstrating the effects of environmentally realistic EMF value on the behavior and physiology of marine invertebrates, thus there is a need for more research.  Highlights:    Effects of 50\u202fHz 1\u202fmT electromagnetic field (EMF) on H. diversicolor were assessed.  H. diversicolor did not exhibit avoidance or attraction behavior to EMF.  Exposure to EMF increased the sediment reworking activity of H. diversicolor.  H. diversicolor maintained a positive energy balance after exposure to EMF.  EMF significantly decreased the ammonia excretion rate of H. diversicolor.","author":["Andrulewicz, E.","Otremba, Z.","Jakubowska, M.","Urban-Malinga, B."],"organization":["National Marine Fisheries Research Institute","Gdynia Maritime University"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.526413000000","18.511602000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/632","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/characterizing-monitoring-marine-nekton-puget-sounds-renewable-energy-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.3589043","title":"Characterizing and monitoring marine nekton at Puget Sound\u0027s renewable energy site","description":"Marine hydrokinetic energy sites have the potential to impact distributions, dynamics, and abundances of macroinvertebrates, fish, and marine mammals (i.e., nekton). Potential impacts include changes in aggregation, avoidance, and occurrences of strikes or impingements. Understanding potential impacts requires knowledge of species\u2010specific distributions over relevant spatial and temporal scales. Configurations and integration of technologies capable of providing images and data are not well\u2010established, and the application of monitoring technologies is complicated by extreme flows at marine hydrokinetic energy sites. An echosounder, multibeam sonar, and acoustic camera will be used to detect, categorize, and enumerate nekton at a proposed renewable energy site in northern Admiralty Inlet, Puget Sound, WA. This is the site selected by Snohomish Public Utility District for the deployment of two OpenHydro turbines. Data from stationary instrument deployments will be compared to data from a mobile acoustic and midwater trawling survey to determine how well each technology captures spatiotemporal variation in nekon density distributions. Results of the design, deployment, retrieval, and analysis of data from these three instrument classes will be used to formulate recommendations for instrument choice, configuration, and the characterization and monitoring of pelagic nekton at any renewable energy site.","author":["Polagye, B.","Thomson, J.","Parker-Stetter, S.","Horne, J.","Fresh, K.","Hanson, M."],"organization":["University of Washington","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)"],"originationDate":"2011-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.956029000000","-122.603318000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/633","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-acoustic-technologies-monitor-aquatic-organisms-renewable-energy-sites","sourceURL":"https:\/\/espis.boem.gov\/final%20reports\/5415.pdf","title":"Evaluating Acoustic Technologies to Monitor Aquatic Organisms at Renewable Energy Sites: Final Report","description":"Marine renewable energy (MRE) devices potentially impact dynamics of aquatic organisms including macroinvertebrates, fish, seabirds, and marine mammals. Understanding potential impacts of MRE technologies on biological communities requires knowledge of species-specific spatial and temporal density distributions. Acoustic technologies capable of providing images and data for baseline characterizations and operational monitoring are commercially available but configurations and system integration for MRE applications have not been established nor evaluated. Deployment, operation, and retrieval of autonomous acoustic instrument packages are also complicated by extreme water flows at MRE sites. At a proposed tidal energy site in Puget Sound, Washington, USA, an echosounder, multibeam sonar, acoustic camera, and an Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP) were deployed on bottom during May and June, 2011. To provide a spatial characterization of the biological community at the site, a vessel-mounted echosounder and pelagic trawl were used to map fish and macrozooplankton densities during day, dusk, and night surveys. Marine mammals and seabirds were identified and counted during surveys. The primary objective of the project was to compare sampling capabilities of surfaceand bottom-deployed acoustic instruments.  Our field work confirmed that autonomous instrument sampling is more constrained by power than by data storage; that direct sampling in high flow environments is a challenge; and that limited direct samples constrain acoustic target classification. A suite of metrics successfully characterized vertical distributions of aquatic organisms in the water column. Results showed that surface and bottom deployed echosounders detected horizontal and vertical density changes that were correlated with environmental covariates. Metric values from the acoustic camera and ADCP data were not as sensitive to changes in density.  Current acoustic technologies can be configured and used to characterize aquatic organism distributions at MRE sites. Integrated acoustic instrument systems that include target tracking and impact warning do not exist in autonomous or cabled configurations. Development of algorithms to translate temporal to spatial variance and to scale observed effects from pilot to commercial site domains is needed to complete the ability to monitor change and to detect impacts on biological communities for MRE site monitoring","author":["Parker-Stetter, S.","Horne, J.","Jacques, D.","Linder, H.","Nomura, J."],"organization":["US Department of the Interior (DOI)","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)","University of Washington","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2013-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.380234000000","-122.885440000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Horne-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/634","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/future-directions-conservation-research-petrels-shearwaters","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2019.00094\/full","title":"Future Directions in Conservation Research on Petrels and Shearwaters","description":"Shearwaters and petrels (hereafter petrels) are highly adapted seabirds that occur across all the world\u2019s oceans. Petrels are a threatened seabird group comprising 124 species. They have bet-hedging life histories typified by extended chick rearing periods, low fecundity, high adult survival, strong philopatry, monogamy and long-term mate fidelity and are thus vulnerable to change. Anthropogenic alterations on land and at sea have led to a poor conservation status of many petrels with 52 (42%) threatened species based on IUCN criteria and 65 (52%) suffering population declines. Some species are well-studied, even being used as bioindicators of ocean health, yet for others there are major knowledge gaps regarding their breeding grounds, migratory areas or other key aspects of their biology and ecology. We assembled 38 petrel conservation researchers to summarize information regarding the most important threats according to the IUCN Red List of threatened species to identify knowledge gaps that must be filled to improve conservation and management of petrels. We highlight research advances on the main threats for petrels (invasive species at breeding grounds, bycatch, overfishing, light pollution, climate change, and pollution). We propose an ambitious goal to reverse at least some of these six main threats, through active efforts such as restoring island habitats (e.g., invasive species removal, control and prevention), improving policies and regulations at global and regional levels, and engaging local communities in conservation efforts.","author":["Rodr\u00edguez, A.","Votier, S.","Montevecchi, W.","Melvin, E.","Sanz-Aguilar, A.","Louzao, M.","Rodr\u00edguez, B.","Arcos, J.","Ronconi, R.","Hedd, A.","Provencher, J.","Borrelle, S.","Hodum, P.","Spatz, D.","Taylor, R.","Bretagnolle, V.","Dias, M.","Holmes, N.","Raine, A.","Ram\u00edrez, F.","Bonnaud, E.","Cortes, V.","Descamps, S.","Friesen, V.","Genovart, M.","Humphries, G.","Le Corre, M.","Lebarbenchon, C.","Martin, R.","Pinet, P.","Pollet, I.","Ramos, R.","Russell, J.","Ryan, P.","Travers, M.","Wanless, R.","Woehler, E.","Chiaradia, A."],"organization":["Estacion Biologica de Donana","SEO\/BirdLife","University of La Rochelle (Universit\u00e9 de La Rochelle)","BirdLife International","Universidade de Lisboa","Island Conservation","AZTI","Acadia University","Kaua\u0027i Endangered Seabird Recovery Project","University of Barcelona","Canary Islands\u00b4 Ornithology and Natural History Group (GOHNIC)","Canadian Wildlife Service","Queens University","Trent University","Paris-Saclay University (Universit\u00e9 Paris-Saclay)","Society for Conservation Biology","Norwegian Polar Institute","Centre d\u0027Estudis Avan\u00e7ats de Blanes (CEAB) - Higher Council of Scientific Investigations (CSIC)","Environment and Climate Change Canada","Oikonos Ecosystem Knowledge","Black Bawks Data Science","Universit\u00e9 de La R\u00e9union","University of Washington","Memorial University of Newfoundland","LIFE+ Petrels","University of Auckland","University of Cape Town","Instituto Mediterr\u00e1neo de Estudios Avanzados: IMEDEA","University of Exeter","University of Tasmania","Monash University"],"originationDate":"2019-03-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:08:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rodriguez-et-al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/635","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/improving-visual-biodiversity-assessments-motile-fauna-turbid-aquatic-environments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/aslopubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/lom3.10331","title":"Improving visual biodiversity assessments of motile fauna in turbid aquatic environments","description":"Current knowledge of turbid coastlines relies heavily on extractive sampling methods with less destructive visual techniques limited primarily by underwater visibility. Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUV) is now a commonly used nonextractive sampling technique which involves the use of bait to attract motile fauna to the field of view of the camera, but its use is restricted to clear water environments. Here, we describe and test the addition of a clear liquid optical chamber (CLOC) to a BRUV system to improve underwater visibility when observing motile fauna in turbid waters. The CLOC method was trialed with respect to the ability of the system to identify taxa to species level in both controlled laboratory and field conditions across gradients of underwater visibility. This study found that the introduction of a CLOC to a conventional BRUV system significantly improved the ability to observe identifying features of four fish species in a controlled low\u2010visibility environment (p\u2009\u2264\u20090.001). The ability to identify taxa to species level in field conditions was also significantly increased with the addition of a CLOC (p\u2009\u2264\u20090.01). We conclude that the introduction of a CLOC to a conventional BRUV system is a reliable way of improving underwater visibility when assessing motile fauna allowing for a more consistent identification of taxa to species level. This system may be applied to both marine and freshwater aquatic environments.","author":["Jones, R.","Rees, S.","Griffin, R.","Unsworth, R."],"organization":["Swansea University","Ocean Ecology Ltd."],"originationDate":"2019-08-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.974292000000","-5.746996000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Marine Mammals","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Jones_et_al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/636","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/buried-alive-behavioural-response-mussels-modiolus-modiolus-mytilus-edulis-sudden","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0151471","title":"Buried Alive: The Behavioural Response of the Mussels, Modiolus modiolus and Mytilus edulis to Sudden Burial by Sediment","description":"Sedimentation in the sea occurs through natural processes, such as wave and tidal action, which can be exacerbated during storms and floods. Changes in terrestrial land use, marine aggregate extraction, dredging, drilling and mining are known to result in substantial sediment deposition. Research suggests that deposition will also occur due to the modern development of marine renewable energy. The response to individual burial under three depths of sediment, three sediment fractions and five burial durations was investigated in two mussel species, Modiolus modiolus and Mytilus edulis in specialist mesocosms. Both mussel species showed substantial mortality, which increased with duration of burial and burial by finer sediment fractions. M. modiolus was better able to survive short periods of burial than M. edulis, but at longer durations mortality was more pronounced. No mortality was observed in M. modiolus in burial durations of eight days or less but by 16 days of burial, over 50% cumulative mortality occurred. Under variable temperature regimes, M. edulis mortality increased from 20% at 8\u00b0C to over 60% at 14.5 and 20\u00b0C. Only M. edulis was able to emerge from burial, facilitated by increased byssus production, laid mostly on vertical surfaces but also on sediment particles. Emergence was higher from coarse sediment and shallow burials. Byssus production in M. edulis was not related to the condition index of the mussels. Results suggest that even marginal burial would result in mortality and be more pronounced in warm summer periods. Our results suggest that in the event of burial, adult M. modiolus would not be able to emerge from burial unless local hydrodynamics assist, whereas a small proportion of M. edulis may regain contact with the sediment water interface. The physiological stress resulting in mortality, contribution of local hydrodynamics to survival and other ecological pressures such as mussels existing in aggregations, are discussed.","author":["Wilson, B.","Burrows, M.","Hutchison, Z.","Last, K.","Hendrick, V."],"organization":["Cranfield University","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)"],"originationDate":"2016-03-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.451326000000","-5.441188000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hutchison-et-al-2016.PDF"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/637","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sediment-burial-intolerance-marine-macroinvertebrates","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0149114","title":"Sediment Burial Intolerance of Marine Macroinvertebrates","description":"The marine environment contains suspended particulate matter which originates from natural and anthropogenic sources. Settlement of this material can leave benthic organisms susceptible to smothering, especially if burial is sudden i.e. following storms or activities such as dredging. Their survival will depend on their tolerance to, and their ability to escape from burial. Here we present data from a multi-factorial experiment measuring burial responses incorporating duration, sediment fraction and depth. Six macroinvertebrates commonly found in sediment rich environments were selected for their commercial and\/or conservation importance. Assessments revealed that the brittle star (Ophiura ophiura), the queen scallop (Aequipecten opercularis) and the sea squirt (Ciona intestinalis) were all highly intolerant to burial whilst the green urchin (Psammichinus miliaris) and the anemone (Sagartiogeton laceratus), showed intermediate and low intolerance respectively, to burial. The least intolerant, with very high survival was the Ross worm (Sabellaria spinulosa). With the exception of C. intestinalis, increasing duration and depth of burial with finer sediment fractions resulted in increased mortality for all species assessed. For C. intestinalis depth of burial and sediment fraction were found to be inconsequential since there was complete mortality of all specimens buried for more than one day. When burial emergence was assessed O. ophiura emerged most frequently, followed by P. miliaris. The former emerged most frequently from the medium and fine sediments whereas P. miliaris emerged more frequently from coarse sediment. Both A. opercularis and S. laceratus showed similar emergence responses over time, with A. opercularis emerging more frequently under coarse sediments. The frequency of emergence of S. laceratus increased with progressively finer sediment and C. intestinalis did not emerge from burial irrespective of sediment fraction or depth. Finally, and perhaps unsurprisingly, the greatest ability to emerge from burial in all other species was from shallow (2 cm) burial. Although survival was consistently highly dependent on duration and depth of burial as expected, emergence behaviour was not as easily predictable thereby confounding predictions. We conclude that responses to burial are highly species specific and therefore tolerance generalisations are likely to be oversimplifications. These data may be used to inform environmental impact models that allow forecasting of the cumulative impacts of seabed disturbance and may provide mitigation measures for the sustainable use of the seabed.","author":["Hutchison, Z.","Last, K.","Hendrick, V."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)"],"originationDate":"2016-02-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.451326000000","-5.441188000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hendrick-et-al-2016.PDF"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/638","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/school-out-noisy-reefs-effect-boat-noise-predator-learning-survival-juvenile-coral","sourceURL":"https:\/\/royalsocietypublishing.org\/doi\/10.1098\/rspb.2018.0033","title":"School is out on noisy reefs: the effect of boat noise on predator learning and survival of juvenile coral reef fishes","description":"Noise produced by anthropogenic activities is increasing in many marine ecosystems. We investigated the effect of playback of boat noise on fish cognition. We focused on noise from small motorboats, since its occurrence can dominate soundscapes in coastal communities, the number of noise-producing vessels is increasing rapidly and their proximity to marine life has the potential to cause deleterious effects. Cognition\u2014or the ability of individuals to learn and remember information\u2014is crucial, given that most species rely on learning to achieve fitness-promoting tasks, such as finding food, choosing mates and recognizing predators. The caveat with cognition is its latent effect: the individual that fails to learn an important piece of information will live normally until the moment where it needs the information to make a fitness-related decision. Such latent effects can easily be overlooked by traditional risk assessment methods. Here, we conducted three experiments to assess the effect of boat noise playbacks on the ability of fish to learn to recognize predation threats, using a common, conserved learning paradigm. We found that fish that were trained to recognize a novel predator while being exposed to \u2018reef + boat noise\u2019 playbacks failed to subsequently respond to the predator, while their \u2018reef noise\u2019 counterparts responded appropriately. We repeated the training, giving the fish three opportunities to learn three common reef predators, and released the fish in the wild. Those trained in the presence of \u2018reef + boat noise\u2019 playbacks survived 40% less than the \u2018reef noise\u2019 controls over our 72 h monitoring period, a performance equal to that of predator-naive fish. Our last experiment indicated that these results were likely due to failed learning, as opposed to stress effects from the sound exposure. Neither playbacks nor real boat noise affected survival in the absence of predator training. Our results indicate that boat noise has the potential to cause latent effects on learning long after the stressor has gone.","author":["Simpson, S.","Nedelec, S.","Ferrari, M.","Chivers, D.","McCormick, M.","Meekan, M."],"organization":["James Cook University","Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS)","University of Exeter","University of Saskatchewan"],"originationDate":"2019-01-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["-14.666412000000","145.466661000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/639","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/boat-noise-affects-early-life-history-two-damselfishes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X19301547","title":"Boat noise affects the early life history of two damselfishes","description":"Anthropogenic noise can have a negative effect on the physiology and survival of marine fishes. Most research has focused on later life-stages, and few studies have investigated the effects of human-induced noise on embryogenesis. The current study investigated whether playback of motorboat noise affected the embryogenesis of the coral reef damselfishes, Amphiprion melanopus and Acanthochromis polyacanthus. Embryos reared under the playback of boat noise had faster heart rates compared to the ambient reef controls. The effects of noise on morphological development differed between species and the fundamental interrelationships between early life history characteristics changed dramatically under boat noise for Ac. polyacanthus. Noise treatments did not alter the survival rates of embryos under laboratory conditions. Although species specific, our findings suggest that anthropogenic noise causes physiological responses in fishes during embryogenesis and these changes have direct impacts on their development and these alterations may have carry-over effects to later life stages.","author":["McCormick, M.","Fakan, E."],"organization":["James Cook University"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/640","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/management-coastal-flooding-under-climate-change-through-wave-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-31318-0_6","title":"Management of Coastal Flooding Under Climate Change Through Wave Farms","description":"This chapter analyzes the effects of wave energy converter farms on storm-induced coastal flooding under three sea-level rise scenarios: present situation, optimistic projection and pessimistic projection. For that, the Delft3D-Wave and XBeach-G models were jointly apply to a gravel-dominated coast in southern Spain. The results show that the wave farm induces redutions, for the three scenarios, in breaking wave heights (about 10% and 25% under westerly and easterly storms, respectively) and total run-up values (8% and 10%, respectively). This leads to reduction in flooded cross-shore distances and dry beach areas. The decreases in flooded dry beach areas for the three sea-level rise scenarios are between 1400 and 3900 m2 under south-westerly storms, and between 2100 and 3400 m 2 under south-easterly storms. Therefore, wave farms are efficient management strategies to mitigate coastal flooding even under sea-level rise conditions.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["University of C\u00f3rdoba","Plymouth University","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-09-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.864589000000","-3.922340000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/641","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-converter-configuration-coastal-erosion-mitigation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-31318-0_3","title":"Wave Energy Converter Configuration for Coastal Erosion Mitigation","description":"This chapter analyses the influence of the wave energy converter geometry, in particular the wedge angle of WaveCat devices, on the performance of wave farms as coastal protection elements against erosion. Laboratory experiments were conducted for two angles between hulls under low-, mid- and high-energy conditions to obtain the reflection and diffraction coefficients. These values were used as input for the joint application of a wave propagation model, a longshore sediment transport formulation and the one-line model to a study site in southern Spain. The shoreline evolution and dry beach area availability for wave farms with by both devices were assessed. The results indicate that WaveCat devices with a wedge angle of 60\u00ba provide more protection than those with 30\u00b0 for long wave periods and less protection for short periods. Thus, to optimize the efficiency of wave farms for coastal defence, the geometry of the wave energy converters should be adapted dynamically to the incoming wave condition.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["University of C\u00f3rdoba","University of Plymouth","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-09-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2025-01-14 09:17:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/642","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/optimization-wave-farm-location-layout-coastal-protection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-31318-0_2","title":"Optimization of Wave Farm Location and Layout for Coastal Protection","description":"In this chapter, a new methodology to manage coastal protection by means of wave farms is proposed. Artificial intelligence tools, more specifically artificial neural networks (ANNs), were used to assess dry beach surface differences between the no wave farm situation and different wave farm project scenarios. A number of alongshore locations and layouts\u2014represented as the number of rows and the spacing between devices\u2014formed the wave farm scenarios and the influence of the wave climate\u2014significant wave height and mean wave direction\u2014was also taken into account. The selected study site was Playa Granada (southern Iberian Peninsula), a beach with important erosion problems. The datasets used for training and testing the ANN were obtained by means of a suite of numerical models including a third generation wave propagation model, a sediment transport formulation and a shoreline response equation. In order to obtain the ANN which provides the best fit to the data, a comparative study involving more than forty different architectures formed by one and two hidden layers and trained by means of two training algorithm was carried out. The [5-10-1] architecture obtained the best results with a correlation coefficient and RMSE of 0.9489 and 4.22 m22, respectively. Once the best architecture was found, the ANN was applied to the study site in order to obtain the optimum location and layout for a wave farm project and the results indicate that dry beach surface could increase up to 5400.18 m22 per year. These results show that ANNs can be useful for managers to optimize the design of wave farms for coastal protection.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["University of C\u00f3rdoba","Plymouth University","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-09-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.724908900000","-3.532989000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/643","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-energy-coastal-protection-novel-strategy-coastal-management-under-climate-change","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-030-31318-0","title":"Ocean Energy and Coastal Protection A Novel Strategy for Coastal Management Under Climate Change","description":"This book presents the innovative concept of the dual function of wave farms as both renewable energy generators and coastal protection elements against erosion and flooding.\n\nDeveloping renewable energy is one of the most pressing targets for society in the coming decades due to the finite nature of fossil fuels, their high costs, and the environmental impacts of their exploration and use, including climate change and the subsequent sea-level rise. Wave energy is one of the most promising renewable energy sources, thanks to its huge potential and low impact on the environment. As such, this book discusses the development and application of artificial intelligence to optimise wave farm location and layout, assesses the influence of the wave energy converter geometry on coastal protection against erosion and flooding, and analyses how the performance of wave farms as coastal defence elements is affected by climate change and sea level rise. The concepts, methods and conclusions presented are helpful to students, researchers, academics, engineers, designers, stakeholders and managers around the globe interested in wave energy, coastal engineering, and coastal management.\n\nOptimization of Wave Farm Location and Layout for Coastal Protection\nWave Energy Converter Configuration for Coastal Erosion Mitigation\nWave Energy Converter Configuration for Coastal Flooding Mitigation\nManagement of Coastal Erosion Under Climate Change Through Wave Farms\nManagement of Coastal Flooding Under Climate Change Through Wave Farms","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["University of C\u00f3rdoba","University of Plymouth","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2020-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.724908900000","-3.532989000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/644","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sustainable-hydropower-using-ecosystem-based-adaptation-increase-local-adaptation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98681-4_10","title":"Sustainable Hydropower: Using Ecosystem-based Adaptation to Increase Local Adaptation Capacity in Brazil","description":"Recent observed changes in climate patterns in Brazil has increased the importance of ecosystem-based adaptation (EbA) in order to reduce the effects of drought and floods. The energy (hydropower) sector is specially starting to be affected by those changes. Changing rainfall patterns, rising temperature, droughts and extreme weather events may affect hydroelectricity generation, causing damages to the infrastructure or disruptions in service. EbA is mentioned in the Brazilian NDC, highlighting the need to increase national capacity in water security (National Water Security Plan), conservation and sustainable use of biodiversity (NBSAP). In addition, the Energy Sector Strategy of the NAP mentions the environmental issues, especially regarding the protection and recovery of natural resources (fauna, flora and physical environment). This paper discusses how the hydropower generation in Brazil can shift to a sustainable hydropower pattern, capable of dealing with climate change issues and, additionally, contributing to increase local adaptation capacity using an ecosystem approach, as accorded on Paris Agreement. A set of EbA measures are presented as opportunities to reduce the climate vulnerability and\/or increase the resilience of local ecosystems and of the communities depending on them, where hydropower projects are installed or are being planned.","author":["Garcia, K.","Mollica, A.","Ferreira de Matos, D.","Leal da Paz, L."],"organization":["Eletrobras Group"],"originationDate":"2018-09-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["-8.750716600000","-54.822246900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/645","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biodiversity-issues-should-be-better-taken-account-energy-transition","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98681-4_3","title":"Biodiversity Issues Should Be Better Taken into Account in the Energy Transition","description":"Climate and biodiversity issues cannot be considered one without the other because of the multiple interactions and interdependencies between them. Solutions for climate mitigation relying on the evolution of the energy sector should take this intertwining into account. The French Foundation for Research on Biodiversity (FRB) and OR\u00c9E, a multi-stakeholder NGO advocating the sharing of good environmental practices among stakeholders, explored potential ways to approach the complexity of climate, energy and biodiversity issues in order to develop sustainable solutions. They have been studying the links and interactions between renewable energy and biodiversity through, among others, a conference organized by FRB and a book published by OR\u00c9E. In both the conference and the book, energy producers and suppliers discussed their level of awareness on the issue and presented measures taken to avoid, reduce or offset biodiversity impacts when installing renewable energy infrastructures. This experience sharing highlighted several ways forward in order to reconcile biodiversity protection with the shift towards sustainable energy. Thus, the need to better take biodiversity into account in the energy transition was voiced both by businesses and the research community. This paper presents the first outcomes of the reflections led at the national level by multiple stakeholders, in order to generate further ideas for research to support the design and implementation of integrated climate change and biodiversity policies.","author":["Hallosserie, A.","Soubelet, H.","Leriche, H.","Savin, P.","Silvain, J."],"organization":["French Foundation for Biodiversity Research","Institut de recherche pour le d\u00e9veloppement"],"originationDate":"2018-08-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/646","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/love-me-love-me-not-perceptions-links-between-energy-sector-biodiversity-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618309769","title":"Love me, love me not: Perceptions on the links between the energy sector and biodiversity conservation","description":"The European Union (EU) performed a comprehensive evaluation of nature conservation directives (the so-called \u201cFitness check\u201d), including public consultations which provided an opportunity to characterize the perspectives of different stakeholders on the links between biodiversity conservation and energy policy. Through content analysis, all the information related to the energy sector produced during the Fitness check was screened. The overall perception was that, compared to other policies, the EU energy policy generally did not support the objectives of the Nature Directives, with identified threats for biodiversity coming from specific activities and policy initiatives. Respondents from the energy sector recognized that the implementation of the Directives brought some improvements (e.g. improved planning of grid developments, collaboration between the energy sector and NGOs) but a number of issues requiring improvement were identified, including (a) lack of coherence with energy policies, (b) need for cost-effective implementation, (c) need for more scientific knowledge and capacity building, and (d) need for clarifications over impact evaluation and compensatory measures. As a follow up of the Fitness check, the European Commission produced an Action Plan. From my perspective, this document should be closely scrutinized by the energy sector, as it provides opportunities to engage in different activities aiming towards a better use of scientific knowledge in decision-making, clarification of rules for procedures in the scope of impact assessment, effective mitigation of impacts on biodiversity, contribution to biodiversity gains, and higher social acceptance of the sector.","author":["Moreira, F."],"organization":["Universidade de Porto","Universidade de Lisboa"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/647","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-use-sea-wide-array-opportunities-site-specific-cases-across-europe","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0215010","title":"Multi-use of the sea: A wide array of opportunities from site-specific cases across Europe","description":"The concept of multi-use of the sea has gained popularity in recent years as a result of ocean space (coastal areas and regions with relatively small sea space in particular) becoming increasingly crowded due to the development of the maritime economy. Competing claims for space can be a source of conflict, however this may also lead to mutual benefits for different users when sustainable combinations are sought. Despite increasing European-wide efforts, on-the-ground knowledge and practice of multi-use are still limited. Therefore, with the aim of investigating opportunities for multi-use development in the European seas, 10 case studies were selected, involving different site-specific contexts. This study analyses the characteristics and development potential for ocean multi-use, integrating results from desk analysis and stakeholder perceptions from different sectors in each of the case study locations. Similarities and differences between various combinations of sea uses are also identified. The results show a high heterogeneity of multi-use opportunities between case studies, with a range of combinations identified. The investigated combinations of maritime uses share an overall balance between factors promoting (drivers) and hindering (barriers) multi-use development. Based on stakeholder opinions, expected benefits (added values) of multi-use implementation outweigh potential negative impacts. Management actions are also proposed to further exploit multi-use potential at a local, regional (sub-national) and national levels.","author":["Kafas, A.","Sangiuliano, S.","Schupp, M.","Bocci, M.","Schultz-Zehden, A.","Onyango, V.","Ansong, J.","Ramieri, E.","Verg\u00edlio, M.","Sarretta, A.","Buchanan, B.","Ca\u00f1a-Varona, M.","Papaioannou, E.","Vassilopoulou, V."],"organization":["Thetis SpA","Marine Scotland Science","National Research Council of Italy (CNR)","University of Azores","University of Dundee","SUBMARINER Network for Blue Growth EEIG","Hellenic Centre for Marine Research (HCMR)"],"originationDate":"2019-04-11","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/648","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mapping-wind-energy-potential-sweden-sociotechnical-wind-atlas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.hindawi.com\/journals\/jre\/2018\/1650794\/abs\/","title":"Mapping the Wind Energy Potential of Sweden: A Sociotechnical Wind Atlas","description":"The installation of onshore wind farms has increased in the past decade all over Sweden, and as a result, more wind projects are facing challenges of, for instance, social opposition and lack of space, which potentially complicate resource assessments. As a response to the current challenges in the Swedish wind industry, this study examines and develops a strategic map of potential areas for the construction of new farms in Sweden. The analyses used to prepare the map are performed using a holistic research strategy that focuses on everything from social to technical challenges. The map is based on an extensive data collection consisting of a comprehensive wind dataset mixed with the outcome of large-scale qualitative studies that include five dominant stakeholder groups in the Swedish wind industry and detailed information on restrictive areas. Consequently, this research presents a resource map, which is intended to inspire all stakeholders in the Swedish wind industry to further develop the successful case of wind power in Sweden. Furthermore, the current research aims to update ongoing debates in the wind energy literature, and finally, it introduces a tool that can be used in all phases of a large-scale energy strategy that involves wind power.","author":["Enevoldsen, P.","Permien, F."],"organization":["Aarhus University","Siemens Gamesa"],"originationDate":"2018-07-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["62.498226400000","14.283287500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/649","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecosystem-approach-studying-impact-offshore-wind-farms-french-case-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/article\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsy125\/5096674\/","title":"An ecosystem approach for studying the impact of offshore wind farms: a French case study","description":"The French government is planning the construction of offshore wind farms (OWF) in the next decade (around 2900\u2009MW). Following the European Environmental Impact Assessment Directive 85\/337\/EEC, several studies have been undertaken to identify the environmental conditions and ecosystem functioning at selected sites prior to OWF construction. However, these studies are generally focused on the conservation of some species and there is no holistic approach for analysing the effects arising from OWF construction and operation. The objective of this article is to promote a sampling strategy to collect data on the different ecosystem compartments of the future Dieppe-Le Tr\u00e9port (DLT) wind farm site, adopting an ecosystem approach, which could be applied to other OWFs for the implementation of a trophic network analysis. For that purpose, an Ecopath model is used here to derive indices from Ecological Network Analysis (ENA) to investigate the ecosystem structure and functioning. The results show that the ecosystem is most likely detritus-based, associated with a biomass dominated by bivalves, which could act as a dead end for a classic trophic food web since their consumption by top predators is low in comparison to their biomass. The systemic approach developed for DLT OWF site should be applied for other French and European installations of Offshore Wind Farm.","author":["Dauvin, J.","Raoux, A.","Pezy, J."],"organization":["Normandie Universit\u00e9"],"originationDate":"2018-09-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.070750000000","1.180152000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/650","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stakeholder-perspectives-value-marine-spatial-planning-towards-advancing-offshore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/08920753.2019.1596675","title":"Stakeholder Perspectives on the Value of Marine Spatial Planning Towards Advancing Offshore Wind in the U.S.","description":"The United States contributes only 0.2% of the 18,814\u2009MW of global installed offshore wind capacity. Lack of development has been attributed in part to a cumbersome regulatory process that includes the evaluation of environmental impacts. Assessments are based on biological, social, and technical data that are often incomplete. Marine spatial planning (MSP) may help fill data gaps. We conducted semi-structured interviews with key informants to understand (1) whether a lack of biological data impedes offshore wind environmental assessments, (2) whether MSP could mitigate these impediments, and (3) whether MSP could advance offshore wind development in the U.S. in other ways. Most informants stated that a lack of biological data in offshore wind environmental assessments was problematic due to incomplete data, uncertainty of data, and mismatched scales. Data issues may be mitigated by creation of data products and increased communication, outcomes of MSP that may benefit the regulatory process by increasing data availability, resolving conflicts among users, and providing a common operating picture. Challenges remain in integrating MSP into the processes of siting and permitting offshore wind, but it provides a strategic framework for the systematic identification, collection, collation, analyses, application, and management of data in the offshore wind environmental regulatory process.","author":["Jordaan, A.","Ryan, K.","Danylchuk, A.","Bates, A.","Gopnik, M."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts","American University"],"originationDate":"2019-04-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.924038400000","-77.045263600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/651","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-sound-wave-tidal-test-sites-improving-knowledge-acoustic-impact-marine","sourceURL":"","title":"Underwater sound on wave \u0026 tidal test sites: improving knowledge of acoustic impact of Marine Energy Convertors","description":"The effects of anthropogenic underwater noise on different marine species is open to study and debate, as it is a source for tension between and within sea users\u2019 (e.g. fishermen, shipping companies, energy companies, etc.), scientists and politicians. This paper aims at identifying and circumventing environmental constrains for better characterising sound emissions from various marine energy converter (MEC) types deployed on both wave and tidal sea-trial test sites. This study benefits from the collaborations of the scientific operators of marine energy sites from Spain (AZTI) and France (Energie de la Lune). Several underwater acoustic measurement campaigns were conducted on Biscay Marine Energy Platform (BIMEP) and SEENEOH tests sites and Mutriku Oscillating Water Column (OWC) wave power plant. The methodology used for data acquisition relies on both drifting and bottom moored hydrophones thus enabling to characterising both ambient operating noises and comparing two different underwater acoustic equipment. Long and time expensive data post-processing allowed for identifying and circumventing different kind of sound emissions from different origins: anthropogenic sound, siterelated noises, and ambient noise. Impulsive and continuous sounds were assessed following criteria compliant with the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD). Results presented here allow for identifying difficulties in operating with different instrumentation and monitoring methodologies in these harsh environments. Analysis of acoustic samples during MEC operation allowed for identifying impulsive noise sources mainly related with mooring lines of MECs. Collection of device-generated noise during various operating states and seasons, for the purpose of evaluating potential noise impacts on marine organisms of concern is needed for a better understanding and characterization of these potential impacts.","author":["Bald, J.","Uriarte, A.","Giry, C."],"organization":["AZTI"],"originationDate":"2018-06-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.312643000000","-2.377133000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:29:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ICOE-cyril-giry_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/652","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/noise-pollution-limits-metal-bioaccumulation-growth-rate-filter-feeder-pacific-oyster","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0194174","title":"Noise pollution limits metal bioaccumulation and growth rate in a filter feeder, the Pacific oyster Magallana gigas","description":"Shipping has increased dramatically in recent decades and oysters can hear them. We studied the interaction between noise pollution and trace metal contamination in the oyster Magallana gigas. Four oyster-groups were studied during a 14-day exposure period. Two were exposed to cadmium in the presence of cargo ship-noise ([Cd++]w \u2248 0.5 \u03bcg\u2219L-1; maximum sound pressure level 150 dBrms re 1 \u03bcPa), and 2 were exposed only to cadmium. The Cd concentration in the gills ([Cd]g) and the digestive gland ([Cd]dg), the valve closure duration, number of valve closures and circadian distribution of opening and closure, the daily shell growth-rate and the expression of 19 genes in the gills were studied. Oysters exposed to Cd in the presence of cargo ship-noise accumulated 2.5 times less Cd in their gills than did the controls without ship noise and their growth rate was 2.6 times slower. In the presence of ship noise, oysters were closed more during the daytime, and their daily valve activity was reduced. Changes in gene activity in the gills were observed in 7 genes when the Cd was associated with the ship noise. In the absence of ship noise, a change in expression was measured in 4 genes. We conclude that chronic exposure to cargo ship noise has a depressant effect on the activity in oysters, including on the volume of the water flowing over their gills (Vw). In turn, a decrease in the Vw and valve-opening duration limited metal exposure and uptake by the gills but also limited food uptake. This latter conclusion would explain the slowing observed in the fat metabolism and growth rate. Thus, we propose that cargo ship noise exposure could protect against metal bioaccumulation and affect the growth rate. This latter conclusion points towards a potential risk in terms of ecosystem productivity.","author":["Charifi, M.","Miserazzi, A.","Sow, M.","Perrigault, M.","Gonzalez, P.","Ciret, P.","Benomar, S.","Massabuau, J."],"organization":["University of Bordeaux"],"originationDate":"2018-04-04","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Charifi-2018-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/653","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dna-ecological-performance-effects-anthropogenic-noise-reef-building-mussel","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/pubmed\/31271981","title":"From DNA to ecological performance: Effects of anthropogenic noise on a reef-building mussel","description":"Responses of marine invertebrates to anthropogenic noise are insufficiently known, impeding our understanding of ecosystemic impacts of noise and the development of mitigation strategies. We show that the blue mussel, Mytilus edulis, is negatively affected by ship-noise playbacks across different levels of biological organization. We take a novel mechanistic multi-method approach testing and employing established ecotoxicological techniques (i.e. Comet Assay and oxidative stress tests) in combination with behavioral and physiological biomarkers. We evidence, for the first time in marine species, noise-induced changes in DNA integrity (six-fold higher DNA single strand-breaks in haemocytes and gill epithelial cells) and oxidative stress (68% increased TBARS in gill cells). We further identify physiological and behavioral changes (12% reduced oxygen consumption, 60% increase in valve gape, 84% reduced filtration rate) in noise-exposed mussels. By employing established ecotoxicological techniques we highlight impacts not only on the organismal level, but also on ecological performance. When investigating species that produce little visually obvious responses to anthropogenic noise, the above mentioned endpoints are key to revealing sublethal effects of noise and thus enable a better understanding of how this emerging, but often overlooked stressor, affects animals without complex behaviors. Our integrated approach to noise research can be used as a model for other invertebrate species and faunal groups, and inform the development of effective methods for assessing and monitoring noise impacts. Given the observed negative effects, noise should be considered a potential confounding factor in studies involving other stressors.","author":["Wale, M.","Briers, R.","Hartl, M.","Bryson, D.","Diele, K."],"organization":["Edinburgh Napier University","Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/654","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/anthropogenic-noise-increases-fish-mortality-predation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/ncomms10544","title":"Anthropogenic noise increases fish mortality by predation","description":"Noise-generating human activities affect hearing, communication and movement in terrestrial and aquatic animals, but direct evidence for impacts on survival is rare. We examined effects of motorboat noise on post-settlement survival and physiology of a prey fish species and its performance when exposed to predators. Both playback of motorboat noise and direct disturbance by motorboats elevated metabolic rate in Ambon damselfish (Pomacentrus amboinensis), which when stressed by motorboat noise responded less often and less rapidly to simulated predatory strikes. Prey were captured more readily by their natural predator (dusky dottyback, Pseudochromis fuscus) during exposure to motorboat noise compared with ambient conditions, and more than twice as many prey were consumed by the predator in field experiments when motorboats were passing. Our study suggests that a common source of noise in the marine environment has the potential to impact fish demography, highlighting the need to include anthropogenic noise in management plans.","author":["Radford, A.","Simpson, S.","Nedelec, S.","Ferrari, M.","Chivers, D.","McCormick, M.","Meekan, M."],"organization":["University of Exeter","University of Bristol","University of Saskatchewan","James Cook University","Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS)"],"originationDate":"2016-02-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["-14.678692000000","145.448258000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Simpson-2016-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/655","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/anthropogenic-noise-playback-impairs-embryonic-development-increases-mortality-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/srep05891","title":"Anthropogenic noise playback impairs embryonic development and increases mortality in a marine invertebrate","description":"Human activities can create noise pollution and there is increasing international concern about how this may impact wildlife. There is evidence that anthropogenic noise may have detrimental effects on behaviour and physiology in many species but there are few examples of experiments showing how fitness may be directly affected. Here we use a split-brood, counterbalanced, field experiment to investigate the effect of repeated boat-noise playback during early life on the development and survival of a marine invertebrate, the sea hare Stylocheilus striatus at Moorea Island (French Polynesia). We found that exposure to boat-noise playback, compared to ambient-noise playback, reduced successful development of embryos by 21% and additionally increased mortality of recently hatched larvae by 22%. Our work, on an understudied but ecologically and socio-economically important taxon, demonstrates that anthropogenic noise can affect individual fitness. Fitness costs early in life have a fundamental influence on population dynamics and resilience, with potential implications for community structure and function.","author":["Radford, A.","Simpson, S.","Mills, S.","Nedelec, S.","Nedelec, B.","Lecchini, D."],"organization":["University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2014-07-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nedelec-2014-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/656","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-boat-noise-behaviour-bluefin-tuna-thunnus-thynnus-mediterranean-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v331\/p243-253\/","title":"Effect of boat noise on the behaviour of bluefin tuna Thunnus thynnus in the Mediterranean Sea","description":"The effect of boat noise on the behaviour of bluefin tuna Thunnus thynnus was investigated in the Egadi Islands, Sicily, during spring 2005 using a fixed tuna trap set near shipping routes. Tuna behaviour was observed when exposed to both natural ambient sound and sound generated by hydrofoil passenger ferries, small boats and large car ferries. Acoustical and behavioural analyses were conducted with and without extraneous sound to define a list of behavioural categories. Each vessel produced different engine sounds with regard to their composition and bandwidth, and all were distinctly different from ambient sound levels. In the absence of boat noise, tuna assumed a concentrated coordinated school structure with unidirectional swimming and without a precise shape. When a car ferry approached, tuna changed swimming direction and increased their vertical movement toward surface or bottom; the school exhibited an unconcentrated structure and uncoordinated swimming behaviour. Hydrofoils appeared to elicit a similar response, but for shorter periods. Agonistic behaviour was more evident when exposed to sounds from outboard motors of small boats. This study showed that local noise pollution generated by boats produced behavioural deviations in tuna schools. Schooling enhances tuna homing accuracy during their spawning migration, and an alteration in schooling behaviour can affect the accuracy of their migration to spawning and feeding grounds.","author":["Mazzola, S.","Buscaino, G.","Dean, J.","Sar\u00e0, G.","D\u0027Amato, D.","Oliveri, A.","Genovese, S.","Ferro, S.","Buffa, G.","Lo Martire, M."],"organization":["University of Turin","University of South Carolina"],"originationDate":"2007-02-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.985563000000","12.205566000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/657","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/anthropogenic-natural-sources-ambient-noise-ocean","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v395\/p5-20\/","title":"Anthropogenic and natural sources of ambient noise in the ocean","description":"Ocean ambient noise results from both anthropogenic and natural sources. Different noise sources are dominant in each of 3 frequency bands: low (10 to 500 Hz), medium (500 Hz to 25 kHz) and high (\u003E25 kHz). The low-frequency band is dominated by anthropogenic sources: primarily, commercial shipping and, secondarily, seismic exploration. Shipping and seismic sources contribute to ambient noise across ocean basins, since low-frequency sound experiences little attenuation, allowing for long-range propagation. Over the past few decades the shipping contribution to ambient noise has increased by as much as 12 dB, coincident with a significant increase in the number and size of vessels comprising the world\u2019s commercial shipping fleet. During this time, oil exploration and construction activities along continental margins have moved into deeper water, and the long-range propagation of seismic signals has increased. Medium frequency sound cannot propagate over long ranges, owing to greater attenuation, and only local or regional (10s of km distant) sound sources contribute to the ambient noise field. Ambient noise in the mid-frequency band is primarily due to sea-surface agitation: breaking waves, spray, bubble formation and collapse, and rainfall. Various sonars (e.g. military and mapping), as well as small vessels, contribute anthropogenic noise at mid-frequencies. At high frequencies, acoustic attenuation becomes extreme so that all noise sources are confined to an area close to the receiver. Thermal noise, the result of Brownian motion of water molecules near the hydrophone, is the dominant noise source above about 60 kHz.","author":["Hildebrand, J."],"organization":["Scripps Institution of Oceanography"],"originationDate":"2009-12-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/HildebrandMEPS2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/658","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/brief-review-anthropogenic-sound-oceans","sourceURL":"https:\/\/escholarship.org\/uc\/item\/5cj6s4r9","title":"A Brief Review of Anthropogenic Sound in the Oceans","description":"Sound in the oceans is generated by a variety of natural sources, such as breaking waves, rain, and marine animals, as well as a variety of human-produced sources, such as ships, sonars and seismic signals. This overview will begin with a quick review of some basic properties of sound waves with particular reference to differences between the behaviours of these waves underwater versus in air. A basic understanding of the physics of underwater sound is critical to understanding how marine animal acoustic signals have evolved relative to their different functions and how changes in the marine acoustic environment due to increasing anthropogenic sound in the oceans may impact these species. We will then review common sources of anthropogenic sound in the oceans. The frequency contributions of three major sources of underwater anthropogenic sound and their relative intensities will be discussed: naval exercises, seismic surveys and commercial shipping. Finally, a case study examining relative inputs to a regional noise budget, that of the Gerry E. Studds Stellwagen Bank National Marine Sanctuary, will be presented to introduce the audience to methodologies for characterizing and managing sound on an ecosystem level.","author":["Wright, A.","Studds, G."],"organization":["National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)"],"originationDate":"2007-12-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Studds-2007-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/659","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-ocean-noise-pollution-fish-invertebrates","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.oceancare.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2022\/05\/Underwater-Noise-Pollution_Impact-on-fish-and-invertebrates_Report_OceanCare_EN_36p_2018.pdf","title":"The Impact of Ocean Noise Pollution on Fish and Invertebrates","description":"Most fish and invertebrates use sound for vital life functions. This review of 115 primary studies encompasses various human-produced underwater noise sources, 66 species of fish and 36 species of invertebrates. Noise impacts on development include body malformations, higher egg or immature mortality, developmental delays, delays in metamorphosing and settling, and slower growth rates. Zooplankton suffered high mortality in the presence of noise. Anatomical impacts from noise involve massive internal injuries, cellular damage to statocysts and neurons, causing disorientation and even death, and hearing loss. Damage to hearing structures can worsen over time even after the noise has ceased, sometimes becoming most pronounced after 96 hrs. post-noise exposure. Even temporary hearing loss can last months. Stress impacts from noise are not uncommon, including higher levels of stress hormones, greater metabolic rate, oxygen uptake, cardiac output, parasites, irritation, distress, and mortality rate, sometimes due to disease and cannibalism; and worse body condition, lower growth, weight, food consumption, immune response, and reproductive rates. DNA integrity was also compromised, as was overall physiology. Behaviorally, animals showed alarm responses, increased aggression, hiding, and flight reactions; and decreased anti-predator defense, nest digging, nest care, courtship calls, spawning, egg clutches, and feeding. Noise caused more distraction, producing more food-handling errors, decreased foraging efficiency, greater vulnerability to predation, and less feeding. Schooling became uncoordinated, unaggregated, and unstructured due to noise. Masking reduced communication distance and could cause misleading information to be relayed. Some commercial catches dropped by up to 80% due to noise, with larger fish leaving the area. Bycatch rates also could increase, while abundance generally decreased with noise. Ecological services performed by invertebrates such as water filtration, mixing sediment layers, and bioirrigation, which are key to nutrient cycling on the seabed, were negatively affected by noise. Once the population biology and ecology are impacted, it is clear fisheries and even food security for humans are also affected. Turtles, sharks, and rays were especially underrepresented in noise impact studies. Research on an individual\u2019s ability to survive and reproduce, and ultimately on population viability and ecosystem community function, is most vital. More long-term, realistic field studies also considering cumulative and synergistic effects, along with stress indicators, are needed.","author":["Weilgart, L."],"organization":["OceanCare","Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Weilgart_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/660","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-potential-impacts-tidal-power-schemes-estuarine-waterbirds","sourceURL":"","title":"Evaluating the potential impacts of tidal power schemes on estuarine waterbirds","description":"As a means of reducing dependence on fossil fuels and thereby combating global climate change, tidal power offers a potentially valuable renewable energy source. The UK coastline has some of the highest tidal ranges in the world and proposals for tidal power schemes have thus been put forward for several estuaries where the tidal range is sufficiently large for energy to be harnessed, including the Severn, Mersey, Dee and Solway.  Although the energy supply at such sites is reliable and plentiful, the development of any tidal power scheme would have great implications for the ornithological interest of the site in question. The UK holds a significant proportion of Europe\u2019s estuarine resource and its estuaries and other wetlands are of considerable international importance for migrant and wintering waterbirds. A peak of 2 907 731 waterbirds, for example, was counted by the Wetland Bird Survey (WeBS) in the UK in winter 2008\/09 (Calbrade et al. 2010). Many of these wetland sites are designated as Special Protection Areas (SPAs; under the EC \u2018Birds Directive\u2019 2009\/147\/EC) as part of the Natura 2000 network, or as Wetlands of International Importance under the Ramsar Convention.  Here we describe the key issues that need to be evaluated as part of any assessment of the effects of a tidal power scheme on birds, as considered in the recent Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) undertaken as part of the Severn Tidal Power Feasibility Study. The Severn Estuary is designated as both an SPA \u2013 with 18 spring\/autumn passage or over-wintering waterbird species listed as features \u2013 and a Ramsar site, and encompasses seven Sites of Special Scientific Interest (Burton et al. 2010). A mean annual peak of 72 909 waterbirds was recorded there by WeBS counts over the period 2004\/05\u20132008\/09 (Calbrade et al. 2010). Five different tidal power options \u2013 three barrage schemes and two lagoon schemes \u2013 have been considered by the feasibility study and SEA (Fig. 1)","author":["Thaxter, C.","Clark, N.","Burton, N.","Wright, L.","Cook, A.","Austin, G."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Burtonetal-2010-ClimateChangeandBirds.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/661","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/possible-impact-wind-power-generators-flying-birds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bto.org\/sites\/default\/files\/shared_documents\/publications\/research-reports\/1982\/rr006.pdf","title":"The possible impact of wind power generators on flying birds","description":"Current research on wind powered generators and the recent announcement that a single machine, with 60m rotors and producing 3MW, is to be built on Orkney have raised the possibility of risk to birds through impact. Plans have been produced for machines with rotors up to 100m (diameter) operating from towers 125m high. Production installations of such machines are likely to take the form of arrays, in areas subject to windy conditions, set across the direction from which prevailing wind blows. This document sets out to examine the liklihood of direct loss to bird life through impact with the moving rotors of such machines and possible means of avoiding such losses. It does not consider the effect of the structures, their construction or maintenance on the composition of local bird communities.\n\nFour sections follow dealing with particular aspects of the problem.\nThe probability of collision. This examines the liklihood of a bird being struck by a moving rotor in the absence of any attraction to or avoidance of the machine being shown by the bird.\nLocal birds at risk. This section discusses the species that might be at risk, possible behaviour which may affect the risk to which they are exposed and steps which might be taken to reduce the risk.\u00a0\nMigrant birds at risk. The height at which migrants fly and the chances of impact, particularly at night, are examined together with the bird\u0027s behaviour and possibilities of reducing risk.\u00a0\nSummary.","author":["Mead, C."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)"],"originationDate":"1982-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mead-1982-Birds.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/662","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-effects-birds-arising-onshore-infrastructure-proposed-greater-gabbard","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bto.org\/our-science\/publications\/research-reports\/potential-effects-birds-onshore-development-proposed","title":"The Potential Effects on Birds arising from the Onshore Infrastructure of the Proposed Greater Gabbard Offshore Wind Farm","description":"This report presents the baseline description of the avifauna occurring in the area of the onshore infrastructure of the proposed Greater Gabbard Offshore Wind Farm and also an impact assessment of these works. The study reports on onshore surveys covering areas that included the beach at Sizewell where cables would come ashore, fields along the proposed cable route and the proposed sub-station location. Field data used in the assessment were collected over two years, 2005 and 2006. The work has been undertaken by the British Trust for Ornithology (BTO).\u00a0","author":["Rehfisch, M.","Burton, N.","Holloway, S.","Thewlis, R.","Carter, N."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)"],"originationDate":"2006-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.205142000000","1.622052000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Burton-2006-Gabbard-Bird-Impacts.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/663","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/identifying-range-options-prevent-or-reduce-avian-collision-offshore-wind-farms-using","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bto.org\/our-science\/publications\/research-reports\/identifying-range-options-prevent-or-reduce-avian","title":"Identifying a Range of Options to Prevent or Reduce Avian Collision with Offshore Wind Farms using a UK-Based Case Study","description":"This project aims to review and evaluate potential mitigation options for preventing or reducing avian collisions with offshore wind farms. Offshore wind farms may potentially affect bird populations through the displacement of birds due to the disturbance associated with developments, the barrier they present for migrating birds and birds commuting between breeding sites and feeding areas, habitat change or loss and through collision mortality.\nThe work has four main objectives: i. To review current avian collision mitigation options, both national and international; ii. To identify existing and novel mitigation methods that could be used to minimise avian collision; iii. To identify which bird species, native and migratory (including breeding units and breeding \/ overwintering populations), are considered most at risk in UK waters, with the view to identifying key species for cumulative assessment; iv. To model the cumulative risk of avian collision in wind farms and, where sufficient information exists to parameterise the models, model this risk against a range of mitigation options to determine which is most successful, using the Greater Wash as a UK case study.\nA range of technologies and techniques have been proposed to reduce bird collisions within different sectors. Few have been tested extensively on either onshore or offshore wind farms. In the UK, the majority of measures implemented to reduce collision rates relate to the siting, orientation and spacing of turbines. Ten novel measures were selected for further analysis. These were evaluated in the context of their technical feasibility, implementation and operational costs and effectiveness in reducing the risk of bird collision rates. This evaluation is summarised below.\nThe risk or vulnerability of species to the effects of developments, such as offshore wind farms, reflects the combination of both species\u2019 sensitivities and exposure to these effects. In this review, we thus first consider which UK species are likely to be most sensitive to the effect of collision mortality with offshore wind farms in UK waters, before then considering which species might be exposed to this effect as a result of Round 1 and 2 developments,\u00a0potential Round 1 and 2 extensions, Round 3 sites, and sites planned for Scottish Territorial Waters.\u00a0\nThree previous studies have appraised the sensitivities of bird species to the effects associated with offshore wind farms. Garthe and H\u00fcppop (2004), and King et al. (2009) which follows that study, determined a Species Sensitivity Index (SSI) considering aspects relating to all the potential effects posed by offshore wind farms. Langston (2010) used a three-level categorical system to define species\u2019 sensitivities to \u2018Collision risk\u2019, \u2018Displacement\u2019, \u2018Barrier\u2019, and \u2018Habitat\/Prey\u2019 effects, and a score for species\u2019 conservation status, and from these scores derived a species-specific value for \u2018Overall Risk\u2019.\nComparison of the scores related to collision risk from these studies reveals a good level of accord. Given this close correlation, we defined the species that are sensitive to the effect of collision mortality with offshore wind farms in UK waters as those having High or Moderate Collision Risk scores according to Langston (2010). This provided a total of 31 species or species\u2019 populations (17 seabird species, 13 wildfowl species or species\u2019 populations and one terrestrial species).\nFor the 17 seabird species sensitive to the effect of collision mortality with offshore wind farms in UK waters, we produced maps showing the species\u2019 foraging ranges from SPAs and their at-sea-distributions (from European Seabirds at Sea data) showing their exposure to offshore wind farms (Figures 3.3.3 to 3.3.34).\nWhether due to their foraging ranges from SPAs, or due to their presence in wind farm development zones at times of year that these species are not associated with SPAs, or due to their migration routes, all 31 sensitive species are potentially exposed and thus should be considered vulnerable to the risk of collision with Round 1 and 2 developments, potential Round 1 and 2 extensions, Round 3 sites, or sites planned for Scottish Territorial Waters. However, six species \u2013 the Greylag Geese and Corncrake which breed in northwest Scotland, and Pomarine Skua, Long-tailed Skua, Iceland Gull and Glaucous Gull which are only present in UK waters in small numbers \u2013 probably face limited exposure to offshore wind farm development zones and should thus be considered to be less vulnerable to collision mortality. Effects on other species, such as the waders and wildfowl considered by King et al. (2009) should also not be discounted.\nFollowing the results of the review, we investigated how the cumulative risk of avian collision within wind farms might be affected by the shortlisted mitigation options, using the Greater Wash as a case study. Seven options were considered \u2013 minimal use of lighting and auditory deterrents not being taken forward due to their respective low feasibility and effectiveness. Remote population monitoring is an approach that would be used in conjunction with other options, such as temporary shutdown, to maximise their effectiveness and thus was not considered directly in this chapter.\nMitigation options may operate in a number of different ways, though in the majority of cases by increasing the level of avoidance of wind turbines. As the literature review summarised, relatively little is known as to how effective different measures may be in increasing avoidance and thus it is unlikely to be possible to compare with precision the different short-listed options. Further, there is still a large degree of uncertainty about the level of avoidance of wind turbines that birds demonstrate. The effects of temporary shutdown and changes to turbine design, in contrast, can be more easily quantified. Thus the modelling exercise undertaken here aimed to identify the most promising mitigation measures, along with those that require further work to confirm their value.\nThe model of Band et al. (2007) was used to quantify the cumulative collision-related mortality of seabirds resulting from offshore wind farms in the vicinity of the Greater Wash, using data collected during Environmental Impact Assessments of the area. In order to demonstrate the efficacy of any mitigation measures, a range of avoidance rates were considered. Population Viability Analysis (PVA) was also used to model the impact of increased mortality on the populations of seven species of seabird \u2013 Northern Gannet, Common Tern, Sandwich Tern, Lesser Black-backed Gull, Black-legged Kittiwake, Common Guillemot and Razorbill \u2013 which breed in the area.\nIn terms of overall mortality rates, the greatest cumulative impacts were estimated for Northern Gannet and Lesser Black-backed Gull with an additional 220 and 238 mortalities respectively, assuming a 99% avoidance rate. Results from PVA suggest that, assuming a 99% avoidance rate, populations of Northern Gannet and Common Tern were most likely to be affected by the increased mortality associated with collisions with wind turbines.\nThe potential effect of the short-listed mitigation options on avian mortality rates was then considered in light of these results. Based on the available evidence from the literature, changes to lighting would be among the most effective of mitigation options, though legislation limits what might be achievable. The use of lasers is most likely to be effective at night, whilst ultra-violet paint is most likely to be effective during the day. The use of decoy towers has shown promise, but would only be effective for certain species, such as seaduck, divers and auks which are themselves less prone to collisions. A temporary shut down of turbines is likely to be highly effective, but financial constraints are likely to highly restrict the length of shut down periods. Targeted shut downs for restricted key periods, perhaps further restricted to times of day when key species are most active, represent a possible option given these constraints and would be worth exploring on a site by species basis. No single measure is likely to be effective at reducing collisions for all species at all times, consequently combinations specifically targeted to the species recorded within each wind farm are likely to prove the most effective mitigation strategy.","author":["Burton, N.","Martin, G.","Cook, A.","Roos, S.","Ross-Smith, V.","Beale, N.","Coleman, C.","Daniel, H.","Fitzpatrick, S.","Rankin, E.","Norman, K."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","University of Birmingham","UK Department for Environment Food and Rural Affairs (DEFRA)"],"originationDate":"2011-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Cook-2011-Avian.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/664","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-risk-offshore-wind-farm-development-migratory-birds-designated-features-uk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bto.org\/sites\/default\/files\/u28\/downloads\/Projects\/final-report-soss05.pdf","title":"Assessing the risk of offshore wind farm development to migratory birds designated as features of UK Special Protection Areas (and other Annex 1 species)","description":"Migratory birds move across seas in large numbers but over a short time period, often at night and sometimes in bad weather, so are not adequately recorded in bird surveys undertaken as part of Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) for proposed offshore wind farms. As such, the possible effects of these developments on migratory birds are not well understood.  A comprehensive review of the literature on bird migration (particularly around the UK) was undertaken in an attempt to identify gaps in our knowledge and make recommendations for future research. The review focussed on species that are designated features of UK Special Protection Areas (SPAs), and other regularly occurring species listed on Annex 1 of the Birds Directive, as agreed with the SOSS steering group. This does not mean that other migratory bird species should not be considered in impact assessments, but they are not included in the scope of this report.  Information was sought on migratory routes and population sizes, along with details of flight altitudes and the frequency of fall events, which were thought likely to influence a species\u2019 vulnerability to collision with wind turbines.  The review showed that although a large number of species migrate across UK waters, for the majority of them our knowledge of migratory behaviour is limited and does not allow estimation of the proportion of birds migrating at heights where they may encounter wind turbines.  Although the migratory destinations on land are quite well understood for many species, details of the routes that they follow when flying over the sea around the UK are rarely known. This means it is difficult to estimate the numbers of birds likely to fly over proposed offshore wind farm sites, particularly for species that use more than one migratory pathway across UK waters.  We have provided guidance on methods to assess the potential risk to migratory birds that are features of SPAs from proposed offshore wind farm developments. Whilst this guidance is currently limited to migratory SPA species, this does not preclude the future need for assessment of other species.  We have made recommendations for future work to address some of the current gaps in knowledge that pose a potential risk to consenting for offshore wind farm developments. We suggest that future work should initially concentrate on those species that are features of SPAs, and whose entire biogeographic population migrates across UK waters, in particular if initial assessment using the guidance in this report suggests that there is a potential risk to the species in question. The importance of work on other species should also be considered in these terms, such that studies of species for which negligible risk is identified using the methods suggested in this report, and of non-SPA species and\/or those species for which only a small proportion of the population is found in UK waters are not prioritised.  Where suitable technology exists, studies combining the use of tags with radar could be particularly valuable in informing our understanding of a species\u2019 migratory behaviour. Studies combining weather data with radar observation of migrating birds would also be very valuable.","author":["Burton, N.","Wright, L.","Cook, A.","Austin, G.","Ross-Smith, V.","Massimino, D.","Dadam, D.","Calbrade, N."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","The Crown Estate"],"originationDate":"2012-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wrightetal2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/665","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/scientific-validity-criticisms-made-rspb-metrics-used-assess-population-level-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bto.org\/our-science\/publications\/research-reports\/scientific-validity-criticisms-made-rspb-metrics-used","title":"The Scientific Validity of Criticisms made by the RSPB of Metrics used to Assess Population Level Impacts of Offshore Wind Farms on Seabirds","description":"The purpose of this report is to consider the validity of criticisms that have been made by the RSPB on the use of risk-based metrics to assess the response of seabird populations to impacts from offshore wind farms. Following the project start-up meeting on 3rd December 2014, it was agreed that this consideration should also include approaches that have been used to set thresholds of additional mortality including Potential Biological Removal (PBR), Acceptable Biological Change (ABC) and reduced uncertainty Acceptable Biological Change (ruABC).","author":["Cook, A.","Robinson, R."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)","Natural England","Natural Resources Wales","Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2015-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Cook_and_Robinson_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/666","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-flight-heights-lesser-black-backed-gulls-great-skuas-gps-bayesian-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/1365-2664.12760","title":"Modelling flight heights of Lesser Black-backed Gulls and Great Skuas from GPS: a Bayesian approach","description":"Wind energy generation is increasing globally, and associated environmental impacts must be considered. The risk of seabirds colliding with offshore wind turbines is influenced by flight height, and flight height data usually come from observers on boats, making estimates in daylight in fine weather. GPS tracking provides an alternative and generates flight height information in a range of conditions, but the raw data have associated error.  Here, we present a novel analytical solution for accommodating GPS error. We use Bayesian state\u2010space models to describe the flight height distributions and the error in altitude measured by GPS for lesser black\u2010backed gulls and great skuas, tracked throughout the breeding season. We also examine how location and light levels influence flight height.  Lesser black\u2010backed gulls flew lower by night than by day, indicating that this species would be less likely to encounter turbine blades at night, when birds\u2019 ability to detect and avoid them might be reduced. Gulls flew highest over land and lowest near the coast. For great skuas, no significant relationships were found between flight height, time of day and location.  We consider four \u2018collision risk windows\u2019, corresponding to the airspace swept by rotor blades for different offshore wind turbine designs. We found the highest proportion of birds at risk for a 22\u2013250 m turbine (up to 9% for great skuas and 34% for lesser black\u2010backed gulls) and the lowest for a 30\u2013258 m turbine. Our results suggest lesser black\u2010backed gulls are at greater risk of collision than great skuas, especially by day.  Synthesis and applications. Our novel modelling approach is an effective way of resolving the error associated with GPS tracking data. We demonstrate its use on GPS measurements of altitude, generating important information on how breeding seabirds use their environment. This approach and the associated data also provide information to improve avian collision risk assessments for offshore wind farms. Our modelling approach could be applied to other GPS data sets to help manage the ecological needs of seabirds and other species at a time when the pressures on the marine environment are growing.","author":["Masden, E.","Rehfisch, M.","Thaxter, C.","Burton, N.","Wright, L.","Johnston, A.","Ross-Smith, V.","Shamoun-Baranes, J."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)","University of Amsterdam","APEM Ltd"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.083805000000","1.566753000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/667","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/avian-vulnerability-wind-farm-collision-through-year-insights-lesser-black-backed","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/1365-2664.13488","title":"Avian vulnerability to wind farm collision through the year: insights from Lesser Black-backed Gulls (Larus fuscus) tracked from multiple breeding colonies","description":"Wind energy generation has become an important means to reduce reliance on fossil fuels and mitigate against human\u2010induced climate change, but could also represent a significant human\u2013wildlife conflict. Airborne taxa such as birds may be particularly sensitive to collision mortality with wind turbines, yet the relative vulnerability of species\u2019 populations across their annual life cycles has not been evaluated.  Using GPS telemetry, we studied the movements of lesser black\u2010backed gulls Larus fuscus from three UK breeding colonies through their annual cycle. We modelled the distance travelled by birds at altitudes between the minimum and maximum rotor sweep zone of turbines, combined with the probability of collision, to estimate sensitivity to collision. Sensitivity was then combined with turbine density (exposure) to evaluate spatio\u2010temporal vulnerability.  Sensitivity was highest near to colonies during the breeding season, where a greater distance travelled by birds was in concentrated areas where they were exposed to turbines.  Consequently, vulnerability was high near to colonies but was also high at some migration bottlenecks and wintering sites where, despite a reduced sensitivity, exposure to turbines was greatest.  Synthesis and applications. Our framework combines bird\u2010borne telemetry and spatial data on the location of wind turbines to identify potential areas of conflict for migratory populations throughout their annual cycle. This approach can aid the wind farm planning process by: (a) providing sensitivity maps to inform wind farm placement, helping minimize impacts; (b) identifying areas of high vulnerability where mitigation warrants exploration; (c) highlighting potential cumulative impacts of developments over international boundaries and (d) informing the conservation status of species at protected sites. Our methods can identify pressures and linkages for populations using effect\u2010specific metrics that are transferable and could help resolve other human\u2013wildlife conflicts.","author":["Masden, E.","Thaxter, C.","Clark, N.","Burton, N.","Bouten, W.","Ross-Smith, V.","Conway, G.","Clewley, G.","Barber, G."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","University of Amsterdam","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.083726000000","1.568040000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/668","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-greenhouse-gas-emissions-floating-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bren.ucsb.edu\/projects\/life-cycle-greenhouse-gas-emissions-assessment-california-floating-offshore-wind-energy","title":"Life Cycle Assessment of Greenhouse Gas Emissions for Floating Offshore Wind Energy in California","description":"Senate Bill 100 of California passed in 2018 establishes the requirement that 100% of the state\u2019s retail electricity be generated from eligible carbon-free resources by 2045. Given the high land prices and limited onshore wind resources in California, floating offshore wind represents a new carbon-free energy resource that can help California meet the Senate Bill 100 target. In order to facilitate the development of floating offshore wind projects in federal waters off the coast of California, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) Pacific Region has tasked the Bren School with characterizing and assessing the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions associated with the integration of offshore wind energy into California electricity markets. By performing a life cycle assessment (LCA) for a representative floating offshore wind project, this report presents the first analysis of the life cycle GHG emissions of any offshore wind project in California. Our results show that supplying 1 MWh of electricity through floating offshore wind power generates ~15kg CO2-equivalent GHG emissions over its life cycle, which is comparable with the literature for conceptual floating offshore wind turbine models. Monte Carlo simulation establishes a 90% confidence interval range of emissions from 11.60 to 25.04kg CO2-equivalent. Our results are within the combined range of both onshore and offshore wind projects at a utility scale. Compared with other energy sources, life cycle GHG emissions from floating offshore wind in California are similar to those from hydro and nuclear. These results indicate that floating offshore wind in California produces at least 92% less GHG emissions per MWh supplied to the grid compared to natural gas. In-depth analysis of our results indicates that the turbine manufacturing stage is responsible for the majority of the life cycle GHG emissions, that recycling rates for materials have strong implications for reducing life cycle GHG emissions, and that the life cycle GHG emissions are most heavily influenced by capacity factor of the turbines and the operational lifetime of the windfarm. These results imply that, first, offshore wind has the potential to provide low-carbon electricity in California, and, second, mitigation efforts should prioritize the manufacturing and recycling phases, and the factors influencing capacity factor (i.e. site selection and generation capacity) and operational lifetime of the windfarm (i.e., maintenance schedule and mechanical durability). Our study demonstrates the potential for floating offshore wind projects to curb GHG emissions and to meet the Senate Bill 100 target.","author":["Ma, C.","Bang, J.","Tarantino, E.","Vela, A.","Yamane, D."],"organization":["University of California Santa Barbara","Bren School of Environmental Science \u0026 Management"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-11 07:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bang-2019-Floating-Wind-LCA.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/669","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-extractive-activities-public-support-renewable-energy-policy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421518305731","title":"The influence of extractive activities on public support for renewable energy policy","description":"Notable spatial variation in public opinion on climate change and energy policy has been demonstrated at various geographic scales (Howe et al., 2015). Understanding the source of this variation is useful for policymakers, energy developers, and utility providers in predicting how different locales may respond to newly proposed policies and energy developments, particularly those encouraging renewable energy. Using nationally representative survey data from 2008 to 2015, we employ hierarchical linear regression to examine variation in public support for renewable energy policy, focusing on how residence in areas with extractive activities may be related to attitudes toward renewable energy policy. We test the influence of several county-level indicators, including oil production, gas production, and economic dependence on the mining sector. We also test for individual factors, including political ideology, belief in anthropogenic climate change, and several sociodemographic variables. Results suggest that individuals living in both mining-dependent counties and counties with natural gas production are somewhat less likely to support renewable energy policies than individuals living outside such places. At the individual level, belief in anthropogenic global warming is the strongest predictor of renewable energy policy support, and liberal political ideology, being more educated, and being female are also positively associated with policy support.","author":["Olson-Hazboun, S.","Howe, P.","Leiserowitz, A."],"organization":["Evergreen State College","Utah State University","Yale University"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.865782100000","-105.806098300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/670","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/positive-energies-empirical-study-community-energy-participation-attitudes-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421518301976","title":"Positive energies? An empirical study of community energy participation and attitudes to renewable energy","description":"It has been suggested that participation in community energy initiatives may play an important role in enabling a transition towards renewable energy (RE) deployment by fostering positive attitudes toward renewables. Yet, little is known about how members of community energy initiatives differ from non-members in terms of energy attitudes and whether different profiles of community energy members exist. This article empirically analyses the relations between community energy membership and attitudes toward RE and onshore wind energy. Based on statistical analyses of a large-scale quantitative dataset from an original survey (N = 3963) conducted with two energy cooperatives in Belgium, it contrasts different groups of cooperative members with each other and a comparison group of non-members. Results show that members have significantly more positive attitudes towards RE than non-members. Results also suggest that non-members tend to be more indifferent or more uncertain, not more objecting, than members to wind power. Finally, significant differences among cooperative members are highlighted, illustrating the contrast between communities of place and communities of interest. The findings suggest a novel perspective on the benefits of community energy membership \u2013 to overcome indifference or uncertainty \u2013 that is relevant to foster a rapid and socially acceptable low carbon transition.","author":["Devine-Wright, P.","Bauwens, T."],"organization":["\u00c9cole polytechnique f\u00e9d\u00e9rale de Lausanne (EPFL)","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.182759000000","5.665218000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/671","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/advanced-flow-noise-simulation-method-wind-farm-assessment-complex-terrain","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148119308134","title":"Advanced flow and noise simulation method for wind farm assessment in complex terrain","description":"A new wind farm during its development phase requires a technical evaluation of its annual power prediction and noise issue in the area in and around the wind farm. In this paper, for the first time, an advanced numerical method for wind farm assessment is developed, which consists of a Reynolds averaged Navier-Stokes - Actuator Disc model for the flow modelling, a semi-engineering model for the noise source modelling, and a parabolic wave equation model for the sound propagation modelling. The developed method can evaluate both annual energy production of wind farm and noise emission at receivers nearby. The wind farm considered in this study is located in a typical mountainous area. The energy production of the wind turbines is simulated and compared with measured data. The flow simulations over the complex terrain are performed using the in-house developed Navier-Stokes solver. A wind farm noise map is created by solving the parabolic wave equation. The obtained flow results are the inputs to the parabolic wave equation solver for sound propagation. The numerical computations are performed on a standard high-performance computer cluster. The developed numerical method provides a reliable assessment method for wind farm about its energy efficiency and noise features.","author":["Li, Y.","Zhu, W.","Shen, W.","Barlas, E."],"organization":["Yangzhou University","Technical University of Denmark (DTU)","Shanghai Jiao Tong University"],"originationDate":"2013-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/672","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wildlife-wind-energy-siting-operation-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.esa.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2019\/09\/Issues-in-Ecology_Fall-2019.pdf","title":"Impacts to Wildlife of Wind Energy Siting and Operation in the United States","description":"Electricity from wind energy is a major contributor to the strategy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from fossil fuel use and thus reduce the negative impacts of climate change. Wind energy, like all power sources, can have adverse impacts on wildlife. After nearly 25 years of focused research, these impacts are much better understood, although uncertainty remains. In this report, we summarize positive impacts of replacing fossil fuels with wind energy, while describing what we have learned and what remains uncertain about negative ecological impacts of the construction and operation of land-based and offshore wind energy on wildlife and wildlife habitat in the U.S. Finally, we propose research on ways to minimize these impacts.  TO SUMMARIZE:    Environmental and other benefits of wind energy include near-zero greenhouse gas emissions, reductions of other common air pollutants, and little or no water use associated with producing electricity from wind energy. Various scenarios for meeting U.S. carbon emission reduction goals indicate that a four- to five-fold expansion of land-based wind energy from the current 97 gigawatts (GW) by the year 2050 is needed to minimize temperature increases and reduce the risk of climate change to people and wildlife.  Collision fatalities of birds and bats are the most visible and measurable impacts of wind energy production. Current estimates suggest most bird species, especially songbirds, are at low risk of population-level impacts. Raptors as a group appear more vulnerable to collisions. Population-level impacts on migratory tree bats are a concern, and better information on population sizes is needed to evaluate potential impacts to these species. Although recorded fatalities of cave-dwelling bat species are typically low at most wind energy facilities, additional mortality from collisions is a concern given major declines in these species due to white-nose syndrome (WNS). Assessments of regional and cumulative fatality impacts for birds and bats have been hampered by the lack of data from areas with a high proportion of the nation\u2019s installed wind energy capacity. Efforts to expand data accessibility from all regions are underway, and this greater access to data along with improvements in statistical estimators should lead to improved impact assessments.  Habitat impacts of wind energy development are difficult to assess. An individual wind energy facility may encompass thousands of acres, but only a small percentage of the landscape within the project area is directly transformed. If a project is sited in previously undisturbed habitat, there is concern for indirect impacts, such as displacement of sensitive species. Studies to date indicate displacement of some species, but the long-term population impacts are unknown.  Offshore wind energy development in the U.S. is just beginning. Studies at offshore wind facilities in Europe indicate some bird and marine mammal species are displaced from project areas, but substantial uncertainty exists regarding the individual or population-level impacts of this displacement. Bird and bat collisions with offshore turbines are thought to be less common than at terrestrial facilities, but currently the tools to measure fatalities at offshore wind energy facilities are not available.    The wind energy industry, state and federal agencies, conservation groups, academia, and scientific organizations have collaborated for nearly 25 years to conduct the research needed to improve our understanding of risk to wildlife and to avoid and minimize that risk. Efforts to reduce the uncertainty about wildlife risk must keep up with the pace and scale of the need to reduce carbon emissions. This will require focusing our research priorities and increasing the rate at which we incorporate research results into the development and validation of best practices for siting and operating wind energy facilities.  We recommend continued focus on (1) species of regulatory concern or those where known or suspected population-level concern exists but corroborating data are needed, (2) research improving risk evaluation and siting to avoid impacts on species of concern or sensitive habitats, (3) evaluation of promising collision-reducing technologies and operational strategies with high potential for widespread implementation, and (4) coordinated research and data pooling to enable statistically robust analysis of infrequent, but potentially ecologically significant impacts for some species.","author":["Allison, T.","Baerwald, E.","Strickland, M.","Williams, K.","Hein, C.","Huso, M.","Lovich, J.","Hale, A.","Drake, D.","Loss, S.","Diffendorfer, J.","Winder, V.","Beston, J."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)","US Geological Survey (USGS)","University of Regina","University of Wisconsin Stout","University of Wisconsin","Texas Christian University","Bat Conservation International","Oklahoma State University","Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Biodiversity Research Institute","Benedictine College","Ecological Society of America (ESA)"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Allison_et_al_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/673","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/local-support-renewable-energy-technologies-attitudes-towards-local-near-shore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421519302769","title":"Local support for renewable energy technologies? Attitudes towards local near-shore wind farms among second home owners and permanent area residents on the Danish coast","description":"This paper documents different attitudes towards local renewable energy technology (RET) projects in Denmark among two key RET stakeholder groups, permanent area residents (PRs) and second home owners (SHOs). It does so via survey data collected from almost 2000 respondents during a Danish near-shore wind farm tender. Judging by this data, local PRs are positive towards the planned local RETs, while SHOs are less so. This emphasizes that potential RET project stakeholders and stakeholder groups may have very different RET project perceptions and opinions. The planned RET projects were subject to widespread critique in the public and political RET project related debate, but the documented PR RET project support was rather silent support. This is a noteworthy inconsistency calling for further research. Drawing upon research insights from the interdisciplinary socially focused energy transitions body of literature, the paper suggests that particular uses of and attachments to particular places may inform stakeholder perceptions of RET related local change. The research findings have significant implications for RET planning, practice and policy more broadly.","author":["Johansen, K."],"organization":["Aalborg University"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.583162000000","10.135845000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/674","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/co-production-distributed-generation-renewable-energy-creating-space-fitting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/full\/10.1080\/01426397.2017.1358360","title":"Co-production in distributed generation: renewable energy and creating space for fitting infrastructure within landscapes","description":"This review describes the infrastructural elements of the socio-technical system of power supply based on renewables and the role of landscape concerns in decision-making about emerging \u2018intelligent grids\u2019. The considerable land areas required for energy infrastructure call for sizable \u2018distributed generation\u2019 close to energy consumption. Securing community acceptance of renewables\u2019 infrastructure, perceived impacts on the community, and \u2018landscape justice\u2019 requires two types of co-production: in power supply and in making space available. With co-production, landscape issues are prominent, for some options dominant. However, \u2018objectification\u2019 of landscape, such as the use of \u2018visibility\u2019 as proxy for \u2018visual impact\u2019, is part of lingering centralised and hierarchical approaches to the deployment of renewables. Institutional tendencies of centralisation and hierarchy, in power supply management as well as in siting, should be replaced by co-production, as follows from common pool resources theory. Co-production is the key to respecting landscape values, furthering justice, and achieving community acceptance.","author":["Wolsink, M."],"organization":["University of Amsterdam"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Co-production-in-distributed-generation.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/675","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/community-benefits-offshore-renewables-relationship-between-different-understandings","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/full\/10.1177\/2399654417699206","title":"Community benefits from offshore renewables: The relationship between different understandings of impact, community, and benefit","description":"This paper presents the findings of a research project evaluating community benefit models for offshore renewables. We identify and analyse UK and international case studies of different forms of community benefit, and provide evidence of how such benefits are delivered. In particular we consider the key relationship between the identification of communities, perception of impact, and the apportionment of benefits. In doing so, we develop a range of different definitions of \u2018community\u2019, \u2018benefit\u2019, and \u2018impact\u2019 when considering community benefits. We propose that the way in which community, benefit, and impact are understood is crucial in determining whether or how benefits should be apportioned and delivered; and that these definitions are closely connected to each other. We develop a new series of typologies as a way to understand this. Finally, we assess different mechanisms and schemes of community benefits to identify good practice and key points of learning for policy and planning.","author":["Haggett, C.","Rudolph, D.","Aitken, M."],"organization":["Technical University of Denmark (DTU)","University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2017-03-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/676","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/good-management-practices-social-economic-data-collection-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"","title":"Good Management Practices for Social and Economic Data Collection for Marine Renewable Energy","description":"OES-Environmental has developed Good Management Practices for the collection of social and economic data in order to provide greater standardization in baseline and development\/operational data requested to support permitting\/consenting MRE projects and to increase understanding of the social and economic benefits and effects of MRE developments. By increasing standardization and incorporating agreements among governments and developers, consistency in data collection can increase and allow for comparisons of data across projects, communities, and technologies. The Good Management Practices described in this report should be used to help reach these goals.","author":["Copping, A.","Fox, J.","Hutchison, I.","Freeman, M."],"organization":["Ocean Energy Systems (OES)","Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2019-09-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Good-Management-Practices-for-Socio-Econ-Data-Collection_final_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/677","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewables-reefs-participatory-multicriteria-decision-analysis-required-optimize-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X15004221","title":"Renewables-to-reefs: Participatory multicriteria decision analysis is required to optimize wind farm decommissioning","description":"Smyth et al. (2015) present a detailed consideration of the ecological, societal, economic and regulatory aspects of wind farm decommissioning in the marine environment. The result is a consolidated base of information that will hopefully assist managers and the industry to prepare for the decommissioning phase. However, the analyses used to compare the two decommissioning options (partial and complete removal) are not sufficient to identify the best-performing option, nor do they provide a structured method for incorporating stakeholder values into the decision process. While we suspect the authors\u2019 motives were to provide a general comparison for use as a guide, rather than an exact method to be implemented in specific decommissioning cases, future use of their methods may result in sub-optimal outcomes for both society and the marine environment. Smyth et al. (2015) also propose a large-scale \u2018renewables-to-reefs\u2019 program based on the outcomes of their analyses, which is premature given the lack of rigorous comparison between the two options. We therefore use this comment to outline the above issues with Smyth et al.\u2019s (2015) methods and propose a more rigorous approach for wind farm decommissioning decisions based on multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA). The approach has recently been developed to optimize decommissioning decisions for offshore oil and gas infrastructure (see Fowler et al., 2014), which share many of the environmental and social considerations of wind farms, as well as similar decision challenges.","author":["Fowler, A.","Macreadie, P.","Booth, D."],"organization":["University of Technology Sydney","Deakin University"],"originationDate":"2015-09-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/678","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/simulating-environmental-impact-tidal-turbines-seabed","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/6741161\/","title":"Simulating the environmental impact of tidal turbines on the seabed","description":"Recent proliferation of marine renewable energy installations has inspired a number of researchers to study the possible impact of the technologies on the marine environment. The impact of tidal turbines on the flow downstream of the rotor and their effect on sediment transport from the seabed over the lifetime of the devices is of particular concern, given the potential damage to the seabed, the habitats of marine life and submarine power cables used to connect the devices to the coast. Previous computational studies of the environmental impact of tidal turbines have, however, focused predominantly on largescale one and two dimensional modelling. Resolution of the three-dimensional nature of the flow through the rotor of the turbine proves to be crucial if the mechanism whereby these devices entrain sediment from the seabed is to be properly understood. The three-dimensional phenomena occurring in the flow through the rotor of the turbine have been found to profoundly affect how the sediment is lifted from the seabed and transported downstream in the wake of the device. The physics of sediment transport due to the rotor of a tidal turbine in a tidal current have been investigated using high resolution three-dimensional computational simulations of the hydrodynamics of the rotor wake. The direct impact of the turbine on the seabed has been found to be confined to an area that extends no further than two rotor diameters downstream of the turbine. The maximal values of shear stress, which indicate the extent of the impact, vary with the distance between the rotor hub and the seabed.","author":["Brown, R.","Vybulkova, L.","Vezza, M."],"organization":["University of Glasgow","University of Strathclyde"],"originationDate":"2013-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/679","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/identification-compatibilities-conflicts-reaching-marine-spatial-allocation-agreements","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117309869","title":"From identification of compatibilities and conflicts to reaching marine spatial allocation agreements. Review of actions required and relevant tools and processes","description":"Conflicts related to the use of marine space may emerge both at the spatial and the decision making level, prior to and\/or after the adoption of a marine spatial plan. Marine conflict management is inherent in marine spatial planning (MSP) and should include three stages: a) identification of compatibilities and conflicts, b) avoidance of conflicts, and if required c) resolution of conflicts. Various decision support tools and processes tested so far that aim to address marine conflict management have proved successful in providing identification and visualization of spatial conflicts and compatibilities and their relevant trade-offs and thus in assisting in conflict avoidance efforts. However, in case conflict resolution is required, they fail to provide a final solution (e.g. allocation of space) acceptable by all parties involved. This happens because the (spatial) allocation rules that these processes adopt usually focus only on ensuring efficiency that is not enough to guarantee a (single) mutually acceptable solution. In the present paper, it is suggested that apart from ensuring efficiency, a solution should also ensure fairness, equity, transparency, sustainability and consideration of synergies that may emerge, both at the spatial and at the decision making level. In conclusion, there is no single tool or process that can satisfactory address all conflict management stages, and thus a careful selection and combination of decision support tools and processes is required to facilitate the production of an integrated mutually acceptable marine spatial plan.\n\nHighlights:\nConflict management (identification, avoidance and resolution) is inherent to MSP.\nIn MSP initiatives it is often not clear what marine conflict management includes.\nNo universal tool exists to address all stages of the marine conflict management.\nSpatial allocation rules should ensure efficient and equitable win-win solutions.","author":["Kyriazi, Z."],"organization":["Ghent University","Hellenic Centre for Marine Research (HCMR)"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/680","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/scale-dependent-habitat-selection-wintering-geese-implications-landscape-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10531-017-1427-4","title":"Scale-dependent habitat selection by wintering geese: implications for landscape management","description":"The management of Arctic migrant geese is complex, because they frequently use landscapes under intensive human use, and are conflict species in multiple respects. Some populations are of high conservation concern, but they also cause agricultural damage, are quarry for hunters, and may be particularly sensitive to infrastructure developments. In Bulgarian Dobrudzha, large wintering populations of greater white-fronted geese\u00a0Anser albifrons\u00a0and red-breasted geese\u00a0Branta ruficollis\u00a0feed in agricultural land, and cause management dilemmas. We developed linear models to investigate fine- and meso-scale foraging habitat selection of geese foraging on winter wheat in the area, and used these models to make suggestions for zoning landscape use in order to reduce conflict and conserve geese. Habitat selection was scale-dependent. Geese selected fields that were near to major roosts and had low proximity to roads and tree-lines, which may be a proxy for hunting disturbance. We found some evidence for selection of wheat fields with high nutritional quality. Within fields, geese strongly avoided features which cause landscape \u2018clutter\u2019: power-lines, tree-lines and wind-turbines, but primarily over distances of less than a few hundred metres. Optimal management might involve encouraging goose populations to feed in areas close to roosts, by means of agri-environmental measures and creation of hunting-free refuges. This would allow efficient use of agri-environment funds, might reduce conflict with farmers, and would mean that infrastructure development\u2014notably wind farms\u2014could be sited at greater distance from roosts with relatively minor impact on foraging habitat availability.","author":["Gove, B.","Harrison, A.","Petkov, N.","Mitev, D.","Popgeorgiev, G.","Hilton, G."],"organization":["Wildfowl and Wetlands Trust (WWT)","Bulgarian Society for the Protection of Birds","Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.664409000000","28.422904000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/681","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/practical-approaches-advances-spatial-tools-achieve-multi-objective-marine-spatial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2019.00166\/full","title":"Practical Approaches and Advances in Spatial Tools to Achieve Multi-Objective Marine Spatial Planning","description":"Marine spatial planning (MSP) processes seek to better manage ocean spaces by balancing ecological, social and economic objectives using public and participatory processes. To meet this challenge, MSP approaches and tools have evolved globally, from local to national scales. At two International Marine Conservation Congresses (2016 and 2018), MSP practitioners and researchers from diverse geographic, technical and socio-economic contexts met to share advances in practical approaches and spatial tools to achieve multi-objective MSP. Here we share the lessons learned and commonalities that emerged from studies conducted in Belize, Canada, South Africa, Seychelles, the United Kingdom and the United States on a number of topics related to advancing MSP. We identify seven important themes that we believe are broadly relevant to any multi-objective MSP process: (1) indigenous and local knowledge should inform planning goals and objectives; (2) transparent and evidence-based approaches can reduce user conflict; (3) simple ecosystem service models and scenarios can facilitate multi-objective planning; (4) trade-off analyses can help balance diverse objectives; (5) ecosystem services may assist planning for high value-data poor Blue Economy sectors; (6) game theoretic decision rules can help to deliver fair, equitable and win\u2013win spatial allocation solutions; and (7) strategic mapping products can facilitate decision making amongst stakeholders from different sectors. Some of these themes are evident in MSP processes that have been completed in the previous decade, but the fast-evolving field of MSP is addressing increasingly more complex objectives, and practitioners need to respond with practical approaches and spatial tools that can address this complexity.","author":["Smith, J.","Wood, S.","Lester, S.","Kyriazi, Z.","Sink, K.","Lombard, A.","Ban, N.","Jacob, A.","Tingey, R.","Sims, H."],"organization":["Nelson Mandela University","University of Victoria","The Nature Conservancy","Florida State University","South African National Biodiversity Institute","University of Washington","Ghent University"],"originationDate":"2019-04-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lombard-et-al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/682","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/human-dimensions-marine-hydrokinetic-energies-current-knowledge-research-gaps","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032117310900","title":"Human dimensions of marine hydrokinetic energies: Current knowledge and research gaps","description":"Understanding the human dimensions of marine hydrokinetic (MHK) energies is essential to ensure the viability and sustainability of MHK energy projects. However, these have received little attention in scientific research. Given the diversity of political, and socio-economic settings where MHK energy projects can be applied, place-based information is likely to be most useful in designing and implementing initiatives, along with guiding principles that assure best practice. This study reviews the literature on human dimensions of MHK energies to explore gaps and challenges to be tackled in future research. While peer-reviewed literature on the human dimensions of MHK energies is growing, it is dominated by studies in developed high income countries. Research on human dimensions of MHK energies has focused on public perceptions and social acceptability, public conflicts, stakeholder participation and community cost and benefits. Three methodologies dominated the analysis of data: qualitative approaches, descriptive and inference statistics and mapping tools. Empirical studies performed in sites where MHK energy projects are planned or ongoing were scarce. Given that a great deal of MHK energy projects are occurring globally in developed and developing countries, the research gaps we identified present a number of risks. Scientific research on human dimensions of MHK should diversify, both methodologically and geographically addressing real world applications, in order to support the successful design and implementation of these energies.","author":["Ruano-Chamorro, C.","Castilla, J.","Gelcich, S."],"organization":["Marine Energy Research \u0026 Innovation Center (MERIC)","Pontifical Catholic University of Chile"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-24 11:23:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/683","type":["Document","Document\/Guidance"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-lagoon-environmental-interactions-regulator-perspective-solution-options","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ore.exeter.ac.uk\/repository\/handle\/10871\/24267","title":"Tidal Lagoon Environmental Interactions: Regulator Perspective, Solution Options and Industry Challenges","description":"Tidal range energy is an attractive renewable energy option, particularly in areas of high tidal range, such as the UK. Historically one of the main barriers to tidal range developments in the UK, specifically tidal barrages, has been regulatory environmental concerns and uncertainty surrounding environmental impacts. Tidal lagoons are often suggested as a means of reducing the environmental impact of barrage options. Recent developments in the lagoon sector mean it is now more important than ever to further consider the environmental impacts arising from tidal lagoons and the potential constraints these impacts may pose to the industry\u2019s future growth. Environmental impacts and their interactions are complex, often making them difficult to understand and manage. Here we develop a conceptual framework to categorise impacts, present results from consultation with regulatory and policy organisations and discuss potential impact and enhancement solution options. The article includes a number of case studies to present lessons learnt, opportunities, cautions and successful implementation of past solutions. In the absence of operational tidal lagoons, these case studies are based on barrages and other relevant developments.","author":["Smith, H.","Mackinnon, K.","Moore, F."],"organization":["Black \u0026 Veatch","University of Exeter","Industrial Doctoral Centre for Offshore Renewable Energy (IDCORE)"],"originationDate":"2016-10-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.276117200000","-5.754382000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/684","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-effects-tidal-barrage-water-quality-indicator-distribution-severn-estuary","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s11783-012-0464-1","title":"Modeling effects of a tidal barrage on water quality indicator distribution in the Severn Estuary","description":"In this study, emphasis has focused on assessing the potential hydro-environmental impacts of a barrage across the Severn Estuary, with a numerical model being developed and applied to the estuary to assess the impacts of proposed Severn Barrage on the hydrodynamic, sediment transport and faecal indicator organism distribution within the estuary. The results show that the Severn Barrage has the potential to reduce the tidal currents in a highly dynamic estuary. This leads to the reduction of suspended sediment concentrations, which in turn affects the bacterial transport processes which is highly related to the sediment transport processes.","author":["Falconer, R.","Lin, B.","Gao, G."],"organization":["Nankai University","Cardiff University","Tsinghua University"],"originationDate":"2013-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.259521000000","-3.546557000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/685","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/numerical-study-multi-scale-flow-sediment-structure-interactions-using-multiphase","sourceURL":"https:\/\/tel.archives-ouvertes.fr\/tel-01920495\/","title":"Numerical study of multi-scale flow-sediment-structure interactions using a multiphase approach","description":"The work undertaken in this PhD thesis was to develop and use numerical models to investigate the multi-scale interactions between an offshore wind turbine and the local ocean and sediment dynamics. First, the interactions between the coupled ocean-sediment system and the atmospheric wake generated by an offshore wind turbine are investigated using an idealized two-dimensional model developed during this Phd thesis and written in fortran. The model integrates the shallow water equations for the ocean together with the Exner equation for the sediment bed. In a second part, the 3D scour phenomenon around a vertical cylinder in a steady current is studied using a two-phase flow eulerian-eulerian solver, sedFoam, written within the framework of the numerical toolbox OpenFOAM. The two-phase flow approach accounts for small-scale processes by avoiding the traditional assumptions made for sediment transport modeling, such as a local corre- lation between the sediment flux and the fluid bed shear stress.Regarding the atmospheric wake generated by a turbine, the results shows that its impact on the ocean\u2019s surface can generate vortices. The resulting turbulent ocean dynamics is controlled by the wake parameter S = CdD\/H, where D is the wake diameter at the impact location on the ocean surface, Cd is the quadratic friction coefficient between the ocean and the sediment and H is the oceanic layer depth. A turbulence parameterization based on S is proposed, allowing for upscaling simulations in larger scales Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) models. It is shown that the ocean dynamics has an effect on the available wind power. The results also show that the instantaneous sediment dynamics is strongly coupled with the ocean one but that the overall seabed elevation variations remain small (a few millimeters\/month). The morphodynamic impact of the wake is thus negligible.Concerning the two-phase flow simulation of scour, sedFoam is first validated on 1D and 2D configurations. Then, 3D simulations around a vertical cylindrical pile are presented. At first, a validation of the Unsteady Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes (URANS) turbulence model developed in this work is performed on a configuration without sediment. The results show that the vortices structures responsible for scouring, the Horse Shoe Vortex (HSV) and the vortex-shedding in the lee of the cylinder are correctly reproduced. Then, 3D two-phase flow simulations of the scour around a cylindrical pile have been carried out in a live-bed configuration. This work is the first attempt to model 3D scour phenomenon using the two-phase flow approach. Such simulations represent a real challenge in terms of high performance computing. The good agreement between the numerical predictions and the literature experimental results provide the proof of concept that the two-phase flow approach can be used to study complex 3D and unsteady flow configurations. The relationship between the local bed shear stress, the sediment flux and the local sediment bed slope is further investigated. The deviation of the results from a uniform flow configuration is further analyzed to identify the relevant sediment transport mechanisms associated with the HSV, the slope in the scour mark and the vortex-shedding downstream of the cylinder. Finally, the numerical results show a grid sensitivity of the morphological predictions in the lee of the cylinder that are most probably related to small-scale resolved vortical structures. This highlights the need for two-phase flow Large Eddy Simulations on this configuration in the future.","author":["Nagel, T."],"organization":["Universit\u00e9 Grenoble Alpes"],"originationDate":"2018-07-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/686","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/karman-vortex-turbulent-wake-generation-wind-park-piles","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10236-016-0995-2","title":"K\u00e1rm\u00e1n vortex and turbulent wake generation by wind park piles","description":"Observational evidence of turbulent wakes behind wind parks\u2019 piles motivated a series of numerical experiments, aiming to identify the dynamic regimes associated with wakes\u2019 generation in tidal basins. We demonstrate that the obstacles such as piles of wind parks give rise to vortices similar to the known K\u00e1rm\u00e1n vortices which affect substantially the turbulent kinetic energy. The latter can be considered as the agent enhancing sediment remobilization from the ocean bottom, thus making wakes well visible in satellite data. The temporal and spatial variability of studied processes is analyzed under stationary and nonstationary conditions. The dependence of a vortex generation and evolution upon the environmental conditions is also studied, which demonstrates a large variety of appearances of turbulent wakes. The comparison between simulations using a suspended sediment model and satellite images demonstrated that the model is capable to realistically simulate sediment wakes observed in remote sensing data.","author":["Grashorn, S.","Stanev, E."],"organization":["Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/687","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/situ-observations-suspended-particulate-matter-plumes-offshore-wind-farm-southern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00367-015-0404-8","title":"In situ observations of suspended particulate matter plumes at an offshore wind farm, southern North Sea","description":"Suspended particulate matter (SPM) plumes associated with the monopile foundations of the Belgian offshore wind farm (OWF) Belwind I were acoustically profiled by means of a Doppler current profiler (ADCP). Together with the analysis of a bottom lander dataset of optical and acoustic backscatter sensors (OBSs and ADPs respectively), the spatiotemporal SPM plume dynamics were inferred. The fieldwork comprised (1) near-bed measurements of hydrodynamics and SPM concentrations in the direct vicinity of the wind turbines, by means of a bottom lander over a spring\u2013neap cycle in May 2010; this dataset represents a typically tide-driven situation because there was no significant meteorological forcing during the measurement period; (2) additional vessel-based measurements conducted in May 2013 to capture the SPM plumes inside and outside the OWF over part of a tidal cycle. Both in situ datasets revealed that the SPM plumes were generated at the turbine piles, consistent with aerial and space-borne imagery. The SPM plumes are well aligned with the tidal current direction in the wake of the monopiles, concentrations being estimated to reach up to 5 times that of the background concentration of about 3 mg\/l. It is suggested that the epifaunal communities colonizing the monopile surface and the protective rock collar at the base play a key role as source of the suspended matter recorded in the plumes. The organisms filter and trap fine SPM from the water column, resulting in predominant accumulation of SPM, including detritus and (pseudo-) faeces, at the base of the piles. When tidal currents exceed a certain velocity, fine particles in the near-bed fluff layer are re-suspended and transported downstream in the wake of the piles.","author":["Fettweis, M.","Baeye, M."],"organization":["Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2015-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.410491000000","2.778979000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-09 06:42:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/688","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-role-offshore-structures-managing-potential-watersipora-invasions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/espis.boem.gov\/final%20reports\/BOEM_2019-001.pdf","title":"Understanding the Role of Offshore Structures in Managing Potential Watersipora Invasions","description":"The purpose of this study was to survey offshore oil and gas platforms in the Santa Barbara Channel\/Santa Maria Basin and San Pedro Basin, other artificial structures, and natural reefs for the non-native species Watersipora subatra (previously identified as Watersipora subtorquata), measure the reproductive seasonality of this species, and identify potential vectors for dispersal among platforms and between platforms and natural habitat. The need for this information is to elucidate the role that offshore artificial structures may have in affecting biological communities for use by the State of California in evaluating decommissioning options under California legislation AB 2503 (the California Marine Resources Legacy Act) and to comply with the duties of Federal agencies that are outlined in Section 2 of Executive Order 13112 (Invasive Species). BOEM will use study results for environmental reviews pertaining to ongoing operations and decommissioning alternatives of offshore oil and gas platforms and potential marine renewable energy facilities. This study also developed results applicable specifically for BSEE management decisions so that BSEE can specify requirements to industry or other interested parties when decommissioning occurs. Using the results, the State of California can ensure proper evaluation under the California Rigs-to-Reefs Program law AB 2503 (the California Marine Resources Legacy Act) and BSEE can ensure that specified criteria can be properly evaluated during the decommissioning process pursuant to the federal regulations at 30 CFR 250.1730.","author":["Dugan, J.","Miller, R.","Page, H.","Viola, S.","Simons, R."],"organization":["University of California Santa Barbara","BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.239672000000","-119.885022000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BOEM_2019-001.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/689","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/retrospective-outlook-environmentally-sound-development-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.iaras.org\/iaras\/home\/caijes\/retrospective-and-outlook-for-an-environmentally-sound-development-of-offshore-wind-energy","title":"Retrospective and Outlook for an Environmentally Sound Development of Offshore Wind Energy","description":"This article shows the state of knowledge regarding ecological impacts of offshore wind farms. It developed proposals for reforms and incorporated international developments into the research. These proposals are derived from the experiences of the first OWF projects in Germany and their obstacles in the approval procedures. Therefore consistent and international standards for environmental impact assessments, a focus on specific subjects of protection (i.e. some birds or harbor porpoises) are proposed. Further recommendations include applying research findings to spatial planning and technical mitigation measures and regulating resting impacts with marine compensation measures.","author":["L\u00fcdeke, J."],"organization":["Beuth University of Applied Science"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.084533000000","7.798050000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Cetaceans","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ludeke-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/690","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-offshore-wind-farms-belgian-part-north-sea-continued-move","sourceURL":"https:\/\/odnature.naturalsciences.be\/mumm\/en\/windfarms\/","title":"Environmental Impacts of Offshore Wind Farms in the Belgian Part of the North Sea: a Continued move towards Integration and Quantification","description":"The European Directive 2001\/77\/EC on the promotion of electricity produced from renewable energy sources, in the internal electricity market, imposes a target figure for the contribution of the production of electricity from renewable energy sources upon each Member State. For Belgium, this target figure is 13% of the total energy consumption, which must be achieved by 2020. Offshore wind farms in the Belgian part of the North Sea are expected to make an important contribution (ca. 43%, assuming 2000 MW installed capacity by 2020) to achieve that goal. Within the Belgian part of the North Sea (BPNS), a zone of 238 km\u00b2 is reserved for the production of electricity from water, currents or wind. Four wind farms are already operational. With five more to come, major ecological changes may however be expected. Prior to installing a wind farm, a developer must obtain a domain concession and an environmental permit. The environmental permit includes a number of terms and conditions intended to minimise and\/or mitigate the impact of the project on the marine ecosystem. Furthermore, as required by law, the permit imposes a monitoring programme to assess the effects of the project onto the marine environment. Within the monitoring programme, the Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences and its partners assess the extent of the anticipated impacts on the marine ecosystem and aim at revealing the processes behind these impacts. The first objective is basically tackled through the baseline monitoring, focusing on the a posteriori, resultant impact quantification, while the second monitoring objective is covered by targeted or process monitoring, focusing on cause-effect relationships of a priori selected impacts. As such, baseline monitoring deals with observing rather than understanding impacts and hence leads to area-specific results, which might form a basis for halting activities. This report, targeting marine scientists, marine managers, policy makers and offshore wind farm developers, presents an overview of the scientific findings of the Belgian offshore wind farm monitoring programme, based on data collected unto 2016.","author":["Degraer, S.","Rumes, B.","Brabant, R.","Vigin, L."],"organization":["Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.540075000000","2.782899000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Birds","Seabirds","Physical Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-09 05:46:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Degraer-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/691","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-farms-belgian-part-north-sea-selected-findings-baseline-targeted","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pure.ilvo.be\/ws\/portalfiles\/portal\/913663\/rapport2011.pdf","title":"Offshore Wind Farms in the Belgian Part of the North Sea: Selected findings from the baseline and targeted monitoring","description":"The new European Climate Plan, launched in 2008, imposes upon each member state a target contribution figure for the production of electricity from renewable energy sources that should be achieved by 2020. For Belgium, this target figure is 13 % of the total energy consumption, part of which will be realised in offshore waters. Since the Royal Decree of 17 May 2004 assigned a zone for the production of electricity in the Belgian part of the North Sea (BPNS), three companies, C-Power (Thorntonbank: 54 turbines, 325 MW), Belwind (Bligh Bank: 110 turbines, 330 MW) and Northwind (formerly: Eldepasco) (\u201cBank zonder Naam\u201d: 72 turbines, 216 MW), were granted a domain concession and an environmental permit to build and exploit an offshore wind farm. In 2009, early 2010, three other companies, Norther, Rentel and Seastar, obtained a concession, but so far only Norther is applying for an environmental permit. Both C-Power and Belwind started their construction phase, with six gravity based foundation (GBF) windmills on the Thorntonbank in 2008 (fully operational early 2009) and with 56 monopile windmills on the Bligh Bank in 2009 (fully operational in 2010), respectively.  To allow for a proper evaluation and auditing of the environmental impacts of offshore wind farms, the environmental permit includes a mandatory monitoring program to ensure (1) the ability to mitigate or even halt the activities in case of extreme damage to the marine ecosystem and (2) an understanding of the environmental impact of offshore wind farms to support policy, management and design of future offshore wind farms. The former objective is basically tackled through the baseline monitoring, focusing on the a posteriori, resultant impact quantification, while the latter monitoring objective is covered by the targeted or process monitoring, focusing on the cause-effect relationships of a priori selected impacts. As such, the baseline monitoring deals with observing rather than understanding impacts and hence leads to area-specific results, which might form a basis adjusting existing activities (or even halting activities, in case of extreme environmental damage). Targeted monitoring on the other hand deals with the understanding of the processes behind the impacts and hence leads to more generic results, which might form a sound basis for impact mitigation. For more details on baseline and targeted monitoring we refer to Degraer \u0026amp; Brabant (2009).  The monitoring program targets physical (i.e. hydro-geomorphology and underwater noise), biological (i.e. hard substratum epifauna, hard substratum fish, soft substratum macrobenthos, soft substratum epibenthos and fish, seabirds and marine mammals), as well as socio-economic (i.e. seascape perception and offshore renewables appreciation) aspects of the marine environment. The Management Unit of the North Sea Mathematical Models (MUMM) of the Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS) coordinates the monitoring and specifically covers hydro-geomorphology, underwater noise, hard substratum epifauna, radar detection of seabirds, marine mammals and socioeconomic aspects. In 2010, MUMM further collaborated with different institutes to complete the necessary expertise in the following domains: seabirds (Research Institute for Nature and Forest, INBO), soft substratum epibenthos and fish (Institute for Agricultural and Fisheries Research, ILVOFisheries), soft substratum macrobenthos and hard substratum fish (Marine Biology Research Group of Ghent University) and atmospheric noise (INTEC of Ghent University).","author":["Degraer, S.","Rumes, B.","Brabant, R."],"organization":["Management Unit of the North Sea Mathematical Models (MUMM)","Ghent University","Research Institute for Nature and Forest (INBO)","Flanders Research Institute for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (IVLO)","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.540075000000","2.782899000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Birds","Seabirds","Physical Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Fisheries","Marine Spatial Planning","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Noise","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-09 06:44:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/monwin_report_2011_final.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/692","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-offshore-wind-farms-belgian-part-north-sea-environmental-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/odnature.naturalsciences.be\/mumm\/en\/windfarms\/","title":"Environmental impacts of offshore wind farms in the Belgian part of the North Sea: Environmental impact monitoring reloaded","description":"Offshore renewable energy development in the Belgian part of the North Sea has matured since our previous report in 2013. At present, nine Belgian projects representing a capacity of 2.2 GW were granted both a domain concession and an environmental permit. Three projects are operational, one is under construction, and the last five will need to be constructed in the near future, if Belgium is to meet its 2020 targets for renewable energy. These latter include the Mermaid project, which will generate a certain amount of energy from waves as well as wind. By 2018-2019, the number of wind farms constructed will have doubled with the realization of the Nobelwind, Rentel and Norther projects. The latter will entail the installation of the largest individual turbines (8.4 MW \u2013 reaching 187 m above mean sea level) in our waters. The near future may also see the first co-use of wind farm zones with aquaculture projects being developed in the areas of the C-Power and Belwind wind farms. In the meanwhile the electricity grid is undergoing necessary reinforcements, both onshore with the Stevin project and offshore with the proposed shared connection or \u2018plugat-sea\u2019. In the adjacent Dutch wind farm zone, the Borssele project entails the installation of 1.4 GW of wind energy and the resultant transboundary wind energy zone requires both consistent management measures and a comprehensive environmental monitoring program that adequately assesses cumulative environmental impacts.  To allow for a proper evaluation and auditing of the environmental impacts of offshore wind farms, the environmental permit includes a monitoring program to ensure (1) the ability to mitigate or even halt the activities in case of severe damage to the marine ecosystem and (2) an understanding of the environmental impact of offshore wind farms to support policy, management and design of future offshore wind farms. The former is tackled mainly by the basic monitoring program, the latter by the so called targeted monitoring program. In 2014 the existing basic environmental monitoring program was evaluated and a decision was made to focus on integrating work on several ecosystem components and streamlining research efforts (see below, reloading basic environmental impact monitoring).  The monitoring program targets physical (i.e. hydro-geomorphology and underwater noise), biological (i.e. hard substrate epifouling and fish communities, soft substrate macrobenthos, epibenthos and fish, seabirds and marine mammals), as well as socio-economical (i.e. seascape perception and offshore renewables appreciation) aspects of the marine environment although not all components are yearly studied or extensively reported on. The Operational Directorate Natural Environment (OD Nature) of the Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences coordinates the monitoring and specifically covers hydro-geomorphology, underwater noise, hard substrate epifauna, radar detection of seabirds, marine mammals and socio-economic aspects. In 2014 and 2015, OD Nature further collaborated with different institutes to complete the necessary expertise in the following domains: seabirds (Research Institute for Nature and Forest, INBO), soft substrate epibenthos and fish (Institute for Agricultural and Fisheries Research, ILVO-Fisheries), and soft substrate macrobenthos (Marine Biology Research Group, Ghent University). For details on the specific research strategies followed and methodologies used, one is referred to the individual chapters.","author":["Degraer, S.","Rumes, B.","Brabant, R.","Vigin, L."],"organization":["Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.564667000000","2.799457000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Invertebrates","Birds","Physical Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Noise","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-09 06:41:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Degraer-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/693","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-impacts-offshore-wind-farms-well-being","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.offshorewindindustry.com\/sites\/default\/files\/ei-understanding-the-impacts-of-offshore-wind-farms-on-well-being.pdf","title":"Understanding the Impacts of Offshore Wind Farms on Well-Being","description":"This review aims to explore the positive and negative impacts arising from the UK offshore wind industry in terms of well-being. The emphasis is placed on objective measures of wellbeing relating to material living conditions, such as personal income and jobs, and issues relating to quality of life, such as health (OECD 2011). Drawing on both peer reviewed and grey literature, actual impacts of the offshore wind industry are reported, although anticipated future impacts are noted where relevant. As there is no established baseline against which change can be measured, in most cases only a qualitative assessment of the direction of change is possible; where quantitative information is available this is also reported. The framework developed for use in this review combines the five capitals model (Forum for the Future, 1990) and an ecosystem service approach (Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, 2003) with the Office for National Statistics well-being domains. The five capitals included are: financial, manufactured, human, social and natural capital. Governance is added as a structure in which decisions about the five capitals are made, but it is also an important driver of well-being. Natural capital is subdivided into provisioning, regulating and supporting, and cultural ecosystem services. The well-being domains included are: economy, what we do, where we live, personal well-being, education and skills, personal finance, health, our relationships, the natural environment and governance. How these capital stocks affect well-being is unclear but it is assumed that each of the well-being domains is impacted by changes in capital and that the relationship is positive, i.e. an increase (decrease) in capital will increase (decrease) well-being. The key findings from this assessment are summarised in the table below.","author":["Hooper, T.","Papathanasopoulou, E.","Hattam, C."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory","The Crown Estate"],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.276117200000","-5.754382000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hattam-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/694","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/oceanographic-biological-influences-recruitment-benthic-invertebrates-hard-substrata","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0272771417303773","title":"Oceanographic and biological influences on recruitment of benthic invertebrates to hard substrata on the Oregon shelf","description":"The number of anthropogenic substrata in the ocean \u2013 structures like oil rigs and offshore renewable energy generators \u2013 is increasing. These structures provide hard-bottom habitat in areas previously dominated by sand or mud, so they have the potential to alter species distributions or serve as \u201cstepping-stones\u201d between other hard-bottom habitats. It is thus important to understand what factors influence the composition and abundance of benthic fauna recruiting at these sites. We examined recruitment to hard substrata (fouling panels) deployed on sand at various distances from a large rocky reef (\u223c60 m isobath) on the southern Oregon coast in 2014\u20132015. Recruitment was dominated by the acorn barnacle Hesperibalanus hesperius. For the majority of the study period in 2014, an anti-cyclonic eddy was present near the deployment sites. However, anomalously high recruitment of H. hesperius during August \u2013 early October 2014 coincided with dissipation of the eddy, slower bottom currents, and a positive convergence index, suggesting that H. hesperius larvae from the adjacent area may have been accumulated and retained near our study sites. Other sessile species, including hydroids and bryozoans, recruited to the fouling panels in low abundances, and most of these species have long-range dispersal and fast growth. Mobile invertebrates observed on the fouling panels included gastropods and nudibranchs, most of which also have long-range dispersal and fast growth, and are predators as adults. Thus, a community with two trophic levels assembled on the fouling panels in a relatively short time period (\u0026lt;12 weeks). None of the common hard-bottom species from the adjacent rocky reef recruited to the panels, suggesting that there is a specialized assemblage of species that can exploit hard-bottom habitats surrounded by sandy plains. Our results raise many questions about the influences of dispersal and oceanographic conditions on recruitment to hard substrata.","author":["Meyer, K.","Li, Y.","Young, C."],"organization":["University of Oregon","Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.125689000000","-124.435956000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/695","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/low-genetic-connectivity-fouling-amphipod-among-man-made-structures-southern-north-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v615\/p133-142\/","title":"Low genetic connectivity in a fouling amphipod among man-made structures in the southern North Sea","description":"Offshore environments are increasingly invaded by man-made structures that form hard-substrate habitats for many marine species. Examples include oil and gas platforms, wind turbines and shipwrecks. One of the hypothesised effects is an increased genetic connectivity among natural populations due to new populations growing on man-made structures that may act as stepping stones. However, few data are available on genetic connectivity among organisms inhabiting artificial offshore structures. Here, we present a study on the common fouling amphipod Jassa herdmani from offshore structures in the southern North Sea. Partial mitochondrial DNA sequences (cytochrome-c-oxidase 1, N = 514) were obtained from artificial structures at 17 locations in the southern North Sea, including 13 shipwrecks, 2 wind turbines and 2 platforms. Samples from these locations were significantly differentiated, meaning that strong population structure exists for this species in the area. Levels of intraspecific variation were consistent with stable population sizes. No evidence was found for isolation by distance. Using coalescent simulations, the oldest population subdivision events were estimated to date back to the time the study area was flooded following the Last Glacial Maximum. We therefore tentatively conclude that J. herdmani may have colonised man-made structures from previously existing populations on the sea floor, and that the increase in offshore installations has not led to an overall increase in genetic connectivity for this species.","author":["Coolen, J.","Beermann, J.","Luttikhuizen, P.","Crooijmans, R.","Jak, R."],"organization":["Utrecht University","Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","Helmholtz Institute for Functional Marine Biodiversity (HIFMB)","Wageningen University and Research Centre","IMARES - Wageningen UR"],"originationDate":"2019-04-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.520309000000","3.667413000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/696","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthic-conservation-features-species-associated-subsea-pipelines-considerations","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2019.00200\/full","title":"Benthic Conservation Features and Species Associated With Subsea Pipelines: Considerations for Decommissioning","description":"Oil and gas pipelines that lie exposed on the seabed can function as \u201cartificial reefs,\u201d providing habitat for fish and benthic species, including some that are listed under conservation designations. As the offshore hydrocarbon industry matures, operators and national governments must decide whether decommissioned pipelines should be left in situ or removed for onshore disposal. In most jurisdictions, there is a requirement to evaluate the environmental consequences of different pipeline decommissioning options in a comparative assessment. To do this effectively requires an understanding of the associations between pipelines and fauna. Pipeline operators routinely collect video footage for inspection and maintenance purposes using remotely operated vehicles (ROV). This footage has the potential to provide insight into interactions between the marine environment and offshore pipelines. This study uses inspection footage from eight pipelines to quantify the presence and abundance of species and features listed under a number of EU and United Kingdom conservation designations; 12 such features and species were observed on the pipelines or neighboring sediments. The soft coral Alcyonium digitatum was present in the highest densities on pipelines located on mud, while Sabellaria sp. and Echinus esculentus were more common on pipelines in sand. Gadoids, anemones and hermit crabs were also frequently observed around pipelines. The study identifies the limitations to the use of industry ROV footage for ecological purposes, but shows that with consideration of taxon size, image resolution, ROV speed and altitude, this can be a valuable approach to gain additional insights into environment-infrastructure interactions. The results suggest that removal of pipelines will remove established colonies of epibenthic species, some of which have conservation value. The ecological significance of this loss, however, must be weighed against the broader considerations during pipeline decommissioning including cost, technical feasibility and impacts to other marine users.","author":["Wilding, T.","Rouse, S.","Lacey, N.","Hayes, P."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2019-04-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.915631000000","-0.541368000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/697","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-application-low-cost-rapid-assessment-system-coastal-benthic-habitats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007%2Fs10661-019-7808-2#citeas","title":"Development and application of a low-cost rapid assessment system for coastal benthic habitats","description":"Information on community structure and spatial distribution of benthic habitats are important in marine conservation and management. Coral areas, often monitored by trained scuba divers, are of importance for the ecosystem goods and services they provide. The data gathered may, however, be limited due to cost and time constraints. These restrictions and the continuing decline in coral reef health contribute to the need to develop rapid methods to efficiently document the distribution and status of coral reefs. A Rapid Assessment Instrument for Coastal Benthic Habitats (ARAICoBeH) System was developed to enable large-scale but low-cost coastal benthic habitat characterization and mapping without compromising accuracy. Inquiries on community structure and status in coral-dominated areas are also possible with the data collected using the method. The instrument, as well as the data processing and mapping algorithm are described in detail in this paper. A comparative study was conducted between ARAICoBeH and the frequently used underwater photo transect method. Variables compared were percent coral cover, functional group diversity, community structure as well as time and monetary requirements. There were no significant differences in estimates of percent coral cover and diversity of benthic functional groups for majority of sites while estimates of community structure were very similar. ARAICoBeH is cheaper and requires less time to gather the same amount of data as that of the photo transect method. The spatial distribution of coastal benthic habitats and community structure of coral-dominated areas in El Nido, Palawan, Philippines, are included to illustrate the application of the method.","author":["Benjamin, C.","Cadeli\u00f1a, P.","Y\u00f1iguez, A.","Villanoy, C."],"organization":["University of the Phiippines","Technische Universitat Munchen"],"originationDate":"2019-09-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["13.934445800000","120.424257300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/698","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/oil-gas-platforms-artificial-substrates-epibenthic-north-sea-fauna-effects-location","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S138511011830279X","title":"Oil and gas platforms as artificial substrates for epibenthic North Sea fauna: Effects of location and depth","description":"Offshore oil and gas platforms, shipwrecks and wind farms are known to act as artificial reefs, attracting a broad range of marine species such as algae, invertebrate species and fish. Using Remotely Operated Vehicle (ROV) videos made for technical inspection of eight Dutch and nine Danish oil and gas platforms, we characterize the abundance and diversity of invertebrates and fish species found on or around these artificial hard substrates. Dutch platforms located in the southern part of the North Sea were at depths ranging from 26 to 46\u202fm, whereas Danish platforms located about 400\u202fkm further north were deeper (40\u201366\u202fm). A total of 38 taxa were identified. The most common species were Mytilus edulis (Mollusca), Metridium senile (Cnidaria) and Asterias rubens (Echinodermata). One non-indigenous species was identified: Mnemiopsis leidyi (Ctenophora). A significant clustering of species communities was found based on geographical location: a southern cluster close to the Dutch shoreline and a northern cluster near Denmark (p\u202f=\u202f.01). Species diversity was not significantly different between geographical clusters; however, average Braun-Blanquet abundance was significantly higher on in the northern cluster (p\u202f\u0026lt;\u202f.05). Invertebrate and fish communities did not change significantly with depth. However, depth zone was a significant clustering factor (p\u202f=\u202f.01): communities closer to the seafloor (maximum depth minus 5\u202fm) were characterized by higher species diversity and species richness compared to communities found closer to the surface (\u0026lt;10\u202fm). Future research should focus on the potential role of habitat complexity, substrate orientation and type, and inter-specific relations in explaining the different communities on offshore platforms.  Highlights:    ROV inspection videos provide insight in epibenthic community structure in North Sea.  Hierarchical clustering identifies a northern and southern geographical cluster.  Bathymetry further divides clusters in a bottom, intertidal and intermediate zone.  Non-indigenous species Mnemiopsis leidyi is identified.","author":["Lengkeek, W.","Coolen, J.","Bos, O.","Schutter, M.","Dorenbosch, M.","Driessen, F."],"organization":["Bureau Waardenburg bv","IMARES - Wageningen UR","Wageningen University and Research Centre"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.468700000000","5.133600000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/699","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecological-best-practice-decommissioning-review-scientific-research","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article-abstract\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsy130\/5107800","title":"Ecological best practice in decommissioning: a review of scientific research","description":"The Oslo and Paris Commissions (OSPAR) decision 98\/3 prohibits the dumping of man-made structures (MMS) offshore. However, there are regions of the world where MMS are recognized as providing an ecological and societal benefit through the provision of ecosystem goods and services. This review provides a commentary on our current understanding of the ecological influence of man-made structures, the consequences of their decommissioning and recognizes that our knowledge is far from complete. It is known that a diverse and complex ecosystem of attached organisms develops on submerged structures which supports a localized food web that could not exist without them. However, our lack of detailed information makes modelling of system response to decommissioning very tentative. Ideally, we should use the best possible scientific information to reach a consensus as to whether the blanket removal of MMS (excepting derogations) is the most environmentally supportable option. The evidence available to-date shows both benefits and some risk in leaving MMS in place and this needs to be examined without preconception. On the UKCS, MMS as artificial habitats are not considered under the Habitats Directive, irrespective of the value or rarity of the species present. We conclude that a more comprehensive regulatory process, together with the recognition of the ecology associated with man-made structures, would allow science to play a role in the decision-making rather than supporting a blanket policy ignoring ecological context.","author":["Fortune, I.","Paterson, D."],"organization":["University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2020-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/700","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-artificial-structures-estuarine-infaunal-communities-offshore-biofouling","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.library.oregonstate.edu\/concern\/graduate_thesis_or_dissertations\/8g84mp74n?locale=en","title":"The Effects of Artificial Structures on Estuarine Infaunal Communities and Offshore Biofouling Communities","description":"For hundreds of years, coastal and marine ecosystems have experienced increasing threats due to the cumulative effects of increasing population growth and dependence on these ecosystems. Thus, there has been increased enthusiasm to mitigate the negative effects of human actions through the use of cleaner sources of energy, like marine renewable energy (MRE). The U.S. West Coast shows potential for tidal, wave, and offshore wind energy. Concern about MRE deployments has motivated research on the environmental effects of these new man-made hard structures in the ocean. Although this kind of development is relatively new in the U.S, placing man-made hard structure in coastal and marine ecosystems around the world has shown to create new habitat for algae, invertebrates, and fish and create foraging opportunities for birds and mammals, eventually becoming an artificial reef. The overall goal of my research was to use existing artificial structures to investigate a few specific effects of MRE development in Oregon waters. My research had two components: to assess the extent to which soft-sediment habitats are influenced by the presence of artificial structures deployed in Yaquina Bay, OR, and to characterize the biofouling communities present on bottom and surface artificial structures deployed offshore. Previous research indicates artificial structures modify sediment composition by increasing the erosion around a structure and that there is a close link between infaunal communities and sediment composition. Grain size analyses confirmed artificial structures change the physical environment around them, although these differences were not sufficient to cause a visible change in infaunal communities. Sediment characteristics also did not explain the greater infaunal abundances, mainly of Capitellidae polychaetes, closer to the structures than further away. Results indicated there were significant differences in sediment characteristics between locations in Yaquina Bay, most likely because of the greater amount of fine sediment at the sites located further upstream than those located closer to the mouth of the estuary. These differences in sediment characteristics appeared to be large enough to see a grouping of infaunal communities with location in Yaquina Bay. This study provided additional evidence that artificial structures alter their physical environment, but these structures and physical effects did not change the composition of the infaunal communities after a period of eight years. Assessing the biofouling cover on the offshore bottom and surface artificial structures showed that after a period of two years, the biofouling communities on the offshore bottom structures mostly consisted of balanoid barnacles, which resulted in little biomass. The bottom structures appeared to have been tipped over during their time in the water, potentially preventing the biofouling communities from developing more. In contrast, the surface artificial structures had greater overall cover, although cover mostly consisted of algae and gooseneck barnacles. Mussels, amphipods, crabs, and bivalves were found within the algae demonstrating the additional structure provided by the algae supported a greater variety of organisms on the surface structure. This study provided a \u201csnapshot\u201d of possible biofouling communities on offshore artificial structures, but longitudinal studies would enable us to monitor the development of the biofouling communities on these structures to better understand the mechanisms that caused the observed biofouling communities. Conducting these studies in an estuarine environment where in-stream tidal energy could be developed and in an offshore environment where wave energy devices would be deployed supplies greater specific knowledge about the possible effects of MRE devices in Oregon waters and also demonstrates the importance of site-specific research.","author":["Mendoza, M."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2016-08-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.617122000000","-124.020707000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/701","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-converters-biofouling-review-impacts-prevention","sourceURL":"https:\/\/hal.archives-ouvertes.fr\/hal-01199624\/document","title":"Marine Renewable Energy Converters and Biofouling: A Review on Impacts and Prevention","description":"In recent years, a number of studies have been performed to assess the damages caused by biofouling, which is simply the attachment of organisms to a surface in contact with water for a period of time. This explanation sounds fairly straightforward, but there are several organisms that cause biofouling, many different types of affected surfaces, and therefore many solutions dealing with this problem. Regarding the marine renewable energy emerging and promising area of research, this paper aims to provide a review of the biofouling issue in the context of Marine Renewable Energy Converters (MRECs). The proposed review will specifically highlight biofouling impacts on MRECs and solutions to prevent fouling. In addition, a discussion will highlight challenges that MRECs market needs to undertake to overcome the biofouling problem.","author":["Titah-Benbouzid, H.","Benbouzid, M."],"organization":["Universit\u00e9 de Bretagne Occidentale"],"originationDate":"2015-09-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/TITAH-BENBOUZID-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/702","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/placing-green-energy-sea-offshore-wind-farms-dolphins-oysters-territorial-politics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/24694452.2019.1625749?journalCode=raag21","title":"Placing Green Energy in the Sea: Offshore Wind Farms, Dolphins, Oysters, and the Territorial Politics of the Intertidal Zone in Taiwan","description":"The development of offshore wind farms has been a way for the state to repackage national development projects using green energy discourses. In Taiwan, where the further development of nuclear power is suspended due to public antinuclear sentiment, offshore wind farms have been heavily promoted as a way of meeting electricity demand. The planned site for offshore wind farms, mainly the intertidal zone along the coast of Changhua County, overlaps with both oyster farms and the habitat of Taiwanese humpbacked dolphins, categorized as a critically endangered species by the International Union for Conservation of Nature. This has resulted in a clash between conserving the oyster farming landscape, protecting an endangered species, and developing green energy. Facing this dilemma, pro\u2013wind farm discourses that highlight concerns about global climate change have gradually supplanted those stressing the welfare of oysters and dolphins, even though the latter have been used successfully as local icons by movements opposing previous development projects on the intertidal zone. This article reconsiders the politics of territorialization implied by the \u201cgreen\u201d label affixed to offshore wind farm projects and other forms of green energy in general. As such, the meaning of offshore wind farms, as a newly discovered energy resource, is intertwined with the changing meanings of both dolphins and oyster farms, as rival nonhuman objects of resource exploitation and natural conservation. The territorialization of such resources in the emerging discursive space of green energy has proceeded via relational placemaking with nonlinear connections among multiple human and nonhuman elements.","author":["Hung, P."],"organization":["National Taiwan University"],"originationDate":"2019-08-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["23.961249000000","120.494682000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/703","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-ocean-energy-technologies-systematic-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2077-1312\/7\/9\/322","title":"Life Cycle Assessment of Ocean Energy Technologies: A Systematic Review","description":"The increase of greenhouse gases (GHG) generated by the burning of fossil fuels has been recognized as one of the main causes of climate change (CC). Different countries of the world have developed new policies on national energy security directed to the use of renewable energies mainly, ocean energy being one of them. The implementation of ocean energy is increasing worldwide. However, the use of these technologies is not exempt from the generation of potential environmental impacts throughout their life cycle. In this context, life cycle assessment (LCA) is a holistic approach used to evaluate the environmental impacts of a product or system throughout its entire life cycle. LCA studies need to be conducted to foster the development of ocean energy technologies (OET) in sustainable management. In this paper, a systematic review was conducted and 18 LCA studies of OET were analyzed. Most of the LCA studies are focused on wave and tidal energy. CC is the most relevant impact category evaluated, which is generated mostly by raw material extraction, manufacturing stage and shipping operations. Finally, the critical stages of the systems evaluated were identified, together with, the opportunity areas to promote an environmental management for ocean energy developers.","author":["G\u00fcereca, L.","Paredes, M.","Padilla-Rivera, A."],"organization":["National Autonomous University of Mexico","Universidad de Monterrey","Universit\u00e9 de Montr\u00e9al"],"originationDate":"2019-09-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-09-02 02:22:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Paredes_et_al_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/704","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sight-mind-social-implications-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.era.lib.ed.ac.uk\/handle\/1842\/35911","title":"In sight and in mind: social implications of marine renewable energy","description":"Scotland has significant marine energy resources and is at the forefront of the research and development of wave and tidal marine renewable energy technologies. Much of this research has focussed on the technological challenges of marine renewable energy (MRE) development, and accordingly there has been an important gap in understanding the social implications of the technology. This PhD contributes important new knowledge to the emerging field of the sociology of marine renewable energy. Previous studies have explored the many and varied grounds on which publics might come to support or oppose other low-carbon energy technologies, though to date there has been limited research into whether the same range of factors also inform social responses to MRE. This thesis presents new understanding of social responses towards MRE projects and the social impacts MRE may have on communities. Findings from eighteen months of ethnographic fieldwork, living, working, and coastal skiff rowing, on a Scottish island are presented, along with the results from a series of public dialogue workshops held in six Scottish communities. This innovative twin-track qualitative research approach provides a rich understanding of everyday life and practice in relation to community, environment and energy, and insight into some of the more intangible ways in which MRE projects may affect communities. The research shows that the strong and unique cultural and historical identity of coastal communities, together with the economic fragility of the areas, influences how MRE, and those promoting it, are perceived. Responses to energy projects depend on the perception of change that will occur as a result of the project and vary significantly both within and between communities. The data obtained show that MRE projects that are perceived to positively benefit the local area are welcomed, and that project developers and policy makers should focus as much on ameliorating positive benefits to communities as mitigating negative impacts. Planning processes that appropriately understand and negotiate these concerns are therefore required, in order to engage with communities and maximise the potential opportunities that MRE technologies present for marginal rural communities.","author":["Howell, R."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2019-07-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.351183000000","-4.908582000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/705","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-projections-climate-change-mitigation-analysis-uncertainty-errors","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118307341","title":"Renewable energy projections for climate change mitigation: An analysis of uncertainty and errors","description":"Failures of countries to set and achieve renewable energy targets are prevalent, producing uncertainty as to the possibility of renewable energy contributing to a reduction in global emissions. Lack of policy and incorrect modelling analyses are among the sources of these failures and understanding these two sources is crucial for improving confidence in renewables. We assess errors in projections pertaining to the capacity and production of renewable energy in the United States and those countries of the European Union that have strong commitments to green energy supply. Our results show that solar energy has the lowest level of uncertainty as it has the most achievable capacity projections. However, other renewables entail more attractive policies and further research is needed for the advancement of reliable technology and accurate weather predictions. Our findings also provide ranges for the projection uncertainties for six renewable energy technologies, drawing attentions to ways that the dominant errors in these renewable energy projections may be rectified.","author":["Indra al Irsyad, M.","Halog, A.","Nepal, R."],"organization":["University of Queensland","Massey University","Australian National University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/706","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/research-frontiers-sustainable-development-energy-water-environment-systems-time","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S019689041930929X","title":"Research frontiers in sustainable development of energy, water and environment systems in a time of climate crisis","description":"Sustainable energy conversion and management processes increasingly require an integrated approach, especially in the context of addressing the climate crisis. This editorial puts forth related research frontiers based on 28 research articles of the special issue that is dedicated to the 13th Conference on Sustainable Development of Energy, Water and Environment Systems and regional series based on the 1st Latin American and 3rd South East European Conferences. Seven research frontiers are reviewed, the first three of which are (i) sustainable technologies for local energy systems, (ii) energy storage and advances in flexibility and (iii) solar energy penetration across multiple sectors. These research frontiers contain contributions based on renewable energy for wastewater treatment in islands, energy savings across urban built infrastructure, advanced district heating and cooling networks, power-to-gas and hydrogen production technologies, demand response in industrial systems, hybrid thermal energy storage, hybrid solar energy power plants, novel photovoltaic thermal technologies, and improved solar energy dispatchability. The research frontiers continue with (iv) wind, water based energy and the energy-water nexus, (v) effective valorization and upgrading of resources, (vi) combustion processes and better utilization of heat and (vii) carbon capture, storage and utilization. Significant contributions include innovative wind and hydrokinetic turbines, osmotic power technologies, synergetic solutions for water desalination, efficient catalytic pyrolysis, upgrading to reduce particle pollution, co-processing for alternative fuels, combustion characterization, electricity generation from waste heat sources, advances in heat exchangers and heat transfer, oxy-fuel combustion, post-combustion capture, and fly ash recycling for energy storage material. The research frontiers in this editorial provide ample opportunities to support societal transformations in the next decades to sustain planetary life-support systems.","author":["Rosen, M.","Kraja\u010di\u0107, G.","Wang, Q.","K\u0131lk\u0131\u015f, \u015e.","Dui\u0107, N.","Montorsi, L.","Ahmad Al-Nimr, M."],"organization":["The Scientific and Technological Research Council of Turkey","University of Zagreb","University of Zagreb","University of Modena and Reggio Emilia","Xi\u0027an Jiaotong University","University of Ontario Institute of Technology","Qatar University","Jordan University of Science and Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/707","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-near-future-wave-energy-resources-black-sea-under-two-climate-scenarios","sourceURL":"https:\/\/sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148119305762","title":"Evaluation of the near future wave energy resources in the Black Sea under two climate scenarios","description":"The objective of this study is to evaluate the near future wave power resources (2021\u20132050) in the Black Sea, based on the results coming from a wave modelling system forced with wind fields provided by a Regional Climate Model (RCM). Such wind fields have been produced in the framework of the EURO-CORDEX experiment. They cover the entire European domain and have a resolution of 0.11\u00b0. Two different wind fields are considered in the wave model simulations, according to two Representative Concentration Pathways (RCPs) scenarios, namely RCP4.5 and RCP8.5. The SWAN (Simulating Waves Nearshore) model, which has been implemented over entire the Black Sea basin, is considered for the wave energy predictions. Furthermore, in order to estimate the impact of climate change on the wave energy resources in the Black Sea basin, the results obtained in the near future 30-year period (covering the early 21st century) are compared with historical data. These are the wave energy resources resulted from SWAN model simulations performed also for a 30-year (1976\u20132005) time-slice. Thus, these historical wave energy resources are obtained using historical RCM wind fields to force the wave model. The results show an increase in the range 0.05\u20130.18\u202fkW\/m (a rise of 5\u201316%) of the mean wave power under RCP4.5 scenario in almost all the western part of the Black Sea and also in the north-eastern area, while under RCP8.5 is quite double in. On the other hand, the linear regressions fitted to the annual means computed to each 30-year time-slice in 8 reference points did not indicate significant trends.","author":["Rusu, L."],"organization":["Dunarea de Jos University of Galati"],"originationDate":"2019-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.492568000000","34.292436000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/708","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/30-year-projection-future-wind-energy-resources-coastal-environment-black-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148119302368","title":"A 30-year projection of the future wind energy resources in the coastal environment of the Black Sea","description":"The objective of the present work is to evaluate the wind energy resources in the coastal environment of the Black Sea by providing a reliable projection for the next 30 years. The wind power is assessed for water depths in the range 25\u2013125 m. The wind speeds considered are those provided by the Rossby Centre regional atmospheric model, version (RCA4) and predicted under the Representative Concentration Pathway (RCP) scenarios 4.5 and 8.5 used in Climate Model Intercomparison Project phase 5 (CMIP5). The time interval is 2021\u20132050, the wind speeds having a spatial resolution of 0.11\u00b0, with 6-h temporal resolution. An analysis of the historical data provided by these climatic wind models performed for the 30-year time interval 1976\u20132005 shows reliable results in the basin of the Black Sea. This gives a reasonable degree of confidence for the model results corresponding to the 30-year future time window considered, providing at the same time a mean of comparison with the future wind climate Although from the point of view of the wave energy, the Black Sea cannot be considered with high potential, especially when compared to the ocean coasts, as regards the wind power resources the potential of this coastal environment is in line with other coastal areas where such marine wind farms already successfully operate. Finally, it can be concluded that the present work provides a comprehensive and useful picture of the future wind energy resources in the coastal environment of the Black Sea as well as on the changes expected in the wind climate.","author":["Rusu, E."],"organization":["Dunarea de Jos University of Galati"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.524374000000","34.294634000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/709","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-science-magazine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Ocean-Science-2019\/","title":"Ocean Science Magazine","description":"Articles:\nConducting and Applying Acoustics Research at BOEM\nUsing Acoustics as a Tool to Study Biological and Physical Phenomena in the Ocean\nVerifying the Physical Sources of Marine Species\nKeeping up with the Lates Developments in Marine Acoustics\nSpotlight on the BOEM Acoustics Team","author":["Plummer, M.","Brown, W.","Staaterman, E.","Cluck, R.","Cruickshank, W.","Damour, M.","McPherson, S.","Romero, J.","Weisskohl, M."],"organization":["Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Physical Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/710","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-climate-change-wind-energy-power-four-wind-farms-spain","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148119309632","title":"Impacts of climate change on wind energy power \u2013 Four wind farms in Spain","description":"There is a growing interest on how climate change may affect the energy sector, including changes in wind energy generation. This paper builds on existing research adding an economic component that considers how climate change can affect operating margins and investment values in specific wind farms in Spain. A projection of wind speed was carried out using an ensemble of three climate models, two scenarios (RCP 4.5 and 8.5) and two time periods (2018\u20132041 and 2042\u20132065) per plant. Using historical power curves, the changes in wind speed were converted to production output. The results show variations in production of up to 8% and changes in operating margins up to 10%. Seasonal generation may fluctuate as well, with an increase in summer and decrease in winter. An investment analysis was also conducted to consider how climate change may influence future developments in the sector.","author":["Solaun, K.","Emilio, C."],"organization":["University of Navarra","Complutense University of Madrid"],"originationDate":"2020-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.604398000000","-3.168251000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/711","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/best-available-science-are-noaa-fisheries-marine-mammal-noise-exposure-guidelines-date","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/2.0001003","title":"Best available science? Are NOAA Fisheries marine mammal noise exposure guidelines up to date?","description":"NOAA Fisheries employs a set of in-water noise exposure guidelines that establish regulatory thresholds for ocean actions that impact marine mammals. These are established based on two impact criteria: Level A \u2013 a physiological impact including \u201cPermanent Threshold Shift\u201d (PTS), and\/or tissue damage, and\/or mortality, and Level B \u2013 a behavioral impact or disruption. Recently the Level A exposure thresholds were reconciled to the frequency-dependent hearing sensitivities of five classes of marine mammals based on work done more than a decade ago (Southall et al. 2007). Since that time much more work has been published on behavioral impacts of various noise exposures, and consideration of more variables such as frequency-dependent noise propagation characteristics, cumulative, concurrent, and continuous exposures, and noise impacts on marine soundscapes have entered into the discussion \u2013 but have not been incorporated into the NOAA Fisheries guidelines.","author":["Stocker, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-05-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Pinnipeds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Stocker-2019-NOAA-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/712","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/exposure-benthic-invertebrates-sediment-vibration-laboratory-experiments-outdoor","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/2.0000324","title":"Exposure of benthic invertebrates to sediment vibration: From laboratory experiments to outdoor simulated pile-driving","description":"Activities directly interacting with the seabed, such as pile-driving, can produce vibrations that have the potential to impact benthic invertebrates within their vicinity. This stimuli may interfere with crucial behaviors such as foraging and predator avoidance, and the sensitivity to vibration is largely unknown. Here, the responsiveness of benthic invertebrates to sediment vibration is discussed in relation to laboratory and semi-field trials with two marine species: the mussel (Mytilus edulis) and hermit crab (Pagurus bernhardus). Sensory threshold curves were produced for both species in controlled laboratory conditions, followed by small-scale pile-driving exposures in the field. The merits of behavioral indicators are discussed, in addition to using physiological measures, as a method of determining reception and measuring responses. The measurement and sensors required for sediment vibration quantification are also discussed. Response and threshold data were related to measurements taken in the vicinity of anthropogenic sources, allowing a link between responsiveness and actual operations. The impact of pile-driving on sediment-dwelling invertebrates has received relatively little research, yet the data here suggest that such activities are likely to impact key coastal species which play important roles within the marine environment.","author":["Elliott, M.","Radford, A.","Bruintjes, R.","Simpson, S.","Roberts, L.","Breithaupt, T.","Harding, H.","Voellmy, I."],"organization":["University of Hull","University of Bristol","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.130846000000","-1.507855000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Roberts-2016-Sediment-Vibrations.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/713","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-behavioral-impacts-aquatic-noise-crustaceans","sourceURL":"","title":"Review on behavioral impacts of aquatic noise on crustaceans","description":"This review identified eleven peer-reviewed articles on behavioral impacts of noise on aquatic crustaceans, examining one freshwater species and several marine species, of which all are decapod crustaceans. Research incorporated noise sources such as low-frequency pile driving and airgun exploitation for seismic surveys, ship, and boat noise as well as white noise and pure tones. The studies suggest a variety of biological and ecological impacts ranging from increase in some behaviors (for instance locomotion) and stress, reduced and slower antipredator behavior, changes in foraging, suppressed behaviors with an ecological function (bioirrigation), and changes to intraspecific behavior (for instance agonistic encounters). More research on crustaceans and clearer reporting on the methods used to expose them to noise during experiments are needed. This would allow for consistent methods and ready comparison of results across studies.","author":["Tidau, S.","Briffa, M."],"organization":["Plymouth University","Galway-Mayo Institute of Technology (GMIT)"],"originationDate":"2016-12-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tidau-2016-Crustaceans.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/714","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-exposure-animals-acoustic-disturbance-towards-understanding-population","sourceURL":"","title":"Assessing the exposure of animals to acoustic disturbance: Towards an understanding of the population consequences of disturbance","description":"An essential component of risk assessment is identification whether individuals will be exposed to a risk. This requires information on the proportion of the population exposed, for how long, and during what activity (i.e., feeding, migrating, and breeding). Using satellite telemetry data for humpback and blue whales feeding and migratory regions in Antarctica, California, and Bering Sea, we modeled the potential exposure of individuals to an acoustic disturbance. Foraging and transit regions along the tracks were identified and the time spent foraging in each region calculated. A simulated seismic survey was randomly placed (100 iterations) within the habitat of each of species and the amount of time individual animals were exposed determined. A large disturbance (i.e. 100 km) only exposed 6% of the population of humpback whales in Antarctica and 19% blue whales off California. In contrast, humpback whales in the Bering Sea experienced high exposure with only a 5 km disturbance. This approach can be used to develop a framework for estimating the likelihood that a given animal population would be exposed to disturbance and to develop general risk assessment guidelines.","author":["Mate, B.","Costa, D.","H\u00fcckst\u00e4dt, L.","Schwarz, L.","Friedlaender, A.","Zerbini, A.","Kennedy, A.","Gales, N."],"organization":["University of California Santa Cruz","Oregon State University (OSU)","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)"],"originationDate":"2016-12-27","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Costa-2016-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/715","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/soundscape-characterization-dynamic-acoustic-environment-grand-passage-nova-scotia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/2.0000246","title":"Soundscape characterization in a dynamic acoustic environment: Grand Passage, Nova Scotia, a planned in-stream tidal energy site","description":"The marine environment in the Bay of Fundy hosts a dynamic and diverse soundscape that is a fundamental component of the local ecosystem. The emergence of new human marine activities and infrastructure, such as tidal turbine installations, introduces new sound sources that change or disrupt the existing acoustic environment, but the full extent of these changes is not well understood and is not predictable. To better evaluate the effects of future tidal energy development on the local soundscape in Grand Passage, Nova Scotia, a thorough understanding of the pre-development characteristics must be established. The present research seeks to identify existing anthropophony, biophony, and geophony, and to evaluate the underlying mechanisms contributing to geophonic variability. Passive acoustic measurements have been conducted using long-term moored omnidirectional hydrophones, a moored 5-channel array, and drifting hydrophone arrays, enabling identification of dominant signals and source direction, estimation of pseudonoise masking effects due to turbulent flow, and analysis of diurnal, daily, seasonal, and annual variability as well as spatial variability within the study area. This paper provides an overview of the dominant sound sources and discusses the effects of environmental forcing on soundscape characteristics.","author":["Hay, A.","Barclay, D.","Lombardi, A."],"organization":["Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2016-09-13","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.267736000000","-66.339676000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lombardi-2016-Soundscape.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/716","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-farm-wake-effect-stratification-coastal-upwelling","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1876610215021475","title":"Offshore Wind Farm Wake Effect on Stratification and Coastal Upwelling","description":"In this study, the interactions between an offshore wind farm, upper-ocean currents, and stratification are examined under shallow water conditions from a two-dimensional modeling standpoint. The modeling results from two numerical simulation runs provide new insights on the formation of downwind vortex streets and the adjustment of coastal processes, such as upwelling and stratification. The distorted farm-induced wind deficits are calculated by the concept of single- and multiple-wake models. By assuming farm geometry as a large rigid rectangle, the numerical results of a shallow water model demonstrate the formation of vortex shedding wakes in the downwind of the wind farm. The slice model simulation runs, as the second numerical experiment, will address the coastal upwelling and geostrophic adjustment of density fronts in the presence of wind farm effects over a sloping bathymetry. We apply gravity wave effects using a wave-dependent aerodynamic roughness length when assuming the wind farm as an array of multiple turbines. Despite dynamical differences between simulation runs assuming farm as a rigid element and those considering farm as a cluster of single turbines, the results show some aspects of the farm-induced modulations on the pycnocline displacements and on the spatial-temporal evolution of the coastal upwelling. Although each simulation run has a unique scientific focus, the overall achieved numerical results are greatly able to improve the understanding of physical coupling between the wind farms and upper ocean dynamical processes.","author":["Paskyabi, M."],"organization":["University of Bergen"],"originationDate":"2015-12-02","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/717","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-real-world-wind-turbine-deployments-local-mesoscale-climate","sourceURL":"https:\/\/agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1029\/2017JD028114","title":"The Influence of Real-World Wind Turbine Deployments on Local to Mesoscale Climate","description":"Paired simulations are conducted using the Weather Research and Forecasting model applied at convection permitting resolution in order to determine the impact of wind turbines (WTs) on the local to mesoscale climate. Using actual WT locations and a model of the effect of the WT rotor on the flow field, it is shown that while the presence of WT changes wind speeds (WSs) and near\u2010surface air temperature in 4\u2010km grid cells in which WTs are located, the impact at larger scales on near\u2010surface air temperature, specific humidity, the fluxes of latent and sensible heat, boundary layer heights, and precipitation is not significant in any season other than summer. During summer, the maximum pairwise difference in grid cell mean temperatures is 0.5\u00a0K and the maximum increase in near\u2010surface specific humidity is 0.4\u00a0g\/kg. However, a spatial average of the mean seasonal perturbation of air temperature by WT gives a net impact of","author":["Pryor, S.","Barthelmie, R.","Shepherd, T."],"organization":["Cornell University"],"originationDate":"2018-05-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.767764000000","-105.822747200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/718","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nonlocal-inadvertent-weather-modification-associated-wind-farms-central-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.hindawi.com\/journals\/amete\/2018\/2469683\/abs\/","title":"Nonlocal Inadvertent Weather Modification Associated with Wind Farms in the Central United States","description":"Local effects of inadvertent weather changes within and near wind farms have been well documented by a number of modeling studies and observational campaigns; however, the broader nonlocal atmospheric effects of wind farms are much less clear. The goal of this study is to determine whether wind farm-induced perturbations are able to evolve over periods of days, and over areas of thousands of square kilometers, to modify specific atmospheric features that have large impacts on society and the environment, specifically midlatitude and tropical cyclones. Here, an ensemble modeling approach is utilized with a wind farm parameterization to quantify the sensitivity of meteorological variables to the presence of wind farms. The results show that perturbations to nonlocal midlatitude cyclones caused by a wind farm are statistically significant, with magnitudes of roughly 1\u2009hPa for mean sea-level pressure, 4\u2009m\/s for surface wind speed, and 15\u2009mm for maximum 30-minute accumulated precipitation. Cyclone perturbation magnitude is also found to be dependent on wind farm size and location relative to the midlatitude cyclone genesis region and track.","author":["Lauridsen, M.","Ancell, B."],"organization":["Texas Tech University"],"originationDate":"2018-08-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.759967000000","-96.438941000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/719","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/connectivity-larval-stages-sedentary-marine-communities-between-hard-substrates","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41598-018-32912-2","title":"Connectivity of larval stages of sedentary marine communities between hard substrates and offshore structures in the North Sea","description":"Man-made structures including rigs, pipelines, cables, renewable energy devices, and ship wrecks, offer hard substrate in the largely soft-sediment environment of the North Sea. These structures become colonised by sedentary organisms and non-migratory reef fish, and form local ecosystems that attract larger predators including seals, birds, and fish. It is possible that these structures form a system of interconnected reef environments through the planktonic dispersal of the pelagic stages of organisms by ocean currents. Changes to the overall arrangement of hard substrate areas through removal or addition of individual man-made structures will affect the interconnectivity and could impact on the ecosystem. Here, we assessed the connectivity of sectors with oil and gas structures, wind farms, wrecks, and natural hard substrate, using a model that simulates the drift of planktonic stages of seven organisms with sedentary adult stages associated with hard substrate, applied to the period 2001\u20132010. Connectivity was assessed using a classification system designed to address the function of sectors in the network. Results showed a relatively stable overall spatial distribution of sector function but with distinct variations between species and years. The results are discussed in the context of decommissioning of oil and gas infrastructure in the North Sea.","author":["van der Molen, J.","Whomersley, P.","Garc\u00eda-Garc\u00eda, L.","Callaway, A.","Posen, P.","Hyder, K."],"organization":["Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)","Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research (NIOZ)","University of East Anglia"],"originationDate":"2018-10-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.546806000000","3.539360000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/720","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthic-production-energy-export-man-made-structures-softbottoms-does-it-matter","sourceURL":"https:\/\/epic.awi.de\/id\/eprint\/48137\/","title":"Benthic production and energy export from man-made structures to softbottoms: does it matter?","description":"Over the last decade, the installation and operation of extensive offshore wind farms led to a substantial increase in artificial substrates in the North Sea. Man-made structures (MMS) such as wind turbines, oil and gas rigs represent additional hard-substrate habitats in the areas of the North Sea that are predominantly characterized by soft sediments. Research on large offshore structures has identified a suite of unique effects ranging from biodiversity changes with repercussions on local ecosystem functioning to the provision of habitat for fouling communities, acting as stepping stones also for non-native species. Consequently, MMS might induce structural, functional and process-driven changes over various spatial and temporal scales, that are different from those expected for natural soft-bottom benthic systems. However, our current understanding of how ecological functioning might be modified by the addition of these MMSs is still scarce. Many ecosystem goods and services of the North Sea such as long-term carbon storage and natural resources (e.g. for fish, birds, mammals and finally humans) are intimately linked to the benthic system. Benthic invertebrates form the major food source for many commercially exploited fish species and thus the production (i.e. species energy that is turned into biomass) of benthic communities is of direct relevance for the food provisioning ecosystem service. In this study, production was calculated based on species populations as a quantification of energy flow and trophic interactions. The obtained results may thus provide clear signals for status and possible responses of populations and entire ecosystems to the introduction of MMS. The analysis included different datasets from various monitoring programmes of offshore wind farms and oil and gas rigs (i.e. the production and biomass of fouling communities and of natural soft-bottom community) from the Southern North Sea over several years. We analysed production changes due to environmental parameters and the presence of the structures in a meta-analysis. The analysis revealed clear modifications in the upper parts of MMSs, where the highest production values and potential biomass export to soft bottoms were detected. The outcome may thus represent a first step to disentangle the potential effects of additional biomass discharge from MMS on the ecological functioning of benthic systems.","author":["Degraer, S.","Dannheim, J.","Coolen, J.","Birchenough, S.","De Mesel, I.","Beermann, J.","Garcia, C."],"organization":["Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","Wageningen University and Research Centre","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/721","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-climate-coastline-response-dutch-coast-investigating-effect-large-scale-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.tudelft.nl\/islandora\/object\/uuid:5f45fba6-1149-46fc-a019-acf2cd0a373c","title":"Wave Climate and Coastline Response of the Dutch Coast: Investigating the effect of large-scale offshore wind farm developments in the North Sea","description":"To counteract the effect of climate change, a global agreement was put into force in 2016, aiming to limit the increase in average global warming and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. In that respect, European countries are investing in cleaner sources of energy and predominantly offshore wind, which has seen a rapid growth over the last years. The North Sea is a region suitable for developing offshore wind energy, given its strong wind climate and the relatively shallow waters. Many large-scale offshore wind farm (OWF) developments are currently ongoing in that region, while many more are planned and consented for the coming decades. The concept of large-scale OWF developments has spurred many discussions addressing its potential effect on the greater North Sea region. However, the long-term effect on the surrounding coastal areas has never been studied in detail. Especially for a low-lying country as the Netherlands, assessing the impact of large-scale OWFs is of great importance. This study aims at exploring the effect of future large-scale OWFs in the North Sea, focusing on the wave climate and the coastline response of the Dutch coast. Based on the roadmap for developing offshore wind energy until 2050, existing and future designated OWF areas are accounted in the North Sea region. The effect of OWFs on wind is introduced in a schematized way, with a constant decrease in wind speed of 20% inside the OWF areas, based on literature knowledge. Supplementary, based on the vision of creating an artificial energy island for storing and redistributing the wind farm generated electricity, a 5 km2 island is introduced, approximately 30 km away from the Dutch coast. The effect on the nearshore wave climate is studied using the numerical model SWAN, while the resulting effect on the alongshore morphology is assessed using coastline model Unibest-CL+. The impact of future OWFs on the nearshore wave climate is found to be dependent on the size, shape, orientation and distance from the coast of the individual wind farms. Results show a mean decrease in significant wave height in the order of 1 \u2013 2%. In addition, slight changes in wave direction are observed. The effect on wave climate reduces the alongshore sediment transport at the Dutch coast, by an order of 10% with respect to present values. This results in net-induced erosion, which requires nourishment. The study shows that the areas north of Zandvoort and Petten need the greatest nourishment volumes, in the range of 1.5 \u2013 2.5 m3\/m\/year. This is an additional 1% on the current annual nourishment volumes supplied along the Dutch coast. The underlying study has proved to be effective in quantifying the chain of effects of OWFs and identifying potential hot-spots along the Dutch coast. The knowledge acquired from these effects can be used to optimize future OWF planning in relation to coastline maintenance policies.","author":["Ballas, G."],"organization":["Delft University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2018-11-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.340007000000","4.738531000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/722","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-impact-climate-conditions-harnessing-coastal-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.e3s-conferences.org\/articles\/e3sconf\/abs\/2018\/40\/e3sconf_iccee2018_05010\/e3sconf_iccee2018_05010.html","title":"Assessing the Impact of Climate Conditions on Harnessing Coastal (Offshore) Wind Energy","description":"This study analyses the relationship among various climate factors and their effect on the wind power density available in a coastal region. Climate data from several offshore wind farms in the East Asian region is extracted to perform the calculations and analysis. Reasons for variations of climate parameters such as average wind speed, average temperature, air density, average pressure, average precipitation, average humidity and their influences on wind power generation are explored. It is expected that this study will help the investors to perform a feasibility study on the availability of wind energy at a certain nearshore area before setting up wind farms.","author":["Akter, S.","Loo, J.","Hannan, M."],"organization":["Newcastle University"],"originationDate":"2018-11-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/723","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/vegetation-cover-change-cesme-alacati-wind-power-plant-using-normalized-difference","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dergipark.org.tr\/en\/pub\/jieas\/issue\/40241\/479190","title":"Vegetation Cover Change of \u00c7e\u015fme Ala\u00e7at\u0131 Wind Power Plant Using Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI)","description":"The environmental impacts of wind power plants, one of the most widely used renewable energy sources in the world, are still being discussed. In this study, the effects of \u00c7e\u015fme Ala\u00e7at\u0131 Wind Power Plant on vegetation cover change are evaluated by using normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) between the pre and post-turbine periods. The satellite images of SPOT June 1996 and Pleiades June 2014 have been used for the analysis process. According to the results of the study; it has been determined that the presence of plants increased by 1.3% in the whole area including the health protection band. However, the results showed that the rate of plant presence has been decreased by 27.1 % in the main area excluding the health protection band. Only spatial changes and field studies were considered in evaluations for vegetation cover change.","author":["Balik, G.","Akta\u015f, E.","\u00d6na\u00e7, A.","Biri\u015f\u00e7i, T."],"organization":["Ege University"],"originationDate":"2017-09-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.289111000000","26.377816000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/724","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/detecting-wind-farm-impacts-local-vegetation-growth-texas-illinois-using-modis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2072-4292\/9\/7\/698","title":"Detecting Wind Farm Impacts on Local Vegetation Growth in Texas and Illinois Using MODIS Vegetation Greenness Measurements","description":"This study examines the possible impacts of real-world wind farms (WFs) on vegetation growth using two vegetation indices (VIs), the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) and Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI), at a ~250 m resolution from the MODerate resolution Imaging Spectroradimeter (MODIS) for the period 2003\u20132014. We focus on two well-studied large WF regions, one in western Texas and the other in northern Illinois. These two regions differ distinctively in terms of land cover, topography, and background climate, allowing us to examine whether the WF impacts on vegetation, if any, vary due to the differences in atmospheric and boundary conditions. We use three methods (spatial coupling analysis, time series analysis, and seasonal cycle analysis) and consider two groups of pixels, wind farm pixels (WFPs) and non-wind-farm pixels (NWFPs), to quantify and attribute such impacts during the pre- and post-turbine periods. Our results indicate that the WFs have insignificant or no detectible impacts on local vegetation growth. At the pixel level, the VI changes demonstrate a random nature and have no spatial coupling with the WF layout. At the regional level, there is no systematic shift in vegetation greenness between the pre- and post-turbine periods. At interannual and seasonal time scales, there are no confident vegetation changes over WFPs relative to NWFPs. These results remain robust when the pre- and post-turbine periods and NWFPs are defined differently. Most importantly, the majority of the VI changes are within the MODIS data uncertainty, suggesting that the WF impacts on vegetation, if any, cannot be separated confidently from the data uncertainty and noise. Overall, there are some small decreases in vegetation greenness over WF regions, but no convincing observational evidence is found for the impacts of operating WFs on vegetation growth.","author":["Zhou, L.","Xia, G."],"organization":["State University of New York"],"originationDate":"2017-07-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["31.520701000000","-98.318194700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/725","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/simulating-impacts-real-world-wind-farms-land-surface-temperature-using-wrf-model","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00382-019-04725-0","title":"Simulating impacts of real-world wind farms on land surface temperature using the WRF model: physical mechanisms","description":"A recent study shows that the current wind turbine parameterization in the weather research and forecasting (WRF) model can generally reproduce the satellite observed nighttime warming signal over wind farm (WF) regions over west central Texas, but also tends to produce a cooling effect in the WF downwind regions. The present study conducts a series of WRF simulations to further this research by addressing two fundamental questions: (i) what is the 3-D structure of simulated near-surface temperatures within and around WFs? (ii) what are the main physical mechanisms responsible for the simulated WF-induced temperature changes? Our results indicate that the WF-induced temperature changes are not only restricted to the surface but also can extend vertically to the hub-height level and horizontally in the downwind direction. The WF-induced change in sensible heat flux is the dominant factor for the simulated temperature changes at the surface, for both the warming signals over the WF region and the cooling signals behind it. Further diagnosis shows that the turbulent component of the wind turbine parameterization is responsible for the surface warming signal by enhancing vertical mixing while the momentum sink component is responsible for the surface cooling signal by enhancing near-surface thermal stratification. By analyzing the energy budget, we find two important physical processes that are critical to explain the simulated WF impacts on temperature: (i) vertical divergence of heat flux as parameterized in the planetary boundary layer scheme and (ii) resolved-scale 3-D temperature advection.","author":["Zhou, L.","Xia, G.","Minder, J.","Fovell, R.","Jimenez, P."],"organization":["State University of New York","National Center for Atmospheric Research"],"originationDate":"2019-03-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.294146300000","-102.316728800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/726","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-wind-turbines-impact-plant-community-properties-mountain-region","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.2478\/s11756-019-00333-9","title":"Do wind turbines impact plant community properties in mountain region?","description":"The emergence of renewable energy infrastructures calls for a better understanding of their impact on biodiversity. The aim of the present study was to investigate in a mountain region the impact of a wind turbine on plant communities in their vicinity. A field survey was conducted in a wind farm situated in the Southern Romanian Carpathians, five years after the turbines were installed. We tested for the effects of the presence of the turbine and the distance to the turbine on plant species richness, on five plant ecological indicators and on the quality of the pastures. Overall, 33 plant species belonging to 16 families were recorded, and among them 21 were recorded in both the presence and the absence of wind turbine. The presence of a turbine did not affect the structure of the plant community, as the majority of the plots exhibited similar plant species richness and composition. Finally, the values of the ecological indicators and the pasture quality were not altered by the presence of the turbine. Such analyses could be extended over longer time periods so as to capture potential long-term effects and by integrating other environmental factors such as microclimatic conditions or soil properties.","author":["P\u0103tru-Stupariu, I.","Calot\u0103, A.","Santonja, M.","Anastasiu, P.","Stoicescu, I.","Biri\u015f, I.","Stupariu, M.","Buttler, A."],"organization":["University of Bucharest","\u00c9cole polytechnique f\u00e9d\u00e9rale de Lausanne (EPFL)","Swiss Federal Research Institute WSL","Aix-Marseille University","University of Agronomic Sciences and Veterinary Medicine of Bucharest"],"originationDate":"2019-08-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.501161000000","24.250123000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/727","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-offshore-wind-farm-siting-criteria-using-international-delphi-method","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421517307231","title":"Developing offshore wind farm siting criteria by using an international Delphi method","description":"Previous research on offshore wind farm (OWF) siting has been dominated by studies centred on energy resources and profitability, human activities and acceptance. Recently, studies on environmental impacts of OWFs have emerged. Few studies have been carried out to discuss the issues comprehensively. This study develops a set of comprehensive OWF siting criteria; including the profitability, social, security and environmental considerations. It solicits expert opinions from academia and industry through an international Delphi method. Contrary to the typical consensus seeking in Delphi studies, it focuses on understanding the dissensus through a comprehensive discussion. We find that profitability and social considerations are the most commonly agreed siting criteria among the experts whereas environmental and security criteria receive less agreement. As OWFs move further offshore, we are concerned about the understanding of the associated environmental impacts, and how energy and marine policy affect the marine spatial planning and consenting process. Research must get ahead of the developments to provide a better understanding of the potential impacts and to guide the consenting and monitoring processes.\n\nHighlights:\nA comprehensive discussion of offshore wind farm siting criteria.\nCriteria include profitability, social, security and environmental aspects.\nProfitability and social aspects are the most commonly agreed siting criteria.\nEnvironmental and security aspects receive less agreement.\nA better understanding of environmental impacts is crucial for OWF development.","author":["Ho, L.","Lie, T.","Leong, P.","Clear, T."],"organization":["Auckland University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/728","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/vitamine-ena-framework-development-ecosystem-based-indicators-decision-makers","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096456911830591X","title":"Vitamine ENA: A framework for the development of ecosystem-based indicators for decision makers","description":"The Water Framework Directive (article 2, paragraph 21) as well as the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD, Descriptor 4) stress the need for assessing the quality of the structure and the functioning of ecosystems. The MSFD also underlines the urgent need for development, testing, and validation of ecosystem state indicators. Holistic function-based criteria and indicators as provided by Ecological Network Analysis (ENA) could be used to define and assess the \u2018Good Environmental Status\u2019 of marine ecosystems. This approach also feeds Ecosystem Based Management (EBM). ENA generally analyses the fluxes\u0027 quality of a single medium such as here the carbon fluxes in a food web and produces a number of useful metrics that indicate, inter alia, the total carbon flow through the system, the quality of the functioning of the system or the trophic efficiency of system. A short list of indices [i.e. Detritivory over Herbivory ratio (D\/H), Connectance Index (CI), Transfer Efficiency (TE) over trophic levels, System Omnivory Index (SOI), Finn\u0027s Cycling Index (FCI), relative Redundancy (R\/DC), Average Mutual Information (AMI) and Interaction Strength (IS)] is proposed for practical use. This paper presents a first framework for OSPAR Regional Sea Convention food web indicators based on ENA. These are presented here focusing on their applicability and what is needed for implementation, illustrating their potential use by case studies.  Highlights:    Ecosystem Based Management requires holistic ecological knowledge.  Ecological Network Analysis (ENA) provide holistic functioning-based indicators.  A list of ENA indices is presented and proposed for practical use.  ENA indices as guidelines to advice on regional monitoring programs.","author":["Heymans, J.","Raoux, A.","Tecchio, S.","Niquil, N.","Safi, G.","de Jonge, V.","Giebels, D.","Arroyo, N.","Preciado, I.","Sch\u00fcckel, U."],"organization":["Normandie Universit\u00e9","France Energies Marines","Erasmus University Rotterdam","Carl von Ossietzky Universitat Oldenburg","Instituto Espa\u00f1ol de Oceanograf\u00eda (IEO)","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","European Marine Board (EMB)","The Schleswig-Holstein Agency for Coastal Defence","SINAY - Maritime Data Solutions","University of Hull","University of Cantabria"],"originationDate":"2019-05-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-31 09:23:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/729","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/corridors-aliens-not-natives-effects-marine-urban-sprawl-regional-scale","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/ddi.12301","title":"Corridors for aliens but not for natives: effects of marine urban sprawl at a regional scale","description":"Aim:\u00a0The global sprawl of marine hard infrastructure (e.g. breakwaters, sea walls and jetties) can extensively modify coastal seascapes, but the knowledge of such impacts remains limited to local scales. We examined the regional\u2010scale effects of marine artificial habitats on the distribution and abundance of assemblages of ascidians, a key group of ecosystem engineer species in benthic fouling systems.\n\nLocation:\u00a0Five hundred kilometers of coastline in the North Adriatic Sea.\n\nMethods:\u00a0We sampled a variety of natural reefs, marine infrastructures and marinas, and tested hypotheses about the role of habitat type and location in influencing the relative distribution and abundance of both native and non\u2010indigenous species.\n\nResults:\u00a0Assemblages differed significantly between natural and artificial habitats and among different types of artificial habitats. Non\u2010indigenous species were 2\u20133 times more abundant on infrastructures built along sedimentary coastlines than on natural rocky reefs or infrastructures built close to rocky coastlines. Conversely, native species were twice as abundant on natural reefs than on nearby infrastructures and were scarce to virtually absent on infrastructures built along sedimentary coasts. The species composition of assemblages in artificial habitats was more similar to that of marinas than of natural reefs, independently of their location.\n\nMain conclusions:\u00a0Our results show that marine infrastructures along sandy shores disproportionally favour non\u2010indigenous over native hard bottom species, affecting their spread at regional scales. This is particularly concerning for coastal areas that have low natural densities of rocky reef habitats. We discuss design and management options to improve the quality as habitat of marine infrastructures and to favour their preferential use by native species over non\u2010indigenous ones.","author":["Airoldi, L.","Turon, X.","Perkol-Finkel, S.","Rius, M."],"organization":["University of Bologna","Stanford University","Centre d\u0027Estudis Avan\u00e7ats de Blanes (CEAB) - Higher Council of Scientific Investigations (CSIC)","SeArc - Ecological Marine Consulting","University of Southampton"],"originationDate":"2015-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.023079000000","12.683636000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Airoldi_et_al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/730","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatiotemporal-structure-wind-farm-atmospheric-boundary-layer-interactions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S187661021301655X","title":"Spatiotemporal Structure of Wind Farm-atmospheric Boundary Layer Interactions","description":"Observations and modelling studies show that wind farms can alter their local microclimate. This study examines the effect of real-world wind farms on land surface temperatures in West Central Texas using the Weather Research and Forecasting model under realistic boundary conditions. Three wind turbine parameterizations, including two developed in this study, are used for model sensitivity experiments. The simulated effects of wind farms on temperatures match the spatial patterns observed in satellite data but are weaker in magnitude. The magnitudes of the temperature changes depend on the power coefficients used in the parameterizations.","author":["Roy, S.","Zhou, L.","Cervarich, M."],"organization":["University of Illinois","State University of New York"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.069600000000","-100.386100000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Cervarich-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/731","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-substantial-wind-farms-local-regional-atmospheric-boundary-layer-case-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544219313532","title":"Impact of substantial wind farms on the local and regional atmospheric boundary layer: Case study of Zhangbei wind power base in China","description":"The environment-friendly development of wind power is complicated as the atmospheric impacts of wind farms are difficult to measure. Wind power has made contributions to emission reduction, but it is undeniable that the substantial wind farms (SWFs) have had a non-negligible impact on the local ABL. This paper aims to provide a reliable methodological scheme and practical data for human beings to objectively understand the development of wind power. Based on the data from one of the Chinese gigawatt-scale wind power bases in Zhangbei County of Hebei Province, the mesoscale simulations were conducted to explore the impacts of substantial wind farms on the local and regional atmosphere. The results show that: (i) the impact of substantial wind farms on the local area is significant and sustained, while this impact on the regional area is slight and occasional; (ii) it can bring about the seasonal and diurnal differences in the local ABL property; (iii) it can not only induce the horizontal turbulence directly caused by wind turbine wake flow, but also produce the vertical mixing in the near-surface ABL. A systematic analysis of wind power potential and its atmospheric impact is urgent to ensure sustainable development of wind power.\n\nHighlights:\nWind power brings significant and sustained local atmospheric impacts.\nThe WRF model coupled with WTDP is capable to explore such impacts.\nFilling the gaps in the practical assessment of gigawatt-scale wind power.\nThe seasonal and diurnal impacts of SWFs are quantitatively assessed.","author":["Wu, C.","Wang, Q.","Luo, K.","Fan, J."],"organization":["Zhejiang University"],"originationDate":"2019-09-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.641562000000","115.599789000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/732","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/further-evidence-impacts-large-scale-wind-farms-land-surface-temperature","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032112004455","title":"Further evidence of impacts of large-scale wind farms on land surface temperature","description":"Large wind farms are power plants that generate clean energy from a renewable source. They are increasingly being installed and operated to replace and complement fossil fuel power plants in an effort to help reduce greenhouse and other pollutant emissions (American Wind Energy Association, 2012 [1]; American Wind Energy Association, 2011 [2]; Global Wind Energy Council, 2011 [3]; US Department of Energy, 2008 [4]; Wiser et al., 2007 [5]). Wind energy can have a positive economic impact and numerous locations on the planet are good candidates for wind energy production. Any direct environmental impact of large-scale wind farms needs to be investigated because it could impact agriculture, economics, health, society, and technology. A recent study showed that surface temperature is observed to increase directly downwind of large wind farms [6]. This research, performed concurrently, shows that similar and complementary results are obtained for a different location, and using remotely sensed temperature data obtained from a different satellite, at higher resolution and for a longer time span. Satellite remote sensing observations from Landsat 5 Thematic Mapper are used to study temperature changes over the San Gorgonio Pass Wind Farm from 1984 to 2011, with a pixel resolution of 120 m. A warming trend is consistently observed downwind of the wind farm.","author":["Walsh-Thomas, J.","Cervone, G.","Agouris, P.","Manca, G."],"organization":["George Mason University"],"originationDate":"2012-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.895929000000","-116.586036000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/733","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/changes-fluxes-heat-h2o-co2-caused-large-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0168192314000914","title":"Changes in fluxes of heat, H2O, and CO2 caused by a large wind farm","description":"The Crop Wind-Energy Experiment (CWEX) provides a platform to investigate the effect of wind turbines and large wind farms on surface fluxes of momentum, heat, moisture, and carbon dioxide (CO2). In 2010 and 2011, eddy covariance flux stations were installed between two lines of turbines at the southwest edge of a large Iowa wind farm from late June to early September. We report changes in fluxes of momentum, sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 above a corn canopy after surface air had passed through a single line of turbines. In 2010, our flux stations were placed within a field with homogeneous land management practices (same tillage, cultivar, chemical treatments). We stratify the data according to wind direction, diurnal condition, and turbine operational status. Within these categories, the downwind\u2013upwind flux differences quantify turbine influences at the crop surface. Flux differences were negligible in both westerly wind conditions and when the turbines were non operational. When the flow is perpendicular (southerly) or slightly oblique (southwesterly) to the row of turbines during the day, fluxes of CO2 and water (H2O) are enhanced by a factor of five in the lee of the turbines (from three to five turbine diameter distances downwind from the tower) as compared to a west wind. However, we observe a smaller CO2 flux increase of 30\u201340% for these same wind directions when the turbines are off. In the nighttime, there is strong statistical significance that turbine wakes enhance upward CO2 fluxes and entrain sensible heat toward the crop. The direction of the scalar flux perturbation seems closely associated to the differences in canopy friction velocity. Spectra and co-spectra of momentum components and co-spectra of heat also demonstrate nighttime influence of the wind turbine turbulence at the downwind station.\n\nHighlights:\nCrop energy and CO2 fluxes are modified behind a single wind turbine.\nTurbines slightly enhance daytime CO2 drawdown and double nighttime CO2 respiration.\nTurbines increase simultaneous nighttime canopy mixing of heat and momentum.\nFlux perturbations by single turbines indicate negligible impact on crop yield.","author":["Lundquist, J.","Hatfield, J.","Takle, E.","Rajewski, D.","Prueger, J.","Pfeiffer, R.","Spoth, K.","Doorenbos, R."],"organization":["Iowa State University","University of Colorado Boulder","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","National Laboratory for Agriculture and the Environment"],"originationDate":"2014-08-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.030200000000","-93.642100000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rajewski-et-al-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/734","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/crop-wind-energy-experiment-cwex-observations-surface-layer-boundary-layer-mesoscale","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.ametsoc.org\/doi\/full\/10.1175\/BAMS-D-11-00240.1","title":"Crop Wind Energy Experiment (CWEX): Observations of Surface-Layer, Boundary Layer, and Mesoscale Interactions with a Wind Farm","description":"Perturbations of mean and turbulent wind characteristics by large wind turbines modify fluxes between the vegetated surface and the lower boundary layer. While simulations have suggested that wind farms could significantly change surface fluxes of heat, momentum, momentum, moisture, and CO2 over hundreds of square kilometers, little observational evidence exists to test these predictions. Quantifying the influences of the \u201cturbine layer\u201d is necessary to quantify how surface fluxes are modified and to better forecast energy production by a wind farm. Changes in fluxes are particularly important in regions of intensely managed agriculture where crop growth and yield are highly dependent on subtle changes in moisture, heat, and CO2. Furthermore, speculations abound about the possible mesoscale consequences of boundary layer changes that are produced by wind farms. To address the lack of observations to answer these questions, we developed the Crop Wind Energy Experiment (CWEX) as a multiagency, multiuniversity field program in central Iowa. Throughout the summer of 2010, surface fluxes were documented within a wind farm test site and a 2-week deployment of a vertically pointing lidar quantified wind profiles. In 2011, we expanded measurements at the site by deploying six flux stations and two wind-profiling lidars to document turbine wakes. The results provide valuable insights into the exchanges over a surface that has been modified by wind turbines and a basis for a more comprehensive measurement program planned for the summer in 2014.","author":["Lundquist, J.","Hatfield, J.","Takle, E.","Rajewski, D.","Oncley, S.","Prueger, J.","Horst, T.","Rhodes, M.","Pfeiffer, R.","Spoth, K.","Doorenbos, R."],"organization":["Iowa State University","University of Colorado Boulder","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","National Center for Atmospheric Research","National Laboratory for Agriculture and the Environment"],"originationDate":"2013-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.030200000000","-93.642100000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rajewski-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/735","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/precipitation-reduction-during-hurricane-harvey-simulated-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1748-9326\/aad245","title":"Precipitation reduction during Hurricane Harvey with simulated offshore wind farms","description":"Hurricane Harvey brought to the Texas coast possibly the heaviest rain ever recorded in US history, which then caused flooding at unprecedented levels. Previous studies have shown that large arrays of hypothetical offshore wind farms can extract kinetic energy from a hurricane and thus reduce the wind and storm surge. This study quantitatively tests whether the hypothetical offshore turbines may also affect precipitation patterns. The Weather Research Forecast model is employed to model Harvey and the offshore wind farms are parameterized as elevated drag and turbulent kinetic energy sources. Model results indicate that the offshore wind farms have a strong impact on the distribution of accumulated precipitation, with an obvious decrease onshore downstream of the wind farms, and an increase in offshore areas, upstream of or within the wind farms. Compared with the control case with no wind turbines, increased horizontal wind divergence and lower vertical velocity are found where precipitation is reduced onshore, whereas increased horizontal wind convergence and higher vertical velocity occur upstream of or within the offshore wind farms. The sensitivity to the size of the offshore array, inter-turbine spacing, and the details of the wind farm parameterization are assessed. The results suggest that large arrays of offshore wind turbines can effectively protect the coast from heavy rain during hurricanes and that smart layouts with fewer turbines over smaller areas can be almost as effective as those with more turbines over larger areas.","author":["Archer, C.","Pan, Y.","Yan, C."],"organization":["University of Delaware"],"originationDate":"2018-07-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["28.369389000000","-94.574537000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Pan-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/736","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/functional-structural-responses-marine-urbanisation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1748-9326\/aa98a5","title":"Functional and structural responses to marine urbanisation","description":"Urban areas have broad ecological footprints with complex impacts on natural systems. In coastal areas, growing populations are advancing their urban footprint into the ocean through the construction of seawalls and other built infrastructure. While we have some understanding of how urbanisation might drive functional change in terrestrial ecosystems, coastal systems have been largely overlooked. This study is one of the first to directly assess how changes in diversity relate to changes in ecosystem properties and functions (e.g. productivity, filtration rates) of artificial and natural habitats in one of the largest urbanised estuaries in the world, Sydney Harbour. We complemented our surveys with an extensive literature search. We found large and important differences in the community structure and function between artificial and natural coastal habitats. However, differences in diversity and abundance of organisms do not necessarily match observed functional changes. The abundance and composition of important functional groups differed among habitats with rocky shores having 40% and 70% more grazers than seawalls or pilings, respectively. In contrast, scavengers were approximately 8 times more abundant on seawalls than on pilings or rocky shores and algae were more diverse on natural rocky shores and seawalls than on pilings. Our results confirm previous findings in the literature. Oysters were more abundant on pilings than on rocky shores, but were also smaller. Interestingly, these differences in oyster populations did not affect in situ filtration rates between habitats. Seawalls were the most invaded habitats while pilings supported greater secondary productivity than other habitats. This study highlights the complexity of the diversity-function relationship and responses to ocean sprawl in coastal systems. Importantly, we showed that functional properties should be considered independently from structural change if we are to design and manage artificial habitats in ways to maximise the services provided by urban coastal systems and minimise their ecological impacts.","author":["Airoldi, L.","Dafforn, K.","Johnston, E.","Glasby, T.","Mayer-Pinto, M.","Cole, V.","Bugnot, A.","Hurst, H."],"organization":["University of New South Wales","Sydney Institute of Marine Science","University of Sydney","Port Stephens Fisheries Institute (PSFI)","Plymouth University","University of Bologna"],"originationDate":"2018-01-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["-33.840606000000","151.268769000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:06:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mayer-Pinto_et_al_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/737","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthos-distribution-modelling-its-relevance-marine-ecosystem-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/article\/72\/2\/297\/674105","title":"Benthos distribution modelling and its relevance for marine ecosystem management","description":"Marine benthic ecosystems are difficult to monitor and assess, which is in contrast to modern ecosystem-based management requiring detailed information at all important ecological and anthropogenic impact levels. Ecosystem management needs to ensure a sustainable exploitation of marine resources as well as the protection of sensitive habitats, taking account of potential multiple-use con\ufb02icts and impacts over large spatial scales. The urgent need for large-scale spatial data on benthic species and communities resulted in an increasing application of distribution modelling (DM). The use of DM techniques enables to employ full spatial coverage data of environmental variables to predict benthic spatial distribution patterns. Especially, statistical DMs have opened new possibilities for ecosystem management applications, since they are straightforward and the outputs are easy to interpret and communicate. Mechanistic modelling techniques, targeting the fundamental niche of species, and Bayesian belief networks are the most promising to further improve DM performance in the marine realm. There are many actual and potential management applications of DMs in the marine benthic environment, these are (i) early warning systems for species invasion and pest control, (ii) to assess distribution probabilities of species to be protected, (iii) uses in monitoring design and spatial management frameworks (e.g. MPA designations), and (iv) establishing long-term ecosystem management measures (accounting for future climate-driven changes in the ecosystem). It is important to acknowledge also the limitations associated with DM applications in a marine management context as well as considering new areas for future DM developments. The knowledge of explanatory variables, for example, setting the basis for DM, will continue to be further developed: this includes both the abiotic (natural and anthropogenic) and the more pressing biotic (e.g. species interactions) aspects of the ecosystem. While the response variables on the other hand are often focused on species presence and some work undertaken on species abundances, it is equally important to consider, e.g. biological traits or benthic ecosystem functions in DM applications. Tools such as DMs are suitable to forecast the possible effects of climate change on benthic species distribution patterns and hence could help to steer present-day ecosystem management.","author":["Degraer, S.","Borja, A.","Dannheim, J.","Galparsoro, I.","Darr, A.","Zettler, M.","Birchenough, S.","Reiss, H.","Buhl-Mortensen, L.","Craeymeersch, J.","Gogina, M.","Neumann, H.","Populus, J.","Rengstorf, A.","Valle, M.","Hoey, G."],"organization":["Nord University","Cefas Lowestoft Laboratory","AZTI-Tecnalia","Institute of Marine Research (IMR)","IMARES - Wageningen UR","Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","Leibniz Institute for Baltic Sea Research, Warnem\u00fcnde (IOW)","Senckenberg Research Institute","The French Research Institute for Exploitation of the Sea (IFREMER)","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2015-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Reiss-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/738","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/three-dimensional-mapping-benthic-invertebrates-biophony-compact-four-hydrophones","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0003682X18304638","title":"Three-dimensional mapping of the benthic invertebrates biophony with a compact four-hydrophones array","description":"Benthic invertebrates emit broadband transient sounds, that dominate coastal soundscapes and can inform on the environment and its ecological state. Numerous works have studied temporal patterns of Benthic Invertebrate Biophonies (BIB) and linked them to environmental parameters or ecological processes, but there is a lack of knowledge about the spatial variability of BIB. Here, we mapped Benthic Invertebrate Sounds (BIS) in three dimensions using a compact array (2\u202fm\u202f\u00d7\u202f2\u202fm\u202f\u00d7\u202f2\u202fm) of four hydrophones within the scope of eco-acoustics studies. Firstly, we developed tools to localize any individual sound emitted by benthic invertebrates. A theoretical calculation of the Cramer Rao Bounds (CRB) consolidated by in situ active emissions from known positions, demonstrated the accuracy of the localization. Secondly, by accumulating all the positions of the BIS recorded during a night, three methods are proposed to map the BIB at different spatial scales. An in situ measurement campaign carried out on a 300\u202fm\u202f\u00d7\u202f300\u202fm artificial reef system revealed that the marine fauna was binary spatially distributed: rich and numerous on artificial reefs and poor and weak outside the reefs. At small ranges (10\u202fm), the acoustic maps matched the geometric structures of the reefs with an accuracy of 0.5\u202fm. At large scales (100\u202fm and 300\u202fm), the acoustic hot-spots on the maps corresponded to distant reefs, with an accuracy of 7\u202fm and 10\u202fm respectively.\n\nThis study provides the first maps of the BIB at ecologically relevant scales and shows that they can be used to identify, quantify, follow and track benthic activity hot-spots. In combination with biological and ecological information, passive acoustic monitoring using such maps can be a powerful complementary tool for ecological studies, such as the quantification of grazing activity or the evaluation of the efficiency of marine ecologic restoration programs.","author":["Lossent, J.","Gervaise, C.","Valentini-Poirier, C.","Boissery, P.","Noel, C.","Di lorio, L."],"organization":["CHORUS Acoustics","Grenoble Institute of Technology","Universit\u00e9 Grenoble Alpes","French Water Agency Rh\u00f4ne M\u00e9diterran\u00e9e Corse (RMC)","Semantic T.S."],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.299746000000","5.353063000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/739","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mechanics-blue-growth-management-oceanic-natural-resource-use-multiple-interacting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X17305869","title":"The mechanics of blue growth: Management of oceanic natural resource use with multiple, interacting sectors","description":"Integrated management of multiple economic sectors is a central tenet of blue growth and socially optimal use of ocean-based natural resources, but the mechanisms of implementation remain poorly understood. In this review, we explore the challenges and opportunities of multi-sector management. We describe the roles of key existing sectors (fisheries, transportation, and offshore hydrocarbon) and emerging sectors (aquaculture, tourism, and seabed mining) and the likely synergistic and antagonistic inter-sector interactions. We then review methods to help characterize and quantify interactions and decision-support tools to help managers balance and optimize around interactions.","author":["Watson, J.","Dav\u00ed\u00f0sd\u00f3ttir, B.","Klinger, D.","Eikeset, A.","Winter, A."],"organization":["Princeton University","University of Oslo","University of Iceland","Royal Swedish Academy of Science","Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Klinger-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/740","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/imbalances-interaction-transboundary-marine-spatial-planning-insights-baltic-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117307470","title":"Imbalances in interaction for transboundary marine spatial planning: Insights from the Baltic Sea Region","description":"Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) has evolved over many years and since its early beginnings there has been a growing urgency to develop transboundary planning. This is because the borders of marine ecosystems and the dynamics of some maritime activities, such as navigation, are not restricted to or bound by specific political and administrative borders. Cooperation across borders has been promoted by higher political levels for decades, and the implementation of cross-border consultation procedures is regulated by law. However, literature suggests that transboundary interaction is not an obvious step in the process of MSP and that today\u0027s practices have various weaknesses. This paper examines current practices and procedures of transboundary MSP interactions in the Baltic Sea Region to date. It brings together results from MSP process observations and interviews with marine planners in two recent research projects (Baltic SCOPE and BONUS BALTSPACE). Our results confirm the need for transboundary interaction and integration. The research also shows that there are differences in how MSP agencies interact with domestic and foreign stakeholders. Furthermore, formal transboundary consultations often seem to be limited to topics of the environment and health, and to the stakeholders responsible in these realms. The results include a variety of ways to overcome these challenges.","author":["Jan\u00dfen, H.","Morf, A.","Varjopuro, R.","Luttmann, A.","Nieminen, H."],"organization":["Leibniz Institute for Baltic Sea Research, Warnem\u00fcnde (IOW)","Finnish Environment Institute (SYKE)","University of Gothenburg","Nordregio"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/741","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/international-good-practices-facilitating-transboundary-collaboration-marine-spatial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X18304330","title":"International good practices for facilitating transboundary collaboration in Marine Spatial Planning","description":"The \u201cJoint Roadmap to Accelerate Marine Spatial Planning Processes Worldwide\u201d, adopted by IOC-UNESCO and the European Commission (DG-MARE) in 2017, highlights the growing commitment of policy and decision-makers in developing transboundary collaboration relevant to Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) as a mechanism for promoting sustainable sea use. While collaboration across borders represents positive progress towards global environmental stewardship and international cooperation, transboundary MSP can present challenges and obstacles as it can be a complex process involving different parties and stakeholders across multiple levels of governance. In this article, we examine the different enabling factors and good practices that emerge from two different DG-MARE-funded knowledge exchange projects on transboundary MSP, whose findings led to the development of the Joint Roadmap: the Baltic SCOPE Project, and the Study on International Best Practices for Cross-Border MSP. Recognising that MSP processes are specific to their respective contexts, we aim to provide guidance and support towards the development of effective collaboration in future transboundary MSP initiatives by offering inspiration in the approaches and tools used elsewhere. We hope this will enable others to reflect on the benefits of adopting a strategic approach to transboundary collaboration designed to align marine plans across different jurisdictions.","author":["M\u00e9ndez-Rold\u00e1n, S.","Morf, A.","Kull, M.","Moodie, J.","Thomas, H.","Giacometti, A.","Isaksson, I."],"organization":["Nordregio","United Nations Environment Programme - World Conservation Monitoring Centre (UNEP-WCMC)","NIRAS","Swedish Agency for Marine and Water Management (SwAM)"],"originationDate":"2021-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/742","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-use-use-interactions-sea-theoretical-framework-spatial-decision-support","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X18306729","title":"Assessing use-use interactions at sea: A theoretical framework for spatial decision support tools facilitating co-location in maritime spatial planning","description":"The space occupied by traditional and new human-based marine uses at sea is expanding, creating a need for developing methods to assess interactions between co-located uses in maritime spatial planning (MSP). However, no clear terminology for use-use interactions exists. Thus, an analytical framework for spatial decision support tools (DSTs) to assess use-use interactions is deduced from literature. Four spatial-temporal links are found to either alone or together constitute use-use interactions: location links, environmental links, technical links, and user attraction links. It is found to be important for DSTs to support co-location management in MSP by iteratively through the MSP process 1) spatially-temporally locate spatial-temporal links constituting use-use interactions, 2) list conflicts and synergies of the located use-use interactions, and 3) weight the conflicts and synergies. With this analytical framework, two types of DSTs are analysed for their ability to include co-location; matrix- and ranking-based DSTs to detect conflicts and synergies and space allocating DSTs to avoid\/minimise conflicts and optimise synergies. Whereas the first group of tools categorise or rank use-use combinations, the latter group use information about which multi-use combinations are possible as pre-existing knowledge, and thus the two groups of DSTs can advantageously be used together. A discrepancy is found between the co-location framework and the DSTs. It is argued that future tools could work on removing this discrepancy by considering the spatial-temporal links of use-use interactions, strengthen the focus on synergies, as well as prioritize ranking of synergies and conflicts over binary approaches that only evaluate spatial compatibility.\n\nHighlights:\nA heoretical framework describing marine human-based use-use interactions is developed.\nExisting decision support tools are analysed for their ability to assess marine use-use interactions.\nSpatial-temporal links constituting marine use-use interactions need to be further explored.\nThe focus on synergies could advantageously be strengthened in future tools supporting MSP.\nRanking of conflicts and synergies could advantageously be expanded in future tools supporting MSP.","author":["Bonnevie, I.","Hansen, H.","Schr\u00f8der, L."],"organization":["Aalborg University"],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/743","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/overview-ocean-power-technology","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544219304724","title":"Overview of ocean power technology","description":"This work discusses and provides a critical expose of some of the newly emerging renewable energy technologies with special concentration on marine energy generation.\n\nThe work shows that there are several promising new developments in harvesting marine energy and it examines some of these technologies and discusses their advantages and some of the obstacles that are impeding the commercialization of these emerging technologies. This includes wave energy harvesting, tidal energy harvesting, ocean thermal energy and the utilisation of salinity gradients for electricity generation.\n\nThe work emphasises the fact that these new emerging technologies are currently at the developing stages and has a long way to go before successful commercialization and wide adoption become the norm.\n\nThe work stresses the need for more research and developmental work to address several of the technical issues that need to be addressed including devices designs, their installation and maintenance, the infrastructure which includes the grid and power transmission as well as losses, their use in arrays, and their longevity.\n\nThis work underlines the lack of reliable studies on the long term impacts of these technologies on both the marine environment and nearby habitations and highlights the need for proper environmental and social impact assessments of these technologies.\n\nThe work concludes that combination of technical, policy and economic advances will enable marine energy technologies to play a large role in combination with currently adopted non-pollution renewable energy resources to provide the world population with their energy needs and contribute to affecting significant reduction in the use of non-renewable and other polluting fuels worldwide.","author":["Thompson, J.","Wilberforce, T.","Hassan, Z.","Durrant, A.","Soudan, B.","Olabi, A."],"organization":["University of the West of Scotland","University of Sharjah","Aston University"],"originationDate":"2019-05-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/744","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-governance-industrialised-ocean-case-study-emerging-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X14002838","title":"Marine governance in an industrialised ocean: A case study of the emerging marine renewable energy industry","description":"The world\u05f3s oceans are currently undergoing an unprecedented period of industrialisation, made possible by advances in technology and driven by our growing need for food, energy and resources. This is placing the oceans are under intense pressure, and the ability of existing marine governance frameworks to sustainably manage the marine environment is increasingly being called into question. Emerging industries are challenging all aspects of these frameworks, raising questions regarding ownership and rights of the sea and its resources, management of environmental impacts, and management of ocean space. This paper uses the emerging marine renewable energy (MRE) industry, particularly in the United Kingdom (UK), as a case study to introduce and explore some of the key challenges. The paper concludes that the challenges are likely to be extensive and argues for development of a comprehensive legal research agenda to advance both MRE technologies and marine governance frameworks.\n\nHighlights:\nA\u00a0 brief history of marine governance and its evolution from single-sector management towards a holistic approach.\nThe ocean is industrialising and marine governance is evolving in response.\nMarine renewables provide an excellent case study of evolving marine governance frameworks.\nA\u00a0legal research agenda for marine renewables would advance both the technology and marine governance generally.","author":["Wright, G."],"organization":["Institute for Sustainable Development and International Relations (IDDRI)","Australian National University"],"originationDate":"2015-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/745","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysis-state-impact-assessment-research-low-carbon-power-production-building-better","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618303001","title":"An analysis of the state of impact assessment research for low carbon power production: Building a better understanding of information and knowledge gaps","description":"This study provides a portrait of the state of impact assessment (IA) research for four types of low carbon power production (wind, solar, small-scale hydro and small modular nuclear reactors). The emphasis is on IA research that has relevance to the Canadian policy setting. The method involved a systematized scan of the academic literature (peer reviewed publications, conference proceedings and book chapters) and reports and studies produced by government and other organizations. The literature was categorized according to a framework adapted from transition theory. The results indicate that the literature addressing wind power is comprehensive, but there is a relative scarcity of research (in both quantity and breadth) on the impacts of solar, small-scale hydro, and small modular reactors (SMRs). In each of these three energy areas there is a lack of available work addressing the social, political and cultural impacts accompanied by more specialized gaps in the biophysical research. Drawing on a transition theory typology, the majority of the literature can be characterized as reflexive, with less than 20% of research exploring primarily operational, tactical, or strategic themes. But there are many sources where the research contains overlapping categories. The research for SMR impacts is distinct from the other three alternative power sources; this literature is largely strategic. Priorities for further analysis in the short-term include applying lessons from the international literature to the Canadian context and developing a better understanding of the specific impacts of alternative energy sources on Indigenous communities. In the longer term, there is a need for more research in the field, with a particular emphasis on understanding the operational and strategic qualities of low carbon power production.","author":["Hanna, K.","McGuigan, E.","Noble, B.","Parkins, J."],"organization":["University of British Columbia","University of Saskatchewan","University of Alberta"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.556342400000","-112.080631300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/746","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-man-made-sound-fishes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-1-4939-8574-6_6","title":"Effects of Man-Made Sound on Fishes","description":"Sound provides animals with a means of rapid, directional, and long-distance communication. It also provides animals with a \u201cgestalt\u201d view of their environment by giving an acoustic image of the world that often extends far beyond what is available from other senses. Thus, sound is highly relevant for fishes, and any interference with the ability to detect sound has potential consequences for the fitness and survival of individuals, populations, and species. There is a growing body of evidence that the addition of man-made sound in the aquatic environment has the potential to affect the ability of fishes to detect and use the biologically relevant sounds that are important for their survival. Moreover, there is also evidence that especially intense sounds not only affect sound detection and behavior but also have the potential to have physiological and physical effects on fish that could result in greatly reduced fitness and, in some cases, directly to death. This chapter examines the potential effects of man-made sound on fishes. It considers the sources of such sounds, the current data on potential effects and impacts, and implications for regulation of such sounds so that the potential impact is mitigated.\n\nThis chapter is from the book Effects of Anthropogenic Noise on Animals.","author":["Hawkins, A.","Popper, A."],"organization":["Loughine Limited","University of Maryland"],"originationDate":"2018-08-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/747","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-anthropogenic-noise-animals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-1-4939-8574-6","title":"Effects of Anthropogenic Noise on Animals","description":"Over the past several years, many investigators interested in the effects of man-made sounds on animals have come to realize that there is much to gain from studying the broader literature on hearing sound and the effects of sound as well as data from the effects on humans. It has also become clear that knowledge of the effects of sound on one group of animals (e.g., birds or frogs) can guide studies on other groups (e.g., marine mammals or fishes) and that a review of all such studies together would be very useful to get a better understanding of the general principles and underlying cochlear and cognitive mechanisms that explain damage, disturbance, and deterrence across taxa.\n\nThe purpose of this volume, then, is to provide a comprehensive review of the effects of man-made sounds on animals, with the goal of fulfilling two major needs. First, it was thought to be important to bring together data on sound and bioacoustics that have implications across all taxa (including humans) so that such information is generally available to the community of scholars interested in the effects of sound. This is done in Chaps. 2-5. Second, in Chaps. 6-10, the volume brings together what is known about the effects of sound on diverse vertebrate taxa so that investigators with interests in specific groups can learn from the data and experimental approaches from other species. Put another way, having an overview of the similarities and discrepancies among various animal groups and insight into the \u201chow and why\u201d will benefit the overall conceptual understanding, applications in society, and all future research.\n\nChapters:\nMan-Made Sounds and Animals -\u00a0H.\u00a0Slabbekoorn, R. Dooling, \u0026 A. Popper (pgs.\u00a01-22)\nCommunication Masking by Man-Made Noise -\u00a0R. Dooling \u0026\u00a0M. Leek (pgs.\u00a023-46)\nPrinciples of Auditory Object Formation by Nonhuman Animals - M. Dent \u0026\u00a0M. Bee (pgs. 47-82)\nCharacteristics of Temporary and Permanent Threshold Shifts in Vertebrates - J. Saunders \u0026\u00a0R. Dooling (pgs. 83-107)\nAcoustic Conditions Affecting Sound Communication in Air and Underwater - O.\u00a0Larsen \u0026C. Radford (pgs.109-144)\nEffects of Man-Made Sound on Fishes - A. Hawkins \u0026\u00a0A.\u00a0Popper (pgs.145-177)\nEffects of Anthropogenic Noise on Amphibians and Reptiles - A. Simmons \u0026 P. Narins (pgs.179-208)\nImpact of Man-Made Sound on Birds and Their Songs - W. Halfwerk, B. Lohr, H. Slabbekoorn (pgs. 209-242)\nEffects of Man-Made Sound on Terrestrial Mammals - H. Slabbekoorn, J.\u00a0McGee, \u0026 E. Walsh (pgs. 243-276)\nEffects of Noise on Marine Mammals - C.\u00a0Erbe, R. Dunlop, \u0026 S. Dolman (pgs. 277-309)","author":["Popper, A.","Dooling, R.","Slabbekoorn, H.","Fay, R."],"organization":["Leiden University","University of Maryland","Loyola University Chicago"],"originationDate":"2018-08-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/748","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-noise-marine-mammals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-1-4939-8574-6_10","title":"Effects of Noise on Marine Mammals","description":"Marine mammals (whales, dolphins, seals, sea lions, sea cows) use sound both actively and passively to communicate and sense their environment, covering frequencies from a few hertz to greater than 100 kHz, differing with species. Although a few documents on marine mammal sound production and reception date back 200 years, concern about the effects of man-made noise on marine mammals has only been documented since the 1970s. Underwater noise can interfere with key life functions of marine mammals (e.g., foraging, mating, nursing, resting, migrating) by impairing hearing sensitivity, masking acoustic signals, eliciting behavioral responses, or causing physiological stress. Many countries are developing and updating guidelines and regulations for underwater noise management in relation to marine mammal conservation. In the United States, the Marine Mammal Protection Act, enacted in 1972, is increasingly being applied to underwater noise emission. Common mitigation methods include (1) time\/area closures, (2) the establishment of safety zones that are monitored by visual observers or passive acoustics and that lead to shut-down or low-power operations if animals enter these zones, (3) noise reduction gear like bubble curtains around pile driving, and (4) noise source modifications or operational parameters like soft starts. Mitigation management mostly deals with single operations (like a one-month seismic survey). Key questions that remain are how noise impacts accumulate over time and multiple exposures, how multiple acoustic and nonacoustic stressors interact, and how effects on individuals affect a population as a whole.\n\nThis chapter is from the book\u00a0Effects of Anthropogenic Noise on Animals.","author":["Erbe, C.","Dolman, S.","Dunlop, R."],"organization":["Curtin University","University of Queensland","Whale and Dolphin Conservation"],"originationDate":"2018-08-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/749","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/determining-dependence-marine-pile-driving-sound-levels-strike-energy-pile-penetration","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/1.5114797","title":"Determining the dependence of marine pile driving sound levels on strike energy, pile penetration, and propagation effects using a linear mixed model based on damped cylindrical spreading","description":"Acoustic recordings were made during the installation of four offshore wind turbines at the Block Island Wind Farm, Rhode Island, USA. The turbine foundations have four legs inclined inward in a pyramidal configuration. Four bottom mounted acoustic recorders measured received sound levels at distances of 541\u20139067 m during 24 pile driving events. Linear mixed models based on damped cylindrical spreading were used to analyze the data. The model\u0027s random effects coefficients represented useful information about variability in the acoustic propagation conditions. The received sound levels were dependent on the angle between pile and seabed, strike energy, and pile penetration (PP). Deeper PPs increased sound levels in a frequency dependent manner. The estimated area around the piles where auditory injury and disturbance to marine life could occur were not circular and changed by up to an order of magnitude between the lowest and highest sound level cases. The study extends earlier results showing a linear relationship between the peak sound pressure level and per-strike sound exposure level. Recommendations are made for how to collect and analyze pile driving data. The results will inform regulatory mitigations of the effects of pile driving sound on marine life, and contribute to developing improved pile driving source models.","author":["Martin, S.","Barclay, D."],"organization":["Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.174915000000","-71.556344000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/750","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measuring-responses-harbour-seals-potential-aversive-acoustic-mitigation-signals-using","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/aqc.3150","title":"Measuring responses of harbour seals to potential aversive acoustic mitigation signals using controlled exposure behavioural response studies","description":"Some anthropogenic activities pose acute risks for marine species. For example, pile driving could damage the hearing of marine mammals while underwater explosions can also result in physical damage or death. Effective mitigation is required to reduce these risks, but the exclusion zones specified in regulations can extend over hundreds or thousands of metres and seals pose particular problems because they are difficult to detect at sea.  Aversive sound mitigation aims to exclude animals from high\u2010risk areas before dangerous activities take place by broadcasting specific acoustic signals. Field research is needed to identify signals that might be effective in eliciting short\u2010term avoidance by marine species such as harbour seals (Phoca vitulina). A series of controlled\u2010exposure experiments (CEEs) were undertaken to measure seal movements in response to acoustic deterrent devices (ADD) and predator calls, and to assess the effectiveness of candidate signals for aversive sound mitigation.  Seals were fitted with UHF\/GPS transmitters providing continuous high\u2010resolution tracks and real\u2010time transmissions of their locations. A tracking\/playback vessel located seals at sea and transmitted either ADD signals or orca (Orcinus orca) calls over a range of distances while seals were foraging or moving between sites. Behaviour before, during and after exposure was analysed to assess responses.  One\u2010hundred and ten CEEs were assessed as being of at least \u2018adequate\u2019 quality. Of the 71 adequate trials with the Lofitech ADD, all 38 at ranges of \u0026lt;1 km (predicted received level 134.6 dB RMS re 1 \u03bcPa) elicited a response. The maximum response range was 3123 m (predicted RL: 111 dB RMS re 1 \u03bcPa). However, the responses observed did not always result in substantial movements away from the source, especially for seals that were travelling at the time of the exposures. More work is needed to better understand how exposure risks would be reduced in different scenarios.  The mean net speed of horizontal movements for seals responding to aversive sounds (1.15 m s\u22121) was only 7% higher than their mean travel speed.  Responses to broadcasts of orca calls were highly variable.  The results suggest that signals similar to those generated by a Lofitech ADD could be used to reduce risks to harbour seals from pile driving and underwater explosions in coastal waters. More work will be needed to develop systems that match the requirements of industry and regulators and to explore whether these results can be generalized to offshore waters and to other phocids.","author":["Gordon, J.","Thompson, D.","Blight, C.","Bryant, E."],"organization":["University of St Andrews","Pathtrack Ltd."],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.263630000000","-5.638583000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gordon-et-al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/751","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/consequences-seabird-habitat-loss-offshore-wind-turbines-version-2","sourceURL":"https:\/\/library.wur.nl\/WebQuery\/wurpubs\/fulltext\/496173","title":"The consequences of seabird habitat loss from offshore wind turbines, version 2","description":"The planned large-scale development of offshore wind farms (OWFs) in the North Sea has potential consequences for many marine organisms, including seabirds. The response of seabirds to wind farms varies depending on species: some may be attracted to the wind farms leading to risk of collisions, some will avoid them and some do not respond. Those birds that avoid wind farms do not suffer from collisions but may suffer from habitat loss if OWFs are built in areas they use, which may in turn negatively affect the populations of seabirds using the Dutch continental shelf. Adverse effects of offshore wind farms on seabirds potentially lead to a trade-off between societal demands for marine nature conservation and clean energy. Seabirds are important target species in European conservation frameworks. In this report, we develop and apply a method for assessing the effect of habitat loss on five seabird species: red-throated divers (Gavia stellata), northern gannets (Morus bassanus), sandwich terns (Thalasseus sandvicensis), razorbills (Alca torda) and common guillemots (Uria aalge). To our knowledge, this is the first study that calculates effects on the full life cycle and the larger North Sea population.","author":["Chen, C.","Tulp, I.","Leopold, M.","van Kooten, T.","Soudijn, F.","Benden, D."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","Rijkswaterstaat"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.762248000000","4.933929000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Habitat Change","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/van_Kooten_et_al_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/752","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/kyle-rhea-tidal-stream-array-environmental-statement","sourceURL":"https:\/\/marine.gov.scot\/datafiles\/lot\/Kyle_Rhea\/environmental_statement\/KRTSA%20Vol%20II%20ES.pdf","title":"The Kyle Rhea Tidal Stream Array: Environmental Statement","description":"Sea Generation (Kyle Rhea) Ltd is proposing to construct and operate an 8 megawatt (MW) rated capacity demonstration array of tidal stream turbines. The \u2018Kyle Rhea Tidal Stream Array\u2019 (henceforth referred to as \u0022the Project\u0022) is proposed to be situated in the narrow strait between the Isle of Skye and mainland Scotland, known as Kyle Rhea. Sea Generation (Kyle Rhea) Ltd is a project company established by Marine Current Turbines Ltd (MCT), who are the world\u2019s leading tidal turbine technology developer and part of the Siemens group. The development of an array represents the next step in the development of tidal energy projects, following the successful commercial demonstration of single devices including MCT\u2019s SeaGen device at Strangford Lough, Northern Ireland. Whilst a tidal array in the Sound of Islay has been consented, there are currently no constructed and operational tidal arrays in the world. The tidal industry has an important role to play in contributing to the UK Government\u2019s target for renewable energy to provide 15% of the gross annual electricity generation by 2020, and the Scottish Government\u2019s targets of providing the equivalent of 100% of Scotland\u0027s gross annual electricity consumption by 2020 from renewable sources.  This document constitutes the Environmental Statement (ES) under The Electricity Works (EIA)(Scotland) Regulations 2000, and provides details of the project and key findings of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) carried out for the Project. The ES supports an application for a Marine Licence under the Marine Scotland Act 2010, consent under the Section 36 Electricity Act 1989, and consent for the offshore aspects of the Project under the Town and Country (Scotland) Planning Act 1997 (as amended)    Volume 1: Non-Technical Summary  Volume 2: Environmental Statement  Volume 2: Environmental Statement Figures  Volume 3: Appendices","author":["Royal Haskoning","Sea Generation (Kyle Rhea) Ltd."],"organization":["Royal Haskoning"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.235040000000","-5.663580000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-10 11:42:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kyle-Rhea-Environmental-Statement-2013-Volume1.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kyle-Rhea-Environmental-Statement-2013-Volume2.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kyle-Rhea-Environmental-Statement-2013-Volume2Figures.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kyle-Rhea-Environmental-Statement-2013-Volume3.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/753","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/uk-national-ecosystem-assessment-follow-work-package-report-6-shared-plural-cultural","sourceURL":"https:\/\/research.edgehill.ac.uk\/ws\/files\/20063797\/UKNEAFO%20WP6_FinalReport.pdf","title":"The UK National Ecosystem Assessment Follow-on. Work package Report 6: shared, plural and cultural values of ecosystems","description":"The UK National Ecosystem Assessment Follow-on Work Package on Shared, Plural and Cultural Values (UK NEAFO WP5) report consists of the following main documents:    The full report  A summary to the full report  A handbook for decision-makers, analysts and practitioners   The summary and full reports both start off with a set of key findings. The summary key findings can be read as an executive summary. The full key findings provide more detailed conclusions and an overview of the evidence that supports each of the findings, with reference to the report sections where one can find further detail. The summary and full report apply the same section headings and numbering. This facilitates using the documents side-by-side, allowing the reader to dip in and out of the full report where he or she is interested in greater depth or wants to look up references. The handbook provides a brief explanation of what shared, plural and cultural values are and why they are important to national and local government, business, NGOs, policy-analysts and practitioners. It provides an overview of methods for assessing shared, plural and cultural values and incorporating them into decisions, with short examples and case studies. In addition to these three documents, WP5 has also produced an interim report titled The value of potential marine protected areas in the UK to divers and sea anglers, which can be read independently or as supporting material for the marine protected areas case study in Section 4.4.  10 findings of this report:    Finding 1: Shared values resulting from deliberative, group-based valuation are different from individual values. Case study evidence suggests that they are more informed, considered, confident and reflective of participants\u2019 deeper-held, transcendental values.  Finding 2: The ethical, moral and justice dimensions of many environmental issues necessitate approaches that allow for the elicitation of shared and plural values.  Finding 3: Catalyst and\/or conflict points can play a key role in the emergence and articulation of values at a societal or community level that have not previously been outwardly or explicitly articulated.  Finding 4: There is a diversity of ways in which shared, plural, cultural and social values are used, but they are rarely conceptualised.  Finding 5: Shared and social values in the sense of value to society is conceptualised very differently by conventional economics and other disciplines.  Finding 6: A mixed method approach is required to elicit the multiple dimensions of shared values and to translate deeper-held, transcendental values into contextual values and preferences.  Finding 7: Deliberative and social learning processes help people to understand the values held by others; they can lead to increased sharing of values and\/or to greater acceptance of the decisions emerging from such processes.  Finding 8: Media analysis is a promising avenue for characterising different types of shared values at a large scale, as well as assessing the conflicts between the communal values of different sectors of society.  Finding 9: Aesthetic and spiritual values of ecosystems have a strong non-instrumental component. While they benefit human well-being, they should not simply be classified as just \u2018services\u2019 or \u2018benefits\u0027.  Finding 10: Subjective well-being measures provide a useful means of assessing \u2018intangible\u2019 cultural ecosystem services and their benefits.","author":["Reed, M.","Davies, A.","Ryan, M.","Irvine, K.","Kenter, J.","O\u0027Brien, L.","Brady, E.","Bryce, R.","Christie, M.","Church, A.","Cooper, N.","Evely, A.","Everard, M.","Fazey, I.","Hockley, N.","Jobstvogt, N.","Molloy, C.","Orchard-Webb, J.","Ravenscroft, N.","Watson, V."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen","Birmingham City University","James Hutton Institute","De Montfort University","Forest Research - Alice Holt Lodge","University of Edinburgh","Aberystwyth University","University of Brighton","Anglia Ruskin University (ARU)","Church of England - Diocese of Ely","University of St Andrews","Project Maya","University of Dundee","Bangor University","Edge Hill University","United Nations Environment Programme - World Conservation Monitoring Centre (UNEP-WCMC)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.276117200000","-5.754382000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Environmental Justice"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/UKNEAFO_WP6_FinalReport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/754","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interplay-between-economics-legislative-power-social-influence-examined-through-social","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969718336258","title":"The interplay between economics, legislative power and social influence examined through a social-ecological framework for marine ecosystems services","description":"In the last 15\u202fyears, conservation has shifted increasingly towards perspectives based on the instrumental value of nature, where what counts is what provides benefits to humans. The ecosystem services framework embraces this vision of nature through monetary valuation of the environment to correct market failures and government distortions that hinder efficient allocation of public goods, including goods and services provided by biodiversity and ecosystems. The popularity of this approach is reflected in different countries legislation; for instance, US, EU and UK have introduced economic criteria for comparing costs and benefits of environmental policies in protecting ecosystem services.\n\nFrom an operational perspective, the ecosystem services framework requires ecologists to estimate how the supply of services is affected by changes in the functionality and\/or the extent of ecosystems; and economists to identify how changes in the supply affect the flow of direct and indirect benefits to people. However, this approach may be simplistic when faced with the complexity of social-ecological systems. We investigated this for three different marine services: assimilative capacity of waste, coastal defense and renewable energy. We find that economic valuation could provide efficient and fair allocations in the case of assimilative capacity, but leads to social clashes between outputs generated by cost benefit analysis and citizens\u0027 expectation in the case of coastal defense. In the case of renewable energy, controversies can be generated by regulatory mechanisms that are not necessarily aligned with the interests of industry or important social groups. We conclude that there is a need to integrate perspectives arising from utilitarian allocation of resources with those involving legislation and communal values in order to reconcile conflicting interests and better sustain marine social-ecological systems.\n\nHighlights:\nA\u00a0social-ecological framework analyses three marine ecosystem services (ES).\nAssimilative capacity, coastal defence and renewable energy are object of study.\nThe role of economics, regulation and civil society is debated for the three ES.\nEconomics shows some axiomatic issues in guaranteeing the provision of these ES.\nOther institutions are required to enable social learning and conflicts resolution.","author":["Kenter, J.","Martino, S.","Tett, P."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","University of York"],"originationDate":"2019-02-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/755","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthic-monitoring-during-wind-turbine-installation-operation-block-island-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/BOEM-2018-047\/","title":"Benthic Monitoring During Wind Turbine Installation and Operation at the Block Island Wind Farm, Rhode Island","description":"Key observations, data, findings, and results from benthic monitoring conducted in and around the Block Island Wind Farm (BIWF) Project Area are presented in this report. The monitoring was conducted to gather real-time data during the installation and initial operations of the wind turbine generators. The data collected during this monitoring will provide additional information necessary for the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management\u2019s (BOEM) evaluation of environmental effects of future facilities and generate data to improve the accuracy of models and analysis criteria employed to establish monitoring references and mitigations.  The overall goal of the study was to better understand the nature and potential spatial and temporal scales of anticipated alterations in benthic macrofaunal community characteristics because of the long-term placement of the turbine foundations on the seafloor. Key community characteristics evaluated included species abundance, richness, and assemblage structure, along with relationship dynamics between macrofaunal communities and their associated environments.","author":["King, J.","Khan, A.","English, P.","Bartley, M."],"organization":["HDR Engineering Inc","BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2018-02-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.177120000000","-71.557052000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BOEM-2018-047.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/756","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecology-infrastructure-decommissioning-north-sea-what-we-need-know-how-achieve-it","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsz143\/5543459","title":"The ecology of infrastructure decommissioning in the North Sea: what we need to know and how to achieve it","description":"As decommissioning of oil and gas (O\u0026amp;G) installations intensifies in the North Sea, and worldwide, debate rages regarding the fate of these novel habitats and their associated biota\u2014a debate that has important implications for future decommissioning of offshore wind farms (OWFs). Calls to relax complete removal requirements in some circumstances and allow part of an O\u0026amp;G installation to be left in the marine environment are increasing. Yet knowledge regarding the biological communities that develop on these structures and their ecological role in the North Sea is currently insufficient to inform such decommissioning decisions. To focus debate regarding decommissioning policy and guide ecological research, we review environmental policy objectives in the region, summarize existing knowledge regarding ecological aspects of decommissioning for both O\u0026amp;G and OWF installations, and identify approaches to address knowledge gaps through science\u2013industry collaboration. We find that in some cases complete removal will conflict with other policies regarding protection and restoration of reefs, as well as the conservation of species within the region. Key ecological considerations that are rarely considered during decommissioning decisions are: (i) provision of reef habitat, (ii) productivity of offshore ecosystems, (iii) enhancement of biodiversity, (iv) protection of the seabed from trawling, and (v) enhancement of connectivity. Knowledge gaps within these areas will best be addressed using industry infrastructure and vessels for scientific investigations, re-analysis of historical data held by industry, scientific training of industry personnel, joint research funding opportunities, and trial decommissioning projects.","author":["Degraer, S.","Rumes, B.","Brabant, R.","Jones, D.","Coolen, J.","Fowler, A.","J\u00f8rgensen, A.","Svendsen, J."],"organization":["University of Technology Sydney","Wageningen University and Research Centre","National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","Technical University of Denmark (DTU)","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2020-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fowler-et-al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/757","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecology-brown-crab-cancer-pagurus-production-potential-passive-fisheries-dutch","sourceURL":"https:\/\/library.wur.nl\/WebQuery\/wurpubs\/fulltext\/496176","title":"Ecology of the brown crab (Cancer pagurus) and production potential for passive fisheries in Dutch offshore windfarms","description":"With the rapid upscaling of offshore wind farms (OWF\u2019s) in the North Sea, pressures are mounting on other users, such as fisheries. Successful increase of OWF development and exploitation requires integration in the environment, in terms of ecology and multi-use. This poses an innovation challenge for multiple parties. OWF operators need to minimise the risks involved in multi-use. Spatial design of OWF\u2019s might need to be adapted. Fisheries need knowledge on alternative species with commercial potential and innovation on catch methods. Amongst others the passive low-impact fisheries of European lobster (Homarus gammarus) and brown crab (Cancer pagurus) have been proposed as excellent opportunities (Linley et al., 2007). To that extent a TKI tender has been awarded and the project Win-Wind on enabling this type of fisheries has commenced. The current research is part of phase 1 \u201cpreconditions for a demonstration pilot\u201d: generating the essential knowledge to proceed. Subsequent future phases comprise phase 2 \u201cimplementation pilot\u201d and phase 3 \u201cbusiness implementation and upscaling\u201d. This report on the ecology of brown crabs is a product of phase 1. Here we focus on the ecologic and sustainable feasibility of passive low impact brown crab fisheries by describing the general ecology of brown crabs in the North Sea and around Dutch OWF\u2019s in particular. It is currently unknown whether low impact brown crab fishery in offshore wind farms in the North Sea is feasible from an ecological point of view. This desk study provides an overview of current knowledge on brown crab ecology and a base document in order to create insight in harvest potential of brown crab (Cancer pagurus) within Dutch offshore wind farms.","author":["Tonk, L.","Rozemeijer, M."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","Topsector Energie"],"originationDate":"2019-10-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.113734000000","4.090375000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tonk_and_Rozemeijer_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/758","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/block-island-wind-farm-block-island-transmission-system-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/offshorewindhub.org\/resource\/1385","title":"Block Island Wind Farm and Block Island Transmission System Environmental Report\/Construction and Operations Plan","description":"Deepwater Wind Block Island, LLC, a wholly owned indirect subsidiary of Deepwater Wind Holdings, LLC, proposes to develop the Block Island Wind Farm (BIWF), a 30-megawatt (MW) offshore wind farm located on average approximately 3 miles (mi) (4.8 kilometers [km])1 southeast of Block Island, Rhode Island. The BIWF will consist of five, 6-MW wind turbine generators (WTGs), a submarine cable interconnecting the WTGs (Inter-Array Cable), and a 34.5-kilovolt (kV) transmission cable from the northernmost WTG to an interconnection point on Block Island (Export Cable). In connection with the BIWF, Deepwater Wind Block Island Transmission, LLC, also a wholly owned indirect subsidiary of Deepwater Wind Holdings, LLC, proposes to develop the Block Island Transmission System (BITS), a 34.5-kV alternating current (AC) bi-directional submarine transmission cable that will run up to approximately 21.8 miles (35.1 km) from Block Island to the Rhode Island mainland. The BITS will be capable of delivering power both to and from the Rhode Island mainland.  The BIWF is located entirely within Rhode Island state territorial waters. The BIWF WTGs, Inter-Array Cable, and a portion of the Export Cable are located within the Rhode Island Renewable Energy Zone established by the Rhode Island Coastal Resources Management Council (CRMC). The offshore BITS cable is located within Rhode Island state territorial waters and in federal waters on the outer continental shelf (OCS).   Deepwater Wind has prepared this ER to support the environmental assessment under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), as amended (42 USC 4321 et seq.), as well as the environmental analysis required as part of other federal, state, and local approvals and consultations for the Project.  The location of the WTG Array within the Rhode Island Renewable Energy Zone reflects substantial efforts undertaken with the involvement of agencies and stakeholders to choose a site that minimizes the potential impact on natural resources (benthic ecology, birds, marine mammals, sea turtles, fisheries resources, and habitat) and existing human uses (commercial and recreational fishing, cultural and historic sites, recreation and tourism, marine transportation, navigation and infrastructure). Deepwater Wind has taken further action to design a Project that avoids, minimizes, or mitigates effects to environmental resources.","author":["Tetra Tech Inc."],"organization":["Tetra Tech Inc.","Deepwater Wind"],"originationDate":"2012-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.174915000000","-71.556344000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BlockIsland_2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/759","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-energy-good-practice-impact-assessment-mitigation-compensation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.worldscientific.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1142\/S1464333217500053","title":"Offshore Wind Energy: Good Practice in Impact Assessment, Mitigation and Compensation","description":"Aiming towards good practice in the planning and approval of offshore wind farms suggestions are provided for the amendment of environmental impact assessment (EIA), an effective marine spatial planning and the establishment of marine compensation measure. The investigation is focused on the situation in Germany as a frontrunner in ecological research on offshore wind energy. After 10 years of research in Germany, it is timely to offer a synopsis of the results especially regarding the successful investigations of mitigation measures. The results are based on published data collected in Germany over the last 10 years, as well as international research. The outcomes of the research were validated by interviewing experts using the Delphi method.  Key findings for good practice in impact assessment, mitigation and compensation:    EIAs should focus on decision-relevant subjects of protection (i.e. specific bird species and harbour porpoises).  There is a strong necessity for thresholds for the approval process.  Exclusion of OWFs in hotspots of sensitive species.  Application of state-of-the-art mitigation measures particularly against underwater noise to avoid damages of the hearing of porpoises.  The introduction of marine compensation measures is strongly suggested.","author":["L\u00fcdeke, J."],"organization":["Technical University of Berlin"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.721651000000","10.227671000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/760","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-acceptance-offshore-wind-power-does-perceived-fairness-process-matter","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/09640568.2012.688658","title":"Public acceptance of offshore wind power: does perceived fairness of process matter?","description":"This paper analyses the findings of recent mail surveys of residents living near two proposed offshore wind power projects \u2013 Cape Wind off Massachusetts and Bluewater Wind off Delaware. In 2009, 57% supported Cape Wind, while 80% supported Bluewater Wind. To measure the relationship between perceptions of public process and substantive support or opposition, we assessed opinions of procedural fairness, local community voice and trust in developers. A plurality ofresidents in both cases is relatively satisfied with the process, while statistical modelling suggests that satisfaction with the process and outcome may be mutually reinforcing or jointly determined.","author":["Kempton, W.","Firestone, J.","Lilley, M.","Samoteskul, K."],"organization":["University of Delaware","University of Hawaii"],"originationDate":"2012-12-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.117489000000","-73.256840000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/761","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/perceptions-fishers-developers-co-location-offshore-wind-farms-decapod-fisheries-uk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X15001967","title":"Perceptions of fishers and developers on the co-location of offshore wind farms and decapod fisheries in the UK","description":"The predicted expansion of the global offshore wind sector is likely to increase conflicts as users of the coastal zone compete for space, and the displacement of fisheries is of particular concern. It is therefore important to explore opportunities that could support the co-existence of offshore wind farms (OWFs) and fishing activity. In addition to ecological evidence on the effects of OWFs on commercially exploited species, the co-location issue requires understanding of the perceptions of fishers and OWF developers on key constraints and opportunities. Interviews were carried out in 2013 with 67 fishers in South Wales and Eastern England and with 11 developers from major energy companies, to discover experiences and opinions on the co-location of OWFs with crab and lobster fisheries. Developers expressed broad support for co-location, perceiving potential benefits to their relationship with fishers and their wider reputation. Fishers had more mixed opinions, with geographical variation, and exhibited a range of risk perception. The lack of reported experience of potting within OWFs was not related to stock concerns but to uncertainty around safety, gear retrieval, insurance and liability. Clear protocols and communication to address these issues are essential if co-location is to be feasible. Scale may also limit the potential benefits to fishers, especially in that large offshore OWFs are likely to be inaccessible to much of the inshore fleet. There remains the potential to enhance the artificial reef effects of OWFs by deploying additional material between the turbines, but options to finance such schemes, and how investment by OWF developers could be offset against compensation paid to displaced fishers, require further investigation.\n\nHighlights:\nCrab and lobster fishing within offshore wind farms remains feasible.\nThere are site-specific attitudes and issues which need to be taken into account.\nScale and distance offshore may limit the potential benefits to inshore fishers.\nSuccessful co-location\u00a0requires early engagement and community management.\nProtocols for safety, insurance, liability and gear retrieval are essential.","author":["Ashley, M.","Hooper, T.","Austen, M."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2015-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.313926000000","-5.079389000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/762","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-biodiversity-development-north-sea-offshore-powerhouse","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.academia.edu\/36690374\/Marine_Biodiversity_and_the_Development_of_a_North_Sea_Offshore_Powerhouse","title":"Marine Biodiversity and the Development of a North Sea Offshore Powerhouse","description":"The purpose of this white paper is to support consensus and alignment around a sustainable North Sea renewable energy system and to explore the potential for North Sea renewable energy development to increase marine biodiversity. It does not set out a full assessment of ecological risks and opportunities. This paper is the third in a series of thought leadership pieces on the potential of a North Sea Offshore Powerhouse. The first and second pieces are A Potential North Sea Grid Powerhouse and The North Sea as a Hub for Renewable Energy, Sustainable Economies, and Biodiversity. Ecofys, a Navigant company, has a long track record in advising and working with many of the stakeholders involved in developing the North Sea renewable energy system. This work is independent and not funded by a third party. It is undertaken as part of the company\u2019s contribution to the growth of the industry.\n\nEcofys spoke to stakeholders from around the North Sea, including the European Commission services and national authorities, transmission system operators (TSOs) and offshore wind developers, nongovernmental organisations (NGOs), and fishery associations. The team asked for their opinions on the implications of the large number of projected offshore wind turbines in the North Sea and their level of involvement, what they believed the key knowledge gaps and anticipated ecological effects and benefits could be, and about how they had been engaged with as stakeholders. Finally, the team analysed stakeholders\u2019 reaction to a set of provocative hypotheses that included accelerating offshore wind rollout and maximising ecological benefits versus a rigid focus on impact mitigation.","author":["van Steen, H.","Buseman, M."],"organization":["Navigant Consulting Inc","Navigant Consulting Inc"],"originationDate":"2018-05-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.944943000000","4.597706000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Marine_Biodiversity_and_the_Development_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/763","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/perceptions-commercial-recreational-fishers-potential-ecological-impacts-block-island","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2018.00439\/full","title":"Perceptions of Commercial and Recreational Fishers on the Potential Ecological Impacts of the Block Island Wind Farm (US)","description":"Offshore wind is gaining momentum in the United States as a viable source for meeting domestic energy needs. Although offshore wind farms have been developed in Europe and Asia, the Block Island Wind Farm (BIWF) is the first offshore wind farm built in North America. To improve marine resource management, it is critical to understand the impacts of the wind farm on marine resource users in context. Little is known about the impacts of offshore wind farms on marine resource users in the United States. This study investigates recreational and commercial fishers\u2019 perceptions of the impacts of the BIWF on the local marine ecosystem. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 25 fishers, mostly based out of Block Island or Point Judith, Rhode Island (US), in the summer and fall of 2017. During the interviews, fishers were asked about their perceptions of changes in the marine ecology of the wind farm area during and after the offshore wind turbines were constructed, and how their activities in the area have changed since the wind farm was installed. Results indicate that there were perceived impacts of the BIWF on the local ecosystem and the behavior of the marine resource users. For some recreational fishers, the wind farm functioned as a destination or target and served as an artificial reef for spearfishing. For some commercial fishers, the increase in recreational fishing due to the establishment of the BIWF crowded out commercial fishers in these areas. As the offshore wind farm industry expands within US waters, findings from this study and others like it can provide valuable insights on the potential impacts of these wind farms on marine resource users.","author":["ten Brink, T.","Dalton, T."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2018-11-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.174915000000","-71.556344000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-17 03:59:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/tenBrink_Dalton_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/764","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-environmental-impacts-energy-performance-wind-farm-system-utilizing-life","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/12\/17\/3263","title":"Evaluating the Environmental Impacts and Energy Performance of a Wind Farm System Utilizing the Life-Cycle Assessment Method: A Practical Case Study","description":"The ever-increasing popularity of finding alternative forms of renewable energy has seen an increased interest and utilization of wind energy. The objective of this research therefore, is to evaluate the environmental impacts and energy performance of wind farms. This study was operationalized in Jordan using a life-cycle assessment (LCA) method. The environmental impact is evaluated through lifecycle emissions that include all emissions during various phases of the project. The energy performance is illustrated by the energy indicators. The latter is the energy payback ratio (EPR) and the energy payback time (EPT). This study was conducted on a 38 Vestas V112 3-MW wind turbine located in the southern region of Tafilah in Jordan that is host to the country\u2019s first wind farm. SimaPro 7.1 software was used as the modeling platform. Data for this study were collated from various sources, including, manufacturers, the wind turbine farm, and local subcontractors. A software database was used for the modeling process, and the data obtained modeled in accordance with ISO 14040 standards. The findings of this study indicate that the impacts of the transportation and installation phases were moderate, with the largest negative environmental impact deriving from the manufacturing phase. To remedy some of the negative impacts in these phases, green cement was used for the turbine foundation to limit the environmental impacts to be had during the installation phase, while the transportation phase saw the utilization of locally-manufactured turbines. Furthermore, an evaluation of the study\u2019s results revealed that the energy payback period of the wind farm is approximately 0.69 year (8 months), while the payback ratio is 29, and the annual CO2 saving estimated to be at 2.23 \u00d7 108 kg, 3.02 \u00d7 108 kg, 3.10 \u00d7 108 kg for an annual generated power of 371, 501, and 515 GWh\/year.","author":["Gomaa, M.","Rezk, H.","Mustafa, R.","Al-Dhaifallah, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-08-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.813056000000","35.586672000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-02 07:52:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/energies-12-03263-v2.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/765","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/optimising-tidal-lagoons-environmental-focus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.era.lib.ed.ac.uk\/handle\/1842\/36069","title":"Optimising tidal lagoons: an environmental focus","description":"Tidal lagoons could help towards meeting ambitious global and national renewable energy and carbon reduction targets, contributing towards tackling climate change through the displacement of fossil fuel generation. Lagoons have additional benefits over other forms of renewable energy which include: predictability, use of proven technology, long expected life spans (100 years) and the ability to be strategically located to provide a base load supply of continuous energy. Despite these advantages there are no tidal lagoons in the world to date, the key barriers to lagoon development have been cost and environmental concerns. This research shows how to optimise tidal lagoons in terms of the environment, considering the wider socio-economic implications of lagoon developments as multi-use facilities. Through industry engagement, the research provides a snapshot of industry perspectives, allowing presentation of the key environmental impacts and benefits of tidal lagoons. It then uses systematic literature review to investigate transferable solution options from other relevant coastal and marine industries to address these key impacts. Finally, the research demonstrates use of a potential methodology to select and assess solution options which allows for consideration of the wider environmental, socio-economic implications of lagoons. Unlike many other large-scale marine energy projects tidal lagoons have the potential to be multi-use, multi-benefit facilities which are likely to have far reaching environmental, social and economic impacts, both positive and negative. The lagoon sector is in its infancy with recent political debates arising over the \u2018value for money\u2019 of lagoons and the cost of developments to both the tax payer and to the environment. Independent research addressing the uncertainty surrounding the environmental impacts of lagoons and considering how to optimise lagoons in terms of the potential value they could provide to society is now more important than ever.","author":["Elliott, K."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2019-07-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/766","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/protocol-implementing-interim-population-consequences-disturbance-pcod-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/data.marine.gov.scot\/dataset\/protocol-implementing-interim-population-consequences-disturbance-pcod-approach-quantifying","title":"A Protocol for Implementing the Interim Population Consequences of Disturbance (PCoD) approach: Quantifying and Assessing the Effects of UK Offshore Renewable Energy Developments on Marine Mammal Populations","description":"14Our understanding of the effects of underwater noise and other disturbing activities on marine mammals, and of how to assess and quantify potential impacts, is rapidly evolving. The Steering Group for the Interim PCoD work emphasise that this framework is very much an interim measure, that is, the Interim PCoD approach has been developed to help developers, regulators and advisers working on offshore renewable energy projects now. It is expected that the framework will be further refined and built upon over time as more evidence becomes available. The Interim PCoD approach should be regarded as another tool among others already available for assessing potential impacts of disturbance on marine mammal populations. How appropriate it will be for use with particular projects and situations should be decided on a case by case basis. It is important that developers considering using the Interim PCoD approach seek advice from the SNCBs and\/or regulators at an early stage.","author":["Donovan, C.","Booth, C.","King, S.","Schick, R."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2013-11-14","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Booth_et_al_2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/767","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/endangered-atlantic-sturgeon-new-york-wind-energy-area-implications-future-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41598-019-48818-6","title":"Endangered Atlantic Sturgeon in the New York Wind Energy Area: implications of future development in an offshore wind energy site","description":"Imminent development of offshore wind farms on the outer continental shelf of the United States has led to significant concerns for marine wildlife. The scarcity of empirical data regarding fish species that may utilize development sites, further compounded by the novelty of the technology and inherent difficulty of conducting offshore research, make identification and assessment of potential stressors to species of concern problematic. However, there is broad potential to mitigate putatively negative impacts to seasonal migrants during the exploration and construction phases. The goal of this study was to establish baseline information on endangered Atlantic Sturgeon in the New York Wind Energy Area (NY WEA), a future offshore development site. Passive acoustic transceivers equipped with acoustic release mechanisms were used to monitor the movements of tagged fish in the NY WEA from November 2016 through February 2018 and resulted in detections of 181 unique individuals throughout the site. Detections were highly seasonal and peaked from November through January. Conversely, fish were relatively uncommon or entirely absent during the summer months (July\u2013September). Generalized additive models indicated that predictable transitions between coastal and offshore habitat were associated with long-term environmental cues and localized estuarine conditions, specifically the interaction between photoperiod and river temperature. These insights into the ecology of marine-resident Atlantic Sturgeon are crucial for both defining monitoring parameters and guiding threat assessments in offshore waters and represent an important initial step towards quantitatively evaluating Atlantic Sturgeon at a scale relevant to future development.","author":["Frisk, M.","Dunton, K.","Ingram, E.","Cerrato, R."],"organization":["Stony Brook University","Monmouth University"],"originationDate":"2019-08-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.417431000000","-73.603107000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-04 06:05:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ingram-2019-Sturgeon.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/768","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/simulation-study-potential-impacts-tidal-farm-eastern-waters-chengshan-cape-china","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s11802-019-3975-6","title":"Simulation Study of Potential Impacts of Tidal Farm in the Eastern Waters of Chengshan Cape, China","description":"The sea area east of Chenshan Cape has peak tidal current flows that exceed 2.3 m s\u22121, which make it a promising site for the development of tidal current energy. Before these resources can be exploited, a comprehensive assessment is needed of the potential environmental impacts of the extraction of this energy. In this paper, we describe our construction of a three-dimensional hydrodynamic model of the waters near Chengshan Cape, and verify the performance of the model using continuous data measured\u00a0in situ. We modeled the potential impacts of the exploitation of these resources on the flow field by adding a momentum loss term in the governing equation of the model. Simulation results show that an assumed tidal farm with an estimated power output of 20.34 MW would have a significant impact on the surrounding water level, especially next to the farm, where fluctuation could reach 6 cm. The maximum drop in the flow velocity in the wake of the farm was predicted to be more than 0.8 m s\u22121, and this influence would extend 10 km downstream.","author":["Wang, S.","Yuan, P.","Liu, X.","Yuan, S.","Tan, J.","Si, X."],"organization":["Ocean University of China"],"originationDate":"2019-08-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.255372000000","121.160707000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/769","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/local-non-local-geomorphic-effects-hydrokinetic-turbines-bridging-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/conservancy.umn.edu\/handle\/11299\/206426","title":"Local and Non-local Geomorphic Effects of Hydrokinetic Turbines: Bridging Renewable Energy and River Morphodynamics","description":"Marine and Hydrokinetic (MHK) energy is an emerging renewable and sustainable technology which harnesses kinetic energy of natural water flows such as tides, rivers and ocean currents. In particular, rivers are currently an overlooked source of local and continuous kinetic energy that can be exploited using the available in-stream converters technology. The uncertainties regarding the interaction between these devices and the surrounding environment complicate the regulatory permitting processes, slowing down the expansion of MHK industry. A crucial issue that needs further attention is the interaction between these devices and the physical fluvial environment such as the bathymetry, sediment transport, and the associated morphodynamic processes. Analytical and experimental research conducted at Saint Anthony Falls Laboratory (SAFL) addressed this topic, unveiling the local and non-local (far from the device location) effects of hydrokinetic turbines on channel bathymetry and morphology. A theoretical model framework based on the phenomenology of turbulence was derived to predict the scour at the base of MHK device. Asymmetric installations of turbine array models within multi-scale laboratory channels were observed to trigger river instabilities known as forced-bars. Results suggest that the amplitude of these instabilities might be reduced by limiting the power plant lateral obstruction within the channel cross-section. A 12-turbine staggered array also proved to be resilient to intense flooding conditions, encouraging the expansion of this technology to large sandy rivers. Current research is investigating how hydrokinetic technology can be synergistically integrated in rivers, not only minimizing the environmental costs but also providing a positive feedback on the channel. Experiments suggest that turbines strategically installed in the river (i.e. at the side bank in yawed condition or in a vane-shaped array) could be used as stream bank protection systems and, eventually, be integrated in stream restoration projects.","author":["Musa, M."],"organization":["University of Minnesota"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/770","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-activism-vertical-axis-wind-turbine-preferences-california","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/we.2399","title":"Environmental activism and vertical-axis wind turbine preferences in California","description":"Wind energy is widely recognized as a key element of the worldwide effort to limit greenhouse gas emissions. As compared with the general population, environmental activists have a much higher level of knowledge, interest, and capacity to affect the final outcome of a proposed wind turbine facility. To explore how their opinions on wind energy, particularly on vertical\u2010axis wind turbines, differ from the general public, we administered the same online experimental survey to a general population sample of adult Californians and to a self\u2010selected sample of online energy and environmental activists. We find that support for wind energy increases with the degree of environmental activism and engagement. The general public prefers vertical\u2010axis wind turbines in open spaces, away from one\u0027s residence. Location and price sensitivity, however, are weaker among activists. Among activists, attitudes about specific vertical\u2010axis wind turbine technologies are more crystalized and less susceptible to the information effects except on the topic of minimizing bird deaths.","author":["Hui, I.","Cain, B.","Dabiri, J."],"organization":["Stanford University"],"originationDate":"2019-08-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.607769000000","-119.627629000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/771","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/humpback-whale-encounter-offshore-wind-mooring-lines-inter-array-cables","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/BOEM-2018-065\/","title":"Humpback Whale Encounter with Offshore Wind Mooring Lines and Inter-Array Cables","description":"Floating offshore wind farms have been proposed in the deep waters off the U.S. west coast and Hawaii to provide renewable energy to coastal populations.Anchoring floating wind platforms to the seabed requires multiple mooring lines that pass through the water column from platforms at the surface to the sea floor. Electrical cables also will be draped in the water column between wind platforms. Concerns have been raised that large cetaceans might encounter lines from an offshore wind array, potentially causing harm, including entanglement, to the whales. There are few floating offshore wind arrays anywhere in the world where this encounter can be tested and no completely appropriate industrial analogues that can be applied. Understanding this potential risk to whales requires other means of visualizing the likelihood and mechanisms of encounter. An animation has been developed as a method for communicating this potential risk. This report provides the information used to create an animation of humpback whales encountering mooring lines and inter-array cables from a hypothetical floating offshore wind farm.","author":["Copping, A.","Grear, M."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["20.401614000000","-150.808567000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Entanglement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Copping_and_Grear_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/772","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/vulnerability-wind-power-climate-change-brazil","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148109004480","title":"The vulnerability of wind power to climate change in Brazil","description":"The availability and reliability of wind power depend a great deal on current and future climate conditions, which may vary in light of possible global climate change (GCC). Long-term energy planning, however, does not normally take possible future GCC into consideration, which may turn out to be a risky exercise. In the case of Brazil, the untapped wind power potential is known to be impressive, provided that climate conditions remain the same over time. The focus of this study is to analyze some possible impacts of GCC on the wind power potential of Brazil, by simulating wind conditions associated with the IPCC A2 and B2 Scenarios. Results based on the HadCM3 general circulation model and the analysis of the country\u0027s wind database indicate that the wind power potential in Brazil would not be jeopardized in the future due to possible new climate conditions. On the contrary, improved wind conditions are expected, particularly in the Northeast coast of the country. Therefore, investments in wind power generation can be an interesting way to expand renewable energy production in Brazil. However, given the large uncertainties associated with GCC models and scenarios, the findings of this paper should be viewed as a possibility rather than as a projection.","author":["Pereira de Lucena, A.","Szklo, A.","Schaeffer, R.","Dutra, R."],"organization":["Federal University of Rio de Janeiro","Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)"],"originationDate":"2010-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-8.735018000000","-52.881468000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/773","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-wind-energy-impacts-bats-testing-reduction-strategies-south-texas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digital.library.txstate.edu\/handle\/10877\/8463","title":"Understanding Wind Energy Impacts to Bats and Testing Reduction Strategies in South Texas","description":"Negative impacts from burning fossil fuels, including climate change, are promoting an increase in development of renewable energy alternatives. In response, wind energy development is expanding at an exponential rate across the globe. However, wind energy development has long been known to directly impact bats, which incur fatalities at wind turbines when struck by moving turbine blades. In the U.S., Texas is the leading producer of wind energy with approximately \u0026gt;13,300 commercially operating wind turbines while also having the greatest diversity of bats. Despite this, research in Texas on this topic is lacking with only a few wind energy facilities producing publicly available or peer-reviewed data. In this dissertation, I conducted one of the first comprehensive studies to understand and reduce wind energy impacts on bats in South Texas. My study site was the Los Vientos Wind Energy Facility with 255 wind turbines encompassing 22,666 ha in Starr County, Texas, part of the Lower Rio Grande Valley region. For my first study I estimated bat fatality rates at Los Vientos using a novel fatality estimator and reported a moderate to high fatality rate, in which Brazilian free-tailed bats (Tadarida brasiliensis) were the most impacted species. Based on my results, I recommend bat impact reduction strategies for this location and others in the region experiencing similar impacts. Los Vientos has a similar bat species composition and climate as other regions in the southwestern U.S. and northern Mexico which also lack data on wind energy impacts to bats. My results might provide insights and guidance for these regions as well. In my second study, I monitored bat acoustic activity at three wind turbines at Los Vientos during late summer to early fall. I investigated relationships between bat activity and bat fatality, weather, and temporal covariates to further our understanding of conditions under which bats are at risk. My results revealed specific climatic (e.g., low wind speeds) and temporal conditions (e.g., hour of the night) during which bats are most active at wind turbines, and showed a positive relationship between activity and fatality, thereby highlighting conditions in which bats are more susceptible to fatality. In my final study, I tested the efficacy of a novel ultrasonic acoustic deterrent system to reduce bat fatalities at wind turbines. Results of my study indicate this technology is a promising tool for reducing fatalities of Brazilian free-tailed bats and hoary bats (Lasiurus cinereus). This was one of the most successful field trials using acoustic deterrents to date. However, my results indicate species-specific responses to deterrents, particularly for yellow bat spp. Therefore, I conclude the technology warrants further studies to increase effectiveness for more species. Studies investigating wind energy impacts to bats are timely, relevant, and necessary for conservation of imperiled species, informing policy, and guiding responsible wind energy development. Moreover, developing regional and site-specific impact reduction strategies are important for maximizing the generation of renewable energy. Results of my studies can be used to develop such strategies in other data-deficient regions with similar climates and bat species such as the southwestern U.S. and northern Mexico, and with further improvements, the applications of the acoustic deterrent technology I tested are potentially global in reach.","author":["Weaver, S."],"organization":["Texas State University"],"originationDate":"2019-08-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["26.561225000000","-98.779130000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/774","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-two-different-2-mw-class-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148111002254","title":"Life cycle assessment of two different 2 MW class wind turbines","description":"Although wind technology produces no emissions during operation, there is an environmental impact associated with the wind turbine during the entire life cycle of the plant, from production to dismantling. A life cycle assessment is carried out to quantify the environmental impact of two existing wind turbines, a 1.8\u00a0MW-gearless turbine and a 2.0\u00a0MW turbine with gearbox. Both technologies will be compared by means of material usage, carbon dioxide emissions and energy payback time based on the cumulative energy requirements for a 20 year life period. For a quantitative analysis of the material and energy balances over the entire life cycle, the simulation software GEMIS\u00ae\u00a0(Global Emission Model of Integrated System) is used.\n\nThe results show, as expected, that the largest energy requirement contribution is derived mainly from the manufacturing phase, representing 84.4% of the total life cycle, and particularly from the tower construction which accounts for 55% of the total turbine production. The average energy payback time for both turbines is found to be 7 months and the emissions 9 gCO2\/kWh. Different scenarios regarding operation performance, recycling of materials and different manufacturing countries such as Germany, Denmark and China are analysed and the energy payback time and carbon dioxide values obtained. Finally, the wind energy plant is compared with other renewable and non-renewable sources of energy to conclude that wind energy is among the cleanest sources of energy available nowadays.","author":["Guezuraga, B.","Zauner, R.","Polz, W."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2012-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/775","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/noise-impact-assessment-basis-onsite-acoustic-noise-immission-measurements","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148111006112","title":"Noise impact assessment on the basis of onsite acoustic noise immission measurements for a representative wind farm","description":"Wind energy, comprising a techno-economically mature and clean technology, is not entirely free of impacts on the environment and human health. In this context, noise still comprises a major siting criterion, even hindering the approval for the installation of new wind power projects. The present study evaluates the noise level immission using real acoustic measurements of a representative wind farm, while these measurements are also compared with simulation results of two well-known noise immission prediction models. Emphasis is firstly given on the development of a reliable experimental process and secondly on the estimation of the real noise impact of the existing wind turbines dissociated by the background noise for several wind speed values and distances from the wind farm. According to the results obtained, validation of the prediction models is provided by observing a fairly good agreement between experimental and simulated results. Furthermore, wind farms may be characterized as relatively low noise emission sources, compared to other industrial units or conventional power plants, as the sound pressure level (SPL) at a distance of 300 m away is almost 45 dB(A), i.e. not a prohibitive value for human activities in the wind farm\u2019s broader area.","author":["Kaldellis, J.","Kapsali, M.","Garakis, K."],"organization":["TEI of Piraeus"],"originationDate":"2012-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.734965000000","24.026867000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/776","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-array-shape-tidal-stream-turbines-hydro-environmental-impacts-power-output","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148112001450","title":"Assessment of array shape of tidal stream turbines on hydro-environmental impacts and power output","description":"This study investigates the significance of the layout of an array of tidal stream turbines on the power output and the hydro-environmental impacts array using the Research Centre\u2019s widely used open-source hydro-environmental model, namely DIVAST (Depth Integrated Velocities And Solute Transport), which was modified by the authors to include turbines as momentum sinks, to simulate the impact of an array of turbines in a coastal environment. For this purpose, three various layouts of an array of turbines, having the same number of turbines and located in the Severn Estuary and Bristol Channel, were modelled and compared. The estuary, including the Bristol Channel, is approximately 200\u00a0km long and with a typical spring tidal range of over 14\u00a0m has the third highest rise and fall of tide in the world, with the spring tidal currents in the estuary being well in excess of 2\u00a0m\/s.\n\nThe study has demonstrated that the impacts of the arrays on the water levels and the maximum water levels which are associated with the flood risk were very small. However, the tidal currents were more significantly influenced by the tidal turbine arrays. The flow velocity field, suspended sediment levels and faecal bacteria levels were increased on the side of the arrays, whilst they were reduced both upstream and downstream of the arrays. The model showed the significance of including the interaction of the turbines and the flow in assessing the potential power output by comparing the discrepancy in the estimated power output of the various arrays, both with and without the inclusion of the impact of energy extraction by the turbines in the model. Moreover, the model showed that the available power during a neap ebb tide was significantly less than (","author":["Ahmadian, R.","Falconer, R."],"organization":["Cardiff University"],"originationDate":"2012-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.361510000000","-4.302095000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/777","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-raptor-sections-bluestone-wind-avian-risk-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doas.us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2019\/04\/Review-of-Raptor-Sections-of-the-Bluestone-Wind-Avian-Risk-Assessment_20190329.pdf","title":"Review of Raptor Sections of the Bluestone Wind Avian Risk Assessment","description":"The Bluestone Wind Project (BWP) has been proposed for construction on the Northern Allegheny Plateau in Broome County, New York. Because both Bald and Golden Eagles are known to be killed by wind turbines and are federally protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act and the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (Pagel et al. 2013), the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service recommends that wind energy projects conduct surveys for eagles as part of a risk assessment to determine if eagles are likely to be incidentally taken at a facility during normal operating of that facility (USFWS 2013). WEST, Inc. (hereafter, WEST) was contracted to conduct eagle use surveys for BWP.  Delaware-Otsego Audubon Society (DOAS) requested New York State Article 10 Siting Process Intervenor Funding in October 2017 to garner funds to assess telemetry data and conduct independent surveys of the project area for raptors including eagles. DOAS requested intervenor funds for a second time in February 2019 so that, among other things, materials and reports could receive an independent review by an outside scientist and eagle expert.  The purpose of this report is to review the raptor sections included in the BWP Avian Risk Assessment (ARA). This review was conducted in a manner similar to peer review of a scientific manuscript.","author":["Miller, T."],"organization":["Conservation Science Global","New York State Department of State"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.140084000000","-75.812412000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Miller_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/778","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-wind-energy-survey-protocols-migrating-eagle-detection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/wsb.934","title":"Evaluation of Wind-Energy Survey Protocols for Migrating Eagle Detection","description":"Wind energy development is increasing in the United States and Canada and may affect bald (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) and golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetos) populations through direct mortality. Wind farms on ridge\u2010tops may present a greater mortality threat because of the importance of these features for migrating raptors. Regulators in both countries recommend methods for preconstruction surveys, so that eagle use and collision risk can be assessed at potential construction sites. We obtained hourly count data collected during the autumn seasons of 1990\u20132014 from 22 ridge\u2010top raptor\u2010migration monitoring sites in the Pacific, Eastern, and Central flyways of North America. We simulated 18 different survey protocols and effort levels based on survey guidance by repeatedly drawing quasi\u2010random subsamples from continuously collected data in a manner that imitated the recommended protocols, comparing the number of eagles seen in simulated counts to the eagles seen in all data collected to assess the effectiveness of those protocols in correctly estimating the eagle passage rate (eagles detected per hour of counts) at each site. Multihour point counts conducted on a weekly basis were found to be ineffective at correctly estimating eagle passage both within and across years. Counts conducted in the afternoon were found to be more effective than those conducted in the morning. We demonstrate that full\u2010day counts, conducted weekly during the peak period of eagle passage, were much more effective at estimating eagle passage rate. Although current guidance recommends the performance of such full day counts, this result underscores their importance in preconstruction surveys at potential wind sites as an essential tactic to estimate eagle passage and risk of collision with energy infrastructure.\u00a0","author":["Chabot, E.","Slater, S."],"organization":["HawkWatch International"],"originationDate":"2018-12-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/779","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-wind-energy-development-columbian-sharp-tailed-grouse-tympanuchus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/etd\/5908\/","title":"The Influence of Wind Energy Development on Columbian Sharp-tailed Grouse (Tympanuchus phasianellus columbianus) Breeding Season Ecology in Eastern Idaho","description":"The Columbian sharp-tailed grouse (Tympanuchus phasianellus columbianus; CSTG) has experienced range-wide population declines, primarily as a result of habitat loss or degradation, and currently occupies \u0026lt;10% of its historic range. Expansion of wind energy developments across the remaining occupied CSTG range has been identified as a potential threat to the species. To assess the potential influence of wind energy development on CSTG breeding season ecology, I captured and radio-marked 135 female CSTG during 2014-2015 at leks located between 0.1-13.8 km from wind turbines in restored grassland habitats. I subsequently monitored 147 nests and 68 broods and used an information-theoretic model selection approach to assess the potential influence of wind energy distance and density variables, multi-scale habitat features, temporal factors, and precipitation on CSTG nest site selection, daily nest survival, brood success, and chick survival. The best nest site selection model suggested a positive functional response to the amount of restored grassland habitat with \u0026gt;30% forb cover at the nesting core use (60 ha) scale. Daily nest survival was positively associated with visual obstruction readings at the nest and the amount of restored grassland habitat containing \u0026gt;30% forb cover at the core use (60 ha) scale. Nest site selection and daily nest survival were not influenced by proximity to turbines or turbine density at the core use or breeding season home range (1385 ha) scales. Early (14-day) brood success was positively influenced by post-hatch precipitation and late (42-day) brood success was positively influenced by earlier hatch dates. Chick survival to 42 days post hatch was positively influenced by post-hatch precipitation and earlier hatch dates and negatively influenced by increasing densities of wind turbines at the breeding season home range scale. The probability of an individual chick surviving to 42 days decreased by 50% when there were \u226510 turbines within 2.1 km of the nest. In restored grassland habitats, such as Conservation Reserve Program fields, I recommend plantings and management practices that will result in diverse, bunchgrass-dominated nesting habitat with residual grass cover and \u0026gt;30% forb canopy cover during the nesting season. My results suggest that wind turbines occurring within 2.1 km of nesting habitats (i.e., 4.8 km of occupied leks) may negatively affect CSTG recruitment.","author":["Proett, M."],"organization":["Utah State University"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.557441000000","-114.233332000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/780","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/columbian-sharp-tailed-grouse-nesting-ecology-wind-energy-habitat","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/jwmg.21673","title":"Columbian sharp-tailed grouse nesting ecology: wind energy and habitat","description":"The rapid pace of wind\u2010energy development has increased stakeholder concerns regarding the potential effects on wildlife. Locations targeted for wind\u2010energy development frequently overlap prairie grouse and greater sage\u2010grouse (Centrocercus urophasianus) habitats. Research suggests that anthropogenic developments may have negative effects on these species. There is, however, no information published regarding the effect of wind\u2010energy development on Columbian sharp\u2010tailed grouse (Tympanuchus phasianellus columbianus), a subspecies that has twice been petitioned for Endangered Species Act protection. To address this need, from 2014 to 2015 we studied Columbian sharp\u2010tailed grouse nesting ecology across restored grasslands in eastern Idaho, USA, where a 215\u2010turbine wind\u2010energy complex had been developed. We monitored 147 nests from 135 females captured at leks 0.1\u201313.8\u2009km from wind turbines. We used an information\u2010theoretic approach to evaluate the influence of wind\u2010energy infrastructure and habitat characteristics on nest\u2010site selection and daily nest survival. We did not detect any influence of wind\u2010energy infrastructure on nest\u2010site selection or nest survival. Nest\u2010site selection and daily nest survival were influenced by vegetation structure and composition measured at 2 spatial scales. Females selected nest sites with more restored grassland containing \u0026gt;30% forb cover within the nesting core\u2010use area (i.e., 60\u2009ha around the nest) and exhibited a functional response to the availability of that land cover type. Daily nest survival was best predicted by visual obstruction at the nest site and the amount of restored grassland containing \u0026gt;30% forb cover within the nesting core\u2010use area. We recommend wildlife managers continue to implement management practices that will provide bunchgrass\u2010dominated grasslands with \u0026gt;30% forb cover in restored grasslands (e.g., Conservation Reserve Program fields) within Columbian sharp\u2010tailed grouse range.","author":["Horne, J.","Proett, M.","Roberts, S.","Koons, D.","Messmer, T."],"organization":["Idaho Department of Fish and Game","Utah State University"],"originationDate":"2019-05-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.474760000000","-114.303309000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/781","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/red-bat-fatality-geographic-extents-through-deuterium-niche-models","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21721","title":"Red bat fatality: Geographic extents through deuterium and niche models","description":"Bat fatality at wind energy facilities is a conservation issue, but its effect on bat populations is difficult to estimate. We have little understanding of wind turbine effects on bat population persistence, in part because we have poor knowledge of bat migration pathways and hence the source populations for individual fatalities. We used deuterium ratio analysis combined with genetic algorithm for rule\u2010set prediction and the web\u2010based isoscapes modeling, analysis, and prediction in a geographic information system environment as a novel approach. Our objectives were to explore the utility of these methods together and map the geographic extents of eastern red bat (Lasiurus borealis) specimens salvaged in 2008\u20132010 from a single, 92\u2010km2 wind energy facility in Illinois, USA. Results indicate that combining these methods can be successful and support their use with species where ranges may be less well defined. Because of the migratory nature of this species and the range of deuterium values of pixels in our isotope model, we predicted that 18% and 82% of the specimens would have isotope results inside and outside of the wind facility\u0027s isocline respectively. We concluded that 71.4% of the specimens had isotope signatures placing them outside the wind facility\u0027s isocline. It could be argued that the wide distribution of bat fatalities dilutes the overall effect of those fatalities on the bat species; however, if other facilities show a similar pattern, each facility could have cumulative and far reaching population\u2010level effects.","author":["Johnson, G.","Capparella, A.","Murtaugh, R.","Kostelnick, J."],"organization":["Illinois State University","Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2019-07-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.220515000000","-89.493642000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Murtaghetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/782","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predictable-shorebird-departure-patterns-staging-site-can-inform-collision-risks","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1111\/ibi.12771","title":"Predictable shorebird departure patterns from a staging site can inform collision risks and mitigation of wind energy developments","description":"High quality staging sites are critical for long distance migratory shorebirds to rest and refuel but are under threat from human development, including expansion in wind energy projects. However, predicting migration timing and movements in relation to weather conditions at staging sites can increase our understanding and mitigate effects of wind turbine collisions. Here we assessed northward migration timing and orientation in relation to environmental conditions at an inland staging area in Saskatchewan, Canada with active and proposed wind energy developments. The area is known to host ~25% of North America\u0027s Sanderling Calidris alba population and 16 other arctic\u2010breeding migrant shorebird species. We quantified arrival and departure time of day in relation to weather using data from 237 Sanderlings radiotagged locally and at a southern staging site in the Gulf of Mexico with the Motus Wildlife Tracking System (April\u2010June, 2015\u20102017). While Sanderling arrival times were not related to time of day or weather, departures were more likely at sunset in winds blowing towards the northwest at intermediate speeds (\u0026lt;22 km\/h). Departure flights were also primarily oriented north\u2010northwest in the direction of a proposed wind energy development site at a mean ground speed of 21.4 m\/s. Based on published climb rates and flight speed data, we estimated that shorebirds needed between 2 and 14 km setback distance to clear maximum turbine heights of 165m. Given that departure events were predictable in time and space, adaptive mitigation may be useful for planning wind energy developments while reducing risk for staging Arctic shorebirds.","author":["Howell, J.","McKellar, A.","Espie, R.","Morrissey, C."],"organization":["University of Saskatchewan","Canadian Wildlife Service"],"originationDate":"2019-08-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.402452000000","-107.104445000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Shorebirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/783","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/strategic-marine-planning-project-licences-striking-balance-between-predictability","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X19303215","title":"From strategic marine planning to project licences \u2013 Striking a balance between predictability and adaptability in the management of aquaculture and offshore wind farms","description":"Renewable energy and sustainable food production are high on the international agenda, as is the prospect of expanding activity northwards to Arctic waters. In this article, we review core elements of the marine governance systems for aquaculture facilities and offshore wind farms in Norway and Scotland. Management of these sectors through strategic planning, marine spatial planning and licensing systems furthers rule of law values such as stability and predictability, making investment less risky. The review illustrates how the governance systems also facilitate flexibility and adaptability, balancing predictability considerations against the need to adapt management to natural and economic changes and innovative technologies, or even effective multi-use. This article discusses what endeavours have been made to strike a balance between predictability and adaptability in these sectors in Norway and Scotland. This study of marine management regimes in the Arctic and northern parts of the Temperate Northern Atlantic, and the values underpinning these regimes, provides lessons for the future of the Arctic.","author":["Sch\u00fctz, S.","Slater, A."],"organization":["University of Bergen","University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2019-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.883701000000","1.491243000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/784","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-impacts-energy-development-shrublands-western-north-america","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/nrei\/vol17\/iss1\/14\/","title":"Potential impacts of energy development on shrublands in western North America","description":"Impending rapid development of the abundant energy resources found in western North America may have dramatic consequences for its terrestrial ecosystems. We used lease and license data to provide an approximate estimate of direct and indirect potential impacts from renewable and non-renewable energy development on each of five major terrestrial ecosystems and completed more detailed analyses for shrubland ecosystems. We found that energy development could impact up to 21 percent (96 million ha) of the five major ecosystems in western North America. The highest overall predicted impacts as a percent of the ecosystem type are to boreal forest (23-32 percent), shrublands (6-24 percent), and grasslands (9-21 percent). In absolute terms, the largest potential impacts are to shrublands (9.9 to 41.1 million ha). Oil, gas, wind, solar, and geothermal development each have their greatest potential impacts on shrublands. The impacts to shrublands occur in all ecological regions across western North America, but potential impacts are greatest in the North American Deserts (up to 27 percent or 25.8 million ha), Great Plains (up to 24 percent or 8.9 million ha), and Northern Forests (up to 47 percent or 4.3 million ha). Conventional oil and gas development accounts for the largest proportion of the potential impact in all three of these regions. Some states or provinces may experience particularly large impacts to shrublands, including Alberta and Wyoming, where potential for oil and gas development is especially high, and New Mexico, where solar development could potentially affect large areas of shrubland. Understanding the scale of anticipated impacts to these ecosystems through this type of coarse-scale analysis may help to catalyze policy makers to engage in proactive planning.","author":["Copeland, H.","Pocewicz, A.","Kiesecker, J."],"organization":["The Nature Conservancy"],"originationDate":"2011-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.538111000000","-106.307630000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/785","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/land-use-requirements-modern-wind-power-plants-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/964608","title":"Land-Use Requirements of Modern Wind Power Plants in the United States","description":"By the end of 2008, a combination of environmental, economic, and policy factors resulted in the cumulative deployment of more than 25 gigawatts (GW) of wind generation capacity in the United States (AWEA 2009a). Continued growth is anticipated due to renewable portfolio standards and expected constraints on carbon emissions in the electric sector. One of the concerns regarding large-scale deployment of wind energy is its potentially significant land use. Estimates of land use in the existing literature are often based on simplified assumptions, including power plant configurations that do not reflect actual development practices to date. Land-use descriptions for many projects are available from various permitting agencies and other public sources, but we are not aware of any single source that compiles or summarizes this data. In addition, there is limited information comparing land use for wind power plants across different terrain and plant configurations. The existing data and analyses limit the effective quantification of landuse impacts for existing and future wind energy generation, particularly in comparison to other electricity generation technologies.  In this report, we provide data and analysis of the land use associated with modern, large wind power plants (defined as greater than 20 megawatts (MW) and constructed after 2000). We begin by discussing standard land-use metrics as established in the life-cycle assessment literature, and then discuss their applicability to wind power plants. We identify two major \u201cclasses\u201d of wind plant land use: 1) direct impact (i.e., disturbed land due to physical infrastructure development), and 2) total area (i.e., land associated with the complete wind plant project). We also provide data for each of these classes, derived from project applications, environmental impact statements, and other sources. We also attempt to identify relationships among land use, wind plant configuration, and geography. We evaluated 172 existing or proposed projects, which represents more than 26 GW of capacity.  In addition to providing land-use data and summary statistics, we identify several limitations to the existing wind project area data sets, and suggest additional analysis that could aid in evaluating actual land use and impacts associated with deployment of wind energy","author":["Denholm, P.","Hand, M.","Jackson, M.","Ong, S."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2009-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.461651500000","-101.609717000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Denholm_et_al_2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/786","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-tidal-energy-development-sea-level-rise-gulf-maine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544219316263","title":"The impacts of tidal energy development and sea-level rise in the Gulf of Maine","description":"In this study, we employed a 3-D and two-way nested Regional Ocean Modeling System (ROMS) to address several important outstanding issues regarding tidal energy development in the Gulf of Maine. We investigated the impact of projected sea-level rise (SLR) on the energy resources of the region, and examined how tidal dynamics will be influenced by energy extraction and\/or SLR. Further, we assessed whether the effect of SLR on the generation of tides in the ocean (hence at the boundary of the region) is significant in these assessments. We find that the impact of SLR exceeds the impact due to energy extraction in the Gulf of Maine - even when considering very large energy extraction, of order 3.0\u202fGW, in the Minas Passage. Although results showed that energy extraction does not significantly increase the amplitude of the tides in the far-field, a drastic change in the Bay of Fundy (e.g. full blockage) can lead to considerably higher amplitudes of tides (around 35\u202fcm, or 12%) in the western Gulf of Maine. As a result of 1\u202fm SLR, the theoretical tidal energy resources in some areas, including the Bay of Fundy can increase noticeably while any significant change in extracted energy highly depends on the turbine technology.","author":["Neill, S.","Green, J.","Hashemi, M.","Kresning, B.","Xue, H."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island","Bangor University","University of Maine"],"originationDate":"2019-11-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.159549000000","-68.340212000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/787","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/alteration-shallow-water-tides-tidal-asymmetry-tidal-stream-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.research.lancs.ac.uk\/portal\/en\/publications\/alteration-to-the-shallowwater-tides-and-tidal-asymmetry-by-tidalstream-turbines(b5c42086-cced-47c5-81fb-819ea26853f8).html","title":"Alteration to the shallow-water tides and tidal asymmetry by tidal-stream turbines","description":"Tidal flow velocity asymmetry (FVA) plays a crucial role in residual sediment transport and has been shown to impact significantly on the amount of tidal energy that is technically extricable by tidal-stream turbines (TSTs). TSTs are known to alter tidal hydrodynamics locally, and large arrays of turbines do this on regional scales. However, less is known about the effect of TSTs on the FVA. This thesis explores changes to the FVA and therefore the shallow-water tidal constituents resulting from the deployment of TSTs. Numerical experiments in a uniform rectangular channel were undertaken, using the MIKE21 software package. The effects of single TSTs and multiple TSTs on tidal hydrodynamics were simulated, as well as those of a single TST on sediment transport. Flood-ebb asymmetry in the spatial distribution of current attenuation by the turbines altered the FVA. The overall attenuation of the current led to predictable changes in the total available tidal energy per tidal cycle, and the gross volume of sediment transported. The attenuation of the current by the TSTs was of greater importance to these aspects of the environment than any changes to the FVA that they caused. Changes in the FVA led to changes in the flood-ebb asymmetry of the available power, and the net volume of sediment transported, and were of far greater importance than the overall attenuation of the current in these respects. Multiple turbines deployed in a line along the channel, such that their areas of effect overlapped, had an additive effect on the FVA. When deployed as a row across the channel width, the total area affected by the turbines remained similar to that of a single turbine, so long as an inter-turbine spacing of at least three turbine diameters was maintained.","author":["Potter, D."],"organization":["Lancaster University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/788","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interference-flying-insects-wind-parks","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wind-watch.org\/documents\/interference-of-flying-insects-and-wind-parks\/","title":"Interference of Flying Insects and Wind Parks","description":"The study investigates possible coherence of flying insect losses recently discovered in Germany and\ninsect impingement on the rotor blades of wind turbines.\n\n\nEvidence from literature confirms that migrating insects select fast air streams above the turbulent\nsurface layer of the atmosphere for the purpose of efficient displacement to breeding grounds. Wind\nfarm developers select sites with strong winds and install high towers with rotors just above the\nsurface layer in order to optimize the energy output of their wind turbines. As a result of this\ncoincidence, large numbers of flying insects can be expected in wind farms.\n\n\nModel calculation of the amount of insect biomass that traverses wind rotors during operation\nprovides a first estimate of the order of magnitude of 24,000 tons of insects crossing the German\nwind park throughout the summer season. Based on conservative model assumptions, five percent of\nthe insects flying through a rotor could be actually damaged. The related loss of 1,200 tons per year\nsince more than fifteen years could be relevant for population stability.\n\n\nSpecies flying at critical rotor heights between 20 and 220 meters above ground level in addition to\nthose already found within this study should urgently be identified by DNA meta-barcoding of the\ndeposits that are regularly found on rotor blades. In addition to that, wind farms should be enabled\nto recognize approaching insect swarms and to react accordingly for their protection and\nconservation.","author":["Trieb, F."],"organization":["German Aerospace Center (DLR)","German Aerospace Center (DLR)"],"originationDate":"2018-10-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Collision","Attraction","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/FliWip-Final-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/789","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-renewable-energy-development-plan-oredp-ireland-strategic-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.seai.ie\/resources\/publications\/OREDP-SEA-ER-Volume-1-Non-Technical-Summary.pdf","title":"Offshore Renewable Energy Development Plan (OREDP) For Ireland: Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA): Volume 1: Non - Technical Summary (NTS)","description":"This document provides a Non-Technical Summary of the results of the Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) of the Offshore Renewable Energy Development Plan (OREDP) for Ireland. The OREDP, which is the subject of this SEA, includes scenarios for the development of offshore renewable energy in Irish waters up to 2030, including an initial review in 2015 and a full review in 2020. The main issues covered in the SEA are listed below. This list is derived from the SEA Directive and refined to make it relevant to the coastal and marine environment. The effects of offshore wind and marine renewable energy developments on these issues\/subjects are summarised in Section 6: Assessment Results. The issues covered in the SEA include:    Soil and water (substrate including sediment, geology, geomorphology and coastal processes, water quality).  Biodiversity, flora and fauna (protected sites and species including sea birds, fish, marine mammals and reptiles, benthic ecology).  Cultural heritage including archaeological heritage (marine and coastal archaeological and historical natural\/built environment including wrecks and submerged landscapes).  Population and human health (commercial fishing, aquaculture, shipping and navigation including navigational safety, ports and harbours, recreation and tourism, radar interference and military practice areas).  Material assets (cables and pipelines, coastal infrastructure, oil and gas infrastructure, aggregates, dredging and disposal areas).  Landscape\/Seascape (seascape quality and character).  Climatic factors (Renewable energy developments, CO2 emissions, carbon storage and responding to climate change e.g. threat of sea level rise on coastal infrastructure.","author":["Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI)"],"organization":["Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI)"],"originationDate":"2010-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.168871000000","-7.691427000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OREDP-SEA-ER-Volume-1-Non-Technical-Summary-2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/790","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/jwgbird-report-2018-report-joint-osparhelcomices-working-group-marine-birds-jwgbird","sourceURL":"https:\/\/orbit.dtu.dk\/files\/239871201\/2018_Report_of_the_Joint_OSPARHELCOMICES_Working_Grou.pdf","title":"JWGBIRD Report 2018: Report of the Joint OSPAR\/HELCOM\/ICES Working Group on Marine Birds (JWGBIRD)","description":"Hosted by the Flanders Marine Institute, the Joint ICES\/OSPAR\/HELCOM Working Group on Seabirds met in Ostende, Belgium, 1\u20135 October 2018. The meeting was cochaired by Morten Frederiksen, Ian Mitchell and Volker Dierschke, and was attended by 15 members representing 11 countries. Following the tradition of the preceding meetings, the objectives of the meeting were to develop and implement indicators for seabirds under the Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD), as well as to review and discuss seabird-related issues relevant for human uses of the sea. The meeting consisted of a series of interconnected workshops, where subgroups with floating membership discussed Terms of Reference. Report chapters were drafted by Term of Reference leads and collated by the chairs.  Further refinements of the existing indictor for breeding productivity in OSPAR were discussed. The suggested approach uses matrix population models to assess the impact of the observed level of breeding productivity on population growth rate, and relates the projected growth rate to IUCN criteria for species red-listing. Links between trends in population abundance (HELCOM) and potential drivers were explored. Preliminary results are complex and require further interpretation. A combined mid-winter aerial survey of the offshore Baltic was carried out in early 2016. The data have been collated, but results are not ready yet. The group discussed integration rules for GES assessments of birds under MSFD, both within and across species. ICES workshops in 2018 resulted in advice on these rules. JWGBIRD mostly agree with this advice, but propose a few changes. JWGBIRD reviewed the UK national assessment of seabirds under MSFD, and made suggestions for further development of indicators. A reporting template for the periodic assessments of OSPAR Threatened and\/or Declining Species and Habitats was tested for the black-legged kittiwake.  The group reviewed the progress so far on assessing bycatch mortality of marine birds in the NE Atlantic. The main limitation currently is the near absence of regular monitoring data on bycatch of birds. This also hampers the definition of threshold values for the MSFD indicator D1C1. The information collated by JWGBIRD will be used to inform a joint OSPAR-HELCOM workshop to examine possibilities for developing indicators for incidental by-catch of birds and marine mammals, planned for September 2019.  JWGBIRD provided input to the HELCOM indicator review process as well as to the HELCOM workshop on migratory waterbirds in November 2018.","author":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"organization":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:21:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ICES-JWGBIRD-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/791","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ices-wgmbred-report-2018-report-working-group-marine-benthal-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"","title":"ICES WGMBRED Report 2018: Report of the Working Group on Marine Benthal and Renewable Energy Developments (WGMBRED)","description":"In the most recent multi-annual cycle of the Working Group on Marine Benthal and Renewable Energy Developments (WGMBRED), three meetings were held: 14\u201318 March 2016, Delft, the Netherlands (22 experts); 6\u201310 March 2017, Gdynia, Poland (19 experts); and 6\u20139 March 2018, Galway, Ireland (15 experts).  Our focus throughout has been on addressing the \u2018So what?\u2019 question in relation to the interaction between marine renewable energy developments and the benthic ecosystem. The main themes which WGMBRED captured under the Terms of References during the annual meetings and intersessionally focused on understanding the importance of the benthic ecosystem interacting with marine renewable energy developments and ensuring effective communication of scientific findings from the group. The main topics covered were:    spatial and temporal scale (e.g. the interaction between a device and the benthic species, how these changes could occur at the scale of an array or over larger scales of defined regions\/over time);  the extent of knowledge available (leading to an understanding of the causeeffect pathways between benthos and marine renewable energy devices and developments) in order to identify gaps in knowledge;  development of indicators to measure the effects arising;  understanding how effective the benthic ecologists working on the interactions between the benthal and marine renewables were able to cascade these scientific messages.   The WGMBRED has made significant progress towards meeting the group\u2019s Terms of Reference and also our own professional and personal aspirations in communicating that the benthos is a vital part of our marine ecosystems and must be considered in the context of the industrial expansion of marine renewable energy developments. During the three years\u2019 work the group has adapted the focus of our activities to more effectively address our objectives in light of our analysis and new knowledge. Some of the topics proved highly complex and require further research. To convey this message several written reviews have helped to summarise the existing knowledge base (across different marine energy device types), and group members have also attended and presented at numerous international conferences and workshops. The specific outputs coming from meeting the Terms of Reference will be useful to inform the advisory process (and licencing) as they are directly linked to the marine renewable energy sector and the ecosystem based management that is being promoted across the ICES region.  The activities of the WG will assist ICES towards a structural and functional understanding of how the marine benthic system associated with marine renewable energy devices contributes to the functioning of the marine ecosystem, and how they can act as areas where benthic biodiversity can potentially be promoted. There is evidently a future need for the WG and a further multi-annual cycle with new co-chairs has been proposed to ICES secretariat. The new objectives to be addressed by this group are considered of high relevance in the context of ecosystem-based management of coastal areas where an increasing number or marine renewable energy devices are planned. There will be direct knowledge gained to support marine spatial planning initiatives. Hence, the activities of WGMBRED can be considered to be of direct benefit and very high priority for several EGs.  The WGMBRED has worked well with a constant and active membership of experts and representatives of various countries. During 2016\u20132018, we have produced some significant outputs (with plans to meet all our outstanding deliverables by the end of 2018).  When considering the future, the offshore renewable industry continues to evolve at a rapid pace with expansion across the world. In addition there are upcoming ideas of multiple use of energy device arrays (e.g. for energy generation and food supply via aquaculture), as well as developments of new technologies in countries where no marine renewable energy devices have been installed before. There are several topics which have not been explored yet in this context which cause uncertainty of the potential effects of these evolving new topics and technologies and inconsistent legislation frameworks between countries. Thus, the WGMBRED expertise contributes to the determination of these effects strategies that are as important now as well as in the near future.  A new set of Terms of Reference supported unanimously by all the members to continue with new co-chairs, gives us confidence to propose to ICES that WGMBRED will successfully continue for three more years. With the growing interest in marine renewable energy developments we believe that the activity of the WG will be of key importance for ICES in the event that they need to advise on marine renewable energy developments in relation to the benthic ecosystem.","author":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"organization":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)","International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ICES-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/792","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ices-sgwte-report-2013-report-study-group-environmental-impacts-wave-tidal-energy","sourceURL":"","title":"ICES SGWTE Report 2013: Report of the Study Group on Environmental Impacts of Wave and Tidal Energy","description":"The Study Group on the Environmental Impacts of Wave and Tidal Energy (Chair: Michael Bell, UK) held its third and final meeting in Cork, Ireland, 19\u201321 March 2013. The meeting was attended by four participants from Ireland, and the UK (England, Scotland) and contributions by correspondence were made by participants, from Spain and the UK (Scotland).  The wave and tidal energy sector is a newcomer to the marine environment, but is developing rapidly. There is an urgent need for new science to understand the potential environmental and socio-economic interactions of wave and tidal energy developments and for this science be applied in policy, planning, consenting and regulatory processes. SGWTE 2013 continued the work of the previous meetings, collating information on the current state of development of the wave and tidal energy industry, in both testing and commercial deployment phases, on progress with leasing and consenting processes, and on research relating to environmental and socio-economic interactions. Status reports were updated for five countries and summary tables were updated and extended to 80 wave and tidal energy developments or test deployments and 121 research projects. SGWTE 2013 also considered the application of Integrated Ecosystem Approaches to management of marine renewable energy activities in the marine environment. Potential interactions of marine renewables with Ecosystem Services were identified, and their relevance to GES descriptors under the MSFD was assessed. Canada\u2019s development of risk analysis and the ecosystem approach (as detailed in the recent CRR No. 317) was reviewed and application of risk-based approaches to management were compared between Scotland and Canada.  This was the third and final meeting of SGWTE, but it is clear that there is an ongoing and increasing need for ICES to develop science in relation to marine renewable energy. SGWTE 2013 developed a proposal for a new Working Group on Marine Renewable Energy (WGMRE), to be established with multi-annual Terms of Reference running from 2014. A key role for WGMRE will be to work in close collaboration with topic-based science Working Groups with the purpose of synthesising their outputs in relation to marine renewable energy for application to planning, consenting and regulatory processes for tidal (both in-stream and barrage), wave and offshore wind energy. WGMRE will also continue the work of SGWTE to facilitate access to up-to-date information on the state of development of the marine renewable energy sector and on associated research activities.","author":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"organization":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2013-03-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ICES-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/793","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ices-sgwte-report-2012-report-study-group-environmental-impacts-wave-tidal-energy","sourceURL":"","title":"ICES SGWTE Report 2012: Report of the Study Group on Environmental Impacts of Wave and Tidal Energy","description":"The Study Group on the Environmental Impacts of Wave and Tidal Energy (Chair: Michael Bell, UK) held its second meeting in Stromness, Orkney, UK, 4-6 May 2012. The meeting was attended by nine participants from Ireland, Spain, Sweden and the UK (England, Scotland and Wales) and contributions by correspondence were made by four participants, from France, Norway, Portugal and the UK (Wales).  The wave and tidal energy sector is a newcomer to the marine environment, but is developing rapidly. There is an urgent need for new science to understand the potential environmental and socio-economic interactions of wave and tidal energy developments and for this science be applied in policy, planning, consenting and regulatory processes. SGWTE 2012 continued the work of the previous meeting, collating information on the current state of development of the wave and tidal energy industry, in both testing and commercial deployment phases, on progress with leasing and consenting processes, and on research relating to environmental and socioeconomic interactions. Status reports were made for individual countries and summary tables were prepared for 53 wave and tidal energy developments or test deployments and 74 research projects. The aim is to compile a searchable database as a resource for scientists and regulators. SGWTE also reported on progress addressing research gaps identified in the previous meeting, and compiled a list of priority research areas under topics such as marine mammals, oceanography and fisheries interactions.  SGWTE is set to finish with a third meeting in 2013, but it is clear that there is an ongoing and increasing need for ICES to develop science in relation to marine renewable energy. SGWTE noted the existence of at least 17 other ICES expert groups with interests in marine energy. A new Working Group on Marine Energy is proposed for the purpose of coordinating the flow of science between topic-based science Working Groups (e.g. on seabirds, benthic ecology, fish ecology) and its application in planning, consenting and regulatory processes in relation to tidal (both in-stream and barrage), wave and offshore wind energy.","author":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"organization":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2012-05-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ICES-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/794","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interim-report-working-group-marine-benthal-renewable-energy-developments-wgmbred","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.vliz.be\/imisdocs\/publications\/ocrd\/307732.pdf","title":"Interim Report of the Working Group on Marine Benthal and Renewable Energy Developments (WGMBRED)","description":"The 2017 annual meeting of the Working Group on Marine Benthal and Renewable Energy Developments (WGMBRED) was attended by 19 experts, representing seven countries and was held in Gdynia, Poland from March 6-10, 2017. The meeting was co-chaired by Jennifer Dannheim (Alfred Wegener Institute, Germany) and Andrew B. Gill (Cranfield University, United Kingdom\/Cape Eleuthera Institute, the Bahamas).  The question of Scale was the focus of ToR A. This ToR was determined as crucial to the work of the group following the first three years of WGMBRED. So we took previous case studies, which were set up at the last meeting and in sub-groups developed them in the context of defining their key elements associated with scale effects. From these case studies a conceptual model to show why scale matters has started to be developed.  The goal of the work on ToR B was to expand the matrices of effects to encompass those devices not considered in the knowledge publication (Dannheim, Degraer, Jackson et al. unpubl.) which considered fixed wind devices only. In order to progress, the knowledge base was updated in relation to specific marine renewable devices, i.e. floating wind, wave and tidal devices. Matrixes on the likely interactions between specific devices (i.e., floating wind, wave and tidal) were elucidated using the template on specific cause-effect relationship and the scoring system following the scheme presented in the ICES WGBMRED report in 2015 which accounts for the spatial and temporal scale of an effect, the sensitivity, the confidence and consistency. Matrixes and scoring of effects were summarised in tables for each marine renewable energy device.  With ToR C intersessional work using an online survey questionnaire provided some very interesting pilot data on a network analysis, which is being undertaken to create a map of interconnectivity between individuals, which when combined with information about individuals\u2019 membership of groups, generates new information on the way that groups interact, exchange knowledge and influence each other. During the meeting further contact details were sought to increase the number of respondents to the questionnaire for a more thorough analysis. This will form the basis of the main analysis and publishable outputs.  ToR D was addressed by looking at the cause-effect relationships in the conceptual scheme (see ICES WGMBRED report 2016), the functions that may be changed and to link these functions to specific services provided by the benthos. The group aimed at defining ecologically relevant indicators that are suitable to detect changes in functions and thus benthic services. Ecosystem services were identified following mainly Hattam et al. (2015, which basically is following CICES). The ToR D was tackled in three sub-groups related to the societal important issues: biogeochemical reactor, food resources and biodiversity.","author":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"organization":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ICES-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/795","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-learning-impact-assessments-european-wave-energy-developments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ices.dk\/sites\/pub\/CM%20Doccuments\/CM-2011\/S\/S1811.pdf","title":"SOWFIA: Learning from Impact Assessments of European wave energy developments","description":"The lack of coordinated policy for environmental impact assessment (EIA) at offshore energy sites has been identified as a hindrance to the growth of the wave energy industry. It may simultaneously result in lack of effective and cohesive EIA monitoring. The SOWFIA Project brings together ten European partners who have an interest in planned wave farm test centres, incorporating 15 existing wave power sites. The project encourages the sharing and consolidation of wave energy development approval processes, EIA best practices for offshore wave energy conversion developments. Key objectives are: to identify barriers and accelerators in existing EIA processes in EU member states; to assess EIA focuses and methodologies at wave energy sites, and to make recommendations for the development of streamlined project approval processes. To date, the project has produced a catalogue of wave energy sites across Europe, which also summarises European targets for renewable energy and provides an overview of the member states\u2019 action plans for ocean energy. An inventory of EIA data sets being collected at European wave energy sites is currently in progress and will result in a data management platform facilitating an analysis of current impact detection capabilities. These outputs will be invaluable in streamlining the EIA process to ensure environmental protection and faster, more economically effective wave energy project development in the future. Future work will include workshops to examine barriers to the industry and a socio-economic study to examine public perceptions of offshore energy developments.\u00a0","author":["Conley, D.","Greaves, D.","Leeney, R.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","Osta, V.","Holmes, B.","Olivares, C."],"organization":["University College Cork","University of Plymouth","Inabensa","International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OHagan-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/796","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seabird-surveys-irelands-atlantic-marine-energy-test-site-amets","sourceURL":"","title":"Seabird Surveys at Ireland\u0027s Atlantic Marine Energy Test Site (AMETS)","description":"A wave energy test site is proposed for inshore waters off the west coast of County Mayo, Ireland. The test site has been selected for its high wave energy levels, due to full Atlantic exposure conditions. Some seabird data for the test site is available from past surveys of Irish waters. Detailed data is not available and baseline bird surveys as part of the Environmental Impact Assessment began in 2009. Surveys at sea followed standard European Seabird at Sea survey methods. Eight surveys were completed between October 2009 and October 2010, excluding the winter months. A total of 8,092 birds of 33 species were recorded. In March 2011 monitoring surveys began at the wave energy test site. The monitoring survey design has been adapted to detect effects of wave-energy related activities on bird densities within the immediate area surrounding each test berth. It is an experimental approach that uses test (berth) and control sites with pre- and post-activity monitoring. Because there are only two test berths, the \u2018treatment\u2019 sample size of our sampling design is limited to two in order to avoid pseudoreplication. This, coupled with natural variance in seabird numbers, means that power to detect small differences in seabird densities will be rather limited. Large scale differences should however be detectable. The key challenge has been how to develop an effective sampling strategy, within practical and budgetary limitations and for a novel development. Baseline survey work was financed by Tonn Energy Ltd.","author":["Hunt, J.","Beaubier, J.","McLoughlin, D."],"organization":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.233810900000","-10.125399000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-16 04:47:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hunt-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/797","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/social-structure-abundance-coastal-bottlenose-dolphins-tursiops-truncatus-normano","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/jmammal\/article\/96\/3\/481\/905030","title":"Social structure and abundance of coastal bottlenose dolphins, Tursiops truncatus, in the Normano-Breton Gulf, English Channel","description":"A large, but poorly studied, bottlenose dolphin community, Tursiops truncatus, inhabits coastal waters of Normandy (Normano-Breton Gulf, English Channel, France). In this study, the social structure and abundance of this community were assessed using photo-identification techniques. Like other bottlenose dolphin communities worldwide, this resident community has a fission\u2013fusion social structure with fluid associations among individuals (half-weight index = 0.10). Association patterns were highly variable as indicated by a high social differentiation (S = 0.95\u00b10.03). The majority of associations were casual, lasting days to months. However, individuals exhibited also a smaller proportion of long-term relationships. A mean group size of 26 was large compared with other resident coastal communities, and variable, ranging from 1 to 100, which could be the results of ecological conditions, in particular resource predictability and availability. Analyses also showed that the community was organized in 3 social clusters that were not completely isolated from each other. Abundance was estimated at 420 dolphins (95% confidence interval: 331\u2013521), making this coastal community one of the largest identified along European coastlines. Because human activities in the Gulf are expected to increase in the upcoming years, long-term demographic monitoring of this dolphin community will be critical for its management.","author":["Louis, M.","Gally, F.","Barbraud, C.","B\u00e9esau, J.","Tixier, P.","Simon-Bouhet, B.","Le Rest, K.","Guinet, C."],"organization":["University of La Rochelle (Universit\u00e9 de La Rochelle)"],"originationDate":"2015-05-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.107480000000","-0.325892000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Louis-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/798","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/provision-evidence-conservation-impacts-energy-production","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieep.eu\/publications\/provision-of-evidence-of-the-conservation-impacts-of-energy-production\/?utm_source=chatgpt.com","title":"Provision of Evidence of the Conservation Impacts of Energy Production","description":"This report provides a broad overview of 15 energy technologies identified by JNCC, including their life cycle carbon dioxide reduction potential and their other environmental impacts. It then focuses on eight key technologies that are likely to have the most significant impacts on the environment over the next 50 years (namely coal, oil, gas, nuclear, wind, tidal stream and range, biomass crops and biofuels). The report describes and whenever possible quantifies the likely impacts of the key UK energy technologies, in the light of current capacity and a selection of published future scenarios for the UK energy mix for 2020 and 2050.  The analysis primarily investigates the impacts of the key energy technologies on biodiversity (particularly regarding UK BAP Priority habitats and UK BAP priority birds). In addition, significant implications for geodiversity (ie the variety of rocks, minerals and landforms), landscape and access to nature are identified. The focus is on impacts to the UK environment, but insights on wider global environmental impacts are provided when relevant.  The review provides clear evidence that energy production can have significant detrimental impacts on the environment, particularly as a result of land take and habitat change (especially from open cast coal mining, tidal barrages, biomass and biofuels), disturbance (eg seismic surveys for oil and gas production, infrastructure construction such as new power plants and transmission systems, and wind farm operation), pollution (eg from oil spills, acid mine drainage from coal pits, biofuels and especially eutrophication impacts from nitrogen oxides from coal power stations), and the accidental killing of some species (eg by power lines, wind turbines and tidal barrages).   It is also clear that more comprehensive and detailed monitoring needs to be undertaken of the impacts of energy developments, during their construction, operational and decommissioning phases. Such monitoring should assess the effectiveness of project level mitigation measures as well as the overall cumulative effects of energy policies on landscapes, geodiversity resources, habitats and species populations.","author":["Tucker, G.","Anderson, J.","Bassi, S.","Chiavari, J.","Casper, K.","Fergusson, M."],"organization":["Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)","Institute for European Environmental Policy (IEEP)"],"originationDate":"2008-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-03 04:38:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/pub08_Conservationimpactsofenergyproduction.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/799","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-crustacean-sensitivity-high-amplitude-underwater-noise-data-needs-effective","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X16302892","title":"A review of crustacean sensitivity to high amplitude underwater noise: Data needs for effective risk assessment in relation to UK commercial species","description":"High amplitude anthropogenic noise is associated with adverse impacts among a variety of organisms but detailed species-specific knowledge is lacking in relation to effects upon crustaceans. Brown crab (Cancer pagurus), European lobster (Homarus gammarus) and Norway lobster (Nephrops norvegicus) together represent the most valuable commercial fishery in the UK (Defra, 2014). Critical evaluation of literature reveals physiological sensitivity to underwater noise among N. norvegicus and closely related crustacean species, including juvenile stages. Current evidence supports physiological sensitivity to local, particle motion effects of sound production in particular. Derivation of correlative relationships between the introduction of high amplitude impulsive noise and crustacean distribution\/abundance is hindered by the coarse resolution of available data at the present time. Future priorities for research are identified and argument for enhanced monitoring under current legislative frameworks outlined.  Highlights:    Marine crustaceans detect, produce and respond to sound.  Crustacean sound sensitivity is restricted to particle motion.  Sound sensitivity of commercial UK crustaceans is unknown.  Licencing bodies do not capture detailed spatio-temporal noise introduction data.  Landings cannot be correlated with sound introduction given course data resolution.","author":["Faulkner, R.","Edmonds, N.","Firmin, C.","Goldsmith, D.","Wood, T."],"organization":["Cefas Lowestoft Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2016-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.112873000000","-5.346237000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Edmonds-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/800","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/meeting-europes-renewable-energy-targets-harmony-nature","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ww2.rspb.org.uk\/Images\/Renewable_energy_report_tcm9-297887.pdf","title":"Meeting Europe\u0027s Renewable Energy Targets in Harmony with Nature","description":"BirdLife International is a global partnership of conservation organisations that strives to conserve birds, their habitats and global biodiversity, working with people towards sustainability in the use of natural resources. The BirdLife Partnership operates in over 100 countries and territories worldwide with over 2.5 million members, 10 million supporters and over a million hectares owned or managed. It is the world\u0027s largest partnership of conservation organisations. Together the BirdLife Partnership forms the leading authority on the status of birds, their habitats and the issues and problems affecting bird life.  The development of renewable energy sources is an essential element in fighting climate change. However, some measures intended to contribute to climate change mitigation, like unsustainably produced biofuels, are posing new threats and stresses on birds and their habitats. BirdLife works to promote effective emissions reductions using renewables without harming ecosystems and biodiversity, both at international and European levels.  BirdLife Europe supports action to cut Europe\u2019s greenhouse gas emissions through energy savings and displacing fossil energy with clean, sustainable, renewable energy sources. To be sustainable, harm to birds and biodiversity must be avoided, and Europe\u2019s most important sites for wildlife must be protected. This means the development of renewable energy sources must follow a strategic approach, so that the most appropriate energy sources are exploited in the most appropriate places.  BirdLife strongly supports the achievement of the EU\u2019s 20% renewable energy target. We believe it is an essential element in the fight against global climate change. With current policies and prevailing technologies, however, meeting the transport target using liquid biofuels does not meet the ecological sustainability criteria above. Therefore, BirdLife cannot support this element of the targets, and calls for greater use of energy savings, electrification of transport and other ecologically acceptable renewables instead. This report explains why we support sustainable renewables deployment, and shows how policy makers can help to meet Europe\u2019s renewables targets in harmony with nature.","author":["BirdLife Europe"],"organization":["BirdLife International","Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BirdLifeInternational-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/801","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reconciling-biodiversity-conservation-widespread-deployment-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article\/file?id=10.1371%2Fjournal.pone.0150956\u0026type=printable","title":"Reconciling Biodiversity Conservation and Widespread Deployment of Renewable Energy Technologies in the UK","description":"Renewable energy will potentially make an important contribution towards the dual aims of meeting carbon emission reduction targets and future energy demand. However, some technologies have considerable potential to impact on the biodiversity of the environments in which they are placed. In this study, an assessment was undertaken of the realistic deployment potential of a range of renewable energy technologies in the UK, considering constraints imposed by biodiversity conservation priorities. We focused on those energy sources that have the potential to make important energy contributions but which might conflict with biodiversity conservation objectives. These included field-scale solar, bioenergy crops, wind energy (both onshore and offshore), wave and tidal stream energy. The spatially-explicit analysis considered the potential opportunity available for each technology, at various levels of ecological risk. The resultant maps highlight the energy resource available, physical and policy constraints to deployment, and ecological sensitivity (based on the distribution of protected areas and sensitive species). If the technologies are restricted to areas which currently appear not to have significant ecological constraints, the total potential energy output from these energy sources was estimated to be in the region of 5,547 TWh\/yr. This would be sufficient to meet projected energy demand in the UK, and help to achieve carbon reduction targets. However, we highlight two important caveats. First, further ecological monitoring and surveillance is required to improve understanding of wildlife distributions and therefore potential impacts of utilising these energy sources. This is likely to reduce the total energy available, especially at sea. Second, some of the technologies under investigation are currently not deployed commercially. Consequently this potential energy will only be available if continued effort is put into developing these energy sources\/ technologies, to enable realisation of their full potential.","author":["Langston, R.","Teuten, E.","Campbell, C.","Gove, B.","Williams, L.","Beresford, A.","Roddis, P.","Bradbury, R."],"organization":["Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)"],"originationDate":"2016-05-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.153332000000","-5.561394000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gove-et-al-2016.PDF"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/802","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-aspects-developing-irelands-atlantic-marine-energy-test-site-amets","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Simon_Berrow\/publication\/258883533_Environmental_Aspects_of_Developing_Ireland\u0027s_Atlantic_Marine_Energy_Test_Site_AMETS\/links\/0046352951847673ce000000\/Environmental-Aspects-of-Developing-Irelands-Atlantic-Marine-Energy","title":"Environmental Aspects of Developing Ireland\u0027s Atlantic Marine Energy Test Site (AMETS)","description":"This paper examines the environmental aspects associated with the development of Ireland\u2019s Atlantic Marine Energy Test Site (AMETS), which is being developed off the west coast of County Mayo near Belmullet by the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI) in conjunction with its project partners, ESB International (ESBI), the Marine Institute and TONN Energy. The test site will provide a grid-connected national test facility, at which full scale pre-commercial wave energy converters (WEC) could be deployed during their final stages of pre-commercial development. It will facilitate small arrays of up to five WECs each. It is an integral component of Irelands Ocean Energy Strategy and will facilitate testing and validation of wave energy converters in an open ocean environment. It will be operational for a period of up to twenty years and will be decommissioned thereafter. The results of a year long environmental assessment of the use of the site by birds and marine mammals together with details of subtidal, intertidal and terrestrial habitats are presented. The test site will provide a facility, not only for testing WEC\u2019s, but also for gaining experience on how to develop wave farms for electricity generation, what environmental impacts are associated with such developments and how electricity generated from WEC\u2019s can be integrated and connected to the existing electricity network.","author":["Kavanagh, P.","Scally, L.","Kennedy, B.","Fielding, M.","Berrow, S.","Hunt, J."],"organization":["ESB International (ESBI)","MERC Consultants","Irish Whale and Dolphin Group","National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2011-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.233810900000","-10.125399000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-16 04:46:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/803","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/kentish-flats-wind-farm-fifth-ornithological-monitoring-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.academia.edu\/2619610\/Kentish_Flats_Wind_Farm_Fifth_Ornithological_Monitoring_Report","title":"Kentish Flats Wind Farm Fifth Ornithological Monitoring Report","description":"This Fifth Monitoring Report analyses the results of the 12 months of boat data collected from December 2005 to November 2006 for the Kentish Flats offshore wind farm project, and aerial data collected from 13th November 2005 to 18th February 2006 over the area immediately surrounding the Kentish Flats wind farm site. The aerial surveys cover a much greater area extending far beyond the Kentish Flats site, and are part of the wider aerial bird survey regime that covers the Thames strategic offshore wind farm area.  The purpose of this report is to meet the monitoring requirements set out by DEFRA (with advice from English Nature, now Natural England) as a condition for the FEPA consent for the Kentish Flats project. The objectives of the pre-, during and post-construction monitoring program are quoted below from Annex 2 of the Schedule to FEPA Licence No. 31780\/03\/0, dated March 7th, 2003:    Determine whether there is change in bird use and passage through the wind farm site, measured by species, abundance and behaviour  Determine whether there is disruption to bird flight lines  Determine the distribution of wildfowl and divers in the Thames Estuary, covering the Kentish Flats study area. This will include movements of wildfowl to and from the coastal SPA sites surrounding the Thames Estuary  Determine the rate of bird collision at the Kentish Flats site  Determine the effectiveness of mitigation measures implemented during wind farm construction","author":["Gill, J.","Pinder, S.","Sales, D.","Salazar, R."],"organization":["Environmentally Sustainable Systems, Ltd."],"originationDate":"2008-07-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.425344000000","1.055822000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Shorebirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kentish_Flats_Wind_Farm_Fifth_Ornitholog.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/805","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/regulating-wave-tidal-energy-industry-perspective-scottish-marine-governance-framework","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X1500384X","title":"Regulating wave and tidal energy: An industry perspective on the Scottish marine governance framework","description":"The emerging ocean energy industry, which seeks to utilise waves and tides to generate electricity, is developing in many jurisdictions. The UK, and Scotland in particular, is strongly interested in these technologies, and has made considerable efforts to reform its marine governance processes to better meet the needs of innovative new marine industries. This paper provides an industry perspective on this regulatory framework, reporting on the experiences of ocean energy project and technology developers. Semi-structured interviews with companies with practical experience with Scotland\u0027s regulatory framework provide evidence of a number of legal and regulatory challenges, as well as interesting insights into how developers are interacting with new marine governance systems. The paper details the findings of these interviews and offers some suggested directions for future research.","author":["Wright, G."],"organization":["Australian National University"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.028407000000","-2.846032000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/806","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/refusal-planning-consent-docking-shoal-offshore-wind-farm-stakeholder-perspectives","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X18309345","title":"Refusal of planning consent for the Docking Shoal offshore wind farm: Stakeholder perspectives and lessons learned","description":"The Docking Shoal project was developed by Centrica as part of The Crown Estate\u0027s Round 2 of UK offshore wind licensing. After 8 years of development, the project was ultimately refused planning consent by the Secretary of State for Energy and Climate Change. The current study seeks to explore the factors behind this decision, as well as its impact and legacy for the offshore wind industry from the perspectives of key stakeholders including the project developer, a statutory consultee, and the regulatory body. Key findings are aligned along themes of the consenting process, environmental impacts, views and reactions to the decision, and lessons learned. The study concludes that the Docking Shoal decision centred on issues of impacts upon seabird populations of the Docking Shoal project itself, as well as the potential cumulative impacts of neighbouring offshore wind project developments. The study also reveals that the Docking Shoal project marked a shift in approach by the regulator towards a more holistic and strategic assessment of cumulative impacts, taking into account the combined effects of all foreseeable neighbouring projects in the pipeline. Finally, the paper discusses some of the key issues highlighted by the Docking Shoal project that have continued to impact upon the development and deployment of offshore wind projects.","author":["Broadbent, I.","Nixon, C."],"organization":["Robert Gordon University"],"originationDate":"2019-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.166768000000","0.749914000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/807","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pilot-field-study-observations-fixed-platform-occurrence-behaviour-common-guillemots","sourceURL":"https:\/\/library.wur.nl\/WebQuery\/wurpubs\/541476","title":"Pilot field study: observations from a fixed platform on occurrence and behaviour of common guillemots and other seabirds in offshore wind farm Luchterduinen","description":"Two marine ornithologists spent two days watching seabird behaviour from a fixed platform at the periphery of offshore wind farm Luchterduinen, The Netherlands, in January 2018. The aim of this study was to assess whether meaningful observations could be made from a non-moving platform, that was part of the wind farm scenery, i.e., one of the turbine foundations. On each observation day, a turbine was selected that was located at the wind farm perimeter, that offered views both of the interior of the wind farm and to waters just outside the wind farm. Earlier studies of seabirds in offshore wind farms have shown that many species tend to avoid wind farms, but also that some individuals, of most species, do enter. However, as these studies are typically conducted from moving platforms (ships or aircraft), it is not known how birds behave within a wind farm perimeter. Birds that find themselves between moving turbines might be intimidated. This might impair their normal feeding behaviour at sea, if the birds would be overly watchful, or mainly seeking to exit the wind farm. On the other hand, birds may specifically move into a wind farm, if they can deal with the fact that turbines are present, and if feeding conditions within the wind farm are good. Such birds would be expected to show feeding behaviour, such as diving.  Seabirds may also be habituating to the presence of wind farms in their environment. In the airspace below the rotors, at the sea\u2019s surface and under water, there is no danger to seabirds from collision. Seabirds can thus safely enter and feed in offshore wind farms, and may, over the years, have learnt to exploit this new habitat. Therefore, even though earlier studies have shown displacement of seabirds away from offshore wind farms, this may no longer be the status quo as seabirds may be adapting to the new situation: a marine environment with offshore wind farms.  Two auk species, the common guillemot and the razorbill, were seen to move through the wind farm. Birds were seen here both flying and swimming, and diving (presumably for food) was commonly seen. Northern gannets were also commonly seen within wind farm perimeters, but only flying: not swimming or diving. We observed bird behaviour during only two days, in a relatively new wind farm not visited by us earlier, while using different methods of observing seabirds, as compared to earlier T-0 and T-1 studies nearby offshore wind farms. Acknowledging these methodological limitations, seabird presence in the wind farm seemed considerably higher than observed during the earlier T-0 and T-1 (personal observations) periods. This might suggest that these birds (both auks and gannets) are habituating to the wind farms in their environment.  Based on this pilot study of only two days of observations in only one season, it is fair to conclude that meaningful behavioural observations can be made from the turbine foundations and that the suggested process of habituation can be followed. It is suggested to conduct more such observations and to do so both from peripheral turbines and from turbines deeper into the wind farm.","author":["Leopold, M.","Verdaat, H."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","Rijkswaterstaat"],"originationDate":"2018-09-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.164001000000","5.598000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-30 09:30:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mardik_et_al_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/808","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/use-optical-rangefinder-assess-reliability-seabird-flight-heights-boat-based-surveyors","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/epdf\/10.1111\/jofo.12269","title":"Use of an optical rangefinder to assess the reliability of seabird flight heights from boat-based surveyors: implications for collision risk at offshore wind farms","description":"Visual estimates of the distribution of the flight heights of birds are often critical for collision risk assessments for wind\u2010energy projects. However, the reliability of such data is largely unknown. The results of trials where rangefinder height estimates were compared with those of an Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) used to mimic a flying bird at varying distances and heights from the operator suggested that the rangefinder performed well, with an overall mean deviation from the actual UAV height of \u22120.4\u00a0m. Accuracy and precision were influenced by an interaction between UAV height and distance to the surveyor. We also compared measurements of the flight heights of 16 species of seabirds made with an optical rangefinder to surveyor estimates made in 5\u2010m bands during boat\u2010based surveys off the east coast of Scotland UK from May to October 2017. Overall agreement between the rangefinder and surveyor estimates (N\u00a0=\u00a01235) was 58%, but increased to 92% when including the adjacent 5\u2010m bands. We found that surveyors were more likely to underestimate bird heights, potentially influencing collision\u2010risk assessments for wind farm projects. Use of rangefinders may be limited to days with good visibility, but their accuracy can be excellent within equipment limitations. However, suitability of rangefinders for the species or task in question should be verified before application. Further use of rangefinders is recommended for training, assessment of surveyor accuracy and consistency, calibration of visual flight height distributions, or replacement of visual observations where appropriate. Such applications could increase confidence in impact assessments and inform appropriate mitigation for wind farms.","author":["Perrow, M.","Harwood, A.","Berridge, R."],"organization":["ECON Ecological Consultancy"],"originationDate":"2018-10-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.038138000000","-3.260594000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/809","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/characteristics-soundscape-after-construction-block-island-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.5068166","title":"Characteristics of the soundscape before and after the construction of the Block Island Wind Farm","description":"The Block Island Wind Farm (BIWF) south of Rhode Island is the first offshore windfarm in the United States. As part of the Ocean Special Area Management Plan, acoustic data were collected before the construction in the fall of 2009. Noise budgets were estimated based on this data and showed the dominant sources of sound in a 1\/3-octave band centered at 500 Hz were shipping and wind. Data were again collected during and after construction of the wind farm and will be presented and compared to pre-construction levels. In 2009, Passive Aquatic Listener (PALs) were deployed. After construction was complete, data from a tetrahedral hydrophone array (~50 m from one of the wind turbines) were analyzed to study the soundscape from December 20, 2016 to January 14, 2017. The acoustic environment near the BIWF after construction showed contributions from shipping, wind, and marine life. Noise from the wind turbine was measured near 70 Hz at approximately 100 dB re 1 mPa at a range of 50 m. Significant marine mammal vocalizations were recorded including from humpback and fin whales. (Work supported by the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management.)","author":["Potty, G.","Frankel, A.","Miller, J.","Lin, Y.","Newhall, A.","Vigness-Raposa, K.","Tripathy, A.","Amaral, J."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island","Marine Acoustics Inc","Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution"],"originationDate":"2018-10-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.173652000000","-71.558055000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/810","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mitigation-impact-impact-mitigation-ethical-perspective","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_6","title":"The Mitigation of Impact and the Impact of Mitigation: An Ethical Perspective","description":"Societal concerns regarding the negative impacts of wind turbines on species and ecosystems have placed more emphasis on mitigation efforts pre- and post-construction. While the mitigation hierarchy is usually fronted to deal with negative ecological impacts, it is hardly employed accordingly. This calls for the core of the problem to be addressed, namely, the lack of an appropriate framework for mitigation as a concept to properly address ecological impacts caused by wind-power development. In this chapter, mitigation is defined as the intervention(s) implemented to affect the risk of wind turbines impacting species or ecosystems. This concept is placed within a social-ecological context where the consecutive steps of the mitigation hierarchy may be affected by socio-economic, technological or environmental spheres of interest. Decisions relating to mitigation are in principle normative, which necessitates addressing three central ethical questions: (1) In which circumstances should mitigation be implemented? (2) How much mitigation is required? (3) Who is responsible for mitigation? Implementing mitigation requires decision-makers to acknowledge that trouble never comes alone, which requires balancing trade-offs and embracing uncertainty into the decision-making process. Adaptive and participatory management may be the best decision-making framework to do this, as it allows for improved ecological understanding through monitoring and a flexible approach to mitigate locally but manage regionally.  Book information can be found here.","author":["May, R."],"organization":["Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/811","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/agent-based-modelling-fish-collisions-tidal-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/eprints.hrwallingford.com\/1391\/","title":"Agent-Based Modelling of fish collisions with tidal turbines","description":"With growing developments in marine tidal energy, coupled with high densities of marine species in suitable installation locations, there is concern about marine wildlife colliding with underwater devices. Methods are needed to predict such collisions when assessing environmental impacts of underwater turbines. Agent-Based Models (ABMs) in the field of ecology: simulate interactions between organisms; assess how they live (i.e. grow, reproduce, function, adapt) and die in a dynamic physical environment; consider a population from the point of view of the individuals, or agents with population level behaviours emerging from the behaviour of the individuals; have individual within a system that are defined by traits (e.g. size, age or sensitivity to a stressor) and behaviours they can perform (e.g. migration or avoidance). To better predict collisions with underwater devices, HR Wallingford has developed an Agent-Based Model (ABM) to predict the probability of marine animals colliding with an underwater device.","author":["Rossington, K.","Benson, T."],"organization":["HR Wallingford Ltd"],"originationDate":"2019-05-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.483251000000","-5.583165000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/TP-060_Rossington-Benson.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/812","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dynamic-risk-assessment-method-address-safety-navigation-concerns-around-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/full\/10.1177\/1475090219837409#articleCitationDownloadContainer","title":"A dynamic risk assessment method to address safety of navigation concerns around offshore renewable energy installations","description":"This work focuses on the development of a deterministic dynamic risk method that can be used by operational end-users such as seafarers, when navigating in restricted waters where there is spatial conflict due to multi-use of marine areas by the shipping and offshore renewable energy industries. The developed method can also be used during the planning stages of offshore renewable energy installations. A case study of vessel operations near an offshore wind farm is also presented. The article also briefly discusses the potential application of manoeuvring-based dynamic risk methods to resolve spatial conflicts in the maritime, as well as other transport domains.","author":["Mehdi, R.","Baldauf, M.","Deeb, H."],"organization":["World Maritime University"],"originationDate":"2019-03-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Navigation"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/813","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/upscaling-positive-effects-scour-protection-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/library.wur.nl\/WebQuery\/wurpubs\/fulltext\/475354","title":"Upscaling positive effects of scour protection in offshore wind farms","description":"The Dutch government has the ambition to realise 3,5 GW in offshore wind farms before 2023. Longer term outlooks estimate 35 to 75 GW for 2050. This would result in the construction of 5,000 wind turbines in the Dutch North Sea. The introduction of artificial hard substrates by placing wind turbine foundations and scour protection facilitates epibenthic species and associated benthic fish. The addition of rocks could be considered as adding H1170 habitat (\u2018Reefs of open sea\u2019) and as such has a positive impact on hard substrate associated benthic macrofauna and fish. The significance of this effect, however, is unclear on a scale outside the scour protection. This report describes the result of a quick-scan in which the significance of this positive effect is quantified. Negative impacts and effects of the turbine foundation and other man-made structures were not included in the quick-scan.  The aim of this quick-scan was to answer the following questions:    What is the biomass of benthic macrofauna on scour protection found in monitoring programmes to date?  Which benthic species, including macrofauna and hard substrate associated fish, have been found to date on and associated with scour protection?  When 5,000 wind turbines are installed in the Dutch Sea, each with 2,000 m2 scour protection, would this significantly change the benthic communities? a. If not, what surface area would be needed to attain a significant change?  To what extent are benthic species\u2019 populations on offshore wind turbine foundations interconnected?  What knowledge gaps prevent answering questions 1-4 with acceptable scientific certainty?   The questions were addressed by desk study combining data from scour protections and soft sediment seabed monitoring (MWTL). Biomass was extrapolated to the 2050 scenario by multiplying single turbine data to 5,000 turbines.  Values of biomass on scour protections were compared with the benthic community of a sandy seabed, with the following results:    Total epibenthic species richness on scour protections may double when introducing scour protection at locations other than the current locations;  Epibenthic biomass in the area covered by scour protection directly around a turbine (2,000 m2) rises 24 times. On a wind farm scale (72 km2), this increase is 4.9%.  5,000 offshore wind turbines, with a total of 10 km2 scour protection, will increase total benthic biomass in the Dutch North Sea (57,000 km2) with 3,400 tonnes (0.43%).  To attain an increase of 5% on this scale, a total of 106 km2 of scour protection should be added.  The Dutch edible crab population may increase with 50 million individuals, an increase of 880% of the population on the sandy seabed.  Fish may increase with hundreds of thousands of Atlantic cod, and many millions of smaller reef-species such as rock gunnel and goldsinny wrasse.  Connectivity between populations of benthic species rises after the construction of wind farms but quantification is challenging due to differences in reported larval durations and lack of reported travel distances.   In general, data availability for scour protection species was low. Biomass data was available from only 5 locations and only a single fish dataset was formatted in a manner that could be extrapolated. The quick scan approached ignored potential variation caused by different scour protection types, negative impact on fish or infaunal benthic species, environmental differences and presence of additional man-made structure. These relevant variables need to be addressed in future research.  To increase our understanding of the ecological importance of wind farms with their turbines and scour protection, future monitoring should focus on the following:    Understanding species ecology and system ecology, e.g. by starting a broad study of the impact (including turbines and scour protection) on the wider ecosystem and food web.  Obtaining more field data on epibenthic fauna and fish on scour protections and connectivity between locations.  Making industry data available to scientists to increase data availability.  Investigate different forms of scour protection as well as ecological limitations of species, including attraction and production effects (including epifauna on foundations).  For fish studies, more use of specific reef-fish sampling methods, such as baited video and fykes or traps, is recommended. All results should be considered against a background of sandy seabed covered with thousands of other man-made structures, including shipwrecks, buoys and platforms.   We advise TKI Wind op Zee and RVO to focus their funding scheme on the following topics:    Assessment of the effects of currently used scour protection types on biodiversity, in particular epibenthic species and scour protection associated fish, including quantification of biomass, numbers and densities.  Investigation of the impact new scour protection specifications in the current tenders for new offshore wind farms have on biodiversity, in particular epibenthic species and scour protection associated fish, including quantification of biomass, numbers and densities.  To evaluate the ecological success of the new scour protection specifications, results from the study on currently used types of scour protection should be compared to the altered types.","author":["Lengkeek, W.","Coolen, J.","van der Have, T.","Bittner, O."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","Rijkswaterstaat"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.170255000000","5.620801000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Demersal Fish","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Coolen-et-al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/814","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-vessel-traffic-fishing-activity-standards-offshore-wind-farm-domestic-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.koreascience.or.kr\/article\/JAKO201810748277931.page","title":"A Review of Vessel Traffic and Fishing Activity Standards for Offshore Wind Farm in Domestic Areas Based on the Analysis of Foreign Cases","description":"According to the Global Wind Report of the Global Wind Energy Council (GWEC) in 2017, global wind power electricity generation capacity has been dramatically developing from 23,900 MW in 2001 to 486,790 MW in 2016. However, wind power generation in South Korea accounts for only 0.2 % of total power generation. Nonetheless, electricity production by wind power generation is soon expected to reach the grid parity where the cost of generating electricity by wind power is equal to the cost of fossil fuels such as oil. In this study, we analyzed the criteria of vessel traffic and fishing activities of major offshore wind farms in Europe where 88 % of the offshore wind power facilities are located. Finally, we suggest critical considerations based on the analysis.","author":["Kwon, Y.","Lee, C.","Rim, G."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Navigation"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/815","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/consequences-seabird-habitat-loss-offshore-wind-turbines-research-plan-five-selected","sourceURL":"https:\/\/edepot.wur.nl\/460458","title":"The consequences of seabird habitat loss from offshore wind turbines: a research plan for five selected species","description":"In order to develop the Dutch offshore wind agenda, as outlined in the \u2018Energie-akkoord voor duurzame groei\u2019 (2013), in an ecologically sound way, the KEC (\u2018Kader Ecologie en Cumulatie\u2019) was compiled. This document gives an overview of species and populations where potential problems occur between fauna and the planned OWF (\u2018Offshore Wind Farm\u2019) development, and highlights potential mitigating measures to prevent these problems. The research described in this plan follows directly from the KEC: it aims to do a further study of the top five seabird species deemed most at risk from the Dutch offshore wind farms through displacement and habitat loss. The project will not consider the effect of wind farms on seasonal, long-distance bird migration patterns.","author":["Leopold, M.","van Kooten, T.","Soudijn, F."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre"],"originationDate":"2018-09-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.176018000000","5.665092000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/van_Kooten_et_al_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/816","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-challenges-ocean-energy-generation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.journalijdr.com\/environmental-challenges-ocean-energy-generation","title":"Environmental Challenges for Ocean Energy Generation","description":"The world\u0027s depleting fossil fuels have put the globe into serious global warming concern. Normally, these fossil fuels emit greenhouse gases when burnt in most of the industrial processes and as well in automobiles. The earth\u0027s economic activities have therefore triggered high energy demand which has put the world into acute energy shortage. This global energy insecurity has attracted the technological research on how to ensure there is constant supply of energy owing to the increasing energy demand. Different energy resources have been identified which can help generate clean energy which emit near zero greenhouse gases such as SOX, NOX and CO2. As the renewable energy sources come into play, they are also accompanied by several environmental impacts. This paper critically discusses different environmental challenges posed by the generation of energy via ocean energy technology and gives an insight on the proposed remedy. The challenges explored include; electromagnetic field in the ocean, toxicity caused by the technology, alteration of water currents and waves, benthic organisms\u0027 habitat alteration, noise impacts, strike and collision and water temperature increment.","author":["Apunda, M.","Nyangoye, B."],"organization":["University of Leeds","Masinde Muliro University of Science and Technology"],"originationDate":"2018-07-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-11 10:08:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/817","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/health-environmental-benefits-wind-solar-energy-united-states-2007-2015","sourceURL":"https:\/\/emp.lbl.gov\/publications\/health-and-environmental-benefits","title":"The Health and Environmental Benefits of Wind and Solar Energy in the United States, 2007-2015","description":"Wind and solar energy provide public health and environmental benefits to the United States. However, not only do these benefits vary dramatically by region, they also vary over time. In the last decade, cumulative wind and solar power deployment has increased rapidly; at the same time, regulatory changes and fossil fuel price changes have led to steep cuts in overall power-sector emissions of pollutants such as SO2, NOx, and PM2.5 as well as to reductions to CO2 emission rates in certain regions. The goal of this work is to evaluate how a subset of wind and solar energy\u2019s health and environmental benefits have evolved from 2007 through 2015 both in absolute terms as well as on a dollar-benefit per kWh basis. We present results regionally across the continental United States and we assess certain uncertainties in the magnitude of the benefits. We develop a time series of wind and solar power generation by location within the U.S. and utilize EPA\u2019s AVERT tool to develop avoided emissions estimates. A suite of air quality exposure and health impact models along with a wide range of social cost of carbon estimates are used to monetize the benefits of the avoided emissions. Presented here are the working results of this analysis.","author":["Wiser, R.","Bolinger, M.","Millstein, D.","Barbose, G."],"organization":["Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Chemicals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/818","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/climate-air-quality-benefits-wind-solar-power-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/nenergy2017134","title":"The climate and air-quality benefits of wind and solar power in the United States","description":"Wind and solar energy reduce combustion-based electricity generation and provide air-quality and greenhouse gas emission benefits. These benefits vary dramatically by region and over time. From 2007 to 2015, solar and wind power deployment increased rapidly while regulatory changes and fossil fuel price changes led to steep cuts in overall power-sector emissions.Here we evaluate how wind and solar climate and air-quality benefits evolved during this time period. We find cumulative wind and solar air-quality benefits of 2015 US$29.7\u2013112.8 billion mostly from 3,000 to 12,700 avoided premature mortalities,and cumulative climate benefits of 2015 US$5.3\u2013106.8 billion. The ranges span results across a suite of air-quality and health  impact models and social cost of carbon estimates. We find that binding cap-and-trade pollutant markets may reduce thesecumulative benefits by up to 16%. In 2015, based on central estimates, combined marginal benefits equal 7.3\u00a2kWh\u22121(wind) and 4.0\u00a2kWh\u22121(solar).","author":["Wiser, R.","Bolinger, M.","Millstein, D.","Barbose, G."],"organization":["Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2017-08-14","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Millstein_et_al-2017-Nature_Energy.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/819","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-marine-energy-technologies-uk-evaluation-systems-perspective","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096014811730719X","title":"The potential of marine energy technologies in the UK- Evaluation from a systems perspective","description":"Accelerated technological change plays a crucial role in enabling the low-carbon energy transition. Quantitative energy modelling exploring alternative long-term decarbonisation pathways can support policy-makers in choosing the most important areas for technology promotion. This study analyses the potential contribution of marine energy in the UK from an energy systems perspective considering the trade-offs between local lead markets and global learning, the uncertainty in the learning potential, competition with alternative technologies and impacts on system balancing. The results indicate that only under very favourable conditions, i.e. with learning rates above 15% and high global deployment, marine energy will have a significant contribution to the UK decarbonisation pathway. Alternatively, marine energy could constitute a hedging strategy against multiple failure in other low-carbon options. The early strategic investments into marine energy lead, in most cases, to a slight rise in societal welfare costs compared to the respective cases without attempts to induce marine learning and brings benefits to the electricity system. Thus, on the whole, we conclude that marine energy has the potential to contribute to the UK energy system, but there is a substantial risk that strategic investments in a national lead market will not directly pay off in the long term.","author":["Zeyringer, M.","Fais, B.","Keppo, I.","Price, J."],"organization":["University College London"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.276117200000","-5.754382000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zeyringeretal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/820","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/governmental-regulation-ocean-wave-energy-converter-installations","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/4347867","title":"Governmental Regulation of Ocean Wave Energy Converter Installations","description":"Interest in ocean energy converter technology has increased with the revival of renewable energy awareness. To date, ocean current energy converters have been implemented with relatively mature technology when compared to wave energy converters. Despite the novelty of wave energy, several commercial wave energy projects have recently been undertaken. However, this process has not been accompanied by the development of a legal process for developers to follow. Therefore, this paper focuses on wave energy legal jurisdiction issues. These issues are addressed with regards to siting license dilemmas and which government agencies may assert jurisdiction. Regulatory actions needed to promote wave energy conversion technology are also investigated.","author":["Vining, J.","Muetze, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2007-10-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/822","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/3d-modelling-impacts-stream-horizontal-axis-tidal-energy-converters-tecs-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141118719300896","title":"3D modelling of the impacts of in-stream horizontal-axis Tidal Energy Converters (TECs) on offshore sandbank dynamics","description":"The tidal energy sector is a growing industry in the UK and beyond. Energy developers\u2019 interests are progressing towards the deployment of large arrays of tidal energy converters (TECs). Numerous factors will affect decision making related to arrays siting and size. One key factor is the effect that the TEC arrays may have on the natural sediment transport patterns and the sea bottom morphodynamics. The Inner Sound Channel located between the Island of Stroma of Pentland Firth and the Scottish Mainland (UK) has been accredited for a large-scale TEC array installation to be developed in the future. Three morphodynamically active, large sandbanks are located in the Inner Sound channel. This study investigated the impacts of tidal energy extraction from a large array of TECs on the sediment dynamics and morphology of these sandbanks. A large-scale 3D hydrodynamic and morphodynamic Delft3D model was set up to computationally model Pentland Firth, Inner Sound Channel in order to study the impacts of tidal energy extraction from a generic TEC array, on the existing hydrodynamic and morphodynamic regime. A range of hypothetical energy extraction scenarios was modelled. Results reveal that the changes to morphodynamics of these sandbanks as a result of large scale tidal energy extraction far exceeds the morphology change under the natural hydrodynamic regime and that the severity of morphology change depends on the level of energy extraction.","author":["Reeve, D.","Karunarathna, H.","Chatzirodou, A."],"organization":["University of the West of England, Bristol","Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2019-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.736584000000","-3.151596000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/823","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/full-life-cycle-assessment-two-surge-wave-energy-converters","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/full\/10.1177\/0957650919867191","title":"Full life cycle assessment of two surge wave energy converters","description":"Wave energy has the potential to play an important role in the UK\u0027s electricity mix in the coming years and it is important to understand the interactions of wave energy converters with the environment before considering them viable alternatives for other technologies. The aim of this study was to identify the environmental impacts of the deployment of the Oyster wave energy converter to the EMEC test site at Orkney, UK over its lifetime across three general categories: resource use, human health and ecological consequences. A full life cycle assessment was performed on two different models of the Oyster wave energy converter: Oyster 1 and Oyster 800. It was found that the latter is a fitting upgrade for its predecessor as it has lower environmental impacts in all categories; however, the high infrastructural needs of the Oyster technology makes its environmental performance worse than most other wave energy converters. Key sustainability indicators for energy converters include carbon footprint and energy payback period, and these were found to be 79 and 57 gCO2 eq\/kWh and 45 and 42 months for the Oyster 1 and Oyster 800, respectively. Although these are significantly higher than most estimates for other types of renewable energy converter, the carbon impacts are still significantly lower than for conventional fossil-fuelled power generation.","author":["Harrison, G.","Thomson, R.","Karan, H."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2020-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.962382000000","-3.293508000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-02 07:55:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/824","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-wildlife-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/books.google.com\/books?hl=en\u0026id=LtmmDwAAQBAJ\u0026pg=PR5#v=onepage\u0026q\u0026f=false","title":"Renewable Energy and Wildlife Conservation","description":"Contents  Introduction - Renewable Energy and Wildlife Conservation  Part I - Bioenergy and Wildlife Conservation  1 - Short-Rotation Woody Crops and Wildlife Conservation  2 - Effects of Harvesting Forest-Based  Biomass on Terrestrial Wildlife  3 - Impacts on Wildlife of Annual Crops for Biofuel Production  4 - Second-Generation Feedstocks from Dedicated Energy Crops: Implications for Wildlife and Wildlife Habitat  Part II - Wind Energy and Wildlife Conservation  5 - Wind Energy Effects on Birds  6 - Wind Energy Effects on Bats  7 - Effects of Wind Energy on Wildlife: Emerging Issues and Underrepresented Taxa  Part III - Solar Energy, Waterpower, and Wildlife Conservation  8 - Solar Energy: A Technology with Multi-Scale Opportunities to Integrate Wildlife Conservation  9 - Waterpower: Hydropower and Marine Hydrokinetic Energy  Part IV - The Future of Renewable Energy and Wildlife Conservation  10 - Renewable Energy Policy Directives: Implications for Wildlife Conservation  11 - Renewable Energy Ecology: The Next Frontier in Wildlife Science","author":["Grodsky, S.","Moorman, C.","Rupp, S."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Moormanetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/825","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-impacts-tropical-marine-environment-shore-clean-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214785319318577","title":"Assessment of impacts on tropical marine environment for off-shore clean energy development","description":"Off-shore Floating Solar Photovoltaic and Wind Power installations are two potential future clean energy technology options which are being considered by energy developers. Environmental impacts must be evaluated on project-by-project basis as these are site-specific. In the present work, we propose a method for determining baseline reference level of underwater ambient noise in tropical marine coastal shallow waters. The underwater ambient noise has been measured at 30\u202fm depth at a site near Grande island (15\u00b018\u2032 N 73\u00b0 41\u2032 E) 18\u202fkm off Goa, on India\u2019s western coast during 2012\u20132016. Analysis of recorded data shows that the noise levels in general have increased by a margin of 10\u201324\u202fdB over the observed frequency band of 10\u202fHz to 100\u202fkHz, at the site. Therefore, the impacts of clean energy development projects on marine environment need to be evaluated carefully.","author":["Sharma, N.","Kandlakunta, L.","Deshmukh, M."],"organization":["BITS Pilani K K Birla Goa Campus"],"originationDate":"2020-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["15.352424000000","73.778048000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/826","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/legislative-regime-environment-assessment-approval-offshore-wind-energy-developments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/search.informit.com.au\/documentSummary;dn=018787739844852;res=IELBUS","title":"The legislative regime for environment assessment and approval of offshore wind energy developments in England and Wales","description":"The United Kingdom is a European and world leader for installed offshore wind energy capacity. Despite its benefits, offshore wind energy may have a range of negative environmental impacts. This article will examine and critically assess the regime for environmental assessment and approval of offshore wind energy projects in England and Wales. It will begin by giving an overview of the broader framework for the location and selection of sites for offshore wind energy facilities, including the role of Strategic Environmental Assessment, the establishment of zones for development, procedures for obtaining tenure over the sea bed, and non-mandatory procedures for environmental assessment at the zone level. The article will then describe and critically analyse the environmental assessment and approval procedures for individual offshore wind energy projects that classify as national infrastructure projects under the Planning Act 2008 (UK). While the government\u0027s 2011 National Policy Statements for Energy have been crucial to achieving a high rate of success of applications for development consent, concerns remain in relation to the assessment of offshore wind energy projects, in particular the cumulative impacts on birds and marine mammals, and the most appropriate methodologies for predicting and measuring these impacts.","author":["Wawryk, A."],"organization":["University of Adelaide"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.468794000000","-2.342050000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/827","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/social-acceptance-wind-energy-development-planning-rural-communities-australia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421514004881","title":"Social acceptance of wind energy development and planning in rural communities of Australia: A consumer analysis","description":"Social acceptance is necessary for widespread adoption of new renewable energy technologies. A lack of social acceptance by local community residents is a barrier to increasing the renewable energy mix and targets in Australia. This study empirically evaluated predictor importance of key constructs of social acceptance, using responses from a sample of 226 survey respondents in Australia. Regression analysis suggest that \u2018Concerns with wind turbines\u2019 was the predictor most strongly correlated with Social Acceptance, followed by \u2018Annoyance with wind turbines\u2019, and then \u2018Consultation with stakeholders\u2019. Implications of the study and recommendations for consideration by various interest groups (such as policy makers, and potential entrepreneurs) are discussed. This research contributes to theory building rather than theory testing of social acceptance of wind energy development.","author":["D\u0027Souza, C.","Yiridoe, E."],"organization":["La Trobe University","Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2014-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-24.237842000000","133.536539000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/828","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farm-externalities-public-preferences-community-consultation-ireland-discrete","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421516302002","title":"Wind farm externalities and public preferences for community consultation in Ireland: A discrete choice experiments approach","description":"In Ireland the deployment of onshore wind turbines has become progressively more difficult in some areas because of the potential negative externalities associated with their operation. Using a discrete choice experiment (DCE) we employ a willingness to accept framework to estimate the external effects of wind turbines on local residents with the inclusion of community consultation and to quantify the compensation required to permit wind farms to be built in Ireland. Our findings reveal that the majority of respondents are willing to make (monetary) tradeoffs to allow for wind power initiatives and we find that respondents require less compensation if provision is made for a community representative and setback distance is increased.","author":["Brennan, N.","Van Rensburg, T."],"organization":["National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2016-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.145652000000","-7.727007000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/829","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farms-farmland-occupation-compensation-evidences-landowners-preferences-through","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S030142151930463X","title":"Wind farms, farmland occupation and compensation: Evidences from landowners\u0027 preferences through a stated choice survey in Italy","description":"The willingness to accept the construction of wind farms on private properties is investigated using a latent class model approach. This type of research is required in view of the frequent conflicts between landowners and system operators, who often pay little in easement compensation.  This study highlights the fact that the acceptance of wind farms is a multifaceted issue comprising aspects relating to socioeconomics, farm type, territory, and past experience. In particular, the compensation claimed by landowners depends on the property\u0027s size, the number of turbines, the crop, the presence of surrounding wind farms, natural impacts, the landscape configuration, land fragmentation, land agreements, the presence of other wind towers on the property, and past experience with system operators concerning transparency and participation in the siting and planning phases.  Stakeholders should take these factors into account to develop energy policies based on clear, and well-structured processes concerning the siting, planning, construction, and management of wind farms, in order to prevent conflict and to benefit the community and environment.","author":["Sardaro, R.","Faccilongo, N.","Roselli, L."],"organization":["University of Bari Aldo Moro","University of Foggia"],"originationDate":"2019-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.606069000000","12.796687000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/830","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-effects-deep-seawater-discharge-ocean-thermal-energy-conversion-plant-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969719334114","title":"Potential effects of deep seawater discharge by an Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion plant on the marine microorganisms in oligotrophic waters","description":"Installation of an Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion pilot plant (OTEC) off the Caribbean coast of Martinique is expected to use approximately 100,000 m3 h\u22121 of deep seawater for its functioning. This study examined the potential effects of the cold nutrient-rich deep seawater discharge on the phytoplankton community living in the surface warm oligotrophic waters before the installation of the pilot plant. Numerical simulations of deep seawater upwelled by the OTEC, showed that a 3.0 \u00b0C temperature change, considered as a critical threshold for temperature impact, was never reached during an annual cycle on the top 150 m of the water column on two considered sections centered on the OTEC. The thermal effect should be limited, \u0026lt;1 km2 on the area exhibited a temperature difference of 0.3 \u00b0C (absolute value), producing a negligible thermic impact on the phytoplankton assemblage. The impact on phytoplankton of the resulting mixed deep and surface seawater was evaluated by in situ microcosm experiments. Two scenarios of water mix ratio (2% and 10% of deep water) were tested at two incubation depths (deep chlorophyll-a maximum: DCM and bottom of the euphotic layer: BEL). The larger impact was obtained at DCM for the highest deep seawater addition (10%), with a development of diatoms and haptophytes, whereas 2% addition induced only a limited change of the phytoplankton community (relatively higher Prochlorococcus sp. abundance, but without significant shift of the assemblage). This study suggested that the OTEC plant would significantly modify the phytoplankton assemblage with a shift from pico-phytoplankton toward micro-phytoplankton only in the case of a discharge affecting the DCM and would be restricted to a local scale. Since the lower impact on the phytoplankton assemblage was obtained at BEL, this depth can be recommended for the discharge of the deep seawater to exploit the OTEC plant.","author":["Sudre, J.","Giraud, M.","Gar\u00e7on, V.","de la Broise, D.","L\u0027Helguen, S.","Boyes, M."],"organization":["France Energies Marines"],"originationDate":"2019-11-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["14.660206000000","-61.007932000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["OTEC"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Water Quality","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/831","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/external-effects-renewable-energy-projects-life-cycle-analysis-based-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/econjournals.com\/index.php\/ijeep\/article\/view\/7959","title":"External Effects of Renewable Energy Projects: Life Cycle Analysis-based Approach","description":"Nowadays planning and developing of innovative renewable energy projects across the globe imply calculation and consideration of negative environmental effects not only at the stage of utilization but also at the stage of manufacturing and disposal. Thus, the modern practice of environmental management on a regional level requires the more widespread introduction of life cycle analysis. The aim of the present paper is to develop an environmental effects evaluation methodology based on ecological impact categories through all the stages of lifecycle of renewable energy technologies. We used DEA-based calculation of the efficiency score for each renewable energy technology. EcoInvent database which rests on CML 2001 methodology has been chosen as a source of eco-indicators. We suppose, the efficiency ratio will remain unchanged, when transferring estimates of the life cycle of renewable energy facilities to another territory. This allows us to use data obtained in other regions of the world, to extrapolate comparative assessments and make the choice of the most environmentally preferable technology. The input-oriented DEA modelling has demonstrated geothermal and biogas technologies are the most preferable from an environmental point of view with the highest possible score. The least effective technologies are both modifications of PV with the minimum efficiency score. The results of the presented work might be useful for decision- and policymakers for a more consistent planning and energy strategy deployment.","author":["Salnikova, A.","Chepurko, Y.","Starkova, N.","Ho\u00e0ng, H."],"organization":["Kuban State University"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-11 08:07:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/lca_renewable.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/833","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/geographic-context-affects-landscape-change-fragmentation-caused-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/peerj.com\/articles\/7129\/","title":"Geographic context affects the landscape change and fragmentation caused by wind energy facilities","description":"Wind energy generation affects landscapes as new roads, pads, and transmission lines are constructed. Limiting the landscape change from these facilities likely minimizes impacts to biodiversity and sensitive wildlife species. We examined the effects of wind energy facilities\u2019 geographic context on changes in landscape patterns using three metrics: portion of undeveloped land, core area index, and connectance index. We digitized 39 wind facilities and the surrounding land cover and measured landscape pattern before and after facility construction using the amount, core area, and connectivity of undeveloped land within one km around newly constructed turbines and roads. New facilities decreased the amount of undeveloped land by 1.8% while changes in metrics of landscape pattern ranged from 50 to 140%. Statistical models indicated pre-construction development was a key factor explaining the impact of new wind facilities on landscape metrics, with pre-construction road networks, turbine spacing, and topography having smaller influences. As the proportion of developed land around facilities increased, a higher proportion of the facility utilized pre-construction developed land and a lower density of new roads were built, resulting in smaller impacts to undeveloped landscapes. Building of new road networks was also a predictor of landscape fragmentation. Utilizing existing development and carefully placing turbines may provide opportunities to minimize the impacts of new wind energy facilities.","author":["Diffendorfer, J.","Dorning, M.","Keen, J.","Kramer, L.","Taylor, R."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-07-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.418580600000","-94.146991400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/834","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/increased-integration-between-innovative-ocean-energy-eu-habitats-species-water","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X18303245","title":"Increased integration between innovative ocean energy and the EU habitats, species and water protection rules through Maritime Spatial Planning","description":"This article investigates whether Maritime Spatial Planning (MSP) \u2013which promotes the integrated planning and management of seas and oceans\u2013 can play a role in creating increased integration between the EU\u0027s renewable energy policy and the potentially conflicting rules on the protection of habitats, species and water. The article focuses on innovative ocean energy (tidal stream, wave and salinity gradient energy). It can be said that there is a possible lack of integration between the Renewable Energy Directive and the EU rules on the protection of habitats, species and water: the Habitats Directive, the Birds Directive, the Water Framework Directive and the Marine Strategy Framework Directive. The role that MSP could play in solving this is assessed with regard to the following two legal issues that reflect the said lack of integration: 1) while there are derogation clauses, there is no obligation for Member States to apply these clauses and to undertake a balancing act between ocean energy, on the one hand, and the protection of habitats, species and water, on the other; 2) even if these clauses are applied, it remains unclear how much weight Member States should attach to ocean energy under a subsequent balancing act. The concept of Maritime Spatial Planning in theory is very suitable for guaranteeing that the interests of both renewable energy policy and environmental policy are duly taken into account in licensing procedures and management measures. The contribution that MSP can make towards increased integration is, however, strongly dependent on the way MSP is interpreted on the Member State level. This is illustrated by a discussion of the differences in the current MSP approaches in Scotland and the Netherlands. This article concludes that Maritime Spatial Planning may \u2013if certain conditions are fulfilled\u2013 be a suitable way to create a necessity to balance the EU\u0027s habitats, species and water protection rules with (ocean) renewable energy projects, on different levels of governance. Nevertheless, it also concludes that MSP alone cannot guarantee a balancing act that represents the goals of the Renewable Energy Directive and those of the aforementioned environmental directives in an equal manner. This article proposes to link MSP to detailed renewable energy plans per Member State in order to solve this issue.","author":["van Hees, S."],"organization":["Utrecht University"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.340922600000","5.220445400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Ocean Current","Salinity Gradient","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/835","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-epibenthic-assemblages-artificial-habitat-associated-marine-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article-abstract\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsy151\/5137117","title":"Development of epibenthic assemblages on artificial habitat associated with marine renewable infrastructure","description":"Offshore marine renewable energy installations (MREI) introduce structure into the marine environment and can locally exclude destructive, bottom trawl fishing. These effects have the potential to aid restoration of degraded seabed habitats but may be constrained by timescales of ecological succession following MREI construction, and the removal of infrastructure during decommissioning. To inform managers about appropriate decommissioning strategies, a 25 km cable and associated rock armouring (Wave Hub, UK), installed on rocky reef, was monitored up to 5 years post-deployment. The epibenthic Assemblage composition, and Number of taxa remained significantly different from surrounding controls, while Abundance was similar in all survey years between the cable and controls. Six morphotaxa showed four patterns of colonization on cable plots compared to the controls: (i) Early colonization, which remained in greater abundances (Porifera), (ii) early colonization, converging (Turf), (iii) slow colonization, converging Anthozoa and Vertebrata), and (iv) slow colonization, remaining lower in abundance (Tunicata and Echinodermata). The environmental relevance of this MREI is considered relatively benign as it covers 0.01% of the surrounding bioregion, appears to be supporting similar assemblages to the surrounding habitat, and exhibited minimal evidence of invasive species (three records of two non-native species). Longer monitoring timescales are required to provide comprehensive, site-specific decommissioning advice.","author":["Sheehan, E.","Attrill, M.","Witt, M.","Holmes, L.","Cartwright, A.","Vural, M."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2020-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.049336000000","-2.077346000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/836","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-impact-tidal-stream-energy-extraction-lagrangian-circulation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261917307791","title":"Assessing the impact of tidal stream energy extraction on the Lagrangian circulation","description":"Whereas numerous numerical modelling have been conducted to gain further insights about the hydrodynamic characteristics of tidal stream energy sites, the long-term transport of water particles has been routinely ignored. However, a refined evaluation of circulation pathways is fundamental to assess water-quality changes induced by tidal energy converters. The present study investigates the tide-induced Lagrangian circulation in north-western coastal waters of Brittany (France, western Europe), including numerous islands, shoals and straits with strong potential for turbine farm implementation. Particular attention is dedicated to the hydrodynamic impact of tidal stream power extraction from a series of horizontal-axis turbines. An original approach, based on the coupling of the Lagrangian barycentric method with predictions from a model at high spatial resolution, is considered to assess circulation pathways in a single synoptic view. Spatial results reveal a complex Lagrangian circulation highly controlled by bathymetry and islands geometry. The residual flow in the Fromveur Strait, separating Ushant island from Mol\u00e8ne archipelago, displays thus a strong asymmetry, between a prominent north-eastern pathway with residual currents up to 0.45ms-1 and a southward circulation. The positions of cyclonic and anti-cyclonic recirculations, both upstream and downstream the Strait, are furthermore precisely defined. The north eddy is found closely located to the sand bank of the Four. The extraction of tidal stream power impacts mainly the residual Lagrangian circulation along the current stream emerging from the Strait, with a tendency for surrounding eddies to get closer to the tidal stream energy site. The displacements of the south and north recirculations may thus exceed 1.5 km with possible implications on the evolution of surrounding seabed features.","author":["Guillou, N.","Chapalain, G."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.820126000000","2.759407000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/837","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-noise-abatement-systems-offshore-wind-farm-construction-noise-potential-their","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/snh-research-report-1070-review-noise-abatement-systems-offshore-wind-farm-construction-noise-and","title":"A review of noise abatement systems for offshore wind farm construction noise, and the potential for their application in Scottish waters","description":"The Scottish Government supports plans to develop a large number of offshore wind farms (OWF) in Scottish territorial waters and the exclusive economic zone. The installation of foundations for offshore wind turbines often involves pile driving operations using large hydraulic hammers which introduce significant noise into the marine environment. Piling noise has the potential to impact both marine mammals and fish.  The primary objectives of this study were to undertake a review of available underwater noise abatement systems (NAS) in relation to their applicability for pile-driving operations for OWF construction in Scottish waters. Parameters of interest were: efficacy in noise reduction and the resulting benefit to marine fauna, practicality of use, cost, and impact\/influence on the construction schedule. A secondary objective was to consider the applicability of existing NAS to mitigate noise generated by controlled explosions of unexploded ordnance. The study was based on a review of peer-reviewed publications and relevant \u2018grey\u2019 literature, combined with a questionnaire-based survey followed up by interviews with system-suppliers and end-users of NAS.  This review reflects available information, together with the knowledge, experience and opinions of NAS-suppliers and NAS-users, and does not necessarily reflect those of the authors or of Scottish Natural Heritage. This is not a detailed evaluation of which system can or cannot be deployed in specific wind farm areas.","author":["Sparling, C.","Verfuss, U.","Sinclair, R."],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Verfuss_et_al_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/838","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/monitoring-marine-mammal-strandings-along-french-coasts-reveals-importance-ship","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2019.00486\/full","title":"Monitoring of Marine Mammal Strandings Along French Coasts Reveals the Importance of Ship Strikes on Large Cetaceans: A Challenge for the European Marine Strategy Framework Directive","description":"The incidence of marine traffic has risen in recent decades and is expected to continue rising as maritime traffic, vessel speed, and engine power all continue to increase. Although long considered anecdotal, ship strikes are now recognized as a major threat to cetaceans. However, estimation of ship strike rates is still challenging notably because such events occurred generally far offshore and collision between large ships and whales go often unnoticed by ship crew. The monitoring of marine mammal strandings remain one the most efficient ways to evaluate the problem. In France, a national coordinated network collected data and samples on stranded marine mammals since 1972 along the Mediterranean and Atlantic French coasts. We examined stranding data, including photography and necropsy reports, collected between 1972 and 2017 with the aim to provide a comprehensive review of confirmed collision records of large whales in France. During this period, a total of 51 ship strike incidents were identified which represents the 1st identified causes of mortality for large whale in France. It has increased since 1972 with seven records during the 1st decade to reach 22 stranded animals observed between 2005 and 2017. This issue appears particularly critical in the Mediterranean Sea where one in five stranded whales showed evidence of ship strike. This review of collision records highlights the risk of a negative impact of this anthropogenic pressure on the dynamic of whale populations in Europe, suggesting that ship strike rates could not allow achieving the Good Environmental Status of marine mammal populations required by the European Marine Strategy Framework Directive.","author":["Peltier, H.","Beaufils, A.","Cesarini, C.","Dabin, W.","Dars, C.","Demaret, F.","Dhermain, F.","Doremus, G.","Labach, H.","Canneyt, O.","Spitz, J."],"organization":["University of La Rochelle (Universit\u00e9 de La Rochelle)"],"originationDate":"2019-07-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.895578000000","-2.370878000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Vessel Strike"],"modifiedDate":"2025-02-14 06:58:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Peltier-2019-Whales.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/839","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-birds-offshore-wind-farm-egmond-aan-zee-owez-overview-integration-insights","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.academia.edu\/2387412\/Effects_on_birds_of_Offshore_Wind_farm_Egmond_aan_Zee_OWEZ_._An_overview_and_integration_of_insights_obtained","title":"Effects on birds of Offshore Wind farm Egmond aan Zee (OWEZ): An overview and integration of insights obtained","description":"\u2018NoordzeeWind\u2019 (a joint venture of Nuon Duurzame Energie and Shell Wind Energy) has built a wind farm consisting of 36 Vestas V90\/3MW wind turbines off the coast of the Netherlands, near Egmond aan Zee. The turbines were built in the summer of 2006 and the site is in operation since January 2007. The main goal of this wind farm is to evaluate the economical, technical, ecological and social effects of offshore wind farms in general. Therefore a Monitoring and Evaluation Program (NSW-MEP) has been developed to gather the knowledge resulting from this project. This knowledge will be made available to all parties involved in the realization of large-scale offshore wind farms. Bureau Waardenburg and IMARES in cooperation have been commissioned to execute both the baseline and the effect study on the effects the wind farm has on flight paths, flight altitudes and flux of local and migrating marine birds as well as non-marine migrating birds.  The bird research in OWEZ, before and after the realization of the wind farm, took place between 2002 and 2010. The research included studies on the effects of the wind farm on local birds (Leopold et al. 2011), as well as on flying birds (Krijgsveld et al. 2011) and also included an assessment of the cumulative effects of the hypothetical realisation of multiple offshore wind farms in the Dutch North Sea (Poot et al. 2011a). Finally, in 2010-2011, the situation at OWEZ was compared to the situation at a location much further offshore, at the gas production platform K14C (Fijn et al. 2012).  In the report at hand, the knowledge gathered at OWEZ on the effects of the wind farm on birds is summarised and integrated in order to obtain a comprehensive overview of the current knowledge on potential effects of offshore wind farms on birds. The conclusions presented in this report can be used in the site-selection process for future offshore wind farms, to minimise the potential effects of these wind farms on birds.  The Offshore Wind farm Egmond aan Zee has a subsidy of the Ministry of Economic Affairs under the CO2 Reduction Scheme of the Netherlands.","author":["Poot, M.","Dirksen, S.","Fijn, R.","Krijgsveld, K.","Leopold, M.","Hartman, J."],"organization":["Bureau Waardenburg bv","Noordzeewind"],"originationDate":"2012-06-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.626169000000","4.614176000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-25 06:25:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hartman-et-al-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/840","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-habitat-loss-method-assessing-displacement-impacts-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.academia.edu\/29384482\/Developing_a_Habitat_Loss_Method_for_Assessing_Displacement_Impacts_from_Offshore_Wind_Farms","title":"Developing a Habitat Loss Method for Assessing Displacement Impacts from Offshore Wind Farms","description":"The impacts of offshore wind farms (OWFs) on seabirds are typically divided into three forms: collision mortality, barrier impacts and displacement impacts. This report investigates the validity of assumptions underlying a recently suggested approach, defined as the \u2032Displacement as Habitat Loss\u2032 approach. This approach interprets displacement impacts as a time restricted, quasi-permanent habitat loss rather than a year-on-year effect across the entire operational lifetime of an OWF. It proposes that after displacement impacts have been exerted on a population, a new, stable population equilibrium is reached at some level below the initial starting population. By examining the assumptions underlying this approach and outlining ways of translating it into a staged assessment framework, this report provides an analysis of the pros and cons of the \u2032Displacement as Habitat Loss\u2032 approach.","author":["Busch, M.","Rehfisch, M.","Buisson, R.","Barrett, Z.","Davies, S."],"organization":["Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)"],"originationDate":"2015-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.276117200000","-5.754382000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Busch-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/841","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/education-training-maritime-spatial-planners","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_19","title":"Education and Training for Maritime Spatial Planners","description":"The practice of Maritime Spatial Planning (MSP) has developed substantially during the last decade, calling for more qualified professionals. Education, training, and growth capacity for MSP, however, are (still) some of the less addressed themes in MSP forums and specific learning materials, such as textbooks and practice manuals. Some teaching initiatives have nevertheless arisen at the postgraduate level for training new and specialised practitioners in the MSP field. A quick overview of such initiatives will help answer some questions concerning the path to follow for MSP education and training. This chapter presents an exploratory diagnosis based on a discussion of the basic skills needed to achieve successful professional practice. What skills are expected from a maritime spatial planner? Is a specific background required to become a maritime spatial planner? How should such professionals be trained? These questions are discussed using the visions and insights of consultants, maritime sectors, policymakers, scientists, and teachers of MSP, with experience in countries where MSP processes are already in place.  More on Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future","author":["Fonseca, C.","Calado, H.","Ansong, J.","Frias, M.","Verg\u00edlio, M."],"organization":["University of Azores","Universidade de Lisboa","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/842","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-marine-spatial-planning-valuing-process-knowing-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_18","title":"Evaluation of Marine Spatial Planning: Valuing the Process, Knowing the Impacts","description":"A need for evaluating maritime spatial planning (MSP) has become more important as countries are preparing and implementing their MSP. Evaluations are opportunities to foster learning and to accumulate knowledge in order to improve the processes and effectiveness of MSP. Empirical evidence has shown that MSP processes are run in different ways and for different purposes. To address this diversity, this chapter presents a methodology for designing a flexible and context-specific evaluation of MSP. This chapter introduces a theory-based evaluation approach that aims to explain how and why the evaluated planning process or plan works or fails to work. It scrutinises how MSP produces intended and unintended effects, for whom and in what contexts and what mechanisms are triggered by the MSP.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future","author":["Varjopuro, R."],"organization":["Finnish Environment Institute (SYKE)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/843","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/need-marine-spatial-planning-areas-beyond-national-jurisdiction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_17","title":"The Need for Marine Spatial Planning in Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction","description":"Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) provides an important tool for sustainably managing mounting pressures on the living and non-living resources in marine areas beyond national jurisdiction (ABNJ). Taking into account the interests of sectors and nature conservation, MSP fosters processes related to stakeholder exchange and collective governance mechanisms. A large amount of experience has been gained at national or regional level on how to apply MSP in cross-border situations. This chapter highlights the existing legal framework and which organisations could foster MSP in ABNJ. Furthermore, it assesses whether existing MSP tools are somehow transferable to ABNJ and shows first results of MSP projects in these areas.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Altvater, S.","Fletcher, R.","Passarello, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/844","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/role-law-sea-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_16","title":"The Role of the Law of the Sea in Marine Spatial Planning","description":"The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) is a globally recognized legal regime. UNCLOS has been widely regarded as a \u201cconstitution for the oceans\u201d and enshrines the notion that \u201cthe problems of ocean space are closely interrelated and need to be considered as a whole\u201d. In compliance with the concept of effective enforcement of international norms, standards and procedures, State Parties to UNCLOS have an obligation to preserve the marine environment. The purpose of this chapter is to consider the role of the law of the sea in marine spatial planning (MSP), bearing in mind that UNCLOS has also provided the framework for the further development of, inter alia, global ocean governance.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future","author":["Py\u0107, D."],"organization":["University of Gda\u0144sk"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/845","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/managing-risk-through-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_15","title":"Managing Risk Through Marine Spatial Planning","description":"Governance and management are inherently risk management processes. In a management context, risk is related to the uncertainties of achieving set objectives. Risk assessment is used to identify and analyse risks in terms of likelihood and consequences. This chapter relates risk to the process of developing a maritime spatial plan. Risk may arise from not identifying and understanding the risks perceived by stakeholders, from not having specific goals and objectives or from unclear structures and decision-making rules. For the plan itself, risks are related to not having adequate spatial allocation for activities to achieve set objectives. Risk may also be related to not having the authority needed to lead the planning process and, subsequently, implement the spatial allocation identified in the plan.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Kannen, A.","Cormier, R."],"organization":["Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/847","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/scenario-building-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_14","title":"Scenario-Building for Marine Spatial Planning","description":"This chapter focuses on the use of scenarios to inform the development of marine spatial plans. An in-depth example of scenario-building for the Celtic Seas is presented, based on a four-way\u00a0possibility space\u00a0using the axes of spatial efficiency and cooperation between planning authorities to create four scenarios which were tested in a workshop. This demonstrated the importance of using scenarios to understand the aspirations of different stakeholders towards integration within the marine spatial planning (MSP) process, the realities of encouraging co-location between sea uses and highlighted important issues where further transboundary cooperation on MSP may be required.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future","author":["Jay, S.","Kidd, S.","McGowan, L."],"organization":["University of Liverpool"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/848","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stakeholder-processes-marine-spatial-planning-ambitions-realities-european-atlantic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_13","title":"Stakeholder Processes in Marine Spatial Planning: Ambitions and Realities from the European Atlantic Experience","description":"Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) requires the participation of various stakeholders representing the multiple sectors operating in any given planning area. At a theoretical level, early and effective stakeholder participation is a fundamental aspect of MSP; it is also a legal requirement under a host of international and European instruments. This chapter explores the real-life challenges associated with delivering multi-sector participatory MSP processes. Insights and practical recommendations are drawn from five case studies from Europe\u2019s Atlantic sea basin including a research-based civil-society-led transboundary MSP pilot project, and four statutory initiatives from EU Member States on the island of Ireland and the Iberian coast. Various degrees of disconnect are identified between the conceptual underpinnings of MSP theory and the reality of recent stakeholder processes.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Twomey, S.","O\u0027Mahony, C."],"organization":["University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/849","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/linking-integrated-coastal-zone-management-maritime-spatial-planning-mediterranean","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_12","title":"Linking Integrated Coastal Zone Management to Maritime Spatial Planning: The Mediterranean Experience","description":"The Mediterranean is not only complex in ecology but also socio-politically and economically. The rapid economic development of the last decades is expected to further increase in the future, providing benefits for Mediterranean countries but also increasing pressure on coastal and marine environments and intensifying conflicts between different activities. This chapter illustrates the policy frame supporting Maritime Spatial Planning (MSP) implementation in the entire Mediterranean Sea. It discusses the importance of linking MSP with Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM) given the high relevance of land-sea interactions. Although the process of MSP implementation is mainly at an initial stage in this sea basin, it can rely on broad-scale project-based experience. Examples of developed practices are provided in this chapter.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Bocci, M.","Ramieri, E.","Markovic, M."],"organization":["Thetis SpA"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.038788700000","17.890005300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/850","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-perspective","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_2","title":"The Ocean Perspective","description":"Oceans have held varying places in the imagination of societies, always linked to particular cultures and shifting in line with predominant world views and developing socio-economic and technological capacities. This chapter presents three Western ways of looking at the ocean. Each emerged at a particular period, but all continue to shape today\u2019s conceptions of the ocean. There are many other ways of conceptualising the ocean, and different concepts exist concurrently, resulting in a multiplicity of perspectives that are changing over time. Although some scholars are debating whether it is possible to know the ocean at all, the selected concepts\u2014incomplete though they may be\u2014also point to contradictory perceptions of the ocean that may have a bearing on how we do maritime spatial planning.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future","author":["Gee, K."],"organization":["Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/851","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/towards-ladder-marinemaritime-spatial-planning-participation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_10","title":"Towards a Ladder of Marine\/Maritime Spatial Planning Participation","description":"Presently, institutional systems and practices in marine\/maritime spatial planning (MSP) are evolving rapidly. At the same time, cross-border learning and exchange are still at an early stage. This chapter is based on the need to assess and compare participation processes across cases and countries and foster learning to develop public participation in MSP. Based on theoretical reflections, but anchored in results derived from the BaltSpace and the Baltic SCOPE projects, we present an analytical framework to characterise participation in MSP, including a participation ladder emphasising power sharing, roles, functions and learning. It is inspired by the land-based planning discourse, rural development literature, natural resource and conflict management and the latest publications with an MSP perspective including one in this book.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future","author":["Gee, K.","Morf, A.","Kull, M.","Piwowarczyk, J."],"organization":["University of Gothenburg","Polish Academy of Sciences","Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/852","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/politics-power-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_9","title":"Politics and Power in Marine Spatial Planning","description":"Marine spatial planning (MSP) has been lauded as a remedy to unsuitable marine management. There is, however, growing MSP research illustrating that it is failing to foster paradigm shifts towards sustainable governance. The gap between MSP theory and practice is due to its asocial and apolitical implementation. This narrow version of MSP has been advanced through post-political planning and uncritical rationalities. The result is a choreographed form of MSP, with clearly defined outcomes that serve the needs of elite actors rather than the public interest. This chapter argues that to recapture its democratising potential, MSP requires explicit engagement with politics and power. We highlight the use of the boundary object lens and citizen science as two potential avenues to facilitate this engagement.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Clarke, J.","Flannery, W.","McAteer, B."],"organization":["Queen\u0027s University Belfast"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/853","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/adding-people-sea-conceptualizing-social-sustainability-maritime-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_8","title":"Adding People to the Sea: Conceptualizing Social Sustainability in Maritime Spatial Planning","description":"While there is growing critique emerging to address social sustainability in marine\/maritime spatial planning (MSP), overwhelmingly attention has been on governance, economic and environmental aspects. This chapter redresses this by proposing a conceptual framework to elucidate key features of social sustainability in MSP. The ambition is to both note the existing critique of MSP and go beyond it by more clearly and comprehensively articulating how social sustainability could be conceived in MSP, as well as how this framework could be applied to analyse MSP practice. Key features of social sustainability elaborated are: deepening democratic decision-making, inclusion of socio-cultural values and knowledge, equitable distribution and social cohesion. Finally, the chapter concludes by nominating strategies to give greater visibility to social sustainability as a key MSP concern.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Tafon, R.","Saunders, F.","Gilek, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/854","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/socio-cultural-dimensions-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_7","title":"Socio-cultural Dimensions of Marine Spatial Planning","description":"Bringing together the complex social and cultural dimensions of marine spatial planning (MSP), this chapter examines how these two terms are applied (or not) in the context of MSP. Global marine and coastal planning continues to recognise that human activities must be considered in order to account for the dynamic interconnectivity between society and the sea. Many research fields explore the importance of the sea to identity, sense of place, health or community cohesion. However, these draw on a range of different assumptions to mainstream marine science and struggle to be incorporated into traditional policy processes, environmental assessments and large-scale planning processes. In this chapter, we interrogate the concept of \u2018socio-cultural\u2019, examining how this is being defined and applied across the MSP landscape.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Stojanovic, T.","McKinley, E.","Acott, T."],"organization":["Cardiff University","University of Greenwich","University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/855","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/maritime-spatial-planning-eus-blue-growth-policy-past-present-future-perspectives","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_6","title":"Maritime Spatial Planning and the EU\u0027s Blue Growth Policy: Past, Present and Future Perspectives","description":"This chapter discusses the role of Maritime spatial planning (MSP) and its relationship to Blue Growth. After presenting differences among European sea-basins with regard to blue sector development, it underlines the need for a differentiated definition and policy support for Blue Growth. We argue that MSP should be adapted towards the different Blue Growth support needs of countries, regions and maritime sectors throughout Europe. The success of MSP as a tool to support Blue Growth depends on how strongly MSP is intertwined with other measures of the Integrated Maritime Policy and territorial development measures. MSP should be seen more strongly in strategic future development planning, for example, highlighting potential development areas which may stimulate economic growth in territorial areas lagging behind others.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Lukic, I.","Schultz-Zehden, A.","Weig, B."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/856","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/can-classical-location-theory-apply-sea-space","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_5","title":"Can Classical Location Theory Apply to Sea Space?","description":"In economics, maritime\/marine spatial planning (MSP) can be classified as a public choice mechanism designed to alleviate market failure. As such, MSP should ensure rational use or conservation of sea space in situations where the market cannot deliver optimal solutions. In this chapter, both market and public choice mechanisms for allocating sea space are discussed. The final conclusion is that both are closely interrelated. MSP cannot neglect market forces; however, the market itself is unable to allocate space to issues considered important from a societal point of view, such as nature conservation, defence or non-use of the sea.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Zaucha, J."],"organization":["University of Gda\u0144sk"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/857","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/systematic-conservation-planning-tool-advance-ecologically-or-biologically-significant","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_4","title":"Systematic Conservation Planning as a Tool to Advance Ecologically or Biologically Significant Area and Marine Spatial Planning Processes","description":"Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) intends to create an improved, rational use of the ocean to reduce conflict among competing uses to achieve social, economic and environmental objectives. Systematic Conservation Planning (SCP) can contribute to MSP because it is also spatially explicit, deliberately seeks to reduce conflict and generates an evidence-based prioritisation of ocean-space use. Importantly, SCP includes biodiversity representation and persistence, is underpinned by quantitative targets and uses complementarity to achieve targets efficiently. Therefore, designing Ecologically or Biologically Significant Areas (EBSAs) using SCP improves their identification and delineation compared to current expert-based approaches, with greater likelihood of uptake in MSP because their SCP-based design deliberately avoids competing activities where possible. These principles are demonstrated in a case study of the Benguela Current Large Marine Ecosystem.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Harris, L.","Holness, S.","Finke, G.","Kirkman, S.","Sink, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["-12.515713700000","13.341432100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/858","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/maritimemarine-spatial-planning-interface-research-practice","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_1","title":"Maritime\/Marine Spatial Planning at the Interface of Research and Practice","description":"This chapter introduces marine\/maritime spatial planning (MSP) from the perspective of research and practice. After providing some basic definitions and terminology, it shows how MSP has developed since its inception, ending with a description of its\u00a0current status of adoption around the world. It also sets out how MSP has been received in various academic disciplines and traces some of the key discussions that have emerged. The chapter closes by providing a brief overview of the subsequent chapters.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Gee, K.","Ehler, C.","Zaucha, J."],"organization":["United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)","University of Gda\u0144sk","Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/859","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/challenges-opportunities-ecosystem-based-management-marine-spatial-planning-irish-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_3","title":"Challenges and Opportunities for Ecosystem-Based Management and Marine Spatial Planning in the Irish Sea","description":"Ecosystem-Based Management (EBM) integrates the connections between land, air, water and all living things including human beings and their institutions. The location of the Irish Sea, between major historical industrial centres, its history of use and exploitation, combined with its hydrographic characteristics, have led to the current patterns of use. EBM efforts have been ongoing for over a decade but political boundaries have led to fragmented governance. The forthcoming UK exit from the European Union (EU) may pose further challenges. This chapter examines articulations between political boundaries, spatial scales of Marine Spatial Planning and nested social-ecological systems including the gyre in the western Irish Sea, and Dublin Bay. Examples of emerging best practices are provided and the challenges of data availability for ecosystem services are considered.\n\nMore on\u00a0Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["O\u0027Hagan, A.","O\u0027Higgins, T.","Ansong, J.","O\u0027Higgins, L."],"organization":["University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.655016600000","-5.651578800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/860","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/maritime-spatial-planning-past-present-future","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8#about","title":"Maritime spatial planning: past, present, future","description":"Maritime or marine spatial planning has gained increasing prominence as an integrated, common-sense approach to promoting sustainable maritime development. A growing number of countries are engaged in preparing and implementing maritime spatial plans: however, questions are emerging from the growing body of MSP experience. How can maritime spatial planning deal with a complex and dynamic environment such as the sea? How can MSP be embedded in multiple levels of governance across regional and national borders \u2013 and how far does the environment benefit from this new approach?\n\nThis open access book is the first comprehensive overview of maritime spatial planning. Situated at the intersection between theory and practice, the volume draws together several strands of interdisciplinary research, reflecting on the history of MSP as well as examining current practice and looking towards the future. The authors and contributors examine MSP from disciplines as diverse as geography, urban planning, political science, natural science, sociology and education; reflecting the growing critical engagement with MSP in many academic fields. This innovative and pioneering volume will be of interest and value to students and scholars of maritime spatial planning, as well as planners and practitioners.\n\nTable of Contents: \n\nChapter 1: Maritime\/Marine Spatial Planning at the Interface of Research and Practice\n\nChapter 2: The Ocean Perspective \n\nChapter 3: Challenges and Opportunities for Ecosystem-Based Management and Marine Spatial Planning in the Irish Sea\n\nChapter 4: Systematic Conservation Planning as a Tool to Advance Ecologically or Biologically Significant Area and Marine Spatial Planning Processes\n\nChapter 5: Can Classical Location Theory Apply to Sea Space?\n\nChapter 6: Maritime Spatial Planning and the EU\u2019s Blue Growth Policy: Past, Present and Future Perspectives \n\nChapter 7: Socio-cultural Dimensions of Marine Spatial Planning\n\nChapter 8: Adding People to the Sea: Conceptualizing Social Sustainability in Maritime Spatial Planning\n\nChapter 9: Politics and Power in Marine Spatial Planning\n\nChapter 10: Towards a Ladder of Marine\/Maritime Spatial Planning Participation\n\nChapter 11: Taking Account of Land-Sea Interactions in Marine Spatial Planning\n\nChapter 12: Linking Integrated Coastal Zone Management to Maritime Spatial Planning: The Mediterranean Experience\n\nChapter 13: Stakeholder Processes in Marine Spatial Planning: Ambitions and Realities from the European Atlantic Experience\n\nChapter 14: Scenario-Building for Marine Spatial Planning\n\nChapter 15: Managing Risk Through Marine Spatial Planning\n\nChapter 16: The Role of the Law of the Sea in Marine Spatial Planning\n\nChapter 17: The Need for Marine Spatial Planning in Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction\n\nChapter 18: Evaluation of Marine Spatial Planning: Valuing the Process, Knowing the Impacts \n\nChapter 19: Education and Training for Maritime Spatial Planners","author":["Gee, K.","Zaucha, J."],"organization":["University of Gda\u0144sk","Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-29 10:00:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/861","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/taking-account-land-sea-interactions-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-98696-8_11","title":"Taking Account of Land-Sea Interactions in Marine Spatial Planning","description":"This chapter reflects on marine\/maritime spatial planning (MSP) from a Land-Sea Interaction (LSI) perspective. It raises questions about the role and limitations of MSP in addressing sustainable development of the world\u2019s oceans as many of the issues it is concerned with are inextricably connected to activity on the land. The chapter starts by identifying LSI considerations in some of the key documents that are guiding the establishment of MSP. It then sets out a framework for considering LSI and explores the different dimensions with particular reference to examples from European experience. It ends with an exploration of how LSI matters might inform future directions for MSP and may be heralding a new era of Territorial Spatial Planning (TSP), which spans both land and sea.\n\n\nMore on Maritime Spatial Planning: past, present, future\u00a0","author":["Jay, S.","Jones, H.","Kidd, S."],"organization":["University of Liverpool"],"originationDate":"2019-01-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_1.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_2.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_3.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_4.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_5.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_6.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_7.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_8.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_9.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_10.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_11.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_12.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_13.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_14.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_15.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_16.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2019_Book_MaritimeSpatialPlanning_17.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/862","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/integrated-ecosystem-assessments-developing-scientific-basis-ecosystem-based","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosbiology\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pbio.1000014","title":"Integrated Ecosystem Assessments: Developing the Scientific Basis for Ecosystem-Based Management of the Ocean","description":"A series of prominent and controversial papers about the state of marine ecosystems has occupied the pages of high-profile journals over the last decade. While some might quarrel with the specific conclusions of these papers, there is no dispute that managers of ocean and coastal habitats confront a growing diversity of very serious challenges\u00a0that, if left unattended, threaten the ability of marine ecosystems to supply the goods and services required or desired by humans.","author":["Levin, P.","Fluharty, D.","Fogarty, M.","Murawski, S."],"organization":["National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2009-01-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.368338300000","-121.542597000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Integrated_Ecosystem_Assessments_Developing_the_Scientific_Basis_for_Ecosystem_Based_Management_of_the-Ocean.PDF"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/863","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/internet-things-marine-environment-monitoring-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1424-8220\/19\/7\/1711","title":"Internet of Things in Marine Environment Monitoring: A Review","description":"Marine environment monitoring has attracted more and more attention due to the growing concern about climate change. During the past couple of decades, advanced information and communication technologies have been applied to the development of various marine environment monitoring systems. Among others, the Internet of Things (IoT) has been playing an important role in this area. This paper presents a review of the application of the Internet of Things in the field of marine environment monitoring. New technologies including advanced Big Data analytics and their applications in this area are briefly reviewed. It also discusses key research challenges and opportunities in this area, including the potential application of IoT and Big Data in marine environment protection.","author":["Sun, X.","Xu, G.","Shi, Y.","Shen, W."],"organization":["Dalian Maritime University"],"originationDate":"2019-04-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/864","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sustainable-renewable-energy-planning-wind-farming-optimization-biodiversity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544219314896","title":"Sustainable renewable energy planning and wind farming optimization from a biodiversity perspective","description":"The impacts of climate change, largely fuelled by the consumption of fossil fuels and an unhealthy consuming lifestyle, are encouraging a wide and far ranging adoption of renewable energy sources. This is critical, and well received, for countries who are on the frontline of climate change, in particular Small Island Developing States (SIDS) and those with fragile, unique and complex natural ecosystems. While there has been research on the importance of renewable energy and on the increasing of its efficiency for bettering its adoption and resulting economic gain, there is however little literature on the design and its implementation in respect to the rich and fragile biodiversity of areas; which contribute greatly to local ecosystems, and even to liveability dimensions of fauna, flora as well as humans, regions and cities. To ensure optimal energy generation while preserving fragile ecosystems, a method for numerical Genetic Algorithm (GA) is proposed for wind farming optimization to determine both the sitting of wind turbines and the Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE). Optimal sites were identified in the small island of Mauritius and the model was applied on a complex terrain around an airport to identify optimal sites for the sitting of wind turbines while analysing the energy offset in terms of demand and supply of the area to encourage decentralised and more stable energy networks. Based on a set of parameters including local regulations and guidelines, 3 scenarios with a layout of 12, 24 and 36 wind farming sitting arrangements were proposed with a minimal impact on the fauna and flora; including the pathways of migratory birds. This paper is aimed at energy, urban planners and policy makers looking at sustainable energy planning.","author":["Dhunny, A.","Allam, Z.","Lobine, D.","Lollchund, M."],"organization":["University of Mauritius","Curtin University"],"originationDate":"2019-10-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["-20.272039000000","57.599346000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/865","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/exploring-technologically-temporally-geographically-sensitive-life-cycle-inventories","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118310838","title":"Exploring technologically, temporally and geographically-sensitive life cycle inventories for wind turbines: A parameterized model for Denmark","description":"In\u00a0life cycle assessments\u00a0of wind\u00a0turbines\u00a0and, more generally, of Renewable Energy Systems (RES), environmental impacts are usually normalized by electricity production to express their performance per\u00a0kilowatt-hour. For most RES, manufacture and installation dominate the impacts. Hence, results are sensitive to parameters governing both impacting phases and electricity production. Most available studies present the environmental performance of generic\u00a0wind turbines\u00a0with assumed fixed values for sensitive parameters (e.g. electricity production) that often vary between studies and fail to reflect specificities of\u00a0wind farmprojects. This study presents an approach to build a comprehensive\u00a0parameterized model\u00a0that generates unique wind turbine life cycle\u00a0inventories\u00a0conditioned by technologically, temporally and geographically-sensitive parameters. This approach allows for the\u00a0characterization\u00a0of the\u00a0carbon footprint\u00a0of five sets of turbines in Denmark, where wind power is highly developed. The analysis shows disparities even between turbines of similar power output, mostly explained by the service time, load factor and components weights but also by background processes (evolution of electricity mix and recycled steel content). Project-specific inventories with technologically, temporally and geographically-sensitive parameters are essential for supporting RES\u00a0development projects. Such inventories are especially important to evaluate highly-renewable electricity mixes, such as that of Denmark.","author":["Blanc, I.","Besseau, R.","Sacchi, R.","P\u00e9rez-L\u00f3pez, P."],"organization":["Aalborg University","MINES ParisTech"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.174114000000","9.148379000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/866","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/recycling-offshore-wind-farms-decommissioning-stage","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421519300618","title":"Recycling offshore wind farms at decommissioning stage","description":"Since Vindeby in 1991, more than 100 projects have been installed in Europe, and will need\u00a0decommissioning\u00a0one day. Despite the increasing number of projects reaching this phase, decommissioning is still an area that has received relatively little attention.\n\nThis paper considers the practicalities and economic implications of recycling offshore wind components as part of an end of life strategy. There is no existing source that gathers together materials data for currently operational wind\u00a0turbines\u00a0in Europe relevant to recycling. Since this\u00a0information\u00a0is necessary for any economic analysis of component recycling, such a\u00a0dataset\u00a0was generated.\n\nThe results illustrate the specific wind turbine materials suitable for recycling, expressed in percentage values of the wind turbine\u0027s total mass. An economic analysis is then performed to study how recovering these materials and selling them as\u00a0scrap metal\u00a0can impact the decommissioning costs. As concluding remarks, recycling offshore wind components could pay for nearly 20% of the total\u00a0wind farmdecommissioning costs if\u00a0monopile foundations\u00a0are considered. Furthermore, the\u00a0volatility\u00a0of scrap\u00a0prices\u00a0is such that this could even help define when it would be best to decommission an offshore wind farm.","author":["Topham, E.","McMillan, D.","Bradley, S.","Hart, E."],"organization":["DNV GL","University of Strathclyde","Offshore Renewable Energy (ORE) Catapult"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/867","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-onshore-wind-farm-located-northeastern-coast-brazil","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148112006714","title":"Life cycle assessment of an onshore wind farm located at the northeastern coast of Brazil","description":"This article assesses the life cycle emissions of a fictive onshore wind power station consisting of 141.5-MW wind turbines situated on the northeastern coast of Brazil. The objective is to identify the main sources of CO2(eq)-emissions during the life cycle of the wind farm. The novelty of this work lies in the focus on Brazil and its emerging national manufacturing industry. With an electricity matrix that is primarily based on renewable energy sources (87% in 2010), this country emits eight times less CO2\u00a0for the production of 1\u00a0kWh of electricity than the global average. Although this fact jeopardizes the CO2\u00a0mitigation potential of wind power projects, it also reduces the carbon footprint of parts and components manufactured in Brazil. The analysis showed that reduced CO2-emissions in the material production stage and the low emissions of the component production stage led to a favorable CO2-intensity of 7.1\u00a0g CO2\/kWh. The bulk of the emissions, a share of over 90%, were unambiguously caused by the production stage, and the transportation stage was responsible for another 6% of the CO2-emissions. The small contributions from the construction and operation phases could be neglected. Within the manufacturing process, the steel tower was identified as the source responsible for more than half of the emissions. The environmental impacts of the wind farm are small in terms of CO2-emissions, which can be credited to a green electricity mix. This scenario presents an advantage for the country and for further production sites, particularly in the surroundings of the preferred wind farm sites in Brazil, which should be favored to reduce CO2\u00a0emissions to an even greater extent.","author":["Oebels, K.","Pacca, S."],"organization":["University of S\u00e3o Paulo (USP)"],"originationDate":"2013-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-2.664888000000","-45.832300000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/868","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/long-term-assessment-raptor-displacement-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/fee.2089","title":"A long-term assessment of raptor displacement at a wind farm","description":"Wind energy development is advancing rapidly, but the potential ramifications of this growth on wildlife, particularly birds and bats, are not fully understood. Wind energy development may affect raptor (birds of prey) populations indirectly by displacing them from their previously occupied habitat; however, there are limited empirical data demonstrating this effect. We performed long\u2010term raptor surveys at a wind farm previously implicated in the displacement of resident raptors and found that the duration of displacement varied among raptor species. Abundances of turkey vultures (Cathartes aura), red\u2010tailed hawks (Buteo jamaicensis), and accipiters (sharp\u2010shinned hawks [Accipiter striatus] and Cooper\u0027s hawks [Accipiter cooperii] combined) all rebounded in years 7 and 8 of wind farm operation, while the apparent displacement of northern harriers (Circus hudsonius) and American kestrels (Falco sparverius) persisted across all post\u2010construction monitoring periods. Our long\u2010term assessment indicates not only that wind farm construction and operation may displace raptors but also that these impacts can diminish over time for certain species. This finding underscores the importance of assessing potential impacts over the operational life of a given wind farm and the need for long\u2010term monitoring to validate predicted impacts, particularly for raptor communities.","author":["Garvin, J.","Jennelle, C.","Drake, D.","Dohm, R."],"organization":["University of Wisconsin","Minnesota Department of Natural Resources","Tetra Tech Inc."],"originationDate":"2019-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.544166000000","-88.459444000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/869","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dual-wave-farms-energy-production-coastal-protection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117310402","title":"Dual wave farms for energy production and coastal protection","description":"The synergetic application of wave farms, i.e., arrays of wave energy converters (WECs), for protecting the coast in addition to their main objective of generating carbon-free energy can place this renewable resource as a major element in ocean and coastal management. In particular, their ability to mitigate coastal erosion by reducing the amount of wave power reaching the coast will be put to use \u2013 and this is the motivation for this work. We propose a new approach in which the wave farm has a dual purpose: to generate carbon-free energy and to contribute to coastal erosion management. We illustrate this approach by means of a case study: a dual-purpose wave farm off Xago, a beach-dune system in Asturias (N Spain) subject to severe erosion \u2013 manifested dramatically in the retreat of the dune \u2013 and located in the area earmarked for the first wave farm in Spain. The objective of this work is to establish whether or not the wave farm may be useful to counter the erosion of the beach-dune system. To this end a wave propagation model is coupled with a state-of-the-art coastal processes model and applied to analyse the response of the system under storm conditions in two scenarios: with and without the farm. The efficiency of the wave farm in mitigating erosion is determined by comparing the results in both scenarios by means of a series of coastal indicators defined ad hoc. We find that the farm reduces storm-induced erosion particularly where it is most acute, in the dune front, and thus contributes to alleviate the current erosive trends. This opens up exciting possibilities of using dual wave farms in lieu of, or as a complement to, coastal structures or beach nourishment. As wave energy develops into a major renewable energy source in the coming decades, dual wave farms are poised to constitute a breakthrough in coastal erosion management.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Abanades, J.","Flor-Blanco, G.","Flor, G."],"organization":["University of Plymouth","University of Oviedo"],"originationDate":"2018-06-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.604088000000","-5.920935000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/870","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/artificial-neural-network-model-coastal-erosion-mitigation-through-wave-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364815218309885","title":"An artificial neural network model of coastal erosion mitigation through wave farms","description":"In this work, a novel approach based on artificial intelligence (AI) to assess the efficiency of wave energy converter (WEC) farms in coastal protection is developed. We consider as a case study a beach subjected to severe erosion: Playa Granada (S Spain). More specifically, we analyse the changes in the dry beach area (quantified through the Pelnard-Consid\u00e8re equation) with and without wave farm protection by means of an Artificial Neural Network (ANN) model. The model is selected after a thorough comparative study involving forty ANN architectures, with one and two hidden layers, and two training algorithms (Levenberg-Marquadt and Bayesian regression). The best results are obtained with a [5-10-1] architecture trained with the Bayesian regression algorithm. Once validated, this ANN model is applied to optimize the design and position of the wave farm. The results confirm that ANN models are a useful design tool for hybrid wave farms.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["University of Plymouth","University of C\u00f3rdoba","University of Granada","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.723565000000","-3.524986000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/871","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/co-benefits-analysis-climate-change-environmental-effects-wind-power-case-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148113000438","title":"Co-benefits analysis on climate change and environmental effects of wind-power: A case study from Xinjiang, China","description":"The combustion of fossil fuel contributes to not only global warming but also the emissions of air pollutants. In China, the rapid growth of energy consumption leads to a large quantity of greenhouse gas (GHG) and air pollutant emissions. Although many measures have been proposed by the local governments to mitigate the GHG emissions and improve air quality, limited economic resources slow the efforts of the local government to implement measures to control both types of emissions. The co-benefits approach can use resources efficiently to solve multiple environmental problems. In this study, we first calculated the CO2\u00a0and air pollutants (SO2, NOx\u00a0and PM2.5) emissions in Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region. Then, the co-benefits of wind power, including mitigation of CO2\u00a0and air pollutants (SO2, NOx\u00a0and PM2.5) emissions and water savings, were assessed and quantified in the Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region. The results demonstrate that, during the 11th five-year period (2006\u20132010), emissions mitigation by wind power accounted for 4.88% (1065\u00a0\u00d7\u00a0104\u00a0t) of CO2, 4.31% (4.38\u00a0\u00d7\u00a0104\u00a0t) of SO2, 8.23% (3.41\u00a0\u00d7\u00a0104\u00a0t) of NOxand 4.23% (0.32\u00a0\u00d7\u00a0104\u00a0t) of PM2.5\u00a0emission by the thermal power sector. The total economic co-benefits of wind power accounted for 0.46% (1.38 billion 2009US$) of the GDP of Xinjiang during 2006\u20132010.","author":["Jacques, D.","Xue, B.","Ma, Z.","Geng, Y.","Ren, W.","Fujita, T.","Zhang, Z.","Puppim de Oliveira, J.","Xi, F."],"organization":["Chinese Academy of Sciences","National Institute for Environmental Studies (NIES)","United Nations University","University of Leeds"],"originationDate":"2013-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.982624000000","85.853230000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/872","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/refinements-efdc-model-predicting-hydro-environmental-impacts-barrage-across-severn","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096014811300414X","title":"Refinements to the EFDC model for predicting the hydro-environmental impacts of a barrage across the Severn Estuary","description":"This paper presents an investigation of the impacts of a Severn Barrage on the hydro-environment of the Bristol Channel and Severn Estuary using the Environmental Fluid Dynamics Code (EFDC) model with a recently developed Barrage module (EFDC_B). Details are given of a barrage module being implemented into the EFDC model to represent the various hydraulic structures, such as turbines and sluice gates, as deployed along the barrage line. Several cases, both with and without the barrage, have been simulated to investigate the potential changes on the peak water levels, minimum water depths and peak tidal currents arising from a barrage. The impacts of a barrage on the salinity concentration distribution have also been simulated in both 2D and 3D modes. The predicted results showed that the maximum water levels could be significantly reduced, especially downstream of the barrage and for much of the region in the Severn Estuary and that the minimum water depths would be changed so much that there would be 80.5 km2 loss of intertidal habitats due to the sitting of a barrage across the estuary. Likewise, the peak tidal currents would be considerably reduced, and by as much as a half in the middle of the main channel. The predicted salinity concentrations results indicated that at high water, the salinity concentrations would be reduced by 1\u20132 ppt downstream and upstream of the barrage and salinity concentrations in the region near Beachley would be reduced by up to 5 ppt, and that at low water, salinity concentrations would be reduced by 0.5\u20131 ppt in the middle of the Bristol Channel and by typically 0.5 ppt and 1 ppt downstream and upstream of the barrage, respectively. The predicted results also indicated that salinity concentrations downstream and upstream of the barrage would be under a stable state with slight oscillations all the time due to the effects of the barrage. A comparison between the salinity concentration distributions predicted by the 2D and 3D models indicated that the two models produced similar salinity distributions, especially in the Severn Estuary and in the region between the middle of the Bristol Channel and the seaward open boundary.","author":["Falconer, R.","Lin, B.","Zhou, J."],"organization":["Cardiff University","Tsinghua University"],"originationDate":"2014-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.427737000000","-3.029018000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Water Quality","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/873","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/rural-wind-farm-development-social-environmental-economic-features-important-local","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148113004370","title":"Rural wind farm development: Social, environmental and economic features important to local residents","description":"The research problem was to examine residents\u0027 perceptions of personal costs and benefits in terms of social, environmental or economic features that influence support of or resistance to wind farm development in four rural communities in eastern Michigan. Data were collected from residents using a mail questionnaire, which included twenty-one Likert-style questions inquiring about perceived impact statements of wind farm development in the community. The analysis indicated that there were both differences and similarities in the perception of wind farm impacts on the rural communities. More specifically, the results of the Akaike information criterion test indicated that there was substantial support for nine of the twenty-one variables in support of wind farm development. The contribution of this study recognizes the importance of noneconomic perspectives of wind farm development where turbine construction had not yet been fully exploited. In particular, the data lend support for the use of Social Exchange Theory and further exploration of its applicability in renewable energy investigations.","author":["Groth, T.","Vogt, C."],"organization":["Charles Sturt University","Michigan State University"],"originationDate":"2014-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.821582000000","-83.091620000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/874","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/addressing-conflicting-spatial-demands-msp-considerations-msp-planners","sourceURL":"https:\/\/publications.europa.eu\/en\/publication-detail\/-\/publication\/8971ab22-8285-11e9-9f05-01aa75ed71a1\/language-en\/format-PDF\/source-98582084","title":"Addressing conflicting spatial demands in MSP: Considerations for MSP planners","description":"This report presents the key findings of a study that was carried out in 2018 to explore the range of spatial conflicts experienced in MSP in Europe. The aim was to provide an overview of common types of spatial conflicts and solutions that have been found in various EU Member States, with particular focus on spatial conflict prevention and mitigation. This report looks at the different conflict potential of sectors, conflicting issues and stakeholder contexts, as well as different types of solutions and conditions for applying them.  The study drew on conflicts described in the literature (e.g. past MSP projects) and input from planners and experts describing real-life examples of spatial conflicts. Its focus was on single cross-sectoral conflicts, bearing in mind that the term \u201cconflict\u201d may be contentious and that the respective sectors are not always in spatial conflict with each other. Various conflict cases between offshore wind farming, commercial fisheries, areabased maritime conservation, aquaculture, maritime tourism, maritime transport, defence, and cables and pipelines were identified for detailed consideration, either as likely to play a greater role in the future or to be faced by most countries at some stage of MSP. Detailed results are presented in nine conflict fiches available on www-mspplatform.eu.","author":["Gee, K.","Lukic, I.","Schultz-Zehden, A.","Ooms, E.","Ansong, J.","Passerello, C."],"organization":["European Commission","European Commission"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EU-2018-MSP.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/875","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-cost-analysis-floating-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148113006642","title":"Life-cycle cost analysis of floating offshore wind farms","description":"The purpose of this article is to put forward a methodology in order to evaluate the Cost Breakdown Structure (CBS) of a Floating Offshore Wind Farm (FOWF). In this paper CBS is evaluated linked to Life-Cycle Cost System (LCS) and taking into account each of the phases of the FOWF life cycle. In this sense, six phases will be defined: definition, design, manufacturing, installation, exploitation and dismantling. Each and every one of these costs can be subdivided into different sub-costs in order to obtain the key variables that run the life-cycle cost. In addition, three different floating platforms will be considered: semisubmersible, Tensioned Leg Platform (TLP) and spar. Several types of results will be analysed according to each type of floating platform considered: the percentage of the costs, the value of the cost of each phase of the life-cycle and the value of the total cost in each point of the coast. The results obtained allow us to become conscious of what the most important costs are and minimize them, which is one of the most important contributions nowadays. It will be useful to improve the competitiveness of floating wind farms in the future.","author":["Castro-Santos, L.","Diaz-Casas, V."],"organization":["Universidade da Coruna"],"originationDate":"2014-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/876","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-emf-emissions-undersea-electric-cables-coral-reef-fish","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/bem.22092","title":"Effects of EMF emissions from undersea electric cables on coral reef fish","description":"The objective of this study was to determine if electromagnetic field (EMF) emissions from undersea power cables impacted local marine life, with an emphasis on coral reef fish. The work was done at the South Florida Ocean Measurement Facility of Naval Surface Warfare Center in Broward County, Florida, which has a range of active undersea detection and data transmission cables. EMF emissions from a selected cable were created during non\u2010destructive visual fish surveys on SCUBA. During surveys, the transmission of either alternating current (AC), direct current (DC), or none (OFF) was randomly initiated by the facility at a specified time. Visual surveys were conducted using standardized transect and point\u2010count methods to acquire reef fish abundances and species richness prior to and immediately after a change in transmission frequency. The divers were also tasked to note the reaction of the reef fish to the immediate change in EMF during a power transition. In general, analysis of the data did not find statistical differences among power states and any variables. However, this may be a Type II error as there are strong indications of a potential difference of a higher abundance of reef fish at the sites when the power was off, and further study is warranted.","author":["Spieler, R.","Dhanak, M.","Kilfoyle, A.","Jermain, R.","Huston, J."],"organization":["Nova Southeastern University","Florida Atlantic University"],"originationDate":"2017-11-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["25.922194800000","-80.161748000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/877","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/socioeconomic-demographic-factors-influence-publics-awareness-different-forms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148114003346","title":"Socioeconomic and demographic factors that influence publics\u0027 awareness on the different forms of renewable energy sources","description":"Public awareness of renewable energy sources can offer multiple benefits, as it can contribute to the social acceptance of projects based on these energy sources and to the overall improvement of consumers\u0027 energy behaviour. The objective of the present study is to examine the demographic and socioeconomic factors that determine someone\u0027s knowledge on different forms of renewable energy, based on data from a survey that took place in the summer of 2012 in Greece. The most known renewable energy forms are solar and wind energy, followed by geothermal, hydropower and biomass. The lesser known forms are tidal, wave and ocean thermal energy. Factors having a statistically significant relation with the different forms of renewable energy are gender, age, education level, head of household education level, environmentally friendly behaviour and having an occupation, studies or interests related to environment, technology or engineering.","author":["Karytsas, S.","Theodoropoulou, H."],"organization":["Harokopio University"],"originationDate":"2014-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.110786000000","21.816388000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/878","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/installation-operational-effects-hvdc-submarine-cable-continental-shelf-setting-bass","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2468013316300316","title":"Installation and operational effects of a HVDC submarine cable in a continental shelf setting: Bass Strait, Australia","description":"Despite the many submarine telecommunications and power cables laid world-wide there are fewer than ten published studies of their environmental effects in the refereed literature. This paper describes an investigation into the effects of laying and operating the Basslink High Voltage Direct Current (HVDC) cable and its associated metallic return cable across Bass Strait in South East Australia. Over more than 95% of its length the cable was directly laid into a wet jetted trench given the predominantly soft sediments encountered. Underwater remote video investigations found that within two years all visible evidence of the cable and trench was gone at over a third of the transects at six deep water sites (32\u201372 m deep). At other deep water transects the residual trench trapped drift material providing habitat for the generally sparsely distributed benthic community. Diver surveys at both of the near shore sites (\u0026lt;15 m deep) on the northern side of the Strait also found the cable route was undetectable after a year. On the southern side, where the cable traversed hard basalt rock near shore, it was encased in a protective cast iron half shell. Ecological studies by divers over 3.5 years demonstrated the colonization of the hard shell by similar species occupying hard substrates elsewhere on the basalt reef. Magnetic field strengths associated with the operating cable were found to be within 0.8% of those predicted from theory with strength dropping rapidly with distance from the cable. Beyond 20 m the field was indistinguishable from background.","author":["Williams, A.","Sherwood, J.","Chidgey, S.","Crockett, P.","Gwyther, D.","Ho, P.","Stewart, S.","Strong, D.","Whitely, B."],"organization":["Deakin University","Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-38.388255000000","142.248441200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","EMF","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/879","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-submarine-power-transmission-cables-glass-sponge-reef-associated-megafaunal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113615000513","title":"Effects of submarine power transmission cables on a glass sponge reef and associated megafaunal community","description":"We examined the effects of submarine power transmission cable installation and operation on glass sponge reef condition and associated megafauna. Video and still imagery were collected using a Remotely Operated Vehicle twice a year for 4 years following cable installation. The effects of cables on glass sponges were assessed by comparing sponge cover along fixed transects and at marked index sites. Megafauna counts along transects were used to explore the effects on associated community. We found no evidence of cable movement across the sponge reef surface. Live sponge cover was found to be consistently lower along cable transects and at cable index sites compared to controls. Live sponge cover was the lowest (55 \u00b1 1.1% decrease) at cable index sites 1.5 years after installation and recovered to 85 \u00b1 30.6% of the original size over the following 2 years. Our data suggest 100% glass sponge mortality along the direct cable footprint and 15% mortality in the surrounding 1.5 m corridor 3.5 years after cable installation. Growth rate of a new glass sponge was 1 and 3 cm\/year in first and second year, respectively, and appeared to be seasonal. We observed a diverse megafaunal community with representatives from 7 phyla and 14 classes. Total megafauna, spot prawn, and other Arthropoda abundances were slightly lower along cable transects although the effect of cable presence was not statistically significant. The following measures could be taken to reduce the amount of damage to glass sponge reefs and associated fauna: routing the cable around reefs, whenever possible, minimizing cable movement across the surface of the reef at installation and routine operation, and assessing potential damage to glass sponges prior to decommissioning.","author":["Dunham, A.","Pegg, J.","Carolsfeld, W.","Davies, S.","Murfitt, I.","Boutillier, J."],"organization":["Fisheries and Oceans Canada"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.912306000000","-123.335053000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/880","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/auv-based-characterization-emf-emissions-submerged-power-cables","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/7271719\/authors#authors","title":"AUV-based characterization of EMF emissions from submerged power cables","description":"AUV-based field measurement and characterization of the electromagnetic field in coastal waters associated with live submerged cables is described. The effort is in support of a program to characterize the EMF emissions associated with submerged power transmission cables from offshore energy harvesting devices to shore and identifying their environmental impact on marine animals. The electric field is measured using a custom 3-axes sensor mounted on a Bluefin 21 AUV and the magnetic field is measured using a Marine Magnetics SeaSPY magnetometer towed from the vehicle so that it is isolated from the AUV machinery. The AUV is equipped with onboard upward (600kHz) and downward (300kHz) looking ADCPs, and a CTD package which simultaneously provide the contextual in-situ oceanographic information, including temperature, salinity, and current velocity in the water column. The electric-field sensor development, its implementation on the AUV, and illustrative at-sea surveys, involving deployment of the EM sensors in shallow waters over a submerged cable with the power in the cable turned off\/on, are described.","author":["Dhanak, M.","Ravenna, S.","Coulson, R.","Frankenfield, J.","Valdes, G.","Pugsley, D.","An, E.","Venezia, W."],"organization":["Florida Atlantic University"],"originationDate":"2015-09-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["25.956293800000","-80.034851000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/881","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-noise-mitigated-offshore-pile-driving-harbour-porpoise-abundance-german-bight","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Georg-Nehls\/publication\/334429664_Effects_of_noise_mitigated_offshore_pile_driving_on_harbour_porpoise_abundance_in_the_German_Bight_2014-2016_Gescha2\/links\/5d28a35692851cf4407e6873\/Effects-of-noise-mitigated-offshore-pile-driving-on-harbour-porpoise-abundance-in-the-German-Bight-2014-2016-Gescha2.pdf","title":"Effects of noise-mitigated offshore pile driving on harbour porpoise abundance in the German Bight 2014-2016 (Gescha 2)","description":"This study (Gescha 2) analyses the impact of the construction of eleven offshore wind farms (OWFs) and offshore converter platforms (OSS) built in the German North Sea and adjacent Dutch waters in the period 2014-2016 on harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena). The study is a direct follow-up to the Gescha 1 project, which investigated the effects of pile driving of the first eight wind farms in the German Bight (2009-2013). For the present study, also a combined dataset from 2010 to 2016 could be considered, containing most Gescha 1 and all Gescha 2 data. The dataset combines porpoise monitoring data from passive acoustic monitoring using Porpoise Detectors (CPODs) and digital aerial survey data with measured data on noise levels in 750 m and 1500 m distance from the piling location as well as other piling characteristics. These data were analysed in order to describe the response of harbour porpoises to pile driving activities, most of which took place under operation of noise-mitigation systems with the aim to reduce disturbance effects on porpoises.  Prior to investigating piling effects on harbour porpoises, baseline analyses were conducted to identify the seasonal distribution of porpoises in different geographic subareas. Daily CPOD data and digital aerial survey data uncovered seasonal patterns with often higher densities in spring and summer, especially in the north-eastern part of the German Bight. Lowest porpoise abundance was found in the central part of the German Bight with deep waters, whereas higher densities were found in the more coastal subareas. Seasonal patterns differed from subarea to subarea. In the northern German Bight porpoises showed a pronounced summer peak, whereas in the eastern subarea animals also showed considerable activity in autumn. In overall, this resulted in highest porpoise densities and detections in summer within and next to the SAC Sylt Outer Reef. Another high-density area was identified near the SAC Borkum Reef Ground in the south-western German Bight and adjacent Dutch waters. Here, highest densities were found in late winter. These results are in line with previous findings and point towards a very stable occurrence of porpoises within the German Bight. Both CPOD and aerial survey datasets showed matching regional porpoise phenology trends, indicating a high degree of correlation between these completely independent datasets.  Noise measurements at 750 m and 1500 m distance from piling locations for all German wind farms constructed between 2014 and 2016 were combined with CPOD porpoise monitoring data. Analyses of noise levels revealed a high variability within each wind farm. However, both the variability of the sound values and the average noise level were significantly reduced with the noisemitigated pile drivings of Gescha 2, and noise levels were mostly below the BSH\u0027s mandatory noise limit of 160 dB SEL05 at a distance of 750 m from a piling location. Pile driving carried out during the study period of Gescha 2 had on average 9 dB lower noise levels than those of Gescha 1, and had on average more than 15 dB lower noise levels than those measured during unmitigated piling, which can be attributed to a significant improvement in noise-mitigation systems in recent years. Still, some variability in the noise measurements remained, which may result from certain environmental factors affecting sound propagation, such as water depth, substrate, and wind speed. The present study shows that noise-mitigation systems used between 2014 and 2016 had improved considerably when compared to 2010-2013 and worked consistently well in the German Bight.  Establishing of the relationship of noise level to porpoise response is crucial for environmental impact assessment based on the noise prognosis for specific projects.  Since noise-mitigation technology became more efficient over the last years and noise levels were reduced significantly, the expectation was that the displacement range and duration for porpoises due to piling noise should have been reduced accordingly.  However, this was not the case. The effect range regarding porpoise detection rates based on all hourly CPOD data during mitigated pile driving from all projects within Gescha 2 was at 17 km (std. error range: 15-19 km), and the effect duration in close range lasted from 28 hours (lower s.e.: not available; upper s.e.: 22 hours) before until 48 hours (lower s.e.: 35 hours; upper s.e.: not available) after stop of pile driving. These values were similar to those obtained at Gescha 1, and thus no reduced displacement effect could be shown when comparing Gescha 2 to Gescha 1. Analyses of 12 digital aerial surveys, conducted during or up to 12 hours after stop of pile driving, showed an effect range of 11.4-19.5 km to piling sites and thus confirmed the effect range found by CPOD data.  We discuss this outcome with five explanatory approaches which might be relevant alone or in combination.  1. Stereotypical escape distance within a certain noise-level range: Results of the hourly CPOD data indicate that there is no correlation between noise level and displacement range below noise levels of 165 dB SEL05 at 750 m from piling locations. Below this value the effect range seemed not to be further reduced. This might be explained by animals maintaining a certain minimum escape distance independent of the respective noise level if it is below this value and within a certain intermediate range. Thus, animals may react stereotypically as soon as pile-driving noise exceeds a certain individually differing unknown threshold level that must be regarded in the context of a seasonally and sitespecific different condition of animals. However, regarding piling-noise levels we only had access to the broadband SEL05 cut off at 20 kHz, and could not refer to noise levels being weighted according to the hearing spectrum of harbour porpoises; hence, we might not have dealt with the noise most relevant for porpoises.  2. Increasing relative importance of the displacement effect of seal scarers with better noise reduction: Based on theoretical considerations and on measured values at a distance of 750 m from piling sites, it can be assumed that seal scarer noise up to a distance of approximately 20 km is clearly better audible for harbour porpoises than pile-driving noise mitigated by well-functioning noise-mitigation systems. This cannot explain the farreaching effect by its own because seal scarers were also used in projects where the response range was rather short. Thus, seal scarer effects cannot be the only explanation, but might have contributed to the fact that no improvement of effect range and duration from Gescha 1 to Gescha 2 was found.  3. Other construction-related noise, commencing already prior to the start of deterrence and driving a large part of the animals away from those noise sources: A reduction of detection rates before deterrence and pile driving was shown for all wind farms investigated during both Gescha studies. Thus, there has to be a reason why animals leave the area up 5 to 24 hours before the start of the seal scarer. However, displacement during pile driving is clearly stronger than the effect before piling, at least in the close range of a few kilometres. Since the animals\u0027 only sense of perceiving a disturbance over many kilometres is their hearing system, it is assumed that anthropogenic sounds associated with pile driving are the trigger for the reaction.  4. Cumulative effects due to tight piling sequence: Piling schedules became much tighter with latest OWFs. By this fact it cannot be completely excluded that the time between consecutive pilings was partly so short that animals did not have enough time to come back before the next piling started. Even though we tried to include several variables into our models to capture this possible phenomenon these were often thrown out during the model-selection process. By applying to the hourly CPOD dataset a model approach with a reduced dataset where at least a break of 72 hours occurred between two consecutive pilings, we tried to minimise the possible influence of tight piling sequences. Still, the displacement range was similar to the range for OWFs built in the period 2010-2013 when piling sequences were much less tight. However, the cumulative effect might not have been captured adequately by only three days of break between pilings.  5. Habitat characteristics at different OWF areas: Above all, there also exists a high variability of porpoise occurrence due to different small-scale habitat structures, which might have consequences on a seasonal and inter-annual time scale in the North Sea. A good example in this context is the patchy presence of sandeel and sand goby in and around the DanTysk and Sandbank project areas, which may have contributed to different displacement radii within these two areas. Hence, since the response of harbour porpoises to disturbance also depends on habitat use and habitat characteristics, the unexpectedly high effect range for Gescha 2 might partly be attributable to habitat differences between and among the Gescha 1 and 2 OFW projects.  When looking at long-term trends of daily harbour porpoise detection rates obtained by CPODs, spatial differences occurred among the investigated subareas. In the eastern and, less pronounced, the southern part of the German North Sea and adjacent Dutch waters, we found an increasing trend from 2010 to 2016, whereas porpoise detections remained relatively constant in the northern part, and decreased in the central part of the study area. The latter subarea, however, was less important for harbour porpoises, as it generally showed low porpoise detection rates. Regarding the entire study area, porpoise detection rates increased from 2010 to 2016. Hence, cumulative OWF construction activities in the German Bight apparently did not have any measurable negative effect on population level.  In conclusion, the future development of noise-reduction measures, with the aim of reducing the radius of disturbance of harbour porpoises, must be critically reviewed, as no improvement regarding piling effects on harbour porpoises was found. Nevertheless, despite of large disturbance radii no negative effect on population level was observed.","author":["Piper, W.","Diederichs, A.","Nehls, G.","Brandt, M.","Ketzer, C.","Schubert, A.","Kosarev, V.","Wahl, V.","Michalik, A.","Laczny, M.","Rose, A.","Vilela, R.","Volkenandt, M.","Wendeln, H.","Freund, A.","Limmer, B."],"organization":["IBL Umweltplanung GmbH","BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.450998000000","3.623010000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rose-et-al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/882","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-pile-driving-playback-sound-level-fish-catching-efficiency-harbor-porpoises","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aquaticmammalsjournal.org\/index.php?option=com_content\u0026view=article\u0026id=1939:effect-of-pile-driving-playback-sound-level-on-fish-catching-efficiency-in-harbor-porpoises-phocoena-phocoena\u0026catid=176\u0026Itemid=326","title":"Effect of Pile-Driving Playback Sound Level on Fish-Catching Efficiency in Harbor Porpoises (Phocoena phocoena)","description":"The foundations of offshore wind turbine parks are often constructed by means of percussion pile driving. Broadband impulsive sounds generated by pile driving may disturb and distract marine mammals such as harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena); their concentration may be reduced, affecting the skills they need for foraging (e.g., timing and precision) or reducing their ability to catch prey and, thus, their foraging efficiency. The resulting reduction in fitness may eventually lead to population declines. Therefore, it is important to understand the effects of these anthropogenic sounds on the ability of harbor porpoises to catch fish. Two captive harbor porpoises (porpoise F05 and porpoise M06) performed a fish-catching task (i.e., retrieving dead fish from a net feeding cage) while they were exposed to low ambient noise (quiet conditions) and impulsive pile-driving playback sounds at three (porpoise M06) or four (porpoise F05) mean received single-strike sound exposure levels (SELss) between 125 and 143 dB re 1 \u00b5Pa2s. The two study animals differed in their fish-catching success rate at all noise levels, including under quiet conditions: Porpoise F05 was less likely to catch fish than porpoise M06. They also responded differently to increasing SELss: Only porpoise F05 was significantly more likely to terminate trials and less likely to catch fish as SELss increased above 134 dB, but her trial failure rate remained unaffected by increasing SELss. The time taken to catch a fish did not vary with SELss but was slightly longer for porpoise F05 than for porpoise M06. Results suggest that high-amplitude pile driving sounds are likely to negatively affect foraging in some harbor porpoises by decreasing their catch success rate and increasing the termination rate of their fish-catching attempts; the severity of the effects is likely to increase with increasing pile driving SELss. However, individual differences in responses to sound, termination rates, and fish-catching success (even in ambient conditions) may complicate the quantification of the impacts of pile driving sounds on harbor porpoises.","author":["de Jong, C.","Kastelein, R.","Jennings, N.","Helder-Hoek, L.","Huijser, L.","Cornelisse, S."],"organization":["SEAMARCO","TNO (Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research) Wind Energy"],"originationDate":"2019-07-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.062240000000","5.463748000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/883","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-perceptions-responses-new-energy-technologies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41560-019-0399-x","title":"Public perceptions of and responses to new energy technologies","description":"Energy\u2019s central place in economic, political and social systems\u2014and the broad impacts that energy choices have on the natural world and public health\u2014mean that new technologies often spur public reactions. Understanding these public responses and their drivers is important, as public support can influence new technology adoption and deployment. Here I review the literature on public perceptions of and responses to a wide range of new energy technologies. Unlike previous reviews that tend to focus on particular technologies or types of technologies, this Review covers both large-scale energy infrastructure projects, such as utility-scale wind and solar, fossil fuel extraction and marine renewables, as well as small-scale, \u2018consumer-facing\u2019 technologies such as electric vehicles, rooftop solar and smart meters. This approach reveals broad trends that may facilitate communication between policymakers, technologists and the public, and support the transition to a more sustainable energy system.","author":["Boudet, H."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2019-05-27","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/884","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimating-potential-costs-cumulative-barrier-effects-migrating-raptors-case-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_4#citeas","title":"Estimating Potential Costs of Cumulative Barrier Effects on Migrating Raptors: A Case Study Using Global Positioning System Tracking in Japan","description":"Wind farms along the migration route of birds act as unnatural barriers, and avoiding them during flight may require the expenditure of extra energy. Information regarding cumulative effects of barriers on migrating birds is generally lacking, mainly because of the complexities of monitoring the number of encounters of migratory birds with wind farms and their flight path for avoiding these barriers. It would be desirable to develop a general method for monitoring the rate at which migratory birds encounter wind farms. In this study, we attempted to assess the potential cumulative barrier effects on 17 eastern buzzards (Buteo japonicus) and eight Oriental honey-buzzards (Pernis ptilorhynchus) using global positioning system (GPS) tracking data. We obtained the location data of wind turbines in Japan and migration paths of the birds using GPS loggers and assumed four scenarios that birds could use to avoid the wind turbines along their routes. Although the number of studied individuals was limited and the impact of the cumulative effects are inconclusive at the present stage, the estimated additional distance, time, and energetic cost during one migration were no more than 31.97 km, 75.74 min and 132 kJ, respectively, which were relatively small. Additionally, we showed the possibility that GPS tracking could provide information on migration episodes of birds associated with wind farms and could be a promising method for addressing the cumulative barrier effects. We expect that a higher sampling frequency of locations would enable precise measurement of avoidance flights and energetic costs.\n\nFor book information go here.","author":["Kikuchi, D.","Nakahara, T.","Kitamura, W.","Yamaguchi, N."],"organization":["Tokyo City University","Nagasaki University"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.862804000000","138.173459000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:14:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/885","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/texturizing-wind-turbine-towers-reduce-bat-mortality","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1502997","title":"Texturizing Wind Turbine Towers to Reduce Bat Mortality","description":"There is still a great need for the development of mitigation strategies that are economically viable and can be used alone or in combination with other options (e.g., operational minimization, acoustic deterrents) to ensure that bat fatalities are effectively reduced at wind facilities across the U.S. Our goal was to develop a wind turbine tower coating that 1) bats show little or no interest in approaching, 2) can be applied to currently deployed wind turbine towers and to towers as they are constructed, 3) is economically feasible to produce and apply, and 4) ultimately contributes to a reduction in bat mortality at utility-scale wind facilities. Wind turbine tower monopoles are large, smooth surfaces and numerous studies have reported bats making close investigative approaches at turbine tower surfaces that are suggestive of drinking and foraging behavior. We therefore hypothesized that such activity could be contributing to bat-wind turbine fatalities by increasing the amount of time that bats spend in or around the rotor-swept zone. We further hypothesized that a texturizing the tower might minimized bat activity at the towers and therefore reduce fatality risk. To explore this, we designed a series of experiments to characterize how bats interact with smooth and texture-treated surfaces in a controlled environment. We conducted 64 behavioral trials in a flight facility from 10 June to 25 September 2015 and an additional 76 behavioral trials from 9 June to 30 August 2016. The first set of trials showed that while bats did make contact with smooth surfaces, they did not make contact with textured surfaces. We ascertained that bat activity occurred at 0 to 1 m distances from surfaces, suggesting that the bats (used in this study) may need to be this close to a surface to accurately discern its texture. From the results were developed a texture coating. For the second set of trials, we tested the texture coating. Bats showed a \u0026gt;40% reduction in activity within 1 m of the textured surfaces in comparison to the smooth surfaces. Following these controlled experiments, we conducted field tests at Wolf Ridge Wind, LLC. We applied the texture coating to the midsection of turbine monopoles. The texture coating was manually applied to 2 turbine towers, although we noted during the application there was variation in texture coating between turbines. We considered that this variation could potentially impact bat behavior. We then conducted bat activity surveys at both texture-treated towers and 2 nearby control towers, over 55 nights from 24 June to 22 September, 2017. All species of bats known to be present at the site were detected in the acoustic recordings at these turbine towers. We found no significant differences in overall numbers of bats observed and levels of acoustic activity at the smooth and texture-treated towers. When we analyzed the experimental pairs separately, however, we found that a greater proportion of the close range bat activity within Pair 1 occurred at the texture-treated tower and that much of this activity could be attributed to foraging behavior. In contrast at turbine Pair 2, we observed no difference in the proportion of close range bat activity between the smooth and texture-treated tower, with no clear differences in behavior at the two tower types. When we examined acoustic bat activity at the tower pairs separately, we found species-specific differences in activity that differed between the smooth and texture-treated towers within the pairs. For example, hoary bat acoustic activity was significantly higher at the texture-treated tower in Pair 1, but significantly lower at the texture-treated tower in Pair 2. Given the observational nature of the field test, our limited sample size (2 turbine pairs), variation in the texture-coating between the 2 turbine pairs, and different patterns of bat activity observed at the 2 turbine pairs, inferences from this one field test are limited at best. In conclusion, the results from the flight facility experiments were promising (i.e., we observed a significant decrease in bat activity at smooth compared to texture-treated surfaces); however, due to coating installation and application challenges prior to our field test, we were unable to collect sufficient information to understand how these coatings affect bat activity at operational wind turbine towers. Although the results from the field test are inconclusive, the lessons learned will be informative for future research into turbine surface materials that can modify the surface of the turbine tower and therefore alter how bats perceive wind towers. Thus, the outcomes of this research project may have a significant impact on wind energy operators, wind developers, and OEMs by contributing to future impact mitigation strategies. In future research we will test new ideas to improve the development, application, and evaluation of this mitigation technique.","author":["Bennett, V.","Hendrix, T."],"organization":["Texas Christian University","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2018-07-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.599825200000","-108.171097200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bennett-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/886","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/winter-summer-differences-probability-fish-encounter-spatial-overlap-mhk-devices","sourceURL":"https:\/\/marineenergyjournal.org\/imej\/article\/view\/19","title":"Winter and summer differences in probability of fish encounter (spatial overlap) with MHK devices","description":"The likelihood of fish encountering an MHK device, and therefore the risk posed to fish, depends largely on the natural distribution of fish at tidal energy development sites. In temperate locations, such as the Bay of Fundy, seasonal changes in the environment and fish assemblage may alter the likelihood of fish encounters with MHK devices. We examined two one-month hydroacoustic datasets collected in winter 2015 and summer 2016 by an upward-facing echosounder deployed at the Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy test site in the Minas Passage. Fish density was higher and less variable in winter than in summer, likely due to the presence of migratory vs. overwintering fish. The vertical distribution of fish varied with sample period, diel stage, and tidal stage. The proportion of fish at MHK device depth was greater, but more variable, in summer than in winter. Encounter probability, or potential for spatial overlap of fish with an MHK device, was \u0026lt; 0.002 for winter and summer vertical distributions. More information on the distribution of fish (horizontal and vertical), species present, fish sensory and locomotory abilities, and nearfield behaviours in response to MHK devices is needed to improve our understanding of likely device effects on fish.","author":["Viehman, H.","Redden, A.","Boucher, T."],"organization":["Acadia Centre for Estuarine Research (ACER)","Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.812914000000","-66.282429000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Viehman-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/887","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-assessment-intake-alternatives-seawater-reverse-osmosis-arabian-gulf","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479719305080","title":"Environmental assessment of intake alternatives for seawater reverse osmosis in the Arabian Gulf","description":"The study carried out an environmental assessment for two seawater reverse osmosis (RO) plants located within the Arabian Gulf considering subsurface intake alternatives and differing energy source options. The study used life cycle assessment to quantify the environmental impacts for open intake pretreatment vs. subsurface intake pretreatments of two plants with operating capacities of approximately 175,000 m3\/d and 275,000 m3\/d respectively. For both RO plants, electricity and chemical inputs were considered. Significant energy reductions of 30% were observed with subsurface intakes for extraction and pretreatment, resulting in a plant-wide energy saving of 6%. Open intake pretreatment had higher environmental impacts compared to subsurface intake across all impact categories, although in some impact categories significant differences existed between the two similar plants due to differences in chemicals used. The study further established that the renewable PV power generation resulted in the lowest global warming potential (GWP); however, a significant trade-off occurs with this energy source since it had the highest impact relative to both ozone and abiotic depletion potentials and was also worse than natural gas for both marine and human toxicity potentials. The GWP reductions achievable using a subsurface intake for the larger of the two plants is equivalent to 58,000 tons of CO2 per year, or more than 12,000 cars, making subsurface intakes a worthy alternative to conventional open intake systems in the Arabian Gulf region. Marine aquatic eco-toxicity potential was identified as the most significant normalized environmental impact, which should be best managed through using natural gas as an energy source.","author":["Al-Kaabi, A.","Mackey, R."],"organization":["Khalifa University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["27.105637500000","47.951347800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/888","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/adaptive-marine-spatial-planning-netherlands-sector-north-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X18304597","title":"Adaptive marine spatial planning in the Netherlands sector of the North Sea","description":"The territorial waters and the EEZ of the Netherlands form a part of the southern North Sea. The area is intensely used and for several of these uses considerable growth is forecast. For years, industrial freedom and market forces prevailed during discussions on marine spatial planning in the Netherlands. But in 2005 it became clear that this might lead to increasing conflicts with the environment and between users. The introduction of a new spatial planning framework was in response to an increasing interest in new developments and a growing demand for governmental coordination of these developments. During the years after, societal demands changed rapidly, especially with regard to renewable energy and demand for sand to strengthen the coast. At a regular interval of 6 years, revised Marine Spatial Plans have been developed which are adapted to the new knowledge and experience acquired and the new societal demands. Each cycle has a strong stakeholder involvement, both informal and formal.","author":["de Vrees, L."],"organization":["Ministry of Infrastructure and the Environment (Rijkswaterstaat)"],"originationDate":"2021-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.042739200000","4.427103400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Vrees.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/889","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-effects-electrical-energy-transmission-case-study-polish-marine-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.degruyter.com\/view\/j\/ohs.2019.48.issue-2\/ohs-2019-0018\/ohs-2019-0018.xml","title":"Potential effects of electrical energy transmission - the case study from the Polish Marine Areas (southern Baltic Sea)","description":"The operation of offshore wind turbines and electricity transmission through submarine cables over long distances generate electromagnetic or static magnetic fields (depending on the technical solution) that may modify the natural geomagnetic field and cause induced electric and electromagnetic fields in the water. The present study synthesizes the current knowledge and speculates on the possible environmental impact of electrical energy transfer based on the example of the Polish Marine Areas (southern Baltic Sea). We review the possible effects of the electrical energy induction and transfer against the existing and planned wind turbine installations. Furthermore, we consider different cable design variants as a way of environmental impact mitigation. Possible impacts of induced magnetic fields on marine organisms and, consequently, on the ecosystem functioning are also addressed.","author":["Andrulewicz, E.","Otremba, Z.","Jakubowska, M.","Urban-Malinga, B."],"organization":["Gdynia Maritime University"],"originationDate":"2019-06-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.055379000000","18.504628700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/890","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-gas-production-infrastructure-reutilisation-blue-energy-production","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032119301923","title":"Offshore gas production infrastructure reutilisation for blue energy production","description":"Blue energy is one of the development sectors identified in the European Union strategic documents within the blue economy that promotes the exploitation of the sea potential. European energy initiatives recognize the importance of blue energy and encourage its research and development. The offshore exploitation of hydrocarbons worldwide is entering the final phase, followed by the gradual decommissioning of the production platforms and their removal. Decommissioning usually has an adverse effect on the environment aside from its economic intensity. By proper planning, lifetime of existing offshore infrastructure can be extended as it can be used for blue energy or other activities related to the blue economy. The paper deals with preliminary assessment of natural gas offshore infrastructure applicability for various blue energy options such as the wind power for electricity generation along with hydrogen, methane or ammonia production and other uses to reduce waste, energy consumption and CO2 emissions. Methods used included data gathering from 19 offshore gas facilities including assessment of natural gas production on current offshore fields, reserves and technology use, wind potential and decommissioning. Review of potential for energy production, storage and other activities such as CCS and CCU have also been given. Preliminary results show that there are possibilities for feasible and environmentally friendly blue energy utilisation. Average calculated capacity factors for the wind turbines are at the 32%. To investigate economic feasibility of decommission delay, detailed data gathering of wind potential should be done at specific heights along with load capacity of the gas platforms.","author":["Sedlar, D.","Vulin, D.","Kraja\u010di\u0107, G.","Juki\u0107, L."],"organization":["University of Zagreb","University of Zagreb"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.962738400000","17.015243000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/891","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reconversion-offshore-oil-gas-platforms-renewable-energy-sites-production-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118315209","title":"Reconversion of offshore oil and gas platforms into renewable energy sites production: Assessment of different scenarios","description":"The contemporary energy transition will be characterized by many sub-transitions in the next three decades. Oil and gas will continue to play a very important role coupled with renewable energy sources in an energy mix scenario. In this context, the authors of the present work developed a project, named RELife (Renewable Energy for a new Life of offshore platforms), with the main goal of develop a model for the reuse of offshore Oil \u0026 Gas platforms at end-of-life stage for the production of renewable energy. In this paper, by considering two types of platforms (4-legged platform with 3 or 4 production wells), various technical scenarios are studied and investigated and for each scenario also the environmental and economic feasibility is evaluated. In addition, all the sub-models are compared with a standard decommissioning process. The evaluations are made for both the Adriatic Sea and the North Sea, two geographic areas with different availabilities of renewable resources. In order to assess also the economic and environmental feasibility, a Discount Cash Flow Analysis and a Life Cycle Assessment of all the scenarios have been conducted.","author":["Leporini, M.","Marchetti, B.","Corvaro, F.","Polonara, F."],"organization":["Polytechnic University of Milan","Universit\u00e0 degli Studi e-Campus","Universita Politecnica Delle Marche","Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche \u2013 Istituto di Ricerca sulle Acque (CNR-IRSA)"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.866085900000","17.144497200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-02 08:14:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/892","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/best-management-practices-north-atlantic-right-whales-during-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrdc.org\/sites\/default\/files\/best-management-practices-north-atlantic-right-whales-during-offshore-wind-energy-construction-operations-along-us-east-coast-20190301.pdf","title":"Best Management Practices for North Atlantic Right Whales During Offshore Wind Energy Construction and Operations Along the U.S. East Coast","description":"North Atlantic right whales are at a critical moment. At their current rate of decline, and in the absence of immediate conservation measures, we will lose this majestic animal within only a few decades. Their most serious threats are fishing gear entanglement, including chronic entanglement where they may drag fishing gear for months or even years, and vessel collisions, one of the leading causes of mortality for all large whales. The probability of a whale suffering a serious injury or mortality from a vessel collision significantly increases when vessels of any length travel at speeds greater than ten knots. North Atlantic right whales are also subjected to numerous stressors during their annual migration along the eastern seaboards of Canada and the United States, including significant levels of noise pollution generated by human activities. Underwater noise can mask important communication calls and reduce foraging success as well as the ability to find mates. Science tells us that such additional stressors force whales to expend extra energy, which negatively affects their health and ability to reproduce successfully. For the North Atlantic right whale to survive and recover, threats must be avoided, minimized, and mitigated to the fullest extent possible.","author":["Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)"],"organization":["Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Vessel Strike"],"modifiedDate":"2025-02-15 01:29:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NRDC_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/893","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/harnessing-wind-how-advance-wind-power-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrdc.org\/sites\/default\/files\/harnessing-wind-advance-wind-power-offshore-ib.pdf","title":"Harnessing the Wind: How to Advance Wind Power Offshore","description":"Harnessing the Wind outlines how we can tap into the enormous wind power potential off the United States coastline in a smart way, protective of ocean life. Developed in consultation with other environmental organizations, the guide identifies key challenges and proposes actions to avoid, minimize, and mitigate wildlife impacts.","author":["Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)"],"organization":["Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Collision","Noise","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-26 11:33:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/harnessing-wind-advance-wind-power-offshore-ib.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/894","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sound-islay-demonstration-tidal-array-inter-tidal-survey-potential-cable-routes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.scottishpowerrenewables.com\/pages\/sound_of_islay.aspx","title":"Sound of Islay Demonstration Tidal Array: Inter-tidal Survey of Potential Cable Routes","description":"Scottish Power Renewables (SPR) has commissioned Haskoning UK Ltd to assist in applications for consent to install a demonstration tidal turbine array within the Sound of Islay, Scotland. The proposed area of interest lies within the central channel of the Sound of Islay. The demonstration tidal array of ten devices would be deployed within this area and is anticipated to have a footprint of approximately 0.4 km 2 . The turbines would generate up to 10MW of power and will be linked via underwater cabling to onshore infrastructure on Islay. SPR are currently investigating six potential landing sites on Islay for cable routing onshore to a substation that is currently proposed to be located in Keills. To inform the Environmental Impact Assessment an intertidal survey was undertaken across an area shown in Figure 1.1. The intertidal survey was completed in conjunction with the Phase 1 habitat survey of potential cable routes.","author":["Trendall, J."],"organization":["Royal Haskoning","ScottishPower Renewables"],"originationDate":"2009-08-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.850000000000","-6.100000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 10:18:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Trendall2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/896","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/numerical-simulations-effects-tidal-turbine-array-near-bed-velocity-local-bed-shear","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/9\/10\/852","title":"Numerical Simulations of the Effects of a Tidal Turbine Array on Near-Bed Velocity and Local Bed Shear Stress","description":"We apply a three-dimensional hydrodynamic model to consider the potential effects of energy extraction by an array of tidal turbines on the ambient near-bed velocity field and local bed shear stress in a coastal channel with strong tidal currents. Local bed shear stress plays a key role in local sediment dynamics. The model solves the Reynold-averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations on an unstructured mesh using mixed finite element and finite volume techniques. Tidal turbines are represented through an additional form drag in the momentum balance equation, with the thrust imparted and power generated by the turbines being velocity dependent with appropriate cut-in and cut-out velocities. Arrays of 1, 4 and 57 tidal turbines, each of 1.5 MW capacity, were simulated. Effects due to a single turbine and an array of four turbines were negligible. The main effect of the array of 57 turbines was to cause a shift in position of the jet through the tidal channel, as the flow was diverted around the tidal array. The net effect of this shift was to increase near-bed velocities and bed shear stress along the northern perimeter of the array by up to 0.8 m\u00b7s\u22121 and 5 Pa respectively. Within the array and directly downstream, near-bed velocities and bed shear stress were reduced by similar amounts. Changes of this magnitude have the potential to modify the known sand and shell banks in the region. Continued monitoring of the sediment distributions in the region will provide a valuable dataset on the impacts of tidal energy extraction on local sediment dynamics. Finally, the mean power generated per turbine is shown to decrease as the turbine array increased in size","author":["Walters, R.","Gillibrand, P.","McIlvenny, J."],"organization":["North Highland College"],"originationDate":"2016-10-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.716010300000","-3.123754800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gillibrand-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/897","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sustainable-deployment-marine-current-energy-indonesia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/7271449","title":"Sustainable deployment of Marine Current Energy in Indonesia","description":"Marine Current Energy Generation (MCEG) is a new technology that can produce emission-free electricity by using the velocity of sea currents. This paper explores possible environmental, social and environmental impacts of MCEG in Indonesia, a developing country that is currently facing a shortage of electricity. Multi-criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) is used to conduct an integrated assessment using different indicators of sustainability and to capture the view of the various local stakeholders, as stakeholder engagement is crucial for sustainability. Results show that all the stakeholder groups prefer MCEG to fulfill their electricity needs rather than the current method of diesel electricity generation. However, the people would prefer the electricity from MCEG to be cheaper than the current tariff paid by them. The environmental impacts also need to be scrutinized further, while the society needs to be sensitized for the successful introduction of MCEG to Indonesia.","author":["Takagi, K.","Ramachandran, R."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2015-05-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["-3.959091300000","119.190607000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Ocean Current"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/898","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysing-potentials-effects-multi-use-between-tidal-energy-development-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X18300368","title":"Analysing the potentials and effects of multi-use between tidal energy development and environmental protection and monitoring: A case study of the inner sound of the Pentland Firth","description":"As the population of cities continues to proliferate, society places a greater strain on the productivity of geographical features and their resources. In recent years, this trend has increased for the planet\u0027s seas. In order to further maximize the utility of marine space, the concept of co-location between economic sectors operating in the sea, and coexistence of such sectors with the ecosystem, has provided traction for the concept of multi-use (MU). In response, the European Union Horizon 2020 programme funded the Multi-Use in European Seas (MUSES) project which aims to provide innovative technical and policy solutions to facilitate MU in the five European sea basins. Within the broader analytical framework of MUSES, 10 case studies were developed to determine the potentials and effects of MU for various sectors. This paper examines MU between tidal energy development and environmental protection, as well as tidal energy development and environmental monitoring. A desk analysis provided for known drivers, added values, barriers, and impacts of MU. Results from the desk analysis were validated by key stakeholders, resulting in policy and technical recommendations informing the MUSES Action Plan. The analysis demonstrates that technological advancements to monitoring equipment are required to further studies of environmental interactions with tidal energy arrays, and determine the viability of co-locating developments in environmentally sensitive areas. However, greater capacity deployments of tidal energy are required so that robust monitoring data sets can accumulate over time, geographical scope, and ecological make-up. Such capacity development is currently hindered by ineffective government fiscal measures.","author":["Sangiuliano, S."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-08-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.716010300000","-3.123754800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/899","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning-irish-perspective-towards-best-practice-integrated-maritime","sourceURL":"https:\/\/aran.library.nuigalway.ie\/xmlui\/handle\/10379\/2235","title":"Marine Spatial Planning from an Irish perspective: Towards Best Practice in Integrated Maritime Governance","description":"Ireland with its extensive seas, belatedly being recognised as a significant development resource. There is evidence that a diverse range of stakeholders at national and local levels in Ireland are positively disposed toward MSP but no practical manifestation of the concept is in place, though some preparatory work is underway to facilitate its likely implementation into the future. Little in-depth research has been undertaken to explore how MSP could be best implemented in Ireland. The European Commission (EC) is a major promoter of MSP and has developed a set of common principles for MSP in the European Union. A critical examination of these principles in practice is undertaken through an evaluation of three marine spatial planning initiatives: The Channel Islands National Marine Sanctuary; The Clyde Pilot MSP Project; and The Eastern Scotian Shelf Integrated Management Initiative. The objective of these evaluations is to derive useful lessons regarding the implementation of these principles in general. A critical examination of the Irish context is also presented and a roadmap for MSP in Ireland is developed. It is evident that the EC\u0027s guiding principles provide a useful framework for the implementation of MSP. Some principles, however, need further clarification, elaboration and strengthening. Successful implementation of MSP in Ireland requires the development of national marine policy which creates an overall vision for Ireland\u0027s marine environment and economy and which emphasizes the place-based nature and integrated management dimensions of MSP. It also requires the development of new ecosystem governance practices and mechanisms through which stakeholders can engage in a dialogue about the management of the marine environment.","author":["Flannery, W."],"organization":["NUI Galway"],"originationDate":"2011-07-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.279589000000","-8.816055900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2011FlanneryPhD.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/900","type":["Document","Document\/Guidance"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/guidance-communities-development-wave-tidal-projects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/localenergy.scot\/resource\/guidance-for-communities-on-the-development-of-wave-and-tidal-projects\/","title":"Guidance for Communities on the Development of Wave and Tidal Projects","description":"Islay Energy Trust (IET), Natural Power Consultants (Natural Power) have produced a guide to assist coastal communities in the development of wave and tidal projects around Scotland. It has been fundied from Scottish Government Community and Renewable Energy Scheme (CARES).  The Scottish Government is committed to the development of community renewable projects. They have clearly stated that they wish to maximise the benefits from renewable energy for communities, both in direct energy and financial benefits as well as local regeneration and skills development. There are a range of potential benefits for communities involved with the development of wave and tidal developments.  These include revenue streams, economic development and development of local businesses, infrastructure, skills and job creation, community cohesion and development precedent. However, a central difference between community marine energy projects and conventional commercial developments is the opportunity to secure socio-economic as well as financial benefits in the eventual operation of any project.  While using this guide, it is important to understand that the wave and tidal industry is an embryonic industry with high costs and higher risks in comparison with more conventional types of renewable energy. While this report is applicable to wave and tidal developments the content as with regards to community development is biased towards tidal projects.  The guide provides advice and recommendations on the process of developing a project from concept, through a feasibility study, and successfully gaining the leases, licences and consents required. It offers detailed guidance on the topics to consider at feasibility stage and signposts to publically available information. An overview of the consenting and licensing process is given, as well as advice on resource assessment, device selection criteria, finance and funding. A section dedicated to ports, vessels, supply chain and socioeconomics has been supplied by SeaRoc Ltd.  It is hoped that this guide equips and informs coastal communities who are considering the development of, or investment in, a wave or tidal project. While not covering in detail every aspect of a community development, the guide aims to provide an overview of topics to consider, investigate and discuss, and a reference section is provided to direct towards other publically available information sources.","author":["De Silva, R.","Edwards, C.","Halliday, R.","Knight, A.","Bentley, P."],"organization":["Natural Power"],"originationDate":"2013-09-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.906971700000","-4.960066200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Edwards_et_al_2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/901","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-co-existence-options-marine-renewable-energy-projects-japan","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2071-1050\/11\/10\/2840\/htm","title":"Evaluation of Co-Existence Options of Marine Renewable Energy Projects in Japan","description":"Consensus building among local stakeholders is vital for the success of the proposed initial commercial marine renewable energy (MRE) projects in Japan. Even though the literature on stakeholder acceptance highlights the importance of creating local benefits and co-creation options, very few studies and almost no empirical data have been published on the application of non-monetary benefit creation schemes in the context of MRE. Hence, the purpose of this study was to systematically evaluate the possible co-existence options available for Japan\u2019s MRE projects through data collected from interviews and questionnaire surveys in two development sites in Nagasaki and Kitakyushu in Southern Japan. To overcome the limitations of data unavailability and uncertainty, the Dempster Shafer Analytic Hierarchy Process (DS-AHP) was used for evaluating the best co-existence strategy out of five potential options. The results indicate that local fisheries prefer the oceanographic information sharing option whereas most of the other stakeholders prefer using local resources to construct and operate the power plant, creating business involvement opportunities for the local community. Analysis of stakeholders\u2019 decision behaviors suggests that perceived impacts, knowledge, and values influence the preference decision. In addition to the validation of stakeholder preference of the previously proposed co-existence options with empirical data, this study provides a robust method to further evaluate the potential options with the availability of new data.","author":["Kularathna, A.","Suda, S.","Takagi, K.","Tabeta, S."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2019-05-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.348200500000","138.106151200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/902","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/working-group-marine-benthal-renewable-developments-wgmbred","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ices-library.figshare.com\/articles\/report\/Working_Group_on_Marine_Benthal_and_Renewable_Energy_Developments_WGMBRED_\/18621806","title":"Working Group on Marine Benthal Renewable Developments (WGMBRED)","description":"This report provides an overview of the state of affairs (1) with regards to the deployment of wet renewables and (2) marine energy storage systems; (3) how they affect abiotic and biotic components of the marine ecosystem and (4) developments and concepts on cumulative impact assessments related to marine renewable energy devices and (5) future perspectives. This report provides the scientific basis to address the OSPAR request for advice on the current state and knowledge of studies into the deployment and environmental impacts of the following wet renewable energies and marine energy storage (floating, coastal infrastructure), tidal stream (screws, kites), tidal flow (barrage, lagoon) and others. Advice should cover the status of wet renewable developments in the OSPAR region, future prospects, potential environmental prob-lems (sea bed habitat loss\/disturbance, fish, marine mammals, birds, seascape\/ public perception, and cumulative impacts), potential benefits, next steps and conclusions\u201d. The request was directed towards the Working Group on Marine Benthal Energy Developments (WGMBRED) and the Working Group on Marine Renewable Energy (WGMRE). A pre-meeting chaired by Jan Vanaverbeke, Belgium (WKWET, 15\u201316 January 2019) at ICES Headquarters, was attended by 11 participants from 4 countries, including members of WGMBRED and WGMRE and additional experts. The group analysed the OSPAR request, agreed on a structure for the report, and certain experts volunteered to conduct a literature re-view and provide the necessary knowledge base for the report.WGMBRED met from 12\u201315 February 2019 in Brussels, Belgium. The input from WKWET participants was compiled, quality checked and adapted where needed; when relevant expertise was represented in the group. WKWET experts, not present at WGMBRED, reviewed text, where needed, and a first version of this report was delivered to WGMRE.WGMRE met in Oostende (Belgium) from 26\u201328 February 2019. Participants reviewed the WKWET report following input from WGMBRED, quality checked, and adapted where neces-sary. Relevant experts contributed additional text and data to tables on MRE developments in ICES areas, and provided text on public perceptions and future prospects of MRE. This report presents an overview of the currently known \u201cwet renewables\u201d (all marine renewable energy devices, excluding offshore wind devices) and how their deployment will likely change in the future. It further provides an overview of the concepts and techniques of related to marine energy storage devices. Given the conceptual and experimental stage of marine energy storage devices, and the absence of data on how these devices affect the marine environment, the report is limited to a description of these marine energy storage devices. This report provides a receptor-based summary of how the wet renewables can affect the marine environment. Receptors are either abiotic (hydrodynamics, physical seabed and sediment transport) or biotic (benthos, fish, marine mammals, birds, sea turtles, otters and polar bears). To avoid repetition, effects on these receptors were grouped according to pressure-inducing components (static component of the device, dynamic component of the device, cables) of wet renewables or consequences of their presence. The report further discusses the developments on cumulative impacts assessments associated with wet renewables deployment in addition to many other human activities, and the need to move away from \u201cdata rich \u2013 information poor\u201d monitoring of structural aspects of the marine ecosystem to hypothesis-driven functional research at the relevant spatial and temporal scales. This will require cross-border coordination in data collection, data storage and exchange and the development of a joint research agenda.","author":["Vanaverbeke, J.","Gill, A.","Wood, D.","Bald, J.","Sparling, C.","Rumes, B.","Brabant, R.","Hutchison, Z.","Coolen, J.","Murray, R.","Evans, T.","Warnas, M.","Hunt, W.","Culloch, R.","Wright, K.","Harrald, M.","Tait, A.","Buyse, J.","Salvany, L."],"organization":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-11-16 06:28:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WGMBRED_2019_Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/903","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-offshore-wave-farms-coastal-process-impact-assessment-waves-beach-morphology","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/11\/10\/2517","title":"Modelling Offshore Wave farms for Coastal Process Impact Assessment: Waves, Beach Morphology, and Water Users","description":"The emerging global wave energy industry has the potential to contribute to the world\u2019s energy needs, but careful consideration of potential impacts to coastal processes in the form of an impact assessment is required for each new wave energy site. Methods for conducting a coastal processes impact assessment for wave energy arrays vary considerably in the scientific literature, particularly with respect to characterising the energy absorption of a wave energy converter (WEC) array in a wave model. In this paper, modelling methods used in the scientific literature to study wave farm impacts on coastal processes are reviewed, with the aim of determining modelling guidance for impact assessments. Effects on wave climate, beach morphology, and the surfing resource for coastal water users are considered. A novel parameterisation for the WEC array transmission coefficient is presented that, for the first time, uses the permitted power rating of the wave farm, which is usually well defined at the impact assessment stage, to estimate the maximum likely absorption of a permitted WEC array. A coastal processes impact assessment case study from a wave farm in south-west Ireland is used to illustrate the application of the reviewed methods, and demonstrates that using the new \u2018rated power transmission coefficient\u2019 rather than a WEC-derived transmission coefficient or complete energy absorption scenario can make the difference between significant and non-significant levels of coastal impacts being predicted.","author":["Conley, D.","Stokes, C."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.752465000000","-9.628841000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Stokesetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/904","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-tidal-lagoon-hydrodynamics-swansea-bay-wales-uk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.worldscientific.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1142\/9789811204487_0185","title":"Effects of a Tidal Lagoon on the Hydrodynamics of Swansea Bay, Wales, UK","description":"A world\u2019s first tidal energy lagoon has been proposed in Swansea Bay area (Severn Estuary, west coast of UK). The Severn Estuary is a highly dynamic environment and understanding the bay hydrodynamics is important to the sustainable use of the coastal area in this region. Changes to hydrodynamic processes due to the construction and operation of the lagoon will lead to some potential changes in the sediment pathways and depositional processes within the bay. Possible impacts on natural sites, located southeast of the lagoon, are a concern. A hydrodynamic model (DELFT3D) of Swansea bay has been set up to investigate the sediment pathways within this area. The focus of this paper is the potential link between tidal flows and the configuration of Swansea Bay with the construction of the tidal lagoon and as it is at present. The results will be useful for assessing tidal lagoon impact as well as many aspects of local shoreline management.","author":["Masters, I.","Yin, Y.","Reeve, D.","Fairley, I.","Karunarathna, H.","Horrillo-Caraballo, J."],"organization":["Swansea University","Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2019-05-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.595077000000","-3.886663000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/905","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/current-policy-technology-tidal-current-energy-korea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/12\/9\/1807","title":"Current Policy and Technology for Tidal Current Energy in Korea","description":"As global energy consumption continues to increase, the negative impact of global warming also grows. Therefore, eco-friendly energy policy is being established all over the world. Korea\u2019s energy consumption problems are further complicated by the country\u2019s high dependence on energy sourced overseas. Korean energy policy is evolving rapidly to address these problems. Korea has begun to phase out nuclear power and is focusing on developing new sources of renewable energy. So there has been substantial interest in the development of ocean energy. Of all ocean energy technologies, tidal current energy is the closest to the commercialization. Especially, the southwestern coast of Korea is the most promising candidate site for the development of tidal current energy owing to the abundant tidal current energy resource. Meanwhile, ocean energy policy is an important factor in determining the development of ocean energy. Thus, this paper presents the overview of the current status of policy and technology for the tidal current energy system in Korea. These policies explained in this paper can provide significant interest and motivation for the use of tidal current energy resources.","author":["Lee, K.","Park, J.","Chung, J.","Ko, D.","Yi, J."],"organization":["Korean Institute of Ocean Science and Technology (KIOST)"],"originationDate":"2019-05-12","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ko-2019-Korea.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/906","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/current-state-marine-renewable-energy-policy-china","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X18304718","title":"The current state of marine renewable energy policy in China","description":"The\u00a0advancement\u00a0of the Marine\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0(MRE) industry will contribute to actualizing\u00a0sustainable development\u00a0in China. However, the Chinese MRE industry is still in its nascent stage. Therefore, effective policies are needed to improve the development of this emerging sector and facilitate its maturation. Focusing on MRE policies, this article provides constructive suggestions for the establishment and reform of Chinese MRE policy. It summarizes current MRE policies in both China and in nations with a relatively mature MRE industry, identifying the challenges in China\u0027s current MRE policy in the process. While several market incentive strategies have been found to be incomplete and have faced significant limitations during implementation, several non-market incentive strategies are entirely absent. Examining these deficiencies and their causes, this paper suggests corresponding improvement strategies: notably the need to reform the Marine Renewable Energy Funds, refine feed-in\u00a0tariffs\u00a0and subsidy policy, introduce a tradable renewable\u00a0certificate, enact special laws for this field, and strengthen its publicity campaign.","author":["Zhang, P.","Yang, X.","Ma, C.","Zhang, X.","Liu, N.","Guo, Z.","Hu, P."],"organization":["Qingdao University of Science and Technology","State Oceanic Administration (SOA)","National Ocean Technology Center (NOTC)"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/907","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-converter-arrays-optimizing-power-production-while-minimizing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.onepetro.org\/conference-paper\/OTC-29658-MS","title":"Wave Energy Converter Arrays: Optimizing Power Production While Minimizing Environmental Effects","description":"The nascent marine renewable energy (MRE) industry requires robust tools to maximize power output while evaluating the potential environmental effects of marine hydrokinetic (MHK) devices. Wave energy converter (WEC) devices in particular, are in early stages of development and may deploy a wide range of technologies to harness wave energy. The technical activities and processes used to assess WEC arrays for both power production and environmental effects requires streamlining to lower the levelized cost of wave energy projects and facilitate timely, cost-effective environmental review and compliance. A robust approach using numerical models to simulate the WEC devices and array layouts is presented that simultaneously evaluates power production and assesses environmental effects. \u0022WEC-friendly\u0022 open-source numerical tools have been developed that are capable of assessing the environmental force on and potential changes to the environment caused by the energy extraction by WEC arrays. A case study is presented to demonstrate how the changes in WEC array configurations can be mapped and quantified using a validated model. A discussion of how changes in WEC devices and array configurations are developed to provide critical information on both engineering and environmental risk. This allows for optimization of WEC deployments to maximize power capture while minimizing environmental impacts.","author":["Chang, G.","Roberts, J.","Jones, C.","McWilliams, S.","Raghukumar, K."],"organization":["Integral Consulting Inc","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"2019-05-09","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/908","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-tropical-regions-deployment-challenges-environmental-social-perspectives","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2077-1312\/7\/7\/219","title":"Wave Energy in Tropical Regions: Deployment Challenges, Environmental and Social Perspectives","description":"The harnessing of renewable sources of marine energy has become a promising solution for a number of problems, namely satisfying the increasing demand for electricity, the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions, and the provision of energy to regions unconnected to a national grid. Tropical countries have an interesting dichotomy: Despite their varied potential sources of marine energy, their environmental and social conditions impose severe constraints on the development of a renewable energy industry. Moreover, the exploitation of these opportunities is limited by national economies\u2019 reliance on fossil fuels, political and social restraints, and technological immaturity. The present work addresses challenges and opportunities common to wave energy implementation in tropical nations, as a first approach to a regional diagnosis. The motivation for this work is to encourage research on wave energy policies in the Tropics. Technical, environmental, and social challenges to be overcome in wave energy projects are discussed. The technical challenges are grouped into development, deployment, and operation stages of wave energy converters; environmental challenges are divided into biodiversity, cumulative effects, and monitoring aspects, whilst social issues include population growth and energy access matters. The Mexican strategy for developing sustainable technology throughout the wave energy production chain is also presented.","author":["Silva, R.","Mendoza, E.","Lithgow, D.","Felix, A.","Hern\u00e1ndez-Fontes, J.","Posada, G.","Ring, M."],"organization":["National Council for Science and Technology, Mexico","National Autonomous University of Mexico","Campeche Autonomous University (Universidad Aut\u00f3noma de Campeche)"],"originationDate":"2019-07-14","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Fish","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Felix-2019-Tropical.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/909","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/abundance-composition-succession-sessile-subtidal-assemblages-high-wave-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0022098118303605","title":"Abundance, composition and succession of sessile subtidal assemblages in high wave-energy environments of Central Chile: Temporal and depth variation","description":"Limited knowledge exists about the\u00a0sessile species\u00a0found in wave exposed\u00a0subtidal environments\u00a0of southeastern Pacific shores, including the temporal patterns of\u00a0colonization, growth, succession, and the potential problems they pose to human industries, including oceanic\u00a0aquaculture\u00a0and renewable wave energy. Filling this information gap is urgent considering the increased interest to exploit these environments. We conducted a 23mo long\u00a0experimental study\u00a0on the coast of central Chile to characterize\u00a0biofouling\u00a0colonization, rates of accumulation and succession patterns at two different depths and different substrates. Throughout the study, we recorded 62 species, 36 of which were sessile.\u00a0Biomass\u00a0accumulation rates\u00a0were among the highest recorded, with significantly higher and more seasonal rates above than below the\u00a0thermocline. Slightly but significantly higher biomass was observed in\u00a0ceramic\u00a0tiles than acrylic or safety-walk surfaces, but such differences varied with depth and month of the year. In all materials, surface cover reached nearly 100% within about a month of exposure at 5\u202fm deep in spring and summer months, and over 70% at 15\u202fm deep, with lower cover in winter months. The patterns of total biofouling biomass measured in air (weight) were quite different to those measured submerged in\u00a0seawater, highlighting the importance of species attributes (body density) when assessing risks of biofouling for different human-made structures. The hydrozoan\u00a0Obelia geniculata\u00a0was by far the fastest colonizing\u00a0macro-invertebrate\u00a0species throughout the year and both depths, covering the entire plate surface in spring-summer months. Community composition shifted in favor of large-bodied, heavier species when surfaces were exposed for more than 6mo. Succession in shallow waters followed a deterministic path from hydrozoans, to the large-bodied barnacle\u00a0Austromegabalnus psittacus\u00a0to dominance by the tunicate\u00a0Pyura chilensis. Final successional stages appear to be the same in deeper waters, but dominance was not achieved before the end of the experiment. Ecological perspectives and simple recommendations to developers and the productive sector are discussed.","author":["Navarrete, S.","Parragu\u00e9, M.","Osiadacz, N.","Rojas, F.","Bonicelli, J.","Fern\u00e1ndez, M.","Arboleda-Baena, C.","Perez-Matus, A.","Finke, R."],"organization":["Pontifical Catholic University of Chile","Marine Energy Research \u0026 Innovation Center (MERIC)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-33.537573000000","-71.611299000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-27 03:55:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/910","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/optimising-multiple-multibeam-sonars-assess-marine-life-interactions-underwater-kite","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/319417252_Optimising_multiple_multibeam_sonars_to_assess_marine_life_interactions_with_an_underwater_kite","title":"Optimising multiple multibeam sonars to assess marine life interactions with an underwater kite","description":"Multibeam sonar has emerged as a powerful tool for environmental monitoring of marine renewable energy (MRE) devices. Moving away from manned operations, self-contained multibeam sonar systems may be costly at purchase, but are costeffective for long-duration, autonomous deployments. However, there is no single multibeam sonar configuration that suits all environments and MRE devices currently being tested, and licence requirements may vary between regulatory bodies. A novel, quarter-scale tidal turbine, Deep Green (the \u2018kite\u2019), is being tested in a tidal channel in Strangford Lough, Northern Ireland, UK. The kite consists of a wing with a turbine, \u2018flies\u2019 in a figure-eight shape trajectory underwater and is tethered to the seabed. Strangford Lough is a Special Area of Conservation (SAC) for harbour seals and a multibeam sonar configuration is required that allows the detection and tracking of seals and other marine life with high spatial and temporal resolution. Developed through a collaboration between the research team, local regulatory authority, kite developer and the sonar manufacturers, we describe the transition from a marine mammal detection system through to a configuration that eventually aims to understand the four-dimensional animal movement and interactions as well as underlying hydrodynamic features around the kite.","author":["Kregting, L.","Lieber, L.","Zambrano, C.","Nilsen, T."],"organization":["Queen\u0027s University Belfast","Kongsberg Maritime Ltd","Minesto"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.483017000000","-5.583243000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Ocean Current"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/911","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-cold-shock-egg-larval-juvenile-stages-tropical-fishes-potential-impacts-ocean","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/0141113688900025","title":"Effects of cold shock on egg, larval, and juvenile stages of tropical fishes: Potential impacts of ocean thermal energy conversion","description":"Ocean thermal energy conversion (OTEC) facilities will bring large volumes of deep, cold water to the surface, where it will be mixed with warm surface water after the utilization of the thermal differential. Mixing of these two water types will result in exposure of larval and juvenile fishes entrained in the warm water intake to lowered temperatures. A time course of cold shock from simulated entrainment was used to determine potential effects upon egg and larval mahimahi, Coryphaena hippurus, manini, Acanthurus triostegus, and juvenile striped mullet, Mugil cephalus. Experiments were designed to test varying exposure times and temperature changes upon different early life stages of tropical fishes.  Earlier stage eggs were more sensitive to temperature shock, with mortality increasing with increasing delta T as compared to controls; exposure time, however, did not exert a significant effect. Significant excess mortality for all stages of eggs occurred at the range of times and temperatures used in the experiments, although in some cases these exceed values proposed in current OTEC engineering plans. For mahimahi larvae, excess mortality increased with age to values higher than for latest stage eggs, but we consider this to be caused by stress associated with yolk exhaustion. A single size range of juvenile mullet was exposed to the same experimental protocol as the eggs and larvae. Although exposure time was not significant, delta T had a significant effect upon mortality, and there was a significant interaction between exposure time and delta T.","author":["Boehlert, G.","Lamadrid-Rose, Y."],"organization":["National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)"],"originationDate":"1988-03-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":["OTEC"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/912","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proportion-flatfish-recruitment-north-sea-potentially-affected-offshore-windfarms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article-abstract\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsz050\/5445401","title":"The proportion of flatfish recruitment in the North Sea potentially affected by offshore windfarms","description":"Understanding the influence of man-made infrastructures on fish population dynamics is an important issue for fisheries management. This is particularly the case because of the steady proliferation of offshore wind farms (OWFs). Several flatfish species are likely to be affected because areas with OWFs in place or planned for show a spatial overlap with their spawning grounds. This study focuses on six commercially important flatfish species in the North Sea: common sole (Solea solea), European plaice (Pleuronectes platessa), turbot (Scophthalmus maximus), brill (Scophtalmus rhombus), European flounder (Platichthys flesus), and common dab (Limanda limanda). We used a particle-tracking model (LARVAE\u0026amp;CO) coupled to a 3D hydrodynamic model to assess the effects of spatial overlap of OWFs with the species\u2019 spawning grounds on the larval fluxes to known nursery grounds. An important overlap between planned areas of OWFs and flatfish spawning grounds was detected, with a resulting proportion of settlers originating from those areas varying from 2% to 16%. Our study suggests that European plaice, common dab, and brill could be the most affected flatfish species, yet with some important local disparities across the North Sea. Consequently, the study represents a first step to quantify the potential impact of OWFs on flatfish settlement, and hence on their population dynamics.","author":["Degraer, S.","Vigin, L.","Barbut, L.","Vastenhoud, B.","Volckaert, F.","Lacroix, G."],"organization":["Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","DTU Aqua (National Institute of Aquatic Resources)"],"originationDate":"2020-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.764534000000","5.629623000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/913","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/future-policy-implications-tidal-energy-array-interactions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X19302994","title":"Future policy implications of tidal energy array interactions","description":"Tidal stream energy technology has progressed to a point where commercial exploitation of this sustainable resource is practical, but tidal physics dictates interactions between tidal farms that raise political, legal and managerial challenges that are yet to be met. Fully optimising the design of a turbine array requires its developer to know about other farms that will be built nearby in the future. Consequently future developments, even those in adjacent channels, have the potential to impact on project efficiency.  Here we review the relevant physics, consider the implications for marine policy, and discuss potential solutions. Possible management paths range from minimal regulation to prioritise a free market, to strongly interventionist approaches that prioritise efficient resource use. An attractive exemplar of the latter is unitization, an approach to resource allocation widely used in the oil and gas industry. We argue that an interventionist approach is necessary if the greatest possible energy yield is to be produced for a given level of environmental impact.","author":["Kerr, S.","Woolf, D.","Murray, R.","Waldman, S.","Weir, S."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2019-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/914","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/path-planning-approach-based-multi-direction-algorithm-ships-navigating-within-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0029801818318365","title":"A path planning approach based on multi-direction A* algorithm for ships navigating within wind farm waters","description":"Trajectory planning for working ships within offshore wind farms is significant for navigation safety and efficiency. Regarding to this, a global multi-direction A* algorithm is introduced. The algorithm is modified from three perspectives: (1) Artificial potential field (APF) is expressed in scalar mode instead of vector mode; (2) The moving distance in each step is adjusted based on the complexity of the around environment; (3) The penalty mode is proposed for the subsea pipelines. The scalar APF model avoids ships crossing between the two obstacles very close to each other, which is very important in dense wind turbine waters. The adjusted stepping mode can extend possible moving directions compared with conventional A* algorithm while making a trade-off between computation complexity and efficiency. The penalty model plays an effective role, so that the planned trajectory is crossing the pipelines only once. Simulation results indicate that the trajectory from 20-direction A* algorithm has similar path length with real cases while enhancing navigation safety to a large degree. Compared with the real-case trajectory, the minimum distance to the wind turbines has increased more than 3 times and the path length outside the wind farm decreased from more than 16000m to less than 11000m.","author":["Tian, W.","Zhang, J.","Xie, L.","Xue, S.","Zhang, M.","Haugen, S."],"organization":["Wuhan University","Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)"],"originationDate":"2019-06-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.756278800000","121.965162000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Navigation"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/915","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dual-wave-farms-coastline-dynamics-role-inter-device-spacing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969718325932","title":"Dual wave farms and coastline dynamics: The role of inter-device spacing","description":"In dual wave farms, i.e., arrays of wave\u00a0energy converters\u00a0(WECs) with a dual function \u2013 generation of renewable power and\u00a0mitigation\u00a0of coastal erosion \u2013 the spacing between the WECs is a fundamental design parameter. The present research has the objective of establishing how this parameter affects the\u00a0shoreline evolutionbehind the array and, on this basis, to propose and apply a method to determine the optimum spacing for coastal protection. The method is demonstrated on a beach subjected to severe erosion. Five case studies are considered: four with different inter-WEC spacings, and one without the wave farm (baseline). A spectral\u00a0wave propagation\u00a0model is applied to analyse the variations in\u00a0significant wave height\u00a0behind the WEC array. Longshore\u00a0sediment transport\u00a0rates are calculated, and a\u00a0shoreline\u00a0model is applied. We find that in all the case studies the dry beach area is greater than in the baseline (no farm) case study, which proves the capacity of the dual WEC array to mitigate the erosive trends of the system. Importantly, we obtain that the inter-WEC spacing plays a fundamental role in the evolution of the shoreline and, consequently, in the effectiveness of the WEC array for coastal protection. The case studies with intermediate spacings yield the best performance in terms of dry beach area. More generally, the benefits of dual wave farms in terms of protection of coastal properties and infrastructure, and the ensuing savings in conventional coastal defence measures (coastal structures,\u00a0beach nourishment, etc.) contribute to the development of wave energy by enhancing its\u00a0economic viability. The methodology presented in this paper can be used to optimize the design of dual wave farms elsewhere.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["University of Plymouth","University of Granada"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.705274000000","-3.557113000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/917","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/framework-evaluate-environmental-impact-ocean-energy-devices","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032119303831","title":"A framework to evaluate the environmental impact of OCEAN energy devices","description":"Ocean energy technologies are still at an early stage of development; only a handful of concepts are being invented and tested worldwide. The environmental impact of these devices is not always taken into account, mainly because of the prevailing uncertainty regarding its assessment. It is vital that attention is paid to the mitigation of potential negative impacts on physical and biotic marine systems. In this study, the direct and indirect effects of ocean energy projects on biophysical systems, and their interactions, are identified from an analysis of current literature on the subject. A tool that could be applied to any ocean energy project at any stage of an EIA is then proposed from a framework designed to evaluate the widely varying impacts of devices. This framework uses a categorisation of the environmental impacts of MRE devices (biophysical, chemical and socio-economic), based on the technology used and the device location. It is hoped that this tool will facilitate the identification of the potential environmental impacts of MRE devices and thus serve as a guide to quantitatively assess these impacts.","author":["Simas, T.","Silva, R.","Mendoza, E.","Lithgow, D.","Felix, A.","Flores, P."],"organization":["National Autonomous University of Mexico"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Ocean Current","OTEC","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mendozaetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/918","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dual-wave-farms-energy-production-coastal-protection-under-sea-level-rise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0959652619307474","title":"Dual wave farms for energy production and coastal protection under sea level rise","description":"Climate change is poised to exacerbate coastal erosion. Recent research has presented a novel strategy to tackle this issue: dual wave farms, i.e., arrays of wave\u00a0energy converters\u00a0with the dual function of\u00a0carbon-free\u00a0energy generation\u00a0and coastal erosion\u00a0mitigation. However, the implications of\u00a0sea level rise\u00a0\u2013 another consequence of climate change \u2013 for the effectiveness of wave farms as\u00a0coastal defence\u00a0elements against\u00a0shoreline\u00a0erosion have not been studied so far. The objective of this work is to investigate how the coastal defence performance of a dual wave farm is affected by sea level rise through a case study (Playa Granada, southern Iberian Peninsula). To this end, a spectral\u00a0wave propagation\u00a0model, a longshore\u00a0sediment transport\u00a0formulation and a one-line model are combined to obtain the final subaerial beach areas for three sea level rise scenarios: the present situation, an optimistic and a pessimistic projection. These scenarios were modelled with and without the wave farm to assess its effects. We find that the dual wave farm reduces erosion and promotes\u00a0accretion\u00a0regardless of the sea level rise scenario considered. In the case of westerly storms, the dual wave farm is particularly effective: erosion is transformed into accretion. In general, and importantly, sea level rise strengthens the effectiveness of the dual wave farm as a\u00a0coastal protection\u00a0mechanism. This fact enhances the\u00a0competitiveness\u00a0of wave farms as coastal defence elements.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["University of Plymouth","University of C\u00f3rdoba","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-06-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.713350000000","-3.527991000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/919","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-impulsive-noise-marine-mammals-investigating-range-dependent-risk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/eap.1906","title":"Effects of impulsive noise on marine mammals: investigating range-dependent risk","description":"Concerns exist about the impacts of underwater noise on marine mammals. These include auditory damage, which is a significant risk for marine mammals exposed to impulsive sounds such as explosions, pile\u2010driving, and seismic air guns. Currently, impact assessments use different risk criteria for impulsive and non\u2010impulsive sounds (e.g., ships, drilling). However, as impulsive sounds dissipate through the environment, they potentially lose hazardous features (e.g., sudden onset) and become non\u2010impulsive at some distance from the source. Despite management implications, a lack of data on range\u2010dependent characteristics currently limits their inclusion in impact assessments. We address this using acoustic recordings of seismic air guns and pile\u2010driving to quantify range dependency in impulsive characteristics using four criteria: (1) rise time \u0026lt; 25 ms; (2) quotient of peak pressure and pulse duration \u0026gt; 5,000 Pa\/s; (3) duration \u0026lt; 1 s; (4) crest factor \u0026gt; 15 dB. We demonstrate that some characteristics changed markedly within ranges of ~10 km, and that the mean probability of exceeding criteria 1 and 2 was \u0026lt;0.5 at ranges \u0026gt;3.5 km. In contrast, the mean probability of exceeding criteria 3 remained \u0026gt;0.5 up to ~37.0 km, and the mean probability of exceeding criteria 4 remained \u0026lt;0.5 throughout the range. These results suggest that a proportion of the recorded signals should be defined as impulsive based on each of the criteria, and that some of the criteria change markedly as a result of propagation. However, the impulsive nature of a sound is likely to be a complex interaction of all these criteria, and many other unrelated parameters such as duty cycle, recovery periods, and sound levels will also strongly affect the risk of hearing damage. We recommend future auditory damage studies and impact assessments explicitly consider the ranges at which sounds may lose some of their potentially hazardous characteristics.","author":["Hastie, G.","Thompson, P.","G\u00f6tz, T.","Merchant, N.","Janik, V.","Russell, D."],"organization":["University of St Andrews","University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2019-04-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.864305000000","-3.373778000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/921","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-impact-wave-energy-converter-mediterranean-shallow-waters","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41598-019-45926-1","title":"Acoustic impact of a wave energy converter in Mediterranean shallow waters","description":"In this study, underwater noise from a full-scale wave energy converter system (ISWEC), installed on the coast of Pantelleria Island (central Mediterranean Sea), was characterized. The noise was measured using an autonomous acoustic recorder anchored to the sea bottom 40\u2009m from the ISWEC hull. Acoustic monitoring continued for 15 months, starting 7 months before (PRE), 2 months during (INST) and 6 months after the ISWEC installation (POST). The levels of noise, assessed with power spectrum density and octave and third-octave band sound pressure levels (BSPLs), were higher during the POST period than during the PRE period at lower frequencies up to 4\u2009kHz and increased with wave height. During the ISWEC activation for energy production (POST_ON) in the wave height range 1\u20132.9\u2009m, the BSPLs increased much more at lower frequencies up to 4\u2009kHz (the median BSPLs at 63\u2009Hz for the PRE, POST, and POST_ON conditions were 73, 106, and 126\u2009dB re 1\u03bcPa, respectively). Considering the biophonies that make up the soundscape of the area, we examined the possible masking of fish choruses due to ISWEC noise and highlighted that at a distance of 1000\u2009m, the 800\u2009Hz peak frequency was 10\u2009dB above the ISWEC signal. Within this distance from ISWEC, a possible masking effect is supposed.","author":["Mazzola, S.","Buscaino, G.","Sannino, G.","Carillo, A.","Mattiazzo, G.","Papale, E.","Bracco, G.","Grammauta, R.","Kenny, J.","De Cristofaro, N.","Ceraulo, M."],"organization":["National Research Council of Italy (CNR)","Regio Politecnico di Torino (Royal Turin Polytechnic)","University of Turin","Universit\u00e0 degli Studi di Perugia (University of Perugia)"],"originationDate":"2019-07-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.789508000000","11.994126000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Buscaino-2019-Acoustic-WEC.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/922","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-high-quality-habitat-cause-disproportionate-increases-collision","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320718311571","title":"Wind turbines in high quality habitat cause disproportionate increases in collision mortality of the white-tailed eagle","description":"The increasing number of wind farms for energy production raises concerns about their effects on wildlife and particularly on birds. To date it is unclear whether models that combine data on wind turbine densities and habitat suitability can explain the actual spatial occurrence of collision fatalities and how well these models perform in comparison to models including measures of bird population densities (e.g., the distribution and density of nest sites). Here we analysed whether collision mortality increases with wind turbine density and whether a high population density or habitat suitability in the vicinity of wind turbines amplifies the effect of wind turbine density on collision mortality. We combined opportunistic records of dead White-tailed Eagles by the public in Northeast Germany during the period 2003 to 2014 with data on the distribution of wind turbines, nest sites and habitat suitability. As expected, wind turbine density was a strong predictor of collision mortality. In addition, we found that wind turbine density and habitat suitability had synergistic effects on collision mortality, so that the effect of wind turbine density was amplified in areas of high habitat suitability. Moreover, combining wind turbine density and habitat suitability allowed for better predictions of collision mortality than combining wind turbine density and nest site density. These results suggest that assessments of the spatial occurrence of collision fatalities based on models that combine data on wind turbine densities and habitat suitability can be useful for the strategic planning of wind farm development on regional scales. In particular, our study highlights that wind turbines should not be placed in core population areas of vulnerable bird species because synergies between wind turbine densities and habitat suitability may cause disproportionate increases in mortality. This might undermine the positive effects of parallel conservation efforts.","author":["Heuck, C.","Brandl, R.","Albrecht, J.","Krone, O.","Herrmann, C.","Levers, C.","Leit\u00e3o, P."],"organization":["Philipps-Universit\u00e4t Marburg","Technische Universit\u00e4t Braunschweig","Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","Senckenberg Biodiversity and Climate Research Centre"],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.279831000000","9.600080000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/924","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-effects-stressors-fiscal-year-2010-progress-report-environmental-effects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1004822","title":"Evaluating Effects of Stressors - Fiscal Year 2010 Progress Report: Environmental Effects of Marine and Hydrokinetic Energy","description":"Possible environmental effects of marine and hydrokinetic (MHK) energy development are not well understood, and yet regulatory agencies are required to make decisions in spite of substantial uncertainty about environmental impacts and their long-term effects. An understanding of risk associated with likely interactions between MHK installations and aquatic receptors, including animals, habitats, and ecosystems, can help reduce the level of uncertainty and focus regulatory actions and scientific studies on interactions of most concern. As a first step in developing the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) Environmental Risk Evaluation System (ERES), PNNL scientists conducted a preliminary risk screening analysis on three initial MHK cases - a tidal project in Puget Sound using Open Hydro turbines, a wave project off the coast of Oregon using Ocean Power Technologies point attenuator buoys, and a riverine current project in the Mississippi River using Free Flow turbines. Through an iterative process, the screening analysis revealed that top-tier stressors in all three cases were the effects of the dynamic physical presence of the device (e.g., strike), accidents, and effects of the static physical presence of the device (e.g., habitat alteration). Receptor interactions with these stressors at the four highest tiers of risk were dominated by marine\u00a0mammals (cetaceans and pinnipeds) and birds (diving and non-diving); only the riverine case (Free Flow) included different receptors in the third tier (fish) and the fourth tier (benthic invertebrates). Although this screening analysis provides a preliminary analysis of vulnerability of environmental receptors to stressors associated with MHK installations, probability analysis, especially of risk associated with chemical toxicity and accidents such as oil spills or lost gear, will be necessary to further understand high-priority risks. Subject matter expert review of this process and results is required and is planned for the first quarter of FY11. Once expert review is finalized, the screening analysis phase of ERES will be complete.","author":["Copping, A.","Anderson, R.","Van Cleve, F."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2010-11-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.838017400000","-120.831620500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Birds","Fish","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/PNNL-19990_Anderson_e_tal_2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/925","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-changes-marine-soundscape-offshore-wind-farm-machine-learning-based-source","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/8734295","title":"Evaluating Changes in the Marine Soundscape of an Offshore Wind Farm via the Machine Learning-Based Source Separation","description":"Investigating the ecological effects of offshore wind farms requires comprehensive surveys of marine ecosystem. Recently, the monitoring of marine soundscapes has been included in the rapid appraisals of geophysical events, marine fauna, and human activities. Machine learning is widely applied in acoustic research to improve the efficiency of audio processing. However, the use of machine learning to analyze marine soundscapes remains limited due to a general lack of human-annotated databases. In this study, we used unsupervised learning to recognize different sound sources underwater. We also quantified the temporal, spatial, and spectral variabilities of long-term underwater recordings collected near Phase I of the Formosa I wind farm. One source separation model was developed to recognize choruses made by fish and snapping shrimp, as well as shipping noise. Another model was developed to identify transient fish calls and echolocation clicks of marine mammals. Models were trained in an unsupervised manner using the periodicity-coded non-negative matrix factorization. After the sound sources were separated, events can be identified using Gaussian mixture models. Our information retrieval techniques facilitate future investigations of the spatiotemporal changes in marine soundscapes and allow to build an annotated database efficiently. The soundscape information can be used to evaluate the potential impacts of noise-generating activities on soniferous marine animals and their acoustic behavior before, during, and after the development of offshore wind farms.","author":["Lin, T.","Yang, H.","Huang, J.","Yao, C.","Lien, Y.","Wang, P.","Hu, F."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-06-13","spatial":{"coordinates":["24.651774000000","120.719468000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/926","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-anthropogenic-light-bird-movement-habitat-selection-distribution-systematic-map","sourceURL":"https:\/\/environmentalevidencejournal.biomedcentral.com\/articles\/10.1186\/s13750-019-0155-5","title":"Effect of anthropogenic light on bird movement, habitat selection, and distribution: A systematic map protocol","description":"Anthropogenic light is known or suspected to exert profound effects on many taxa, including birds. Documentation of bird aggregation around artificial light at night, as well as observations of bird reactions to strobe lights and lasers, suggests that light may both attract and repel birds, although this assumption has yet to be tested. These effects may cause immediate changes to bird movement, habitat selection and settlement, and ultimately alter bird distribution at large spatial scales. Global increases in the extent of anthropogenic light contribute to interest by wildlife managers and the public in managing light to reduce harm to birds, but there are no evidence syntheses of the multiple ways light affects birds to guide this effort. Existing reviews usually emphasize either bird aggregation or deterrence and do so for a specific context, such as aggregation at communication towers and deterrence from airports. We outline a protocol for a systematic map that collects and organizes evidence from the many contexts in which anthropogenic light is reported to affect bird movement, habitat selection, or distribution. Our map will provide an objective synthesis of the evidence that identifies subtopics that may support systematic review and knowledge gaps that could direct future research questions. These products will substantially advance an understanding of both patterns and processes associated with the responses of birds to anthropogenic light.","author":["Fern\u00e1ndez-Juricic, E.","Adams, C.","Blumenthal, A.","Bayne, E.","St. Clair, C."],"organization":["University of Alberta","Purdue University"],"originationDate":"2019-06-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Lighting"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/927","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-wind-turbines-bird-abundance-national-scale-analysis-based-fixed-effects-models","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421519302897","title":"Effect of wind turbines on bird abundance: A national scale analysis based on fixed effects models","description":"Existing studies regarding the impact of wind turbines on birds typically utilize data collected from a few wind facilities to estimate the impact at national level. This study examines the impact of wind turbines on breeding bird abundance by using a fine scale, spatial longitudinal dataset for 1,670 wind turbines and 86 bird observation routes located in 36 states in the United States over 2008\u20132014. We find that the establishment of one additional wind turbine, on average, leads to disappearance of about three breeding birds. The aggregate effect of the U.S. on-shore wind turbines on breeding bird count is 151,630, a magnitude at the lower end of existing estimates that range between 20,000 and 573,000. We also find that turbine size is a critical determinant of the magnitude of this impact, with turbine tower height positively, but blade length negatively, associated with aggregate breeding bird abundance. Grassland breeding bird abundance increases by up to 0.81 following the establishment of an additional wind turbine, although it is insensitive to tower height or blade length. Our findings provide important implications for policies related to wind facility siting and wind turbine development that can enhance the sustainability of wind energy.","author":["Miao, R.","Ghosh, P.","Khanna, M.","Wang, W.","Rong, J."],"organization":["Auburn University","University of Illinois"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.061913200000","-103.770736300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/928","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/iowa-atmospheric-observatory-revealing-unique-boundary-layer-characteristics-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.ametsoc.org\/doi\/full\/10.1175\/EI-D-17-0024.1","title":"The Iowa Atmospheric Observatory: Revealing the Unique Boundary Layer Characteristics of a Wind Farm","description":"The Iowa Atmospheric Observatory was established to better understand the unique microclimate characteristics of a wind farm. The facility consists of a pair of 120-m towers identically instrumented to observe basic landscape\u2013atmosphere interactions in a highly managed agricultural landscape. The towers, one within and one outside of a utility-scale low-density-array wind farm, are equipped to measure vertical profiles of temperature, wind, moisture, and pressure and can host specialized sensors for a wide range of environmental conditions. Tower measurements during the 2016 growing season demonstrate the ability to distinguish microclimate differences created by single or multiple turbines from natural conditions over homogeneous agricultural fields. Microclimate differences between the two towers are reported as contrasts in normalized wind speed, normalized turbulence intensity, potential temperature, and water vapor mixing ratio. Differences are analyzed according to conditions of no wind farm influence (i.e., no wake) versus wind farm influence (i.e., waked flow) with distance downwind from a single wind turbine or a large group of turbines. Differences are also determined for more specific atmospheric conditions according to thermal stratification. Results demonstrate agreement with most, but not all, currently available numerical flow-field simulations of large wind farm arrays and of individual turbines. In particular, the well-documented higher nighttime surface temperature in wind farms is examined in vertical profiles that confirm this effect to be a \u201csuppression of cooling\u201d rather than a warming process. A summary is provided of how the wind farm boundary layer differs from the natural boundary layer derived from concurrent measurements over the summer of 2016.","author":["Takle, E.","Rajewski, D.","Purdy, S."],"organization":["Iowa State University"],"originationDate":"2019-03-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.790831000000","-94.391547000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/929","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wind-turbine-noise-surrounding-soundscape-context-greater-prairie-chicken","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0003682X18311411","title":"Effects of wind turbine noise on the surrounding soundscape in the context of greater-prairie chicken courtship vocalizations","description":"The development of wind energy facilities in grasslands has increased in recent years. We assessed sound levels near a 36-turbine wind energy facility in a contiguous grassland in Brown County, Nebraska, USA, using a grid sampling design. Greater prairie-chickens (Tympanuchus cupido pinnatus), a bird species of special conservation concern, occupy the landscape near the wind facility. We evaluated the variation in wind turbine noise in the landscape at 296\u202fHz, the average peak frequency of the critically important courtship (\u2018boom\u2019) vocalization of male prairie-chickens. The levels of ambient sounds were affected by ordinal day (\u03b2\u202f=\u202f\u22120.0752, SE\u202f=\u202f0.0073) and wind speed (\u03b2\u202f=\u202f1.1679, SE\u202f=\u202f0.0419). Sound levels (dB) at the wind facility were affected by distance to the nearest turbine (\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.6917, SE\u202f=\u202f0.0111). Sound levels increased during the breeding season (ordinal day:\u00a0\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.0166, SE\u202f=\u202f0.0028), during the day (time of day:\u00a0\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.0035, SE\u202f=\u202f0.0015), and at higher wind speeds (\u03b2\u202f=\u202f1.1929, SE\u202f=\u202f0.0261). Sound levels were higher downwind from the facility (wind direction:\u00a0\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.9914, SE\u202f=\u202f0.1691) and at sites that were within the viewshed of turbines (topography:\u00a0\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.3819, SE\u202f=\u202f0.0824). At 100\u202fm from the turbines, under average temporal, landscape, and wind conditions, wind turbine noise at 296\u202fHz was 25\u202fdB above the ambient sound level. At 500\u202fm from the turbines, wind turbine noise at 296\u202fHz was 16\u202fdB above the ambient sound level. Our results demonstrate the variation of wind turbine noise in the soundscape and suggest a protocol for evaluating effects of wind turbine sound on sound-sensitive wildlife.","author":["Brown, M.","Whalen, C.","McGee, J.","Powell, L.","Walsh, E."],"organization":["University of Nebraska"],"originationDate":"2019-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.450004000000","-99.900129000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/930","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assess-risk-individual-turbines-golden-eagles","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doas.us\/wp-content\/uploads\/2019\/04\/Assess-risk-of-individual-turbines-to-Golden-Eagles-20190322.pdf","title":"Assess risk of individual turbines to Golden Eagles","description":"Wind power production is an important part of international strategies to reduce greenhouse gases and combat climate change. Nonetheless, there are costs to wildlife, especially eagles and bats, from wind turbines. Golden Eagles are a federally protected species; therefore, when a wind facility is predicted to \u201ctake\u201d Golden Eagles during normal operation, the facility is often legally required to attempt to avoid that take. If avoiding take is not possible, minimizing take is the next step. Minimizing take can be achieved by micro-siting wind turbines to avoid high risk areas. I applied existing models of predicted risk to low-flying Golden Eagles from wind energy, Golden Eagle habitat suitability, and wind turbine suitability to wind turbine locations at the Bluestone Wind Project. Of the 33 turbines, 24% (n = 8) were originally sited in high risk areas. Models suggest that each of those turbines could be micro-sited, i.e., relocated to a spot within 500 feet of the original location, to reduce predicted risk to Golden Eagles.","author":["Miller, T."],"organization":["Conservation Science Global"],"originationDate":"2019-03-23","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.349199000000","-77.985396000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Miller-2019-Golden-Eagles.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/931","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-bat-conservation-strategy-deuel-harvest-north-wind-farm-deuel-county-south-dakota","sourceURL":"https:\/\/puc.sd.gov\/commission\/dockets\/electric\/2018\/EL18-053\/rebuttal\/deuelharvest\/a15-1.pdf","title":"Bird and Bat Conservation Strategy Deuel Harvest North Wind Farm Deuel County, South Dakota","description":"Deuel Harvest Wind Energy LLC (Deuel Harvest) is proposing to construct the up to 310.1- megawatt (MW) Deuel Harvest North Wind Farm (Project) in Deuel County, South Dakota (Figure 1.1). The Project area is approximately 19,726 hectares (ha; 48,743 acres [ac]). The proposed Project consists of several components, including 124 proposed wind turbine locations, access roads, underground electrical collector lines and communication cable, a project substation, an interconnection substation, a 150 foot gen-tie line, and additional associated facilities The Project currently anticipates beginning construction in Q4 2019, and beginning commercial operations in Q4 2020. The Project Bird and Bat Conservation Strategy (BBCS) provides strategies for mitigating risks to birds and bats during the construction and operation phases of the Project.\n\nEnvironmental surveys of the Project area commenced in April 2016. An area larger than the final Project area was studied to provide the developer the flexibility to site the Project facilities away from high value environmental areas. The total area studied (Study Area) is 30,974 ha (76,542 ac) (Figure 1.2). The first year study area consisted of 21,248 ha (52,950 ac), and the Study Area expanded in early 2017 by an additional 9,548 ha (23,595 ac; expansion study area). The second year of field studies was conducted in the Current Project Area, hereafter referred to as the Project area (Figure 1.3).\u00a0","author":["Simon, S.","Welch-Acosta, B."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.777735000000","-96.697148000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Simon-2019-Bird-Bat.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/932","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-cumulative-impact-assessment-guidelines-offshore-wind-farms-evaluation-use","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/14615517.2018.1498186","title":"Development of cumulative impact assessment guidelines for offshore wind farms and evaluation of use in project making","description":"The offshore wind energy sector in the United Kingdom (UK) has grown rapidly since the first turbine generators were installed in 2000: by 2016 there were over 1400 installed turbines with combined capacity of 5.1 GW. The sector is considered by UK Government as essential to the development of a low carbon economy and to meeting binding targets on carbon reduction and renewable energy generation. The Crown Estate, responsible for licensing development on the sea bed around the UK, has held three rounds of licensing since 2000 for wind developments. Some of the projects in the first two rounds suffered long delays due to uncertainty of project level impacts, particularly cumulative impacts. A number of key stakeholders identified a need for cumulative impact assessment (CIA) methodology to be developed that was definitive and endorsed by regulators and industry to aid unblocking barriers to delivery. This paper explores the background to the development of the guidelines and how they were \u2018co-created\u2019 with industry and regulators. We evaluate to what extent they have been used to shape and develop practice.","author":["Durning, B.","Broderick, M."],"organization":["Oxford Brookes University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/933","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-benefits-vessel-slowdowns-endangered-southern-resident-killer-whales","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2019.00344\/full","title":"Potential Benefits of Vessel Slowdowns on Endangered Southern Resident Killer Whales","description":"A voluntary commercial vessel slowdown trial was conducted through 16 nm of shipping lanes overlapping critical habitat of at-risk southern resident killer whales (SRKW) in the Salish Sea. From August 7 to October 6, 2017, the trial requested piloted vessels to slow to 11 knots speed-through-water. Analysis of AIS vessel tracking data showed that 350 of 951 (37%) piloted transits achieved this target speed, 421 of 951 (44%) transits achieved speeds within one knot of this target (i.e., \u226412 knots), and 55% achieved speeds \u2264 13 knots. Slowdown results were compared to \u2018Baseline\u2019 noise of the same region, matched across lunar months. A local hydrophone listening station in Lime Kiln State Park, 2.3 km from the shipping lane, recorded 1.2 dB reductions in median broadband noise (10\u2013100,000 Hz, rms) compared to the Baseline period, despite longer transit. The median reduction was 2.5 dB when filtering only for periods when commercial vessels were within 6 km radius of Lime Kiln. The reductions were highest in the 1st decade band (-3.1 dB, 10\u2013100 Hz) and lowest in the 4th decade band (-0.3 dB reduction, 10\u2013100 kHz). A regional vessel noise model predicted noise for a range of traffic volume and vessel speed scenarios for a 1133 km2 \u2018Slowdown region\u2019 containing the 16 nm of shipping lanes. A temporally and spatially explicit simulation model evaluated the changes in traffic volume and speed on SRKW in their foraging habitat within this Slowdown region. The model tracked the number and magnitude of noise-exposure events that impacted each of 78 (simulated) SRKW across different traffic scenarios. These disturbance metrics were simplified to a cumulative effect termed \u2018potential lost foraging time\u2019 that corresponded to the sum of disturbance events described by assumptions of time that whales could not forage due to noise disturbance. The model predicted that the voluntary Slowdown trial achieved 22% reduction in \u2018potential lost foraging time\u2019 for SRKW, with 40% reductions under 100% 11-knot participation. Slower vessel speeds reduced underwater noise in the Slowdown area despite longer passage times and therefore suggest this is an effective way to benefit SRKW habitat function in the vicinity of shipping lanes.","author":["Tollit, D.","Wood, J.","Joy, R.","Li, Z.","MacGillivray, A.","Trounce, K.","Robinson, O."],"organization":["SMRU Consulting","Simon Fraser University","JASCO Applied Sciences"],"originationDate":"2019-06-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.527836000000","-123.204101000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Joy-2019-Killer-Whales.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/934","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/emec-billia-croo-test-site-environmental-appraisal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.emec.org.uk\/services\/consents\/","title":"EMEC Billia Croo Test Site: Environmental Appraisal","description":"Project background: The European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) was established in 2003 in Orkney. The centre offers potential marine renewable energy developers the opportunity to test prototype devices in real sea conditions. The centre has two key sites, one to test tidal energy devices which is located at Fall of Warness, Eday and a second (the focus of this document) a test site for Wave Energy Converters (WECs) and other infrastructure associated with marine renewables, located at Billia Croo, Stromness.  Billia Croo test site: Billia Croo is a full-scale grid-connected test site currently composed of five deep-water test berths and two inshore test berths with associated pipelines and cables to shore. The grid-connected test berths are serviced by subsea cables from an onshore substation, buried under the beach to 5 m below the Mean Low Water Spring (MLWS) mark, and then laid directly onto the seabed with cast iron cable protection for the first 250 m, the remaining length of each cable is unprotected. The test site is situated at Billia Croo off the west coast of the Orkney Mainland. The site is currently being expanded to accommodate future developer testing requirements. The current extent and agreed lease area extension are shown in Figure 1-1.  Requirement for Environmental Appraisal: In order to streamline licensing and testing for developers at the Billia Croo test site, a site-wide S36 consent under the Electricity Act 1989 is being sought by EMEC based on an envelope of testing activities. To support the S36 consent application, Xodus Group Limited (Xodus) has been commissioned by EMEC to undertake a full Environmental Appraisal (EA) for the Billia Croo test site. The purpose of the EA (this document) is to preappraise potential deployments and activities, based on the Project Envelope within the context of the wider environment. The Project Envelope will accompany this EA document as part of the S36 application (EMEC, 2019a). to produce an EA which will inform developer licence applications for all the testing and operations described within the Project Envelope.  As part of the original development of the Billia Croo test site, EMEC commissioned an EIA (Environmental Impact Assessment) in 2002, the findings of which were reported in an Environmental Statement (ES) (Carl Bro Group Ltd, 2002). This ES supported the Food and Environment Protection Act 1985 (FEPA) and Coast Protection Act 1949 (CPA) licences (Table 1-1). These licences allowed the presence of the test site but did not cover the deployment of individual wave devices by developers. An updated Environmental Description (from that contained in the 2002 ES) was produced in 2005 (Aurora Environmental, 2005) and subsequently updated by EMEC in 2009.  A Navigational Risk Assessment (NRA) was undertaken in 2008 and a subsequent report based on the NRA was produced to provide information to allow developers to produce a project-specific annex to the NRA (Abbott Risk Consulting Ltd, 2009). A new NRA has been undertaken in 2018\/2019 and will be submitted with the S36 application (Marine and Risk Consultants Ltd, 2019).  Click here for more on the EMEC Billia Croo Grid-Connected Wave Test Site.","author":["Xodus Group"],"organization":["Xodus Group","European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.959105000000","-3.376339000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-06 02:44:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BilliaCroo_XodusGroup_2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/935","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-energy-extraction-wave-energy-converter-arrays-wave-climate-under-multi","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s40722-019-00127-w","title":"The impact of energy extraction of wave energy converter arrays on wave climate under multi-directional seas","description":"This paper investigates the energy extraction of three types of wave energy converters (WEC) arranged in arrays and subjected to multi-directional seas of different wave spreading. The changes in the wave climate observed in the neighborhood of the arrays by their energy extraction were also reported. The hydrodynamic software, WAMIT, has been used to generate the performance of the WEC arrays in regular waves, whereas, a post-processing programming code developed in-house has been used to generate the device arrays\u2019 performance in multi-directional seas characterized by single-peaked (JONSWAP and Bretschneider) and double-peaked (Ochi\u2013Hubble) wave energy spectra. The results showed interesting findings on the WEC array performance and change in the wave environment around the devices, both strongly depend on the wave energy generation mechanism of the WECs and the wave spreading. The results obtained from the multi-directional seas with double-peaked wave spectrum showed significant differences in the energy production performance by the WEC arrays to those with single-peaked wave spectra. The uni-directional seas resulted in a larger q-factor. The q-factor differed with the peak wave periods, and at small wave periods, the q-factor for the terminator and attenuator WEC arrays are found to be higher than their counterparts for the point absorber WECs. With reference to the wave height modification in the neighborhood of the WEC arrays, the attenuator generated a greater wave disturbance followed by the terminator and point absorbers.","author":["Venugopal, V.","Tay, Z."],"organization":["Singapore Institute of Technology","University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/936","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/three-dimensional-movements-harbour-seals-tidally-energetic-channel-application-novel","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/aqc.3017","title":"Three-dimensional movements of harbour seals in a tidally energetic channel: Application of a novel sonar tracking system","description":"Understanding how marine predators utilize habitats requires that we consider their behaviour in three dimensions. Recent research has shown that marine mammals often make use of tidally energetic locations for foraging, yet data are generally limited to observations of animals at the water surface. Such areas are also of interest to the renewable energy industry for the deployment of tidal\u2010stream energy turbines; this has led to concerns about potential impacts on marine mammals.\nMethods for measuring animal movements underwater are limited; however, active sonar can image marine mammals and could potentially measure three\u2010dimensional movements in tidally energetic locations. Here, a dual 720\u00a0kHz sonar system was developed to investigate the three\u2010dimensional movements of harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) in a tidally energetic channel.\nEstimated mean depth (distance from the surface) of seals was 12.0\u00a0m (95% confidence intervals [CIs]: 11.6\u201312.4\u00a0m), and the majority of time was spent at the surface and at approximately 10\u201312\u00a0m distance from the surface. When expressed as distances from the sea bed, mean distance was 18.5\u00a0m (95% CI: 18.0\u201318.9\u00a0m), and the majority of time was spent at 14\u00a0m from the sea bed.\nSeal movements were generally in the same direction as the tidal flow with mean horizontal speeds of between 0.51 and 3.13\u00a0m\u00a0s\u22121\u00a0(95% CIs\u00a0=\u00a01.24\u20131.54\u00a0m\u00a0s\u22121). Mean vertical velocities (where negative and positive values represent a descent and ascent respectively) for each seal track ranged between \u22121.76 and +0.88\u00a0m\u00a0s\u22121\u00a0(95% CIs: \u22120.23 to +0.03\u00a0m\u00a0s\u22121).\nThese results provide a basis for understanding how seals utilize a dynamic tidal environment and suggest that harbour seal behaviour can be markedly different to less tidally energetic habitats. The results also have important implications for the prediction of risk associated with interactions between diving seals and tidal turbines in these dynamic habitats.","author":["Gordon, J.","Gillespie, D.","Hastie, G.","Sparling, C.","Macaulay, J.","Coram, A.","Bivins, M.","Jepp, P."],"organization":["University of St Andrews","SMRU Consulting"],"originationDate":"2019-03-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.234677000000","-5.660888000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/937","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fundamental-coupling-methodology-modeling-near-field-far-field-wave-effects-floating","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148119307086","title":"A fundamental coupling methodology for modeling near-field and far-field wave effects of floating structures and wave energy devices","description":"This research focuses on the numerical modelling of wave fields around (oscillating) structures such as wave energy converters (WECs), to study both near and far field WEC effects. As a result of the interaction between oscillating WECs and the incident wave field, additional wave fields are generated: the radiated and the diffracted wave field around each WEC. These additional wave fields, together with the incident wave field, make up the perturbed wave field. Several numerical methods are employed to analyse these wave fields around WECs. For example, for investigating wave-structure (wave-WEC) interactions, wave energy absorption and near field effects, the commonly used and most suitable models are based on Boundary Element Methods for solving the potential flow formulation, or models based on the Navier-Stokes equations. These models are here referred to as \u2018wave-structure interaction solvers\u2019. On the other hand, for investigating far field effects of WEC farms in large areas, wave propagation models are most suitable and commonly employed. However, all these models suffer from a common problem; they cannot be used to model simultaneously both near and far field effects due to limitations.\n\nIn this paper, a generic coupling methodology is presented, developed to combine the advantages of the above two approaches; (a) the approach of wave-structure interaction solvers, which are used to investigate near field effects because they can more correctly model wave energy absorption and the resulting wave fields induced by oscillating WECs or WEC farms. These solvers suffer from high computational cost and thus are mainly used for limited: (i) areas around WECs; (ii) number of WECs, and (b) the approach of wave propagation models, which are used for predicting far field effects and which can model the effect of WEC farms on the wave field and the shoreline in a cost-effective manner, but usually cannot deliver high-fidelity results on wave energy absorption by the WECs.\n\nIn addition, a novel wave generation technique is presented, for generating the perturbed wave field induced by an oscillating WEC, in a wave propagation model. The results obtained from the proposed coupling methodology and wave generation technique along a circle are validated and show very good agreement. Finally, the benefits of the proposed coupling methodology to model floating bodies in a phase resolving wave propagation model are discussed.","author":["Troch, P.","Stratigaki, V.","Forehand, D."],"organization":["Ghent University","University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2019-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/938","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ospar-request-advise-current-state-knowledge-studies-deployment-environmental-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ices.dk\/sites\/pub\/Publication%20Reports\/Advice\/2019\/Special_Requests\/ospar.2019.05.pdf","title":"OSPAR request to advise on the current state and knowledge of studies into the deployment and environmental impacts of wet renewable technologies and marine energy storage systems","description":"Current evidence suggest that, given responsible siting, significant changes (both near and far field) will only occur in the event either large numbers of devices or tidal barriers or tidal lagoons are deployed.  Notwithstanding the lack of model validation, ICES advises that large-scale developments should use regional hydrodynamic and morphodynamics models to predict environmental impacts, while ongoing monitoring of impacts should be continued during all phases of a development and at relevant spatial and temporal scales. However, for some receptors the predicted environmental effects from a relatively small number of devices are significant challenges when deploying wet renewable devices.  ICES advises both a move towards receptor-based assessments, and that targeted research and monitoring is needed to address key knowledge gaps for the different types of wet renewable devices as well as for the range of receptors and pressures acting both in isolation and in combination with each other. In addition, practical approaches and guidance, including worked examples on more ecosystem level cumulative effects assessments, are needed. Given the ongoing technological development and advancements in monitoring and assessment methodologies, such guidance will require regular review.  Clear and significant benefits would accrue from standardization in data collection, storage, and analyses, as well as improved access to all data and knowledge from all relevant sources.  Energy storage technologies are currently conceptual and their possible environmental impacts have not yet been fully described.","author":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"organization":["International Council for the Exploration of the Sea (ICES)"],"originationDate":"2019-04-02","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OSPAR-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/939","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/integrated-risk-based-assessment-north-sea-guide-ecosystem-based-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S004896971834347X","title":"An integrated risk-based assessment of the North Sea to guide ecosystem-based management","description":"This study provides an integrated perspective to ecosystem based management (EBM) by considering a diverse array of societal goals, i.e. sustainable food supply, clean energy and a healthy\u00a0marine ecosystem, and a selection of management measures to achieve them. The primary aim of this exercise is to provide guidance for (more) integrated EBM in the North Sea based on an evaluation of the effectiveness of those management measures in contributing to the conservation of\u00a0marine biodiversity. A secondary aim is to identify the requirements of the knowledge base to guide such future EBM initiatives.\n\nStarting from the societal goals we performed a scoping exercise to identify a \u201cfocal social-ecological system\u201d which is a subset of the full social-ecological system but considered adequate to guide EBM towards the achievement of those societal goals. A semi-quantitative\u00a0risk assessment\u00a0including all the relevant human activities, their pressures and the impacted ecosystem components was then applied to identify the main threats to the North Sea biodiversity and evaluate the effectiveness of the management measures to mitigate those threats.\n\nThis exercise revealed the need for such risk-based approaches in providing a more integrated perspective but also the\u00a0trade-offbetween being comprehensive but qualitative versus quantitative but limited in terms of the \u201cfocal\u201d part of the SES that can be covered. The findings in this paper provide direction to the (further) development of EBM and its knowledge base that should ultimately allow an integrated perspective while maintaining its capacity to deliver the accuracy and detail needed for decision-making.","author":["Rumes, B.","Jongbloed, R.","Robinson, L.","Piet, G.","Culhane, F.","Tamis, J."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","University of Liverpool","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Piet-2019-Risk-Based-Assessment.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/940","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-marine-spatial-planning-scientific-legal-implications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/brill.com\/view\/book\/edcoll\/9789004256842\/B9789004256842_009.xml","title":"Renewable Energy and Marine Spatial Planning: Scientific and Legal Implications","description":"Increasingly changing patterns of human sea and sea floor use originate in political, economic and societal developments often motivated by the process of transition towards a green economy. Offshore wind farming has turned into a major agent of change with a set of expected cumulative ecological impacts. Coastal and shelf seas become contested, but at the same time politically recognised areas, with emerging conflicts rooted in different perceptions, values and attitudes of coastal people. Associated with our limited understanding of environmental regimes and ecosystem impacts of cumulative shelf sea modifications are fragmented frameworks, in policy and economic sectors often opposing the balancing approach of Marine\/Maritime Spatial Planning (MSP). Mid and long-term management plans are further hampered by limitations faced in predicting long-term and regional climate change impact and future socio-economic and cultural developments. Planning under these circumstances is \u201cplanning under uncertainty\u201d. Based on a brief analysis of offshore wind farming in the context of MSP the paper illustrates the role of science by highlighting the important complementary functions of disciplinary process oriented research versus interdisciplinary and transdisciplinary approaches in assessing and modelling the expected cumulative effects of large scale offshore wind farming. In light of recent global discourse about future Earth system science, challenges and the emerging global science initiative \u201cFuture Earth\u201d (supported by the UN, and major research and funding institutions) key research questions and the relevance of applying a co-design approach inviting all actors and researchers to the framing process are discussed. The ultimate goal is to foster ecosystem-based management. It is most evident that scientific information needs to be provided to inform one of the major and unprecedented transformations on continental shelves which is motivated by a socio-political decision to move towards global sustainability in response to climate change and economic development. Designing appropriate social environmental assessment, forecasting, observations and involving the institutional and legal dimensions are central in this context.","author":["Kannen, A.","Gee, K.","Lange, M.","Kremer, H."],"organization":["Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2013-08-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/941","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/toward-best-practices-public-acceptability-wave-energy-whom-when-how-address","sourceURL":"","title":"Toward Best Practices for Public Acceptability in Wave Energy: Whom, When and How to Address","description":"Wave energy (WE) has the potential to eventually cover more than half of the world\u2019s electricity demand. The WE sector is still nascent; some technologies are approaching commercialization but others are in their infancy. Likewise, public opinion about WE is emerging. Public perception has been identified as a non-critical barrier of WE development provided public opinion is properly handled from the early stages of the sector. The public is now having its first acquaintance with WE, thus, the sooner there is an effective approach, the more opportunities will there be for the sector.  Research shows there are different techniques of addressing the public. This paper discusses different approaches as to whom, when and how developers should address by focusing on the experience of several renewable energy projects and the achieved results. The experience proves that early information dissemination to all interested parties via two-way communication methods contributes to achieving public acceptability most effectively","author":["Stefanovich, M.","S\u00f8rensen, H.","Chozas, J."],"organization":["Wave Dragon ApS","Aalborg University","Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.730391000000","10.125144000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Toward-Best-Practices-for-Public-Acceptability-in-Wave-Energy.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/942","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-bird-colony-sea-distributions-along-oregon-coast-implications-marine-spatial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.library.oregonstate.edu\/concern\/technical_reports\/5999n3855","title":"Marine bird colony and at-sea distributions along the Oregon coast: Implications for marine spatial planning and information gap analysis","description":"Increasingly diverse interests in commercial and recreational use of marine resources are creating new challenges for coastal ocean management. One concern of increased offshore use and development off the Oregon coast is the potential impact on marine bird populations. We summarized the primary surveys of seabird breeding colonies and at-sea distribution along the Oregon coast to describe spatial patterns in species distribution and identify gaps where additional data are needed. The abundance of breeding birds during the summer (over 1 million in total, primarily Common Murre Uria aalge and Leach\u2019s Storm-Petrel Oceanodroma leucorhoa) is greatest in northern and southern Oregon due to the availability of breeding habitat on large offshore rocks and islands. While there are fewer breeding colonies along sandy shorelines, the adjacent coastal waters are still frequented by breeding birds and nonbreeding migrants, but generally in lower densities during summer. Seabird density, and likely potential interaction with offshore structures, is greatest nearshore and steadily declines to lowest levels beyond the outer continental shelf. Dynamic soaring species, however, which have a greater potential to interact with taller structures such as wind turbines, tend to be more common on the middle to outer shelf. Species composition also changes dramatically among seasons. Low flying (\u0026lt; 30 m above sea level) diving species dominate in most seasons, however, which has potential conservation implications for interactions with structures above and below the water\u2019s surface. Given the abundance of storm-petrels, increased light pollution is also a concern for these and other nocturnal, phototactic species. Dramatic declines or redistributions have occurred at some breeding colonies, indicating long-term planning should consider changing habitat requirements. The greatest data needs currently include fall\/winter\/spring at-sea distribution, summer distribution off southern Oregon, and more accurate estimates and monitoring of burrow-nesting seabirds. Oregon\u2019s coastal waters provide habitat for a large portion of breeding and nonbreeding marine birds along the U.S. west coast and a thorough knowledge of their spatial distribution, seasonal abundance, and migration corridors is critical for well-informed marine spatial planning.","author":["Suryan, R.","Phillips, E.","So, K.","Zamon, J.","Stephensen, S.","Lowe, R."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2012-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.588916000000","-124.177759000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Suryan_et_al_2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/943","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/social-licence-marine-sector-review-understanding-application","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X16306558","title":"Social licence in the marine sector: A review of understanding and application","description":"Our global oceans are threatened by climate change, overfishing, pollution and a growing list of other impacts that demonstrate an urgent global need for sustainable ocean management. Whilst marine conservation initiatives and protected ocean spaces have increased over recent years, ocean management still lags behind the terrestrial sectors in incorporating and involving communities in its development. \u2018Social licence to operate\u2019 is used broadly across the terrestrial literature, but its understanding and application within the marine has been limited to date. This review sought to collate and synthesise instances of social licence in the marine realm as documented in the literature, aiming to create an understanding that may inform future research and development of social licence. Its results determine that social licence is yet an emergent concept in the marine sector but there may be great potential for its application in the marine context. Social licence has become an important theme for development in marine industry and resource use, particularly towards exploring communication and stakeholder engagement. This paper identifies future themes and areas requiring investigation and application in this domain.","author":["Kelly, R.","Pecl, G.","Fleming, A."],"organization":["University of Tasmania","Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-25.681709000000","133.945451000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/944","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tilting-offshore-windmills-regulating-wind-farm-development-within-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/jel\/article-abstract\/18\/1\/89\/468145","title":"Tilting at Offshore Windmills: Regulating Wind Farm Development Within the Renewable Energy Zone","description":"Offshore wind farms are likely to be a key component of the United Kingdom\u2019s strategy for renewable energy, and the Energy Act 2004 introduced a new legislative framework for the development of wind farms beyond the limits of territorial sea within designated renewable energy zones. The compatibility of the new arrangements with international marine and environmental obligations is analysed. Rights of navigation, the protection of the marine environment and the decommissioning of turbines at the end of their operational life all raise significant legal issues. The introduction of the Energy Act is an important development in assisting the construction and operation of offshore wind farms. But the law was passed at a time when a number of major reviews had concluded that the legislative and policy framework for the protection of the marine environment suffered severe weaknesses. It is unfortunate that the UK Government did not consider the creation of an offshore renewable energy industry as an opportunity to develop and apply the sort of new marine conservation strategies and legal frameworks being advocated as essential in this area.","author":["Scott, K."],"organization":["University of Canterbury"],"originationDate":"2005-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.356886000000","-2.602784000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/945","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/who-cares-european-attitudes-towards-marine-coastal-environments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X16303670","title":"Who cares? European attitudes towards marine and coastal environments","description":"Understanding how the public perceives the marine environment is a central component of the ecosystem approach. Despite the importance of exploring the links between society and the sea, it is still a relatively unexplored dimension of marine science. This paper presents the results of a novel European survey that explores the values, concerns and aspirations of individuals regarding the marine environment in seven countries across four regional seas. It provides an innovative contribution to the literature by refining our knowledge of how public perceptions on the oceans vary significantly by country, region and by demographic variables such as age and gender. Four issues emerge as important from this survey: (1) Concern about the oceans is variable but generally below other environmental concerns in different countries; (2) Ecosystem services, in particular regulatory, cultural and provisioning services that have broader societal relevance are recognised as important by the public; (3) There is a schism between scientific and public perspectives on the key pressures that affect marine systems; and (4) demographic factors such as age or generation can influence perceptions on marine issues more than the proximity of a community to the coastal environment. Public viewpoints on the oceans will play an important, if yet undetermined, role in supporting reforms such as marine planning, the large scale deployment of marine renewables and marine protected areas that have significant social and economic consequences.","author":["Potts, T.","Mee, L.","Pita, C.","O\u0027Higgins, T."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen","University of Aveiro","University College Cork","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.537079000000","-2.233740000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/946","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/building-blue-economy-role-marine-spatial-planning-facilitating-offshore-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/brill.com\/view\/journals\/estu\/30\/1\/article-p148_5.xml","title":"Building the Blue Economy: The Role of Marine Spatial Planning in Facilitating Offshore Renewable Energy Development","description":"The oceans hold a stunning potential for meeting our ever-growing demand for energy in a sustainable manner by converting energy stored in the form of heat, waves, currents and tides. At present the offshore renewable energy industry remains in its infancy, but given the right conditions, it could grow into a significant contributor to the global energy mix. A number of inter-related barriers, such as resource and user conflicts, regulatory complexity, and a limited understanding of environmental impacts associated with offshore renewable energy technologies, as well as the general challenges surrounding ocean governance, hamper the development of the industry. Marine spatial planning is emerging around the world as a practical tool for promoting a more rational and wise use of the oceans. It could also play a significant role in promoting the speedy and environmentally sound deployment of offshore renewable energy by assisting in overcoming the various hurdles to the development of that sector of the blue economy.","author":["Young, M."],"organization":["University of Cape Town"],"originationDate":"2015-02-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/947","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-evaluation-marine-spatial-planning-shetland-islands","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X14000293","title":"Review and evaluation of marine spatial planning in the Shetland Islands","description":"Marine spatial planning (MSP) is a fast evolving discipline signified by the European Commission\u05f3s proposed directive to create a common framework for MSP and integrated coastal management in EU waters and coastal areas. The Shetland Islands\u2019 Marine Spatial Plan (SMSP) first developed in 2006 is one of the most advanced in the UK. With seven years\u2019 experience of MSP and integrated coastal zone management (ICZM) in Shetland\u05f3s waters, and the pending statutory implementation of the SMSP in 2014, Shetland represents an exemplar case study for the monitoring and evaluation of this discipline in practice. A review was carried out in 2012 to evaluate and monitor the effectiveness of the SMSP to date. This exercise highlighted achievements to date, future challenges and opportunities and helped to guide the development of the forthcoming edition of the SMSP. The sharing of knowledge and practical experiences of MSP and ICZM ensures an adaptive approach in addressing uncertainty over time. It is also imperative to understand that early \u2018pioneers\u2019 in this discipline may not get it exactly right on the first attempt but by developing initial precedents and processes, these can be built upon in the future.","author":["Gray, L.","Kelly, C.","Tweddle, J.","Shucksmith, R."],"organization":["NAFC Marine Centre"],"originationDate":"2014-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.369542000000","-1.248452000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/948","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/integration-marine-research-results-maritime-spatial-plan-lithuania","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/268218585_Integration_of_marine_research_results_into_a_maritime_spatial_plan_for_Lithuania","title":"Integration of marine research results into a maritime spatial plan for Lithuania","description":"Integration of marine research results into a maritime spatial plan for Lithuania. Abstract This paper presents the results of integration of the environmental, economic and social data into comprehensive spatial plan of Lithuania. The main driving forces for the economic developments at sea are offshore wind energy growth and demand for exploration and exploitation of potential oil deposits. The de-veloped spatial plan is a practical step towards implementation of the strategy for the Baltic Sea region and particularly focused on proper management of the marine resources. The concept of location of existing and future marine activities along with regulatory framework was created. The developed spatial solutions create the pre\u2013conditions for future development at the sea and at the same time highlights the demand for new quality of the scientific research while investigating the marine resources and evaluating the economic effect as well as environmental consequences","author":["Bla\u017eauskas, N.","Mileriene, R.","Gulbinskas, S."],"organization":["Klaipeda University"],"originationDate":"2014-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.697370000000","20.972664000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Integration-of-marine-research-results-into-a-maritime-spatial-plan-for-Lithuania.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/949","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-french-wave-energy-test-site-sem-rev","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Alain_Clement\/publication\/229000632_Development_of_the_French_wave_energy_test_site_SEM-REV\/links\/0c960521b1b8321a46000000\/Development-of-the-French-wave-energy-test-site-SEM-REV.pdf","title":"Development of the French Wave Energy Test Site SEM-REV","description":"Progress to date in different stages of the SEM-REV French Wave Energy test site development is highlighted in this paper. The SEM-REV will serve wave technology developers as well as research in hydrodynamics related to wave energy extraction. The test site comprises a 2.5MVA power cable connected to the national grid through an onshore substation. The offshore 1km2 test zone is fully instrumented with 2 wave buoys and a matrix of current profilers hence providing continuous wave climate information.  After completing the initial site assessments and defining the regulatory frame, the development of the project is undergoing several consultation phases.  The SEM-REV permitting process is aiming to obtain a consented zone with pre-arranged permits, which will enable developers to operate easily under the site\u2019s requirements. Nevertheless, the identified regulatory frame will be a good baseline for project development in French waters. Assessment of the performance of wave energy converters relies on accurate measurement and knowledge of the wave climate. Additionally, the electrical analysis of the power systems requires accurate process and preparation of the electrical assets to perform different state measurements.  The SEM-REV wave test site planning is taking into account these requirements to prepare detailed performance testing and future certification.","author":["Mouslim, H.","Babarit, A.","Cl\u00e9ment, A.","Borgarino, B."],"organization":["Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)"],"originationDate":"2009-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.138928000000","-2.373584000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 09:39:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/950","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/roadmap-marine-spatial-planning-critical-examination-european-commissions-guiding","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X11001059","title":"A roadmap for marine spatial planning: A critical examination of the European Commission\u0027s guiding principles based on their application in the Clyde MSP Pilot Project","description":"The European Commission has developed a set of common principles for marine spatial planning in the European Union. A critical examination of these principles in practice is undertaken through an evaluation of the Clyde Marine Spatial Planning Pilot Project. The principles are found to be lacking in specificity and somewhat inconsistent with the ecosystem based approach, which they advocate. Lessons for new marine spatial planning initiatives, relating particularly to stakeholder participation, governance, data requirements, objective setting, and skills and knowledge needs, are derived from the Clyde Pilot.","author":["Flannery, W.","Cinn\u00e9ide, M."],"organization":["National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2012-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.534405000000","-4.875317000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/951","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/national-policy-framework-marine-renewable-energy-within-united-kingdom","sourceURL":"https:\/\/core.ac.uk\/download\/pdf\/43094355.pdf","title":"National Policy Framework for Marine Renewable Energy within the United Kingdom","description":"This document is intended to provide an introduction into the international, national and regional policy and legislation framework relevant to the deployment of marine renewable energy technologies within the UK, and specifically with a focus upon the South West and the county of Cornwall and its neighbouring Isles of Scilly. Within the context and scope of this document, devices that utilize wave, tidal stream, and floating wind within the marine environment are included within the definition of \u2018marine renewable energy devices\u2019 however limited focus is also given to offshore fixed wind turbines as it is recognised that, (although outside of the scope and context of this document and at a much further stage of technology maturity) there are many complimentarities between these technology groupings.","author":["Xu, J.","Bailey, I.","Whitehead, I.","de Groot, J.","Vantoch-Wood, A.","Connor, P.","Hamlyn, V."],"organization":["University of Exeter","University of Plymouth","Marine Energy in Far Peripheral Island Communities (MERiFIC)"],"originationDate":"2012-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.368118000000","-2.748121000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/VantochWood_et_al_2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/952","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-regional-locational-guidance-wave-tidal-energy-shetland-islands","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X14001419","title":"Developing regional locational guidance for wave and tidal energy in the Shetland Islands","description":"Marine renewables offer potential economic and environmental benefits, however there is a need to ensure that the growth of this emergent industry considers existing features and users of the marine environment. There is a clear role for marine spatial planning to guide its future development. The Shetland Regional Locational Guidance is a sensitivity led approach to identifying the suitability of areas around the Shetland Islands for renewable energy development and associated shore based infrastructure, and is an example of integrated coastal zone management. Working closely with local stakeholders was key to this process, which incorporates economic, environmental, social and cultural uses into one constraint model; constraint levels are set by local and societal values, rather than monetary equivalences. It has been successfully translated into policy within the Shetland Islands\u05f3 Marine Spatial Plan, which will form supplementary guidance to the Shetland Islands Council\u05f3s forthcoming Local Development Plan. The policy integrates with GIS data without requiring the creation of \u2018zones\u2019, as was requested by local stakeholders, and allows for updating of the GIS spatial model without requiring changes to the policy wording.","author":["Gray, L.","Kelly, C.","Tweddle, J.","Shucksmith, R.","Marengo, I."],"organization":["NAFC Marine Centre"],"originationDate":"2014-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.325985000000","-1.266769000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/953","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/meteorological-hydrological-effect-wind-farm-arid-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.worldscientific.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1142\/9789813142589_0062","title":"Meteorological and Hydrological Effect of Wind Farm in Arid Areas","description":"Large-scale development of wind farms has not only brought environmental benefits, but it will also affect the local meteorological environment. We chose Zhurihe wind farm, which is located on Sonid Youqi of Inner Mongolia, as our study area. Our observation instrument is the HOBO automatic meteorological station. The observation points are set up in the upwind area, inner wind farm and downwind area. This allows simultaneous observation of land temperature and near-surface air temperature and humidity of 1.5m range of wind farm area and analyze the effect of wind farm on near-surface temperature. The results show that the existence of wind farm would affect temperature and humidity inside and outside of wind farm area. In the daytime (10:00-16:00), there is a cooling and humidifying function in the inner area and downwind area. The relationship of air temperature and land temperature in these three seasons is upwind area\u0026gt;inner wind farm\u0026gt;downwind area. On the contrary, air relative humidity is downwind area \u0026gt;inner wind farm\u0026gt; upwind area, compared with upwind area. This means that the influence of the wind farm on the near surface temperature reduces with the increase in environment air temperature and land temperature while the influence on air relative humidity increases at the same time. The water surface evaporation of 24 hours of the inner wind farm is less than upwind area.","author":["Liu, J.","Sun, X.","Xu, R.","Yin, R.","Zhang, X.","Cheng, X."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.088230000000","112.717312000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/954","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wind-farms-near-surface-wind-speed","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1755-1315\/233\/5\/052041\/meta","title":"Effects of wind farms on near-surface wind speed","description":"Large-scale development of wind farm has brought environmental benefits, at the same time, it will also affect local meteorological environment. We choose Zhurihe wind farm, which is located in Sonid Youqi of Inner Mongolia, as our study area. Our Observation instrument is HOBO automatic meteorological station. The observation points are set on upwind area, inner wind farm and downwind area, in order to parallelly observe wind speed of 0.5m, 1.5m and 3.0m height. The results show that the wind farm consumes wind energy and reduces wind speed of inner wind farm and downwind area. The relationship of average wind speed in spring, summer and autumn is upwind area\u0026gt; downwind area \u0026gt; inner wind farm. Compared with upwind area, the decrease scope of average wind speed of inner wind farm and downwind area in spring is 5%-22%, summer is 3%-25%, autumn is 5%-33%. The influence of wind farm on the near surface wind speed reduces with the increase of environment wind speed in the same season. The existence of the wind farm has no effect on the form of wind velocity profile, which are all the standard logarithmic curve. But the slope of wind velocity profile of inner wind farm and downwind area is decrease. That is to say the fluctuation trend of wind speed increasing with the increase of height is not significant. In addition, compared with upwind area, the existence of wind farm has increased the surface roughness of the area where the wind farm is located in.","author":["Jing, L.","Xin, Z.","Ruiping, Y.","Xu, R.","Jingli, H.","Yanping, L.","Yongsheng, W.","Xu, S.","Lixia, W."],"organization":["Inner Mongolia Agricultural University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.952029000000","112.866900000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Xinetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/955","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/microclimate-effects-wind-farms-local-crop-yields","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0095069618306545","title":"Microclimate effects of wind farms on local crop yields","description":"This paper considers a novel spillover effect of wind farms - microclimate impacts on neighboring crop yields. Using US county-level crop and wind capacity data, I examine the effects of wind energy development on crop yields, controlling for time-invariant county characteristics and state-level annual shocks. I find robust evidence that counties with increased wind power development have also experienced increased corn and other crop yields, such that an additional 100\u202fMW of wind capacity increases county yields by roughly 1%. At recent prices, this implies a more than $5 dollar per megawatt-hour local benefit, corresponding to several hundred million dollars in annual benefits.","author":["Kaffine, D."],"organization":["University of Colorado Boulder"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.431486200000","-99.525377900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/956","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-farm-impact-based-realistic-wave-wec-interaction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544213000066","title":"Wave farm impact based on realistic wave-WEC interaction","description":"The objective of this work is to investigate the impact of a wave farm on the nearshore wave climate quantifying, for the first time, the interaction of the WECs (Wave Energy Converters) with the waves using ad hoc laboratory tests. To accomplish this objective, a procedure consisting of three main steps is implemented and illustrated with a case study: a wave farm of WaveCats (a lateral overtopping WEC) proposed for the Death Coast (NW Spain). First, the wave climate in the wave farm area is characterised and reference wave conditions are established. Second, wave-WEC interaction and, more specifically, wave energy transmission is determined by means of 3D physical model tests. Third, on the basis of the results of the laboratory tests, the impact of different layouts of the wave farm (single-row and two-row arrays) on the nearshore wave climate is computed using a high-resolution spectral wave model. The results indicate that the difference between the two layouts is negligible at a distance of 5000\u00a0m or greater past the farm. Although the case study concerns a specific WEC and area of deployment, the procedure is entirely general in that it can be applied to other WECs and areas of interest.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Carballo, R."],"organization":["University of Santiago de Compostela","University of Plymouth"],"originationDate":"2013-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.117407000000","-9.300328000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/957","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/rhode-island-ocean-special-area-management-plan-2008-2015-inception-through","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.crc.uri.edu\/download\/OceanSAMPImplCaseStudy_8.23_FINAL.pdf","title":"The Rhode Island Ocean Special Area Management Plan 2008-2015: From Inception through Implementation","description":"The Rhode Island Ocean Special Area Management Plan (Ocean SAMP), a marine spatial plan \u2014 and, one of the United States\u2019 first such plans \u2014 laid the groundwork for the siting and permitting of the nation\u2019s first offshore wind farm. This document examines the Ocean SAMP process from the time it was conceived, through its intensive plan development period (2008 \u2013 2010) and its five years of implementation to date (2010\u20102015). The focus, however, is on examining the implementation phase, as this is the period that has yet to be studied. Drawing on the field\u2010tested experience of planners, managers, and stakeholders interviewed for this study, the case offers lessons learned through this intensive marine spatial planning (MSP) process. These lessons emphasize the importance of: building a broad base of leadership; allowing time to build trust; using the planning driver to maintain stakeholder engagement through plan implementation; including clear policy tools in the plan to facilitate streamlined decision\u2010making; and preparing to work even harder during implementation than in the design and development phases.  This case study tells two stories. First is that of preparing a marine spatial plan for an area shaped by numerous interests and resources important to Rhode Islanders: commercial and recreational fishing, commercial shipping, recreational boating and sailing, marine resources and habitats, and potentially offshore wind energy development. Second is that of locating and permitting the United States\u2019 first offshore wind energy project. The coast of the northeastern United States has premier wind resources, and renewable energy development is arguably a priority to both the nation and to the state of Rhode Island. The two stories are interwoven, as that is how they have taken place. Yet, it is important to emphasize that the Ocean SAMP was launched, prepared and adopted as a comprehensive ecosystem\u2010based marine spatial plan, not as a renewable energy facility siting plan.  This report is one of three marine spatial planning (MSP) case study reports produced by the Coastal Resources Center\/Rhode Island Sea Grant College Program (CRC) at the URI Graduate School of Oceanography.  The purpose of the case studies is to document and share lessons learned from examples of marine spatial planning in the U.S. in order to build the capacity of MSP and coastal management practitioners. Research was conducted in three locations: Rhode Island, Washington State and San Francisco. The Rhode Island case focused on implementation of the Rhode Island Ocean Special Area Management Plan; the Washington case focused on the ongoing development of the Washington Coast Marine Spatial Plan; and the San Francisco study became a two\u2010case analysis of two different Coast Guard\u2010led waterways management initiatives.","author":["Fox, C.","Smythe, T.","Andrescavage, N."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island","Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation","University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.556975300000","-71.778776900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Smythe_et_al_2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/958","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-sensitivity-modeling-site-characterization","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.onepetro.org\/conference-paper\/OTC-29255-MS","title":"Environmental Sensitivity Modeling and Site Characterization","description":"This paper examines an environmental weighting tool developed for site assessment of New York offshore wind development and discusses future applications of sensitivity weighting for site identification and assessment as part of the development of other renewable energy projects across different geographic locations. As part of New York State\u0027s Offshore Wind Master Plan, Ecology and Environment, Inc. (E \u0026amp; E), with direction from New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA), developed a weighted sensitivity model to evaluate the relative risk of developing offshore wind infrastructure. This relative risk assessment compared the potential impacts, or \u0022stressors,\u0022 to selected biological marine resources, or \u0022receptors,\u0022 from activities that may occur during the pre-construction, construction, and post-construction phases of offshore wind energy development off the coast of New York.","author":["Guttenplan, K.","Koopman, M.","Belin, D."],"organization":["Ecology and Environment Inc"],"originationDate":"2019-04-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.697403000000","-74.120106200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/959","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/collision-displacement-barrier-effect-concept-note","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bto.org\/our-science\/publications\/research-reports\/collision-displacement-and-barrier-effect-concept-note","title":"Collision, Displacement and Barrier Effect Concept Note","description":"1. Offshore wind farms (OWFs) may potentially affect birds in a number of ways, most notably through: i) collisions with turbines; ii) displacement of birds due to effective loss of habitat; and iii) barrier effects where the wind farm creates an obstacle to regular movements to and from breeding colonies or migration. These effects have usually been considered separately in Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs). There is a need to consider whether the multiple impacts from these different effects in combination may be significant.  2. This summary concept note outlines the issues associated with and options for integrating the impacts associated with collision, displacement and barrier effects associated with OWFs in a statistically and ecologically appropriate way. The extent to which barrier effects have been differentiated from displacement effects is questionable, however, as both are manifested as a reduction in the number of birds in flight within the wind farm.  3. An initial overview is provided of key reviews which have assessed the sensitivities or vulnerabilities of species to the likely effects of OWFs. This information has then been used to derive a list of key species where two or more effects could operate together and therefore where multiple impacts need to be considered in combination. Displacement, barrier and collision effects have often not been considered in combination because the species considered at greatest risk from collision have generally been considered to be of low risk from displacement and vice versa. Based on the methodology outlined above, none of the species considered here required the effects of wind farms to be combined. Caution is urged, however, with using this approach as the basis for making the decision as to whether effects should be combined or not and a watching brief needs to be maintained on the evidence base.  4. A further review briefly summarises how collision, displacement and barrier effects have been assessed and treated by different OWF project applications for these species in the UK.","author":["Burton, N.","Humphreys, E.","Cook, S."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)"],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.090998800000","-2.977053300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Human Dimensions","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Humphreys_et_al_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/960","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/uncertainty-analysis-soil-pile-interactions-monopile-offshore-wind-turbine-support","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S014111871830395X","title":"Uncertainty analysis of soil-pile interactions of monopile offshore wind turbine support structures","description":"The objective of this work is to study the uncertainties involved in the modelling of the soil-pile interaction concerning their influence on the prediction of the dynamic structural response of monopile offshore wind turbine support structures. Two main issues are identified and addressed: the adequacy of the method used to deal with the soil-pile interactions and the adequacy of the soil properties reflecting the behaviour of the soil. The present study develops an approach that defines the penetrated pile length depending on the soil profile. Also, a parameter is defined to avoid the excessive usage of steel for the penetrated pile structure. The uncertainties are included in the probabilistic free vibration analysis and the contribution of each random variable to the scatter of the response is estimated by performing a sensitivity analysis. The results indicate that the uncertainty involved in the modelling of the soil profile has a significant effect on the coefficient of variance of the natural frequency, which is a serious issue to be considered in the fatigue life assessment of offshore wind turbine support structures.","author":["Soares, C.","Yeter, B.","Garbatov, Y."],"organization":["Centre for Marine Technology and Engineering (CENTEC)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/962","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/numerical-simulation-spudcan-soil-interaction-using-improved-smoothed-particle","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0951833918305215","title":"Numerical simulation of spudcan-soil interaction using an improved smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) method","description":"This paper proposes an improved soil-water-structure coupled interaction model within the framework of smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH). The continuous penetration process of the spudcan in clayey soil was investigated along with the concomitant variation of pore water pressure. The proposed method enables the efficient capturing of excess pore water pressure variation in soil undergoing large deformations. Verification and validation performed using previous numerical investigations and centrifuge test data indicate that the proposed model is valid, robust, and effective. This model can be employed to solve various penetration problems and other problems involving complex soil-water-structure interaction and large soil deformations.","author":["Chen, J.","Wu, H.","Njock, P.","Shen, S."],"organization":["Shanghai Jiao Tong University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["31.025220100000","121.431584400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/964","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-dernah-libya-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148115004176","title":"Life Cycle Assessment of Dernah (Libya) wind farm","description":"Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), is a technique to assess environmental impacts associated with all the stages of a product\u0027s life from-cradle-to-grave (i.e., from raw material extraction through materials processing, manufacture, distribution, use, repair and maintenance, and disposal or recycling). Wind energy is one of clean energy forms during the operation phase of the project, but it includes some environmental pollution during other stages of its life cycle such as manufacturing and dismantling of the wind turbines.  The aim of this study is to analyze and evaluate the LCA and real impact of the first wind farm to be installed in Libya considering the whole life cycle. This wind farm is located in Dernah, east coast of Libya. The analysis revealed that the energy payback period is 0.475 year (5.7 months), and the pay back ratio is 42.1, which confirms very well with other results in the literature. The electricity generated by one wind turbine 1.65 MW (model M. Torres (TWT 1.65\/82)) land based in this wind farm is expected to emit approximately 10.42, 0.02713, 0.03823, 0.0001474, 0.0001065, 0.0003469 and 0.0112237 g m per kWh CO2, SO2, NOx, N2O, CH4, NMVOC and CO respectively. The results obtained in this study confirm that wind energy produces the lowest CO2 emissions per kWh of electricity (\u223c10 g m\/kWh) compared to fossil fuel and other renewable energy sources. By recycling the wind turbine material the specific emissions of CO2 is 4.65 g m\/kWh of energy generated. The amount of fuel savings is 85,700 m3\/year or 79,013,800 kgfuel\/year, which is equivalent to $2,804,900\/year (more than fifty six million dollars over the life time of the wind farm) if the local subsidized price of HFO was considered. The savings could reach a value as high as $63,404,570\/year ($ 1.3 \u00d7 109 over the entire life time of the wind farm) if the international prices of HFO were considered.","author":["Al-Behadili, S.","El-Osta, W."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.758794000000","22.607988500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-02 08:36:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/965","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/empirical-determination-severe-trauma-seals-collisions-tidal-turbine-blade","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1111\/1365-2664.13388","title":"Empirical Determination of Severe Trauma in Seals from Collisions with Tidal Turbine Blade","description":"1. Tidal energy converters (turbines) are being developed in many countries as part of attempts to reduce reliance on hydrocarbon fuels. However, the moving blades of tidal turbines pose potential collision risks for marine animals. Accurate assessment of mortality risk as a result of collisions is essential for risk management during planning and consenting processes for marine energy developments. In the absence of information on the physical consequences of such collisions, predicting likely risks relies on theoretical collision risk models. The application of these at a population level usually assumes that all collisions result in mortality. This is unlikely and the approach therefore produces upwardly biased estimates of population consequences.  2. In this study, we estimate the pathological consequences of direct collisions with tidal turbines using seal carcasses and physical models of tidal turbine blades. We quantify severe trauma at a range of impact speeds and to different areas of seal carcasses. A dose\u2013response model was developed with associated uncertainty to determine an impact speed threshold of severe trauma to use in future collision risk models.  3. Results showed that severe trauma was restricted to the thoracic region, with no evidence of injury to the lumbar or cervical spine. Pathological indicators of mortality were only predicted to occur in collision speeds in excess of 5.1 m\/s (95% C.I. 3.2\u20136.6) and was affected by body condition; increasing blubber depth reduced the likelihood of severe trauma.  4. Synthesis and applications. This study provides important information for policy makers and regulators looking to predict the potential impacts of tidal turbines on marine mammals. We demonstrate that the probability of severe trauma in seals due to collisions with turbine blades is highly dependent upon collision speed, and that the majority of predicted collisions are unlikely to cause fatal skeletal trauma. We recommend that collision risk models incorporate appropriate mortality assumptions to ensure accurate estimates of the population consequences are produced in risk assessments for tidal turbine deployments.","author":["Hastie, G.","Moss, S.","Brownlow, A.","Onoufriou, J."],"organization":["University of St Andrews","Scotland\u0027s Rural College (SRUC)"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Pinnipeds","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-12 04:33:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/966","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interaction-between-instream-axial-flow-hydrokinetic-turbines-uni-directional-flow","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148115302196","title":"Interaction between instream axial flow hydrokinetic turbines and uni-directional flow bedforms","description":"A series of experiments were completed to investigate the interactions between relatively large-scale sediment dunes and axial flow hydrokinetic turbines. Baseline experiments were completed under clear water conditions to assess local scour impacts of single and two-turbine installations. Spatio-temporal measurements of bed elevation were obtained simultaneously with turbine voltage output, from which a measure of the instantaneous rotor angular velocity was used as a proxy for turbine response to unsteady loads. These experiments were completed in a mobile bed of 1.8 mm coarse sand with migrating bedforms. A bedform tracking routine was used to analyze streamwise bed elevation profiles to estimate bedform geometric characteristics and their corresponding impact on turbine performance. Cross-correlation analysis was also performed, investigating critical relationships between approaching bedform crest location, height and the corresponding turbine voltage output. In parallel with the analysis on bedform effects on turbine performance, an extended region downstream of the rotor location was analyzed to investigate how bedform geometric characteristics changed along the channel after turbine deployment.","author":["Hill, C.","Guala, M.","Musa, M."],"organization":["University of Minnesota"],"originationDate":"2016-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Ocean Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/967","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-willingness-pay-policy-preferences-tidal-energy-research-development-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0921800916304372","title":"Public Willingness to Pay and Policy Preferences for Tidal Energy Research and Development: A Study of Households in Washington State","description":"Puget Sound in Washington State (WA) has significant tidal energy resources, but the industry is at a nascent stage of development. At this stage, the availability of research and development (R\u0026D) funding plays a critical role in the success or failure of renewable energy schemes. However, information about public interest in developing marine renewable energy technology, including tidal energy technology, in WA and the U.S. has been limited. Responses to a dichotomous choice referendum question on a mail survey sent to a representative sample of WA households were used to estimate residents\u0027 Willingness to Pay (WTP) for tidal energy R\u0026D. Public preferences for policies to support tidal energy R\u0026D were also assessed. WA households are WTP between $29M and $127M annually for tidal energy R\u0026D, indicating public preference for an increase in government spending on tidal energy R\u0026D over current levels. Public perceptions of potential social, environmental, and economic risks and benefits of developing tidal energy emerged as highly significant predictors of WTP.","author":["Dreyer, S.","Polis, H.","Jenkins, L."],"organization":["University of Washington","Arizona State University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/968","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewables-coastal-communities-experiences-offshore-oil-industry-1970s-their","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X12001716","title":"Marine renewables and coastal communities\u2014Experiences from the offshore oil industry in the 1970s and their relevance to marine renewables in the 2010s","description":"Ambition to create jobs and economic growth from the vast open spaces of the oceans and seas is made real by new and developing technologies. In the 2010s, renewable energy generated from wind, wave and tide is laying claim to large areas of marine space and driving the search to find new ways to manage ocean and coastal development. Many more activities are expected and precedents are currently being set for the future of marine governance. Several observers have drawn parallels with the development of offshore oil and gas in the 1970s, which also represented a step change in use of the seas and coasts. The change was particularly felt in the Orkney and Shetland archipelagos, at the centre of the North Sea oilfields. Special powers were granted to the county councils here to control development and share in its benefits. This paper compares the oil and renewables industries, separated in time by nearly 40 years, and their influence on adjacent communities. The similarities and differences are identified to test the hypothesis that the 1970s oil model of local participation could be repeated for the development of marine renewables in the 2010s. The conclusion is that the model could well be applied but that the political and policy drivers of today make it unlikely, at least for the time being. Most notably, the change in the role of the public and private sectors and the use of market instruments to achieve national objectives tend to favour a climate of central control.","author":["Johnson, K.","Side, J.","Kerr, S."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2013-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.035148600000","-3.999372500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/969","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-application-lifecycle-analysis-renewable-energy-systems","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1177\/0270467608315920","title":"A Review of the Application of Lifecycle Analysis to Renewable Energy Systems","description":"The lifecycle concept is a \u201ccradle to grave\u201d approach to thinking about products, processes, and services, recognizing that all stages have environmental and economic impacts. Any rigorous and meaningful comparison of energy supply options must be done using a lifecycle analysis approach. It has been applied to an increasing number of conventional and renewable energy generation systems and in an increasing range of countries. There is now a good amount of research reporting the lifecycle environmental and economic aspects of power generation systems. This article reviews the existing lifecycle analyses of renewable energy systems to determine the current understanding of their full lifecycle impacts. These are then compared with each other and those of conventional power generation systems. The renewable energy systems reviewed include wind, solar photovoltaic, solar thermal (for electricity), hydroelectric, solid biomass, wave, geothermal, biogas, and tidal. The article also highlights the areas where more lifecycle analysis is needed.","author":["Lund, C.","Biswas, W."],"organization":["Curtin University"],"originationDate":"2008-04-16","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/970","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/governance-challenges-marine-renewable-energy-developments-us-creating-enabling","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X17307029","title":"Governance challenges of marine renewable energy developments in the U.S. - Creating the enabling conditions for successful project development","description":"Increasingly, marine renewable energy developments are viewed as an opportunity to meet climate change obligations, with the added benefit of powering the economy and the creation of jobs. Technical, economic and engineering challenges co-exist with governance challenges in the development of large-scale marine renewable energy projects. This paper addresses the question, if the prerequisites for sustainable project development are evident in selected case studies. It also asks what lessons can be learned from current practice in the context of energy governance at the local level. The authors argue that these lessons can be central enablers to support decision makers in future programmes, to better understand how to build the enabling conditions for programme implementation towards renewable energy at higher spatial scales of governance, importantly the national level. The study builds on a multiple stakeholder approach involving interviews and group discussions with key individuals from industry, government and civil society in emerging pilot programmes along the East Coast of the United States (U.S.). New policy windows were opening at the time of the analysis and ambitious development was underway by a range of actors who are driving progress in the sector and positioning the area to become a major provider of blue energy.","author":["Lange, M.","Cummins, V.","Page, G."],"organization":["University College Cork","Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.291467400000","-78.446123900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Langetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/971","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/determining-local-acceptance-wind-energy-projects-switzerland-importance-general","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629614001121","title":"Determining the local acceptance of wind energy projects in Switzerland: The importance of general attitudes and project characteristics","description":"This article explores the relationship between general attitudes toward wind energy, local acceptance of specific wind projects and respective intentions to act on those attitudes in Switzerland. Its primary instrument of data collection was a survey experiment with 919 citizens in five Swiss rural municipalities with potential wind sites. The survey presented descriptions of several potential wind projects. Participants rated their acceptance and intention to act for each wind project, as well as their general attitude toward wind energy. Results showed that general attitude is a strong predictor of local acceptance but is rated significantly higher than local acceptance. When matched with the effects of three procedural and distributive justice measures on local acceptance, the results of the study seem to support the concept of \u2018Qualified Support\u2019: local acceptance by participants with a moderate or positive general attitude is dependent on the associated local benefits, while local acceptance by participants with a negative attitude is not. Interestingly, the study also finds that general attitude and local acceptance both had only minimal effects on respective intentions to act. Thus, researchers should be aware of cognitive and behavioral aspects of local acceptance and seek to better distinguish between these two dimensions.","author":["Walter, G."],"organization":["University of Zurich"],"originationDate":"2014-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.807688600000","7.100538000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/972","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-city-interurban-comparison-social-acceptance-wind-energy-projects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629615000511","title":"Wind energy in the city: An interurban comparison of social acceptance of wind energy projects","description":"A transition towards low-carbon energy sources, such as wind, requires higher levels of public interaction; as such, the ultimate contribution of wind energy relies as much on technological advancements and policies as on societal sentiments. This study evaluates the influence of region, community involvement, and several IEA-recommended practices on social acceptance of wind energy projects among residents (n = 350) surveyed from cities in four OECD and three non-OECD countries. The results indicate interurban variations among the generally high levels of acceptance reported, especially among residents of cities in developing countries with lower domestic CO2 emissions. The level of community involvement in a hypothetical wind energy project had a positive effect on acceptance, and respondents from cities in countries with the highest installed wind capacity reported the greatest sensitivity towards involvement. Moreover, the results revealed that although the IEA-recommended practices collectively predicted acceptance across all cities, fair distribution of earnings and costs was the only significant individual predictor. These economic considerations, combined with increased community involvement, appear to be paramount to facilitating future development of wind energy. Through its broad geographical coverage, this research provides valuable groundwork for future cross-cultural studies on social acceptance of wind energy.","author":["Crawford, C.","Khorsand, I.","Kormos, C.","MacDonald, E."],"organization":["University of Victoria"],"originationDate":"2015-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/973","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparative-assessment-proposed-offshore-wind-power-demonstration-projects-united","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629615300141","title":"A comparative assessment of proposed offshore wind power demonstration projects in the United States","description":"Wind energy development on land has faced local opposition for reasons such as effects on cultural landscapes and wildlife, which can be instrumental in whether or not and the speed with which a project moves toward completion. Offshore wind can generate electricity where onshore wind is limited. Factors leading to support for, or opposition to, offshore wind energy are not well known, particularly for developments that are near-shore and in-view of coastal communities. Here we present results from a survey of 699 residents (35.5% response rate) completed in 2013 in greater Atlantic City, New Jersey and coastal Delaware, United States, where near-shore wind demonstration projects had been proposed. We examined how the public considers the societal tradeoffs that are made to develop small-scale, in-view demonstration wind projects instead of larger facilities farther offshore. Results indicate that a strong majority of the public supports near-shore demonstration wind projects. We find the primary reasons for support include benefits to wildlife, cost of electricity, and job creation, while the primary reasons for opposition include wildlife impacts, aesthetics, tourism, and user conflicts. These factors differ between the two communities and highlight the importance of local, community engagement in the early stages of development.","author":["Firestone, J.","Bates, A."],"organization":["University of Delaware"],"originationDate":"2015-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.040872200000","-79.074891500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/974","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-farms-southern-europe-determining-tourist-preference-social-acceptance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629615300116","title":"Offshore wind farms in Southern Europe \u2013 Determining tourist preference and social acceptance","description":"There is increasing consensus that resistance to the siting of wind power facilities cannot be explained by the NIMBY phenomenon alone or other localized environmental impacts. This deficiency is addressed by examining the determinants of tourist preferences for positioning of wind farms in the Mediterranean Sea. A principal component analysis is used to identify general attitudinal themes that act as covariates in a choice model. We demonstrate that the welfare economic impacts associated with spending holidays in the vicinity of an offshore wind farm do not merely depend on visibility effects, but equally on the individual\u0027s opinion of climate change, efficiency of wind energy and the substitutability of nuclear and fossil fuels with renewable power generating sources.","author":["Westerberg, V.","Jacobsen, J.","Lifran, R."],"organization":["Montpellier 1 University","University of Copenhagen"],"originationDate":"2015-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Recreation \u0026 Tourism"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/975","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/does-more-wind-energy-influence-choice-location-wind-power-development-assessing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629615000766","title":"Does more wind energy influence the choice of location for wind power development? Assessing the cumulative effects of daily wind turbine encounters in Denmark","description":"An increasing number of studies suggest that the cumulative impacts of wind turbine encounters might have a negative impact on the acceptance of onshore wind power development. In many countries offshore wind resources are seen as the new wind energy resource, though the offshore cost of energy is markedly higher compared to onshore. In the present paper it is tested if the cumulative effect of wind turbines makes people favour offshore wind turbine development to onshore development. The results suggest that the cumulative effects from wind turbine encounters have weak effects on the relative attitude towards more onshore and offshore wind power development. This suggests that increasing onshore wind power development does not make people favour offshore wind power development to a higher extent.","author":["Ladenburg, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.209707700000","9.295234800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/976","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/beauty-motion-expectations-attitudes-values-wind-energy-development-rural-us","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629615300554","title":"Beauty in motion: Expectations, attitudes, and values of wind energy development in the rural U.S","description":"Attitudes towards wind energy development are influenced by a number of social, political, and geographic factors. Initial resident expectations for a development, and then the degree to which these expectations were later met can help explain support or opposition for wind energy. Yet, the role of met or unmet expectations is not well researched in explaining perceptions of and attitudes towards wind energy development. This study explores the relationship between met and unmet expectations and resident attitudes towards wind energy, as well as perceptions of wind turbine beauty, for rural residents near two wind energy projects in the U.S. state of South Dakota (SD). A survey (n = 239) administered in 2014 across two counties investigates the process of attitude and expectation formation towards the projects as they developed. Results show that the majority of residents had positive expectations, and these expectations are largely unmet; nonetheless, most residents retain positive attitudes towards both projects, although certain types of expectations are related to more positive or more negative attitudes. Furthermore, the survey results show that residents find turbines in motion to be more beautiful than static turbines\u2014demonstrating the role of economic and environmental values in influencing wind energy attitudes and expectations.","author":["Jacquet, J.","Fergen, J."],"organization":["South Dakota State University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.828101000000","-99.514137000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:07:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/977","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/community-perceptions-renewable-energies-portugal-impacts-environment-landscape-local","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S221462961530089X","title":"Community perceptions of renewable energies in Portugal: Impacts on environment, landscape and local development","description":"This article aims to contribute to the debate on energy transitions in Europe, by focusing on community perceptions in a southern European country marked by a significant development of renewable energy in recent years, Portugal. Three main dimensions of community perceptions of the impact, both positive and negative, of renewables are addressed: environmental, landscape and socioeconomic. The article is based on case studies of communities living in the vicinities of three wind farms and a solar power plant. The results show that not only community perceptions are heterogeneous but also that, in order to better understand the factors for social acceptance, it is crucial to examine perceptions not just at the planning stage but also once the energy infrastructures are constructed and functioning.","author":["Silva, L.","Delicado, A.","Figueiredo, E."],"organization":["Universidade de Lisboa","University of Aveiro","New University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.527775500000","-9.428595100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/978","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/media-policy-complex-adaptive-system-insights-wind-energy-legislation-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629616301232","title":"Media and policy in a complex adaptive system: Insights from wind energy legislation in the United States","description":"Since the early 1970s, debates surrounding the promises and pitfalls of renewable energy as a way to securely meet consumption demands in the United States have been commonplace in the media and political discourse. Drawing on the communication and political science literatures, this research addresses the relationships between the amount of media coverage given to wind energy, as well as the frames used in covering the topic, and the number of bills presented to state legislatures. We argue the media and political decision-making bodies are working as agents in a complex adaptive system, wherein they are constantly interacting and adjusting to both internal and external variables.","author":["Smith, J.","Smith, H.","Gilbert, C.","Silka, L.","Lindenfield, L."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island","Utah State University","University of Maine","Stony Brook University"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.198969300000","-103.830795800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/979","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biodiversity-wind-energy-kenya-revealing-landscape-wind-turbine-perceptions-worlds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S221462961630127X","title":"Biodiversity and wind energy in Kenya: Revealing landscape and wind turbine perceptions in the world\u0027s wildlife capital","description":"People vary in their perceptions of wind turbines. Perceptions have been well-documented in European and North American studies and have been attributed to constructs like place attachment. Genius loci, or \u201cspirit of a place,\u201d is an ancient Roman idea that has new relevance in the study of landscape perceptions, including perceptions of wind turbines. As wind energy development expands to developing countries, new studies of public perceptions in unique cultural landscapes are required. We surveyed visitors to Nairobi National Park about their perceptions of the park landscape and the six-turbine Ngong Hills wind farm. Two complementary theories were used to analyze perceptions: place attachment and genius loci. The Ngong Hills Wind Farm had a slightly positive effect on the visitors who saw them. Additional turbine development would have no effect on their visitor experience but additional urban growth would have a very negative effect. Responses show that place attachment and genius loci explain aspects of visitor perceptions of the Nairobi National Park landscape. The human aspects of the landscape, including wind turbines and the Nairobi skyline, interact with the natural elements and the visitors\u2019 own experiences to create a distinct genius loci and evokes feelings of place attachment.","author":["Nordman, E.","Mutinda, J."],"organization":["Grand Valley State University","Kenyatta University"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-1.361595100000","36.842959300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/980","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-views-renewable-energy-rocky-mountain-region-united-states-distinct-attitudes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629616301773","title":"Public views on renewable energy in the Rocky Mountain region of the United States: Distinct attitudes, exposure, and other key predictors of wind energy","description":"Renewable energy is often framed by policymakers and the media as an environmental or \u2018green\u2019 issue motivated by global climate change and the need for greenhouse gas reductions. However, some researchers studying social responses to renewables have found that factors other than opinions about climate change may be more influential in determining support for renewables. This study analyzes survey data from a study of five communities in the Rocky Mountain region of the U.S. experiencing wind energy development to examine the relationship between environmental beliefs, climate change opinions, and support for renewable energy. Results show that views on renewable energy comprise a distinct dimension of public views on energy, environment, and climate, suggesting that public support for renewable energy is less related to environmental beliefs than to some other factors, including beliefs about economic benefits and concerns about landscape impacts. Findings also indicate that the frequency with which individuals see nearby wind turbines are strongly related to their level of support for renewable energy, while physical proximity is not. Overall, results suggest that ceasing to frame renewable energy as an environmental issue and instead framing it in a way that invokes locally relevant social values may garner broader public support.","author":["Robertson, P.","Olson-Hazboun, S.","Krannich, R."],"organization":["Utah State University"],"originationDate":"2016-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.246506700000","-110.654210600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/981","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-wind-energy-north-sea-offshore-grid-initiative-multi-level-perspective-stalled","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S221462961630192X","title":"Marine wind energy and the North Sea Offshore Grid Initiative: A Multi-Level Perspective on a stalled technology transition?","description":"Building electricity grids out to sea implies a radical transformation of grid topologies. In time, a marine super-grid is conceivable. If growing numbers of subsea electricity cables are meshed with marine renewable, a \u2018greening\u2019 of such grids is also possible. Based on interview research, this paper examines one such ambitious proposal: the Northern Seas Countries Offshore Grid Initiative (NSCOGI). The Multi-Level Perspective (MLP) on technology transitions is used to evaluate progress to date. Obstacles uncovered include competing and still immature grid technology niches. There is only equivocal support from key actors within the relevant socio-technical electricity regime. National grid Transmission System Operators (TSOs) appear more interested in subsea cables to trade electricity rather than enhancing marine renewables. While the EU might be assumed to be a vital actor to support a North Sea Grid, it has only limited influence. National policy insiders and decisions matter more. This paper stresses the residual importance of the national level for offshore wind and electricity grids. A marine super-grid wired up with offshore wind-farms throughout the North Sea, is both more tentative in its emergence, but also ambiguous in its support for offshore wind.","author":["Flynn, B."],"organization":["National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/982","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/transformational-paradigm-marine-renewable-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S221462961630250X","title":"A transformational paradigm for marine renewable energy development","description":"Marine Renewable Energy (MREs) holds extensive environmental, social, and economic potential for rural coastal areas across the globe, which are often resource-rich but capital-poor, often due to historic paradigm of economic (under) development. Focusing on the Highland and Islands region (HIR) of Scotland, we identify a conundrum which is currently limiting overall development of MREs and their positive effects, mainly due to the lack of access to sustained sectorial investments and a stable demand for electricity. From a historic perspective, we identify in the Megaloplis paradigm the reasons for this conundrum. Further, we develop a new policy and governance paradigm, DICEP, rooted in the concepts of diffusion of benefits, inclusive governance, community engagement, regional entrepreneurship, and a balancing top-down approaches with bottom up initiatives. The paradigm builds upon local strengths and policies for combining MREs and economic development policies for expanding non-residential electricity demand through the support of productive activities. Finally, we present two case studies where elements of Megalopolis and DICEP emerge, as well as propose potential localized uses of energy for manufacturing and agricultural practices. DICEP acts as an operationalization of the New Rural Paradigm, and a bridge between the initial diffusion of MREs and their future full deployment.","author":["Greenhill, L.","Kenter, J.","Billing, S.","Graziano, M."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","Central Michigan University"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/983","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stakeholder-empowerment-through-participatory-planning-practices-case-electricity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629616302377","title":"Stakeholder empowerment through participatory planning practices: The case of electricity transmission lines in France and Norway","description":"The importance of grid extension in Europe has risen in the last decade as a result of an aging grid and the energy transition toward a decarbonized electricity sector. While grid extension is claimed as necessary, stakeholder opposition has slowed down this process. To alleviate this tension, increased stakeholder participation is considered as a solution to increase acceptance. The question of stakeholder empowerment is central to participation and it is assumed that higher levels of empowerment improve planning processes. In this paper, we describe, evaluate and compare the planning processes for very high-voltage transmission lines in France and Norway by means of a document analysis. We operationalize the degree of empowerment in three levels: information, consultation and cooperation. The results reveal low stakeholder empowerment that barely rises above the level of consultation. The evaluation of recent projects entailing innovations to enhance stakeholder participation reveals a trend of increasing empowerment levels, especially in the early phases of the planning procedure, i.e. the discussion about the needs for new lines and about the needs of the affected stakeholders. The results suggest that current planning regulations can benefit from high levels of stakeholder empowerment, especially in the early phases of the planning process.","author":["Sp\u00e4th, L.","Scolobig, A."],"organization":["ETH Zurich"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Stakeholder-empowerment-through-participatory-planning-practices.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/984","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-high-voltage-power-lines-feelings-evoked-different-swiss-surroundings","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629616302948","title":"The influence of high-voltage power lines on the feelings evoked by different Swiss surroundings","description":"The planned transition from nuclear power to decentralized renewable energy sources in Switzerland requires the modification and expansion of the electricity grid. However, public acceptance of high-voltage power lines (HVPLs) is generally low. Drawing on the importance of affect in the context of technology acceptance, the goal of the present work was to shed light on people\u2019s affective responses to HVPLs, as well as to examine the influence of different siting options. Results of an online study (N = 94) showed that pictures of landscapes featuring HVPLs evoke significantly stronger negative feelings than pictures of the same landscapes without HVPLs. These differences were greater for positively perceived surroundings such as rural landscapes than for negatively perceived surroundings such as urban landscapes. In a second step, an eye tracking study (N = 95) was conducted to validate these findings and gain insights into people\u2019s decision making. Results show that people pay more attention to HVPLs when they are sited in positively perceived landscapes than when they are sited in negatively perceived landscapes. Furthermore, increased attention on HVPLs was related to a more negative affective evaluation of otherwise positively perceived landscapes. The results underline the importance of siting decisions in the context of grid infrastructure projects.","author":["Lienert, P.","S\u00fctterlin, B.","Siegrist, M."],"organization":["ETH Zurich"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.807688600000","7.100538000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/985","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spoiled-darkness-sense-place-annoyance-over-obstruction-lights-worlds-largest-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629616303280","title":"Spoiled darkness? Sense of place and annoyance over obstruction lights from the world\u0027s largest wind turbine test centre in Denmark","description":"The relation between wind power development and local communities has received considerable attention in literature and practice. Relatively few studies, however, have provided evidence about how local citizens perceive enduring environmental impacts such as aviation obstruction lights installed on wind turbines or on wind farm light masts. Evidence regarding people\u2019s perceived annoyance over obstruction lights is of increasing importance as wind turbines become taller, thus potentially affecting more people in the future. The paper conducts individual web-based surveys and interviews with local residents around the world\u2019s largest onshore test site for tall wind turbines in Denmark \u2013 the national test site in the rural area of \u00d8sterild. The aim is to explore the nature and extent of perceived annoyance over aviation obstruction lights from the test site and the efficiency of different coping strategies. In particular, the discussion focuses on the perceived annoyance in relation to the perceived changes in sense of place, hereunder the loss of the area\u2019s unique night darkness. We argue that perceived annoyance can only be mitigated through coping strategies to a limited extent, as a) perceived effects on sense of place are distinctive in shaping annoyance, and b) an internalisation of planning-related inequities persists.","author":["Clausen, N.","Rudolph, D.","Kirkegaard, J.","Lyhne, I.","K\u00f8rn\u00f8v, L."],"organization":["Technical University of Denmark (DTU)","Aalborg University"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.025500000000","8.858150000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Lighting"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/986","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/procedural-justice-canadian-wind-energy-development-comparison-community-based","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S221462961730124X","title":"Procedural justice in Canadian wind energy development: A comparison of community-based and technocratic siting processes","description":"Though there is a growing literature on the value of participatory siting processes for increasing local acceptance of wind energy development, there has been much less unpacking of how residents view the siting process itself. We explore differences in the ways governments and developers enact planning and how this impacts both acceptance\/support and procedural justice outcomes. This mixed methods study employed in-depth interviews (n = 54) and surveys (n = 252) with multiple stakeholder groups to understand perceptions of procedural justice across two Canadian provinces. We compared Ontario \u2013 which has built a strong base of wind energy capacity using technocratic siting procedures with Nova Scotia \u2013 which has anchored its development strategy more explicitly with a community-based program. We find stronger levels of perceived procedural justice in Nova Scotia across the majority of principles tested. In Ontario, opposition to local developments was highly conflated with a lack of procedural justice including few opportunities to take part in siting. Across both provinces however, specific aspects of planning processes \u2013 mostly related to \u2018the ability to affect the outcome\u2019 \u2013 were strong predictors of local approval of wind. This paper closes with a discussion of how future policy programs can more effectively engage with principles of procedural justice.","author":["Baxter, J.","Walker, C."],"organization":["University of Western Ontario"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.052033500000","-115.391409300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Environmental Justice"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/987","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/muillean-gaoithe-melin-wynt-cultural-sustainability-community-owned-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629617301251","title":"The Muillean Gaoithe and the Melin Wynt: Cultural sustainability and community owned wind energy schemes in Gaelic and Welsh speaking communities in the United Kingdom","description":"There is a shortage of scholarly research into understanding the cultural values, drivers and outcomes of community renewable developments. This paper contributes towards addressing this gap, by comparing four community renewable projects set in Scottish Gaelic speaking Scotland and in Welsh speaking Wales. Not only do cultural values drive the developments of these community energy projects, but evidence gathered here through qualitative interviews show that these communities aim to contribute towards the long term cultural sustainability of their respective areas. This research paper focuses on how community wind energy projects in Scotland and Wales have contributed towards the retention of cultural attributes, particularly language retention and revitalisation. It also contributes to a deeper understanding of the cultural reasons why historically indigenous communities are turning towards the renewable energy sector (and developing their own local projects) as a way to help achieve cultural sustainability through economic development.","author":["Haf, S.","Parkhill, K."],"organization":["Bangor University","University of York"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.035148600000","-3.999372500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/The-Muillean-Gaoithe-and-the-Melin-Wynt.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/988","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/when-tourists-meet-transmission-lines-effects-electric-transmission-lines-tourism","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629617302037","title":"When tourists meet transmission lines: The effects of electric transmission lines on tourism in Iceland","description":"The transition towards a low-carbon economy has led to a growing demand for renewable energy. However, while publics are often supportive of renewable energy they are often more critical of the infrastructure required to generate and distribute energy. Although transmission lines are necessary to carry renewable energy, they are often highly visible and frequently meet strong public opposition. This is especially true in areas with a high degree of perceived aesthetic naturalness, which are often valued landscapes for nature-based tourism. While nature-based tourism in Iceland has increased greatly, so also has energy production. There are plans for reinforcing the distribution system by building transmission lines in either existing areas or new locations, such as the relatively pristine Central Highlands. Due to tourism\u0027s economic importance, and the growing necessity for a stronger transmission system, it is imperative to identify tourists\u0027 opinions on transmission lines in natural areas. Attitudes were analysed by employing a questionnaire at seven locations where power plants are proposed. Results demonstrate that tourists are generally negative towards transmission lines, especially in the Highlands and consider them one of the least desirable infrastructures. Nevertheless, there is considerable variance between different markets, with opposition highest among domestic tourists.","author":["Hall, C.","Stef\u00e1nsson, P.","S\u00e6\u00fe\u00f3rsd\u00f3ttir, A."],"organization":["University of Iceland","University of Canterbury"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["64.990487500000","-19.970521100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Recreation \u0026 Tourism"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/989","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-sails-or-choppy-seas-people-place-relations-aesthetics-public-support-united","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618301956","title":"Wind in the sails or choppy seas?: People-place relations, aesthetics and public support for the United States\u0027 first offshore wind project","description":"The primary social challenge of offshore wind power development may be local community members\u2019 struggle to come to terms with the transformation of the ocean. In this study of local residents\u2019 perceptions of the first wind power project off the North American coast, we consider whether factors such as aesthetics and place attachment, dependency and identity might serve as barriers or gateways toward an offshore wind power future. Respondents are 420 coastal Rhode Island and Block Island residents who were randomly sampled by mail or internet prior to turbine installation and after project commissioning. Data were analysed using weighted descriptive statistics and multiple imputed regression analysis. 87% of respondents who live in census tracts bordering the coast support or lean toward supporting the project despite paying significantly above-market prices for the electricity generated. Regression models show that support for the project is influenced, at least in part, by general disposition toward wind power and whether a respondent likes the turbines\u2019 appearance, with place-related measures having less influence. Descriptions of the wind turbines that resonated with supporters and opponents include respectively, \u201cSymbolic of progress towards clean energy\u201d and \u201cCause the loss of something intangible, where all you see is the ocean\u201d.","author":["Firestone, J.","Bidwell, D.","Gardner, M.","Knapp, L."],"organization":["University of Delaware","University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.447532000000","-70.991288000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/990","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-power-gone-bad-critiquing-wind-power-planning-processes-northeastern-brazil","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629617304425","title":"Wind power gone bad: Critiquing wind power planning processes in northeastern Brazil","description":"Social and political opposition to wind power in North America and Europe has complex origins, but recent analyses emphasize exclusionary planning processes and human attachment to cultural and physical landscapes. In the global South, knowledge is far less developed regarding reasons for opposition to wind power. Physical and economic marginalization of affected people, whose lands may be appropriated for wind farms, from the positive benefits of renewable power is thought to motivate opposition. We analyze results of pilot research on the planning and licensing process and mitigation policies responding to negative impacts of a wind farm in Cear\u00e1 state, Brazil. The pilot work reveals flaws in siting wind farms and need for more careful approaches to mitigation policies. These preliminary findings suggest the need to modify policies and procedures governing Brazil\u2019s wind-power development and in locations elsewhere in the global South.","author":["Gorayeb, A.","Brannstrom, C.","Meireles, A.","Mendes, J."],"organization":["Universidade Federal do Cear\u00e1","Texas A\u0026M University"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-3.079350000000","-40.835157500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/991","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fragmented-authorities-institutional-misalignments-challenges-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618303815","title":"Fragmented authorities, institutional misalignments, and challenges to renewable energy transition: A case study of wind power curtailment in China","description":"To date, challenges to renewable energy transition have been discussed largely based on the cases and experiences from the Global North. In this paper, we aim at broadening our understanding of this specific socio-technical transition by incorporating the case of wind power development in China. Based on the analysis of policy and legal documents, we examine how institutions are organized and incentives are distributed among relevant stakeholders. We argue that China\u2019s significant wind curtailment problem has been produced and exacerbated by multiple axes of institutional misalignments stemming from China\u2019s fragmented energy bureaucracy. Through the study of the Chinese approach to renewable energy transition, our goal is to demonstrate the institutional plurality of socio-technical transition and the context specificity of its challenges.","author":["Cai, Y.","Aoyama, Y."],"organization":["Clark University"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.694296100000","103.777703000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/992","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/worldviews-predictors-wind-solar-energy-support-austria-bridging-social-acceptance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618302779","title":"Worldviews as predictors of wind and solar energy support in Austria: Bridging social acceptance and risk perception research","description":"With increasing demand for renewable energy, research focusing on social acceptance of production facilities has firmly established itself over the past decades. While the influence of worldviews on individuals\u2019 perceptions and behaviour has received widespread scholarly attention regarding a variety of related issues, social acceptance of renewable energy technologies (RET) has not been one of them. The study presented here addresses this shortcoming in the literature by examining the impact of various constructs, including worldviews, with respect to individuals\u2019 acceptance of RET in their vicinity. The study builds on a representative sample of Austrian citizens. Our findings suggest that RET belief is most strongly associated with acceptance regarding the construction of RET in participants\u2019 community. Further, we find that the more strongly participants feel about a variety of motives that generally support the use of renewable energies, the more accepting they are of local RET power plants. Regarding the effect of worldviews, we find that individuals who value the common good and equality are more supportive of RET in their vicinity. Our discussion focuses on the theoretical implications with particular attention to the results regarding the effect of worldviews.","author":["Sposato, R.","Hampl, N."],"organization":["Alpen-Adria-Universit\u00e4t Klagenfurt (University of Klagenfurt)","University of Vienna"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.626796900000","13.030498800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/993","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/korean-traditional-beliefs-renewable-energy-transitions-pungsu-shamanism-local","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618301385","title":"Korean traditional beliefs and renewable energy transitions: Pungsu, shamanism, and the local perception of wind turbines","description":"Wind farms are constructed in mountainous rural villages where indigenous elderly people believe in Korean traditional beliefs such as pungsu (fengshui or geomancy) thought and shamanism. Built upon mixed qualitative methods, this research examines the relationship between traditional beliefs and local opposition to wind farms. First, the interpretation of mountains and wind based on pungsu clashes with favorable discourses on wind turbines. From the pungsu viewpoint, the wind turbine is considered similar to the iron stakes driven into renowned Korean mountains by Japanese imperialists to block the national spirit of Korea during the Japanese colonial era. A straight, strong wind with high-energy efficiency for wind power generation is considered inauspicious in terms of pungsu. Second, pungsu in local opposition to wind farms is prominent in clan communities in mountainous inland areas with a high proportion of elderly people. Third, senses are associated with shamanism in shaping the elderly\u2019s perception of wind turbines. The noise and lights of wind turbines is a reminder of past memories related to ghosts or dokkaebi (a Korean goblin). Thus, pungsu and Korean shamanism present a unique story that is absent in Western debates on wind farms.","author":["Kim, E.","Chung, J.","Seo, Y."],"organization":["Kyung Hee University","Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology (UNIST)"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.505939500000","127.141893900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/994","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/integrated-offshore-grid-europe-exploring-challenges-regional-energy-governance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618304675","title":"The integrated offshore grid in Europe: Exploring challenges for regional energy governance","description":"The deployment of offshore wind and power transmission in the European North Sea is accelerating. Stakeholders advocate regional governance for the European grid expansion, which may evolve into a pan-European governance and is key to developing integrated, hybrid offshore projects. However, such projects are still scarce. We thus analyze the governance of the North Sea offshore grid expansion using the dimensions of level, implementation obligation, and implementation discretion. Our exploratory approach identifies five challenges. The challenges relate to 1) the interaction of the European and regional levels; 2) the interaction of the national and regional levels; 3) the participation of non-European Union countries; 4) the dependence of regional planning on national development plans, which consider national interests; and 5) the interaction of cost allocation and European financing for Projects of Common Interest. The recent Clean Energy Package proposal extensively reforms the regulation of the European power system. The Package is part of the Energy Union strategy and focuses on the energy and climate policies\u2019 governance and the power system operation. Thus, regional governance of offshore expansion is largely unaltered, and our identified challenges remain unaddressed.","author":["Dedecca, J.","Hakvoort, R.","Herder, P."],"organization":["Delft University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/The-integrated-offshore-grid-in-Europe.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/995","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/who-influences-windpower-licensing-decisions-norway-formal-requirements-informal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618306042","title":"Who influences windpower licensing decisions in Norway? Formal requirements and informal practices","description":"Licensing processes for renewable electricity plants have been surprisingly little studied. Yet, how public and private stakeholders influence the process, formally and informally, is crucial to the outcome of the licensing decision. This article analyses how the organisation of the Norwegian windpower licensing process affects actor influence, and the consequences for licensing outcomes as well as the transparency and predictability of the process. Drawing on licence application and decision documents, official regulations, policy documents and reports, as well as research papers, media articles and 19 interviews, we map and discuss formal rules and informal practices. Changes in regulations and organisation of the licensing process, along with locating the licensing body within a sector authority instead of generalised planning, have given the licensing body considerable room for decisional discretion. This gives rise to the issue of transparency, where the grounds for the licensing outcome and the weighting of various factors are unclear, and also makes it difficult to predict the results for similar projects. We argue that the superficial impression of a centrally driven and controlled process should be modified somewhat, as some local stakeholders have more influence on the licensing outcome than is immediately apparent.","author":["Inderberg, T.","Rognstad, H.","Saglie, I.","Gulbrandsen, L."],"organization":["Fridtjof Nansen Institute","Norwegian University of Life Sciences"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["62.654787100000","8.911603900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Who-influences-windpower-licensing-decisions-in-Norway.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/996","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-normal-politics-science-wind-power-planning-evidence-danish-near-shore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618310120","title":"The post-normal politics and science of wind power planning: Evidence from a Danish near-shore wind farm tender","description":"Post-normal science (PNS) has long advocated the inclusion of stakeholders in scientific processes where there is uncertainty, urgency and high stakes. Increasingly, however, such conditions have become recognised as the norm. Using the theoretical perspective of PNS, we examine the interactions between public objection, unstable coalition politics and uncertain environmental assessment knowledge to understand the case study of a Danish near-shore wind farm tender. In this case the original distinction made by PNS between facts, judgements, politics and science are confirmed as difficult to separate in what has been described as a condition of post-normal politics. The case, taking place within Denmark\u2019s relatively transparent and inclusive wind power governance system, offers insights into the challenges of managing long-term environmental and energy policy objectives. However the case also demonstrates the challenges to the policy prescriptions of PNS, specifically regarding the notion of extended peer review communities (EPCs). Here we propose that the de facto condition for energy siting controversies is one of multiple, often self-organised EPCs.","author":["Johansen, K.","Upham, P."],"organization":["Leuphana University of L\u00fcneburg","Utrecht University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.209707700000","9.295234800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/997","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hidden-outlaws-forest-legal-spatial-analysis-onshore-wind-energy-germany","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618312945","title":"Hidden outlaws in the forest? A legal and spatial analysis of onshore wind energy in Germany","description":"Onshore wind power has become one of the most important technologies for renewable electricity production throughout the world, with Germany being one of the global leaders. More than 27,000 wind turbines are currently spinning across Germany. Given the government\u2019s ambitious renewable energy targets, their numbers will continue to rise rapidly. It has now become technically and economically feasible to install wind turbines in forested areas. Our interdisciplinary analysis combines legal knowledge with spatial land use and wind power data to analyse the past development of wind farms in German forests and check whether the existing planning instruments successfully steer their spatial distribution. Our results reveal that, since 2011, a growing number of wind turbines are being installed in forests, even if they only account for 5.5% of the total number (8% of the total installed wind power capacity) and are almost exclusively limited to six of the 16 federal states. As there are no nationwide, uniform regulations governing wind turbines in forested areas, the federal states developed their own specific regulations. While some, especially those with high forest shares, generally permit wind farms in forests for reaching their renewable energy targets, others aim to keep their forests clear. So far, planning law and regional planning could successfully steer the hitherto comparatively slow expansion of wind energy in forest areas and ensure that windmills in forests are by no means \u201coutlaws\u201d.","author":["Eichhorn, M.","Bunzel, K.","Bovet, J.","Thran, D."],"organization":["Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ)"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.933184900000","8.807107400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/998","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/politics-evidence-conflicting-social-commitments-environmental-priorities-debate-over","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618309654","title":"The politics of evidence: Conflicting social commitments and environmental priorities in the debate over wind energy and public health","description":"The question of whether wind turbines cause a range of adverse health effects has emerged as a key issue in social controversies over wind farms and become a topic of debate in the scientific literature. We review the literature from the perspective of Science and Technology Studies (STS) to examine the experimental evidence and argumentative reasoning constituting three main explanations for how wind turbines impact health: 1) Exposure to infrasound directly causes adverse physiological effects, 2) Exposure to audible noise is associated with annoyance and sleep disturbance, and 3) Psychogenic factors act as mediators to adverse effects. In addition to technical and pragmatic arguments, the debate consists of value-based arguments about the desirability of wind energy, how precautionary development should be, what counts as a valid health issue in public policy, and what counts as valid evidence in health research. Thus, it encompasses the conflicting social commitments and environmental priorities of the wider wind energy debate and the politics of evidence in the health sciences. It suggests the controversy is unlikely to be settled by science but that an STS perspective can provide insights to foster governance that more effectively addresses the complexity of health issues in wind energy transitions.","author":["Taylor, J.","Klenk, N."],"organization":["University of Toronto"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/999","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/social-construction-risk-non-conventional-renewable-energy-risk-perception-function","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0921800917318013","title":"Social construction of risk in non-conventional renewable energy: Risk perception as a function of ecosystem services in La Araucan\u00eda, Chile","description":"The growth of renewable energy has been raised as a strategy to respond to the global demand to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. However, this type of energy infrastructure has faced local opposition that could be explained by the perceived risk associated with new energy technologies. Our research aims to understand how risk is socially constructed in relation to non-conventional renewable energy (NCRE) projects in Chile, considering ecosystem services (ES) as central. This research was carried out through a qualitative methodological framework, which involved the application of semi-structured interviews. The information was analysed based on a qualitative strategy of categorisation, combining the inductive and a-priori approaches to the definition of themes. Our results reveal that ecosystem services are a practical tool that can be applied in the social perception of risk to improve the management processes associated with NCRE projects. We provide an understanding of ES\u0027s role within the social amplification of risk theoretical framework. Our findings suggest that conflicts around NCRE projects would be linked to a reduction of an ES provision. These results contribute to understanding the function of ES in risk perception associated with the balance between supply and demand.","author":["Cordoves-S\u00e1nchez, M.","Vallejos-Romero, A."],"organization":["Universidad de La Frontera"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-38.608513100000","-73.298362600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1000","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-power-deployment-stressor-ecosystem-services-comparative-case-study-germany","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-96229-0_20","title":"Wind Power Deployment as a Stressor for Ecosystem Services: A Comparative Case Study from Germany and Sweden","description":"The ecological and social impacts of wind power plants affect the provision of ecosystem services in many ways, mainly with respect to cultural services as well as habitat provision. These challenges need to be considered when a proper institutional framework for the deployment of wind power is to be designed to mitigate trade-offs between different ecosystem services. Understanding how the current institutional framework affects the spatial allocation of wind turbines and the related impacts on ecosystem services is a first step towards this insight. Using the cases of Germany and Sweden, we show that both noninstitutional and institutional factors may have a significant impact on the distribution of wind turbines. Their relative importance varies with geographical and regulatory contexts.","author":["S\u00f6derholm, P.","Lauf, T.","Gawel, E.","Lehmann, P."],"organization":["Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ)","Lule\u00e5 University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1001","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidgen-power-system-commercialization-project-final-technical-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/servlets\/purl\/1115743","title":"TidGen Power System Commercialization Project Final Technical Report","description":"ORPC Maine, LLC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Ocean Renewable Power Company, LLC (collectively ORPC), submits this Final Technical Report for the TidGen\u00ae Power System Commercialization Project (Project), partially funded by the U.S. Department of Energy (DE-EE0003647). The Project was built and operated in compliance with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) pilot project license (P12711) and other permits and approvals needed for the Project. This report documents the methodologies, activities and results of the various phases of the Project, including design, engineering, procurement, assembly, installation, operation, licensing, environmental monitoring, retrieval, maintenance and repair. The Project represents a significant achievement for the renewable energy portfolio of the U.S. in general, and for the U.S. marine hydrokinetic (MHK) industry in particular.  The stated Project goal was to advance, demonstrate and accelerate deployment and commercialization of ORPC\u2019s tidal-current based hydrokinetic power generation system, including the energy extraction and conversion technology, associated power electronics, and interconnection equipment capable of reliably delivering electricity to the domestic power grid.  ORPC achieved this goal by designing, building and operating the TidGen\u00ae Power System in 2012 and becoming the first federally licensed hydrokinetic tidal energy project to deliver electricity to a power grid under a power purchase agreement in North America. Located in Cobscook Bay between Eastport and Lubec, Maine, the TidGen\u00ae Power System was connected to the Bangor Hydro Electric utility grid at an on-shore station in North Lubec on September 13, 2012. ORPC obtained a FERC pilot project license for the Project on February 12, 2012 and the first Maine Department of Environmental Protection General Permit issued for a tidal energy project on January 31, 2012. In addition, ORPC entered into a 20-year agreement with Bangor Hydro Electric Company on January 1, 2013 for up to 5 megawatts at a price of $215\/MWh, escalating at 2.0% per year.","author":["ORPC Maine"],"organization":["Ocean Renewable Power Company (ORPC)"],"originationDate":"2013-12-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.909800000000","-67.045630000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-22 03:55:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ORPC-2013-Technical-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1002","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/perspectives-environmental-ethics-sustainability-membrane-based-technologies-water","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2352186415000292","title":"Perspectives on environmental ethics in sustainability of membrane based technologies for water and energy production","description":"Securing a sustainable supply of water and energy is nowadays a key global issue. In the current practice of water and energy supply, there is still some gap in meeting the value criteria for sustainable development mainly related to environmental pollution as well as ecosystem disturbances. In this work, the sustainability of integrated membrane based processes for water and energy production is assessed with a special focus on environmental and ecosystem impacts. Feasibility of bridging the available gaps through process performance improvements is presented. Major environmental impacts from hybridmembrane based technologies for water and energy production are identified and considered for upstream balance of social benefits and burdens to the present and future generations. Ethical considerations were pointed mainly in the aspect of intergenerational justice (IRG-J) and ecological justice (EC-J) while setting value criteria for sustainability. The ethical significance of the identified impacts was predicted based on the associated difficulties to meet these criteria. The overall outcome will be beneficial in designing strategies for development and implementation of sustainable hybrid processes for clean water and energy production.","author":["Tufa, R."],"organization":["University of Calabria"],"originationDate":"2015-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Salinity Gradient"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Environmental Justice"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1003","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/power-salinity-gradients-australian-example","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S136403211500461X","title":"The power of salinity gradients: An Australian example","description":"The development and exploitation of sustainable and environmentally friendly energy sources are required in order to resolve global energy shortages and to reduce the reliance of many countries on fossil fuel combustion. Salinity gradient energy has been considered a potential candidate for renewable energy due to the abundance of saline waters that could be combined with less saline solutions across the globe. Pressure Retarded Osmosis (PRO) is one of the technologies to harness salinity gradient energy. Apart from zero carbon dioxide emission, PRO is capable of producing power with less periodicity, abundance and low environmental impacts. One of the preconditions for the technical and financial feasibility of PRO, however, is the development of a PRO-specific membrane\u2014one that meets the conditions that none of the current commercially-available membranes have met so far. The current paper discusses the progress made in PRO membrane development, particularly during the past decade, and analyses the challenges that are still hindering the implementation of PRO at large scales. Also, this paper explores possibilities for the implementation of PRO by analysing various combinations of existent solutions of various salt concentrations. Australia has been chosen to demonstrate some potential applications of PRO. This vast country has extensive reserves of saline waters that could be paired with less concentrated solutions to generate power. For each combination of solutions, a conceptual idea is presented, and an estimate of power production is given. Also, advantages and disadvantages of each scheme are discussed. The ideas and estimates can be easily extrapolated, with minor adjustments, to other countries with similar conditions. It is hoped that this publication will be valuable to those nations that have similar policies as Australia\u2019s, with government incentives for the development and implementation of new technologies to explore new renewable energy sources.","author":["Helfer, F.","Lemckert, C."],"organization":["Griffith University"],"originationDate":"2015-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Salinity Gradient"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1004","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/characterizing-first-wave-fish-invertebrate-colonization-new-offshore-petroleum","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article-abstract\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsz077\/5485757","title":"Characterizing the first wave of fish and invertebrate colonization on a new offshore petroleum platform","description":"Offshore Oil \u0026amp; Gas (O\u0026amp;G) infrastructure creates artificial reef complexes that support marine communities in oceans. No studies have characterized the first wave of colonization, which can reveal information about habitat attraction and ecological connectivity. Here we used opportunistically-collected industrial Remotely Operated Vehicles (ROVs) to investigate fish and invertebrate colonization on a new North Sea O\u0026amp;G platform and trenching of an associated pipeline. We observed rapid colonization of fish communities, with increases in species richness (S), abundance (N), and diversity (H\u2032) over the first four days (the entire study period). By contrast, there was minimal change in motile invertebrate communities over the survey period. After trenching, invertebrate S, N and H\u2032 decreased significantly, whilst fish S, N and H\u2032 increased. This study is the first to report on the pioneer wave of fish and invertebrate colonization on O\u0026amp;G infrastructure, thereby providing rare insight into formation of new reef communities in the sea. These short and opportunistic data are valuable in terms of showing what can be discovered from analysis of \u2018pre-installation\u2019 ROV footage of O\u0026amp;G structures, of which there are terabytes of data held by O\u0026amp;G companies waiting to be analyzed by environmental scientists.","author":["Todd, V.","Cox, S.","Macreadie, P.","Williamson, L.","Todd, I."],"organization":["Solent University","Ocean Science Consulting","Deakin University"],"originationDate":"2020-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1005","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/three-dimensional-underwater-sound-propagation-model-offshore-wind-farm-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.5099560","title":"A three-dimensional underwater sound propagation model for offshore wind farm noise prediction","description":"A three-dimensional underwater sound propagation model with realistic ocean environmental conditions has been created for assessing the impacts of noise from offshore wind farm construction and operation. This model utilizes an existing accurate numerical solution scheme to solve the three-dimensional Helmholtz wave equation, and it is compared and validated with acoustic transmission data between 750 and 1250\u2009Hz collected during the development of the Block Island Wind Farm (BIWF), Rhode Island. The variability of underwater sound propagation conditions has been investigated in the BIWF area on a temporal scale of months and a spatial scale of kilometers. This study suggests that future offshore wind farm developments can exploit the seasonal variability of underwater sound propagation for mitigating noise impact by scheduling wind farm construction during periods of high acoustic transmission loss. Discussions on other applications of soundscape prediction, planning, and management are provided.","author":["Potty, G.","Miller, J.","Lin, Y.","Newhall, A.","Vigness-Raposa, K."],"organization":["Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution","University of Rhode Island","Marine Acoustics Inc"],"originationDate":"2019-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.233379000000","-71.482624000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lin-2019-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1006","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/contingent-valuation-study-wind-farm-burfellslundur-willingness-pay-preservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0959652618331731","title":"The contingent valuation study of the wind farm B\u00farfellslundur - Willingness to pay for preservation","description":"Following the success of two trial\u00a0wind turbines, the national\u00a0power company\u00a0of\u00a0Iceland, Landsvirkjun, proposed a\u00a0wind farm\u00a0at B\u00farfellslundur on the edge of the Icelandic\u00a0highlands. The farm would comprise of 67\u00a0turbines\u00a0with combined production capacity of 200\u202fMW. The\u00a0Environmental Impact Assessment\u00a0for the development raised concerns about the visual impacts of the\u00a0proposals\u00a0on the surrounding countryside. In this study, the contingent\u00a0valuation\u00a0method was applied to evaluate preferences and estimate willingness to pay to preserve B\u00farfellslundur. This study represents only the third contribution in the international academic literature concerning the\u00a0economic\u00a0value of the\u00a0environmental costs\u00a0of developing wind farms, and the first focused on onshore resources. In addition, this paper fulfills a call by the\u00a0OECD, who have requested that Iceland commence economic valuation of the environmental impacts of\u00a0energy projects. A web-based\u00a0contingent valuation\u00a0survey was developed and issued by the University of Iceland\u0027s Social Science Research Institute, receiving 690 respondents. Of these, 28% were willing to pay for preservation. Interval\u00a0regression\u00a0using log-transformation was applied to estimate mean willingness-to-pay, which was 12,549 ISK (approximately US $128). When scaled up to the Icelandic population of taxpayers, the economic value of preserving B\u00farfellslundur was estimated to be 3.17 billion ISK (approximately US $32.3 million). These results are of a scale that could have a significant impact on the\u00a0social welfare\u00a0gains or losses associated with B\u00farfellslundur, and inform the international\u00a0land-use\u00a0management\u00a0debate concerning the trade-offs of developing wind farms.","author":["Einarsd\u00f3ttir, S.","Cook, D.","Dav\u00ed\u00f0sd\u00f3ttir, B."],"organization":["University of Iceland"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["64.080171000000","-19.820621000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1007","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-environmental-impacts-wind-energy-technologies-review-simplified-models","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032119303259","title":"Life cycle environmental impacts of wind energy technologies: A review of simplified models and harmonization of the results","description":"Nowadays, wind energy is taking on primary role within renewable energies scenario. However, impact of wind energy industry on the environment still requires to be fully understood and better quantified. This study provides an updated review of Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) studies of electricity produced from onshore and offshore wind turbines (WTs). Special emphasis is put on results harmonization and simplified LCA models existing in the literature. The synthesis of the results is performed for wide range of WTs capacities, providing an exhaustive and general frame of the environmental impacts of WTs systems. Moreover, new simplified LCA models, which make use of a non-linear regression, were developed in this work for the following impact categories: Acidification Potential (AP), Eutrophication Potential (EP), Global Warming Potential (GWP) and Cumulative Energy Demand (CED) and for onshore (1\u20135000\u202fkW) and offshore (500\u20138000\u202fkW) WTs. Nonlinear data fitting models are provided with a sufficiently high correlation coefficient for total life cycle impacts. Moreover, the proposed simplified LCA models predict the final results with acceptable uncertainty. This indicates that the one-term power series describes the behavior of the impact indicators accurately, providing a useful correlation to estimate the life cycle environmental performance for a specific turbine model with a given nominal power. Furthermore, obtained simplified LCA models were generalized for different site-specific wind conditions, i.e. wind speeds and wind classes. By analyzing all the considered impact indicators for electricity generation, we notice that the highest values of life cycle impacts of electricity, for a particular WT correspond to the highest wind velocities. This is particularly valid for low nominal power turbines, which seem to be significantly affected by wind conditions. The trends exhibit an asymptotic behavior, indicating that, on the contrary, wind conditions are a minor contributor to the environmental impact of large-scale systems.","author":["Mendecka, B.","Lombardi, L."],"organization":["University of Florence","Niccol\u00f2 Cusano University (Universit\u00e0 degli Studi Niccol\u00f2 Cusano)"],"originationDate":"2019-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1008","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/combined-exploitation-offshore-wind-wave-energy-italian-seas-spatial-planning-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fenrg.2019.00042\/full","title":"Combined Exploitation of Offshore Wind and Wave Energy in the Italian Seas: A Spatial Planning Approach","description":"The opportunity to co-locate wind and wave energy exploitation is analyzed in the Italian seas grounding on the rationale that benefits are greater when un-correlated resources are combined. The study shows that, although waves and winds are generally strongly correlated, in some conditions their correlation is lower and the combined energy harvesting more interesting. As spatial conflicts of sea use and demand for maritime space are increasing, the development of the marine renewable energy sector needs to be evaluated in the perspective of the cumulative pressures deriving from present activities or expected from future developments. The evaluation of areas of potential conflicts among human activities, environmental vulnerabilities and marine renewable developments may facilitate the early development of mitigation actions and negotiations between stakeholders. In this study the opportunity of co-locating offshore wind turbines and wave energy converters is analyzed through a spatial planning approach. Both the potential for combining different renewable technologies, and the impact associated to such development was considered in the context of the existing pressures (e.g., naval traffic; mariculture activities; submarine cables routes; dredge spoils dumping; offshore activities; windfarms and ocean energy projects) and vulnerabilities (Marine Protected Areas, Key habitat presence) through quantitative indicators. The portion of Tyrrhenian coast south of Elba island, the northern-western Sardinian coast, and the southern Adriatic and Ionian coastal waters appear to be the most suitable sites. Moreover, the study presents a spatial quantitative methodology to identify sites of potential interest for the development of the marine renewable energy sector in the perspective of cost-effectiveness and environmental impact minimization.","author":["Azzellino, A.","Vicinanza, D.","Lanfredi, C.","Riefolo, L.","Contestabile, P.","De Santis, V."],"organization":["Polytechnic University of Milan","University of Campania Luigi Vanvitelli"],"originationDate":"2019-04-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.872285000000","13.181640000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Azzellino-2019-Colocation.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1009","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/minimizing-wildlife-impacts-offshore-wind-energy-development-winning-tradeoffs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0215722","title":"Minimizing wildlife impacts for offshore wind energy development: Winning tradeoffs for seabirds in space and cetaceans in time","description":"Although offshore wind energy development (OWED) offers a much-needed renewable energy alternative to fossil fuels, holistic and effective methods for evaluating environmental impacts on wildlife in both space and time have been lacking. The lengthy environmental compliance process, estimated to incur a 7\u201310 year permitting timeline [1], has been identified as a significant impediment to offshore energy development in U.S. waters. During operation, seabirds can collide and be displaced by turbines. During episodic pre-operation phases, cetaceans are most heavily impacted acoustically by pile driving (and similarly seismic air gun surveys for oil and gas exploration). The varying nature of impacts in space and time leads us to conclude that sites should be selected in space to minimize long-term operational impacts on seabirds, and timing of surveying and construction activities to be conducted in times of the year when sensitive migratory marine mammals are least present. We developed a novel spatiotemporal decision support framework that interactively visualizes tradeoffs between OWED industry profits and wildlife sensitivities, in both space and time. The framework highlights sites on a map that are the most profitable and least sensitive to seabirds. Within the U.S. Mid-Atlantic study area, the New York Call Areas are particularly well optimized for minimal impact on seabirds with maximal profits to OWED. For a given site, pre-operational activities (e.g. pile driving and seismic air gun surveying) are advised by cetacean sensitivity across months of the year that minimize impacts on migratory cetaceans, particularly those of highest conservation concern such as the North Atlantic right whale (Eubalaena Glacialis). For instance, within optimal sites for the New York Call Area the least impacting months are May and June. Other taxa are certainly affected by OWED and should be incorporated into this framework, but data on their distributions and\/or sensitivities is currently less well known. Built with open-source software made publicly available, the authors hope this framework will be extended even more comprehensively into the future as our knowledge on species distributions and OWED sensitivities expands for streamlining environmental compliance.","author":["Halpin, P.","Best, B."],"organization":["Duke University"],"originationDate":"2019-05-14","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Collision","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-02-14 02:10:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Best-2019-Minimizing-Impacts.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1010","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/characterizing-benthic-community-marylands-offshore-wind-energy-areas-using-towed","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0215966","title":"Characterizing the benthic community in Maryland\u0027s offshore wind energy areas using a towed camera sled: Developing a method to reduce the effort of image analysis and community description","description":"Offshore wind farms are a crucial component for the improvement of renewable energy in the United States. The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) designated ~170 km2 of shelf area for wind energy development off the coast of Maryland, USA. In order to understand potential environmental impacts of wind turbine installation on the benthic ecosystem within the designated area, we conducted a study to visually characterize bottom habitats and epibenthic communities in the Mid-Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf blocks of the Maryland wind energy area. Seven 5 km long transects were sampled using a towed camera sled with a downward-facing digital camera that captured images at 5 frames\u00b7s-1s. Additional small-mesh beam trawling was also conducted at selected locations complementary for species identification. Image data were analyzed using two image selection methods, random and systematic (i.e. video frames were selected at various intervals). For both methods, estimates of community diversity (Hill\u2019s N2) stabilized with sample sizes ranging from 316 to 398 frames. Our results allowed us to define distinct epibenthic communities and bottom habitats that are associated with offshore wind energy sites and to develop a sampling technique for digital images that can be applied to other research programs.","author":["Cruz-Marrero, W.","Cullen, D.","Gay, N.","Stevens, B."],"organization":["University of Maryland","Lawrence University"],"originationDate":"2019-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.302841000000","-74.818068000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1011","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/artificial-reefs-facilitate-tropical-fish-their-range-edge","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s42003-019-0398-2","title":"Artificial reefs facilitate tropical fish at their range edge","description":"Spatial planning increasingly incorporates theoretical predictions that artificial habitats assist species movement at or beyond range edges, yet evidence for this is uncommon. We conducted surveys of highly mobile fauna (fishes) on artificial habitats (reefs) on the southeastern USA continental shelf to test whether, in comparison to natural reefs, artificial reefs enhance local abundance and biomass of fishes at their poleward range margins. Here, we show that while temperate fishes were more abundant on natural reefs, tropical, and subtropical fishes exhibited higher abundances and biomasses on deep (25\u201335\u2009m) artificial reefs. Further analyses reveal that this effect depended on feeding guilds because planktivorous and piscivorous but not herbivorous fishes were more abundant on artificial reefs. This is potentially due to heightened prey availability on and structural complexity of artificial reefs. Our findings demonstrate that artificial habitats can facilitate highly mobile species at range edges and suggest these habitats assist poleward species movement.","author":["Peterson, C.","Taylor, J.","Paxton, A.","Adler, A.","Pickering, E.","Silliman, B."],"organization":["University of North Carolina","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","Duke University"],"originationDate":"2019-05-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.599121000000","-77.201854000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Paxton-2019-Artificial-Reefs.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1012","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/overview-trends-ecological-socioeconomic-research-artificial-reefs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113618307888","title":"Overview and trends of ecological and socioeconomic research on artificial reefs","description":"It is presented a systematic\u00a0literature\u00a0review of\u00a0artificial reef\u00a0research, including 620 studies throughout the world from 1962 to 2018. The primary focus of this study was to examine\u00a0long-term trends\u00a0in research, focusing on ecological and\u00a0socioeconomic\u00a0questions, and to develop new research directions for this\u00a0field. From 1962 to the beginning of the 1990s, the\u00a0United States\u00a0and Japan were the main centers of\u00a0artificial reef\u00a0research. Subsequently, researchers in several other countries (particularly China,\u00a0Australia,\u00a0Italy,\u00a0Brazil, and the United Kingdom) began to focus on this subject, resulting in an increase in the number of artificial reef studies. In general,\u00a0publications\u00a0about artificial reefs have concentrated on investigating the structure of populations and marine communities and evaluating new technical\u00a0designs\u00a0and materials to construct artificial\u00a0habitats. The science of artificial reefs is responding to new challenges with an increase in more elaborate techniques, such as the use of remotely-operated\u00a0submarines, organic indicators,\u00a0isotopes, and\u00a0molecular biology, while research that evaluates the\u00a0socioeconomic\u00a0aspects of artificial reefs is lacking. There are many aspects that deserve more research attention, such as the use of alternative inert materials,\u00a0environmental impact\u00a0assessment and\u00a0mitigation, and analysis of\u00a0conflicts\u00a0with affected\u00a0fisheries\u00a0communities. The greater challenge is to overcome the apparent division between theory vs. application and to include robust\u00a0management\u00a0models\u00a0of these artificial environments.","author":["Love, M.","Lima, J.","Zalmon, I."],"organization":["State University of Northern Rio de Janeiro","University of California Santa Barbara"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1013","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-occurrence-inter-colony-segregation-seabird-foraging-areas-implications-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/ibi.12677","title":"A review of the occurrence of inter-colony segregation of seabird foraging areas and the implications for marine environmental impact assessment","description":"Understanding the determinants of species\u2019 distributions is a fundamental aim in ecology and a prerequisite for conservation but is particularly challenging in the marine environment. Advances in bio\u2010logging technology have resulted in a rapid increase in studies of seabird movement and distribution in recent years. Multi\u2010colony studies examining the effects of intra\u2010 and inter\u2010colony competition on distribution have found that several species exhibit inter\u2010colony segregation of foraging areas, rather than overlapping distributions. These findings are timely given the increasing rate of human exploitation of marine resources and the need to make robust assessments of likely impacts of proposed marine developments on biodiversity. Here we review the occurrence of foraging area segregation reported by published tracking studies in relation to the density\u2010dependent hinterland (DDH) model, which predicts that segregation occurs in response to inter\u2010colony competition, itself a function of colony size, distance from the colony and prey distribution. We found that inter\u2010colony foraging area segregation occurred in 79% of 39 studies. The frequency of occurrence was similar across the four seabird orders for which data were available, and included species with both smaller (10\u2013100\u00a0km) and larger (100\u20131000\u00a0km) foraging ranges. Many predictions of the DDH model were confirmed, with examples of segregation in response to high levels of inter\u2010colony competition related to colony size and proximity, and enclosed landform restricting the extent of available habitat. Moreover, as predicted by the DDH model, inter\u2010colony overlap tended to occur where birds aggregated in highly productive areas, often remote from all colonies. The apparent prevalence of inter\u2010colony foraging segregation has important implications for assessment of impacts of marine development on protected seabird colonies. If a development area is accessible from multiple colonies, it may impact those colonies much more asymmetrically than previously supposed. Current impact assessment approaches that do not consider spatial inter\u2010colony segregation will therefore be subject to error. We recommend the collection of tracking data from multiple colonies and modelling of inter\u2010colony interactions to predict colony\u2010specific distributions.","author":["Caldow, R.","Bolton, M.","Wakefield, E.","Carroll, M.","Conolly, G."],"organization":["Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)","Natural England","University of Glasgow"],"originationDate":"2018-10-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1014","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/positive-ecological-effects-wind-farms-vegetation-chinas-gobi-desert","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41598-019-42569-0","title":"Positive ecological effects of wind farms on vegetation in China\u0027s Gobi desert","description":"With the rapid development of wind power, there are increasing concerns about the negative ecological effects of its construction and operation. However, previous studies have mainly focused on the effects of wind farms on fying fauna (i.e., birds and bats) or climate change separately from communities or ecosystems, and little attention has been paid to vegetation during wind farm operation. Furthermore, few studies have referred to vulnerable ecosystems with low biomass and biodiversity. In this research, a feld study was conducted to investigate the effects of wind farms on the individual traits, community structures and ecosystem functions of Gobi Desert ecosystems. The effects were measured by comparing interfering areas (IAs, located between 40m and 90m in the downstream direction of the wind turbine) with non-interfering areas (NIAs, located over 200m from the wind turbine matrixes). The results showed that (1) plant individuals in IAs were less stressed and in better physiological states than those in NIAs; (2) for community structures, IA plants tended to be shorter and denser and had a higher coverage condition than that of NIA plants; and (3) ecosystem functions in IAs were signifcantly improved due to the existence of shrubs and higher biomass. Meanwhile, signifcant correlations were identifed between the wind wake caused by the large spinning blades and the community structures. Constructing wind turbines in the Gobi Desert is a win-win strategy that both contributes to the growth of desert vegetation with a favourable microclimate and sufciently utilizes wind power to produce clean energy.","author":["Wang, Z.","Li, Y.","Wang, G.","Khan, A.","Xu, K.","He, L.","Hu, H.","Liu, S.","Du, Y.","Li, L."],"organization":["Zhejiang University"],"originationDate":"2019-04-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["23.186660000000","113.261103000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Xu-2019-Positive-ecological-effects.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1015","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-arrays-wave-energy-converters-nearshore-wave-climate","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0029801818321140","title":"The effect of arrays of wave energy converters on the nearshore wave climate","description":"The\u00a0exploitation\u00a0of\u00a0wave energy\u00a0using arrays of wave\u00a0energy converters\u00a0(WEC), which contain a\u00a0large number\u00a0of devices, could have significant impact on the\u00a0wave climate in the nearshore region. This research investigates the impact of WEC arrays at the Westwave demonstration commercial site, which is located on the West coast of\u00a0Ireland. The methodology involves the determination of an appropriate\u00a0transmission coefficient\u00a0(Ct) from a\u00a0computational fluid dynamic\u00a0(CFD) model of a numerical wave tank (NWT) simulation using ANSYS CFX and the subsequent implementation of WEC arrays using SWAN (Version 41.01). Within this analysis, the\u00a0Ct value\u00a0from the\u00a0CFD\u00a0NWT model was used in SWAN to represent WEC arrays which are treated as obstacles. Hence, a nested local\u00a0wave model\u00a0at the Westwave site have been developed and validated for the period of December 2015 in order to accommodate the simulation of WEC arrays. Three\u00a0array configurations, which contain 12 WECs (single row, two row arrays and three row arrays), have been simulated and analysed to estimate the impact to the wave conditions at the nearshore area, while also considering the effect of array configuration on power captured. The results of the analysis suggest there is minor impact on the nearshore wave climate for all the scenarios, where the\u00a0reduction\u00a0in\u00a0wave height\u00a0and\u00a0wave power\u00a0was below 1% at a distance of between 1 and 3\u00a0km from the\u00a0shoreline\u00a0(at water depths varying from 20 to 60\u00a0m). At a distance of 100\u2013300\u00a0m from the shoreline (at a\u00a0water depth of\u00a0approximately 10\u00a0m and below), a decrease in\u00a0wave height\u00a0and\u00a0wave power\u00a0of 0.1% and 0.2%, respectively, was observed. In addition, the methodology can also be applied to other types of WEC and study areas depending on the purpose of the project.","author":["Nash, S.","Atan, R.","Finnegan, W.","Goggins, J."],"organization":["NUI Galway"],"originationDate":"2019-01-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.112263300000","-9.426747900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1016","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/critical-challenges-capacity-building-needs-renewable-energy-deployment-pacific-small","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117300290","title":"Critical challenges and capacity building needs for renewable energy deployment in Pacific Small Island Developing States (Pacific SIDS)","description":"The Pacific Small Island Developing States (SIDS) are among the most vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. Besides, they are some of the most dependent on imported petroleum products in the world, the use of renewable energy (RE) can help minimize the economic risk associated with the price volatility of fossil fuels. The region is increasingly adopting renewable energy (RE) targets and policies. Successful examples of RE deployment in the Pacific SIDS exist; however, many barriers persist and prevent the use of the region\u2019s RE resources in a larger scale. Challenges for RE deployment in islands can be grouped in six categories: i) lack of RE data, ii) need for policy and regulatory frameworks, iii) scarcity of financial opportunities, iv) lack of human resources, v) costly infrastructure, and vi) socio-cultural impediments. Based on a survey conducted among main stakeholders in the region, within the framework of the Pacific Region Capacity Building Initiative of the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) carried out in cooperation with the Secretariat of the Pacific Community (SPC), this paper identifies the specific characteristics of these challenges in the context of the Pacific SIDS, provide a qualitative assessment and identifies recommendations to overcome these challenges.","author":["Lucas, H.","Talab, I.","Marschel, C.","Cabeza, L."],"organization":["York University"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1017","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comprehensive-life-cycle-assessment-large-wind-turbines-us","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10098-019-01678-0","title":"Comprehensive life cycle assessment of large wind turbines in the US","description":"The goal of this study was to conduct a comprehensive life cycle assessment (LCA) for large onshore wind turbines in the US, including all phases of the turbine\u2019s life cycle separately (materials acquisition, manufacturing, transportation, installation, operation and maintenance, and end of life) and multiple impact categories (environmental, human health, resource consumption). Particular attention was given to make the installation and maintenance phases complete and transparent. The contribution of this study is that it is the first comprehensive LCA for large wind turbines in the US, where different transport distances (including overseas transport of turbine parts), truck emission standards, mixes of electricity sources, and waste disposal practices will affect impacts, compared to those conducted for other countries. It is also the first comprehensive LCA to examine separately all 6 phases of the turbine\u2019s life cycle (in particular separating manufacturing from raw material acquisition\/installation) and the first to evaluate turbine lifespan as a sensitivity parameter. The study was conducted for 200 Gamesa 2-MW wind turbines located near Abilene, Texas. SimaPro8 software was used for modeling, according to ISO 14040 standards. The manufacturing phase contributed the greatest overall impacts, which was consistent with other studies; hence, alternative methods of manufacturing should be explored to reduce impacts. Installation, transportation, maintenance, and raw materials acquisition ranked second through fifth, respectively. Consistent with other studies, end-of-life ranked last, which means that the disposal method (landfilling or combustion) for turbine parts which are not recycled makes little difference in terms of the overall turbine life cycle.","author":["Alsaleh, A.","Sattler, M."],"organization":["University of Texas"],"originationDate":"2019-02-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1018","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/past-present-future-environmental-footprint-danish-wind-turbine-fleet-lcawinddk-online","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032119301704","title":"Past, present and future environmental footprint of the Danish wind turbine fleet with LCA_WIND_DK, an online interactive platform","description":"Renewable energy\u00a0systems are promoted and developed notably due to their low\u00a0environmental footprint. Fleet-wide robust\u00a0environmental assessmentsare needed to drive the sustainable transition of energy systems worldwide. This study introduces a tailored comprehensive impact assessment methodology for fleets of renewable energy systems based on\u00a0Life Cycle Analysis\u00a0and its application to Danish\u00a0wind turbines\u00a0fleet through an online platform LCA_WIND_DK (viewer.webservice-energy.org\/lca-wind-dk\/). This platform enables to visualize\u00a0environmental performances\u00a0of wind turbines in Denmark and their\u00a0temporal evolution. The fleet is known in detail from 1980 to 2016 and projected from 2017 to 2030 based on national objectives for onshore\/offshore capacity and pre-approved offshore projects. Each\u00a0turbine\u0027sfuture\u00a0electricity production\u00a0is estimated from its\u00a0power curve\u00a0and geo-localized wind time-series. More than 10,000 cradle-to-grave\u00a0life cycle inventories\u00a0are generated, considering the spatio-temporal context and technological characteristics. The comprehensive analysis of the Danish fleet over fifty years reveals long-term trends for several\u00a0impact categories. Improvements in all categories follow similar trends as in\u00a0climate change, which decreases from 40 to 13\u202fg CO2-eq\/kWh between 1980 and 2030. Improvements stem from combined economies of\u00a0scale and higher loadfactors linked to increasingly large and powerful turbines. The interactive mapping tool LCA_WIND_DK may provide statistics to support renewable energy oriented policy scenarios and unique spatio-temporal environmental information to project developers. This novel approach designed for large territories, here applied to the Danish wind turbine fleet, is generic and can be applied to other renewable energy systems and\/or to other territories.","author":["Blanc, I.","Besseau, R.","Sacchi, R.","P\u00e9rez-L\u00f3pez, P."],"organization":["MINES ParisTech","Aalborg University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.209707000000","9.295234800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1019","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/low-frequency-acoustic-pressure-velocity-intensity-thresholds-bottlenose-dolphin","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.1423925","title":"Low-frequency acoustic pressure, velocity, and intensity thresholds in a bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) and white whale (Delphinapterus leucas)","description":"The relative contributions of\u00a0acoustic pressure\u00a0and\u00a0particle velocity\u00a0to the low-frequency, underwater\u00a0hearing\u00a0abilities of the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus) and white whale (Delphinapterus leucas) were investigated by\u00a0measuring(masked)\u00a0hearing\u00a0thresholds while manipulating the relationship between the\u00a0pressure\u00a0and\u00a0velocity.\u00a0This was accomplished by varying the distance within the near field of a single\u00a0underwater sound\u00a0projector (experiment I) and using two\u00a0underwater sound\u00a0projectors and an active\u00a0soundcontrol system\u00a0(experiment II). The results of experiment I showed no significant change in\u00a0pressure\u00a0thresholds as the distance between the subject and the\u00a0sound\u00a0source was changed. In contrast,\u00a0velocity\u00a0thresholds tended to increase and intensity thresholds tended to decrease as the source distance decreased. These data suggest that\u00a0acoustic pressure\u00a0is a better indicator of threshold, compared to\u00a0particle velocity\u00a0or mean active intensity, in the subjects tested. Interpretation of the results of experiment II (the active\u00a0sound\u00a0control system)\u00a0was difficult because of complex acoustic conditions and the unknown effects of the subject on the generated acoustic field; however, these data also tend to support the results of experiment I and suggest that odontocete thresholds should be reported in units of\u00a0acoustic pressure,\u00a0rather than intensity.","author":["Finneran, J.","Ridgway, S.","Carder, D."],"organization":["Space and Naval Warfare Systems Center"],"originationDate":"2002-01-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.708748000000","-117.247421000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1020","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ship-noise-cortisol-secretion-european-freshwater-fishes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320705004350","title":"Ship noise and cortisol secretion in European freshwater fishes","description":"Underwater noise pollution is a growing problem in aquatic environments and as such may be a major source of stress for fish. In the present study, we addressed the effects of ship noise and continuous Gaussian noise on adrenal activity in three European freshwater species. Underwater ship noise recorded in the Danube River and two Austrian lakes was played back to fish at levels encountered in the field (153\u00a0dB re 1\u00a0\u03bcPa, 30\u00a0min). Post exposure cortisol secretion was compared with control situations. Cortisol was measured with enzyme immunoassay techniques (EIA, ng cortisol\/l water\/g fish) in extracted aquarium water with corrections for fish mass. In the first series, two hearing specialists, the common carp (Cyprinus carpio) and the gudgeon (Gobio gobio) and one hearing generalist, the European perch (Perca fluviatilis) were exposed to ship noise. The noise level was well above hearing thresholds in these species. In a second series, fish were exposed to continuous Gaussian noise at a similar level (156\u00a0dB) which is known to induce temporary hearing loss in hearing specialists. All three species responded with increased cortisol secretion when exposed to ship noise. Interestingly, no elevation was observed when fish were exposed to continuous Gaussian noise. Our results indicate that ship noise characterized by amplitude and frequency fluctuations, constitutes a potential stressor in contrast to continuous noise. Surprisingly, the data also demonstrate no apparent differences between species possessing excellent hearing abilities (hearing specialists) and species with poor hearing abilities like perch.","author":["Wysocki, L.","Ladich, F.","Dittami, J."],"organization":["University of Vienna"],"originationDate":"2006-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1021","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-air-bubble-curtain-reduce-underwater-noise-percussive-piling","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113699000501","title":"Development of an air bubble curtain to reduce underwater noise of percussive piling","description":"Underwater bubbles can inhibit sound transmission through water due to density mismatch and concomitant reflection and absorption of sound waves. For the present study, a perforated rubber hose was used to produce a bubble curtain, or screen, around pile-driving activity in 6\u20138-m depth waters of western Hong Kong. The percussive hammer blow sounds of the pile driver were measured on 2 days at distances of 250, 500, and 1000 m; broadband pulse levels were reduced by 3\u20135 dB by the bubble curtain. Sound intensities were measured from 100 Hz to 25.6 kHz, and greatest sound reduction by the bubble curtain was evident from 400 to 6400 Hz. Indo-Pacific hump-backed dolphins (Sousa chinensis) occurred in the immediate area of the industrial activity before and during pile driving, but with a lower abundance immediately after it. While hump-backed dolphins generally showed no overt behavioral changes with and without pile driving, their speeds of travel increased during pile driving, indicating that bubble screening did not eliminate all behavioral responses to the loud noise. Because the bubble curtain effectively lowered sound levels within 1 km of the activity, the experiment and its application during construction represented a success, and this measure should be considered for other appropriate areas with high industrial noises and resident or migrating sound-sensitive animals.","author":["Jefferson, T.","Greene, C.","W\u00fcrsig, B."],"organization":["Texas A\u0026M University","Greeneridge Science Inc."],"originationDate":"2000-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["22.235608000000","114.172041000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1022","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-underwater-noise-auditory-sensitivity-cyprinid-fish","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378595500002136","title":"Effects of underwater noise on auditory sensitivity of a cyprinid fish","description":"The ability of a fish to interpret acoustic information in its environment is crucial for its survival. Thus, it is important to understand how underwater noise affects fish hearing. In this study, the fathead minnow (Pimephales promelas) was used to examine: (1) the immediate effects of white noise exposure (0.3\u20134.0 kHz, 142 dB re: 1 \u03bcPa) on auditory thresholds and (2) recovery after exposure. Audiograms were measured using the\u00a0auditory brainstem response\u00a0protocol and compared to baseline audiograms of fathead minnows not exposed to noise. Immediately after exposure to 24 h of white noise, five out of the eight frequencies tested showed a significantly higher threshold compared to the baseline fish. Recovery was found to depend on both duration of noise exposure and auditory frequency. These results support the hypothesis that the auditory threshold of the fathead minnow can be altered by white noise, especially in its most sensitive hearing range (0.8\u20132.0 kHz), and provide evidence that these effects can be long term (\u003E14 days).","author":["Scholik, A.","Yan, H."],"organization":["University of Kentucky"],"originationDate":"2001-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.030423000000","-84.504077000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1023","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/anthropogenic-sound-effects-behavior-physiology-fishes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/content\/mts\/mtsj\/2003\/00000037\/00000004\/art00004","title":"Anthropogenic Sound: Effects on the Behavior and Physiology of Fishes","description":"Anthropogenic sound in the marine environment continues to increase. Sound sources range from increased vessel traffic to transient but intense sounds such as those produced by seismic air guns, pile driving, or some sonars. While most interest in anthropogenic sounds has focused on marine mammals, there is an increasing concern regarding the impact of such sounds on fishes and marine invertebrates. Since the inner ear hearing receptors of fishes are similar to those of marine mammals, any effects seen on the hearing receptors of marine mammals may also be found in fishes and\u00a0vice versa. Despite increasing interest in the effects of sounds on fishes, this issue has only been addressed on the most limited scale. Here we review the current literature in this area. It has been reported that high sound levels can damage the inner ear sensory cells, produce hearing loss (threshold shifts), elicit stress responses, and alter the behavior of fishes. At least in terms of hearing loss, these effects are modulated by exposure sound level and duration. The effects of various types of sound (e.g., impulsive vs. continuous) and long-term impacts of how anthropogenic sounds affect the behavior and ecology of fishes need exploration in the future.","author":["Popper, A.","Smith, M.","McCauley, R.","Fewtrell, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2003-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1024","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/short-long-term-changes-right-whale-calling-behavior-potential-effects-noise-acoustic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.2799904","title":"Short- and long-term changes in right whale calling behavior: The potential effects of noise on acoustic communication","description":"The\u00a0impact\u00a0of anthropogenic\u00a0noise\u00a0on marine mammals has been an area of increasing concern over the past two decades. Most low-frequency anthropogenic\u00a0noise\u00a0in the\u00a0ocean\u00a0comes from commercial shipping which has contributed to an increase in\u00a0ocean\u00a0background\u00a0noise\u00a0over the past 150 years. The long-term\u00a0impacts\u00a0of these changes on marine mammals are not well understood. This paper describes both short- and long-term behavioral changes in calls produced by the\u00a0endangered\u00a0North Atlantic right whale (Eubalaena glacialis) and South Atlantic right whale (Eubalaena australis) in the presence of increased low-frequency\u00a0noise.\u00a0Right whales produce calls with a higher average fundamental frequency and they call at a lower rate in high\u00a0noise\u00a0conditions, possibly in response to masking from low-frequency\u00a0noise.\u00a0The long-term changes have occurred within the known lifespan of individual whales, indicating that a behavioral change, rather than selective pressure, has resulted in the observed differences. This study provides evidence of a behavioral change in\u00a0soundproduction of right whales that is correlated with increased\u00a0noise\u00a0levels and indicates that right whales may shift call frequency to compensate for increased band-limited background\u00a0noise.","author":["Clark, C.","Parks, S."],"organization":["Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology","Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution"],"originationDate":"2007-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1025","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/individual-right-whales-call-louder-increased-environmental-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/royalsocietypublishing.org\/doi\/full\/10.1098\/rsbl.2010.0451","title":"Individual right whales call louder in increased environmental noise","description":"The ability to modify vocalizations to compensate for environmental noise is critical for successful communication in a dynamic acoustic environment. Many marine species rely on sound for vital life functions including communication, navigation and feeding. The impacts of significant increases in ocean noise levels from human activities are a current area of concern for the conservation of marine mammals. Here, we document changes in calling behaviour by individual endangered North Atlantic right whales (Eubalaena glacialis) in increased background noise. Right whales, like several bird and primate species, respond to periods of increased noise by increasing the amplitude of their calls. This behaviour may help maintain the communication range with conspecifics during periods of increased noise. These call modifications have implications for conservation efforts for right whales, affecting both the way whales use sound to communicate and our ability to detect them with passive acoustic monitoring systems.","author":["Johnson, M.","Tyack, P.","Nowacek, D.","Parks, S."],"organization":["Pennsylvania State University","Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution","Duke University"],"originationDate":"2011-02-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1026","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/whale-call-response-masking-boat-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/428910a","title":"Whale-call response to masking boat noise","description":"Background noise can interfere with the detection and discrimination of crucial signals among members of a species. Here we investigate the vocal behaviour in the presence and absence of whale-watcher boat traffic of three social groups (pods) of killer whales (Orcinus orca) living in the nearshore waters of Washington state. We find longer call durations in the presence of boats for all three pods, but only in recent recordings made following a period of increasing boat traffic. This result indicates that these whales adjust their behaviour to compensate for anthropogenic noise once it reaches a threshold level.","author":["Foote, A.","Osborne, R.","Hoelzel, R."],"organization":["Durham University"],"originationDate":"2004-04-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.335104000000","-124.548616000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1027","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/how-does-wind-turbine-noise-affect-people","sourceURL":"https:\/\/acousticstoday.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2015\/05\/How-Does-Wind-Turbine-Noise-Affect-People.pdf","title":"How Does Wind Turbine Noise Affect People?","description":"Recent articles in Acoustics Today have reviewed a number of difficult issues concerning wind turbine noise and how it can affect people living nearby (Leventhall 2013, Schomer 2013; Timmerman 2013). Here we present potential mechanisms by which effects could occur.  The essence of the current debate is that on one hand you have the well-funded wind industry 1. advocating that infrasound be ignored because the measured levels are below the threshold of human hearing, allowing noise levels to be adequately documented through A-weighted sound measurements, 2. dismissing the possibility that any variants of wind turbine syndrome exist (Pierpont 2009) even when physicians (e.g., Steven D. Rauch, M.D. at Harvard Medical School) cannot otherwise explain some patients\u2019 symptoms, and, 3. arguing that it is unnecessary to separate wind turbines and homes based on prevailing sound levels.  On the other hand you have many people who claim to be so distressed by the effects of wind-turbine noise that they cannot tolerate living in their homes. Some move away, either at financial loss or bought-out by the turbine operators. Others live with the discomfort, often requiring medical therapies to deal with their symptoms. Some, even members of the same family, may be unaffected.","author":["Salt, A.","Lichtenhan, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Salt-2014-How-Does-Wind-Turbine-Noise-Affect-People.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1028","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/adbm-demonstration-butendiek-offshore-wind-farm-ballast-nedam","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.prweb.com\/releases\/2014\/09\/prweb12144236.htm","title":"AdBm Demonstration at Butendiek Offshore Wind Farm with Ballast Nedam","description":"A demonstration of the AdBm Technologies underwater noise abatement system was conducted July 11\u201312, 2014 during pile driving operations for monopiles BU 32 and BU 21 in the Butendiek Offshore Wind Farm. The panel-based noise abatement system was deployed and recovered four times without incident. Acoustic testing was conducted at three locations ranging from 285 meters to 750 meters from the monopile being driven. Measurements were collected on 668 hammer strikes at a distance of 285 meters from the monopile. Attenuation of up to 36.8 dB was realized across all hammer strikes at this location. At 750 m from the monopile, 136 hammer strikes were analyzed and the noise radiated from the pile driving was attenuated to the level of ambient noise near the recording vessel, which ranged on average from 140\u2013150 dB re 1 \u00b5Pa. The results from this test strongly suggest that this system alone will be sufficient to meet the required sound exposure level of 160 dB at 750 m.","author":["AdBm Technologies"],"organization":["AdBm Technologies"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.454756000000","8.433074000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/AdBm-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1029","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/installing-offshore-wind-turbine-foundations-quieter-performance-overview-first-full","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.onepetro.org\/conference-paper\/OTC-29613-MS","title":"Installing Offshore Wind Turbine Foundations Quieter: A Performance Overview of the First Full-Scale Demonstration of the AdBm Underwater Noise Abatement System","description":"Offshore wind is a quickly-emerging market resulting from the worldwide transition towards renewable energies. Whilst this transition has countless environmental benefits, the negative aspects pertaining to underwater noise generated during wind park construction are coming under increased public scrutiny. A number of countries have responded to this environmental and social concern by establishing underwater noise regulations. Construction using current piling techniques often requires the use of underwater noise mitigation systems to meet these legislative requirements. These systems can be applied at the piling source, near pile or far from pile. Under the Underwater Noise Abatement System (UNAS) program, partially sponsored by the Dutch government\u2019s \u2018Rijksdienst voor Ondernemend Nederland\u2019 (RVO), a new noise mitigation system has been tested. The UNAS consortium consists of three partners: Van Oord Offshore Wind Projects, AdBm Technologies, and TNO (Netherlands Organization for Applied Scientific Research). The noise mitigation system, here after referred to as NMS, consists of a slatted system containing Helmholtz resonators which is deployed around a monopile in a similar method to venetian blinds. Scaled tests of the NMS at Butendiek and Luchterduinen Offshore Wind Parks showed potential for full-scale deployment. The full-scale test of the NMS was executed in the fall of 2018. A configuration where the vertical spacing of the slats was 0.67 m yielded a 7 to 8 dB SEL re 1 \u03bcPa2s reduction compared to the unmitigated scenario, while combining the NMS with a big bubble curtain (BBC) resulted in a 14 to 15 dB SEL reduction compared to the unmitigated situation. This reduction range, as well as a smooth offshore operational performance, puts the NMS in line with other near pile mitigation systems. Deployment of the NMS appears a feasible option to ensure underwater noise compliance in various nation\u2019s legislation.","author":["Wochner, M.","Nijhof, M.","Jansen, E.","Elzinga, J.","Mesu, A.","van Eekelen, E."],"organization":["Van Oord","AdBm Technologies","TNO (Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research) Wind Energy"],"originationDate":"2019-05-09","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1030","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sustainability-tourism-effect-united-states-first-offshore-wind-farm-vacation-rental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0928765518302902","title":"Sustainability and tourism: the effect of the United States\u0027 first offshore wind farm on the vacation rental market","description":"One concern with offshore wind energy development is a negative impact to tourism. In this paper we assess this concern by examining how the Block Island\u00a0Wind Farm, the first of its kind in the United States, has impacted the vacation rental market. Using data from AirBnb, we estimate a difference-in-differences model that compares Block Island to three nearby tourist destinations in Southern New England before and after construction. Our results suggest that construction of the Block Island Wind Farm caused a significant increase in nightly reservations, occupancy rates, and monthly revenues for AirBnb properties in Block Island during the peak-tourism months of July and August, but had no effect in other months. The findings indicate that offshore wind farms can act as an attractive feature of a location, rather than a deterrent.","author":["Carr-Harris, A.","Lang, C."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.383705000000","-71.630936000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Recreation \u0026 Tourism"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-17 11:40:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1031","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/winds-change-predicting-water-based-recreationists-support-opposition-offshore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0380133018301904","title":"Winds of change \u2013 Predicting water-based recreationists\u0027 support and opposition for offshore wind energy development in the Great Lakes","description":"This study examined the factors influencing water-based recreationists\u0027 perceptions of support and opposition towards off-shore\u00a0wind energy development\u00a0(OWD) on Lake Erie. Much of the proposed or future Lake Erie OWD infrastructure may either be within or adjacent to public lands, waters, and protected areas, raising concerns about the potential environmental and\u00a0social impacts\u00a0upon\u00a0recreation\u00a0stakeholders. The limited body of OWD research within the\u00a0United States\u00a0has suggested there are numerous factors that may influence overall perceptions of support and opposition such as political orientation and beliefs in climate change. Moreover, recent research has proposed that the perceived recreation impact of OWD may be the most important predictor of support and opposition. This study confirmed this premise and found the perceived recreation impact of OWD to be the strongest predictor of support. Results of a multiple linear regression suggested that political orientation (\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.135), beliefs in the anthropogenic causation of climate change (\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.207), beliefs in the occurrence of climate change (\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.213), and the perceived recreation impact of OWD among water-based recreationists (\u03b2\u202f=\u202f0.439) were significant predictors of support for OWD on Lake Erie (R2\u202f=\u202f0.46). Study findings corroborated previous research which suggested that\u00a0regional climate\u00a0change beliefs and political attitudes may influence support for OWD. From a policy and\u00a0management\u00a0standpoint, study results highlight the importance of assessing and communicating recreation experience and use impacts when planning, developing, and managing OWD and related decisions in the United States.","author":["Ferguson, M.","Powers, S.","Trauntvein, N.","Jacquet, J.","Graefe, A.","Mowen, A."],"organization":["University of New Hampshire","Pennsylvania State University","Utah State University","Ohio State University"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.311965000000","-81.275283000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Recreation \u0026 Tourism"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1032","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/steel-forests-or-smoke-stacks-politics-visualisation-cape-wind-controversy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/full\/10.1080\/09644010903396051","title":"Steel forests or smoke stacks: the politics of visualisation in the Cape Wind controversy","description":"While wind power is now considered both technologically mature and economically feasible, it faces bitter opposition from local communities on the grounds of visual pollution. The role that visual impact analyses play in policy debates about the siting of wind energy facilities is critically examined. The production of viewshed simulations and their reception by members of diverse publics are examined in the context of the Cape Wind project in the United States. The official public comments record for this project is used to explore how viewshed controversies challenge administrative politics. Some ways in which visual impact assessments can better register cultural rationality and enroll civic epistemologies are suggested.","author":["Phadke, R."],"organization":["Macalester College"],"originationDate":"2010-02-08","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.677608000000","-70.503297000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Phadke-2010-Cape-Wind.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1033","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/over-sea-far-away-consideration-planning-politics-public-perception-offshore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/full\/10.1080\/15239080802242787?scroll=top\u0026needAccess=true","title":"Over the Sea and Far Away? A Consideration of the Planning, Politics and Public Perception of Offshore Wind Farms","description":"This paper is about the politics, planning, and public perceptions associated with offshore wind farms. Although only half the applications for onshore wind farms are successful in England and Wales, the latest round of offshore applications have had far higher rates of consent. But is it simply the case that siting wind farms offshore solves the problems that onshore applications encounter? This paper argues that many of the same problems are experienced by both onshore and offshore wind farms, albeit in slightly different ways; and that these need to be addressed if the promised expansion in offshore wind is to be delivered. This paper draws together the research and evidence relating to onshore and offshore wind developments, exploring this with the emerging research on public perceptions of offshore wind farms, and initial empirical evidence from a proposed wind farm off the coast of North Wales. It concludes with some remarks about the potential for offshore wind around the UK, considers the role of spatial planning, and discusses issues for policy and planning that must be addressed if the Government\u0027s ambitious targets are to be achieved.","author":["Haggett, C."],"organization":["Newcastle University"],"originationDate":"2008-08-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1034","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/place-attachment-marine-recreationists-attitudes-toward-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/00222216.2015.11950360","title":"Place attachment and marine recreationists\u0027 attitudes toward offshore wind energy development","description":"Renewable energy initiatives are increasing and many locations selected for offshore wind farms are close to recreation resources. Public involvement processes to assess project support are standard in offshore wind energy planning. However, often missing from these assessments are investigations into subpopulations, such as marine recreationists. Using mixed methods, researchers evaluated a scale that measures marine recreationists\u0027 (n\u00a0= 483) attitudes toward offshore wind energy. Researchers also examined the relationships between place attachment and opposition and support for the proposed projects. Results suggest that place attachment can assist in predicting attitudes toward offshore wind energy development, but the explanatory power and the nature of the relationships differed between two communities. Implications for communication, outreach, and recreation management are discussed.","author":["Wright, B.","Moore, D.","Brownlee, M.","Hallo, J.","Jodice, L.","Powell, R."],"organization":["University of Utah","Clemson University"],"originationDate":"2017-12-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Recreation \u0026 Tourism"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1035","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/economics-visual-disamenity-reductions-offshore-wind-farms-review-suggestions-emerging","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032112004868","title":"The economics of visual disamenity reductions of offshore wind farms\u2014Review and suggestions from an emerging field","description":"The offshore wind power generation market is currently experiencing large growth rates on a global scale and investments exceeding several billion euro are being made. From a welfare economic point of view there is a non-trivial economic trade-off between offshore wind generation costs and the visual impacts from offshore wind farms. Offshore wind farms close to the shore generate cheaper electricity, but also cause higher levels of visual impacts compared to locations at larger distances. In the present paper we carry out a review of the stated preference studies that have elicited the demand for visual disamenity reduction from offshore wind farms. The review has three objectives: (a) to present the results of the different surveys; (b) to explore the more technical parts of the different surveys; and (c) to present the frontiers in the assessment of the demand for visual disamenity reductions associated with offshore wind farm locations. The paper is based on the results from five different studies. The review indicates that locations of offshore wind farms which are close to the shore generate significant welfare losses and that these can be reduced by locating the wind farms at more distant locations. The results also show that the welfare economic costs vary in terms of a range of socio demographic characteristics, experience with wind turbines and recreational activities. Finally, the review suggests that the welfare impacts related to the spatial distribution of the wind farms, intergenerational effects and experience with wind turbines are potential areas that would be beneficial to explore in future studies.","author":["Ladenburg, J.","Lutzeyer, S."],"organization":["North Carolina State University"],"originationDate":"2012-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1036","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparing-nekton-distributions-two-tidal-energy-sites-suggests-potential-generic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166916300492","title":"Comparing nekton distributions at two tidal energy sites suggests potential for generic environmental monitoring","description":"Tidal energy is a renewable resource that can contribute towards meeting growing energy demands, but uncertainties remain about environmental impacts of device installation and operation. Environmental monitoring programs are used to detect and evaluate impacts caused by anthropogenic disturbances and are a mandatory requirement of project operating licenses in the United States. In the United Kingdom, consent conditions require monitoring of any adverse impacts on species of concern. While tidal turbine sites share similar physical characteristics (e.g. strong tidal flows), similarities in their biological characteristics have not been examined. To characterize the generality of biological attributes at tidal energy sites, metrics derived from acoustic backscatter describing temporal and spatial distributions of fish and macrozooplankton at Admiralty Inlet, Washington State and the Fall of Warness, Scotland were compared using t-tests, F-tests, linear regressions, spectral analysis, and extreme value analysis (EVA). EVA was used to characterize metric values that are rare but potentially associated with biological impacts, defined as relevant change as a consequence of human activity. Pelagic nekton densities were similar at both sites, as evidenced by no statistically significant difference in densities, and similar daily density patterns of pelagic nekton between sites. Biological characteristics were similar, suggesting that generic biological monitoring programs could be implemented at these two sites, which would streamline permitting, facilitate site comparison, and enable environmental impact detection associated with tidal energy deployment.","author":["Horne, J.","Scott, B.","Williamson, B.","Wiesebron, L."],"organization":["University of Washington","University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.130649900000","-122.672120000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WiesebronETAL_NetkonDistributionsatMREsites.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1037","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/memory-place-disruption-senses-local-opposition-korean-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421519302472","title":"The memory of place disruption, senses, and local opposition to Korean wind farms","description":"The notion of place is quite useful to account for local\u00a0acceptanceof\u00a0energy transitions. Using\u00a0semi-structured interviews\u00a0and\u00a0content analysis, this article explores how new places are imagined or formed in\u00a0opposition\u00a0to\u00a0wind farms\u00a0in\u00a0South Korea, with a focus on the memory of place\u00a0disruption\u00a0and sensory\u00a0interactionswith\u00a0wind\u00a0turbines. First,\u00a0residents\u00a0opposed to the\u00a0construction\u00a0of\u00a0wind farms\u00a0imagine negative places in opposition to\u00a0future\u00a0energy transitions, such as places in which\u00a0landslides\u00a0and ecological disruptions have occurred, based on trauma from past place disruption. Second, residents\u0027 sensory experiences of the noise created by\u00a0wind turbines\u00a0and the turbines\u0027 aviation-obstruction lights form\u00a0concepts\u00a0of artificial, urban, or mechanical places in opposition to the natural or rural quality of the places\u00a0prior\u00a0to wind turbine construction. These negative places that are formed based on memory and\u00a0sensory input\u00a0drive opposition to\u00a0wind turbines. Therefore, place-people relations should be adequately and carefully discussed in both\u00a0site-planning\u00a0and community engagement processes associated with\u00a0wind farms.","author":["Kim, E.","Chung, J."],"organization":["Kyung Hee University","Ulsan National Institute of Science and Technology (UNIST)"],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1038","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-wind-turbine-visibility-health-local-residents-systematic-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00420-019-01403-w","title":"The influence of wind turbine visibility on the health of local residents: a systematic review","description":"Purpose  The health effects of visible wind turbine features on residents were investigated. Further, it was examined, if visual annoyance has an influence on residents\u2019 health, and if wind turbine visibility impacts residents\u2019 health independently of or in combination with acoustical aspects.  Methods  Medical databases, Google Scholar, public health institutions, and reference lists were searched systematically (PROSPERO registry number: CRD42016041737). Two independent reviewers screened titles\/abstract and full texts, extracted data, and critically appraised the methodology of included studies. Study findings were analyzed qualitatively and quantitatively.  Results  Seventeen studies from 19 publications of varying methodological quality were included (two cohort studies, fifteen cross-sectional studies). The pooled prevalence of high annoyance due to altered views and shadow flicker was 6% each. The results of other health effects were inconsistent, with some indications showing that direct wind turbine visibility increases sleep disturbance. Annoyance by direct visibility, shadow flicker, and blinking lights was significantly associated with an increased risk for sleep disorders. One study indicated reactions to visual wind turbine features may be influenced by acoustical exposures.  Conclusions  In interpreting the results, the differing methodological quality of the included studies needs to be considered. Direct and indirect wind turbine visibility may affect residents\u2019 health, and reactions may differ in combination with noise. Further, annoyance by wind turbine visibility may interact as mediator between visual exposures and the health of local residents. To confirm the results, more high-quality research is needed.","author":["Freiberg, A.","Schefter, C.","Hegewald, J.","Seidler, A."],"organization":["Technische Universit\u00e4t Dresden"],"originationDate":"2019-01-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Health \u0026 Safety","Lighting","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-12 08:19:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1039","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-impact-introduced-infrastructure-sea-cameras-case-study-spatial-scale-time","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113618308201","title":"Assessing the impact of introduced infrastructure at sea with cameras: A case study for spatial scale, time and statistical power","description":"Detecting the effects of introduced artificial structures on the marine environment relies upon research and monitoring programs that can provide baseline data and the necessary statistical power to detect biological and\/or ecological change over relevant spatial and temporal scales. Here we report on, and assess the use of, Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUV) systems as a technique to monitor diversity, abundance and assemblage composition data to evaluate the effects of marine renewable energy infrastructure on mobile epi-benthic species. The results from our five-year study at a wave energy development facility demonstrate how annual natural variation (time) and survey design (spatial scale and power) are important factors in the ability to robustly detect change in common ecological metrics of benthic and bentho-pelagic ecosystems of the northeast Atlantic. BRUV systems demonstrate their capacity for use in temperate, high energy marine environments, but also how weather, logistical and technical issues require increased sampling effort to ensure statistical power to detect relevant change is achieved. These factors require consideration within environmental impact assessments if such survey methods are to identify and contribute towards the management of potential positive or negative effects on benthic systems.","author":["Sheehan, E.","Godley, B.","Witt, M.","Bicknell, A.","Doherty, P."],"organization":["University of Exeter","University of Plymouth"],"originationDate":"2019-04-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.445859000000","-5.657102000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bicknell-2019-Introduced-Infrastructure.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1040","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/implications-visual-simulation-analysis-temporal-variation-visibility-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0169204618310065","title":"The implications for visual simulation and analysis of temporal variation in the visibility of wind turbines","description":"The visual impact of\u00a0wind\u00a0turbines is a central issue in their public acceptance. New wind farm proposals are commonly subject to visual simulation and visual impact assessment. Guidelines for both these processes are already used in a number of jurisdictions and there is widespread interest in making simulation and impact assessments as meaningful as possible. To a large degree the guidelines for both processes tend to be based on worst-case (full-frontal) conditions. There are two quite good reasons for this. Firstly, the worst-case sets a boundary for visual impact. Secondly, we seldom know enough about how visibility or visual impact changes over time and what \u2018typical\u2019 conditions are like \u2013 or how the range of conditions is distributed. This paper argues that if we can address this knowledge gap, then we may also be able to take a more nuanced approach to simulation and analysis. It should be possible, using widespread atmospheric visibility data, to determine the temporal distribution of visual impacts at a particular location rather computing a single estimate. It may also be valid to create simulations of both worst-case and more typical conditions. This paper explores the key variables affecting visual impacts \u2013 visual magnitude and color difference \u2013 and how they may be monitored and analyzed efficiently and effectively. A wind farm in southern Victoria, Australia is used as the case study. Recommendations are made on how the approaches could be used more widely.","author":["Bishop, I."],"organization":["University of Melbourne"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1041","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-turbine-visibility-visual-impact-threshold-distances","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.cambridge.org\/core\/journals\/environmental-practice\/article\/research-article-offshore-wind-turbine-visibility-and-visual-impact-threshold-distances\/59A51F3CD207849FC7F5BD986F15B2CB","title":"Offshore Wind Turbine Visibility and Visual Impact Threshold Distances","description":"Potential visual impact on coastal lands has emerged as a major concern in the development of offshore wind facilities in the United States and Europe. Optimal siting of offshore facilities requires accurate knowledge of the relationship between distance and the visibility of wind turbines. Past assessments of offshore wind turbine visibility were based on smaller turbines and facilities in use at the time and underestimate visibility for current projects, which use more and larger larger turbines. This study is a preliminary assessment of the visibility of offshore wind facilities in the United Kingdom. Study objectives included identifying the maximum distances the facilities could be seen in both daytime and nighttime views and assessing the effect of distance on visual contrasts associated with the facilities. Results showed that small to moderately sized facilities were visible to the unaided eye at distances greater than 42 km [26 miles (mi)], with turbine blade movement visible up to 39 km (24 mi). At night, aerial hazard navigation lighting was visible at distances greater than 39 km (24 mi). The observed wind facilities were judged to be a major focus of visual attention at distances up to 16 km (10 mi), were noticeable to casual observers at distances of almost 29 km (18 mi), and were visible with extended or concentrated viewing at distances beyond 40 km (25 mi)","author":["Sullivan, R.","Kirchler, L.","Cothren, J.","Winters, S."],"organization":["Argonne National Laboratory (ANL)","University of Arkansas"],"originationDate":"2013-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1042","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-characterization-sensors-used-marine-environmental-monitoring","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X19303583","title":"Acoustic characterization of sensors used for marine environmental monitoring","description":"Active acoustic sensors are widely used in oceanographic and environmental studies. Although many have nominal operating frequencies above the range of marine mammal hearing, they can produce out-of-band sound that may be audible to marine mammals. Acoustic emissions from four active acoustic transducers were characterized and compared to marine mammal hearing thresholds. All four transducers had nominal operating frequencies above the reported upper limit of marine mammal hearing, but produced measurable sound below 160\u202fkHz. A spatial map of the acoustic emissions of each sonar is used to evaluate potential effects on marine mammal hearing when the transducer is continuously operated from a stationary platform. Based on the cumulative sound exposure level metric, the acoustic emissions from the transducers are unlikely to cause temporary threshold shifts in marine mammals, but could affect animal behavior. The extent of audibility is estimated to be, at most, on the order of 100\u202fm.","author":["Cotter, E.","Murphy, P.","Bassett, C.","Polagye, B.","Williamson, B."],"organization":["University of Washington","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)","University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.648963000000","-122.312338000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1043","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predictable-changes-fish-school-characteristics-due-tidal-turbine-support-structure","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096014811930549X","title":"Predictable changes in fish school characteristics due to a tidal turbine support structure","description":"There is uncertainty on the ecological effects of tidal stream turbines. Concerns include animal collision with turbine blades, disruption of migratory and foraging behaviour, attraction of animals to prey aggregating around turbines, or conversely displacement of animals from preferred habitat.  This study used concurrent ecological and physical measurements to show the predictability of fish school characteristics (presence, school area and height above seabed) in a high energy tidal site across spring\/neap, ebb\/flood and daily cycles, and how this changed around a turbine structure.  The rate of schools and school area per hour increased by 1.74 and 1.75 times respectively around a turbine structure compared to observations under similar conditions without a turbine structure. The largest schools occurred at peak flow speeds and the vertical distribution of schools over the diel cycle was altered around the turbine structure.  While predictable attraction or aggregation of prey may increase prey availability and predator foraging efficiency, attraction of predators has the potential to increase animal collision risk. Predictable changes from the installation of turbine structures can be used to estimate cumulative effects on predators at a population level. This study can guide a strategic approach to the monitoring and management of turbines and arrays.","author":["Scott, B.","Williamson, B.","Fraser, S.","Nikora, V.","Williamson, L."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)","NAFC Marine Centre"],"originationDate":"2019-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.148317000000","-2.813690000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Williamson-2019-Fish-School.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1044","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/trade-between-tidal-turbine-array-yield-environmental-impact-habitat-suitability","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148119306251","title":"The trade-off between tidal-turbine array yield and environmental impact: A habitat suitability modelling approach","description":"In the drive towards a carbon-free society, tidal energy has the potential to become a valuable part of the UK energy supply. Developments are subject to intense scrutiny, and potential environmental impacts must be assessed. Unfortunately many of these impacts are still poorly understood, including the implications that come with altering the hydrodynamics. Here, methods are proposed to quantify ecological impact and to incorporate its minimisation into the array design process. Four tidal developments in the Pentland Firth are modelled with the array optimisation tool OpenTidalFarm, that designs arrays to generate the maximum possible profit. Maximum entropy modelling is used to create habitat suitability maps for species that respond to changes in bed-shear stress. Changes in habitat suitability caused by an altered tidal regime are assessed. OpenTidalFarm is adapted to simultaneously optimise array design to maximise both this habitat suitability and to maximise the profit of the array. The problem is thus posed as a multi-objective optimisation problem, and a set of Pareto solutions found, allowing trade-offs between these two objectives to be identified. The methods proposed generate array designs that have reduced negative impact, or even positive impact, on the habitat suitability of specific species or habitats of interest.","author":["Kramer, S.","Hill, J.","Piggott, M.","du Feu, R.","Funke, S."],"organization":["Imperial College London","Simula","University of York"],"originationDate":"2019-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/deFeuetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1045","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/agassizs-desert-tortoise-gopherus-agassizii-activity-areas-are-little-changed-after","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.publish.csiro.au\/wf\/WF18147","title":"Agassiz\u0027s desert tortoise (Gopherus agassizii) activity areas are little changed after wind turbine-induced fires in California","description":"Wind turbine-induced fires at a wind energy facility in California, USA, provided an opportunity to study the before and after effects of fire on a population of protected Agassiz\u2019s desert tortoises (Gopherus agassizii) in the Sonoran Desert, a species and ecosystem poorly adapted to fire. We compared annual activity areas (AAs) of tortoises in 2011 and 2013, before and after two 2012 fires, with those of tortoises in adjacent areas unaffected by the same fires. Tortoises in both AAs affected by fire or unaffected by fire occupied the same general AAs in 2013, after the fires, as they did in 2011, before the fires. Some tortoises had both their 2011 and 2013 AAs completely or almost completely within the areas burned by the 2012 fires, despite the proximity of unburned habitat. None of the tortoises with 2011 AAs subsequently unaffected by the 2012 fires shifted their AAs into burned habitat in 2013. For the fire-affected group of tortoises, the mean percentages of 2011 and 2013 AAs burned by the 2012 fires were not significantly different, showing fidelity to the burned areas. Tortoises in both groups generally occupied consistent AAs, even post fire, placing them at potential risk of exposure to unfavourable burned habitat.","author":["Austin, M.","Lovich, J.","Ennen, J.","Agha, M.","Arundel, T."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","University of California Davis","Tennessee Aquarium Conservation Institute"],"originationDate":"2018-11-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.014750000000","-115.477603000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Reptiles"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1046","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-cumulative-adverse-effects-offshore-wind-energy-development-seabird-foraging","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1748-9326\/ab205b\/meta","title":"Assessing the Cumulative Adverse Effects of Offshore Wind Energy Development on Seabird Foraging Guilds Along the East Coast of the United States","description":"Offshore wind farms are rapidly being permitted along the East Coast of the U.S., and with subsequent development could cumulatively affect seabird populations. Yet, the seabird guilds most likely at risk of cumulative effects have not been identified. Assessments of cumulative effects must first calculate the cumulative exposure of seabirds to areas suitable for offshore wind farms and then estimate how exposure will affect populations. This paper addresses this first need, and quantifies how three different wind farm siting scenarios could cumulatively expose seven seabird foraging guilds. The coastal bottom gleaner guild (sea ducks) would be exposed at similar rates regardless of siting decision, while other coastal guilds would be exposed at a higher rate when projects are built in shallow areas and close to shore rather than in high-wind areas. The pelagic seabird guild would be exposed at high rates when projects are built in high-wind areas. There was no single offshore wind siting scenario that reduced the cumulative exposure for all guilds. Based upon these findings, we identify the foraging guilds most likely to be cumulatively exposed and propose an approach for siting and mitigation that may reduce cumulative exposure for all guilds.","author":["Milman, A.","Goodale, M.","Griffin, C."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts"],"originationDate":"2019-07-12","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Goodale-2019-Cumulative-effects.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1047","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stakeholder-requirements-commercially-successful-wave-energy-converter-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117305451","title":"Stakeholder requirements for commercially successful wave energy converter farms","description":"In this study, systems engineering techniques are applied to wave energy to identify and specify stakeholders\u2019 requirements for a commercially successful wave energy farm. The focus is on the continental scale utility market. Lifecycle stages and stakeholders are identified. Stakeholders\u2019 needs across the whole lifecycle of the wave energy farm are analyzed. A list of 33 stakeholder requirements are identified and specified. This list of requirements should serve as components of a technology performance level metric that could be used by investors and funding agencies to make informed decisions when allocating resources. It is hoped that the technology performance level metric will accelerate wave energy conversion technology convergence.","author":["Roberts, J.","Bull, D.","Nielsen, K.","Babarit, A.","Weber, J.","Dykes, K.","Malins, R.","Costello, R.","Ferreira, C.","Kennedy, B."],"organization":["Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1048","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-physical-biochemical-influence-ocean-thermal-energy-conversion-plant-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1055480","title":"Modeling the Physical and Biochemical Influence of Ocean Thermal Energy Conversion Plant Discharges into their Adjacent Waters","description":"This paper describes the modeling work by Makai Ocean Engineering, Inc. to simulate the biochemical effects of of the nutrient-enhanced seawater plumes that are discharged by one or several 100 megawatt OTEC plants. The modeling is needed to properly design OTEC plants that can operate sustainably with acceptably low biological impact.  Summary of Findings: This study has showed that the biochemical response of OTEC discharges can be modeled, quantified, and dynamically visualized for OTEC plants having different discharge configurations. We now have an extremely useful tool for use by OTEC regulators and designers. In all cases modeled (discharge at 70 meters depth or more), no perturbation occurs in the upper 40 meters of the ocean\u0027s surface. The picoplankton response in the 110 - 70 meter depth layer is approximately a 10-25% increase, which is well within naturally occurring variability. The nanoplankton response is negligible. The enhanced productivity of diatoms (microplankton) is small, but this additional \u0022standing stock\u0022 may potentially enhance growth if the plume water subsequently advects into nearshore water. Another significant finding is that detecting the plume of an OTEC pilot plant, as envisioned for the \u0022NAVFAC OTEC Pilot Plant\u0022, will require many more samples in time and space than was originally envisioned, because ocean variability is greater than anticipated. Finally, the model does not attempt to calculate the higher order trophic levels where fauna consume the phytoplankton, but these results could be readily extended to this purpose. The subtle phytoplankton increase of our baseline design suggests that higher-order effects will be very small.","author":["Grandelli, P.","Rocheleau, G.","Hamrick, J.","Powell, B.","Church, M."],"organization":["Makai Ocean Engineering Inc","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2012-09-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["19.987326000000","-156.225649000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["OTEC"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Grandelli-2012-OTEC.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1049","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-seagen-marine-current-turbine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1243\/14750902JEME94","title":"Life cycle assessment of the Seagen marine current turbine","description":"The world\u0027s first commercial\u2010scale grid\u2010connected tidal current energy installation will feature the Seagen marine current turbine developed by Marine Current Turbines Ltd. With potential for the manufacture of significant numbers of such devices there is a need to assess their environmental impact and, in particular, their life cycle energy and carbon dioxide (CO2) performance. This paper presents an analysis of the life cycle energy use and CO2 emissions associated with the first generation of Seagen turbines. The detailed assessment covers the embodied energy and CO2 in the materials and manufacturing of components, device installation, and operation along with those for decommissioning. With relatively conservative assumptions, and despite the early stage of development, the study shows that at 214 kJ\/kWh and 15 g CO2\/kWh, the respective energy and carbon intensities are comparable with large wind turbines and very low relative to the 400 to 1000 g CO2\/kWh typical of fossil\u2010fuelled generation. The energy payback period is approximately 14 months and the CO2 payback is around 8 months. The embodied energy and carbon show limited sensitivity to assumptions with environmental performance remains excellent even under the most adverse scenarios considered. Materials use is identified as the primary contributors to embodied energy and carbon with shipping also significant. Improvements in the environmental impact of the Seagen can be achieved primarily by increased structural efficiency and the use of alternative installation methods to increase recovery of steel at decommissioning.","author":["Harrison, G.","Chick, J.","Douglas, C."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2008-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-11 08:29:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/douglas-et-al-2008-life-cycle-assessment-of-the-seagen-marine-current-turbine.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1050","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-comparison-wave-tidal-energy-device","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/full\/10.1177\/1475090211418892","title":"Life cycle comparison of a wave and tidal energy device","description":"Tidal and wave energy devices are often discussed as a future contributor to the UK\u2019s energy mix. Indeed, marine energy resources are said to have the potential to supply up to 20\u2009per\u2009cent of the nation\u2019s electricity demand. However, these technologies are currently at the development stage and make no meaningful contribution to the national grid. A number of devices have been developed, but no single method has emerged as the leading technology. This paper aims to compare two promising devices, one wave device and one tidal device, and assess the life cycle properties of each. A life cycle assessment of the Oyster wave energy device was conducted as part of this study, and a comparison of this and the SeaGen marine current turbine was undertaken. In both cases a \u2018cradle-to-grave\u2019 assessment was carried out, calculating emissions from materials, fabrication, transport, installation, lifetime maintenance, and decommissioning (including recycling). The SeaGen tidal device was calculated to have an energy payback period of 14 months, and a CO2\u00a0payback period of 8 months. The equivalent figures for the Oyster device were 12 and 8 months, respectively. The respective energy and carbon intensities for the two devices were 214\u2009kJ\/kWh and 15\u2009gCO2\/kWh for the SeaGen and 236\u2009kJ\/kWh and 25\u2009gCO2\/kWh for the Oyster. The calculated intensities and payback periods are close to those of established wind turbine technologies, and low relative to the 400\u20131000\u2009g\u2009CO2\/kWh of typical fossil fuel generation. With further developments in construction and deployment efficiency these intensities are expected to fall, so the devices appear to have the potential to offer a viable contribution to the UK\u2019s future energy mix.","author":["Walker, S.","Howell, R."],"organization":["University of Sheffield"],"originationDate":"2011-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1051","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-energy-machines-comparative-life-cycle-assessment-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.sagepub.com\/doi\/full\/10.1177\/1475090213506184","title":"Tidal energy machines: A comparative life cycle assessment study","description":"Marine\u00a0energy in the United Kingdom is undergoing a period of growth in terms of development and implementation. The current installed tidal energy capacity is expected to rise to provide 20% of the United Kingdom\u0027s electricity demand by 2050. This article used\u00a0life cycle\u00a0assessment to study four tidal energy devices, comparing their embodied energy and carbon dioxide emissions. The device designs studied included a multi-blade\u00a0turbine, two three-blade horizontal axis\u00a0turbine\u00a0machines and an Archimedes\u0027 screw device. These machines were chosen to represent a cross section of design for the device, foundation, installation and operation. Embodied energy was considered over the lifetime of each device. Energy use from fabrication, transport, installation, maintenance, decommissioning and recycling was all calculated and compared to the energy generated by each device. Finally, the embodied energy, CO2 intensity and energy payback periods were compared to those of conventional power generating systems and other renewable energy sources. Devices were studied based on a functional unit, defined as a 10 MW array installed for 100 years. Of the devices studied, the OpenHydro Open Centre\u00a0turbine\u00a0was found to have the best ratio of generated to embodied energy. All devices achieved CO2 and energy payback within 12 years and exhibited CO2 intensity between 18 and 35 gCO(2)\/kW h. This compares favourably against current energy sources such as wind (8-12 gCO(2)\/kW h), solar photovoltaic (similar to 30 gCO(2)\/kW h), nuclear (similar to 70 gCO(2)\/kW h) and coal (similar to 1000 gCO(2)\/kW h).","author":["Walker, S.","Howell, R.","Hodgson, P.","Griffin, A."],"organization":["University of Sheffield"],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1052","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-stream-energy-impact-transient-residual-flow-estuary-3d-analysis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261913009598","title":"Tidal stream energy impact on the transient and residual flow in an estuary: A 3D analysis","description":"The interest in the exploitation of the tidal stream energy has increased significantly over the last years and several tidal farms have been proposed. In spite of this, only a few studies dealt with the potential impacts on the environment resulting from the extraction of this energy, most of them by using 2D numerical models. However, some of the areas of interest for tidal stream exploitation, such as the Galician Rias, present complex transient and residual circulation patterns which in turn result in one of the largest oceanic productivities in the world and whose potential changes cannot be properly studied by means of 2D models. In this work, a 3D numerical model was implemented in Ria de Ortigueira, a promising region for tidal stream energy exploitation, to study the potential flow changes due to the operation of a power plant, including the assessment of the potential impacts on the 3D residual flow in a real estuary. First, the model was validated on the basis of current velocity measurements, then, it was used to describe the potential effects resulting from the operation of a previously proposed tidal stream farm during typical winter and summer conditions. For this purpose, the momentum sink approach was used. Overall, it was found that the resulting transient flow modifications were concentrated in the area occupied by and next to the farm, with nearly negligible effects outside the inner ria. Furthermore, important asymmetry effects were also observed; although the inner part of the estuary is flood dominated, the most important effects occur during the ebb as a result of the complex geometry of this area. Finally, the effects on the residual flow are of the same order, in terms of percentage of velocity variation, as in the case of the transient flow; however, they extend over a wider region, affecting the middle ria, where a complex 3D circulation pattern (a positive estuarine circulation) develops. Nevertheless, the operation of the tidal plant is not capable of modifying the general 3D flow structure in this area.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Ramos, V.","Carballo, R.","Sanchez, M."],"organization":["University of Santiago de Compostela","University of Plymouth"],"originationDate":"2014-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.723022000000","-7.848938000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1053","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-tidal-turbines-water-levels-shallow-estuary","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166917300619","title":"The impacts of tidal turbines on water levels in a shallow estuary","description":"This study aims to provide further understanding about the effects that tidal turbines arranged in block farms could have over the water levels when they are deployed in estuaries with shallow bathymetry. As an application of the methodology presented for this purpose, a real case study, the Solway Firth estuary in the UK, has been modelled by means of MIKE21. An idealised model of the estuary has been used to identify the trends in extractable energy and impacts on tidal range for different farm densities and contrasted with a fully detailed model. A spring tide and a coastal flooding scenario have been considered for the detailed model as well as different densities and configurations of the tidal farms. For the densest arrays the extractable energy tends to a limit and the impacts on tidal range become relevant, although they are still lower than the ones resulting from tidal range schemes with similar installed capacities. It has been found that the effects on water levels are not linearly proportional to the increase of the farm density but they seem more closely related to the energy dissipated by the farms. The results of the changes on high and low tide levels over the estuary and time-series at specific locations have been analysed for the detailed models. When comparing between different layouts, changes during low tide levels are slightly higher for the parallel arrays. It can also be concluded that flood risk levels could be potentially reduced in the shoreline whereas some of the intertidal areas and their habitats could disappear as a consequence of significant water level rise at low tides.","author":["Garcia-Oliva, M.","Djordjevi\u0107, S.","Tabor, G."],"organization":["University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.899575000000","3.543475700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1054","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-impacts-tidal-stream-energy-through-high-resolution-numerical-modeling","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544213007408","title":"Assessment of the impacts of tidal stream energy through high-resolution numerical modeling","description":"When planning the installation of a tidal farm, the disturbances on the marine environment associated with its operation must be studied in detail. The objectives of this paper are to assess the impacts on the hydrodynamics (water level and flow velocity) and to determine how these impacts can alter the tidal resource. For this purpose, a high-resolution model of Ria de Ribadeo (NW Spain) is used to describe the potential effects resulting from the operation of two prospective tidal farms. Two different scenarios of extracted power from the flow (high and low) are analyzed. Overall, it is found that the impact on the water level is negligible, but that on the flow velocity is significant. The velocity is reduced upstream and downstream the farm, and increased beside it. These effects are enhanced in the scenario with the higher power extraction. Finally, these modifications in the flow pattern alter the available energy density at the tidal turbine, with a reduction of 21% and 12% for the high and low levels of power extraction, respectively.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Ramos, V.","Carballo, R.","Sanchez, M.","\u00c1lvarez, M."],"organization":["University of Santiago de Compostela","University of Plymouth"],"originationDate":"2013-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1055","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-stream-energy-impacts-estuarine-circulation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0196890414000715","title":"Tidal stream energy impacts on estuarine circulation","description":"Among the impacts on the marine environment associated with the operation of a tidal farm, the alteration of the transient and residual flow velocities must be assessed in detail, for they constitute the driving force of important environmental processes such as sediment and pollutant transport, and nutrient dispersion. The objective of this study is to assess the impacts caused by the operation of a tidal farm on the transient and residual flow by means of a case study: a tidal stream farm in Ria de Ribadeo, an estuary in NW Spain. For this purpose a 3D numerical model of the estuary is implemented and successfully validated based on field data of tidal levels and flow velocities. The energy extracted by the tidal stream farm from the flow is accounted for by adding a momentum sink term in the equations of the model. Two scenarios representative of typical winter and summer conditions are considered. The results show that the disturbances to the transient flow patterns are concentrated in the proximity of the farm, with a weakening of the flow upstream and, especially, downstream of the farm (up to 0.25\u00a0ms\u22121) and an intensification on both sides (up to 0.10\u00a0ms\u22121). As for the residual flow, we find that the operation of the tidal farm does not disrupt the complex 3D residual circulation of the ria, but it does lead to modifications of the residual flow of up to 0.025\u00a0ms\u22121, or approximately 10% of the baseline residual flow, which affect a much larger area than in the case of the transient flow (up to approximately 2\u00a0km from the farm). The repercussions of these alterations of the transient and residual flow patterns of the estuary for its sedimentary and biological processes warrant further research. Overall, these results confirm the importance of assessing the impacts of a tidal stream farm on the flow.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Veigas, M.","Ramos, V.","Carballo, R.","Sanchez, M."],"organization":["University of Santiago de Compostela","University of Plymouth"],"originationDate":"2014-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.547795000000","-7.030499000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1056","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/lifecycle-environmental-impact-assessment-overtopping-wave-energy-converter-embedded","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fenrg.2019.00032\/full","title":"Lifecycle Environmental Impact Assessment of an Overtopping Wave Energy Converter Embedded in Breakwater Systems","description":"Overtopping breakwater systems are among the most promising technologies for exploiting wave energy to generate electricity. They consist in water reservoirs, embedded in piers, placed on top of ramps, higher than sea-level. Pushed by wave energy, seawater fills up the reservoirs and produces electricity by flowing back down through low headhydro turbines. Different overtopping breakwater systems have been tested worldwide in recent years. This study focuses on the Overtopping BReakwater for Energy Conversion (OBREC) system that has been implemented and tested in the harbor of Naples (Italy). The Life Cycle Assessment of a single replicable module of OBREC has been performed for analyzing potential environmental impacts, in terms of Greenhouse Gas Emissions, considering construction, installation, maintenance, and the operational phases. The Carbon Footprint (i.e., mass of CO2eq) to build wave energy converters integrated in breakwater systems has been estimated, more specifically the \u201cenvironmental investment\u201d (i.e., the share of Carbon Footprint due to the integration of wave energy converter) needed to generate renewable electricity has been assessed. The Carbon Intensity of Electricity (i.e., the ratio between the CO2eq emitted and the electricity produced) has been then assessed in order to demonstrate the profitability and the opportunity to foster innovation in the field of blue energy. Considering the impact for implementing an operational OBREC module (Carbon Footprint = 1.08 t CO2eq; Environmental Investment = 0.48 t CO2eq) and the electricity production (12.6 MWh\/year per module), environmental benefits (avoided emissions) would compensate environmental costs (i.e., Carbon Footprint; Environmental Investment) those provided within a range of 25 and 13 months respectively.","author":["Vicinanza, D.","Bastianoni, S.","Patrizi, N.","Pulselli, R.","Neri, E.","Niccolucci, V.","Contestabile, P."],"organization":["Universit\u00e0 di Siena","University of Campania Luigi Vanvitelli"],"originationDate":"2019-04-11","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-11 06:50:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/overtopping_wec.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1057","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/site-selection-process-floating-offshore-wind-farms-madeira-islands","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Hugo_Diaz9\/publication\/328289917_Site_selection_process_for_floating_offshore_wind_farms_in_Madeira_Islands\/links\/5bc4a9aaa6fdcc2c91fc508c\/Site-selection-process-for-floating-offshore-wind-farms-in-Madeira-Islands.pdf","title":"Site selection process for floating offshore wind farms in Madeira Islands","description":"This work develops and implements a methodology for comprehensive evaluation of feasible areas for floating offshore wind farms, useful to support the strategic spatial planning around the islands. The site selection criteria are classified into five categories: metocean data, proximity to facilities, marine environment, techno-economic data and viability. The basic tool used to achieve the study\u2019s goals is the marine spatial techniques based on geographic information systems and the investigated resources and criteria available in the country. The main output of this study is the provision of an objective and realistic overview of offshore wind farm siting considering the reduction of the environmental impacts and to reduce the social conflicts between stakeholders.","author":["Soares, C.","D\u00edaz, H.","Fonseca, R."],"organization":["Centre for Marine Technology and Engineering (CENTEC)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.628634000000","-16.922861000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1058","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-clatsop-county-or-economic-impact-analysis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu\/nerc_pub\/17\/","title":"Wave Energy in Clatsop County, OR: An Economic Impact Analysis","description":"This study analyzes the economic impacts of building a wave energy commercial generation project in Clatsop County, Oregon. The modeled project is relatively small, and was produced by reviewing relevant wave energy literature and working with two local wave energy developers to estimate the expenditures and related costs of the project. We find that the construction and ongoing operation of a commercial wave energy project would create gains in employment, income, and output in the area as well as preparing Astoria for further wave energy development.  Concern about the full costs of our reliance on fossil fuels, as well as an increased recognition of the vast energy-generating potential of ocean waves, has created renewed interest in wave energy projects. Compared to other renewable energy sources like wind and solar, wave energy is still in early development but project sites in Europe and small-scale demonstrations elsewhere have increased interest. Additionally, the Oregon coast has been identified as an area particularly suited for wave energy generation.  In order to estimate the total economic impact of the project we used IMPLAN, an input-output software. IMPLAN uses social-accounting matrices (SAMs) to model the industry interactions in the economy. These interactions are used to estimate the multipliers associated with expansions of various industries, which produce the total economic impacts.  After consulting relevant literature and wave energy developers, we created a hypothetical project that we feel could be developed in the near future at the Camp Rilea site. The project would have an installed capacity of 5 MW and a capacity factor of 35%. Using data from the wave energy developers and the literature, we created an amalgam of available cost information that matched the characteristics of the project site.","author":["Northwest Economic Research Center"],"organization":["Portland State University","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.119129000000","-123.955799000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NERC_2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1059","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/exploring-potential-sites-salinity-gradient-renewable-energy-north-carolina-coast","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cdr.lib.unc.edu\/concern\/dissertations\/1v53jx67d","title":"Exploring Potential Sites for Salinity Gradient Renewable Energy on the North Carolina Coast and Evaluating the Potential Effects of Local Salinity Regime Variation on SAV Communities Due to Reverse Electrodialysis Effluent","description":"North Carolina has many rivers, tributaries, and back barrier sounds that form complex estuarine systems, the largest of which is the Albemarle Pamlico Estuarine System. The extensive nature of North Carolina estuaries\u2019 vertical and horizontal salinity gradients makes this region a suitable subject for the exploration of salinity gradient energy as an alternative clean energy source. Geographic Information Systems was used to analyze North Carolina salinity data and explore potential natural and anthropogenic salinity gradient energy sites. Though salinity gradients exist within North Carolina estuaries, it was found that citing options were limited due to the proximity of high and low salinity water and the salinity variability at potential sites. The potential environmental impacts of salinity gradient energy and reverse electrodialysis technology, primarily installation effluent-induced salinity change effects on submerged aquatic vegetation growth, distribution, and abundance, were evaluated through literature review. Results were compiled in an annotated bibliography.","author":["Palko, H."],"organization":["University of North Carolina"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.353883900000","-76.899869600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Salinity Gradient"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Physical Environment","Water Quality","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1060","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/experimental-studies-impacts-harbour-sediments-resuspension-marine-invertebrates","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X97001902","title":"Experimental studies of impacts of harbour sediments resuspension to marine invertebrates larvae: bioavailability of Cd, Cu, Pb and Zn and toxicity","description":"The larvae of three marine species (Artemia salina, Crassostrea gigas, Paracentrotus lividus) reared within the suspended particulate phases of contaminated sediments from harbours were used in bioassays firstly to assess their ability to accumulate four metals (Cd, Cu, Pb, Zn) and secondly to show the toxicity of such rearing media by recording delays in growth and possible abnormal larval development. The results show that resuspension processes of dredged harbour sediments may induce both a release of Cd, Cu and Pb which are bioavailable for larvae (levels of bioaccumulation depending on the species) and biological perturbations, i.e. abnormal development in C. gigas and P. lividus larvae for the more contaminated sediments and growth inhibition in all three larvae for slightly contaminated sediments. The concentrations of Pb reached in the C. gigas D-shaped larvae and the P. lividus pluteus were unusually high; in contrast, Zn was not accumulated by the three species. The impact of dumping operations thus appears to depend both on the metal considered and on the larvae used in such tests. In this context, Pb seems a more worrying metal than Zn and C. gigas and P. lividus are better indicator species than A. salina larvae.","author":["Fichet, D.","Radenac, G.","Miramand, P."],"organization":["University of La Rochelle (Universit\u00e9 de La Rochelle)"],"originationDate":"1998-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.150123000000","-1.235917000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1061","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/noise-sea-its-impacts-marine-organisms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1660-4601\/12\/10\/12304","title":"Noise in the Sea and Its Impacts on Marine Organisms","description":"With the growing utilization and exploration of the ocean, anthropogenic noise increases significantly and gives rise to a new kind of pollution: noise pollution. In this review, the source and the characteristics of noise in the sea, the significance of sound to marine organisms, and the impacts of noise on marine organisms are summarized. In general, the studies about the impact of noise on marine organisms are mainly on adult fish and mammals, which account for more than 50% and 20% of all the cases reported. Studies showed that anthropogenic noise can cause auditory masking, leading to cochlear damage, changes in individual and social behavior, altered metabolisms, hampered population recruitment, and can subsequently affect the health and service functions of marine ecosystems. However, since different sampling methodologies and unstandarized measurements were used and the effects of noise on marine organisms are dependent on the characteristics of the species and noise investigated, it is difficult to compare the reported results. Moreover, the scarcity of studies carried out with other species and with larval or juvenile individuals severely constrains the present understanding of noise pollution. In addition, further studies are needed to reveal in detail the causes for the detected impacts.\u00a0","author":["Zhao, X.","Peng, C.","Liu, G."],"organization":["Zhejiang University"],"originationDate":"2015-09-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Peng-2015-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1062","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/anthropogenic-noise-causes-body-malformations-delays-development-marine-larvae","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/srep02831","title":"Anthropogenic noise causes body malformations and delays development in marine larvae","description":"Understanding the impact of noise on marine fauna at the population level requires knowledge about the vulnerability of different life-stages. Here we provide the first evidence that noise exposure during larval development produces body malformations in marine invertebrates. Scallop larvae exposed to playbacks of seismic pulses showed significant developmental delays and 46% developed body abnormalities. Similar effects were observed in all independent samples exposed to noise while no malformations were found in the control groups (4881 larvae examined). Malformations appeared in the D-veliger larval phase, perhaps due to the cumulative exposure attained by this stage or to a greater vulnerability of D-veliger to sound-mediated physiological or mechanical stress. Such strong impacts suggest that abnormalities and growth delays may also result from lower sound levels or discrete exposures during the D-stage, increasing the potential for routinely-occurring anthropogenic noise sources to affect recruitment of wild scallop larvae in natural stocks.","author":["Johnson, M.","Williams, J.","Atkins, J.","de Soto, N.","Delorme, N.","Howard, S."],"organization":["University of La Laguna","University of St Andrews","University of Auckland","University of Otago","National Institute for Water and Atmospheric Research (NIWA)"],"originationDate":"2013-10-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/deSoto-2013-Noise-Marine-Larvae.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1063","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/widely-used-marine-seismic-survey-air-gun-operations-negatively-impact-zooplankton","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41559-017-0195","title":"Widely used marine seismic survey air gun operations negatively impact zooplankton","description":"Zooplankton underpin the health and productivity of global marine ecosystems. Here we present evidence that suggests seismic surveys cause significant mortality to zooplankton populations. Seismic surveys are used extensively to explore for petroleum resources using intense, low-frequency, acoustic impulse signals. Experimental air gun signal exposure decreased zooplankton abundance when compared with controls, as measured by sonar (~3\u20134 dB drop within 15\u201330 min) and net tows (median 64% decrease within 1 h), and caused a two- to threefold increase in dead adult and larval zooplankton. Impacts were observed out to the maximum 1.2 km range sampled, which was more than two orders of magnitude greater than the previously assumed impact range of 10 m. Although no adult krill were present, all larval krill were killed after air gun passage. There is a significant and unacknowledged potential for ocean ecosystem function and productivity to be negatively impacted by present seismic technology.","author":["McCauley, R.","Semmens, J.","Day, R.","Watson, R.","Swadling, K.","Fitzgibbon, Q."],"organization":["Curtin University","University of Tasmania","Antarctic Climate and Ecosystems Cooperative Research Centre"],"originationDate":"2017-06-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["-43.170520000000","147.434540000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1064","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysis-environmental-issues-concerning-deployment-otec-power-plant-martinique","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s11356-017-8749-3","title":"Analysis of the environmental issues concerning the deployment of an OTEC power plant in Martinique","description":"Ocean thermal energy conversion (OTEC) is a form of power generation, which exploits the temperature difference between warm surface seawater and cold deep seawater. Suitable conditions for OTEC occur in deep warm seas, especially the Caribbean, the Red Sea and parts of the Indo-Pacific Ocean. The continuous power provided by this renewable power source makes a useful contribution to a renewable energy mix because of the intermittence of the other major renewable power sources, i.e. solar or wind power. Industrial-scale OTEC power plants have simply not been built. However, recent innovations and greater political awareness of power transition to renewable energy sources have strengthened the support for such power plants and, after preliminary studies in the Reunion Island (Indian Ocean), the Martinique Island (West Indies) has been selected for the development of the first full-size OTEC power plant in the world, to be a showcase for testing and demonstration. An OTEC plant, even if the energy produced is cheap, calls for high initial capital investment. However, this technology is of interest mainly in tropical areas where funding is limited. The cost of innovations to create an operational OTEC plant has to be amortized, and this technology remains expensive. This paper will discuss the heuristic, technical and socio-economic limits and consequences of deploying an OTEC plant in Martinique to highlight respectively the impact of the OTEC plant on the environment the impact of the environment on the OTEC plant. After defining OTEC, we will describe the different constraints relating to the setting up of the first operational-scale plant worldwide. This includes the investigations performed (reporting declassified data), the political context and the local acceptance of the project. We will then provide an overview of the processes involved in the OTEC plant and discuss the feasibility of future OTEC installations. We will also list the extensive marine investigations required prior to installation and the dangers of setting up OTEC plants in inappropriate locations.","author":["Devault, D.","P\u00e9n\u00e9-Annette, A."],"organization":["Paris-Saclay University (Universit\u00e9 Paris-Saclay)"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["14.698761000000","-61.023036000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["OTEC"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1065","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-aspects-economics-salinity-gradient-power-sgp-processes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780081003121000109","title":"Environmental aspects and economics of salinity gradient power (SGP) processes","description":"In this chapter we cover the potential\u00a0environmental impacts, the economic performance, the resource availability, and the relevant regulatory aspects of salinity gradient power (SGP) technologies. We discuss how these issues depend on the\u00a0technology applied(reverse electrodialysis or pressure retarded osmosis), on the sources of water used and on the specific site conditions. Regarding the environmental impacts, we analyse the water intake, the water disposal, and the infrastructure impacts. On the economics, the\u00a0levelized cost of electricity\u00a0metric\u00a0is introduced along with the variables we need to define to calculate it for SGP plants. The expected and required\u00a0cost development\u00a0of key components for making the technology competitive is also discussed. The global resource potential for the seawater\/freshwater applications is estimated, while the possible brine sources and the heat availability for driving the heat engines are also discussed. Finally, the\u00a0regulatory issues\u00a0are introduced, covering the\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0support schemes, subsidies for R\u0026D activities, public acceptance, and the necessary permits for\u00a0construction\u00a0and operation of SGP plants.","author":["Papapetrou, M.","Kumpavat, K."],"organization":["WIP Renewable Energies","DNV GL"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Salinity Gradient"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1066","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/energy-droughts-variable-renewable-energy-sources-european-climates","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118302829","title":"Energy droughts from variable renewable energy sources in European climates","description":"The increasing share of variable renewable energy sources in the power supply system raises questions about the reliability and the steadiness of the production. In this study, we assess the main statistical characteristics of \u201cenergy droughts\u201d for wind, solar and run-of-the-river hydro power in Europe. We propose two concepts of energy droughts, considering either: Energy Production Droughts (EPD) as sequences of days with low power production or Energy Supply Droughts (ESD) as sequences of days with a high production\/demand mismatch.\n\nUsing a set of adhoc weather-to-energy conversion models, we characterize energy droughts in 12 European regions from 30-yr series of daily wind, solar, hydro power and energy demand. The characteristics of EPD are very different between sources with short but frequent wind power droughts and rare but long hydro power ones. Solar power droughts are very region-dependent with much longer droughts in Northern Europe. ESD are next characterized in a 100% renewable energy scenario. The features of EPD and ESD differ significantly, highlighting the interplay with the energy demand. Moreover, both duration and frequency of energy droughts decrease when mixing energy sources or when some storage capacity balances the temporal production\/demand mismatch.","author":["Raynaud, D.","Hingray, B.","Fran\u00e7ois, B.","Creutin, J."],"organization":["Universit\u00e9 Grenoble Alpes"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1067","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-stakeholder-groups-operation-maintenance-services-offshore-wind-farms-lesson","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117313022","title":"The influence of stakeholder groups in operation and maintenance services of offshore wind farms: Lesson from Denmark","description":"One of the prime challenges in offshore wind is to manage and coordinate with the various stakeholders involved in the operation and maintenance (O\u0026M) phase. Therefore the aims of this paper are: i) to map the stakeholder groups involved in O\u0026M of Offshore Wind Farm (OWF), ii) to assess the identified stakeholder group\u0027s interest and power to influence O\u0026M, iii) to evaluate the relationship between different stakeholder groups and iv) to highlight potential strategies to manage the stakeholder groups. In this article, the stakeholder analysis approach is used. The results reveal that eleven key stakeholder groups are directly involved in the O\u0026M phase. Among those, the stakeholder groups named Investor\/owner, Turbine supplier, Operator\u0027s own technicians, Port facility and Vessel supplier are the most powerful stakeholders. In contrast, Onshore service providers and Component suppliers are considered less influential stakeholders. A friendly relationship exists between the governmental agency and the owner of OWFs. The operators consider themselves as competitors. The operator-subcontractor relationship is top-down. The relationship among the sub-contractors is complex because of the perception of losing business if they cooperate with their competitors. From the sustainability point of angel, achieving cooperative advantage is always preferable than competitive advantage.","author":["Ahsan, D.","Pederson, S."],"organization":["University of Southern Denmark"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.209707700000","9.295234800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1068","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/floating-offshore-wind-economic-ecological-challenges-tlp-solution","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118303690","title":"Floating offshore wind - Economic and ecological challenges of a TLP solution","description":"Offshore wind farms will play an important role in supplying the increasing energy demand while considering ecological and economic aspects. Especially floating foundations which have a great potential for offshore wind farms in water depths between 40 m up to 200 m and more, will be a major factor. The objective of this paper is to focus on the design of a TLP substructure including the anchoring in the seabed by considering the economic and ecological aspects. One main focus is on economic challenges and the approaches for reduction of the investment costs and the Levelized Cost of Energy. A second focus is on the cumulative energy demand as well on the expected CO2-emissions during the fabrication process.","author":["Kausche, M.","Adam, F.","Dahlhaus, F.","Gro\u00dfmann, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Floating-offshore-wind-economic-and-ecological-challenges-of-a-TLC-solution.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1069","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/prospective-energy-security-scenarios-spain-future-role-renewable-power-generation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118303550","title":"Prospective energy security scenarios in Spain: The future role of renewable power generation technologies and climate change implications","description":"Energy security is a complex issue that arises as one of the main concerns for most of the countries when regarding the future. In this sense, given the acknowledged lack of future-oriented studies in this field, this article performs a prospective analysis of the energy security of a national energy system. This is done through a novel methodological framework combining Life Cycle Assessment and Energy Systems Modelling. In particular, the recently proposed Renewable Energy Security Index (RESI) is endogenously integrated into a national power generation model in order to prospectively evaluate the energy security of the Spanish electricity production mix. This facilitates the exploration of alternative energy security scenarios based on RESI targets and focused on the penetration of renewables. The results show that, despite the relatively high renewable contribution reached in a business-as-usual scenario, a significantly higher and faster renewable penetration is attained when implementing RESI targets of 70%, 80% and 90% by 2030 in Spain. This is found to be associated with a large deployment of (onshore and offshore) wind power generation technology. Finally, a favourable life-cycle climate change performance is found when pursuing ambitious energy security targets.","author":["Garc\u00eda-Gusano, D.","Iribarren, D."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.925329700000","-4.205419700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1070","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/over-or-under-autonomous-sensor-fish-reveals-why-overshot-weirs-may-be-safer-undershot","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0925857419300941","title":"Over or under? Autonomous sensor fish reveals why overshot weirs may be safer than undershot weirs for fish passage","description":"Many riverine fish species disperse downstream as eggs,\u00a0juveniles, or adults, which can expose them to injury and death at\u00a0hydraulic structures. Low-head\u00a0weirs\u00a0are one example of a structure that can\u00a0kill fish, and this impact has been shown to be substantially higher for undershot weirs when compared to overshot weirs. In this study, autonomous sensor devices were released at an overshot and undershot\u00a0weirunder similar discharges to assess what stressors maybe contributing to differences in the survival rates of fish. Although the undershot weir was more likely to expose fish to rapid\u00a0decompression, the intensity of decompression was mild and it is more likely that higher levels of fluid\u00a0shear\u00a0at the undershot are more damaging to early life stage and small-bodied fish. Both weirs showed potential for strike, but this could be managed through improvements in design.","author":["Deng, Z.","Pflugrath, B.","Boys, C.","Cathers, B."],"organization":["Port Stephens Fisheries Institute (PSFI)","University of New South Wales","Charles Sturt University","Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-35.441056000000","144.735028000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1071","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/justice-social-exclusion-indigenous-opposition-case-study-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618302391","title":"Justice, social exclusion and indigenous opposition: A case study of wind energy development on the Isthmus of Tehuantepec, Mexico","description":"The southern Isthmus of Tehuantepec is one of the windiest places on Earth and the scene of a large-scale wind energy development plan conceived by the Mexican government in conjunction with multinational companies. We analyze the national wind energy development policy, and the negotiation processes, alliances and popular local indigenous resistance created by what is known as the Isthmus of Tehuantepec Wind Energy Megaproject. We observe how the Mexican government, in its eagerness to grant control of regional wind energy resources to private sector companies, generated social schisms and conflicts in regional indigenous communities. These arose largely due to the absence of land use planning rules and conflict resolution mechanisms of the property rights issued for communal and social control, heritage of the Mexican revolution in the 1910\u2019s. We describe recent government initiatives implemented in response to this dynamic and aimed at reviving construction of a wind farm previously blocked by popular indigenous protests. This unsuccessful attempt exposed a lack of institutional interest in guaranteeing local involvement in project planning and in correcting existing top-down political and operation practices. Wind energy development in Mexico resembles an extractive model, with no consideration of local cultures or organizations, or the potential for joint ventures with local stakeholders that would treat rural indigenous populations as assets in the national energy transition, begun in 2007 for wind private projects in the region.","author":["Z\u00e1rate-Toledo, E.","Pati\u00f1o, R.","Fraga, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["16.999999000000","-95.017509600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Environmental Justice"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1072","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/land-use-conflicts-sudetes-poland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1757-899X\/471\/9\/092033\/meta","title":"Land-Use Conflicts in the Sudetes, Poland","description":"The Sudetes (Polish and Czech: Sudety; German: Sudeten) are a mountain range located in the Czech-Polish-German border region with relatively high population density. In the paper we analyse the main type of land-use social conflicts in this region. In the 20th century, the conflicts and problems in the Sudetes were connected mainly with mineral resources exploitation, especially in black coal deep mines and brown coal strip mines. In the 21st century, the growing number of conflicts is caused by plans of ski infrastructure development and settlement growth in valuable nature areas, plans of constructing new quarries and wind power farms. The municipal local spatial management plans and investment plans are sometimes at variance with nature protection needs and focus on the immediate municipal budget income. There are difficulties with the promotion and implementation of alternative projects, which, taking into consideration nature protection, would also satisfy social needs. To promote compromises in spatial planning and to weaken or eliminate ecological conflicts we need to create stronger communication and negotiating networks of local inhabitants, local authorities and naturalists (both scientists and NGOs), and promote the role of alternative nature friendly conceptions at the early stage of spatial planning.","author":["Furmankiewicz, M.","Potocki, J.","Kazak, J."],"organization":["Wroc\u0142aw University of Environmental and Life Sciences"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.815021600000","14.771860100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Land-use-conflicts-in-the-Sudetes-Poland.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1073","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-turbine-collision-detection-review-state-art-sensors-imaging-systems-detecting","sourceURL":"","title":"Tidal Turbine Collision Detection: A review of the state-of-the-art sensors and imaging systems for detecting mammal collisions","description":"This report presents the findings from a review of state-of-the-art sensing and imaging (SIS) technologies relevant to Tidal Turbine Collision Detection (TTCD) application. The study includes an assessment of the approximate technology readiness and the applicability of marine animal collision detection technologies and devices being proposed, in testing and development or already deployed in prototype tidal turbine projects.   There are a number of challenges in collecting the supporting evidence of marine animal collision events; the principal challenge is the monitoring environment and the deployment and operation of sensor systems in this. Highly energetic tidal flows are characterised by high levels of noise from the turbine and from the moving water, variable levels of water turbidity and abrasive materials moving at high velocities. Another challenge is the low maturity of some applicable sensor technologies and the need in each case to collect a sufficient body of data in a short time span to validate the technology design, conclude an optimal system and determine with high certainty that a turbine blade has collided with, or nearly collided with a marine animal.   This report attempts to identify benefits, constraints, barriers to implementation, technology readiness level (TRL1 ) and recommendations on the next steps to further development. The report describes available and emerging sensor technologies against the following stated TTCD detection needs:     proximity\/collision warning   collision detection: object striking tidal turbine blade   post-event condition monitoring: identify and warn of structural damage to turbine blade (e.g. hairline fracture)   post-event object identification: differentiate between animal or debris following impact   The SIS technologies explored in this report include hydrophones active sound navigation and ranging (sonar), video camera and optical imaging, blade mounted strain gauges, blademounted accelerometers, electromagnetic field sensors and tactile sensing technologies. Also addressed are approaches to system architecture. The principal knowledge gap area is SIS to monitor post collision events. The principal evidence gaps are data for sonar imaging and tracking and blade collision impact. A collaborative mechanism to share relevant evidential SIS data would be helpful in progressing the closure of some of these gaps. Seven areas for further study have been suggested including the identified knowledge and evidence gaps, and also suggests feasibility studies to explore emerging technologies that may have additional value in TTCD. Financial resources remain a barrier to progression, with some tidal developments reaching the point of implementation but lacking sufficient funding to deploy and runcomprehensive trials with the application. A common test and development site that implements some of the SIS that require further data input may help standardise experimental results and provide an economically viable opportunity to trial new approaches and technologies.","author":["Jha, S."],"organization":["Offshore Renewable Energy (ORE) Catapult","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)","Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Jha-2016-Tidal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1074","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/globalization-wind-energy-industry-contribution-economic-impact-european-companies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118312904","title":"Globalization in the wind energy industry: contribution and economic impact of European companies","description":"This paper explores the globalization of the wind energy industry with a focus on the contribution by European companies and their economic impact in the global wind energy sector.\n\nThe global wind energy industry is nowadays a tale of two worlds, China and the rest of the world. In the last five years, China installed between 37 and 48% of the annual world market, and it is all but closed to foreign companies. Consequently, Chinese manufacturers captured between 38 and 47% of the world market whereas European reached between 41 and 50%. European manufacturers led in the rest of the world, serving between 73 and 82% of that market. They localise production and supply chain in the main markets (e.g. India, Brazil, US) or in countries where producing for export is cost-efficient (e.g. China, Mexico). Turbine manufacturers enter new markets through joint ventures, technology licensing, establishing wind farm developing subsidiaries, facilitating access to finance, or by acquiring a local company.\n\nManufacturers help improve the capability of their suppliers and take them to serve new markets. Still, European turbine manufacturers maintain important manufacturing, sales and R\u0026D centres in Europe, where they keep major procurement, supply chain and employment thus significantly contributing to its economy.\n\nEuropean developers also expanded into other markets, sometimes by acquiring and strengthening a local developer (this was generally the case in the US), sometimes by starting a subsidiary from scratch. They have been particularly active in the US and Latin America.\n\nThe European wind industry is a success story of worldwide reach that attracts jobs and growth for Europe. In order to support that this will continue to be so in the mid- or long-term future, the industry needs the support of European and national policy makers with consented, well-targeted actions.","author":["Lacal-Ar\u00e1ntegui, R."],"organization":["European Commission"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Globalization-in-the-wind-energy-industry.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1075","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pioneer-transition-horizon-scanning-emerging-issues-germanys-sustainable-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_5","title":"A Pioneer in Transition: Horizon Scanning of Emerging Issues in Germany\u0027s Sustainable Wind Energy Development","description":"With both the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) and the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) adopted at the Rio Earth Summit in 1992, certainly no-one anticipated the challenging trade-offs between renewable energy development and conservation of biological diversity. Densely populated Germany ranks third in worldwide installed wind energy capacity, only outpaced by China and the USA so far. However, power and interest shifts via well-organised civil and political opposition indicate that efforts to reconcile climate protection and wildlife conservation cannot be taken for granted.\n\nFunded by the German Federal Environmental Foundation (DBU), the horizon scan aimed at identifying the emerging need for collaborative action, based on the viewpoints of various stakeholders and the state of research in wildlife conservation and wind energy development. We applied a multi-faceted, inclusive, and peer-reviewed research process, building on ca. 50 explorative expert interviews, previous research, and a literature review. Interviewees ranged across academia, agencies, wind developers, consultants, associations, and environmental groups. The process yielded 18 emerging issues at the nexus of wind and wildlife, planning and technologies, and social aspects to cope with the challenges ahead. We present a majority of the issues in this chapter and conclude with guiding follow-up principles.","author":["K\u00f6ppel, J.","Biehl, J.","Wachend\u00f6rfer, V.","Bittner, A."],"organization":["Berlin Institute of Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.933184900000","8.807107400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1076","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-impacts-tidal-stream-turbines-surface-waves","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118306232","title":"Modelling impacts of tidal stream turbines on surface waves","description":"A high resolution Computational\u00a0Flow Dynamics\u00a0(CFD) numerical model is built based on a laboratory experiment in this research to study impacts of tidal\u00a0turbines on surface wave dynamics. A reduction of\u00a0\u223c3%\u00a0in\u00a0wave height\u00a0is observed under the influence of a standalone turbine located 0.4\u202fm from the\u00a0free surface. The artificial wave\u00a0energy dissipation\u00a0routine \u2018OBSTACLE\u2019 within FVCOM is shown to effectively capture the correct level of wave height reduction, reproducing the CFD results with significantly less computational effort.\n\nThe turbine\u00a0simulation system\u00a0is then applied to a series of test cases to investigate impact of a standalone turbine on bed shear stress. Results suggest an apparent increase in bed stress (\u223c7%) upstream of the turbine due to the inclusion of surface waves. However, in the immediate wake of the turbine, bed stress is dominated by the presence of the turbine itself, accounting for a\u00a0\u223c50%\u00a0increase, with waves having a seemingly\u00a0negligible effect\u00a0up to 9D (D is the turbine diameter) downstream of the turbine. Beyond this point, the effect of waves on bed shear stress become apparent again. The influence of OBSTACLE on bed stress is also noticeable in the far wake, showing a reduction of\u00a0\u223c2%\u00a0in wave height.","author":["Amoudry, L.","Jordan, L.","McLelland, S.","Parsons, D.","Li, M.","Li, X.","Song, Q.","Comerford, L."],"organization":["University of Liverpool","University of Hull","National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","Kiel University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1077","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/smart-curtailment-approach-reducing-bat-fatalities-curtailment-time-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/eap.1881","title":"A smart curtailment approach for reducing bat fatalities and curtailment time at wind energy facilities","description":"The development and expansion of wind energy is considered a key global threat to bat populations. Bat carcasses are being found underneath wind turbines across North and South America, Eurasia, Africa, and the Austro\u2010Pacific. However, relatively little is known about the comparative impacts of techniques designed to modify turbine operations in ways that reduce bat fatalities associated with wind energy facilities. This study tests a novel approach for reducing bat fatalities and curtailment time at a wind energy facility in the United States, then compares these results to operational mitigation techniques used at other study sites in North America and Europe. The study was conducted in Wisconsin during 2015 using a new system of tools for analyzing bat activity and wind speed data to make near real\u2010time curtailment decisions when bats are detected in the area at control turbines (N = 10) vs. treatment turbines (N = 10). The results show that this smart curtailment approach (referred to as Turbine Integrated Mortality Reduction, TIMR) significantly reduced fatality estimates for treatment turbines relative to control turbines for pooled species data, and for each of five species observed at the study site: pooled data (\u201384.5%); eastern red bat (Lasiurus borealis, \u201382.5%); hoary bat (Lasiurus cinereus, \u201381.4%); silver\u2010haired bat (Lasionycteris noctivagans, \u201390.9%); big brown bat (Eptesicus fuscus, \u201374.2%); and little brown bat (Myotis lucifugus, \u201391.4%). The approach reduced power generation and estimated annual revenue at the wind energy facility by \u2264 3.2% for treatment turbines relative to control turbines, and we estimate that the approach would have reduced curtailment time by 48% relative to turbines operated under a standard curtailment rule used in North America. This approach significantly reduced fatalities associated with all species evaluated, each of which has broad distributions in North America and different ecological affinities, several of which represent species most affected by wind development in North America. While we recognize that this approach needs to be validated in other areas experiencing rapid wind energy development, we anticipate that this approach has the potential to significantly reduce bat fatalities in other ecoregions and with other bat species assemblages in North America and beyond.","author":["Gruver, J.","Hayes, M.","Collins, J.","Hooton, L.","Schumacher, S.","Rabie, P.","Gilland, K.","Grandgent, C.","Smith, T.","Lindsay, S.","Goodrich-Mahoney, J."],"organization":["Normandeau Associates Inc","WE Energies"],"originationDate":"2019-04-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.624084800000","-90.378518200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1078","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evidence-based-approach-specifying-survey-effort-ecological-assessments-bat-activity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320717310285","title":"An evidence-based approach to specifying survey effort in ecological assessments of bat activity","description":"Robust ecological assessments are fundamental for effective wildlife conservation. Owing to the high legal protection of bats, surveys are frequently required as part of ecological assessments. Yet there is uncertainty about the amount of survey effort that should be deployed to facilitate bat protection. Bat activity can be extremely variable, and capturing periods of high activity can be as important as estimating parameters such as the median activity level. However the frequency and intensity of surveys required to capture the required information is unknown. Here we assessed the probability that acoustic surveys of differing durations would detect periods of high activity within a focal site and the importance of a site relative to others in a regional or national context. We randomly subsampled from 660 nights of activity data collected from 33 wind farm sites across Britain. The minimum surveying effort required to classify bat activity accurately varied between species and was dependent on weather conditions. We found that the survey periods required to give reasonable certainty in assessing risk exceeded those currently recommended in Europe. The approach of using bat activity accumulation curves, as described here, is transferrable to other situations where determining surveying effort and risk is necessary to ensure that ecological assessments provide a robust evidence base, whilst minimising the time and expense of surveys.","author":["Mathews, F.","Hosken, D.","Lintott, P.","Richardson, S."],"organization":["University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.609799800000","-3.544607600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1079","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biases-literature-direct-wildlife-mortality-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/bioscience\/advance-article-abstract\/doi\/10.1093\/biosci\/biz026\/5427051","title":"Biases in the Literature on Direct Wildlife Mortality from Energy Development","description":"Comparing environmental impacts of different energy sources can inform energy investments and environmental conservation. Direct wildlife mortality from energy development receives substantial public and scientific attention, but it is unclear whether rigorous comparisons of mortality among energy sources are possible. To address this question, we compared availability of mortality studies among energy sources, wildlife groups, and regions, and assessed comparability of mortality indicators measured. Whereas wind and hydropower have received substantial mortality research exceeding their proportional contributions to global energy production, coal, oil and gas, and bioenergy have received fewer studies and are underrepresented relative to their contributions. Furthermore, research is biased toward birds and fish and North America and Europe, and there are inconsistencies among energy sources and limited replication of most indicators measured. These results indicate that rigorous comparisons of direct wildlife mortality among energy sources are not currently possible and highlight research needs for improving understanding of energy\u0027s environmental impacts.","author":["Loss, S.","Diffendorfer, J.","Dorning, M."],"organization":["Oklahoma State University","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1080","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/decision-framework-ocean-thermal-energy-plant-site-selection-sustainability","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.jclepro.2019.04.032","title":"Decision framework for ocean thermal energy plant site selection from a sustainability perspective: The case of China","description":"Site selection is a key factor to the success of ocean thermal energy conversion (OTEC) project. It is a multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) problem with a series of conflicting criteria involved. However, limited studies were found concerning this area and problems existing in classical MCDM methods tended to fail OTEC site selection decisions. Therefore, this paper proposes an extended MCDM method and establishes a new decision-making framework to select the optimal location. First, a comprehensive evaluation criteria system for OTEC site selection from the view of sustainability with 16 criteria involved is established. Second, feasible alternative sites for OTEC project are identified by PEST analysis. Third, an extended PROMETHEE (Preference Ranking Organization Method for Enrichment Evaluation) under intuitionistic fuzzy environment is proposed to avoid compensation assumptions. During the decision process, seven groups of experts shared the work and cooperated with each other according to their backgrounds. Finally, a real case is studied and sensitive analysis is conducted, demonstrating the robustness and effectiveness of the proposed method. This study can effectively improve OTEC site selection decision making quality and also extends the domains of intuitionistic fuzzy PROMETHEE applications.","author":["Huang, Y.","Wu, Y.","Zhang, J.","Xu, C.","Song, Z."],"organization":["North China Electric Power University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["22.848442200000","111.237801400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["OTEC"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1081","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/regional-employment-returns-wave-tidal-energy-welsh-analysis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544214010688","title":"The regional employment returns from wave and tidal energy: A Welsh analysis","description":"The paper examines the expected regional employment returns connected to the development of tidal stream and wave-based electricity generation in a UK region \u2013 Wales. New employment provides economic development opportunities and the paper demonstrates that there is a need to develop the evidence base on these regional employment impacts. It addresses how far a region which is adjacent to significant marine resources is likely to benefit from a change in the energy generation mix which could feature more wave and tidal stream technologies.","author":["Jones, C.","Fanning, T.","Munday, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2014-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.417612000000","-4.425265400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1082","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-tidal-stream-energy-projects-offer-more-value-offshore-wind-farms-case-study-united","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421517306900","title":"Do tidal stream energy projects offer more value than offshore wind farms? A case study in the United Kingdom","description":"Marine-based\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0could help the United Kingdom (UK) move towards a more sustainable and low-carbon energy system. Today, offshore wind is the prevailing marine renewable technology but there is growing progress towards developing others, such as tidal stream energy (TSE)\u00a0turbines\u00a0which capture\u00a0kinetic energy\u00a0from\u00a0tidal currents. Using historical operations data from 18\u00a0wind farms\u00a0and simulated generation data for two TSE sites in the UK, we estimate that TSE projects offer about $10\/MW\u00a0h more in net\u00a0social benefits\u00a0than offshore wind projects. This estimate includes the value of\u00a0energy generated, value of reduced marginal CO2\u00a0emissions, cost of visual changes to the landscape, and cost of\u00a0energy generation\u00a0forecast errors. However, relative to offshore wind, the increased cost of TSE projects far outweighs the increased social benefits. The\u00a0levelized cost of energy\u00a0(LCOE) of TSE projects is expected to be about $74\/MW\u00a0h to $330\/MW\u00a0h higher than offshore wind projects through 2050. Only with optimistic LCOE projections, small TSE projects (20\u00a0MW) may be competitive (when including increased net social benefits) with small offshore wind projects by 2020.","author":["Lamy, J.","Azevedo, I."],"organization":["Carnegie Mellon University"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.068429800000","-3.528431700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1083","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/politics-estonias-offshore-wind-energy-programme-discourse-power-marine-spatial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1177\/2399654418778037","title":"The politics of Estonia\u0027s offshore wind energy programme: Discourse, power and marine spatial planning","description":"There is growing recognition that marine spatial planning is an inherently political process marked by a clash of discourses, power and conflicts of interest. Yet, there are very few attempts to make sense of and explain the political practices of marine spatial planning protests in different contexts, especially the way that planners and developers create the conditions for the articulation of objections, and then develop new strategies to negotiate and mediate community resistance. Using poststructuralist discourse theory, the article analyses the politics of a proposed offshore wind energy project in Estonia within the context of the country\u2019s marine spatial planning processes. First, through the lens of politicization, it explores the strategies of political mobilization and the rival discourses of expertise and sustainability through which residents and municipal actors have contested the offshore wind energy project. Secondly, through the lens of depoliticization, it explains the discursive and legalistic strategies employed by developers, planners and an Administrative Court to displace \u2013 spatially and temporally \u2013 the core issues of contestation, thus legitimizing the offshore wind energy plan. We argue that the spaces created by the pre-planning conjuncture offered the most conducive conditions for residents to voice concerns about the proposed project in a dialogical fashion, whereas the marine spatial planning and post-planning phases became mired in a therapeutic-style consultation, set alongside rigid and unreflexive interpretations and applications of legality. We conclude by setting out the limits of the Estonian marine spatial planning as a process for resolving conflicts, while offering an alternative model of handling such public controversies, which we call pragmatic adversarialism.","author":["Tafon, R.","Howarth, D.","Griggs, S."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.874185000000","26.159308000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tafonetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1084","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-renewable-energy-environment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1201\/9780429463150","title":"Wind energy: renewable energy and the environment","description":"The utilization of wind power and other renewable energy sources has been growing at a phenomenal rate.\u00a0Wind Energy,\u00a0Third Edition\u00a0explores the wind industry from its inception in the 1970s to today; presents the design, aerodynamics, operation, control, applications, as well as different types of wind turbines. An overview of energy examines world consumption and use of fossil fuels, and includes a section on global climate change. It covers the characteristics of wind, such as shear, power potential, and turbulence, and discusses the measurement and siting of individual wind turbines and wind farms. It also discusses the political and economic factors regarding the adoption of wind as an energy source.","author":["Nelson, V.","Starcher, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1085","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-hydrokinetics-regulatory-processes-literature-review","sourceURL":"","title":"Marine Hydrokinetics Regulatory Processes Literature Review","description":"Under a project with the U.S. Department of Energy\u2019s Water Power Technologies Office Marine Hydrokinetic Program (Program), Pacific Northwest National Laboratory is reviewing existing marine renewable energy regulatory material in published, docketed, or circulated forms. This literature review describes existing regulatory conditions, details the regulatory history of seminal marine renewable energy projects, and summarizes recommendations from key reports about marine energy regulation.  There is substantial available literature regarding the environmental effects of marine energy. The authors intentionally avoided reviewing literature regarding direct environmental effects, instead focusing on the literature that provided insight into the regulatory impact of having little knowledge or no established mechanism to address those effects.  This report will be combined with over 30 interviews conducted in 2017 with experienced marine renewable energy regulators, stakeholders, and developers into an analysis of marine energy regulation.  The goal of the greater project is to identify actionable tasks to improve regulatory efficiency for marine renewable energy, to reduce the cost and time of deployment while preserving environmental stewardship and the needs of other ocean users.","author":["Staines, G.","Freeman, M.","O\u0027Neil, R."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.061913200000","-103.770736300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MHK-Regulatory-Processes-Literature-Review_Final.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1086","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ambemar-dss-decision-support-system-environmental-impact-assessment-marine-renewable","sourceURL":"","title":"AMBEMAR-DSS: A decision support system for the environmental impact assessment of marine renewable energies","description":"The high energy demand and the threat of climate change have led to a remarkable development of renewable energies, initially through technologies applied to the terrestrial environment and, recently, through the awakening of marine renewable energies. However, the development of these types of projects is often hampered by failure to pass the corresponding environmental impact assessment process. The complexity of working in the marine environment and the uncertainties associated with assessing the impacts of such projects make it difficult to carry out objective and precise environmental impact assessments. AMBEMAR-DSS seeks to establish a basis for understanding and agreement between the different stakeholders (project developers, public administrations, environmental organizations and the public in general), in order to find solutions that allow the development of marine renewable energies, minimizing their environmental cost. For this purpose, a DSS is proposed which, based on cartographic information and using objective and quantifiable criteria, allows comparative assessments and analyses between different project alternatives. The analytical procedures used by the system include, among others, hydrodynamic modeling tools and visual impact simulators. In addition, impacts on marine species are assessed taking into account intrinsic ecological and biological aspects. The magnitude of the impacts is quantified by means of fuzzy logic operations and the integration of all the elements is carried out by an interactive multi-criteria analysis. The results are shown in tables, graphs and figures of easy interpretation and can be also visualized geographically by means of a cartographic viewer. The system identifies the main impacts generated in the different phases of the project and allows establishing adequate mitigation measures in search of optimized solutions. The establishment of the assessment criteria has been based on the abundant, but dispersed, scientific literature on the various elements of the system and having the opinion of experts in the various fields. Nevertheless, the DSS developed constitutes a preliminary basis on which to build and improve a system with the input of researchers, promoters and experts from different disciplines.","author":["Lopez, J.","Abascal, A.","Garcia, A.","Guinda, X.","Puente, A.","Juanes, J.","Royano, F.","Fernandez, F.","Vega, M.","Garcia, J.","Aragon, G.","Otero, C.","Manchado, C.","Gomez-Jauregui, V.","Monteoliva, A."],"organization":["University of Cantabria"],"originationDate":"2018-06-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Guinda-2018-OMAE.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1087","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/are-magnetic-electromagnetic-fields-anthropogenic-origin-potential-threats-early-life","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/pubmed\/30780112","title":"Are magnetic and electromagnetic fields of anthropogenic origin potential threats to early life stages of fish?","description":"The number of underwater cables transferring electric current in sea and freshwater environments is constantly increasing. As a result, the risk of negative effects of magnetic fields generated in the vicinity of those cables on fish eggs and larvae is also growing. This is especially the case for species that settle on the bottom for certain periods of time during early development. To study those effects, eggs and larvae of rainbow trout, Oncorhynchus mykiss, were subjected under experimental conditions to a static magnetic field (MF) of 10\u2009m\u2009T and a 50\u2009Hz electromagnetic field (EMF) of 1\u2009m\u2009T for a period of 36 days (i.e., from eyed egg stage to approximately 26 days post hatching, dph). Neither MF nor EMF had significant effect on embryonic or larval mortality, hatching time, larval growth, or the time of larvae swim-up from the bottom. However, both MF and EMF enhanced the yolk-sac absorption rate. Although it was not related directly to magnetic field effect, it was also shown that larvae with absorbed yolk-sacs by the time of swim-up were less efficient in taking advantage of available food at first feeding (i.e., obtained smaller weight at age). That indicates the importance of processes affecting yolk-sac absorption rate.","author":["Andrulewicz, E.","Otremba, Z.","Fey, D.","Jakubowska, M.","Greszkiewicz, M.","Urban-Malinga, B."],"organization":["National Marine Fisheries Research Institute","Gdynia Maritime University"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1088","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stochastic-collision-risk-model-seabirds-flight","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/publications\/stochastic-collision-risk-model-for-seabirds-in-flight\/","title":"A Stochastic Collision Risk Model for Seabirds in Flight","description":"Collision Risk Models (CRM) are used to assess impacts on seabird populations in all offshore wind farms Environmental Impact Assessments (\u2018EIA\u2018) and Habitats Regulations Appraisals (\u2018HRA\u2018) in the UK. Existing models are unable to properly incorporate uncertainty in the input parameters into calculations of uncertainty in the collision prediction and consequently are not expressed in the outputs. Uncertainty in predicted collision has resulted in the delayed deployment of offshore wind projects, with projects being reduced in size or even cancelled. Not incorporating uncertainty when it is known to occur may be failing to meet the requirement from the European Court of justice to use, \u201c\u2026the best scientific knowledge in the field\u2026\u201d. This project aimed to create a CRM that incorporates variability in input parameters correctly into a predicted collision impact with estimated variability. In order to produce a model that was fit for purpose, stakeholders were consulted through a questionnaire-based survey. The survey results section was in seven parts, each asking about different aspects of the CRM. These were: CRM concept, user experience, CRM inputs, CRM operation, CRM outputs, CRM error checking and CRM improvements. The survey, while taking in to account the scope of the project, resulted in the following changes requested by stakeholders:  \u2022 Create a user-friendly interface for non-R users; \u2022 Speed up the code; \u2022 The number of turbines should be a user input; \u2022 Output predicted collision probability data; \u2022 Seasonal (as well as monthly \u0026amp; annual) assessment (default + user defined); \u2022 Error checking inputs and collision probability; and, \u2022 Monthly or seasonal flight height inputs.  The new stochastic CRM (sCRM) was based on the code written by Masden (2015), but had to be compatible with the Band (2012) offshore CRM. Testing showed that the predictions of the Masden (2015) code matched the predictions of the Band (2012) Excel spreadsheets for Option 1, but that differences in outputs for Options 2 and 3 arose because of a calculation error in Masden (2015) code. Consequently, the sCRM was based on an updated, and streamlined, version of the Masden (2015) code. The new sCRM was produced in two forms: Firstly, a Shiny app based on the R-code, available as an online tool, which can be run from: https:\/\/dmpstats.shinyapps.io\/avian_stochcrm\/ Secondly, the Shiny app can be downloaded as a package and run locally in a browser. It can be downloaded from: https:\/\/github.com\/dmpstats\/stochCRM","author":["Donovan, C.","King, S.","Caneco, B.","McGregor, R.","Webb, A."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-04-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/McGregor-2018-Stochastic.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1089","type":["Document","Document\/Guidance"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pontica-myth-reality-birds-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/331021011_Via_Pontica-Myth_and_Reality_for_Birds_and_Wind_Turbines","title":"Via Pontica-Myth and Reality for Birds and Wind Turbines","description":"The story is very interesting and indicative of our time marked by historical changes in Eastern Europe.The first reports of concentrations of migratory raptors on the western Black Sea Coast are reported by Alleon \u0026amp; Vian (1869, 1870) who have established an intensive migratory migration in the Bosphorus but they do not use the term Via Pontica. In 1930, the great Bulgarian ornithologist, Pavel Patev, published a report on the Black Sea coast for the purpose of searching for a suitable place for exploring bird migration. In his report Pavel Patev writes \u0022......... Observations on bird migration around the Black Sea have been made so far first by Mr Braun, who has been able to observe for many years the bird migration around Constantinople. According to his observations, a large number of birds, mainly raptors, fly over the Bosphorus to Asia Minor. The same writer assumes that these birds are moving along the western coast of the Black Sea and gave for the first time the name FLY WAY \u0022Pontius\u0022 ... \u0022 In 1970, this Pontiac road was mentioned as Via Pontica in two scientifically popular articles by the famous ornithologist and environmentalist Nikolay Boev (Boev 1970a, b). Over the next decades, the term Via Pontica is becoming more and more common in the scientific literature on bird migration on the Bulgarian Black Sea coast. How does this historical fact come to the idea of a bird-migration migratory airspace limited in a corridor and even to a ban on the construction of wind power facilities in the entire Dobrudja region of Bulgaria is described in the text.","author":["Zehtindjiev, P.","Manev, T."],"organization":["Bulgarian Academy of Sciences"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.405271000000","27.905197000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1090","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/rangifer-within-areas-human-influence-understanding-effects-relation-spatiotemporal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00300-018-2410-6","title":"Rangifer within areas of human influence: understanding effects in relation to spatiotemporal scales","description":"Depending on the spatial scale, fluctuations in the area use of social, migratory herbivores may be related to changes in population size, season, predation, climatic variation, different types of disturbance, and random animal movement. We present a review and case study highlighting how study design limitations and publication bias have influenced our current knowledge on effects of human disturbance on\u00a0Rangifer\u00a0spp. Our case study illustrates how yearly variation may lead to false conclusions about the effects of infrastructure. From 58 analyses presented in 52 reviewed papers, we found that 14 analyses had study designs comparing area use before and after construction of infrastructure, 24 included spatial time series of\u2009\u003E\u20096\u00a0years, 21 included spatiotemporal variation in their analyses, and only six contained both static and dynamic habitat variables. Categorizing the 58 analyses into 404 specific outcomes, we found that 64% of the authors focused their conclusions on negative effects and 14% focused on mixed effects but emphasized on negative effects of human activities and infrastructure, while only 53% of the outcomes actually showed negative effects, 34% no effects and 13% positive effects. Our review shows that only one study had a before\u2013after-control\u2013impact (BACI) design, and a majority of publications do not include before\u2013after (BA) designs (76%), have not included spatiotemporal variation (64%), and do not evaluate the effects of spatial fluctuations on\u00a0Rangifer\u00a0area use at long enough time intervals (only 8 studies had\u2009\u003E\u200910\u00a0years data). Although\u00a0Rangifer\u00a0is vulnerable to human disturbances, we have showed how the effects of infrastructure differ among studies and highlight the need for study designs that integrate and account for spatiotemporal variation in future studies, for a better understanding of\u00a0Rangifer(or wildlife) area use in relation to anthropogenic effects.","author":["Colman, J.","Tsegaye, D.","Flydal, K.","Eftest\u00f8l, S."],"organization":["University of Oslo","Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1091","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-solutions-address-climate-change-its-effects-marine-ecosystems","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2018.00337\/full","title":"Ocean Solutions to Address Climate Change and Its Effects on Marine Ecosystems","description":"The Paris Agreement target of limiting global surface warming to 1.5\u20132\u2218C compared to pre-industrial levels by 2100 will still heavily impact the ocean. While ambitious mitigation and adaptation are both needed, the ocean provides major opportunities for action to reduce climate change globally and its impacts on vital ecosystems and ecosystem services. A comprehensive and systematic assessment of 13 global- and local-scale, ocean-based measures was performed to help steer the development and implementation of technologies and actions toward a sustainable outcome. We show that (1) all measures have tradeoffs and multiple criteria must be used for a comprehensive assessment of their potential, (2) greatest benefit is derived by combining global and local solutions, some of which could be implemented or scaled-up immediately, (3) some measures are too uncertain to be recommended yet, (4) political consistency must be achieved through effective cross-scale governance mechanisms, (5) scientific effort must focus on effectiveness, co-benefits, disbenefits, and costs of poorly tested as well as new and emerging measures.","author":["Cheung, W.","Duarte, C.","Gattuso, J.","Magnan, A.","Bopp, L.","Hinkel, J.","Mcleod, E.","Micheli, F.","Oschlies, A.","Williamson, P.","Bill\u00e9, R.","Chalastani , V.","Gates, R.","Irisson, J.","Middelburg, J.","P\u00f6rtner, H.","Rau, G."],"organization":["Sorbonne University","University of British Columbia","King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST)","Aarhus University","The Nature Conservancy","Stanford University","GEOMAR, Helmholtz Centre for Ocean Research Kiel","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)","University of East Anglia","University of Hawaii","Utrecht University","University of California Santa Cruz"],"originationDate":"2018-10-04","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ocean_Solutions_to_Address_Climate_Change_and_Its_Effects_on_Marine_Ecosystems.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1092","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/europe-china-united-states-three-different-approaches-development-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.rser.2019.04.025","title":"Europe, China and the United States: Three different approaches to the development of offshore wind energy","description":"In those countries where wind plays a major role in the energy mix (EU, China and USA) actions have been carried out to develop offshore wind energy, albeit to varying degrees. These actions range from studying offshore wind to the development of laws and planning related to the construction of wind farms. Europe currently leads the way in offshore wind energy (with 84% of global installations), having achieved technical and commercial maturity, including the first floating wind farm to generate electricity, together with an emerging zero-subsidy culture. The Chinese wind industry has seen rapid development since 2005, however, well established laws, the use of a one-stop-shop system in the licencing process, and the establishment of higher feed-in tariffs (FITs), could all boost the Chinese offshore wind industry further. The possible future role of the USA in the offshore wind industry is now in the hands of its decision makers. A more streamlined licencing process, together with a long-term vision enshrined within stable economic incentives, could help to boost the offshore wind industry in the USA.","author":["Carvalho, D.","deCastro, M.","Costoya, X.","Salvador, S.","Gomez-Gesteira, M.","Sanz-Larruga, F.","Gimeno, L."],"organization":["Universidade de Vigo","University of Aveiro","NASA Goddard Space Flight Center","Universities Space Research Association\u00a0(USRA)","Universidade da Coruna"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind","Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1093","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/feeding-home-ranges-pacific-coast-feeding-group-gray-whales","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21642","title":"Feeding home ranges of pacific coast feeding group gray whales","description":"There is a lack of detailed information about the range and habitat use of gray whales (Eschrichtius robustus) during their seasonal occupation off the Pacific Northwest (PNW) coast from northern California to southeast Alaska, USA. These data are important for management because of anthropogenic pressures (e.g., indigenous harvesting, fishing gear entanglements, ship strikes, naval exercises, siting of marine renewable energy facilities). We applied satellite tags to 35 gray whales in the eastern north Pacific (ENP) off the coasts of Oregon and northern California from September to December 2009, 2012, and 2013. These whales are members of the Pacific Coast Feeding Group (PCFG), a subset of gray whales in the ENP that feed off the PNW, during summer and fall. Tracking periods for the satellite\u2010tagged whales in this study ranged from 3 days to 383 days. We applied a Bayesian switching state\u2010space model (SSSM) to locations for each whale track to provide a regularized track with 2 estimated locations per day and associated movement behavior (either transiting or area\u2010restricted searching [ARS]). We isolated the portion of the SSSM track in the feeding area for each whale by removing all southward and northward migration locations. We calculated home ranges (90% isopleths) and core areas (50% isopleths) for these non\u2010migrating, feeding\u2010area tracks with \u0026gt;50 SSSM locations using local convex hull utilization distributions. Feeding\u2010area home ranges for the resulting 23 whales covered most of the near\u2010shore waters from northern California to Icy Bay, Alaska, and ranged in size from 81\u2009km2 to 13,634\u2009km2. Core areas varied widely in size (11\u20133,976\u2009km2) and location between individuals, with the highest\u2010use areas off Point St. George in northern California, the central coast of Oregon, and the southern coast of Washington, USA. Nearshore waters off Point St. George were a hot spot for whales in the PCFG in late fall, close to where most of the whales were tagged; 19 whales had overlapping home ranges and 15 whales had overlapping core areas there. One whale, a male tracked for 383 days, did not migrate, spending the entire winter off Point St. George and the California\u2010Oregon border. Residence times (portions of the track with a minimum of 3 successive locations in ARS behavioral mode) ranged from 1 day to 142.5 days; 19 whales had residencies \u0026gt;30 days in some areas. Because most of the whales in this study were tagged in the fall in the southern portion of the feeding area, off northern California, results are weighted toward fall and winter movements. Although some whales were tracked into the spring and summer, additional tagging earlier in the year and in more northerly locations would provide an even clearer picture of gray whale use of feeding areas in the PNW. Nevertheless, these results constitute valuable information about high\u2010use areas for gray whales in this region, providing baseline home range data for future comparisons with regard to year\u2010to\u2010year variability, potential responses to climate change, and exposure to anthropogenic activities in the marine environment.","author":["Mate, B.","Lagerquist, B.","Palacios, D.","Winsor, M.","Irvine, L.","Follett, T."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.177209000000","-124.373759000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Feeding-home-ranges-of-pacific-coast-feeding-group-gray-whales.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1094","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sustainably-reconciling-offshore-renewable-energy-natura-2000-sites-interim-adaptive","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.enpol.2019.02.007","title":"Sustainably reconciling offshore renewable energy with Natura 2000 sites: An interim adaptive management framework","description":"The nascent nature of offshore renewable energy (ORE) technologies coupled with the existence of considerable data gaps and uncertainty on the receiving marine environment demands a paradigm shift in our approach to assessing and managing the impacts of the ORE sector on marine Natura 2000 sites. This paper investigates how the ecosystem-based principles of resilience and adaptive management can be best applied under the appropriate assessment process of the Habitats Directive to reconcile the increasing demand for offshore renewables and biodiversity conservation. In so doing, it challenges the strict interpretation of the precautionary principle which has been crystallised by the EU judiciary under the regime of Article 6(3) of the Habitats Directive and suggests embracing adaptive management as a better methodology to enhance the outcomes of the appropriate assessment in the face of uncertain impacts on Natura 2000 sites and their qualifying features. The aim of this study is solution-based: it seeks to improve the implementation of the assessment procedure of the Habitats Directive before it truly becomes an \u2018obstacle course\u2019 for offshore renewable energy developers.","author":["Le Li\u00e8vre, C."],"organization":["University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1095","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proceedings-wind-wildlife-research-meeting-xii","sourceURL":"https:\/\/rewi.org\/resources\/12th-wind-wildlife-research-meeting-proceedings\/","title":"Proceedings of the Wind-Wildlife Research Meeting XII","description":"Wind energy is recognized as a key component of reducing greenhouse gas emissions from energy production. By generating electricity with lower carbon emissions and water use than fossil fuels, wind energy benefits birds, bats, and many other animal and plant species. Yet wind energy development and operation, like most human activities including other forms of energy generation, can pose risks to wildlife. These proceedings document current research pertaining to wind energy-related wildlife fatalities; habitat and behavioral impacts at the project level as well as cumulative and landscape-scale impacts; and avoidance, minimization, and mitigation strategies and technologies. As the window of opportunity to prevent the most catastrophic consequences of climate change narrows, these proceedings reflect discussions among stakeholders \u2013 scientists, wildlife agencies, wind energy developers, and conservation organizations \u2013 about how to balance the need to understand and mitigate wind energy impacts with the need to expedite responsible development of wind energy.","author":["PNWWRM XII"],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-05-30 12:59:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1096","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-mammal-noise-exposure-criteria-updated-scientific-recommendations-residual","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aquaticmammalsjournal.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2019\/03\/45_2_southall.pdf","title":"Marine Mammal Noise Exposure Criteria: Updated Scientific Recommendations for Residual Hearing Effects","description":"This article evaluates Southall et al. (2007) in light of subsequent scientific findings and proposes revised noise exposure criteria to predict the onset of auditory effects in marine mammals. Estimated audiograms, weighting functions, and underwater noise exposure criteria for temporary and permanent auditory effects of noise are presented for six species groupings, including all marine mammal species. In-air criteria are also provided for amphibious species. Earlier marine mammal hearing groupings were reviewed and modified based on phylogenetic relationships and a comprehensive review of studies on hearing, auditory anatomy, and sound production. Auditory weighting functions are derived for each group; those proposed here are less flattened and closer to audiograms than the Southall et al. M-weightings. As in Southall et al., noise sources are categorized as either impulsive or non-impulsive, and criteria use multiple exposure metrics to account for different aspects of exposure. For continuous (non-impulsive) noise sources, exposure criteria are given in frequency-weighted sound exposure level (SEL, given in units relative to 1 \u03bcPa2-s or (20 \u03bcPa2)-s for water and air, respectively). Dual exposure metrics are provided for impulsive noise criteria, including frequency-weighted SEL and unweighted peak sound pressure level (SPL, given in units relative to 1 \u03bcPa or 20 \u03bcPa for water and air, respectively). Exposures exceeding the specified respective criteria level for any exposure metric are interpreted as resulting in predicted temporary threshold shift (TTS) or permanent threshold shift (PTS) onset. Scientific findings in the last decade provide substantial new insight but also underscore remaining challenges in deriving simple, broadly applicable quantitative exposure criteria for such diverse taxa. These criteria should be considered with regard to relevant caveats, recommended research, and with the expectation of subsequent revision.","author":["Southall, B.","Tyack, P.","Bowles, A.","Ellison, W.","Finneran, J.","Ketten, D.","Nachtigall, P.","Nowacek, D.","Reichmuth, C."],"organization":["Southhall Environmental Associates, Inc.","University of California Santa Cruz","Space and Naval Warfare Systems Center","University of Hawaii","Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution","Harvard University","Hubbs SeaWorld Research Institute","Marine Acoustics Inc","Duke University","University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2019-03-11","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Southall-et-al-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1097","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/coastal-environments-challenges-integrated-management-multi-use-settings","sourceURL":"https:\/\/erda-rte.eu\/sites\/default\/files\/Principles_of_env_policy_2018.pdf","title":"Coastal Environments \u2014 Challenges for Integrated Management in Multi-use Settings","description":"This chapter examines a range of contemporary issues relating to coastal management, and the challenge of delivering sustainable development of coastal and marine resources. While the geographic focus is European, literature from other regions of the globe is incorporated within the chapter sections. Indeed, many of the coastal issues addressed in this chapter are not specific to Europe\u2019s coastal domain; therefore, the content is applicable to many coastal locations outside of Europe. Within this chapter, coastal environments (including the marine component) are presented in terms of their socio-environmental character, how they are managed, salient issues and challenges, and associated management responses, and finally an examination of the outlook for the management of coastal environments is provided. Case study material is used to communicate contemporary approaches to integrated management of coastal environments.","author":["O\u0027Hagan, A.","O\u0027Mahony, C.","Gault, J.","Falaleeva, M."],"organization":["University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2018-12-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1098","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-chinese-wind-farms-climate","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1029\/2017JD028028","title":"The Impacts of Chinese Wind Farms on Climate","description":"As a renewable energy resource, wind energy has developed fast in recent years, and its impacts on climate have received widespread attention. In this study, a new wind farm fleet scenario is designed based on Chinese wind farm data from the Chinese Wind Energy Association and Chinese cumulative wind power capacity data from the Global Wind Energy Council. A mesoscale numerical model is used to simulate the impacts of wind farms on climate. The results indicate that the wind farms in the designed scenario could impact the local and regional climate in China, causing changes in both lower-level atmosphere (changes within 0.5K for 2-m temperature) and upper-level atmosphere (changes within 30m(2)\/s(2) for 500-hPa geopotential height) over several specific areas. The momentum sink and the turbulent kinetic energy source generated by wind farms are first separated to evaluate their respective contributions to the impacts of wind farms on climate.","author":["Sun, H.","Zhao, Z.","Luo, Y.","Chang, R."],"organization":["Tsinghua University"],"originationDate":"2018-05-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.694296100000","103.777703000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/The-impacts-of-Chinese-wind-farms-on-climate.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1099","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/study-wave-energy-propagation-patterns-western-black-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2076-3417\/8\/6\/993","title":"Study of the Wave Energy Propagation Patterns in the Western Black Sea","description":"The most relevant patterns of the wave energy propagation in the western side of the Black Sea were assessed in the present work. The emphasis was put on the western side because this is also the most energetic part of the Black Sea. The assessments performed relate some recent results provided by a numerical wave modeling system based on the spectrum concept. The SWAN model (acronym for Simulating Waves Nearshore) was considered. This was implemented over the entire sea basin and focused with increasing resolution in the geographical space towards the Romanian nearshore. Furthermore, some data assimilation techniques have also been implemented, such that the results provided are accurate and reliable. Special attention was paid to the high, but not extreme, winter wave energy conditions. The cases considered are focused on the coastal waves generated by distant storms, which means the local wind has not very high values in the targeted areas. This also takes into account the fact that the configuration of the environmental matrix in the Black Sea is currently subjected to significant changes mainly due to the climate change. From this perspective, the present work illustrates some of the most recent patterns of wave energy propagation in the western side of the Black Sea, considering eight different SWAN computational domains. According to most of the recent evaluations, the nearshore of the Black Sea is characterized by an average wave power lower than 6 kW\/m. The results of the present work show that there is a real tendency of the wave energy enhancement. This tendency, especially concerns the western side of the basin, where in the high conditions considered, values of the wave power about 10 times greater than the average have been noticed.","author":["Rusu, E."],"organization":["Dunarea de Jos University of Galati"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.382109800000","28.204289600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Study-of-the-Wave-Energy-Propagation-Patterns-in-the-Western-Black-Sea.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1100","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/non-conventional-energy-sources-geo-spatial-study-site-situation-production-economy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s12594-018-0959-x","title":"Non-Conventional Energy Sources: A Geo-Spatial Study of Site, Situation, Production and Economy of Wind Farms in Satara District","description":"Wind energy is a popular from the non-conventional energy sources in the World. In India states like Tamil Nadu, Gujarat, Orissa, and Maharashtra are as regarded as superior areas with respect to this type energy. The installed capacity of wind in India till December 2010 was 13,056.37 MW, principally distributed throughout the Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Rajasthan, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh, Gujarat, Kerala, Madhya Pradesh, West Bengal, etc. In Maharashtra, there are 38 wind farms and the 3655 wind machines are installed with the 3431.86MW capacity of power generation up to September 2013. In Satara district, 17 wind sites and also other some sites are discovered. At present there are 1636 wind turbines are installed with its capacity of power generation is 1122.61MW and the production of wind energy of 2183745.15KWh average per annum in Satara district.  The main objectives of the present paper are to assess the scope of non-conventional energy resources especially the power generation from wind and to analyze the trend and distribution of the wind mills and wind farms in Satara district. It is find out the amount of recovered from the power generation comes around 12 years without subsidy and around 8 years with subsidy. The total life span of wind turbines is 25 years. It is very much clean and does not cause any problem to the environment as well as to the survival on the surface of the earth. Therefore, it is inferred that the generation of power from wind is not only cheaper and permanent energy source but also a non-polluting, freely available source. It is helpful for the development of economically and socially in a region especially in rural development. With these consequences the income level will increase and it will further help in minimising the social disparities.","author":["Sule, B."],"organization":["Solapur University"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["17.679973100000","74.006804400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1101","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/current-status-wind-energy-policy-poland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118314472","title":"Current status of wind energy policy in Poland","description":"The European Union\u0027s energy strategy and environmental policies are achieving a sustainable, low-carbon and environment friendly economy by combating\u00a0global warming\u00a0and increasing production of energy from\u00a0renewable sources. These sources, which are characterised with high investment costs of required use of appropriate support mechanisms as introduced by relevant laws. The article presents the\u00a0current state and perspectives\u00a0of using\u00a0renewable energy sources\u00a0in Poland, especially\u00a0wind power. The economic analysis of investment in\u00a0wind farms\u00a0in Poland is presented according to a new act on renewable energy sources. This publication show how important appropriate government support is for producers of green energy.","author":["Gnatowska, R.","Moryn-Kucharczyk, E."],"organization":["Cz\u0119stochowa University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.118559200000","17.727364600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1102","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/why-does-offshore-wind-industry-need-standardized-hse-management-systems-evidence","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148119300345?via%3Dihub","title":"Why does the offshore wind industry need standardized HSE management systems? An evidence from Denmark","description":"The offshore wind sector is one of the key sources for producing renewable energy. Though there is a rapid growth in the offshore wind sector, there is still a dearth of synchronization in HSE (Health, Safety and Environment) standards. This paper attempts to ascertain what are the major challenges of the company specific HSE standards, why does the offshore wind industry need a standardized HSE management system and who can play the key role in this process? To achieve these objectives, this research applies the interview and survey techniques. The research identified several key challenges such as gaps in coordination and communication among the stakeholders, gaps in incident reporting systems and the absence of a common HSE standard to overcome these challenges. Seven stakeholders were identified who can influence the development process of a harmonized HSE management system. However, the operators and turbine manufacturers are the key stakeholders to play role in this development process. The results of this study provide the top management to understand the problems associated with the current un-harmonized company specific HSE management systems and how to address these problems by creating a common HSE management standard to achieve the goal of \u0027zero accidents\u0027.","author":["Ahsan, D.","Pederson, S.","Nielsen, M.","Ovesen, J."],"organization":["University of Southern Denmark","Aalborg University"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.209707700000","9.295234800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1103","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/economic-geography-variable-renewable-energy-impacts-trade-formulations-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032119301194?via%3Dihub","title":"The economic geography of variable renewable energy and impacts of trade formulations for renewable mandates","description":"This paper examines electricity market responses to flexibility provisions in prospective renewable energy mandates and the geographical incidence of impacts. Using an integrated model of electric sector investments and operations with detailed spatial and temporal resolutions, the analysis demonstrates how renewable mandate trade formulations for electricity and renewable energy certificates can materially impact power sector outcomes like capacity planning decisions, compliance costs, CO2 emissions, and the regional distribution of renewable development. There are substantial welfare gains, up to $84 billion in present value terms through 2050, from inter-regional electricity and permit trade (and costs of market fragmentation), but the degree and direction of impact depend on region-specific considerations. Allowing permit trade encourages greater deployment of wind and solar in regions with favorable investment environments and resources, but renewable capacity additions are appreciable in all regions since diminishing marginal returns and transmission constraints limit the benefits of overdevelopment in any single region. Model results suggest that regions will likely find it beneficial to generate at least half of their renewable mandate compliance obligations through in-state resources and that most of the economic benefits from inter-regional REC exchange can be captured with a relatively modest amount of trading flexibility. Trade flexibility is shown to have minimal impacts on CO2 emissions leakage nationally.","author":["Young, D.","Bistline, J.","Santen, N."],"organization":["Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1104","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/where-decibels-hit-water-perspectives-application-science-real-world-underwater-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/acousticstoday.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2015\/08\/Decibels.pdf","title":"Where the Decibels Hit the Water: Perspectives on the Application of Science to Real-World Underwater Noise and Marine Protected Species Issues","description":"Understanding the potential impacts of man-made underwater sound on the marine environment is a complicated and often controversial issue. Working as a scientist for over eight years at the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), a US federal agency, has afforded me a unique perspective on the importance and challenges of applying science to real-world issues associated with underwater noise and marine protected species. This article shares and highlights some of those aspects.","author":["Scholik-Schlomer, A."],"organization":["National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Scholik-Schlomer-2015-Decibels.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1105","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-acoustic-modeling-report-virginia-offshore-wind-technology-advancement","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/State-Activities\/VA\/2013-12-06_Appendix-M-2_VOWTAP-Underwater-Noise-Modeling-Report_FINAL.aspx","title":"Underwater Acoustic Modeling Report - Virginia Offshore Wind Technology Advancement Project (VOWTAP)","description":"Virginia Electric and Power Company, a wholly owned subsidiary of Dominion Resources, Inc. (Dominion) is proposing the Virginia Offshore Wind Technology Advancement Project (VOWTAP or Project), a 12 megawatt (MW), two turbine offshore wind demonstration project located approximately 24 nautical miles (27 statute miles, 43 kilometers) offshore of the city of Virginia Beach, Virginia (Figure 1). Other offshore Project facilities include a 34.5 kilovolt (kV) Inter-Array Cable that will interconnect the two VOWTAP wind turbine generators (WTGs), and a 34.5 kV Export Cable that will convey electricity from the WTGs to a landfall site located in Virginia Beach, Virginia (Figure 1).  Dominion is aware that construction and operation of the Project has the potential to cause acoustic harassment to marine species, in particular marine mammals, sea turtles, and fish populations. This technical appendix presents the acoustic modeling methodologies, as applied, to estimate the expected underwater noise levels generated during construction and operation of the proposed Project, including pile driving of wind turbine foundations, which is expected to generate the highest underwater sound levels.","author":["Tetra Tech Inc."],"organization":["Tetra Tech Inc.","Dominion Energy"],"originationDate":"2013-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.857437000000","-75.766218000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/TetraTech-2013-Noise.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1106","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behavioral-responses-minke-whales-balaenoptera-acutorostrata-experimental-fishing-gear","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S002209811100517X","title":"Behavioral responses of minke whales (Balaenoptera acutorostrata) to experimental fishing gear in a coastal environment","description":"Whale entanglement in fishing gear is a global problem, and underwater ropes associated with this gear are often the cause of injuries that can lead to fatalities. Minke whales (Balaenoptera acutorostrata) are especially at risk because they are relatively small, widely distributed, and often occur in coastal habitats where many types of fishing gear are deployed. It is unknown whether minke whales can detect and avoid ropes associated with fishing gear. To address this question we conducted a series of field experiments to measure behavioral responses of nearshore minke whales to underwater ropes simulating crab and whelk fishing gear. We also investigated correlations between whale behaviors and specific environmental variables. Our methods involved both visual and acoustic monitoring of whale behaviors near experimental ropes and buoys of different colors. A remote sensing system was also used to simultaneously monitor oceanographic conditions, record underwater sounds, and capture underwater video of whales swimming near ropes. Minke whales (N\u00a0=\u00a042) decreased their swimming velocity and altered their bearing when passing near experimental ropes, especially during trials with white and black ropes. Some minkes (N\u00a0=\u00a07) also altered their underwater swimming trajectories when passing near ropes, and often appeared to produce low-frequency vocalizations. Collectively this information provides strong evidence that minke whales detect and react behaviorally to the presence of underwater ropes that simulate fishing gear in nearshore areas. We hypothesize that visual and perhaps passive acoustic sensory abilities may be the mechanisms behind these rope avoidance behaviors. We recommend that high contrast ropes (white and black) be used with fishing gear in coastal areas to help minimize entanglements of minke and perhaps other whale species.","author":["Nowacek, D.","Gedamke, J.","Kot, B.","Sears, R.","Anis, A.","Marshall, C."],"organization":["Texas A\u0026M University","Duke University","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)"],"originationDate":"2012-02-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.238295300000","-64.277067300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1107","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-potential-impacts-energized-submarine-power-cables-crab-harvests","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0278434317301759","title":"Assessing potential impacts of energized submarine power cables on crab harvests","description":"Offshore renewable energy facilities transmit electricity to shore through submarine power cables. Electromagnetic field emissions (EMFs) are generated from the transmission of electricity through these cables, such as the AC inter-array (between unit) and AC export (to shore) cables often used in offshore energy production. The EMF has both an electric component and a magnetic component. While sheathing can block the direct electric field, the magnetic field is not blocked. A concern raised by fishermen on the Pacific Coast of North America is that commercially important Dungeness crab (Metacarcinus magister Dana, 1852)) might not cross over an energized submarine power cable to enter a baited crab trap, thus potentially reducing their catch. The presence of operating energized cables off southern California and in Puget Sound (cables that are comparable to those within the arrays of existing offshore wind energy devices) allowed us to conduct experiments on how energized power cables might affect the harvesting of both M. magister and another commercially important crab species, Cancer productus Randall, 1839. In this study we tested the questions: 1) Is the catchability of crabs reduced if these animals must traverse an energized power cable to enter a trap and 2) if crabs preferentially do not cross an energized cable, is it the cable structure or the EMF emitted from that cable that deters crabs from crossing? In field experiments off southern California and in Puget Sound, crabs were given a choice of walking over an energized power cable to a baited trap or walking directly away from that cable to a second baited trap. Based on our research we found no evidence that the EMF emitted by energized submarine power cables influenced the catchability of these two species of commercially important crabs. In addition, there was no difference in the crabs\u2019 responses to lightly buried versus unburied cables. We did observe that, regardless of the position of the cable, Cancer productus in southern California tended to move to the west and Metacarcinus magister tended to move to the east.","author":["Bull, A.","Love, M.","Clark, S.","Nishimoto, M.","McCrea, M."],"organization":["University of California Santa Barbara","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.429194000000","-120.584969000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1108","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-increasing-impact-socio-ecological-change-mediterranean-mountain","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.jenvman.2019.02.127","title":"Is wind energy increasing the impact of socio-ecological change on Mediterranean mountain ecosystems? Insights from a modelling study relating wind power boost options with a declining species","description":"The growing concern about future challenges of energy security and climate change has led to the expansion of renewable energy production, with a special emphasis on wind power. Despite the environmental advantages of wind power, it\u0027s important to assess the impacts caused by the presence of wind farms on wildlife, particularly on species also affected by habitat loss and degradation. In Mediterranean Europe, the skylark (Alauda arvensis) is a declining passerine that breeds in mountain habitats vulnerable to the abandonment of traditional management practices and climate change. We have created a spatially explicit agent-based model (ABM) in order to replicate the selection of territories, evaluating the effect of wind farms on the mortality rate of breeding males. We were especially interested in assessing the mortality rates related with the interplay between habitat loss due to socio-ecological change and increasing wind power using alternative strategies: adding wind turbines or substituting existing wind turbines by more powerful ones, i.e. repowering. Several known aspects related with the risk of collision of A. arvensis with wind turbines were considered, particularly regarding the male habitat selection and behaviour displayed throughout the breeding season. By simulating a sequential contraction of suitable habitat for the species, we found a substantial increase in the breeding territories superimposed to the wind farm influence zone. In these conditions males\u0027 relative mortality was predicted to suffer significant increases. For equivalent wind power, adding wind turbines produced significant increases in the males\u0027 relative mortality, whereas repowering didn\u0027t. Based on our findings we propose repowering as a defensible strategy to increase wind energy production without increasing A. arvensis collision risk. We highlight that this strategy might also benefit other vulnerable bird and bat species associated with declining habitats of mountain ridges in the Mediterranean region.","author":["Santos, M.","Cabral, J.","Ferreira, D.","Freixo, C."],"organization":["University of Tras-os-Montes e Alto Douro"],"originationDate":"2019-05-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.289702400000","-7.748243400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Passerines"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1109","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/rite-monitoring-environmental-effects-rmee-reports-draft-ver-mar-2016-rite-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/servlets\/purl\/1327331","title":"RITE Monitoring of Environmental Effects (RMEE) Reports (DRAFT ver. Mar 2016) RITE Project (FERC No. P-12611)","description":"2015 Annual Report - Monitoring of Rare, Threatened and Endangered (RTE) Species   Verdant Power hereby submits this 2015 annual report in accordance with Article 401 - Commission Approval, Notification, and Filing of Amendments of the above captioned FERC Pilot Project License for the RITE Project and NYSDEC WQC permit condition 14:  WQC Condition 14. Monitoring Rare, Threatened, and Endangered Species  Upon FERC License issuance, the licensee shall continue to monitor for rare, threatened and endangered species in the project area. The permittee shall submit annual reports by February 15 of each year. The report shall include, at a minimum:  1) a list of any rare, threatened, or endangered species observed at the project over the previous year;  2) the date, time, and duration the species was present in the project area;  3) a discussion of whether the installed project or any project features appeared to be impacting the observed species;  4) information on any actions taken or proposed by the permittee to limit impacts on those species. FERC further requires that the report be filed with the Commission incorporating comments from relevant agencies.","author":["Smith, R."],"organization":["Verdant Power","Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.763909600000","-73.947136700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Smith2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1110","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fish-finances-feasibility-concerns-about-tidal-energy-development-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.erss.2019.02.024","title":"Fish, finances, and feasibility: Concerns about tidal energy development in the United States","description":"This article explores stakeholder views on tidal energy in the state of Washington. Through compiling and analyzing three qualitative datasets, we take a triangulated approach to better understand stakeholders\u2019 positive and negative views, concerns, and needs regarding tidal energy and if and how these are represented through print and online news sources. We analyzed comments submitted during the permitting process for the Admiralty Inlet Pilot Tidal Project, comments included as part of a tidal energy mail survey sent to Washington residents, and media articles about tidal energy. We found four types of concern themes within negative views towards tidal energy: environmental, social, economic, and technical. Shared concerns between organized stakeholder groups and resident stakeholders about the project and tidal energy in general included concerns related to the harm to marine life, the loss of native fishing rights, expensiveness of development, increased electricity costs, and the engineering challenge of developing tidal energy. Concerns unique to stakeholder groups for the project included threats from scaling up, issues related to public safety and security, damage to cables, inability to stop the turbine, harm to terrestrial flora, and sediment disruption and contamination. Positive views were commonly associated with the need to address environmental issues, technological innovation and leadership, desire to have a diverse energy portfolio, and economic benefits.","author":["Dreyer, S.","Polis, H.","Jenkins, L.","Beaver, E."],"organization":["University of Washington","Arizona State University"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.060068700000","-122.775986700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1111","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/where-should-wind-energy-be-located-review-preferences-visualisation-approaches-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618306662","title":"Where should wind energy be located? A review of preferences and visualisation approaches for wind turbine locations","description":"One of the main drivers for acceptance of wind turbines by the public is their level of visual impacts. While recent studies have focused on estimating the welfare loss of visual impacts from wind turbines, a large share of the studies has used no or very simple visualisations of the visual impacts at stake. These studies thus rely on the cognitive skills of the respondents to imagine wind turbines of different sizes and at different locations. Based on a theoretical argument, we propose a framework for classifying different visualisation types and utilise it to review recent Stated Preferences (SP) wind power studies. The review is subsequently used to discuss the use of visualisations of wind turbines in the SP studies, highlighting the frequent choice of not using visualisations, as well as the need to raise the bar when designing scenario descriptions for valuation of the visual impacts of wind turbines.","author":["Ladenburg, J.","Hevia-Koch, P."],"organization":["Danish Energy Agency"],"originationDate":"2019-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1112","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-sound-field-impact-pile-driving-its-potential-effects-marine-life","sourceURL":"https:\/\/acousticstoday.org\/the-underwater-sound-field-from-impact-pile-driving-and-its-potential-effects-on-marine-life-peter-h-dahl-christ-a-f-de-jong-and-arthur-n-popper\/","title":"The Underwater Sound Field from Impact Pile Driving and Its Potential Effects on Marine Life","description":"Impact pile driving is a method used to install piles for marine and inland water construction projects using high-energy impact hammers. The installation of hollow steel piles in this manner can produce extremely high sound levels in the surrounding waters (as well as in the air). Given the large-scale development of offshore wind in European waters and plans for such development in US waters, along with an increasing need for upgrades in the in-water infrastructure, there is a growing concern about the potential effect of construction-related underwater sounds on marine mammal and fish populations.","author":["de Jong, C.","Popper, A.","Dahl, P."],"organization":["University of Washington","TNO (Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research) Wind Energy","University of Maryland"],"originationDate":"2015-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1113","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-exposure-pile-driving-sounds-fish-inner-ear-tissues","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.cbpa.2013.07.008","title":"Effects of exposure to pile driving sounds on fish inner ear tissues","description":"Impulsive pile driving sound can cause injury to fishes, but no studies to date have examined whether such injuries include damage to sensory hair cells in the ear. Possible effects on hair cells were tested using a specially designed wave tube to expose two species, hybrid striped bass (white bass Morone chrysops \u00d7 striped bass Morone saxatilis) and Mozambique tilapia (Oreochromis mossambicus), to pile driving sounds. Fish were exposed to 960 pile driving strikes at one of three treatment levels: 216, 213, or 210 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2\u00b7s cumulative Sound Exposure Level. Both hybrid striped bass and tilapia exhibited barotraumas such as swim bladder ruptures, herniations, and hematomas to several organs. Hybrid striped bass exposed to the highest sound level had significant numbers of damaged hair cells, while no damage was found when fish were exposed at lower sound levels. Considerable hair cell damage was found in only one out of 11 tilapia specimens exposed at the highest sound level. Results suggest that impulsive sounds such as from pile driving may have a more significant effect on the swim bladders and surrounding organs than on the inner ears of fishes, at least at the sound exposure levels used in this study.","author":["Carlson, T.","Casper, B.","Popper, A.","Halvorsen, M.","Smith, M.","Sun, H."],"organization":["University of Maryland","Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2013-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1114","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/overview-fish-bioacoustics-impacts-anthropogenic-sounds-fishes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/jfb.13948","title":"An overview of fish bioacoustics and the impacts of anthropogenic sounds on fishes","description":"Fishes use a variety of sensory systems to learn about their environments and to communicate. Of the various senses, hearing plays a particularly important role for fishes in providing information, often from great distances, from all around these animals. This information is in all three spatial dimensions, often overcoming the limitations of other senses such as vision, touch, taste and smell. Sound is used for communication between fishes, mating behaviour, the detection of prey and predators, orientation and migration and habitat selection. Thus, anything that interferes with the ability of a fish to detect and respond to biologically relevant sounds can decrease survival and fitness of individuals and populations.  Since the onset of the Industrial Revolution, there has been a growing increase in the noise that humans put into the water. These anthropogenic sounds are from a wide range of sources that include shipping, sonars, construction activities (e.g., wind farms, harbours), trawling, dredging and exploration for oil and gas. Anthropogenic sounds may be sufficiently intense to result in death or mortal injury. However, anthropogenic sounds at lower levels may result in temporary hearing impairment, physiological changes including stress effects, changes in behaviour or the masking of biologically important sounds.  The intent of this paper is to review the potential effects of anthropogenic sounds upon fishes, the potential consequences for populations and ecosystems and the need to develop sound exposure criteria and relevant regulations. However, assuming that many readers may not have a background in fish bioacoustics, the paper first provides information on underwater acoustics, with a focus on introducing the very important concept of particle motion, the primary acoustic stimulus for all fishes, including elasmobranchs. The paper then provides background material on fish hearing, sound production and acoustic behaviour. This is followed by an overview of what is known about effects of anthropogenic sounds on fishes and considers the current guidelines and criteria being used world\u2010wide to assess potential effects on fishes.  Most importantly, the paper provides the most complete summary of the effects of anthropogenic noise on fishes to date. It is also made clear that there are currently so many information gaps that it is almost impossible to reach clear conclusions on the nature and levels of anthropogenic sounds that have potential to cause changes in animal behaviour, or even result in physical harm. Further research is required on the responses of a range of fish species to different sound sources, under different conditions. There is a need both to examine the immediate effects of sound exposure and the longer\u2010term effects, in terms of fitness and likely impacts upon populations.","author":["Hawkins, A.","Popper, A."],"organization":["University of Maryland"],"originationDate":"2019-03-12","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/An-overview-of-fish-bioacoustics-and-the-impacts-of-anthropogenic-sounds-on-fishes.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1115","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interaction-between-hydrokinetic-turbine-wakes-sediment-dynamics-array-performance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148119301533","title":"Interaction between hydrokinetic turbine wakes and sediment dynamics: array performance and geomorphic effects under different siting strategies and sediment transport conditions","description":"In-stream hydrokinetic energy conversion devices can be deployed in large scale rivers to produce energy with minimal infrastructure costs. They are however shown to actively interact with the channel bathymetry and sediment transport generating a scour and deposition pattern similar to bridge pier. Symmetric, streamwise, aligned turbine installations have shown to introduce only local effects, yet complex configurations may trigger non-local morphodynamic instabilities. Experimental investigations, based on continuous spatio-temporal measurements of bed topography, explore a number of inflow conditions and siting strategies for axial-flow hydrokinetic turbine models. Results show that asymmetric turbine installations in a portion of the channel cross section may introduce weak non-local deformation of the mean bed topography and alter bedform migration velocities. Geomorphic effects become stronger with increasing shear stress and with rotors deployed up to half of the channel width, resulting in mean flow distortion within the channel cross section and inducing an alternating scour-deposition pattern resembling the signature of steady, forced fluvial bars. Non-local effects can be mitigated, narrowing the turbine array, or amplified, distributing turbines in a vane-like installation, leading to different estimates of energy production averaged at the power plant scale. A discussion on the key quantities governing geomorphic effects and the potential benefits of asymmetric turbine deployments is provided as a preliminary guideline towards the expansion of Marine Hydrokinetic energy in rivers.","author":["Hill, C.","Guala, M.","Musa, M."],"organization":["University of Minnesota","University of Minnesota Duluth"],"originationDate":"2019-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.982523000000","-93.255011000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1116","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/performance-resilience-hydrokinetic-turbine-arrays-under-large-migrating-fluvial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41560-018-0218-9","title":"Performance and resilience of hydrokinetic turbine arrays under large migrating fluvial bedforms","description":"The deployment of in-stream flow-energy converters in rivers is an opportunity to expand the renewable energy portfolio and limit carbon emissions. Device performance and lifetime, environmental conservation, and the safety of fluvial communities against flood events, however, present unresolved challenges. In particular, we need to understand how multiple submerged hydrokinetic turbines interact with the sediment bed and whether existing technologies can be deployed in morphodynamically active natural rivers. Here, we present a scaled demonstration of a hydrokinetic turbine power plant deployed in a quasi-field-scale channel with sediment transport and migrating bedforms. We measure high-frequency sediment flux, the spatiotemporally resolved bathymetry and the turbine model performance. We find that with opportune siting, kinetic energy can be extracted efficiently without compromising the geomorphic equilibrium of the river and the structural safety of the turbine foundation, even in the presence of large migrating dunes, thus paving the way for harnessing sustainable and renewable energy in rivers.","author":["Sotiropoulos, F.","Hill, C.","Guala, M.","Musa, M."],"organization":["University of Minnesota","University of Washington","Northwest National Marine Renewable Energy Center (NNMREC)","Stony Brook University"],"originationDate":"2018-07-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.982520000000","-93.255043000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1117","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/localised-anthropogenic-wake-generates-predictable-foraging-hotspot-top-predators","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s42003-019-0364-z#Abs1","title":"Localised anthropogenic wake generates a predictable foraging hotspot for top predators","description":"With rapid expansion of offshore renewables, a broader perspective on their ecological implications is timely to predict marine predator responses to environmental change. Strong currents interacting with man-made structures can generate complex three-dimensional wakes that can make prey more accessible. Whether localised wakes from man-made structures can generate predictable foraging hotspots for top predators is unknown. Here we address this question by quantifying the relative use of an anthropogenically-generated wake by surface foraging seabirds, verified using drone transects and hydroacoustics. We show that the wake of a tidal energy structure promotes a localised and persistent foraging hotspot, with seabird numbers greatly exceeding those at adjacent natural wake features. The wake mixes material throughout the water column, potentially acting like a prey conveyer belt. Our findings highlight the importance of identifying the physical scales and mechanisms underlying predator hotspot formation when assessing the ecological consequences of installing or removing anthropogenic structures.","author":["Waggitt, J.","Kregting, L.","Lieber, L.","Nimmo-Smith, W."],"organization":["Queens University","University of Plymouth","Bangor University"],"originationDate":"2019-04-04","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.367579000000","-5.544616000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Changes in Flow","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lieber-2019-Localised.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1118","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/exploring-landowners-post-construction-changes-perceptions-wind-energy-michigan","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0264837718307579","title":"Exploring landowners\u0027 post-construction changes in perceptions of wind energy in Michigan","description":"Researchers have suggested that residents\u2019 acceptance of wind turbines follow a U-shaped curve over time, starting with generally positive attitudes about wind energy, dipping once a project is proposed, and then rebounding after construction. This research considers how residents\u2019 perceptions of the benefits and negative impacts of wind turbines shift post-construction by surveying the same individuals (n\u2009=\u2009520) at two time periods after a nearby wind project became operational. We find that residents\u2019 perceptions follow two separate trajectories based on their perception of the fairness of the wind siting planning process and\u2014to a lesser extent\u2014whether they have a direct financial stake in the wind project. Residents who perceived a fair planning process tended to perceive greater benefits of wind turbines, job creation, and revenues for landowners specifically, while residents who perceived an unfair process perceived significantly greater negative impacts, including visual and noise problems, reduction of nearby property values, and human health problems. These results suggest that while energy business models that extent direct financial compensation to more landowners impact the attitudes of residents in the short-term, resident attitudes about procedural justice may have implications that extend well beyond the project planning stage, impacting long-term support for adding new and repowering old turbines.","author":["Smith, H.","Mills, S.","Bessette, D."],"organization":["University of Michigan","Michigan State University"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.816856100000","-87.313331200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1119","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/attraction-nocturnally-migrating-birds-artificial-light-influence-colour-intensity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320718309054","title":"Attraction of nocturnally migrating birds to artificial light: The influence of colour, intensity and blinking mode under different cloud cover conditions","description":"A growing number of offshore wind farms have led to a tremendous increase in artificial lighting in the marine environment. This study disentangles the connection of light characteristics, which potentially influence the reaction of nocturnally migrating passerines to artificial illumination under different cloud cover conditions. In a spotlight experiment on a North Sea island, birds were exposed to combinations of light colour (red, yellow, green, blue, white), intensity (half, full) and blinking mode (intermittent, continuous) while measuring their number close to the light source with thermal imaging cameras.  We found that no light variant was constantly avoided by nocturnally migrating passerines crossing the sea. The number of birds did neither differ between observation periods with blinking light of different colours nor compared to darkness. While intensity did not influence the number attracted, birds were drawn more towards continuous than towards blinking illumination, when stars were not visible. Red continuous light was the only exception that did not differ from the blinking counterpart. Continuous green, blue and white light attracted significantly more birds than continuous red light in overcast situations.  Our results suggest that light sources offshore should be restricted to a minimum, but if lighting is needed, blinking light is to be preferred over continuous light, and if continuous light is required, red light should be applied.","author":["Hill, R.","Dierschke, V.","Hill, K.","Aumuller, R.","Rebke, M.","Weiner, C."],"organization":["Avitec Research"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.767892200000","8.255003000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Lighting","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rebkeetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1120","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/numerical-modelling-effect-hydro-kinetic-turbines-transport-sediments-application","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.matec-conferences.org\/articles\/matecconf\/abs\/2019\/10\/matecconf_cifma2019_05003\/matecconf_cifma2019_05003.html","title":"Numerical modelling of the effect of the hydro-kinetic turbines on the transport of sediments - Application to the Rhone site.","description":"Interest in electricity generation from low carbon technologies and renewable energy has become recently the most discussed concern. The need of sustainable, predictable energy generation has led in recent years to the development of Stream Turbines (ST) and has become a near reality, to reach 20% from the total energy production in France on 2020. Determining the impact of ST on their environment is becoming a significant interest nowadays. Regional modeling with a representation of the turbines\u2019 array with bed friction or momentum sink approach were proposed to quantify the impacts far away from the turbines. Sanchez and al. (2014) have studied the flow changes around a farm of stream turbines operated in Ria de Ortigueira. They concluded that the flow modifications were concentrated at local scale. While Fairley and al. (2015) found that, a farm of ST does not have remarkable effects on the baseline morphodynamics of sandbanks at regional scale. The energy extracted by the turbine will alter the hydrodynamics of the stream by increasing or reducing the friction in areas around the turbines. The present contribution investigates further the impact of the deployment of riverine turbines on the variation of the sandy bed at local scale. The aim is to provide prediction of the evolution caused by multiple stream turbines.  The first part of study is dedicated to represent the turbine, by a momentum source, without the sandy bed, using first the Actuator Disk, then the Blade Element Momentum Theory (BEMT) to determine the effects of hydrodynamic blades efforts (Shives et al.2016). The second part is dedicated to study the transport of sands affected by the turbine. The mixture of water and sediment is modeled by an Euler-Euler two-phase flow approach (Zhen Cheng et al. 2016), it involves one phase as a granular phase which is treated as a continuum one such as the sediment phase. The open source CFD software package OpenFOAM (Field Operation And Manipulation) is used in this study. The numerical results are validated with experimental measures of Mycek and al. 2014 for the BEMT (figure I), and with Pham Van Bang et al. 2006\u2019s measures for sedimentation processes (figure II).  In terms of perspectives, the validated models have been used to study the evolution of the bed level and the dynamic processes of sedimentation near an optimized farm of turbines.","author":["Guillou, S.","Khaled, F.","Hadri, F.","Mear, Y."],"organization":["University of Caen Normandy (UNICAEN)","Versailles Systems Engineering Laboratory (LISV) of the University of Versailles Saint-Quentin"],"originationDate":"2019-01-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.533454000000","4.723168000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Numerical-modelling-of-the-effect-of-the-hyrdo-kinetic-turbines-on-the-transport-of-sediments-Application-to-the-Rhone-site.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1121","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/aero-acoustic-noise-distribution-prediction-methodology-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/12\/1\/18","title":"An Aero-acoustic Noise Distribution Prediction Methodology for Offshore Wind Farms","description":"Recently attention has been paid to wind farm noise due to its negative health impact, not only on human beings, but also to marine and terrestrial organisms. The current work proposes a numerical methodology to generate a numerical noise map for a given wind farm. Noise generation from single wind turbines as well as wind farms has its basis in the nature of aerodynamics, caused by the interactions between the incoming turbulent flow and the wind turbine blades. Hence, understanding the mechanisms of airfoil noise generation, demands access to sophisticated numerical tools. The processes of modeling wind farm noise include three steps: (1) The whole wind farm velocity distributions are modelled with an improved Jensen\u2019s wake model; (2) The individual wind turbine\u2019s noise is simulated by a semi-empirical wind turbine noise source model; (3) Propagations of noise from all wind turbines are carried out by solving the parabolic wave equation. In the paper, the wind farm wake effect from the Horns Rev wind farm is studied. Based on the resulted wind speed distributions in the wind farm, the wind turbine noise source and its propagation are simulated for the whole wind farm.","author":["Wang, T.","Xu, H.","Cao, J.","Zhu, W.","Wu, X."],"organization":["Yangzhou University","Nanjing University"],"originationDate":"2018-12-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/An-Aero-acoustic-Noise-Distribution-Prediction-Methodology-for-Offshore-Wind-Farms.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1122","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/toward-common-understanding-ocean-multi-use","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fmars.2019.00165\/full","title":"Toward a Common Understanding of Ocean Multi-Use","description":"The \u201copen ocean\u201d has become a highly contested space as coastal populations and maritime uses soared in abundance and intensity over the last decades. Changing marine utilization patterns represent a considerable challenge to society and governments. Maritime spatial planning has emerged as one tool to manage conflicts between users and achieve societal goals for the use of marine space; however, single-sector management approaches are too often still the norm. The last decades have seen the rise of a new ocean use concept: the joint \u201cmulti-use\u201d of ocean space. This paper aims to explain and refine the concept of ocean multi-use of space by reviewing the development and state of the art of multi-use in Europe and presenting a clear definition and a comprehensive typology for existing multi-use combinations. It builds on the connectivity of uses and users in spatial, temporal, provisional, and functional dimensions as the underlying key characteristic of multi-use dimensions. Combinations of these dimensions yield four distinct types of multi-use with little overlap between them. The diversity of types demonstrates that there is no one-size-fits-all management approach, but rather that adaptive management plans are needed, focusing on achieving the highest societal benefit while minimizing conflicts. This work will help to sharpen, refine and advance the public and academic discourse over marine spatial planning by offering a common framework to planners, researchers and users alike, when discussing multi-use and its management implications.","author":["Buck, B.","Krause, G.","Depellegrin, D.","Kafas, A.","Schupp, M.","Bocci, M.","Kyriazi, Z.","Lukic, I.","Schultz-Zehden, A.","Onyango, V."],"organization":["Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","University of Dundee","Thetis SpA","National Research Council of Italy (CNR)","Marine Scotland Science","Hellenic Centre for Marine Research (HCMR)","SUBMARINER Network for Blue Growth EEIG","University of Applied Sciences Bremerhaven"],"originationDate":"2019-04-02","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1123","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/meta-analysis-finfish-abundance-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/full\/10.1080\/23308249.2019.1584601","title":"Meta-Analysis of Finfish Abundance at Offshore Wind Farms","description":"Offshore wind farms are becoming increasingly common in the coastal margins of marine ecosystems worldwide. Yet, the effects that wind farm structures have on fish populations remain unclear. To explore potential effects, a meta-analysis of studies that have examined the abundance of finfish inside of wind farms compared to nearby reference sites was conducted. Using well-established meta-analytic methods, the overall effect size across all studies was calculated, and then changes in effect size for soft-bottom and complex-bottom oriented species were explored in association with several covariates including characteristics of the wind farm (depth, distance from shore, wind farm age), the sampling design (season, gear type, and distance from the turbine sampled), and ecosystem level characteristics (functional feeding group and fishing presence\/absence). The overall effect size was positive and significantly different from zero, indicating greater abundance of fish inside of wind farms. Likewise, positive and significant effect sizes were noted for several covariates for both soft-bottom and complex-bottom species. The findings of this study underscore the need for regional, national, and international collaboration on monitoring approaches and data sharing in order to develop a more holistic understanding of how offshore wind farms affect living marine resources.","author":["Methratta, E.","Dardick, W."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-03-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1124","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/role-adaptive-management-wind-energy-industry","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_1","title":"The Role of Adaptive Management in the Wind Energy Industry","description":"Adaptive management (AM) is a systematic process intended to improve policies and practices and reduce scientific uncertainty by learning from the outcome of management decisions. Although many nations are considering the use of AM for wind energy, its application in practice and in policy has been limited. Recent applications of AM have revealed fundamental differences in the definition of AM, its applications, and the projects or planning processes to which it might be applied. This chapter suggests the need for a common understanding and definition of and framework for AM and its application to wind energy. We discuss a definition of AM and technical guidance created by the United States (US) Department of the Interior\u2019s (DOI\u2019s) Adaptive Management Working Group. The chapter also examines how AM has been applied to wind energy development in several European nations and in the USA. The challenges and opportunities associated with implementation of AM for wind development are addressed, management actions in nations that exhibit attributes of AM are compared, and pathways to appropriate application and potential broader use of AM are explored.\n\nBook information can be found here.","author":["Copping, A.","May, R.","Gartman, V.","Bennet, F."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","Berlin Institute of Technology","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:14:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1125","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-establishment-us-offshore-wind-power-neodymium-flows","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41893-019-0252-z#Abs1","title":"Impact of the establishment of US offshore wind power on neodymium flows","description":"Wind power is often posed as a greenhouse gas emission mitigation option, yet from a global perspective, the constrained supplies of rare-earth metals required for large-scale offshore wind turbines seem increasingly likely to provide limits to offshore wind power and other rare-earth-metal applications in the coming years. A 2015 US Department of Energy study maps an ambitious roadmap for offshore wind power to be capable of meeting substantial US electric-generating capacity by 2050. Our study addresses the neodymium material requirements that would be needed. We find that regional differences in deployment schedules will result in complex patterns of new capacity additions occurring concomitantly with turbine retirements and replacement needs. These demands would total over 15.5 Gg (15.5 kt) of neodymium by 2050, of which 20% could potentially be avoided by circular usage from decommissioned turbines but only if recycling technologies are developed or, better still, magnets are designed for reuse. Because neodymium is deemed to be a \u2018critical material\u2019, these perspectives are vital information for the formation of policy related to wind-energy provisioning, to domestic production, and to the importation of the rare-earth elements that would be required.","author":["Fishman, T.","Graedel, T."],"organization":["Yale University"],"originationDate":"2019-03-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1126","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/use-unsupervised-learning-approach-characterizing-latent-behaviours-accelerometer-data","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ece3.1914","title":"The Use of an Unsupervised Learning Approach for Characterizing Latent Behaviours in Accelerometer Data","description":"The recent increase in data accuracy from high resolution accelerometers offers substantial potential for improved understanding and prediction of animal movements. However, current approaches used for analysing these multivariable datasets typically require existing knowledge of the behaviors of the animals to inform the behavioral classification process. These methods are thus not well\u2010suited for the many cases where limited knowledge of the different behaviors performed exist. Here, we introduce the use of an unsupervised learning algorithm. To illustrate the method\u0027s capability we analyse data collected using a combination of GPS and Accelerometers on two seabird species: razorbills (Alca torda) and common guillemots (Uria aalge). We applied the unsupervised learning algorithm Expectation Maximization to characterize latent behavioral states both above and below water at both individual and group level. The application of this flexible approach yielded significant new insights into the foraging strategies of the two study species, both above and below the surface of the water. In addition to general behavioral modes such as flying, floating, as well as descending and ascending phases within the water column, this approach allowed an exploration of previously unstudied and important behaviors such as searching and prey chasing\/capture events. We propose that this unsupervised learning approach provides an ideal tool for the systematic analysis of such complex multivariable movement data that are increasingly being obtained with accelerometer tags across species. In particular, we recommend its application in cases where we have limited current knowledge of the behaviors performed and existing supervised learning approaches may have limited utility.","author":["Scott, B.","Davies, I.","Owen, E.","Chimienti, M.","Travis, J.","Bolton, M.","Cornulier, T."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2016-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.065000000000","-6.408027300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1127","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/coastal-impact-hybrid-marine-farm-operating-close-sardinia-island","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/7271249","title":"Coastal impact of a hybrid marine farm operating close to the Sardinia Island","description":"The objective of the present work is to evaluate the down wave conditions and the coastal impact induced by a hybrid wave-wind farm that would operate close to the Sardinia Island in the Mediterranean Sea. The target area was selected in the vicinity of Porto Ferro, which is located in the northern part of the island. Considering the most relevant environmental patterns, SWAN model simulations have been performed in order to assess the possible impact of the marine power plant. As regards the hybrid farm considered, it can be mentioned that this is located in the center of the target area and it is developed around some WindFloat offshore wind turbines. Such kind of floating wind turbines are already operational, both in the North Sea and in the Iberian nearshore. For the present study, a number of 11 floating platforms were considered, the spatial configuration of the farm being designed according to the standard prescriptions of the wind turbine manufacturer. Furthermore, a generic wave farm was considered to be implemented over a distance of 3.5 km at about 500 m up wave the wind farm. The most important conclusion coming from the present work is that the future marine power plants, besides extracting renewable energy, can play also an active role in coastal protection.","author":["Onea, F.","Rusu, L."],"organization":["Dunarea de Jos University of Galati"],"originationDate":"2015-05-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.683781000000","8.179579000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave","Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1128","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimating-potential-mortality-griffon-vultures-gyps-fulvus-due-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_13","title":"Estimating the Potential Mortality of Griffon Vultures (Gyps fulvus) Due to Wind Energy Development on the Island of Crete (Greece)","description":"Crete has been characterized as an area with a high wind energy capacity due to its mountainous terrain and the strong prevailing winds throughout the year. At the same time, the island constitutes the last stronghold for vulture species in Greece, currently holding the largest insular population of Eurasian griffons (Gyps fulvus) worldwide (ca. 1000 individuals). Given the empirical data on the mortality of large raptors due to collisions with wind turbine blades, the aim of the present study was to predict the potential impact of wind energy installations on the griffon vulture population on the island. The study was developed in two steps, namely, (a) the spatial mapping of the existing and planned wind energy projects up to the year 2012 and the delineation of their risk area and (b) the calculation of the annual collision rate based on the expected number of vulture risk flights and the probability of being killed. Overall, the minimum number of fatalities due to collision of vultures to wind turbines was estimated at 84 individuals per year. However, this figure could drop by over 50% if the European network of the NATURA 2000 sites was set as an exclusion zone for wind energy facilities. The study pinpoints the need for proper siting of wind farms and the prerequisite of sensitivity mapping for vulnerable species prone to collision on wind turbines.   Book informatin can be found here.","author":["Xirouchakis, S.","Armeni, E.","Nikolopoulou, S.","Halley, J."],"organization":["University of Crete","University of Ioannina"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.274847400000","24.504105100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:44:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1129","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/lost-bias-multifaceted-discourses-framing-communication-wind-wildlife-research-results","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_12","title":"Lost in Bias? Multifaceted Discourses Framing the Communication of Wind and Wildlife Research Results: The PROGRESS Case","description":"In times of increasingly selective interpretations of research results, sound decision-making in environmental management can be complicated. Actors compete for opinion leadership over relevant findings. A recent example is the agitated debate over the study \u201cPrognosis and assessment of collision risks of birds at wind turbines in northern Germany\u201d (PROGRESS). This debate, arising in the science-policy-practice interface, challenges research results and subsequent implications for planning and decision-making processes. We used the PROGRESS discourse to conduct a \u201cframe analysis\u201d and identified relevant actors, their argumentation patterns and potential motives. Discourses reveal patterns of perception that can be spotted by content analyses of available statements. It became obvious that research results do not necessarily just reduce knowledge gaps. The frames \u201cwildlife protection and conservation\u201d and \u201cresearch methods\u201d were of major importance in the discourse, addressing the paramount question of whether wind energy development actually affects raptor populations. The discourse indicated, inter alia, that uncertainties still revolve around collision risk estimators, demographic population models, the efficacy of mitigation measures and whether the challenges at hand might be dealt with on a case-by-case or a metalevel planning approach. In conclusion, the question remains: Who might unanimously communicate both findings and implications? A thorough and bias-sensitive communication of research results might foster sound decision-making processes in the wind and wildlife sector, particularly based on \u201cbest available science\u201d efforts.   Book information can be found here.","author":["K\u00f6ppel, J.","Weber, J.","Biehl, J."],"organization":["Berlin Institute of Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.512532200000","13.324755900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:44:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1130","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/camera-trapping-versus-conventional-methodology-assessment-carcass-persistence","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_11","title":"Camera-Trapping Versus Conventional Methodology in the Assessment of Carcass Persistence for Fatality Estimation at Wind Farms","description":"In the last decades, there has been a worldwide increase in wind energy. Despite its advantages, wind farms carry negative impacts on bird and bat populations, such as direct mortality due to collision with wind turbines.\n\n\nCarcass searches beneath the turbines are mandatory to access this impact, as well as the assessment of two correction factors: searcher efficiency and probability of carcass persistence. The latter considers the possibility of carcass removal by scavengers (or any other event such as decomposition) between monitoring sessions, influencing the number of carcasses detected.\n\n\nCarcass persistence trials consist in randomly placing carcasses under the turbines and, in this study, checking them daily during a 15-day period. Camera traps are looked as an alternative that might reduce human and financial effort while allowing the collection of the exact removal time and characterization of the scavenger\u2019s guild.\n\n\nWe conducted trials in three different wind farms, in a total of seven campaigns (15-day carcass checking periods), across different seasons.\n\n\nWe compared the camera-trapping with the conventional methods and analyzed the influence of using continuous vs. censored data on the correction factor estimate and have not found significant differences.\n\n\nCamera traps allowed the recording of the exact removal time and the identification of the removal agent for most of the carcasses and allowed a significant reduction of the field work and the costs associated.\n\n\n\nWe present a few guidelines to be taken into consideration when using this method.\n\n\nCamera-trapping demonstrated to be a good method to replace the conventional method, ensuring at least the same results, while allowing the characterization of the scavenger\u2019s guild and a significant cost reduction.\n\n\nBook information can be found here.","author":["Mascarenhas, M.","Neves, T.","Rosa, L.","Vieira, D."],"organization":["Bioinsight"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.743605700000","-9.230243100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:14:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1131","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/automatic-bird-identification-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_9","title":"Automatic Bird Identification for Offshore Wind Farms","description":"There is a need for automatic bird identification system at offshore wind farms in Finland. The developed system should be able to operate from onshore, which is cost-effective in terms of installations and maintenance. Indubitably, a radar is the obvious choice to detect flying birds, but external information is required for actual identification. A conceivable method is to exploit visual camera images. In the proposed system, the radar detects birds and provides the coordinates to camera steering system. The camera steering system tracks the flying birds, thus enabling capturing a series of images. Classification is based on the images, and it is implemented by a small convolutional neural network trained with a deep learning algorithm. We also propose a data augmentation method in which images are rotated and converted in accordance with the desired color temperatures. The final identification is based on a fusion of data provided by the radar and image data. We present the results of the number of correctly identified species based on manually taken images.\n\nBook information listed here.","author":["Niemi, J.","Tanttu, J."],"organization":["Tampere University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.109867800000","24.738510200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:14:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1132","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farm-effects-migratory-flight-swans-foraging-distribution-their-stopover-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_8","title":"Wind Farm Effects on Migratory Flight of Swans and Foraging Distribution at Their Stopover Site","description":"Wind farms have unintended negative consequences for birds, such as bird collisions, habitat loss, and barrier effects. Japanese law now requires environmental impact assessments (EIAs) of wind farm construction. Despite these EIAs, assessments of wind farm effects on birds are often inadequate because no data are available that compare bird behavior and distribution before and after wind farm development. Here we investigated macro avoidance and the foraging distribution of swans before and after the construction and onset of operations of a wind turbine operation in Japan\u2019s Tohoku region. During the spring and fall migratory seasons, we used fixed-point observations to survey swan flight trajectories near a newly constructed wind farm and an existing, operational wind farm. Swan turning radius and trajectory altitude were used to determine macro avoidance of wind farms. Swan foraging distribution around wind farms was surveyed by car. Sightings of migratory swans drastically decreased in the wind farm areas, but swan foraging distribution around the turbines remained unaffected. This outcome may be because the wind farm is distant enough from existing swan foraging areas. We conclude that collision risk should be low because migrating swans avoided wind turbines, but their traveling distance is increased by the need to fly around the wind farm area.  Book information listed here.","author":["Moriguchi, S.","Mukai, H.","Komachi, R.","Sekijima, T."],"organization":["Niigata University"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.797204300000","141.047162600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Shorebirds","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:45:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1133","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/first-large-scale-offshore-aerial-survey-using-high-resolution-camera-system","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_7","title":"The First Large-Scale Offshore Aerial Survey Using a High-Resolution Camera System","description":"Aerial digital surveying techniques using aircraft flying at significantly higher and safer altitudes than observer-based aerial surveys have become a key tool in surveying offshore environments worldwide. In preparation for offshore wind energy development, the New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA) has initiated what is probably the world\u2019s largest (43,500 km2) and highest-resolution offshore aerial survey of marine wildlife. The survey uses ultrahigh-resolution aerial digital imagery captured with the purpose-built camera system \u201cShearwater III\u201d at 1.5 cm ground sampling distance (GSD) from a twin-engine aircraft flying at 415 m. This baseline study using an innovative survey technique will facilitate a more efficient planning of energy production offshore by providing the necessary information to meet regulatory requirements for environmental review of wind energy areas (WEAs). This review includes a high-level summary of methods and highlights the advantages of undertaking the NYSERDA surveys using high-resolution digital aerial techniques.\n\nBook information listed here.","author":["Rehfisch, M.","Clough, S.","Lampman, G.","Pembroke, A.","McGovern, S.","Wilmott, J.","Warford, S."],"organization":["Normandeau Associates Inc","New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA)","APEM Ltd"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.220234700000","-73.443817000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:14:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1135","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/avoidance-behaviour-migrating-raptors-approaching-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_3","title":"Avoidance Behaviour of Migrating Raptors Approaching an Offshore Wind Farm","description":"During three seasons, we studied avoidance behaviour of migrating raptors when approaching an offshore wind farm in northern Baltic Sea 20 km from the coast.  From a substation 1.8 km west of the wind farm, we recorded macro, meso and micro avoidance behaviour of individual raptors approaching the wind farm, using a pre-defined protocol. We defined macro avoidance as when the raptor completely avoids entering the wind farm, meso avoidance as a significant change in altitude or direction before arrival and micro avoidance as a sudden change of flight when passing a turbine at close range.  In total, 466 migrating raptors representing 13 species were observed of which 73% representing 9 species showed macro, meso and\/or micro avoidance behaviour.  Macro avoidance was recorded among ten of the species including 59% of red kites, 46% of common kestrels, 42% of sparrowhawks and 30% of honey buzzards. Three quarters of these raptors subsequently left the AOWF in a westerly direction, indicating that they returned to the mainland. The remaining birds flew either north or south parallel to the first row of turbines, suggesting they tried to navigate around the wind farm.  Our study demonstrated a barrier effect from the offshore wind farm influencing the migration of raptors by forcing some birds to use alternative and potentially more risky sea crossings. This may potentially affect survival and fitness of individuals and populations. Accordingly, we recommend that the location of important raptor migration routes is taken into consideration in siting of future offshore wind farms.   Book information can be found here.","author":["Jensen, F.","Blew, J.","Jacobsen, E."],"organization":["BioConsult SH","Orbicon"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.953135600000","10.781719400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:25:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1136","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wildlife-mortality-wind-facilities-how-we-know-what-we-know-how-we-might-mislead","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_2","title":"Wildlife Mortality at Wind Facilities: How We Know What We Know How We Might Mislead Ourselves, and How We Set Our Future Course","description":"To accurately estimate per turbine \u2013 or per megawatt \u2013 annual wildlife mortality at wind facilities, the raw counts of carcasses found must be adjusted for four major sources of imperfect detection: (1) fatalities that occur outside the monitoring period; (2) carcasses that land outside the monitored area; (3) carcasses that are removed by scavengers or deteriorate beyond recognition prior to detection; and (4) carcasses that remain undiscovered by searchers even when present. To accurately estimate regional or national annual wildlife mortality, data must come from a representative (or appropriately weighted) sample of facilities for which estimates of mortality account for all sources of imperfect detection. I argue that the currently available data in the United States and much of the world do not represent the impacts of wind power on wildlife because not all facilities conduct monitoring studies, not all study results are publicly available, and few studies adequately account for imperfect detection. I present examples illustrating the limitations of our current data and pitfalls of interpreting data without accurately adjusting for detection bias. I close by proposing a solution through a simplified monitoring process that can be applied at every facility as part of normal operations. Application of an unbiased estimator that accounts for all sources of imperfect detection would assure comparability of mortality estimates. Public access to reported estimates would achieve representation. With these data we could develop a clearer understanding of how wind power is affecting wildlife throughout the world and inform our efforts to address it.\n\nBook information can be found here.","author":["Huso, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.683313800000","-107.334644100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:14:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1137","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-wildlife-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2","title":"Wind and Energy Wildlife Impacts","description":"This book provides a state-of-art overview of the significant advances in understanding the impacts of wind energy on wildlife.  However, many challenges remain regarding planning and policy, assessment of direct and indirect effects on wildlife, methodological approaches, technology development, and mitigation strategies and their effectiveness.  The book comprises a selection of the best contributions presented at the 4th Conference on Wind Energy and Wildlife impacts, held in Estoril, Portugal, 2017. The contents promote the international cooperation among researchers, developers, regulators and stakeholders that have contributed to building knowledge on this topic.  Chapter 1: The Role of Adaptive Management in the Wind Energy Industry  Chapter 2: Wildlife Mortality at Wind Facilities: How We Know What We Know How We Might Mislead Ourselves, and How We Set Our Future Course   Chapter 3: Avoidance Behaviour of Migrating Raptors Approaching an Offshore Wind Farm  Chapter 4: Estimating Potential Costs of Cumulative Barrier Effects on Migrating Raptors: A Case Study Using Global Positioning System Tracking in Japan  Chapter 5: A Pioneer in Transition: Horizon Scanning of Emerging Issues in Germany\u2019s Sustainable Wind Energy Development  Chapter 6: The Mitigation of Impact and the Impact of Mitigation: An Ethical Perspective  Chapter 7: The First Large-Scale Offshore Aerial Survey Using a High-Resolution Camera System  Chapter 8: Wind Farm Effects on Migratory Flight of Swans and Foraging Distribution at Their Stopover Site  Chapter 9: Automatic Bird Identification for Offshore Wind Farms  Chapter 10: Towards an Ecosystem Approach to Assess the Impacts of Marine Renewable Energy  Chapter 11: Camera-Trapping Versus Conventional Methodology in the Assessment of Carcass Persistence for Fatality Estimation at Wind Farms  Chapter 12: Lost in Bias? Multifaceted Discourses Framing the Communication of Wind and Wildlife Research Results: The PROGRESS Case  Chapter 13: Estimating the Potential Mortality of Griffon Vultures (Gyps fulvus) Due to Wind Energy Development on the Island of Crete (Greece)","author":["Bispo, R.","Bernardino, J.","Coelho, H.","Costa, J."],"organization":["University of Lisbon","University of Porto"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1138","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/towards-ecosystem-approach-assess-impacts-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-030-05520-2_10","title":"Towards an Ecosystem Approach to Assess the Impacts of Marine Renewable Energy","description":"Since the beginning of the 2000\u2019, the French government ambition was to have an offshore wind production formed 40% of the renewable electricity in 2030. Three calls tenders of Offshore Wind Farms (OWFs) construction have been pronounced since 2011. However, no offshore wind farm (OWF) had been constructed at the end of 2017 due to long administrative procedures and numerous appeals in justice, at French and European levels. Nevertheless, several studies have been enterprised to identify the environmental conditions and ecosystem functioning in selected sites before OWF implantations. However, these studies are generally focused on the conservation of some species or groups of species, and there is no holistic study on the effects of the construction and operation of OWF on an ecosystem taken as a whole. In 2017, a complete and integrated view of the ecosystem of two future OWF sites of the eastern English Channel (Courseulles-sur-Mer and Dieppe-Le Tr\u00e9port) was developed to model the marine ecosystems before OWF implementation and to simulate reef effects due to new spatial occupation of maritime territory. Results contribute to a better knowledge of the impacts of the OWFs on the functioning of marine ecosystems. They also allow to define recommendations for environmental managers and industry in terms of monitoring the effects of marine renewable energy (MRE), not only locally but also on other sites, at national and European levels.\n\nBook information can we found here","author":["Dauvin, J.","Raoux, A.","Pezy, J.","Niquil, N."],"organization":["Normandie Universit\u00e9"],"originationDate":"2019-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["49.802980700000","-4.117743700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:14:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1139","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-nearshore-impact-hybrid-wave-wind-energy-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ijern.com\/images\/February-2013\/24.pdf","title":"Evaluation of the nearshore impact of a hybrid wave-wind energy farm","description":"The main objective of the present work is to evaluate the coastal impact of a hybrid wave-wind farm that would operate in the Romanian nearshore. The target area was chosen in the proximity of the Danube Delta. The simulations performed with the SWAN spectral model were focused on three main objectives: a) analysis in the geographical space of the influence induced by the hybrid farm; b) variations of the incident wave field on the contact with the wave-wind configuration line; and c) influence of the hybrid farm on the shoreline dynamics. Finally, it was observed that in the presence of the hybrid wave-wind farm for the average wave conditions the impact in the geographical space is rather insignificant with more significant variations for the nearshore currents, while for the second and more energetic case study the wave fields between the hybrid farm and the shoreline are significantly reduced.","author":["Rusu, E.","Diaconu, S.","Onea, F."],"organization":["Dunarea de Jos University of Galati"],"originationDate":"2013-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Diaconu-2013-Hybrid.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1140","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-wind-energy-cooperative-5th-science-all-committees-meeting-2018-workshop","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/workshops-proceedings.html","title":"Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative 5th Science and All Committees Meeting: 2018 Workshop Proceedings","description":"he Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC or Cooperative) is an alliance of experts from government agencies, private industry, academic institutions, and non-governmental organizations that cooperate to develop and disseminate solutions to reduce to the greatest extent practicable or, where possible, prevent mortality of bats at wind energy facilities. The BWEC is overseen by the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA), the Association of Fish and Wildlife Agencies (AFWA), Bat Conservation International (BCI), the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), the U.S. Department of Energy (USDOE), the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), and the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). BWEC\u2019s Oversight, Science Advisory, and Technical Advisory Committees met at NREL\u2019s National Wind Technology Center from June 5\u20137, 2018 for the 5thScience and All Committees Meetingto examine progress of the BWEC, review existing monitoring and minimization strategies, discuss emerging issues, assess the effectiveness of BWEC, and establish priorities for the Cooperative for the years 2018 to 2021.  Research Priorities and Emerging Issues  The BWEC discussed priorities for 2018\u20132021 in the following categories. Further detail on a wider range of possible activities are included later in this report. Discussions were informed by BWEC progress to date, BWEC participant research initiatives, and guest presentations. The priorities developed were designed to inform Oversight Committee decision-making and did not represent final decisions on specific activities. The priority categories are:    Population estimation, modeling, and data collection  Fatality estimation, modeling, and sampling  Bat behavior at the turbine-or facility-scale  Bat behavior at the landscape-scale  Operational minimization  Deterrent technologies  Other issues: expand network of international partners, monitor offshore wind development, dissemination and training, pre-post construction fatality risk relationship, explore policy options for implementation of practicable impact reduction strategies, monitor distributed wind development","author":["Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"organization":["Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"originationDate":"2018-06-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.913991300000","-105.217640200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BWEC-2018-Proceedingspdf.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1141","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-effects-monitoring-report-2011-2013","sourceURL":"https:\/\/fundyforce.ca\/document-collection\/environmental-monitoring-report-2011-2013","title":"Environmental Effects Monitoring Report 2011-2013","description":"FORCE is Canada\u0027s leading research centre for the demonstration and evaluation of tidal in-stream energy conversion (TISEC) technology. A key component of FORCE\u0027s mandate is to act as a watchdog regarding the environment. If TISEC technology is to grow to a larger, commercial scale project, development must happen safely. As turbines are deployed in the Minas Passage, FORCE is committed to understanding what effects they have on the environment, and reporting those effects to the public.   This is the second Environmental Effects Monitoring (EEM) report for the FORCE demonstration project and provides an overview of the EEM studies and projects completed in 2011 to 2013.","author":["Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"organization":["Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.371351000000","-64.403471000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Birds","Fish","Marine Mammals","EMF","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/FORCE-2014-Annual-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1142","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-effects-monitoring-program-annual-report-2017","sourceURL":"https:\/\/fundyforce.ca\/document-collection\/environmental-effects-monitoring-program-annual-report-2017","title":"Environmental Effects Monitoring Program Annual Report 2017","description":"The Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE) is Canada\u2019s leading research centre for the demonstration and evaluation of tidal in-stream energy conversion (TISEC) technology. This technology (commonly known as \u201cin-stream tidal turbines\u201d) is part of an emerging sector designed to generate electricity from the ebb and flow of the tide. It also has application in river systems and has the potential to introduce another non-carbon emitting source of electricity to the Nova Scotia electrical grid.   The first demonstration in-stream tidal energy turbine was operational at the FORCE site for a short time in 2009 and removed in 2010. There were no turbines present at FORCE until Cape Sharp Tidal Venture (CSTV) deployed a two-megawatt demonstration turbine in November 2016 and began a commissioning process. In April 2017, CSTV announced the turbine would be disconnected for temporary retrieval; on June 15th , the turbine was retrieved and moved to Saint John, New Brunswick shortly thereafter.  Environmental effects monitoring programs (EEMPs) began at FORCE 2009; to-date, over 90 tidal-related research studies have been completed or are underway with funding from FORCE and the Offshore Energy Research Association.  In 2016\/2017, EEMP work is being conducted with academic and research partners, including the University of Maine, the Sea Mammal Research Unit Consulting (Canada), Envirosphere Consultants, Acadia University, Luna Ocean Consulting, JASCO Applied Scientists, Ocean Sonics, and Nexus Coastal Resource Management.  The following document is a 2017 summary of mid-field monitoring work at the FORCE site that has taken place this year. The 2017 EEM Program has completed approximately: 11 days of lobster surveys using 48 traps, ~ 130 hours of hydro-acoustic fish surveys, 334 days of C-POD data collection resulting in \u0026gt;1,300 \u2018C-POD days,\u2019 16 seabird surveys, bi-weekly beach surveys, and four marine noise surveys. At the start of 2017, monitoring activities took place in relation to an operational turbine and continued throughout 2017 in the absence of a deployed instream tidal turbine. Monitoring is scheduled to continue into 2018. Year 1 reports on fish, marine mammals, and seabirds have undergone review by FORCE\u2019s environmental monitoring advisory committee (EMAC)2 and are included as appendices to this report.","author":["Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"organization":["Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.371351000000","-64.403471000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Birds","Fish","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/FORCE-2017-Annual-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1143","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-macro-economic-benefit-installing-farm-oscillating-water-columns-scotland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/11\/10\/2824","title":"Assessing the Macro-Economic Benefit of Installing a Farm of Oscillating Water Columns in Scotland and Portugal","description":"The nascent wave energy sector has the potential to contribute significantly to global renewables targets, yet at present there are no proven commercially viable technologies. Macro-economic assessment is seldom used to assess wave energy projects, yet can provide insightful information on the wider economic benefits and can be used in conjunction with techno-economic analysis to inform policy makers, investors and funding bodies. Herein, we present a coupled techno\u2013macro-economic model, which is used to assess the macro-economic benefit of installing a 5.25 MW farm of oscillating water column wave energy devices at two locations: Orkney in Scotland and Leixoes in Portugal. Through an input-output analysis, the wide-reaching macro-economic benefit of the prospective projects is highlighted; evidenced by the finding that all 29 industry sectors considered are either directly or indirectly stimulated by the project for both locations. Peak annual employment is expected to be 420 and 190 jobs in Portugal and Scotland respectively during the combined installation and manufacturing stage, with an associated peak annual GVA of over \u20ac16.6 m and \u20ac12.8 m. The discrepancies between the two locations is concluded to largely be a result of the site-specific attributes of the farm locations: specifically, increased water depth and distance to shore for the Portuguese site, resulting in higher costs associated with mooring and electrical cables and vessels. The insights gained through the presented results demonstrate the merit of macro-economic analysis for understanding the wider economic benefit of wave energy projects, while providing an understanding over key physical factors which will dominate estimated effects.","author":["Ingram, D.","Silva, M.","Draycott, S.","Szadkowska, I."],"organization":["WavEC Offshore Renewables","University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2018-10-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.182729600000","-8.703423800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Draycottetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1144","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/study-white-tailed-eagle-haliaeetus-albicilla-movements-mortality-wind-farm-norway","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/228501717_A_study_of_White-tailed_Eagle_Haliaeetus_albicilla_movements_and_mortality_at_a_wind_farm_in_Norway","title":"A study of White-tailed Eagle Haliaeetus albicilla movements and mortality at a wind farm in Norway","description":"The wind power plant on the island of Sm\u00f8la, western Norway, is currently the largest in Norway; it has 68 turbines with nominal capacity of 2\u20132.3 MW each, hub height of 70 m and rotor blade radius of 38\u201341 m,. It was constructed in two phases between 2001 and 2005. Approximately 60 White-tailed Eagle Haliaeetus albicilla territories are found in the whole Sm\u00f8la archipelago. Before construction there were 13 Eagle pairs holding territories in the wind farm area and within 500 m of it, whereas in 2009 this was reduced to only five. Since 1996, baseline data on the White-tailed Eagle population size and reproduction have been collected.  In a post-construction study, 50 fledglings were satellite-tagged during 2003\u20132009, of which 45 provided more than 80 000 GPS positions in total. In addition to the geographical location, data on altitude and flight speed were provided by the transmitters (Microwave Telemetry, Inc., Columbia, MD, USA). Juveniles of both sexes stayed within the Sm\u00f8la archipelago during their first winter. Most individuals moved away from the area during spring in their second year (April\u2013May). Females dispersed further than males, often more than 800 km during summer, generally to the north. There was a return movement to the natal area during the second autumn. The same pattern was repeated in the third and fourth years for females, while the males showed more philopatry (Bevanger et al., 2009).","author":["Bevanger, K.","Follestad, A.","May, R.","Dahl, E.","Nyg\u00e5rd, T.","Reitan, O.","Hoel, P.","Flagstad, \u00d8."],"organization":["Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","Norwegian Water Resources and Energy Directorate (NVE)"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["63.404412000000","8.023150000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nygardetal2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1145","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/social-acceptance-ocean-wave-energy-case-study-owc-shoreline-plant","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032113004772","title":"Social acceptance of ocean wave energy: A case study of an OWC shoreline plant","description":"Social acceptance, along with technical, economic and legal aspects, is a prerequisite for the successful adoption of renewable energies. Research into the social acceptance of the underlying implementation of different renewable energy technologies, such as grid connected photovoltaic solar, biomass and wind power plants, is increasingly gaining interest. Nevertheless, studies that address the issue of the social acceptance of sea wave energy plants are very rare. This article aims at making a contribution towards filling this gap analyzing the community acceptance of the oscillating water column (OWC) shoreline plant of Mutriku, a facility that has been subject of great interest due to its innovative technical characteristics. This article\u2032s findings emphasize the importance of effective and meaningful social involvement in the successful promotion and diffusion of renewable energy infrastructures such as wave energy plants.","author":["Heras-Saizarbitoria, I.","Zamanillo, I.","Laskurain, I."],"organization":["University of the Basque Country"],"originationDate":"2013-08-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.307097000000","-2.390316000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1146","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/strategic-policy-framework-promoting-marine-energy-sector-spain","sourceURL":"https:\/\/aip.scitation.org\/doi\/pdf\/10.1063\/1.4938405?class=pdf","title":"A strategic policy framework for promoting the marine energy sector in Spain","description":"Marine renewable energy (MRE), which includes wave, tidal, and offshore wind energy, has the potential to make significant contributions towards a sustainable energy future in a number of countries worldwide. One such country is Spain, where MREs are among the largest renewable resources; yet they are not playing their full part in the national energymix. Among other constraints, the lack of a specific policy framework promoting this emerging sector is often pointed to as the main barrier for MRE grid penetration. This paper assesses the Spanish MRE sector, in terms of resource availability, government plans, policyregulations, and projects undertaken, with a view to establish a comparison with the situation in other European countries. In particular, the United Kingdom is used as a case study to analyze ongoing research activities, pilot projects, and lessons learned. As a result, it is found that public funding needs to be increased; the economic crisis should be seen as an opportunity for job creation and industrial development rather than a barrier; administrative procedures must be simplified and cross-national cooperation should be increased. Policies focused on these aspects may contribute to boost the MRE sector in Spain.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Astariz, S.","Vazquez, S."],"organization":["University of Plymouth","University of Santiago de Compostela"],"originationDate":"2015-12-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.437869800000","-3.819620000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Vazquezetal2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1147","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-farm-effects-coast-alongshore-position","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969718319326","title":"Wave farm effects on the coast: The alongshore position","description":"For wave energy to become a fully-fledged renewable and thus contribute to the much-needed decarbonisation of the energy mix, the effects of wave farms (arrays of wave energy converters) on coastal systems must be addressed. The objective of this work is to investigate the effects of wave farms on the longshore sediment transport and shoreline evolution of a gravel-dominated beach and, in particular, its sensitivity to the longshore position of the farm based on eight scenarios. Nearshore wave propagation patterns are computed by means of a spectral wave propagation model (SWAN), variations in sediment transport rates induced by the farm are calculated, and a one-line model is applied to determine the shoreline position and dry beach area. The significant wave height at breaking is reduced in the lee of the wave farm, dampening sediment transport. We find that changes in the dry beach area induced by the wave farm are highly sensitive to its alongshore position, and may result in: (i) erosion relative to the baseline scenario (without wave farm) in three of the eight scenarios, (ii) accretion in three other scenarios, and (iii) negligible effects in the remaining two. These results prove that the alongshore position of the wave farm controls the response of the beach to the extent that it may shift from accretionary to erosionary, and provide evidence of its effectiveness in countering erosion if appropriately positioned. This effectiveness opens up the possibility of using wave farms not only to generate carbon-free energy but also to manage coastal erosion, thus strengthening the case for the development of wave energy.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Ortega-S\u00e1nchez, M.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["Plymouth University","University of Granada"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.709085000000","-3.542666000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1148","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wave-energy-converter-arrays-wave-induced-forcing-surf-zone","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0029801818303597","title":"The impact of wave energy converter arrays on wave-induced forcing in the surf zone","description":"An alternative metric for assessing nearshore hydrodynamic impact due to Wave Energy Converter (WEC) arrays is presented that is based on the modeled changes in alongshore radiation stress gradients in the lee of the array. The metric is developed using a previously observed relationship between measured radiation stresses and alongshore current magnitudes. Next, a parametric study is conducted using the spectral model SWAN to analyze the nearshore impact of different WEC array designs. A realistic range of array configurations, locations, and incident wave conditions are examined and conditions that generate alongshore radiation stress gradients exceeding a chosen impact threshold on a uniform beach are identified. Finally, the methodology is applied to two permitted WEC test sites to assess the applicability of the results to sites with more realistic bathymetries. For these sites, the overall trends seen in the changes in wave height, direction, and radiation stress gradients in the lee of the array are similar to those seen in the parametric study. However, interactions between the wave field and real bathymetry induce additional alongshore variability in wave-induced forcing. Results indicate that array-induced changes can exceed the natural variability up to 15% of the time with certain array designs and locations.","author":["Haller, M.","O\u0027Dea, A.","Ozkan-Haller, H."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.684279000000","-124.092341000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1149","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/protection-gravel-dominated-coasts-through-wave-farms-layout-shoreline-evolution","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969718315110","title":"Protection of gravel-dominated coasts through wave farms: Layout and shoreline evolution","description":"The impacts of wave farms (arrays of wave\u00a0energy converters, or WECs) on the nearshore must be fully understood for wave technology to develop and thus contribute to a sustainable, carbon-free energy mix in the near future. The objective of this work is to investigate the role played by the farm layout on the\u00a0wave propagation\u00a0patterns leewards and the implications for longshore\u00a0sediment transport\u00a0(LST) and\u00a0shoreline evolution\u00a0on a gravel-dominated deltaic coast. Changes in wave propagation in four scenarios, corresponding to as many wave farm layouts, are computed by means of a spectral numerical model (Delft3D-WAVE) under (i) low-energy and storm conditions, and (ii) westerly and\u00a0easterly waves\u00a0- the two prevailing wave directions. On this basis, sediment transport rates are computed and changes in the shoreline position assessed using a one-line model. To quantify the impact of the wave farm on the nearshore wave conditions, sediment transport and shoreline, we define three ad hoc indicators: the non-dimensional wave height reduction, the non-dimensional\u00a0LST\u00a0rate reduction and the non-dimensional shoreline advance.\u00a0Significant wave heightsdecrease in the lee of the wave farm, with the consequent reduction in LST rates. As a result, the dry beach area increases in every scenario under both westerly and easterly waves. We find that case studies with the WECs arranged on fewer rows but covering a greater stretch of coastline provide better\u00a0coastal protection. These results confirm that wave farms can be used not only to generate carbon-free energy but also to protect gravel-dominated coasts.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Ortega-S\u00e1nchez, M.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["Plymouth University","University of Granada"],"originationDate":"2018-09-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.710874000000","-3.557007000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1150","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimating-optimum-size-tidal-array-multi-inlet-system-considering-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261918315216","title":"Estimating the optimum size of a tidal array at a multi-inlet system considering environmental and performance constraints","description":"This paper investigates the optimum tidal energy converter array density at a tidal inlet by applying surrogate-based optimisation. The SBO procedure comprises problem formulation, design of experiments, numerical simulations, surrogate model construction and constrained optimisation. This study presents an example for the Faro-Olh\u00e3o Inlet in the Ria Formosa (Portugal), a potential site for tidal in-stream energy extraction. A 35\u202fkW Evopod\u2122 floating tidal energy converter from Oceanflow Energy Ltd. has been used for array size calculations considering two design variables: (1) number of array rows, and (2) number of tidal energy converter per row. Arrays up to 13 rows with 6\u201311 tidal energy converters each are studied to assess their impacts on array performance, inlets discharges and bathymetry changes. The analysis identified the positive\/negative feedbacks between the two design variables in real case complex flow fields under variable bathymetry and channel morphology. The non-uniformity of tidal currents along the array region causes the variability of the resource in each row, as well as makes it difficult to predict the resultant array configuration interactions. Four different multi-objective optimisation models are formulated subject to a set of performance and environmental constraints. Results from the optimisation models imply that the largest array size that meets the environmental constraints is made of 5 rows with 6 tidal energy converter each and an overall capacity factor of 11.6% resulting in an energy production of 1.01 GWh year\u22121. On the other hand, a higher energy production (1.20 GWh year\u22121) is achieved by an optimum array configuration, made of 3 rows with 10 tidal energy converters per row, which maximises power output satisfying environmental and performance restrictions. This optimal configuration permits a good level of energy extraction while having a reduced effect on the hydrodynamic functioning of the multi-inlet system. These results prove the suitability and the potential wide use of the surrogate-based optimisation method to define array characteristics that enhance power production and at the same time respect the environmental surrounding conditions.","author":["Pacheco, A.","Ferreira, O.","Sequeira, C.","Gonz\u00e1lez-Gorbe\u00f1a, E.","Plomaritis, T."],"organization":["University of Algarve","University of Cadiz"],"originationDate":"2018-12-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.018515000000","-8.002957000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1151","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-effects-monitoring-program-2018-annual-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/fundyforce.ca\/document-collection\/environmental-effects-monitoring-program-annual-report-2018","title":"Environmental Effects Monitoring Program 2018 Annual Report","description":"The Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE) is Canada\u2019s leading research centre for the demonstration and evaluation of in-stream tidal energy devices. The technology is part of an emerging sector designed to generate electricity from the ebb and flow of the tides that is being explored in countries throughout the world.\n\nFORCE was established in 2009 after undergoing a joint federal-provincial environmental assessment with the mandate to enable the testing and demonstration of these devices. Since that time, more than 100 related research studies have been completed or are underway with funding from FORCE, the Offshore Energy Research Association of Nova Scotia, and others. These studies have considered socio-economics, biological, and other research areas.\n\nThe latest monitoring programs at the FORCE site were initiated in 2016 in anticipation of turbine deployments by one of FORCE\u2019s \u2018berth holders\u2019, Cape Sharp Tidal Venture (CSTV) in 2016. These efforts are divided into two components: mid-field (i.e., 100 m or greater from a turbine) monitoring activities led by FORCE, and near-field (i.e., less than 100 m from a turbine) or \u2018turbine-specific\u2019 monitoring led by individual tidal energy developers or \u2018berth holders\u2019 at the FORCE site. All plans are reviewed by FORCE\u2019s independent Environmental Monitoring Advisory Committee and federal and provincial regulators prior to implementation.\n\nMid-field monitoring at the FORCE site presently consists of monitoring for fish, marine mammals, seabirds, lobster, and marine sound. Since the commencement of this latest monitoring effort in 2016, FORCE has completed:\n\n\u2022 ~408 hours of hydroacoustic fish surveys; \u2022 more than 2,600 \u2018C-POD\u2019 marine mammal monitoring days; \u2022 bi-weekly shoreline observations; \u2022 42 observational seabird surveys; \u2022 four drifting marine sound surveys and additional sound monitoring; and \u2022 11 days of lobster surveys.\n\nIn July 2018, CSTV installed a two-megawatt OpenHydro turbine at \u2018Berth D\u2019 of the FORCE site. Due to the insolvency of OpenHydro, announced four days after turbine installation, the approved near-field monitoring program and contingency monitoring program for this turbine could not be initiated. Efforts were taken to monitor the turbine in the interim, with a focus on fish and marine mammals, until the turbine was re-energized on September 4th, 2018. At that time, it was confirmed that the turbine\u2019s rotor was not turning, and the turbine-mounted monitoring sensors were re-energized (with the exception of one non-functioning hydrophone).\n\nAs a result of the status of the turbine\u2019s rotor, the monitoring requirements and reporting timelines approved as part of CSTV\u2019s authorization from Fisheries and Oceans Canada were subsequently modified to monthly confirmation of the turbine rotor\u2019s status. This is done through data collected from turbine-mounted acoustic Doppler current profilers during peak 2 tidal flow. Data from other operating turbine-mounted sensors are being used by FORCE and its partners to inform research objectives.\n\nFurther information regarding the turbine\u2019s status, CSTV project updates, and contingency monitoring efforts, is included in this report and Appendix 1.\n\nThis Annual Report provides a summary of monitoring activities and data analysis completed at the FORCE site throughout 2018. In addition, it also highlights findings from international research efforts, previous data collection periods at the FORCE site, and additional research work of FORCE and its partners. This includes supporting fish tagging efforts with Acadia University and the Ocean Tracking Network, radar research projects, and subsea instrumentation platform deployments through the Fundy Advanced Sensor Technology (FAST) Program. Finally, the report presents details regarding future research and monitoring efforts at the FORCE test site.\n\nAll reports, including quarterly monitoring summaries, are available online at www.fundyforce.ca\/environment.","author":["Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"organization":["Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.692324400000","-66.681345500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 06:16:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/FORCE-2018-Annual-Monitoring_report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1152","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-ocean-sprawl-ecological-connectivity-impacts-solutions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0022098117300618","title":"Effects of ocean sprawl on ecological connectivity: impacts and solutions","description":"The growing number of artificial structures in estuarine, coastal and marine environments is causing \u201cocean sprawl\u201d. Artificial structures do not only modify marine and coastal ecosystems at the sites of their placement, but may also produce larger-scale impacts through their alteration of ecological connectivity - the movement of organisms, materials and energy between habitat units within seascapes. Despite the growing awareness of the capacity of ocean sprawl to influence ecological connectivity, we lack a comprehensive understanding of how artificial structures modify ecological connectivity in near- and off-shore environments, and when and where their effects on connectivity are greatest.We reviewthe mechanisms bywhich ocean sprawl maymodify ecological connectivity, including trophic connectivity associated with the flow of nutrients and resources. We also review demonstrated, inferred and likely ecological impacts of such changes to connectivity, at scales from genes to ecosystems, and potential strategies of management for mitigating these effects. Ocean sprawl may alter connectivity by: (1) creating barriers to the movement of some organisms and resources - by adding physical barriers or by modifying and fragmenting habitats; (2) introducing new structural material that acts as a conduit for themovement of other organisms or resources across the landscape; and (3) altering trophic connectivity. Changes to connectivitymay, in turn, influence the genetic structure and size of populations, the distribution of species, and community structure and ecological functioning. Twomain approaches to the assessment of ecological connectivity have been taken: (1)measurement of structural connectivity - the configuration of the landscape and habitat patches and their dynamics; and (2) measurement of functional connectivity - the response of organisms or particles to the landscape. Our review reveals the paucity of studies directly addressing the effects of artificial structures on ecological connectivity in the marine environment, particularly at large spatial and temporal scales. With the ongoing development of estuarine andmarine environments, there is a pressing need for additional studies that quantify the effects of ocean sprawl on ecological connectivity.Understanding the mechanisms by which structures modify connectivity is essential if marine spatial planning and ecoengineering are to be effectively utilised to minimise impacts.","author":["Airoldi, L.","Dafforn, K.","Morris, R.","Coleman, R.","Bishop, M.","Mayer-Pinto, M.","Firth, L.","Loke, L.","Hawkins, S.","Naylor, L.","Chee, S."],"organization":["Macquarie University","Sydney Institute of Marine Science","University of New South Wales"],"originationDate":"2017-02-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bishopetal2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1153","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/basin-wide-contributions-underwater-soundscape-multiple-seismic-surveys-implications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X18308154","title":"Basin-wide contributions to the underwater soundscape by multiple seismic surveys with implications for marine mammals in Baffin Bay, Greenland","description":"Seismic surveys increasingly operate in deeper Arctic waters with propagation conditions and marine mammal fauna different from the better-studied temperate, or shallow-water, regions. Using 31 calibrated sound recorders, we quantified noise contributions from four concurrent seismic surveys in Baffin Bay, Greenland, to estimate their potential impacts on marine mammals. The impact was cumulative as the noise level rose in response to the onset of each survey: on a minute-by-minute scale the sound-exposure-levels varied by up to 70\u202fdB (20\u202fdB on average), depending on range to the seismic vessel, local bathymetry effects and interference patterns, representing a significant change in the auditory scene for marine mammals. Airgun pulse energy did not decrease to ambient before arrival of the next pulse leaving very little low-frequency masking-free time. Overall, the measured values matched well with pre-season-modeling, emphasizing the importance of noise-modeling in impact assessments, if responses of focal marine mammals are known.","author":["Kyhn, L.","Tougaard, J.","Beedholm, K.","Madsen, P.","Wisniewska, D.","Simon, M.","Mosbech, A."],"organization":["Aarhus University","Stanford University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["73.926280000000","-62.534180000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-08-21 10:00:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1154","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-platform-concepts-combining-offshore-wind-energy-fish-farming-freezing-sea-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=2704521","title":"Multi-Platform Concepts for Combining Offshore Wind Energy and Fish Farming in Freezing Sea Areas: Case Study in the Gulf of Bothnia","description":"Climate change together with increasing demand for space pose a challenge to energy and food production at sea areas. Co-location of offshore renewable energy production, aquaculture and other blue economy activities can answer the need for more sustainable marine space utilization while reducing and dividing costs of the different activities. This paper presents a case study of a multi-use platform that combines wind energy and fish farming in the Gulf of Bothnia, where the sea freezes every winter. A marine spatial planning (MSP) tool is used to find suitable locations for the multi-use platform with respect to economic potential of energy and nutrient production, structural solutions and environmental impact. The tool is used to visualize site selection criteria based on geographic information system (GIS) data such as seabed data, wind and wave data and ice data as well as protected marine areas. Production potential scenarios for the multi-use platform at different scales are calculated. Synergies of combining offshore wind energy and fish farming are discussed.","author":["Mikkola, E.","Heinonen, J.","Kankainen, M.","Hekkala, T.","Kurkela, J."],"organization":["Natural Resources Institute Finland","VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland"],"originationDate":"2018-06-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["62.825385700000","16.625226400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1155","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behavioural-physiological-effects-pile-driving-noise-marine-species","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ore.exeter.ac.uk\/repository\/handle\/10871\/36001","title":"The Behavioural and Physiological Effects of Pile-driving Noise on Marine Species","description":"Anthropogenic noise is a recognised pollutant in both terrestrial and aquatic environments. Noise levels in the ocean have risen greatly over the past few decades. The principal low-frequency background noise in the oceans is generated by commercial shipping, and can have a profound impact on fitness in a variety of marine species. Additionally, the loud impulsive noise from industrial pile-driving activity is increasingly prevalent in the oceans due to the recent development of offshore windfarms to meet renewable energy targets. Little research has explored the impact that this noise is having on marine species, especially invertebrates. The aim of this thesis is to explore the physiological and behavioural responses of marine species to playback of pile-driving noise, using playback of ambient marine sound as a control. The first study aimed to assess the physiological and behavioural response of the decapod crustacean Carcinus maenas to pile-driving noise playback in experimental tanks. In the physiological experiment, crabs did not significantly differ in their oxygen consumption or haemolymph parameters in response to pile-driving noise and ambient sound. However, in the behavioural feeding experiment, crab behaviour was significantly altered during pile-driving playback, including increased time spent immobile and decreased likelihood to feed. The second study aimed to assess the avoidance behavioural response of marine fish in their natural environment to pile-driving noise playback by use of a baited remote underwater video (BRUV) system coupled with a loudspeaker. Playback of pile-driving noise had a significant effect on the number of pelagic fish species surrounding the BRUV, indicating an avoidance effect. However, playback did not have a significant effect on the number of benthic fish species or species richness. Both these studies demonstrate that pile-driving noise causes behavioural changes in marine species, which could have potential fitness costs. Thus, exploration into ways of mitigating noise impacts when undertaking pile-driving activities in the ocean should be further explored.\n\u00a0","author":["Corbett, W."],"organization":["University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2019-02-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.737156900000","-3.543902300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1156","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-turbines-bat-activity-ommited-long-distance-concern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/314187294_Impact_of_wind_turbines_on_bat_activity_an_ommited_long-distance_concern","title":"Impact of wind turbines on bat activity: an ommited long-distance concern","description":"Wind farm developers have to provide an effective mitigation hierarchy: an avoidance and a reduction of negative impacts of wind farm on biodiversity (bats in our case), and to implement offsetting measures when residual impacts persist. Offsetting consists in implementing measures (e.g. hedgerows) that counteract residual losses of biodiversity and generate gains in order to achieve a no net loss or a net environmental benefit. Indeed, due to the reluctance of local people to install wind turbines near their homes, project developers often attempt to install wind energy facilities on agricultural land, particularly in arable land dominated by open fields or wooded countryside. Research and ecological impact assessments studies are focused for many years on bat mortality impact, without really know if the mitigation hierarchy applied is effective. Mortality is often describe as a significant negative impact on bat population, even though population parameters are poorly known, but what about habitat losses by revulsion? To our knowledge no study attempts to evaluate impact distance of wind turbines on bat activity. To determine the loss of number of bat passes according to distance to wind turbine, we performed a sampling design focused on hedgerows. We simultaneously recorded activity on 10 points per night, at 10 different distances to wind turbine. We studied one wind farm per night, and each record point was chosen in order to minimize differences in local and landscape characteristics with other simultaneous points. Sampled distances were between 0 and 1000 meters to wind turbines, thus, we did not use controls. A total of 36 wind farms were studied using 280 record points in north-west France. Results show for all species\/species groups, for which statistical analysis were possible, a significant negative impact of wind farms on bat activity. We found quadratic or linear positive relationship between bat activity and distance to wind farm, without threshold effects, except for Plecotus sp (around 750 meters). Predicted number of bat passes from models reveals a loss of a minimum of 50% within a range from 1000 to 0 meters. Amongst these species, some are known to be less sensitive to wind turbines in literature (i.e. mortality) are affected by long distances. Results indicates that loss of foraging and moving habitat is very important and could play an important role on population dynamics. This concern should therefore be taken into account in mitigation reflections and implementation ways, especially in wooded countryside regions.","author":["Julliard, R.","Kerbiriou, C.","Bas, Y.","Barre, K.","Le Viol, I."],"organization":["Museum National d\u0027Histoire Naturelle"],"originationDate":"2017-02-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.115910200000","1.723473800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/barreetal2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1157","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/noise-mitigation-during-pile-driving-efficiently-reduces-disturbance-marine-mammals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-1-4939-2981-8_92","title":"Noise mitigation during pile-driving efficiently reduces disturbance of marine mammals","description":"Acoustic monitoring of harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena\u00a0L., 1758) indicated a strongly reduced disturbance by noise emitted by pile driving for offshore wind turbine foundations insulated by a big bubble curtain (BBC). This newly developed noise mitigation system was tested during construction of the offshore wind farm Borkum West II (North Sea). Because porpoise activity strongly corresponded to the sound level, operation of the new system under its most suitable configuration reduced the porpoise disturbance area by ~90%. Hence, for the first time, a positive effect of a noise mitigation system during offshore pile driving on an affected marine mammal species could be demonstrated.","author":["Diederichs, A.","Nehls, G.","Bellmann, M.","Rose, A.","Pehlke, H."],"organization":["Institute of Technical and Applied Physics (itap) GmbH","BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.681421000000","2.758411000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1158","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-law-policy-bay-fundy-impact-ambiguous-domestic-boundaries","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.mainelaw.maine.edu\/oclj\/vol24\/iss1\/2\/","title":"Marine Renewable Energy Law and Policy in the Bay of Fundy: The Impact of Ambiguous Domestic Boundaries in Canada on Nova Scotia\u0027s Regulatory Framework","description":"Using a legal history methodology, this paper examines existing marine renewable energy law and policy in Nova Scotia with a focus on its application in the Bay of Fundy. This paper critically assesses the current approach to coastal management in light of recent recommendations summarized in the Fournier report. This paper argues that, despite clear calls to develop integrated ocean management and marine spatial planning in policies and regulations, Canada and Nova Scotia have failed to do so because of unclear federal-provincial boundaries. Ambiguous domestic borders in the Bay of Fundy have been at the source of an overly cautious, issue-driven and jurisdictionally uncertain approach to ocean governance which has permeated marine renewable energy law. This approach is unsuited for today\u0027s environmental objectives and does not hold promise for goals to reconcile competing interests in increasingly industrialised waters. Through a historical account of shifting limits in the Bay of Fundy, this paper connects existing doubts and frictions associated with domestic offshore boundaries to ineffective coastal management in an attempt to renew interest in federal-provincial maritime delimitation.","author":["Salcedo, E."],"organization":["University of Maine"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.021506300000","-67.514263600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Salcedo2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1159","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/resource-selection-wintering-phenology-white-winged-scoters-southern-new-england","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/condor\/article-abstract\/121\/1\/duy014\/5347918","title":"Resource selection and wintering phenology of White-winged Scoters in southern New England: Implications for offshore wind energy development","description":"Southern New England provides key wintering habitat for White-winged Scoters (Melanitta fusca). This area has also pioneered the development of offshore wind energy in North America. The U.S. Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) has established 9 Wind Energy Area (WEA) lease blocks along the Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf in areas that may provide important staging and wintering habitat for scoters and other species of sea ducks. Concern over the potential impact of offshore wind energy on sea duck populations has led to efforts to develop models to understand their distribution, habitat use, and site fidelity. We used satellite telemetry to document winter phenology and site fidelity, as well as fine-scale resource selection and habitat use, of 40 White-winged Scoters along the southern New England continental shelf. Scoters spent over half of the annual cycle on the wintering grounds and demonstrated a high degree of interannual site fidelity to composite core-use areas. Sizes of individual 50% core-use home ranges were variable (\u2060\u2060X\u00af = 868 km2; range: 32\u20134,220 km2) and individual 95% utilization distributions ranged widely (\u2060X\u00af = 4,388 km2; range: 272\u201318,235 km2). More than half of all tagged birds occupied 2 or more discrete core-use areas that were up to 400 km apart. Throughout the study area, scoters selected areas with lower salinity, lower sea surface temperature, higher chlorophyll-a concentrations, and higher hard-bottom substrate probability. Resource selection function models classified 18,649 km2 (23%) of the study area as high probability of use, which included or immediately bordered ~420 km2 of proposed WEA lease blocks. Future offshore wind energy developments in the region should avoid key habitats highlighted by this study and carefully consider the environmental characteristics selected by sea ducks when planning and siting future WEAs.","author":["Paton, P.","McWilliams, S.","Osenkowski, J.","Gilliland, S.","Olsen, G.","Meattey, D.","Lepage, C.","Savoy, L."],"organization":["Canadian Wildlife Service","Biodiversity Research Institute","University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2019-02-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.351241900000","-70.861096700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1160","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/high-resolution-hindcast-sea-level-3d-currents-marine-renewable-energy-applications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118313880","title":"A high-resolution hindcast of sea level and 3D currents for marine renewable energy applications: A case study in the Bay of Biscay","description":"In this work, we develop a high-resolution oceanographic database, suitable for marine renewable energy (MRE) applications. We apply downscaling techniques, using ROMS numerical model, to generate a 29-year (1985\u20132013), high-resolution (325\u202fm), hourly sea level and currents (10 vertical levels) hindcast that reproduces storm surge and astronomical tide dynamics at a MRE test site (BiMEP) in the Bay of Biscay.\nThe results are fully validated using instrumental data. We also analyze the result sensitivity to the open boundary conditions. We find that using boundary conditions from a baroclinic reanalysis, reproducing a wide range of physical processes, does not give more accurate results than a barotropic reanalysis, reproducing storm surge and astronomical tides, the main forcings at the study area. This analysis also leads us to address the importance of the temporal extent in the databases used for MRE applications.\nFinally, the generated hindcast is used to analyze normal and extreme currents and sea level regimes in BiMEP, following the internationally accepted standards for the design of MRE converters. The generated database offers MRE converter developers an alternative to the often-proposed empirical formulae for the definition of the design cases to consider in the loads and safety analysis of their devices.","author":["Chiri, H.","Cid, A.","Abascal, A.","Garcia-Alba, J.","Garcia, A.","Iturrioz, A."],"organization":["University of Cantabria"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.578404100000","6.701414000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1161","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-energy-development-bats-global-perspective","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007%2F978-3-319-25220-9_11","title":"Impacts of Wind Energy Development on Bats: A Global Perspective","description":"Wind energy continues to be one of the fastest growing renewable energy sources under development, and while representing a clean energy source, it is not environmentally neutral. Large numbers of bats are being killed at utility-scale wind energy facilities worldwide, raising concern about cumulative impacts of wind energy development on bat populations. We discuss our current state of knowledge on patterns of bat fatalities at wind facilities, estimates of fatalities, mitigation efforts, and policy and conservation implications. Given the magnitude and extent of fatalities of bats worldwide, the conservation implications of understanding and mitigating bat fatalities at wind energy facilities are critically important and should be proactive and based on science rather than being reactive and arbitrary.\n\nBook:\u00a0Bats in the Anthropocene: Conservation of Bats in a Changing World","author":["Baerwald, E.","Arnett, E.","Villegas-Patraca, R.","Rodrigues, L.","Voigt, C.","Mathews, F.","Rydell, J.","Rodr\u00edguez-Dur\u00e1n, A."],"organization":["Texas Tech University","University of Calgary","University of Exeter","Instituto da Conserva\u00e7\u00e3o da Natureza e das Florestas","Interamerican University of Puerto Rico","Lund University","Instituto de Ecolog\u00eda UNAM","Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Arnett-2016-Bats.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1162","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-golden-eagle-habitat-selection-flight-activity-their-home-ranges-safer-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0195925517303281","title":"Modelling golden eagle habitat selection and flight activity in their home ranges for safer wind farm planning","description":"Onshore wind farm development may impact vulnerable large eagles at both individual and population levels and requires appropriate assessment under the EU Bird and Habitat Directives. The present conservation policy (e.g. fixed safety zones around nest sites) improves species conservationbut may not prevent habitat loss or reduce collision risk in the best possible way because this policy may not consider habitat-specific effects on eagle behaviour. Here, we develop a method for estimating habitat use and flying time distribution within Golden Eagle (Aquila chrysaetos) home ranges. Location data retrieved with GPS-transmitters (Global Positioning system) in Finland indicated that these large raptors used vast areas (mean 297\u202fkm2, 95% Minimum Convex Polygon), reaching up to 14\u202fkm, but not uniformly around their nests. The best resource selection functionmodels (cross-validation performance 83%) revealed that flying Golden Eagles preferred the vicinity of their nests, steep slopes, and old forests in their home range. They avoided human settlements and neighboring territories. GPSdata indicated short flying times per day (mean 2.2\u202fh) and about 30% of the flying time within collision risk heights (50\u2013200\u202fm). Together with information on habitat selection, flying times can be used for predicting airspace use of birds and in assessing the collision risk at particular wind farm locations. Thus, our method can be applied in planning wind farm locations that enable a safer co-existence of large territorial birds and wind power plants in the same landscape.","author":["Tikkanen, H.","Rytk\u00f6nen, S.","Karlin, O.","Ollila, T.","Pakanen, V.","Tuohimaa, H.","Orell, M."],"organization":["University of Oulu"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["63.549467000000","23.694803000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1163","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-black-naped-hares-lepus-nigricollis-mammalia-lagomorpha-leporidae-have-synanthropic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/325998389_Do_Black-naped_Hares_Lepus_nigricollis_Mammalia_Lagomorpha_Leporidae_have_synanthropic_association_with_wind_farms","title":"Do Black-naped Hares Lepus nigricollis (Mammalia: Lagomorpha: Leporidae) have synanthropic association with wind farms?","description":"Wind energy is an upcoming major source of clean energy. The unprecedented proliferation of wind farms across landscapes has raised concerns on the environmental impacts. Generally reported direct impacts of wind farms include collision of birds and bats with turbines, habitat alterations, noise pollution from the turbines, aesthetic impact on landscapes and displacement of faunal species. Here we report our preliminary results indicating an apparent positive association of Indian Hares Lepus nigricollis with a wind farm in a scrub forest area. This study was conducted at Harada Reserve Forest near Harapanahalli of Davangere District, Karnataka, India. The pellet count method was used for comparing the abundance of the species between areas. The abundance of Indian Hares in wind farm area was significantly higher than in the surrounding forest area without turbines. The factors that might be affecting this pattern of preferential use of wind farm area by the Indian Hare are discussed and the scope for further studies also highlighted.","author":["Arun, P.","Anoop, V.","Jaypal, R."],"organization":["Salim Ali Centre for Ornithology and Natural History (SACON)"],"originationDate":"2018-06-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["14.766485000000","75.980519000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Anoop-2018-Hares.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1164","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/avian-monitoring-mortality-report-national-wind-technology-center-january-2010","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrel.gov\/docs\/fy18osti\/70626.pdf","title":"Avian Monitoring and Mortality Report at the National Wind Technology Center: January 2010 - February 2011","description":"The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) contracted Tetra Tech EC, Inc. (Tetra Tech) to conduct avian monitoring and bird and bat mortality surveys at the National Wind Technology Center (NWTC) in 2010\u20132011 to quantify local avian use in the NWTC and vicinity and to assess potential impacts to avian and bat species associated with the wind turbines and associated meteorological (met) towers at NWTC. Several different types of wind turbines are present on the NWTC with different capacities for energy production (1 kilowatt\u20133 megawatts [MW]; varying hub heights and turbine blade lengths) and met towers (guyed and unguyed) that vary in height (9.1\u2013135 meters [m]). Installation of three newer generation, multi-MW wind turbines (large turbines) has raised awareness regarding the potential for wildlife impacts. In a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) review of the large turbine installations, DOE requested monitoring of avian and bat mortality be conducted, so that mitigation measures could be developed if impacts to avian and bat species are observed.   To quantify local avian use in the NWTC and vicinity, Tetra Tech conducted avian point count surveys at 6 locations within the NWTC, as well as at reference locations in the adjacent Rocky Flats National Wildlife Refuge (3 locations; Rocky Flats) and the nearby Boulder County Open Space (3 locations; Boulder County). Further, Tetra Tech conducted breeding bird transect surveys to assess use of the NWTC by breeding grassland birds. To assess potential impacts to avian and bat species associated with the operation of wind turbines and associated met towers at the NWTC, Tetra Tech conducted fatality monitoring surveys at all vertical structures within the NWTC including observer efficiency and carcass persistence trials to refine the mortality estimation. It is therefore important to note when considering the results that multiple factors influence the probability of a species to have negative interactions with turbines, met towers, or guy wires, including the number of individuals at the site and the frequency that the species flies at rotor-swept area (RSA) height. Additionally, the relationship between avian use and mortality is not yet completely well-defined (NWCC 2010). Conclusions discussed below were based upon available data.","author":["Tetra Tech Inc."],"organization":["Tetra Tech Inc.","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.913646000000","-105.215489000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tetra-Tech-2018-Avian-Monitoring.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1165","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-conservation-barrier-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/conferences.iaia.org\/2018\/final-papers\/Montano,%20Marcelo%20-%20Bird%20conservatiion%20-%20wind%20energy.pdf","title":"Is bird conservation a barrier to wind energy?","description":"Project\u2019s location is a major aspect to prevent significant adverse impacts on biodiversity, such as mortality of birds and bats, disturbance of migratory routes, and loss of habitats. The identification of alternatives that presents adequate environmental conditions is essential requirement for Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA). However, EIA literature features the poor consideration of alternatives. This study presents the application of a methodology for integration of birdlife conservation during the identification of suitable areas for wind energy. This methodology is based on criteria defined through a review of literature and the creation of suitability map using GIS tools and multi-criteria decision making. Topics covered by suitability maps include protected areas, habitats of migratory and endangered birds, breeding areas, and wind speed. The Brazilian state of Bahia was the object of study, since it has important birdlife and great wind power installed capacity. The current location of wind farms indicates that the sites selection presumably was based on technical aspects over environmental criteria. However, the results indicate that the birdlife conservation is not a barrier for wind energy expansion, since a scenario of expansion is possible when restrictions that prevents tradeoffs between its conservation are considered. This study aims to contribute towards the improvement of the alternative sites identification, and of EIA process.","author":["Aversa, I.","Polizel, J.","Monta\u00f1o, M."],"organization":["University of S\u00e3o Paulo (USP)"],"originationDate":"2018-05-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["-12.749024000000","-41.673971000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Aversa-2018-Bird-conservation.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1166","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/billia-croo-fisheries-project-final-report-scottish-government","sourceURL":"","title":"Billia Croo Fisheries Project: Final Report to the Scottish Government","description":"The European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) wave energy converter test site, at Billia Croo, Orkney Islands, is within an area commonly used as a lobster fishery. In summer 2010 a Scottish Government funded project to investigate the possible effects of marine energy converter deployments on resident crustacean species within the area of the EMEC Billia Croo test site was established. This collaborative project, led by EMEC, had scientific input from Herriot Watt University\u2019s International Centre for Island Technology (ICIT) and Seafood Scotland, and industry input from Orkney Fishermen\u2019s Society (OFS) and Orkney Fishermen\u2019s Association (OFA).   The project encompassed two broad aims: firstly, to determine the likely influence of a small-scale refuge area on local lobster population abundance and availability to the fishery; and secondly to explore the potential for using such areas to augment local lobster stocks by using them as nursery grounds for the release of hatchery-reared juveniles. A supplementary aim of the project was to characterise experimental creel catches of all crustacean species in the area in the context of catches experienced by the commercial fishery operating in adjacent areas open to fishing.   The study concludes that the area within the EMEC wave test site at Billia Croo provides suitable feeding and refuge habitat for lobster, and has the potential to act as a nursery area to both the local fishery and to the Orkney Islands as a whole. Continuation of the project will be essential in order to assess the survivability and mobility of juvenile lobster electronically tagged and released during this project. The potential for artificial structures placed on the seabed during development of marine renewable projects to act as juvenile lobster habitat also requires further investigation. Previous sampling of lobster and brown crab landings across Orkney can provide valuable information on catch composition, but data on effort and catch rate are lacking and should be an important component of any future monitoring programme in order to determine stock abundance.","author":["European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)"],"organization":["European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2012-11-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.960955000000","-3.293149000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-20 11:22:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EMEC-2012-Billia-Croo-Fisheries.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1167","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-statistical-models-baseline-characterization-measuring-change-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/depts.washington.edu\/pmec\/docs\/Linder_thesis_2016.pdf","title":"Evaluating Statistical Models for Baseline Characterization and Measuring Change in Environmental Monitoring Data","description":"In Before-After monitoring studies, statistical models are used to characterize baseline (i.e., predisturbance) conditions, and to detect, quantify, and forecast change during operational monitoring (i.e., post-disturbance). To establish best practices for analyzing monitoring data, a model evaluation was developed and applied using Marine Renewable Energy (MRE); a case study of a disturbance with no best practice monitoring methods. The evaluation was performed on normal and non-normal acoustic metrics representative of MRE monitoring data. Evaluated models included: generalized regression models, time series models, and nonparametric models. 10-fold Cross Validation was used to evaluate baseline model fit. Models were then fit to 5 simulated Before-After change scenarios using Intervention Analysis. A power analysis was used to evaluate model ability to detect change. Residual error diagnostics were used to quantify model fit and forecast accuracy. State-space models are recommended for baseline characterization. Deterministic Parametric models are recommended to detect change. Time series and semi-parametric models are recommended to quantify change. Nonparametric models are recommended to forecast change. These recommendations form best practices for analyzing MRE monitoring data, which enables comparisons among MRE sites and reduces uncertainty in environmental effects. The evaluation approach is applicable to any monitoring program.","author":["Linder, H."],"organization":["University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.145524000000","-122.694783000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1168","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-energy-scenario-analysis-holistic-stakeholder-considerations-sustainable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/depts.washington.edu\/pmec\/docs\/UWMastersThesis_Tidal_Energy_Scenario_Analysis.pdf","title":"Tidal Energy Scenario Analysis: Holistic Stakeholder Considerations for Sustainable Development","description":"Interest in renewable energy development to mitigate climate change and provide a secure energy source includes investigation into the feasibility of marine renewable energy sources, including the harnessing of tides. Tidal renewable energy is a growing area of research and development with key benefits including its location near coastal communities, minimal viewshed impacts, a powerful ocean resource, and a uniquely high level of predictability. I conducted a research study to understand perceptions of risk and benefit around tidal energy development, focusing on lessons learned from a proposed project in Puget Sound, WA. I used grounded theory methodology to conduct interviews and a focus group, and to analyze these data. I used scenarios to show conceptual tidal energy technology alternatives, with a focus on considering not only technical differences, but also economic, environmental, and social dimensions. Results of my study show\u00a0that there is much uncertainty in this new technology, and aspects of its development were perceived as being risks or benefits. Spatial position and scale were both common frameworks for considering trade-offs, and marine life interactions were a particularly sensitive area of risk. Market applications of tidal energy aligned seemingly conflicting goals, as slow, sustainable development of this technology enhanced the benefits from many perspectives. My study shows that slowly building from small to commercial scale, working collaboratively with many disciplines, and focusing on holistic learning may be crucial for tidal energy development, especially in advance of a clear drive for a fully renewable energy market.","author":["McTiernan, K."],"organization":["University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.760924000000","-122.428904000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/McTiernan-2017-Tidal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1169","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/use-ecological-risk-assessing-effects-human-activities-example-including","sourceURL":"https:\/\/landscape-online.org\/index.php\/lo\/article\/view\/LO.200805","title":"The use of \u0027ecological risk\u0027 for assessing effects of human activities: an example including eutrophication and offshore wind farm construction in the North Sea","description":"This paper takes the move from the uncertainty surrounding ecosystem thresholds and addresses the issue of ecosystem-state assessment by means of ecological integrity indicators and \u2018ecological risk\u2018. The concept of \u2018ecological risk\u2018 gives a measure of the likelihood of ecosystem failure to provide the level of natural ecological goods and services expected\/desired by human societies. As a consequence of human pressures (use of resources and discharge into the environment), ecosystem thresholds can be breached thus resulting in major threats to human health, safety and well-being. In this study we apply the concept of \u2018ecological risk\u2018 to two case-studies in the German exclusive economic zone: eutrophication and construction of offshore wind farms. The effects of different future scenarios for single-uses upon ecosystem integrity are analysed as well as the effects of one combined scenario. We conclude that in the short term construction of offshore wind farms can influence some processes to a much larger degree than eutrophication, however, combined impacts deriving from eutrophication and offshore wind farm construction need a more detailed analysis. Due to non-linear ecosystem processes, effects of combined or multiple uses of marine resources in terms of \u2018ecological risk\u2018, cannot be extrapolated from single-use scenarios.","author":["Burkhard, B.","Windhorst, W.","Lenhart, H.","Nunneri, C.","Colijn, F.","M\u00fcller, F."],"organization":["Kiel University","Universit\u00e4t of Hamburg","Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2008-10-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.251290000000","7.585225000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nunneri-2008-Eco-Risk.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1170","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/integrated-assessment-coastal-marine-changes-using-example-offshore-wind-farms-coastal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/content\/oekom\/gaia\/2009\/00000018\/00000003\/art00009","title":"Integrated Assessment of Coastal and Marine Changes Using the Example of Offshore Wind Farms: the Coastal Futures Approach","description":"This article begins with a discussion of developments concerning offshore wind farms in the German North Sea as an example of marine use change. Specifically, it takes a look at whether Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM) can help to improve the planning framework. While ICZM cannot solve all political problems, it meets some planning needs. Recently, integrated approaches have become more and more influential in legislation, but a significant implementation gap exists. To overcome this gap, new modes of coastal governance need to be established (e.g., moving from management of single human activities to management of use patterns, from protection of individual species to protection of ecosystems, or from single scales to multiple scales). The second part of the article describes the integrative approach of the German research project\u00a0Coastal Futures. Using the DPSIR (drivers, pressure, state, impact, response) framework, scenario storylines were used to describe potential marine use patterns causing different ecological and socio-economic impacts. With the approach developed for the example of offshore wind,\u00a0Coastal Futures\u00a0aims to establish a general concept for integrated assessments of coastal change.","author":["Kannen, A.","Burkhard, B."],"organization":["Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon","Leibniz Universit\u00e4t Hannover"],"originationDate":"2009-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.320958000000","7.431278000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1171","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-power-development-affected-seascape-values-german-north-sea-coast","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0264837709000593","title":"Offshore wind power development as affected by seascape values on the German North Sea coast","description":"In Germany, the first permits have now been issued for the construction of large-scale offshore wind farms in the German Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ). This paper focuses on perceptions of the local seascape and the role of aesthetic seascape qualities in shaping local attitudes to offshore wind farming. Based on a survey of local residents in the districts of Dithmarschen and North Frisia, it shows that aesthetic seascape perception alone cannot account for local attitudes to offshore wind farming. Three main aspects seem to come together to determine these attitudes: deeply held convictions of the sea as a natural space, deeply held views of the local landscape and linked to this local identity, and also perceptions of renewable energies in combination with attitudes to issues such as climate change and sea level rise. The paper draws some conclusions on the future of the sea as a natural space or energy space.","author":["Gee, K."],"organization":["Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2010-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.145472000000","9.113207000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1172","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/trade-offs-between-seascape-offshore-wind-farming-values-analysis-local-opinions-based","sourceURL":"https:\/\/portal.dnb.de\/opac.htm?method=simpleSearch\u0026cqlMode=true\u0026query=idn%3D1044361506","title":"Trade-offs between seascape and offshore wind farming values: An analysis of local opinions based on a cognitive belief framework","description":"This study explores the acceptance of offshore wind farming on the West coast of SchleswigHolstein in Germany. It is an explorative, qualitative study owing to the fact that no offshore wind farms have yet been constructed in the German North Sea, which means it assesses expectations associated with offshore wind farming rather than actual experiences. Based on a non-representative questionnaire survey of local residents in selected municipalities in Dithmarschen and North Frisia (n = 387), it shows that residents are equally divided between supporters and opponents. The study uses the concept of values to uncover the reasons behind these attitudes. It shows that attitudes to offshore wind farming are driven by (1) beliefs about offshore wind farming (including the values associated with offshore wind and the impacts it is believed to have on the local environment), and (2) the importance assigned to potentially conflicting values, in particular seascape values. Attitudes to offshore wind farming are the result of trade-offs between offshore wind farming values on the one hand and nature and seascape values on the other. A cognitive belief framework was constructed to assess the varying values and beliefs that lead to attitudes to offshore wind farming. It includes basic human beliefs as the first order of cognition, followed by beliefs about nature, the sea and the West coast before coming to attitude to offshore wind farming. The cognitive belief framework is used to trace the specific bifurcation points which are instrumental in forming an attitude to offshore wind farming. \u2018Value types\u2019 are established at different points of the cognitive belief framework indicative of different value constellations. The study particularly focuses on seascape values as a potential point of contention. In order to establish the range of values carried by the sea, the concept of landscape was applied to the specific setting of the North Sea. A new definition of \u2018seascape\u2019 was developed as a full equivalent of landscape, encompassing physical properties (forms), visual-aesthetic elements as well as the \u2018sea of the mind\u2019. The empirical part revealed that non-use values play a particular role in assigning value to the seascape, expressed for example in the visual aesthetic qualities of the seascape and the symbolic values assigned to it. Rather than abstract space, the sea is very much a place. Levels of attachment are high, and the sea yields a variety of intangible benefits to local residents. This is an aspect which has so far been neglected in offshore wind planning processes. Qualitative links were established between particular images of nature, nature ideologies and sea values. These in turn have links to West coast values and with these offshore wind farming values. Values associated with offshore wind farming and moral convictions (such as the belief that renewable energies are relevant and important) are key factors in tipping the balance in favour of offshore wind, even if nature and sea values are also considered important. Certain moral convictions and beliefs about the sea (such as the view that nature is fragile) are more likely to lead to a negative attitude to offshore wind farming. However, unless the underlying value base is very strong and consistent, support or rejection of offshore wind farming is always the result of a complex internal process driven by subjective rationalities.\u00a0Since circumstances change, the results described in this study must be interpreted as a snapshot in time, reflecting a particular situation in the case study area and also the particular situation of each respondent at the time of questioning. Nevertheless, the cognitive belief framework presented and the overall approach can readily be transferred to other settings and contexts, enabling cross-cultural comparisons as well as assessment of changing opinions over time. The benefit of the approach is that it leads to better understanding of the positions taken up by stakeholders, facilitating process of negotiation and debate.\u00a0","author":["Gee, K."],"organization":["Georg-August University of G\u00f6ttingen"],"originationDate":"2013-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.511445000000","7.944639000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gee-2013-Dissertation.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1173","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/open-ocean-aquaculture-offshore-wind-farms-feasibility-study-multifunctional-use","sourceURL":"https:\/\/epic.awi.de\/id\/eprint\/26591\/1\/BerPolarforsch2002412.pdf","title":"Open Ocean Aquaculture and Offshore Wind Farms. A feasibility study on the multifunctional use of offshore wind farms and offshore mariculture in the North Sea area","description":"The feasibility study deals, on theoretical basis, with the potential multifunctional use of planned offshore-windfarms with commercial marine aquaculture (open ocean aquaculture) in the North Sea area. Exclusively, literature data from existing international experiences are reviewed here, as well as the output of several discussions with experts. Firstly, the study reviews the current \u201cstate of the art\u201d of open ocean aquaculture. The data was derived from existing projects within the international scientific community, which focused on candidate organisms, and dealt with offshore technology and maintenance aspects. Choice of location and infrastructure needed was also extracted from the findings of these projects. It became clear, that, in terms of commercial marine aquaculture, Germany, in comparison to many other maritime countries throughout the world, has to date little knowledge and background. Only one offshore aquaculture project nearby the Island of Helgoland was carried out. The current complicated and even counteractive national jurisdiction is identified being one of the main reasons for this lack of knowledge and experience. Next, the vast array of marine protected areas, national parks, as well as input of urban waste water adds to the calamity. However, especially the hydrodynamics of the North Sea play a key role as hindrance of establishing commercial marine aquaculture in Germany. Secondly, the study carries out a selection of parameters, which need to be met during the decision-making of the location and construction of an offshore aquaculture farm. Next to geo-physical parameters, as wave parameters and local current profiles, other abiotic parameter, such as degree of contamination through urban waste water are addressed. Additionally, certain biological factors, such as plankton load and the concentration of chlorophyll within the possible locations were derived from existing data sets. A synthesis from these above parameters allowed the identification of suited candidates for a commercially running offshore-aquaculture. It is suggested to employ the cultivation of mussel (Mytilus edulis) and pacific oyster (Crassostrea gigas), as such a culture could be run extensively in the offshore region and the work-labour being minimal. Similar accounts for seaweed, such as Laminaria saccharina and Palmaria palmata. Thirdly, the study looked upon the possible selling market of the offshore aquaculture and their candidates in comparison to the performance of existing conventional operated farms in coastal waters. Main focus was placed on existing experience within the European community. It was put out, that a strong market exists for the suggested brown algae and red algae, which is likely to expand in the near future. The latter species can also be directly sold to the consumer as healthy food. However, one of the major elements for the economic success of the culture is the decision of the right location of an aquaculture. Here, factors like rapid accessibility due to shorter distances to the main land and available infrastructure need to be closely considered. Furthermore harbours with a good transport network and processing industries are, next to the direct local environmental factors at a specific wind farm, crucial factors. Thus, some of the wind farms, which are closer to the coastal areas economically more compatible as farm locations further off within the exclusive economic zone (EEZ). These factors, next to good management of the culture, are directly linked to the economic success of the activity. The feasibility study closes with a final evaluation of all factors, which are critical for the development of a commercial offshore aquaculture in combination with the planned wind farms in the North Sea region.","author":["Buck, B."],"organization":["Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)"],"originationDate":"2002-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.201464000000","3.599388000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Buck-2002-Aquaculture-Offshore-Wind.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1174","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-aquaculture-within-offshore-wind-farms-social-aspects-multiple-use-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/content\/oekom\/gaia\/2009\/00000018\/00000002\/art00014","title":"Marine Aquaculture within Offshore Wind Farms: Social Aspects of Multiple-Use Planning","description":"Combining offshore wind farming and marine aquaculture is an opportunity to share stakeholder resources and can lead to greater spatial efficiency in the offshore environment. Although biological and technical studies have demonstrated the general feasibility of this approach, a number of complex socioeconomic and technical challenges still need to be dealt with. Focusing on selected social aspects of multiple offshore use, this paper presents a short overview of recent research results on the potential and problems of wind farm\u2013mariculture integration in the German Bight.","author":["Buck, B.","Krause, G.","Michler-Cieluch, T."],"organization":["Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","Leibniz Center for Tropical Marine Ecology (ZMT)"],"originationDate":"2009-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.788384000000","8.354495000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1175","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analyzing-coastal-marine-changes-offshore-wind-farming-case-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/233932674_Analyzing_Coastal_and_Marine_Changes_Offshore_Wind_Farming_as_a_Case_Study","title":"Analyzing Coastal and Marine Changes \u2013 Offshore Wind Farming as a Case Study","description":"Coastal and marine areas experience physical and ecological as well as social and economic change, caused by pressure from climate change and globalization related processes. This change may include changes in species composition, hydrodynamic and morphological patterns, but also new patterns of land and sea use, all together translating into challenges for planning and management. As a response new forms of coastal (and marine) management approaches like Integrated Coastal Zone Management (ICZM), Ecosystem Based Management (EBM) and Adaptive Management evolved as alternatives or additions to traditional ad hoc and sector-based planning and management. Within this context inter- and transdisciplinary research, which addresses the numerous ecological, perceptual, normative, cultural and economic interactions between society and coastal (eco)systems becomes more and more prominent. The LOICZ R\u0026S Report No. 36 describes the German research project Zukunft K\u00fcste - Coastal Futures (in short: Coastal Futures) as an example of an interdisciplinary research approach. Coastal Futures was LOICZ affiliated project and one out of two research projects funded by the Federal Ministry for Education and Research (BMBF) from 2004 \u2013 2010. In order to accompany the process of developing a national ICZM strategy for Germany the Coastal Futures approach analytically integrates not only results of social and natural science investigations, but also links qualitative empirical research and quantitative modelling. The approach aims to understand the impacts of offshore wind farming as part of a wider systems perspective. It had been designed to gain new insights into the complex social-ecological system of the German North Sea coast by applying a range of tools from natural and social sciences and linking them together as part of a common methodological framework and by focusing on a particular case study.","author":["Garthe, S.","Kannen, A.","Burkhard, B.","Windhorst, W.","Lenhart, H.","Gee, K.","Lange, M."],"organization":["Land Ocean Interactions in the Coastal Zone (LOICZ) Project","Federal Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF)"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.420719000000","7.564289000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lange-2010-Coastal-Changes.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1176","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-established-offshore-wind-farms-energy-flow-coastal-ecosystems-case-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569118306483","title":"Effects of established offshore wind farms on energy flow of coastal ecosystems: A case study of the Rudong offshore wind farms in China","description":"To assess the impact of offshore wind farms (OWFs) on the structure and energy flow of coastal ecosystems, Ecopath models of the Jiangsu coastal ecosystem (JCE) based on biological field data collected before and after the establishment of the Rudong OWFs in 2007 and 2015, respectively, were constructed and compared. The results indicated that after OWF construction, detritus, phytoplankton, zooplankton, anchovies, and some benthic fish were positively impacted. The increased primary production and detritus resulted in the increased food supply for zooplankton, which made it possible for planktivorous species (particularly anchovies) to be fed. Consequently, the biomass and production of some benthic fish increased, which indicates a potential reef effect. Other groups with decreased biomasses and productions may have been negatively impacted by the OWFs. Herbivory flows dominated the pre- and post-construction JCE despite their low transfer efficiencies; however, the proportion of detritivory flow increased after OWF construction, and this was especially prominent at high trophic levels. The post-construction JCE was immature with lower system connectivity, trophic flow utilisation, and transfer efficiency. However, the ecosystem tended to develop towards higher maturity with higher energy throughput, ecosystem activity, and recycling capability.","author":["Wang, T.","Wang, J.","Zhang, D.","Yu, W.","Zou, X."],"organization":["Ocean University of China","Nanjing University"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.689601000000","121.346815000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1177","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-high-seas-geo-spatial-modelling-resource-potential-legal-implications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421519300400","title":"Renewable energy from the high seas: Geo-spatial modelling of resource potential and legal implications for developing offshore wind projects beyond the national jurisdiction of coastal States","description":"Offshore\u00a0wind energy\u00a0projects are currently restricted to the\u00a0exclusive economic zones\u00a0of\u00a0coastal States. Recent advances in technology are raising the prospect of utilising excellent wind resources on the high seas.\n\nUsing a global geo-spatial model we identify potential resource areas for this. In the\u00a0shallow water\u00a0case\u00a0for bottom fixed foundations the largest locations are found on the Mascarene Plateau in the Indian Ocean and the Grand Banks in the North Atlantic. The\u00a0deep water\u00a0case for floating platforms identifies the largest regions on the Grand Banks\/Flemish Cap and Rockall Bank\/Hatton Ridge, both in the North Atlantic. The overall legal framework for wind energy projects on the high seas is the\u00a0United NationsConvention in the Law of the Sea.\u00a0Flag states\u00a0will play a central regulatory role for high seas wind energy developments. There is the danger that flags of convenience might evolve and unduly undercut environmental and\u00a0safety standards\u00a0that are in place for projects on the\u00a0territorial seaand EEZ. Such abuse of high seas\u00a0freedom\u00a0could compromise the\u00a0UNCLOS\u00a0principle of \u2018due regard\u2019.\u00a0Marine spatial planning\u00a0approaches and the establishment of cooperative mechanisms, led by the IMO, could safeguard against such potential misappropriation.","author":["Elsner, P.","Suarez, S."],"organization":["University of London","Universit\u00e4t of Hamburg"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1178","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-monitoring-reveals-times-tides-harbor-porpoise-phocoena-phocoena-distribution","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/mms.12537","title":"Acoustic monitoring reveals the times and tides of harbor porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) distribution off central Oregon, U.S.A.","description":"Harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) are commonly observed in Oregon\u0027s nearshore marine environment yet knowledge of their ecosystem use and behavior remains limited, generating concerns for potential impacts on this species from future coastal development. Passive acoustic monitoring was used to investigate spatial and temporal variations in the presence and foraging activity of harbor porpoises off the Oregon coast from May through October 2014. Digital monitoring devices (DMONs) were deployed to record acoustic data (320 kHz sample rate) in two neighboring but bathymetrically different locations off the Oregon coast: (1) a site on the 30 m isobath in close proximity (\u0026lt;50 m) to a rocky reef, and (2) a site on the 60 m isobath in an open sandy environment. Data were analyzed with respect to two dynamic cyclic variables: diel and tidal phase. Porpoise presence at the rocky reef site was aligned with the ebb phase of the tidal forcing, while, harbor porpoise presence and foraging at the offshore, sandy bottom site was associated with night\u2010time foraging. The spatial and temporal patterns identified in this study suggest harbor porpoise habitat use is modulated by specific environmental conditions particular to each site that maximize foraging efficiency.","author":["Torres, L.","Haxel, J.","Klinck, H.","Holdman, A."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","Cornell University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.247904000000","-124.808926000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Holdman-2019-Acoustic.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1179","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/soundscape-indo-pacific-humpback-dolphin-sousa-chinensis-hotspot-windfarm-construction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X1930102X","title":"Soundscape of an Indo-Pacific humpback dolphin (Sousa chinensis) hotspot before windfarm construction in the Pearl River Estuary, China: Do dolphin engage in noise avoidance and passive eavesdropping behavior?","description":"Soundscapes are vital to acoustically specialized animals. Using passive acoustic monitoring data, the temporal and spectral variations in the soundscape of a Chinese white dolphin hotspot were analyzed. By cluster analysis, the 1\/3 octave band power spectrum can be grouped into three bands with median overall contribution rates of 35.24, 14.14 and 30.61%. Significant diel and tidal soundscape variations were observed with a generalized linear model. Temporal patterns and frequency ranges of middle frequency band sound matched well with those of fish vocalization, indicating that fish might serve as a signal source. Dolphin sounds were mainly detected in periods involving low levels of ambient sound and without fish vocalization, which could reflect noise avoidance and passive eavesdropping behaviors engaged in by the predator. Pre-construction data can be used to assess the effects of offshore windfarms on acoustic environments and aquatic animals by comparing them with the soundscape of postconstruction and\/or postmitigation.","author":["Wang, D.","Nowacek, D.","Akamatsu, T.","Wang, Z.","Wang, K.","Zhou, L.","Yuan, J.","Lei, P.","Li, J.","Duan, P."],"organization":["Duke University","Chinese Academy of Sciences"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["22.131072900000","113.715967100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wangetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1180","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/vessel-noise-cuts-down-communication-space-vocalizing-fish-marine-mammals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/gcb.13996","title":"Vessel noise cuts down communication space for vocalizing fish and marine mammals","description":"Anthropogenic noise across the world\u0027s oceans threatens the ability of vocalizing marine species to communicate. Some species vocalize at key life stages or whilst foraging, and disruption to the acoustic habitat at these times could lead to adverse consequences at the population level. To investigate the risk of these impacts, we investigated the effect of vessel noise on the communication space of the Bryde\u0027s whale\u00a0Balaenoptera edeni, an endangered species which vocalizes at low frequencies, and bigeye\u00a0Pempheris adspersa, a nocturnal fish species which uses contact calls to maintain group cohesion while foraging. By combining long\u2010term acoustic monitoring data with AIS vessel\u2010tracking data and acoustic propagation modelling, the impact of vessel noise on their communication space was determined. Routine vessel passages cut down communication space by up to 61.5% for bigeyes and 87.4% for Bryde\u0027s whales. This influence of vessel noise on communication space exceeded natural variability for between 3.9 and 18.9% of the monitoring period. Additionally, during the closest point of approach of a large commercial vessel,","author":["Merchant, N.","Radford, C.","Farcas, A.","Putland, R."],"organization":["University of Auckland","Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)"],"originationDate":"2017-11-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["-36.451146000000","175.150156000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Pelagic Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1181","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/lost-listening-area-assessment-anthropogenic-sounds-chukchi-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/citedby\/10.1121\/1.4969572","title":"Lost listening area assessment of anthropogenic sounds in the Chukchi Sea","description":"The term listening area, refers to the region of\u00a0oceanover which sources of\u00a0sound\u00a0can be detected by an animal at the center of the space. The lost listening area assessment method has been applied to in-air\u00a0sounds\u00a0for a noise\u00a0effects\u00a0assessment on birds but not, in our knowledge, previously to the assessment of\u00a0underwater\u00a0noise\u00a0effects\u00a0on marine mammals. The lost listening area method calculates a fractional reduction in listening area due to the addition of anthropogenic noise to ambient noise. It does not provide absolute areas or volumes of space, as does the communication space method; however, a benefit of the lost listening area method is that it does not rely on source levels of the\u00a0sounds\u00a0of interest. Instead, the method depends only on the rate of\u00a0sound\u00a0transmission loss. We present a preliminary application of the method from an assessment of \u201ccumulative and chronic effects\u201d of noise produced by\u00a0oil\u00a0and gas\u00a0exploration\u00a0activities used in the National Marine Fisheries Service\u0027s\u00a0Effects\u00a0of\u00a0Oil\u00a0and Gas\u00a0Exploration\u00a0in the Arctic\u00a0Ocean\u00a0Final Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement.","author":["Hatch, L.","Harrison, J.","Hannay, D."],"organization":["JASCO Applied Sciences","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)"],"originationDate":"2016-11-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["69.312075000000","-171.847721000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1182","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fish-marine-mammal-audiograms-summary-available-information","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cupdf.com\/document\/fish-and-marine-mammal-audiograms-a-summary-of-.html?page=1","title":"Fish and Marine Mammal Audiograms: A summary of available information","description":"Compendium and review of audiograms of underwater animals, including a brief overview of the methods used to obtain them and fuller details of the method used for each experiment.","author":["Nedwell, J.","Gordon, J.","Edwards, B.","Turnpenny, A."],"organization":["Subacoustech Ltd","Fawley Aquatic Research Laboratories"],"originationDate":"2004-09-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nedwell-2004-Audiograms.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1183","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-case-study-two-wind-turbines-used-mexico","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1359431114009272","title":"Life cycle assessment: A case study of two wind turbines used in Mexico","description":"This paper presents the case study of two\u00a0wind turbinesinstalled in Mexico which are analyzed using the\u00a0life cycle assessment\u00a0(LCA) methodology.\u00a0Environmental impacts\u00a0of different\u00a0fabrication\u00a0materials and\u00a0electricity consumptionwere studied for the main\u00a0turbine components. The designs of both\u00a0turbines\u00a0were examined through the phases of manufacture,\u00a0construction, and final disposal. Both turbines (turbine A and turbine B) were of 2.0\u00a0megawatts\u00a0(MW). Results ascertain that the most intensive environmental impacts come from the\u00a0nacelle\u00a0and tower components of both turbines; and that within life cycle phases, turbine A influences the environment less than turbine B, specifically during manufacture and final disposal. This study is valuable for decision makers in the domain of technological\u00a0product design\u00a0and marketing; in order to determine which features of the wind turbines can be modified to mitigate environmental impacts, contributing to technological innovation in the domains of sustainability and\u00a0renewable energies\u00a0in Mexico.","author":["Vargas, A.","Zen\u00f3n, E.","Oswald, U.","Islas, J.","G\u00fcereca, L.","Manzini, F."],"organization":["Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico"],"originationDate":"2015-01-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["22.873628600000","-102.797955700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1184","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-energy-greenhouse-emissions-analysis-wind-turbines-effect-size-energy-yield","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032109001403","title":"Life cycle energy and greenhouse emissions analysis of wind turbines and the effect of size on energy yield","description":"Wind turbines, used to generate renewable energy, are typically considered to take only a number of months to produce as much energy as is required in their manufacture and operation. With a life expectancy of upwards of 20 years, the energy produced by wind turbines over their life can be many times greater than that embodied in their production. Many previous life cycle energy studies of wind turbines are based on methods of assessment now known to be incomplete. These studies may underestimate the energy embodied in wind turbines by more than 50%, potentially overestimating the energy yield of those systems and possibly affecting the comparison of energy generation options. With the increasing trend towards larger scale wind turbines, comes a respective increase in the energy required for their manufacture. It is important to consider whether or not these increases in wind turbine size, and thus embodied energy, can be adequately justified by equivalent increases in the energy yield of such systems. This paper presents the results of a life cycle energy and greenhouse emissions analysis of two wind turbines and considers the effect of wind turbine size on energy yield. The issue of incompleteness associated with many past life cycle energy studies is also addressed. Energy yield ratios of 21 and 23 were found for a small and large scale wind turbine, respectively. The embodied energy component was found to be more significant than in previous studies, emphasised here due to the innovative use of a hybrid embodied energy analysis approach. The life cycle energy requirements were shown to be offset by the energy produced within the first 12 months of operation. The size of wind turbines appears to not be an important factor in optimising their life cycle energy performance.","author":["Crawford, R."],"organization":["University of Melbourne"],"originationDate":"2009-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1185","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-offshore-wind-electricity-generation-scandinavia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/brage.bibsys.no\/xmlui\/handle\/11250\/233683","title":"Life Cycle Assessment of Offshore Wind Electricity Generation in Scandinavia","description":"In this study a Multi Regional Input Output model has been developed for the base year 2000, and thereafter extended and hybridized to enable a study of offshore wind power generation in Scandinavia. Foremost the per-unit environmental impact of offshore wind power generation was calculated to an average of 16.5 grams of CO2-eq. per kWh. The MRIO model offers a broad system boundary, covering a complete set of background flows and enables in this way a thorough study of the inter-regional value chains and the corresponding emissions embodied in trade. Scenarios from 2000 to 2030 for future offshore wind power were developed on the basis of GDP projections and projections for future energy demand. One baseline scenario, assuming no further offshore wind power installation, was developed, together with a Medium and a High scenario of future offshore wind power installation. The installed wind power was assumed to replace non-renewable energy sources, primarily domestically and secondly in power importing countries. The Medium and High scenario resulted in a cumulative reduction of 220 Mtons CO2-equivalents and 308 Mtons by 2030, respectively. The Norwegian offshore wind power was by a large exported, while Denmark and Sweden experienced a substantial wind power implementation into their economies, resulting in considerable increase in the percentage share of renewable energy in their electricity mix. This shows that offshore wind power could have a vital role in reaching the European Union s target of a 20% share of renewable energy by 2020, under the assumption that a substantial capacity of wind power is installed. The results from this study provide important guidance and a broad overview of the effect a large wind power implementation will have on the Scandinavian economy.","author":["Tveten, A."],"organization":["Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)"],"originationDate":"2009-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tveten-2009-Thesis.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1186","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ghg-emissions-energy-performance-offshore-wind-power","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148113006654","title":"GHG emissions and energy performance of offshore wind power","description":"This paper presents specific life cycle GHG emissions from wind power generation from six different 5\u00a0MW offshore wind turbine conceptual designs. In addition, the energy performance, expressed by the energy indicators Energy Payback Ratio (EPR) Energy Payback Time (EPT), is calculated for each of the concepts.\n\nThere are currently few LCA studies in existence which analyse offshore wind turbines with rated power as great as 5\u00a0MW. The results, therefore, give valuable additional environmental information concerning large offshore wind power. The resulting GHG emissions vary between 18 and 31.4\u00a0g CO2-equivalents per kWh while the energy performance, assessed as EPR and EPT, varies between 7.5 and 12.9, and 1.6 and 2.7 years, respectively. The relatively large ranges in GHG emissions and energy performance are chiefly the result of the differing steel masses required for the analysed platforms. One major conclusion from this study is that specific platform\/foundation steel masses are important for the overall GHG emissions relating to offshore wind power. Other parameters of importance when comparing the environmental performance of offshore wind concepts are the lifetime of the turbines, wind conditions, distance to shore, and installation and decommissioning activities.\n\nEven though the GHG emissions from wind power vary to a relatively large degree, wind power can fully compete with other low GHG emission electricity technologies, such as nuclear, photovoltaic and hydro power.","author":["Raadal, H.","Vold, B.","Myhr, A.","Nygaard, T."],"organization":["Ostfold Research (\u00d8stfoldforskning)","Norwegian University of Life Sciences"],"originationDate":"2014-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1187","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-assessment-floating-offshore-wind-turbine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148108001754","title":"Life cycle assessment of a floating offshore wind turbine","description":"A development in wind energy technology towards higher nominal power of the wind turbines is related to the shift of the turbines to better wind conditions. After the shift from onshore to offshore areas, there has been an effort to move further from the sea coast to the deep water areas, which requires floating windmills. Such a concept brings additional environmental impact through higher material demand. To evaluate additional environmental burdens and to find out whether they can be rebalanced or even offset by better wind conditions, a prospective life cycle assessment (LCA) study of one floating concept has been performed and the results are presented in this paper. A comparison with existing LCA studies of conventional offshore wind power and electricity from a natural gas combined cycle is presented. The results indicate similar environmental impacts of electricity production using floating wind power plants as using non-floating offshore wind power plants. The most important stage in the life cycle of the wind power plants is the production of materials. Credits that are connected to recycling these materials at the end-of-life of the power plant are substantial.","author":["Hertwich, E.","Weinzettel, J.","Reenaas, M.","Solli, C."],"organization":["Czech Technical University in Prague (CTU)","Charles University in Prague","Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)"],"originationDate":"2009-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1188","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sustainable-energy-africa-comprehensive-data-andpolicies-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032114003943","title":"Sustainable energy in Africa: A comprehensive data andpolicies review","description":"Achieving sustainable energy development in a region requires rational use of energy resources and technologies, and the development of appropriate policies. Three concerns are therefore required to achieve these issues: (i) to acquire a picture of the local current energy situation, (ii) to measure the state of development and the progress towards a sustainable energy system, and (iii) to have energy decision- and policy-makers fully aware of the implications on sustainable development of selected policies. It is in this perspective and in the frame of activities on sustainable energy for all and access to energy in developing countries carried out by the UNESCO Chair in Energy for Sustainable Development, that we developed this review. The objective of this paper is to depict the current energy situation of Africa by using the most up to date data, describing it as far as the concept of sustainable development is concerned, and to see if and how energy policies promoted by local players fi t with this asset. We assess the energy situation of Africa by combining (i) data, mainly by the International Energy Agency, about national energy balances for primary and electric energy, the Energy Development Index and energy resources, with (ii) a more comprehensive analysis of the African energy system, accomplished by the Energy Indicators for Sustainable Development. An overview of the energy-related policies and action plans developed by different local players in the African continent is also carried out with the goal of providing remarks by coupling such plans with the above mentioned energy analysis.","author":["Mandelli, S.","Barbieri, J.","Mattarolo, L.","Colombo, E."],"organization":["Polytechnic University of Milan"],"originationDate":"2014-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-11-18 10:55:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1189","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/north-atlantic-right-whale-eubalaena-glacialis-occurrence-offshore-wind-energy-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/esr\/v34\/p45-59\/","title":"North Atlantic right whale Eubalaena glacialis occurrence in offshore wind energy areas near Massachusetts and Rhode Island, USA","description":"Recent surveys of wind energy areas offshore of Massachusetts and Rhode Island (USA) have demonstrated that they encompass habitat used by the Endangered North Atlantic right whale Eubalaena glacialis. Prior to 2011, little systematic survey effort had been conducted in the area. The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management and the state of Massachusetts supported 3.5 yr of twice-monthly aerial surveys by the Northeast Large Pelagic Survey Collaborative (NLPSC). Additional survey teams including the Northeast Fisheries Science Center and the Center for Coastal Studies have collected sightings data in the region. Data systematically collected by the NLPSC allowed analyses of monthly sightings rates, sightings per unit effort, and hot spots which provided information on current temporal and spatial use patterns. Abundance estimates for each season-year (i.e. a 3 mo period within a given survey year) were calculated. Behaviors observed included feeding and surface active groups. Photo-identification of whales since 2010 yielded a minimum count of 196 unique individuals (annual average = 35), or over one-third of the current population estimate. Analyses of demographics of these individuals revealed that 34 known calving females (30% of the total currently presumed alive) visited the study area. These results demonstrate consistent annual use of this area by a significant portion of the E. glacialis population, with a strong correlation between season and presence. These findings can inform management activities and development planning, and be used as a baseline dataset for assessing long-term impacts to the species.","author":["Thompson, J.","Kraus, S.","Cole, T.","Leiter, S.","Stone, K.","Accardo, A.","Wikgren, B.","Zani, M.","Kenny, R.","Mayo, C."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island","Northwest Fisheries Science Center","New England Aquarium","Provincetown Center for Coastal Studies"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.279435000000","-71.054966000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Leiteretal2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1190","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impact-analysis-power-generation-biomass-wind-farms-different-locations","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S136403211830813X","title":"Environmental impact analysis of power generation from biomass and wind farms in different locations","description":"Accelerated urbanization in China has increased electricity demand. Recently, environmentally-friendly renewable energy resources have become more popular for generating power. Energy consumption and environmental impacts vary depending on the types of renewable energy, while the impacts of such variations are rarely studied in the existing literature. This study used a life-cycle perspective to analyze energy consumption and environmental impacts of wind farms and compared the results to a biomass power plant. The environmental impacts of wind power plants were further analyzed on a site by site basis, using locations in desert (G), steppe (S), and woodland (W) landscapes. The results showed that the G site had the lowest global warming potential of wind power plants at 51.547 gCO2-eq\/kWh, about 60% that of the S site and 80% that of W. The global warming potential of the G site was also about 25% of the biomass power plant. Additionally, the G site had a solid waste potential of 25.248\u202fg-eq\/kWh, which is only 10% compared to the biomass plant. The results also indicated energy payback times for the G, S, and W wind farms to be 0.67, 2.40, and 1.42 years, respectively. The G site also had an acidification potential of 6.836 gSO2-eq\/kWh, which was equivalent to 45% of the S site and 30% that of W. Consequently, wind farms located in the desert have the least environmental impact, followed by those located in the steppe and woodland. Accounting for energy payback time and environmental impacts, this study suggests that wind power plants should be built in desert areas when possible.","author":["Song, K.","Gao, C.","Na, H.","Dyer, N.","Tian, F.","Xu, Q.","Xing, Y."],"organization":["Northeastern University (China)","University of Maryland"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.605528300000","106.468772200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1191","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-pile-driving-hectors-dolphin-lyttelton-harbour-new-zealand","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X19302012","title":"Impact of pile-driving on Hector\u0027s dolphin in Lyttelton Harbour, New Zealand","description":"Several dolphin species occur close inshore and in harbours, where underwater noise generated by pile-driving used in wharf construction may constitute an important impact. Such impacts are likely to be greatest on species such as the endangered Hector\u0027s dolphin (Cephalorhynchus hectori), which has small home ranges and uses this habitat type routinely. Using automated echolocation detectors in Lyttelton Harbour (New Zealand), we studied the distribution of Hector\u0027s dolphins using a gradient sampling design over 92 days within which pile-driving occurred on 46 days. During piling operations, dolphin positive minutes per day decreased at the detector closest to the piling but increased at the mid-harbour detector. Finer-grained analyses showed that close to the piling operation, detections decreased with increasing sound exposure level, that longer piling events were associated with longer reductions in detections, and that effects were long-lasting - detection rates took up to 83 h to return to pre-piling levels.","author":["Leunissen, E.","Dawson, S.","Rayment, W."],"organization":["University of Otago"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-43.819336100000","172.926776300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Leunissenetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1192","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-cause-functional-habitat-loss-migratory-soaring-birds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/1365-2656.12961","title":"Wind turbines cause functional habitat loss for migratory soaring birds","description":"1 . Wind energy production has expanded to meet climate change mitigation goals, but negative impacts of wind turbines have been reported on wildlife. Soaring birds are among the most affected groups with alarming fatality rates by collision with wind turbines and an escalating occupation of their migratory corridors. These birds have been described as changing their flight trajectories to avoid wind turbines, but this behaviour may lead to functional habitat loss, as suitable soaring areas in the proximity of wind turbines will likely be underused.  2 . We modelled the displacement effect of wind turbines on black kites ( Milvus migrans ) tracked by GPS . We also evaluated the impact of this effect at the scale of the landscape by estimating how much suitable soaring area was lost to wind turbines.  3 . We used state-of-the-art tracking devices to monitor the movements of 130 black kites in an area populated by wind turbines, at the migratory bottleneck of the Strait of Gibraltar. Landscape use by birds was mapped from GPS data using dynamic Brownian bridge movement models, and generalized additive mixed modelling was used to estimate the effect of wind turbine proximity on bird use while accounting for orographic and thermal uplift availability.  4 . We found that areas up to approximately 674 m away from the turbines were less used than expected given their uplift potential. Within that distance threshold, bird use decreased with the proximity to wind turbines. We estimated that the footprint of wind turbines affected 3%\u201314% of the areas suitable for soaring in our study area.   5 . We present evidence that the impacts of wind energy industry on soaring birds are greater than previously acknowledged. In addition to the commonly reported fatalities, the avoidance of turbines by soaring birds causes habitat losses in their movement corridors. Authorities should recognize this further impact of wind energy production and establish new regulations that protect soaring habitat. We also showed that soaring habitat for birds can be modelled at a fine scale using publicly available data. Such an approach can be used to plan low-impact placement of turbines in new wind energy developments.","author":["Mu\u00f1oz, A.","Hanssen, F.","Santos, C.","Onrubia, A.","Wikelski, M.","Silva, J.","Marques, A.,","Moreira, F.","Palmeirim, J."],"organization":["Universidade de Lisboa","Universidade de Porto","Max Planck Institute for Ornithology"],"originationDate":"2020-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.013200000000","5.602700000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:45:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Marquesetal2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1193","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-cumulative-exposure-wildlife-offshore-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479719300222","title":"Assessing the cumulative exposure of wildlife to offshore wind energy development","description":"Governments and developers are pursuing offshore wind energy to address climate change, but multiple wind farms may cumulatively affect wildlife populations. Assessments of cumulative effects must first calculate the cumulative exposure of a wildlife population to a hazard and then estimate how the exposure will affect the population. Our research responds to the first need by developing a model designed to assess how different wind farm siting scenarios cumulatively expose wildlife. The model assesses cumulative exposure by identifying all locations where development could occur, placing wind farms within this suitability layer, and then overlaying wind engineering and biological data sets. The first model output is a graphical representation of how offshore wind farm siting decisions affect wildlife cumulative exposure. The second output is an index that ranks which offshore wind farm siting decisions will have the greatest influence on wildlife cumulative exposure. Together these outputs provide stakeholders with valuable information that could be used to guide siting and management decisions.","author":["Milman, A.","Wing Goodale, M."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts","Biodiversity Research Institute"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.687781400000","-70.283653100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1194","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/world-seas-environmental-evaluation-volume-iii-ecological-issues-environmental-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/book\/9780128050521\/world-seas-an-environmental-evaluation","title":"World Seas: An Environmental Evaluation Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","description":"World Seas: An Environmental Evaluation, Second Edition, Volume Three: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts covers global issues relating to our seas, including a biological description of the coast and continental shelf waters, the development and use of the coast, landfills and their effects, pollutant discharges over time, the effects of over-fishing, and the management methods and techniques used to ensure continued ecosystem functioning. The relative importance of water-borne and airborne routes differ in different parts of the world is explored, along with extensive coverage of major habitats and species groups, governmental, education and legal issues, fisheries effects, remote sensing, climate change and management.  This book is an invaluable, worldwide reference source for students and researchers concerned with marine environmental science, fisheries, oceanography and engineering and coastal zone development.  Chapter 1 - The Mangrove Ecosystem  Chapter 2 - Global Status of Coral Reefs: In Combination, Disturbances and Stressors Become Ratchets  Chapter 3 - Status and Trends for the World\u2019s Kelp Forests  Chapter 4 - Salt Marshes: Their Role in Our Society and Threats Posed to Their Existence  Chapter 5 - Remote Sensing for Marine Management  Chapter 6 - New Advances in Benthic Monitoring Technology and Methodology  Chapter 7 - Seabirds  Chapter 8 - Blooms of the Moon Jellyfish Aurelia: Causes, Consequences and Controls  Chapter 9 - European Protection of Fisheries in the North East Atlantic  Chapter 10 - Ghost Fishing  Chapter 11 - Far-Field and Near-Field Effects of Marine Aquaculture  Chapter 12 - The Making of a Global Marine Fisheries Catch Database for Policy Development  Chapter 13 - Ballast Water: Problems and Management  Chapter 14 - Debris in Deep Water  Chapter 15 - Polychlorinated Biphenyls in the Global Ocean  Chapter 16 - Microbial Remediation of Organic Pollutants  Chapter 17 - Macroplastics Pollution in the Marine Environment  Chapter 18 - Microplastics Pollution in the Marine Environment  Chapter 19 - International Instruments for the Prevention of Marine Alien Invasive Species  Chapter 20 - Underwater Noise: Sources and Effects on Marine Life  Chapter 21 - Marine Oil Spills\u2014Oil Pollution, Sources and Effects  Chapter 22 - Marine Oil Spills\u2014Preparedness and Countermeasures  Chapter 23 - Threats to Seamount Ecosystems and Their Management  Chapter 24 - Dead Zones: Oxygen Depletion in Coastal Ecosystems  Chapter 25 - Marine Protected Areas: Attempting the Sustainability of the Seas  Chapter 26 - Shoreline Defenses  Chapter 27 - Environmental Effects of Marine Transportation  Chapter 28 - Collisions of Vessels With Cetaceans\u2014The Underestimated Threat  Chapter 29 - Marine Protected Areas  Chapter 30 - Marine Spatial Planning  Chapter 31 - The Role of Ports in a Global Economy, Issues of Relevance and Environmental Initiatives  Chapter 32 - Molecular Approaches for an Operational Marine Biodiversity Observation Network","author":["Sheppard, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ecosystem Processes","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Legal \u0026 Policy","Environmental Impact Assessment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1195","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/2017-state-wind-development-united-states-region","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrel.gov\/docs\/fy18osti\/70738.pdf","title":"2017 State of Wind Development in the United States by Region","description":"Although the wind capacity installed by the end of 2016 is estimated, in an average year, to equate to 6.4% of electricity demand in the United States, wind energy has the potential to meet even more of our country\u2019s demand for energy (U.S. Department of Energy 2017c). In 2016, the industry took a major step forward with the commissioning of the nation\u2019s first offshore project, the 30-MW Block Island project in Rhode Island. Another exciting development in 2017 was wind energy becoming the largest source of renewable electric capacity in the United States (and the fourth largest overall) (American Wind Energy Association 2018). Additionally, corporate and other non-utility purchases of wind energy continue to influence expansion across the country. With more than 1,500 megawatts of power purchase agreements signed in 2016 and multiple new agreements signed in 2017 by companies such as Kimberly-Clark, Google, General Motors, Anheuser-Busch, Cummins, and JP Morgan Chase, this growing market enhances the long-term installation prospects for the wind industry moving forward. Despite this growth, continued expansion of wind energy development will be required to achieve the scenarios outlined in the U.S. Department of Energy\u2019s (DOE)\u2019s Wind Vision: 20% wind energy by 2030 and 35% wind energy by 2050.\n\nResearchers at DOE\u2019s national laboratories have conducted analyses and determined that innovation in wind technology can have consequential implications for future wind power development throughout the United States, and it can impact the broader electricity system, lower electric system and consumer costs, provide potential environmental benefits, and expand the U.S. wind workforce (Mai et al. 2017). The wind industry and the DOE\u2019s Wind Energy Technologies Office are addressing technical wind energy challenges, such as reducing turbine costs and increasing energy production and reliability. Turbine nameplate capacity, hub height, and rotor diameter have increased significantly. Turbines originally designed for lower wind speed sites have rapidly gained market share, and pending and proposed projects are continuing the trend of even-taller turbines as lower wind sites appear to be targeted (U.S. Department of Energy 2017c). This turbine scaling is significantly boosting wind project performance, contributing to low power sales prices. Wind power sales prices are at all-time lows, enabling economic competitiveness despite low natural gas prices. Analysts project that annual wind power capacity additions will continue for the next several years before declining, driven by the 5-year extension of the Production Tax Credit signed in December 2015 and the progressive reduction in the value of the credit over time (U.S. Department of Energy 2017c). Demand drivers also include corporate wind energy purchases and state-level renewable energy policies. At the same time, expectations for continued low natural gas prices, modest electricity demand growth, and lower near-term demand from state RPS policies put a damper on growth expectations, as do inadequate transmission infrastructure and competition from solar energy in certain regions of the country. Yet the potential for continued technological advancements and cost reductions enhance the prospects for longer-term growth, as does burgeoning corporate demand for wind\u00a0energy and continued state RPS requirements. Given these diverse underlying potential trends, wind capacity additions\u2014especially after 2020\u2014remain deeply uncertain (U.S. Department of Energy 2017c).\n\nBeyond these market trends, the Office also recognizes that human-use conflicts with wind energy can be challenging, depending on the proximity of proposed wind farms to local populations. As wind development expands, more information is becoming available on the local community impacts of wind deployment. However, the public and local decision-makers often cite a lack of scientifically credible information as an issue. In some cases, this information is available but not readily accessible; in others, the information is not conclusive. Where information does exist, it should be made readily available to the public in a user-friendly format. Continued and increased engagement at multiple levels will be needed given the expanding nature of the industry. In 2014, DOE established six Regional Resource Centers (RRCs) across the United States to communicate unbiased, credible information about wind energy development to stakeholders through regional networks. The RRCs serve as a platform to localize the information important to the regions they cover, provide information about potential benefits and issues in wind development, and disseminate data on wind development siting considerations such as turbine sound and wildlife habitat protection community considerations.\n\nEach U.S. region experiences unique wind energy development challenges due to many factors: availability of wind resources and other natural resources, population density, community needs, and permitting processes resulting from the presence of local wildlife species. Continued growth of U.S. wind energy would require high-impact, regional-specific strategies that provide region-specific, unbiased information to inform communities making policy and permitting decisions on processes and improve public discourse, seeking to reduce human-use conflict around development decisions and ensuring that wind development is responsible and responsive to the American public\u2019s needs. As a starting point to developing strategies, WINDExchange requested that the RRC representatives identify market challenges in their regions that have affected wind energy development. These issues include:\nInsufficient transmission capacity and the need for transmission improvements\nPower market conditions that limit wind development (such as small balancing areas and hour-ahead dispatching)\nLack of local wind siting or zoning ordinances; ordinances that do not reflect best practices or do not allow the flexibility in wind development to address small, distributed, community, or utility-scale wind projects\nGrid interconnection and integration challenges and costs\nLack of clear federal policy covering wind power-related initiatives and awareness of those policies\nMinimal past public education and engagement on wind siting issues, exacerbated by inaccurate information and negative public opinion regarding wind energy\nLack of understanding about wind energy\u2019s economic impacts, including local tax benefits, jobs and economic development, and turbine manufacturing\nChallenges with development on federal and native lands\nAccurate wind information not being utilized in utility integrated resource and state-based clean energy planning\nRestricted access to capital; limited financing, funding, and technical assistance for small, community, and distributed wind development.\n\nThe RRCs also identified the following issues as unique to offshore wind energy development:\nThe current high costs of offshore wind energy and lack of articulated benefits describing how initial high costs for early projects can lead to reduced costs for future projects\nMinimal independent information and outreach geared toward innovative regional procurement targets, limiting the ability of projects to attract financing, investigate alternative financing mechanisms, and initiate regional supply chain development\nThe fact that there are few full-scale offshore wind turbines currently deployed in the United States and therefore limited U.S.-based research about actual offshore wind development. This limited research results in inadequate information regarding the offshore wind regulatory process; technical issues related to installation, interconnection, and operation; environmental and human use impacts; and acceptance of offshore wind\nLack of clear understanding of the regional and national market opportunity for offshore wind development.\n\nThe RRCs also identified distinct challenges unique to wind development in isolated, islanded power systems found primarily in Alaska, coastal New England, Hawaii, the Territories of the United States, and international locations. The primary development challenges include:\nThe high up-front cost of deploying sophisticated wind technologies and associated hardware in an isolated, remote, or islanded area with relatively low technical and human capacity\nExcessive transportation and mobilization costs, much higher than costs for communities in other regions on the road system\nLimited ability to gain economies of scale due to the relatively small project size\nLack of experience and extra costs of integrating wind into smaller, less flexible electric grids\nLack of clear regulatory policy and examples that define the rules of engagement between small utilities and independent power producers that wish to develop wind energy supplied to small, typically municipal utilities\nSpecific challenges relating to expanded wind integration into the Railbelt transmission system1 in Alaska (Baranowski et al. 2017).\n\nThis document summarizes the status and drivers for U.S. wind energy development in 2017. RRC leaders provided a report of wind energy development in their regions, which was combined with findings from National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) researchers to provide an account of the state of the regions, as well as updates on developments in individual states. NREL researchers and state partners added updates for all states that are not directly supported by an RRC. Accounts for each region include updates on renewable portfolio standards, workforce development, manufacturing andeconomic development, and individual state updates for installed wind capacity, ongoing policy developments, planned projects and their status, transmission progress reports, etc.\n\n\nThis report also highlights the efforts of the RRCs to engage stakeholders in their individual regions. The RRCs and the regions they serve are (in alphabetical order):\nFour Corners Wind Resource Center, serving Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico, Utah, Nevada, and part of Wyoming\nIslanded Grid Resource Center, serving Alaska, Maine, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Hawaii, Guam, American Samoa, Commonwealth of Northern Marianas, and U.S. Virgin Islands\nMidwest Wind Energy Center, serving eastern Montana and Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, North Dakota, Ohio, South Dakota, and Wisconsin\nNortheast Wind Resource Center, serving New England (Connecticut, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Vermont) and New York for land-based wind, and that same region plus New Jersey for offshore wind\nNorthwest Wind Resource and Action Center, serving Washington, Oregon, Idaho, western Montana, and part of Wyoming\nSoutheast Wind Energy Resource Center, serving North Carolina, Florida, Louisiana, South Carolina, Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee, and Arkansas.\n\nOn the national level, DOE\u2019s WINDExchange2 initiative (managed by NREL) provides additional information to the RRCs and supports states not covered by one of these regional organizations.\n\n\nIn the second year of this initiative, the RRCs reported that they provided more than 95,000 key stakeholders with unbiased information about wind power. The RRCs also reported that more than 68,700 people or organizations were directly engaged by the RRCs, meaning that they entered a two-way conversation about wind energy or progressed to a point of accepting wind energy as an option to address the nation\u2019s long-term energy needs. Engagements were typically made through events such as meetings with identified stakeholders, interactive webinars, workshops, tours, and presentations at regional conferences. Additional efforts were undertaken through outreach products such as handouts, meeting materials, and newsletters, while direct engagement with regional media organizations was also supported. More than 3.5 million people have been reached by RRC outreach efforts. More targeted efforts ensured that key stakeholders received information that allowed them to include wind technology in plans or policies that had either not included wind or that included outdated wind information.\nMany notable RRC projects that may help support expanded wind development are underway. Examples include:\nIn 2017, Utah counties published the first locally written resource management plans (RMPs), defining county priorities for the development and use of federal lands. With more than half of Utah\u2019s land under the jurisdiction of federal land management agencies, federal agencies and state and county governments find these RMPs indispensable in planning and integrating the goals and policies of local jurisdictions when establishing new rules. As part of this effort, the Four Corners Wind Resource Center (4CWRC) worked with Utah county officials for more than a year to ensure that local stakeholders have the information they need to address wind energy development within the scope of their RMPs. The 4CWRC provided background on wind energy and guidance language regarding wind resources, technology advancements, and development that all of Utah\u2019s 29 counties, as well as seven multi-county associations and the Utah Association of Counties, could use to ensure that those unfamiliar with wind energy would have current information and appropriate language to meet Utah\u2019s renewable energy target.\nIn March 2017, residents and energy leaders from Monhegan, Maine, and Nantucket and Martha\u0027s Vineyard, Massachusetts, traveled to Block Island with the Islanded Grid Resource Center and representatives from the University of Maine\u2019s Aqua Ventus project to meet with local stakeholders and expand an ongoing dialogue among all four communities. In addition to discussions that covered aspects of offshore development, the March 2017 IGRC effort featured a multi-perspective exploration of the Block Island Wind Farm. This allowed participants to observe the turbines from the shore to understand land-based visual impacts before boarding a maintenance vessel to get an up-close view of the project, an opportunity to experience an offshore wind farm prior to the installation of proposed projects that will impact residents back home. Participants also met with the local tourism council to learn about the project\u2019s impacts to tourism on the island.\n\u00a0A Midwest Wind Energy Center principal provided testimony to the Iowa Utility Board supporting Interstate Power and Light Company\u2019s proposal to expand its wind generation near the town of Hampton by 500 MW. This testimony helped lead to the project\u2019s approval, and construction is slated to begin in spring 2018.\nThrough the Northeast Wind Resource Center, the Clean Energy Group and its sister organization the Clean Energy States Alliance have worked with state agencies in the region on mechanisms for reducing offshore wind barriers and developing a domestic offshore wind market. In early 2015, the Clean Energy Group, Clean Energy States Alliance, and stakeholders from various Northeast states discussed the potential for cooperative action to develop offshore wind at scale to reduce costs. The Massachusetts Clean Energy Center, the Massachusetts Department of Energy Resources, the Rhode Island Office of Energy Resources, and the New York State Energy Research Development Authority agreed to collaborate to develop a roadmap for speeding offshore wind development and reducing the cost of that development. Three reports published in November 2017 are a result of this effort.\nWith contributions from Northwest Wind Resource and Action Center and a multitude of RRC partners, the Oregon Department of Energy released a new report that outlines the necessary steps to foster the development of offshore wind in the Pacific Northwest. Published in May 2017, Offshore Wind in the Pacific Northwest: Strategy Recommendations3 examines the current state of offshore wind in terms of technology, regulatory practices, resource potential, and existing infrastructure.\nIn 2017, the Southeastern Wind Coalition organized and led North Carolina state legislators on two tours of the Amazon Wind Farm U.S. East, the first wind energy project in the state. The tours of the site near Elizabeth City, North Carolina, were meant to educate stakeholders about the project\u0027s economic benefits and potential impacts, including those to military operations as there is a Navy radar system in the region.\n\nIn states not represented by an RRC, significant developments include:\nIn 2017, Texas produced more wind power in a given amount of time than ever in history. The state reached \u201cpeak wind\u201d at 3:50 a.m. on March 23, when local wind farms produced 50% of the total electricity load of the state\u2019s main power grid (ERCOT 2017). On March 31, wind electricity generation in Texas hit a new wind output record of 16,141 MW, representing approximately 39.5% of total electric demand (S\u0026P Global Platts 2017).\nIn December 2016, the 60-mile Elm Creek to Summit Project went online in Kansas, providing increased reliability and new wind transmission capacity between Salina and Concordia. Additionally, the proposed Grain Belt Express Clean Line will impact the ability to transmit Kansas wind energy outside of the state. If approved, the 780-mile project will deliver 4,000 MW of wind energy from the western portion of the state to Missouri, Indiana, Illinois, and other neighboring states. Both projects help to address a significant barrier to wind development in the state: a lack of transmission to deliver clean energy from wind-rich areas to the demand.\nThe Maryland Public Service Commission approved two proposals for offshore wind farms off the coast of Ocean City because of economic benefit to the state: approximately 9,700 jobs and $1.8 billion of in-state spending over 20 years. The Public Service Commission required project developers U.S. Wind and Deepwater Wind to build part of their supply chains in Maryland, to spend at least $76 million on steel manufacturing in Maryland, and to use ports in the state. The developers are also required to invest $40 million into Tradepoint Atlantic, a shipyard near Baltimore that was once home to Bethlehem Steel.\n\nAccording to the American Wind Energy Association, as of the end of 2017, almost 29,000 MW of wind capacity are under construction or in advanced development (American Wind Energy Association 2018). In 2017, U.S. regions experienced many wind energy successes, but many challenges remain along with unanswered questions about what\u2019s next for technology development and the opportunity for wind to be a viable energy resource responsibly harnessed across the country.","author":["Tegen, S.","Baring-Gould, I.","Oteri, F.","Baranowski, R."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.740770900000","-105.170799500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2017-State-of-Wind.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1196","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-analysis-ecological-impacts-offshore-land-based-wind-power-plant","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2076-3417\/9\/2\/231","title":"Life Cycle Analysis of Ecological Impacts of an Offshore and a Land-Based Wind Power Plant","description":"This study deals with the problems connected with the benefits and costs of an offshore wind power plant in terms of ecology. Development prospects of offshore and land-based wind energy production are described. Selected aspects involved in the design, construction, and operation of offshore wind power plant construction and operation are presented. The aim of this study was to analyze and compare the environmental impact of offshore and land-based wind power plants. Life cycle assessment analysis of 2-MW offshore and land wind power plants was made with the use of Eco-indicator 99 modeling. The results were compared in four areas of impact in order to obtain values of indexes for nonergonomic (impact on\/by operator), nonfunctional (of\/on the product), nonecological (on\/by living objects), and nonsozological impacts (on\/by manmade objects), reflecting the extent of threat to human health, the environment, and natural resources. The processes involved in extraction of fossil fuels were found to produce harmful emissions which in turn lead to respiratory system diseases being, thus, extremely dangerous for the natural environment. For all the studied areas, the impact on the environment was found to be higher for land-based wind power plants than for an offshore wind farm.","author":["Piasecka, I.","Tomporowski, A.","Flizikowski, J.","Kruszelnicka, W.","Kasner, R.","Mrozinski, A."],"organization":["UTP University of Science and Technology in Bydgoszcz"],"originationDate":"2019-01-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-11 12:03:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Piasecka-2019-LCA.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1197","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-farm-impacts-coastal-flooding-under-sea-level-rise-case-study-southern-spain","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969718343213","title":"Wave farm impacts on coastal flooding under sea-level rise: A case study in southern Spain","description":"Coastal flooding, already an acute problem in many parts of the world, will be exacerbated in the near future by the sea level rise induced by climate change. The influence of wave farms, i.e., arrays of wave energy converters, on coastal processes, in particular sediment transport patterns, has been analysed in recent works; however, their influence on coastal flooding has not been addressed so far. The objective of this work is to investigate whether a wave farm can provide some protection from flooding on the coast in its lee through a case study: a gravel-dominated beach in southern Spain (Playa Granada). We consider three sea-level rise (SLR) scenarios: the present situation (SLR0), an optimistic projection (SLR1) and a pessimistic projection (SLR2). Two state-of-the-art numerical models, SWAN and XBeach-G, are applied to determine the wave propagation patterns, total run-up and flooded dry beach area. The results indicate that the absorption of wave power by the wave farm affects wave propagation in its lee and, in particular, wave heights, with alongshore-averaged reductions in breaking wave heights about 10% (25%) under westerly (easterly) storms. These lower significant wave heights, in turn, result in alongshore-averaged run-up reductions for the three scenarios, which decreases with increasing SLR values from 5.9% (6.8%) to 1.5% (5.1%) for western (eastern) storms. Importantly, the dry beach area flooded under westerly (easterly) storms is also reduced by 5.7% (3.2%), 3.3% (4.9%) and 1.99% (4.5%) in scenarios SLR0, SLR1 and SLR2, respectively. These findings prove that a wave farm can actually reduce coastal flooding on its leeward coast.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Bergillos, R.","Rodriguez-Delgado, C."],"organization":["University of Granada","University of C\u00f3rdoba","Plymouth University","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2019-02-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.724907900000","-3.541722400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1198","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mineral-raw-material-requirements-associated-climate-change-impacts-french-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0959652618331718","title":"Mineral raw material requirements and associated climate-change impacts of the French energy transition by 2050","description":"In France, significant investments regarding\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0power plants will be required in future years in order to attain targets set by French and European regulations. This study aims\u00a0i)\u00a0at quantifying the requirements for steel, aluminium, copper (among the most impactful metal productions with respect to\u00a0climate change\u00a0in the world) and concrete resulting from the projected\u00a0energy transition\u00a0in France by 2050 (with a focus on the power sector) and\u00a0ii)\u00a0at estimating the climate change impacts associated with the production of these raw materials. As a basis to the modelling exercise, coefficients of material intensities of\u00a0electricity generation\u00a0systems were collected from the literature. Despite the variety of data sources, uncertainties regarding the information gathered on material intensity are of an epistemic nature, reflecting incompleteness. Therefore possibility theory was used to represent uncertainties relative to these parameters and to propagate uncertainty in the calculation. Results are expressed as upper and lower bounds on the probability that requirement for materials, and subsequent climate change impacts of their production, should be lower than a certain value. From these limiting bounds, values are derived for an 80% confidence index and put in perspective with\u00a0current consumption\u00a0of raw materials and\u00a0greenhouse gas emissions\u00a0of specific French economic activities. In particular, there is a 20% risk that requirements for steel be greater than 46,000 ktonnes (corresponding to 20 years of\u00a0steel products\u00a0consumption by the French automotive sector) and for aluminium be greater than 6360 ktonnes (21 years of aluminium consumption by the French building sector). Moreover, there is a 20% risk that the production of steel, copper, aluminium and concrete, as a response to the French energy transition, induces more than 445 million tonnes of CO2-eq. The results provide decision-makers with a basis to decide whether the calculated risks of\u00a0raw material consumption\u00a0and corresponding climate change impacts are acceptable, taking into account other types of activities.","author":["M\u00fcller, S.","Beylot, A.","Guyonnet, D.","Vaxelaire, S.","Villeneuve, J."],"organization":["French Geological Survey (BRGM)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.700757900000","1.344896300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1199","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-social-impacts-wind-energy-view-point-reference-india","sourceURL":"https:\/\/apcz.umk.pl\/czasopisma\/index.php\/EQ\/article\/view\/19605","title":"Environmental and social impacts of wind energy: a view point with reference to India","description":"Energy is a basic requirement for economic development and is an integral part of every sector of Indian economy. Renewable energy is increasingly seen as the energy choice of the future as it offers an alternative yet effective solution to reduce carbon emissions and minimize the tradeoffs between environment and energy development. India is increasingly adopting responsible renewable energy technologies and taking positive steps towards carbon emissions, cleaning the air and ensuring a more sustainable future. A large body of literature addressing the issues regarding large negative environmental externalities caused by electricity generation from fossil fuels based energy is available; yet, literature dealing with environmental and social impacts of wind power energy plants, especially in developing countries like India is almost absent. This study is expected to contribute towards filling this gap by synthesizing information about the environmental and social impacts of the wind power projects especially in Indian context.","author":["Gawande, A.","Chaudhry, P."],"organization":["Indian Institute of Forest Management (IIFM)"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["16.623862500000","74.881515600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1200","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/risk-assessment-fish-passage-through-small-low-head-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.worldcat.org\/title\/risk-assessment-for-fish-passage-through-small-low-head-turbines\/oclc\/316564537","title":"Risk assessment for fish passage through small, low-head turbines","description":"This report summarises the findings of a study to improve the accuracy of prediction methods for fish fatalities for small-head Francis and Kaplan propeller turbine designs and gives details of computational fluid dynamic modelling to estimate pressure fluxes and shear stresses. Biological data is reviewed, and the STRIKER Excel spreadsheet model is used to predict death caused by pressure flux, shear turbulence, and blade strike. Field validation is discussed, and drawings of the Francis 1 and Kaplan 1 turbines, results of the fish passage trials, and STRIKER instructions and sample runs are presented in the appendices.","author":["Turnpenny, A.","Clough, S.","Hanson, K.","Ramsay, R.","McEwan, D."],"organization":["Fawley Aquatic Research Laboratories"],"originationDate":"2000-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Turnpennyetal2000.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1201","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-impact-lake-erie-wind-farms-water-temperatures-mixed-layer-depths-some","sourceURL":"https:\/\/agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1029\/2018JC014577","title":"On the Potential Impact of Lake Erie Wind Farms on Water Temperatures and Mixed-Layer Depths: Some Preliminary 1-D Modeling Using COHERENS","description":"Lake Erie has a significant wind energy resource potential, with extensive areas of moderate water depth and proximity to major cities and industries with substantial electricity demands. The presence of significant numbers of large turbines in wind farms will lead to reduced wind speeds and wind stresses in the wakes within and downwind of the farms. This in turn will affect surface fluxes, currents, and mixing in lake waters, generally allowing increased surface temperatures and reduced summer time mixed\u2010layer depths. The potential magnitude of these impacts is investigated with a one dimensional application of the Coupled Hydrodynamical\u2010Ecological Model for Regional and Shelf Seas model for three different water depths using observed meteorological data as input.","author":["Taylor, P.","Afsharian, S."],"organization":["York University"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.257407000000","-81.291451000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Water Quality","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1202","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/chains-trust-energy-justice-public-engagement-first-offshore-wind-farm-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618300756","title":"Chains of trust: Energy justice, public engagement, and the first offshore wind farm in the United States","description":"Public acceptance of renewable energy technologies (RETs) is critical to the broader adoption of these technologies and reducing the role of fossil fuels in electricity generation. Recent investigations into the public engagement processes surrounding RET projects reveal certain procedural deficits, especially concerning procedural fairness and stakeholder trust. With this in mind, we analyze two engagement processes that led to the Block Island Wind Farm, the first operational offshore wind farm in the United States. Through semi-structured interviews we identify certain procedural techniques that allowed process leaders to first build public trust in themselves, then in the process, and ultimately in the outcome. This chain of trust was fostered through informal efforts of process leaders to meet stakeholder expectations concerning process leaders\u2019 ability to work for the public interest, provide meaningful engagement opportunities, and to produce non-discriminatory outcomes. This case study highlights the potential of such informal actions to meet stakeholder expectations and build trust, while also empirically demonstrating specific techniques that future process leaders could employ to increase stakeholder acceptance of RETs.","author":["Bidwell, D.","Dwyer, J."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.122511000000","-71.477549000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Environmental Justice"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1203","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/costs-consequences-wind-turbine-wake-effects-arising-uncoordinated-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41560-018-0281-2","title":"Costs and consequences of wind turbine wake effects arising from uncoordinated wind energy development","description":"Optimal wind farm locations require a strong and reliable wind resource and access to transmission lines. As onshore and offshore wind energy grows, preferred locations become saturated with numerous wind farms. An upwind wind farm generates \u2018wake effects\u2019 (decreases in downwind wind speeds) that undermine a downwind wind farm\u2019s power generation and revenues. Here we use a diverse set of analysis tools from the atmospheric science, economic and legal communities to assess costs and consequences of these wake effects, focusing on a West Texas case study. We show that although wake effects vary with atmospheric conditions, they are discernible in monthly power production. In stably stratified atmospheric conditions, wakes can extend 50+\u2009km downwind, resulting in economic losses of several million dollars over six years for our case study. However, our investigation of the legal literature shows no legal guidance for protecting existing wind farms from such significant impacts.","author":["Lundquist, J.","DuVivier, K.","Kaffine, D.","Tomaszewski, J."],"organization":["University of Colorado Boulder","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","University of Denver"],"originationDate":"2018-11-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.444081200000","-100.558946700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1204","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-environmental-impacts-recycling-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/we.2287","title":"Evaluating the environmental impacts of recycling wind turbines","description":"Wind power is one of the fastest growing renewable energy sources. The wind turbines have an expected design lifetime in the range of 20 to 25 years after which decommissioning is expected. The trend in the wind turbine industry is that the turbines increase in size\u2014especially when considering offshore wind turbines in the 7 to 8 MW size range. Life cycle assessments show that the materials used for manufacturing the turbines accounts for 70 to 80% of the environmental impact, so ensuring optimal recycling at the end\u2010of\u2010service\u2010life is of economic and environmental interest and in line with the principles of transitioning towards a circular economy. The decommissioning and recycling process is analysed in this paper, with special considerations given to the environmental aspects of a theoretical 100% recyclability scenario. This includes cradle\u2010to\u2010gate life\u2010cycle inventory analysis of the materials, embedded energy, and CO2\u2010equivalent emissions. The findings show that established recycling methods are present for most of the materials and that recycling of a 60 MW wind park at end\u2010of\u2010service\u2010life provides environmental benefits as well as lowering the natural resource use and securing resources for use in the future. The saved energy is estimated to approximately 81 TJ. The reduction in emissions related to the recycling of wind turbine material totals approximately 7351 ton CO2.","author":["Jensen, J."],"organization":["Aalborg University"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1205","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wake-effect-assessment-flap-type-wave-energy-converter-farm-under-realistic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378383917305549","title":"Wake effect assessment of a flap type wave energy converter farm under realistic environmental conditions by using a numerical coupling methodology","description":"Ocean Energy Europe has estimated that 100\u202fGW of ocean energy capacity (wave and tidal) could be deployed in Europe by 2050. Along with the European targets it is expected that large farms of Wave Energy Converters (WECs) will be installed in the sea and, as part of the consenting process for their installation, it will be necessary to quantify their impact on the local environment. The objective of this study is to improve the assessment of WEC farms impact on the surrounding wave field (wake effect) through the use of a numerical coupling methodology. The methodology consists of a Boundary Element Method (BEM) solver to obtain the wave perturbation generated by the WEC farm for the near-field accounting for the wave-body interactions within the farm whilst a Wave Propagation Model (WPM) based on the mild-slope equations determines the wave transformation in the far-field. The near-field solution obtained from the BEM solver is described as an internal boundary condition in the WPM and then it is propagated throughout the WPM numerical domain. The internal boundary is described by imposing the solution of the surface elevation and velocity potential at the free-surface at each instant of time along a line surrounding the WEC farm. As a case study the methodology was applied to flap type WECs that are deployed in shallow water conditions. The validation of the technique was done first for a single flap and then for a farm of 5 flaps. Once validated, a realistic scenario was assessed by quantifying the impact of irregular sea states composed of long crested waves on a large WEC farm composed of 18 flaps and located on a real bathymetry. The irregular waves were obtained by superposing the regular wave field solutions for all wave frequencies represented in the considered sea state based on the linear water wave theory. Within the limits of this theory these simulations demonstrate the versatility of the methodology to accurately represent the impact of a WEC farm on the surrounding wave climate. The influence of the peak period and the spacing between flaps on the WEC farm wake effect was assessed as well.","author":["Troch, P.","Lewis, T.","Tomey-Bozo, N.","Babarit, A.","Murphy, J.","Stratigaki, V.","Thomas, G."],"organization":["University College Cork","Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)","Ghent University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.455826300000","-8.465752500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1206","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-turbines-local-recreation-evidence-two-travel-cost-method-contingent","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2213078018300616","title":"The impact of wind turbines on local recreation: Evidence from two travel cost method-contingent behavior studies","description":"This paper analyzes recreation demand on the fringe of an urban center in Norway. Specifically, it investigates the potential impact of\u00a0wind energy\u00a0projects on local recreation values.\u00a0Recreation areas\u00a0near\u00a0citiesare often scarce and under increasing pressures from growing populations with associated real-estate development and expanding or emerging industries. Hence, public planners and policy makers who seek to make optimal resource\u00a0management decisions\u00a0need information\u00a0on all\u00a0opportunity costs, including those associated with diminished recreational access or quality. Two separate\u00a0case studiesutilize the travel cost method (TCM) to derive baseline recreation demands. Supplementary information from contingent behavior (CB) scenarios provides identification of the impact of wind\u00a0turbines\u00a0on recreation benefits. For a unique\u00a0comparison, one case examines a possible inland\u00a0wind farm\u00a0near a popular local mountain area, whereas the other case examines an offshore wind farm near local beaches.\u00a0Econometric\u00a0estimations\u00a0are performed in a joint revealed preference (RP) \u2013\u00a0stated preference\u00a0(SP) pseudo-panel count-data framework. The analysis generates baseline\u00a0consumer surplus\u00a0estimates in the range of NOK 70\u2013155 per trip and indicates that the wind turbines would have negative impacts that are both statistically and economically significant.","author":["Kipperberg, G.","Onozaka, Y.","Bui, L.","Lohaugen, M.","Refsdal, G.","S\u00e6land, S."],"organization":["University of Stavanger"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.853268500000","5.736830300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Recreation \u0026 Tourism"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1207","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/consideration-scales-offshore-wind-environmental-impact-assessments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0195925518300830","title":"Consideration of scales in offshore wind environmental impact assessments","description":"Quality of environmental impact assessments (EIAs) has been criticized, in part due to a lack of accounting in these tools for differing spatial and temporal scales inherent in ecological data. In the United States, leases of outer continental shelf blocks for offshore wind projects and their construction and operation plans require EIAs in accordance with the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 and the 1978 Council on Environmental Quality Regulations for Implementing the Procedural Provisions of the National Environmental Policy Act. This study evaluated consideration of spatiotemporal scales of stressors, receptors (specifically cetaceans), and effects in eight federal offshore wind energy EIAs against 26 criteria extracted from federal regulations. The criteria analysis determined that EIAs do not consistently or comprehensively address spatiotemporal scales with respect to federal requirements. Deficiencies in addressing spatiotemporal scales may result from imprecise regulations, intent to simplify encyclopedic documents, or lack of data resulting in incomplete assessments, inappropriate mitigation actions, and projects delays. Recommendations to improve compliance with federal regulations include making federal guidance binding, focusing on non-trivial impacts of species, tiering information, and incorporating outcomes of marine spatial planning.","author":["Jordaan, A.","Ryan, K.","Danylchuk, A."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.023228000000","-74.331066000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1208","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000334","title":"Marine Spatial Planning","description":"Planning of marine areas is being developed worldwide to foster sustainable ocean management and governance. Marine spatial planning (MSP) is a process that aims to organize the use of the ocean space, as well as the interactions among human uses (e.g., fisheries, aquaculture, shipping, tourism, renewable energy production) and between users and the marine environment. Over the past 30 years, significant progress has been made by governments in their thinking about MSP. The MSP is currently under development in over 66 countries (44% of the nations with marine waters), encompassing six continents and four ocean basins, and the interest in MSP continues to grow. While most countries are still in the early phase of their MSP initiatives, others have already approved, implemented, or even revised marine spatial plans for many years. Despite its acceptance and use, development and implementation of MSP still faces several conceptual and practical challenges, from political to institutional, social, economic, scientific, and environmental sources. The present chapter provides a review on all these topics by addressing three main questions: what is MSP and why is it needed; what is the global distribution of MSP around the world, together with its state of development by region; and what are some of the most prominent and widespread challenges, present and future, that are linked to the development of MSP?  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Santos, C.","Orbach, M.","Andrade, F.","Ehler, C.","Agardy, T.","Crowder, L."],"organization":["University of Lisbon","United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)","Duke University","Stanford University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1209","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/startle-response-captive-north-sea-fish-species-underwater-tones-between-01-64-khz","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Ronald_Kastelein\/publication\/254215135_Acoustic_dose-response_effects_in_marine_fish\/links\/00b7d51fe67c8a4260000000\/Acoustic-dose-response-effects-in-marine-fish.pdf","title":"Startle response of captive North Sea fish species to underwater tones between 0.1 and 64 kHz","description":"World-wide, underwater background noise levels are increasing due to anthropogenic activities. Little is known about the effects of anthropogenic noise on marine fish, and information is needed to predict any negative effects. Behavioural startle response thresholds were determined for eight marine fish species, held in a large tank, to tones of 0.1\u201364 kHz. Response threshold levels varied per frequency within and between species. For sea bass, the 50% reaction threshold occurred for signals of 0.1\u20130.7 kHz, for thicklip mullet 0.4\u20130.7 kHz, for pout 0.1\u20130.25 kHz, for horse mackerel 0.1\u20132 kHz and for Atlantic herring 4 kHz. For cod, pollack and eel, no 50% reaction thresholds were reached. Reaction threshold levels increased from 100 dB (re 1 lPa, rms) at 0.1 kHz to 160 dB at 0.7 kHz. The 50% reaction thresholds did not run parallel to the hearing curves. This shows that fish species react very differently to sound, and that generalisations about the effects of sound on fish should be made with care. As well as on the spectrum and level of anthropogenic sounds, the reactions of fish probably depend on the context (e.g. location, temperature, physiological state, age, body size, and school size).","author":["Verboom, W.","Jennings, N.","van der Heul, S.","Kastelein, A.","van der Veen, J.","Haam, D."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","SEAMARCO"],"originationDate":"2008-01-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.532827000000","3.895385700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1210","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-effects-marine-transportation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000309","title":"Environmental Effects of Marine Transportation","description":"Marine transportation drives global trade, moving \u0026gt; 10 billion tons of containers, solid, and liquid bulk cargo across the world\u2019s seas annually. Historically, shipping companies and ports operated with limited environmental oversight, but accidental oil spills in the 1960s, caused widespread coastal pollution and seabird mortality, triggering the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships (MARPOL). MARPOL is the main international convention to prevent marine pollution by ships from operational or accidental causes. Additionally, the International Maritime Organization (IMO) uses various instruments to protect the marine environment from shipping activities. Nevertheless, marine transportation still generates negative impacts on the marine environment, including air pollution, greenhouse gas emissions, releases of ballast water containing aquatic invasive species, historical use of antifoulants, oil and chemical spills, dry bulk cargo releases, garbage, underwater noise pollution; ship-strikes on marine megafauna, risk of ship grounding or sinkings, and widespread sediment contamination of ports during transshipment or ship breaking activities. This chapter summarizes the environmental effects of marine transportation and describes the mitigative, legislative, and environmental performance measures currently available to improve management of these global issues.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Morrison, C.","Walker, T.","Adebambo, O.","Feijoo, M.","Elhaimer, E.","Hossain, T.","Edwards, S.","Romo, J.","Sharma, N.","Taylor, S.","Zomorodi, S."],"organization":["Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Navigation"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1211","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-protected-areas-attempting-sustainability-seas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000280","title":"Marine Protected Areas: Attempting the Sustainability of the Seas","description":"Current population and development trends are leading to an acute deterioration of the environmental state of the oceans. One of the tools to manage the world\u2019s seas more sustainably is marine protected areas(MPAs). MPAs are legally designated areas to protect and conserve valuable marine and coastal biodiversity and associated ecosystem services and cultural values. The recent pace of MPA designation and coverage has resulted in large increases in global MPA coverage, currently at 6.4%. However, most of this area concentrates in few huge offshore MPAs designated by few countries and lacks effective management. MPAs can be effective at preventing important local pressures such as overexploitation of marine resources or habitat destruction, but may be of little or no use to tackle some broad-scale marine pressures such as pollution or global warming. Although legal stringency is a broadly acknowledged factor for MPA environmental effectiveness, their ecological and socioeconomic effects are very context-specific and trade-offs among environmental features, between environmental and socioeconomic effects, and among socioeconomic stakeholders, are expected. Future marine conservation challenges include increasing demand for marine resources, global change, and scarce management budgets. In contrast, positive trends in MPA coverage, aquaculture production, and water quality make us slightly optimistic on the future of our oceans. Nevertheless, ultimate sustainability of the world\u2019s seas will very much depend on global human population, consumption, and behavioral patterns.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Rodr\u00edguez-Rodr\u00edguez, D."],"organization":["Spanish National Research Council (CSIC)","University of M\u00e1laga","International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:25:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1212","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-tidal-turbine-noise-environmental-impact-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cdn.southampton.ac.uk\/assets\/imported\/transforms\/content-block\/UsefulDownloads_Download\/7C58C38010AB40B7B63709445E09230D\/Lloyd_Thomas.pdf","title":"Predicting Tidal Turbine Noise for Environmental Impact Assessment","description":"Background  \u2022 The development of tidal turbine technology is key to the capture of renewable energy, with an estimated 18TWh\/year1 available from the UK\u2019s tidal resource alone. \u2022 In the design and implementation of such devices environmental impact assessment is mandatory, including an investigation of the noise generated by the turbine and its likely effect on marine animals (summarised in Figure 1). \u2022 Modelling noise at the design stage will allow a better understanding of the mechanisms of generation, and save costs related to re-design and mitigation.  Aims  \u2022 Identify the key sources of flow-generated noise in a typical tidal turbine, such as that shown in Figure 2. \u2022 Model these sources using analytical and numerical techniques. \u2022 Estimate the propagation of the generated sound, and its effect on marine animals.","author":["Lloyd, T.","Turnock, S.","Humphrey, V."],"organization":["University of Southampton"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lloydetal2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1213","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/threats-seamount-ecosystems-their-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000188","title":"Threats to Seamount Ecosystems and Their Management","description":"Seamounts are isolated topographic elevations with summit depths at least 100 m above the seafloor. Recent estimates of the number of seamounts have ranged from 171,864 seamounts and to more than 25 million seamounts with a relief of more than 100 m in height. Those with a relief of \u0026gt; 1000 m cover an estimated 4.7% of the ocean floor while features \u0026lt; 1000 m in elevation cover 16.3% of the seafloor, which is equivalent to or greater than the area covered by tropical dry forestsor by temperate broad-leafed forest or grassland. They are hotspots of biological diversity, and one of the main forms of impact have come from deep-sea fisheries, including bottom trawling. Other and future impacts come from deep-sea mineral mining. Management of these areas and implementation of sustainable fisheries has been problematic, but there has been some modest progress in limiting damage to seamount ecosystems, but to date this is inadequate.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Rogers, A."],"organization":["University of Oxford"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1214","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-oil-spills-preparedness-countermeasures","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000255","title":"Marine Oil Spills\u2014Preparedness and Countermeasures","description":"Marine oil spills have been of tremendous concern due to the adverse impact on economic and ecological systems. Major oil spills such as the 2010 Deepwater Horizon oil spill triggered worldwide consciousness of marine spill response. In past decades, significant advances have been made in diverse aspects including prevention and preparedness, spill response and cleanup options, modeling of marine oil spill, and response decision support; however, challenges still remain particularly associated with cold and harsh environmental conditions such as in the Arctic. This chapter provides a comprehensive review of marine oil spill preparedness and countermeasures, tackling topics such as preparedness and contingency planning, sensitivity and vulnerability, policies and regulations, cleanup technologies, oil trajectory and weathering modeling, early warning, response technology screening, net environmental benefit analysis, risk assessment, cleanup process simulation, and response decision-making. Knowledge gaps and technical challenges are also discussed indicating future research opportunities.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Lee, K.","Ye, X.","Zhang, B.","Chen, B.","Jing, L."],"organization":["Memorial University of Newfoundland","Fisheries and Oceans Canada"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Chemicals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1215","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-oil-spills-oil-pollution-sources-effects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000243","title":"Marine Oil Spills\u2014Oil Pollution, Sources and Effects","description":"As the major energy source worldwide, petroleum products have been increasingly produced and consumed, and the environmental impact involved also rises. Despite significant progress in reducing spillagethrough a variety of technological and regulatory prevention measuresand better industry practices, the risk of significant oil spills remains. On a daily basis, hundreds to thousands of spills are likely to occur worldwide including in the oceans. Marine oil spills involve accidental release of oil ranging from various types of crude oil to a large array of refined products, from heavy persistent fuels to light, less persistent, but very toxic fuels. The chemical composition and bulk properties of the spilled oil, and the associated weathering reactions, govern their fate, behavior, and impact in the marine environments. Oil spills are of great concern due to the enormous economic loss and the long-term, significant harm to marine ecosystems, local economy, and coastal society and community. During the long period of oil and gas exploitation, the adverse impacts of marine oil spill have been documented in various aspects. This chapter summarizes facts and effects of oil spills in oceans, and based on this, the response strategies and policies can be improved.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Lee, K.","Ye, X.","Zhang, B.","Matchinski, E.","Chen, B.","Jing, L."],"organization":["Memorial University of Newfoundland","Fisheries and Oceans Canada"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Chemicals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1216","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-noise-sources-effects-marine-life","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000231","title":"Underwater Noise: Sources and Effects on Marine Life","description":"Sound travels fast in the sea and has good propagation abilities, which makes it an excellent mean of rapid information acquisition and exchange. Many marine animals have therefore developed auditory capabilities and rely on the sound to overcome the many challenges of living in the sea. However, the advantages of using sound (to communicate, locate prey, and navigate) have been jeopardized in recent times, as the world seas have become noisier. Noise generated by diverse human activities (anthropogenic noise) has altered the quality of the marine environment with consequences on physiology, communication, behavior, and energetics of different marine species. Their responses to sound depend on characteristics such as sound levels and frequency, duration of exposure to it, animals\u2019 state and distance from the sound source, and they differ between species based on their hearing sensitivity. Anthropogenic sound in the sea is acknowledged as an important environmental stressor that can, in the long term, have detrimental consequences on the fitness, survival, and reproductive success of entire populations and species. Owing to this, the responsibility to minimize the environmental impact of noise on marine organisms has become a part of many international agreements and conventions. The effects of noise at the physiological and behavioral levels have been most studied in cetaceans and fish, though in more recent times, effects on invertebrates and larvae have also been identified. Here we summarize current knowledge on the sources of anthropogenic noise in the sea and the effects this humanly generated noise may have on different acoustically sensitive marine species.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Picciulin, M.","Rako-Gospi\u0107, N."],"organization":["Blue World Institute of Marine Research and Conservation"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1217","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/debris-deep-water","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000152","title":"Debris in Deep Water","description":"Marine debris is a recognized global ecological concern. Increasing numbers of quantitative studies worldwide are investigating litterdistribution and its influence on deep habitats (50\u20137000 m depth), but little is still known about the extent of the problem. Anthropogenic and environmental factors influence the distribution of debris that enters the seas from both land-based and marine sources. Debris can be displaced for long distances by wind and currents before sinking and can converge in accumulation areas, such as canyons. Plastics typically comprise 50%\u201380% of debris, due to their wide use and high resistance to degradation. Plastic-related-fishing debris are typical in rocky habitats (\u2248 70% of items), which traditionally are subject to intense fishing effort. The widespread presence of debris is strongly impacting deep-water organisms and habitats worldwide. Standardized approaches and specific conservation measures are needed in order to protect unique deep-sea ecosystems that are progressively under threat.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Angiolillo, M."],"organization":["Italian Institute for Environmental Protection and Research (ISPRA)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1218","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/far-field-near-field-effects-marine-aquaculture","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000115","title":"Far-Field and Near-Field Effects of Marine Aquaculture","description":"Aquaculture for finfish, bivalves, and seaweed is an important and growing food producing sector globally. However, culturing of species in the marine environment implies multiple interactions between farmed species and their environment. This has led to concerns over the ecological effects of aquaculture, which include benthic organic loading, changes to water quality, habitat modification, disease spread, and introduction of exotic or invasive species, interaction with wild species, coastal eutrophication, and marine litter. Over the years, governments and international organizations have recognized the need to identify, mitigate, and reduce these ecological effects. The Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations proposes an Ecosystem Approach to Aquaculture (EAA), which implies recognizing its effects at multiple spatial scales, including near-field effect (farm scale) and far-field (bay scale and global scale) effect. This chapter reviews ecological effects of finfish, bivalve, and seaweed aquaculture in marine coastal waters, and describes the mitigation efforts currently used to improve its sustainable management.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Weitzman, J.","Steeves, L.","Bradford, J.","Filgueira, R."],"organization":["Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1219","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seabirds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000073","title":"Seabirds","description":"Seabirds have a global distribution, are numerous throughout the world\u2019s oceans, and have been used for decades to track and understand changes in the marine environment. They are dependent on a variety of ecosystems, including terrestrial, coastal, and pelagic, and are thus vulnerable to both marine and terrestrial environmental stressors. This chapter examines impacts on seabird populations that occur in the marine environment and are global in nature (touch more than one ocean basin). Both widespread (i.e., climate change induced alterations to marine food webs and sea level rise) and more point-source impacts (i.e., incidental bycatch in fisheries, hunting) are discussed. Additionally, natural occurrences in marine ecosystems (i.e., oceanographic regime shifts, parasites) and issues related to anthropogenic activities (i.e., plastic and oil pollution) are covered. Lastly, we discuss marine protected areasand other efforts aimed at conserving global seabird populations, including colony restoration, community-based research, and international conservation actions.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Votier, S.","Crawford, R.","Merkel, F.","Provencher, J.","Borrelle, S.","Sherley, R.","Avery-Gomm, S.","Hodum, P.","Bond, A.","Major, H.","McCoy, K.","Reynolds, M.","Hatfield, J.","Spatz, D.","Mallory, M."],"organization":["Acadia University","Auckland University of Technology","University of Exeter","University of Queensland","University of Puget Sound","Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)","University of New Brunswick","Montpellier 1 University","Aarhus University","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1220","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/new-advances-benthic-monitoring-technology-methodology","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000061","title":"New Advances in Benthic Monitoring Technology and Methodology","description":"The last few decades have seen dramatic increases in the abundance and variety of data that can be collected within benthic marine environments to monitor species and ecosystems. These developments are now allowing ecologists to view their study systems in ever greater detail and over scales ranging from microscopic to global. Here we give an overview of current widely used techniques, touch on a number of recent advances in both technologies and methodologies, and focus on photogrammetry. We recommend that greater synergies, standardization, and automation of a range of these methods could further improve many monitoring programs\u2019 effectiveness.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Bayley, D.","Mogg, A."],"organization":["University College London","Zoological Society of London","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1221","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/short-term-integration-costs-variable-renewable-energy-wind-curtailment-balancing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032118300091","title":"Short-term integration costs of variable renewable energy: Wind curtailment and balancing in Britain and Germany","description":"Britain and Germany saw unprecedented growth of variable renewable energy (VRE) in the last decade. Many studies suggest this will significantly raise short-term power system operation costs for balancing and congestion management. We review the actual development of these costs, their allocation and policy implications in both countries.  Since 2010, system operation costs have increased by 62% in Britain (with a five-fold increase in VRE capacity) and remained comparable in Germany (with capacity doubling). Within this, balancing costs stayed level in Britain (\u20134%) and decreased substantially in Germany (\u201372%), whilst congestion management costs have grown 74% in Britain and 14-fold in Germany. Curtailment costs vary widely from year to year, and should fall strongly when ongoing and planned grid upgrades are completed. Curtailment rates for wind farms have risen to 4\u20135% in Germany and 5\u20136% in Britain (0\u20131% for offshore and 15\u201316% for onshore Scottish farms).  Policy debates regarding the balancing system are similar in both countries, focussing on strengthening imbalance price signals and the extent that VRE generators bear the integration costs they cause. Both countries can learn from each other\u0027s balancing market and imbalance settlement designs. Britain should reform its balancing markets to be more transparent, competitive and open to new providers (especially VRE generators). Shorter trading intervals and gate closure would both require and enable market participants (including VRE) to take more responsibility for balancing. Germany should consider a reserve energy market and move to marginal imbalance pricing.","author":["Joos, M.","Staffell, I."],"organization":["Element Energy","Imperial College London"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Short-term_integration_costs_of_variable_renewable_energy_Wind_curtailment_and_balancing_in_Britain_and_Germany.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1222","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/remote-sensing-marine-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B978012805052100005X","title":"Remote Sensing for Marine Management","description":"Remote sensing has become an important tool for the management of the marine environment. Currently, researchers are able to map several important facets of the marine environment from space. This includes chlorophyll-a, ocean salinity, and sea surface temperature. In addition, researchers are able to use satellite data to assist in mapping out marine regions including seagrasses, corals, mangroves, wetlands, and even shallow benthic environments. Satellite data currently enable the researcher to determine significant wave height and ocean currents. They are being used to track biota ranging from fish, whales, turtles, and even large birds. Oil spill remote sensing continues to develop apace. This chapter briefly reviews these technologies and gives examples of the application to the various disciplines.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Fingas, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1223","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/salt-marshes-their-role-our-society-threats-posed-their-existence","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000048","title":"Salt Marshes: Their Role in Our Society and Threats Posed to Their Existence","description":"Salt marshes are middle to high latitude intertidal wetlands of great value. They play a major role in coastal defense, wildlife conservation, and as a key sink\/source of organic material and nutrients, and are vitally important for a wide range of marine communities. Salt marshes also function as a sink for pollutants that would otherwise damage the surrounding environment. They also represent important historical and scientific archives. However, the majority of them are increasingly threatened by direct (e.g., land reclamation, groundwater extraction) and indirect (e.g., the so-called \u201ccoastal squeeze\u201d) human actions, or by the effects of climate change. Indeed, salt marsh habitats have shrunk to half their historical coverage in the last century, and the enhanced sea level rise will be responsible for the loss of 60%\u201390% of today\u2019s salt marsh areal coverage in the near future, according to whether or not effective measures to limit greenhouse gas emissions are undertaken. Local, small-scale solutions, such as barriers and fences, can be effective only on a short-term perspective or when dealing with immediate risk. Managed realignment techniques that require the landward retreat of coastal defenses and the subsequent tidal inundation of previously claimed agricultural land are actions that ensure the survival of existing salt marshes (or the creation of new ones) over a longer temporal period. However, only the transition to a global model of development that is environmentally sustainable can ensure the persistence of salt marsh habitats and the maintenance of ecosystem services that they provide.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Giuliani, S.","Bellucci, L."],"organization":["National Research Council of Italy (CNR)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1224","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-drives-biotic-patterns-beyond-surf-zone-factors-influencing-abundance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2352485518302482","title":"Wave energy drives biotic patterns beyond the surf zone: Factors influencing abundance and occurrence of mobile fauna adjacent to subtropical beaches","description":"Management of beach ecosystems often focuses on geomorphic and socio-economic issues. Yet understanding patterns and processes affecting fishes and invertebrates in this dynamic inshore environment will better inform ecosystem management. We used Baited Remote Underwater Video (BRUVs) to survey fish and mobile invertebrate assemblages immediately beyond the surf zone (in 5\u20138 m depth) across 12 beaches of varying energy and geomorphology, to assess drivers of abundance and occurrence. These beaches in subtropical eastern Australia were categorised based on various morphological, energy, connectivity and management characteristics. Characteristics associated with wave energy (aspect, exposure, modal value) were the strongest drivers of assemblages and functional groups overall. Patterns were strongest for crabs, with high relative abundance of Diogenid crabs (hermit crabs) at low energy beaches, and high relative abundance of Matutid crabs (moon crabs) at higher energy beaches. Bony fish and elasmobranchs were also predominantly influenced by energy characteristics, but these patterns were highly variable. This habitat beyond the surf zone was richer in species relative to adjacent deeper unconsolidated habitats, especially for elasmobranchs. It included target fished species and was a juvenile nursery for several Carangid species. These patterns and values should be considered when management actions are undertaken.","author":["Smith, S.","Schultz, A.","Malcolm, H.","Ferrari, R."],"organization":["Southern Cross University","University of Sydney"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-32.199038700000","146.483675800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1225","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-approach-offshore-wind-farm-feasibility-respect-ecosystem-based-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969719307661","title":"A modelling approach for offshore wind farm feasibility with respect to ecosystem-based marine spatial planning","description":"Demand for renewable energy is increasing steadily and regulated by national and international policies. Offshore wind energy sector has been clearly the fastest in its development among other options, and development of new wind farms requires large ocean space. Therefore, there is a need of efficient spatial planning process, including the site selection constrained by technical (wind resource, coastal distance, seafloor) and environmental (impacts) factors and competence of uses. We present a novel approach, using Bayesian Belief Networks (BBN), for an integrated spatially explicit site feasibility identification for offshore wind farms. Our objectives are to: (i) develop a spatially explicit model that integrates the technical, economic, environmental and social dimensions; (ii) operationalize the BBN model; (iii) implement the model at local (Basque Country) and regional (North East Atlantic and Western Mediterranean), and (iv) develop and analyse future scenarios for wind farm installation in a local case study. Results demonstrated a total of 1% (23\u202fkm2) of moderate feasibility areas in local scaled analysis, compared to 4% of (21,600\u202fkm2) very high, and 5% (30,000\u202fkm2) of high feasibility in larger scale analysis. The main challenges were data availability and discretization when trying to expand the model from local to regional level. The use of BBN models to determine the feasibility of offshore wind farm areas has been demonstrated adequate and possible, both at local and regional scales, allowing managers to take management decisions regarding marine spatial planning when including different activities, environmental problems and technological constraints.","author":["Borja, A.","Bald, J.","Galparsoro, I.","Depellegrin, D.","P\u0131narba\u015f\u0131, K.","P\u00e9rez-Mor\u00e1n, G."],"organization":["AZTI","National Research Council of Italy (CNR)","Tecnalia"],"originationDate":"2019-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.963377100000","-3.151079100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:08:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1226","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/status-trends-worlds-kelp-forests","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000036","title":"Status and Trends for the World\u0027s Kelp Forests","description":"Kelp forests are extensive underwater habitats that range along 25% of the world\u2019s coastlines, providing valuable resources, habitat, and services for coastal communities. They grow best in cold, nutrient-rich water, where they attain some of the highest rates of primary production of any natural ecosystem. Kelps exhibit a great diversity of growth forms and life strategies, with the largest individuals reaching lengths of \u0026gt; 30 m and biomasses of 42 kg. In the past half century, threats to kelp forests have increased in number and severity, leading to a global decline of kelp abundances of ~ 2% per year. Trajectories of change vary considerable across regions and include range contractions, range expansions, species replacements, establishment of invasive kelps, replacement by turf algae reefs, or regime shifts to sea urchinbarrens. These changes will likely have significant impacts on marine biodiversity and ecosystem functioning because kelps are foundation species for a plethora of habitat-associated plants and animals, many of which are socioeconomically important. Some forms of management have been effective in restoring kelp forests, but in many cases the threats facing kelp forests in the future greatly exceed local conservation strategies, necessitating novel conservation solutions to protect and conserve these ecosystems. Although the diversity of changes to kelp forest globally make it challenging to generalize about their future, it seems almost certain that many kelp forests a few decades from now will differ substantially from what they are today.  Book: World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Pedersen, M.","Wernberg, T.","Krumhansl, K.","Filbee-Dexter, K."],"organization":["University of Western Australia","Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)","Norwegian Institute for Water Research (NIVA)","Roskilde University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1227","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/global-status-coral-reefs-combination-disturbances-stressors-become-ratchets","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128050521000024","title":"Global Status of Coral Reefs: In Combination, Disturbances and Stressors Become Ratchets","description":"Although there are still many local coral-reef communities that display remarkably rapid recovery, numerous surveys have indicated that the average living coral cover is decreasing circumtropically. This is partly because disturbance is nearly always faster than recovery, damaged or stressed corals tend to produce fewer larvae, reef community recovery times become longer when fast-growing branching corals are more vulnerable to stresses and disturbances and are replaced by more tolerant slow-growing corals, disturbances become more frequent and do not allow sufficient time for recovery, combinations of local and global disturbances and stresses result in positive feedbacks that accelerate reef degradation, and degraded reefs decrease the proportion of habitat acceptable to recruiting larvae. In the recent past, many reefs had time to largely recover before the next disturbance; otherwise, the reefs at the sites would not have developed as well as they had. As more reefs are disturbed and become less favorable for survival of recruits, connectivity is reduced by fewer larvae produced, more areas become unattractive to larvae for settlement, distances between fewer favorable sites become longer, and larval pelagic duration sometimes becomes shorter with increasing temperature. The processes listed above determine that prevention is more efficient and effective than repair. Marine reserves and fixing local problems are important to continue, but they are not buying time. The time has arrived and we have to act directly on the reduction of CO2 emissions.\n\nBook:\u00a0World Seas: an Environmental Evaluation (Second Edition) Volume III: Ecological Issues and Environmental Impacts","author":["Birkeland, C."],"organization":["University of Hawaii"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1228","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-clustering-mediterranean-sea-case-pelagos-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fenrg.2019.00016\/full","title":"Marine Renewable Energy Clustering in the Mediterranean Sea: The Case of PELAGOS Project","description":"The main ideas presented in this work are an outcome of the Interreg MED project PELAGOS (Promoting innovative nEtworks and cLusters for mArine renewable energy synerGies in Mediterranean cOasts and iSlands). Since Blue Energy development is at its very beginning in the Mediterranean Sea, the aim of the paper is to present and discuss in depth the key-issues for a Marine Renewable Energy (MRE) cluster development in the Mediterranean and reveal its necessity for the commercial and sustainable development of Blue Energy in the area. This cluster is expected to stimulate the relevant Blue Energy sectors under the perspective of smart and sustainable growth. A healthy cluster is based on an efficient cluster policy. The main policy constituents (innovation, legislation and financial frameworks) are discussed taking into account the interrelated characteristics that are expected to specify the commercial development of MRE in the area. Key issues that can contribute to the establishment and acceleration of deployment of the related technological innovation are identified, and existent hindrances and challenges encountered in MRE sector are determined. The importance of solid financing instruments and strong collaborations among interested stakeholders is also highlighted for the viability of the MRE cluster. Finally, as an example of the cluster activities at a national level, the Greek Hub for Blue Energy is introduced. In this respect, aspects in terms of its structure and the services provided to its members are analyzed.","author":["Soukissian, T.","Adamopoulos, C.","Prospathopoulos, A."],"organization":["National Technical University of Athens"],"originationDate":"2019-02-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Soukissian-2019-Med-Sea.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1229","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/role-maritime-spatial-planning-advance-blue-energy-european-union","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X1830304X","title":"The role of maritime spatial planning on the advance of blue energy in the European Union","description":"In recent years the European Union has firmly committed itself to energy from oceans as a means of decarbonising the European energy system. Despite a favourable political landscape, the development of offshorerenewables still faces economic and technological barriers, which are coupled with the inherent difficulties of anincreasingly industrialised marine environment, such as complex evolving regulation, lack of knowledge re-garding the possible environmental impact of such an activity, as well as spatial conflicts with other traditionaland emerging uses. Most of the coastal Member States have adopted Maritime Spatial Planning (MSP) as afundamental tool for integrated and sustainable management of human activities in the marine environment.MSP is capable of definitively driving the use of offshore renewable facilities. Its proper application supportsdecision making, simplifies and accelerates the process of obtaining permits, improves compatibility of uses,integrates stakeholders in planning, prevents environmental deterioration of sensitive areas, enhances theavailability of information and promotes cross-border co-operation. This paper aims to evaluate the influence ofmaritime spatial planning processes on the advance of blue energy within the framework of the European Union.The results show positive relationships between MSP and the development of offshore renewable energy incountries such as Germany, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom.","author":["Ruiz, J.","Garc\u00eda, P.","Sanabria, J."],"organization":["University of Cadiz"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1230","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proceedings-ocean-waves-workshop-2013","sourceURL":"https:\/\/scholarworks.uno.edu\/oceanwaves\/2013\/","title":"Proceedings of Ocean Waves Workshop (2013)","description":"Ocean wave information relies on the collection of oceanographic and meteorological data, analysis and interpretation of the data, and dissemination of the resulting information products. These products can range from statistical tables and charts to bulletins and technical reports. Operational oceanography is distinct in that the science is focused on the development of information products that are used for decision making. Ocean wave conditions are a major constituent in any operational plan and are important to support safe maritime activities such as navigation, loading ships, fishing, recreation, mineral extraction, power generation, and military exercises. This workshop goes beyond consideration of descriptive wave products such as spectra from buoys, hindcasts from historical weather records, and forecasts from wave models. It provides the opportunity for participants to share their procedures for preparing and distributing wave information products; workshop attendees will discuss how their products are actually used to support decision making.  Scientists, engineers, and managers have been invited to present ideas, research results, case studies, work in progress, and system demonstrations related to the use of wave buoys, models, and information to support operations. Discussions will highlight how wave information is used to make decisions such as the issuance of warnings to mariners, evacuation of coastal areas, routing of ships into favorable seaways, and efficient deployment of marine spill response equipment. This workshop provides a forum for operational oceanographers to stimulate discussion, provide new insights, and provide feedback for focused experiments.  Workshop Objectives:  (1) Discuss technologies and applications that provide information on ocean waves.  (2) Improve the exchange of information on state-of-the-art wave measuring and modeling capabilities through cross-fertilization by participants of diverse backgrounds and areas of expertise.  (3) Share information on projects using ocean wave measurements to illustrate the kinds of problems and solutions encountered in real world oceanography.","author":["Williams, R.","Nichols, C."],"organization":["University of New Orleans"],"originationDate":"2013-02-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.027254300000","-90.064225800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nichols-2013-Proceedings.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1231","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proceedings-ocean-waves-workshop-2015","sourceURL":"https:\/\/scholarworks.uno.edu\/oceanwaves\/2015\/","title":"Proceedings of Ocean Waves Workshop (2015)","description":"Ocean wave information relies on the collection of oceanographic and meteorological data, analysis and interpretation of the data, and dissemination of the resulting information products. These products can range from statistical tables and charts to bulletins and technical reports. Operational oceanography is distinct in that the science is focused on the development of information products that are used for decision making. Ocean wave conditions are a major constituent in any operational plan and are important to support safe maritime activities such as navigation, loading ships, fishing, recreation, mineral extraction, power generation, and military exercises. This workshop goes beyond consideration of descriptive wave products such as spectra from buoys, hindcasts from historical weather records, and forecasts from wave models. It provides the opportunity for participants to share their procedures for preparing and distributing wave information products; workshop attendees will discuss how their products are actually used to support decision making.  Scientists, engineers, and managers have been invited to present ideas, research results, case studies, work in progress, and system demonstrations related to the use of wave buoys, models, and information to support operations. Discussions will highlight how wave information is used to make decisions such as the issuance of warnings to mariners, evacuation of coastal areas, routing of ships into favorable seaways, and efficient deployment of marine spill response equipment. This workshop provides a forum for operational oceanographers to stimulate discussion, provide new insights, and provide feedback for focused experiments.  Topics that were discussed included, but were not limited to:    (1) Wave measurements to support coastal construction.  (2) Numerical studies of waves, currents, and sediment transport.  (3) Sediment model applications with wave observations.  (4) Coastal wave buoys to save lives and protect property.  (5) Accessibility of wave information for scientists, engineers, and managers.","author":["Nichols, C."],"organization":["University of New Orleans"],"originationDate":"2015-01-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.028522200000","-90.065604400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1232","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/numerical-modeling-effects-wave-energy-converter-characteristics-nearshore-wave","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148115305528","title":"Numerical modeling of the effects of wave energy converter characteristics on nearshore wave conditions","description":"Modeled nearshore wave propagation was investigated downstream of simulated wave energy converters (WECs) to evaluate overall near- and far-field effects of WEC arrays. Model sensitivity to WEC characteristics and WEC array deployment scenarios was evaluated using a modified version of an industry standard wave model, Simulating WAves Nearshore (SWAN), which allows the incorporation of device-specific WEC characteristics to specify obstacle transmission. The sensitivity study illustrated that WEC device type and subsequently its size directly resulted in wave height variations in the lee of the WEC array. Wave heights decreased up to 30% between modeled scenarios with and without WECs for large arrays (100 devices) of relatively sizable devices (26 m in diameter) with peak power generation near to the modeled incident wave height. Other WEC types resulted in less than 15% differences in modeled wave height with and without WECs, with lesser influence for WECs less than 10 m in diameter.Wave directions and periods were largely insensitive to changes in parameters. However, additional model parameterization and analysis are required to fully explore the model sensitivity of peak wave period and mean wave direction to the varying of the parameters.","author":["Chang, G.","Roberts, J.","Ruehl, K.","Jones, C.","Chartrand, C."],"organization":["Integral Consulting Inc","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1233","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-renewable-energy-ecological-implications-generating-electricity-coastal-zone","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/j.1365-2664.2005.01060.x","title":"Offshore renewable energy: ecological implications of generating electricity in the coastal zone","description":"Summary:  1) Global\u2010scale environmental degradation and its links with non\u2010renewable fossil fuels have led to an increasing interest in generating electricity from renewable energy resources. Much of this interest centres on offshore renewable energy developments (ORED). The large scale of proposed ORED will add to the existing human pressures on coastal ecosystems, therefore any ecological costs and benefits must be determined.  2) The current pressures on coastal ecology set the context within which the potential impacts (both positive and negative) of offshore renewable energy generation are discussed.  3) The number of published peer\u2010review articles relating to renewable energy has increased dramatically since 1991. Significantly, only a small proportion of these articles relate to environmental impacts and none considers coastal ecology.  4) Actual or potential environmental impact can occur during construction, operation and\/or decommissioning of ORED.  5) Construction and decommissioning are likely to cause significant physical disturbance to the local environment. There are both short\u2010 and long\u2010term implications for the local biological communities. The significance of any effects is likely to depend on the natural disturbance regime and the stability and resilience of the communities.  6) During day\u2010to\u2010day operation, underwater noise, emission of electromagnetic fields and collision or avoidance with the energy structures represent further potential impacts on coastal species, particularly large predators. The wider ecological implications of any direct and indirect effects are discussed.  7) Synthesis and applications. This review demonstrates that offshore renewable energy developments will have direct and, potentially, indirect consequences for coastal ecology, with these effects occurring at different scales. Ecologists should be involved throughout all the phases of an ORED to ensure that appropriate assessments of the interaction of single and multiple developments with the coastal environment are undertaken.","author":["Gill, A."],"organization":["Cranfield University"],"originationDate":"2005-08-08","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gill2005.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1234","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-cetaceans","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Sarah_Dolman2\/publication\/228658933_Marine_Renewable_Energy_and_Cetaceans\/links\/00b7d516fe794f160e000000.pdf","title":"Marine renewable energy and cetaceans","description":"There is an ongoing development of offshore renewable energy projects worldwide. Marine wind power technology is the most advanced and tidal and wave power projects are creating increasing interest. Marine renewable energy projects to date have been focused in northern Europe, yet developments are also planned and underway in other parts of the world. Whilst these offshore renewable energy developments are typically characterised as environmentally desirable, there are some associated adverse impacts that deserve careful consideration. However, the renewable energy industry is in some ways still in its infancy and, as such, not all of its impacts are clear or fully assessed. This paper outlines the global development of this sector, identifies species of particular concern, outlines some of the possible effects from renewable energy developments on cetaceans and identifies research and monitoring needs to address important knowledge gaps.","author":["Simmonds, M.","Dolman, S.","Green, M."],"organization":["Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society"],"originationDate":"2007-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Dolman_et_al_2007.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1235","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/minimal-effects-wind-turbines-distribution-wintering-farmland-birds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/j.1365-2664.2008.01560.x","title":"Minimal effects of wind turbines on the distribution of wintering farmland birds","description":"Summary:  1) Energy production from wind power is increasing rapidly in Europe to help combat the threats from global warming. For example, the European Commission have set a target for 20% of EU energy to come from renewable sources by 2020. In recent decades, biodiversity on European farmland has fallen dramatically due to agricultural intensification. Agri\u2010environment schemes (AES) have been implemented across the EU, in part at least, to combat these declines. Significant numbers of turbines are, and will be, built on farmland. There is, therefore, a potential conflict between wind turbines and AES on farmland.  2) Various mechanisms potentially cause wind turbines to alter bird distribution including noise and physical structure.  3) We show that turbine location (controlling for other effects such as boundary location and crop type) did not affect the distribution of four functional groups of wintering farmland birds (seed\u2010eaters, corvids, gamebirds and Eurasian skylarks) at differing distances from wind turbines ranging from 0\u2013150 m to 600\u2013750 m. The only species for which distribution was related to the presence of wind turbines was the largest and least manoeuvrable (common pheasant Phasianus colchicus L.).  4) In a further analysis of data collected at 0\u201375 m and 75\u2013150 m from turbines, we found no evidence to suggest that farmland birds in our study avoided areas close to wind turbines.  5) Synthesis and applications. This is the first evidence suggesting that the present and future location of large numbers of wind turbines on European farmland is unlikely to have detrimental effects on farmland birds (at least for those species included in our study). This should be welcome news for nature conservationists, wind energy companies and policy\u2010makers. However, our work is only a first step, as there may be potential influences of wind turbines on bird distribution during the breeding season.","author":["Devereux, C.","Denny, M.","Whittingham, M."],"organization":["Newcastle University"],"originationDate":"2008-10-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.462558000000","0.562089000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/devereuxetal2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1236","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-benefits-leaving-offshore-infrastructure-ocean","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/fee.1827","title":"Environmental benefits of leaving offshore infrastructure in the ocean","description":"The removal of thousands of structures associated with oil and gas development from the world\u2019s oceans is well underway, yet the environmental impacts of this decommissioning practice remain unknown. Similar impacts will be associated with the eventual removal of offshore wind turbines. We conducted a global survey of environmental experts to guide best decommissioning practices in the North Sea, a region with a substantial removal burden. In contrast to current regulations, 94.7% of experts (36 out of 38) agreed that a more flexible case-by-case approach to decommissioning could benefit the North Sea environment. Partial removal options were considered to deliver better environmental outcomes than complete removal for platforms, but both approaches were equally supported for wind turbines. Key considerations identified for decommissioning were biodiversity enhancement, provision of reef habitat, and protection from bottom trawling, all of which are negatively affected by complete removal. We provide recommendations to guide the revision of offshore decommissioning policy, including a temporary suspension of obligatory removal.","author":["Degraer, S.","Vanaverbeke, J.","Teilmann, J.","Gill, A.","Schroeder, D.","May, R.","Todd, V.","Lindeboom, H.","Brabant, R.","Boon, A.","Dahlgren, T.","Claisse, J.","Van Hoey, G.","Jones, D.","Coolen, J.","Fowler, A.","J\u00f8rgensen, A.","Svendsen, J.","Macreadie, P.","Booth, D.","Callahan, E.","Dokken, Q.","Johns, D.","Leewis, R.","Linden, O.","Murk, A.","Ottersen, G.","Shastri, S."],"organization":["University of Technology Sydney","North Sea Futures","Technical University of Denmark (DTU)","Deakin University","National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","Deltares (NL)","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","Blue Latitudes LLC","California Polytechnic State University Pomona","Uni Research AS","University of Gothenburg","Tarleton State University","PANGALIA Environmental","The Citadel Hill Laboratory","Wageningen University and Research Centre","Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research (NIOZ)","World Maritime University","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","Institute of Marine Research (IMR)","University of Oslo","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)","Aarhus University","Ocean Science Consulting","Solent University","Flanders Research Institute for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (IVLO)"],"originationDate":"2018-07-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.165084000000","3.367724000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1238","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-artificial-structures-amplifiers-aurelia-aurita-sl-blooms-case-study-newly","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007%2Fs10872-014-0249-1","title":"Marine artificial structures as amplifiers of Aurelia aurita s.l. blooms: a case study of a newly installed floating pier","description":"Increase of marine artificial structures, providing more substrate for jellyfish polyps, has been argued to increase jellyfish outbreaks, although no explicit evidence exists. We report a case study demonstrating a remarkable increase of Aurelia aurita s.l. ephyrae after the installation of a floating pier (48 9 6 m) in a fishing port on the Inland Sea of Japan. Monitoring of ephyrae from January 2010, prior to the installation of the floating pier in April 2010, to July 2011, revealed that their time-weighted average density increased 3.5 fold, from 1.1 to 3.9 ephyrae m-3, and the integrated number of ephyrae exported from the port increased 4.3 fold, from 5.7 9 106 to 25 9 106 ephyrae, after the installation. However, in a nearby port, a control site, the abundance of ephyrae decreased by ca. one third during the same period. Monitoring of polyps showed that they initially colonized the undersurface of the pier by August 2010, followed by a rapid population increase. They strobilated from December 2010 to May 2011. We computed the number of ephyrae released from the strobilae to be ca. 25 9 106, very close to the net increase of ephyrae produced and exported from the port. This study corroborates that the installation of an artificial structure provides new a substrate for polyps, which allows them to produce more ephyrae to induce medusa blooms.","author":["Makabe, R.","Furukawa, R.","Takao, M.","Uye, S."],"organization":["Hiroshima University","Ishinomaki Senshu University"],"originationDate":"2014-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.407545000000","131.296415000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Makbeetal2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1239","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-potential-effects-wave-energy-devices-kelp-biotopes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/snh-commissioned-report-783-understanding-potential-effects-wave-energy-devices-kelp-biotopes","title":"Understanding the potential effects of wave energy devices on kelp biotopes","description":"Background:  Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) has identified a research need to improve understanding of the changes to kelp habitats as a result of the development of wave energy projects around Scotland. Notable development is planned in The Crown Estate\u2019s current leasing round with further zones being identified by Scottish Government in the latest draft plan options for the sector. Some of these developments have the potential to occur within the subtidal zone, where kelp habitats are prevalent.  Activities associated with wave projects such as installation, operation, maintenance and decommissioning may impact kelp communities in a number of ways, including kelp removal to permit installation of devices and associated infrastructure (cables and pipelines).  Main findings:    Areas designated for the deployment of shallow-water and shore-based wave energy converters (WECs) in Scotland coincide with important kelp habitats (dominated by Laminaria hyperborea).  Kelp covers approximately 3600 km2 of Scotland\u0027s coast and the estimated 10 million tonnes of kelp biomass supports more than 1800 different species of flora and fauna including other seaweeds, invertebrates, fish, diving birds and otters.  Existing wave lease areas coincide with 1.2% of Scotland\u2019s kelp habitats where kelp has a 50% likelihood of being rare or more abundant on the SACFOR scale.  The expected area of impact on kelp habitats will be much lower, given that the footprint of individual WECs will be far smaller than the wave lease areas.  Environmental impacts associated with wave energy projects may occur during construction, operation, maintenance and decommissioning project phases. Activities with potential impacts on kelp include: site preparation; installation of mooring anchors, cabling, mono-piling and \/ or construction of breakwaters; introduction of new substrates such as rock mattressing, metal or plastic piping; routine maintenance and decommissioning. These activities may result in direct loss of kelp habitats and \/ or temporary disturbances from which kelp can recover.  WECs may indirectly impact kelp habitats and wider nearshore ecosystems by inducing changes in hydrodynamics, sedimentation and wave energy, which favour the establishment of less diverse seaweed communities. The introduction of non-native species also poses a risk to kelp communities. However, the degree of this threat is largely uncertain.  Kelp habitats are subject to a high level of natural disturbance (for example loss of biomass during storms) and have an inherent capacity to recover rapidly.  After clearing, the kelp canopy can return to virgin biomass within 2-5 years and associated flora and fauna may take 1 to \u0026gt;6 years to return to their original density, dependent on species. Kelps are also able to colonise a variety of artificial substrates such as concrete blocks and rock mattressing. Repeat clearing of kelp at intervals of less than 2 years will prevent recovery of kelp habitat.  Recovery of kelp habitats after disturbance can be facilitated by: - Introducing new substrates that best match the natural environment. - Not sterilising new surfaces unless essential for device operation. - Leaving kelp holdfasts intact when clearing and thereby retaining refuges for associated fauna. - Allowing kelp canopy to mature (\u0026gt;5 years age) between successive clearings. - Avoiding sites that are adjacent to extensive areas of fine sediments.  The findings of the objective risk assessment are that kelp habitats have a medium to very high sensitivity to site-specific disturbances that may be induced by wave energy projects. However, given the extent of kelp habitat in Scotland and the level of natural disturbance tolerated by these habitats, the magnitude of the predicted impact is generally minor or negligible on a regional and national scale.","author":["Burrows, M.","Macleod, A.","Greenhill, L.","Orr, K."],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.854193200000","-4.791505500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Understanding-the-potential-effects-of-wave-energy-devices-on-kelp-biotopes.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1240","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/riding-waves-use-pelamis-device-seabirds","sourceURL":"","title":"Riding the waves: use of the Pelamis device by seabirds","description":"Seabirds are important marine predators that may be influenced by developments in marine renewable energy. To explore how seabirds might exploit novel floating structures at sea, an autonomous camera system was used to record attendance of seabirds on a Pelamis wave-energy device. Numbers and identities of seabirds on the machine were explored in relation to a set of metocean variables. Use of the machine was most affected by time of day, but less so by state of the tide. Birds did not use the machine during strong winds or when waves were large. Cameras can provide an effective, low-cost way to collect data about seabirds over weeks or months in inaccessible locations and under inclement metocean conditions.","author":["Jackson, A."],"organization":["Cornwall College","North Highland College"],"originationDate":"2014-04-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.982000000000","3.391000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/jacksonetal2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1241","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-magnetic-pulses-caribbean-spiny-lobsters-implications-magnetoreception","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jeb.biologists.org\/content\/219\/12\/1827.abstract","title":"Effect of magnetic pulses on Caribbean spiny lobsters: implications for magnetoreception","description":"The Caribbean spiny lobster, Panulirus argus, is a migratory crustacean that uses Earth\u2019s magnetic field as a navigational cue, but how these lobsters detect magnetic fields is not known. Magnetic material thought to be magnetite has previously been detected in spiny lobsters, but its role in magnetoreception, if any, remains unclear. As a first step toward investigating whether lobsters might have magnetite-based magnetoreceptors, we subjected lobsters to strong, pulsed magnetic fields capable of reversing the magnetic dipole moment of biogenic magnetite crystals. Lobsters were subjected to a single pulse directed from posterior to anterior and either: (1) parallel to the horizontal component of the geomagnetic field (i.e. toward magnetic north); or (2) antiparallel to the horizontal field (i.e. toward magnetic south). An additional control group was handled but not subjected to a magnetic pulse. After treatment, each lobster was tethered in a water-filled arena located within 200 m of the capture location and allowed to walk in any direction. Control lobsters walked in seemingly random directions and were not significantly oriented as a group. In contrast, the two groups exposed to pulsed fields were significantly oriented in approximately opposite directions. Lobsters subjected to a magnetic pulse applied parallel to the geomagnetic horizontal component walked westward; those subjected to a pulse directed antiparallel to the geomagnetic horizontal component oriented approximately northeast. The finding that a magnetic pulse alters subsequent orientation behavior is consistent with the hypothesis that magnetoreception in spiny lobsters is based at least partly on magnetite-based magnetoreceptors.","author":["Lohmann, K.","Ernst, D."],"organization":["University of North Carolina"],"originationDate":"2016-06-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["24.826327700000","-80.816127100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ernst-Lohmann-2016-Spiny-Lobsters.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1242","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-tidal-power-schemes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.icevirtuallibrary.com\/doi\/10.1680\/maen.2009.162.4.165","title":"Environmental impacts of tidal power schemes","description":"This paper describes the potential environmental changes caused by tidal power installations with illustration for schemes in the eastern Irish Sea, focussing mainly on major estuarine barrages. The generic impacts in the near-field and far-field are discussed. Results from a 0-D and a 2-D model are presented: the former allows rapid calculations to be made for a large range of options while the latter allows the full effect on 2D hydrodynamics to be investigated. It is shown that there may be a significant change in tidal amplitude at the coast of Northern Ireland. The bed stress in the Bristol Channel will be significantly reduced if a Severn barrage is constructed. Some effects on the tidal mixing are expected although the location of tidal fronts in the Irish and Celtic Seas will not be changed significantly. The largest environmental impact is expected to be on the amount of inter-tidal area retained after construction of an estuarine barrage. It is shown that the loss of mudflats can be substantially reduced by using a dual-mode (ebb and flood generation) scheme with an increased number of turbines over the lowest-cost option.","author":["Wolf, J.","Walkington, I.","Holt, J.","Burrows, R."],"organization":["University of Liverpool"],"originationDate":"2009-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.464099500000","-6.195259100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/wolfetal2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1243","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/characterization-benthic-conditions-organisms-oregon-south-coast-areas-targeted-wave","sourceURL":"","title":"Characterization of Benthic Conditions and Organisms on the Oregon South Coast in areas targeted for Wave Energy Development","description":"This project was a single assessment of the benthic habitat characteristics and organisms near the future Ocean Power Technologies Demonstration facility near Reedsport, OR, and a reference location. The goal of this project was to assess sediment characteristics, infaunal invertebrates, epifaunal invertebrates, and fish at the future installation site, inshore of the target site, and at a reference site. Specifically, CTD casts, box cores, and beam trawl collections were conducted at the sited in summer 2011. In summary, all assemblages sampled had distributions strongly driven by depth. Other factors contributing to the variability among sampling stations were potentially due to differences in temperature and dissolved oxygen, which co-vary with depth. In the following document we report in detail on the spatial variability of the habitat features and biological assemblages. Finally, we make recommendations for plans for future monitoring at these or similar sites.","author":["Henkel, S."],"organization":["Northwest National Marine Renewable Energy Center (NNMREC)","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)"],"originationDate":"2011-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.680843000000","-124.229817000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Physical Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2025-07-28 10:49:43","signatureProject":["PacWave"],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Henkel-2011-Oregon-South-Coast.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1244","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/baseline-characterization-monitoring-oregon-state-universitys-ocean-test-facility-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pacificoceanenergy.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/09\/Baseline-Characterization-of-Benthic-Habitats-and-Organisms-Newport-December-2011.pdf","title":"Baseline Characterization and Monitoring of Oregon State University\u0027s Ocean Test Facility Site","description":"This project was carried out collaboratively by Oregon State University (OSU) scientists and involved participation by scientists from the Oregon Department of Fisheries and Wildlife (ODFW) and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Northwest Fisheries Science Center. The goal of this project was baseline characterization via observations and sample collection of the habitat and biological assemblages present at the future site of the Northwest National Marine Renewable Energy Center (NNMREC) Ocean Test Facility near Newport, OR. Specifically, CTD casts, box core and beam trawl collections, and video observations were conducted at the site from spring 2010 to fall 2011. These collections and observations help characterize the baseline variability in habitat and species characteristics across seasons over two years. Below we summarize overall findings. In the following document we report on the spatial and temporal variability of the habitat features and biological assemblages. Finally, we review our participation to date in disseminating these results and outline plans for post-installation monitoring of the Ocean Test Facility site.","author":["Henkel, S.","Barth, J.","Ciannelli, L."],"organization":["Northwest National Marine Renewable Energy Center (NNMREC)","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)"],"originationDate":"2011-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.675829000000","-124.099587000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Physical Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2025-07-28 10:47:33","signatureProject":["PacWave"],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Henkel-2011-Ocean-Test-Facility.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1245","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stakeholder-perceptions-wave-hub-development-cornwall-uk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/submissions.ewtec.org\/proc-ewtec\/issue\/archive","title":"Stakeholder Perceptions of the Wave Hub Development in Cornwall, UK.","description":"Despite a growing body of research examining stakeholder perceptions of offshore wind-farms, little social research has focused on offshore wave energy devices. With the Wave Hub project proposed for Hayle Bay, Cornwall, in 2010, it is apparent that even developments that are \u2018out of sight, out of mind\u2019 still require extensive stakeholder engagement if opposition is to be reduced. Findings from ongoing research into stakeholder perceptions of marine renewable energy suggest that the science underpinning these devices needs to be more robust and clearly articulated, with baseline data accounting for temporal shifts in marine environments, to allay stakeholder concerns. There also needs to be realistic information by project proponents on the local benefits of the Wave Hub project, as many stakeholders feel the public will be disappointed if benefits are artificially inflated. The Wave Hub also creates a quandary for some stakeholders who see supporting the Wave Hub as paving the way for widespread deployment of marine renewables, leading to significant impacts on marine environments. The more general findings from the study are that it cannot be assumed that \u2018out of sight\u2019 means \u2018out of mind\u2019 or that the same opposition factors identified for offshore wind developments apply to wave and tidal devices.","author":["Bailey, I.","West, J.","Whithead, I."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2009-09-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.578287700000","-4.918734600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-27 11:43:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Westetal2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1246","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/west-coast-marine-bird-surveys-quantitative-shipboard-surveys-species-distribution","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pacificoceanenergy.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/09\/Baseline-Seabird-Assessment-August-2008.pdf","title":"West Coast Marine Bird Surveys - Quantitative shipboard surveys of species distribution and abundance on the continental shelf during April 2008 and July-August 2008","description":"As part of the California Current Ecosystem Survey, NOAA Fisheries sponsored pairs of seabird observers who collected quantitative information on marine bird species, abundance, and behavior during all daylight hours when the ship was under way. Observers participated on Leg 1 and Leg 2 of the April 2008 Miller Freeman survey, and Legs 1, 2, and 3 of the July-August David Starr Jordan survey. OWET provided funding for observers on Leg 2 of the April cruise and Legs 1 and 2 of the July cruise; data from non-OWET funded legs are included for completeness. This report is meant to provide a concise data summary of methods, survey dates and locations, and relative abundance of bird species seen during the surveys. It is not a final analysis, nor have data been fully processed to provide absolute abundances.","author":["Zamon, J."],"organization":["National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)"],"originationDate":"2008-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.981425000000","-125.221706000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zamon-2008-West-Coast-Bird-Surveys.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1247","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/winter-marine-bird-surveys","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pacificoceanenergy.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/05\/Marine-Bird-Winter-Surveys%E2%80%94March-2012.pdf","title":"Winter Marine Bird Surveys","description":"Information on winter marine bird and mammal distributions in Oregon coastal waters has been identified as a data need for marine spatial planning of ocean energy development. As part of the annual marine mammal surveys of the critical habitat for Endangered Species Act (ESA)-listed Southern Resident Killer Whales (Orcinus orca), National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Fisheries mobilized a winter research survey during 16 February to 06 March 2012. To study marine birds. Partnership between NOAA Fisheries Northwest Fisheries Science Center (Conservation Biology and Fish Ecology divisions) and the Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET) allowed the principal investigator to place two contract seabird observers on board the Shimada for the entire survey. Deployment of seabird observers during this winter survey allowed quantitative information of marine bird species, abundance and behavior to be collected during all daylight hours when the ship was under way and weather conditions permitted. This report is meant to provide a concise data summary of methods, survey dates and locations, and basic information about bird species seen during the surveys. It is not a final analysis, nor have data been fully processed to provide absolute at-sea density estimates. Marine mammal observations and other ecosystem data collection were funded entirely by NOAA Fisheries; these data are in the custody of M. Bradley Hanson and Dawn Noren, who served as Chief Scientists for the 2012 research survey.","author":["Mills, G."],"organization":["National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)"],"originationDate":"2012-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.057494800000","-125.071869700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:08:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mills-2012-Winter-Bird-Surveys.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1248","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/project-assess-potential-impacts-reedsport-ocean-power-technologies-wave-energy","sourceURL":"","title":"Project to Assess Potential Impacts of the Reedsport Ocean Power Technologies Wave Energy Generation Facility on Migration and Habitat use of Green Sturgeon (Acipenser medirostris)","description":"Sites selected for ocean energy projects (e.g., wave energy) are typically near estuaries and bays. A wave energy project had been planned in the ocean at depths of 62\u201369 m near Reedsport, Oregon, northwest of the Umpqua River estuary. Green sturgeon (Acipenser medirostris) from the southern and northern distinct population segments (DPS) use this estuary during the spring\u2013fall, presumably for feeding. The Southern DPS is listed as threatened under the U.S. Endangered Species Act. A \u201cbeforeafter\u201d study was designed to identify potential interactions between the proposed wave energy project and green sturgeon, but the project was terminated before fieldwork ended. Nonetheless, understanding movements and habitat use of green sturgeon near estuaries and bays is important for site selection of future ocean energy projects. Using up to 43 automated acoustic receivers within and outside of the proposed project area, we monitored for the occurrence of 770 subadult and adult green sturgeon tagged with coded ultrasonic transmitters, which were affixed by other researchers on unrelated projects. We detected 248 green sturgeon within the receiver array from January 2013 through June 2014. Green sturgeon were detected on 492 of 515 monitoring days (95.5%) by the ocean array of receivers anchored at depths of 12\u2013110 m. Peak detections occurred at 50\u201370 m. Some individuals migrated through the area quickly, whereas others used the area for extended periods of time (e.g., months). Although there was some migration of green sturgeon between receivers anchored in the Umqpua River estuary and the ocean receivers, most of the individuals detected on the ocean array were not detected inside of the estuary. These results suggest that the ocean immediately offshore and upcoast\/downcoast of estuaries that support green sturgeon may be important green sturgeon habitats, and significant numbers of green sturgeon may interact with wave energy project projects in such areas.","author":["Payne, J.","Erickson, D.","Donnellan, M.","Lindley, S."],"organization":["Oregon Department of Fish and Wildlife","Alaska Department of Fish \u0026 Game","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)"],"originationDate":"2015-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.686563600000","-124.235447100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Payne-2015-Green-Sturgeon.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1249","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/high-use-oceanic-areas-atlantic-leatherback-sea-turtles-dermochelys-coriacea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00227-006-0262-z","title":"High-use oceanic areas for Atlantic leatherback sea turtles (Dermochelys coriacea) as identified using satellite telemetered location and dive information","description":"The movements and behavior of nine female leatherback sea turtles, Dermochelys coriacea (L.) were monitored for up to 370 days from their nesting beaches on the Caribbean island of Trinidad between 1995 and 2004 using satellite-linked time and depth recorders. During the inter-nesting period (typically March\u2013July) turtles ranged widely, but frequented the area around Galera Point on the NE corner of Trinidad. Diving depths were typically 26 min) as the turtles left the Caribbean, but became very shallow (\u003E50 m) and short at high latitudes. Between midOctober and mid-November, the turtles left high latitudes for a presumed foraging area in the Mauritania upwelling where they resided until their tracking records ended. Diving remained relatively shallow. It is proposed that movements of these turtles from one foraging area to another are driven by the opportunity to forage in areas of distinct oceanic structure which serve to concentrate their gelatinous prey (e.g., salps, Scyphomedusae, Siphonophora) either at or below the surface.","author":["Eckert, S."],"organization":["Hubbs SeaWorld Research Institute","Duke University"],"originationDate":"2006-03-04","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Reptiles","Sea Turtles"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-30 07:47:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1250","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fencing-bay-place-attachment-social-representations-energy-technologies-protection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/books.google.com\/books?hl=en\u0026lr=\u0026id=S1JfAgAAQBAJ\u0026oi=fnd\u0026pg=PA227\u0026dq=Devine-Wright,+P.,+2009.+Fencing+in+the+bay%3F+Place+attachment,+social+representations+of+energy+technologies+and+the+protection+of+restorative+environments.+In+Eds.+Marino+Bonai","title":"Fencing in the bay? Place attachment, social representations of energy technologies and the protection of restorative environments","description":"Although numerous UK and European opinion polls have indicated public support for more renewable energy, actual developments have often met with local opposition, typically described as \u0022NIMBYism\u0022 (not in my backyard). Although the NIMBY concept has been used both to describe and explain local opposition, the perjorative nature of the concept has led some researchers to recommend that the concept be abandoned. An alternative explanation has been proposed, where so-called \u0022NIMBY\u0022 responses are reconceived as place-protective actions, founded upon processes of place attachment and place identity. This chapter empirically explores this alternative perspective, drawing on mixed method data from a case study of a proposed offshore wind farm in North Wales, UK. Results indicated that place attachment negatively correlated with support for the wind farm. Analysis of place-related meanings and of perceived project impacts suggested that the project threatened place-related identities and attachments since it was objectified to \u0027fence in the bay\u0027, thereby closing off the horizon, damaging the distinctiveness and historical continuity of the place, as well as its ability to provide a restorative environment for visitors. The implications of the findings for theory and practice are explored.","author":["Devine-Wright, P."],"organization":["University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.319371500000","-3.858995700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1251","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/endogenous-cycles-activity-patterns-energy-expenditure-intertidal-fish-modified","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0269749118335656","title":"Endogenous cycles, activity patterns and energy expenditure of an intertidal fish is modified by artificial light pollution at night (ALAN)","description":"The increase of global light emissions in recent years has highlighted the need for urgent evaluation of their impacts on the behaviour, ecology and physiology of organisms. Numerous species exhibit daily cycles or strong scototaxic behaviours that could potentially be influenced if natural lighting conditions or cycles are disrupted. Artificial Light Pollution at Night (ALAN) stands for situations where artificial light alters natural light-dark cycles, as well as light intensities and wavelengths. ALAN is increasingly recognized as a potential threat to biodiversity, mainly because a growing number of studies are demonstrating its influence on animal behaviour, migration, reproduction and biological interactions. Most of these studies have focused on terrestrial organisms and ecosystems with studies on the effects of ALAN on marine ecosystems being more occasional. However, with the increasing human use and development of the coastal zone, organisms that inhabit shallow coastal or intertidal systems could be at increasing risk from ALAN. In this study we measured the levels of artificial light intensity in the field and used these levels to conduct experimental trials to determine the impact of ALAN on an intertidal fish. Specifically, we measured ALAN effects on physiological performance (oxygen consumption) and behaviour (activity patterns) of \u201cBaunco\u201d the rockfish Girella laevifrons, one of the most abundant and ecologically important intertidal fish in the Southeastern Pacific littoral. Our results indicated that individuals exposed to ALAN exhibited increased oxygen consumption and activity when compared with control animals. Moreover, those fish exposed to ALAN stopped displaying the natural (circatidal and circadian) activity cycles that were observed in control fish throughout the experiment. These changes in physiological function and behaviour could have serious implications for the long-term sustainability of fish populations and indirect impacts on intertidal communities in areas affected by ALAN.","author":["Vargas, J.","Pulgar, J.","Zeballos, D.","Aldana, M.","Manriquez, P.","Manriquez, K.","Quij\u00f3n, P.","Widdicombe, S.","Anguita, C.","Quintanilla, D.","Duarte, C."],"organization":["Universidad Andres Bello","Universidad Santo Tom\u00e1s"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Lighting"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1252","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthic-effects-offshore-renewables-identification-knowledge-gaps-urgently-needed","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article-abstract\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsz018\/5368123?redirectedFrom=fulltext","title":"Benthic effects of offshore renewables: identification of knowledge gaps and urgently needed research","description":"As the EU\u0027s commitment to renewable energy is projected to grow to 20% of energy generation by 2020, the use of marine renewable energy from wind, wave and tidal resources is increasing. This literature review (233 studies) (i) summarizes knowledge on how marine renewable energy devices affect benthic environments, (ii) explains how these effects could alter ecosystem processes that support major ecosystem services and (iii) provides an approach to determine urgent research needs. Conceptual diagrams were set up to structure hypothesized cause-effect relationships (i.e. paths). Paths were scored for (i) temporal and spatial scale of the effect, (ii) benthic sensitivity to these effects, (iii) the effect consistency and iv) scoring confidence, and consecutively ranked. This approach identified prominent knowledge gaps and research needs about (a) hydrodynamic changes possibly resulting in altered primary production with potential consequences for filter feeders, (b) the introduction and range expansion of non-native species (through stepping stone effects) and, (c) noise and vibration effects on benthic organisms. Our results further provide evidence that benthic sensitivity to offshore renewable effects is higher than previously indicated. Knowledge on changes of ecological functioning through cascading effects is limited and requires distinct hypothesis-driven research combined with integrative ecological modelling.","author":["Degraer, S.","Vanaverbeke, J.","Wilhelmsson, D.","Gill, A.","Dannheim, J.","Wilding, T.","Jackson, A.","Martin, G.","Bergstr\u00f6m, L.","Boon, A.","Derweduwen, J.","Hutchison, Z.","Dauvin, J.","Coolen, J.","Raoux, A.","Birchenough, S.","Janas, U.","Rostin, L.","Brzana, R.","De Mesel, I.","Reubens, L."],"organization":["Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences","Cefas Lowestoft Laboratory","University of Gda\u0144sk","Deltares (NL)","Wageningen University and Research Centre","Normandie Universit\u00e9","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","Institute for Agricultural and Fisheries Research (ILVO)","PANGALIA Environmental","Cornwall College","University of Rhode Island","University of Tartu","Flanders Marine Institute","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","Royal Swedish Academy of Science"],"originationDate":"2020-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1253","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/parameterization-wind-turbine-impacts-hydrodynamics-sediment-transport","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10236-016-0983-6#citeas","title":"Parameterization of wind turbine impacts on hydrodynamics and sediment transport","description":"Monopile foundations of offshore wind turbines modify the hydrodynamics and sediment transport at local and regional scales. The aim of this work is to assess these modifications and to parameterize them in a regional model. In the present study, this is achieved through a regional circulation model, coupled with a sediment transport module, using two approaches. One approach is to explicitly model the monopiles in the mesh as dry cells, and the other is to parameterize them by adding a drag force term to the momentum and turbulence equations. Idealised cases are run using hydrodynamical conditions and sediment grain sizes typical from the area located off Courseulles-sur-Mer (Normandy, France), where an offshore windfarm is under planning, to assess the capacity of the model to reproduce the effect of the monopile on the environment. Then, the model is applied to a real configuration on an area including the future offshore windfarm of Courseulles-sur-Mer. Four monopiles are represented in the model using both approaches, and modifications of the hydrodynamics and sediment transport are assessed over a tidal cycle. In relation to local hydrodynamic effects, it is observed that currents increase at the side of the monopile and decrease in front of and downstream of the monopile. In relation to sediment transport effect, the results show that resuspension and erosion occur around the monopile in locations where the current speed increases due to the monopile presence, and sediments deposit downstream where the bed shear stress is lower. During the tidal cycle, wakes downstream of the monopile reach the following monopile and modify the velocity magnitude and suspended sediment concentration patterns around the second monopile.","author":["Magar, V.","Pinon, G.","Gross, M.","Rivier, A.","Bennis, A."],"organization":["Normandie Universit\u00e9"],"originationDate":"2016-09-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["49.587525700000","-1.245278300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/rivieretal2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1254","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthic-biodiversity-old-platforms-young-wind-farms-rocky-reefs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsy092\/5057660","title":"Benthic biodiversity on old platforms, young wind farms, and rocky reefs","description":"The introduction of artificial hard substrates in an area dominated by a sandy seabed increases habitat available to epifouling organisms. To investigate this, samples were taken on old offshore oil and gas platforms, and data were compared with data of a young wind farm and a natural reef. Depth, sampling date, abundance of Mytilus edulis, Psammechinus miliaris, Metridium dianthus, and the presence of Tubulariidae and substrate (rock or steel) all correlated with species richness. Multivariate analysis showed a large overlap in communities on steel and rock and between the wind farm and platforms. The community changed over a gradient from deep rocks to shallow steel substrate, but no strong community differentiation was observed. Deep steel was more similar to natural rocks than shallow steel. When an artificial reef is intended to be colonized by communities similar to those on a natural reef, its structure should resemble a natural reef as much as possible.","author":["Degraer, S.","Lindeboom, H.","Coolen, J.","Norkko, J.","van der Weide, B.","Cuperus, J.","Blomberg, M.","Van Moorsel, G.","Faasse, M.","Bos, O."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","Ministry of Infrastructure and the Environment (Rijkswaterstaat)","ecoSub Robotics Ltd","eCOAST Marine Research","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2018-07-23","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.416513000000","4.040282000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Coolen-2018-Benthic-Biodiversity.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1255","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mussel-cultivation-co-use-offshore-wind-farms-potential-economic-feasibility","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/13657305.2010.526018","title":"MUSSEL CULTIVATION AS A CO-USE IN OFFSHORE WIND FARMS: POTENTIAL AND ECONOMIC FEASIBILITY","description":"More than 50% of the annual worldwide harvest of mussels is produced in Europe. The mussel cultivation in Germany is based on an extensive on-bottom culture and depends entirely on natural resources for food, spat and space. Due to stakeholder conflicts and a lack of spat availability, mussel farmers tend to move offshore where space is not limited and adequate settlement guaranteed. Newcomers \u2013 the offshore wind farmers \u2013 are covering large areas in the German Bight which in contrast give the opportunity to use these areas in a multifunctional way by accepting mussel cultivation within the wind farms. This study compiles the basic data for offshore mussel cultivation in close vicinity to a designated offshore wind farm in the open sea of the German Bight and employs different case-scenario calculations to illustrate the impact of changing parameter values on overall profitability or non-profitability of this activity. Primary focus is placed on the production of consumer mussels but seed mussel cultivation is also taken into consideration. We show that production of consumer mussels with longline technology is sufficiently profitable even under the assumption of substantial cost increases. This is especially true, if existing capacities could be used. The cultivation of seed mussels depends on the possibility of using existing equipment. A substantial increase of seed mussel prices to at least 0.6 4, given the main cost categories remaining constant, turns this alternative into substantial profitability. This study concludes with providing some recommendations on how favorable terms or actions could further improve profitability of offshore mussel cultivation. Altogether, our results are intended to shed some light on business management topics that future offshore mariculture operators such as traditional mussel farmers should follow in order to be efficient.","author":["Buck, B.","Michler-Cieluch, T.","Ebeling, M."],"organization":["University of Applied Sciences Bremerhaven","Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)"],"originationDate":"2010-12-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.453883500000","7.178955400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/bucketal2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1256","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/micrometeorological-impacts-offshore-wind-farms-seen-observations-simulations","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1748-9326\/aaea0b\/meta","title":"Micrometeorological impacts of offshore wind farms as seen in observations and simulations","description":"In Europe, offshore wind farms have a capacity of 16 GW, with 71% installed at the North Sea. These wind farms represent an additional source of turbulence and may influence the stratification of the marine boundary layer. We present aircraft measurements and simulations showing an impact on temperature and humidity at hub height in the order of 0.5 K and 0.5 g kg\u22121 even 60 km downwind of a wind farm cluster. We extend these simulations to explore a realistic future scenario, suggesting wakes in potential temperature and water vapor propagating more than 100 km downwind. Such impacts of wind farms are only observed in case of a strong stable stratification at rotor height, allowing wind farms to mix warmer air downward.","author":["Neumann, T.","Platis, A.","Siedersleben, S.","Bange, J.","Lampert, A.","B\u00e4rfuss, K.","Ca\u00f1adillas, B.","Emeis, S.","Lundquist, J."],"organization":["Karlsruhe Institute of Technology","University of Colorado Boulder","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","University of T\u00fcbingen","Technische Universit\u00e4t Braunschweig","UL International GmbH (DEWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-11-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Siedersleben-2018-Micrometeorological-Impacts.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1257","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-green-house-gas-emissions-onshore-offshore-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0959652618334310","title":"Life-cycle green-house gas emissions of onshore and offshore wind turbines","description":"Onshore and offshore wind turbines may have different environmental sustainability due to their owncharacteristics, and this information is important for future growth of wind power. The paper uses lifecycle assessment (LCA) to estimate the life-cycle greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of onshore andoffshore wind turbines with the nominal capacity of 2 MW, to advance our understanding of onshore andoffshore wind energy and to inform policy, planning, and investment decisions for future growth of windpower. Results show that the life-cycle GHG emission intensity is 0.082 kg CO2-equivalent (eq)\/Mega-joule (MJ) for onshore wind turbine and is 0.130 kg CO2-eq\/MJ for offshore wind turbine, respectively.Offshore wind turbine has larger life-cycle GHG emissions than onshore wind turbine, owing to thefloating platformfixed in sea. Onshore and offshore wind turbines have much smaller life-cycle GHGemission intensity than coal power plants. If the installed wind turbines in 2014 displace coal, the savedGHG emissions can roughly reach 5.08x107tCO2-eq, accounting for 0.09% of global GHG emissions in2012. The sensitive analysis shows that the lifetime and energy production of wind turbine have largeinfluences on the GHG emission intensity of both onshore and offshore wind turbines, implying that it isan effective way to prolong the lifetime of wind turbine and increase the energy production of windturbine to reduce the GHG emission intensity of wind turbine. The sensitivity analysis further shows thatthe distance from wind turbine factory to wind farm site has more significant influence on the life-cycle GHG emission intensities of both onshore and offshore wind turbines than that from wind farm site tothe recycling and landfill locations, suggesting that the wind farm site and the wind turbine factoryshould be as close as possible.","author":["Wang, S.","Jinxiang, L."],"organization":["Nanjing Tech University","Chinese Academy of Social Sciences","Newcastle University"],"originationDate":"2019-02-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind","Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1258","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-impacts-artificial-reef-development-sea-turtle-conservation-florida","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.library.noaa.gov\/view\/noaa\/13140","title":"Potential impacts of artificial reef development on sea turtle conservation in Florida","description":"Artificial reefs have been constructed and deployed worldwide to enhance marine habitat, primarily to increase socio-economic benefits stemming from associated fishing and diving activities, but also for habitat restoration and mitigation purposes. As a result, the majority of studies focused on artificial reefs to date have centered on measuring performance, with metrics such as species\u2019 richness and abundance compared to natural reefs, or economic benefits to local users. While there may be demonstrable benefits to artificial reef development, there may also be unforeseen consequences. This study investigates the impacts Florida artificial reefs may have on sea turtle populations, such as increased predation stemming from altered predator complexes, mortality due to entrapment, and entanglement issues. Based on some of the associated effects artificial reef development may have on sea turtles, management recommendations to minimize potential impacts are offered for consideration.","author":["Barnette, M."],"organization":["National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["28.206614000000","-81.809107900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Reptiles","Sea Turtles","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-30 07:42:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NOAA-2017-SeaTurtle.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1259","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/detection-visual-signatures-marine-mammals-fish-within-marine-renewable-energy-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2077-1312\/7\/2\/22","title":"Detection of Visual Signatures of Marine Mammals and Fish within Marine Renewable Energy Farms using Multibeam Imaging Sonar","description":"Techniques for marine monitoring have been greatly evolved over the past decades, making the acquisition of environmental data safer, more reliable and more efficient. On the other hand, the marine renewable energy sector has introduced dissimilar ways of exploring the oceans. Marine energy is mostly harvested in murky and high energetic places where conventional data acquisition techniques are impractical. This new frontier on marine operations brings the need for finding new techniques for environmental data acquisition, processing and analysis. Modern sonar systems, operating at high frequencies, can acquire detailed images of the underwater environment. Variables such as occurrence, size, class and behavior of a variety of aquatic species of fish, birds, and mammals that coexist within marine energy sites can be monitored using imaging sonar systems. Although sonar images can provide high levels of detail, in most of the cases they are still difficult to decipher. In order to facilitate the classification of targets using sonar images, this study introduces a framework of extracting visual features of marine animals that would serve as unique signatures. The acoustic visibility measure (AVM) is here introduced as technique of identification and classification of targets by comparing the observed size with a standard value. This information can be used to instruct algorithms and protocols in order to automate the identification and classification of underwater targets using imaging sonar systems. Using image processing algorithms embedded in Proviwer4 and FIJI software, this study found that acoustic images can be effectively used to classify cod, harbour and grey seals, and orcas through their size, shape and swimming behavior. The sonar images showed that cod occurred as bright, 0.9 m long, ellipsoidal targets shoaling in groups. Harbour seals occurred as bright torpedo-like fast moving targets, whereas grey seals occurred as bulky-ellipsoidal targets with serpentine movements. Orca or larger marine mammals occurred with relatively low visibility on the acoustic images compared to their body size, which measured between 4 m and 7 m. This framework provide a new window of performing qualitative and quantitative observations of underwater targets, and with further improvements, this method can be useful for environmental studies within marine renewable energy farms and for other purposes.","author":["Sundberg, J.","Francisco, F."],"organization":["Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-10 11:59:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fransisco-and-Sundberg-2019.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1260","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/best-practice-framework-reconcile-full-scale-marine-renewable-energy-deployments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.icoe-conference.com\/library\/conference\/icoe-2018\/","title":"A Best Practice Framework to Reconcile Full-scale Marine Renewable Energy Deployments with Marine Natura 2000 Sites","description":"As the marine renewable energy industry is now rapidly scaling up from single devices to arrays of multiple turbines, this paper brings science and law together to investigate how the mechanisms of adaptive management can be best applied under the appropriate assessment procedure of the Habitats Directive to provide regulators with the best scientific knowledge about the ecological risks of full-scale deployments on marine Natura 2000 species.","author":["Le Li\u00e8vre, C."],"organization":["University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2018-06-14","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/A_Best_Practice_Framework_to_Reconcile_Full-scale_Marine_Renewable_Energy_Deployments_with_Marine_Natura_2000_Sites.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1261","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-hydrokinetic-turbine-sound-behavior-four-species-fish-within-experimental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0165783617300218","title":"Effects of hydrokinetic turbine sound on the behavior of four species of fish within an experimental mesocosm","description":"The development of hydrokinetic energy technologies (e.g., tidal turbines) has raised concern over the potential impacts of underwater sound produced by hydrokinetic turbines on fish species likely to encounter these turbines. To assess the potential for behavioral impacts, we exposed four species of fish to varying intensities of recorded hydrokinetic turbine sound in a semi-natural environment. Although we tested freshwater species (redhorse suckers [Moxostoma spp], freshwater drum [Aplondinotus grunniens], largemouth bass [Micropterus salmoides], and rainbow trout [Oncorhynchus mykiss]), these species are also representative of the hearing physiology and sensitivity of estuarine species that would be affected at tidal energy sites. We evaluated changes in fish position relative to different intensities of turbine sound as well as trends in location over time with linear mixed-effects and generalized additive mixed models. We also evaluated changes in the proportion of near-source detections relative to sound intensity and exposure time with generalized linear mixed models and generalized additive models. Models indicated that redhorse suckers may respond to sustained turbine sound by increasing distance from the sound source. Freshwater drum models suggested a mixed response to turbine sound, and largemouth bass and rainbow trout models did not indicate any likely responses to turbine sound. Findings highlight the importance for future research to utilize accurate localization systems, different species, validated sound transmission distances, and to consider different types of behavioral responses to different turbine designs and to the cumulative sound of arrays of multiple turbines.","author":["Bevelhimer, M.","Scherelis, C.","Schramm, M."],"organization":["Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL)"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.928788400000","-84.312513100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1262","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-regulatory-framework-environmental-impact-assessment-development-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096456911730443X","title":"The influence of regulatory framework on environmental impact assessment in the development of offshore wind farms in Spain: Issues, challenges and solutions","description":"It is clear that\u00a0renewable energies, and particularly offshore\u00a0wind power, constitute an opportunity to meet international and national commitments and targets for the reduction of\u00a0greenhouse gas emissions\u00a0as established by the United Nations Framework Convention on\u00a0Climate Change, the\u00a0Kyoto Protocol, and the Paris Agreement, and they therefore constitute an element of the approach necessary to address\u00a0global warming\u00a0in general. However, such sources of energy are not without drawbacks, given that their\u00a0installation, operation and\u00a0decommissioning may potentially cause damage to and threaten the marine environment. It is therefore important to achieve a balance between the environmental benefits of using of the oceans and the need for protection of the environment.\n\nScientific uncertainty and lack of initial data on the potential effects of these facilities, have led to long delays in processing\u00a0Environmental Impact Assessments, and public opposition to these projects has contributed to stagnation in terms of its development in Spain. Furthermore, incomplete\u00a0environmental impact\u00a0studies and inappropriate\u00a0environmental impact statements\u00a0(such as those that fail to assess the\u00a0synergistic effects\u00a0of nearby facilities and all components thereof) can lead to delays in processing applications, the inadmissibility of wind projects, and ineffective protection of the marine environment.\n\nThe current regulations on Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) -along with case-law decisions-, are an attempt to solve several of these varied problems and clashes of interests between promoters, citizens, and administrators, while protecting biodiversity and fighting climate change. However, some regulatory gaps and legal uncertainties still require regulatory improvement in this respect.\n\nThe\u00a0main objective\u00a0of this research is therefore to assess the real and potential future legal and factual problems in the field of\u00a0environmental assessmentassociated with offshore\u00a0wind farms\u00a0in Spain, in an analysis of the responses and solutions provided by the Directive 2014\/52\/EU and the 21\/2013 Environmental Assessment Law. Regulatory improvements are proposed, which could help to boost the development of marine renewable energy facilities, promoting greater public consensus, while at the same time protecting biodiversity and the marine environment.\n\nThe main proposed improvements consist of establishing a joint or coordinated processing of EIA with other assessments and procedures (such as the evaluations derived from birds and habitats directives); elaborating\u00a0guidance documents\u00a0which help promoters in analyzing synergistic and cumulative effects in their Environmental Impact Studies, hereafter EIS; enhancing the role of the scoping phase and, specially, considering the inclusion of this stage in the regulation of the simplified EIA procedure; improving public information and participation in the EIA process through the establishment of the obligation of disseminate relevant information through electronic means, the expansion of the legal concept of \u201cinterested persons\u201d and the inclusion of public participation phases both in early stages of the procedure and after substantial modifications of the project or the study of EIA.","author":["Salvador, S.","Gimeno, L.","Larruga, F."],"organization":["Universidad de Vigo","Universidade da Coruna"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.636203400000","-3.642670100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1263","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-mammal-behavioral-response-tidal-turbine-sound","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1458457","title":"Marine Mammal Behavioral Response to Tidal Turbine Sound","description":"The sound emitted by tidal turbines overlaps with the generalized hearing ranges for marine mammals and may, consequently, affect marine mammal behavior. Because of the strong environmental protections for marine mammals, these effects are of interest to resource agencies and project developers. The primary goal of this project is to improve the understanding of how sound emitted by tidal turbines may affect marine mammal behavior, with the intent that such understanding may allow this environmental risk to be \u201cretired\u201d for initial demonstrations and arrays. A secondary project goal is to evaluate the efficacy of marine mammal observations from a shore-based vantage point as a method to detect change as a consequence of marine energy stressors. Three, two-week trials were conducted across spring, summer and autumn of 2017 during which vantage-point observations of marine mammals were made from land. We refer to these two-week periods as \u2018trials\u2019 as they represent different periods of field data collection. These observations consisted of scan samples every 10 minutes with a set of binoculars and a DSLR camera. When pinnipeds were sighted, still images were taken. When harbor porpoise were sighted, focal follows using video were initiated. These data were later analyzed to estimate the location of animals sighted using photogrammetric techniques. For approximately half of each trial period, a boat was moored in the study area from which an underwater projector was used to play back tidal turbine sounds at a broadband source level of 158 dB re \u00b5Pa @ 1 m. The other half of each trial period had no playbacks and was used as a control period. During the control and playback periods, ancillary data were collected in the study area near the sea floor (ambient noise, tidal velocity, and porpoise clicks) while weather and vessel tracks were recorded near the vantage-point station. Harbor seals did not show a significant response to the simulated turbine noise, nor did harbor porpoise change their closest point of approach or change the direction\/deviation of the paths during periods when the playback was occurring. While porpoise sightings and porpoise acoustic detections were significantly reduced during playback periods in the first two trials, the number of detections during the playback periods increased during the third trial. Similarly, the calculated distance from porpoises to the playback location suggests that harbor porpoises avoided an area around the playback location of approximately 300 m during Trial 1, which decreased to approximately 100 m in Trial 2, and disappeared in Trial 3. This could be an indication of habituation or increased tolerance, either to the playback sound or the vessel presence. Our finding of no significant effect of turbine noise on harbor seals contrast with the findings in a previous study by Hastie et al. (2017) conducted in United Kingdom waters. However, due to substantive differences in source levels and propagation loss, seals in our study would need to have been within 10 m of the playback location to experience similar received levels to those in the Hastie et al. study. Consequently, the two studies may actually be in agreement. Our findings of significant effect of turbine noise on harbor porpoise are in line with previous studies suggesting the harbor porpoise are sensitive to noise. However, we note that, due to cost and logistical constraints, the playback vessel was only mooring during the playback periods. Consequently, we cannot definitively ascribe the changes in porpoise behavior to the simulated turbine noise, playback vessel presence, or a combination of both factors. This methodological limitation and other lessons learned are discussed to benefit future studies that explore the effects of acoustic stressors on marine mammals.","author":["Joslin, J.","Polagye, B.","Wood, J.","Joy, R.","Robertson, F."],"organization":["University of Washington","Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2018-06-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.176320000000","-122.768226000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Plagye-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1264","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wave-energy-generators-nephrops-norvegicus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.diva-portal.org\/smash\/record.jsf?pid=diva2%3A1250482\u0026dswid=-1784","title":"Effects of Wave Energy Generators on Nephrops norvegicus","description":"Wave energy research is primarily focused on the technical developments of energy conversion but the parallel evaluation of environmental effects related to wave energy is also essential and reflects sustainable development of renewable energy. At the west coast of Sweden, 120 km north of Gothenburg, the Wave Energy Park \u201cSoten\u00e4s Project\u201d is located. This area has been the location of environmental impact studies from wave energy generators on the macro crustacean species Nephrops norvegicus (Linnaeus, 1758), the Norway lobster. The Norway lobster is an ecologically as well as economically important species in Sweden and across Europe. The aim of this preliminary study was to detect possible positive or negative effects on numbers of individuals by the presence of the wave energy generators and the created \u201cno take\u201d zone. For that purpose, ROV aided seabed recordings of the characteristic Norway lobster burrow entrances were conducted inside the Wave Energy Park and respective control areas in 2016 and 2017. Preliminary results do not show a clear distinct result between the different transects and years. Long-term observations and complementary studies are necessary to draw conclusions and outweigh extreme and rare events of annual one-time samplings.","author":["Bender, A.","Sunberg, J."],"organization":["Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2018-09-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.387444000000","11.128556000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 09:57:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/AWTEC2018-283.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1265","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/investigation-monitoring-fish-using-underwater-fish-eye-camera-test-site-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=2704509","title":"Investigation of Monitoring Fish Using Underwater Fish-Eye Camera at the Test Site of Marine Renewable Energy","description":"Assessment of any significant effects on the local marine environment when considering the installation of a marine renewable energy device is of the utmost importance. In particular, the effect of such device on fish is concerned by local fishermen. To confirm variation of fish before and after installing the device of marine renewable energy, we investigated effective monitoring system using an underwater fish-eye camera. In this paper, visibility of the fish-eye camera was tested off Kamaishi city, Iwate prefecture, Japan, which is a test site of marine renewable energy in Japan. Device of wave power generation is planning to install at this site in the future. We confirmed the visibility of the fish-eye camera using a fish-shaped target by changing the distance between the target and camera. The water depth and photon were simultaneously measured. From the result, the horizontal visibility was discussed, and then we made a plan to observe around wave power generator using this fish-eye camera.","author":["Chen, Q.","Kitazawa, D.","Mizukami, Y.","Yoshida, T.","Mochizuki, A."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2018-06-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.275818000000","141.885608000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1266","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/strategic-analysis-tidal-current-energy-conversion-systems-european-union","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261917317609#s0100","title":"A strategic analysis of tidal current energy conversion systems in the European Union","description":"The exploitation of ocean energy is currently recognized as an abundant, geographically diverse and renewable energy source that could benefit European citizens by increasing energy independence, enhancing economic growth, creating jobs, allowing decarbonization or serving as a complement to other renewable sources within the global energy mix. Of the various types of ocean energy (wave, tidal, offshore wind, salinity gradient and thermal gradient), this paper is focused on technologies with which to harness the energy from ocean currents. This energy will have considerable possibilities in the future thanks to its high predictability and its enormous potential for the production of electricity. Most of the review papers concerning tidal energy systems are focused on engineering topics. However, there continues to be limited information as regards other aspects, such as those of an economical, social, political, legislative and environmental nature which, together with their interrelationships, need to be dealt with as a whole in order to detect the key drivers that could affect the success or failure of making tidal energy technologies marketable. The objective of this review paper is to address this gap by providing a detailed strategic analysis based on the most up-to-date literature, reports and guidelines. The paper discusses the different disciplines of which the PESTEL analysis (political, economical, social, technological, environmental and legal) is composed and provides different strategies\/recommendations through which to mitigate many of the risks identified in order to facilitate the successful development of these technologies and bring them onto the market. Finally, some recent advances in tidal technologies developed by our research group (GIT-ERM) are also highlighted in the technological part of this paper.\n\nHighlights:\nA strategic analysis for offshore tidal energy conversion systems is provided.\nIt covers political, economic, social, technological, environmental and legal aspects.\nDifferent strategies\/recommendations to mitigate all risks are suggested.\nThe presented analysis can be used to support future R\u0026D and deployment.","author":["Segura, E.","Morales, R.","Somolinos, J."],"organization":["University of Castilla\u2013La Mancha","Universidad Polit\u00e9cnica de Madrid"],"originationDate":"2018-02-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1267","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biofree-international-study-biofouling-impacts-marine-renewable-energy-industry","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/8559322","title":"BioFREE: An International Study of Biofouling Impacts on the Marine Renewable Energy Industry","description":"The success of the marine renewable energy (MRE) industry is dependent upon maximising energy capture and minimising down-time. Device performance is negatively impacted by the growth of fouling organisms, leading to reduced efficiency and reliability; anti-fouling strategies are costly and time consuming. Biofouling also reduces accuracy of data buoys and sensors used to assess the hydrodynamic resource and device performance. While biofouling has been a recognised problem for centuries, deployment of MRE devices creates several unique issues. Additional concerns exist over the role that MRE infrastructure may play as `stepping-stones\u0027 promoting the spread of non-native and invasive species. A paucity of published studies exists concerning biofouling in this sector. With a general trend towards stricter environmental controls, it is essential that the MRE industry demonstrate commitments that minimise disturbance and promote positive impacts. Given small margins for MRE, there are potentially substantive benefits from tackling biofouling in terms of increased investor confidence. The BioFREE project (a collaboration between Heriot-Watt University and the European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) in the UK) is addressing these issues by detailed characterisation of the biofouling communities from multiple habitats used by the MRE sector, and monitoring benthic impacts following deployment and decommissioning. BioFREE is developing a workable Standard Monitoring System designed to facilitate data collection using practical and effective methods. Frames are populated with settlement panels, data loggers, and components comprised of materials of greatest concern to MRE developers. Components of this system can be treated with anti-fouling coatings. Frames are being deployed in a variety of habitats at additional test centres and research institutes located in Japan, Chile, France, and the USA; organisms are recorded quarterly to identify the major foulants, determine the rate of settlement and growth, and study successional changes. These studies indicate strong species-specific seasonal settlement patterns. Fouling communities vary between deployment habitats depending on factors such as hydrodynamic conditions, water depth, and substrate type. These findings will allow recommendations for test centres and developers to minimise the impacts of fouling, chiefly through selective scheduling of deployments and maintenance, in different habitats, to times when the settlement of fouling organisms will be minimal or their removal will be least costly. In addition, BioFREE has created training materials to help inform the MRE industry of ways to better capture biofouling information when conducting operations at sea. Practical suggestions are informed by recent maintenance and decommissioning operations conducted on MRE infrastructure. These studies have identified structural areas and materials of particular concern from the impacts of biofouling. The lead role of EMEC, as a representative of MRE developers in the sector, is allowing promotion of project outputs within the industry and between test centres. These findings are being disseminated through conference presentations, technical reports, scientific publications, public engagement, and webinars planned for the near future.\n\nMore information about the OCEANS\u201918 MTS\/IEEE Kobe \/ Techno-Ocean 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Want, A.","Porter, J."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2018-12-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-24 06:42:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1268","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/anthropogenic-disturbance-facilitates-non-native-species-offshore-oil-platforms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/1365-2664.13104","title":"Anthropogenic disturbance facilitates a non-native species on offshore oil platforms","description":"Anthropogenic practices that facilitate species introductions must be identified and modified to improve management and control the spread of non\u2010native taxa in many environments. Maintenance practices that remove dense epifaunal invertebrates attached to offshore structures create a disturbance that may facilitate the establishment of non\u2010native species.  We evaluated the effect of disturbance on the abundance (percent cover) of a non\u2010native bryozoan, Watersipora subatra, on an offshore oil platform in the Santa Barbara Channel, USA by removing the existing epifaunal community in experimental plots and comparing Watersipora cover in these plots to that in undisturbed control plots over a 15\u2010month period. We explored the importance of larval supply and the epifaunal community in driving observed patterns, using measurements of Watersipora larval availability and colony recruitment and growth in the disturbed and control plots. We also examined the effect of disturbance on Watersipora establishment at the larger, platform\u2010scale over c. 18 months with comparative surveys of cleaned and uncleaned portions of another oil platform.  Both the experimental disturbance and the larger platform cleaning facilitated Watersipora establishment, with cover increasing from c. 5% to 20\u201360% at shallower (\u226412 m) depths within 15 to 18 months following disturbance.  Initial Watersipora recruitment to the disturbed plots occurred during a period of elevated larval availability, as indicated by recruitment onto settlement plates. However, 1 year after the experimental disturbance, sessile invertebrates occupied all available settlement space, and there was little recruitment of Watersipora into disturbed plots despite the availability of larvae.  Synthesis and applications. Maintenance operations for offshore structures can include the manual removal of subtidal epibenthic invertebrates attached to the structure. Our study at offshore oil platforms found that this anthropogenic disturbance enhanced the establishment of the non\u2010native invertebrate Watersipora subatra. The timing of disturbance relative to Watersipora\u0027s reproductive season was an important driver of this pattern. Scheduling maintenance practices to occur soon after the reproductive period of Watersipora could allow adequate time for native species to recruit and occupy the available bare space, thereby reducing the potential for establishment of this non\u2010native species.","author":["Dugan, J.","Schroeder, D.","Miller, R.","Page, H.","Viola, S.","Zaleski, S.","Doheny, B.","Schroeter, S."],"organization":["University of California Santa Barbara","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.316652000000","-119.616663000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Viola-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1269","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysis-wind-turbine-noise-emissions-impact-environment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032115015233","title":"Analysis of the wind turbine noise emissions and impact on the environment","description":"Research of regularity patterns of statistic\u00a0parameter variation\u00a0of\u00a0wind turbine(further referred to as WT) generated noise is presented in the article. The\u00a0Fast Fourier Transform algorithm\u00a0for the analysis of the measured data was used to establish the\u00a0noise spectrum, which was a broadband range. In the noise spectrum, the greatest changes were observed in the frequency range of 200\u20135000\u00a0Hz when WT was operating and when it was not. The level of the wind turbine noise increases as wind velocity increases. But the level of this spectrum decreases under all frequencies when the distance from wind turbines increases.\n\nThe literature data analysis reveals that the intensity level of WT generated\u00a0acoustic noise\u00a0depends on aerodynamic processes and mechanical\u00a0noise intensity\u00a0of its element flow. While estimating WT generated noise level, it is necessary to consider the background noise level evoked by wind, which significantly depends on wind\u00a0flow velocity. When there are high wind speeds, WT generated noise is concealed by the background noise level evoked by wind. It was determined that WT generated noise level, when wind speed is\u00a0v\u224812\u00a0m\/s, and when there distance is greater than 100\u00a0m to the WT tower, it becomes equal to the background noise level. In such cases, the influence of WT noise on the environment could be underrated. Experimental and theoretical investigations of the WT generated\u00a0acoustic\u00a0noise were carried out. A methodology was developed, and a mathematical noise\u00a0propagation model, which enables to forecast WT generated acoustic pollution level in residential places or other selected areas, was presented.","author":["Katinas, V.","Mar\u010diukaitis, M.","Tama\u0161auskien\u0117, M."],"organization":["Lithuanian Energy Institute"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1270","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-non-volant-terrestrial-vertebrates-response-wind-farms-study-small-mammals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10661-016-5095-8","title":"An assessment of non-volant terrestrial vertebrates response to wind farms\u2014a study of small mammals","description":"The majority of studies on the effects of wind energy development on wildlife have been focused on birds and bats, whereas knowledge of the response of terrestrial, non-flying vertebrates is very scarce. In this paper, the impact of three functioning wind farms on terrestrial small mammal communities (rodents and shrews) and the population parameters of the most abundant species were studied. The study was carried out in southeastern Poland within the foothills of the Outer Western Carpathians. Small mammals were captured at 12 sites around wind turbines and at 12 control sites. In total, from 1200 trap-days, 885 individuals of 14 studied mammal species were captured. There was no difference in the characteristics of communities of small mammals near wind turbines and within control sites; i.e. these types of sites were inhabited by a similar number of species of similar abundance, similar species composition, species diversity (H\u2032 index) and species evenness (J\u2032) (Pielou\u2019s index). For the two species with the highest proportion in the communities (Apodemus agrarius and Microtus arvalis), the parameters of their populations (mean body mass, sex ratio, the proportion of adult individuals and the proportion of reproductive female) were analysed. In both species, none of the analysed parameters differed significantly between sites in the vicinity of turbines and control sites. For future studies on the impact of wind turbines on small terrestrial mammals in different geographical areas and different species communities, we recommend the method of paired \u2018turbine-control sites\u2019 as appropriate for animal species with pronounced fluctuations in population numbers.","author":["\u0141opucki, R.","Mr\u00f3z, I."],"organization":["John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin"],"originationDate":"2016-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["49.484158000000","21.873185000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lopucki-Mroz-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1271","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/opposition-overblown-community-response-wind-energy-siting-western-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618304870","title":"Opposition \u0022overblown\u0022? Community response to wind energy siting in the Western United States","description":"Much of the literature on local\u00a0opposition\u00a0to wind development is based on small-N\u00a0case studies\u00a0of controversial cases. This focus has led to an emphasis on the so-called \u201csocial gap\u201d between positive general attitudes toward\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0development and local\u00a0resistance\u00a0to actual proposals. Instead, we conduct a fuzzy set\/Qualitative\u00a0Comparative Analysis\u00a0of 53 proposals for\u00a0wind energy\u00a0development in the Western United States to better understand both the amount of local opposition\u00a0and\u00a0the factors and processes that shape it. We find that while some level of local opposition to wind proposals is not rare, it is typically restricted to more benign activities that require few resources and take place in standard institutional settings. Drawing on insights from the literatures on social acceptance of wind and social movement studies, we show that proximity to protected areas, political opportunity, and opponents\u2019 framing of the risks posed by wind development are\u00a0important factors\u00a0in driving community resistance. These findings suggest that resistance to wind energy proposals is more likely to be shaped by existing processes for\u00a0public participation\u00a0than to shape them, and that calls to streamline\u00a0regulatory processes\u00a0to expedite development due to local resistance may be premature.","author":["Taylor, C.","Giordono, L.","Boudet, H.","Karmazina, A.","Steel, B."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","Idaho State University"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.781500700000","-121.655044400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1272","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparison-recent-oil-gas-wind-energy-other-anthropogenic-landscape-alteration-factors","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00267-018-1000-2","title":"Comparison of Recent Oil and Gas, Wind Energy, and Other Anthropogenic Landscape Alteration Factors in Texas Through 2014","description":"Recent research assessed how hydrocarbon and wind energy expansion has altered the North American landscape. Less understood, however, is how this energy development compares to other anthropogenic land use changes. Texas leads U.S. hydrocarbon production and wind power generation and has a rapidly expanding population. Thus, for ~47% of Texas (~324,000\u2009km2), we mapped the 2014 footprint of energy activities (~665,000 oil and gas wells, ~5700 wind turbines, ~237,000\u2009km oil and gas pipelines, and ~2000\u2009km electrical transmission lines). We compared the footprint of energy development to non-energy-related activities (agriculture, roads, urbanization) and found direct landscape alteration from all factors affects ~23% of the study area (~76,000\u2009km2), led by agriculture (~16%; ~52,882\u2009km2). Oil and gas activities altered","author":["Wolaver, B.","Pierre, J.","Labay, B.","LaDuc, T.","Duran, C.","Ryberg, W.","Hibbitts, T.","Andrews, J."],"organization":["University of Texas","The Nature Conservancy","Texas A\u0026M University","Siglo Group"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.192983700000","-100.614795100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1273","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/carbon-or-cash-evaluating-effectiveness-environmental-economic-messages-attitudes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629618306339","title":"Carbon or Cash: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Environmental and Economic Messages on Attitudes about Wind Energy in the United States","description":"Public support or opposition to the expansion of wind energy plays a key role in energy policy and the development of the industry. For more than 30 years, scholars have attempted to understand the nature of public opinion about wind energy. Unfortunately, the largely observational and correlational nature of the evidence limits the abilities of scholars to isolate the causal relationships that shape attitudes about wind energy. Recent summaries of the literature illustrate the need for experimental designs to improve our understanding of the public\u2019s view on this growing technology. Using an original survey experiment with a national sample, we test the effectiveness of messages about the economic and environmental implications of the expansion of wind energy. Our results indicate that 1) the public is sensitive to messaging about both the environmental and economic effects of wind energy; 2) the messages have both a persuasive (changing the content of attitudes) and priming (changing the weight applied to existing attitudes) effect on the public; and 3) the environmental messages have a greater effect on public opinions of wind energy than economic messages. Those interested in promoting positive attitudes about alternative energy need to be aware of both the persuasive and priming influences in messages about wind energy.","author":["Peterson, D.","Carter, K.","Wald, D.","Gustafson, W.","Hartz, S.","Donahue, J.","Eilers, J.","Hamilton, A.","Hutchings, K.","Macchiavelli, F.","Mehner, A.","Cajigas, Z.","Pfeiffer, O.","Van Middendorp, A."],"organization":["Iowa State University","University of North Texas","Interamerican University of Puerto Rico","University of Massachusetts"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1274","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/population-level-effects-wind-farms-desert-lizard","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21565","title":"Population-Level Effects of Wind Farms on a Desert Lizard","description":"Renewable forms of energy production can have major societal benefits including reduced carbon pollution and decreased dependence on fossil fuels but are not without associated costs. For example, habitat degradation at renewable energy production sites may affect the persistence of wildlife populations. We assessed the effects of wind farms in the San Gorgonio Wind Resource Area near Palm Springs, California, 2013\u20132015, on local populations of the side\u2010blotched lizard (Uta stansburiana). The side\u2010blotched lizard is a common and ubiquitous desert reptile that is a major consumer of invertebrates and, in turn, represents a key prey base for many avian, reptilian, and mammalian predators. We used spatially explicit capture\u2010recapture methods to compare a comprehensive set of population\u2010level vital signs (i.e., abundance, population growth rate, survival, recruitment, body condition, age structure, activity area size, movement rates) among populations at 4 wind farms and at 5 reference areas. Although our models indicate that wind facilities have a weak negative effect on side\u2010blotched lizard survival, our overall results suggest that wind farms do not substantially influence the demography or behavior of these small lizards. Population response to general anthropogenic disturbance (quantified as an index of road type and density) was more pronounced, with lower population growth rates, adult\u2010skewed age structure, and reduced body condition at highly disturbed wind farm and reference sites. We therefore conclude that wind\u2010power facilities can support healthy populations of side\u2010blotched lizards, indicating that wind energy development is compatible with a native Mojave Desert species. However, our results show that anthropogenic disturbance, as measured by the type and density of roadways, has a negative effect on lizard populations, and should be carefully planned whether associated with energy development or not. Our study demonstrates a methodological approach that can be applied to other species, including those with lower tolerances to disturbance, to measure their response to renewable energy development.\u00a0","author":["Keehn, J.","Feldman, C.","Shoemaker, K."],"organization":["University of Nevada"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.771553000000","-116.704372900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Reptiles","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1275","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-maritime-spatial-planning-development-marine-renewable-energies-portugal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421518308693","title":"The influence of maritime spatial planning on the development of marine renewable energies in Portugal and Spain: Legal challenges and opportunities","description":"The objective of this study is to analyse, from a legal point of view, the influence of the transposition of Marine Spatial Planning Directive into both Spanish and Portuguese domestic laws on the development of marine renewable energies in both countries. This article concludes that the Portuguese legal system is more favourable for the development of marine renewable energies than the Spanish legal regime, since the former establishes a more flexible planning system, sets criteria for the prioritisation of marine uses, incorporates trade-off mechanisms, introduces an electronic single-window system and regulates a pilot zone. These measures can help streamline licensing processes, avoid and resolve conflicts with other sea users, and adapt planning instruments to the rapid development of new marine renewable technologies. However, both legal regimes lack specific legal mechanisms aimed at offering effective protection of the marine environment against negative effects arising from the installation of such devices. Similarly, there is a lack of coordination between maritime spatial planning instruments and land planning instruments, and between the Central Government and the autonomous regions. This may hinder the installation of marine renewable energies. This study has implications in relation to the EU integrated marine policy aimed at achieving a balance between blue growth and the conservation of the marine environment, as well as an inter-administrative coordination improvement in decision-making.","author":["Salvador, S.","Gimeno, L.","Larruga, F."],"organization":["Universidad de Vigo","Universidade da Coruna"],"originationDate":"2019-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1276","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/systematic-review-transferable-solution-options-environmental-impacts-tidal-lagoons","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X1830294X","title":"A systematic review of transferable solution options for the environmental impacts of tidal lagoons","description":"Tidal lagoons are presented as an environmentally friendly alternative to tidal barrages. This does not mean that their environmental impacts can be overlooked. A UK government review recommended a pilot scheme lagoon go ahead, with careful environmental monitoring. Despite recent government rejection of a lagoon scheme, it is still more important than ever to consider environmental solution options for any future lagoon developments. There are no operating lagoons in the world and so their environmental impacts are not fully understood. However, there is a vast quantity of literature available from other industries addressing similar impacts in the coastal, ocean and river environments. This systematic review follows the PRISMA and CEE guidance. Using this methodology the available literature covering relevant solution options from other industries that could be applied to future lagoon developments was quantified. This presents an investigation into solution options only, giving a quantitative analysis of what resources are available, how this compares to industry understanding, where the expertise lies globally, what impacts are being addressed and how applicable the solutions are for lagoon application. This paper analyses the extent and relevance of this available research on solutions as a resource for the nascent lagoon industry. Over half of the solutions found in this review require only small shifts in development for them to be realistic solution options for the lagoon industry in the future. This review opens the door on a vast and valuable resource and justifies the need for further investigation into solutions for the lagoon industry.","author":["Smith, H.","Moore, F.","van der Weijde, A.","Lazakis, I.","Elliott, K."],"organization":["Black \u0026 Veatch","University of Exeter","University of Edinburgh","University of Strathclyde"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Elliot-et-al-2019.pdf.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1277","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/testing-effectiveness-acoustic-deterrent-grey-whales-along-oregon-coast","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.library.oregonstate.edu\/concern\/technical_reports\/ht24wj826","title":"Testing the Effectiveness of an Acoustic Deterrent for Grey Whales Along the Oregon Coast","description":"This study was conducted to determine whether a low-powered sound source could be effective at deterring gray whales from areas that may prove harmful to them. With increased interest in the development of marine renewal energy along the Oregon coast the concern that such development may pose a collision or entanglement risk for gray whales. A successful acoustic deterrent could act as a mitigation tool to prevent harm to whales from such risks. In this study, an acoustic device was moored on the seafloor in the pathway of migrating gray whales off Yaquina Head on the central Oregon coast. Shore-based observers tracked whales with a theodolite (surveyor\u2019s tool) to accurately locate whales as they passed the headland. Individual locations of different whales\/whale groups as well as tracklines of the same whale\/whale groups were obtained and compared between times with the acoustic device was transmitting and when it was off. Observations were conducted on 51 d between January 1 and April 15, 2012. A total of 143 individual whale locations were collected for a total of 243 whales, as well as 57 tracklines for a total of 142 whales. Inclement weather and equipment problems resulted in very small sample sizes, especially during experimental periods, when the device was transmitting. Because of this, the results of this study were inconclusive. We feel that another season of field testing is warranted to successfully test the effectiveness of the deterrent, but recommend increasing the zone of influence to 3 km to ensure the collection of adequate sample sizes. Steps have been taken to acquire the necessary federal research permit modification to authorize the increased zone of influence and to modify the acoustic device for the increased power. With these changes we are confident we will be able to determine whether the deterrent is effective at deflecting gray whales. A successful deterrent device may serve as a valuable mitigation tool to protect gray whales, and other baleen whales, in the event that marine energy development poses a collision or entanglement risk.","author":["Mate, B.","Lagerquist, B.","Windsor, M."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2012-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.675878000000","-124.095336000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Collision","Entanglement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lagerquist_et_al_2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1278","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-hydrokinetic-turbine-technology-environment-device-biota-interactions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/5664055","title":"Marine Hydrokinetic Turbine Technology and the Environment: Device-Biota Interactions","description":"Because marine hydrokinetic (MHK) turbine technologies are still in their infancy, their impacts on the environment remain largely unknown. Although few empirical data exist for MHK technologies, more data are available for other man-made structures. This paper discusses fish, mammal, bird, and benthic organism interactions with MHK devices and other man-made structures that may be analogous to these MHK technologies. In experiments conducted on the Mississippi River Lock and Dam No. 2, the survival of several species of small and large fish that passed through an MHK turbine was 99%. No data on mammal, sea turtle, or bird interactions with MHK turbines were available, but other types of anthropogenic mortality and traumatic injuries to these groups of animals have been well documented. Collisions with ships and fishing gear have greatly impacted most groups of marine mammals. Large whales that inhabit shallow coastal waters and diving birds that use sight to pursue prey underwater are at risk for collision. However, many devices have a positive impact on fish or benthic organism populations because they act as fish aggregation devices or artificial reefs.","author":["Thresher, R.","Li, Y.","Crevison, S."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)"],"originationDate":"2010-12-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.760920000000","-92.875562300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1279","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/obtaining-baseline-measurements-ocean-ambient-sound-mobile-test-berth-site-wave-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/abstract\/document\/6107223","title":"Obtaining Baseline Measurements of Ocean Ambient Sound at a Mobile Test Berth Site for Wave Energy Conversion Off the Central Oregon Coast","description":"A year-long experiment to monitor underwater ambient noise measurements in shallow, (~50m) open water along an energetic coastline in the Pacific Northwest (USA) was conducted. Bottom mounted passive acoustic recorders were deployed in March 2010 by Oregon State University (OSU) and NOAA\/Pacific Marine Environmental Laboratory\u0027s Marine Acoustics Research Group in an area designated by the Northwest National Marine Renewable Energy Center (NNMREC) as a mobile ocean test berth (MOTB) site for wave energy conversion (WEC) platforms off the central coast of Oregon. Acoustic recording packages recorded continuous (1 Hz-2 kHz) sampling at two offshore locations near and within the MOTB. Maximum and minimum total sound pressure levels recorded during the experiment reached 136 dB re 1 \u03bcPa and 95 dB re 1 \u03bcPa respectively. Meanwhile, the time averaged sound pressure levels for the year long deployment were 113 dB re 1\u03bcPa. These data provide the initial baseline recordings required for a meaningful assessment of the shallow water ambient noise levels in the Oregon nearshore coastal environment prior to the installation and operation of wave energy conversion devices.","author":["Haxel, J.","Matsumoto, H.","Dziak, R."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)"],"originationDate":"2011-12-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.851435500000","-124.346450300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-07-28 10:54:28","signatureProject":["PacWave"],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1280","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-wildlife-proceedings-conference-wind-energy-wildlife-impacts-october-2012","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007%2F978-94-017-9490-9#toc","title":"Wind and Wildlife: Proceedings from the Conference on Wind Energy and Wildlife Impacts, October 2012, Melbourne, Australia","description":"This book gathers papers presented and discussions held at the Conference on Wind Energy and Wildlife Impacts in Melbourne, Australia on 9th October 2012. The purpose of the conference was to bring together researchers, industry, consultants, regulators and Non-Government Organizations to share the results of studies into wind farm and wildlife investigations in Australia and New Zealand. The aim was to further networking and communication between these groups. The conference discussed key issues and areas for future investigation, with the intention of developing consistencies in research and management. Like the Conference, the book showcases current research and management in the field of wind farms and wildlife in Australia and New Zealand; establishes consistencies in research and management; and highlights areas in need of further examination. The papers in these Proceedings are presented in two session topics. The first covers \u201cInvestigations and assessment of new wind farms\u201d and the second, \u201cMonitoring, mitigation and offsets.\u201d  The Proceedings then summarize the panel discussions held at the end of the conference. The themes include improving pre- and post-construction survey design; identifying key knowledge gaps and research priorities; uncertainties and errors in data sets and analysis; creating opportunities to share knowledge; and assessing cumulative impacts across multiple sites.  Contents  Section 1: Investigations and Assessments of New Wind Farms    Predicting the Weather-Dependent Collision Risk for Birds at Wind Farms (Henrik Skov, Stefan Hein\u00e4nen) - Pages 3-21  Fauna Collisions with Wind Turbines: Effects and Impacts, Individuals and Populations. What Are We Trying to Assess? (Ian Smales) - Pages 23-40  Wind Farms and Biodiversity: Improving Environmental Risk Assessments (I. K. G. Boothroyd, L. P. Barea) - Pages 41-58  The Use of Aerial Surveys for the Detection of the Brolga Grus rubicunda Through South-West Victoria: Key Considerations for the Wind Industry (David Wilson, Aaron Organ) - Pages 59-68  Planning for Net Biodiversity Gains: A Case Study of Hau\u0101uru m\u0101 raki Wind Farm, New Zealand (John L. Craig, Gerry Kessels, Peter Langlands, Stephen Daysh) - Pages 69-91   Section 2: Monitoring, Mitigation and Offsets    Results and Analysis of Eagle Studies from the Bluff Point and Studland Bay Wind Farms 2002\u20132012 (Cindy Hull, Chris Sims, Elizabeth Stark, Stuart Muir) - Pages 95-111  Observations from the Use of Dogs to Undertake Carcass Searches at Wind Facilities in Australia (Emma Bennett) - Pages 113-123  Key Learnings from Ten Years of Monitoring and Management Interventions at the Bluff Point and Studland Bay Wind Farms: Results of a Review (Chris Sims, Cindy Hull, Elizabeth Stark, Robert Barbour) - Pages 125-144","author":["Hull, C.","Stark, E.","Smales, I.","Bennett, E.","Lau, J.","Venosta, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-23.244181400000","131.393920600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1281","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/draft-generic-environmental-impact-statement-procurement-offshore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/documents.dps.ny.gov\/public\/Common\/ViewDoc.aspx?DocRefId=%7B1C423DD7-3C69-4999-BBF3-5DD36E71B86D%7D","title":"Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement for Procurement of Offshore Wind","description":"This Draft Generic Environmental Impact Statement (draft GEIS), prepared pur-suant to the New York State Environmental Quality Review Act (SEQRA), ana-lyzes the potential environmental impacts associated with the State\u2019s procurement of this 2.4 GW of offshore wind energy by 2030, and builds upon and incorpo-rates by reference relevant material from NYSERDA\u2019s Offshore Wind Master Plan. The offshore wind procurement contemplated by the Offshore Options pa-per is a separate action and procurement program from the Renewable Energy Standard (RES) or the Zero Emission Credit (ZEC) programs previously approved by the Commission. The environmental review conducted for the Commission pursuant to the \u201cReforming the Energy Vision\u201d (REV) proceeding and the RES and ZEC programs, did consider the impacts of offshore generation and whererelevant the information contained in those documents is also incorporated herein. However, the previous environmental reviews did not contemplate a standalone procurement of offshore wind at the scale now being proposed, necessitating the development and consideration of this draft GEIS.  The Proposed Action under consideration is the procurement by 2030 of 2,400 MW of offshore wind energy capacity through a competitive mechanism with the ability to meet the delivery requirements of the RES. The procurement contem-plated by the Proposed Action is meant to encourage the development of new off-shore wind energy projects in the Atlantic Ocean. However, those projects, if de-veloped, could be undertaken in a broad range of scenarios with countless varia-bles, including the geographic area of the marine environment (offshore between Maine and North Carolina), project timing (2018 to 2030), project scale, and pro-ject technology. Therefore, it is not possible at this stage to meaningfully assess the specific potential environmental impacts of future offshore development pur-suant to SEQRA.","author":["Ecology and Environment Inc","New York State Department of Public Service"],"organization":["Ecology and Environment Inc"],"originationDate":"2018-02-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.351992800000","-75.871856200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NY-Public-Service-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1282","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-technologies-migratory-species-guidelines-sustainable-deployment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.cms.int\/sites\/default\/files\/document\/ETF1_Inf.1.pdf","title":"Renewable Energy Technologies and Migratory Species: Guidelines for sustainable deployment","description":"In order to plan future renewable energy technologies (RET) in a sustainable way, impacts on migrating species should be minimised. As RET proceed rapidly worldwide, impacts might be serious but on the other hand knowledge on minimising these impacts increases as well. CMS, AEWA and BirdLife International realised this and started a cooperative initiative to present an overview of current knowledge (Van der Winden et al. 2015) to be used in minimising impacts on migratory species.\n\nThis guidelines report provides expert guidance on minimising the impacts of RET on migratory species. This includes steps in the planning, design and policy process as well as mitigating and avoiding possible impacts by renewable energy technologies. The types of renewable energy and site specific situations make it impossible to provide straightforward guidelines ensuring sustainable planning in an easy way. This means that procedures, policy as well as mitigation techniques should be integrated in the planning process to make it most effectively. This document combines existing guidelines and examples of good practices related to six types of renewable energy technology, including bioenergy, geothermal energy, hydropower, ocean energy, solar energy and wind energy.","author":["van der Winden, J.","Lane, B.","van Vliet, F.","Patterson, A."],"organization":["Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals (CMS)","African-Eurasian Migratory Waterbirds Agreement (AEWA)","BirdLife International","African-Eurasian Migratory Waterbirds Agreement (AEWA)","BirdLife International","Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals (CMS)"],"originationDate":"2015-02-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/van-der-Winden-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1283","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measuring-interaction-between-marine-features-special-protection-areas-offshore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/assets.publishing.service.gov.uk\/government\/uploads\/system\/uploads\/attachment_data\/file\/657524\/BTO_Research_Report_649_-_Interactions_between_SPA_features_and_offshore_windfarms_final_report.pdf","title":"Measuring the Interaction Between Marine Features of Special Protection Areas with Offshore Wind Farm Development Sites Through Telemetry: Final Report","description":"The UK government has a commitment to obtain 20% of the UK\u2019s energy from renewable sources by 2020, of which wind energy is likely to form a major part (DECC 2009). Consequently many wind farms are currently under construction and more developments are proposed (e.g. Round 3 zones, Scottish Territorial Waters sites and extensions to Round 1 and Round 2 sites). There is, however, much concern as to the effects that offshore wind developments may have on seabird populations.Potential areas for development of offshore wind farms include locations that may hold large numbers of seabirds, seaduck and other waterbirds. Both consented and proposed development sites within the North Sea may also overlap the foraging areas of seabirds that are features of protected sites. Offshore wind farms may potentially have an impact on these bird populations through four main effects: (1) displacement due to the disturbance associated with developments; (2) the barrier effect posed by developments to migrating birds and birds commuting between breeding sites and feeding areas; (3) collision mortality; (4) indirect effects due to changes in habitat or prey availability. When assessing the potential effects of proposed wind farms on local bird populations, it is important to establish not only the use that birds make of the proposed wind farm area, but also in the assessment of collision risk, whether they are likely to come into contact with the turbines. The latter is largely determined by the height at which the birds fly, and any avoidance behaviour that they may show towards the turbines.Before construction is consented, an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is required to identify the possible risks posed by a development. As part of this process, where a \u2018likely significant effect\u2019 upon a Natura 2000 site (Special Protection Area, SPA, or Special Area of Conservation, SAC) is identified, an Appropriate Assessment (AA) needs to be conducted, to understand and predict the effects on the feature species found at those sites. SPAs are designated under the European Bird\u2019s Directive (79\/409\/EEC), which protects sites within the European Union of international importance for breeding, wintering, feeding, or migrating vulnerable bird species. Wind farms have the potential to affect breeding seabirds or wintering waterbirds that are features of SPAs if they forage in areas where wind farms are proposed, or pass through these areas on migration. Thus, it is important to understand the connectivity between features of SPAs with development regions.This study uses the latest tracking technology to investigate the movements of two seabird species that are features of SPAs \u2013 the Lesser Black-backed Gull Larus fuscus and the Great Skua Stercorarius skua.This final report is also associated with a first breeding season report, second year report and third year report.","author":["Masden, E.","Thaxter, C.","Wade, H.","Clark, N.","Burton, N.","Bouten, W.","Johnston, A.","Ross-Smith, V.","Conway, G."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","North Highland College","University of Amsterdam","UK Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)"],"originationDate":"2014-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2025-08-18 06:51:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Thaxter-et-al-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1284","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/migratory-bats-are-attracted-red-light-not-warm-white-light-implications-protection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ece3.4400","title":"Migratory bats are attracted by red light but not by warm-white light: Implications for the protection of nocturnal migrants","description":"The replacement of conventional lighting with energy\u2010saving light emitting diodes (LED) is a worldwide trend, yet its consequences for animals and ecosystems are poorly understood. Strictly nocturnal animals such as bats are particularly sensitive to artificial light at night (ALAN). Past studies have shown that bats, in general, respond to ALAN according to the emitted light color and that migratory bats, in particular, exhibit phototaxis in response to green light. As red and white light is frequently used in outdoor lighting, we asked how migratory bats respond to these wavelength spectra. At a major migration corridor, we recorded the presence of migrating bats based on ultrasonic recorders during 10\u2010min light\u2010on\/light\u2010off intervals to red or warm\u2010white LED, interspersed with dark controls. When the red LED was switched on, we observed an increase in flight activity for\u00a0Pipistrellus pygmaeus\u00a0and a trend for a higher activity for\u00a0Pipistrellus nathusii. As the higher flight activity of bats was not associated with increased feeding, we rule out the possibility that bats foraged at the red LED light. Instead, bats may have flown toward the red LED light source. When exposed to warm\u2010white LED, general flight activity at the light source did not increase, yet we observed an increased foraging activity directly at the light source compared to the dark control. Our findings highlight a response of migratory bats toward LED light that was dependent on light color. The most parsimonious explanation for the response to red LED is phototaxis and for the response to warm\u2010white LED foraging. Our findings call for caution in the application of red aviation lighting, particularly at wind turbines, as this light color might attract bats, leading eventually to an increased collision risk of migratory bats at wind turbines.","author":["Lindecke, O.","Voigt, C.","Petersons, G.","Rehnig, K."],"organization":["Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","University of Vienna","University of Latvia"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.159623000000","21.025822000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Voigt-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1285","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/local-impacts-wind-farms-property-values-spatial-difference-differences-analysis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/papers.ssrn.com\/sol3\/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2500217","title":"Local Impacts of Wind Farms on Property Values: A Spatial Difference-in-Differences Analysis","description":"Today\u2019s investment decisions in large-scale onshore wind projects in Germany are no longer determined only by the investment\u2019s economic benefit, but also by concerns associated to social acceptance. Despite a mostly positive attitude towards the expansion of wind power, local public concerns often stem from the belief that the proximity to large-scale wind farms may lead to a decrease in property prices. In particular, the change in landscape caused by the construction of a wind farm may have an adverse impact on the view from some properties, and thus may negatively affect their price. To investigate the potential devaluation of properties in Germany due to wind farms, we use a quasi-experimental technique and apply a spatial difference-in-differences approach to various wind farm sites in the federal state of North Rhine-Westphalia. We adopt a quantitative visual impact assessment approach to account for the adverse environmental effects caused by the wind turbines. To properly account for spatial dependence and unobserved variables biases, we apply augmented spatial econometric models. The estimates indicate that the asking price for properties whose view was strongly affected by the construction of wind turbines decreased by about 10-17%. In contrast, properties with a minor or marginal view on the wind turbines experienced no devaluation.","author":["Sunak, Y.","Madlener, R."],"organization":["RWTH Aachen University (Rheinisch-Westf\u00e4lische Technische Hochschule Aachen)","RWTH Aachen University (Rheinisch-Westf\u00e4lische Technische Hochschule Aachen)"],"originationDate":"2014-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.468147100000","7.197585400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Sunak_and_Madlener_2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1286","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbine-noise-sleep-pilot-studies-influence-noise-characteristics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1660-4601\/15\/11\/2573","title":"Wind Turbine Noise and Sleep: Pilot Studies on the Influence of Noise Characteristics","description":"The number of onshore wind turbines in Europe has greatly increased over recent years, a trend which can be expected to continue. However, the effects of wind turbine noise on long-term health outcomes for residents living near wind farms is largely unknown, although sleep disturbance may be a cause for particular concern. Presented here are two pilot studies with the aim of examining the acoustical properties of wind turbine noise that might be of special relevance regarding effects on sleep. In both pilots, six participants spent five consecutive nights in a sound environment laboratory. During three of the nights, participants were exposed to wind turbine noise with variations in sound pressure level, amplitude modulation strength and frequency, spectral content, turbine rotational frequency and beating behaviour. The impact of noise on sleep was measured using polysomnography and questionnaires. During nights with wind turbine noise there was more frequent awakening, less deep sleep, less continuous N2 sleep and increased subjective disturbance compared to control nights. The findings indicated that amplitude modulation strength, spectral frequency and the presence of strong beats might be of particular importance for adverse sleep effects. The findings will be used in the development of experimental exposures for use in future, larger studies.\u00a0","author":["Smith, M.","Pedersen, E.","Waye, K.","Forss\u00e9n, J.","Morsing, J.","Ogren, M.","Thorsson, P."],"organization":["University of Gothenburg","University of Pennsylvania","Chalmers University of Technology","Lund University"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Morsing-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1287","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-offshore-wind-farms-birds-cuisinarts-sky-or-just-tilting-windmills","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.vliz.be\/en\/catalogue?module=ref\u0026refid=100585","title":"Effects of offshore wind farms on birds: \u0022Cuisinarts of the sky\u0022 or just tilting at windmills?","description":"A significant concern in the development of offshore wind farms is their potentially negative effect on birds. The general public\u2019s perception of these effects does not always agree with the scientific evidence, however. To bridge this information gap, this study seeks to review and analyze the existing literature on birdwind interactions in order to assess what we know and to recommend mitigation solutions. The findings are then used to examine the impacts of a proposed offshore wind farm south of Cape Cod, Massachusetts. Much of our knowledge of avian effects at offshore wind farms comes from one site in Denmark, which demonstrated a disturbance effect on sea ducks caused by turbines, resulting in minor indirect habitat loss and a barrier to movement. Collisions with turbines remain the largest potential threat to birds from any wind farm, however, and evidence from extensive work at onshore sites has demonstrated that collisions will occur no matter where a farm is located. The magnitude and severity of all impacts, not just collisions, could best be minimized by the careful siting of proposed wind farms, although there are several other effective ways to mitigate impacts through design and planning. The proposed wind farm south of Cape Cod puts multiple groups of birds\u2014passerine and seabird, migrant and local\u2014at risk of collisions and other impacts. One species of primary concern is the federally-endangered roseate tern (Sterna dougalli), which has a large breeding and pre-migratory staging population near the proposed wind farm. In addition to requiring thorough pre- and post-construction avian monitoring regimes, U.S. policymakers should address our lack of offshore experience by limiting the size and scale of proposed projects until impacts on birds are better understood.","author":["Tingley, M."],"organization":["Harvard University"],"originationDate":"2003-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.786625000000","-70.290459000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Passerines","Seabirds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tingley-2003.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1288","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hong-kong-offshore-wind-farm-southeastern-waters-environmental-impact-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.epd.gov.hk\/eia\/english\/alpha\/aspd_479.html","title":"Hong Kong Offshore Wind Farm in Southeastern Waters - Environmental Impact Assessment","description":"\u201cThe Project\u201d refers to the development of the proposed Hong Kong Offshore Wind Farm (HKOWF) in Southeastern Waters of the HKSAR. The Project will be capable of producing a maximum output of approximately 200MW of electricity.  The annual production would be approximately 1% of HK\u2019s total electricity needs. The turbines will be arranged in a grid, and each will be affixed to the seabed by a foundation consisting of a jacket structure with suction caissons.  The turbines will be linked by collection cables to an offshore transformer platform from which electricity shall be transmitted to shore via two 132kV cables.  A research mast will also be installed to collect data on the offshore environment.  At its closest point, the Project would be approximately 9 km and 5km east of the Clearwater Bay peninsula and the main Ninepin Islands respectively. The Project will be constructed over approximately 2 years, and will be serviced using local port facilities over its anticipated life-span 20-25 years.  Every year of operation it is estimated that the Project would offset approximately:    343,000 - 383,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide.  54 - 60 tonnes of Sulphur Dioxide.  394 - 440 tonnes of Nitrogen Oxides.  14 - 16 tonnes of particulate material.   Inspection and maintenance works will be conducted on an ongoing basis, and the wind farm will be decommissioned at the end of its working life. The energy required to build a wind farm is typically recovered in the first year of operation, thus bringing a net positive effect on greenhouse gas emissions. Tendering for Project construction is yet to take place, whilst the rapid pace of developments in offshore wind technology mean that Project details may be subject to minor modification.  However, this EIA presents a reasonable worst case scenario for the assessment of potential environmental outcomes and impacts.","author":["Hong Kong Offshore Wind Limited"],"organization":["BMT"],"originationDate":"2009-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["22.387101200000","114.079823500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hong-Kong-Offshore-Wind-Farm-EIA.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1289","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/standard-investigation-impacts-offshore-wind-turbines-marine-environment-stuk4","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bsh.de\/DE\/PUBLIKATIONEN\/_Anlagen\/Downloads\/Offshore\/Standards\/Standard-Investigation-impacts-offshore-wind-turbines-marine-environment_en.html","title":"Standard Investigation of the Impacts of Offshore Wind Turbines on the Marine Environment (StUK4)","description":"Within the framework of the approval procedure for offshore wind farms in the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), potential adverse impacts of the planned facilities on the marine environment have to be assessed. Besides, in line with the German regulation \u00a7 3 Abs. 1 Nr. 1 UVPG i.V.m. Anlage 1, Nr. 1.6, an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is now mandatory. In the Standard for Environmental Impact Assessments (StUK) at hand, information is provided to applicants on the scope of investigations required by the planning approval\/approval authority, with all relevant details and explanations. Likewise, the planning approval\/approval holders and operators of wind farms are provided with detailed information about the requirements for operation-phase monitoring, which is currently considered indispensable.  The StUK constitutes a framework of the current thematic and technical minimum requirements for marine environmental surveys and monitoring of constituent criteria as per \u00a7 5 Section. 6 No. 2 Seeanlagenverordnung (Marine Facilities Ordinance) from 23 January 1997 (BGBI \u2013 German Federal Law Gazette. I p. 57), last amended by Article 11 of the law from 21 January 2013 (BGBI. I p. 95), (hereinafter called SeeAnlV) as well as for monitoring during the construction and operation phase.  The third update of the StUK is based on experience that has been gained with the versions of December 2001, February 2003 and on data from the surveys conducted in the context of the research project \u201c\u00d6kologische Begleitforschung am Offshore-Testfeldvorhaben alpha ventus zur Evaluierung des Standarduntersuchungskonzeptes des BSH \u2013 StUKplus\u201d (FKZ: 0327689A), funded by the German Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety. Apart from a general increase in knowledge, the findings of environmental monitoring carried out under the German Federal and State monitoring programme in the North Sea and Baltic Sea, the Helsinki Convention on the Protection of the Marine Environment of the Baltic Sea Area and the OSPAR Convention for the Protection of the North Sea and North-East Atlantic have been taken into account.  The following international documents based on mutual exchange of information have been published:    OSPAR Commission (2008). Guidance on Environmental Considerations for Offshore Wind Farm Development (Replaces agreements 2003-16, 2005-2, 2006-5, 2007-9). Reference number: 2008\/-3.  OSPAR Commission (2004). Problems and Benefits Associated with the Development of Offshore Wind-Farms. ISBN 1-904426-48-4.  OSPAR Commission (2008). Assessment of the environmental impact of offshore windfarms. Reference number: 2008\/-385.  OSPAR Commission (2006). Review of the Current State of Knowledge on the Environmental Impacts of the Location Operation and Removal\/Disposal of Offshore Wind-Farms. Reference number: 2006\/-278.   It should be noted that this standard, as well as its earlier versions, has been developed in consultation with numerous experts. The fact that various concepts discussed in the course of the decision making process have not been considered in the StUK does not imply any criticism of such concepts. The planning approval\/approval authority, after having consulted the experts and having studied the different concepts, in each case selected one of several possible solutions and also allowed alternatives considered suitable for the procedure.","author":["German Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH)"],"organization":["German Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH)","German Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH)"],"originationDate":"2013-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.505684900000","8.868697700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BSH_2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1290","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-migrating-birds-avoid-offshore-wind-turbines-method-investigate-analyze-reactions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/289381526_Do_migrating_birds_avoid_offshore_wind_turbines_A_method_to_investigate_and_analyze_reactions_of_diurnally_migrating_birds_to_offshore_wind_farms","title":"Do migrating birds avoid offshore wind turbines? A method to investigate and analyze reactions of diurnally migrating birds to offshore wind farms","description":"When addressing potential threats of offshore wind farms on migrating birds, avoidance behavior in response to wind farms is among those commonly mentioned, meaning that wind farms can act as barriers for migrants. Substantial - but otherwise sparsely - proof for this exits from Denmark and The Netherlands. However, monitoring potential threats in the German Bight failed in providing evidence of an avoidance response of migrating birds to offshore wind farms. Minor adaptations of the current method of investigation and analysis provided here, however, have led to substantiated results. In addition, these adaptations can easily be incorporated into current standard protocols of environmental impact assessment studies. Demonstrating this, we here present an example of avoidance behavior of gannets Sula bassana in particular to a wind farm and of birds in general.","author":["Hill, R.","Hill, K.","Aumuller, R.","Boos, K.","Freienstein, S."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1291","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimation-seabird-numbers-german-north-sea-throughout-annual-cycle-their","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/259332896_Estimation_of_seabird_numbers_in_the_German_North_Sea_throughout_the_annual_cycle_and_their_biogeographic_importance","title":"Estimation of seabird numbers in the German North Sea throughout the annual cycle and their biogeographic importance","description":"Increasing plans for economic activities at sea have recently led to intensive studies of seabird distribution and seabird numbers. However, there are still some temporal gaps concerning seabird numbers, and important up-to-date information is still missing. Thus, the aim of this study is to provide most recent seabird numbers for all seasons and all species that are regularly resting and\/or foraging in German waters of the North Sea, split into the politically relevant areas EEZ as well as the 12 nautical miles zones of Niedersachsen and Schleswig-Holstein, respectively.  For our analyses at sea, we investigated seabird numbers from the outer Wadden Sea islands to the outer boarders of German waters, using standardised ship-based (years: 1993\u20132003) and aerial (2002\u20132006) transect methods. We calculated and applied species-specific correction factors for birds presumably overlooked in the outer transect area. Using grid maps of seabird distribution, geographic units of similar bird densities were designed for each bird species and each season, covering the entire study area. Then, numbers within each unit were calculated by firstly dividing the total number of birds by the total area surveyed and by secondly multiplying this value by the size of the unit. Finally, the total was derived as the sum across all of these units. In addition to the numbers at sea, we included (1) data from regular counts on Helgoland, (2) data from counts along the German Wadden Sea coast and (3) from aerial censuses for sea ducks as well as (4) colony census data.  When only considering numbers at sea, between 183,000 (autumn) and 265,000 (winter) birds occur in the German part of the North Sea. The most numerous species are Common Scoter Melanitta nigra (130,000 ind.; winter), Lesser Black-backed Gull Larus fuscus (45,000 ind.; summer) and Northern Fulmar Fulmarus glacialis (40,000 ind.; summer). Including coastal areas, total numbers range from 463,000 ind. (autumn) to 693,000 ind. (summer). Common Eiders Somateria mollissima are most numerous (180,000 ind.; autumn), followed by Black-headed Gulls Larus ridibundus (170,000 ind.; autumn) and Common Scoters (135,000 ind.; winter). In relation to their biogegographic populations, Common Eiders (23.7%; autumn), Lesser Blackbacked Gulls (19.9%; summer) and Sandwich Terns Sterna sandvicensis (12.5%; summer) are most important. From a conservation point of view, summer is the most important time of the year. Overall, our results show that 13 species occur in internationally important concentrations in the German North Sea area.","author":["Garthe, S.","Dierschke, V.","Schwemmer, P.","Sonntag, N."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2007-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.065706000000","8.112284000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1292","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/2nd-iteration-effect-turbine-capacity-collision-numbers-three-large-gull-species-based","sourceURL":"https:\/\/edepot.wur.nl\/344019","title":"2nd Iteration: Effect of turbine capacity on collision numbers for three large gull species, based on revised density data, when assessing cumulative effects of offshore wind farms on birds in the southern North Sea","description":"This report is an additional note to IMARES report number C166\/14.  This report is an additional note to the report of Leopold et al. (2014) that evaluates the cumulative effects of offshore wind farm development in accordance with the roadmap of the Social and Economic Agreement (in Dutch: SER-akkoord) on birds and bats in the southern North Sea. In that report, unacceptably high mortalities were predicted for three large gull species: lesser black-backed gull (Larus fuscus), great black-backed gull (L. marinus) and European herring gull (L. argentatus).  To more accurately assess the impact of the projected offshore wind farms as compared to Leopold et al. (2014, 2015), two options were jointly analysed in this second iteration: 1) the density numbers for the aforementioned three gull species were revised; for the Dutch Continental Shelf (DCS) the calculations were based on aerial survey data from the MWTL monitoring programme only. The idea was, that since gulls tend to a aggregate near (active) fishing vessels, density numbers based on ship-based monitoring data (e.g. ESAS data) may (severely) skew the outcome of calculations (Leopold et al. 2015). Therefore, density numbers based only on MWTL data are regarded as more realistic densities. 2) the options of mitigating collision rates by installing larger wind turbines were analysed with Band (2012) model settings for 4 MW and 5 MW turbines. Per turbine type, two variants (different rotor diameter and - as a result of the chosen method - higher hub height) were considered. Note: in the main study and the first iteration, a 3 MW turbine was assessed.","author":["Fijn, R.","van der Wal, J.","Gyimesi, A.","Scholl, M."],"organization":["IMARES - Wageningen UR","IMARES - Wageningen UR"],"originationDate":"2015-05-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.563193000000","4.005260000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/wan_der_Wal_et_al_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1293","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/iteration-cycle-dealing-peaks-counts-birds-following-active-fishing-vessels-when","sourceURL":"https:\/\/edepot.wur.nl\/334085","title":"Iteration cycle: Dealing with peaks in counts of birds following active fishing vessels when assessing cumulative effects of offshore wind farms and other human activities in the Southern North Sea","description":"This report is an additional note to IMARES report number C166\/14.  This report is an addition to the report of Leopold et al. (2014) that evaluates the effects of offshore wind farm development in the southern North Sea, on birds and birds. In that report, unacceptably high mortalities were predicted for several large gull species. However, it was felt that this might be an effect of local, short-lived concentrations of these birds, e.g. around fishing vessels. If this were the case, such concentrations of gulls in the vicinity of future offshore wind farms would unduly increase the estimated number of victims at these locations. Here, we explore a method to decrease the impact of high peaks in gull densities recorded in the past, by redistributing the gulls attracted to a temporal feeding hotspot over the supposed area from which they were attacted. This results in a marked (ca 37-41%) reduction of estimated numbers of victims among the bird species supposedly most impacted, the Lesser Blackbacked Gull. The reduction of predicted numbers of victims among Great Black-backed Gulls was lower (14-21%), while predicted numbers of victims among Herring Gulls increased by 32-42%). The latter is probably an artifact of the coastal habits of Herring Gulls and a redistribution extending too far into offshore waters.","author":["Poot, M.","Collier, M.","Leopold, M.","Jongbloed, R.","van der Wal, J.","Gyimesi, A.","Scholl, M."],"organization":["IMARES - Wageningen UR","IMARES - Wageningen UR"],"originationDate":"2015-03-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.563193000000","4.005260000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Leopold_et_al_2015_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1294","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/first-approach-deal-cumulative-effects-birds-bats-offshore-wind-farms-other-human","sourceURL":"https:\/\/edepot.wur.nl\/329714","title":"A first approach to deal with cumulative effects on birds and bats of offshore wind farms and other human activities in the Southern North Sea","description":"Renewable energy is an increasing demand, and governments of North Sea countries are looking at developing offshore wind farms to help meet sustainability demands. The first at-sea wind farms have become operational in several countries, or are under construction, but many more are on the drawing board. Altogether, around 100 offshore wind farms are scheduled to be operational by 2023 in the southern North Sea (51-56\u00b0N) alone. There may be two sides to this development in environmental terms: on the one hand this will help reduce CO2 emissions, on the other hand protected North Sea biota may be negatively impacted. This report considers the cumulative impact of all projected wind farms in the southern North Sea (by 2023) on birds and bats.  Click here for a note on the original report: Iteration cycle: Dealing with peaks in counts of birds following active fishing vessels when assessing cumulative effects of offshore wind farms and other human activities in the Southern North Sea  Click here for another note: 2nd Iteration: Effect of turbine capacity on collision numbers for three large gull species, based on revised density data, when assessing cumulative effects of offshore wind farms on birds in the southern North Sea","author":["Poot, M.","Collier, M.","Fijn, R.","Lensink, R.","Krijgsveld, K.","Leopold, M.","Jongbloed, R.","van der Wal, J.","Boonman, M.","Davaasuren, N.","Gyimesi, A.","Poerink, B.","Lagerveld, S.","Scholl, M.","Kleyheeg-Hartman, J.","Jong, J."],"organization":["IMARES - Wageningen UR","Bureau Waardenburg bv","The Fieldwork Company","IMARES - Wageningen UR"],"originationDate":"2015-01-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.879408000000","5.127484000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Leopold_et_al_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1295","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seabirds-what-seabirds-exploratory-study-origin-seabirds-visiting-se-north-sea-their","sourceURL":"https:\/\/edepot.wur.nl\/416194","title":"Seabirds? What seabirds? An exploratory study into the origin of seabirds visiting the SE North Sea and their survival bottlenecks","description":"This report summarises existing data on seabird tracking devices: classic steel rings, which mostly only get read at deployment and once the bird is found dead; colour rings, which can be read and reported more often, but which are rarely read at sea; and telemetric tracking devices such as GPS loggers, which enable following birds in great detail, also at sea. Seabirds, being long-lived, numerous and easily accessible (in breeding colonies) have long been popular for ringing studies. For most species relevant to offshore wind farm development, ringing data exist that can be used to learn more about yearly and age-related survival. However, it will be difficult, with only two data points per ring (date and place of deployment and of the bird\u2019s death) to relate these to offshore wind farms, which do not cause many birds to die in sharply defined incidents (such as major oil spills do). Colour ringing schemes, such as already used in large gulls for many years, and in Sandwich Tern for a shorter, but growing number of years, yield more possibilities to learn more about the survival (or mortality) of within-species groups of birds. GPS loggers provide the best data of seabirds\u2019 usage of the open sea, including offshore wind farm areas. Many birds have already been equipped with such loggers, but mostly at relatively large distances from offshore wind farms. Specific tagging programmes related to offshore wind farms are rare, the best data probably are now collected on Helgoland.\n\nSeveral possible next steps forward are identified. Detailed analyses of existing colour ringing data would be a first logical step. Colour ringing and GPS-tracking of birds in colonies closest to existing and planned offshore wind farms is advisable, as this will increase the probability that the most relevant birds (those that actually make use of offshore wind farm areas) are being tagged, rather than random birds, of which many will go elsewhere. A final and, for the Netherlands new, approach would be to catch birds directly at sea for tagging, in or near wind farm areas. This would greatly increase the usefulness of tagging data and our understanding of seabird movement around and through our offshore wind farms.","author":["Leopold, M."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","WOZEP"],"originationDate":"2017-05-23","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.167440900000","0.726096600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Leopold-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1296","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seabirds-samplers-marine-environment-case-study-northern-gannets","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ocean-sci.net\/13\/337\/2017\/","title":"Seabirds as samplers of the marine environment - a case study of northern gannets","description":"Understanding distribution patterns, activities, and foraging behaviours of seabirds requires interdisciplinary approaches. In this paper, we provide examples of the data and analytical procedures from a new study in the German Bight (North Sea) tracking northern gannets (Morus bassanus) at their breeding colony on the island of Heligoland. Individual adult northern gannets were equipped with different types of data loggers for several weeks, measuring geographic positions and other parameters mostly at 3\u20135 min intervals. Birds flew in all directions from the island to search for food, but most flights targeted areas to the (N)NW (north\u2013northwest) of Heligoland. Foraging trips were remarkably variable in duration and distance; most trips lasted 1\u201315 h and extended from 3 to 80 km from the breeding colony on Heligoland. Dives of gannets were generally shallow, with more than half of the dives only reaching depths of 1\u20133 m. The maximum dive depth was 11.4 m. Gannets showed a clear diurnal rhythm in their diving activity, with dives being almost completely restricted to the daylight period. Most flight activity at sea occurred at an altitude between the sea surface and 40 m. Gannets mostly stayed away from the wind farms and passed around them much more frequently than flying through them. Detailed information on individual animals may provide important insights into processes that are not detectable at a community level.","author":["Garthe, S.","Peschko, V.","Corman, A.","Kubetzki, U."],"organization":["Kiel University","Universit\u00e4t of Hamburg"],"originationDate":"2017-04-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.180327000000","7.888944000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Garthe-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1297","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/identifying-ecologically-important-marine-areas-seabirds-using-behavioural-information","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320711004873#bb0095","title":"Identifying ecologically important marine areas for seabirds using behavioural information in combination with distribution patterns","description":"The identification of marine areas of importance for seabirds is a challenge, because it is often unclear how birds are using the different areas in which they occur. Species differ in habitat choice, foraging behaviour and feeding range, but also in tendencies to roost at sea or to utilise resting places closer to or even on land. Because the designation of marine protected areas (MPAs) for seabirds should bear relevance to the ecological importance of these regions, simple presence\/absence information is not sufficiently accurate and could even be misleading. Large amounts of data have been collected to assess distribution patterns of seabirds around the world. Two sources of data are highlighted here: ship-based surveys and sensor data from instruments attached to individual birds. Recently developed protocols to systematically record seabird behaviour at sea during ship-based surveys and novel tracking technology that facilitate spatio-temporal quantification of space use and identification of behaviour will be evaluated in the context of MPA designations. We present some limitations of traditional techniques and exciting possibilities of new protocols and the latest generations of electronic devices attached to seabirds. These advanced approaches in data collection and spatial analysis will reveal important ecological information that will enhance our understanding of offshore seabird distribution and activity which can guide the designation of marine protected areas.","author":["Garthe, S.","Bouten, W.","Camphuysen, K.","Shamoun-Baranes, J."],"organization":["Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research (NIOZ)","University of Amsterdam","Kiel University"],"originationDate":"2012-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1298","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tracking-seabirds-identify-ecologically-important-high-risk-marine-areas-western-north","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320711004642","title":"Tracking seabirds to identify ecologically important and high risk marine areas in the western North Atlantic","description":"Protection of the marine environment lags far behind that of terrestrial domains. To help ameliorate this circumstance, top predators are being tracked to identify important ocean habitats, biodiversity hotspots and high risk areas and to assess effects of anthropogenic developments, pollution and environmental perturbations. We used GPS, Global Location Sensors (GLSs) and satellite platform terminal transmitters (PTTs) to track foraging and migrating thick-billed and common murres and northern gannets along with vessel surveys to identify potential Marine Protected Areas, to assess risk and to evaluate the consequences of the recent Gulf of Mexico oil disaster. Multi-year persistent sites of forage fishes generated multi-species predator aggregations. Species- and colony-specific winter inshore and offshore distributions of murres are associated with risks of climate change (ice), by-catch in fishing gear, hunting and oil extraction. Some thick-billed murres wintered in oceanic areas beyond the continental slope, and an area of high biological diversity was identified west of the Mid-Atlantic Ridge that, owing to its location beyond national jurisdictions, presents unique challenges for protection. Migration research indicated a substantial proportion of the North American gannet population wintering in the Gulf of Mexico near the\u00a0Deepwater Horizon\u00a0pollution area. Northern gannets incurred the highest incidence of oiling\/recoveries and were the third-most oiled avian species; distributions and exit dates suggest that sub-adult birds suffered much, likely most, of this mortality. Environmental risk is being assessed by tracking combined with stable isotope and blood assays to probe trophic interactions, habitat relationships and to identify and protect biologically significant marine areas.","author":["Garthe, S.","Montevecchi, W.","Burke, C.","Robertson, G.","Phillips, R.","Hedd, A.","Tranquilla, L.","Fifield, D.","Regular, P.","Davoren, G."],"organization":["Memorial University of Newfoundland","University of Manitoba","Kiel University","Environment Canada","Natural Environment Research Council (NERC)"],"originationDate":"2012-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1299","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cumulative-impacts-offshore-windfarms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_17","title":"Cumulative impacts of offshore windfarms","description":"Offshore windfarms intrude upon an environment already heavily affected by human activities such as shipping and fishing. As they are large and complex installations and given the large numbers planned, offshore windfarms can be expected to have significant impacts on marine ecosystems with long-lasting effects from both construction and operation. Environmental impacts of offshore windfarms include destruction of the sea bottom and benthic communities, disruption of migrating species such as birds via barrier effects, and disturbance of sound-sensitive marine species through increased underwater noise. The various impacts affect species both concurrently and sequentially at different life stages and should therefore be assessed from a cumulative perspective.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm\u00a0alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Merck, T.","Damian, H."],"organization":["Federal Environment Agency (Umweltbundesamt - UBA)","German Federal Agency for Nature Conservation (BfN)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1300","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/noise-mitigation-systems-low-noise-installation-technologies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_16","title":"Noise mitigation systems and low-noise installation technologies","description":"In line with Germany\u2019s national renewable energy targets, thousands of wind turbines are going to be installed in the North Sea and the Baltic Sea in the coming decades. This expansion of offshore wind power is obliged to take place in a sustainable and environmentally sound manner. To mitigate environmental impacts associated with the installation process for offshore wind turbines, extensive research and development (R\u0026D) effort has gone into the development, full-scale testing and evaluation of noise mitigation measures and low-noise foundation installation technologies. The article focuses on relevant primary and secondary noise mitigation techniques (adjustment of piling energy, impulse prolongation, bubble curtains, hydro sound dampers, casings, cofferdams) and on selected low-noise installation technologies (vibro piling, drilling, gravity based foundations, suction buckets).\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm\u00a0alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Verfu\u00df, T."],"organization":["Projekttr\u00e4ger J\u00fclich"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1301","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-construction-operational-noise-alpha-ventus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_15","title":"Underwater construction and operational noise at alpha ventus","description":"Between April and August 2009, an extensive monitoring programme was carried out at\u00a0alpha ventus\u00a0to determine and quantify the underwater noise produced by the installation of the wind turbine foundations (jackets and tripods). The sound measurements took place between April and August 2009. Most recordings were made with autonomous systems. Measurement distances were between 800 and 2,400 m, and at about 16 km distance from\u00a0alpha ventus\u00a0within the Borkum Reef Ground SCI. During the installation of a tripod, a prototype noise mitigation (Small Bubble Curtain) system was tested and evaluated. Measurements of operational noise were made in May and June 2011. This was the first operating noise measurement on wind turbines in the 5 MW class; until then, only smaller turbines had been evaluated.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm\u00a0alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Betke, K."],"organization":["Institute of Technical and Applied Physics (itap) GmbH"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1302","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-habitat-modelling-harbour-porpoises-german-bight","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_14","title":"Marine habitat modelling for harbour porpoises in the German Bight","description":"The harbour porpoise habitat modelling project aims to synthesise the data by long-term analysis and modelling of harbour porpoise distribution in the German Bight, i.e. the\u00a0alpha ventus\u00a0area and adjacent waters. This study uses predictive distribution models \u2013 a recent development in habitat modelling \u2013 to estimate harbour porpoise distributions in the German Bight during the summer season (June to August). The statistical models link observations from aerial surveys to oceanographic conditions and pressures. Oceanographic conditions during porpoise surveys were estimated using hydrodynamic models capable of describing patterns and dynamics of feeding habitats. As the modelling depends on the availability of coherent oceanographic and pressure data for the entire German Bight, the approach used combines hydrodynamic and noise models designed for the purpose.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Skov, H.","Thomsen, F.","Zydelis, R.","Arreborg-Hansen, D.","Ladage, F.","Schlenz, B."],"organization":["Danish Hydraulic Institute (DHI)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1303","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-mammals-windfarms-effects-alpha-ventus-harbour-porpoises","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_13","title":"Marine mammals and windfarms: Effects of alpha ventus on harbour porpoises","description":"Offshore windfarms have the potential to affect marine mammal populations. For harbour porpoises, the threat considered most important is the influence of noise during the construction phase. Effects of the operational period that need to be considered can be either noise effects or effects due to alteration to the habitat where foundations were erected. Visual surveys and stationary acoustic monitoring showed a strong avoidance reaction during pile-driving while during the operational period results were inconclusive. In future, these impacts must be seen in a larger framework to predict the biological significance of cumulative effects.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Lucke, K.","D\u00e4hne, M.","Gilles, A.","Peschko, V.","Adler, S.","Siebert, U.","Ronnenberg, K."],"organization":["Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences","University of Veterinary Medicine Hannover Foundation","IMARES - Wageningen UR"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1304","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-alpha-ventus-offshore-test-site-distribution-patterns-behaviour-flight-heights","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_11","title":"Effects of the alpha ventus offshore test site on distribution patterns, behaviour and flight heights of seabirds","description":"The North Sea and its adjacent waters are an area of world-wide importance for seabirds. With regard to the establishment of offshore windfarms, it becomes necessary to investigate the possible effects of these installations. In this project, distribution patterns of seabirds were determined and detailed observations were made on the behaviour and flight heights of individual birds in and around the\u00a0alpha ventus\u00a0windfarm area. Data was used from the combined database on seabird abundance and distribution in order to make predictions and draw conclusions about selected seabird species in relation to\u00a0alpha ventus. A recently developed digital method for aerial surveys was also tested in the course of this project.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Garthe, S.","Mendel, B.","Schwemmer, H.","Kotzerka, J.","Sommerfeld, J.","Sonntag, N."],"organization":["Kiel University","Aarhus University"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1305","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-alpha-ventus-offshore-test-site-pelagic-fish","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_10","title":"Effects of the alpha ventus offshore test site on pelagic fish","description":"At present, all studies on the impact of offshore windfarms on pelagic fish are restricted to a narrow survey area of a localised windfarm and surrounding reference areas. The same applies for investigations at the\u00a0alpha ventus\u00a0offshore windfarm. These include surveys on the distribution of pelagic fish in alpha ventus and the surrounding area based on hydroacoustic measurements, addressing immediate attraction and repulsion effects of offshore windfarms. The effect of changes in food supply was addressed as a single effect by analysis of the gut content of pelagic fish in and outside\u00a0alpha ventus. The study was performed over the period from August 2008 to April 2012. The survey covers a period before construction, during construction and during operation of the windfarm, in different seasons (spring, summer and autumn). The study further includes an evaluation of the survey methods, including development of a stationary measuring system for hydroacoustic long-term monitoring of fish.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Kr\u00e4gefsky, S."],"organization":["Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1306","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/rapid-increase-benthic-structural-functional-diversity-alpha-ventus-offshore-test-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_9","title":"Rapid increase of benthic structural and functional diversity at the alpha ventus offshore test site","description":"The ecological importance of benthic organisms, which provide valuable ecosystem goods and services, necessitates careful research into the effects of offshore windfarms on the marine benthos. This chapter summarizes the results from benthos research activities within the StUKplus programme. The results showed considerable effects of the windfarm\u00a0alpha ventuson the abundance and biomass of the benthic fauna. The major effect of the introduction of numerous wind turbine constructions into the marine environment was the aggregation and production of marine biota on the submersed structures, resulting in a substantial increase of the structural and functional biodiversity of the benthic system.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Krone, R.","Gutow, L.","Dannheim, J.","Gusky, M.","Schmidt, A.","Teschke, K."],"organization":["Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","Institute of Applied Ecology (IfAO)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1307","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/conservation-features-sensitive-species-habitats-german-exclusive-economic-zone","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_6","title":"Conservation features: Sensitive species and habitats in the German Exclusive Economic Zone","description":"In German seas, most of the windfarms are located in the southern North Sea. From a biological point of view this part of the North Sea is one of the most productive parts of the Atlantic Ocean and historically it is known as a sea with an overwhelming number of species. The development of offshore windfarms is planned in a marine water body whose ecological condition has already been significantly altered by existing anthropogenic impacts, as a result of which conflicts with the diverse flora and fauna of the North Sea have increased continuously. Obviously, the North Sea gives the impression that it could provide space for a number of anthropogenic installations. However, approvals for such installations have to take into account the long history of human activities and their existing impact on species and habitats in the water column and on the sea floor.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Krause, J."],"organization":["German Federal Agency for Nature Conservation (BfN)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1308","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/current-situation-offshore-development-germany-environmentally-sound-expansion","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_1","title":"Current situation of offshore development in Germany and environmentally sound expansion of offshore wind energy","description":"In September 2010, the German government adopted the national Energy Concept, a roadmap for an environmentally friendly, reliable and affordable energy supply up to the year 2050. The importance of this goal increased further when in the wake of the Fukushima incident in 2011, Germany decided to phase out nuclear energy. The German government\u2019s target is for the installation of 10 GW of wind power off the German coast by 2020, rising to 25 GW by 2030. The Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH) which is responsible for licensing offshore wind power projects in the German Exclusive Economic Zone, has so far granted 33 licences for offshore windfarms. Considerable effort goes into ensuring the environmentally sound expansion of offshore wind energy.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["van Leusen, S."],"organization":["German Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.720425000000","14.428404000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1309","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/birds-blades-barriers-detecting-analysing-mass-migration-events-alpha-ventus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-658-02462-8_12","title":"Of birds, blades and barriers: Detecting and analysing mass migration events at alpha ventus","description":"Most birds migrate at night and may be at risk of colliding with artificial structures that protrude into the open airspace. Collision risk assessments concerning offshore windfarms have been routinely based on discontinuous observations from ships. Dedicated avian radar systems installed close to the operational offshore windfarm\u00a0alpha ventus, however, allowed continuous quantification of migrating birds during day and night. Combined data collected by radar and various other optical and acoustical remote sensing techniques showed that nocturnal migrants get attracted to illuminated windfarms when visibility is low, occasionally leading to mass accumulations. On-going research will allow testing the severity of this impact and the effectiveness of possible mitigation measures.\n\nClick here to view the book\u00a0Ecological Research at the Offshore Windfarm alpha ventus: Challenges, Results and Perspectives.","author":["Hill, R.","Coppack, T.","Hill, K.","Aumuller, R.","Schulz, A.","Dittmann, T.","Kulemeyer, C."],"organization":["Avitec Research","Institute of Applied Ecology (IfAO)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.679252000000","6.704521000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1310","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/investigations-bird-collision-risk-responses-harbour-porpoises-offshore-wind-farms-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/289504864_Investigations_of_the_bird_collision_risk_and_the_responses_of_harbour_porpoises_in_the_offshore_wind_farms_Horns_Rev_North_Sea_and_Nysted_Baltic_Sea_in_Denmark_Part_II_Harbour_porpoises","title":"Investigations of the Bird Collision Risk and the Responses of Harbour Porpoises in the Offshore Wind Farms Horns Rev, North Sea, and Nysted, Baltic Sea, in Denmark - Part II: Harbour porpoises","description":"Like other European countries, Germany promotes the extension of renewable energies in order to protect the atmosphere from harmful emissions. The Federal Government of Germany has set the target to double the energy production from renewable sources by the year 2010. Offshore wind farming is supposed to play a major role in order to achieve this target. The installation of offshore wind farms at a large scale has raised concerns about possible impacts on nature, especially birds and marine mammals. Amongst others, there is concern that migrating birds might collide with the turbines; this may regard slow manoeuvring birds, times of limited visibility (night, fog, low clouds etc.), attraction by the turbine lights or other circumstances. The noise emissions of constructing and operating the wind farms might disturb harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena). A problem of the current discussion in Germany is that empirical research is not possible, as up to now no offshore wind turbines have been erected in German waters, though several approvals have been granted. Thus, a lack of knowledge about possible ecological problems exists and aggravates the discussion of these topics.  In 2005 we started a two-year project on the responses of harbour porpoises in the Danish offshore wind farms Horns Rev in the North Sea and Nysted in the Baltic Sea. The project is financed by the German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety. Access to the offshore wind farms was granted by the Danish Energy companies Vattenfall (formerly ELSAM eng.) and DONG energy (formerly Energi E2). Background of this study is the question, whether there are differences in the presence, echolocation activity and behaviour of harbour porpoises between inside and outside the wind farm or between close to far away (up to 1.5 km away) from a single turbine. The study was conducted with acoustic dataloggers (T-PODs) recording harbour porpoise echolocation signals. The devices were mounted on the seabed in an array of short transects with five TPODs in a row. Positions with T-PODs covered areas inside and outside the two wind farms Nysted and Horns Rev. In each wind farm area, two rows \u2013 totalling in ten devices \u2013 were deployed simultaneously. During the campaign, we changed the position of the rows four times, resulting in ten different experiments for each wind farm.  Click here to view Part I: Birds.","author":["Diederichs, A.","Nehls, G.","Hennig, V."],"organization":["BioConsult SH","Universit\u00e4t of Hamburg","German Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation, Building and Nuclear Safety (BMUB)"],"originationDate":"2008-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.576493000000","11.763411000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Marine Mammals","Collision","Noise","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2025-09-08 08:39:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Diederichs-et-al-2008.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1311","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-1-estimate-bat-populations-southern-north-sea-supporting-note-zdv-report-no","sourceURL":"https:\/\/edepot.wur.nl\/410617","title":"Bat 1: Estimate of bat populations at the southern North Sea - Supporting note to ZDV report no. 2016.031 Migrating bats at the southern North Sea","description":"This report is a supporting note to ZDV report no. 2016.031 Migration bats at the southern North Sea.\n\nIn recent years, exploratory research into the occurrence of bats at the Dutch North Sea has shown that there is regular seasonal migration over sea of at least Nathusius\u2019 Pipistrelle Pipistrellus nathusii but perhaps also of Parti-coloured Bat Vespertilio murinus and Common Noctule Nyctalus noctula (Boshamer \u0026 Bekker 2008; Jonge Poerink et al. 2013; Lagerveld et al. 2014a, 2014b, 2015; Leopold et al. 2014). Given the planned large-scale development of wind farms in the Dutch part of the southern North Sea in the coming years (SER Agreement 2013), the growing evidence that bats are vulnerable to collisions with wind turbine rotor blades and barotrauma caused by the fluctuating air pressure near the blades (e.g. Baerwald et al. 2008, Brinkmann et al. 2011, Bach et al. 2014, Cryan et al. 2014), the Ministry of Economic Affairs commissioned to Rijkswaterstaat (RWS) a two-year monitoring programme in 2015 to determine the occurrence and abundance of bats at the North Sea. This study is currently being conducted in a monitoring project titled \u0027Research on distribution and behaviour of bats in the southern North Sea\u0027 (RWS case number 31103115). It aims at providing insight into bat movements over sea. However, in order to be able to make better estimates of the actual numbers of bats at sea and thus to get a clearer picture of the potential impact of offshore wind energy development on population level, more research is needed into the population ecology of bats in Europe and beyond. It is currently unclear what is the population size of the relevant species, which proportion migrates over sea and which proportion travels over land.\u00a0","author":["Lagerveld, S.","Scholl, M.","Limpens, H.","Schillemans, M."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","Bureau van de Zoogdiervereniging (Dutch Mammal Society)","WOZEP"],"originationDate":"2017-03-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.167440900000","0.726096600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lagerveld-et-al-March10-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1312","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-mid-frequency-active-sonar-hearing-fish","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/1.3664082","title":"Effects of mid-frequency active sonar on hearing in fish","description":"Caged fish were exposed to sound from mid-frequency active (MFA) transducers in a 5\u2009\u00d7\u20095 planar array which simulated MFA sounds at received sound pressure levels of 210 dB SPL(re 1 \u03bcPa). The exposure sound consisted of a 2 s frequency sweep from 2.8 to 3.8 kHz followed by a 1 s tone at 3.3 kHz. The sound sequence was repeated every 25 s for five repetitions resulting in a cumulative sound exposure level (SELcum) of 220 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2 s. The cumulative exposure level did not affect the hearing sensitivity of rainbow trout, a species whose hearing range is lower than the frequencies in the presented MFA sound. In contrast, one cohort of channel catfish showed a statistically significant temporary threshold shift of 4\u20136 dB at 2300 Hz, but not at lower tested frequencies, whereas a second cohort showed no change. It is likely that this threshold shift resulted from the frequency spectrum of the MFA sound overlapping with the upper end of the hearing frequency range of the channel catfish. The observed threshold shifts in channel catfish recovered within 24 h. There was no mortality associated with the MFA sound exposure used in this test","author":["Popper, A.","Halvorsen, M.","Ellison, W.","Chicoine, D.","Zeddies, D."],"organization":["University of Maryland","Marine Acoustics Inc"],"originationDate":"2012-01-13","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.698218000000","-76.924820000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1313","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-energy-systems-annual-report-2017","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ocean-energy-systems.org\/publications\/oes-annual-reports\/","title":"Ocean Energy Systems Annual Report 2017","description":"Ocean Energy Systems (OES) is the short name for the Technology Collaboration Programme on Ocean Energy Systems under the International Energy Agency (IEA). This Annual Report presents an overview of the activities undertaken within OES in 2017, as well as updated country reviews prepared by the Delegates.  The year 2017 marked the beginning of the fourth 5-year mandate (2017 \u2013 2022) of the OES.  The Strategic Plan for this next five years continues to be the guiding document for the OES work programme. The development of ocean energy has been slower than expected. A longer term vision is required to see the development of ocean energy to the stage where it becomes a viable, cost-effective and reliable alternative to other forms of renewable energy. The added value of the OES arises from good, truly international cooperation. OES is the only intergovernmental, multinational organization in the ocean energy sector, independent of any commercial interests and composed of active members, that encompass the full range of interests from government policy to industry developments. For this new work period, OES will bring added value to national activities by coordinated efforts on priority topics for the whole sector and by delivering clear key technology policy messages to decision makers.  The OES has 25 members, which provide a broad international base of information, sharing experience and knowledge and further a diversified representation of interests: members are from governmental departments, utilities, universities and research organizations, energy agencies and industry associations. This is one of the benefits of joining OES: participants gain an international perspective on ocean energy issues, opportunities and present challenges.  The OES is always looking for new members across the globe, and key representatives from potential new member countries are encouraged to attend meetings as Observers.  The OES international co-operation facilitates:  \u2022 Securing access to advanced R\u0026amp;D teams in the participating countries; \u2022 Developing a harmonized set of measures and testing protocols for the testing of prototypes; \u2022 Reducing national costs by collaborating internationally; \u2022 Creating valuable international contacts between government, industry and science; \u2022 Sharing information and networking.  This Executive Summary provides a brief summary of the OES Annual Report for the year 2017. It synthesizes the main achievements in the OES collaborative activities and presents relevant policies and projects by each OES member country. It also includes, as in previous years, an interview on a specific topic, this year about environmental issues on ocean energy: Andrea Copping, coordinator of the work done under Task 4 (known as Annex IV) gives her views to six questions from OES.","author":["Ocean Energy Systems (OES)"],"organization":["Ocean Energy Systems (OES)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OES-Annual-Report-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1314","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/migrating-bats-southern-north-sea-approach-estimation-migration-populations-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/318284644_Migrating_bats_at_the_southern_North_Sea_Approach_to_an_estimation_of_migration_populations_of_bats_at_the_southern_North_Sea","title":"Migrating bats at the southern North Sea: Approach to an estimation of migration populations of bats at the southern North Sea","description":"Bats experience a fatality risk at wind turbines. Since some species migrate not only over land, but also over sea, offshore turbines might pose a threat. To be able to assess the impact of potential added mortality at sea, it is necessary to know or estimate the population size of bats, including the portion of the population crossing the sea. Potentially relevant species are Nathusius\u2019 Pipistrelle (Pipistrellus nathusii), Common Noctule (Nyctalus noctula) and Particoloured Bat (Vespertilio murinus). The current study aims at developing a prototype estimator for migrating populations of bats. This is based on data, or estimates, regarding the size and bandwidth of source populations, population dynamical factors defining such populations, and factors defining migration fluxes. Acknowledging the rareness of such data, a flow model is constructed targeting a preliminary estimate for the southern North Sea (SNS). However, the approach can be adapted for use in other regions\/study areas as well.\u00a0The model is based on available information and data regarding bat species in the different countries bordering the SNS. This includes countries further off, which might be \u2018source countries\u2019 of bats that eventually might fly on the SNS.\u00a0Currently the model focuses on the Nathusius\u2019 Pipistrelle, because this is the species where some information and data are available. Even for this species quantitative basic estimates on source populations were only available for RO Ireland, UK (specifically for England and northern Ireland) and the Netherlands.","author":["Ahl\u00e9n, I.","Bach, L.","Durinck, J.","Johansen, T.","Rodrigues, L.","Mathews, F.","Dubourg-Savage, M.","Petersons, G.","Elmeros, M.","Roche, N.","Aughney, T.","Jansen, E.","de Jong, J.","Lagerveld, S.","Bach, P.","Limpens, H.","Hurst, J.","Haarsma, A.","Anxionnat, D.","Baagoe, H.","Boshamer, J.","Boughey, K.","Campion, T.","Christensen, M.","Douma, T.","Haddow, J.","Hargreaves, D.","Jouan, D.","van der Kooij, J.","Kyheroinen, E.","Michaelsen, T.","Moller, J.","Russ, J.","Smits, Q.","Swift, S.","Fjederholt, E.","Twisk, P.","Vandendriesche, B.","Schillemans, M."],"organization":["Bureau van de Zoogdiervereniging (Dutch Mammal Society)","Wageningen University and Research Centre"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.167440900000","0.726096600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Limpens-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1315","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-flight-analysis-around-wind-turbines-feasibility-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/library.wur.nl\/WebQuery\/wurpubs\/fulltext\/417091","title":"Bat Flight Analysis around Wind Turbines - A Feasibility Study","description":"In recent years, research into the occurrence of bats at the Dutch North Sea has shown that there is regular seasonal migration over sea. However, so far, little is known about their migration ecology, the fatality risks at offshore wind turbines, and the number of individuals migrating over sea. Since the Dutch government wants to boost the further development of wind energy production in the southern North Sea, the Ministry of Economic Affairs commissioned to Rijkswaterstaat the elaboration of an integrated Wind at Sea Ecological Programme (in Dutch: Wozep). This study, as part of the Wozep-project Behaviour and Collision Risk of Bats (Bats_2), investigates how bat behaviour can be studied near offshore wind turbines. To find out whether it is wise to continue and further develop behavioural research at wind turbines in the context of the Wozep programme, we first conducted a feasibility study on land. A stereoscopic setup consisting of two thermal cameras was devised and used to collect footage of bats in August and September 2016 at the Wind Turbine test Site in the Wieringermeer. The cameras were positioned in such a way that the overlapping field of view in both cameras could be used to determine 3D bat paths at a distance of 80 m around a single wind turbine. In addition, acoustic bat activity was measured with a 12 channel bat detector at three different heights with microphones in each wind direction.\u00a0Tailor made 3D analysis tools were developed to synchronize both thermal cameras, calibrate the stereoscopic setup, determine 2D tracks in the left and the right view and eventually to reconstruct the x, y, z coordinates of bat positions in time.\n\nThe conclusion of this feasibility study is that computer vision components can be used to measure bat flight trajectories in 3D to study the effects of wind turbines on the bat mortality and bat flight behaviour. The bat detector configuration is able monitor bat activity simultaneously at multiple heights in different directions, which can be used for species identification and to assess the accuracy of the estimated bat flight trajectories. During nights with much bat activity several thousand recordings can be obtained and therefore it is necessary to identify these automatically. Before a system can be built for wind turbines at sea, further improvements are needed to mature the current system and meet the goal to automatically detect bat fight paths and fatalities. Before application at sea we recommend to build a prototype on land with multiple stereo setups to monitor the complete area of the rotors and improve and automatize the current 3D analysis tools.","author":["de Haan, D.","Lagerveld, S.","Scholl, M.","Manshanden, J.","Kooistra, G.","Otten, G.","Meesters, L.","Gerla, D.","Verhoef, H."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","WOZEP"],"originationDate":"2017-03-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.791048000000","4.693080000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lagerveld-et-al-March31-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1316","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/telemetry-migratory-bats-feasibility-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/library.wur.nl\/WebQuery\/wurpubs\/fulltext\/417092","title":"Telemetry for migratory bats - a feasibility study","description":"In recent years, research into the occurrence of bats at the Dutch North Sea has shown that there is regular seasonal migration over sea. However, so far, little is known about their migration ecology, the fatality risks at offshore wind turbines, and the number of individuals migrating over sea. Since the Dutch government wants to boost the further development of wind energy production in the southern North Sea, the Ministry of Economic Affairs commissioned to Rijkswaterstaat a Wind at Sea Ecological Programme (in Dutch: Wozep). This study, as part of the Wozep-project Behaviour and Collision Risk of Bats (Bats_2), investigates how telemetry can be applied to gain insight into migratory movements of bats over land and over sea and individual bat behaviour near and in offshore wind farms. To find out whether it is wise to continue and further develop telemetry research in the context of the Wozep programme, we first identified potential telemetry methods for small bats based on a desk study and selected the most promising method for the application of telemetry. Members of the team attended an international workshop on telemetry in Lund (Sweden) to gather practical technical knowledge, gain insight in data-management standards, and increase their international network. Several field tests were conducted to test the equipment and explore the possibilities of tracking. Finally, suitable locations for bat trapping in bat boxes and for the use of a Heligoland trap were identified.\n\nIn conclusion, we are confident that telemetry can be successfully applied to study migratory movements of bats over land and over sea and individual bat behaviour near and in offshore wind farms. Joining a wildlife tracking system like Motus (Canada) in order to enlarge the data collection, is highly recommended. Motus-members can get detections from both their own tags received by stations owned by other members, and from tags owned by other members if received by their own stations.","author":["Janssen, R.","Brabant, R.","Lagerveld, S.","Scholl, M.","Manshanden, J.","Haarsma, A.","Vries, S."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","WOZEP"],"originationDate":"2017-02-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.886065000000","4.687618000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lagerveld-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1317","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/motus-wildlife-tracking-system-collaborative-research-network-enhance-understanding","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ace-eco.org\/vol12\/iss1\/art8\/","title":"The Motus Wildlife Tracking System: a collaborative research network to enhance the understanding of wildlife movement","description":"We describe a new collaborative network, the Motus Wildlife Tracking System, which is an international network of researchers using coordinated automated radio-telemetry arrays to study movements of small flying organisms including birds, bats, and insects, at local, regional, and hemispheric scales. Radio-telemetry has been a cornerstone of tracking studies for over 50 years, and because of current limitations of geographic positioning systems (GPS) and satellite transmitters, has remained the primary means to track movements of small animals with high temporal and spatial precision. Automated receivers, along with recent miniaturization and digital coding of tags, have further improved the utility of radio-telemetry by allowing many individuals to be tracked continuously and simultaneously across broad landscapes. Motus is novel among automated arrays in that collaborators employ a single radio frequency across receiving stations over a broad geographic scale, allowing individuals to be detected at sites maintained by others. Motus also coordinates, disseminates, and archives detections and associated metadata in a central repository. Combined with the ability to track many individuals simultaneously, Motus has expanded the scope and spatial scale of research questions that can be addressed using radio-telemetry from local to regional and even hemispheric scales. Since its inception in 2012, more than 9000 individuals of over 87 species of birds, bats, and insects have been tracked, resulting in more than 250 million detections. This rich and comprehensive dataset includes detections of individuals during all phases of the annual cycle (breeding, migration, and nonbreeding), and at a variety of spatial scales, resulting in novel insights into the movement behavior of small flying animals. The value of the Motus network will grow as spatial coverage of stations and number of partners and collaborators increases. With continued expansion and support, Motus can provide a framework for global collaboration, and a coordinated approach to solving some of the most complex problems in movement biology and ecology.","author":["Francis, C.","Smith, P.","Taylor, P.","Loring, P.","Smetzer, J.","Welch, L.","Crewe,T.","Mackenzie, S.","Lepage, D.","Aubry, Y.","Crysler, Z.","Finney, G.","Guglielmo, C.","Hamilton, D.","Holberton, R.","Mitchell, G.","Norris, D.","Paquet, J.","Ronconi, R.","Woodworth, B."],"organization":["Acadia University","Bird Studies Canada","University of Western Ontario","Canadian Wildlife Service","Mount Allison University","University of Maine","University of Massachusetts","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","Environment and Climate Change Canada","University of Guelph"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Taylor-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1318","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/swimming-speed-harbor-porpoise-phocoena-phocoena-during-playbacks-offshore-pile","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aquaticmammalsjournal.org\/index.php?option=com_content\u0026view=article\u0026id=1734:swimming-speed-of-a-harbor-porpoise-phocoena-phocoena-during-playbacks-of-offshore-pile-driving-sounds\u0026catid=167\u0026Itemid=326","title":"Swimming Speed of a Harbor Porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) During Playbacks of Offshore Pile Driving Sounds","description":"The loud sounds produced under water during offshore percussion pile driving for the construction of wind turbines may affect harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena). Kastelein et al. (2013b) exposed a porpoise in a quiet pool to playbacks of underwater pile driving sound at several mean received sound pressure levels (SPLs; range: 130 to 154 dB re 1 mu Pa) and suggested that harbor porpoises at sea swim away from offshore pile driving locations (moving tens of km), thus reducing their received SPL. The speed at which they swim both determines the acoustic exposure and impacts the energetic costs of a behavioral response. Therefore, information on swimming speed is important for estimating the potential impact of pile driving sounds on the hearing, the energetics, and the population dynamics of harbor porpoises. The video recordings from the Kastelein et al. (2013b) study were analyzed for swimming speed. During quiet baseline periods, the mean swimming speed of the porpoise was 4.3 km\/h, and he swam a mean distance of 2.2 km in 30 min. Even at the lowest SPL tested (130 dB re 1 mu Pa), his mean swimming speed was significantly greater than during baseline periods. At the highest SPL (154 dB re 1 mu Pa), his mean swimming speed was 7.1 km\/h, and he swam a mean distance of 3.6 km in 30 min. Swimming speed did not decline significantly during the 30-min test periods, and a speed of similar to 7 km\/h appears to he sustainable for harbor porpoises.","author":["Kastelein, R.","Jennings, N.","Van de Voorde, S."],"organization":["SEAMARCO"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1319","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-pile-driving-sounds-harbor-seal-phoca-vitulina-hearing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/1.5040493","title":"Effect of pile-driving sounds on harbor seal (Phoca vitulina) hearing","description":"Seals exposed to intense sounds may suffer hearing loss. After exposure to playbacks of broadband pile-driving sounds, the temporary hearing threshold shift (TTS) of two harbor seals was quantified at 4 and 8 kHz (frequencies of the highest TTS) with a psychoacoustic technique. The pile-driving sounds had: a 127 ms pulse duration, 2760 strikes per h, a 1.3 s inter-pulse interval, a similar to 9.5% duty cycle, and an average received single-strike unweighted sound exposure level (SELss) of 151dB re 1\u00b5Pa2s. Exposure durations were 180 and 360 min [cumulative sound exposure level (SELcum): 190 and 193 dB re 1\u00b5Pa2s]. Control sessions were conducted under low ambient noise. TTS only occurred after 360 min exposures (mean TTS: seal 02, 1-4min after sound stopped: 3.9 dB at 4 kHz and 2.4 dB at 8 kHz; seal 01, 12-16min after sound stopped: 2.8 dB at 4 kHz and 2.6 dB at 8 kHz). Hearing recovered within 60min post-exposure. The TTSs were small, due to the small amount of sound energy to which the seals were exposed. Biological TTS onset SELcum for the pile-driving sounds used in this study is around 192 dB re 1\u00b5Pa2s (for mean received SELss of 151 dB re 1\u00b5Pa and a duty cycle of similar to 9.5%).","author":["Kastelein, R.","Gransier, R.","Helder-Hoek, L.","Covi, J.","Kommeren, A."],"organization":["SEAMARCO","Katholieke University Leuven"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1320","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/structure-borne-wave-radiation-impact-vibratory-piling-offshore-installations-sound","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2077-1312\/4\/3\/44","title":"Structure-Borne Wave Radiation by Impact and Vibratory Piling in Offshore Installations: From Sound Prediction to Auditory Damage","description":"Anthropogenic noise emission in the marine environment is a key issue nowadays and has drawn the attention of regulatory bodies in various nations. In particular, the noise generated during the installation of foundation piles for the offshore wind industry is considered to be harmful for aquatic species. A reliable prediction of the underwater noise during the installation of a foundation pile is thus essential for the proper assessment of the ecological impact. In this paper, the structure-borne wave radiation is investigated with the help of a semi-analytical model for two cases. The first case considers a pile that is installed with the help of an impact hammer, whereas the second one deals with a pile that is driven into the seabed with the help of a vibratory device. The spatial distribution and the frequency content of the radiated sound are analyzed, and the differences are highlighted between the two cases. The model is validated with data available in the literature that were collected during several measurement campaigns. Subsequently, the predicted noise levels are converted into an equivalent index that reflects the auditory damage to certain marine species, and a method is presented for the derivation of zones of impact around the pile that are based on the noise predictions by the models and the chosen method of installation. This approach can be used to define critical zones within which a predefined level of auditory damage is to be expected based on a specific installation scenario.","author":["Tsouvalas, A.","Metrikine, A."],"organization":["Delft University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2016-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/tsouvalasetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1321","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pelagic-effects-offshore-wind-farm-foundations-stratified-north-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0079661117300381","title":"Pelagic effects of offshore wind farm foundations in the stratified North Sea","description":"A recent increase in the construction of Offshore Wind Farms (OWFs) has initiated numerous environmental impact assessments and monitoring programs. These focus on sea mammals, seabirds, benthos or demersal fish, but generally ignore any potential effects OWFs may have on the pelagic ecosystem. The only work on the latter has been through modelling analyses, which predict localised impacts like enhanced vertical mixing leading to a decrease in seasonal stratification, as well as shelf-wide changes of tidal amplitudes. Here we provide for the first-time empirical bio-physical data from an OWF. The data were obtained by towing a remotely operated vehicle (TRIAXUS ROW) through two non-operating OWFs in the summer stratified North Sea. The undulating TRIAXUS transects provided high-resolution CTD data accompanied by oxygen and chlorophyll-a measurements. We provide empirical indication that vertical mixing is increased within the OWFs, leading to a doming of the thermocline and a subsequent transport of nutrients into the surface mixed layer (SML). Nutrients were taken up rapidly because underwater photosynthetically active radiation (PAR) enabled net primary production in the entire water column, especially within submesoscale chlorophyll-a pillars that were observed at regular intervals within the OWF regions. Video Plankton Recorder (VPR) images revealed distinct meroplankton distribution patterns in a copepod-dominated plankton community. Hydroacoustic records did not show any OWF effects on the distribution of pelagic fish. The results of a pre-OWF survey show however, that it is difficult to fully separate the anthropogenic impacts from the natural variability.","author":["Lenhart, H.","Zielinski, O.","Carpenter, J.","Callies, U.","Floeter, J.","van Beusekom, J.","Auch, D.","Dudeck, T.","Eberle, S.","Eckhardt, A.","Gloe, D.","Hanselmann, K.","Hufnagl, M.","Janssen, S.","Moller, K.","North, R.","Pohlmann, T.","Riethmuller, R.","Schulz, S.","Spreizenbarth, S.","Temming, A.","Walter, B.","Mollmann, C."],"organization":["Universit\u00e4t of Hamburg","Max Planck Society","Carl von Ossietzky Universitat Oldenburg"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.500000000000","6.200000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1322","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-farm-marine-spatial-planning-stakeholders-engagement-opportunities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117302648","title":"Offshore wind farm in marine spatial planning and the stakeholders engagement: Opportunities and challenges for Taiwan","description":"Taiwan has advantages in the development of offshore wind power, as it has abundant wind energy resources at the seas. The local government has developed a series of measures to promote the development of wind power generation industry. The development of offshore wind farm in Taiwan, however, has to solve the problems that offshore wind farms are overlapping with some traditional fishing grounds and are unable to reach consensus with relevant stakeholders. This paper starts from the great potential of offshore wind power in Taiwan and the active promotion of the government, and analyses the impact and possible opportunities brought by offshore wind farm development to local fisheries, from the perspective of Zhanghua Area, a key area of development of offshore wind farm in Taiwan. This paper proposes that the local government in Taiwan should use marine spatial planning as a tool, through the comprehensive participation of government, developers, fishermen and other bodies, seeking the coexistence and prosperity of offshore wind farm and fisheries. Avoidance, compensation, and feedback, as well as communication and collaboration will be an important strategy to solve the conflicts of multiple use of the sea and to promote the development of marine renewable energy.","author":["Zhang, Y.","Liu, W.","Chang, Y.","Zhang, C."],"organization":["National Kaohsiung University of Science \u0026 Technology","Shandong University","State Grid Corporation of China"],"originationDate":"2017-11-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["23.905512200000","120.713943300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1323","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-noise-levels-pile-driving-new-zealand-harbour-potential-impacts-endangered","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X18305022","title":"Underwater noise levels of pile-driving in a New Zealand harbour, and the potential impacts on endangered Hector\u0027s dolphins","description":"Impact pile-driving generates loud underwater anthropogenic sounds, and is routinely conducted in harbours around the world. Surprisingly few studies of these sounds and their propagation are published in the primary literature. To partially redress this we studied pile-driving sounds in Lyttelton Harbour, New Zealand, during wharf reconstruction after earthquake damage. That Lyttelton harbour is routinely used by Hector\u0027s dolphins (Cephalorhynchus hectori), an endangered species found only in New Zealand, provided further context for this study. Steel piles of 0.61 or 0.71 m diameter were driven using three different pile-drivers. Maximum calculated source SEL was 192 dB re 1 mu Pa(2)s @ 1 m (SPL0-p of 213 dB re 1 mu Pa @ 1 m). Propagation of piling noise was strongly influenced by harbour bathymetry and a rock breakwater near the piling operation. We calculated range estimates at which Hector\u0027s dolphins may suffer temporary hearing threshold shift and behavioural change.","author":["Leunissen, E.","Dawson, S."],"organization":["University of Otago"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-43.613060000000","172.740000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1324","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/prioritisation-monitoring-research-diadromous-fish-context-marineoffshore-renewables","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/publications\/scottish-marine-freshwater-science-volume-5-number-4-prioritisation-monitoring\/pages\/2\/","title":"Prioritisation of monitoring and research for diadromous fish in the context of Marine\/Offshore Renewables: A summary of stakeholder engagement meetings between Marine Scotland, wild fisheries interests and wind, wave and tidal developers","description":"Marine Scotland Science (MSS) prepared a scoping report of the research requirements for Atlantic salmon, sea trout and European eel in the context of offshore renewables (Malcolm et al, 2013). This report was intended to inform the development of a National Research and Monitoring Strategy for Diadromous Fish (hereafter NRMSD) to investigate the potential for interactions between diadromous fish and wind, wave and tidal renewable energy developments. To ensure that the NRMSD had broad sectorial support, meetings were convened to identify and discuss priority areas.  There was general agreement on information requirements between the stakeholder groups. The following areas were considered priorities:    Fish Distribution,  Population Status,  Response to noise,  Effects of electromagnetic fields  Risk of collision.   Future engagement events will be convened at suitable stages in the development of the National Research and Monitoring Strategy for Diadromous Fish.","author":["Hunter, D.","Armstrong, J.","Malcolm, I."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2014-03-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.186690400000","-4.659774500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Stakeholder Engagement","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/hunteretal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1325","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/current-state-knowledge-effects-offshore-renewable-energy-generation-devices-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/publications\/current-state-knowledge-effects-offshore-renewable-energy-generation-devices-marine\/pages\/5\/","title":"Current state of knowledge of effects of offshore renewable energy generation devices on marine mammals \u0026 research requirements","description":"This report is designed to fulfil requirements MR1 and MR2 within the Marine Mammal Scientific Support Research Programme MMSS\/001\/11. The report describes the current state of knowledge of effects of offshore renewable energy generators on marine mammals and then identifies a prioritised list of research gaps.  A total of 28 specific research gaps are identified. Of these, 16 are already under investigation to some extent with either active research projects or planned and funded future projects.  The 12 remaining projects have yet to secure funding. These are prioritised but the list of priorities has yet to be agreed with the steering group for the MMSS\/001\/11. A final project list with agreed priorities will be included in the next update of this report.  In parallel with this study an analysis of research requirements for developing models to identify population consequences of disturbance (PCOD) has been carried out under the Offshore Renewable Joint Industry Programme (ORJIP). The results of that analysis will be used to extend the list of research gaps and amend the priorities of specific projects in the next update of this report.","author":["Thompson, D.","Lonergan, M.","McConnell, B.","Northridge, S.","Hall, A."],"organization":["University of St Andrews","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2013-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/thompsonetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1326","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/strategic-surveys-seabirds-west-coast-lewis-determine-use-seaspace-areas-potential","sourceURL":"https:\/\/data.marine.gov.scot\/dataset\/strategic-surveys-seabirds-west-coast-lewis-determine-use-seaspace-areas-potential-marine","title":"Strategic Surveys of Seabirds off the West Coast of Lewis to Determine Use of Seaspace in Areas of Potential Marine Renewable Energy Developments","description":"1.1 By 2020 the percentage of Scotland\u0027s energy coming from renewable sources will increase. Studies have identified that there is a need to research how offshore renewable developments affect wildlife populations. The surveys presented here will help to find out how one area of marine development, the west coast of Lewis, is used by waterbirds and marine mammals. Areas close to the Isle of Lewis have already been identified as being important for these groups of animals, through the Special Protection Areas ( SPA) network.  1.2 Methods used during these surveys included a desk-based study, a digital aerial survey and ground-based counts. The digital aerial survey involved an aircraft flying systematic 2km spaced transects through the survey area recording high definition video along four 200m strips thus achieving 10% sampling coverage of the area. The images recorded were processed, and bird and mammal species were identified by analysts post survey and strip transect analysis undertaken to derive abundance estimates for the study area. Density surface modelling was undertaken for fulmars, gannets and auk species.  1.3 Ground-based counts involved an ornithologist undertaking a bird and marine mammal survey from 14 vantage points along the west coast of Lewis. These counts were co-ordinated as much as possible with the aerial survey, and were used to gain more information about more difficult to identify species, or undertaken in places known to be important for seabirds but likely to be missed by the aerial survey. A further vantage point study covering the majority of Loch Roag was also undertaken, covering areas outside the aerial survey study area.  1.4 Aerial and coastal ground-count surveys were undertaken in April, June, July, September and December 2012 and February 2013 with additional surveys of Loch Roag in April, June, July and October 2012 and January and February 2013.  1.5 In April the digital aerial survey recorded 792 birds and 11 mammals from 31 species and species groups. Fulmars were the most abundant bird. In May 347 birds from 24 species and species groups were recorded, with Fulmar again the most abundant bird. In June 491 birds, 24 mammals and one shark were counted, from 41 species and species groups. Fulmars again had the highest count. In July, 525 birds, 15 mammals and one shark were recorded, from 36 species and species groups. In this month gannets were the most numerous bird species. Gannets were again the most commonly recorded bird in September with 247 recorded out of 494 bird records of 25 species or species groups. Five basking sharks were recorded in September, together with eight other marine mammal records. Fulmars were again the most commonly recorded bird species in December 2012 and February 2013 with 133 and 186 records out of 410 and 589 bird records from 22 and 23 species or species groups respectively. The only marine mammals recorded in December and February were two and one harbour porpoises respectively.  1.6 From the west coast of Lewis ground-based counts, a total of 122 birds were counted in April, from 19 species and species groups, in May 145 birds were counted from 18 species and species groups. In June 245 birds and seven mammals from 24 species and species groups were recorded. Recorded bird activity declined in July with 111 birds, three mammals and one shark counted in total, from 21 species and species groups. Fulmars and auks were commonly the most numerous birds counted. 315 birds of 10 species and species groups and eight grey seals and a basking shark were recorded in September, 247 birds of 11 species or species groups were recorded in December with no mammals and the busiest survey was in February 2013 with 655 birds of 12 species or species groups and one grey seal.  1.7 Overall numbers of birds recorded from the aerial and ground counts were low in comparison to numbers of these species breeding on colonies within foraging range.  1.8 Thirty eight species of bird were recorded from the six Loch Roag surveys, including six species of high conservation importance and small numbers of harbour seal and grey seals.  1.9 A comparison of the aerial and ground counts was undertaken. Small sample sizes precluded detailed statistical analysis and the identification of conclusive trends, although some general trends were identified. These included more diving birds such as shags, divers, and auks, particularly black guillemots recorded during ground counts than by aerial surveys, due partly to them spending a proportion of their time underwater in dives and thus unavailable for counting by the almost instantaneous aerial surveys.","author":["Woodward, R.","Simpson, M."],"organization":["Wildfowl and Wetlands Trust (WWT)","HiDef Aerial Surveying Ltd","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2014-07-23","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.303820000000","-6.898926000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/simpsonetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1327","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/depth-use-movements-homing-atlantic-salmon-salmo-salar-scottish-coastal-waters","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/publications\/scottish-marine-freshwater-science-volume-5-number-18-depth-use\/","title":"Depth use and movements of homing Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar) in Scottish coastal waters in relation to marine renewable energy development","description":"The depth use of homing Atlantic salmon caught and released on the north coast of Scotland was recorded over 1-20 days using pop-up satellite telemetry during the summers of 2013 and 2014. Data were returned from 47 out of 50 salmon tagged in 2013 and 80 out of 85 salmon tagged in 2014. Overall the fish were predominantly surface-orientated, spending a median of 80.4% of their time in the upper 5m of the water column. There was, however, significant variation between individuals: the time spent in the upper 5 m ranged from 8-99%, while individual median swimming depths ranged from 0-28.5 m. All fish undertook dives to below 10m of depth and the mean maximum depth was 67 m (range 13\u2011256 m), of similar magnitude to the likely available water depth. Pop-up locations were obtained for 122 tags and indicated that salmon swam in all possible directions from the release point.","author":["Godfrey, J.","Armstrong, J.","Stewart, D.","Middlemas, S."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2014-12-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.556000000000","-4.093000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Godfreyetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1328","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/request-advice-populations-cetaceans-might-be-involved-significant-interactions-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/publications\/work-package-c2-request-advice-populations-cetaceans\/","title":"Request for advice on the populations of cetaceans that might be involved in significant interactions with marine renewable energy developments in Scottish marine waters","description":"This report aims to provide advice on appropriate biological population units to be used in environmental impact assessments of the potential impacts on cetacean populations of marine renewable energy developments in Scottish waters. The advice takes account of and where appropriate, is consistent with population units already established in related contexts, including Moray Firth SAC population of bottlenose dolphins, population units used for the assessment of the significance of by-catch of harbour porpoise in the ICES area, and population units for minke whale and other cetaceans used by the IWC, ASCOBANS etc. The report focuses on the most regularly present and significant cetacean species in Scottish waters - i.e. bottlenose dolphins, harbour porpoise, minke whales, risso\u0027s dolphins, white-beaked dolphins, common dolphins, white-sided dolphins and killer whales - and provides scientific support, as appropriate, for the populations selected. The tabulated species data below provides information on the structure of populations of regularly present and significant cetacean species (see above) in Scottish waters (out to 200 nm) and the geographical scale of biologically meaningful population units of the relevant species where these units extend beyond Scottish waters.  It can be used to provide advice on the relevant population units of these regularly present and significant cetacean species, which can be found in areas of search for renewable developments identified in Marine Scotland Scoping Studies for wind (2011), wave (2012) and tidal stream (2012) energy, and which therefore should be used in SEAs and project EIAs.","author":["Northridge, S."],"organization":["University of St Andrews","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2012-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.749999200000","-3.508776200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/northridge.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1329","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/request-advice-about-displacement-marine-mammals-around-operational-offshore-windfarms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www2.gov.scot\/Publications\/2012\/10\/7937","title":"Request for advice about the displacement of marine mammals around operational offshore windfarms","description":"The report provides an authoritative review of what is known about the behaviour of marine mammals (seals and cetaceans) around operational offshore wind farms and, in particular, any degree of displacement that persists, after completion of the construction phase. It provides an initial assessment of the significance of any displacement risk, and proposals for practical research activity, if necessary.  In particular it includes a review of information on degree of displacement of marine mammals by operational wind farms using published and preliminary information from wind farms in European waters, and elsewhere. Also, advice on the potential significance of any risk of displacement found. And advice on feasible research activities to improve the characterisation of any displacement risk and, the potential consequences for individual marine mammals and larger populations.","author":["Alcock, P."],"organization":["Scottish Government","Marine Scotland Science","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2012-10-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.611376000000","-1.344918000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/alcock.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1330","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-influence-robin-rigg-wind-farm-abundance-adult-juvenile-atlantic-salmon","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www2.gov.scot\/Topics\/marine\/marineenergy\/Research\/workpackageAP6","title":"The potential influence of Robin Rigg Wind Farm on the abundance of adult and juvenile Atlantic salmon","description":"Data on the abundance of adult (rod catch) and juvenile (electrofishing surveys) Atlantic salmon were analysed to assess the potential impact of offshore wind farm construction and operation on local stocks.  Given the available data and assumptions of the models (including choice of treatment and control rivers) no significant effect of wind farm construction was detected on the abundance of either adult or juvenile salmon.  The findings of this analysis should be interpreted in the context of the limited power of both the rod catch (adult abundance) and electrofishing (juvenile abundance) data to detect change. Specifically, there is a 1 in 5 chance that the wind farm could be depressing Atlantic salmon abundance in potentially affected rivers by as much as 40% without being detected.   In the current situation, where there is not an opportunity for obtaining greater predevelopment baseline information, the collection of additional electrofishing data does not improve the chances of detecting an effect of the wind farm beyond that already provided by the rod catch data (a freely available resource collated by Marine Scotland Science).  Given the associated costs, it is suggested that the collection of additional electrofishing data is therefore unwarranted at the present time.  Given the remaining uncertainty and the (small) improvements in statistical power provided by longer runs of data, it is suggested that the rod catch data should continue to be monitored and assessed.  If, in the future, rod catch data suggest a substantial decline in adult numbers returning to the rivers to the north-east of the wind farm relative to those on the Irish Sea side, then collection of supplementary electrofishing data may be justified.  It is recommended that prior to a future offshore development situational-specific power analyses should be performed and a decision made with regard to the amounts and types of data to be collected.","author":["Thorley, J."],"organization":["Poisson Consulting","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2013-02-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.750000000000","-3.716667000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2025-04-11 10:56:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/thorleyetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1331","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/population-trends-breeding-seabird-colonies-scottish-spas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/publications\/population-trends-breeding-seabirds-colonies-scottish-spas\/","title":"Population Trends of Breeding Seabird Colonies in Scottish SPAs","description":"In accordance with the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and Habitats Regulation Appraisal (HRA) developers need to consider the impacts of a plan or project on Special Protection Areas (SPA) populations where there is the potential for an interaction to exist. At present there is no single source of information that identifies the best available population trends of SPA breeding populations to inform this process. As a result there is often inconsistent population estimates with high degrees of uncertainty used in impact assessments. The application of various approaches to EIA and HRA places additional resourcing requirements on Marine Scotland and their statutory nature conservation advisors who will review each approach adopted. To address this issue Marine Scotland commissioned Natural Power Consultants (NPC) to undertake a review of extant data on SPA breeding populations around the Scottish Coast to:     Provide an overview of current data availability for key seabird species relevant to offshore renewable developments at SPA\u2019s for which they are designated.   Demonstrate evidence for any population trends in species on an SPA basis with a view to estimating current population sizes if possible.  Provide a resource detailing the allocation of data from colony counts from JNCC to specific SPA colonies.","author":["Lye, G.","Lewis, M.","Malcolm, F."],"organization":["Natural Power","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2012-07-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.532476300000","-1.645239700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/malcolmetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1332","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/population-sizes-seabirds-breeding-scottish-special-protection-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/publications\/population-sizes-seabirds-breeding-scottish-special-protection-areas\/","title":"Population Sizes of Seabirds breeding in Scottish Special Protection Areas","description":"For proposed renewable developments in the marine environment, accurate SPA population estimates are required to inform the EIA process. Citation data for SPAs are often out of date as much of it is from the early 1990s, with some of it dating back to as early as 1970. As such, Natural Power Consultants (NPC) was commissioned by Marine Scotland to collate existing data on SPA populations breeding around the Scottish coast (from JNCC, SNH, RSPB \u0026amp; other sources), with a view to:    Provide a single source of information on the current SPA breeding population levels specifically for renewables  Provide any information on trends obtainable from these data  Fill the \u2018data gap\u2019 between Seabird 2000 and the next national seabird census (likely to be between 2013 and 2015)   It is of key importance to note that the purpose of this collation of data for Marine Scotland is to help inform renewable developers, rather than acting as a specific review of SPAs.  The task was originally to include all features of \u2018SPAs with marine components\u2019. However, a \u2018marine component\u2019 of an SPA refers to a species that is dependent on a marine habitat, such as a sea inlet, estuary or mud flats, or salt marsh. A total of 119 species of birds are listed by JNCC as being dependent on marine environments, including wildfowl, divers, grebes, waders, true seabirds, and certain species that can occupy littoral habitats such as short-eared owl, kingfisher, and twite. Therefore, Marine Scotland focused the scope of the work towards species which are more frequently recorded in locations proposed for offshore renewable developments (offshore wind, wave \u0026amp; tidal schemes), the list of species to be considered was restricted to SPA populations of true seabirds (petrels, shearwaters, northern gannet, great cormorants, skuas, gulls, terns, and auks) that relied on marine habitats during the breeding season.","author":["Walls, R.","Lye, G.","Lewis, M.","Pendlebury, C."],"organization":["Natural Power","Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2012-07-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.532476300000","-1.645239700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/lewisetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1333","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/population-consequences-displacement-proposed-offshore-wind-energy-developments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www2.gov.scot\/Topics\/marine\/marineenergy\/Research\/SB7\/FinalReport","title":"Population Consequences of Displacement from Proposed Offshore Wind Energy Developments for Seabirds Breeding at Scottish SPAs","description":"The aim of this project was to develop a model to estimate the population consequences of displacement from proposed offshore wind energy developments for key species of seabirds breeding at SPAs in proximity to proposed Forth\/Tay offshore wind farm developments.  The steering group identified five seabird species for which displacement modelling was required in support of HRA\/AA for Forth\/Tay developments: black-legged kittiwakes Rissa tridactyla; common guillemot Uria aalge; razorbill Alca torda; Atlantic puffin Fratercula arctica; northern gannet Morus bassanus.  The steering group agreed that the SPAs to be considered in this report were Buchan Ness to Collieston Coast SPA, Fowsheugh SPA, Forth Islands SPA and St Abb\u2019s Head to Fastcastle SPA. \uf0b7 We considered impacts of displacement on population size operating via two main processes: reduced survival of offspring during the breeding season, and reduced body mass of adults leading to lower survival in the following winter. \uf0b7 Displacement effects are of two main types: the effects of displacement of birds that intended to forage in the wind farm, and the effects of the wind farm acting as a barrier to movement of birds intending to forage beyond the wind farm.  This study is, to our knowledge, the most comprehensive assessment of the population level consequences of displacement for seabirds to date. Displacement effects have been considered to potentially impact on chick survival. What has been less widely appreciated is that impacts on adult survival are also possible, mediated via changes in body condition. Declines in adult and chick survival were recorded for some species\/wind farm\/SPA combinations that matched expectations in terms of foraging range, foraging costs and wind farm location relative to SPAs. The model had to make a number of assumptions that would benefit from parameterisation with local data, in particular prey distribution, behaviour of seabirds in response to wind farms (including habituation) and effects of adult body mass change on subsequent survival.","author":["Searle, K.","Daunt, F.","Wanless, S.","Butler, A.","Mobbs, D.","Bogdanova, M.","Freeman, S."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science","Scottish Government","UK Centre for Ecology \u0026 Hydrology (CEH)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2014-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.000000000000","-2.000000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/searleetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1334","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/population-dynamics-white-tailed-eagle-shore-wind-farm-area-coastal-norway","sourceURL":"https:\/\/brage.bibsys.no\/xmlui\/handle\/11250\/245556","title":"Population dynamics in white-tailed eagle at an on-shore wind farm area in coastal Norway","description":"Collision with turbines and disturbance leading to loss of or reduced habitat quality are the two main impacts from wind energy development on birds. In addition, wind farms can act as barriers to birds. The conflict between birds and wind farms are highly site-, season- and species-specific. Among the most vulnerable group of birds are the raptorial species. Large soaring birds have proven to be particularly vulnerable to collision with turbines. In this thesis I aimed to test if a 68-turbine wind farm on the island of Sm\u00f8la, mid-Norway, was in conflict with a population of white-tailed eagles breeding at high density. The white-tailed eagle is a species with slow reproduction, long life span and high annual survival rates. These demographic characteristics make them particularly vulnerable to increased mortality. I found that the white-tailed eagle population was affected both by disturbance and collision mortality. Eagles did not significantly change their flight behavior when inside the wind farm, possibly explaining the relative high collision mortality. Territories close to the wind farm experienced reduced breeding success in the post-construction period compared to pre-construction. The effect was due to mortality and birds being displaced from their territories within the wind farm. Also, mortality among both sub-adult and adult birds was higher for birds with origin close to turbines compared to those originating further away from turbines. The growth rate in the population was reduced by the wind farm development, with the part of the population breeding close to the wind farm being most affected. Also, expected average age of adult birds in territories close to turbines was lower than for birds further away from turbines. Among the demographic parameters, adult survival was, by far, the most influential to the population growth rate. There was a clear spatial component in the impact from the wind farm on the white-tailed eagle population. The impact from mortality had a wider spatial component compared to the impact from disturbance. I traced the impact from increased mortality among adult eagles in territories out to 5 km from the turbines, while the reproductive success was reduced in territories out to 1 km from the turbines. It is therefore highly important to take into consideration both disturbance and mortality when planning future wind farm. As a last option, compensation measures can be an effective tool if avoidance and mitigation of avian conflicts in wind farms are non-efficient or too expensive. Electrocution prevention measures at a nearby power line were identified as a potential compensation project, compensating for white-tailed eagle mortality in the Sm\u00f8la wind farm.","author":["Dahl, E."],"organization":["Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["63.390010500000","7.940213900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1335","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-cause-chronic-stress-badgers-meles-meles-great-britain","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.jwildlifedis.org\/doi\/abs\/10.7589\/2015-09-231","title":"Wind turbines cause chronic stress in badgers (Meles meles) in Great Britain","description":"A paucity of data exists with which to assess the effects of wind turbines noise on terrestrial wildlife, despite growing concern about the impact of infrasound from wind farms on human health and well-being. In 2013, we assessed whether the presence of turbines in Great Britain impacted the stress levels of badgers (Meles meles) in nearby setts. Hair cortisol levels were used to determine if the badgers were physiologically stressed. Hair of badgers living \u0026lt;1 km from a wind farm had a 264% higher cortisol level than badgers \u0026gt;10 km from a wind farm. This demonstrates that affected badgers suffer from enhanced hypothalamo-pituitary-adrenal activity and are physiologically stressed. No differences were found between the cortisol levels of badgers living near wind farms operational since 2009 and 2012, indicating that the animals do not become habituated to turbine disturbance. Cortisol levels in the affected badgers did not vary in relation to the distance from turbines within 1 km, wind farm annual power output, or number of turbines. We suggest that the higher cortisol levels in affected badgers is caused by the turbines\u0027 sound and that these high levels may affect badgers\u0027 immune systems, which could result in increased risk of infection and disease in the badger population.","author":["Smith, V.","Agnew, R.","Fowkes, R."],"organization":["University of London","Zoological Society of London","University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2016-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.423222000000","-2.619869000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1336","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/co-location-passive-gear-fisheries-offshore-wind-farms-german-eez-north-sea-first","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479716305655","title":"Co-location of passive gear fisheries in offshore wind farms in the German EEZ of the North Sea: A first socio-economic scoping","description":"Worldwide the renewable energy sector is expanding at sea to address increasing demands. Recently the race for space in heavily used areas such as the North Sea triggered the proposal of co-locating other activities such as aquaculture or fisheries with passive gears in offshore wind farms (OWFs). Our interdisciplinary approach combined a quantification of spatial overlap of activities by using Vessel Monitoring System and logbook data with a stakeholder consultation to conclude and verify on the actual feasibility of co-location. In the German Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) of the North Sea up to 90% of Danish and 40% of German annual gilinet fleet landings of plaice overlapped with areas where OWFs are developed. Our results indicated further that the international gilinet fishery could lose up to 50% in landings within the North Sea German EEZ when OWF areas are closed entirely for fisheries. No spatial overlap was found for UK potters targeting brown crab in the German EEZ. We further identified a number of key issues and obstacles that to date hinder an actual implementation of co-location as a measure in the marine spatial planning process: defining the legal base; implementation of safety regulations; delineation of minimum requirements for fishing vessels such as capacities, quotas, technical equipment; implementation of a licensing process; and scoping for financial subsidies to set up business. The stakeholder consultation verified the scientific findings and highlighted that all those points need to be addressed in a planning process. In the German EEZ we have shown that the socioeconomic importance of spatial overlap varies within planning boundaries. Therefore we recommend an interdisciplinary bottom-up approach when scoping for suitable areas of co-location. Hence, an informed marine spatial planning process requires comprehensive and spatial explicit socio-economic viability studies factoring in also ecological effects of OWFs on target species.","author":["Berkenhagen, J.","Schulze, T.","Buck, B.","Krause, G.","Kloppmann, M.","Stelzenm\u00fcller, V.","Diekmann, R.","Bastardie, F.","Pogoda, B.","Kraus, G."],"organization":["Thunen Instititute","Technical University of Denmark (DTU)","Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)","SeaKult","University of Applied Sciences Bremerhaven"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.000000000000","6.000000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1337","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-strategic-framework-stage-3-stakeholder-participation-feedback","sourceURL":"https:\/\/mresf.rpsgroup.com\/Resources%2fDocuments%2fSPP%20and%20Public%20Documents%2fPublic%20Resources%2fStage%203%2fStakeholder%20Participation%20Process%2fStakeholder%20Participation%20Feedback%20(December%202010).pdf","title":"Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework: Stage 3 - Stakeholder Participation Feedback","description":"This document reports on the results of the Stage 3 Stakeholder Participation Process for the \u2018Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework\u2019 (MRESF) for Wales; a three stage project currently being undertaken by RPS within Welsh territorial waters on behalf of the Welsh Assembly Government. The MRESF is aimed at exploring and enabling the potential for renewable energy extraction from Welsh waters, with the intention being to minimise impacts on environmental resources and socio-economic activities, while maximising the potential for sustainable energy production. Stakeholder participation forms a key part of Stage 3, providing stakeholders with an opportunity to comment on and provide input to the proposed methodology for the development of the MRESF Framework. The Stakeholder Participation Process (SPP) commenced on 10th June 2010 and ran for 8 weeks, ending on 4th August 2010. A total of 113 organisations were contacted, with stakeholder participation invited through two main routes: via the stakeholder questionnaire; and two workshops. Feedback from the SPP will be incorporated appropriately into the development of the MRESF. Several of the comments made by stakeholders have been addressed where possible within this report.  The Approach to Sustainable Development Report presents the final outputs of the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework (MRESF). The MRESF will be an essential management tool for the sustainable development of wave and tidal energy in Wales.","author":["RPS group"],"organization":["RPS group","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2010-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Welsh-MRESF-Stake-Feedback.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1338","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-strategic-framework-stage-3-stakeholder-participation-process","sourceURL":"https:\/\/mresf.rpsgroup.com\/Resources%2fDocuments%2fSPP%20and%20Public%20Documents%2fPublic%20Resources%2fStage%203%2fStakeholder%20Participation%20Process%2fStakeholder%20Participation%20Process%20(December%202010).pdf","title":"Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework: Stage 3 - Stakeholder Participation Process","description":"This document has been compiled to facilitate stakeholder participation on the \u2019Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework\u2019 (MRESF) for Wales; a three stage project currently being undertaken by RPS within Welsh territorial waters on behalf of the Welsh Assembly Government. The MRESF is aimed at exploring and enabling the potential for renewable energy extraction from Welsh waters, with the intention being to minimise impacts on environmental resources and socio-economic activities, while maximising the potential for sustainable energy production to be gained from Welsh waters. The MRESF project forms part of the Welsh Assembly Government\u2019s commitment to promoting economic development of Welsh waters in a truly sustainable manner, and through such, achieving Wales\u2019 ambitions for low carbon energy generation and the significant contribution marine energy can make to meeting carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gas emission reduction targets.  The MRESF work programme is divided into three stages. Stages 1 and 2 have been undertaken over the past 2 years, with the project outputs from these precursor steps laying the foundation for Stage 3. Stage 3 will now progress through 2010 to develop and deliver the overarching Framework. The focus of this stakeholder participation is the proposed methodology for developing the Framework, with the aim of this document being to support and inform the process.   The Approach to Sustainable Development Report presents the final outputs of the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework (MRESF). The MRESF will be an essential management tool for the sustainable development of wave and tidal energy in Wales.","author":["RPS group"],"organization":["RPS group","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2010-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Welsh-MRESF-Stake-Participation.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1339","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-strategic-framework-review-policy-context-sustainable-marine","sourceURL":"","title":"Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework: Review of the Policy Context for Sustainable Marine Renewable Development","description":"The Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework project has investigated the potential marine renewable energy resource of Welsh Territorial Waters (TWs) and considered potential scenarios for the sustainable development of that resource primarily as an aid to policy development and also an indicator of resource for potential developers. The project has been undertaken by RPS Group in three stages, starting in 2007 with Stage 1, which was focused on the initial literature reviews, data gathering, stakeholder engagement and GIS mapping. Stage 2 was conducted primarily in 2009-2010 and involved a number of discrete reports, each aimed at increasing the knowledge base for a number of key data gaps in Welsh TWs identified as part of Stage 1. Stage 3 has drawn on the findings of Stages 1 and 2 to develop the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework: Approach to Sustainable Development.   This section of Stage 3 provides a review of policy context for sustainable marine renewable development. In order to achieve \u0022a sustainable, innovative and productive economy\u0022, the UK Government, Scottish Executive, Welsh Assembly Government and Northern Ireland Administration have agreed on a set of five shared principles for sustainable development and four priority areas for immediate action. They are as follows:    Sustainable Consumption and Production,  Climate Change and Energy,  Natural Resource Protection and Environmental Enhancement, and  Sustainable Communities.","author":["McGarry, T."],"organization":["RPS group","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2011-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Welsh-MRESF-Stage3-Policy.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1340","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-risk-marine-mammals-underwater-marine-renewable-devices-welsh-waters-phase","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.semanticscholar.org\/paper\/Assessment-of-Risk-to-Marine-Mammals-from-Marine-in-Wilson\/c77a821f056173b98e38135b469c246b3fa690d3","title":"Assessment of Risk to Marine Mammals from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters: Phase 1 - Desktop Review of Marine Mammals and Risks from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters","description":"The Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework for Wales (MRESF) is seeking to provide for the sustainable development of marine renewable energy in Welsh waters. As one of the recommendations from the Stage 1 study, a requirement for further evaluation of potential environmental impacts on marine mammals from marine renewable devices was identified. This report summarises information on marine mammals that frequent those areas within Welsh waters with high tidal currents identified as likely candidate sites for tidal turbine installations. The types of devices that are being developed are briefly reviewed and an assessment of the range of potential hazards that these could pose for marine mammals is made. Particular emphasis is placed on collision risk, which is considered to be one of the most significant hazards. Physical, biological and behavioural factors that might affect the probability and severity of collisions are reviewed and comments are offered on the likely sensitivity of different species and regions. Potential strategies for mitigation and knowledge gaps that need to be addressed are also discussed.   The Approach to Sustainable Development Report presents the final outputs of the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework (MRESF). The MRESF will be an essential management tool for the sustainable development of wave and tidal energy in Wales.","author":["Gordon, J.","Wilson, B."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","RPS group","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2011-03-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Collision","Changes in Flow","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-03 11:38:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Welsh-MRESF-Stage2-Phase1-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1341","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-strategic-framework-wales-stage-1-report-final","sourceURL":"https:\/\/mresf.rpsgroup.com\/Resources%2fDocuments%2fSPP%20and%20Public%20Documents%2fPublic%20Resources%2fStage%201%2fMRESF%20Stage%201%20-%20Report%20Nov%202008.pdf","title":"Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework for Wales: Stage 1 Report Final","description":"RPS was commissioned by the Welsh Assembly Government (WAG) to undertake work towards the development of a \u2018Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework\u00a0for Wales (MRESF). The project forms part of WAGs commitment to strong economic development combined with sustainable growth and prosperity. The work programme is broadly divided into three stages, with the current report describing the outputs from Stage 1. The outputs achieved during Stage 1 can be summarised as follows:\nTo describe and, where possible, map in GIS the existing natural and human environmental baseline for Welsh waters (including the wind, wave and tidal resource);\nDetermine current understanding of environmental impacts (potential and known);\nIdentify development constraints; and\nIdentification of the key constraints on development arising from information gaps, with a brief method to address these issues.\nFollowing discussion and agreement with the Steering Group, Stage 2 is anticipated to take the key constraints forward with the aim of addressing the issues. The final stage, Stage 3, will build on the findings of Stages 1 and 2, aiming towards the development of a strategic approach to the deployment of marine renewable energy technologies in Wales, with the intention of meeting energy targets in a sustainable manner.\n\nThe\u00a0Approach to Sustainable Development Report\u00a0presents the final outputs of the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework (MRESF). The MRESF will be an essential management tool for the sustainable development of wave and tidal energy in Wales.","author":["Kazer, S.","Golding, T."],"organization":["RPS group","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2008-11-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRESF-Stage1-2008.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1342","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-strategic-framework-approach-sustainable-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/mresf.rpsgroup.com\/Resources%2fDocuments%2fSPP%20and%20Public%20Documents%2fPublic%20Resources%2fStage%203%2fApproach%20to%20Sustainable%20Development%2fMRESF%20Stage%203%20-%20Approach%20to%20Sustainable%20Development%20March%202011.pdf","title":"Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework: Approach to Sustainable Development","description":"This report has been prepared by RPS on behalf of the Welsh Assembly Government (the WAG) as part of the development of the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework (MRESF). The MRESF project has been undertaken in three stages, with this report presenting a summary of the findings of the final part of Stage 3. The main aim of the MRESF project has been to investigate the potential marine renewable energy resource of Welsh Territorial Waters (TWs), and to consider potential scenarios for the sustainable development of that resource.   The current report provides a descriptive text to the final outputs of the MRESF, which are essentially a series of GIS maps that compare areas of potential wave and tidal stream resource with the level of existing development constraint. This report has been preceded by a number of documents, which laid the foundations for the Framework and provide the background for the overall assessment. The accompanying reports are summarised below:    Stage 1: Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework for Wales (2008)  Stage 2:     Collision Risk of Fish with Wave and Tidal Devices (2010)   The Potential for Interaction between Wave and Tidal Stream with Military Interests in Welsh Waters (2010)   Positive effects of wave and tidal energy devices. Literature review and desk study (2010)   Assessment of Risk to Marine Mammals from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters: Phase 1 - Desktop Review of Collision Risk to Marine Mammals from Underwater Devices in Welsh Waters (2011)   Assessment of Risk to Marine Mammals from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters: Phase 2 - Studies of Marine Mammals in Welsh High Tide Waters (2011)       Annex I: Movements and Diving Behaviour of Juvenile Grey Seals in Areas of High Tidal Energy (2012)         Assessment of Risk to Diving Birds from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters: Phase 1 - Desktop Review of Birds in Welsh Waters and Preliminary Risk Assessment (2011)   Assessment of Risk to Diving Birds from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters: Phase 2 - Field Methodologies and Site Assessments (2011)      Stage 3:     Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework for Wales: Stakeholder Participation Process (2010)   Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework for Wales: Stakeholder Participation Feedback (2010)   Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework: Review of the Policy Context for Sustainable Marine Renewable Development (2011)   Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework: Technical Addendum (2011)","author":["RPS group"],"organization":["RPS group","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2011-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Welsh-MRESF-March-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1343","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-risk-diving-birds-underwater-marine-renewable-devices-welsh-waters-phase-2","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.marineenergywales.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/01\/MRESF-Stage-2-Diving-Birds-and-Underwater-Renewable-Devices-Site-Surveys.pdf","title":"Assessment of Risk to Diving Birds from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters: Phase 2 - Field Methodologies and Site Assessments","description":"The Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework project has investigated the potential marine renewable energy resource of Welsh Territorial Waters (TWs) and considered potential scenarios for the sustainable development of that resource primarily as an aid to policy development and also an indicator of resource for potential developers. This report is Phase 2\u00a0of the Assessment of Risk to Diving Birds from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters and\u00a0presents seabird survey methods, suitable for collecting data to inform an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) at sites identified as suitable for wave and\/or tidal stream energy generation.\u00a0Methods were developed at two Welsh sites, Carmel Head, Anglesey and Ramsey Sound, Pembrokeshire. Because of the coastal nature of these sites, and the parallels between tidal energy extraction and wind turbines, the starting points for method development were vantage point surveys for birds (typically used in relation to proposed onshore wind farms), and boat surveys (typically used for offshore wind farm assessments).\n\nThe\u00a0Approach to Sustainable Development Report\u00a0presents the final outputs of the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework (MRESF). The MRESF will be an essential management tool for the sustainable development of wave and tidal energy in Wales.","author":["Robinson, C.","Cook, G."],"organization":["RPS group","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2011-02-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.483173000000","-5.088196000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Shorebirds","Waterfowl","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Welsh-Robinson-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1344","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-risk-diving-birds-underwater-marine-renewable-devices-welsh-waters-phase-1","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.marineenergywales.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/01\/MRESF-Stage-2-Diving-Birds-and-Underwater-Renewable-Devices-Desk-Top-Review.pdf","title":"Assessment of Risk to Diving Birds from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters: Phase 1 - Desktop Review of Birds in Welsh Waters and Preliminary Risk Assessment","description":"The Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework project has investigated the potential marine renewable energy resource of Welsh Territorial Waters (TWs) and considered potential scenarios for the sustainable development of that resource primarily as an aid to policy development and also an indicator of resource for potential developers. This report is Phase 1 of the Assessment of Risk to Diving Birds from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters and reviews potential risk to diving birds from marine underwater renewable energy devices (MUREDs). The review is based on the results of desktop research into device type and diving bird ecology, and also includes examination of existing Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs) of MUREDs, together with research from the European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC).\u00a0MUREDs considered in this report fall into two broad designs: tidal stream and wave power. Tidal stream devices are similar to submerged wind turbines and harness the energy of fast ocean currents around headlands, inlets and channels. The four categories of tidal stream device are: horizontal axis turbine, vertical axis turbine, oscillating hydrofoil and turbines which exploit the Venturi effect. Wave power devices are positioned on or near the sea surface and are driven by wave motion. The six categories of wave power device are: attenuators, point absorbers, oscillating wave surge converters, oscillating water columns (OWCs), overtopping devices and submerged pressure differentials.\u00a0\n\nA literature review presents the underwater ecology of 35 diving bird species occurring in Welsh waters. Species population and distribution are discussed, along with foraging range, foraging depth, dive profile, underwater vision and prey preferences. Species discussed are of conservation importance at an international or national scale due to their relative abundance in Welsh waters, their citation in internationally or nationally designated sites, or their legal protection status.\u00a0Potential risks to diving birds posed by these MUREDs are: direct habitat loss; displacement; risk of collision; risk of entrapment; and impacts arising from disturbance or displacement of prey.\u00a0Risk also increases with the size of device array \u2013 the greater the rotor-swept volume of water, the greater the risk. Risk also varies with exposure of the devices\u2019 moving parts: where moving parts are fully exposed risk will be higher than\u00a0where they are partially enclosed.\u00a0\n\nThis report therefore presents an extensive literature review of the underwater behaviour of diving birds. The aim is to inform assessment of the suite of species that are most at risk from the potential impacts of a specific wave or tidal development in Welsh offshore waters. Once identified, this suite of species would form the list of target bird species for baseline surveys during the EIA process. The trialling of survey methodologies appropriate for the collection of baseline EIA ornithology data is being undertaken as part of the second phase of this project.\n\nThe\u00a0Approach to Sustainable Development Report\u00a0presents the final outputs of the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework (MRESF). The MRESF will be an essential management tool for the sustainable development of wave and tidal energy in Wales.","author":["Austin, M.","Dewar, R.","Robinson, C.","Loughrey, J.","Sweeney, J."],"organization":["RPS group","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2011-02-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.483173000000","-5.088196000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Shorebirds","Waterfowl","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Welsh-Loughrey-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1345","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-risk-marine-mammals-underwater-marine-renewable-devices-welsh-waters-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.marineenergywales.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/01\/Resources2fDocuments2fSPP-and-Public-Documents2fPublic-Resources2fStage-22fMRESF-Stage-2-Phase-2-Studies-of-Marine-Mammals-in-Welsh-High-Tidal-Energy-Waters-Mar-2011.pdf","title":"Assessment of Risk to Marine Mammals from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters: Phase 2 - Studies of Marine Mammals in Welsh High Tidal Waters","description":"The Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework for Wales (MRESF) provides for the sustainable development of marine renewable energy in Welsh waters. Phase 2 of the\u00a0Assessment of Risk to Marine Mammals from Underwater Marine Renewable Devices in Welsh Waters provides additional baseline characterisation information on the occurrence and use of Welsh waters by marine mammals\u00a0to ensure that marine renewable energy developments occur with as little adverse environmental impact as possible. Cetaceans, which are European Protected Species (EPS) and seals, for which Special Areas of Conservation (SAC) have been designated close to and encompassing areas of tidal rapid in Wales,\u00a0are groups of particular interest, and for both there are concerns that they may suffer collisions with rotating turbine blades. In addition, turbines may act as barriers to movement, especially if many devices are deployed together in arrays. Marine mammals are often seen within tidal rapids and there are some observations that suggest that these can be important areas for them. However, our understanding of marine mammal distributions and behaviours within high tidal energy areas is actually very poor for two reasons. In the first place, tidal rapids are an extremely difficult environment in which to conduct research, especially when currents are running strongly, which is exactly the time when the potential risk of collision with turbines is greatest. Consequently, very little relevant quantitative data has been collected from these habitats. The second consideration is that these areas are a very small part of the range of any marine mammal species and are so unusual, that it is not possible to extrapolate from observations of densities or behaviour made on a much larger spatial scale outside these areas. The purpose of the project reported here was to undertake directed research on marine mammals at tidal rapid sites in Wales and to collect data relevant to assessing risks if tidal turbines were installed at these sites. As this was very much a new area of investigation a variety of research approaches were trialled and some new techniques were developed and tested.\u00a0  The\u00a0Approach to Sustainable Development Report\u00a0presents the final outputs of the Marine Renewable Energy Strategic Framework (MRESF). The MRESF will be an essential management tool for the sustainable development of wave and tidal energy in Wales.","author":["Gordon, J.","Thompson, D.","Gillespie, D.","Calderan, S.","Leaper, R.","Macaulay, J.","Pierpoint, C.","Gordon, T."],"organization":["Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","Welsh Government"],"originationDate":"2011-03-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.508553000000","-5.088241000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Pinnipeds"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-03 11:39:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Welsh-Gordon-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1346","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-cetacean-monitoring-guidelines-welsh-wave-tidal-energy-developments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.marineenergywales.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2016\/01\/SEACAMS-Nuuttila_Marine-mammal-guideline-review_final-report-2015.pdf","title":"Review of Cetacean Monitoring Guidelines for Welsh Wave and Tidal Energy Developments","description":"SEACAMS has been engaged on a collaborative project with Tidal Energy Limited (TEL) and Marine Current Turbines (MCT) with technical advice from NRW Marine Advisory Team to review existing marine mammal monitoring guidelines for marine renewable energy (MRE) industry, with particular reference to wave and tidal energy developments in Wales. The rationale for the project arose from the Natural Resources Wales (NRW) Marine Advisory Team and various developers\u2019 request to develop a user friendly, practical set of guidelines to cetacean monitoring at wave and tidal developments in order to reduce discrepancies in survey design and data collection methods in particular. This report is a first step in developing such guidelines for the developers, by reviewing existing information and standard methodologies used in Wales. The aim was to compile available information and summarising current understanding on issues related to cetacean monitoring at tidal sites in order to assist developers with survey design, methodologies used and data analysis and interpretation. Please note this report is not intended to be an exhaustive account of all types of survey and analytical methods appropriate for marine renewable energy sites. Additional information on designing surveys to monitor seals will be published in a follow up report. The project was divided into several discrete tasks: identifying existing marine mammal and specifically cetacean surveying guidelines, reviewing the identified guidelines and reports; approaching and interviewing stakeholders (developers, consultants and marine mammal observers) for their opinions on current guidelines and practices and finally compiling these into one coherent report.","author":["Nuuttila, H."],"organization":["Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2015-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SEACAMS-Nuuttila-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1347","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/human-pressures-uk-seabed-habitats-cumulative-impact-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v428\/p33-47\/","title":"Human pressures on UK seabed habitats: a cumulative impact assessment","description":"European Member States are required to assess the status of marine waters, including analysis of cumulative effects. We developed a methodology for evaluating the impact of several human activities that constitute 4 direct pressures on the UK (England and Wales) seabed community: smothering, abrasion, obstruction (sealing), and extraction. The method was tested by mapping the spatial extent of individual and cumulative activities for 2007 by habitat type, quantifying the intensity of activities, and estimating impact using published recovery times. More than half (134400 km2) of the seabed was directly affected by human activities, of which only 165 km2 (\u0026lt;0.1%) was occupied by multiple activities. Benthic fishing accounted for 99.6% of the spatial footprint. Sensitivity to the pressures of human activities varied by habitat type, with estimated recovery times ranging from \u0026lt;1 mo for otter trawling in sand, to ~15 yr for co-occurring aggregate extraction and dredge material disposal in low-energy gravel habitat. Fully integrated, dynamically-linked environmental assessments are generally considered desirable for greater scientific understanding of an ecosystem. The methodology we present for quantifying cumulative effects is a step towards this. However, our findings indicate that a limited number of activities were the predominant cause of widespread, long recovery times of benthic fauna. This suggests that when time and resources are limited, single sector assessment rather than detailed evaluation of cumulative effects, can still usefully guide management. As the observed cumulative effects were primarily related to a few activities, it might reasonably be argued that management effort should be focused on spatially extensive activities, such as benthic fishing to mitigate most of the human impact on the UK seabed.","author":["Jones, A.","Rogers, S.","Foden, J."],"organization":["University of East Anglia","Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)"],"originationDate":"2011-05-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1348","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/oceanographic-drivers-marine-mammal-seabird-habitat-use-across-shelf-seas-guide-key","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0272771417309587#bib81","title":"Oceanographic drivers of marine mammal and seabird habitat-use across shelf-seas: A guide to key features and recommendations for future research and conservation management","description":"Mid-latitude (\u223c30-60\u00b0) seasonally stratifying shelf-seas support a high abundance and diversity of marine predators such as\u00a0marine mammals\u00a0and\u00a0seabirds. However,\u00a0anthropogenic activities\u00a0and\u00a0climate change impacts\u00a0are driving changes in the distributions and\u00a0population dynamics\u00a0of these animals, with negative consequences for\u00a0ecosystem functioning. Across mid-latitude shelf-seas marine mammals and seabirds are known to\u00a0forage\u00a0across a number of oceanographic habitats that structure the spatio-temporal distributions of prey fields. Knowledge of these and the bio-physical mechanisms driving such associations are needed to improve marine management and policy. Here, we provide a concise and easily accessible guide for both researchers and managers of marine systems on the predominant oceanographic habitats that are favoured for\u00a0foraging\u00a0by marine mammals and seabirds across mid-latitude shelf-seas. We (1) identify and describe key discrete physical features present across the\u00a0continental shelf, working inshore from the shelf-edge to the shore line, (2) provide an overview of findings relating to associations between these habitats and marine mammals and seabirds, (3) identify areas for future research and (4) discuss the relevance of such information to\u00a0conservation management. We show that\u00a0oceanographic features\u00a0preferentially foraged at by marine mammals and seabirds include shelf-edge fronts,\u00a0upwellingand tidal-mixing fronts, offshore banks and\u00a0internal waves, regions of stratification, and topographically complex coastal areas subject to strong tidal flow. Whilst associations were variable across taxa and through space and time, in the majority of cases interactions between\u00a0bathymetry\u00a0and\u00a0tidal currents\u00a0appear to play a dominant role, alongside patterns in seasonal stratification and shelf-edge upwelling. We suggest that the ecological significance of these bio-physical structures\u00a0stemsfrom a capacity to alter the\u00a0densities, distributions\u00a0(both horizontally and vertically) and\/or behaviours of prey in a persistent and\/or predictable manner that increases accessibility for predators, and likely enhances foraging efficiency. Future conservation management should aim to preserve and protect these habitats. This will require adaptive and holistic strategies that are specifically tailored to the characteristics of an oceanographic feature, and where necessary, evolve through space and time in response to spatio-temporal variability. Improved monitoring\u00a0of animal movements\u00a0and bio-physical conditions across shelf-seas would aid in this. Areas for future research include multi-disciplinary\/trophic studies of the mechanisms linking bio-physical processes, prey and marine mammals and seabirds (which may elucidate the importance of lesser studied features such as bottom fronts and\u00a0Langmuir circulation\u00a0cells), alongside a better understanding of how predators perceive their environment and develop foraging strategies during immature\/juvenile stages. Estimates of the importance of oceanographic habitat features at a population level should also be obtained. Such information is vital to ensuring the future health of these complex ecosystems, and can be used to assess how anthropogenic activities and future environmental changes will impact the functioning and spatio-temporal dynamics of these bio-physical features and their use by marine predators.","author":["Hosegood, P.","Votier, S.","Embling, C.","Cox, S.","Ingram, S."],"organization":["Plymouth University","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2018-11-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1349","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/empirical-measures-harbor-seal-behavior-avoidance-operational-tidal-turbine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X18306222","title":"Empirical measures of harbor seal behavior and avoidance of an operational tidal turbine","description":"There is global interest in marine renewable energy from underwater tidal turbines. Due to overlap in animal habitat with locations for tidal turbines, the potential for collisions has led to concern around strike risk. Using data from tagged harbor seals collected before construction and after operation of the SeaGen tidal turbine in Northern Ireland, this study quantifies risks of an operational turbine to harbor seals by taking into account turbine characteristics, tidal state, and seal behavior. We found 68% spatial avoidance (95% C.I., 37%, 83%) by harbor seals within 200\u202fm of the turbine. When additionally accounting for variation in seal occupancy over depth and tidal flows, there is an overall reduction in collision risk from 1.29 to 0.125 seals per tidal cycle (90.3% reduction; (95% C.I., 83%, 98%)) compared to risk calculated under assumptions of uniform habitat use. This demonstrates the need to incorporate environmental conditions to properly assess strike risk.","author":["Copping, A.","Tollit, D.","Wood, J.","Sparling, C.","McConnell, B.","Joy, R."],"organization":["Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","Simon Fraser University","Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.368700000000","-5.545820000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1350","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ornithodolite-tool-quantify-animal-space-use-habitat-selection-case-study-birds-diving","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/1749-4877.12327","title":"The Ornithodolite as a tool to quantify animal space use and habitat selection: a case study with birds diving in tidal waters","description":"Animal\u2010attached technologies can be powerful means to quantify space\u2010use and behaviour, however, there are also ethical implications associated with capturing and instrumenting animals. Furthermore, tagging approaches are not necessarily well\u2010suited for examining the movements of multiple individuals within specific, local areas of interest. Here, we assess a method of quantifying animal space use based on a modified theodolite with an inbuilt laser rangefinder. Using a database of \u0026gt; 4,200 tracks of migrating birds, we show that detection distance increases with bird body mass (range 5 g \u2013 \u0026gt;10 kg). The maximum distance recorded to a bird was 5500 m and measurement error was \u2264 5 m for targets within this distance range; a level comparable to methods such as GPS tagging. We go on to present a case study where this method was used to assess habitat selection in seabirds operating in dynamic coastal waters close to a tidal turbine. Combining positional data with outputs from a hydrographic model revealed that great cormorants (Phalacrocorax carbo) appeared to be highly selective of current characteristics in space and time; exploiting areas where mean current speeds were \u0026lt; 0.8 m s\u22121, and diving at times when turbulent energy levels were low. These birds also orientated into tidal currents during dives. Taken together, this suggests that collision risks are low for cormorants at this site, as the two conditions avoided by cormorants (high mean current speeds and turbulence levels), are associated with operational tidal turbines. Overall, we suggest that this modified theodolite system is well\u2010suited to the quantification of movement in small areas associated with particular development strategies, including sustainable energy devices.","author":["Waggitt, J.","Hedenstrom, A.","Piano, M.","Shepard, E.","Cole, E.","Holton, M.","Borger, L."],"organization":["Swansea University","Bangor University","Lund University"],"originationDate":"2018-05-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.878440000000","-5.310667000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1351","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/providing-ecological-context-anthropogenic-subsea-noise-assessing-listening-space","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032118308190","title":"Providing ecological context to anthropogenic subsea noise: Assessing listening space reductions of marine mammals from tidal energy devices","description":"The deployment of tidal energy arrays is gaining momentum to provide marine renewable energy (MRE) to the global market. However, there are concerns over the potential impacts underwater noise emissions from operational devices may have on marine fauna. Auditory masking (the interference of important biological signals by anthropogenic noise) is a highly pervasive impact to marine fauna. We used a relatively new approach to evaluate the effects of noise from operational tidal energy devices on the listening space of marine mammals. Here, listening space reductions (LSR) for harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) and harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) were assessed in winter and summer for two tidal energy devices of different designs. Results demonstrated that LSR was influenced by type of turbine, species, and season. For instance, LSRs for harbour seals were in excess of 80% within 60\u202fm, whilst for harbour porpoises they were in excess of 55% within 10\u202fm of the devices. For both species, LSRs were highest during winter, characterised by low ambient noise conditions. These findings highlight the importance of assessing masking over seasons, as masking effects are highly influenced by ambient noise conditions. Understanding the natural variation within seasons is also particularly relevant for tidal turbine noise assessments as devices are typically situated in highly dynamic environments. Since masking effects occur at the lower level of behavioural impacts in marine mammals, assessing the spatial extent of masking as part of environmental impact assessments is recommended. The listening space formula, which is largely based on measurable environmental factors (device and ambient noise), is transferable to any MRE device, or arrays, for any species (for which an audiogram can be assumed) and therefore provides an effective method to better inform MRE pre- and post-consenting processes.","author":["Pine, M.","Schmitt, P.","Kregting, L.","Lieber, L.","Culloch, R."],"organization":["University of Victoria","Queen\u0027s University Belfast"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.385000000000","-5.571944000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1352","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-local-environmental-impacts-salinity-gradient-energy-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032118307986","title":"Potential local environmental impacts of salinity gradient energy: A review","description":"Marine\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0development aims to harness the vast resources of the coastal environment to meet growing\u00a0energy demands. Among the variety of coastal energy sources,\u00a0salinity gradient\u00a0energy (SGE) technology captures the energy released from the controlled mixing of waters of different salinities found naturally in estuarine systems or in other combinations of anthropogenic sources of brine and\u00a0fresh waters. Although SGE technology is in the pilot stage of development, there is currently no comprehensive published assessment of its\u00a0environmental impacts. This assessment uses research from proxy facilities and pilot SGE projects to predict impacts of an SGE facility through\u00a0construction, operation and decommission phases. Construction and decommission of an SGE facility is expected to disrupt habitat and organisms via noise, land modification, and release of pollutants, similar to other coastal facilities such as\u00a0desalination plants\u00a0or water intake cooling structures. During operation, however, impacts unique to SGE result from intake of both high- and low-salinity waters, which in natural sources will involve\u00a0impingement, entrainment, and chemical treatment to reduce\u00a0biofouling. In addition, SGE effluent is expected to be of lower salinity and higher volume than effluent from a desalination plant, thereby posing unique risks to discharge sites. This review highlights areas of concern and lack of knowledge, which can guide\u00a0environmental impact assessment\u00a0and monitoring priorities of site managers.","author":["Dubbs, L.","Seyfried, C.","Palko, H.."],"organization":["University of North Carolina"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Salinity Gradient"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1353","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/energy-socio-economic-benefits-development-wave-energy-greece","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096014811831070X","title":"Energy and socio-economic benefits from the development of wave energy in Greece","description":"The study quantifies socio-economic benefits by the integration of wave energy in Greece, through resource examination, availability and deployment considerations. Greece has a large number of inhabited islands that mostly utilise conventional fuels for power generation, inclusion of wave energy will contribute both in terms of energy independence but also in job creation. The Greek region is often overlooked, due to its lower resources, but through proper converter selection energy benefits can be significant. Furthermore, milder resources offer opportunities for capital expenditure reductions, hence reducing cost of device and energy.\u00a0\n\n\nScenarios consider technological maturity, legislation, and resource potential to quantify future cumulative installations that can be developed. If a\u00a0wave energy converter\u00a0(WEC) is selected properly, accounting for climate variability and persistence, currently several WEC designs can operate at capacity factors near at from 20%. Based on a resource and availability assessment, the learning rates from an incremental approach are more suitable and allow cost reductions. Job creation targets island regions where majority of exploitable resource is located and can provide up to 1400 direct jobs. Adaptation of wave energy by Greece has the potential to offer major technological, energy and employment benefits.","author":["Lavidas, G."],"organization":["Delft University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2019-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.120917600000","21.602974200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1354","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-selection-net-zero-energy-communities-life-cycle-based-decision","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118307389#bib24","title":"Renewable energy selection for net-zero energy communities: Life cycle based decision making under uncertainty","description":"Developing net-zero energy communities powered by\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0(RE) resources has become a popular concept. To make the best choices for community-level net-zero energy systems, it is necessary to identify the best\u00a0energy technologies\u00a0at local level. Evaluation of RE technologies has to be extended from technical and economic aspects to include environmental and social wellbeing. It is possible to identify the true costs and benefits of\u00a0energy use\u00a0by taking a cradle-to-grave life cycle perspective. In this study, a RE screening and\u00a0multi-stage\u00a0energy selection framework was developed. A fuzzy\u00a0multi-criteria decision making\u00a0approach was used in ranking the technologies to incorporate the conflicting requirements, stakeholder priorities, and uncertainties. Different scenarios were investigated to reflect different decision maker priorities. Under a pro-environment scenario,\u00a0small hydro,\u00a0onshore wind, and\u00a0biomass\u00a0combustion technologies perform best. Under a pro-economic decision scenario, biomass combustion, small hydro, and landfill gas have the best rankings. Triple bottom line sustainability was combined with\u00a0technical feasibility\u00a0through a ruled-based approach to avoid the theoretical pitfalls inherent in energy-related\u00a0decision making. This assessment is geared towards providing decision makers with flexible tools, and is expected to aid in the pre-project planning stage of RE projects.\n\nHighlights:\nEnergy planning needs to be done at community level for optimal outcomes.\nConsidering life cycle impacts and uncertainty is important in energy planning.\nDifferent decision scenarios were considered in selecting technologies.\nSmall hydro and biomass perform particularly well for British Columbia.\nThe developed method provides decision makers with flexible planning tools.","author":["Karunathilake, H.","Hewage, K.","Merida, W.","Sadiq, R."],"organization":["University of British Columbia"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1355","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/regional-variation-public-acceptance-wind-energy-development-europe-what-are-roles","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0264837718309220","title":"Regional variation in public acceptance of wind energy development in Europe: What are the roles of planning procedures and participation?","description":"The successful transition towards renewable energy (RE) technologies is closely intertwined with various societal aspects. Wind energy (WE) is one of the most controversial RE-types, possibly due to the multiplicity of related public concerns. Although some European country-comparisons exist, research concerning acceptance factors in different political and cultural planning contexts is scarce, especially in Eastern and Southern Europe. This paper explores the variation of (1) acceptance issues across Europe, and (2) patterns of strategic and local planning in affecting WE acceptance. We conducted an expert survey among the members of the COST Action \u2018Renewable Energy and Landscape Quality\u2019 and the association Wind Energy Europe. We found that acceptance issues \u2013 as perceived by the experts \u2013 across different regions in Europe share certain similarities, such as concerns about landscape impacts. The priority-levels of acceptance issues are specific to each region and link to the planning quality in that context. Planners\u2019 and decision-makers\u2019 increased awareness about the diversity of acceptance issues would allow them to design more appropriate strategic and local planning processes.\n\nHighlights:\nWe conducted an\u00a0expert survey\u00a0about\u00a0wind energy\u00a0resistancein planning.\nResistance links to planning quality in four supra-national European regions.\nLandscape encroachment is a major reason for resistance in most European regions.\nLack of\u00a0social justice\u00a0ranks high in East- and South-Europe.\nComprehensive strategic planning potentially reduces problems with resistance.","author":["Martinat, S.","Suskevics, M.","Eiter, S.","Stober, D.","Vollmer, E.","de Boer, C.","Buchecker, M."],"organization":["Estonian University of Life Sciences","Norwegian Institute of Bioeconomy Research (NIBIO)","Cardiff University","Czech Academy of Sciences","University of Osijek","University of Twente","Swiss Federal Research Institute WSL"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1356","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-targeting-synergies-scale-exploring-criteria-smart-practices-siting-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421518303355","title":"Spatial targeting, synergies and scale: Exploring the criteria of smart practices for siting renewable energy projects","description":"Policies and strategies to develop\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0and the rates of successful deployment vary from country to country. Academic literature is rife with examples of recurring problems and malpractice in the implementation of renewable energy projects. We could see each national and\u00a0sectoral\u00a0effort as an \u2018experiment\u2019 in the early phase of our attempted transition to a low\u00a0carbon energy system. What lessons can we learn from a\u00a0comparative analysis\u00a0of these experiments? This paper seeks to draw generic lessons not from what has gone wrong but from national\u00a0case studies\u00a0that stand out in a best way. Through a European academic network, we have selected and analysed 51 \u2018smart practice\u2019 case studies of renewable energy development from 20 countries. We present the outcomes of both\u00a0qualitative and quantitative analysis of these case studies (smart practice criteria) and discuss a set of generic findings concerning specific types of smart practices and problems of potential transferability of projects to other regions. With regards to policy relevance, the findings can be used for evaluating portfolios of renewable energy projects developed to date and for setting guiding principles for\u00a0project design,\u00a0spatial planning\u00a0and consent by means of cross-national learning and fertilization.\n\nHighlights:\u00a0\nWe classify criteria of smart practice in renewable energy implementation.\nProper spatial targeting, synergies and scale are key criteria of smart practice.\nWe discuss potential transferability of local smart projects to other regions.\nPractical relevance for guiding principles for spatial planning \u0026 project design.","author":["Frantal, B.","Van der Horst, D.","Martinat, S.","Schmitz, S.","Teschner, N.","Silva, L.","Golobic, M.","Roth, M."],"organization":["Czech Academy of Sciences","University of Edinburgh","\u00a0University of Li\u00e8ge","Technion Israel Institute for Technology","Centre for Research in Anthropology (CRIA)","University of Ljubljana","N\u00fcrtingen-Geislingen University"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1357","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-windfarms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60156-4_42","title":"Offshore Windfarms","description":"The Earth is endowed with a bounty of natural energy sources. So far, fossil fuels have simply proven the simplest to exploit on a large scale. But we have reached a point where the governments of most developed countries have recognised the perils of fossil fuel reliance\u2014for both energy security and environmental reasons\u2014and responded by (to varying extents) consciously diversifying national energy portfolios. Globally, wind generation is a small but growing source of electricity, and offshore wind is making great strides. This chapter considers offshore wind energy specifically, the management and regulatory challenges it poses, and emerging best practice in this relatively new area. It concludes that strategic marine spatial planning, an ecosystem approach to environmental impact assessment, and the precautionary approach are becoming three vital tools in striking an appropriate balance between the need to deploy offshore wind generation on the one hand, and the need to safeguard the marine environment on the other.\n\nChapter from the\u00a0Handbook on Marine Environment Protection: Science, Impacts, and Sustainable Management.","author":["Severinsen, G."],"organization":["Victoria University of Wellington"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1358","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/handbook-marine-environment-protection-science-impacts-sustainable-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60156-4","title":"Handbook on Marine Environment Protection: Science, Impacts, and Sustainable Management","description":"This handbook is the first of its kind to provide a clear, accessible, and comprehensive introduction to the most important scientific and management topics in marine environmental protection. Leading experts discuss the latest perspectives and best practices in the field with a particular focus on the functioning of marine ecosystems, natural processes, and anthropogenic pressures. The book familiarizes readers with the intricacies and challenges of managing coasts and oceans more sustainably, and guides them through the maze of concepts and strategies, laws and policies, and the various actors that define our ability to manage marine activities. Providing valuable thematic insights into marine management to inspire thoughtful application and further study, it is essential reading for marine environmental scientists, policy-makers, lawyers, practitioners and anyone interested in the field.\n\nContents:\nNatural Science Basics\nIntrodution into Physical Oceanography (Rebecca Hummels)\nEcological Organization of the Sea (Birte Matthiessen, Franziska Julie Werner, \u0026 Matthias Paulsen)\nMarine Ecosystem Services (Markus Salomon \u0026 Henriette Dahms)\n\nImpacts of Sectoral Marine Activities\nImpact of Fishing Activities on Marine Life (Gerd Kraus \u0026\u00a0Rabea Diekmann)\nMariculture (Thomas A. Wilding, Kenneth D. Black, Steven Benjamins, \u0026 Iona Campbell)\nShipping (Alan Simcock)\nImpacts of Coastal Developments on Ecosystems (Christian Winter)\nOffshore Oil and Gas Production and Transportation (Stanislav Patin)\nExploitation of Offshore Wind Energy (Jens L\u00fcdeke)\nDredging for Navigation, for Environmental Cleanup, and for Sand\/Aggregates (Craig Vogt, Eugene Peck, \u0026 Gregory Hartman)\nEnvironmental Risks of Deep-sea Mining (Philip P. E. Weaver, David S. M. Billett, \u0026 Cindy L. Van Dover)\nDumped Chemical Weapons (Jacek Be\u0142dowski)\nMarine Climate Engineering (David P. Keller)\n\nImpacts of Land-Based Activities\nAgriculture (Oene Oenema, Qian Liu, \u0026 Jingmeng Wang)\nLand-Based Industries (Elisabeth Schmid)\nLand-Based Wastewater Management (Stephan Koester)\nTourism (Alan Simcock)\n\nPollution from Diffuse Sources\nClimate Change: Warming Impacts on Marine Biodiversity (Helmut Hillebrand, Thomas Brey, Julian Gutt, Wilhelm Hagen, Katja Metfies, Bettina Meyer, \u0026 Aleksandra Lewandowska)\nOcean Acidification (Peter Thor \u0026\u00a0Sam Dupont)\nPollution with Hazardous Substances (Katja Broeg \u0026\u00a0Norbert Theobald)\nPollution with Radioactive Substances (Hartmut Nies)\nEutrophication (Justus E. E. van Beusekom)\nMarine Litter (Stefanie Werner \u0026\u00a0Aleke St\u00f6fen O\u2019Brien)\nInput of Energy\/Underwater Sound (Olaf Boebel, Elke Burkhardt \u0026 Ilse van Opzeeland)\nIntroduction of Non-indigenous Species (Ralph Kuhlenkamp \u0026 Britta Kind)\n\nSocial Drivers, Developments, and Perspectives of Increasing Ocean Uses\nA Short History of the Use of Seas and Oceans (Sunhild Kleing\u00e4rtner)\nFactors Behind Increasing Ocean Use: The IPAT Equation and the Marine Environment (Troels J. Hegland)\n\nGeneral Aspects of Management and Governance of Human Activities\nChallenges and Foundations of Sustainable Ocean Governance (Till Markus)\nInstitutional Framework for Marine Environmental Governance (Pradeep Singh)\nInternational Principles of Marine Environmental Protection (Gerd Winter)\u00a0\nOverview of Management Strategies and Instruments (Carolin Kie\u00df)\nFuture Prospects of Marine Environmental Governance (Pradeep Singh \u0026\u00a0Aline Jaeckel)\n\nTraditional Marine Management Topics\nThe International Legal Framework for Conservation and Management of Fisheries and Marine Mammals (Andrew Serdy)\nAqua- and Mariculture Management: A Holistic Perspective on Best Practices (Marc H. Taylor \u0026\u00a0Lotta C. Kluger)\nOffshore Oil and Gas Exploitation (Henning Jessen)\nSustainable Shipping (Ciar\u00e1n McCarthy \u0026\u00a0B\u00e9n\u00e9dicte Sage-Fuller)\nManagement of Hazardous Substances in the Marine Environment (Mikael Karlsson \u0026\u00a0Michael Gilek)\nOrigin and Management of Radioactive Substances in the Marine Environment (Hartmut Nies)\nWaste\/Litter and Sewage Management (Aleke St\u00f6fen-O\u2019Brien \u0026 Stefanie Werner)\nCoastal and Ocean Tourism (Stefan G\u00f6ssling, C. Michael Hall, \u0026 Daniel Scott)\n\nEmerging Management Topics\nOffshore Windfarms (Greg Severinsen)\nWave and Tidal Energy\u00a0(Kate Johnson \u0026\u00a0Sandy Kerr)\nDeep-Seabed Mining (Philomene Verlaan)\nMarine Biodiversity: Opportunities for Global Governance and Management Coherence (Daniela Diz)\nMarine Protected Areas: Global Framework, Regional MPA Networks and a National Example (Henning von Nordheim)\nMarine Environmental Protection and Climate Change (Birgit Peters)\nManagement of Non-indigenous Species and Invasive Alien Species (Wolfgang K\u00f6ck \u0026\u00a0Bj\u00f8rn-Oliver Magsig)\nIntegrating Sectoral Ocean Policies (Markus Salomon \u0026\u00a0Miriam Dross)\nMarine Scientific Research (Anna-Maria Hubert)\nAn Emerging Environmental Issue: Marine Discharge of Mine Tailings (Craig Vogt \u0026\u00a0Jens Skei)\nManaging and Regulating Underwater Noise Pollution (Till Markus \u0026\u00a0Pedro Pablo Silva S\u00e1nchez)\nMarine Geo-Engineering (Harald Ginzky)\nMarine Spatial Planning (Mathias Schubert)","author":["Salomon, M.","Markus, T."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1359","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/site-selection-hybrid-offshore-wind-wave-energy-systems-greece-incorporating","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/11\/8\/2095\/htm","title":"Site Selection of Hybrid Offshore Wind and Wave Energy Systems in Greece Incorporating Environmental Impact Assessment","description":"This paper presents a methodological framework for evaluating marine areas in Greece for the purpose of identifying the most adequate sites for Hybrid Offshore Wind and Wave Energy Systems (HOWiWaES), with special focus on the HOWiWaES\u2019 environmental impact assessment evaluation. Nine evaluation criteria that reflect various environmental, economic, technical and socio-political aspects are considered, including Wind Velocity (WV), Wave Energy Potential (WEP), Water Depth (WD), Distance from Shore (DS), Connection to Local Electrical Grid (CLEG), Population Served (PS), Shipping Density (SD), Distance from Ports (DP) and Environmental Performance Value (EPV). Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) is performed to hierarchically rank twelve predefined siting alternatives. Questionnaires are used to collect information on pairwise comparisons of the evaluation criteria from a group of stakeholders\/experts. Geographic Information Systems (GIS) are used as a metric tool for pairwise comparisons of each siting alternative with respect to the first eight evaluation criteria, while the last criterion is assessed through the development of an innovative environmental impact assessment tool. The results indicate that WV, WEP and EPV present the evaluation criteria with the highest relative significance, while PS, DP and SD correspond to less influencing criteria. The proposed methodology can be easily applied to other countries worldwide for supporting socially accepted siting of HOWiWaES.","author":["Loukogeorgaki, E.","Vagiona, D.","Vasileiou, M."],"organization":["Aristotle University of Thessaloniki"],"originationDate":"2018-08-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.002401800000","23.650346000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Loukogeorgaki-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1360","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-ocean-test-beds-ocean-technology-adaptation-integration-emerging-us","sourceURL":"https:\/\/darchive.mblwhoilibrary.org\/handle\/1912\/10412","title":"The Development of Ocean Test Beds for Ocean Technology Adaptation and Integration into the Emerging U.S. Offshore Wind Energy Industry","description":"The landscape of applied ocean technology is rapidly changing with forces of innovation emerging from basic ocean science research methodologies as well as onshore high tech sectors. There is a critical need for ocean-related industries to continue to modernize via the adoption of state-of-the-art practices to advance rapidly changing industry objectives, maintain competitiveness, and be careful stewards of the ocean as a common resource. These objectives are of national importance for the dynamic ocean energy sector, and a mechanism by which new and promising technologies can be validated and adopted in an open and benchmarked process is needed. POWER-US seeks to develop Ocean Test Beds as research and development infrastructure capable of driving innovative observations, modeling, and monitoring of the physical, biological, and use characteristics present in offshore wind energy installation areas.","author":["Kirincich, A.","Borkland, J.","Hines, E.","Lohrenz, S."],"organization":["Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution","Tufts University","University of Massachusetts","POWER-US: Partnership for Offshore Wind Energy Research"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.847546000000","-70.695090000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/POWER-US-OTB-Final.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1361","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/overcoming-biological-data-deficiencies-environmental-permitting-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/scholarworks.umass.edu\/dissertations_2\/1271\/","title":"Overcoming Biological Data Deficiencies in Environmental Permitting for Offshore Wind Energy","description":"The offshore wind final net technical resource of 2,059 GW in the United States is unrealized in part due to a cumbersome permitting process. In this dissertation, I examine the role of biological data in the permitting process, and explore frameworks for overcoming identified deficiencies. Criteria analyses and semi-structured interviews were conducted to understand how biological data impede impact assessments of offshore wind projects, which are required by the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA). In addition, spatiotemporal scales of biological data in NEPA assessments were evaluated against federal requirements. Case studies and semi-structured interviews were then conducted to evaluate how the marine spatial planning (MSP) process and its outcomes could address identified data impediments, how MSP could otherwise advance the offshore wind permitting process, what are the limiting factors of MSP, how limiting factors could be overcome, and how species distribution models could provide appropriate data to improve documentation.\n\nThe research conducted for my dissertation showed that scales of biological data are inadequate in impact assessments and insufficient biological data are impediments in the offshore wind permitting process. Data from species distribution models contribute marginal value to impact assessments, and should not be exclusively relied upon. MSP can improve data access and analyses in NEPA documentation, in addition to facilitating communications, minimizing conflict, and providing a common operating picture. However, the full value of MSP is limited due to lack of political support and methodological changes in implementation. Therefore, other initiatives to facilitate data management should be pursued, such as industry sponsored research and relaxing the proprietary nature of baseline biological data. The results of this project highlight the significance that biological data has in impeding offshore wind projects and suggest solutions to overcome this in order to responsibly advance the offshore wind sector in the United States.","author":["Ryan, K."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.558931600000","-110.354532700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Thesis-Ryan-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1362","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/oil-gas-infrastructure-decommissioning-marine-protected-areas-system-complexity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X18305642","title":"Oil and gas infrastructure decommissioning in marine protected areas: System complexity, analysis and challenges","description":"Many offshore oil and\u00a0gas production\u00a0facilities are nearing the end of their operational life, with decommissioning now becoming a global challenge. The compatibility of decommissioning operations to\u00a0marine protected areas\u00a0(MPAs) creates further challenges. The recently-developed DAPSI(W)R(M) problem structuring framework (covering Drivers, Activities, Pressures, State changes, Impacts (on Welfare) and Responses (as Measures)) was applied here to interrogate the complexity of decommissioning oil and gas infrastructure within MPAs, with outputs feeding into the development of a novel database tool for Screening Potential Impacts of Decommissioning Activities (SPIDA). In meeting the current requirements of the marine regulatory regime, SPIDA provides a more streamlined, evidence-based process which can be applied by industry, statutory\u00a0nature conservation\u00a0bodies and regulators for identifying and evaluating evidence that supports the implications of decommissioning alternatives on the condition of MPAs. SPIDA has been developed to be adapted for other activities and sectors, including offshore renewables.\n\nHighlights:\nDecommissioning oil and gas infrastructure in marine protected areas is complex.\nA decision support framework was co-produced with key marine stakeholders.\nNovel tool was built for Screening Potential Impacts of Decommissioning Activities.\nSPIDA identifies risks, opportunities and impacts of decommissioning on features.\nThe framework and tool are of relevance to other marine sectors (e.g. offshore wind.)","author":["Elliott, M.","Burdon, D.","Barnard, S.","Boyes, S."],"organization":["University of Hull"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1363","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning-enough-overcome-biological-data-deficiencies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.worldscientific.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1142\/S1464333218500126","title":"Is Marine Spatial Planning Enough to Overcome Biological Data Deficiencies?","description":"The United States only accounts for 0.2% of the global offshore wind installed capacity despite a potential technical resource four orders of magnitude greater. A cumbersome permitting process is one of the challenges in implementing new projects. Part of this process requires biological data in order to inform assessments of environmental impacts; yet these data may be lacking for particular taxa at the required scale. Marine spatial planning (MSP) is a process that often includes data identification, collection, collation and analyses components. In this paper, we conduct a collective case study of three areas with offshore wind projects located in waters managed by marine spatial plans, focusing on how data efforts inform MSP and offshore wind development. Our study finds that MSP can facilitate data efforts during the permitting phase of offshore wind projects, but that other initiatives, particularly renewable energy policies and zoning, appear critical towards establishing offshore wind.","author":["Jordaan, A.","Ryan, K.","Danylchuk, A."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts"],"originationDate":"2018-11-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.558931600000","-110.354532700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1364","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/intense-short-wavelength-light-triggers-avoidance-response-red-tailed-hawks-new-tool","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bioone.org\/journals\/The-Condor\/volume-119\/issue-3\/CONDOR-16-230.1\/Intense-short-wavelength-light-triggers-avoidance-response-by-Red-tailed\/10.1650\/CONDOR-16-230.1.full","title":"Intense short-wavelength light triggers avoidance response by Red-tailed Hawks: A new tool for raptor diversion?","description":"Collisions between birds and aircraft present serious safety and economic risks to aviation worldwide. Research into the potential for lighting to reduce collision risk has been evolving since the mid-twentieth century. Our objective was to explore the potential for using customized light-emitting diodes (LEDs) as a deterrent to wild raptors under natural conditions. The Red-tailed Hawk (Buteo jamaicensis) is among the top 10 bird species struck by aircraft in the United States; these collisions have resulted in aircraft damage, emergency landings, aborted takeoffs, and human injuries and fatalities. We tested the reactions of migrating Red-tailed Hawks to pulsing, high-brightness, monochromatic LEDs that targeted the avian photoreceptors for light of short and extremely short wavelengths. We installed 3 lighting units to illuminate 2 lures at a raptor banding station during the peak of Red-tailed Hawk migration and compared the number of captures and aborted approaches to these lures with captures and aborted approaches at a control station. The proportion of Red-tailed Hawks that aborted their approaches to lures at the treatment station was .5 times that of hawks that aborted approaches at the control site. We observed individuals abruptly changing flight direction as they neared the illuminated lures. Our results suggest that, with further testing and refinement, high-brightness, monochromatic LEDs that specifically target avian photoreceptors could provide a useful tool to divert raptors from hazardous situations.","author":["Foss, C.","Ronning, D.","Merker, D."],"organization":["Audubon Society","Lite Enterprises","Cape May Raptor Banding Project"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.937334000000","-74.969342000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1365","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/severn-tidal-power-feasibility-study-conclusions-summary-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.uk\/government\/publications\/1-severn-tidal-power-feasibility-study-conclusions-and-summary-report","title":"Severn Tidal Power Feasibility Study: Conclusions and Summary Report","description":"Following a positive recommendation from the Sustainable Development Commission, a 2-year cross-government feasibility study was launched to inform a decision whether or not to promote a scheme to generate electricity from the tides of the Severn estuary. The study has looked at 5 potentially feasible scheme options in outline and assessed their costs, benefits and risks.","author":["Department of Energy \u0026 Climate Change (DECC)"],"organization":["UK Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)","Welsh Government","UK Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)"],"originationDate":"2010-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.480972000000","-3.350624000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Severn-Feasibility-2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1366","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-range-technologies-state-art-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S136403211501730X","title":"Tidal range technologies and state of the art in review","description":"Tidal range technology has seen much development and interest in recent years. The times when a\u00a0barrage\u00a0scheme would be rejected due to environmental and cost concerns is coming to an end. A large variety of new lower cost and less invasive methods have since emerged in the forms of tidal lagoons, reefs and fences. Since the\u00a0construction\u00a0of La Rance in 1967, advancements in\u00a0turbine\u00a0technologies and design has since resulted in a plethora of new, exciting turbine designs for\u00a0tidal energy. A selection of new turbines with possible tidal range applications includes the modified\u00a0bulb turbinewith two sets of\u00a0guide vanes, a counter-rotating turbine,\u00a0Archimedes\u00a0screw and a gyro device. However, the same design is continuously being chosen \u2013 the Kaplan bulb turbine. Through the use of a marking criterion covering key aspects that should be considered when choosing a turbine a variety of the new designs available are investigated. The key aspects researched include,\u00a0environmental effects, the two-way efficiency, initial costs and maintenance costs\/difficulty.","author":["Waters, S.","Aggidis, G."],"organization":["Lancaster University"],"originationDate":"2016-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1367","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-range-energy-resource-optimization-past-perspectives-future-challenges","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118305263#bib81","title":"Tidal range energy resource and optimization - Past perspectives and future challenges","description":"Tidal energy\u00a0is one of the most predictable forms of\u00a0renewable energy. Although there has been much commercial and R\u0026D progress in tidal stream energy, tidal range is a more mature technology, with tidal range power plants having a history that extends back over 50 years. With the 2017 publication of the \u201cHendry Review\u201d that examined the feasibility of tidal lagoon power plants in the UK, it is timely to review tidal range power plants. Here, we explain the main principles of tidal range power plants, and review two main research areas: the present and future tidal range resource, and the optimization of tidal range power plants. We also discuss how variability in the electricity generated from tidal range power plants could be partially offset by the development of multiple power plants (e.g. lagoons) that are complementary in phase, and by the provision of energy storage. Finally, we discuss the implications of the Hendry Review, and what this means for the future of tidal range power plants in the UK and internationally.","author":["Masters, I.","Ahmadian, R.","Falconer, R.","Lewis, M.","Evans, P.","Neill, S.","Robins, P.","Avdis, A.","Piggott, M.","Aggidis, G.","Piano, M.","Ward, S.","Walkington, I.","Angeloudis, A.","Adcock, T.","Zidonis, A."],"organization":["Bangor University","Imperial College London","Liverpool John Moores University","Swansea University","Cardiff University","Lancaster University","Wallingford HydroSolutions (WHS)","University of Oxford"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Neill-et-al-20183.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1368","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/perspectives-way-forward-ocean-renewable-energy-australia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118305573#sec3.2","title":"Perspectives on a way forward for ocean renewable energy in Australia","description":"Australia has considerable wave and tidal\u00a0ocean energy\u00a0resources. Development of the emerging ocean\u00a0renewable energy\u00a0(ORE) industry in Australia offers opportunities to build Australia\u0027s blue economy, while actively contributing to committed carbon mitigation measures. Many interdisciplinary challenges are currently hampering development of the industry in Australia, and globally, including technology, cost reduction, policy and regulations, potential for\u00a0environmental effects, awareness and investment, amongst others. In October 2016, ORE technology and project developers, researchers, academics, policy makers and other stakeholders in Australia\u0027s emerging ORE industry came together to identify these challenges and develop possible pathways to grow ocean energy in Australia. Four themes were identified: Technology Development; Education and Awareness; Policy and Regulation; and Finance and Investment. This paper documents the outcomes of the meeting identifying challenges and a way\u00a0forward\u00a0against each theme. A key element identified across all themes was the need for stronger coordination across the sector, and the need for a representing body to lead necessary initiatives to support growth and management of the ORE industry in Australia, as one element of a burgeoning blue economy.","author":["Penesis, I.","Hemer, M.","Manasseh, R.","McInnes, K.","Pitman, T."],"organization":["Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)","Swinburne University of Technology","University of Tasmania"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-23.244181400000","131.393920600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hemer-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1369","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/state-worlds-raptors-distributions-threats-conservation-recommendations","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320718305871","title":"State of the World\u0027s Raptors: Distributions, Threats, and Conservation Recommendations","description":"Raptors provide critical ecosystem services, yet there is currently no systematic, global synthesis of their\u00a0conservation status\u00a0or threats. We review the International Union for the Conservation of Nature\u0027s\u00a0Red List\u00a0to examine the conservation status, distributions, threats, and conservation recommendations for all 557 raptor species. We further assess the significance of Important Bird and Biodiversity Areas (IBAs) for raptor conservation. We also determine which countries contain the most species listed under the Memorandum of Understanding on the Conservation of\u00a0Migratory Birds\u00a0of Prey in Africa and Eurasia (Raptors MoU). Raptors, especially Old World vultures, are more threatened than birds in general. Eighteen percent of raptors are threatened with\u00a0extinction\u00a0and 52% of raptors have declining global populations. South and Southeast Asia have the highest richness and the largest number of threatened raptor species. By country, Indonesia has the highest richness of raptor species (119) and most declining species (63). China and Russia contain the most Raptors MoU species, although they are not yet signatories to the agreement. Raptor species that require forest are more likely to be threatened and declining than those that do not. Agriculture and logging are the most frequently identified threats, although poisoning is especially detrimental to Old World vultures. Of the 10 most important IBAs for raptors, six are in Nepal. Highest priority conservation actions to protect raptors include preventing mortality and conserving key sites and priority habitats. Improved long-term monitoring would allow for conservation to be appropriately targeted and effectiveness of interventions to be assessed.","author":["Johnson, J.","Davies, R.","Amar, A.","McClure, C.","Butchart, S.","Westrip, J.","Schulwitz, S.","Virani, M.","Symes, A.","Wheatley, H.","Thorstrom, R.","Buij, R.","Jones, V.","Williams, N.","Buechley, E."],"organization":["The Peregrine Fund","BirdLife International","University of North Texas","habitat INFO","University of Cape Town","Wageningen University and Research Centre","Environment Agency Abu Dhabi","HawkWatch International","University of Utah","University of Cambridge"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1370","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nocturnal-flight-activity-northern-gannets-morus-bassanus-implications-modelling","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S019592551830091X","title":"Nocturnal flight activity of northern gannets Morus bassanus and implications for modelling collision risk at offshore wind farms","description":"Assessing the potential impacts of proposed offshore wind farm developments on seabird populations requires estimation of nocturnal flight activity of seabirds for input into collision risk models. One of the seabirds considered most at risk from collision with offshore wind turbines is the northern gannet Morus bassanus. The recommended correction for gannet nocturnal flight activity is currently a highly precautionary value. Here we use data from tracking studiesto derive evidence-based correction factors for nocturnal flight activity of adult gannets during the breeding and nonbreeding seasons, and of immature gannets during the summer prospecting phase. Flight and diving activity of gannets was minimal during the night, astronomical and nautical twilight, for adults during the breeding season and nonbreeding season, and for immatures. Some flight activity occurred during the short period of civil twilight, but on average at about half the level seen during the day. Based on evidence from numerous tracking studies, we recommend that precautionary values of the nocturnal (sunset to sunrise) flight activity factor for estimating collision risk should be 8% of daytime flight activity during the breeding season and 3% of daytime flight activity during the nonbreeding season. Use of these evidence-based correction factors will improve the accuracy, and reduce the uncertainty of collision risk models, providing a more reliable assessment of the impacts of offshore wind farms on gannets.","author":["Furness, R.","Garthe, S.","Trinder, M.","Wanless, S.","Matthiopoulos, J.","Jeglinski, J."],"organization":["MacArthur Green","University of Glasgow","Kiel University","UK Centre for Ecology \u0026 Hydrology (CEH)"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1371","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-criteria-decision-making-assessment-proposed-tidal-barrage-schemes-terms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X17307002","title":"Multi-Criteria Decision-Making on Assessment of Proposed Tidal Barrage Schemes in Terms of Environmental Impacts","description":"For\u00a0tidal range\u00a0power plants\u00a0to be sustainable, the environmental impacts caused by the implement of various tidal barrage schemes must be assessed before construction. However, several problems exist in the current researches: firstly, evaluation criteria of the tidal barrage schemes\u00a0environmental impact assessment\u00a0(EIA) are not adequate; secondly, uncertainty of criteria information fails to be processed properly; thirdly, correlation among criteria is unreasonably measured. Hence the contributions of this paper are as follows: firstly, an evaluation criteria system is established from three dimensions of\u00a0hydrodynamic, biological and morphological aspects. Secondly, cloud model is applied to describe the uncertainty of criteria information. Thirdly, Choquet integral with respect to\u00a0\u03bb-fuzzy measure is introduced to measure the correlation among criteria. On the above bases, a multi-criteria decision-making decision framework for tidal barrage scheme EIA is established to select the optimal scheme. Finally, a case study demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed framework.","author":["Wu, Y.","Xu, C.","Ke, Y.","Chen, K.","Xu, H."],"organization":["North China Electric Power University"],"originationDate":"2012-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1372","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparison-hydro-environmental-impacts-ebb-only-two-way-generation-severn-barrage","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0098300414001198","title":"Comparison of hydro-environmental impacts for ebb-only and two-way generation for a Severn Barrage","description":"Marine renewable energy is playing an increasing significant role in many parts of the world, mainly due to a rise in the awareness of climate change, and its detrimental effects, and the increasing cost of natural resources. The Severn Estuary, located between South West England and South Wales, has a tidal range of up to 14\u00a0m which makes it the second highest tidal range in the world. There are a number of barrage proposals amongst various marine renewable energy schemes proposed to be built in the estuary. The Cardiff-Weston STPG (Severn Tidal Power Group) Barrage, which would be one of the world\u05f3s largest tidal renewable energy schemes if built, is one of the most publicised schemes to-date. This barrage would generate about 17\u00a0TWh\/annum of power, which is approximately 5% of the UK\u05f3s electricity consumption, whilst causing significant hydro-environmental and ecological impact on the estuary.\n\nThis study mainly focuses on investigating the hydro-environmental impacts of the STPG barrage for the option of two-way generation, and compares this with the commonly investigated option of ebb-only generation. The impacts of the barrage were modelled by implementing a linked 1-D\/2-D hydro-environmental model, with the capability of modelling several key environmental processes. The model predictions show that the hydro-environmental impacts of the barrage on the Severn Estuary and Bristol Channel, such as changes in the maximum velocity and reduction in suspended sediment and bacteria levels, were less significant for the two-way generation scheme when compared with the corresponding impacts for ebb-only generation.","author":["Ahmadian, R.","Bockelmann-Evans, B.","Falconer, R."],"organization":["Cardiff University"],"originationDate":"2014-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.409798000000","-3.026132000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1373","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-impacts-tidal-renewable-energy-scheme-eutrophication-potential-severn","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0098300414001848","title":"An assessment of the impacts of a tidal renewable energy scheme on the eutrophication potential of the Severn Estuary, UK","description":"The potential impacts of ebb-only (one-way) and flood-ebb (two-way) modes of operation of a tidal barrage on the eutrophication potential of the Severn Estuary were investigated in this study using the simple modelling approach adopted by the UK\u2019s Comprehensive Studies Task Team (CSTT). The model predictions were compared against CSTT thresholds for assessing eutrophication in estuaries and coastal waters. For the no barrage scenario, as well as the ebb-only and flood-ebb operating modes, the estuary was found to be potentially eutrophic as the predicted equilibrium nutrient concentrations and potential maximum phytoplankton biomass chlorophyll concentrations exceeded the threshold limits. Potential maximum phytoplankton primary productivity under both ebb-only and flood-ebb operating modes were found to be noticeably higher than that for the no barrage scenario. This is believed to be due to a combination of increased water residence time and greater light availability behind the barrage. However, the conditions for phytoplankton production are likely to be more favourable under ebb-only operating mode as the potential for maximum phytoplankton primary production was found to be significantly increased under ebb-only operating mode, with largely decreased suspended particulate matter concentration compared to flood-ebb operating mode where only a small reduction in suspended particulate matter concentration is predicted.","author":["Kadiri, M.","Ahmadian, R.","Bockelmann-Evans, B.","Falconer, R.","Kay, D."],"organization":["Cardiff University","Aberystwyth University"],"originationDate":"2014-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.409798000000","-3.026132000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1374","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/societal-acceptance-wind-farms-analysis-four-common-themes-across-australian-case","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421513001638","title":"Societal acceptance of wind farms: Analysis of four common themes across Australian case studies","description":"Australia\u0027s renewable energy target (RET) seeks to provide 20 per cent of Australia\u0027s electricity generation from renewable energy sources by 2020. As wind power is relatively advanced, it was anticipated that wind power will contribute a major component of the early target. However, high levels of societal resistance to wind farms, combined with new regulatory policies, indicate the RET may not be dominated by wind power. This research involved an examination of seven case studies around wind farm deployment. Qualitative interviews were the primary data for the case studies and analysed using methods informed by grounded theory. Despite the diversity of stakeholder views, the qualitative analysis identified strong community support for wind farms but four common themes emerged that influence this societal acceptance of wind farms in Australia: trust, distributional justice, procedural justice and place attachment. Without addressing these factors through integration into policy development and engagement approaches, wind energy is unlikely to provide the early and majority of new renewable energy. Similar international experiences are incorporated in the discussion of the Australian wind industry\u0027s societal acceptance.","author":["Devine-Wright, P.","Hall, N.","Ashworth, P."],"organization":["Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)"],"originationDate":"2013-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-34.458271800000","149.442273700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Environmental Justice"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1375","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/factors-influencing-citizens-acceptance-non-acceptance-wind-energy-germany","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0959652617328949","title":"Factors influencing citizens\u0027 acceptance and non-acceptance of wind energy in Germany","description":"Among\u00a0renewable\u00a0energy technologies,\u00a0wind energy\u00a0accounts for the highest share in gross\u00a0electricity consumption\u00a0in Germany. To keep this renewable share up, wind energy project have to combine technological aspects with environmental and societally aspects. The successful planning and implementation of a\u00a0wind farm\u00a0crucially depends on acceptance of citizens living in the vicinity of the site.\u00a0Factors influencing\u00a0acceptance of wind energy can be categorised into processrelated variables, personal characteristics, perceived side effects and technical and geographical issues. However, research is still missing on how and to what extend the identified factors have an influence on the acceptance and non-acceptance. This article identifies the relevant factors within each of these four categories by investigating which of these factors have an impact upon acceptance or non-acceptance of a project. This identification enables policy makers and operators to implement wind energy projects with a certain acceptance level by the society. The study is based on a German wide online-survey with about 1,400 participants. Using a multinomial logistic regression analysis, the results show that factors in all categories are relevant in driving citizens\u0027 active acceptance, ambivalence or active non-acceptance of wind energy. The paper reveals that in particular the factors fear of\u00a0infrasoundand the opportunity for participation plays an essential role in the categories perceived side effects and process-related variables. The fear of infrasound has the most significant negative influence on the acceptance. Also the participation level, alibi participation, displays significant\u00a0negative effects\u00a0on the acceptance. Furthermore, the results suggest that some of the most recent changes in the legal framework regulating new wind energy projects in Germany counteract acceptance according the findings of this study. In particular, results show that the distance between the place of residence and\u00a0wind turbines\u00a0has no significant influence on the acceptance.","author":["Langer, K.","Decker, T.","Menrad, K.","Roosen, J."],"organization":["Technische Universitat Munchen"],"originationDate":"2018-02-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.165691000000","10.451525000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1376","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparing-offshore-onshore-wind-development-considering-acceptance-costs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S030142151830675X","title":"Comparing offshore and onshore wind development considering acceptance costs","description":"Cost efficient deployment of wind energy is in focus for reaching ambitious targets for renewable energy and transforming the energy supply to one based on renewables. However, as more wind is being deployed the available sites onshore become less attractive in terms of wind conditions and capacity factor and more resistance from population groups affected in the deployment areas results in a reduction of areas that can be developed. We consider three different methods for estimating acceptance costs, one based on compensation and property purchase costs, one based on property value loss near wind turbines, and one based on willingness to pay calculated from a stated preference study. Utilising these methods, we provide an estimation of Levelised Cost of Energy (LCOE) for an expansion of 12\u202fGW onshore or offshore wind capacity in Denmark. We find that the three methods provide similar estimates for local acceptance, but that a high range of uncertainty exists in the upper bound of acceptance costs. Onshore does not have a clear-cut cost advantage over offshore when considering substantial amounts of wind capacity expansion and using high estimates for nation-wide acceptance costs. Moderate onshore wind expansion considering only local acceptance has a cost advantage.","author":["Hevia-Koch, P.","Jacobsen, H."],"organization":["Technical University of Denmark (DTU)"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.209707700000","9.295234800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1377","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/property-value-impacts-wind-turbines-influence-attitudes-toward-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/le.uwpress.org\/content\/94\/4\/496.abstract","title":"Property Value Impacts of Wind Turbines and the Influence of Attitudes toward Wind Energy","description":"The lack of consensus in the literature on wind turbines and property values suggests that factors such as attitudes toward wind energy may influence whether turbines will impact property values. Based on identified attitudes at the municipality level in the Canadian province of Ontario, this study compares impacts on property values, estimated using a difference-in-differences hedonic approach, between municipalities that oppose wind energy development and those that have not expressed opposition. The results indicate that wind turbines have negatively impacted property values in \u201cunwilling host\u201d municipalities, while no significant impacts are found in unopposed municipalities.","author":["Vyn, R."],"organization":["University of Guelph"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.977545000000","-88.351945400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1378","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/vindication-don-quixote-impact-noise-visual-pollution-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/le.uwpress.org\/content\/90\/4\/668","title":"The Vindication of Don Quixote: The Impact of Noise and Visual Pollution from Wind Turbines","description":"In this article we quantify the marginal external effects of nearby land-based wind turbines on property prices. We succeed in separating the effect of noise and visual pollution from wind turbines. This is achieved by using a dataset consisting of 12,640 traded residential properties located within 2,500 meters of a turbine sold in the period 2000\u20132011. Our results show that wind turbines have a significant negative impact on the price schedule of neighboring residential properties. Visual pollution reduces the residential sales price by up to about 3%, while noise pollution reduces the price between 3% and 7%.","author":["Lundhede, T.","Jensen, C.","Panduro, T."],"organization":["Danish Economic Councils","University of Copenhagen"],"originationDate":"2014-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1379","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/willingness-pay-renewable-energy-investment-korea-choice-experiment-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032110000687","title":"Willingness to pay for renewable energy investment in Korea: A choice experiment study","description":"Renewable energy sources are considered as alternatives for coping with the high price of oil and global warming. The Korean government has set a target that 11% of the total primary energy supply should be obtained through renewable energy sources until 2030. In order to develop proper policies for renewable energy investment, it is necessary to analyze the benefits of renewable energy investment based on households\u2019 willingness to pay. This study attempts to apply a choice experiment (CE) for assessing renewable energy investment in Korea. Moreover, we employ a multinomial probit (MNP) model to relax the assumption that all respondents have the same preferences for the attributes being valued, which is usually required in empirical CE studies. An MNP model allows the most flexible pattern of error correlation structure. The results reveal that the Korean public puts a value on the protection of wildlife, reduction of pollution, and increased employment opportunities. On the other hand, respondents do not derive significant values from the improvement of landscapes. This study is expected to provide policy-makers with useful information for evaluating and planning policies related to renewable energy investment.","author":["Yoo, S.","Ku, S."],"organization":["Korea University","Hoseo University"],"originationDate":"2010-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.505939500000","127.141893900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1380","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/using-conjoint-analysis-quantify-public-preferences-over-environmental-impacts-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421501000635","title":"Using conjoint analysis to quantify public preferences over the environmental impacts of wind farms. An example from Spain","description":"This paper focuses on the effect on people\u0027s utility of the potential environmental impacts of wind farm developments. We report on research designed to provide insight into their preferences, and we show how two alternative choice modelling techniques can be used to estimate them. Our results show that significant social costs in the form of environmental impacts can be associated with wind farm developments. As relative environmental values are revealed by these methods, it would be possible to develop wind farms in such a way that minimises the total social costs of the investment and which maximises its net benefits.","author":["Hanley, N.","Alvarez-Farizo, B."],"organization":["University of Glasgow"],"originationDate":"2002-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.651685900000","-0.930086000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1381","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-displacement-impacts-offshore-windfarms-other-human-activities-red-throated","sourceURL":"https:\/\/publications.naturalengland.org.uk\/publication\/6322489741803520","title":"Assessment of Displacement Impacts of Offshore Windfarms and Other Human Activities on Red-Throated Divers and Alcids","description":"Offshore windfarms have a number of potential impacts on birds at sea. One of the most significant is the potential to displace birds from within and around the windfarm footprint and associated ship traffic access routes \u2013 ie effectively to cause habitat loss (albeit indirectly). Divers and seaducks are generally considered to be amongst the most sensitive bird species to disturbance from such human activities in the marine environment and to be the most likely to exhibit displacement in response to offshore windfarm developments, but a range of other species, including auk species (Alcids) are also vulnerable to displacement from offshore windfarms.\n\nDue to the relatively recent development of the offshore windfarm industry, there are as yet very few long term datasets covering the periods before, during and following construction of offshore windfarms on which robust statistical analyses of distribution and abundance data for key bird species have been, or could be undertaken. The requirement of this project was to develop a novel approach to the analysis of the Outer Thames estuary datasets that enabled all of the data that were suitable and available to be used in the model building stages, to provide greater confidence in the model outputs and develop a modelling framework that can be updated to allow inclusion of additional post-construction data in the future.\n\nThe project also undertook preliminary modelling of the existing datasets (up to and including the first year of post construction surveys) to test for significant changes in the distribution and density of birds over time and to identify the location of such changes with a focus on pre-construction and during-construction changes.\n\nThe findings will be used by those engaged in marine spatial planning and impact assessments, in particular the Statutory Nature Conservation Bodies (SNCBs), regulators and developers in the offshore sector who need to assess the potential displacement impact of offshore development proposals on marine birds.","author":["Rehfisch, M.","McGovern, S.","Goddard, B."],"organization":["APEM Ltd","Natural England"],"originationDate":"2016-12-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.499999200000","0.574556800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NECR227-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1382","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/valuing-visual-impact-wind-farms-application-south-evia-greece","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032114005528","title":"Valuing the visual impact of wind farms: An application in South Evia, Greece","description":"This study presents an application of the Contingent Valuation Method (CVM) for valuing the landscape externalities associated with the large-scale exploitation of\u00a0wind power\u00a0at the local level. The survey was undertaken in South Evia, Greece, which is a region with rich\u00a0wind energy potential\u00a0and a considerable number of\u00a0wind farms\u00a0in operation during the period of the study. The results showed that 57% of the households are not willing to contribute financially in order to implement interventions to mitigate the visual impact of wind farms. \u03a4he mean willingness to pay per household to avoid the visual impact attributed to the installation of new wind farms in the area in question was estimated at \u20ac41.6\/year taking into account all households of the sample. This estimate is relatively lower compared to the results of other relevant studies. As shown by a meta-analysis developed based on these studies, this is mainly attributed to the great recession in Greece and the reduced available income of households.","author":["Mirasgedis, S.","Tourkolias, C.","Tzovla, E.","Diakoulaki, D."],"organization":["National Observatory of Athens (NOA)","National Technical University of Athens"],"originationDate":"2014-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.471771000000","23.877599000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1383","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/landscape-externalities-onshore-wind-power","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421509006430","title":"Landscape externalities from onshore wind power","description":"The expansion of renewable energy is a central element of the German Federal Government\u0027s climate and energy policy. The target for 2020 is to produce 30% of the electricity from renewable energies. Wind power has been selected to be a major contributor to this change. Replacing old wind turbines by modern ones and building new turbines on land will be crucial in meeting this target. However, the expansion of onshore wind power is not universally accepted. In several regions of Germany residents are protesting against setting up new wind turbines. To determine the negative effects two choice experiments were applied in Westsachsen and Nordhessen, Germany. In both regions the externalities of wind power generation until 2020 based on today\u0027s state of technology were measured. The results show that negative landscape externalities would result from expanding wind power generation. Using latent class models three different groups of respondents experiencing different degrees of externalities were identified.","author":["Meyerhoff, J.","Ohl, C.","Hartje, V."],"organization":["Berlin Institute of Technology","Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ)"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.089570300000","5.959164200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1384","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farms-where-how-place-them-choice-experiment-approach-measure-consumer","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0921800914001815","title":"Wind farms - Where and how to place them? A choice experiment approach to measure consumer preferences for characteristics of wind farm establishments in Sweden","description":"This paper explores preferences among the general public in Sweden for attributes related to the establishment of wind power farms. The method applied is a choice experiment where people are asked to choose between two hypothetical wind farms characterized by different attributes. Five attributes are included in the experiment: (i) type of landscape, (ii) type of ownership, (iii) the degree of local participation in the planning process, (iv) the choice to transfer revenue to the society in a pre-specified way, and (v) a monetary cost in terms of an additional electricity certificate fee. The data are analyzed with multinomial logit, random parameter logit, and latent class models. The results indicate that consumers in Sweden are more likely to accept the higher renewable electricity certificate fee if: (a) wind power farms in areas used for recreational purposes are substantially avoided, (b) the establishment is anchored by whole or partial ownership in the local community and, (c) the locals are involved in the planning and implementation process. Our policy simulation exercise shows that respondents are willing to pay a higher electricity fee corresponding to about 0.6 Euro cents per kWh to avoid wind farms located in the mountainous area and private ownership.","author":["Ek, K.","Persson, L."],"organization":["Lule\u00e5 University of Technology","Ume\u00e5 University"],"originationDate":"2014-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["62.521768000000","15.019600000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1385","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-anthropocene-conservation-bats-changing-world","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-319-25220-9#toc","title":"Bats in the Anthropocene: Conservation of Bats in a Changing World","description":"Humans have inadvertently changed global ecosystems and triggered the dawn of a new geological epoch, the Anthropocene. While some organisms can tolerate human activities and even flourish in anthropogenic habitats, the vast majority are experiencing dramatic population declines, pushing our planet into a sixth mass extinction. Bats are particularly susceptible to anthropogenic changes because of their low reproductive rate, longevity, and high metabolic rates. Fifteen percent of bat species are listed as threatened by the IUCN, i.e., they are considered Critically Endangered, Endangered or Vulnerable. About 18 % of species are Data Deficient, highlighting the paucity of ecological studies that can support conservation status assessments. This book summarizes major topics related to the conservation of bats organized into sections that address: the response of bats to land use changes; how the emergence of viral and fungal diseases has changed bat populations; our perception of bats; and drivers of human\u2013bat conflicts and possible resolutions and mitigation. The book ends with approaches that might advance bat conservation through conservation networks and a better understanding of human behavior and behavioral change.  Chapter 11: Impacts of Wind Energy Development on Bats: A Global Perspective","author":["Voigt, C.","Kingston, T."],"organization":["Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","Texas Tech University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1386","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-determinants-local-acceptability-wind-farm-investment-choice-experiment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421509000093","title":"Assessing the determinants of local acceptability of wind-farm investment: A choice experiment in the Greek Aegean Islands","description":"This paper aims at analysing the factors, which motivate communities to resist the installation of wind farms in their vicinity. To this end, the choice experiment methodology was employed in communities in two Greek Aegean Islands to assess the determinants of preferences towards different wind-farm projects. Unlike other studies, the willingness to accept welfare measure was adopted. The results of our analysis show that the conservation status of the area where the wind farms are to be installed, along with the governance characteristics of the planning procedure are the most important determinants of local community welfare in relation to wind farms. In contrast to other studies, we find that the physical attributes of wind farms appear to be of less relative importance from a local community welfare point of view. Implications for the EU\u0027s future energy policy are drawn.","author":["Dimitropoulos, A.","Kontoleon, A."],"organization":["Agilis S.A., Statistics and Informatics","University of Cambridge"],"originationDate":"2009-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.333970000000","25.777580000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1387","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/conservation-management-issues-dadia-lefkimi-soufli-forest-national-park","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wwf.gr\/images\/pdfs\/CatsadorakisConservation.pdf","title":"Conservation and management issues for the Dadia-Lefkimi-Soufli Forest National Park","description":"The main threats to DNP\u2019s principal assets are habitat and landscape homogenization, large-scale fires, the over-development and unwise location of wind-farms around the park, poisoned baits and the aesthetic degradation of landscapes. Impediments to effective management are not only local, but most stem from problems relating to the general system of protected areas in Greece. They are of ecological, administrative, legislative and institutional nature, but there is also a lack of political will to find solutions for them. The principal management and conservation goals for DNP must be to preserve farmland of high ecological value, to arrest forest expansion and to increase the amount of clearings. Others are to preserve old trees and mature stands to ensure optimal nesting conditions for birds of prey and to ensure vulture food resources long-term. To reach these goals, a plan for sustainable local development needs to be developed and the existing legal framework must be amended to support it. Scientific monitoring results must inform all processes. The participation of local communities and authorities is crucial. Local forestry objectives must be revised to match biodiversity conservation needs and promotion of environment-friendly practices in agriculture must be ensured.","author":["Vasilakis, D.","Kati, V.","Poirazidis, K.","Catsadorakis, G.","Liarikos, C.","Skartsi, T.","Karavellas, D."],"organization":["WWF Greece"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.127549000000","26.221370000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WWF-windfarms-DLS-Forest-2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1388","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/special-framework-spatial-planning-sustainable-development-renewable-energy-sources","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148112003369","title":"Special framework for the spatial planning \u0026 the sustainable development of renewable energy sources","description":"Greece has adopted measures to support renewable energy sources ensuring the simplification of the licensing procedures. A regulatory framework is presented for the determination of the appropriate areas and the constraints for the installation of renewable energy projects, categorised by activity (wind farms, small hydroelectric projects, photovoltaic parks), based on the available national data. The sites that are infeasible for installation are defined. Regarding the spatial planning of wind farms, the national territory is divided into major categories based on the exploitable wind potential and particular spatial and environmental characteristics. Criteria are set for the installation of wind farms in the mainland and for their integration into the landscape in such a way that the visual effect has the least possible impact. The cases of installation at inhabited islands and marine areas are also reported. Regarding the spatial planning of Small Hydroelectric Projects, the water districts with exploitable hydraulic potential and restrictions concerning the capacity of the water stream are defined. Criteria are set for the installation of these projects in such a way that the environmental burden is low, taking into account technical and geological constraints. Privileged areas for the installation of biomass\/biogas and geothermal energy projects are also reported.","author":["Baltas, A.","Dervos, A."],"organization":["Aristotle University of Thessaloniki"],"originationDate":"2012-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.510049900000","22.728774100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1389","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-farms-birds-evros-rhodopi-greece-preliminary-results","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.academia.edu\/22356092\/Impacts_of_Wind_Farms_on_Birds_in_Evros_and_Rhodopi_Greece_Preliminary_Results","title":"Impacts of Wind Farms on Birds in Evros and Rhodopi, Greece: Preliminary results","description":"According to European policy, wind farms are a promising alternative energy source. Wind farms can be considered as \u201cgreen\u201d energy but in some cases, especially in areas where protected species of fauna occurs, some problems can rise. In this study the impact of two wind farms on a raptor community in northeastern Greece is presented. The study area is located in Evros and Rhodopi prefectures, Greece, close to the last breeding colony of Eurasian Black Vulture Aegypius monachus in the Balkans (National Park of DadiaSoufli-Lefkimi). The main objective was to determine the impacts of these wind farms on the raptor population. Is focused on: (1) death of birds through collision with the turbines; (2) evaluation of risky behaviour and risk factors; (3) changes in the use of the habitat and evaluation of habitat loss due to the wind farms, and (4) proposing measures to reduce the impacts once the risk factors are detected. Two viewpoints were selected in each wind farm, overlooking the major part of the turbines. We visited the viewpoints during 52 days of fieldwork, 4 hours each time. In addition, a fix group of turbines was walked in every visit to search for dead birds. The data collected include species, number, sex, age, type and height of flight and activity of all observed raptors. Additionally if the birds had been observed close to the turbines or crossing the \u201crow\u201d, some other variables has been collected, like the closest turbine, the distance to the turbine, etc. The results of this study cover the breeding season, summer and autumn 2004. No raptors were found dead. Because of this, it is impossible to relate risk events directly with mortality and a low mortality can be expected. Most of the birds detected in the risk area were local birds. High proportion of detected birds in the risk area crossed the turbines, thus the effect of the windmills on the behaviour of the birds is supposed to be rather low. Many movements of the raptors occurred close to the outermost turbines, but many vultures were observed to cross the lines in the gaps of the lines.","author":["Schindler, S.","Poirazidis, K.","Ruiz, G."],"organization":["WWF Greece"],"originationDate":"2006-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.102091200000","25.223688300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1390","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-bat-conservation-review-canadian-wind-energy-association","sourceURL":"","title":"Wind Energy and Bat Conservation - A Review by the Canadian Wind Energy Association","description":"The Canadian Wind Energy Association (CanWEA) has developed this Wind Energy and Bat Conservation Review (\u201cReview\u201d) to address uncertainties regarding the interactions between wind energy development and bat populations. The Review provides the wind industry, policy makers, and other stakeholders with a scientific and ecological approach to supporting renewable energy production to meet Canada\u2019s commitment to provide citizens with clean energy alternatives, while minimizing the potential for impacts to bats. This Review provides a comprehensive and objective summary of the body of scientific and practical knowledge pertaining to bats and wind energy gained over the last several decades, and provides a structured process for incorporating this knowledge into effective strategies.  Wind energy has become the largest source of new electricity generation in Canada over the last decade. Wind energy is a near zero-emission energy source that can help reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from the electricity sector. At the same time, concern about the potential impacts of wind energy on bats has increased with the rapid pace of wind development across Canada, the United States (U.S.), and Europe. Whereas it is generally recognized that wind energy facilities pose a lower risk to bat population sustainability than other sources of bat mortality, including white-nose syndrome (WNS), environmental contaminants, habitat loss, and the ongoing impacts of climate change, the wind industry recognizes that wind energy facilities can have direct and indirect effects on bats and their habitats, and continues to seek ways to avoid or minimize these impacts.  Regulatory agencies in several Canadian jurisdictions have taken steps to establish guidelines and protocols to minimize potential impacts to bats. Although it is appealing to have standardized approaches to avoidance and minimization, these guidelines are often based on the findings of a limited number of early bat studies in the U.S. or other regions with different ecological conditions. The goal of the Review is to provide current information and an adaptive management approach that incorporates new research and technology into the development of effective strategies to conserve bat populations. Therefore, this Review has the following objectives: 1) facilitate sound policy discussions and flexible mitigation plans across the country, 2) provide avoidance and minimization, and compensation options for varying circumstances, 3) enhance existing information in order to drive science-based policy decisions, and 4) support updates and revisions of provincial and\/or federal guidelines pertaining to bats and wind energy. It is anticipated that reference to this Review can better position the wind industry, regulatory agencies, and other stakeholders to make individual project decisions based on the best-available science. This will result in more efficient, targeted bat conservation, will provide the industry with more predictable project costs and expectations, and will allow Canada to continue to expand renewable energy development using sustainable, science-based approaches to project siting and operations.","author":["Hill, M.","Peters, K.","Barnes, R."],"organization":["DNV GL","Canadian Wind Energy Association (CanWEA)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-13","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.536676200000","-119.670955200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/canweaetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1391","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/thinking-globally-siting-locally-renewable-energy-biodiversity-rapidly-warming-world","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10584-014-1127-y","title":"Thinking Globally and Siting Locally - Renewable Energy and Biodiversity in a Rapidly Warming World","description":"Increasing greenhouse gas emissions are projected to raise global average surface temperatures by 3\u00b0\u20134 \u00b0C within this century, dramatically increasing the extinction risk for terrestrial and freshwater species and severely disrupting ecosystems across the globe. Limiting the magnitude of warming and its devastating impacts on biodiversity will require deep emissions reductions that include the rapid, large-scale deployment of low-carbon renewable energy. Concerns about potential adverse impacts to species and ecosystems from the expansion of renewable energy development will play an important role in determining the pace and scale of emissions reductions and hence, the impact of climate change on global biodiversity. Efforts are underway to reduce uncertainty regarding wildlife impacts from renewable energy development, but such uncertainty cannot be eliminated. We argue the need to accept some and perhaps substantial risk of impacts to wildlife from renewable energy development in order to limit the far greater risks to biodiversity loss owing to climate change. We propose a path forward for better reconciling expedited renewable energy development with wildlife conservation in a warming world.","author":["Allison, T.","Root, T.","Frumhoff, P."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)","Stanford University","Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS)"],"originationDate":"2014-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1392","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/key-seabird-areas-southern-new-england-identified-using-community-occupancy-model","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v533\/p277-290\/","title":"Key Seabird Areas in Southern New England Identified Using a Community Occupancy Model","description":"Seabirds are of conservation concern, and as new potential risks to seabirds are arising, the need to provide unbiased estimates of species\u2019 distributions is growing. We applied community occupancy models to detection\/non-detection data collected from repeated aerial strip-transect surveys conducted in 2 large study plots off southern New England, USA; one off the coast of Rhode Island and the other in Nantucket Sound. A total of 17 seabird species were observed at least once in each study plot. We found that detection varied by survey date and effort for most species and the average detection probability across species was less than 0.4. We estimated the influence of water depth, sea surface temperature, and sea surface chl a concentration on species-specific occupancy. Diving species showed large differences between the 2 study plots in their predicted winter distributions, which were largely explained by water depth acting as a stronger predictor of occupancy in Rhode Island than in Nantucket Sound. Conversely, similarities between the 2 study plots in predicted winter distributions of surface-feeding species were explained by sea surface temperature or chlorophyll aconcentration acting as predictors of these species\u2019 occupancy in both study plots. We predicted the number of species at each site using the observed data in order to detect \u2018hot-spots\u2019 of seabird diversity and use in the 2 study plots. These results provide new information on detection of species, areas of use, and relationships with environmental variables that will be valuable for biologists and planners interested in seabird conservation in the region.","author":["Paton, P.","Winiarski, K.","Allison, T.","O\u0027Connell, A.","Gardner, B.","Flanders, N."],"organization":["North Carolina State University","Old Dominion University","University of Massachusetts","University of Rhode Island","US Geological Survey (USGS)","American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2015-08-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.161383700000","-74.793420900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1393","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impact-capacity-analysis-renewable-energy-resources-case-study-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.semanticscholar.org\/paper\/Environmental-impact-and-capacity-analysis-of-Case-De%C4%9Firmenci\/a354fb42979a38347003ec4f696c941a1478c8de","title":"Environmental impact and capacity analysis of renewable energy resources: Case study of wind energy in Turkey","description":"The majority of electricity in Turkey is generated from coal and natural gas; however, renewable energy, especially wind power, is a promising energy source for Turkey. Development of new wind energy project requires complex planning process involving many social, technical, economic, environmental, political concerns and different agents such as investors, utilities, governmental agencies or social groups. To address the proper site selection, a Geographic Information System (GIS) based Multi- Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) method has been used in previous studies. The aim of this study is to develop a GIS-based multi-criteria decision making application which can be updated by the changing regulations to identify potential sites for wind power plants in Turkey. A variety of constraints and factors were identified based on a literature review, regulations and gathered from variety of agencies. After excluding of infeasible sites, pairwise comparisons was carried out using analytic hierarchy process (AHP) as MCDM method by the study group to estimate relative importance of the criteria. The suitability map obtained from MCDM analysis was divided into four classes from the low suitable to extremely suitable area. As a final stage, decision making was carried out with the objectives by environmental impact approach. The output of this study can be used by energy planners to estimate the extent that wind energy can be developed based on public perception, administrative and environmental aspects.","author":["Degirmenci, S."],"organization":["Izmir Institute of Technology"],"originationDate":"2016-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.963738000000","35.243319000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/thesis-Degirmenci-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1394","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-wildlife-20-years-translational-ecology-action","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/fee.1919","title":"Wind Energy and Wildlife: 20 Years of Translational Ecology in Action","description":"Frontiers\u2019 Special Issue on translational ecology (TE) focused on the urgent need for \u201ceffective translation between good science and informed practice\u201d. As scientists, practitioners, and conveners dedicated to facilitating wind energy development while protecting wildlife, we read that issue with the exciting ring of recognition. We commend such work that advances TE and would like to offer a few supporting observations, based on over 20 years of multi\u2010stakeholder collaboration in the area of wind energy and wildlife.","author":["Allison, T.","Arnold, A."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.801246300000","-102.735842100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1395","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/feasibility-appraisal-offshore-wind-farm-located-greece","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dione.lib.unipi.gr\/xmlui\/bitstream\/handle\/unipi\/10743\/Soursou_Panagiota.pdf","title":"Feasibility Appraisal of an Offshore Wind Farm Located in Greece","description":"The scope of this thesis is the realization of feasibility report about an installation of an offshore wind farm in the North Aegean Sea. This thesis illustrates what exactly contains a real market feasibility report, in order to convince the investors for the sustainability of an investment and the opportunity of gain profits. The next pages contain a brief presentation for the wind energy and technology inviting the reader to enter the terminology and the technology of wind farms. Apart from the literature review, there is a deep analysis of the wind industry, legislation, trends and a detailed analysis of the installation. The last chapter contains the financial analysis and deductions to defend or not the investment. For the convenience of the reader an executive summary is also provided.","author":["Soursou, P."],"organization":["University of Piraeus"],"originationDate":"2017-10-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.565163600000","24.412127700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/thesis-Soursou.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1396","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mortality-estimation-carcass-searches-using-r-package-carcass-tutorial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bioone.org\/journals\/Wildlife-Biology\/volume-21\/issue-1\/wlb.00094\/Mortality-estimation-from-carcass-searches-using-the-R-package-carcass\/10.2981\/wlb.00094.full","title":"Mortality estimation from carcass searches using the R-package carcass - a tutorial","description":"This article is a tutorial for the R-package carcass. It starts with a short overview of common methods used to estimate mortality based on carcass searches. Then, it guides step by step through a simple example. First, the proportion of animals that fall into the search area is estimated. Second, carcass persistence time is estimated based on experimental data. Third, searcher efficiency is estimated. Fourth, these three estimated parameters are combined to obtain the probability that an animal killed is found by an observer. Finally, this probability is used together with the observed number of carcasses found to obtain an estimate for the total number of killed animals together with a credible interval.","author":["Huso, M.","Korner-Nievergelt, F.","Etterson, M.","Dalthorp, D.","Brinkmann, R.","Niermann, I.","Behr, O.","Korner-Nievergelt, P.","Roth, T."],"organization":["Oikostat GmbH","Swiss Ornithological Institute","Friedrich\u2013Alexander University Erlangen\u2013N\u00fcrnberg","Freiburg\u0027s Institute of Applied Animal Ecology","US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)","US Geological Survey (USGS)","Hintermann \u0026 Weber AG","Leibniz Universit\u00e4t Hannover"],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nievergeltetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1397","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farms-birds-updated-analysis-effects-wind-farms-birds-best-practice-guidance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/rm.coe.int\/1680746245","title":"Wind Farms and Birds: An Updated Analysis of the Effects of Wind Farms on Birds, and Best Practice Guidance on Integrated Planning and Impact Assessment","description":"This report is an update of \u2018Windfarms and Birds: An analysis of the effects of windfarms on birds, and guidance on environmental assessment criteria and site selection issues\u2019 (Langston \u0026amp; Pullan, 2003) that was presented to the Standing Committee at its 23rd Bern Convention Bureau meeting, and which informed Recommendation 109 (2004) on minimizing adverse effects of wind power generation on wildlife. In the ten years since the original report, there have been advances in wind energy technology and considerable further work on the science of wind energy\/avian interactions. Likewise, with the rapid growth of the wind energy industry in Europe, there has been a corresponding development of the policy environment and best practice for strategic planning and project development for wind energy. This new report attempts to bring these developments together in one place to help further understanding of potential conflicts and how these can be minimized to facilitate further growth of the wind energy industry whilst protecting and enhancing Europe\u2019s bird populations. \n\nThe report sets out best practice for the integrated planning and assessment of wind energy development in order to avoid or reduce conflicts with nature conservation interests. Vital elements include:\nStrategic planning of the wind energy industry and the use of best practice protocols for individual project site selection, to avoid or minimize conflicts with nature conservation interests;\nRobust Environmental Impact Assessment, including baseline studies, impact assessment and post construction monitoring; and\nIntegrated, inclusive and iterative project development taking full account of potential interactions with nature conservation through the entire project development process.","author":["Langston, R.","McCluskie, A.","Pullan, J.","Gove, B.","Scrase, I."],"organization":["BirdLife International","Council of Europe"],"originationDate":"2013-09-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:14:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WindFarmsBirds-Bern-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1398","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/process-based-vs-ad-hoc-methods-estimate-mortality-using-carcass-surveys-data-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0304380018302266","title":"Process-based vs. ad-hoc methods to estimate mortality using carcass surveys data: A review and a note about evidence complacency","description":"To quantify the rate at which wildlife die from anthropogenic sources like wind farms and poisoning, one may look for the carcasses. The number of detected carcasses, or the absence of carcasses, however needs to be corrected for imperfect detection and early removal by scavengers. To perform this correction, there exist more than a dozen \u201copen\u201d variants of the Lincoln-Petersen \u201cclosed-population\u201d capture-recapture estimator. These different variants typically yield very different results because they are based on different assumptions that end users do not always consider. I conduct a simulation study highlighting severe biases in Lincoln-Petersen type estimators when their assumptions are violated. Recent attempts to relax these assumptions within the closed-population capture-recapture paradigm involve increasingly complex analysis, yet the resulting modified estimators still apply to restricted settings only. By contrast, there is an abundant literature about flexible, process-based, open-population capture-recapture models and how to fit them to survey data using numerical likelihood optimization. My simulations illustrate the good performance of this approach, in the presence of complex sources of bias, for moderate sample sizes. I review existing guidelines to deal with sparser datasets. As a perspective, I use the example of bird mortality estimation in wind farms to argue that the lack of methodological consensus can set the stage for evidence complacency. Biostatisticians should strive to avoid the proliferation of alternative methods and instead work towards increasingly general and unified frameworks.","author":["Peron, G."],"organization":["Universite Claude Bernard Lyon 1"],"originationDate":"2018-09-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1399","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/classification-birds-bats-using-flight-tracks","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954115000692","title":"Classification of Birds and Bats Using Flight Tracks","description":"Classification of birds and bats that use areas targeted for offshore wind farm development is essential to evaluating the potential effects of development. The current approach to assessing the number and distribution of birds at sea is transect-surveys conducted by trained individuals in boats or planes, or analysis of imagery collected from aerial surveys. These methods can be costly and pose safety concerns so that observation times are limited to daylight hours and fair weather. We propose an alternative method based on analysis of thermal video that could be recorded autonomously. We present a framework for building models to classify birds and bats and their associated behaviors from their flight tracks. As an example, we developed a discriminant model for theoretical flight paths and applied it to data (N = 64 tracks) extracted from 5-minute video clips. The agreement between model- and observer-classified path types was initially only 41%, but it increased to 73% when small-scale jitter was censored and the number of different path types was reduced. Classification of 46 tracks of bats, swallows, gulls, and terns on average was 82% accurate, based on a jackknife cross-validation. Model classification of gulls and swallows (N 18) was on average 73% and 85% correct, respectively. Model classification of bats and terns (N = 4 and 2, respectively) was 94% and 91% correct, respectively; however, the variance associated with the tracks from these targets is poorly estimated. The models developed here should be considered preliminary because they are based on a small data set both in terms of the numbers of species and the identified flight tracks. Future classification models could be improved if the distance between the camera and the target was known.","author":["Matzner, S.","Cullinan, V.","Duberstein, C."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.066854000000","-123.031359000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1400","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farms-thrace-updating-proposal-proper-site-selection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wwf.gr\/images\/pdfs\/2013_ProperSiteSelection.pdf","title":"Wind farms in Thrace: Updating the proposal for proper site selection","description":"The region of Thrace, in northeastern Greece, is of exceptional ornithological importance as it hosts habitats that are of European-wide significance mainly due to the presence of large birds of prey and aquatic birds, most of which are under protection and some of them are globally endangered.\n\nIndicative of the ornithological value of the region of Thrace is the presence of 3 out of 4 vulture species found in Europe. More specifically, (I) the last remaining breeding colony of the Black Vulture (Aegypius monachus) in the Balkans can be found in the Dadia-Lefkimi-Soufli National Park (from here on Dadia National Park) in the Regional unit (RU) of Evros, (II) the most important breeding colony of the Griffon Vulture (Gyps fulvs) in mainland Greece is located in the southern part of the RU of Evros, and (III) more than half of the last remaining breeding pairs of the Egyptian Vulture (Neophron percnopterus) in Greece are located inside the RUs of Evros and Rodopi.\n\nA large part of the region has been selected as priority area for the development of wind energy sources as it is one of the areas with the highest wind capacity in mainland Greece. Specifically, the biggest part of the RU of Evros and a part of the RU of Rodopi have been delineated as Wind Priority Area 1 (WPA 1) under the National Renewable Energy Spatial Pl;an framework. Within this area a significant number of wind farms (WFs) is already in operation. This number will increase considerably if the WFs that are at the planning stage are included.\u00a0\n\nWWF Greece (2013) believes that the development of renewable energy sources (RES) is important so that Greece can participate in the global efforts to mitigate climate change, to achieve a degree of energy safety and independence, as well as to enhance the wellbeing of people in the country. At the same time, WWF Greece emphasizes the need for a\u00a0careful WF site selection process based on certain prerequisites so as to avoid the potentially negative consequences on wildlife, especially on birds. As noted by the European Commission (EC 2010) and the IPCC (Wiser et al 2011) WFs can have a significant negative impact on birds, especially when WF site selection falls within areas of increased ornithological interest, such as the Special Protection Areas (SPA) of the EU Birds Directive (2009\/147\/EU).\n\nWith the present report the 2008 proposal is updated. The update is necessary given new facts that are now available based on recent research conducted by WWF Greece in the region, as well as because of changes in the national environmental legislation that introduced important measures for the protection of the bird fauna and in general biodiversity. The research finding point to the undisputed conclusion that the development of WFs in the RUs of Evros and Rodopi must be drastically reconsidered in order to ensure the survival of the bird species and safeguard the region\u0027s ecological integrity, which is both legally and ecologically mandatory. The new proposal aims to the best possible guide for the installation of WFs in the region of Thrace while at the same time assist in the enforcement of recent legislative additions.","author":["WWF Greece"],"organization":["WWF Greece"],"originationDate":"2013-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.131593000000","26.128781000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WWF-windfarms-Thrace.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1401","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/association-windmills-conservation-pollinating-insects-wild-plants-homogeneous","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s11356-017-0864-7","title":"The association of windmills with conservation of pollinating insects and wild plants in homogeneous farmland of western Poland","description":"Loss of suitable seminatural habitats and homogenization of crop types have led to the population decline of pollinating insects in farmland. As these insects support crop production, many practical efforts aim to sustain pollinator diversity which is especially challenging in intensively managed and homogeneous farmland. However, there are ongoing changes of the farmland toward its multifunctionality that includes, for example, wind farm development. Windmills are often built within crops; thus, we examined if the noncropped area around windmills can be valuable habitats for wild plants and pollinating insects: bees, butterflies, and flies. Species richness, abundances, and species diversity index of plants and pollinators around windmills were similar to those found in grassland patches (a typical habitat for these insects) and higher than in the adjacent crops. Pollinator diversity index and species richness at windmills increased with the distance to the nearest grassland patch and windmill. The population sizes of pollinating insects were also positively associated with plant diversity. Particular groups of pollinators showed specific habitat associations: bees occurred mostly at windmills, butterflies were highly associated with grasslands, while flies occurred in a similar number at windmill and on grasslands. Since windmills are frequently built within extensive homogeneous fields, thus, they introduce pollination services into the interior of cropped areas, contrary to field margins, road verges, or seminatural grasslands. Thus, although the development of wind farms has various negative environmental consequences, they can be alleviated by the increase of the local population size and diversity of wild plants and pollinating insects at windmills.","author":["Tryjanowski, P.","Pustkowiak, S.","Banaszak-Cibicka, W.","Mielczarek, L.","Skorka, P."],"organization":["Polish Academy of Sciences","Pozna\u0144 University of Life Sciences"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.943890000000","17.299440000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/pustkowiaketal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1402","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/role-islands-migration-bats-across-lake-erie-lake-ontario-lasiurus-borealis-lasiurus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.lib.uwo.ca\/do\/search\/?q=author_lname%3A%22Thorne%22%20AND%20author_fname%3A%22Toby%22\u0026start=0\u0026context=674312\u0026sort=date_desc\u0026facet=","title":"The Role of Islands in the Migration of Bats Across Lake Erie and Lake Ontario: Lasiurus borealis, Lasiurus cinereus and Perimyotis subflavus","description":"Large bodies of water, such as the Great Lakes in North America, are potential barriers to migrating bats. Islands may be used as stopover sites by bats crossing the Great Lakes as stopover sites, or included in crossing routes to reduce the distance flown over open water. I predicted that stopover use by migrating bats would result in higher activity on Great Lakes islands during late-season migration than at mainland sites. I monitored acoustic activity at 11 sites across four locations in Ontario: Amherst and Pelee islands, Kingston and Pinery Provincial Park during the summer (June and July), and during the putative late-season migration period (August and September). I found some evidence of migration by Lasiurus borealis and Perimyotis subflavus at Amherst Island, and by Perimyotis subflavus at Pelee Island. Islands may have occasional roles as stopover sites for migrating bats.","author":["Thorne, T."],"organization":["University of Western Ontario"],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.533741000000","-81.181905000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1403","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-sex-energy-environmental-conditions-movement-ecology-migratory-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.lib.uwo.ca\/etd\/4411\/","title":"The Effects of Sex, Energy, and Environmental Conditions on the Movement Ecology of Migratory Bats","description":"Lack of knowledge about the behaviour of migratory species during the migratory period is a major barrier to conservation efforts. In this thesis, I focus primarily on differences between the sexes of the bat Lasionycteris noctivagans, during spring migration. Females are pregnant during spring migration and this overlap between migration and reproduction may affect the time and energy management of females as compared to males. In Chapter 2, I examine spring migration phenology of bats at a stopover site. Females arrived earlier than males, likely to give their pups a long growing season. Fat stores appeared to reflect a strategy to provision for upcoming lactation demands. In Chapter 3, I explore stopover behaviour and I show that despite the use of torpor to minimize roosting energy expenditure, cold weather extends stopover duration. There was no sex difference in the length of time spent at stopover. By regressing the time of night bats were captured against their fat and lean mass I demonstrate that bats have greater fat and lean masses closer to dawn, and therefore are likely using stopover periods to refuel. In Chapter 4, I compare sex and seasonal differences in daytime torpor use at stopover. I found that in spring bats used torpor for fewer hours than in autumn, even after accounting for the effect of ambient temperature. Further, females used torpor for fewer hours than males. I propose that these seasonal differences are due to lower prey abundance and predictability in spring; sex differences may be attributable to a higher foraging intensity by females compared to males. Finally, in Chapter 5, I use a radiotelemetry array in southwestern Ontario, Canada to track the spring and autumn long distance migratory movements of L. noctivagans, Lasiurus borealis, and Lasiurus cinereus. No migration corridors were identified in either season. Estimated migration speeds indicate that multiday stopovers are also used in the autumn. These studies combined show that sex affects the spring migration time and energy management of bats. Bat migration research is still in its formative stages and my studies provide new information on bat migration in North America.","author":["Jonassan, K."],"organization":["University of Western Ontario"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.320220800000","-83.358251800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1404","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/day-year-temperature-wind-precipitation-predict-timing-bat-migration","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/jmammal\/article\/98\/5\/1236\/3797414","title":"Day of Year, Temperature, Wind, and Precipitation Predict Timing of Bat Migration","description":"Many temperate-climate bats migrate tens to hundreds of kilometers from hibernacula to summer habitat each spring and in the opposite direction each fall. Understanding the timing of migration can help reduce the risk of disturbance via anthropogenic activities, guide effective management, and determine future impacts of a changing climate. We examined the influence of weather and day of year on the arrival and departure of Indiana bats (Myotis sodalis) monitored at a summer maternity colony site in central Indiana from 1998 to 2014, using emergence count data to track the timing of bat presence during the spring and fall migration seasons. We used an information theoretic approach to compare 23 models that predicted bat presence as a function of weather, climate, and lunar illumination; these models predicted arrival of the first Indiana bat and the first observation of a colony in spring, and the last observation of a colony and the last bat observed in fall. Bats embarked on spring and fall migrations to the maternity colony area at approximately the same time each year (arriving ~3 April and departing ~7 October) and variation was accounted for by changes in weather. Spring arrival and colony formation were predicted by higher temperatures (\u2060x\u00afx\u00af = 22.5\u00b0C for colony formation) and precipitation and lower wind speeds, whereas lower temperatures (\u2060x\u00afx\u00af = 25.9\u00b0C for colony breakup) and precipitation and higher wind predicted colony breakup and departure in fall. Spring migration coincided with periods of increased winds and, thus, we advocate for higher cut-in speeds for wind turbines during bat migration seasons. Resource managers should consider the entire time that bats are on the summer landscape when defining regulations and implementing conservation measures.","author":["Pettit, J.","O\u0027Keefe, J."],"organization":["Indiana State University"],"originationDate":"2017-10-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.318010000000","-86.094009000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1405","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-impact-nine-established-wind-farms-birds-prey-thrace-greece","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wwf.gr\/images\/pdfs\/Assessing%20the%20impact%20of%20nine%20established%20wind%20farms%20on%20birds%20of%20prey%20in%20Thrace,%20Greece.%20WWF%20Greece,%20March%202011.pdf","title":"Assessing the impact of nine established wind farms on birds of prey in Thrace, Greece","description":"This study evaluates the impact on birds of prey of nine wind farms in Thrace, where a large scale wind farm development project of at least 960 MW is under development. The study area is located in the prefectures of Evros and Rhodope in Thrace, northeastern Greece and it is widely known for its high ornithological value. The \u201cNear threatened\u201d Black Vultures reproduce a few kilometers to the southeast of the area and they use it for foraging. This is currently the only Black Vulture population left in Southeast Europe. The area is also considered as the last stronghold of the \u201cEndangered\u201d Egyptian Vulture in Greece, with very important premigratory concentrations while it hosts the most important Golden Eagle breeding population in Greece. Approximately 50% of the wind farm development project area is covered by Natura 2000 sites. Carcass surveys around a selection of wind turbines in the study area were carried out by WWF Greece to estimate bird mortality. Results of the surveys were corrected for bias caused by the observers\u2019 detection ability and the scavenger removal activity. Trials to estimate the bias were performed. In addition, surveys of spatial use by birds were carried out. Indices of avian space use were then calculated and comparisons made between a previous monitoring study run by WWF Greece in 2004- 2005 and this study (hereafter also referred as \u201cfirst monitoring period\u201d and \u201csecond monitoring period\u201d respectively).","author":["Kret, E.","Carcamo, B.","Vasilakis, D.","Zografou, C."],"organization":["WWF Greece"],"originationDate":"2011-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.141200000000","25.914937000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WWF-windfarms-BOP-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1406","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-assessment-wind-farms-birds-prey-thrace-annual-report-august-2009-august-2010","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wwf.gr\/images\/pdfs\/Thrace.pdf","title":"Impact assessment of wind farms on birds of prey in Thrace. Annual Report August 2009 - August 2010","description":"There is currently an urgent need for climate change mitigation measures. Renewable energy sources, such as wind farms, are important components of such mitigation measures. The Greek Government has set targets for generation of renewable energy. Within this framework, a large part of Thrace (northeastern Greece) has been selected as a Wind Priority Area (WPA 1). It is known, however, that wind farm operation may have important impacts on bird populations, although effects may vary among sites and species. The primary aim of the present study was to determine the effect of wind farms on the mortality of birds of prey in Thrace. The study area is of extreme ornithological value, as the Rhodope and Evros prefectures show the greatest diversity of birds of prey in Greece and one of the richest in Europe, including the last Black Vulture breeding colony in the Balkans. Seven areas that belong to the NATURA 2000 network are either included within or partially overlap with the WPA 1, where the carrying capacity of the area has been established at 480 standard wind turbines (960MW in total). Carcass surveys around the wind turbines were carried out in order to estimate the mortality of birds of prey. The study area comprised 163 wind turbines in operation, 88 of which were monitored on a daily basis. The results of the surveys were corrected for the bias caused by the observers\u2019 detection ability and the scavenger removal activity. Correction factors were obtained through trials performed in previous WWF Greece\u2019s studies . In total, 9 birds of prey as well as 73 other birds and 186 bats were found dead due to collision with a wind turbine. There were differences in bird and bat mortality between wind farms. Following two different mortality equations, estimated and adjusted mortality rates of birds of prey were 0.152 and 0.173 birds per year per turbine. Daily searches have kept the effect of removal by scavengers and humans low. Carcass surveys, if possible on a daily basis, should be carried out at operating and future wind farms in order to monitor bird and bat mortality caused by collisions with wind turbines. It is essential to understand the effect of bird and bat wind turbine-caused mortality on their populations by conducting population viability studies.","author":["Kret, E.","Carcamo, B.","Vasilakis, D.","Doutau, B.","Kafkaletou-Diez, D."],"organization":["WWF Greece"],"originationDate":"2011-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.127433000000","26.221363000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WWF-windfarms-vultures2011-annual.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1407","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-environmental-human-impacts-wind-parks-case-study-prefecture-lasithi-crete","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032112001359","title":"A review of the environmental and human impacts from wind parks. A case study for the Prefecture of Lasithi, Crete","description":"A review of the wind parks\u2019 environmental and human impacts, based on extended research on the most recent relevant bibliography, is carried out in the present paper. The results of former studies are presented on:    the impact on the aesthetic of the landscape  the noise emissions  the impact on birds and wildlife  the shadow flicker from wind turbines  the occupation of land  the wind turbines electromagnetic interference.   In addition, the results of case studies for selected wind parks installed in the Prefecture of Lasithi in Crete, concerning their visual impacts and their noise emissions are presented. A statistical survey implemented in Crete concerning the public opinion on wind parks and wind energy is also presented. The accomplished tasks indicated:    There are no serious impacts caused by the installation or operation of wind parks. The wind parks\u2019 impacts may be eliminated with the optimum selection of the installation sites and the appropriate siting of the wind turbines.  People in Crete exhibit a strongly positive attitude towards wind energy and wind parks, although they are not willing to pay a higher price for the electricity produced from wind parks.   A map with the optimum sites for wind parks installation in the Prefecture of Lasithi was constructed, taking into account all possible restrictions concerning the use of land, the environmental conservation and the impacts on human life. This map can constitute a flexible tool for the optimum site selection for a wind park installation, contributing to the elimination of environmental and human impacts of new wind parks, to the minimization of the required project\u0027s licensing time and to the limitation of possible negative public reactions.","author":["Katsaprakakis, D."],"organization":["Technological Educational Institute of Crete"],"originationDate":"2012-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.081169000000","25.710179000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1408","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/avoidance-rates-collision-between-birds-offshore-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bto.org\/our-science\/publications\/research-reports\/avoidance-rates-collision-between-birds-and-offshore","title":"The Avoidance Rates of Collision Between Birds and Offshore Turbines","description":"The Scottish Government has a target for 100% of Scottish demand for electricity to be met from renewables by 2020 by creating a portfolio of both onshore and offshore technologies (Marine Scotland 2011). However, concern over the environmental impacts of these developments in the UK, and in particular the risk of birds colliding with wind turbines, has contributed to the delay and cancellation of some projects. This work aims to reduce the current level of uncertainty around appropriate avoidance rates for seabird species within collision risk modeling by providing a thorough review of the existing evidence base. The review identifies current knowledge gaps and aims to ensure that future strategic work is targeted at addressing the most appropriate issues. The primary objectives discussed in this report are:     Produce definitions for the types and scales of avoidance rates that will be used throughout the review document.  Review the current use of avoidance rates.  Review and critique existing avoidance behaviour studies and any derived rates.  Provide summary table\/s of individual avoidance rates and a final Total Avoidance Rate for each priority species\/species group.  Undertake an assessment of the sensitivity of the conclusions reached to inputs and conditions under which they were collected.  Applicability of avoidance rates to different collision risk models.","author":["Masden, E.","Burton, N.","Cook, A.","Humphreys, E."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","University of Stirling","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2014-12-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.984495900000","-1.595183900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Cook-et-al-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1409","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reconciling-endangered-species-conservation-wind-farm-development-cinereous-vultures","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320716300131","title":"Reconciling endangered species conservation with wind farm development: Cinereous vultures (Aegypius monachus) in south-eastern Europe","description":"Harnessing\u00a0wind energy\u00a0is seen as an environmentally friendly strategy to combat\u00a0climate change. However, adverse environmental impacts have come to light for species that are prone to collision with\u00a0wind turbine\u00a0blades, such as vultures, leading to a conflict between wind energy industry and conservation. Our study area epitomized such a conflict, containing the only population of cinereous vultures in south-eastern Europe while also being the location for substantial existing and planned\u00a0wind farms. We used long-term remote\u00a0telemetry\u00a0data to produce a species-specific sensitivity map for guiding wind energy development and to estimate vulture collision mortality due to currently operating wind farms. Most operational wind farms were in the population core area and in the highest priority areas for vulture conservation. Collision mortality due to the thirteen operating wind farms was estimated by combining global position system (GPS) telemetry data on vulture space use with a collision risk model (CRM). Estimated mortality varied greatly according to the CRM\u0027s \u2018avoidance rate\u2019. Under the most likely avoidance rates annual predicted collision mortality was 5\u201311% of the population, creating risk of\u00a0population decline. Collision mortality was expected almost exclusively in the population core area, rendering further future development plans there severely problematic for vulture population persistence. Our sensitivity map, as a conservation prioritization system, offered a spatially explicit solution to the conflict between wind energy development and vulture conservation. Combining spatial use models derived from telemetry data with collision mortality models offers a novel conservation tool for evaluating large scale wind energy development proposals.","author":["Whitfield, D.","Vasilakis, D.","Kati, V.","Schindler, S.","Poirazidis, K."],"organization":["University of Patras","Natural Research Ltd","University of Vienna","Environment Agency Austria","Technological Educational Institute of Ionian Islands"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.252675000000","25.901232000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1410","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-energy-development-site-assessment-characterization-evaluation-current","sourceURL":"https:\/\/espis.boem.gov\/final%20reports\/5305.pdf","title":"Offshore Wind Energy Development Site Assessment and Characterization: Evaluation of the Current Status and European Experience","description":"The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) hosted this workshop to engage with European scientists and regulators who have experience in offshore wind energy projects. The goal of this workshop was for BOEM to learn from the European experience with offshore wind development about the types of information that should be gathered during site assessment and characterization activities that best informs decisions about the siting of offshore wind facilities and potential mitigation measures. Three areas of particular interest were the focus of this workshop \u2013 birds, benthic habitats, and archaeology. These areas were selected because of the timeliness with respect to the preparation and release of BOEM guidelines for information collection. While the current focus is on pre-construction information collection, BOEM recognizes that this information is also the foundation for post-construction impact evaluation.  BOEM sought to learn from the European experience in order to maximize the potential success of U.S.-based offshore renewable energy. Participation during the workshop of individuals representing five of the six European countries with operating offshore wind energy facilities enabled BOEM to compare and contrast strategies for site assessment activities and managing the stewardship of environmental and archaeological resources on the OCS. The workshop was held on February 26-28, 2013 at the Crowne Plaza in Herndon, Virginia. The workshop as attended by approximately 110 persons, including the 17 invited European experts who were at the core the technical subject breakout sessions. The workshop started with a plenary session for all attendees during which some key BOEM managers welcomed the participants and provided an overview of BOEM\u2019s goals for the workshop. The first morning\u2019s plenary session was followed by a day and a half of detailed technical discussion in the three separate subject matter breakout sessions: avian, benthic habitats, and archaeological resources. The technical breakout sessions each followed a general format where invited European experts discussed a list of questions that had been developed by BOEM technical staff prior to the workshop. As a result of the different technical subject topics and the diversity among the scientists, regulators and other participants in the sessions, each of the individual breakout sessions progressed in somewhat different fashion.  BOEM\u2019s goal for the third morning of the workshop was to use a model that is being developed to evaluate the wide array of factors and to assess methods of bringing together the three different topical areas into a cohesive method for communicating decisions regarding offshore wind siting. After a presentation about the model, the breakout groups discussed how their particular resource of interest could be incorporated in the model and the challenges that arise.  Within the avian break out session, the most widely agreed upon point between the European experts was the need for robust survey designs that clearly define the conditions under which surveys will be carried out and also those conditions that are unsuitable for avian surveys. Once surveys have been completed the results should be made available to insure consistency in the quality of data and allow better functionality for review and conclusions, publication of data collection methods, protocols, and results should be required. There was also significant general agreement that both pre- and post-construction surveys should be tightly focused on answering specific questions about effects of wind farms by comparison of pre- and post-construction data.  In essence, no preconstruction survey should be undertaken without knowing what is desired to be known from the post-construction survey and how the post-construction survey will be conducted. Experience has shown the Europeans that pre-construction surveys did not provide the right data for comparisons with post-construction information. Furthermore, there was also strong general agreement that surveys must include a large enough area around a wind farm, not just the actual proposed project footprint because birds are often clumped and may use different areas within the vicinity of the wind farm from year-to-year.  From the benthic habitat break out session, the following suggestions were made relative to guiding the collection and assessment of benthic data during the offshore wind farm development process:    Need to accept some level of impact. Local effect likely, but may not be meaningful at the regional scale. Focus effort to understand\/evaluate ecosystem service.  If you want to detect a change, define a change to monitor for, don\u2019t just monitor. Need to find a cause and effect within a wind farm area to understand\/monitor.  If you don\u2019t have enough information to establish impact thresholds, take an adaptive management approach. Adapt policy\/regulations as you learn more. If regulations are too stringent, you may end up monitoring for illogical parameters.  Develop an inventory of knowledge gaps and design monitoring program to fill in gaps. Possibly coordinate monitoring efforts across individual developers to ensure robust monitoring at the proper scale.   Participants in the marine archaeology sessions agreed that the discussion in this session was tremendously beneficial for both the Americans and the Europeans. It is strongly recommended that this line of communication be maintained for the benefit of both groups. The Europeans acknowledged that their industry has developed numerous conventions that are not always evident, but that a forum such as this forces reflection and consideration of better alternatives. Similarly, the Americans acknowledged that qualified researchers and reviewers (technical experts) are very limited in this country and that collaboration with European counterparts will be a tremendously valuable strategy for managing this resource limitation until the US offshore renewable energy industry becomes more mature. Marine archaeology is highly interdisciplinary and requires a high degree of technical specialty. Based on the discussion, it is evident that the remote sensing requirements are well established but that the physical sampling required to identify human activity is the biggest challenge facing marine archaeologists. Definitive indicators of human activity are required to differentiate paleolandforms from submerged archaeological sites. Finally, good archaeology and good development are not contradictions. BOEM and developers working together forms a starting point. Combining information from multiple surveys to feed common goals will help historic property identification surveys become more efficient and minimize the perception of burden.  The workshop provided an opportunity for BOEM and other Federal agencies, as well as the interested public, to discuss key questions about offshore wind development with scientists and regulators from Europe, who have direct experience. The format of the workshop allowed for an interactive opportunity to fully discuss, beyond the initial questions posed, the lessons learned from the experience of European colleagues in siting, permitting, developing, and operating offshore wind energy projects. While much was learned, the most important lesson was that we 3 must maintain the lines of communication and continue to learn from each other as wind development progresses into new areas, with new technologies.","author":["Wilson, S.","Rein, C.","Lundin, A.","Kimbrell, E."],"organization":["Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2013-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BOEM-2013-0010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1411","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/eagles-wind-energy-identifying-research-priorities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/260364751_Eagles_and_Wind_Energy_Identifying_Research_Priorities","title":"Eagles and Wind Energy: Identifying Research Priorities","description":"The Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act prohibits the taking (killing, wounding, or disturbing) of bald and golden eagles without a permit. Eagles can be killed by wind turbines, yet, as the most commercially viable and scalable form of renewable energy, wind power is critical to addressing climate change, a major threat to eagles and other wildlife. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) has developed a framework for permitting lawful take and conserving eagles and has recently proposed regulations for the issuance of eagle take permits where the take is associated with an otherwise lawful activity, such as wind energy. Helping to reconcile the goals of wind energy development and eagle conservation is an urgent priority of the American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI) and its partners. This white paper and the November 2011 AWWI Eagle Workshop at which an earlier working draft was discussed draw on input from scientific experts on bald and golden eagles to define the technical issues around wind energy development and eagles, and to identify research that would improve implementation of and compliance with the Service\u2019s Eagle Guidance.  We summarize information about the population status and trends of bald and golden eagles and discuss \u201ctake\u201d threshold in terms of eagle management units. We review anthropogenic sources of eagle mortality along with estimated magnitude of take from wind energy and from leading sources such as electrocution, collision, shooting, and poisoning. Potential mitigation options are identified. Research topics considered include: a) identifying and addressing information gaps on demography and status relevant to calculating take thresholds; b) developing unbiased estimates of eagle mortality; c) creating models for siting and operational strategies that avoid or minimize eagle fatalities at wind energy facilities; d) expanding options for compensatory mitigation; and e) coordinating and enhancing existing collaborative eagle research.  Because bald eagle populations appear to be thriving, Eagle Workshop participants recommend that AWWI emphasize research on golden eagles that is directly relevant to wind energy development. The white paper concludes that AWWI should focus over the next 12 months on expanding options for compensatory mitigation while continuing to identify, support, and collaborate with other research initiatives, as appropriate.","author":["Allison, T."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2012-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.204149200000","-85.409428400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Allison_et_al_2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1412","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-vulnerability-marine-bird-community-western-north-sea-climate-change-other","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v507\/p277-295\/","title":"Assessing the Vulnerability of the Marine Bird Community in the Western North Sea to Climate Change and Other Anthropogenic Impacts","description":"Ocean warming and anthropogenic activities such as fishing, shipping and marine renewable developments are affecting marine top predators. Research has focussed on the impacts of single stressors on single species, yet understanding cumulative effects of multiple stressors on communities is vital for effective conservation management. We studied a marine bird community (45 species; 11 families) that used the Forth and Tay region of the North Sea for breeding, overwintering or migration between 1980 and 2011. Local sea surface temperature (SST) increased significantly over this period, with concomitant changes in lower trophic levels. Simultaneously, the region has been subject to fishing pressure and shipping disturbance and is a priority area for renewable energy developments. We used colony-based and at-sea data to quantitatively assess relationships between SST and counts, productivity and survival of 25 species for which sufficient data were available for analysis. For the remaining species, we applied a qualitative approach using published population trends, published climate relationships and foraging sensitivity. In total, 53% of species showed negative relationships with SST. Trends in counts and demography were combined with climate vulnerability to give an index of population concern to future climate warming, and 44% of species were classified as high or very high concern, notably cormorants, grebes, skuas, shearwaters, terns and auks, as well as species breeding in the region. Qualitative assessments of vulnerability to fisheries, pollutants, disturbance (including introduced predators), marine renewables and climate found that 93% of species were vulnerable to \u0026gt;= 2 threats, and 58% to \u0026gt;= 4. Our results indicate that the majority of birds in this region of the North Sea face an uncertain future, potentially threatening the resilience of this important marine bird community.","author":["Daunt, F.","Wanless, S.","Butler, A.","Newell, M.","Burthe, S."],"organization":["UK Centre for Ecology \u0026 Hydrology (CEH)"],"originationDate":"2014-07-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.080924000000","-3.007291000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1413","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/approach-evaluating-changes-land-use-energy-sprawl-other-anthropogenic-activities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s12665-018-7323-8","title":"An approach for evaluating changes in land-use from energy sprawl and other anthropogenic activities with implications for biotic resource management","description":"This study presents a novel approach for evaluating land-use changes caused by energy development and other anthropogenic activities. We illustrate this technique by assessing the landscape footprint of energy development in the Eagle Ford Shale Play and Permian Basin of Texas, which saw rapid expansion in drilling during 2008-2012. We compare changes in land-use from oil and gas infrastructure construction during this time period with that of wind energy development in West Texas, urbanization in Central Texas, and extensive agricultural areas. Previous studies often use land-use proxies when comparing the footprint of energy infrastructure (e.g., 1 km(2) gridded well density or proposed wind project footprints) with other anthropogenic land-change. This study presents animproved technique because it compares high-resolution datasets of agricultural activity and urbanization with mapped-not surrogate-land-change from oil and gas and wind power infrastructure using high-resolution (1 m) aerial imagery. We found that changes in land-use caused by anthropogenic factors affected 1.06% (3456 km(2)) of the similar to 324,000 km(2) study area. Oil and gas development (well pads and pipelines) was similar to 48% of total changes in land-use (but did not account for access roads), changes in agriculture caused similar to 26%, and urbanization was similar to 24%. Construction of wind turbine pads and high voltage power transmission lines was less important (similar to 1%). We illustrate this approach for a single species (i.e., Spot-tailed Earless Lizard, Holbrookia lacerata) in Texas. This study is part of an ongoing, multi-year research program generating science to inform the federal Endangered Species Act listing decision for H. lacerata. Additionally, this technique can facilitate effective management of a variety of biotic resources inother rapidly developing environments globally by identifying what anthropogenic activities are most important and where land-change is most intense so that on-the-ground conservation strategies can be implemented where they are needed most.","author":["Wolaver, B.","Pierre, J.","Labay, B.","LaDuc, T.","Duran, C.","Ryberg, W.","Hibbits, T."],"organization":["University of Texas","The Nature Conservancy","Texas A\u0026M University","Siglo Group"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Reptiles","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1414","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-bat-impacts-behaviors-old-wind-turbines-forebay-altamont-pass-wind-resource-area","sourceURL":"https:\/\/lccn.loc.gov\/2017473365","title":"Bird and Bat Impacts and Behaviors at Old Wind Turbines at Forebay, Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area","description":"Wind is a clean, renewable energy resource that is expanding rapidly in California and nationwide. However, high numbers of fatal bird and bat collisions with wind turbines have led to cancellations or permitting delays for many wind energy projects. Because the likelihood of such fatal collisions depends upon complex interactions between site characteristics, turbine design, and animal behavior, the two most promising approaches to reducing collisions risks are to carefully site new wind turbines and to develop new wind turbines designs that reduce collision risk.  The original goal of this study was to test whether a new shrouded wind turbine design would reduce avian and bat collisions; unfortunately, before installation of the new wind turbines could occur, the wind project was cancelled. Following this, the researchers then analyzed the collected data to explore whether variation in fatality rates can be explained by bird and bat flight patterns and avoidance behaviors. This information was then used to map collision hazards in the study portion of the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area to inform the siting of new and repowered wind turbines. The researchers also sought to improve collision risk estimation methods by conducting integrated trials to determine bird and bat carcass detection probabilities, assessing whether body mass can serve as a predictor of detection rate variables, quantifying species identification, and reducing estimation errors when fatality rates occur. The results of this research improve current understanding of bird and bat mortality rates at wind turbine sites and provide a template for guiding the siting of new and repowered turbines to minimize wildlife fatalities throughout the state.","author":["Smallwood, K.","Neher, L."],"organization":["California Energy Commission","California Energy Commission"],"originationDate":"2016-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/smallwood.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1415","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/threats-industrial-wind-turbines-ontarios-wildlife-biodiversity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/docs.wind-watch.org\/stelling-petrie-policy-guidance-document-final.pdf","title":"Threats From Industrial Wind Turbines to Ontario\u0027s Wildlife and Biodiversity","description":"The precautionary principle outlined in The Bergen Agreement, signed by Canada in 1990, has become, over the past fifteen years, part of customary international law and has been included in virtually every recently adopted treaty and policy document related to the protection and preservation of the environment. It states: \u0022policies must be based on the precautionary principle. Environmental measures must anticipate, prevent and attack the causes of environmental degradation. Where there are threats of serious or irreversible damage, lack of full scientific certainty should not be used as a reason for postponing measures to prevent environmental degradation\u0022. The unprecedented rapidity with which industrial wind turbine developments are being proposed and constructed in Ontario, raises major concerns about the efficacy of the Green Energy Act which has allowed and promoted this phenomenon.","author":["Stelling, K.","Petrie, S."],"organization":["University of Western Ontario","Bird Studies Canada"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.320220800000","-83.358251800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Stelling_and_Petrie_2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1416","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparing-field-methods-used-determine-bird-bat-fatalities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60351-3_6","title":"Comparing Field Methods Used to Determine Bird and Bat Fatalities","description":"Wind energy production across the globe has grown over the years and Portugal is no exception. Like other forms of energy production, wind energy causes ecological impacts and these impacts are a matter of major concern. One of the impacts caused by operating wind farms is bird and bat casualties due to collision with the wind turbines. Since real mortality is very difficult to determine, due to the impossibility of detecting all carcasses and the probability of carcass disappearance before being detected, field methods for collecting data and estimating mortality have been implemented. Regular searches around wind turbines are implemented to detect carcasses. The protocol of searches must define the size of the searched area, the search method, the duration and frequency of the searches according to guidelines and the objectives of each study. To correct the observed mortality and estimate real mortality, correction factors, such as the probability of carcass persistence or the carcass detection rate, must be assessed by field trials. For Portugal, a search area of 5\u00a0m more than blade length and random walk or zig-zag methods resulted in a cost-effective way to collect carcasses. A frequency of 1\u20133\u00a0days is recommended in order to reduce the bias of mortality estimates. If a considerable number of removal trials had to be carried out, camera-trapping was revealed to be a cost-effective method. Otherwise, a carefully planned traditional method also obtained accurate estimates. For detection trials, the use of models is recommended and the number of models and the design should be adapted to homogeneity or heterogeneity of vegetation cover.\n\nClick here for more on the book Biodiversity and Wind Farms in Portugal: Current Knowledge and Insights for an Integrated Impact Assessment Process.\u00a0","author":["Bispo, R.","Mascarenhas, M.","Paula, J.","Neves, T.","Augusto, M.","Cardoso, P."],"organization":["Bioinsight","University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.527775500000","-9.428595100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1417","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-environmental-impact-report-hatchet-ridge-wind-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.shastacounty.gov\/planning\/page\/final-environmental-impact-report-hatchet-ridge-wind-project","title":"Final Environmental Impact Report for the Hatchet Ridge Wind Project","description":"The Shasta County Department of Resource Management (County) is the lead agency under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for the environmental review of the Hatchet Ridge Wind Project and has principal responsibility for approving the project. This document, together with the draft environmental impact report (EIR) for the Hatchet Ridge Wind Project that was circulated in December 2007, constitutes the final EIR (FEIR) for the Hatchet Ridge Wind Project in Shasta County. The information presented in this document has been provided in accordance with the requirements of CEQA and the State CEQA Guidelines.Cover pageTitle pageTable of contentsChapter 1: IntroductionChapter 2: Responses to comments (pages 2-1 through 2-110)Chapter 2: Responses to comments (pages 2-111 through 2-241)Chapter 3: Revisions to EIRFigure 2-1Table 3-4-3Chapter 4: Mitigation, monitoring, and reporting programAppendix AAppendix BAppendix CAppendix D","author":["Shasta County Department of Resource Management"],"organization":["Shasta County Department of Resource Management"],"originationDate":"2008-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.862040900000","-121.799340300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-30 09:02:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/cover_page.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/title_page.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/table_of_contents.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/1._introduction.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2._responses_to_comments_pages_2-111_thru_2-241.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2._responses_to_comments_pages_2-1_thru_2-110_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/3._revisions_to_the_eir.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/figure_2-1.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/table_3-4-3.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/4._mitigation_monitoring_and_reporting_program.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/appendix_a.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/appendix_b.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/appendix_c.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/appendix_d.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1418","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/habitat-mapping-assessment-northeast-wind-energy-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nefsc.noaa.gov\/press_release\/pr2018\/features\/wind-energy-areas-report\/","title":"Habitat Mapping and Assessment of Northeast Wind Energy Areas","description":"Background: The U.S Department of Interior, Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) has issued leases in eight Wind Energy Areas (WEA) along the Northwest Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) from Massachusetts to North Carolina, encompassing \u0026gt;7,000 square km of seafloor for offshore renewable energy (ORE) development. While BOEM is responsible for regulating the development of offshore energy within each of these areas, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) Fisheries is charged with managing and protecting the nation\u2019s living marine resources. At the intersection of these two responsibilities, BOEM and NOAA Fisheries are working closely to ensure that offshore resources are sustainably managed as nascent ORE industries develop.  Project Goals and Objectives: To that end, the NOAA Northeast Fisheries Science Center (NEFSC), in collaboration with Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution and the University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth School for Marine Science and Technology (SMAST), has developed a comprehensive multi-scale benthic assessment of the eight Atlantic OCS WEAs. The goal of this partnership is to increase the understanding of the current benthic structure, function and valued resources within the Atlantic WEA network, prior to development. From new and existing data sources, NOAA NEFSC has established a contemporary and comprehensive benthic habitat database that can serve as a baseline for evaluating the potential impacts of ORE construction, operation and decommissioning to benthic marine resources. Being implemented in three phases, this study characterizes the 1) abiotic components, 2) biotic components and 3) abiotic-biotic relations (between habitat and fauna) that will support ecosystem-level assessments and cumulative impact analyses for all eight WEAs. The following report describes a broad-brush assessment of benthic habitats within eight proposed WEAs in the National Marine Fisheries Service Greater Atlantic Region (BOEM Northeast and Mid-Atlantic Planning Areas). The goal of this project is to provide the data necessary to establish a contemporary and comprehensive benthic habitat database for the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) Wind Energy Areas (WEAs) in the northeastern region of the United States in order to provide insight into benthic environmental issues and potential impacts associated wind power development on the continental shelf. Our investigations included the following WEAs: Massachusetts (MA), Rhode Island \u2013 Massachusetts (RIMA), New York (NY), New Jersey (NJ), Delaware (DE), Maryland (MD), Virginia (VA), and North Carolina \u2013 Kitty Hawk (NC-KH). The database is established at the J.J. Howard Laboratory of the Northeast Fisheries Science Center.","author":["Johnson, D.","Guida, V.","Drohan, A.","Welch, H.","McHenry, J.","Kentner, V.","Brink, J.","Timmons, D.","Pessutti, J.","Fromm, S.","Estela-Gomez, E."],"organization":["BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.861321100000","-79.156987000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Ecosystem Processes","Fish","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Guida-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1419","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-environmental-impact-onshore-offshore-wind-farms-texas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2071-1050\/10\/6\/2022","title":"Life Cycle Environmental Impact of Onshore and Offshore Wind Farms in Texas","description":"The last decade witnessed a quantum increase in wind energy contribution to the U.S. renewable electricity mix. Although the overall environmental impact of wind energy is miniscule in comparison to fossil-fuel energy, the early stages of the wind energy life cycle have potential for a higher environmental impact. This study attempts to quantify the relative contribution of individual stages toward life cycle impacts by conducting a life cycle assessment with SimaPro\u00ae and the Impact 2002+ impact assessment method. A comparative analysis of individual stages at three locations, onshore, shallow-water, and deep-water, in Texas and the gulf coast indicates that material extraction\/processing would be the dominant stage with an average impact contribution of 72% for onshore, 58% for shallow-water, and 82% for deep-water across the 15 midpoint impact categories. The payback times for CO2 and energy consumption range from 6 to 14 and 6 to 17 months, respectively, with onshore farms having shorter payback times. The greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) were in the range of 5\u20137 gCO2eq\/kWh for the onshore location, 6\u20139 CO2eq\/kWh for the shallow-water location, and 6\u20138 CO2eq\/kWh for the deep-water location. A sensitivity analysis of the material extraction\/processing stage to the electricity sourcing stage indicates that replacement of lignite coal with natural gas or wind would lead to marginal improvements in midpoint impact categories.","author":["Chipindula, J.","Botlaguduru, V.","Du, H.","Kommalapati, R.","Huque, Z."],"organization":["Prairie View A\u0026M University"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["28.748075500000","-98.350040700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-10 11:11:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Chipindula-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1421","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/second-year-post-construction-monitoring-bats-birds-wind-turbine-test-centre-osterild","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dce2.au.dk\/pub\/SR232.pdf","title":"Second year post-construction monitoring of bats and birds at Wind Turbine Test Centre \u00d8sterild","description":"The Department of Bioscience, Aarhus University was commissioned by the Danish Nature Agency to undertake a bat and bird monitoring programme of a national test centre for wind turbines near \u00d8sterild in Thy, Denmark. Here we present the results from the second and final year of the post-construction studies. A total of ten bat species were recorded in 2013-2014. Species composition and occurrence were comparable to the results obtained during the pre-construction survey in 2011. Bats were recorded at all turbine sites and on all nights at surveyed ponds and lakes. Overall, the bat activity level decreased from 2013 to 2014 to the levels recorded in 2011. Bat activity was higher near the wind turbines than at nearby forest edges. Bat activity at the turbines was correlated to aggregations of insects on the turbine towers, which suggest that bats exploit the food resources that accumulate on the turbine towers on some nights. Nathusius\u2019 pipistrelles and noctules were recorded at nacelle height. Two dead Nathusius\u2019 pipistrelles were found in 2014 at the southern turbine situated in forest. Whooper swan, taiga bean goose, pink-footed goose, common crane, light-bellied brent goose, white-tailed eagle and nightjar were included as focal species in the ornithological investigations. In addition, species specific data on all bird species occurring regularly in the study area were collected. On the basis of this final assessment of collision risk, the potential impacts of the combined structures on the bird species occurring in the study area were considered unlikely to be significant. We recommend that the mortality related to human developments on the white-tailed eagle, common crane and nightjar populations, particularly the impact of the continued development of wind energy in the region, is closely monitored in the future.\u00a0\n\nContents:\nPart A: Bats\u00a0(Authors:\u00a0M. Elmeros, J. Moller, \u0026 H. Baagoe)\u00a0- pg. 19\nPart B: Birds (Authors:\u00a0O. Therkildsen, T. Balsby, R. Nielsen, L. Haugaard, \u0026 J. Kjeldsen)\u00a0- pg. 47\nAppendicies and Tables - pg. 128","author":["Therkildsen, O.","Elmeros, M."],"organization":["Aarhus University","Aarhus University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.030145200000","8.838069800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Therkildsen-Elmeros-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1422","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-simulated-seal-scarer-sounds-harbour-porpoises","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dce2.au.dk\/pub\/SR247.pdf","title":"The Effect of Simulated Seal Scarer Sounds on Harbour Porpoises","description":"Pile driving of steel monopile foundations for offshore wind turbines is a recent, but very significant addition to anthropogenic noise sources in the ocean. The primary concern with respect to impact of pile driving noise is marine mammals, most notably small cetaceans, including the harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena).\n\nA significant potential effect of the pile driving noise is temporary habitat loss due to avoidance of the noise source. Another potential effect of pile driving is direct injury due to the sound pressure, which is sufficiently high to be able to induce temporary or permanent hearing loss.\n\nMitigation of injury from loud noise can be accomplished by three different methods: reduce the generated noise energy, reduce the radiated noise energy and reduce the received noise energy. Deterrence, by means of powerful seal scarers, belongs to the third type and has been used extensively for pile driving during construction of offshore wind farms in the North Sea and continues to be a key element in mitigation of noise induced injury. The objective of the seal scarer is to deter porpoises out to a safe distance from a pile driving site, before the pile driving itself starts.\n\nIn order to provide better estimates of the deterrence distance a so-called controlled exposure study was conducted at Helgen\u00e6s, Denmark. Harbour porpoises were tracked from land by means of a theodolite placed at a high observation point, before, during and after emission of replica seal scarer signals at reduced levels from an underwater loudspeaker.\n\nExperiments were conducted over a period of three weeks in June-July 2015. In total, 121 groups of porpoises were observed during nine days with usable weather conditions. In total 14 trials with sound exposure were conducted.\n\nDuring control periods without playback of sound the porpoises were predominantly observed in a band approximately 500-800 m from the coast, approximately along the 10 m depth contour. During trials with sound on the number of observations was too low to detect any clear patterns in distribution, except for some tracks clearly leading away from the loudspeaker.\n\nTrials were scored as either \u201cresponse\u201d or \u201cno response\u201d without distinction between strong and weak responses. Two groups of porpoises that were within 300 m of the loudspeaker when the sound was turned on both responded, but beyond 300 m some groups responded and others did not. One group at 600 m responded very strongly, whereas several other groups that were closer at onset didn\u2019t respond.\n\nReaction distances to the reduced levels of the controlled exposure must be scaled up to be applied to a real seal scarer. Doing so results in a scaled-up deterrence distance of 3,100 m, somewhat higher, but of the same order of magnitude as previous estimates.","author":["Tougaard, J.","Mikkelsen, L.","Hermannsen, L."],"organization":["Aarhus University","Aarhus University"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.108330000000","10.499423000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Pinnipeds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hermannsen-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1423","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-monitoring-mitigation-plan-shetland-tidal-array-bluemull-sound","sourceURL":"https:\/\/marine.gov.scot\/data\/environmental-monitoring-and-mitigation-plan-deposits-tidal-array-bluemull-sound-shetland-04859","title":"Environmental Monitoring and Mitigation Plan: Shetland Tidal Array, Bluemull Sound","description":"Nova Innovation implements an integrated Health, Safety and Environmental (HSE) policy that underpins everything we do. For individual projects the company produces an Environmental Monitoring and Mitigation Plan (EMMP) specific to the project. This document details our EMMP for the Shetland Tidal Array project in the Bluemull Sound. It outlines how we will meet our environmental requirements with particular reference to the conditions set down by Marine Scotland.","author":["McPherson, G."],"organization":["Nova Innovation"],"originationDate":"2015-07-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.699478200000","-0.985542600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-24 06:02:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NovaInnovation-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1424","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/black-rock-tidal-power-grand-passage-mre-permit","sourceURL":"https:\/\/energy.novascotia.ca\/sites\/default\/files\/files\/MRE-Permit-Black-Rock-Tidal-Powers-Project-Summary.pdf","title":"Black Rock Tidal Power Grand Passage MRE Permit","description":"Black Rock Tidal Power Inc. (BRTP), and its partners SCHOTTEL Hydro, Sustainable Marine Energy (SME) and Sustainable Oceans Applied Research (SOAR), wish to conduct an off-grid demonstration of the 280kW PLAT-I tidal energy platform at Grand Passage, located between communities of Westport and Freeport in Digby County, Nova Scotia. The proposed demonstration will be the first North American application of the technology. PLAT-I had a successful inaugural deployment in Connel, Scotland throughout late 2017 and the first half of 2018. For the proposed project, this prototype will be brought to Nova Scotia, assembled, and transported by sea to Grand Passage where it will undergo testing according to a pre-determined schedule for a period of a minimum of three months beginning in late Summer and into Fall 2018.  The Grand Passage location has the great advantage of having strong tidal currents and shelter from open ocean waves but also allowing easy access to the platform. The water clarity and visibility at Grand Passage is also good. These site characteristics create the ideal test location for technology development and proving while also affording an opportunity for key stakeholders to observe and visit the platform. In addition to assessing and proving the engineering performance of the system, the deployment will also provide ample opportunity to conduct environmental monitoring to detect marine life such as fish and marine mammals and assess any interactions they may have with the platform. Through this project BRTP and its partners intend to continue progressive development of community and utility-scale floating tidal energy devices that can be installed in rivers and tidal currents around the world to provide clean, renewable electricity for remote communities, industrial facilities, and utilities.","author":["Black Rock Tidal Power"],"organization":["Black Rock Tidal Power"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.263230900000","-66.337935200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-31 09:13:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Black-Rock-Tidal-Power-2018-Permit.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1425","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-current-power-resources-influence-sea-level-rise-coastal-waters-kinmen-island","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/10\/5\/652","title":"Tidal Current Power Resources and Influence of Sea-Level Rise in the Coastal Waters of Kinmen Island, Taiwan","description":"The tidal current power (TCP) resource, the impact of TCP extraction on hydrodynamics and the influence of sea-level rise (SLR) on TCP output in the coastal waters of Kinmen Island (Taiwan) are investigated using a state-of-the-art unstructured-grid depth-integrated numerical model. The model was driven by eight tidal constituents extracted from a global tidal prediction model and verified with time series of measured data for tide level and depth-averaged current. The simulations showed reasonable agreement with the observations; the\u00a0skill\u00a0index was in the excellent (0.71\u20130.93) range with regard to simulating tide level and currents. Model predictions indicated that the channel between Kinmen and Lieyu serves as an appropriate site for deploying the tidal turbines because of its higher tidal current and deeper water depth. The bottom friction approach was utilized to compute the average TCP over a spring-neap cycle (i.e., 15 days). Mean TCP reached its maximum to 45.51 kW for a coverage area of 0.036 km2\u00a0when an additional turbine friction coefficient (Ct) increased to 0.08, and a cut-in speed of 0.5 m\/s was used. The annual TCP output was estimated to be 1.08 MW. The impact of TCP extraction on the change in current is significant, with a maximum reduction rate of instant current exceeding 60%, and the extent of influence for the average current is 1.26 km in length and 0.30 km in width for the \u22120.05 m\/s contour line. However, the impact of TCP extraction on the change in tide level is insignificant; the maximum change in amplitude is only 0.73 cm for the K2\u00a0tide. The influence of SLR on the TCP output in Kinmen waters was also estimated. Modeling assessments showed that due to SLR produces faster tidal current, the annual TCP output increased to 1.52 MW, 2.01 MW, 2.48 MW and 2.97 MW under the same cut-in speed and coverage area conditions when SLR 0.25 m, SLR 0.5 m, SLR 0.75 m and SLR 1.0 m were imposed on the model.","author":["Lin, L.","Chen, W.","Chen, H.","Yu, Y."],"organization":["National Science and Technology Center for Disaster Reduction","National Taiwan University"],"originationDate":"2017-05-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["24.691907500000","118.564034000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tidal_Current_Power_Resources_and_Influence_of_Sea-Level_Rise_in_the_Coastal_Waters_of_Kinmen_Island_Taiwan.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1426","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cape-sharp-tidal-environmental-effects-monitoring-program-2018","sourceURL":"https:\/\/fundyforce.ca\/document-collection\/2018-cape-sharp-tidal-venture-monitoring-program-update","title":"Cape Sharp Tidal Environmental Effects Monitoring Program 2018","description":"This document provides details for an updated Environm ental Effects Monitoring Program (EEMP) (the Program) for Cape Sharp Tidal Venture (CSTV) for 2018. This document is submitted to meet the conditions listed under the Environmental Assessment (EA) Approval granted to the Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE) in 2009 (September 15, 2009) by Nova Scotia Environment (NSE) for effects monitoring, as defined under the Nova Scotia Environment Act.  As required by the conditions of the FORCE EA Approval (2009), the EEMP was developed in collaboration with experts in the field of in-stream tidal energy, monitoring and technology developers and with input from government agencies, including Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO) and NSE, as well as other in-stream tidal energy interests including the Offshore Energy Research Association of Nova Scotia (OERA), FORCE, and the associated FORCE Environmental Monitoring and Advisory Committee (EMAC).  The 2018 EEMP has been updated from the 2016\/2017 CSTV EEMP which was implemented for the first turbine deployment from November 2016 to June 2017 (refer to Section 3).","author":["Cape Sharp Tidal"],"organization":["Cape Sharp Tidal"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.364000000000","-64.422000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/CapeSharpTidal-EEMP-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1427","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/contrasting-effects-gps-device-harness-attachment-adult-survival-lesser-black-backed","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/ibi.12340","title":"Contrasting effects of GPS device and harness attachment on adult survival of Lesser Black-backed Gulls Larus fuscus and Great Skuas Stercorarius skua","description":"Telemetry has become an important method for studying the biology and ecology of animals. However, the impact of tracking devices and their method of attachment on different species across multiple temporal scales has seldom been assessed. We compared the behavioural and demographic responses of two species of seabird, Lesser Black\u2010backed Gull\u00a0Larus fuscus\u00a0and Great Skua\u00a0Stercorarius skua, to a GPS device attached using a crossover wing harness. We used telemetry information and monitoring of breeding colonies to compare birds equipped with a device and harness, and control birds without an attachment. We assessed whether tagged birds have lower short\u2010term breeding productivity or lower longer term overwinter return rates (indicative of overwinter survival) than controls. For Great Skua, we also assessed whether territory attendance within the breeding season differed between tagged and control birds. As with previous studies on Lesser Black\u2010backed Gull, we found no short\u2010term impacts on breeding productivity or long\u2010term impacts on overwinter return rates. For Great Skua, there was no evidence for impacts of the device and harness on territory attendance or breeding productivity. However, as found by a previous study of Great Skuas using a different (body) harness design, there was strong evidence of reduced overwinter return rates. Consequently, a device attached using a wing harness was considered suitable for long\u2010term deployment on Lesser Black\u2010backed Gulls, but not on Great Skuas. These findings will inform the planning of future tracking studies.","author":["Masden, E.","Furness, R.","Thaxter, C.","Booth, C.","Wade, H.","Votier, S.","Clark, N.","Burton, N.","Ross-Smith, V.","Conway, G.","Clark, J.","Leat, E.","Gear, S.","Marsh, M."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)","University of Glasgow","Landguard Bird Observatory","MacArthur Green","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.083332400000","1.557911900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1428","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/handling-environmental-knowledge-paradox-estuarine-coastal-policy-making","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569114003378","title":"Handling the \u0027environmental knowledge paradox\u0027 in estuarine and coastal policy making","description":"Knowledge is a key feature in our attempts to achieve sustainable development during environmental decision-making. Particularly complex decision making processes, where integrated economic, social and ecological issues need to be handled, suffer from what could be called the \u2018Environmental Knowledge Paradox\u2019 or EKP (having more and more detailed knowledge does not necessarily reduce uncertainty and settle competing truth-claims). We need to make significant changes in the decision-making process itself and the way we use scientific models to support these decisions. Starting from a simple linear decision-making model we explore potential improvements. Supported by recent progress in the environmental as well as the social sciences, we suggest four main procedural and technical adjustments. (1) To reduce the uncertainty in exploratory studies the \u2018contra expertise\u2019 approach should be explicitly applied. (2) The \u2018uncertainty\u2019 in impact assessments needs to be reduced by combining completely different approaches and model techniques. (3) The discussions during the decision-making process should be led by an independent not discipline-related professional facilitator. (4) Formal and informal actors need to be able to play an explicit and significant role during the decision-making process by contributing to a \u2018divergence\u2019 as well as a \u2018convergence\u2019 of ideas, options and solutions.","author":["de Jonge, V.","Giebels, D."],"organization":["University of Hull","Erasmus University Rotterdam"],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1429","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-energy-development-wildlife-challenges-opportunities-integrating-science","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781439847749\/chapters\/10.1201\/b12139-21","title":"Impacts of Wind Energy Development on Wildlife: Challenges and Opportunities for Integrating Science, Management, and Policy","description":"The aforementioned State of the Union address by President Obama highlights the growing and politically charged demand for development of renewable energy sources, including wind. Wind energy is one of the fastest growing renewable energy sources under development and while representing a clean energy source, it is not environmentally neutral. The impacts of wind energy development on wildlife and their habitats have become an increasing concern and topic of research and political discussion. However, a lack of credible scientific information, poor or even nonexistent frameworks for decision making, lack of transparency, and weak policies or lack of policy and regulation altogether continue to fuel controversy over wind energy development and wildlife impacts. The issues and challenges presented in this chapter are not all-inclusive, but represent some key factors that must be overcome if wildlife and wind energy development conflicts are to be resolved such that responsible development that minimizes wildlife impacts can be achieved.","author":["Arnett, E."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2012-05-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1430","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wildlife-science-connecting-research-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781439847732","title":"Wildlife Science: Connecting Research with Management","description":"Despite the potential synergy that can result from basing management applications on results from research, there is a polarization of cultures between wildlife managers and wildlife researchers.\u00a0Wildlife Science: Connecting Research with Management\u00a0provides strategies for bridging cultural and communication gaps between these groups. Contributors present case studies highlighting the role of state and federal agencies and private organizations in management and research; the lingering disconnects between grassland birds, quail, and deer research and management; as well as the development of management techniques from field research, rangelands management, and ranch management.\n\nChapters:\nIntroduction\nA History of the Disconnect between Wildlife Research and Management,\u00a0Stephen J. DeMaso\u00a0\nStrengthening the Ties between Wildlife Research and Management,\u00a0Paul Krausman\n\nResearch and Management Entities\nUniversities and the Disconnect between Wildlife Research and Management,\u00a0Leonard A. Brennan\nSoutheast State Wildlife Agencies; Research Priorities and Constraints,\u00a0John Bowers, Chris Baumann, and Reggie Thackston\nPutting Science into Action on Forest Service Lands,\u00a0William M. Block, Victoria A. Saab, and Leonard Ruggiero\nClosing the Gap between Private Land Managers and Wildlife Scientists: The Importance of Private Wildlife Research Institutions,\u00a0William Palmer\nThe Role of Professional Societies in Connecting Science and Management: The Wildlife Society as an Example, Laura Bies, Michael Hutchins, John Organ, and Stephen DeStefano\nFunding Research as an Investment for Improving Management,\u00a0Matthew J. Schnupp and Dave Delaney\n\nSpecies Case Studies\nThe Disconnect between Quail Research and Management,\u00a0Leonard A. Brennan\nSage-Grouse and the Disconnect between Research and Management on Public Lands in the American West,\u00a0Steven G. Herman\nEcological Goals, not Rigid Management Plans, are the Key to Effective Grassland Bird Conservation,\u00a0Robert Askins\nA Historical Perspective of the Connectivity between Waterfowl Research and Management,\u00a0Christopher K. Williams, and Paul M. Castelli\nDeer in the Western United States,\u00a0James R. Heffelfinger\nCollaboration among Sciences, Managers, Landowners, and Hunters: The Kinzua Quality Deer Cooperative,\u00a0David deCalesta\n\nManagement and Policy Case Studies\nImpacts of Wind Energy Development on Wildlife: Challenges and Opportunities for Integrating Science, Management, and Policy,\u00a0Edward B. Arnett\nThe Role of Joint Ventures in Bridging the Gap between Research and Management, James J. Giocomo, Mary Gustafson, Jennifer N. Duberstein, and Chad Boyd\nDeveloping Management Strategies from Research: Pushmataha Forest Habitat Research Area, Oklahoma,\u00a0Ron Masters and Jack Waymire\n\nConclusions and Future Directions\nMoving Forward: Connecting Wildlife Research and Management for Conservation in the Twenty-First Century,\u00a0Joseph P. Sands, Stephen J. DeMaso, Leonard A. Brennan, and Matthew J. Schnupp","author":["Brennan, L.","DeMaso, S.","Sands, J.","Schnupp, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2012-05-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1431","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/networking-networks-global-bat-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-25220-9_17#enumeration","title":"Networking Networks for Global Bat Conservation","description":"Conservation networks link diverse actors, either individuals or groups, across space and time. Such networks build social capital, enhance coordination, and lead to effective conservation action. Bat conservation can benefit from network approaches because the taxonomic and ecological diversity of bats, coupled with the complexity of the threats they face, necessitates a wide range of expert knowledge to effect conservation. Moreover, many species and issues transcend political boundaries, so conservation frequently requires or benefits from international cooperation. In response, several regional bat conservation networks have arisen in recent years, and we suggest that, with the globalization of threats to bats, there is now a need for a global network to strengthen bat conservation and provide a unified voice for advocacy. To retain regional autonomy and identity, we advocate a global network of the regional networks and develop a roadmap toward such a meta-network using a social network framework. We first review the structure and function of existing networks and then suggest ways in which existing networks might be strengthened. We then discuss how regional gaps in global coverage might best be filled, before suggesting ways in which regional networks might be linked for global coverage.","author":["Racey, P.","Waldien, D.","Kingston, T.","Aguirre, L.","Armstrong, K.","Mies, R.","Rodriguez-Herrera, B."],"organization":["Texas Tech University","Universidad Mayor de San Sim\u00f3n","Australasian Bat Society, Inc.","University of Adelaide","South Australian Museum","Organization for Bat Conservation","University of Exeter","Universidad de Costa Rica","Bat Conservation International"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kingston2016-NetworkingNetworksForGlobalBat.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1432","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-habitat-prey-mesopredator-associations-community-marine-birds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/article-abstract\/75\/5\/1602\/4973731","title":"Evaluating habitat, prey, and mesopredator associations in a community of marine birds","description":"Offshore wind energy development on the US Atlantic Continental Shelf has brought attention to the need for marine spatial planning efforts to reduce potential conflict between wind turbines and marine animals, including seabirds. We evaluated the effects of marine mammals, fishes, and habitat characteristics on the distribution and relative abundance of marine birds off the coast of Delaware, Maryland, and Virginia. From May 2012 to 2014, we collected line transect data from 14 shipboard surveys, and novel high-resolution digital videography data from 14 aerial surveys. We compiled five habitat covariates: three static (distance to shore, sea floor slope, and sediment grain size), and two dynamic (sea surface temperature, salinity). We additionally analysed two seabird community covariates: the density of observed marine mammals and detected fish. Using zero-altered models, we tested our hypothesis that plunge-diving seabird species would show positive associations with marine mammals. Our results provide statistical evidence that, alongside competition, facilitative interactions occur among pelagic communities, where subsurface predators improve the detectability and accessibility of prey to surface-feeding seabirds. This study highlights the importance of quantifying community and ecological influences on avian abundance, particularly in predicting the potential exposure of marine birds and mammals to offshore development.","author":["Williams, K.","Johnson, S.","Veit, R.","Gilbert, A.","Connelly, E.","Goyert, H.","Gardner, B.","Duron, M."],"organization":["North Carolina State University","The City University of New York (CUNY)","Biodiversity Research Institute"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.269322000000","-75.559526000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1433","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stereo-optic-high-definition-imaging-new-technology-understand-bird-bat-avoidance-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/servlets\/purl\/1423631","title":"Stereo-Optic High Definition Imaging: A New Technology to Understand Bird and Bat Avoidance of Wind Turbines","description":"Biodiversity Research Institute (BRI) collaborated with the University of Maine School of Computing and Information Science (UMaine SCIS), HiDef Aerial Surveying, Limited (HiDef), and SunEdison, Inc. (formerly First Wind) to test a stereo-optic camera system for documenting aerofauna interactions with wind turbines. The team also further developed the monitoring system, which uses an image-processing algorithm to detect and track daytime and nighttime aerofauna and assist video reviewers in parsing large amounts of visual data. Each of these components had not been tested in the field, so we had an opportunity to test and improve these components based on realistic deployment conditions. These developments allowed us to bring this technology closer to market and provide additional data for understanding aerofauna exposure to wind turbines. This project supports the Department of Energy (DOE) Wind Energy Technologies Office (WETO) goals of lowering the unsubsidized, levelized cost of energy (LCOE), and alleviates a significant market barrier to wind power development by reducing the uncertainty surrounding avian avoidance behavior and collision risk.\u00a0","author":["Goodale, W.","Gilbert, A.","Adams, E.","Burns, S.","Dorr, C.","Duron, M.","Moratz, R.","Robinson, M."],"organization":["Biodiversity Research Institute","HiDef Aerial Surveying Ltd","University of Maine","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.166352500000","-71.232813200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Adams-et-al-final-report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1434","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/improving-knowledge-exchange-among-scientists-decision-makers-facilitate-adaptive","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569115001167","title":"Improving knowledge exchange among scientists and decision-makers to facilitate the adaptive governance of marine resources: A review of knowledge and research needs","description":"The science-based management of natural resources requires knowledge exchange between scientists and environmental decision-makers, however, this exchange remains a significant challenge. Rather, evidence suggests that decision-makers rely on individual experience or other secondary sources of knowledge in isolation from scientific evidence when formulating decisions, potentially compromising the effectiveness of their decisions. As a result a new field of research broadly characterised as \u2018knowledge exchange\u2019 has emerged, focused largely on identifying and overcoming the barriers to knowledge exchange among scientists and decision-makers. More recently knowledge exchange research has also begun to explore the relationship between science and decision-making specifically in relation to marine ecosystems and resources. The aim of this paper is to review the literature in relation to knowledge exchange for natural resource management, with a focus on recent evidence in relation to the management of marine resources. This review identifies critical barriers inhibiting knowledge exchange among marine scientists and decisions-makers, such as the inaccessibility of science to decision-makers as well as institutional barriers that limit the extent to which scientists and decision-makers can prioritise knowledge exchange activities. Options for overcoming these barriers, such as novel approaches to knowledge exchange (e.g. \u2013 knowledge co-production, knowledge brokers and boundary organisations) and the enabling environments and institutional reforms needed to complement efforts to improve knowledge exchange, are also identified. This review concludes by articulating the gaps in our understanding of knowledge exchange, to help guide future research in this field and improve the sustainable management of marine resources.","author":["Wilson, S.","Cvitanovic, C.","Hobday, A.","van Kerkhoff, L.","Dobbs, K.","Marshall, N."],"organization":["Australian National University","University of Tasmania","University of Western Australia"],"originationDate":"2015-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1435","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-offshore-distribution-abundance-marine-birds-hierarchical-community","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1890\/15-1955.1","title":"Predicting the offshore distribution and abundance of marine birds with a hierarchical community distance sampling model","description":"Proposed offshore wind energy development on the Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf has brought attention to the need for baseline studies of the distribution and abundance of marine birds. We compiled line transect data from 15 shipboard surveys (June 2012 - April 2014), along with associated remotely sensed habitat data, in the lower Mid\u2010Atlantic Bight off the coast of Delaware, Maryland, and Virginia, USA. We implemented a recently developed hierarchical community distance sampling model to estimate the seasonal abundance of 40 observed marine bird species. Treating each season separately, we included six oceanographic parameters to estimate seabird abundance: three static (distance to shore, slope, sediment grain size) and three dynamic covariates (sea surface temperature [SST], salinity, primary productivity). We expected that avian bottom\u2010feeders would respond primarily to static covariates that characterize seafloor variability, and that surface\u2010feeders would respond more to dynamic covariates that quantify surface productivity. We compared the variation in species\u2010specific and community\u2010level responses to these habitat features, including for rare species, and we predicted species abundance across the study area. While several protected species used the study area in summer during their breeding season, estimated abundance and observed diversity were highest for nonbreeding species in winter. Distance to shore was the most common significant predictor of abundance, and thus useful in estimating the potential exposure of marine birds to offshore development. In many cases, our expectations based on feeding ecology were confirmed, such as in the first winter season, when bottom\u2010feeders associated significantly with the three static covariates (distance to shore, slope, and sediment grain size), and surface\u2010feeders associated significantly with two dynamic covariates (SST, primary productivity). However, other cases revealed significant relationships between static covariates and surface\u2010feeders (e.g., distance to shore) and between dynamic covariates and bottom\u2010feeders (e.g., primary productivity during that same winter). More generally, we found wide interannual, seasonal, and interspecies variation in habitat relationships with abundance. These results show the importance of quantifying detection and determining the ecological drivers of a community\u0027s distribution and abundance, within and among species, for evaluating the potential exposure of marine birds to offshore development.","author":["Williams, K.","Veit, R.","Gilbert, A.","Connelly, E.","Goyert, H.","Gardner, B.","Sollmann, R."],"organization":["North Carolina State University","The City University of New York (CUNY)","Biodiversity Research Institute"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.054372900000","-76.943119300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1436","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-acoustic-studies-pleasant-ridge-wind-resource-area-livingston-county-illinois","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.livingstoncounty-il.org\/wordpress\/wp-content\/uploads\/2014\/11\/PR-Ex.-104-Pleasant-Ridge-Bat-Acoustic-Studies.pdf","title":"Bat Acoustic Studies for the Pleasant Ridge Wind Resource Area - Livingston County, Illinois - Final Report July 15 - October 21, 2009","description":"Invenergy LLC (Invenergy) is proposing to develop a wind-energy facility in Livingston County, Illinois. Invenergy requested Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) develop and implement a standardized protocol for baseline studies of bat use in the Pleasant Ridge Wind Resource Area (PRWRA) for the purpose of estimating the impacts of the wind-energy facility on bats. The protocol for this baseline study is similar to protocols used at other wind-energy facilities in the US and involves passive acoustic sampling using AnabatTM ultrasonic SD1 bat detectors.  Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. initiated surveys in July 2009 designed to assess bat use within the proposed Pleasant Ridge Wind Resource Area in Livingston County, Illinois. Acoustic surveys for bats using AnabatTM SD1 ultrasonic detectors were conducted at five stations using six Anabats from July 15 to October 21, 2009. One station was placed in an area expected to receive high bat activity to be used as reference site. The remaining five stations were located at met towers, or non-reference areas. Detectors were placed below two met towers for the entire study. One paired set of detectors (raised and ground) and one raised unit was rotated between the remaining three met towers each week, so that monitoring occurred at five of the six stations each survey week.   The final report describes the results of Anabat surveys during the 2009 study season within the proposed PRWRA. In addition to site-specific data, this report presents existing information and results of bat monitoring studies conducted at other wind-energy facilities. Where possible, comparisons with regional and local studies were made.","author":["Gruver, J.","Bay, K.","Good, R.","Ritzert, J."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2010-02-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.620795000000","-83.847302000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2009-Pleasant-Ridge-Bat-Acoustic-Studies.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1437","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/genetic-diversity-migratory-bats-results-radseq-data-three-tree-bat-species-ohio","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/pmc\/articles\/PMC4730867\/pdf\/peerj-04-1647.pdf","title":"Genetic Diversity in Migratory Bats: Results from RADseq Data for Three Tree Bat Species at an Ohio Windfarm","description":"Genetic analyses can identify the scale at which wildlife species are impacted by human activities, and provide demographic information useful for management. Here, we use thousands of nuclear DNA genetic loci to assess whether genetic structure occurs within\u00a0Lasiurus cinereus\u00a0(Hoary Bat),\u00a0L. borealis\u00a0(Red Bat), and\u00a0Lasionycteris noctivagans\u00a0(Silver-Haired Bat) bats found at a wind turbine site in Ohio, and to also estimate demographic parameters in each of these three groups. Our specific goals are to: 1) demonstrate the feasibility of isolating RADseq loci from these tree bat species, 2) test for genetic structure within each species, including any structure that may be associated with time (migration period), and 3) use coalescent-based modeling approaches to estimate genetically-effective population sizes and patterns of population size changes over evolutionary timescales. Thousands of loci were successfully genotyped for each species, demonstrating the value of RADseq for generating polymorphic loci for population genetic analyses in these bats. There was no evidence for genetic differentiation between groups of samples collected at different times throughout spring and fall migration, suggesting that individuals from each species found at the wind facility are from single panmictic populations. Estimates of present-day effective population sizes varied across species, but were consistently large, on the order of 105\u2013106. All populations show evidence of expansions that date to the Pleistocene. These results, along with recent work also suggesting limited genetic structure in bats across North America, argue that additional biomarker systems such as stable-isotopes or trace elements should be investigated as alternative and\/or complementary approaches to genetics for sourcing individuals collected at single wind farm sites.","author":["Sovic, M.","Carstens, B.","Gibbs, H."],"organization":["Ohio State University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.359839200000","-83.792989900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Sovic-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1438","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/carcass-age-searcher-identity-affect-morphological-assessment-sex-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21544","title":"Carcass Age and Searcher Identity Affect Morphological Assessment of Sex of Bats","description":"Carcasses provide an important resource for assessing the vulnerability of bat species and sexes to threats, but the reliability of sex data derived from the external morphology (sexmorph) of bat carcasses remains uncertain. We used genetic\u2010based assessment of sex (sexgen) to evaluate the effect of carcass age and searcher identity on sexmorph\u2010based assessments of eastern red (Lasiurus borealis) and hoary (Lasiurus cinereus) bat carcasses identified by 15 different searchers at a wind\u2010energy facility. The proportion of carcasses for which sexmorph\u00a0was unknown increased from 0.11 for those recovered within a day of death, to 0.56 within 2\u20133 days of death, and to \u22650.82 at \u22654 days after death. The proportion of carcasses for which sexmorph\u00a0was correct decreased from 0.9 for those recovered within a day of death, to 0.65 within 2\u20133 days of death, and to 0.25 at \u22654 days after death. The proportion of sexmorph\u00a0misidentifications of the 108 fresh carcasses (collected within 24 hours of death) varied (0.0\u20130.43) among searchers. These results suggest that sexmorph\u2010based assessments should be limited to fresh carcasses. Furthermore, additional training of people who collect and identify bat carcasses from renewable\u2010energy facilities may improve the accuracy of sexmorph\u00a0data obtained from carcasses.","author":["Good, R.","Nelson, D.","Iskali, G.","Nagel, J.","Trott, R.","Campbell, C.","Pruitt, L.","Gugger, P."],"organization":["University of Maryland","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.644786000000","-87.341360000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1439","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/id-stat-innovative-technology-assessing-wildlife-collisions-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/etdeweb\/biblio\/1023992","title":"ID Stat: Innovative Technology for Assessing Wildlife Collisions with Wind Turbines","description":"Assessing wildlife mortality resulting from collision with wind turbines is a recurring concern for conservationists and governmental agencies around the world. Monitoring wildlife fatality is often based on carcass searches below the turbines. However, the efficiency of this technique is known to have many biases, or even be unfeasible in some areas (e.g. offshore wind farms and heavily vegetated environments). To solve this problem, we have developed a system that uses specifically-designed microphones placed within turbine blades to record individual collisions of birds or bats with the blades. The accompanying data loggers contain software that uses acoustical signatures to filter noises produced by the shock on the blade by birds and bats (down to 2.5 grams), from those produced by other objects (rain drops, insects, mechanical noises, etc.). Every time a collision occurs, the system automatically sends the information (sensor ID and turbine, time, etc.) to a remotely located server. Collision can be signalled instantaneously on a cell phone so a ground search can be done soon after the collision under the turbine where the event occurred. After field validation, the system will ultimately allow for quantification of mortality in areas that were previously inaccessible (e.g. offshore wind farms) and the standardization of mortality data collection across wide geographic areas. The remote monitoring capabilities of the system will also allow for low-cost, accurate, long-term mortality monitoring.  Report was presented at the Conference on Wind Energy and Wildlife Impacts on the 2nd-5th of May 2011, in Trondheim, Norway.","author":["Delprat, B.","Alcuri, G."],"organization":["Calidris","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)"],"originationDate":"2011-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Delprat_and_Alcuri_2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1440","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-study-bat-activity-proposed-roaring-brook-wind-project-new-york-spring-fall","sourceURL":"","title":"An Acoustic Study of Bat Activity at the Proposed Roaring Brook Wind Project, New York, Spring - Fall 2008","description":"Bat fatalities at wind-energy facilities have been documented since the early 1970s. Previous studies have documented high fatality rates along forested ridges in the eastern United States (e.g., Mountaineer, WV, Kerns et al. 2005; Buffalo Mountain, TN, Fiedler 2004, Fiedler et al. 2007). However, recent data suggests high fatality events occur across a variety of landscapes across North America, including agricultural, grassland prairies, and deciduous or coniferous forests. Most bat fatalities documented at wind farms involve migratory tree-roosting species [i.e., hoary (Lasiurus cinereus), Eastern red (Lasiurus borealis), big brown (Eptesicus fuscus), and silver-haired (Lasionycteris noctivagans)] bats during seasonal periods of migration in late summer and fall. Several hypotheses explaining possible bat\/turbine interactions exist (i.e., roost, landscape, acoustic or visual attraction), however, none have been tested. The lack of data on population estimates, migratory pathways, and flight behaviors around wind turbines of North American bats highlights the need for additional information to resolve these different hypotheses.  The primary goal of the study was to collect acoustic information on activity levels of bats during nocturnal hours, particularly during spring and fall migration. Specifically, our objectives were to: (1) collect baseline information on levels of bat activity (i.e., # bat passes\/h, night, or tower) for migratory tree-roosting bats (e.g., hoary, Eastern red, and big brown\/silver-haired bats) and other bat species (mainly Myotis spp.); and (2) examine spatial (height and location) and temporal (e.g., nightly and seasonal) variations in bat activity.","author":["Mabee, T.","Hein, C.","Schwab, N."],"organization":["ABR Inc","Iberdrola Renewables"],"originationDate":"2009-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.851521000000","-75.576024000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hein-et-al-2008.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1441","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/visual-acoustic-study-nocturnal-bird-bat-migration-proposed-roaring-brook-wind-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Nathan_Schwab\/publication\/242515767_A_VISUAL_AND_ACOUSTIC_STUDY_OF_NOCTURNAL_BIRD_AND_BAT_MIGRATION_AT_THE_PROPOSED_ROARING_BROOK_WIND_PROJECT_NEW_YORK_FALL_2007\/links\/546ccad40cf2a7492c55aa25.pdf","title":"A Visual and Acoustic Study of Nocturnal Bird and Bat Migration at the Proposed Roaring Brook Wind Project, New York, Fall 2007","description":"Recent data from Appalachian ridge tops in the eastern US, the Tug Hill Plateau region in New York, prairie locations in both the US and Canada, have indicated that substantial bat kills are also possible at wind power projects. These unexpected collisions have prompted researchers to develop standard methods for assessing bat use of proposed wind power projects. Most of the bat fatalities documented at wind farms have been associated with migratory tree-roosting species [i.e., Hoary (Lasiurus cinereus), Eastern red (Lasiurus borealis), Big brown (Eptesicus fuscus), and Silver-haired (Lasionycteris noctivagans)] bats during seasonal periods of dispersal and migration in late summer and fall, and several hypotheses have been posited, but not tested, to explain bat\/turbine interactions. Limited evidence suggests that bats may be killed when flying straight into objects (and not\u00a0reacting) and their movement rates (or foraging activity at or below turbines), therefore, may be correlated with their fatality rates. There are many possible hypotheses as to why bats may collide with wind turbines\u00a0including the idea that bats are using large, modern, wind turbines as rendezvous sites during the fall mating season. The lack of information on migratory pathways, measures of abundance, flight altitudes, and flight behaviors for migratory tree-roosting bats in North America highlights the need to obtain this critical information.\n\nThe primary goals of this study were to collect visual and acoustic information on both the flight characteristics and activity levels of migratory and resident birds (especially passerines) and bats during nocturnal hours of fall migration. Specifically, the objectives of this study were to: (1) collect baseline information on flight characteristics (i.e., flight directions, observation rates, flight altitudes) of birds and bats flying at night with visual methods; (2) estimate the relative proportions of birds and bats at low altitudes (\u2264 ~ 150 m agl) with visual methods; (3) collect baseline information on levels of bat activity (i.e., # bat passes\/h, night, or tower) for migratory tree-roosting bats (e.g., Hoary, Eastern red, and Big brown\/Silver-haired bats) and other species (mainly Myotis spp.) of bats.","author":["Mabee, T.","Schwab, N."],"organization":["ABR Inc","PPM Energy"],"originationDate":"2008-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.851521000000","-75.576024000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mabee-Schwab-Roaring-Brook-NY-2007.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1442","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-strikes-electrocutions-power-lines-communication-towers-wind-turbines-state-art","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fs.usda.gov\/treesearch\/pubs\/32105","title":"Bird Strikes and Electrocutions at Power Lines, Communication Towers, and Wind Turbines: State of the Art and State of the Science - Next Steps Toward Mitigation","description":"Migratory birds suffer considerable human-caused mortality from structures built to provide public services and amenities. Three such entities are increasing nationwide: communication towers, power lines, and wind turbines. Communication towers have been growing at an exponential rate over at least the past 6 years. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is especially concerned about growing impacts to some 836 species of migratory birds currently protected under the Migratory Bird Treaty Act of 1918, as amended. While mortality estimates are often sketchy, and won\u2019t be verified until nationwide cumulative impact studies are conducted, current figures are troubling. Communication towers may kill from 4-50 million birds per year. Collisions with power transmission and distribution lines may kill anywhere from hundreds of thousands to 175 million birds annually, and power lines electrocute tens to hundreds of thousands more birds annually, but these utilities are poorly monitored for both strikes and electrocutions. More than 15,000 wind turbines may kill 40,000 or more birds annually nationwide, the majority in California. This paper will address the commonalities of bird impacts among these industries; those bird species that tend to be most affected; and research (completed, current, and proposed) intended to reduce bird collisions and electrocutions nationwide. The issues of structure location (siting), lighting, guy supports, lattice or tubular structures, bird behavior, and habitat modifications are reviewed. In addition, this paper reviews the respective roles and publications of the Avian Power Line Interaction Committee and the Wildlife Workgroup of the National Wind Coordinating Committee, the roles of the Service-chaired Communication Tower Working Group and Wind Turbine Siting Working Group, and the Fish and Wildlife Services\u2019 voluntary tower and turbine siting and placement guidelines. An update on recent Communication Tower Working Group research initiatives will also be discussed along with promising research findings and needs.","author":["Manville, A."],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2005-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/psw_gtr191_1051-1064_manville.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1443","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/habitat-risk-assessment-regional-ocean-planning-us-northeast-mid-atlantic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0188776","title":"Habitat risk assessment for regional ocean planning in the U.S. Northeast and Mid-Atlantic","description":"Coastal habitats provide important benefits to people, including habitat for species targeted by fisheries and opportunities for tourism and recreation. Yet, such human activities also can imperil these habitats and undermine the ecosystem services they provide to people. Cumulative risk assessment provides an analytical framework for synthesizing the influence of multiple stressors across habitats and decision-support for balancing human uses and ecosystem health. To explore cumulative risk to habitats in the U.S. Northeast and Mid-Atlantic Ocean Planning regions, we apply the open-source InVEST Habitat Risk Assessment model to 13 habitats and 31 stressors in an exposure-consequence framework. In doing so, we advance the science priorities of EBM and both regional planning bodies by synthesizing the wealth of available data to improve our understanding of human uses and how they affect marine resources. We find that risk to ecosystems is greatest first, along the coast, where a large number of stressors occur in close proximity and secondly, along the continental shelf, where fewer, higher consequence activities occur. Habitats at greatest risk include soft and hard-bottom nearshore areas, tidal flats, soft-bottom shelf habitat, and rocky intertidal zones\u2014with the degree of risk varying spatially. Across all habitats, our results indicate that rising sea surface temperatures, commercial fishing, and shipping consistently and disproportionally contribute to risk. Further, our findings suggest that management in the nearshore will require simultaneously addressing the temporal and spatial overlap as well as intensity of multiple human activities and that management in the offshore requires more targeted efforts to reduce exposure from specific threats. We offer a transparent, generalizable approach to evaluating cumulative risk to multiple habitats and illustrate the spatially heterogeneous nature of impacts along the eastern Atlantic coast and the importance of spatial scale in estimating such impacts. These results offer a valuable decision-support tool by helping to constrain the decision space, focus attention on habitats and locations at the greatest risk, and highlight effect management strategies.","author":["Guerry, A.","Ruckelshaus, M.","Arkema, K.","Griffin, R.","Wyatt, K.","Fogarty, M."],"organization":["Stanford University"],"originationDate":"2017-12-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.735958800000","-74.681316800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wyatt-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1444","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-wind-energy-impacts-mitigation-tradeoffs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/awwi.org\/resources\/bat-white-paper\/","title":"Bats and Wind Energy: Impacts, Mitigation, and Tradeoffs","description":"This white paper,\u00a0Bats and Wind Energy: Impacts, Mitigation, and Tradeoffs, provides an overview and review of what is known about wind energy\u2019s impacts to bats, incorporating findings from the recent\u00a0AWWI technical paper\u00a0on a new analysis of post-construction fatality data. A summary of this review can be found in AWWI\u2019s\u00a0Bats and Wind Energy Issue Brief. The white paper also discusses the tradeoff of expanding wind energy to meet urgent emissions mitigation needs and accepting some uncertainty about risk to bats.","author":["Allison, T."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)","American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-11-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2026-05-30 01:02:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1445","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-small-medium-wind-turbines-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ore.exeter.ac.uk\/repository\/handle\/10871\/27219","title":"The Impacts of Small and Medium Wind Turbines on Bats","description":"Global efforts to address climate change have recently introduced a new source of fatality risk to bats, from wind turbines. Bat fatalities have now been confirmed in varying magnitudes at wind energy facilities around the world. Research at large turbines and wind farms has started to produce a knowledge base regarding impacts upon bats, though many questions remain. Little, however, is known about risk levels at small and medium scale wind turbines. Equally, research regarding the impacts of turbines in the UK is limited. This thesis examines the impacts of small and medium scale wind turbines upon bats. Planning records of wind turbines in Wales and south west (SW) England were reviewed. Approved planning applications for single and double turbine sites were found to greatly outnumber those for larger scale wind farms. The large majority of single and double turbine approvals were also for small turbines. The potential impacts of turbine presence and density on current bat roost populations and population changes were analysed, finding no impact. An estimate of bat fatality rates at small and medium turbines was calculated, using a trained search dog to locate carcasses. An average fatality rate between 0.81 and 15.15 turbine-1 year-1 was estimated. The higher rate accounted for uncertainty in the monitoring protocol. Only 3 bat carcasses were however observed across all monitored turbines, suggesting more stringent monitoring would likely confirm a lower maximum annual fatality rate. Bat activity levels were also compared between the turbine location and differing habitat types. A disturbance effect was consequently identified in proximity to turbines during high wind speeds. Finally moderating influences of environmental weather and habitat conditions upon bat activity were confirmed. Social Network Analysis (SNA) methods were used to analyse bat movement networks within a small grid of bat detectors centred on each turbine. Associations were identified between bats\u2019 movement routes and habitat structures present at sites, highlighting vulnerabilities to disruption. Furthermore bats actively used the turbine area, potentially for foraging purposes. Finally by assessing bats\u2019 activity levels in response to a turbine noise playback experiment, small turbine noise was found to have no impact upon bat activity. Planning guidance regarding bats and small and medium turbines is highlighted as a priority for policy development.","author":["Moyle, A."],"organization":["University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2016-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.400004900000","-5.283560200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1446","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-understanding-drivers-bat-activity-patterns-relevant-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"","title":"Developing an Understanding of the Drivers of Bat Activity Patterns Relevant to Wind Turbines","description":"The increasing number of proposed wind farm developments in South Africa provides an immediate reason to assess bat activity and diversity, with the expectation of developing measures to mitigate for negative impacts. The overall aim of this thesis was contribute to an understanding of the drivers of bat activity, relevant to wind turbines, and to determine what factors (exogenous \u2013 environmental, or endogenous \u2013 intrinsic physiological processes) contributed to observed bat activity patterns, at the Metrowind Van Stadens Wind Farm in the Eastern Cape of South Africa.  A combination of active (mist netting) and passive (acoustic) bat monitoring techniques were used to determine free-ranging bat activity patterns (Chapter 3). A total of 889 bat passes were recorded over 323 detector nights from the beginning of May 2012 to the end of December 2012. The Cape serotine bat (82%) and the Egyptian free-tailed bat (97%) made up the majority of all bat passes recorded on site. Large variations in bat activity per month and per hour were apparent, with bat activity peaking in May 2012 and during the first few hours after sunset (18:00-23:00). Patterns in nightly, free-ranging bat activity at the site were modelled against various environmental conditions. Month, temperature, wind speed and an interaction between month and rainfall were the most significant predictors of bat activity, explaining 80% of the variation observed on free-ranging bat activity patterns.  A total of eight Cape serotine bats (Table 4.1.) were caught in mist nets on site and changes in the resting metabolic rate (RMR) of torpid (n = 6), and normothermic (n = 2) bats, over a 24 hr period, were measured and used to predict free-ranging Cape serotine bat activity (Chapter 4). Cape serotine bats showed a high proclivity for torpor in the laboratory and peaks in RMR were observed at 18:00 (0.89 \u00b1 0.95 VO2 m\u2113.g-1 .hr-1 ) and again from 20:00- 21:00 (0.89 \u00b1 0.91 VO2 m\u2113.g-1 .hr-1 ). Peaks in RMR of torpid individuals coincided with peaks in the average hourly free-ranging activity of the Cape serotine bat, and RMR explained 33% of the variation and was a good predictor of free-ranging bat activity (R2 = 0.2914).   This study showed that both exogenous (Chapter 3) and endogenous (Chapter 4) factors drive bat activity in the wild. Although this dissertation was not intended for wind turbine management, the information presented on the biology and activity of bats is important for managing interactions between bats and wind turbines. By determining what factors influence bat activity, we are able to predict when bats will be most active and thus can develop mitigation measures to reduce the potential impacts that wind turbines will have on the bat community. In order to conserve bats and reduce potential bat fatalities from occurring at the site, mitigation measures should be concentrated to those times when bats are most active (May and during the first few hours after sunset \u2013 18:00 to 22:00).","author":["Thwaits, T."],"organization":["Nelson Mandela University"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-33.961871000000","25.246110000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Thwaits-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1447","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ultrasonic-bat-deterrent-technology","sourceURL":"","title":"Ultrasonic Bat Deterrent Technology","description":"The project objective was to advance the development and testing of an Near commercial bat-deterrent system with a goal to increase the current GE deterrent system effectiveness to over 50% with broad species applicability. Additionally, the research supported by this program has provided insights into bat behavior and ultrasonic deterrent design that had not previously been explored. Prior research and development had demonstrated the effectiveness of a commercial-grade, air-powered, ultrasonic bat deterrent to be between 30-50% depending upon the species of bat. However, the previous research provided limited insight into the behavioral responses of bats in the presence of ultrasonic deterrent sound fields that could be utilized to improve effectiveness. A unique bat flight room was utilized to observe the behavioral characteristics of bats in the presence of ultrasonic sound fields. Behavioral testing in the bat flight facility demonstrated that ultrasonic sounds similar to those produced by the GE deterrent influenced the activities and behaviors, primarily those associated with foraging, of the species exposed. The study also indicated that continuous and pulsing ultrasonic signals had a similar effect on the bats, and confirmed that as ultrasonic sounds attenuate, their influence on the bats\u2019 activities and behavior decreases. Ground testing at\u00a0Wolf Ridge Wind, LLC and Shawnee National Forest assessed both continuous and pulsing deterrent signals emitted from the GE deterrent system and further enhanced the behavioral understanding of bats in the presence of the deterrent. With these data and observations, the existing 4-nozzle continuous, or steady, emission ultrasonic system was redesigned to a 6-nozzle system that could emit a pulsing signal covering a larger air space around a turbine. Twelve GE 1.6-100 turbines were outfitted with the deterrent system and a formal three-month field study was performed using daily carcass searches beneath the 12 turbines. Additionally, a unique 3D bat flight path visualization system was utilized to monitor for and identify any changes in bat activity caused by the operation of the deterrent system. Both the carcass search and flight path visualization data indicated that the pulsed deterrent system was effective, but not more effective, than the steady system tested in prior years. The pulsed deterrent system was effective at reducing bat fatalities by 38% for all species and 54% effective at reducing fatalities if Eastern Red bats were excluded from the data. However, an unanticipated byproduct of the pulsing system was the emission of intermittent water vapor from the deterrent devices due to the air compression process that powered the devices. This water vapor may have altered the ultrasonic signal and obscured the results in an unknown way. While a qualitative analysis of the effect of the water vapor on the deterrent signal had indicated there was not dramatic change in the expected ultrasonic signal, it was not possible to conclusively determine if the pulse signal would have been more effective in the absence of the water vapor.","author":["Kinzie, K."],"organization":["General Electric Company","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2018-06-27","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kinzie-Rominger-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1448","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-bat-collision-risks-wind-energy-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/publications.iadb.org\/en\/bird-and-bat-collision-risks-wind-energy-facilities","title":"Bird and Bat Collision Risks \u0026 Wind Energy Facilities","description":"The Inter-American Development Bank (IDB) has seen its portfolio of wind power projects increase substantially, a trend which is expected to continue. This report is intended to provide expert guidance regarding wind wildlife risk issues, and to ensure that environmental impact considerations are sufficiently incorporated into the IDB\u0027s wind energy projects. Guidance is provided in 3 specific areas corresponding to the 3 chapters of this report as follows:  Chapter 1: Efficacy of bird and bat impact minimization\/mitigation measures  - This chapter is intended as a review of the effectiveness of various measures that have been implemented at wind energy facilities to reduce wildlife fatalities. The emphasis of this chapter is on synthesizing empirical evidence supporting the effectiveness of the different measures, and the applicability of each measure to IDB\u2019s wind energy projects. This chapter was prepared by Julia Willmott (birds), E. Allison Costello (bats), and Caleb Gordon.  Chapter 2: Efficacy of preconstruction collision risk prediction models - This chapter is intended as an evaluation of the value of preconstruction collision risk modeling, as a tool to predict bird and\/or bat fatality rates at wind energy facilities prior to construction. The emphasis of this chapter is on empirical support for the prediction accuracy of existing models, as demonstrated by validation studies in which preconstruction predicted fatality rates are compared with observed postconstruction fatality rates. This chapter was prepared by Greg Forcey and Caleb Gordon, with input from a variety of wind-wildlife modeling experts who responded to a wind-wildlife collision risk modeling accuracy survey questionnaire developed for this review.  Chapter 3: Postconstruction fatality monitoring protocols for birds and bats - This chapter is intended to provide a standardized protocol and methodology for the monitoring of bird and bat fatalities of wind energy projects in operation. Essential considerations in developing this protocol include scientific validity, robustness, and comparability of data across projects, and also feasibility for application to IDB\u2019s wind energy projects. This chapter was prepared by Caleb Gordon and Sean Casto, with helpful discussion and commentary on an earlier draft provided by Drs. Amanda Hale and Victoria Bennett of Texas Christian University.","author":["Gordon, C.","Willmott, J.","Forcey, G.","Allison Costello, E.","Casto, S.","Beaulac, G.","Pilla, E."],"organization":["Normandeau Associates Inc","Inter-American Development Bank (IDB)"],"originationDate":"2012-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bird-and-Bat-Collision-Risks--Wind-Energy-Facilities.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1449","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-changes-bat-activity-response-acoustic-deterrent-implications-decreasing-bat","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.tcu.edu\/handle\/116099117\/17469","title":"Assessing changes in bat activity in response to an acoustic deterrent? Implications for decreasing bat fatalities at wind energy facilities","description":"No abstract\u00a0or information was provided for this thesis.","author":["Lindsey, C."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1450","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cool-rationalities-hot-air-rhetorical-approach-understanding-debates-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mitpressjournals.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1162\/glep.2008.8.2.67","title":"Cool Rationalities and Hot Air: A Rhetorical Approach to Understanding Debates on Renewable Energy","description":"A key obstacle to the wide-scale development of renewable energy is that public acceptability of wind energy cannot be taken for granted when wind energy moves from abstract support to local implementation. Drawing on a case study of opposition to the siting of a proposed off-shore wind farm in Northern Ireland, we offer a rhetorical analysis of a series of representative documents drawn from government, media, pro- and anti-wind energy sources, which identifies and interprets a number of discourses of objection and support. The analysis indicates that the key issue in terms of the transition to a renewable energy economy has little to do with the technology itself. Understanding the different nuances of pro- and anti-wind energy discourses highlights the importance of thinking about new ways of looking at these conflicts. These include adopting a \u201cconflict resolution\u201d approach and \u201cupstreaming\u201d public involvement in the decision-making process and also the counter-productive strategy of assuming that objection is based on ignorance (which can be solved by information) or NIMBY thinking (which can be solved by moral arguments about overcoming \u201cfree riders\u201d).","author":["Ellis, G.","Barry, J.","Robinson, C."],"organization":["Queens University"],"originationDate":"2008-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1451","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/using-deuterium-garp-estimate-geographic-extents-source-populations-hoary-lasiurus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.library.illinoisstate.edu\/etd\/180\/","title":"Using Deuterium and GARP To Estimate Geographic Extents of Source Populations of Hoary (Lasiurus cinereus) and Eastern Red (Lasiurus borealis) Bats Killed at a Central Illinois Wind Facility","description":"High bat mortality at wind energy facilities is a widely cited conservation issue, but the population-level impacts are not understood. In Illinois, the main species affected are migratory tree bats like the Hoary (Lasiurus cinereus) and Eastern Red (Lasiurus borealis).This research used deuterium isotope analysis of hair combined with ecological niche modeling (GARP: Genetic Algorithm for Rule-set Prediction) in a novel way to map the geographic extents of Hoary and Eastern Red bat specimens salvaged at a single central Illinois wind facility from 2008-2010. Hair was chosen after determining that the claw is currently a problematic tissue due to a lack of knowledge about bats\u0027 claw growth rates. Hair samples from different sample sites on the body were not significantly different from each other, and there was no significant variation among hair samples from the same body sample site.\n\nThe proportions of isotopic extents of both bats\u0027 summer ranges revealed that the salvaged specimens came from areas that cover more than 50% of their summer ranges (hence, many populations). When males\u0027 and females\u0027 isotope extents were overlapped, Hoary bats had less than 50% overlapping of the sexes while Eastern Red bats had over 50%. Relationships among the salvage years and months were also examined. The percentage of overlap among specimen salvage years suggests that these bats utilize their complete range every summer. When each salvage month was examined, there was no evidence of a correlation between month of arrival at the wind facility and their summer geographic extent. This study shows the importance of specimens salvaged from wind facilities for studying both the population-level impacts of wind farm facilities and bat migratory biology.","author":["Van Essen, R."],"organization":["Illinois State University"],"originationDate":"2014-04-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1452","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/quantifying-demographic-cost-human-related-mortality-raptor-population","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0172232","title":"Quantifying the Demographic Cost of Human-Related Mortality to a Raptor Population","description":"Raptors are exposed to a wide variety of human-related mortality agents, and yet population-level effects are rarely quantified. Doing so requires modeling vital rates in the context of species life-history, behavior, and population dynamics theory. In this paper, we explore the details of such an analysis by focusing on the demography of a resident, tree-nesting population of golden eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) in the vicinity of an extensive (142 km2) windfarm in California. During 1994\u20132000, we tracked the fates of \u003E250 radio-marked individuals of four life-stages and conducted five annual surveys of territory occupancy and reproduction. Collisions with wind turbines accounted for 41% of 88 uncensored fatalities, most of which were subadults and nonbreeding adults (floaters). A consistent overall male preponderance in the population meant that females were the limiting sex in this territorial, monogamous species. Estimates of potential population growth rate and associated variance indicated a stable breeding population, but one for which any further decrease in vital rates would require immigrant floaters to fill territory vacancies. Occupancy surveys 5 and 13 years later (2005 and 2013) showed that the nesting population remained intact, and no upward trend was apparent in the proportion of subadult eagles as pair members, a condition that would have suggested a deficit of adult replacements. However, the number of golden eagle pairs required to support windfarm mortality was large. We estimated that the entire annual reproductive output of 216\u2013255 breeding pairs would have been necessary to support published estimates of 55\u201365 turbine blade-strike fatalities per year. Although the vital rates forming the basis for these calculations may have changed since the data were collected, our approach should be useful for gaining a clearer understanding of how anthropogenic mortality affects the health of raptor populations, particularly those species with delayed maturity and naturally low reproductive rates.","author":["Hunt, T.","Wiens, J.","Hunt, W.","Driscoll, D.","Law, P.","Fuller, M.","Jackman, R."],"organization":["The Peregrine Fund","University of California Santa Cruz","US Geological Survey (USGS)","Nelson Mandela University","Garcia and Associates (GANDA)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.746639000000","-121.657921000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/GraingerHunt-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1453","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/application-isoscapes-determine-geographic-origin-terrestrial-wildlife-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320718304002","title":"Application of Isoscapes to Determine Geographic Origin of Terrestrial Wildlife for Conservation and Management","description":"Accounting for migration and connectivity of mobile species across the annual cycle can present challenges for conservation and management efforts. The use of\u00a0stable isotope\u00a0approaches to examine the movements and\u00a0ecology\u00a0of wildlife has been widespread over the past two decades. Hydrogen stable isotope (\u03b42H) composition, in particular, has been frequently used to provide insight into the origin of\u00a0migratory species, although isotopes of other elements are sometimes used. These intrinsic markers can yield valuable information about distributions of wildlife on a broad scale, with reduced labor and expense compared to tracking and\u00a0telemetry. Many of the applications of isotopes to migratory species to date have addressed connectivity and origin, and studies in support of conservation\u00a0biology\u00a0are less common. In addition, there are few guides for how to best employ these methods for management. Therefore, we provide an overview for the\u00a0wildlife conservation and management\u00a0community on how stable isotope methods may be applied to conservation problems and a primer on the process for assigning geographic origins to terrestrial wildlife. We also discuss best practices for employing environmental isoscapes (isotopic distributions across landscapes), rescaling functions, and the assumptions required for assignment to origin while highlighting emerging issues in the modeling process. Finally, we provide example applications to illustrate these principles, and we explore strengths and limitations of this approach in a conservation context.","author":["Katzner, T.","Wunder, M.","Nelson, D.","Vander Zanden, H.","Conkling, T."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","University of Maryland","University of Colorado Boulder","University of Florida"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1454","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/disturbance-effects-harbour-porpoise-population-north-sea-depons-status-report-model","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dce2.au.dk\/pub\/SR140.pdf","title":"Disturbance Effects on the Harbour Porpoise Population in the North Sea (DEPONS): Status report on model development","description":"There is mounting scientific evidence that anthropogenic disturbances, such as offshore wind farm construction, affect the behaviour of harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) and other marine mammals. The impact of noise generated through human activities on porpoise population dynamics has, so far, only been evaluated for the inner Danish waters (IDW) population. As part of the Disturbance Effects on the Harbour Porpoise Population in the North Sea (DEPONS) project, the main goal of this report is to demonstrate how the individual-based model (IBM) that was developed to simulate the cumulative impacts of different kinds of disturbances on the porpoise population in the IDW can be extended for evaluating the impact of pile-driving noise from offshore wind farm construction on the porpoise population in the North Sea (DEPONS model). The focus of this status report is on model parameterization and the types of processes included in the DEPONS model. The presented results are only indicative of the kinds of effects to be expected in the final model simulations. Although the results based partly on parameters for the IDW can give a first indication of the impact of different wind farm construction scenarios on the porpoise population in the North Sea, the DEPONS model output will become more accurate as the behaviour of the simulated porpoises is refined to resemble North Sea porpoises more closely. Porpoise deterrence behaviour in relation to pile-driving noise was parameterised based on empirical data showing reductions in porpoise density at different distances from the construction site before and during pile-driving events as collected around the DanTysk wind farm in the North Sea. We considered five different porpoise movement and dispersal strategies, which were either derived from theoretical movement models or from behaviour observed in the IDW. We used the movement\/dispersal models in combination with three hypothetical pile-driving scenarios ranging from no noise to a realistic but worst case piling scenario. We compared the average simulated porpoise population sizes and dynamics across movement\/dispersal models and pile-driving scenarios. Although the results should be considered preliminary, the patterns generated by the current version of the DEPONS model did not suggest any clear, long-lasting effects of pile-driving noise on the average porpoise population size and dynamics in the North Sea. The movement\/dispersal strategy employed by the simulated porpoises had a far greater impact on the population size and whether population dynamics stabilized over time. To improve the DEPONS model further and enhance model inference, we highlight and discuss several model components that need to be investigated in more detail so as to replace certain underlying assumptions in the model with a direct data driven parameterization approach. Most importantly, empirical data on porpoise movement behaviour and dispersal strategies from the North Sea are required to better parameterize the model. Most of the data deficiencies in the current parameterization will be addressed during the remainder of the DEPONS project. The preliminary results presented here do indicate that the DEPONS model can ultimately become a valuable and powerful modelling platform for use in informing offshore wind farm construction planning.","author":["Tougaard, J.","Teilmann, J.","Nabe-Nielsen, J.","Carstensen, J.","van Beest, F."],"organization":["Aarhus University","Forewind","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2015-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/VanBeest-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1455","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-larger-turbines-offshore-wind-farm-kriegers-flak-sweden-assessment-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dce2.au.dk\/pub\/SR286.pdf","title":"Effects of larger turbines for the offshore wind farm at Krieger\u0027s Flak, Sweden. Assessment of impact on marine mammals","description":"Construction and operation of an offshore wind farm on the Swedish part of Kriegers Flak has been assessed with respect to impacts on marine mammals, in the context of an application to increase the size of turbines in the wind farm, compared to the original Environmental Impact Assessment from 2004.  Abundance of marine mammals  Two species of seals, harbour seal (Phoca vitulina, knubbs\u00e4l) and grey seal (Halichoerus grypus, gr\u00e5s\u00e4l) are abundant in the waters around Kriegers Flak. Both populations are in favourable conservation status.  One cetacean, the harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena, tumlare) inhabits the waters around Kriegers Flak. The area is a mixing zone between two populations. The by far largest number of porpoises in the area are believed to belong to the Danish Belt Seas population, which is in favourable conservation status. A smaller number of porpoises, in particular during winter months, are believed to belong to the critically endangered population in the Baltic Proper.  Sensitivity to impact  Underwater noise is likely to be a main source of potential impact from windfarm construction, in particular percussive piling of foundations. Percussive pile driving is known to generate very high sound pressures, likely capable of inflicting permanent damage to the hearing of seals and porpoises and has been shown to cause behavioural disturbances at distances of tens of km from the pile driving site. Various mitigation measures are available, including use of deterring devices, soft-start and reduction of radiated noise by means of for example air bubble curtains. Magnitude of impact was assessed for direct damage (acoustic trauma), hearing loss (permanent threshold shift, PTS), disturbance of behaviour and masking. Hearing loss was assessed by considering total cumulated sound exposure levels (SELcum) over the duration expected for piling of one foundation (4.5 hours), taking movements of the animals into consideration and applying appropriate auditory frequency weighting to the acoustic measurements. Disturbance of behaviour was assessed by applying reaction distances from observational studies at other wind farm construction projects.  Impact from construction  Noise exposure from pile driving was modelled in a worst-case scenario. This scenario included the largest monopiles under investigation for the project (15 m pile diameter) and worst-case assumptions regarding location of the turbine foundation and sound propagation properties of the surrounding waters (upward-refracting sound speed profile). This scenario included standard practice of deployment of a deterring device and soft-start procedure as mitigation against damage to marine mammal hearing. It is considered unlikely that marine mammals will be exposed to sound pressures likely to cause acoustic trauma. Under this scenario, it is expected that seals and porpoises close to the pile-driving site will be exposed to levels capable of inflicting smaller amounts of permanent hearing loss. This hearing loss is assessed to have a minor impact on the populations of harbour seals, grey seals and porpoises from the Danish Belt Sea population. In a precautionary assessment, the impact on the critically endangered Baltic Proper population of porpoises is assessed to be moderate during winter months and minor during summer months. The difference in assessments is due to the seemingly very low likelihood of encountering porpoises from the Baltic Proper population around Kriegers Flak during summer. Pile driving is also likely to cause disturbances to the natural behaviour of both seals and porpoises. The magnitude of this disturbance was assessed by relating the expected area of disturbance to the total area where the different species are regularly encountered. The largest impact from disturbance is expected for harbour seals and Baltic Proper porpoises in winter, where the impact is assessed to be moderate. The impact on grey seals and Belt Sea porpoises is assessed to be minor and for Baltic Proper porpoises in summer impact is assessed to be negligible, due to the very low likelihood of encountering porpoises from this population during summer.  Impacts can be reduced by reducing the radiated noise from the pile driving. This was investigated by modelling the noise impact by application of a bubble curtain, currently considered best available technology for reduction of noise radiation. The bubble curtain is expected to reduce the broadband source level of the piling by at least 5.5 dB and frequency weighted levels even more. Such a reduction in radiated noise means that permanent hearing loss is not expected to occur in neither seals, nor porpoises, and impact from hearing loss is thus assessed to be negligible on all populations. Reduction of radiated noise from piling is also predicted to reduce both impact ranges and duration of the disturbance of behaviour. Impact from disturbance of behaviour is thus assessed to be minor for all populations, except for Baltic Proper porpoises in summer, where it is assessed as negligible, due to the low likelihood of encountering these animals. It is considered unlikely that pile driving noise will be capable of masking sounds relevant to porpoises to any noticeable degree and the magnitude of this impact on porpoises was thus assessed as negligible. There is a possibility that communication sounds from both grey seals and harbour seals can be masked by pile driving noise, but as this communication is only expected to take place close to haul out sites (primarily at Falsterbo), the possible masking is considered to be small and impact assessed as minor. Cumulative effects of simultaneous pile driving at one or more currently planned offshore wind farms in the area are considered negligible.    Impact from operation  No negative effects of the wind farm is predicted once in operation and the effect is thus assessed as negligible, based on studies of effects of operating offshore wind farms on seals and porpoises. The cumulative effect of adding an additional offshore wind farm to already existing offshore wind farms in the area is likewise considered negligible.  Impact on Natura2000 areas  It is considered likely that the adjacent Natura2000 area Sydv\u00e4stsk\u00e5nes Udsj\u00f6vatten will be impacted during construction of the wind farm. Disturbance from pile driving is estimated to make 27% of the habitat area inaccessible to seals and porpoises (computed in both time and space) during the period where pile driving takes place, and is assessed to constitute a major impact. Application of mitigation measures to reduce the emitted noise during pile driving, such as bubble curtains, is estimated capable of reducing the habitat loss to 2.5%, and the disturbance in that case is assessed to constitute a minor impact. Impact on Sydv\u00e4stsk\u00e5nes Udsj\u00f6vatten during operation of the wind farm is assessed as negligible, as are the impacts of both construction and operation on the remaining Natura2000 areas in Swedish, Danish and German waters.","author":["Tougaard, J.","Mikaelsen, M."],"organization":["Aarhus University","NIRAS","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.027000000000","12.939000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Pinnipeds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-02 06:45:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tougaard_and_Mikaelsen_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1456","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-mammals-investigations-preparation-environmental-impact-assessment-kriegers","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pure.au.dk\/portal\/en\/publications\/marine-mammals-investigations-and-preparation-of-environmental-im","title":"Marine Mammals - Investigations and preparation of environmental impact assessment for Kriegers Flak Offshore Wind Farm","description":"Energinet.dk has commissioned NIRAS and subcontractors to conduct the environmental impact assessment (EIA) for the construction and operation of the largest offshore wind farm, called Kriegers Flak, in Denmark to date. The preliminary study area of 180 km2 around the projected wind farm is located approximately 15 km east of the east coast of Zealand, in the South-western part of the Baltic bordering the EEZ (Exclusive Economic Zone) of Sweden and Germany. The exact wind farm area will consist of two sections, 44km2 to the west and 88 km2 to the east of the study area. As part of the EIA, DCE\/Aarhus University and DHI have conducted the baseline studies on marine mammals to assess the impacts of the construction and operation of a wind farm at Kriegers Flak. Three species of marine mammals are known to occur regularly in the area of Kriegers Flak: harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena), harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) and grey seals (Halichoerus gryphus). All three species are protected by international agreements and legislation, including the EU Habitats Directive, the Convention for protection of Migratory Species (Bonn-convention), ASCOBANS, HELCOM as well as national legislation. The purpose of this report is to outline the baseline conditions for the marine mammals occurring in the Kriegers Flak area by providing detailed information on their spatial and temporal use of the area, and to evaluate the potential effects of the construction, operation and dismantling of the planned wind farm on the marine mammals.","author":["Skov, H.","Teilmann, J.","Nabe-Nielsen, J.","Thomsen, F.","Dietz, R.","Sveegaard, S.","Riget, F.","Mikkelsen, L.","Galatius, A.","Schack, H."],"organization":["Aarhus University","Danish Hydraulic Institute (DHI)"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.027000000000","12.939000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-02 06:45:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Dietz-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1457","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farm-kriegers-flak-environmental-impact-assessment","sourceURL":"","title":"Wind Farm - Kriegers Flak: Environmental Impact Assessment","description":"Sweden Offshore Wind AB (hereinafter Sweden Offshore) is developing a wind farm on Kriegers Flak, an area in the southern Baltic Sea outside of Swedish territorial waters, situated about 30 km south of Trelleborg. The wind farm will consist of maximum 128 wind turbines with a total installed capacity of maximum 640 MW. This document constitutes an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) in accordance with Chapter 6 of the Swedish Environmental Code (EC). In accordance with the EC, Chapter 6, Section 7, an EIA shall contain the following information:    A non-technical summary  A description of the planned activity (location, design, scope etc.)  A description of alternative locations and designs  A description of the consequences of not implementing the planned activity  A description of the impact on human health, the environment and the economising of land and water resources  A description of actions to minimise impact   The purpose of an EIA is to identify and describe the direct and indirect effects that a planned activity or action may have on humans, animals, fauna, land, water, air, climate, landscape and cultural heritage, partly also on the economising of land, water and the physical environment in general and partly on the economising with raw material, energy and other materials. Further, the purpose is to facilitate a collected view of these effects on human health and the environment. This EIA primarily deals with the wind farm. However, it also deals with the cabling within the Swedish Economic Zone. Therefore, and as the cabling is a precondition for the realisation of the project, certain information about the cabling has been included in this document (Chapter 16). The cabling within Swedish territorial water will be subject to a separate permitting process in due course.","author":["Sweden Offshore Wind AB"],"organization":["Vattenfall","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2007-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.027000000000","12.930000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-02 06:46:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Sweden-Offshore-Wind-2007.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1458","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/us-geological-survey-energy-wildlife-research-annual-report-2018","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.3133\/cir1447","title":"U.S. Geological Survey energy and wildlife research annual report for 2018","description":"Terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems provide valuable services to humans and are a source of clean water, raw materials, and productive soils. Healthy rivers contribute to commercial fisheries, native pollinators enhance agricultural crops, and insect-eating bats provide pest control services worth billions of dollars to farmers annually (Boyles and others, 2011). Fish and wildlife are vital to a vibrant outdoor recreation and tourism industry, which generates billions of dollars in revenue to States, large and small businesses, and local communities (Cullinane Thomas and others, 2018).\n\nU.S. Geological Survey (USGS) scientists study and monitor fish and wildlife, providing natural resource managers evidence-based information on the status and trends of species of interest. A rigorous scientific process is applied to understand risks, measure impacts, and inform solutions to national and local challenges facing both humans and wildlife. Energy security remains a national priority, and the United States is expanding access to vast natural resources to produce electricity as well as petroleum and natural gas products to meet society\u2019s growing energy needs (U.S. EIA, 2017). Oil and gas production and wind and solar energy generation have shown consistent growth over the last 10 years. Currently, more than 57,000 wind turbines are contributing to power grids in 41 States, Guam, and Puerto Rico (American Wind Energy Association, 2018).\n\nWith expanding energy generation infrastructure across the Nation, some conflicts have surfaced. Effects of energy infrastructure include fragmentation and loss of habitat as well as mortality of birds, bats, fish, and other wildlife interacting with energy generation facilities. Because energy development often takes place in critical wildlife habitats, ecological science can be used to help guide project siting and operational decisions to areas and practices that present the lowest risk to energy development and wildlife. The USGS produces science that addresses challenges and develops workable solutions to help sustain wildlife and their habitats while allowing informed development.","author":["Khalil, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Fish","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Khalil-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1459","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-novel-approach-optimize-operational-minimization-reduce-bat-fatalities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/curtailment-deterrence.html","title":"Evaluating a Novel Approach to Optimize Operational Minimization to Reduce Bat Fatalities at the Pinnacle Wind Farm, Mineral County, West Virginia, 2015","description":"In accordance with the guidance of the West Virginia Public Service Commission (WVPSC) and with recommendations from the Pinnacle Technical Advisory Committee, which included members from the WVPSC, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), West Virginia Division of Natural Resources (WVDNR), and NRG Energy, we initiated a study in July 2015 to test alternative wind turbine operational strategies to reduce bat fatalities at the Pinnacle Wind, LLC (PWF), Mineral County, West Virginia. Our primary objective was to test the effectiveness of a novel operational minimization strategy to reduce bat fatalities at Pinnacle Wind Farm, LLC (PWF). A secondary objective was to examine potential mechanisms that effect fatality risk to bats.  We randomly selected 15 of the 23 turbines at the PWF for the experiment to evaluate 3 operational minimization strategies. We used a completely randomized block design and treatments were randomly assigned to turbines each night of the experiment, with the night when treatments were applied as the experimental unit. We conducted daily fatality searches between 15 July and 30 September 2015, which represents the expected peak fatality period of bats for this region. The following treatments involved the decision framework to initiate turbine start-up and included:  Treatment A: increased the wind speed requirement to initiate turbine start-up from 3.0 m\/s and fully feathered blades until wind speed reached 5.0 m\/s based on a 10-minute rolling average as measured at a nearby meteorological (met) tower anemometer at 76 m above ground level (agl). Turbine blades were fully feathered until wind speeds reached 5 m\/s. This treatment is currently the standard operating procedure at the PWF from 15 July\u201330 September,  Treatment B: increased the wind speed requirement to initiate turbine start-up from 3.0 m\/s and fully feathered blades until wind speed reached 5.0 m\/s based on a 20-minute rolling average measured at the same meteorological tower as Treatment A, and  Treatment C: increased the wind speed requirement to initiate turbine start-up from 3.0 m\/s and fully feathered until wind speed reached 5.0 m\/s based on a 20-minute rolling average as measured from anemometers on individual turbines at 80 m agl. To reduce the effects of the turbine blades on the wind speed measured downwind on the nacelle mounted anemometer, proprietary calculations were implemented to determine the \u201cfree-stream wind speed\u201d.  Decisions to shut-down operations, or curtail turbines, were all based on a 10-minute rolling average of wind speed \u0026lt;5.0 m\/s as measured at the met tower for Treatments A and B and the individual turbine for Treatment C. Thus, the shutdown\/start-up decision framework for Treatment A was symmetrical (10-minute average to shut-down and start-up), whereas Treatments B and C were asymmetrical (10-minute average to shut-down, 20-minute average to start-up), but with wind speed measurements based on the met tower for Treatment A and B and the individual turbine Treatment C.  During standardized searches, we found 57 fresh bat carcasses, representing 5 different species, including 31 eastern red bats (Lasiurus borealis), 11 hoary bats (Lasiurus cinereus), 10 big brown bats (Eptesicus fuscus), 4 silver-haired bats (Lasionycteris noctivagans), and 1 tri-colored bat (Perimyotis subflavus). No Myotis species were found. We found 17 bat fatalities associated with 4 Treatment A, 12 under Treatment B, and 23 under Treatment C. We removed 5 carcasses prior to analysis because they were associated with nights that experienced treatment implementation error.  We used two methods, Poisson regression and estimated fatality, to evaluate the 3 operational minimization strategies based on fresh bat fatalities. These two methods generally supported each other, although estimated fatality, corrected for detection bias, was the only one that showed a significant difference and only between Treatments B and C. The best Poisson Regression model explaining the number of bat fatalities found under turbines only included turbine differences, but the models with mean hours on and treatment were within 1 Deviance Information Criterion (DIC) unit. In general, Treatment C had higher bat fatalities, significantly higher than Treatment B, and turbines in that treatment were operational for significantly longer periods compared to Treatments A and B. The turbine anemometer had an average 1.03 m\/s higher wind speed value compared to the met tower, which likely caused turbines under Treatment C to start-up earlier and shut-down later increasing the operating time. Operating time was not significant and therefore was not solely determined to be the reason for higher bat fatalities based on our Poisson regression models.  As a secondary objective, we examined potential mechanisms that influenced fatality only on nights when turbines were operating regardless of treatment. The best logistic regression mixed model of bat fatalities found per hour the turbine was spinning included number of stops. However, stops\/starts and starts were within one AIC unit. This suggested that bats may be at risk during operational transitions (i.e. during turbine start-up or shut-down), specifically the probability of finding a fatality increased significantly with an increasing number of stops. Alternatively, since all treatments were based on a wind speed of 5 m\/s it is difficult to separate risk to bats when turbine operations were in transition compared to risk at relatively low wind speeds (e.g. ~ 5 m\/s), which might influence changes in turbine operation.  The results of this study suggest that fewer bat fatalities occurred when turbine operations were based on the meteorological tower (Treatment A and B) rather than the individual turbine (Treatment C). This is likely associated with the amount of time turbines were in operation each night, which was longer for Treatment C, although our models suggested other factors may also influence fatality. Furthermore, extending the decision time, from 10 minutes (Treatment A) to 20 minutes (Treatment B), to begin operating turbines when wind speeds exceed the cut-in speed, also may reduce fatalities by reducing the number of transitions (i.e., turbine start-ups and shut-downs). Minimizing the number of start-ups\/shut-downs may assist in reducing wear-andtear on turbines and, at least in this study, may also reduce the power loss related to this reduction strategy. Thus, Treatment B represents a decision framework with fewer fatalities, significantly fewer than Treatment C, and compared to Treatment A had less wear-and-tear on turbines (i.e. start-up and shut-downs) with no additional loss in power, and may be the most cost effective option of the 3 treatments studied in this experiment.  The relationship between turbine transitions and bat fatalities is unclear and additional research is needed at other wind energy facilities to better understand bat\/wind turbine interactions during start-ups and shut-downs. Until more data are gathered, implementing strategies that limit operational transition of turbines at low wind speeds, such as extending the average decision time period (e.g., from 10 to 20 minutes) to inform turbine operation, may further reduce bat fatalities at the same cut-in speed. Moreover, limiting the number of times 5 turbines start-up and shut-down may reduce turbine wear-and-tear and power loss, which provide benefits for wind facility operators. Future research across a variety of facilities, turbine types and species should consider comparing differences between a longer decision framework and higher cut-in speeds or combine different decision frameworks with additional weather variables to assess the most cost-effective strategy to reduce bat fatalities at wind turbines.","author":["Mabee, T.","Hein, C.","Schirmacher, M.","Prichard, A."],"organization":["Bat Conservation International","Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.343805700000","-80.261396900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Schirmacher-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1460","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-offshore-wind-farms-belgian-part-north-sea-assessing-managing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/odnature.naturalsciences.be\/mumm\/en\/windfarms\/","title":"Environmental Impacts of Offshore Wind Farms in the Belgian Part of the North Sea: Assessing and Managing Effect Spheres of Influence","description":"The European Directive 2001\/77\/EC, on the promotion of electricity produced from renewable energy sources in the internal electricity market, imposes a target figure for the contribution of the production of electricity from renewable energy sources upon each Member State. For Belgium, this target figure is 13% of the total energy consumption, which must be achieved by 2020. Offshore wind farms in the Belgian part of the North Sea are expected to make an important contribution (ca. 43%, assuming 2000 MW installed capacity by 2020) to achieve that goal.  Within the Belgian part of the North Sea (BPNS), a zone of 238 km\u00b2 is reserved for the production of electricity from water, currents or wind. Four wind farms are already operational. With five more to come, major ecological changes may however be expected.  Prior to installing a wind farm, a developer must obtain a domain concession and an environmental permit. The environmental permit includes a number of terms and conditions intended to minimise and\/or mitigate the impact of the project on the marine ecosystem. Furthermore, as required by law, the  permit imposes a monitoring programme to assess the effects of the project onto the marine environment.  Within the monitoring programme, the Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences and its partners assess the extent of the anticipated impacts onto the marine ecosystem and aim at revealing the processes behind these impacts. The first objective is basically tackled through the baseline monitoring, focusing on the a posteriori, resultant impact quantification, while the second monitoring objective is covered by the targeted or process monitoring, focusing on the cause-effect relationships of a priori selected impacts. As such, the baseline monitoring deals with observing rather than understanding impacts and hence leads to area-specific results, which might form a basis for halting activities.  This report, targeting marine scientists, marine managers and policy makers, and offshore wind farm developers presents an overview of the scientific findings of the Belgian offshore wind farm monitoring programme, based on data collected up to and including 2017.","author":["Degraer, S.","Rumes, B.","Brabant, R.","Vigin, L."],"organization":["Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","C-Power","Parkwind"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.540075000000","2.782899000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Invertebrates","Birds","Seabirds","Physical Environment","Fish","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment","Sediment Transport","Noise","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-09 06:40:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Degraer-et-al-2018_1.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1461","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/maritime-renewable-energy-markets-power-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/contentone\/mts\/mtsj\/2018\/00000052\/00000005\/art00011","title":"Maritime Renewable Energy Markets: Power From the Sea","description":"Marine renewable energy (MRE) is in the early stages of contributing to the energy portfolios of the United States and many other nations around the world. Although many MRE developers are designing devices that will harvest energy to contribute to the electrical grid from waves, tides, and ocean currents, a number of other promising maritime markets could be supplied with MRE power at sea. These maritime markets are often less price sensitive, have fewer options than utility-scale electricity markets, and can handle some degree of intermittency. Some of the promising maritime markets that could benefit from co-located power generation include ocean observation nodes, underwater recharge of autonomous vehicles, desalination of seawater for remote coastal areas, offshore aquaculture, shoreline protection and electricity generation, providing electricity and freshwater following coastal emergencies, providing power to islanded and isolated communities, powering and cooling nearshore underwater data centers, recharging of electric surface vessels, and personal charging of electronics. Pairing of MRE power generation with these and other maritime markets is in the early stages, but the potential for synergy and growth of MRE coupled to these markets is promising.","author":["Copping, A.","Gill, G.","Gorton, A.","LiVecchi, A.","Spence, H.","Jenne, S.","Preus, R.","Robichaud, R.","Gore, S."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1462","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-collisions-offshore-platform-north-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/00063657.2015.1134440","title":"Bird collisions at an offshore platform in the North Sea","description":"Capsule Collisions with offshore structures in the North Sea could account for the mortality of hundreds of thousands of nocturnally migrating birds.\u00a0\n\n\nAims:\u00a0To assess, for the first time, the circumstances of mass fatalities at an offshore structure, including the species involved, their numbers, ages, body conditions and injuries.\u00a0\n\n\nMethods: At an unmanned tall offshore research platform in the southeastern North Sea, bird corpses were collected on 160 visiting days from October 2003 to December 2007. Corpses were identified to species and kinds of injury, ages, and fat and muscle scores were determined. Nocturnal bird calls were recorded, identified to species and quantified. Local and large-scale weather parameters were also considered.\u00a0\n\n\nResults: A total of 767 birds of 34 species, mainly thrushes, European Starlings and other passerines, were found at 45 visits. Most carcasses were in good body condition and young birds were not more affected than adults. Three quarters of 563 examined individuals had collision induced injuries. Birds in poor body condition were less likely to be collision victims than those in good condition. Mass collision events at the illuminated offshore structure coincided with increasingly adverse weather conditions and an increasing call intensity of nocturnal birds.\u00a0\n\n\nConclusions: Assuming an average of 150 dead birds per year at this single offshore structure and additionally assuming that a considerable proportion of the corpses were not found, we estimate that mortality at the 1000 + human structures in the North Sea could reach hundreds of thousands of birds. Since offshore industrialization will progress and collision numbers at offshore turbines will consequently increase considerably, we recommend reinforced measures to reduce bird strikes at offshore structures, especially in the light of substantial declines in some migrant species.","author":["H\u00fcppop, O.","Hill, R.","Huppop, K.","Diersche, J."],"organization":["Institute of Avian Research \u0027Vogelwarte Helgoland\u0027","Avitec Research"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1463","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/empirical-evidence-factors-affecting-searcher-efficiency-scavenging-rates-coastal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fwspubs.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3996\/032014-JFWM-019","title":"Empirical Evidence for Factors Affecting Searcher Efficiency and Scavenging Rates at a Coastal, Terrestrial Wind-Power Facility","description":"The rapid expansion of wind power development in recent years has accentuated the need to develop standard guidelines for identifying, assessing, and monitoring potential impacts to birds and bats. Although postconstruction mortality estimates generally take into account well-established sources of bias, including searcher efficiency and scavenging loss, methods for addressing these biases can be improved. Currently used bias-adjustment methods differ across studies, do not explicitly account for factors that may affect initial bias estimates, and often use averaged or assumed levels of bias. We examined scavenging and detection trial data from a 3-y study at a small, terrestrial wind-farm in coastal New Jersey. Logistic regression models indicated that carcass size, substrate, and observer all affected carcass detection rates, with larger carcasses more likely to be detected than smaller carcasses, and those located on bare ground or grass more likely to be detected than those on gravel. Known-fate mark-recapture models indicated that scavenging rates were highest within the first 3 d of placement, with some variation among seasons. We suggest that empirically based estimates of factors affecting observer detection and scavenging loss be generated for individual wind-farm mortality studies, because they likely vary across sites and could heavily bias resulting adjustment factors and mortality estimates.","author":["Mizrahi, D.","Peters, K.","Allen, M."],"organization":["New Jersey Audubon Society"],"originationDate":"2014-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.366670000000","-74.450000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1464","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/utilization-probability-map-migrating-bald-eagles-northeastern-north-america-tool","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0157807","title":"Utilization Probability Map for Migrating Bald Eagles in Northeastern North America: A Tool for Siting Wind Energy Facilities and Other Flight Hazards","description":"Collisions with anthropogenic structures are a significant and well documented source of mortality for avian species worldwide. The bald eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) is known to be vulnerable to collision with wind turbines and federal wind energy guidelines include an eagle risk assessment for new projects. To address the need for risk assessment, in this study, we 1) identified areas of northeastern North America utilized by migrating bald eagles, and 2) compared these with high wind-potential areas to identify potential risk of bald eagle collision with wind turbines. We captured and marked 17 resident and migrant bald eagles in the northern Chesapeake Bay between August 2007 and May 2009. We produced utilization distribution (UD) surfaces for 132 individual migration tracks using a dynamic Brownian bridge movement model and combined these to create a population wide UD surface with a 1 km cell size. We found eagle migration movements were concentrated within two main corridors along the Appalachian Mountains and the Atlantic Coast. Of the 3,123 wind turbines \u0026gt;= 100 m in height in the study area, 38% were located in UD 20, and 31% in UD 40. In the United States portion of the study area, commercially viable wind power classes overlapped with only 2% of the UD category 20 (i.e., the areas of highest use by migrating eagles) and 4% of UD category 40. This is encouraging because it suggests that wind energy development can still occur in the study area at sites that are most viable from a wind power perspective and are unlikely to cause significant mortality of migrating eagles. In siting new turbines, wind energy developers should avoid the high-use migration corridors (UD categories 20 \u0026amp; 40) and focus new wind energy projects on lower-risk areas (UD categories 60-100).","author":["Mojica, E.","Watts, B.","Turrin, C."],"organization":["College of William and Mary","EDM International Inc","Yale University"],"originationDate":"2016-06-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1465","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-bird-bat-mortality-forward-energy-center","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/264890518_Assessing_Bird_and_Bat_Mortality_at_the_Forward_Energy_Center","title":"Assessing Bird and Bat Mortality at the Forward Energy Center","description":"The Forward Energy Center (Center) consists of 86 General Electric 1.5MW turbines in southeastern Wisconsin. Each turbine has an 80-meter hub height and 120-meter rotor-tip height. The turbines are located in agricultural land (corn\/soybean rotations being the predominant crop types) in southern Fond du Lac County and northern Dodge County. The Center is approximately 5 km east of Horicon National Wildlife Refuge, 63 km west of Lake Michigan, 22 km north of Neda Mine State Natural Area, and 21 km south of Lake Winnebago. Steve Grodsky and Dr. David Drake conducted a two year bird and bat mortality study.  The primary objectives of our study were to:  1) Assess bird and bat mortality at the Center,  2) Provide corrected mortality estimations for birds and bats using the most recent statistical estimator, and  3) Correlate observed mortality rates with select weather variables, proximity to Horicon Marsh and Neda Mine, turbine operating status, and bird and bat activity at the Center.  When comparing corrected mortality estimates, bird and bat mortality rates recorded at the Forward Energy Center were similar to those of neighboring wind farms and other studies throughout the Midwest. In order to understand corrected mortality estimates in the proper context comparisons with other wind project mortality studies are presented with the caveat that direct comparisons are difficult and potentially misleading due to the crucial differences between study methodologies, especially those used in searches and mortality estimators.","author":["Drake, D.","Grodsky, S."],"organization":["University of Wisconsin","Forward Energy Group LLC"],"originationDate":"2011-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.616940000000","-88.491111000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Grodsky_and_Drake_2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1466","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/landscape-design-integrating-ecological-social-economic-considerations-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/wsb.683","title":"Landscape design: Integrating ecological, social, and economic considerations into conservation planning","description":"Landscape design is a conservation planning process, described in the landscape ecology literature, proposed to rectify the knowledge and implementation gap in planning that have limited the effectiveness of many conservation planning efforts. Use of landscape design bridges this gap through increased emphasis on the interdisciplinary nature of conservation planning and engagement of a stakeholder advisory team to create a conservation plan that resonates with biological, cultural, social, and economic realities of the area concerned. We define landscape design as a conservation planning process that integrates societal goals and values with established biological conservation goals, using science grounded in landscape ecology to describe future scenarios where specific and measurable biological goals can be attained. First, we describe a landscape design process and provide examples from the literature and partnerships such as Connect the Connecticut and the Appalachian Landscape Conservation Cooperative. We follow by discussing a case study of a landscape design effort to conserve playa wetlands to support waterfowl goals for migrating waterfowl established in the North American Waterfowl Management Plan. We further highlight characteristics of a successfully completed landscape design. We conclude that landscape design is a powerful process that goes beyond identifying high\u2010priority conservation assets and intended to be an action\u2010oriented process. Landscape design provides a framework for ensuring that conservation planning does not occur in a vacuum by ensuring social, cultural, and economic needs of people are recognized before valuable conservation dollars are expended. It provides a mechanism for understanding the effects of future landscape drivers on natural resources and engages stakeholders in proactive discussions regarding conservation. The final result is a commitment by a partnership to a set of actions that will achieve the stated conservation goal.\u00a0","author":["Taylor, K.","Bartuszevige, A.","Carter, M.","Daniels, A."],"organization":["Playa Lakes Joint Venture"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1467","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/energy-development-siting-recommendations-playas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pljv.org\/for-industry\/energy-development-siting-recommendations-for-playas\/","title":"Energy Development Siting Recommendations for Playas","description":"Playa Lakes Joint Venture (PLJV) has developed Energy Development Siting Recommendations for Playas, which take a precautionary approach around playas by advising that all energy development and associated infrastructure avoid playa clusters. We believe infrastructure on or near playas, playa clusters, or large isolated playas may adversely affect wildlife habitat and may increase the risk of collision mortality for waterfowl and other wetland birds. This guidance depends on PLJV\u2019s mapping of playa clusters, which can be viewed and downloaded as part of our playa decision support system.  Playas are round, shallow, clay-lined wetlands found throughout the short- and mixed-grass prairie region. Precipitation and associated runoff is the sole source of water for playas. Once a playa has filled it may remain wet for several months, eventually drying out to start the process all over again. The hydroperiod of individual playas is highly variable over time and differs amongst playas.  As of this writing over 80,000 playas have been mapped in the western Great Plains region. The distribution of playas varies across the region; playas are sparsely distributed in some areas and clustered in other areas. These high density clusters of playas have been shown to host significantly greater numbers of waterfowl than other areas. In areas with few playas, large isolated playas can serve as stepping stone wetlands which connect playa clusters for feeding waterfowl.  Waterfowl (e.g., ducks and geese), shorebirds (e.g., plovers, rails, sandpipers) and waterbirds (e.g., cranes), as well as the birds that prey on them (e.g., raptors), use inundated playas during migration as stopover points for feeding and resting. Proximity of infrastructure to playas may directly affect avian mortality as birds traverse among playas, and the constant disturbance and persistent noise in the area may indirectly impact many bird species. Where playas are the only source of nearby surface water, they can attract many species of wildlife, often in high concentrations. Wet playas are known to be habitat for amphibians, a taxon which is experiencing world-wide declines, and reptiles such as the yellow mud turtle. Bats are known to feed on emerging insects at wet playas. Placement of energy infrastructure in playas may reduce water-holding capacity and reduce or degrade habitat for wetland dependent species.  Energy development on playa wetlands (either directly within a playa or among a cluster of playas) may limit the hydrologic function of the playas. Playas recharge the High Plains (Ogallala) Aquifer by allowing percolation of surface water through the clay layer of soil in the basin. Recharge through playa basins occurs at a rate one to two orders of magnitude greater than through inter-playa areas.","author":["Bartuszevige, A.","Carter, M.","Daniels, A.","McCready, B."],"organization":["Playa Lakes Joint Venture","Playa Lakes Joint Venture"],"originationDate":"2017-05-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bartuszevige_et_al_2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1468","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proposal-permit-take-provided-under-bald-golden-eagle-protection-act","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.regulations.gov\/document?D=FWS-R9-MB-2011-0094-0491","title":"Proposal to Permit Take Provided Under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act","description":"The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has removed the bald eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) from the list of threatened and endangered species under the Federal Endangered Species Act in all areas except the range of the Sonoran Desert bald eagle population, which remains protected as a threatened species. The Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (Eagle Act) remains as the primary law protecting bald eagles in other parts of its range and the golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetos).     The Eagle Act authorizes the Secretary to permit take of eagles \u201cnecessary for the protection of \u2026 other interests in any particular locality.\u201d In addition, there may be instances where take of eagle nests is necessary to protect public safety and welfare.      In this assessment we consider three alternatives for regulations establishing new take permits under the Eagle Act, and authorizing take of eagle nests where necessary to protect public safety and welfare.     The assessment looks at potential impacts that could result from the implementation of the proposed regulation or alternatives to the proposed regulation within the context of other take already authorized or otherwise occurring.     This assessment also summarizes the biological foundation for defining take thresholds for bald eagles and golden eagles. Under the preferred alternative, the Service will define thresholds for take by adapting a published model used in other recent raptor regulations. The thresholds will guide annual take limits on a regional basis to ensure that we are consistent with the goal of stable or increasing breeding populations.       The majority of authorized take will be non-lethal and will simply allow activities to disturb eagles in a way that will result in a loss or reduction of one year\u2019s productivity by a nesting pair.     On-the-ground information and conditions will guide the actual amount of take authorized, which may be less than modeled, as long as the total does not exceed the modeled thresholds.     Except for safety emergencies, the rule will give priority in permitting to Native American use for rites and ceremonies that require eagles be taken from the wild if requests for permits will likely approach the annual threshold. The next permit priorities will be for activities necessary to ensure public health and safety, renewal of programmatic nest-take permits, and Non-emergency activities necessary to ensure public health and safety, and (for inactive golden eagle nests only) resource development or recovery operations (\u00a7 22.25).     The Service\u2019s preferred alternative, number 3, will: (1) authorize disturbance take of eagles; (2) authorize removal of eagle nests where necessary to protect public health and safety; and (3) provide for permits for take resulting in mortality in some limited circumstances. It will authorize take permits for both bald eagles and golden eagles.     Alternative 3 is also the environmentally-preferred alternative. It is expected to have the least adverse impact on the human environment, with negligible effects on the natural and physical environment and the least adverse impact along with the most beneficial impacts to the socioeconomic environment.     The criteria for issuance of permits would initially limit their issuance to only 5% of the Maximum Sustainable Yield for bald eagles, which is consistent with the recommendations in published literature for take of raptors where population monitoring may be limited or there are concerns about the vital rates for a species.     The best available data we have for golden eagles indicate modest declines in the four BCRs that constitute 80 percent of its range in the lower 48 states. Estimates of population size in Alaska are coarse, based upon even fewer data sources than in the lower 48 states, and juvenile survival may be far lower, so management would therefore need to be conservative. In addition, McIntyre et al. (2008) suggested that conservation strategies for migratory golden eagles require a continental approach. Therefore, until we have additional data to show that populations can withstand additional take, of those authorized under the new rule, we will only consider issuance of permits for safety emergencies and programmatic and other permits that will result in a net reduction in take or a net take of zero for golden eagles. We will continue to issue historically-authorized take permits under existing permit types at the level of take carried out under those permits (average over 2000-2007).","author":["Gould, R."],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2009-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gould_2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1469","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimation-bird-fatalities-caused-wind-turbines-turkey","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/322664943","title":"Estimation of bird fatalities caused by wind turbines in Turkey","description":"The present study aims to examine several aspects of the interaction between wind farms and birds in Turkey. Between 2010 and 2014, we conducted surveys at three wind farms in three Turkish provinces with the highest wind speed capacity. The total installed power capacity at the farms was 78 MW on 30 turbines. We assessed carcass persistence rates, bird fatality rates (FA), and bird fatalities around turbines. The carcass detection surveys yielded 27 bird fatalities, comprising 12 non-passerines and 15 passerines. There were 20,154 flights recorded within 0-500 m of all turbines. We used fatality estimation methods to derive an FA of 1.32 birds\/turbine\/year for all study areas. Moreover, the FA for small, medium, and large birds was 0.62, 0.52, and 0.16 birds\/turbine\/year, respectively. The results revealed that there was a negative relationship (rs = 0.444, p = 0.034) between the flight frequency of birds within 0-500 m of the wind turbines and bird mortality. The number of individuals, flight frequency, and abundance of species were not among the direct causes of bird fatalities within the study areas.","author":["Arikan, K.","Turan, S."],"organization":["Hacettepe University"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1470","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/improving-estimation-flight-altitude-wildlife-telemetry-studies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/1365-2664.13135","title":"Improving estimation of flight altitude in wildlife telemetry studies","description":"1. Altitude measurements from wildlife tracking devices, combined with elevation data, are commonly used to estimate the flight altitude of volant animals. However, these data often include measurement error. Understanding this error may improve estimation of flight altitude and benefit applied ecology.\n2. There are a number of different approaches that have been used to address this measurement error. These include filtering based on GPS data, filtering based on behaviour of the study species, and use of state\u2010space models to correct measurement error. The effectiveness of these approaches is highly variable.\n3. Recent studies have based inference of flight altitude on misunderstandings about avian natural history and technical or analytical tools. In this Commentary, we discuss these misunderstandings and suggest alternative strategies both to resolve some of these issues and to improve estimation of flight altitude. These strategies also can be applied to other measures derived from telemetry data.\n4. Synthesis and applications. Our Commentary is intended to clarify and improve upon some of the assumptions made when estimating flight altitude and, more broadly, when using GPS telemetry data. We also suggest best practices for identifying flight behaviour, addressing GPS error, and using flight altitudes to estimate collision risk with anthropogenic structures. Addressing the issues we describe would help improve estimates of flight altitude and advance understanding of the treatment of error in wildlife telemetry studies.","author":["Hall, J.","Duerr, A.","Katzner, T.","Braham, M.","Poessel, S."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","Bloom Research Inc","West Virginia University"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1471","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-bird-avoidance-high-contrast-lights-using-choice-test-approach-implications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/peerj.com\/articles\/5404\/","title":"Assessing bird avoidance of high-contrast lights using a choice test approach: implications for reducing human-induced avian mortality","description":"Background: Avian collisions with man-made objects and vehicles (e.g., buildings, cars, airplanes, power lines) have increased recently. Lights have been proposed to alert birds and minimize the chances of collisions, but it is challenging to choose lights that are tuned to the avian eye and can also lead to avoidance given the differences between human and avian vision. We propose a choice test to address this problem by first identifying wavelengths of light that would over-stimulate the retina using species-specific perceptual models and by then assessing the avoidance\/attraction responses of brown-headed cowbirds to these lights during daytime using a behavioral assay.   Methods: We used perceptual models to estimate wavelength-specific light emitting diode (LED) lights with high chromatic contrast. The behavioral assay consisted of an arena where the bird moved in a single direction and was forced to make a choice (right\/left) using a single-choice design (one side with the light on, the other with the light off) under diurnal light conditions.   Results: First, we identified lights with high saliency from the cowbird visual perspective: LED lights with peaks at 380 nm (ultraviolet), 470 nm (blue), 525 nm (green), 630 nm (red), and broad-spectrum (white) LED lights. Second, we found that cowbirds significantly avoided LED lights with peaks at 470 and 630 nm, but did not avoid or prefer LED lights with peaks at 380 and 525 nm or white lights.   Discussion: The two lights avoided had the highest chromatic contrast but relatively lower levels of achromatic contrast. Our approach can optimize limited resources to narrow down wavelengths of light with high visual saliency for a target species leading to avoidance. These lights can be used as candidates for visual deterrents to reduce collisions with man-made objects and vehicles.","author":["DeVault, T.","Blackwell, B.","Fern\u00e1ndez-Juricic, E.","Goller, B.","Baumhardt, P."],"organization":["Purdue University","US Department of Agriculture (USDA)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Lighting","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1472","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/density-dependence-marine-bird-populations-are-wind-farm-assessments-precautionary","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/1365-2664.12841","title":"Density dependence and marine bird populations: are wind farm assessments precautionary?","description":"1. Although density\u2010dependent regulation of population growth is thought to be relatively widespread in nature, density\u2010independent models are often used to project the population response to drivers of change. Such models are often considered to provide a maximum estimate of mortality and therefore offer a precautionary approach to impact assessment. However, this perception assumes that density dependence operates as compensatory (negative density dependence), and overlooks that other forms of density dependence, such as depensation (positive density dependence), would generate a contrasting population response.\n2. Currently, there is debate about including density\u2010dependent mechanisms in models that assess the impact of offshore wind farms on marine bird populations. Density dependence is considered poorly understood for this group of species. Consequently, it is either excluded from assessments, or incorporated in a compensatory form that has little empirical validation.\n3. We reviewed the evidence for compensatory and depensatory regulation of 31 marine bird species, and conducted a meta\u2010analysis to examine the functional shape of density\u2010dependent population growth. The evidence was also evaluated in relation to established species\u2010specific indices of wind farm vulnerability in order to assess whether compensatory mechanisms are likely to offset losses associated with collision or displacement.\n4. Compensatory regulation was reported across all of the demographic processes and focal groups considered, and was attributed to a variety of causal mechanisms. The strength of compensatory population growth appeared consistent between colonies; however, the regulation of productivity was highly context\u2010dependent with a similar number of studies reporting compensatory, depensatory and insignificant effects. Depensation was consistently attributed to increased rates of predation at lower population densities.\n5. Synthesis and applications. We conclude that among marine bird species with high vulnerability to wind farms, compensatory regulation is unlikely to offset large and sustained losses from the breeding population. In addition, depensation has the potential to accelerate population declines and generate local or regional extinctions, especially in smaller colonial species. Consequently, density\u2010independent models will not offer a consistently precautionary approach for assessing the potential impact of wind farms on marine bird populations. Instead, assessments should examine the potential population response using a range of density\u2010dependent structures.","author":["Robinson, R.","O\u0027Brien, S.","Horswill, C."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1473","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-diurnal-wind-turbine-collision-risk-grassland-birds-southern-great-plains","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fwspubs.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3996\/042015-JFWM-031","title":"Assessment of Diurnal Wind Turbine Collision Risk for Grassland Birds on the Southern Great Plains","description":"Wind energy is one of the fastest growing renewable energy sources in the United States and has the potential to reduce the use of traditional nonrenewable energy. However, there is concern for potential short-and long-term influences on wildlife populations, such as bird collisions with turbine blades, habitat loss, habitat fragmentation, and habitat avoidance. Bird flight heights are indicative of collision risks, but knowledge of their distributions is limited. Our goal was to examine the diurnal flight heights of bird species to assess which are at greatest risk of collision with wind turbine blades. During October 2008-August 2009, we estimated the flight heights of 66 bird species at a planned wind energy facility on the southern Great Plains. Flight heights were estimated by measuring angle of incline with a clinometer and ground distance with a laser rangefinder. Previous work has been limited to flight height measurements categorized to site-specific rotor swept zone (RSZ) specifications that has resulted in limited applicability to other wind turbine RSZ specifications. Our research is distinctive because it provides more resolution in flight height estimates than those categorized into bins and allows application to wind turbines with different RSZs. We found that the flight heights of six bird species varied among seasons, indicating their risk of collision changed throughout the year. Observations indicated that the average flight heights of 28 bird species were within the potential RSZ (32-124 m above ground level) at our study site and that two species exhibited mean flight heights above the RSZ. Fifteen of those species were wetland-associated species, 7 were raptor or vulture species, and 6 were listed as species of greatest conservation need by Texas Parks and Wildlife Department. We observed 14 bird species (1 vulture, 2 raptors, 7 wetland-associated species, and 4 passerines or other species) with greater than 25% of their observed flight heights within the RSZ. Our results indicate that raptors and wetland-associated species are the avian groups at greatest risk of collision with wind turbines due to their diurnal flight heights. However, the resolution of our data will allow assessment of which bird species are at greatest risk of collision for various wind turbine specifications. This information can help guide site assessment and placement for wind energy facilities across the southern Great Plains and help mitigate potential collision impacts on bird species.","author":["Butler, M.","Ballard, W.","Wulff, S."],"organization":["Texas Tech University","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2016-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.184160000000","-100.800000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1474","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-bird-collisions-wind-turbines-comparison-new-empirical-flux-collision-model","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0304380018302308","title":"Predicting bird collisions with wind turbines: Comparison of the new empirical Flux Collision Model with the SOSS Band model","description":"Collision of birds with wind turbines is an important negative effect of wind energy generation. Assessments of the potential numbers of bird collisions are required prior to the construction of wind farms. Collision rate models (CRMs) are used as a tool to estimate numbers of collision victims for wind farm initiatives.\u00a0\n\n\nIn the past couple of decades various CRMs have been developed. These models are all based on the theoretical calculation of collision probabilities (theoretical models).\u00a0\n\n\nIn this paper we introduce an empirical model, the Flux Collision Model (FCM), in which actual knowledge of species (group)-specific collision probabilities collected in existing wind farms on land is used to calculate collision rates for planned wind farms.\u00a0\nAn important quality of the FCM is that it provides a means to use empirical information to assess collision rates in Environmental Impact Assessments (ETAS) for wind farm initiatives. In addition, no detailed information on bird behaviour close to the rotor is needed, as this information is already incorporated in the empirical collision probability.\u00a0\n\n\nIn two case studies, one offshore and one on land, we compare and discuss the use and performance of the empirical FCM and the theoretical SOSS Band model for predicting collision rates of birds at wind farm initiatives. To date, no actual collision rates are known for the offshore situation. Accordingly, in the FCM, collision probabilities derived from wind farms on land were used. Nevertheless, in the offshore case study, the results of the FCM were comparable with those of the SOSS Band model.\u00a0\n\n\nBasic sensitivity analyses for both the FCM and the SOSS Band model showed that purely theoretically both models are equally sensitive to changes in avoidance rates. However, because lower values for avoidance are applied in the FCM (wind farm avoidance) than in the SOSS Band model (overall avoidance), in practice the effect of realistic variation in avoidance rates on the resulting collision rates is much smaller for the FCM than for the SOSS Band model.\u00a0\n\n\nOur results show that the FCM provides a valuable addition to the existing suite of (theoretical) CRMs. The predictive value of the theoretical SOSS Band model is constrained by the limited availability of knowledge on species (group)-specific (wind turbine) avoidance rates, which is not the case for the FCM. By contrast, the reliability of the empirical FCM is determined only by variation in the availability and quality of information on species (group)-specific collision probabilities.\u00a0\n\n\nThe choice of which CRM to use (theoretical or empirical) seems not to depend on the location of the wind farm initiative as being offshore or on land, but on the availability and reliability of species (group)-specific information in existing wind farms. The availability of a reliable collision probability supports the use of the FCM, while the availability of information on (overall) avoidance rates in the absence of a species (group) specific collision probability supports the use of a theoretical CRM like the SOSS Band model.\u00a0\n\n\nSynthesis and applications. The predictive power of collision rate models relies in the first place on the quality of the input information, and second on the theoretical details of the model calculations. Although the FCM is less dependent on measurements of avoidance rates, an urgent need remains to obtain information on actual collision rates and corresponding collision probabilities as well as avoidance rates in existing wind farms both offshore and on land in order to accurately determine the impact of wind energy on bird populations.","author":["Poot, M.","Collier, M.","Dirksen, S.","Krijgsveld, K.","Boon, A.","Kleyheeg-Hartman, J.","Troost, A."],"organization":["Bureau Waardenburg bv","Deltares (NL)"],"originationDate":"2018-11-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1475","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/disturbance-affects-biotic-community-composition-desert-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1071\/WR17059","title":"Disturbance affects biotic community composition at desert wind farms","description":"Context.\u00a0The global benefits of increased renewable energy production may come at a cost to local biotic communities and even regional ecosystems. Wind energy developments, in particular, are known to cause bird and bat mortalities, and to fragment habitat for terrestrial vertebrates within developed project areas. Effects on species sensitive to wind turbines (and increased prevalence of species tolerant to this disturbance) might alter community-level patterns of occurrence, with potentially detrimental changes to wildlife habitat and ecosystem health.\n\nAims.\u00a0The present study assessed whether wind energy developments produced downstream ecological costs. Specifically, community composition and diversity were compared between wind farms and nearby areas without energy development.\n\nMethods.\u00a0Traditional diversity measures and non-metric multidimensional scaling (NMDS) were used to map ecological dissimilarity across four wind farms and five reference (control) areas in Southern California, USA.\n\nKey results.\u00a0Wind farms had more noise and road disturbance than sites without turbine installations. Noise and disturbance were correlated with reduced plant richness, particularly for endemic plant species and, conversely, with increased non-native plant richness. Animal communities at wind farms were less diverse, with fewer species and lower evenness relative to reference areas with minor or no disturbances. Wind farms had fewer rare and unique species and, for some species of avian predators, encounter rates were lower at wind farms.\n\nConclusions.\u00a0Renewable wind energy may indeed cause shifts in local communities. Although wind farms still supported many of the same species found in natural areas, suggesting that renewable wind energy facilities can provide useable habitat for some wildlife, these communities were also less rich and diverse.\n\nImplications.\u00a0Non-native species were more prevalent at wind farms, which may then facilitate further invasions into surrounding habitats. In addition, reduced overall plant and predator diversity at wind farms, and lower encounter rates for specific taxa (particular birds), may significantly affect community structure and function.","author":["Feldman, C.","Keehne, J."],"organization":["University of Nevada"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1476","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evidence-migratory-bat-pipistrellus-nathusii-aggregating-coastlines-northern-baltic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/content\/miiz\/actac\/2017\/00000019\/00000001\/art00010","title":"Evidence of the migratory bat, Pipistrellus nathusii, aggregating to the coastlines in the Northern Baltic Sea","description":"Similar to birds, bats also perform long-distance migration between their breeding and wintering sites. In Northern Europe, migratory bat species are often detected along the coastline of the Baltic Sea particularly during migration seasons in the spring and autumn. In spite of regular monitoring of bat migration at coastal sites, the overall distribution of migratory bats in Northern Europe and variability between sites and seasons are still very poorly known. In this study we used automated bat detectors to compare the activity of migratory bat species between coastal and inland monitoring sites along the west coast of Finland (61.5-61.9 degrees N, 21.3-22.3 degrees E). Our main goal was to test whether the activity of migratory bat species is associated with the coastline or whether these species also occur inland. Of migratory bat species observations, 98.6% were covered by Pipistrellus nathusii, which was detected at all our monitoring sites. The activity of the species decreased rapidly, with increasing distance from the coastline towards inland, indicating a sharp activity gradient along the coastline of the Baltic Sea. Because the activity of P. nathusii occurred in migration season and no similar spatial pattern was detected among sedentary species, our results suggest that the aggregation of P. nathusii at the coastline is related to migration as such rather than regular foraging behavior of this species. Our study has direct implications to the wind power planning in Northern Europe. Based on our study we conclude that the impact of wind power on both migratory (namely P. nathusii) and sedentary bat species (namely Eptesicus nilssonii) should be taken into account in wind power planning and impact mitigation in Northern Europe, especially if new wind farms are located along the coastline of the Baltic Sea. When the turbines are located further inland, more attention in the planning process should however be given to the sedentary bat E. nilssonii.","author":["Ijas, A.","Kahlilainen, A.","Vasko, V.","Lilley, T."],"organization":["University of Turku","University of Helsinki"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["61.700000000000","21.800000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1477","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/species-composition-mortality-bats-osorio-wind-farm-southern-brazil","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/01650521.2014.1001595","title":"Species composition and mortality of bats at the Osorio Wind Farm, southern Brazil","description":"We present the results of a three-year study on the bat species killed by wind turbines at the Osorio Wind Farm, a large wind power complex in southern Brazil, and compare these fatalities to the composition of the local bat fauna. Fatality searches around wind turbines were conducted from 2006 to 2009, as well as a bat inventory through mist-netting and searches for colonies from 2004 to 2010. We found a total of 336 bat fatalities: Tadarida brasiliensis (n = 245), Lasiurus cinereus (n = 44), Nyctinomops laticaudatus (n = 12), Molossus molossus (n = 9), Lasiurus blossevillii (n = 6), Promops nasutus (n = 3), Lasiurus ega (n = 3), Molossus rufus (n = 1), and Artibeus lituratus (n = 1). By mist-netting, we recorded 13 bat species in the region, of which only six were killed by wind turbines. Our results are similar to mortality patterns from the Northern Hemisphere in terms of: (1) uneven distribution of fatalities among species; (2) dominance of migratory species, including foliage\/tree-roosting bats; and (3) discrepancy between presence and abundance of species recorded in the wind farm area and in the fatality sample.","author":["Barros, M.","Rui, A.","de Magalhaes, R."],"organization":["Universidade Federal de Pelotas (UFP)"],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-29.924347000000","-50.303797000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1478","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pre-construction-breeding-bird-surveys-number-three-wind-energy-project-lewis-county","sourceURL":"https:\/\/number3wind.invenergyllc.com\/assets\/pdfs\/ntw_22h-4b_breeding_bird_survey_2016.pdf","title":"Pre-Construction Breeding Bird Surveys Number Three Wind Energy Project Lewis County, New York","description":"Number Three Wind Energy, LLC (Number Three) is developing the Number Three Wind Energy Project (Project) in Lewis County, New York (Figure 1). To assist in the development of the Project, Number Three contracted Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) to conduct pre-construction breeding bird surveys. This study was designed and conducted to meet objectives and recommendations of the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC) 2016 Guidelines for Conducting Bird and Bat Studies at Commercial Wind Energy Projects (NYSDEC 2016a) and the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) Land-Based Wind Energy Guidelines (USFWS 2012). This final report contains results of pre-construction breeding bird use surveys conducted from June 4 \u2013 July 12, 2016.","author":["Bay, K.","Fritchman, C.","Ritzert, J.","DiDonato, G."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2017-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.846714000000","-75.664666000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/bayetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1479","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reproductive-output-hen-harriers-circus-cyaneus-relation-wind-turbine-proximity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pdfs.semanticscholar.org\/9ef3\/446d20b038f38fa34e0ef253399ee708f156.pdf","title":"Reproductive output of Hen Harriers Circus cyaneus in relation to wind turbine proximity","description":"Despite the growing importance of wind energy developments in Ireland, and concerns about its potential ecological impact on birds, there is a notable lack of published scientific information in this area. As a bird of conservation concern, the Hen Harrier Circus cyaneus inhabits upland areas with potential for wind energy resources. This study assessed the breeding performance of Hen Harriers across Ireland in relation to wind farm development by analysing the breeding output from 84 nests located at varying distances from wind farms. Three measures of breeding performance were investigated: (a) nest success (the proportion of nests that fledged one or more young), (b) fledged brood size (the average number of fledged chicks per successful nest), and (c) overall productivity of breeding pairs (the average number of fledged chicks across all nesting attempts). No statistically significant relationships were found between these breeding parameters and distance of the nest from the nearest wind turbine. However, lower nest success within 1 km of wind turbines than at greater distances were sufficiently close to statistical significance, and with a sufficiently small sample size, that this difference may be of biological relevance. Nests within 1 km of wind turbines which were successful had similar fledged brood sizes to those of nests at greater distances from turbines. These findings support previous research which highlighted the importance of areas within a 1 km radius of raptor nests. Our results provide the first insight into the potential effects of wind turbines for breeding success of Hen Harriers, which should be taken into consideration in assessments of wind farm impacts on this vulnerable species. Further work is required to quantify (a) direct Hen Harrier mortality through collisions, (b) habitat loss and displacement caused by wind turbines and (c) to continue ongoing monitoring of breeding success in order to confirm whether the effect of wind farm proximity suggested here is consistent. This work will support the development of an integrated management strategy for Hen Harriers in Ireland.","author":["Wilson, M.","Irwin, S.","O\u0027Halloran, J.","Fernandez-Bellon, D."],"organization":["University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1480","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farm-le-peuchapatte-analysis-bat-recordings-evaluation-mitigation-measures","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aramis.admin.ch\/default.aspx?documentID=46471\u0026load=true","title":"Wind Farm Le Peuchapatte: Analysis of Bat Recordings and Evaluation of Mitigation Measures","description":"English  It is well known that wind turbines (WTs) can have an impact on flying animals, bats in particular. Studies in Europe have shown that many bat species can be affected. This is evidenced by between 0 and 41 dead bats reported per wind turbine per year (Brinkmann et al. 2006, Rydell et al. 2010). However, the extent of bat mortality in Switzerland is largely unknown. So far, only a limited number of studies have been carried out in Entlebuch LU and Mont - Crosin BE in 2007 (Leuzinger et al. 2008).  The aim of this study is to improve knowledge about possible conflicts between bats and wind turbines in Switzerland. The study was carried out on behalf of the FOEN and the SFOE. For the first time, bat activity was recorded at the nacelle of the wind turbines and, at the same time, a search for dead bats was carried out on the ground.  A large number of the wind turbines in Switzerland are located in the Jura mountains. In 2015 a detailed study was carried out there on three wind turbines at the Le Peuchapatte JU wind farm. The study consists of two parts:  a) Search for bats having died from collisions (NATURA S\u00e0rl, Swiss Ornithological Institute)  b) Bat activity monitoring at nacelle height and on the ground (SWILD, KohleNus-baumer SA)     The results of these investigations were analysed in two reports and then compared:  I. Estimation de la mortalit\u00e9 caus\u00e9e parles \u00e9oliennes sur les chiropt\u00e8res \u2013 Parc\u00e9olien du Peuchapatte (NATURA 2018). [Estimated bat mortality due to wind turbines \u2013 Le Peuchapatte wind farm (NATURA 2018)].  II. Windpark Le Peuchapatte, JU: Fledermaus Abkl\u00e4rungen 2015: Analysen der Fledermausmessungen und Bewertung der Massnahmen (SWILD 2018). [Bat monitoring for 2015: Analysis of bat data and evaluation of measures \u2013 Le Peuchapatte wind farm (SWILD 2018)]  III. Comparison: prediction of bat mortality due to carcass searches vs. bat activity.     The two reports and the comparison are summarised in the report and general conclusions are drawn.  Francais  Il est reconnu que les \u00e9oliennes peuvent avoir un impact sur la faune ail\u00e9e et en particulier sur les chauves-souris. Des recherches en Europe montrent que beaucoup d\u2019esp\u00e8ces de chauves-souris peuvent \u00eatre touch\u00e9es. En Europe, un taux de mortalit\u00e9 annuel compris entre 0 et 41 chauves-souris par \u00e9olienne a \u00e9t\u00e9 constat\u00e9 (Brinkmann et al. 2006, Rydell et al. 2010).  L\u2019importance r\u00e9elle de cette mortalit\u00e9 en Suisse demeure cependant largement inconnue, une seule \u00e9tude limit\u00e9e ayant jusqu\u2019\u00e0 pr\u00e9sent \u00e9t\u00e9 r\u00e9alis\u00e9e dans ce pays en 2007 dans l\u2019Entlebuch LU et Mont-Crosin BE (Leuzinger et al. 2008). Le but de la pr\u00e9sente \u00e9tude, mandat\u00e9e par l\u2019OFEV et l\u2019OFEN, est d\u2019am\u00e9liorer les connaissances pour la Suisse en effectuant en parall\u00e8le une mesure de l\u2019activit\u00e9 des chauves-souris depuis les nacelles et une recherche des cadavres au sol.  Une grande partie des \u00e9oliennes existantes en Suisse se trouve sur les cr\u00eates jurassiennes. Aussi, une \u00e9tude d\u00e9taill\u00e9e a-t-elle \u00e9t\u00e9 men\u00e9e en 2015 sur les 3 \u00e9oliennes du parc \u00e9olien du Peuchapatte JU. Cette \u00e9tude se compose dedeux parties:  a) Recherche de cadavres de chauves-souris au sol (NATURA S\u00e0rl, Schweizerische Vogelwarte)  b) Monitoring de l\u2019activit\u00e9 des chauves-souris \u00e0 hauteur de nacelle et \u00e0 partir du sol (SWILD, KohleNusbaumer SA)  Les r\u00e9sultats de ces deux \u00e9tudes ont \u00e9t\u00e9 analys\u00e9s dans deux rapports distincts et une comparaison:  I. Estimation de la mortalit\u00e9 caus\u00e9e par les \u00e9oliennes sur les chiropt\u00e8res \u2013 Parc\u00e9olien du Peuchapatte (NATURA 2018)  II. Windpark Le Peuchapatte, JU: Fledermaus Abkl\u00e4rungen 2015: Analysen der Fledermausmessungen und Bewertung der Massnahmen (SWILD 2018). [Parc\u00e9olien du Peuchapatte, JU: \u00e9valuation sur les chauves-souris 2015. Analyse des donn\u00e9es r\u00e9colt\u00e9es sur les chauves-souris et \u00e9valuation des mesures. (SWILD 2018)]  III. Comparaison: pronostic de la mortalit\u00e9 \u00e9tablie par la recherche des cadavres par rapport \u00e0 l\u2019activit\u00e9 des chauves-souris  Ces deux rapports, ainsi que la comparaison, sont r\u00e9sum\u00e9s dans le rapport, et une synth\u00e8se est finalement donn\u00e9e en conclusion.  Deutsch  Es ist bekannt, dass Windenergiean lagen (WEA) Auswirkungen auf fliegende Tiere und insbesondere auf Flederm\u00e4use haben k\u00f6nnen. Untersuchungen in Europa haben gezeigt, dass viele Fledermausarten betroffen sein k\u00f6nnen. Dies wird durch die ermittelte j\u00e4hrliche Mortalit\u00e4t zwischen 0 und 41 Flederm\u00e4usen pro Windenergieanlage deutlich (Brinkmann et al. 2006, Rydell et al. 2010). In der Schweiz ist das Ausmass der Fleder-maus-Mortalit\u00e4t jedoch weitgehend unbekannt. Bisher wurde lediglich eine bedingt aussagekr\u00e4ftige Studie im Jahr 2007 im Entlebuch LU und in Mont-Crosin BE durchgef\u00fchrt (Leuzinger et al. 2008).  Ziel der vorliegenden Studie war, das Wissen \u00fcber m\u00f6gliche Konflikte zwischen Flederm\u00e4usen und Windenergieanlagen in der Schweiz zu verbessern. Die Studie wurde im Auftrag des BAFU und des BFE durchgef\u00fchrt. Erstmals wurde die Aktivit\u00e4t der Flederm\u00e4use bei der Gondel von Windr\u00e4dern aufgenommen und gleichzeitig eine Totfundsuche am Boden durchgef\u00fchrt.  Ein grosser Anteil der Windenergieanlagen in der Schweiz befindet sich auf den Jurah\u00f6hen. Dort wurde im Jahr 2015 bei drei Windenergie-anlagen des Windparks Le Peuchapatte JU eine detaillierte Studie durchgef\u00fchrt. Diese Studie besteht aus zwei Teilen:  a) Schlagopfersuche (NATURA S\u00e0rl, Schweizerische Vogelwarte)  b) Fledermausmonitoring: in der Gondel und am Boden (SWILD, KohleNusbaumer SA)     Die Resultate dieser Untersuchungen wurden in zwei Berichten analysiert und anschliessend einem Vergleich unterzogen:  I. Estimation de la mortalit\u00e9 caus\u00e9e par les \u00e9oliennes sur les chiropt\u00e8res \u2013 Parc\u00e9olien du Peuchapatte (NATURA 2018). [Sch\u00e4tzung der Mortalit\u00e4t von Flederm\u00e4usen durch Windenergieanlagen \u2013 Windpark Le Peuchapatte (NATURA 2018)]  II. Windpark Le Peuchapatte, JU: Fledermaus Abkl\u00e4rungen 2015: Analysen der Fledermausmessungen und Bewertung der Massnahmen (SWILD 2018)  III. Vergleich: Prognose Mortalit\u00e4t aufgrund Schlagopfersuche vs. Fledermausaktivit\u00e4t  Im Bericht werden die beiden Berichte und der Vergleich zusammengefasst und generelle Schlussfolgerung gezogen","author":["Bontadina, F.","Dietrich, A.","Aschwanden, J.","Brossard, C.","Deplazes, L.","M\u00e4rki, K.","Lauper, M."],"organization":["NATURA Biologie Appliqu\u00e9e S\u00e0rl","Stadt\u00f6kologie, Wildtierforschung, Kommunikation (SWILD)","Swiss Federal Office for the Environment (FOEN)","Swiss Federal Office of Energy (SFOE)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.197712800000","6.949885300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Brossardetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1481","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/shorebird-staging-migratory-movements-chaplin-reed-lakes-saskatchewan-implications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/harvest.usask.ca\/handle\/10388\/8570","title":"Shorebird Staging and Migratory Movements at Chaplin and Reed Lakes, Saskatchewan, with Implications for Wind Energy Development","description":"Increasing knowledge of long distance shorebird (order Charadriiformes) migrations may elucidate causes of shorebird declines and direct management within migratory routes. Migrating birds rely on staging sites, areas with reliably high food abundance, for rest and refueling. Stressors at these sites could have population level impacts and post-migration carry-over effects. My thesis research examined staging bird abundance and migratory movements to and from Chaplin and Reed Lakes, Saskatchewan, a major staging site of hemispheric importance in the Central Flyway used by over 100,000 shorebirds each year. My objectives were to 1) examine time of peak abundance by multiple migratory shorebird species using Chaplin and Reed Lakes during spring and fall migration, as well as estimate spring stopover duration and population size of Sanderling (Calidris alba) and 2) investigate movement patterns of migratory shorebirds as they arrive at and depart from Chaplin and Reed Lakes, and determine the extrinsic factors influencing observed flight patterns to inform risk from current and future wind energy developments. I used a combination of point count surveys and radio telemetry data to meet my objectives. Staging, arctic-breeding species at Chaplin and Reed Lakes were counted weekly during spring northward (2014 \u2013 2017) and fall southward (2016 \u2013 2017) migration by conducting point count surveys to examine temporal patterns and estimate population size. Detailed assessments of my focal species, Sanderling included capture, banding and radio-tagging in the Gulf of Mexico and at Chaplin Lake (2015-2017) to track their migratory movements and stopover duration in relation to weather and time of day variables using automated radio telemetry. Spring migration involved larger numbers of species (including species at risk), larger numbers of individuals, and more concentrated timing among years than fall migration. Sanderlings staged for a mean of 11.1 (95% CI = 8.59 \u201313.6) days and population size averaged ~75,000 birds, with estimates ranging from ~56,000 to ~91,000 among years. Population estimates were seven to 17 times larger than raw peak abundance counts, demonstrating the need to account for stopover duration in population estimates. Chaplin and Reed Lakes departures, but not arrivals, were significantly influenced by time and weather. Sanderlings were more likely to depart at sunset or sunrise when winds were blowing towards the northwest at intermediate speeds and less likely to depart when winds were blowing towards the southeast at high speeds. Knowledge of when large numbers of birds are using the area and what environmental conditions are associated with migratory movements can be used to identify where and when birds are at the greatest risks of collision with wind energy turbines. My results have implications for shorebird conservation at Chaplin and Reed Lakes and other staging sites in the Central flyway, and my thesis provides recommendations for management and mitigation of threats from current and future wind energy developments.","author":["Howell, J."],"organization":["University of Saskatchewan"],"originationDate":"2018-05-04","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Shorebirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1482","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/welcoming-wind-determinants-wind-power-development-among-us-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/full\/10.1080\/00330120802580271?scroll=top\u0026needAccess=true","title":"Welcoming the Wind? Determinants of Wind Power Development Among U.S. States","description":"Although currently supplying less than 1 percent of consumption, wind is the fastest growing source of electricity in the United States. This article analyzes the emerging geography of wind energy on a state-by-state basis. Rather than physical wind energy potential, the primary determinants of wind energy development among U.S. states are human geographic factors of population distribution, and resulting geography of electricity demand and transmission line accessibility, together with state-based energy policies, including electric utility restructuring, renewable portfolio standards, and procedures for siting and permitting wind farms. Although simplified state-level siting and permitting procedures that minimize opportunities for local opposition show a statistical advantage in wind energy development, examination of U.S. examples of local opposition to wind farms and the European experience in wind energy development show that community acceptability of wind farms depends on procedural legitimacy in siting decisions and a perceived aesthetic fit between wind farms and the local landscape.","author":["Bohn, C.","Lant, C."],"organization":["Southern Illinois University (SIU)"],"originationDate":"2009-01-14","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1483","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reproductive-success-horned-lark-mccowns-longspur-relation-wind-energy-infrastructure","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1650\/CONDOR-15-25.1","title":"Reproductive success of Horned Lark and McCown\u0027s Longspur in relation to wind energy infrastructure","description":"Wind energy is a rapidly expanding industry with potential indirect effects to wildlife populations that are largely unexplored. In 2011 and 2012, we monitored 211 nests of 2 grassland songbirds, Horned Lark (Eremophila alpestris) and McCown\u0027s Longspur (Rhynchophanes mccownii), at 3 wind farms and 2 undeveloped reference sites in Wyoming, USA. We evaluated several indices of reproductive investment and success: clutch size, size-adjusted nestling mass, daily nest survival rate, and number of fledglings. We compared reproductive success between wind farms and undeveloped sites and modeled reproductive success within wind farms as a function of wind energy infrastructure and habitat. Size-adjusted nestling mass of Horned Lark was weakly negatively related to turbine density. In 2011, nest survival of Horned Lark decreased 55% as turbine density increased from 10 to 39 within 2 km of the nest. In 2012, however, nest survival of Horned Lark was best predicted by the combination of vegetation height, distance to shrub edge, and turbine density, with survival increasing weakly with increasing vegetation height. McCown\u0027s Longspur nest survival was weakly positively related to vegetation density at the nest site when considered with the amount of grassland habitat in the neighborhood and turbine density within 1 km of the nest. Habitat and distance to infrastructure did not explain clutch size or number of fledglings for either species, or size-adjusted nestling mass for McCown\u0027s Longspur. Our results suggest that the influence of wind energy infrastructure varies temporally and by species, even among species using similar habitats. Turbine density was repeatedly the most informative measure of wind energy development. Turbine density could influence wildlife responses to wind energy production and may become increasingly important to consider as development continues in areas with high-quality wind resources.","author":["Mahoney, A.","Chalfoun, A."],"organization":["University of Wyoming"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Passerines","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1484","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/addressing-factors-juxtapose-raptors-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3356\/rapt-50-01-92-96.1","title":"Addressing the factors that juxtapose raptors and wind turbines","description":"Humans unintentionally expose raptors to a variety of lethal collision hazards, most notably road vehicles (Massemin and Zorn 1998), wires (Jenkins et al. 2010), and wind turbines (Loss et al. 2013). Other human-related sources of frequent raptor mortality are electrocutions on distribution lines (Lehman et al. 2007), ingestion of pesticides and other synthetics (Goldstein et al. 1999), and lead poisoning from bullet fragments and shotgun pellets in the remains of gun-killed animals (Pain et al. 2009). These last three factors involve the attraction of raptors to potentially lethal situations, and all can be remedied at their source: the first by deploying safer poles (Lehman et al. 2007), the second by substitution with safer chemicals (Oaks et al. 2004), and the third by the use of non-lead projectiles (Watson et al. 2009).\n\nWhere a lethal agent cannot be rendered harmless, however, reducing its effect on raptors must necessarily focus upon the conditions that attract raptors to its vicinity. The increasing occurrence of bladed wind-turbines in the landscape presents just such a problem in that neither their lethality nor their overall contribution to raptor mortality appear to be diminishing (Zimmerling et al. 2013, Pagel et al. 2013). Even so, large-scale wind-energy development has the potential of incrementally reducing world dependence on fossil fuels as agents of climate disruption, an adversity with profound implications for the future of raptor populations worldwide. A logical step in conservation, therefore, is to consider the factors that juxtapose raptors and wind turbines (see Marques et al. 2014). We will argue that the extensive development of wind farms should be much more closely scrutinized with respect to their placement within habitats attractive to raptors (see Marques et al. 2014). Where this consideration has been overlooked and raptor mortality is excessive, remedies may require nontraditional methods.","author":["Watson, J.","Hunt,G."],"organization":["The Peregrine Fund","Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW)"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1485","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/consultation-collaboration-participatory-framework-positive-community-engagement-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629617300488","title":"From consultation to collaboration: A participatory framework for positive community engagement with wind energy projects in Ontario, Canada","description":"The\u00a0social conflict\u00a0over the development of wind facilities is evidence of a new type of environmental controversy. One side of the argument is composed of wind proponents who advocate the environmental benefits of\u00a0wind energy\u00a0to tackle\u00a0climate change\u00a0and secure\u00a0energy sources. On the other side of the argument are the opponents who are concerned with\u00a0potential health\u00a0and ecological impacts. Although wind has become a contributor to the energy mix in Ontario, Canada there remains a significant and organized\u00a0resistance\u00a0to wind power development in the province. This paper serves to identify the factors that can lead to social acceptance of wind\u00a0project development, and applies a\u00a0conceptual framework\u00a0for encouraging more effective\u00a0public participation. Employing the\u00a0case study\u00a0methodology,\u00a0representatives\u00a0of key stakeholder groups in five Ontario wind projects were interviewed. The results of this study indicate that community engagement in Ontario wind project approvals remains limited and explains, to some degree, the ongoing resistance to these projects. Stakeholders were however, broadly supportive of the authors proposed conceptual participatory framework, which encourages a collaborative approach in the approval process. Also, all stakeholder groups welcomed the notion of a knowledge-broker to assist in the\u00a0decision-making\u00a0process.","author":["Jami, A.","Walsh, P."],"organization":["Ryerson University"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1486","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-interaction-analysis-offshore-wind-energy-areas-breeding-avian-species-us","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.odu.edu\/cgi\/viewcontent.cgi?article=1030\u0026context=biology_etds","title":"Potential Interaction Analysis of Offshore Wind Energy Areas and Breeding Avian Species on the US Mid-Atlantic Coast","description":"Due to increasing US interest in developing wind energy sites in offshore waters, we synthesized existing data on colonial breeding seabird populations with the potential risk of interacting with lease areas in the mid-Atlantic. Previous efforts by BOEM and NOAA have predicted avian density using at-sea survey data; we seek to complement this work by focusing specifically on birds during the critical and energetically demanding breeding life history stage. We combined colony size and location for each species along the mid-Atlantic coast with buffers around the colonies that correlate with the species\u2019 foraging range. We integrated population size, vulnerability to offshore wind, and foraging areas to create a multi-species vulnerability model and overlaid this model onto current BOEM lease areas. Our model determined areas of high-predicted vulnerability in the northern and southern ends of the Eastern Shore of Virginia, southern to mid-areas of the New Jersey coastline, and western Long Island of New York. Out of the total study area, 31.73% of the high-predicted vulnerable areas overlapped with currently leased areas for offshore wind energy development. We also compared our model to NOAA\u2019s predicted density models and found they could be used together to identify areas with both high predicted density and high vulnerability as they overlapped 38.54% in our study area. The differences between these two models also suggest that simply relying on predicted density as a metric for determining impacts may miss areas that are critical for breeding birds. We also collected GPS location data on common terns (Sterna hirundo) at Dawson Shoals, Virginia during their 2017 nesting season. We analyzed their movement and behavior in relation to offshore wind sites. We determined that common terns most often utilized an area roughly half the size of the suggested foraging range found in the literature, and that some traditional risk-models may be overestimating the potential impacts of offshore wind development on seabirds. Tracking data should be integrated into methods used to minimize seabird impacts while developing an offshore wind energy industry in the mid-Atlantic.","author":["Wisman, J.","Maxwell, S."],"organization":["Old Dominion University"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1487","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-nest-success-post-fledging-survival-buteo-hawks","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21125","title":"Wind energy, nest success, and post-fledging survival of Buteo hawks","description":"Quantifying the rate of turbine collision mortality for raptors has been the primary focus of research at wind energy projects in Europe and the United States. Breeding adults and fledglings may be especially prone to collisions, but few studies have assessed the consequences of increased mortality and indirect effects from this type of development activity on reproduction. We examined the influence of wind turbines and other factors on nest success and survival of radio-marked juveniles during the post-fledging period for 3 sympatric breeding Buteo species in the Columbia Plateau Ecoregion (CPE), Oregon, USA. Nest success for ferruginous hawks (Buteo regalis) decreased as the number of wind turbines within the home range buffer (32km(2)) increased. There was no effect of turbines on nest success for red-tailed hawks (Buteo jamaicensis) or Swainson\u0027s hawks (Buteo swainsoni). Of 60 nestlings radio-marked from all 3 species, we found no evidence that any were killed as a result of collisions with wind turbines after fledging. This was likely due, in part, to the limited size of the natal home range and the relatively short duration of the post-fledging period. However, juveniles of all 3 species hatched from nests in areas of greater turbine density were more likely to die from predation or starvation just after fledging and prior to becoming independent compared to those in areas of lower turbine density. Taken together, these results suggest that wind turbines affected reproductive efforts by all 3 species to some degree, but these effects were greater for ferruginous hawks compared to the other 2 congeneric species. The causes of this negative association are unknown but likely represent some combination of breeding adults being killed from turbine collisions, disturbed from activities associated with the increasing wind energy development in the area, or displaced from portions of their home range to minimize the risk of disturbance or death. The potential for these effects necessitate that planning of future wind energy facilities be considered at larger geographic scales beyond the placement of individual turbines to limit development near raptor breeding areas.","author":["Bechard, M.","Kolar, P."],"organization":["Boise State University"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.689294000000","-120.170964000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1488","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/patterns-migrating-soaring-migrants-indicate-attraction-marine-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/royalsocietypublishing.org\/doi\/full\/10.1098\/rsbl.2016.0804","title":"Patterns of migrating soaring migrants indicate attraction to marine wind farms","description":"Monitoring of bird migration at marine wind farms has a short history, and unsurprisingly most studies have focused on the potential for collisions. Risk for population impacts may exist to soaring migrants such as raptors with K-strategic life-history characteristics. Soaring migrants display strong dependence on thermals and updrafts and an affinity to land areas and islands during their migration, a behaviour that creates corridors where raptors move across narrow straits and sounds and are attracted to islands. Several migration corridors for soaring birds overlap with the development regions for marine wind farms in NW Europe. However, no empirical data have yet been available on avoidance or attraction rates and behavioural reactions of soaring migrants to marine wind farms. Based on a post-construction monitoring study, we show that all raptor species displayed a significant attraction behaviour towards a wind farm. The modified migratory behaviour was also significantly different from the behaviour at nearby reference sites. The attraction was inversely related to distance to the wind farm and was primarily recorded during periods of adverse wind conditions. The attraction behaviour suggests that migrating raptor species are far more at risk of colliding with wind turbines at sea than hitherto assessed.","author":["Desholm, M.","Kahlert, J.","Skov, H.","Hein\u00e4nen, S.","Zydelis, R.","Jensen, N.","Jensen, B.","Laubek, B."],"organization":["Danish Hydraulic Institute (DHI)","Aarhus University","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.666700000000","11.666700000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1489","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/balanced-solution-cumulative-threat-industrialized-wind-farm-development-cinereous","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0172685","title":"A balanced solution to the cumulative threat of industrialized wind farm development on cinereous vultures (Aegypius monachus) in south-eastern Europe","description":"Wind farm development can combat climate change but may also threaten bird populations\u0027 persistence through collision with wind turbine blades if such development is improperly planned strategically and cumulatively. Such improper planning may often occur. Numerous wind farms are planned in a region hosting the only cinereous vulture population in southeastern Europe. We combined range use modelling and a Collision Risk Model (CRM) to predict the cumulative collision mortality for cinereous vulture under all operating and proposed wind farms. Four different vulture avoidance rates were considered in the CRM. Cumulative collision mortality was expected to be eight to ten times greater in the future (proposed and operating wind farms) than currently (operating wind farms), equivalent to 44% of the current population (103 individuals) if all proposals are authorized (2744 MW). Even under the most optimistic scenario whereby authorized proposals will not collectively exceed the national target for wind harnessing in the study area (960 MW), cumulative collision mortality would still be high (17% of current population) and likely lead to population extinction. Under any wind farm proposal scenario, over 92% of expected deaths would occur in the core area of the population, further implying inadequate spatial planning and implementation of relevant European legislation with scant regard for governmental obligations to protect key species. On the basis of a sensitivity map we derive a spatially explicit solution that could meet the national target of wind harnessing with a minimum conservation cost of less than 1% population loss providing that the population mortality (5.2%) caused by the operating wind farms in the core area would be totally mitigated. Under other scenarios, the vulture population would probably be at serious risk of extinction. Our \u0027win-win\u0027 approach is appropriate to other potential conflicts where wind farms may cumulatively threaten wildlife populations.","author":["Whitfield, D.","Vasilakis, D.","Kati, V."],"organization":["University of Patras","Natural Research Ltd"],"originationDate":"2017-02-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1490","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hen-harrier-circus-cyaneus-population-trends-relation-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/00063657.2016.1262815","title":"Hen Harrier Circus cyaneus population trends in relation to wind farms","description":"Capsule:\u00a0The data presented here demonstrate a considerable spatial overlap between wind farms and the breeding distribution of Hen Harriers in Ireland, but evidence for a negative impact of wind farms on their population is weak.\n\nAims:\u00a0To assess the extent of the overlap between wind farms and breeding Hen Harriers and to investigate their potential impact on Hen Harrier population trends.\n\nMethods:\u00a0Data on Hen Harrier breeding distribution in 10\u2005km x 10\u2005km survey squares from national surveys were used in conjunction with information on the location of wind farms to examine whether, and to what extent, changes in Hen Harrier distribution and abundance between 2000 and 2010 were related to wind energy development.\n\nResults:\u00a0Of the 69 survey squares holding Hen Harriers during the 2010 breeding season, 28% also overlapped with one or more wind farms. Data from 36 of the squares with breeding Hen Harriers during the 2000 survey revealed a marginally non-significant negative relationship between wind farm presence and change in the number of breeding pairs between 2000 and 2010.\n\nConclusions:\u00a0A considerable overlap exists between Hen Harrier breeding distribution and the location of wind farms in Ireland, particularly in areas between 200 and 400\u2005m above sea level. The presence of wind farms is negatively related to Hen Harrier population trends in squares surveyed in 2000 and 2010, but this relationship is not statistically significant, and may not be causal. This is the first study to assess the influence of wind energy development on Hen Harriers at such a large geographic and population scale.","author":["Wilson, M.","Irwin, S.","Fernandex-Bellon, D.","O\u0027Halloran, J."],"organization":["University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1491","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/testing-errors-estimating-bird-mortality-rates-wind-farms-power-lines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.cambridge.org\/core\/journals\/bird-conservation-international\/article\/testing-for-errors-in-estimating-bird-mortality-rates-at-wind-farms-and-power-lines\/C82DC6A4D4272775014C1651E66E11E9","title":"Testing for errors in estimating bird mortality rates at wind farms and power lines","description":"Wind power, as an alternative to fossil fuels, is increasingly common, and is expanding worldwide. Wind farms cause mortality of flying animals through collision with moving rotor blades, and from electrocution on associated power lines. Avian mortality rates have been estimated from birds collected under turbines over varying time intervals. However, without adequate and frequent monitoring, dead birds may be removed by scavengers and thus cause an underestimation of fatalities. In this paper, we tested experimentally for possible errors arising in avian mortality caused by the removal of carcasses by scavengers. At two different wind farms and associated power lines in southern Spain, we placed pigeon and quail carcasses to determine their disappearance rate. All dead pigeons were radio-tagged to estimate distances taken by scavengers. We found significant differences in carcass disappearance rates of pigeons and quails, and between wind farms and power lines but not between habitats. All quails and 45% of pigeon carcasses had disappeared by the third and fourteenth day, respectively. Less than half (40%) of the carcasses were found \u003C 100 m from where they were deposited. While scavenging losses may vary according to the location of the wind farm or power line, here we propose a method to estimate correctly the number of fatalities at any wind farm and power line. Using this method, we can improve our understanding of the real impact of wind structures on adjacent bird communities, and adopt appropriate measures to ensure their conservation.","author":["Real, R.","Farfan, M.","Vargas, J.","Duarte, J.","Fa, J."],"organization":["Biogea Consultores","University of M\u00e1laga","Manchester Metropolitan University"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.852500000000","-4.820000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1492","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/scavenger-removal-bird-carcasses-simulated-wind-turbines-does-carcass-type-matter","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ecs2.1994","title":"Scavenger removal of bird carcasses at simulated wind turbines: Does carcass type matter?","description":"Wind energy development can negatively impact bird populations due to bird-turbine collisions. To accurately estimate bird mortality at wind farms, the number of dead birds found under turbines is commonly corrected for carcass removal by scavengers, which is quantified by measuring persistence of experimental carcasses through time. These studies often use domestic birds as surrogates because carcasses of wild birds (e.g., raptors) are difficult to obtain. We assessed scavenger removal of carcasses from five bird species at simulated turbines to determine whether domestic surrogates are scavenged at a different rate than raptors, species of interest for wind turbine mortality. The percentage of carcasses scavenged during 14-d rounds ranged from 34.6% for American kestrels (Falco sparverius) to 65.4% for chickens (Gallus gallus), and the percentage of carcasses completely removed ranged from 13.5% for red-tailed hawks (Buteo jamaicensis) to 67.3% for northern bobwhites (Colinus virginianus). Carcass type (i.e., species) was the only predictor included in the best-fit logistic regression model of complete carcass removal, and a survival analysis indicated carcass type influenced elapsed time to scavenging events. Our results suggest the use of surrogate species to quantify carcass removal at wind turbines could lead to inaccurate mortality estimates.","author":["DeVault, T.","Sparks, D.","Seamans, T.","Linnell, K.","Beasley, J."],"organization":["US Department of Agriculture (USDA)","Montana Fish, Wildlife, and Parks","Environmental Solutions and Innovations Inc","University of Georgia"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.349960000000","-82.650215000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1493","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/energy-landscape-predicts-flight-height-wind-turbine-collision-hazard-three-species","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/1365-2664.12909","title":"The energy landscape predicts flight height and wind turbine collision hazard in three species of large soaring raptor","description":"1.Collisions of large soaring raptors with wind turbines and other infrastructures represent a growing conservation concern. We describe a way to leverage knowledge about raptor soaring behaviour to forecast the probability that raptors fly in the rotor\u2010swept zone. Soaring raptors are theoretically expected to select energy sources (uplift) optimally, making their flight height dependent on uplift conditions. This approach can be used to forecast collision hazard when planning or operating wind farms. Empirical investigations of the factors influencing flight height have, however, so far been hindered by observation error.\n2. We propose a two\u2010pronged approach. First, we fitted state\u2010space models to\u00a0z\u2010axis GPS\u00a0tracking data to filter heavy\u2010tailed observation error and estimate the relationship between vertical movement parameters and weather variables describing the energy landscape (thermal and orographic uplift potential). Second, we fitted a mechanistic model of flight height above ground based on aerodynamics and resource selection theories. The approach was replicated for five GPS\u2010tracked Andean condors\u00a0Vultur gryphus, eight griffon vultures\u00a0Gyps fulvus, and six golden eagles\u00a0Aquila chrysaetos.\n3. In all individuals, movement parameters correlated with thermal uplift potential in the expected direction. In all species, collision hazard was lowest for high thermal uplift potential values. Species specificities in the presence of a peak in collision hazard for medium values of thermal uplift potential could be explained by differences in wing loading and aspect ratio.\n4. Synthesis and applications. Our fitted models convert weather data (thermal uplift potential) into a prediction of collision hazard (probability to fly in the rotor\u2010swept zone), making it possible to prioritize different wind development projects with respect to the relative hazard they would pose to raptors. However, our model should be combined with post\u2010construction monitoring to document, and eventually account for turbine avoidance behaviours in collision rate predictions.","author":["Peron, G.","Duriez, O.","Safi, K.","Fleming, C.","Fluhr, J.","Itty, C.","Lambertucci, S.","Shepard, E.","Calabrese, J."],"organization":["Smithsonian Institution","Universite Claude Bernard Lyon 1","University of Maryland","Montpellier 1 University","Office national de la chasse et de la faune sauvage (ONCFS)","Universidad Nacional del Comahue","Max Planck Institute for Ornithology","Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1494","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mapping-global-potential-exposure-soaring-birds-terrestrial-wind-energy-expansion","sourceURL":"https:\/\/hdl.handle.net\/10138\/234561","title":"Mapping the global potential exposure of soaring birds to terrestrial wind energy expansion","description":"The wind energy sector is steadily growing, and the number of wind turbines is expected to expand across large areas of the globe in the near future. While the development of wind energy can contribute to mitigating climate change, it also poses challenges to wildlife, particularly birds, due to increased collision risk with wind turbines. Here we quantify and map potential conflicts between the potential for wind energy development and the distribution of terrestrial soaring birds. We explore the relationship between species traits (including body mass, migration ecology and extinction risk) and exposure to potential wind energy development, and identified areas of potential conflict between wind power production and soaring bird conservation. We considered the full range of each species, as well as separately analyzing the breeding, non-breeding and passage ranges for migratory species. We show that exposure to potential wind energy development is similar for soaring and non-soaring bird species. Within different parts of the range of soaring bird species, passage distributions have significantly higher potential for wind energy development than the full, breeding or non-breeding ranges. Moreover, exposure to potential wind energy development was higher within the ranges of heavier soaring bird species and those that are migratory. We show that areas of conflict between soaring bird conservation and potential wind energy development could be very large, particularly when the passage ranges of soaring bird species are considered. Such areas of potential conflict are largely unprotected. This highlights a risk for soaring birds from potential wind energy development wherever it is not carefully sited in order to minimise environmental impacts.","author":["Smith, P.","Santangeli, A.","Butchart, S.","Pogson, M.","Hastings, A.","Girardello, M.","Moilanen, A."],"organization":["University of Helsinki","BirdLife International","University of Cambridge","University of Bolton","University of Aberdeen","University of Azores"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1495","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-impacts-anthropogenic-disturbances-marine-populations","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/conl.12563","title":"Predicting the impacts of anthropogenic disturbances on marine populations","description":"Marine ecosystems are increasingly exposed to anthropogenic disturbances that cause animals to change behavior and move away from potential foraging grounds. Here we present a process\u2010based modeling framework for assessing population consequences of such sub\u2010lethal behavioral effects. It builds directly on how disturbances influence animal movements, foraging and energetics, and is therefore applicable to a wide range of species. To demonstrate the model we assess the impact of wind farm construction noise on the North Sea harbor porpoise population. Subsequently, we demonstrate how the model can be used to minimize population impacts of disturbances through spatial planning. Population models that build on the fundamental processes that determine animal fitness have a high predictive power in novel environments, making them ideal for marine management.","author":["Teilmann, J.","Nabe-Nielsen, J.","Thompson, P.","Sibly, R.","Grimm, V.","van Beest, F."],"organization":["Aarhus University","Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ)","University of Reading","University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1496","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/breeding-density-fine-scale-tracking-large-scale-modeling-reveal-regional-distribution","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/eap.1591","title":"Breeding density, fine-scale tracking, and large-scale modeling reveal the regional distribution of four seabird species","description":"Population-level estimates of species\u0027 distributions can reveal fundamental ecological processes and facilitate conservation. However, these may be difficult to obtain for mobile species, especially colonial central-place foragers (CCPFs; e.g., bats, corvids, social insects), because it is often impractical to determine the provenance of individuals observed beyond breeding sites. Moreover, some CCPFs, especially in the marine realm (e.g., pinnipeds, turtles, and seabirds) are difficult to observe because they range tens to ten thousands of kilometers from their colonies. It is hypothesized that the distribution of CCPFs depends largely on habitat availability and intraspecific competition. Modeling these effects may therefore allow distributions to be estimated from samples of individual spatial usage. Such data can be obtained for an increasing number of species using tracking technology. However, techniques for estimating population-level distributions using the telemetry data are poorly developed. This is of concern because many marine CCPFs, such as seabirds, are threatened by anthropogenic activities. Here, we aim to estimate the distribution at sea of four seabird species, foraging from approximately 5,500 breeding sites in Britain and Ireland. To do so, we GPS-tracked a sample of 230 European Shags Phalacrocorax aristotelis, 464 Black-legged Kittiwakes Rissa tridactyla, 178 Common Murres Uria aalge, and 281 Razorbills Alca torda from 13, 20, 12, and 14 colonies, respectively. Using Poisson point process habitat use models, we show that distribution at sea is dependent on (1) density-dependent competition among sympatric conspecifics (all species) and parapatric conspecifics (Kittiwakes and Murres); (2) habitat accessibility and coastal geometry, such that birds travel further from colonies with limited access to the sea; and (3) regional habitat availability. Using these models, we predict space use by birds from unobserved colonies and thereby map the distribution at sea of each species at both the colony and regional level. Space use by all four species\u0027 British breeding populations is concentrated in the coastal waters of Scotland, highlighting the need for robust conservation measures in this area. The techniques we present are applicable to any CCPF.","author":["Miller, P.","Votier, S.","Daunt, F.","Wanless, S.","Soanes, L.","Green, J.","Owen, E.","Newton, S.","Bolton, M.","Wakefield, E.","Robertson, G.","Baer, J.","Carroll, M.","Dodd, S.","Guilford, T.","Mavor, R.","Newell, M.","Shoji, A."],"organization":["Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)","University of Glasgow","BirdWatch Ireland","UK Centre for Ecology \u0026 Hydrology (CEH)","University of Liverpool","University of Oxford","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)","Plymouth Marine Laboratory","University of Roehampton","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1497","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-spatial-effects-disturbance-constructive-critique-provide-evidence-ecological","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/full\/10.2981\/wlb.00245","title":"Modeling the spatial effects of disturbance: a constructive critique to provide evidence of ecological thresholds","description":"Biologists and conservation planners are frequently asked to evaluate the spatial effects of anthropogenic disturbance on species of conservation concern. The linear response of a demographic parameter, such as survival or abundance, to the distance-from-disturbance is often used to inform spatial restrictions on development. The linear response, we argue, does not model the most common biological mechanisms that cause changes to demographic parameters, nor does it provide an estimate of a threshold that planners could use to protect species of concern. In the Great Plains of North America, biologists are increasingly concerned about the impact of energy development on populations of four species of grouse. To address this gap in our ability to properly assess distance thresholds, we developed a framework of four response patterns (null, linear, stair step, ramped) to describe the potential effects of a disturbance on biological processes relevant to nesting grouse located along a gradient from the disturbance. We simulated position and survival of grouse nests along a 25-km disturbance gradient to mimic the response to disturbances. We evaluated the relative support for a set of linear and nonlinear models in a known fate analysis of nest survival. Each of the underlying response patterns was detected with an appropriate model in a model selection framework (\u03c9AIC = 0.61\u20130.75) when the sample size of nests was high (n = 500), and thresholds were identified when present. In a low sample size scenario (n = 50 nests) that may be typical of shortterm empirical sampling schemes, the stair step threshold was detected, but the more complex, ramped threshold was not detected. We provide recommendations regarding study design and inference for ecological and policy thresholds, and we encourage researchers to be cautious about the manner in which threshold responses are assessed and described.","author":["Brown, M.","Harrison, J.","Smith, A.","Whalen, C.","Powell, L."],"organization":["University of Nebraska","Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1498","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/opportunistically-collected-data-reveal-habitat-selection-migrating-whooping-cranes-us","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/10.1650\/CONDOR-17-80.1","title":"Opportunistically collected data reveal habitat selection by migrating Whooping Cranes in the US Northern Plains","description":"The Whooping Crane (Grus americana) is a federally endangered species in the United States and Canada that relies on wetland, grassland, and cropland habitat during its long migration between wintering grounds in coastal Texas, USA, and breeding sites in Alberta and Northwest Territories, Canada. We combined opportunistic Whooping Crane sightings with landscape data to identify correlates of Whooping Crane occurrence along the migration corridor in North Dakota and South Dakota, USA. Whooping Cranes selected landscapes characterized by diverse wetland communities and upland foraging opportunities. Model performance substantially improved when variables related to detection were included, emphasizing the importance of accounting for biases associated with detection and reporting of birds in opportunistic datasets. We created a predictive map showing relative probability of occurrence across the study region by applying our model to GIS data layers; validation using independent, unbiased locations from birds equipped with platform transmitting terminals indicated that our final model adequately predicted habitat use by migrant Whooping Cranes. The probability map demonstrated that existing conservation efforts have protected much top-tier Whooping Crane habitat, especially in the portions of North Dakota and South Dakota that lie east of the Missouri River. Our results can support species recovery by informing prioritization for acquisition and restoration of landscapes that provide safe roosting and foraging habitats. Our results can also guide the siting of structures such as wind towers and electrical transmission and distribution lines, which pose a strike and mortality risk to migrating Whooping Cranes.","author":["Niemuth, N.","Pearse, A.","Brandt, D.","Ryba, A.","Kvas, S.","Wangler, B.","Austin, J.","Carlisle, M."],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1499","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/long-term-implications-sustained-wind-power-growth-united-states-potential-benefits","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261916308984","title":"Long-term implications of sustained wind power growth in the United States: Potential benefits and secondary impacts","description":"We model scenarios of the U.S. electric sector in which wind generation reaches 10% of end-use electricity demand in 2020, 20% in 2030, and 35% in 2050. As shown in a companion paper, achieving these penetration levels would have significant implications for the wind industry and the broader electric sector. Compared to a baseline that assumes no new wind deployment, under the primary scenario modeled, achieving these penetrations imposes an incremental cost to electricity consumers of less than 1% through 2030. These cost implications, however, should be balanced against the variety of environmental and social implications of such a scenario. Relative to a baseline that assumes no new wind deployment, our analysis shows that the high-penetration wind scenario yields potential greenhouse-gas benefits of $85-$1,230 billion in present-value terms, with a central estimate of $400 billion. Air-pollution-related health benefits are estimated at $52-$272 billion, while annual electric-sector water withdrawals and consumption are lower by 15% and 23% in 2050, respectively. We also find that a high-wind-energy future would have implications for the diversity and risk of energy supply, local economic development, and land use and related local impacts on communities and ecosystems; however, these additional impacts may not greatly affect aggregate social welfare owing to their nature, in part, as resource transfers.","author":["Mai, T.","Lantz, E.","Wiser, R.","Bolinger, M.","Heath, G.","Keyser, D.","Macknick, J.","Millstein, D."],"organization":["Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1500","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/land-cover-topography-affect-land-transformation-caused-wind-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0088914","title":"Land cover and topography affect the land transformation caused by wind facilities","description":"Land transformation (ha of surface disturbance\/MW) associated with wind facilities shows wide variation in its reported values. In addition, no studies have attempted to explain the variation across facilities. We digitized land transformation at 39 wind facilities using high resolution aerial imagery. We then modeled the effects of turbine size, configuration, land cover, and topography on the levels of land transformation at three spatial scales. The scales included strings (turbines with intervening roads only), sites (strings with roads connecting them, buried cables and other infrastructure), and entire facilities (sites and the roads or transmission lines connecting them to existing infrastructure). An information theoretic modeling approach indicated land cover and topography were well-supported variables affecting land transformation, but not turbine size or configuration. Tilled landscapes, despite larger distances between turbines, had lower average land transformation, while facilities in forested landscapes generally had the highest land transformation. At site and string scales, flat topographies had the lowest land transformation, while facilities on mesas had the largest. The results indicate the landscape in which the facilities are placed affects the levels of land transformation associated with wind energy. This creates opportunities for optimizing wind energy production while minimizing land cover change. In addition, the results indicate forecasting the impacts of wind energy on land transformation should include the geographic variables affecting land transformation reported here.","author":["Compton, R.","Diffendorfer, J."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2014-02-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1501","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-power-externalities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0921800915305255","title":"Wind Power and Externalities","description":"This paper provides a literature review on wind power and externalities from multiple perspectives. Specifically, the economic rationale behind world-wide wind power deployment is to mitigate negative externalities of conventional electricity technologies, notably emissions from fossil fuels. However, wind power entails externalities itself. Wind turbines can lower quality of human life through noise and visual impacts, and threaten wildlife. Variable wind electricity can impose additional costs within the electricity system. Locally and nationally, employment, output, and security of electricity supply can be affected. Assembling evidence from diverse strands of research, this literature review provides a structured account of external and indirect costs, both mitigated and imposed.","author":["Zerrahn, A."],"organization":["German Institute for Economic Research (DIW Berlin)"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1502","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-activity-during-autumn-relates-atmospheric-conditions-implications-coastal-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/jmammal\/article\/97\/6\/1565\/2628024","title":"Bat activity during autumn relates to atmospheric conditions: implications for coastal wind energy development","description":"The cryptic behavior of migrating bats leaves us largely uninformed of their seasonal distribution and abundance, important movement corridors, and migration behaviors. However, models of avian migration in relation to meteorological variables may prove useful in describing seasonal patterns of coastal bat activity. We pursued 2 primary objectives regarding regional autumn bat activity along the Atlantic Coast of southern New England, United States, inferred from continuous acoustic monitoring: 1) to evaluate hypotheses regarding the association of regional atmospheric conditions and coastal bat activity and 2) to construct and evaluate models that predict regional bat activity on a given night using meteorological data accessed ahead of the activity. Acoustic bat activity was attributable primarily to 2 species of migratory tree bats, red bat and silver-haired bat, but also the short-distance migrant tricolored bat and generally sedentary big brown bat. Myotis spp. and hoary bat detections were relatively uncommon among classified calls. Coastal bat activity varied with regional wind conditions indicative of cold front passage and expected to induce a more coastal flight path, but associations with other atmospheric conditions from models of songbird migration were typically weak. Bat acoustic activity also was associated strongly with various aspects of temperature. Predictive models of regional nightly bat activity were reasonably accurate in anticipating nights of the highest and lowest bat activity, particularly for low-frequency bats such as silver-haired and big brown bat. The ability to anticipate high bat activity may help reduce adverse interactions with forthcoming wind energy development in coastal and offshore areas along the western Atlantic Ocean.","author":["McWilliams, S.","Smith, A."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2016-12-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.367331000000","-71.591068000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1503","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-man-made-structures-water-depth-affect-diel-rhythms-click-recordings-harbor","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/mms.12112","title":"Do man-made structures and water depth affect the diel rhythms in click recordings of harbor porpoises (Phocoena phocoena)?","description":"The construction of industrial offshore structures may lead to colonization by a variety of marine organisms resulting in locally enhanced biodiversity and biomass, which may then affect the habitat use and behavior of marine predators. For harbor porpoises high nocturnal echolocation activity was demonstrated near industrial structures and it was hypothesized that this was caused by increased feeding opportunities at night. Here we tested the hypothesis that bridge pillars will lead to more nocturnal echolocation activity by porpoises near them than at positions further away. The daily rhythms in porpoise detections near bridge pillars tended to be slightly more pronounced and a greater proportion of clicks occurred during the night. However, water depth had a greater impact on these rhythms, with more nocturnal porpoise echolocation activity and more pronounced daily rhythms in deeper waters. This may be related to different feeding techniques and prey choice by porpoises in deep and shallow water. In deeper water porpoises may be feeding pelagically on herring and cod, which show more activity and are easier to catch at night. In shallow water they may be targeting mainly gobies using a bottom feeding technique and this may not be more efficient at night.","author":["Diederichs, A.","Nehls, G.","Brandt, M.","Hansen, S."],"organization":["BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2014-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.333300000000","11.000000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1504","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/displacement-seabirds-offshore-wind-farm-north-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v554\/p173-182\/","title":"Displacement of seabirds by an offshore wind farm in the North Sea","description":"The number of offshore wind farms in Europe and elsewhere has substantially in creased in recent years. This rapid development has raised concerns about potential impacts on marine wildlife, particularly on seabirds, as these can be negatively affected through collision and displacement. While collision risk has been the focus of a number of studies, information about displacement of seabirds is scarce. Here we present data from an extensive survey program that aimed at determining the effects on seabirds of the first German offshore wind farm, \u0027alpha ventus\u0027. Data were collected by line transect surveys during the first 3 yr of operation. We found significant displacement of 5 species with 75-92% lower abundance inside compared to outside the wind farm. For 3 species, the response distance to the outermost turbines was estimated to exceed 1 km. Two gull species were attracted to the wind farm site. Our results and a review of the available literature revealed good agreement with respect to the sign of the response (avoidance vs. attraction) but considerable differences in the strength of the response and the spatial extent of the disturbance outside the footprint of wind farms. While it seems unlikely that small-scale displacement by single wind farms would have an impact at the population level, the extent of the proposed development of offshore wind energy warrants further research into cumulative effects and their biological significance for seabird populations.","author":["Nehls, G.","Welcker, J."],"organization":["BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2016-07-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.000000000000","6.616670000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Habitat Change","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1505","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nocturnal-migrants-do-not-incur-higher-collision-risk-wind-turbines-diurnally-active","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/ibi.12456","title":"Nocturnal migrants do not incur higher collision risk at wind turbines than diurnally active species","description":"Nocturnally migrating birds, particularly passerines, are known to be vulnerable to collision with man- made structures such as buildings, towers or offshore platforms, yet information with respect to wind farms is ambiguous. We recorded bird flight intensities using radar during autumn migration at four wind farms situated within a major migration flyway in northern Germany and simultaneously conducted systematic searches for collision fatalities at the same sites. We found that migration traffic rates at rotor height estimated by radar observations were significantly higher during the night, yet strictly nocturnal migrants constituted only 8.6% of all fatalities at the wind farms. In contrast to the situation at other vertical structures, nocturnal migrants do not have a higher risk of collision with wind energy facilities than do diurnally active species, but rather appear to circumvent collision more effectively.","author":["Nehls, G.","Blew, J.","Grunkorn, T.","Welcker, J.","Liesenjohann, M."],"organization":["BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.500000000000","11.333300000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1506","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/investigations-effects-pile-driving-offshore-wind-farm-horns-rev-ii-fino-iii-research","sourceURL":"","title":"Investigations into the effects of pile driving at the offshore wind farm Horns Rev II and the FINO III research platform","description":"During summer 2008, 92 monopile foundations of 3.9 m diameter were rammed into the seabed of the Danish North Sea west of Esbjerg to construct the offshore wind farm Horns Rev II. Effects of pile driving on harbour porpoise behaviour were studied by Brandt et al. (2009a) and a strong effect with reduced porpoise recordings that lasted up to 23 hours in the vicinity was found. The length of this effect rapidly decreased with distance. At more than 10 km distance it only lasted about 1-2 hours and was thus more or less limited to the time that pile driving took place.  In this study, we tested the effects of the construction of the research platform FINO III in the German North Sea and the wind farm Horns Rev II in the Danish North Sea on harbour porpoises on a large scale by passive acoustic monitoring. As the previous study at Horns Rev II only covered a maximum distance of about 20 km, the aim of this study was to investigate potentially further reaching effects of pile driving. For this purpose five C-PODs were deployed along a 50 km transect reaching from the Horns Rev II construction site southwest to the research platform FINO III.  Unlike during the previous study the parameter PP10M\/day and PPM\/H did not show a clear effect of pile driving on harbour porpoises at any location. However, the duration of waiting time indicated an effect which was statistically detectable at close distance (7 km) to the construction site. There may be some methodological reasons, why an effect was detectable by analysing waitingtimes but not the other parameters, which are discussed.. Compared to random waiting times first waiting times after pile driving increased 4.5fold by 7.6 hours (from 2.2 hours to 9.8 hours) at a distance of 7 km. A somewhat weaker effect was found at greater distances (15 - 37 km) where the increase of first waiting times was between 1.3 and 3.6 hours compared to random waiting times. However, here the difference was not statistically significant. A significant effect at 46 km was likely to have been an artefact.  The results are discussed in relation to expected noise levels at large distances and possibly diverging responses of harbour porpoises in habitats of differing function or quality.  From available data it cannot be finally concluded until what range piling noise from Horns Rev 2 was audible to harbour porpoises, but they are likely to be masked by background noise at 50 km. It is concluded, that harbour porpoise responses at distances beyond 15 km, if at all present, are certainly weak and of short duration.","author":["Diederichs, A.","Nehls, G.","Brandt, M."],"organization":["BioConsult SH","Dong Energy"],"originationDate":"2009-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.430538000000","7.658034000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 10:11:39","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Brandt-et-al-2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1507","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/methodologies-measuring-assessing-potential-changes-marine-mammal-behaviour-abundance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/289249731_Methodologies_for_measuring_and_assessing_potential_changes_in_marine_mammal_behaviour_abundance_or_distribution_arising_from_the_construction_operation_and_decommissioning_of_offshore_windfarms","title":"Methodologies for measuring and assessing potential changes in marine mammal behaviour, abundance or distribution arising from the construction, operation and decommissioning of offshore windfarms","description":"This reports reviews methodologies for measuring and assessing potential changes in marine mammal behaviour, abundance or distribution arising from the construction, operation and decommissioning of offshore windfarms. The report first describes impacts from offshore windfarms on marine mammals and defines the spatial and temporal scope of investigations in order to detect impacts on marine mammals. Impacts from offshore windfarming occur at very different spatial and temporal scales: Construction work, especially pile driving, may result in short-termed but long ranged impacts, whereas the operation of windfarms is expected to result in local but long-lasting impacts.  The report reviews the standard methods used in studies on marine mammals in relation to offshore windfarms. Statistical power of line transect surveys using aircrafts and ships and Static Acoustic Monitoring using T-PODs is analysed from datasets obtained in German studies.  Aerial surveys provide an efficient method for multi-species surveys covering rather large areas (2000 km2 ) per survey, which are considered to be sufficient to compare impact and reference areas. In areas where abundance of harbour porpoises are sufficiently high, which is expected to be the case in many UK waters, aerial surveys are useful to measure population size and population changes. Based on datasets in areas of high densities, it is concluded that 30 % changes can be detected by 1-3 surveys. Aerial surveys will provide additional data on other species, however, as either densities (dolphins, whales) or detection rates (seals) are low, no quantitative data can be obtained in restricted areas. Aerial surveys are often restricted by weather conditions and thus suffer from a low temporal resolution. The spatial resolution may not be sufficient to detect small-scaled impacts as expected during the operation of offshore windfarms.  Line transect counts from ships may also be used for marine mammal surveys. They have a lower spatial resolution and are even more restricted to suitable weather conditions. Based on datasets in areas of high densities, it is concluded that 30 % changes can also be detected by 1-3 surveys. The efficiency of ship transect surveys can probably be highly improved by towed hydrophones, which record echolocation clicks from porpoises and dolphins. The main advantage of towed hydrophones would be, that it can be used at night and during weather conditions, which do not allow visual surveys.  Static Acoustic Monitoring (SAM) using T-PODs or other devices provide excellent data on harbour porpoises and potentially also dolphin species at a high temporal but low spatial resolution. The spatial resolution can be improved by deploying several SAM devices in the area of interest. Statistical analysis from areas with low and high porpoise densities proved that a 30 % change in harbour porpoise presence can be proved with a sample size of 3-11.  Other methods, as telemetry tracking, photo-identification and haul-out counts for seals are described.  For impact studies in relation to offshore windfarms a BACI (Before-After\/Control-Impact) design is generally recommended but recommendations are also given for cases, where no baseline data are available or a BACI may not be possible for other reasons.  It is recommended to combine line transect surveys using aircrafts or ships with Static Acoustic Monitoring. An impact study on offshore windfarms should ideally cover two years before construction, the construction period and at least two years of operation. If longer lasting effects are detected, the study during the operational phase should be extended. It is recommended to conduct line transect surveys in monthly intervals. In areas with a marked seasonal occurrence, surveys may be restricted to periods with high abundance, when sufficient data are more likely to be obtained. Continuous recordings of harbour porpoises with SAM are recommended for all areas, where these animals occur in relevant numbers. SAM will provide data which are needed to detect short-termed changes in behaviour and abundance as expected in response to pile driving, but also to detect changes on a much smaller spatial scale as can be detected by other methods as well as long-term changes in response to construction of operation. For seals and dolphins severe problems in assessing the impacts remain, as their behaviour or low densities make it very difficult to obtain enough data for statistical analysis.","author":["Koschinski, S.","D\u00e4hne, M.","Adler, S.","Diederichs, A.","Nehls, G.","Verfu\u00df, U."],"organization":["BioConsult SH","German Oceanographic Museum","Collaborative Offshore Wind Research into the Environment (COWRIE)"],"originationDate":"2008-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Diederichs_et_al_2008.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1508","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/high-resolution-sea-duck-distribution-modeling-relating-aerial-ship-survey-data-food","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/10.1650\/CONDOR-16-57.1","title":"High-resolution sea duck distribution modeling: Relating aerial and ship survey data to food resources, anthropogenic pressures, and topographic variables","description":"Anthropogenic developments in marine coastal zones potentially overlap with areas of conservation interest, including important areas for birds. Ideally, spatial patterns of species abundance should be considered at ecologically relevant spatial resolutions (high resolutions) to inform spatial planning and environmental assessments. Most planning so far, however, has relied on coarse-resolution distribution maps from atlas projects or models often based on limited datasets (few surveys), and relationships with environmental variables have rarely been taken into account, leaving many studies and recommendations vulnerable to criticism. We therefore combined the strengths of a detailed database of spatially explicit aerial and ship surveys with high-resolution environmental predictors and species distribution models to predict detailed density patterns for 3 sea duck species, as part of an environmental impact assessment (EIA) in the southern Baltic Sea. We also compared the results from 2 different survey platforms to assess potential differences. We related survey data for Common Eiders (Somateria mollissima), Long-tailed Ducks (Clangula hyemalis), and Common Scoters (Melanitta nigra) to topographic variables, food resources, and anthropogenic pressures using 2-step generalized additive models accounting for zero inflation, nonnormality, and nonlinearity. We accurately predicted distribution patterns (the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve [AUC]: 0.79-0.84) and abundances (Spearman\u0027s correlation: 0.36-0.62) at a resolution of 750 m. However, abundance predictions based on aerial survey data differed in magnitude in comparison with predictions from ship survey data, particularly for the frequently diving Long-tailed Duck. We suggest that the main source of the differing abundance estimates was differences in the input data collected using different survey platforms, rather than the modeling approach. A correction factor for birds missed during surveys due to diving activity would therefore increase the accuracy of abundance estimates. Our results show that it is possible to fit ecologically interpretable relationships between species and environmental variables, allowing for the creation of high-resolution predictions useful for management and conservation.","author":["Skov, H.","Hein\u00e4nen, S.","Zydelis, R.","Nehls, G.","Dorsch,M."],"organization":["Danish Hydraulic Institute (DHI)","BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.613630000000","11.151492000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1509","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/response-migrating-raptors-increasing-number-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1111\/1365-2664.12673","title":"Response of migrating raptors to an increasing number of wind farms","description":"Flying birds have been documented to respond in different ways to the presence of wind farms. Such responses are species- and site-specific, with wind farm design playing an important role. Between 2009 and 2014, the length of rows of wind turbines within our study area increased from 34km to approximate to 75km, and the total area occupied by wind farms increased from 647km(2) to 1421km(2). This area is located on an important migratory corridor in southern Mexico.\u00a0\n\n\nWe used marine radar and hawk-watch monitoring stations to collect data during six consecutive autumn seasons from a single wind farm. We analysed the response of migrating raptors to the presence of two new wind farms by comparing the mean bearing of flight trajectories and the number of intersectionskm(-1) of trajectories with wind farm areas between 2009-2011 and 2012-2014, representing the pre- and post-construction stages of the new wind farms.\u00a0\n\n\nMean raptor count was \u003E600000 individuals for the six seasons. The most abundant species were Turkey Vulture Cathartes aura, Swainson\u0027s Hawk Buteo swainsoni and Broad-winged hawk Buteo platypterus. Between 79% and 97% of migration occurred in October. Radar monitoring overlapped with the peak migratory activity each season. We observed significant differences between periods, involving more scattering in flight bearings and less intersectionskm(-1) of trajectory in the post- than in the pre-construction period, implying an avoidance of the new wind farms.Synthesis and applications. We show that migrating raptors adjusted their flight trajectories to avoid new wind farms, but also discuss the extent and limitations of our findings. Our results from our hawk-watch monitoring station, which represent the first published account about the seasonality and intensity of raptor migration in the area, could be used by decision-makers for careful planning of future wind energy developments in the area. Our results might aid in the conservation of those species of raptors that migrate through the Isthmus of Tehuantepec.\u00a0\n\n\nWe show that migrating raptors adjusted their flight trajectories to avoid new wind farms, but also discuss the extent and limitations of our findings. Our results from our hawk-watch monitoring station, which represent the first published account about the seasonality and intensity of raptor migration in the area, could be used by decision-makers for careful planning of future wind energy developments in the area. Our results might aid in the conservation of those species of raptors that migrate through the Isthmus of Tehuantepec.","author":["Villegas-Patraca, R.","Cabrera-Cruz, S."],"organization":["Instituto de Ecolog\u00eda UNAM","University of Delaware"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["16.589689000000","-94.822489000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1510","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/composition-activity-arthropodivorous-bat-community-wind-farms-mexican-tropics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1870345317301951","title":"Composition and activity of arthropodivorous bat community in wind farms in the Mexican Tropics","description":"We studied the bat arthropodivorous species composition and their activity during the rainy and dry seasons of 2013 and 2014, to evaluate the effect of wind farms on these species. We captured specimens using mist nets and we recorded echolocation sounds a free fly with an ultrasonic detector in 2 areas: with wind farms (DPE) and without it (FPE). We recorded 13 species and 4 genera. In mist nets we registered 100 individuals from 8 species (with a sampling effort of 120,600 m.mist net\/hr); using an ultrasonic detector, 4,518 passes of 9 species and 4 genera were recorded. In the DFE area, we recorded 12 species and 4 genera, in the FPE area, 10 species and 4 genera. The analysis did not show significant differences for the activity between DPE and FPE areas, however seasonal differences were found. The 19:00 and 20:00 hrs in both conditions registered the greatest number of passes. It is possible that environmental and landscape variables, which have been reported of importance for bat activity, intervene in this region as no differences were found in the analysis performed.  Composici\u00f3n y actividad de la comunidad de murci\u00e9lagos artropod\u00edvoros en parques e\u00f3licos del tr\u00f3pico mexicano   Se estudi\u00f3 la composici\u00f3n y actividad de murci\u00e9lagos artropod\u00edvoros durante las temporadas de lluvias y secas de 2013 y 2014, para evaluar el efecto de los parques e\u00f3licos sobre estas especies. Se capturaron ejemplares con redes de niebla y se grabaron sonidos de ecolocaci\u00f3n en vuelo libre con un detector ultras\u00f3nico en 2 \u00e1reas: dentro de parques e\u00f3licos (DPE) y fuera de parques e\u00f3licos (FPE). Se registraron 13 especies y 4 g\u00e9neros. En las redes se registraron 100 individuos de 8 especies (con un esfuerzo de muestreo de 120,600 m.red\/hora); con el detector, se grabaron 4,518 pases de 9 especies y 4 g\u00e9neros. En el \u00e1rea DPE se registraron 12 especies y 4 g\u00e9neros; en el \u00e1rea FPE, 10 especies y 4 g\u00e9neros. El an\u00e1lisis no mostr\u00f3 diferencias significativas para la actividad entre las \u00e1reas DPE y FPE; no obstante, por temporadas s\u00ed se encontraron diferencias. Durante las 19:00 y las 20:00 h, en ambas condiciones se registraron el mayor n\u00famero de pases. Es posible que las variables ambientales y del paisaje que han sido reportadas de importancia para la actividad de murci\u00e9lagos intervengan en esta regi\u00f3n, al no encontrarse diferencias en el an\u00e1lisis realizado.  This article is only available in Spanish.","author":["Briones-Salas, M.","Garcia-Luis, M."],"organization":["Instituto Politecnico Nacional"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["16.590716400000","-94.799709300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Garcia-Luis-Briones-Salas-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1511","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-fatalities-wind-farms-taiwan","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/10.3106\/041.042.0208","title":"Bat fatalities at wind farms in Taiwan","description":"We collected bat carcasses at three wind farms in Taiwan, located along the west coast mostly near the sea and\/or in former coastal wetland habitats. We found 43 bat carcasses, mostly of common aerial-hawking species such as\u00a0Pipistrellus abramus\u00a0and\u00a0Scotophilus kuhlii,\u00a0but the island endemics\u00a0Eptesicus serotinus horikawai\u00a0and\u00a0Myotis formosus flavus\u00a0were also recovered. All bat species affected are believed to remain on the island all year. As far as we know this is the first report of bat fatalities at wind energy facilities in eastern Asia.","author":["Huang, Y.","Liu, W.","Rydell, J.","Chou, C.","Hsieh, T.","Chou, T."],"organization":["Lund University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1512","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/large-scale-citizen-science-improves-assessment-risk-posed-wind-farms-bats-southern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320717302884","title":"Large-scale citizen science improves assessment of risk posed by wind farms to bats in southern Scotland","description":"In order to ensure that the placement of future wind energy developments does not conflict with important areas for bats, surveys and analyses are required to deliver a robust understanding of large-scale patterns in species\u0027 distributions and abundance. We demonstrate that extensive presence-absence survey data can be collected for bats across a large (\u003E 20,000 km(2)) region of southern Scotland using volunteers supplemented with additional fieldworker effort in remote areas. We advocate a survey design that allows data to be collected for all bat species, but provide more focused analyses on three species (Leisler\u0027s bat, noctule and Nathusius\u0027 pipistrelle) that are currently considered to be at highest risk from wind turbines. We estimate that between 16% and 24% of the regional populations of these three high risk species overlap existing and approved wind farms, with 50% of this overlap concentrated at just 10% of wind farms. This emphasises the importance of new wind farm placement to minimise impact on these species. We have stratified the region according to the potential impact on bats of future wind farm development, highlighting those areas in the top 1%, 5% and 10% of risk. We conclude that there is a need for higher quality data of this type in order to inform spatial models of bat distribution and activity. As a minimum standard, researchers working on bats should prioritise the collection and use of presence-absence data with consideration of the underlying survey design and representativeness of the data collected. This can be achieved most cost-effectively by working with the public to develop large-scale acoustic monitoring schemes.","author":["Wilson, M.","Newson, S.","Evans, H.","Gillings, S.","Jarrett, D.","Raynor, R."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1513","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farms-have-cascading-impacts-ecosystems-across-trophic-levels","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41559-018-0707-z","title":"Wind farms have cascading impacts on ecosystems across trophic levels","description":"Wind farms are a cleaner alternative to fossil fuels for mitigating the effects of climate change, but they also have complex ecological consequences. In the biodiversity hotspot of the Western Ghats in India, we find that wind farms reduce the abundance and activity of predatory birds (for example, Buteo, Butastur and Elanus species), which consequently increases the density of lizards, Sarada superba. The cascading effects of wind turbines on lizards include changes in behaviour, physiology and morphology that reflect a combination of predator release and density-dependent competition. By adding an effective trophic level to the top of food webs, we find that wind farms have emerging impacts that are greatly underestimated. There is thus a strong need for an ecosystem-wide view when aligning green-energy goals with environment protection.","author":["Thaker, M.","Zambre, A.","Bhosale, H."],"organization":["Indian Institute of Science","University of Minnesota"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1514","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/observation-sandhill-cranes-grus-canadensis-flight-behavior-heavy-fog","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wjoonline.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1676\/wils-127-02-281-288.1","title":"Observation of Sandhill Cranes\u0027 (Grus canadensis) Flight Behavior in Heavy Fog","description":"The behaviors of birds flying in low visibility conditions remain poorly understood. We had the opportunity to monitor Sandhill Cranes (Grus canadensis) flying in heavy fog with very low visibility during a comprehensive landscape use study of refuging cranes in the Horicon Marsh in southeastern Wisconsin. As part of the study, we recorded flight patterns of cranes with a portable marine radar at various locations and times of day, and visually counted cranes as they departed the roost in the morning. We compared flight patterns during a fog event with those recorded during clear conditions. In good visibility, cranes usually departed the night roost shortly after sunrise and flew in relatively straight paths toward foraging areas. In fog, cranes departed the roost later in the day, did not venture far from the roost, engaged in significantly more circling flight, and returned to the roost site rather than proceeding to foraging areas. We also noted that compared to mornings with good visibility, cranes flying in fog called more frequently than usual. The only time in this 2-year study that observers heard young of the year calling was during the fog event. The observed behavior of cranes circling and lingering in an area while flying in poor visibility conditions suggests that such situations may increase chances of colliding with natural or anthropogenic obstacles in the vicinity.","author":["Kirsch, E.","Diehl, R.","Suarez, M.","Wellik, M.","Lutes, J.","Woyczik, W.","Krapfl, J.","Sojda,R."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","University of Southern Mississippi","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.566340000000","-88.647450000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1515","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-spring-direct-mortality-avifauna-wind-energy-facilities-dakotas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.1051","title":"Assessing spring direct mortality to avifauna from wind energy facilities in the Dakotas","description":"The Northern Great Plains (NGP) contains much of the remaining temperate grasslands, an ecosystem that is one of the most converted and least protected in the world. Within the NGP, the Prairie Pothole Region (PPR) provides important habitat for \u003E50% of North America\u0027s breeding waterfowl and many species of shorebirds, waterbirds, and grassland songbirds. This region also has high wind energy potential, but the effects of wind energy developments on migratory and resident bird and bat populations in the NGP remains understudied. This is troubling considering \u003E2,200 wind turbines are actively generating power in the region and numerous wind energy projects have been proposed for development in the future. Our objectives were to estimate avian and bat fatality rates for wind turbines situated in cropland\u2010 and grassland\u2010dominated landscapes, document species at high risk to direct mortality, and assess the influence of habitat variables on waterfowl mortality at 2 wind farms in the NGP. From 10 March to 7 June 2013\u20132014, we completed 2,398 searches around turbines for carcasses at the Tatanka Wind Farm (TAWF) and the Edgeley\u2010Kulm Wind Farm (EKWF) in South Dakota and North Dakota. During spring, we found 92 turbine\u2010related mortalities comprising 33 species and documented a greater diversity of species (n\u2009=\u200930) killed at TAWF (predominately grassland) than at EKWF (n\u2009=\u20099; predominately agricultural fields). After accounting for detection rates, we estimated spring mortality of 1.86 (SE\u2009=\u20090.22) deaths\/megawatt (MW) at TAWF and 2.55 (SE\u2009=\u20090.51) deaths\/MW at EKWF. Waterfowl spring (Mar\u2013Jun) fatality rates were 0.79 (SE\u2009=\u20090.11) and 0.91 (SE\u2009=\u20090.10) deaths\/MW at TAWF and EKWF, respectively. Our results suggest that future wind facility siting decisions consider avoiding grassland habitats and locate turbines in pre\u2010existing fragmented and converted habitat outside of high densities of breeding waterfowl and major migration corridors.","author":["Jenks, J.","Graff, B.","Stafford, J.","Jensen, K.","Grovenburg, T."],"organization":["South Dakota State University"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.954541000000","-98.981193000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1516","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/indirect-effects-existing-wind-energy-facility-lekking-behavior-greater-prairie","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/eth.12489","title":"Indirect Effects of an Existing Wind Energy Facility on Lekking Behavior of Greater Prairie-Chickens","description":"Rapid expansion of the wind energy industry has raised concerns about the potential effects of anthropogenic disturbance on prairie grouse. While efforts have been made to address the effects of wind energy facilities on measures of fitness, their effect on the behaviors of prairie grouse has been largely neglected. To address these concerns, we investigated the effects of an existing wind energy facility in Nebraska that became operational in 2005 on the lekking behavior of male greater prairie\u2010chickens Tympanuchus cupido pinnatus between March and May 2013. Given the potential for disturbance caused by wind turbine noise to disrupt acoustic communication and thus behavior, we predicted that males at leks close to, compared to far from, the wind energy facility would spend more time in agonistic behaviors, and less in booming displays. Given the potential for wind turbine noise to reduce the number of females attending leks (hereafter \u2018female lek attendance\u2019), we also predicted that males at leks close to the wind energy facility would spend more time in non\u2010breeding behaviors and less time in breeding behaviors than males farther from the facility. Although we found no effect of the wind energy facility on female lek attendance, males at leks closer to the wind energy facility spent less time in non\u2010breeding behaviors than those at leks farther away. However, distance from the wind energy facility had no effect on time spent performing booming displays, flutter jumps, or in agonistic behaviors. Given that lekking behaviors of males influence mating success, our results may have consequences for the fitness of prairie grouse breeding in the vicinity of wind energy facilities.","author":["Smith, J.","Brown, M.","Whalen, C.","Powell, L.","Ebensperger, L."],"organization":["University of Nebraska"],"originationDate":"2016-03-11","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1517","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/avian-interactions-renewable-energy-infrastructure-update","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1650\/CONDOR-15-61.1","title":"Avian interactions with renewable energy infrastructure: An update","description":"Energy infrastructure is widespread worldwide. Renewable energy technologies, which are expanding their footprint on the landscape and their contribution to energy availability, represent a different kind of infrastructure from extractive energy technologies. Although renewable energy sources may offer a \u2018greener alternative\u0027 to traditional extractive energy sources, mounting evidence suggests that renewable energy infrastructure, and the transmission lines needed to convey energy from renewable energy facilities to users, may impact birds. Peer-reviewed literature historically has focused on the direct effects of electrocution and, to a lesser extent, collisions with overhead power systems, and on avian collisions at wind energy facilities, with less consideration of indirect effects or other energy sectors. Here, we review studies that have examined direct and indirect effects on birds at utility-scale onshore wind- and solar-energy facilities, including their associated transmission lines. Although both direct and indirect effects appear site-, species-, and infrastructure-specific, generalities across energy sectors are apparent. For example, large-bodied species with high wing loading and relatively low maneuverability appear to be especially susceptible to direct effects of tall structures, and the risk of collision is likely greater when structures are placed perpendicular to flight paths or in areas of high use. Given that all infrastructure types result in direct loss or fragmentation of habitat and may affect the distribution of predators, indirect effects mediated by these mechanisms may be pervasive across energy facilities. When considered together, the direct and indirect effects of renewable energy facilities, and the transmission lines serving these facilities, are likely cumulative. Ultimately, cross-facility and cross-taxon meta-analyses will be necessary to fully understand the cumulative impacts of energy infrastructure on birds. Siting these facilities in a way that minimizes avian impacts will require an expanded understanding of how birds perceive facilities and the mechanisms underlying direct and indirect effects.","author":["Smith, J.","Dwyer, J."],"organization":["University of Nebraska","EDM International Inc"],"originationDate":"2016-04-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:09:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1518","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wind-farm-installation-understory-bat-community-highly-biodiverse-tropical","sourceURL":"https:\/\/peerj.com\/articles\/3424\/","title":"Effects of a wind farm installation on the understory bat community of a highly biodiverse tropical region in Mexico","description":"Wind energy has rapidly become an important alternative among renewable energies, and it is generally considered clean. However, little is known about its impact at the level of ecological communities, especially in biodiversity hotspots. The Isthmus of Tehuantepec is a highly biodiverse region in Mesoamerica, and has the highest potential for generating wind energy in Mexico. To assess the effects of installing a wind farm on the understory bat community in a landscape of fragmented habitat, we assessed its diversity and composition over four stages of installation (site preparation, construction, and two stages of operation). We captured 919 bats belonging to 22 species. Species richness, functional diversity and phylogenetic diversity decreased during construction and the first stage of operation. However, these components of biodiversity increased during the second stage of operation, and species composition began to resemble that of the site preparation stage. No species considered as sensitive to disturbance was recorded at any stage. This is the first study to reveal the diversity of a Neotropical bat community after wind turbines begin to operate.","author":["Briones-Salas, M.","Lavariega, M.","Moreno, C."],"organization":["Instituto Politecnico Nacional","Universidad Autonoma del Estado de Hidalogo"],"originationDate":"2017-06-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["16.500000000000","-94.800000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/brionessalasetal.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/brionessalasetal_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1519","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nest-site-selection-nest-survival-greater-prairie-chickens-near-wind-energy-facility","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1650\/CONDOR-17-51.1","title":"Nest site selection and nest survival of Greater Prairie-Chickens near a wind energy facility","description":"Rapid development of wind energy facilities in the Great Plains of North America has raised concerns regarding their potential negative impact on the nesting ecology of Greater Prairie-Chickens (Tympanuchus cupido pinnatus). We investigated the effects of a pre-existing, 36-turbine wind energy facility on nest site selection and nest survival of Greater Prairie-Chickens in the unfragmented grasslands of the Nebraska Sandhills, USA. In 2013 and 2014, we monitored 91 nests along a 24-km disturbance gradient leading away from the wind energy facility. We found little evidence of an effect of the wind energy facility on Greater Prairie-Chicken nest site selection and nest survival. Instead, we found that the primary drivers of nest site selection and nest survival were related to landscape and habitat factors. Greater Prairie-Chickens avoided nesting near roads, with 74% of Greater Prairie-Chickens selecting nest sites \u0026gt;700 m from roads. Greater Prairie-Chickens selected nest sites with more than twice the visual obstruction and residual standing dead vegetation of random points. Our results suggest that small wind energy facilities, such as the facility in our study, may have little effect on Greater Prairie-Chicken nest site selection and nest survival. We suggest that livestock grazing and other grassland management practices still have the most important regional effects on Great Prairie-Chickens, but we caution future planners of wind energy facilities to account for the potential negative effect of roads on nest site selection.","author":["Smith, J.","Brown, M.","Harrison, J.","Powell, L.","Schacht, W."],"organization":["University of Nebraska","Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University"],"originationDate":"2017-08-09","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1520","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/grassland-bird-community-acoustic-complexity-appear-unaffected-proximity-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/condor\/article\/119\/3\/484\/5152922?searchresult=1","title":"Grassland bird community and acoustic complexity appear unaffected by proximity to a wind energy facility in the Nebraska Sandhills","description":"The placement of wind energy facilities on the landscape is a potential source of direct mortality for wildlife, but indirect effects of wind facilities on natural communities are less well known. An anthropogenically altered acoustic environment may render habitat unsuitable for species that use vocalizations to communicate. We listened to sound recordings to identify the species assemblage of common breeding birds in an unfragmented grassland in the Nebraska Sandhills (USA) in the vicinity of a wind energy facility. From the recordings, we calculated the Acoustic Complexity Index (ACI), which we used to assess differences in the avian community between a reference area (\u003E760 m from any turbines) and a treatment area (","author":["Brown, M.","Whalen, C.","Powell, L.","Raynor, E."],"organization":["University of Nebraska"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.457100000000","-99.914200000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1521","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predation-risk-potential-mechanism-effects-wind-energy-facility-greater-prairie","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ecs2.1835","title":"Predation risk: a potential mechanism for effects of a wind energy facility on Greater Prairie-Chicken survival","description":"Recent expansion of the wind energy industry has raised concerns about the potential effects of wind energy facilities on prairie grouse. For example, efforts have been made to evaluate indirect effects on prairie grouse survival, but it is also critical to investigate the underlying mechanisms to direct conservation strategies. The objective of this study was to investigate the indirect effects of a wind energy facility on the survival of female Greater Prairie-Chickens (Tympanuchus cupido pinnatus) and on the occupancy of avian and mammalian predators. Between March and July of 2013 and 2014, we investigated spatial variation in predation risk by sampling occupancy of mammalian and avian predators within 10 km of a wind energy facility constructed in 2005 in Brown County, Nebraska, USA. During the same period, we assessed spatial variation in daily survival of radio-marked females within the same area. We found little evidence that probability of site occupancy (\u03a8) of avian predators was lower near the wind energy facility (within 2 km: \u03a8 = 0.70, 95% CI = 0.22-0.95; beyond 2 km: \u03a8 = 0.93, 95% CI = 0.02-1.00), suggesting that avian predators did not display local-scale avoidance behavior around wind turbines. Mammalian predators were documented at all of our sample locations, but the capture index for all mammals was lower at sample sites near the wind turbines (P = 0.004). Occupancy of coyotes (Canis latrans), the likely main mammalian predator of adult prairie-chickens in the area, did not vary significantly throughout our study site (within 0.5 km of wind energy facility: \u03a8 = 0.65, 95% CI = 0.07-0.98; beyond 0.5 km: \u03a8 = 0.96, 95% CI = 0.04-1.00), although trends were in the direction expected if coyotes were avoiding the wind energy facility. Distance to wind turbine had no effect on daily survival (SD) of female prairie-chickens (SD = 0.9948, SE = 0.0015). The potential for predators to avoid wind energy facilities, and thus affect predation risk, underscores the complexity of planning to address potential impacts of wind energy as variation in predation risk may have consequences for the population viability of a wide range of species at risk from wind energy development.","author":["Smith, J.","Brown, M.","Harrison, J.","Powell, L."],"organization":["University of Nebraska"],"originationDate":"2017-06-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.455000000000","-99.915000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1522","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-american-golden-plovers-pluvialis-dominica-avoid-wind-energy-turbines-agricultural","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wjoonline.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1676\/15-134.1","title":"Do American Golden-Plovers (Pluvialis dominica) Avoid Wind-energy Turbines in Agricultural Fields in Indiana During Spring Migration?","description":"The American Golden-Plover (Pluvialis dominica), a species of conservation concern, uses large agricultural fields during its spring passage through the mid-western United States. In west-central Indiana, large numbers of golden-plovers make a stopover in corn or soybean fields that were harvested the previous fall. Stopovers last for a number of days during which the birds feed and molt into alternate plumage. In recent years, wind energy facilities have been developed in the area with hundreds of wind turbines erected in fields used by the golden-plovers. During spring 2011 and 2012, we investigated patterns of golden-plover behavior at these facilities in Benton County, Indiana at a site where large spring aggregations of plovers have been observed for many years. Our results showed only limited behavioral avoidance of the turbines, and suggested that wind-energy development in this area was not significantly impacting migrant golden-plovers. However, we caution that additional studies could negate these somewhat tentative findings, and we urge that further evaluation precede possible expansion of wind energy development in the region.","author":["Moore, J.","Homoya, W.","Ruhl, P.","Dunning, J."],"organization":["Purdue University","US Department of Agriculture (USDA)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.604778000000","-87.304058000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Shorebirds","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1523","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/long-term-effect-tidal-hydroelectric-propeller-turbine-populations-three-anadromous","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/jfb.13755","title":"Long-term effect of a tidal, hydroelectric propeller turbine on the populations of three anadromous fish species","description":"Tidal hydroelectric power has been proposed as one potential solution for sustainable energy sources. The first tidal turbine in North America began continuous operation in the Annapolis River estuary (44 degrees 45\u0027N; 65 degrees 29\u0027W) in June, 1985. The machine is an axial-flow, hydraulic-lift propeller turbine, a type known to cause fish mortality. Anadromous populations of American shad Alosa sapidissima, striped bass Morone saxatilis and Atlantic sturgeon Acipenser oxyrinchus utilize the Annapolis River for spawning and other life history phases. After power generation commenced obvious turbine mortalities of these fishes began appearing downstream of the turbine. Assessments of the A. sapidissima adult spawning runs during 1981-1982 (pre-operation) and 1989-1996 (operational) indicated significant changes in population characteristics after power generation began. Adult length, mass, age and per cent repeat spawners declined and total instantaneous mortality (Z) increased from 0.30 to 0.55. The pre-turbine spawning runs had older fish with numerous adult cohorts whereas by 12 years after operation began runs consisted of younger fish with fewer adult cohorts. During 1972-1987 numerous studies indicated the Annapolis River had an important angling fishery for M. saxatilis, but detailed annual records kept by a fishing contest during 1983-1987 and an elite angler family during the period 1976-2008 demonstrated a rapid decline in the number of fish \u003E4.0 kg after turbine operation began. Pre-turbine catch by the angling family of fish \u003E4.0 kg accounted for 84.1% of total catch, but declined significantly to 39.6% of total catch from 1986-1999, and to none from 2000-2008. The existence of an A. oxyrinchus stock in the Annapolis River was unknown before turbine operation, but during 1985-2017, 21 mortalities were recovered by chance seaward of the turbine. Mechanical strike and cavitation mortalities consisted of juveniles, mature males and gravid and spent females of ages 10 to 53 years found during June to October, the period when this anadromous species returns to its natal river to spawn. The results of the long-term studies at Annapolis indicate managers should realize substantial risks exist for the fish resources of the world\u0027s oceans from deployment of instream propeller turbines.","author":["Dadswell, M.","Rulifson, R.","Spares, A.","McIean, M.","Harris, P."],"organization":["Acadia University","East Carolina University"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.750000000000","-65.483330000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1524","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/flatfish-habitat-use-near-north-americas-first-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1385110117303271","title":"Flatfish habitat use near North America\u0027s first offshore wind farm","description":"Use of offshore wind power as a renewable energy source is underway in North America with the construction of the pilot, five wind turbine, Block Island Wind Farm, off Rhode Island, USA. Demersal trawl monitoring was conducted in two reference areas and near the wind farm that allowed an examination of whether flatfish abundances, size, and condition differed between baseline, construction, and operation time periods. Seven flatfish, (American plaice Hippoglossoides platessoides, fourspot flounder Paralichthys oblongus, Gulf stream flounder Citharichthys arctifrons, summer flounder Paralichthys dentatus, windowpane flounder Scophthalmus aquosus, winter flounder Pseudopleuronectes americanus, and yellowtail flounder Pleuronectes ferruginea) were collected in the study area. Winter flounder, windowpane and fourspot flounder accounted for 83% of all flatfish collected. Flatfish exhibited spatial and temporal variation in abundance, size, and condition, but this variation was not consistent with either positive or negative effects of wind farm construction or operation. Lower winter flounder abundances during the pile-driving time period and higher abundances during the cable-laying time period in the reference and wind farm areas suggest regionwide population fluctuations occurred. Although noise from pile driving may have been detectable in the reference areas, other flatfish abundances were not lower during this time period. Although no artificial reef effect was found for flatfish, negative impacts from construction activity and wind farm operation also were not evident.","author":["Wilber, D.","Carey, D.","Griffin, M."],"organization":["INSPIRE Environmental"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.083300000000","-71.500000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1525","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/creation-microhabitats-tidepools-ripraps-climax-communities-way-mitigate-negative","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0925857418302362","title":"Creation of microhabitats (tidepools) in ripraps with climax communities as a way to mitigate negative effects of artificial substrate on marine biodiversity","description":"Urbanisation and the construction of commercial structures on coasts cause a significant impact on natural marine habitats. The concept of \u00a8Ecological Engineering\u00a8, recently applied to marine biology, integrates ecology, economy and society\u2019s needs into the design of artificial marine structures. Recently, some ecological designs, such as the addition of pools, pits, and crevices, have been proposed in order to reduce habitat modification, diminish colonization by invasive species, and spread and maintain ecosystem functioning and biodiversity indexes that are more similar to those of the natural environment. Within the features that may increase artificial habitats\u2019 diversity, tidepools are unique habitats that reduce stress in the intertidal, favouring breeding and feeding, as well as providing shelter and a greater degree of moisture to a certain group of species, which may present an advantage for them. Nevertheless, the ecological benefits that arise from the inclusion of these features on fully mature artificial structures are still poorly known. In the present study, tidepools were created on artificial substrate with an affordable method (jackhammer) in the locality of Ceuta (Strait of Gibraltar). The pools were carved on dolomitic riprap at two different intertidal levels, high and low shore (+0.75\u202fm and +0.25\u202fm higher than the lowest tide, respectively) with an average area of 195.2\u202fcm2\u00a0and 353.01\u202fcm3\u00a0of volume. These coastal defence structures were built more than eight years ago, thus the biota has substantially completed its colonization period and is set in terms of species composition. To test humidity effects on benthic assemblages around tidepools, the adjacent halo around the pool, with a width of 5\u202fcm, was equally traced. Pool assemblages were compared to adjacent artificial and natural substrate and also to nearby natural pools. One year later, the results in species richness and diversity were significantly higher in the tidepools than the other two studied treatments (5\u202fcm and control), artificial pools exceeded control species richness by 39.21% and control diversity by 30.70%. Focusing on the tidepool halo (5\u202fcm) effect in the artificial substrate, the results show that the biological assemblages were different than tidepool and emerged rock, indicating that the newly created habitat extends its influence beyond the limits of the tidepools. Tidepools increased the number of species on ripraps and contributed to reduced fragmentation of some vagile species\u2019 populations, as they favoured settlement of species that previously seemed excluded from artificial substrate such as\u00a0Pisania striata, Fisurella\u00a0sp., Phorcus turbinatus\u00a0and\u00a0Lepidochitona\u00a0sp. In the case of\u00a0Siphonaria pectinata,\u00a0it increased its presence in the tidepools and most of its egg masses were observed inside the pools. Finally, it should be mentioned that the pools have extended the upper vertical limits of infra-littoral level species such as\u00a0Paracentrotus\u00a0sp.,\u00a0mostly young individuals, and\u00a0Aiptasia\u00a0sp. These results may help to modify existing artificial shores to reduce their ecological impact.","author":["Ostale-Valriberas, E.","Sempere-Valverde, J.","Coppa, S.","Garcia-Gomez, J.","Espinosa, F."],"organization":["University of Seville","National Research Council of Italy (CNR)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.887002000000","-5.318533000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1526","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/linking-ecosystem-services-epibenthic-biodiversity-change-following-installation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1462901118304556","title":"Linking ecosystem services with epibenthic biodiversity change following installation of offshore wind farms","description":"The growing awareness of climate change and the recognised need to secure energy production has been a driving force behind the expansion of the offshore wind industry across the world. Benefits from offshore wind farms (OWFs) may extend further than low CO2 energy production. Wind turbine substructures introduce hard surfaces that are rapidly colonised by epibenthic marine organisms, altering biomass and biodiversity within the local ecosystem. Biodiversity plays a critical role in supporting ecosystem processes and functions that maintain ecosystem services. As offshore wind development continues to grow and modify marine habitats, changes in biodiversity could affect the provision of ecosystem services. In this context, this review sets out to capture the current understanding of epibenthic biodiversity change following the installation of OWFs and attempt to link these changes in biodiversity with marine ecosystem services through the associated processes and functions.","author":["Gill, A.","Causon, P."],"organization":["Cranfield University","PANGALIA Environmental"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1527","type":["Document","Document\/Guidance"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/eagle-conservation-plan-guidance-module-1-land-based-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.federalregister.gov\/documents\/2013\/05\/02\/2013-10387\/migratory-birds-eagle-conservation-plan-guidance-module-1-land-based-wind-energy-version-2","title":"Eagle Conservation Plan Guidance: Module 1 Land-based Wind Energy","description":"Of all America\u2019s wildlife, eagles hold perhaps the most revered place in our national history and culture. The United States has long imposed special protections for its bald and golden eagle populations. Now, as the nation seeks to increase its production of domestic energy, wind energy developers and wildlife agencies have recognized a need for specific guidance to help make wind energy facilities compatible with eagle conservation and the laws and regulations that protect eagles.  To meet this need, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service) has developed the Eagle Conservation Plan Guidance (ECPG). This document provides specific in\u2010depth guidance for conserving bald and golden eagles in the course of siting, constructing, and operating wind energy facilities. The ECPG guidance supplements the Service\u2019s Land\u2010Based Wind Energy Guidelines (WEG). WEG provides a broad overview of wildlife considerations for siting and operating wind energy facilities, but does not address the in\u2010depth guidance needed for the specific legal protections afforded to bald and golden eagles.  The ECPG fills this gap. Like the WEG, the ECPG calls for wind project developers to take a staged approach to siting new projects. Both call for preliminary landscape\u2010level assessments to assess potential wildlife interactions and proceed to site\u2010specific surveys and risk assessments prior to construction. They also call for monitoring project operations and reporting eagle fatalities to the Service and state and tribal wildlife agencies.  Compliance with the ECPG is voluntary, but the Service believes that following the guidance will help project operators in complying with regulatory requirements and avoiding the unintentional \u201ctake\u201d of eagles at wind energy facilities, and will also assist the wind energy industry in providing the biological data needed to support permit applications for facilities that may pose a risk to eagles.","author":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2013-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/usfws.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1528","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-commercial-ready-technology-raptor-detection-deterrence-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/awwi.org\/resources\/dtbird-technical-report\/","title":"Evaluating a Commercial-Ready Technology for Raptor Detection and Deterrence at a Wind Energy Facility in California","description":"Bird collisions with anthropogenic objects are well documented in the literature, including those involving wind turbines. The purpose of this study was to evaluate and help improve the effectiveness of an automated detection and deterrent system designed to minimize the risk of raptors colliding with wind turbines. We evaluated the DTBird\u00ae system (Liquen Consultor\u00eda Ambiental, S.L., Madrid, Spain), which is designed to detect and deter raptors flying near and in the risk zone of wind turbines. The DTBird system includes a camera\/video-based detection module that detects and tracks objects based on settings calibrated for birds with specific wingspans, and a collision-avoidance or deterrence module that emits sounds designed to discourage birds from proceeding into the collision risk zone of an operational turbine. The deterrence module first emits an audible warning signal when the surveillance system estimates that a detected flying object (whether a bird or an inanimate object) has crossed a calibrated distance threshold. If the surveillance system estimates that the tracked object crosses a second, closer distance threshold, then it emits a stronger dissuasion signal intended to scare the bird away from the signal noise and turbine.  The ultimate goal of the study was to quantify the effectiveness of the DTBird system as a measure to reduce collision risk for golden eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) and other large raptors. If found to be effective, and if accepted by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), the DTBird system or other risk-reduction technologies could be considered for use by commercial wind energy facilities in eagle conservation plans as a Best Management Practice (BMP) under the Eagle Rule, a minimization measure for take permits or habitat conservation plans, or as an adaptive management measure in a Bird and Bat Conservation Strategy. Determining whether DTBird is suitable for use in eagle conservation plans or other minimization measures was beyond the scope of this study.  As the first in-depth study of DTBird with raptors in the United States, this study estimated detection and deterrence of eagles and buteos, and identified several important limitations of the technology and the study design for evaluating detection and deterrence of the target raptor species. Limitations included a large number of false-positive detections (i.e., detections that were not large raptors), unclear deterrent responses from in situ eagles and other raptors, potential bias from use of eagle-like unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) as surrogates for live eagles, and detection degradation from sun glare, clouds, and visual clutter. These limitations suggest future studies that could build on our initial findings.  The study was hosted by the Manzana Wind Power Project, which is owned and operated by Avangrid Renewables and located in Kern County, California. Over the course of a 9-month study period from December 2016 through August 2017, we used fixed-wing UAVs as surrogates for live eagles in experimental flight trials to evaluate the performance of the DTBird detection and deterrent-triggering systems installed at this facility. The UAVs used for the study were similar in size and painted to resemble a golden eagle, and carried onboard avionics that provided high temporal and spatial resolution Geographic Positioning System (GPS) tracking data. We also evaluated the effectiveness of the DTBird deterrence module by examining the behavioral responses of in situ raptors evident in videos recorded by the seven DTBird systems installed at the facility. We derived estimates of the probability of detection from the UAV flight trials as a surrogate for live eagles and estimates of the probability of deterrence from classifying the responses of in situ raptors. We then estimated the probability of collision-risk reduction from deploying DTBird as the cross-products of the estimated probabilities of detection and deterrence.","author":["Terrill, S.","Smith, J.","Howell, J.","Lindke, K.","Zirpoli, J.","Wolf, K.","Watt, S."],"organization":["H.T. Harvey \u0026 Associates","American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2026-05-30 01:02:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1529","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/habitat-use-migratory-bats-killed-during-autumn-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1890\/15-0671","title":"Habitat use of migratory bats killed during autumn at wind turbines","description":"The killing of large numbers of migratory bats at wind turbines is a pressing conservation problem. Even though avoidance and mitigation measures could benefit from a better knowledge of the species\u2019 migratory habits, we lack basic information about what habitats and corridors bats use during migration. We studied the isotopic niche dimensions of three bat species that are frequently killed at wind turbines in Germany: non\u2010migratory\u00a0Pipistrellus pipistrellus, mid\u2010distance migratory\u00a0Nyctalus noctula, and long\u2010distance migratory\u00a0Pipistrellus nathusii. We measured stable carbon and nitrogen isotope ratios (\u03b413C, \u03b415N) in five tissues that differed in isotopic retention time (fur, wing membrane tissue, muscle, liver, blood) to shed light on the species\u2010specific habitat use during the autumn migration period using standard ellipse areas (SEAc). Further, we used stable isotope ratios of non\u2010exchangeable hydrogen (\u03b42HK) in fur keratin to assess the breeding origin of bats. We inferred from isotopic composition (\u03b413C, \u03b415N) of fur keratin that isotopic niche dimensions of\u00a0P.\u00a0nathusii\u00a0was distinct from that of\u00a0N. noctula\u00a0and\u00a0P.\u00a0pipistrellus, probably because\u00a0P.\u00a0nathusii\u00a0was using more aquatic habitats than the other two species. Isoscape origin models supported that traveled distances before dying at wind turbines was largest for\u00a0P.\u00a0nathusii, intermediate for\u00a0N.\u00a0noctula, and shortest for\u00a0P.\u00a0pipistrellus. Isotopic niche dimensions calculated for each sample type separately reflected the species\u2019 migratory behavior.\u00a0Pipistrellus pipistrellus\u00a0and\u00a0N.\u00a0noctula\u00a0showed similar isotopic niche breadth across all tissue types, whereas SEAc\u00a0values of\u00a0P.\u00a0nathusiiincreased in tissues with slow turnaround time. Isotopic data suggested that\u00a0P.\u00a0nathusiiconsistently used aquatic habitats throughout the autumn period, whereas\u00a0N.\u00a0noctulashowed a stronger association with terrestrial habitats during autumn compared to the pre\u2010migration period.","author":["Kramer-Schadt, S.","Schonborn, S.","Lindecke, O.","Voigt, C.","Lehmann, D."],"organization":["Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","Martin Luther University Halle-Wittenberg"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1530","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wind-energy-generation-white-nose-syndrome-viability-indiana-bat","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/pmc\/articles\/PMC5183089\/","title":"Effects of wind energy generation and white-nose syndrome on the viability of the Indiana bat","description":"Wind energy generation holds the potential to adversely affect wildlife populations. Species-wide effects are difficult to study and few, if any, studies examine effects of wind energy generation on any species across its entire range. One species that may be affected by wind energy generation is the endangered Indiana bat (Myotis sodalis), which is found in the eastern and midwestern United States. In addition to mortality from wind energy generation, the species also faces range-wide threats from the emerging infectious fungal disease, white-nose syndrome (WNS). White-nose syndrome, caused by Pseudogymnoascus destructans, disturbs hibernating bats leading to high levels of mortality. We used a spatially explicit full-annual-cycle model to investigate how wind turbine mortality and WNS may singly and then together affect population dynamics of this species. In the simulation, wind turbine mortality impacted the metapopulation dynamics of the species by causing extirpation of some of the smaller winter colonies. In general, effects of wind turbines were localized and focused on specific spatial subpopulations. Conversely, WNS had a depressive effect on the species across its range. Wind turbine mortality interacted with WNS and together these stressors had a larger impact than would be expected from either alone, principally because these stressors together act to reduce species abundance across the spectrum of population sizes. Our findings illustrate the importance of not only prioritizing the protection of large winter colonies as is currently done, but also of protecting metapopulation dynamics and migratory connectivity.","author":["Thogmartin, W.","Diffendorfer, J.","Erickson, R.","Szymanski, J.","Russell, R."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1531","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-migratory-corridors-white-storks-ciconia-ciconia-enhance-sustainable-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2071-1050\/10\/5\/1470","title":"Predicting Migratory Corridors of White Storks, Ciconia ciconia, to Enhance Sustainable Wind Energy Planning: A Data-Driven Agent-Based Model","description":"White storks (Ciconia ciconia) are birds that make annual long-distance migration flights from their breeding grounds in the Northern Hemisphere to the south of Africa. These trips take place in the winter season, when the temperatures in the North fall and food supply drops. White storks, because of their large size, depend on the wind, thermals, and orographic characteristics of the environment in order to minimize their energy expenditure during flight. In particular, the birds adopt a soaring behavior in landscapes where the thermal uplift and orographic updrafts are conducive. By attaining suitable soaring heights, the birds then use the wind characteristics to glide for hundreds of kilometers. It is therefore expected that white storks would prefer landscapes that are characterized by suitable wind and thermal characteristics, which promote the soaring and gliding behaviors. However, these same landscapes are also potential sites for large-scale wind energy generation. In this study, we used the observed data of the white stork movement trajectories to specify a data-driven agent-based model, which simulates flight behavior of the white storks in a dynamic environment. The data on the wind characteristics and thermal uplift are dynamically changed on a daily basis so as to mimic the scenarios that the observed birds experienced during flight. The flight corridors that emerge from the simulated flights are then combined with the predicted surface on the wind energy potential, in order to highlight the potential risk of collision between the migratory white storks and hypothetical wind farms in the locations that are suitable for wind energy developments. This work provides methods that can be adopted to assess the overlap between wind energy potential and migratory corridors of the migration of birds. This can contribute to achieving sustainable trade-offs between wind energy development and conservation of wildlife and, hence, handling the issues of human\u2013wildlife conflicts.","author":["Oloo, F.","Safi, K.","Aryal, J."],"organization":["University of Salzburg","Max Planck Institute for Ornithology","University of Tasmania"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1532","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/awwi-white-paper-integration-wildlife-detection-deterrent-systems-wind-power-plants","sourceURL":"https:\/\/awwi.org\/resources\/technology-integration-white-paper\/","title":"AWWI White Paper: Integration of Wildlife Detection and Deterrent Systems in Wind Power Plants","description":"Currently there is significant focus on developing technologies for detecting and deterring wildlife around wind power plants. For these technologies to become long term commercial successes, they have to be effectively integrated into wind power plants and the functionality must align with the workflows in the plant\u2019s local and remote control rooms. If the integration of detection and deterrent systems is difficult and thus costly, this may delay the deployment on a large scale, prolong the risk to the species that need protection, and in the end result in increased leveled cost of energy as well as increased cost of service to the energy consumer.  By sharing technical details and considerations among stakeholders, the hope that the process of integrating all these technologies into effectively operating wind power plants can be streamlined, and also that the end user will have a better experience using the new technologies as an integrated part of the plant control strategy.\u00a0","author":["Nielsen, K."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-12-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-05-30 01:02:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1533","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/auditory-attributes-golden-eagles-do-golden-aquila-chrysaetos-bald-eagles-haliaeetus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1121\/1.5067726","title":"The auditory attributes of Golden Eagles: Do Golden (Aquila chrysaetos) and Bald Eagles (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) share the same auditory space?","description":"According to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (2018), fatalities associated with wind turbine collisions have been reported for more than 200 bird species. Furthermore, based on statistical models of industry growth it has been suggested that as many as 1.4 million bird fatalities\/year could be realized if the Department of Energy (DOE) wind energy goals are achieved; i.e., wind energy supplying 20% of total U.S. energy needs by 2030. Although passerine bird fatalities are most commonly reported, raptors that hunt by day, including bald and golden eagles, are the second most frequent casualties of turbine collisions. To address this concern, deterrence protocols designed to discourage eagles from encroaching into wind energy facility air spaces and thereby constrain the degree of risk to which birds are exposed are under investigation. As part of an effort to guide development of acoustic deterrence protocols, we report that the responsive frequency range of golden eagles is similar to that reported for bald eagles; upper and lower frequency limits of hearing are approximately 6.0 and 0.3 kHz, respectively. Suprathreshold response profiles measured in golden eagles exhibit standard features that will be compared with those of bald eagles.\u00a0","author":["Nelson, P.","McGee, J.","Walsh, E.","Ponder, J.","Milliren, C.","Feist, C.","Marr, J.","Redig, P."],"organization":["University of Minnesota"],"originationDate":"2018-10-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1534","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/whooping-crane-sandhill-crane-monitoring-five-wind-energy-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.west-inc.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2018\/12\/Derby-et-al.-2018.-Whooping-crane-and-sandhill-crane-monitoring-at-five-wind-energy-faciities.pdf","title":"Whooping Crane and Sandhill Crane Monitoring at Five Wind Energy Facilities","description":"Biologists have expressed concern that individuals of the Aransas-Wood Buffalo Population of the federallyendangered whooping crane (Grus americana), numbering about 300, may be injured or killed by wind turbines during migration. To help address this concern and curtail (stop) turbine operations when whooping cranes approached turbines, we monitored the area around 5 wind energy facilities in North and South Dakota during spring and fall migration for whooping cranes and sandhill cranes (G. canadensis). Observers monitored cranes for 3 years at each facility from 2009 to 2013 (1,305 total days of monitoring), recording 14 unique observations for a total of 45 whooping cranes for which curtailment occurred during portions of 9 days. Observers also searched for dead cranes at the base of every turbine each day of monitoring. This resulted in approximately 92,022 cumulative individual inspections, during which no dead or injured cranes were detected. Based on our results and monitoring efforts at other wind energy facilities in the migration corridor, no whooping crane fatalities have been documented. Although migrating cranes use areas near turbines, they do not appear to be overly susceptible to collisions with wind turbines.","author":["Derby, C.","Thorn, T.","Welsch, M."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Shorebirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1535","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-state-occupancy-models-foraging-habitat-use-hawaiian-hoary-bat-lasiurus-cinereus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0205150","title":"Multi-state occupancy models of foraging habitat use by the Hawaiian hoary bat (Lasiurus cinereus semotus)","description":"Multi-state occupancy modeling can often improve assessments of habitat use and site quality when animal activity or behavior data are available. We examine the use of the approach for evaluating foraging habitat suitability of the endangered Hawaiian hoary bat (Lasiurus cinereus semotus) from classifications of site occupancy based on flight activity levels and feeding behavior. In addition, we used data from separate visual and auditory sources, namely thermal videography and acoustic (echolocation) detectors, jointly deployed at sample sites to compare the effectiveness of each method in the context of occupancy modeling. Video-derived observations demonstrated higher and more accurate estimates of the prevalence of high bat flight activity and feeding events than acoustic sampling methods. Elevated levels of acoustic activity by Hawaiian hoary bats were found to be related primarily to beetle biomass in this study. The approach may have a variety of applications in bat research, including inference about species-resource relationships, habitat quality and the extent to which species intensively use areas for activities such as foraging.","author":["Gorresen, P.","Bonaccorso, F.","Montoya-Aiona, K.","Brinck, K.","DeLisle, M.","Pinzari, C."],"organization":["University of Hawaii","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2018-10-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["21.605830000000","-158.037200000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1536","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/echolocation-activity-migratory-bats-wind-energy-facility-testing-feeding-attraction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/jmammal\/article-abstract\/99\/6\/1472\/5183277","title":"Echolocation activity of migratory bats at a wind energy facility: testing the feeding-attraction hypothesis to explain fatalities","description":"As development of wind energy facilities continues, questions of why fatalities of migrating insectivorous bats occur at turbines still remain. Numerous hypotheses have been proposed, including a feeding-attraction hypothesis that suggests bats may be attracted to insects congregating near turbine nacelles. To test this hypothesis, we analyzed echolocation calls of hoary (Lasiurus cinereus) and silver-haired (Lasionycteris noctivagans) bats recorded over 72 nights at a wind energy facility in Southern Alberta, Canada. We recorded calls at 3 heights: 67 m at turbine nacelles, 30 m at meteorological towers, and ground level at turbines and meteorological towers. We used feeding buzzes as indicators of foraging behavior. We compared the occurrence of feeding buzzes across heights, and between turbines and meteorological towers to test the prediction that if bats are attracted to turbines for foraging, there will be a greater proportion of feeding buzzes at turbines, and in particular, at nacelle height. We found no significant evidence that foraging rates were higher at nacelle height compared to 30 m or ground level, or between turbines and meteorological towers for either species. For silver-haired bats, foraging activity was greater at meteorological towers, and in particular, at 30 m height. These results do not support the feeding-attraction hypothesis for silver-haired or hoary bats, and suggest that while some bats forage in the vicinity of wind turbines, they are not specifically attracted to turbines to feed.","author":["Baerwald, E.","Reimer, J.","Barlay, R."],"organization":["University of Alaska Anchorage","University of Calgary"],"originationDate":"2018-12-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1537","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/resource-availability-may-not-be-useful-predictor-migratory-bat-fatalities-or-activity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1424-2818\/10\/2\/44","title":"Resource Availability May Not Be a Useful Predictor of Migratory Bat Fatalities or Activity at Wind Turbines","description":"A better understanding of the ultimate mechanisms driving bat fatalities at wind turbines (i.e., the reason why bats are coming in close proximity to wind turbines) could inform more effective impact reduction strategies. One hypothesis is that bats come into close proximity to turbines due to existing resources (e.g., roosting sites) in the immediate area. Thus, if resource hotspots for bats could be identified in areas proposed for wind energy development, then fatalities could be reduced by siting turbines away from such hotspots. To explore this, we conducted a resource mapping exercise at a 48 km2 wind energy facility in north-central Texas. We mapped known resources (such as water sources, roosting sites, foraging sites, and commuting routes) for the 6 bat species present and compared resource availability with observed fatalities and acoustic activity. Although resource mapping identified concentrations of known resources for all species, it did not predict bat activity or fatalities. For example, Lasiurus cinereus and Lasiurus borealis comprised \u0026gt;90% of the fatalities, yet we found no positive relationship between resource availability and fatalities or acoustic activity for either species. Furthermore, up to 33% of these fatalities occurred at turbines without known resources within 200 m of the turbines, demonstrating that the fine-scale distribution of resources may not effectively inform turbine siting for these two migratory species. The challenge, therefore, remains to determine why bats during the migratory season are coming in close proximity with wind turbines.","author":["Bennett, V.","Hale, A."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.731540000000","-97.405050000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1538","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-flight-height-monitored-wind-masts-predicts-mortality-risk-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S000632071730229X","title":"Bat flight height monitored from wind masts predicts mortality risk at wind farms","description":"Bat fatalities by collision or barotrauma at wind farms currently raise high conservation concerns. In many countries, pre-installation acoustic surveys are mandatory in order to assess the impacts of wind farm projects. In this purpose, the use of wind masts to estimate bat activity and hence predict collision risk is highly recommended by conservation committees worldwide. Yet, the degree to which collisions may be predicted from acoustic monitoring at wind masts has been strongly debated. To assess this relationship, microphone arrays were installed on 23 wind masts in order to record and locate bat activity on the vertical axis during 3260 nights. For each species, we also calculated a collision susceptibility index, based on fatality data gathered in the literature and corrected for species abundance. We demonstrate that the collision susceptibility index is correlated with the percentage of bat passes at blade height. The acoustic recordings allowed us to establish a reference for the ratios of flight activity above heights of 20\u201345 m high for more than 16 European bat species. The correlation we demonstrate here between the percentage of bat passes at height \u2013 recorded from acoustic surveys on wind masts \u2013 and bat fatalities strongly supports that activity estimates from wind masts are appropriate for wind turbine impact assessments.","author":["Bas, Y.","Roemer, C.","Disca, T.","Coulon, A."],"organization":["French National Museum of Natural History (MNHN)","Biotope","Montpellier 1 University"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1539","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/inconspicuous-echolocation-hoary-bats-lasiurus-cinereus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/royalsocietypublishing.org\/doi\/full\/10.1098\/rspb.2018.0441","title":"Inconspicuous echolocation in hoary bats (Lasiurus cinereus)","description":"Echolocation allows bats to occupy diverse nocturnal niches. Bats almost always use echolocation, even when other sensory stimuli are available to guide navigation. Here, using arrays of calibrated infrared cameras and ultrasonic microphones, we demonstrate that hoary bats (Lasiurus cinereus) use previously unknown echolocation behaviours that challenge our current understanding of echolocation. We describe a novel call type (\u2018micro\u2019 calls) that has three orders of magnitude less sound energy than other bat calls used in open habitats. We also document bats flying close to microphones (less than 3 m) without producing detectable echolocation calls. Acoustic modelling indicates that bats are not producing calls that exceed 70\u201375 dB at 0.1 m, a level that would have little or no known use for a bat flying in the open at speeds exceeding 7 m s\u22121. This indicates that hoary bats sometimes fly without echolocation. We speculate that bats reduce echolocation output to avoid eavesdropping by conspecifics during the mating season. These findings might partly explain why tens of thousands of hoary bats are killed by wind turbines each year. They also challenge the long-standing assumption that bats\u2014model organisms for sensory specialization\u2014are reliant on sonar for nocturnal navigation.","author":["Weller, T.","Corcoran, A."],"organization":["Wake Forest University","US Department of Agriculture (USDA)"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.334152000000","-124.024720000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1540","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/avian-use-surveys-prevailing-winds-wind-project-bon-homme-charles-mix-counties-south","sourceURL":"https:\/\/puc.sd.gov\/commission\/dockets\/electric\/2018\/el18-026\/appendixg.pdf","title":"Avian Use Surveys for the Prevailing Winds Wind Project: Bon Homme and Charles Mix Counties, South Dakota. Year Two Final Report: March 3, 2016 - April 19, 2017","description":"Prevailing Winds, LLC. (Prevailing Winds), has proposed a wind energy facility in Bon Homme and Charles Mix counties, South Dakota, referred to as the Prevailing Winds Wind Project (Project). Prevailing Winds contracted Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) to conduct field surveys developed in coordination with the US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) and South Dakota Game Fish and Parks (SDGFP). Surveys were designed to assess wildlife resources in the Project area and assess risk to sensitive species by addressing the issues posed under Tier 3 of the USFWS Final Land-Based Wind Energy Guidelines. The following document contains results for the general fixed-point bird use surveys and incidental wildlife observations. A summary of all data collected is contained in the document, but the overall body of the report focuses on a smaller group of species \u2013 diurnal raptors, eagles, state\/federally listed species, and South Dakota Sensitive Species (State Species of Concern [SSC] and State Species of Greatest Conservation Need [SGCN]).\n\nThe principal objectives of the fixed-point bird use surveys were to: 1) assess the relative abundance and spatial distribution of species in the Project area during all seasons, and 2) identify and assess the potential risk of adverse impacts to species or groups.","author":["Derby, C.","Agudelo, S.","Thorn, T."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","\u200bPrevailing Wind Park, LLC"],"originationDate":"2018-02-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.115489000000","-98.081853000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WEST_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1541","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-efficient-protocol-monitoring-eagle-fatalities-wind-energy-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0208700","title":"Developing an efficient protocol for monitoring eagle fatalities at wind energy facilities","description":"Researchers typically conduct fatality monitoring to determine a wind energy facility\u2019s direct impacts on wildlife. In the United States, wind energy impacts on eagles have received increased attention in recent years because eagle incidental take permits became available. Permit holders are required to conduct fatality monitoring to evaluate compliance with permitted eagle take. Our objective was to develop an efficient eagle fatality monitoring protocol with a quantifiable detection probability based on a stationary scanning search method. We conducted scanning searches for eagle carcasses at four wind energy facilities. We estimated searcher efficiency of the scanning search method using feathered turkey decoys as eagle carcass surrogates, used publicly available data on large raptor carcass distances from turbines to evaluate the proportion of carcasses expected to occur in searched areas, and estimated carcass persistence rates for game birds and raptors. These three bias adjustments were combined to estimate the overall probability of detection for the scanning search method. We found generally high searcher efficiency for the scanning search method, with 76% of decoys detected; however, detection decreased with distance and difficulty of visibility class. Mean carcass persistence time varied between 28 and 76 days for raptors and between three and nine days for game birds, showing that game birds do not persist as long as raptors. We estimated that 95% of large avian carcasses fall within 100 m of turbine bases, and 99% fall within 150 m. Using these estimates and assuming a 30-day search interval for all facility turbines, we estimated that the probability of detecting a large raptor carcass using the scanning search method at a wind facility ranged from 0.50 to 0.69. Our research suggests a monitoring program that uses scanning searches can be a cost-effective approach for gathering data necessary to meet incidental eagle take permit requirements.","author":["Hallingstad, E.","Rabie, P.","Telander, A.","Roppe, J.","Nagy, L."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Avangrid Renewables"],"originationDate":"2018-12-12","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hallingstadetal.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1542","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/turbine-induced-bird-bat-fatalities-wind-projects-statistical-methods-mortality","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.library.oregonstate.edu\/concern\/graduate_thesis_or_dissertations\/4m90f1916","title":"Turbine Induced Bird and Bat Fatalities at Wind Projects: Statistical Methods for Mortality Estimation Using Road and Pad Carcass Surveys","description":"Turbines at wind projects pose a threat to birds and bats flying at altitudes within the rotor swept area. These animals die from colliding with the turbine blades. Estimating mortality, or the total number of bird or bat fatalities at a wind project, is critical to understanding environmental impacts of wind energy, and potential population effects to at-risk species. Mortality is estimated by conducting carcass surveys, and then adjusting observed counts for carcasses that land outside the searched area, carcasses removed by scavengers, and imperfect detection. The goal of this research is to assess if and when mortality estimation can be achieved by only searching the roads that lead up to turbines and pads beneath turbines (R\u0026P). Accounting for unsearched area, or equivalently estimating the proportion of carcasses that land on R\u0026P, is pivotal to the success of mortality estimation from R\u0026P searches. Methods based on previously proposed ideas to account for unsearched area are tested and compared using simulations to determine what situations and methods are the most appropriate for mortality estimation based on R\u0026P carcass surveys under different spatial carcass distributions. Results of the simulations are utilized to develop an estimator of mortality based on R\u0026P searches under isotropic carcass distributions. The theoretical properties of the estimator are derived, and utilized for standard error calculation and confidence interval creation. Because optimal methods differ for isotropic and anisotropic spatial carcass distributions, a hypothesis test is needed to determine if it is valid to assume an isotropic distribution.","author":["Maurer, J."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2017-08-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1543","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/conclusions-risk-assessment-conflict-minimisation-practical-recommendations-need","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_16","title":"Conclusions, Risk Assessment, Conflict Minimisation, Practical Recommendations, Need for Further Research","description":"This chapter summarizes the main results of the study and recommends measures to avoid collisions of birds of prey at wind turbines.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["H\u00f6tker, H.","Nehls, G.","Durr, T.","Mammen, U.","Grunkorn, T.","Mammen, K.","Rasran, L.","Krone, O.","Treu, G.","Resetaritz, A.","Grajetzky, B.","Joest, R."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)","BioConsult SH","Soest District Working Group for Nature Conservation (ABU)","Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","\u00d6KOTOP B\u00fcro f\u00fcr Angewandte Landschafts\u00f6kologie"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1544","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/population-development-breeding-success-birds-prey-relation-development-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_15","title":"Population Development and Breeding Success of Birds of Prey in Relation to the Development of Wind Energy Use in Germany","description":"Aim of this sub-study was to investigate possible relations between the construction of wind turbines and the development of populations and breeding success of birds of prey and especially of red kites. Long-term monitoring data for areas with and without wind turbines were compared (data: MEROS,\u00a0https:\/\/www.greifvogelmonitoring.de). For a total of 225 monitoring areas of a size of between 30 and 2000\u00a0km2, data collected between 1991 and 2006 for at least one the following species could be analysed: red and black kite, white-tailed sea eagle, common buzzard, European honey buzzard, Eurasian hobby, common kestrel, Eurasian sparrowhawk, northern goshawk or marsh harrier. Statistical analyses (ANOVA with repeated measures; linear mixed effect models adjusted for maximum likelihood) showed no significant relations between the development of wind energy use and bird of prey populations or breeding success. It was remarkable however that high densities of red kites could only be observed in areas without wind turbines. To date (data as from 2006) wind energy use seems to have no extensive influence on the bird of prey populations in Germany. The spatial distribution of wind turbines within the monitoring areas could not be included in the analyses requiring further research.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Mammen, U.","Rasran, L."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)","\u00d6KOTOP B\u00fcro f\u00fcr Angewandte Landschafts\u00f6kologie"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1545","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/calculation-probability-collision-territorial-birds-prey-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_14","title":"Calculation of the Probability of a Collision of Territorial Birds of Prey with Wind Turbines","description":"To estimate the collision probability of red kites and Montagu\u2019s harriers depending on the distance between wind turbines and nest, the results of telemetric monitoring of these two species were modelled following Band et al. (2007). The basic idea of the Band model is to determine three components: I\u2014the frequency of flights through the rotor swept area of a wind turbine, II\u2014the probability of a collision of the bird with the rotor in these flights and III\u2014the avoidance behaviour of the bird in the immediate vicinity of the rotor. For the latter factor only few reliable data were available and absolute values of the collision risk were therefore subject to a high level of uncertainty. Within a species these values were still comparable. Collision probabilities were calculated for different distances between wind turbines and nest. Several sample turbines could be compared for Montagu\u2019s harriers (small E-40 wind turbines, 500\u00a0kW; medium E-66 wind turbines, 1800\u00a0kW; large V90 wind turbines, 3000\u00a0kW). The results relate to one turbine only per distance class. For the Montagu\u2019s harrier results showed an increased estimated collision risk within a distance of below 300\u00a0m between nest and wind turbine. The absolute collision risk in this close-up area around the nest was largest for small wind turbines and significantly higher than for the two larger wind turbines. For red kites the estimated collision risk was substantially higher than for Montagu\u2019s harriers. For red kite too, the collision risk was highest with wind turbines in the vicinity of the nest. Lower values were reached from a distance of 1250\u00a0m. The results show that a minimum distance kept between wind turbines and red kite nests will considerably reduce the collision risk. This is also true for the Montagu\u2019s harrier with a collision risk mainly occurring in the close-up area of the nest. For this species a standardised distance recommendation will not be practicable, as Montagu\u2019s harriers choose a new nesting site every year. Definition of breeding areas outside the main breeding areas existing in Germany will hardly be possible.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Mammen, U.","Rasran, L.","Grajetzky, B."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)","BioConsult SH","\u00d6KOTOP B\u00fcro f\u00fcr Angewandte Landschafts\u00f6kologie"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1546","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/collision-victims-lattice-towers-frequency-collision-breeding-population-breeding","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_13","title":"Collision Victims and Lattice Towers - Frequency of Collision, Breeding Population and Breeding Success of Birds of Prey in Two Wind Farms in Brandenburg","description":"To determine whether wind turbines with lattice towers will lead to more collisions of birds of prey than wind turbines with tubular towers, two comparable Brandenburg wind farms with lattice and tubular towers were searched for collision victims, correction factors were determined to estimate the number of victims and the behaviour of birds of prey at lattice towers and breeding populations and breeding success in the vicinity of the wind farm were determined. The number of bird of prey fatalities found per wind turbine during the 34\u00a0weeks of the study period (summer half-year) was 0.3 per wind turbine with lattice tower and 0.2 per wind turbine with tubular tower. An estimate of 1.4 birds of prey per wind turbine per year for lattice towers and 3.3 birds of prey per tubular tower was calculated depending on different correction factors influencing the search success. The perching height of birds of prey on lattice towers as well as breeding population and breeding success did not indicate an additional risk for birds of prey caused by wind turbines with lattice towers.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Durr, T.","Rasran, L."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.207475000000","13.562178000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1547","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/collisions-birds-prey-wind-turbines-analysis-circumstances","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_12","title":"Collisions of Birds of Prey with Wind Turbines - Analysis of the Circumstances","description":"We analysed the data of reported avian collisions with wind energy facilities in Germany between 1989 and end of 2008. Species, age and population density of collision victims, technical specifications of wind turbines as well as season, weather conditions, landscape and land use in the surrounding area were taken into account. The influences of these factors on the collision risk were analysed in analyses of variance and by means of multivariate statistics. In relation to their population size in Germany birds of prey such as white-tailed sea eagles and red kite can disproportionately often be found among collision victims. Large turbines with a larger rotor swept area cause higher collision risks than small ones, but the overall collision risk per megawatt generated power is decreasing with increasing turbine size. Landscape structures in the surrounding area as well as land use have a significant influence on the collision risk. Among others, wind turbines surrounded by arable fields were more frequently reported as locations of a collision than wind turbines surrounded by grassland.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Durr, T.","Rasran, L."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1548","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/distances-between-breeding-sites-white-tailed-sea-eagles-found-dead-near-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_10","title":"Distances Between Breeding Sites and White-Tailed Sea Eagles Found Dead Near Wind Turbines in Schleswig-Holstein","description":"In this chapter, distance from breeding site, spatial distribution of birds found dead and location of foraging waters of white-tailed sea eagles is put into context with existing wind turbines in Schleswig-Holstein in northern Germany. A general spatial separation of breeding sites of the white-tailed sea eagle and currently installed wind turbines is obvious. Within a distance of 3\u00a0km around the 67 nest sites of the year 2011, no wind turbines can be found in 51 cases (76%) and within a distance of 6\u00a0km around the nest site, no wind turbine can be found in 22 cases (33%). On the west coast of Schleswig-Holstein with the relatively low number of breeding pairs, only three birds were found dead. In the districts Pl\u00f6n (PL\u00d6) and Ostholstein (OH) the results are clearly different. The highest number of collisions was found in the northern and southern part of Ostholstein (with a high density of wind turbines). This also coincides with the highest densities of white-tailed sea eagle breeding pairs. In the Pl\u00f6n district (with less wind turbines) only one collision victim became known, what can be regarded as a success of the local site planning of wind turbines. There is no indication of an influence of wind turbines on the direction of flight paths. The birds appropriately use the randomly distributed foraging waters within a distance of 12\u00a0km around the breeding site. Apparently, wind farms do not cause large scale evasive movements like flying round or over wind turbines. A reduction of the collision risk can therefore only be achieved by excluding the construction of new wind turbines in the vicinity of known nest sites.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Nehls, G.","Grunkorn, T."],"organization":["BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1549","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-individuals-lost-due-wind-turbines-time-occupying-territory-survival-breeding","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_9","title":"Effects of Individuals Lost Due to Wind Turbines on the Time of Occupying a Territory, the Survival of Breeding Territories and the Breeding Success of White-Tailed Sea Eagles (Case Studies)","description":"By means of case studies, nature and extent of the effects of individuals lost due to wind turbines on establishment and survival of breeding territories and the breeding success of the white-tailed sea eagle are presented. By identifying individual colour rings and collection of moulted feathers, the individual breeding birds and the breeding success (number of fledged young birds) is known for many breeding birds in Schleswig-Holstein. Three of the 26 collision victims in Schleswig-Holstein could be allocated to local breeding pairs. Impacts of individuals lost due to collisions with wind turbines vary in severity between none at all (case 3), one year of delay in establishing a breeding territory (cases 1 and 2) or permanent abandonment of the territory for the time being (case 4). Case studies from Schleswig-Holstein indicate that white-tailed sea eagles are especially prone to collisions in the time of establishing a breeding territory. Between 1993 and 2011, 26 collisions of white-tailed sea eagles were recorded in Schleswig-Holstein. 19 of these birds were ringed. Of the total of 13 collisions, which could be attributed to a breeding site (8 breeding birds, 5 first year birds), seven occurred within the protection zone (radius 3\u00a0km declared by the Working Group of German State Bird Observatories).\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Nehls, G.","Grunkorn, T."],"organization":["BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1550","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behavioural-observations-white-tailed-sea-eagles-vicinity-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_8","title":"Behavioural Observations of White-Tailed Sea Eagles in the Vicinity of Wind Turbines","description":"Aim of this part of the study was to investigate the flight behaviour of white-tailed sea eagles in the vicinity of existing wind farms by means of visual observations to determine especially the collision risk. Attempts were made to observe adult birds flying near wind turbines and to determine flight paths. Despite long watching series no substantial results were achieved. At two breeding sites in Schleswig-Holstein no large-scale avoidance behaviour towards wind farms was observed. Generally, visual observations of untagged birds proved to be unsuitable. Due to the low number of direct behavioural observations (and especially possible avoidance behaviour) in the close-up area of wind turbines, the three known cases of directly observed collisions of white-tailed sea eagles with wind turbines in Mecklenburg Western-Pomerania (Krone and Scharnweber\u00a02003) and Schleswig-Holstein (Projektgruppe Seeadlerschutz Schleswig-Holstein e.V.) are described. White-tailed sea eagles may be distracted by conflicts with crows or birds of prey and probably intraspecific competition preventing proper perception of the danger arising from the rotor. In inter- and intraspecific conflicts, the restricted view of birds described by Martin (2011) might well lead to an increased collision risk.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Nehls, G.","Grunkorn, T.","Treu, G.","Gippert, M."],"organization":["BioConsult SH","Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1551","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/satellite-tracking-white-tailed-sea-eagles-mecklenburg-western-pomerania-brandenburg","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_7","title":"Satellite Tracking of White-Tailed Sea Eagles in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania and Brandenburg","description":"The increase of wind power plants as a German strategy to develop green, renewable energy in order to overcome energy produced by nuclear power and fossil energy sources leads to a substantial collision risk for the white-tailed sea eagle. The aim of our study was to understand how frequently and under which circumstances eagles approach wind turbines in order to assess and minimize the collision risk in the future by means of satellite telemetry and behavioural observations. One territorial adult, two sub-adults and one immature bird have been fitted with satellite transmitters between 2007 and 2010. Additionally telemetry data of three adult birds and another 13 young eagles, which have been tagged for other projects between 2003 and 2010, has been evaluated for the first time in the present research project. In the evaluation no avoidance behaviour of the adult bird towards wind turbines could be identified for the different calculated home ranges by comparing average distances to random distances. The number of locations per km2\u00a0is significantly higher within the wind farm area than in the reference area (cropland without wind turbine). Thus on average, the adult bird returned more locations within the risk area than statistically expected. One of the three tagged eaglets has been recorded within a wind farm during the period of transmission. GPS data as well as visual observations have shown that the young bird repeatedly traversed the wind farm in the vicinity of its nest and showed no fear of the turbines. Although all three tagged young eagles (immature and sub-adult) had very large home ranges and might have crossed a number of wind farms, only one individual approached the risk area of a wind turbine. Among the attractive structures were: kettle holes, ponds, large bodies of water, perching trees on forest edges and local elevations. To estimate a possible collision risk with a wind turbine in the vicinity of the nest, the proportion of locations at a distance of 3000\u00a0m was looked at, a distance which is discussed in the recommendations for distances of wind turbines to important areas for birds by the Working Group of German State Bird Conservancies. The adult white-tailed sea eagle equipped with a satellite transmitter in this study showed only 17.3% of the locations in an area of 3000\u00a0m around the nest. Half (50%) of the localizations occur within a distance of 7486\u00a0m. The analysis of locations of another three territorial white-tailed sea eagles, which was satellite tagged for other studies, resulted in 80% locations in an area of 3000\u00a0m around the nest, 87% locations up to 3000\u00a0m and in one case even 98% of the recorded locations at distances up to 3000\u00a0m around the nest. The mean of all locations at distances from 50\u00a0m and up to 3000\u00a0m around the nest is 71% for all four white-tailed sea eagles. As a large proportion of the recorded locations of tagged adult birds can be found at a distance of 3000\u00a0m around the nest, the probability that the eagles enter the area of a wind turbine decreases significantly with increasing distance. If however, a preferred flight path towards a foraging habitat will be obstructed by a wind turbine, the probability of contact with wind turbines is increasing.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Grunkorn, T.","Krone, O.","Treu, G."],"organization":["Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1552","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-turbines-population-nest-site-selection-montagus-harrier-north-frisia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_6","title":"Impacts of Wind Turbines on the Population and Nest Site Selection of the Montagu\u0027s Harrier in North Frisia","description":"In the following sub-study we looked at the nest site selection of Montagu\u2019s harriers and their behaviour towards wind turbines in North Frisia and compared it to the behaviour of this species in the Hellweg B\u00f6rde (see Chap.\u00a0\u00a05). The study area covers 960\u00a0km2, subdivided into 198\u00a0diked polders, where nest sites of Montagu\u2019s harriers were mapped between 1995 and 2006. For further analyses, the locations of nests were overlaid with the locations and data on the capacity of wind turbines within the same area. Besides known nest sites, we also included a reference group of random points into the data set. Linear mixed models were used to analyse the influence of wind turbines and some further environmental parameters (distance to potential foraging areas in salt marshes) on the nest site selection. In contrast to the Hellweg B\u00f6rde, the number of Montagu\u2019s harriers nests in the area increased slightly over the study period, while the number of wind turbines remained stable with a significantly increasing total capacity due to repowering. Montagu\u2019s harriers in North Frisia showed no clear avoidance behaviour towards wind turbines in the selection of a nest site. The birds in North Frisia often selected areas for breeding and foraging, which were at the same time used as sites for wind turbines. Thus, the collision risk of Montagu\u2019s harriers with wind turbines should not be underestimated (see Chaps. 4 and 14).\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Thomsen, K.","Rasran, L."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.650543000000","8.871451000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1553","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-turbines-population-nest-site-selection-montagus-harrier-hellweg-borde","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_5","title":"Impacts of Wind Turbines on the Population and Nest Site Selection of the Montagu\u0027s Harrier in the Hellweg B\u00f6rde, North Rhine-Westphalia","description":"This study analyses impacts of wind turbines on the population and nest site selection of Montagu\u2019s harriers in the Hellweg B\u00f6rde. From 1993 to 2007, wind energy use increased while the number of nests decreased. No correlation between the number of turbines on the number of nests in grid cells of 4\u00a0km2\u00a0was found. In areas previously occupied by harriers, only single broods occurred after the construction of turbines at a median distance of 500\u00a0m from the next turbine. No broods were found within wind farms. Nests were located in less sloping areas at larger distances from forests or settlements as well as from turbines and wind farms than to be expected randomly. In logistic regression models, an increase in distance from the next neighbour as well height and slope gradient had a negative effect, whereas an increase in distance from the next forests or settlements had a positive effect on the probability of a brood. A positive effect of the distance from the next power pylon or from the next power pylon and wind turbine combined was found in some models. These results indicate that further development of infrastructure could reduce the size of suitable habitat below the required minimum size of available open landscape. If nesting harriers do not avoid wind turbines, the risk of birds to collide with turbines will increase, because in the surrounding of the nest many flight movements (e.g. display, attacks on predators, soaring) occur within the rotor swept area.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Joest, R.","Griesenbrock, B.","Illner, H."],"organization":["Soest District Working Group for Nature Conservation (ABU)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.465361000000","7.497402000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Habitat Change","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1554","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/telemetric-monitoring-montagus-harrier-schleswig-holstein","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_4","title":"Telemetric Monitoring of Montagu\u0027s Harrier in Schleswig-Holstein","description":"The behaviour of breeding Montagu\u2019s harriers towards wind farms in Schleswig-Holstein in Northern Germany was investigated in a two years telemetry study. A total of 11 breeding birds were fitted with VHF transmitters. The home ranges varied between 340 and 1560\u00a0ha (kernel). Males had larger home ranges than females. Centres of flight activity (50% kernel) were in the surroundings of nests and comprised between 41 and 252\u00a0ha. The salt marshes of the intertidal zone and large extensive grasslands rich in ecotones were important foraging grounds. Wind farms within the home range were used without avoidance of the close-up area of wind turbines. The intensity of use depended on location and distance of wind turbines from the centre of activity (nest) and available foraging grounds. The results gave no hint of displacement effects in the selection of the nest site or avoidance behaviour in the use of the habitat. 60\u201370% of the flight heights of Montagu\u2019s harriers were below 10\u00a0m, rarely reaching the risk area of currently installed wind turbines. Flight activities in critical heights were concentrated on the nest site with 50% of the recorded locations within a radius of 182\u2013497\u00a0m around the nest. With increasing distance from the nest, the flight activity per area was decreasing considerably. Due to hunting flights, mainly below 10\u00a0m height, low collision risk occured in the periphery of the home range. The distance between nest and wind turbine was a decisive factor for the collision risk. Habitat management concepts in order to lower the collision risk by relocating breeding sites to locations outside the impact range of wind turbines and by channeling flight activity along suitable created foraging grounds are discussed.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Nehls, G.","Grajetzky, B."],"organization":["BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.195663000000","9.566775000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1555","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/red-kite","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2_3#citeas","title":"Red Kite","description":"To analyse habitat use of red kite (Milvus milvus), behavioural observations, vantage point counts and telemetric monitoring were carried out in five wind farms in Saxony-Anhalt between 2007 and 2010. Home ranges were remarkably large, showing clear individual differences but no significant differences in home range size between genders. Nests formed the centres of activity of the home ranges, both during and after the breeding season. 54% of all activities were recorded within a distance of 1,000\u00a0m from the nest. Spatial overlaps between kernel home ranges and wind farm areas were common and depended on distance between wind turbines and nest. Between sunrise and sunset, red kites spent 25% of the time in flight covering a mean distance of 90.1\u00a0km. When birds visited wind farms, about 47% of the flights occurred within the height band of between 25 and 150\u00a0m. Use of areas within or outside wind farms depended on the cultivated crop or the stage of cultivation. All crops including alfalfa were most attractive shortly after harvesting or ploughing. Only few foraging areas are available in spring and early summer and the birds concentrated their foraging activity on a few clearly visible crop areas as well as edge structures including fallows around turbine bases and access routes to wind turbines. The following measures may minimise conflicts: (1) observance of a distance of at least 1,250\u00a0m between wind turbines and red kite nests, (2) avoidance of attractive areas within wind farms (3) no mowing or harvesting activities within wind farms before mid-July.\n\nThis is a chapter in the book Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","author":["Mammen, U.","Mammen, K.","Resetaritz, A."],"organization":["\u00d6KOTOP B\u00fcro f\u00fcr Angewandte Landschafts\u00f6kologie","Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.724074000000","11.391750000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1556","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/birds-prey-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53402-2#toc","title":"Birds of Prey and Wind Farms","description":"This book discusses the increase in number and capacity of wind farms in Germany and how this is affecting birds of prey. Several methods are used to study the behaviour of birds of prey in relation to wind farms, including telemetry data, field observations, and comparisons of turbine base areas. Special attention is given to the effects on different bird species and the impact wind farms may have on population growth and breeding success of birds of prey. Chapter 6 discusses the collision risks at wind turbines and provides an analysis of the fatalities. In the concluding chapter, ideas are put forward to help minimize conflicts, estimate risks, and offer practical recommendations for future research.  This book will be of interest to wind farm developers, researchers, applied ecologists and landscape planners.  Table of Contents:  Chapter 1- Research Issues and Aims of the Study  Chapter 2- Project Structure and Methodological Approach  Chapter 3- Red Kite  Chapter 4- Telemetric Monitoring of Montagu\u0027s Harrier in Schleswig-Holstein  Chapter 5- Impacts of Wind Turbines on the Population and Nest Site Selection of the Montagu\u0027s Harrier in the Hellweg Borde, North Rhine-Westphalia  Chapter 6- Impacts of Wind Turbines on the Population and Nest Site Selection of the Montagu\u0027s Harrier in North Frisia  Chapter 7- Satellite Tracking of White-Tailed Sea Eagles in Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania and Brandenburg  Chapter 8- Behavioral Observations of White-Tailed Sea Eagles in the Vicinity of Wind Turbines  Chapter 9- Effects of Individuals Lost Due to Wind Turbines on the Time of Occupying a Territory, the Survival of Breeding Territories and the Breeding Success of White-Tailed Sea Eagles (Case Studies)  Chapter 10- Distances Between Breeding Sites and White-Tailed Sea Eagles Found Dead Near Wind Turbines in Schleswig-Holstein  Chapter 11- White-Tailed Sea Eagle- Summary and Conclusions  Chapter 12- Collisions of Birds of Prey with Wind Turbines- Analysis of the Circumstances  Chapter 13- Collision Victims and Lattice Towers- Frequency of Collision, Breeding Population and Breeding Success of Birds of Prey in Two Wind Farms in Brandenburg  Chapter 14- Calculation of the Probability of a Collision of Territorial Birds of Prey with Wind Turbines  Chapter 15- Population Development and Breeding Success of Birds of Prey in Relation to the Development of Wind Energy Use in Germany  Chapter 16- Conclusions, Risk Assessment, Conflict Minimisation, Practical Recommendations, Need for Further Research","author":["H\u00f6tker, H.","Nehls, G.","Krone, O."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)","Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-04-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1557","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-tropical-wind-farm-species-composition-importance-spatial-attributes-vegetation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/jmammal\/article\/97\/4\/1197\/1753426","title":"Bats in a tropical wind farm: species composition and importance of the spatial attributes of vegetation cover on bat fatalities","description":"Although many tropical countries have functional wind farms, most of the information on their impact on bat populations has come from temperate zones. Our study is based on a 5-year study (2009\u20132013) of bat captures using mist nets, acoustic recordings, and carcass searches at a wind farm in tropical southern Mexico. We investigated the composition of bat species, estimated the number of bat fatalities per turbine, and assessed the effect of the spatial attributes of vegetation cover near turbines on numbers of bat carcasses recovered by trophic guild. We recorded 29 bat species at the wind farm. The family Phyllostomidae was best represented in terms of number of species and individuals captured.\u00a0Glossophaga soricina\u00a0and\u00a0G. morenoiexhibited the highest relative abundance, whereas\u00a0Balantiopteryx plicata\u00a0had the highest acoustic activity. We found 203 carcasses, including 73\u00a0Pteronotus davyi\u00a0individuals (35.9%); other frequent species were\u00a0Mormoops megalophylla,\u00a0Molossus sinaloae, and\u00a0Lasiurus intermedius.\u00a0The total number of carcasses found within a year ranged from 17 to 83 (2012 and 2009, respectively), with the corrected estimates ranging from 410 to 1,980, or 4.18\u201320.20 fatalities\/turbine. The number of carcasses recorded was positively correlated with secondary vegetation surrounding turbines but negatively correlated with agricultural fields. The spatial attributes of vegetation surrounding turbines influenced numbers of bat carcasses differentially depending on the bats\u2019 trophic guild and habitat use. Contrary to findings from United States and Canadian wind farms, most of the carcasses observed in our study were resident species. Notably, the most commonly captured and acoustically active species were not the most commonly found in carcass searches. To obtain more accurate information about the most vulnerable species and how to reduce the impact on bat mortality, we advise the use of alternative monitoring methods in pre-construction studies.","author":["Villegas-Patraca, R.","Cabrera-Cruz, S.","Bolivar-Cime, B.","Bolivar-Cime, A.","Munoz-Jimenez, O."],"organization":["Universidad Veracruzana","Universidad Juarez Autonoma de Tabasco","University of Delaware","Instituto de Ecolog\u00eda UNAM"],"originationDate":"2016-07-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["16.516670000000","-94.878610000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1558","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-facilities-bats-neotropics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3161\/15081109ACC2015.17.2.012","title":"Impact of wind facilities on bats in the Neotropics","description":"We monitored the\u00a0bat\u00a0fatalities caused by a 13 turbines\u00a0wind\u00a0facility\u00a0installed in western Puerto Rico (West Indies) over a period of 23 months. The post-construction monitoring includes observed fatalities and a corrected fatality estimate expressed as\u00a0bats\/ turbine\/year adjusted for\u00a0bat\u00a0carcass removal rates, searcher efficiency, and percent area searched. Data on seasonality of fatalities and distance of carcasses from turbines is also provided. Eleven out of the 13 species of\u00a0bats\u00a0in Puerto Rico suffered fatalities, including all five species of phyllostomids. These were:\u00a0Molossus molossusand\u00a0Tadarida brasiliensis\u00a0(Molossidae);\u00a0Artibeus jamaicensis,\u00a0Monophyllus redmani,\u00a0Stenoderma rufum,\u00a0Brachyphylla cavernarum\u00a0and\u00a0Erophylla bombifrons\u00a0(Phyllostomidae);\u00a0Noctilio leporinus\u00a0(Noctilionidae);\u00a0Eptesicus fuscus\u00a0and\u00a0Lasiurus minor\u00a0(Vespertilionidae); and\u00a0Mormoops blainvillei\u00a0(Mormoopidae). This is one of the first published reports of the\u00a0impact\u00a0of\u00a0wind\u00a0turbines on\u00a0bats\u00a0in the\u00a0Neotropics.","author":["Rodr\u00edguez-Dur\u00e1n, A.","Feliciano-Robles, W."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["18.184400000000","-65.694720000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1559","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cobscook-bay-tidal-energy-project-2014-environmental-monitoring-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/orpc.co\/storage\/2022\/02\/2014-Environmental-Monitoring-Report.pdf","title":"Cobscook Bay Tidal Energy Project: 2014 Environmental Monitoring Report","description":"ORPC Maine, LLC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Ocean Renewable Power Company, LLC, (collectively, ORPC), is a Maine-based developer of hydrokinetic power systems and projects that harness the power of oceans and rivers to generate clean, predictable renewable energy. In partnership with coastal and river communities, ORPC works to create and sustain local jobs while promoting energy independence and protecting the environment. ORPC received a pilot project license for the Cobscook Bay Tidal Energy Project (Project) from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) on February 27, 2012 (FERC Project No. P-12711-005). The purpose of the Project is to evaluate the potential for a new source of clean, renewable energy generation using tidal energy resources in Cobscook Bay, Maine. ORPC obtained a preliminary permit for the Project area in Cobscook Bay from FERC on July 23, 2007; FERC issued a successive preliminary permit on January 13, 2011. Feasibility studies, including environmental surveys, and pre-filing consultation were conducted, resulting in ORPC\u2019s filing of a draft pilot project license application with FERC on July 24, 2009 and subsequently, the final pilot project license application in September 2011. The FERC pilot project license boundary for the Project encompasses the proposed development area (Figure 1). In March 2012, ORPC began construction of the Project off the coast of Eastport and Lubec, Maine (Figure 1). Following installation of the initial phase of the Project during the spring and summer of 2012, the Project began delivering electricity to the Emera Maine grid in September 2012. This is the first grid-connected installation of ORPC\u2019s TidGen\u00ae Power System.","author":["ORPC Maine"],"organization":["Ocean Renewable Power Company (ORPC)"],"originationDate":"2015-03-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.914400000000","-67.051400000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-22 03:45:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ORPC-2014-Monitoring.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1560","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cobscook-bay-tidal-energy-project-2016-environmental-monitoring-report","sourceURL":"","title":"Cobscook Bay Tidal Energy Project: 2016 Environmental Monitoring Report","description":"ORPC Maine, LLC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Ocean Renewable Power Company, LLC, (collectively, ORPC), is a Maine-based developer of hydrokinetic power systems and projects that harness the power of oceans and rivers to generate clean, predictable renewable energy. In partnership with coastal and river communities, ORPC works to create and sustain local jobs while promoting energy independence and protecting the environment. ORPC received a pilot project license for the Cobscook Bay Tidal Energy Project (Project) from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) on February 27, 2012 (FERC Project No. P-12711-005). The purpose of the Project is to evaluate the potential for a new source of clean, renewable energy generation using tidal energy resources in Cobscook Bay, Maine. ORPC obtained a preliminary permit for the Project area in Cobscook Bay from FERC on July 23, 2007; FERC issued a successive preliminary permit on January 13, 2011. Feasibility studies, including environmental surveys, and pre-filing consultation were conducted, resulting in ORPC\u2019s filing of a draft pilot project license application with FERC on July 24, 2009 and subsequently, the final pilot project license application in September 2011. The FERC pilot project license boundary for the Project encompasses the proposed development area (Figure 1). In March 2012, ORPC began construction of the Project off the coast of Eastport and Lubec, Maine (Figure 1). Following installation of the initial phase of the Project during the spring and summer of 2012, the Project began delivering electricity to the Emera Maine grid in September 2012. This is the first grid-connected installation of ORPC\u2019s TidGen\u00ae Power System.","author":["ORPC Maine"],"organization":["Ocean Renewable Power Company (ORPC)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.914400000000","-67.051400000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-22 03:46:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ORPC-2016-Monitoring.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1561","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/experimental-study-impact-large-scale-wind-farms-land-atmosphere-exchanges","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1748-9326\/8\/1\/015002\/meta","title":"Experimental study of the impact of large-scale wind farms on land\u2013atmosphere exchanges","description":"Large-scale wind farms, covering a significant portion of the land and ocean surface, may affect the transport of momentum, heat, mass and moisture between the atmosphere and the land locally and globally. To understand the wind-farm\u2013atmosphere interaction, we conducted wind-tunnel experiments to study the surface scalar (heat) flux using model wind farms, consisting of more than ten rows of wind turbines\u2014having typical streamwise and spanwise spacings of five and four rotor diameters\u2014in a neutral boundary layer with a heated surface. The spatial distribution of the surface heat flux was mapped with an array of surface heat flux sensors within the quasi-developed regime of the wind-farm flow. Although the overall surface heat flux change produced by the wind farms was found to be small, with a net reduction of 4% for a staggered wind farm and nearly zero change for an aligned wind farm, the highly heterogeneous spatial distribution of the surface heat flux, dependent on the wind-farm layout, was significant. The difference between the minimum and maximum surface heat fluxes could be up to 12% and 7% in aligned and staggered wind farms, respectively. This finding is important for planning intensive agriculture practice and optimizing farm land use strategy regarding wind energy project development. The well-controlled wind-tunnel experiments presented in this study also provide a first comprehensive dataset on turbulent flow and scalar transport in wind farms, which can be further used to develop and validate new parameterizations of surface scalar fluxes in numerical models.","author":["Zhang, W.","Markfort, C.","Porte-Agel, F."],"organization":["University of Minnesota","\u00c9cole polytechnique f\u00e9d\u00e9rale de Lausanne (EPFL)"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1562","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-soundscape-effects-noise-aquatic-mammals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/2224","title":"The Marine Soundscape and the Effects of Noise on Aquatic Mammals","description":"The marine soundscape is made up of natural ambient sounds (e.g. wind and waves), biological sounds (e.g. animal calls) and anthropogenic sounds (e.g. ship noise). Acoustic ecology studies the relationships\u2014 mediated through sound\u2014between organisms and their environment. As ocean water conducts light very poorly yet sound very well, marine mammals rely heavily on acoustics for communication and navigation. Since the onset of the industrial revolution, man-made noise in the ocean has steadily increased. The effects of noise on marine animals can be short-term or long-term, transient or chronic, negligible to biologically significant, where the survival of a population is at risk. This article gives an overview of the components constituting the marine soundscape, of the use of sound by marine mammals and of the effects of noise. The acoustic ecology of animals other than mammals and the effects of noise on animals other than mammals are less understood.","author":["Erbe, C."],"organization":["JASCO Applied Sciences"],"originationDate":"2010-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1563","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/algorithms-marine-mammal-modelling-application-ramsey-sound","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/319311507_Algorithms_for_marine_mammal_modelling_and_an_application_in_Ramsey_Sound","title":"Algorithms for Marine Mammal Modelling and an Application in Ramsey Sound","description":"The main function of a marine renewable energy device is to remove energy from a marine environment and transform it into (generally) electrical energy for further use. This has potential for environmental benefits in the form of reducing global carbon emissions, but also has the potential for impact on the local ecology.  Using computer models and simulations to design and develop devices is not a new or uncommon idea, but this use is often concentrated on the mechanics of a design and its interaction with the physical environment. A simulation framework has been developed in an attempt to mimic the movement of marine mammals in a tidal environment, specifically looking at the potential interaction between tidal stream turbines and harbour porpoise.  Following from the basic rules and principles presented previously, a set of simulations have been conducted based on a tidal model of Ramsey Sound - a tidal channel off the south western tip of Wales. Four different simulations are examined, based on combinations of the behavioural influences incorporated into the model - food and noise. This allows the potential interactions between these factors to be examined, as well as how changes in these results might appear in real observational data.  Click here for more information on Ramsey Sound.","author":["Masters, I.","Lake, T.","Croft, N."],"organization":["Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.877780000000","-5.326110000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1564","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/methods-individual-based-modelling-harbour-porpoise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/281279995_Methods_for_Individual_Based_Modelling_of_Harbour_Porpoise","title":"Methods for Individual Based Modelling of Harbour Porpoise","description":"Individual Based Models (IBMs) can be used to investigate emergent behaviours of groups and flocks of animals. Early uses of IBMs showed plausible looking behaviours emerging from simple rules and were used in computer generated animations and images. This type of model has since seen use simulating behaviours of a range of animals ranging from clam larvae to moose in a range of environments. The flexibility of the model allows a range of environmental parameters to be included, allowing the response of the simulated animals to the environment to be investigated. The complexity of these models can vary considerably, and a number of additions can be made to the basic IBM structure. The detail and complexity of these models is in part constrained by the availability of environmental data and in part by available data of the animals to be simulated, which can be particularly difficult to obtain in a marine environment. A planned model for the behaviour of Harbour Porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) is given as an example use of these techniques.","author":["Masters, I.","Lake, T.","Croft, N."],"organization":["Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2013-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1565","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/particles-porpoise-applying-cfd-results-environmental-interactions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/281280339_Particles_as_Porpoise_-Applying_CFD_Results_to_Environmental_Interactions","title":"Particles as Porpoise - Applying CFD Results to Environmental Interactions","description":"Individual Based Models (IBMs) provide a way of taking simple rules and principles and simulating the movement and interaction of living creatures with each other and\/or the environment around them. These models have been used to investigate habitat use and movements of a variety of animals, including both marine and terrestrial mammals, fish and birds, over a range of timescales and degrees of sophistication. An advantage of this type of model is the potential to allow changes to the environment to be simulated, and potential effects of these changes to be investigated before they take place. This could include potential impacts of marine energy devices on local marine mammals. This model uses meshes and tidal flow data from an openTELEMAC model, with the 3D mesh being composed of linear, wedge shaped elements with nodes fixed in x, y but with time varying z coordinates. Data values (such as x, y and z flow velocities, prey density or noise levels) are specified at each node and are interpolated spatially using mean value coordinates and interpolated linearly with respect to time in order to obtain values at the location of each individual animal, or boid, within the simulation. The movement of the mesh, including the changing heights of the elements, leads to a variety of issues when tracking the location of the boids within the mesh.  Click here for more information on Ramsey Sound.","author":["Masters, I.","Lake, T.","Croft, N."],"organization":["Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1566","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/lcri-2015-overview-lcri-research-2008-2015","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/279443248_LCRI_2015_Overview_of_LCRI_Research_2008_to_2015","title":"LCRI 2015 Overview of LCRI Research 2008 to 2015","description":"The LCRI has built research capacity in Wales, linking academic research with industry and government relating to the low carbon agenda. Many projects have been near market, working with industry partners on emerging low carbon technologies. Each have a key role to play in supporting recent legislation in Wales and contributing to a more sustainable future.\n\nThe Low Carbon Built Environment (LCBE) programme based at the Welsh School of Architecture, Cardiff University, has carried out research at a range of scales, from components, to buildings, to urban, and finally to the Wales region. New products developed at component level have been integrated into the design of new buildings as well as the retrofit of existing buildings. The Sustainable Building Envelope Centre (SBEC) at Tata Shotton and the SOLCER energy positive house are two buildings that were designed within the LCBE programme. They demonstrate new technologies for generating energy from fully integrated renewable energy systems that also form a construction component of the building envelope. Energy retrofits have been investigated for housing, factories, retail and schools. Buildings in-use have been monitored and design guidance produced. Computer simulation models developed at building scale have been extended to urban scale, for new build and retro\u012et applications. The implementation of new technologies and processes has been examined at regional scale, in relation to industry innovation and government policy and regulations. Research on transitions to a low carbon future has included projects in the UK, Europe and China. International collaboration activities have taken place, including, the European Smart Energy Regions COST network, and research links with China. The built environment is key to achieving a low carbon future. The challenges now are to further develop and demonstrate new low carbon technologies and processes that can be integrated into building design in an a\u012bordable and replicable way, to measure their performance in use, to develop simulation tools to assist research and design activities at building and city-region scale, and to work with industry and government to understand the barriers and opportunities in relation to the wide-scale implementation in practice of sustainability and low carbon policy.\n\nThe Solar Photovoltaic Academic Research Consortium (SPARC) has formed a strategic link between the solar energy research in the partner universities of Glyndwr, Bangor and Swansea. This has established Wales as an innovation centre for new PV solar energy products and, together with LCBE activities at SBEC, has contributed to the establishment of the SPECIFIC centre in Swansea where manufacturing processes are being developed based on the materials research carried out on SPARC. Wales has a strong tradition of PV supply chain companies from power electronics through to module manufacture and the SPARC team have been effective in working with these industries to help to develop new products that will fuel the rapidly growing solar PV industry. SPARC has built the world\u2019s \u012erst in-line atmospheric pressure deposition system for thin film PV manufacture based at its dedicated centre for solar energy research (CSER) in the OpTIC Centre at St Asaph. It has new rapid processing techniques for dye sensitised solar cells (DSC) compatible with high volume manufacturing. It has researched new power electronics designs for e\u0138cient extraction of the electrical power from PV solar energy modules, leading to a new ultra-light-weight thin film PV technology for space in collaboration with Welsh industry.\n\nThe LCRI Hydrogen theme investigates the development and deployment of hydrogen and fuel cell technologies as a low or zero carbon solution for both energy and transport systems. Led by the University of South Wales, much of the research and development activity is world-leading and covers many aspects of hydrogen and fuel cell technology. Research includes hydrogen production techniques, novel hydrogen storage material development, infrastructure and distribution development, and a range of application technologies including fuel cell materials research and development of both fuel cell and combustion technologies for energy conversion. The hydrogen theme also incorporates techno-economic and environmental assessment of hydrogen and fuel cell technologies. As the relevance of hydrogen and fuel cells is being understood, worldwide interest in hydrogen and fuel cell technology has dramatically increased in recent years. Industrial deployment of hydrogen and fuel cell technology for energy and transport is now a reality and future challenges centre around technological and economic improvement. There remain a number of critical R\u0026D issues to be addressed, including, the development of hydrogen solutions for grid-scale energy storage to allow for increased penetration of renewable electricity, utilisation of existing grid assets to enable hydrogen based energy storage (power-to-gas), investigation of novel hydrogen storage and fuel cell materials and techniques including the engineering to incorporate these at commercial scale, development of improved hydrogen fuel cell electric vehicle and hydrogen combustion based propulsion systems, optimisation of the deployment of hydrogen refuelling infrastructure, continued improvement of fermentative and bioelectrochemical hydrogen and methane production processes, development of industrial hydrogen separation and recovery techniques including upgrading via reforming and other methods. With active academic and industrial partners and the engagement of government, Wales is ideally placed to be a leading European region deploying hydrogen and fuel cell technologies and deriving economic and environmental benefit in the process.\n\nCardiff\u00a0University\u2019s Gas Turbine Research Centre (GTRC) at Margam is carrying out research on a wide variety of projects including fuel variability, operational flexibility and risk and hazard assessment. LCRI capital funding has been used to set up a world leading experimental simulation facility through the addition of a flexible 5-component gas mixing station to its highpressure\/ temperature facilities\u2019. This new mixing station can accurately mix different gas fuel compositions, including varying concentrations of hydrogen, and is investigating hydrogen-rich syngas from high-efficiency gasification processes with or without carbon capture. In the short term, increasing amounts of imported natural gas and LNG from around the world are having a significant affect on the natural gas composition being utilised by power generators. As a result modern gas turbines can experience operational instability issues which adversely affect reliability and emissions. Further research is required to understand this phenomena to assist UK and EU natural gas regulators in standardising gas composition and quality. The research is also important to the gas turbine Original Equipment Manufacturers and end users to optimise the reliability of current and future gas turbines. In the medium term, consideration must be given to increasing levels of Hydrogen created from renewable sources being injected into the natural gas grid and being utilised by power generators. Hydrogen has been shown to increase burning rate and flame temperatures which could adversely affect gas turbine operation. Due to the reliance on natural gas for power generation in the UK, the integration of carbon capture and storage alongside gas turbine power stations is required. The GTRCs input in this area will be with oxygen enriched combustion and exhaust gas recirculation which are both techniques for enriching the CO2 stream in the exhaust to enhance capture e\u0138ciency. With the research infrastructure now in place at the GTRC it is well positioned to be a signifcant contributor in these research fields.\n\nLCRI Marine led by Swansea University provides independent and world-class research to enable, support and help build a sustainable marine energy sector in Wales. It develops engineering tools, which optimise the design and performance of technology that recovers energy from waves, tidal streams and tidal ranges around the Welsh coast. In addition, it considers the likely effects that these devices have on the environment, such as their effect on seabed communities, sediment transport and marine wildlife. The future of the Marine Renewable Energy sector in Wales is very positive. Technology development continues, devices are ready to deploy, and commercial projects planned. Two 100MW demonstration zones have been created (one wave, one tidal) which are managed by community companies; Strategic investment planned by WEFO into the infrastructure of these sites will make Wales a world class destination for the sector. The universities are fully engaged with the companies deploying on the demonstration sites, providing a pipeline of the highest quality research and development to continue the growth of the sector into a mature industry. The key issues for future R\u0026D are: uncertainty of energy resource, particularly where waves and currents interact; extreme storm loadings; fatigue and life prediction; optimum positioning of arrays and devices within them; cost reduction intelligent design; standardisation and supply chain diversification. An integrated partnership of universities, developers and supply chain is working to make this a reality.\n\nLCRI now aims to build on its success and continue to provide Wales with a research network that can work with industry and government to help deliver and implement low carbon policy in Wales, and help promote low carbon research on the international stage.","author":["Masters, I.","Jones, P.","Irvine, S.","Guwy, A.","Bowen, P."],"organization":["Cardiff University","University of South Wales","Swansea University","Bangor University"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/LCRI_Report2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1567","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-marine-mammal-observation-methods-vantage-point-surveys-ramsey-sound","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/279885287_Development_of_marine_mammal_observation_methods_for_vantage_Point_surveys_in_Ramsey_sound","title":"Development of Marine Mammal Observation Methods for Vantage Point Surveys in Ramsey Sound","description":"SEACAMS has been working on a collaborative R\u0026amp;D project with Pembrokeshire Guided Walks (PGW) to develop and trial equipment and methods for collecting marine mammal sightings data from fixed vantage points in Ramsey Sound. The study site has been subject to various marine mammal studies, mainly due to the planned deployment of a demonstration tidal turbine by Tidal Energy Limited (TEL).  Here we briefly cover the rationale for fixed vantage point surveys for marine mammals, their limitations and possible methodological solutions to some of the main problems identified. The report described the steps taken to build and trial fieldwork equipment to accurately collect data on animal distances for marine mammal observations, as well as one method for achieving simultaneous data from two adjacent but independent observation stations.  Click here for more information on Ramsey Sound.","author":["Nuuttila, H.","Mendzil, A."],"organization":["Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2015-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.877780000000","-51.877780000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NuuttilaandMendzil_ReportD75_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1568","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cumulative-adverse-effects-offshore-wind-energy-development-wildlife-thesis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/scholarworks.umass.edu\/cgi\/viewcontent.cgi?article=2412\u0026context=dissertations_2","title":"Cumulative Adverse Effects of Offshore Wind Energy Development on Wildlife [Thesis]","description":"Offshore wind energy development is being pursued as a critical component in achieving a low-carbon energy economy. While the adverse effects of one wind farm on a particular wildlife population may be negligible, the aggregate effect of multiple wind farms through space and time could cause wildlife population declines. The risk of cumulative adverse effects (CAE) of offshore wind farms on wildlife is poorly researched and assessment processes are underdeveloped. Assessments of CAE must first calculate the cumulative exposure of a wildlife population to a hazard and then estimate how the exposure will affect the population. Our research responds to the first need by developing a framework to assess CAE and then developing a deterministic, geospatial decision-support model that assesses how wildlife are cumulatively exposed to the hazard of multiple wind farms. We first utilize the model to quantify how Northern Gannet (Morus bassanus) would be cumulatively exposed to three different wind farm siting scenarios along the East Coast of the U.S. The findings suggest that Northern Gannets will be cumulatively exposed regardless of siting decisions and avoidance is not an effective mitigation measure. Second, we use the model to assess how seven seabird foraging guilds would be cumulatively exposed to the same three wind farm siting scenarios. The model outputs indicate that no single offshore wind siting decision can reduce the cumulative exposure for all guilds. Based upon these findings, we identify the foraging guilds most likely to be cumulatively exposed and propose an approach for siting and mitigation that reduces cumulative exposure for all guilds.","author":["Goodale, M."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.265341000000","-70.963482000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind","Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1569","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effectiveness-mitigation-measure-lesser-kestrel-falco-naumanni-wind-farms-spain","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479718312349","title":"Effectiveness of a mitigation measure for the lesser kestrel (Falco naumanni) in wind farms in Spain","description":"Central-eastern Spain is characterised as being a flat and relatively open landscape, greatly used for agricultural purposes and with a high density of wind installations. This landscape also hosts a large population of the lesser kestrel (Falco naumanni), one of the species most threatened by collisions with wind turbines. During a ten-year period, we analysed bird mortality by recording deaths on three wind farms (WF), Cerro del Palo, Cerro Calder\u00f3n and La Muela I, located in the province of Cuenca (Spain) and containing a total of 99 turbines. The aim of the study was to determine the variables associated with mortalities caused by these types of devices. Subsequently, the information obtained allowed a mitigation measure to be implemented for avoiding and minimising collisions. The procedure involved superficially tilling the soil around the base of turbines with a high collision rate. This measure was monitored for two years before and after implementation in order to compare its effectiveness, and involved making the areas around the turbines less attractive to kestrels by tilling and reducing the amount of vegetation and consequently the abundance of potential prey, mainly Orthoptera. If effective, the lack of prey would decrease the number of dead kestrels, as the birds of prey would need to search for food in other less dangerous areas (approximately 80 m away from the turbines). After monitoring the mitigation measure it was found that the number of collisions decreased by 75\u2013100%. In fact, no collisions were registered during the two year period for all of the wind turbines with tilled surroundings. Based on these results it can be safely stated that this mitigation measure is an easy and inexpensive procedure that significantly and effectively reduces the number of kestrels that collide into wind turbines.","author":["Pescador, M.","Ram\u00edrez, J.","Peris, S."],"organization":["University of Salamanca"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.061970800000","-2.165577400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1570","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/operational-offshore-wind-farms-associated-ship-traffic-cause-profound-changes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479718311873","title":"Operational offshore wind farms and associated ship traffic cause profound changes in distribution patterns of Loons (Gavia spp.)","description":"Seabirds select suitable habitats at sea, but these habitats may be strongly impacted by marine spatial planning, including the construction of offshore wind farms (OWFs) and the associated ship traffic. Loons (Gavia spp.) are particularly vulnerable to anthropogenic activities and are also of high conservation status, making them particularly relevant to marine planning processes. We investigated the effects of OWF construction and ship traffic on Loon distributions in the German North Sea on a large spatial scale, using a \u2018before\u2013after\u2019 control impact analysis approach and a long-term data set. Many OWFs were built in or close to core areas of Loon distributions. Loons showed significant shifts in their distribution in the \u2018after\u2019 period and subsequently aggregated between two OWF clusters, indicating the remaining suitable habitat. The decrease in Loon abundance became significant as far as about 16 km from the closest OWF. Ship traffic also had a significant negative impact on Loons, indicating that OWFs deterred Loons through the combined effect of ship traffic and the wind turbines themselves. This study provides the first analysis of the extensive effects of OWFs and ships on Loons on a large spatial scale. The results provide an essential baseline for future marine spatial planning processes in the German North Sea and elsewhere.","author":["Garthe, S.","Peschko, V.","Mendel, B.","Schwemmer, P.","M\u00fcller, S.","Schwemmer, H.","Mercker, M."],"organization":["Kiel University"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.939427000000","8.135586000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1571","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-energy-resource-assessment-under-techno-economic-social-ecological","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117303630","title":"Offshore wind energy resource assessment under techno-economic and social-ecological constraints","description":"An offshore wind energy resource assessment is presented. This includes techno-economic and social-ecological constraints. The theoretical total installed capacity is estimated using a wind climate dataset. Then techno-economic constraints are incorporated to assess the practical energy potential using water depth and proximity to high voltage transmission lines as the two limiting factors. The assessed area is the northern half of the Gulf of California, a marginal sea on the Northwestern Pacific coast of Mexico. Adding ecological constraints by incorporating natural resource systems, results in a techno-economic and ecologically viable offshore wind energy potential of 35% of the theoretical potential. Finally, social constraints are assessed by incorporating small-scale fisheries geographical information. When removing most of the fishing grounds the fully constrained potential is 2500 GW, only 13% of the theoretical wind energy potential. If areas used by only one community are included then this increases to 30% of the theoretical potential, or 5766 GW. The technical installed capacity for 6 MW turbines is 131 GW with fishing grounds exploited by at most one fishing community included, and of 52 GW for the fully-constrained problem, i.e. with no fishing grounds included. The latter is equivalent to 84% of Mexico\u0027s total energy production. Exploiting these resources would be crucial for the country\u0027s current and future sustainable development, but it is necessary to implement flexible and dynamic marine spatial plans, and include all stakeholders and regulators in the analysis and decision-making process.","author":["Magar, V.","Gross, M.","Gonz\u00e1lez-Garc\u00eda, L."],"organization":["Ensenada Center for Scientific Research and Higher Education"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["27.604209000000","-111.486471700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1572","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-anthropogenic-landscape-alterations-wildlife-hazards-wind-farms-example","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X18305090","title":"Evaluating anthropogenic landscape alterations as wildlife hazards, with wind farms as an example","description":"Anthropogenic alterations to landscape are indicators of potential compromise of that landscape\u2019s ecology. We describe how alterations can be assessed as \u2018hazards\u2019 to wildlife through a sequence of three steps: diagnosing the means by which the hazard acts on individual organisms at risk; estimating the fitness cost of the hazard to those individuals and the rate at which that cost occurs; and translating that cost rate into a demographic cost by identifying the relevant demographically-closed population. We exploit the conservation-oriented literature on wind farms to illustrate this conceptual scheme. For wind farms, the third component has received less attention than the first two, which suggests it is the most challenging of the three components. A wind farm provides an example of a \u2018spatially localized hazard\u2019, i.e., a discrete alteration of landscape hazardous to some population but of which there are some individuals that do not interact directly with the hazard themselves but nevertheless suffer a reduction in fitness in terms of their contribution to the next generation. Spatially localized hazards are identified via the third component of the scheme and are of particular conservation concern as, by their nature, their depredations on wildlife may be underestimated without an appropriate population-level estimation of the demographic cost of the hazard.","author":["Law, P.","Fuller, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2018-07-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1573","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/social-dynamics-turbine-tourism-recreation-introducing-mixed-method-approach-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S221462961830673X","title":"The social dynamics of turbine tourism and recreation: Introducing a mixed-method approach to the study of the first U.S. offshore wind farm","description":"Understanding the complex dynamics that influence energy transitions requires mixed methods and collaborations among researchers, resource managers, and communities. This essay details how an interdisciplinary team of researchers used a mixed-method approach to study the social dimensions of tourism and recreation as they relate to the first offshore wind farm in the United States, the Block Island Wind Farm. Although impacts to tourism from wind energy systems are widely cited as a concern by communities and policymakers, little work has sought to define what constitutes tourism and recreation impacts or provided empirical evidence of impacts from operating projects. Researchers adopted an iterative approach to research that combined discrete studies using media content analysis, ethnographic participant observation, and stakeholder focus groups, to understand the social effects of the wind farm on the tourism and recreation experience and the quality of life in Block Island and coastal Rhode Island. We detail key insights from our experimentation with an iterative mixed-method approach at Block Island and offer lessons for future studies using collaborative approaches to understand both the tangible and the intangible social dynamics of energy system transitions.","author":["McCann, J.","Smith, H.","Bidwell, D.","Moore, A.","Smythe, T."],"organization":["University of Oregon","US Coast Guard Academy","University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2018-07-08","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.116000000000","-71.521000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Recreation \u0026 Tourism"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1574","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/making-marine-noise-pollution-impacts-heard-case-cetaceans-north-sea-within-life-cycle","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2071-1050\/9\/7\/1138","title":"Making Marine Noise Pollution Impacts Heard: The Case of Cetaceans in the North Sea within Life Cycle Impact Assessment","description":"Oceans represent more than 95% of the world\u2019s biosphere and are among the richest sources of biodiversity on Earth. However, human activities such as shipping and construction of marine infrastructure pose a threat to the quality of marine ecosystems. Due to the dependence of most marine animals on sound for their communication, foraging, protection, and ultimately their survival, the effects of noise pollution from human activities are of growing concern. Life cycle assessment (LCA) can play a role in the understanding of how potential environmental impacts are related to industrial processes. However, noise pollution impacts on marine ecosystems have not yet been taken into account. This paper presents a first approach for the integration of noise impacts on marine ecosystems into the LCA framework by developing characterization factors (CF) for the North Sea. Noise pollution triggers a large variety of impact pathways, but as a starting point and proof-of-concept we assessed impacts on the avoidance behaviour of cetaceans due to pile-driving during the construction of offshore windfarms in the North Sea. Our approach regards the impact of avoidance behaviour as a temporary loss of habitat, and assumes a temporary loss of all individuals within that habitat from the total regional population. This was verified with an existing model that assessed the population-level effect of noise pollution on harbour porpoises (Phocoenaphocoena) in the North Sea. We expanded our CF to also include other cetacean species and tested it in a case study of the construction of an offshore windfarm (Prinses Amalia wind park). The total impact of noise pollution was in the same order of magnitude as impacts on other ecosystems from freshwater eutrophication, freshwater ecotoxicity, terrestrial acidification, and terrestrial ecotoxicity. Although there are still many improvements to be made to this approach, it provides a basis for the implementation of noise pollution impacts in an LCA framework, and has the potential to be expanded to other world regions and impact pathways.","author":["Verones, F.","Middel, H."],"organization":["Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)"],"originationDate":"2017-06-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Middel-Verones-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1575","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/east-anglia-three-preliminary-environmental-information-report-peir","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.scottishpowerrenewables.com\/pages\/east_anglia_three_project_documentation.aspx","title":"East Anglia THREE: Preliminary Environmental Information Report (PEIR)","description":"Preliminary Environmental Information East Anglia THREE Limited published the Preliminary Environmental Information Report (PEIR) for the proposed East Anglia THREE project in accordance with Section 42 of the Planning Act 2008. The documents that comprise this report are available below.  Introductory Chapters Chapter 1 Introduction  Chapter 1 Introduction - Figures  Chapter 2 Need for the Project  Chapter 3 Policy and Legislative Context  Chapter 4 Site Selection and Alternatives  Chapter 4 Site Selection and Alternatives - Figures  Chapter 5 Description of the Development  Chapter 5 Description of the Development - Figures  Chapter 5 Description of the Development - Appendices  Chapter 6 Environmental Impact Assessment Methodology    Offshore Chapters Chapter 7 Marine Geology, Oceanography and Physical Processes  Chapter 7 Marine Geology, Oceanography and Physical Processes - Figures  Chapter 7 Marine Geology, Oceanography and Physical Processes - Appendices  Chapter 8 Marine Water and Sediment Quality  Chapter 8 Marine Water and Sediment Quality - Figures    Chapter 9 Underwater Noise and Vibration and Electromagnetic Fields  Chapter 9 Underwater Noise and Vibration and Electromagnetic Fields - Appendices    Chapter 10 Benthic Ecology  Chapter 10 Benthic Ecology - Figures  Chapter 10 Benthic Ecology - Appendices    Chapter 11 Fish and Shellfish Ecology  Chapter 11 Fish and Shellfish Ecology - Figures  Chapter 11 Fish and Shellfish Ecology - Appendix 11.1  Chapter 11 Fish and Shellfish Ecology - Appendix 11.2    Chapter 12 Marine Mammal Ecology  Chapter 12 Marine Mammal Ecology - Appendices    Chapter 13 Offshore Ornithology  Chapter 13 Offshore Ornithology - Figures  Chapter 13 Offshore Ornithology - Appendices    Chapter 14 Commercial Fisheries  Chapter 14 Commercial Fisheries - Figures  Chapter 14 Commercial Fisheries - Appendices    Chapter 15 Shipping and Navigation Chapter 15 Shipping and Navigation - Figures  Chapter 15 Shipping and Navigation - Appendices    Chapter 16 Aviation and MoD  Chapter 16 Aviation and MoD - Figures  Chapter 16 Aviation and MoD - Appendices    Chapter 17 Offshore Archaeology and Cultural Heritage  Chapter 17 Offshore Archaeology and Cultural Heritage - Figures  Chapter 17 Offshore Archaeology and Cultural Heritage - Appendices    Chapter 18 Infrastructure and Other Users  Chapter 18 Infrastructure and Other Users - Figures    Onshore Chapters Chapter 19 Soils, Geology and Ground Conditions   Chapter 19 Soils, Geology and Ground Conditions - Figures   Chapter 19 Soils, Geology and Ground Conditions - Appendices    Chapter 20 Air Quality  Chapter 20 Air Quality - Figures  Chapter 20 Air Quality - Appendices    Chapter 21 Waster Resources and Flood Risk  Chapter 21 Water Resources and Flood Risk - Figures  Chapter 21 Water Resources and Flood Risk - Appendices    Chapter 22 Land Use  Chapter 22 Land Use - Figures  Chapter 22 Land Use - Appendices    Chapter 23 Ecology  Chapter 23 Ecology - Figures  Chapter 23 Ecology - Appendices    Chapter 24 Onshore Ornithology  Chapter 24 Onshore Ornithology - Figures  Chapter 24 Onshore Ornithology - Appendices    Chapter 25 Onshore Archaeology and Cultural Heritage  Chapter 25 Onshore Archaeology and Cultural Heritage - Figures  Chapter 25 Onshore Archaeology and Cultural Heritage - Appendices    Chapter 26 Noise and Vibration  Chapter 26 Noise and Vibration - Figures  Chapter 26 Noise and Vibration - Appendices    Chapter 27 Traffic and Transport  Chapter 27 Traffic and Transport - Figures  Chapter 27 Traffic and Transport - Appendices    Wider Scheme Aspects Chapter 28 Socio Economic  Chapter 28 Socio Economic - Figures  Chapter 28 Socio Economic - Appendices    Chapter 29 Seascape, Landscape and Visual Assessment  Chapter 29 Seascape, Landscape and Visual Assessment - Figures  Chapter 29 Seascape, Landscape and Visual Assessment - Appendices    Summary and Conclusion Chapter 30 Summary and Conclusion  Chapter 30 Summary and Conclusion - Appendices    Additional Documentation East Anglia THREE Preliminary Environmental Information Report Frontispiece  East Anglia THREE PEIR Acronyms   East Anglia THREE High Level Habitats Regulations Assessment Screening Report","author":["Royal Haskoning"],"organization":["Royal Haskoning","ScottishPower Renewables","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.664000000000","2.846000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA3-PIER-Non-Technical-Summary-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1576","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-eagle-fatalities-wind-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21086","title":"Predicting Eagle Fatalities at Wind Facilities","description":"The United States Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) recommends using a Bayesian modeling framework to predict the annual golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetos) fatality rate at a wind energy facility, and the modeling approach defines prior distributions for collision rate and exposure rate from data at existing wind projects. Collision rate is defined as the number of collisions per exposure. Exposure rate is a function of minutes of eagle activity and survey effort; we used site\u2010specific data to update the prior distribution, resulting in the posterior distribution. An expansion factor adjusts the fatality prediction by accounting for daylight hours and the hazardous area within a wind project footprint. The product of the collision rate, posterior exposure rate, and expansion factor is the predicted annual fatality rate. We reviewed the input data for the prior distribution for collision rate, and provided an updated prior distribution for collision rate using more contemporary information. As suggested by the current USFWS guidance, we updated the prior distribution for collision rate from the USFWS baseline model with data from a site with modern specifications to obtain an updated prior distribution. We also created alternative prior distributions by estimating parameters for the distributions from data at 26 modern facilities only. Using more recent data and a larger data set, we determined the predictions using the alternative prior distributions for collision rate are approximately half the estimates using the original distribution.","author":["Erickson, W.","Bay, K.","Kosciuch, K.","Taylor, K.","Nasman, K."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2016-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1577","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-ecology-female-mule-deer-area-proposed-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.jstor.org\/stable\/42003979","title":"Spatial Ecology of Female Mule Deer in an Area Proposed for Wind Energy Development","description":"Development for wind energy is increasing rapidly across the United States, particularly in Wyoming, despite a general lack of information on the potential interaction development could have on wildlife species. Therefore, knowledge of the space use and movement patterns of individuals can help define spatial distributions and management unit boundaries for populations prior to development. Such knowledge can also be used as baseline data from which to assess any future impacts on animal populations. We investigated the spatial ecology of female mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus; n = 18) equipped with global positioning system collars from 23 February 2011 to 15 January 2012 in an area along the Wyoming-Colorado border that has been proposed for wind energy development. The objectives of this study were to collect predevelopment baseline estimates of annual and seasonal home-range and core area size and fidelity, movement between seasonal ranges, changes in the use of elevation, and movement patterns at 2 temporal resolutions (i.e., within-season diel patterns and year-round diurnal and nocturnal movements by week). Annual size of home ranges averaged 2495 ha (SE = 121), whereas size of core areas averaged 310 ha (SE = 30). Seasonal site fidelity was substantial (81.1%, SE = 5.7) between successive cool-season ranges. Migration distances between cool-and warm-season home ranges were minimal (spring migration = 1319 m; autumn migration = 1342 m). Deer exhibited crepuscular movement patterns (peaks near 06: 00 and 18: 00) during the warm season but showed a diurnal movement pattern during the cool season (peak from 06: 00 to 15: 00). Partuition influenced movement during the warm season; movement was much reduced during a period from mid-June to mid-July. Deer in this population appear to be year-round residents that exhibit strong seasonal and annual fidelity to previously established ranges and modify movement patterns in relation to general changes in environmental conditions (e.g., snow). These findings can be used to define seasonally important ranges and formulate boundaries and sizes of game management units. Understanding fine-scale temporal movement allows the development of strategies that could minimize disturbance to deer while allowing for development or recreation.","author":["Kosciuch, K.","Webb, S.","Dzialak, M.","Winstead, J.","Houchen, D."],"organization":["Hayden-Wind Associates LLC","Tetra Tech Inc."],"originationDate":"2013-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1578","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/breeding-bird-surveys-arkwright-summit-wind-project-chautauqua-county-new-york","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.edpr.com\/north-america\/sites\/edprna\/files\/2020-09\/Arkwright-Summit-ArkwrightSummit_SEIS2_AppendixH-2_BreedingBirdSurveys_0.pdf","title":"Breeding Bird Surveys Arkwright Summit Wind Project Chautauqua County, New York","description":"EDP Renewables (EDPR) has proposed to develop the Arkwright Summit Wind Project (Project) in Chautauqua County, New York. EDPR contracted Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) to conduct breeding bird surveys within the proposed Project Area to assist in evaluating potential impacts that the development of a wind energy facility, associated construction, and operations might have on breeding birds in the Project area. The principal objectives of the study were to: 1) provide site-specific data on avian resources and use of the Project area that would be useful in evaluating potential impacts from the proposed wind energy facility, 2) provide information that could be useful in project planning and design of the facility to minimize potential impacts to birds, and 3) recommend further studies or potential mitigation measures, if warranted.","author":["Bay, K.","Young, D.","Lukins, W."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2013-11-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lukins-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1579","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysis-overlap-between-priority-greater-sage-grouse-habitats-existing-potential","sourceURL":"https:\/\/westernvaluesproject.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2014\/10\/Greater-Sage-Grouse-Priority-Habitats-and-Energy-Development.pdf","title":"Analysis of the Overlap between Priority Greater Sage-Grouse Habitats and Existing and Potential Energy Development Across the West: Final Report","description":"Greater sage-grouse have experienced range-wide population declines, and many monitored populations have declined, on average 2% per year since 1965. Decline in greater sage-grouse populations has been attributed to degradation of sagebrush habitats from disturbance factors, including agricultural conversion, invasions of exotic plants leading to increased fire frequencies, and, more recently, energy exploration and development. Greater sage-grouse was proposed to be listed as an endangered or threatened species under the Endangered Species Act (ESA) of 1973, and in 2010, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) found that the proposed listing was warranted but precluded by higher priority listing actions. The USFWS is required to issue its proposed listing decision in September 2015. The impending listing decision of greater sagegrouse has prompted an inter-state, inter-agency planning effort by federal agencies and states within the greater sage-grouse range. Each state mapped key greater sage-grouse habitats and the USFWS used these as the basis for identifying Priority Areas for Conservation (PACs). Loss of habitat as a result of further infrastructure development within the PACs, among other factors, would reduce long-term viability of sage-grouse populations.  The objectives of this study are twofold:  1. to evaluate the overlap between the PACs and existing leases and rights-of-way (ROWs) for coal, oil and gas, solar and wind energy development on federal lands and minerals; and  2. to analyze the development potential for oil and gas, solar, and wind energy on federal lands and minerals within the PACs and compare that to the development potential for lands outside of the PACs.  We restricted the analysis to seven states that include 92% of the PACs: Colorado, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, Oregon, Utah and Wyoming. We further restricted the analysis to federal lands and minerals that are managed by the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) and United States Forest Service (FS). We acquired energy development leases and ROWs from the BLM\u2019s LR2000 and energy development potential from various sources, and then used this information to calculate the acreages and percentages included in this study.","author":["LeBeau, C.","Boehrs, J.","Fruhwirth, J."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Western Values Project"],"originationDate":"2014-10-16","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/LeBeau-et-al-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1580","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-shoreline-effect-marine-energy-farms-different-coastal-environments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.e3s-conferences.org\/articles\/e3sconf\/abs\/2018\/26\/e3sconf_icacer2018_03005\/e3sconf_icacer2018_03005.html","title":"Evaluation of the shoreline effect of the marine energy farms in different coastal environments","description":"The objective of the proposed work is to assess the possible effects on the shoreline dynamics of the marine energy farms. Three different coastal environments have been considered as case studies. The first area is located in the Portuguese continental nearshore at the European western coast of the Atlantic Ocean. The second in the Mediterranean Sea in the coastal environment of Sardinia Island and the third on the western side of the Black Sea in the Romanian nearshore. Besides the fact that, from a geographical point of view, the three areas targeted are located in very different zones, they represent also coastal environments with very different characteristics. A computational framework joining a spectral phase averaged wave model with a 1D parametric circulation model has been used. The numerical models are SWAN (acronym from Simulating Waves Nearshore) for the waves and NSSM (the Navy Standard Surf Model) for estimating the longshore currents. For each case study, the main characteristics of the environmental matrix have been analyzed first. Then, various transmission scenarios have been, designed considering also in each case different distances from the marine energy farm to the shoreline. A general conclusion of the proposed work is that the longshore currents are very sensitive to the presence of the marine energy farms and that is why such farms can also play an active role in coastal protection. Moreover, since it presents in parallel similar analyses for three coastal environments that have very different features, the present study provides a more comprehensive picture concerning the medium to long term impact on the shoreline dynamics of the future marine energy farms operating in the nearshore.","author":["Rusu, E.","Onea, F."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-08-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rusu-Onea-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1581","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-autumn-migration-rare-soaring-raptor-identifies-new-movement-corridors","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0304380015000666","title":"Modeling autumn migration of a rare soaring raptor identifies new movement corridors in central Appalachia","description":"Understanding animal movements is fundamental to ecology and conservation, yet direct measurement of movements of birds is both challenging and costly. Raptor behavior and demography are especially difficult to monitor, but models of movement can provide information toward this goal. The golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetos) in eastern North America is an apex predator of regional conservation concern, and little is known about its population ecology, movements, or behavior. We designed an agent-based model to simulate autumn migration of eagles in Pennsylvania, USA. Inputs to the model included information on regional topography, known flight behaviors (i.e. slope-soaring and thermal-soaring and gliding), estimated uplift, and a principal axis of migration. In total, we modeled 6094 flight routes, averaging 2191 (+\/- 1281; +\/- SD; range: 3-5373) moves. Simulations were spatially comparable to historic flight route data collected via telemetry and generally followed topography that provided uplift. In our model, orographic uplift available to migrant eagles was stronger and more frequent than thermal uplift, and uplift forms were not correlated with one another (r=-0.145). Modeled golden eagle migration in autumn follows a narrow-front pattern as individuals are concentrated in areas that produce orographic uplift. Simulated flights were more concentrated on days when historic counts of golden eagles were high at monitoring sites. In contrast, simulations were more dispersed on days when fewer actual eagles were recorded. We used output from our simulations to select new sites that could be used for monitoring migratory raptors. Relatively large numbers of golden eagles were observed at these sites, thus validating performance of our model. This work identifies a novel, cost-effective method for modeling migration patterns of and furthering conservation goals for a rare, low-density raptor species.","author":["Duerr, A.","Katzner, T.","Brandes, D.","Dennhardt, A."],"organization":["West Virginia University","Lafayette College"],"originationDate":"2015-05-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1582","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-environmental-assessment-tool-seat-modeling-tool-evaluate-potential","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/11\/8\/2036","title":"Spatial Environmental Assessment Tool (SEAT): A Modeling Tool to Evaluate Potential Environmental Risks Associated with Wave Energy Converter Deployments","description":"Wave energy converter (WEC) arrays deployed in coastal regions may create physical disturbances, potentially resulting in environmental stresses. Presently, limited information is available on the nature of these physical disturbance or the resultant effects. A quantitative Spatial Environmental Assessment Tool (SEAT) for evaluating the potential effects of wave energy converter (WEC) arrays on nearshore hydrodynamics and sediment transport is presented for the central Oregon coast (USA) through coupled numerical model simulations of an array of WECs. Derived climatological wave conditions were used as inputs to the model to allow for the calculation of risk metrics associated with various hydrodynamic and sediment transport variables such as maximum shear stress, bottom velocity, and change in bed elevation. The risk maps provided simple, quantitative, and spatially-resolved means of evaluating physical changes in the vicinity of a hypothetical WEC array in response to varying wave conditions. The near-field risk of sediment mobility was determined to be moderate in the lee of the densely spaced array, where the potential for increased sediment deposition could result in benthic habitat alteration. Modifications to the nearshore sediment deposition and erosion patterns were observed near headlands and topographic features, which could have implications for littoral sediment transport. The results illustrate the benefits of a risk evaluation tool for facilitating coastal resource management at early market marine renewable energy sites.","author":["Chang, G.","Roberts, J.","Jones, C.","McWilliams, S.","Dallman, A.","Raghukumar, K."],"organization":["Integral Consulting Inc","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Jones-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1583","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interpreting-failure-reject-null-hypothesis-displacement-wind-turbines-three-species","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1650\/CONDOR-16-71.1","title":"Interpreting failure to reject the null hypothesis of displacement from wind turbines in three species of grassland birds: Response to Johnson (2016)","description":"Johnson (2016) criticized our 3-year study investigating displacement in breeding grassland birds at an operational wind facility in the southern Great Plains. Although Johnson characterized our statistical methods as inappropriate and our study as intentionally misleading, his claims are based on his own view of the appropriate analysis and interpretation. Although we failed to reject the null hypothesis of no displacement in breeding grassland birds at our study site, the main message of our manuscript was a cautionary tale\u2014that is, that at many wind facilities it will be difficult to isolate the effect of distance to turbine from other factors that covary with distance.","author":["Hale, A."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Passerines","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1584","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/how-anthropogenic-noise-affects-foraging","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/gcb.12997","title":"How anthropogenic noise affects foraging","description":"The influence of human activity on the biosphere is increasing. While direct damage (e.g. habitat destruction) is relatively well understood, many activities affect wildlife in less apparent ways. Here, we investigate how anthropogenic noise impairs foraging, which has direct consequences for animal survival and reproductive success. Noise can disturb foraging via several mechanisms that may operate simultaneously, and thus, their effects could not be disentangled hitherto. We developed a diagnostic framework that can be applied to identify the potential mechanisms of disturbance in any species capable of detecting the noise. We tested this framework using Daubenton\u0027s bats, which find prey by echolocation. We found that traffic noise reduced foraging efficiency in most bats. Unexpectedly, this effect was present even if the playback noise did not overlap in frequency with the prey echoes. Neither overlapping noise nor nonoverlapping noise influenced the search effort required for a successful prey capture. Hence, noise did not mask prey echoes or reduce the attention of bats. Instead, noise acted as an aversive stimulus that caused avoidance response, thereby reducing foraging efficiency. We conclude that conservation policies may seriously underestimate numbers of species affected and the multilevel effects on animal fitness, if the mechanisms of disturbance are not considered.","author":["Luo, J.","Siemers, B.","Koselj, K."],"organization":["Max Planck Institute for Ornithology","Northeast Normal University"],"originationDate":"2015-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1585","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-mirrors-sensory-traps-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/science.sciencemag.org\/content\/357\/6355\/1045","title":"Acoustic mirrors as sensory traps for bats","description":"Sensory traps pose a considerable and often fatal risk for animals, leading them to misinterpret their environment. Bats predominantly rely on their echolocation system to forage, orientate, and navigate. We found that bats can mistake smooth, vertical surfaces as clear flight paths, repeatedly colliding with them, likely as a result of their acoustic mirror properties. The probability of collision is influenced by the number of echolocation calls and by the amount of time spent in front of the surface. The echolocation call analysis corroborates that bats perceive smooth, vertical surfaces as open flyways. Reporting on occurrences with different species in the wild, we argue that it is necessary to more closely monitor potentially dangerous locations with acoustic mirror properties (such as glass fronts) to assess the true frequency of fatalities around these sensory traps.","author":["Greif, S.","Zsebok, S."],"organization":["Max Planck Institute for Ornithology","Tel Aviv University"],"originationDate":"2017-09-08","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1586","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/greater-sage-grouse-male-lek-counts-relative-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/wsb.725","title":"Greater sage-grouse male lek counts relative to a wind energy development","description":"Wind energy development is an emerging source of anthropogenic disturbance that could affect greater sage\u2010grouse (Centrocercus urophasianus; sage\u2010grouse) populations. Our objective was to determine the response of male sage\u2010grouse attending leks (lek counts) to wind energy development using a before\/after\u2013control\/treatment study design. We counted males attending each lek within control and treatment areas annually and analyzed peak numbers. We obtained lek count data from 5 treatment and 9 control leks over an 11\u2010year period. We estimated trends in lek counts pre\u2010 (2006\u20132008) and postdevelopment (2009\u20132016) using a generalized linear mixed negative binomial model. We considered time lags at which the effect of the wind energy development was realized by the male breeding population. Although all lek counts were apparently in decline prior to development and trends on the control and treatment area changed during postdevelopment, we found no negative differences in the relative trends in lek counts between control and treatment areas between pre\u2010 and postdevelopment periods. We detected a 56% drop in lek counts at treatment leks relative to control leks assuming the effect of the wind energy development was realized between 2010 and 2011 (i.e., 3\u2009yr postdevelopment). Use of\u00a0a posteriori\u00a0power analysis estimated similar data sets would have 80% probability of detecting a 28% decrease in the rate of decline of lek counts at treatment leks relative to control leks after development. Our findings suggest males attending leks in close proximity to wind energy development may respond differently compared with leks in close proximity to other forms of anthropogenic features, adding to a growing body of literature regarding the potential effects of energy development on prairie grouse. We recommend additional research and an abundance of caution in designating buffer sizes","author":["Johnson, G.","LeBeau, C.","Holloran, M.","Beck, J.","Nielson, R.","McDonald, T.","Gerow, K."],"organization":["University of Wyoming","Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Wyoming Wildlife Consultants"],"originationDate":"2017-03-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.759422000000","-106.393169000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1587","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seabird-distribution-abundance-offshore-environment-final-report","sourceURL":"","title":"Seabird Distribution and Abundance in the Offshore Environment Final Report","description":"Seabirds are wide-ranging upper trophic level foragers and good indicators of changes in marine ecosystems. Seabirds spend most of the year offshore, yet our data gaps are greatest for the pelagic aspect of their lives. The goal of the Seabirds Offshore Project was to conduct at-sea surveys in lease sale areas and adjacent ocean planning areas, to provide current temporal and spatial data on marine birds and mammals, and submit the data to the North Pacific Pelagic Seabird Database (NPPSD). During this project, 2010-2016, we placed seabird observers on 45 research and monitoring vessels, usually in association with multidisciplinary ecosystem projects. Because many of these cruises transited from southern Alaska ports, we included all surveyed routes in this report. We surveyed a total of 97,525 km, with the majority (31,497 km) in the Chukchi Sea, followed by the southern Bering Sea (30,265 km), northern Bering Sea (26,326 km) and Beaufort Sea (9,438 km). Our survey coverage extended from the northern GOA shelf to the eastern Aleutian Islands, north throughout the Bering Sea shelf, into the eastern Chukchi Sea, and the western Beaufort Sea shelf, including the Arctic Basin. The seabird survey data collected under the Seabirds Offshore Project has been included in over 30 presentations and 17 publications to date, as well as at least 12 public outreach and education venues and 7 websites. We have described seasonal distribution patterns of seabirds in offshore waters of Alaska, and identified \u2018hotspots\u2019 of foraging and migration activity. Through several collaborative projects, including on-going efforts, we have linked seabird survey data to oceanographic and prey data collected during concurrent cruises, and from remote sensing data. These efforts test hypotheses about the distribution of upper trophic level predators in response to changes in prey and ice cover. All seabird data collected during this project has been submitted to the NPPSD, to the Alaska BOEM office, and to affiliated ecosystem projects (available via Alaska Ocean Observing System work spaces).","author":["Kuletz, K.","Labunski, E."],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Seabird-distribution-and-abundance.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1588","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/surface-texture-differentiation-using-synthetic-bat-echolocation-calls-implications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.tcu.edu\/handle\/116099117\/10244","title":"Surface Texture Differentiation Using Synthetic Bat Echolocation Calls: Implications for Reducing Bat Fatalities at Wind Turbines","description":"Wind power is a fast-growing renewable energy source with great potential to reduce pollution, water consumption, and greenhouse gas emissions (Ledec 2011, REN21 2015). Nevertheless, the large numbers of dead bats that have been discovered beneath operating wind turbines have raised concerns about its environmental sustainability (Kunz et al. 2007, Arnett et al. 2008). From 2000 to 2011, bat mortality at utility-scale wind turbines in North America was estimated to be 650,000 to 1,300,000 bats, which translates to an annual fatality rate of 54,000 to 108,000 bats per year (Arnett and Baerwald 2013). However, due to continued growth in the wind energy industry, the estimated mortality in 2012 alone was \u003E600,000 bats (Hayes 2013, but see Huso and Dalthorp 2014). Three migratory, tree-roosting bat species (collectively known as tree bats), the hoary bat (Lasiurus cinereus), eastern red bat (Lasiurus borealis), and silver-haired bat (Lasionycteris noctivagans), make up 78% of total fatalities with peak fatality rates occurring between July and October, which coincides with fall migration (Kunz et al. 2007, Baerwald and Barclay 2011, Arnett and Baerwald 2013, Hein et al. 2013). Although reliable population estimates are lacking for these and other affected bat species, annual fatalities at wind turbines may have population-level consequences because bats are long-lived and have low reproductive rates which limits their ability to recover from declines (Barclay and Harder 2003, O\u0027Shea et al. 2003, Brunet-Rossinni and Austad 2004, Podlutsky et al. 2005).\n\nAt present, we have a good understanding of the proximate causes of bat fatalities at wind energy facilities (collision with rotating wind turbine blades and barotrauma; Baerwald et al. 2008, Grodsky et al. 2011, Rollins et al. 2012). Nevertheless, we still do not have a good understanding of the reasons bats come in close proximity to wind turbines. Three broad hypotheses have been proposed to this end: (1) random chance, where wind turbine kills are simply a representative sample of bat abundance and activity in an area; (2) coincidence, where some aspect of bats\u2019 ecology (e.g., migration) brings them in close proximity to wind turbines; and (3) attraction, where bats are attracted to wind turbines because wind turbines provide resources, bats perceive wind turbines to be resources, or bats are simply curious about wind turbines (Cryan and Barclay 2009). While some bat species and individual bats are likely to be at wind turbines due to random chance and coincidence, these two hypotheses alone do not appear to be able to explain the emerging patterns of bat fatalities (Kunz et al. 2007, Arnett et al. 2008, Hein et al. 2013).\n\nThe bat species commonly comprising fatalities at wind energy facilities all use echolocation rather than sight to navigate and capture prey (Barclay 1986, Obrist and Wenstrup 1998). McAlexander (2013) suggested that if the acoustic similarity between wind turbine towers and water contributes to bat-wind turbine collisions, then steps to reduce the similarity between wind turbine towers and water should reduce bat fatality rates at wind turbines. We hypothesized that incorporating texture additives (e.g., sand) as part of the wind turbine paint coating could alter the acoustic properties of wind turbine towers such that ultrasonic echoes returning from these modified towers could be differentiated from those returning from smooth surfaces. We further hypothesized that addition of texture additives with larger particle sizes would result in greater acoustic differences from smooth surfaces. As an initial step in testing these hypotheses, we conducted an ultrasonic playback experiment with the objective of determining the extent to which these modified surfaces could be differentiated from smooth surfaces using synthetic bat echolocation calls. In order to achieve our objective, we characterized the acoustic features of echoes returning from synthetic bat echolocation calls played at a range of smooth and textured surfaces.","author":["Yuen, B."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2015-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.708961000000","-97.360357000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1589","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-development-specialist-report-kiowa-rita-blanca-black-kettle-mcclellan","sourceURL":"https:\/\/permanent.access.gpo.gov\/gpo73379\/65916_FSPLT2_067345%5b1%5d.pdf","title":"Wind Energy Development Specialist Report: Kiowa, Rita Blanca, Black Kettle and McClellan Creek National Grasslands Plan Revision Environmental Impact Statement","description":"This report discloses and evaluates the potential environmental consequences on the wind energy development resource as permitted by special use authorization that may result with the adoption of a revised land management plan. It examines, in detail, three different alternatives for revising the management direction from the 1985 Cibola National Forest Land Management Plan (only that which is relevant to the National Grasslands).","author":["Hall, D."],"organization":["US Forest Service","US Department of Agriculture (USDA)"],"originationDate":"2011-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hall_2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1590","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/quantifying-health-environmental-benefits-wind-power-natural-gas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S030142151200969X","title":"Quantifying the Health and Environmental Benefits of Wind Power to Natural Gas","description":"How tangible are the costs of natural gas compared to the benefits of one of the fastest growing sources of electricity \u2013 wind energy \u2013 in the United States? To answer this question, this article calculates the benefits of wind energy derived from two locations: the 580\u00a0MW wind farm at Altamont Pass, CA, and the 22\u00a0MW wind farm in Sawtooth, ID. Both wind farms have environmental and economic benefits that should be considered when evaluating the comparative costs of natural gas and wind energy. Though there are uncertainties within the data collected, for the period 2012\u20132031, the turbines at Altamont Pass will likely avoid anywhere from $560 million to $4.38 billion in human health and climate related externalities, and the turbines at Sawtooth will likely avoid $18 million to $104 million of human health and climate-related externalities. Translating these negative externalities into a cost per kWh of electricity, we estimate that Altamont will avoid costs of 1.8\u201311.8 cents\/kWh and Sawtooth will avoid costs of 1.5\u20138.2 cents\/kWh.","author":["Sovacool, B.","McCubbin, D."],"organization":["Vermont Law School"],"originationDate":"2013-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Health \u0026 Safety"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-12 08:19:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1591","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impact-offshore-wind-farms-geolocalized-life-cycle-assessment-lca","sourceURL":"https:\/\/hal.archives-ouvertes.fr\/hal-00912879\/","title":"Environmental Impact for Offshore Wind Farms: Geolocalized Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) Approach","description":"This paper presents an approach for Environmental Impact Assessment through the use of geolocalized LCA approach, for fixed and floating offshore wind farms. This work was undertaken within the EU-sponsored EnerGEO project, aiming at providing a versatile modeling platform for stakeholders allowing calculation, forecasting and monitoring of environmental impacts of different sources of energy. This paper described the geolocalized LCA approach, and its use for the evaluation of environmental impacts of wind energy. The effects of offshore wind farms on global environnemental impacts are evaluated though the LCA approach. It takes into account the type of wind farm, the construction phase, all technical aspects, the operation and maintenance scheme and the decommissioning. It also includes geolocalized information such as wind resources, bathymetry, accessibility. Environmental impact parameters are accessible through a web service helping the decision makers in assessing the environnemental impacts.","author":["Guermont, C.","Blanc, I.","Ranchin, T.","Menard, L.","Gschwind, B."],"organization":["MINES ParisTech"],"originationDate":"2013-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OCOSS2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1592","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-energy-wildlife-synthesis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/hwi\/vol10\/iss1\/10\/","title":"Impact of Wind Energy on Wildlife: Synthesis","description":"Humankind on Earth is desperate for energy. Fossil fuels including coal, oil, and natural gas have served as the main energy source since oil\u2019s discovery by Colonel Drake in Titusville, Pennsylvania during 1857, with the first well drilled in 1859 (Hubbert 1949). However, 2 issues have become gravely important regarding our use of fossil fuels. It is estimated that there are \u0026lt;44 years of oil remaining, with primary oil fields already showing declines in production (BP 2015). Secondly, continued fossil fuel consumption will only exacerbate effects of global climate change (Baes et al. 1977). Therefore, the search for new sources of renewable energy not based on fossil fuels has begun. One promising source is wind energy. Consequently, we invited the key scientists, knowledgeable on wind energy impacts on wildlife, to contribute to this Special Topic volume. We hope that you agree after reading these papers that wind energy development is an important energy source, but also a profoundly important mortality factor for 2 ecologically important types of wildlife: our avifauna and chiropterans.","author":["Hutchins, M.","Leopold, B."],"organization":["Mississippi State University","American Bird Conservancy"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Leopold-Hutchins-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1593","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/abcs-bird-smart-wind-energy-campaign-protecting-birds-poorly-sited-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/hwi\/vol10\/iss1\/9\/","title":"ABC\u0027s Bird-Smart Wind Energy Campaign: Protecting Birds from Poorly Sited Wind Energy Development","description":"This article summarizes American Bird Conservancy\u2019s (ABC\u2019s) strategies and goals for achieving Bird-Smart wind energy in the United States. We describe the current and projected impact of wind energy development on birds and bats in the United States. We also discuss how bird (and bat) conservation goals could be made more compatible with wind energy development through improved science and regulation. We provide examples of poorly sited wind energy projects, existing and proposed, which call into question the efficacy of current voluntary federal permitting guidelines. We discuss the need for improved transparency and independent site-by-site pre-construction risk assessment, science-based decision-making, independent collection and reporting of post-construction bird (and bat) fatality data, and consideration of cumulative impacts.","author":["Schroeder, D.","Hutchins, M.","Parr, M."],"organization":["American Bird Conservancy"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hutchins-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1594","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/synthesis-wind-energy-development-potential-impacts-wildlife-pacific-northwest-oregon","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fs.usda.gov\/treesearch\/pubs\/40988","title":"Synthesis of Wind Energy Development and Potential Impacts on Wildlife in the Pacific Northwest, Oregon and Washington","description":"Nationally, there is growing public interest in and policy pressure for developing alternative and renewable sources of energy. Wind energy facilities in the Pacific Northwest expanded rapidly over the past decade, as a result of state policies that encourage wind energy development. While much of the development thus far has occurred on private lands, there is interest in expanding onto federal land. However, there are concerns about the impacts of wind energy on wildlife. Wind energy facilities have the potential to harm wildlife both directly through collisions with turbines and transmission lines, and indirectly by modifying habitat. This report synthesizes the available scientific literature on potential wind energy facility impacts to wildlife, with a focus on the Pacific Northwest (Oregon and Washington), and summarizes the current best management practices recommended in federal and state guidelines for wind energy development. Research gaps in our understanding of wind energy impacts on wildlife remain. Future research needs include long-term, multisite, experimental studies of wind energy impacts on wildlife, improved ability to estimate population-level and cumulative impacts of wind energy facilities on wildlife, and better knowledge of key wildlife species\u2019 migration and demography.","author":["Mockrin, M.","Gravenmier, R."],"organization":["US Forest Service","US Department of Agriculture (USDA)","US Forest Service"],"originationDate":"2012-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/PNW-GTR-863.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1595","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-development-methods-assessing-risks-birds-bats-pre-construction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/hwi\/vol10\/iss1\/6\/","title":"Wind Energy Development: Methods for Assessing Risks to Birds and Bats Pre-Construction","description":"Wind power generation is rapidly expanding. Although wind power is a low-carbon source of energy, it can impact negatively birds and bats, either directly through fatality or indirectly by displacement or habitat loss. Pre-construction risk assessment at wind facilities within the United States is usually required only on public lands. When conducted, it generally involves a 3-tier process, with each step leading to more detailed and rigorous surveys. Preliminary site assessment (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Tier 1) is usually conducted remotely and involves evaluation of existing databases and published materials. If potentially at-risk wildlife are present and the developer wishes to continue the development process, then on-site surveys are conducted (Tier 2) to verify the presence of those species and to assess site-specific features (e.g., topography, land cover) that may influence risk from turbines. The next step in the process (Tier 3) involves quantitative or scientific studies to assess the potential risk of the proposed project to wildlife. Typical Tier-3 research may involve acoustic, aural, observational, radar, capture, tracking, or modeling studies, all designed to understand details of risk to specific species or groups of species at the given site. Our review highlights several features lacking from many risk assessments, particularly the paucity of before-and-aftercontrol-impact (BACI) studies involving modeling and a lack of understanding of cumulative effects of wind facilities on wildlife. Both are essential to understand effective designs for pre-construction monitoring and both would help expand risk assessment beyond eagles.","author":["Duerr, A.","Bennett, V.","Hale, A.","Katzner, T.","Miller, T.","Braham, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","Texas Christian University","West Virginia University"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Katzner-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1596","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/avian-fatalities-wind-energy-facilities-north-america-comparison-recent-approaches","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/hwi\/vol10\/iss1\/3\/","title":"Avian Fatalities at Wind Energy Facilities in North America: A Comparison of Recent Approaches","description":"Three recent publications have estimated the number of birds killed each year by wind energy facilities at 2012 build-out levels in the United States. The 3 publications differ in scope, methodology, and resulting estimates. We compare and contrast characteristics of the approaches used in the publications. In addition, we describe decisions made in obtaining the estimates that were produced. Despite variation in the 3 approaches, resulting estimates were reasonably similar; about a quarter- to a half-million birds are killed per year by colliding with wind turbines.","author":["Erickson, W.","Johnson, D.","Loss, S.","Smallwood, K."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","Oklahoma State University","Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Johnson-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1597","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/special-topic-wildlife-wind-energy-are-they-compatible","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/hwi\/vol10\/iss1\/2\/","title":"Special Topic: Wildlife and Wind Energy: Are They Compatible?","description":"The world is hungry for energy, and with growing concerns about the exacerbating effects of burning fossil fuels on climate change, there has been a profound demand for and, thus, rapid growth of clean, renewable energy sources, such as solar and wind. The United States is one of the world\u2019s leaders in wind energy development. As of September 2014, there were 46,600 operational wind turbines, having a total generating capacity of 62,300 mW. An additional 1,254 mW came online in 2014, and there are currently 13,600 mW under construction (Today\u2019s Energy Solutions 2014). In addition, the U.S. Department of Energy recently revised its original estimate of 20% of electrical energy being produced by wind by 2030 to a projected 35% by 2050 (Jackson 2015). This would mean tens of thousands of new turbines, many of which may be 152 to 213 m high, with blades as long as a football field, traveling at up to 274 km per hour. It would also mean hundreds of kilometers of new power lines and towers to carry this power into the national grid (Wernau 2014), both of which pose a substantial risk to wildlife, primarily birds, through collision and electrocution (Manville 2005, Loss et al. 2014).","author":["Hutchins, M.","Leopold, B."],"organization":["American Bird Conservancy","Mississippi State University"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hutchins-Leopold-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1598","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-energy-bats-summary-our-current-knowledge","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/hwi\/vol10\/iss1\/4\/","title":"Impact of Wind Energy on Bats: A Summary of Our Current Knowledge","description":"Since 2003, when it was discovered that large numbers of bats were being killed at wind turbines in the eastern United States, our understanding of the impact of wind energy development on bats has increased and consistent patterns of fatality, including seasonality and species composition have become evident. Yet, many questions remain despite the wealth of data collected across numerous post-construction monitoring studies. We synthesized the recent literature to provide an overview of our current understanding of patterns of bat fatalities at wind energy facilities in the United States and Canada. Our understanding of the impact of wind energy development on bats continues to be hindered by inconsistencies among studies and lack of publicly available data. It will be difficult to fully address this complex issue and develop sustainable strategies to reduce the impact of wind turbines on bats and generate wind energy without standardized protocols for field methods, estimation of fatality, and greater cooperation among stakeholders.","author":["Hein, C.","Schirmacher, M."],"organization":["Bat Conservation International"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hein-Schirmacher-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1599","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-energy-development-humans","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nap.edu\/read\/11935\/chapter\/6","title":"Impacts of Wind-Energy Development on Humans","description":"This chapter addresses some key potential human impacts, positive and negative, of wind-energy projects on people in surrounding areas. The impacts discussed here include aesthetic impacts; impacts on cultural resources such as historic and archeological sites and recreation sites; impacts on human health and well-being, specifically, from noise and from shadow flicker; economic and fiscal impacts; and the potential for electromagnetic interference with television and radio broadcasting, cellular phones, and radar.  Chapter from the book Environmental Impacts of Wind-Energy Projects","author":["National Research Council of the National Academies (NRC)"],"organization":["National Research Council of the National Academies (NRC)"],"originationDate":"2007-08-27","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1600","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-bugs-wind-turbines-there-connection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.tcu.edu\/handle\/116099117\/4451","title":"Bats, Bugs, and Wind Turbines - Is There a Connection?","description":"Large numbers of migratory tree-bats are being killed at wind turbines worldwide and it remains unclear why this is happening. The purpose of this study was to test the hypothesis that prey items for bats are abundant in the immediate vicinity of wind turbines. During the 2012 fall migratory season (July to October), we used light taps and malaise traps to sample the aerial invertebrate community at Wolf Ridge Wind, LLC, in north-central Texas. Overall, we collected more invertebrates and a greater number of species earlier in the season compared to later in the season and the use of malaise traps significantly added to invertebrate diversity yielded by light traps. Invertebrate abundance and species richness did not differ between the base of turbines and 400 m away, but compilation of data from previous bat diet studies suggested that the area around wind turbines provided foraging resources for local bats. Further research is needed, however, to determine if bats are attracted to wind turbines as a foraging resource.","author":["Cochran, C."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2013-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.731538000000","-97.405052000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1601","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecological-effects-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nap.edu\/read\/11935\/chapter\/5","title":"Ecological Effects of Wind-Energy Development","description":"At regional to global scales, the effects of wind energy on the environment often are considered to be positive, through the production of renewable energy and the potential displacement of mining activities, air pollution, and greenhouse gas emissions associated with nonrenewable energy sources (see Chapter 2). However, wind-energy facilities have been demonstrated to kill birds and bats and there is evidence that wind-energy development also can result in the loss of habitat for some species. To the extent that we understand how, when, and where wind-energy development most adversely affects organisms and their habitat, it will be possible to mitigate future impacts through careful siting decisions. In this chapter, we review the effects of wind-energy development on ecosystem structure and functioning, through direct effects of turbines on organisms, and on landscapes through alteration and displacement. We recommend a research and monitoring framework for reducing these impacts. Although the focus of our analysis is the Mid-Atlantic Highlands, we use all available information to assess general impacts. Although other sources of development on sites that are suitable for wind-energy development affect wildlife and their habitats (e.g., mineral extraction, cutting of timber), and there are other sources of anthropogenic mortality to animals, as stated previously, this committee was charged to focus on wind energy, and therefore did not conduct a comprehensive comparative analysis of impacts from other sources of development.\n\nChapter from the book Environmental Impacts of Wind-Energy Projects","author":["National Resource Council"],"organization":["National Research Council of the National Academies (NRC)"],"originationDate":"2007-08-27","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1602","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/aerial-hawking-bats-can-glean-prey-items-surfaces-similar-wind-turbine-towers","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.tcu.edu\/handle\/116099117\/10934","title":"Aerial-Hawking Bats Can Glean Prey Items From Surfaces Similar to Wind Turbine Towers: Implications for Reducing Bat Fatalities at Wind Facilities","description":"Wind turbines have been linked to high numbers of bat fatalities worldwide (Voigt et al. 2012; Hayes 2013; Lehnert et al. 2014), with estimates of over 600,000 bats killed in the US alone for the year of 2012 (Hayes 2013). Within the US, the majority of bats killed at wind turbines are echolocating, insectivorous, migratory species that roost in trees (the top 3 species collected in carcass searches at wind turbines are the hoary (Lasiurus cinereus), eastern red (Lasiurus borealis), and silver-haired (Lasionycteris noctivagans) bat; reviewed in Arnett and Baerwald 2013; Schuster et al. 2015). Many of\u00a0these fatalities correlate with nights with lower wind speeds, as bats will often restrict their movement during periods of strong wind velocities, and between the mid-summer to early autumn months, a time in which migratory bats will relocate to their winter habitats (Horn 2008; Arnett et al. 2011). A possible strategy to reduce fatalities has been to increase the cut-in speed (the speed at which a wind turbine begins to produce electricity); however, this mitigation measure results in a decrease in the amount of electricity produced by the wind turbines. Furthermore, the ultimate causes, why the bats are coming close enough to be hit by the wind turbine blades, remain largely unknown (Kunz et al. 2007; Arnett et al. 2008).\n\nMcAlexander (2013) also demonstrated that wind turbine towers are acoustically similar to smooth surfaces such as water. Based on this result, we hypothesized that the smooth surface of a wind turbine tower could act as an acoustic mirror, and any invertebrates aggregating on the light-colored surface may represent a readily accessible foraging resource for bats. In order to take advantage of prey resting on the turbine towers, however, bats would have to switch from an aerial hawking strategy to a\u00a0gleaning foraging strategy. If bats that are commonly killed at wind turbines can switch foraging strategies to take advantage of conspicuous and abundant prey on turbine towers, then this foraging activity (i.e., bats entering the rotor swept zone, defined as the area occupied by the blades of the wind turbine when they are in motion, to glean prey from the tower surfaces) may be contributing to bat-wind turbine mortality. We further predict that if the turbine tower surfaces were altered so that they were no longer smooth, then prey items would not be as conspicuous to echolocating bats because of the background clutter generated by returning echoes from the textured surface itself (Clare and Holderied 2015; Fig. 2). Thus, we hypothesize that texturizing wind turbine towers would eliminate the acoustic mirror effect, thereby reducing a bat\u2019s ability to efficiently locate prey items on the towers, which in turn would make wind turbines a less suitable foraging resource.\n\nWe therefore designed a two-part experiment using wild-caught bats (including species commonly killed at wind turbines) in a flight facility to 1) determine if aerialhawking bats could switch to a gleaning foraging strategy, and 2) estimate foraging success at a range of smooth and textured surfaces. Ultimately, the results from these experiments will provide important insights into bat foraging behavior. In addition, this research may be used to inform the development of a texture coating that could be used as a novel mitigation strategy to reduce bat foraging activity at turbine towers, especially within the rotor swept zone, and thus reduce bat fatalities at wind facilities worldwide.","author":["Jarzombek, L."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.708961000000","-97.360357000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1603","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evidence-bats-perceive-wind-turbine-surfaces-be-water","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.tcu.edu\/handle\/116099117\/4482","title":"Evidence that Bats Perceive Wind Turbine Surfaces to be Water","description":"Large numbers of migratory tree bats are being killed at wind energy facilities across North America, and this rapidly growing source of renewable energy may pose a threat to bat populations. In 2012 and 2013 we conducted an ultrasound playback experiment, night vision surveys, and acoustic monitoring to determine if bats could be attracted to the smooth wind turbines surfaces because they perceive them to be water. Our playback experiment revealed little or no differences in the physical characteristics of echoes reflected from water and turbine surfaces. Our video and acoustic surveys indicated that bats behave at wind turbines as they do around water sources. Moreover, we observed bats attempting to drink from turbine towers at rates similar to water sources. Our data suggest that bats may be attracted to wind turbines because the surfaces produce an acoustic signature that is indistinguishable from water.","author":["McAlexander, A."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2013-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.733664000000","-97.415906000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1604","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/surface-texture-discrimination-bats-implications-reducing-bat-mortality-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.tcu.edu\/handle\/116099117\/10916","title":"Surface Texture Discrimination by Bats: Implications for Reducing Bat Mortality at Wind Turbines","description":"Wind power is one of the fastest growing renewable energy sources and is expected to continue to increase globally (Wiser et al. 2015). Nonetheless, there are concerns over the potential threats that wind facilities pose to wildlife populations. For example, large numbers of bats are killed at wind turbines annually across North America, and just 3 species of migratory tree bats comprise 78% of these fatalities: hoary (Lasiurus cinereus), eastern red (Lasiurus borealis), and silver-haired bats (Lasionycteris noctivagans; Arnett et al. 2008, Arnett and Baerwald 2013). The period of peak fatality at wind turbines for these species occurs from July through September coinciding with fall migration, and it has been estimated that up to 90% of annual fatalities occur during this time (Rydell et al. 2010). Many studies have been undertaken to better understand fatality rates (e.g., Huso 2011, Strickland et al. 2011, Korner-Nievergelt et al. 2013), patterns of fatality (e.g., Arnett et al. 2008, Baerwald and Barclay 2008, Korstian et al. 2013), and the proximate causes of fatality (e.g., Baerwald et al. 2008, Horn et al. 2008, Rollins et al. 2012); however, we still do not entirely understand why bats are coming into contact with wind turbines.\u00a0\n\nResearchers have proposed 3 broad explanations for the ultimate causes of bat fatalities at wind turbines: 1) fatalities are random events that reflect local bat abundance; 2) fatalities are coincidental as wind turbines are located in close proximity to existing resources where bat activity may be concentrated; and 3) fatalities occur because bats are attracted to wind turbines (Cryan and Barclay 2009). Note that these proposed explanations are not mutually exclusive and may vary among species. Previous studies at wind facilities have shown that bats approach both rotating and non-rotating blades and investigate various parts of wind turbines, providing evidence that bats are attracted to wind turbines (Horn et al. 2008, McAlexander 2013). Three\u00a0general hypotheses of attraction have been proposed: 1) bats are interested or intrigued by the sound, motion, or lights associated with wind turbines; 2) turbines provide a resource for bats (i.e., foraging, mating, or roosting sites; Kunz et al. 2007, Horn et al. 2008, Cryan et al. 2014); and 3) turbines are misperceived to provide one or more resources (Cryan and Barclay 2009, Cryan et al. 2014, McAlexander 2013).\u00a0\n\nThe objectives of this project were to 1) determine if bats in a flight facility would attempt to drink from smooth painted surfaces similar to wind turbine towers, and 2) identify a surface texture that bats show little or no interest in approaching. To accomplish these objectives, we captured local bats (including species that are frequently killed at wind turbines) and conducted a behavioral experiment in a flight facility at Texas Christian University. We created smooth and textured surfaces of varying types and grade and recorded how these wildcaught bats behaved towards each surface. The ultimate goal of the behavioral experiment was to inform the development of a cost-effective texture coating that could be applied to existing wind turbine towers or towers in the manufacturing stage as a mitigation strategy for bat fatalities at wind farms.\u00a0","author":["Bienz, C."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.755576000000","-97.330017000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1605","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-overwintering-sites-attractive-invasive-lady-beetle-harmonia-axyridis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/10.1649\/0010-065X-69.4.665","title":"Wind Turbines as Overwintering Sites Attractive to an Invasive Lady Beetle, Harmonia axyridis Pallas (Coleoptera: Coccinellidae)","description":"One of the most invasive species of insects in Europe is the Asian lady beetle,\u00a0Harmonia axyridis\u00a0(Pallas, 1773).\u00a0This species is often observed in anthropogenic areas, especially during autumn and winter when the adults enter buildings and start the overwintering process in large aggregations. On wind farms in intensively used farmland in Poland,\u00a0H. axyridis\u00a0uses wind turbines as overwintering sites. We hypothesize that\u00a0H. axyridis\u00a0adults are attracted to wind turbines for heat and protection from the wind. We examined\u00a0H. axyridis\u00a0aggregations on 33 wind turbines and surrounding areas and measured temperatures on different parts of the turbines. Turbines had a higher temperature than the surrounding areas. The lady beetles mostly occupied the northwestern side of the turbines, which is the side protected from wind. A possible explanation for the beetle\u0027s preference for turbines as overwintering sites is the lack of other anthropogenic structures available for overwintering in a homogenous farmland.","author":["Dudek, K.","Dudek, M.","Tryjanowski, P."],"organization":["Pozna\u0144 University of Life Sciences"],"originationDate":"2015-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.919436000000","19.145134000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1606","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/when-excrement-hits-fan-fecal-surveys-reveal-species-specific-bat-activity-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1616504717302045","title":"When the Excrement Hits the Fan: Fecal Surveys Reveal Species-Specific Bat Activity at Wind Turbines","description":"The reasons why bats are coming into contact with wind turbines are not yet well understood. One hypothesis is that bats are attracted to wind turbines and this attraction may be because bats perceive or misperceive the turbines to provide a resource, such as a foraging or roosting site. During post-construction fatality searches at a wind energy facility in the southern Great Plains, U.S., we discovered bat feces near the base of a wind turbine tower, which led us to hypothesize that bats were actively roosting and\/or foraging at turbines. Thus over 2 consecutive years, we conducted systematic searches for bat feces on turbines at this site. We collected 72 bat fecal samples from turbines and successfully extracted DNA from 56 samples. All 6 bat species known to be in the area were confirmed and the majority (59%) were identified as Lasiurusborealis; a species that also comprised the majority of the fatalities (60%) recorded at the site. The presence of bat feces provides further evidence that bats were conducting activities in close proximity to wind turbines. Moreover, feces found in areas such as turbine door slats indicated that bats were using turbines as night or foraging roosts, and further provided evidence that bats were active near the turbines. Future research should therefore aim to identify those features of wind turbines that bats perceive or misperceive as a resource, which in turn may lead to new minimization strategies that effectively reduce bat fatalities at wind farms.","author":["Bennett, V.","Hale, A.","Williams, D."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.731528000000","-97.405056000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1607","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-wind-turbine-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/1465\/1209","title":"Evaluation of Wind Turbine Noise","description":"Virtually anything with moving parts will make some sound, and wind turbines are no exception. Well designed wind turbines are generally quiet in operation. Wind turbine noise is very low compared to the noise from road traffic, trains, aircraft and construction activities and can also be compared to the sound level inside a typical living room, the reading room of a library or in an unoccupied, quiet, air-conditioned office. Typically, the sound of a working wind farm is actually less than normal road traffic or an office.","author":["Lewis, A.","DeGagne, D.","May, C."],"organization":["SNC-Lavalin"],"originationDate":"2002-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1608","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/noise-impact-wind-farms-quebec","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/2683\/2683","title":"Noise Impact - Wind Farms in Quebec","description":"The wind energy branch of power production in Quebec was truly created at the end of the 1990\u2019s, with the commissioning of the Le Nordais wind farm in the Gasp\u00e9sie region of Quebec. Throughout various tenders issued by Hydro-Qu\u00e9bec, the Crown corporation responsible for the supply of energy, wind generation has increased gradually to reach an installed capacity of nearly 2,900 MW. In Quebec, industrial projects (including wind farms) must be the subject of impact assessments and public hearings, according to certain parameters. Although this is a green form of energy production, wind farm projects have met with opposition on the basis of noise, which has led to the abandonment of some projects. The noise and vibration personnel at SNC-Lavalin Inc. have been involved in the Quebec\u2019s wind energy branch since its beginnings and have developed a unique expertise in Quebec in terms of their ability to characterize a wind farm\u2019s initial situation, perform noise modeling, popularize technical aspects of the project at public hearings, to monitor during construction, and finally to monitor during the operational phase.","author":["Savard, J.","Meunier, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1609","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/health-effects-related-wind-turbine-noise-exposure-systematic-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0114183","title":"Health Effects Related to Wind Turbine Noise Exposure: A Systematic Review","description":"Background: Wind turbine noise exposure and suspected health-related effects thereof have attracted substantial attention. Various symptoms such as sleep-related problems, headache, tinnitus and vertigo have been described by subjects suspected of having been exposed to wind turbine noise.   Objective: This review was conducted systematically with the purpose of identifying any reported associations between wind turbine noise exposure and suspected health-related effects.   Data Sources: A search of the scientific literature concerning the health-related effects of wind turbine noise was conducted on PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar and various other Internet sources.   Study Eligibility Criteria: All studies investigating suspected health-related outcomes associated with wind turbine noise exposure were included.   Results: Wind turbines emit noise, including low-frequency noise, which decreases incrementally with increases in distance from the wind turbines. Likewise, evidence of a dose-response relationship between wind turbine noise linked to noise annoyance, sleep disturbance and possibly even psychological distress was present in the literature. Currently, there is no further existing statistically-significant evidence indicating any association between wind turbine noise exposure and tinnitus, hearing loss, vertigo or headache.   Limitations: Selection bias and information bias of differing magnitudes were found to be present in all current studies investigating wind turbine noise exposure and adverse health effects. Only articles published in English, German or Scandinavian languages were reviewed. Conclusions: Exposure to wind turbines does seem to increase the risk of annoyance and self-reported sleep disturbance in a dose-response relationship.   Conclusions: Exposure to wind turbines does seem to increase the risk of annoyance and self-reported sleep disturbance in a dose-response relationship. There appears, though, to be a tolerable level of around L-Aeq of 35 dB. Of the many other claimed health effects of wind turbine noise exposure reported in the literature, however, no conclusive evidence could be found. Future studies should focus on investigations aimed at objectively demonstrating whether or not measureable health-related outcomes can be proven to fluctuate depending on exposure to wind turbines.","author":["Schmidt, J.","Klokker, M."],"organization":["University of Southern Denmark","University of Copenhagen"],"originationDate":"2014-12-04","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Health \u0026 Safety","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-12 08:19:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SchmidtKlokker-2014.PDF"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1610","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/exposure-response-relationship-wind-turbine-noise-self-reported-symptoms-sleep-health","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.noiseandhealth.org\/text.asp?2016\/18\/81\/53\/178478","title":"Exposure-response relationship of wind turbine noise with self-reported symptoms of sleep and health problems: A nationwide socioacoustic survey in Japan","description":"The association of wind turbine noise (WTN) with sleep and physical\/mental health has not been fully investigated. To investigate the relationship of WTN with the prevalence of self-reported symptoms of sleep and health problems, a socioacoustic survey of 1079 adult residents was conducted throughout Japan (2010-2012): 747 in 34 areas surrounding wind turbine plants and 332 in 16 control areas. During face-to-face interviews, the respondents were not informed of the purpose of the survey. Questions on symptoms such as sleeplessness and physical\/mental complaints were asked without specifying reasons. Insomnia was defined as having one or any combination of the following that occurs three or more times a week and bothers a respondent: Difficulty initiating sleep, difficulty maintaining sleep, premature morning awakening, and feeling of light overnight sleep. Poor health was defined as having high scores for health complaints, as determined using the Total Health Index, exceeding the criteria proposed by the authors of the index. The noise descriptor for WTN was\u00a0LAeq,n\u00a0outdoor, estimated from the results of actual measurement at some locations in each site. Multiple logistic analysis was applied to the\u00a0LAeq,n\u00a0and insomnia or poor health. The odds ratio (OR) of insomnia was significantly higher when the noise exposure level exceeded 40 dB, whereas the self-reported sensitivity to noise and visual annoyance with wind turbines were also independently associated with insomnia. OR of poor health was not significant for noise exposure, but significant for noise sensitivity and visual annoyance. The above two moderators appear to indicate the features of respondents who are sensitive to stimuli or changes in their homeostasis.","author":["Kageyama, T.","Yano, T.","Kuwano, S.","Sueoka, S.","Tachibana, H."],"organization":["Oita University of Nursing and Health Sciences","Kumamoto University","Osaka University"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.204828000000","138.252927000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Health \u0026 Safety","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-12 08:20:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1611","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proceedings-fourth-international-partners-flight-conference-tundra-tropics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.partnersinflight.org\/resources\/partners-in-flight-4th-international-conference-in-mcallen-tx-2008\/","title":"Proceedings of the Fourth International Partners in Flight Conference: Tundra to Tropics","description":"These proceedings are from the The 4th International Partners in Flight (PIF) Conference, which was held at the McAllen Convention Center, in McAllen, Texas, on 13\u201316 February 2008. The theme of the conference - Tundra to Tropics: Connecting Bird, Habitats and People -  was also the theme of International Migratory Bird Day for 2008. Nearly 700 people attended the conference, with over 100 participants representing countries other than the U.S. There were nearly 500 oral and poster presentations among the conference\u2019s 39 pre-planned sessions.\n\nThese proceedings consist of papers contributed from authors who wished to further develop their content. The editors view these proceedings as a unique tool for sharing information that may not always lend itself to publication in the traditional ornithological literature. All papers were reviewed by at least one editor and by at least one other peer to ensure quality. Because not all aspects of the original program are represented by written contributions to this proceedings, logical organization of contributed papers herein differs somewhat from that of the conference.\n\nTable of Contents:\n\n\n Preface\n Needs Assessment\n Basic Biology\n Bird Communities\n Anthropogenic Impacts\n \n  Wind Energy Development, Prescribed Fire and Migratory Land Birds in the Southeastern United States (pgs. 184-193)\n  Potential Impacts of Wind Farm Energy Development on Upland Game Birds: Questions and Concerns (pgs. 179-183)\n  Towers, Turbines, Power Lines, and Buildings - Steps Being Taken by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to Avoid or Minimize Take of Migratory Birds at these Structures (pgs. 262-272)\n \n \n Decision Support Tools\n Education, Communication, and Outreach\n Project Implementation\n Monitoring\n Response to Habitat Changes","author":["Thompson, C.","Rich, T.","Arizmendi, C.","Demarest, D."],"organization":["Partners in Flight"],"originationDate":"2009-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-24 06:41:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/PIF-IV-Preface.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1612","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-shore-shore-wind-turbine-farms-property-prices","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421518300557","title":"The impact of on-shore and off-shore wind turbine farms on property prices","description":"We present the results of a large-scale analysis on how on-shore and off-shore\u00a0wind turbines\u00a0affect the property\u00a0prices\u00a0of nearby single family residential and\u00a0vacationhomes in\u00a0Denmark. We find that on-shore wind turbines negatively affect the price of surrounding properties to a distance of three kilometers. The\u00a0negative impact increases with the number of wind turbines at a declining\u00a0marginal rate\u00a0but declines with distance. In the case of off-shore wind\u00a0turbine\u00a0farms, we do not find a significant effect of having an off-shore wind farm in view from a property itself or from the nearest\u00a0beach, likely because the closest off-shore turbine is 9\u202fkm from the closest traded home. We\u00a0illustrate\u00a0the\u00a0policy\u00a0relevance\u00a0of our findings by providing\u00a0maps showing how the marginal impact of a wind turbine varies across the\u00a0landscape according to the\u00a0spatial distribution\u00a0of home density and homes values in the proximity of a wind turbine site. The results suggest that\u00a0ceteris paribus, wind turbine farms should be built quite far away from\u00a0residential areas\u00a0with turbines gathered in larger wind farms rather than installed as single turbines.","author":["Lundhede, T.","Dalsgaard, M.","Thorsen, B.","Jensen, C.","Panduro, T.","Nielsen, A."],"organization":["University of Copenhagen","COWI A\/S","University of Pretoria"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.263920000000","9.501785000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1613","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/zooplankton-community-responses-relation-environmental-factors-established-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.jcronline.org\/doi\/abs\/10.2112\/JCOASTRES-D-17-00058.1","title":"Zooplankton Community Responses and the Relation to Environmental Factors from Established Offshore Wind Farms within the Rudong Coastal Area of China","description":"The goal of this study was to examine the responses of the zooplankton community to the establishment of an OWF, the causes of any observed effects, and their relation to environmental factors in the study area. This article describes the results of an investigation into the zooplankton community and the main environmental factors affecting that community based on data obtained from three cruises in May, August, and November of 2015 in the area of the Longyuan OWF in Rudong, China. This study analyzed the spatiotemporal distribution of zooplankton, including data obtained before the construction of the wind farm, to assess any postconstruction change in the zooplankton community. Data from the zooplankton community were analyzed using canonical correlation analysis, redundancy analysis, and multiple regression analysis. The analysis indicates that the presence of the wind turbine foundations reduced the quantity of the macrozooplankton significantly (the percentage of change was \u221296.87% in the autumn, and \u221226.70% in the spring), and reduced the biomass slightly in autumn (the percentage of change was \u221258.20%) or increased the biomass in the spring (the percentage of change was 75.77%). However, the quantity of the microzooplankton significantly increased (the percentage of change was 542.76% in the spring) or decreased slightly (the percentage of change was \u221286.25% in the autumn). The water also showed a postconstruction trend toward eutrophication in this study area. The data also showed that water temperature, dissolved oxygen, suspended matter concentration, and pH were the most important factors influencing the zooplankton community. The suspended-matter concentration had opposite effects on the macrozooplankton and microzooplankton, suggesting that the postconstruction zooplankton community might show a trend toward miniaturization.","author":["Wang, T.","Wang, J.","Zhang, D.","Yu, W.","Zou, X.","Li, B.","Zhang, H."],"organization":["Nanjing University of Science and Technology","Ocean University of China"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.500000000000","121.330000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Physical Environment","Water Quality"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1614","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-impacts-wind-farm-energy-development-upland-game-birds-questions-concerns","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.partnersinflight.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2017\/03\/Brennan-L.-A.-et-al.-p-179-183.pdf","title":"Potential Impacts of Wind Farm Energy Development on Upland Game Birds: Questions and Concerns","description":"Ecologists and wildlife managers have been concerned about the negative impacts of wind energy developments or wind farms on migratory birds such as passerines and raptors, as well as bats. However, we present a series of arguments that culminate in a plea to also consider the potential direct and indirect impacts of wind farms on resident and migratory upland game birds. We pose these arguments from both ecological and economic perspectives because economic impacts derived from hunters are a major driver that provides incentives for landowners to sustain habitats, not only for upland game birds, but also for scores of other terrestrial wildlife species as well. The primary concern regarding the impacts of wind farms on upland game birds seems to revolve around the widespread fragmentation that results, not only from placement of the wind turbine towers, but also from the infrastructure of roads needed to construct and service them and the transmission lines required to access the continental electrical power grid. We consider these issues from the standpoint of habitat resources needed to sustain both resident (Northern Bobwhite, Colinus virginianus; Wild Turkey, Meleagris gallopavo; prairie-chickens, Tympanuchus spp.; and migratory Mourning Dove, Zenaida macroura; and White-winged Dove, Z. asiatica) game birds. Implementation of policies and procedures, such as the 12-point position statement on wind energy development and wildlife as proposed by The Wildlife Society, is critically needed to conserve upland game birds and all wildlife populations during the course of planning and locating wind farms.  Paper published in Proceedings of the Fourth International Partners in Flight Conference: Tundra to Tropics.","author":["Brennan, L.","Ballard, B.","Kuvlesky, W.","Perez, R.","DeMaso, S."],"organization":["Texas A\u0026M University","Texas Parks and Wildlife Department"],"originationDate":"2009-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Brennan-2009-TundraTropicsConferencePaper.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1615","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/valuing-visual-impact-wind-farms-calculus-method-synthesizing-choice-experiments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969718316292","title":"Valuing the visual impact of wind farms: A calculus method for synthesizing choice experiments studies","description":"Despite the great potential of mitigating\u00a0carbon emission, development of\u00a0wind farms is often opposed by local communities due to the visual impact on landscape. A growing number of studies have applied nonmarket valuation methods like Choice Experiments (CE) to value the visual impact by eliciting respondents\u0027 willingness to pay (WTP) or willingness to accept (WTA) for hypothetical wind farms through survey questions. Several meta-analyses have been found in the literature to synthesize results from different valuation studies, but they have various limitations related to the use of the prevailing multivariate meta-regression analysis. In this paper, we propose a new\u00a0meta-analysis\u00a0method to establish general functions for the relationships between the estimated WTP or WTA and three wind farm attributes, namely the distance to residential\/coastal areas, the number of\u00a0turbines\u00a0and turbine height. This method involves establishing WTA or WTP functions for individual studies, fitting the average derivative functions and deriving the general\u00a0integral functions\u00a0of WTP or WTA against wind farm attributes. Results indicate that respondents in different studies consistently showed increasing WTP for moving wind farms to greater distances, which can be fitted by non-linear (natural logarithm) functions. However, divergent preferences for the number of turbines and turbine height were found in different studies. We argue that the new analysis method proposed in this paper is an alternative to the mainstream multivariate meta-regression analysis for synthesizing CE studies and the general integral functions of WTP or WTA against wind farm attributes are useful for future\u00a0spatial modelling\u00a0and benefit transfer studies. We also suggest that future multivariate meta-analyses should include non-linear components in the regression functions.","author":["Wen, C.","Carver, S.","Ziv, G.","Dallimer, M."],"organization":["University of Leeds","Wuhan University"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wenetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1616","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/procedure-deriving-wind-turbine-noise-limits-taking-account-annoyance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969718330717","title":"A procedure for deriving wind turbine noise limits by taking into account annoyance","description":"With the increasing installation of\u00a0wind farms, the attention of citizens towards\u00a0wind turbine\u00a0noise (WTN) has grown. Differently from some national legislations, the scientific community has promptly responded, increasing the studies and the\u00a0social surveys\u00a0in order to better understand the cause of disturbance and the indicators that relate to it. At first, the paper underlines the importance of low WTN levels for indirect health effects such as\u00a0sleep disturbance\u00a0and annoyance. The importance to consider noise annoyance in legislation is also discussed, as WTN is more disturbing than other most common noise sources. Then, conversion curves for equally highly annoyed are introduced considering the annoyance perceived by population in relation with the type of source. Finally, a specific\u00a0limit value\u00a0of 43\u202fdB(A) for WTN is derived and suggested, comparable with British and Danish standards.","author":["Fredianelli, L.","Carpita, S.","Licitra, G."],"organization":["University of Pisa","National Research Council of Italy (CNR)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1617","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/prioritizing-avian-species-their-risk-population-level-consequences-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0150813","title":"Prioritizing Avian Species for Their Risk of Population Level Consequences from Wind Energy Development","description":"Recent growth in the wind energy industry has increased concerns about its impacts on wildlife populations. Direct impacts of wind energy include bird and bat collisions with turbines whereas indirect impacts include changes in wildlife habitat and behavior. Although many species may withstand these effects, species that are long-lived with low rates of reproduction, have specialized habitat preferences, or are attracted to turbines may be more prone to declines in population abundance. We developed a prioritization system to identify the avian species most likely to experience population declines from wind facilities based on their current conservation status and their expected risk from turbines. We developed 3 metrics of turbine risk that incorporate data on collision fatalities at wind facilities, population size, life history, species\u2019 distributions relative to turbine locations, number of suitable habitat types, and species\u2019 conservation status. We calculated at least 1 measure of turbine risk for 428 avian species that breed in the United States. We then simulated 100,000 random sets of cutoff criteria (i.e., the metric values used to assign species to different priority categories) for each turbine risk metric and for conservation status. For each set of criteria, we assigned each species a priority score and calculated the average priority score across all sets of criteria. Our prioritization system highlights both species that could potentially experience population decline caused by wind energy and species at low risk of population decline. For instance, several birds of prey, such as the long-eared owl, ferruginous hawk, Swainson\u2019s hawk, and golden eagle, were at relatively high risk of population decline across a wide variety of cutoff values, whereas many passerines were at relatively low risk of decline. This prioritization system is a first step that will help researchers, conservationists, managers, and industry target future study and management activity.","author":["Johnson, D.","Loss, S.","Diffendorfer, J.","Beston, J."],"organization":["University of Wisconsin","US Geological Survey (USGS)","Oklahoma State University"],"originationDate":"2016-03-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Beston2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1618","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-mortality-due-wind-turbines-canada","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21128","title":"Bat Mortality Due to Wind Turbines in Canada","description":"Wind turbines have been hypothesized to affect bat populations; however, no comprehensive analysis of bat mortality from the operation of wind turbines in Canada has been conducted. We used data from carcass searches for 64 wind farms, incorporating correction factors for scavenger removal, searcher efficiency, and carcasses that fell beyond the area searched to estimate bat collision mortality associated with wind turbines in Canada. On average, 15.5 \u00b1\u00a03.8 (95% CI) bats were killed per turbine per year at these sites (range =\u00a00-103 bats\/turbine\/yr at individual wind farms). Based on 4,019 installed turbines (the no. installed in Canada by Dec 2013), an estimated 47,400 bats (95% CI =\u00a032,100-62,700) are killed by wind turbines each year in Canada. Installed wind capacity is growing rapidly in Canada, and is predicted to increase approximately 3.5-fold over the next 15 years, which could lead to direct mortality of approximately 166,000 bats\/year. Long-distance migratory bat species (e.g., hoary bat [Lasiurus cinereus], silver-haired bat [Lasionycteris noctivagans], eastern red bat [Lasiurus borealis]) accounted for 73% of all mortalities. These species are subject to additional mortality risks when they migrate into the United States. The little brown myotis (Myotis lucifugus), which was listed as Endangered in 2014 under the Species At Risk Act (SARA), accounted for 13% of all mortalities from wind turbines, with most of the mortality (87%) occurring in Ontario. Population-level impacts may become an issue for some bat species as numbers of turbines increase.","author":["Francis, C.","Zimmerling, J."],"organization":["Canadian Wildlife Service"],"originationDate":"2016-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1619","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-bat-species-global-vulnerability-collision-mortality-wind-farms-revealed-through","sourceURL":"https:\/\/rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org\/content\/284\/1862\/20170829","title":"Bird and Bat Species\u0027 Global Vulnerability to Collision Mortality at Wind Farms Revealed Through a Trait-Based Assessment","description":"Mitigation of anthropogenic climate change involves deployments of renewable energy worldwide, including wind farms, which can pose a significant collision risk to volant animals. Most studies into the collision risk between species and wind turbines, however, have taken place in industrialized countries. Potential effects for many locations and species therefore remain unclear. To redress this gap, we conducted a systematic literature review of recorded collisions between birds and bats and wind turbines within developed countries. We related collision rate to species-level traits and turbine characteristics to quantify the potential vulnerability of 9538 bird and 888 bat species globally. Avian collision rate was affected by migratory strategy, dispersal distance and habitat associations, and bat collision rates were influenced by dispersal distance. For birds and bats, larger turbine capacity (megawatts) increased collision rates; however, deploying a smaller number of large turbines with greater energy output reduced total collision risk per unit energy output, although bat mortality increased again with the largest turbines. Areas with high concentrations of vulnerable species were also identified, including migration corridors. Our results can therefore guide wind farm design and location to reduce the risk of large-scale animal mortality. This is the first quantitative global assessment of the relative collision vulnerability of species groups with wind turbines, providing valuable guidance for minimizing potentially serious negative impacts on biodiversity.","author":["Thaxter, C.","Pearce-Higgins, J.","Green, R.","Buchanan, G.","Carr, J.","Butchart, S.","Newbold, T.","Tobias, J.","Foden, W.","O\u0027Brien, S."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)","International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN)","BirdLife International","University College London","University of Cambridge","Imperial College London","Stellenbosch University","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)"],"originationDate":"2017-09-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1620","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/airspace-habitat","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0169534713000670","title":"The Airspace is Habitat","description":"A preconception concerning habitat persists and has gone unrecognized since use of the term first entered the lexicon of ecological and evolutionary biology many decades ago. Specifically, land and water are considered habitats, while the airspace is not. This might at first seem a reasonable, if unintended, demarcation, since years of education and personal experience as well as limits to perception predispose a traditional view of habitat. Nevertheless, the airspace satisfies the definition and functional role of a habitat, and its recognition as habitat may have implications for policy where expanding anthropogenic development of airspace could impact the conservation of species and subject parts of the airspace to formalized legal protection.","author":["Diehl, R."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2013-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1621","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/problematic-wildlife-cross-disciplinary-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007%2F978-3-319-22246-2","title":"Problematic Wildlife: A Cross-Disciplinary Approach","description":"This book provides insight into the instances in which wildlife species can create problems. Some species trigger problems for human activities, but many others need humans to save them and to continue to exist. The text addresses issues faced by economists and politicians dealing with laws involving actions undertaken to resolve the problems of the interaction between humans and wildlife. Here, the words \u2018problematic species\u2019 are used in their broadest sense, as may be appreciated in the short introductions to the various sections. At times, the authors discuss special cases while always extending the discussion into a more general and broad vision. At others, they present real cutting-edge analysis of ecological topics and issues.\n\nThe book will be of interest to biologists, ecologists and wildlife managers involved in research on wildlife, parks, and environmental management, as well as to government departments and agencies, NGOs and conservation wildlife organizations. Even those in contact with nature, such as hunters, herders, and farmers, will be able to find a great deal of important information. Specific case studies are selected from among the most significant and prevalent cases throughout the world.\n\nA total of 26 papers have been selected for this book, written by zoologists, biologists and ecologists. Many have an interdisciplinary approach, with contributions by economists, criminologists, technical specialists, and engineers.\n\nTable of Contents:\nPart 1\u00a0- General Introduction: The Reasons Behind and Significance of the Book. Problematic Wildlife: Definitions and Concepts. When and Why a Wild Species May Become Problematic\nPart 2\u00a0- Extinct Species, Species at Risk of Extinction and Declining Species: Some Current and Past Case Studies. Land Fragmentation and Habitat Degradation\nPart 3\u00a0- When Wildlife Creates Problems for the Environment and Human Activities: General Features and Some Case Studies\nPart 4\u00a0- Managing Problematic Species: Case Studies from Protected Areas and Areas Subject to Other Kinds of Management (Rural, Forest, Hunting and Urban Areas). Introductions, Reintroductions and Restocking\nPart 5\u00a0- Genetic Contributions to the Management of Problematic Species\nPart 6\u00a0- Species that Are a Danger to Humans, Man-Eating Wildlife, etc.\nPart 7\u00a0- Some Special Cases: Wind Farms and Fauna, Bird-Strikes, Electrocution, etc.\nChapter 20 -\u00a0Impacts to Birds and Bats Due to Collisions and Electrocutions from Some Tall Structures in the United States: Wires, Towers, Turbines, and Solar Arrays\u2014State of the Art in Addressing the Problems\u00a0(A. Manville)\nChapter 21\u00a0- Conflict of Wings: Birds Versus Aircraft\u00a0(J. Thorpe)\nChapter 22\u00a0-\u00a0Approaches to Wildlife Management in Aviation\u00a0(J. McKee, P. Shaw, A. Dekker, and K. Patrick)\nChapter 23\u00a0-\u00a0Conflicts Between Birds and On-Shore Wind Farms (M. Zwart, A. McKenzie, J. Minderman, M. Whittingham)\u00a0\nPart 8\u00a0- Bushmeat: A Socioecological Problem. The Overexploitation of Wildlife for Nutritional and Traditional Purposes. World Animal Trade, Extinction Risk and Socio-economic Issues\nPart 9\u00a0- Hidden Species: An Appropriate Scientific Approach to Cryptozoology","author":["Angelici, F."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1622","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-birds-bats-due-collisions-electrocutions-some-tall-structures-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-22246-2_20","title":"Impacts to Birds and Bats Due to Collisions and Electrocutions from Some Tall Structures in the United States: Wires, Towers, Turbines, and Solar Arrays - State of the Art in Addressing the Problems","description":"This chapter reviews the current status of bird and bat populations in the contiguous United States, along with growing concerns about declines in populations of both birds (366 [36 %] of 1027 protected migratory bird species in North America) and bats (6 of 45 species federally listed as endangered in the contiguous U.S.), many from the effects of human-made structures. Specifically, this chapter assesses the human-related causes of bird and bat mortality in the U.S. due primarily to collisions and electrocutions with tall structures and known effects of nonionizing radiation from antennas. These structural effects include impacts from power transmission and distribution lines, communication towers, commercial land-based wind turbines, and industrial solar arrays. Accepted and scientifically validated conservation measures for avoiding and minimizing direct \u201ctake\u201d (i.e., the legal term for un-permitted injury or death) are discussed. The indirect effects to migratory birds and their habitats and direct and indirect negative impacts on bats (Microchiroptera) caused primarily by land-based wind turbines are evaluated. Suggested mitigation tools are based on innovative scientifically supported best practices, best available technologies, and accepted conservation measures. Several ongoing partnerships between the U.S. Fish \u0026 Wildlife Service, other action agencies that implement regulations and guidelines, and industry stakeholder groups are described as examples of successful industry-agency-stakeholder coordination, partnership, and initiatives. The consequences of inaction are briefly reviewed.\n\nChapter from the book Problematic Wildlife: A Cross-Disciplinary Approach.","author":["Manville, A."],"organization":["Johns Hopkins University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1623","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/conflicts-between-birds-shore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-22246-2_23","title":"Conflicts Between Birds and On-Shore Wind Farms","description":"Wind energy, like all renewable energy resources, is sustainable with a far lower carbon footprint than the burning of fossil fuels. Consequently, it plays a role in mitigating climate change. While there has been a rapid rise in the use of wind energy over the last 15 years, there are concerns regarding the potential effects of wind turbines on wildlife, of which birds are one group of concern. Potential effects include disturbance via direct or indirect habitat loss and fatality through collision with turbine blades. The probability of bird collisions with turbines depends on factors associated both with the location and design of wind farms and species\u2019 behaviour and physiology. Most adverse effects can be prevented by careful wind farm placement and Environmental Impact Assessments, with sensitivity maps providing vital means of doing so. Unexpected effects post-construction may be mitigated in a variety of ways, including shutting down turbines during times of high collision risk or repowering of old turbines. Currently, we do not fully understand the interaction between birds and wind farms and thus our predictions of potential effects are limited. Therefore, further research is needed to improve our understanding of both the causes and consequences of collision mortality and displacement effects on bird populations before we can prevent these in the future.\n\nChapter from the book Problematic Wildlife: A Cross-Disciplinary Approach.","author":["Whittingham, M.","Minderman, J.","Zwart, M.","McKenzie, A."],"organization":["Newcastle University","University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1624","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-field-analytical-methods-assess-avian-collision-risk-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.natural-research.org\/application\/files\/4114\/9182\/2839\/Band_et_al_2007.pdf","title":"Developing Field and Analytical Methods to Assess Avian Collision Risk at Wind Farms","description":"Most studies of wind farm \u2013 bird interactions examine the effects of disturbance on bird use of a wind farm site, and mortality through collision of birds with turbine blades. Here we describe an approach of field study and modelling that can be used to predict collision mortality risk, illustrated by two examples of studies at proposed wind farm sites in Scotland involving greylag goose and hen harrier. We use the modelling method developed by W. Band to estimate the number of bird collisions over a period of time. The calculation is in two stages: number of birds colliding per annum = number flying through rotor (Stage 1) x probability of bird flying through rotor being hit (Stage 2). Vantage point observational studies at a proposed wind farm site are used to gather information on bird use of the site and the frequency of bird flights in the area swept by turbine blades (Stage 1). For Stage 2 the probability of collision depends on the size of the bird (both length and wingspan), the breadth and pitch of the turbine blades, the rotation speed of the turbine, and the flight speed of the bird. Combining Stage 1 with Stage 2 gives a predicted collision mortality rate that assumes birds take no action to avoid collision. In practice, birds probably show a very high degree of collision avoidance, which dramatically lowers predicted mortality. For the collision risk model to predict accurate measures of collision mortality it is essential that more information is collected on avoidance.\n\nThis is a book chapter in Birds and Wind Farms: Risk Assessment and Mitigation.","author":["Whitfield, D.","Madders, M.","Band, W."],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage","Natural Research Ltd"],"originationDate":"2007-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-11 11:14:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1625","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/theoretical-approach-estimating-bird-risk-collision-wind-turbines-where-empirical","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.scirp.org\/journal\/PaperInformation.aspx?paperID=65390","title":"A Theoretical Approach to Estimating Bird Risk of Collision with Wind Turbines Where Empirical Flight Activity Data Are Lacking","description":"There are standard procedures for collecting data on numbers of birds at sites being proposed for wind farm development and evaluating collision risk for each key species. However, methods do not work well for all species. Where a local bird population is depleted, empirical data cannot provide estimates of likely collision mortality numbers if that population returns to satisfactory conservation status. Field survey methods are also inadequate for cryptic bird species. Both these problems can be important for evaluation of impacts of proposed wind farms on bird populations protected by the EU Birds Directive. We present an alternative method, based on energy constrained activity budgets and natural history, which permits assessment of likely collision numbers where empirical data are inadequate. Two case studies are presented where this approach has been successfully used to resolve disputed planning applications, one for a hen harrier population where numbers present are much below the population size at designation, and one for a cryptic species (greenshank). Our novel method helps reduce uncertainty in assessments constrained by difficulties in collecting suitable empirical data.","author":["Furness, R.","Trinder, M.","Douse, A.","MacArthur, D."],"organization":["MacArthur Green","Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Furness-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1626","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wind-farms-birds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nhbs.com\/effects-of-wind-farms-on-birds-book","title":"Effects of Wind Farms on Birds","description":"The report analyses the literature into the effects of windfarms on birds and suggests some guidance for assessing their impact and the precautions to be taken when selecting sites. The location selected for windfarms is of vital importance. The main potential hazards for birds are disturbance, leading to their exclusion from an area or barring their movement; death by collision; and loss of or damage to their habitat due to the turbines and their infrastructure.\n\nThis report was commissioned by the Council of Europe for the Bern Convention as an update of the one commissioned by them last year and presented to the 22nd meeting of the Standing Committee for\u00a0information. It is number 139 of the Nature and Environment Series published by the Convention on the Conservation of European Wildlife and Habitats (Bern Convention). Contents include:\n1. Introduction\n2. Review of the literature on the impacts of windfarm on birds\nDisturbance\nDisturbance onshore\nDisturbance offshore\n\nCollision risk and mortality\nCollision risk and mortality onshore\nCollision risk and mortality offshore\n\nBirds and windfarm offshore\nHabitat loss or damage\nOther issues\nPlatforms for roosting, nesting, colonisation\nPollution offshore\n\n3. Environmental assesment and site selection guidelines\nCriteria for environmental assessment\nSensitive species\nPrecautions for site selection for windfarms\nRecommendations\n4. Acknowledgements\n5. References\n6. Useful websites\nAppendix 1 - Environmental assessment\nAppendix 2 - Draft Bern Convention Recommendation","author":["Langston, R.","Pullan, J."],"organization":["Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)","BirdLife International","Council of Europe"],"originationDate":"2004-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1627","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pre-construction-impact-assessment-wind-development-bats-grande-prairie-wind-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wapa.gov\/wp-content\/uploads\/2023\/04\/GrandePrairieNLEBAssessment2013.pdf","title":"Pre-Construction Impact Assessment of Wind Development on Bats: Grande Prairie Wind Project, Holt County, Nebraska","description":"The Grande Prairie Wind Project proposal is for the construction and operation of a commercial scale wind turbine facility (estimated up to 400 MW capacity) in eastern Holt County, Nebraska. The project site is located in the Mixed Grass Prairie Ecoregion, although the land use within the project area is primarily agricultural. North East Ecological Services (\u2018NEES\u2019) conducted a desktop risk assessment for the impact of project development on bats residing or migrating through the project area. In addition to the desktop analysis, NEES conducted an extensive site evaluation to document the presence of potential roosting and foraging habitat within the project area. Lastly, NEES conducted a full year of acoustic monitoring at the project site using ultrasonic microphones to document the spatial, temporal, and species distribution of bat activity within the Grande Prairie project area.   Nebraska has one of the largest wind resources in the United States and responsible development of that resource will allow cleaner energy while minimizing the impact to wildlife. Using methodologies consistent with state, national, and international guidelines, NEES documented a spatial and temporal distribution of bats at the project site that was consistent with other wind projects in the state. These data suggest that the Grande Prairie project site would have minimal indirect impact on bats and that the vast majority of direct impacts (mortality) will occur among the migratory tree bats. There are no data to suggest the scale of mortality should be any different than mortality levels seen at nearby projects on similar habitat; generally less than 4 bats per turbine annually.  Contents:  1. Project Overview  2. Bats of Nebraska and the Risk of Wind-Related Mortality  3. Sources of Mortality for Bats  4. Existing Data on Bat Mortality from Wind Projects  5. Pre-Construction Monitoring Data from Grande Prairie  6. Conclusions  7. Literature Cited  Appendix One: Bats of Nebraska with Basic Ecological Properties  Appendix Two: Natural History of Bat Species in Nebraska  Appendix Three: Migratory Behavior of Bats  Appendix Four: Pre-Construction Acoustic Monitoring for Bats at the Grande Prairie Wind Project Site","author":["Midwest Wind Energy, LLC."],"organization":["North East Ecological Services LLC","Midwest Wind Energy, LLC"],"originationDate":"2013-01-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.380331000000","-98.660058000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/GrandePrairieNLEBAssessment2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1628","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-year-acoustic-monitoring-bats-maple-ridge-wind-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nyserda.ny.gov\/Search-Results?searchvalue=Multi-Year+Acoustic+Monitoring+of+Bats+at+the+Maple+Ridge+Wind+Project\u0026sort=0\u0026pagetype=0\u0026pagenumber=1\u0026page=1","title":"Multi-Year Acoustic Monitoring of Bats at the Maple Ridge Wind Project","description":"The post-construction wildlife monitoring program at the Maple Ridge Wind project is one of the most extensive investigations on the impact of wind development on wildlife at any site in the world. As part of this investigation, North East Ecological Services (NEES) was contracted to design and conduct a multi-year acoustic monitoring program to understand how bats use the landscape and what factors put them at greatest risk of collision with the turbines. Using a vertical sampling array and multiple sampling platforms across the project site, NEES explored the temporal (nightly and seasonal) and spatial (horizontal and vertical) distribution of bat activity across the project site. NEES analyzed the impact of meteorological variables on bat activity that may help inform predictive models used for adaptive management in order to reduce the impact of wind development on migratory bats.","author":["New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA)"],"organization":["North East Ecological Services LLC","New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA)"],"originationDate":"2011-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.787040300000","-75.484940000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2025-10-17 08:16:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MultiYearAcousticMonitoring-NYSERDA-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1629","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-sea-occurrence-abundance-marine-birds-support-atlantic-marine-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/coastalscience.noaa.gov\/data_reports\/modeling-at-sea-occurrence-and-abundance-of-marine-birds-to-support-atlantic-marine-renewable-energy-planning-phase-i-report\/","title":"Modeling At-Sea Occurrence and Abundance of Marine Birds to Support Atlantic Marine Renewable Energy Planning: Phase 1 Report","description":"This report describes the first phase of a project aimed at producing maps of the spatial distributions of marine bird species in U.S. Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) waters that can be used to inform marine spatial planning in the region. Visual sighting survey data from over three decades were analyzed to derive seasonal and annual maps of the spatial distributions of 40 marine bird species in U.S. Atlantic OCS waters from Florida to Maine. Spatial predictive modeling was applied to the survey data to account for spatial and temporal heterogeneity in survey effort, platform, and protocol. Model predictions are presented as seasonal and annual maps of the relative probability of occurrence and relative abundance of study species throughout the U.S. Atlantic OCS. The relative importance of different predictor variables is presented, indicating which variables most influenced the predicted distributions for each species in each season. While the primary objective of this study was not to determine the ecological drivers and mechanisms behind the spatial distributions of marine bird species in the study area, our model results may provide useful hypotheses for future studies aimed more at ecological inference.","author":["Kinlan, B.","White, T.","Winship, A.","Christensen, J."],"organization":["US Department of Commerce (DOC)","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BOEM_2016-039.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1630","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbine-noise-meteorological-influences","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/1963\/1710","title":"Wind Turbine Noise and Meteorological Influences","description":"Wind turbines and wind farms produce power from the forces of wind. The prevailing wind, in addition, generates ambient sound levels that can mask the no-wind ambient sound levels. It has been argued that such masking may not be a real phenomenon and is influenced by meteorological wind classes. A simple analysis is presented based on a three-month wind conditions during the summer in a typical Ontario location.","author":["Ramakrishnan, R.","Sylvestre-Williams, N."],"organization":["Ryerson University"],"originationDate":"2007-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1631","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/overview-offshore-wind-energy-resources-europe-under-present-future-climate","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nyaspubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/nyas.13924","title":"An Overview of Offshore Wind Energy Resources in Europe Under Present and Future Climate","description":"Long\u2010term sustainable development of European offshore wind energy requires knowledge of the best places for installing offshore wind farms. To achieve this, a good knowledge of wind resources is needed, as well as knowledge of international, European, and national regulations regarding conflict management, marine environment conservation, biodiversity protection, licensing processes, and support regimes. Such a multidisciplinary approach could help to identify areas where wind resources are abundant and where conflicts with other interests are scarce, support measures are greater, and licensing processes are streamlined. An overview of offshore wind power studies at present, and of their future projections for the 21st century, allows for determining the optimal European locations to install or maintain offshore wind farms. Only northern Europe, the northwest portion of the Iberian Peninsula, the Gulf of Lyon, the Strait of Gibraltar, and the northwest coast of Turkey show no change or increase in wind power, revealing these locations as the most suitable for installing and maintaining offshore wind farms in the future. The installation of wind farms is subject to restrictions established under international law, European law, and the domestic legal framework of each EU member state. Europe is moving toward streamlining of licensing procedures, reducing subsidies, and implementing auction systems.","author":["Carvalho, D.","deCastro, M.","Costoya, X.","Salvador, S.","Gomez-Gesteira, M.","Sanz-Larruga, F.","Gimeno, L."],"organization":["Universidad de Vigo","University of Aveiro","Universities Space Research Association\u00a0(USRA)","Universidade da Coruna"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1632","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/phase-1-bay-fundy-nova-scotia-including-fundy-tidal-energy-demonstration-project-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.oera.ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/04\/MEKS-Phase-I-Final-Report.pdf","title":"Phase 1 - Bay of Fundy, Nova Scotia including the Fundy Tidal Energy Demonstration Project Site - Mi\u0027kmaq Ecological Knowledge Study","description":"This Mi\u2019kmaq Ecological Knowledge Study, also commonly referred to as MEKS or a TEKS, was developed by Membertou Geomatics Consultants for the Nova Scotia Department of Energy and Minas Basin Pulp and Power Co Ltd on behalf of the Fundy Ocean Research Centre for Energy (FORCE).\u00a0 In January 2008, the Province of Nova Scotia announced that Minas Basin Pulp and Power Co Ltd. had been awarded the opportunity to construct a tidal energy testing and research facility in the Minas Basin, known as the Fundy Tidal Energy Demonstration Facility.\u00a0 This Facility will be managed by a non-profit corporation called FORCE.\n\nThe objectives of this study are twofold;\n\nto undertake a broad MEKS\u00a0study for the Bay of Fundy Phase I Area as it may relate to future renewable energy projects i.e. wind, tidal and wave, specifically in Phase 1 area of the Bay of Fundy (as identified in MGC Proposal - Minas Channel and Minas Basin), and\n\nto undertake a more focused MEKS review specific to the Fundy Tidal Energy Demonstration Project area which would consider the land and water area potentially affected by the project, identify what is the Mi\u2019kmaq traditional use activity that has or is currently taking place within the Project Site and Study Area and what Mi\u2019kmaq ecological knowledge presently exists in regards to the Project Site and Study Area.\n\nIn order for to the Fundy Tidal Energy Demonstration Project to proceed with the implementation of the project, the project proponent must receive required approvals from the involved regulatory departments, which involves the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA) for the federal environmental assessment.\u00a0 The Proposed Project is being assessed under a Joint Federal -\u00a0Provincial Assessment Process and the Environmental Assessment Document was registered with Nova Scotia Department of the Environment under the NS Environmental Assessment Regulations on June 17, 2009. This MEKS has been developed as a mechanism to ensure that Mi\u2019kmaq traditional knowledge and use of the Study Area is included in the environmental data and considered in the development of the Environmental Management Plan and Environmental Monitoring Plan if the project proceeds.\n\nIn order to ensure accountability and ethic responsibility of this MEKS, the MEKS development has adhered to the \u201cMi\u2019kmaq Ecological Knowledge Protocol\u201d.\u00a0 The protocol is a document that has been established by the Assembly of Nova Scotia Mi\u2019kmaq Chiefs, which speaks to the process, procedures and results that are expected of a MEKS.\u00a0\u00a0\n\nThe Mi\u2019kmaq Ecological Knowledge Study consisted of two major components:\n\n\u2022\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 Mi\u2019kmaq Traditional Land and Resource Use Activities, both past and present,\n\u2022\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 A Mi\u2019kmaq Significance Species Analysis, considering the resources that are important to Mi\u2019kmaq use.\n\nThe Mi\u2019kmaq Traditional Land and Resource Use Activities component utilized interviews as the key source of information regarding Mi\u2019kmaq use in the Project Site, Study Area and the Phase I Overall Area.\u00a0 The Project Site is located on the seabed in Minas Passage in the vicinity of Black Rock (west of Cape Sharp) on the Parrsboro (north) side of the Passage which includes the three turbines that will be located due west of Black Rock, approximately 1.25 km from the shoreline which will be installed on the seabed in approximately 30 - 45 m depth at low tide and an on-shore facility in the municipality of the County of Cumberland.\u00a0 The Study Area, is a 10\u00a0kilometer radius zone around the Project Site which encompasses Parrsboro and Greenhill, up into the Cobequid Mountains to south west of Lake Road Crooner, over Glasgow Mountain to Port Greville, crossing the Minas Basin and including Blomidon Peninsula from Cape Split to South Scots Bay to Cape Blomidon.\u00a0 The Phase I Overall Area, known as the Phase I Area, covers a part of the Chignecto Bay, the Bay of Fundy, Greville Bay, Minas Channel, and a large portion of the Minas Basin.\u00a0 This area also included:\n\n\u2022\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 to the south west: Berwick, Morden, and Dempseys Corner\n\u2022\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 to the south east: Hantsport, Horton, Cheverie, and the Avon River\n\u2022\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 to the north east: Parrsboro, Green Hill, Moose River, New Canaan\n\u2022\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0\u00a0 to the north west: New Yarmouth, West Apple River, and Advocate harbour.\n\nNumerous interviews were undertaken by the MEKS Team with Mi\u2019kmaq hunters, fishers and plant gatherers, who shared with the team the details of their knowledge of traditional use activities.\u00a0 The interviews were undertaken during the months of June and July 2009, whereby Mi\u2019kmaq were shown topographical maps of the Project Site, Study Area and the Phase I Area.\u00a0 Those interviewed were then asked to identify where they undertake their activities as well as to identify where and what activities were undertook by other Mi\u2019kmaq.\u00a0 All interviews were recorded with permission of the interviewee.\u00a0 If permitted by the interviewee, their information was incorporated into the GIS data.\u00a0 These interviews allowed the team to develop data that reflects the most recent Mi\u2019kmaq traditional use in this area.\u00a0 All interviewee\u2019s names are kept confidential and will not be released by MGC as part of a consent form between MGC and the interviewee to ensure confidentiality.\n\nThe data gathered was also considered in regards to Mi\u2019kmaq Significance whereby each Species identified was analyzed through the consideration as food\/sustenance resources, medicinal\/ceremonial plant resources and art\/tools resources.\u00a0\u00a0 These resources were also considered for their availability or abundance in the areas listed above, and their availability in areas adjacent or in other areas outside of these areas, their use, and their importance, with regards to the Mi\u2019kmaq.\n\nThis Mi\u2019kmaq Ecological Knowledge Study has also gathered, documented and analyzed the traditional use activities that have been occurring in the Project Site, Study Area and Phase I Area by undertaking interviews with individuals who practice traditional use or know of traditional use activities within these areas and reside in the nearby Mi\u2019kmaq communities.\n\nProject Site:\n\nBased on the data documentation and analysis, it was found that the Mi\u2019kmaq have historically undertaken traditional fishing activities in the Project Site, and that this practice continues to occur today.\u00a0 Commercial Fishing and harvesting activities by members of the Annapolis Valley First Nation was found to have occurred and is still occurring today.\u00a0 Lobster, Mackeral and Herring are currently, and have been in the recent past, fished for commercial purposes while Lobster and Halibut are currently being fished for harvesting.\n\nStudy Area:\n\nBased on the data documentation and analysis, it was concluded that the Mi\u2019kmaq have historically undertaken traditional use activities in the Study Area, and that this practice continues to occur today.\u00a0 These activities involve the harvesting of fish species, plants and animals; all of which occurs in varying locations throughout the Study Area and at varying times of the year.\u00a0\u00a0\n\nFlounder, Lobster and Mackeral was found to be the most fished species in the Study Area.\u00a0 Halibut, Haddock, Herring, Perch, Periwinkle, Trout, Cod, Clams and Mussels were also found to a somewhat lesser degree. Deer, Rabbit and Partridge were found to be the most hunted species within Study Area.\u00a0 Blueberries, Apples and Strawberry were the most harvested plant species that was found within the Study Area.\u00a0\u00a0\n\nBear, Beaver, Bobcat, Deer, Lynx, Muskrat, Otter, Partridge, Pheasant, Porpoise, Rabbit and Raccoon were found to be hunted within the Study Area with no specific species identified as the majority species harvested.\u00a0 Dulse was the only plant identified that is harvested by the Mi\u2019kmaq in the Study Area.\u00a0\u00a0\n\nA historical site, a historical fishing area and a reported burial site was also identified through the interview process within the Study Area.\n\nPhase I Area:\n\nBased on the data documentation and analysis, it was concluded that the Mi\u2019kmaq have historically undertaken traditional use activities in the Phase I Area, and that this practice continues to occur today.\u00a0 These activities involve the harvesting of fish species, plants and animals; all of which occurs in varying locations throughout the Phase I Area and at varying times of the year.\u00a0\u00a0\n\nLobster, Mackeral, Flounder, and Herring were found to the most fished species in the area both currently and traditionally.\u00a0 Deer, Rabbit and Partridge were found to be the most hunted species within Phase 1 Area, both currently and traditionally.\u00a0 Blueberries, Apples and Strawberry were the most harvested plant species that was found within the Phase 1 Area.\u00a0\u00a0\n\nSeveral archaeological sites, historical sites, legend areas and a reported burial site were also identified within the Phase 1 Area through the interview process and historical documents.","author":["Moore, D.","Hodder, G."],"organization":["Membertou Geomatics Solutions","Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)","Nova Scotia Department of Energy"],"originationDate":"2009-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.325539800000","-64.412410600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BayofFundy-Phase1-2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1633","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/phase-2-bay-fundy-nova-scotia-including-outer-bay-fundy-tidal-energy-project-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.oera.ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2013\/04\/MEKS-Phase-II-Final-Report.pdf","title":"Phase 2 - Bay of Fundy, Nova Scotia including the Outer Bay of Fundy Tidal Energy Project Site - Mi\u0027kmaq Ecological Knowledge Study","description":"This Mi\u2019kmaq Ecological Knowledge Study, also commonly referred to as a MEKS or a TEKS, was developed by Membertou Geomatics Solutions for the Nova Scotia Department of Energy and Fundy Tidal Inc.\u00a0 Fundy Tidal Inc. plans to install and operate Tidal In-stream Energy Conversion devices, supporting technologies, and infrastructure within the Outer Bay of Fundy and Digby County, Nova Scotia, known as the Outer Bay of Fundy Tidal Energy project.\n\nThe objectives of this study are twofold:\n\nTo undertake a broad MEKS for the Bay of Fundy Phase II Area as it may relate to future renewable energy projects (i.e. wind, tidal and wave), specifically in the Phase II Area of the Bay of Fundy), and\nTo undertake a more focused MEKS review specific to the Outer Bay of Fundy Energy Project Site and Study Area.\n\nThis MEKS mandate has been to consider the land and water area that the project will utilize and identify what is the Mi\u2019kmaq traditional use activity that has or is currently taking place within, and what Mi\u2019kmaq ecological knowledge presently exists in regards to the Project Site, Study Area and Phase II Area.\u00a0 In order to ensure accountability and ethic responsibility of this MEKS, the MEKS development has adhered to the \u201cMi\u2019kmaq Ecological Knowledge Protocol\u201d.\u00a0 The protocol is a document that has been established by the Assembly of Nova Scotia Mi\u2019kmaq Chiefs, which speaks to the process, procedures and results that are expected of a MEKS.\u00a0\n\nThe Mi\u2019kmaq Ecological Knowledge Study consisted of two major components:\n\n\u00a0Mi\u2019kmaq Traditional Land and Resource Use Activities,both past and present,\n\u00a0A Mi\u2019kmaq Significance Species Analysis, considering the resources that are important to Mi\u2019kmaq use.\n\nThe Mi\u2019kmaq Traditional Land and Resource Use Activities component utilized interviews as the key source of information regarding Mi\u2019kmaq use in the Project Site, Study Area and the Phase II Area.\u00a0 \u00a0\n\nThe Project Site(s) cover an area in the Digby Gut around Bay View, and Victoria Beach; the southern tip of Digby Neck, including East Ferry, Petit Passage, and a northern portion of Long Island including Tiverton to just northeast of Central Grove; the southern tip of Long Island, including Freeport, a northeastern part of Brier Island, including Westport and Peter Island, as well as Grand Passage; as well as a southwest portion of Brier Island, extending into the Bay of Fundy and Gulf of Maine.\u00a0 The Study Area is the area within a five kilometer (5km) radius of the Project Site(s).\u00a0\n\nThe Phase II Area includes areas of the Bay of Fundy directly north, west and south of the Project Sites straddling back through St. Mary\u2019s Bay to Digby Gut.\u00a0 The Phase II Areas also include lands between Bear Cove, Nova Scotia, following a northeast direction to areas just north of the Tobeatic Wilderness Area.\n\nNumerous interviews were undertaken by the MEKS Team with Mi\u2019kmaq hunters, fishers, and plant gatherers, who shared with the team the details of their knowledge of traditional use activities.\u00a0 The interviews took place in February and March, 2012.\u00a0 These informants were shown topographical maps of the Project Site, Study Area and Phase II Area and then asked to identify where they undertake their activities as well as to identify where and what activities were undertaken by other Mi\u2019kmaq.\u00a0 All interviews were voice recorded with permission of the interviewee for the sole purpose of data verification during the analysis to collected information.\u00a0 If permitted by the interviewee, their information was incorporated into the GIS data.\u00a0 These interviews allowed the team to develop a collection of data that reflected the most recent Mi\u2019kmaq traditional use in this area.\u00a0 All interviewee\u2019s names are kept confidential and will not be released by MGS as part of a consent agreement between MGS and the interviewee to ensure confidentiality.\n\nThe data gathered was also considered in regards to Mi\u2019kmaq Significance.\u00a0 Each species identified was analyzed by considering their use as food\/sustenance resources, medicinal\/ceremonial plant resources and art\/tools resources. These resources were also considered for their availability or abundance in the areas listed above, and their availability in areas adjacent or in other areas outside of these areas, their use, and their importance, with regards to the Mi\u2019kmaq.\n\nThis Mi\u2019kmaq Ecological Knowledge Study has also gathered, documented and analyzed the traditional use activities that have been occurring within the Project Site, Study Area and Phase II Area, by undertaking interviews with individuals who practice traditional use or know of traditional use activities within these areas and reside in the nearby Mi\u2019kmaq communities.\n\nProject Site\n\nBased on the data documentation and analysis, it was found that the Mi\u2019kmaq have historically undertaken some fishing, hunting, and gathering activities in the Project Site and that this practice continues to occur today.\u00a0 It appears the majority of activity that occurs in the area is the fishing of lobster and mackerel.\n\nStudy Area\n\nBased on the data documentation and analysis, it was concluded that the Mi\u2019kmaq have historically undertaken traditional use activities in the Study Area, and that this practice continues to occur today.\u00a0 These activities primarily involve the harvesting of fish species, but also include plants and animals; all of which occurs in varying locations throughout the Study Area and at varying times of the year.\n\nLobster was found to be the most fished species in the Study Area.\u00a0 Mackerel and clam were also found to be harvested in the area, but at a somewhat relatively lesser degree.\u00a0 Seal, deer, partridge, pheasant and porpoise were all found to be hunted in the Study Area, but not in enough numbers to determine a primary hunted species.\u00a0 Dulse and sweetgrass were the most harvested plant species that was found within the Study Area.\n\nPhase II Area\n\nBased on the data documentation and analysis, it was concluded that the Mi\u2019kmaq have historically undertaken traditional use activities in the Phase II Area, and that this practice continues to occur today.\u00a0 These activities primarily involve the harvesting of fish species, but also include plants and animals; all of which occurs in varying locations throughout the Phase II Area and at varying times of the year.\u00a0 \u00a0\n\nLobster was found to be the most fished species in the Phase II Area.\u00a0 Mackerel and clam were also found to be harvested in the area, but at a somewhat relatively lesser degree.\u00a0 Deer was found to be the most hunted species in the Phase II Area.\u00a0 Rabbit, partridge, seal and other species were also found to be hunted in the Phase II Area, but at a somewhat relatively lesser degree.\u00a0 Dulse and sweetgrass were the most harvested plant species that was found within the Phase II Area.","author":["Moore, D.","Hodder, C."],"organization":["Membertou Geomatics Solutions","Fundy Tidal Inc","Nova Scotia Department of Energy"],"originationDate":"2012-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.247593800000","-66.393170700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BayofFundy-Phase2-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1634","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-sea-density-marine-birds-support-atlantic-marine-renewable-energy-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/coastalscience.noaa.gov\/data_reports\/modeling-at-sea-density-of-marine-birds-to-support-atlantic-marine-renewable-energy-planning-final-report\/","title":"Modeling At-Sea Density of Marine Birds to Support Atlantic Marine Renewable Energy Planning","description":"Marine birds have the potential to be affected by human activities in the ocean environment such as offshore wind energy development. This report describes a project that developed maps of the spatial distributions of marine bird species in U.S. Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf (OCS) waters that can be used to aid ocean planning in the region and guide future data collection efforts. Sighting survey data from over three decades contained in the \u2018Northwest Atlantic Seabird Catalog\u2019 database, along with Eastern Canada Seabirds at Sea data from Canadian Wildlife Service, Environment and Climate Change Canada, were analyzed to derive seasonal maps of the spatial distributions of 47 marine bird species in U.S. Atlantic OCS and adjacent waters from Florida to Maine. Spatial predictive modeling was applied to the survey data to account for spatial and temporal heterogeneity in survey effort, platform, and protocol. An ensemble machine-learning technique, component-wise boosting of hierarchical zero-inflated count models, was used to relate the relative density of each species to multiple spatial and temporal predictor variables while accounting for survey heterogeneity and the aggregated nature of sightings. Dynamic spatial environmental predictor variables were formulated as long-term climatologies. The modeling technique allowed for complex non-linear relationships between response and predictor variables and interacting effects among predictors. Bootstrapping was used to derive estimates of the uncertainty in model predictions. Model predictions are presented as seasonal maps of the relative density of each study species throughout the study area. The maps were reviewed by experts with experience and knowledge of marine birds in the study area and their comments were incorporated in this report. The maps indicate where species are likely to be more or less abundant. The analysis was not designed to estimate the actual number of individuals\/density of a given species that would be expected in any location, so the maps should not be interpreted that way. Also, the maps represent the spatial distributions of birds averaged over time (e.g., across days within a season and across years for a given season). The analysis was not designed to provide predictions of the density of birds that would be expected in a specific location at a specific date or time, so the maps should also not be interpreted that way. Two indications of the uncertainty associated with the model predictions are provided. First, a hatched overlay is included on the maps of predicted relative density to indicate areas with no survey effort. Model predictions in areas with no survey effort should be interpreted with extreme caution. Predictions in these areas were often questionable or unrealistic, so we recommend additional field surveys in these areas to validate the model predictions. Second, estimates of the precision of model predictions are presented as maps of the coefficient of variation (CV) of predicted relative density. Less precise predictions (i.e., higher CV) should be interpreted with more caution. The maps of predicted relative density should always be considered in conjunction with these two indications of uncertainty. The relative importance of different predictor variables is also presented, indicating which variables most influenced the predicted distributions for each species in each season. While the primary objective of this study was not to determine the ecological drivers and mechanisms behind the spatial distributions of marine bird species in the study area, our model results may provide useful hypotheses for future studies aimed more at ecological inference.\n\nAppendix A:\u00a0Description of individual survey datasets analyzed\nAppendix B:\u00a0Predictor variable plots and grids\nAppendix C:\u00a0Maps of predicted relative density and its coefficient of variation (CV) for each species and season modeled\nAppendix D:\u00a0Tables of predicted relative abundance as a proportion of total relative abundance in the\u00a0study area by BOEM wind energy planning\/lease area and season for each species modeled","author":["Kinlan, B.","White, T.","Winship, A.","Leirness, J.","Christensen, J."],"organization":["US Department of Commerce (DOC)","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BOEM_2018-010_Appendix_D.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1635","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/investigation-wind-induced-background-sound-levels-rural-areas-existing-proposed-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/2180\/1927","title":"An Investigation of the Wind Induced Background Sound Levels in Rural Areas for Existing and Proposed Wind Farms","description":"The increasing prevalence of wind power across the globe has led to a growth in the number of wind turbines in proximity to human settlement. As a result, the sound level impact from wind turbines has become a fairly contentious issue in some areas. The audibility of wind turbine generators is often a factor of low background sound levels, which in rural environments are dominated by natural sounds. Thus, HGC Engineering has considered ambient sound levels as part of a number of acoustic audits and assessments for existing and proposed wind farms. This paper investigates the variability of wind induced background sound levels in various rural areas by comparing sound level measurements conducted by HGC Engineering in Canada, the United States, and Central America with the reference background sound levels presented by the Ontario Ministry of the Environment (MOE). Specific consideration will be given to the effects of topography and the relationship between hub height wind speeds and ground level wind speeds. This analysis of actual wind induced background sound levels provides a better understanding of the sound level impact from wind turbines in varying rural environments.","author":["Bonsma, I.","Munro, M."],"organization":["HGC Engineering"],"originationDate":"2009-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1636","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farm-noise-assessment-australia-model-comparison","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/1795\/1542","title":"Wind Farm Noise Assessment in Australia and Model Comparison","description":"Wind farm development in Australia has grown significantly since 1999. From 2003 to 2005, there were several proposals submitted for approval with numbers of turbines ranging from 30 to over 100. Noise impacts from wind farms remains a contentious issue for the community and statutory authorities, but there is no nationally agreed approach to assessment. Prediction methods can include computer modelling, but there are no preferred models and it is up to the developer to justify the model. Very little, if any, data has been published comparing the accuracy ofmodels. Compliance assessment is only required at the nearest residential or noise sensitive locations. Operators seem loathe to provide actual data to allow such comparisons to be made and provide some confidence in the predictions. This paper describes the noise assessment process for wind farms in Australia and compares the predictions of a number of models, including two commonly used industrial noise packages and one model specially developed for wind turbines.","author":["Tickell, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2006-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1637","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-regulatory-requirements-wind-turbines-alberta","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/1793\/1540","title":"Development of Regulatory Requirements for Wind Turbines in Alberta","description":"The process of developing regulations of any type is extremely challenging in that they must be relatively simple, easy to understand, technically correct, defensible in their need and approach, and enforceable. The Energy and Utility Board (EUB) recognized that the use of wind turbines for electrical generation in Alberta was growing at an alarming rate and that noise was going to be a significant issue for individuals and communities situated near wind farms. This paper examines the considerations that were taken by the EUB to understand the issues around noise and what ultimately influenced the regulatory requirements that will be incorporated in the new edition of the province\u2019s Noise Control Directive.","author":["Lewis, A.","DeGagne, D."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2006-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1638","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-geophysical-measurement-infrasound-wind-farm-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/1797\/1544","title":"Acoustic and Geophysical Measurement of Infrasound from Wind Farm Turbines","description":"An experiment was conducted to measure and characterize infrasound (and higher frequency acoustic energy) from turbines at a wind farm in Southern Alberta. Simultaneous telemetry and point measurements were acquired from three sensor types: low frequency geophones, acoustic microphones, and a precision sound analyzer. Measurements were recorded for three wind states: low, medium, and high. Down wind telemetry measurements were recorded for thirty (30) continuous 50m offsets, up to a distance of 1450 m from the wind farm. Point measurements, coincident with the telemetry measurements, were acquired with a low frequency precision sound analyzer for two offsets: 50m and 1000m from the turbines. The same measurements were recorded with the turbines on, and with the turbines off. The low frequency results of the experiment are presented in this paper.\u00a0","author":["Hepburn, H."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2006-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1639","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cape-breton-resource-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/oera.ca\/research\/cape-breton-tidal-energy-resource-assessment","title":"Cape Breton Resource Assessment","description":"The following document was prepared for the O\ufb00shore Energy Research Association of Nova Scotia (OERANS). It summarizes the \ufb02ow measurements that were made using acoustic Doppler current pro\ufb01lers (ADCPs) at three locations in Cape Breton: two in the Great Bras d\u2019Or Channel (Carey Point and Seal Island Bridge), and one in the Barra Strait (near Iona). The measurements at Seal Island Bridge and Barra Strait were recorded over the duration of a month using a bottom mounted 600 kHz ADCP beginning in November 2011 and April 2012, respectively. These two deployments were conducted by Dalhousie University. The measurements at Carey Point were recorded for over 7 months beginning in October 2002 using a 300 kHz ADCP that was situated approximately 4 m above the sea\ufb02oor and held in place by a taut wire mooring. The deployment at Carey Point was conducted by the Bedford Institute of Oceanography.  Of the three sites, Carey Point has the most energetic \ufb02ow with horizontal currents reaching 2.8 m\/s. The maximum currents at Seal Island Bridge and Barra Strait were 1.9 m\/s and 1.1 m\/s, respectively. Furthermore, the vertical velocities at all three sites exceeded 4 cm\/s during some tidal cycles. The vertical pro\ufb01le of the horizontal currents at Seal Island Bridge and Barra Strait were used to determine the bottom friction coef-\ufb01cients during both the \ufb02ood and ebb phases of the tide. The Barra Strait values were in agreement with the canonical value of 0.003, whereas the Seal Island Bridge values were an order of magnitude larger which suggests the possibility of turbulent \ufb02ow in the boundary layer.  This document also presents the predicted output of four typical Tidal Energy Con-version (TEC) devices at each site. The TEC devices were assumed to be passive yaw devices with a water-to-wire e\ufb03ciency of 0.4. Recognizing that these assumptions result in estimates greater than a realisable value, we compare the average daily energy produc-tion, maximum power output and operating time for the devices. The predictions indicate that an optimal 10 m diameter turbine could produce over 1000 kWh per day at the Carey Point ADCP deployment site. Given a Feed-In Tari\ufb00 (FIT) rate of 60 cents\/kWh, the resulting gross revenue would be $600\/day. At the same FIT rate, the 10 m device at Seal Island Bridge and Barra Strait would produce $110\/day and $20\/day, respectively, due to lower \ufb02ow speeds and power density. It is important to note that the water depth at all three sites is less than 22 m; therefore, a 10 m device may prove to be unfeasible due to navigational restrictions.","author":["Hay, A.","McMillan, J.","Trowse, D.","Schillinger, D.","Hatcher, B."],"organization":["Dalhousie University","Cape Breton University","Offshore Energy Research Association of Nova Scotia (OERA)"],"originationDate":"2012-08-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.959900000000","-60.798500000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Cape-Breton-Resource-Assessment.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1640","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/noise-characterization-subsea-tidal-kite","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/1.5080268","title":"Noise characterization of a subsea tidal kite","description":"This paper presents the first noise measurements of a quarter-scale subsea tidal kite (anchored to the sea floor by a tether and flying in a figure-eight configuration in the water column) operating in field conditions. Challenges in the measurement and post-processing of the data are detailed. Results are presented for three operating conditions of the kite: (1) varying turbine rotations per minute (RPM), (2) varying kite speed, and (3) a twisted tether. Turbine RPM was identified as the main parameter influencing noise emissions.","author":["Pine, M.","Schmitt, P.","Kregting, L.","Lieber, L.","Culloch, R."],"organization":["Queen\u0027s University Belfast","University of Victoria","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-11-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.383371600000","-5.566558300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1641","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stakeholder-priorities-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrel.gov\/docs\/fy11osti\/51590.pdf","title":"Stakeholder Priorities in Wind Energy","description":"This presentation was given at AWEA Windpower 2011 Conference \u0026amp; Exhibition, which was held from May 22 - 25, 2011 in Anaheim, California. The presentation delves into how understanding stakeholder values and concerns is critical to wind project success. The knowledge of stakeholders and their values allows space to develop a strategy that solves potential problems before they emerge. Project success depends on one\u0027s ability to manage varied community interests.","author":["Lantz, E."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)"],"originationDate":"2011-05-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2011_NREL_Lantz_WindEnergyStakeholders.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1642","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stakeholder-outcomes-wind-turbine-investment-irish-energy-policy-effective-reducing","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148116308710","title":"Stakeholder Outcomes in a Wind Turbine Investment; Is the Irish Energy Policy Effective in Reducing GHG Emissions by Promoting Small-Scale Embedded Turbines in SME\u0027s?","description":"As a member state of the European Union (EU), Ireland has adopted an energy policy which includes promoting wind powered electricity generators as an economically viable, GHG-reducing, alternative to environmentally damaging fossil-fuel driven electrical generators. This longitudinal, inductive in-depth study investigates the outcomes for the government and other stakeholders involved in a wind turbine project investment by a Small-to-Medium-Enterprise (SME) based in rural Ireland. A case study research methodology is used to acquire and analyse quantitative numerical data from multiple sources including electrical power and energy meters, historical electricity bills and company sustainability reports. The study found that the installation of this wind turbine did not contribute significantly to the EU-binding Green-House-Gas (GHG) national emissions targets. The research uncovered weaknesses in the sustainability reporting mechanism. The numbers of kWh energy units thought to have been produced by the wind turbine were overstated and this error went undetected by all of the stakeholders involved in this venture. This exploratory study will be of benefit to all stakeholders, including the national government who are promoting wind energy as a major player in the overall energy policy as they target a reduction of Green-House-Gas emissions.","author":["Kealy, T."],"organization":["Dublin Institute of Technology"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.350389000000","-6.269297000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1643","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/recent-developments-environmental-assessment-methods-wind-turbine-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/2035\/1782","title":"Recent Developments in Environmental Assessment Methods for Wind Turbine Noise","description":"Some of the latest developments in environmental methods for assessing wind turbine noise are discussed. HGC Engineering prepared a document for the Canadian Wind Energy Association (CanWEA), outlining best practices for the developers of wind farm projects and summarizing the assessment methodologies in the different areas in Canada. Some of the significant factors that are essential for wind turbine assessment, include factors which change with time, such as distance and site topography. Some of the latest developments in environmental assessment methodologies for wind turbines, include air absorption and ground absorption. The effect of variations in air temperature and humidity are considered by noise propagation models for wind turbines.","author":["Howe, B.","McCabe, N."],"organization":["HGC Engineering"],"originationDate":"2006-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1644","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-noise-assessment-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/1796\/1543","title":"Environmental Noise Assessment of Wind Farms","description":"Energy recovered from wind farms is becoming very popular in North America. However, the environmental impact of large wind farms is still under study and regulations are being fine-tuned to alleviate the impacts. Noise is perceived to be a major environmental concern of wind farms. The overall characteristics of wind farms and its noise potential will be discussed in this short review paper through a case study. Appropriate regulatory guidelines will be applied and the noise impact of wind farms are assessed and discussed in this paper.","author":["Lightstone, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2006-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1645","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-health-impact-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.health.gov.on.ca\/en\/common\/ministry\/publications\/reports\/wind_turbine\/wind_turbine.aspx","title":"The Potential Health Impact of Wind Turbines","description":"This report was prepared by the Chief Medical Officer of Health (CMOH) of Ontario in response to public health concerns about wind turbines, particularly related to noise.  Assisted by a technical working group comprised of members from the Ontario Agency for Health Protection and Promotion (OAHPP), the Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care (MOHLTC) and several Medical Officers of Health in Ontario with the support of the Council of Ontario Medical Officers of Health (COMOH), this report presents a synopsis of existing scientific evidence on the potential health impact of noise generated by wind turbines.  The review concludes that while some people living near wind turbines report symptoms such as dizziness, headaches, and sleep disturbance, the scientific evidence available to date does not demonstrate a direct causal link between wind turbine noise and adverse health effects. The sound level from wind turbines at common residential setbacks is not sufficient to cause hearing impairment or other direct health effects, although some people may find it annoying.","author":["Chief Medical Officer of Heath of Ontario"],"organization":["Ontario Ministry of Health \u0026 Long-Term Care"],"originationDate":"2010-05-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Health \u0026 Safety","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-12 08:20:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/wind_health_impacts_OntarioReport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1646","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbine-noise-overview","sourceURL":"https:\/\/jcaa.caa-aca.ca\/index.php\/jcaa\/article\/view\/1791\/1538","title":"Wind Turbine Noise - An Overview","description":"This paper presents a general overview of wind turbine noise including sources, measurements standards, psychoacoustics, infrasound, propagation and regulatory perspectives. The authors presented similar material at the National Wind Coordinating Committee\u2019s special meeting on \u201cTechnical Considerations in Siting Wind Developments\u201d held in Washington D.C. In addition, many relevant papers can be found in the proceedings of the First International Conference on Wind Turbine Noise 2005, some of which are summarized here.","author":["S\u00f8ndergaard, B.","Rogers, A.","Bastasch, T.","van Dam, J."],"organization":["CH2M Hill","University of Massachusetts","Windward Engineering"],"originationDate":"2006-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1647","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/strategic-health-impact-assessment-wind-energy-development-oregon","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.oregon.gov\/oha\/PH\/HEALTHYENVIRONMENTS\/TRACKINGASSESSMENT\/HEALTHIMPACTASSESSMENT\/Pages\/completedhias.aspx","title":"Strategic Health Impact Assessment on Wind Energy Development in Oregon","description":"Wind Energy is an important area of renewable energy development for the Pacific Northwest and for the United States. As a key area of energy and economic development, wind energy has positive contributions to offer to Oregon and to the communities that host and are served by wind energy projects. In response to ever-growing energy demand and concerns over environmental and health impacts of petroleum and coal-based energy production, many states have enacted laws and policies requiring that increasing portions of their energy portfolios be derived from sustainable energy production, such as hydro, wind, solar, geo-thermal and wave sources. In 2007, Oregon\u2019s Legislature enacted one of the most aggressive sustainable energy plans among other states in the U.S. by passing a renewable energy bill that requires large utilities to obtain at least 25% of their retail electricity portfolio from renewable sources by 2025.  There is little doubt that sustainable energy development is here to stay, but some who live and work in locations where this development is occurring are expressing mixed reactions to the projects being built in their backyards. As these developments are sited near more communities around the state, there are questions and concerns about the potential impacts these projects have on nearby communities.  Health Impact Assessment (HIA) is a tool that is being used with increasing frequency around the world. Developed in the European Union in the 1990\u2019s and ratified by consensus of the World Health Organization, HIA is \u201ca combination of procedures, methods and tools by which a policy, programme or project may be judged as to its potential effects on the health of a population, and the distribution of those effects within the population.\u201d1 HIAs are guided by the World Health Organization\u2019s definition of health as \u201ca state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity.\u201d  An HIA, as endorsed by the World Health Organization, aims to ensure that:    people can meaningfully participate in a transparent process for the formulation, implementation and evaluation of policies that affect their health, both directly and through elected political decision makers,  both positive and negative impacts are shared equitably across a community,  both short term and long term impacts are considered in the decision-making process, and  different scientific disciplines and methodologies are used as needed to get as comprehensive an assessment as possible.   This Health Impact Assessment was conducted as a \u201cstrategic HIA\u201d, as differentiated from a site-specific HIA. A site-specific HIA is designed primarily to answer questions about the health impact of a specific project. In contrast, this HIA is a more general assessment of the ways that wind energy developments in Oregon might affect the health of individuals and communities where they are built and maintained. It is designed to provide both a framework and relevant reference material for future HIAs that may be conducted on proposed wind energy installations. It is intended for use in Oregon, but we recognize that there are communities outside of Oregon where wind energy is being proposed and developed who may also find this a useful framework.  All development projects have both advocates and opponents, and the passions around wind energy developments in Oregon were running high when this HIA was conceived and executed. So it is not at all surprising that this HIA engendered some controversy. I want to recognize the staff that worked on this HIA, particularly the project lead, Dr. Jae Douglas, and thank them for their willingness to guide this project through those choppy waters, and maintain their professionalism and commitment to the goals of this project. Similarly, I want to recognize and thank the members of the project Steering Committee for their extremely constructive engagement with us, despite the passions which this work may have aroused.  Sometimes in the heat of controversy about development projects, economic development and health protection get portrayed as in opposition to one another. But this is a false dichotomy. A robust economy is a powerful driver of good health, just as healthy workers are a critical ingredient to a sustainably robust economy. Both are needed for a truly healthy community. While individual decisions related to a specific development project may of necessity involve compromising one of these goals in favor of another, the long-term public interest is best served when the interdependence of these goals is recognized and balanced through a process that empowers people to shape their lives and communities. It is my hope that this HIA will be a useful tool to do just that for future wind energy development projects in Oregon.","author":["Joshi, S.","Hamberg, A.","Cain, D.","Douglas, J.","Teshale, S.","Early-Alberts, J."],"organization":["Public Health Division Oregon Health Authority","Public Health Division Oregon Health Authority"],"originationDate":"2013-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.241715000000","-122.993204000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Joshietal2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1648","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/state-science-assessment-research-ecological-impacts-wind-energy-great-lakes-region","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.glc.org\/state-of-the-science-an-assessment-of-research-on-the-ecological-impacts-of-wind-energy-in-the-great-lakes-region\/","title":"State of the Science: An Assessment of Research on the Ecological Impacts of Wind Energy in the Great Lakes Region","description":"This report provides an assessment of the research and research needs based on information presented at the March 2011 Great Lakes Wind Collaborative State of the Science Workshop on the Ecological Effects of Wind.","author":["Hinderer, J.","Pebbles, V.","Pearson, B.","Hummer, J."],"organization":["Great Lakes Wind Collaborative (GLWC)","Great Lakes Commission (GLC)"],"originationDate":"2011-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2011_GLWC_StateOScience.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1649","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-o-summary-current-information-related-electromagnetic-field-impacts-fish","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_O_Summary_Current_Info_Related_EMF_Impacts_Fish_and_Trans_Cable.pdf","title":"Appendix O Summary of Current Information Related to Electromagnetic Field Impacts on Fish and LEEDCo Proposed Transmission Cable","description":"This document is Appendix O from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. The Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDC0) is proposing to develop the first offshore freshwater wind project in the Great Lakes \u2013 planned to be located in Lake Erie offshore of Cleveland. As part of the project, an eight mile long, three-phase, 34.5kV, AC transmission cable will be buried below the sediment surface along the bottom of Lake Erie to transmit electricity from the turbines to the mainland transformer station. During recent discussions regarding the LEEDCo project, the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) expressed an interest in the potential impacts of the electric transmission cable on fish in the project area; particularly with respect to electromagnetic field (EMF) impacts. In addition, the ODNR Aquatic Sampling Protocol for Offshore Wind Development requires acoustic telemetry studies to monitor fish behavior and the ODNR has suggested that LEEDCo\u2019s study should also include monitoring near the transmission line to evaluate its effects on fish behavior. This memorandum is intended to summarize current research and information regarding the impact of EMFs on fish and provide our assessment of the likely impact to fish in the vicinity of the proposed transmission line. Based on the current research and existing EMF fish impact studies that have been done in the Great Lakes, the expected EMF to be generated by the LEEDCo electric transmission line will not have an adverse impact on fish behavior and habitat.","author":["Verhamme, E.","Daley, J.","Peterson, G."],"organization":["LimnoTech","Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo)"],"originationDate":"2016-06-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_O_Summary_Current_Info_Related_EMF_Impacts_Fish_and_Trans_Cable.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1650","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-energy-understanding-impacts-great-lakes-fishery-other-aquatic-resources","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.glc.org\/library\/2013-offshore-wind-energy-understanding-impacts-on-great-lakes-fishery","title":"Offshore Wind Energy: Understanding Impacts on Great Lakes Fishery and Other Aquatic Resources","description":"This document summarizes discussions from the workshop Offshore Wind Energy \u2013 Understanding Impacts on Great Lakes Fishery and Other Aquatic Resources. Organized by the Great Lakes Commission (GLC), through the Great Lakes Wind Collaborative (GLWC), the workshop took place on November 28-29, 2012, at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration\u2019s Great Lakes Environmental Research Laboratory (GLERL) in Ann Arbor, Michigan. Primary funding support for the workshop came from the Great Lakes Fishery Trust.   The need for the workshop grew out of a 2011 report by the Great Lakes Wind Collaborative (State of the Science Report: Ecological Impacts of Wind Energy in the Great Lakes Region). That report noted that Great Lakes region-specific research, particularly as it relates to offshore wind, is notably lacking. Additional research and studies are needed to direct how wind projects are planned, sited and operated in the region. As such, the November 2012 workshop aimed to build knowledge about the potential impacts of offshore wind energy on the Great Lakes fishery and related aquatic resources by:    sharing scientific and related policy and management information about what is known about the impacts of offshore wind farms on aquatic resources;  identifying the most important questions that need to be addressed to effectively review permit applications for offshore wind development; and  identifying knowledge gaps and priority areas for future research to answer the most important questions that decisionmakers face when determining whether and how wind projects are planned, sited and operated in the waters of the Great Lakes.   Contents:    Background and Introduction  Offshore Wind in the U.S. and Canada  Status of OSW in the Great Lakes  Workshop Discussion and Findings     Physical and Biological Context   Potential Impacts on Fish       Noise    Electromagnetic Fields    Turbidity    Fish Movement    Lakebed Habitat    Fishing    Artificial Reefs         Potential Impacts on Other Aquatic Resources       Ice    Bathymetry    Wind Climate    Waves    Sediment Transport    Circulation Patterns            Research Needs  Summary and Conclusions  Appendix A - Workshop Agenda  Attendee list  References","author":["GLWC","GLC"],"organization":["Great Lakes Commission (GLC)","Great Lakes Wind Collaborative (GLWC)"],"originationDate":"2013-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.216662000000","-83.735639000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/2013-fishery-impact-workshop-summary.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1651","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-e-2-limnotech-report-results-2017-aquatic-sampling","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_E-2_LimnoTech_2017_Aquatic_AnnualReport.pdf","title":"Appendix E-2 LimnoTech Report - Results of 2017 Aquatic Sampling","description":"This document is Appendix E-2 from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. The proposed Icebreaker Wind demonstration project will include installation of six wind turbines, 8 to 10 miles offshore of Cleveland, Ohio in the Central Basin of Lake Erie. The turbines will be placed in water depths ranging from 58 feet to 63 feet, each with a nameplate capacity of 3.45 megawatts (MW) for a total generating capacity of 20.7 MW. A 2.3-mile buried electric cable will connect the six turbines, and an approximate 9.3-mile buried electric cable will connect the turbines to the Cleveland Public Power Lake Road substation.  The purpose of this report is to document the field methods, results, and analysis carried out in 2017 to support the Icebreaker Wind project. LimnoTech, under contract to Icebreaker Windpower, Inc., led a multi-disciplinary team of researchers to collect site specific data at the site of and in the vicinity of the proposed Offshore Wind (OSW) demonstration project in Lake Erie. The report includes the following major sections:    Project introduction (Section 1)  Sampling methods (Section 2)   Results and discussion (Section 3)  Conclusion (Section 4)  References (Section 5)  Appendices","author":["LimnoTech"],"organization":["LimnoTech","Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo)"],"originationDate":"2018-02-08","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_E-2_LimnoTech_2017_Aquatic_AnnualReport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1652","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-e-1-limnotech-report-results-2016-aquatic-sampling","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_E-1_Final_2016_LimnoTech_Report.pdf","title":"Appendix E-1 LimnoTech Report - Results of 2016 Aquatic Sampling","description":"This document is Appendix E-1 from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. The proposed Icebreaker Wind demonstration project will include installation of six wind turbines, 8 to 10 miles offshore of Cleveland, Ohio in the Central Basin of Lake Erie. The turbines will be placed in water depths ranging from 58 feet to 63 feet, each with a nameplate capacity of 3.45 megawatts (MW) for a total generating capacity of 20.7 MW. The facility is expected to operate for approximately 8,200 hours annually, and have an approximate capacity factor of 41.1%, generating approximately 75,000 megawatt- hours (MWh) of electricity each year. A 2.3-mile buried electric cable will connect the six turbines, and an approximate 9.3-mile buried electric cable will connect the turbines to the Cleveland Public Power Lake Road substation.   The purpose of this report is to document the field methods, results, and analysis carried out in 2016 to support the Icebreaker Wind project. LimnoTech, under contract to Icebreaker Windpower, Inc., led a multi-disciplinary team of researchers to collect site specific data at the site of and in the vicninity of the proposed Offshore Wind (OSW) demonstration project in Lake Erie. The report includes the following major sections:    Project introduction (Section 1)  Sampling methods (Section 2)  Results and discussion (Section 3)  Conclusion (Section 4)  References (Section 5)  Appendices","author":["LimnoTech"],"organization":["LimnoTech","Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_E-1_Final_2016_LimnoTech_Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1653","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-m-1-biological-assessment-project-icebreaker","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_M-1_Biological_Assessment.pdf","title":"Appendix M-1 Biological Assessment for Project Icebreaker","description":"This document is Appendix M-1 from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) is proposing to authorize the expenditure of federal funding to support the design, permitting, construction, and decommissioning of a proposed offshore wind energy demonstration project in Lake Erie. Project Icebreaker (the Project) would be an approximately 21 megawatt (MW) offshore wind energy demonstration project consisting of six wind turbine generators in Lake Erie, approximately 8-10 miles from Cleveland, Ohio. DOE is the lead federal agency responsible for the preparation of an Environmental Assessment (EA) for the Project. The U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) and the U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) are cooperating agencies. USACE is responsible for reviewing impacts pursuant to Section 404 and 408 of the Clean Water Act and Section 10 of the Rivers and Harbors Act. USCG is responsible for reviewing impacts related to navigation and the USCG mission.  This Biological Assessment (BA) was prepared in accordance with Section 7 of the Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA), which requires that all Federal agencies ensure that any action they authorize, fund, or execute will not jeopardize the continued existence of any federally-listed threatened or endangered species (i.e., listed species) or result in the destruction or adverse modification of any critical habitat of such species.  Five federally-listed species may occur in Cuyahoga County, Ohio at some point in their life cycles. Thus, these are the federally-listed species that could potentially be affected by the proposed action:    Indiana bat (Myotis sodalis) \u2013 Endangered  Northern long-eared bat (Myotis septentrionalis) \u2013 Threatened  Kirtland\u2019s warbler (Setophaga kirtlandii) \u2013 Endangered  Piping plover (Charadrius melodus) \u2013 Endangered  Rufa red knot (Calidris canatus rufa) \u2013 Threatened   There are no candidate species, proposed listed species, or proposed or designated critical habitats in Cuyahoga County, Ohio. The purpose of this BA is to review the proposed Project in sufficient detail to determine to what extent the proposed action may affect any of the threatened and endangered species listed above.","author":["EDR, D.P.C."],"organization":["Environmental Design \u0026 Research, Landscape Architecture, Engineering, \u0026 Environmental Services, D.P.C. (EDR)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_M-1_Biological_Assessment.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1654","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-l-2-west-bird-bat-annual-report-2018","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_L-2_WEST_Bird_Bat_Annual_Report_2018_0.pdf","title":"Appendix L-2 WEST Bird and Bat Annual Report 2018","description":"This document is Appendix L-2 from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. This first annual status report is being provided by Western EcoSystems Technology Inc. (WEST) to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) pursuant to the Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) between ODNR and Icebreaker Windpower Inc. (IWP) dated July 12, 2017. The MOU sets forth the avian and bat monitoring protocols, reporting requirements and other commitments of the parties in regard to construction and operation of the Icebreaker Wind Project (Project), a 20.7 megawatt offshore wind demonstration project proposed 8 to 10 miles (mi) off the shore of Cleveland, Ohio. This first annual report covers all activities undertaken by the WEST team related to items described in the MOU and associated Monitoring Plan (MP) during 2017. It encompasses the activity reported in the first two quarterly reports, submitted in September and December of 2017 pursuant to the MOU, and additional activities undertaken during December, 2017 and January, 2018. The report includes a comprehensive summary of all MOU-specified activity on the Project by the WEST team that has occurred through early February, 2018. This report summarizes, but does not fully recapitulate all of the detail contained within the previously submitted quarterly reports. Activities covered in the current report include bat acoustic monitoring surveys, conducted between March and November, 2017, ongoing aerial waterfowl and waterbird surveys initiated in mid-October, 2017, and ongoing research, meetings, and deliberations aimed at finalizing several components of the MP that were contemplated in the MOU. These include collection of baseline data using surveillance radar, exploration into emerging technologies for collision fatality monitoring in the offshore environment, and the completion of an initial draft of the Bird and Bat Conservation Strategy (BBCS) which includes committed impact avoidance and minimization measures, as well as an adaptive management plan for the Project.","author":["Gordon, C.","Good, R.","Matteson, A.","Stucker, J."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo)"],"originationDate":"2018-02-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_L-2_WEST_Bird_Bat_Annual_Report_2018_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1655","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-l-1-west-summary-risks-birds-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_L-1_WEST_Summary_of_Risks_to_Birds_and_Bats_0.pdf","title":"Appendix L-1 WEST Summary of Risks to Birds and Bats","description":"This document is Appendix L-1 from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio\u200b. The Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo) has proposed the Icebreaker Wind project, a small, demonstration 6-turbine, 20.7-megawatt (MW) offshore wind energy facility eight to 10 miles (13 to 21 kilometers [km]) from the shore of Cleveland, Ohio. WEST has completed a review and summary of baseline data and other publicly available data on bird and bat use and other information of the Project\u2019s environment for the purpose or evaluating the level of risk posed by the proposed project to birds and bats. The overall conclusion of this analysis is that the Project poses low risk of adverse impacts to birds and bats. This conclusion stems largely from two principal observations: 1) the Project is small in scale, consisting of six turbines; 2) the level of use of this area by birds and bats is low compared to bird and bat use of terrestrial or nearshore environments.","author":["Gordon, C.","Erickson, W."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo)"],"originationDate":"2016-11-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_L-1_WEST_Summary_of_Risks_to_Birds_and_Bats_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1656","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-k-tetra-tech-bird-survey-report-spring-fall-2010-avian-bat-studies-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_K_Tetra_Tech_Bird_Survey_Report_0.pdf","title":"Appendix K Tetra Tech Bird Survey Report: Spring - Fall 2010 Avian and Bat Studies Report Lake Erie Wind Power Study","description":"This document is Appendix K from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. Tetra Tech, Inc. (Tetra Tech) was contracted by the Cuyahoga County Department of Development (CCDD) to conduct avian and bat studies for the Lake Erie Wind Power Project (the Project). The Project will consist of up to eight turbines to be located off the coast of Ohio, approximately 4 to 7 miles (mi) into Lake Erie, north of the City of Cleveland. The avian and bat Study Area consisted of habitat within 4 nautical mile (nm) radius circle centered on the City of Cleveland Water Intake Crib (Crib), as well as the adjacent shoreline south and east of the Crib. This report provides the results of the baseline ecological surveys conducted in the Study Area in 2010.  The goal of the 2010 survey effort was to document the species composition, overall occurrence patterns, phenology, and flight behavior of birds and bats within the Study Area. The results of the 2010 field survey provide baseline data that may be used for the preparation of a formal risk assessment and for comparison with post-construction surveys. Surveys completed as part of the 2010 biological survey program included a MERLIN avian radar survey, boat-based surveys, avian acoustic monitoring, and bat acoustic monitoring.  For the purposes of this study, the turbine used to determine the rotor swept zone (RSZ) was the largest offshore wind turbine currently in production, which is the Siemens SWT 6.0, 6 megawatt (MW) with a rotor diameter of up to 165 meters (m) (541 feet [ft]) and a hub height of up to 120 m (394 ft). The size of the turbines used for the Lake Erie Wind project has yet to be determined, since the project is in its inception. The RSZ used for this report assumed the largest possible turbine that could be deployed at the time of the reporting, which would presumably present the greatest risk to birds and bats, and presumably any smaller turbine would present less risk. The RSZ used was defined as 27 m (89 ft) to 202.5 m (664 ft) above mean low water level (AMWL). The use of the largest turbine dimensions enables a conservative approach to risk assessment and it is possible that smaller turbines will be used, thereby reducing potential risk to birds and bats.","author":["Svedlow, A.","Gilpatrick, L.","McIlvain, D."],"organization":["Tetra Tech Inc.","Cuyahoga County Department of Development"],"originationDate":"2012-07-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_K_Tetra_Tech_Bird_Survey_Report_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1657","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-j-west-nexrad-analysis-assessment-nocturnal-bird-migration-activity-weather","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_J_WEST_NEXRAD_Analysis_0.pdf","title":"Appendix J WEST NEXRAD Analysis: Assessment of Nocturnal Bird Migration Activity from Weather Radar Data for the Proposed Icebreaker Wind Energy Facility, Lake Erie, Ohio","description":"This document is Appendix J from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. This document examines NEXRAD weather radar data from Cleveland, Ohio and another radar station in Buffalo, New York for the purpose of assessing nocturnal bird and bat migration above the proposed site of the Icebreaker Wind Energy Facility in Lake Erie, and several comparison areas near Cleveland and Buffalo. The acronym NEXRAD represents \u201cNEXt generation RADar\u201d,a network of approximately 160 Doppler radar stations maintained by the National Weather Service, and designed to monitor precipitation throughout the United States. NEXRAD data are stored and disseminated in two forms\u2013as raw, high resolution Level II data, and as more highly processed, lower resolution Level III data. Level II products include reflectivity (a measure of the density of reflecting targets), radial velocity (the component of velocity either toward or away from the radar unit), and several other products. Most radar ornithological studies published to date have relied on analysis of reflectivity and radial velocity.","author":["Gordon, C.","Nations, C."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-23","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_J_WEST_NEXRAD_Analysis_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1658","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-development-wind-energy-associated-changes-land-use-bird-densities-upland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/conbio.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/cobi.13239","title":"Effects of development of wind energy and associated changes in land use on bird densities in upland areas","description":"Wind energy development is the most recent of many pressures on upland bird communities and their habitats. Studies of birds in relation to wind energy development have focused on effects of direct mortality, but the importance of indirect effects (e.g., displacement, habitat loss) on avian community diversity and stability is increasingly being recognized. We used a control-impact study in combination with a gradient design to assess the effects of wind farms on upland bird densities and on bird species grouped by habitat association (forest and open-habitat species). We conducted 506 point count surveys at 12 wind-farm and 12 control sites in Ireland during 2 breeding seasons (2012 and 2013). Total bird densities were lower at wind farms than at control sites, and the greatest differences occurred close to turbines. Densities of forest species were significantly lower within 100 m of turbines than at greater distances, and this difference was mediated by habitat modifications associated with wind-farm development. In particular, reductions in forest cover adjacent to turbines was linked to the observed decrease in densities of forest species. Open-habitat species\u2019 densities were lower at wind farms but were not related to distance from turbines and were negatively related to size of the wind farm. This suggests that, for these species, wind-farm effects may occur at a landscape scale. Our findings indicate that the scale and intensity of the displacement effects of wind farms on upland birds depends on bird species\u2019 habitat associations and that the observed effects are mediated by changes in land use associated with wind-farm construction. This highlights the importance of construction effects and siting of turbines, tracks, and other infrastructure in understanding the impacts of wind farms on biodiversity.","author":["Wilson, M.","Fern\u00e1ndez-Bellon, D.","Irwin, S.","O\u0027Halloran, J."],"organization":["University College Cork","University of Stirling"],"originationDate":"2019-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.592884800000","-8.122031400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1659","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appendix-i-aquatic-ecological-resource-characterization-impact-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045_Appendix_I_Aquatic_Ecological_Resource_Characterization_and_Impact_Assessment.pdf","title":"Appendix I Aquatic Ecological Resource Characterization and Impact Assessment","description":"This document is Appendix I from the Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio. This document summarizes the relevant ecological issues affecting offshore wind development in Lake Erie that have been identified by experts. The report characterizes the site chosen by Icebreaker Windpower, Inc. (Icebreaker Windpower) for Icebreaker Wind, the six turbine demonstration project 8 to 10 miles off the shore of Cleveland, Ohio and assesses the potential aquatic ecological impact of the project on Lake Erie. This assessment was done utilizing a weight of evidence approach based on information presented from the following sources:    Review of risk factor maps created by Ohio Department of Natural Resources (ODNR) to specifically map out key aquatic habitats and areas of low and high potential impact from offshore wind across the Ohio Waters of Lake Erie.  Review of recent reports authored by experts from around the Great Lakes region as part of the Great Lakes Wind Collaborative (GLWC) to identify categories of impacts from offshore wind in the Great Lakes.  Review of other studies and reports from similar projects in Lake Erie, on the east coast of the U.S., and abroad where offshore wind (OSW) turbines have been installed in freshwater.  Collection of site specific ecological data in 2016 at the proposed project site to validate the impact assessments contained in GLWC reports and in ODNR\u2019s risk analysis maps.   A project team led by LimnoTech with support from Ohio State University and Cornell University identified relevant potential impact categories from ODNR and GLWC documents. These major impact categories included:    Aquatic habitat alteration during and after construction  Noise impacts during and after construction  Electromagnetic field impacts from electric cables  Sediment disturbance  Physical changes to wind, waves, and currents on the lake   The primary receptors for these potential impacts would include the following:    Fish, which includes all growth stages including larval, juvenile, and adult  Zooplankton and phytoplankton  Benthic macroinvertebrates  Humans that use the lake\u2019s resources for fishing, boating, swimming, and a source of drinking water   A review of the available information from federal, state, universities, and site specific data collected as part of the project concludes that Icebreaker Wind poses minimal risk to the aquatic ecological resources of Lake Erie. This conclusion was based on the following major assessment outcomes:    Aquatic habitat alteration  Sediment disturbance  Noise  Fish movement\/behavior  Physical lake conditions   The 2016 aquatic data collection by LimnoTech was conducted under the guidance of ODNR with review by the US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS). A comprehensive sampling plan was developed to guide the 2016 monitoring and characterization effort and to meet the requirements of the submerged lands lease from ODNR (ODNR, 2013). The sampling plan was first drafted in May 2016, but has undergone minor revisions after review with ODNR and USFWS. The latest version is dated January 23, 2017 (LimnoTech 2017). ODNR, USFWS and Icebreaker Windpower are finalizing a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU), which details the annual level of sampling and analysis that Icebreaker Windpower will be required to perform during all pre-, during-, and post- construction phases of the project. ODNR and USFWS will review monitoring data and address any discrepancies between the assessment of potential impacts and results from monitoring data.   It is our assessment that the scientific weight of evidence presented here shows that Icebreaker Wind presents minimal risk to the aquatic ecosystem. Ongoing engagement with regulators through ecosystem monitoring, adaptive management, and stakeholder engagement will address any other concerns.","author":["LimnoTech"],"organization":["LimnoTech","Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_Appendix_I_Aquatic_Ecological_Resource_Characterization_and_Impact_Assessment.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1660","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-environmental-assessment-leedco-project-icebreaker-lake-erie-city-cleveland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/sites\/prod\/files\/2018\/09\/f55\/EA-2045-LEEDCo-Final%20EA-2018.pdf","title":"Final Environmental Assessment LEEDCo Project Icebreaker Lake Erie, City of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio","description":"Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation\u0027s (LEEDCo\u2019s) Project Icebreaker (also known as Icebreaker Wind) was competitively selected for a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) financial assistance award under Funding Opportunity Announcement U.S. Offshore Wind: Advanced Technology Demonstration Projects (DE-FOA-0000410). DOE is proposing to provide funding to LEEDCo to support the development of the demonstration-scale offshore wind project that would be located approximately 8 miles off the shore of Cleveland, Ohio in Lake Erie. This Environmental Assessment (EA) evaluates the potential environmental impacts of providing funding to LEEDCo to support the development of the offshore wind advanced technology demonstration project (the Proposed Action) and evaluates the impacts that could occur if DOE did not provide funding (No-Action Alternative). The Proposed Project would consist of six wind turbine generators erected on foundations constructed on the Lake Erie lakebed that would generate approximately 21 megawatts (MW) of electricity. Inter-array cables (connecting the wind turbines) and an export cable (transmitting electricity generated by the wind turbines to the shore) would be buried in the lakebed, and the export cable would be brought ashore entirely under the Cleveland Harbor and the Cleveland Harbor breakwater to a new electrical substation located at the existing Lake Road Substation. The energy generated by the Proposed Project would deliver power to a single point of interconnection on the existing Cleveland Public Power electric grid \u2013 the138 kilovolt (kV) Lake Road Substation.\n\nList of Appendices:\n\nA-1 : Public Scoping Documents\n\nA-2 : Draft EA Public Comment Documents\n\nB : Substation Layout Plan\n\nC : Favorability Analysis Map\n\nD : Substation and Cable Route Design Report\n\nE-1 : LimnoTech Report \u2013 Results of 2016 Aquatic Sampling\n\nE-2 : LimnoTech Report \u2013 Results of 2017 Aquatic Sampling\n\nF-1 : Alpine Geophysical Survey Report\n\nF-2 : McNeilan Windfarm Ground Conditions Report\n\nF-3 : McNeilan Harbor \u0026amp; Nearshore Ground Conditions Report\n\nG-1 : Sediment Quality Evaluation Technical Memorandum\n\nG-2 : Inadvertent Return Contingency Plan\n\nH : Substation Geotechnical and Subsurface Exploration Report\n\nI : Aquatic Ecological Resource Characterization and Impact Assessment\n\nJ : WEST NEXRAD Analysis\n\nK : Tetra Tech Bird Survey Report\n\nL-1 : WEST Summary of Risks to Birds and Bats\n\nL-2 : WEST Bird and Bat Annual Report 2018\n\nM-1 : Biological Assessment\n\nM-2 : USFWS BA Concurrence Letter\n\nN : ODNR Division of Wildlife Letter\n\nO : Summary of Current Information Related to Electromagnetic Field Impacts on Fish and LEEDCo Proposed Transmission Cable\n\nP : LimnoTech Boat Survey\n\nQ : Characterization of Lake Erie Ice\n\nR : Navigational Risk Assessment\n\nS : Gray \u0026amp; Pape Cultural Resources Report\n\nT-1 : Section 106 Geophysical Survey Review\n\nT-2 : Addendum to Section 106 Geophysical Survey Review\n\nU : Visual Impact Assessment\n\nV-1 : Cultural Resources Effects Analysis\n\nV-2 : OHPO and ACHP Correspondence\n\nW : Socioeconomic Report from EDR, January 2017\n\nX : Fisheries and Aquatic Resources and Avian and Bat Memoranda of Understanding","author":["Parker, R.","Kerwin, K.","Kozlowski, D.","Wheatley, K."],"organization":["US Department of Energy (DOE)","US Army Corps of Engineers","US Coast Guard","CH2M Hill","Lake Erie Energy Development Corporation (LEEDCo)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.538306000000","-81.729425000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-29 11:04:55","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA_2045_LEEDCo_FinalEA_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1661","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-construction-bat-bird-fatality-study-blue-sky-green-field-wind-energy-center-fond","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fwspubs.org\/doi\/suppl\/10.3996\/032012-JFWM-024\/suppl_file\/10.3996_032012-jfwm-024.s4.pdf","title":"Post-Construction Bat and Bird Fatality Study at the Blue Sky Green Field Wind Energy Center, Fond du Lac County, Wisconsin: July 21, 2008 \u2013 October 31, 2008 and March 15, 2009 \u2013 June 4, 2009","description":"The Blue Sky Green Field Wind Energy Center began commercial operation in May of 2008. The\u00a0wind farm is located in the townships of Calumet and Marshfield in Fond du Lac County, Wisconsin.\u00a0The wind farm consists of 88 Vestas V-80 wind turbines that rise to approximately 121 meters (397\u00a0feet) at the highest point at the top of a turbine blade. Each wind turbine is capable of generating 1.65\u00a0MW of electricity, and the wind farm as a whole is capable of generating 145 MW of electricity, or\u00a0enough to provide power to 36,000 average residences. Here, we report results of fatality studies at\u00a0Blue Sky Green Field that were conducted during the summer and fall of 2008 and spring of 2009.\u00a0\n\nFrom July 21 to October 31, 2008, and again from March 17 to June 4, 2009, we conducted studies\u00a0designed to estimate the number of bird and bat fatalities attributable to wind turbine operation.\u00a0These dates correspond with the fall and spring migration periods for birds and bats. These studies\u00a0included systematic searches at a random sample of 30 turbines at daily and weekly intervals. We\u00a0also conducted trials designed to estimate potential sources of bias, including searcher efficiency and\u00a0scavenger removal rates. We used a statistical estimator designed to accurately estimate total\u00a0fatalities. The estimator started with the total number of fatalities found during searches and added\u00a0amounts associated with the bias rates, search interval and proportion of area searched. We generated\u00a0estimates of fatalities for all birds and all bats, as well as separate estimates for migratory and nonmigratory\u00a0bat species.\n\nFor the entire study, we estimated 11.83 bird fatalities\/turbine\/year (9.08, 16.43; 90% C.I.) and 7.17\u00a0bird fatalities\/MW\/year (5.50, 9.94; 90% C.I.). We estimated 40.54 bat fatalities\/turbine (30.98, 51.16;\u00a090% C.I.) and 24.57 bat fatalities\/MW (18.78, 31.03; 90% C.I.). This estimate includes 27 fatalities\u00a0(12.2% of the total number used to generate fatality estimates) found on search plots outside of the\u00a0scheduled searches and increased the overall estimate by at least 12% relative to excluding them. If\u00a0the incidental finds are removed, the estimates would be 35.6 bat fatalities\/turbine\/year and 21.6 bat\u00a0fatalities\/MW\/year. Fatality studies may not consistently include incidental finds of carcasses, or may\u00a0not have any incidental fatalities to include, as the number of incidental finds likely depends heavily\u00a0on total number of people active on site, number of inspections and\/or visits to the turbine by other\u00a0(non-study related) site personnel, number of visits to search plots for other activities, etc.\u00a0\n\nDaily and weekly searches yielded estimates of 12.9 (8.81, 17.57; 90% C.I.) and 11.32 (7.72, 17.21;\u00a090% C.I.) bird fatalities per turbine, respectively. We estimated 39.97 (30.76, 50.70; 90% C.I.) and\u00a040.82 (28.16, 54.29; 90% C.I.) bats per turbine during daily and weekly, respectively. Non-migratory\u00a0bat fatalities were estimated to be 23.37 (13.51, 27.78; 90% C.I.) and 20.23 (12.17, 26.14; 90% C.I.)\u00a0per turbine for daily and weekly searches, respectively. Migratory bat fatalities were estimated to be\u00a016.60 (12.99, 21.12; 90% C.I.) and 20.59 (16.33, 32.71; 90% C.I.) per turbine based on daily and\u00a0weekly searches. The estimates for birds and bats are within the range of others from the United\u00a0States and Canada but are higher than others reported from the Midwest to date. It may also be noted\u00a0that estimates based on daily and weekly search intervals did not differ, which may be useful to\u00a0consider with other goals when designing future studies.\n\nWe investigated the relationship between the number of fresh (\u003C 1 day old) bat fatalities found during\u00a0searches and local meteorological conditions measured on-site and at a local airport. The AIC-ranked\u00a0best models indicated significant positive relationships between number of fresh fatalities and\u00a0average temperature and low visibility conditions, and negative effects of wind speed at 50 meters\u00a0and low cloud ceiling. The models also indicated a significant positive correlation between bat pass\u00a0rates measured with ground-based detectors and number of fresh fatalities.\u00a0\n\nThis study represents one of the few currently available that we are aware of to estimate bird and bat\u00a0fatalities from wind turbine operation in the Midwest and contributes to our understanding of wind\u00a0energy impacts to birds and bats. As more wind power projects are built in the region, and additional\u00a0studies become available, a clearer picture of the impacts to birds and bats will emerge.","author":["Erickson, W.","Gruver, J.","Bay, K.","Sonnenburg, M."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","WE Energies"],"originationDate":"2009-12-17","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.914096000000","-88.305494000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/West_FondDuLac_BlueSkyWind.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1662","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/regional-analysis-wind-turbine-caused-bat-mortality","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/full\/10.3161\/15081109ACC2015.17.1.015","title":"Regional Analysis of Wind Turbine-Caused Bat Mortality","description":"Wind energy has been the fastest-growing renewable energy source in the world. Studies have estimated bat fatalities at wind facilities, but direct comparisons of results is difficult and can be misleading due to numerous differences in protocols and methods used. We had a unique opportunity to compare fatality estimates from three wind facilities in southeastern Wisconsin. These three facilities are located within two neighboring counties with similar land use and land cover, used similar post-construction study methodologies, have turbine models that are close in size and nameplate capacity, and all became operational within seven months of each other. Our objectives were to analyze bat mortality data across all three wind facilities to: 1) examine species composition; and 2) investigate whether select structural, habitat, and landscape features influence mortality at a fine and broad scale. Corrected estimates of bat mortality were higher than reported in most other previous research in Midwestern agricultural lands in the United States. Similarities within the data were shared by all three wind facilities, but differences across them included species composition of bat mortalities and raw and corrected number of bat carcasses recovered. Our analysis suggested that select habitat and landscape features were among the predictor variables that explained bat mortality at the broad scale. Given heterogeneity in mortality estimates within the upper Midwest region, we recommend that individual wind facilities conduct project-specific pre- and postconstruction monitoring rather than infer mortality effects based on published results from other wind facilities.","author":["Liu, J.","Jennelle, C.","Drake, D.","Grodsky, S.","Schumacher, S.","Sponsler, M."],"organization":["University of Wisconsin","Minnesota Department of Natural Resources","Academia Sinica","North Carolina State University","WE Energies","TRC"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.715811000000","-88.144529000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1663","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/regional-analysis-wind-turbine-caused-bat-bird-fatality-final-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.focusonenergy.com\/sites\/default\/files\/2018-05\/1007Drake_FinalReportx.pdf","title":"Regional Analysis of Wind Turbine-caused Bat and Bird Fatality: Final Report","description":"Wind energy has been the fastest-growing renewable energy source for electricity in the United\u00a0States. Many studies have estimated avian and bat fatalities at wind turbine facilities.\u00a0However, direct comparisons of the results of these studies is difficult and can be misleading\u00a0due to the numerous differences in the study protocols and the methods used to develop a final\u00a0estimate of fatality. We had a unique opportunity to compare the fatality estimates from 3 wind\u00a0energy facilities (Blue Sky Green Field Wind Energy Center (BSGF), Cedar Ridge Wind Farm\u00a0(CR), and Forward Energy Wind Center (FE) in southeastern Wisconsin. These 3 energy\u00a0developments are contained within 2 neighboring counties (Dodge and Fond du Lac) in similar\u00a0land use and land cover, used similar post-construction study methodologies, have turbine\u00a0models that are close in size and nameplate capacity, and all became operational within 7\u00a0months of each other. Analysis of these facilities as a group provides a detailed picture of\u00a0regional fatalities. Therefore, our objectives were to combine bird and bat mortality across all\u00a03 wind energy facilities:\n1) To examine bird and bat species composition relative to mortality\n2) To examine temporal and spatial patterns of bird and bat mortality;\n3) To investigate whether select habitat, structural, and landscape features may influence\u00a0mortality.\n\nBird mortality was low and within the norms observed by other studies; however, bat mortality\u00a0was higher than most other previous research in Midwestern agricultural lands. Similarities\u00a0within the data were shared by all 3 wind projects, including greater overall bat mortality at\u00a0each wind facility relative to bird mortality, temporal and spatial patterns for bird and bat\u00a0mortality, and avian species composition. Data differences across the 3 wind facilities included\u00a0species composition of the bat mortalities and raw and corrected number of bat carcasses\u00a0recovered. Our landscape analysis suggested that the fall season was the predictor variable that\u00a0best explained bat mortality.\u00a0\n\nWe recommend that pre- and post-construction bat monitoring occur at individual wind\u00a0facilities rather than relying on published results from other wind facilities and assumptions that\u00a0wind facilities in close geographic proximity will have similar mortality rates and species\u00a0composition of mortalities. We also suggest further research be conducted to better understand\u00a0and be able to predict bat mortalities, especially during peak mortality times in the fall, thereby\u00a0refining curtailment as a cost-effective mitigation technique when necessary.","author":["Drake, D.","Schumacher, S.","Sponsler, M."],"organization":["University of Wisconsin","WE Energies","BHE Environmental Inc","Focus on Energy"],"originationDate":"2012-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.541713000000","-89.705869000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wisc_Drake_FinalReport_2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1664","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-construction-bird-bat-mortality-study-cedar-ridge-wind-farm-fond-du-lac-county","sourceURL":"https:\/\/apps.psc.wi.gov\/ERF\/ERFview\/viewdoc.aspx?docid=146174","title":"Post-Construction Bird and Bat Mortality Study: Cedar Ridge Wind Farm, Fond Du Lac County, Wisconsin","description":"BHE Environmental, Inc. was contracted by Wisconsin Power and Light Company (WPL) to conduct two years of post-construction bird and bat mortality surveys at its Cedar Ridge Wind Farm in Fond du Lac County, Wisconsin. Twenty of the 41 turbines were selected to be surveyed from March 15 to May 31, 2009, July 15 to November 15, 2009, March 15 to May 31, 2010, and July 15 to October 15, 2010. This report summarizes data collected during the 2009 and 2010 survey periods.","author":["BHE Environmental Inc"],"organization":["BHE Environmental Inc","Wisconsin Power and Light Company"],"originationDate":"2011-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.692100000000","-88.329198000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/FonDuLacs_Wind_BatBirdMort.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1665","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nepa-review-offshore-wind-farms-ensuring-emission-reduction-benefits-outweigh-visual","sourceURL":"https:\/\/lawdigitalcommons.bc.edu\/ealr\/vol31\/iss2\/7\/","title":"NEPA Review of Offshore Wind Farms: Ensuring Emission Reduction Benefits Outweigh Visual Impacts","description":"Wind power may greatly reduce overall emissions of air pollutants from fossil fuel plants. Benefits could range from fewer premature deaths to reduced global warming, and cover the gamut of goals that the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) articulates. Previous NEPA reviews of wind projects, however, have focused on local aesthetic objections and given only cursory treatment to emission reductions. This imbalance threatens to frustrate, rather than further, NEPA\u2019s goals. Beginning with the offshore wind farm proposed near Cape Cod, Massachusetts, reviewers must accord the prominence and depth of treatment to emission offset benefits that NEPA requires. Local aesthetic preferences must not be permitted to overshadow broad regional benefits.","author":["Bisbee, D."],"organization":["Southern New England School of Law"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NEPAReview_Wind_Bisbee_2004.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1666","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/baseline-avian-studies-proposed-maiden-wind-farm-yakima-benton-counties-washington","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.yumpu.com\/en\/document\/view\/46256285\/baseline-avian-studies-for-the-proposed-maiden-wind-west-inc","title":"Baseline Avian Studies for the Proposed Maiden Wind Farm, Yakima and Benton Counties, Washington","description":"Bonneville Power Administration is evaluating whether to purchase power from a proposed wind power development in Benton and Yakima Counties, Washington. The proposed Maiden Wind Farm is located in the Rattlesnake Hills northeast of the town of Sunnyside, Washington. The proposed development could be up to 494 MW with as many as 549 turbines and four met towers depending on factors such as turbine model selected and power purchase agreements.  Studies conducted for the project include fixed-point surveys which targeted raptors and large birds, paired-plots surveys which targeted breeding passerines in the study area, raptor nest surveys, vegetation\/habitat mapping, and general wildlife observations. The principal goals of the baseline studies were to: (1) quantitatively describe the temporal and spatial use by birds of the study area; and (2) provide baseline information on avian species and their habitat sufficient to use in evaluating the probable impact of the development. Detailed study methodology of the surveys for each component is provided below in the text of the report.  Four basic habitat types (agriculture, steppe, riparian, and wetland) occur in the study area. The agriculture habitat type is comprised of one vegetation type, cropland, and makes up approximately 35% of the study area (6419 acres). The steppe habitat is comprised of four types, grassland steppe, shrub steppe, lithosol, and rock outcrop shrub. The steppe habitats combined make up approximately 64% of the study area (8527 acres). Riparian habitat was found in draws below springs and along Sulphur Creek. Riparian habitat comprised 1% of the study area (135 acres). The wetland vegetation type was a minor component of the study area and comprised \u0026lt;0.1% (3 acres) and is confined to springs and a fringe along Sulphur Creek.  Several avian species of interest (bald eagle, ferruginous hawk, merlin, loggerhead shrike, sage thrasher, and sage sparrow) were observed on or near the site outside of scheduled surveys when observers were traveling to or between points. Six species of mammals (coyote, mule deer, elk, porcupine, Townsend\u2019s ground squirrel, and unidentified jackrabbit) and three species of reptiles (rattlesnake, short-horned lizard and yellow-bellied racer) were recorded in the study area during the studies. No federally listed threatened or endangered species were observed in the study area.","author":["Erickson, W.","Bay, K.","Young, D.","Kronner, K.","Good, R."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Northwest Wildlife Consultants Inc","Bonneville Power Administration"],"originationDate":"2002-11-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.517388000000","-120.307381000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Maiden_Avian_report_2002.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1667","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/how-ecofriendly-are-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/bioscience\/article\/58\/7\/576\/236879","title":"How Ecofriendly are Wind Farms?","description":"Paul Cryan was surprised and curious. Cryan had been studying bats since 1990, but only in 2003 did he learn that bats were being killed at wind energy farms. Cryan wanted to know why the bats, whose visual and echolocation abilities allow them to find and catch flying insects at night and avoid obstacles in the dark, run into or otherwise are killed by rotating turbine blades. Why would bats be around wind turbines in the first place? And which species were most at risk?\n\nNot just bats but also birds are killed at wind farms, which have been touted as more environmentally friendly energy sources than coal, oil, and gas. After all, wind turbines produce no air, water, or thermal pollutants, and emit no greenhouse gases. \u201cIf we don\u0027t do wind, we\u0027ll wind up doing coal,\u201d warns Robert Thresher, director of the National Wind Technology Center at the US Department of Energy\u0027s National Renewable Energy Laboratory in Golden, Colorado. Wind farms may fragment the environment, however, and make it unusable for some birds.","author":["Cohn, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2008-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1668","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fisheries-environment-offshore-wind-farms-location-location-location","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/313196689_Fisheries_the_environment_and_offshore_wind_farms_location_location_location","title":"Fisheries, the environment and offshore wind farms: location, location, location","description":"The common view is that access to the sea is homogenously distributed and all fishers can and do work anywhere and everywhere. The stakes for the environment and fishing industry are likely to be higher as the ecological and spatial footprint of wind farms is so much larger. The key issues for all concerned with wind farms, which were less significant with the oil and gas industry, are location and access, and it is these that require real stakeholder involvement and proactive decision-making which takes effective account of the sensitivities and needs of fishing communities.","author":["Johnson, M.","Rodmell, D."],"organization":["University of Hull","The National Federation of Fishermen\u0027s Organisations (NFFO)"],"originationDate":"2009-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1669","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-attitudes-environmental-impacts-wind-farms-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journal.gnest.org\/publication\/932","title":"Public Attitudes and Environmental Impacts of Wind Farms: A Review","description":"The promotion of renewable sources for electricity production, independent of carbon fuels and nuclear power, is a priority in the energy policy of many countries all over the world. The European Union has launched an ambitious program to increase the contribution of energy production from wind turbines; the aim set for the year 2020 is that wind power should account for 31% of EU\u2019s current target regarding 20% reductions of carbon dioxide. This policy is favored by the fact that wind energy production cost is nowadays competitive in many cases to the cost of electricity produced from conventional non-renewable sources. However, there is a conflict concerning public attitudes: although the public in general is in favor of renewable energy sources including wind, there is usually very strong opposition by local people living in neighboring areas of wind farm developments that is attitudes toward wind power are to a large extent different from attitudes toward wind farms. It is also interesting that negative public opinion is rather high during the planning stage and significantly lower during the implementation stage. In addition, there are impacts on landscape aesthetic, human health as well as ecological impact on the flora and fauna, although compared to environmental impact from conventional energy sources, the environmental impact caused by wind turbines is relatively minor. Recent developments of offshore wind farms seemed to avoid people\u2019s negative attitudes and soften public resistance and hostility against wind power energy but these expectations were rather optimistic. Opposition due to seascape aesthetic spoiling is as strong even for the marine environment. The impact on marine life and particularly on sea mammals due to noise and vibrations need to be further investigated. Existing activities such as navigation, fishing and recreational activities should not be hindered during site selection and planning. In the present work public attitudes and impacts on human health as well as impacts on landscape and ecosystem level, both terrestrial and marine, are reviewed and discussed.","author":["Karydis, M."],"organization":["University of the Aegean"],"originationDate":"2013-02-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1670","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/minnesota-department-natural-resources-guidance-commercial-wind-energy-projects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/files.dnr.state.mn.us\/publications\/ewr\/dnr_wind_energy_project_guidance.pdf","title":"Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Guidance for Commercial Wind Energy Projects","description":"Commercial scale wind farms provide important renewable energy sources for our state and have a positive impact on Minnesota\u2019s economy. Wind energy conversion systems do not pose the same kind of environmental challenges that other sources do, prompting less concern about air and water pollution and the release of greenhouse gases. However, the turbines, access roads, transmission lines, and substations do have the potential to impact natural, recreational, and cultural resources. This guide outlines the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (DNR) role in the wind project review process and explains issues to be considered during project development. The DNR must balance its threefold mission of facilitating the state\u2019s economic development, providing Minnesotans with high-quality outdoor recreation, and protecting and enhancing valued habitat for future generations.\n\nThe DNR has jurisdiction over wildlife in the state of Minnesota according to Minnesota Statutes, section 84.027, subdivision 2 and administers the Minnesota Outdoor Recreation System (Minnesota Statutes, chapter 86A). The Minnesota Outdoor Recreation System managed by the DNR includes: Wildlife Management Areas, Scientific and Natural Areas, State Parks, State Forests, State Recreation Areas, and other DNR managed lands. The DNR reviews and comments on proposed wind farms to meet statutory obligations that have been developed to ensure natural, recreational, and cultural resources are protected for the enjoyment of all Minnesota residents and our visitors.\n\nThe Minnesota Department of Natural Resources Guidance for Commercial Wind Energy Projects applies to Large Wind Energy Conversion Systems (LWECS) (projects \u003E 5 megawatts) or any turbine that has a height greater than or equal to 200 feet to the top of blade. The document includes discussion of both DNR regulated (by Minnesota Statute or DNR issued permits) resources and resources managed, but not regulated by, the DNR. Pertinent statutes and permits are included within the text to clarify resources that are regulated by the DNR. The DNR participates in several review activities associated with LWECS. The DNR provides prospective project developers with information and guidance during early coordination that can help them site and develop a potential project.\n\nThe DNR also manages lands that it owns, and has regulatory responsibilities over species designated as threatened or endangered, public waters, and utility crossings. DNR recommendations, not specifically tied to Minnesota Statute or DNR issued permits, are provided to the Energy Environmental Review and Analysis (EERA) unit of the Department of Commerce and to the Public Utilities Commission (PUC) during the environmental review and site permitting phase. The EERA provides staffing for wind energy permitting and conducts permitting and environmental review activities on behalf of the PUC. At their discretion, the EERA\/PUC may include the recommendations as permit conditions. The PUC issues the site permit for LWECS, except for those delegated to a county. The DNR also encourages implementation of DNR recommendations by other applicable regulators, such as counties.\n\nWind projects pose a unique set of potential impacts to natural resources due to their height, spinning blades, and widespread turbine layouts over large project areas. Turbines, transmission lines, access roads, and substations have been shown to reduce available habitat, kill birds and bats, cause some species to avoid habitat near turbines, and disrupt animal behavior. Recreational activities may be degraded due to the change in viewshed, noise, increased vehicle traffic, and safety concerns for trail users.\n\nThe mission of the DNR is to work with citizens to conserve and manage the state\u2019s natural resources, to provide outdoor recreation opportunities, and to provide for commercial uses of natural resources in a way that creates a sustainable quality of life. The DNR goal relative to wind energy development is to support responsible development of the state\u2019s wind resource while ensuring that Minnesota\u2019s natural, scenic and cultural resources are protected. The DNR provides technical assistance during the early planning stages of 4 project development and during the EERA and PUC energy facility environmental review and site permitting process. Detailed information about the siting and permitting process for wind projects can be accessed from the Wind Turbines tab on the Department of Commerce website. The DNR also provides technical assistance to other applicable regulators and reviewers, such as county, city, or federal environmental reviewers.\n\nDNR technical assistance helps to ensure natural resource impacts are considered during the planning, environmental review and permitting, construction, and post-construction phases of the project. The DNR will provide recommendations and consultations during the pre-application period to proactively and collaboratively identify potential issues prior to company submittal of a site application to the PUC. DNR recommendations are designed to identify high value natural resources, help proposers avoid, minimize, and propose mitigation for impacts to those resources, and to recommend wildlife surveys to quantify potential impacts of specific projects. The DNR will work with the project developer and other appropriate agencies to address natural resource issues prior to submission of the site application to the PUC or a county. Agency recommendations (e.g., resolution of rare feature concerns, avoidance areas, and pre- or post-construction wildlife studies) can then be considered during the PUC site application process.","author":["Minnesota Department of Natural Resources"],"organization":["Minnesota Department of Natural Resources"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MN_DNR_wind_energy_project_guidance.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1671","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impact-statement-hermanvilleclearspring-30-mw-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.pe.ca\/photos\/original\/elj_eiawindfb13.pdf","title":"Environmental Impact Statement Hermanville\/Clearspring - 30 MW Wind Farm","description":"Prince Edward Island Energy Corporation (\u201cPEIEC\u201d) proposes to develop and operate a 30 megawatt (MW) wind farm. The Hermanville\/Clearspring 30 MW Wind Farm, hereafter referred to as the \u201cProject\u201d, would be located between Clearspring and Hermanville, near the northeastern tip of the province of Prince Edward Island (PEI). The Study Area consists of approximately 4.5 kilometres (km) along Northside Road (Route 16) between New Zealand Road and Souris Line Road; 3 km along New Zealand Road from Northside Road, 2 km along Souris Line Road from Northside Road and 4.4 km along the southern boundary. The Study Area has been used in the past and currently for forestry purposes. The main stem of the proposed transmission line will be located along the eastern boundary of Souris Line Road between Northside Road and Grant Road.  The Study Area has minimal residential development around its perimeter and can meet the Provincial requirements of a setback four (4) times the height of the turbine from any residential development. Along Souris Line Road, the proposed transmission line will run adjacent to six (6) residential properties. Approximately 20 km east of the Project is the East Point Wind Farm which currently operates ten (10) wind turbines and was also developed by PEIEC.  The proposed Project implementation will begin Spring 2013, with operations to begin in late fall 2013. The Project will consist of erecting ten (10) wind turbines, each capable of producing 3 MW for a total nameplate production of 30 MW; a meteorological mast; a buried and\/or overhead electrical collector system; single phase power line for the substation, substation; service building, 138 kilovolt (kV) transmission line between the substation and existing T-12 transmission line; as well as access roads to each turbine, substation and service building. Key environmental features identified within the Study Area are watercourses, wetlands, avian fauna (birds and bats) as well as identified floral Species-at-Risk. The operational life of this Project\u2019s assets is expected to be twenty-five (25) years, at which time the assets will have to be replaced or decommissioned.  The goal of the Project is to allow PEIEC to fulfil its directive to develop another 30 MW of wind power for domestic consumption by 2013 as stated in the PEI Energy Accord. Direct, measurable benefits of the Project to the Province and Canada will include:  \u2022 reduced emissions, thereby contributing to Canada\u2019s objective of reducing national total greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 17% from 2005 levels by the year 2020; \u2022 enabling the Province to generate approximately 30% of its electricity from renewable power; \u2022 lowered dependence on imports of electricity to the Province; \u2022 more stabilized electricity costs within the Province; and \u2022 economic development benefits to the local area.  This report addresses the environmental effects of the construction, operation and decommissioning project phases. The information reviewed and field studies have shown that no significant adverse residual impacts on the valued environmental components (VECs) are likely. The generation of electricity from renewable resources such as wind is in accordance with federal and provincial strategies, since it contributes to the reduction of GHG emissions and air pollutants. The Hermanville\/Clearspring 30 MW Wind Farm, once approved, would contribute to the reduction of GHG emissions required to meet Canada\u2019s and the Province of PEI\u2019s targets.","author":["AMEC Environment \u0026 Infrastructure"],"organization":["AMEC Environment \u0026 Infrastructure","Prince Edward Island Energy Corporation"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.454166700000","-62.304166700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Clearspring-EIS-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1672","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-terrestrial-animals-avoid-areas-close-turbines-functioning-wind-farms-agricultural","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007%2Fs10661-017-6018-z","title":"Do Terrestrial Animals Avoid Areas Close to Turbines in Functioning Wind Farms in Agricultural Landscapes?","description":"Most studies on the effects of wind energy on animals have focused on avian and bat activity, habitat use, and mortality, whereas very few have been published on terrestrial, non-volant wildlife. In this paper, we studied the utilization of functioning wind farm areas by four terrestrial animals common to agricultural landscapes: European roe deer, European hare, red fox, and the common pheasant. Firstly, we expected that the studied animals do not avoid areas close to turbines and utilize the whole area of functioning wind farms with a frequency similar to the control areas. Secondly, we expected that there is no relation between the turbine proximity and the number of tracks of these animals. The study was conducted over two winter seasons using the snow-tracking method along 100 m linear transects. In total, 583 transects were recorded. Wind farm operations may affect terrestrial animals both in wind farm interiors and in a 700-m buffer zone around the edge of turbines. The reactions of animals were species specific. Herbivorous mammals (roe deer and European hare) avoided wind farm interiors and proximity to turbines. The common pheasant showed a positive reaction to wind turbine proximity. The red fox had the most neutral response to wind turbines. Although this species visited wind farm interiors less often than the control area, there was no relation between fox track density and turbine proximity. Greater weight should be given to the effects of wind farms on non-flying wildlife than at present. Investors and regulatory authorities should always consider the likely impacts of wind farms during environmental impact assessments and try to reduce these negative effects.","author":["Klich, D.","\u0141opucki, R.","Gielarek, S."],"organization":["John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin","Warsaw University of Life Sciences (SGGW)"],"originationDate":"2017-06-19","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Terrestrial Mammals","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1673","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-environmental-impact-statement-na-pua-makani-wind-project-habitat-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dlnr.hawaii.gov\/?s=na+pua+wind+HEPA\u0026type=usa","title":"Final Environmental Impact Statement Na Pua Makani Wind Project and Habitat Conservation Plan","description":"This Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the Na Pua Makani Wind Project (Project) has been prepared pursuant to Hawaii Environmental Policy Act (HEPA) (Chapter 343 of the Hawaii Revised Statutes [HRS]). The Project would be partially located on State of Hawaii lands, triggering environmental review under HEPA. Therefore, the Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resources (DLNR) serve as the lead agencies for this EIS. A portion of the proposed Project\u2019s transmission line would occur within the State of Hawaii Department of Transportation right-ofway, which is also a trigger for environmental review under HEPA and is addressed through this EIS. The purpose of this document is to inform the public and the permitting agencies about the potential adverse and beneficial environmental impacts of the construction and operation of the proposed Project (the Proposed Action), and to recommend mitigation measures that will avoid or reduce significant adverse impacts to the maximum extent possible.  The purpose of the proposed Project is to provide clean, renewable wind energy for the island of Oahu. The proposed Project would provide economic benefits by contributing to the local economy, generating new jobs, and providing a stable, long-term source of tax revenue for the state and county. The power generated by the wind farm would be sold to the Hawaiian Electric Company (HECO) under a long-term, fixed base price contract with fixed annual escalation providing longterm price stability for consumers. The energy delivered by the proposed Project would help HECO meet its Renewable Portfolio Standard (RPS), established in HRS \u00a7 269-92, and the State of Hawai\u2019i goal of increasing energy independence through the development of additional sources of renewable energy. To accomplish this purpose, NPMPP proposes to construct and operate a new wind farm on state and private lands near the town of Kahuku, adjacent to the existing Kahuku Wind Farm with a net generating capacity of up to approximately 25 megawatts (MW).  The original Draft EIS considered a Proposed Action of up to 10 wind turbines. In response to public comments on the original Draft EIS, a Modified Proposed Action Option (consisting of only nine turbines with larger generating capacities and dimensions) was added to the Second Draft EIS analysis. The Project would also include an underground electrical collection system, an onsite substation, an operations and maintenance (O\u0026amp;M) facility and related infrastructure, access roads, an approximately 0.8-mile (1.2 kilometer) 34.5-kilovolt HECO-owned transmission line, and a permanent meteorological tower. Because the proposed Project could potentially impact species listed under the Federal ESA, NPMPP is preparing a joint Federal and State Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) to accompany its application for an Incidental Take Permit (ITP) from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), and an Incidental Take License (ITL) from the Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resources (DLNR) Division of Forestry and Wildlife (DOFAW) under Hawaii Revised Statute (HRS) Section 195D.  The EIS addresses alternatives to the Proposed Action (and Modified Proposed Action Option), including the No Action Alternative and a larger generation facility of up to approximately 42 MW (Alternative 3). Under the No Action Alternative, the Project would not be constructed. Under the No Action Alternative, Project objectives listed in Chapter 1 would not be met. However, this Na Pua Makani Wind Project ES-1 FINAL ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT STATEMENT alternative establishes a baseline against which the action alternatives can be compared. Alternative 3 (larger generation facility) would involve the construction and operation of up to 12 turbines and associated infrastructure, constructed in two phases. Alternatives that were eliminated from further consideration include smaller (less than 25 MW) and larger (more than 42 MW) facilities, alternative locations on Oahu, and other alternative renewable energy sources. These preliminary alternatives were subsequently dismissed if it was determined they did not meet the Project\u2019s Purpose and Need or the Project\u2019s objectives, described in Chapter 1 of this EIS.  The original Draft EIS was prepared and published as a joint state\/federal document meeting HEPA and National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) requirements. Due to differences in procedural requirements, the HEPA and NEPA processes have diverged and will continue along separate paths, with this EIS fulfilling requirements under HEPA. The NEPA Final EIS has been published under separate cover. Where information supports the analysis or provides additional context, reference to the NEPA process has been retained.","author":["Tetra Tech Inc.","Case, S."],"organization":["Tetra Tech Inc.","Hawaii Department of Land and Natural Resource"],"originationDate":"2016-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Na-Pua-Wind_EIS_2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1674","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/upper-great-plains-wind-energy-final-programmatic-environmental-impact-statement","sourceURL":"","title":"Upper Great Plains Wind Energy Final Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement: Volume 2","description":"Western Area Power Administration (Western) and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) have jointly prepared this programmatic environmental impact statement (PEIS) to identify environmental impacts associated with various environmental review processes that could be implemented to evaluate requests for interconnection of wind energy projects to Western\u2019s transmission system or requests for land exchanges to accommodate wind energy elements that may affect wetland or grassland conservation easements managed by the USFWS in Western\u2019s Upper Great Plains Customer Service Region. The PEIS assesses environmental impacts associated with wind energy development and identifies management practices to address impacts. The processes and management practices identified in the PEIS are intended to expedite site-specific National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) evaluations by providing a framework document from which other NEPA documents could tier. The PEIS provides information that will help developers know what will be expected when they apply for an interconnection or land exchange and will assist them with identifying and avoiding environmentally sensitive areas where permitting would be more difficult. Decisions regarding implementation of a programmatic process for environmental evaluations of requests for interconnection of wind energy projects to Western\u2019s transmission facilities or for land exchanges to accommodate wind energy that may affect easements managed by the USFWS will be issued following the final PEIS as Records of Decision for each agency.","author":["US Department of Energy (DOE)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","Western Area Power Administration (WAPA)"],"organization":["Western Area Power Administration (WAPA)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Department of Energy (DOE)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/UpperGreatPlains_Vol2_EIS_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1675","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/upper-great-plains-wind-energy-final-programmatic-environmental-impact-statement-0","sourceURL":"","title":"Upper Great Plains Wind Energy Final Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement: Volume 1","description":"Western Area Power Administration (Western) and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) have jointly prepared this programmatic environmental impact statement (PEIS) to identify environmental impacts associated with various environmental review processes that could be implemented to evaluate requests for interconnection of wind energy projects to Western\u2019s transmission system or requests for land exchanges to accommodate wind energy elements that may affect wetland or grassland conservation easements managed by the USFWS in Western\u2019s Upper Great Plains Customer Service Region. The PEIS assesses environmental impacts associated with wind energy development and identifies management practices to address impacts. The processes and management practices identified in the PEIS are intended to expedite site-specific National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (NEPA) evaluations by providing a framework document from which other NEPA documents could tier. The PEIS provides information that will help developers know what will be expected when they apply for an interconnection or land exchange and will assist them with identifying and avoiding environmentally sensitive areas where permitting would be more difficult. Decisions regarding implementation of a programmatic process for environmental evaluations of requests for interconnection of wind energy projects to Western\u2019s transmission facilities or for land exchanges to accommodate wind energy that may affect easements managed by the USFWS will be issued following the final PEIS as Records of Decision for each agency.","author":["US Department of Energy (DOE)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","Western Area Power Administration (WAPA)"],"organization":["Western Area Power Administration (WAPA)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Department of Energy (DOE)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/UpperGreatPlains_EIS_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1676","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/onshore-offshore-wind-energy-introduction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wiley.com\/en-us\/Onshore+and+Offshore+Wind+Energy%3A+An+Introduction-p-9780470976081","title":"Onshore and Offshore Wind Energy: An Introduction","description":"A highly accessible and authoritative account of wind energy\u2019s scientific background, current technology, and international status, with an emphasis on large turbines and wind farms, both onshore and offshore.\u00a0Topics covered include:\na brief history of wind energy\nthe nature of the wind\nturbine aerodynamics, mechanics, and electrics\nwind farms\noffshore opportunities and challenges\ngrid integration of wind energy\neconomic and environmental aspects\nWhilst intellectually rigorous, this is not an academic treatise. Key equations are fully discussed, providing essential theoretical background. The text is supported by copious illustrations and about 50 inspiring full-colour photographs from around the world.\n\nThis book is aimed at a wide readership including professionals, policy makers and employees in the energy sector in need of a basic appreciation of the underlying principles of wind energy or a quick update. Its style and level will also appeal to second and third year undergraduate and postgraduate students of renewable and wind energy, energy systems and electrical\/electronic engineering. It also gives a concise account of the technology for the large and growing number of people who are interested in onshore and offshore wind farms and the contribution they are making to carbon-free electricity generation in the 21st\u00a0century.\n\nTable of Contents:\nIntroduction\nWind energy and Planet Earth\nWinds of the world\nFrom windmills to wind turbines\nPower, energy and performance\nComing up to date\n\nCapturing the wind\nWind speed and power\nWild wind\nIntroductory\nWind statistics\nMapping and forecasting\n\nPredicting turbine output\n\nWind turbines\nTurbine types and sizes\nAerodynamics\nRotor efficiency and the Betz limit\nLift and drag\nRotor speed\nRotor blades\nChoosing airfoils\nStall and pitch control\n\n\nMechanics\nGearboxes\nTowers\nVibration and fatigue\n\nElectrics\nAC electricity\nGenerators\nIntroductory\nSynchronous generators\nAsynchronous generators\nSquirrel-cage and wound-rotor induction machines\nDoubly-fed induction generators\n\n\n\nTurbine control\nOnshore wind farms\nIntroductory\nSiting and spacing\nMonitoring and control\n\n\nMoving offshore\nIntroductory\nWind and waves\nTurbines and foundations\nOffshore wind farms\nBringing the power ashore\n\nGrid integration\nSetting the scene\nConnecting to the grid\nGrid strength and fault levels\nElectrical quality\n\nLarge-scale wind power\nIntroductory\nIntermittency and variability\nCapacity credit and backup generation\n\n\nEconomics and the environment\nWind energy economics\nCapital and installation costs\nOperation, maintenance and cash flow\n\nEnvironmental aspects\nIntroductory\nLandscape and amenity\nBirds, bats and farming\nSeabirds, fish and marine conservation","author":["Lynn, P."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1677","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/global-wind-energy-policy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch22","title":"Global Wind Energy Policy and Development","description":"This chapter explores worldwide policies and development of wind energy over the next several decades. It first examines the global thrust to develop renewable energy sources. The chapter also examines how and why wind energy is a major component of these renewable energy development initiatives by considering how the technology, national policies, and public opinion contribute to meet growing worldwide electric demand. Global wind statistics for 2012 compiled by the Global Wind Energy Council show that Europe, Asia, and North America have far more installed wind power capacity than other regions of the world. The chapter discusses policies driving wind energy development in these regions, and presents additional information for an important nation or state in the region, to include electric consumption data, population, quality of life (QOL) data, wind energy growth rates, and policies in place that support the development of wind energy and renewable power.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1678","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-economics-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch20","title":"Environmental Impacts and Economics of Offshore Wind Energy","description":"This chapter talks about offshore wind farms, what they are, and how they could impact the development of wind energy both in the United States and worldwide. The first variable in determining the economics of both offshore and onshore wind is to estimate the annual energy production from the wind power plant. In some respects, wind resource measurement and turbine output estimation is simpler offshore because of the uniform topography over the sea surface. Integration of offshore wind farms may be easier than onshore wind farms, especially in the United States, depending on how the timing of the output of the turbine coincides with peak load requirements of the regional utility. There are a number of environmental impacts that have to be considered for offshore wind turbine installations. Due to their coastal location, offshore wind farms are exposed to the risk of hurricanes.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1679","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/economic-impacts-benefits-wind-energy-projects-other-sources-electric-generation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch19","title":"Economic Impacts and Benefits of Wind Energy Projects and Other Sources of Electric Generation","description":"This chapter focuses on the economic impacts of wind energy projects. An announcement of a new electric generation project in or near a community is likely to draw opposition from people who perceive that the project will be harmful to the community, whether the project will be using wind power, solar energy, nuclear energy, natural gas, biomass, landfill gas, or coal to produce electricity. The chapter provides the impacts potentially detrimental to the region\u0027s economy. Some of the economic impacts that developers of any type of electric generation project must consider or address during the project design phase includes: environmental impacts that may translate to reduced property values, impacts on the local job market, and impacts on local roads, utilities, and emergency services. Reasons often cited for granting tax abatements to businesses may include creation of new jobs in the area and providing access to services for residents.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1680","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-energy-electric-grid","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch12","title":"Impact of Wind Energy on the Electric Grid","description":"The most important characteristics of wind turbines and wind plants that will impact their ability to be effectively integrated into the electrical grid on a large scale without significantly affecting the grid\u0027s reliability are power quality, low\u2010voltage ride\u2010through, reactive power control, communication with grid operators and wind forecasting. The wind integration studies point to the need for accurate forecasts of wind generation as a means to minimize the costs of wind integration and to mitigate the potential for wind generation to reduce the reliability and stability of the electric grid. Addition of one or more large wind plants in a region does create new challenges for grid operators and can result in additional costs to regional balancing authorities. Keys to ensuring successful integration of large\u2010scale wind generation include use of wind forecasting and continued dialogue between electric utilities, grid operators, turbine vendors, and wind plant owners\/operators.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1681","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energys-impact-aviation-radar-telecommunications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch10","title":"Wind Energy\u0027s Impact on Aviation, Radar, and Telecommunications","description":"Wind energy development can affect aviation in a number of ways. The federal aviation administration (FAA) requires that persons or entities wishing to build structures of certain heights and\/or proximity to military or civilian airports or heliports provide public notice of the construction by filing FAA Form 7460\u20101. Marking and\/or lighting of wind turbine structures are intended to provide day and night conspicuity and to assist pilots in identifying and avoiding these obstacles. In addition to impacting aviation radar systems, wind turbines may also have an effect on weather radar systems. Microwave telecommunication systems are wireless point\u2010to\u2010point (or line\u2010of\u2010sight) links that communicate between two sites (antennas) and require clear line\u2010of\u2010sight conditions between each antenna. Wind developers need to perform a Licensed Microwave Search and Worst Case Fresnel Zone Analysis to identify microwave paths within a project area.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Navigation","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1682","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/other-environmental-issues-wind-energy-development-aesthetics-cultural-resources-land","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch11","title":"Other Environmental Issues of Wind Energy Development: Aesthetics, Cultural Resources, Land Use Compatibility, Water Resources, and Site Restoration","description":"Landscape architects may be interested in the use of turbines for landscaping, with small vertical\u2010axis turbines in particular being designed for use on buildings or in homeowners\u0027 backyards. Some of the ways that developers of wind energy projects can reduce the likelihood of controversy and opposition to the project based on aesthetic concerns is by avoiding siting projects near well\u2010known scenic or cultural resources. Desktop and in\u2010the\u2010field archeological surveys should be performed by qualified experts for all areas within the proposed wind project where construction activities may disturb the land including turbine locations. The needs or uses for water by wind energy projects is very small compared with traditional sources of electric generation. The current developers of wind projects have the financial backing and mechanisms to ensure that wind project facilities will be removed following the end of a project\u0027s life.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1683","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-ecological-impacts-wind-energy-humans-public-workforce-safety-issues","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch9","title":"Environmental and Ecological Impacts of Wind Energy on Humans: Public and Workforce Safety Issues","description":"Developers, construction contractors, owners, and operators of wind plants need to be aware of the issues and situations that can jeopardize the safety of their employees and the general public. The use of some predetermined setback distances from homes, occupied buildings, and public roads is the primary means of mitigating issues with ice throw from wind turbines. Setback distances between wind turbines and occupied buildings established by wind developers to mitigate turbine noise and shadow flicker should exceed the maximum distance for blade throw. The incidence of turbine fires is small, and suspected causes of such fires include electromechanical malfunctions such as bearing failures. Precise planning of equipment delivery routes is crucial for any wind project. Identifying the location and depth of any existing underground electric lines and oil or gas pipelines is also critically important.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1684","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-ecological-impacts-wind-energy-humans-public-health-issues","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch8","title":"Environmental and Ecological Impacts of Wind Energy on Humans: Public Health Issues","description":"This chapter explains the impacts of wind energy on humans as well as how effective methods are for reducing or mitigating the extent of such impacts. Audible noise is generally considered to have frequencies between 20 and 20,000 Hz, although some show the range extending down to 16 Hz. Shadow flicker occurs when the blades of a wind turbine rotate in sunny conditions, casting moving shadows on the ground or on windows of buildings resulting in alternating changes in light intensity. Exposure to electric and magnetic fields (EMFs) is very common. Electric distribution lines that run up and down streets and alleys are a source of EMFs, as well as electric substations and the high voltage transmission lines that connect power plants to cities and towns. Proper handling of solid and hazardous wastes generated during the construction and operation of a wind energy project is very important.  This is a book chapter in Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Health \u0026 Safety","EMF","Lighting","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-12 08:20:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1685","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-wildlife-siting-issues-challenges","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch7","title":"Wind and Wildlife: Siting Issues and Challenges","description":"As wind energy development expands rapidly within the United States and many other nations, the wind energy industry must be diligent in responding to any potential environmental issues. One of the more significant issues for the industry is the impact on wildlife, and as offshore wind development becomes a reality, the issue is extended to fish as well. The issues and topics discussed in this chapter include: avian issues, bat issues, and other wildlife issues. In 2003, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) proposed a set of voluntary interim guidelines for mitigating the impacts of land\u2010based wind energy projects to wildlife. Proper project siting and understanding of wildlife and avian behavior and habitat are critical to the wind project development process. Wind developers must identify regions where it is known that wind projects could pose a substantial risk to wildlife very early in the siting process.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Fish","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1686","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/overview-issues-faced-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119040934.ch6","title":"Overview of Issues Faced by Wind Energy","description":"Wind energy is one of the cleanest and most environmentally neutral energy sources in the world today. Wind energy production can also negatively affect the wildlife habitat and individual species, and measures to mitigate prospective impacts may be required. Maintaining good relationships with the community surrounding a proposed wind energy project and providing accurate and timely information to the public will mitigate or prevent many potential problems. Admittedly, not all problems, issues, or complaints can be avoided, and almost all wind energy projects will have some type of issue that arises. The benefits, challenges, and issues for wind energy can be classified into several broad categories, and several of the specific issues may fit into multiple categories. For example, air quality is shown under \u201cHuman Health Related\u201d but air quality will also affect wildlife.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts.","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1687","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-essentials-societal-economic-environmental-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/book\/10.1002\/9781119040934","title":"Wind Energy Essentials: Societal, Economic, and Environmental Impacts","description":"This book begins with a history of wind power and the social impacts of both electricity and wind power from a historical perspective, a discussion of basic electrical terms, and a primer on the conversion of power in the wind to electricity. Much of the second half of the book is devoted to comparing wind energy to other forms of electric generation, both renewable and non-renewable sources. In order to have a true understanding of the impact of wind energy on society, one also has to have a thorough understanding of the impacts that other sources of electric generation have, such as fossil-fuelled plants or nuclear power plants. The comparison of electric generation sources includes a review of how such sources are typically utilized within the electric system, as well as the economic factors and environmental considerations that affect which resources utilities or operators of electric grids have to take into account. The authors conclude with a discussion of energy policies in the U.S., individual states, and foreign nations, how these policies influence the use of renewable energy, and what our future may hold in terms of energy supply and demand. Some highlights of this book are:\n\u00a0\nDiscusses the wind energy impacts on the environment, local economy, electric utilities, individuals and communities\nProvides a visual explanation of wind energy principles through tables, graphs, maps, illustrations and photographs\nOffers a comprehensive overview of the issues associated\u00a0with the creation and use of wind energy\nModels chapters around an existing university curriculum\nSpanning the broad range of environmental, financial, policy and other topics that define and determine the relationships between wind energy technology and our energy-dependent society,\u00a0Wind Energy Essentials\u00a0is a resource for students, universities, and the entire wind energy industry.\n\nTable of Contents:\u00a0\nImpacts of Energy and Electricity on Society\n\nThe Basics of Electricity\n\nOverview of Wind Energy and Other Sources of Electricity\n\nConversion of Power in the Wind to Electricity\n\nThe Wind Energy Development Process\n\nOverview of Issues Faced by Wind Energy\n\nWind and Wildlife: Siting Issues and Challenges\n\nEnvironmental and Ecological Impacts of Wind Energy on Humans: Public Health Issues\u00a0\n\nEnvironmental and Ecological Impacts of Wind Energy on Humans: Public and Workforce Safety Issues\n\nWind Energy\u0027s Impact on Aviation, Radar, and Telecommunications\n\nOther Environmental Issues of Wind Energy Development: Aesthetics, Cultural Resources, Land Use Compatibility, Water Resources, and Site Restoration\n\nImpact of Wind Energy on the Electric Grid\n\nNon\u2010Wind Renewable Energy Sources Used to Meet Electricity Needs\n\nNonrenewable Energy Sources Used to Meet Electricity Needs\n\nEnergy Efficiency and Conservation: \u201cLess Is More\u201d and \u201cDoing Without\u201d\n\nGreenhouse Gas Emissions\n\nSiting and Permitting of Electric Generation Projects\n\nEconomics of Electricity Generation\n\nEconomic Impacts and Benefits of Wind Energy Projects and Other Sources of Electric Generation\n\nEnvironmental Impacts and Economics of Offshore Wind Energy\n\nState and National Energy Policies\n\nGlobal Wind Energy Policy and Development\n\nWind Energy Workforce, Education, and Jobs\n\nThe Future of Electric Energy","author":["Walker, R.","Swift, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1688","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/research-brief-effects-wind-power-development-population-biology-greater-prairie","sourceURL":"https:\/\/rewi.org\/resources\/effects-of-wind-power-development-on-the-population-biology-of-greater-prairie-chickens-in-kansas\/","title":"Research Brief: Effects of Wind Power Development on the Population Biology of Greater Prairie-Chickens in Kansas","description":"Greater Prairie-Chicken populations have declined, primarily from loss of their prairie habitat to agriculture and other human development. As wind energy projects are proposed in Kansas and other states where Greater Prairie-Chickens and other grassland birds are now of conservation concern, conservationists, wildlife agencies, and wind energy companies are collaborating to study possible impacts from such development. Results from a comprehensive seven-year research project in Kansas suggest that wind power does not strongly affect Greater Prairie-Chickens. While weak negative effects were observed in male attendance of leks (communal display sites), female survival showed a positive trend. Little to no impacts were observed on most of the demographic parameters studied. The strongest correlates of population performance were the availability of native prairie and vegetative cover at the nest site. Efforts to improve rangeland management and to reduce predation would aid in the recovery of Greater Prairie-Chicken populations.","author":["National Wind Coordinating Collaborative"],"organization":["Kansas State University","American Wind Energy Association (AWEA)","National Wind Coordinating Collaborative"],"originationDate":"2013-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.011902000000","-98.484247000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NWCC_PrairieChickens_2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1689","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimating-seabird-flight-height-using-lidar","sourceURL":"https:\/\/data.marine.gov.scot\/dataset\/estimating-seabird-flight-height-using-lidar","title":"Estimating Seabird Flight Height using LiDAR","description":"Accurately estimating the proportion of birds at collision risk height forms a key part of assessing potential collision risk at offshore wind farms.\u00a0 Recent advances in LiDAR and digital aerial imaging offer the potential to collect precise estimates of the altitude of birds in flight.\u00a0 We trialled LiDAR and digital aerial photography as an approach to measuring the flight heights of seabirds in the Outer Forth and Tay Estuaries and carried out an exercise to validate measurements of flight height gained from LiDAR.\u00a0 The validation exercise demonstrated that the height of birds in flight could be measured using LiDAR to an accuracy of within 1 m.\u00a0 This compares very favourably to other approaches used for measure seabird flight height.\n\nWe successfully collected flight height information on 2,201 birds of which 806 were believed to be black-legged kittiwakes and 377 were identified as northern gannets. These data were used to derive continuous flight height distributions.\u00a0 We also demonstrate how data can be used to plot spatial patterns in seabird flight heights which may be of use for the purposes of marine spatial planning.\u00a0 Based on our experiences, we provide recommendations for the best practice in the use of LiDAR to collect seabird flight height data as part of future studies.\u00a0","author":["Cook, A.","Ward, R.","Hansen, W.","Larsen, L."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.022356000000","-3.369992500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Estimating_Seabird_Flight_Height_using_LiDAR.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1690","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-report-high-prairie-ii-wind-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fws.gov\/library\/collections\/high-prairie-renewable-energy-center","title":"Environmental Report: High Prairie II Wind Project","description":"The project under review here is called the High Prairie II Wind Farm (Project). This Project is a large wind energy conversion system (LWECS), as defined in the Wind Siting Act, Minnesota Statutes \u00a7\u00a7 216F.01\u2013216F.07. This Project is also a large energy facility (LEF), as defined in Minnesota Statutes \u00a7 216B.2421. The Project is located in Clayton, Bennington, Grand Meadow, and Marshall Townships (Township 104 N, Range 33 W, Sections 7-9, 16-21, 28-30) in Mower County. The Project site contains approximately 13,000 acres. The Project will generate electricity using up to 61 wind turbines with a rated capacity of 1.65 megawatts each. The Project will have a combined net electric generating capacity of approximately 100.65 MW. If one assumes an estimated net capacity factor of approximately 39 percent, projected average annual output would be 343,000 megawatt hours (MWh). The annual capacity factor will vary based on weather conditions and operational and maintenance issues associated with the facility. Output will also be dependent on final design, site-specific features, and equipment.","author":["Minnesota Department of Commerce"],"organization":["Minnesota Department of Commerce"],"originationDate":"2001-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.630337800000","-92.664456900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/High_Prairie_IES_2006.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1691","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/energy-sprawl-or-energy-efficiency-climate-policy-impacts-natural-habitat-united","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0006802","title":"Energy Sprawl or Energy Efficiency: Climate Policy Impacts on Natural Habitat for the United States of America","description":"Concern over climate change has led the U.S. to consider a cap-and-trade system to regulate emissions. Here we illustrate the land-use impact to U.S. habitat types of new energy development resulting from different U.S. energy policies. We estimated the total new land area needed by 2030 to produce energy, under current law and under various cap-and-trade policies, and then partitioned the area impacted among habitat types with geospatial data on the feasibility of production. The land-use intensity of different energy production techniques varies over three orders of magnitude, from 1.9\u20132.8 km2\/ TW hr\/yr for nuclear power to 788\u20131000 km2\/TW hr\/yr for biodiesel from soy. In all scenarios, temperate deciduous forests and temperate grasslands will be most impacted by future energy development, although the magnitude of impact by wind, biomass, and coal to different habitat types is policy-specific. Regardless of the existence or structure of a cap-and-trade bill, at least 206,000 km2\u00a0will be impacted without substantial increases in energy efficiency, which saves at least 7.6 km2\u00a0per TW hr of electricity conserved annually and 27.5 km2\u00a0per TW hr of liquid fuels conserved annually. Climate policy that reduces carbon dioxide emissions may increase the areal impact of energy, although the magnitude of this potential side effect may be substantially mitigated by increases in energy efficiency. The possibility of widespread energy sprawl increases the need for energy conservation, appropriate siting, sustainable production practices, and compensatory mitigation offsets.","author":["Fargione, J.","Kiesecker, J.","McDonald, R.","Miller, W.","Powell, J."],"organization":["The Nature Conservancy","Northwestern University"],"originationDate":"2009-08-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/McDonald_et_al_2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1692","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-anthropogenic-noise-wildlife-research-priorities-development-standards","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Jessica_Blickley\/publication\/235991778_Impacts_of_Anthropogenic_Noise_on_Wildlife_Research_Priorities_for_the_Development_of_Standards_and_Mitigation\/links\/00b7d51547dd6ade40000000.pdf","title":"Impacts of Anthropogenic Noise on Wildlife: Research Priorities for the Development of Standards and Mitigation","description":"Human development introduces anthropogenic noise sources into the environment\u00a0across many elements of the modern terrestrial landscape, including\u00a0roads, airports, military bases, and cities.\u00a0The impacts of these introduced\u00a0noise sources on wildlife are less well studied than many of the other effects\u00a0human activities have on wildlife, the most well known of which are habitat\u00a0fragmentation and the introduction of invasive species. A growing and substantial\u00a0body of literature suggests, however, that noise impacts may be more\u00a0important and widespread than previously imagined.\u00a0They range in effects\u00a0from mild to severe. They can impact wildlife species at both the individual\u00a0and population levels. The types of impacts run the gamut from damage to the\u00a0auditory system, the masking of sounds important to survival and reproduction,\u00a0the imposition of chronic stress and associated physiological responses,\u00a0startling, interference with mating, and population declines.","author":["Blickley, J.","Patricelli, G."],"organization":["University of California Davis"],"originationDate":"2010-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1693","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/greater-sage-grouse-overview-effects-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/rewi.org\/resources\/greater-sage-grouse-fact-sheet-overview-and-effects-of-wind-energy-development\/","title":"Greater Sage-Grouse: Overview and Effects of Wind Energy Development","description":"This fact sheet provides an overview of current knowledge on greater sage-grouse ecology, status, conservation challenges, and current conservation efforts, and presents a summary of recent research findings on the interactions between sage-grouse and wind energy development. There is a wide range of research outcomes on sage-grouse ecology and some uncertainty remains. This fact sheet presents current knowledge based on recent research and the references cited provide further information on specific findings.","author":["National Wind Coordinating Collaborative"],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)","National Wind Coordinating Collaborative"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2026-05-30 01:08:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1694","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proceedings-wind-wildlife-research-meeting-xi","sourceURL":"https:\/\/rewi.org\/resources\/wind-wildlife-research-meeting-xi-proceedings\/","title":"Proceedings of the Wind-Wildlife Research Meeting XI","description":"The biennial Wind Wildlife Research Meeting provides an internationally recognized forum for researchers and wind-wildlife stakeholders to hear contributed papers, view research posters, and listen to panels that synthesize the most recent wind power-related wildlife research. Academics, researchers, conservation scientists, consultants, federal and state officials, NGO representatives, and wind industry professionals come together every other year for this unique opportunity. The meeting is organized and presented by the American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI).  Wind energy\u2019s ability to generate electricity without carbon emissions will help reduce the potentially catastrophic effects of unlimited climate change on wildlife. Wind energy also provides several other environmental benefits including substantially reduced water withdrawals and consumption, mercury emissions, and other sources of air and water pollution associated with burning fossil fuels. Adverse impacts of wind energy facilities to wildlife, particularly to individual birds and bats, have been documented. Impacts to wildlife populations have not been documented, but the potential for biologically significant impacts continue to be a source of concern for some species that are experiencing long-term declines because of habitat loss and fragmentation, disease, non-native invasive species, and increased mortality from numerous anthropogenic activities. These proceedings document current research pertaining to wind energy and wildlife impacts and innovations in technologies and methods to address these impacts, including: understanding risk, demographic impacts, fatality estimation, detection and deterrence technologies, and impact minimization and mitigation. Because of concentrated investment in detection and deterrent technologies, presentations documented progress being made to minimize impacts in a meaningful way.   Topics Covered in these Proceedings:    Framework for Policy Questions Going Forward  Raptors \u0026amp; Wind Energy: Lessons Learned from Altamont, Estimating Origins \u0026amp; Fatalities     U.S. Raptor Mortality Estimates from Wind Energy for the U.S. - Presented by: Wallace Erickson, Western EcoSystems Technology (WEST), Inc.   Scientific Insights and Lessons Learned from the 9-year Monitoring Program in the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area - Presented by: Douglas Leslie, ICF International      Golden Eagles \u0026amp; Wind Energy: Prediciting Interactions, Migratory Corridors \u0026amp; Range, \u0026amp; More     Response of Golden Eagle Flight Altitude to Topographic Variation in California and Implications for Potential for Wind-Wildlife Interactions - Presented by: Adam Duerr, Division of Forestry \u0026amp; Natural Resources, West Virginia University   Genomic Resources for the Management and Conservation of Bald and Golden Eagles - Presented by: Ronald Van Den Bussche, Oklahoma State University   Golden Eagle Migration Corridors along the Rocky Mountain Front and Intermountain Flyways - Presented by: Adam Shreading, Raptor View Research Institute   Evaluating and Adapting Surveys designed to Predict Wind-Wildlife Interactions: a Simulation Approach Focused on Golden Eagles - Presented by: Todd Katzner, USGS Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center   Overview of USFWS Western Golden Eagle Team Risk Assessment and Conservation Planning Program - Presented by: Brian Woodbridge, US Fish \u0026amp; Wildlife Service      Using Modeling to Inform Siting of Wind Energy at a Landscape Scale     Low Ecological Risk Wind Energy Development Areas Analysis - Presented by: Jim Hays, The Nature Conservancy   Using a Landscape Design Conservation Planning Process to Assess and Plan for Wind Energy Development in the Western Great Plains, USA - Presented by: Anne Bartuszevige, Playa Lakes Joint Venture      Offshore Wind Energy     Exploring the Displacement of Seabirds from Offshore Wind Farms (OWFs) - Presented by: Fraser Carter, Joint Nature Conservation Committee   Responses of Marine Top Predators to an Offshore Wind Farm in UK Waters: Does Evidence Exist for Displacement? - Presented by: Nancy McLean, Natural Power   Collision and Displacement Vulnerability among Marine Birds of the California Current System Associated with Offshore Wind Energy Infrastructure - Presented by: Emma C. Kelsey, U.S. Geological Survey   Satellite Tracking Highlights Use of Ocean Habitat by Diving Bird Species in Federal Waters of the US Mid-Atlantic - Presented by: Alicia Berlin, U.S. Geological Survey Patuxent Wildlife Research Center   Bats at Sea: A Final 6-Year Summary of Bat Monitoring on Islands, Offshore Structures, and Coastal Sites in the Gulf of Maine, Mid-Atlantic States, and Great Lakes Regions - Presented by: Steve Pelletier, Stantec Consulting Services, Inc.      Innovative Approaches to Fatality Monitoring     Challenges with the Multitude of Fatality Estimators and the Need for a Generalized Estimator - Presented by: Cris Hein, Bat Conservation International   Area Correction Methods for Efficient Post-Construction Fatality Monitoring Studies - Presented by: Daniel Riser-Espinoza, Western EcoSystems Technology (WEST), Inc.   Developing an Operations Staff-Based Monitoring Protocol for Eagle Fatalities at Wind Energy Facilities - Presented by: Paul Rabie, Western EcoSystems Technology (WEST), Inc.   Wildlife Monitoring and Reporting System using Operations Personnel: 5-year Assessment - Presented by: Laura Nagy, Avangrid Renewables      Operational Mitigation: Strategies to Minimize Bat Fatalities     Bats in the Rotor Zone...Managing Risk with Acoustics - Presented by: Trevor Peterson, Stantec Consulting Services Inc.; University of Maine   Acoustic Bat Monitoring at a Southern Alberta Wind Farm - Presented by: Katrina Lukianchuk, Tannas Conservation Services Ltd.   Turbine Integrated Mortality Reduction for Bats - Presented by: Christine Sutter, Normandeau Associates   Smart Curtailment: Improving Efficiency by Using More Than Wind Speed - Presented by: Manuela Huso, U.S. Geological Survey, Forest and Rangeland Ecosystem Science Center   Multi-year Operational Minimization Study in West Virginia: Potential Novel Strategy to Reducing Bat Fatalities at Wind Turbines - Presented by: Michael Schirmacher, Bat Conservation International      Examining Species\u0027 Responses \u0026amp; Vulnerability to Wind Energy     An Evaluation of Potential Pronghorn Responses to Wind Energy Development in North-Central Arizona - Presented by: Martin Piorkowski, Arizona Game and Fish Department   Modeling the Impact of Wind Energy on Hoary Bat Populations - Presented by: Erin Baerwald, University of Calgary and American Wind Wildlife Institute   The Effects of a Wind Energy Development on a Greater Sage-Grouse Population - Presented by: Chad LeBeau, Western EcoSystems Technology (WEST), Inc.      Furthering Understanding of Siting \u0026amp; Assessment     Avian Mortality at Three Wind Energy Facilities on the Gulf Coast of Texas - Presented by: Elizabeth Baumgartner, Western EcoSystems Technology (WEST), Inc.   Challenges in Quantifying the Effectiveness of Impact Avoidance and Minimization Measures and Potential Solutions - Presented by: Julie Garvin, Tetra Tech   Managing Wind Farms \u2013 What is the Role of Adaptive Management? - Presented by: Andrea Copping, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory\u200b      Endangered Species Risk \u0026amp; Impact Estimation     Flight Response to Topographic, Vegetative, and Temporal Correlates Predicts Risk from Wind Turbines to an Obligate-Soaring Bird, the California Condor - Presented by: Sharon Poessel, U.S. Geological Survey   Spring Migration of Indiana Bats (Myotis sodalis) and What It Means for the Wind Industry - Presented by: Piper Roby, Copperhead Environmental Consulting, Inc.   Estimating Inter-annual Variability in Project Take for Rare Events - Presented by: Jonathan Plissner, Tetra Tech      Using Advanced Technologies to Study and Minimize Impacts     Stereo-optic High Definition Imaging: A Technology to Understand Bird Avoidance of Wind Turbines - Presented by: Evan Adams, Biodiversity Research Institute   Heterogeneous Sensor Fusion for Autonomous Detection of Wildlife Collisions with Wind Turbines - Presented by: Roberto Albertani, Oregon State University   Ultraviolet Illumination as a Means of Reducing Bat Activity at Wind Turbines - Presenter: Paul Cryan, U.S. Geological Survey, Fort Collins Science Center   Reduction of Eagle Take at Windfarms through Machine Vision Enhanced Informed Curtailment - Presented by: Tom Hiester, Renewable Energy Systems      Research Priorities \u0026amp; Key Meeting Takeaways   Disclaimer: Some of the presentations described in the Proceedings of the Wind Wildlife Research Meeting XI may have been peer-reviewed independent of this meeting, but results should be considered preliminary. Information presented in this document may be cited, although communication with the author before doing so is highly recommended to ensure that the information cited is current. These proceedings do not necessarily reflect the views of the American Wind Wildlife Institute or the National Wind Coordinating Collaborative. AWWI expressly disclaims any warranties or guarantees, expressed or implied, and shall not be liable for damages of any kind in connection with the material, information, techniques, or procedures set forth in this publication.","author":["Schwartz, S."],"organization":["National Wind Coordinating Collaborative","American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2026-05-30 01:07:41","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1695","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-biological-characteristics-marine-renewable-energy-sites-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/depts.washington.edu\/pmec\/","title":"Evaluating biological characteristics of marine renewable energy sites for environmental monitoring","description":"Tidal energy is a renewable resource that helps meet growing energy demands, but uncertainties remain about environmental impacts of device installation and operation. Monitoring programs are used to detect impacts caused by anthropogenic disturbances and are a mandatory requirement of project operating licenses in the United States. Because tidal technology is new, studies describing environmental change due to tidal devices are scarce, limiting the information that can be used to characterize environmental impacts for monitoring requirements. Extreme value analysis (EVA) was used to characterize infrequent values from monitoring studies that are potentially associated with impact, defined as relevant biological change as a consequence of human activity, at a tidal energy site. EVA was adapted for monitoring aquatic organisms in the water column using an active acoustic dataset from Admiralty Inlet, a proposed tidal energy site. First derivatives were used to identify extreme value thresholds to improve estimation precision. Return level plots, which indicate the average period that extreme values are expected to appear, and uncertainty estimates of return level predictions, were generated using Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) simulations. Managers and site developers could use EVA to characterize rare values that may be associated with impacts, and tailor monitoring programs to include operational protocols for conditions under which these events occur. To characterize the generality of tidal energy sites, metrics describing temporal and spatial distributions of fish and macrozooplankton at the Admiralty Inlet site and a second tidal energy site from the Fall of Warness, Scotland were compared using statistical methods (t-test, F-test, linear regression), spectral analysis, and EVA. General biological characteristics were similar enough that generic biological monitoring programs could be implemented at these two sites, which would streamline the permitting process as well as facilitate site comparison and detection of environmental impact due to tidal technology deployment.","author":["Wiesebron, L."],"organization":["University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wiesebron_thesis_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1696","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measuring-sensitivity-two-ospar-indicators-coastal-food-web-model-under-offshore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X1830534X","title":"Measuring sensitivity of two OSPAR indicators for a coastal food web model under offshore wind farm construction","description":"A combination of modelling tools was applied to simulate the impacts of the future Courseulles-sur-mer offshore wind farm (OWF) construction (Bay of Seine, English Channel) on the ecosystem structure and functioning. To do so, food-web models of the ecosystem under three scenarios were constructed to investigate the effect caused by the OWF of added substrate (reef effect), fishing restriction (reserve effect), and their combined effect. Further, Ecological Network Analysis indices and Mean Trophic Level were derived to investigate their suitability for detecting changes in the ecosystem state. Our analysis suggests changes in the ecosystem structure and functioning after the OWF construction, the ecosystem maturity was predicted to increase, but no alterations in its overall resilience capacity.","author":["Dauvin, J.","Raoux, A.","Pezy, J.","Tecchio, S.","Niquil, N.","Lassalle, G.","Ernande, B.","Maz\u00e9, C.","Safi, G.","Le Loch, F.","Lequesne, J.","Girardin, V."],"organization":["Normandie Universit\u00e9","Institut Universitaire Europ\u00e9en de la Mer (IUEM)","The French Research Institute for Exploitation of the Sea (IFREMER)"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.075119000000","-0.858406000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1697","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/first-situ-evidence-wakes-far-field-behind-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41598-018-20389-y","title":"First in situ evidence of wakes in the far field behind offshore wind farms","description":"More than 12 GW of offshore wind turbines are currently in operation in European waters. To optimise the use of the marine areas, wind farms are typically clustered in units of several hundred turbines. Understanding wakes of wind farms, which is the region of momentum and energy deficit downwind, is important for optimising the wind farm layouts and operation to minimize costs. While in most weather situations (unstable atmospheric stratification), the wakes of wind turbines are only a local effect within the wind farm, satellite imagery reveals wind-farm wakes to be several tens of kilometres in length under certain conditions (stable atmospheric stratification), which is also predicted by numerical models. The first direct in situ measurements of the existence and shape of large wind farm wakes by a specially equipped research aircraft in 2016 and 2017 confirm wake lengths of more than tens of kilometres under stable atmospheric conditions, with maximum wind speed deficits of 40%, and enhanced turbulence. These measurements were the first step in a large research project to describe and understand the physics of large offshore wakes using direct measurements, together with the assessment of satellite imagery and models.","author":["Neumann, T.","Platis, A.","Siedersleben, S.","Bange, J.","Lampert, A.","B\u00e4rfuss, K.","Hankers, R.","Ca\u00f1adillas, B.","Foreman, R.","Schulz-Stellenfeth, J.","Djath, B.","Emeis, S."],"organization":["UL International GmbH (DEWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/platis-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1698","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/future-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-17","title":"The future of marine spatial planning","description":"This conclusion presents some closing thoughts on the concepts discussed in the preceding chapters of this book. The book provides how effective marine spatial planning can minimise the negative impacts of offshore-energy developments and realise new opportunities for multi-sector benefits. It highlights some of many challenges that remain for marine spatial planning, and suggests how increased collaboration, more meaningful participation, and more aligned governance structures combined with transparent planning tools can contribute to future successes. The book provides an in-depth assessment of the stakeholder-engagement process and describes that effective participation is essential to successful planning outcomes and that participation needs to each stakeholder to be effective. It examines how the process of stakeholder engagement can be a form of data generation and validation that can work in conjunction with ecosystem service trade-off analysis. The book discusses the marine spatial planning invoking a complex array of disciplines that must be harmonised-from the scientific, socio-economic, legal, political, to the psychological.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Greenhill, L.","Yates, K.","Bradshaw, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1699","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-national-project-management-framework-audit-european-union-marine-spatial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/data.marine.gov.scot\/dataset\/multi-national-project-management-framework-audit-european-union-marine-spatial-planning-1","title":"A Multi-National Project Management Framework Audit of a European Union Marine Spatial Planning Project","description":"Marine spatial planning (MSP) is an emerging field of management aimed at promoting the sustainable use of the marine environment. In order to further the progression of MSP, a European Union funded Project is exploring the opportunities for multi-use across Europe\u2019s sea basins. Given the complex multi-national partner approach, and the relatively immature status of MSP, the utilization of an effective project management regime is vital in order to achieve the vision set out by The Project. This paper details the development of a Multi-National Project Management Framework Audit (MPMFA) matrix informed by the Project Management Body of Knowledge. The MPMFA is applied to The Project\u2019s ongoing project management practices in order to identify knowledge and process gaps and recommend a suite of tools and techniques. The results demonstrate that The Project has underdeveloped cost, schedule, and change management plans in relation to project execution and monitoring phases.","author":["Sangiuliano, S."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-03-02","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Sangiuliano-2018-MSP-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1700","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/co-locating-offshore-wind-farms-marine-protected-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-14","title":"Co-locating offshore wind farms and marine protected areas","description":"Offshore wind farms have been operational in the United Kingdom since 2003 and continue to be constructed, driven by the United Kingdom\u2019s commitment to meet 15% of energy needs from renewable sources by 2020. As a result, United Kingdom seas contain many offshore wind farms. The presence of infrastructure such as foundations and cables could limit the types of economic activities that can take place around them, such as fishing or aggregate dredging. By restricting activities that can negatively affect the environment, offshore wind farms potentially create de facto marine protected areas. Formalising this arrangement and co-locating offshore wind farms and marine protected areas might therefore maximise spatial efficiency by allowing these activities to occur concurrently in time and space where they are compatible. In our case study, we review the scenario within United Kingdom waters by examining the planning and licencing requirements in relation to co-location of offshore wind farms and marine protected areas, using case-study sites with two different forms of marine protected area designation in the United Kingdom. We examine the compatibility of these co-location scenarios and discuss implications for management and mitigation to ensure marine protected area objectives are met.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Mangi, S.","Ashley, M.","Rodwell, L.","Austen, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1701","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning-stakeholder-collaboration","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-13","title":"Marine spatial planning and stakeholder collaboration","description":"Over the past decade in the United States, there has been growing interest among governmental, academic, environmental, and resource-user communities in managing the ocean in a more comprehensive and ecosystem-based manner. Proposals for new uses of ocean resources and space\u2014most notably from the energy sector\u2014have left resource managers grappling with how to protect our increasingly compromised ocean ecosystems while allowing for sustainable use. Debate over this issue has been heated in New England where proposals for offshore, liquefied natural gas terminals, sand and gravel mining, desalination plants, gas pipelines, and wind and tidal energy facilities have raised concerns among local, state, and federal agencies and the general public about how to manage the diversity of uses and minimise the negative impacts of this intensified development pressure on the marine environment. In response, the region has embraced marine spatial planning as a tool to optimise use and advance ocean health; maximizing what the ocean has to offer in the way of food, transportation, recreation, jobs, and energy, while ensuring protection of the ecosystem. Massachusetts and Rhode Island have completed marine spatial plans (known locally as \u2018ocean plans\u2019) for their state ocean waters. More recently, a Northeast Regional Ocean Plan was completed in 2016 to guide management of state and federal ocean waters from Maine to Connecticut. Intensive planning for offshore wind energy development is sparking new scientific research, data collection, and stakeholder collaboration that aims both to advance renewable energy development and to ensure ecosystem protection. In this case study, we focus on marine spatial planning in New England and collaboration between wind energy developers and environmental organisations to advance offshore wind development and effective protection of North Atlantic right whales\u2014one of the world\u2019s most endangered species of marine mammals.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Brooks, P.","Jedele, T."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1702","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/capturing-benefits","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-11","title":"Capturing benefits","description":"The infrastructure required for offshore energy creates new substrata that provide settlement surfaces for a range of benthic species. These artificial reef effects are well-documented, and there is growing evidence that the enhanced prey availability and shelter can attract species of interest to commercial and recreational fishers, creating potential co-location opportunities. The exclusion of towed bottom gears from the proximity of energy installations due to concerns about safety and infrastructure damage creates further opportunities for static gear and small-scale fishers. However, even for these groups, taking advantage of fishing opportunities might not be straightforward in practice. We review the ecological evidence supporting the potential for energy infrastructure to enhance fisheries, considering which target fish and shellfish species appear to benefit, at which stage in their lifecycle, and whether there is evidence for any contribution to fisheries production, as opposed to the simple attraction of individuals from elsewhere. We also discuss the socio-economic issues related to the potential exploitation of any enhanced fishery resource, considering the attitudes, opinions, and existing practice of fishers, boat skippers and developers with respect to such factors as the feasibility, safety, and economic viability of co-location. We also review the possibilities for the co-location of aquaculture as an alternative to capture fisheries. We conclude by considering how this information on the potential for fishery and aquaculture co-location might be incorporated into future marine spatial planning.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Ashley, M.","Hooper, T.","Austen, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1703","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tracing-regime-shifts-provision-coastal-marine-cultural-ecosystem-services","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-8","title":"Tracing regime shifts in the provision of coastal-marine cultural ecosystem services","description":"Marine spatial planners need to understand the potential consequences of offshore wind farm development at multiple levels and spatial\/temporal scales. Comparatively little is still known about how offshore wind farms affect cultural ecosystem services and how this in turn can affect individual and societal well-being. Based on a survey of local residents in a case-study region on the North Sea coast of Germany, we describe the values commonly associated with the seascape and how these can be threatened by offshore wind farm development. We show that regime shifts in the cultural ecosystem-services domain can have knock-on effects in the socio-economic system on the coast, in particular at the level of perceived individual quality of life. At the same time, opportunities exist for using this change constructively and for the benefit of the region. Marine planning, if used on appropriate spatial scales and societal levels, can help to deal constructively with changes in sea use.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Burkhard, B.","Gee, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1704","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/displacement-existing-activities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-7","title":"Displacement of existing activities","description":"The introduction of a new marine activity in marine spatial planning often imposes spatial restrictions on existing marine users. This chapter describes the potential effects of offshore energy developments on established widespread marine users, using the commercial wild-capture fishing sector as an example. The potential for fishing effort displacement is a concern amongst stakeholders and has a range of direct and indirect, positive and negative, economic, social, and environmental effects on individual fishers, the fishing industry, fishery-dependent coastal communities, and wider society. We present methods for assessment of possible impacts, as well as management recommendations for prevention and mitigation.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Davies, I.","Kafas, A.","Donohue, P."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1705","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/challenges-opportunities-governance-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-5","title":"Challenges and opportunities for governance in marine spatial planning","description":"Marine spatial planning integrates the planning of multiple sectors and interests to support public negotiation and decision making regarding sustainable resource use. Marine spatial planning is integrated and holistic, which are important features of governance required to address competing demands of growing and diversifying maritime economies within social and ecological limits. Marine spatial planning presents an opportunity to reflect on the currently fragmented governance of marine activities, and could provide a focus for improving management and supporting the sustainable development of sectors such as offshore energy, alongside other interests. The implementation of marine spatial planning is highly context-specific, and this chapter outlines some of the main challenges faced, and how these can be approached to improve governance. Conceptual and practical challenges exist in: (a) understanding the respective roles of government, industry and civil society in marine spatial planning; (b) reaching consensus on the purpose of marine spatial planning (including its definition and \u2018operationalising\u2019 concepts such as \u2018sustainability\u2019 and \u2018ecosystem-based management\u2019); (c) understanding how marine spatial planning relates to existing governance structures of decision making and management of individual activities; (d) how to evaluate the effectiveness of marine spatial planning and enable on-going improvements through adaptive management; and (e) how to ensure the knowledge and capacity to support the process. While the influence of marine spatial planning on existing decision-making processes depends on the characteristics of each case, we suggest that the integrated perspective of marine spatial planning and dialogue among participants it supports can enable changes in related governance. Considering the issues, proactively and collaboratively engaging through dynamic and adaptive processes could facilitate change, reduce existing complexity, and support progress towards \u2018sustainability\u2019 in marine resource use.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Greenhill, L."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1706","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/methods-utility-ecosystem-service-trade-analysis-guiding-marine-planning-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-3","title":"Methods and utility of ecosystem service trade-off analysis for guiding marine planning of offshore energy","description":"Successful development of offshore energy will require strategic planning in relation to incumbent ocean users and activities (i.e., sectors) in order to maximise their respective benefits. Marine ecosystems are finite in size and resource availability, creating the potential for extensive overlap between areas preferred for energy development and those already in use by fisheries, shipping, conservation, and other sectors. Further, operational and market activities by the offshore energy industry can interact with incumbent sectors both biophysically and socioeconomically. Consequently, strategic planning of offshore energy across a seascape is a highly complex problem that cannot be solved without the aid of analytical tools that explicitly account for these factors and interactions when calculating the costs and benefits of alternative spatial plans. Herein, we discuss such a tool\u2014ecosystem service trade-off analysis\u2014and its utility for guiding strategic planning of offshore energy. Ecosystem service trade-off analysis imbeds outputs of coupled biophysical-socioeconomic models of sector interactions into a weighted multi-sector objective function that is used to determine optimal spatial plans that maximise individual-sector values and minimise conflicts to the extent possible. We describe the history of the development of ecosystem service trade-off analysis, and outline its main analytical components and procedural steps. Next, we draw on actual and conceptual case studies and estimate the potential value of using ecosystem trade-off analysis over conventional planning approaches for guiding strategic planning. Finally, we look beyond energy to studies that used ecosystem service trade-off analysis to guide other planning processes, and highlight lessons from those studies that could help guide marine planning of offshore energy.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Lester, S.","White, C.","Stevens, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1707","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-2","title":"Marine spatial planning","description":"Marine spatial planning is a process now employed in more than 60 countries around the world to identify and resolve conflicts among competing uses of ocean space, and to resolve conflicts between human uses and the natural marine environment. Marine spatial planning is often driven by the need to find space for new users\u2014including energy extraction and generation\u2014in increasingly busy seas, and to reduce conflicts in space and time among uses and between use and conservation. Marine spatial planning should be (1) place-based, with a focus on marine spaces that people can understand, relate to, and care about; (2) participatory, building on a broad base of stakeholders to ensure long-term support for management; (3) integrated and multi-objective, including all important economic sectors\u2014and economic and social objectives as well as ecological ones; (4) strategic and future-oriented, considering alternative means to achieve desired future conditions of the marine area; (5) ecosystem-based, with a focus on maintaining ecosystem services over time; and (6) continuing and adaptive, with an emphasis on monitoring and evaluating the performance of management actions, and learning by doing. Good marine spatial planning is a public process done mainly by government, but it should also effectively involve users and stakeholders. While often presented as an overly complicated process, marine spatial planning reduces to four simple questions: (1) Where are we now? (2) Where do we want to be? (3) How do we get there? (4) What have we accomplished? One of its assumptions is that not all areas of the ocean are equally important from an ecological, economic, or social perspective, and many opportunities exist to identify the most important areas and resolve any conflicts among alternative uses (or non-use) of those areas.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Ehler, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1708","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/meaningful-stakeholder-participation-marine-spatial-planning-offshore-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-10","title":"Meaningful stakeholder participation in marine spatial planning with offshore energy","description":"Within an increasingly busy seascape, competition between different uses of marine resources is growing. Offshore energy generation in particular is expanding rapidly, with implications for both existing users and nature conservation. Marine spatial planning is seen as the primary tool for mitigating conflicts and optimising resources allocation, and within its processes, effective and timely stakeholder involvement is essential to success. In reality, however, stakeholder involvement in planning is rarely seen as effective, especially from the stakeholders\u2019 perspective. Using illustrative examples, the author\u00a0reviews why stakeholder involvement is so important, what constitutes meaningful participation, and what prevents the successful incorporation of stakeholders into planning processes, examins\u00a0issues of integration, transparency and communication. They\u00a0look at how stakeholder engagement in planning process driven by pressure to expand offshore energy can have unique characteristics that need to be accounted for. Finally, they\u00a0consider ways to make stakeholder participation in planning inclusive, meaningful, and transparent. In particular, they\u00a0describe how participatory mapping can be used to collect quantitative, spatial stakeholder data that can be incorporated into trade-off analysis and optimisation processes.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Yates, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1709","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/compatibility-offshore-energy-installations-marine-protected-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-12","title":"Compatibility of offshore energy installations with marine protected areas","description":"Energy generation sites are increasingly being constructed in coastal and marine spaces and the rate of implementation is likely to increase in coming decades, due to a combination of increasing energy demand and international targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. In many cases, the installation of energy generation structures greatly reduces or entirely prevents other potentially damaging industries, such as fishing and mining, from operating in surrounding areas. These sites also provide hard substratum and complex habitat in what are commonly soft sediment environments. As such, they have been associated with high rates of colonisation by marine life, increased biodiversity and increased productivity. However, energy generation sites also have the potential to damage and fragment habitats and associated communities, and increase noise and\/or chemical pollution in the marine environment. As competition for marine space grows, an emerging literature is increasingly considering whether conservation objectives and energy generation can be co-located. We synthesise available literature from around the world to consider what the potential conservation benefits of marine energy generation sites are. We discuss whether such sites are compatible with marine protected area designation, and examine this argument both from a biodiversity and policy perspective.\n\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Yates, K.","Thurstan, R.","O\u0027Leary, B."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1710","type":["Document","Document\/Video"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/humpback-whales-floating-offshore-wind-farm-animation","sourceURL":"","title":"Humpback Whales and Floating Offshore Wind Farm Animation","description":"Commercial interest in developing floating wind energy in the deep waters of the Pacific Outer Continental Shelf has raised questions about whales and other large cetaceans potentially encountering the mooring lines and electrical cables from a floating offshore wind farm. The BOEM Pacific Region asked the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory to create an animated simulation of a humpback whale mother and her calf swimming through a hypothetical floating offshore wind farm in order to visualize the scale of the whales compared to the scale of the wind farm\u2019s underwater components. This simulation helps characterize the risk of whale encounters with mooring lines and electrical cables.  The floating wind farm shown in the video is a hypothetical but realistic depiction of what could be installed off the U.S. west coast and Hawaii. Humpbacks were chosen as the whale species to depict because of their presence in the Pacific Region and their large pectoral fins\u2014appendages that could make them more likely to encounter the mooring lines and electrical cables if they are swimming nearby. For more information, see the accompanying report.  For more information, see the accompanying report.","author":["Copping, A.","Grear, M.","Sanders, G.","Guiltinan, S."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs"],"originationDate":"2018-11-19","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Entanglement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/HumpbackWhaleWindFarmEncounterFinalReport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1711","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/good-practice-during-wind-farm-construction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/guidance-good-practice-during-wind-farm-construction","title":"Good practice during Wind Farm construction","description":"The Scottish Government and its agencies support the development of renewable energy, including wind farms, as a key means of tackling climate change.  Considerable experience has been gained from the construction and operation of wind farms across Scotland with an installed capacity totalling over 5000 Megawatts. The purpose of this guidance is to share that experience amongst the industry, planning authorities and those more broadly involved in the planning and development of wind farms. It is focused on pollution prevention, nature conservation, environment, natural resources, landscape, hydrological, biosecurity and non-native species, archaeological and related issues.  It does not offer guidance on the detailed design or erection of turbines, their components or related infrastructure. It does not address matters of Health and Safety on site specifically. Please refer to the Health and Safety Executive for guidance on these matters. It is aimed at the post consent, pre-construction planning and construction phase of development.  This guidance seeks to identify Good Practice, not necessarily Best Practice, which is evolving constantly. This guidance aims to \u2018raise the bar\u2019 and ensure that all wind farm sites are constructed in a sustainable way which respects the surrounding environment and minimises environmental risks. This means going beyond ensuring compliance with environmental legislation whilst balancing this with the practicalities of construction and commercial constraints on developers and contractors.  The guidance will be updated as more experience is gained. In particular, our understanding of issues relating to carbon emissions from wind farm sites is evolving quickly and as a result this guidance will be updated regularly. Box 1 below outlines the current approach to Good Practice when addressing issues of peat management on site and minimising carbon loss.  This guidance is aimed at:    Wind farm developers  Construction companies and contractors working on wind farm sites  Consultants and advisers supporting the wind farm industry  Planning officers working on wind farm applications  Statutory consultees such as SNH, SEPA, Marine Scotland Science \u2013 Freshwater Laboratory (MSS-FL) and others with an interest in wind farm construction, Environmental and Ecological Clerks of Works","author":["Scottish Natural Heritage","Scottish Renewables","Scottish Environment Protection Agency","Forestry Commission Scotland","Historic Environment Scotland"],"organization":["Scottish Renewables","Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2015-09-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SNH-2015-Good-Practice-Wind-Farm-Construction.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1712","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/scoping-advice-information-required-environmental-impact-assessment-reports-relation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www2.gov.scot\/Resource\/0053\/00534941.pdf","title":"Scoping advice on information required in environmental impact assessment reports in relation to assessing risk to freshwater and diadromous fish and associated fisheries","description":"Onshore wind farm and transmission line developments have the potential to adversely affect freshwater and diadromous fish and associated fisheries through a number of mechanisms, including: increased sediment transport and deposition; pollution incidents e.g. fuel, concrete spillage, incorrect use of flocculants (for sediment control); altered hydrological pathways; removal or degradation of fish habitat, including spawning areas; reduction in food supply and obstruction to upstream and downstream migration of fish. It is important to avoid and\/or reduce the possibility of such impacts occurring by careful pre-construction consideration; including site investigations to select a suitable site and design, and good practice throughout construction (see here).  The principal fish species of concern are Atlantic salmon, sea trout, brown trout and European eel, but for some developments other species, such as lamprey species, may be of concern. All are of conservation interest, and Atlantic salmon, sea trout and brown trout support important fisheries of economic value which could also be affected, either directly or by impacts on population size.  Marine Scotland Science (MSS), which is part of the Scottish Government, regularly provides scientific advice to Energy Consents Unit (ECU) in relation the potential impacts of wind farm developments on the above fish. ECU has the responsibility, under Sections 36 and 37 of the Electricity Act (1989), for processing applications for electricity generating stations of 50 megawatts or more, power lines and associated infrastructure for Scottish Ministers\u2019 consent. Under the Electricity Works (Environmental Impact Assessment) (Scotland) (EIA) Regulations (2017), Scottish Ministers are required to consider whether any proposal for a wind farm is likely to have a significant effect on the environment. An application for an Electricity Act consent for an EIA development must be accompanied by an Environmental Impact Assessment Report (EIAR). This guidance note outlines MSS advice on matters which should be addressed in the EIAR.","author":["Marine Scotland Science"],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Pelagic Fish","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Marine-Scotland-Science-2018-Scoping-Advice.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1713","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/generic-monitoring-programme-monitoring-watercourses-relation-onshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www2.gov.scot\/Topics\/marine\/Salmon-Trout-Coarse\/Freshwater\/Research\/onshoreren\/watercourse","title":"Generic monitoring programme for monitoring watercourses in relation to onshore wind farm developments","description":"Appropriate site selection and design, good construction techniques and implementation of appropriate site specific mitigation measures are the primary means of avoiding and\/or minimising impacts on the freshwater environment from wind farm developments. In addition, integrated monitoring programmes that include water quality, macroinvertebrate and fish population assessments can also provide important and rapid information on impacts, ensuring effective site management, mitigation and, if necessary, restoration throughout the course of a wind farm development.","author":["Marine Scotland Science"],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Marine-Scotland-Science-2018-Monitoring-Program.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1714","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-array-configuration-hydro-environmental-impacts-tidal-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148113005661","title":"The effects of array configuration on the hydro-environmental impacts of tidal turbines","description":"The economic viability of tidal turbines will require the deployment of multiple devices in array formations in a manner analogous to wind farms. This research investigates the effects of the configuration of a tidal turbine array, specifically the turbine spacing and capacity, on the hydro-environmental impacts of the array. The hydrodynamic regime of the Shannon Estuary, a highly energetic estuary on the west coast of Ireland, was simulated using a depth integrated 2D hydro-environmental model. The numerical model was modified to incorporate the mechanics of energy extraction using linear momentum actuator disc theory and the impacts of a multiple device array were simulated. Three different array configurations were examined with turbine spacings of 0.5, 2 and 5 rotor diameters. The model results demonstrate that flows are attenuated inside the array and accelerated around the array. Water levels are also affected with a reduction in tidal range within, and upstream of, the array and a delay in high and low tides upstream of the array. The magnitude and extent of the observed impacts are found to reduce as the density and capacity are increased and that the impacts of large-scale arrays can be acceptable if deployed using a low density spacing of 5 rotor diameters.","author":["Nash, S.","Olbert, A.","Hartnett, M.","Fallon, D."],"organization":["National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2014-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.608904000000","-9.223261000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1715","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimating-bird-bat-fatality-wind-farms-formula-based-methods-models-assess-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60351-3_7","title":"Estimating Bird and Bat Fatality at Wind Farms: From Formula-Based Methods to Models to Assess Impact Significance","description":"The impact of the operation of wind farms on birds and bats in terms of true fatality is still unknown. However, fatality numbers can be estimated using statistical methods that have improved over recent years, aiming to provide a closer representation of the real ecological conditions. To assess which statistical methods have been used to estimate bird and bat fatality in the Portuguese context, we analysed 225 wind farm fatality monitoring reports, published between 2005 and 2015, and concluded that the methodology is not standardised. Importantly, the estimators used to calculate fatality differ amongst the environmental specialists and over time. These findings can hamper an integrated analysis of the impacts caused by wind farms at a national scale and bias the importance of cumulative impacts. We also reviewed the most recently published fatality estimators in order to better understand their applicability to the Portuguese private environmental consultancy context. Our analysis identified the criteria that most influences the implementation of a valuable fatality estimation methodology and assembled a list of considerations that a best practice guidelines protocol can be based upon for application at both the regional and national scale.","author":["Bispo, R.","Bernardino, J.","Marqu\u00e9s, J.","Rodrigues, L.","Silva, M.","Santos, J."],"organization":["Bioinsight","Instituto da Conserva\u00e7\u00e3o da Natureza e das Florestas","University of Aveiro","University of St Andrews","University of Lisbon","University of Evora"],"originationDate":"2017-09-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1716","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/overview-methods-assess-bird-bat-collision-risk-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60351-3_4","title":"An Overview on Methods to Assess Bird and Bat Collision Risk in Wind Farms","description":"Wind farms present several impacts on wildlife. However, the scientific community, as well as environmental practitioners, have focused most of their attention on bat and bird collision and fatality impacts. As a result, an increasing variety of methods have been developed to assess the risk of collision in wind farms during both the pre-construction phase and the post-construction phase. This chapter provides a review of the main methodologies that are currently used to address collision risk in wind farms (collision risk models, indexes and other tools) at both the international level, as well as in Portugal. In this review, a brief description of each analysed methodology is presented, and a comparison of limitations, advantages and disadvantages is made, in light of Environmental Impact Assessments studies. Final remarks are given with regards to the Portuguese context in terms of methodologies currently in use, and new tendencies to assess collision risk. A case study is presented demonstrating a simple and practical method for estimating collision risk. Developed in Portugal and in use since 2007, this method is currently used to relate risky behaviour of the common kestrel observed across a Portuguese wind farm with turbines where higher levels of fatalities of the species occur.\n\nThis is a book chapter in Biodiversity and Wind Farms in Portugal: Current Knowledge and Insights for an Integrated Impact Assessment Process.","author":["Mascarenhas, M.","Rodrigues, S.","Rosa, L."],"organization":["Bioinsight","New University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2017-09-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1717","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impact-assessment-methods-overview-process-wind-farms-different-phases","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60351-3_3","title":"Environmental Impact Assessment Methods: An Overview of the Process for Wind Farms\u0027 Different Phases - From Pre-construction to Operation","description":"Although significant progress has been made into better understanding interactions between biodiversity and wind farms, providing accurate and reliable assessment methods that allow studying the real effects of these projects is of major importance. Focusing on the Portuguese wind energy development current status and by referring to other international guidelines, the currently applied general procedures were compiled in a step-by-step process, from pre-project development to the operation phases. Today, legislation stipulates that impact assessment is mandatory for most of the energy development projects in Portugal, including wind energy. Wind farm impact assessment starts\u2014in most cases\u2014with baseline studies to allow prediction of the main impacts expected on wildlife, as well as the presence of endangered species and\/or landscape features. This may lead to the need for layout adjustment or the definition of mitigation measures on site. When a project is approved, even if it is assumed that the major impacts have been identified and mitigated, that does not mean that it is free of negative effects. It is of major importance that the real impacts are evaluated during construction and operation phases based on the methods applied during pre-construction. In addition, the establishment of a reference area to compare with the wind farm situation is fundamental. These temporal and spatial features should be assessed by a before-after-control-impact design. A basis of the sampling and data collection methods is also addressed in this chapter according to most commonly targeted biodiversity (fauna and flora). Techniques vary from standard field surveys by one or more observers to the use of less common and more recent technologies.  This is a book chapter in Biodiversity and Wind Farms in Portugal: Current Knowledge and Insights for an Integrated Impact Assessment Process.","author":["Marqu\u00e9s, J.","Mascarenhas, M.","Marques, A.","Ramalho, R.","Santos, J.","Neves, T."],"organization":["Bioinsight","New University of Lisbon","University of Porto"],"originationDate":"2017-09-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1718","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-shore-wind-farms-wildlife-communities-direct-fatalities-indirect-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60351-3_2","title":"Impacts of On-shore Wind Farms in Wildlife Communities: Direct Fatalities and Indirect Impacts (Behavioural and Habitat Effects)","description":"In addition to its immense environmental benefits, the great expansion of wind energy generates simultaneous concerns about its adverse impacts. The impacts have been identified for human populations, landscape and wildlife, but, due to direct fatality, birds and bats are the groups for which scientists are most concerned. Due to renewable energy goals, Portugal has witnessed a great development of wind energy in recent years, with a substantial part of its mountainous areas occupied by on-shore wind turbines. In this chapter we present a literature review on the major impacts that wind energy has on birds and bats, but also in terrestrial mammals, because of the evidence of disturbance and\/or displacement of more sensitive species, mostly during the operation phase. Despite there are few published data, we focus the research on Portuguese examples. Some considerations of evaluation of the impacts and cumulative impacts are also made.\n\nThis is a book chapter in Biodiversity and Wind Farms in Portugal: Current Knowledge and Insights for an Integrated Impact Assessment Process.","author":["Pereira, P.","Mesquita, S.","Salgueiro, N."],"organization":["Bioinsight"],"originationDate":"2017-09-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1719","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-industry-portugal-its-impacts-wildlife-special-focus-spatial-temporal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60351-3_1","title":"Wind Industry in Portugal and Its Impacts on Wildlife: Special Focus on Spatial and Temporal Distribution on Bird and Bat Fatalities","description":"Exponential growth of the wind energy industry in Portugal entails a non-negligible pressure on wildlife, especially on bird and bat communities that must be studied. In this chapter, a general characterisation of the wind energy industry in mainland Portugal is provided, in association with a quantitative analysis of the direct impacts identified over the past 10\u00a0years. Aiming to identify the species most affected by wind turbine-caused fatalities, we analysed the reports of 44 monitoring programmes pertaining to wind farms in their operational phase conducted between 2005 and 2015. The information gathered from these reports, combined with the general characteristics of the territory and the timeframe when fatalities happened, highlighted both spatial and temporal fatality hotspots for the bird and bat communities. Our analysis revealed a higher fatality concentration in northern Portugal and, although several of the affected species are widespread and of least conservation concern, they are migratory and have known fatalities in neighbouring countries. Such findings emphasise the importance of studying the impacts at a regional scale, using a single framework, since the cumulative effects on the populations\u2019 viability are currently unknown and require further investigation.\n\nThis is a book chapter in Biodiversity and Wind Farms in Portugal: Current Knowledge and Insights for an Integrated Impact Assessment Process.","author":["Marqu\u00e9s, J.","Mascarenhas, M.","Rodrigues, S.","Ferriera, R."],"organization":["Bioinsight","New University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2017-09-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1720","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/emissions-corrosion-protection-systems-offshore-wind-farms-evaluation-potential-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X18306301","title":"Emissions from corrosion protection systems of offshore wind farms: Evaluation of the potential impact on the marine environment","description":"Offshore wind energy is a fast growing sector of renewable energies worldwide. This will change the marine environment and thus, a wide range of environmental impacts of offshore wind farms are subject of current research. Here we present an overview about chemical emissions from corrosion protection systems, discuss their relevance and potential impact to the marine environment, and suggest strategies to reduce their emissions. Corrosion is a general problem for offshore infrastructures and corrosion protection systems are necessary to maintain the structural integrity. These systems are often in direct contact with seawater and have different potentials for emissions, e.g. galvanic anodes emitting substantial amounts of metals. Organic coatings may release organic substances due to weathering and\/or leaching. Current assumptions suggesting a low environmental impact, but monitoring data is not sufficient to assess the environmental impact of this new source.","author":["Kirchgeorg, T.","Weinberg, I.","H\u00f6rnig, M.","Schmid, M.","Brockmeyer, B."],"organization":["German Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH)","German Federal Waterways Engineering and Research Institute (BAW)"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind","Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Chemicals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1721","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-tidal-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60156-4_43","title":"Wave and Tidal Energy","description":"Wave and tidal energy is a visible expression of the power of nature. Ambition to convert the natural energy bound up in marine systems into something useable by mankind goes back a long way and practical measures date from at least the 1940s. In the twenty-first Century efforts have increased enormously in response to the search for clean energy sources, a reduction in emissions of greenhouse gases and the mitigation of the effects of climate change. Hundreds of millions of Euros have been invested in research and development and much has been learned. However, the solutions to a viable Ocean Energy industry remain elusive. The outstanding challenges are daunting in scale:\n\u00a0\nThe engineering challenge in the search for a device technology which will convert marine energy to usable energy with a degree of operational and economic efficiency.\n\n\nThe operational challenge of installing, servicing and maintaining thousands of floating and fixed structures in high energy marine environments.\n\n\nThe environmental and social challenge of understanding and managing the ecosystem and spatial impacts of such a heavy industrial intrusion into mainly coastal waters.\nThere have been recent setbacks with the failure of companies promoting what seemed to be promising technical solutions. However, the level of investment in research remains high involving ten or more nations including China, Japan, the United States and the United Kingdom. It must be expected that the ambition will be realised in the medium term. This chapter explores the state of the industry and the management challenges it reveals. The central challenge for the planning and management of a future wave and tidal energy industry is to move from a very early developmental stage in the lifecycle to a mature activity in a measured and sustainable way. Best practice in management and the step by step approach to precaution is examined.\n\nChapter from the\u00a0Handbook on Marine Environment Protection: Science, Impacts, and Sustainable Management.","author":["Johnson, K.","Kerr, S."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1722","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimating-habitat-loss-due-wind-turbine-avoidance-bats-implications-european-siting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320718305469","title":"Estimating habitat loss due to wind turbine avoidance by bats: Implications for European siting guidance","description":"Wind energy is rapidly growing as a renewable source of energy but is not neutral for wildlife, especially bats.Whereas most studies have focused on bat mortality through collision, very few have quanti\ufb01ed the loss of habitat use resulting from the potential negative impact of wind turbines, and none of them for hub heights higher than 55 m. Such impacts could durably a\ufb00ect populations, creating a need for improvement of knowledge to integrate this concern in implementation strategies. We quanti\ufb01ed the impact of wind turbines at di\ufb00erent distances on the activity of 11 bat taxa and 2 guilds. We compared bat activity at hedgerows (207 sites) located at a distance of 0\u20131000 m from wind turbines (n = 151) of 29 wind farms in an agricultural region in the autumn (overall 193,980 bat passes) using GLMMs. We found a signi\ufb01cant negative e\ufb00ect of proximity to turbines on activity for 3 species (Barbastella barbastellus, Nyctalus leisleiri, Pipistrellus pipistrellus), 2 species-groups (Myotis spp., Plecotus spp.) and 2 guilds (fast-\ufb02ying and gleaner). Bat activity within 1000 m of wind turbines by gleaners and fast-\ufb02ying bats is reduced by 53.8% and 19.6%, respectively. Our study highlighted that European re-commendations (at least 200 m from any wooded edge) to limit mortality events likely strongly underestimate the loss of bat activity. The current situation is particularly worrying, with 89% of 909 turbines established in a region that does not comply with recommendations, which themselves are far from su\ufb03cient to limit the loss of habitat use.","author":["Julliard, R.","Kerbiriou, C.","Bas, Y.","Barre, K.","Le Viol, I."],"organization":["Sorbonne University"],"originationDate":"2018-08-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1723","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/efficient-unstructured-mesh-generation-marine-renewable-energy-applications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117309205","title":"Efficient unstructured mesh generation for marine renewable energy applications","description":"Renewable energy is the cornerstone of preventing dangerous climate change whilst maintaining a robust energy supply. Tidal energy will arguably play a critical role in the renewable energy portfolio as it is both predictable and reliable, and can be put in place across the globe. However, installation may impact the local and regional ecology via changes in tidal dynamics, sediment transport pathways or bathymetric changes. In order to mitigate these effects, tidal energy devices need to be modelled, to predict hydrodynamic changes. Robust mesh generation is a fundamental component required for developing simulations with high accuracy. However, mesh generation for coastal domains can be an elaborate procedure. Here, we describe an approach combining mesh generators with Geographical Information Systems. We demonstrate robustness and ef\ufb01ciency by constructing a mesh with which to examine the potential environmental impact of a tidal turbine farm installation in the Orkney Islands.The mesh is then used with two well-validated ocean models, to compare their \ufb02ow predictions with and without a turbine array. The results demonstrate that it is possible to create an easy-to-use tool to generate high-quality meshes for combined coastal engineering, here tidal turbines, and coastal ocean simulations","author":["Kramer, S.","Hill, J.","Avdis, A.","Piggott, M.","Candy, A."],"organization":["Imperial College London","Delft University of Technology","University of York"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-11-18 10:56:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1724","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-implications-offshore-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/9781315666877\/chapters\/10.4324\/9781315666877-9","title":"Environmental implications of offshore energy","description":"The marine environment has long been a major source of energy across the globe and will continue to be central to future energy provision to meet growing human demands. Historically, energy has been extracted in the form of fossil fuels from below the seabed, but more recently there has been an increase towards harnessing renewable energy resources. While these industrial-scale activities generate power in different ways, they can all potentially degrade the surrounding environment. At present, understanding how the localised extraction of energy affects the marine environment is highly uncertain. Although some information exists, the available evidence is patchy and incomplete such that optimal decision making is difficult. Furthermore, most of the available evidence relates to direct effects on a few particular species or habitats. There is also a tendency to report only the negative effects, principally driven by targeted environmental impact assessments. Unanswered questions often remain about whether the effects recorded are biologically meaningful. To determine if a negative impact has occurred requires considering both direct and indirect effects, identifying pathways of effects, and taking into account the spatial and temporal scales over which changes occur. Properly considering the demonstrable effects of predicted impacts over a wide range of spatial and temporal scales is fundamental to the development and understanding of cumulative environmental effects arising from offshore energy development. Accounting for cumulative effects is essential for the sustainable use of the marine environment and thus must be a central consideration in marine spatial planning processes. The results of cumulative impacts assessments underpin decision making by licensors, regulators and stakeholders. A robust and transparent process when assessing interactions and making planning decisions associated with cumulative environmental impacts will reduce conflict surrounding offshore energy development. As many countries aim to increase offshore energy development and improve the efficiency of the associated licencing processes, marine spatial planning will play a pivotal role by providing integrated process for the mitigation of user-nature as well as user-user conflicts.\n\nThis is a book chapter in\u00a0Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning.\u00a0","author":["Wilson, B.","Gill, A.","Judd, A.","Jones, A.","Jude, S.","Birchenough, S.","Payo-Payo, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1725","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reducing-wind-curtailment-through-transmission-expansion-wind-vision-future","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrel.gov\/docs\/fy17osti\/67240.pdf","title":"Reducing Wind Curtailment through Transmission Expansion in a Wind Vision Future","description":"The Department of Energy\u2019s 2015 Wind Vision study analyzed an aggressive scenario in which wind power served 35% of U.S. electricity consumption in 2050 and showed the potential for wind energy to provide substantial health, environmental, and economic benefits. Using a higher fidelity modeling framework we build on this research by assessing the operational feasibility of a similar high wind future in the western United States. For this analysis, we use a commercial unit commitment and economic dispatch model to simulate grid operations and transmission flows with high spatial and temporal resolution. Our detailed simulations affirm the Wind Vision conclusions that effective power system operation can be achieved with wind penetrations above 35%.\n\nAlthough our analysis identifies no reliability issues in any of the high-wind scenarios, we find that transmission expansion is likely to be critical. Absent significant upgrades to the western transmission network, we find that a substantial amount of renewable energy cannot be utilized by the system, and therefore is curtailed. This curtailment results from an inability to transmit power from where it is generated to where it is needed, and could degrade the potential for wind power to reduce fuel costs and emissions. To assess the value of transmission to mitigate wind curtailment, we model a suite of transmission expansion scenarios. We find that wind curtailment could be reduced by approximately 50% under a scenario adding 10.5 GW of new transmission, based on four proposed projects (Transmission 1 in Figure E1). This avoided wind curtailment could lower annual production costs and reduce carbon dioxide emissions substantially. Greater transmission expansion was found to yield further benefits, although the marginal benefits of these new lines were found to have diminishing returns (Transmission 2 and 3 in Figure E1). Overall, these results suggest that the power system can be operated with more than 35% wind penetration (and 12% solar penetration), but that transmission expansion is necessary to fully utilize the available renewable energy.\n\nResults from and implications of our analysis are summarized as follows:\nEffective power system operation can be achieved with annual wind penetrations greater than 35%.\nThis finding helps affirm conclusions from the Wind Vision study that variability is manageable and the grid will be operable under a high renewable energy future.\nHigh fidelity nodal modeling found no hours of unmet load or unserved reserves. Although this confirms some aspects of grid reliability, this is not a full reliability study, which would include analysis of dynamic stability and frequency response. Other analyses have focused on these questions for high renewable penetrations in the western United States.\nTransmission expansion will play a vital role in allowing for efficient usage of renewable resources.\n\nRenewable curtailment can be mitigated by transmission expansion. Reducing curtailment also effectively reduces generation costs and carbon dioxide emissions.\nIf transmission is not built to support new wind generation in the western United States, significant renewable energy curtailment (15.5%) could be an issue.\nCurtailment can be reduced by about half (to 7.8%) based only on proposedtransmission projects.\nFurther transmission buildout continues to reduce curtailment and generation costs but with diminishing returns.\n\nTransmission can provide flexibility for electric power system operation. Inefficient scheduling practices can reduce this flexibility; these practices could include fixed bilateral contracts or the lack of ability to adjust schedules in real-time operations. Inflexibility in transmission scheduling can increase costs and curtailment.\nGrid simulations showed that inflexible transmission utilization could double curtailment levels compared to a scenario with optimal transmission utilization. Generation costs also increased as a result of increased dispatch of fossil-fired units.\n\n\nView presentation on this topic here as part of NREL\u0027s Grid Integration Webinar Series.","author":["Jorgenson, J.","Mai, T.","Brinkman, G."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-24 06:41:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NREL_TP_6A20_67240.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1726","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparing-methods-suitable-monitoring-marine-mammals-low-visibility-conditions-during","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X17308809","title":"Comparing methods suitable for monitoring marine mammals in low visibility conditions during seismic surveys","description":"Loud sound emitted during offshore industrial activities can impact marine mammals. Regulations typically prescribe marine mammal monitoring before and\/or during these activities to implement mitigation measures that minimise potential acoustic impacts. Using seismic surveys under low visibility conditions as a case study, we review which monitoring methods are suitable and compare their relative strengths and weaknesses. Passive acoustic monitoring has been implemented as either a complementary or alternative method to visual monitoring in low visibility conditions. Other methods such as RADAR, active sonar and thermal infrared have also been tested, but are rarely recommended by regulatory bodies. The efficiency of the monitoring method(s) will depend on the animal behaviour and environmental conditions, however, using a combination of complementary systems generally improves the overall detection performance. We recommend that the performance of monitoring systems, over a range of conditions, is explored in a modelling framework for a variety of species.","author":["Gordon, J.","Gillespie, D.","Thomas, L.","Tollit, D.","Marques, T.","Miller, B.","Verfuss, U.","Plunkett, R.","Theriault, J.","Zitterbart, D.","Hubert, P."],"organization":["SMRU Consulting","Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","University of St Andrews","Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1727","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-energy-exploitation-mediterranean-region-steps-forward-challenges","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.frontiersin.org\/articles\/10.3389\/fenrg.2018.00109\/full","title":"Marine Energy Exploitation in the Mediterranean Region: Steps Forward and Challenges","description":"This works aims to describe current perspectives for marine energy exploitation in the Mediterranean basin, highlighting challenges and opportunities as well as the factors that still limit its market deployment. Technologies for the conversion of Marine Energy (ME) into electricity are now ready for full-scale deployment in farms of devices, making the final step from demonstration to operability and commercial exploitation. Although marine energy is more abundant along the Atlantic and Nordic European coasts, significant resources are also available in the Mediterranean Sea, opening up new perspectives for sustainable energy production in sensitive coastal areas and for the economic development of Southern Europe. The implementation of ME converters in the Mediterranean is in fact liable to induce significant technological advancements leading to product innovation, due to the local low energy levels which impose more restrictive constraints on device efficiency and environmental compatibility. In addition, the milder climate allows the testing of concepts and prototypes in the natural environment at more affordable costs, lowering capital risks for new and innovative small and medium enterprises. Research institutions and industrial players in Mediterranean countries have already taken up the challenge, despite the numerous limiting factors that still need to be removed. In particular, the ME sector adds up to the many different traditional maritime activities and to the new ocean-related industries that are developing, potentially exacerbating the competition for the use of marine space in the Mediterranean region and threatening its environmental status. The ME sector needs therefore to design suitable instruments to involve all the relevant stakeholders in a participative public debate as to how to best manage the maritime space. As the prospective sea use patterns are rapidly changing, an adequate international legal and policy framework needs to be designed for the coherent management of sea space, and Marine Spatial Planning needs to be finally implemented by EU Member States also in the Mediterranean area. To this end, the creation of transnational clusters of stakeholders is expected be an effective catalyzer, especially as they can foster the exchange of knowledge and best practices both across European countries and between the North and the South shore of the Mediterranean basin.","author":["Pisacane, G.","Sannino, G.","Carillo, A.","Struglia, M.","Bastianoni, S."],"organization":["National Agency for New Technologies, Energy and Sustainable Economic Development (ENEA)","Universit\u00e0 di Siena"],"originationDate":"2018-10-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.687514100000","6.083741500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MarineEnergyExploitationMediterraneanRegion_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1728","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/practical-implementation-auditory-time-frequency-weighting-marine-bioacoustics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0003682X18303967","title":"Practical implementation of auditory time and frequency weighting in marine bioacoustics","description":"Much effort is currently directed at describing the behavioral reactions of marine mammals following exposure to sound with the aim of deriving generalized thresholds and dose-response functions. The perceived loudness of a given sound is a candidate for a common metric for sound exposure. The loudness of a signal relates to various factors, including the stimulus duration and frequency content, and it can be approximated by an appropriate time and frequency weighting of the signal. Auditory frequency weighting is achieved by applying a frequency weighting function (band-pass filter), with a frequency response resembling the shape of an inverted audiogram. Temporal weighting may be achieved by computing the running rms-average (Leq) with a time constant that is comparable to that of the mammalian auditory system. The practical implementation of such weighting functions are presented in the form of Matlab functions. These functions generate output signals that are weighted according to current recommendations for different groups of marine mammals. With these functions, it is possible to derive the weighted peak Leq of a signal, which is likely to be a good proxy for the loudness of the signal. Ultimately, this weighted level is conjectured to be a predictor of behavioral response of marine mammals to the sound.","author":["Tougaard, J.","Beedholm, K."],"organization":["Aarhus University"],"originationDate":"2019-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1729","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimating-cetacean-density-abundance-central-western-mediterranean-sea-through-aerial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0967064517301418","title":"Estimating cetacean density and abundance in the Central and Western Mediterranean Sea through aerial surveys: Implications for management","description":"Systematic, effective monitoring of animal population parameters underpins successful conservation strategy and wildlife management, but it is often neglected in many regions, including much of the Mediterranean Sea. Nonetheless, a series of systematic multispecies aerial surveys was carried out in the seas around Italy to gather important baseline information on cetacean occurrence, distribution and abundance. The monitored areas included the Pelagos Sanctuary, the Tyrrhenian Sea, portions of the Seas of Corsica and Sardinia, the Ionian Seas as well as the Gulf of Taranto. Overall, approximately 48,000\u00a0km were flown in either spring, summer and winter between 2009\u20132014, covering an area of 444,621\u00a0km2. The most commonly observed species were the striped dolphin and the fin whale, with 975 and 83 recorded sightings, respectively. Other sighted cetacean species were the common bottlenose dolphin, the Risso\u0027s dolphin, the sperm whale, the pilot whale and the Cuvier\u0027s beaked whale. Uncorrected model- and design-based estimates of density and abundance for striped dolphins and fin whales were produced, resulting in a best estimate (model-based) of around 95,000 striped dolphins (CV=11.6%; 95% CI=92,900\u2013120,300) occurring in the Pelagos Sanctuary, Central Tyrrhenian and Western Seas of Corsica and Sardinia combined area in summer 2010. Estimates were also obtained for each individual study region and year. An initial attempt to estimate perception bias for striped dolphins is also provided. The preferred summer 2010 uncorrected best estimate (design-based) for the same areas for fin whales was around 665 (CV=33.1%; 95% CI=350\u20131260). Estimates are also provided for the individual study regions and years. The results represent baseline data to develop efficient, long-term, systematic monitoring programmes, essential to evaluate trends, as required by a number of national and international frameworks, and stress the need to ensure that surveys are undertaken regularly and at a sufficient spatial scale. The management implications of the results are discussed also in light of a possible decline of fin whales abundance over the period from the mid-1990s to the present. Further work to understand changes in distribution and to allow for improved spatial models is emphasized.","author":["Donovan, G.","Burt, L.","Panigada, S.","Lauriano, G.","Pierantonio, N.","Ca\u00f1adas, A.","V\u00e1zquez, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.124408400000","12.599590600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1730","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fine-scale-hydrodynamics-influence-spatio-temporal-distribution-harbour-porpoises","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0079661114001256","title":"Fine-scale hydrodynamics influence the spatio-temporal distribution of harbour porpoises at a coastal hotspot","description":"The coastal Runnelstone Reef, off southwest Cornwall (UK), is characterised by complex topography and strong tidal flows and is a known high-density site for harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena); a European protected species. Using a multidisciplinary dataset including: porpoise sightings from a multi-year land-based survey, Acoustic Doppler Current Profiling (ADCP), vertical profiling of water properties and high-resolution bathymetry; we investigate how interactions between tidal flow and topography drive the fine-scale porpoise spatio-temporal distribution at the site. Porpoise sightings were distributed non-uniformly within the survey area with highest sighting density recorded in areas with steep slopes and moderate depths. Greater numbers of sightings were recorded during strong westward (ebbing) tidal flows compared to strong eastward (flooding) flows and slack water periods. ADCP and Conductivity Temperature Depth (CTD) data identified fine-scale hydrodynamic features, associated with cross-reef tidal flows in the sections of the survey area with the highest recorded densities of porpoises. We observed layered, vertically sheared flows that were susceptible to the generation of turbulence by shear instability. Additionally, the intense, oscillatory near surface currents led to hydraulically controlled flow that transitioned from subcritical to supercritical conditions; indicating that highly turbulent and energetic hydraulic jumps were generated along the eastern and western slopes of the reef. The depression and release of isopycnals in the lee of the reef during cross-reef flows revealed that the flow released lee waves during upslope currents at specific phases of the tidal cycle when the highest sighting rates were recorded. The results of this unique, fine-scale field study provide new insights into specific hydrodynamic features, produced through tidal forcing, that may be important for creating predictable foraging opportunities for porpoises at a local scale. Information on the functional mechanisms linking porpoise distribution to static and dynamic physical habitat variables is extremely valuable to the monitoring and management of the species within the context of European conservation policies and marine renewable energy infrastructure development.","author":["Hosegood, P.","Jones, A.","Embling, C.","Wynn, R.","De Boer, M.","Butler-Cowdry, S."],"organization":["National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","Plymouth University","IMARES - Wageningen UR","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2014-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["49.975040800000","-5.589996700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1731","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-wave-energy-overview-research-oregon-state-university","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/document\/5208333","title":"Ocean wave energy overview and research at Oregon State University","description":"The solutions to today\u0027s energy challenges need to be explored through alternative, renewable and clean energy sources to enable a diverse national energy resource plan. An extremely abundant and promising source of energy exists in the world\u0027s oceans. Ocean energy exists in the forms of wave, tidal, marine currents, thermal (temperature gradient) and salinity. Among these forms, significant opportunities and benefits have been identified in the area of ocean wave energy extraction, i.e., harnessing the motion of the ocean waves, and converting that motion into electrical energy. This paper presents the fundamentals of ocean wave energy, and also a summary of the wave energy research being conducted at Oregon State University. This paper is intended to serve as an introduction to wave energy for scientists and engineers, particularly those with a wind energy background.","author":["Brekken, T.","von Jouanne, A.","Han, H."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2009-06-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1732","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/applying-simple-model-estimating-likelihood-collision-marine-mammals-tidal-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/marineenergyjournal.org\/imej\/article\/view\/21","title":"Applying a simple model for estimating the likelihood of collision of marine mammals with tidal turbines","description":"As tidal turbine deployments continue at test sites and in commercial areas, the potential risk for injury or death of marine mammals from colliding with rotating turbine blades continues to confound efficient consenting (permitting) of devices. Direct observation of collisions is technically very challenging and costly. Estimates of collision risk to date have been derived from complex collision risk models that depend on estimates of the number of marine mammals found in the area. Using a simple collision model, the risk of collision was examined at three real-world sites, each of which featured an indigenous marine mammal. Two different turbine designs were examined at each site to extend the range of the estimates. The results of the model runs allow for comparison of risk at a range of tidal sites for a variety of the marine mammals thought to be at potential risk.","author":["Copping, A.","Grear, M."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Copping-Grear-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1733","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecological-impact-airborne-wind-energy-technology-current-state-knowledge-future","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-981-10-1947-0_28","title":"Ecological Impact of Airborne Wind Energy Technology: Current State of Knowledge and Future Research Agenda","description":"In this first review on the subject we describe the ecological impact of airborne wind energy technologies in general, with a particular focus on the rigid wing system developed by Ampyx Power. The chapter outlines a framework consisting of disturbance, ecological sensitivity, impact and legal aspects. We conclude that between 2\u201313 birds will collide annually with the autonomous aircraft alone. A challenging aspect is to estimate the mortality caused by the tether. Based on data from studies on power lines we find that a tether, that is one kilometer long and active all year round, will cause approximately 11 bird victims per year. For a tethered aircraft active only during the day and only with sufficiently strong wind an estimate of 5\u201315 bird fatalities per year will be realistic. This estimate is comparable to the number of fatalities found at average wind turbines. These figures can be ten times higher or lower depending on the bird activity at the specific deployment site. We provided a model for the mortality based on the specific characteristics of a bird species. A challenging future task will be the validation of this model considering that evidence suggest that birds can survive an encounter with the tether.","author":["Brenninkmeijer, A.","Klop, E.","Bruinzeel, L.","Bosch, J."],"organization":["Altenburg \u0026 Wymenga"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1734","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/costs-chronic-noise-exposure-terrestrial-organisms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0169534709002614","title":"The Costs of Chronic Noise Exposure for Terrestrial Organisms","description":"Growth in transportation networks, resource extraction, motorized recreation and urban development is responsible for chronic noise exposure in most terrestrial areas, including remote wilderness sites. Increased noise levels reduce the distance and area over which acoustic signals can be perceived by animals. Here, we review a broad range of findings that indicate the potential severity of this threat to diverse taxa, and recent studies that document substantial changes in foraging and anti-predator behavior, reproductive success, density and community structure in response to noise. Effective management of protected areas must include noise assessment, and research is needed to further quantify the ecological consequences of chronic noise exposure in terrestrial environments.","author":["Barber, J.","Crooks, K.","Fristrup, K."],"organization":["Colorado State University","National Park Service"],"originationDate":"2010-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1735","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/information-gaps-understanding-effects-noise-fishes-invertebrates","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s11160-014-9369-3","title":"Information gaps in understanding the effects of noise on fishes and invertebrates","description":"The expansion of shipping and aquatic industrial activities in recent years has led to growing concern about the effects of man-made sounds on aquatic life. Sources include (but are not limited to) pleasure boating, fishing, the shipping of goods, offshore exploration for oil and gas, dredging, construction of bridges, harbors, oil and gas platforms, wind farms and other renewable energy devices, and the use of sonar by commercial and military vessels. There are very substantial gaps in our understanding of the effects of these sounds, especially for fishes and invertebrates. Currently, it is almost impossible to come to clear conclusions on the nature and levels of man-made sound that have potential to cause effects upon these animals. In order to develop a better understanding of effects of man-made sound, this paper identifies the most critical information needs and data gaps on the effects of various sounds on fishes, fisheries, and invertebrates resulting from the use of sound-generating devices. It highlights the major issues and discusses the information currently available on each of the information needs and data gaps. The paper then identifies the critical questions concerning the effects of man-made sounds on aquatic life for which answers are not readily available and articulates the types of information needed to fulfill each of these drivers for information\u2014the key information gaps. Finally, a list of priorities for research and development is presented.","author":["Hawkins, A.","Popper, A.","Pembroke, A."],"organization":["Normandeau Associates Inc","University of Maryland"],"originationDate":"2015-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1737","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reindeer-windpower","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.naturvardsverket.se\/Om-Naturvardsverket\/Publikationer\/ISBN\/6500\/978-91-620-6564-5\/","title":"Reindeer and windpower","description":"This repoert is in Swedish  In the track of ever-expanding new infrastructure, such as wind power, roads and power lines, it becomes increasingly important to map and understand how free-ranging animals and wildlife respond. During the past decades, human \u2013 Rangifer interactions have been assessed in over a hundred studies, with a strong bias on wild reindeer and caribou, although more recently also studies on domesticated reindeer in Norway, Finland, Sweden and Russia have been done with similar results. To clarify further the possible responses of domes-ticated reindeer to various disturbance sources, a review was made of over 15 existing disturbance studies of domesticated reindeer, we also discuss the effect of domestication on reindeer. The review shows the same pattern of avoidance in domesticated reindeer as for wild reindeer and caribou despite the domestication process. Sami reindeer husbandry today is an extensive form of pastoralism, which has led to a low degree of tameness among the reindeer. Domesticated reindeer can avoid infrastructure and human activity up to 12 km from the disturbance source and the avoided distance may shift between seasons and years and type of disturbance source, as well as diminish during periods of extreme starvation or insect harassment, similar to observa-tion in wild reindeer and caribou. To get an overall picture of how the rein-deer use their grazing land, it is therefore important to study large-scale and long-term habitat use of the reindeer whether they are domesticated or not.","author":["Skarin, A.","Nellemann, C.","Lundqvist, H.","R\u00f6nneg\u00e5rd, L.","Sandstr\u00f6m, P."],"organization":["Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","Dalarna University","Vindval"],"originationDate":"2015-05-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["64.967150100000","14.997503300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Skarinetal2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1738","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/windpower-reindeer","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.naturvardsverket.se\/Documents\/publikationer6400\/978-91-620-6799-1.pdf","title":"Windpower and reindeer","description":"In this report, we have summarized existing knowledge about the effects of wind power on reindeer. The effects of technical installations and disturbance in general and the effects of wind power plants in particular have been studied by different research groups. Their efforts have improved our knowledge about the effects of such installations on reindeer and reindeer husbandry. In some cases, various projects reported contrasting results. We have tried to explain the results from the respective investigations.  This report is in Swedish - Abstract Kunskapsprogrammet Vindval \u00e4r ett samarbete mellan Energi myndig\u00adheten och Naturv\u00e5rdsverket med uppgiften att ta fram och f\u00f6rmedla veten\u00adskapligt baserade fakta om vindkraftens effekter p\u00e5 m\u00e4nniska, natur och milj\u00f6. Programmets tv\u00e5 f\u00f6rsta etapper 2005\u20132014 resulterade i ett 30\u00adtal forsknings rapporter samt fyra s\u00e5 kallade syntesarbeten. I syntesrapporterna samman st\u00e4ller och bed\u00f6mer experter de samlade forskningsresultaten och erfarenheterna av vindkraftens effekter nationellt samt internationellt inom fyra omr\u00e5den: M\u00e4nniskors intressen, f\u00e5glar och fladderm\u00f6ss, marint liv och d\u00e4ggdjur p\u00e5 land. Resultaten har bidragit till underlag f\u00f6r milj\u00f6konsekvens\u00adbeskrivningar samt planerings\u00ad och tillst\u00e5ndsprocesser i samband med etable\u00adring av vindkraftsanl\u00e4ggningar. I Vindvals tredje etapp, som inleddes 2014 och p\u00e5g\u00e5r till 2018, ing\u00e5r \u00e4ven att f\u00f6rmedla erfarenheter och ny kunskap fr\u00e5n parker som \u00e4r i drift. Resultat fr\u00e5n programmet ska ocks\u00e5 komma till anv\u00e4nd\u00adning i tillsyn och kontrollprogram samt myndigheters v\u00e4gledning.Liksom tidigare st\u00e4ller Vindval h\u00f6ga krav vid vetenskaplig granskning av forskningsans\u00f6kningar och forskningsresultat, samt vid beslut om att god\u00adk\u00e4nna rapporter och publicering av projektens resultat. Denna rapport har finansierats av Vindval. Vetenskaplig granskning har genomf\u00f6rts i enlighet med NINA:s (Norsk Institutt f\u00f6r Naturforskning) rutiner. Relevansgranskning har skett inom Vindval.Rapporten har skrivits av Olav Strand (NINA), Jonathan E. Colman och Sindre Eftest\u00f8l (Fakultet for milj\u00f8vitenskap og naturforvaltning, Norges milj\u00f8\u00adog biovitenskapelige universitet och Institutt for bio veten skap, Universitetet i Oslo), Per Sandstr\u00f6m och Anna Skarin (Sveriges Lant bruks universitet), och J\u00f6rn Thomassen (NINA). Rapporten har publicerats p\u00e5 norska i NINA:s rapportserie (rapport 1305, 2017).","author":["Colman, J.","Skarin, A.","Sandstr\u00f6m, P.","Strand, O.","Eftest\u00f8l, S.","Thomassen, J."],"organization":["Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","University of Oslo","Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences","Vindval"],"originationDate":"2018-03-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Strandetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1739","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-power-infrastructure-development-semi-domesticated-reindeer-reindeer","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.google.com\/url?sa=t\u0026rct=j\u0026q=\u0026esrc=s\u0026source=web\u0026cd=1\u0026ved=2ahUKEwiNjpX56vndAhVrrFQKHfhvDb4QFjAAegQIAxAC\u0026url=https%3A%2F%2Fpub.epsilon.slu.se%2F13562%2F7%2Fskarin_a_et_al_160818.pdf\u0026usg=AOvVaw3RUTValXj1D3txhH0U5p_p","title":"Impacts of wind power infrastructure development on semi-domesticated reindeer and reindeer husbandry","description":"This report is in Swedish  A surge in wind power development and associated road and powerline infrastructure is currently taking place worldwide. In Sweden and Fennoscandia, plans of large-scale wind power mill farms counting several hunderd windmills and their associated infrastructure of roads and power-lines are being implemented. In this report we describe how wind farms not only during construction, but also during operational phases impact reindeer and reindeer husbandry. Reindeer behaviour in relation to wind farms were studied in three different study areas in V\u00e4sterbotten County in northern Sweden. In the Mal\u00e5 reindeer herding community the effects of Storliden and Jokkmokkliden wind farms were assessed during the calving and sum-mer grazing period. In Vilhelmina Norra reindeer herding community, use of the winter grazing range around Stor-Rotliden wind farm was studied. Finally, the use of the L\u00f6gde\u00e5landets winter grazing range by reindeer from the Byrkije reindeer herding community from Norway was assessed in rela-tion to the Gabrielbergets wind farm.","author":["Skarin, A.","Nellemann, C.","Sandstr\u00f6m, P.","Alam, M.","Buhot, Y."],"organization":["Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences"],"originationDate":"2016-07-08","spatial":{"coordinates":["64.851125700000","15.692144700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Skarinetal2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1740","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/building-industries-sea-blue-growth-new-maritime-economy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.riverpublishers.com\/research_details.php?book_id=469","title":"Building Industries at Sea: \u0027Blue Growth\u0027 and the New Maritime Economy","description":"Throughout the world there is evidence of mounting interest in marine resources and new maritime industries to create jobs, economic growth and to help in the provision of energy and food security. Expanding populations, insecurity of traditional sources of supply and the effects of climate change add urgency to a perceived need to address and overcome the serious challenges of working in the maritime environment. Four promising areas of activity for \u0027Blue Growth\u0027 have been identified at European Union policy level including Aquaculture; Renewable Energy (offshore wind, wave and tide); Seabed Mining; and Blue Biotechnology. Work has started to raise the technological and investment readiness levels (TRLs and IRLs) of these prospective industries drawing on the experience of established maritime industries such as Offshore Oil and Gas; Shipping; Fisheries and Tourism. An accord has to be struck between policy makers and regulators on the one hand, anxious to direct research and business incentives in effective and efficient directions, and developers, investors and businesses on the other, anxious to reduce the risks of such potentially profitable but innovative investments.  The EU H2020 MARIBE (Marine Investment for the Blue Economy) funded project was designed to identify the key technical and non-technical challenges facing maritime industries and to place them into the social and economic context of the coastal and ocean economy. MARIBE went on to examine with companies, real projects for the combination of marine industry sectors into multi-use platforms (MUPs). The purpose of this book is to publish the detailed analysis of each prospective and established maritime business sector. Sector experts working to a common template explain what these industries are, how they work, their prospects to create wealth and employment, and where they currently stand in terms of innovation, trends and their lifecycle. The book goes on to describe progress with the changing regulatory and planning regimes in the European Sea Basins including the Caribbean where there are significant European interests. The book includes:    Experienced chapter authors from a truly multidisciplinary team of sector specialisms  First extensive study to compare and contrast traditional Blue Economy with Blue Growth  Complementary to EU and National policies for multi-use of maritime space","author":["Masters, I.","Johnson, K.","Dalton, G."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University","University College Cork","Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2018-01-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Johnsonetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1741","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-human-activity-infrastructure-disturb-domesticated-reindeer-need-reindeers","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00300-014-1499-5","title":"Do human activity and infrastructure disturb domesticated reindeer? The need for the reindeer\u0027s perspective","description":"In recent decades, human\u2013Rangifer (reindeer and caribou) interactions have increasingly been studied from a scienti\ufb01c perspective. Many of the studies have examined Norwegian wild  reindeer or caribou in North America. It is often questioned whether results from these studies can be applied to reindeer in managed herds, as these animals have been exposed to domestication and are also more used to humans. In order to examine the domesticated reindeer\u2019s reactions to various disturbance sources, we reviewed 18 studies of the effects of human activity and infrastructure on 12 populations of domesti-cated reindeer and compared these to studies on wild reindeer and caribou; based on this, we discuss the effects of domestication and tameness on reindeer responses to anthropogenic disturbance. We also consider the relevance of spatial and temporal scales and data collection methods when evaluating the results of these studies. The reviewed studies showed that domesticated reindeer exhibit avoid-ance behaviours up to 12 km away from infrastructure and sites of human activity and that the area they avoid may shift between seasons and years. Despite a long domesti-cation process, reindeer within Sami reindeer-herding systems exhibit similar patterns of large-scale avoidance of anthropogenic disturbance as wild Rangifer, although the strength of their response may sometimes differ. This is not surprising since current Sami reindeer husbandry repre-sents an extensive form of pastoralism, and the reindeer are not particularly tame. To obtain a true picture of how reindeer use their ranges, it is of fundamental importance to study the response pattern at a spatial and temporal scale that is relevant to the reindeer, whether domesticated or wild.","author":["Skarin, A.","\u00c5hman, B."],"organization":["Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences"],"originationDate":"2014-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Do-human-activity-and-infrastructure-distrub-domesticated-reindeer.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1742","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reindeer-habitat-use-relation-two-small-wind-farms-during-preconstruction-construction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/ece3.2941","title":"Reindeer habitat use in relation to two small wind farms, during preconstruction, construction, and operation","description":"Worldwide there is a rush toward wind power development and its associated infrastructure. In Fennoscandia, large\u2010scale wind farms comprising several hundred windmills are currently built in important grazing ranges used for S\u00e1mi reindeer husbandry. In this study, reindeer habitat use was assessed using reindeer fecal pellet group counts in relation to two relatively small wind farms, with 8 and 10 turbines, respectively. In 2009, 1,315 15\u2010m2 plots were established and pellet groups were counted and cleaned from the plots. This was repeated once a year in May, during preconstruction, construction, and operation of the wind farms, covering 6 years (2009\u20132014) of reindeer habitat use in the area. We modeled the presence\/absence of any pellets in a plot at both the local (wind farm site) and regional (reindeer calving to autumn range) scale with a hierarchical logistic regression, where spatial correlation was accounted for via random effects, using vegetation type, and the interaction between distance to wind turbine and time period as predictor variables. Our results revealed an absolute reduction in pellet groups by 66% and 86% around each wind farm, respectively, at local scale and by 61% at regional scale during the operation phase compared to the preconstruction phase. At the regional, scale habitat use declined close to the turbines in the same comparison. However, at the local scale, we observed increased habitat use close to the wind turbines at one of the wind farms during the operation phase. This may be explained by continued use of an important migration route close to the wind farm. The reduced use at the regional scale nevertheless suggests that there may be an overall avoidance of both wind farms during operation, but further studies of reindeer movement and behavior are needed to gain a better understanding of the mechanisms behind this suggested avoidance.","author":["Skarin, A.","Alam, M."],"organization":["Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences","Dalarna University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["65.233357200000","18.826584300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Reindeer-habitat-use-in-relation-to-two-small-wind-farms.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1743","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/out-sight-wind-turbine-reindeer-response-wind-farms-operation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/ece3.4476","title":"Out of Sight of Wind Turbine-Reindeer Response to Wind Farms in Operation","description":"To meet the expanding land use required for wind energy development, a better understanding of the effects on terrestrial animals\u2019 responses to such development is required. Using GPS-data from 50 freely ranging female reindeer (Rangifer tarandus) in the Mal\u00e5 reindeer herding community, Sweden, we determined reindeer calving sites and estimated reindeer habitat selection using resource selection functions (RSF). RSFs were estimated at both second- (selection of home range) and third-order (selection within home range) scale in relation to environmental variables, wind farm (WF) development phase (before construction, construction, and operation), distance to the WFs and at the second-order scale whether the wind turbines were in or out of sight of the reindeer. We found that the distance between reindeer calving site and WFs increased during the operation phase, compared to before construction. At both scales of selection, we found a significant decrease in habitat selection of areas in proximity of the WFs, in the same comparison. The results also revealed a shift in home range selection away from habitats where wind turbines became visible toward habitats where the wind turbines were obscured by topography (increase in use by 79% at 5 km). We interpret the reindeer shift in home range selection as an effect of the wind turbines per se. Using topography and land cover information together with the positions of wind turbines could therefore help identify sensitive habitats for reindeer and improve the planning and placement of WFs. In addition, we found that operation phase of these WFs had a stronger adverse impact on reindeer habitat selection than the construction phase. Thus, the continuous running of the wind turbines making a sound both day and night seemed to have disturbed the reindeer more than the sudden sounds and increased human activity during construction work.","author":["Skarin, A.","Sandstr\u00f6m, P.","Alam, M."],"organization":["Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences","Dalarna University"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["65.233335500000","18.964472700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Out-of-sight-of-wind-turbines-Reindeer-response-to-wind-farms-in-operation.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1744","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/considerations-upscaling-individual-effects-wind-energy-development-towards-population","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479718310727","title":"Considerations for Upscaling Individual Effects of Wind Energy Development Towards Population-Level Impacts on Wildlife","description":"The expansion of wind energy poses challenges to policy- and decision-makers to address con\ufb02icts with wildlife. Con\ufb02icts are associated with impacts of existing and planned projects on wildlife, and associated di\ufb03culties of prediction where impacts are subject to considerable uncertainty. Many post-construction studies have demonstrated adverse e\ufb00ects on individuals of various bird and bat species. These e\ufb00ects may come in the form of collision-induced mortality or behavioral or physiological changes reducing the \ufb01tness of individuals exposed to wind energy facilities. Upscaling these individual e\ufb00ects to population impacts provides information on the true value of interest from a conservation point of view. This paper identi\ufb01es methodological issues associated when moving from individual e\ufb00ects to population impacts in the context of wind energy. Distinct methodological approaches to predict population impacts are described using published case studies. The various choices of study design and metrics available to detect signi\ufb01cant changes at the population level are further assessed based on these. Ways to derive impact thresholds relevant for decision-making are discussed in detail. Robust monitoring schemes and sophisticated modelling techniques may inevitably be unable to describe the whole complexity of wind and wildlife interactions and the natural variability of animal populations. Still, they will provide an improved understanding of the response of wildlife to wind energy and better-informed policies to support risk-based decision-making. Policies that support the use of adaptive management will promote assessments at the population level. Providing information to adequately balance the development of wind energy with the persistence of wildlife populations.","author":["Masden, E.","May, R.","Bennet, F.","Perron, M."],"organization":["Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","Environmental Research Institute (ERI)","Marine Scotland Science","nateco AG"],"originationDate":"2019-01-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1745","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/swimming-behavior-roach-rutilus-rutilus-three-spined-stickleback-gasterosteus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bioone.org\/journals\/AMBIO-A-Journal-of-the-Human-Environment\/volume-36\/issue-8\/0044-7447(2007)36[636:SBORRR]2.0.CO;2\/Swimming-Behavior-of-Roach-Rutilus-rutilus-and-Three-spined-Stickleback\/10.1579\/0044-7447(2007)36[636:SBORRR]2.0.CO;2.full","title":"Swimming Behavior of Roach (Rutilus rutilus) and Three-spined Stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) in Response to Wind Power Noise and Single-tone Frequencies","description":"The aims of this study were to examine how swimming behavior of roach Rutilus rutilus and three-spined stickleback Gasterosteus aculeatus were influenced by single-frequency sounds and noise generated by an offshore wind turbine, and the function of sound pressure level. In this study, two different species of fish were exposed to single-tone frequencies and sound generated by an offshore wind power plant.","author":["Sigray, P.","Andersson, M.","\u00d6hman, M.","Dock-\u00c5kerman, E.","Ubral-Hedenberg, O."],"organization":["Stockholm University","FOI (Swedish Defence Research Agency)"],"originationDate":"2007-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.366470700000","18.049691500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Anderssonetal2007.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1746","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/heart-sustainable-energy-transition-public-acceptability-energy-projects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/document\/8246638","title":"At the Heart of a Sustainable Energy Transition: The Public Acceptability of Energy Projects","description":"Public acceptability is at the heart of changing the energy system toward a more sustainable way of energy production and use. Without public acceptability and support for changes, a sustainable energy transition is unlikely to be viable. We argue that public acceptability is often addressed too late and should be incorporated into the planning process from the start. Moreover, engineers, policy makers, and project developers tend to misjudge the complexity and causes of public resistance, trying to find the magic bullet to \u0022solve\u0022 the lack of public acceptability. Such attempts are likely to be ineffective, or even counterproductive, if they fail to address people\u0027s key concerns surrounding energy projects. There is not a one-size-fits-all solution: public acceptability is a dynamic process that depends on the context, the specific project at stake, and the parties involved.","author":["Ram, B.","Devine-Wright, P.","Perlaviciute, G.","Schuitema, G."],"organization":["University of Groningen","University College Dublin","University of Exeter","University of Delaware"],"originationDate":"2018-01-04","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1747","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-landscape","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128094518000230","title":"Wind Turbines and Landscape","description":"We think that most people are passionate about landscape, as a source of inspiration, as a setting for the production of food or as daily surroundings. We discuss how wind energy developments affect people\u2019s perception of landscape through the number, composition, and size of turbines in wind farms.\u00a0Landscapes are constantly changing, and some significant changes are the result of measures we take to combat climate change, including building wind farms. Wind energy has been harnessed for centuries, but recent technological advancement has seen turbine size rapidly increase. We discuss the issues of very large turbines in relation to landscapes, and how a proactive design approach can make a positive contribution to the wind farm industry.\n\nA chapter from Wind Energy Engineering: A Handbook for Onshore and Offshore Wind Turbines.","author":["van Grieken, M.","Dower, B."],"organization":["MVGLA"],"originationDate":"2017-05-19","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1748","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-structural-safety-issues-related-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/B9780128094518000229","title":"Environmental and Structural Safety Issues Related to Wind Energy","description":"Wind energy is one of the most mature renewable energy technologies and has been developing rapidly in recent years. Many countries have shown interest in utilizing wind energy, but its impact on the environmental is a concern. The primary environmental impacts include avian safety issues, biosystem disturbances, noise, visual pollutions, electromagnetic interferences, and local climate changes. This chapter provides a review and summary of the environmental impacts caused by the wind energy industry. Available mitigation technologies to minimize these adverse environmental impacts are also discussed. In addition to environmental impacts, structural safety is becoming an issue as many structural failures of wind turbines have been reported. A summary of studies related to these structural safety problems are included in this chapter; the focus here is on the structural performance of wind turbine towers under wind and seismic loads together with health monitoring and vibration control technologies. The intention of this chapter is to provide state-of-the-art knowledge about the aforementioned issues associated with wind energy development as well as strategies for wind energy planners and developers to mitigate the negative effects.\n\n\nA chapter from Wind Energy Engineering: A Handbook for Onshore and Offshore Wind Turbines.","author":["Huang, Z.","Dai, K.","Gao, K."],"organization":["Tongji University","University of North Texas"],"originationDate":"2017-05-19","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1749","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-engineering-handbook-onshore-offshore-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/book\/9780128094518\/wind-energy-engineering","title":"Wind Energy Engineering: A Handbook for Onshore and Offshore Wind Turbines","description":"Wind Energy Engineering: A Handbook for Onshore and Offshore Wind Turbines is the most advanced, up-to-date and research-focused text on all aspects of wind energy engineering. Wind energy is pivotal in global electricity generation and for achieving future essential energy demands and targets. In this fast moving field this must-have edition starts with an in-depth look at the present state of wind integration and distribution worldwide, and continues with a high-level assessment of the advances in turbine technology and how the investment, planning, and economic infrastructure can support those innovations. Each chapter includes a research overview with a detailed analysis and new case studies looking at how recent research developments can be applied. Written by some of the most forward-thinking professionals in the field and giving a complete examination of one of the most promising and efficient sources of renewable energy, this book is an invaluable reference into this cross-disciplinary field for engineers.\n\nKey Features:\nContains analysis of the latest high-level research and explores real world application potential in relation to the developments\nUses system international (SI) units and imperial units throughout to appeal to global engineers\nOffers new case studies from a world expert in the field\nCovers the latest research developments in this fast moving, vital subject\nContents:\nPart I: Introduction\nChapter 1 - Why Wind Energy? (T. Letcher\u200b)\n\n\u200bPart II: Wind Resource and Wind Energy Worldwide\nChapter 2 - Wind Power Fundamentals (A. Kalmikov)\nChapter 3 - Estimation of Wind Energy Potential and Prediction of Wind Power (J. Shi \u0026amp; E. Erdem)\nChapter 4 - Global Potential for Wind-Generated Electricity (X. Lu \u0026amp; M. McElroy)\nChapter 5 - The Future of Wind Energy Development in China (P. Guo et al.)\nChapter 6 - Wind Power in the German System - Research and Development for the Transition Toward a Sustainable Energy Future (M. Luther et al.)\n\nPart III: Wind Turbine Technology\nChapter 7 - History of Harnessing Wind Power (M. Ragheb)\nChapter 8 - Wind Turbine Technologies (A. Hansen)\nChapter 9 - Aerodynamics and Design of Horizontal-Axis Wind Turbines (M. Hansen)\nChapter 10 - Vertical Axis Wind Turbines: Farm and Turbine Design (R. Whittlesey)\nChapter 11 - Multielement Airfoils for Wind Turbines (A. Ragheb \u0026amp; M. Selig)\nChapter 12 - Civil Engineering Aspects of a Wind Farm and Wind Turbine Structures (S. Bhattacharya)\nChapter 13 - Civil Engineering Challenges Associated With Design of Offshore Wind Turbines With Special Reference to China (S. Bhattacharya et al.)\nChapter 14 - Numerical Methods for SSI Analysis of Offshore Wind Turbine Foundations (S. Lopez-Querol et al.)\nChapter 15 - Reliability of Wind Turbines (S. Sheng and R. O\u2019Connor)\nChapter 16 - Practical Method to Estimate Foundation Stiffness for Design of Offshore Wind Turbines (S. Jalbi et al.)\nChapter 17 - Physical Modeling of Offshore Wind Turbine Model for Prediction of Prototype Response (D. Lombardi et al.)\n\nPart IV: Generation of Electricity\nChapter 18 - Energy and Carbon Intensities of Stored Wind Energy (C. Barnhart)\nChapter 19 - Small-Scale Wind Turbines (P. James and A. Bahaj)\nChapter 20 - Integration Into National Grids (J. Weiss and T. Tsuchida)\n\nPart V: Environmental Impacts of Wind Energy\nChapter 21 - Life Cycle Assessment: Meta-analysis of Cumulative Energy Demand for Wind Energy Technologies (M. Carbajales-Dale)\nChapter 22 - Environmental and Structural Safety Issues Related to Wind Energy (K. Dai et al.)\nChapter 23 - Wind Turbines and Landscape (M. van Grieken and B. Dower)\nChapter 24 - Global Rare Earth Supply, Life Cycle Assessment, and Wind Energy (Z. Weng and G. Mudd)\n\nPart VI: Financial Modeling\/Wind Economics\nChapter 25 - Economics of Wind Power Generation (M. Ragheb)\n\nPart VII: Investment, Growth Trends, and the Future of Wind Energy \nChapter 26 - Growth Trends and the Future of Wind Energy (L. Fried et al.)","author":["Letcher, T."],"organization":["University of KwaZulu-Natal"],"originationDate":"2017-05-19","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-22 11:34:37","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1750","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/challenges-opportunities-animal-conservation-renewable-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/zslpublications.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/acv.12067","title":"Challenges and opportunities for animal conservation from renewable energy development","description":"Global climate change is among the greatest threats confronting both human and natural systems (IPCC, 2007). A substantial component of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions is from energy production, generated via the burning of fossil fuels, especially coal, natural gas and refined petroleum. Given that reduction in global energy consumption is unlikely over the next century or so, renewable energy generation has been proposed as a low\u2010carbon alternative to limit GHG emissions. Consequently, many national and regional governments have set targets for renewable energy manufacture and use (e.g. \u201820% Wind Energy by 2030\u2019 \u2013 DoE, 2008;\u00a0EU, 2009). Nevertheless, despite the benefits associated with reducing carbon emissions, renewable energy development itself has important, sometimes severe, implications for the conservation of biodiversity that should not be ignored. A central challenge and opportunity for animal conservation is to understand and manage environmental problems associated with the rapid growth in renewable energy production, while simultaneously maintaining progress toward reducing dependence on fossil fuels.","author":["Evans, D.","Johnson, J.","Katzner, T.","Garner, T.","Gompper, M.","Altwegg, R.","Branch, T.","Gordon, I.","Pettorelli, N."],"organization":["West Virginia University","US Forest Service","University of North Texas","University of Hull","Zoological Society of London","University of Missouri","South African National Biodiversity Institute","University of Cape Town","University of Washington","James Hutton Institute"],"originationDate":"2013-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1751","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-biodiversity-implications-transitioning-green-economy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032116304622","title":"Renewable energy and biodiversity: Implications for transitioning to a Green Economy","description":"This literature review identifies the impacts of different renewable energy pathways on ecosystems and biodiversity, and the implications of these impacts for transitioning to a Green Economy. While the higher penetration of renewable energy is currently the backbone of Green Economy efforts, an emerging body of literature demonstrates that the renewable energy sector can affect ecosystems and biodiversity. The current review synthesizes the existing knowledge at the interface of renewable energy and biodiversity accross the five drivers of ecosystem change and biodiversity loss of the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment (MA) framework (i.e. habitat loss\/change, pollution, overexploitation, climate change and introduction of invasive species). It identifies the main impact mechanisms for different renewable energy pathways, including solar, wind, hydro, ocean, geothermal and bioenergy. Our review demonstrates that while all reviewed renewable energy pathways are associated (directly or indirectly) with each of the five MA drivers of ecosystem change and biodiversity loss, the actual impact mechanisms depend significantly between the different pathways, specific technologies and the environmental contexts within which they operate. With this review we do not question the fundamental logic of renewable energy expansion as it has been shown to have high environmental and socio-economic benefits. However, we want to make the point that some negative impacts on biodiversity do exist, and need to be considered when developing renewable energy policies. We put these findings into perspective by illustrating the major knowledge\/practices gaps and policy implications at the interface of renewable energy, biodiversity conservation and the Green Economy.","author":["Esteban, M.","Gasparatos, A.","Doll, C.","Ahmed, A.","Olang, T."],"organization":["University of Tokyo","United Nations University"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1752","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/short-term-effects-fishery-exclusion-offshore-wind-farms-macrofaunal-communities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0165783616300492","title":"Short-term effects of fishery exclusion in offshore wind farms on macrofaunal communities in the Belgian part of the North Sea","description":"With the wide scale construction of offshore wind farms (OWFs) throughout the entire North Sea, large areas are permanently being closed to beam trawl fisheries. Beam trawling has affected macrobenthic assemblages for centuries, especially the fragile and long-lived species. Due to the prohibition of bean trawling in many OWFs, opportunities are being provided to investigate the potential recovery of vulnerable species and the creation of de-facto Marine Protected Areas (MPAs). The soft-substrate macrobenthic community was investigated from 2008 to 2012, before and after the construction of an OWF in the Belgian part of the North Sea, situated on the Bligh Bank. The fishery enclosed area (\u00b121 km2) within the OWF (No Fishery area) was compared with a surrounding control area (\u00b130 km2) where regular fishing activities were registered through vessel monitoring system (VMS) data throughout the period 2010\u20132011. Three years after the exclusion of beam trawl fisheries, subtle changes within the macrobenthic community were observed in the No Fishery area. The benthic mysid shrimp Gastrosaccus spinifer (30 \u00b1 15 ind m\u22122), tube-building polychaetes Terebellidae sp. (196 \u00b1 151 ind m\u22122) and the echinoderm Echinocyamus pusillus (73 \u00b1 71 ind m\u22122), sensitive to trawling activities, showed increased abundances within the No Fishery area. With an expansion of the wind farm concession area to 238 km2 in the future, the likely increase of dense Terebellidae patches (e.g., Lanice conchilega reefs) within the No Fishery area could create an ecological important large-scale refugium for higher trophic levels. This study creates a baseline for the evaluation of long-term changes due to the fishing impacts and effects related to the presence of OWFs and highlights the importance of executing long-term monitoring programs in combination with targeted research.","author":["Vanaverbeke, J.","Vincx, M.","Coates, D.","Kapasakali, D."],"organization":["Ghent University","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)"],"originationDate":"2016-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.597131000000","2.767442000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1753","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-offshore-windfarms-act-marine-protected-areas-systematic-review-current","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X13001991","title":"The potential of offshore windfarms to act as marine protected areas \u2013 A systematic review of current evidence","description":"As offshore windfarm (OWF) construction in the UK is progressing rapidly, monitoring of the economic and ecological effects of these developments is urgently needed. This is to enable both spatial planning and where necessary mitigation in an increasingly crowded marine environment. One approach to mitigation is co-location of OWFs and marine protected areas (MPAs). This systematic review has the objective to inform this co-location proposal and identify areas requiring further research. A limited number of studies addressing marine renewable energy structures and related artificial structures in coastal waters were found. The results of these studies display a change in species assemblages at artificial structures in comparison to naturally occurring habitats. An increase in hard substrata associated species, especially benthic bivalves, crustaceans and reef associated fish and a decrease in algae abundance were the dominant trends. Assemblages associated with complex concrete structures revealed greater similarity to natural hard substrata compared to those around steel structures. To consider marine renewable energy sites, especially large scale OWFs as MPAs, the dissimilar nature of assemblages on the structures themselves to natural communities should be considered. However positive effects were recorded on the abundance of commercially important crustacean species. This suggests potential for incorporation of OWFs as no fishing, or restricted activity zones within a wider MPA to aid fisheries augmentation. The limited available evidence highlights a requirement for significant further research involving long term monitoring at a variety of sites to better inform management options.","author":["Mangi, S.","Ashley, M.","Rodwell, L."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory","Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)","Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2014-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1754","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-revolution-short-review-long-history","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148111000085","title":"The wind energy (r)evolution: A short review of a long history","description":"Although wind energy exploitation dates back five thousand years ago, contemporary societies are based almost exclusively on fossil fuels for covering their electrical energy needs. On the other hand, during the last thirty years, security of energy supply and environmental issues have reheated the interest for wind energy applications. In this context, the present work traces the long and difficult steps of wind energy development from the California era to the construction of huge offshore wind parks worldwide, highlighting the prospects and the main challenges of wind energy applications towards the target of 1000\u00a0GW of wind power by 2030.","author":["Kaldellis, J.","Zafirakis, D."],"organization":["Piraeus University of Applied Science (PUAS)"],"originationDate":"2011-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1755","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/factors-affecting-stakeholders-acceptance-offshore-wind-farms-along-western-coast","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569115000599","title":"The factors affecting stakeholders\u0027 acceptance of offshore wind farms along the western coast of Taiwan: Evidence from stakeholders\u0027 perceptions","description":"Stakeholder participation is an important concept in marine environmental management; thus, their acceptance and opinions might influence policy decision making and effectiveness. This paper explores the factors that affect stakeholders\u0027 (traditional ocean users, including fishers and aquaculture farmers) acceptance and conducts an empirical analysis to determine the relationship among stakeholders\u0027 perceptions and acceptance. A total of 238 respondents completed a survey that was conducted in six coastal counties in western Taiwan. We used principle component analysis and two logistic regression models for the analysis: one model does not consider perception factors, while the other model estimates perception factors. The empirical results reveal that three perception factors related to the benefits of offshore wind farms significantly affect stakeholders\u0027 acceptance. Furthermore, the explanatory power, goodness-of-fit, and the predicted probability are greater when perception factors are considered in the logistic model. As a result, stakeholders\u0027 perceptions are important factors that influence their acceptance of OWFs along the western coast of Taiwan. According to our findings, recommendations are offered to resolve the user conflicts regarding OWF turbine construction and operation, including (1) communicating effectively and integrating stakeholder participation and (2) offering benefits to ocean users and local communities.","author":["Chen, J.","Liu, H.","Chuang, C.","Lu, H."],"organization":["National Taiwan Ocean University","Fisheries Research Institute, Council of Agriculture","National Taipei University"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["23.697811000000","120.960513000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1756","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/portfolio-model-siting-offshore-wind-farms-economic-environmental-objectives","sourceURL":"https:\/\/mie.umass.edu\/sites\/default\/files\/mie\/faculty\/baker\/1.Cranmer_Baker_EJOR.pdf","title":"A portfolio model for siting offshore wind farms with economic and environmental objectives","description":"Siting offshore wind farms is a complex problem due to the wake interactions between wind farms. We develop a profit maximizing portfolio model based on underlying network models to track the wake effects through a series of wind farms. Our portfolio model optimizes the siting of wind farms considering multiple wind directions and wind speeds and performs better than simple decision heuristics. Excluding sites from the portfolio has nonlinear impacts on the profitability of the portfolio of sites in that areas excluded from consideration have greater impacts on profit if they are grouped together or aligned parallel to the prevailing wind direction. The model can be readily adapted to include additional cost factors.","author":["Baker, E.","Cranmer, A.","Liesi\u00f6, J.","Salo, A."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts","Aalto University"],"originationDate":"2018-05-16","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1757","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sustainable-worldwide-offshore-wind-energy-potential-systematic-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/aip.scitation.org\/doi\/pdf\/10.1063\/1.5009948","title":"The sustainable worldwide offshore wind energy potential: A systematic review","description":"The offshore wind industry is expanding rapidly around the world due to several factors enabling this source of renewable energy. Stronger wind resources in offshore areas, lack of social and geographical constraints related to onshore wind power, the evolution of technology, and increasing demand for electricity in coastal regions as a result of a massive increase in population are some of the factors favoring the use of wind energy. The assessment of the potential global capacity that considers the different economic, environmental, and social factors and the dynamics of market, policy, and technology are vital for estimating the competitiveness of offshore wind energy in the future energy profile. There are several studies and technical reports that evaluate the potential of offshore wind energy in different countries or regions. They used a different source of data, metrics, and quantitative approaches in appraising the potential offshore wind power capacity and its cost efficiency. The critical factors that have been considered are geographical, technical, economic, environmental, and social and market elements. This paper provides a systematic review for analyzing the studies that address the potential offshore wind energy around the world and published during the 2000\u20132016 period. This study highlights the key criteria for assessing the potential for offshore wind energy deployment and the related tools and methods.","author":["Keivanpour, S.","Ramudhin, A.","Kadi, D."],"organization":["Laval University","University of Hull"],"originationDate":"2017-11-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1758","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/finding-out-fate-displaced-birds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/data.marine.gov.scot\/dataset\/finding-out-fate-displaced-birds","title":"Finding out the Fate of Displaced Birds","description":"Scotland is committed to meeting 100% of its electricity demands from renewable sources by 2020. Marine renewables are a significant contributor to these targets, but the industry must comply with strict legislation (EU Birds Directive [2009\/147\/EC]) that protects internationally important seabird populations. This is a critical challenge because marine renewable developments have the potential to impact on seabird populations. The two effects that have received the most attention are collisions with turbine blades and displacement from developments (Drewitt \u0026amp; Langston 2006; Larsen \u0026amp; Guillemette 2007; Masden et al. 2010; Grecian et al. 2010, Langton et al. 2011, Scottish Government 2011). Other factors that may be important include barrier effects to the movement of migrating or commuting birds, disturbance during construction and operation, contamination, noise and indirect effects via impact of developments on seabird prey.  This project will focus on the means by which marine developments may affect seabirds from displacement and barrier effects. If the development is located in a foraging area then birds can be displaced, a process that may equate to habitat loss. If the development is on a route used by birds for daily or seasonal commuting then this may create a barrier to movement, potentially forcing affected individuals to travel further to meet their requirements.  This project first undertook a literature review of displacement and barrier effects (see Appendix A). This review demonstrated that there is considerable uncertainty about the potential impacts on seabird populations from these effects. To assess the state of knowledge, displacement can be split into two components for assessment: the proportion of the population that are displaced from the development and the magnitude of the demographic consequences on colony SPAs that arises from displacement and barrier effects.  Estimates of the former have been obtained primarily from at-sea surveys. Studies have shown marked variation in barrier effects and displacement among species. However, they have also shown substantial variation within species among studies, suggesting that effects are highly context dependent. One potential cause of this variation is intrinsic differences among individuals in different populations studied, for example the extent to which they are central place foraging or operating as independent individuals. However, another potential cause is the challenge in obtaining robust quantification of displacement and barrier effects. In particular, these quantifications rely on key assumptions, arguably the most important of which is that the relative differences in density of birds inside and outside the wind farm are due to displacement or barrier effects, when alternative explanations such as the relative distribution of prey are equally plausible.  Such studies based on monitoring surveys are also not structured to address the second component outlined above - the magnitude of demographic consequences. The absence of empirical data has necessitated the use of a precautionary approach to assessments. When based on well-grounded assumptions and reliable parameter estimates, individual-based simulation models can provide a valuable framework for estimating the demographic consequences of a variety of environmental perturbations. As such, this approach can be used to estimate demographic effects for seabirds of offshore renewable developments (ORD) mediated via the costs of barrier effects and displacement, whilst incorporating the uncertainty surrounding these estimates. This project sought to develop an analytical tool that uses this approach to quantify the demographic consequences of displacement and barrier effects, thereby improving the precision of assessment of ORD impact on seabirds so that regulatory bodies and their statutory advisors can reach informed, evidencebased decisions on the potential impacts of renewable developments whilst also encouraging sustainable use of the sea, consistent with the Scottish Government\u0027s twin goals of meeting its obligations with respect to climate change mitigation and safeguarding the marine environment.","author":["Furness, R.","Searle, K.","Trinder, M.","Daunt, F.","Butler, A.","Mobbs, D."],"organization":["MacArthur Green","Scottish Government"],"originationDate":"2018-02-02","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:57","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/searletal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1759","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mechanical-properties-harbor-seal-skin-blubber-test-anisotropy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0944200617301484","title":"Mechanical properties of harbor seal skin and blubber a test of anisotropy","description":"The skin and blubber of marine mammals provides protection from the surrounding environment, whether that be temperature, microbes, or direct mechanical impacts. To understand the ability of harbor seals\u2019 (Phoca vitulina) skin and blubber to resist blunt force trauma, we tested the material properties of these tissues. We quanti\ufb01ed two mechanical properties of the tissue: tensile strength and tensile sti\ufb00ness, at two test speeds, three sample orientations, and two age groups. We found signi\ufb01cant di\ufb00erences in material properties between test speeds, orientation, and age of the animal, but did not \ufb01nd a large di\ufb00erence with orientation. From this analysis, we conclude that harbor seal skin and blubber should be modeled as an isotropic non-linear elastic material with strain rate dependence. Moreover, we were interested in the e\ufb00ects of freezing on the biomechanical properties. The material was tested fresh and after being frozen for four months. Frozen data revealed an increase in sti\ufb00ness and strength for the skin (epidermis and dermis), but did not show a conclusive trend in the blubber material properties. While the availability of frozen marine mammal tissue is greater than that of fresh material, frozen tissue of harbor seals, especially the skin, cannot serve as an accurate replacement for testing of fresh material.","author":["Grear, M.","Motley, M.","Crofts, S.","Witts, A.","Summers, A.","Ditsche, P."],"organization":["University of Washington","University of Alaska Anchorage"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.605308900000","-122.967075200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1760","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/how-many-observation-days-are-needed-reliably-describe-bird-migration","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/327136940_How_many_observation_days_are_needed_to_reliably_describe_bird_migration","title":"How many observation days are needed to reliably describe bird migration?","description":"The total number of migrating birds is needed, for exam-ple, to estimate collisions risk as part of the assessment process for wind-power parks. This estimation is often based on a small sample of observation days, making  estimates uncertain. To determine the number of days needed to obtain reliable \ufb01gures we used observations of migrating birds obtained from the Signilsk\u00e4r bird obser-vatory, \u00c5land, Finland during the autumn seasons from 2009 to 2013. We sampled 1\u201314 days during each 14 day time window and used linear extrapolation and Poisson regression with weather covariates to estimate the total number of migrating birds and distribution of estimates. We calculated the head-wind and side-wind components according to the species\u2019 most common \ufb02ight directions. We found that observations should cover at least 90% of the migration period to obtain precise results and 70\u201390% to obtain results sufficiently reliable to use in practice. Linear extrapolation is the best model for small samples. The larger the proportion of days observed, the better is Poisson regression with weather covariates.","author":["Tanskanen, A.","Yrjola, R.","Baum, U.","Tanskanen, S.","Eriksson, J."],"organization":["Karolinska Institutet","University of Turku","Aalto University","Aland Bird Protection Association"],"originationDate":"2018-06-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.194906000000","19.340952000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tanskanenetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1761","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/project-pacific-marine-energy-center-south-energy-test-site-pmec-sets-final-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1419795-pacific-marine-energy-center-south-energy-test-site-pmec-sets","title":"Project: The Pacific Marine Energy Center South Energy Test Site (PMEC-SETS) Final Report: Final Site Selection, Preliminary Facility Design, and Cost \u0026 Schedule Estimates","description":"The overall goal of this project was to build on existing progress to establish the Pacific Marine Energy Center South Energy Test Site (PMEC-SETS) as the nation\u0027s first fully permitted test site for wave energy converter arrays. Specifically, it plays an essential role in reducing levelized cost of energy for the wave energy industry by providing both the facility and resources to address the challenges of cost reduction.","author":["Stewart, A.","Henkel, S.","Polagye, B.","Klure, J.","Sutton, G.","Bull, D.","Dalton, G.","Hellin, D.","Alcorn, R.","Batten, B.","Weber, J.","Cahill, B.","Amon, E.","Armstrong, S.","Cotilla-Sanchez, E.","Husky, A.","Langley, B.","Rea, J.","Sanders, M."],"organization":["Pacific Marine Energy Center (PMEC)","University College Cork","Oregon State University (OSU)","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)","Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI)","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","Pacific Energy Ventures LLC","University of Washington","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-11-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.621445700000","-124.189982800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-27 08:59:03","signatureProject":["PacWave"],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/PMEC-SETS-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1762","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-report-feasibility-study-california-wave-energy-test-center-calwave-volume-2","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1406135-final-report-feasibility-study-california-wave-energy-test-center-calwavesm-volume-appendices","title":"Final Report Feasibility Study for the California Wave Energy Test Center (CalWave) Volume 2","description":"The California Wave Energy Test Center (CalWave) Feasibility Study project was funded over multiple phases by the Department of Energy to perform an interdisciplinary feasibility assessment to analyze the engineering, permitting, and stakeholder requirements to establish an open water, fully energetic, grid connected, wave energy test center off the coast of California for the purposes of advancing U.S. wave energy research, development, and testing capabilities. Work under this grant included wave energy resource characterization, grid impact and interconnection requirements, port infrastructure and maritime industry capability\/suitability to accommodate the industry at research, demonstration and commercial scale, and macro and micro siting considerations. CalWave Phase I performed a macro-siting and down-selection process focusing on two potential test sites in California: Humboldt Bay and Vandenberg Air Force Base. This work resulted in the Vandenberg Air Force Base site being chosen as the most favorable site based on a peer reviewed criteria matrix. CalWave Phase II focused on four siting location alternatives along the Vandenberg Air Force Base coastline and culminated with a final siting down-selection. Key outcomes from this work include completion of preliminary engineering and systems integration work, a robust turnkey cost estimate, shoreside and subsea hazards assessment, storm wave analysis, lessons learned reports from several maritime disciplines, test center benchmarking as compared to existing international test sites, analysis of existing applicable environmental literature, the completion of a preliminary regulatory, permitting and licensing roadmap, robust interaction and engagement with state and federal regulatory agency personnel and local stakeholders, and the population of a Draft Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Preliminary Application Document (PAD). Analysis of existing offshore oil and gas infrastructure was also performed to assess the potential value and re-use scenarios of offshore platform infrastructure and associated subsea power cables and shoreside substations. The CalWave project team was well balanced and was comprised of experts from industry, academia, state and federal regulatory agencies. The result of the CalWave feasibility study finds that the CalWave Test Center has the potential to provide the most viable path to commercialization for wave energy in the United States.","author":["Toman, W.","Davy, D.","Dooher, B.","Blakslee, S."],"organization":["Pacific Gas and Electric Company","California Polytechnic State University (San Luis Obispo)","CH2M Hill","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.742026700000","-120.642478200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-05 05:19:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/dooheretal2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1763","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-report-feasibility-study-california-wave-energy-test-center-calwave-volume-1","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1406134-final-report-feasibility-study-california-wave-energy-test-center-calwavesm","title":"Final Report Feasibility Study for the California Wave Energy Test Center (CalWave) Volume 1","description":"The California Wave Energy Test Center (CalWave) Feasibility Study project was funded over multiple phases by the Department of Energy to perform an interdisciplinary feasibility assessment to analyze the engineering, permitting, and stakeholder requirements to establish an open water, fully energetic, grid connected, wave energy test center off the coast of California for the purposes of advancing U.S. wave energy research, development, and testing capabilities. Work under this grant included wave energy resource characterization, grid impact and interconnection requirements, port infrastructure and maritime industry capability\/suitability to accommodate the industry at research, demonstration and commercial scale, and macro and micro siting considerations. CalWave Phase I performed a macro-siting and down-selection process focusing on two potential test sites in California: Humboldt Bay and Vandenberg Air Force Base. This work resulted in the Vandenberg Air Force Base site being chosen as the most favorable site based on a peer reviewed criteria matrix. CalWave Phase II focused on four siting location alternatives along the Vandenberg Air Force Base coastline and culminated with a final siting down-selection. Key outcomes from this work include completion of preliminary engineering and systems integration work, a robust turnkey cost estimate, shoreside and subsea hazards assessment, storm wave analysis, lessons learned reports from several maritime disciplines, test center benchmarking as compared to existing international test sites, analysis of existing applicable environmental literature, the completion of a preliminary regulatory, permitting and licensing roadmap, robust interaction and engagement with state and federal regulatory agency personnel and local stakeholders, and the population of a Draft Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) Preliminary Application Document (PAD). Analysis of existing offshore oil and gas infrastructure was also performed to assess the potential value and re-use scenarios of offshore platform infrastructure and associated subsea power cables and shoreside substations. The CalWave project team was well balanced and was comprised of experts from industry, academia, state and federal regulatory agencies. The result of the CalWave feasibility study finds that the CalWave Test Center has the potential to provide the most viable path to commercialization for wave energy in the United States.","author":["Jacobson, P.","Toman, W.","Hagerman, G.","Potter, C.","Davy, D.","Thompson, J.","Dooher, B.","West, A.","Blakeslee, S.","Willaims, R.","Connet, R.","Dolan, D.","Baltimore, C.","Wendt, D.","Sheppard, C.","Harris, A.","Lawson, W."],"organization":["California Polytechnic State University (San Luis Obispo)","Protean Wave Energy Ltd.","Leidos","CH2M Hill","Kearns \u0026 West","Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)","Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University","California Natural Resources Agency","Pacific Gas and Electric Company","Humboldt State University","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.742873700000","-120.584546200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-05 05:19:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/blakesleeetal2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1764","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/need-wind-change-use-offshore-wind-messages-stakeholders-media-germany-their-effects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/09640568.2016.1221799","title":"Need for a wind of change? Use of offshore wind messages by stakeholders and the media in Germany and their effects on public acceptance","description":"This study investigates German news media coverage and PR material of offshore wind stakeholders from industry, politics, science and civil society thoroughly to provide insights about offshore wind benefits and risks communicated frequently and rarely to the public. By comparative analyses, differences between stakeholder and media messages are revealed: while stakeholders strongly focused on the supportive argument relevance of offshore wind for the energy turnaround, the media often discussed the negative impacts higher costs and delays in grid connection. Furthermore, the influence of offshore wind arguments on acceptance is measured within a survey representative of the German population. With these results, it can be assessed how far influential arguments were presented and which messages have been used frequently despite their low impact. Disruptions to viewscapes, limitation of commercial fishing areas, and hazards to shipping proved to be effective arguments to influence offshore wind acceptance \u2013 however, they were seldom used.","author":["Schmidt, A."],"organization":["Technische Universit\u00e4t Dresden"],"originationDate":"2016-10-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.165691000000","10.451525000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1765","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-engagement-offshore-renewable-energy-critical-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/wcc.282","title":"Public engagement with offshore renewable energy: A critical review","description":"Offshore renewable energy, including offshore wind, tidal and wave energy, has sometimes been represented as opposition\u2010free alternatives to controversial technologies such as onshore wind turbines, and has received increasing attention from social scientists in recent years. A fragmented literature has emerged investigating public engagement with these technologies and the determinants of public acceptance, comprising 59 key studies\u2014the majority investigating offshore wind energy (59%). This literature review argues that while the ways in which public actors engage with offshore renewable energy are to some extent similar to onshore energy infrastructure, there are also important differences. These include the generally lower levels of public knowledge about the technologies, a changing role for visual impacts, a fundamentally different, marine, spatial context, and different sets of stakeholders in different decision\u2010making arenas. There is a need to explore as yet unasked and unanswered questions\u2014going beyond \u2018established\u2019 variables identified in the onshore wind\u2010based \u2018beyond NIMBY\u2019 literature\u2014especially regarding the role of the marine location of these technologies, and the cross\u2010technology and cross\u2010disciplinary applicability of findings. In order to more fully understand public responses to energy infrastructures, future research needs to move beyond case studies of onshore wind developments, adopting more diverse and ambitious research designs and methodologies.","author":["Devine-Wright, P.","Wiersma, B."],"organization":["University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2014-06-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1766","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/climate-change-renewable-energy-ocean-tides-calming-sea-regulatory-uncertainty","sourceURL":"https:\/\/booksandjournals.brillonline.com\/content\/journals\/10.1163\/092735209x12499043518269","title":"Climate change and renewable energy from the ocean and tides: Calming the sea of regulatory uncertainty","description":"We examine the state of ocean energy in 2009 and consider its potential as a source of renewable energy. We provide a background on the current state of technology and commercial development, and examine the implications for law and policy of the re-emergence of ocean energy as a source of renewable energy in 2009. In the 1970s much of the academic and policy literature highlighted jurisdictional uncertainty surrounding ocean energy under international law. This is not the case today. Although some questions remain with respect to navigation rights, most questions surrounding the nature and extent of coastal State jurisdiction in relation to ocean energy have been resolved by the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. Instead we argue that one of the biggest challenges faced by ocean energy today is the uncertain state of regulation under domestic legal systems. We highlight issues requiring attention by policy-makers and legislators, including managing hazards to navigation, providing further financial incentives for wide-scale commercialisation of this technology (such as increased research and development funding and feed-in tariffs) and managing ocean energy\u0027s relatively benign environmental impacts.","author":["Leary, D.","Esteban, M."],"organization":["University of New South Wales","Yokohama National University"],"originationDate":"2009-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1767","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/national-offshore-wind-strategy-facilitating-development-offshore-wind-industry-united","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1325403-national-offshore-wind-strategy-facilitating-development-offshore-wind-industry-united-states","title":"National Offshore Wind Strategy: Facilitating the Development of the Offshore Wind Industry in the United States","description":"Offshore wind energy holds the promise of significant environmental and economic benefits for the United States. It is an abundant, low-carbon, domestic energy resource. It is located close to major coastal load centers, providing an alternative to long-distance transmission or development of electricity generation in these land-constrained regions. Once built, offshore wind farms could produce energy at low, long-term fixed costs, which can reduce electricity prices and improve energy security by providing a hedge against fossil fuel price volatility.  Realizing these benefits will require overcoming critical challenges in three strategic themes: 1) reducing the costs and technical risks associated with domestic offshore wind development, 2) supporting stewardship of U.S. waters by providing regulatory certainty and understanding and mitigating environmental risks of offshore wind development, and 3) increasing understanding of the benefits and costs of offshore wind energy.  The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), through its Wind Energy Technologies Office, and U.S. Department of the Interior (DOI), through its Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM), have jointly produced this updated national strategy to facilitate the responsible development of offshore wind energy in the United States. In doing so, the agencies accounted for progress made since the last national offshore wind strategy released in 2011, and utilized significant input from the offshore wind community. This strategy highlights the gaps that need to be addressed by the offshore wind community as a whole, and provides a suite of actions that DOE and DOI are positioned to undertake to address these gaps and help the nation realize the benefits of offshore wind development.  Sections included in this report are as follows:    Introduction  The Value of Offshore Wind  Major Action Areas for U.S. Offshore Wind Industry Development  Federal Offshore Wind Strategy","author":["Gilman, P.","Musial, W.","Duerr, A.","Feinberg, L.","Beiter, P.","Maurer, B.","Peterson, L.","Golladay, J.","Stromberg, J.","Johnson, I.","Boren, D.","Moore, A."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind","Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NOWS_DOE_DOI.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1768","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/determinants-wind-energy-growth-united-states-drivers-barriers-state-level-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032118306063","title":"The determinants of wind energy growth in the United States: Drivers and barriers to state-level development","description":"The focus of this paper is to analyse the determinants of wind energy development in the United States and how procedural and regulatory frameworks influence the deployment of wind power facilities. The empirical analysis uses statistical regression models integrating geospatial, macroeconomic and socio-environmental control variables. Using wind penetration as well as wind capacity additions as dependent variable permits a more differentiated analysis of both absolute and relative growth factors. This enables a precise assessment of state-to-state variations in permitting, zoning and siting procedures that wind developers have to clear before being authorised to start construction. Quantifying the number of state-level financial support measures and various permitting and regulatory process stages allowed for a more comprehensive assessment of administrative barriers to wind energy development than prior research studies. The results indicate a partial reversal of previous findings that showed that a high quantity of state-level regulations negatively affects wind capacity additions. Exogenous factors such as the ratio of in-state federal lands, population density, and especially wind energy potential, as well as federal statutes and incentives remain the main drivers of wind capacity additions and overall wind energy penetration. Contrasting prior literature, the influence of localised financial incentives or regulatory approval procedures appears to be minor; therefore streamlining national policies and incentives at the federal level might prove more effective than promoting wind development at the state level. We point out that future research should also examine the role of quality of state-level regulations in addition to quantity.","author":["Yang, Z.","Schumacher, K."],"organization":["University of Oxford","University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:10:59","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1769","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecosystem-service-tradeoff-analysis-reveals-value-marine-spatial-planning-multiple","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.pnas.org\/content\/early\/2012\/02\/27\/1114215109.short","title":"Ecosystem service tradeoff analysis reveals the value of marine spatial planning for multiple ocean uses","description":"Marine spatial planning (MSP) is an emerging responsibility of resource managers around the United States and elsewhere. A key proposed advantage of MSP is that it makes tradeoffs in resource use and sector (stakeholder group) values explicit, but doing so requires tools to assess tradeoffs. We extended tradeoff analyses from economics to simultaneously assess multiple ecosystem services and the values they provide to sectors using a robust, quantitative, and transparent framework. We used the framework to assess potential conflicts among offshore wind energy, commercial fishing, and whale-watching sectors in Massachusetts and identify and quantify the value from choosing optimal wind farm designs that minimize conflicts among these sectors. Most notably, we show that using MSP over conventional planning could prevent \u003E$1 million dollars in losses to the incumbent fishery and whale-watching sectors and could generate \u003E$10 billion in extra value to the energy sector. The value of MSP increased with the greater the number of sectors considered and the larger the area under management. Importantly, the framework can be applied even when sectors are not measured in dollars (e.g., conservation). Making tradeoffs explicit improves transparency in decision-making, helps avoid unnecessary conflicts attributable to perceived but weak tradeoffs, and focuses debate on finding the most efficient solutions to mitigate real tradeoffs and maximize sector values. Our analysis demonstrates the utility, feasibility, and value of MSP and provides timely support for the management transitions needed for society to address the challenges of an increasingly crowded ocean environment.","author":["Halpern, B.","White, C.","Kappel, C."],"organization":["University of California Santa Barbara"],"originationDate":"2012-03-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.358701000000","-70.781620000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/White-et-al-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1770","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/automatic-optical-detection-classification-marine-animals-around-mhk-converters-using","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.2172\/1416953","title":"Automatic optical detection and classification of marine animals around MHK converters using machine vision","description":"Optical systems provide valuable information for evaluating interactions and associations between organisms and MHK energy converters and for capturing potentially rare encounters between marine organisms and MHK device. The deluge of optical data from cabled monitoring packages makes expert review time-consuming and expensive. We propose algorithms and a processing framework to automatically extract events of interest from underwater video. The open-source software framework consists of background subtraction, filtering, feature extraction and hierarchical classification algorithms. This principle classification pipeline was validated on real-world data collected with an experimental underwater monitoring package. An event detection rate of 100% was achieved using robust principal components analysis (RPCA), Fourier feature extraction and a support vector machine (SVM) binary classifier. The detected events were then further classified into more complex classes \u2013 algae | invertebrate | vertebrate, one species | multiple species of fish, and interest rank. Greater than 80% accuracy was achieved using a combination of machine learning techniques.","author":["Brunton, S."],"organization":["University of Washington","Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Brunton_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1771","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/barbastelle-bats-wind-farm-are-they-risk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10344-018-1202-1","title":"Barbastelle bats in a wind farm: are they at risk?","description":"We need to know if and how western barbastelles Barbastella barbastellus are affected by wind farming in Sweden. This is because wind turbines are frequently constructed in barbastelle habitats and yet there is no national guideline on how the arising conflict should be handled. We studied the movement, behavior and mortality of a barbastelle population at a wind farm in southern Sweden, using radio-telemetry, automatic bat detectors and carcass searches. The tagged bats (6 males and 8 females) roosted mainly under loose bark of dead oak trees and foraged in patches of mature deciduous woodlands or pockets of mature spruce trees within 15\u00a0km of the roosts. Extensive areas of young spruce plantation, open farmland and lakes were not used for roosting or foraging but were crossed by commuting bats. Continuous recordings with bat detectors frequently picked up barbastelles at forest edges 30\u00a0m from the turbines, but rarely over the turbine pads within 10\u00a0m from the turbines and never at heights of 30 and 100\u00a0m at the turbine towers. Barbastelles were apparently not attracted to the wind turbines and did not seem to interact with them in any way. Carcass searches under 10 wind turbines at 1-week intervals over three summers did not reveal any dead barbastelles, although three other species were recovered. We conclude that wind farming is not nessarily incompatible with effective conservation of barbastelles in Sweden, but instead of focusing on wind turbines, effors should concentrate on (a) preservation and restoration of mature, age-structured deciduous woodlands and spruce forests, including very small and isolated patches, which provide food and roosts, and probably also (b) avoidance of outdoor lighting in areas used by barbastelles. Designating large circular buffer zones around each known or suspected colony according to current practice would be inefficient or meaningless in our case, because barbastelles use extensive home ranges and switch roost frequently. We argue that barbastelle management must be applied on a landscape scale.","author":["Rydell, J.","Pettersson, S.","Apoznanski, G.","Sanchez-Navarro, S.","Kokurewicz, T."],"organization":["Wroc\u0142aw University of Environmental and Life Sciences","Lund University","Estacion Biologica de Donana"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.000000000000","12.666667000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1772","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/movement-patterns-white-tailed-sea-eagles-near-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/jwmg.21488","title":"Movement patterns of white-tailed sea eagles near wind turbines","description":"White\u2010tailed sea eagles (Haliaeetus albicilla) exhibit one of the highest mortality rates at wind power plants (WPPs) among raptor species in Europe, but data on circumstances of collision and behavioral response to WPPs are scarce. We analyzed the effect of WPPs on movement patterns of sea eagles in Germany with satellite telemetry. We analyzed ranging behavior and environmental parameters that influence the behavioral flight response to WPPs using multiple regression models. During 2003 through 2009 we radio\u2010tracked 25 white\u2010tailed sea eagles in northern Germany (8 territorial, 7 non\u2010territorial, 10 young eagles marked as nestlings). Mean home range sizes of territorial eagles varied with individuals tracked and the estimation method applied, ranging from 2.7\u2009km2 to 669.7\u2009km2. Sex or breeding status did not influence home range size. Ranging behavior varied between individuals and was correlated with habitat quality (i.e., nest distance to nearest water source and to anthropgogenic structure) and weather conditions. Among the 9 territorial eagles, only 1 individual resided within the officially proposed 3\u2010km minimum safety distance between nest and planned WPP. However, others frequently moved \u003E3\u2009km away from their nests, leaving the proposed safety area. One eagle inhabiting a territory within intensively cultivated landscape frequently approached a WPP and did not alter its movement patterns near the WPP compared to control areas. We identified several features visited by the eagles (e.g., perches, small lakes). To mitigate the collision risk of eagles, the recommended safety radius of 3\u2009km between nest and WPP should become an international standard with a safe flight corridor to feeding grounds. To avoid frequent collisions at the population scale with WPPs, it is important to construct WPPs only outside the main distribution areas of white\u2010tailed sea eagles. \u00a9 2018 The Wildlife Society.","author":["Krone, O.","Treu, G."],"organization":["Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.216667000000","10.600000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1773","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimating-wind-turbine-fatalities-using-integrated-detection-trials","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1002\/jwmg.21468","title":"Estimating wind turbine fatalities using integrated detection trials","description":"Fatality monitoring at wind projects requires carcass detection trials to adjust fatality estimates for the proportion of fatalities not found. However, detection trials vary greatly in metric, duration, carcass monitoring schedule, species, number placed, state of decomposition, whether placed within or outside search areas, and other factors. We introduce a new approach for estimating fatalities by quantifying overall detection rates rather than separate rates for searcher detection error and carcass persistence, and by leaving placed and found fatality carcasses undisturbed throughout monitoring. We placed 2 fresh\u2010frozen bird carcasses weekly at random sites within fatality search areas and on randomized days Monday\u2013Friday at Sand Hill and Santa Clara wind projects, Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area, California, USA. To estimate detection rates, we used logit regression to fit detection outcomes on body mass, which served as an axis of similitude between placed trial carcasses and fatality finds. Adjusted carcass placement rates among species detected by searchers regressed on true placement rates with a slope of 1.0 so long as sufficient numbers of trial carcasses were placed, thus validating our approach as an unbiased estimator. Our approach generally estimated lower fatality rates than did conventional approaches, the latter of which demonstrated biases in searcher detection rates and carcass persistence rates whether based on proportion of carcasses remaining or mean days to removal. Our approach also revealed detection errors that highlight the difficulty of finding and identifying the remains of dead animals, and which warrant routine reporting. Despite averaging only a 5\u2010day search interval on intensively grazed annual grasslands where ground visibility was usually high, our experienced fatality monitors averaged 4.3 searches\/first carcass detection, failed to detect 25% of 75 species represented by placed carcasses, and misidentified carcasses to species among 44% of species detected. Estimates of time since death also suffered bias and large error. Our approach more realistically simulates carcass detection probabilities associated with fatality monitoring, is less costly, facilitates hypothesis testing, eliminates multiple sources of error and bias suspected of conventional methods, and enables quantification of errors in estimated time since death, species identifications, and false negative findings. \u00a9 2018 The Wildlife Society.","author":["Bell, D.","Karas, B.","Mount, J.","Smallwood, K. Shawn","Walther, E.","Leyvas, E.","Standish, S."],"organization":["East Bay Regional Park District"],"originationDate":"2018-04-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.745490000000","-121.658155000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1774","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/exploitation-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60156-4_9","title":"Exploitation of Offshore Wind Energy","description":"Offshore wind energy will substantially contribute to future energy generation. However, the use of wind energy in marine areas has implications for marine ecosystems. The results of more than a decade of ecological research concerning offshore wind farms in Germany and abroad have revealed potential negative impacts of offshore wind farms, particularly with regards to seabirds, migrating terrestrial birds, and marine mammals such as harbor porpoises, especially by noise effects during installation of the turbines. Depending on the location of the wind farm, effects on bat populations are also possible. Impact on fish and benthic species are probably less relevant. There are even examples of positive (local) effects on marine biodiversity, for example, due to the introduction of a new hard substrate into ecosystems or the exclusion of fishing from the area of the offshore wind farm. For an overall assessment of the impacts of offshore wind, the effects still have to be investigated on a cumulative and international level over the long term.\n\nA number of measures are necessary to achieve environmentally sound development of the use of offshore wind energy. Marine spatial planning is important for guiding human activities in the marine environment, such as the use of offshore wind energy. Marine protected areas are of high relevance for protecting sensitive habitats and species. State-of-the-art mitigation measures against underwater noise are required to avoid hazards to whales. Finally, marine compensation measures can help to counterbalance adverse impacts of offshore wind farms.\n\nChapter from the\u00a0Handbook on Marine Environment Protection: Science, Impacts, and Sustainable Management.","author":["L\u00fcdeke, J."],"organization":["Technical University of Berlin"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1775","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/song-skylarks-alauda-arvensis-indicates-deterioration-acoustic-environment-resulting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1111\/ibi.12514","title":"The song of Skylarks Alauda arvensis indicates the deterioration of an acoustic environment resulting from wind farm start-up","description":"The rapid development of wind energy may have negative effects on bird populations, including collisions with turbines, displacement due to disturbance or habitat loss, indirect effects of reduced breeding success and barrier effects. This challenging conservation issue has attracted a great deal of interest, but the noise generated by turbines has been largely overlooked. Here, we studied acoustic behaviour of Skylarks Alauda arvensis in relation to wind farm start\u2010up to assess whether a change in song parameters can indicate a deterioration in the acoustic environment. We recorded territorial males displaying close to operating and non\u2010operating turbines and at a control site without turbines. In the following breeding season, we undertook replications at the same sites, except that the non\u2010operating turbines were now in operation. We found that Skylarks displaying at the wind farm were affected by wind turbine noise. Males singing close to operating wind turbines sang higher\u2010frequency songs than males from a control site and those that displayed near non\u2010operating turbines. In addition, an upward frequency shift in songs was observed when non\u2010operating turbines started to operate in the consecutive season. We therefore conclude that the frequency shift observed did not result from turbine presence, but from the noise they started to generate. This shows that a change in song parameters may reliably and within a relatively short time indicate a significant deterioration of the acoustic environment as a consequence of wind farm start\u2010up. This may help conservation biologists to identify species and populations that are particularly susceptible to wind farm noise.","author":["Szymanski, P.","Deoniziak, K.","Losak, K.","Osiejuk, T."],"organization":["Adam Mickiewicz University in Pozna\u0144"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.160504000000","17.047588000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1776","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/collision-displacement-vulnerability-offshore-wind-energy-infrastructure-among-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479718309228","title":"Collision and displacement vulnerability to offshore wind energy infrastructure among marine birds of the Pacific Outer Continental Shelf","description":"Marine birds are vulnerable to collision with and displacement by offshore wind energy infrastructure (OWEI). Here we present the first assessment of marine bird vulnerability to potential OWEI in the California Current System portion of the U.S. Pacific Outer Continental Shelf (POCS). Using population size, demography, life history, flight heights, and avoidance behavior for 62 seabird and 19 marine water bird species that occur in the POCS, we present and apply equations to calculate Population Vulnerability, Collision Vulnerability, and Displacement Vulnerability to OWEI for each species. Species with greatest Population vulnerability included those listed as species of concern (e.g., Least Tern [Sternula antillarum], Marbled Murrelet [Brachyramphus marmoratus], Pink-footed Shearwater [Puffinus creatopus]) and resident year-round species with small population sizes (e.g., Ashy Storm-Petrel [Oceanodroma homochroa], Brandt\u0027s Cormorant [Phalacrocorax penicillatus], and Brown Pelican [Pelecanus occidentalis]). Species groups with the greatest Collision Vulnerability included jaegers\/skuas, pelicans, terns and gulls that spend significant amounts of time flying at rotor sweep zone height and don\u0027t show macro-avoidance behavior (avoidance of entire OWEI area). Species groups with the greatest Displacement Vulnerability show high macro-avoidance behavior and low habitat flexibility and included loons, grebes, sea ducks, and alcids. Using at-sea survey data from the southern POCS, we combined species-specific vulnerabilities described above with at-sea species densities to assess vulnerabilities spatially. Spatial vulnerability densities were greatest in areas with high species densities (e.g., near-shore areas) and locations where species with high vulnerability were found in abundance. Our vulnerability assessment helps understand and minimize potential impacts of OWEI infrastructure on marine birds in the POCS and could inform management decisions.","author":["Adams, J.","Felis, J.","Pereksta, D.","Kelsey, E.","Czapanskiy, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1777","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behavioral-accommodation-nesting-hawks-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildlife.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/jwmg.21532","title":"Behavioral accommodation of nesting hawks to wind turbines","description":"The most direct effects of wind energy development on birds are rotor blade strikes and collisions with wind turbines. Probability of a blade strike is affected by the rates at which a bird visits the rotor swept zone (RSZ), and mitigated by the behaviors it uses to avoid being struck. Between 2011 and 2013, we studied the occurrence and nature of avoidance responses of 3 nesting ferruginous hawks (Buteo regalis), 5 Swainson\u0027s hawks (B. swainsoni), and 2 red\u2010tailed hawks (B. jamaicensis) to turbines built within their territories. Two of 10 breeding males we tracked with satellite telemetry were turbine\u2010collision fatalities, one during the study and the other in the following year. Collectively, nesting hawks displayed no macro\u2010avoidance of turbine projects and flew adjacent to or within RSZs at high rates (\u2009=\u20090.8\u2009visits\/hr, 1.3\u2009min\/visit; n\u2009=\u2009387 visits during 434\u2009hr of observation) synchronized with morning and afternoon peaks in foraging activity. Passes through rotors accounted for 9.8% of responses. The turbine that hawks approached most closely from collective encounters on each territory accounted for an average of 29% of all visits to RSZs and visitation was greater than expected at turbines \u0026lt;0.8\u2009km from nests (P\u2009\u0026lt;\u20090.001). As rotor speed increased, the frequency that hawks in RSZs flew between turbine rows increased relative to other avoidance behaviors and hawks that were potentially distracted (i.e., hunting or aggressive chasing) increased avoidance flights over and between turbines. The ability of hawks to employ evasive behaviors mitigated blade collision but allowed for close, hourly interaction with turbines that increased risk of collision. Where nesting populations of hawks are at risk, particularly ferruginous hawks, pre\u2010construction siting of wind turbines needs to account for nest locations and expected high rates of hawk visitation to turbines \u0026lt;800\u2009m from nests. On existing projects collision risk can be reduced through operational shutdown of turbines in this zone during 2 daily peaks in hawk foraging in the vicinity where hawks nest, but a greater effectiveness can be achieved by shutdown of specific turbines associated with highest regular use. \u00a9 2018 The Wildlife Society.","author":["Watson, J.","Davies, R.","Keren, I."],"organization":["Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW)"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.675824000000","-120.094501000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1778","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-sector-analysis-report-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/msp.wa.gov\/wp-content\/uploads\/2014\/03\/EnergySectorAnalysis.pdf","title":"Marine Sector Analysis Report: Marine Renewable Energy","description":"The Washington Department of Ecology is leading an effort to develop a marine spatial plan (MSP) for Washington\u2019s Pacific coast. The plan is being developed in coordination with an interagency team that includes the Office of the Governor, the Washington Department of Natural Resources (DNR), the Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW), Washington Sea Grant, and the Washington State Parks and Recreation Commission. The planning process also involves and engages coastal stakeholders, the public and local, tribal and federal governments. In particular, the Washington Coastal Marine Advisory Council (WCMAC) is advising on the development of the plan. WCMAC is a 26-member advisory group established in the Governor\u2019s office and comprised of a diverse range of stakeholder interests. In support of this effort, DNR has engaged Industrial Economics, Incorporated and BST Associates to develop reports on five major sectors of the state\u2019s marine economy: aquaculture; fishing (non-tribal); marine renewable energy; recreation and tourism; and shipping. These reports are intended to help state agencies, the WCMAC, and other stakeholders understand the trends and potential issues associated with economically important activity in the marine environment.  This report focuses on the marine renewable energy sector. It synthesizes information from publicly available sources to provide an overview of current economic activity, major trends in activity, and potential future resource uses and needs. In addition, the report draws on perspectives and insights from industry experts and relevant government agencies to highlight critical issues affecting the sector \u2013 including any current or potential future conflicts within the sector or with other sectors \u2013 and the role of marine spatial planning in addressing these issues (see Appendix A for a complete list of individuals interviewed). It also identifies key remaining questions, data quality issues, and data gaps.","author":["Industrial Economics Inc"],"organization":["Industrial Economics Inc"],"originationDate":"2014-10-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/IEC_EnergySectorReport_2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1779","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fixed-point-raptor-migration-survey-national-wind-technology-center-april-2010","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.2172\/1458824","title":"Fixed Point Raptor Migration Survey at the National Wind Technology Center: April 2010","description":"The U.S. Department of Energy\u0027s (DOE) National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) conducts a variety of research projects concerning wind energy research at the National Wind Technology Center (NWTC) located approximately 8 miles south of Boulder, Colorado, in northern Jefferson County. The NWTC provides a location with consistent winds and high speed gusts suitable for testing wind turbine technologies. Currently the NWTC houses a variety of structures on the 123 hectare (310 acre) site, including 13 operating turbines and 24 meteorological (met) towers. This report details the results of a migratory raptor field survey conducted at the NWTC during the month of April, 2010 as part of the larger study of site use by birds, and the site\u0027s effects on birds and bats.","author":["Ryon, T.","Brenda, B."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","Office of Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE)"],"originationDate":"2018-06-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.913216000000","-105.218600000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ryon_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1780","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-farms-soaring-bird-populations-migratory-bottleneck","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10344-018-1192-z","title":"Impact of wind farms on soaring bird populations at a migratory bottleneck","description":"Collision with turbines at wind farms is expected to have a greater impact on birds at particular sites where high concentrations of individuals occur, such as migration bottleneck areas. The Strait of Gibraltar (southern Spain) has long been recognized as the most important bottleneck in western Europe for soaring bird migration. Moreover, this area is within one of the most important potential areas for wind energy generation in Spain. Here, we examine monthly migratory soaring bird abundance in relation to long-term avian mortality rates at 21 wind farms located near the Strait of Gibraltar using zero-inflated hurdle negative binomial and gamma models. Best fit models included an effect of season in the collision mortality rates and in the proportion of adult individuals within the total deaths. However, monthly bird abundance was not directly related to the number of fatalities over the year. The accumulated fatalities during autumn migration constitute a small percentage (1%) of the total migrating population size. Moreover, mortality peak during autumn migration is largely attributable to juvenile birds. In contrast, the number of fatalities coinciding with the breeding period constitutes a substantial proportion (6%) of the local population, and it involved substantial losses among adult birds. Our results show that wind farms probably have an individually low impact on the migratory population of soaring birds. On the contrary, annual losses among adult local birds are remarkably high considering the small size of the local populations, and they may have population level effects.","author":["Ferrer, M.","de Lucas, M.","Martin, B.","Onrubia, A.","Perez-Bacalu, C."],"organization":["Fundacion Migres","United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)","Estacion Biologica de Donana"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.227861000000","-5.690944000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1781","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-impact-submarine-power-cables-crab-harvest","sourceURL":"https:\/\/adsabs.harvard.edu\/abs\/2016AGUOSHI53A..08B","title":"Potential Impact of Submarine Power Cables on Crab Harvest","description":"Offshore renewable energy installations convert wave or wind energy to electricity and transfer the power to shore through transmission cables laid on or buried beneath the seafloor. West coast commercial fishermen, who harvest the highly prized Dungeness crab (Metacarcinus magister) and the rock crab (Cancer spp.), are concerned that the interface of crabs and electromagnetic fields (EMF) from these cables will present an electrified fence on the seafloor that their target resource will not cross. Combined with the assistance of professional fishermen, submarine transmission cables that electrify island communities and offshore oil platforms in the eastern Pacific provide an opportunity to test the harvest of crab species across power transmission cables. In situ field techniques give commercial crab species a choice to decide if they will cross fully energized, EMF emitting, power transmission cables, in response to baited traps. Each independent trial is either one of two possible responses: the crab crosses the cable to enter a trap (1) or the crab does not cross the cable to enter a trap (0). Conditions vary among sample units by the following categorical, fixed factors (i.e., covariates) of cable structure (buried or unburied); direction of cable from crab position (west or east, north or south); time and season. A generalized linear model is fit to the data to determine whether any of these factors affect the probability of crabs crossing an energized cable to enter baited traps. Additionally, the experimental design, aside from the number of runs (set of sample trials) and the dates of the runs, is the same in the Santa Barbara Channel for rock crab and Puget Sound for Dungeness crab, and allows us to compare the capture rates of the two species in the two areas. We present preliminary results from field testing in 2015.","author":["Bull, A.","Nishimoto, M."],"organization":["University of California Santa Barbara","BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs"],"originationDate":"2016-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.684172000000","-126.899990000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","EMF","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1782","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysis-offshore-wind-development-non-market-stated-preference-approach-measure","sourceURL":"https:\/\/deepblue.lib.umich.edu\/handle\/2027.42\/97427","title":"An Analysis of Offshore Wind Development: A Non-market, Stated Preference Approach to Measure Community Perceptions and Opinions and Estimate Willingness to Pay in Two Lake Michigan Regions","description":"What socioeconomic factors are indicative of support or opposition for offshore wind development? At some distance offshore, does the local community incur a social cost or benefit from building a wind farm as measured through non-market valuation? This contingent valuation method (CVM) case study was conducted to explore the socioeconomic dimensions of opinions regarding offshore wind development in Lake Michigan and estimate willingness to pay (WTP) in two regions: 1) Evanston, Rogers Park, and Wilmette, Illinois (N=2880; n=208) and 2) Mason and Oceana Counties, Michigan (N=952; n=122). Data was collected from November 2012 though February 2013 via online surveys after mailing invitations to systematic samples that received 7% and 13% response rates, respectively. Respondents were presented with three WindPro simulations of a 400 MW wind farm at three, six and ten miles from each region\u2019s respective shore along with one hypothetical (+ or -) monthly electricity price impact and then asked to vote \u2018for\u2019 or \u2018against\u2019 each scenario. Initial probit model results indicate that variables for the monthly increase\/decrease in utility bill price, offshore wind farm siting distance, and liberal political ideology are statistically significant in determining the probability of support for the proposed offshore wind farm scenario; the logit analysis also suggests that individuals with a household income between $160,000 \u2013 $200,000\/year are more likely to support the proposed offshore project relative to the most affluent respondents. Mean WTP calculations imply a negative WTP (social cost) from siting a wind farm 3 and 6 miles offshore but a positive WTP (social benefit) when setback 10 miles for the average respondent. Additional results indicate considerable uncertainty among respondents regarding not only current support for offshore wind development but also both the type and extent of subsequent impacts. These results could provide valuable insight regarding offshore wind development opinions and environmental economic implications for policymakers in coastal communities both with and without prior exposure to formalized development proposals.","author":["Li, Y.","Ma, Y.","Knapp, L.","Rife, M."],"organization":["University of Michigan"],"originationDate":"2013-04-23","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.278044000000","-83.738224000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Knappetal2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1783","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sensitivity-tidal-lagoon-barrage-hydrodynamic-impacts-energy-outputs-operational","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148116307340","title":"Sensitivity of tidal lagoon and barrage hydrodynamic impacts and energy outputs to operational characteristics","description":"The feasibility and sustainable operation of tidal lagoons and barrages has been under scrutiny over uncertainties with regards to their environmental impacts, potential interactions and energy output. A numerical modelling methodology that evaluates their effects on the hydro-environment has been refined to consider technical constraints and specifications associated with variable turbine designs and operational sequences. The method has been employed to assess a number of proposals and their combinations within the Bristol Channel and Severn Estuary in the UK. Operational challenges associated with tidal range power plants are highlighted, while also presenting the capabilities of modelling tools tailored to their assessment. Results indicate that as the project scale increases so does its relative hydrodynamic impact, which may compromise annual energy output expectations if not accounted for. However, the manner in which such projects are operated can also have a significant impact on changing the local hydro-environment, including the ecology and morphology. Therefore, it is imperative that tidal range power plants are designed in such a way that efficiently taps into renewable energy sources, with minimal interference to the regional hydro-environment through their operation.","author":["Falconer, R.","Angeloudis, A."],"organization":["Cardiff University"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.290817000000","-3.344981000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Angeloudis-Falconer-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1784","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/clean-energy-safeguards-ecosystems-livelihoods-integrated-assessments-unleash-full","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148112000845","title":"Clean energy that safeguards ecosystems and livelihoods: Integrated assessments to unleash full sustainable potential for renewable energy","description":"In promoting renewable energy options, the environmental problem of GHG emissions should not be replaced with other environmental problems. Large-scale renewable infrastructure projects in particular \u2013 from offshore wind farms to concentrated solar towers to hydropower installations \u2013 need to be accompanied by adequate environmental and social impact assessments. For policies, plans and programmes around renewable energy investments, strategic environmental assessments should be applied. Such assessments will increasingly need to consider the changing nature of supporting ecosystem services and the need for climate adaptation. Financing institutions should promote appropriate safeguards, supported by capacity building activities from international organizations, including IRENA, in order to unleash the full sustainable potential of renewable energy options. This paper explores the experiences of applying impact assessment tools and processes to renewable investments and highlights some of the key aspects which should be taken into consideration when pursuing a renewable energy future.","author":["McCormick, N.","Athanas, A."],"organization":["African Wildlife Foundation","International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN)"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1785","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-barrages-uk-ecological-social-impacts-potential-mitigation-tools-support-barrage","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032113001500","title":"Tidal barrages in the UK: Ecological and social impacts, potential mitigation, and tools to support barrage planning","description":"The UK Government is committed to ambitious targets to reduce carbon emissions. The large tidal ranges in estuaries on the west coast of the UK make the deployment of tidal barrages an attractive proposition, and repeated feasibility studies have been undertaken. No barrage scheme has yet been taken forward, and one factor contributing to this reluctance to proceed is the significant environmental impacts that could result from the barrage construction and operation. This paper provides a detailed review of the current understanding of the potential ecological and social impacts of tidal barrages, including a case study of La Rance in northern France, and a discussion of strategies for mitigating barrage impacts. The review considers how more comprehensive ecological modelling could reduce uncertainty in predicting the impacts in specific estuaries, and discusses the use of Multi-criteria Analysis and ecosystem valuation as tools for evaluating the disparate costs and benefits of barrages schemes.","author":["Hooper, T.","Austen, M."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2013-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1786","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/human-dimensions-tidal-energy-review-theories-frameworks","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032118306208","title":"Human dimensions of tidal energy: A review of theories and frameworks","description":"This paper provides a comprehensive review of theories and frameworks for understanding and managing human dimensions of tidal energy. The methods for this review were: 1) the construction of an annotated bibliography of the human dimensions of marine renewable energy literature, 2) an analytical review of the core theories and frameworks found in the literature as applied to tidal energy development in the United States, and 3) an iterative process of conceptual refinement through peer review. Only 48.9% of the articles in the literature review included a theoretical underpinning, or discussed an existing framework. Of these, 42.2% were theories or frameworks that were only featured in a single paper, highlighting the need for theoretical focus within this field of study. For those theories and frameworks that had been explored in multiple articles, these theories and frameworks were grouped into nine overarching concepts: acceptance, place attachment, justice, economics, technology innovation systems, environmental assessment, strategic environmental assessment, adaptive management, and marine spatial planning (MSP). Each of these concepts were expounded on to discuss the limitations of the current research on the concept and identify promising avenues for future research. In comparing the functionality of these concepts, most have a realized capacity for understanding costs and benefits, risk and uncertainty. However less than half have a realized capacity for managing costs and benefits and risk, while less than a third have a realized capacity for managing uncertainty. This paper offers a summary table of existing theories and frameworks that could be used as a launching point for detailing a research agenda for more systematically exploring theories and frameworks for human dimensions of tidal energy.","author":["Wiesebron, L.","Dreyer, S.","Polis, H.","Jenkins, L.","Linder, H.","Beaver, E.","Kowalski, A.","McMillin, T.","McTiernan, K.","Rogier, T."],"organization":["Arizona State University","University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1787","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-hydrokinetic-renewable-energy-technologies-potential-navigational-impacts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/970954","title":"Marine and Hydrokinetic Renewable Energy Technologies: Potential Navigational Impacts and Mitigation Measures","description":"On April 15, 2008, the Department of Energy (DOE) issued a Funding Opportunity Announcement for Advanced Water Power Projects which included a Topic Area for Marine and Hydrokinetic Renewable Energy Market Acceleration Projects. Within this Topic Area, DOE identified potential navigational impacts of marine and hydrokinetic renewable energy technologies and measures to prevent adverse impacts on navigation as a sub-topic area. DOE defines marine and hydrokinetic technologies as those capable of utilizing one or more of the following resource categories for energy generation: ocean waves; tides or ocean currents; free flowing water in rivers or streams; and energy generation from the differentials in ocean temperature. PCCI was awarded Cooperative Agreement DE-FC36-08GO18177 from the DOE to identify the potential navigational impacts and mitigation measures for marine hydrokinetic technologies, as summarized herein. The contract also required cooperation with the U.S. Coast Guard (USCG) and two recipients of awards (Pacific Energy Ventures and reVision) in a sub-topic area to develop a protocol to identify streamlined, best-siting practices. Over the period of this contract, PCCI and our sub-consultants, David Basco, Ph.D., and Neil Rondorf of Science Applications International Corporation, met with USCG headquarters personnel, with U.S. Army Corps of Engineers headquarters and regional personnel,\u00a0with U.S. Navy regional personnel and other ocean users in order to develop an understanding of existing practices for the identification of navigational impacts that might occur during construction, operation, maintenance, and decommissioning. At these same meetings, \u201cstandard\u201d and potential mitigation measures were discussed so that guidance could be prepared for project developers. Concurrently, PCCI reviewed navigation guidance published by the USCG and international community. This report summarizes the results of this effort, provides guidance in the form of a checklist for assessing the navigational impacts of potential marine and hydrokinetic projects, and provides guidance for improving the existing navigational guidance promulgated by the USCG in Navigation Vessel Inspection Circular 02 07. At the request of the USCG, our checklist and mitigation guidance was written in a generic nature so that it could be equally applied to offshore wind projects. PCCI teleconferenced on a monthly basis with DOE, Pacific Energy Ventures and reVision in order to share information and review work products. Although the focus of our effort was on marine and hydrokinetic technologies, as defined above, this effort drew upon earlier work by the USCG on offshore wind renewable energy installations. The guidance provided herein can be applied equally to marine and hydrokinetic technologies and to offshore wind, which are collectively referred to by the USCG as Renewable Energy Installations.","author":["Hudon, T.","Cool, R.","Basco, D.","Rondorf, N."],"organization":["PCCI, Inc.","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2009-12-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Cool_et_al_2009_Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1788","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stream-hydrokinetic-power-review-appraisal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ascelibrary.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1061\/(ASCE)EY.1943-7897.0000197","title":"In-Stream Hydrokinetic Power: Review and Appraisal","description":"The objective of this paper is to provide a review of in-stream hydrokinetic power, which is defined as electric power generated by devices capturing the energy of naturally flowing water\u2014stream, tidal, or open ocean flows\u2014without impounding the water. North America has significant in-stream energy resources, and hydrokinetic electric power technologies to harness those resources have the potential to make a significant contribution to U.S. electricity needs by adding as much as 120\u2009\u2009TWh\/year from rivers alone to the present hydroelectric power generation capacity. Additionally, tidal and ocean current resources in the U.S. respectively contain 438\u2009\u2009TWh\/year and 163 TWh\/year of extractable power. Among their attractive features, in-stream hydrokinetic operations do not contribute to greenhouse gas emissions or other air pollution and have less visual impact than wind turbines. Since these systems do no utilize dams the way traditional hydropower systems typically do, their impact on the environment will differ, and a small but growing number of studies support conclusions regarding those impacts. Potential environmental impacts include altered water quality, altered sediment deposition, altered habitats, direct impact on biota, and navigability of waterways.","author":["Bevelhimer, M.","Cribbs, A.","VanZwieten, J.","McAnally, W.","Davis, T.","Martin, J.","Ahmad, J.","Lippert, R.","Hudon, T.","Trudeau, M."],"organization":["Florida Atlantic University","Mississippi State University","Cooper Union College","US Army Engineer Research and Development Center","Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL)","Ecomerit Technologies","Boeing"],"originationDate":"2015-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1789","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-hydrokinetic-energy-development-technical-support-general-environmental-studies","sourceURL":"","title":"Marine and Hydrokinetic Energy Development Technical Support and General Environmental Studies","description":"In response to the Energy Independence and Security Act (EISA) of 2007, the U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy (EERE) Waterpower Program Office developed a program on marine and hydrokinetic (MHK) energy development. During fiscal year 2009 (FY09) the EERE Waterpower Program provided support to Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) to enable staff to interact with the MHK industry, regulators, and other stakeholders to learn more about the challenges of accelerating the MHK industry to a sustainable source of energy and to make connections among those groups.\nPNNL staff carried out a program of stakeholder outreach during FY09 to accomplish the following:\n\nIdentify the breadth of individuals and groups with a stake in MHK development to understand which groups have the ability to affect the course and success of MHK industrial development.\n\u00a0Develop an understanding of the key environmental and socioeconomic issues facing MHK development.\nIdentify stakeholders who can provide information about key environmental issues and outcomes of MHK development.\nDevelop and deliver unbiased information about MHK development for the interested public.\n\nStakeholders were initially identified and contacted informally, and each contact led to others. Conferences and workshops were a rich source of contacts. Using standard outreach techniques, PNNL staff parsed the stakeholders into three groups:\n\n\u00a0an essential group without whose involvement the industry cannot progress (essential)\ninfluential stakeholders who may have an impact on the outcome of a technology, siting or permitting processes, or who have influence over essential players (influential\nstakeholders interested in the outcome of the MHK industry due to place-based interests or concerns (interested).\nSpecific activities and products generated during FY09 included\n\na capitalization survey of the largest U.S. MHK companies\na survey of the regulatory landscape\na modeling report on Tacoma Narrows tidal energy.\n\nLessons learned from PNNL\u2019s outreach effort include the following:\n\nEach stakeholder group has important information to contribute to the understanding of what is needed to develop the MHK industry, in terms of technical perspectives as well as acceleration to market.\nThe MHK industry in the United States and in other countries with active MHK endeavors is an important source of information about the technologies, project proposals, and challenges of developing a sustainable MHK industry.\nThe industry generally has limited insight into regulatory needs for siting and permitting processes.\nThe MHK industry in the United States is severely undercapitalized, which can exacerbate a potential adversarial relationship with regulatory agencies and other stakeholders as they struggle to meet environmental assessment and siting needs.\nThe regulatory community is struggling to develop appropriate regulatory processes and steps to permit MHK devices.\nInfluential stakeholders, including Indian Tribes, major nongovernmental organizations, elected officials, and place-based groups, have little understanding of MHK technologies and limited knowledge of the regulatory environment that will be needed to establish the industry.\n\nFuture directions that will help to accelerate the development of a sustainable MHK industry in the United States include the following:\n\na broad-based education and outreach program\ninteraction with individuals in the industry, as well as regulatory and resource management agencies\nparticipation in ongoing planning exercises, including coastal and marine spatial planning and regional ocean planning\na framework and roadmapping activities that help to organize information.","author":["Copping, A.","Geerlofs, S."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/CoppingandGeerlofs_2010_Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1790","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/going-flow-tidal-influence-occurrence-harbour-porpoise-phocoena-phocoena-marsdiep-area","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1385110115300332","title":"Going with the flow: Tidal influence on the occurrence of the harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena) in the Marsdiep area, The Netherlands","description":"One of the most important factors explaining the distribution and behaviour of coastal marine mammals are tides. Tidal forces drive a large number of primary and secondary processes, such as changes in water depth, salinity, temperature, current velocity and direction. Unravelling which tidal process is the most influential for a certain species is often challenging, due to a lack of observations of all tide related covariates, strong correlation between them, and the elusive nature of most marine organisms which often hampers their detection.\n\nIn the Marsdiep area, a tidal inlet between the North Sea and the Dutch Wadden Sea, the presence of harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena) was studied as a function of tide related covariates. Observations were carried out in early spring from a ferry crossing the inlet on a half hourly basis. Environmental and sightings data were collected by one observer, while an on-board Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP) and temperature sensor continuously recorded current velocity profiles and temperature, respectively. Sea surface temperature and salinity were measured at a nearby jetty. Sightings (n\u00a0=\u00a0134) were linked to tidal elevation, geographical position, local depth-averaged current velocity, water temperature (with and without trend correction) and salinity.\n\nVariation in sighting rate was best described by salinity, with highest sighting rate at high levels of salinity (\u003E\u00a030\u00a0g\u00a0kg\u2212\u00a01), indicating that porpoises enter the area in bodies of (more saline) North Sea water. Second best variable was time of day, with the highest sighting rate early morning, and decreasing during the day. However, surveys in the morning happened to coincide more often with high water and hence, the apparent time of day effect could be due to collinearity. Most porpoises were present in the northern part of the Marsdiep, particularly during high tide.\n\nTide dependent sighting rates confirmed that porpoises reside in the North Sea, and enter the western Wadden Sea during the flood and leave during ebb. This tidal influx is most likely related to prey availability, which corresponds to other recent studies in this area showing higher fish abundance during high tide. Documenting information on tide related patterns could be used in practice, when e.g. planning anthropogenic activities or assessing critical habitats for this species.","author":["Aarts, G.","Nauw, J.","IJsseldijk, L.","Camhuysen, K."],"organization":["IMARES - Wageningen UR","Utrecht University","Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research (NIOZ)","Wageningen University and Research Centre"],"originationDate":"2015-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.981284900000","4.776528900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1791","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/quantifying-avian-avoidance-offshore-wind-turbines-current-evidence-key-knowledge-gaps","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.marenvres.2018.06.017","title":"Quantifying avian avoidance of offshore wind turbines: Current evidence and key knowledge gaps","description":"The risk of collision between birds and turbines is seen as one of the key issues in the planning process for offshore wind farms. In some cases, predictions of collision risk have led to projects either being withdrawn from the planning process, or refused planning consent. Despite this, the evidence base on which collision risk is assessed is extremely limited and assessments rely on models which can be highly sensitive to assumptions, notably about bird collision avoidance behaviour. We present a synthesis of the current state of knowledge about collision risk and avoidance behaviour in seabirds. Evidence suggests species-specific responses to turbines and that in order to avoid collision, most birds adjust their flight paths at some distance from the turbines, rather than making last-second adjustments. We highlight the key gaps in knowledge and make recommendations for future data collection.","author":["Masden, E.","Burton, N.","Cook, A.","Humphreys, E.","Bennet, F."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","Marine Scotland Science","Environmental Research Institute (ERI)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.983333000000","-3.283333000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1792","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/numerical-modelling-flight-behaviour-bats-estimate-collision-risk-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ubt.opus.hbz-nrw.de\/opus45-ubtr\/frontdoor\/deliver\/index\/docId\/832\/file\/MAller_Christina.pdf","title":"Numerical modelling of the flight behaviour of bats to estimate the collision risk with wind turbines","description":"In this thesis, we present a new approach for estimating the effects of wind turbines for a local bat population. We build an individual based model (IBM) which simulates the movement behaviour of every single bat of the population with its own preferences, foraging behaviour and other species characteristics. This behaviour is normalized by a Monte-Carlo simulation which gives us the average behaviour of the population. The result is an occurrence map of the considered habitat which tells us how often the bat and therefore the considered bat population frequent every region of this habitat. Hence, it is possible to estimate the crossing rate of the position of an existing or potential wind turbine. We compare this individual based approach with a partial differential equation based method. This second approach produces a lower computational effort but, unfortunately, we lose information about the movement trajectories at the same time. Additionally, the PDE based model only gives us a density profile. Hence, we lose the information how often each bat crosses special points in the habitat in one night.rnIn a next step we predict the average number of fatalities for each wind turbine in the habitat, depending on the type of the wind turbine and the behaviour of the considered bat species. This gives us the extra mortality caused by the wind turbines for the local population. This value is used for a population model and finally we can calculate whether the population still grows or if there already is a decline in population size which leads to the extinction of the population.rnUsing the combination of all these models, we are able to evaluate the conflict of wind turbines and bats and to predict the result of this conflict. Furthermore, it is possible to find better positions for wind turbines such that the local bat population has a better chance to survive.rnSince bats tend to move in swarm formations under certain circumstances, we introduce swarm simulation using partial integro-differential equations. Thereby, we have a closer look at existence and uniqueness properties of solutions.","author":["Muller, C."],"organization":["Trier University"],"originationDate":"2018-02-09","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1793","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/determining-night-time-distribution-long-tailed-ducks-using-satellite-telemetry","sourceURL":"https:\/\/espis.boem.gov\/final%20reports\/4823.pdf","title":"Determining Night-Time Distribution of Long-Tailed Ducks Using Satellite Telemetry","description":"Mass Audubon staff in partnership with USGS have used satellite telemetry to gather information on nighttime roosting locations for Long-tailed Duck (LTDU) (Clangula hyemalis), especially with respect to Horseshoe Shoal, the proposed site of a 130-turbine wind farm. Hundreds of thousands of LTDUs overwinter in Nantucket Sound. These LTDU Nantucket display commuting behavior: each day at dawn, thousands of LTDU exit the Sound traveling to feeding sites on Nantucket Shoals, returning to the Sound at dusk. Mass Audubon and the applicant for the Cape Wind project have conducted extensive aerial surveys of Nantucket during daylight hours when the vast majority of LTDUs are absent from the Sound. Previously there was little direct information available regarding the nighttime roosting locations of LTDUs, especially in relation to Horseshoe Shoal. In particular, we needed to know whether Horseshoe Shoal is used by significant numbers of LTDUs as a nighttime roosting site or staging area as they exit or return to Nantucket Sound. If the answer to this question was yes, then the LTDUs would be potentially at risk of collision with the wind turbines when they enter, exit, or otherwise move within the project area. A principal goal of our avian monitoring has been to obtain a reliable baseline estimate of the relative abundance of wintering sea ducks that will, in future surveys, allow us to detect and interpret changes in bird abundance and distribution in Nantucket Sound.","author":["Allison, T.","Perkins, S.","Perry, M."],"organization":["Audubon Society","US Geological Survey (USGS)","US Minerals Management Service (MMS)"],"originationDate":"2009-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.609312000000","-70.304207000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/allisonetal2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1794","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-lighting-schemes-offshore-wind-facilities-impacts-local-environments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/espis.boem.gov\/final%20reports\/5298.pdf","title":"Evaluation of Lighting Schemes for Offshore Wind Facilities and Impacts to Local Environments","description":"Given BOEM\u2019s authority under the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (EPAct), and the various considerations under the OCS Lands Act and NEPA, BOEM needs to garner a better understanding of the potential impacts to the environment from the development of offshore renewable energy projects, and to identify specific mitigation measures that can be taken to reduce or avoid such impacts. The ESS Project Team, comprised of ESS Group, Inc. (ESS), GL Garrad Hassan America Inc. (GL GH), Curry and Kerlinger LLC (C\u0026amp;K), and Mote Marine Laboratory (MML), was selected to conduct a review of regulations and lighting schemes currently in use and evaluate how proposed lighting schemes for offshore wind facilities may impact local environments and offshore waters as a desktop study, literature review and synthesis.  The study was conducted in three parts: 1. a literature review of scientific studies, journals and grey literature of the potential direct and indirect impacts of various lighting schemes to birds, bats, marine mammals, sea turtles and fish was conducted; 2. a compilation of current international and domestic guidelines, rules and regulations for obstruction and navigation lights for offshore wind facilities was conducted, and project specific information was gathered from operational offshore wind facilities throughout the world describing various lighting schemes currently in use; and 3. using information from the literature review and project specific lighting schemes, measures to mitigate impacts to wildlife and coastal communities were identified and evaluated.  In general, the literature review found few studies that were specific to the lighting of offshore wind turbines and their impact to the identified biological resources (birds, bats, marine mammals, sea turtles and fish). The primary tenet in reducing impacts to night-migrating birds from lighted structures is reducing the amount of light broadcast into the environment. Many of the studies reviewed agree on a few general principles regarding mitigation of impacts to avian resources from offshore lighting. These are the following. 1) Fewer lights are preferable to more lights. 2) Lower intensity lights are preferable to higher intensity lights. 3) White lights are the least favorable choice for lighting structures. 4) Strobing lights are preferable to steady lights.  Impacts to bats from offshore lighting are less well-defined than those for birds, and appear to be linked to insect attraction. Several references considered artificial lighting on marine mammals during the operational phase of wind facilities to be in the low risk and low negative effect category. Intermittent flashing lights with a very short on-pulse and long off-interval have been shown to be non-disruptive to marine turtle behavior, irrespective of the color. These findings are consistent with flashing marine navigational lighting (MNL) currently being used at offshore wind facilities not causing disorientation of turtles. Much of the literature appears to be based on direct lighting of the water surface, and it is unlikely that any indirect lighting from aviation obstruction lighting (AOL) or MNL will have any meaningful impact on fish, although the literature that investigated lighting impacts to fish indicated that the effects of artificial light on fish and other marine organisms needs to be studied in greater detail.  Currently operating offshore wind facilities (OWF) in Europe and elsewhere tend to follow international guidelines for the lighting and marking of offshore structures, although variations do exist on a case by case basis. The FAA and the USCG are generally consistent with international standards, and the guidelines that are currently in place in the U.S. appear to provide for the marking and lighting of OWF that will pose minimal if any impacts to birds, bats, marine mammals, sea turtles or fish.  Suggested Best Practices for minimizing impacts from lighting of OWF:    Continue consultation and collaboration with the FAA and USCG. Existing guidelines and regulations appear to be adequate to develop safe lighting plans for OWF on a case by case basis.  Minimize lighting whenever and wherever possible. This includes minimizing the number of lights, the intensity of lights, and the amount of time lights are turned on.  The use of lights that appear red to the eye for AOL should continue to be preferred over white, flashing lights should be used whenever practicable, and steady burning lights should be avoided.  Flashing lights should use the lowest flash rate practicable for the application (i.e., 20 rather than 60 flashes per minute) to maximize the duration \u201coff\u201d between flashes.  Avoid direct lighting of the water surface, and minimize indirect lighting on the water surface to the extent practicable once the OWF is in operation. During construction, it may not be possible to avoid temporary lighting of the water surface for short durations and still maintain worker safety and construction schedules.  Direct lighting to where it is needed and avoid general area \u201cfloodlighting\u201d. Area and work lighting should be limited to the amount and intensity necessary to maintain worker safety.  Automatic timers and\/or motion activated shutoffs should be considered for all lights not related to AOL or MNL.  AOL should be most conspicuous to aviators, and the lighting spread below the horizontal plane of the light should be minimal.  Allow for the automatic reduction of AOL intensity when visibility sensors indicate that the meteorological visibility is conducive to safely do so; for example, reducing the AOL to 30% when visibility is 5 km (3.1 mi) or greater and to 10% when visibility is 10 km (6.2mi) or greater. Consultation with, and agreement by, the FAA will likely be necessary if this practice is to be considered.","author":["Orr, T.","Herz, S.","Oakley, D."],"organization":["ESS Group Inc","BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs"],"originationDate":"2013-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Lighting"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Orretal2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1795","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/collision-risk-model-rufa-red-knots-calidris-canutus-rufa-interacting-proposed","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/WEST-final-report-M14PD00050\/","title":"Collision Risk Model for \u0022rufa\u0022 Red Knots (Calidris canutus rufa) Interacting with a Proposed Offshore Wind Energy Facility in Nantucket Sound, Massachusetts","description":"The objective of the present study was to produce a robust, quantitative prediction of fatality rates of \u201crufa\u201d Red Knots (Calidris canutus rufa) resulting from collisions with the physical structures of a yet-to-be-constructed offshore wind energy facility (the \u201cFacility\u201d) that has been approved for construction in federal waters of Nantucket Sound, Massachusetts. To accomplish this objective, we assembled a technical team consisting of field leading experts in offshore wind bird collision risk assessment, collision risk modeling, and Red Knot biology to synthesize existing technical information on this subject, and to use this synthesis as the basis for developing an original quantitative collision risk modeling effort.  A comprehensive review of technical literature related to bird collision risk modeling at offshore wind energy facilities was performed as an initial step in this process. On the basis of this review, we adopted a modeling approach that included the Band (2012) model to represent a subset of collision dynamics, with various additional elements incorporated to represent the most important biological and meteorological dynamics of the system of interest, as hypothesized and conceived by the Project\u2019s technical team on the basis of best available scientific information. We developed an original simulation model to represent this system, and conducted a series of simulations with the model in order to produce quantitative predictions of Red Knot fatality rates resulting from collisions with the structures of the approved Facility. These simulations included variation in several of the model\u2019s inputs in order to characterize the sensitivity of the model\u2019s fatality rate predictions to changes in these inputs.  The overall average collision fatality rate for rufa Red Knots at the approved Facility predicted by our model was 0.16 Red Knots per year equivalent to one fatality every 6.25 years, composed of 0.10 predicted fatalities per fall migration season and 0.060 predicted fatalities per spring migration season, under baseline, or default model inputs. Predicted fatalities scaled linearly with population size, such that under the assumption of a \u201crecovered\u201d population three times the size of the current population, the predicted fatality rates were exactly three times higher.  Collision fatality rates were largely driven by collisions of Red Knots with stationary structures, and particularly turbine towers, in our modeled results, with turbine towers accounting for roughly 90% of all collision fatalities in most simulations. The influence of collisions with turbine towers was also evidenced by the result that for all model iterations in which at least one collision occurred, the average number of collisions was approximately eight, corresponding to the number of Red Knot wingspan lengths in the tower\u2019s diameter. Red Knots were represented flying in chevron-shaped flocks, aligned wingtip to wingtip in our model, hence when the path of a flock intercepted a turbine tower, seven or eight collisions typically resulted, depending on the elevation at which the flock encountered the tapered, cylindrical towers.  Biologically realistic representations of the influence of variations in wind speed and direction, precipitation, and visibility were incorporated into the model in the form of behavioral switches between high and low elevation migratory flight altitude distributions (effective headwind speed, heavy precipitation), fall migratory flight departure delay decisions (effective headwind speed), and avoidance rate parameters (heavy precipitation, visibility, and effective headwind speed). Simulation results indicated that of these, only effective headwind speed exerted a strong influence on the fatality rates. The relative insensitivity of fatality rates to variation in precipitation was explained by the relative rarity of heavy precipitation events during the migratory seasons of interest, as characterized by an empirical summary of hourly precipitation data from regional meteorological data. Low visibility events occurred more frequently than heavy precipitation events within the Facility region during the seasons of interest. Nonetheless, low visibility conditions were still far less common than high visibility conditions, resulting in an overall weak influence of variation in visibility on modeled fatality rates. By contrast to heavy precipitation and low visibility , the effective headwind conditions that were hypothesized to trigger behavioral switches in migrating Red Knots occurred more commonly, and consequently exerted a more important influence on modeled fatality rates. Specifically, fatality rates were significantly higher when the effective headwind speed threshold for fall migratory flight departure was below the effective headwind speed threshold for switching from the high-altitude to the low-altitude flight distribution. Under such conditions, fall migrating birds would commonly decide to fly under conditions that would cause them to fly at a lower altitude. In all other conditions, fall migrating birds would either tend to fly at a higher altitude, or not fly at all.  Relaxing the Band model\u2019s assumption of perpendicular approach angle had a marginally significant influence on fatality rates for approach angles close to perpendicular to the rotor (head on) and a negligible influence for approach angles close to parallel to the rotor. Altering the mean flight altitudes had a slight influence on modeled fatality rates for the high-altitude flight distribution, which was elected by migrating birds in our model under favorable weather conditions, and a moderate influence on fatality rates for the low-altitude flight distribution, which was elected by migrating birds in our model under poor weather conditions.  Avoidance behaviors were incorporated in our model at two distinct spatial scales. Macro-avoidance was defined as the avoidance of the entire modeled wind farm by a flock of birds that sees the Facility from a distance. Our model included the assumption that macro-avoidance ability was diminished to near zero (0.01) under low visibility conditions or heavy precipitation. Micro-avoidance was defined as the avoidance of a wind energy Facility structure by a flock that was present within the Facility, and approaching the structure. In our model, micro-avoidance capacity was reduced by the presence of heavy precipitation, strong headwinds, and low visibility, and separate micro-avoidance rates were included for stationary versus (vs.) moving structures. Modeled fatality results generally exerted a moderate level of sensitivity to variation in macro-avoidance rates and a high level of sensitivity to variation in micro-avoidance rates. These patterns are consistent with a general trend reported in previous studies of bird collision risk with offshore wind energy facility structures, and highlight the importance of characterizing birds\u2019 behavioral responses to wind energy facilities for understanding collision risk.","author":["Gordon, C.","Nations, C."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.363666000000","-70.272553000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Shorebirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gordon_and_Nations_2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1796","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparison-supervised-learning-techniques-classification-bat-echolocation-calls","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954110000919","title":"A comparison of supervised learning techniques in the classification of bat echolocation calls","description":"Today\u0027s acoustic monitoring devices are capable of recording and storing tremendous amounts of data. Until recently, the classification of animal vocalizations from field recordings has been relegated to qualitative approaches. For large-scale acoustic monitoring studies, qualitative approaches are very time-consuming and suffer from the bias of subjectivity. Recent developments in supervised learning techniques can provide rapid, accurate, species-level classification of bioacoustics data. We compared the classification performances of four supervised learning techniques (random forests, support vector machines, artificial neural networks, and discriminant function analysis) for five different classification tasks using bat echolocation calls recorded by a popular frequency-division bat detector. We found that all classifiers performed similarly in terms of overall accuracy with the exception of discriminant function analysis, which had the lowest average performance metrics. Random forests had the advantage of high sensitivities, specificities, and predictive powers across the majority of classification tasks, and also provided metrics for determining the relative importance of call features in distinguishing between groups. Overall classification accuracy for each task was slightly lower than reported accuracies using calls recorded by time-expansion detectors. Myotis spp. were particularly difficult to separate; classifiers performed best when members of this genus were combined in genus-level classification and analyzed separately at the level of species. Additionally, we identified and ranked the relative contributions of all predictor features to classifier accuracy and found measurements of frequency, total call duration, and characteristic slope to be the most important contributors to classification success. We provide recommendations to maximize accuracy and efficiency when analyzing acoustic data, and suggest an application of automated bioacoustics monitoring to contribute to wildlife monitoring efforts.","author":["Armitage, D.","Ober, H."],"organization":["University of Florida"],"originationDate":"2010-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1797","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/feasibility-lca-wave-dragon-platform-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.onepetro.org\/conference-paper\/ISOPE-I-16-546","title":"Feasibility and LCA for a Wave Dragon platform with wind turbines","description":"The objective of this study is to assess the environmental and economic performance of a combined wind-wave energy converter over its entire lifecycle. The lifecycle analysis covers embedded costs, energy balance and carbon footprint, right from the raw materials to the final decommissioning. It is demonstrated that Wave Dragon in combination with wind has a 17% lower LCOE than a Wave Dragon without wind turbines. This is due to the fact that wind turbines are a very cost efficient technology when deployed in high wind speed sites if the costs of foundation and grid connection can be kept at a reasonable level \u2013 and this is obviously the case when installing on top of a heavy and stable platform like Wave Dragon.","author":["Friis-Madsen, E.","Russell, I.","Soerensen, H.","Parmeggiani, S.","Fernandez-Chozas, J."],"organization":["Wave Dragon ApS"],"originationDate":"2016-06-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-28 04:04:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1798","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/progress-renewable-energies-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/books.google.com\/books?id=qBINDgAAQBAJ\u0026printsec=frontcover\u0026dq=Progress+in+Renewable+Energies+Offshore\u0026hl=en\u0026sa=X\u0026ved=0ahUKEwj_t8fV45LdAhVmllQKHUqCBHcQ6AEIJzAA#v=onepage\u0026q\u0026f=false","title":"Progress in Renewable Energies Offshore","description":"Renewable energies offshore are becoming a significant contributor to the total energy produced in some countries and the interest in the subject is increasing worldwide. Various forms of renewable energy are being developed, from which some are at sea. There are some forms of energy that depend on the sea such as wave, tides and OTEC, which are the ones traditionally known as ocean energy but there are others like wind energy that can also be located at sea and thus be subjected to the same environmental conditions. Therefore, this conference is aimed at addressing all forms of renewable energy at sea, expanding from the concept of ocean energies.   The first International Conference on Renewable Energies Offshore (RENEW2014) was organized at Instituto Superior Tecnico contributing to the exchange of information on the developments and experience obtained in concept development, design and operation of such devices.   The scope of this second Conference is broad, covering all aspects of the renewable energies offshore activities such as resource assessment; wind energy; wave energy; tidal energy; ocean energy devices; multiuse platforms; PTO design; grid connection; economic assessment; installment and maintenance planning.   The Conference aims at covering academically oriented papers, although not only from academic audiences, complementing the various existing initiatives that are associated with exhibitions of equipment both of ocean energy and of wind energy. Therefore, the papers have been subjected to a review process on the full papers and we leave here the recognition of the efforts of the various anonymous reviewers and of the Technical Programme Committee, who shared an important part of the review process.   The final result after the review process of the 180 submitted abstracts are around 103 papers presented in 4 parallel sessions during the 3 days of the conference. The conference included also plenary presentations in the first morning with a number of invited speakers providing overviews of relevant matters in the various areas.   The contents of the present book are organized in the main subject areas corresponding to the sessions of the Conference and within each group the papers are listed by the alphabetic order of the authors.      Resource assessment - waves       A hindcast study on wave energy variablility and trends in Le Croisic, France M. Goncalves, P. Martinho \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares  On the peak period distributions conditions on significant wave heights in Aqucadoura, Portugal G. Muraleedharan, C. Lucas, D. Martins \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Assessing the wave energy potential in the Mediterranean Sea using WAVEWATCH III D. Pelli, L. Cappietti \u0026amp; H. Oumeraci   Assessing the utility and effectiveness of the IEC standards for wave energy resource characterisation V. Ramos, R. Carballo \u0026amp; J.V. Ringwood  Wave energy potential assessment along the west coast of Fuerteventura G. Rodriguez, G. Clarindo \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Wave energy resource assessment from a 12-year hindcast, for Pembrokshire, Wales A.R. Bento, P. Martinho \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Trends in the available wave power at the Portuguese pilot zone D. Silva, P. Martinho \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Development of a numerical modelling tool for combined near field and far field wave transformations using a coupling of potential flow solvers T. Verbrugghe, P. Troch, A. Kortenhaus, V. Stratigaki \u0026amp; A.P. Engsig-Karup       Resource assessment - tidal        Evaluation of the Agucadoura pilot area as an ocean current turbine site with ROMS modeled ocean current data T.C. Costa, L.T. Pereira, M. Marta-Almeida \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Assessing the importance of including waves in simulations of tidal stream turbine impacts I. Fairley \u0026amp; H. Karunarathna   Exploring the utility and effectiveness of tidal stream energy resource assessment and characterisation standards: A case study V. Ramos, R. Carballo \u0026amp; J.V. Ringwood  Tidal energy resource characterisation in the Dover Strait by using VHF radar and ADCP measurements M. Thiebaut \u0026amp; A. Sentchev       Resource assessment - wind       Assessing climate change effect in offshore wind power in the North of Portugal M. Bernardino \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Regional frequency analysis of wind speed on the coast of Portugal R.M. Campos \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   A methodology for the power performance assessment of floating offshore wind turbines A. Couto, P.A.P. Justino, J. Silva \u0026amp; A. Estanqueiro   Application of reanalysis data for offshore wind power potential assessment off the west coast of India G. Nagababu, N.K. Naidu, S.S. Kachhwaha \u0026amp; V. Savsani        Environmental monitoring       Development of an autonomous offshore monitoring system D.B.S. Lopes \u0026amp; H. Sarmento   Evaluation of offshore wind power potential of India by combining satellite and moored buoy data N.K. Naidu, G. Nagababu, S.S. Kachhwaha \u0026amp; V. Savsani   High resolution monitoring for marine renewable energy L. Ren \u0026amp; M. Hartnett   Additional attenuation detection and correction of radar wave within the interior region of offshore wind farm L. Xie, S.W. Wang, X.P. Yan, F. Ma \u0026amp; S. Haugen        Wave energy devices       Energy capture optimization for an adaptive wave energy converter J.J. Barradas-Berglind, H. Meijer, M. van Rooij, S. Clemente-Pinol, B. Galvan-Garcia, W.A. Prins, A.I. Vakis \u0026amp; B. Jayawardhana  Biomimetic marine energy devices in waves and sheared currents K.A. Belibassakis, E.S. Filippas \u0026amp; Th.P. Gerostathis   Systems engineering applied to the development of a wave energy farm D. Bull, J. Roberts, R. Malins, A. Babarit, J. Weber, K. Dykes, R. Costello, B. Kennedy, K. Neilson \u0026amp; C. Bittencourt   Numerical simulation of a single Floating Point Absorber Wave Energy Converter using OpenFOAM\u00a9 B. Devolder, P. Rauwoens \u0026amp; P. Troch   Revenue optimization for the Ocean Grazer wave energy converter through storage utilization H.T. Dijkstra, J.J. Barradas-Berglind, H. Meijer, M. van Rooij, W.A. Prins, A.I. Vakis \u0026amp; B. Jayawardhana   Numerical and experimental studies of water impact on conical point absorber buoys H. Li, H. -Z. He, S. -H. Yang, J. Zhang, J. Liang \u0026amp; W. Sheng   Study of the influence of design parameters on the structural behavior of a point absorber wave converter using a finite element approach C. Malca, R. Felismina \u0026amp; P. Beirao   Design optimization of a multifunctional wave energy device G. Palma, S.M. Formentin, B. Zanuttigh, P. Contestabile \u0026amp; D. Vicinanza   Wave energy generation with thermo-chemical storage: Getting a uniform injection into the grid M.C. Rodriguez-Hidalgo, A. Lopez, A. de Bonis, P.A. Rodriguez-Aumente \u0026amp; A. Lecuona   Wave dragon -- \u0027Coldward and Stormward\u0027 I. Russell, E. Friis-Madsen \u0026amp; H.-C. Soerensen   Wave Energy converters: Fix- or self-referenced? W. Sheng \u0026amp; T. Lewis   Modelling of the 3-float WEC M4 with nonlinear PTO options and longer bow beam P.K. Stansby, E. Carpintero Moreno \u0026amp; T. Stallard   Performance of the three-float wave energy converter M4 in regular and random waves L. Sun, J. Zang, P.K. Stansby \u0026amp; E. Carpintero Moreno  The modelling of a flap type wave energy converter in a time-dependent mild-slope equation model N. Tomey-Bozo, J. Murphy, T. Lewis, P. Troch, A. Babarit \u0026amp; G. Thomas    Hydodynamic analysis and optimization of a wave activated device S. Xu, J.M. Rodrigues \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares        Wave energy devices - OWC       Performance of oscillating water column wave energy converters integrated in breakwaters V. Anvesh, D. Karmakar \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   The first worldwide application at full-scale of the REWEC3 device in the Port of Civitavecchia: Inital energetic performances F. Arena, A. Romolo, G. Malara, V. Fiamma \u0026amp; V. Laface   Parametric study of blade shape to enhance performance of a turbine used in OWC K. Ezhilsabareesh \u0026amp; A. Samad   Turbine choice and optimization for a shoreline OWC wave energy plant A.F.O. Falcao, J.C.C. Henriques \u0026amp; L.M.C. Gato   A CFD analysis of the wave field in front of a U-OWC breakwater P. Filianoti \u0026amp; L. Gurnari   Mathematical modeling of a non-axisymmetric floating OWC P.A.P. Justino   Site-specific optimization of an OWC wave energy converter in a Mediterranean area I. Simonetti, I. Crema, L. Cappietti, H. El Safti \u0026amp; H. Oumeraci   Integration of breakthrough concepts into the OWC spar buoy B. Teillant, Y. Debruyne, A. Sarmento, R. Gomes, L.M.C. Gato, M. Fontana, M. Philippe \u0026amp; A. Combourieu        Wave energy devices - arrays       A 3D-BEM coupled-mode method for WEC arrays in variable bathymetry K.A. Belibassakis, Th.P. Gerostathis \u0026amp; G.A. Athanassoulis   Time domain analysis of array interaction and different heading angles for wave energy converter arrays F. Kara   A critical discussion about optimisation approaches for ocean energy array design V. Nava, M.B.R. Topper, P. Ruiz-Minguela, A. de Andres \u0026amp; H. Jeffrey   Influence of a parabolic reflector wall on the sea state in an array of point absorber wave energy converters R.J. van der Wiel, J. Kramer, P.P.D. van der Ven, M.J.A. Borsboom \u0026amp; M.P.C. de Jong       Wave energy devices - control       Control and instrumentation topologies for an integrated wave energy array C.J. Kenny, D. Findlay, I. Lazakis, J. Shek \u0026amp; P.R. Thies  Improving seabed cable plough performance for offshore renewable energy S. Robinson, M.J. Brown, A.J. Brennan, M. Cortis, C.E. Augarde \u0026amp; W.M. Coombs   Tuning a linear quadratic regulator for point absorber wave energy converters D. Valerio, P. Beirao, G. Vissio, G. Bracco \u0026amp; G. Mattiazzo   ISWEC control tuning: Lessons learned G. Vissio, G. Bracco, E. Giorcelli, G. Mattiazzo, D. Valerio \u0026amp; P. Beirao        Wave energy devices - PTO       Optimization of an oil-hydraulic Power Take-Off system based on an adaptable mechanism interface M. Calvario, J.F. Gaspar, A. Sinha \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Best practices for the use of electrical test infrastructures to validate control strategies: A case study in wave energy conversion F.X. Fay, E. Robles, J.C.H. Henriques \u0026amp; M. Marcos   Practical performances of MPC for wave energy converters F. Ferri, A. Tetu \u0026amp; J. Hals   Concept of reciprocating oil-hydraulic cylinders for increased wave power harvesting J.F. Gaspar, A. Sinha, M. Calvario \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares       Ocean energy devices       Performance assessment for high temperature OTEC plant H.S. Lee, S.T. Lim, J.H. Moon \u0026amp; H.J. Kim   The performance comparison of the OTEC cycles with an ejector J.H. Moon, H.S. Lee, H.J. Kim \u0026amp; J.I. Yoon  Conceptual design of a floating plant of fresh water production by using the ocean thermal energy as power source L.R. Nunez Rivas, J.A. Somolinos Sanchez, L. Blay Munoz \u0026amp; M.P. Portilla   Analytical and numerical investigation of a sea water desalination plant with integration of renewable marine energy (Jorf Lasfar OCP Morocco) D. Saifaoui, M. Rouway, M. Nachtane \u0026amp; M. Tarfaoui        Tidal energy devices       Operation modelling of tidal energy lagoon proposals within the Bristol channel and Severn Estuary A. Angeloudis \u0026amp; R.A. Falconer   Assessing the performance of tidal turbines arrays using an analytical method: Application to the Alderney Race (France) O.A. Lo Brutto, J. Thiebot, S.S. Guillou, H. Gualous \u0026amp; V.T. Nguyen   Load alleviation technology for extending life in tidal turbines A.M. Young, J.R. Farman \u0026amp; R.J. Miller   Experimental investigation of the turbulent flow behind a horizontal axis tidal current turbine C. Del Frate, F. Di Felice, F. Alves Pereira, G.P. Romano, D. Dhome \u0026amp; J.C. Allo   Design and operation of a 1MW four turbine tidal fence F. Heathcote, C.R. Vogel \u0026amp; R.H.J. Willden   Parametric analysis of a tidal current turbine using CFD techniques T. Karthikeyan, K. Ezhilsabareesh, A. Samad, N. Venkatesan \u0026amp; E.J. Avital   Predictions of the dynamic performance of horizontal axis marine current turbines under the effect of different impact scenarios M. Nachtane, M. Tarfaoui, A. El Moumen, M. Ait Mohamed \u0026amp; D. Saifaoui   PD control with buoyancy compensation for automatic emersion maneuvers of first generation TEC J.A. Somolinos Sanchez, M.P. Portilla, M. Espin, L.R. Nunez Rivas, A. Lopez \u0026amp; E. Segura  Assessing the turbulence in a tidal estuary and the effect of turbulence on marine current turbine performance M. Thiebaut, A. Sentchev, F.G. Schmitt \u0026amp; T. Le Kien   Numerical modeling with porous media for current field around HAMT array Y. Watanabe, T. Ikoma, K. Masuda \u0026amp; H. Eto   Computational analysis of blockage designed tidal turbine rotors A. Wimshurst \u0026amp; R.H.J. Willden        Wind energy devices       Pre-Design of a TLP steel-concrete composite substructure for a 6 MW wind turbine as a way to essential cost-reduction F. Adam, U. Ritschel, E. Plumridge \u0026amp; J. Grobmann   Open-sea 1:30 scale tests on a spar-type offshore wind turbine in parked conditions: Progress and future work C. Ruzzo, V. Fiamma, G. Failla, F. Arena, M. Collu \u0026amp; V. Nava   Aero-elastic analysis and classical flutter of a multi-megawatt slender bladed horizontal-axis wind turbine M.A. Sayed, T. Lutz, E. Kramer \u0026amp; F. Borisade   Supervisory system for the automation of model building and simulations with the wind turbine code FAST E. Uzunoglu \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Performance of barge-type floaters for floating wind turbine K.G. Vijay, D. Karmakar, E. Uzunoglu \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Design and automation of a pile test facility for offshore foundations and first experimental results E. Weichhold, F. Dahlhaus, F. Adam, T. Meier \u0026amp; J. Grobmann   Modular jacket offshore wind turbine support structure for the Northern Portuguese coastal zone B. Yeter, Y. Garbatov \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares        Multiuse solutions       Experimental and numerical design of a combined wind-wave concept A. Iturrioz, J. Sarmiento, V. Ayllon, J.A. Armesto, A. Jurado, R. Guanche, C. Vidal \u0026amp; I.J. Losada   Energy yield for co-located offshore wind and tidal stream turbines D.R. Lande-Sudall, T. Stallard \u0026amp; P.K. Stansby   Design of a TLP floating structure concept for combined wind and wave energy exploitation T.P. Mazarakos, D.N. Konispoliatis \u0026amp; S.A. Mavrakos        Mooring systems       Mooring cable simulations with snap load capturing for wave energy applications J. Palm, C. Eskilsson \u0026amp; L. Bergdahl   Experimental testing of mooring for large floating wave energy converters J.B. Thomsen, F. Ferri \u0026amp; J.P. Kofoed   The influence of biofouling on power capture and the fatigue life of mooring lines and power cables used in wave energy converters S.-H. Yang, J.W. Ringsberg \u0026amp; E. Johnson   The dynamic effects of marine growth on a tension moored floating wind turbine C. Wright, J. Murphy \u0026amp; V. Pakrashi        Risk and reliability       Evaluating a novel approach to reliability decision support for offshore wind turbine installation T. Gintautas \u0026amp; J.D. Sorensen   Fault tree analysis of the failure of floating offshore wind turbines support structures and blade systems J.C. Kang, L.P. Sun \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Reliability assessment of tidal stream energy: Significance for large-scale deployment in the UK F. Khalid, P.R. Thies \u0026amp; L. Johanning   Uncertainty management in risk assessment of offshore energy structures U. Okoro \u0026amp; A. Kolios   Uncertainty associated with the estimation of drag and inertia coefficients of fixed vertical cylinders K. Raed, E. Uzunoglu \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   A novel reliability-based simulation tool for offshore renewable technologies G. Rinaldi, L. Johanning, P.R. Thies \u0026amp; R.T. Walker   On the model uncertainty of wave induced responses of a floating semisubmersible wind system E. Uzunoglu \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares       Maintenance planning       Operations and maintenance planning for community-scale, off-grid wave energy devices A. Gray, D. Findlay \u0026amp; L. Johanning   Towards improved forecasting for offshore wind turbine O\u0026amp;M transfers P.R. Mills, B. Stephen, D. McMillan \u0026amp; I. Lazakis   Development of innovative coatings for marine renewable energy A. Rodriguez, B. Santos, V. Gonzalez de Lena, A. Yedra \u0026amp; C. Manteca  Modelling the propagation of underwater acoustic emissions for condition monitoring of marine renewable energy J. Walsh, I. Bashir, P.R. Thies, L. Johanning \u0026amp; Ph. Blondel        Economic assessments       Enhancing marine energy competitiveness: Economic assessment of a co-located wave-wind energy farm S. Astariz \u0026amp; G. Iglesias   Economic feasibility of floating offshore wave farms in Galicia, Spain L. Castro-Santos \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Preliminary cost assessment of an offshore floating wind farm installation on the Galician coast H. Diaz, J.M. Rodrigues \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares  The economic potential value of offshore wind near Berlengas A. Faria Lopes  Mapping economic performance of wave energy C. Frost, D. Findlay, L. Johanning, E. Macpherson \u0026amp; P. Sayer   The potential offshore energy cluster in Portugal A. Pego, M. Marques, R. Salvador, C. Guedes Soares \u0026amp; A. Monteiro   Evaluation of the expected power output of wave energy converters in the north of the Portugueses nearshore D. Silva, E. Rusu \u0026amp; C. Guedes Soares   Capital costs in tidal stream energy projects: A site-specific approach A. Vazquez \u0026amp; G. Iglesias","author":["Soares, C."],"organization":["University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2016-10-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["OTEC","Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:05","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1799","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/case-study-wave-dragon-milford-haven-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aquaret.com\/images\/stories\/aquaret\/pdf\/cswavewavedragon.pdf","title":"Case Study - Wave Dragon Milford Haven Project","description":"The Milford Haven Wave Dragon Pre-Commercial Demonstrator is a floating slack moored wave energy converter with a rated capacity of 7MW. The demonstrator device will be located 2 - 3 miles off the southwest Wales coast, off St Ann\u2019s Head, northwest of Milford Haven, on an area of approximately 0.25 km2. The deployment of the 7 MW Wave Dragon device is the largest undertaking of wave energy deployment to date, and consists of one single device. Unlike other wave energy converters, the Wave Dragon can be scaled up with relative ease compared to multi-MW devices. The first objective of the project is to prove the feasibility of installing and grid connecting the device at commercial scale, with the intention of undertaking tests and verifying performance for a period of up to five years. The intention would then be to commercialise the development of multiple devices to be deployed further offshore as part of a wave farm or array. The second objective of the project is to generate clean electricity from a renewable source of energy. The device is intended to be tested for three to five years, and then removed and the site decommissioned. This demonstrator project has been linked to a further development of a 77MW wave energy farm in the Celtic Sea following the successful demonstrator testing. The demonstration project is being supported by the Welsh Assembly under the Objective 1 initiative and the Welsh Development Agency (WDA) has been supporting the efforts of the project over the last few years. The Welsh Demonstrator project will also host an EC research and development project funded under the Framework Programme 6. Wave Dragon Wales Ltd is backed by KP Renewables Plc who is providing the required co-funding to deliver the project. Wave Dragon is the offshore wave energy technology that has endured one of the most extensive consecutive testing periods: \u201cA 1:4.5 scale prototype launched in 2003 was the world\u2019s first offshore grid-connected wave energy conversion device. Deployed off the coast of Denmark at Nissum Bredning, this test unit has accumulated over 20,000 hours of experience supplying electricity to domestic homes\u201d (www.wavedragon.net)","author":["Wave Dragon ApS"],"organization":["Wave Dragon ApS"],"originationDate":"2008-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 10:49:17","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Case-Study-Wave-Dragon-2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1800","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/monitoring-wintering-geese-aes-geo-energy-wind-farm-st-nikola-territory-kaliakra-2","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aesgeoenergy.com\/site\/images\/Winter%20Report%202017-2018.pdf","title":"Monitoring of wintering geese in the AES Geo Energy Wind Farm \u0022St. Nikola\u0022 territory and the Kaliakra region in winter 2017\/2018","description":"This report presents results of the ornithological survey and monitoring at Saint Nikola Wind Farm (SNWF) in the period 01 December 2017 to 15 March 2018, continuing from similar studies in previous winters before and after construction of SNWF including period of carcass searches and Turbine Shut Down System application in winter 2017-2018. As stated in previous reports the primary objective of wintering bird studies at SNWF is to investigate the possible effects of the wind farm on geese populations, notably the Red-breasted Goose (Branta ruficollis) (RBG) due to its globally threatened conservation status. Previous years\u2019 wintering studies at SNWF have been reported and presented for download on the AES SNWF website.  To date, as documented by previous reports, there have been no indications that SNWF has had any adverse impact on wintering geese, including RBG, and the more abundant Greater Whitefronted Goose (Anser albifrons) (GWFG). This report presents the latest results, from the 2017- 2018 winter monitoring of SNWF.","author":["Whitfield, D.","Zehtindjiev, P."],"organization":["Bulgarian Academy of Sciences","Natural Research Ltd","AES Geo Energy"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.444331700000","28.453690400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zehtindjiev-and-Whitfield-2018-Winter.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1801","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/monitoring-wintering-geese-aes-geo-energy-wind-farm-st-nikola-territory-kaliakra-1","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aesgeoenergy.com\/site\/images\/Winter%20Report%202016-2017.pdf","title":"Monitoring of wintering geese in the AES Geo Energy Wind Farm \u0022St. Nikola\u0022 territory and the Kaliakra region in winter 2016\/2017","description":"This report presents results of the ornithological survey and monitoring at Saint Nikola Wind Farm (SNWF) in the period 01 December 2016 to 15 March 2017, continuing from similar studies in previous winters before and after construction of SNWF including period of carcass searches and Turbine Shut Down System application in winter 2016-2017. As stated in previous reports the primary objective of wintering bird studies at SNWF is to investigate the possible effects of the wind farm on geese populations, notably the Red-breasted Goose Branta ruficollis (RBG) due to its globally threatened conservation status. Previous years\u2019 wintering studies at SNWF have been reported and presented for download on the AES SNWF website.  To date, as documented by previous reports, there have been no indications that SNWF has had any adverse impact on wintering geese, including RBG, and the more abundant Greater White-fronted Goose (Anser albifrons) (GWFG). This report presents the latest results, from the 2016-17 winter monitoring of SNWF.","author":["Whitfield, D.","Zehtindjiev, P."],"organization":["Bulgarian Academy of Sciences","Natural Research Ltd","AES Geo Energy"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.444331700000","28.453690400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zehtindjiev-and-Whitfield-2017-Saint-Nikola-Wind-Farm.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1802","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/monitoring-wintering-geese-aes-geo-energy-wind-farm-st-nikola-territory-kaliakra-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aesgeoenergy.com\/site\/images\/EN%20Monitoring%20of%20wintering%20geese%20-%20winter%202014-2015.pdf","title":"Monitoring of wintering geese in the AES Geo Energy Wind Farm \u0022St. Nikola\u0022 territory and the Kaliakra region in winter 2015\/2016","description":"This report presents results of the ornithological survey and monitoring at Saint Nikola Wind Farm (SNWF) in the period 01 December 2015 to 15 March 2016, continuing from similar studies in previous winters before and after construction of SNWF including period of carcass searches and Turbine Shut Down System application in winter 2015-2016. As stated in previous reports the primary objective of wintering bird studies at SNWF is to investigate the possible effects of the wind farm on geese populations, notably the Redbreasted Goose Branta ruficollis (RBG) due to its globally threatened conservation status. Previous years\u2019 wintering studies at SNWF have been reported and presented for download on the AES SNWF website.  To date, as documented by previous reports, there have been no indications that SNWF has had any adverse impact on wintering geese, including RBG, and the more abundant Greater White-fronted Goose (Anser albifronsi) (GWFG). This report presents the latest results, from the 2015\/16 winter monitoring of SNWF.","author":["Whitfield, D.","Zehtindjiev, P."],"organization":["Bulgarian Academy of Sciences","Natural Research Ltd","AES Geo Energy"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.444331700000","28.453690400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zehtindjiev-and-Whitfield-2016-Saint-Nikola-Wind-Farm.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1803","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-migration-monitoring-saint-nikola-wind-farm-kaliakra-region-autumn-2016-analysis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aesgeoenergy.com\/site\/images\/Bird%20migration%20monitoring%20in%20autumn%202016.pdf","title":"Bird migration monitoring in the Saint Nikola Wind Farm, Kaliakra region, in autumn 2016, and an analysis of potential impact after seven years of operation","description":"This report presents the results of 90 consecutive days of monitoring and mitigation at Saint Nikola Wind Farm (SNWF) in 2016, its 7th operational year. The continued purpose is to investigate the possible impacts of SNWF on migrating birds.\nSpatial and temporal dynamics in the numbers of different species passing through the wind farm territory during autumn migration 2016 (15 August to 31 October) are presented. The data from the autumn monitoring in the years 2008 to 2016 are used to investigate the potential change in species composition, numbers, altitude or the flight direction of birds observed in these nine years at SNWF.\nThe variations in numbers of species, absolute number of birds, overall altitudes of flight and migratory direction of birds most sensitive to wind turbines do not indicate an adverse effect of the wind farm on diurnal migrating birds.\nThe Turbine Shutdown System (TSS) probably contributed to a reduced risk of collision during all years of operation within infrequent periods of intensive soaring bird migration and provided a safety mechanism to reduce collision risk for single birds and flocks of endangered bird species.\nRegular searches under operational turbines for collision victims were continued, as in several previous years. In autumn 2016 these searches recorded only single casualties, for several species of no conservation concern: Magpie, Jay, Spotted flycatcher, Red-backed shrike, House martin, Kestrel, Goldcrest, Starling and Yellow-legged gull.\nThe predicted mortality rates by species based on preconstruction data on numbers of migrating birds are not supported by the mortality observed during any of the seven years of operation of SNWF. The levels of mortality predicted pre-construction have not been recorded during any year of operation. This is largely because \u2018worst case\u2019 predictions were based on BSPB (Bulgarian BirdLife partner) data that substantially exaggerated the numbers of migrants passing through SNWF.\nThe results to date continue to indicate that SNWF does not constitute a significant displacement\/disturbing obstacle or mortality threat, either physically or demographically, to any of the populations of diurnal autumn migrants observed in this study.","author":["Zehtindjiev, P."],"organization":["Bulgarian Academy of Sciences","AES Geo Energy"],"originationDate":"2016-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.444331700000","28.453690400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zehtindjiev-2016-Saint-Nikola-Wind-Farm.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1804","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-migration-monitoring-saint-nikola-wind-farm-kaliakra-region-autumn-2017-analysis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.aesgeoenergy.com\/site\/images\/Autumn%20Monitoring%202017.pdf","title":"Bird migration monitoring in the Saint Nikola Wind Farm, Kaliakra region, in autumn 2017, and an analysis of potential impact after eight years of operation","description":"This report presents the results of 78 consecutive days of monitoring and mitigation at Saint Nikola Wind Farm (SNWF) in 2017, its 8th operational year. The continued purpose is to investigate the possible impacts of SNWF on migrating birds.\nSpatial and temporal dynamics in the numbers of different species passing through the wind farm territory during autumn migration 2017 (15 August to 31 October) are presented. The data from the autumn monitoring in the years 2008 to 2017 are used to investigate the potential change in species composition, numbers, altitude or the flight direction of birds observed in these nine years at SNWF.\nThe variations in numbers of species, absolute number of birds, overall altitudes of flight and migratory direction of birds most sensitive to wind turbines do not indicate an adverse effect of the wind farm on diurnal migrating birds.\nThe Turbine Shutdown System (TSS) probably contributed to a reduced risk of collision during all years of operation within infrequent periods of intensive soaring bird migration and provided a safety mechanism to reduce collision risk for single birds and flocks of endangered bird species.\nRegular searches under operational turbines for collision victims were continued, as in several previous years. In autumn 2017 these searches recorded only casualties, for several species of no conservation concern: four Common Swifts, three Yellow-legged gulls, one Chiffchaff, one Willow warbler, one Common moorhen, one Grey partridge, one Red-backed shrike, one Red-breasted flycatcher and one Scops owl.\nThe predicted mortality rates by species based on preconstruction data on numbers of migrating birds are not supported by the mortality observed during any of the eight years of operation of SNWF. The levels of mortality predicted pre-construction have not been recorded during any year of operation. This is largely because \u2018worst case\u2019 predictions were based on BSPB (Bulgarian BirdLife partner) data that substantially exaggerated the numbers of migrants passing through SNWF.\nThe results to date continue to indicate that SNWF does not constitute a significant displacement\/disturbing obstacle or mortality threat, either physically or demographically, to any of the populations of diurnal autumn migrants observed in this study.","author":["Zehtindjiev, P."],"organization":["Bulgarian Academy of Sciences","AES Geo Energy"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.444331700000","28.453690400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zehtindjiev-2017-Saint-Nikola-Wind-Farm.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1805","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-energy-fish-impact-method-development-determine-impact-open-water-tidal-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/library.wur.nl\/WebQuery\/wurpubs\/524357","title":"Tidal Energy Fish Impact: Method Development to Determine the Impact of Open Water Tidal Energy Converters on Fish","description":"The goals of the proposed project are: 1. to develop a robust method and experimental set\u2010up to determine behaviour of fish in the vicinity of tidal turbines and collision risk in the strong turbid currents of the Marsdiep based on DIDSON technology, 2. to provide a first insight and measure avoidance and collision rate of fish (and although the focus will be on fish, also if marine mammals such as harbour porpoises and seals approach the device this will be determined within the project), 3. to develop data analysis methodology since analysing large DIDSON datasets manually is very labour\u2010intensive and will enhance the efficiency of future large scale studies using DIDSON.","author":["van Keeken, O.","Winter, E.","Scheijgrond, P.","Griffioen, B.","Quesson, B.","Smit, M.","Bergmeijer, P.","Schuitema, R.","Nichols, C.","Visser, B.","Thijssen, M.","van Duren, L.","Boom, L.","Nauw, J."],"organization":["Royal Netherlands Institute for Sea Research (NIOZ)","IMARES - Wageningen UR"],"originationDate":"2016-12-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Smit_et_al_Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1806","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/using-residential-proximity-wind-turbines-alternative-exposure-measure-investigate","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.5039840","title":"Using residential proximity to wind turbines as an alternative exposure measure to investigate the association between wind turbines and human health","description":"This analysis uses data from the Community Noise and Health Study developed by Statistics Canada to investigate the association between residential proximity to wind turbines and health-related outcomes in a dataset that also provides objective measures of wind turbine noise. The findings indicate that residential proximity to wind turbines is correlated with annoyance and health-related quality of life measures. These associations differ in some respects from associations with noise measurements. Results can be used to support discussions between communities and wind-turbine developers regarding potential health effects of wind turbines.","author":["Barry, R.","Sulsky, S.","Kreiger, N."],"organization":["University of Toronto"],"originationDate":"2018-06-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Health \u0026 Safety","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-12 08:13:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1807","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/laboratory-study-effects-hydro-kinetic-turbines-hydrodynamics-sediment-dynamics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118306190","title":"Laboratory study on the effects of hydro kinetic turbines on hydrodynamics and sediment dynamics","description":"The need for hydrokinetic turbine wake characterisation and their environmental impact has led to a number of studies. However, a small number of them have taken into account mobile sediment bed effects. The aim of the present work is to study the impact of the presence of a horizontal-axis three-bladed turbine with the flow and a mobile sediment bed. We use a series of laboratory experiments with a scaled modelled turbine installed in a flume with a mobile sandy bed at the bottom. Acoustic instruments were used to monitor flow, suspended sediment and bed behaviour. Results show a velocity decrease of about 50% throughout the water column and no flow recovery after a distance of 15 rotor diameters. Clearly visible ripples in the absence of the model turbine were replaced by horseshoe-shaped scour pit in the near wake region, and a depositional heap in the far wake. Suspended sediment differences were recorded in the streamwise direction with a possible effect of the wake as far as 15 rotor diameters. These results imply potentially important effects on the efficiency of turbine arrays, if the flow were to be lower than expected, on turbine foundations and modify coastal sediment transport.","author":["Amoudry, L.","Thorne, P.","Jordan, L.","Simmons, S.","Ram\u00edrez-Mendoza, R.","Cooke, R.","McLelland, S.","Parsons, D.","Murdoch, L."],"organization":["National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","University of Hull","CFD People Ltd"],"originationDate":"2018-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ramirez-Mendoza-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1808","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/local-scour-around-model-hydrokinetic-turbine-erodible-channel","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ascelibrary.org\/doi\/10.1061\/%28ASCE%29HY.1943-7900.0000900","title":"Local scour around a model hydrokinetic turbine in an erodible channel","description":"Laboratory experiments were performed to study the effect of an axial-flow hydrokinetic turbine model on an erodible channel under both clear water and live-bed conditions. Clear water experiments were performed at two scales with a local bed shear stress just below the critical state. Live-bed experiments, performed at small scale, examined the interactions between relatively large-scale bedforms and the flow induced by an axial flow turbine. Spatiotemporal topographic measurements were obtained by sonar and by a state-of-the-art high-resolution scanning system integrated into an automated data acquisition carriage designed and fabricated at the St. Anthony Falls Laboratory at the Univ. of Minnesota. Results indicate that the presence of the turbine rotor increases the local shear stress resulting in accelerated and expanded scour development when compared with typical bridge pier scour mechanisms. The inferred key difference is the alteration of the flow patterns in the rotor wake leading to an accelerated flow region below the bottom tip. The footprint of the rotor is observed in the extension and scaling of the bed surface area impacted by the turbine and consistent with the near-wake region. Temporally averaged bed topography data from live-bed experiments indicate amplified scour depths in the turbine near-wake region as compared with the clear water results despite spatial patterns remaining qualitatively similar.","author":["Hill, C.","Guala, M.","Musa, M.","Chamorro, L.","Ellis, C."],"organization":["University of Minnesota","University of Trento","University of Illinois"],"originationDate":"2018-04-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:07","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1809","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predictive-model-local-scour-downstream-hydrokinetic-turbines-erodible-channels","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.aps.org\/prfluids\/abstract\/10.1103\/PhysRevFluids.3.024606","title":"Predictive model for local scour downstream of hydrokinetic turbines in erodible channels","description":"A modeling framework is derived to predict the scour induced by marine hydrokinetic turbines installed on fluvial or tidal erodible bed surfaces. Following recent advances in bridge scour formulation, the phenomenological theory of turbulence is applied to describe the flow structures that dictate the equilibrium scour depth condition at the turbine base. Using scaling arguments, we link the turbine operating conditions to the flow structures and scour depth through the drag force exerted by the device on the flow. The resulting theoretical model predicts scour depth using dimensionless parameters and considers two potential scenarios depending on the proximity of the turbine rotor to the erodible bed. The model is validated at the laboratory scale with experimental data comprising the two sediment mobility regimes (clear water and live bed), different turbine configurations, hydraulic settings, bed material compositions, and migrating bedform types. The present work provides future developers of flow energy conversion technologies with a physics-based predictive formula for local scour depth beneficial to feasibility studies and anchoring system design. A potential prototype-scale deployment in a large sandy river is also considered with our model to quantify how the expected scour depth varies as a function of the flow discharge and rotor diameter.","author":["Guala, M.","Musa, M.","Heisel, M."],"organization":["University of Minnesota","University of Illinois"],"originationDate":"2018-02-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1810","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farms-affect-occurrence-abundance-population-trends-small-passerine-birds-case","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/1365-2664.13107","title":"Wind farms affect the occurrence, abundance and population trends of small passerine birds: The case of the Dupont\u0027s lark","description":"The assessment of the effects of wind farms on bird populations is commonly based on collision fatality records. This could undervalue the effect of wind farms on small-sized birds. We evaluate the effect of wind turbines on occurrence, abundance and population trends of a threatened small passerine species, the Dupont\u0027s lark Chersophilus duponti. To our knowledge, this is one of the first studies addressing the effect of wind farms on population trends using time-series data from multiple wind farms.\nWe estimated population trends by fitting a switching linear trend model with the software trim (Trend \u0026 Indices for Monitoring data). We used multiannual data surveys of five populations in the presence of wind farms and nine in their absence (2008-2016 period). Furthermore, we fitted a logistic and a negative binomial regression model to test the effect of wind farm proximity on species occurrence and abundance in 2016, respectively. We incorporated local connectivity and habitat availability estimates in both models as predictors.\nResults showed a negative trend overall, but that was significantly more regressive in the presence of wind farms: 21.0% vs. 5.8% average annual decline in the absence of wind farms.\nDupont\u0027s lark occurrence and abundance in 2016 were negatively affected by measures of population isolation and positively affected by the distance to wind farms.\nThese results highlight the negative effect of isolation and wind farm proximity on Dupont\u0027s lark population parameters. Taking into account the metapopulation structure exhibited by the species in the study area, this work established a 4.5-km threshold distance from wind farms, beyond which Dupont\u0027s lark populations should be unaffected.\nSynthesis and applications. This work highlights the negative impact of wind farms on small-sized birds and provides a 4.5-km threshold distance that should be taken into account in the design of future wind energy projects. Moreover, we suggest an analytical approach based on population trends, species abundance and occurrence variation in relation to wind farms, useful for the assessment of wind farm impacts on small-sized birds.","author":["Gomez-Catasus, J.","Garza, V.","Traba, J."],"organization":["Universidad Autonoma de Madrid"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.191361000000","-2.443083000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Passerines"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1811","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proximity-wind-power-plants-reduces-breeding-success-white-tailed-eagle","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1111\/acv.12238","title":"Proximity to wind-power plants reduces the breeding success of the white-tailed eagle","description":"As a clean and renewable energy source, wind power is expected to play a major role in climate change mitigation. Despite its benefits, the construction of large-scale wind farms in many parts of the world is a cause of concern for wildlife, including the often vulnerable raptor populations. Here, we examined the influence of distance to wind-power plants on the white-tailed eagle Haliaeetus albicilla in terms of (1) breeding success; (2) post-fledging survival; and (3) territory occupancy and turbine avoidance (via nest site changes). Our results show that the probability of a pair breeding successfully is lower when the territory is located closer to turbines, potentially because of collision mortality (to which adults are particularly vulnerable). A capture-mark-recapture analysis showed no evidence for the effect of distance on post-fledging survival, suggesting that collision risk may not have been greater for juveniles that fledged closer to a power plant. The levels of disturbance experienced by birds in the study areas were not great enough to prevent breeding at closer distances to the turbines. Our findings on breeding success underline the importance of building appropriately sited wind farms as a way to reduce or avoid undesirable effects on avian populations.","author":["Balotari-Chiebao, F.","Brommer, J.","Laaksonen, T.","Niinimaki, T."],"organization":["University of Turku"],"originationDate":"2016-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1812","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-space-use-pre-breeding-white-tailed-eagles-context-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0169204618303463","title":"Assessing space use by pre-breeding white-tailed eagles in the context of wind-energy development in Finland","description":"The expansion of wind energy over large areas may be accompanied by major conflicts with birds, including birds of prey. Hence, it is desirable that the space use of species known to be vulnerable to wind energy be assessed in light of current and future developments. Here, we report on the large-scale dispersal movements of pre-breeding white-tailed eagles (Haliaeetus albicilla) in Finland, where a currently modest wind-energy capacity is expected to increase in the near future. We studied white-tailed eagle space use with a particular focus on the potential for annual power production (GWh) at specific locations, as estimated by the Finnish Wind Atlas. Also, we aimed to detect a potential human-wildlife conflict by assessing white-tailed eagle space use against the spatial distribution of existing and recently proposed wind farms. We found that, despite visiting a large proportion of the country, the eagles stayed primarily within coastal areas and islands, restricted to where human infrastructure was present only at very small amounts. Because of the distribution of wind resources, such areas were found to contain considerable potential for power production. The eagles visited most of the areas targeted for wind-energy development. However, these areas did not coincide with a higher-than-average eagle relocation frequency, suggesting that the existing and recently proposed wind farms do not represent an elevated threat to dispersing eagles. Caution should nevertheless be taken against interpreting that co-occurrence poses no threat at any given site, as site selection is paramount to avoid conflicts with avian conservation.","author":["Balotari-Chiebao, F.","Brommer, J.","Saurola, P.","Ijas, A.","Laaksonen, T."],"organization":["University of Turku","University of Helsinki"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.259180000000","21.067081000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1813","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-farms-land-surface-temperature","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/nclimate1505","title":"Impacts of wind farms on land surface temperature","description":"The wind industry in the United States has experienced a remarkably rapid expansion of capacity in recent years and this fast growth is expected to continue in the future1,2,3. While converting wind\u2019s kinetic energy into electricity, wind turbines modify surface\u2013atmosphere exchanges and the transfer of energy, momentum, mass and moisture within the atmosphere4,5,6. These changes, if spatially large enough, may have noticeable impacts on local to regional weather and climate. Here we present observational evidence for such impacts based on analyses of satellite data for the period of 2003\u20132011 over a region in west-central Texas, where four of the world\u2019s largest wind farms are located7. Our results show a significant warming trend of up to 0.72\u2009\u00b0C per decade, particularly at night-time, over wind farms relative to nearby non-wind-farm regions. We attribute this warming primarily to wind farms as its spatial pattern and magnitude couples very well with the geographic distribution of wind turbines.","author":["Baidya Roy, S.","Zhou, L.","Tian, Y.","Bosart, L.","Hu, Y."],"organization":["State University of New York","University of Illinois"],"originationDate":"2012-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.500000000000","-100.400000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1814","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-potential-impacts-submarine-power-cables-marine-environment-knowledge-gaps","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032118305355","title":"A review of potential impacts of submarine power cables on the marine environment: Knowledge gaps, recommendations and future directions","description":"Submarine power cables (SPC) have been in use since the mid-19th century, but environmental concerns about them are much more recent. With the development of marine renewable energy technologies, it is vital to understand their potential impacts. The commissioning of SPC may temporarily or permanently impact the marine environment through habitat damage or loss, noise, chemical pollution, heat and electromagnetic field emissions, risk of entanglement, introduction of artificial substrates, and the creation of reserve effects. While growing numbers of scientific publications focus on impacts of the marine energy harnessing devices, data on impacts of associated power connections such as SPC are scarce and knowledge gaps persist. The present study (1) examines the different categories of potential ecological effects of SPC during installation, operation and decommissioning phases and hierarchizes these types of interactions according to their ecological relevance and existing scientific knowledge, (2) identifies the main knowledge gaps and needs for research, and (3) sets recommendations for better monitoring and mitigation of the most significant impacts. Overall, ecological impacts associated with SPC can be considered weak or moderate, although many uncertainties remain, particularly concerning electromagnetic effects.","author":["Want, A.","Bald, J.","Carlier, A.","Lejart, M.","Taormina, B.","Desroy, N.","Thouzeau, G."],"organization":["France Energies Marines","The French Research Institute for Exploitation of the Sea (IFREMER)","AZTI","Heriot-Watt University","Technop\u00f4le Brest-Iroise"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:28:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1815","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/using-network-analysis-identify-indicator-species-reduce-collision-fatalities-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.biocon.2018.06.003","title":"Using network analysis to identify indicator species and reduce collision fatalities at wind farms","description":"The adverse effects of wind farms on wildlife, mainly the mortality of flying animals at turbines, should be carefully studied to reconcile renewable energy production and biodiversity conservation. The growing consensus about the aggregated pattern of this mortality at particular turbines suggests that the identification of high-mortality turbines can decisively aid in the implementation of effective management actions. Here, taking advantage of a long-term monitoring program of animal mortality at wind farms (10,017 fatalities of 170 bird and bat species between 1993 and 2016) in two Spanish regions, we demonstrate the utility of network analysis in identifying species indicative of high-risk turbines whose stoppage could significantly reduce the mortality of other species. Our protocol can be easily applied to any region with available data on animal mortality to help managers reduce the negative impacts of wind farms.","author":["Carrete, M.","Sanchez-Zapata, J.","Donazar, J.","Perez-Garcia, J.","Sebastian-Gonzalez, E."],"organization":["Universidad Miguel Hernandez","Universitat de Lleida","Universidad Pablo de Olavide"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1816","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/combining-radar-direct-observation-estimate-pelican-collision-risk-proposed-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0192515","title":"Combining radar and direct observation to estimate pelican collision risk at a proposed wind farm on the Cape west coast, South Africa","description":"Pre-construction assessments of bird collision risk at proposed wind farms are often confounded by insufficient or poor quality data describing avian flight paths through the development area. These limitations can compromise the practical value of wind farm impact studies. We used radar- and observer-based methods to quantify great white pelican flights in the vicinity of a planned wind farm on the Cape west coast, South Africa, and modelled turbine collision risk under various scenarios. Model outputs were combined with pre-existing demographic data to evaluate the possible influence of the wind farm on the pelican population, and to examine impact mitigation options. We recorded high volumes of great white pelican movement through the wind farm area, coincident with the breeding cycle of the nearby colony and associated with flights to feeding areas located about 50 km away. Pelicans were exposed to collision risk at a mean rate of 2.02 High Risk flights.h-1. Risk was confined to daylight hours, highest during the middle of the day and in conditions of strong north-westerly winds, and 82% of High Risk flights were focused on only five of the proposed 35 turbine placements. Predicted mean mortality rates (22 fatalities.yr-1, 95% Cl, 16\u201329, with average bird and blade speeds and 95% avoidance rates) were not sustainable, resulting in a negative population growth rate (\u03bb = 0.991). Models suggested that removal of the five highest risk turbines from the project, or institution of a curtailment regimen that shuts down at least these turbines at peak traffic times, could theoretically reduce impacts to manageable levels. However, in spite of the large quantities of high quality data used in our analyses, our collision risk model remains compromised by untested assumptions about pelican avoidance rates and uncertainties about the existing dynamics of the pelican population, and our findings are probably not reliable enough to ensure sustainable development.","author":["Jenkins, A.","Reid, T.","du Plessis, J.","Colyn, R.","Benn, G.","Millikin, R."],"organization":["Avisense Consulting","University of Cape Town"],"originationDate":"2018-02-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["-33.422221600000","18.316729200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl","Collision","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Jenkins-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1817","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/monitoring-environmental-interactions-tidal-devices-how-do-we-achieve-what-required","sourceURL":"","title":"Monitoring the environmental interactions of tidal devices - how do we achieve what is required in a practical and cost effective manner whilst retaining focus on the key issues to assist the consenting of future projects?","description":"The tidal industry is still in its infancy; numerous designs of devices are being tested at sea to prove the technology, and there has been some deployment of early small scale arrays. The consents issued for these early deployments have included conditions that require the monitoring of environmental effects. It is fair to say some developers have considered these to be onerous and they have certainly generated a number of challenges for the Project developers. The presentation will draw on developer specific experience to provide an overview of the scope of the environmental monitoring that has taken place to date, highlighting:    a)   Topics that have been\/are being studied\/monitored;  b)   Practicalities of the monitoring techniques deployed; and  c)   Key outcomes (where available) with regards to verification of potential impacts.    The author will then go on to present her views on what can be learnt from this early environmental monitoring. Not only with regards to the impacts associated with the use of tidal technology, but perhaps more importantly what is an appropriate monitoring plan for a tidal project? What should project developers be expected to take responsibility for and what should be left to the wider research community? And critically, how do the regulators and their advisors make best use of lessons learnt to date.  Does the current research agenda focus on the right issues or can it be further developed to help expedite commercial deployments and avoid unnecessary duplication of effort between project developers, as well as between different jurisdictions? There is a balance to strike between developer responsibility and the wider academic research agenda, but where does the balance lie and how do the regulators and their advisors use the results available to influence future consent conditions?  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Foubister, L."],"organization":["Xodus Group"],"originationDate":"2018-04-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Foubister2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1818","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelled-cumulative-impacts-swift-parrot-wind-farms-across-species-range-south-eastern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/237283300_Modelled_cumulative_impacts_on_the_Swift_Parrot_of_wind_farms_across_the_species%27_range_in_south-_eastern_Australia","title":"Modelled cumulative impacts on the Swift Parrot of wind farms across the species\u0027 range in south-eastern Australia","description":"The Swift Parrot Lathamus discolor is listed as Endangered under provisions of the EPBC Act for threatened species. The species migrates annually between Tasmania and the coast of south-eastern Australia. Current population estimates indicate that the population numbers fewer than 2000 birds. The species range coincides with a number of recently constructed wind power generation facilities (wind farms) and more facilities are proposed within its range. The wind farms may pose a risk of collision to the parrot as bird mortalities are known from wind farms in a variety of situations worldwide.  The essential aim of the current project is to predict, based upon the extant population of Swift Parrots, the potential cumulative impacts of collision risk posed by wind farms across the range of the species distribution. The project utilises bird collision risk modelling to generate assessments of the cumulative risk to the endangered Swift Parrot posed by such collisions.  The cumulative modelling was undertaken for the species using the Biosis Research avian collision risk model. The assessment is based on existing and currently proposed wind farm sites.  Using data available for the Swift Parrot, the Biosis Research collision model is utilised to determine the bird strike risk for the parrot\u2019s population from the wind farms in the following categories, as at 30th May 2005, within the species range:    already constructed or approved;  referred under the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation Act 1999 (EPBC Act) and:     determined to be not a controlled action (NCA);  determined to be not a controlled action manner specified (NCA-MS);  approved under the EPBC Act; and  proposed and currently being assessed for a determination under the EPBC Act.","author":["Smales, I."],"organization":["Biosis"],"originationDate":"2005-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Smales_2005.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1819","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/optimisation-underwater-imagery-analysis-method-characterise-reef-effect-caused","sourceURL":"","title":"Optimisation of an underwater imagery analysis method to characterise the reef effect caused by submarine power cables on epibenthic communities","description":"The number of submarine power cables (SPC) will drastically increase in the next decades with the development of Marine Renewable Energy (MRE). Thus it becomes vital to better understand their potential impacts on the benthic compartment. Unburied SPC and associated protection\/stabilisation structures represent artificial hard substrates available for benthic species. The spatio-temporal dynamics of this \u2018reef effect\u2018 depend on physical parameters (size, nature of structure) but also on biological characteristics of the surrounding area.  Underwater imagery is a relevant approach to monitor benthic colonisation at sites difficult to access (e.g. tidal sites) and to rapidly collect biodiversity data in a non-destructive way and with high spatial resolution. Although image acquisition is rapid, analysis is time-consuming, thus requiring optimised exploitation methods. A method to estimate benthic community on sill images is the random point count method, this method is organized in three successive steps:   randomly distribute a number of points on an image, identify the features (e.g. taxa or substrate-type) lying under each point, and then estimate the different covering rates. We used this method to estimate change of biodiversity on cable protection devices, concrete mattresses and natural substratum (taken as a reference) at the Paimpol-Br\u00e9hat tidal test site in France.  The aim of this study was to optimise methods of underwater imagery analysis to efficiently characterise the reef effect of SPC on epibenthic communities of the study site. To reach this objective, the authors answered three distinct questions:  1)    What is the optimum point density (number of points\/area) needed for the random point count approach?  2)    What is the optimum number of photographs to analyse?  3)    What is the taxonomic level of identification needed?  Our results showed that the random point count applied with underwater imagery can be an efficient and standardized tool (in terms of time allocated and accuracy achieved) used to investigate the reef effect of MRE structures. Although we optimised this method for a single French MRE site, this approach should be useful to compare the extent of reef effects in different ecological contexts.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Carlier, A.","Lejart, M.","Taormina, B.","Thiesse, E.","Desroy, N."],"organization":["France Energies Marines","Technop\u00f4le Brest-Iroise"],"originationDate":"2018-04-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/055_Bastien_Taormina_EIMR2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1820","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/towards-improving-biofouling-information-within-mre-environments","sourceURL":"","title":"Towards improving biofouling information within MRE environments","description":"Biofouling, i.e. the colonisation of surfaces remaining within aquatic ecosystems by living organisms, is a process that affects all structures at sea including marine renewable energy (MRE) devices. This phenomenon can specifically impact hydrodynamic loadings and therefore contribute to component fatigue and decrease device performance, thus challenging engineers during the design and maintenance phases of MRE projects. Currently, engineers apply conservative norms found in the Oil\u0026amp;Gas sector which are ill-adapted to MRE applications as the operational environments differ significantly and the demands for low levelised costs of energy in the MRE sector require restricted development budgets. In particular, biofouling most probably impacts MRE devices in different ways depending on the location (which directly affects the composition of the biofouling, a site-dependant process) and the technology\/device component. For these reasons, there is a strong need for in-situ knowledge and new approaches to improve the understanding of biofouling in the MRE context. As a first step towards achieving this ambitious objective, published literature, investigative reports, and information gathered directly from device developers and engineers were examined to 1) extricate information about communities colonising both natural and artificial substrates within differing environments (both temperate and tropical systems), and 2) analyse the different methods used to characterise\/measure macrofouling variables. The extracted data support the development of a biofouling atlas (through the creation of a Geographical Information System) that focusses on 6 areas within French marine systems (including oversea territories), and which allows for the highlighting of site-specific trends. In addition, the combination of this macro-scale analysis and the review of methods formed a foundation for multidisciplinary adaptations to existing methods used to quantify biofouling in different MRE contexts\/problematics. This work provides an improved understanding of biofouling processes and implications for MRE, as well as valuable tools for increasing the range and scope of standardized approaches.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Lejart, M.","Barillier, A.","Quillienn, N.","Cayocca, K.","Damblans, G.","Ameryoun, H.","Schoefs, F.","Felix-Henry, A.","Bressy, C.","Briand, J.","Gueun\u00e9, H.","Jacob, D.","Leblanc, V.","Boukerma, K.","Comp\u00e8re, C.","Dreanno, C.","Pagot, J.","Grenier, A.","Debout, V.","Dubois, F.","Reynaud, M."],"organization":["France Energies Marines","The French Research Institute for Exploitation of the Sea (IFREMER)","EDF Renewable Energy"],"originationDate":"2018-04-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/042_Quillien_et_al_ABIOP_EIMR.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1821","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multiple-maritime-uses-european-seas-findings-muses-project","sourceURL":"","title":"Multiple maritime uses in European seas: Findings from the MUSES project","description":"The ever increasing demands on ocean resources in all European Sea Basins and resulting pressure on the use of ocean space, are underlining issues of compatibility (or conflicts) between different maritime uses as well as between economic activities and environmental protection. As a result ocean space is a valuable asset deserving special attention in marine management and planning.  Management should be systematic, coordinated, as well as account both for existing maritime uses and anticipate future needs. This means that co-uses, synergies and multiple spatial uses should be promoted as much as possible. Integrating different functions\/ uses\/ activities in time and space in the sea, in a complementary way, termed here as Multi-Use (MU), can offer multiple benefits.  While there are good reasons for promoting MU, its realisation is rendered difficult by conceptual problems and the need to overcome sectoral demands, vested interests, and any other barriers associated with existing political institutions and practices. The goal of Multi-Use in European Seas (MUSES) project is to identify and highlight the real opportunities for MU in European Seas.  The MUSES project has explored practical solutions on overcoming existing barriers and minimizing risks associated with MU development at a local level, through a range of case studies around Europe. MUSES case studies focused on the challenges arising from tensions between maritime activities demanding ocean space. Key findings suggest that combining compatible activities in the same marine space can serve to share and reduce costs, and generate further synergies between those activities. MUSES case study findings focusing on offshore energy will be presented, including the environmental, spatial, economic \u0026amp; societal benefits of MU, as well as practical solutions to overcome identified barriers.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Davies, I.","Kafas, A.","Roberts, T."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-04-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MUSES-Findings.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1822","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-energy-planning-provisions-transnational-maritime-spatial-planning-north-sea","sourceURL":"","title":"Offshore Energy Planning Provisions and transnational Maritime Spatial Planning in the North Sea Region: Findings from the NorthSEE project","description":"The North Sea is one of the busiest seas for maritime industries in the world. Its shared resources represent a crucial asset, but also a shared territorial challenge to North Sea Region (NSR) countries, including Belgium, Denmark, Germany, Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, and the United Kingdom (England and Scotland). Various maritime sectors, such as offshore energy, play a major part in generating economic value and employment and are set to expand in line with smart \u2018Blue Growth\u2019 objectives. Given the transnational nature of offshore energy activities and the transnational character of most marine ecosystems, facilitating greater transnational coherence and cooperation in marine planning represents a key shared challenge. The European-funded NorthSEE project addresses this challenge directly.  The NorthSEE project promotes a better exchange of information among NSR marine planning authorities and related experts and institutions. The NorthSEE project aims at achieving greater coherence in MSP across the NSR for three topics of transnational nature: environmental aspects, shipping routes, and energy infrastructure. Here, the focus of our presentation will be offshore energy planning provisions, the sustainable development of offshore renewable energies, related offshore grid infrastructure, and relevant transnational marine planning aspects in NSR. We will present an overview of the state-of-the-art of offshore energy planning provisions for the production and transportation of energy in the North Sea, including:     the existing international MSP institutional framework in the NSR, including past and current experience of transnational energy cooperation between North Sea countries;  an overview of short- (2020), mid- (2030), and long- (2050) term national and transnational energy planning provisions, including energy objectives, policies, and planning areas; and  future trends in the offshore energy policy landscape and industry developments across the NSR   More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Davies, I.","Kafas, A.","Wright, K."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science","German Federal Maritime and Hydrographic Agency (BSH)"],"originationDate":"2018-04-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wright2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1823","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparative-effects-climate-change-tidal-stream-energy-extraction-nw-european","sourceURL":"","title":"Comparative effects of climate change and tidal stream energy extraction in the NW European continental shelf","description":"The environmental implications of tidal stream energy extraction need to be evaluated against the potential climate change impacts on the marine environment. Here, we present how hypothetical very large tidal stream arrays and a \u0022business as usual\u0027\u0027 future climate scenario can change the hydrodynamics of a seasonally stratified shelf sea.  The Scottish Shelf Model, an unstructured grid three-dimensional ocean model, has been used to reproduce the present and the future state of the NW European continental shelf. Four scenarios have been modelled: present conditions and projected future climate in 2050 with and without very large scale tidal stream arrays in Scottish Waters (UK). This allows us to evaluate the potential effect of climate change on the hydrodynamics and compare it with the future state of the seas modified by large scale energy extraction.  It is found that where tidal range is reduced of by few cm by tidal stream energy extraction, it can help to counter extreme water levels associated with future sea level rise. Tidal velocities, and consequently tidal mixing, are also overall reduced by the action of the tidal turbine arrays. A key finding is that climate change and tidal energy extraction both act in the same direction, in terms of increasing stratification due to warming and reduced mixing, however, the effect of climate change is an order of magnitude larger.  The results presented in this work are the basis for other studies that evaluate the impacts of the above mentioned physical changes on animal behaviours, in particular the distributions of mobile predator and prey species, on sediment dynamics with special attention to water turbidity, and on benthic communities.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Wolf, J.","Murray, R.","De Dominicis, M."],"organization":["National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-04-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/030_dedominicis_EIMR2018_web.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1824","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/us-west-coast-large-whale-entanglement-information-sharing-workshop-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.westcoast.fisheries.noaa.gov\/publications\/protected_species\/marine_mammals\/finalentanglementwsreport.pdf","title":"U.S. West Coast Large Whale Entanglement Information Sharing Workshop Report","description":"Addressing the serious injury and mortality of large whales due to entanglement in fishing gear is a national priority for the NOAA\u2019s National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS). However, along the U.S. west coast, much is unknown about why, when, where, and how whales are seriously injured or killed due to entanglement, how this threat may be affecting their populations, and what can be done to minimize the risk. For some fisheries NMFS tracks entanglements along with other bycatch using onboard observers; however, for the majority of fisheries, entanglement information comes from opportunistic reports by the public or other agencies. Of the reports received, fixed gear (e.g., pot and trap gear) is the most commonly recognized and reported gear type causing entanglements since 2000 (Saez et al., In prep.). Over the past four years, NMFS WCR has been compiling data on entanglements and large whale migratory movements to identify areas of overlap and increased risk of entanglement. The results of that effort are presented in a NOAA technical memorandum titled Understanding the co-occurrence of larges whales and commercial fixed gear fisheries off the west coast of the United States (Saez et al., 2013). NMFS WCR hosted a two day workshop to review, share, and analyze the information from the Tech Memo along with results from similar analyses from other fisheries in the Pacific and Atlantic Oceans and other current research with interested stakeholders, promote feedback, and consider next steps in achieving the long-term goal of reducing large whale interactions with fixed gear fisheries (Appendix 1 \u2013 Agenda).  The three primary goals for this workshop were to:    Bring together experts in the fields of marine mammals, fisheries, modeling, bycatch, lost gear\/marine debris, and management, to share information relevant to this issue;  Identify data gaps, data needs, and next steps;  If possible, begin to develop research and outreach priorities. These steps are necessary to better understand large whale entanglement and continue to build a strong sciencebased foundation for any actions that may be necessary to protect whales.   Workshop participants included scientists, managers, and experts with knowledge of large whales, large whale entanglement and fisheries (Appendix 2 \u2013 List of Participants). Presentations spanned several topics including: risk assessment models; large whale abundance, distribution and behavior; fishery characterizations and management regimes; and, gear reduction\/recovery efforts. The workshop concluded that although the models presented provide direction on where whales are more likely to encounter commercial fishing gear, more research is needed to understand the conservation concern and mechanisms of large whale entanglement to help better inform future management actions aimed at reducing whale entanglement risks. In the interim, workshop participants identified action items that may be pursued such as gear marking and engagement with the commercial fishing industry through port-based meetings. Participants identified four recommendations concerning reducing large whale entanglements off the U.S. west coast. The four recommendations are listed under the Workshop Recommendations\/Action Items in Section 1.1 below.","author":["NOAA Fisheries"],"organization":["National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)"],"originationDate":"2014-03-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NOAA-Fisheries-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1825","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/draft-fisheries-report-cape-wind-energy-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/SL-ESS2006DraftFisheriesReport.aspx","title":"Draft Fisheries Report\u00a0of Cape Wind Energy Project","description":"The waters of Nantucket Sound support a diverse fish community. Both commercial and recreational fishing are conducted in the Sound. During the summer months, a temperature gradient forms off the east coast of Cape Cod that demarcates the cold-water fishes to the north and warmer water fishes to the south. This gradient, however, is variable and will oscillate north and south along a 20-40 mile section of the Cape Cod Coast. Due to its geographic location and the temperature gradient observed along Cape Cod, Nantucket Sound serves as a migratory pathway for many warm water species that pass through the Sound moving into Cape Cod Bay and Massachusetts Bay. The area also serves as a northern border for several summer migrants including scup,northern fluke and black sea bass.  Information on fish resources from scientific studies or monitoring activities in Nantucket Sound is less prevalent. The main source of resource data available in Nantucket Sound is from the MarineFisheries independent fisheries monitoring program. MarineFisheries conducts bi-annual resource trawls for all coastal waters including Nantucket Sound and the information gathered is independent of commercial fisheries monitoring. Data from those trawls located in Nantucket Sound are discussed in detail in Section 5.0.","author":["Battelle","ESS Group Inc"],"organization":["ESS Group Inc","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2006-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SL-ESS2006DraftFisheriesReport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1826","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fisheries-data-report-south-tuckernuck-area","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/SL-ESS2006FisheriesDataReportTuckernuck.aspx","title":"Fisheries Data Report South of Tuckernuck Area","description":"The offshore area south of Tuckernuck Island, between Muskeget Channel to the west and the southwestern coast of Nantucket Island to the east was previously presented in the DEIR\/S (see Figure 1). In response to comments received on the DEIR\/S, the FEIR evaluates the South of Tuckernuck Island alternative site at a greater level of detail with respect to environmental resources including fisheries resources. During the comment period for the DEIR\/S, the Massachusetts Coastal Zone Management Office requested more detailed environmental evaluations of the South of Tuckernuck site so that it could serve as a deeper water comparison to the Project site in Nantucket Sound. The following report presents fisheries information on the South of Tuckernuck Island site including available state and federal data on commercial fisheries, recreational fisheries, and fishery resources.","author":["ESS Group Inc"],"organization":["ESS Group Inc"],"originationDate":"2006-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SL-ESS2006FisheriesDataReportTuckernuck.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1827","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/long-tailed-duck-report-winter-2005-2006","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/SL-ESS2006LongTailedDuckReport.aspx","title":"Long-tailed Duck Report, Winter 2005-2006","description":"This report summarizes the results of a study conducted during 12 field days over a four-month period (December 2005, January, February, and March 2006) to document the use of Nantucket Sound by Longtailed Ducks (Clangula hyemalis) during the 2005-2006 winter season. This report is a continuation of studies that began in March 2002 at the suggestion of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), the Massachusetts Division of Fisheries and Wildlife (MADFW), and the Massachusetts Audubon Society (Mass Audubon).  Long-tailed Ducks are migratory, breeding in extensive portions of northern Canada and Alaska, and wintering on both coasts of North America and the Great Lakes (Robertson and Savard, 2002). Locally, Long-tailed Ducks are reported to arrive in numbers around Nantucket Sound during mid-November, and are usually present until mid-April, when the birds begin departing for the arctic breeding grounds (Davis 1997). Long-tailed Ducks roost at night in Nantucket Sound (Veit and Petersen, 1993) and then fly in large flocks over Nantucket Island and Tuckernuck Island to forage over the Nantucket Shoals during the day (Veit and Petersen 1993, Davis 1997). A large roost was discovered in the southern portion of Nantucket Sound, north of Tuckernuck Island during a preliminary survey flight conducted in December 2001 (USACE, 2004). However, Long-tailed duck roosting locations and movements are not well understood\u2014it is not known if individuals follow the same daily flight patterns between Nantucket Sound and Nantucket Shoals or if there is a consistent nighttime roosting area in Nantucket Sound. Flight timing, and whether or not all of the local winter population follows this flight pattern on a daily basis, is also unknown.","author":["ESS Group Inc"],"organization":["ESS Group Inc","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2006-09-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SL-ESS2006LongTailedDuckReport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1828","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-underwater-noise-analysis-cape-wind-energy-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/SL-ESS2006FinalUnderwaterNoiseAnalysis.aspx","title":"Final Underwater Noise Analysis of Cape Wind Energy Project","description":"The section augments the detailed analysis of noise effects in the Draft EIR with a discussion of the behavioral responses of different marine species to underwater sound from Project construction (pile driving) and operation. First, the hearing bandwidth and auditory thresholds of different marine species are presented. Next, a calculation of species-specific hearing threshold (dBht) sound levels for construction and operation sound is presented. Finally, the zone of behavioral response is provided for each species, and conclusions are drawn regarding the Project\u2019s effect on marine mammals, sea turtles, and fish. Underwater construction sound from the Project is in the low frequency bands. Vessel underwater sound has its energy peak well below 1,000 Hz1, and pile driving sound for the Project is concentrated in the very low frequencies below 250 Hz.  The existing data on these two items are presented below for the following families of marine animals:  \u2022 Toothed Whales \u2022 Baleen Whales \u2022 Hair Seals \u2022 Sea Turtles \u2022 Finfish","author":["ESS Group Inc"],"organization":["ESS Group Inc","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2006-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Reptiles","Sea Turtles","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-30 07:57:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SL-ESS2006FinalUnderwaterNoiseAnalysis.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1829","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/submerged-aquatic-vegetation-investigation-cape-wind-energy-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/SL-ESS2006Submerged.aspx","title":"Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Investigation of the Cape Wind Energy Project","description":"ESS Group, Inc. (ESS) was contracted by Cape Wind Associates LLC to conduct an investigation of several areas of Horseshoe Shoal in Nantucket Sound, where previous side-scan sonar observations indicated potential submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV) beds. This investigation was conducted on July 25, 2006, to ground-truth these potential SAV signatures in the general area of the proposed Cape Wind Energy Project. The major goal of this study was to determine the presence or absence, and to qualitatively assess the composition of, SAV in these areas of variable side-scan sonar returns.  The vegetative composition within the study area was found to consist primarily of attached red (Grinnellia americana, Dasya pedicellata and Gracillaria tikvahiae), and green (Codium fragile, Ulva lactuca) macro-algae. Of the 20 observation points, only one location included patches of eelgrass (Zostera marina). Of the species identified above, only C. fragile is not native to New England waters; however its presence since its introduction has rapidly expanded to range from emergent tidal pools to depths of -12 meters (Villard-Bohnsack 2003).  The data collected during this investigation indicates that while there is significant SAV present on Horseshoe Shoal, it is primarily macro-algae and not seagrass. Many of the macro-algae observed are considered seasonal, beginning its growth in early to mid-summer and disappearing by late August (Hillson 1982, Kingsburry and Sze 1997, Villard-Bohnsac 2003). Of the species observed, G. americana is potentially the most likely responsible for the variable side-scan sonar readings collected during previous geophysical studies conducted in 2003 and 2005. G. americana is a fast growing red alga, with a two- to four-inch-wide blade capable of growing to 50 centimeters in length within a single summer growth season (Hillson 1982). These algae would potentially show as an irregularity on side-scan sonar surveys during the summer growth season, and is likely the reason for the original variable sonar returns.","author":["ESS Group Inc"],"organization":["ESS Group Inc","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2006-08-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SL-ESS2006Submerged.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1830","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/simulation-sediment-transport-deposition-cable-burial-operations-alternative-site-cape","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/SL-ASA2006SimulationofSediment.aspx","title":"Simulation of Sediment Transport and Deposition from Cable Burial Operations for the Alternative Site of the Cape Wind Energy Project","description":"Cape Wind Energy, LLC has proposed to build a wind turbine farm on Horseshoe Shoal in Nantucket Sound. This site has been evaluated in a previous study (Swanson and Isaji, 2005). An alternative site, 9 km (5.6 mi) southwest of Tucknernuck Island, is also being evaluated for the purposes of comparison and is the subject of this report. The project will consist of 130 wind turbine generators (WTG), an electric service platform (ESP) and a series of cables connecting the WTGs to the ESP and a pair of cables from the ESP to shore at Yarmouth. The cables are to be buried using a jetting technique whereby pressurized seawater is jetted below the seabed to fluidize the sediments along the cable route. The cable then sinks of its own weight through the fluidized sediments and is buried as the sediment returns to its pre jetted condition.\n\n\nQuestons have been raised during regulatory agency review concerning the environmental effects of the suspended sediment injected into the water column above the cable route during the jetting process. Specifically, questions concerning the concentration of suspended sediment and the subsequent deposition on the seabed as well as the spatial extent and duration that these processes last have been raised.\n\n\nCape Wind Energy, LLC contracted with Applied Science Associates, Inc. to perform a modeling study to estimate the resulting suspended sediment and deposition from the cable burial process for the cables connecting the WTGs to the ESP at the alternative site. The study used two models: HYDROMAP to calculate currents, and SSFATE to calculate suspended sediments in the water column and bottom deposition resulting from jetting operations.\n\u00a0","author":["Swanson, C.","Isaji, T."],"organization":["Applied Science Associates","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2006-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SL-ASA2006SimulationofSediment.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1831","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysis-effects-wind-turbine-generator-array-alternative-site-cape-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/SL-ASA2006AnalysisofWindTurbine.aspx","title":"Analysis of Effects of Wind Turbine Generator Array for the Alternative Site of the Cape Wind Energy Project","description":"Cape Wind Energy, LLC has proposed to build a wind turbine farm on Horseshoe Shoal in Nantucket Sound. This site has been evaluated in a previous study (Swanson et al., 2005). An alternative site, 9 km (5.6 mi) southwest of Tuckernuck Island, is also being evaluated for comparison purposes. The project will consist of 130 wind turbine generators (WTG), an electric service platform (ESP) and a series of cables connecting the WTGs to the ESP and a pair of cables from the ESP to shore at Yarmouth. Each WTG is either mounted on a monopile or a quad-caisson, consisting of four piles, depending on water depth. Concerns have been raised by regulatory agency review as to the cumulative environmental effects of the WTG pile array on waves and currents and ultimately on sediment transport in Nantucket Sound.\n\nCape Wind Associates LLC contracted with Applied Science Associates, Inc. to perform an analysis to estimate the expected changes in waves and currents from the placement of the WTG pile array both at the primary site at Horseshoe Shoal and the alternative site southwest of Tuckernuck Island, which is the subject of this report. The study used both a hydrodynamic model, HYDROMAP to calculate currents in the area and wave data collected from the Martha\u2019s Vineyard Coastal Observatory (MVCO) to provide input information for the analytic approaches used to estimate the zone of influence of the WTG piles.","author":["Swanson, C.","Subbayya, S."],"organization":["Applied Science Associates","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2006-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SL-ASA2006AnalysisofWindTurbine.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1832","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/risk-whale-encounters-offshore-renewable-energy-mooring-lines-electrical-cables","sourceURL":"","title":"Risk of whale encounters with offshore renewable energy mooring lines and electrical cables","description":"Surface-placed wave energy converters, floating tidal turbines, and floating offshore wind platforms all require anchoring to the seabed with multiple mooring lines and electrical cables passing through the water column, from near the sea surface to the sea floor. Concerns have been raised that large whales may collide with and\/or become entangled in lines and cables from renewable energy installations, causing injury or death. Currently, there are few floating arrays where this encounter can be tested, and no appropriate industrial analogues that can be applied. Using literature values for humpback swimming behavior, diving speed, dive duration, foraging behavior, as well as specifications for a generic floating marine energy array, we have modeled the passage of the whales through the array. Using animation software, we have visualized the passage of an adult-calf pair through the array, as well as the foraging behavior of an adult humpback. From this animation, we hope to gain insight and provide visual context for the risk of large whales and offshore mooring lines and cables.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Copping, A.","Grear, M.","Sanders, G."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","University of Washington","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2018-04-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Collision","Entanglement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BOEM-2018-065_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1833","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tern-observations-near-monomoy-island","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/TernReport12-8-06.aspx","title":"Tern Observations Near Monomoy Island","description":"This report summarizes the results of a study conducted from August 28 through August 31, 2006. The purpose of the study was to document commuting behavior, general flight direction, and the altitude at which terns fly. Observations occurred near a major fall staging area where high concentrations of terns are known to occur. Common (Sterna hirundo) and Roseate Terns (Sterna dougallii) are found in southeastern Massachusetts from May through September. Major breeding, feeding, and staging areas are located in and near Buzzards Bay and Nantucket Sound (Figure 1). After the breeding season, terns congregate in large numbers at staging areas prior to migrating south in late August and September. South Beach and Monomoy Island in Chatham are significant staging areas for the federally and state endangered Roseate Tern. Surveys in 1998 (Trull et al. 1999) found Roseate Terns roosted in the thousands at only two sites in Nantucket Sound, South Beach and the northern portion of Monomoy Island. Subsequent surveys performed by Cape Wind and Massachusetts Audubon confirmed the large concentration of terns at these locations (Perkins et al. 2004, Sadoti et al. 2005, and USACE 2004). The South Beach staging area includes Roseate Terns from as far away as Maine and New York (Trull et al. 1999). Cape Cod and the Islands appear to be the major staging area for much of the New England population of Roseate Terns. In addition, the area appears to be a major staging area for Common Terns, which are listed as a species of special concern by the Massachusetts Natural Heritage Program.","author":["ESS Group Inc"],"organization":["ESS Group Inc","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2006-12-08","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/TernReport2006.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1834","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/revised-navigational-risk-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/FinalRevisedRiskNav11-16-06fullreport.aspx","title":"Revised Navigational Risk Assessment","description":"Cape Wind Associates (CWA) is proposing to construct and operate a 130-turbine Wind Park in central Nantucket Sound along with a submarine electrical transmission cable system interconnecting the Wind Park with the onshore electrical grid. Each wind turbine generator (WTG) will have a tower diameter of approximately 16 feet (FT), and will be installed in a grid with a minimum spacing of 0.34 nautical miles (NM) by 0.54 NM. Inner-array cables connecting each WTG to an electrical service platform located within the Wind Park and the submarine electrical transmission cable system to shore will be embedded into the bottom of Nantucket Sound through the use of a jet plow.\n\n\nAs part of the Environmental Impact Statement preparation process, the US Coast Guard (USCG) requested that a qualitative assessment be prepared of navigational risks related to the proposed Project. The analyses required by the USCG were outlined in a letter to the US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) dated February 10, 2003. ESS Group, Inc. (ESS) prepared the Navigational Risk Assessment per request of the USACE.","author":["ESS Group, Inc."],"organization":["ESS Group Inc","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2006-11-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Navigation"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/CapeWindFinalRevisedRiskNav2006.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1835","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cape-wind-submerged-aquatic-vegetation-diver-survey","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Renewable-Energy-Program\/Studies\/CWfiles\/SL-WH2003DiverSurvey.aspx","title":"Cape Wind Submerged Aquatic Vegetation Diver Survey","description":"A visual check of the areas specified by ESS Group, Inc. and Len Fagan was conducted on June 17, 18, and July 1, 2003 at sites, AV-SS16, AV-SS56, AV SS58, and AV-EGG (Appendix 1 ESS Scope of Work). Positioning was obtained by using a Leica 421B DGPS system with a DGPS accuracy of less than one meter.","author":["Woods Hole Group, Inc."],"organization":["Woods Hole Group, Inc","Cape Wind Associates"],"originationDate":"2003-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.515793000000","-70.347262000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SL-WH2003DiverSurvey.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1836","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparative-effects-climate-change-tidal-stream-energy-extraction-shelf-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1029\/2018JC013832","title":"Comparative Effects of Climate Change and Tidal Stream Energy Extraction in a Shelf Sea","description":"The environmental implications of tidal stream energy extraction need to be evaluated against the potential climate change impacts on the marine environment. Here we study how hypothetical very large tidal stream arrays and a business as usual future climate scenario can change the hydrodynamics of a seasonally stratified shelf sea. The Scottish Shelf Model, an unstructured grid three\u2010dimensional ocean model, has been used to reproduce the present and the future state of the NW European continental shelf. Four scenarios have been modeled: present conditions and projected future climate in 2050, each with and without very large scale tidal stream arrays in Scottish Waters (UK). It is found that where tidal range is reduced a few centimeters by tidal stream energy extraction, it can help to counter extreme water levels associated with future sea level rise. Tidal velocities, and consequently tidal mixing, are also reduced overall by the action of the tidal turbine arrays. A key finding is that climate change and tidal energy extraction both act in the same direction, in terms of increasing stratification due to warming and reduced mixing; however, the effect of climate change is an order of magnitude larger.","author":["Wolf, J.","Murray, R.","De Dominicis, M."],"organization":["National Oceanography Centre (NOC)"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.320850600000","-5.967896300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Dominicis-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1837","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/draft-bat-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-farm-benton-county-indiana-august-3","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fws.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/documents\/Fowler%20Ridge%202016.pdf","title":"Draft Bat Monitoring Studies at the Fowler Ridge Wind Farm Benton County, Indiana: August 3 - October 12, 2016","description":"The Fowler Ridge Wind Farm (FRWF) collectively includes Fowler Ridge Wind Farm LLC, Fowler Ridge II Wind Farm LLC, Fowler Ridge III Wind Farm LLC, and Fowler Ridge Wind Farm IV LLC. The FRWF consists of 420 wind turbines in four phases in Benton County, Indiana. A post-construction casualty study of bats was conducted by Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) within Phases I and III in 2009. During that study period, an Indiana bat carcass was found. The FRWF worked with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and developed a Habitat Conservation Plan for the Indiana bat designed to minimize Indiana bat casualties. FRWF received an Incidental Take Permit for Indiana bats in August of 2014 (TE95012A-0). Monitoring the effectiveness of minimization measures is required by both the Habitat Conservation Plan and the Incidental Take Permit. Two years of Evaluation Phase monitoring, utilizing a larger sample of turbines to test effectiveness of applied minimization procedures, was completed for FRWF Phases I, II and III in 2014 and 2015. Because Indiana bat mortality was below adaptive management thresholds, Implementation Phase monitoring was completed for FRWF Phases I, II and III in 2016 and will continue unless adaptive management thresholds are exceeded in the future. Evaluation Phase monitoring, requiring a minimum of 33% of turbines to be searched, was completed at FRWF Phase IV in 2016 during its first year of operation.  The 2016 casualty study occurred during the fall (August 1 \u2013 October 15) migration period for Indiana bats. Casualty searches were completed once per week on roads and gravel pads of 140 turbines from August 3 \u2013 October 12, 2016. Personnel trained in proper search techniques conducted the carcass searches. Bias trials of searcher efficiency and carcass removal trials were conducted to adjust for removal bias and searcher efficiency.  A total of 129 bat carcasses were found in 2016 during carcasses searches and incidentally. Similar to previous years of monitoring, the most commonly found bat species were eastern red bats, silver-haired bats, and hoary bats. Three big brown bats and one evening bat (state endangered) were also found. No Indiana bat or any other Myotis spp. carcasses were found.  Bat casualty rates were calculated based on number of carcasses found, the results of bias trials, and adjustments for bats that did not fall on roads and pads. Bat casualty rates in 2016 were estimated to be 4.54 bat casualties\/MW\/study period (90% confidence interval 3.42 \u2013 6.05), which was 72.3% lower than casualty estimates at turbines operating normally in 2010. The results of monitoring during 2016 provide evidence that operational strategies exceeded the objective of reducing bat casualty rates by 50%, compared to casualty estimates from turbines in normal operation modes in 2010. Within-season adjustments (for minimization strategies) were not required in 2016 because bat casualty rates were well below adaptive management thresholds.","author":["Good, R.","Iskali, G.","Nasman, K.","Ciecka, A."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.603396000000","-87.297592000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Draft-bat-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-energy-facility-benton-county-indiana-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1838","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-bat-fatality-studies-fowler-ridge-iii-wind-energy-facility-benton-county-indiana","sourceURL":"","title":"Bird and Bat Fatality Studies Fowler Ridge III Wind-Energy Facility Benton County, Indiana: April 2 - June 10, 2009","description":"BP Wind Energy North America, Inc. (BPWENA) is developing a wind-energy facility in five separate phases for a total build out capacity of 1,000 megawatts (MW) in Benton County, Indiana. Currently, the first three phases have a total energy capacity of 750 MW. The third phase of the facility, Fowler Ridge III, is owned entirely by BPWENA and is located approximately two miles (3.2 km) east of Fowler, Indiana, and consists of 60 Vestas V82 1.65-MW turbines with a nameplate capacity of 99 MW.\n\n\nBP Wind Energy North America contracted Western Ecosystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) to develop a post-construction fatality monitoring study at the Fowler I and Fowler III facilities to assess the level of impacts to birds and bats (i.e., high, moderate, low) relative to other wind-energy facilities from operation of the Fowler Ridge I and Fowler Ridge III facilities. Monitoring at the Fowler Ridge III Wind-Energy Facility occurred during the spring migration and early breeding season (April 2 through June 10, 2009), while monitoring of the Fowler I Wind-Energy Facility occurred from April 6 to October 30, 2009. This report presents results of monitoring conducted only at the Fowler III Wind-Energy Facility.\u00a0 Summer and fall migration surveys at the Fowler III Wind-Energy Facility were not conducted due to project-related budget constraints and the expectation that a more robust study would be conducted the second year.\n\n\nThe primary objective of the monitoring study was to determine the level of bird and bat mortality (i.e., relatively high, moderate, or low mortality) attributable to collisions with wind turbines compared to other regional wind-energy facilities. Because not all turbines were sampled, the study was not designed to quantify mortality with a high degree of accuracy for the entire wind energy facility, nor was it designed to detect every wind turbine casualty present on the site.\u00a0 The monitoring study consisted of four components: 1) standardized carcass surveys of selected turbines; 2) searcher efficiency trials to estimate the percentage of carcasses found by searchers; 3) carcass removal trials to estimate the length of time that a carcass remained in the field for possible detection; and 4) adjusted fatality estimates for birds and bats, calculated using the results from searcher efficiency trials and carcass removal trials, to estimate the approximate level of bird and bat mortality within the Fowler Ridge III Wind-Energy Facility. \u00a0\n\n\nTwenty percent of the available turbines (12 turbines) were scheduled to be searched either weekly or biweekly throughout the monitoring period. Search plots 160 meters (525 feet) on a side were established around each turbine to ensure all areas within 80 meters (262 feet) of a turbine were searched. Most of the turbines were located in corn and soybean fields; however, these crops were either not present or very immature during the time frame of the study (April 2 \u2013 June 10) and therefore no clearing of crops was conducted for this study. Surveyors walked parallel transects within the search plots while scanning the ground for fatalities or injured birds or bats.\n\n\nThe objective of the standardized carcass surveys was to systematically search selected turbines for bird and bat casualties attributable to collision with project facilities. During the study, three birds were found. All three of the fatalities were comprised only of a few bones without any feathers or fleshy parts remaining. Two of the fatalities were identifiable only as ducks based on skull characteristics, while the remaining casualty was only identifiable as a large bird because no skull was present; that casualty was likely also a species of waterfowl. No bird fatalities were found incidentally. The FRWEF-III is near an area designated as an Important Bird Area (IBA) due to high concentrations of staging American golden plovers during spring migration. Although concerns have been raised over the potential for collision mortality, no American golden plover fatalities were found during this study.\n\n\nTwo of the bird fatalities (the unidentified large bird and one unidentified duck) were found at Turbine 432 and the remaining unidentified duck casualty was found at Turbine 435. All bird fatalities were found greater than 60 meters (197 feet) from the turbines.\u00a0\n\n\nFive bat fatalities comprised of four species were found, including two hoary bats and one each of the following species: eastern red bat, silver-haired bat, and big brown bat. No bat casualties were found incidentally. Bat fatalities were all found at Turbines 387, 432, 435, 444, and 464. Two of the bat fatalities were found between 10 and 20 meters (33-66 feet) from the turbines, two were found between 40 and 50 meters (131-164 feet) from the turbines, and one was found more than 60 meters (197 feet) from the turbine. Bat fatalities were evenly distributed throughout the duration of the study season. Three bat fatalities were intact, one was scavenged, and one was found alive and was subsequently released.\n\n\nPre-construction ground-based bat acoustical surveys were conducted at the Fowler Ridge Wind Resource Area from August 15 \u2013 October 19, 2007 and from July 17 \u2013 October 15, 2008, time periods that cover the time frame during which most bat mortality at wind energy facilities occurs throughout North America.\u00a0 Overall bat detections were low to moderate for sites in the Midwest, ranging from 4.7 bat calls\/detector-night in 2007 to 6.45 bat calls\/detector-night in 2008.\u00a0 Although none of the bat casualties found at the FRWEF-III in 2009 were high-frequency species (e.g., Myotis spp.), high-frequency bats comprised 49.0% of bat calls in 2007 and 34.2% of bat calls recorded in 2008, suggesting that high frequency species such as Myotis bats may be much less susceptible to turbine collisions.\n\n\nSearcher efficiency data from the adjacent Fowler Ridge Phase I Wind-Energy Facility were combined with data from this study to increase sample sizes, whereas all carcass removal data for the Fowler Ridge Phase I Wind-Energy Facility were used for this study. For searcher efficiency trials, 16 carcasses (eight large birds and eight small birds) were placed in the field during searcher efficiency trials conducted on two separate dates. Observer detection rates were 83.3% for large birds and 50.0% for small birds.\u00a0\n\n\nFor carcass removal trials, 16 carcasses were placed in the Fowler Ridge Phase I Wind-Energy Facility, including eight large bird and eight small birds. By day ten, approximately 25% of the large birds remained, while approximately 35% of the small birds remained.\n\n\nBecause all three birds found during the study were estimated to have died well before the study was initiated, no estimates of avian mortality could be made. The estimated number of bat fatalities and associated 90% confidence limits for the study period from April 2 \u2013 June 10 was 3.03 bat fatalities\/turbine (90% confidence interval of 0.71 to 6.58 bat fatalities\/turbine). Based on the 1.65-megawatt capacity of turbines at the Fowler Ridge Phase III Wind-Energy Facility, the estimated number of bat fatalities was 1.84 bat fatalities per megawatt during the April 2 to June 10 study time period, or a total of 182 estimated bat fatalities for the entire 99-MW facility.\n\n\nTo date there have been fewer than 10 studies conducted to estimate bird and bat fatalities from wind turbine operations in the Midwest, and studies at the Fowler Ridge Wind Energy Facility represent the first such studies in Indiana.\u00a0\u00a0 Results of this study further contribute to our understanding of wind-energy impacts to birds and bats. As more wind-energy facilities are built in the region, and additional studies become available, a clearer picture of the impacts to birds and bats will emerge.","author":["Johnson, G.","Bay, K.","Nomani, S.","Ritzert, M."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","BP"],"originationDate":"2010-04-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.603396000000","-87.297592000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/bird-and-bat-fatality-studies-fowler-ridge-III-wind-energy-facility-benton-county-indiana-2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1839","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/small-beautiful-will-small-wecs-ever-become-commercial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/326261186_Small_is_beautiful_-_but_will_small_WECs_ever_become_commercial","title":"\u0022Small is Beautiful\u0022 - But will Small WECs Ever Become Commercial?","description":"This paper presents a short overview of the development of wave energy converters (WECs) since the 1970s where the oil crises raised the interest in renewable power generation. The \u201csmall is beautiful\u201d motto is dealt with and dismissed when regarding the commercial viability of utility scale WEC power plants. The potential future developmental pathway towards commercialisation of wave energy is compared to the development of the Danish wind mill sector where the first series production of 22 kW started in 1978 \u2013 four years after Prof. Stephen Salter presented his MW sized so called Duck. The paper discusses the capital expenditure CAPEX and operation and maintenance costs (OPEX) for small and large WECs seen over the WEC lifetime and the resulting levelized cost of energy (LCOE) for power plant size wave energy parks. The following statement is taken from the 2014 JRC Ocean Energy Status Report [8]: \u201cMaintenance: small-scale devices are associated with reduced maintenance, since they are designed to operate in farms and a defect to one unit may not affect the overall array performance, hence reducing the time necessary for maintenance.\u201d The paper explains why this is a false statement - maintenance costs will inevitably decrease with increasing WEC size. The paper also justifies that large WECs can obtain relatively low CAPEX and OPEX compared to small WECs, and that large WECs can be expected to match the LCOE for floating wind turbines. Combined offshore wave-wind power plants can be expected to deliver lower LCOE than pure wave or wind parks.","author":["Friis-Madsen, E.","Russell, I.","Soerensen, H."],"organization":["Wave Dragon ApS"],"originationDate":"2018-07-09","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-28 04:05:01","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Friis-Madsen-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1840","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-report-bird-bat-fatality-studies-fowler-ridge-i-wind-energy-facility-benton","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cdxapps.epa.gov\/cdx-enepa-II\/public\/action\/eis\/details;jsessionid=D147A567E3C3F14FA749192B3E1E1F6A?downloadAttachment=\u0026attachmentId=171068","title":"Final Report Bird and Bat Fatality Studies Fowler Ridge I Wind-Energy Facility Benton County, Indiana: April 6 - October 30, 2009","description":"BP Wind Energy North America, Inc. (BPWENA) is developing a wind-energy facility in five separate phases for a total build out capacity of 1,000 megawatts (MW) in Benton County, Indiana. Currently, the first three phases have a total energy capacity of 750 MW. The first phase of the facility, Fowler Ridge I, is jointly owned by BPWENA and Dominion Energy, Inc. and has a nameplate capacity of 301 MW.  The Fowler Ridge I Wind\u2013Energy Facility (FRWEF-I) is located approximately 0.5 miles (0.8 km) south and east of Fowler, Indiana, and consists of 122 Vestas V82 1.65-MW turbines and 40 Clipper C96 2.5-MW turbines. BPWENA contracted Western Ecosystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) to conduct a post-construction fatality monitoring study at the Fowler Ridge I facility.  The study was designed to assess the level of impacts to birds and bats (i.e., high, moderate, low) relative to other regional projects from operation of the wind-energy facility.  Because not all turbines were sampled and because all study plots were not completely cleared of crops, the study was not designed to quantify mortality with a high degree of accuracy for the entire wind energy facility, nor was it designed to detect every wind turbine casualty present on the site.  Monitoring at the Fowler Ridge I facility occurred from April 6 to October 30, 2009.  FRWEF-I is located in western Indiana in Benton County. The topography of the site is mostly flat to slightly rolling and there are no hills, ridges, or other areas of starkly elevated topography. Habitat within and surrounding the FRWEF-I is dominated by tilled agriculture, with corn and soybeans being the dominant crops. Of the roughly 29,000 acres (about 43 mi2) within the FRWEF-I and half-mile (0.8-km) buffer, row crops compose 93%, developed areas compose 5.7%, pastures\/hayfields compose 1.7%, grasslands compose 0.1%, and forested areas compose 0.4% of the land cover.   The monitoring study for the FRWEF-I consisted of the following components: 1) standardized carcass surveys of selected turbines within a square plot centered on the turbine; 2) searcher efficiency trials to estimate the percentage of carcasses found by searchers; 3) carcass removal trials to estimate the length of time that carcasses remain in the field for possible detection; and 4) adjusted fatality estimates based on the results of searcher efficiency trials and carcass removal trials and proportion of the plot searched.  Twenty-five wind turbines were included in the study, and nine of those had crops cleared in late summer within the search plot to facilitate conducting surveys in mature corn and soybean fields. To the extent possible, turbines were selected for sampling using a systematic design with a random start so that the search effort was spread throughout the entire wind-energy facility. However, some modifications to turbine sample selection had to be made to accommodate landowners who did not wish to participate in the study. Square plots 160 by 160 meters (525 by 525 feet) in size were established around the 25 turbines and systematically searched for carcasses. Standardized carcass surveys were conducted anywhere from twice a week to twice a month, with more intensive surveys conducted during the spring and fall migration periods.    Searcher efficiency trials were conducted in the same areas as carcass surveys and searcher efficiency was estimated by the type of carcass (bird or bat), size of carcass (bird carcasses only) and season. Estimates of searcher efficiency were used to adjust the total number of carcasses found for those missed by searchers, correcting for detection bias. Carcass removal studies were conducted during each season, outside of the carcass search plots (i.e., near turbines that were not included in the standard search plots). Estimates of carcass removal were used to adjust the total number of carcasses found for those removed from the study plots, correcting for removal bias.   A total of 778 turbine searches were conducted over the course of the fatality monitoring study. Twenty-eight birds and 156 bats were found during standardized carcass surveys or incidentally. Twenty-four birds comprised of 11 identified species were found during scheduled searches, and four additional bird fatalities were found incidentally. The most common bird species found as a casualty at the site was killdeer (four fatalities), followed by tree swallow (three), red-tailed hawk (three) and unidentified large bird (three); two unidentified ducks were also found as fatalities.  The three unidentified large birds and two unidentified ducks found during the study consisted entirely of a few large bones with no feathers or flesh remaining. The ducks were identified to type based on skull characteristics, but no skulls were found associated with the remaining three unidentified large birds.  The FRWEF-I is near an area designated as an Important Bird Area (IBA) due to high concentrations of staging American golden plovers during spring migration. Although concerns have been raised over the potential for collision mortality, no American golden plover fatalities were found during this study.  Of all the bird fatalities, 35.6% were found within 30 m (99 feet) of the turbine, 28.5% were found from 31 to 60 m (100 to 197 feet), and 35.7% were found more than 60 m from the turbine. Most (64.2%) of the bird fatalities occurred during fall migration (September 3 to October 29), 25.0% occurred during spring migration (April 6 to May 25), and 10.7% occurred during the breeding season (June 10 to August 14).   A total of 107 bat fatalities comprised of six species were found during scheduled searches, and an additional 49 bats were found incidentally. Most (94.2%) of the bat fatalities were migratory tree bats, including 56 eastern red bats (35.9%), 48 hoary bats (30.8%), 42 silver-haired bats (26.9%) and one unidentified Lasiurus spp. (either hoary or eastern red bat). The other bat fatalities included four big brown bats, three little brown bats, one northern long-eared bat, and one Indiana bat.  The Indiana bat is listed as an endangered species by the US Fish and Wildlife Service. The Indiana bat casualty was collected as an incidental casualty on September 11, 2009. The majority (88.2%) of bat fatalities were found within 40 m (131 feet) of the turbines, and most (73.7%) of the bat fatalities occurred from August 1 to September 15, with an additional 12.8% found between September 16 and October 30.   A total of 89 carcasses (17 large birds, 12 small birds, and 60 bats) were placed in the field during searcher efficiency trials conducted on 11 separate dates. Observer detection rates were 64.3% for large birds, 37.5% for small birds, and 56.0% for bats. A total of 82 carcasses were placed in study area throughout the duration of the monitoring period for carcass removal trials, including 16 large birds, 12 small birds, and 54 bats. By day ten, approximately 30% of the bats remained, while approximately 20% of the large birds and nearly 35% of the small birds remained.  Seven turbines surveyed during the study season were lit with Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) mandated aviation strobe lights and 18 were unlit. There were no significant differences in the number of bird or bat fatalities occurring at turbines with or without FAA lighting.   The estimated fatality rate and 90% confidence interval (CI) for the entire study period (all three study seasons) was 5.26 birds\/turbine (90% CI = 3.52, 10.25) and 15.03 bats\/turbine (10.89, 20.52). Given the 301-MW nameplate capacity of the FRWEF-I, the overall fatality estimate for the entire study period (all three study seasons) was 2.83 bird fatalities\/MW and 8.09 bat fatalities\/MW.  The estimated bird fatality rate of 2.83 birds\/MW is lower than average compared to other wind-energy facilities in the Midwest. Overall bird fatality estimates at seven Midwest wind-energy facilities located in Nebraska, Wisconsin, Minnesota, Iowa and Illinois have ranged from 0.6 to 7.2 and averaged 4.28 birds\/MW\/year. The estimated bat fatality rate of 8.09 bats\/MW would be considered moderate when compared to other wind-energy facilities in North America, and is somewhat below average based on the regional average for reported bat fatality estimates at seven wind energy facilities in the Midwest, where bat fatality estimates ranged from 0.8 to 30.6, and averaged 9.8 bats\/MW\/year.   Species composition of bat fatalities was similar to that at most other wind-energy facilities, in that the majority (94.2%) of identified bat fatalities was comprised of three species of migratory tree bats, namely the hoary, eastern red and silver-haired bat. These three species typically comprise over 75% of bat fatalities at wind-energy facilities throughout North America. Based on the timing of fatalities for these three species and the lack of forest cover that might provide habitat for resident bats, most of the fatalities were apparently migrants through the area, as is the case at virtually all other wind energy facilities in North America. It seems unlikely that the FRWEF-I is located along a concentrated tree bat migration route, as there are no topographical features or large expanses of forested areas that would tend to concentrate migrating bats.   Pre-construction ground-based bat acoustical surveys were conducted at the Fowler Ridge Wind Resource Area from August 15 \u2013 October 19, 2007 and from July 17 \u2013 October 15, 2008, time periods that cover the time frame during which most bat mortality at wind energy facilities occurs throughout North America.  Overall bat detections were low to moderate for sites in the Midwest, ranging from 4.7 bat calls\/detector-night in 2007 to 6.45 bat calls\/detector-night in 2008.  Although only 3.2% of the bat casualties found at the FRWEF-I in 2009 were high-frequency species (i.e., Myotis spp.), high-frequency bats comprised 49.0% of bat calls in 2007 and 34.2% of bat calls recorded in 2008, suggesting that high frequency species such as Myotis bats may be much less susceptible to turbine collisions.  The discovery of an Indiana bat turbine casualty at a wind-energy facility sited in a corn and soybean agroecosystem was unexpected. To our knowledge, this is the first Indiana bat related casualty documented at a wind-energy facility in North America, as well as the first documented casualty of a federally-listed bat species at a wind-energy facility. The Indiana bat casualty found during this study is also apparently the first record of Indiana bat in Benton County, Indiana. Based on the lack of Indiana bat summer habitat at or near the FRWEF-I, and the time frame that he Indiana bat casualty occurred (estimated to be September 9, 2009), this individual was likely a migrant through the area.   To date there have been fewer than 10 studies conducted to estimate bird and bat fatalities from wind turbine operations in the Midwest, and studies at the Fowler Ridge Wind Energy Facility represent the first such studies in Indiana.   Results of this study further contribute to our understanding of wind-energy impacts to birds and bats. As more wind-energy facilities are built in the region, and additional studies become available, a clearer picture of the impacts to birds and bats will emerge.","author":["Johnson, G.","Bay, K.","Nomani, S.","Ritzert, M."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","BP"],"originationDate":"2010-04-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.603396000000","-87.297592000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Final-Report-Bird-and-Bat-Fatality-Studies-Fowler-Ridge-I-Wind-Energy-Facility-Benton-County-Indiana.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1841","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-evaluation-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-farm-benton-county-indiana-august","sourceURL":"","title":"Bat Evaluation Monitoring Studies at the Fowler Ridge Wind Farm Benton County, Indiana: August 1 - October 15, 2017","description":"The Fowler Ridge Wind Farm (FRWF) collectively includes Fowler Ridge Wind Farm LLC, Fowler Ridge II Wind Farm LLC, Fowler Ridge III Wind Farm LLC, and Fowler Ridge IV Wind Farm LLC. The FRWF consists of 420 wind turbines in four phases in Benton County, Indiana. A post-construction casualty study of bats was conducted by Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) within Phases I and III in 2009, during which an Indiana bat carcass was found. The FRWF worked with the US Fish and Wildlife Service and developed a Habitat Conservation Plan for the Indiana bat designed to minimize Indiana bat casualties. FRWF received an Incidental Take Permit for Indiana bats in August of 2014 (TE95012A-0). Monitoring the effectiveness of minimization measures is required by both the Habitat Conservation Plan and the Incidental Take Permit. Two years of more intensive evaluation phase monitoring, utilizing a larger sample of turbines to test effectiveness of applied minimization procedures, was completed for FRWF Phases I, II and III in 2014 and 2015. Because Indiana bat mortality was below adaptive management thresholds, less intensive implementation phase monitoring was applied for FRWF Phases I, II and III in 2016 and 2017, and will continue unless adaptive management thresholds are exceeded in the future. The second year of evaluation phase monitoring, requiring a minimum of 33% of turbines to be searched, was completed at FRWF Phase IV in 2017.\n\n\nThe 2017 casualty study occurred during the fall (August 1 \u2013 October 15) migration period for Indiana bats. Casualty searches were completed once per week on roads and gravel pads of 140 turbines from August 1 \u2013 October 11, 2017. Personnel trained in proper search techniques conducted the carcass searches. Searcher efficiency and carcass persistence trials were conducted to adjust for removal bias and searcher efficiency.\n\n\nA total of 130 bat carcasses were found in 2017 during carcass searches and incidentally. Similar to previous years of monitoring, the most commonly found bat species were eastern red bats, silver-haired bats, and hoary bats. Eight big brown bats, one Seminole bat and one evening bat (state-listed as endangered) were also found. No Indiana bat, northern long-eared bat or any other Myotis spp. carcasses were found.\n\n\nBat casualty rates were calculated based on the number of carcasses found, the results of bias trials, and adjustments for bats that did not fall on roads and pads. Bat casualty rates in 2017 were estimated to be 5.24 bat casualties\/MW\/study period (90% confidence interval: 4.09 \u2013 6.90), which was 66.3% lower than casualty estimates at turbines operating normally in 2010. The results of monitoring during 2017 provide evidence that operational strategies exceeded the objective of reducing bat casualty rates by 50%, compared to casualty estimates from turbines operating normally in 2010. Within-season adjustments of minimization strategies were not required in 2017 because bat casualty rates were well below adaptive management thresholds.","author":["Good, R.","Iskali, G.","Nasman, K.","Ciecka, A."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.633960000000","-87.297592000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/bat-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-energy-facility-benton-county-indiana-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1842","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-evaluation-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-farm-benton-county-indiana-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bloximages.chicago2.vip.townnews.com\/pharostribune.com\/content\/tncms\/assets\/v3\/editorial\/0\/bb\/0bba1400-f326-11e7-93b5-978676768af5\/5a513b7701a4b.pdf.pdf","title":"Bat Evaluation Monitoring Studies at the Fowler Ridge Wind Farm Benton County, Indiana: August 3 - October 14, 2015","description":"he Fowler Ridge Wind Farm (FRWF) collectively includes Fowler Ridge Wind Farm LLC, Fowler Ridge II Wind Farm LLC, Fowler Ridge III Wind Farm LLC, and Fowler Ridge Wind Farm IV LLC. Phases I, II and III consists of 355 wind turbines that have been operating in Benton County, Indiana since 2009. Phase IV was constructed during 2015 and began commercial operation in January of 2016. A post-construction casualty study of bats was conducted by Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) within Phases I and III in 2009. During that study period, an Indiana bat carcass was found. The FRWF worked with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service and developed a Habitat Conservation Plan for the Indiana bat designed to minimize Indiana bat casualties. FRWF received an Incidental Take Permit for Indiana bats in August of 2014 (TE95012A-0). FRWF contracted with WEST to complete evaluation phase monitoring of bat carcasses in 2014 and 2015 per the terms of the Habitat Conservation Plan, with the goal of determining if the level of Indiana bat mortality was within authorized limits.    The primary objective of the 2015 monitoring was to determine if the FRWF\u2019s approved minimization measures resulted in a 50% or greater reduction in mortality compared to turbines that operated normally in 2010. The 2015 casualty study occurred during the fall (August 1 \u2013 October 15) migration period for Indiana bats. Casualty searches were completed once per week on roads and gravel pads of 118 turbines from August 3 \u2013 October 14, 2015. Personnel trained in proper search techniques conducted the carcass searches. Searchers walked at a rate of approximately 45 to 60 meters (m) per minute (about 148 to 197 feet [ft] per minute) along each transect looking for bat carcasses. Transects were spaced at approximately 5 m (16 ft) intervals on road and pads, and searchers scanned the area on both sides out to approximately 2.5 m (about eight ft) for casualties as they walked each transect. Bias trials of searcher efficiency and carcass removal trials were conducted.  A total of 164 bat carcasses were found in 2015 during carcasses searches and incidentally. Similar to previous years of monitoring, the most commonly found bat species were eastern red bats, silver-haired bats, and hoary bats. Four big brown bats, one Seminole bat and one little brown bat were also found. No Indiana bat carcasses were found.  Bat fatality rates were calculated based on number of carcasses found, the results of bias trials, and adjustments for bats that did not fall on roads and pads. Bat fatality rates in 2015 were estimated to be 4.86 bat fatalities\/MW\/study period (90% confidence interval 3.66 \u2013 6.65), which was 71.8% lower than casualty estimates at turbines operating normally in 2010. The results of monitoring during 2015 provide evidence that operational strategies exceeded the objective of reducing bat casualty rates by 50% compared to casualty estimates from turbines in normal operation modes in 2010. Within-season adjustments (for minimization strategies) were not required in 2015 because bat fatality rates were well below adaptive management thresholds.","author":["Good, R.","Iskali, G.","Nasman, K."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2016-01-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.603396000000","-87.297592000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/bat-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1843","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-evaluation-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-farm-benton-county-indiana-1","sourceURL":"","title":"Bat Evaluation Monitoring Studies at the Fowler Ridge Wind Farm Benton County, Indiana: August 4 - October 14, 2014","description":"The Fowler Ridge Wind Farm (FRWF) collectively includes Fowler Ridge Wind Farm LLC, Fowler Ridge II Wind Farm LLC, Fowler Ridge III Wind Farm LLC, and Fowler Ridge Wind Farm IV LLC. The FRWF currently consists of 355 wind turbines in three phases in Benton County, Indiana. A post-construction casualty study of bats was conducted by Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) within Phases I and III in 2009. During that study period, an Indiana bat carcass was found. The FRWF worked with the USFWS and developed a Habitat Conservation Plan for the Indiana bat designed to minimize Indiana bat casualties. FRWF received an Incidental Take Permit for Indiana bats in March of 2014 (TE95012A-0). FRWF contracted with WEST to complete monitoring of bat carcasses in 2014 per the terms of the HCP, with the goal of determining if the level of Indiana bat mortality was within authorized limits.\u00a0 \u00a0\n\n\nThe primary objective of the 2014 monitoring was to determine if the FRWF\u2019s approved minimization measures resulted in a 50% or greater reduction in mortality compared to turbines that operated normally in 2010. The 2014 casualty study occurred during the fall (August 1 \u2013 October 15) migration period for Indiana bats. Casualty searches were completed twice per week on roads and gravel pads of 118 turbines from August 4 \u2013 October 14, 2014. Personnel trained in proper search techniques conducted the carcass searches. Searches occurred along transects within each search plot. Searchers walked at a rate of approximately 45 to 60 meters (m) per minute (about 148 to 197 feet [ft] per minute) along each transect looking for bat carcasses. Transects were spaced at approximately 5 m (16 ft) intervals on road and pads, and searchers scanned the area on both sides out to approximately 2.5 m (about eight ft) for casualties as they walked each transect. Bias trials of searcher efficiency and carcass removal rates were conducted.\n\n\nA total of 116 bat carcasses were found in 2014. Similar to previous years of monitoring, the most commonly found bat species were eastern red bats, silver-haired bats, and hoary bats. One big brown bat and one tri-colored bat were also found. No Indiana bat carcasses or other Myotis species were found.\n\n\nBat fatality rates were calculated based on number of carcasses found, the results of bias trials, and adjustments for bats that did not fall on roads and pads. Bat fatality rates in 2014 were estimated to be 3.84 bat fatalities\/MW\/study period (90% CI 3.05 \u2013 4.82), which was 78% lower than casualty estimates at turbines operating normally in 2010. The results of monitoring during 2014 provide evidence that operational strategies exceeded the objective of reducing bat casualty rates by 50% compared to casualty estimates from turbines in normal operation modes in 2010. Within season adjustments to minimization strategies were not required in 2014 because bat fatality rates were well below adaptive management thresholds.","author":["Good, R.","Iskali, G.","Adachi, K."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2015-01-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.603396000000","-87.297592000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/bat-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-energy-facility-benton-county-indiana-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1844","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-energy-facility-benton-county-indiana-april","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.conservationevidence.com\/individual-study\/8850","title":"Bat Monitoring Studies at the Fowler Ridge Wind Energy Facility Benton County, Indiana: April 13 \u2013 October 15, 2010","description":"The Fowler Ridge Wind Farm (FRWF) is collectively owned by BP Wind Energy, Sempra Generation, and Dominion Energy, and is being developed in five separate phases for a total of 1,000 megawatts (MW). The project currently consists of 355 wind turbines in three phases in Benton County, Indiana. A post-construction casualty study of birds and bats was conducted within Phases I and III during 2009 by Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc (WEST). One carcass of an Indiana bat (Myotis sodalis), a federally endangered species, was found by wind plant personnel during the fall of 2009. As a result of this discovery, the US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) Field Office in Bloomington, Indiana, has recommended that the FRWF develop a Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP). Consequently, the owners of the FRWF requested that WEST conduct further research of potential bat casualty and use rates at the FRWF during 2010 for use in completing a HCP and obtaining an Incidental Take Permit (ITP) from Region 3 of the USFWS. The results presented in this report were collected under a Scientific Research and Recovery Permit for the Indiana bat (TE15075A).  Studies at the FRWF were comprised of two components: a bat casualty study and an acoustical bat survey. The goals of the casualty study were: 1) to determine if Indiana bat fatalities were widespread and if fatalities occurred at levels that may reduce the viability of Indiana bat populations; and 2) determine if facility operation management can be utilized as an effective tool for reducing bat casualty rates. The goals of the bat use study were to: 1) measure the overall rates of use of the FRWF by Indiana bats and other bat species; and to 2) provide information that may help to better define periods when potential mitigation and minimization measures for Indiana bats may be most effective.  Casualty searches were conducted during the spring (April 13 \u2013 May 15, 2010) and fall (August 1 \u2013 October 15, 2010) migration periods. Casualty searches were completed on two types of plots: 1) 80 x 80-meter (m; 262 x 262-foot [ft]) square plots centered on 36 turbines and cleared of vegetation; and 2) roads and turbine gravel pads within 40 m (131 ft) of 100 additional turbines. Carcass searches were conducted daily at the 36 square plots, and weekly at the road and pad plots. During the spring, 128 turbines were sampled during the study. Surveys were unable to be completed on eight turbines originally selected for road and pad searches as part of the study plan due to construction activities. Surveys were completed at all 136 turbines in the fall.  Turbines were selected for carcass searches using a systematic sampling design with a random start. During the fall migration period the effectiveness of raising turbine cut-in speeds was tested at a sample of the daily searched turbines. Bat casualty rates were measured at two different cut-in speed adjustments or \u201ctreatments\u201d and two sets of \u201ccontrol\u201d or \u201creference\u201d turbines with no turbine cut-in speed adjustment. Nine turbines were randomly selected from the sample of 36 daily searched turbines for use as a \u201ccontrol\u201d sample, and had no treatments for the duration of the study. Treatments for cut-in speed adjustment and a second set of \u201ccontrol\u201d turbines were rotated on a weekly basis between the remaining 27 daily search turbines, with nine turbines assigned to each group. The treatments included turbines with cut-in speeds raised to a lower level (5 m\/s), and turbines with cut-in speeds raised to higher level (6.5 m\/s). Turbines were randomly assigned to control and treatment groups among the 27 turbines, and treatments were distributed to ensure each turbine received 3 - 4 weeks of each treatment or control status.  During the spring migration period (April 13, 2010 \u2013 May 15, 2010) 80 x 80-m square plots were surveyed 33 times for a total of 1,169 searches. A total of 423 surveys were completed at roads and pads during spring 2010. Thirty-six bat casualties (18 silver-haired bats [Lasionycteris noctivagans], 15 eastern red bats [Lasiurus cinereus], two hoary bats [Lasiurus borealis], and one big brown bat [Eptesicus fuscus]) were found during the spring. Of the 36 bat casualties found, 32 were found during scheduled searches and four were found incidentally. All fresh, non-myotis bat casualties were collected and utilized in searcher efficiency and carcass removal trials. Four raptor casualties (three red-tailed hawks [Buteo jamaicensis] and one rough-legged hawk [Buteo lagopus]), eight small bird casualties (two European starlings [Sturnus vulgaris], one horned lark [Eremophila alpestris], one Tennessee warbler [Vermivora peregrina], one common yellowthroat [Geothlypis trichas], one unidentified dove and two unidentified birds) were also found during spring migration searches.  During the fall 3,871 plot surveys were conducted during 110 visits to the study area at the 36 daily search turbines, with an additional 1,618 surveys being conducted during 17 visits to the facility at the 100 turbines selected for road and pad surveys. A total of 556 bats were found during regularly scheduled searches, with an additional 25 bats found incidentally at turbine search plots. The remaining 228 bat carcasses were found outside of the study period during clearing searches or not on scheduled search turbines and were not included in the casualty estimates. The most commonly found bat species during scheduled searches was eastern red bat (353 fatalities, 63.49% of fatalities), followed by silver haired bat (98 fatalities, 17.62%), hoary bat (84 fatalities, 15.11%), and big brown bat (16 fatalities, 2.88%). Two tri-colored bats (Perimyotis subflavus), two little brown bats (Myotis lucifigus) and one Indiana bat (Myotis sodalis) were also found during scheduled searches.  During these studies, some casualties may have been missed on search plots because either searchers missed them, or scavengers removed them prior to the search. Experimental trials were conducted to estimate these adjustment factors, including an estimate of the probability a carcass is available to be found during a search (i.e. not removed by scavengers) and is detected by observers. A total of 222 fresh bat carcasses were used in calculating an empirical estimate of the probability of availability and detection. These carcasses were allowed to remain where placed for a 28 day period and the date when searchers found the carcasses was noted. Of the 222 carcasses placed 77 were placed on turbines where only the road and pad was searched and 145 were placed on turbines where cleared plots were searched. The empirical estimate for the probability of available and detected on road\/pad searches was 0.51 for weekly searches and 0.58 for cleared plot turbines (i.e. daily searches).  Two casualty estimators were used. The Schoenfeld method utilizes a formula to estimate the probability of a carcass being available and detected by search, and is typically used for studies with infrequent search intervals. The Schoenfeld estimate was calculated to ensure a casualty estimate could be compared to the 2009 bat casualty estimate. The 2nd estimator used, the empirical estimate, was based on daily checks of bat carcasses, and represents an actual measure of carcass availability and detectability.  The estimated number of bat fatalities per turbine (based on Shoenfeld\u2019s pi estimates) was 0.91 for daily search plots and 0.43 for weekly search plots during the spring season. These estimates increased during the fall season, with 17.69 bat fatalities per turbine per season at daily search turbines and 15.73 bats per turbine at weekly searches. Adjusted casualty estimates based on empirical estimates for the probability of available and detected were 1.25 bats per turbine for daily search turbines and 0.55 bats per turbine for weekly searches in the spring and 24.17 bats per turbine for daily search turbines and 20.96 per turbine for weekly searches in the fall, with an overall adjusted casualty estimate of 22.20 bats per turbine for the study period.  Bat casualty rates were lower at turbines where cut-in speeds were adjusted. Bat casualty rates and corresponding 90% bootstrap confidence intervals of 14.0 (11.6 - 16.5), 7.0 (7.0 - 9.1), and 3.0 (1.8 - 4.2) bats\/turbine\/season were recorded at control, 5.0 m\/s, and 6.5 m\/s treatment conditions respectively. Non-overlapping confidence intervals for observed casualty rates under each cut-in speed condition indicate a significant difference between treatments. An approximate 50% reduction in overall bat mortality was realized by raising the cut-in speed by 1.5 m\/s (from 3.5 m\/s to 5.0 m\/s). An approximate 78% reduction in overall bat mortality was realized by raising the cut-in speed by 3.0 m\/s (from 3.5 m\/s to 6.5 m\/s).  Relationships between bat casualty rates and weather factors were evaluated utilizing Poisson regression during the fall migration period of 2010. Bat casualty rates were highest on nights with higher bat activity, lower mean wind speeds, higher mean temperature and increasing variance in temperature, and increasing barometric pressure. In other words, higher bat fatalities were associated with warmer, calmer evenings prior to or after the passage of weather fronts and increasing bat activity. Bat casualty rates were also related to turbine type, with higher bat casualty rates observed at turbines with greater rotor swept areas.  Bat activity was monitored at the base of four daily search turbines on 36 nights during the spring period of April 9 through May 14. Bat activity was monitored at ground locations previously monitored during 2007 on 95 nights during the fall period of July 15 through October 18, 2010. Turbine locations were monitored at the base from August 1 through October 18, 2010; and nacelle units from August 17 through October 18, 2010. Anabat units recorded 185 bat passes on 137 detector-nights during the spring, and 5,721 bat passes on 685 detector-nights during the fall. The average bat activity for ground stations was 1.34 \u00b1 0.29 bat passes per detector-night in the spring, and 11.46 \u00b1 1.29 at ground stations and 3.10 \u00b1 0.42 at raised stations during the fall.  Calls were placed in three groups, based on call frequency. During the spring study season, passes by low-frequency bats (LF; 46.5% of all bat passes) outnumbered passes by mid-frequency bats (MF; 28.1%) and high-frequency bats (HF; 25.4%), and this pattern was consistent among ground stations. Temporal patterns of use were similar among all three species groups during the study period, with the highest periods of use occurring during the first two weeks in August. During the fall study season, passes by LF bats (55.2% of all bat passes) outnumbered passes by HF (22.4%), and MF (22.3%), and this pattern was consistent among ground stations. Among raised stations, LF bats comprised 71.6% of passes. LF and MF comprised a greater proportion, and HF comprised a lower proportion, of calls recorded on the nacelle of turbines compared to ground stations. Temporal patterns of use were similar among all three species groups during the study period.  Using a call library, Myotis bat calls were analyzed to determine if call characteristics resembled Indiana bat calls. Three methods were utilized to identify potential Indiana bat calls, including a Discriminant Function Analysis, the \u201cBritzke\u201d filter, and a qualitative analysis by WEST biologists. Thirty calls were identified by the Discriminant Function Analysis as resembling calls made by Indiana bats in 2010, two calls passed the Britzke filter, and WEST biologists identified all 30 calls as being made by Myotis, but were not able to conclusively determine if calls were made by Indiana or little brown bat. Most potential Myotis calls were identified as occurring on the evening of August 9-10, 2010 at a ground-based station located away from turbines. Based on the presence of multiple potential calls, Myotis were present on the evening of August 9-10 at Station 2 (located away from turbine locations), and some potential exists that these calls were made by Indiana bats. The recording of individual potential Myotis sodalis calls identified by the Discriminant Function Analysis on other nights and stations does not provide strong evidence of Myotis sodalis activity due to the potential for incorrect identifications.  Bat activity was also actively sampled during both the spring and fall study seasons by driving east-west transects across the study area twice per week and recording calls at water sources and other potential bat habitat features. During the spring study period (five detector nights), active bat monitoring efforts recorded five HF bat passes, one MF bat pass, and nine LF bat passes. During the fall study season (21 detector-nights), active bat monitoring efforts recorded 32 HF bat passes, 59 MF bat pass, and 43 LF bat passes. None of the passes were identified as Indiana bat.  Bat activity was positively correlated with observed casualty rates, although other factors, such as weather and turbine type also played a role in observed bat casualty rates. Correlation between bat activity (number of bat passes per detector night) recorded with Anabat units located on the nacelles of selected turbines and observed casualty rates of fresh bat carcass finds was stronger than the correlation of casualty rates to Anabat detectors located at the base of turbines (Pearson\u2019s correlation coefficients; 0.45 and 0.07 respectively).  The primary goals of the 2010 casualty study were to: 1) determine if Indiana bat fatalities were widespread, and if fatalities occurred at levels that may reduce the viability of Indiana bat populations; and 2) determine if facility operation management can be utilized as an effective tool for reducing bat casualty rates. Despite the increased survey effort over studies conducted in 2009, and despite reasonable probabilities of detecting bat carcasses during the study, very few Myotis carcasses were found, with only one Indiana bat carcass found during the study. Very few Myotis calls were recorded during the course of the study, and multiple calls potentially resembling Indiana bat calls were recorded at a single station on one evening during the fall migration period. It is clear that Indiana bat casualties were not widespread and did not occur at a high rate during the spring and fall migration period of Indiana bats. The data collected during this study also provide a reasonable estimate of overall bat casualties within the FRWF. More detailed estimates of Indiana bat casualties for future operations of the FRWF will be calculated within a Habitat Conservation Plan, currently being prepared for the FRWF.  The data collected at the FRWF show bat casualty rates were affected by bat activity, weather, turbine types, and habitat. These observed relationships provide a baseline for developing additional hypotheses for implementing and testing measures to reduce bat casualty rates. The results also show that Indiana bat fatalities occur at the FRWF, albeit at an extremely low rate. While the low rate of Indiana bat fatalities likely indicate impacts of operation of the FRWF are also low, the low casualty rates also make it difficult to recommendations specific measures for Indiana bats. Thus, recommendations provided in this report are aimed at providing a basis for designing a strategy for reducing overall bat casualty rates under the assumption that Indiana bat casualty rates will also be reduced.  Raising turbine cut-in speeds showed a reduction in bat casualty rates at FRWF during the fall of 2010, and similar reductions in bat casualty rates have also been documented by researchers at other wind-energy facilities. However; correlations observed between weather variables and bat fatalities suggest that focusing or adjusting cut-in speeds during periods when bats may be at most risk, or at locations where bats may be more likely to be found as fatalities, may provide similar reductions in bat fatalities.","author":["Erickson, W.","Bay, K.","Good, R.","Merrill, A.","Simon, S.","Murray, K.","Fritchman, C."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2011-01-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.509231200000","-85.769856400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Good-et-al-2011_Fowler-Ridge.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1845","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/efficient-3d-movement-based-kernel-density-estimator-application-wildlife-ecology","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dl.acm.org\/citation.cfm?doid=2616498.2616522","title":"Efficient 3D Movement-Based Kernel Density Estimator and Application to Wildlife Ecology","description":"We describe an efficient implementation of a 3D movement-based kernel density estimator for determining animal space use from discrete GPS measurements. This new method provides more accurate results, particularly for species that make large excursions in the vertical dimension. The downside of this approach is that it is much more computationally expensive than simpler, lower-dimensional models. Through a combination of code restructuring, parallelization and performance optimization, we were able to reduce the time to solution by up to a factor of 1000x, thereby greatly improving the applicability of the method.","author":["Fisher, R.","Tracey, J.","Sheppard, J.","Lockwood, G.","Chourasia, A.","Tatineni, M.","Sinkovits, R."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2014-07-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1846","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/continental-scale-seasonal-movements-heterothermic-migratory-tree-bat","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1890\/13-0752.1","title":"Continental-scale, seasonal movements of a heterothermic migratory tree bat","description":"Long\u2010distance migration evolved independently in bats and unique migration behaviors are likely, but because of their cryptic lifestyles, many details remain unknown. North American hoary bats (Lasiurus cinereus cinereus) roost in trees year\u2010round and probably migrate farther than any other bats, yet we still lack basic information about their migration patterns and wintering locations or strategies. This information is needed to better understand unprecedented fatality of hoary bats at wind turbines during autumn migration and to determine whether the species could be susceptible to an emerging disease affecting hibernating bats. Our aim was to infer probable seasonal movements of individual hoary bats to better understand their migration and seasonal distribution in North America. We analyzed the stable isotope values of non\u2010exchangeable hydrogen in the keratin of bat hair and combined isotopic results with prior distributional information to derive relative probability density surfaces for the geographic origins of individuals. We then mapped probable directions and distances of seasonal movement. Results indicate that hoary bats summer across broad areas. In addition to assumed latitudinal migration, we uncovered evidence of longitudinal movement by hoary bats from inland summering grounds to coastal regions during autumn and winter. Coastal regions with nonfreezing temperatures may be important wintering areas for hoary bats. Hoary bats migrating through any particular area, such as a wind turbine facility in autumn, are likely to have originated from a broad expanse of summering grounds from which they have traveled in no recognizable order. Better characterizing migration patterns and wintering behaviors of hoary bats sheds light on the evolution of migration and provides context for conserving these migrants.","author":["Cryan, P.","Wunder, M.","Stricker, C."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","University of Colorado Boulder"],"originationDate":"2014-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1847","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/home-heat-dramatic-seasonal-variation-home-range-desert-golden-eagles-informs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320715001317","title":"Home in the heat: Dramatic seasonal variation in home range of desert golden eagles informs management for renewable energy development","description":"Renewable energy is expanding quickly with sometimes dramatic impacts to species and ecosystems. To understand the degree to which sensitive species may be impacted by renewable energy projects, it is informative to know how much space individuals use and how that space may overlap with planned development. We used global positioning system\u2013global system for mobile communications (GPS-GSM) telemetry to measure year-round movements of golden eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) from the Mojave Desert of California, USA. We estimated monthly space use with adaptive local convex hulls to identify the temporal and spatial scales at which eagles may encounter renewable energy projects in the Desert Renewable Energy Conservation Plan area. Mean size of home ranges was lowest and least variable from November through January and greatest in February\u2013March and May\u2013August. These monthly home range patterns coincided with seasonal variation in breeding ecology, habitat associations, and temperature. The expanded home ranges in hot summer months included movements to cooler, prey-dense, mountainous areas characterized by forest, grasslands, and scrublands. Breeding-season home ranges (October\u2013May) included more lowland semi-desert and rock vegetation. Overlap of eagle home ranges and focus areas for renewable energy development was greatest when eagle home ranges were smallest, during the breeding season. Golden eagles in the Mojave Desert used more space and a wider range of habitat types than expected and renewable energy projects could affect a larger section of the regional population than was previously thought.","author":["Duerr, A.","Katzner, T.","Miller, T.","Lanzone, M.","Braham, M.","Fesnock, A.","LaPre, L.","Driscoll, D."],"organization":["West Virginia University","US Bureau of Land Management (BLM)","US Geological Survey (USGS)","US Department of Agriculture (USDA)"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.013588000000","-115.473340000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:46:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1848","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/call-independent-automatic-acoustic-system-individual-recognition-animals-novel-model","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0031320310002529","title":"A call-independent and automatic acoustic system for the individual recognition of animals: A novel model using four passerines","description":"Research into acoustic recognition systems for animals has focused on call-dependent and species identification rather than call-independent and individual identification. Here we present a system for automatic call-independent individual recognition using mel-frequency cepstral coefficients and Gaussian mixture models across four passerine species. To our knowledge this is the first application of these techniques to the individual recognition of birds, and the results are promising. Accuracies of 89.1\u201392.5% were achieved and the acoustic feature and classifier method developed here have excellent potential for individual animal recognition and can be easily applied to other species.","author":["Sun, Y.","Cheng, J.","Ji, L."],"organization":["Chinese Academy of Sciences"],"originationDate":"2010-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Passerines"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:15","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1849","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/summary-bat-fatality-data-nationwide-database","sourceURL":"https:\/\/awwi.org\/resources\/awwic-bat-technical-report\/","title":"A Summary of Bat Fatality Data in a Nationwide Database","description":"Bats collide with wind turbines resulting in fatalities, and much has been learned about the pattern and magnitude of this mortality in the U.S. and Canada (Kunz et al. 2007, Arnett et al. 2008, Arnett and Baerwald 2013, Barclay et al. 2017). Previously, cumulative assessments of this mortality have relied almost entirely on data gleaned from publicly available studies of bat collision fatalities at wind energy facilities (e.g., Arnett and Baerwald 2013). In this report we describe and summarize the bat fatality rate and fatality incident data contained in the American Wind Wildlife Information Center (AWWIC: pronounced \u201cA-wic\u201d), which includes both publicly available and confidential bat collision fatality data from wind energy facilities. We focus on describing the patterns of bat fatalities at wind farms across regions of the U.S. as represented in AWWIC. It is our intention that this report will focus future research evaluating the patterns observed in the data thus furthering our understanding of the variation in risk to bats from wind energy development among species and regions. The current report focuses on data from U.S. wind energy facilities, but we intend to include available data from wind facilities in Canada in future reports. In the process described below, we continue to add data as studies become available and this report will be updated on a regular basis.","author":["Allison, T.","Butryn, R."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-07-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2026-05-30 01:03:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1850","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biofree-international-collaboration-assess-impacts-biofouling-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"","title":"BioFREE: an international collaboration to assess the impacts of biofouling on the marine renewable energy industry","description":"The success of the marine renewable energy (MRE) industry is dependent upon maximising energy capture and minimising down-time. Device performance is negatively impacted by the growth of fouling organisms, leading to reduced efficiency and reliability; anti-fouling strategies are costly and time consuming. Biofouling also reduces accuracy of data buoys and sensors used to assess the hydrodynamic resource and device performance. While biofouling has been a recognised problem for centuries, deployment of MRE devices creates several issues unique to this sector. \u201cBiofouling of Renewable Energy Environments \u2013 Marine\u201d (BioFREE) is a NERC-funded multidisciplinary project that partners Heriot-Watt University with the European Marine Energy Centre. This project is addressing these issues by detailed characterisation of the biofouling communities from multiple habitats used by the MRE sector, and monitoring benthic impacts following deployment and decommissioning. BioFREE has designed a system using framemounted settlement panels to facilitate data collection. Frames are populated with materials of greatest concern to MRE developers, and allow testing of antifouling coatings. Frames are being deployed at several international test centres. Ongoing studies indicate strong species specific seasonal settlement patterns. Fouling communities varied between deployment habitats depending on factors such as hydrodynamic conditions, water depth, and substrate type.  These findings will allow recommendations for test centres and developers to minimise the impacts of fouling, chiefly through selective scheduling of deployments and maintenance, in different habitats, to times when the settlement of fouling organisms will be minimal or their removal will be least costly. In addition, BioFREE has created training materials to help inform the MRE industry of ways to better capture biofouling information when conducting operations at sea. Practical suggestions are informed by recent decommissioning operations conducted on MRE infrastructure. These studies have identified structural areas and materials of particular concern from the impacts of biofouling.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Want, A.","Porter, J."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2018-04-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wantetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1852","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/overcoming-barriers-marine-renewables-energy-development","sourceURL":"","title":"Overcoming Barriers to Marine Renewables Energy Development","description":"Currently, the marine renewable energy (MRE) industry is struggling with high costs of baseline environmental assessments and post-installation monitoring, as well as long timelines for obtaining permits, leading to uncertainty and risk for financing projects. One solution to overcome such barriers and help advance the MRE industry could be the ability to transfer learning, analyses, and datasets among countries, projects, and across jurisdictional boundaries. Encouraging transfer of data between projects can help satisfy regulatory requirements, amplify understanding of environmental effects of MRE devices, and lead to standardized processes for data collection and analysis. Key to enabling the transfer of data among projects is ensuring that the regulators and advisers are engaged and willing to help implement a process for sharing data.  In 2017, the Annex IV team engaged US regulators through online webinars, and carried out a survey to understand the state of regulator knowledge and preferences for permitting MRE developments. Based on these exchanges, progress can be made by: 1) disseminating information of MRE interactions with the marine environment; 2) conducting new research for outstanding questions of environmental effects; 3) making a case that data transfer can occur with confidence, including developing a set of best practices for data transferability and to ensure data collection consistency.  This paper will present the findings of the survey and other engagements with regulators, provide insight into the process of data transferability, and seek to engage the research community in furthering this process.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Copping, A.","Gorton, A.","Dreyer, S.","Freeman, M."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","Arizona State University"],"originationDate":"2018-04-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Freemanetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1853","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-impact-rows-tidal-stream-turbines-overtides-m2-presentation","sourceURL":"","title":"Assessing the Impact of Rows of Tidal-Stream Turbines on the Overtides of the M2 [Presentation]","description":"Flood-ebb asymmetry of a tidal flow has important implications for net sediment transport (e.g. Wang 1999) and the potential extractable resource (Neill et al. 2014, Robins et al. 2015). The asymmetry of the tide may be understood through the interaction of the M2 (principal lunar) and M4 (first even overtide of the M2) tidal constituents in UK waters (Pingree \u0026amp; Griffiths, 1979). The interaction of the M2 tide with a tidal-stream turbine will alter the M4 tide, both augmenting and reducing the M4 amplitude, leading to an alteration of flood-ebb asymmetry (Potter et al., 2017). In this paper, through numerical modelling, the impact of multiple turbines, deployed in a row aligned normal to the tidal flow direction, on the overtides of the M2 have been investigated, along with the way that additional turbines change the way the turbines impact shallow-water tides individually. The results of the modelling show that in rows of turbines, each individual turbine has less impact on the asymmetry than it would individually. In rows with spacings of 1D and 2D, where D is the turbine diameter, despite the smaller impact of the turbines individually, the footprint of the row on the asymmetry (defined as the area where the change to the asymmetry is \u2265 2%) grows with additional turbines and therefore reduced spacing. For a more sparsely packed row, with a spacing of 3D, the footprint of the row is the same as that of an individual turbine. This suggests that for N \u2265 2, where N is the number of turbines in the row, and spacings \u0026gt; 3D a row of turbines may have a smaller footprint than an individual turbine. This requires further testing to confirm.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Potter, D.","Folkard, A.","Ili\u0107, S."],"organization":["Lancaster University"],"originationDate":"2018-04-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/016_POTTER_EMIR2018_3.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1854","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-climate-change-renewable-energy-development-habitat-endemic-squirrel","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320716302142","title":"Impacts of climate change and renewable energy development on habitat of an endemic squirrel, Xerospermophilus mohavensis, in the Mojave Desert, USA","description":"Predicting changes in species distributions under a changing climate is becoming widespread with the use of species distribution models (SDMs). The resulting predictions of future potential habitat can be cast in light of planned land use changes, such as urban expansion and energy development to identify areas with potential conflict. However, SDMs rarely incorporate an understanding of dispersal capacity, and therefore assume unlimited dispersal in potential range shifts under uncertain climate futures. We use SDMs to predict future distributions of the Mojave ground squirrel, Xerospermophilus mohavensis Merriam, and incorporate partial dispersal models informed by field data on juvenile dispersal to assess projected impact of climate change and energy development on future distributions of X. mohavensis. Our models predict loss of extant habitat, but also concurrent gains of new habitat under two scenarios of future climate change. Under the B1 emissions scenario- a storyline describing a convergent world with emphasis on curbing greenhouse gas emissions- our models predicted losses of up to 64% of extant habitat by 2080, while under the increased greenhouse gas emissions of the A2 scenario, we suggest losses of 56%. New potential habitat may become available to X. mohavensis, thereby offsetting as much as 6330 km2 (50%) of the current habitat lost. Habitat lost due to planned energy development was marginal compared to habitat lost from changing climates, but disproportionately affected current habitat. Future areas of overlap in potential habitat between the two climate change scenarios are identified and discussed in context of proposed energy development.","author":["Inman, R.","Esque, T.","Nussear, K.","Leitner, P.","Matocq, M.","Weisberg, P.","Dilts, T."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","University of Nevada","California State University"],"originationDate":"2016-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1855","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/landscape-scale-distribution-density-raptor-populations-wintering-anthropogenic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10531-015-0916-6","title":"Landscape-scale distribution and density of raptor populations wintering in anthropogenic-dominated desert landscapes","description":"Anthropogenic development has great potential to affect fragile desert environments. Large-scale development of renewable energy infrastructure is planned for many desert ecosystems. Development plans should account for anthropogenic effects to distributions and abundance of rare or sensitive wildlife; however, baseline data on abundance and distribution of such wildlife are often lacking. We surveyed for predatory birds in the Sonoran and Mojave Deserts of southern California, USA, in an area designated for protection under the \u201cDesert Renewable Energy Conservation Plan\u201d, to determine how these birds are distributed across the landscape and how this distribution is affected by existing development. We developed species-specific models of resight probability to adjust estimates of abundance and density of each individual common species. Second, we developed combined-species models of resight probability for common and rare species so that we could make use of sparse data on the latter. We determined that many common species, such as red-tailed hawks, loggerhead shrikes, and especially common ravens, are associated with human development and likely subsidized by human activity. Species-specific and combined-species models of resight probability performed similarly, although the former model type provided higher quality information. Comparing abundance estimates with past surveys in the Mojave Desert suggests numbers of predatory birds associated with human development have increased while other sensitive species not associated with development have decreased. This approach gave us information beyond what we would have collected by focusing either on common or rare species, thus it provides a low-cost framework for others conducting surveys in similar desert environments outside of California.","author":["Duerr, A.","Katzner, T.","Miller, T.","Lanzone, M.","Duerr, K.","Fesnock, A."],"organization":["West Virginia Division of Natural Resources","US Department of Agriculture (USDA)","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2015-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1856","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/can-tidal-stream-turbines-change-tides-pentland-firth-there-acceptable-limit","sourceURL":"","title":"Can tidal stream turbines change the tides in the Pentland Firth, and is there an acceptable limit?","description":"Around half of Scotland\u2019s tidal stream resource is located in the Pentland Firth and Orkney Waters (PFOW), with most of it in the Pentland Firth. This work investigates the effect that extracting tidal stream energy in the region may have on the tide (tidal amplitudes, speeds, phases and transport) and addresses the following questions: (i) what is the maximum energy that can be extracted, and (ii) is there a sustainable upper limit of energy extraction? A hydrodynamic model of the PFOW was used to study a number of idealised tidal stream array layouts in the Pentland Firth. The tidal stream turbines were represented as sub grid scale objects using a momentum sink. This work shows that, on average, 5.3 GW could be extracted from the Pentland Firth using tidal stream turbines, but that doing this would cause a large change in water levels and tidal currents in specific areas within this region. It is therefore important to consider how much energy to extract from this region, taking into consideration the potential environmental impact. This work shows that it is important to consider where and how to extract energy, as this will influence the degree of change to the tides and, consequently, the marine environment.  More information about the EIMR 2018 Conference is available here.","author":["Murray, R."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2018-04-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/002_2018-04-24_EIMR_ROMurray.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1857","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spotlight-ocean-energy-20-projects-5-policy-initiatives","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.energy.gov\/eere\/water\/articles\/ocean-energy-systems-releases-spotlight-ocean-energy-report","title":"Spotlight on Ocean Energy: 20 Projects + 5 Policy Initiatives","description":"This report provides insights of 20 ocean energy projects and 5 policy initiatives on the OES member countries. These projects are good examples of the intense activity of this emerging sector but there is a much larger number of relevant projects being developed world wide.","author":["Ocean Energy Systems (OES)"],"organization":["Ocean Energy Systems (OES)"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OES-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1858","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sea-troubles-evaluating-user-conflicts-development-ocean-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/seagrant.oregonstate.edu\/sgpubs\/sea-troubles-evaluating-user-conflicts-development-ocean-energy","title":"A Sea of Troubles? Evaluating User Conflicts in the Development of Ocean Energy","description":"As an emerging industry, ocean energy (OE) is expected to play a major contributory role to reach long-term global emissions reductions targets. The offshore environment has become the new frontier for renewable energy production with many high-capacity wind parks and other technologies such as tidal and wave energy being increasingly developed. The scale and extent of the ocean renewables industry is unprecedented. Their demands for space places increased pressure on the marine area.","author":["Conway, F.","Colton, J.","Campbell, M.","de Groot, J.","Reilly, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1859","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ensuring-sustainable-development-ocean-energy-technologies-through-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/chapters\/edit\/10.9774\/gleaf.9781315618586_10\/ensuring-sustainable-development-ocean-energy-technologies-environmental-assessment-laws-policies-glen-wright-edward-willsteed-anne-marie-hagan","title":"Ensuring the sustainable development of ocean energy technologies through environmental assessment laws and policies","description":"Environmental assessments (EA) are a range of tools commonly used in the regulation and consenting of projects and plans to estimate and evaluate the effects of a course of action on the environment. EA helps project proponents and decision makers consider the environmental consequences of proposed actions by identifying impacts and considering ways to minimise, mitigate or compensate for them.","author":["Wright, G.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","Willsteed, E."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1860","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/consenting-ocean-energy-projects-issues-challenges-opportunities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.worldcat.org\/title\/ocean-energy-governance-challenges-for-wave-and-tidal-stream-technologies\/oclc\/1011559804","title":"Consenting ocean energy projects: issues, challenges and opportunities","description":"Most jurisdictions have not yet implemented specific consenting processes for ocean energy (OE), and instead rely on a patchwork of existing instruments to consent various aspects of OE projects. The inefficient and ad hoc consenting frameworks that result have been consistently recognised as a major barrier to the progress of OE. Policymakers are, however, beginning to modernise regulatory frameworks in order to better facilitate and manage OE projects. In particular, some jurisdictions have started streamlining their regulatory frameworks, for example through the establishment of a one-stop shop (OSS) for consenting and the development of targeted legislation and regulatory processes.","author":["Wright, G.","O\u0027Hagen, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1861","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-planning-ocean-energy-perspective","sourceURL":"https:\/\/researchportal.hw.ac.uk\/en\/publications\/marine-planning-an-ocean-energy-perspective","title":"Marine Planning: An Ocean Energy Perspective","description":"It was long thought that the marine environment was not amenable to planning. Property rights, the core of the terrestrial planning system, were virtually non-existent in the marine environment, jurisdictions were vague, and the whole maritime area appeared as a single homogeneous mass of unstable waters without boundaries. The dominant and traditional maritime industries, fishing and shipping, had managed to coexist in relative peace for hundreds of years without formal planning processes to guide them.","author":["Johnson, K.","Wright, G."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1862","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behavioral-responses-migrating-juvenile-salmonids-subsea-high-voltage-dc-power-cable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00227-018-3385-0","title":"Behavioral responses by migrating juvenile salmonids to a subsea high-voltage DC power cable","description":"Currently, there is large-scale interest in developing marine-based energy sources and extensive subsea power cable networks. Despite growing concern that local perturbations in the magnetic field produced by current passing through these cables may negatively affect electromagnetically sensitive marine species, e.g., disrupted migration; few studies have examined free-living animals. We used acoustic biotelemetry tracking data to examine movement behaviors and migration success of a magneto-sensitive fish, late-fall run Chinook (LFC) salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha), in relation to the energization of a magnetic field-producing subsea power cable, as well as other potentially influential environmental parameters. We analyzed detection records of tagged LFC salmon smolts during their out-migration through the San Francisco Bay before and after the installation of an 85-km high-voltage direct-current transmission cable. Cable energization did not significantly impact the proportion of fish that successfully migrated through the bay or the probability of successful migration. However, after cable energization, higher proportions of fish crossed the cable location and fish were more likely to be detected south of their normal migration route. Transit times through some regions were reduced during cable activity, but other environmental factors were more influential. Resource selection models indicated that proximity to the active cable varied by location: migration paths moved closer to the cable at some locations, but further away at others. Overall, cable activity appeared to have mixed, but limited effects on movements and migration success of smolts. Additional studies are recommended to further investigate impacts of subsea cables on fish migrations, including potential long-term consequences.","author":["Klimley, A.","Kavet, R.","Wyman, M.","Battleson, R.","Agosta, T.","Chapman, E.","Haverkamp, P.","Pagel, M."],"organization":["University of California Davis","University of Zurich","Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.021861100000","-122.317617800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1863","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-energy-governance-challenges-wave-tidal-stream-technologies","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.worldcat.org\/title\/ocean-energy-governance-challenges-for-wave-and-tidal-stream-technologies\/oclc\/1011559804","title":"Ocean Energy: Governance Challenges for Wave and Tidal Stream Technologies","description":"Energy from wave and tidal power is a key component of current policies for renewable sources of energy. This book provides the first comprehensive exploration of legal, economic, and social issues related to the emerging ocean energy industry, in particular wave and tidal energy technologies.    This industry is rapidly developing, and considerable technical literature has developed around the technology. However, it is shown that challenges relating to regulation and policy are major impediments to industry development, and these aspects have not previously been sufficiently highlighted and studied. The book informs policymakers, industry participants, and researchers of the key issues in this developing field. Ocean energy is considered in the context of the blue economy and an industrialising ocean, and the topics covered include: development of policy (policy instruments, risk and delay in technology development); legal aspects (consenting processes, resource management, impact assessment); human interactions (conflicts, consultation, community benefits); and spatial planning of the marine environment.    While offshore wind energy, sited in the oceans but not strictly derived from the ocean, is not the primary focus of the book, there is also discussion of the similarities and differences between offshore wind and wave and tidal power policy dimensions.    Preliminary Material             1. Introduction G. Wright, S.  Kerr  and K. Johnson Part I: Risk and economics             2. Risk and ocean energy S. Jude, Simon, A. Gill, C.  Mauelshagen and E. Willsteed             3. Government policy, risk and investment timing S. MacDougall    Part II: Marine governance             4. Building governance at sea K. Johnson             5. Marine planning: an ocean energy perspective K. Johnson and G. Wright             6. Mare reservarum: enclosure of the commons and the evolution of marine rights in an era of ocean industrialisation S. Kerr, K. Johnson, J. Colton, G. Wright and S. Weir   Part III: Project consenting and regulation             7. Consenting ocean energy projects: issues, challenges and opportunities A. O\u2019Hagan and G. Wright             8. Consenting ocean energy projects: an overview of procedures in selected jurisdictions A. O\u2019Hagan and G. Wright             9. Ensuring the sustainable development of ocean energy technologies through environmental assessment laws and policies G. Wright, E. Willsteed and A. O\u2019Hagan   Part IV: Community and conflicts             10. A sea of troubles? Evaluating user conflicts in the development of ocean energy J. de Groot, M. Campbell, K. Reilly, J. Colton and  F. Conway             11. Community benefits schemes S. Kerr and S. Weir              12. Consultation in ocean energy development J. Colton, F. Conway, B. Wiersma, J.  Carlson and P. Devine-Wright             13. Ocean energy at the edge L. Watts and B. R.  Winthereik","author":["Johnson, K.","Kerr, S.","Wright, G."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1864","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-bird-habitats-guidelines-wind-power-projects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ontario.ca\/page\/birds-and-bird-habitats-guidelines-windpower-projects","title":"Bird and Bird Habitats: Guidelines for Wind Power Projects","description":"The Green Energy Act, 2009 places a priority on expanding Ontario\u2018s use of clean and renewablesources of energy such as wind, water, solar and bioenergy. Developing these resources is a cornerstone of the province\u2018s plan to reduce the impacts of climate change and to build a greener economy for Ontario.  A key element of the Green Energy Act is a coordinated provincial approval process for renewable energy projects. This new process integrates into one process all provincial Ministry requirements for the review and decision making on proposed renewable energy generation facilities. The requirements are outlined under the Ministry of the Environment\u2018s Renewable Energy Approvals Regulation (O.Reg. 359\/09) and the Ministry of Natural Resources\u2018 (MNR) Approval and Permitting Requirements Document for Renewable Energy Projects.  The Renewable Energy Approvals Regulation describes the requirements for wind power projects related to significant natural features, including significant wildlife habitat. Birds are important to Ontario\u2018s biodiversity, and their habitats are identified as significant wildlife habitat (SWH) under MNR\u2018s Significant Wildlife Habitat Technical Guide.  This Guideline provides guidance on identifying and assessing bird habitat and addressing potential negative effects on birds and bird habitats during the planning, construction, and operation of onshore wind power projects in Ontario. This Guideline supports the Renewable Energy Approvals Regulation and is applicable to both Crown and private land.","author":["Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources"],"organization":["Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources"],"originationDate":"2011-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.253776000000","-85.323215000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/birds_and_habitat_ontario.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1865","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/taiwanese-white-dolphins-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.forskningsdatabasen.dk\/en\/catalog\/2410043948","title":"Taiwanese white dolphins and offshore wind farms","description":"Taiwan has proposed development of offshore wind energy in the Eastern Taiwan Strait, which is home to the endemic and critically endangered Taiwanese white dolphin (Sousa chinensis taiwanensis). The most significant source of disturbance from offshore wind is noise from percussive piling on turbine foundations. The direct impact on Taiwanese white dolphins from construction and operation of offshore wind farms in the Taiwan Strait is considered to be manageable by appropriate mitigation measures (most importantly by application of air bubble curtains during percussive piling of turbine foundations) and within limits, that will not further endanger the population of dolphins. However, considering and handling possible knock-on effects from changes in use of the areas, including consequences for bycatch rates in fisheries, is critical in order to secure the long-time survival of the Taiwanese white dolphin.","author":["Tougaard, J.","Mikaelsen, M."],"organization":["Aarhus University","NIRAS","Danish Center for Environment and Energy"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tougaard-and-Mikaelsen-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1866","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/eagle-take-minimization-system","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1460284-eagle-take-minimization-system","title":"Eagle Take Minimization System","description":"Laufer Wind (LW) has developed a prototype Eagle Take Minimization System that shows capabilities for autonomously detecting, tracking, and visually identifying eagles and other protected avians out to approximately 1 km range with no human-in-the-loop. This type of detection system is important for animals that fly too close to facilities that can harm them, such as large wind turbine farms. The Eagle Take Minimization System consists of networked and sensor-fused commercial-off-the-shelf (COTS) X-band radars, PZT visible cameras and a Central Controller computer that can be interfaced with a wind facility SCADA. The intended design of the Eagle Take System is to detect and reliably identify eagles at far enough range so that proximate turbines can be stopped to greatly reduce the risk of eagle injury or death. These curtailed turbines would be released when eagles have moved away. Other wind turbines that are not in close proximity to eagles would continue producing electricity as usual throughout the process.","author":["Petr, R.","Knag, J.","Laufer, E."],"organization":["Laufer Wind","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-08","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Petr-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1867","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/lca-pelamis-wave-energy-converter","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s11367-018-1504-2","title":"An LCA of the Pelamis wave energy converter","description":"Purpose: To date, very few studies have attempted to quantify the environmental impacts of a wave energy converter, and almost all of these focus solely on the potential climate change impacts and embodied energy. This paper presents a full life cycle assessment (LCA) of the first-generation Pelamis wave energy converter, aiming to contribute to the body of published studies and examine any potential trade-offs or co-benefits across a broad range of environmental impacts.  Methods: The process-based attributional LCA was carried out on the full cradle-to-grave life cycle of the Pelamis P1 wave energy converter, including the device, its moorings and sub-sea connecting cable up to the point of connection with the grid. The case study was for a typical wave farm located off the north-west coast of Scotland. Foreground data was mostly sourced from the manufacturer. Background inventory data was mostly sourced from the ecoinvent database (v3.3), and the ReCiPe and CED impact assessment methods were applied.  Results and discussion: The Pelamis was found to have significantly lower environmental impacts than conventional fossil generation in 6 impact categories, but performed worse than most other types of generation in 8 of the remaining 13 categories studied. The greatest impacts were from steel manufacture and sea vessel operations. The device performs quite well in the two most frequently assessed impacts for renewable energy converters: climate change and cumulative energy demand. The carbon payback period is estimated to be around 24 months (depending on the emissions intensity of the displaced generation mix), and the energy return on investment is 7.5. The contrast between this and the poor performance in other impact categories demonstrates the limitations of focussing only on carbon and energy.  Conclusions: The Pelamis was found to generally have relatively high environmental impacts across many impact categories when compared to other types of power generation; however, these are mostly attributable to the current reliance on fossil fuels in the global economy and the early development stage of the technology. Opportunities to reduce this also lie in reducing requirements for steel in the device structure, and decreasing the requirements for sea vessel operations during installation, maintenance and decommissioning.","author":["Harrison, G.","Thomson, R.","Chick, J."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.963614000000","-3.301120000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:27:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Thomsonetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1868","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-digital-vhf-technology-monitor-shorebird-seabird-use-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/scholarworks.umass.edu\/dissertations_2\/761\/","title":"Evaluating Digital VHF Technology to Monitor Shorebird and Seabird Use of Offshore Wind Energy Areas in the Western North Atlantic","description":"Information on offshore movements of high priority bird species is needed for monitoring and managing adverse effects of offshore wind energy development in the western North Atlantic Ocean. This information is particularly important at night and during periods of inclement weather when risks of collision with offshore wind turbines may be elevated. For small-bodied avian taxa, technologies for monitoring movements of individually-marked birds are limited since satellite-based devices are still too heavy (\u003E 5 g) for use on birds weighing \u003C 150 g. In this dissertation, I evaluate the use of light-weight (1 to 1.5 g) digital VHF transmitters and a network of automated radio telemetry stations for tracking shorebirds and seabirds in offshore areas. In Chapter One, I compare digital VHF telemetry with satellite telemetry for tracking a shorebird, the American Oystercatcher (Haematopus palliatus), at nesting areas in coastal Massachusetts. In Chapter Two, I evaluate possible adverse effects and retention time of using a glue and suture method for attaching digital VHF transmitters to the inter-scapular region of Common Terns (Sterna hirundo), a small-bodied seabird. In Chapter Three, I analyze data on the movements of digital VHF-tagged Common Terns and Arctic terns (Sterna paradisaea) from four colonies throughout the western North Atlantic Ocean to assess the utility of this technology for tracking birds at regional scales. In Chapter Four, I examine movements of digital VHF-tagged Common Terns from two colonies in southern New England shelf region of the U.S. Atlantic relative to Wind Energy Areas in state and federal waters. The aim of this chapter is to evaluate the use digital VHF telemetry for tracking terns across offshore Wind Energy Areas and to relate offshore movement events to temporal (time of day, calendar date), atmospheric (wind speed, precipitation rate, visibility) and demographic (sex, nesting colony) covariates associated with assessments of collision risk. Through these studies, I evaluate the safety and effectiveness of using digital VHF transmitter technology on non-Endangered Species Act listed shorebird and seabirds with the aim of informing future studies on two species of high conservation concern, the federally threatened Piping Plover (Charadrius melodus) and the federally endangered Roseate Tern (Sterna dougallii).","author":["Loring, P."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Shorebirds","Collision","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Loring-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1869","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/commercial-wind-lease-issuance-site-characterization-activities-atlantic-outer","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.federalregister.gov\/documents\/2012\/02\/03\/2012-2494\/commercial-wind-lease-issuance-and-site-assessment-activities-on-the-atlantic-outer-continental","title":"Commercial Wind Lease Issuance and Site Characterization Activities on the Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf Offshore New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, and Virginia","description":"On November 23, 2010, Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar announced the \u201cSmart from the Start\u201d Atlantic wind energy initiative to accelerate the responsible development of wind energy on the Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf (OCS). The initiative calls for the identification of areas on the Atlantic OCS that appear most suitable for commercial wind energy activities, and the opening of these areas for leasing and detailed site assessment activities. On February 9, 2011, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management, Regulation and Enforcement (BOEMRE) identified areas of the OCS offshore the Mid-Atlantic States \u2013 New Jersey, Delaware, Maryland, and Virginia \u2013 that appeared to provide the most suitable opportunity for wind energy development while presenting the fewest apparent user conflicts.   Under the renewable energy regulations, the issuance of leases and subsequent approval of wind energy development on the OCS is a staged decision-making process. BOEMRE\u2019s wind energy program occurs in four distinct phases: (1) planning and analysis; (2) lease issuance; (3) approval of a site assessment plan (SAP); and (4) approval of a construction and operation plan (COP). The first phase is to identify suitable areas for wind energy leasing consideration through collaborative, consultative and analytical processes. The second phase, issuance of a commercial wind energy lease, gives the lessee the exclusive right to subsequently seek BOEMRE approval for the development of the leasehold. The lease does not grant the lessee the right to construct any facilities; rather, the lease grants the right to use the leased area to develop its plans, which must be approved by BOEMRE before the lessee can move on to the next stage of the process. The third stage of the process is the submission of a SAP, which contains the lessee\u2019s detailed proposal for the construction of a meteorological tower and\/or the installation of meteorological buoys on the leasehold. The lessee\u2019s SAP must be approved by BOEMRE before it conducts these \u201csite assessment\u201d activities on the leasehold. The fourth stage of the process is the submission of a COP, a detailed plan for the construction and operation of a wind energy project on the lease.  Pursuant to the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), 42 U.S.C. \u00a7\u00a7 4321-4370f, and the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) Regulations at 40 CFR 1501.3, this EA was prepared to assist the agency in determining which OCS areas offshore the Mid-Atlantic States should be the focus of BOEMRE\u2019s wind energy leasing efforts. This EA considers a number of reasonable geographic and non-geographic alternatives, and evaluates the environmental and socioeconomic consequences (including potential user conflicts) associated with issuing leases and approving site assessment plans under each alternative.","author":["Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"organization":["BOEM Office of Renewable Energy Programs","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2011-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.935766000000","-74.411388000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MidAtlanticWEAs_DraftEA.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1870","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impact-assessment-wave-energy-converters-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/285579453_Environmental_Impact_Assessment_Of_Wave_Energy_Converters_A_Review","title":"Environmental Impact Assessment Of Wave Energy Converters: A Review","description":"In Europe, wave energy developments are increasing in both number and size. Even though, most wave devices are still at the prototype development stage, an increasing number are now approaching sufficient levels of development where more advanced projects are already operative, in particular in North Europe. Accordingly, there is a growing need to consider the environmental consequences and potential impacts of these renewables activities on the marine environment. This paper presents an overview of the state of art in Europe of the existing environmental impact studies on Wave Energy Converters (hereafter WECs). A summary of the European legislation is also provided and together with an overview of the current WECs technology operating in Europe. Then, the different identified environmental impacts by technologies and life process (construction, operation and decommissioning) in the European seas is also described. This review represents a starting point to identify which are the main effects of WECs on marine and coastal environment. Possible future strategies to minimize such environmental impacts are provided. Finally, recommendations are given for future studies of Environmental Impact Assessment EIA of Marine Renewable Energy Installations MREIs in the perspective to enhance future deployments minimizing the associated impacts.","author":["Azzellino, A.","Vicinanza, D.","Lanfredi, C.","Riefolo, L."],"organization":["Polytechnic University of Milan","Seconda Universit\u00e0 degli Studi di Napoli"],"originationDate":"2015-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.769560000000","11.255814000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1871","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/potential-environmental-effects-leading-edge-hydrokinetic-energy-technology","sourceURL":"https:\/\/rosap.ntl.bts.gov\/view\/dot\/12471","title":"Potential Environmental Effects of Leading Edge Hydrokinetic Energy Technology","description":"The Volpe Center evaluated potential environmental challenges and benefits of the ARPA-E funded research project, Marine Hydrokinetic Energy Harvesting Using Cyber-Physical Systems, led by Brown University. The \u201cLeading Edge\u201d research team developed and tested an innovative hydrofoil-type power conversion device to capture energy from flowing water. The technology could provide low-carbon energy to power remote homes\/businesses, port and marine facilities, or other coastal facilities, among other uses. This primary aim of this study was to assess which potential environmental impacts of the Leading Edge technology are similar to other tidal energy devices and which might be unique. This report identifies best practices and mitigation measures that could minimize environmental risk during design and deployment of hydrokinetic energy devices. To support future permitting processes, this report includes a summary of NEPA requirements and information that could contribute to a site-specific environmental impact assessment. Volpe also collected environmental data during Leading Edge prototype testing and found that for a vessel-mounted stationary deployment, alteration of water currents and acoustic impacts are likely to be at the lower range of possible impacts.","author":["Sudderth, E.","Lewis, K.","Cumper, J.","Mangar, A.","Flynn, D."],"organization":["US Department of Transportation (DOT)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Sudderth_et_al_2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1872","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-public-nimby-participation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/books.google.com\/books?hl=en\u0026lr=\u0026id=Fld0TnYF504C\u0026oi=fnd\u0026pg=PR3\u0026dq=environmental+impact+statements+wave+energy\u0026ots=ycdVj-nuj9\u0026sig=w5wPXbHEQ0HeYKsK75hpQqjDQco","title":"Renewable Energy and the Public: from NIMBY to Participation","description":"Throughout the world, the threat of climate change is pressing governments to accelerate the deployment of technologies to generate low carbon electricity or heat. But this is frequently leading to controversy, as energy and planning policies are revised to support new energy sources or technologies (e.g. offshore wind, tidal, bioenergy or hydrogen energy) and communities face the prospect of unfamiliar, often large-scale energy technologies being sited near to their homes. Policy makers in many countries face tensions between \u0027streamlining\u0027 planning procedures, engaging with diverse publics to address what is commonly conceived as \u0027NIMBY\u0027 (not in my back yard) opposition, and the need to maintain democratic, participatory values in planning systems.\u00a0\n\nThis volume provides a timely, international review of research on public engagement, in contexts of diverse, innovative energy technologies. Public engagement is conceived broadly - as the interaction between how developers and other key actors engage with publics about energy technologies (including assumptions held about the methods used, such as the provision of financial benefits or the holding of deliberative events), and how individuals and groups engage with energy policies and projects (including indirectly through the media and directly through emotional and behavioural responses).\u00a0\n\nThe book\u0027s contributors are leading experts in the UK, Europe, North and South America and Australia drawn from a variety of relevant social science disciplinary perspectives. The book makes a significant contribution to our existing knowledge, as well as providing interested professionals, policymakers and members of the public with a timely overview of the critical issues involved in public engagement with low carbon energy technologies.\n\nIntroduction -\u00a0P. Devine-Wright\nSection 1: Conceptual approaches\nSymmetries, expectations, dynamics and contexts: A\u00a0framework for understanding public engagement with renewable energy projects -\u00a0G. Walker, P. Devine-Wright, J. Barnett, K. Burningham, N. Cass, H. Devine-Wright, G. Speller, J. Barton, B. Evans, Y. Heath, D. Infield, J. Parks, and K. Theobald\n\u0027Planning and persuasion\u0027: The principles, procedures, and pitfalls of public engagement in decision-making about renewable energy -\u00a0C. Haggett\nBeyond consensus? Agonism, republicanism and a low carbon future -\u00a0J. Barry and G. Ellis\nPublic roles and socio-technical configurations: Diversity in renewable energy deployment in the UK and its implications -\u00a0G. Walker and N. Cass\nFrom backyards to places: Public engagement and the emplacement of renewable energy technologies - P.\u00a0Devine-Wright\n\nSection 2: Empirical studies of public engagement\nPart 1: Stakeholder and media representations of public engagementDiscourses on the implementation of wind power: Stakeholder views on public engagement -\u00a0M. Wolsink\nGoverning the reconfiguration of energy in Greater London: Practical public engagement as \u0027delivery\u0027 -\u00a0M. Hodson and S. Marvin\nEnvisioning public engagement with renewable energy: an empirical analysis of images within the UK National Press 2006\/2007 -\u00a0H. Devine-Wright\nNIMBYism and community consultation in electricity transmission network planning -\u00a0M. Cotton and P. Devine-Wright\n\nPart 2: Case studies of public beliefs and responses:\nFuture energy scenarios:Turning the heat on: Public engagement in Australia\u0027s energy future -\u00a0P. Ashworth, A. Littleboy, P. Graham, and\u00a0S. Niemeyer\n\nSolar energy and microgeneration:Shaping people\u0027s engagement with microgeneration technology: the case of solar photovoltaics in UK homes -\u00a0D. Abi-Ghanem and C. Haggett\nSiting solar power in Arizona: A public value failure? -\u00a0M. Pasqualetti and C. Schwartz\nSocio-environmental research on energy sustainable Communities: Participation experiences of two decades -\u00a0P. Schweizer-Ries\nYes in my back yard: UK householders pioneering microgeneration heat -\u00a0R. Roy and S. Caird\n\nWind energySocio-environmental impacts of Brazil\u0027s first large-scale wind farm -\u00a0R.L. Improta and J.Q. Pinheiro\nPerceptions and preferences regarding offshore wind power in the United States:\u00a0The leading edge of a new energy source for the Americas -\u00a0J. Firestone\n\nHydrogen energyThe limits of upstream engagement in an emergent technology: Lay perceptions of hydrogen energy technologies -\u00a0R. Flynn, P. Bellaby, and\u00a0M. Ricci\nPublic engagement with wind-hydrogen energy technology: A\u00a0comparative study -\u00a0F. Sherry-Brennan, P. Devine-Wright, and H. Devine-Wright\n\nMarine energySymbolic interpretations of wave energy in the UK: surfers\u0027 perspectives - C. McLachlan\n\nBioenergyHeat and light: Understanding bioenergy siting controversy -\u00a0P. Upham\n\nNuclear and low carbon energyFrom the material to the imagined: Public engagement with low carbon technologies in a nuclear community -\u00a0C. Butler, K. Parkhill, and N. Pidgeon\n\n\n\nConclusions:\u00a0P. Devine-Wright","author":["Devine-Wright, P."],"organization":["University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave","Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1873","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/you-dont-do-chemistry-experiment-your-best-china-symbolic-interpretations-place","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421509005758","title":"\u0027You don\u0027t do a chemistry experiment in your best china\u0027: Symbolic interpretations of place and technology in a wave energy case","description":"In-depth interviews were combined with analysis of a wide range of secondary data to assess the formation of opposition and support in the case of the Wave Hub in Cornwall, UK. It is argued that stakeholder responses to renewable energy developments are, in part, related to interpretations of what both the technology and the location or \u2018place\u2019 are seen to represent or symbolise. There is a need to move beyond knowledge deficit and NIMBY models if these issues are to be explored. Place was interpreted at different scales and was seen as: economically vulnerable, as having a sense of local ownership, as a resource and as nature. Symbolic interpretations of the technology related to the contested environmental status and significance of electricity produced, as well as it being seen as a project for local people, commercial, experimental, pioneering, industrial and at one with Mother Nature. These interpretations gave rise to various symbolic logics of opposition and support, some of which are outlined. Although a case study of a wave energy development, many of the issues discussed relate to renewable energy developments more widely. Therefore the findings are discussed in relation to their implications for renewable energy developers and UK energy strategy.","author":["McLachlan, C."],"organization":["University of Manchester"],"originationDate":"2009-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.266047000000","-5.052713000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1874","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/disturbance-harbour-porpoises-during-construction-first-seven-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v596\/p213-232\/","title":"Disturbance of harbour porpoises during construction of the first seven offshore wind farms in Germany","description":"We investigated the disturbance effects of offshore windfarm construction on harbour porpoises Phocoena phocoena using acoustic porpoise monitoring data and noise measurements during construction of the first 7 large-scale offshore wind farms in the German Bight between 2010 and 2013. At 6 wind farms, active noise mitigation systems (NMS) were applied during most piling events, and 1 was constructed without. Based on generalized additive modelling analyses, we describe a clear gradient in the decline of porpoise detections after piling, depending on noise level and distance to piling. Declines were found at sound levels exceeding 143 dB re 1 \u00b5Pa2s (the sound exposure level exceeded during 5% of piling time, SEL05) and up to 17 km from piling. When only considering piling events with NMS, the maximum effect distance was 14 km. Compared to 24-48 h before piling, porpoise detections declined more strongly during unmitigated piling events at all distances: at 10-15 km declines were around 50% during piling without NMS, but only 17% when NMS were applied. Within the vicinity (up to about 2 km) of the construction site, porpoise detections declined several hours before the start of piling and were reduced for about 1-2 d after piling, while at the maximum effect distance, avoidance was only found during the hours of piling. The application of first generation NMS thus reduced the effect range of pile driving and led to a lower decline of porpoise detections over all distances. However, NMS were still under development and did not always work with equal efficiency. As NMS have further developed since, future investigations are expected to show additional reduction of disturbance effects.","author":["Nabe-Nielsen, J.","Piper, W.","Diederichs, A.","Nehls, G.","Brandt, M.","Dragon, A.","Wahl, V.","Bellmann, M."],"organization":["IBL Umweltplanung GmbH","Institute of Technical and Applied Physics (itap) GmbH","BioConsult SH","Aarhus University"],"originationDate":"2018-05-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1875","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/building-stakeholders-vision-offshore-wind-farm-project-group-modeling-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969712000745","title":"Building a stakeholder\u0027s vision of an offshore wind-farm project: A group modeling approach","description":"This paper describes a Group Model Building (GMB) initiative that was designed to discuss the various potential effects that an offshore wind-farm may have on its local ecology and socioeconomic development. The representatives of various organizations in the study area, Lu-Kang, Taiwan, have held several meetings, and structured debates have been organized to promote the emergence of a consensual view on the main issues and their implications. A System Dynamics (SD) model has been built and corrected iteratively with the participants through the GMB process. The diverse interests within the group led the process toward the design of multifunctional wind-farms with different modalities. The scenario analyses, using the SD model under various policies, including no wind-farm policy, objectively articulates the vision of the local stakeholders. The results of the SD simulations show that the multifunctional wind-farms may have superior economic effects and the larger wind-farms with bird corridors could reduce ecological impact. However, the participants of the modeling process did not appreciate any type of offshore wind-farm development when considering all of the identified key factors of social acceptance. The insight gained from the study can provide valuable information to actualize feasible strategies for the green energy technique to meet local expectations.","author":["Chang, Y.","Ch\u00e2teau, P.","Chen, H.","Ko, T."],"organization":["National Sun Yat-Sen University"],"originationDate":"2012-03-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["24.075514000000","120.447285000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1876","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-protected-areas-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/9781119075806.ch14","title":"Marine Protected Areas and Offshore Wind Farms","description":"This chapter discusses the potential negative impacts that an offshore wind farms (OWFs) can have on marine biodiversity and the ways an OWF can increase species abundance, richness and biodiversity to establish whether OWF and Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) can in fact ever co\u2010exist. It also discusses the future prospects for OWF development that may reduce the initial impact, thereby enhancing their co\u2010existence. The chapter considers examples where OWFs and MPAs exist in the same place as well as examples of where the existence of an MPA has prohibited or stalled the construction of an OWF. There are three main stages in the life of an OWF: construction, operation and decommissioning. The chapter discusses some of the known effects of OWF noise on marine mammals, such as temporary hearing loss and permanent tissue damage.","author":["Sanders, N.","Haynes, T.","Goriup, P."],"organization":["NatureBureau"],"originationDate":"2017-03-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1877","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/responses-bottlenose-dolphins-harbor-porpoises-impact-vibration-piling-noise-during","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ecs2.1793","title":"Responses of bottlenose dolphins and harbor porpoises to impact and vibration piling noise during harbor construction","description":"The development of risk assessments for the exposure of protected populations to noise from coastal construction is constrained by uncertainty over the nature and extent of marine mammal responses to man\u2010made noise. Stakeholder concern often focuses on the potential for local displacement caused by impact piling, where piles are hammered into the seabed. To mitigate this threat, use of vibration piling, where piles are shaken into place with a vibratory hammer, is often encouraged due to presumed impact reduction. However, data on comparative responses of cetaceans to these different noise sources are lacking. We studied the responses of bottlenose dolphins and harbor porpoises to both impact and vibration pile driving noise during harbor construction works in northeast Scotland, using passive acoustic monitoring devices to record cetacean activity and noise recorders to measure and predict received noise levels. Local abundance and patterns of occurrence of bottlenose dolphins were also compared with a five\u2010year baseline. The median peak\u2010to\u2010peak source level estimated for impact piling was 240 dB re 1 \u03bcPa (single\u2010pulse sound exposure level [SEL] 198 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2 s), and the r.m.s. source level for vibration piling was 192 dB re 1 \u03bcPa. Predicted received broadband SEL values 812 m from the piling site were markedly lower due to high propagation loss: 133.4 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2 s (impact) and 128.9 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2 s (vibration). Bottlenose dolphins and harbor porpoises were not excluded from sites in the vicinity of impact piling or vibration piling; nevertheless, some small effects were detected. Bottlenose dolphins spent a reduced period of time in the vicinity of construction works during both impact and vibration piling. The probability of occurrence of both cetacean species was also slightly less during periods of vibration piling. This work provides developers and managers with the first evidence of the comparative effects of vibration and impact piling on small cetaceans, enabling more informed risk assessments, policy frameworks, and mitigation plans. In particular, our results emphasize the need for better understanding of noise levels and behavioral responses to vibration piling before recommending its use to mitigate impact piling.","author":["Barton, T.","Hastie, G.","Thompson, P.","Merchant, N.","Graham, I.","Farcas, A.","Pirotta, E.","Cheney, B."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen","Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)","University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2017-05-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.623927000000","-4.023353000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Graham_et_al-2017-Ecosphere.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1878","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-impacts-wind-farms-seabirds-individual-based-model","sourceURL":"https:\/\/besjournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1111\/1365-2664.12996","title":"Predicting the impacts of wind farms on seabirds: An individual-based model","description":"Individual\u2010based models (IBMs) are a powerful tool in predicting the consequences of environmental change on animal populations and supporting evidence\u2010based decision making for conservation planning.\n\n\nThere are increasing proposals for wind farms in UK waters and seabirds are a vulnerable group, which may be at risk from these developments.\n\n\nWe developed a spatially explicit IBM to investigate the potential impacts of the installation of wind farms in the English Channel and North Sea on body mass, productivity and mortality of a breeding population of Northern gannets for which we have tracking data.\n\n\nA baseline model with no wind farms accurately represented the status of a sample of tracked gannets at the end of the 90\u2010day chick\u2010rearing period, and the behaviour\u2010time budget was similar to that of tracked gannets.\n\n\nModel simulations in the presence of wind farms indicated that installations should have little impact on the gannet population, when either avoidance behaviour or collision risk scenarios were simulated. Furthermore, wind farms would need to be ten times larger or in more highly used areas in order to have population\u2010level impacts on Alderney\u0027s gannets.\n\n\nSynthesis and applications. Our spatially explicit individual\u2010based models (IBM) highlight that it is vital to know the colony\u2010specific foraging grounds of seabirds that may be impacted, when identifying potential wind farm sites, in order to account for cumulative impacts from multiple sites. Avoiding areas highly used for foraging and commuting, and avoiding large\u2010scale developments should be effective in limiting gannet mortality as a result of collision, competition and energy expenditure. Our IBM provides a robust approach which can be adapted for other seabird populations or to predict the impacts from other types of spatial change in the marine environment.","author":["Atkinson, P.","Green, J.","Warwick-Evans, V.","Walkington, I."],"organization":["University of Liverpool","British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.971524000000","1.435206000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Warwick-Evans_et_al-2018-Journal_of_Applied_Ecology.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1879","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dim-ultraviolet-light-means-deterring-activity-hawaiian-hoary-bat-lasiurus-cinereus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/esr\/v28\/n3\/p249-257\/","title":"Dim ultraviolet light as a means of deterring activity by the Hawaiian hoary bat Lasiurus cinereus semotus","description":"Widespread bat fatalities at industrial wind turbines are a conservation issue with the potential to inhibit efficient use of an abundant source of energy. Bat fatalities can be reduced by altering turbine operations, but such curtailment decreases turbine efficiency. If additional ways of reducing bat fatalities at wind turbines were available such tradeoffs might not be needed. Based on the facts that bats perceive distant objects primarily through vision and can see in very dim lighting conditions, and the possibility that bats might interact with turbines after approaching them as they would trees, we propose a novel method of reducing bat activity at wind turbines: illumination of the structure with dim light. As a first step toward assessing this approach, we illuminated trees with dim flickering ultraviolet (UV) light in areas frequented by Hawaiian hoary bats Lasiurus cinereus semotus, an endangered subspecies affected by wind turbines. We used a repeated-measures design to quantify bat activity near trees with acoustic detectors and thermal video cameras in the presence and absence of UV illumination, while concurrently monitoring insect numbers. Results indicate that dim UV reduces bat activity despite an increase in insect numbers. Experimental treatment did not completely inhibit bat activity near trees, nor did all measures of bat activity show statistically significant differences due to high variance in bat activity among sites. However, the observed decreases in bat activity with dim UV illumination justify further testing of this method as a means to reduce bat fatalities at wind turbines.","author":["Cryan, P.","Johnson, J.","Gorresen, P.","Bonaccorso, F.","Dalton, D.","Wolf, S.","Todd, C."],"organization":["University of Hawaii","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2015-10-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:23","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gorresenetal2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1880","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbine-impact-near-ground-air-temperature","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118302350","title":"Wind turbine impact on near-ground air temperature","description":"Several aspects of wind farms\u2019 environmental impacts have been thoroughly studied. Their effect on surface temperature, however, has not been sufficiently explored. We analysed variations in land surface temperature observed over 5 months on a large wind farm (42\u202f000\u202fkW maximum output). To describe the near-surface microclimate variability, we measured air temperature at 15\u202fcm above ground using 14 autonomous microclimatic stations arranged in the vicinity of 4 turbines. The observation covered various weather conditions from summer to winter. In contrast to some other recent studies, we confirmed no clear long-term, stable effect of wind turbines on near-ground temperatures. The only effect we found was a daytime warming effect at one of the four turbines. Our results suggest that in mountainous conditions the effect of turbulence caused by wind turbines can be overridden by natural wind turbulence.","author":["Moravec, D.","Bart\u00e1k, V.","Pu\u0161, V.","Wild, J."],"organization":["Czech University of Life Sciences Prague"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.475026800000","13.124154400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1881","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-cumulative-socio-ecological-impacts-offshore-wind-farm-development-bay-seine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X1730444X","title":"Assessing cumulative socio-ecological impacts of offshore wind farm development in the Bay of Seine (English Channel)","description":"As part of the energy transition, the French government is planning the construction of O\ufb00shore Wind Farms (OWFs) in Normandy. These OWFs will be integrated into an ecosystem already facing multiple anthropogenic disturbances. A holistic view of cumulated impacts (OWF construction, global warming and \ufb01sheries) were developed on the Courseulles-sur-Mer\u2019 ecosystem through the use of a qualitative mathematical modelling approach. This modelling approach provides the mean to consider alternative hypotheses about how the ecosystem structure and function a\ufb00ects its dynamics. Alternative models were constructed to address the di\ufb00erent hypotheses regarding the behaviour of top predator (whether the top predators will be scared away by the OWF or attracted by the reef e\ufb00ect), impacts of global warming and changes in \ufb01sheries activities. Key \ufb01ndings from these analyses are that the OWF construction could lead to an increase in benthos species and \ufb01sh benthos feeders whatever the perturbation scenario, while the predicted response of top predators was ambiguous across all perturbation scenario. Qualitative modelling results can play a vital role in decision making by improving long term planning for the marine environment but also as a tool for communication with the public and so contribute to a better acceptability of the Marine Renewable Energy (MRE) project.","author":["Dambacher, J.","Raoux, A.","Pezy, J.","Niquil, N.","Maz\u00e9, C.","Dauvin, C."],"organization":["Normandie Universit\u00e9","Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO)"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Ecosystem Processes","Fish","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1882","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/conceptual-model-determine-vulnerability-wildlife-populations-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/hwi\/vol10\/iss1\/7\/","title":"A Conceptual Model to Determine Vulnerability of Wildlife Populations to Offshore Wind Energy Development","description":"As offshore wind energy development is planned in the United States, there is an increasing need for pre- and post-construction monitoring plans to be focused on species determined to be most vulnerable to hazards of a specific project. We propose a conceptual model that incorporates biological and sociological parameters. Specifically, we suggest that demographic, ethological\/biological, and population sensitivity be considered with legal protection, economic importance, and\/or stakeholder interest. We recommend that vulnerability determinations include qualitative and quantitative methods.","author":["Stenhouse, J.","Goodale, M."],"organization":["Biodiversity Research Institute"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Goodale-Stenhouse-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1883","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/trends-challenges-maritime-energy-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-319-74576-3","title":"Trends and Challenges in Maritime Energy Management","description":"This book provides an overview of contemporary trends and challenges in maritime energy management (MEM). Coordinated action is necessary to achieve a low carbon and energy-efficient maritime future, and MEM is the prevailing framework aimed at reducing greenhouse gas emissions resulting from maritime industry activities. The book familiarizes readers with the status quo in the field, and paves the way for finding solutions to perceived challenges. The 34 contributions cover six important aspects: regulatory framework; energy-efficient ship design; energy efficient ship and port operation; economic and social dimensions; alternative fuels and wind-assisted ship propulsion; and marine renewable energy. This pioneering work is intended for researchers and academics as well as practitioners and policymakers involved in this important field.","author":["\u00d6l\u00e7er, A.","Kitada, M.","Dalaklis, D.","Ballini, F."],"organization":["World Maritime University"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1884","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-different-tidal-renewable-energy-projects-hydrodynamic-processes-severn-estuary","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S146350030900208X","title":"Impact of different tidal renewable energy projects on the hydrodynamic processes in the Severn Estuary, UK","description":"The Severn\u00a0Estuary, located in the UK between south east Wales and south west England, is an ideal site for tidal renewable energy projects, since this estuary has the third highest\u00a0tidal range\u00a0in the world, with a spring tidal range approaching 14\u00a0m. The UK Government recently invited proposals for tidal renewable energy projects from the estuary and many proposals were submitted for consideration. Among the proposals submitted and subsequently shortlisted were: the Cardiff\u2013Weston Barrage, the Fleming\u00a0Lagoon\u00a0and the Shoots Barrage, all three of which are nationally public interest. Therefore a two-dimensional finite volume numerical model, based on an unstructured triangular mesh, has been refined to study the\u00a0hydrodynamic\u00a0impact and flood inundation extent, post construction, of all three of these proposed\u00a0tidal power\u00a0projects. The model-predicted hydrodynamic processes have been analysed in detail, both without and with the structures, including the discharge processes at key sections, the contours of maximum and minimum water levels, the envelope curves of high and low water levels, the maximum\u00a0tidal currents, the local\u00a0velocity fields\u00a0around the structures and the mean power output curves. Simulated results indicate that: (i) although the construction of the Cardiff\u2013Weston Barrage would have an adverse impact on a range of environmental aspects, due to there being approximately a 50% decrease in the\u00a0peak discharge\u00a0entering the upstream region, it would reduce the maximum water levels upstream of the barrage by typically 0.3\u20131.2\u00a0m, which could be positive in respect of\u00a0coastal flooding; (ii) the construction of the Fleming Lagoon would have little influence on the hydrodynamic processes in the Severn Estuary; and (iii) the construction of the Shoots Barrage would decrease the maximum water levels upstream of the M4 bridge by between 0.3 and 1.0\u00a0m, but it could lead to an increase in the maximum water levels downstream of the barrage by typically 20\u201330\u00a0cm.","author":["Falconer, R.","Lin, B.","Xia, J."],"organization":["Cardiff University","Tsinghua University"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.295916000000","-3.392950000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1885","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/framework-decision-points-trigger-adaptive-management-actions-long-term-incidental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pubs.er.usgs.gov\/publication\/ofr20151227","title":"A framework for decision points to trigger adaptive management actions in long-term incidental take permits","description":"The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) has begun to issue incidental take permits (ITPs) to wind power companies to allow limited take of bird and bat species that are protected under the Endangered Species Act, the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act, or the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (Huso and others, 2015). Expected take rates are determined using scientifically based collision-risk models and knowledge about the ecology of the population of interest. ITPs often include mitigation requirements to compensate for estimated take and further describe (1) adaptive management actions (AMAs) that may be required to reduce take rates if permitted rate is exceeded, or (2) additional compensatory mitigation to offset take that exceeds permitted levels.  Confirming the accuracy of predicted take and providing evidence that permitted take levels have not been exceeded can be challenging because carcasses may be detected with probability much less than 1, and often no carcasses are observed. When detection probability is high, finding 0 carcasses can be interpreted as evidence that none (or few) were actually killed. As the probability of observing an individual decreases, the likelihood of missing carcasses increases, making it unclear how to interpret having observed 0 (or few) carcasses. In a practical sense, the consequences of incorrect inference can be significant: overestimating take could result in costly and unjustified mitigation, whereas underestimating could result in unanticipated declines in species populations already at risk.","author":["Huso, M.","Dalthorp, D."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2015-12-02","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/DalthorpandHuso.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1886","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wind-energy-facilities-breeding-grassland-bird-distributions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pubs.er.usgs.gov\/publication\/70155896","title":"Effects of wind-energy facilities on breeding grassland bird distributions","description":"The contribution of renewable energy to meet worldwide demand continues to grow. Wind energy is one of the fastest growing renewable sectors, but new wind facilities are often placed in prime wildlife habitat. Long\u2010term studies that incorporate a rigorous statistical design to evaluate the effects of wind facilities on wildlife are rare. We conducted a before\u2010after\u2010control\u2010impact (BACI) assessment to determine if wind facilities placed in native mixed\u2010grass prairies displaced breeding grassland birds. During 2003\u20132012, we monitored changes in bird density in 3 study areas in North Dakota and South Dakota (U.S.A.). We examined whether displacement or attraction occurred 1 year after construction (immediate effect) and the average displacement or attraction 2\u20135 years after construction (delayed effect). We tested for these effects overall and within distance bands of 100, 200, 300, and \u0026gt;300 m from turbines. We observed displacement for 7 of 9 species. One species was unaffected by wind facilities and one species exhibited attraction. Displacement and attraction generally occurred within 100 m and often extended up to 300 m. In a few instances, displacement extended beyond 300 m. Displacement and attraction occurred 1 year after construction and persisted at least 5 years. Our research provides a framework for applying a BACI design to displacement studies and highlights the erroneous conclusions that can be made without the benefit of adopting such a design. More broadly, species\u2010specific behaviors can be used to inform management decisions about turbine placement and the potential impact to individual species. Additionally, the avoidance distance metrics we estimated can facilitate future development of models evaluating impacts of wind facilities under differing land\u2010use scenarios.","author":["Shaffer, J.","Buhl, D."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2016-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-12-04 08:26:47","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1887","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/renewable-energy-wildlife-conservation-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pubs.er.usgs.gov\/publication\/fs20163067","title":"Renewable Energy and Wildlife Conservation","description":"The renewable energy sector is rapidly expanding and diversifying the power supply of the country. Yet, as our Nation works to advance renewable energy and to conserve wildlife, some conflicts arise. To address these challenges, the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) is conducting innovative research and developing workable solutions to reduce impacts of renewable energy production on wildlife.","author":["Khalil, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Khalil_et_al_2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1888","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/us-geological-survey-energy-wildlife-research-annual-report-2016","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pubs.er.usgs.gov\/publication\/ofr20161147","title":"U.S. Geological Survey\u2014Energy and Wildlife Research Annual Report for 2016","description":"Recent growth and development of renewable energy and unconventional oil and gas extraction are rapidly diversifying the energy supply of the United States. Yet, as our Nation works to advance energy security and conserve wildlife, some conflicts have surfaced. To address these challenges, the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) is conducting innovative research and developing workable solutions to reduce the impacts of energy production on wildlife. USGS scientists collaborate on many studies with scientists from other Federal, State, and local government agencies; Tribal nations; academic research institutions; and nongovernmental and private organizations.  The mix of fuels used for electricity generation is evolving. Solar, natural gas, and wind energy made up most electricity generation additions in 2015 and 2016. The United States now leads the world in natural gas production, with new record highs for each year from 2011 through 2015. More than 48,000 wind turbines now contribute to power grids in most States, providing about 5 percent of U.S. end-use electricity demand in an average year. The number of utility-scale solar-energy projects is growing rapidly with solar energy projected to contribute to the largest electricity generation addition in 2016.  A substantial number of large energy projects have been constructed on undeveloped public lands, and more are anticipated at an increasing rate, creating new stress to wildlife. Direct impacts include collisions with wind turbines and structures at solar facilities and loss of habitat which may negatively affect sensitive species. Recent estimates suggest 250,000 to 500,000 birds die each year at wind turbine facilities. Bat fatality rates at wind turbine facilities are less certain, but may average several hundred thousand per year throughout North America. Because new projects may be located in or near sensitive wildlife habitats, ecological science plays a key role in helping to guide project siting and operational decisions.","author":["Khalil, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Khalil2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1889","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/international-experiences-opposition-wind-energy-siting-decisions-lessons","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/full\/10.1080\/09640568.2018.1473150","title":"International experiences with opposition to wind energy siting decisions: lessons for environmental and social appraisal","description":"The planning of renewable energy infrastructure has proven highly controversial across many countries. We critically examine the lessons that can be learned from research investigating the causes of controversy over wind turbines. The review focuses on a specific, but often highly controversial, component of planning practice: environmental and social appraisal. The review advances understandings of the reasons for contestation over the social impacts of wind turbines; the basis and legitimacy of plurality and contestation; and, the biases that tend to underpin understandings of the role and functioning of participation in appraisal. A typology of actors\u0027 attitudes to wind energy is employed to elucidate the implications of our review for appraisal practices. We conclude that a broader understanding of the societal purposes of public participation needs to be integrated into appraisal theory and practice, including an acceptance of the legitimacy of antagonism and dissent and its value in fostering social learning.","author":["Larsen, S.","Cashmore, M.","Rudolph, D.","Nielsen, H."],"organization":["Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences","Technical University of Denmark (DTU)","Aalborg University"],"originationDate":"2019-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1890","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hornsea-project-three-offshore-wind-farm-environmental-statement","sourceURL":"https:\/\/hornseaproject3.co.uk\/en\/Application-documents","title":"Hornsea Project Three Offshore Wind Farm Environmental Statement","description":"Orsted Hornsea Project Three (UK) Ltd., on behalf of Orsted Power (UK) Ltd., is promoting the development of the Hornsea Project Three Offshore Wind Farm (hereafter referred to as Hornsea Three). Hornsea Three is a proposed offshore wind farm located in the southern North Sea.The Hornsea Three array area (i.e. the area in which the turbines are located) is approximately 696 km2, and is located approximately 121 km northeast off the Norfolk coast and 160 km east of the Yorkshire coast (Figure 1.1). The Hornsea Three array area lies to the east of Hornsea Project One and Hornsea Project Two offshore wind farms, and is located within the former Hornsea Zone (as shown on Figure 1.1). Hornsea Three is a project that will consist of an offshore generating station(s) with a capacity of greater than 100 MW and therefore is a Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project (NSIP), as defined by Section 15(3) of the Planning Act 2008. As such, there is a requirement to submit an application for Development Consent to the Planning Inspectorate (PINS) to be decided by the Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy.The Hornsea Three application for Development Consent has been submitted to PINS with the prescribed forms and documents as required by the Infrastructure Planning (Applications: Prescribed Forms and Procedure) Regulations 2009.The purpose of the Environmental Statement is to provide the environmental information which has been gathered in order to carry out an assessment of the likely significant environmental effects of Hornsea Three. The Environmental Statement specifically: Provides statutory and non-statutory consultees with technical information to enable an understanding of Hornsea Three;Presents the existing environmental baseline information, established from desktop studies, offshore and onshore surveys and consultation;Describes the methodology used within the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process;Presents the potential environmental impacts arising from Hornsea Three, based upon the baseline information and data gathered, and the analysis and impact assessments completed;Indicates any limitations encountered during the compilation of the environmental information, including the acknowledgement of any data gaps or deficiencies and confidence in the information gathered;Puts forward potential mitigation measures that could prevent, minimise, reduce or offset potential adverse environmental impacts identified during the EIA process. Where additional mitigation measures have been identified, the residual significance of effect has also been identified; andProvides an outline of the main project alternativesPlease see relevant documents below:6 Non-Technical SummaryVolume 16.1.1 Volume 1 Ch 1 Introduction and Overarching Glossary6.1.2.Volume 1 Ch 2 Policy and Legislation6.1.3 Volume 1 Ch 3 Project Description6.1.4 Volume 1 Ch 4 Site Selection and Consideration of Alternatives6.1.5 Volume 1 Ch 5 Environmental Impact Assessment MethodologyVolume 26.2.1 Volume 2 Ch 1 Marine Processes6.2.2 Volume 2 Ch 2 Benthic Ecology6.2.3 Volume 2 Ch 3 Fish and Shellfish Ecology6.2.4 Volume 2 Ch 4 Marine Mammals6.2.5 Volume 2 Ch 5 Offshore Ornithology6.2.6 Volume 2 Ch 6 Commercial Fisheries6.2.7 Volume 2 Ch 7 Shipping and Navigation6.2.8 Volume 2 Ch 8 Aviation Military and Communication6.2.9 Volume 2 Ch 9 Marine ArchaeologyVolume 36.3.1 Volume 3 Ch 1 Geology and Ground Conditions6.3.2 Volume 3 Ch 2 Hydrology and Flood Risk6.3.3 Volume 3 Ch 3 Ecology and Nature Conservation6.3.4 Volume 3 Ch 4 Landscape and Visual Resources6.3.6 Volume 3 Ch 6 Land Use and Recreation6.3.7 Volume 3 Ch 7 Traffic and Transport6.3.8 Volume 3 Ch 8 Noise and Vibration6.3.9 Volume 3 Ch 9 Air Quality6.3.10 Volume 3 Ch 10 Socioeconomics6.3.11 Volume 3 Ch 11 Interrelated Effects OnshoreVolume 46.4.1.1 Volume 4 - 1.1 Hornsea Project One and Hornsea Project Two Consultation of Relevance to Horn6.4.3.1 Volume 4 - 3.1 Subsea Noise Technical Report6.4.3.2 Volume 4 - 3.2 Dredging and Disposal Site Characterisation6.4.3.3 Volume 4 - 3.3 EMF Compliance Statement6.4.3.4 Volume 4 - 3.4 Site Waste Management Plan6.4.3.5 Volume 4 - 3.5 Onshore Crossing Schedule6.4.3.6 Volume 4 - 3.6 Offshore Operation and Maintenance Licensable Activities6.4.3.7 Volume 4 - 3.7 Layout Development Principles6.4.4.1 Volume 4 - 4.1 Grid Connection and Refinement of the Cable Landfall6.4.4.2 Volume 4 - 4.2 Selection and Refinement of the Offshore ECR and HVAC Booster Station6.4.4.3 Volume 4 - 4.3 Refinement of the Onshore Cable Corridor and Associated Infrastructure Stages6.4.4.4 Volume 4 - 4.4 Post PEIR Changes Stages 896.4.5.1 Volume 4 -5.1 Enhancement Mitigation and Monitoring Commitments6.4.5.2 Volume 4 - 5.2 Cumulative Effects Screening Matrix6.4.5.3 Volume 4- 5.3 Location of Cumulative Schemes6.4.5.4 Volume 4 - 5.4 Transboundary Impacts Screening6.4.5.5 Volume 4 - 5.5 Scoping Report and Secretary of States Scoping OpinionVolume 56.5.1.1 Volume 5 - 1.1 Marine Processes Technical Report6.5.2.1 Volume 5 - 2.1 Benthic Ecology Technical Report6.5.2.2 Volume 5 - 2.2 Water Framework Directive Assessment6.5.2.3 Volume 5 - 2.3 Marine Conservation Zone Assessment6.5.3.1 Volume 5 - 3.1 Fish and Shellfish Ecology Technical Report6.5.4.1 Volume 5 - 4.1 Marine Mammal Technical Report6.5.5.1 Volume 5 - 5.1 Baseline Characterisation Report6.5.5.2 Volume 5 - 5.2 Analysis of Displacement Impacts on Seabirds6.5.5.3 Volume 5 - 5.3 Collision Risk Modelling6.5.5.4 Volume 5 - 5.4 Data Hierarchy Report6.5.6.1 Volume 5 - 6.1 Commercial Fisheries Technical Report6.5.7.1 Volume 5 - 7.1 Navigational Risk Assessment6.5.8.1 Volume 5 - 8.1 Aviation Military and Communication Technical Report6.5.9.1 Volume 5 - 9.1 Marine Archaeology Technical Report6.5.9.2 Volume 5 - 9.2 Outline Written Scheme of Investigation6.5.10.1 Volume 5 - 10.1 Seascape and Visual Resources Technical Report6.5.10.2 Volume 5 - 10.2 Seascape and Visual Resources Wirelines6.5.10.3 Volume 5 - 10.3 Seascape and Visual Resources Cumulative Wirelines6.5.11.1 Volume 5 - 11.1 Radar Early Warning Technical ReportVolume 66.6.1.1 Volume 6 - 1.1 Borehole Logs6.6.1.2 Volume 6 - 1.2 Abstraction Licences and Source Protection Zones6.6.1.3 Volume 6 - 1.3 Discharge Consents and Permits6.6.1.4 Volume 6 - 1.4 Water Framework Directive Groundwater Assessment6.6.2.1 Volume 6 - 2.1 Onshore Infrastructure Flood Risk Assessments6.6.2.2 Volume 6 - 2.2 Environment Agency and Internal Drainage Board Watercourses and Flood Zones6.6.2.3 Volume 6 - 2.3 Surface Water Abstraction Licences Discharge Consents and Pollution Incidents6.6.2.4 Volume 6 - 2.4 Hydrological Characterisation Study6.6.2.5 Volume 6 - 2.5 Water Framework Directive Surface Water Assessment6.6.3.1 Volume 6 - 3.1 Desk Study and Phase 1 Habitat Survey6.6.3.2 Volume 6 - 3.2 Hedgerow Survey6.6.3.3 Volume 6 - 3.3 Desmoulins Whorl Snail Survey6.6.3.4.Volume 6 - 3.4 WhiteClawed Crayfish Survey6.6.3.5 Volume 6 - 3.5 Great Crested Newt Survey6.6.3.6 Volume 6 - 3.6 Reptile Survey6.6.3.7 Volume 6 - 3.7 Water Vole Survey6.6.3.8 Volume 6 - 3.8 Bat Surveys6.6.3.9 Volume 6 - 3.9 Onshore Ornithology Wintering and Migratory Birds6.6.3.10 Volume 6 - 3.10 Onshore Ornithology Breeding Birds6.6.3.11 Volume 6 - 3.11 Otter Survey nonconfidential6.6.3.12 Volume 6 - 3.12 Badger Survey nonconfidential6.6.3.13 Volume 6 - 3.13 Hazel Dormouse Red Squirrel and Freshwater Pearl Mussel Desk Study6.6.4.1 Volume 6 - 4.1 Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment Methodology6.6.4.2 Volume 6 - 4.2 Extracts from National Landscape Character Area Descriptions6.6.4.3 Volume 6 - 4.3 Extracts from Local Landscape Character Area Descriptions6.6.4.4 Volume 6 - 4.4 Qualities of Natural Beauty of the Norfolk Coast AONB6.6.4.5 Volume 6 - 4.5 Photograph Panels Wirelines and Photomontages6.6.4.6 Volume 6 - 4.6 Residential Visual Amenity6.6.4.7 Volume 6 - 4.7 Effects of the Offshore HVAC Booster Station6.6.5.1 Volume 6 - 5.1 Desk Based Assessment6.6.5.2 Volume 6 - 5.2 Fieldwalking Report6.6.5.3 Volume 6 - 5.3 Site Gazetteer6.6.5.4 Volume 6 - 5.4 Screening Assessment Onshore HVDC ConverterHVAC Substation6.6.5.5 Volume 6 - 5.5 Screening Assessment Onshore HVAC Booster Station6.6.5.6 Volume 6 - 5.6 Onshore Geophysical Survey Report6.6.5.7 Volume 6 - 5.7 Historic Environment Visualisations6.6.6.1.Volume 6 - 6.1 Agricultural Land Classification Published Data6.6.6.2 Volume 6 - 6.2 Soil Survey Data6.6.6.3 Volume 6 - 6.3 Agricultural Land Classification and Farm Holdings Figures6.6.7.1 Volume 6 - 7.1 Transport Assessment6.6.7.2 Volume 6 - 7.2 Description of Network Links and Sensitivity6.6.7.3 Volume 6 - 7.3 Base Traffic Flows6.6.7.4 Volume 6 - 7.4 Personnel Injury Accident Locations6.6.7.5 Volume 6 - 7.5 Public Transport Networks6.6.7.6 Volume 6 - 7.6 Construction Vehicle Trip Generation Assumptions6.6.7.7 Volume 6 - 7.7 Traffic Flows with Construction Traffic6.6.7.8 Volume 6 - 7.8 Traffic and Transport Figures6.6.8.1 Volume 6 - 8.1 Baseline Noise Survey6.6.8.2 Volume 6 - 8.2 Construction Noise Model Output6.6.8.3 Volume 6 - 8.3 Operational Noise Model Input6.6.8.4 Volume 6 - 8.4 Operational Noise Model OutputVolume 76.7 Volume 7 Addendum Land at Booton","author":["RPS group"],"organization":["\u00d8rsted"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.873000000000","2.537000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-03-27 07:05:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/H3_Environmental_Statement_Non-Technical_Summary_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.7 Volume 7 Addendum Land at Booton.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.1.1_Volume_1_Ch 1_Introduction_and_Overarching_Glossary.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.1.2.Volume_1_Ch_2_Policy_and_Legislation.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.1.3_Volume_1_Ch_3_Project_Description.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.1.4_Volume_1_Ch_4_Site_Selection_and_Consideration_of_Alternatives.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.1.5_Volume_1_Ch_5_Environmental_Impact_Assessment_Methodology.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.1_Volume_2_Ch_1_Marine_Processes.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.2_Volume_2_Ch_2_Benthic_Ecology.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.3_Volume_2_Ch_3_Fish_and_Shellfish_Ecology.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.4_Volume_2_Ch_4_Marine_Mammals.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.5_Volume_2_Ch_5_Offshore_Ornithology.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.6_Volume_2_Ch_6_Commercial_Fisheries.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.7_Volume_2_Ch_7_Shipping_and_Navigation.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.8_Volume_2_Ch_8_Aviation_Military_and_Communication.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.9_Volume_2_Ch_9_Marine_Archaeology.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.2.5_Volume_2_Ch_5_Offshore_Ornithology_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.1_Volume_3_Ch_1_Geology_and_Ground_Conditions.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.2_Volume_3_Ch_2_Hydrology_and_Flood_Risk.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.3_Volume_3_Ch_3_Ecology_and_Nature_Conservation.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.4_Volume_3_Ch_4_Landscape_and_Visual_Resources.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.6_Volume_3_Ch_6_Land_Use_and_Recreation.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.7_Volume_3_Ch_7_Traffic_and_Transport.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.8_Volume_3_Ch_8_Noise_and_Vibration.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.9_Volume_3_Ch_9_Air_Quality.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.10_Volume_3_Ch_10_Socioeconomics.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.3.11_Volume_3_Ch_11_Interrelated_Effects_Onshore.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.1.1_Volume_4-1.1_Hornsea_Project_One_and_Hornsea_Project_Two_Consultation_of_Relevance_to_Horn.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.3.1_Volume_4-3.1_Subsea_Noise_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.3.2_Volume_4-3.2_Dredging_and_Disposal_Site_Characterisation.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.3.3_Volume_4-3.3_EMF_Compliance_Statement.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.3.4_Volume_4-3.4_Site_Waste_Management_Plan.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.3.5_Volume_4-3.5_Onshore_Crossing_Schedule.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.3.6_Volume_4-3.6_Offshore_Operation_and_Maintenance_Licensable_Activities.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.3.7_Volume_4-3.7_Layout_Development_Principles.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.4.1_Volume_4-4.1_Grid_Connection_and_Refinement_of_the_Cable_Landfall.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.4.2_Volume_4-4.2_Selection_and_Refinement_of_the_Offshore_ECR_and_HVAC_Booster_Station.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.4.3_Volume_4-4.3_Refinement_of_the_Onshore_Cable_Corridor_and_Associated_Infrastructure_Stages.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.4.4_Volume_4-4.4_Post_PEIR_Changes_Stages_89.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.5.1_Volume_4-5.1_Enhancement_Mitigation_and_Monitoring_Commitments.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.5.2_Volume_4-5.2_Cumulative_Effects_Screening_Matrix.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.5.3_Volume_4-5.3_Location_of_Cumulative_Schemes.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.5.4_Volume_4-5.4_Transboundary_Impacts_Screening.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.4.5.5_Volume_4-5.5_Scoping_Report_and_Secretary_of_States_Scoping_Opinion.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.1.1_Volume_5-1.1_Marine_Processes_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.2.1_Volume_5-2.1_Benthic_Ecology_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.2.2_Volume_5-2.2_Water_Framework_Directive_Assessment.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.2.3_Volume_5-2.3_Marine_Conservation_Zone_Assessment.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.3.1_Volume_5-3.1_Fish_and_Shellfish_Ecology_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.4.1_Volume_5-4.1_Marine_Mammal_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.5.1_Volume_5-5.1_Baseline_Characterisation_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.5.2_Volume_5-5.2_Analysis_of_Displacement_Impacts_on_Seabirds.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.5.3_Volume_5-5.3_Collision_Risk_Modelling.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.5.4_Volume_5-5.4_Data_Hierarchy_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.6.1_Volume_5-6.1_Commercial_Fisheries_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.7.1_Volume_5-7.1_Navigational_Risk_Assessment.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.8.1_Volume_5-8.1_Aviation_Military_and_Communication_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.9.1_Volume_5-9.1_Marine_Archaeology_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.9.2_Volume_5-9.2_Outline_Written_Scheme_of_Investigation.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.10.1_Volume_5-10.1_Seascape_and_Visual_Resources_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.10.2_Volume_5-10.2_Seascape_and_Visual_Resources_Wirelines.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.10.3_Volume_5-10.3_Seascape_and_Visual_Resources_Cumulative_Wirelines.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.5.11.1_Volume_5-11.1_Radar_Early_Warning_Technical_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.1.1_Volume_6-1.1_Borehole_Logs.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.1.2_Volume_6-1.2_Abstraction_Licences_and_Source_Protection_Zones.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.1.3_Volume_6-1.3_Discharge_Consents_and_Permits.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.1.4_Volume_6-1.4_Water_Framework_Directive_Groundwater_Assessment.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.2.1_Volume_6-2.1_Onshore_Infrastructure_Flood_Risk_Assessments.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.2.2_Volume_6-2.2Environment_Agency_and_Internal_Drainage_Board_Watercourses_and_Flood_Zones.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.2.3_Volume_6-2.3_Surface_Water_Abstraction_Licences_Discharge_Consents_and_Pollution_Incidents.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.2.4_Volume_6-2.4_Hydrological_Characterisation_Study.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.2.5_Volume_6-2.5_Water_Framework_Directive_Surface_Water_Assessment.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.1_Volume_6-3.1_Desk_Study_and_Phase_1_Habitat_Survey.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.2_Volume_6-3.2_Hedgerow_Survey.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.3_Volume_6-3.3_Desmoulins_Whorl_Snail_Survey.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.4.Volume_6-3.4_WhiteClawed_Crayfish_Survey.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.5_Volume_6-3.5_Great_Crested_Newt_Survey.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.6_Volume_6-3.6_Reptile_Survey.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.7_Volume_6-3.7_Water_Vole_Survey.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.8_Volume_6-3.8_Bat_Surveys.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.9_Volume_6-3.9_Onshore_Ornithology_Wintering_and_Migratory_Birds.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.10_Volume_6-3.10_Onshore_Ornithology_Breeding_Birds.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.11_Volume_6-3.11_Otter_Survey_nonconfidential.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.12_Volume_6-3.12_Badger_Survey_nonconfidential.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.3.13_Volume_6-3.13_Hazel_Dormouse_Red_Squirrel_and_Freshwater_Pearl_Mussel_Desk_Study.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.4.1_Volume_6-4.1_Landscape_and_Visual_Impact_Assessment_Methodology.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.4.2_Volume_6-4.2_Extracts_from_National_Landscape_Character_Area_Descriptions.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.4.3_Volume_6-4.3_Extracts_from_Local_Landscape_Character_Area_Descriptions.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.4.4_Volume_6-4.4_Qualities_of_Natural_Beauty_of_the_Norfolk_Coast_AONB.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.4.5_Volume_6-4.5_Photograph_Panels_Wirelines_and_Photomontages.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.4.6_Volume_6-4.6_Residential_Visual_Amenity.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.4.7_Volume_6-4.7_Effects_of_the_Offshore_HVAC_Booster_Station.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.5.1_Volume_6-5.1_Desk_Based_Assessment.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.5.2_Volume_6-5.2_Fieldwalking_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.5.3_Volume_6-5.3_Site_Gazetteer.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.5.4_Volume_6-5.4_Screening_Assessment_Onshore_HVDC_ConverterHVAC_Substation.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.5.5_Volume_6-5.5_Screening_Assessment_Onshore_HVAC_Booster_Station.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.5.6_Volume_6-5.6_Onshore_Geophysical_Survey_Report.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.5.7_Volume_6-5.7_Historic_Environment_Visualisations.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.6.1.Volume_6-6.1_Agricultural_Land_Classification_Published_Data.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.6.2_Volume_6-6.2_Soil_Survey_Data.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.6.3_Volume_6-6.3_Agricultural_Land_Classification_and_Farm_Holdings_Figures_1.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.7.1_Volume_6-7.1_Transport_Assessment_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.7.2_Volume_6-7.2_Description_of_Network_Links_and_Sensitivity_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.7.3_Volume_6-7.3_Base_Traffic_Flows_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.7.4_Volume_6-7.4_Personnel_Injury_Accident_Locations_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.7.5_Volume_6-7.5_Public_Transport_Networks_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.7.6_Volume_6-7.6_Construction_Vehicle_Trip_Generation_Assumptions_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.7.7_Volume_6-7.7_Traffic_Flows_with_Construction_Traffic_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.7.8_Volume_6-7.8_Traffic_and_Transport_Figures_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.8.1_Volume_6-8.1_Baseline_Noise_Survey_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.8.2_Volume_6-8.2_Construction_Noise_Model_Output_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.8.3_Volume_6-8.3_Operational_Noise_Model_Input_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.6.8.4_Volume_6-8.4_Operational_Noise_Model_Output_0.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/6.7_Volume_7_Addendum_Land_at_Booton_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1891","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/kentish-flats-offshore-wind-farm-extension-environmental-scoping-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/south-east\/kentish-flats-extension","title":"Kentish Flats Offshore Wind Farm Extension Environmental Scoping Study","description":"The information in this study has been provided to support Vattenfall\u2019s formal request for a scoping opinion in relation to the potential impacts of the Kentish Flats Extension and the scope of the forthcoming EIA.  Vattenfall believe that knowledge of the impacts associated with the construction, operation and decommissioning of offshore wind farms has progressed throughout both Round 1 and Round 2. As described in Sections 1.4 and 1.7, it is to be expected that for a number of parameters the Kentish Flats Extension EIA process need not be as onerous as it was for early projects. Furthermore, due to the exhaustive and extensive amount of data already collected for the existing Kentish Flats project, a number of potential impacts do not need to be considered in the amount of detail that would normally be expected of a new development site,. As such, it is Vattenfall\u2019s belief that the use of relevant existing data will enable effective comparisons to be made with the Kentish Flats ES and firm conclusions to drawn based upon observed impacts.  The identification of impacts throughout this report has been undertaken based upon the extensive data sets which exist for Kentish Flats, in a manner not possible on previously undeveloped sites. The small size of the Kentish Flats Extension will result in any identified impacts being limited in scale and magnitude and therefore in a large number of cases (particularly where supported by evidence from monitoring data), the predictions and conclusions made in the original ES will still remain valid.  The Kentish Flats Extension benefits from the fact that a much larger project has already been constructed at the site and which has been subject to an extensive program of environmental monitoring. This allows a much greater degree of confidence in the predictions of effects and the success of recommended mitigation given that the baseline environment and the response to the existing wind farm is well documented and understood.  Vattenfall has already undertaken discussions with statutory consultees regarding the development of the Kentish Flats Extension, especially with regards to the key issues and how these should be addressed. Of particular importance to the Kentish Flats Extension EIA, these discussions have enabled Vattenfall to understand where gaps exist in the extensive data sets already collected for Kentish Flats and to develop an approach to both this scoping report and the EIA which will streamline the process.  This scoping report has identified the key issues associated with the construction, operation and decommissioning of the Kentish Flats Extension, with no impacts identified which have the potential to limit the scale of, or prevent the development of the Kentish Flats Extension. Vattenfall believes, therefore, that the Kentish Flats Extension project is viable, deliverable and of a scale appropriate for the location and existing project.","author":["Royal Haskoning"],"organization":["Vattenfall","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2010-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.460000000000","1.094000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Haskoning2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1892","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/rampion-offshore-wind-farm-scoping-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/south-east\/rampion-offshore-wind-farm\/","title":"Rampion Offshore Wind Farm - Scoping Report","description":"E.ON Climate and Renewables UK Rampion Offshore Wind Limited (EC\u0026amp;R) is proposing the development of the Rampion Offshore Wind Farm, located off the Sussex coast. As a nationally significant infrastructure project (NSIP) and, owing to the size and nature of the project, an environmental impact assessment (EIA) will be produced in accordance with the Infrastructure Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2009. EC\u0026amp;R has commissioned RSK Environment (RSK) as \u2018lead EIA consultants\u2019.  This document is a scoping report prepared to support a request for a scoping opinion from the Infrastructure Planning Commission (the Commission). This process will also provide feedback on any additional information given in the Environmental Statement (ES) in support of an application for a Development Consent Order (DCO) to be submitted in due course to the Commission for the Rampion Offshore Wind Farm.","author":["RSK Group"],"organization":["E.ON","E.ON"],"originationDate":"2010-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.668000000000","-0.276000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/RSK_2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1893","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/triton-knoll-environmental-impact-assessment-scoping-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/east-midlands\/triton-knoll-offshore-wind-farm","title":"Triton Knoll Environmental Impact Assessment Scoping Report","description":"Triton Knoll Offshore Wind Farm Ltd (TKOWFL) is proposing to develop an offshore wind farm in the Greater Wash Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) region. The proposed project, known as Triton Knoll Offshore Wind Farm (OWF), would be located approximately 33 km off the Lincolnshire coast, 46 km off the North Norfolk coast and 48km off the nearest point on the East Riding of Yorkshire coastline. The project could comprise between 150 and 333 wind turbines and would have a total generating capacity of up to 1200 megawatts (MW).\n\nThe initial Triton Knoll project area was selected as a suitable development site due to a number of key attributes, including an excellent wind resource, and a reasonably flat seabed in relatively shallow waters. Following the initial award of the site by The Crown Estate, TKOWFL carried out a more detailed review of the constraints (biological, physical and human) acting on the site. Following this review TKOWFL identified that the original Triton Knoll site was likely to have potential significant impacts on commercial shipping routes, helicopter access buffers to oil and gas platforms to the north of the site and a helicopter main route which traverses north of the site.\n\nRe-evaluation of the site using experiences from development of the Gwynt y M\u00f4r OWF, off the North Wales coast, concluded that the impacts of the constraints identified above could be addressed, and that the Triton Knoll site in an amended form did offer a substantial development opportunity. The boundaries of the Triton Knoll area, as now proposed, have been developed principally to mitigate the potential impacts of the site on shipping and navigation.\n\nThe purpose of this Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) scoping report is to build on consultation carried out to date on the Triton Knoll OWF project and to seek opinion from a wide range of statutory and non-statutory consultees and stakeholders on the scope of the EIA required for the Triton Knoll project. This report is an updated version of a previous scoping report issued in January 2009. Since this date, the Infrastructure Planning Commission (IPC) has come into force and will be the body that assesses the eventual formal consent application by TKOWFL. In light of this change, the IPC advised TKOWFL that a new scoping report should be issued so they could provide their own formal scoping opinion, separate to that provided previously by the Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC).\n\nThe Triton Knoll OWF will have associated onshore and offshore electrical infrastructure to enable the electricity generated by the wind turbines to be transformed to a suitable voltage and connected to the national grid strategic electricity transmission system. National Grid has identified the East Lindsey District coast of Lincolnshire as the appropriate location for a new strategic electricity connection to serve Triton Knoll and future Round 3 connections, although a specific compound location and incoming routing has not yet been identified by them. This scoping report presents the current knowledge of this aspect of the project and best available information from third parties. The scoping report also presents details on the baseline environment around the Triton Knoll development area and identifies potential impacts that may arise as a result of this development.\n\nPotential surveys\/studies to inform the EIA process are listed, along with discussion about possible mitigation and monitoring measures that may be implemented to reduce the significance of any impacts.","author":["Wilson, M.","Ireland, P."],"organization":["RWE Innogy","RWE Innogy"],"originationDate":"2010-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.478000000000","0.839000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1894","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implications-european-sites-proposed-triton-knoll-electrical-system","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/east-midlands\/triton-knoll-electrical-system\/","title":"Report on the Implications for European Sites Proposed Triton Knoll Electrical System","description":"Triton Knoll Offshore Wind Farm Ltd (the applicant) has applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) for the proposed Triton Knoll Electrical System (the proposed development). The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State as to the decision to be made on the application.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive and the Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations for applications submitted under the Planning Act 2008 regime (as amended). The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the ExA will assist the Secretary of State in performing their duties under the Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations.  This Report on the Implications for European Sites (RIES) compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the DCO application, and the information submitted throughout the examination by both the applicant and interested parties, up to 10 February 2016 in relation to potential effects on European sites. It is not a standalone document and should be read in conjunction with the examination documents referred to in this report.  It is issued to ensure that interested parties including Natural England (NE) as the statutory nature conservation body are consulted formally on Habitats Regulations matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the Habitats Regulations and Regulation 25 of the Offshore Marine Regulations. Following consultation the responses will be considered by the ExA in making its recommendation to the Secretary of State and made available to the Secretary of State along with this report. The RIES is not revised following consultation.  The applicant has not identified any potential impacts on European sites in other European Economic Area States. Only UK European sites are addressed in this report.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":["RWE Innogy","RWE Innogy"],"originationDate":"2016-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.478000000000","0.839000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_Triton_Knoll_Electrical_System_2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1895","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/thanet-extension-offshore-wind-farm-environmental-impact-assessment-report-inform","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/south-east\/thanet-extension-offshore-wind-farm\/","title":"Thanet Extension Offshore Wind Farm Environmental Impact Assessment Report to Inform Scoping","description":"This document supports a request for an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Scoping Opinion from the Planning Inspectorate (PINS) for the Thanet Extension Offshore Wind Farm (Thanet Extension). Thanet Extension is a Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project (NSIP) and as such an EIA is required as part of a Development Consent Order (DCO) application under the Planning Act 2008.  Thanet Extension is being developed by Vattenfall Wind Power Ltd (Vattenfall) a company which has invested nearly \u00a33bn in the UK, in onshore and offshore wind since 2008 and is expected to have nearly 1GW in operation onshore and offshore by 2017. Vattenfall plans to invest \u00a35bn in renewables, mainly offshore wind, in Northern Europe by 2020. Vattenfall has world leading experience in offshore wind, as owner of Kentish Flats, Kentish Flats Extension, Ormonde, and Thanet Offshore Wind Farms, which are currently operational in the UK, as well as a growing portfolio of wind projects across its European markets.  The key drivers for renewable energy, and therefore the Thanet Extension project are reducing greenhouse gas emissions, providing energy security, and maximising economic opportunities from investment for the UK. In addition, extension projects are considered to represent a significant opportunity for cost reduction in offshore wind, an increasingly important consideration under the highly competitive UK subsidy regime and drive to deliver the best possible value to the consumer. The proposed project would have a generation capacity of up to 340MW and produce enough energy to power over 229,000 homes in the UK.  The Thanet Extension would be located off the south east coast of Kent in the South East of England approximately 8km offshore (at the closest point), in proximity to the operational Thanet Offshore Wind Farm (TOWF). Electricity generated would be transported to the shore by offshore export cables installed within the proposed Thanet Extension Offshore Export Cable Corridor.  The project would also require onshore infrastructure in order to connect the offshore wind farm to the electricity network, which in summary will comprise:    Landfall and transition pit;  Underground export cables; and  Onshore substation;   At the time of writing, Vattenfall are in negotiation with National Grid regarding an agreement for connection to the electricity transmission network at the site of the former Richborough Power Station. A grid connection agreement is expected to be in place in 2017, prior to submission of the application for DCO. The exact location of the landfall and onshore infrastructure are yet to be determined, though a Thanet Extension Onshore Area of Interest (encompassing areas being considered for siting of the onshore substation, plus landfall and Onshore Cable Route Options) has been defined for consultation purposes and is referred to throughout this document.  Site selection within the Onshore Area of Interest is ongoing and responses to the Scoping Request and associated public consultation will help to inform the development of the Thanet Extension project.  The EIA will be completed by technical specialists using best practice and following appropriate guidance. Early feasibility work and consultation with major stakeholders has determined that key aspects of the EIA are likely to be seascape, landscape and visual, shipping and navigation, ornithology, commercial fisheries, and marine and coastal designated sites. This Report to Inform Scoping outlines all of the receptors that will be considered during the EIA and the planned approach to characterising the existing environment, assessing potential impacts associated with Thanet Extension and developing mitigation measures.  Consultation is already underway and will be ongoing with stakeholders throughout the EIA and DCO application process. Vattenfall is committed to engaging with the community and other stakeholders, and working alongside them to deliver a project of the best possible quality.  Section 4.2 of this Scoping Report provides an outline of the undertaken and planned consultation associated with the project.","author":["Royal Haskoning"],"organization":["Vattenfall","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2016-12-13","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.430000000000","1.628000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-07-28 09:01:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Haskoning2010_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1896","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behaviour-related-flight-speeds-sandwich-terns-their-implications-wind-farm-collision","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S019592551730389X","title":"Behaviour related flight speeds of Sandwich Terns and their implications for wind farm collision rate modelling and impact assessment","description":"Accurate quantification of flight speeds is a prerequisite to accurately predict the numbers of collision victims of proposed wind farms using collision rate models that are a vital part of Environmental Impact Assessments. We used GPS-loggers on Sandwich Terns to collect novel data on instantaneous flight speeds during foraging trips, separated for different behavioural stages, and applied these estimates in a widely used collision rate model. Average flight speed during a foraging trip corrected for individual variation and flight type was 36.9\u202f\u00b1\u202f12.3\u202fSD\u202fkm\u202fh\u22121 and flight speed was highest during inbound commuting (44.4\u202f\u00b1\u202f12.0\u202fkm\u202fh\u22121) and lowest during foraging (29.9\u202f\u00b1\u202f10.7\u202fkm\u202fh\u22121). Our results show significant differences in flight speeds of Sandwich Terns between behaviour stages during foraging trips, which resulted in divergent estimates of collision victims due to wind turbines depending on the function of the area in which wind farms are proposed. Since these conclusions are likely to hold for many other bird species, we conclude that behaviour of birds in a proposed wind farm is a factor to take into account when modelling collision rates as part of the Environmental Impact Assessment.","author":["Fijn, R.","Gyimesi, A."],"organization":["Bureau Waardenburg bv"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1897","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measuring-sound-detection-spaces-acoustic-animal-sampling-monitoring","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320716302452","title":"Measuring sound detection spaces for acoustic animal sampling and monitoring","description":"Sound recordings obtained from passive acoustic monitoring systems are increasingly used to sample animal biodiversity. However, sound recorders sample variable detection spaces, so that data may not be comparable between sampling sites and recording setups.\n\nFocusing on terrestrial systems, we measured understory vegetation, tree structure, sound transmission, ambient sound pressure level, and derived sound detection spaces of 38 plots in lowland rainforest, jungle rubber, and oil palm and rubber plantations, using different combinations of sound frequency (0.05 to 40\u00a0kHz) and source height (0 to 5\u00a0m).\n\nWe show that simple vegetation structure measures poorly predict sound transmission, so that direct sound transmission measurements are indispensable. We depict highly variable sound detection spaces in different land-use types. Finally we estimated species richness of exemplary animal groups and found considerable differences between land-use types on the basis of variable detection space areas alone.\n\nSound detection spaces respond non-linearly to sound frequency and source height, and they need to be quantified in acoustic surveys to avoid substantial bias in biodiversity estimates between sampling sites. Detection spaces also determine species detection probabilities and allow comparing data between recording setups. We provide guidelines and computer scripts for measuring sound transmission and ambient sound level using consumer audio equipment, and for computing detection spaces. Appreciating the effective sampling area of acoustic recorders closes a gap between acoustic and traditional animal survey methods. Species richness estimates can now be reported for measured sampling areas, and animal population variables such as abundance, density, and activity can be compared at equal areas.","author":["Darras, K.","P\u00fctz, P.","Fahrurrozi","Rembold, K.","Tscharntke, T."],"organization":["Georg-August University of G\u00f6ttingen","University of Jambi"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1898","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/data-integration-conservation-leveraging-multiple-data-types-advance-ecological","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954114000041","title":"Data integration for conservation: Leveraging multiple data types to advance ecological assessments and habitat modeling for marine megavertebrates using OBIS\u2013SEAMAP","description":"Spatially explicit conservation efforts to identify, designate, and prioritize protected areas or biologically significant areas require analyses beyond basic species distribution and abundance studies, including assessments of migration patterns, habitat use, and ecological drivers of behavior. With the advent of alternate survey methods and platforms within the marine environment (e.g. satellite telemetry, passive acoustics, photo identification, nesting site monitoring and genetic sampling) in addition to traditional shipboard or aerial visual surveys, researchers have been developing novel analytical and modeling methodologies to fulfill such in-depth ecological assessments. This trend has raised interests and needs not only in filling spatial, temporal and \u2018ecological\u2019 gaps but also in the synthesis of these disparate data from multiple methods\/platforms. OBIS\u2013SEAMAP, a thematic node of the Ocean Biogeographic Information System (OBIS) specializing on marine megavertebrates, takes a unique approach to data integration into the OBIS\u2013SEAMAP database to enable novel applications of a global biogeographic database. In this paper, we summarize our efforts to accomplish this integration and to develop novel mapping and visualization tools available on the OBIS\u2013SEAMAP web site. We also discuss advantages and implications of an integrated database in advancing ecological assessments and modeling efforts based on preliminary assessments of the OBIS\u2013SEAMAP data and derived products. Finally, we make critical suggestions for the design and function of biogeographic databases to make contributed data more useful for conservation efforts.","author":["Halpin, P.","Best, B.","Fujioka, E.","Kot, C.","Wallace, B.","Moxley, J.","Cleary, J.","Donnelly, B."],"organization":["Duke University"],"originationDate":"2014-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1899","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/automated-bird-acoustic-event-detection-robust-species-classification","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S157495411630231X","title":"Automated bird acoustic event detection and robust species classification","description":"Non-invasive bioacoustic monitoring is becoming increasingly popular for biodiversity conservation. Two automated methods for acoustic classification of bird species currently used are frame-based methods, a model that uses Hidden Markov Models (HMMs), and event-based methods, a model consisting of descriptive measurements or restricted to tonal or harmonic vocalizations. In this work, we propose a new method for automated field recording analysis with improved automated segmentation and robust bird species classification. We used a Gaussian Mixture Model (GMM)-based frame selection with an event-energy-based sifting procedure that selected representative acoustic events. We employed a Mel, band-pass filter bank on each event\u0027s spectrogram. The output in each subband was parameterized by an autoregressive (AR) model, which resulted in a feature consisting of all model coefficients. Finally, a support vector machine (SVM) algorithm was used for classification. The significance of the proposed method lies in the parameterized features depicting the species-specific spectral pattern. This experiment used a control audio dataset and real-world audio dataset comprised of field recordings of eleven bird species from the Xeno-canto Archive, consisting of 2762 bird acoustic events with 339 detected \u201cunknown\u201d events (corresponding to noise or unknown species vocalizations). Compared with other recent approaches, our proposed method provides comparable identification performance with respect to the eleven species of interest. Meanwhile, superior robustness in real-world scenarios is achieved, which is expressed as the considerable improvement from 0.632 to 0.928 for the F-score metric regarding the \u201cunknown\u201d events. The advantage makes the proposed method more suitable for automated field recording analysis.","author":["Zhao, Z.","Zhang, S.","Xu, Z.","Bellisario, K.","Dai, N.","Omrani, H.","Pijanowski, B."],"organization":["Nanjing University of Science and Technology","Purdue University"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1900","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/using-multi-label-classification-acoustic-pattern-detection-assisting-bird-species","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0003682X16300603","title":"Using multi-label classification for acoustic pattern detection and assisting bird species surveys","description":"Acoustics is a rich source of environmental information that can reflect the ecological dynamics. To deal with the escalating acoustic data, a variety of automated classification techniques have been used for acoustic patterns or scene recognition, including urban soundscapes such as streets and restaurants; and natural soundscapes such as raining and thundering. It is common to classify acoustic patterns under the assumption that a single type of soundscapes present in an audio clip. This assumption is reasonable for some carefully selected audios. However, only few experiments have been focused on classifying simultaneous acoustic patterns in long-duration recordings. This paper proposes a binary relevance based multi-label classification approach to recognise simultaneous acoustic patterns in one-minute audio clips. By utilising acoustic indices as global features and multilayer perceptron as a base classifier, we achieve good classification performance on in-the-field data. Compared with single-label classification, multi-label classification approach provides more detailed information about the distributions of various acoustic patterns in long-duration recordings. These results will merit further biodiversity investigations, such as bird species surveys.","author":["Zhang, J.","Zhang, L.","Towsey, M.","Xie, J.","Roe, P."],"organization":["Queensland University of Technology"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1901","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/norfolk-vanguard-offshore-wind-farm-environmental-impact-assessment-scoping-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/eastern\/norfolk-vanguard\/","title":"Norfolk Vanguard Offshore Wind Farm Environmental Impact Assessment Scoping Report","description":"This document supports a request for an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Scoping Opinion from the Planning Inspectorate for the Norfolk Vanguard offshore wind farm. Norfolk Vanguard is a Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project (NSIP) and as such an EIA is required as part of a Development Consent Order (DCO) application under the Planning Act 2008.  The key drivers for renewable energy, and therefore the Norfolk Vanguard project are reducing greenhouse gas emissions, providing energy security, and maximising economic opportunities from investment for the UK.  Norfolk Vanguard is located 47km offshore (at the closest point). It will have a generation capacity of 1.8GW (1800MW) and will produce enough energy to power 1.3million UK households. The wind farm comprises two distinct areas, Norfolk Vanguard East (NV East) and Norfolk Vanguard West (NV West) and will be connected to the shore by offshore export cables installed within the provisional offshore cable corridor.  The project will also require onshore infrastructure in order to connect the offshore wind farm to the National Grid, which in summary will comprise:    Landfall (within the landfall search area);  Cable relay station if required (within the cable relay search area);  Underground cables (within the cable corridor search area); and  Onshore substation (within the substation search area).   A grid connection offer was provided by National Grid in July 2016 based on an onshore connection point at the existing 400kV Necton National Grid Substation. The Applicant has taken up this offer and is committed to an underground cable solution which has the benefit of avoiding landscape and visual impacts associated with overhead lines.  The exact locations of the landfall and onshore infrastructure are yet to be determined. Site selection for the onshore infrastructure locations is ongoing and responses to the Scoping Request and public consultation will help to inform the development of Norfolk Vanguard.  Norfolk Vanguard is being developed by VWPL (or an affiliate company). VWPL has invested nearly \u00a33bn in the UK, in onshore and offshore wind since 2008 and will have nearly 1GW in operation onshore and offshore by 2017. Vattenfall plans to invest \u00a35bn in renewables, mainly offshore wind, in Northern Europe by 2020 and Norfolk Vanguard represents the next step in the UK. VWPL has world leading experience in offshore wind, as owners of the Kentish Flats, Kentish Flats Extension, Ormonde, and Thanet offshore wind farms, which are currently operational in the UK.  The EIA will be completed by technical specialists using best practice and following appropriate guidance. Key aspects of the EIA are likely to be traffic and transport, noise, landscape and visual, tourism and recreation, commercial fisheries, ornithology and marine mammals. This Scoping Report outlines all of the receptors that will be considered during the EIA and the planned approach to characterising the existing environment, assessing potential impacts associated with Norfolk Vanguard and developing mitigation measures. Consultation will be ongoing with stakeholders throughout the EIA and DCO application process. VWPL is committed to engaging with the community and stakeholders. Section 5 of this Scoping Report provides an outline of the planned consultation associated with the project.","author":["Royal Haskoning"],"organization":["Vattenfall","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.870000000000","2.688000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EIA_Scoping_report_Norfolk_Vanguard_2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1902","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/norfolk-boreas-offshore-wind-farm-environmental-impact-assessment-scoping-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/eastern\/norfolk-boreas\/","title":"Norfolk Boreas Offshore Wind Farm Environmental Impact Assessment Scoping Report","description":"This document supports a request by Vattenfall Wind Power Limited (VWPL) for an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Scoping Opinion from the Planning Inspectorate for the Norfolk Boreas offshore wind farm. Norfolk Boreas is a Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project (NSIP) and as such an EIA is required as part of a Development Consent Order (DCO) application under the Planning Act 2008.  The key drivers for renewable energy, and therefore the Norfolk Boreas project, are reducing greenhouse gas emissions, providing energy security for the UK, and maximising economic opportunities through investment in the UK. Norfolk Boreas is located 72km offshore (at the closest point). It will have a generation capacity of 1.8GW (1,800MW) and will produce enough energy to power 1.3million UK households. The Norfolk Boreas site would comprise an array of offshore wind turbines and offshore substations which will be connected to the shore by offshore export cables installed within an offshore cable corridor.  The project will also require onshore infrastructure in order to transmit and connect the offshore wind farm to the National Grid, which in summary would comprise: - Landfall; - A cable relay station, if required; - Underground cables; - An onshore project substation; and - Works at the Necton National Grid Substation (including extension of the existing substation and modification of the overhead powerlines).  A grid connection offer was provided by National Grid in October 2016 based on an onshore connection point at the existing Necton National Grid Substation. VWPL has taken up this offer and is committed to burying all the onshore cables for Norfolk Boreas project. This has the benefit of avoiding the landscape and visual impacts associated with the use of overhead lines.  Norfolk Boreas is the sister project to the proposed Norfolk Vanguard offshore wind farm project which is of the same capacity and located across two offshore wind farm sites, adjacent to the Norfolk Boreas site. Norfolk Vanguard is being developed first and its EIA and project design development are at a more advanced stage than for Norfolk Boreas. As both projects will connect to the Necton National Grid Substation, there has been a strategic approach to identifying locations for all onshore infrastructure with the aim of optimising overall design and reducing impacts where practical.  Norfolk Boreas is being developed by Vattenfall Wind Power Ltd (VWPL) (although the project will soon be transferred to a wholly owned subsidiary). VWPL has invested nearly \u00a33bn in the UK, in onshore and offshore wind since 2008 and will have nearly 1GW in operation onshore and offshore by the end of 2017. Vattenfall plans to invest \u00a35bn in renewables, mainly offshore wind, in Northern Europe by 2020 and Norfolk Boreas along with Norfolk Vanguard represent the next steps in the UK. VWPL has world leading experience in offshore wind, as owners of the Kentish Flats, Kentish Flats Extension, Ormonde (see front cover) and Thanet offshore wind farms, which are currently operational in the UK.  The EIA for Norfolk Boreas will be undertaken by experienced and well qualified technical specialists using best practice and following appropriate and relevant guidance. Key topics for investigation within the EIA are expected to be traffic and transport, onshore archaeology, noise, landscape and visual, tourism and recreation, commercial fisheries, other sea users, ornithology and marine mammals. This Scoping Report is the first stage of the EIA process, it outlines the receptors that will be considered during the EIA and the planned approach to data gathering and characterising the existing environment, assessing potential impacts associated with Norfolk Boreas and developing mitigation measures. A programme of consultation will be ongoing with stakeholders and communities throughout the EIA and DCO application process. VWPL is committed to engaging with the community and stakeholders. Section 5 of this Scoping Report provides an outline of the planned consultation associated with the project.","author":["Royal Haskoning"],"organization":["Vattenfall","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.041000000000","2.934000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EIA_Scoping_report_Norfolk_Boreas_2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1903","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implications-european-sites-proposed-navitus-bay-wind-park","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/south-east\/navitus-bay-wind-park","title":"Report on the Implications for European Sites Proposed Navitus Bay Wind Park","description":"Navitus Bay Development Limited (the applicant) has applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under Section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) for the proposed Navitus Bay Wind Park (the application). The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State as to the decision to be made on the application.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive and the Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations for applications submitted under the Planning Act 2008 regime (as amended). The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the ExA will assist the Secretary of State in performing their duties under the Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations.  This report has been produced by the ExA, with support from the Environmental Services Team within the Planning Inspectorate. It compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the DCO application, and the information in relation to potential effects to European Sites submitted throughout the examination up to and including Deadline VIa (5 February 2015) by both the applicant and interested parties. It is not a standalone document and should be read in conjunction with the examination documents referred to in this report.  This RIES is issued to ensure that interested parties including the statutory nature conservation bodies in this case Natural England (NE) is consulted formally on Habitats Regulations matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the Habitats Regulations and Regulation 25 of the Offshore Marine Regulations. Following consultation, responses to this RIES will be considered by the ExA in making their recommendation to the Secretary of State and made available to the Secretary of State along with this report. The RIES will not be revised following consultation.  The applicant considered a number of European sites in other EEA States6 (APP-059 and APP-060), however no likely significant effects (LSE) were identified and all non-UK sites were screened out of the assessment. Only UK sites are considered in this report.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":["ENECO","\u00c9lectricit\u00e9 de France (EDF)","\u00c9lectricit\u00e9 de France (EDF)","ENECO"],"originationDate":"2015-02-20","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.462000000000","-1.757000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_Navitus_Bay_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1904","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/deployment-characterization-floatable-tidal-energy-converter-tidal-channel-ria-formosa","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544218310934","title":"Deployment characterization of a floatable tidal energy converter on a tidal channel, Ria Formosa, Portugal","description":"This paper presents the results of a pilot experiment with an existing tidal energy converter (TEC), Evopod 1\u202fkW floatable prototype, in a real test case scenario (Faro Channel, Ria Formosa, Portugal). A baseline marine geophysical, hydrodynamic and ecological study based on the experience collected on the test site is presented. The collected data was used to validate a hydro-morphodynamic model, allowing the selection of the installation area based on both operational and environmental constraints. Operational results related to the description of power generation capacity, energy capture area and proportion of energy flux are presented and discussed, including the failures occurring during the experimental setup. The data is now available to the scientific community and to TEC industry developers, enhancing the operational knowledge of TEC technology concerning efficiency, environmental effects, and interactions (i.e. device\/environment). The results can be used by developers on the licensing process, on overcoming the commercial deployment barriers, on offering extra assurance and confidence to investors, who traditionally have seen environmental concerns as a barrier, and on providing the foundations whereupon similar deployment areas can be considered around the world for marine tidal energy extraction.","author":["Soares, C.","Pacheco, A.","Garel, E.","Zabel, F.","Gorbe\u00f1a, E.","Gon\u00e7alves, J.","Bentes, L.","Monteiro, P.","Afonso, C.","Oliveira, F.","Sequeira, C."],"organization":["University of Algarve","Marine Sensing and Acoustic Technologies (MarSensing)"],"originationDate":"2018-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.971634400000","-7.870425400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 08:10:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1905","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-tidal-energy-environmental-effects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/9781119014492.ch9","title":"Wave and Tidal Energy: Environmental Effects","description":"Wave and tidal energy devices extract energy from the environment. This extraction is bound to have effects at different levels, from the physical to the biological, which are the subject of this chapter. This chapter deals with the physical effects of marine renewable energy (MRE) on the environment: the effects of wave farms on the wave field and coastal processes, and those of tidal stream farms on the hydrodynamics and sediment transport processes. It considers the impacts of MRE on the marine biota, focusing on the environmental impact assessment that must form part of any MRE project. The chapter summarises the work carried out to date on hydrodynamics and sediment transport. It also deals with the effects on the marine biota, combined with those of wave farms. As far as concerns MRE projects, an evaluation of the sensitivity of the site with regard to both environmental and socioeconomic issues, should be carried out during the initial stage of an environmental impact assessment (EIA) process.  This is a chapter from Wave and Tidal Energy.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Simas, T.","Cruz, E.","Machado, I.","Tercero, J."],"organization":["Plymouth University","WavEC Offshore Renewables"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1906","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fine-scale-hydrodynamic-metrics-underlying-predator-occupancy-patterns-tidal-stream","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X18305181","title":"Fine-Scale Hydrodynamic Metrics Underlying Predator Occupancy Patterns in Tidal Stream Environments","description":"Whilst the development of the tidal stream industry will help meet marine renewable energy (MRE) targets, the potential impacts on mobile marine predators using these highly dynamic environments need consideration. Environmental impact assessments (EIAs) required for potential MRE sites generally involve site-specific animal density estimates obtained from lengthy and costly surveys. Recent studies indicate that whilst large-scale tidal forcing is predictable, local hydrodynamics are variable and often result in spatio-temporal patchiness of marine predators. Therefore, understanding how fine-scale hydrodynamics influence animal distribution patterns could inform the placing of devices to reduce collision and displacement risks. Quantifying distributions requires animal at-sea locations and the concurrent collection of high-resolution hydrodynamic measurements. As the latter are routinely collected during tidal resource characterization at potential MRE sites, there is an untapped opportunity to efficiently collect information on the former to improve EIAs. Here we describe a survey approach that uses vessel-mounted ADCP (Acoustic Doppler current profiler) transects in combination with marine mammal surveys to collect high-resolution and concurrent hydrodynamic data in relation to pinniped (harbour seals Phoca vitulina, grey seals Halichoerus grypus) at-sea occupancy patterns within an energetic tidal channel (peak current magnitudes \u0026gt;4.5\u202fms\u22121). We identified novel ADCP-derived fine-scale hydrodynamic metrics that could have ecological relevance for seals using these habitats. We show that our local acoustic backscattering strength metric (an indicator for macro-turbulence) had the highest influence on seal encounters. During peak flows, pinnipeds avoided the mid-channel characterized by extreme backscatter. At-sea occupancy further corresponded with the increased shear and eddies that are strong relative to the mean flows found at the edges of the channel. Our approach, providing oceanographic context to animal habitat use through combined survey methodologies, enhances environmental management of potential MRE sites. The cost-effective collection of such data and the application of our metrics could streamline the EIA process in the early stages of the consenting process.","author":["Waggitt, J.","Kregting, L.","Lieber, L.","Nimmo-Smith, A."],"organization":["Queen\u0027s University Belfast","Plymouth University","Bangor University"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.363959600000","-5.544411100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1907","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spanish-approach-marine-spatial-planning-marine-strategy-framework-directive-vs-eu","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X11000522","title":"The Spanish approach to marine spatial planning. Marine Strategy Framework Directive vs. EU Integrated Maritime Policy","description":"The coming into effect of the Directive 2008\/56\/EC (Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD)) will induce European Union member States to create mechanisms for managing maritime space in order to comply with the goals set out in this binding legislation. This leads one to think that marine spatial planning in various countries in the EU will be directed at complying with the Directive\u0027s environmental goals, as is the case in Spain, rather than undertaking proactive planning for developing the maritime sectors. To put the case of Spain into perspective, a review is conducted of the initiatives taken, especially in Europe and the European Union, exploring the correlations between the main focuses of the maritime sectors and the planning systems. The analysis of the Spanish initiative demonstrates how the maritime economy model and geopolitical factors explain the planning options for the marine environment. In other respects, with the coming into effect of the MSFD, a dual institutional course for marine spatial planning seems to be opening up in the EU: Integrated Maritime Policy vs. the Marine Strategy Framework Directive.","author":["Su\u00e1rez de Vivero, J.","Rodr\u00edguez Mateos, M."],"organization":["University of Seville"],"originationDate":"2012-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1908","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/practical-tools-support-marine-spatial-planning-review-some-prototype-tools","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X12001364","title":"Practical tools to support marine spatial planning: A review and some prototype tools","description":"Marine planners use spatial data to assess planning options. They need analytical approaches, methods, applications and practical software tools to enable assessment of the relationships between human uses and ecosystem components. Here the results of a two-stage process, aimed at developing practical and GIS-based tools for direct use by planners, are presented. First, some available tools for use in the early stages of plan development were reviewed; for example, to identify interaction between activities to reduce potential conflicts or assist in zone delineation, methods to facilitate a risk assessment of the cumulative effect of human pressures and tools offering decision support. Second, a stakeholder workshop was organised to identify routine marine planning tasks and the technical tools required to support those tasks. From the 39 practical tools reviewed, mostly published in peer-reviewed literature between 1998 and 2009, the majority have been applied in the marine environment in Europe, USA and Australia. It was observed that many of the tools are designed to be used by scientists, programmers or strategic planners with only a few that could be used by case officers (regulators). Together with the results of the stakeholder workshop a suite of prototype tools were developed that offer utility to marine planners. Thus the developed tools provide a solid basis for future development as they are a result of a transparent and participatory process.","author":["Rogers, S.","Lee, J.","Stelzenm\u00fcller, V.","South, A.","Foden, J."],"organization":["Johann Heinrich von Th\u00fcnen Institute (vTI)","Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)"],"originationDate":"2013-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1909","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning-reality-introduction-case-studies-discussion-findings","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X16302147","title":"Marine spatial planning in reality: Introduction to case studies and discussion of findings","description":"This paper explores the realities of marine spatial planning (MSP\u2019ing), drawing on 12 case studies around Europe, employing a structured qualitative empirical approach. The findings indicate that (1) MSP\u2019ing is often focused on achieving specific sectoral objectives, related to nationally important strategic priorities, and might better be termed \u2018strategic sectoral planning\u2019. (2) MSP\u2019ing processes tend to be complex, fragmented and emergent on an ad hoc basis, rather than cyclical, adaptive and prescribed on an a priori basis. (3) Top-down processes tend to dominate, more participative platforms tending to be \u2018disconnected by design\u2019 from executive decision-making. (4) Blue growth is the dominant overall priority, often aligned with strategic sectoral priorities, despite growing indications that the target for Good Environmental Status (GES) by 2020 is unlikely to be met. This is consistent with growing concerns about the tensions between the Marine Strategy Framework Directive and the Directive Establishing a Framework for Maritime Spatial Planning. It is concluded that the realities of how MSP\u2019ing is working contrast with widely recognised concepts and ideals as to how MSP\u2019ing should work, as integrated-use MSP\u2019ing based on political expedience and blue growth priorities is diverging from and potentially competing with ecosystem-based MSP\u2019ing, including marine protected area networks, based on GES priorities. It is argued that a more empirical approach should be taken to MSP\u2019ing research, whereby conceptual approaches which integrate sustainable blue growth and GES co-evolve with marine spatial planning practices through critical analyses of whether the realities of MSP\u2019ing are consistent with these concepts.","author":["Lieberknecht, L.","Jones, P.","Qiu, W."],"organization":["University College London","State Oceanic Administration (SOA)"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Jones-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1910","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-spatial-planning-advancing-ecosystem-based-approach-coastal-zone-management","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X16300161","title":"Marine Spatial Planning Advancing the Ecosystem-Based Approach to Coastal Zone Management: A Review","description":"Planning a sustainable future for coastal populations requires the effective implementation of ecosystem management frameworks that explicitly incorporate human activities. A coupled framework of the Ecosystem-Based Approach with Marine Spatial Planning has been discussed and promoted by coastal managers for more than a decade. The proposed framework supports a balanced approach between development needs and the natural environment. This paper presents a qualitative review of Marine Spatial Planning case studies to gain insights into methodological approaches that account for human systems as components of the coastal environment. A total of twelve Marine Spatial Planning case studies were evaluated. Their use and integration of the Ecosystem-Based framework was assessed through a linguistic scale linked to a score of fuzzy numbers. Two management issues of interest were highlighted: how social, economic and environmental values were integrated into the spatial planning analysis; and how cross-realm connectivity was addressed by planning teams. Although the majority of case studies claimed to use the Ecosystem-Based Approach as the guiding framework, mixed results were observed. Relevant features of the Ecosystem-Based Approach were rarely included; such as the standardization of pressures from human activities, the integration of frameworks to assess ecosystem services and the implementation of Precautionary and Adaptive Management approaches. Important knowledge gaps were observed with regards to the assessment of social values, including the lack of spatial representation of \u2018social connections\u2019 to the marine environment and the lack of economic estimates of non-market values. Terrestrial and catchment units were not included in the majority of case studies; however, water quality management was used as a key element for the consideration of transboundary impacts. This comparative study reveals major differences in how coastal managers understand and integrate Ecosystem-Based Approaches with Marine Spatial Planning.","author":["Johnston, E.","Dom\u00ednguez-Tejo, E.","Metternicht, G.","Hedge, L."],"organization":["University of New South Wales","Sydney Institute of Marine Science"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1911","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/how-sustainable-sustainable-marine-spatial-planning-part-ii-portuguese-experience","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X1400116X","title":"How sustainable is sustainable marine spatial planning? Part II - The Portuguese experience","description":"With one of Europe\u05f3s largest exclusive economic zones, Portugal has a paramount role in the implementation of EU maritime policies. In the Portuguese context, ocean planning and management are presently undergoing major advances. This paper analyzes and discusses the present state of affairs regarding the Portuguese marine spatial planning (MSP) process, comprising: (1) an update on the status of MSP in Portugal; (2) an analysis on how sustainability concepts are to be implemented in the Portuguese MSP process and (3) a discussion on major challenges to Portuguese MSP long-term sustainability. The Portuguese MSP process can be divided in two phases: development of the \u201cPlano de Ordenamento do Espa\u00e7o Mar\u00edtimo\u201d (POEM) \u2013 initially intended to be the first Portuguese \u201cmarine spatial plan\u201d but then published as a \u201cstudy\u201d; and development of the Law Proposal 133\/XII on marine planning and management \u2013 soon to be approved. A key question for the long-term adequacy of Portuguese MSP is how is it addressing environmental sustainability: is it relying on soft or hard sustainability concepts? Is it prioritizing the achievement of good environmental status (GES) or blue growth? In both cases (POEM and Law Proposal), soft sustainability seems to be the underlying principle, because although the ecosystem approach is recognized as fundamental, environmental quality seems to come second when set against economic goals.","author":["Santos, C.","Orbach, M.","Andrade, F.","Domingos, T.","Ferreira, M."],"organization":["Duke University","University of Lisbon","New University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2014-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1912","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X12000917","title":"Evaluation of marine spatial planning","description":"Evaluation is generally recognised as an essential step for learning and improvement in marine spatial planning (MSP). Practical guidance and experience relative to evaluation in MSP is, however, very limited. To address this gap, this paper addresses a set of issues relevant for evaluation design and performance: the object of evaluation is discussed in relation to the functions of planning, the choice of objectives and the timing of evaluation; factors affecting causality attribution are analysed, namely multi-causality of observed effects, counterfactual design, time lags and uncertainty; and possibilities and requirements regarding stakeholder involvement in evaluation are considered.  Six models of planning evaluation are reviewed, based on which a step-wise framework for MSP evaluation is developed. Future research should pilot test and assess this framework and broaden the evidence base relative to impacts of marine management initiatives.","author":["Carneiro, G."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1913","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implications-european-sites-proposed-hornsea-offshore-wind-farm-zone-4-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/yorkshire-and-the-humber\/hornsea-offshore-wind-farm-zone-4-project-two\/","title":"Report on the Implications for European Sites Proposed Hornsea Offshore Wind Farm (Zone 4) - Project Two","description":"Optimus Wind Limited and Breesea Limited (jointly referred to as the applicant) have applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) for the proposed Hornsea Offshore Wind Farm (Zone 4) Project Two (the application). The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State as to the decision to be made on the application.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive and the Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations for applications submitted under the Planning Act 2008 regime (as amended). The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the ExA will assist the Secretary of State in performing their duties under the Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations.  This report compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the DCO application, and the information submitted throughout the examination by both the applicant and interested parties, up to examination deadline 5 (12 November 2015) in relation to potential effects to European Sites. The RIES makes reference to examination documents in the Planning Inspectorate\u2019s document library. Each document is identified by a unique reference number in the document library. The RIES should be read in conjunction with these documents.  It is issued to ensure that interested parties including the statutory nature conservation bodies: Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC), Natural England (NE) and Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH), are consulted formally on Habitats Regulations matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the Habitats Regulations and Regulation 25 of the Offshore Marine Regulations. Following consultation the responses will be considered by the ExA in making its recommendation to the Secretary of State and made available to the Secretary of State along with this report. The RIES is not revised following consultation.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":["SMart Wind","SMart Wind"],"originationDate":"2015-11-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.940000000000","1.688000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_Hornsea_Z4_P2_2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1914","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implications-european-sites-proposed-hornsea-offshore-wind-farm-zone-4-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/yorkshire-and-the-humber\/hornsea-offshore-wind-farm-zone-4-project-one\/","title":"Report on the Implications for European Sites Proposed Hornsea Offshore Wind Farm (Zone 4) - Project One","description":"SMart Wind Ltd (the applicant) has applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) for the proposed Hornsea Offshore Wind Farm (Zone 4) \u2013 Project One which comprises of up to 332 wind turbine generators with capacities ranging from 3.6 MW up to 8 MW, together with on and offshore infrastructure. It is intended that there will be three development zones. The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State as to the decision to be made on the application.  The Hornsea Zone is located in the southern region of the North Sea, covering an area of 4,735 km2. The western boundary of the Hornsea Zone is 31 km from the coastline of the East Riding of Yorkshire and the eastern boundary is 1 km from the median line between United Kingdom (UK) and Dutch waters.  Subzone 1 is situated within the centre of the Hornsea Zone with a total area of 407 km2. The term Subzone 1 is used to describe the area within the Hornsea Zone containing the offshore array, comprising wind turbine generators and foundations, inter-array cabling, offshore converter stations, offshore collector stations, offshore accommodation platforms, and all associated infrastructure.  Project One consists of the infrastructure contained in Subzone 1, offshore export cable route, offshore reactive compensation substation, and landfall as well as the onshore cabling, onshore HVAC substation or HVDC converter station, and associated infrastructure and works.  The western boundary of Subzone 1 lies 103 km off the East Riding of Yorkshire coast and the eastern boundary of Subzone 1 is 43.6 km from the median line between UK and Dutch waters.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive and the 2010 Habitats Regulations for applications submitted under the Planning Act regime (as amended). The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the ExA will assist the Secretary of State in performing their duties under the Habitats Regulations.  This report compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the DCO application, and the information submitted throughout the examination by both the applicant and interested parties. It is issued to ensure that interested parties including the Statutory Nature Conservation Bodies (SNCB\u2019s): Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC) and Natural England (NE) are consulted formally on habitats regulations matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the Habitats Regulations.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":["SMart Wind","SMart Wind"],"originationDate":"2014-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.885000000000","1.791000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_Hornsea_Z4_2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1915","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implication-european-sites-proposed-east-anglia-one-offshore-windfarm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/eastern\/east-anglia-one-offshore-windfarm\/","title":"Report on the Implication for European Sites Proposed East Anglia ONE Offshore Windfarm","description":"East Anglia ONE Limited (the applicant) has applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) for the proposed East Anglia ONE Offshore Windfarm. The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State as to the decision to be made on the application.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive and the 2010 Habitats Regulations for applications submitted under the Planning Act regime (as amended). The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the Examining Authority will assist the Secretary of State in performing its duties under the Habitats Regulations.  This report compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the DCO application, and the information submitted throughout the examination by both the applicant and interested parties. It is issued to ensure that interested parties including the statutory nature conservation bodies, Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC) and Natural England (NE), are consulted formally on habitats regulations matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the Habitats Regulations.  Attention is drawn in particular to integrity matrix 3.4 and the potential impacts of the project in-combination with other projects on Gannet and Kittiwake. Please note the comments raised by NE regarding a strategic approach to the allocation of wind resource in the North Sea. The ExA would welcome comments from Interested Parties on this matter spelling out in particular the practical implications of this approach and if possible how this could be progressed and the likely timescales involved.  In addition, the ExA would welcome a copy of the citation documents from NE relating to the consultation on the Flamborough Head and Filey Coast as an SPA and comments from Interested Parties about whether this emerging designation affects the assessment by the applicant of the impact of the project on internationally designated sites and the provision of sufficient information to inform an Appropriate Assessment.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-11-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.226000000000","2.494000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_EA_ONE_2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1916","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/east-anglia-one-north-offshore-windfarm-scoping-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/eastern\/east-anglia-one-north-offshore-windfarm\/","title":"East Anglia ONE North Offshore Windfarm Scoping Report","description":"This Scoping Report supports a request for a formal Scoping Opinion from the Planning Inspectorate in relation to the proposed East Anglia ONE North offshore windfarm. This Scoping Report has been prepared in accordance with Regulation 10 of the Infrastructure Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2017 which enables an applicant to seek a Scoping Opinion from the Planning Inspectorate on the information to be included in an EIA.  This report presents an initial overview and description of the project and a review of the potential impacts associated with the construction, operation and eventual decommissioning of the proposed East Anglia ONE North project. Project details presented are accurate at the time of writing. This report aims to identify the likely significant effects arising from the proposed East Anglia ONE North project on the physical, human and biological environments and also outlines the approach to understanding baseline conditions and addressing environmental impacts through the EIA process.  The East Anglia ONE North project will have an anticipated capacity of up to 800MW, which has the potential to provide 650,000 homes with power. At its nearest point, the East Anglia ONE North windfarm site is 36km from shore. From the wind turbines electricity would flow via subsea inter-array cables to a number of offshore electrical platforms and then to the shore via export cables.  Offshore export cables will connect the proposed East Anglia ONE North windfarm site to shore, making landfall in the vicinity of Sizewell and Thorpeness in Suffolk. From the landfall, cables will be routed underground to an onshore substation which will in turn connect into the main transmission network via a new transmission infrastructure owned and operated by National Grid connecting into the existing overhead pylons. In addition, there may be a requirement to upgrade the existing pylons to allow for connection to the transmission network. The location of the substation and National Grid infrastructure will be finalised in early 2018.  The EIA will be undertaken by experienced and well qualified technical specialists using industry best practice and following appropriate and relevant guidance. Key topics for investigation within the EIA are expected to be offshore ornithology, marine mammals, seascape, landscape and visual amenity, traffic and transport, onshore archaeology and noise.  This Scoping Report is the first stage of the EIA process, it outlines the receptors that will be considered during the EIA and the planned approach to data gathering and characterising the existing environment, assessing potential impacts and developing mitigation measures. A programme of consultation will be ongoing with stakeholders and communities throughout the EIA and DCO application process.","author":["ScottishPower Renewables"],"organization":["ScottishPower Renewables","ScottishPower Renewables"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.372000000000","2.430000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EA1N-ScottishPower-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1917","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implications-european-sites-proposed-dogger-bank-teesside-b-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/yorkshire-and-the-humber\/dogger-bank-teesside-a-sofia-offshore-wind-farm-formerly-dogger-bank-teesside-b-project-previously-known-as-dogger-bank-teesside-ab\/","title":"Report on the Implications for European Sites Proposed Dogger Bank Teesside A \u0026 B Offshore Wind Farm","description":"Forewind Limited (the Applicant) has applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) (PA 2008) for the proposed Dogger Bank Teesside A \u0026amp; B offshore wind farm (the application). The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State as to the decision to be made on the application.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive and the Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations for applications submitted under the PA 2008 regime. The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the ExA will assist the Secretary of State in performing their duties under the Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations.  This Report on the Implications for European Sites (RIES) compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the DCO application, and the information submitted throughout the examination by both the Applicant and other Interested Parties up to and including Deadline VII (11 December 2014) of the examination, in relation to potential effects of the application on European Sites. The RIES makes reference to examination documents in the Planning Inspectorate\u2019s document library. Each document is identified by a unique reference number in the document library. This RIES should be read in conjunction with these documents.  This RIES is issued to ensure that the Interested Parties including the statutory nature conservation bodies: Natural England (NE), Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC), the Marine Management Organisation (MMO), Natural Resources Wales (NRW) and Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) are consulted formally on Habitats Regulations Assessment matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the Habitats Regulations and Regulation 25 of the Offshore Marine Regulations and so the RIES is not revised following consultation. The consultation responses received on this RIES will be considered by the ExA in making their recommendation to the Secretary of State and made available to the Secretary of State along with this RIES.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":["Forewind","Forewind"],"originationDate":"2014-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.040000000000","2.822000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-22 08:42:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_Dogger_Bank_Teesside_2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1918","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implications-european-sites-proposed-dogger-bank-creyke-beck-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/yorkshire-and-the-humber\/dogger-bank-creyke-beck\/","title":"Report on the Implications for European Sites Proposed Dogger Bank Creyke Beck Offshore Wind Farm","description":"Forewind Limited (the Applicant) has applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) (the PA 2008) for the proposed Dogger Bank Creyke Beck wind farm (the Application). The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the Application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State, as to the decision to be made on the Application.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive, the 2010 Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations for applications submitted under the PA 2008 regime. The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the ExA will assist the Secretary of State in performing the duties under the 2010 Habitats Regulations and the Offshore Marine Regulations.  This Report on the Implications for European sites (\u2018the Report\u2019) compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the DCO application, and the information submitted throughout the examination by both the Applicant and Interested Parties.  This Report is issued to Interested Parties including: Natural England (NE), the Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC) and the Marine Management Organisation (MMO). The ExA also addressed questions in the examination, to Natural Resources Wales (NRW) and Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) in relation to the European sites located in Wales and Scotland respectively, which the Applicant identified within their HRA Report submitted with their DCO application. This was to ensure that these bodies are consulted on habitats regulations matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the 2010 Habitats Regulations and Regulation 25(3) of the Offshore Marine Regulations.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":["Forewind","Forewind"],"originationDate":"2014-07-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.769000000000","1.909000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-22 08:43:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_Dogger_Bank_2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1919","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implications-european-sites-proposed-burbo-bank-extension-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/north-west\/burbo-bank-extension-offshore-wind-farm\/","title":"Report on the Implications for European Sites Proposed Burbo Bank Extension Offshore Wind Farm","description":"Dong Energy Burbo Extension (UK) Limited (the applicant) has applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) for the proposed Burbo Bank Extension offshore wind farm (the Project). The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State as to the decision to be made on the application.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive and the 2010 Habitats Regulations for applications submitted under the Planning Act regime (as amended). The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the ExA will assist the Secretary of State in performing their duties under the Habitats Regulations.  This report compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the Development Consent Order (DCO) application, and the information submitted throughout the examination by both the applicant and interested parties. It is issued to ensure that interested parties including the statutory nature conservation bodies: Natural England (NE) and Natural Resources Wales (NRW), are consulted formally on habitats regulations matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the Habitats Regulations.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":["Dong Energy","Dong Energy"],"originationDate":"2014-02-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.483333000000","-3.166667000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_Burbo_Bank.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1920","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-implications-european-sites-proposed-walney-extension-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/projects\/north-west\/walney-extension-offshore-wind-farm\/","title":"Report on the Implications for European Sites Proposed Walney Extension Offshore Wind Farm","description":"DONG Energy (the Applicant) has applied to the Secretary of State for a development consent order (DCO) under section 37 of the Planning Act 2008 (as amended) for the proposed Walney Extension Offshore Wind Farm. The Secretary of State has appointed an Examining Authority (ExA) to conduct an examination of the application, to report its findings and conclusions, and to make a recommendation to the Secretary of State as to the decision to be made on the application.  The relevant Secretary of State is the competent authority for the purposes of the Habitats Directive and the 2010 Habitats Regulations for applications submitted under the Planning Act regime (as amended). The findings and conclusions on nature conservation issues reported by the Examining Authority will assist the Secretary of State in performing their duties under the Habitats Regulations.  This report compiles, documents and signposts information provided within the DCO application, and the information submitted throughout the examination by both the Applicant and interested parties. It is issued to ensure that interested parties including the statutory nature conservation bodies, Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)\/ Natural England (NE)\/ Natural Resources Wales (NRW)\/ Scottish National Heritage (SNH), are consulted formally, as appropriate, on habitats regulations matters. This process may be relied on by the Secretary of State for the purposes of Regulation 61(3) of the Habitats Regulations.","author":["The Planning Inspectorate for England and Wales"],"organization":["Dong Energy","Dong Energy"],"originationDate":"2014-04-14","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.103000000000","-3.252000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Report_on_the_Implications_for_European_Sites_Walney.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1921","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-central-apennine-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/sisn.pagepress.org\/index.php\/rio\/article\/view\/134","title":"The impact of a central Apennine wind-farm","description":"We monitored raptors and investigated collision rate of birds with 2 turbines of a central Apennine wind-farm. We detected 1,18\/raptors\/km2\/h. We have not found bird fatalities with turbines. We found 2 carcasses: one Subalpine Warbler, Sylvia cantillans, died by collision with a close communication tower and a Kestrel, Falco tinnunculus, died by electrocution with an MT power-line starting from the communication tower.","author":["Forconi, P.","Fusari, M.","Appiotti, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2012-09-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.469167000000","13.565833000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Forconi-et-al-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1922","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dodging-blades-new-insights-three-dimensional-space-use-offshore-wind-farms-lesser","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v587\/p247-253\/","title":"Dodging the blades: new insights into three-dimensional space use of offshore wind farms by lesser black-backed gulls Larus fuscus","description":"GPS telemetry is improving our understanding of the way animals interact with their environment. Recent research has used this technology to assess the impact of offshore wind farms (OWFs) on seabirds, but few studies have collected fine-scale data from birds flying within OWFs. We use GPS telemetry to investigate movements of lesser black-backed gulls Larus fuscus in relation to OWFs from a protected site with an active breeding colony. Individual birds varied considerably in their use of OWFs; 15 out of 24 birds visited them, and time spent in these areas was 1.3% of time budgets across all birds. Two birds, for which the most data was collected, frequently entered OWFs and flew at turbine blade height; however, their overlap with the spherical 3-dimensional rotor swept volume was significantly lower than a random distribution. Although preliminary, these tracking data suggest a lack of a macro-scale (wind farm-scale) avoidance for L. fuscus but a potential meso-scale (within wind farm-scale) avoidance of turbines. Such data are therefore important in improving our understanding of the implications of OWFs for seabirds.","author":["Masden, E.","Thaxter, C.","Clark, N.","Burton, N.","Bouten, W.","Ross-Smith, V.","Conway, G.","Barber, L.","Clewley, G."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)","University of Amsterdam","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.041284000000","-3.190318000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1923","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/east-anglia-two-offshore-windfarm-scoping-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/wp-content\/ipc\/uploads\/projects\/EN010078\/EN010078-000059-EAN2%20-%20Scoping%20Report.pdf","title":"East Anglia TWO Offshore Windfarm Scoping Report","description":"This Scoping Report supports a request for a formal Scoping Opinion from the Planning Inspectorate in relation to the proposed East Anglia TWO offshore windfarm. This Scoping Report has been prepared in accordance with Regulation 10 of the Infrastructure Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2017 which enables an applicant to seek a Scoping Opinion from the Planning Inspectorate on the information to be included in an EIA.  This report presents an initial overview and description of the project and a review of the potential impacts associated with the construction, operation and eventual decommissioning of the proposed East Anglia TWO project. Project details presented are accurate at the time of writing. This report aims to identify the likely significant effects arising from the proposed East Anglia TWO project on the physical, human and biological environments and also outlines the approach to understanding baseline conditions and addressing environmental impacts through the EIA process.  The East Anglia TWO project will have an anticipated capacity of up to 900MW, which has the potential to provide 740,000 homes with power. At its nearest point, the East Anglia TWO windfarm site is 31km from shore. From the wind turbines electricity would flow via subsea inter-array cables to a number of offshore electrical platforms and then to the shore via export cables.  Offshore export cables will connect the proposed East Anglia TWO windfarm site to shore, making landfall in the vicinity of Sizewell and Thorpeness in Suffolk. From the landfall, cables will be routed underground to an onshore substation which will in turn connect into the main transmission network via a new transmission infrastructure owned and operated by National Grid connecting into the existing overhead pylons. In addition, there may be a requirement to upgrade the existing pylons to allow for connection to the transmission network. The location of the substation and National Grid infrastructure will be finalised in early 2018.  The EIA will be undertaken by experienced and well qualified technical specialists using industry best practice and following appropriate and relevant guidance. Key topics for investigation within the EIA are expected to be offshore ornithology, marine mammals, seascape, landscape and visual amenity, traffic and transport, onshore archaeology and noise.  This Scoping Report is the first stage of the EIA process, it outlines the receptors that will be considered during the EIA and the planned approach to data gathering and characterising the existing environment, assessing potential impacts and developing mitigation measures. A programme of consultation will be ongoing with stakeholders and communities throughout the EIA and DCO application process.","author":["ScottishPower Renewables"],"organization":["ScottishPower Renewables","ScottishPower Renewables"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.907778000000","2.628611000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Birds","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EAN2_Scoping_Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1924","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-underwater-noise-propagation-marine-hydrokinetic-power-devices-through-time","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.5039839","title":"Modeling underwater noise propagation from marine hydrokinetic power devices through a time-domain, velocity-pressure solution","description":"Marine hydrokinetic (MHK) devices generate electricity from the motion of tidal and ocean currents, as well as ocean waves, to provide an additional source of renewable energy available to the United States. These devices are a source of anthropogenic noise in the marine ecosystem and must meet regulatory guidelines that mandate a maximum amount of noise that may be generated. In the absence of measured levels from in situ deployments, a model for predicting the propagation of sound from an array of MHK sources in a real environment is essential. A set of coupled, linearized velocity-pressure equations in the time-domain are derived and presented in this paper, which are an alternative solution to the Helmholtz and wave equation methods traditionally employed. Discretizing these equations on a three-dimensional (3D), finite-difference grid ultimately permits a finite number of complex sources and spatially varying sound speeds, bathymetry, and bed composition. The solution to this system of equations has been parallelized in an acoustic-wave propagation package developed at Sandia National Labs, called Paracousti. This work presents the broadband sound pressure levels from a single source in two-dimensional (2D) ideal and Pekeris wave-guides and in a 3D domain with a sloping boundary. The paper concludes with demonstration of Paracousti for an array of MHK sources in a simple wave-guide.","author":["Roberts, J.","Johnson, E.","Johnson, C.","Preston, L.","Halfa, E.","Aldridge, D."],"organization":["Montana State University","DNV GL","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1925","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-effects-electromagnetic-field-emissions-marine-renewable-energy-devices","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X18302935","title":"Understanding the effects of electromagnetic field emissions from Marine Renewable Energy Devices (MREDs) on the commercially important edible crab, Cancer pagurus (L.)","description":"The effects of simulated electromagnetic fields (EMF), emitted from sub-sea power cables, on the commercially important decapod, edible crab (Cancer pagurus), were assessed. Stress related parameters were measured (l-Lactate, d-Glucose, Haemocyanin and respiration rate) along with behavioural and response parameters (antennular flicking, activity level, attraction\/avoidance, shelter preference and time spent resting\/roaming) during 24-h periods. Exposure to EMF had no effect on Haemocyanin concentrations, respiration rate, activity level or antennular flicking rate. EMF exposure significantly disrupted haemolymph l-Lactate and d-Glucose natural circadian rhythms. Crabs showed a clear attraction to EMF exposed shelter (69%) compared to control shelter (9%) and significantly reduced their time spent roaming by 21%. Consequently, EMF emitted from Marine Renewable Energy Devices (MREDs) will likely affect edible crabs both behaviourally and physiologically, suggesting that the impact of EMF on crustaceans must be considered when planning MREDs.","author":["Scott, K.","Harsanyi, P.","Lyndon, A."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1926","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predator-attack-rates-anti-predator-behavior-side-blotched-lizards-uta-stansburiana","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.herpconbio.org\/Volume_13\/Issue_1\/Keehn_Feldman_2018.pdf","title":"Predator attack rates and anti-predator behavior of side-blotched lizards (Uta stansburiana) at Southern California wind farms, USA","description":"The development of renewable wind energy farms changes land-use patterns at a landscape scale. Wind energy sites are characterized by high levels of anthropogenic disturbance (e.g., noise, roads, structures, etc.) that can facilitate the use of wind farms by some species, while fragmenting and degrading habitat for others. We lack an understanding of how these species-specific responses to changes in habitat quality will affect patterns of species interactions. Here, we test whether changes in habitat quality alter predator attack rates and anti-predator behavior in Side-blotched Lizards (Uta stansburiana) at wind farms relative to reference sites in the San Gorgonio Wind Resource Area (SGWRA) of Southern California, USA. We use clay models of Side-blotched Lizards to show that predator attack rates on these lizards appear lower at turbine sites (though total number of predation attempts precludes robust statistical analysis). We then use flight-initiation-distance (FID) trials to show that Side-blotched Lizards are also less wary to approaching predators at turbine sites. These data suggest that Side- blotched Lizards have responded to changes in predator community composition and abundance at disturbed wind farms by becoming less wary. Additional work is needed to better understand how other species will respond to changes in community structure at wind farm developments, and whether wind farm habitats are truly suitable for a wide variety of terrestrial taxa.","author":["Keehn, J.","Feldman, C."],"organization":["University of Nevada"],"originationDate":"2018-04-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.900000000000","-116.583333000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Reptiles","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Keehn_Feldman_2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1927","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/indirect-impacts-wind-farms-terrestrial-mammals-insights-disturbance-exclusion-effects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60351-3_5","title":"The Indirect Impacts of Wind Farms on Terrestrial Mammals: Insights from the Disturbance and Exclusion Effects on Wolves (Canis lupus)","description":"Due to the technical and functional characteristics of wind turbines, impact assessment studies have focused mainly on flying vertebrates. Nevertheless, evidence from the little available knowledge indicates potential impacts on large terrestrial mammals resulting from habitat fragmentation and increasing human disturbance. Over the last 15\u00a0years, more than 900 wind turbines were built inside the range of the Portuguese wolf. Due to the endangered status of this large carnivore in Portugal, several monitoring plans were conducted, resulting in a reasonable amount of information being collected on the effects of wind farms on wolves. We reviewed the methodological approaches, compiled major findings and summarised the mitigation\/compensation measures used in Portuguese wind farms. The overall outcomes show increasing human disturbance in wind farm areas, resulting in lower wolf reproduction rates during construction and the first years of operation, as well as shifts in denning site locations of more than 2.5\u00a0km away from the wind farm. These findings are of major concern in humanised landscapes, where suitable wolf breeding habitats are reduced. As precautionary measure, new wind farm projects should be restricted in areas that are closer than 2\u00a0km from known wolf denning locations.\n\nThis is a book chapter in Biodiversity and Wind Farms in Portugal: Current Knowledge and Insights for an Integrated Impact Assessment Process.","author":["Paula, J.","da Costa, G.","Petrucci-Fonseca, F.","\u00c1lvares, F."],"organization":["Bioinsight","University of Lisbon","University of Porto"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Habitat Change","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1928","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/burbo-bank-extension-offshore-wind-farm-red-throated-diver-displacement","sourceURL":"","title":"Burbo Bank Extension Offshore Wind Farm: Red-throated Diver Displacement","description":"This paper provides clarification on the Burbo Bank Extension ornithological impact assessment, specifically the information and analysis performed to determine the cumulative assessment of displacement of red-throated diver. Following representations made by Natural England (paragraphs 4.2.1 \u2013 4.2.5, 24 June 2013) and Natural Resources Wales (Annex 1, paragraphs 1.2.1 - 1.2.5, 24 June 2013), and as discussed at meetings held with these parties on the 3rd July 2013 and the 23 rd July 2013, the analysis presented in the Environmental Statement Volume 2 - Chapter 15: Offshore Ornithology (PINS document reference 5.1.2.15) and Habitats Regulations Assessment Report (PINS document reference 4.3) has been refined using an alternative red-throated diver data set provided by the Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC). This dataset had been derived by JNCC from data on the number and distribution of red-throated divers in Liverpool Bay SPA as determined using visual aerial survey methods which have been corrected for distance related detection errors. Bird observations were smoothed by JNCC using kernel density estimation (KDE) and were combined to create a mean modelled density surface of red-throated diver in Liverpool Bay SPA.  This Paper considers the implication of the predicted changes in red-throated diver density within Liverpool Bay SPA as a result of displacement from the offshore wind farm alone and in-combination with a number of wind farms in the Liverpool Bay SPA.","author":["Ward, R.","Ellis, I."],"organization":["NIRAS","Dong Energy"],"originationDate":"2013-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.446405500000","-3.234504300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Burbo-Bank-Extension-Red-Throated-Diver-Displacement.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1929","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/burbo-bank-extension-offshore-wind-farm-environmental-impact-assessment-scoping-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/infrastructure.planninginspectorate.gov.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2010\/08\/Burbo-Bank-scoping-opinion.pdf","title":"Burbo Bank Extension Offshore Wind Farm: Environmental Impact Assessment Scoping Report","description":"DONG Energy is proposing to develop an extension to the existing and operational Burbo Bank offshore wind farm in Liverpool Bay, located 7 to 8.5 km off the North Wirral and Sefton coasts.  DONG Energy specialises in developing projects for the generation of electricity from renewable sources like offshore wind farms, and intends to submit an application for a Development Consent Order (DCO) to the Infrastructure Planning Commission (IPC) to develop an extension to the operational Burbo Bank offshore wind farm, which is to be known as Burbo Bank Extension offshore wind farm. The DCO will also contain proposals for associated development, such as onshore underground cables and an onshore substation, away from the offshore wind farm site which is deemed necessary for the construction and operation of the project.  The DCO application will comprise full details of the development proposals and will be accompanied by an Environmental Statement (ES) (conforming to the Infrastructure Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2009) and other documents, including a statement on pre-application consultation.  This Scoping Report sets out the proposed content, methodologies and key issues to be included in the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and the resulting ES to be submitted with the DCO application. The purpose of this document is to support a request for a scoping opinion for an EIA from the IPC. It is also intended that this report builds upon consultation carried out to date and supports ongoing consultation with statutory and non-statutory consultees and stakeholders on the scope of the EIA required for the Burbo Bank Extension offshore wind farm.  The Scoping Report is structured in sections relating to principal topic areas, providing an overview of the project, the developer, and the assessment and consents process by way of an introduction section (Chapter 1), a description of the project (Chapter 2), the scoping of environmental offshore and onshore impacts with summary tables of potential impacts (Chapter 3), and finally an overview of the consultation process and the probable dates of the various steps leading to the grant of the DCO and subsequent construction and operation (Chapter 4).  Within Chapter 3 (Scoping of Environmental Impacts), specific topics are arranged within categories of physical, biological, human offshore environments and onshore environments. Each of these subsections presents a description of baseline conditions from field and survey work followed by an assessment of potential impacts and the studies and surveys proposed to address these within the EIA.","author":["S\u00f8rensen, T.","Giammichele, F.","Barberis-Negra, N.","Marshall, E.","Walsh, T.","Hui, S.","Liingaard, M.","Brack, J."],"organization":["Dong Energy"],"originationDate":"2010-07-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.446405500000","-3.234504300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Burbo-Bank-Extension-EIA-Scoping-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1930","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/port-elizabeth-wind-energy-facility-avifaunal-bat-impact-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.the-eis.com\/data\/literature\/FEIR%20App%20H_avifauna%20and%20bat%20SS%20report_EWT_Jul2010.pdf","title":"Port Elizabeth Wind Energy Facility Avifaunal and Bat Impact Assessment","description":"The proposed wind farm will consist of ten wind turbines (with a power generation potential of 2.3MW each), appropriately spaced over the site, as well as the associated infrastructure for connection onto the existing power grid, and access for maintenance purposes, as required for the particular site selected. Each turbine will have a tower height of 80 meters, and a rotor diameter of 85 meters (total height is therefore 122.5 meters). Phase 1 of the proposed development will have a total power generation potential of 20MW, with possible future expansion to 40MW (by the addition of more turbines), depending on the area limitations of the site.\n\nThe three site alternatives (Figure 5) have been selected for their suitability with regard to wind, topography and conservation status, and will be examined in more detail in this report.\n\nThe proposed development falls within three quarter degree squares, namely 3325CC, 3325CD and 3325DC and the number of bird species recorded in these squares by the South African Bird Atlas Project (SABAP) range from 272 to 325 species. Of these species 36 are Red List species, with two classified as Endangered, 10 classified as Vulnerable and 24 classified as Near-threatened. One bird species is protected internationally under the Bonn Convention.\n\nThe proposed development can be built with acceptable impact on avifauna should the recommendations regarding site selection in this report be followed.\n\nThe Bushy Park site is the most preferred site alternative from an avifaunal perspective and the Driftsands site is least preferred. The Driftsands site should be discarded as an alternative from an avifaunal perspective.\n\nWith regards to bats, the Van Staden site is the most preferred site alternative with Bushy Park and Driftsands being least preferred.\n\nIn particular the following important points must be stressed:\nA Site specific EMP is strongly recommended to site the turbines correctly as well as to deal with the details of the associated infrastructure that was not provided at this stage of the process.\nA monitoring program is seen as critical in extending our knowledge of wind energy and avifaunal and bat interactions. Since this could be the first commercial wind energy facility in South Africa, it is recommended that a monitoring program be planned to collect data on a host of environmental factors, including avifaunal collisions and bat fatalities.\nTurbines must be painted as detailed in this report to mitigate for collision of bird species.\nIf possible the wind turbines must be shut down in extreme wind and extreme low visibility events such as thick cloud or mist.\nIf possible the wind turbines should be shut down in low-wind conditions at night when the bats are foraging.\nThe wind energy facility should not be lit, if this is not feasible the lights must only be red strobe lights and lights that do not attract insects.\nThe use of a radar to alert bats to the presence of wind turbines is strongly encouraged.\n\nIt must also be stressed that with wind energy and avifaunal interactions the cumulative impacts of multiple developments could be important. It is recommended that a national or at least municipal strategic study be undertaken to address this issue.","author":["Smallie, J.","Strugnell, L.","Patterson-Abrolat, C."],"organization":["Endangered Wildlife Trust"],"originationDate":"2009-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-33.961848800000","25.246002600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Strugnell-et-al-2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1931","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/management-acoustic-metadata-bioacoustics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954115001983","title":"Management of Acoustic Metadata for Bioacoustics","description":"Recent expansion in the capabilities of passive acoustic monitoring of sound-producing animals is providing expansive data sets in many locations. These long-term data sets will allow the investigation of questions related to the ecology of sound-producing animals on time scales ranging from diel and seasonal to inter-annual and decadal. Analyses of these data often span multiple analysts from various research groups over several years of effort and, as a consequence, have begun to generate large amounts of scattered acoustic metadata. It has therefore become imperative to standardize the types of metadata being generated. A critical aspect of being able to learn from such large and varied acoustic data sets is providing consistent and transparent access that can enable the integration of various analysis efforts. This is juxtaposed with the need to include new information for specific research questions that evolve over time. Hence, a method is proposed for organizing acoustic metadata that addresses many of the problems associated with the retention of metadata from large passive acoustic data sets.\n\nA structure was developed for organizing acoustic metadata in a consistent manner, specifying required and optional terms to describe acoustic information derived from a recording. A client-server database was created to implement this data representation as a networked data service that can be accessed from several programming languages. Support for data import from a wide variety of sources such as spreadsheets and databases is provided. The implementation was extended to access Internet-available data products, permitting access to a variety of environmental information types (e.g. sea surface temperature, sunrise\/sunset, etc.) from a wide range of sources as if they were part of the data service. This metadata service is in use at several institutions and has been used to track and analyze millions of acoustic detections from marine mammals, fish, elephants, and anthropogenic sound sources.","author":["Risch, D.","Van Parijs, S.","Roch, M.","Hildebrand, J.","Fujioka, E.","Soldevilla, M.","Batchelor, H.","Baumann-Pickering, S.","Berchok, C.","Cholewiak, D.","Garland, E.","Herbert, S.","Oleson, E.","\u0160irovi\u0107, A."],"organization":["San Diego State University","Scripps Institution of Oceanography","National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)","Duke University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Roch-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1932","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/using-coupled-hydrodynamic-biogeochemical-models-predict-effects-tidal-turbine-arrays","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2077-1312\/6\/2\/58","title":"Using Coupled Hydrodynamic Biogeochemical Models to Predict the Effects of Tidal Turbine Arrays on Phytoplankton Dynamics","description":"The effects of large scale tidal energy device (TED) arrays on phytoplankton processes owing to the changes in hydrodynamic flows are unknown. Coupled two-dimensional biogeochemical and hydrodynamic models offer the opportunity to predict potential effects of large scale TED arrays on the local and regional phytoplankton dynamics in coastal and inshore environments. Using MIKE 21 Software by DHI, coupled two-dimensional biogeochemical and hydrodynamic models were developed with simulations including no turbines or an array of 55 turbines with four solar radiation scenarios to assess the temporal and spatial changes of phytoplankton dynamics in an idealised domain. Results suggest that the effect of TEDs on phytoplankton dynamics accounted for up to 25% of the variability in phytoplankton concentrations, most likely associated with an increased residence time in an inshore basin. However, natural variation, such as the intensity of photosynthetically active radiation, had a larger effect on phytoplankton dynamics than an array of TEDs.","author":["Els\u00e4\u00dfer, B.","Savidge, G.","Pritchard, D.","Kregting, L.","Schuchert, P."],"organization":["Agri-Food and Biosciences Institute Northern Ireland","Queen\u0027s University Belfast","University of Otago","New Zealand Ministry for Primary Industries (MPI)","Danish Hydraulic Institute (DHI)"],"originationDate":"2018-05-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2025-02-04 12:04:33","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Schuchert-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1933","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/governance-barriers-sustainable-energy-transitions-assessing-irelands-capacity-towards","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421517307668","title":"Governance barriers to sustainable energy transitions - Assessing Ireland\u0027s capacity towards marine energy futures","description":"Marine energies (ME), including offshore hydcrocarbons along with marine renewable energies (MRE), such as offshore wind, wave and tidal energy, are increasingly important in the future energy mix of many nations. We observe that ME governance is complex, as development offshore involves engagement and may often result in conflict.\n\nThis paper examines the Irish case, where offshore gas and oil remain relatively undeveloped, and yet have provoked extensive controversy. Moreover, Ireland exhibits very ambitious plans for MRE developments. Against a background, where ME development seems to have stalled, the objective of the paper is to analyse the Irish governance setup and its capacity to deliver ME and whether the current system is equipped to enable transition to MREs. Current governance systems lack efficacy in terms of policy integration and enforcement, government oversight, and public trust due to past failures. Although, management approaches have been developed to address some of the barriers, domains such as policy\/regulation, industry development and public engagement are disconnected.\n\nResults presented may not simply be generalised, as each country context is different. An analysis of examples with similar issues must focus on studying the context of the governance setup and balances of power across domains.","author":["O\u0027Hagan, A.","Lange, M.","Devoy, R.","Tissier, M.","Cummins, V."],"organization":["University College Cork","Helmholtz-Zentrum Hereon"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.994650200000","-9.607514600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lange-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1934","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/2018-state-sector-report-marine-renewable-energy-canada","sourceURL":"https:\/\/marinerenewables.ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2018\/06\/MRC-State-of-the-Sector-2018.pdf","title":"2018 State of the Sector Report: Marine Renewable Energy in Canada","description":"Marine renewable energy (MRE) from waves, tides and river currents has been harnessed for centuries \u2013 powering mills, transporting nutrient-rich sediment, moving vessels, supporting marine life migration \u2013 but only over the past few decades has it become more of a focus for its vast untapped reserve of power. Seventy-one per cent of the Earth\u2019s surface is composed of moving water, all containing energy that can be converted to electricity.\n\nTheoretical estimates for global MRE potential indicate resources exceeding 100,000 terawatt hours (TWh) of electricity, equal to the power needs of over 8 billion Canadian households 1 \u2013 more than the current power demands of the entire planet.\n\nCanada continues to deepen its exploration of MRE as a potential solution to clean energy, greenhouse gas emission (GHG) reduction, and economic growth targets.\n\nGiven the country\u2019s natural resource assets as well as existing expertise in the marine sector, ocean waves, wind, tides, salinity, temperature differences and river currents can all contribute to Canada\u2019s clean energy bottom line. Canada has an estimated 35,700 megawatts (MW) of tidal energy potential, enough clean power to displace over 113 million tonnes of CO2 (equal to removing over 24 million cars off the road). Adding wave and river, the potential climbs to 340 gigawatts, enough energy to power every home in Canada five times over. The country\u2019s offshore wind energy potential is still being mapped, but projected to be larger still.\n\nThe opportunity includes both large-scale transmission projects and small, distributed community generation. Over 300 companies have already found work in the Bay of Fundy\u2019s emerging tidal stream sector. A total of 251 remote Canadian communities rely on their own fossil fuel plants; 176 of them are fueled by imported diesel. Canada is now demonstrating river current technologies that offer remote communities a solution that can be cost competitive, avoid emissions, and create jobs.","author":["Marine Renewables Canada"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Canada"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRC-State-of-the-Sector-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1935","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/literature-review-evidence-based-field-study-effects-high-voltage-transmission-lines","sourceURL":"","title":"Literature review and evidence based field study on the  effects of high voltage transmission lines on birds","description":"Wild birds and their habitats are an important part of the natural environment. Over 450 birds have been recorded in Ireland. Ireland is important for migrating birds with large numbers of birds such as waterfowl and waders spending the winter in Ireland. Summer migrants such as swallows and terns are also a feature of Ireland\u2019s bird life.  This report is an independent, evidence-based study undertaken by experts in bird ecology. The research examines the effects of existing high voltage transmission projects at a number of sites on bird activity and behaviour.  The purpose of this study has been:    To determine the effects of existing high voltage transmission infrastructure on bird activity in Ireland  To provide a factual basis for the development of bird specific recommendations and guidelines for electricity transmission projects   The routing of transmission projects is a complex process. It requires a balance between a number of issues, including EirGrid\u2019s obligations to ensure a safe and secure transmission grid, land use constraints, cost, engineering and other technical requirements. Impacts on the natural environment must also be considered. Transmission lines have the potential to impact on birds and routing of new lines must take this into account.  This study included a literature review of existing information and a field survey at sites around Ireland. The aim of the study is to find out if, and how, transmission powerlines affect birds in Ireland.  Published information from around the world has shown that certain birds are more at risk of collision with transmission lines than others. Large species such as swans, geese, and cranes are most at risk. Bird species considered \u2018poor fliers\u2019 such as grouse, pheasant, and rails are also at risk of collision. Certain factors such as time spent in flight, territorial displays, foraging flights or night flights can increase collision risk for birds including waders and raptors where overhead lines are present. Local conditions such as landscape and weather conditions can also influence the risk of collision.  The thin wire at the top of powerlines is widely reported as the main cause of bird collisions. Collisions with powerlines are considered to be rare events. Most studies conclude that mortality from collisions is unlikely to affect bird populations. However, where rare or protected species occur, impacts could be significant.  Measures to reduce bird collisions include careful line route assessments and the marking of lines to make them more visible to birds. Research shows positive results from marking lines, with reductions in bird deaths of 50% or more. The location for marked sections of transmission line is determined by survey and analysis of bird movements. Monitoring the effectiveness of the line marking is recommended.  The risk of electrocution on the transmission system is low. This is due to the wide spacing between live elements on the transmission lines and support structures.  The possible impacts of transmission line construction and electromagnetic fields (EMFs) are also investigated. Construction activities may cause temporary disturbance or permanent displacement to birds.  An important part of this study included a survey of collision risk. This involved a widespread field study in 2012\/2013. This study examined a number of high risk sit es (5) for birds, and a sample of low risk (54) or control sites on the existing transmission system. Searches for dead birds were carried out at all sites.  A targeted survey was undertaken in 2014 at three high risk sites. This survey also collected information on flight activity of target species. Target species included swans, geese, ducks, gulls, herons, raptors, waders, and cormorant.  Results of the surveys were broadly in line with collision estimates published in the scientific literature. Results from high risk sites showed estimated collision rates of 0 to 179 birds per kilometre per year. This result does not take account of possible bias such as scavenger removal of dead birds by fox for example. The species recorded most frequently as collision victims at high and low risk sites included crow and pigeon species. Small numbers of gulls, waders, ducks, and passerines were also recorded. Grey Heron was recorded at wetland sites.  The flight activity survey provided new information on bird responses to transmission lines. No collisions were observed, however some avoidance behaviour was noted. At all sites, the majority of birds flew above the powerlines. The exception was at the 400 kV site (with the tallest pylons), where a third of all birds flew beneath the wires. Very few birds crossed powerlines at or near to pylons.  This study provides data and results which will inform the development of bird specific recommendations and guidelines for transmission projects in Ireland. The preparation of guidelines will ensure a consistent approach to ecology, including birds, at all stages of the development of transmission projects.","author":["RPS group"],"organization":["RPS group"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EirGrid-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1936","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/study-risk-collision-power-lines-waterbirds-winter-shotton-steel-works-north-wales","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bto.org\/file\/335699\/download?token=4ZGS8IAw","title":"A Study of the Risk of Collision with Power Lines by Waterbirds in Winter at Shotton Steel Works, North Wales","description":"The aim was to investigate the impact of power lines at Shotton (North Wales) on waterbirds wintering on the lagoons and on birds crossing the power lines to reach nearby habitats.\nSystematic observations were made of all waterbirds attempting to cross the power lines. Their direction and height of flight, together with weather variables were recorded. Surveys were also made of the ground beneath the power lines in order to look for casualties.\nIn total, 3,957 birds were observed crossing the wires. Wildfowl and Gulls were the most frequently recorded groups of species. Frequency of crossings peaked in September for all species groups except Gulls which peaked in mid-winter. Gulls, Wildfowl, Cormorants and Herons tended to cross in smaller groups than Waders. Half the observations involved birds flying straight over the power lines and making no use of the lagoons.\nThe main directions of travel were related to the birds\u0027 feeding and roosting areas. The majority of birds of all groups crossed the power lines above the top earth wire, and only a small proportion were recorded flying either through or beneath the power cables. Up to 3.8% of birds came within 1 m of the cables. The spans to the north-west of the lagoons were crossed most frequently.\nOne Mallard wing was found beneath the power lines but it was not known if this was a collision casualty or not. One Mute Swan was seen to strike the power lines and fall but survived and one diverted at a late stage, this represents 14% of the species seen to cross. In general, mortality rate of waterbirds due to collisions with wires was considered to be low.\nThe impact of the power lines on the mortality rate of waterbirds at Shotton is discussed.","author":["Balmer, D.","Clark, N.","Henderson, I."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)"],"originationDate":"1995-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.227182800000","-3.058672200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Balmer-et-al-1995.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1937","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/estimator-wildlife-fatality-observed-carcasses","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/env.1052","title":"An estimator of wildlife fatality from observed carcasses","description":"Counts of animal carcasses are often used to estimate fatality caused by disease, environmental accidents (oil spills, radiation leaks), or human structures (power lines, sky scrapers, wind turbines). The need to adjust raw carcass counts for imperfect detectability to produce unbiased estimates of fatality has long been recognized, but the accuracy and precision of some estimators used to make the adjustments have not been evaluated. In this paper, I formalize a conceptual model of fatality and the factors that lead to imperfect detection, primarily removal by scavengers before searches can be carried out and inability of searchers to find all remaining carcasses. I propose an estimator of fatality that adjusts for imperfect detectability. Through simulation I evaluate the statistical properties (bias and precision) of this estimator and two others commonly used to estimate fatality at wind power facilities, when sources and magnitudes of imperfect detectability vary. None of the estimators was always unbiased under all conditions. Bias in the proposed estimator never exceeded \u00b127% whereas bias in the other two estimators was always negative and exceeded that of the proposed estimator in 98% and 93% of the simulated conditions, respectively. The proposed estimator was relatively robust to variation in sources and magnitudes of imperfect detectability, but was sensitive to distributional assumptions regarding carcass removal rates and searcher efficiency. It offers significant improvement over two current estimators and provides relatively unbiased estimates of fatality that can be applied under a variety of conditions and survey protocols.","author":["Huso, M."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2011-04-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1938","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-iwg-wind-turbines-bat-populations-2018","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.eurobats.org\/node\/874","title":"Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2018","description":"Sub-group topics:    Update\/reorganizing of the list of references  Compilation of data on bat mortality per country  Updating of tables on monitoring studies done in Europe and on bats \u0301 behaviour in relation to windfarms  Mitigation and compensation measures  Estimation of mortality rate taking into consideration predation, efficiency and controlled area; choose of best estimator for Europe  Impact of mortality rate on populations  Deterrents, technical mitigation systems and automated monitoring systems  Maximum foraging distances of species  Collect national guidelines  Use of dogs vs humans during carcass searches  Comparing measurement of activity at ground level and rotor height  Small Wind Turbines  Offshore windfarms  Wind farms and forests  Implementation of mitigation and post-construction monitoring  200m buffer distance to habitats particularly important for bats  Sensitivity maps   Past Reports include:    Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2012  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2013  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2014  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2015  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2016  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2017","author":["Rodrigues, L."],"organization":["EUROBATS"],"originationDate":"2018-05-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Eurobats-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1939","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-iwg-wind-turbines-bat-populations-2017","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.eurobats.org\/sites\/default\/files\/documents\/pdf\/Advisory_Committee\/Report_IWG_Wind_Turbines.pdf","title":"Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2017","description":"Sub-group topics:    Update\/reorganizing of the list of references  Compilation of data on bat mortality per country  Updating of tables on monitoring studies done in Europe and on bats \u0301 behaviour in relation to windfarms  Mitigation and compensation measures  Estimation of mortality rate taking into consideration predation, efficiency and controlled area; choose of best estimator for Europe  Impact of mortality rate on populations  Deterrents  Maximum foraging distances of species and Detectability coefficients to compare activity indices  Collect national guidelines  Use of dogs vs humans during carcass searches  Comparing measurement of activity at ground level and rotor height  Small Wind Turbines  Offshore windfarms  Wind farms and forests  Implementation of mitigation and post-construction monitoring  200m buffer distance to habitats particularly important for bats  Sensitivity maps   Past Reports include:    Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2012  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2013  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2014  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2015  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2016","author":["Rodrigues, L."],"organization":["EUROBATS"],"originationDate":"2017-03-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Eurobats-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1940","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-iwg-wind-turbines-bat-populations-2016","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.eurobats.org\/sites\/default\/files\/documents\/pdf\/Advisory_Committee\/Doc.AC21.8_ReportIWGTurbines.pdf","title":"Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2016","description":"Sub-group topics:    Update\/reorganizing of the list of references  Compilation of data on bat mortality per country  Updating of tables on monitoring studies done in Europe and on bats \u0301 behaviour in relation to windfarms  Mitigation and compensation measures  Estimation of mortality rate taking into consideration predation, efficiency and controlled area; choose of best estimator for Europe  Impact of mortality rate on populations  Deterrents  Maximum foraging distances of species and Detectability coefficients to compare activity indices  Collect national guidelines  Use of dogs vs humans during carcass searches  Comparing measurement of activity at ground level and rotor height  Small Wind Turbines  Offshore windfarms  Wind farms and forests  Implementation of mitigation and post-construction monitoring  200m buffer distance to habitats particularly important for bats   Past Reports include:    Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2012  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2013  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2014  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2015","author":["Rodrigues, L."],"organization":["EUROBATS"],"originationDate":"2016-04-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Eurobats-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1941","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-iwg-wind-turbines-bat-populations-2015","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.eurobats.org\/sites\/default\/files\/documents\/pdf\/Advisory_Committee\/Doc.AC_.20.5.ReportIWGWindTurbines_0.pdf","title":"Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2015","description":"Sub-group topics:    Update\/reorganizing of the list of references  Compilation of data on bat mortality per country  Updating of tables on monitoring studies done in Europe and on bats \u0301 behaviour in relation to windfarms  Mitigation and compensation measures  Estimation of mortality rate taking into consideration predation, efficiency and controlled area; choose of best estimator for Europe  Impact of mortality rate on populations  Deterrents  Maximum foraging distances of species and Detectability coefficients to compare activity indices  Collect national guidelines (including information on feathering\/stopping WTs)  Use of dogs vs humans during carcass searches  Comparing measurement of activity at ground level and rotor height  Small Wind Turbines  Offshore windfarms  Wind farms and forests   Past Reports include:    Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2012  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2013  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2014","author":["Rodrigues, L."],"organization":["EUROBATS"],"originationDate":"2015-03-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EUROBATS-2015.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Eurobats-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1942","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/report-iwg-wind-turbines-bat-populations-2014","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.eurobats.org\/sites\/default\/files\/documents\/pdf\/Advisory_Committee\/Doc_StC9_AC19_12_ReportIWG_WindTurbines%20incl_Annexes.pdf","title":"Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2014","description":"Sub-group topics:    Update\/reorganizing of the list of references  Compilation of data on bat mortality per country  Updating of tables on monitoring studies done in Europe  Mitigation and compensation measures  Estimation of mortality rate taking into consideration predation, efficiency and controlled area; choose of best estimator for Europe  Impact of mortality rate on populations  Deterrents  Maximum foraging distances of species and Detectability coefficients to compare activity indices  Collect national guidelines (including information on feathering\/stopping WTs)  Use of dogs vs humans during carcass searches  Comparing measurement of activity at ground level and rotor height  Small Wind Turbines  Offshore windfarms  Update of guidelines   Past Reports include:    Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2012  Report of the IWG on Wind Turbines and Bat Populations 2013","author":["Rodrigues, L."],"organization":["EUROBATS"],"originationDate":"2014-04-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Eurobats-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1943","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/integration-passive-acoustic-monitoring-data-obis-seamap-global-biogeographic-database","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954113001258","title":"Integration of passive acoustic monitoring data into OBIS-SEAMAP, a global biogeographic database, to advance spatially-explicit ecological assessments","description":"We successfully developed an extension of the OBIS-SEAMAP database, a global biogeographic database specializing in marine mammals, seabirds and sea turtles, to integrate passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) data with other commonly collected data types (i.e. line-transect visual sightings, animal telemetry, and photo-identification). As part of this effort, we made significant improvements in mapping and visualization tools for PAM data, including spatially and temporally interactive summary statistics, diel plots, temporal effort representation, and the unique rendering of PAM data to distinguish them from other data types. In this paper, we summarize technical challenges we overcame, report the methodologies and implementation of the integration, and conduct case studies using visual sightings and PAM data from bowhead whales and Risso\u0027s dolphins to demonstrate how the integrated database facilitates in-depth ecological assessments that form the foundation for spatially-explicit conservation efforts.","author":["Halpin, P.","Read, A.","Fujioka, E.","Soldevilla, M."],"organization":["Duke University","National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)"],"originationDate":"2014-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Marine Mammals","Reptiles","Sea Turtles"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-30 08:08:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1944","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/collaboration-innovation-challenges-faced-ocean-energy-sector-possible-solutions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mria.ie\/site\/assets\/files\/1016\/mria_paper_on_collaboration_and_innovation.pdf","title":"Collaboration and Innovation Challenges faced by the Ocean Energy Sector and Possible Solutions","description":"This Paper was prepared and published by the Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA) with the generous support of the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland. The MRIA represents the marine renewables emerging technologies on the island of Ireland, although this Paper focuses on wave and tidal energy (\u2018ocean energy\u2019). This is the tenth annual Paper published by the Association about policy topics relevant to marine renewables.  The jobs and income potential of ocean energy globally is well documented (see recent MRIA Papers at www.mria.ie for detail on this) and Ireland is uniquely qualified to exploit this given our abundant wave resource off the West coast (and a significant tidal resource in Northern Ireland) as well as our significant R\u0026amp;D facilities and supportive Government policies, although the ongoing saga of the new consenting regime to be set out in the Maritime Area and Foresh ore (Amendment) Bill is an issue. Of wider concern is the small scale of almost all ocean energy companies - Ireland is home to about 9% of the global population at present - and their failure to collaborate on R\u0026amp;D. Ocean energy companies are unique \u2013 small, with limited financial resources and yet engaged in capital intensive innovation on the frontiers of man\u2019s knowledge. They have been quite effective in advancing our knowledge of how to convert the kinetic energy contained in waves and tides into electricity. They could do more with greater intercompany collaboration and with tailored company development support from the agency with experience and expertise in ocean energy, Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI).  This Paper deals with these issues and sets out the research and industry views which led to the actions recommended. The recommendations boil down to giving SEAI the remit, under a special protocol with Enterprise Ireland, to provide company development support to ocean energy firms in their early years. The recommendations, if implemented, could make the difference between Ireland playing a lead role in this potentially huge industry of tomorrow and being an \u2018also ran\u2019 in the one field where we have a natural resource of scale.","author":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"organization":["Marine Renewables Industry Association (MRIA)"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MRIA-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1945","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/automated-monitoring-birds-flight-proof-concept-eagles-wind-power-facility","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320717319407","title":"Automated monitoring for birds in flight: Proof of concept with eagles at a wind power facility","description":"Automated surveys for wildlife have the potential to improve data collection while averting mortality of animals. Collisions of eagles at wind power facilities are particularly of concern and therefore an automated system that could detect birds, determine if they are eagles, and track their movement, might aid in curtailing wind turbines before collisions occur. Here, we use human observers and photographs to test the ability of a camera-based monitoring system, called IdentiFlight, to detect, classify, and track birds. IdentiFlight detected 96% of the bird flights detected by observers and detected 562% more birds than did observers. The discrepancy between observers and IdentiFlight seemed to be because the ability of observers to detect birds declined sharply by distance and toward the west. We reviewed photographs taken by IdentiFlight and determined that IdentiFlight misclassified nine of 149 eagles as non-eagles for a false negative rate of 6%, and 287 of 1013 non-eagles as eagles for a false positive rate of 28%. The median distance at classification for birds classified as eagles was 793\u202fm and the median time from detection till classification was 0.4\u202fs. Collectively, our results suggest that automated cameras can be effective means of detecting birds in flight and identifying eagles.","author":["Allison, T.","McClure, C.","Marinson, L."],"organization":["The Peregrine Fund","Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)"],"originationDate":"2018-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.907237700000","-105.781123300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/McClure-et-al-2018.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/McClure-et-al-2018_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1946","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-motion-wave-power-generation-water-tank-test","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=2655670","title":"Assessment of the Motion of Wave Power Generation by Water Tank Test","description":"Installing devices of marine renewable energy is planned off Kamaishi city, Iwate prefecture, Japan. A device of wave power generation was settled at this site as a test case. It is important to coexist the power generation device and local fishermen. Since Kamaishi is known as a good fishing area, acceptance of fishermen is required to run the wave power generation at the test site. Especially, local fishermen in Kamaishi have a concern about how wave power generation moves along with ocean waves and currents. To acquire an acceptance from local fishermen in terms of setting wave power generation, a model test was conducted to understand the device of wave power generation. It consists of float, spar, middle float, gimbal mechanism and anchor. Middle float, gimbal mechanism and anchor are mooring. The submerged weights of the model almost satisfy the targeted values calculated by the scale ratio and actual submerged weights. The experiment was conducted for 1\/125 scale model at a water tank in marine environmental and ecosystem laboratory, the university of Tokyo. We monitored the motion of the model under several conditions of regular waves and currents. The motions of the model were recorded by a video camera and were analyzed. The model was moved with respect to the surface waves and currents. We assessed the motions of the float based on the experiment. The experimental results will be used to explain local fishermen.","author":["Kitazawa, D.","Mizukami, Y.","Yoshida, T."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2017-06-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.225000000000","141.996000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1947","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/observing-fish-using-underwater-camera-test-site-installing-ocean-power-generation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=2655671","title":"Observing Fish Using Underwater Camera at the Test Site before Installing Ocean Power Generation","description":"Assessment of local ocean environment is significant when devices of marine renewable energy are installed at a demonstration site. A concern about how these devices affect the existence of fish is remained among local fishermen. To confirm variation of fish before and after installing the devices of marine renewable energy, we investigated fish using an underwater camera before installation as a main objective of this paper. First, fish-eye video camera was tested to monitor in a fish cage off Kamaishi city, Iwate prefecture, Japan. We aimed to observe the abundance of fish and to specify the species of fish. The fish-eye video camera is composed of a dome-shaped lens, a container, and a digital video equipped into the container. The recorded video showed outlines of fish, consequently it may be possible to know the abundance of fish. However, specifying the species of fish has a difficulty if we use fish-eye camera since the recorded image is unclear enough to identify correctly. In addition, we examined horizontal transparency of fish-eye camera using a fish-shaped target. Before recording by the video camera, vertical transparency was measured using a white plate. Then we recorded the images by varying the water depth and the distance between the camera and target. When the target was close to the camera, it can be displayed clearly, nevertheless the outline of the target was smeared with increasing the distances between them. Our measurement suggested that the horizontal transparency might be relating to the parameters of water depth and vertical transparency. The investigation was conducted under the one condition, thus we need to obtain further data to understand horizontal transparency qualitatively. Next time, we will conduct another test using additional underwater optical video camera, which is attached on the fish-eye video camera. The combination of these two types of video cameras may enable to observe the abundance of fish as well as to specify the species of fish.","author":["Kitazawa, D.","Mizukami, Y.","Yoshida, T."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2017-06-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.258712500000","141.907482400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1948","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-marine-ecosystem-acoustic-diversity-across-ocean-basins","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954113001167","title":"Assessing Marine Ecosystem Acoustic Diversity Across Ocean Basins","description":"Concurrent with the elevation of the concern over the state of sound in the ocean, advances in terrestrial acoustic monitoring techniques have produced concepts and tools that may be applicable to the underwater world. Several index values that convey information related to acoustic diversity with a single numeric measurement made from acoustic recordings have been proposed for rapidly assessing community biodiversity. Here we apply the acoustic biodiversity index method to low frequency recordings made from three different ocean basins to assess its appropriateness for characterizing species richness in the marine environment. Initial results indicated that raw acoustic entropy (H) values did not correspond to biological patterns identified from individual signal detections and classification. Noise from seismic airgun activity masked the weaker biological signals and confounded the entropy calculation. A simple background removal technique that subtracted an average complex spectrum characteristic of seismic exploration signals from the average spectra of each analysis period that contained seismic signals was applied to compensate for salient seismic airgun signals present in all locations. The noise compensated (HN) entropy index was more reflective of biological patterns and holds promise for the use of rapid acoustic biodiversity in the marine environment as an indicator of habitat biodiversity and health.","author":["Denes, S.","Miksis-Olds, J.","Parks, S."],"organization":["Pennsylvania State University"],"originationDate":"2014-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["19.300000000000","166.600000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1949","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-cross-platform-performance-marine-mammal-indicators-between-two-collocated","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.library.oregonstate.edu\/concern\/articles\/sx61dp068","title":"Assessing the Cross Platform Performance of Marine Mammal Indicators Between Two Collocated Acoustic Recorders","description":"Equipment and deployment strategies for remote passive acoustic sensing of marine environments must balance memory capacity, power requirements, sampling rate, duty-cycle, deployment duration, instrument size, and environmental concerns. The impact of different parameters on the data and applicability of the data to the specific questions being asked should be considered before deployment. Here we explore the effect of recording and detection parameters on marine mammal acoustic data across two platforms. Daily classifications of marine mammal vocalizations from two passive acoustic monitors with different subsampling parameters, an AURAL and a Passive Aquatic Listener (PAL), collocated in the Bering Sea were compared. The AURAL subsampled on a pre-set schedule, whereas the PAL sampled via an adaptive protocol. Detected signals of interest were manually classified in each dataset independently. The daily classification rates of vocalizations were similar. Detections from the higher duty-cycle but lower sample rate AURAL were limited to species and vocalizations with energy below 4 kHz precluding detection of echolocation signals. Temporal coverage from the PAL audio files was limited by the adaptive sub-sampling protocol. A method for classifying ribbon (Histriophoca fasciata) and bearded seal (Erignathus barbatus) vocalizations from the sparse spectral time histories of the PAL was developed. Although application of the acoustic entropy as a rapid assessment of biodiversity was not reflective of the number of species detected, acoustic entropy was robust to changes in sample rate and window length.","author":["Nystuen, J.","Denes, S.","Miksis-Olds, J.","Mellinger, D."],"organization":["Pennsylvania State University","Oregon State University (OSU)","University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2014-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Denes-et-al-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1950","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/photography-low-impact-method-survey-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1616504714001219","title":"Photography as a Low-Impact Method to Survey Bats","description":"Bats are mammals of chief conservation concern and also represent potentially powerful bio-indicators. Surveying bats is thus an important task but the approaches adopted may either be too invasive (capture) or prone to identification errors (acoustic methods). We here report on the use of a photographic trap to survey bat species richness we tested at two drinking sites in central Italy. The species richness we estimated was similar to that obtained by a previous mist-netting effort at the same sites. We also photographed species often overlooked in acoustic surveys due to their faint echolocation calls. From the photographs we could frequently identify sex, reproductive status, age class and individual marks. Given the relative non-invasiveness of this approach, we strongly recommend it in lieu of capture at sensitive sites or to complement acoustic surveys in order to improve identification rates.","author":["Russo, D.","Rydell, J."],"organization":["Lund University","University of Naples Federico II","University of Bristol"],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.800000000000","13.766700000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1951","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-multi-criteria-decision-analysis-smcda-toolbox-consensus-based-siting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/brage.bibsys.no\/xmlui\/handle\/11250\/2478678","title":"Spatial Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (SMCDA) toolbox for Consensus-based Siting of Powerlines and Wind-power plants (ConSite)","description":"The expansion of wind energy development causes both societal and environmental concerns worldwide. Traditional land use planning approaches however limit addressing such concerns adequately. The scale and complexity of emerging renewable energy construction projects enforce the development of improved plan- and decision support tools that ensure democratic and cost-effective processes securing qualified decision making. The multiplicity of criteria and actors involved in decision-making processes requires holistic approaches that enable capturing the variety stakeholder views from technological, economic, societal and environmental perspectives.  As a response to this societal need, the Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA) has developed a Spatial Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis tool (SMCDA) for siting of onshore wind-power plants and associated infrastructure such as powerlines and roads. The tool ConSite (Consensus Based Siting) aims to ensure socially acceptable, environmentally friendly and cost-effective siting, routing and design of wind-power plants and powerlines. ConSite helps to identify and justify decisions taken with respect to both transparency and verification. ConSite is based on current developments in stakeholder dialogue theory, GIS-based Spatial Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (SMCDA) and decision theory.  The ConSite framework is structured into the operational steps of a classical SMCDA and combines stakeholder dialogue with multi-criteria assessment. The objective of the toolbox is to identify areas with the lowest possible conflict level and the highest possible production level. Dialogue with affected stakeholders and documentation of relevant expertise is used to provide information about, and to consider the relative importance of (weighting of) the different stake-holder interests. This helps to identify potential land use conflicts in a \u201cconflict-map\u201d. The \u201cconflict-map\u201d is used together with wind resource maps to identify which areas are most optimal for wind power development. This way ConSite helps to structure the decision problem, balance conflicting interests and identify relevant decision strategies based on a holistic evaluation of risk and trade-off between different alternatives. ConSite can be used to evaluate different scenarios by visualizing the spatial consequences of different decision strategies.  This report exemplifies the practical usage of the ConSite toolbox. ConSite has previously been successfully implemented in spatial planning of wind-power development in Lithuania, and validated through a power line routing case study in S\u00f8r-Tr\u00f8ndelag County (Bevanger et al., 2014 \u0026amp; Hanssen et al., 2014). Further development to integrate the ecosystem services concept into an adaptive landscape planning context, helps making the complexity of social-ecological systems more comprehensible for involved stakeholders. This enables the application of ConSite across sectoral interests (e.g. renewable energy, road infrastructure, urban development and fish farming). ConSite can thus help decision makers to secure socially acceptable, environmentally friendly and cost-effective siting and optimal design of renewable construction projects. The current version of the ConSite SMCDA toolbox framework is developed for a desktop GIS platform. To increase the access to and user-friendliness of ConSite, NINA has the ambition to move the ConSite SMCDA framework to an online GIS-platform. This development will be based on an evaluation of user needs, a detailed requirement specification and system prototyping.","author":["May, R.","Hanssen, F.","Stokke, B.","Van Dijk, J.","De Stefano, M."],"organization":["Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hanssenetal2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1952","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/performance-test-verification-shelf-automated-avian-radar-tracking-system","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/ece3.3162","title":"Performance Test and Verification of an Off the Shelf Automated Avian Radar Tracking System","description":"Microwave radar is an important tool for observation of birds in flight and represents a tremendous increase in observation capability in terms of amount of surveillance space that can be covered at relatively low cost. Based on off- the- shelf radar hardware, auto-mated radar tracking systems have been developed for monitoring avian movements. However, radar used as an observation instrument in biological research has its limita-tions that are important to be aware of when analyzing recorded radar data. This article describes a method for exploring the detection capabilities of a dedicated short- range avian radar system used inside the operational Sm\u00f8la wind- power plant. The purpose of the testing described was to find the maximum detection range for various sized birds, while controlling for the effects of flight tortuosity, flight orientation relative to the radar and ground clutter. The method was to use a dedicated test target in form of a remotely controlled unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) with calibrated radar cross section (RCS), which enabled the design of virtually any test flight pattern within the area of interest. The UAV had a detection probability of 0.5 within a range of 2,340 m from the radar. The detection performance obtained by the RCS- calibrated test target (\u221211 dBm2, 0.08 m2 RCS) was then extrapolated to find the corresponding performance of differently sized birds. Detection range depends on system sensitivity, the environment within which the radar is placed and the spatial distribution of birds. The avian radar under study enables continuous monitoring of bird activity within a maximum range up to 2 km dependent on the size of the birds in question. While small bird species may be detected up to 0.5\u20131 km, larger species may be detected up to 1.5\u20132 km distance from the radar.","author":["May, R.","Hanssen, F.","Steinheim, Y.","Vang, R.","Kval\u00f8y, P."],"organization":["Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","SINTEF Energy Research"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mayetal2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1953","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-birds-flight-respond-ultraviolet-lighting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1186\/s40657-017-0092-3","title":"Do birds in flight respond to (ultra)violet lighting?","description":"Concerns for bird collisions with wind turbines affect the deployment of onshore and offshore wind-power plants. To avoid delays in consenting processes and to streamline the construction and operation phase, functional mitigation measures are required which efficiently reduces bird mortality. Vision is the primary sensory system in birds, which for a number of species also includes the ultraviolet spectrum. Many bird species that are known to collide with offshore wind turbines are sensitive in the violet or ultraviolet spectrum. For species that are mainly active at lower ambient light levels, lighting may deter birds from the lit area. Utilizing (ultra)violet lights may in addition not disturb humans. However, we do not know whether UV-sensitive birds in flight actually respond behaviourally to UV lights.","author":["May, R.","Dahl, E.","Hamre, \u00d8.","\u00c5str\u00f6m, J."],"organization":["Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mayetal2017_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1954","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-onshore-wind-energy-production-birds-bats-recommendations-future-life-cycle","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s11367-017-1434-4","title":"Impacts of onshore wind energy production on birds and bats: recommendations for future life cycle impact assessment developments","description":"Purpose Models for quantifying impacts on biodiversity from renewable energy technologies are lacking within life cycle impact assessment (LCIA). We aim to provide an overview of the effects of wind energy on birds and bats, with a focus on quantitative methods. Furthermore, we investigate and provide the necessary background for how these can be integrated into new developments of LCIA models in future.  Methods We reviewed available literature summarizing the effects of wind energy developments on birds and bats. We provide an overview of available quantitative assessment methods that have been employed outside of the LCIA framework to model the different impacts of wind energy developments on wildlife. Combining the acquired knowledge on impact pathways and associated quantitative methods, we propose possibilities for future approaches for a wind energy impact assessment methodology for LCIA.  Results and discussion Wind energy production has impacts on terrestrial biodiversity through three main pathways: collision, disturbance, and habitat alterations. Birds and bats are consistently considered the most affected taxonomic groups, with different responses to the before-mentioned impact pathways. Outside of the LCIA framework, current quantitative impact assessment prediction models include collision risk models, species distribution models, individual-based models, and population modeling approaches. Developed indices allow scaling of species-specific vulnerability to mortality, disturbance, and\/or habitat alterations.  Conclusions Although insight into the causes behind collision risk, disturbance, and habitat alterations for bats and birds is still limited, the current knowledge base enables the development of a robust assessment tool. Modeling the impacts of habitat alterations, disturbance, and collisions within an LCIA framework is most appropriate using species distribution models as those enable the estimation of species\u2019 occurrences across a region. Although local-scale developments may be more readily feasible, further up-scaling to global coverage is recommended to allow comparison across regions and technologies, and to assess cumulative impacts.","author":["May, R.","Laranjeiro, T.","Verones, F."],"organization":["Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)"],"originationDate":"2018-02-02","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1955","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/direct-mortality-birds-anthropogenic-causes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.annualreviews.org\/doi\/10.1146\/annurev-ecolsys-112414-054133","title":"Direct Mortality of Birds from Anthropogenic Causes","description":"Understanding and reversing the widespread population declines of birds require estimating the magnitude of all mortality sources. Numerous anthropogenic mortality sources directly kill birds. Cause-specific annual mortality in the United States varies from billions (cat predation) to hundreds of millions (building and automobile collisions), tens of millions (power line collisions), millions (power line electrocutions, communication tower collisions), and hundreds of thousands (wind turbine collisions). However, great uncertainty exists about the independent and cumulative impacts of this mortality on avian populations. To facilitate this understanding, additional research is needed to estimate mortality for individual bird species and affected populations, to sample mortality throughout the annual cycle to inform full life-cycle population models, and to develop models that clarify the degree to which multiple mortality sources are additive or compensatory. We review sources of direct anthropogenic mortality in relation to the fundamental ecological objective of disentangling how mortality sources affect animal populations.","author":["Loss, S.","Will, T.","Marra, P."],"organization":["Oklahoma State University","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","Smithsonian Institution"],"originationDate":"2015-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1956","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energys-impacts-birds-south-africa-preliminary-review-results-operational","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.birdlife.org.za\/conservation\/terrestrial-bird-conservation\/birds-and-renewable-energy","title":"Wind Energy\u0027s Impacts on Birds in South Africa: A Preliminary Review of the Results of Operational Monitoring at the First Wind Farms of the Renewable Energy Independent Power Producer Procurement Programme in South Africa","description":"Wind turbines can have both positive and negative environmental effects, and these impacts are likely to vary according to the local context. This report is the first of its kind for South Africa \u2013 it summarises the results of monitoring birds at eight wind farms. Monitoring was largely conducted according to standard procedures outlined in BirdLife South Africa and the Endangered Wildlife Trust\u2019s Best Practice Guidelines for assessing and monitoring the impact of wind-energy facilities on birds in southern Africa (Best Practice Guidelines). Post-construction phase monitoring was conducted for a minimum of one year, and for no more than two years at all wind farms in the study. No clear evidence for disturbance or displacement was found. However, there were a number of confounding factors \u2013 a metaanalysis of the raw data and further research on some species would be of value. The average estimated fatality rate at the wind farms (accounting for detection rates and scavenger removal) ranged from 2.06 to 8.95 birds per turbine per year. The mean fatality rate was 4.1 birds per turbine per year. This places South Africa within the range of fatality rates that have been reported for North America and Europe. The number of fatalities recorded decreased in the winter months, coinciding with the period where lower bird activity levels can be expected. Diurnal raptors accounted for most fatalities (36%), followed by songbirds (26%). Threatened species affected by collisions with wind turbines included Blue Crane (three), Verreaux\u2019s Eagle (five), Martial Eagle (two) and Black Harrier (five). A large number of Jackal Buzzard fatalities (24) also were reported. This species is not threatened, but it is endemic to southern Africa. No fatalities were reported for a number of species predicted to be vulnerable to the impacts of wind energy; however, this review is based on data from a limited number of wind farms and a short period of monitoring, and a precautionary approach remains warranted when assessing and mitigating impacts for these species.\n\nAlthough preliminary, the results of this study point to a number of potential research questions. Recommendations are also made which could help build our understanding around how to minimise the negative effects of wind energy on birds in South Africa.","author":["Smallie, J.","Ramalho, R.","Pearson, A.","Ralston-Paton, S."],"organization":["BirldLife South Africa"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-33.635526800000","25.461350000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ralston-Paton-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1957","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/verreauxs-eagle-wind-farms-guidelines-impact-assessment-monitoring-mitigation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.birdlife.org.za\/conservation\/terrestrial-bird-conservation\/birds-and-renewable-energy","title":"Verreauxs\u0027 Eagle and Wind Farms: Guidelines for Impact Assessment, Monitoring, and Mitigation","description":"These guidelines summarise the current state of knowledge with regards to the potential effects of wind energy on Verreauxs\u2019 Eagle, and outline the steps necessary to ensure that negative effects are adequately assessed and minimised.\n\nVerreauxs\u2019 Eagle has been listed as regionally Vulnerable in the latest Eskom Red Data Book of Birds of South Africa, Lesotho and Swaziland (Taylor et al. 2015). There is evidence to suggest that this species is vulnerable to colliding with wind turbines. Eagles may also be affected by disturbance and displacement related to wind farm activities, particularly around nests. Opportunities to avoid and minimise these impacts lie largely within the planning phase (i.e. before construction).\n\nWhere a wind farm is proposed within potentially important Verreauxs\u2019 Eagle habitat, BirdLife South Africa recommends the following:\nWind turbines should be placed outside of the core territory of eagles to reduce the risk of collisions.\nAreas associated with increased flight activity and\/or risky behaviour should also be avoided, for example the edge the escarpment, ridge tops, cliffs, steep slopes and particularly slopes that are perpendicular to the prevailing wind direction.\nDedicated surveys must be conducted to identify potential nest sites. Cliff-lines should be surveyed for evidence of nesting. These surveys should extend beyond the development footprint to include the likely territory of any pair that may regularly use the site.\nA buffer of 3 km is recommended around all nests (including alternate nests). This is intended to reduce the risk of collisions and disturbance. This is a precautionary buffer and may be reduced (or increased) based on the results of rigorous avifaunal surveys, but nest buffers should never be less than 1.5 km.\nVantage point surveys should be conducted for a minmum of 72 hours per vantage point per year.\nFieldwork must include surveys during the breeding season.\nSurveys (including vantage point monitoring) should extend beyond the developable area.\nThe relative extent and type of use of the site by eagles must be assessed.\nSteps should be taken to avoid increasing the prey population (and thereby attracting eagles to the wind farm). For example excavated rocks and animal carcasses should be removed.\nIf it is suspected that a proposed wind farm may pose a significant risk to Verreauxs\u2019 Eagles, the duration of pre-construction monitoring should be extended to two years, particularly where alternate nests are some distance apart and\/or turbines are proposed in areas that may be associated with increased flight activity and\/or risky behaviour.\nNo construction activities (e.g. new roads) should be allowed within 1 km of nests during the breeding season.\nNests should be monitored for breeding activity throughout the lifespan of the wind farm (including during construction), but care must be taken to ensure that monitoring activities do not disturb breeding birds.","author":["BirdLife South Africa"],"organization":["BirldLife South Africa"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BLSA-2017-VerreauxsEagle.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1958","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-effectiveness-acoustic-deterrent-devices-minke-whale-balaenoptera","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/321965772_Understanding_the_Effectiveness_of_Acoustic_Deterrent_Devices_ADDs_on_Minke_Whale_Balaenoptera_acutorostrata_a_Low_Frequency_Cetacean","title":"Understanding the Effectiveness of Acoustic Deterrent Devices on Minke Whale (Balaenoptera acutorostrata), A Low Frequency Cetacean","description":"Increasing scale and complexity of offshore wind farms (OWF) and on-going concern for European Protected Species (EPS) has led to interest in identifying alternative mitigation strategies to commonly used visual observation and acoustic detection methods for marine mammals. Acoustic Deterrent Devices (ADDs) have been identified as a potentially effective tool for a number of small cetacean species, but research has been lacking for some other key species that occur within prospective OWF sites.  A controlled exposure experiment (CEE) was designed and implemented to test the efficacy of the Lofitech ADD as a potential mitigation tool for the minke whale during piling operations. During August and September 2016, visual tracking of minke whales was undertaken in Faxafl\u00f3i Bay, Iceland by a team of researchers on the R.V. Song of the Whale. When a focal animal had been identified and tracked for at least 30 minutes, the ADD was deployed at a distance of 1,000 m in order to expose the animal to the ADD signal. The behaviour of the focal animal was tracked during a control, treatment and post-treatment phase in order to understand the potential reactions to the ADD signal. Biological parameters such as inter-sequence interval, inter-blow interval, net swim speed, and measures of path predictability were recorded and later analysed to examine the behaviour in detail. In addition, the variable \u2018away speed\u2019 was derived in order to determine both the directionality and the longevity of any effect on the behaviour of the focal animal.  The ADD itself was fully characterised in the field. The unit deployed was found to have a source root mean square (rms) sound pressure level of 198 dB re 1 \u03bcPa re 1m, for a fundamental frequency of 14.6 kHz. The pulse length had an average of 752 ms. As noted in the literature, variability among individual units is expected.  A total of 46 minke whales were successfully tracked. Of these, 15 included successful deployments of the ADD. The focal animal moved away from the ADD deployment site in all cases. A significant increase in net swim speed during the treatment phase was observed, with whales increasing their speed by an average of 7.4 kmh-1. The away speed variable showed a significant increase in speed during the second half of the treatment phase, indicating that animals both increase their speed and the directness of their path in relation to exposure to the ADD signal.  The results highlight that the Lofitech ADD is effective at evoking a deterrence response in minke whales, suggesting that such devices could be effective at reducing any potential for injurious effects from exposure to subsea noise generated during pile-driving activity at OWF sites.","author":["Compton, R.","McGarry, T.","Boisseau, O.","Stephenson, S."],"organization":["Offshore Renewables Joint Industry Programme (ORJIP)","RPS group","The Carbon Trust"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/McGarry-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1959","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-europe-views-experiences-progress-date","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166915000338","title":"Wave energy in Europe: Views on experiences and progress to date","description":"Through the Intelligent Energy Europe-funded SOWFIA project, the experiences of developers, regulators and stakeholders in relation to consenting wave energy deployments to date was assessed and analysed. The work focussed on wave energy test centres in Europe and involved consultation with wave energy device and project developers, regulatory authorities, stakeholders, environmental consultants and others through dedicated workshops and questionnaire surveys. Themes that arise in the analysis relate to planning and consenting processes, administrative procedures, Environmental Impact Assessment and stakeholder consultation. An analysis of the barriers as perceived by those consulted is presented and discussed, and recommendations are drawn from the analysis within each of the themes. In particular the need for Maritime Spatial Planning (MSP) to alleviate complex planning and consenting processes; the need for coordination of administrative procedures; the need for clearer requirements in the EIA process; and the need for early participation of stakeholders in consultation are discussed. Progress has been made in many EU countries but certain priority areas remain to be addressed if wave energy is to realise its full potential.","author":["Greaves, D.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","O\u0027Callaghan, J.","Huertas, C."],"organization":["Plymouth University","Abengoa Seapower","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2016-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.324537000000","4.078552000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1960","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/resolving-environmental-effects-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/servlets\/purl\/1437561","title":"Resolving environmental effects of wind energy","description":"Concerns for potential wildlife impacts resulting from land-based and offshore wind energy have created challenges for wind project development. Research is not always adequately supported, results are neither always readily accessible nor are they satisfactorily disseminated, and so decisions are often made based on the best available information, which may be missing key findings. The potential for high impacts to avian and bat species and marine mammals have been used by wind project opponents to stop, downsize, or severely delay project development. The global nature of the wind industry\u2014combined with the understanding that many affected species cross-national boundaries, and in many cases migrate between continents\u2014also points to the need to collaborate on an international level. The International Energy Agency (IEA) Wind Technology Collaborative Programs facilitates coordination on key research issues. IEA Wind Task 34\u2014WREN: Working Together to Resolve Environmental Effects of Wind Energy\u2013is a collaborative forum to share lessons gained from field research and modeling, including management methods, wildlife monitoring methods, best practices, study results, and successful approaches to mitigating impacts and addressing the cumulative effects of wind energy on wildlife.  WREN develops products such as white papers, fact sheets, and short science summaries, and is involved in a number of activities including hosting a webinar series and outreach and information dissemination through participation in meet-ings, workshops, and conferences to increase and expand the knowledge base per-taining to wildlife challenges at wind energy facilities. This information is available on WREN Hub, hosted on the Tethys website.","author":["Copping, A.","May, R.","Sinclair, K.","Bennet, F.","Warnas, M.","Perron, M.","Elmqvist, A."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","Marine Scotland Science","Ministry of Infrastructure and the Environment (Rijkswaterstaat)","nateco AG","Swedish Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)"],"originationDate":"2018-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1961","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/applying-bioacoustic-methods-long-term-monitoring-nocturnal-wetland-bird","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954113001301","title":"Applying bioacoustic methods for long-term monitoring of a nocturnal wetland bird","description":"Bioacoustic monitoring is becoming more and more popular as a non-invasive method to study populations and communities of vocalizing animals. Acoustic pattern recognition techniques allow for automated identification of species and an estimation of species composition within ecosystems. Here we describe an approach where on the basis of long term acoustic recordings not only the occurrence of a species was documented, but where the number of vocalizing animals was also estimated. This approach allows us to follow up changes in population density and to define breeding sites in a changing environment. We present the results of five years of continuous acoustic monitoring of Eurasian bittern (Botaurus stellaris) in a recent wetland restoration area. Using a setup consisting of four four-channel recorders equipped with cardioid microphones we recorded vocal activity during entire nights. Vocalizations of bitterns were detected on the recordings by spectrogram template matching. On basis of time differences of arrival (TDOA) of the acoustic signals at different recording devices booming bitterns could be mapped using hyperbolic localization. During the study period not only changes in the number of calling birds but also changes in their spatial distribution connected with changes in habitat structure could be documented. This semi-automated approach towards monitoring birds described here could be applied to a wide range of monitoring tasks for animals with long distance vocalizations.","author":["Frommolt, K.","Tauchert, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2014-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1962","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/statistical-guidelines-assessing-marine-avian-hotspots-coldspots-case-study-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S000632071530001X","title":"Statistical guidelines for assessing marine avian hotspots and coldspots: A case study on wind energy development in the U.S. Atlantic Ocean","description":"Estimating patterns of habitat use is challenging for marine avian species because seabirds tend to aggregate in large groups and it can be difficult to locate both individuals and groups in vast marine environments. We developed an approach to estimate the statistical power of discrete survey events to identify species-specific hotspots and coldspots of long-term seabird abundance in marine environments. We illustrate our approach using historical seabird data from survey transects in the U.S. Atlantic Ocean Outer Continental Shelf (OCS), an area that has been divided into \u201clease blocks\u201d for proposed offshore wind energy development. For our power analysis, we examined whether discrete lease blocks within the region could be defined as hotspots (3 \u00d7 mean abundance in the OCS) or coldspots (1\/3 \u00d7) for individual species within a given season. For each of 74 species\/season combinations, we determined which of eight candidate statistical distributions (ranging in their degree of skewedness) best fit the count data. We then used the selected distribution and estimates of regional prevalence to calculate and map statistical power to detect hotspots and coldspots, and estimate the p-value from Monte Carlo significance tests that specific lease blocks are in fact hotspots or coldspots relative to regional average abundance. The power to detect species-specific hotspots was higher than that of coldspots for most species because species-specific prevalence was relatively low (mean: 0.111; SD: 0.110). The number of surveys required for adequate power (\u003E 0.6) was large for most species (tens to hundreds) using this hotspot definition. Regulators may need to accept higher proportional effect sizes, combine species into groups, and\/or broaden the spatial scale by combining lease blocks in order to determine optimal placement of wind farms. Our power analysis approach provides a general framework for both retrospective analyses and future avian survey design and is applicable to a broad range of research and conservation problems.","author":["O\u0027Connell, A.","Kinlan, B.","Sussman, A.","Rypkema, D.","Wimer, M.","Zipkin, E."],"organization":["Michigan State University","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","Stanford University","Patuxent Wildlife Research Center"],"originationDate":"2015-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1963","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/quantifying-clutter-comparison-four-methods-their-relationship-bat-detection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378112714001315","title":"Quantifying clutter: A comparison of four methods and their relationship to bat detection","description":"The degree of spatial complexity in the environment, or clutter, affects the quality of foraging habitats for bats and their detection with acoustic systems. Clutter has been assessed in a variety of ways but there are no standardized methods for measuring clutter. We compared four methods (Visual Clutter, Cluster, Single Variable, and Clutter Index) and related these to the probability of detecting bat calls. From June to July, 2005\u20132006, we used Anabat detectors to conduct acoustic surveys for 2\u20134 nights at each of 71 points representing three visual clutter classes. We used a cluster analysis to identify groups of plots with similar characteristics. We used backwards stepwise discriminant analyses to identify important plot structure variables that differentiated among clutter classes and used discriminant analyses to test the effectiveness of the plot structure variables in classifying plots into visual clutter classes or clusters. Two clutter volume indices (Indexmax and Index15m) were computed for each plot by calculating the ratio of vegetation volume to available space in the plot. We assessed the effects of the clutter estimation methods on the probability of detecting bats in low and high frequency phonic groups. Occupancy rates ranged from 0.30 to 0.78 and probability of detecting any bat was \u2a7e0.78 for each period; however, few identifiable calls were recorded. Live tree basal area, midstory live stem count, and canopy crown volume were the most effective measures of clutter for bats because each was a plausible predictor of bat detection and the former two were important for discriminating among plots with differing structure. The use of clutter indices has promise but such methods need to be tested prior to implementation. In future studies of bat foraging habitat, quantitative measures should be used to assess clutter so it is possible to make comparisons among habitats or studies.","author":["Loeb, S.","O\u0027Keefe, J.","Hill, H.","Lanham, J."],"organization":["Clemson University"],"originationDate":"2014-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.231276500000","-83.569309400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1964","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/methodological-challenges-monitoring-bat-population-assemblage-level-changes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1616504714001207","title":"Methodological challenges in monitoring bat population- and assemblage-level changes for anthropogenic impact assessment","description":"Recent years have seen increased attention to bats as an effective bioindicator group for assessing responses to drivers of global change, which concurrently has led to a revived interest in establishing a global bat monitoring network. To be effective and efficient, global-scale monitoring of bats will largely have to rely on integrating data collected as part of a network of regional monitoring schemes. Herein, I highlight and discuss some of the principal challenges faced in the monitoring of population- and assemblage-level changes of bats, focusing mainly on methodological and statistical issues and the selection of suitable state variables for quantifying regional trends in bat biodiversity. Particularly in the tropics, where detailed single-species monitoring is challenging due to high species richness, I recommend that monitoring programs focus on tracking changes in species turnover and composition as more informative measures of anthropogenic impact than species richness. Imperfect species detection is an important source of variation and uncertainty associated with animal count data. Bat monitoring programs need to correct for this, most importantly through the use of sampling protocols that rely on strictly standardized approaches and a well-balanced design, or a posteriori by using appropriate statistical models so as to avoid the detection of spurious trends. Multi-species occupancy models that allow for simultaneous assemblage- and species-level inference about occurrence and detection probabilities provide a suitable analysis framework for monitoring data, and are a comparatively low-cost approach that should prove useful especially in the regional monitoring of bats in the tropics. To ensure robust inference about temporal and spatial trend estimates in the state variables of interest, the efficacy of sampling designs should be carefully gauged at the design stage to ensure sufficient statistical power, and data should be collected according to a formal randomized design to allow for regional-scale inference. I stress the importance for long-term bat monitoring programs to have sustained funding, the need to establish trigger points for the application of appropriate mitigation measures, and for monitoring to be adaptive so as to maximize effectiveness and efficiency based on the data collected. Finally, I argue that to overcome the challenges associated with initiating monitoring networks in tropical countries \u2013 a major step towards the realization of global-scale bat monitoring \u2013 reliance on citizen scientists and participatory monitoring will be key.","author":["Meyer, C."],"organization":["University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1965","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/variation-ocean-acoustic-environments-along-western-north-atlantic-coast-case-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954114000065","title":"Variation of ocean acoustic environments along the western North Atlantic coast: A case study in context of the right whale migration route","description":"Differing physical characteristics and levels of biological, environmental, and anthropogenic sounds contribute in varying levels of noise in different ocean environments. As a result, animals migrating over large ranges or widely distributed species are now exposed to a myriad of different acoustic environments, within which they must navigate, forage and reproduce. Given current increases in low-frequency (","author":["Clark, C.","Guerra, M.","Rice, A.","Tielens, J.","Estabrook, B.","Muirhead, C.","Rahaman, A."],"organization":["Cornell University"],"originationDate":"2014-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1966","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-energy-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.taylorfrancis.com\/books\/e\/9781317356424","title":"Offshore Energy and Marine Spatial Planning","description":"The generation of offshore energy is a rapidly growing sector, competing for space in an already busy seascape. This book brings together the ecological, economic, and social implications of the spatial conflict this growth entails. Covering all energy-generation types (wind, wave, tidal, oil, and gas), it explores the direct and indirect impacts the growth of offshore energy generation has on both the marine environment and the existing uses of marine space.\n\nChapters explore main issues associated with offshore energy, such as the displacement of existing activities and the negative impacts it can have on marine species and ecosystems. Chapters also discuss how the growth of offshore energy generation presents new opportunities for collaboration and co-location with other sectors, for example, the co-location of wild-capture fisheries and wind farms.\n\nThe book integrates these issues and opportunities, and demonstrates the importance of holistic marine spatial planning for optimising the location of offshore energy-generation sites. It highlights the importance of stakeholder engagement in these planning processes and the role of integrated governance, with illustrative case studies from the United States, United Kingdom, northern Europe, and the Mediterranean. It also discusses trade-off analysis and decision theory and provides a range of tools and best practices to inform future planning processes.\n\nIntroduction:\nThe global demand for energy continues to grow, with a projected 30% increase over the next 25 years (International Energy Agency 2016). By 2022, global spending on offshore oil and gas development and operations is estimated to be US$114 billion, which is more than 2.5 times the US$43 billion spent in 2012 (Marine Board 2013). New, highly lucrative resource discoveries are being made regularly (Chapter 14), and multibillion-dollar investments in previously unexplored areas are announced every year (Eurasia Group 2014; Mann 2016). Likewise, the Environmental and Energy Study Institute (www.eesi.org) predicts substantial growth in offshore renewable-energy generation, with more than seven times the capacity expected in 2020 compared to 2015, and potentially more than triple the 2020 capacity by 2030 (Small et al. 2016). As many countries endeavour to meet international obligations to reduce carbon emissions (EC 2015; Heard et al. 2017), the expansion of renewable energy becomes incorporated into national strategic priorities (e.g., Department for the Economy 2009), with some countries boldly committing to legally binding targets for renewable-energy production (EC 2007; International Energy Agency 2014). Much of the increase in renewable-energy generation is focussed on offshore areas: offshore wind, wave, and tidal energy (also referred to as \u2018ocean energy\u2019). Indeed, offshore renewable-energy generation is expected to expand markedly in Europe and across the world (Ecofys 2014; EC 2015; International Energy Agency 2015), with predictions that as much as 7% of the total global electrical energy will be generated from marine renewables by 2050 (Esteban and Leary 2012).\n\nTable of Contents:\n\n\nMarine Spatial Planning\nCharles Ehler\nPages 6-17\n\n\nMethods and utility of ecosystem service trade-off analysis for guiding marine planning of offshore energy\u00a0\nJoel Stevens, Sarah Lester and Crow White\nPages 18-33\n\n\nIt starts with a conversation\nJohanna Polsenberg and Anna Kilponen\nPages 34-55\n\n\nChallenges and opportunities for governance in marine spatial planning\nLucy Greenhill\nPages 56-73\n\n\nLegal aspects of marine spatial planning\nErik van Doorn and Sarah Fiona Gahlen\nPages 74-87\n\n\nDisplacement of existing activities\nAndronikos Kafas, Penelope Donohue, Ian Davies and Beth\u00a0Scott\nPages 88-112\n\n\nTracing regime shifts in the provision of coastal-marine cultural ecosystem services\nKira Gee and\u00a0Benjamin Burkhard\nPages 113-131\n\nEnvironmental implications of offshore energy\nAndrew Gill, Silvana Birchenough, Alice Jones, Adrian Judd, Simon Jude, Ana Payo-Payo and Ben Wilson\nPages 132-168\n\nMeaningful stakeholder participation in marine spatial planning with offshore energy\nKatherine Yates\nPages 169-188\n\n\nCapturing benefits\nTara Hooper, Matthew Ashley and Melanie Austen\nPages 189-213\n\nCompatibility of offshore energy installations with marine protected areas\nRuth Thurstan, Katherine Yates and Bethan O\u2019Leary\nPages\u00a0214-230\n\n\nMarine spatial planning and stakeholder collaboration\nPriscilla Brooks and Tricia Jedele\nPages 231-245\n\n\nCo-locating offshore wind farms and marine protected areas\nMatthew Ashley, Melanie Austen, Lynda Rodwell and Stephen Mangi\nPages 246-259\n\n\nConservation challenges in the face of new hydrocarbon discoveries in the Mediterranean Sea\nTessa Mazor, Noam Levin, Eran Brokovich and Salit Kark\nPages 260-273\n\n\nSiting offshore energy arrays\nKaren Alexander, Ron Janssen and Timothy O\u2019Higgins\nPages 274-283\n\n\nThe future of marine spatial planning\nCorey Bradshaw, Lucy Greenhill and Katherine Yates\nPages 284-293","author":["Yates, K.","Bradshaw, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1967","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fisheries-marine-conservation-marine-renewable-energy-displacement-fresh-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pearl.plymouth.ac.uk\/handle\/10026.1\/8336","title":"Fisheries, Marine Conservation, Marine Renewable Energy and Displacement: A Fresh Approach","description":"Fishers are among the biggest commercial resource users in the marine environment. In order to meet international, national and local policies, the UK has to designate a suite of marine protected areas (MPAs) and reach marine renewable energy (MRE) targets. Inevitably, there will be conflict between these two industries and marine conservation. This study uses a multi-disciplinary approach to examine evaluate the suitability of various sources of data, which could be used to detect, assess, and ultimately predict, fishing effort displacement within the different sectors of the \u0026gt; 15 m fleet in the South West of the UK. Gear-specific Vessel Monitoring System (VMS) data from 2005-2008 was used to assess potential effort displacement due to Haig Fras, a proposed MPA and Wave Hub, a marine renewable energy installation (MREI). The spatial distribution of fishing activity was highly heterogeneous and distinct areas of intense fishing could be identified for all gear-types. A closure of Haig Fras would have the greatest impact on gillnetters. Scallop dredgers also occasionally use the area. The current closure at Wave Hub has the greatest impact on potters and whelkers whose geographic specialisation is most pronounced and who use the area extensively. Longliners also use the area disproportionately would be affected. A simple index of variability was developed in order to determine baselines and two other sources of data were used. High resolution seabed data and low resolution catch data. A semi structured interview was conducted with forty fishers to elicit further information on the challenges, barriers to progress and priority issues in relation to MRE those fishers face. The theme of discontent with the consultation process scored highly throughout. Fishers\u2019 Knowledge (FK) another source of data also scored highly, although further work must be carried out to identify what aspects of this data are useful in assessment of fishing effort displacement.","author":["Campbell, M."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2015-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Campbell-2017-Thesis.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1968","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/flight-response-spatial-temporal-correlates-informs-risk-wind-turbines-california","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/10.1650\/CONDOR-17-100.1","title":"Flight Response to Spatial and Temporal Correlates Informs Risk from Wind Turbines to the California Condor","description":"Wind power is a fast-growing energy resource, but wind turbines can kill volant wildlife, and the flight behavior of obligate soaring birds can place them at risk of collision with these structures. We analyzed altitudinal data from GPS telemetry of critically endangered California Condors (Gymnogyps californianus) to assess the circumstances under which their flight behavior may place them at risk from collision with wind turbines. Condor flight behavior was strongly influenced by topography and land cover, and birds flew at lower altitudes and closer to the rotor-swept zone of wind turbines when over ridgelines and steep slopes and over forested and grassland cover types. Condor flight behavior was temporally predictable, and birds flew lower and closer to the rotor-swept zone during early morning and evening hours and during the winter months, when thermal updrafts were weakest. Although condors only occasionally flew at altitudes that placed them in the rotor-swept zone of turbines, they regularly flew near or within wind resource areas preferred by energy developers. Practitioners aiming to mitigate collision risk to this and other soaring bird species of conservation concern can consider the manner in which flight behavior varies temporally and in response to areas of high topographic relief and proximity to nocturnal roosting sites. By contrast, collision risk to large soaring birds from turbines should be relatively lower over flatter and less rugged areas and in habitat used during daytime soaring.\n\nLa respuesta de vuelo a correlaciones espaciales y temporales revela el riesgo de las turbinas e\u00f3licas para Gymnogyps californianus \n\nLa energ\u00eda e\u00f3lica es un recurso energ\u00e9tico en r\u00e1pido crecimiento, pero las turbinas e\u00f3licas pueden matar a la fauna silvestre que vuela, y el comportamiento de vuelo de las aves que son planeadoras obligadas puede ponerlos en riesgo de colisi\u00f3n con estas estructuras. Analizamos datos altitudinales obtenidos con telemetr\u00eda de GPS del C\u00f3ndor de California (Gymnogyps californianus), una especie en peligro cr\u00edtico, para evaluar las circunstancias bajo las cuales sus comportamientos de vuelo pueden ponerlos en riesgo de colisi\u00f3n con las turbinas e\u00f3licas. El comportamiento de vuelo del c\u00f3ndor estuvo fuertemente influenciado por la topograf\u00eda y la cobertura del suelo, y las aves volaron a menores altitudes y m\u00e1s cerca de la zona de barrido del rotor de las turbinas e\u00f3licas cuando estuvieron sobre los filos y en pendientes pronunciadas y sobre tipos de cobertura boscosa y de pastizal. El comportamiento de vuelo del c\u00f3ndor fue temporalmente predecible, y las aves volaron m\u00e1s bajo y m\u00e1s cerca de la zona de barrido del rotor durante la ma\u00f1ana temprano y a la tarde y durante los meses de invierno, cuando las t\u00e9rmicas ascendentes fueron m\u00e1s d\u00e9biles. Aunque los c\u00f3ndores volaron solo ocasionalmente a altitudes en las que se ubicaron en la zona de barrido del rotor de las turbinas, s\u00ed volaron regularmente cerca o dentro de los recursos e\u00f3licos preferidos por los desarrollos de energ\u00eda. Los profesionales que deseen mitigar el riesgo de colisi\u00f3n de esta y otras especies de aves planeadoras de preocupaci\u00f3n para la conservaci\u00f3n pueden considerar el modo en el que var\u00eda el comportamiento de vuelo temporalmente y en respuesta a \u00e1reas de alto relieve topogr\u00e1fico y en proximidad a los dormideros nocturnos. En contraste, el riesgo de colisi\u00f3n de las aves planeadoras grandes con las turbinas deber\u00eda ser relativamente m\u00e1s bajo en las \u00e1reas m\u00e1s planas y menos escarpadas y en h\u00e1bitats usados durante las horas de planeo diurno.","author":["Katzner, T.","Lanzone, M.","Braham, M.","Poessel, S.","Brandt, J.","Mendenhall, L.","McGann, A."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","West Virginia University","Cellular Tracking Technologies"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1969","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/landscape-scale-wildlife-species-richness-metrics-inform-wind-solar-energy-facility","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421518300600","title":"Landscape-Scale Wildlife Species Richness Metrics to Inform Wind and Solar Energy Facility Siting: An Arizona Case Study","description":"The juxtaposition of wildlife and wind or solar energy facility infrastructure can present problems for developers, planners, policy makers, and management agencies. Guidance on siting of these renewable energy facilities may help identify potential wildlife-facility conflicts with species of regulatory or economic concern. However, existing spatial guidance usually does not consider all wildlife that might use a potential facility location or corridors for its servicing infrastructure. We illustrate an approach toward assessing potential wildlife-facility conflicts using readily available vertebrate habitat models. The U.S. Geological Survey\u0027s Gap Analysis Program (GAP) has developed spatial models of potential habitat for vertebrate species across the entire nation. To illustrate their applicability, we used GAP models to estimate richness of all native, terrestrial vertebrates within Arizona and for those vertebrates grouped by class or by sensitivity to the type of facility infrastructure. We examined the spatial overlap of high species richness of each group with agency-developed guidance used to inform facility-siting decisions and found that GAP-based richness mappings augmented existing guidance. As the GAP vertebrate habitat models are publicly available for the entire USA, use of these data can provide a coarse view of potential wildlife-facility conflicts and inform facility planning early in the process.","author":["Arundel, T.","Thomas, K.","Jarchow, C.","Jamwal, P.","Borens, A.","Dorst, C."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.124717400000","-112.170299300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1970","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/semi-automatic-long-term-acoustic-surveying-case-study-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954113001313","title":"Semi-Automatic Long-Term Acoustic Surveying: A Case Study with Bats","description":"Increasing concern about decline in biodiversity has created a demand for population surveys. Acoustic monitoring is an efficient non-invasive method, which may be deployed for surveys of animals as diverse as insects, birds, and bats. Long-term unmanned automatic monitoring may provide unique unbiased data from a whole season, but the large amount of data presents serious challenges for the automatic processing of the measurements. To demonstrate feasibility of automatic multi-channel surveying using a new prototype hardware, we carried out a 2-month study of echolocating bats requiring high data sampling rates (500\u00a0kHz). Using a sound energy threshold criterion for triggering recording, we collected 236\u00a0GB (Gi\u00a0=\u00a010243) of data at full bandwidth. We implemented a simple automatic method using a Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier based on a combination of temporal and spectral analyses to classify events into bat calls and non-bat events. After experimentation we selected duration, energy, bandwidth, and entropy as classification features to identify short high energy structured sounds in the right frequency range. The spectral entropy makes use of the orderly arrangement of frequencies in bat calls to reject short noise pulses, e.g. from rain. The SVM classifier reduced our dataset to 162\u00a0MB of candidate bat calls with an estimated accuracy of 96% for dry nights and 70% when it was raining. The automatic survey revealed calls from two species of bat not previously recorded in the area, as well as an unexpected abundance of social calls. The recordings provide data which can be used to correlate bat activity with rain, temperature, and sunset\/sunrise. We discuss future applications, achieving higher accuracy in classifying bat calls and the possibility of using trajectory-tracking data to determine bat behavior and correct for the bias toward loud bats inherent in acoustic surveying.","author":["Andreassen, T.","Surlykke, A.","Hallam, J."],"organization":["University of Southern Denmark"],"originationDate":"2014-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.366560000000","10.431690000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1971","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/towards-framework-quantifying-population-level-consequences-anthropogenic-pressures","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479716310040","title":"Towards a Framework for Quantifying the Population-Level Consequences of Anthropogenic Pressures on the Environment: The Case of Seabirds and Windfarms","description":"Quantifying impacts of development on populations is a key problem for ecologists.\nHowever, approaches to do this are often subject to significant uncertainty.\nWe propose a framework to assess the impacts of wind farms on seabird populations.\nProbabilistic approaches proved less robust to uncertainty than others.\nDecisions about impacts must be made in the context of the population concerned.","author":["Cook, A.","Robinson, R."],"organization":["British Trust for Ornithology (BTO)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1972","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/long-search-intervals-underestimate-bird-bat-fatalities-caused-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/wsb.774","title":"Long Search Intervals Underestimate Bird and Bat Fatalities Caused by Wind Turbines","description":"Bird and bat fatality estimates based on scientific monitoring are used to assess and compare impacts among wind energy projects. Fatality estimates are influenced by multiple factors, including variation in methodology. Variation in the interval between fatality searches exemplifies a monitoring decision that can potentially confound comparison of fatality estimates. A study at the Sand Hill portion of the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area, California, USA, provided the first opportunity to compare fatality-rate estimates derived from 2 independent, experienced monitoring teams searching the same wind turbines at 2 different periodic intervals. Over 30 months of monitoring the same wind turbines, April 2012\u2013October 2014, searches averaging 5-day intervals detected 308 additional fatalities (of 431 fatalities total) representing 20 additional species (of 32 species total) compared with the searches averaging 39-day intervals. Body mass explained most of the variation in discrepant fatality detections between the 2 search intervals, with the 39-day interval searches detecting only 10% of the bats and birds of 10\u201340g that were found by the 5-day interval searches. The 39-day search interval produced an estimate of annual bird fatalities\/MW that was 39% lower than the estimate produced from the 5-day search interval. The 39-day search interval also resulted in many more species identification errors and greater errors in estimated time since death. The average search interval used in fatality monitoring strongly influences fatality estimates; long intervals can contribute to false impressions that wind projects have small or negligible effects on small birds and bats.","author":["Smallwood, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1973","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparing-bird-bat-data-new-wind-power-generation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/books.google.com\/books\/about\/Comparing_Bird_and_Bat_Use_Data_for_Siti.html?id=gRswR694I-QC","title":"Comparing Bird And Bat Data For New Wind Power Generation","description":"Comparison of bird and bat mortality data gathered across the United States.","author":["Neher, L.","Smallwood, S."],"organization":["Neher \u0026 Associates","Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory","California Energy Commission"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Smallwood-Neher-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1974","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mating-eastern-red-bats-found-dead-wind-energy-facility","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/275337336","title":"Mating Eastern Red Bats Found Dead at a Wind Energy Facility","description":"At 0830 h on 3 September 2010, a male and a female eastern red bat (Lasiurus borealis) were found dead on the ground at a wind-energy facility in Somerset County, Pennsylvania. The bats were discovered in an open gravel parking lot, 6 m from the Operations and Management building and 130 m from the nearest wind turbine. The building was located in open grassland, on a high ridgeline (ca. 900 m ASL) in the Appalachian Mountains. The carcasses were fresh and had no obvious signs of injury (e.g., broken limbs, blood). The pair was clasped together, venter to venter, in what appeared to be a copulatory position (Fig. 1). The male\u2019s uropatagium was curled around the posterior of the female, and his jaws were locked onto the fur of her lower chest. We did not have a collection permit, so the bats were not handled or removed for further examination. As such, the cause of death could not be determined, and it could not be verified whether intercourse had occurred.","author":["Gruver, J.","Courage, Z.","Clement, M.","Solick, D.","Murray, K."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2012-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.995925400000","-79.073546500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1975","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/status-herpatofaunal-diversity-ramagiri-east-west-reserve-forests-ananthapuramu","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.faunajournal.com\/archives\/2017\/vol4issue4\/PartA\/4-4-2-229.pdf","title":"Status of herpatofaunal diversity of Ramagiri east and west reserve forests of Ananthapuramu district, Andhra Pradesh","description":"Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, recommended an impact assessment study in view of the potential adverse impacts of windmill projects on terrestrial species of wildlife resulting from alternation and damage to habitats. In accordance with the broad terms of reference set by the Ministry, the present Herpatofaunal study was carried out in the proposed area of Windmill project and subsequently listed 30 reptile species belonging to 11 families. Varanus bengalensis and Python molurus Linnaeus, 1758 are the two reptile fauna belonging to SCHEDULE-I species of INDIAN WILDLIFE (PROTECTION) ACT, 1972. Totally one year were spent in assessing the distribution of herpetofauna. Visual Encounter Survey Method was followed for the collection of data. IUCN status of Recorded Herpatofauna are mostly Lower Risk least Concern least concern (LR-lc). In this study only the density of identified species was specified and calculated based on the average percentage of sightings representing abundant (70 to 100%), common (50 to 70%), frequent (20 to 50%) and rare (0 to 20%). Anthropogenic activities like Forest fires, killing, hunting, and biotic stress like grazing and browsing are the major threats to the proposed wind power project in the Reserve forest area (East and West) of Anantapur district, Andhra Pradesh.","author":["Subramanyam, B.","Khan, I.","Kumari, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["14.420435000000","77.587573000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1976","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-windmills-power-lines-birds-case-study-porbandar-taluka-gujarat-india","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.faunajournal.com\/archives\/?year=2017\u0026vol=4\u0026issue=3\u0026part=B\u0026ArticleId=345","title":"Impact of Windmills and Power Lines on Birds: A Case Study at Porbandar Taluka, Gujarat-India","description":"A great number of birds are killed each year through electrocutions and collisions with power lines and windmills globally. Windmills and associated power lines located near some important wetlands (Important Bird Area) of Porbandar taluka, Gujarat state is surveyed from May 2016 to January 2017. During present study, total 111 species of birds belong to 42 families, which include 11 IUCN threatened species (4 VU, 7 NT). Of all birds 73 species (66%) represent aquatic and 39 species (35%) migratory, this indicates the ecological importance of the landscape. The results show that collision and electrocution of birds by power lines and windmills is of conservation concern in Porbandar with Pelicans, Storks, Cranes, Pea-fowls and Raptors as the most affected species. Preliminary findings of this study confirm the possible impact of wind turbines and Power lines on birds in Porbandar Taluka.","author":["Suthar, A.","Rathod, J.","Singh, N.","Patel, I.","Gavali, D."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1977","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/no-substitute-survival-perturbation-analyses-using-golden-eagle-population-model","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/10.3356\/JRR-16-32.1","title":"No Substitute for Survival: Perturbation Analyses Using a Golden Eagle Population Model Reveal Limits to Managing for Take","description":"Conserving populations of long-lived birds of prey, characterized by a slow life-history (e.g., high survival and low reproductive output), requires a thorough understanding of how variation in their vital rates differentially affects population growth. Stochastic population modeling provides a framework for exploring variation in complex life histories to better understand how environmental and demographic variation within individual vital rates affects population dynamics. Specifically, we used life-stage simulation analysis (LSA) to identify those life-history characteristics that most affect population growth and are amenable to management actions. The Golden Eagle (Aquila chrysaetos) is a wide-ranging raptor of conservation concern, which has been adopted as a focal species for conservation planning. Golden Eagle population trends in western North America currently appear stable. Yet an expanding human footprint that may increase mortality stimulated our investigation into the ability of populations to sustain reduced survival. We fit mixed-effects models to published estimates of vital rates to estimate the mean and process variation of productivity (young fledged per pair) and survival for use in a LSA framework. As expected, breeding adult survival had the greatest relative effect on population growth, though productivity explained the most variation in growth. Based on perturbation analyses, we demonstrate that even minor reductions in breeding adult survival (4% required increases in productivity that generally exceed the evolutionary potential for Golden Eagles. Our findings support the current U.S. Fish and Wildlife conservation strategy which mitigates eagle \u0022take\u0022 via efforts to reduce mortality elsewhere.\n\nSIN SUSTITUTO PARA LA SUPERVIVENCIA: AN\u00c1LISIS DE PERTURBACI\u00d3N UTILIZANDO UN MODELO POBLACIONAL DE AQUILA CHRYSAETOS REVELAN LOS L\u00cdMITES AL MANEJO DE LAS REMOCIONES\n\nLa conservaci\u00f3n de poblaciones de aves de presa longevas, caracterizadas por una historia de vida lenta (e.g., supervivencia elevada y bajo rendimiento reproductivo), requiere de un entendimiento profundo de c\u00f3mo la variaci\u00f3n en las tasas vitales afecta diferencialmente el crecimiento poblacional. El modelado de poblaciones estoc\u00e1sticas proporciona un marco de trabajo para explorar la variaci\u00f3n en historias de vida complejas para comprender mejor c\u00f3mo la variaci\u00f3n ambiental y demogr\u00e1fica en las tasas vitales individuales afectan las din\u00e1micas poblacionales. Espec\u00edficamente, utilizamos un an\u00e1lisis de simulaci\u00f3n de clases de edad (ASCE) para identificar las caracter\u00edsticas de la historia de vida que m\u00e1s afectan el crecimiento poblacional y que son corregibles a trav\u00e9s de acciones de gesti\u00f3n. A. chrysaetos es una rapaz de distribuci\u00f3n amplia de inter\u00e9s para la conservaci\u00f3n, que ha sido adoptada como una especie focal para la planificaci\u00f3n de la conservaci\u00f3n. Actualmente, las tendencias poblacionales de A. chrysaetos en el oeste de Am\u00e9rica del Norte parecen estables. La huella humana en crecimiento y que puede incrementar la mortalidad de esta especie impuls\u00f3 nuestra investigaci\u00f3n sobre la capacidad de las poblaciones para soportar una supervivencia reducida. Adaptamos modelos de efectos mixtos a las estimaciones publicadas de tasas vitales para estimar la media y procesar la variaci\u00f3n en la productividad (volantones por pareja) y supervivencia para su uso en un marco de trabajo ASCE. Como se esperaba, la supervivencia de adultos reproductores tuvo el mayor efecto relativo sobre el crecimiento poblacional, aunque la productividad explic\u00f3 la mayor parte de la variaci\u00f3n en el crecimiento. En base a los an\u00e1lisis de perturbaci\u00f3n, demostramos que incluso disminuciones peque\u00f1as en la supervivencia de adultos reproductores (4% requieren incrementos en la productividad que generalmente exceden el potencial evolutivo de A. chrysaetos. Nuestros hallazgos apoyan la actual estrategia de conservaci\u00f3n del Servicio de Pesca y Vida Silvestre de los Estados Unidos que mitiga las \u201cremociones\u201d de \u00e1guilas a trav\u00e9s de esfuerzos para reducir la mortalidad en cualquier otro lado.","author":["Tack, J.","Fedy, B.","Noon, B.","Bowen, Z.","Strybos, L."],"organization":["Colorado State University","University of Waterloo"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tack-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1978","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-impact-analysis-composite-wind-turbine-blade","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.irjet.net\/archives\/V4\/i8\/IRJET-V4I8112.pdf","title":"Bird Impact Analysis of a Composite Wind Turbine Blade","description":"Wind turbines are located at open fields to generate the electricity by using natural power of wind. Turbine blades have aero foil shapes they must tolerable against the bird impacts. We discussed here a methodology for damage valuation. Structural response of the blade is evaluated through implicit \/ explicit finite element simulations addressing its static and dynamic behavior focusing on deformation, stresses, damage mechanisms, and energy absorption. Impactor geometry is considered as cylindrical rigid body proportional mass of 2 kg, along with velocity 9.5 m\/s which represents the bird. Stresses and deflections for impact loading were found to be around 90 MPa near the hub root fillet, and 70 Mpa in the laminate blade profile. Hub and Blade both are well within the limits. The structural response at different time shows the impact force on the blade is transmitted through the lateral and longitudinal stiffeners. Displacements are found to be around 16 mm, which follow the expected pattern and are within acceptable limits.","author":["Tejas, K.","Prashanth, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tejas-Proshanth-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1979","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/insect-prey-eaten-hoary-bats-lasiurus-cinereus-prior-fatal-collisions-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3398\/064.073.0404","title":"Insect Prey Eaten by Hoary Bats (Lasiurus cinereus) Prior to Fatal Collisions with Wind Turbines","description":"Wind turbines are being deployed all across the world to meet the growing demand for energy, and in many areas, these turbines are causing the deaths of insectivorous migratory bats. One of the hypothesized causes of bat susceptibility is that bats are attracted to insects on or near the turbines. We examined insect remains in the stomachs and intestines of hoary bats (Lasiurus cinereus) found dead beneath wind turbines in New York and Texas to evaluate the hypothesis that bats die while feeding at turbines. Most of the bats we examined had full stomachs, indicating that they fed in the minutes to hours leading up to their deaths. However, we did not find prey in the mouths or throats of any bats that would indicate the bats died while capturing prey. Hoary bats fed mostly on moths, but we also detected the regular presence of beetles, true bugs, and crickets. Presence of terrestrial insects in stomachs indicates that bats may have gleaned them from the ground or the turbine surfaces, yet aerial capture of winged insect stages cannot be ruled out. Our findings confirm earlier studies that indicate hoary bats feed during migration and eat mostly moths. Future studies on bat behaviors and insect presence at wind turbines could help determine whether feeding at turbines is a major fatality risk for bats.\n\nLas turbinas e\u00f3licas se est\u00e1n implementando en todo el mundo para cumplir con la creciente demanda de energ\u00eda y en muchas \u00e1reas estas turbinas est\u00e1n provocando la muerte de murci\u00e9lagos insect\u00edvoros migratorios. Una de las posibles causas de la muerte de los murci\u00e9lagos es que son atra\u00eddos por insectos que se encuentran en las turbinas o cerca de ellas. Examinamos los restos de insectos en los est\u00f3magos y en los intestinos de los murci\u00e9lagos grises (Lasiurus cinereus) que encontramos muertos debajo de las turbinas e\u00f3licas en Nueva York y Texas para evaluar la veracidad de la hip\u00f3tesis que sostiene que los murci\u00e9lagos murieron mientras se alimentaban en las turbinas. La mayor parte de los murci\u00e9lagos que examinamos ten\u00edan el est\u00f3mago lleno, lo cual indicaba que se estaban alimentando cuando murieron. Sin embargo, no encontramos presas en la boca ni en la garganta de ninguno de los murci\u00e9lagos que indicaran que hab\u00edan muerto al capturar las presas. Los murci\u00e9lagos grises se alimentaron principalmente de polillas, detectamos la presencia regular de escarabajos, chinches de campo y grillos. La presencia de insectos terrestres en el est\u00f3mago indica que es posible que los murci\u00e9lagos los atraparan en el suelo o en las turbinas, sin embargo no se puede descartar que capturaran a los insectos alados en el aire. Nuestros hallazgos confirman estudios anteriores en los que indican que el murci\u00e9lago gris se alimenta durante la migraci\u00f3n y que consume principalmente polillas. Se necesitan estudios que se enfoquen en la conducta de los murci\u00e9lagos y en la presencia de insectos en las turbinas e\u00f3licas para determinar si los murci\u00e9lagos que se alimentan en las turbinas corren un mayor riesgo de morir.","author":["Cryan, P.","Valdez, E."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2013-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1980","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-probe-aerosphere-during-landscape-guided-altitudinal-flights","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1111\/mam.12109","title":"Bats probe the aerosphere during landscape-guided altitudinal flights","description":"As the only mammals capable of powered flight, bats make efficient use of the aerosphere. Yet, our understanding of how bats use the three-dimensional air column is sketchy. By attaching miniaturised Global Positioning System tags to cave bats near a mountain ridge in Thailand, we show that these bats perform undulating ascending and descending flights in quick succession. Bats repeatedly used mountain slopes to ascend to altitudes of more than 550 m above the ground. We infer that mountain ridges are key habitat features for some openspace foraging bats, facilitating altitudinal movements which may aid effective foraging and navigation. Therefore, the development of wind farms along mountain ridges might lead to conflicts with the conservation of some open-space foraging bats.","author":["Voigt, C.","Roeleke, M.","Bumrungsri, S."],"organization":["Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)"],"originationDate":"2017-11-09","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1981","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/no-evidence-displacement-wintering-red-breasted-geese-branta-ruficollis-pallas-1769","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.acta-zoologica-bulgarica.eu\/downloads\/acta-zoologica-bulgarica\/2017\/69-2-215-228.pdf","title":"No Evidence for Displacement of Wintering Red-breasted Geese Branta ruficollis (Pallas, 1769) (Anseriformes) at a Wind Farms Area in Northeast Bulgaria: Long-term Monitoring Results","description":"While broadly considered \u0022environmentally friendly\u0022\u009d, being a clean source of renewable energy, wind farms are not without potentially adverse effects on environmental features, notably on birds. The conservation status of the Red-breasted Goose Branta ruficollis (RBG) has changed from endangered in the past to vulnerable in 2015. At present, the hinterland of the western Black Sea coast, including Bulgaria, is one of the main wintering grounds of RBG, where flocks co-exist in the same region with around 200 wind turbines. We hypothesise that the operation of wind parks has caused displacement of wintering geese. However, according to the results of our study, RBG are using the same territory in the same number but distributed in smaller flocks. Our findings do not indicate displacement of RBG from traditional feeding grounds but are associated with the changes in the property of the land in Bulgaria and fragmentation of the crop fields, including those of wheat, which is the main feeding resource of RBG in winter. Our study provides no evidence for a displacement effect of wind turbines and describes the opportunistic strategy of wintering of RGB in the area in the last 20 years.","author":["Zahtindjiev, P.","Vasilev, V.","Marinov, M.","Ilieva, M.","Dimitrov, D.","Peev, S.","Raykov, I.","Rykova, V.","Ivanova, K.","Bedev, K.","Yankov, Y."],"organization":["Bulgarian Academy of Sciences","University of Shumen","Bulgarian Museum of Natural History (NMNHS)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1982","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-construction-meteorological-tower-fatality-study-shiloh-i-wind-project-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.solanocounty.com\/civicax\/filebank\/blobdload.aspx?blobid=8917","title":"Post-Construction Meteorological Tower Fatality Study at the Shiloh I Wind Project Site Solano County, California Final Report","description":"This report details the results of twenty-three (23) months of a post-installation study of meteorological tower related fatalities at the Shiloh I wind power project. This is the second of three fatality studies of temporary met towers installed in the Collinsville Montezuma Hills Wind Resource Area (CMHWRA). Data from the Shiloh I study is compared with data collected from the adjacent Hamilton Ranch (FPL) and Shiloh II projects (enXco). These three surveys will be used to evaluate the risk of met towers to avian species, and to provide data to help determine if ongoing studies are needed at such towers.","author":["Kerlinger, P.","Curry, R.","Hasch, A.","Wilkerson, C.","Culp, L.","Fischer, B."],"organization":["Curry \u0026 Kerlinger LLC","EDF Renewable Energy"],"originationDate":"2008-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.108889000000","-121.845000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kerlinger-et-al-2008-MetTower.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1983","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-construction-avian-monitoring-study-shiloh-i-wind-power-project-solano-county","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.solanocounty.com\/civicax\/filebank\/blobdload.aspx?blobid=8914","title":"Post-Construction Avian Monitoring Study for the Shiloh I Wind Power Project Solano County, California","description":"This report details the three-year post-construction study of the Shiloh I wind power project, the third study of the newer turbine technology in the CMHWRA the previous two year study was conducted at the adjacent High Winds project from August, 2003 through July, 2004 and from August, 2004 through July, 2005). During the first eighteen months (April 10, 2006 to October 15, 2007) of this three-year study, carcass surveys were conducted once per week at every other wind turbine, for a total of 78 rounds at 50 turbines. After this period (October 15, 2007 to April 11, 2009), carcass surveys were conducted at the second half of wind turbines, for a total of 78 complete rounds. Thus, during the 36 month study all turbines were searched at the same search interval and an equal number of times. In addition to reporting the results of the study, we provide details regarding the fulfillment of the Solano County Use Permit U-03-06, specifically Condition 40.","author":["Kerlinger, P.","Curry, R.","Jain, A.","Hasch, A.","Culp, L."],"organization":["Curry \u0026 Kerlinger LLC","Iberdrola Renewables"],"originationDate":"2009-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.108889000000","-121.845000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kerlinger-et-al-2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1984","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-temporal-patterns-golden-eagle-diets-western-united-states-implications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/10.3356\/JRR-16-38.1","title":"Spatial and Temporal Patterns in Golden Eagle Diets in the Western United States, with Implications for Conservation Planning","description":"Detailed information on diets and predatory ecology of Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) is essential to prioritize prey species management and to develop landscape-specific conservation strategies, including mitigation of the effects of energy development across the western United States. We compiled published and unpublished data on Golden Eagle diets to (1) summarize available information on Golden Eagle diets in the western U.S., (2) compare diets among biogeographic provinces, and (3) discuss implications for conservation planning and future research. We analyzed 35 studies conducted during the breeding season at 45 locations from 1940-2015. Golden Eagle diet differed among western ecosystems. Lower dietary breadth was associated with desert and shrub-steppe ecosystems and higher breadth with mountain ranges and the Columbia Plateau. Correlations suggest that percentage of leporids in the diet is the factor driving overall diversity of prey and percentage of other prey groups in the diet of Golden Eagles. Leporids were the primary prey of breeding Golden Eagles in 78% of study areas, with sciurids reported as primary prey in 18% of study areas. During the nonbreeding season, Golden Eagles were most frequently recorded feeding on leporids and carrion. Golden Eagles can be described as both generalist and opportunistic predators;theycan feedon a wide range of prey species but mostfrequently feedon abundant medium-sized prey species in a given habitat. Spatial variations in Golden Eagle diet likely reflect regional differences in prey community, whereas temporal trends likely reflect responses to long-term change in preypopulations. Evidence suggests dietary shifts from traditional (leporid) prey can have adverse effects on Golden Eagle reproductive rates. Land management practices that support or restore shrub-steppe ecosystem diversity should benefit Golden Eagles. More information is needed on nonbreeding-season diet to determine what food resources, such as carrion, are important for overwinter survival.","author":["Watson, J.","Woodbridge, B.","Kochert, M.","Steenhof, K.","Bedrosian, G.","Preston, C.","Williams, G.","Keller, K.","Crandall, R."],"organization":["US Bureau of Land Management (BLM)","Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW)"],"originationDate":"2017-09-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bedrosian-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1985","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/breathe-life-ethical-wind-power-wildlife","sourceURL":"https:\/\/vjel.vermontlaw.edu\/publications\/breath-of-life-ethical-wind-power-and-wildlife\/","title":"Breathe of Life: Ethical Wind Power and Wildlife","description":"Few ideas arouse national consensus as much as the need to establish new sources of energy. This is a security as much as economic issue since dependence on foreign oil increases America\u0027s vulnerability. Alternative oil and coal pollute, contribute to climate change, and deface the landscape through extraction. Wind power is undergoing earnest development because of its tantalizing potential to address these concerns on a renewable and clean basis. Yet this energy refreshment is not without costs. Some of these are straightforwardly subject to economic balancing. For instance, sporadic wind speed can be weighed against the costs of infrastructure and operation in site decisions. Harnessing wind power for public electricity involves efficiency assessments of proximity to existing power plants and roads. This article examines the toll on wildlife associated with inland wind power generation, an issue ethically less amenable to balancing costs and advantages. I shall identify factors that should be considered in policy decisions on research, placement, and operation of wind facilities, providing some theoretical justifications for this ethical framework. Although I leave technical and legal analyses of wind policy largely to others, those perspectives inevitably implicate ethics. I contend that making explicit the ethical underpinnings of law and policy discussions results in a more reflective, deliberative process and more justified decisions. I concentrate on inland wind power, recognizing that offshore wind development raises some overlapping wildlife concerns, especially particular avian threats. Yet inland wind generation poses special direct and habitat risks to bears, bats, and other mammals, which are worthy of separate attention. Because the best disposition of each wind project is inevitably contextual, the analysis offered here springs from a concrete case in Vermont. One can extrapolate from this particular situation to understand better the nature and importance of ethical considerations applicable to wind projects generally.","author":["Loder, R."],"organization":["Vermont Law School"],"originationDate":"2009-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1986","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/living-habitats-affected-wind-turbines-may-result-increase-corticosterone-levels","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X17305423","title":"Living in Habitats Affected by Wind Turbines May Result in an Increase in Corticosterone Levels in Ground Dwelling Animals","description":"Environmental changes and disturbance factors caused by wind turbines may act as potential stressors for natural populations of both flying and ground dwelling animal species. The physiological stress response results in release of glucocorticoid hormones. We studied two rodent species of the agricultural landscape (the common vole Microtus arvalis and the striped field mouse Apodemus agrarius) and tested the hypothesis that living in habitats affected by wind turbines results in an increase in corticosterone levels. Rodents were trapped at sites near wind turbines and in control areas. Faeces samples were collected from traps where the targeted animals were caught. For the analysis of corticosterone concentrations in the faeces, we used ELISA tests with antibodies for this hormone. The common vole showed a distinct physiological response \u2212 the individuals living near the wind turbines had a higher level of corticosterone. The striped field mouse did not show a similar response. We pointed out the main factors increasing corticosterone levels in voles and features of the studied species that may determine the differences in their reaction including: the width of the ecological niche, spatial mobility, and predation pressure. This is the first study suggesting impact of wind farms on physiological stress reactions in wild rodent populations. Such knowledge may be helpful in making environmental decisions when planning the development of wind energy and may contribute to optimization of conservation actions for wildlife.","author":["Klich, D.","Scibior, A.","Perzanowski, K.","\u0141opucki, R.","Go\u0142\u0119biowska, D."],"organization":["John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin","Warsaw University of Life Sciences (SGGW)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1987","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wind-turbines-spatial-distribution-european-hamster","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X17305873","title":"Effects of Wind Turbines on Spatial Distribution of the European Hamster","description":"Rapid worldwide growth of wind energy is an important factor that is changing agricultural areas and affecting wildlife. The impact of wind farms on ground-dwelling animals is poorly recognized. Such lack of knowledge is disadvantageous, particularly in the case of rare and protected species, because it may lead to incomplete or inappropriate conservation strategies. We studied whether wind turbines through their vibration and visual or acoustic impact contribute to fragmentation of the environment and change the spatial distribution of the European hamster Cricetus cricetus (a small mammal, threatened with extinction) within wind farm areas. The study was conducted at three wind farms in Poland. The hamsters\u0027 burrows were counted along 218 transects near turbines (up to 150 m), at intermediate distances (200\u2013500 m), and outside of wind farms (1\u20135 km). We did not find any evidence that wind farms in their operational phase cause habitat fragmentation for the European hamster and change its spatial distribution. The studied species occurred even near wind turbines, within the zone of the most intense noise and ground vibrations. Possible explanations for the spatial patterns of hamsters\u0027 distribution around wind turbines and their implications for the conservation strategy of this endangered species in contemporary agricultural habitats are discussed.","author":["Perzanowski, K.","\u0141opucki, R."],"organization":["John Paul II Catholic University of Lublin"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.600000000000","23.733300000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1988","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/responses-two-marine-top-predators-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/ece3.3389","title":"Responses of Two Marine Top Predators to an Offshore Wind Farm","description":"Quantifying the likely effects of offshore wind farms on wildlife is fundamental before permission for development can be granted by any Determining Authority. The effects on marine top predators from displacement from important habitat are key concerns during offshore wind farm construction and operation. In this respect, we present evidence for no significant displacement from a UK offshore wind farm for two broadly distributed species of conservation concern: common guillemot (Uria aalge) and harbor porpoise (Phocoena phocoena). Data were collected during boat\u2010based line transect surveys across a 360 km2 study area that included the Robin Rigg offshore wind farm. Surveys were conducted over 10 years across the preconstruction, construction, and operational phases of the development. Changes in guillemot and harbor porpoise abundance and distribution in response to offshore wind farm construction and operation were estimated using generalized mixed models to test for evidence of displacement. Both common guillemot and harbor porpoise were present across the Robin Rigg study area throughout all three development phases. There was a significant reduction in relative harbor porpoise abundance both within and surrounding the Robin Rigg offshore wind farm during construction, but no significant difference was detected between the preconstruction and operational phases. Relative common guillemot abundance remained similar within the Robin Rigg offshore wind farm across all development phases. Offshore wind farms have the potential to negatively affect wildlife, but further evidence regarding the magnitude of effect is needed. The empirical data presented here for two marine top predators provide a valuable addition to the evidence base, allowing future decision making to be improved by reducing the uncertainty of displacement effects and increasing the accuracy of impact assessments.","author":["Canning, S.","Nelson, E.","Grellier, K.","Mclean, N.","Vallejo, G.","McGregor, R.","Caryl, F."],"organization":["Natural Power"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.750000000000","-3.716667000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2025-04-11 10:55:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Vallejo-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1989","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/industrial-wind-turbine-post-construction-bird-bat-monitoring-policy-framework-canada","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479717306436","title":"Industrial Wind Turbine Post-Construction Bird and Bat Monitoring: A Policy Framework for Canada","description":"Electricity generation from wind energy has proliferated throughout North America and will continue to grow. Given Canada\u0027s expected increase in wind energy capacity, consideration of the potential adverse impacts to bird and bat populations is prudent given their sensitivity to these projects. The province of Ontario, Canada is currently the leading jurisdiction for wind energy development, and for provincial guidance on pre- and post-construction monitoring. With uniform monitoring guidance in Ontario, wind energy proponents, and third-party consultants, have developed post-construction monitoring protocols that meet provincial guidance, while also providing standardized reporting. In Atlantic Canada, post-construction guidelines vary between provinces, depending mostly on guidance from the Environment Canada Canadian Wildlife Service and relevant provincial agencies. To ensure quality post-construction monitoring results in Atlantic Canada and other provinces, it is imperative that all Canadian provinces adopt similar approaches to those employed in Ontario. This paper reviews major causes of bird and bat mortalities; reviews Canadian federal and Ontario provincial bird and bat monitoring guidelines to elucidate gaps between environmental assessment (EA) theory and application; summarizes post-construction monitoring protocols from eight bird and bat post-construction monitoring programs used in Ontario; and, proposes recommendations to support future wind development opportunities across Canada and specifically in Atlantic Canada.","author":["Paris\u00e9, J.","Walker, T."],"organization":["Dalhousie University"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.431802500000","-75.730191800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1990","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/golden-eagle-diet-breadth-reproduction-relation-fluctuations-primary-prey-abundance","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3356\/JRR-16-39.1","title":"Golden Eagle Diet Breadth and Reproduction in Relation to Fluctuations in Primary Prey Abundance in Wyoming\u0027s Bighorn Basin","description":"Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) are facing rapid environmental changes that may reduce the abundance and distribution of their prey in the western United States. Mitigation of negative effects depends in part on understanding Golden Eagle diet and the relationship between prey abundance and eagle reproduction. We documented reproduction and diet for Golden Eagles nesting in Wyoming\u0027s Bighorn Basin 2009\u20132015 and examined relationships between primary prey abundance and Golden Eagle diet breadth and reproductive rate. Annual Golden Eagle reproductive rate averaged 0.73 (range = 0.38\u20131.32) fledglings per occupied nesting territory. Cottontails (Sylvilagus spp.) dominated the diet in each year of the study, although cottontail abundance fluctuated markedly from year to year. The annual occurrence of cottontails in prey remains collected from nests ranged from 60.1% to 90.9% (frequency) and from 46% to 96% (biomass). Annual Golden Eagle diet breadth (Levins index) averaged 1.91 (frequency) and 1.98 (biomass). Both measures of annual diet breadth were negatively related to cottontail abundance. Annual eagle reproductive rate increased significantly as cottontail abundance increased (r2 = 0.78, F1,5 = 17.35, P = 0.009). Our results suggest that the abundance of cottontails was the critical factor influencing Golden Eagle reproduction in a given year during our study. To mitigate negative effects of environmental changes on the Golden Eagle population in the Bighorn Basin, we suggest maintaining or improving habitat conditions that support robust cottontail populations and improving conditions for potential alternative prey species where ecologically feasible and socially acceptable.\n\nAmplitud de Dieta y Reproducci\u00f3n en Aquila Chrysaetos en Relaci\u00f3n con las Fluctuaciones en la Abundancia de la Presa Principal en la Cuenca de Bighorn, Wyoming\n\nAquila chrysaetos se est\u00e1 enfrentando cambios ambientales r\u00e1pidos que pueden reducir la abundancia y la distribuci\u00f3n de sus presas en el oeste de los Estados Unidos. La mitigaci\u00f3n de los efectos negativos depende en parte de nuestro conocimiento de la dieta de esta especie y de la relaci\u00f3n entre la abundancia de presas y la reproducci\u00f3n del \u00e1guila. Documentamos la reproducci\u00f3n y la dieta de individuos de A. chrysaetos nidificando en la Cuenca de Bighorn, Wyoming, entre 2009 y 2015 y examinamos las relaciones entre la abundancia de la presa principal y la amplitud del espectro tr\u00f3fico y la tasa reproductiva. La tasa reproductiva anual promedio de A. chrysaetos fue de 0.73 (rango = 0.38\u20131.32) volantones por territorio reproductor ocupado. Sylvilagus spp. domin\u00f3 la dieta en cada a\u00f1o del estudio, aunque la abundancia de esta especie fluctu\u00f3 marcadamente entre a\u00f1os. La aparici\u00f3n anual de Sylvilagus spp. en los restos de presa recolectados en los nidos oscil\u00f3 desde el 60.1% al 90.9% (en frecuencia) y desde el 46% al 96% (en biomasa). La amplitud anual de la dieta de A. chrysaetos (\u00cdndice de Levins) promedi\u00f3 1.91 (en frecuencia) y 1.98 (en biomasa). Ambas mediciones de la amplitud anual de la dieta estuvieron negativamente relacionadas con la abundancia de Sylvilagus spp. La tasa reproductiva anual de A. chrysaetos aument\u00f3 significativamente a medida que la abundancia de Sylvilagus spp. increment\u00f3 (r2 = 0.78, F1,5 = 17.35, P = 0.009). Nuestros resultados sugieren que la abundancia de Sylvilagus spp. fue un factor cr\u00edtico que influy\u00f3 la reproducci\u00f3n de A. chrysaetos en cualquier a\u00f1o durante nuestro estudio. Para mitigar los efectos negativos de los cambios ambientales sobre la poblaci\u00f3n de A. chrysaetos en la Cuenca de Bighorn, sugerimos el mantenimiento o la mejora de las condiciones del h\u00e1bitat que mantengan poblaciones importantes de Sylvilagus spp. y la mejora de las condiciones para especies presa potenciales alternativas, donde sea ecol\u00f3gicamente posible y socialmente aceptable.","author":["Jones, R.","Preston, C.","Horton, N."],"organization":["Draper Natural History Museum"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.439073100000","-108.275501500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1991","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/match-between-soaring-modes-black-kites-fine-scale-distribution-updrafts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41598-017-05319-8","title":"Match Between Soaring Modes of Black Kites and the Fine-Scale Distribution of Updrafts","description":"Understanding how soaring birds use updrafts at small spatial scales is important to identify ecological constraints of movement, and may help to prevent conflicts between wind-energy development and the conservation of wildlife. We combined high-frequency GPS animal tracking and fine-spatial-scale uplift modelling to establish a link between flight behaviour of soaring birds and the distribution of updrafts. We caught 21 black kites (Milvus migrans) and GPS-tracked them while flying over the Tarifa region, on the Spanish side of the Strait of Gibraltar. This region has a diverse topography and land cover, favouring a heterogeneous updraft spatial distribution. Bird tracks were segmented and classified into flight modes from motion parameters. Thermal and orographic uplift velocities were modelled from publically available remote-sensing and meteorological data. We found that birds perform circular soaring in areas of higher predicted thermal uplift and linear soaring in areas of higher predicted orographic uplift velocity. We show that updraft maps produced from publically available data can be used to predict where soaring birds will concentrate their flight paths and how they will behave in flight. We recommend the use of this methodological approach to improve environmental impact assessments of new wind-energy installations.","author":["Mu\u00f1oz, A.","May, R.","Hanssen, F.","Santos, C.","Onrubia, A.","Wikelski, M.","Silva, J."],"organization":["Max Planck Institute for Ornithology","Universidade Federal do Par\u00e1","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","University of M\u00e1laga","Fundacion Migres","University of Konstanz","University of Porto","University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2017-07-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Santos-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1992","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparing-pre-versus-postoperational-movement-nocturnal-migrants-around-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ace-eco.org\/vol12\/iss2\/art3\/","title":"Comparing Pre- Versus Postoperational Movement of Nocturnal Migrants around a Wind Energy Facility in Northeast British Columbia, Canada","description":"We used two data-recording, open-array marine surveillance radars to track microscale movements of nocturnal migrants at a wind energy project in northeast British Columbia during the preoperational (2008-2010) and operational periods (2011-2012). Data was collected during the peak periods of spring and fall passerine migration in each year. We measured bearing and altitude of nocturnal migrants, as well as the average number of migrants flying in the airspace closest to the wind turbines. Using weather data on wind direction and strength during the periods of monitored migration, we calculated flow-assistance of wind in aiding migration. Although there was greater flow-assistance to movement in spring over fall migration, we did not find a significant difference between the preoperational and operational periods in flow-assisted flight. The altitude at which migrants flew did differ with development phase of the wind facility; migrants flew at higher altitudes during years when the turbines were operational compared to preoperational years. Although the proportion of migrants detected in the airspace 0-150 m above ground level (agl), coinciding with turbine height, did not differ with season or operational phase of the installation, there was a reduction in the proportion of migrants in the airspace just above turbines (151-300 m agl) when turbines were operational. In general, though, the overall altitudes used by migrants were typically higher than turbine height, so the adjustments we documented would only further reduce what appear to be already low levels of collision risk at this particular facility. We discuss possible reasons why this facility appeared to induce low collision risk to migrants, and how this might inform siting decisions of other wind facilities.  Comparaison des d\u00e9placements d\u0027oiseaux migrateurs nocturnes avant et apr\u00e8s la construction d\u0027un parc d\u0027\u00e9oliennes dans le nord-est de la Colombie-Britannique, Canada  Nous avons utilis\u00e9 deux radars de navigation maritime, \u00e0 tableau ouvert et pouvant enregistrer des donn\u00e9es, afin de suivre les microd\u00e9placements d\u0027oiseaux migrateurs nocturnes sur le site d\u0027un projet de parc d\u0027\u00e9oliennes dans le nord-est de la Colombie-Britannique en p\u00e9riodes pr\u00e9op\u00e9rationnelle (2008-2010) et op\u00e9rationnelle (2011-2012). Les donn\u00e9es ont \u00e9t\u00e9 r\u00e9colt\u00e9es durant les p\u00e9riodes de pointe de la migration des passereaux au printemps et \u00e0 l\u0027automne chaque ann\u00e9e. Nous avons mesur\u00e9 la position et l\u0027altitude des migrateurs nocturnes, et le nombre moyen de migrateurs volant dans l\u0027espace a\u00e9rien le plus pr\u00e8s des \u00e9oliennes. Au moyen de donn\u00e9es m\u00e9t\u00e9orologiques sur la direction et la force du vent durant les p\u00e9riodes de migration suivies, nous avons calcul\u00e9 l\u0027apport du vent pour faciliter la migration. M\u00eame si l\u0027apport du vent \u00e9tait plus \u00e9lev\u00e9 pour les d\u00e9placements au printemps qu\u0027\u00e0 l\u0027automne, nous n\u0027avons pas trouv\u00e9 de diff\u00e9rence significative pour les d\u00e9placements facilit\u00e9s par le vent entre les p\u00e9riodes pr\u00e9op\u00e9rationnelle et op\u00e9rationnelle. L\u0027altitude \u00e0 laquelle les migrateurs ont vol\u00e9 a vari\u00e9 pendant la construction du parc d\u0027\u00e9oliennes; les migrateurs ont vol\u00e9 \u00e0 des altitudes plus \u00e9lev\u00e9es durant les ann\u00e9es o\u00f9 les \u00e9oliennes \u00e9taient en op\u00e9ration comparativement aux ann\u00e9es preop\u00e9rationnelles. M\u00eame si la proportion de migrateurs d\u00e9tect\u00e9s dans l\u0027espace a\u00e9rien compris entre 0 et 150 m au-dessus du sol (AGL) - ce qui correspond \u00e0 la hauteur des \u00e9oliennes - n\u0027a pas vari\u00e9 selon les saisons ou lors de la mise en op\u00e9ration du parc, il y a eu une diminution de la proportion de migrateurs dans l\u0027espace a\u00e9rien juste au-dessus des \u00e9oliennes (151-300 m AGL) une fois que les \u00e9oliennes ont \u00e9t\u00e9 op\u00e9rationnelles. Toutefois, en g\u00e9n\u00e9ral, les altitudes utilis\u00e9es par les migrateurs \u00e9taient typiquement plus hautes que les \u00e9oliennes, de sorte que les ajustements d\u0027altitude que nous avons document\u00e9s contribueraient \u00e0 r\u00e9duire encore plus ce qui semble d\u00e9j\u00e0 \u00eatre de faibles risques de collision \u00e0 ce parc en particulier. Nous traitons des raisons possibles pouvant expliquer que ce parc semble pr\u00e9senter peu de risques de collision pour les migrateurs et comment ceci peut contribuer \u00e0 orienter les d\u00e9cisions touchant la localisation d\u0027autres parcs d\u0027\u00e9oliennes.","author":["Otter, K.","d\u0027Entremont, M.","Hartley, I."],"organization":["LGL Ltd"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.691100000000","-122.301700000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/dEntremont-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1993","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/feasibility-study-meta-analysis-red-throated-diver-displacement","sourceURL":"https:\/\/hub.jncc.gov.uk\/assets\/935d0ab2-9d2e-4a4f-a604-f446a2336358","title":"Feasibility Study for Meta-Analysis of Red-Throated Diver Displacement","description":"The aim of this report is to assess the feasibility and levels of stakeholder interest in undertaking a meta-analysis of data on displacement of red-throated divers Gavia stellata by offshore wind farms (OWFs). There may be considerable obstacles to undertaking a meta-analysis. These include: Willingness to collaborate and share data. Statistical difficulties regarding the type of meta-analysis and the feasibility of combining data sources. Buy-in from relevant stakeholders including the use of the outputs and their contribution to its delivery. These issues could pose a risk to the meta-analysis being undertaken successfully and the work contracted by JNCC sought to evaluate and quantify the extent to which that may be the case. The objectives of the work were to: 1. Assess the amount of data that has been collected on red-throated diver abundance and distribution in relation to OWFs and the availability of that data for the proposed meta-analysis. 2. Consider which statistical approaches could feasibly be used in the meta analysis, given the quality and quantity of data. 3. Assess levels of stakeholder interest in the outputs of the meta-analysis and willingness to contribute data and\/or funds to the meta-analysis. The amount of data that has been collected on red-throated diver in relation to OWFs was assessed through a literature review. The willingness of data holders to contribute data to the proposed meta-analysis and the potential support from a wider group of stakeholders was assessed through two questionnaires. The request for information through the questionnaires was predicated on an assurance of anonymity in the way that the responses were reported - the information obtained through the questionnaire is aggregated, categorised or simply not attributed to any individual or related to any individual OWF development. The consideration of statistical approaches was based on a literature review and the expertise held by Biomathematics and Statistics Scotland and the Centre for Ecology and Hydrology.","author":["Dirksen, S.","Searle, K.","Rehfisch, M.","Daunt, F.","Butler, A.","Buisson, R.","Coppack, T.","Petersen, I-K."],"organization":["APEM Ltd","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Coppack-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1994","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cedren-final-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.cedren.no\/english\/Publications?udt_5869_param_detail=11695","title":"CEDREN Final Report","description":"CEDREN is a true multi-disciplinary research centre, and all projects and activities are organised with emphasis on bringing several disciplines together, with technologists, economists, ecologists, hydrologists and political scientists joining forces to work towards common goals. The structure of the FME scheme concentrating on \u0022thematic research centres\u0022 makes this possible. We strongly believe this would not have been possible in traditionally organised research.  CEDREN has contributed to gain more knowledge in specific fields of research. However, the largest advances in research and contribution to solve challenges related to renewable energy, has clearly been in the interface between traditional disciplines. In addition, the FME scheme also creates a platform of dialogue between scientists and a broad range of end users and stakeholders from industry, authorities and the public. We have experienced that meetings, workshops and seminars organised by CEDREN, creates an open atmosphere where parties that may have contrasting views can meet for information exchange, discussion and positive dialogue.  Before CEDREN started, the strategic vision for future energy policy in Norway did not emphasize the role of hydropower as an important part of future technology. After eight years of research on environmental design of renewable energy, the attitude towards hydropower has changed. Hydropower and flexible energy systems are now given top priority, and the need for ecological and environmental design of renewables is clearly stated by the updated Norwegian Energi21 research strategy. The concept of environmental design of hydropower is in wide use by the industry and the authorities.  CEDREN has developed new and innovative solutions for hydropower technology to meet future demands for more flexible operation and increased need for balancing and storage in the electricity system. At the same time, CEDREN has developed methods, models and guidelines to assess environmental impacts and to find win-win solutions for hydropower production and the ecosystem - successfully implemented as environmental design of hydropower.  The term environmental design has been established and demonstrated not only for hydropower but also for wind power and power lines. CEDREN has developed methods and ready-to-use tools to find the most optimal routing of power transmission lines taking technical, economic, environmental and societal factors into consideration. Through new tools and methods developed in CEDREN, siting and operation of wind power plants can be better adapted to the environment, avoiding conflicts between wildlife and energy production.  One of the main tasks in CEDREN has been to educate PhD, post docs and MSc students. About 30 PhD and post docs and around 100 master students have done their thesis in a broad spectre of CEDREN topics. These candidates are now well suited to serve industry, academia and authorities in future challenges in renewable energy. A lot of the research achievements and results from CEDREN are now used in lectures and special courses at various topics at several study programmes at NTNU.  CEDREN has produced results ranging from fundamental research findings and new theoretical explanations, to computer model development and application of new methods. In-depth research in specific topics have helped understand how river-bed shear stress and lift forces work when discharge changes rapidly, how environmental conditions such as physical habitat, water temperature, ice conditions and water flow influence the growth and survival of young salmonids, and how power line corridors can be maintained to create important grazing areas for moose. These and many more examples of fundamental research all contribute to the wider understanding of the complex challenge to improve environmental conditions at the same time as increasing or maintaining the power production. CEDREN has used such new findings together with existing knowledge and international literature to systematically develop methods, models and guidelines for application, implementation and a broad use of science. This is demonstrated widely in CEDREN, for example in:    Tools for consensus based siting of wind power plants and powerlines  Tools to calculate discharge in ungauged rivers  Models to study how salmon populations are affected by river regulation and climate change  Guidance in how to make decision-making processes for renewable energy better  How to compare environmental impacts from different renewable energy sources   The above list is just showing a few of the applied results from CEDREN. Many of these results have been used in case studies, mostly in close collaboration with user partners, describing case studies as the best way of learning and implementing new methods, models and research results.  CEDREN has met with individual user partners 56 times, and the authorities 18 times throughout the project-period. Targeting academia and the scientific community, industry, authorities, stakeholders and the wider public, communication and dissemination have been a central part of CEDREN. This has resulted in:    170 scientific publications and more than 500 conference presentations  Results communicated as reports, briefs, memos, books, handbooks and booklets in order to reach target groups outside the scientific community  The \u0022Handbook for environmental design in regulated salmon rivers\u0022 which gives direct advice for users, and is translated to English and Chinese  Five textbooks summarizing and illustrating results using a popular science language very well received among end users  That CEDREN results and knowledge have been exposed in the media in more than 1000 articles.   Being a research centre has also made it easier to obtain funding and support for laboratory infrastructure and instrumentation for field work to be used by students and researchers in CEDREN. Updated laboratories and modern instruments for field work are crucial to perform in-depth and high-quality experiments and research, and for attracting excellent students and researchers to CEDREN.  32 specific innovations have been identified, ranging from an elevated perch for eagle owls to avoid electrocution, to laser scanning of tunnels and rock caverns - from new models to study energy storage by pumped hydro, to a methodology describing how to obtain environmental adapted hydropeaking.  CEDREN has been very visible internationally and the concept of thematic research centres has been highly appreciated and recognized as an excellent platform to increase international collaboration. In all projects, CEDREN has collaborated with internationally recognised research groups. A research centre offers a good platform to organise international activities, and CEDREN has hosted, organised or co-organised seminars, workshops and meetings in China, Ethiopia, France, Germany, India, Netherlands, Romania, Tanzania, Turkey, Uganda, USA and UK.  The research groups at SINTEF Energi, NINA and NTNU are all engaged in advancing the research and bringing new methods, models and solutions for environmental design of renewable energy further in the coming years.","author":["Centre for Environmental Design of Renewable Energy (CEDREN)"],"organization":["SINTEF Energy Research","Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","The Research Council of Norway"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2025-06-17 11:11:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/CEDREN-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1995","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/energy-economic-environmental-impact-wind-power-malaysia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ijasrm.com\/wp-content\/uploads\/2017\/07\/IJASRM_V2S7_302_81_87.pdf","title":"Energy, Economic and Environmental Impact of Wind Power in Malaysia","description":"Wind energy, commonly recognized as an environmentally friendly and renewable energy resource, has experienced major developments since its inception. The harnessing of energy through this resource is said to be one of the best alternatives to non-renewables like coal and fossil fuels in many countries. However, developments in wind energy have not come very far in tropical countries like Malaysia. This paper seeks to provide an overview of the possible impact wind energy could have on the local energy industry, its influence on the economy as well as the direct and indirect effects on the environment. Also, the potentiality and practicality of harnessing wind energy in Malaysia are discussed.","author":["Faizal, M.","Chelvan, R.","Amirah, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["3.756696600000","102.221762900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1996","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-noise-budgets-practice","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1111\/conl.12420","title":"Marine Noise Budgets in Practice","description":"Many countries have made statutory commitments to ensure that underwater noise pollution is at levels which do not harm marine ecosystems. Nevertheless, coordinated action to manage cumulative noise levels is lacking, despite broad recognition of the risks to ecosystem health. We attribute this impasse to a lack of quantitative management targets\u2014or \u201cnoise budgets\u201d\u2014which regulatory decision-makers can work toward, and propose a framework of risk-based noise exposure indicators which make such targets possible. These indicators employ novel noise exposure curves to quantify the proportion of a population or habitat exposed, and the associated exposure duration. This methodology facilitates both place-based and ecosystem-based approaches, enabling the integration of noise management into marine spatial planning, risk assessment of population-level consequences, and cumulative effects assessment. Using data from the first international assessment of impulsive noise activity, we apply this approach to herring spawning and harbor porpoise in the North Sea.","author":["Merchant, N.","Faulkner, R.","Martinez, R."],"organization":["Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Merchant-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1997","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/do-you-hear-what-i-see-vocalization-relative-visual-detection-rates-hawaiian-hoary","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/ece3.3196","title":"Do You Hear What I See? Vocalization Relative to Visual Detection Rates of Hawaiian Hoary Bats (Lasiurus cinereus semotus)","description":"Bats vocalize during flight as part of the sensory modality called echolocation, but very little is known about whether flying bats consistently call. Occasional vocal silence during flight when bats approach prey or conspecifics has been documented for relatively few species and situations. Bats flying alone in clutter\u2010free airspace are not known to forgo vocalization, yet prior observations suggested possible silent behavior in certain, unexpected situations. Determining when, why, and where silent behavior occurs in bats will help evaluate major assumptions of a primary monitoring method for bats used in ecological research, management, and conservation. In this study, we recorded flight activity of Hawaiian hoary bats (Lasiurus cinereus semotus) under seminatural conditions using both thermal video cameras and acoustic detectors. Simultaneous video and audio recordings from 20 nights of observation at 10 sites were analyzed for correspondence between detection methods, with a focus on video observations in three distance categories for which accompanying vocalizations were detected. Comparison of video and audio detections revealed that a high proportion of Hawaiian hoary bats \u201cseen\u201d on video were not simultaneously \u201cheard.\u201d On average, only about one in three visual detections within a night had an accompanying call detection, but this varied greatly among nights. Bats flying on curved flight paths and individuals nearer the cameras were more likely to be detected by both methods. Feeding and social calls were detected, but no clear pattern emerged from the small number of observations involving closely interacting bats. These results may indicate that flying Hawaiian hoary bats often forgo echolocation, or do not always vocalize in a way that is detectable with common sampling and monitoring methods. Possible reasons for the low correspondence between visual and acoustic detections range from methodological to biological and include a number of biases associated with the propagation and detection of sound, cryptic foraging strategies, or conspecific presence. Silent flight behavior may be more prevalent in echolocating bats than previously appreciated, has profound implications for ecological research, and deserves further characterization and study.","author":["Cryan, P.","Gorresen, P.","Bonaccorso, F.","Montoya-Aiona, K."],"organization":["University of Hawaii","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gorresen-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1998","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/increasing-evidence-bats-actively-forage-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/peerj.com\/articles\/3985\/","title":"Increasing Evidence that Bats Actively Forage at Wind Turbines","description":"Although the ultimate causes of high bat fatalities at wind farms are not well understood, several lines of evidence suggest that bats are attracted to wind turbines. One hypothesis is that bats would be attracted to turbines as a foraging resource if the insects that bats prey upon are commonly present on and around the turbine towers. To investigate the role that foraging activity may play in bat fatalities, we conducted a series of surveys at a wind farm in the southern Great Plains of the US from 2011-2016. From acoustic monitoring we recorded foraging activity, including feeding buzzes indicative of prey capture, in the immediate vicinity of turbine towers from all six bat species known to be present at this site. From insect surveys we found Lepidoptera, Coleoptera, and Orthoptera in consistently high proportions over several years suggesting that food resources for bats were consistently available at wind turbines. We used DNA barcoding techniques to assess bat diet composition of (1) stomach contents from 47 eastern red bat (Lasiurus borealis) and 24 hoary bat (Lasiurus cinereus) carcasses collected in fatality searches, and (2) fecal pellets from 23 eastern red bats that were found on turbine towers, transformers, and tower doors. We found that the majority of the eastern red bat and hoary bat stomachs, the two bat species most commonly found in fatality searches at this site, were full or partially full, indicating that the bats were likely killed while foraging. Although Lepidoptera and Orthoptera dominated the diets of these two bat species, both consumed a range of prey items with individual bats having from one to six insect species in their stomachs at the time of death. The prey items identified from eastern red bat fecal pellets showed similar results. A comparison of the turbine insect community to the diet analysis results revealed that the most abundant insects at wind turbines, including terrestrial insects such as crickets and several important crop pests, were also commonly eaten by eastern red and hoary bats. Collectively, these findings suggest that bats are actively foraging around wind turbines and that measures to minimize bat fatalities should be broadly implemented at wind facilities.","author":["Bennett, V.","Hale, A.","Korstian, J.","Williams, D.","Foo, C.","Schildt, A."],"organization":["Texas Christian University"],"originationDate":"2017-11-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Foo-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/1999","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/conservation-guidance-indiana-bat-myotis-sodalis","sourceURL":"https:\/\/core.ac.uk\/display\/158322082?source=1\u0026algorithmId=15\u0026similarToDoc=4819669\u0026similarToDocKey=CORE\u0026recSetID=c6ade5a4-35c5-40c1-a7da-1deb0f226a12\u0026position=2\u0026recommendation_type=same_repo\u0026otherRecs=143479346,158322082,5014131,475675729,482682082","title":"Conservation Guidance for Indiana Bat (Myotis sodalis)","description":"Illinois Natural History Survey has undertaken a project producing documents that provide conservation guidance for listed species in Illinois for the Illinois Department of Natural Resources. The project is titled: Conservation Guidance for Species in Greatest Need of Conservation (SGNC) T- 96-R-001. The primary purpose of guidance documents is to provide various project developers\/land managers with information on the species, how their actions may impact the species, and how they can minimize\/mitigate\/monitor those impacts. In addition, the documents may be useful for identifying research needs to direct various funds, as a first step towards recovery planning, or for informing the general public. We intend the documents to be comprehensive and inclusive of scientific and experiential knowledge of the species and its conservation. The documents incorporate information on current conservation efforts, conservation opportunities and research needs. Interviews with stakeholders were held to identify information that should be included in conservation guidance documents. We prioritized document production for species that were frequently the subject of Incidental Take Authorizations or were consulted on in the IDNR\u0027s EcoCat program. Initial literature reviews was conducted to produce first draft documents. Then a list of potential document reviewers, including academic taxa experts, conservation organizations, private consultants, and government agency staff, was compiled for each species. The documents underwent review and revision. What follows is the final document providing conservation guidance for Indiana bat, which was reviewed by 7 individuals.","author":["Henning, B.","Hinz Jr., L.","Kath, J."],"organization":["Illinois Department of Natural Resources","Illinois Natural History Survey","Illinois Department of Natural Resources","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2017-08-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Henning-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2000","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-construction-avian-monitoring-study-shiloh-i-wind-power-project-solano-county-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.solanocounty.com\/civicax\/filebank\/blobdload.aspx?blobid=8913","title":"Post-Construction Avian Monitoring Study for the Shiloh I Wind Power Project Solano County, California, Two Year Report","description":"The Shiloh I Wind Power Project Area is situated on roughly 6,800 acres of agricultural land in the Montezuma Hills, near Rio Vista in Solano County, California. The project consists of 100 wind turbines rated at 1.5 MW each for a total capacity of up to 150 MW. Seventy \u2013six of the turbines are mounted on 80 meter towers and twenty-four are on 65 meter towers. These turbines are arrayed on similar landscape and habitat as that in which approximately 510 turbines of the older technology are deployed along with more than 200 turbines of the newer technology.\n\nThe Collinsville-Montezuma Hills Wind Resource Area (WRA) consists of approximately 40,300 acres of area. The current development area of the existing wind plants including Shiloh I, consists of approximately 17,300 acres. The landscape consists of rolling hills with elevations ranging between near sea level adjacent to the Sacramento River to about 250 - 300 feet (61-91 m) in elevation above sea level. Turbines are placed on the highest ground and do not run through low-lying valleys. Moving from south to north the terrain becomes more uniform with less elevation differential between the ridges and the valleys. On the west is the Suisun Marsh. The terrain is generally uniform along the east-west axis.\n\nThe land is privately owned and is largely agricultural. Where turbines and project roads are located the land use is rotating agricultural crops and grazed pastures. Crops include wheat, barley, hay, safflower and fallow fields. A multi-year rotation is the norm with wheat, fallow, and grazing alternating being the regime used most often. There are some isolated wetlands (mostly cattail marsh) and one small reservoir within the project boundaries, but these are not within the project footprint.\n\nTreed areas within the project are limited to the areas close to homes and in a few valleys. No trees were removed to construct the project. Many of the trees are non-native eucalyptus, olive, and other species, although some native oaks and junipers are present near homes. There is a large olive grove to the east of the project area. These treed habitats provide havens and nesting substrate for birds that do not use farmland and other birds that forage in tilled fields.\n\nThis report details the results of the first two years of a three-year post-construction study of the Shiloh I wind power project. This is the third fatality study of the newer turbine technology installed in the Collinsville Montezuma Hills Wind Resource Area (CMHWRA).","author":["Kerlinger, P.","Curry, R.","Jain, A.","Hasch, A.","Wilkerson, C.","Culp, L.","Fischer, B."],"organization":["Curry \u0026 Kerlinger LLC","PPM Energy"],"originationDate":"2008-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.101901500000","-121.860397200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kerlinger-et-al-2008.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2001","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-construction-avian-monitoring-study-shiloh-i-wind-power-project-solano-county-1","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.solanocounty.com\/civicax\/filebank\/blobdload.aspx?blobid=8912","title":"Post-Construction Avian Monitoring Study for the Shiloh I Wind Power Project Solano County, California Year One Final Report","description":"The Shiloh I Wind Power Project Area is situated on roughly 6,800 acres of agricultural land in the Montezuma Hills, near Rio Vista in Solano County, California. The project consists of 100 wind turbines rated at 1.5 MW each for a total capacity of up to 150 MW. All one hundred turbines went on-line in March 2006. This report details the first year results of a three-year post-construction study of the Shiloh I wind power projects. This is the third fatality study of the newer turbine technology installed in the Collinsville Montezuma Hills Wind Resource Area (CMHWRA). These turbines are arrayed on similar landscape and habitat as that in which approximately 510 turbines of the older technology are deployed along with more than 200 turbines of the newer technology. During the first year of this study, carcass surveys were conducted once per week at every other wind turbine tower between April 10, 2006 and April 5, 2007, for a total of 52 near-complete rounds at fifty wind turbine towers. A total of 173 avian incidents were recorded by searchers during standardized wind turbine tower surveys, representing 35 species plus 13 unidentified passerines. Of the 35 species, 5 were raptor species including American Kestrel, Red-tailed Hawk, Northern Harrier, Golden Eagle, and Barn Owl. There were a total of 30 raptor incidents, 121 songbird incidents involving 22 species (plus unidentified species) and 22 incidents involving a mix of 8 other avian species found during this one year study. Remains of fifty-two bats were found at wind turbine towers by searchers during standardized surveys, representing 4 different species including Hoary Bat, Mexican Free-tailed Bat, Western Red Bat, and Silver-haired Bat.","author":["Kerlinger, P.","Curry, R.","Hasch, A.","Wilkerson, C.","Culp, L.","Fischer, B."],"organization":["Curry \u0026 Kerlinger LLC","PPM Energy"],"originationDate":"2007-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.108889000000","-121.845000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Passerines","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kerlinger-et-al-2007.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2002","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/identifying-peaks-bat-activity-new-application-satscan","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.publish.csiro.au\/WR\/WR16194","title":"Identifying Peaks in Bat Activity: A New Application of SaTScan","description":"Context: Identifying key spatio\u2013temporal periods of an organism\u2019s activity is an important focus of many ecological studies. Bat activity, as assessed by passive acoustic monitoring, can be extremely variable and currently there exists no agreed-upon method for identifying periods of high activity.\n\nAims: We proposed a new application for the space\u2013time scan statistic (SaTScan) as an objective technique for identifying peak periods of bat activity. We aimed to test the validity of SaTScan as a method for identifying peaks in bat activity and demonstrate its use for assessing species-specific temporal patterns of activity.\n\nMethods: To evaluate the effectiveness of SaTScan for detecting peaks in activity, we compared SaTScan to peaks identified with percentile thresholds. We evaluated peaks in activity across three scales: within nights; among nights at a site; and among sites. We applied SaTScan to demonstrate analysis of species-specific activity as further use of this technique.\n\nKey results: SaTScan was effective at identifying peak time periods that included the majority of the high activity minutes. Timing of peaks of activity was most consistent for Myotis lucifugus during swarming and Lasiurus borealis during migration. All other activity for five species at three sites was indicative of foraging activity, with peaks in the first 5\u00a0h after sunset.\n\nConclusions: SaTScan can be a valuable tool for quickly identifying peaks in acoustic activity of bats, with an objective, replicable and statistically sound method that can be applied at many temporal and spatial scales.\n\nImplications: This tool has the potential for many more applications in ecology. Beyond acoustic analyses of bat activity, this technique could easily identify peaks in a research or management context, such as study activity among habitats, commercial developments or years at a single site.","author":["Adams, A.","Fenton, M."],"organization":["Texas A\u0026M University","University of Western Ontario"],"originationDate":"2017-06-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2003","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-environmental-impacts-renewable-energy-sourced-electric-production-province","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tojsat.net\/journals\/tojsat\/articles\/v07i04\/v07i04-11.pdf","title":"Evaluation of the Environmental Impacts of Renewable Energy Sourced Electric Production for the Province of Sinop\/Turkey","description":"Demand for energy is increasing day by day in our country and worldwide due to many factors, such as population growth, industrialization, technological progress, more people live in the city (Mann and Teilmann, 2013). From the perspective of our country, our energy production from domestic sources cannot meet the energy that we consume (Y\u00fcksel, 2010). In order to get to the level of the industrialized countries in the development process of our country, the need to increase energy production and energy consumption compared to the current situation (Acaro\u011flu, 2013). In developed countries, there have been made investments at a great rate in renewable energy sources, to meet the energy demand of electricity production and to minimize the damage to the environment (Kenisarina et al. 2006). Adding essence and affordable, environment- friendly alternative energy sources to our energy production policy, it is an inevitable necessity to reduce our dependence foreign countries (Y\u00fcksel and Kaygusuz, 2011). In addition, national and international legal and statutory contracts are also supportive of this orientation (Anonim1, 2016). It makes attractive alternative energy sources that they are unlimited, renewable and not cause environmental pollution. As a result of these developments in the energy sector in our country, a large number of theoretical and practical studies have been made on environmentally friendly energy sources (Akda\u011f and G\u00fcler 2010). Wind energy is the energy source that in the focus of this studies (\u0130lkili\u00e7, 2012). Wind energy stands out in terms of more economical, easy installation and operation of power plants when compared with other forms of energy (G\u00fcler, 2009). Researchers have done a lot of work for the regions where they thought it was the wind potential in sub-issues such as, cost, environmental impacts and site selection (\u00d6zgener, 2010). In our country, with increase of the support in the wind energy field of, increasing numbers of new wind power plants have been established every day without huge installed power capacities. In Turkey, annual production capacity of wind energy is 11 552 GWh at the end of 2015. The installed capacity of wind power plants in operation by the end of the year 2015 4.503 MW (Anonim2, 2016).  In this study it was analyzed and evaluated of the possible environmental impact of a wind energy power generation system with taking into account recent data that may be established in Sinop.","author":["Alcan, Y."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.022582300000","35.133444200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2004","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-options-mitigating-take-golden-eagles-wind-energy-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3356\/JRR-16-76.1","title":"A Review of Options for Mitigating Take of Golden Eagles at Wind Energy Facilities","description":"Wind energy development has expanded rapidly in the past decade, becoming a significant source of electricity, and a major element in a global strategy to reduce carbon emissions and the effects of climate change. Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) can collide with wind turbines, adding to the existing and substantial mortality from other anthropogenic sources. These collisions are a conservation concern, and they pose a legal risk to wind energy companies and potentially hamper development in areas where the range of Golden Eagle overlaps areas of high wind energy potential. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, through the revised Eagle Rule and the Eagle Conservation Plan Guidance, has designed a mitigation strategy for eagle conservation that allows wind energy companies to obtain incidental take permits. However, the strategy is challenged by a lack of data supporting scientifically rigorous strategies to mitigate eagle take, where mitigation is defined as efforts to avoid and minimize take, and compensate for unavoidable take. We review the steps and options a wind developer can consider to mitigate predicted eagle collisions with wind turbines consistent with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service\u0027s revised Eagle Rule and Eagle Conservation Plan Guidance. Most of these options have limited or no scientific support and their effect on reducing risk of eagle collisions is unknown. We briefly describe approaches for evaluating technology intended to minimize eagle take and for developing options to offset unavoidable eagle take that are quantifiable and verifiable. Because estimates of Golden Eagle fatalities at many wind energy projects are low, research to evaluate mitigation measures needs to be coordinated and collaborative across multiple wind energy facilities to improve our ability to produce scientifically robust mitigation strategies. The impetus for these efforts is improving implementation and compliance with the revised Eagle Rule, but the results have benefits beyond Golden Eagles, for raptors and their ecological communities.","author":["Allison, T.","Cochrane, J.","Lonsdorf, E.","Sanders-Reed, C."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)","University of Minnesota"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Allison-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2005","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/agricultural-benefits-aviation-safety-realizing-potential-continent-wide-radar","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/bioscience\/article\/67\/10\/912\/3896239","title":"From Agricultural Benefits to Aviation Safety: Realizing the Potential of Continent-Wide Radar Networks","description":"Migratory animals provide a multitude of services and disservices - with benefits or costs in the order of billions of dollars annually. Monitoring, quantifying, and forecasting migrations across continents could assist diverse stakeholders in utilizing migrant services, reducing disservices, or mitigating human - wildlife conflicts. Radars are powerful tools for such monitoring as they can assess directional intensities, such as migration traffic rates, and biomass transported. Currently, however, most radar applications are local or small scale and therefore substantially limited in their ability to address large-scale phenomena. As weather radars are organized into continent-wide networks and also detect \u0022biological targets,\u0022 they could routinely monitor aerial migrations over the relevant spatial scales and over the timescales required for detecting responses to environmental perturbations. To tap these unexploited resources, a concerted effort is needed among diverse fields of expertise and among stakeholders to recognize the value of the existing infrastructure and data beyond weather forecasting.","author":["Dokter, A.","Reynolds, D.","Shamoun-Baranes, J.","Bauer, S.","Chapman, J.","Alves, J.","Menz, M.","Sapir, N.","Ciach, M.","Pettersson, L.","Kelly, J.","Leijnse, H."],"organization":["Swiss Ornithological Institute","University of Exeter","University of Greenwich","University of Aveiro","University of Iceland","University of Amsterdam","Cornell University","University of Bern","University of Western Australia","University of Haifa","Lund University","University of Oklahoma","Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bauer-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2006","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/climate-change-wind-energy-conservation-survey-conflicting-issues","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bsbo.org\/uploads\/3\/0\/8\/0\/30807041\/climate_change_wind_energy_and_conservation.pdf","title":"Climate Change, Wind Energy, and Conservation: A Survey of Conflicting Issues","description":"There is a multiplicity of program offerings by many groups which intend to contribute to the remediation and mitigation of climate change. This multiplicity brings into play a very real problem of its own: the lack of concerted and coordinated action among the groups. The actions and planning by these groups are neither on the same track, nor do they seem to share common goals. Some of these groups are the US Department of Energy, the US Fish \u0026 Wildlife Service, the American Wind Energy Association, the American Bird Conservancy, and the National Audubon Society to name just a very few. It is the purpose of this paper to bring together a \u00e2\u20ac\u0153state of the art\u00e2\u20ac\u009d description of the wind energy efforts, and to relate how they are often at odds with each other, particularly with respect to the conservation of habitat and wildlife species and the mitigation of climate change.\n\nOne approach to mitigate climate change is the transformation of the energy industry toward renewable energy generation of electricity, specifically going from traditional coal-fired generation to wind energy generation. There are a number of problems that have arisen from this course of action: (1) the lack of coordination among agencies and business groups responsible for siting, installing and operating wind farms; (2) the lack of public understanding of the consequences of installing a wind farm of many turbines as compared to a small number of turbines; (3) the lack of environmental regulatory authority over the businesses installing wind farms; (4) a general lack of understanding of the true nature of the environmental impact of wind farms, both to humans and other species, particularly birds and bats; and (5) most fundamentally, the unabashed lack of environmental care or concern on the part of some wind farm businesses, as if somehow a wind farm were inherently good for the planet no matter what.\n\nTaken together these problems have led to a disturbing trend among scientists of all sorts, from engineers to ornithologists, which is that they and their work become a mere marketing tool for the wind farm industry, subordinating science to concerns about public perception and industry growth. This is particularly true in the misuse of environmental impact assessments as tools to allow wind projects to proceed without due caution or concern for the environment and the species that reside there. Granted, some of the science involved in predicting the effect of wind farms on bird and bat species is imprecise at best; but in the last analysis we know one thing for sure: there are good places and bad places to put wind farms. Herein lies the crux of the dilemma. The wind industry, like all successful capitalist groups in a fairly uncontrolled business environment, sees unfettered growth as good in itself. Mitigating climate change does not require that kind of growth, however; it only requires enough growth in the wind industry to cover the increase in energy requirements of the growing world economies and replacement of energy produced by non-renewable sources, i.e. coal.\n\nOne of the effects of climate change, coupled with a growing world economy, has been the disappearance\/displacement and extinction of various plants and animal species. Wind farms are specifically harmful to birds and bats, killing them by the hundreds of thousands here in the United States alone. One reason this is so unpalatable to us who are \u0022conservationist\u0022\u009d is that the killing is largely avoidable. There are simply places that wind farms should not be installed because they are too close to too many birds or bats. As an analogy: we can tell you it is not safe for your children to play in the street. We may not be able to tell you for certain that it is safe for them to play in the front yard instead because we haven\u0027t any information about your front yard. We would have to get that information before allowing the children to play there. So it is with wind farms: we know they should not be placed in bird and bat migration routes, along sea shores or lake shores, near nesting areas, or in wintering spots. That\u0027s where birds and bats congregate at different times of the year. We can\u0027t tell you for sure whether there is a safe place for them nearby until after doing a scientific, rigorous environmental impact study for a proposed \u0022front yard.\u0022\n\nWhat is to follow is a survey of conflicting issues in the wind industry from the perspective of conservationists concerned for the welfare of bird and bat species. It is a description of the current wind energy technology with the hope of illuminating the issues both sides are facing, and with the hope that a resolution to them may be developed intelligently. We conservationists refuse to relegate the lives of birds and bats to collateral damage when to do so is unjustified and so avoidable. If even a small fraction of the scientific rigor used to engineer the complex systems within wind turbines were applied to proper siting of turbines, this discussion would not be necessary. However, since the wind industry has avoided or been negligent of scientific integrity in their siting choices, we conservationists must defend the birds and bats and their role in sustaining the ecosystems of which they are an integral part.","author":["Bauman, D."],"organization":["Black Swamp Bird Observatory"],"originationDate":"2017-03-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bauman-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2007","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/guidelines-consideration-bats-environmental-impact-assessment-wind-farms-brazil","sourceURL":"https:\/\/revistas.ufrj.br\/index.php\/oa\/article\/view\/13817","title":"Guidelines for Consideration of Bats in Environmental Impact Assessment of Wind Farms in Brazil: A Collaborative Governance Experience from Rio Grande Do Sul State","description":"In recent years Brazil has become the third largest market for new investments in wind power in the world. Though a change in the national policy towards more sustainable energy sources is desirable, wind energy is not free from negative impacts. According to studies done in the temperate region, bats are negatively affected by wind farms, due to fatalities resulting from direct collision with the turbines or from barotrauma. If in many countries national and international laws follow guidelines for consideration of potential impacts of wind farms on bats, and even consider potential minimization and mitigation schemes, the Brazilian current normative for wind farm licencing presents vague approaches on this matter. With a few exceptions, states are the main responsible for the licencing processes. In this context, a joint initiative in Rio Grande do Sul, the state with the third highest wind power generation in Brazil, put together the Secretary of State for the Environment and Sustainable Development of Rio Grande do Sul, the Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul, and the Brazilian Society for the Study of Bats to set reference terms for consideration of bats in impact assessments of wind farms in the state. Consensus was built from a collaborative process resulting from a two-day workshop involving technicians and academics with expertise in bat biology, conservation and management. Guidelines were divided into pre-installation, construction, and operation phases, considering the decisions to make, potential impacts and relevant questions to answer, methodological and technical recommendations or constraints, and current gaps in knowledge. Here we describe this collaborative experience hoping it can be replicable in other Brazilian states and used by other potentially impacting sectors. With few adaptations and considering specificities in the regional bat fauna and environmental conditions, the proposed reference terms can be used elsewhere in Brazil.","author":["Pereira, M.","Bernard, E.","Aguiar, L.","Barros, M.","Chaves, T.","Rui, A.","Dotto, J.","Braun, A.","Barbosa, J.","Kindel, A.","Sana, D."],"organization":["Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS)","Universidade Federal de Pernambuco (UFPEL)","Universidade Federal de Pelotas (UFP)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-31.258723800000","-53.350677000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bernard-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2008","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-collision-power-lines-estimating-carcass-persistence-detection-associated-ground","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ecs2.1966","title":"Bird collision with power lines: estimating carcass persistence and detection associated with ground search surveys","description":"The quantification of bird mortality due to collision with power lines is complicated by the heterogeneity of survey methods used and the bias related to searching for carcasses on the ground (e.g.,carcass persistence and imperfect detection by observers). To estimate the bias associated with ground search surveys, we conducted three 30-d trials to test carcass persistence by placing and monitoring carcasses of red-legged partridges (Alectoris rufa) and common pheasants (Phasianus colchicus) below power lines at 14 sites. We also conducted two detection experiments, testing the ability of 19 observers to detect bird carcasses. We used survival analysis and generalized linear mixed-effects models to investigate the effects of site, habitat, carcass size, and survey period on both carcass persistence and detection. We also investigated the effect of carcass age on carcass persistence and the effect of the observer on carcass detection. Our findings show significant variations in carcass persistence between sites and survey periods, as well as significant interaction between these variables. The daily carcass persistence probability was highly variable between sites, with an up to eight fold variation. Carcass detection increased with increasing carcass size and was significantly affected by the micro habitat surrounding the carcass; it also varied between observers. These findings suggest that both carcass persistence and detection vary strongly and unpredictably at a small scale. As a result, conservation managers should be encouraged to conduct carcass persistence and detection experiments on sites where they aim to produce unbiased estimates of bird mortality below power lines, and these trials should be carried out in conditions similar to the mortality survey. A large-scale, unbiased, and accurate estimate of bird collision mortality due to power lines may require substantial field effort, with a survey frequency of more than once a week.","author":["Borner, L.","Duriez, O.","Besnard, A.","Robert, A.","Carrere, V.","Jiguet, F."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-12-09","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Borner-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2009","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/golden-eagles-changing-world","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3356\/0892-1016-51.3.193","title":"Golden Eagles in a Changing World","description":"In recent years, Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) have emerged as a conservation concern in the United States, particularly in the West. Our nation\u0027s effort to become more energy independent has involved a significant expansion in the development of domestic sources of both renewable and non-renewable energy. The influence of energy development, particularly wind energy, taken together with other anthropogenic sources of mortality, including electrocution on power distribution lines, contaminants, collisions with vehicles, and illegal shooting, may be resulting in declining Golden Eagle populations (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service [U.S.F.W.S.] 2016a). To achieve the objective of \u0022stable or increasing breeding populations\u0022 promulgated under the Bald and Golden Eagle Protection Act (Eagle Act; 16 U.S.C. 668-668d) and appurtenant regulations (U.S.F.W.S. 2009, 2016b; hereafter Eagle Rule), the U.S.F.W.S. will require a greater understanding of Golden Eagle population dynamics, movement patterns, and genetic connectivity across populations, and conservation practices that reliably reduce or mitigate population limiting factors (U.S.F.W.S. 2016a, 2016b). In addition, state, federal, and tribal wildlife and land management agencies need this information to support conservation planning for Golden Eagles at local and regional scales.","author":["Collopy, M."],"organization":["University of Nevada","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Preston-et-al-2017.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Preston-et-al-2017_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2010","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/north-lowther-energy-initiative-bat-survey-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/northlowther.co.uk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2017\/06\/NLEI-ES_Appendix-8.3-Bat-Report_PV.pdf","title":"North Lowther Energy Initiative Bat Survey Report","description":"These surveys were undertaken to inform the ecological assessment for the North Lowther Energy Initiative Environmental Impact Assessment. This report presents the results of the bat survey work undertaken 18th May and 15th September 2015 (inclusive) at the site. Fat bat species were recorded during the temporal spatial surveys: common pipistrelles (Pipistrellus pipistrellus), soprano pipistrelle (Pipistrellus pygmaeus), Nyctalus Pipistrelle, Myotis and possible Nathusius\u0027 pipistrelle (Pipistrellus nathusii). The daytime inspection recorded two properties at Duntercleuch House and Clackleith with bat roost potential. The Bat Activity Index (BAI) for all species is considered to be low for the Development Area.","author":["Cooke, L."],"organization":["MacArthur Green","North Lowther Energy Initiative"],"originationDate":"2017-05-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.387818700000","-3.855082700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Cooke-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2011","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/2016-2017-status-assessment-update-wind-vision-roadmap","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrel.gov\/docs\/fy18osti\/69026.pdf","title":"2016-2017 Status Assessment and Update on the Wind Vision Roadmap","description":"In March 2015, the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) released Wind Vision: A New Era for Wind Power in the United States (DOE 2015), which explores a scenario in which wind provides 10% of U.S. electricity in 2020, 20% in 2030, and 35% in 2050. The Wind Vision report also includes a roadmap of recommended actions aimed at pursuit of the vision and its underlying wind-deployment scenario. The roadmap was compiled by the Wind Vision project team, which included representatives from the industrial, electricpower, government-laboratory, academic, environmental-stewardship, regulatory, and permitting stakeholder groups. The roadmap describes high-level activities suitable for all sectors with a stake in wind power and energy development. It is intended to be a\u0022living document,\u0022 and DOE expects to engage the wind community from time to time to track progress. During 2016, DOE\u0027s Wind Energy Technologies Office (WETO) engaged the National Renewable Energy Laboratory and Renewable Energy Consulting Services, Inc. to help in assessing the roadmap\u0027s status and needs. Central to this assessment were several informal working sessions focused on key topical areas included in the roadmap. These sessions, listed here in chronological order (except as noted) based on the dates of the sessions, addressed all the action areas included in the 2015 roadmap, including: Wind Electricity Delivery and Integration Wind Power Resources and Site Characterization Supply Chain, Manufacturing, and Logistics Workforce Development Wind Siting and Permitting (with a separate session on wildlife issues) Wind Plant Technology Advancement (coupled with Wind Power Performance, Reliability, and Safety) Wind Power Performance, Reliability, and Safety (coupled with Wind Plant Technology Advancement) Collaboration, Education, and Outreach (addressed in all sessions) Policy Analysis (addressed in most sessions).","author":["DeMeo, E."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)"],"originationDate":"2017-11-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/DeMeo-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2012","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/markov-model-planning-permitting-offshore-wind-energy-case-study-radio-tracked-terns","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479717301147","title":"A Markov Model for Planning and Permitting Offshore Wind Energy: A Case Study of Radio-Tracked Terns in the Gulf of Maine, USA","description":"Quantifying and managing the potential adverse wildlife impacts of offshore wind energy is critical for developing offshore wind energy in a sustainable and timely manner, but poses a significant challenge, particularly for small marine birds that are difficult to monitor. We developed a discrete-time Markov model of seabird movement around a colony site parameterized by automated radio telemetry data from common terns (Sterna hirundo) and Arctic terns (S.\u00a0paradisaea), and derived impact functions that estimate the probability of collision fatality as a function of the distance and bearing of wind turbines from a colony. Our purpose was to develop and demonstrate a new, flexible tool that can be used for specific management and wind-energy planning applications when adequate data are available, rather than inform wind-energy development at this site. We demonstrate how the tool can be used 1) in marine spatial planning exercises to quantitatively identify setback distances under development scenarios given a risk threshold, 2) to examine the ecological and technical trade-offs of development alternatives to facilitate negotiation between objectives, and 3) in the U.S. National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) process to estimate collision fatality under alternative scenarios. We discuss model limitations and data needs, and highlight opportunities for future model extension and development. We present a highly flexible tool for wind energy planning that can be easily extended to other central place foragers and data sources, and can be updated and improved as new monitoring data arises.","author":["Baker, E.","Cranmer, A.","Smetzer, J.","Welch, L."],"organization":["University of Massachusetts","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2017-05-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.454825700000","-67.854865400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2013","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/orjip-bird-collision-avoidance-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.carbontrust.com\/resources\/bird-collision-avoidance-study","title":"ORJIP Bird Collision and Avoidance Study","description":"The ORJIP BCA study, 2014 - 2017, has been designed to improve the evidence base for seabird avoidance behaviour and collisions around offshore wind farms, with the aim of informing impact assessment and supporting consenting applications for the offshore wind industry.  Driven by ambitious renewable energy targets and reduced costs, the offshore wind industry has experienced a significant growth over the last 20 years, particularly in Europe, where the majority of installed capacity can be found.  The consenting process of offshore wind projects requires the identification, prediction and evaluation of the environmental effects of those proposed projects. In this context, the risk of birds colliding with turbine blades during operation is potentially one of the most significant environmental impacts predicted. In order to quantify bird collision risk, collision risk models (CRM) are used and parametrised with technical specifications of the turbines, bird densities, morphology and flight behaviour of existing bird populations present on site. The CRM e.g. the Band model (Band 2012), provides an estimate of the potential number of bird collisions likely to occur at a proposed wind farm assuming that birds take no action to avoid colliding with the wind turbines. In order to obtain realistic risk estimates, the collision risk modelling is subsequently corrected to take account of behavioural responses of birds to the presence of wind farms (i.e. avoidance). However, there is considerable uncertainty over the scale of such impacts due to the relatively few offshore monitoring studies so far undertaken, that have gathered empirical evidence.  As the number of offshore wind farm projects increases, it is widely recognised that in order to minimise consenting risks for future project applications, further robust evidence on the avoidance behaviour of seabirds is required to inform CRM and environmental impact assessments.  This study has centred its work around four main phases:    Development of a bird monitoring system, that allows detecting and tracking bird movements at the species level in and around an operational offshore wind farm, including testing and validation of video monitoring coupled with radar technology under different weather and visibility conditions.  Monitoring of bird behaviour at Thanet Offshore Wind Farm, deploying a multiple sensor monitoring system partly operated by experienced seabird observers (laser rangefinders and radar equipment), and partly automated through the collection of video evidence, with a focus on five target species: Northern Gannet, Black-legged Kittiwake and three species of large gulls (Lesser Black-backed Gull, Herring Gull, Great Black-backed Gull).  Development of an appropriate methodology for data analysis to quantify empirical avoidance behaviour termed as empirical avoidance rates (EARs), based on existing research and equipment \/ data limitations.  Formulation of recommendations on the use of empirical evidence gathered by this study in support of collision risk assessments in offshore wind planning applications.   This report presents the final publication of the study and presents findings associated with these four phases.","author":["Skov, H.","Hein\u00e4nen, S.","Norman, T.","Ward, R.","M\u00e9ndez-Rold\u00e1n, S.","Ellis, I."],"organization":["Offshore Renewables Joint Industry Programme (ORJIP)","The Carbon Trust"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2025-07-28 08:58:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Skov-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2014","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/role-wave-energy-converter-farms-coastal-protection-eroding-deltas-guadalfeo-southern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0959652617323090","title":"The Role of Wave Energy Converter Farms on Coastal Protection in Eroding Deltas, Guadalfeo, Southern Spain","description":"Many worldwide coasts are under erosion with climate projections indicating that damages will rise in future decades. Specifically, deltaic coasts are highly vulnerable systems due to their low-lying characteristics. This paper investigates the role of wave energy converter (WEC) farms on the protection of an eroding gravel-dominated deltaic coast (Guadalfeo, southern Spain). Eight scenarios with different alongshore locations of the wave farm were defined and results were compared with the present (no farm) configuration of the coast. Assuming that storm conditions drive the main destruction to the coast, we analysed the impact of the most energetic storm conditions and quantified the effects of the location of the farm. Significant wave heights in the lee of the farm were calculated by means of a calibrated wave propagation model (Delft3D-Wave); whereas wave run-up and morphological changes in eight beach profiles were quantified by means of a calibrated morphodynamic model (XBeach-G). The farm induces average reductions in significant wave heights at 10\u00a0m water depth and wave run-up on the coast down to 18.3% and 10.6%, respectively, in the stretch of beach most affected by erosion problems (Playa Granada). Furthermore, the erosion of the beach reduces by 44.5% in Playa Granada and 23.3% in the entire deltaic coast. Combining these results with previous works at the study site allowed selecting the best alternative of wave farm location based not only on coastal protection but also on energetic performance criteria. This work, whose methodology is feasibly extensible to other coasts worldwide, provides insights into the role of the alongshore location of WEC farms on wave propagation, run-up and morphological storm response of deltaic coasts.","author":["Bergillos, R.","L\u00f3pez-Ruiz, A.","Medina-L\u00f3pez, E.","Mo\u00f1ino, A.","Ortega-S\u00e1nchez, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-01-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.722617600000","-3.580423100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2015","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-environmental-impact-analysis-tidal-current-energy-turbines-china","sourceURL":"https:\/\/iopscience.iop.org\/article\/10.1088\/1755-1315\/121\/4\/042003\/meta","title":"Development and the Environmental Impact Analysis of Tidal Current Energy  Turbines in China","description":"Chinese government pays more attentions to renewable energies (RE) in the context of increasing energy demand and climate change problems. As a promising RE, the utilization of marine renewable energy (MRE) is engaging in the world, including the wave energy and tidal current energy mainly. At the same time, the tidal current energy resources in China are abundant. Thus, the utilization of tidal current energy becomes an inevitable choice for China to meet the challenge of global climate change. The Renewable Energy Law (amendment) and \u0022Twelfth Five-Year\u0022 Plan of Renewable Energy Development (2011-2015) were released in recent years in China, the tidal current energy are successfully implemented in China, including the R\u0026D and pilot projects. After the summary of the status of tidal current energy converters in recent years in China, especially the devices being in the open sea test. The environmental impact study in China is also introduced in order to offer reference for the environmental impact assessment of tidal current power generation.","author":["Liu, Y.","Ma, C.","Jiang, B."],"organization":["National Ocean Technology Center (NOTC)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.155577400000","122.207783900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Liu-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2016","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/male-greater-prairie-chickens-adjust-their-vocalizations-presence-wind-turbine-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1650\/CONDOR-17-56.1","title":"Male Greater Prairie-Chickens Adjust their Vocalizations in the Presence of Wind Turbine Noise","description":"The potential for wind energy facilities to affect species of grouse in the grasslands of the Great Plains of North America is a conservation concern. Communication by male Greater Prairie-Chickens (Tympanuchus cupido pinnatus) is essential for lek mating displays and includes low-frequency vocalizations that could be disrupted by wind turbine noise. We studied the effects of wind turbine noise on the boom, cackle, whine, and whoop vocalizations of male Greater Prairie-Chickens recorded at 14 leks located 703 m to 23 km away from a wind energy facility near Ainsworth, Brown County, Nebraska, USA, in 2013 and 2014. First, we assessed ambient sound levels at our study sites. Wind turbine noise contributed to the soundscape; leks","author":["Brown, M.","Whalen, C.","McGee, J.","Powell, L.","Walsh, E."],"organization":["University of Nebraska"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.548447300000","-99.861531600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2017","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/electromagnetic-field-emf-impacts-elasmobranch-shark-rays-skates-american-lobster","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Zoe_Hutchison\/publication\/323855234_Electromagnetic_Field_EMF_Impacts_on_Elasmobranch_shark_rays_and_skates_and_American_Lobster_Movement_and_Migration_from_Direct_Current_Cables\/links\/5aafb957a6fdcc1bc0bd022a\/Electromagnetic-Field-EMF-Impacts-on-Elasmobranch-shark-rays-and-skates-and-American-Lobster-Movement-and-Migration-from-Direct-Current-Cables.pdf","title":"Electromagnetic Field (EMF) Impacts on Elasmobranch (shark, rays, and skates) and American Lobster Movement and Migration from Direct Current Cables","description":"In 2014, The University of Rhode Island and key partners were contracted by the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) to conduct a two-year study entitled \u0022Electromagnetic Field (EMF) Impacts on Elasmobranch (sharks, rays, and skates) and American Lobster Movement and Migration from Direct Current Cables.\u0022  The BOEM-URI project had five major components:    A synthesis of existing information published subsequent to the report entitled \u0022 Effects of EMFs from Undersea Power Cables on Elasmobranchs and Other Marine Species\u0022 (Normandeau et al., 2011) for BOEM on EMF and the potential effects on marine species;  Field surveys to characterize the EMF from two high voltage direct current (HVDC) cables; the Cross Sound Cable (CSC) and the Neptune Cable;  A computer model to predict the EMF generated by HVDC cables and a comparison of EMF model predictions with EMF field measurements for validation and to determine if the model could be extrapolated to higher capacity cables that are likely to be installed in the future;  A statistically robust field experiment that would detect potential effects of EMF from HVDC cables on the movements of marine species (American lobster, Homarus americanus and Little skate, Leucoraja erinacea) of concern; and  An integration, interpretation and evaluation of the multidisciplinary findings.","author":["King, J.","Sigray, P.","Gill, A.","He, H.","Hutchison, Z.","Gibson, C."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island","Cranfield University","FOI (Swedish Defence Research Agency)","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hutchison2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2018","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-collisions-wind-turbines-mountainous-area-related-bird-movement-intensities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320717311047","title":"Bird Collisions at Wind Turbines in a Mountainous Area Related to Bird Movement Intensities Measured by Radar","description":"Bird collisions at wind turbines are perceived to be an important conservation issue. To determine mitigation actions such as temporary shutdown of wind turbines when bird movement intensities are high, knowledge of the relationship between the number of birds crossing an area and the number of collisions is essential. Our aim was to combine radar data on bird movement intensities with collision data from a systematic carcass search.\n\nWe used a dedicated bird radar, located near a wind farm in a mountainous area, to continuously record bird movement intensities from February to mid-November 2015. In addition, we searched the ground below three wind turbines (Enercon E-82) for carcasses on 85 dates and considered three established correction factors to extrapolate the number of collisions.\n\nThe extrapolated number of collisions was 20.7 birds\/wind turbine (CI-95%: 14.3\u201329.6) for 8.5\u202fmonths. Nocturnally migrating passerines, especially kinglets (Regulus sp.), represented 55% of the fatalities. 2.1% of the birds theoretically exposed to a collision (measured by radar at the height of the wind turbines) were effectively colliding.\n\nCollisions mainly occurred during migration and affected primarily nocturnal migrants. It was not possible to assign the fatalities doubtlessly to events with strong migration. Fresh-looking carcasses were found after nights with both strong and weak bird movement intensities, indicating fatalities are not restricted to mass movement events (onshore). Rather, it is likely that an important factor influencing collision risk is limited visibility due to weather conditions. Local and regional visibility should be considered in future studies and when fine-tuning shutdown systems for wind turbines.","author":["Liechti, F.","Peter, D.","Stark, H.","Aschwanden, J.","Steuri, T.","Schmid, B."],"organization":["Swiss Ornithological Institute"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.194783000000","6.967052000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Passerines","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2019","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/scotland-new-scotland-constructing-sectoral-marine-plan-tidal-energy-nova-scotia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X17300970?via%3Dihub","title":"From Scotland to New Scotland: Constructing a Sectoral Marine Plan for Tidal Energy for Nova Scotia","description":"Competing usage of marine space has prompted several coastal nations to implement marine spatial planning (MSP). While progressive governments promote the deployment of renewable energy technologies (RETs) in order to meet renewable energy capacity and greenhouse gas emissions reductions targets, offshore RETs become another player operating within a \ufb01nite and already stressed marine environment. This paper applies the sectoral MSP process employed by Scotland to the Nova Scotia context in order to draft a MSP for the province\u0027s tidal energy sector. Applicable legislation is reviewed in order to establish the regulatory authorities with powers to plan for both the marine development and ecosystem protection agendas. The scoping process identi\ufb01es suitable resource areas based on the operational parameters of commercially viable tidal current turbines (TCTs), while the sustainability appraisal identi\ufb01es areas of cultural, industry, ecological, and socioeconomic constraint and exclusion. Plan option areas emanating from the applied methodology demonstrated a 238.345 km2 (98.1%) increase in suitable TCT deployment area than the marine renewable energy areas identi\ufb01ed in Nova Scotia\u0027s Marine Renewable Energy Act which did not undertake such a methodology.","author":["Sangiuliano, S.","Mastrantonis, S."],"organization":["York University"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.681986600000","-63.744311000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:27:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2020","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-energy-environmental-emissions-typical-offshore-wind-farm-china","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0959652618300969","title":"The Life-Cycle Energy and Environmental Emissions of a Typical Offshore Wind Farm in China","description":"China\u0027s vast untapped offshore wind energy and the concentration of electricity consumers in coastal regions make offshore wind power a promising solution to the country\u0027s cleaner power transition. However, the potential energy and environmental emissions of offshore wind farms have not been thoroughly investigated. Thus, this study employed a process-based life cycle inventory (LCI) model to calculate the life-cycle energy and emissions of offshore wind power in China based on the country\u0027s first offshore wind energy project. Results showed that the life-cycle energy of the studied wind farm was 2.28E+09\u00a0MJ, or 0.39 MJ\/kwh, with emission intensities of 25.5\u00a0g CO2-eq\/kWh for GHG, 0.02\u202fg\/kWh for PM2.5, 0.06\u202fg\/kWh for SO2 and 0.09\u202fg\/kWh for NOx. The life-cycle footprints are dominated by the manufacture of wind turbines and foundation materials production. Compared to onshore wind farms, offshore wind power plants usually have greater life-cycle electricity yields, but their levelized energy and environmental footprints are less favorable. The green manufacturing of China\u0027s steel sector, and scientific operation and maintenance programs of wind facilities contribute to greening offshore wind power. Results of this study facilitate robust policy making of government authorities and contribute to the green deployment of offshore wind technologies in China.","author":["Wang, C.","Chang, Y.","Yang, J.","Zhang, L.","Hao, Y."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-04-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["29.055590700000","122.559075800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment","Chemicals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2021","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbine-sensor-array-monitoring-avian-bat-collisions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/we.2160","title":"Wind Turbine Sensor Array for Monitoring Avian and Bat Collisions","description":"Assessment of avian and bat collisions with wind turbines is necessary to ensure that the benefits of renewable wind power generation are not outweighed by mortality of protected species. An onboard, integrated multisensor system capable of providing detection of turbine collision events, including taxonomic information, was developed. The conceptual design of a multisensor system including a vibration sensing node, an optics node, and an bioacoustic node with an event\u2010driven trigger architecture was field\u2010tested on utility\u2010scale wind turbines. A pixel density computational model was built to estimate the spatial coverage and target resolution to the optimized configuration for camera placement. Field test results of the vibration node showed that nearly half of the recorded impact events were successfully identified by visual inspection and running short\u2010time Fourier transform on recorded vibration signals. The remaining undetected impact events were masked under background noise due to low impact energy and high background noise of the operating turbine, which result in subsequent low signal\u2010to\u2010noise ratio. Our results demonstrate the feasibility of triggering the system through single impact event sensed by vibration sensors.","author":["Suryan, R.","Albertani, R.","Hu, C."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2022","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-hydrodynamic-morphological-impacts-tidal-stream-development-ramsey-sound","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148118304014","title":"Modelling the Hydrodynamic and Morphological Impacts of a Tidal Stream Development in Ramsey Sound","description":"A number of sites around the UK are being considered for development of tidal stream energy, one of which is Ramsey Sound off the coast of Pembrokeshire, South Wales. The Sound was used to test the prototype of the Delta Stream by Tidal Energy Ltd. After initial testing, a 10 MW tidal array was proposed at St David\u2019s Head. To investigate any possible environmental impacts of the array due to energy extraction, a case study of the Pembrokeshire coast was performed using a high-resolution depth averaged hydrodynamic model, Telemac2D, to investigate changes to hydrodynamics and morphodynamics. Results show that the proposed array of nine tidal energy converters will cause alterations to eddy propagation leading to changes in the velocity field up to 24km from the tidal array. Changes in morphodynamics are predicted through alterations to the bed shear stress. Changes to the mean and maximum bed shear stress, over a 30-day period, are found to be more localised and extend 12km from the array. These changes indicate that the proposed tidal array will lead to localised sediment accumulation and will act as a barrier to sediment transport, with potential consequences for the benthic ecology of the region.  Click here for more information on Ramsey Sound.","author":["Venugopal, V.","Smith, H.","Xiao, Q.","Haverson, D.","Bacon, J."],"organization":["Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)","University of Exeter","University of Edinburgh","University of Strathclyde"],"originationDate":"2018-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.877780000000","-5.326110000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2023","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-chemicals-released-marine-environment-dielectric-elastomers-useful-active","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0304389417305587","title":"Assessment of Chemicals Released in the Marine Environment by Dielectric Elastomers Useful as Active Elements in Wave Energy Harvesters","description":"A series of elastomers, either natural or synthetic (some of them commercial, while others prepared in the laboratory), suitable for use as active elements in devices for wave energy harvesting, were evaluated concerning their behavior and effects on the marine environment. In this aim, the elastomer films, initially evaluated regarding their aspect, structure, surface wettability, and tolerance of microorganisms growth, were immersed in synthetic seawater (SSW) within six months for assessing compounds released. There were analyzed the changes occurred both in the elastomers and salt water in which they were immersed. For this, water samples taken at set time intervals were analyzed by using a sequence of sensitive spectral techniques: UV\u2013vis, IR, and in relevant cases 1H NMR and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI\u2013MS), able to detect and identify organic compounds, while after six months, they were also investigated from the point of view of aspect, presence of metal traces, pH, and biological activity. The changes in aspect, structure and morphology of the dielectric films at the end of the dipping period were also evaluated by visual inspection, IR spectroscopy by using spectral subtraction method, and SEM-EDX technique.","author":["Zaltariov, M.","Bele, A.","Vasiliu, L.","Gradinaru, L.","Vornicu, N.","Racles, C.","Cazacu, M."],"organization":["Petru Poni Institute of Macromolecular Chemistry"],"originationDate":"2018-01-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Chemicals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2024","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mitigating-negative-impacts-tall-wind-turbines-bats-vertical-activity-profiles","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0192493","title":"Mitigating the negative impacts of tall wind turbines on bats: Vertical activity profiles and relationships to wind speed","description":"Wind turbines represent a source of hazard for bats, especially through collision with rotor blades. With increasing technical development, tall turbines (rotor-swept zone 50\u2013150 m above ground level) are  becoming widespread, yet we lack quantitative information about species active at these heights, which impedes proposing targeted mitigation recommendations for bat-friendly turbine operation. We investigated vertical activity profiles of a bat assemblage, and their relationships to wind speed, within a major valley of the European Alps where tall wind turbines are being deployed. To monitor bat activity we  installed automatic recorders at sequentially increasing heights from ground level up to 65 m, with the goal to determine species-specific vertical activity profiles and to link them to wind speed. Bat call sequences were analysed with an automatic algorithm, paying particular attention to mouse-eared bats (Myotis myotis and Myotis blythii) and the European free-tailed bat (Tadarida teniotis), three locally rare species. The most often recorded bats were the Com-mon pipistrelle (Pipistrellus pipistrellus) and Savi\u2019s pipistrelle (Hypsugo savii). Mouse-eared bats were rarely recorded, and mostly just above ground, appearing out of risk of collision.T. teniotis had a more evenly distributed vertical activity profile, often being active at rotor level, but its activity at that height ceased above 5 ms-1 wind speed. Overall bat activity in the rotor-swept zone declined with increasing wind speed, dropping below 5% above 5.4 ms-1. Collision risk could be drastically reduced if nocturnal operation of tall wind turbines would be restricted to wind speeds above 5 ms-1. Such measure should be implemented year-round because T. teniotis remains active in winter. This operational restriction is likely to cause only small energy production losses at these tall wind turbines, although further analyses are needed to assess these losses precisely.","author":["Wellig, S.","Miltner, D.","Kohle, O.","Glaizot, O.","Braunisch, V.","Obrist, M.","Arlettaz, R.","Nussle, S."],"organization":["University of Bern"],"originationDate":"2018-03-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.122029700000","7.098675700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2025","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/testing-performances-automated-identification-bat-echolocation-calls-request-prudence","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X17301401","title":"Testing the Performances of Automated Identification of Bat Echolocation Calls: A Request for Prudence","description":"Echolocating bats are surveyed and studied acoustically with bat detectors routinely and worldwide, yet identification of species from calls often remains ambiguous or impossible due to intraspecific call variation and\/or interspecific overlap in call design. To overcome such difficulties and to reduce workload, automated classifiers of echolocation calls have become popular, but their performance has not been tested sufficiently in the field. We examined the absolute performance of two commercially available programs (SonoChiro and Kaleidoscope) and one freeware package (BatClassify). We recorded noise from rain and calls of seven common bat species with Pettersson real-time full spectrum detectors in Sweden. The programs could always (100%) distinguish rain from bat calls, usually (68\u2013100%) identify bats to group (Nyctalus\/Vespertilio\/Eptesicus, Pipistrellus, Myotis, Plecotus, Barbastella) and usually (83\u201399%) recognize typical calls of some species whose echolocation pulses are structurally distinct (Pipistrellus pygmaeus, Barbastella barbastellus). Species with less characteristic echolocation calls were not identified reliably, including Vespertilio murinus (16\u201326%), Myotis spp. (4\u201393%) and Plecotus auritus (0\u201389%). All programs showed major although different shortcomings and the often poor performance raising serious concerns about the use of automated classifiers for identification to species level in research and surveys. We highlight the importance of validating output from automated classifiers, and restricting their use to specific situations where identification can be made with high confidence. For comparison we also present the result of a manual identification test on a random subset of the files used to test the programs. It showed a higher classification success but performances were still low for more problematic taxa.","author":["Russo, D.","Rydell, J.","Jones, G.","Nyman, S.","Ekl\u00f6f, J."],"organization":["Lund University","University of Bristol","Seconda Universit\u00e0 degli Studi di Napoli"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2026","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-impact-bat-activity-leading-high-losses-habitat-use-biodiversity-hotspot","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0925857417306572","title":"Wind turbines impact bat activity, leading to high losses of habitat use in a biodiversity hotspot","description":"Previous studies have mainly focused on bat mortality through collision by wind turbines, and very few studies have assessed the indirect impacts on bat activity and on foraging habitat availability. Also, there is a global lack of knowledge on the vulnerability of tropical bat fauna due to wind energy production, even though it is well known that windpower can affect bat communities and biodiversity hotspots are widespread in the tropics. We present one of the first studies to quantify the indirect impact of wind farms on insectivorous bats in tropical hotspots of biodiversity. Bat activity was compared between wind farm sites and control sites, via ultrasound recordings at stationary points. The activity of bent winged bats (Miniopterus sp.) and wattled bats (Chalinolobus sp.) were both significantly lower at wind turbine sites. The result of the study demonstrates a large effect on bat habitat use at wind turbines sites compared to control sites. Bat activity was 20 times higher at control sites compared to wind turbine sites, which suggests that habitat loss is an important impact to consider in wind farm planning. We strongly recommend that the loss of the foraging habitat loss is considered in mitigation hierarchy (avoiding, reducing, offsetting) when compensating for negative impacts of wind farms.","author":["Millon, L.","Kerbiriou, C.","Colin, C.","Brescia, F."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Habitat Change","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2027","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/raptor-interactions-wind-energy-case-studies-around-world","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3356\/JRR-16-100.1","title":"Raptor Interactions with Wind Energy: Case Studies from Around the World","description":"The global potential for wind power generation is vast, and the number of installations is increasing rapidly. We review case studies from around the world of the effects on raptors of wind-energy development. Collision mortality, displacement, and habitat loss have the potential to cause population-level effects, especially for species that are rare or endangered. The impact on raptors has much to do with their behavior, so careful siting of wind-energy developments to avoid areas suited to raptor breeding, foraging, or migration would reduce these effects. At established wind farms that already conflict with raptors, reduction of fatalities may be feasible by curtailment of turbines as raptors approach, and offset through mitigation of other human causes of mortality such as electrocution and poisoning, provided the relative effects can be quantified. Measurement of raptor mortality at wind farms is the subject of intense effort and study, especially where mitigation is required by law, with novel statistical approaches recently made available to improve the notoriously difficult-to-estimate mortality rates of rare and hard-to-detect species. Global standards for wind farm placement, monitoring, and effects mitigation would be a valuable contribution to raptor conservation worldwide.","author":["Ferrer, M.","Nyg\u00e5rd, T.","Huso, M.","Johnston, N.","Katzner, T.","Farmer, C.","Smit-Robinson, H.","Kolar, P.","Watson, R.","Hunt, W."],"organization":["The Peregrine Fund","Boise State University","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","University of Northern British Columbia","BirdLife International","DNV GL","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Watson-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2028","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/location-offshore-wave-power-devices-structures-epifaunal-assemblages","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166916300522?via%3Dihub","title":"The location of offshore wave power devices structures epifaunal assemblages","description":"With large-scale development of offshore wave power conversion, artificial structures become more common in the open sea. To examine how wave power devices may be colonized by epifaunal organisms, 21 concrete foundations used for anchoring wave power generators were studied during two years, 2007 and 2008. The foundations were placed in two different clusters, located north and south within the Lysekil test site at the Swedish west coast. The degree to which early recruits covered the foundations and the succession of epibenthic communities were documented during two years. A succession in colonization over time was observed, with a higher degree of cover in the northern location. Furthermore, the northern location showed an increase in number of individuals, number of species and in Shannon-Wiener diversity in 2008. Dominant organisms on the foundations were the serpulid tubeworms (Pomatoceros triqueter) and barnacles (Balanus sp.). This comprehensive large-scale study about succession and colonization patterns on wave power foundations suggests that the location of wave energy devices affects colonization patterns. This gives indications on settlement patterns on already operating and planned offshore wave power parks further off the coasts.","author":["Langhamer, O."],"organization":["Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.204170000000","11.379440000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-10 11:59:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2029","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/2017-marine-hydrokinetic-instrumentation-workshop-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrel.gov\/docs\/fy18osti\/70591.pdf","title":"2017 Marine Hydrokinetic Instrumentation Workshop Report","description":"The third Marine Hydrokinetic Instrumentation Workshop was held at Florida Atlantic University\u2019s Sea Tech Campus in Dania Beach, Florida, from February 28 to March 1, 2017. The workshop brought together 37 experts in marine energy measurement, testing, and technology development to present and discuss the instrumentation and data-processing needs of the marine energy industry. The goals of the meeting were to:    Better understand the state of instrumentation, measurement, and data-processing capabilities for testing, assessment, monitoring, and operation of marine energy converters (MECs)  Identify gaps (problems, deficiencies, or lack of capabilities) in marine hydrokinetic (MHK) measurement and data-processing technology, assess the impact of those gaps, and prioritize the gaps for solutions  Define pathways for developing solutions to the gaps  Present progress made to address gaps identified at previous workshops.   The workshop was comprised of a plenary session followed by two focused breakout sessions. The half-day plenary session reviewed findings from prior instrumentation workshops, presented research activities that aim to fill previously identified gaps, and had industry experts present the state of the marine energy measurement technologies. The bulk of the workshop was spent in the breakout sessions where the workshop participants split into three groups 1) wave energy converter (WEC) field testing and operation, 2) current energy converter (CEC) field testing and operation, and 3) laboratory testing (WEC and CEC). The first session defined and ranked gaps in measurement technology and data processing. The second session defined ways to develop measurement and data-processing technologies to fill the gaps.  The first section of this report provides the background for the workshop, review s the objectives, and details the structure. The body of this report details the findings from the workshop in terms of gaps i n existing technology, capabilities, and infrastructure. The findings also include descriptions of the benefits of closing the gaps and potential solutions to those gaps. A final section describes the common themes that emerged in several of the findings.  The workshop identified 28 primary findings in the areas of    Information dissemination and data processing  Standards, guidelines, and recommended practices  Enhanced measurement capabilities  New measurement and testing capabilities   Four cross-cutting themes emerged from many of the findings:    Limited knowledge transfer: a wealth of experience, knowhow, and tools have been generated from laboratory and field testing, yet much of this knowledge is not disseminated or is hard to find. There is a need to disseminate knowledge so the MHK industry can avoid repeating mistakes, minimize duplicate efforts, and leverage the experience of others to help accelerate technology development and reduce costs while not compromising intellectual property.  High cost of measurement: marine grade instruments can be expensive and strain tight test budgets; often leading to a tradeoff between the breadth and duration of a test and the number and quality of measurements. By adopting mechanisms to increase instrument availability, share instrument costs between projects, increase the measurement capabilities of existing instruments, adapt instruments for MHK application, share knowledge of instrument use, and standardize measurements, measurement costs can be reduced.  Better measurement capabilities at low technology readiness levels (TRLs): measurement capabilities for smaller-scale models (1:10 and smaller) typically used at low TRLs are inadequate and sensors either do not exist, are too expensive, or adversely impact device response. For technologies to advance at smaller TRLs, new measurement technologies are needed to enable accurate and affordable measurements.  Open-source tools for unified data processing and analysis: data processing and analysis is typically performed on a project-by-project basis using custom code with unique processing and visualization methods. By encouraging sharing of vetted data reduction, processing, QA, and visualizations code and by adopting standard methods, the MHK industry would be able to accelerate the analysis and increase the credibility of test results.   The gaps, impacts of the gaps, benefits of closing the gaps, and solutions to the gaps contained within this report were synthesized from the preworkshop survey and input from workshop participants. The findings are intended to be informative and used by government bodies, industry and the research community to help advance MHK testing and measurement \u2013 they do not necessarily represent the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Water Power Technologies Office (WPTO) views or program objectives.","author":["Rieks, J.","Driscoll, F.","Mauer, E."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NREL-2018-Instrumentation-Workshop.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2030","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/first-situ-passive-acoustic-monitoring-marine-mammals-during-operation-tidal-turbine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v590\/p247-266\/","title":"First in situ Passive Acoustic Monitoring for Marine Mammals during Operation of a Tidal Turbine in Ramsey Sound, Wales","description":"The development of marine renewables has raised concerns regarding impacts on wildlife, and environmental monitoring is often required. We examined 3 mo of continuous passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) data collected at the Tidal Energy Ltd. DeltaStream turbine deployment in Ramsey Sound, UK. We aimed to assess the performance of the PAM system at an operational turbine, describe the 3D movements and behaviours of small cetaceans in the vicinity of the turbine, and model changes in detection rates against temporal and environmental variables. The PAM system was designed to acoustically detect, classify and track porpoises and dolphins via their vocalisations within a ~100 m radius of the turbine. In total, 247 small cetacean encounters were identified from click detections, which were also used to reconstruct the spatial movements of porpoises and dolphins, including close approaches to the turbine. Not all hydrophones were functional, which limited the ability to localise porpoise clicks; the probability of detecting and localising a click decreased by 50% at a range of ~20 m. Mechanical sounds on the turbine may have alerted cetaceans of its presence. In models examining acoustic detection patterns, the tidal state, time of day, low low-frequency noise levels and moon phase best explained the acoustic presence of porpoises. The limited duration of turbine operation yielded insufficient data to understand the effect of turbine rotation on animal presence and movement near the turbine. This is the first description of how small cetaceans behave and move around a tidal turbine, and we present recommendations regarding how PAM can be used to improve environmental monitoring at future tidal energy sites.","author":["Gillespie, D.","Sparling, C.","Macaulay, J.","Malinka, C.","Joy, R."],"organization":["Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","SMRU Consulting","Simon Fraser University","Aarhus University"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.877780000000","-5.326110000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2031","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/corrections-fish-school-area-mean-volume-backscattering-strength-simulation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsy009\/4924926","title":"Corrections of Fish School Area and Mean Volume Backscattering Strength by Simulation of an Omnidirectional Multi-Beam Sonar","description":"Fish school descriptors extracted from omnidirectional multi-beam data are biased due to beam width-related effects, and echotraces are distorted in a range-dependent manner that is a function of transducer intrinsic properties, as well as fish school characteristics. This work investigates a simulation approach that models the three-dimensional insonification of fish schools by an omnidirectional fishery sonar in order to assess the bias in measuring two key morphometric and energetic descriptors, namely the horizontal cross-sectional area of schools and their mean volume backscattering strength. Simulated fish schools of different sizes and backscattering properties were insonified at various ranges from the multi-beam transducer, outputting volume backscattering strength echograms. The simulated data were used to develop empirical models that correct the examined descriptors using only information extracted from the observed echotraces. Depending on the difference between the observed mean volume backscattering strength of a school and the echogram processing threshold, mean absolute percentage errors in measured area and volume backscatter reduced from 100.7% and 79.5% to 5.2% and 6.4%, respectively. The mean volume backscattering strength of a school is a key parameter for obtaining fish density estimates, and the results highlight the need for descriptor corrections to better interpret the multi-beam data.","author":["Trygonis, V.","Kapelponis, Z."],"organization":["University of the Aegean","Hellenic Centre for Marine Research (HCMR)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-08","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2032","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/utility-point-count-surveys-predict-wildlife-interactions-wind-energy-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X18300244","title":"The utility of point count surveys to predict wildlife interactions with wind energy facilities: An example focused on golden eagles","description":"Wind energy development is rapidly expanding in North America, often accompanied by requirements to survey potential facility locations for existing wildlife. Within the USA, golden eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) are among the most high-profile species of birds that are at risk from wind turbines. To minimize golden eagle fatalities in areas proposed for wind development, modified point count surveys are usually conducted to estimate use by these birds. However, it is not always clear what drives variation in the relationship between on-site point count data and actual use by eagles of a wind energy project footprint. We used existing GPS-GSM telemetry data, collected at 15\u202fmin intervals from 13 golden eagles in 2012 and 2013, to explore the relationship between point count data and eagle use of an entire project footprint. To do this, we overlaid the telemetry data on hypothetical project footprints and simulated a variety of point count sampling strategies for those footprints. We compared the time an eagle was found in the sample plots with the time it was found in the project footprint using a metric we called \u201cerror due to sampling\u201d. Error due to sampling for individual eagles appeared to be influenced by interactions between the size of the project footprint (20, 40, 90 or 180\u202fkm2) and the sampling type (random, systematic or stratified) and was greatest on 90\u202fkm2 plots. However, use of random sampling resulted in lowest error due to sampling within intermediate sized plots. In addition sampling intensity and sampling frequency both influenced the effectiveness of point count sampling. Although our work focuses on individual eagles (not the eagle populations typically surveyed in the field), our analysis shows both the utility of simulations to identify specific influences on error and also potential improvements to sampling that consider the context-specific manner that point counts are laid out on the landscape.","author":["Katzner, T.","Millsap, B.","Sur, M.","Belhoff, J.","Bjerre, E."],"organization":["Boise State University","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.987266700000","-117.411197500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2033","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/collision-sensitive-niche-profile-worst-affected-bird-groups-wind-turbine-structures","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41598-018-22178-z","title":"Collision sensitive niche profile of the worst affected bird-groups at wind turbine structures in the Federal State of Brandenburg, Germany","description":"Biodiversity-related impacts at wind energy facilities have increasingly become a cause of conservation concern, central issue being the collision of birds. Utilizing spatial information of their carcass detections at wind turbines (WTs), we quantified the detections in relation to the metric distances of the respective turbines to different land-use types. We used ecological niche factor analysis (ENFA) to identify combinations of land-use distances with respect to the spatial allocation of WTs that led to higher proportions of collisions among the worst affected bird-groups: Buntings, Crows, Larks, Pigeons and Raptors. We also assessed their respective similarities to the collision phenomenon by checking for overlaps amongst their distance combinations. Crows and Larks showed the narrowest \u201ccollision sensitive niche\u201d; a part of ecological niche under higher risk of collisions with turbines, followed by that of Buntings and Pigeons. Raptors had the broadest niche showing significant overlaps with the collision sensitive niches of the other groups. This can probably be attributed to their larger home range combined with their hunting affinities to open landscapes. Identification of collision sensitive niches could be a powerful tool for landscape planning; helping avoid regions with higher risks of collisions for turbine allocations and thus protecting sensitive bird populations.","author":["Durr, T.","Bose, A.","Klenke, R.","Henle, K."],"organization":["Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research (UFZ)"],"originationDate":"2018-02-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.049849800000","13.805127400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bose-etal-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2034","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-assessment-anthropogenic-noise-sources-using-field-recording-method","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/content\/dav\/aaua\/2018\/00000104\/00000001\/art00004","title":"Underwater Assessment of Anthropogenic Noise Sources Using a Field Recording Method","description":"Concern about underwater noise has been increasing due to the high number of projects needing environmental impact assessment to know how the underwater environment could be affected by pollutant noise, especially when living beings are involved. Since in countries like Chile there is no current legislation about anthropogenic underwater noise, the main objective of this work was to face this topic in Chile. To achieve it, noise sources present in rivers from Valdivia City-located in south center Chile-were evaluated. Underwater and airborne noise emissions measurement, coming from a high number of anthropogenic noise sources, both mobil and stationary, were carried out using a field method. It uses a digital recorder through which the noise emitted from the evaluated source is recorded. Subsequently, using a software, the desired noise descriptors are obtained. Measurements were carried out both in summer and winter seasons, between December 2015 and December 2016. To have a database of sources as those assessed in this study, measured in field conditions and with low natural background-noise, takes a relevant value when working with mathematics models of acoustic prediction. The information we have to introduce into them must be as accurate and as similar as possible to those acoustic characteristics of the noise sources considered. It is important to state how necessary standardizing procedures used to measure and present results of under-water measurements appears now. There exists a wide variety of literature showing divergences regarding this. This work tried to bring into the area of underwater measurements techniques and considerations used in air measurements, since, strictly speaking, the change is only in the involved fluids.","author":["Fernandez, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2035","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/black-guillemot-ecology-relation-tidal-stream-energy-generation-evaluation-current","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113617303859","title":"Black Guillemot Ecology in Relation to Tidal Stream Energy Generation: An Evaluation of Current Knowledge and Information Gaps","description":"The black guillemot Cepphus grylle has been identified as a species likely to interact with marine renewable energy devices, specifically tidal turbines, with the potential to experience negative impacts. This likelihood is primarily based on the species being a diving seabird, and an inshore, benthic forager often associating with tidal streams. These behavioural properties may bring them into contact with turbine blades, or make them susceptible to alterations to tidal current speed, and\/or changes in benthic habitat structure. We examine the knowledge currently available to assess the potential impacts of tidal stream turbines on black guillemot ecology, highlight knowledge gaps and make recommendations for future research. The key ecological aspects investigated include: foraging movements, diving behaviour, seasonal distribution, other sources of disturbance and colony recovery. Relating to foraging behaviour, between studies there is heterogeneity in black guillemot habitat use in relation to season, tide, diurnal cycles, and bathymetry. Currently, there is also little knowledge regarding the benthic habitats associated with foraging. With respect to diving behaviour, there is currently no available research regarding how black guillemots orientate and manoeuvre within the water column. Black guillemots are considered to be a non-migratory species, however little is known about their winter foraging range and habitat. The effect of human disturbance on breeding habitat and the metapopulation responses to potential mortalities are unknown. It is clear further understanding of black guillemot foraging habitat and behaviour is needed to provide renewable energy developers with the knowledge to sustainably locate tidal turbines and mitigate their impacts.","author":["Masden, E.","Furness, R.","Robbins, A.","Johnston, D.","Tyler, G.","Taggart, M."],"organization":["Environmental Research Institute (ERI)","MacArthur Green","Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.024690600000","-6.490507300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2036","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-wind-zoning-china-method-experience","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117304039","title":"Offshore wind zoning in China: Method and experience","description":"Over the past decade, the increasing demand for renewable energy has driven the rapid development of China\u0027s offshore wind industry. However, it is not clear to developers and management departments which types of sea areas can be used for offshore wind projects. According to the provincial marine functional zoning (MFZ), China\u0027s coastal provinces have put offshore wind zoning (OWZ) into practice. This paper clarifies the method of OWZ, collects the results from offshore wind zones (OWZs) of 10 coastal provinces, and assesses the characteristics of OWZs by area, functional attribute and distance from the coastline. The results show that most of the areas available for offshore wind are co-existence zones where offshore wind can be sited in an agricultural and fisheries zone, an industrial and urban construction zone, a special-use zone, etc. Currently, 47% of existing offshore wind projects have been located in the OWZs in the East China Sea. Moreover, parts of the coastline distance of OWZs do not meet the \u201cdouble-ten principle\u201d in China or global siting trends. Generally, the existing areas for OWZ would allow China to meet its national target by 2020, but measures still need to be taken to meet the demands of conservation and sea-use management.","author":["Ou, L.","Xu, W.","Yue, Q.","Ma, C.","Teng, X.","Dong, Y."],"organization":["National Ocean Technology Center (NOTC)","Ocean University of China"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2037","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seabird-flight-behavior-height-response-altered-wind-strength-direction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.marineornithology.org\/PDF\/43_1\/43_1_25-36.pdf","title":"Seabird Flight Behavior and Height in Response to Altered Wind Strength and Direction","description":"The ocean is swept by winds in regionally and seasonally predictable ways, and seabirds have been exploiting these patterns for millennia. Seabird use of wind energy is an under-appreciated aspect of seabird ecology. Using data from 114 cruises spanning the Southern Ocean, Peru Current, California Current and Equatorial Pacific from 1976 to 2006, we evaluate the effect of wind speed and direction on two key characteristics of seabird behavior, flight height and flight behavior. We used cluster analysis to partition 104 seabird species into morphological groupings based on degree of divergence in morphology from Pennycuick\u2019s \u201cstandard seabird,\u201d with subgroups evident among and within flappers, glide-flappers, and flap-gliders. Gliders, sea-anchor soarers and soarers showed no such divergence in morphology within their respective groups. Morphological grouping was in accord with foraging ecology, facilitating foraging behavior. Seabird flight height and behavior varied among groups and subgroups and changed as a function of wind speed and direction relative to travel, with the probability of more gliding and flying above 10 m increasing as wind speed increased. Most of the glide-flappers, flap-gliders and gliders, especially, would be highly vulnerable to offshore wind-generating facilities, as their flight heights bring them well within the blade-swept zone of typical turbines when winds are strong, and their more prevalent gliding makes them less maneuverable than flappers.","author":["Ainley, D.","Zajanc, D.","Porzig, E.","Spear, L."],"organization":["H.T. Harvey \u0026 Associates","Point Blue Conservation Science"],"originationDate":"2015-04-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["1.719733000000","-114.356093000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ainley-et-al-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2038","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-animal-alert-system-task-2153-development-monitoring-technologies-final-report","sourceURL":"","title":"Marine Animal Alert System Task 2.1.5.3 - Development of Monitoring Technologies Final Report","description":"The Marine Animal Alert System (MAAS) was developed by the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory as an element of compliance monitoring to support deployment of marine hydrokinetic energy devices.\u00a0 An initial focus is prototype tidal turbines to be deployed in Puget Sound in Washington State.\u00a0 The MAAS will help manage the risk of injury or mortality to marine animals from blade strike or contact with tidal turbines.\u00a0 In particular, development has focused on using both active and passive acoustic approaches to detect, classify, and localize listed Southern Resident killer whales within 200 m of prototype turbines.\u00a0 A passive acoustic system consisting of a pair of four-element symmetrical star arrays and parallel processing of eight channels of acoustic receptions has been designed, built, and evaluated under field conditions.\u00a0 Field evaluation of the performance of the system for detection and localization of killer whale calls and of the acoustic beacons was conducted in Sequim Bay, Washington, during the last calendar quarter of 2011.\u00a0 The probability of detection of whale calls with source levels of 150 dB referenced to a micropascal\u00a0 was found to be on the order of 0.75 when the whale playback transducer was at a range of approximately 190 m and increased to 1.0 at a range of approximately 130 m.\u00a0 The whale call classifier correctly classified essentially all of the calls detected.\u00a0 The location of sound sources was estimated by computing a two-dimensional (2D) bearing to the sound source from each star array and then computing the 2D location at which the 2D bearings crossed.\u00a0 Except for locations where the sound source was very close to the line passing through the centers of both star arrays, bearing errors were on the order of 1\u00b0, and range errors were less than 30 m at the maximum ranges tested.\u00a0 Inclusion of an active acoustic component into the system was not pursued following findings that the 200-kHz sonars selected based on whale target strength and acoustic propagation considerations were emitting sound within the hearing range of killer whales at levels that could possibly affect their behavior.\u00a0 The results of measurements of sideband sound made for the selected echo sounders are presented.\u00a0\u00a0","author":["Matzner, S.","Copping, A.","Deng, Z.","Carlson, T.","Myers, J."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2012-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.079000000000","-123.044000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Carlson-et-al-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2039","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fish-distributions-tidal-channel-indicate-behavioural-impact-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2352484717301968","title":"Fish Distributions in a Tidal Channel Indicate the Behavioural Impact of a Marine Renewable Energy Installation","description":"In the dynamic environments targeted for marine renewable energy extraction, such as tidal channels, the natural distribution of fish and behavioural impacts of marine renewable energy installations (MREIs) are poorly understood. This study builds on recent methodological developments to reveal the behaviour of fish schools using data collected by a seabed-mounted echosounder deployed in extreme tidal flows and in the wake of a MREI (composed of the foundation of a full-scale tidal stream energy turbine). The results show a significant change (p \u0026lt;0.001) in the vertical distribution of fish schools in the vicinity of a MREI compared to a nearby control location representative of the natural conditions. The MREI is associated with an overall increased rate of fish school observations (+74%), particularly at night (+163%) and in the MREI wake flow (+378%), related to the disruption of natural diurnal behavioural patterns in school characteristics (size, relative density, and distance from seabed). These results indicate an attraction effect of the MREI, and show that the aggregation and vertical distribution of fish in the modified flow conditions is dependent on tidal phase with evidence of avoidance of the MREI depth range during peak flow velocities. The behavioural responses observed in this study provide new information relevant to the environmental impact assessment of marine renewable energy developments and highlight priorities for further research.","author":["Scott, B.","Williamson, B.","Fraser, S.","Nikora, V."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2018-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.150000000000","-2.808333333000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:11:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fraser-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2040","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/numerical-modelling-study-effects-suspended-aquaculture-farms-tidal-stream-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/document\/7271494\/","title":"Numerical Modelling Study of the Effects of Suspended Aquaculture Farms on Tidal Stream Energy Generation","description":"Recent endeavours have focused on the possibility of developing multi-use marine areas that integrate open-ocean aquaculture in conjunction with marine renewable energy device deployment. Advantages of performing mariculture activities within offshore tidal stream farms are manifold, including increased spatial efficiency, shared infrastructures and reduced labour costs due to linkage of individual activities of both industries. This work investigates the combined impacts of a suspended installation hosting aquaculture developments and potential energy-production capacity of tidal stream devices installed beneath the aquaculture farm. Numerical modelling studies of the impacts of the suspended aquaculture farms on energy production are conducted. The study adopts an amended version of an existing three-dimensional hydro-environmental model to describe the effects of aquaculture structures. The effects of suspended mariculture canopies are simulated using a laboratory validated, vertically varying drag coefficient profile within the canopy, along with a two-equation turbulence closure scheme, which includes additional turbulent production and dissipation terms. The quantifiable energy production capacity of the tidal stream devices with and without the suspended canopy is considered. In particular, the research investigates the optimum density and distribution of suspended shellfish cultivation that ensures viable growth and economic production of the shellfish while increasing production capacity of the tidal energy farms. Results demonstrate that there is potential to optimize energy generation by combining turbine arrays with suspended aquaculture farms.","author":["James, S.","O\u0027Brien, N.","O\u0027Donncha, F.","Ragnoli, E."],"organization":["IBM Research","Baylor University"],"originationDate":"2015-09-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2041","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/simulating-current-energy-converters-snl-efdc-model-development-verification-parameter","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117306328","title":"Simulating Current-Energy Converters: SNL-EFDC Model Development, Verification, and Parameter Estimation","description":"Increasing interest in power production from ocean, tidal, and river currents has led to significant efforts to maximize energy conversion through optimal design and siting and to minimize effects on the environment. Turbine-based, current-energy-converter (CEC) technologies remove energy from current-driven systems and in the process generate distinct wakes, which can interact with other CEC devices and can alter flow regimes, sediment dynamics, and water quality. This work introduces Sandia National Laboratories-Environmental Fluid Dynamics Code CEC module and verifies it against a two-dimensional analytical solution for power generation and hydrodynamic response of flow through a CEC tidal fence. With a two-dimensional model that accurately reflects an analytical solution, the effort was extended to three-dimensional models of three different laboratory-flume experiments that measured the impacts of CEC devices on flow. Both flow and turbulence model parameters were then calibrated against wake characteristics and turbulence measurements. This is the first time that turbulence parameter values have been specified for CEC devices. Measurements and simulations compare favorably and demonstrate the utility and accuracy of this numerical approach for simulating the impacts of CEC devices on the flow field. The model can be extended to future siting and analyses of CEC arrays in complex domains.","author":["Roberts, J.","Johnson, E.","Barco, J.","James, S."],"organization":["Baylor University","Montana State University","Universidad de Medell\u00edn","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"2020-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2042","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-study-effects-suspended-aquaculture-installations-tidal-stream-generation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148116308898","title":"Modelling Study of the Effects of Suspended Aquaculture Installations on Tidal Stream Generation in Cobscook Bay","description":"Recent endeavours have focused on the possibility of developing multi-use marine areas that integrate aquaculture with marine renewable energy device deployment. This work investigates both the individual and the combined impacts of suspended long-line mussel farms (canopies) and tidal stream devices. An amended version of an existing three-dimensional hydro-environmental code was used to describe the effects of both the aquaculture canopies and the tidal energy devices. The model was applied to a designated tidal energy test site on the East Coast of the United States, Cobscook Bay, ME. The quantifiable energy production capacity of the tidal stream devices with and without suspended canopies was considered. The effects of both types of structures on hydrodynamics and solute transport were analysed including flushing studies to quantify renewal timescales in the bay. Results demonstrate potential to optimise energy generation by combining turbine arrays with suspended aquaculture canopies. Combining MHK and aquaculture installations did not significantly impact the physical environment beyond the effects of the aquaculture canopies alone. Moreover, the potential energy production capacity was increased by up to 19% due to flow diversion and acceleration induced by the aquaculture canopies.","author":["James, S.","O\u0027Donncha, F.","Ragnoli, E."],"organization":["IBM Research","Baylor University"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.909800000000","-67.045630000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2043","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-temporary-exclusion-activity-due-wind-farm-construction-lobster-homarus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/article-abstract\/75\/4\/1416\/4841920","title":"The effects of temporary exclusion of activity due to wind farm construction on a lobster (Homarus gammarus) fishery suggests a potential management approach","description":"Offshore wind farms (OWF) form an important part of many countries strategy for responding to the threat of climate change, their development can conflict with other offshore activities. Static gear fisheries targeting sedentary benthic species are particularly affected by spatial management that involves exclusion of fishers. Here we investigate the ecological effect of a short-term closure of a European lobster (Homarus gammarus (L.)) fishing ground, facilitated by the development of the Westermost Rough OWF located on the north-east coast of the United Kingdom. We also investigate the effects on the population when the site is reopened on completion of the construction. We find that temporary closure offers some respite for adult animals and leads to increases in abundance and size of the target species in that area. Reopening of the site to fishing exploitation saw a decrease in catch rates and size structure, this did not reach levels below that of the surrounding area. Opening the site to exploitation allows the fishery to recuperate some of the economic loss during the closure. We suggest that our results may indicate that temporary closures of selected areas may be beneficial and offer a management option for lobster fisheries.","author":["Johnson, M.","Roach, M.","Cohen, M.","Forster, R.","Revill, A."],"organization":["University of Hull"],"originationDate":"2018-02-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2044","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-northern-gannet-avoidance-offshore-windfarms","sourceURL":"","title":"Assessing Northern Gannet Avoidance of Offshore Windfarms","description":"A novel approach is presented for estimating northern gannet Morus bassanus macro- and micro-avoidance of offshore windfarms from high resolution digital images gathered from aerial survey. This approach calculates macro- and micro-avoidance based on the measured change in gannet density at a distance from the windfarm and inside the windfarm.\nFour aerial surveys of the built Greater Gabbard offshore windfarm (GGOWF) were carried out between 30 October 2014 and 23 November 2014, a period of high gannet autumn passage off the East Anglian coast and in the southern North Sea.\nDigital images were collected by planes flying at over 300 m leading to no observable disturbance to the birds and thus minimising any bias in the data. Each survey consisted of between 14 and 20 pseudo-randomly generated transects, with the caveat that each transect had to either cross or abut the windfarm. Each transect started and ended 10 km before and after the GGOWF, respectively. In total the four surveys covered 320% and 75% of the windfarm footprint and buffer areas, respectively, with 570 m wide transects.\nIn total 336 gannets were recorded in the images during the four autumn passage surveys of which eight and 328 were recorded within and outside the GGOWF footprint, respectively. The gannets had a minimum recorded approach distance of 443 m and 359 m away from the nearest turbine within and outside the footprint, respectively.\nA zero-inflated negative binomial model is used to describe the relationship between the distance to the nearest turbine and gannet counts outside of the GGOWF footprint.\nThe model suggests that gannet numbers change with distance to the built windfarm (P=0.0518). Gannet counts increase from zero close to the turbines to reach a \u201cbackground at sea\u201d plateau two kilometres away from the nearest turbine. The lower density within two kilometres of the windfarm is likely to reflect gannets avoiding the vicinity of the GGOWF.\nA macro-avoidance value of 95.02% has been calculated for gannets as the percentage change from their background at sea density 4 km or more outside of the GGOWF compared to their density within the GGOWF footprint. A distance of 4 km outside the GGOWF is used rather than 2 km to ensure that a robust background gannet density is used. Observing no birds closer than 359 m to a turbine suggests 100% micro-avoidance and an overall avoidance value of 100%.\nIn conclusion, the results of this study strongly suggest that northern gannets avoid the close proximity of built windfarms, at least during the autumn passage period and they support previous studies that also showed strong avoidance. A 95.02% macro-avoidance value, a 100% micro-avoidance value and a 100% total avoidance value is indicated by the data. Based on the published offshore micro-avoidance value of 97.6% we estimate total avoidance to be 99.9%. It is therefore not unreasonable from the evidence of this study, taken together with previous studies, to suggest that an avoidance rate of 99.5%, at least for autumn passage gannets, may be appropriately precautionary for use in collision risk modelling.","author":["Rehfisch, M.","Perez-Dominguez, R.","Buisson, R.","Barrett, Z.","Brown, L.","Clough, S."],"organization":["APEM Ltd"],"originationDate":"2014-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.907778000000","2.628611000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rehfisch-et-al-2014-APEM.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2045","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/state-knowledge-environmental-effects-driving-consentingpermitting-marine-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ocean-energy-systems.org\/news\/oes-publishes-a-position-paper-the-state-of-knowledge-for-environmental-effects\/","title":"The State of Knowledge for Environmental Effects: Driving Consenting\/Permitting for the Marine Renewable Energy Industry","description":"The marine renewable energy (MRE) industry is young\u2014most technology development and testing for tidal and wave devices has taken place over the past 10\u201315 years. As wave and tidal devices continue to be deployed for demonstration, testing, and pilot projects, and the earliest commercial arrays are being developed, regulators around the world are requiring that a significant amount of data be collected to determine the effects of devices and systems on marine animals, habitats, and ecosystems. The collection of pre- and post-installation monitoring data places substantial cost burdens on device and project developers, threatening the financial viability of this young industry.  This paper describes the state of knowledge that drives the consenting (permitting) processes for the MRE industry in most of the Ocean Energy Systems Technology Collaboration Programme (OES) nations, and how that level of knowledge is, or is not, driving the processes for consenting projects and moving the industry forward. There are of course many differences among the levels of acceptance and application of this knowledge. This paper attempts to summarize the current status and suggest pathways for moving the industry forward through efficient consenting processes.","author":["Copping, A."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","Ocean Energy Systems (OES)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Copping-2018-Environmental-Effects.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2046","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/factors-influencing-winter-mortality-risk-pronghorn-exposed-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1016\/j.rama.2015.12.003","title":"Factors Influencing Winter Mortality Risk for Pronghorn Exposed to Wind Energy Development","description":"Evaluating the influence of energy development on pronghorn (Antilocapra americana) winter mortality risk is particularly critical given that northern populations already experience decreased survival due to harsh environmental conditions and increased energetic demands during this season. The purpose of our study was to evaluate pronghorn mortality risk over 3 winters (2010, 2010\u20132011, 2011\u20132012) on a landscape developed in 2010 for wind energy production (Dunlap Ranch) in south-central Wyoming, United States. We obtained locational data and survival status of 47 adult female pronghorn captured and equipped with Global Positioning System (GPS) transmitters. Overall, 17 pronghorn died during winter seasons, with 76.4% (13) of deaths occurring during the winter with highest snow accumulation (2010\u20132011). Survival (\u0160) was lowest in winter 2010\u20132011 (\u0160 = 0.53, 90% confidence interval [CI]: 0.37\u20130.70) and highest in winters 2010 (\u0160 = 0.97, 90% CI: 0.92\u20131.00) and 2011\u20132012 (\u0160 = 0.91, 90% CI: 0.82\u20131.00). We modeled mortality risk for pronghorn using Cox\u0027s proportional hazards model inclusive of time-dependent and time-independent covariates within anthropogenic, environmental, and wind energy variable classes. Across winters, pronghorn winter mortality risk decreased by 20% with every 1.0-km increase in average distance from major roads (hazard ratio = 0.80, 90% CI: 0.66\u20130.98), decreased by 4.0% with every 1% increase in average time spent in sagebrush (Artemisia spp. L; hazard ratio = 0.96, 90% CI: 0.95\u20130.98), and decreased by 92% with every 1 unit (VRM \u00d7 1000) increase in terrain ruggedness (hazard ratio = 0.08,90% CI: 0.01\u20130.68). Pronghorn winter survival was not influenced by exposure to wind energy infrastructure; however, pronghorn survival may be impacted by larger-scale wind energy developments than those examined in our study. We recommend wildlife managers focus on conserving sagebrush stands in designated pronghorn winter range.","author":["Taylor, K.","Beck, J.","Huzurbazar, S."],"organization":["University of Wyoming"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2047","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/harbour-seals-phoca-vitulina-around-operational-tidal-turbine-strangford-narrows-no","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1002\/aqc.2790","title":"Harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) around an operational tidal turbine in Strangford Narrows: No barrier effect but small changes in transit behaviour","description":"Data were obtained from 32 electronic tags that were glued to the fur of harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) in and around Strangford Lough, Northern Ireland, during the environmental monitoring of the SeaGen tidal turbine.  This study provides the first detailed information on the behaviour of marine mammals close to a commercial\u2010scale tidal energy device. The turbine did not prevent transit of the animals through the channel and therefore did not result in a \u2018barrier\u2019 effect.  However, the animals\u0027 behaviour did change when the turbine was operating, demonstrating the importance of allowing for behavioural responses when estimating collision risks associated with tidal turbines.  Tagged animals passed the location of the device more frequently during slack water than when the current was running. In 2010 the frequency of transits by tagged seals reduced by 20% (95% CI: 10\u201350%) when the turbine was on, relative to when it was off. This effect was stronger when considering daylight hours only with a reduction of transit rate of 57%(95% CI: 25\u201364%). Seals tagged during the operational period transited approximately 250 m either side of the turbine suggesting some degree of local avoidance compared with the pre\u2010installation results.  The results presented here have implications for monitoring and managing the potential interactions between tidal turbines and marine wildlife. Principally that the design of telemetry studies for measuring change in response to developments should seek to understand and take into account variability in seal behaviour.  This study only looked at the effects of a single turbine rather than an array, and mitigation limited the ability to determine close range interactions. However, the study indicates that the effect of the turbine on Strangford Lough harbour seals was minor and that collision risk was reduced by the behaviour of the seals.","author":["Sparling, C.","Lonergan, M.","McConnell, B."],"organization":["SMRU Consulting","University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.483647000000","-5.583000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-12-30 07:33:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Sparling_et_al-2017-Aquatic_Conservation__Marine_and_Freshwater_Ecosystems.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2048","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-operational-noise-level-emitted-tidal-current-turbine-its-potential-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.4988869","title":"Underwater operational noise level emitted by a tidal current turbine and its potential impact on marine fauna","description":"Marine renewable energy development raised concerns over the impact of underwater noise. We assessed the acoustic impacts of an operating tidal current turbine (Paimpol-Br\u00e9hat site, France) on marine fauna. The turbine\u2019s source level (SL) was estimated using 19 acoustic drifting transects at distances between 100m to 2400m from the device. SL ranges from 118 to 152dBre1\u03bcPa@1m in the third-octave bands at frequencies between 40 and 8192Hz, a noise level comparable to the one emitted by a 19m boat travelling at 10kt. The SL was used to estimate the impact of the turbine\u2019s noise based on acoustic propagation simulations. The overall acoustic footprint of the device corresponds to a disk of 350 meters radius. Our results showed that within this footprint, physiological trauma is improbable but behavioral disturbance may occur up to 350m around the device for marine mammals (impact limited by the footprint area), and 55m, 5m and 5m respectively for pollocks, sea basses and a shrimp species. Feedbacks from this study show that the assessment of TTS and PTS risk areas for marine mammals is rather mature, but there are still many uncertainties about the assessment of risk areas for behavioral disturbance and masking for fishes and marine invertebrates.","author":["Folegot, T.","Lejart, M.","Lossent, J.","Gervaise, C.","Iorio, L.","Clorennec, D."],"organization":["CHORUS Acoustics","Quiet Oceans (QO)","France Energies Marines"],"originationDate":"2017-06-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Marine Mammals","Demersal Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2049","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-dimensional-optimisation-tidal-energy-converters-array-layouts-considering","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117309709","title":"Multi-Dimensional Optimisation of Tidal Energy Converters Array Layouts Considering Geometric, Economic and Environmental Constraints","description":"A study for the optimisation of in-stream tidal energy converter array layout for a three-dimensional fluid flow field is presented. The study involves design of experiments, computational fluid dynamics simulations, surrogate model construction, and constrained optimisation. Linear Radial Basis Functions (RBF) are used to build surrogate models as a function of four design variables: streamwise, spanwise, vertical and staggered spacings, with the purpose of approximating the capacity factor of an array with a fixed number of Tidal Energy Converters (TECs). Effects of arrays on maximum and minimum stream velocities at specific locations are also assessed. A constrained optimisation mathematical model is formulated considering geometric, economic and environmental aspects. Results are presented in terms of economic revenue for each optimisation model. The method proves to be very time efficient in the evaluation of numerous tidal energy convert array layouts with a view to satisfying optimality criteria.","author":["Rosman, P.","Gonz\u00e1lez-Gorbe\u00f1a, E.","Qassim, R."],"organization":["Federal University of Rio de Janeiro"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2050","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-interactions-tidal-lagoons-comparison-industry-perspectives","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117311679","title":"Environmental Interactions of Tidal Lagoons: A Comparison of Industry Perspectives","description":"Tidal lagoons are an attractive renewable energy option that could aid the UK in meeting its ambitious renewable energy targets. One of the main barriers to tidal range development in the UK to date has been regulatory environmental concern. In order for the nascent lagoon industry to move forward into development, the views of the developers and other influential stakeholders such as government bodies, regulators, conservationists and practitioners (herein referred to as \u2018influencing stakeholders\u2019 or \u2018influencers\u2019) need to be aligned. This study is the first of its kind using online questionnaires and semi-structured interviews to present and compare the views of both developers and influencing stakeholders on the environmental interactions of tidal lagoons. We find that, whilst both influencers and developers are working towards the common goal of a good environmental outcome for tidal lagoons, there are mismatches in their views in terms of the priorities given to the key environmental impacts, benefits and potential solution options. The work provides insight into what is at the forefront of developers\u0027 and influencers\u0027 minds, highlighting the key themes within their views and transforming this information into policy recommendations that will help the industry\u0027s development move forward.","author":["Smith, H.","Mackinnon, K.","Moore, F.","van der Weijde, A.","Lazakis, I."],"organization":["Black \u0026 Veatch","University of Exeter","University of Hull","University of Edinburgh","University of Strathclyde"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Mackinnon-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2051","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/characterisation-tidal-flows-european-marine-energy-centre-absence-ocean-waves","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/1996-1073\/11\/1\/176","title":"Characterisation of Tidal Flows at the European Marine Energy Centre in the Absence of Ocean Waves","description":"The data analyses and results presented here are based on the field measurement campaign of the Reliable Data Acquisition Platform for Tidal (ReDAPT) project (Energy Technologies Institute (ETI), U.K. 2010\u20132015). During ReDAPT, a 1 MW commercial prototype tidal turbine was deployed and operated at the Fall of Warness tidal test site within the European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC), Orkney, U.K. Mean flow speeds and Turbulence Intensity (TI) at multiple positions proximal to the machine are considered. Through the implemented wave identification techniques, the dataset can be filtered into conditions where the effects of waves are present or absent. Due to the volume of results, only flow conditions in the absence of waves are reported here. The analysis shows that TI and mean flows are found to vary considerably between flood and ebb tides whilst exhibiting sensitivity to the tidal phase and to the specification of spatial averaging and velocity binning. The principal measurement technique was acoustic Doppler profiling provided by seabed-mounted Diverging-beam Acoustic Doppler Profilers (D-ADP) together with remotely-operable Single-Beam Acoustic Doppler Profilers (SB-ADP) installed at mid-depth on the tidal turbine. This novel configuration allows inter-instrument comparisons, which were conducted. Turbulence intensity averaged over the rotor extents of the ReDAPT turbine for flood tides vary between 16.7% at flow speeds above 0.3 m\/s and 11.7% when considering only flow speeds in the turbine operating speed range, which reduces to 10.9% (6.8% relative reduction) following the implementation of noise correction techniques. Equivalent values for ebb tides are 14.7%, 10.1% and 9.3% (7.9% relative reduction). For flood and ebb tides, TI values resulting from noise correction are reduced in absolute terms by 3% and 2% respectively across a wide velocity range and approximately 1% for turbine operating speeds. Through comparison with SB-ADP-derived mid-depth TI values, this correction is shown to be conservative since uncorrected SB-ADP results remain, in relative terms, between 10% and 21% below corrected D-ADP values depending on tidal direction and the range of velocities considered. Results derived from other regions of the water column, those important to floating turbine devices for example, are reported for comparison.","author":["Ingram, D.","Venugopal, V.","Sellar, B.","Sutherland, D.","Wakelam, G."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.128445000000","-2.803811000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Sellar-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2052","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/triton-igiugig-fish-video-analysis","sourceURL":"","title":"Triton: Igiugig Fish Video Analysis","description":"Tidal and instream turbine technologies are currently being investigated for power generation in a variety of locations in the US. An environmental permitting and consenting requirement parallels this exploration generating the need to ensure little or no harm, in the form of strike or collision, befalls marine animals from device deployments. Monitoring methods (e.g., underwater cameras, active acoustics, passive acoustics) around turbine deployments provide empirical data allowing regulators and other stakeholders to assess risk. At present, there is a high level of concern and limited data precluding robust conclusions, which creates a challenge to regulators who must make decisions based on perceived risk versus actual risk. However, the data that are currently available to the scientific community for analysis indicate the issue to be of low risk to date, and strike or collision to be rare events. One such dataset that provides insight to the rarity of strike and collision risk to fish came from an instream turbine deployment in Alaska that used underwater video as the monitoring method.  This document describes the analysis of video data collected around the Ocean Renewable Power Company\u2019s RivGen\u00ae device deployed in the Kvichak River during July and August 2015 to gain an understanding of the implications of using underwater video cameras as a fish monitoring technique. The data were analyzed manually and used to develop automated algorithms for detecting fish in the video frames and describing their interaction behavior relative to the device. In addition, Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) researchers developed a web application, EyeSea, to combine manual and automated processing, so that ultimately the automated algorithms could be used to identify where human analysis was needed (i.e., when fish are present in video frames).  The goal of the project was to develop software algorithms that could identify video frames with fish present to inform and accelerate manual analysis. To achieve this, independent manual analysis was completed for specific video clips (i.e., visual analysis and annotation by a human observer was the standard for assessing the algorithms). The analysis process indicated that some confounding aspects of the algorithm development could potentially be solved with recommended improvements in the initial camera data collection methods.  The manual analysis began to look at all data from the start of deployment of the RivGen\u00ae device, primarily using video from Camera 2 that looked directly at the upstream side of the turbine so any interaction could be identified; this was to ensure rare events were seen, and initially focused on Nighttime Data when more fish were present. This process highlighted the amount of time it takes to identify fish, and ultimately only 42.33 hours of video were reviewed because of the time-consuming analysis. The data were classified as \u201cFish\u201d when the reviewer was confident it was a fish, and \u201cMaybe\u201d fish when it was difficult to distinguish. The two classes were distinguished based on the movement, shape, and color characteristics. Fish Events were further classified by \u201cadult\u201d, \u201cjuvenile\u201d, or \u201cunidentifiable\u201d age. Behavioral attributes were noted and were broadly divided into Passive and Avoidance activities. In over 42 hours of the data reviewed, there were only 20 potential contact interactions, of which 3 were Maybe classifications, 12 were juveniles, and 5 were adults. While only 11.5% of the video data were analyzed from Camera 2, these results are from the time when most fish were present over the turbine deployment period (from Alaska Department of Fish and Game data) and provide preliminary evidence that fish strike or collision of fish in the Kvichak River with an instream turbine is rare.  On only one occasion was an actual contact confirmed, and this was an adult fish that contacted the camera, not the turbine itself. This experience highlights the difficulties associated with confirming a strike or collision event as either having occurred or having been a near-miss. More interactions were detected at night; this was probably biased by nighttime use of artificial light, which may have attracted fish, but also could have increased detection probability because the light is reflected from the fish itself.  For the algorithm development, background subtraction, optical flow, and Deep Learning techniques were considered. The Deep Learning approach was determined to need too much training data for this application, so its use was not continued. The optical flow analysis was considered promising, but did not give immediate results, so it needs further investigation. Therefore, background subtraction was the main focus in algorithm development. Three methods of background subtraction were tried: Robust Principal Components Analysis (RPCA), Gaussian Mixture Model (GMM), and Video Background Extraction (ViBE). A classification technique was then applied to the foreground images to determine fish presence. Using this combination, fish could be accurately identified when occupying a higher number of pixels (\u003E200 pixels, 98.2% correct; 100\u2013200 pixels, 99.6% correct; 5\u2013100 pixels, 85.4% correct; 2\u20135 pixels, 66.3% correct).  In parallel, EyeSea was developed to convert the video data to a usable form and to enable manual and automated analysis of the data that would have a standardized output.  Recommendations for further research, and optimizing methods for enhancing data collection and analysis include the following: Research Conduct more studies of the effect of lights on fish behavior. Investigate the use of low light video applications as an alternative to using lights. Further investigate optical flow techniques and their applicability for automated analysis. Further refine the parameters for background subtraction in automated analysis.  Standardized techniques Include markings on the turbines to determine relative range and size of fish within the field of view. Use a standardized (non-proprietary) video format that has a consistent frame rate of at least 25 frames per second. Use a scientific camera designed for underwater measurement in low light environments that has a field of view appropriate for the observations and a pixel resolution high enough to determine fish within the given range. Carefully consider the use of lights and how they illuminate the areas of interest. Standardized and detailed record keeping and metadata collection Use other monitoring technologies (e.g., strain sensors on turbine blades) to determine actual collision or strike events.","author":["Matzner, S.","Staines, G.","Harker-Klimes, G.","Trostle, C.","Hull, R.","Avila, A."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.325474800000","-155.913624500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-14 08:25:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Triton-Igiugig-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2053","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nedpower-mount-storm-wind-energy-facility-post-construction-avian-bat-monitoring","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Saif_Nomani\/publication\/267690951_NedPower_Mount_Storm_Wind_Energy_Facility_Post-Construction_Avian_and_Bat_Monitoring_NedPower_Mount_Storm_Wind_Energy_Facility_Post-Construction_Avian_and_Bat_Monitoring\/links\/556f523108aec226830a8fa7\/NedPower-Mount-Storm-Wind-Energy-Facility-Post-Construction-Avian-and-Bat-Monitoring-NedPower-Mount-Storm-Wind-Energy-Facility-Post-Construction-Avian-and-Bat-Monitoring.pdf","title":"NedPower Mount Storm Wind Energy Facility Post-Construction Avian and Bat Monitoring","description":"NedPower Mount Storm LLC (NedPower) is conducting a three year post-construction monitoring study of the NedPower Mount Storm Wind Energy Facility (the Project) to study the impacts of the development on birds and bats. The West Virginia Public Service Commission (PSC) certificate of convenience and necessity (certificate) issued to NedPower for development of the Mount Storm site contains two conditions requiring monitoring of post-construction impacts to avian and bat resources for each phase of development. The certificate conditions require that a report be filed with the Commission within 60 days of the completion of each six-months of study. Specifically, the conditions of the certificate related to post-construction monitoring are: (1) for a three-year period, NedPower shall conduct six-month post-construction studies for each phase of the project assessing the mortality of both birds and bats; and (2) for a one-year period, NedPower shall conduct six-month post-construction lighting studies at each phase after each phase begins operation.","author":["Bay, K.","Nomani, S.","Young, D. Jr.","Tidhar, W."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","NedPower Mount Storm LLC"],"originationDate":"2011-02-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Young_et_al_2011_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2054","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/when-blade-meets-bat","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.scientificamerican.com\/article\/when-blade-meets-bat\/","title":"When Blade Meets Bat","description":"The interaction of bats and wind turbines is emerging as a major and unexpected problem in northern Appalachia. From mid-August through October 2003, during the fall migration period, at least 400 bats died at FPL Energy\u0027s 44-turbine Mountaineer Wind Energy Center on Backbone Mountain in West Virginia.\nThe bats apparently died by colliding with the wind turbines, but why so many animals were killed at this particular site remains a mystery. The public outcry over these numbers threatens to delay or halt construction of some of the additional several hundred wind turbines planned for the tristate region of West Virginia, western Maryland and south-central Pennsylvania.","author":["Williams, W."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2004-02-02","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2055","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/improving-methods-estimating-fatality-birds-bats-wind-energy-facilities","sourceURL":"","title":"Improving Methods for Estimating Fatality of Birds and Bats at Wind Energy Facilities","description":"The California Wind Energy Association (CalWEA) evaluated the procedures in the California Guidelines for Reducing Impacts to Birds and Bats from Wind Energy Development (the Guidelines) for estimating fatality of birds and bats associated with wind energy facilities. The research sought to improve the accuracy of methods for estimating the number of bird and bat fatalities by evaluating the effect of time dependency on the probability of scavenging and removal of bird and bat carcasses (carcass persistence) and detection by searchers (searcher proficiency). Researchers used data collected from the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area from January 7 to April 30, 2011, to calculate traditional carcass persistence and searcher proficiency functions and to create new functions in which searcher proficiency and carcass persistence are modeled as a function of time and carcass age. This study is the first to document quantitatively that searcher proficiency and carcass persistence are time-based processes. The report offers lessons and implications for experimental designs and the field monitoring recommendations provided in the Guidelines. The study also investigated the fatality estimation equation provided in the Guidelines and three other prominent equations from the literature that are used to adjust fatality observations for searcher proficiency and carcass persistence. The report examines both the common and equation-specific assumptions inherent in these fatality estimators, evaluates them in light of data from the field experiment, and finds that each of the fatality estimation equations can result in positive or negative bias, depending on the length of search interval relative to carcass persistence time. A new equation incorporating carcass persistence from one search interval to the next is proposed. This project will help reduce conflict in the siting process and make sound wind project permitting decisions easier by improving the accuracy of fatality estimates and the ability to accurately compare them with those from other wind facilities.","author":["Newman, J.","Tran, L.","Karas, B.","Wolpert, R.","Warren-Hicks, W."],"organization":["California Wind Energy Association","California Energy Commission"],"originationDate":"2013-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-30 09:17:35","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Warren-Hicks-et-al-2013_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2056","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/draft-guidelines-review-evaluation-potential-natural-resources-impacts-utility-scale","sourceURL":"https:\/\/anr.vermont.gov\/sites\/anr\/files\/co\/planning\/documents\/guidance\/Guidelines%20for%20the%20Review%20and%20Evaluation%20of%20Potential%20Natural%20Resources%20Impacts%20from%20Utility-Scale%20Wind%20Energy%20Facilities%20in%20Vermont.pdf","title":"Draft Guidelines for the Review and Evaluation of Potential Natural Resources Impacts from Utility-Scale Wind Energy Facilities in Vermont","description":"The purpose of these guidelines is to establish an Agency process for reviewing proposals and applications for Certificates of Public Good (CPGs), pursuant to 30 V.S.A. \u00a7248, and for providing testimony before the Public Service Board related to the development of utility-scale wind energy facilities.  The Agency is a statutory party under Section 248, which requires that the project will not have an undue adverse impact on aesthetics, historic sites, air and water purity, the natural environment and the public health and safety, and give due consideration to the criteria in 10 V.S.A. \u00a71424a(d) and \u00a76086(a)(l) through (8) and (9)(K) before issuing a CPG.  The Agency needs specific data to develop testimony and provide recommendations to the Public Service Board, as well as to review permit applications for aspects of proposed projects subject to separate Agency permitting authority. To accomplish this, the Agency provides herein a detailed outline of expectations for pre- and post-construction data collection as well as general guidelines for construction, operation, and maintenance of utility-scale wind facilities. Applicants should contact the Agency in advance of collecting any data or commencing any studies related to a proposed wind project in order to ensure that such activities are designed and conducted in such a manner as to be useful to the Agency in evaluating the project.  Although these guidelines, and the process derived from them, are non-binding, they reflect the current thinking of the Agency. These guidelines will be revised and adjusted based on available science and information that is pertinent and applicable to the state and the region.","author":["Moore, J."],"organization":["Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department","Vermont Fish and Wildlife Department"],"originationDate":"2006-04-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ANR-2006-Vermont.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2057","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interim-guidelines-avoid-minimize-wildlife-impacts-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/docs.wind-watch.org\/usfwswind.pdf","title":"Interim Guidelines to Avoid and Minimize Wildlife Impacts from Wind Turbines","description":"The following guidance was prepared by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (Service). Like the Service\u2019s voluntary guidance addressing the siting, construction, operation, and decommissioning of communication towers and the voluntary guidance developed in cooperation with the electric utility industry to minimize bird strikes and electrocutions (APLIC 1994, APLIC 1996), this guidance is intended to assist the wind energy industry in avoiding or minimizing impacts to wildlife and their habitats. This is accomplished through: (1) proper evaluation of potential Wind Resource Areas (WRAs), (2) proper location and design of turbines and associated structures within WRAs selected for development, and (3) pre- and post-construction research and monitoring to identify and\/or assess impacts to wildlife. These guidelines are based on current science and will be updated as new information becomes available. They are voluntary, and interim in nature. They will be evaluated over a two-year period, and then modified as necessary based on their performance in the field, on comments from the public, and on the latest scientific and technical discoveries developed in coordination with industry, states, academic researchers, and other Federal agencies. After this period, the Service plans to develop a complete operations manual for evaluation, site selection, design, construction, operation, and monitoring of wind energy facilities in both terrestrial and aquatic environments.","author":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2003-05-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/US-FWS-2003.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2058","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/maiden-wind-farm-benton-county-washington-final-sepa-environmental-impact-statement","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bpa.gov\/efw\/Analysis\/NEPADocuments\/nepa\/Maiden_Wind\/Comments\/MaidenFEISwoletters.pdf","title":"Maiden Wind Farm Benton County, Washington Final SEPA Environmental Impact Statement and Final NEPA Environmental Impact Statement","description":"Washington Winds Inc. (the project developer) proposes to construct and operate up to 494 megawatts (MW) of wind generation on privately- and publicly-owned property in Benton and Yakima Counties, Washington. This Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) evaluates the environmental effects of BPA\u2019s Proposed Action to execute power purchase and interconnection agreements for the purpose of acquiring up to 50 average megawatts (aMW) (up to about 200 MW) of the project developer\u2019s proposed Maiden Wind Farm. This EIS also evaluates the environmental impacts of the No Action Alternative. BPA\u2019s preferred alternative is the Proposed Action. This action requires Conditional Use Permits (CUPs) from Benton and Yakima Counties, as well as other state and federal permits. The project would include integration of energy into BPA\u2019s existing transmission system. This EIS satisfies the requirements of both the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and the Washington State Environmental Policy Act (SEPA). The project would be located about 10 miles northeast of Sunnyside in the Rattlesnake Hills and would occupy about 251 acres of land. Except for portions of two sections of land owned by the Washington Department of Natural Resources (DNR), the project would be constructed on privately-owned farm and ranch land in Benton and Yakima Counties. The major facilities of the project include up to 549 wind turbines with small transformers at the base of each turbine tower, underground and overhead collector cables, access roads, up to two substations, up to three operation and maintenance buildings, possibly a 4-mile 230-kilovolt (kV) transmission line, and up to four meteorological towers. During construction, several staging areas and up to two quarries would be developed. Best management practices would be implemented to protect wildlife, limit weeds, erosion, and fire hazard, and ensure public safety, among other purposes. The project could be developed in several phases. The first phase would consist of 50 aMW in the northwestern portion of the project site. The project developer has requested a CUP for up to 494 MW. Although the full 494 MW of power may or may not be constructed, this EIS evaluates impacts from full build-out of the project.","author":["Bonneville Power Administration"],"organization":["US Department of Energy (DOE)","Bonneville Power Administration","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2002-01-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BPA-Benton-County-2002.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2059","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/battered-harsh-winds-must-bats-pay-price-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batcon.org\/resources\/media-education\/bats-magazine\/bat_article\/140?tmpl=component","title":"Battered by harsh winds - must bats pay the price for wind energy?","description":"Through the psychedelic lens of a thermal-imaging camera, the 115-foot (35-meter) blades of giant wind turbines are blends of reds, yellows, blues and purples. Then a bat arrives as a surreal triangle with an orange core that shifts through yellows, reds and shades of blue out to its wing tips. The images show the colorful little bat meeting the spinning blade and spiraling down and out of the picture. If the camera could have tracked the bat, it would have seen orange warmth fade to cold blue.","author":["Tuttle, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2005-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Tuttle-2005.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2060","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/obligations-aspirations-critical-evaluation-offshore-wind-farm-cumulative-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S136403211731225X","title":"Obligations and Aspirations: A Critical Evaluation of Offshore Wind Farm Cumulative Impact Assessments","description":"Proponents of marine renewable energy worldwide highlight that regulatory and consenting procedures are a significant barrier to the upscaling of infrastructure required to transform the energy generation sector. Uncertainties about the cumulative effects of marine renewable energy developments cause substantial delays during the consenting process, which are exacerbated by the lack of clarity about how to assess cumulative effects. These obstacles have contributed to perceptions that this essential emerging industry receives disproportionate scrutiny relative to established maritime activities. However, alongside legislated targets to reduce carbon emissions, there are legal obligations to protect, maintain and improve the condition of the marine environment. As the imperative to halt the decline in the condition of the environment increases, so expectations of cumulative impact assessments grow and the risk of consenting delays persists. To investigate how robust current cumulative impact assessment practise is, a novel evaluation framework was developed and applied to Environmental Statements of the world\u0027s largest offshore wind farms, currently in United Kingdom waters. The framework was designed to evaluate cumulative impact assessments relative to the information needs of decision-makers tasked with managing cumulative effects. We found that current practise does not meet those needs, that there is dissonance between science and practise, and problematic variability between assessments was observed. Straightforward recommendations for improved practise are provided, which if implemented may ease the perceived regulatory burden by clarifying practise. We also highlight additional steps that could enable project-led cumulative impact assessments to better support regional marine management. The results and recommendations will be of interest to countries worldwide where marine renewable energy is emerging alongside ecosystem-approach and marine spatial planning aspirations.","author":["Gill, A.","Jude, S.","Willsteed, E.","Birchenough, S."],"organization":["Cranfield University","Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)","Cape Eleuthera Institute"],"originationDate":"2018-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Willsteed-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2061","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wing-kinematics-flexibility-optimal-manoeuvring-escape","sourceURL":"https:\/\/qspace.library.queensu.ca\/bitstream\/handle\/1974\/15931\/Wong_Jaime_G_201707_PhD.pdf","title":"Wing Kinematics and Flexibility for Optimal Manoeuvring and Escape","description":"Understanding how animals control the dynamic stall vortices in their wake is critical to developing micro-aerial vehicles and autonomous underwater vehicles, not to mention wind turbines, delta wings, and rotor craft that undergo similar dynamic stall processes. Applying this knowledge to biomimetic engineering problems requires progress in three areas: (i) understanding the flow physics of natural swimmers and flyers; (ii) developing flow measurement techniques to resolve this physics; and (iii) deriving low-cost models suitable for studying the vast parameter space observed in nature. This body of work, which consists of five research chapters, focuses on the leading-edge vortex (LEV) that forms on profiles undergoing rapid manoeuvres, delta wings, and similar devices. Lagrangian particle tracking is used throughout this thesis to track the mass and circulation transport in the LEV on manoeuvring profiles. The growth and development of the LEV is studied in relation to: flapping and plunging profile kinematics; spanwise flow from profile sweep and spanwise profile bending; and varying the angle-of-attack gradient along the profile span. Finally, scaling relationships derived from the observations above are used to develop a low-cost model for LEV growth, that is validated on a flat-plate delta wing. Together these results contribute to each of the three topics identified above, as a step towards developing robust, agile biomimetic swimmers and flyers.","author":["Wong, J."],"organization":["Queens University"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2062","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/windy-business-exploring-local-wind-power-project-germany","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.diva-portal.org\/smash\/get\/diva2:1147730\/FULLTEXT01.pdf","title":"Windy Business: Exploring a Local Wind Power Project in Germany","description":"The need for a sustainable energy supply is widely recognized, as formulated under goal 7 of the United Nations\u2019 Sustainable Development Goals. Yet, on the local level problems may arise with the implementation of renewable energy systems, such as wind power. Issues around visual intrusion of the landscape, noise and shadow flicker, and concerns over wildlife protections are often in the heart of local resistance to wind power projects. The aim of this thesis is to closely examine the developments for wind power in the city of Euskirchen in Germany, including the planning and decision making processes, with regards to milestones and obstacles encountered over the last two decades. The analysis applies the methodology of a qualitative case study. Furthermore, views and opinions of involved and affected parties are collected through semi-structured interviews, and analysed through the lenses of social acceptance and public participation. Finally, from the examination of the planning and decision making processes and the discovered local attitudes towards wind energy, recommendations will be formulated to guide future wind power developments in the region.","author":["Dennis, K."],"organization":["Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.121955300000","9.886519500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2063","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-criteria-decision-analysis-wind-power-project-development-case-study-latvia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/uu.diva-portal.org\/smash\/get\/diva2:1121452\/FULLTEXT01.pdf","title":"Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis in Wind Power Project Development: Case Study in Latvia","description":"Wind Power Project Development is a complicated, capital and resource-inclusive process, where a wide variety of factors have to be considered and several stakeholders have a significant say in the process. Decision making in such an environment is complex and has to be approached comprehensively. In order to sustain a structured and clear decision-making process, the sustainable energy industry has recognized Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) method as a suitable set of tools to aid in the decision-making process. One of the MCDA tools \u2013 PROMETHEE II, has been examined in this master thesis, to evaluate its eligibility as a decision making aid in wind power project development.\n\nTo structurally and realistically evaluate the tool, it has been applied to a case study in Ventspils region, in Latvia. The author of this thesis has a preliminary agreement with the owners of the sites to develop the project, therefore, this thesis has a strong potential for a practical implementation in future. Four scenarios have been developed for an evaluation, contributing to four variations of the different amount of turbines erected, with two different hub heights, on two differently sized sites. The scenarios are assessed based on the interests of six key stakeholders. Their opinion on twelve criteria is examined.\n\nInput data for each criterion has been generated via WindPro and MS Excel software or by authors assessment based on the researched literature. PROMETHEE II is used to extrapolate a comprehensive and clear representation of the results.\n\nThe evaluation of the MCDA method proved that MCDA tools, and PROMETHEE II, in particular, can provide excellent support in decision making in wind power development. A wide variety of input data, as well as the various and often contradicting interests by different stakeholders, can be taken into account, while, at the same time, a clear result that can assist in decision making, is generated.\n\nWind Power Project Development is a complicated, capital and resource-inclusiveprocess, where a wide variety of factors have to be considered and severalstakeholders have a significant say in the process. Decision making in such anenvironment is complex and has to be approached comprehensively. In order to sustaina structured and clear decision making process, sustainable energy industry hasrecognized Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis (MCDA) method as a suitable set of tools toaid in the decision making process. One of the MCDA tools \u2013 PROMETHEE II, hasbeen examined in this master thesis, to evaluate its eligibility as a decision making aidin wind power project development.To structurally and realistically evaluate the tool, it has been applied on a case study inVentspils region, in Latvia. The author of this thesis has a preliminary agreement withthe owners of the sites to develop the project, therefore, this thesis has a strongpotential for a practical implementation in future. Four scenarios have been developedfor an evaluation, contributing to four variations of different amount of turbines erected, with two different hub heights, on two differently sized sites. The scenarios are assessed based on the interests of six key stakeholders. Their opinion on twelve criteria examined. Input data for each criterion has been generated via WindPro and MS Excel software orby authors assessment based on the researched literature. PROMETHEE II is used to extrapolate a comprehensive and clear representation of the results.The evaluation of the MCDA method proved that MCDA tools, and PROMETHEE II in particular, can provide excellent support in decision making in wind power development. Wide variety of input data, as well as the various and often contradicting interests by different stakeholders can be taken into account, while, at the same time, a clear result that can assist in decision making, is generated.","author":["Antans, A."],"organization":["Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.805801500000","20.060885300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2064","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-analysis-ecologically-conscious-wind-farm-siting-pacific-northwest","sourceURL":"https:\/\/archives.evergreen.edu\/masterstheses\/Accession86-10MES\/Moore_EEMESthesis2017.pdf","title":"A Spatial Analysis for Ecologically Conscious Wind Farm Siting in the Pacific Northwest","description":"As renewable energy resources are increasing availability, there is evidence to suggest that the renewable alternatives have numerous ecological impacts that should be addressed before developers proceed to mass produce energy. Birds are particularly vulnerable to experiencing population decline as a result of mortality from collision with wind turbines and displacement from habitat in which the wind farms are developed. The presently used mortality rate is based on rates at individual wind farms rather than on a collective rate for wind farms along flyways. Additionally, the present mortality rate does not account for population declines related to loss of viable habitat or habitat connectivity during and after construction of wind farms, so the overall population declines are grossly underestimated. The goal of this study is to locate sites for new wind farms that will aid in the reduction of bird mortality resulting from wind farm development in the United States. To accomplish this goal I will perform a spatial analysis of the United States using Geographic Information Systems (GIS) as an analysis platform. My analysis resulted in a preliminary siting tool that will address the conservation of birds by avoiding the important bird areas and protected areas while encouraging a multipurpose landscape. This tool can be used by the public, politicians and developers to make informed decisions about wind farm siting to reduce the overall ecological impacts birds while increasing the availability of renewable energy resources.","author":["Moore, E."],"organization":["Evergreen State College"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2065","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-diversity-activity-habitat-use-mixed-disturbance-landscape","sourceURL":"https:\/\/etd.ohiolink.edu\/apexprod\/rws_etd\/send_file\/send?accession=bgsu1498765592627811","title":"Bat Diversity, Activity, and Habitat Use in a Mixed Disturbance Landscape","description":"Bat species face multiple threats. One such threat, white-nose syndrome (WNS) has drastically reduced many bat populations. Also, habitat loss and fragmentation often forces bats to concentrate in remnant natural areas, or utilize habitats that are not as suitable. Both of these threats, while threaten bats in a general sense, also affect species differentially. The Oak Openings Region of Northwest Ohio is a biodiversity hotspot with a landscape composed of remnant natural areas within a matrix of agriculture and urban areas. This area, which provides crucial summer foraging habitat, has experienced declines in bat activity, shifts in bat assemblages, and some in diversity, in recent years, especially since WNS introduction. To study bats in this diverse landscape, we sampled bats acoustically from May \u2013 August 2016. We sampled mobile transects along roads along with stationary sites within the Oak Openings Preserve within the region. We identified calls to species and ran analyses investigating total bat activity, species-specific activity and presence, and bat diversity compared to. We compared bats to environmental, vegetation, road, and landcover parameters. Our results show that certain parameters influence bats as a whole, while others only affect one or a few species. We found that savanna stationary sites had more species-specific activity and bat diversity than forested sites (Rank Sums, p\u0026lt;0.05). Parameters that affected most bat species most prevalently were temperature and forest cover, both reflecting positive relationships with total bat activity and diversity (Chi-square; Rank Sums, p\u0026lt;0.05). When looking at species specific relationships, we focused on the least active species, as they may be more in need of management than more active species. Parameters that most influenced our least active species were humidity and open\/savanna vs. forested sampling areas. Humidity had positive relationships with the likelihood of presence of our rarer species, while habitat type relationships depended on species specific life history traits (Chi-Square; Rank Sums, p\u0026lt;0.05). Our research suggests managing for forest cover across the landscape for all native bats; however, encourages managers to consider heterogeneity by maintaining both dense and open forest stands, along with open areas to benefit certain species.","author":["Hollen, J."],"organization":["Bowling Green State University"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2066","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/land-trust-response-renewable-energy-siting-challenges-new-york","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.bard.edu\/cgi\/viewcontent.cgi?article=1000\u0026context=bcep","title":"Land Trust Response to Renewable Energy Siting Challenges in New York","description":"Energy policies promoting energy independence, grid modernization, climate change mitigation, and clean energy standards are a leading driver of land-use change in the United States. This has resulted in an increased pressure to develop land. The recent focus by states to expand renewable energy poses an interesting challenge to organizations dedicated to conserving open space and natural resources, creating a potential tension between competing \u201cgreen\u201d goals. In response, The Land Trust Alliance, a national organization supporting over 1,100 member land trusts, has recently set a goal to \u201cempower land trusts to encourage the buildout of renewable energy facilities while steering the facilities away from sensitive lands through a pilot project in New York.\u201d This report creates a baseline assessment of New York\u2019s land trusts that evaluates the extent to which land trusts are aware of and responding to the changing policies around renewable energy and its impacts on land use. Using an online survey, 42 land trusts were sampled. The data was analyzed using simple aggregations and Spearman\u2019s Rank-Order Correlation tests. Survey results found that just under half of land trusts surveyed are beginning to form policies around renewable energy on conserved land yet only 7% are incorporating renewable energy into their strategic plans. This report suggests five areas in which the Alliance can provide support to New York\u2019s land trusts to improve their preparedness around renewable energy siting. These include: mission alignment, information flows, strategic planning, siting utility scale wind and solar, and easements and fee-lands. These focal areas present New York\u2019s land trusts with an opportunity to boost relevancy and\/or visibility through engaging more deeply in a set of broader policy goals for New York State around climate and energy.","author":["Adkins, C."],"organization":["Bard College"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2067","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-methods-models-environmental-monitoring-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/319939267_A_Review_of_Methods_and_Models_for_Environmental_Monitoring_of_Marine_Renewable_Energy","title":"A Review of Methods and Models for Environmental Monitoring of Marine Renewable Energy","description":"A continued expansion of the marine renewable energy sector will result in an increased demand in monitoring the natural marine environment. This may be due to a basic scientific interest but is foremost linked to the requirement of pre-and post-construction studies in relation to environmental impact assessments and consenting processes for marine renewable energy projects. With focus on wave and tidal power, but without attempting to provide a comprehensive list, we review methods, technologies and other scientific tools used for monitoring and predicting possible impacts from marine energy installations, on both population and behavioural levels. This includes traditional methods such as fishing gear, like nets and cages, modern technologies such as platforms with multi parameter equipment and the use of deterministic models. This paper is intended to serve as an overview for technology developers as well as authorities, regulators and decision makers with interests in general techniques, and naturally for scientists and consultants commonly being executors of studies and monitoring programs. By giving relevant and up to date references this paper may also be useful for finding more detailed information on study methods and variants. Finally, we give recommendations on where development of technologies is needed in order to face future requirements.","author":["Sundberg, J.","Bender, A.","Francisco, F."],"organization":["Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.204170000000","11.379440000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-11 12:02:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2068","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-tidal-range-energy-devices-offer-environmental-opportunities-artificial-reefs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/319311720_Wave_and_Tidal_Range_Energy_Devices_Offer_Environmental_Opportunities_as_Artificial_Reefs","title":"Wave and Tidal Range Energy Devices Offer Environmental Opportunities as Artificial Reefs","description":"Artificial structures such as wave and tidal energy devices provide surfaces and structures that are naturally colonised by marine flora and fauna. Properties of the building material, surface texture and structural complexity of the infrastructure will determine the suitability as a habitat for marine organisms. While it may be desirable to inhibit fouling of some parts of the energy devices, the colonisation of other features may not compromise their overall functionality. Here we explore opportunities to not just tolerate the colonisation of marine infrastructure, but to design and manipulate features that would deliberately attract and host marine organisms. Serendipitous colonisation would be transformed into deliberately creating artificial reefs on the seafloor as well as floating reefs. This paper focuses on conceptual options for coastal, close-to-shore infrastructure, and it introduces two case studies: a proposed tidal lagoon that exploits tidal range energy and a wave energy converter. Positive reef-effects of these devices could include the enhancement of biodiversity of invertebrates and fish, habitat restoration or the production of commercial species.","author":["Carter, T.","Bertelli, C.","Callaway, R.","Lock, G.","Friis-Madsen, E.","Unsworth, R.","Sorense, H.","Neumann, F."],"organization":["Swansea University","Tidal Lagoon Power","Wave Dragon ApS"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2069","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/book-abstracts-xth-international-symposium-wild-fauna-isowif-2017","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repositorio.utad.pt\/handle\/10348\/8095","title":"Book of Abstracts of the Xth International Symposium on Wild Fauna (ISoWiF 2017)","description":"Wild Animals Vigilance Euromediterranean Society (WAVES), have a pleasure of welcoming all participants in the Xth International Symposium on Wild Fauna (ISoWiF2017) and express its feeling of honor to organize this conference in the University of Tr\u00e1s-os-Montes and Alto Douro (UTAD), in Vila Real, a city located in the North of Portugal, in the Douro Region, World Heritage listed by UNESCO.  For WAVES and UTAD, Wild Fauna subjects represent a common topic of major interest. Therefore, organize this ISoWiF edition, it was of main significance, being selected important topics transversal to this area that should be transparently and pragmatically presented during this two conference days:    A - Wild fauna management and conservation;  B - Wild fauna photography seen by professional eyes and researchers;  C - Wild fauna diseases under One Health approach;  D - Effects of environmental changes on wild fauna and habitats.   Around 150 participants (students, researchers, technicians, representatives of government authorities and wild fauna management companies) from different countries are expected to attend this symposium, with more than 80 presentations, providing the opportunity of interacting with an interdisciplinary group, exchange experience, improve innovation and knowledge, fortifying relationships and network and participating in the discussion about the future of wild fauna, under an integrated perspective and ONE HEALTH approach.","author":["Bastos, E.","Teixeira, A.","Ven\u00e2ncio, C.","Domingos, A.","Silva, F.","Viera-Pinto, M.","Monz\u00f3n, A.","Chaves, R.","Carrola, J.","Martins, J."],"organization":["University of Tras-os-Montes e Alto Douro"],"originationDate":"2017-09-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/iSoWiF-2017-Abstracts.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2070","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/economic-importance-bats-agriculture","sourceURL":"https:\/\/science.sciencemag.org\/content\/332\/6025\/41","title":"Economic Importance of Bats in Agriculture","description":"White-nose syndrome (WNS) and the increased development of wind-power facilities are threatening populations of insectivorous bats in North America. Bats are voracious predators of nocturnal insects, including many crop and forest pests. We present here analyses suggesting that loss of bats in North America could lead to agricultural losses estimated at more than $3.7 billion\/year. Urgent efforts are needed to educate the public and policy-makers about the ecological and economic importance of insectivorous bats and to provide practical conservation solutions.","author":["Kunz, T.","Cryan, P.","McCracken, G.","Boyles, J."],"organization":["University of Pretoria","US Geological Survey (USGS)","University of Tennessee","Boston University"],"originationDate":"2011-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2071","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/socio-technical-framework-examining-consequences-deforestation-case-study-wind-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421518300077","title":"A Socio-Technical Framework for Examining the Consequences of Deforestation: A Case Study of Wind Project Development in Northern Europe","description":"Wind projects are frequently developed in forested areas, and especially in Northern Europe, due to less restrictions and social opposition, favorable renewable energy policies and, of course, the heavily forested areas in this region of the world. Wind project development in forested areas has an unpreventable impact on nature, namely deforestation. The felling of trees is carried out to free space for the wind turbine installation and potentially also to increase the performance of the wind turbine and lower the levelized cost of energy. This study examines the impact of such a felling strategy, including the environmental and social consequences of deforestation. Based on a case study carried out in Sweden, this research study develops the first socio-technical framework for examining the consequences of deforestation. The deliverables of this research include recommendations for wind industry and forest industry stakeholders on how to apply deforestation in future development of wind projects in forested areas in Northern Europe. In addition, the framework is expected to encourage academia to further develop and analyze the socio-technical parameters associated with wind project development in forested areas.","author":["Enevoldsen, P."],"organization":["Aarhus University"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2072","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/us-geological-survey-energy-wildlife-research-annual-report-2017","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pubs.usgs.gov\/circ\/1435\/circ1435.pdf","title":"U.S. Geological Survey - Energy and Wildlife Research Annual Report for 2017","description":"Terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems provide valuable services to humans and are a source of clean water, energy, raw materials, and productive soils. The Nation\u2019s food supply is more secure because of wildlife. For example, native pollinators enhance agricultural crops, and insect-eating bats provide pest control services worth billions of dollars to farmers annually. Fish and wildlife are also vital to a vibrant outdoor recreation and tourism industry. Recreational activities, such as hunting, shooting, boating, and angling, generated $1.1 billion in excise taxes paid to State wildlife agencies in 2017. National parks, wildlife refuges, and monuments accounted for $35 billion in economic output and 318,000 jobs nationwide in 2016 (Cullinane and Koontz, 2017). Additional economic benefits are generated from the use and enjoyment of wildlife in State-owned lands and waters.\n\nAlthough the United States is rich in natural resources, human activity continues to place new pressures on fish and wildlife and the habitats they rely on. The United States became the world\u2019s top producer of petroleum and natural gas products in 2012, surpassing Russia\u2019s natural gas production levels in 2009 and Saudi Arabia\u2019s petroleum production in 2013 (U.S. EIA, 2017a). The U.S. Energy Information Administration projects that the demand for liquid fuel, natural gas, and renewable energy will show strong growth in the next 20 years (U.S. EIA, 2016). Wind energy has demonstrated consistent growth since 2007 with now more than 53,000 wind turbines contributing to power grids in 41 States, Guam, and Puerto Rico (American Wind Energy Association, 2017). Solar energy has seen rapid growth since 2013 and made up nearly one-third of the total electricity generation additions in 2016 (U.S. EIA, 2017b). Yet as our Nation works to advance energy security and sustain wildlife, some conflicts have surfaced. Impacts of an expanding energy infrastructure include fragmentation and loss of habitat as well as mortality of birds, bats, fish, and other animals from interactions with energy generation facilities. Because energy development can often occur in wildlife habitats, ecological science can help guide project siting and operational decisions to areas that present the lowest risk to wildlife and energy developers.\n\nTo address these challenges and make the most of new opportunities, the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS) is producing innovative science to develop workable solutions that can help sustain wildlife and the habitat they rely upon, while allowing informed development","author":["Khalil, M."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Fish","Terrestrial Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Khalil-2017_USGS-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2073","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/factors-associated-bat-mortality-wind-energy-facilities-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320717307802","title":"Factors Associated with Bat Mortality at Wind Energy Facilities in the United States","description":"Hundreds of thousands of bats are killed annually by colliding with wind turbines in the U.S., yet little is known about factors causing variation in mortality across wind energy facilities. We conducted a quantitative synthesis of bat collision mortality with wind turbines by reviewing 218 North American studies representing 100 wind energy facilities. This data set, the largest compiled for bats to date, provides further evidence that collision mortality is greatest for migratory tree-roosting species (Hoary Bat [Lasiurus cinereus], Eastern Red Bat [Lasiurus borealis], Silver-haired Bat [Lasionycteris noctivagans]) and from July to October. Based on 40 U.S. studies meeting inclusion criteria and analyzed under a common statistical framework to account for methodological variation, we found support for an inverse relationship between bat mortality and percent grassland cover surrounding wind energy facilities. At a national scale, grassland cover may best reflect openness of the landscape, a factor generally associated with reduced activity and abundance of tree-roosting species that may also reduce turbine collisions. Further representative sampling of wind energy facilities is required to validate this pattern. Ecologically informed placement of wind energy facilities involves multiple considerations, including not only factors associated with bat mortality, but also factors associated with bird collision mortality, indirect habitat-related impacts to all species, and overall ecosystem impacts.","author":["Thompson, M.","Etterson, M.","Loss, S.","Diffendorfer, J.","Beston, J."],"organization":["Oklahoma State University","University of Wisconsin","US Geological Survey (USGS)","US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2074","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/genetic-mark-recapture-improves-estimates-maternity-colony-size-indiana-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.fwspubs.org\/doi\/10.3996\/122016-JFWM-093","title":"Genetic Mark-Recapture Improves Estimates of Maternity Colony Size for Indiana Bats","description":"Genetic mark-recapture methods are increasingly being used to estimate demographic parameters in species where traditional techniques are problematic or imprecise. The federally endangered Indiana bat (Myotis sodalis) has declined dramatically and threats such as White-Nose Syndrome continue to afflict this species. To date, important demographic information for Indiana bats has been difficult to estimate precisely using traditional techniques such as emergence counts. Successful management and protection of Indiana bats requires better methods to estimate population sizes and survival rates throughout the year, particularly during summer when these bats reproduce and are widely dispersed away from their winter hibernacula. In addition, the familial makeup of maternity colonies is unknown, yet important for understanding local and regional population dynamics. We had four objectives in this study. For the first two objectives we investigated the potential use of DNA from fecal samples (fecal DNA) collected at roosts to obtain genetically based mark-recapture estimates of: 1) colony size and 2) survival rates, for an Indiana bat maternity colony in Indianapolis, Indiana. The third objective was to compare our genetically based colony size estimates to emergence counts conducted at the same roost tree to evaluate the genetic mark-recapture method. Our fourth objective was to use fecal DNA to estimate levels of relatedness among individuals sampled at the roost. In the summer of 2008, we collected fecal pellets and conducted emergence counts at a prominent roost tree during three time periods each lasting seven or eight days. We genotyped fecal DNA using five highly polymorphic microsatellite loci to identify individuals and used a robust design mark-recapture approach to estimate survival rates as well as colony size at the roost tree. Emergence count estimates at the roost tree ranged from 100 - 215, whereas genetic mark-recapture estimates were higher ranging from 122 - 266 and more precise. Apparent survival was 0.994 (SE=0.04) between sampling periods suggesting that few bats died or permanently emigrated during the course of the study. Relatedness estimates, r, between all pairs of individuals averaged 0.055 ranging from 0 - 0.779 indicating that most individuals were not closely related. We demonstrate here the promise of using fecal DNA to estimate demographic information for Indiana bats and potentially other bat species.","author":["Lukacs, P.","O\u0027Shea, T.","Oyler-McCance, S.","Fike, J.","Sparks, D.","Witaker, J."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","University of Montana","Indiana State University"],"originationDate":"2018-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2075","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bridge-between-oceans-overland-migration-marine-birds-wind-energy-corridor","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/jav.01474\/full","title":"A Bridge Between Oceans: Overland Migration of Marine Birds in a Wind Energy Corridor","description":"Located at the shortest overland route between the Gulf of Mexico and the Pacific Ocean, Mexico\u0027s Tehuantepec Isthmus is a globally important migratory corridor for many terrestrial bird species. The Pacific coast of the Isthmus also contains a significant wetland complex that supports large multi-species aggregations of non-breeding waterbirds during the boreal winter. In recent years, extensive wind energy development has occurred in the plains bordering these wetlands, directly along the migratory flyway. Using recent studies of movement patterns of three marine-associated bird species\u2014reddish egrets (Egretta rufescens), brown pelicans (Pelecanus occidentalis), and red knots (Calidris canutus)\u2014from the northern Gulf of Mexico, we assess the use of the isthmus as a migratory corridor. Our data provide evidence that marine birds from the Gulf region regularly overwinter along the Pacific coast of Mexico and use the isthmus as a migratory corridor, creating the potential for interaction with terrestrial wind farms during non-breeding. This study is the first to describe migration by marine-associated bird species between the Gulf of Mexico and Pacific coast. These data contribute new information toward ongoing efforts to understand the complex migration patterns of mobile marine species, with the goal of informing integrated conservation efforts for species whose year-round habitat needs cross ecoregional and geopolitical boundaries.","author":["Ballard, B.","Green, M.","Lamb, J.","Newstead, D.","Koczur, L.","Jodice, P."],"organization":["Clemson University","Texas A\u0026M University","Texas State University"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["16.440186400000","-95.035394600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2076","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/using-gps-transmitters-explore-movement-ecology-assess-risk-wind-energy-industry","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1408777","title":"Using GPS Transmitters to Explore Movement Ecology and to Assess Risk of the Wind Energy Industry for Swainson\u0027s Hawks","description":"Swainson\u2019s hawks (Buteo swainsoni) are a long-distance migratory species that breed in western North America and winter in Argentina. As a grassland species, they can also be found in agricultural settings, such as croplands and pastures. Wind energy is expanding rapidly across the breeding range of the population we chose to study, and we suspect the industry is also expanding in their wintering range and across the migratory pathway. Wind turbines pose a threat to birds, and migratory species may be especially susceptible to turbine-related mortality when these structures are placed in important migratory pathways. The purposes of this longterm study were to examine potential threats that wind energy might pose to Swainson\u2019s hawks on the breeding range, wintering range, and during migration, add to the body of ecological knowledge on migration and wintering habits, and describe breeding habits in a portion of their range that is relatively understudied.","author":["Walker, J.","Boal, C.","Watson, K.","Groen, L."],"organization":["Texas Tech University","US Geological Survey (USGS)","Texas A\u0026M University"],"originationDate":"2017-09-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.969930900000","-101.411965200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Watson-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2077","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/meteorological-environmental-variables-affect-flight-behaviour-decision-making","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/ibi.12531\/full","title":"Meteorological and Environmental Variables Affect Flight Behaviour and Decision-Making of an Obligate Soaring Bird, the California Condor Gymnogyps californianus","description":"The movements of animals are limited by evolutionary constraints and ecological processes and are strongly influenced by the medium through which they travel. For flying animals, variation in atmospheric conditions is critically influential in movement. Obligate soaring birds depend on external sources of updraft more than do other flying species, as without that updraft they are unable to sustain flight for extended periods. These species are therefore good models for understanding how the environment can influence decisions about movement. We used meteorological and topographic variables to understand the environmental influences on the decision to engage in flight by obligate soaring and critically endangered California Condors Gymnogyps californianus. Condors were more likely to fly, soared at higher altitudes and flew over smoother terrain when weather conditions promoted either thermal or orographic updrafts, for example when turbulence and solar radiation were higher and when winds from the east and north were stronger. However, increased atmospheric stability, which is inconsistent with thermal development but may be associated with orographic updrafts, was correlated with a somewhat higher probability of being in flight at lower altitudes and over rougher terrain. The close and previously undescribed linkages between Condor flight and conditions that support development of thermal and orographic updrafts provide important insight into the behaviour of obligate soaring birds and into the environmental parameters that may define the currently expanding distribution of Condors within and outside the state of California.","author":["Katzner, T.","Miller, T.","Poessel, S.","Brandt, J."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","West Virginia University"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2078","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/applying-citizen-science-data-mark-recapture-models-estimate-numbers-migrant-golden","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/10.1650\/CONDOR-16-166.1","title":"Applying citizen-science data and mark\u2013recapture models to estimate numbers of migrant Golden Eagles in an Important Bird Area in eastern North America","description":"Estimates of population abundance are important to wildlife management and conservation. However, it can be difficult to characterize the numbers of broadly distributed, low-density, and elusive bird species. Although Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) are rare, difficult to detect, and broadly distributed, they are concentrated during their autumn migration at monitoring sites in eastern North America. We used hawk-count data collected by citizen scientists in a virtual mark\u2013recapture modeling analysis to estimate the numbers of Golden Eagles that migrate in autumn along Kittatinny Ridge, an Important Bird Area in Pennsylvania, USA. In order to evaluate the sensitivity of our abundance estimates to variation in eagle capture histories, we applied candidate models to 8 different sets of capture histories, constructed with or without age-class information and using known mean flight speeds \u00b1 1, 2, 4, or 6 SE for eagles to travel between hawk-count sites. Although some abundance estimates were produced by models that poorly fitted the data (\u0109 \u003E 3.0), 2 sets of population estimates were produced by acceptably performing models (\u0109 \u2264 3.0). Application of these models to count data from November, 2002\u20132011, suggested a mean population abundance of 1,354 \u00b1 117 SE (range: 873\u20131,938). We found that Golden Eagles left the ridgeline at different rates and in different places along the route, and that typically","author":["Duerr, A.","Katzner, T.","Brandes, D.","Dennhardt, A."],"organization":["West Virginia University","Lafayette College"],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.550641400000","-76.365742800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Dennhardt-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2079","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/distribution-nesting-activities-age-class-territorial-pairs-golden-eagles-altamont","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pubs.er.usgs.gov\/publication\/ofr20171035","title":"Distribution, Nesting Activities, and Age-Class of Territorial Pairs of Golden Eagles at the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area, California, 2014-16","description":"The substantial numbers of golden eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) killed by collisions with oldgeneration wind turbines each year at the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area (APWRA) in California has been well documented from previous studies. Few eagle nests have been documented in the APWRA, however, and adults and subadults 3+ years of age killed by turbines were generally not associated with nearby territories. We searched a subset of randomly selected survey plots for territorial pairs of golden eagles and associated nesting attempts within the APWRA as part of a broader investigation of population dynamics in the surrounding northern Diablo Range. In contrast to limited historical observations from 1988 to 2013, our surveys documented up to 15 territorial pairs within 3.2 kilometers (km) of wind turbines at the APWRA annually, 9 of which were not previously documented or only observed intermittently during historical surveys. We found evidence of nesting activity by adult pairs at least once during our study at six of these territories. We also determined that 23\u201336 percent of territories identified within 3.2 km of the APWRA had a subadult pair member, but that no pairs with a subadult member attempted to nest. These data will be useful to developers, wildlife managers, and future raptor studies in the area to evaluate and minimize the potential effects of wind energy or other development activities on previously unknown territorial pairs in the area.","author":["Wiens, J.","Kolar, P."],"organization":["NextEra Energy Resources","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","East Bay Regional Park District","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.745778000000","-121.667038700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kolar-and-Wiens-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2080","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-demographic-models-inform-conservation-planning-golden-eagles-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/full\/10.3356\/JRR-16-77.1","title":"Spatial Demographic Models to Inform Conservation Planning of Golden Eagles in Renewable Energy Landscapes","description":"Spatial demographic models can help guide monitoring and management activities targeting at-risk species, even in cases where baseline data are lacking. Here, we provide an example of how site-specific changes in land use and anthropogenic stressors can be incorporated into a spatial demographic model to investigate effects on population dynamics of Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos). Our study focused on a population of Golden Eagles exposed to risks associated with rapid increases in renewable energy development in southern California, U.S.A. We developed a spatially explicit, individual-based simulation model that integrated empirical data on demography of Golden Eagles with spatial data on the arrangement of nesting habitats, prey resources, and planned renewable energy development sites. Our model permitted simulated eagles of different stage-classes to disperse, establish home ranges, acquire prey resources, prospect for breeding sites, and reproduce. The distribution of nesting habitats, prey resources, and threats within each individual\u0027s home range influenced movement, reproduction, and survival. We used our model to explore potential effects of alternative disturbance scenarios, and proposed conservation strategies, on the future distribution and abundance of Golden Eagles in the study region. Results from our simulations suggest that probable increases in mortality associated with renewable energy infrastructure (e.g., collisions with wind turbines and vehicles, electrocution on power poles) could have negative consequences for population trajectories, but that site-specific conservation actions could reduce the magnitude of negative effects. Our study demonstrates the use of a flexible and expandable modeling framework to incorporate spatially dependent processes when determining relative effects of proposed management options to Golden Eagles and their habitats.","author":["Inman, R.","Esque, T.","Nussear, K.","Wiens, J.","Schumaker, N.","Longshore, K."],"organization":["US Geological Survey (USGS)","US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)","University of Nevada"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.464985400000","-116.885655300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wiens-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2081","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/operational-noise-tidal-turbine-arrays-assessment-collision-risk-marine-mammals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.4988862","title":"Operational Noise from Tidal Turbine Arrays and the Assessment of Collision Risk with Marine Mammals","description":"The ability for marine species to detect and thereby avoid potentially harmful collision with the moving parts of a tidal stream turbine depends on relative levels of the ambient sound with the acoustic emissions from the turbine. Tidal streams targeted for exploitation by renewable energy converters are by their nature highly energetic environments often with high ambient sound levels. Commonly the first time that the operational sound from new tidal turbines can be measured is after it has been installed and is already interacting with animals in the marine environment. A modelling solution is therefore required to estimate whether marine animal will be able to hear and avoid contact with turbines. An acoustic-structural interaction model is used to calculate the acoustic output of tidal turbines. The cumulative sound of an array of tidal turbines and its dependence on bathymetry is calculated using a parabolic equation code. Modelled and measured sound pressure levels give information on potential upstream warning distances\/times for animals which help us consider collision risk.","author":["Marmo, B."],"organization":["Xi Engineering Consutants"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Collision","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2082","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measuring-changes-ambient-noise-levels-installation-operation-surge-wave-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1400245","title":"Measuring Changes in Ambient Noise Levels from the Installation and Operation of a Surge Wave Energy Converter in the Coastal Ocean","description":"Ecosystem impacts resulting from elevated underwater noise levels generated by anthropogenic activities in the coastal ocean are poorly understood and remain difficult to address as a result of a significant gap in knowledge for existing nearshore sound levels. Ambient noise is an important habitat component for marine mammals and fish that use sound for essential functions such as communication, navigation, and foraging. Questions surrounding the amplitudes, frequency distributions, and durations of noise emissions from renewable wave energy conversion (WEC) projects during their construction and operation present concerns for long-term consequences in marine habitats. Oregon\u2019s dynamic nearshore environment presents significant challenges for passive acoustic monitoring that include flow noise contamination from wave orbital motions, turbulence from breaking surf, equipment burial, and fishing pressure from sport and commercial crabbers. This project included 2 techniques for passive acoustic data collection: 1) campaign style deployments of fixed hydrophone lander stations to capture temporal variations in noise levels and 2) a drifting hydrophone system to record spatial variations within the project site. The hydrophone lander deployments were effective and economically feasible for enabling robust temporal measurements of ambient noise levels in a variety of sea state conditions. Limiting factors for the fixed stations included 1) a flow shield mitigation strategy failure in the first deployment resulting in significant wideband data contamination and 2) flow noise contamination of the unshielded sensors restricting valuable analysis to frequencies above 500 Hz for subsequent deployments. Drifting hydrophone measurements were also effective and economically feasible (although logistically challenging in the beginning of the project due to vessel time constraints) providing a spatial distribution of sound levels, comparisons of noise levels in varying levels of vessel traffic during similar sea states, and reducing the frequencies contaminated by flow noise to f \u0026lt; 50 Hz by an effective drifting hydrophone system design strategy. Results from this project can still assist regulatory agencies and WEC developers in permitting and licensing, reducing project costs overall and assisting the economic development of the WEC industry, thus furthering the MHK energy industry and easing the U.S. reliance on foreign oil for energy production. Additionally, results from this project can be used to help inform coastal resource managers and regulatory agencies on existing baseline noise level variability and ecosystem health.","author":["Henkel, S.","Haxel, J."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-10-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Henkel-and-Haxel-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2083","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seabirds-offshore-wind-farms-european-waters-avoidance-attraction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320716303196","title":"Seabirds and Offshore Wind Farms in European Waters: Avoidance and Attraction","description":"The extent to which seabirds are displaced from, or attracted to, offshore wind farms (OWFs) is uncertain, but rapid development of OWFs in European waters could conflict with seabird conservation. We review post-construction studies of seabirds at 20 OWFs in European waters to extract and classify evidence for displacement or attraction of 33 different seabird species. Divers and northern gannets showed consistent and strong avoidance behaviour\/displacement, and this may also be the case for great crested grebe and northern fulmar. Long-tailed duck, common scoter, Manx shearwater, razorbill, common guillemot, little gull and sandwich tern showed less consistent displacement from OWFs. Several gull species and red-breasted merganser showed weak attraction, while great cormorant and European shag showed strong attraction to OWFs. Other species show little response. Displacement seems mainly to be due to bird responses to OWF structures and appears stronger when turbines are rotating, but could in part be due to boat traffic to and from OWFs. Attraction of cormorants relates at least in part to their use of structures for roosting and for drying plumage, but increases in food availability at OWFs appears to be an important influence for several species.","author":["Furness, R.","Garthe, S.","Dierschke, V."],"organization":["MacArthur Green","Kiel University"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2084","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/power-generation-using-kuroshio-current","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ihi.co.jp\/var\/ezwebin_site\/storage\/original\/application\/149ee9de3149aba2e1215fd5f9cd46ec.pdf","title":"Power Generation Using the Kuroshio Current","description":"Ocean currents, such as the Kuroshio Current, are expected to be effectively used as marine renewable energy in order to supply sustainable energy and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. IHI is aiming to realize power generation using an ocean current and is working toward development of a floating type ocean current turbine system.\n\nJapan\u2019s Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) extending outside Japanese territorial waters is the world\u2019s sixth largest EEZ. Development of marine renewable energy in the EEZ needs to be actively promoted from the viewpoints of reduction in greenhouse gas emissions and energy security. As seen in the map on the next page, the ocean current known as the Kuroshio Current flows near the coastal areas of Japan stably throughout the year. Accordingly, it is expected that use of its enormous energy will allow us to establish a new clean and stable source of electricity based on Japan\u2019s own natural energy. In order to realize power generation by using this ocean current, IHI is developing a floating type ocean current turbine system. In this article, we introduce its technological characteristics.","author":["IHI Corporation"],"organization":["IHI Corporation"],"originationDate":"2014-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.048646000000","129.893726000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Ocean Current"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/IHI-Corporation-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2085","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-d55-report-final-project-conference-aalborg-denmark","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/8\/8941\/WP5_-_Final_project_conference.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable D5.5: Report of Final Project Conference, Aalborg, Denmark","description":"The SOWFIA project final conference was held as a side event of the European Wave and Tidal Conference EWTEC13 in Aalborg Denmark on the 3rd September 2013.  The SOWFIA Project team presented the final results of the project in four presentations given by Deborah Greaves, Cristina Huertas Olivares, Teresa Simas and Daniel Conley. This was followed by an interactive demonstration of the SOWFIA Data Management Platform, DMP, given by Jos\u00e9 Chambel Leit\u00e3o, and a reception.  The presentations are included in Annex A.  46 attended the final conference and the list of attendees is included in Annex B.","author":["Greaves, D.","Perez-Collazo, C."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2013-09-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.048819500000","9.921747000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WP5_-_Final_project_conference.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2086","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-d44-interim-report-critical-environmental-impacts-relevant-socio","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/8\/8940\/WP4_-_Interim_Report.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable D.4.4 Interim Report: Critical Environmental Impacts for Relevant Socio-economic Activities and Mitigation Measures Including Main Conclusions and Feedback Analysis from Workshop B and Analysis of the Stakeholder Survey","description":"This report aims to compile the information gathered so far regarding environmental and socio-economic key issues for each test centre under analysis and integrate it with stakeholders opinions collected during Workshop B and the stakeholders\u2019 survey for each test centre (Deliverable 4.3). For that purpose the environmental key issues for each test centre have been reviewed using the EIA reports available so far.\n\n\nThe comparison of EIA results for the six wave energy test centres reveals some commonalities on the environmental descriptors and impact evaluation. The same environmental descriptors have usually been identified for most but not all test sites (i.e. benthos, marine mammals, avifauna, coastal processes and water quality). Perhaps surprisingly, potential impacts on fish and elasmobranches have only been looked at for a minority of test centres. Even though the classification of impacts in the EIAs for the different test centres is different, the significance of an impact is generally linked to whether and how quickly the original site conditions can be restored and often linked to the magnitude of the habitat or species population potentially affected in comparison to the overall size of the habitat or species population. The significance of a potential impact is also determined by comparing the potential effects from the wave energy test centres with effects caused by naturally occurring phenomenon. The impacts identified are generally not significant, sometimes after mitigation. The most significant impacts are those which are associated with the installation phases for both the subsea cable and WECs, including foundations and moorings. The impacts associated with the operational phase of WECs are generally considered to be not significant even though it is recognised that potential impacts are largely unknown. Some differences in impacts evaluation occur often because of this uncertainty over impacts and sometimes due to site sensitivity. Given the low expected impacts of test centres on most of the environmental descriptors, mitigation measures are not overly onerous and often aim to be preventative. These mostly take the form of good practice during construction, good project management, contingency planning and avoiding certain construction operations at sensitive periods. To deal with the uncertainty of impacts evaluation, monitoring plans have been proposed but the exact nature of these (e.g. objectives, methodologies and duration) are not however specified.\n\n\nThe main socio-economic issues identified in the review were impacts on fishing, navigation and tourism. This is in agreement with the key socio-economic issues identified in the second SOWFIA workshop and the stakeholder survey. Consultation with stakeholders groups prior to the design of test centres layout has been identified in the EIA reports as an effective measure which the test centre developers undertook to mitigate stakeholders\u2019 concerns. The potential for positive socio-economic impacts is also highlighted in some of the EIAs. These include the direct and indirect creation of employment, increased tourism and the potential for increased fish stocks due to the creation of no take zones. There was however an important warning that potential benefits from developments should not be oversold in order for stakeholders\u2019 trust to be retained.\n\n\nGuidance can be taken from this work regarding the environmental descriptors and socio-economic issues that may be assessed in commercial scale projects in the future even though these are likely to require assessment on a larger scale. Similarly, guidance can be taken on the types of mitigation measures that may be required from commercial scale projects although it is uncertain how these will scale up. Once more is known about the environmental and socio-economic impacts of wave energy developments, assessment requirements, mitigation measures and stakeholder opinions may change considerably. Indeed, in the stakeholder surveys, concerns were expressed that test centres were relatively small facilities and consulted stakeholders stressed that this should not be automatically taken as acceptance of commercial scale ocean energy sites.","author":["Conley, D.","Simas, T.","Sundberg, J.","Greaves, D.","Bailey, I.","Magagna, D.","Saulnier, J.","Embling, C.","Marina, D.","O\u0027Callaghan, J."],"organization":["WavEC Offshore Renewables","Plymouth University","University College Cork","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)","Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)","Uppsala University","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2013-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WP4_-_Interim_Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2087","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-d-31-inventory-environmental-impact-monitoring-activities-wave","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/9\/9987\/D3.1_Inventory_of_Environmental_Impact_Monitoring_Activities_at_Wave___Tidal_Energy_Sites_in_Europe.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable D 3.1: Inventory of Environmental Impact Monitoring Activities at Wave \u0026 Tidal Energy Sites in Europe Final Report","description":"Whilst wind power is currently the main form of renewable energy generation in the marine environment, developments in the fields of wave and tidal power in recent years have brought these technologies to the forefront of renewable energy generation. Wave and tidal energy conversion devices have been in development for many years and numerous pilot projects for these devices are now underway in many countries across Europe, as well as areas such as Canada and the United States. In Europe, most developments of marine renewable energy installations (MREIs) require an Environmental Impact Assessment, the purpose of which is to ascertain the effects of the development on the natural environment, species, biological and physical processes. The permitting process can then weigh the scale of such impacts on the environment against the value of the installation in order to determine whether consent to proceed with the development will be granted or not. While some of the effects of introducing MREIs to the marine environment will be the same regardless of the installation involved, other effects will be device-specific. Effects will vary with the stage (construction, operation and decommissioning) and scale of the project, and will depend on location and the ecosystem in that area.","author":["Conley, D.","Sundberg, J.","Greaves, D.","Godley, B.","Witt, M.","Leeney, R.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","Holmes, B.","Mouslim, H.","McClellan, C."],"organization":["Plymouth University","University College Cork","University of Exeter","Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)","Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2011-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/D3.1_Inventory_of_Environmental_Impact_Monitoring_Activities_at_Wave___Tidal_Energy_Sites_in_Europe.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2088","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-d33-interim-wp3-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/8\/8938\/WP3_-_Interim_Report.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable D.3.3: Interim WP3 Report","description":"The present report highlights the work carried out by the SOWFIA project within Work Package 3 (WP3): \u201cCollection and Representation of environmental assessment data for wave energy test sites\u201d.   The objectives of WP3 are to gain experience in activities related to the detection of environmental impacts at wave energy test centres and to use that experience along with information obtained from environmental impact assessment activities in analogue activities in order to refine recently developed EIA recommendations.    These are achieved by including examples of EIA data collected at wave energy test sites from across Europe.  This data is to be analysed to examine the effectiveness of different techniques for detecting potential impacts and to assess their effectiveness at communicating to stakeholders their potential for impact detection.  As a result, procedures improve data presentation methods and platforms to enhance stakeholder communicability will be implemented.    The experience gained and outputs developed in this work package will provide examples of will be used to inform the recommendations for the streamlining of pan-European consenting procedures.","author":["Conley, D.","Simas, T.","Sundberg, J.","Greaves, D.","Torre-Enciso, Y.","Godley, B.","Witt, M.","Magagna, D.","Holmes, B.","Saulnier, J.","Embling, C.","Leit\u00e3o, J.","Mouslim, H.","Aires, E.","O\u0027Callaghan, J.","O\u0027Hagen, A."],"organization":["Plymouth University","Hidromod","University of Exeter","Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)","WavEC Offshore Renewables","University College Cork","Uppsala University","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)"],"originationDate":"2013-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WP3_-_Interim_Report-1.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2089","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-d21-catalogue-wave-energy-test-centres","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/9\/9986\/D2.1_Catalogue_of_Wave_Energy_Test_Centres.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable D.2.1: Catalogue of Wave Energy Test Centres","description":"The objective of this catalogue is to provide context for the future development of wave energy. This is achieved by identifying the level of ocean energy that could be introduced in order to achieve the targets set by Member States, what progress has been made to date in this regard, what is needed by 2020, the timeframe associated with achieving this set of targets, and what this will look like in reality. To do this, the document is presented in four key sections, followed by an Annex of physical and technical data.\u00a0","author":["Torre-Enciso, Y.","Leeney, R.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","Holmes, B.","Olivares, C.","Mora-Figueroa, V."],"organization":["Inabensa","University College Cork","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)","Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2012-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/D2.1_Catalogue_of_Wave_Energy_Test_Centres.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2090","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-d24-interim-report-barriers-accelerators-lessons-learned-all-wave","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/8\/8936\/WP2_-_Interim_Report.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable D.2.4: Interim Report on Barriers, Accelerators and Lessons Learned from all Wave Energy Site Experiences","description":"In October 2010, the SOWFIA project (Streamlining of Ocean Wave Farms Impact Assessment) was launched. The SOWFIA project draws together partners from across Europe that have an interest in streamlining impact assessment for wave farm developments.  This deliverable is part of the Work Package 2, aimed to identify non-technological barriers and accelerators of the Impact Assessment process among EU Member states and import the lessons learned to date in wave energy developments in Europe. Information has been gathered through a series of workshops, interviews, surveys and meetings. Within this framework an analysis of the workshop and questionnaires conducted in previous deliverables (D2.2 \u0026amp; D2.3) has been carried out to extract from developers\u2019 experiences the common barriers and accelerators to wave energy development in each country and compare them in order to reach recommendations for the streamlining of the impact assessment across all EU Member states. This report does not intend to be an exhaustive list of the non-technological barriers and accelerators to wave energy development as this was one of the outputs of the EU IEE WAVEPLAM (2007 \u2013 2010) project. Rather, it aims to analyse information gathered from real experience of recent wave energy developments and described in D2.2 and D2.3.  This analysis aims to describe the procedures experienced for the development of marine energy installations in each country and identify what the challenges are and what commitments should be made by policy makers and regulators if wave energy is to be brought to the forefront of the renewable energy market.  The countries analysed are those in which surveys were conducted. We can observe that more data is available for analysis from those countries that have been more active in the development of wave energy projects.  In these countries, the procedure is clearly defined whilst the analysis of the countries with less information is based on the experience of a smaller number of project developers.  The countries for which the analysis is carried out are the United Kingdom, Ireland, France, Spain, Portugal, Sweden, Norway and Denmark.  The layout of this document consists of the analysis of the Workshop A (\u201cReal Experience to Date in Wave Energy Development\u201d), followed by the analysis of the questionnaires (\u201cSite and technology developers, project financers and authorities questionnaires\u201d)  divided by country. A summary of both analyses follows, comparing the main aspects from a general view, and can be used as a preview for the last section. Recommendations for the streamlining of the ocean wave farms impact assessment are given in the last section of the report expressing the suggestions of the SOWFIA project team at this interim stage of the project.","author":["Greaves, D.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","Magagna, D.","Holmes, B.","Olivares, C.","Arjona, E."],"organization":["Inabensa","University College Cork"],"originationDate":"2012-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Arjonaetal2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2092","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-species-concern-wind-farms-new-zealand","sourceURL":"https:\/\/citeseerx.ist.psu.edu\/viewdoc\/download?doi=10.1.1.585.9371\u0026rep=rep1\u0026type=pdf","title":"Bird species of concern at wind farms in New Zealand","description":"Wind generation currently contributes about 1.5% of New Zealand\u2019s energy production, but the forecast rapid expansion in wind farm construction is likely to take this to close to 20% over the next 10 years. To date, no published studies are available giving accounts of the impacts of wind farms on birdlife in New Zealand; therefore, part of the challenge is to determine which species are likely to be adversely affected by wind farm construction and operation here. This resource document provides a brief summary of the threat ranking, distribution and movements of native and migrant bird species on the North and South Islands of New Zealand, and the potential impacts that wind farms may have on them (displacement, habitat loss and collision fatalities). The following species warrant particular consideration when present as residents in the vicinity of a wind farm, or when likely to be moving through a wind farm area on migration or during local movements: all kiwi, Australasian crested grebe (Podiceps cristatus), all penguins, threatened species of herons and allies, blue duck (Hymenolaimus malacorhynchos), brown teal (Anas aucklandica), New Zealand falcon (Falco novaeseelandiae), waders (Charadrii), and cuckoos. More research is required into the migratory behaviour of several native species to determine which wind farm sites are most likely to result in collision fatalities. In addition, data on the rates of avoidance of wind turbines by birds flying through wind farms is required, especially for those undertaking nocturnal migrations. The number of collision fatalities at New Zealand wind farms needs to be determined using systematic searches that take account of searcher efficiency and scavenger activity.","author":["Powlesland, R."],"organization":["New Zealand Department of Conservation"],"originationDate":"2009-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2093","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/too-loud-talk-do-wind-turbine-related-sounds-affect-harbour-seal-communication","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.springer.com\/us\/book\/9783835102354","title":"Too loud to talk?: Do wind turbine-related sounds affect harbour seal communication?","description":"The construction of wind turbines in the offshore areas of the German North and Baltic Seas represents a grave intrusion into the habitat of harbour seals and grey seals. One of the most important aspects in this context is the emission of intense acoustic impulses during the ramming of the turbine foundations. While hearing is of secondary importance in seals for locating prey, they use acoustic signals, and hence their hearing, for communication underwater and in air. Acoustic signals are used to keep contact between mother and pups during the nursing phase as well as for territorial display and to attract mating partners. The wind turbine-related sounds could mask these signals and severely impact seals on an individual basis but also on a population level. An auditory study was conducted on trained and wild seals to provide baseline data basis for the assessment of these effects. The experiments were conducted by measuring the auditory evoked potentials (AEPs) in the seals. Subsequent to a refinement of the method an audiogram for in-air sound stimuli was measured in a trained seal at the Seal Centre in Friedrichskoog, Germany.To successfully apply this approach to wild seals, the animals had to be immobilised to avoid the strong aversive reaction of the seals to being handled. Five seal pups rehabilitated at the seal station and three free-ranging seals were tested for the hearing sensitivity. While the hearing thresholds of the trained seals were elevated at in some frequencies, the results for the wild seals are in agreement with previously published hearing data from other studies on harbour seals from the North Pacific and Atlantic. The use of previously published data on the underwater hearing sensitivity in harbour seals was therefore considered acceptable to assess the effect of wind turbine related sounds on their communication. This analysis reveals that the ramming impulses will be detectable by seals over a range of 100km and is likely to mask their communication over wide ranges, too. The potential for masking from the operational noise of wind turbines was considered to be comparably low due to its acoustic characteristics.","author":["Lucke, K.","Siebert, U.","Sundermeyer, J.","Driver, J.","Rosenberger, T."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2008-03-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2094","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-wind-power-birds-bats-updated-synthesis-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.naturvardsverket.se\/Om-Naturvardsverket\/Publikationer\/ISBN\/6700\/978-91-620-6791-5\/","title":"The Effects of Wind Power on Birds and Bats: An Updated Synthesis Report","description":"The report is an update of the previous synthesis report: The effects of wind power on birds and bats, published in 2011. The updated report compiles international research in recent years and provides an analysis of Swedish postconstruction surveys implemented until 2016.\n\nThe report describes the types of environments to be avoided, what is important to consider prior to licensing, as well as which species that can be affected in different areas. It includes species facts with a review of species that may be adversely affected by wind power. The report contains in-depth reasoning about how to use scientifically based buffer zones, especially for eagles. For bats, new knowledge shows that wind power is generally a more serious problem than was realized five years ago. At the same time results of recent research suggest that relatively simple measures can limit the damage to bats considerably.\n\nThe Vindval research programme collects, creates and communicatesinformation and facts about the environmental impact of wind poweron the environment, the social landscape and people\u2019s perceptionof wind power installations. Vindval provides funding for research,including literature reviews and syntheses regarding the effects and experiences of wind power.","author":["Rydell, J.","Green, M.","Ottvall, R.","Pettersson, S."],"organization":["Lund University","University of Gothenburg","Vindval"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rydell-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2095","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/site-selection-offshore-wind-farms-southwest-coast-south-korea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117312879","title":"Site Selection for Offshore Wind Farms in the Southwest Coast of South Korea","description":"This study is to provide guidance for selecting sites suitable for offshore wind farm developments with lower social, economic, and environmental impacts in the South Korea southwest coastal area with its complicated shoreline configuration, large ecologically important tidal flats, and various marine-based human activities. To analyze the economic feasibility of offshore wind farms, harvestable energy was calculated using an InVEST (Integrated Valuation of Environmental Services and Tradeoffs) model that has been used widely for marine ecosystem service analysis. Capital costs for grid connection and electricity transmission, operation and maintenance costs, and other costs were integrated together to calculate a net present value (NPV) of a 60-MW offshore wind farm assuming a lifetime of 20 years of operation. It is important to note that NPVs of offshore wind farms are affected significantly by the proximity to the closest inland substations, showing the importance of grid connection. Criteria that may cause social and environmental conflicts were grouped into three categories: nature conservation and landscape protection, marine-based human activities, and marine environment and marine ecosystem. Available datasets for each category were compiled and incorporated into GIS-based maps. Many social and environmental criteria overlapped spatially, and areas influenced by one or more criteria were designated as areas of potential conflicts. Economic analysis results and potential social and environmental conflicts were considered together to select areas that could produce wind energy more efficiently with minimum social and environmental conflicts. Economic, social, and environmental assessment strategies and procedures provided in this study can be used as an effective decision-making support tool to find sites for offshore wind farm development and various other offshore developments as well.","author":["Kim, C.","Kim, T.","Jang, S."],"organization":["Korea Environment Institute"],"originationDate":"2018-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.557531800000","126.128895400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2096","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/winter-foraging-activity-central-european-vespertilionid-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1616504714001153","title":"Winter Foraging Activity of Central European Vespertilionid Bats","description":"The winter activity of bats was studied in an area of Bavaria, Southern Germany, for seven consecutive years (2007\u20132013). Echolocation calls were recorded in known foraging areas between October and March of each winter, and bats were regularly seen on evenings with temperatures above +6\u00a0\u00b0C, except for the period between mid-December and mid-February, when even bouts of warm weather did not appear to trigger foraging activity. Below +3\u00a0\u00b0C no bats appeared in the foraging areas. The most frequently recorded species were Nyctalus noctula, Pipistrellus pipistrellus, Pipistrellus nathusii and Vespertilio murinus. Final buzzes indicating attempts to catch prey were recorded for these species even in December and February, which supports the idea that the bats were not only in search of water or just moving between roosts. Myotis species, on the other hand, which hibernate in roosts offering more constant temperature conditions, were not observed at all between mid-November and March. Further investigations have to show whether warmer winter evenings offer bats an opportunity for casual hunting or whether winter foraging expresses an urgent need for weak individuals.","author":["Zahn, A.","Kriner, E."],"organization":["Ludwig Maximilian Universit\u00e4t of Munich"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.183333000000","12.400000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2097","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seasonal-diel-patterns-cetacean-use-foraging-potential-marine-renewable-energy-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X17308974","title":"Seasonal and Diel Patterns in Cetacean Use and Foraging at a Potential Marine Renewable Energy Site","description":"Marine renewable energy (MRE) developments often coincide with sites frequented by small cetaceans. To understand habitat use and assess potential impact from development, echolocation clicks were recorded with acoustic click loggers (C-PODs) in Swansea Bay, Wales (UK). General Additive Models (GAMs) were applied to assess the effects of covariates including month, hour, tidal range and temperature. Analysis of inter-click intervals allowed the identification of potential foraging events as well as patterns of presence and absence. Data revealed year-round presence of porpoise, with distinct seasonal and diel patterns. Occasional acoustic encounters of dolphins were also recorded. This study provides further evidence of the need for assessing temporal trends in cetacean presence and habitat use in areas considered for development. These findings could assist MRE companies to monitor and mitigate against disturbance from construction, operation and decommissioning activities by avoiding times when porpoise presence and foraging activity is highest in the area.","author":["Nuuttila, H.","Bertelli, C.","Mendzil, A.","Dearle, N."],"organization":["Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["3.901084000000","51.597663000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2098","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/broad-scale-acoustic-monitoring-cetaceans-underwater-noise-relation-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.4988864","title":"Broad-Scale Acoustic Monitoring for Cetaceans and Underwater Noise in Relation to Offshore Wind Farm Construction in Scotland","description":"Marine construction projects, such as offshore wind farms and port developments often use techniques that produce significant levels of noise underwater, which could have effects on marine wildlife. Marine Scotland is the government body responsible for regulating these activities in Scottish waters and for ensuring that wildlife populations are protected in line with legislation. Large scale offshore wind farm construction will begin to take place off the Scottish east coast in 2017, using piled foundations. To monitor for potential broad scale changes in distribution of protected cetacean species during construction activities, Marine Scotland have deployed an array of 30 click detectors and 10 broadband acoustic recorders across the Scottish east coast each summer since 2013. Here we present baseline distributions for dolphins and harbour porpoises, along with ambient noise levels recorded concurrently. Dolphin detections across the monitored area are highly variable, with some locations that are clearly favoured. Harbour porpoise are ubiquitous and in more than 60% of locations are detected on 100% of monitored days. This is likely to mean that there is more power to detect changes in porpoise distribution in relation to offshore wind farm pile driving than for dolphins.","author":["Davies, I.","Merchant, N.","Edwards, E.","Brookes, K."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science","Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.949242900000","-4.160241400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2099","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/whale-entanglements-submarine-telecommunication-cables","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/document\/4769692\/","title":"Whale Entanglements With Submarine Telecommunication Cables","description":"Before 1955-1966, 16 instances of whale entanglement with submarine telegraphic cables were reported in the scientific literature. Here we present new information, derived from global cable fault databases, that reveals an absence of whale entanglements since 1959. This cessation coincided with the transition from telegraphic to coaxial telecommunication cables followed by the change to fiber-optic systems in the 1980s. We propose that entanglements ceased in response to advances in cable design, marine surveying, and cable laying techniques. These changes involved the following: 1) development of torque-balanced cables that were less prone to self-coiling, 2) laying armored cables under slight tension to minimize suspensions and loops, and laying low-torque, nonarmored cables with minimum slack to follow the seabed topography, 3) avoidance of rough topography where suspensions may develop, 4) burial of cables below the seabed on the continental shelf and upper slope to protect against shipping and fishing activities, and 5) use of fault repair procedures that reduce cable slack.","author":["Wood, M.","Carter, L."],"organization":["Victoria University of Wellington"],"originationDate":"2008-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Entanglement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2100","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nova-bluemull-sound-appropriate-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/Topics\/marine\/Licensing\/marine\/scoping\/nova\/nova-aa","title":"Nova Bluemull Sound - Appropriate Assessment","description":"The proposal is for the installation, operation and decommissioning of five 2 bladed 100 kW tidal turbines. The proposed devices are bottom mounted, gravity anchored, non-yawing horizontal axis tidal turbines comprising of a cylindrical nacelle unit, rotor and gravity base to secure it to the sea bed (no seabed drilling or additional site works are required). The negatively buoyant nacelle is securely connected to the base by means of a latching system. The rotor rotates in the tidal stream and powers a generator that is housed within the nacelle.  The turbine has a rotor diameter of 10m and a hub height of 9m, making the total height 14m from the bottom of the feet to the tip of the blades. In the Bluemull Array the devices will be installed in water depths greater than 30 m, so clearance will be more than 15 m below mean tide. The footprint of the device is 13.5 x 12.2 m, and the weight in water is 80 tonnes. The device will operate in a maximum sustained tidal speed of 2.6 m\/s.  This is a record of the appropriate assessment (AA) of the Nova Tidal Array proposal. The assessment has been undertaken by  MSS and MS-LOT. This assessment is required under Regulation 48 of the Conservation (Natural Habitats, \u0026amp;c.) Regulations 1994. This AA is in accordance with Council Directive 92\/43\/EEC on the conservation of natural habitats under wild fauna and flora (\u201cthe  Habitats Directive\u201d) and Council Directive 2009\/147\/EC on the conservation of wild birds (\u201cthe Birds Directive\u201d). MS-LOT, as the \u0027competent authority\u0027 under the Regulations, has to be satisfied that the project will not cause an adverse effect to the integrity of any European site (special areas of conservation (SACs) and special protection areas (SPAs)) before it can grant consent for the project.","author":["Marine Scotland Science"],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2016-01-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.668061000000","-0.969035000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-24 04:28:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NovaBluemullSound-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2101","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/new-wave-marine-evidence-based-management-emerging-challenges-solutions-transform","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/advance-article\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsx216\/4739744","title":"A New Wave of Marine Evidence-Based Management: Emerging Challenges and Solutions to Transform Monitoring, Evaluating, and Reporting","description":"Sustainable management and conservation of the world\u2019s oceans requires effective monitoring, evaluation, and reporting (MER). Despite the growing political and social imperative for these activities, there are some persistent and emerging challenges that marine practitioners face in undertaking these activities. In 2015, a diverse group of marine practitioners came together to discuss the emerging challenges associated with marine MER, and potential solutions to address these challenges. Three emerging challenges were identified: (i) the need to incorporate environmental, social and economic dimensions in evaluation and reporting; (ii) the implications of big data, creating challenges in data management and interpretation; and (iii) dealing with uncertainty throughout MER activities. We point to key solutions to address these challenges across MER activities: (i) integrating models into marine management systems to help understand, interpret, and manage the environmental and socio-economic dimensions of uncertain and complex marine systems; (ii) utilizing big data sources and new technologies to collect, process, store, and analyze data; and (iii) applying approaches to evaluate, account for, and report on the multiple sources and types of uncertainty. These solutions point towards a potential for a new wave of evidence-based marine management, through more innovative monitoring, rigorous evaluation and transparent reporting. Effective collaboration and institutional support across the science\u2013management\u2013policy interface will be crucial to deal with emerging challenges, and implement the tools and approaches embedded within these solutions.","author":["Addison, P.","Jones, G.","Collins, D.","Trebilco, R.","Howe, S.","Bax, N.","Hedge, P.","Miloslavich, P.","Roelfsema, C.","Sams, M.","Stuart-Smith, R.","Scanes, P.","von Baumgarten, P.","McQuatters-Gollop, A."],"organization":["University of Oxford","Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS)","University of Tasmania","University of Queensland","Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2017-12-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Addison-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2102","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/white-pines-wind-project-natural-heritage-assessment-environmental-impact-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/canada.wpd.de\/fileadmin\/pdfs\/WhitePines\/WPWF%20(1-41-013)_NHAEIS_28June2012%20Report(1).pdf","title":"White Pines Wind Project: Natural Heritage Assessment and Environmental Impact Study","description":"wpd Canada Corporation (wpd) is a renewable energy development company based in Mississauga, Ontario dedicated to providing renewable energy for Ontario.  wpd is proposing to develop the White Pines Wind Farm (the Project) on privately-owned land in Prince Edward County, Ontario, in response to the Government of Ontario\u2019s initiative to promote the development of renewable electricity in the province. The Project was awarded an Ontario Feed-In-Tariff (FIT) contract with the Ontario Power Authority (OPA) in May, 2010 (FIT Contract NO. F-000675-WIN-130-601).  The Project Study Area is generally bounded by i) Brummell Road\/Bond Road to the North; ii) Lighthall Road to the West; iii) Gravelly Bay Road to the East; and iv) Lake Ontario to the South. Settlements in the area include Picton, Milford, Port Milford and South Bay. All turbines, access roads, and underground collector lines will be located on private property and within the municipal road allowance. The location of the Project Study Area within Prince Edward County is shown on Figure 1, Appendix A.  The interconnection line is not considered a Project component and has therefore not been included within the NHA\/EIS Assessment. The substation near the Picton Transformer Station is considered a Project component and has been included within the NHA\/EIS Assessment. The substation is located north of Picton, on County Road 5, west of Elmbrook Road. The location of the northern substation is shown on Figure 2, Appendix A (see \u201cNorthern Study Area\u201d).","author":["Stantec Consulting"],"organization":["Stantec Consulting"],"originationDate":"2012-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.908013800000","-77.084651400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Stantec-2012-White-Pines.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2103","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hermosa-west-wind-energy-project-draft-environmental-impact-statement","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.wapa.gov\/transmission\/interconnection\/hermosa-west\/","title":"Hermosa West Wind Energy Project: Draft Environmental Impact Statement","description":"ShellWind Energy (SWE), a wholly owned subsidiary of Shell Oil Company, is proposing to construct a commercial, utility\u2010scale wind energy generation facility that would be located near Tie Siding, Wyoming, in Albany County. At full build\u2010out, the Hermosa West Wind Energy Project (Project) would include up to 200 wind turbines with a combined generating capacity of up to 300 megawatts (MW) of renewable energy. The wind turbines would be configured along 11 strings, oriented north to south to capture prevailing winds on an 11,125\u2010acre site. In addition to the turbines, other proposed Project facilities would include all\u2010weather access roads, underground power collection lines linking turbines to the Project substation, the Project substation and switchyard, a short (approximately 0.3\u2010mile) high\u2010voltage gen\u2010tie line linking the Project substation to Western\u2019s transmission system, a low voltage distribution line, operation and maintenance facilities, backup power for the 345\u2010kilovolt substation\/switchyard site, supervisory control and data acquisition equipment and metering equipment, and up to four permanent meteorological towers. The proposed Project would be located on private and state land; no federally\u2010managed land would be affected.  Western\u2019s purpose and need is to consider SWE\u2019s interconnection request under its Open Access Transmission Service Tariff (Tariff), which is compliant with Federal Energy Regulatory Commission\u2019s Order No. 888 establishing open access to power transmission systems (18 CFR Parts 35 and 385). Under the Tariff, Western must either approve or deny the interconnection request.  Western\u2019s decision to approve or deny the interconnection request, and to construct an interconnection facility (switchyard) financed by SWE for operational control of the interconnection is considered a major Federal action subject to NEPA, Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) regulations for implementing NEPA, and DOE NEPA Implementing Procedures (40 CFR Parts 1500\u22121508, 10 CFR Part 1021). This environmental impact statement (EIS) is prepared in accordance with NEPA requirements to analyze the potential effects to the natural and human environments associated with approving or denying the interconnection request. As part of the analysis, Western is disclosing the potential effects to the natural and human environments resulting from SWE\u2019s proposed Project. This EIS analysis also includes a federal \u201cNo Action\u201d alternative under which Western would not consider an interconnection agreement with SWE and the proposed Project would not be constructed and interconnected with Western\u2019s transmission system.  Appendices:    Appendix A: Facilities study  Appendix B: Threatened and Endangered Species Report  Appendix C: Surface Water Assessment Report  Appendix D: Wetland Assessment Reports  Appendix E: Wildlife Baseline Studies  Appendix F: Bat Acoustical Studies  Appendix G: Tribal Consultation Letter  Appendix H: Paleontologic Resources Analysis  Appendix I: Noise Assessment  Appendix J: Transportation Analysis  Appendix K: Recreation and Land Use Assessment  Appendix L: Social and Economic Impacts  Appendix M: Lease Area-Potential for Development of Economic Resources  Appendix N: Preliminary Geotechnical Inversigation Results  Appendix O: Second Geotechnical Investigation Results  Appendix P: Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment  Appendix Q: Viewshed Analysis","author":["Western Area Power Administration (WAPA)"],"organization":["Western Area Power Administration (WAPA)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2012-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.652162000000","-105.528338000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hermosa-West-EIS-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2104","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tool-simulating-collision-probabilities-animals-marine-renewable-energy-devices","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0188780","title":"A Tool for Simulating Collision Probabilities of Animals with Marine Renewable Energy Devices","description":"The mathematical problem of establishing a collision probability distribution is often not trivial. The shape and motion of the animal as well as of the device must be evaluated in a four-dimensional space (3D motion over time). Earlier work on wind and tidal turbines was limited to a simplified two-dimensional representation, which cannot be applied to many new structures. We present a numerical algorithm to obtain such probability distributions using transient, three-dimensional numerical simulations. The method is demonstrated using a sub-surface tidal kite as an example. Necessary pre- and post-processing of the data created by the model is explained, numerical details and potential issues and limitations in the application of resulting probability distributions are highlighted.","author":["Hammar, L.","Molander, S.","Schmitt, P.","Kregting, L.","Lieber, L.","Culloch, R."],"organization":["Queen\u0027s University Belfast","Chalmers University of Technology","Swedish Agency for Marine and Water Management (SwAM)"],"originationDate":"2017-11-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Schmitt-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2105","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/strategic-sectoral-planning-offshore-renewable-energy-scotland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-94-017-8002-5_11","title":"Strategic Sectoral Planning for Offshore Renewable Energy in Scotland","description":"The development-plan-based approach being taken to the establishment of the offshore wind, wave and tidal sectors in Scotland is outlined. The strategic planning framework and processes leading to the development of Draft Plans are explained, along with the relationships between these and the sustainability appraisal process. Detail is also given of the spatial planning methods used to identify development opportunities for one sector in Scottish waters.  This is a chapter from Humanity and the Sea: Marine Renewable Energy Technology and Environmental Interactions.","author":["Pratt, D.","Davies, I."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-10-14 10:53:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2106","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/determining-water-column-usage-seals-brims-lease-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/data.marine.gov.scot\/dataset\/determining-water-column-usage-seals-brims-lease-site","title":"Determining the Water Column Usage by Seals in the Brims Lease Site","description":"The report describes how adult harbour seals and grey seal pups use the water column within the Brims lease site.\nTelemetry data from 12 adult harbour seals and seven grey seal pups diving within the Brims lease site were analysed to extract descriptors of dive behaviour.\nDive data were summarised to provide estimates of the proportion of time seals spent at different depths relative to the sea surface and relative to the seafloor. In addition to estimates of the proportion of time at depth, the number of times seals transited through different depth bins relative to the sea surface and sea floor was also determined.\nWater depths at dive locations were estimated from high resolution bathymetry data corrected for tide height at that time and place.\nHarbour seals spent approximately 31 % of their time at intermediate depths between 10 m to 25 m from the surface, with a secondary but less pronounced peak between 75 m and 80 m from the surface. When expressed as a distance from the seafloor, harbour seals spent the highest proportion of time within 5 m of the seafloor (mean = 0.16; 95 % CIs: 0.04-0.46) with a secondary peak between 65 m and 70 m from the seafloor (mean = 0.12; 95 % CIs: 0.03-0.26) indicating a significant amount of mid water swimming by harbour seals at this site. Harbour seals spent on average 12.8 % of their time in the band between 5 m and 25 m above the sea floor.\nFor grey seal pups, the proportion of time spent in depth bands decreases monotonically with depth and the amount of time spent close to the sea floor was lower than in harbour seals. Grey seal pups spent on average 6.5 % of their time in the band between 5 m and 25 m above the sea floor.\nHarbour seals in the Brims site entered or transited through the zone between 5 m and 25 m from the sea floor on approximately 27 % of dives. Grey seal pups entered the depth bands closest to the seafloor less frequently than did the harbour seals.","author":["Thompson, D.","Hastie, G.","Onoufriou, J.","Blight, C.","Evers, C."],"organization":["Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2017-11-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Evers-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2107","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/rethinking-underwater-sound-recording-methods-work-tidal-stream-wave-energy-sites","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-94-017-8002-5_9","title":"Rethinking Underwater Sound-Recording Methods to Work at Tidal-Stream and Wave-Energy Sites","description":"Commercial-scale devices to extract energy from tidal streams and waves may be new, but an associated industry is developing fast. In most countries, device introduction will require investigation and some level of proof that they do not unduly harm local wildlife. Of the impacts that they might have, the emission of acoustic energy (noise) into the marine environment is important. In operation, it is possible, though unlikely, that they will emit sufficient noise to cause auditory damage to sensitive species, but some level of area avoidance\/attraction and masking is likely. Nevertheless, all such devices will require perceivable acoustic signatures for animals to detect and avoid colliding with them. To understand these issues, information on operational device acoustic characteristics is required along with information on existing background noise levels at sites suitable for extraction of marine energy. However, the energetic features of these locations with intense lateral, vertical or oscillatory motion mean that conventional methods of underwater sound recording are unsuitable. Here new methods for sound measurement specifically tailored to tidal-stream and wave-energy sites are introduced. The methods are illustrated following performance tests and real measurements at the European Marine Energy Centre tidal test site in Orkney, UK.\n\nThis is a chapter from Humanity and the Sea: Marine Renewable Energy Technology and Environmental Interactions.","author":["Wilson, B.","Carter, C.","Lepper, P.","Robinson, S."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","Loughborough University","National Physical Laboratory (NPL)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2108","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/influence-fisheries-exclusion-addition-hard-substrata-fish-crustaceans","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-94-017-8002-5_5","title":"The Influence of Fisheries Exclusion and Addition of Hard Substrata on Fish and Crustaceans","description":"Offshore renewable energy development (ORED) could induce local ecological changes and put species assemblages of conservation interest at risk. If well planned and coordinated, however, ORED could be beneficial to the local subsurface marine environment in several aspects. Acknowledging the scale of ORED, there is increasing interest in the opportunities offered by the resulting changes in fishing patterns, such as exclusion or limi-tation of bottom trawling, in wind and wave farms. Areas encompassing several square kilometres may in some important aspects resemble Marine Protected Areas, and wind and wave-energy foundations and other associated structures can function as artificial reef modules and enhance the local abundance of marine organisms, including commercially important fish and crustaceans. It is also possible that floating offshore energy devices can function as fish aggregation devices for pelagic fish. Here, the potential influence of off-shore wind and wave farms on fish and commercially important crustaceans is described, mentioning the uncertainties with regard to positive and negative effects on benthic and pelagic assemblages and specific species.  This is a chapter from Humanity and the Sea: Marine Renewable Energy Technology and Environmental Interactions.","author":["Langhamer, O.","Wilhelmsson, D."],"organization":["Royal Swedish Academy of Science","Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2026-10-14 10:55:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2109","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/baselines-monitoring-methods-detecting-impacts-hydrodynamic-energy-extraction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-94-017-8002-5_3","title":"Baselines and Monitoring Methods for Detecting Impacts of Hydrodynamic Energy Extraction on Intertidal Communities of Rocky Shores","description":"As part of the UK government\u2019s objective to deliver an increasing proportion of electricity from renewable sources, West Mainland, Orkney, is at the forefront of the development of wave-energy extraction devices. Exposure to wave energy plays a dominant role in shaping the Orkney landscape and determining the ecological community, but little is known of the consequences of commercial scale removal of energy from the environment. An extensive long-term monitoring programme to assess the impacts of altering wave-energy exposure on these rocky shores alongside responses to other systemic forcing agents such as climate change is continuing. Within the programme are photographic surveys, including quadrat and fixed viewpoint techniques, littoral studies of sentinel species, and the development of cost-effective wave-energy quantifying devices. Software has been developed to analyse images efficiently, to produce quantitative data on species and biotope coverage. Additionally, extensive surveys along the shoreline provide detailed image records, including areas without prior scientific description, and have helped identify locations of environmental sensitivity. Collectively, the data provide a comprehensive pre-development baseline along this important coast.\n\nThis\u00a0is a chapter from\u00a0Humanity and the Sea: Marine Renewable Energy Technology and Environmental Interactions.","author":["Side, J.","Beharie, R.","Want, A.","Bell, M."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2110","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/coating-selection-process-gulf-stream-hydroturbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/coet.fau.edu\/sites\/default\/files\/research\/theses\/DT-09-340.pdf","title":"Coating Selection Process for Gulf Stream Hydroturbines","description":"The study addresses the coating selection for a proposed placement of a hydroturbine into the Gulf Stream. The turbine will generate energy in a similar manner to a wind turbine. The effects of biofouling and corrosion in the current project are assessed. A review of different types of traditional paint coatings is given, as well as the option for a copper-nickel alloy. Testing that should be undertaken for the coating selection is described in detail. Coating considerations are offered and discussed. Design considerations and modifications are also offered.","author":["Bak, A."],"organization":["Florida Atlantic University"],"originationDate":"2009-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2111","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/physics-hydrodynamic-setting-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/278711398_The_Physics_and_Hydrodynamic_Setting_of_Marine_Renewable_Energy","title":"The Physics and Hydrodynamic Setting of Marine Renewable Energy","description":"Increasing interest is apparent in marine energy resources, particularly tidal and wave. Some TeraWatts of energy propagate from the world\u2019s oceans to its marginal seas in the form of surface waves (\u2248 2 TW) and tides (\u2245 2.6 TW) where that energy is naturally dissipated. The seas and coastlines around the UK and its neighbours are notable for dissipating a significant fraction of the global energy of waves (\u2248 50 MW km\u22121 on the Atlantic coast) and especially tides (\u0026gt; 250 GW north of Brittany). Displacing a significant fraction of the natural dissipation by energy capture is a tempting and reasonable proposition, but it does raise technical and environmental issues. Sustainable exploitation of the energy needs to consider diverse effects on the environment, waves and tides having a role in maintaining the shelf sea, coastal, estuarine and shoreline environment through associated advection, stirring and other processes. Tides are particularly significant in controlling the stratifica-tion of shelf seas and their flow characteristics. Surface waves are more important in deter-mining conditions nearshore and in the intertidal zone. Also, the exploitation of wave and tidal resources is only practical economically and technologically at a limited number of energetic and accessible sites, and societal and ecological considerations inevitably narrow the choice.  This is a chapter from Humanity and the Sea: Marine Renewable Energy Technology and Environmental Interactions.","author":["Woolf, D.","Easton, M.","Bowyer, P.","McIvenny, J."],"organization":["University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)","Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2112","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/introduction-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-94-017-8002-5_1","title":"An Introduction to Marine Renewable Energy","description":"It is now widely recognized that there is a need for long-term secure and suitable sustainable forms of energy. Renewable energy from the marine environment, in particular renewable energy from tidal currents, wave and wind, can help achieve a sustainable energy future. Our understanding of environmental impacts and suitable mitigation methods associated with extracting renewable energy from the marine environment is improving all the time and it is essential that we distinguish between natural and anthropocentric drivers and impacts.  This is a chapter from Humanity and the Sea: Marine Renewable Energy Technology and Environmental Interactions.","author":["Sheilds, M."],"organization":["UK Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)","University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-10-14 10:53:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2113","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measuring-underwater-background-noise-high-tidal-flow-environments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148112000316","title":"Measuring Underwater Background Noise in High Tidal Flow Environments","description":"Understanding the effect of marine energy development on the underwater noise levels in a proposed installation area forms a crucial part of any Environmental Impact Assessment. This paper uses boat-based hydrophone survey data taken from an area subject to tidal currents up to 3 m s-1 and deter-mines how the background noise levels change with tidal \ufb02ow and \ufb02ow direction. It was found that a more meaningful expression of background noise was gained by reference to \u201cPower level\u201d as measured by the Root Mean Square of the spectrum. Hydrophone measurements were taken during low season (with respect to other maritime activity) and in high season over the entire tidal cycle. Back-ground noise levels ranged between 72 and 108 dB re 1 \u00b5PaRMS with higher sound pressure levels occurring at frequencies below 100 Hz. Background noise levels increased with increasing tidal \ufb02ow and were higher on ebb tides than \ufb02ood tides.  Click here for more information on Ramsey Sound.","author":["Willis, M.","Broudic, M.","Masters, I.","Haywood, C.","Thomas, S."],"organization":["Swansea University","Ecole d\u0027Ing\u00e9nieurs en G\u00e9nie des Syst\u00e9mes Industriels (EIGSI)","Tidal Energy Ltd"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2114","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-benefits-offshore-wind-energy-projects-nepa","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Final-Version-Offshore-Benefits-White-Paper\/","title":"Evaluating Benefits of Offshore Wind Energy Projects in NEPA","description":"Pursuant to Title 30 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 585, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) has regulatory authority over offshore energy development including conventional oil and gas exploration and production, and renewable energy production from wind, waves, and currents. BOEM must comply with the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) prior to approving a lessee\u2019s construction and operation plan for a wind or other renewable energy production project on the Outer Continental Shelf (OCS). NEPA analyses (Environmental Assessments [EAs] or Environmental Impact Statements [EISs]) typically focus on adverse impacts to the environment. However, NEPA analyses also need to include environmental and socioeconomic benefits analyses. AECOM has been contracted by BOEM to prepare this white paper to identify resources and describe technical approaches that can be used by authors of EAs and EISs to capture the beneficial effects that can accrue from the development of renewable energy sources on the OCS. This white paper is also prepared for interested members of the general public who seek a better understanding of how benefits can be captured, described, and evaluated during the NEPA process.  In 2007, the Minerals Management Service (MMS) published the report Assessing the Costs and Benefits of Electricity Generation Using Alter native Energy Resources on the Outer Continental Shelf (MMS 2007a). The report noted that while wind is not the only potential energy resource in the offshore environment, the commercial-scale development of energy from hydrokinetic sources (waves and tidal and ocean currents) is considerably behind the commercial-scale development of offshore wind, despite nearly a decade of development. Since October 2010, BOEM has issued 13 commercial wind energy leases consisting of 1,383,109 acres (over 559,724 hectares). In contrast, no commercially viable hydrokinetic projects have been developed on the OCS, although several demonstration projects have been proposed.  In addition, in April 2009, BOEM and the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) that clarified jurisdiction of each agency over renewable energy projects on the OCS. In the MOU, BOEM has jurisdiction over offshore wind and solar power projects and issues leases for hydrokinetic energy projects, while the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission issues licenses for offshore hydrokinetic energy production. Because information on wind energy production methods are more robust than other offshore alternative energy sources and offshore wind energy production falls fully within BOEM\u2019s regulatory authority, this report is primarily focused on offshore wind production. However, many of the issues considered and resources identified in this report are applicable to other renewable energy projects, independent of the offshore wind energy generation method under consideration.  This report is organized into three primary sections: Section 2 briefly discusses three factors that will be important in dictating how a NEPA-focused benefits analysis could be included in the NEPA process; Section 3 identifies tools and resources for conducting the benefits analysis; and Section 4 describes where in the NEPA process this benefit analysis could most readily fit. Section 5 provides a summary of the key features of the white paper.","author":["AECOM"],"organization":["AECOM","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/AECOM-2017-BOEM.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2115","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/improving-efficiencies-national-environmental-policy-act-documentation-offshore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Improving-Efficiencies-of-National-Environmental\/","title":"Improving Efficiencies of National Environmental Policy Act Documentation for Offshore Wind Facilities - Case Studies Report","description":"The United States (US) is currently embracing offshore wind farm (OWF) development as part of its expanding renewable energy generation objectives in response to renewables targets, financial incentives, and technological advancements. Expansion of the US offshore renewables industry was initially facilitated by amendments to the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act (OCSLA), made under Section 388 of the Energy Policy Act (EPAct) (2005), which granted authority for the leasing of offshore renewables developments to the Department of the Interior (DOI) and subsequently to the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM). In 2009, BOEM released its Renewable Energy Program Regulations (30 CFR 585) setting out the statutory framework within which the offshore renewables industry would be regulated and has subsequently disseminated rules and guidelines to further enable offshore renewables developments.\n\nAs well as the regulatory regime laid out by the EPAct Section 388, BOEM also considers the requirements of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. \u00a74321-4347) (NEPA). This discusses the potential environmental consequences of federal actions, including detailed site specific environmental analyses that are typically needed to evaluate the likelihood and significance of impacts of proposed federal actions on physical, biological, and historic resources, societal values and socio-economic factors. The findings of the impact analyses are typically reported in an Environmental Assessment (EA) and\/or Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) and made available for public consumption and scrutiny 1. Identification of the scope of issues to be reviewed and addressed in EA and EIS are commonly identified through extensive project scoping and consultation exercises with relevant agencies, stakeholders, and interested parties. These exercises also draw out the scale of the perceived concerns, the methods of the analyses to be used in EIS and the scope of supporting investigative studies.\n\nWith respect to offshore wind leasing, most of BOEM EAs to date have addressed only the installation of meteorological buoys or towers to gather wind resource data and conducting surveys to gather geotechnical and geophysical data. When BOEM receives construction and operations plans (COP) for the installation of wind facilities, BOEM will likely prepare EISs to analyze potential impacts. Additionally, there will be other NEPA analyses throughout the project. Determinations of NEPA adequacy (DNA), or Categorical Exclusions may also be used. Design changes and new information may require additional analyses throughout the life of the project.\n\nFor large infrastructure proposals within nascent industries with limited experience, consultations may be extensive and the level of perceived statutory and stakeholder concern may be substantial. This can result in the identification of a wide range of issues that are required to be addressed in sufficient depth and detail to provide the necessary knowledge, comfort, and precaution to underpin confident decision making. Applications for larger projects, such as OWFs, can therefore place a considerable burden on permitting authorities to undertake and complete environmental analyses and reviews and permit them to proceed in a timely and responsible fashion. This is particularly relevant in light of the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) Regulations (40 CFR 1502.5) which calls for respective agencies to prepare EIS in a sufficiently timely fashion to enable findings to be used practically within the decision-making processes and to be available prior to that portion of public hearings relevant to impact statement.\n\nIn light of increased numbers of applications for offshore wind development and associated increases in case load, as well as the ambitions of the CEQ Regulations, BOEM has recognized the need to streamline the preparation, review and, analysis of associated environmental information required under NEPA.\n\nTo facilitate potential streamlining of the NEPA review processes, Fugro noted that substantial environmental analyses of large offshore wind projects have already been completed in Europe where commercial scale developments have been operating for approximately 20 years. These analyses have been undertaken as required by the European Union (EU) Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Directive and which may be considered analogous to NEPA in terms of the broad environmental aims, sustainability aspirations and dissemination of conclusions among stakeholders and the wider public. In addition, many OWFs in Europe have been subject to environmental monitoring and research under the terms of their specific development licenses and in response to stakeholder concerns. This means that there is considerable empirical evidence available as to the actual environmental impacts of OWF construction and operation. Fugro considered that a systematic review and synthesis of these monitoring studies, where publicly available, may be appropriate to develop a robust evidence base to demonstrate consistent impacts for given receptors, conditions, geographic locations, and vulnerabilities and thereby help identify some elements that, in time, could be subject to reduced NEPA analysis or removed from repeated study entirely. This may be possible, for instance, where perceived concerns have not been realized following post-construction monitoring campaigns, or where impacts are consistently shown to be of minor or negligible significance. In particular, it may be possible to reduce certain aspects of planned activities, or environmental components, from the consideration of NEPA analysis where the following conditions exist:\nPrecedent for impacts to be of minor or negligible significance;\nHigh confidence in the baseline environmental data;\nReceptor similarity of conditions;\nA robust design envelope; and\nEffective and agreed mitigation which can be conditioned within the final Construction and Operations Pl an (COP) approval.\n\nSimilarly, where adverse impacts have been successfully mitigated, evidence of that outcome can also be used to inform mitigation implementation. Conversely, where unanticipated adverse impacts have occurred, this data too could be used to ensure the future EIA include the necessary evaluation of these impacts. This document presents the findings of a systematic review and synthesis of European OWF monitoring campaigns and consolidates available impact and mitigation data with the intention of improving stakeholder understanding of comparable work done in Europe, reducing uncertainties associated with current state-of-the-practice knowledge in the US and identifying critical data gaps requiring further and more detailed study specific to US conditions","author":["Mason, T.","Smith, M.","Mackay, A.","Tibbles, B.","English, P.","Backstrom, J.","Mitchell, T."],"organization":["Fugro EMU","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/English-et-al-2017-BOEM.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2116","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/munitions-explosives-concern-survey-methodology-field-testing-wind-energy-areas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/Munitions-and-Explosives-of-Concern-Survey-Methodology-and-In-field-Testing-for-Wind-Energy-Areas-on-the-Atlantic-Outer-Continental-Shelf\/","title":"Munitions and Explosives of Concern Survey Methodology and In-Field Testing for Wind Energy Areas on the Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf","description":"This report summarizes the in-field testing and methodology verification associated with Task 3 of the United States Department of the Interior, Bureau of Safety and Environmental Enforcement\u2019s Statement of Work, \u201cUnexploded Ordnance (UXO) Survey Methodology Investigation\u201d under contract M16PC00001. CALIBRE and its subcontractors (University of Delaware, University of Hawaii, and Environet, Inc.) met the goal of the study by investigating, verifying, and recommending methodologies to identify munitions and explosives of concern (MEC), including UXO, specific to conditions found in renewable energy lease and planning areas along the Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf (OCS). Regional expectations of type, size, and likelihood of presence for UXO and MEC along the Atlantic OCS were identified through desktop review. The overarching goal of this project is to develop an approach for identifying technologies and methodologies to be used in the ocean to determine routes free from significant obstacles to enable the safe construction and operation of wind turbines, power cables, and similar offshore energy projects. Based on this research, the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) may develop guidance for lessees on surveying for MEC on the Atlantic OCS.\n\nIn-field testing was performed within the Delaware Wind Energy Area (WEA), an approximately 391 square kilometer (km2) area offshore of Delaware. The closest point to shore is approximately 18 kilometers (km) due east from Rehoboth Beach, Delaware. A 4.5 km2 area within the Delaware WEA was designated as the study area and was investigated between July 18 and 29, 2016.","author":["Carton, G.","DuVal, C.","Trembanis, A.","Edwards, M.","Rognstad, M.","Briggs, C.","Shjegstad, S."],"organization":["CALIBRE Systems Inc","University of Delaware","University of Hawaii","Environet Inc","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.677141800000","-74.471822100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Carton-et-al-2017-BOEM.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2117","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/determining-fine-scale-use-movement-patterns-diving-bird-species-federal-waters-mid","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pubs.er.usgs.gov\/publication\/70194432","title":"Determining Fine-Scale Use and Movement Patterns of Diving Bird Species in Federal Waters of the Mid-Atlantic United States Using Satellite Telemetry","description":"Offshore wind energy development in the United States is projected to expand in the upcoming decades to meet growing energy demands and reduce fossil fuel emissions. There is particular interest in commercial offshore wind development within Federal waters (i.e., \u0026gt; 3 nautical miles from shore) of the mid-Atlantic. In order to understand the potential for adverse effects on marine birds in this area, information on distribution and behavior (e.g., flight pathways, timing, etc.) is required for a broad suite of species. In areas where offshore wind development is likely to occur, such information can be used to identify high use areas during critical life stages, which can inform the siting of offshore facilities. It can also be used to provide baseline data for understanding broad changes in distributions that occur after offshore wind developments are constructed in a specific area.  The primary objective of this study was to determine fine scale use and movement patterns of three species of diving marine birds, Red-throated Loon (Gavia stellata), Surf Scoter (Melanitta perspicillata), and Northern Gannet (Morus bassanus), in Federal waters of the mid-Atlantic U.S. during migration and winter. These species are each found in relatively large numbers and represent a cross-section of marine birds within mid-Atlantic U.S. waters during this time period. They are all considered species of conservation concern, and also exhibit traits that may make them vulnerable to the adverse effects of offshore wind development.  Additional objectives included: 1) linking areas used by each species across seasons (e.g., delineating source breeding population s); 2) designing and testing externally mounted transmitter attachment techniques, and assessing improved tracking technology on focal species, with goals of increased tag longevity, reduced bird mortality, and a more continuous record of movement pathways; and 3) developing winter capture techniques for Northern Gannets, which had not previously been targeted for at-sea capture during winter. This study also examined practices during tag attachment that could cause capture stress, and post-tagging mortality, in an effort to reduce such impacts.  In order to determine use and movement patterns of our three study species, we tagged 239 adult birds, primarily in bays and near-shore waters from New Jersey to North Carolina, between 2012 and 2015, and tracked them with Platform Terminal (satellite) Transmitters (PTTs). An additional 109 Surf Scoters, and 38 Northern Gannets tagged with PTTs as part of prior field efforts from other studies were also added to our analyses. Tracking data were analyzed using dynamic Brownian bridge movement models to develop spatial utilization distributions for each species. In winter, and in general, all three species exhibited a largely near-shore, coastal, or in-shore distribution within our study area (southern Long Island to the southern border of North Carolina). Habitat use was concentrated in or around large bays (e.g., Delaware, Chesapeake, Pamlico Sound), with the most extensive use at bay mouths. Northern Gannets ranged much farther offshore than the other two species, and covered a much larger area (including instances of individuals using both the Gulf of Mexico and the mid-Atlantic within a single season). Differences among species distributions were likely due to differences in motility and distribution of their preferred prey. For example, Surf Scoters, which left bays the least during winter, target largely sessile prey in shallower waters. Winter distributions of all three species were primarily inshore of current federal Wind Energy Areas (WEAs) and Lease Areas. However, WEAs and\/or Lease Areas overlapped with portions of Northern Gannet distributions throughout the study area, whereas the winter home range distributions of Surf Scoters and Red-throated Loons showed a much more limited overlap (primarily off of Massachusetts, New Jersey, and Delaware).  Resource selection analysis indicated that core use areas for all three species were associated with shallower, colder, and more productive waters, compared to other locations within each of their winter home ranges, further supporting the idea that distributions were linked to forage resources. There was variation, however, in the range of values associated with the habitat characteristics we measured within the winter core use and home range areas, which differed for each species.  All three study species used Federal offshore waters substantially more during migratory periods than in winter. Offshore use during migration was particularly extensive for Northern Gannets, with WEAs and Lease Areas overlapping their fall and spring distributions more than the other species. Red-throated Loons and Surf Scoters exhibited more coastal use than Northern Gannets during migration, and WEAs and Lease Areas generally overlapped with their distributions less extensively. The greatest overlap of WEAs and Lease Areas with Red-throated Loon and Surf Scoter distributions occurred during spring migration, and was concentrated in the northern half (MD \u2013NJ) of our study area, and the area immediately to the north (e.g., Cape Cod and Islands), with some additional overlap of Red-throated Loon distribution further south along the North Carolina coast. Red-throated Loons and Surf Scoters often migrated overland in fall resulting in less overlap with WEAs and Lease Areas during this period. Despite the increased use of Federal waters and consequent increased potential for exposure to future offshore wind development in WEAs and Lease Areas during migratory periods, the overall area of overlap and potential exposure generally made up a very small percentage of the overall distributions of our study species during this period (\u0026lt; 5%), and occurred during a brief portion of the annual cycle.  Fall migration was more prolonged, and less synchronized across species than spring migration. Northern Gannets were the first to arrive in the study area in fall, starting in early October, followed by Surf Scoters in mid to late October, and Red-throated Loons in mid-November. All three species began to depart the study area by mid-April and the vast majority of individuals had departed the study area by mid-May. Differences in average dates of arrival and departure in the study area between males and females were noted for Red-throated Loons and Northern Gannets, with females generally arriving earlier and departing later. No such difference was noted for Surf Scoters.  Most of our deployed satellite tags transmitted long enough to identify the wintering area and breeding area for each individual, establishing a connection between birds wintering in the mid-Atlantic, and their source populations. Locations of and distances to breeding areas varied widely among the three species. Red-throated Loons had the longest migration and most dispersed breeding distribution, with breeding birds spread across the Arctic and Subarctic from the Northwest Territories to northwest Greenland. Surf Scoters also widely dispersed to breeding grounds, primarily in middle and eastern portions of Subarctic Canada. Tagged Northern Gannets associated with five of the six North American breeding colonies, all of which occur in Atlantic Canada. Most of the tagged Northern Gannets associated with Bonaventure Island, which supports by far the largest breeding colony in North America. Major stop-over sites included the Gulf of St. Lawrence for all three species, the St. Lawrence River for Red-throated Loons and Surf Scoters, Hudson Bay and James Bay and the eastern Great Lakes for Red-throated Loons, and the Northumberland Strait for Surf Scoters. A subset of 38 juvenile Northern Gannets tagged on breeding colonies in Newfoundland, dispersed much farther offshore during their fall migration than adults.  The mortality rate of all birds tagged with PTTs during our study (2012 to 2015) was slightly under 20%, with the highest rate in Red-throated Loons, and the lowest in Northern Gannets. Several medical (e.g., surgeon experience, distance between capture and deployment sites, use of midazolam, presence of captivity-related injuries) and non-medical factors (e.g., weather during and immediately after release; bird age, sex, and mass; sea surface temperature) were examined to better understand how the surgical implant procedure may have affected their survival. Surprisingly, few of these factors were found to be correlated with survival. In Red-throated Loons, north-south wind speed and extant medical issues were significant factors affecting post release survival, while in Northern Gannets, only time under anesthesia was a significant factor. No variables examined corresponded with post-tagging survival in Surf Scoters.  In an effort to increase tag longevity, reduce bird mortality, and increase retention times over PTTs attached with existing tagging methods (surgical implants, and tail tape for some Northern Gannets), we tested novel external harness attachment methods on over 25 birds in captivity (mostly scoters) during 2013 and 2014. A newly-developed silicone harness proved the most promising and was tested on all three species in the field during 2015 and 2016 (n = 38). Tagged birds, however, experienced poor tag retention and notable impacts on behavior and mortality. While effectiveness varied among the species, these issues likely resulted from intolerance of the harnesses, buoyancy issues at dive depth, harness breakage during normal preening behavior, hydrodynamic drag while pursuing prey, or a combination of all of these factors. Therefore, although using silicone harnesses to attach external transmitters to marine birds shows some promise, their use remains inadvisable without further refinement of the harness design.  A new tracking technology (solar GPS-GSM) was tested in 2015 and 2016, in conjunction with the experimental silicone harness techniques. In addition, 10 GPS-GSM tags were attached to Northern Gannets using a tail tape attachment (limited tag retention of 2-4 months) in 2016. GPS-GSM tags provided location data at a greater precision and frequency than PTT tags. Although finding an ideal external attachment method is still an issue with these tags, we present a pilot analysis of migration data showing how GPS-GSM technology may be used in future studies to provide a more complete understanding of fine-scale movement patterns of marine birds.  Overall, this study tracked movements of over 400 individuals of three species over the course of five years; one of the most comprehensive satellite tracking studies of marine birds ever conducted in Atlantic North America. Results provide a better understanding of how diving birds use offshore areas of the mid-Atlantic U.S. and beyond, and, in combination with results from other types of research (e.g., surveys, other tracking work), can be used to inform placement and pre-and post-construction impact assessments of offshore energy infrastructure. Additional work is needed to put the extensive quantity of information collected on birds in the offshore environment into a common analytical framework for undertaking the most informed management decisions (see Chapter 7).","author":["Berlin, A.","Montevecchi, W.","Spiegel, C.","Gilbert, A.","Stenhouse, I.","Gray, C.","Ford, S.","Olsen, G.","Fiely, J.","Savory, L.","Goodale, M.","Burke, C."],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Geological Survey (USGS)","Biodiversity Research Institute","Memorial University of Newfoundland","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.677141800000","-74.471822100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Spiegel-et-al-2017-BOEM.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2118","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/harbour-seals-avoid-tidal-turbine-noise-implications-collision-risk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/1365-2664.12981\/full","title":"Harbour Seals Avoid Tidal Turbine Noise: Implications for Collision Risk","description":"Tidal stream energy converters (turbines) are currently being installed in tidally energetic coastal sites. However, there is currently a high level of uncertainty surrounding the potential environmental impacts on marine mammals. This is a key consenting risk to commercial introduction of tidal energy technology. Concerns derive primarily from the potential for injury to marine mammals through collisions with moving components of turbines. To understand the nature of this risk, information on how animals respond to tidal turbines is urgently required.  We measured the behaviour of harbour seals in response to acoustic playbacks of simulated tidal turbine sound within a narrow coastal channel subject to strong, tidally induced currents. This was carried out using data from animal-borne GPS tags and shore-based observations, which were analysed to quantify behavioural responses to the turbine sound.  Results showed that the playback state (silent control or turbine signal) was not a significant predictor of the overall number of seals sighted within the channel.  However, there was a localised impact of the turbine signal; tagged harbour seals exhibited significant spatial avoidance of the sound which resulted in a reduction in the usage by seals of between 11% and 41% at the playback location. The significant decline in usage extended to 500 m from the playback location at which usage decreased by between 1% and 9% during playback.  Synthesis and applications. This study provides important information for policy makers looking to assess the potential impacts of tidal turbines and advise on development of the tidal energy industry. Results showing that seals avoid tidal turbine sound suggest that a proportion of seals encountering tidal turbines will exhibit behavioural responses resulting in avoidance of physical injury; in practice, the empirical changes in usage can be used directly as avoidance rates when using collision risk models to predict the effects of tidal turbines on seals. There is now a clear need to measure how marine mammals behave in response to actual operating tidal turbines in the long term to learn whether marine mammals and tidal turbines can coexist safely at the scales currently envisaged for the industry.","author":["Thompson, D.","Wilson, B.","Hastie, G.","Lepper, P.","Benjamins, S.","Russell, D.","Elliot, J."],"organization":["Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","Loughborough University","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)"],"originationDate":"2018-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Pinnipeds","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hastie-et-al-2018.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2119","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/northeast-offshore-wind-regional-market-characterization-report-roadmap-project-multi","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cesa.org\/resource-library\/resource\/northeast-offshore-wind-regional-market-characterization","title":"Northeast Offshore Wind Regional Market Characterization: A Report for the Roadmap Project for Multi-State Cooperation on Offshore Wind","description":"The Atlantic coast of the northeastern United States has significant technical potential for the deployment of offshore wind power generation. The Northeast states are well positioned to benefit from the deployment of offshore wind (OSW) as a resource that can stabilize volatile energy costs, create clean energy at a scale that can contribute to replacing the region\u2019s retiring fossil-fueled and nuclear plants, diversifying the supply mix of a region heavily reliant on natural gas, meeting the region\u2019s ambitious goals for addressing climate change impacts from the energy sector, and creating significant numbers of local clean energy jobs.  The European experience with OSW has produced an industry that has over 12 gigawatts (GW) of installed capacity thus far and is expected to reach 24.6 GW by 2020 and up to 40 GW by 2024. In 2014, the European OSW industry supported 75,000 full-time equivalent (FTE) jobs. Based on the existing pipeline of projects in Europe, the industry is expected to support approximately 125,000 FTE jobs by 2019 (Ernst \u0026amp; Young, 2015; Ho, Mbistrova, Pineda, \u0026amp; Tardieu, 2017).  Although the OSW resource of the Northeast region has the potential to meet the needs of the region, successful deployment thus far has been limited. While the Cape Wind project in Massachusetts was vital in starting the conversation in the United States about the potential of offshore wind \u2014which led to the development of the Federal OSW permitting process, after 15 years navigating previously unchartered waters of permitting, long-term contracting, and public acceptance\u2014 the project has stalled due to cancelled power purchase agreements (PPA) and litigation. In Maine, two proposed 12 megawatts (MW) pilot projects were selected for long-term contracts by the Maine Public Utilities Commission (ME PUC). Statoil suspended development of its Hywind Maine project (selected in 2011) in 2013, but pre-construction research and development is underway on the University of Maine\u2019s Aqua Ventus I, an innovative floating technology demonstration project (selected in 2013). This project was selected to receive up to $40 million of DOE support. New Jersey has established an offshore wind renewable energy credit (OREC) program to drive OSW deployment. Although Fishermen\u2019s Energy\u2019s project, a fully permitted 24 MW pilot-scale Atlantic City Windfarm, received DOE support, the project stalled without New Jersey BPU approval to participate in the state\u2019s OREC program and due to failure to reach a funding milestone to receive additional DOE funding (U.S. Department of Energy, 2016; Offshore Wind Hub, 2016).  However, encouraging recent state and regional policy and project development activities suggest increasingly favorable prospects for OSW in the United States. The nation\u2019s first OSW development, Deepwater Wind\u2019s 30 MW Block Island Wind project, became operational in December 2016 in Rhode Island\u2019s state waters. In January 2017, the Long Island Power Authority (LIPA) selected Deepwater Wind\u2019s 90 MW South Fork Wind Farm for a long-term PPA. The Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) continues to oversee the auctioning of lease areas off the Atlantic coast, awarding to Statoil in December 2016 a hotly-contested lease in New York State\u2019s first Wind Energy Area that can support up to 1 GW of OSW capacity. In addition, legislation enacted in Massachusetts in 2016 requires the state\u2019s utilities to solicit 1.6 GW of OSW between 2017 and 2027. In early 2017, New York Governor Andrew M. Cuomo announced a statewide target of 2.4 GW of OSW capacity by 2030.  This report presents a Regional Market Characterization (RMC), one component of \u201cA Roadmap for Multi-State Cooperation on Offshore Wind Development,\u201d a DOE-funded effort Massachusetts, New York, and Rhode Island to evaluate the potential for mutual action that could bring OSW to scale in the region. The report describes the context for OSW deployment in the region and seeks to answer the question: What could the scale of near-term and long-term regional OSW deployment be, given the nature of regional OSW resources and supply chain, individual state policy drivers and initiatives, regional energy needs as well as the region\u2019s existing resource base?  A project team consisting of Sustainable Energy Advantage, LLC (SEA) and its subcontractors, AWS Truepower, Daymark Energy Advisors, and Meister Consultants Group, was commissioned to develop a forward-looking estimate of the potential market for OSW, expressed in installed capacity and associated energy production. In the report, they present the OSW market potential as a range of likely regional OSW deployment bounded by low- and high-deployment trajectories in Atlantic waters off the northeastern U.S. coast through the year 2030. In addition, the project team compiled and summarized data and other background information on OSW development potential, electric system and market factors, and state and regional policies, and developed plans and other initiatives that are relevant to the future potential for building out the OSW resource in the Northeast.","author":["Shoesmith, J.","Waggoner, E.","Grace, R.","Donovan, D.","Goodman, C.","Hamilton, N.","Bailey, B.","Gilbert, C.","Rickerson, W."],"organization":["Sustainable Energy Advantage","New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA)"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind","Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NYSERDA-Report-2017-Market-Characterization.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2120","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/us-job-creation-offshore-wind-report-roadmap-project-multi-state-cooperation-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.cesa.org\/resource-library\/resource\/u-s-job-creation-in-offshore-wind\/","title":"U.S. Job Creation in Offshore Wind: A Report for the Roadmap Project for Multi-State Cooperation on Offshore Wind","description":"The goal of the Roadmap Project for Multi-State Cooperation on Offshore Wind is to understand the economic benefits from the development of offshore wind farms off the U.S. Northeast coastline, from Maine to Maryland. It commissioned BVG Associates to conduct this study of job creation, drawing on its experience of offshore wind industrialization in Europe.  The analysis used two market scenarios for the Northeast: a low scenario in which 4GW is installed by 2030 and a high scenario in which 8GW is installed by 2030. The study considered 17 subelements of the offshore wind supply chain and concluded whether the jobs would be baseline, where there are no compelling reasons why the work would not be undertaken in the U.S., or additional, where the demand for jobs is less certain (high, medium, or low probability). In both scenarios, about 45% of jobs are baseline. These jobs are related to the development of wind farms, the manufacture of substations, and the delivery of operations, maintenance, and service (OMS) activities.  In the low scenario, this translates to 160,000 baseline full-time equivalent (FTE) job years over the lifetime of the wind farms, with a peak of 8,300 FTE jobs in 2028. In the high scenario, there would be a total of 320,000 baseline FTE job years, with a peak of 16,700 FTE jobs in 2028.  If additional jobs with a medium or high probability of being performed in the U.S. are performed there, a total of 195,000 FTE US job years are created in the low scenario over the lifetime of the wind farms, with a peak of 12,600 FTE jobs in 2028, including baseline jobs. For the high scenario, there would be 500,000 FTE job years, with a peak of 36,300 FTE jobs in 2028.  The reason for greater numbers in the high scenario is that the levels of deployment make it more likely that additional jobs will be created. For example, U.S. production of turbine blades and towers, foundations, and array cables becomes a high probability. The annual market of 960MW in the late 2020s provides sufficient demand for investment in new manufacturing facilities to take place. This finding suggests significant economic development benefits from the U.S. having a robust pipeline of offshore wind projects.  These findings assume that investments leading to offshore wind jobs in the U.S. are made on purely commercial grounds. States and the federal government may offer a range of incentives for local investment because the economic benefits from job creation exceed the cost of the incentives. Were that to happen, then the outlook for U.S. jobs could be more favorable than the one presented here.  The study analyzed the specific occupations created in each of the 17 supply chain subelements using the Bureau of Labor Statistics\u2019 Standard Occupational Classification (SOC) system. Excluding the jobs created in general business services and equipment showed 75% of the FTE years created are spread between three major group occupational categories:    Installation, repair, and maintenance  Management  Production   Broad group occupations were further analyzed. The main finding was a significant requirement for technician-level workers. These may be in:    Production roles, particularly high-value manufacturing positions  Installation and commissioning positions, vessel and offshore equipment operation, and commissioning and testing turbines, cables, and substations  OMS roles, particularly turbine technicians   Although these technician roles are quite diverse, many initially will follow similar training paths. This means that skills development organizations in key states can establish their workforce training initiatives now in preparation of advancing local supply chains.","author":["BVG Associates"],"organization":["BVG Associates","New York State Energy Research and Development Authority (NYSERDA)"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2025-10-25 02:47:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NYSERDA-Report-2017-OSW-Jobs.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2121","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatial-explicit-agent-based-model-approach-evaluate-performance-different-monitoring","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X16305751","title":"A Spatial Explicit Agent Based Model Approach to Evaluate the Performance of Different Monitoring Options for Mortality Estimates in the Scope of Onshore Windfarm Impact Assessments","description":"Despite the environmental benefits associated with wind energy, studies have confirmed the occurrence of significant levels of bat and bird fatalities at windfarms, which raise concerns about the long-term effects of these infra-structures on these populations. Reliable estimates of windfarm fatalities are fundamental for accurate environmental assessment studies and supporting management actions. A spatially explicit agent-based model (ABM) was developed to investigate how searcher \u201ccontrolled\u201d variables, i.e., different field monitoring protocols, monitoring periods and periodicities influence the success of carcasses detection in field trials and estimator accuracy. Different rates of bat mortality due to collision, scavenger pressures and habitat complexity were simulated in order to reproduce variable conditions that might take place at onshore wind facilities. Based on our findings we propose a reduction in the monitoring periods and a shortening in the periodicity of searches in order to reduce bias in the estimations and increase the confidence limits of impact assessments associated with mortality estimates at onshore windfarms.","author":["Santos, M.","Bastos, R.","Cabral, J.","Morinha, F.","Travassos, P.","Carvalho, D.","Ferreira, D.","Barros, P.","Hughes, S.","Santos, A.","Gomes, C.","Vale-Gon\u00e7alves, H.","Braz, L.","Paiva-Cardoso, M."],"organization":["University of Tras-os-Montes e Alto Douro"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2122","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-scale-ocean-response-large-tidal-stream-turbine-array","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096014811730678X","title":"Multi-Scale Ocean Response to a Large Tidal Stream Turbine Array","description":"The tidal stream energy sector is now at the stage of deploying the world\u0027s first pre-commercial arrays of multiple turbines. It is time to study the environmental effects of much larger full-size arrays, to scale and site them appropriately. A theoretical array of tidal stream turbines was designed for the Pentland Firth (UK), a strait between Scotland and the Orkney Islands, which has very fast tidal currents. The practical power resource of a large array spanning the Pentland Firth was estimated to be 1.64\u00a0GW on average. The ocean response to this amount of energy extraction was simulated by an unstructured grid three-dimensional FVCOM (Finite Volume Community Ocean Model) and analysed on both short-term and seasonal timescales. Tidal elevation mainly increases upstream of the tidal array, while a decrease is observed downstream, along the UK east coast. Tidal and residual flows are also affected: they can slow down due to the turbines action or speed up due to flow diversion and blockage processes, on both a local and regional scale. The strongest signal in tidal velocities is an overall reduction, which can in turn decrease the energy of tidal mixing and perturb the seasonal stratification on the NW European Shelf.","author":["Wolf, J.","Murray, R.","De Dominicis, M."],"organization":["National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/De-Dominicis-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2123","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-power-siting-regulations-wildlife-guidelines-united-states","sourceURL":"","title":"Wind Power Siting Regulations and Wildlife Guidelines in the United States","description":"The contents of this report are the results of a survey of state fish and wildlife agencies as well as independent research. The results were made available for review by the States to verify the results and contents. All efforts were made to ensure the accuracy of the information and all information contained within is believed to be accurate as of April 11, 2007.","author":["Stemler, J."],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2007-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-30 09:19:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Stemler-2007_1.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2124","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/proceedings-bats-wind-power-generation-technical-workshop","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/workshops-proceedings.html","title":"Proceedings: Bats and Wind Power Generation Technical Workshop","description":"On February 19-20 at a two-day workshop in Juno Beach, Florida was organized with over 20 participants (see Appendix B), including several of the world\u2019s leading bat scientists and experts from other relevant fields, the wind industry, and federal and state agencies to share information and discuss what is needed to understand and resolve issues involving bat mortality at wind turbines. Bat Conservation International and the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service recognized the need for this workshop, which was funded by the Department of Energy\u2019s National Renewable Energy Laboratory and the American Wind Energy Association and hosted by Florida Power and Light Energy. Participants are hopeful that collaboration will yield solutions that support the continued growth of wind power production in concert with wildlife conservation.  The purpose of the workshop was to:    To identify what participants know and do not know about the problem of bat strikes at U.S. wind energy projects  To discuss the state-of-the-art methods and technologies and understanding of bat behaviors that may better define the problem and\/or prevent future bat kills   The workshop was not intended to make decisions about specific project proposals or who implements and finances the potential solutions. The expected outcomes of the meeting were:    Proceedings about the state of knowledge and applicable tools to address the problem that the participants identified  A list of potential technical solutions best suited to address the defined problem and near term priorities for a path forward   The agenda (see Appendix A) was designed to encourage dialogue and the meeting was facilitated. This document is a summary of the workshop proceedings. It captures the comments and ideas that were exchanged, and summarizes the major themes that were expressed throughout the workshop.  The morning of the first day provided the participants and the experts with a brief over view of a wind turbine project layout, infrastructure, development process, and operation from the industry perspective. Background on relevant bat studies and surveys in the U.S was also provided. Thereafter, the ten bat and migration expert s invited provided a brief overview of their relevant knowledge. This session allowed for discussion about the current state-of-the-art tool s and techniques used to better understand bat ecology and behavior and a report on relevant European studies.  The first of five facilitated discussions began on the afternoon of the first day addressing specific questions outlined in the agenda. The facilitator posed the focus questions and led the group in a discussion to explore and organize responses to the focus questions. All participants, including industry and agency observers, provided ideas and they were posted on storyboards. The ten invited bats experts then independently evaluated these ideas and expressed their individual views and preferences regarding which of these should be priorities. The experts made their thoughts known by placing a dot ( \u2666 ) next to those ideas on the storyboard that were a priority to them. They acted individually, not in consensus, in placing the limited number of dots each was provided. These preferences, and all of the ideas, are reflected in the tables that follow in this report. The participants addressed the following questions:    What are the problems associated with bats and wind turbines?     What are the underlying and most critical causes of the problems with bats and wind turbines?      What are the most significant knowledge gaps with understanding and addressing the underlying causes of the problems with bats and wind turbines?     What is preventing an understanding of the problem?   What does the group need to know to address the problem?      What tools, technologies, and information gathering techniques (e.g., radar, thermal imaging, acoustic tracking) would be most helpful in developing a better understanding of bat-turbine interactions and quantifying the magnitude of the problem?     What can be done to address the knowledge gaps and\/or the problem?      What actions do we need to take now to address the problems and near term priorities?     What is the path forward?       At the end of the second day, the participants were divided into smaller groups of 3 or 4 and discussed the details of the priority actions. At this time, some of the priority suggestions were combined, if they were related. The experts led ten breakout groups and presented their findings to all the participants. This break out session focusing on near-term solutions addressed the following questions:    What are the immediate next steps associated with implementing the top priority actions\/solutions?  What are the defined tasks, schedules and involved parties?   The summary session at the end of the work shop allowed the entire group to hear the results of each of the ten priority actions, engage in a discussion of the findings of the breakout groups, and provide concluding remarks. For a detailed list of the ten priority actions selected and discussed, see Table six.","author":["Energetics Incorporated"],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2004-04-16","spatial":{"coordinates":["26.875057000000","-80.075182500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BWEC-2004-Proceedings.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2125","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-wind-energy-cooperative-2008-workshop-proceedings","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/workshops-proceedings.html","title":"Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative: 2008 Workshop Proceedings","description":"The Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC) is an initiative sponsored by Bat Conservation International (BCI), the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA), and the Department of Energy\u2019s National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL).The objectives of BWEC are to build a scientific understanding about why bats collide with wind turbines and to develop mitigation strategies that reduce potential risks to bat populations. Following the first scientific workshop in February 2004, BWEC shaped a research agenda and conducted field research on pre-construction studies, post-construction fatality monitoring, and deterrent technologies. The management structure of BWEC consists of a Program Director, an Oversight Committee (the founders mentioned above), a five-member Scientific Advisory Committee and a Technical Committee that includes state and federal agencies, private industry, academic institutions, and non-governmental organizations. BWEC meetings and workshop are facilitated by Energetics Incorporated (A full list of individuals is provided in Appendix A).  On January 8th, 9th, and 10th, some of the world\u2019s leading bat scientists from the U.S. and Europe, wind industry and federal and state resource agency representatives came together in Austin, Texas, for a workshop to share information about what we know today and what we need to know in the future about bat mortality at wind turbines. The workshop, sponsored by the four founders of the Cooperative, had almost 50 participants in attendance (see Appendix A). Participants are hopeful that this collaboration will yield solutions that support the continued growth of wind energy production in concert with bats \u0026amp; their habitats.  The purpose of the workshop was to:    Determine the current state of knowledge by identifying potential risks, gaps in knowledge and future directions for bat and wind energy research conducted by BWEC and other research groups in North America and Europe.  Maximize dialogue between subject matter experts.  Develop preliminary research plans focusing on knowledge gaps that are essential to solving the greatest risks.   The workshop was not intended to make decisions about specific project proposals or who implements and finances the potential solutions. The expected outcomes of the meeting were:    A brief report about the state of knowledge and relevant technology based on research by BWEC and others to address the problems identified at the 2004 Workshop.  An action plan and a list of potential technical solutions best suited to address the defined problem and near term priorities for a BWEC research agenda.   This document is a summary of the workshop proceedings, including the comments and ideas captured during the facilitated sessions and a list of next steps, grouped by priority research tasks.  The workshop began with a participant from the wind energy industry providing a brief overview of wind energy project development and how research results may be incorporated into operational requirements. The rest of the workshop relied on panel presentations on technical topics followed by facilitated discussions on potential significant risks, knowledge gaps, and the near-term action items needed to address these gaps. Facilitation questions, outlined in the agenda (see Appendix B), were used to encourage dialogue on the four topics discussed:    Post-Construction Monitoring and Risk Assessment  Pre-Construction Risk Assessment Methods  Operational Mitigation Studies and Deterrent Research  Evaluation of Population Parameters and Modeling   For each topic, a panel of experts gave presentations on their research methods and results to date. Following each set of presentations on a topic area, the facilitator posed focus questions and led the group in a discussion to explore the most up-to-date information available. All participants, including industry and agency observers, provided ideas and responses which were collected in real-time on an electronic storyboard. A summary of these discussions are summarized as \u201cResults of the Facilitated Discussion\u201d with a list of issues raised. These lists are provided for background in formation only and are not intended as a comprehensive list of priority actions for each research topic. The lists are intended to give an overview of a number of the major risks and challenges facing BWEC and their research partners. The questions used to facilitate discussions on the four topics listed above were as follows:    What are the most significant risks and knowledge gaps?  What can be done to address the most significant risks and knowledge gaps? What tools, technologies, and protocols are needed to address the solution?   On the morning of the third day, the participants were divided into four breakout groups, one for each topic area, based on their relevant expertise. Each breakout group was tasked with prioritizing next steps for their appropriate topic area using a research plan template. After the groups finished developing their research priortties, one representative from each topic area breakout group presented the group\u2019s findings to all attendees. The research plan templates focused on the following questions:    What are the immediate next steps associated with implementing the top priority actions\/solutions?  What are the defined tasks, schedules, and involved parties?   The priority research tasks developed at the concluding breakout session as well as the list of risks and knowledge gaps developed at the plenary sessions were submitted for critical review and revised by the BWEC Science Advisory Committee following the workshop. The \u201cpriority research tasks\u201d for the four topics are prioritized within each topic area, and offer specific recommendations for BWEC\u2019s consideration in their research planning and management activities. The tentative BWEC Work Plan can be found in Appendix C. The Over sight Committee and the Project Coordinator will consider these recommendations for the 2008-2009 research seasons and continue to collaborate with other partners.","author":["Energetics Incorporated"],"organization":["Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"originationDate":"2008-01-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.263546600000","-97.739795400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BWEC-2008-Proceedings.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2126","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-wind-energy-cooperative-synthesis-activities-2004-2011-key-findings-next-steps","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/workshops-proceedings.html","title":"The Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative: Synthesis of Activities (2004-2011), Key Findings and Next Steps","description":"This report summarizes the activities of the Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC: www.batsandwind.org) from inception (January 2004) to present (July 2011). Here, we synthesize the history, key findings, future deliverables, next steps and financials of the BWEC. Our goal is to provide insight into previous efforts of the BWEC and to set the stage for the upcoming Science Meeting scheduled for January 2012.","author":["Arnett, E.","Hein, C.","Patterson, R."],"organization":["Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"originationDate":"2011-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 03:16:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BWEC-2011-Synthesis.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2127","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-wind-energy-cooperative-3rd-science-all-committees-meeting-2012-workshop","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/workshops-proceedings.html","title":"Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative 3rd Science and All Committees Meeting: 2012 Workshop Proceedings","description":"The Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC \u2013 www.batsandwind.org) is an alliance of state and federal agencies, private industry, academic institutions, and non-governmental organizations that cooperates to develop solutions to minimize or, where possible, prevent mortality of bats at wind power turbines. It is an initiative founded by Bat Conservation International (BCI), the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (US FWS), the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA), and the Department of Energy\u2019s National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL). New members include the Department of Energy (DOE) and the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). BWEC\u2019s Oversight, Science Advisory, and Technical Advisory Committees met in Austin, Texas from January 10-13, 2012 to review BWEC\u2019s progress, discuss emerging issues, determine approaches and feasibility for modeling bat populations and mortality factors, and revise priorities for the Cooperative.\n\nResearch Priorities and Emerging Issues\n\nOver the course of the 3.5-day meeting, BWEC committees discussed potential research priorities, tasks, and roles in the categories noted below. The discussion was informed by BWEC progress to date, existing research commitments, and high priority research needs. The priorities and tasks discussed were designed to inform Oversight Committee decision-making, and did not represent final decisions on specific activities, priorities, or roles.\n\nSynthesis and Meta-Analysis \u2013 Given the information collected over the last several years, it was agreed that existing data and information should be coalesced and synthesized in order to answer key research questions. Specific, high priority questions articulated included: factors influencing nightly variability in species presence and fatality; correlation between pre-construction acoustic activity and post-construction fatality; correlation between post-construction acoustic activity and post-construction fatality on a nightly basis; and species-specific fatality rates.\n\nOperational Mitigation \u2013 It was agreed that optimizing operational mitigation for minimizing bat fatalities and minimizing turbine downtime remained a high priority research area. The highest priority tasks identified were: drawing lessons from a synthesis analysis of data from existing sites; working to delineate preliminary operational mitigation considerations for regions not yet studied; conducting additional site-based studies; informing study design for other sites, as appropriate; disseminating information to stakeholders through webinars and other means; and incorporating a synthesis of weather factors and bat presence into operational mitigation synthesis reports.\n\nPopulation Estimation, Modeling and Data Collection \u2013 It was agreed that BWEC should continue to support efforts to estimate, model, and collect data on bat populations. The highest priority tasks identified were: provide additional population data for those species most affected by wind power; and validate parameters for population models to maximize efficacy and refine models. BWEC\u2019s primary roles in these and other population research priorities identified were to fundraise, identify partners, engage researchers with appropriate expertise, and collect data.\n\nDeterrents \u2013 It was agreed that BWEC should continue working to identify how to deter bats from wind turbines, but that the high costs associated with developing and field-testing deterrent devices raised questions about whether BWEC should continue leading this work. Accordingly, the highest priority deterrent activities identified were: 1) advancing the video monitoring approach to turbine-bat surveillance being led by USGS; 2) understanding deterrent effects on bat behavior to determine what frequencies and periodicity deter which bat species; and 3) working with turbine manufacturers and engineers on further research and development.\n\nPost-Construction Protocols \u2013 It was agreed that BWEC and its partners could make important contributions to developing and disseminating protocols for post-construction monitoring. The highest priority tasks identified were: review existing protocols and guidance information, and then develop protocols and methods agreed to by BWEC committees for the Cooperative\u0027s post-construction studies; disseminate these BWEC protocols; and support USGS efforts to refine, publish and disseminate information on the low frequency monitoring and density estimator approaches being developed.\n\nEmerging Issues \u2013 BWEC committee members identified the below emerging issues associated with bats and wind energy. While these issues are not necessarily BWEC research priorities, BWEC should stay apprised of developments in these areas, and engage in them as cost opportunities arise:\n\n\n International Work \u2013 It was agreed that BWEC should expand its network of international partners, with the main objectives of providing capacity building and transferring knowledge (both to and from others).\n Offshore Wind \u2013 It was agreed that BWEC should inform and engage on offshore wind-related bat issues as appropriate, particularly in light of BWEC\u2019s knowledge and experience regarding impacts of land-based wind development on bats.\n Endangered Species \u2013 It was agreed that BWEC should work to provide additional science and consultation for key issues related to bat species that are currently or expected to become listed as threatened or endangered.\n Regional Expansion of Wind \u2013 Wind development continues to expand to regions for which little or no data are available. BWEC could help fill data gaps, which might be identified more clearly through BWEC\u2019s synthesis and meta-analysis work.\n Small-Scale Wind \u2013 Little research has been done on issues associated with small-scale wind, for example with regard to impacts of lower turbine height and more scattered turbines across landscapes. It was agreed that BWEC should be prepared to engage on this issue as deployment grows and opportunities arise.","author":["Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"organization":["Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"originationDate":"2012-01-13","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.263546600000","-97.739795400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 03:16:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BWEC-2012-Proceedings.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2128","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-wind-energy-cooperative-4th-science-all-committees-meeting-final-2015-workshop","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/workshops-proceedings.html","title":"Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative 4th Science and All Committees Meeting: Final 2015 Workshop Proceedings","description":"The Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC or Cooperative) is an alliance of experts from government agencies, private industry, academic institutions, and non-government al organizations that cooperate to develop and disseminate solutions to reduce to the greatest extent practicable or, where possible, prevent mortality of bats at wind energy facilities. The BWEC is overseen by Bat Conservation International (BCI), the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (US FWS), the American Wind Energy Association (AWEA), the U.S. Department of Energy (US DOE), the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), and the U.S. Geological Survey (USGS). BWEC\u2019s Oversight, Science Advisory, and Technical Advisory Committees met in Louisville, Colorado at the National Wind Technology Center from January 6 \u2013 8, 2015 for the 4th Science and All Committees Meeting to examine progress of the BWEC, review existing monitoring and minimization strategies, discuss emerging issues, assess the effectiveness of BWEC, and establish priorities for the Cooperative for the years 2015 to 2018  Research Priorities and Emerging Issues  The BWEC committee members discussed and identified potential priorities for 2015 \u2013 2018 in the following categories. Further detail on a wider range of possible activities is included later in this report. Discussions were informed by BWEC progress to date, BWEC participant research initiatives, and guest presentations. The priorities the BWEC developed during the meeting were designed to inform Oversight Committee decision-making and did not represent final decisions on specific activities.  Operational strategies to reduce impact \u2013 The BWEC should prepare a summary report on impact reduction strategies to describe the current state of the science, the challenges and opportunities of existing impact reduction strategies, and areas of future research. The BWEC also agreed to advance understanding in two high priority areas: 1) options to refine operational minimization such as feathering bel ow manufacturer\u2019s cut-in speed or considering start\/stop times when implementing operational minimization, impacts of changing wind technologies (turbines with lower cut-in speeds) and the effect of ramp-up speeds on fatality, and 2) the costs of implementing impact reduction strategies i n wind energy projects.  Ultrasonic acoustic deterrents \u2013 Given the advancement of deterrent technology and the promising findings of acoustic deterrents to date, the BWEC should advance the development of deterrents and research their effectiveness. In particular, the BWEC should design and implement a study to compare the effectiveness and costs of acoustic deterrents and operational reduction strategies, using a 2-factorial randomized block design.  Pre- and post-construction monitoring and data collection \u2013 The BWEC should support the compilation of site and project level data into a large database that is considered a trusted and credible data source for research purposes by industry, government agencies, academic institutions, and conservation organizations. It was also agreed the BWEC should examine landscape patterns of activity and fatality and site covariates to identify potential predictors of risk.  Fatality estimation and modeling \u2013 A general fatality estimator should be developed to help standardize fatality estimation and mode ling. The BWEC recommended that weather patterns and peak fatality events should be analyzed to determine whether or not a relationship exists that could help predict when peak fatality events might occur and thus enable turbine operators to implement and refine impact reduction strategies to minimize fatalities.  Bat behavior at various scales \u2013 Thermal video technology and analysis tools should continue to be used and advanced to study bat behavior and draw conclusions about when and how bats interact with turbines and how deterrent devices could be positioned to reduce impacts. The BWEC should monitor advances in strike-detection technology that may help pinpoint the times of impact and the environmental and operational conditions under which strikes occur.  Population estimation, modeling, and data collection \u2013 Population estimation, modeling, and data collection is a high priority. This work is mostly being undertaken by scientists in academic institutions with the support of state and federal resource management agencies. BWEC should continue to support these efforts through the provision of tissue and hair samples as needed and through help coordinating research efforts conducted by population geneticists.  International network and emerging issues \u2013 The BWEC should expand its network of international partners and seek opportunities to exchange knowledge in order to better understand bat and wind turbine interactions, and re duce fatality in North America and throughout the world.","author":["Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"organization":["Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"originationDate":"2015-01-08","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.913991300000","-105.217640200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BWEC-2015-Proceedings.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2129","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/responses-big-brown-bat-eptesicus-fuscus-acoustic-deterrent-device-lab-setting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/curtailment-deterrence.html","title":"Responses of the Big Brown Bat, Eptesicus fuscus, to an Acoustic Deterrent Device in a Lab Setting","description":"Documented bat fatalities from collisions with wind turbines have prompted the search for a means to discourage bats from approaching them. Because echolocating bats depend upon sensitive ultrasonic hearing for orientation and prey capture, broadcasting ultrasound from turbines may disrupt or \u201cjam\u201d their perception of echoes and serve as a deterrent. I tested the response of bats to a prototype eight speaker deterrent emitting broadband white noise at frequencies from 12.5 to 112.5 kHz at about 100 dB SPL per speaker at 1 m. I tested the effect of broadcasting ultrasound on bats flying in feeding or non-feeding trials with the acoustic deterrent device placed among four quadrants in a flight chamber. In half the trials, the acoustic deterrent broadcast broadband noise, and in half the trials, the device remained silent. Bats in feeding trials were presented with a tethered meal worm in the same quadrant as the device.  In non-feeding trials, bats landed in the quadrant containing the device significantly less when it was broadcasting broadband noise (1.7% vs. 22.4%, p = 0.00375). In feeding trials, bats never successfully took a tethered mealworm when the device broad cast sound but captured mealworms near the device in about 1\/3 of trials when it was silent. Bats in both feeding and non-feeding trials flew through the quadrant containing the device significantly less when it broadcast noise than when it remained silent (non-feeding trials: n =136, p = 0.0035, one-sided test; feeding trails: n = 132, p = 0.0103, one-sided test). While bats\u2019 avoidance of the active device was not absolute, these results indicate that broadcasting broadband noise shows promise as a means to deter bats from approaching wind turbines.","author":["Spanjer, G."],"organization":["Bat Conservation International","Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)","Maryland Department of Natural Resources"],"originationDate":"2006-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.986918300000","-76.944748300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Spanjer-2006.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2130","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/patterns-pre-construction-bat-activity-proposed-hoosac-wind-energy-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.batsandwind.org\/preconstruction-acoustic-monitoring.html","title":"Patterns of Pre-Construction Bat Activity at the Proposed Hoosac Wind Energy Project, Massachusetts, 2006-2007","description":"We initiated a multi-year, pre-construction study in summer 2006 to investigate patterns of bat activity at the proposed Hoosac Wind Energy Project (HWEP) in northwestern Massachusetts. The primary objectives of this study were to: 1) determine levels and patterns of activity of different phonic groups of bats using the proposed HWEP prior to construction; 2) correlate bat activity with weather and other environmental variables; and, 3) combine results from this study with those from similar efforts to determine if indices of pre-construction bat activity can be used to predict post-construction bat fatalities at proposed wind facilities. We report results from two years of pre-construction data collection.  We recorded echolocation calls of bats with Anabat II zero-crossing ultrasonic detectors, programmed to record calls beginning \u00bd-hour prior to sunset and ending \u00bd-hour after sunrise each day of the study from 27 July \u2013 11 November 2006, and 1 June \u2013 31 October 2007. We used 5 meteorological towers to position acoustic microphones at 10, 31.5, and 39.2 m above ground level (agl). We identified 2 broad phonic groups, high frequency bats frequency (\u2265 33 kHz, mostly Myotis spp., red bats [Lasiurus borealis] and tri-colored bats [Perimyotis subflavus]), low frequency bats (\u0026lt;33 kHz, hoary bats [Lasiurus cinereus], big brown bats [Eptesicus fuscus], and silver-haired bats [Lasionycteris noctivagans]). We also identified a third phonic group, hoary bats, because this species is vulnerable to wind development and because their echolocation sequences are relatively easy to distinguish among other low frequency bats. In 2006, we recorded a total of 2,424 and 1,364 high frequency and low frequency bat passes, respectively. Hoary bats comprised 30 % (n = 410) of low frequency passes. In 2007, we recorded a total of 7,739 and 2,063 high frequency and low frequency passes, respectively. Hoary bats comprised 13 % (n = 267) of low frequency passes.  Seasonally, bat activity was highest between mid-July and mid-August for all phonic groups. However, timing and intensity of peak activity differed between years. Flight altitude was consistent between years, but differed among phonic groups. We detected high frequency bats more frequently at 10 m. Although activity by low frequency bats was more evenly distributed among the three heights, the majority of passes were recorded from higher altitudes (i.e., 31 m and 39 m agl). We also detected hoary bat passes more frequently at higher altitudes.  Our models incorporated location, temperature and several win d speed measurements. Temperature and location were consistently the most important factors in our models. We found a positive relationship with bat activity and temperature, particularly at temperatures \u0026gt;12\u00b0 C. In general, both the probability of activity and estimated number of calls from each phonic group increased as much as 39% for every 1\u00b0 C increase in temperature. Bat activity was highest at Bakke 2 followed by Crum 1, Crum 2 and Bakke 1. However, location alone explained only 2 \u2013 8% of the variation in activity. While some measure of wind speed often was important, it never explained more than an additional 3.6% of the variation in activity. The HWEP has higher mean nightly wind speeds than other sites where comparable data have been gathered, which may explain why the relationship between activity and wind was not as strong as previously documented.  As this study was conducted at a single proposed wind energy facility located on forested ridges in northwestern Massachusetts the statistical inferences are limited to this site. To improve statistical power and determine whether our findings reflect patterns of bat activity on similar forested ridges with comparable vegetation composition and topography, additional studies are required at sites with similar characteristics in the region. Despite acoustic and meteorological equipment malfunctions, we were able to quantify the spatial (vertical and horizontal) and temporal (seasonal and yearly) activity patterns of bats. These data may provide useful information for predicting when, where, and which bats may be most at risk of interacting with wind turbines at the HWEP. Moreover, specific timings and locations of peak activity may further refine the use of curtailment as a mitigation option.","author":["Arnett, E.","Hein, C.","Schirmacher, M.","Huso, M.","Reynolds, D."],"organization":["Bat Conservation International","Northeast Ecological Services","Bats and Wind Energy Cooperative (BWEC)"],"originationDate":"2011-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.729722000000","-73.023611000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hein-et-al-2011_Hoosac.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2131","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/observing-cable-laying-particle-settlement-during-construction-block-island-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/espis.boem.gov\/final%20reports\/5596.pdf","title":"Observing Cable Laying and Particle Settlement During the Construction of the Block Island Wind Farm","description":"Key observations, data, findings, and results from two different types of environmental monitoring surveys conducted in and around the Block Island Wind Farm (BIWF) Project Area during its second construction phase are presented in this report. The monitoring was conducted to gather real-time data during the installation of a submarine cable from the mainland at Scarborough State Beach to Block Island\u2019s Fred Benson Town Beach. The cable was installed using a customized jet plowing mechanism. Real-time monitoring included recording visual observations of the installation process and measuring suspended sediment concentrations in the water column.  The data collected during this monitoring will provide additional information necessary for the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management\u2019s (BOEM) evaluation of environmental effects of future facilities and generate data to improve the accuracy of models and analysis criteria employed to establish monitoring controls and mitigations.  Visual monitoring included recording visibility of construction activities from both offshore and shoreline, types of lighting used at the construction site, information on what aspects of the construction activity can be seen from the shoreline, and meteorological conditions. Real-time observations were recorded by dedicated observers from the shoreline and from a vessel adjacent to the cable lay operations. Both still photography and video footage were employed to document the process from Block Island to the mainland at Scarborough State Beach.  The monitoring team was onsite for a period of 27 days. The team arrived on 31 May 2016 and departed 26 June 2016. The initial cable pull on mainland at Scarborough Beach State Park was originally scheduled for 3 June but was delayed until 9 June due to weather and delays in placing the cable mats at crossings. Approximately 105,232 feet (19.93 miles) of the Block Island Transmission System (BITS) cable was successfully laid from Scarborough Beach to Block Island over a period of 16 days. The construction time frame appeared optimal since it appeared to minimize impacts on recreational beach visitors and avoided operational delays due to adverse weather. Scarborough Beach access was not limited as conduit was in place upon team arrival. Access to Town Beach on Block Island was restricted for only two days during winch pull of BITS to cofferdam. The jet plowing operation did not hinder recreational craft traffic. No sediment plume was observed offshore from the observation vessel.  Sediment monitoring included two days of background sampling and one full day of sampling during the cable laying operations. Suspended sediment monitoring was undertaken using two complimentary techniques; acoustic backscatter and optical backscatter. These two techniques respond differently to different sediment grain characteristics such as size, shape, and angularity. Therefore, using both techniques allows for the suspended sediment load to be characterized as robustly as possible. Data were collected at various points around the cable trench footprint from Block Island Town Beach to Scarborough State Beach in Narragansett. A vessel-mounted 600-kilohertz (kHz) Teledyne RDI Sentinel Workhorse ADCP was used to take current and acoustic backscatter (ABS) measurement transects around the cable route and the cable-laying vessel Big Max.  An Idronaut EA89 multiparameter probe was used to collect profiles of turbidity through the water column at 23 locations around the BITS cable route. Eight of these profiles were conducted along the cable route to provide background information while the jet plow was not operational. The remaining 15 profiles were conducted in the vicinity of Big Max and the jet plow during cable laying operations. In addition to turbidity, the Idronaut also recorded conductivity, temperature and depth (CTD) data through the water column. Water samples were collected using Niskin bottles and analyzed for total suspended solids and particle size distribution for calibrating the Idronaut data.  No sediment plume was observed as a result of the jet plow operations. Data obtained during the background and jet plow monitoring remained comparable across all datasets. Sediment concentration estimates derived from high frequency acoustic backscatter measurements were \u0026lt; 1 mg\/l at the surface and \u0026lt; 6 mg\/l at the seabed. This is supported by the low frequency Multibeam Echosounder (MBES) data that found no significant levels of sediment in the water column. Estimated concentrations from optical backscatter measurements were \u0026lt; 2 mg\/l at the surface and \u0026lt; 9 mg\/l at the seabed.  Efforts to \u201ccalibrate\u201d the backscatter measurements (convert to concentration values) using the on-site water samples were unsuccessful. Therefore, Fugro provided indicative values based on significant previous experience in backscatter calibrations. The estimated maximum concentration derived from the Idronaut data (9 mg\/l) can be considered a \u201cworst case.\u201d Suspended sediment levels on site during jet plow activity were found to be up to 100 times lower than those predicted by the modeling work (RPS ASA 2012).  Trench morphology was evaluated at 11 cross section locations to estimate the amount and extent of material deposited outside the trench as an overspill levee. Analyses were performed at locations along the cable route from the mainland to near the mid-point of Rhode Island Sound where the plume monitoring was conducted. Pre- and post-lay MBES data were used in this evaluation. Overspill levees were interpreted to extend 1.5 to 7 meters beyond the trench and were up to 25 centimeters thick. The average distance from the trench and thickness were 3.8 m and 7 cm, respectively. It was noted that overspill sediments may have deposited beyond the interpreted extent of the overspill levee, but likely were too thin to resolve with the MBES data. RPS ASA (2012) estimated that sediments up to 1 cm thick would be deposited within 10 to 30 meters from the trench. This analysis of overspill levee extent suggests that the modeled predictions did not underestimate the distance that overspill sediments deposited from the trench.  The estimated volume of the overspill levees was similar to the volume of the trench scar. This suggests that most of the overspill sediments deposited within the overspill levee. The volume of the overspill levee material was estimated to be 0.1 to 0.6 m3 per meter travelled by the jet plow. The mean value of the overspill levee volumes in the cross sections analyzed is 0.24 m3. For comparison, the modeling report prepared by RPS ASA (2012) estimated that approximately 25 percent of sediment release volume would occur for a 2.28 m3 trench volume. This corresponds to a sediment release volume of 0.57 m3 per meter travelled.  It should be noted that the mean value of our overspill levee volumes is approximately half of what was predicted but the upper limit of the range is very similar to what the modeling predicted. This could be attributed to conservatism in the modeling or more sediment was deposited outside of our interpreted overspill levee body.  The interpretations presented in this report are limited to seafloor elevation differences that could be discerned with MBES data. Near the trench, the levee was more pronounced and exhibited a larger elevation difference from the pre-lay survey. The toe of the levee was interpreted where the two surveyed seafloor elevations converged. A thin drape of overspill sediments may have extended beyond the interpreted levee toe and could not be confidently discerned using the MBES data. However, the OBS and acoustic analysis of the MBES did not reveal a sediment plume that extended upward into the water column and beyond the immediate vicinity of the trencher which supports that most of the overspill sediments deposited within the overspill levee.  The visual and sediment monitoring was conducted for BOEM by the HDR RODEO Team under Contract M15PC00002, Task Order M16PD00011.","author":["Smith, K.","James, E.","Gallien, D.","Khan, A."],"organization":["HDR Engineering Inc","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.114711000000","-71.521161000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Elliot-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2132","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-sensitivity-suspended-sediment-profiles-tidal-current-wave-conditions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569116302587","title":"Modelling the Sensitivity of Suspended Sediment Profiles to Tidal Current and Wave Conditions","description":"Seawater turbidity due to suspended particulate material (SPM) is an important property of a marine ecosystem, determining the underwater light environment and many aspects of biological production and ecology. SPM concentrations are largely determined by patterns of sediment resuspension from the seabed due to shear stress caused by waves and currents. Hence planning for the construction of large scale offshore structures which will alter regional hydrodynamics needs to consider the consequences for SPM concentrations. Here we develop a one-dimensional (vertical) model of SPM dynamics which can be used to scope the effects of changes in wave and tidal current properties at a site. We implement the model for a number of sites off the east coast of Scotland where we have extensive data sets to enable numerical parameter optimisation. The model performs well at simulating fluctuations in turbidity varying from flood-ebb tidal cycles, spring-neap cycles, storm wave events, and an annual cycle of SPM concentration which is attributed to seasonal consolidation of seabed sediments. Sensitivity analysis shows that, for the range of seabed sediment types in the study (water depth 16\u201350\u00a0m; mud content 0.006\u20130.380 proportion by weight), relatively large (50%) attenuations of tidal current speed are required to produce changes in water column turbidity which would be detectable by observations given the variability in measurements. The model has potential for application to map the large scale sensitivity of turbidity distributions to the installation of wave and tidal energy extraction arrays.","author":["Murray, R.","Sabatino, A.","Heath, M.","Serpetti, N.","McCaig, C."],"organization":["University of Strathclyde","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.481283900000","-1.062339800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Heath-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2133","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/differential-recovery-habitat-use-birds-after-wind-farm-installation-multi-year","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0195925516301780","title":"Differential Recovery of Habitat Use by Birds after Wind Farm Installation: A Multi-Year Comparison","description":"Onshore wind farms remain one of the most widely used technologies for the production of renewable energy. These are known to affect birds through disturbance or collision. Most research focus on the impact of wind farms on raptors or other large bird species, especially those of conservation concern. However, limited information exists on the effect of wind farms on small birds. Recovery of large versus small bird populations impacted by wind farms is also largely unstudied. A reason for this is the lack of long-term datasets based on standardized, systematic assessments. We monitored birds in the vicinity of a wind farm in an upland habitat in southern Spain (Malaga province), immediately after installation and 6.5\u00a0years post-construction. During both study periods, we observed 11 raptor and 38 non-raptor species (including 30 passerines). We found differences in recovery rates between raptors and non-raptors. Raptors showed an upturn in numbers but non-raptor abundance fell significantly.\n\nGreater attention should be paid to the recovery of wildlife after initial impact assessments than at present. This study confirms that regulatory authorities and developers should consider the likely impacts of wind farms on small bird populations. Mitigation measures focused particularly on non-raptor species should be considered and implemented as a means to reduce these negative effects.","author":["Mu\u00f1oz, A.","Real, R.","Farfan, M.","Vargas, J.","Duarte, J.","Fa, J."],"organization":["Biogea Consultores","University of M\u00e1laga","University of Valencia","Manchester Metropolitan University"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.855000000000","-4.778611000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2134","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-scale-interactions-between-offshore-wind-turbine-wake-ocean-sediment-dynamics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096014811730839X","title":"On the Multi-Scale Interactions Between an Offshore-Wind-Turbine Wake and the Ocean-Sediment Dynamics in an Idealized Framework - A Numerical Investigation","description":"We investigate the turbulent dynamics of the coupled atmosphere-ocean-sediment system around a wind turbine. To this end, a coupled two-dimensional idealized numerical model of the ocean and sediment layers, forced by an idealized offshore wind turbine wake is used. The turbine wake impacts the ocean surface and for strong wind and water layer thickness higher than 20 m, large scale eddies of the size comparable to the wake thickness are generated, leading to a turbulent dynamics in the ocean. The turbulence in the ocean is controlled by the shallow wake parameter S.  The turbulent ocean dynamics is numerically integrated using time dependent simulations at fine horizontal resolution (1 m). From these simulations, eddy coefficients parametrizating the turbulent fluxes are proposed to be used in larger-scale (RANS) models. The ocean dynamics and the parameter values depend mainly on S. The ocean dynamics is laminar (S \u0026gt; 7.10\u22122), has a localized (7.10\u22122 \u22122) or domain wide turbulent (S \u0026lt; 3.10\u22122) behavior. In the first two cases, changes in seabed elevation are around a few millimeters per month. For the third case, averaged over several days, changes decreases to a few tenths of millimeters per month. This is due to the alternating local velocity which transports sediments back and forth.","author":["Wirth, A.","Nagel, T.","Chauchat, J.","Bonamy, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2135","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/large-scale-three-dimensional-modelling-wave-tidal-energy-resource-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096456911630360X","title":"Large Scale Three-Dimensional Modelling for Wave and Tidal Energy Resource and Environmental Impact: Methodologies for Quantifying Acceptable Thresholds for Sustainable Exploitation","description":"We describe a modelling project to estimate the potential effects of wave \u0026 tidal stream renewables on the marine environment.\nRealistic generic devices to be used by those without access to the technical details available to developers are described.\nResults show largely local sea bed effects at the level of the currently proposed renewables developments in our study area.\nLarge scale 3D modelling is critical to quantify the direct, indirect and cumulative effects of renewable energy extraction.\nThis is critical to comply with planning \u0026 environmental impact assessment regulations and achieve Good Environmental Status.","author":["Side, J.","Davies, I.","Venugopal, V.","Bell, M.","Fairley, I.","Burrows, M.","Baston, S.","Karunarathna, H.","Murray, R.","Waldman, S.","Sabatino, A.","Heath, M.","McKee, D.","Chatzirodou, A.","Gallego, A.","McCraig, C.","Nemalidinne, R.","Yung, T."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science","Heriot-Watt University","Marine Alliance for Science and Technology Scotland (MASTS)","University of Strathclyde","Swansea University","University of Edinburgh","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2136","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-statistical-models-measure-environmental-change-tidal-turbine-case-study","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X1730609X","title":"Evaluating Statistical Models to Measure Environmental Change: A Tidal Turbine Case Study","description":"Statistical models are routinely used in Before-After monitoring studies to detect, quantify, and forecast environmental change caused by natural or anthropogenic disturbances. For monitoring programs that have not established standard statistical procedures, an evaluation of models\u2019 abilities to measure change over a range of scenarios is vital to develop best practices for analyzing monitoring data. A comprehensive evaluation was developed and applied using Marine Renewable Energy (MRE) tidal turbine site as a case study of a developing industry with no standard monitoring methods. Before-After monitoring datasets that contained change were simulated using normal and non-normal empirical baseline data collected at a MRE site. Thirteen regression models from three classes were evaluated: 6 generalized regression models, 4 time series models, and 3 nonparametric models. Intervention Analysis was used to fit models to five change scenarios that included three amplitudes of change and a lag in the onset of change. A power analysis was used to evaluate model ability to detect change. Residual error diagnostics were used to quantify model fit and forecast accuracy. Parametric models that did not include lagged dependent variables were the most capable at detecting change. A comparison of the fit and forecast metric results indicated that deterministic time series models in conjunction with semi-parametric generalized regression models provided a robust and informative quantification of change. Nonparametric models most accurately forecasted change. The results provide insight on model behavior, which is used to recommend specific models to measure change in the case study data. These recommendations form best practices for analyzing monitoring data, which enables comparisons among monitoring sites and reduces uncertainty when quantifying environmental effects.","author":["Horne, J.","Linder, H."],"organization":["Oceana","University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2137","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dictionary-ocean-energy-chinese","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.amazon.com\/energy-development-utilization-Dictionary-Chinese\/dp\/750278893X","title":"Dictionary of Ocean Energy (Chinese)","description":"As ocean energy develops, theres is a need to develop standardized terminology around the offshore renewable energy industry. The Chinese language Dictionary of Ocean Energy Development has thousands of entries, using a framework that follows 10 branches of marine renewable energy: Integration, The Development of Tidal Energy, The Development of Wave Energy, The Development of Tidal\/Sea Current Energy, The Development of Thermal and Salinity Gradient Energy, The Development of Offshore Wind Energy, Standards and Measurement of Ocean Energy, Marine Energy Programs and Conferences, Marine Energy and Economy, and Marine Energy Agencies. The dictionary includes many concisely defined words such as terminologies, concepts, and many technical terms. It also provides substantial information on the latest events, facts, photographs, and data.","author":["Zhu, K.","Wen, X."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2014-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["29.575733000000","123.336508000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2138","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mobile-demersal-megafauna-common-offshore-wind-turbine-foundations-german-bight-north","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113616303014","title":"Mobile Demersal Megafauna at Common Offshore Wind Turbine Foundations in the German Bight (North Sea) Two Years after Deployment - Increased Production Rate of Cancer pagurus","description":"Within the next decades the construction of thousands of different types of large wind turbine foundations in the North Sea will substantially increase the amount of habitat available to reef fauna. To gain first insights which effect these substantial changes in habitat structure and diversity might have on faunal stocks settling on hard substrata, we compared the mobile demersal megafauna associated with the common types of wind turbine foundations (\u0027jacket\u0027, \u0027tripod\u0027 and \u0027monopile with scour protections of natural rock\u0027) in the southern German Bight, North Sea. Monopiles with scour protection were mostly colonized by typical reef fauna. They were inhabited by an average of about 5000 edible crabs Cancer pagurus (per foundation), which is more than twice as much as found at the foundation types without scour protection. Strong evidence was found that all three foundation types not only function as aggregation sites, but also as nursery grounds for C. pagurus. Assuming equal shares of the three foundation types in future wind farms, we project that about 27% of the local stock of C. pagurus might be produced on site. When, for example, comparing the existing fauna at 1000 ship wrecks and on the autochthonous soft substrate with those which probably will establish at the foundations of 5000 hypothetically realized wind turbines, it becomes clear that the German Bight in the future will provide new artificial reef habitats for another 320% crabs (C. pagurus) and 50% wrasse (Ctenolabrus rupestris) representing substrata-limited mobile demersal hard bottom species. Further research is urgently required in order to evaluate this overspill as it would be an important ecological effect of the recent offshore wind power development.","author":["Krone, R.","Schneider, C.","Schmalenbach, I.","Dederer, G.","Kanstinger, P.","Kr\u00e4mer, P."],"organization":["Alfred Wegener Institute (AWI)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.388884000000","7.205134000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Demersal Fish","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2139","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tidal-energy-benthic-effects-operational-tidal-stream-turbine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113616302860","title":"Tidal Energy: The Benthic Effects of an Operational Tidal Stream Turbine","description":"The effect of modified flow on epifaunal boulder reef communities adjacent to the SeaGen, the world\u0027s first grid-compliant tidal stream turbine, were assessed. The wake of the SeaGen was modelled and the outputs were used in conjunction with positional and substrate descriptor variables, to relate variation in epifaunal community structure to the modified physical environment. An Artificial Neural Network (ANN) and Generalised Linear Model (GLM) were used to make predictions on the distribution of Ecological Status (ES) of epifaunal communities in relation to the turbulent wake of the SeaGen. ES was assigned using the High Energy Hard Substrate (HEHS) index. ES was largely High throughout the survey area and it was not possible to make predictions on the spatial distribution of ES using an ANN or GLM. Spatial pattern in epifaunal community structure was detected when the study area was partitioned into three treatment areas: area D1; within one rotor diameter (16 m) of the centre of SeaGen, area D2; between one and three rotor diameters, and area D3; outside of three rotor diameters. Area D1 was found to be significantly more variable than D2 and D3 in terms of epifaunal community structure, bare rock distributions and ES.","author":["Savidge, G.","Kennedy, R.","Creech, A.","O\u0027Carroll, J."],"organization":["National University of Ireland","University of Edinburgh","Queen\u0027s University Belfast"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.480202000000","-5.580769000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2140","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/how-green-green-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0169534717302380","title":"How Green is \u0027Green\u0027 Energy?","description":"Renewable energy is an important piece of the puzzle in meeting growing energy demands and mitigating climate change, but the potentially adverse effects of such technologies are often overlooked. Given that climate and ecology are inextricably linked, assessing the effects of energy technologies requires one to consider their full suite of global environmental concerns. We review here the ecological impacts of three major types of renewable energy \u2013 hydro, solar, and wind energy \u2013 and highlight some strategies for mitigating their negative effects. All three types can have significant environmental consequences in certain contexts. Wind power has the fewest and most easily mitigated impacts; solar energy is comparably benign if designed and managed carefully. Hydropower clearly has the greatest risks, particularly in certain ecological and geographical settings. More research is needed to assess the environmental impacts of these \u2018green\u2019 energy technologies, given that all are rapidly expanding globally.","author":["Gibson, L.","Wilman, E.","Laurance, W."],"organization":["Southern University of Science and Technology (SUSTech)","University of Hong Kong","James Cook University"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2141","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biodiversity-wind-farms-portugal-current-knowledge-insights-integrated-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-319-60351-3","title":"Biodiversity and Wind Farms in Portugal: Current Knowledge and Insights for an Integrated Impact Assessment Process","description":"This book presents a review of the state-of-the-art knowledge on the interactions between biodiversity and wind energy development, focused on the Portuguese reality. The volume addresses the particularities of the impact assessment procedures in Portugal, contrasting it with the international practices and presenting its main findings by covering the following broader themes: i) evaluation of spatial and temporal dynamics of wildlife affected by wind farms, including birds, bats and terrestrial mammals (in particularly Portuguese wolf population); ii) the methodologies used to assess impacts caused by this type of developments in biodiversity; iii) the best practice methodologies to implement an adaptive management approach to reconcile biodiversity and wind farms.  The knowledge presented in this book was gathered through the research and development activities developed by Bioinsight company (former Bio3 company) during the last 13 years and partially funded by a R\u0026amp;D project designated as \u201cIntegrated solutions for biodiversity management at wind farms: reduce and compensate bird and bat mortality\u201d (acronym: Wind \u0026amp; Biodiversity), co-funded by the European Regional Development Fund (FEDER), under the Regional Operational Programme of Centre (Mais Centro).  This volume fills a void in the literature as a book giving insights on the best practices to install and manage a wind farm from a biodiversity management point of view, while establishing a commitment between economic sustainability and biodiversity conservation.  Table of Contents:  Wind Industry in Portugal and Its Impacts on Wildlife: Special Focus on Spatial and Temporal Distribution on Bird and Bat Fatalities  Joana Marques, Sandra Rodrigues, Rita Ferreira, Miguel Mascarenhas  Pages 1-22  Impacts of On-shore Wind Farms in Wildlife Communities: Direct Fatalities and Indirect Impacts (Behavioural and Habitat Effects)  Pedro Pereira, Nuno Salgueiro, S\u00edlvia Mesquita  Pages 23-33  Environmental Impact Assessment Methods: An Overview of the Process for Wind Farms\u2019 Different Phases\u2014From Pre-construction to Operation  Joana Santos, Joana Marques, Tiago Neves, Ana Teresa Marques, Ricardo Ramalho, Miguel Mascarenhas  Pages 35-86  An Overview on Methods to Assess Bird and Bat Collision Risk in Wind Farms  Sandra Rodrigues, Lu\u00eds Rosa, Miguel Mascarenhas  Pages 87-110  The Indirect Impacts of Wind Farms on Terrestrial Mammals: Insights from the Disturbance and Exclusion Effects on Wolves (Canis lupus)  Gon\u00e7alo Ferr\u00e3o da Costa, Jo\u00e3o Paula, Francisco Petrucci-Fonseca, Francisco \u00c1lvares  Pages 111-134  Comparing Field Methods Used to Determine Bird and Bat Fatalities  Jo\u00e3o Paula, Margarida Augusto, Tiago Neves, Regina Bispo, Paulo Cardoso, Miguel Mascarenhas  Pages 135-149  Estimating Bird and Bat Fatality at Wind Farms: From Formula-Based Methods to Models to Assess Impact Significance  Joana Marques, Lu\u00edsa Rodrigues, Maria Jo\u00e3o Silva, Joana Santos, Regina Bispo, Joana Bernardino  Pages 151-204  How to Design an Adaptive Management Approach?  Helena Coelho, Silvia Mesquita, Miguel Mascarenhas  Pages 205-224","author":["Bernardino, J.","Mascarenhas, M.","Fonseca, C.","Marques, A.","Ramalho, R.","Santos, D."],"organization":["University of Lisbon","University of Porto","Bioinsight","University of Evora","University of Aveiro"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.399867000000","-8.224454000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Terrestrial Mammals","Collision","Habitat Change","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2142","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-life-cycle-assessment-offshore-renewables-implications-wave-energy-converter","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.4988867","title":"Acoustic Life Cycle Assessment of Offshore Renewables - Implications from a Wave-Energy Converter Deployment in Falmouth Bay, UK","description":"Marine Renewable Energy is developing fast, with hundreds of prototypes and operational devices worldwide. Two main challenges are assessing their environmental impacts (especially in near-shore, shallow environments) and ensuring efficient and effective maintenance (requiring specialised ships and fair weather windows), compounded by the lack of long-term measurements of full-scale devices. We present here broadband measurements (10 Hz to 32\/48 kHz) acquired at the Falmouth Bay Test site (FaBTest, UK) from 2010 onwards, for a 16-m ring-shaped Wave Energy Converter, in waters up to 45 m deep. This period covers baseline measurements, including shipping from the neighbouring English Channel, one of the busiest shipping lanes in the world (ca. 45,000 ship transits annually) and the full period of installation and energy production, including maintenance episodes. Acoustic signatures are measured as Sound Pressure Levels (e.g. for impacts) and time\/frequency variations (for condition-based monitoring via Acoustic Emissions). They change through time, depending on weather and modes of operation. Long-term measurements are compared with modelling of potential variations in this complex environment and with laboratory experiments. These are used to outline the varying acoustic contributions through the life cycle of a typical wave energy converter, yielding insights for other wave devices in other environments.","author":["Blondel, P.","Walsh, J."],"organization":["University of Bath","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.124230400000","-5.031881700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-06 09:45:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2143","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-methodologies-large-scale-wave-tidal-stream-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569116303106","title":"Developing Methodologies for Large Scale Wave and Tidal Stream Marine Renewable Energy Extraction and its Environmental Impact: An Overview of the TeraWatt Project","description":"This article presents an introduction and overview of a modelling project \u0022TeraWatt: Large scale interactive coupled 3D modelling for wave and tidal energy resource and environmental impact\u0022.\n\nThe project was funded by the SUstainable PowER GENeration (SUPERGEN) \u0022Marine Hub\u0022. SUPERGEN is an initiative of the Research Councils UK (RCUK) Energy Programme, led by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC). It is focused on supporting resilient and sustainable generation, supply, transmission and storage of the UK\u0027s energy. The Marine Challenge addresses the UK Centre for Marine Energy Research\u0027s (UKCMER) mission to support the wave and tidal energy sector beyond their current state of development.","author":["Side, J.","Davies, I.","Venugopal, V.","Burrows, M.","Karunarathna, H.","Heath, M.","V\u00f6gler, A.","Gallego, A.","James, M."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University","Marine Scotland Science","Marine Alliance for Science and Technology Scotland (MASTS)","University of Strathclyde","Swansea University","University of Edinburgh","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2144","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/possible-impacts-offshore-wind-farms-seabirds-pilot-study-northern-gannets-southern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10336-016-1402-y","title":"Possible Impacts of Offshore Wind Farms on Seabirds: A Pilot Study in Northern Gannets in the Southern North Sea","description":"We studied the impact of offshore wind farms on the distribution of Northern Gannets in the southern North Sea. Distributions were derived from ship-based and aerial-transect counts, and from global positioning system (GPS) tracking of chick-rearing adults from the colony on Helgoland. Foraging trips of tagged Gannets lasted from 0.4 to 53.5\u00a0h, with a total distance flown per trip of 4.7\u2013937.9\u00a0km, and range of 2.0\u2013320.8\u00a0km. Gannets largely avoided the wind farm area north of Helgoland. This avoidance behaviour implies that, although Northern Gannets may not be killed by rotor blades, they may experience substantial habitat loss. GPS tracking is well suited to the study of wind farm effects on birds and possible habituation processes at the individual level.","author":["Garthe, S.","Markones, N.","Corman, A."],"organization":["Kiel University"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.183330000000","7.916670000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2145","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/application-reanalysis-data-estimate-offshore-wind-potential-eez-india-based-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544216315420","title":"Application of Reanalysis Data to Estimate Offshore Wind Potential in EEZ of India Based on Marine Ecosystem Considerations","description":"India is striving hard to develop new and renewable energy resources on a vast scale, to meet its future energy demands. To fulfill the need of renewable energy resources, utilization of wind energy is a good option to avoid several issues of pollution and climate change caused by the consumption of fossil fuels. The present study aims to provide a summary of offshore wind energy potential available in the exclusive economic zone (EEZ) of India, by utilizing reanalysis wind dataset (ERA-Interim) for 14 years (2001\u20132014) along with corresponding data of bathymetry and cumulative human impact on marine ecosystem. Geographic Information System (GIS) environment is used to develop maps of wind speed and power density at a hub height of 80\u00a0m. Annual energy production (AEP) capacity in Indian EEZ was observed to be about ten and six times of the present (Financial year 2015\u201316) and anticipated future (Financial year 2021\u201322) energy demand while considering 5\u00a0MW turbine. Outcomes of the present study seem to be useful for developers, planners and decision makers in realizing about available offshore wind power potential at the coasts of India.","author":["Nagababu, G.","Kachhwaha, S.","Naidu, N.","Savsani, V."],"organization":["Pandit Deendayal Petroleum University"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["16.748257500000","82.867169700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2146","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/method-estimate-visual-impact-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261917305184","title":"Method to Estimate the Visual Impact of an Offshore Wind Farm","description":"The objective of this paper is to introduce a method that quantifies the degree of visibility of an offshore wind farm from an observer located along the coast. Due to the relative vicinity with living areas, the installation of an offshore wind farm leads in many cases to public opposition. Therefore, there is still a need to provide planners and decision makers appropriate methods and objective criteria to actually evaluate the visual impact of offshore wind farms. The aim is to provide an intelligible method for visual assessment that can be applied and used within a full decision-aid system oriented towards offshore wind turbines. A visual operator that takes into account the visual distance of an observer located on the ground to the farms layout is introduced. Such operator is based on the aggregation of three different indexes. The horizon occupation is the main index, it evaluates the horizon surface impact. This parameter is modulated by a second index that computes the number of distinguishable turbines and a third index considered as an aesthetic one based on turbine alignments. The whole method is implemented on top of a Geographical Information System (GIS). Overall, the approach provides an estimation of the visual impact without further need for local surveys, it is conceived as a decision-aided mechanism oriented to decision-makers and that can be used at the preliminary steps of the study of an offshore wind farm. The whole approach is experimented in the context of a wind farm in North West France.","author":["Wang, T.","Maslov, N.","Claramunt, C.","Tang, T."],"organization":["Shanghai Maritime University","French Naval Academy Research Institute"],"originationDate":"2017-10-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2148","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-d52-reports-interactive-meetings-policy-makers","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/8\/8942\/WP5_-_Report_on_interactive_meetings_with_policy_makers.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable D5.2: Reports of Interactive Meetings with Policy Makers","description":"In October 2010, the SOWFIA project (Streamlining of Ocean Wave Farms Impact Assessment) was launched. The SOWFIA project draws together partners from across Europe with the aim to streamlining impact assessment for wave farm developments.\n\nThe streamlining process is carried out at local, national and European level though a gathering of the experiences of the key actors in the wave energy sector and dissemination of the finding to Policy makers at European and National level, by means of interactive meetings and presentations.\n\nIt is therefore intended to hold a series of meetings with at least 5 EC directorates, namely DG Mare, DG Environment, DG Climate change, DG Energy, DG RTD and with EACI to present the main outcomes of the project and measure of how European authorities will use the project findings.\n\nIn occasion of the EU-OEA Ocean Energy 2012 a nd a short notice a n informal meeting was held with representat ive of the EU - DG Mare, Dr. Brian Toll and EU \u2013 DG RTD, Dr Ir. Matthijs Soede in Brussels on Monday the 25 th of June 2012. The meeting represented the first possibility to raise awareness about the aims and objective of the SOWFIA process.\n\nThe meeting was aimed at presenting the up-to-date findings of the SOWFIA project, outlining the proposed outcome and paving the way for the integration of the SOWFIA outcome within the agendas of the different DGs in the form of recommendation and guidelines.","author":["Magagna, D.","Rousseau, N."],"organization":["Plymouth University","European Ocean Energy Association (EU-OEA)"],"originationDate":"2012-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SOWFIA-WP5-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2149","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-d46-final-work-package-report-consenting-procedures-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/8\/8939\/WP4_-_Final_Report.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable D.4.6 - Final Work Package Report: Consenting Procedures Review with Guidelines for Expansion to Larger Projects and Approval Process Streamlining, Incorporating the Findings of Interim Report and Feedback from Workshop D","description":"This report summarises the findings from SOWFIA project WP4 examining wave energy consenting processes and stakeholder opinions (other marine users and regulators) on wave energy approval processes in six European countries where wave energy test centres have been established. The barriers and accelerators to wave energy consenting identified in SOWFIA WP2 were also considered and general and country-specific recommendations were developed under four main themes which were identified as critical to the expansion of wave energy across Europe: (i) integrated planning; (ii) administrative procedures; (iii) environmental impact assessment (EIA); and (iv) consultation. For each theme, strategic and operational recommendations were assigned.\n\nBefore presenting country-specific recommendations, and to support them, a summary of the context for each theme is presented covering: the implementation of strategic plans; wave energy consenting systems; experiences derived from EIA for wave energy developments in various countries; and developers and stakeholders\u2019 opinions on consultation activities for wave energy developments. In general, strategic plans like Maritime Spatial Planning (MSP) and Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) aimed at maximising and managing the sustainable use of maritime areas are not yet fully implemented. Suitably tailored licensing processes do not exist in most of the countries analysed, although some countries have taken steps recently to adapt existing legislation to accommodate wave energy licensing. Some experience exists on wave energy EIA but reliable baseline and long-term impact data are not yet available, partly because the industry is still relatively new. Such knowledge gaps hinder the transfer of knowledge and the improvement of the environmental assessment for projects. Consultation is sometimes perceived by stakeholders as mainly a \u201ctick-box\u201d exercise and there is a widespread perception that developers do not really take stakeholders\u2019 concerns and opinion into account. This may explain a common lack of interest in such events among many stakeholders. Furthermore, in some cases the time periods for consultation are too short to review technical and lengthy documentation. Nevertheless, most stakeholders are generally supportive of marine renewables, particularly wave energy, which is viewed as having lower visual and other impacts than some other marine renewable technologies, particularly offshore wind.\n\nThe following general recommendations to improve wave energy consenting processes in Europe are suggested:\nFurther efforts to promote the development and implementation of MSP;\nIncreased application of the SEA process to wave energy planning and future development;\nWhere possible, the introduction of \u2018one-stop-shop\u2019 consenting approaches (or the definition of a coordinating body) for wave energy project or at least better collaboration between authorities in a parallel processing approach;\nThe amendment of current consenting processes towards tailored and fit-for-purpose licensing and the availability of clear guidance documents on licensing procedures in each country;\nThe establishment of more common and consistent timeframes for licensing developments;\nGreater availability of EIA results, particularly impact evaluations and monitoring results to increase the knowledge base for prediction and evaluation of impacts;\nThe need for early engagement and consultation with stakeholders and the creation of a mechanism for considering and dealing with any concerns raised;\nThe importance of giving more time to stakeholders to analyse project documentation; The need to carefully plan (time and venue) consultation events according to the stakeholder group being targeted (e.g. evenings for fishermen).\nA number of country-specific recommendations are also identified and presented for each critical theme. These are based on the SOWFIA project team\u2019s expertise of their national context and feedback from stakeholders interviewed during the project.","author":["Simas, T.","Sundberg, J.","Greaves, D.","Bailey, I.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","Marina, D.","Le Crom, I."],"organization":["WavEC Offshore Renewables","University College Cork","Plymouth University","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)","Uppsala University","Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)"],"originationDate":"2013-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SOWFIA-WP4-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2150","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-35-work-package-3-final-report-report-analysis-environmental-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/8\/8937\/WP3_-_Final_Report.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable 3.5 - Work Package 3 Final Report: Report on the Analysis of the Environmental Impact Assessment Experience for Wave Energy","description":"The wave energy industry is an emerging sector and, in comparison to more established industries, is a new user of maritime space. In order to realise the potential for wave energy to contribute towards EU renewable energy goals several technological and non-technological barriers need to be overcome. Many of the non-technological barriers are due to wave energy being at a relatively early stage in its development. Much attention has focused on the potential environmental impacts of wave energy and the burden of responding to this attention represents a significant barrier to the wave energy industry. As part of the SOWFIA project, an evaluation of experience related to the detection of environmental impacts at EU wave energy test centres along with information gained from environmental impact assessments produced for other similar renewable energy developments has been undertaken. This experience has been examined to understand key receptors of concern and methods used for detecting impacts, to produce effective methods for communicating the information gathered and to identify where possible, the type and magnitude of impacts which may be expected.\n\nThe key environmental receptors of concern for wave energy EIA include the physical environment (morphology, waves and current etc.) and flora and fauna as represented by marine mammals, seabirds, benthos and fish and shellfish.\n\nThere is a concern that removal of energy from waves and currents in the marine environment may result in significant environmental impact, whether to the marine ecosystem or to users of the marine space. Standard measurements such as wave buoys and ADCPs along with numerical simulations and more innovative measurement techniques can be used to study this issue Preliminary studies suggest that the magnitude of the non-local effects on the amplitude of waves or currents from projects studied so far are of order 10% reduction or less.\n\nThe introduction of additional anthropogenic sound into the marine environment is of concern for its potential to impact marine species which use sound for communication, navigation, finding prey and evading predators. Key aspects of assessing the impacts from introduced noise include identifying the baseline noise signal at the site of interest, the noise signature of the planned devices and the auditory sensitivity of species present. There is very limited experience in measuring noise emissions from wave devices with results which varied from being unable to distinguish the device noise from the ambient anthropogenic signal to having to limit measurements to very low sea states in order to avoid sensor saturation. Limited measurements from a deployed Pelamis device confirm that the signal varies with sea state and that the noise emitted would be detectable by marine species.\n\nThat all marine mammals are protected by national, European and\/or international legislation is reflected in the fact that the impacts of wave energy on marine mammals was of significant concern at all the test centres in the SOWFIA project. There are a wide range of methods for monitoring marine mammals and the methods utilised will be determined by the questions to be assessed. Whatever methods are employed, it is critical to determine whether the survey design method will be able to detect an impact at an early stage. Limited existing experience within marine renewable energy developments suggests that marine mammals may avoid devices but further studies are needed. Experience with nets and static (but slack) fishing gear indicate that entanglement is a potential issue although the risk associated with wave energy devices is likely to be much lower than other ocean energy technology. This risk is potentially aggravated by the increased food arising from the FAD potential of WECs. Because of the highly mobile nature of marine mammals, cumulative effects from increasing MREI deployments are of a special concern which must be carefully considered primarily during SEA and secondarily in planning.\n\nSeabird species are subject to various levels of regulatory protection and monitoring of seabird distribution and behaviour is a universal component of wave energy EIA. A special and key feature of this work is understanding the connectivity of development sites with SPAs which can be achieved only through tagging studies. The potential effects of marine renewable energy developments on birds can be summarised in three main categories: direct (collision, entrapment, displacement), indirect (noise, habitat enhancement, de facto MPAs), and cumulative. WECs have a much smaller above-water profile than wind turbines, and so are likely to have much lower risk of collision but the considerable underwater structure of some devices may provide an enhanced collision or entrapment risk. Entrapment of birds can be mitigated by covering openings, where possible, with a protective mesh. Migratory species and species that are restricted to foraging in specific habitats may be particularly vulnerable but sensible development planning to avoid sensitive foraging areas will help mitigate possible population impacts.\n\nExpected impacts from wave energy developments on benthos are largely limited to the construction phase of development and relate to habitat disturbance, increased suspended sediment, sediment deposition, scour and abrasion and release of contaminants from dredged sediments. Potential operational impacts include changes in hydrodynamics and the introduction of new habitat types from foundation structures and\/or other submerged equipment. The experience provided from test centres EIA suggests that the effects of the deployment of wave energy converters on coastal processes and geology would be insignificant in comparison to the natural processes occurring at the sites. Similarly, seabed disturbance from construction are generally considered to be local, temporary and similar in magnitude to common natural occurrences in the marine environment. Similarly, the evidence to date is that the potential impacts to fish and shellfish from wave energy developments are limited and of a short duration. The greatest potential for displacement effects is limited to construction phase and can be mitigated by keeping this phase as brief as possible. Entrapment and, to a lesser extent, collision remain as viable threats during the operation phase but can be mitigated by appropriate protective measures. Wave energy developments have credible potential to exhibit positive impacts, for example, by behaving similarly to fish attraction devices, artificial reefs and no take zones. At the Swedish Lysekil test centre, WECs were judged to exhibit clear features of artificial reefs (ARs), with expected positive effects.\n\nA review of the EIAs performed at all of the test centres associated with SOWFIA confirms several lessons regarding the wave energy EIA process which were developed during SOWFIA. While the selection of receptors discussed in this report is confirmed by this experience, there is clear evidence that the receptors of primary interest are dependent on factors such as the local environmental characteristics, the presence\/absence of protected species and the regulatory authority under which the EIA is performed. Across all test centres, the impacts which were perceived as lowest significance were air quality and climate and water quality and ground water with physical processes as the next least significant.\n\nSome common themes appear in the study of EIA for wave energy projects. These include: the necessity of two years of monitoring to provide a baseline sufficient to detect changes attributable to the presence of WECs; the lack of any documented evidence of significant behavioural effect on a species level from EMF emissions by any existing undersea power cables; the logistical preference for BAG design on impact studies due to the BACI requirement for an appropriate independent control site and the high number of replicates required to achieve the desired level of impact detection sensitivity.\n\nFinally, concern related to cumulative impacts from an expanding level of wave energy development taking place in a background of growing utilisation of the marine environment which is difficult for individual developers to address adequately suggest that this issue be comprehensively addressed at the national level as part of SEA.","author":["Conley, D.","Simas, T.","Sundberg, J.","Greaves, D.","Torre-Enciso, Y.","Godley, B.","Witt, M.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","Magagna, D.","Holmes, B.","O\u0027Callaghan, J.","Saulnier, J.","Embling, C.","Leit\u00e3o, J.","Marina, D.","Aires, E.","Bicknell, A."],"organization":["Plymouth University","Hidromod","University of Exeter","Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)","WavEC Offshore Renewables","University College Cork","Uppsala University","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)"],"originationDate":"2013-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SOWFIA-WP3-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2151","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sowfia-deliverable-26-work-package-2-final-report-report-analysis-work-package-2","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.plymouth.ac.uk\/uploads\/production\/document\/path\/8\/8935\/WP2_-_Final_Report.pdf","title":"SOWFIA Deliverable 2.6 - Work Package 2 Final Report: Report on the Analysis of the Work Package 2 Findings Regarding Barriers and Accelerators of Wave Energy","description":"The wave energy industry is an innovative and developing industry which aims to contribute to meeting EU renewable energy targets. Consenting processes across the EU and Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) legislation were not designed with the wave energy industry in mind. During SOWFIA Work Package 2 wave energy developers (wave energy test centre developers, device and project developers) and regulators with experience of the wave energy consenting process have identified barriers and accelerators (things which are working well), based on their experiences to date. These barriers and accelerators have been compiled and analysed in this document along with suggestions provided by these key actors for improving the situation.\n\nIt is important to note that only a relatively small amount of wave energy capacity, in comparison to 2020 ocean energy targets for Member States, has been installed to date. This implies that the consenting process for wave energy developments in Member States has not yet been seriously tested. Wave energy capacity that has been installed has largely been single devices deployed at specially built wave energy test centres in different Member States. As such, any accelerators identified cannot yet be judged to be robust and although there is a possibility that some of the barriers identified will diminish as the sector expands, it is more judicious to assume that some, if not most, of the barriers discussed will become more serious as the size of proposed developments increases and their environmental impacts and effects on other users of marine areas also increase. With this in mind, recommendations are presented for ameliorating barriers in the consenting process in Europe. The barriers, accelerators and recommendations are presented within three thematic areas:\nAdministrative Procedures\nEnvironmental Impacts (EIA Process and Environmental Monitoring)\nHuman Dimensions","author":["Simas, T.","Greaves, D.","Bailey, I.","Godley, B.","Witt, M.","O\u0027Hagan, A.","Magagna, D.","Holmes, B.","O\u0027Callaghan, J.","Olivares, C.","Embling, C.","Marina, D.","Enciso, Y.","Arjona, E."],"organization":["University College Cork","Inabensa","Plymouth University","University of Exeter","WavEC Offshore Renewables","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)"],"originationDate":"2013-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SOWFIA-WP2-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2152","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/whales-entangled-deep-sea-cables","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/0146631356900405","title":"Whales entangled in deep sea cables","description":"Fourteen instances of whales entangled in submarine cables are reported. Ten entanglements occured off the Pacific coast of Central and South America. Six cases occurred in about 500 fathoms, with 620 fathoms the maximum depth reported. Five entanglements occured in the period, February\u2013March\u2013April. All whales positively identified were sperm whales. The submarine cable was generally wrapped around the jaw and often around the flukes and fins. The cable was rarely broken but always badly mauled. The entanglements often occurred near former repairs where there is a chance for extra slack cable on the bottom. Two pothographs of a sperm whale entangled in a cable and one photograph of a whale-jaw entangled in a cable are presented.\n\nIt is concluded that sperm whales often swim along the sea floor in depths as great as 620 fathoms. It is suggested that the whales become entangled while swimming along with their jaw plowing through the sediment in search of food. It is possible that the whales attacked tangled masses of slack cable mistaking them for items of food.","author":["Heezen, B."],"organization":["Columbia University"],"originationDate":"1957-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Entanglement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2153","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impact-assessment-guide-procedures","sourceURL":"https:\/\/webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk\/20120920030709\/https:\/\/www.communities.gov.uk\/documents\/planningandbuilding\/pdf\/157989.pdf","title":"Environmental impact assessment: guide to procedures","description":"Environmental impact assessment (EIA) is an important procedure for ensuring that the likely effects of new development on the environment are fully understood and taken into account before the development is allowed to go ahead. This booklet, which is intended primarily for developers and their advisers, explains how European Community (EC) requirements for the environmental impact assessment of major projects have been incorporated into consent procedures in the UK. It revises the booklet \u0027Environmental Assessment: A Guide to the Procedures\u0027, first published in 1989, to take account of the requirements of Directive 97\/11\/EC, which was adopted on 3 March 1997 and came into effect on 14 March 1999.  Directive 97\/11\/EC amends the original Directive 85\/337\/EEC on \u0027The assessment of the effects of certain public and private projects on the environment\u0027, which came into effect in July 1988. The text of the Directive as amended (with amendments shown in italics) is reproduced in Appendix 1 to this booklet. Throughout this booklet, references to `the Directive\u0027 mean Directive 85\/337\/ EEC as amended by Directive 97\/11\/EC. The effect of the Directive is to require environmental impact assessment to be carried out, before development consent is granted, for certain types of major project which are judged likely to have significant environmental effects.  Parts 1 and 2 of this booklet explain the procedures which apply to projects falling within the scope of the Directive and requiring planning permission in England and Wales. For such projects the Directive was given legal effect through the Town and Country Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) (England and Wales) Regulations 1999 (SI No 293 https:\/\/www.legislation.hmso.gov.uk:443\/si \/si1995\/uksi_19950418_en_1.htm) (\u0027the EIA Regulations\u0027) which came into force on 14 March 1999 and apply to relevant planning applications lodged on or after that date. The full text of the Regulations is published separately by The Stationery Office. For ease of reference, those parts of the Regulations which list the types of project to which they apply, and specify what information an environmental statement must contain, are reproduced in Appendices 2 to 4 to this booklet. The booklet is not intended to be an authoritative interpretation of the law and does not remove the need to refer to the Regulations.  Formal guidance on procedures under the Regulations, directed principally at local planning authorities, was issued in DETR Circular 2\/99 (Welsh Office Circular 11\/99). Although the present booklet, like its predecessor, is meant to be reasonably self-contained, developers may need to refer to that Circular, particularly for fuller information on how planning authorities are expected to judge the significance of a project\u0027s likely effects for the purpose of deciding whether environmental impact assessment is required. Parts 1 and 2 also give some general guidance, applicable to all types of project, on the nature of environmental impact assessment and on the practical aspects of preparing an environmental statement.  Part 3 gives a brief account of the procedures which apply to other projects within the scope of the Directive but which are not approved under planning procedures, for example, motorways, harbour works and long distance pipe-lines. It also deals very briefly with environmental impact assessment procedures in Scotland and Northern Ireland. For the detailed requirements, reference will need to be made to the relevant statutory instruments and associated guidance (see Appendix 8 to this booklet). Throughout this booklet, the term \u0027environmental impact assessment\u0027 (EIA) is used to describe the whole process whereby information about the environmental effects of a project is collected, assessed and taken into account in reaching a decision on whether the project should go ahead or not. The process was formerly referred to in the UK as `environmental assessment\u0027 (EA). An \u0027environmental statement\u0027 is a document setting out the developer\u0027s own assessment of a project\u0027s likely environmental effects, which is prepared and submitted by the developer in conjunction with the application for consent.","author":["UK Communities and Local Government"],"organization":["Government of the United Kingdom"],"originationDate":"2000-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-26 10:21:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Environmental_impact_assessment-guide_to_procedures_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2154","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-power-devices-artificial-reefs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/241604133_Wave_Power_Devices_as_artificial_Reefs","title":"Wave power devices as artificial reefs","description":"Offshore energy installations, such as wave power parks have large area demands. Little is known about their effects on the marine environment, and early studies may minimize environmental risks and enhance potential positive effects on the marine environment. The Islandsberg project is a wave power park located on the Swedish west coast under construction since 2005. Here, buoys acting as point absorbers are connected to generators anchored on concrete foundations on the seabed. Most likely, biofouling has the potential to be an engineering concern but at the same time, these structures can be considered as artificial reefs. In the present study the colonisation of foundations by invertebrates and fish was investigated. The influences of holes in and on the surface of the foundations on colonisation and species composition were examined and a succession in colonisation over time is shown. Structural heterogeneity may enhance the colonisation of macrobenthic organisms. This pilot study is the first contribution to what constitutes an important research topic based on different ideas of an effective and purposeful reef design integrating wave power devices and their development.","author":["Langhamer, O.","Wilhelmsson, D."],"organization":["Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2007-09-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.203686000000","11.401747000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-11 12:04:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2155","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-invertebrate-assemblages-fish-offshore-wave-power","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleID=1624516","title":"Development of Invertebrate Assemblages and Fish on Offshore Wave Power","description":"A significant development of offshore wave power is planned in the future, and its impact on the marine environment is unclear. Solid structures placed on the seabed create new habitats and function as artificial reefs for marine organisms. In this study we investigated the artificial reef effect and fouling impacts on offshore wave power devices deployed at the Swedish west coast. Here, buoys acting as point absorbers on the surface are connected to generators anchored on concrete foundations on the seabed. We studied the influence of surface orientation of the wave power foundations on epibiotic colonisation, and made in situ observations of micro-habitat use by fish and crustaceans over four years of submergence. We also examined fouling assemblages on buoys and calculated the effects of biofouling on the energy absorption of the wave power buoys.","author":["Langhamer, O.","Wilhelmsson, D.","Engstro\u0308m, J."],"organization":["Stockholm University","Uppsala University"],"originationDate":"2009-05-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.987988000000","11.210620000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-10 11:58:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2156","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/d417-report-environmental-monitoring-protocols","sourceURL":"","title":"D4.17 Report on environmental monitoring protocols","description":"This document presents a short review and overview of monitoring protocols developed and employed for surveying species and habitats in relation to offshore renewable energy developments. The document summarises the design phase of the monitoring process as well as providing a quick overview for key environmental descriptors (mammals, seabirds and benthic communities) which are protected under EU and national regulation. The main outcomes of this will be taken forward into D4.7 (Best practice report on environmental monitoring and new study techniques).  The core of this document is based on the \u0022Guidance on survey and monitoring in relation to marine renewables deployment in Scotland1\u0022 developed by Scottish Natural Heritage and on \u0022Guidelines for data acquisition to support marine environmental assessment of offshore renewable energy projects\u0022 developed by CEFAS in 2012 which have provided in depth reviews and analysis of protocols for environmental monitoring. This document highlights the key points of environmental protocols which are under development for monitoring the impact of marine and offshore energy converters on the marine environment. It is not the intention of this document to replicate or duplicate the work available in literature but to point users in the direction of more in-depth methodologies.  It is expected that the monitoring protocols described in this document will be improved with the growth of offshore renewable energy technology and through monitoring technology improvements, allowing for more specific and less intrusive monitoring programmes.","author":["Butler, M.","Magagna, D.","Bristow, C.","Lauri, C."],"organization":["European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)","Plymouth University","Marine Renewables Infrastructure Network (MARINET)"],"originationDate":"2014-05-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Birds","Seabirds","Fish","Marine Mammals","Chemicals","Collision","Noise","Habitat Change","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MARINET-D4.17.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2157","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marinet-d413-report-field-buoy-research","sourceURL":"","title":"MaRINET D4.13 Report on field buoy research","description":"This report constitutes deliverable WP4.D13 as part of MARINET project. The aim of this report is to provide a summary of the field buoy research at the South West Mooring Test Facility (SWMTF).  The initial section gives an overview of the facility: location, environmental conditions and configuration: the floating structure, its mooring and the wave and current transducer.  The instrumentation and data collection is presented. This includes the equipment to measure environmental conditions, mooring loads, motion of the floating structure, and other equipment. The equipment and data collection are summarized in tables.  Some results are shown: time series and summary data of environmental data, mooring load and buoy motion. These results will be the base for further studies which aim to test new materials or configuration in real sea conditions, and to gain understanding of mooring system for Marine Renewable Energy (MRE) devices.  The principal outcome of this deliverable is a common information source for all MARINET partners about sea trials. Sea trials are a key point in the development process of a MRE device. They should be used to develop methodologies for installation and operation of MRE devices.","author":["Harnois, V.","Johanning, L.","Rudolph, C.","Bauer, A."],"organization":["Fraunhofer Institute for Wind Energy and Energy System Technology (IWES)","University of Exeter","Marine Renewables Infrastructure Network (MARINET)"],"originationDate":"2015-03-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MARINET-D4.13.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2158","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/d48-database-environmental-monitoring-techniques-equipment","sourceURL":"","title":"D4.8 Database for Environmental Monitoring Techniques and Equipment","description":"This document provides an introduction to the Database for Environmental Monitoring Techniques and Equipment which presents measuring instruments and survey techniques currently used by the MaRINET project partners. This is a common information source for all MaRINET partners to cross reference. This will be of key importance in synchronising the various approaches across Europe and working towards the creation of best practice methodologies for environmental monitoring.  The first part of this report also consists of a brief introduction on the conceptual basis of monitoring activities in the marine and coastal environment. It then links to a comparative table in which available monitoring techniques are matched with the various environmental compartments that characterize the marine environment.  In the final part of the report, existing gaps in the catalogue of instrumentation are discussed and some considerations about the actual thematic coverage of the techniques and instrumentation available are highlighted.","author":["Dampney, K.","Scanu, S.","Carli, F.","Peviani, M."],"organization":["Tuscia University","European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC)","Marine Renewables Infrastructure Network (MARINET)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MARINET-D4.08.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2159","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/d228-model-construction-methods","sourceURL":"","title":"D2.28 Model Construction Methods","description":"Harnessing wave energy is a new concept that requires the development of new technologies able to extract energy from the waves and transmit it to the shore. A large number of technologies are proposed and given the complexity of the task and the high cost of offshore work, a staged development path is required involving indoor and offshore testing at various scales. This offers a large reduction in the development costs of device testing in hydrodynamic facilities and low energy offshore test sites. This leads to the validation of the operation principle, verification of numerical model result, model optimisation, operation training, etc.  In order to ensure the reduced scale provides an accurate representation of the full scale model, a number of techniques can be applied. Two main scaling methods, called Froude and Reynolds, are commonly used for the scaling of hydrodynamic structures. The full design of a scaled model must follow the chosen scaling method and be chosen taking into account suitable materials which can vary with the scales.  This document aims at reviewing the techniques used for scaling, designing and building models for the best representation of the full scale prototype characteristics in controlled ocean test facilities. It provides a description of the full scale prototype characteristics and the scaling methods available. It then provides useful information on the design techniques and the last section concentrates on the verification methods to assess the quality of the model built. This work is based on experience from MARINET partners and documents such as (Gr\u00e9gory S. Payne 2009), (Lu\u00eds Mallen, D2.13, Collation of model construction methods 2012) and (ITTC 2014).  The most common scaling method for WEC testing is using the Froude similitude explained in this document and the most appropriate scale depends mainly on the stage of development of the device, the equipment available and related costs. When the approximate scale is chosen, the characteristics of the deployment location and\/or the material cost and availability may be used to select the final modelling scale.  For the model design, at the chosen scale, a large number of parameters are presented in this report and must be taken into account. It includes the test objectives (optimisation or validation), characteristics of the materials and instrumentation available. All the design parameters must be accurately set and measured in order to ensure repeatability of the results at all scales of testing. This document also suggests and describes a number of verification methods for the most commonly used parameters, weight and weight distribution, power take off systems, instrumentation and mooring lines.  Although the weight and weight distribution is a critical part in the design and construction of floating or underwater models in motion, this is not relevant for the modelling of fixed devices.","author":["Johnstone, C.","Sutton, G.","Thiebaut, F."],"organization":["University College Cork","University of Strathclyde","Marine Renewables Infrastructure Network (MARINET)"],"originationDate":"2015-10-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MARINET-D2.28.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2160","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparative-studies-reveal-variability-use-tidal-stream-environments-seabirds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X16305024","title":"Comparative Studies Reveal Variability in the use of Tidal Stream Environments by Seabirds","description":"The global increase in tidal stream turbine installations creates a need to identify and mitigate any impacts on seabird populations. Within Scotland, UK, the vulnerability of black guillemots Cepphus grylle and European shags Phalacrocorax aristotelis is dependent on their tendency to exploit microhabitats characterised by fast mean horizontal current speeds (\u22652 ms\u20131), and tidal states with maximum current speeds, within tidal stream environments. Identifying consistencies in their relative use of different microhabitats (fast versus slow mean horizontal current speeds) and tidal states (increasing\/decreasing versus maximum currents) across these habitats could assist risk assessment and mitigation measures at both a regional and development site level. Datasets from shore-based surveys collated across 6 tidal stream environments showed that the probability of detecting foraging black guillemots and European shags tended to be higher in fast and slow microhabitats, respectively. However, differences between microhabitats were reversed and\/or marginal in 3 out of the 5 sites used for each species. Differences between tidal states were almost always marginal. These variabilities show that a species\u0027 vulnerability could differ greatly among development sites, and environmental impact assessments (EIA) must quantify habitat-use using dedicated and site-specific surveys to reduce uncertainty. However, a greater understanding of the mechanisms underlying variation in the use of tidal stream environments is needed when selecting a suite of potential development sites that reduce the possibility of population-level impacts. The current collection of physical and biological data across tidal stream environments could therefore prove invaluable for the protection of seabird populations.","author":["Masden, E.","Furness, R.","Waggitt, J.","Scott, B.","Wade, H.","Robbins, A.","Jackson, A."],"organization":["Bangor University","University of Aberdeen","Marine Scotland Science","University of Glasgow","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)","Scottish Natural Heritage","MacArthur Green","Cornwall College"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2161","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bubble-curtains-attenuate-noise-offshore-wind-farm-construction-reduce-temporary","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v580\/p221-237\/","title":"Bubble Curtains Attenuate Noise from Offshore Wind Farm Construction and Reduce Temporary Habitat Loss for Harbour Porpoises","description":"Effects of constructing the DanTysk offshore wind farm (German Bight, 80 turbines, 6 m diameter foundations) were studied by passive acoustic monitoring of pile-driving noise and harbour porpoise Phocoena phocoena echolocation. An acoustic deterrence device (seal scarer) was used to protect porpoises from hearing loss and bubble curtains were used to attenuate the pile-driving noise. Porpoise occurrence, quantified by echolocation signals, decreased when the seal scarer was engaged, during pile driving and up to 5 h after pile driving stopped. This effect extended out to 12 km, less than the 18-25 km reported from other pile drivings performed without bubble curtains. The bubble curtains thus effectively reduced the temporary habitat loss and risk of hearing loss. The 2 bubble curtains each attenuated the noise by between 7 and 10 dB, when used separately, and 12 dB when used together. Attenuation was most pronounced above 1 kHz, where the pile-driving noise at larger distances was comparable to or lower than ambient noise. This suggests that noise regulation should be based on frequency-weighted sound levels in addition to broadband levels, to assure that mitigation measures are effective in reducing impact on animals and not only in fulfilling legal requirements. The strong reaction to the seal scarer raises concern that it may surpass the reactions to the pile-driving noise itself, when operating with bubble curtains, and calls for a re-evaluation of the specifications of seal scarer sounds.","author":["Tougaard, J.","D\u00e4hne, M.","Nabe-Nielsen, J.","Carstensen, J.","Rose, A."],"organization":["Aarhus University","German Oceanographic Museum","BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-09-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Dahne-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2162","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/combining-passive-acoustics-imaging-sonar-techniques-study-sperm-whales-foraging","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.5002895","title":"Combining Passive Acoustics and Imaging Sonar Techniques to Study Sperm Whales\u0027 Foraging Strategies","description":"Sperm whales forage in the deep ocean, hunting for squid. An innovative approach for the study of sperm whale foraging behavior and habitat selection is reported in this letter. A DIDSON imaging sonar mounted on a profiler with a conductivity, temperature, and depth sensor was used to count and measure potential prey in the deep ocean during sperm whales\u0027 acoustical foraging encounters in Hawaii. Preliminary results show how this technique can be applied to the study of deep diving whale foraging and habitat selection. Sperm whales foraged where the density of prey decreased with depth and where the size of prey increased with depth.","author":["Giorli, G."],"organization":["National Institute for Water and Atmospheric Research (NIWA)","University of Hawaii"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2163","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hydroacoustic-assessment-behavioral-responses-fish-passing-near-operating-tidal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/00028487.2017.1339637","title":"Hydroacoustic Assessment of Behavioral Responses by Fish Passing Near an Operating Tidal Turbine in the East River, New York","description":"An important environmental issue facing the marine and hydrokinetic energy industry is whether fish that encounter underwater energy devices are likely to be struck and injured by moving components, primarily rotating turbine blades. The automated analysis of nearly 3 weeks of multibeam hydroacoustics data identified about 35,000 tracks of fish passing a tidal turbine in the East River, New York. These tracks included both individual fish and schools during periods with the turbine absent, the turbine present and operating, and the turbine present but not operating. The density of fish in the sampled area when the turbine was absent was roughly twice the density observed when the turbine was in place, particularly when the turbine was operating. This suggests that some avoidance occurred before fish were close enough to the turbine to be observed by the hydroacoustics system. Various measures of swimming behavior (direction, velocity, and linearity) were calculated for each track and evaluated for indication of behavioral responses to turbine presence and operation. Fish tracks were grouped based on tidal cycle, current velocity, and swimming direction and were evaluated with respect to turbine presence and operation and with respect to distance from the turbine. Nonparametric tests (Kolmogorov\u2013Smirnov test) and multivariate analysis (canonical discriminant analysis) found significant differences among groups with respect to turbine presence and operation, suggesting that some fish responded to the turbine by adjusting swimming behavior, such as making small adjustments to swimming direction and velocity as they passed near the turbine. We found no evidence that fish were being struck by rotating blades, but there did appear to be large-scale avoidance initiated out of the range of the hydroacoustics detection system. More study is needed to determine whether such avoidance behavior has significant ramifications for normal fish movement patterns, bioenergetics, seasonal migrations, and predator exposure.","author":["Bevelhimer, M.","Adonizio, M.","Colby, J.","Scherelis, C."],"organization":["Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL)","Verdant Power"],"originationDate":"2017-08-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.770560000000","-73.940000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 06:58:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2164","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/challenges-opportunities-monitoring-impacts-tidal-stream-energy-devices-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032117309395","title":"Challenges and Opportunities in Monitoring the Impacts of Tidal-Stream Energy Devices on Marine Vertebrates","description":"Marine tidal-stream renewable energy devices (MREDs) are beginning to move from demonstration to early commercial deployment. However, the ecological impacts which may result when large arrays of these devices are deployed are unknown. This uncertainty is placing a considerable burden on developers who must collect biological data through baseline and post-deployment monitoring programs under the Environmental Impact Assessment process. Regulators and other stakeholders are often particularly concerned about impacts on marine vertebrates (fish, seabirds and mammals) because many of these receptors are of high conservation and public concern. Unfortunately monitoring for most marine vertebrates is challenging and expensive, especially in the energetic waters where tidal-stream MREDs will be deployed. Surveys for marine vertebrates often have low statistical power and so are likely to fail to detect all but substantial changes in abundance. Furthermore, many marine vertebrate species have large geographical ranges so that even if local changes in abundance are detected, they cannot usually be related to the wider populations. Much of the monitoring currently being undertaken at tidal-stream MRED development sites is thus leading to a \u2018data-rich but information-poor\u2019 (DRIP) situation. Such an approach adds to development costs whilst contributing little to wider ecosystem-based understanding. In the present article we discuss the issues surrounding the impacts of tidal-stream MREDs on marine vertebrates and address the questions regulators, developers and other stakeholders need to consider when agreeing monitoring programs for these receptors.","author":["Masden, E.","Miller, R.","Benjamins, S.","Fox, C."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2165","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/setting-agenda-biofouling-research-marine-renewable-energy-industry","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166917300711","title":"Setting an Agenda for Biofouling Research for the Marine Renewable Energy Industry","description":"Extensive marine growth on man-made structures in the ocean is commonplace, yet there has been limited discussion about the potential implications of marine growth for the wave and tidal energy industry. In response, the Environmental Interactions of Marine Renewables (EIMR) Biofouling Expert Workshop was convened. Discussions involved participants from the marine renewable energy (MRE) industry, anti-fouling industry, academic institutions and regulatory bodies. The workshop aimed to consider both the benefits and negative effects of biofouling from engineering and ecological perspectives. In order to form an agenda for future research in the area of biofouling and the marine renewable energy industry, 119 topics were generated, categorised and prioritised. Identified areas for future focus fell within four overarching categories: operation and maintenance; structured design and engineering; ecology; and knowledge exchange. It is clear that understanding and minimising biofouling impacts on MRE infrastructure will be vital to the successful development of a reliable and cost effective MRE industry.","author":["Simas, T.","Want, A.","Miller, R.","Macleod, A.","Loxton, J.","Nall, C.","McCollin, T.","Machado, I.","Vance, T.","Kenny, C."],"organization":["University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","Marine Scotland Science","WavEC Offshore Renewables","PML Applications Ltd","Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2166","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/has-designating-protecting-critical-habitat-had-impact-endangered-north-atlantic-right","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X13000973","title":"Has Designating and Protecting Critical Habitat had an Impact on Endangered North Atlantic Right Whale Ship Strike Mortality?","description":"Ship strike is the major anthropogenic source of mortality for severely endangered North Atlantic right whales. Two primary tools are given to US wildlife managers by the Endangered Species Act post-listing to ensure species survival by reducing negative anthropogenic impacts: (1) creating a recovery plan and (2) defining and protecting critical habitat. This study reviews and analyzes the impact these strategies have had in reducing North Atlantic right whale ship strike mortality in US waters from 1973 to 2011. Defining and protecting critical habitat poses distinct spatial and human-use overlap challenges when applied to highly migratory species. Managers should consider two different levels in designating critical habitat for highly migratory species such as the North Atlantic right whale: permanently protected critical habitat in areas where species take up seasonal residence, and temporarily protected migratory habitat to maintain functional migration corridors between seasonal residence critical habitat areas. Managers and stakeholders should also be aware that, given current definitions for North Atlantic right whale critical habitat, human-use overlap in critical habitat areas is inevitable. Instead of eliminating human-use in critical habitat, wildlife managers should apply a combination of adaptive human-behaviors, functional habitat definitions, and on-going habitat-use studies to reduce ship strike mortality, particularly for pregnant and nursing females. Ascertaining methods to effectively manage North Atlantic right whale critical habitat is particularly relevant as current regulatory actions aimed at reducing North Atlantic right whale ship strike mortality will be reviewed by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration in December 2013, offering wildlife managers an opportunity to adjust current ship strike mortality reduction strategies in order to improve the population growth rate.","author":["Peterson, M.","Mullen, K.","Todd, S."],"organization":["University of Maine"],"originationDate":"2013-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.979339500000","-69.385888100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Vessel Strike"],"modifiedDate":"2025-02-15 01:34:43","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2167","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hydrodynamic-impacts-marine-renewable-energy-installation-benthic-boundary-layer-tidal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1876610217336652","title":"Hydrodynamic Impacts of a Marine Renewable Energy Installation on the Benthic Boundary Layer in a Tidal Channel","description":"Field measurements of the flow in the benthic boundary layer (BBL) of a tidal channel are presented which compare data collected in the wake of a marine renewable energy installation (MREI) with control data representative of the natural conditions. The results show significant flow modification in the wake of the MREI including a reduction in mean velocity, enhanced turbulence, and the breakdown of the natural structure and dynamics of the BBL. This study provides new information relevant to the environmental impact assessment of MREIs and to the design and consenting of marine renewable energy projects.","author":["Scott, B.","Williamson, B.","Fraser, S.","Nikora, V."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.150000000000","-2.800000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fraser-et-al-2017.pdf","https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fraser-et-al-2017_0.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2168","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analytical-impact-assessment-framework-wildlife-inform-siting-permitting-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1113262","title":"An Analytical Impact Assessment Framework for Wildlife to Inform the Siting and Permitting of Wind Energy Facilities","description":"In the United States overall electrical generation capacity is expected to increase by 10-25 gigawatts (GW) per year to meet increases in demand. Wind energy is a key component of state and federal renewable energy standards, and central to the Department of Energy\u2019s 20% by 2030 wind production goals. Increased wind energy development may present increased resource conflict with avian wildlife, and environmental permitting has been identified as a potential obstacle to expansion in the sector.  ICF developed an analytical framework to help applicants and agencies examine potential impacts in support of facility siting and permitting. A key objective of our work was to develop a framework that is scalable from the local to the national level, and one that is generalizable across the different scales at which biological communities operate \u2013 from local influences to meta-populations. The intent was to allow natural resource managers to estimate the cumulative impacts of turbine strikes and habitat changes on long-term population performance in the context of a species demography, genetic potential, and life history.  We developed three types of models based on our literature review and participation in the scientific review processes. First, the conceptual model was developed as a general description of the analytical framework. Second, we developed the analytical framework based on the relationships between concepts, and the functions presented in the scientific literature. Third, we constructed an application of the model by parameterizing the framework using data from and relevant to the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area (APWRA), and an existing golden eagle population model. We developed managed source code, database create statements, and written documentation to allow for the reproduction of each phase of the analysis.  ICF identified a potential template adaptive management system in the form of the US Fish \u0026amp; Wildlife Service (USFWS) Adaptive Harvest Management (AHM) program, and developed recommendations for the structure and function of a similar wind-facility related program. We provided a straw-man implementation of the analytical framework based on assumptions for APWRA-wide golden eagle fatalities, and presented a statistical examination of the model performance.  APWRA-wide fatality rates appear substantial at all scales examined from the local APWRA population to the Bird Conservation Region. Documented fatality rates significantly influenced population performance in terms of non-territorial non-breeding birds. Breeder, Juvenile, Subadult, and Adult abundance were mostly unaffected by Baseline APWRA-wide fatality rates. However, increased variability in fatality rates would likely have impacts on long-term population performance, and would result in a substantially larger REA estimate.  We developed four recommendations for future study. First, we recommend establishment of concept experts through the existing system of non-profits, regulatory agencies, academia, and industry in the wind energy sector. Second, we recommend the development of a central or distributed shared data repository, and establish guidelines for data sharing and transparency. Third, we recommend development a forum and process for model selection at the local and national level. Last, we recommend experimental implementation of the prescribed system at broader scales, and refinement the expectations for modeling and adaptive management.","author":["Schwartz, J."],"organization":["ICF International","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Schwartz-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2169","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/spatially-explicit-bat-impact-screening-tool-wind-turbine-siting","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1097521","title":"Spatially-Explicit Bat Impact Screening Tool for Wind Turbine Siting","description":"As the U.S. seeks to increase energy production from renewable energy sources, development of wind power resources continues to grow. One of the most important ecological issues restricting wind energy development, especially the siting of wind turbines, is the potential adverse effect on bats. High levels of bat fatality have been recorded at a number of wind energy facilities, especially in the eastern United States. The U.S. Department of Energy contracted with Versar, Inc., and Exponent to develop a spatially-explicit site screening tool to evaluate the mortality of bats resulting from interactions (collisions or barotrauma) with wind turbines. The resulting Bat Vulnerability Assessment Tool (BVAT) presented in this report integrates spatial information about turbine locations, bat habitat features, and bat behavior as it relates to possible interactions with turbines. A model demonstration was conducted that focuses on two bat species, the eastern red bat (Lasiurus borealis) and the Indiana bat (Myotis sodalis). The eastern red bat is a relatively common tree-roosting species that ranges broadly during migration in the Eastern U.S., whereas the Indiana bat is regional species that migrates between a summer range and cave hibernacula. Moreover, Indiana bats are listed as endangered, and so the impacts to this species are of particular interest. The model demonstration used conditions at the Mountaineer Wind Energy Center (MWEC), which consists of 44 wind turbines arranged in a linear array near Thomas, West Virginia (Tucker County), to illustrate model functions and not to represent actual or potential impacts of the facility. The turbines at MWEC are erected on the ridge of Backbone Mountain with a nacelle height of 70 meters and a collision area of 72 meters (blade height) or 4,071 meters square. The habitat surrounding the turbines is an Appalachian mixed mesophytic forest. Model sensitivity runs showed that bat mortality in the model was most sensitive to perceptual range and flying height. The BVAT model demonstration found that after 30 model iterations, Red bats suffered greater rates of mortality (i.e., 2.5 times the number of bats killed per 10-day period) than Indiana bats, primarily resulting from the higher flying height of the red bat. The model described in this report is a first release. There are opportunities to expand and enhance the model in the future. For example, additional focus on the model experience would include adding project level saving\/loading, integrating the outputs (trajectory mapping) into the main output window, and providing tools for preparing habitat maps. In addition to the model framework, the actual modeling options could be enhanced by adding associative learning (including additional behavioral states), adding additional movement models, and exploring the information transfer among bats. Ultimately, this standalone model could be integrated into ArcGIS as a plugin.","author":["Exponent Inc.","Versar Inc."],"organization":["Versar Inc.","Exponent Inc."],"originationDate":"2013-10-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Versar-and-Exponent-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2170","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/genetic-approaches-understanding-population-level-impact-wind-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1312842-genetic-approaches-understanding-population-level-impact-wind-energy-development-migratory-bats","title":"Genetic Approaches to Understanding the Population-Level Impact of Wind Energy Development on Migratory Bats","description":"Documented fatalities of bats at wind turbines have raised serious concerns about the future impacts of increased wind power development on populations of migratory bat species. Yet there is little data on bat population sizes and trends to provide context for understanding the consequences of mortality due to wind power development. Using a large dataset of both nuclear and mitochondrial DNA variation for eastern red bats, we demonstrated that: 1) this species forms a single, panmictic population across their range with no evidence for the historical use of divergent migratory pathways by any portion of the population; 2) the effective size of this population is in the hundreds of thousands to millions; and 3) for large populations, genetic diversity measures and at least one coalescent method are insensitive to even very high rates of population decline over long time scales and until population size has become very small. Our data provide important context for understanding the population-level impacts of wind power development on affected bat species.","author":["Vonhof, M.","Russell, A."],"organization":["Western Michigan University","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2013-09-30","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Vonhof-and-Russell-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2171","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/win-win-wind-wildlife-vision-facilitate-sustainable-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0017566","title":"Win-Win for Wind and Wildlife: A Vision to Facilitate Sustainable Development","description":"Wind energy offers the potential to reduce carbon emissions while increasing energy independence and bolstering economic development. However, wind energy has a larger land footprint per Gigawatt (GW) than most other forms of energy production, making appropriate siting and mitigation particularly important. Species that require large unfragmented habitats and those known to avoid vertical structures are particularly at risk from wind development. Developing energy on disturbed lands rather than placing new developments within large and intact habitats would reduce cumulative impacts to wildlife. The U.S. Department of Energy estimates that it will take 241 GW of terrestrial based wind development on approximately 5 million hectares to reach 20% electricity production for the U.S. by 2030. We estimate there are \u223c7,700 GW of potential wind energy available across the U.S., with \u223c3,500 GW on disturbed lands. In addition, a disturbance-focused development strategy would avert the development of \u223c2.3 million hectares of undisturbed lands while generating the same amount of energy as development based solely on maximizing wind potential. Wind subsidies targeted at favoring low-impact developments and creating avoidance and mitigation requirements that raise the costs for projects impacting sensitive lands could improve public value for both wind energy and biodiversity conservation.","author":["Kunz, T.","Naugle, D.","Evans, J.","Fargione, J.","Kiesecker, J.","Doherty, K.","Foresman, K.","Nibbelink, N.","Niemuth, N."],"organization":["The Nature Conservancy","Audubon Society","University of Montana","Boston University","University of Georgia","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)"],"originationDate":"2011-04-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kiesecker-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2172","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/energy-design-science-based-wind-energy-siting-avoid-environmental-impact-continental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1037447-final-technical-report","title":"Energy By Design: Science-Based Wind Energy Siting to Avoid Environmental Impact In the Continental United States","description":"The United States has abundant wind resources, such that only about 3% of the resource would need to be developed to achieve the goal of producing 20% of electricity in the United States by 2030. Inappropriately sited wind development may result in conflicts with wildlife that can delay or derail development projects, increase projects costs, and may degrade important conservation values. The most cost-effective approach to reducing such conflicts is through landscape-scale siting early in project development. To support landscape scale siting that avoids sensitive areas for wildlife, we compiled a database on species distributions, wind resource, disturbed areas, and land ownership. Wind project developers can use this web tool to identify potentially sensitive areas and areas that are already disturbed and are therefore likely to be less sensitive to additional impacts from wind development. The United States goal of producing 20% of its electricity from wind energy by the year 2030 would require 241 GW of terrestrial nameplate capacity. We analyzed whether this goal could be met by using lands that are already disturbed, which would minimize impacts to wildlife. Our research shows that over 14 times the DOE goal could be produced on lands that are already disturbed (primarily cropland and oil and gas fields), after taking into account wind resource availability and areas that would be precluded from wind development because of existing urban development or because of development restrictions. Even projects that are sited appropriately may have some impacts on wildlife habitat that can be offset with offsite compensatory mitigation. We demonstrate one approach to mapping and quantifying mitigation costs, using the state of Kansas as a case study. Our approach considers a range of conservation targets (species and habitat) and calculates mitigation costs based on actual costs of the conservation actions (protection and restoration) that would be needed to fully offset impacts.","author":["Fargione, J."],"organization":["The Nature Conservancy","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2012-02-24","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fargione-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2173","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/development-geographic-information-system-based-decision-support-tool-evaluating","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1303492-development-geographic-information-system-based-decision-support-tool-evaluating-windfarm-sitings-great-lakes-aquatic-habitats","title":"Development of a Geographic Information System-Based Decision Support Tool for Evaluating Windfarm Sitings in Great Lakes Aquatic Habitats","description":"As an outcome of our research project, we developed software and data for the Lakebed Alteration Decision Support Tool (LADST), a web-based decision support program to assist resource managers in making siting decisions for offshore wind farms (as well as other lakebed-altering projects) in the United States\u0027 waters of the Great Lakes. Users of the LADST can create their own offshore wind farm suitability maps, based upon suitability criteria of their own choosing by visiting a public web site. The LADST can be used to represent the different priorities or values of different Great Lakes stakeholders for wind farm siting, as well as the different suitability requirements of wind farms (or different types of development projects) in a single suitability analysis system. The LADST makes this type of customized suitability analysis easily accessible to users who have no specialized software or experience with geographic information systems (GIS). It also may increase the transparency of the siting and permitting process for offshore wind farms, as it makes the suitability analysis equally accessible to resource managers, wind farm developers, and concerned citizens.","author":["Wang, L.","Wehrly, K.","Rutherford, E.","Breck, J.","Mason, L.","Nelson, S."],"organization":["University of Michigan","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2011-07-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.308038700000","-86.965816300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wehrly-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2174","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-high-resolution-spatial-data-migration-corridors-avian-species-concern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1314133-developing-high-resolution-spatial-data-migration-corridors-avian-species-concern-regions-high-potential-wind-development","title":"Developing High-Resolution Spatial Data of Migration Corridors for Avian Species of Concern in Regions of High Potential Wind Development","description":"The future of the US economy, our national security, and our environmental quality all depend on decreasing our reliance on foreign oil and on fossil fuels. An essential component of decreasing this reliance is the development of alternative energy sources. Wind power is among the most important alternative energy sources currently available, and the mid-Atlantic region is a primary focus for wind power development.\n\nIn addition to being important to the development of wind power, the mid-Atlantic region holds a special responsibility for the conservation of the eastern North America\u0027s golden eagles (Aquila chrysaetos). This small population breeds in northeastern Canada, winters in the southern Appalachians, and nearly all of these birds pass through the mid-Atlantic region twice each year. Movement of these birds is not random and, particularly during spring and autumn, migrating golden eagles concentrate in a narrow 30-50 mile wide corridor in central Pennsylvania. Thus, because the fate of these rare birds may depend on responsible management of the habitat they use it is critical to use research to identify ways to mitigate prospective impacts on this and similar raptor species.\n\nThe goal of this project was to develop high-resolution spatial risk maps showing migration corridors of and habitat use by eastern golden eagles in regions of high potential for wind development.\n\nTo accomplish this, we first expanded existing models of raptor migration for the eastern USA to identify broad-scale migration patterns. We then used data from novel high-resolution tracking devices to discover routes of passage and detailed flight behavior of individual golden eagles throughout the eastern USA. Finally, we integrated these data and models to predict population-level migration patterns and individual eagle flight behavior on migration. We then used this information to build spatially explicit, probabilistic maps showing relative risk to birds from wind development.\n\nThis project has numerous benefits to people and to wildlife, primarily because it will provide a framework for safer and less controversial development of wind power. Because golden eagles are an important \u0022umbrella\u0022 for other raptors, this project benefits a suite of species that may be impacted by wind turbines. Finally this work is a recognized priority for central Appalachian states and it is explicitly called for in, and meets the goals of, numerous state wildlife conservation plans.\n\nThe final product we created, a region-wide map of relative risk to eagles of development of wind power, has allowed us to make specific recommendations regarding siting and operation of and mitigation at wind facilities. This approach also serves as a model for other projects to protect eagles in other places and to conserve suites of species beyond raptors.","author":["Katzner, T."],"organization":["West Virginia University","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2014-06-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Katzner-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2175","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-lesser-prairie-chicken-lek-density-relative-landscape-characteristics-texas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1049690-assessment-lesser-prairie-chicken-lek-density-relative-landscape-characteristics-texas","title":"Assessment of Lesser Prairie-Chicken Lek Density Relative to Landscape Characteristics in Texas","description":"My 2.5-yr Master\u0027s project accomplished the objectives of estimating lesser prairie-chicken (LPC) lek density and abundance in the Texas occupied range and modeling anthropogenic and landscape features associated with lek density by flying helicopter lek surveys for 2 field seasons and employing a line-transect distance sampling method. This project was important for several reasons. Firstly, wildlife managers and biologists have traditionally monitored LPC populations with road-based surveys that may result in biased estimates and do not provide access to privately-owned or remote property. From my aerial surveys and distance sampling, I was able to provide accurate density and abundance estimates, as well as new leks and I detected LPCs outside the occupied range. Secondly, recent research has indicated that energy development has the potential to impact LPCs through avoidance of tall structures, increased mortality from raptors perching on transmission lines, disturbance to nesting hens, and habitat loss\/fragmentation. Given the potential wind energy development in the Texas Panhandle, spatial models of current anthropogenic and vegetative features (such as transmission lines, roads, and percent native grassland) influencing lek density were needed. This information provided wildlife managers and wind energy developers in Texas with guidelines for how change in landscape features could impact LPCs. Lastly, LPC populations have faced range-wide declines over the last century and they are currently listed as a candidate species under the Endangered Species Act. I was able to provide timely information on LPC populations in Texas that will be used during the listing process.\n\nLine-transect distance sampling is a common technique used to estimate density and abundance of wildlife populations. Aerial surveys allow a larger area to be sampled in less time and access to remote or privately-owned land and helicopters in particular allow for reduced air speeds, sharper and safer turns between transects, and better vision directly below the aircraft as compared to fixed-wing aircraft. A recent Texas Tech graduate student evaluated the use of helicopters for surveying LPC leks and he found that lek detectability from an R-22 helicopter (2 observers) was 72.3% and there was minimal disturbance to the LPCs (McRoberts et al. 2011 ). He also found that the use of R-22 helicopters was a cost-effective technique for finding new leks as compared to driving roads and listening for leks. I followed the survey protocol of McRoberts et al. (2011 ) (i.e., transects spaced 400 - m apart, flight altitude of 15 m above ground-level, target speed of 60 km\/hr, survey bet ween sunrise until \u22482.5 hr post-sunrise) and also concluded that the use of an R-22 helicopter is an efficient and effective method for monitoring LPC populations. My surveys cost $350\/hr of flight time (for an average of 3hr of flight time per survey) plus gas mileage for the pilots, myself, and technicians. This may cost more than driving county roads for 3 hr listening for leks, but I found new leks that had not been previously detected by other graduate students or biologists and I was able to cover more area in less time with fewer personnel.\n\nSpatial models relate landscape features, such as percent grassland and road density, with animal abundance, density, or occurrence. These models can identify suitable habitat and predict species occurrence or abundance. In particular, hierarchical distance sampling models rely on data collected by distance sampling methods and then relate spatial covariates to animal density or abundance through regression techniques. These methods model spatial variation associated with density or abundance and the resulting estimates are often more precise. These methods also estimate a detection probability for the sampled population, which many other spatial techniques, such as occupancy modeling, do not.","author":["Timmer, J."],"organization":["Texas Tech University","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2012-08-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["33.665504600000","-103.045965900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Timmer-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2176","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/are-flying-wildlife-attracted-or-do-they-avoid-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1227698-flying-wildlife-attracted-do-avoid-wind-turbines","title":"Are Flying Wildlife Attracted to (or do they Avoid) Wind Turbines?","description":"A DOE-sponsored research project found strong evidence that flying wildlife avoid or are attracted to commercial-scale wind turbines from a distance. Some nocturnally migrating birds avoid flying near turbines and few or none change flight paths to approach them. High-flying bats less often avoid flying near turbines and some are attracted to them from a distance, although bats\u2019 flight paths were often complex and convoluted. The findings are being prepared for submission to a peer-reviewed scientific journal (Larkin, in prep 2013).","author":["Larkin, R."],"organization":["University of Illinois","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2010-03-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Larkin-2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2177","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/habitat-based-wind-wildlife-collision-model-application-upper-great-plains-region","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1049318-habitat-based-wind-wildlife-collision-model-application-upper-great-plains-region","title":"A Habitat-Based Wind-Wildlife Collision Model with Application to the Upper Great Plains Region","description":"Most previous studies on collision impacts at wind facilities have taken place at the site-specific level and have only examined small-scale influences on mortality. In this study, we examine landscape-level influences using a hierarchical spatial model combined with existing datasets and life history knowledge for: Horned Lark, Red-eyed Vireo, Mallard, American Avocet, Golden Eagle, Whooping Crane, red bat, silver-haired bat, and hoary bat. These species were modeled in the central United States within Bird Conservation Regions 11, 17, 18, and 19. For the bird species, we modeled bird abundance from existing datasets as a function of habitat variables known to be preferred by each species to develop a relative abundance prediction for each species. For bats, there are no existing abundance datasets so we identified preferred habitat in the landscape for each species and assumed that greater amounts of preferred habitat would equate to greater abundance of bats. The abundance predictions for bird and bats were modeled with additional exposure factors known to influence collisions such as visibility, wind, temperature, precipitation, topography, and behavior to form a final mapped output of predicted collision risk within the study region. We reviewed published mortality studies from wind farms in our study region and collected data on reported mortality of our focal species to compare to our modeled predictions. We performed a sensitivity analysis evaluating model performance of 6 different scenarios where habitat and exposure factors were weighted differently. We compared the model performance in each scenario by evaluating observed data vs. our model predictions using spearmans rank correlations. Horned Lark collision risk was predicted to be highest in the northwestern and west-central portions of the study region with lower risk predicted elsewhere. Red-eyed Vireo collision risk was predicted to be the highest in the eastern portions of the study region and in the forested areas of the western portion; the lowest risk was predicted in the treeless portions of the northwest portion of the study area. Mallard collision risk was predicted to be highest in the eastern central portion of the prairie potholes and in Iowa which has a high density of pothole wetlands; lower risk was predicted in the more arid portions of the study area. Predicted collision risk for American Avocet was similar to Mallard and was highest in the prairie pothole region and lower elsewhere. Golden Eagle collision risk was predicted to be highest in the mountainous areas of the western portion of the study area and lowest in the eastern portion of the prairie potholes. Whooping Crane predicted collision risk was highest within the migration corridor that the birds follow through in the central portion of the study region; predicted collision risk was much lower elsewhere. Red bat collision risk was highly driven by large tracts of forest and river corridors which made up most of the areas of higher collision risk. Silver-haired bat and hoary bat predicted collision risk were nearly identical and driven largely by forest and river corridors as well as locations with warmer temperatures, and lower average wind speeds. Horned Lark collisions were mostly influenced by abundance and predictions showed a moderate correlation between observed and predicted mortality (r = 0.55). Red bat, silver-haired bat, and hoary bat predictions were much higher and shown a strong correlations with observed mortality with correlations of 0.85, 0.90, and 0.91 respectively. Red bat collisions were influenced primarily by habitat, while hoary bat and silver-haired bat collisions were influenced mainly by exposure variables. Stronger correlations between observed and predicted collision for bats than for Horned Larks can likely be attributed to stronger habitat associations and greater influences of weather on behavior for bats. Although the collision predictions cannot be compared among species, our model outputs provide a convenient and easy landscape-level tool to quickly screen for siting issues at a high level. The model resolution is suitable for state or multi-county siting but users are cautioned against using these models for micrositing. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service recently released voluntary land-based wind energy guidelines for assessing impacts of a wind facility to wildlife using a tiered approach. The tiered approach uses an iterative approach for assessing impacts to wildlife in levels of increasing detail from landscape-level screening to site-specific field studies. Our models presented in this paper would be applicable to be used as tools to conduct screening at the tier 1 level and would not be appropriate to complete smaller scale tier 2 and tier 3 level studies. For smaller scale screening ancillary field studies should be conducted at the site-specific level to validate collision predictions.","author":["Forcey, G."],"organization":["Normandeau Associates Inc","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2012-08-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.564967900000","-99.113111600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Forcey-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2178","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/synthesis-human-related-avian-mortality-canada","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ace-eco.org\/vol8\/iss2\/art11\/","title":"A synthesis of human-related avian mortality in Canada","description":"Many human activities in Canada kill wild birds, yet the relative magnitude of mortality from different sources and the consequent effects on bird populations have not been systematically evaluated. We synthesize recent estimates of avian mortality in Canada from a range of industrial and other human activities, to provide context for the estimates from individual sources presented in this special feature. We assessed the geographic, seasonal, and taxonomic variation in the magnitude of national-scale mortality and in population-level effects on species or groups across Canada, by combining these estimates into a stochastic model of stage-specific mortality. The range of estimates of avian mortality from each source covers several orders of magnitude, and, numerically, landbirds were the most affected group. In total, we estimate that approximately 269 million birds and 2 million nests are destroyed annually in Canada, the equivalent of over 186 million breeding individuals. Combined, cat predation and collisions with windows, vehicles, and transmission lines caused \u0026gt; 95% of all mortality; the highest industrial causes of mortality were the electrical power and agriculture sectors. Other mortality sources such as fisheries bycatch can have important local or species-specific impacts, but are relatively small at a national scale. Mortality rates differed across species and families within major bird groups, highlighting that mortality is not simply proportional to abundance. We also found that mortality is not evenly spread across the country; the largest mortality sources are coincident with human population distribution, while industrial sources are concentrated in southern Ontario, Alberta, and southwestern British Columbia. Many species are therefore likely to be vulnerable to cumulative effects of multiple human-related impacts. This assessment also confirms the high uncertainty in estimating human-related avian mortality in terms of species involved, potential for population-level effects, and the cumulative effects of mortality across the landscape. Effort is still required to improve these estimates, and to guide conservation efforts to minimize direct mortality caused by human activities on Canada\u2019s wild bird populations. As avian mortality represents only a portion of the overall impact to avifauna, indirect effects such as habitat fragmentation and alteration, site avoidance, disturbance, and related issues must also be carefully considered.","author":["Calvert, A.","Bishop, C.","Elliot, R.","Krebs, E.","Kydd, T.","Machtans, C.","Robertson, G."],"organization":["Environment Canada"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2179","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-wind-energy-development-bats-implications-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007%2F978-1-4614-7397-8_21","title":"Impacts of Wind Energy Development on Bats: Implications for Conservation","description":"At a time of growing concern over the rising costs and long-term environmental impacts from the use of fossil fuels, wind energy has become an increasingly important sector of the electrical power industry. However, large numbers of bats are being killed at utility-scale wind energy facilities, and these fatalities raise important concerns about cumulative impacts of proposed wind energy development on bat populations. We discuss our current state of knowledge on patterns of bat fatalities at wind facilities, present new information on cumulative fatalities in the USA and Canada, and present findings from mitigation studies. Given the magnitude and extent of fatalities of bats worldwide, the conservation implications of understanding and mitigating bat fatalities at wind energy facilities are critically important.","author":["Baerwald, E.","Arnett, E."],"organization":["Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership","University of Calgary"],"originationDate":"2013-07-08","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2180","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/framework-regulating-underwater-noise-during-pile-driving","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.naturvardsverket.se\/publikationer\/6700\/a-framework-for-regulating-underwater-noise-during-pile-driving\/","title":"A Framework for Regulating Underwater Noise During Pile Driving","description":"Pile driving is a common technique used during the construction of bridges, offshore wind power, and underwater infrastructure or shoreline structures. It is the process by which a foundation, beam or pole is hammered or vibrated down into the bottom, which can generate extremely loud noise that propagates throughout the surrounding water and sediment. The noise can reach such high levels that marine animals are at risk of disturbance, injury or even death.  Sweden currently lacks established thresholds stating the level at which underwater noise potentially disturbs or injures marine animals. Hence, there are no guidance values for allowable underwater noise levels from noise-producing activities to avoid serious environmental impacts. Several countries in Europe have defined thresholds for when underwater noise can result in severe negative environmental impacts as well as standards for measuring, analysing and reporting underwater noise levels.  The purpose of this study is to review the scientific literature on underwater noise from pile driving and its effects on marine life. The study aims to define the noise levels that can cause injury and other negative effects and, on this basis, recommend noise levels that can be used to establish guidance values for regulating underwater noise for Swedish waters and species. The study presents examples of the factors that contribute to sound propagation in Swedish waters and how this influences the noise level from a pile strike as a function of distance at four study areas along the Swedish coast. Additionally, the study contains a thorough technical description of pile driving activities, basic underwater acoustics and noise effects on marine animals. These effects (injury and behavioral, e.g., flight, but not subtle effects) are demonstrated on representative species such as the harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena), Atlantic cod (Gadus morhua), Atlantic herring (Clupea harengus) and on fish larvae and eggs. The study\u2019s authors look at the original sources of information that other countries base their guidelines and thresholds on, so the recommendations follow scientifically determined levels rather than values that have been rounded off or otherwise altered.  The study presents sound levels in three different units, each with different biological relevance to the effects caused by a pile driving activity. None of the sound levels have been frequency weighted for a specific species, as this method is not yet fully established. The first unit used is the sound pressure level SPL(peak), which is the maximum overpressure or underpressure of the noise pulse generated by the pile strike. This unit has a high relevance for behavioural effects. The sound exposure level, SEL, is the calculated energy level over a period of time and expresses the energy of the entire sound pulse. SEL is the unit most related to hearing impairing effects. SEL(ss) is the value for a single strike while SEL(cum) is the cumulative value of a determined number of pulses over a period of time.  The review revealed that for Atlantic cod and Atlantic herring there are currently no studies that can be used to determine a species\u2019 specific threshold value for injury, but studies show that loud noise can affect both species negatively. Because of this, the recommended noise levels for injury are based mainly on studies on other species exposed to pile driving noise in laboratory environments, supported by studies conducting large-scale experiments in tanks and oceans. The levels at which fish are at risk of death or sustaining serious injury to internal organs is SPL(peak) 207 dB re 1 \u03bcPa, SEL(ss) 174 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2s and SEL(cum) 204 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2s. Note that for injury in fish, the cumulative sound exposure level has higher relevance than the single-strike level as the cited studies found injuries after a certain time period of exposure. The thresholds for fish larvae and eggs are based on the fact that no negative effects were observed at exposures of up to SPL(peak) 217 dB re 1 \u03bcPa, SEL(ss) 187 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2s and SEL(cum) 207 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2s. However, there are relatively few studies on early life stages of fish.  There are more species-specific studies on harbour porpoises regarding noise than there are for Atlantic cod and Atlantic herring. Nonetheless, only a few can be used to determine thresholds that will lead to injury or negative behavioural effects. The levels at which there is a risk of a temporary impact on hearing, i.e. temporary threshold shift (TTS), for the harbour porpoises is SPL(peak) 194 dB re 1 \u03bcPa, SEL(ss) 164 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2s and SEL(cum) 175 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2s. When it comes to TTS, the cumulative sound exposure level, SEL(cum), is of primary importance. However, this unit is dependent on a specific time and number of pulses. For permanent threshold shift (PTS), the level is set to SPL(peak) 200 dB re 1 \u03bcPa, SEL(ss) 179 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2s and SEL(cum) 190 dB re 1 \u03bcPa2s. The recommended level should be revised as new relevant studies are conducted.","author":["Sigray, P.","Andersson, M.","Andersson, S.","Wikstr\u00f6m, A.","Persson, L.","Ahls\u00e9n, J.","Andersson, B.","Hammar, J.","Pihl, J."],"organization":["Vindval","Swedish Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Andersson-et-al-2017-Report6775.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2181","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/boosting-blue-growth-mild-sea-analysis-synergies-produced-multi-purpose-offshore","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2071-1050\/7\/6\/6804","title":"Boosting Blue Growth in a Mild Sea: Analysis of the Synergies Produced by a Multi-Purpose Offshore Installation in the Northern Adriatic, Italy","description":"In the near future, the oceans will be subjected to a massive development of marine infrastructures, including offshore wind, tidal and wave energy farms and constructions for marine aquaculture. The development of these facilities will unavoidably exert environmental pressures on marine ecosystems. It is therefore crucial that the economic costs, the use of marine space and the environmental impacts of these activities remain within acceptable limits. Moreover, the installation of arrays of wave energy devices is still far from being economically feasible due to many combined aspects, such as immature technologies for energy conversion, local energy storage and moorings. Therefore, multi-purpose solutions combining renewable energy from the sea (wind, wave, tide), aquaculture and transportation facilities can be considered as a challenging, yet advantageous, way to boost blue growth. This would be due to the sharing of the costs of installation and using the produced energy locally to feed the different functionalities and optimizing marine spatial planning. This paper focuses on the synergies that may be produced by a multi-purpose offshore installation in a relatively calm sea, i.e., the Northern Adriatic Sea, Italy, and specifically offshore Venice. It analyzes the combination of aquaculture, energy production from wind and waves, and energy storage or transfer. Alternative solutions are evaluated based on specific criteria, including the maturity of the technology, the environmental impact, the induced risks and the costs. Based on expert judgment, the alternatives are ranked and a preliminary layout of the selected multi-purpose installation for the case study is proposed, to further allow the exploitation of the synergies among different functionalities.","author":["Airoldi, L.","Zanuttigh, B.","Zagonari, F.","Troianos, D.","Suffredini, R.","Taramelli, A.","Angelelli, E.","Krontira, Y.","Bellotti, G.","Romano, A.","Franceschi, G.","Cantu, M.","Filipponi, F.","Jimenez, C.","Evriviadou, M.","Broszeit, S."],"organization":["University of Bologna","University of Rome III","The Cyprus Institute","Institute for the Protection Environmental Research","Plymouth Marine Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2015-05-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.800320000000","13.261983000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zunittighetal2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2182","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hybrid-renewable-energy-system-minimum-noise-wind-turbine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117306274","title":"Hybrid Renewable Energy System with Minimum Noise Wind Turbine","description":"In this study, a photovoltaic-wind hybrid renewable energy system has been examined and analyzed, with concentration on wind turbine to minimize generated noise. Mechanical and electrical analyses were performed. Harmonic electrical analysis on the wind turbine generator and electronic devices within the conversion system was conducted to get better performance. Mechanical vibration analysis was also done on selected wind turbine to estimate the forces and frequencies that may affect the blade during operation and cause noise and disturbance effects.\n\nIt was found that Harmonics and total Harmonic Distortion were minimized after implementing an AC\/DC\/AC conversion system consisting of a diode full wave rectifier and an LC filter to stabilize the DC bus. Finally IGBT inverter was used to convert the DC signal into AC output signal with a useful frequency of 50\u00a0Hz after reshaping. The total harmonic distortion was minimized to 2.81%, less than the IEEE standards of 5% of the fundamental current frequency.\n\nFurthermore, it was also found that according to suggested arrangement of the hybrid system in this study, the blade of the proposed wind turbine, if operated even under its natural frequencies, its performance will be slightly affected resulting in minimized resonance effect.","author":["Al-Hamidi, H.","Asfar, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2183","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/current-wave-effects-around-windfarm-monopile-foundations","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378383917300054","title":"Current and Wave Effects around Windfarm Monopile Foundations","description":"Laboratory measurements were undertaken to investigate wave and current velocities in the vicinity of a wind turbine monopile foundation, in order to inform environmental impact assessments and to quantify flow variability in the region of the power take off cable. Flow measurements were made up to 15.5 pile diameters (D) downstream of the pile. Measurements were also taken around the perimeter of the pile (~0.75 D from the pile centre) at the approximate representative height of the power cable. In current-only tests, the mean flow was reduced immediately downstream of the pile, but returned to within 5% of background levels by 8.3 D downstream of the pile centre in representative conditions. A new parameterisation of the velocity recovery is given. The turbulent eddy shedding frequency was well predicted by the Strouhal number. Turbulence peaked at 1.5 D from the pile centre, and the subsequent decay was parameterised. Velocity magnitudes at the side of the pile were up to 1.35 times greater than background flow rates, in line with potential flow theory. Velocities in the wake region were much less than predicted by potential flow theory, corresponding with increased turbulence. Tests with waves indicated that oscillatory velocities reduced immediately down-wave of the pile, but returned quickly to background levels (by 1.65 to 3.5 D of the pile centre). The general near-pile distribution of the orbital velocity maximum was well represented by potential flow theory. Orbital velocities were reduced immediately up-wave and down-wave of the pile. At the side of the pile in wind sea conditions, the velocity increased up to 1.66 times the background level. This increased to 1.85 times in swell conditions. For orthogonal currents and waves, a velocity parameter was calculated as the mean current plus wave orbital velocity, resolved. With the mean current direction as a reference, the maximum flow was observed at the side of the pile. At 0.75 D from the pile centre, the flow was enhanced by up to 1.2 times the no\u2013pile case. Spectral peaks in the velocity were evident at both wave frequency and at the Strouhal frequency, immediately down current from the pile.","author":["Miles, J.","Martin, T.","Goddard, L."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.374528400000","-4.142835200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2184","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-larval-connectivity-marine-spatial-planning-adriatic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113617300430","title":"Assessing larval connectivity for marine spatial planning in the Adriatic","description":"There are plans to start building offshore marine renewable energy devices throughout the Mediterranean and the Adriatic has been identified as a key location for wind farm developments. The development of offshore wind farms in the area would provide hard substrata for the settlement of sessile benthos. Since the seafloor of the Adriatic is predominantly sedimentary this may alter the larval connectivity of benthic populations in the region. Here, we simulated the release of larvae from benthic populations along the coasts of the Adriatic Sea using coupled bio-physical models and investigated the effect of pelagic larval duration on dispersal. Our model simulations show that currents typically carry particles from east to west across the Adriatic, whereas particles released along western coasts tend to remain there with the Puglia coast of Italy acting as a sink for larvae from benthic populations. We identify areas of high connectivity, as well as areas that are much more isolated, and discuss how these results can be used to inform marine spatial planning and the licensing of offshore marine renewable energy developments.","author":["Hall-Spencer, J.","Bray, L.","Kassis, D."],"organization":["Hellenic Centre for Marine Research (HCMR)","Plymouth University","National Technical University of Athens","University of Tsukuba"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.770746500000","15.698198600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2185","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-methods-techniques-field-validation-collision-rates-avoidance-amongst-birds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/317585745_Review_of_methods_and_techniques_for_field_validation_of_collision_rates_and_avoidance_amongst_birds_and_bats_at_offshore_wind_turbines","title":"Review of Methods and Techniques for Field Validation of Collision Rates and Avoidance Amongst Birds and Bats at Offshore Wind Turbines","description":"The Dutch government has started a new round of wind energy development in its EEZ. The aim is set at 4500 MW in 2023. Directly related to these developments, a research programme on ecological effects has been designed, building on research and monitoring carried out in The Netherlands and abroad. The programme, called \u2018Wozep\u2019 (Wind op Zee Ecologisch Programma) will run until 2021. In 2016 some initial steps have been taken.  One of the aims in Wozep is to design an integrated monitoring programme, aiming at detecting collisions of birds and bats, and simultaneously carry out measurements of species-specific fluxes of both groups. This should be done around the wind farm, within the wind farm and in the rotor-swept area (RSA). This way, the programme should result in species-specific collision risk figures. The results of such a monitoring programme will also be used to improve collision risk modelling (e.g. the Band Model - Band 2000, 2012, Band et al. 2007, Masden 2015, Masden \u0026amp; Cook 2015 - or the Flux Collision Model, Kleyheeg-Hartman et al. in prep.).  One of the tasks to be completed in 2016 is an inventory and review of systems and techniques that can be used to carry out the measurements described above. This will eventually lead to a draft TOR (Terms of Reference) for a field project. This report provides the inventory and review only.  The aim of this report is to provide a full overview of \u2018state of art\u2019 monitoring systems and methods that are currently available and\/or in development, and can be used as (part of) an integrated monitoring programme to measure collision victims and fluxes of birds and\/or bats in offshore wind farms. The review will deal with relevant features of the systems: effectively measure collisions in combination with fluxes (within reach of wind farm, within wind farm and in Rotor Swept Area - RSA), species specificity of both, data-processing (real time vs indirect), applicability in different weather and light circumstances (night time), requirements related to installation, network band width, power supply etc.  The review is meant to give a general overview of what is available to carry out the measurements Rijkswaterstaat may decide to include in Wozep. It is aiming at showing there is a variety of solutions available, not a detailed comparison aiming at a ranking or quality comparison. Also, this is a snapshot: data on systems will be different tomorrow. Anyone interested in using any of the systems will have to compare the actual capabilities of systems, and features not (yet) evaluated in public papers or reports will have to be shown or demonstrated by system producers.","author":["Dirksen, S."],"organization":["WOZEP","WOZEP"],"originationDate":"2017-03-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Dirksen-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2186","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/regional-scale-patterns-harbour-porpoise-occupancy-tidal-stream-environments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/article-abstract\/doi\/10.1093\/icesjms\/fsx164\/4101444\/Regional-scale-patterns-in-harbour-porpoise?redirectedFrom=fulltext","title":"Regional-Scale Patterns in Harbour Porpoise Occupancy of Tidal Stream Environments","description":"As harbour porpoises Phocoena phocoena are abundant within tidal stream environments, mitigating population-level impacts from tidal stream energy extraction is considered a conservation priority. An understanding of their spatial and temporal occupancy of these habitats at a regional-scale will help steer installations towards locations which maximize energy returns but reduce the potential for interactions with populations. This study quantifies and compares relationships between the presence of harbour porpoise and several hydrodynamic characteristics across four tidal stream environments in Anglesey, UK\u2014a region that has been earmarked for extensive industrial development. Within sites (0.57\u20131.13\u2009km2), encounters with animals were concentrated in small areas (\u0026lt;200 m2) and increased during certain tidal states (ebb vs. flood). In sites showing relatively high maximum current speeds (2.67\u20132.87\u2009ms\u22121), encounters were strongly associated with the emergence of shear-lines. In sites with relatively low maximum current speeds (1.70\u20132.08\u2009ms\u22121), encounters were more associated with areas of shallow water during peak current speeds. The overall probability of encounters was higher in low current sites. It is suggested that the likelihood of interactions could be reduced by restricting developments to sites with high maximum current speeds (\u0026gt;2.5\u2009ms\u22121), and placing turbines in areas of laminar currents therein. This study shows that a combination of local and regional hydrodynamic characteristics can partially explain variations in occupancy patterns across tidal-stream environments. However, it was found that such hydrodynamic characteristics could not comprehensively explain these occupancy patterns. Further studies into the biophysical mechanisms creating foraging opportunities within these habitats are needed to identify alternative explanatory variables that may have universal applications.","author":["Evans, P.","Waggitt, J.","Scott, B.","Robins, P.","Veneruso, G.","Piano, M.","Dunn, H.","Hiddink, J.","Holmes, L.","Keen, E.","Murcott, B.","Whitmore, J."],"organization":["Bangor University","Sea Watch Foundation"],"originationDate":"2018-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2187","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/dtbird-system-pilot-installation-sweden-possibilities-bird-monitoring-systems-around","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.dtbird.com\/images\/Downloads\/Ecocom-AB-Report-with-summary-translated.pdf","title":"DTBird System Pilot Installation in Sweden. Possibilities for Bird Monitoring Systems around Wind Farms. Experiences from Sweden\u0027s First DTBird Installation","description":"DTBird\u2019s monitoring system is used today on wind turbine farms in a number of European countries but to date, DTBird installations and similar technical systems have not been used in Sweden.  In order to keep pace with continual investment in renewable energy in Sweden \u2013 where wind power is widely used \u2013 it is all the more important to look at the possibilities on offer to reduce the effects of wind turbines on avifauna. Against the problematical background that wind turbines kill birds, in 2015 Ecocom, in collaboration Vindform, initiated a pilot project 1) to install and showcase the DTBird system, and 2) to evaluate how the DTBird system performs under Swedish conditions. Part 1 of the project comprised a presentation and seminar on two occasions in Lundsbrunn during the course of 2015, where wind turbine designers, authorities and law practitioners were invited. Part 2 of the project, that comprises evaluation of the pilot installation, is reviewed in this report.  Within the framework of the pilot project, a DTBird System 1 was set up at a wind turbine near Lundsbrunn in Sweden. During July-September 2015, i.e. during the breeding and migration period of birds, data was collected from the system to be subsequently analysed.  Testing recorded how effective the DTBird system was in warning away birds from the wind turbine and therefore from the collision risk area, from how far away the warning sound can be heard and whether the installed system on the wind turbine in Lundsbrunn was observed to disturb breeding birds or was deemed to have a negative effect by local residents. The total system activation time has also been recorded and therefore energy production loss that wind turbine stoppages would have led to.  The attached is an English translation of the Swedish summary.","author":["Eriksson, M.","Litsg\u00e5rd, F.","Wizelius, T.","S\u00e4fstr\u00f6m, T."],"organization":["Liquen Consultoria Ambiental"],"originationDate":"2016-12-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/dtbird-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2188","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-detection-species-classification-time-lapse-images-around-wind-farm-dataset","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/we.2135\/abstract","title":"Bird Detection and Species Classification with Time-Lapse Images around a Wind Farm: Dataset Construction and Evaluation","description":"Collisions of birds, especially endangered species, with wind turbines is a major environmental concern. Automatic bird monitoring can be of aid in resolving the issue, particularly in environmental risk assessments and real-time collision avoidance. For automatic recognition of birds in images, a clean, detailed, and realistic dataset to learn features and classifiers is crucial for any machine-learning-based method. Here, we constructed a bird image dataset that is derived from the actual environment of a wind farm and that is useful for examining realistic challenges in bird recognition in practice. It consists of high-resolution images covering a wide monitoring area around a turbine. The birds captured in these images are at relatively low resolution and are hierarchically labeled by experts for fine-grained species classification. We conducted evaluations of state-of-the-art image recognition methods by using this dataset. The evaluations revealed that a deep-learning-based method and a simpler traditional learning method were almost equally successful at detection, while the former captures more generalized features. The most promising results were provided by the deep-learning-based method in classification. The best methods in our experiments recorded a 0.98 true positive rate for bird detection at a false positive rate of 0.05 and a 0.85 true positive rate for species classification at a false positive rate of 0.1.","author":["Yoshihashi, R.","Kawakami, R.","Iida, M.","Naemura, T."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2189","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mooring-system-considerations-renewable-energy-standards","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.onepetro.org\/conference-paper\/OTC-27870-MS","title":"Mooring System Considerations for Renewable Energy Standards","description":"Marine renewables have made great strides in recent years. The IEC, ABS, and DNV GL continue to generate standards and recommended practices in an effort to formulate approved processes as the renewable products make their way offshore and into the market. There are many similarities in some of the processes and designs when compared to oil and gas structures, especially when it comes to moorings. However, many design areas are uniquely related to renewables, even within the same field of energy conversion (e.g. multiple types of wave energy converters). As more renewable systems are installed, the standards will continue to transition from philosophical to more prescriptive recommendations. One area in which the lines are blurred between oil and gas and renewable industries is mooring systems. The interdependency between the mooring and power generation systems plays a crucial role early in the design phase. Modeling marine energy converters and the mooring system can be complex due the variability of moving parts, and without proper attention, it may be easy to underestimate the loads and fatigue cycles to which moorings will be exposed. Moorings for these structures should incorporate existing standards and recommended practices to ensure safety and reliability. Inspection, maintenance, repair, and replacement should also be considered. As the renewable industry continues to move forward from scaled prototypes to farms of devices, the oil and gas supply chain will contemplate when to become involved from a financial and resource perspective. However, there are still hurdles within the US authorization bodies like BSEE, BOEM, FERC, NOAA, USCG, etc. to overcome. This paper addresses the existing mooring related standards and delineates areas that need further refinement or conservatism as the renewable industry moves forward with the installation of offshore energy converters.","author":["Cribbs, A.","K\u00e4rrsten, G.","Shelton, J.","Nicoll, R.","Stewart, W."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-05-04","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2190","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-killer-industrial-intruder-or-clean-energy-perceiving-risks-ecosystem-services","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0921800916313854","title":"Bird Killer, Industrial Intruder or Clean Energy? Perceiving Risks to Ecosystem Services Due to an Offshore Wind Farm","description":"Proposals to develop renewable energy technologies may threaten local values, which can generate opposition. Efforts to explain this opposition have focused on perceived negative aesthetic and environmental impact. Less attention has been paid to a fuller suite of the perceived risks and benefits associated with new energy technologies. This paper thus investigates impacts of an offshore wind farm pertaining to individual perceptions and judgments, and why risks to some ecosystem services might be cause for greater public concern than others. We find that this difference can be attributed to the affective and intuitive ways in which people perceive risk. Our mixed-methods design used interviews (n\u00a0=\u00a027) that involved risk-benefit weighting tasks and an animated visualization to help people imagine an offshore wind farm in a familiar place. We found that affectively-loaded impacts (harm to charismatic wildlife and visual intrusion) were assigned greater weight than more easily quantifiable impacts (displacement of fishing, impact to tourism, cost of compliance with regulations). Interviewees identified increased regional energy self-sufficiency as the most valued potential benefit of an offshore wind farm. These results have implications for ecosystem service assessments generally and, more specifically, for our understanding of \u2018affective\u2019 dimensions of development proposals.","author":["Chan, K.","Ellis, J.","Klain, S.","Satterfield, T.","Sinner, J."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","University of British Columbia","Cawthron Institute","King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST)"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2191","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-baseline-conditions-ecological-indicators-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X17304284","title":"Modeling Baseline Conditions of Ecological Indicators: Marine Renewable Energy Environmental Monitoring","description":"Ecological indicators are often collected to detect and monitor environmental change. Statistical models are used to estimate natural variability, pre-existing trends, and environmental predictors of baseline indicator conditions. Establishing standard models for baseline characterization is critical to the effective design and implementation of environmental monitoring programs. An anthropogenic activity that requires monitoring is the development of Marine Renewable Energy sites. Currently, there are no standards for the analysis of environmental monitoring data for these development sites. Marine Renewable Energy monitoring data are used as a case study to develop and apply a model evaluation to establish best practices for characterizing baseline ecological indicator data. We examined a range of models, including six generalized regression models, four time series models, and three nonparametric models. Because monitoring data are not always normally distributed, we evaluated model ability to characterize normal and non-normal data using hydroacoustic metrics that serve as proxies for ecological indicator data. The nonparametric support vector regression and random forest models, and parametric state-space time series models generally were the most accurate in interpolating the normal metric data. Support vector regression and state-space models best interpolated the non-normally distributed data. If parametric results are preferred, then state-space models are the most robust for baseline characterization. Evaluation of a wide range of models provides a comprehensive characterization of the case study data, and highlights advantages of models rarely used in Marine Renewable Energy environmental monitoring. Our model findings are relevant for any ecological indicator data with similar properties, and the evaluation approach is applicable to any monitoring program.","author":["Horne, J.","Ward, E.","Linder, H."],"organization":["University of Washington","National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2192","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effect-offshore-wind-farm-viviparous-eelpout-biometrics-brood-development-population","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X17305253","title":"Effect of an Offshore Wind Farm on the Viviparous Eelpout: Biometrics, Brood Development and Population Studies in Lillgrund, Sweden","description":"Sufficient, clean and secure energy is the main driver for a worldwide growing welfare and economic development of a society. Environmental concerns on the expansion of offshore renewable energy and its impact on marine organisms need to be scientifically assessed for risks and consequences. In order to observe the effects of an operating wind farm on fish, we studied the rather stationary and benthic-living fish species viviparous eelpout (Zoarces viviparous) as model indicator organisms. We compared local populations of viviparous eelpout in the Lillgrund Offshore Wind Farm (OWF) with natural sites in the \u00d6resund strait in Sweden. Eelpout studies on population dynamics, biometrics, reproductive success and fry development were conducted in 2011 and 2012. Condition index, histosomatic index, gonadosomatic index were measured additionally. Our findings showed that Lillgrund OWF neither had an impact on the condition index (CI), nor on brood development of female viviparous eelpout. Furthermore, populations size estimates in Lillgrund indicated that eelpout neither specifically aggregated in nor avoided the offshore wind farm, and no clear reef effect attracting eelpout to the foundations and scour protections of the OWF was observed. Our conclusion is that the operating wind farm did not have any potentially negative effects, since we did not observe any negative effects neither on the individual health of eelpout nor of the reproductive performance. We suggest that eelpout which may also be used as an indicator species for the environmental status of Lillgrund, as well as for other offshore wind farms and marine renewable energy installations, both in the Baltic and coastal waters in northern Europe.","author":["Langhamer, O.","Dahlgren, T.","Rosenqvist, G."],"organization":["Chalmers University of Technology","Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)","University of Gothenburg","Uni Research AS"],"originationDate":"2018-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.516667000000","12.783333000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2193","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/value-proposition-tidal-energy-development-nova-scotia-atlantic-canada-canada","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.oera.ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2015\/04\/Value-Proposition-FINAL-REPORT_April-21-2015.pdf","title":"Value Proposition for Tidal Energy Development in Nova Scotia, Atlantic Canada and Canada","description":"This report was produced on behalf of the Offshore Energy Research Association of Nova Scotia (OERA) to provide government and industry with a clear understanding of the value proposition for tidal energy in Canada, including the opportunities and challenges of creating a supply chain for a future tidal energy industry.\n\nThe main objective of the report is to produce a comprehensive assessment of the value proposition for tidal energy that provides an estimate of the potential value, broader benefits and potential economic impacts of tidal power development to Nova Scotia, the Atlantic Region and Canada. Meeting this objective requires casting the net widely for relevant information and lessons learned.\u00a0","author":["Johnson, K.","Karsten, R.","Kerr, S.","MacDougall, S.","Taylor, J.","Gardner, M.","MacAskill, G.","Maillet, S.","Fitzharris, J."],"organization":["Gardner Pinfold Consultants Inc.","Acadia Tidal Energy Institute","Offshore Energy Research Association of Nova Scotia (OERA)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-21","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gardner-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2194","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/funding-financial-supports-tidal-energy-development-nova-scotia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/netzeroatlantic.ca\/research\/funding-and-financial-supports-tidal-energy-development-nova-scotia","title":"Funding and Financial Supports for Tidal Energy Development in Nova Scotia","description":"Within the global tidal energy industry, companies are now undertaking activities related to technology demonstration and demonstration of arrays. In Nova Scotia, at FORCE, demonstration arrays are planned by berth-holders. The costs of developing tidal energy are large and private, while the potential benefits are not only private but societal and environmental as well. Accordingly, provincial and federal governments have a role to play while the costs and risks at this stage are a barrier to progress.  In Scotland and France, where full-scale devices are being deployed and small arrays demonstrated, the funding and financial supports are largely a combination of demonstration grants and price supports through feed-in tariffs or renewables credits. The grants are not only for demonstrations of TEC devices but also of array-enabling technologies. While Nova Scotia\u2019s feed-tariff has been effective in attracting international developers to FORCE berths, for all but the largest companies, a feed-in tariff alone will likely be insufficient support for getting devices and arrays in the Bay of Fundy. A package of capital grants and price supports are needed, as well as continued investments in infrastructure.  Federal agencies and departments needed as partners are ACOA, SDTC, BDC, EDC, Innovation Science Economic Development Canada, and Natural Resources Canada. In Nova Scotia, the Department of Business and Consumer Services, and Nova Scotia Business Inc. have roles to play. These organizations should be engaged early to gain experience in the tidal energy industry and will need to draw on the knowledge of experts in industry, academia, investment and insurance in the design and oversight of project funding.","author":["MacDougall, S."],"organization":["Acadia Tidal Energy Institute"],"originationDate":"2016-09-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.371491900000","-64.405218000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MacDougall_et_al_2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2195","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/confronting-financing-impasse-risk-management-through-internationally-staged","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166917300267","title":"Confronting the Financing Impasse: Risk Management through Internationally Staged Investments in Tidal Energy Development","description":"Progress toward commercial deployment of in-stream tidal energy devices and commercial arrays has frequently met with delays, particularly in the UK and Canada. While some delays are due to the manifestation of the uncertainties inherent in new technology development, this study seeks to better understand the strategic timing decisions of tidal energy conversion companies in developing a globally-distributed renewable resource. The study consists of semi-structured interviews with executives and senior managers of organizations in the international tidal energy industry. Themes emerging from the interviews find companies manage risk by timing their investments across an international portfolio of seabed leases, consistent with the exercise of real options.","author":["MacDougall, S."],"organization":["Acadia University"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2196","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/licensing-guidance-marine-renewable-energy-projects-portugal-mainland-coast","sourceURL":"","title":"Licensing Guidance for Marine Renewable Energy Projects in Portugal (Mainland Coast)","description":"The complexity of the licensing process of Marine Renewable Energy (MRE) projects is indicated world- wide as one of the main barriers to the sector development. The reasons for this barrier are attached, among others, to the lack of clarity of procedures (arising from the lack of specific laws for this type of projects), to the varied number of authorities to be consulted and to the process delay. Understanding the factors that consider licensing as a barrier, as well as the discussion of the necessary measures to minimise their effects on the sector implementation in several Member States, have been some of the topics explored in various European-funded projects. This analysis has been based on the description of the licensing process in several countries in order to identify differences and similarities, advantages and disadvantages and good or better practices to streamline the process.  This Guide was partially funded by the RiCORE project and results from an in-depth study conducted in one of the project tasks, more specifically regarding report 2.2 (Le Li\u00e8vre \u0026amp; O\u2019Hagan, 2016), which presents and discusses licensing processes in several European countries. This project was funded by the European Commission under the HORIZON 2020 programme and it is aimed at establishing an environ- mental licensing approach, based on the risk assessment of MRE technologies. This approach has already been successfully implemented in Scotland and can be summed up in the use of information about the natural sensitiveness of the location and project scale to be installed in order to define the level of re- quirements needed for the environmental studies.  The findings of the aforementioned report include an assessment of the efforts made by the countries represented in the project consortium (Spain, France, Ireland, Portugual and United Kingdom) on the measures adopted to improve licensing processes. These can be summarised in the following aspects:    Improved operation of the single platforms or offices to managed the licensing process (the so-called one-stop-shop);  Better integration of the licensing procedures in order to minimise the process fragmentation and centralise decisions;  Introduction of a timeline for the various procedures and a maximum period of time for the all licensing process, taking into account the scale of the project;  Development and provision (in institutional websites) of guidance documents explaining the licensing process in order to instruct their intervening parties.   Throughout the RiCORE project, several workshops were held to discuss the implementation of the environmental licensing risk-based approach in the countries under the project consortium. Represent- atives from several EU Member States have been invited, regarding the areas of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) consultancy, marine environment research (academy), industry (device developers) and public administration (regulators). This Guidance has been developed as a consequence of the need identified by some of the national stakeholders, who together with WavEC, have joined efforts to com- pile the information presented herein.  The authors believe this document contributes to clarify the licensing process of MRE technologies in Portugal, as well as making it more expedient, since good or better practices are proposed throughout the document.  This document also had the engagement of a group of authorities and colleagues with relevant expertise in the field, some of whom with direct intervention in the licensing process that promptly offered them- selves to review and validate the document. Given the constant evolution of legal systems, the aim is to update the present information whenever significant change in the law may occur.","author":["Simas, T.","de Jesus, J.","Almodovar, M."],"organization":["WavEC Offshore Renewables","WavEC Offshore Renewables"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.740799000000","-8.219166400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wavec-Licensing-Guidance-Portgal-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2197","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecological-monitoring-using-wildlife-detection-dogs-bat-carcass-searches-wanlip-wind","sourceURL":"","title":"Ecological Monitoring using Wildlife Detection Dogs: Bat Carcass Searches at the Wanlip Wind Turbine","description":"Planning permission is often conditional upon postconstruction, ecological monitoring of wind turbine developments to assess impacts on wildlife. Ecological monitoring at wind turbines frequently focuses on bird and bat carcass searches, which in some cases can be carried out more effectively and efficiently using wildlife detection dogs. This article describes the use of wildlife detection dogs to identify bat carcasses at Wanlip wind turbine, demonstrating the value of this novel monitoring option as an effective method to be used alongside other ecological monitoring methods.","author":["Stanhope, K."],"organization":["Atkins"],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.691000000000","-1.115000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Stanthorpe-2015-InPractice.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2198","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reintroduction-white-tailed-eagles-republic-ireland-case-study-media-coverage","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/271341027_Reintroduction_of_white-tailed_eagles_to_the_Republic_of_Ireland_A_case_study_of_media_coverage","title":"Reintroduction of White-Tailed Eagles to the Republic of Ireland: A Case Study of Media Coverage","description":"Media can be important in the success or failure of conservation projects. This study examined newspaper coverage of the white-tailed eagle reintroduction to the Republic of Ireland to examine public awareness and attitudes towards the project, and the resultant influence on changes to national legislation and the likely success of the project in the future. National, local newspaper and a special-interest farming newspaper articles, from 2007-2011, were categorised as \u2018positive\u2019, \u2018negative\u2019 or \u2018ambiguous\u2019 according to their portrayal of eagles. Media coverage in terms of the number and valence of articles published is discussed in the context of key events during the study period, namely poisoning incidents, increased stakeholder engagement and changes to national legislation. The eagles received considerable newspaper coverage: most articles were in 2007, the first year of white-tailed eagle reintroduction, and 2010, when the issue of poisoning was finally addressed in Irish legislation. Articles were mostly positive while project staff engaged with media throughout the study period providing updates, condemning poisonings and responding to misinformation published. The future prospects for the project seemed positive, with appropriate newspaper coverage and information relating to legislative changes to benefit white-tailed eagles and several other species.","author":["Smith, S.","McMahon, B.","Burke, B.","Finna, A.","Flanagan, D.","Fogarty, D.","Foran, M.","O\u0027Sullivan, J.","Linnell, J."],"organization":["University College Dublin","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)"],"originationDate":"2014-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.146635900000","-7.732121000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2199","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reintroduction-white-tailed-eagles-haliaeetus-albicilla-ireland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/317318909_Reintroduction_of_White-tailed_Eagles_Haliaeetus_albicilla_to_Ireland","title":"Reintroduction of White-tailed Eagles Haliaeetus albicilla to Ireland","description":"White-tailed Eagles Haliaeetus albicilla were extirpated as a breeding species in Ireland in the early 20th century following decades of population decline due to human persecution. Preparatory studies including population modelling, site selection and identification of a donor population, resulted in the initiation of a reintroduction programme for the species in the Republic of Ireland. Between 2007 and 2011 one hundred young White-tailed Eagles (51 males and 49 females) were collected from nests in Norway under licence and transported to Ireland for release in Killarney National Park, Co. Kerry. Birds were held for 6-10 weeks before release. Wing-tags and radio and\/or GPS satellite transmitters were attached to birds for individual identification and tracking post-release. Birds tended to remain in the Killarney area for the first few months after release, moving away in late winter but remaining in south Kerry. Most birds dispersed in spring, tending to return towards the \u2018natal\u2019 area in autumn. First pairing occurred in 2010 when birds were still sub-adults. First nesting took place in 2012 with chicks fledged successfully in 2013. The number of territorial pairs increased rapidly but declined after 2014 with the loss of some adult birds. However, the number of breeding pairs and the number of young fledged continues to increase, with 14 chicks fledged to date. Comparisons with the first phase of the Scottish west coast reintroduction suggest that the outlook for the Irish population is reasonably optimistic. Illegal poisoning (64% of known mortalities) has had a serious impact on population growth and continues to threaten the viability of the reintroduction programme.","author":["Mee, A.","Breen, D.","Clarke, D.","Heardman, C.","Lyden, J.","McMahon, F.","O\u0027Sullivan, P.","O\u0027Toole, L."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.146635900000","-7.732121000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2200","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-bird-strike-mortality-irish-onshore-windfarms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.academia.edu\/12918710\/A_Review_of_Bird_Strike_Mortality_at_Irish_Onshore_Windfarms","title":"A Review of Bird Strike Mortality at Irish Onshore Windfarms","description":"This article reviews bird strikes at Irish onshore windfarms based largely upon unpublished accounts and expert opinion. The level of carcass searching is estimated and the effectiveness of carcass searching methodologies is assessed. A standardised method for carcass searching is recommended for Ireland and the UK.","author":["Fennelly, R."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.535197200000","-6.242927300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fennelly-2015-In-Practice-Magazine.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2201","type":["Document","Document\/Magazine Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/conflict-greens-green-development-versus-habitat-preservation-case-incheon-south-korea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.environmentmagazine.org\/archives\/back%20issues\/2011\/may-june%202011\/conflict-of-greens-full.html","title":"A Conflict of Greens: Green Development Versus Habitat Preservation - The Case of Incheon, South Korea","description":"Boosting the green economy is a goal for many nations, but not all agree on what \u201cgreen\u201d means. In this paper, we discuss the conflict between two green approaches: \u201cgreen development\u201d (highlighted by what would be the world\u0027s largest tidal power barrages (Incheon Bay and Ganghwa tidal power plants) and the sustainable award-winning new green city development in Incheon, South Korea) and \u201chabitat preservation\u201d for endangered birds. Given the crisis of climate change and dependence on fossil fuels, this conflict of \u201cgreens\u201d will increasingly occur around the world, so we discuss the implications for prudent policy-making and planning in comparable cases.\n\n*Due to the controversy on socioeconomic and environmental concerns, the plans for the Incheon Bay and Ganghwa tidal power plants were halted in 2012.","author":["Ko, Y.","Schubert, D.","Hester, R."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.422077500000","128.079841000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2202","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/south-koreas-plans-tidal-power-when-green-solution-creates-more-problems","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nautilus.org\/napsnet\/napsnet-special-reports\/south-koreas-plans-for-tidal-power-when-a-green-solution-creates-more-problems\/","title":"South Korea\u0027s Plans for Tidal Power: When a \u0022Green\u0022 Solution Creates More Problems","description":"The authors introduce a fierce controversy between large-scale tidal barrage power and the local efforts toward preserving wetlands and fisheries in Incheon, South Korea. Due to the controversy on socioeconomic and environmental concerns, the plans for the Incheon Bay and Ganghwa tidal power plants were halted in 2012.","author":["Ko, Y.","Schubert, D."],"organization":["Nautilus Institute","Nautilus Institute"],"originationDate":"2011-11-29","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.422077500000","128.079841000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-06 06:28:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ko_and_Schubert_2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2203","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seabird-ecology-high-energy-environments-approaches-assessing-impacts-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/theses.gla.ac.uk\/8300\/1\/2017robbinsph.pdf","title":"Seabird Ecology in High-Energy Environments: Approaches to Assessing Impacts of Marine Renewables","description":"It has been widely acknowledged that a global change in energy production, from fossil fuels to renewable sources, is required in order to reduce carbon dioxide outputs and help mitigate anthropogenic climate change. The UK is recognised as having one of the largest practical marine energy resources in Europe, including \u2018wet renewables\u2019 energy sources; tidal-stream and wave energy. Scotland, as well as having some of the best marine energy resources, also holds internationally important numbers of breeding seabirds. Both wave energy and tidal stream devices have the potential to place a new anthropogenic pressure on already declining seabird populations. Wet renewables are predicted to impact seabird populations through collision, disturbance, habitat loss and changes to food availability. However, few devices have been deployed to enable monitoring of impacts and there have been few studies of the ecological implications and magnitude of any impacts to these populations. The aim of this thesis is to address key knowledge gaps relating to our understanding of seabird ecology in high-energy marine environments, specifically exploring spatial, temporal and habitat drivers for their use of these areas. This is to help expand the scientific basis used to assess the impacts of marine renewable energy devices on marine birds. This thesis also aims to increase our understanding of bird survey requirements for wet renewable energy schemes to help develop methods for environmental impact assessment. Chapters 2, 3 and 4 demonstrate that marine birds show differing spatial and temporal patterns of abundance and behaviour within high-energy marine environments. By using shore-based vantage point methods in three high-energy areas in the Northern Isles, I explore some variations in vantage point methods. Chapter 5 provides the most extensive and up-to-date review of diving and foraging behaviour for UK marine bird species. I identify knowledge gaps including the species and parameters for which there are a paucity of studies. I demonstrate a more robust approach to data collection in these high-energy tidal stream, which can shed insight on how they are being used by marine birds, while the diving and foraging behaviour synthesis provided many of the values that are required to undertake underwater collision risk modeling. It is hoped that developers can adopt the approaches identified here, which will improve the accuracy of their assessments and improve monitoring of any potential impacts.","author":["Robbins, A."],"organization":["University of Glasgow"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.686171600000","-0.993284400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2204","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/observations-tracking-killer-whales-orcinus-orca-shore-based-x-band-marine-radar","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/mms.12395\/full","title":"Observations and Tracking of Killer Whales (Orcinus orca) with Shore-Based X-Band Marine Radar at a Marine Energy Test Site","description":"The Atlantic killer whale (Orcinus orca) is a top-level marine predator with a global range, being found in all of Earth\u0027s oceans. The potential interaction between killer whales and marine renewable energy projects requires surveillance and monitoring efforts that call for new technologies, with marine radar showing promise in the field. Marine radar images recorded at the European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) were used to track a pair of male killer whales undertaking Surface Active Behavior (SAB) with visual observations used as validation. Using a tidal prediction model, the tide-adjusted, radar-derived target speeds between SAB events provide estimates of swim speeds averaging 4 m\/s and time between SAB events of 30 s. The similarities between the radar signatures of the animals and sea clutter, combined with their low occurrence compared to other imaged phenomena renders automatic detection with this system difficult. However, the combination of opportunistic radar imagery and independent visual observation has allowed the radar signature of one form of killer whale SAB to be documented. It is hoped that with a greater number of validated observations such as these that automated, radar-based identification and the benefits it will bring to long-term observations at MRE sites will be possible.","author":["Bell, P.","McCann, D."],"organization":["National Oceanography Centre (NOC)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.156000000000","-7.484000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2205","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/patterns-benthic-mega-invertebrate-habitat-associations-pacific-northwest-continental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10531-016-1158-y","title":"Patterns of Benthic Mega-Invertebrate Habitat Associations in the Pacific Northwest Continental Shelf Waters: A Reassessment","description":"As human impacts and demands for ocean space increase (fisheries, aquaculture, marine reserves, renewable energy), identification of marine habitats hosting sensitive biological assemblages has become a priority. Epifaunal invertebrates, especially the structure-forming species, are an increasing conservation concern as many traditional (bottom-contact fishing) and novel (marine renewable energy) ocean uses have the potential to displace or otherwise impact these slow-growing organisms. The differences in mega-invertebrate species assemblages between high-relief rocks and low-relief sediments are well documented and likely hold for most marine environments. In anticipation of potential development of marine renewable energy faculties off Oregon and Washington (USA), a survey of the benthic invertebrate assemblages and habitats was conducted on three rocky reefs on the continental shelf of the Pacific Northwest, using video footage collected by remotely operated vehicle, to more finely characterize these assemblage\u2013habitat associations. Benthic assemblages appeared to first group by depth (50\u201380 vs. 100\u2013120\u00a0m), then by relief (consolidated rocks vs. unconsolidated rocks and soft sediments). Consolidated rocks were characterized at each site by a combination of various sponges, gorgonians, sea anemones and echinoderms; unconsolidated rocks were characterized at Grays Bank by sea anemones and burrowing brittle stars, and at Bandon-Arago by sponges and echinoderms; soft sediments were characterized at Grays Bank and Siltcoos Reef by sea whips and burrowing brittle stars, as well as pink shrimps and sea stars at Siltcoos Reef, and at Bandon-Arago by sponges, gorgonians and echinoderms. The results of this study will help classify and map the seafloor in a way that represents benthic habitats reflective of biological species assemblage distributions, rather than solely geological features, and support conservation and management planning.","author":["Henkel, S.","Hemery, L."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2016-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.965147300000","-124.434208300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2206","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/patterns-benthic-mega-invertebrate-habitat-associations-pacific-northwest-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/276345284_Patterns_of_benthic_mega-invertebrate_habitat_associations_in_the_Pacific_Northwest_continental_shelf_waters","title":"Patterns of Benthic Mega-Invertebrate Habitat Associations in the Pacific Northwest Continental Shelf Waters","description":"As human impacts and demands for ocean space increase (fisheries, aquaculture, marine reserves, renewable energy), identification of marine habitats hosting sensitive biological assemblages has become a priority. Epifaunal invertebrates, especially the structure-forming species, are an increasing conservation concern as many traditional (bottom-contact fishing) and novel (marine renewable energy) ocean uses have the potential to displace or otherwise impact these slow-growing organisms. The differences in mega-invertebrate species assemblages between high-relief rocks and low-relief sediments are well documented and likely hold for most marine environments. In anticipation of potential development of marine renewable energy faculties off Oregon and Washington (USA), a survey of the benthic invertebrate assemblages and habitats was conducted on the continental shelf of the Pacific Northwest, using video footage collected by ROV, to more finely characterize these assemblage\u2013habitat associations. Four main associations were found: pure mud\/sand dominated by sea whips and burrowing brittle stars; mixed mud\u2013rock (which may be further divided based on size of mixed-in rocks) characterized by various taxa at small densities; consolidated rocks characterized by high diversity and density of sessile or motile mega-invertebrates; and rubble rocks showing less diversity and density than the consolidated rocks, possibly due to the disturbance generated by movement of the unconsolidated rocks. The results of this study will help classify and map the seafloor in a way that represents benthic habitats reflective of biological species assemblage distributions, rather than solely geological features, and support conservation and management planning.","author":["Henkel, S.","Hemery, L."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2015-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.965147300000","-124.434208300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Hemery-Henkel-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2207","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bridging-gap-between-energy-environment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301421516300386","title":"Bridging the Gap Between Energy and the Environment","description":"Meeting the world\u2019s energy demand is a major challenge for society over the coming century. To identify the most sustainable energy pathways to meet this demand, analysis of energy systems on which policy is based must move beyond the current primary focus on carbon to include a broad range of ecosystem services on which human well-being depends. Incorporation of a broad set of ecosystem services into the design of energy policy will differentiates between energy technology options to identify policy options that reconcile national and international obligations to address climate change and the loss of biodiversity and ecosystem services. In this paper we consider our current understanding of the implications of energy systems for ecosystem services and identify key elements of an assessment. Analysis must consider the full life cycle of energy systems, the territorial and international footprint, use a consistent ecosystem service framework that incorporates the value of both market and non-market goods, and consider the spatial and temporal dynamics of both the energy and environmental system. While significant methodological challenges exist, the approach we detail can provide the holistic view of energy and ecosystem services interactions required to inform the future of global energy policy.","author":["Smith, P.","Thomas, A.","Beaumont, N.","Hooper, T.","Austen, M.","Papathanasopoulou, E.","Cazenave, P.","Torres, R.","Scott, K.","Tickner, R.","Taylor, G.","Holland, R.","Hinton, E.","Barrett, J.","Blaber-Wegg, T.","Brown, G.","Carter-Silk, E.","Eigenbrod, F.","Hiscock, K.","Lovett, A."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory","Imperial College London","University of Aberdeen","University of Southampton","University of East Anglia","University of Leeds"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Holland-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2208","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-potential-risk-marine-mammals-collision-tidal-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166917300590","title":"Understanding the Potential Risk to Marine Mammals from Collision with Tidal Turbines","description":"Many marine mammal populations worldwide are in decline due to stresses from climate change and interactions with anthropogenic activities such as fishing, coastal construction petroleum extraction, and commercial shipping. The advent of the marine renewable energy industry has raised questions, particularly for tidal turbines. However, it is technically very difficult to observe close interactions of marine mammals and underwater turbines, and the likelihood of viewing a rare event such as a collision, is very small. This research seeks to understand the potential risk to a marine mammal from the presence of a tidal turbine by examining the sequence of behavioral events that could lead to a potential collision with the turbine, and the likely consequences to the marine mammal if such a collision were to occur. We examine this potential risk within the context of the physical environment into which a turbine might be deployed, and the attributes of one tidal device, and investigate the biomechanical properties of a marine mammal that may allow the animal to resist injury from a tidal blade collision. The data examined in this research (likelihood of a marine mammal being in close proximity to a tidal turbine, biomechanics of marine mammal tissues, and engineering models) provide insight into the interaction.","author":["Copping, A.","Grear, M.","Jepsen, R.","Chartrand, C.","Gorton, A."],"organization":["Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)","Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2209","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wildlife-impacts-public-attitudes-towards-small-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/dspace.stir.ac.uk\/bitstream\/1893\/22894\/1\/Thesis_final.pdf","title":"Wildlife Impacts of and Public Attitudes Towards Small Wind Turbines","description":"Global wind power generation has grown rapidly in response to targets to reduce greenhouse gas emissions as part of efforts to mitigate climate change, and to increase energy security. While much of the focus in wind energy technology to date has been on wind farms, a relatively recent development is the expansion of the micro-wind sector (turbines generating \u003C 100 kW), and there are now over 870,000 small wind turbines (SWTs) installed globally. However, official planning guidance for SWTs in the UK and elsewhere is lacking. This may be a barrier to SWT installations if there is confusion over the requirements to gain planning permission.\n\nOne reason for the lack of planning guidance is that our understanding of the wildlife impacts of SWTs is limited and therefore it is difficult to make recommendations for their mitigation. There are a range of potential negative effects wind power can exert on wildlife, in particular on birds and bats, yet to date, there has been very little published research into the wildlife impacts of SWTs. Mortality rates of wildlife at SWTs appear to be relatively low, but disturbance of bats, highly protected species, near SWTs has been previously demonstrated. However, the extent (if any) of this disturbance at habitat features of known importance was unclear. Therefore this thesis used acoustic surveys of bat activity to quantify disturbance of use of linear features (e.g. hedgerows, treelines), habitat important to bats for commuting and foraging, caused by SWTs. Firstly, bat activity did decline after experimental installation of SWTs 5m away from linear features. This decline was species-specific with Pipistrellus pygmaeus showing declines in activity in close proximity to the SWT associated with SWT operation, while P. pipistrellus activity declined in response to installation both at the SWT site and 30m away. Secondly, bat use of linear features is lower when SWTs are located nearby. In particular, P. pygmaeus activity at linear features is lower the closer a SWT is to the feature, and at high wind speeds Myotis spp. use of linear features is similarly lower where SWTs are located nearby. This disturbance did not dissipate along the linear features away from the SWT for at least 60m. This is much further than previously documented disturbance of bats by SWTs, which appeared fairly localised, and may be due to the importance of linear features specifically for commuting between habitat fragments. If so, the cumulative impacts of such disturbance will be important in areas where suitable foraging and roosting habitats is limited and fragmented, and linear features suitable for commuting between habitat fragments are already rare. These results offer support for recommendations that SWTs should be subject to siting restrictions that create a buffer distance between them and important bat habitats such as linear features. Specifically, iv this thesis recommends that in landscapes with few alternative commuting routes or where particularly rare bat species are present SWT installations require buffer distances to ensure they are a minimum of 60m away from linear features.\n\nThere has also been a lack of research into public attitudes towards SWTs, despite local attitudes towards wind farm developments having been linked to planning outcomes, implying attitudes can be a barrier to installations. This thesis presents the results of the first survey of public attitudes specifically towards SWTs. Generally attitudes towards SWTs were positive, with over half of respondents rating SWTs as acceptable across a range of landscape settings. However, as for wind power where public attitudes in general are positive but local wind farm developments may still face opposition, only 35% of respondents were in favour of having a SWT installed in sight of their home. A key finding of this survey was that acceptance of SWTs significantly differed between landscape settings, with those in hedgerows and gardens being less well accepted compared to those on road signs, buildings and fields. Respondent comments highlighted visual impacts, efficient use of technology, noise impacts, wildlife impacts and educational value as important factors in their decisions regarding SWT acceptability. Public concern about wildlife impacts appears to be responsive to context, being important to the lower acceptance of SWTs in hedgerows, which were perceived to be particularly risky for wildlife. Potential SWT owners are also shown to be concerned about wildlife impacts from SWTs. Using a choice experiment methodology, an economics technique that allows valuation of non-market goods, farmers (a group most likely to own SWTs in the UK) were found to be willing-to-pay, through loss of SWT earnings from electricity generation, to avoid disturbance of birds and bats or collision mortality of bats. These findings also support the recommendation of the use of buffer distances for SWTs. Buffer distances between SWTs and linear features will help to alleviate public and SWT owner concerns about wildlife impacts, and also increase public acceptance of SWTs by encouraging their installation away from some of the least accepted landscape settings such as hedgerows. Further, potential SWT owners were also found to have no significant preference for avoiding siting restrictions of SWT installations,suggesting they are open to the use of buffer distances, although the suggested distances were substantially smaller than those this thesis ultimately recommends.\n\nThe findings presented in this thesis have implications for planning guidance, policy makers and developers, but also raise many questions that will require further study. A list of planning v guidance recommendations and a list of recommendations for future SWT research are presented in the final section.","author":["Tatchley, C."],"organization":["University of Stirling"],"originationDate":"2015-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.144097000000","-3.921529000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2210","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/comparing-bird-bat-fatality-rate-estimates-among-north-american-wind-energy-projects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/wsb.260\/abstract","title":"Comparing bird and bat fatality-rate estimates among North American wind-energy projects","description":"Estimates of bird and bat fatalities are often made at wind-energy projects to assess impacts by comparing them with other fatality estimates. Many fatality estimates have been made across North America, but they have varied greatly in field and analytical methods, monitoring duration, and in the size and height of the wind turbines monitored for fatalities, and few benefited from scientific peer review. To improve comparability among estimates, I reviewed available reports of fatality monitoring at wind-energy projects throughout North America, and I applied a common estimator and 3 adjustment factors to data collected from these reports. To adjust fatality estimates for proportions of carcasses not found during routine monitoring, I used national averages from hundreds of carcass placement trials intended to characterize scavenger removal and searcher detection rates, and I relied on patterns of carcass distance from wind turbines to develop an adjustment for variation in maximum search radius around wind turbines mounted on various tower heights. Adjusted fatality rates correlated inversely with wind-turbine size for all raptors as a group across the United States, and for all birds as a group within the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area, California. I estimated 888,000 bat and 573,000 bird fatalities\/year (including 83,000 raptor fatalities) at 51,630 megawatt (MW) of installed wind-energy capacity in the United States in 2012. As wind energy continues to expand, there is urgent need to improve fatality monitoring methods, especially in the implementation of detection trials, which should be more realistically incorporated into routine monitoring.","author":["Smallwood, S."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-03-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.195748400000","-123.763605000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:32","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2211","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-impact-small-scale-wind-energy-proposals-natural-heritage","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/sites\/default\/files\/2017-09\/Guidance%20note%20-%20Assessing%20the%20impact%20of%20small-scale%20wind%20energy%20proposals%20on%20the%20natural%20heritage.pdf","title":"Assessing the Impact of Small-Scale Wind Energy Proposals on the Natural Heritage","description":"Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) view groups of three or fewer wind turbines with an o utput greater than 50kW to be \u2018small-scale wind energy\u2019, even when the turbines themselves might be quite large. This small-scale wind energy development makes a valuable contribution to managing climate change, but it is important to ensure that it happens in the right places and that natural heritage impacts are minimised. There is however a limit to the engagement SNH is able to have with individual small-scale wind energy proposals, and this will normally be restricted to proposals that require an Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), or where a protected area is likely to be affected (see our Service Statement for Planning \u0026amp; Development). This guidance aims to help applic ants and planning authorities consider the natural heritage impact of small-scale wind energy proposals without the need for direct input from SNH. The guidance seeks to promote a consistent and proportionate level of assessment, but ultimately it is for the planning authority to determine what is required. In some locations this may differ from what we suggest. For smaller wind energy development of less than 50kW, please refer to our guidance on micro-renewables.","author":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.671214800000","-9.169611200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SNH-2016-V3.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2212","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-framework-predict-bat-activity-patterns-wind-farms-outline-possible","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969716328133","title":"A modelling framework to predict bat activity patterns on wind farms: An outline of possible applications on mountain ridges of North Portugal","description":"Worldwide ecological impact assessments of wind farms have gathered relevant information on bat activity patterns. Since conventional bat study methods require intensive field work, the prediction of bat activity might prove useful by anticipating activity patterns and estimating attractiveness concomitant with the wind farm location. A novel framework was developed, based on the stochastic dynamic methodology (StDM) principles, to predict bat activity on mountain ridges with wind farms. We illustrate the framework application using regional data from North Portugal by merging information from several environmental monitoring programmes associated with diverse wind energy facilities that enable integrating the multifactorial influences of meteorological conditions, land cover and geographical variables on bat activity patterns. Output from this innovative methodology can anticipate episodes of exceptional bat activity, which, if correlated with collision probability, can be used to guide wind farm management strategy such as halting wind turbines during hazardous periods. If properly calibrated with regional gradients of environmental variables from mountain ridges with windfarms, the proposed methodology can be used as a complementary tool in environmental impact assessments and ecological monitoring, using predicted bat activity to assist decision making concerning the future location of wind farms and the implementation of effective mitigation measures.","author":["Santos, M.","Cabral, J.","Silva, C.","Hughes, S."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.539768000000","-10.096205300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2213","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/factors-influencing-carcass-removal-wind-farms-mountain-areas-center-north-region","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/311681536_FACTORS_INFLUENCING_CARCASS_REMOVAL_AT_WIND-FARMS_IN_MOUNTAIN_AREAS_OF_THE_CENTER-NORTH_REGION_OF_PORTUGAL","title":"Factors influencing carcass removal at wind-farms, in mountain areas of the center-north region of Portugal","description":"Bat fatalities are frequently associated with wind-farms. The methodology commonly used to estimate this mortality includes trials to determine the removal rate of carcasses by scavengers.","author":["Silva, B.","Barreiro, S.","Alves, P."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2008-08-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.539768000000","-10.096205300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2214","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/appropriate-assessment-plans-projects-croatian-national-ecological-network-utilization","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cww2011.nina.no\/Portals\/cww2011\/DynamicForms_Uploads\/53f95094-6241-46d2-b4d8-b9775710e5ca.pdf","title":"Appropriate assessment of plans and projects for Croatian National Ecological Network - utilization of bird and bat impact zonation in the southern coastal part of Croatia","description":"Croatia in the process of accession to European Union established the National Ecological Network and Appropriate Assessment procedure. The National Ecological Network covers the areas of Croatia that have been identified as areas of importance for conservation or establishment of a favorable status of threatened and rare habitat types and\/or wild taxa at the European (Birds Directive and the Habitats Directive and Bern Convention) and national level. No wind farm can be built if it is not planned in spatial plan. Due to this reason, numerous locations were put into spatial plans to reserve potential location. Although these locations of wind farms are only potential, huge number of planned locations represent a big threat to biodiversity of Croatia, first of all to birds of prey and bats, which are groups of animals most endangered from wind farms (direct collision, barotrauma, alteration of flight path etc.). In the process of issuing building permits each wind farm has to pass Nature Impact Assesment (Appropriate Assessment) procedure for National Ecological Network, which is a part of Environmental Impact Assessment. For the purpose of helping authorities in the screening process, project COAST* engaged experts for birds and bats to prepare zonation maps of the COAST area.","author":["Schneider, D.","Trenc, N.","Ivi\u010di\u0107, B.","Pavlini\u0107, I.","Peternel, H.","Radovi\u0107, D."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.453334500000","14.226014000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/schneider-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2215","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-may-eat-diurnal-flies-rest-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1616504716300027","title":"Bats May Eat Diurnal Flies that Rest on Wind Turbines","description":"Bats are currently killed in large numbers at wind turbines worldwide, but the ultimate reason why this happens remains poorly understood. One hypothesis is that bats visit wind turbines to feed on insects exposed at the turbine towers. We used single molecule next generation DNA sequencing to identify stomach contents of 18 bats of four species (Pipistrellus pygmaeus,\u00a0Nyctalus noctula,\u00a0Eptesicus nilssonii\u00a0and\u00a0Vespertilio murinus) found dead under wind turbines in southern Sweden. Stomach contents were diverse but included typically diurnal flies, e.g. blow-flies (Calliphoridae), flesh-flies (Sarcophagidae) and houseflies (Muscidae) and also several flightless taxa. Such prey items were eaten by all bat species and at all wind turbine localities and it seems possible that they had been captured at or near the surface of the turbines at night. Using sticky traps, we documented an abundance of swarming (diurnal) ants (Myrmica\u00a0spp.) and sometimes blow-flies and houseflies at the nacelle house. Near the base of the tower the catches were more diverse and corresponded better with the taxa found in the bat stomachs, including various diurnal flies. To evaluate if flies and other insects resting on the surface of a wind turbine are available to bats, we ensonified a house fly (Musca) on a smooth (plastic) surface with synthetic ultrasonic pulses of the frequencies used by the bat species that we had sampled. The experiment revealed potentially useful echoes, provided the attack angle was low and the frequency high (50\u201375\u00a0kHz). Hence resting flies and other arthropods can probably be detected by echolocating bats on the surface of a wind turbine. Our findings are consistent with published observations of the behavior of bats at wind turbines and may actually explain the function of some of these behaviors.","author":["Rydell, J.","Bogdanowicz, W.","Boonman, A.","Pomorski, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["60.246558400000","12.053105000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2216","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-activity-small-wind-turbine-baltic-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3161\/15081109ACC2015.17.2.011?journalCode=acta","title":"Bat Activity at a Small Wind Turbine in the Baltic Sea","description":"Activity of bats at an old wind park four km off the island of Gotland in the Baltic Sea was monitored during 50 nights from August to October 2013, using an automatic bat detector (Pettersson D500-X) mounted on one of the turbines. Single individuals or pairs of common noctules Nyctalus noctula were recorded on five occasions only (26 and 27 August), all in calm weather and when little or no rotor movement occurred. Since such conditions were unusual (five of 50 nights of observation) the visits by the bats were unlikely to be chance events (migrating bats passing the turbine), but more likely involved bats attracted to the turbines. However, no feeding buzzes were recorded and the bats never stayed near the turbine more than one minute. The turbines studied are lit by 250 W white lights and this could have been the reason why bats visited the turbines, because such lights potentially attract insects. The bats could not have been attracted to the turbines by any factor related of the movement of the rotor or the generator, such as Doppler-effects, noise, heat or electric fields.","author":["Rydell, J.","Wickman, A."],"organization":["Lund University"],"originationDate":"2015-10-30","spatial":{"coordinates":["57.416881900000","18.043770400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2217","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reedsport-opt-wave-park-settlement-agreement","sourceURL":"","title":"Reedsport OPT Wave Park Settlement Agreement","description":"The Parties have entered into this Agreement for the purposes of (1) resolving all issues that have or could have been raised by the Parties in connection with a FERC order issuing a License for construcation and operation of the Proejct, including in part through agreement on an adaptive management process that the Parties will use to address uncertainties, and (2) agreeing to use an adaptive managment process to identify and implement additional studies that may be required pursuant to the Federal Power Act (\u0022FPA\u0022) to evaluate a potential future application for an Expanded Project. Therefore, pursuant to the Parties\u0027 various authorities under the FPA as well as other statutory and regulatory authorities, this Agreement establishes the Company\u0027s obligations for the protection, mitigation, and enhancement of resources that may be affected by the Project under the License or procedures for determining those obligations, and it establishes the Parties\u0027 agreement on a process for identifying and implementing studies to be conducted or funded by the Company in relation to a future application for an Expanded Project.","author":["Ocean Power Technologies (OPT)"],"organization":["Ocean Power Technologies (OPT)"],"originationDate":"2010-07-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.782500000000","-124.238060000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OPT-2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2218","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/habitat-use-bats-relation-wind-turbines-revealed-gps-tracking","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/pmc\/articles\/PMC4931514\/","title":"Habitat use of bats in relation to wind turbines revealed by GPS tracking","description":"Worldwide, many countries aim at countering global climate change by promoting renewable energy. Yet, recent studies highlight that so-called green energy, such as wind energy, may come at environmental costs, for example when wind turbines kill birds and bats. Using miniaturized GPS loggers, we studied how an open-space foraging bat with high collision risk with wind turbines, the common noctule Nyctalus noctula(Schreber, 1774), interacts with wind turbines. We compared actual flight trajectories to correlated random walks to identify habitat variables explaining the movements of bats. Both sexes preferred wetlands but used conventionally managed cropland less than expected based on availability. During midsummer, females traversed the land on relatively long flight paths and repeatedly came close to wind turbines. Their flight heights above ground suggested a high risk of colliding with wind turbines. In contrast, males recorded in early summer commuted straight between roosts and foraging areas and overall flew lower than the operating range of most turbine blades, suggesting a lower collision risk. Flight heights of bats suggest that during summer the risk of collision with wind turbines was high for most studied bats at the majority of currently installed wind turbines. For siting of wind parks, preferred bat habitats and commuting routes should be identified and avoided.","author":["Kramer-Schadt, S.","Voigt, C.","Roeleke, M.","Yovel, Y.","Blohm, T."],"organization":["Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","Tel Aviv University"],"originationDate":"2016-07-04","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.085324500000","5.968598700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Roeleke-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2219","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cobscook-bay-tidal-energy-project-2015-environmental-monitoring-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/orpc.co\/storage\/2022\/02\/2015-Environmental-Monitoring-Report.pdf","title":"Cobscook Bay Tidal Energy Project: 2015 Environmental Monitoring Report","description":"ORPC Maine, LLC, a wholly-owned subsidiary of Ocean Renewable Power Company, LLC, (collectively, ORPC), is a Maine-based developer of hydrokinetic power systems and projects that harness the power of oceans and rivers to generate clean, predictable renewable energy. In partnership with coastal and river communities, ORPC works to create and sustain local jobs while promoting energy independence and protecting the environment. ORPC received a pilot project license for the Cobscook Bay Tidal Energy Project (Project) from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) on February 27, 2012 (FERC Project No. P-12711-005). The purpose of the Project is to evaluate the potential for a new source of clean, renewable energy generation using tidal energy resources in Cobscook Bay, Maine. ORPC obtained a preliminary permit for the Project area in Cobscook Bay from FERC on July 23, 2007; FERC issued a successive preliminary permit on January 13, 2011. Feasibility studies, including environmental surveys, and pre-filing consultation were conducted, resulting in ORPC\u2019s filing of a draft pilot project license application with FERC on July 24, 2009 and subsequently, the final pilot project license application in September 2011. The FERC pilot project license boundary for the Project encompasses the proposed development area (Figure 1). In March 2012, ORPC began construction of the Project off the coast of Eastport and Lubec, Maine (Figure 1). Following installation of the initial phase of the Project during the spring and summer of 2012, the Project began delivering electricity to the Emera Maine grid in September 2012. This is the first grid-connected installation of ORPC\u2019s TidGen\u00ae Power System.","author":["ORPC Maine"],"organization":["Ocean Renewable Power Company (ORPC)"],"originationDate":"2016-03-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.914400000000","-67.051400000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-22 03:46:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ORPC-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2220","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-automated-risk-management-tool-minimize-bird-bat-mortality-wind-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s13280-015-0707-z","title":"Developing an automated risk management tool to minimize bird and bat mortality at wind facilities","description":"A scarcity of baseline data is a significant barrier to understanding and mitigating potential impacts of offshore development on birds and bats. Difficult and sometimes unpredictable conditions coupled with high expense make gathering such data a challenge. The Acoustic and Thermographic Offshore Monitoring (ATOM) system combines thermal imaging with acoustic and ultrasound sensors to continuously monitor bird and bat abundance, flight height, direction, and speed. ATOM\u2019s development and potential capabilities are discussed, and illustrated using onshore and offshore test data obtained over 16\u00a0months in the eastern USA. Offshore deployment demonstrated birds tending to fly into winds and activity declining sharply in winds\u00a0\u003E10\u00a0km\u00a0h\u22121. Passerines showed distinct seasonal changes in flight bearing and flew higher than non-passerines. ATOM data could be used to automatically shut down wind turbines to minimize collision mortality while simultaneously providing information for modeling activity in relation to weather and season.","author":["Willmott, J.","Forcey, G.","Hooton, L."],"organization":["Normandeau Associates Inc"],"originationDate":"2015-10-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["31.907516800000","-82.360267700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Willmott-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2221","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/measurement-effect-power-absorption-lee-wave-energy-converter","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=1624600","title":"Measurement of the Effect of Power Absorption in the Lee of a Wave Energy Converter","description":"Monitoring the effect of floating wave energy converter (WEC) devices on the surrounding wave field will be an important tool for monitoring impacts on the local wave climate and coastlines. Measurement will be hampered by the natural variability of ocean waves and the complex response of WEC devices, causing temporal and spatial variability in the effects. Measurements taken during wave tank tests at MARINTEK are used to analyse the effectiveness of point wave measurements at resolving the influence of an array of WEC on the local wave conditions. The variability of waves is measured in front and in the lee of a device, using spectral analysis to identify changes to the incident wave field due to the operating WEC. The power capture and radiation damping are analysed in order to predict the measured changes. Differences in the wave field across the device are clearly observable in the frequency domain. However, they do not unanimously show a reduction in wave energy in the lee of a device and are not well predicted by measured power capture.","author":["Johanning, L.","Ashton, I.","Linfoot, B."],"organization":["University of Exeter","Heriot-Watt University"],"originationDate":"2009-06-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2222","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-electromagnetic-em-fields-em-sensitive-animals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-94-017-8002-5_6","title":"Marine Renewable Energy, Electromagnetic (EM) Fields and EM-Sensitive Animals","description":"In the marine environment there are natural magnetic and electric fields associated with both physical and biological sources, and there are anthropogenic electromagnetic fields (EMFs) that permeate it. Many marine animals can detect electric and magnetic fields and utilize them in such important life processes as movement, orientation and foraging. Here, these EMFs are explored and discussed in terms of how they arise, their properties (particularly those that are measurable) and the animals that have the ability to detect them. Then the evidence base for whether anthropogenic EMFs can affect sensitive receptor animals is explored. As marine renewable energy developments (MREDs) expand rapidly worldwide, with multiple devices and networks of subsea cables that emit EMFs into the marine environment, it is necessary to focus on their interaction with marine animals. The MRED industry has to take EMFs into account, so the industry perspective is also covered. Finally, suggestions are made on how research on EMFs associated with MREDs (and other sources) and its interaction with marine animals should advance in future.\n\nThis is a\u00a0chapter from Humanity and the Sea: Marine Renewable Energy Technology and Environmental Interactions.","author":["Sigray, P.","Gill, A.","Gloyne-Philips, I.","Kimber, J."],"organization":["Cranfield University","Centre for Marine and Coastal Studies Ltd (CMACS)","FOI (Swedish Defence Research Agency)"],"originationDate":"2014-02-13","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2223","type":["Document","Document\/Webpage"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nova-scotia-tidal-energy-atlas","sourceURL":"https:\/\/tidalenergy.acadiau.ca\/ns-tidal-energy-web-map.html","title":"Nova Scotia Tidal Energy Atlas","description":"The Nova Scotia Tidal Energy Atlas is an interactive web mapping application that makes tidal energy related spatial information readily accessible to the public and provides online tools to allow users to interact with the data. Tidal energy-related spatial data collected to date represents work conducted in various projects and regions within the Bay of Fundy. These studies support the developing industry through risk reduction and informed decision making. Several of the reports from these studies can be found on the Offshore Energy Research Association of Nova Scotia (OERA) and the Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE) websites. Much of the data available for the tidal energy industry in Nova Scotia is in the form of lengthy technical reports and large data sets housed by numerous institutions. Accessing information for technical analysis, business development and community engagement requires extensive exploration. To overcome this challenge, these otherwise disparate sets are being successfully combined, displayed and manipulated in the Nova Scotia Tidal Energy Atlas.  Background  An existing web mapping application, Assessment of Energy Production Potential from Tidal Streams in the United States created by Georgia Tech was referenced as a starting point for developing a web mapping application for tidal energy in Nova Scotia. A proof-of-concept for the Nova Scotia Tidal Energy Atlas was developed by FORCE, the Acadia Tidal Energy Institute and Tekmap Consulting in the spring of 2014 with seed funding from OERA. The aim was to build a decision-making tool that integrates complex spatial information of importance to the tidal energy industry. In 2015, the Acadia Tidal Energy Institute, in partnership with Atlantic Canada Opportunities Agency, Nova Scotia Department of Energy, Offshore Energy Research Association, Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy and Tekmap Consulting continued development of the proof-of-concept to bring it to a level of readiness for government, industry and public use. The Nova Scotia Tidal Energy Atlas was made publically available in March 2016. The project aims to make accessible a range of geospatial data associated with tidal energy projects in the Bay of Fundy and to serve as a tool for making quantitative assessments at potential turbine deployment locations. To provide a flexible, expandable tool for tidal energy assessment, Tekmap Consulting chose open source technology. Using open source software allows for future project growth and development, with the addition of more data and assessment tools. To store and deliver the data, the robust Geoserver software provides the Web Mapping Services. The Geoserver software is fully compliant with the Open Geospatial Consortium (OGC). The Heron Mapping Client provides the map display and processing tools for this project. The mapping client is built upon existing open source technologies including: OpenLayers and the GeoExt JavaScript toolkit. The flexibility of this open source software allows for the development of new tools including the Tidal Scoring Interface. The Tidal Scoring Interface provides a powerful geospatial query tool, allowing users to extract and display tidal power model data.","author":["Acadia Tidal Energy Institute","Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)","TEKMap Consulting"],"organization":["Acadia Tidal Energy Institute","Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.290569300000","-65.275903200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2224","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/implications-tidal-energy-extraction-sedimentary-processes-within-shallow-intertidal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/netzeroatlantic.ca\/research\/implications-tidal-energy-extraction-sedimentary-processes-within-shallow-intertidal","title":"Implications of Tidal Energy Extraction on Sedimentary Processes within Shallow Intertidal Environments","description":"Sediments are the primary determinants of biological activity in the upper Bay of Fundy. Gaining an understanding of their behavior under varying environmental and energy conditions will provide a critical baseline to model anticipated effects of tidal energy extraction on sensitive intertidal ecosystems such as tidal flats and salt marshes. For example, changes in tidal energy or tidal range can induce changes in hydrodynamic forces, the structure and location of biotic communities and rates of sedimentation and erosion. These changes are most likely to be felt within intertidal communities at the upper reaches of the vertical influence of the tides. Since the processes of sedimentation and erosion are spatially and temporally variable, field data are required over a range of suspended sediment concentrations, current velocities, water depths, topographies, biotic communities (e.g. vegetation and benthos) and wind-wave energy. Any potential energy extraction or change in the tidal range will exert an influence on sediment dynamics within the system. However the magnitude of the change in intertidal areas is currently unknown and may or may not occur within a range of natural variability therefore it is vital to model these processes over a range of environmental conditions.  The purpose of this research project is to assess the implications of tidal energy extraction on sedimentary processes within shallow intertidal ecosystems. We specifically address OERA \u2019s research priority area regarding the relationships between tidal energy extraction and inshore areas (e.g. tidal creeks, marshes, intertidal flats). While previous modelling and field validation efforts have been able to resolve hydrodynamic and sedimentary processes at the basin scale (Smith and Mulligan, 2010), we focus on processes within the relatively shallow upper intertidal zone to gather much needed insight into hydrodynamics over smaller scale and ecologically sensitive areas. Our previous field work has already confirmed significant spatial and temporal variability in sedimentary processes between tidal creek and exposed salt marsh\/mudflat ecosystems (van Proosdij et al. 2010). The additional data in this project have helped to refine preliminary empirical relationships including seasonal variability in processes, particularly suspended sediment concentration and sediment composition (e.g. grain size and floc fraction).  This study significantly advances our understanding of the seasonal variability in intertidal ecomorphodynamics: the interaction and adjustment of topography, vegetation, fluid and hydrodynamic processes, morphologies and sequence of change dynamics involving the movement of sediment. In addition, it provides the first numerical model in the Bay of Fundy that effectively integrates near and far field hydrodynamic processes and serves as an important step towards three-dimensional modelling the full impacts of tidal energy extraction in these important ecosystems.  In the field study, the seasonal control on deposition was strongest in the channel, seen at the creek and marsh bank stations. At these two stations, deposition and suspended sediment concentration were higher and this occurred in the winter, because of rapid deposition from high sediment supply. On the high marsh, the amount of sediment in floc form decreased and the seasonal control was less prominent. The period of October to February was the most active period in terms of high suspended sediment concentrations and sediment re-suspension. Episodic events with strong winds and heavy rainfall were effective at changing the grain size distribution of deposited sediment, this re-suspension also changing the characteristics of the sediment in suspension and therefore the incoming sediment on following tidal cycles. In addition, these episodic events appear to play an important role in maintaining equilibrium and a balanced annual sediment budget within the salt marsh tidal creek channel. However, this study also demonstrates that using only one scale of data (e.g. tidal cycle versus seasonal GIS digital elevation models) may lead to an in accurate estimation of the sediment budget, and more accurate sediment budgets should be developed by integrating over broad spatial and temporal scales.  The three-dimensional high-resolution hydrodynamic model (Delft3D) was used to simulate tidal currents and water levels, calibrated using acoustic observations over multiple tidal cycles in the intertidal zone at Kingsport. Using a system of three interconnected model domains at increasing resolution toward the intertidal zone, high resolution of the salt marsh and drainage channels was attained. A vegetation model that incorporated stem height, diameter and density was implemented and the resulting vegetation was determined to be crucial in reproducing currents in the marsh. A simulation that included turbines in Minas Passage was developed, representing the 2 .5 GW of tidal power extraction. The test produce d a 3.5% ( 0.2 m ) tidal amplitude decrease within the Kingsport marsh, suggesting that turbines may have impacts on intertidal water level elevations and inundation times. Future work will address sediment dynamics, tidal currents and surface waves in June 2013, corresponding to the dataset collected during the CCGS Hudson research cruise in Minas Basin.  The numerical model was also used to simulate the combined effects of surface waves, tidal currents and sediments with results indicating that storm events have major impacts on sediment transport, with winds that generate fetch-limited surface waves. The waves are important for re-suspension over the shallow tidal flats in the basin, by inducing wave orbital velocities at the seabed that in addition to tidal currents, create strong shear stresses on the bed. The results indicate that locally generated wind waves, can vary significantly over seasonal timescales, contributing up to 1-5 Nm-2 to the bottom shear stresses on tidal flats. The added shear stress due to waves leads to increased erosion of the tidal flats around the rim of the basin and increases the suspended sediment concentrations by 100-200 gm-3 in intertidal areas and by 10-20 gm-3 in deeper areas of the basin, representing a doubling in concentration in these areas. Predicting sediment transport processes in macrotidal environments is therefore de pendant on accurate simulation of the combined tidal flow and surface wave field properties.  The results of this project add tremendous value to industry and government partners involved in the Fundy FORCE initiative, but also build on two successful OERA projects led by Danika van Proosdij in collaboration with Peter Smith (Bedford Institute of Oceanography) and Ryan Mulligan (Queen\u2019s University). In addition, it contributes directly to building local capacity in environmental effects monitoring and model ling by enriching our baseline data sets, adopting leading edge technologies and, providing \u201creal world\u201d training grounds for young scientists in Canada. This project was the foundation for training two bright young scholars at the Masters level: Emma Poirier at Saint Mary\u2019s University and Logan Ashall at Queen\u2019s University. An additional three undergraduate research assistants were trained in the field within the In_CoaST research unit. All team members have presented at regional, national and international conferences, disseminating our research widely and numerous papers will be submitted to referred journals in the near future. We have demonstrated that our team has taken full advantage of OERA \u2019s funding opportunity. By building on previous project investments and acquiring new data at key sites, we have developed a high resolution hydrodynamic model allowing us to integrate the field and model results that will help simulate anticipated TISEC installations while minimizing environmental impacts. Continuing work develop a combined wave\/current\/ sediment transport model that can be used to investigate the impacts of turbines on ecologically sensitive intertidal areas. Finally, the project results will benefit Nova Scotians by serving as a baseline that can be used to understand whether or not future changes associated with commercial scale tidal power generating structures in the Minas Passage are outside the range of natural variability of stressors that intertidal ecosystems have adequate resilience to respond.","author":["Mulligan, R.","van Proosdij, D.","Ashall, L.","Poirier, E."],"organization":["Saint Mary\u0027s University","Queens University"],"originationDate":"2013-03-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.346288900000","-64.390584800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Van-Proosdij-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2225","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fundy-ocean-research-centre-energy-force-environmental-assessment-addendum-report","sourceURL":"","title":"Fundy Ocean Research Centre for Energy (FORCE) Environmental Assessment Addendum to the Report: Environmental Assessment Registration Document - Fundy Tidal Energy Demonstration Project, Volumes 1 and 2","description":"The Fundy Ocean Research Centre for Energy (FORCE; the Proponent) will construct, operate and decommission a Tidal Energy Demonstration Facility in the Minas Passage, near Parrsboro, Nova Scotia (Figure 1-1).  The Project consists of multiple subsea turbine generators, subsea cables connecting the turbines to land-based infrastructure, an onshore transformer substation, and power lines connecting to the local power distribution system. The Project was assessed under a joint federal \u2013 provincial Environmental Assessment (EA) review process and was subject to federal and provincial environmental approval in accordance with the following legislation:    Canadian Environmental Assessment Act (CEAA): pursuant to Section 5(1)(d) of CEAA, Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO) and Transport Canada (TC) were required to issue permits to enable the Project to proceed; and  Environmental Assessment Regulations: pursuant to Schedule A of the provincial regulations under the Environment Act, registration as a Class 1 Undertaking was required.   The Project received EA approval on September 15, 2009. The Proponent, as part of the EA approval for the Project, was required to meet Terms and Conditions, provided by Nova Scotia Environment (NSE). The Terms and Conditions for EA Approval are included in Appendix A of this EA Addendum Report. Since the Project was approved, construction began with installation of the first turbine on November 12, 2009 by Nova Scotia Power Inc., and commencement of land-based facilities in February 2010.  In January 2010, Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) awarded funding for the Project through the federal Clean Energy Fund (CEF) Program. In accordance to Section 5(1)(b) of the CEAA, NRCan is required to conduct a screening level environmental assessment of the Project prior to releasing funds. It is understood that the scope of NRCan\u2018s assessment will include all aspects of the Project as proposed, including those aspects approved in September 2009. Furthermore, it is understood that NRCan will prepare an Environmental Screening Report based on the original environmental assessment, plus new information gathered in the Project area since 2009.  As a result of negotiations with landowners, the location of the landfall and land-based facilities has changed from what was originally proposed and approved in the Environmental Assessment Registration Document \u2013 Fundy Tidal Energy Demonstration Project (AECOM 2009). Subsequently, the Nova Scotia Department of Energy asked FORCE to develop a fourth subsea grid connected berth within the approved Crown Lease area. This EA Addendum Report has been prepared to support NRCan\u2018s environmental assessment process, describe the changes to the Project, and assesses any potential environmental effects that may arise as a result of the changes. The Province of Nova Scotia was advised of the location changes in a letter to Mr. Peter Geddes of Nova Scotia Environment, dated February 5, 2010, and was advised of the Department of Energy\u2018s request for a fourth berth in a letter to Mr. Peter Geddes dated July 7, 2010. A copy of relevant correspondence is provided in Appendix B. The combined total production rating of the four turbines will remain below 5.0 MW, the limit for a Canadian Environmental Assessment Act Screening Level EA.  In addition to describing and assessing changes to the Project, this EA Addendum Report also summarizes the supplementary baseline studies that have been conducted since the September 2009 approval. The additional studies are appended to this report.  This EA Addendum Report is organized to describe the changes to the Project and to reflect the process by which the assessment of the changes has been conducted. This report does not include a discussion or assessment of the proposed Parrsboro Power Transmission Line Project as the study is still underway and it will be filed separately later this summer.    Section 1.0 introduces the Project, provides a brief history, and describes the need for the EA Addendum Report.  Section 2.0 describes the changes to the Project from what was originally proposed and approved including changes to location, components, activities, emissions and discharges and potential malfunctions and accidental events, as appropriate.  Section 3.0 describes the existing terrestrial, marine and socio-economic characteristics of the new location for the landfall and land-based facilities.  Section 4 .0 provides the results of the environmental effects assessment for the valued environmental components (VECs) affected by the Project changes.  A summary of the EA Addendum Report and conclusions are presented in Section 5 .0.  A summary of additional \/ post-EA studies is provided in Section 6.0 and a copy of the studies are appended to this Report.  Section 7 .0 details literature and personal communications cited in the report.   Given that changes to the Project are limited to the addition of a fourth berth and cable and moving the location of landfall 200 m east of the original site, re-assessment of cumulative environmental effects and effects of the environment on the Project is not warranted.","author":["AECOM"],"organization":["AECOM","Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"originationDate":"2010-07-22","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.369760000000","-64.402540000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/AECOM-Addendum-Report-2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2226","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-beliefs-support-offshore-wind-energy-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117302478","title":"Ocean Beliefs and Support for an Offshore Wind Energy Project","description":"Wind turbines located in the ocean contribute to the ongoing global transition to renewable sources of electricity, but further expansion of this technology will depend as much on social acceptance as on technological know-how. This article explores how underlying values and beliefs about the ocean influence public support for offshore wind energy. An intercept survey was conducted with more than 600 individuals on Block Island, site of the first offshore wind farm in the United States. Following a values-beliefs-norm framework, this survey measured respondents\u0027 underlying values, anticipated impacts of the proposed wind energy project, attachment to the island, and beliefs about the ocean. The results indicate that ocean beliefs and underlying values have direct and indirect associations with expectations and support for an offshore wind energy project development. These findings provide insights into objections that arise over offshore wind farms, by acknowledging that the probability of conflict increases when one interpretation of the marine environment is imposed on people holding different beliefs about the ocean. Understanding these dynamics and integrating them into planning dialogues may be critical for successfully navigating the broader energy transition.\n\nInterest in producing electricity from alternative sources (i.e., not from fossil fuels) has grown dramatically in recent years. It is widely acknowledged that a wider transition to renewable energy technologies is as much a social challenge as a technical one (Szarka, 2004; W\u00fcstenhagen et al., 2007), and public opposition is viewed as a significant barrier to specific projects. Motivated in part by a promise of reduced social conflict (Haggett, 2008, 2011), several countries have prioritized the development of wind farms (i.e., interconnected clusters of electricity-producing turbines) in the ocean. Support for moving this technology offshore is far from universal, however, and some of these projects face opposition from local and regional interests.\n\nA broad literature examines the factors that contribute to or diminish public support for renewable energy technologies. Much of this literature focuses on wind energy, perhaps because it is a highly visible and increasingly common renewable energy technology (Devine-Wright, 2008). Researchers have identified several contributors to public attitudes towards both on- and offshore wind-energy projects, including concerns about environmental and economic impacts of projects, as well as trust in developers and other institutional factors. One theme that has received a great deal of recent attention is the role of public perceptions of and relationships with the places where these projects are sited. Much of this work has focused on place attachment, positing that individuals reject projects that threaten place-based identities. Other authors have asked whether the ocean is a place with special symbolic value, which may further influence attitudes towards offshore projects (Gee, 2010; Wiersma and Devine-Wright, 2014).\n\nThis article seeks to understand how beliefs about the ocean influence public support for offshore wind energy. In it, I report results from a survey of more than 600 individuals contacted in public locations on Block Island, site of the first offshore wind farm in the United States. Following an established theoretical perspective from environmental sociology, the values-beliefs-norm framework (Stern et al., 1995), this survey measured the importance of respondents\u0027 underlying values (guiding principles), beliefs regarding likely impacts of the proposed wind energy project, attachment to the island, and beliefs about the ocean. The results indicate that ocean beliefs and underlying values have direct and indirect associations with expectations and support for an offshore wind energy project. These findings provide insights into how public beliefs about the ocean affect beliefs about the project and, ultimately, project support or opposition. They also provide further insights on conflicts that arise over offshore wind farm siting, acknowledging that conflicts may arise when one interpretation of the marine environment is given preference over others. Understanding these dynamics and integrating them into planning dialogues are critical for navigating the broader energy transition.","author":["Bidwell, D."],"organization":["University of Rhode Island"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2227","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/two-dimensional-thermal-video-analysis-offshore-bird-bat-flight","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1574954115001478","title":"Two-Dimensional Thermal Video Analysis of Offshore Bird and Bat Flight","description":"Thermal infrared video can provide essential information about bird and bat activity for risk assessment studies, but the analysis of recorded video can be time-consuming and may not extract all of the available information. Automated processing makes continuous monitoring over extended periods of time feasible, and maximizes the information provided by video. This is especially important for collecting data in remote locations that are difficult for human observers to access, such as proposed offshore wind turbine sites. We developed new processing algorithms for single camera thermal video that automate the extraction of two-dimensional bird and bat flight tracks, and that characterize the extracted tracks to support animal identification and behavior inference. The algorithms consist of video peak store followed by background masking and perceptual grouping to extract flight tracks. The extracted tracks are automatically quantified in terms that could then be used to infer animal taxonomy and possibly behavior, as described in the companion article from Cullinan, et al. [\u201cClassification of birds and bats using flight tracks.\u201d Ecological Informatics, 27:55\u201363]. The developed automated processing was evaluated using six video clips containing a total of 184 flight tracks. The detection rate was 81% and the false positive rate was 17%. In addition to describing the details of the algorithms, we suggest models for interpreting thermal imaging information.","author":["Matzner, S.","Cullinan, V.","Duberstein, C."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2015-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Matzner-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2228","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/phase-ii-cumulative-effects-framework-final-report","sourceURL":"","title":"Phase II Cumulative Effects Framework Final Report","description":"Phase 2 of the development of the Cumulative Effects Framework (Framework) accomplished several critical objectives. First, the \u201csensitivities\u201d that were identified in Phase 1 were organized around an ecological function and ecosystem services framework, which facilitated communication and provided a more coherent structure. Second, the link between the data used and the scoring of the functions and services being evaluated was made more explicit through development of clear concept models. Third, concept models were used as a means of structuring dialogue with relevant stakeholders on several of the important functions within the system. This provided valuable feedback and greater consensus on how functions and services are being measured. The device suitability models are a particular example of this. Fourth, the data being used within the system was updated and improved.\n\nThe Framework also evolved considerably in unanticipated directions to adapt to circumstances during Phase 2 of the project. Phase 2 evolved in two distinct ways. First, two versions of the Framework were developed: the original RADMAPP version of the Framework, which is intended to provide easy access for stakeholders; and an ESRI-based version with expanded analytical capabilities that is intended for expert users. Second, the focus of system refinement shifted to updating conceptual models for siting wave energy devices in an economically constrained context. These changes made the tool much more relevant to the ongoing Territorial Sea Planning (TSP) process.\n\nWe anticipate that the Framework will continue to evolve as the context in which it is most often used and the nature of the questions it seeks to inform become clearer. To gain greater understanding of these issues, the next phase of Framework development will require completing a case study to test the tool based on a given scenario, and use the results of the modeling analysis to identify areas within the Territorial Sea that, if developed for wave energy, would result in the greatest change and\/or generate the most impact. This case study is critical to testing the cumulative effect tool\u2019s ability to assist wave energy developers in making better choices for siting and operating wave energy facility development and operation.","author":["Halsey, K.","Radil, A."],"organization":["Parametrix","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)"],"originationDate":"2012-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OWETCumulativeEffectsAnalysisFramework.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2229","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/putting-pieces-together-alternatives-analysis-decision-support","sourceURL":"","title":"Putting the Pieces Together: Alternatives Analysis and Decision Support","description":"The OWET Cumulative Effects Analysis Framework is a multi-criteria decision making tool for evaluating the potential impacts of various ocean renewable energy technologies. The tool is designed to provide decision makers, stakeholders and the public more information about the potential impacts associated with various development scenarios. The tool includes three main parts: data library of applicable resource data; resource and development interaction database; and a user interface that combines the data and interaction to allow for alternatives analysis. The final product is a GIS tool for assessing various development scenarios and the potential impacts and benefits.","author":["Halsey, K.","Manson, P."],"organization":["Parametrix"],"originationDate":"2012-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OWETAlternativesAnalysisDecisionSupport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2230","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/developing-novel-risk-based-methodology-multi-criteria-decision-making-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148116309193","title":"Developing a Novel Risk-Based Methodology for Multi-Criteria Decision Making in Marine Renewable Energy Applications","description":"Research and development of alternative energy resources such as wave energy has always attracted significant attention due to their abundant and sustainable nature. The uncertainties associated with the marine environment and the significant costs required for implementation of Wave Energy Converters (WECs) require a sound decision making methodology. This paper presents a novel risk-based methodology for selecting sites for WEC installation to minimize the overall economic risk. It provides WEC developers, investors, governments and policy makers a methodology for evaluating influencing parameters for potential site locations whilst also optimizing wave energy extraction. A Bayesian network is developed to model the probabilistic influencing parameters and then it is extended to an influence diagram for estimating the expected utility of installing the WEC equipment in a selected location. To demonstrate the application of the developed methodology, three sites in the south coast of Tasmania are considered. Based on actual sea state data, the optimum location for installing WEC equipment is determined as location 2 and the economic risk associated with energy extraction is minimized by suggesting a specific wave height (HS\u00a0=\u00a05\u00a0m) as a design criteria.","author":["Abaei, M.","Arzaghi, E.","Abbassi, R.","Garaniya, V.","Penesis, I."],"organization":["University of Tasmania"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2231","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/framework-determining-improved-placement-current-energy-converters-subject","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/14786451.2017.1334654","title":"A Framework for Determining Improved Placement of Current Energy Converters Subject to Environmental Constraints","description":"A modelling framework identifies deployment locations for current-energy-capture devices that maximise power output while minimising potential environmental impacts. The framework, based on the Environmental Fluid Dynamics Code, can incorporate site-specific environmental constraints. Over a 29-day period, energy outputs from three array layouts were estimated for: (1) the preliminary configuration (baseline), (2) an updated configuration that accounted for environmental constraints, (3) and an improved configuration subject to no environmental constraints. Of these layouts, array placement that did not consider environmental constraints extracted the most energy from flow (4.38\u2005MW-hr\/day), 19% higher than output from the baseline configuration (3.69\u2005MW-hr\/day). Array placement that considered environmental constraints removed 4.27\u2005MW-hr\/day of energy (16% more than baseline). This analysis framework accounts for bathymetry and flow-pattern variations that typical experimental studies cannot, demonstrating that it is a valuable tool for identifying improved array layouts for field deployments.","author":["Roberts, J.","James, S.","Jones, C.","Nelson, K."],"organization":["Integral Consulting Inc","Baylor University","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"2017-06-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nelson-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2232","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/legal-system-development-marine-renewable-energy-china","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032116307092","title":"Legal System for the Development of Marine Renewable Energy in China","description":"At present, there is no specific legal basis for the development and utilisation of marine renewable energy, nor legal protection for the developers in China. The consequence is that the Chinese Government is unable to provide institutional support for the substantive development of marine renewable energy, resulting in slow development of China\u0027s marine energy industry. This paper provides an institutional framework for the establishment of relevant laws in China and legislative proposals in legal perspective, for the better development of marine renewable energy. The Chinese Government should optimise the administrative management system, strengthen financial regulation such as tax and emphasise sustainable development.","author":["Chang, Y.","Wang, N."],"organization":["Shandong University"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["28.739150100000","121.428727200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2233","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-detection-shutdown-system-utility-scale-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.epri.com\/#\/pages\/product\/000000003002009038\/","title":"Bat Detection and Shutdown System for Utility-Scale Wind Turbines","description":"At utility-scale wind energy facilities, blanket curtailment of turbines in response to wind speed minimizes bat fatalities, but sacrifices generation and revenue by remaining in effect even when bats are absent. We Energies, EPRI, and its member companies funded a study to develop a turbine curtailment approach that minimizes such economic costs while ensuring lower fatality rates for bats. Turbine-Integrated Mortality Reduction (TIMRSM) is a Smart Curtailment hardware and software system that runs real-time bat activity and weather data in predictive models that link these parameters to bat mortality and issue a current risk value (red\/curtail, green\/resume, or yellow\/override) used to drive turbine operation. Because the TIMR system does not curtail when bats are absent, it frees up turbine operating time for generation.\n\nWe Energies chose to implement a predictive model based on descriptive statistical cost\u2013benefit analysis at its Wisconsin Blue Sky Green Field (BSGF) wind energy facility in 2015. During fall bat migration, 10 turbines were operated normally and 10 were model-operated with a 30-minute curtailment period. Real-time data for the study were supplied by acoustic monitoring of bat activity (calls) and wind speed recordings at the turbine nacelle. Bat carcass counts for three species and the Myotis family provided evidence of bat mortality. Study results showed a strong correlation between bat activity and mortality, validating the use of activity data to drive curtailment. This is the first study to demonstrate a reduction in mortality for any Myotis species; some members of this family are endangered. The study presents an economic analysis of generation and revenue under Smart Curtailment at BSGF, as well as other factors affecting facility operations.\n\nTIMR could be implemented at a new site in weeks, since there is no need to reprogram the core Supervisory Control and Data Acquisition (SCADA) and the communication and alerting interface with SCADA is readily transferred to new users with minimal customization.","author":["Sutter, C.","Schumacher, S."],"organization":["Normandeau Associates Inc","Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)"],"originationDate":"2017-07-12","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EPRI-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2234","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-renewable-energy-resource-characterization-physical-effects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.springer.com\/us\/book\/9783319535340","title":"Marine Renewable Energy: Resource Characterization and Physical Effects","description":"This complete reference to marine renewable energy covers aspects of resource characterization and physical effects of harvesting the ocean\u2019s vast and powerful resources\u2014from wave and tidal stream to ocean current energy. Experts in each of these areas contribute their insights to provide a cohesive overview of the marine renewable energy spectrum based on theoretical, numerical modeling, and field-measurement approaches. They provide clear explanations of the underlying physics and mechanics, and give close consideration to practical implementation aspects, including impacts on the physical system. Engineers, researchers, and students alike will find invaluable tools and studies that will aid them in realizing significant sustainable energy production from near-shore and ocean environments.","author":["Yang, Z.","Copping, A."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2235","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biodiversity-characterisation-hydrodynamic-consequences-marine-fouling-communities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/08927014.2017.1336229","title":"Biodiversity Characterisation and Hydrodynamic Consequences of Marine Fouling Communities on Marine Renewable Energy Infrastructure in the Orkney Islands Archipelago, Scotland, UK","description":"As part of ongoing commitments to produce electricity from renewable energy sources in Scotland, Orkney waters have been targeted for potential large-scale deployment of wave and tidal energy converting devices. Orkney has a well-developed infrastructure supporting the marine energy industry; recently enhanced by the construction of additional piers. A major concern to marine industries is biofouling on submerged structures, including energy converters and measurement instrumentation. In this study, the marine energy infrastructure and instrumentation were surveyed to characterise the biofouling. Fouling communities varied between deployment habitats; key species were identified allowing recommendations for scheduling device maintenance and preventing spread of invasive organisms. A method to measure the impact of biofouling on hydrodynamic response is described and applied to data from a wave-monitoring buoy deployed at a test site in Orkney. The results are discussed in relation to the accuracy of the measurement resources for power generation. Further applications are suggested for future testing in other scenarios, including tidal energy.","author":["Want, A.","Harris, R.","Crawford, R.","Porter, J.","Kakkonen, J.","Kiddie, G.","Miller, S."],"organization":["Heriot-Watt University","Orkney Islands Council"],"originationDate":"2017-07-04","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.031712200000","-3.463686500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Want-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2236","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-marine-renewable-energy-extraction-sediment-dynamics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-53536-4_12","title":"The Impact of Marine Renewable Energy Extraction on Sediment Dynamics","description":"The extraction of marine energy, through either tidal or wave array operation, will clearly influence the hydrodynamics of a region. Although the influence on tidal currents and wave properties is likely to be very small for most extraction scenarios, the influence on bed shear stress is likely to be greater, because bed shear stress is quadratically related to tidal currents and wave orbital velocities. Further, the transport of sediments is a function of tidal current and wave orbital velocity cubed. Therefore, even small modifications to the flow field through tidal or wave array operation could lead to significant impacts on regional sediment dynamics. In this chapter, after providing an introduction to sediment dynamics in the marine environment, we explore the impact of tidal energy devices\/arrays on regional sediment dynamics, with a particular emphasis on offshore sand banks\u2014important sedimentary systems that protect our coastlines from the full impact of storm waves. Next, we discuss how generating electricity from waves could influence nearshore sediment processes, such as beach erosion or replenishment, over a range of timescales. To assess the magnitude of impacts on sedimentary systems, it is essential to consider the scale of the impact in relation to the range of natural variability. We suggest ways in which impacts can be assessed using numerical models, tuned by in situ measurements, that quantify variability over a range of timescales from individual storm events and lunar cycles to seasonal and interannual periods. We also discuss the sedimentary processes associated with tidal lagoons, such as scour and sediment drift outside a lagoon and sediment accretion inside a lagoon.","author":["Neill, S.","Fairley, I.","Robins, P."],"organization":["Bangor University","Swansea University"],"originationDate":"2017-04-10","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2237","type":["Document","Document\/Webpage"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wild-whales-noise-cetaceans","sourceURL":"https:\/\/wildwhales.org\/threats\/noise-and-cetaceans\/","title":"Wild Whales Noise and Cetaceans","description":"Sound is as important to cetaceans as light is to humans. In most oceans visibility underwater is limited to a few 10s of metres and is regularly much less. In response to the challenges of using light to navigate and locate food in the ocean, cetaceans have adapted to take advantage of the physics of sound underwater. Sound travels ~4.4 times faster in sea water than in air and, all things being equal, travels ~100 times further underwater than in air. As in air, low frequency sounds travel much further underwater than high frequencies (think of the distant sound of the bass drum heard will before the rest of the marching band at the parade). If conditions are right, underwater sounds can travel thousands of kilometres across entire ocean basins \u2013 low frequency blue whale calls can travel in \u201cdeep water sound channels\u201d that refract waves up and down allowing them to travel thousands of kilometers.","author":["BC Cetacean Sightings Network"],"organization":["Fisheries and Oceans Canada","Vancouver Aquarium"],"originationDate":"2013-08-27","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2238","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/biocide-free-antifouling-insulating-surface-wave-driven-triboelectrification-induced","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/admi.201600187\/full","title":"Biocide-Free Antifouling on Insulating Surface by Wave-Driven Triboelectrification-Induced Potential Oscillation","description":"A biocide-free antifouling method on wetted insulating surfaces, enabled by the oscillation of electric potential generated by an integrated triboelectric wave harvester (I-TEWH) is reported. Distinct from previous studies that reported antifouling on conducting surfaces by applying an additional power source, this method achieves antifouling on insulating surfaces with zero-power consumption. The electric potential in the vicinity of a protected surface oscillates in large amplitude as a result of periodically accumulated free electrons on an underlying electrode. The dynamic flow of the free electrons is driven by the I-TEWH that converts ambient wave energy by solid\u2013liquid interface triboelectrification. As a consequence, the oscillating electric potential disturbs the inherent charge distribution on microbes due to electrostatic induction, preventing their initial adhesion onto the protected surface and thus prohibiting the subsequent formation of macroorganisms. Significant anti-adhesion efficiencies of as high as 99.3%, 99.1%, and 96.0% are achieved for negative-gram bacteria (Escherichia coli), positive-gram bacteria (Staphylococcus aureus), and diatoms (bacillariophyceze), respectively, on a smooth surface. The antifouling efficiency on a roughened surface with micro\/nanostructures can be further enhanced by another 75%. This approach can be potentially utilized in coastal constructions, offshore facilities, and vessels that are either moving or stationary in port.","author":["Yan, L.","Wang, Z.","Zhao, X.","Tian, J.","Kuang, S.","Ouyang, H.","Li, Z.","Zhu, G."],"organization":["Chinese Academy of Sciences"],"originationDate":"2016-09-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["31.392989500000","85.498531400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Chemicals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2239","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-avian-mortality-collisions-electrocutions","sourceURL":"","title":"Assessment of Avian Mortality from Collisions and Electrocutions","description":"Safeguarding endangered and protected avian species is an increasingly important component of both California\u2019s development of electric generation and the siting and operation of power lines. Bird deaths from electrocution and collision with wind turbines and power lines are an ongoing environmental issue affecting wind energy development and the siting and operation of electrical transmission and distribution lines. Wind energy is a major part of the renewables portfolio standard (RPS), and wind developers rely on federal and state tax credits to help offset costs of new development. However, high wind areas are also prime habitat for certain protected bird species. Major wind developments in Altamont Pass, San Gorgonio, Tehachapi Pass, and Solano County have caused numerous bird deaths. To resolve issues with current wind resources and accommodate additional wind development and repowering, mitigation and\/or avoidance is needed to reduce avian mortality.\n\nWhen birds and bats collide with electrical power line infrastructure, their electrocution also can result in electrical outages, affect service reliability, and cause wildfires. Most bird species being killed are protected under state and federal laws and are thus of concern to the public at large, as well as environmental and wildlife law enforcement officials.\n\nThis staff paper issued in conjunction with the 2005 Environmental Performance Report examines the ongoing issues of avian fatalities from electrocution and collision with energy structures. This paper includes current research results, information provided from the utilities, research conducted through the Public Interest Energy Research (PIER) program and a brief look at how some other states are addressing energy infrastructure-related avian fatalities. This paper is divided into two chapters: the first discusses avian fatalities in relation to wind energy resources and the second, avian fatalities in relation to electrical transmission and distribution lines.\n\nThere are several trends in California wind energy development and associated avian issues. Among them are research shifting from identifying the extent of the avian collision problem to resolving it, the discovery that bat fatalities may be an issue in at least one wind resource area, and how mitigation for projects is determined and applied. The rates of bird use and collision differs in other wind resource areas in California. California\u2019s Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area stands out as having a high bird fatality problem due to the combination of approximately 5,000 operating turbines and a high concentration of year-round raptors. Alameda County continues to implement a moratorium on developing additional wind development in the Altamont Pass until avian fatalities can be reduced. Solano County also has a high rate of collisions, while San Gorgonio and Tehachapi Pass have lower rates. More recently, studies at wind farms have identified bat fatalities as an issue. In Solano County, surveys for bats have been conducted confirming bat fatalities are an issue there. Elsewhere in California, bat fatality studies have not been conducted and, therefore, the extent of the problem in these wind resource areas is uncertain.\n\nWind turbines should be sited in areas that reduce impacts to birds and other species as well as critical habitat. Mitigation measures should also be developed for all of the wind resource areas and applied to existing and new development to effectively lessen impacts on avian resources. Applying measures that reduce the chances of avian interactions with wind turbines and electrical infrastructure is the only way to reduce collisions. Voluntary guidelines for surveys and mitigation measures exist, but industry and local agencies do not implement them consistently between projects.\n\nAvian fatalities due to collisions with and electrocutions from electrical power lines in California cannot be accurately quantified although they can be reduced using birdsafe designs. In some areas the utilities collect information on avian interactions with transmission lines and have adopted an Avian Protection Plan. The data collected are not normally publicly reported, except when federally listed species are reported to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. However, one recent study in Arizona showed that 85 percent of avian interactions with electrical power lines go undetected by the utility (Dwyer 2004), although they still critically injure or kill the bird. Therefore, the information collected by the utilities maybe grossly underestimating the impacts to avian resources in California.\n\nThe PIER Environmental Area (PIER\u2013EA) is collaborating on current research to help quantify the problem as well as resolve it through identification of mitigation measures and dissemination of information to stakeholders. There are other guidance documents available that utilities use to lower the potential for electrocutions and collisions with power lines. The guidelines are voluntary and the extent of their implementation differs throughout the state.","author":["Dorin, M.","Speigel, L.","McKinney, J.","Tooker, C."],"organization":["California Energy Commission"],"originationDate":"2005-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Dorin-et-al-2005.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2240","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-seabed-shear-stress-sediment-mobility-sediment-transport-bay-fundy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrcresearchpress.com\/doi\/full\/10.1139\/cjes-2014-0211","title":"Modelling Seabed Shear Stress, Sediment Mobility, and Sediment Transport in the Bay of Fundy","description":"Information about seabed stability and sediment dynamics is part of the fundamental geoscience knowledge required for the extraction of tidal energy in the Bay of Fundy and for the integrated management of the Bay. Waves, tidal currents, and wind-driven and circulation currents were obtained from oceanographic models to assess the wave and current processes for the broader Bay of Fundy. The wave and current outputs were coupled with observed grain size in a sediment transport model to predict, for the first time, the seabed shear stresses, sediment mobility, and sediment transport patterns for the entire Bay. The root mean square tidal current, highest in the upper Bay (\u003E1.4 m\u00b7s\u22121), is reduced to moderate in the central Bay (0.5\u20130.8 m\u00b7s\u22121) and decreases further in the outer Bay (0.2\u20130.5 m\u00b7s\u22121). The maximum tidal current occurs in the Minas Passage and is \u003E5 m\u00b7s\u22121. The mean significant wave height, in contrast, is the greatest in the outer Bay (\u223c1.3 m) and gradually decreases to the northeast in the central and upper Bay (30% of the time over most of the Bay and reaches 100% of the time in some areas. The maximum total-load sediment transport rate under spring tide can reach \u223c5 kg\u00b7m\u22121\u00b7s\u22121 and is to the northeast during flood and to the southwest during ebb. Net sediment transport flux, however, is dominantly to the northeast and reaches 2 kg\u00b7m\u22121\u00b7s\u22121. Eddies of net transport are found to occur around headlands and at the narrows of Grand Manan Island, largely due to the occurrence of eddies of residual tidal flows. The regional distribution of substrate types and bedform fields and patterns of seabed erosion and deposition are well correlated with tidal current strength and sediment transport patterns.","author":["Hannah, C.","Greenberg, D.","Tang, C.","Li, M.","Perrie, W.","Prescott, R."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.895176400000","-66.948374500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2241","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/variability-suspended-sediment-concentration-minas-basin-bay-fundy-implications","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378383915001738","title":"Variability in Suspended Sediment Concentration in the Minas Basin, Bay of Fundy, and Implications for Changes due to Tidal Power Extraction","description":"The Bay of Fundy in eastern Canada has the world\u0027s largest tidal range of over 16 m with tidal currents up to 5 ms(-1) making it an ideal place for tidal power extraction using tidal in-stream energy conversion devices in the Minas Passage. Field observations collected from ship-based and bottom-moored sensors over an 8-day period in 2013 are used to validate a 3D hydrodynamic and sediment transport model of the Minas Basin with measurements of water levels, current profiles, waves, suspended sediment fluxes and suspended sediment concentration (SSC) profiles. The sediment conditions are initialized using a bi-modal sediment distribution map and the model simulates both cohesive and non-cohesive sediments in the Minas Basin. Model results for fine-grained suspended sediment concentrations are compared horizontally, vertically, and temporally to observations and indicate strong data-model agreement for SSC from 5 to 287 mg L-1. The implications of constructing a large-scale turbine farm within the Minas Passage and the impacts on suspended sediment within the Minas Basin are investigated using the model. The farm is simulated by adding semi-permeable structures that use an energy loss term in the fluid momentum equations to parameterize turbine regions in the hydrodynamic model. The results emphasize the sensitivity of the system to changes in flow and suggest that a large-scale\u00a0tidal energy\u00a0farm that extracts maximum power could reduce SSC by 37% on average across the basin which would influence physical and biological processes particularly on the fine-grained intertidal areas around the macrotidal basin.","author":["Mulligan, R.","Law, B.","Ashall, L."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.206831600000","-64.528274100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2242","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-climate-change-wave-energy-resource-case-menorca-spain","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148116307704","title":"Impact of Climate Change on Wave Energy Resource: The Case of Menorca (Spain)","description":"The aim of this paper was to analyse how changes in wave patterns, due to the effect of climate change, can affect\u00a0wave energy\u00a0power and yield around Menorca (NW Mediterranean Sea). The present and future\u00a0wave energy\u00a0conditions were derived from recently developed high-resolution wave projections in the NW Mediterranean. These wave projections were forced by surface wind fields obtained, respectively, by 5 different combinations of global and regional\u00a0circulation\u00a0models (GCMs and RCMs) for the MB scenario. The results showed that the projected future spatial and directional distributions of\u00a0wave energy\u00a0are very similar to those of the present conditions. The multi-model ensemble average illustrated a slight general decrease in the annual and seasonal wave power (except for summer). However, the inter-model variability is large since two models showed opposite trends to the other 3 in most cases. Such inter-model variability is lower(higher) for winter(autumn). Another result is the reduction of the temporal variability in the future, considering both the multi-model mean and each single model projection. Such a decrease is consistent with the future seasonal redistribution of energy throughout the year. This would entail an increase in the efficiency of\u00a0wave energy\u00a0converters deployed in this area due to the more regular temporal distribution of the energy.","author":["Sierra, J.","Casas-Prat, M.","Campins, E."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.988241100000","3.882294600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2243","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/application-tidal-energy-purification-fresh-water-lake","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S209267821630111X","title":"Application of Tidal Energy for Purification in Fresh Water Lake","description":"In order to preserve the\u00a0quality\u00a0of fresh\u00a0water\u00a0in the artificial lake after the reclamation of an intertidal flat at the mouth of a river; we suggest two novel methods of\u00a0water\u00a0purification by using tidal potential energy and an enclosed permeable embankment called an utsuro (Akai et al., 1990) in the reclaimed region. One method uses an inflatable bag on the seabed within an utsuro, while the other uses a moored floating barge out of a dyke. Each case employs a subsea pipe to allow flow between the inside and outside of the utsuro. The change in\u00a0water\u00a0level in the utsuro, which is pushed through the pipe by the potential energy outside, caused circulation in the artificial lake. In this paper, we analyzed the inflatable bag and floating barge motion as well as the pipe flow characteristics and drafts as given by a harmonic sea level, and compared the theoretical value with an experimental value with a simple small model basin. The numerical calculation based on theory showed good agreement with experimental values.","author":["Jung, R.","Isshiki, H."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.470136400000","125.374263200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Jung-Isshiki-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2244","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/french-application-case-tidal-turbine-certification","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=2570927","title":"A French Application Case of Tidal Turbine Certification","description":"Tidal turbines are emerging technologies offering great potential for the harnessing of a renewable and predictable oceanic resource. However, exploitation at sea comes with significant design, installation, grid connection, and maintenance operations challenges. Consequently, guidelines and standards are required to ensure safety, quality, performance and accelerate tidal turbines development and commercialisation. Standardisation is also a necessity to support and improve safety and confidence of a wide range of Marine Renewable Energy (MRE) stakeholders such as designers, project operators, investors, insurers or final users.  There are undergoing developments on guidelines, standards and certification systems within the International Electrotechnical Commission (IEC) Technical Committee TC 114 \u201cMarine energy - Wave, tidal and other water current converters\u201d and the IEC Renewable Energy \u201cMarine Energy - Operational Management Committee\u201d (IECRE ME \u2013 OMC). However, as the tidal energy concepts are only at the demonstration stage, only few guidelines and no dedicated certification scheme has been published so far within this organization, which guarantee an international, independent, non-governmental and consensus-based elaboration process.  The aim of this paper is to present a proposal of certification methodology, developed by Bureau Veritas for the design assessment of current and tidal turbines, and its application to a French case study. This certification procedure was developed within the French research project Sabella D10 funded by ADEME and is published in the Bureau Veritas guideline NI603 \u201cCurrent \u0026amp; Tidal Turbines\u201d.  The suggested certification procedure addresses prototype, component, type and project certification. Main objective, scope, intermediary steps to be completed and resulting certificates will be detailed for each certification scheme, as well as their interactions.  This methodology will be illustrated by the case study on the Sabella D10 prototype, a French tidal turbine installed in 2015 in the Fromveur Passage, off Ushant Island. Sabella D10 is a 1 MW tidal turbine fully submerged laid on the seabed with a horizontal axis and 6 blades. It is the first French tidal turbine producing electricity and connected to the electrical network.  The Sabella D10 case study will focus on prototype certification and computations performed for support structure and blades. The paper will describe the load cases that have been considered, the review procedure for the support structure and the blades design assessment, including description of a streamlined method for basic design and a detailed method for final design. In conclusion, the next steps will be introduced to continue the certification developments of tidal and current turbines.","author":["Paboeuf, S.","Macadre, L.","Sun, P."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-06-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.507893300000","-0.434694800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2245","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/thirty-years-north-american-wind-energy-acceptance-research-what-have-we-learned","sourceURL":"https:\/\/emp.lbl.gov\/publications\/thirty-years-north-american-wind","title":"Thirty Years of North American Wind Energy Acceptance Research: What have we Learned?","description":"Thirty years of North American research on public acceptance of wind energy has produced important insights, yet knowledge gaps remain. This review synthesizes the literature, revealing the following lessons learned. (1) North American support for wind has been consistently high. (2) The NIMBY explanation for resistance to wind development is invalid. (3) Socioeconomic impacts of wind development are strongly tied to acceptance. (4) Sound and visual impacts of wind facilities are strongly tied to annoyance and opposition, and ignoring these concerns can exacerbate conflict. (5) Environmental concerns matter, though less than other factors, and these concerns can both help and hinder wind development. (6) Issues of fairness, participation, and trust during the development process influence acceptance. (7) Distance from turbines affects other explanatory variables, but alone its influence is unclear. (8) Viewing opposition as something to be overcome prevents meaningful understandings and implementation of best practices. (9) Implementation of research findings into practice has been limited. The paper also identifies areas for future research on wind acceptance. With continued research efforts and a commitment toward implementing research findings into developer and policymaker practice, conflict and perceived injustices around proposed and existing wind energy facilities might be significantly lessened.","author":["Rand, J.","Hoen, B."],"organization":["Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rand-Hoen-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2246","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-wave-energy-united-states-current-status-future-perspectives","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032116308164","title":"Ocean Wave Energy in the United States: Current Status and Future Perspectives","description":"Ocean waves are a more predictable resource with a higher energy density compared to solar and wind. In addition, and specifically for the United States, resource locations with high wave power are close to major load centers being located along coastlines. These features have sparked a surge of attention in the United States on trying to economically harness ocean wave power. The aim of this article is to provide a concise review of the current state of ocean wave energy conversion technologies and industry status in the United States including research and development as well as commercial activities and governmental support, concluding with a discussion of future industry perspectives. Existing facilities, softwares as well as laboratory and open-water test facilities and resources, active research groups and commercial activities have been identified. Over one third of commercially active wave energy developers worldwide are located within the United States, but only a few have reached a high Technology Readiness Level. These findings, together with a relevant practical resource located within the U.S. and the advantageous nature of the resource compared to other renewable resources, indicate that the United States is well positioned to advance the wave energy industry in the near future.","author":["Jacobson, P.","Lehmann, M.","Karimpour, F.","Goudey, C.","Alam, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.171681300000","-109.227806900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2247","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/supergen-phase-three-monograph","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.supergen-marine.org.uk\/sites\/supergen-marine.org.uk\/files\/attachments\/Phase_3_Monograph_Nov_2016.pdf","title":"SuperGen Phase Three Monograph","description":"The Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) Sustainable Power Generation and Supply (Supergen) programme is the flagship research initiative established in 2003 to establish a platform for the development of new and improved devices, processes, facilities and know-how for sustainable power generation and supply and with the aim of increasing coherence and collaboration across the energy research landscape.\n\n1.1 Phases 1 and 2\n\nSupergen Marine Phase 1 (October 2003 \u2013 September 2007) brought together research staff from the Universities of Edinburgh, Robert Gordon, Lancaster, Heriot -Watt and Strathclyde. The research aimed to:\n\n\n Increase knowledge and understanding of the extraction of energy from the sea;\n Reduce risk and uncertainty for stakeholders in the development and deployment of technology;\n Enable progression of marine technology and energy into true positions in future energy portfolios.\n\n\nThirteen research work packages (WPs) were undertaken:\n\n\n WP1 Appraisal of Energy Resource \u0026amp; Converters: Environmental Interaction;\n WP2 Development of Methodologies for Device Evaluation and Optimisation;\n WP3 Engineering Guidance;\n WP4 Offshore Energy Conversion and Power Conditioning;\n WP5 Chemical Conversion and Storage;\n WP6 Network Interaction of Marine Energy;\n WP7 Lifetime Economics;\n WP8 Moorings and Foundations;\n WP9 Novel Control Systems for Marine Energy Converters;\n WP10 Full -scale Field Validation;\n WP11 Assessment of Testing Procedures for Tidal Current Devices;\n WP12 Economic, Environmental and Social Impact of New Marine Technologies;\n WP13 Dissemination and Outreach.\n\n\nSupergen Marine Phase 2 (October 2007 \u2013 September 2011) brought together research staff from the core Universities of Edinburgh, Queen\u2019s Belfast, Heriot-Watt, Lancaster and Strathclyde. The consortium included affiliate Universities of Durham, Exeter, Highlands and Islands, Manchester, Robert Gordon and Southampton. They delivered generic research in 12 work streams (WSs) with the following objectives:\n\n\n Increase knowledge and understanding of device -sea interactions of energy converters from model-scale in the laboratory to full-size in the open sea, subjected to waves and currents.\n Build human and physical capacity to carry out research and development to address remaining and new challenges as the expanding sector works towards the targets set.\n Internationalise its articulation, activities, perception and influence.\n\n\nTwelve research work streams (WSs) were undertaken:\n\n\n WS1 Numerical and physical convergence;\n WS2 Optimisation of collector form and response;\n WS3 Combined wave and tidal effects;\n WS4 Arrays, wakes and near field effects;\n WS5 Power take-off and conditioning;\n WS6 Moorings and positioning;\n WS7 Advanced control and network integration;\n WS8 Reliability;\n WS9 Economic analysis of variability and penetration;\n WS10 Ecological Consequences of Tidal \u0026amp; Wave Energy Conversion;\n WS11 Training and Development;\n WS12 Dissemination, Engagement and International Articulation.\n\n\nThrough their Doctoral Training Programmes, Phase s 1\u0026amp; 2 trained over 40 PhD students. The outcomes and publications of this work are recorded in the Phase s 1 and 2 monograph s, copies of which are available at the Supergen Marine website: https:\/\/www.supergen-marine.org.uk\/online-bookmaker\/.\n\n1.2 Phase 3\n\nPhase 3 commenced in October 2011, funded by EPSRC under award EP\/I027912\/1 bringing together staff from the core Universities of Edinburgh, Queen\u2019s Belfast, Strathclyde and Exeter. The consortium included associate Universities of Plymouth, Heriot-Watt, Lancaster, Manchester, Swansea, Oxford and Southampton. Together they formed the UK Centre for Marine Energy Research aiming to ensure joined-up regional, disciplinary and thematic effort by:\n\n\n Conducting world-class fundamental and applied research that assisted the marine energy sector to accelerate deployment and ensure growth in generating capacity through 2020 targets.\n Expanding and operating an inclusive marine network of academic researchers, industry partners and international collaborators.\n Continuing to provide the highest quality of doctoral training and knowledge transfer in partnership with industry to build intellectual and human capacity for the sector.\n\n\nThe research in phase 3 was grouped into five themes:\n\n\n Arrays and farms \u2013 to understand and better quantify the interactions between devices, the energy flux in the sea, the natural environment and the electricity network - to optimise behaviour and energy yield;\n Environmental interaction \u2013 to understand the 3D time varying interaction between single and multiple devices and the energy and natural environment arising from the local and large -scale abstraction of energy through electricity generation;\n Extreme loadings and durability \u2013 to become able to predict the extreme conditions, their consequent device and structural loading and the effects on the ultimate survival of components, technologies or devices;\n Fatigue loadings and reliability \u2013 to become able to predict the effects of combined wave and tidal action on the cyclic loadings and the effects on the wear-out or fatigue failure of components, technologies or devices;\n Novel marine energy systems and components \u2013 to develop new wave and tidal energy device concepts, sub -systems and components that improve from those existing.\n\n\nDuring phase 3 there were three Grand Challenge calls for proposals to extend the research base and broaden the contributing community. They generated very considerable interest and many excellent proposals, from which the following were selected by peer-review. Phase 3 integrated the staff and activities of these GC projects into the hub in the themes above. All but the most recent of the Grand Challenge Projects are complete and key highlights are reported in section 4 of this monograph.\n\nOptimal Design of Very Large Tidal Stream Farms for Shallow Estuarine Applications; Oct12-Mar16 EP\/J010138\/1; Prof M Belmont \u2013 Exeter, collaborative with Edinburgh.\n\nThe Effects of Realistic Tidal Flows on the Performance and Structural Integrity of TSTs; Jul12-Sep15 EP\/J010200\/1; Prof T O\u2019Doherty \u2013 Cardiff, collaborative with Liverpool, Swansea, Bangor and Cranfield.\n\nExtreme Loading of MEDs due to Waves, Currents, Flotsam and Mammal Impact (XMED); Feb12-Jul15 EP\/J010235\/1; Prof P Stansby \u2013 Manchester, collaborative with Plymouth and Edinburgh.\n\nModelling Marine Renewable Energy Devices - Designing for Survivability (ELoWEC); Jun12-Dec15 EP\/J010197\/1; Prof C Swan \u2013 Imperial, collaborative with Queens and Manchester Metropolitan.\n\nSupergen Marine Technology Challenge (SMARTY); Oct12-Mar16 EP\/J010316\/1; Prof P Taylor \u2013 Oxford, collaborative with UCL and Bath.\n\nStep Change for WEC through Floating Multi-Body Multi-Mode Systems in Swell (STEPWEC); Jun13-16 EP\/K012487\/1; Prof P Stansby \u2013 Manchester, collaborative with Oxford and Bath.\n\nThe hydrodynamics of deformable flexible fabric structures for wave energy conversion; May13-Apr16 EP\/K012177\/1; Prof D Greaves \u2013 Plymouth, collaborative with Southampton.\n\nSupergen UKCMER 4 Increasing the life of Marine Turbines by Design and Innovation; May12-Oct15 EP\/J010308\/1; Prof R Miller \u2013 Cambridge, collaborative with Cranfield.\n\nInteractions of Flow, TSTs, Local Sediment Bed under Combined Waves \u0026amp; Tides (INSTRON); Sep12-Feb16 EP\/J010359\/1; Prof P Dong, - Dundee, collaborative with Hull, Liverpool and Strathclyde.\n\nLS-Interactive Coupled 3D Modelling for Wave \u0026amp; Tidal Energy Res \u0026amp; Env Impact (Terawatt); Jun 12-Nov15 EP\/J010170\/1; Prof J Side \u2013 Heriot-Watt, collaborative with Edinburgh, Strathclyde, Swansea \u0026amp; UHI\n\nEcoWatt 2050; Mar14-Feb17 EP\/K012851\/1; Prof J Side \u2013 Heriot-Watt, collaborative with Edinburgh, Strathclyde, Swansea \u0026amp; Aberdeen.\n\nLS interactive coupled modelling of environmental impacts of marine RE farms (LINC); Oct12-Mar16 EP\/J010065\/1; Dr B Elsaesser: Queens, collaborative with Imperial College and Cefas.\n\nReducing the Costs of Marine Renewables via Advanced Structural Materials (ReC-ASM); Jun13-Jun16 EP\/K013319\/1; Prof M Stack \u2013 Strathclyde, collaborative with Newcastle and Southampton.\n\nDynamic Loadings on Turbines in a Tidal Array (DyLoTTA); Jul16-Jun19 EP\/N020782\/1; Prof T O\u2019Doherty \u2013 Cardiff, collaborative with Strathclyde.\n\nSurvivability of Floating Tidal Energy Converters (SURFTEC); Sep16-Aug19 EP\/N02057X\/1; Prof A Williams \u2013 Swansea.\n\nAll Electric Drive Train for Marine Energy Converters (EDRIVE-MEC); Apr16-Mar19 EP\/N021452\/1; Prof M A Mueller \u2013 Edinburgh, collaborative with Newcastle, Delft and UdeChile.\n\nResponse of Tidal Energy Converters to Combined Flow, Waves \u0026amp; Turbulence (FloWTurb); Apr16-19 EP\/N021487\/1; Dr V Venugopal, collaborative with U Highlands and Islands and Heriot-Watt.\n\nDuring the course of phase 3 several of the early deployments of wave and tidal technologies experienced failure either through their inability to survive extreme loadings, their failure under normal loadings in extreme displacements or their early fatigue failure under repetitive cyclic loadings. Concurrently there was a recognition in the wave sector that a structured innovation strategy, based on the phased development and deployment of smaller units that may later be scaled-up, is a potentially more efficient and reliable way of demonstrating and consolidating learning. Interest in the wave sector moved towards the development of components, subsystems and technologies that will lead to improved performance and the availability of ocean-ready and durable elements and know-how. The ETI:UKERC 2014 roadmap re-prioritised R\u0026amp;D needs from the perspective of the sector and identified the high level areas needing most urgent effort: Device and System Deployment; Sub-Systems; Design and O ptimisation Tool Development and Arrays. Across these, several fields are common, including: development of reliability tools and demonstration at array scale; array design and modelling tools; hydraulic systems and power take offs; array electrical systems and interaction analysis. At a European level, the SI Ocean project identified the following priorities: novel system concepts; device and sub-component level reliability demonstration; reliability tools; resource analysis tools and array interaction analysis. Experience gained working with developers, observations of unfolding events in the sector and the agendas of recent investments like the ORE-Catapult affirmed the following need for the work of UKCMER. Additional core funding under award EP\/M014 738\/1 as Extension of UKCMER Core Research, Industry and International Engagement or Supergen 3+. It seeks to explore numerically and physically the interaction of tidal turbines and wave energy converters with their energy fluxes, one another, their moorings and the electricity network to better understand the cyclic and irregular forces acting and the structural loadings arising, ultimately to reduce fatigue and increase reliability. Staff had to complete other concurrently funded work and only transferred wholly to these WPs in the course of the last year. A 12-month contract extension now schedules the work for completion by December 2017.\n\n1.3 Phase 4\n\nThe existing hub of UKCMER was renewed in phase 4 under award EP\/P008682\/1 in October 2016, with the structure shown and ambitions described in section 5.\n\nOther SuperGen Monographs:\n\n\n SuperGen Monograph Phase 1\n SuperGen Monograph Phase 2","author":["SuperGen UK Centre for Marine Energy Research (UKCMER)"],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2016-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-04-05 11:28:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Supergen-2016-Monograph-Phase3.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2248","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/supergen-phase-two-monograph","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.supergen-marine.org.uk\/sites\/supergen-marine.org.uk\/files\/publications\/Phase_2_Monograph_Oct_2011.pdf","title":"SuperGen Phase Two Monograph","description":"The Engineering and Physical Science s Research Council (EPSRC) Sustainable Power Generation and Supply (SuperGen) programme is the flagship research initiative shaping the future of the United Kingdom\u2019s energy research landscape. It contributes to the UK\u0027s environmental emission targets by conducting research that leads to radical improvement in the sustainability of the UK\u0027s power generation and supply. The first of a total of 13 consortia was launched in October 2003. The mission of these consortia was to establish a platform for the development of new and improved devices for efficient and sustainable power generation and supply. The research of the Marine Energy Consortium focuses on developing the potential for future exploitation of the marine energy resource.  1.1 Phase 1  SuperGen Marine Phase 1 (October 2003 \u2013 September 2007) brought together research staff from the Universities of Edinburgh, Robert Gordon, Lancaster, Heriot-Watt and Strathclyde. Together they undertook generic research with the following long-term objectives. To:    Increase knowledge and understanding of the extraction of energy from the sea;  Reduce risk and uncertainty for stakeholders in the development and deployment of technology;  Enable progression of marine technology and energy into true positions in future energy portfolios.   In order to meet these objectives, thirteen research work packages (WPs) were undertaken:    WP1 Appraisal of Energy Resource \u0026amp; Converters: Environmental Interaction;  WP2 Development of Methodologies for Device Evaluation and Optimisation;  WP3 Engineering Guidance;  WP4 Offshore Energy Conversion and Power Conditioning;  WP5 Chemical Conversion and Storage;  WP6 Network Interaction of Marine Energy;  WP7 Lifetime Economics;  WP8 Moorings and Foundations;  WP9 Novel Control Systems for Marine Energy Converters;  WP10 Full-scale Field Validation;  WP11 Assessment of Testing Procedures for Tidal Current Devices;  WP12 Economic, Environmental and Social Impact of New Marine Technologies;  WP13 Dissemination and Outreach.   Phase 1 trained 13 PhD students that took up employment across the sector. The outcomes and publications of this work are recorded in a preceding monograph, copies of which are available to download at the SuperGen Marine website.  1.2 Phase 2  SuperGen Marine Phase 2 (October 2007 \u2013 September 2011) brought together research staff from the core Universities of Edinburgh, Queen\u2019s Belfast, Heriot-Watt, Lancaster and Strathclyde. The consortium included affiliate Universities of Durham, Exeter, Highlands and Islands, Manchester, Robert Gordon and Southampton. Together they undertook generic research with the following long-term objectives:    Increase knowledge and understanding of device-sea interactions of energy converters from model-scale in the laboratory to full-size in the open sea, subjected to waves and currents.  Build human and physical capacity to carry out research and development to address remaining and new challenges as the expanding sector works towards the targets set.  I nternationalise its articulation, activities, perception and influence.   There were twelve work streams (WSs).    WS1 Numerical and physical convergence;  WS2 Optimisation of collector form and response;  WS3 Combined wave and tidal effects;  WS4 Arrays, wakes and near field effects;  WS5 Power take-off and conditioning;  WS6 Moorings and positioning;  WS7 Advanced control and network integration;  WS8 Reliability;  WS9 Economic analysis of variability and penetration;  WS10 Ecological Consequences of Tidal \u0026amp; Wave Energy Conversion; SuperGen Marine Energy Research 4  WS11 Training and Development;  WS12 Dissemination, Engagement and International Articulation.   Through its Doctoral Training Programme, Phase 2 has trained over 30 PhD students. Many have taken employment in the sector with, for example Vattenfall, AWS Ocean Energy, E-on, DetNorkseVeritas, Garrad Hassan and Open Hydro. Many others have joined the research staff in universities across the UK and Europe.  Phase 2 was advised by an Industry Research Advisory Forum that included Marine Current Turbines; Open Hydro; Pelamis Wave Power; Ocean Power Technology; Scottish\u0026amp;Southern Energy; Scottish Power; Ed F; E-On; NPower; ETI; Carbon Trust; EMEC; NaREC; Crown Estates; Scottish Natural Heritage.  Phase 2 collaborated with the following international partners: HMRC Cork-Ireland, TU Delft-Netherlands, Ecole Centrale Nautique Nantes-France, Dalhousie University-Canada, Oregon State University, Florida Atlantic University, UMass \u2013 USA; Universities of Osaka City and Hokkaido \u2013 Japan; Harbin Engineering University and Dalian University of Technology \u2013 China; National Sun-Yat Sen, National Taiwan Ocean University, National Chen Kung University \u2013 Taiwan.  1.3 Phase 3  The Marine consortium secured continuation funding for Phase 3, supporting a further five years of research from October 2011, and this brings together staff from the core Universities of Edinburgh, Queen\u2019s Belfast, Strathclyde and Exeter. The consortium includes associate Universities of Plymouth, Heriot-Watt, Lancaster, Manchester, Swansea, Oxford and Southampton. Together they form the UK Centre for Marine Energy Research, whose core membership and management tea m will aim to ensure a joined-up regional, disciplinary and thematic effort to meet the challenges in accelerating deployment towards and through 2020 targets, and maintain the international brand image and UK world-lead in marine energy with the following long-term objectives:    Conduct world-class fundamental and applied research that assists the marine energy sector to accelerate deployment and ensure growth in generating capacity through 2020 targets.  Expand and operate an inclusive marine network of academic researchers, industry partners and international collaborators.  Continue to provide the highest quality of doctoral training and knowledge transfer in partnership with industry to build intellectual and human capacity for the sector.   This document consists of five sections and contains three appendices. Section 2 summarises research in Phase 2 over the second four years of the programme. The aims of the future research in Phase 3 are presented in section 3. The Doctoral Training Programme and Dissemination, Engagement and International Articulation are summarised in sections 4 and 5. Details of the individuals involved in the programme, abstracts of the research outputs from Phase 2 grouped by work stream, and then alphabetically, are contained in Appendices 1 - 3.  Other SuperGen Monographs:    SuperGen Monograph Phase 1  SuperGen Monograph Phase 3","author":["SuperGen UK Centre for Marine Energy Research (UKCMER)"],"organization":["University of Edinburgh","SuperGen UK Centre for Marine Energy Research (UKCMER)"],"originationDate":"2011-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Supergen-2011-Monograph-Phase2.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2249","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/supergen-phase-one-monograph","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.supergen-marine.org.uk\/sites\/supergen-marine.org.uk\/files\/publications\/supergen_2007_monograph.pdf","title":"SuperGen Phase One Monograph","description":"The Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) Sustainable Power Generation and Supply (SuperGen) programme is the flagship research initiative shaping the future of the United Kingdom\u2019s energy landscape. The first of a total of 13 consortia were launched in October 2003. The mission of these consortia is to establish a platform for the development of new and improved devices for efficient and sustainable power generation and supply. The research of the Marine Energy Consortium focuses on the potential for future exploitation of the marine energy resource. SuperGen Marine Phase 1 (October 2003 \u2013 September 2007) brought together research staff from the Universities of Edinburgh, Robert Gordon, Lancaster, Heriot-Watt and Strathclyde. Together they undertook generic research with the following long-term objectives. To:    Increase knowledge and understanding of the extraction of energy from the sea;  Reduce risk and uncertainty for stakeholders in the development and deployment of technology;  Enable progression of marine technology and energy into true positions in future energy portfolios.   In order to meet these objectives, thirteen research work packages (WPs) were undertaken:    WP1 Appraisal of Energy Resource \u0026amp; Converters: Environmental Interaction  WP2 Development of Methodologies for Device Evaluation and Optimisation  WP3 Engineering Guidance  WP4 Offshore Energy Conversion and Power Conditioning  WP5 Chemical Conversion and Storage  WP6 Network Interaction of Marine Energy  WP7 Lifetime Economics  WP8 Moorings and Foundations  WP9 Novel Control Systems for Marine Energy Converters  WP10 Full-scale Field Validation  WP11 Assessment of Testing Procedures for Tidal Current Devices  WP12 Economic, Environmental and Social Impact of New Marine Technologies  WP13 Dissemination and Outreach   The Marine consortium secured continuation funding for Phase 2, supporting a further four years research from October 2007, and this now brings together staff from the Universities of Edinburgh, Queens Belfast, Lancaster, Heriot-Watt and Strathclyde. There are ten work streams (WSs), all of which are scheduled to be completed by October 2011.    WS1 Numerical and physical convergence  WS2 Optimisation of collector form and response  WS3 Combined wave and tidal effects  WS4 Arrays, wakes and near field effects  WS5 Power take-off and conditioning  WS6 Moorings and positioning  WS7 Advanced control of devices and network integration  WS8 Reliability  WS9 Economic analysis of variability and penetration  WS10 Dissemination of results   Two additional programmes have been funded in parallel with the core work streams in Phase 2. The first is a Doctoral Training Programme providing for eighteen PhD studentships across the six named universities and at an additional six affiliate universities active in marine renewable research. The second additional programme is the study of the ecological consequences of tidal and wave energy conversion.  The document consists of five sections and contains three appendices. Section 2 contains detailed discussion of Phase 1, spanning the research effort undertaken in the first four years of the programme. The aims of the future research in Phase 2 are presented in section 3. The two additional programmes associated with Phase 2 are summarised in sections 4 and 5. Details of the individuals involved in the programme, abstracts of the research outputs from Phase 1 grouped by work package, and then alphabetically, are contained in the appendices.  Other SuperGen Monographs:    SuperGen Monograph Phase 2  SuperGen Monograph Phase 3","author":["SuperGen UK Centre for Marine Energy Research (UKCMER)"],"organization":["University of Edinburgh"],"originationDate":"2007-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Supergen-2007-Monograph-Phase1.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2250","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecological-value-submerged-breakwaters-habitat-enhancement-residential-scale","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00267-014-0394-8","title":"Ecological Value of Submerged Breakwaters for Habitat Enhancement on a Residential Scale","description":"Estuarine shorelines have been degraded since humans arrived in the coastal zone. In recent history, a major cause of habitat degradation has been the armoring of shorelines with vertical walls to protect property from erosive\u00a0wave energy; however, a lack of practical alternatives that maintain or enhance ecological function has limited the options of waterfront residents and coastal zone managers. We experimentally investigated the habitat value of two configurations of submerged breakwaters constructed along an eroding shoreline in northwest Mobile Bay, AL (USA). Breakwaters comprised of bagged oyster shell or Reef Ball (TM) concrete domes were built by a community-based restoration effort. Post-deployment monitoring found that: bagged oyster breakwaters supported much higher densities of live ribbed mussels than Reef Ball breakwaters; both breakwater configurations supported increased species richness of juvenile and smaller fishes compared to controls; and that larger fishes did not appear to be affected by breakwater presence. Our study demonstrates that ecologically degraded shorelines can be augmented with small-scale breakwaters at reasonable cost and that these complex structures can serve as habitat for filter-feeding bivalves, mobile\u00a0invertebrates, and young fishes. Understanding the degree to which these structures mitigate erosive\u00a0wave energy\u00a0and protect uplands will require a longer time frame than our 2-year-long study.","author":["Powers, S.","Scyphers, S.","Heck, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.702136000000","-88.233666200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:40","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2251","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/does-stability-local-community-composition-depend-temporal-variation-rates-dispersal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1385110114001610","title":"Does Stability in Local Community Composition Depend on Temporal Variation in Rates of Dispersal and Connectivity?","description":"In ecology understanding variation in connectivity is central for how biodiversity is maintained. Field studies on dispersal and temporal dynamics in community regulating processes are, however, rare. We test the short-term temporal stability in community composition in a soft-sediment benthic community by determining among-sampling interval similarity in community composition. We relate stability to\u00a0in situ\u00a0measures of connectivity (wind, wave, current energy) and rates of dispersal (quantified in different trap types). Waves were an important predictor of when local community taxa are most likely to disperse in different trap-types, suggesting that wave energy is important for connectivity in a region. Community composition at the site was variable and changed stochastically over time. We found changes in community composition (occurrence, abundance, dominance) to be greater at times when connectivity and rates of dispersal were low. In response to periods of lower connectedness dominant taxa in the local community only exhibited change in their relative abundance. In contrast, locally less abundant taxa varied in both their presence, as well as in relative abundance. Constancy in connectivity and rates of dispersal promotes community stability and persistence, suggesting that local community composition will be impacted by changes in the spatial extent over which immigration and emigration operates in the region. Few empirical studies have actually measured dispersal directly in a multi-species context to demonstrate the role it plays in maintaining local community structure. Even though our study does not evaluate coexistence over demographic time scales, it importantly demonstrates that dispersal is not only important in initial recruitment or following a disturbance, but also key in maintaining local community composition.","author":["Valanko, S.","Norkko, J.","Norkko, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.449836200000","10.924788200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2252","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/semi-active-control-sound-radiated-elastic-circular-plate-integrated-adaptive-tuned","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=2589257","title":"Semi-Active Control of Sound Radiated From an Elastic Circular Plate Integrated With Adaptive Tuned Vibration Absorbers","description":"While adaptive tuning of vibration absorbers (ATVA) have been widely studied for vibration control applications, limited studies have been done to explore their potential for noise control applications. This study aims to utilize magnetorheological elastomer (MRE)-based ATVA to control the radiated sound from an elastic plate excited by a plane wave especially at low frequencies. Radiated sound from a clamped circular plate integrated with MRE-based ATVA is analytically studied using classical plate theory. Rayleigh integral approach is, then, used to express the transmitted sound pressure in terms of the plate\u2019s displacement modal amplitude. A MRE-based ATVA under shear mode is investigated. The semi-active Skyhook controller is proposed to attenuate the transverse displacement of the plate and subsequently reduce the radiated sound. The controller determines the current input to the electromagnet and tunes the MRE-based ATVA with the desired stiffness.","author":["Sedaghati, R.","Hemmatian, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-09-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.868255700000","-73.568848800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2253","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/out-wash-spatial-ecology-temperate-marine-shallow-rocky-reef-species-derived-using","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/272762238_Out_in_the_wash_Spatial_ecology_of_a_temperate_marine_shallow_rocky-reef_species_derived_using_acoustic_telemetry","title":"Out in the Wash: Spatial Ecology of a Temperate Marine Shallow Rocky-Reef Species Derived using Acoustic Telemetry","description":"Characterising the movement and habitat affinities of\u00a0fish\u00a0is a fundamental component in understanding the functioning of marine ecosystems. A comprehensive array of acoustic receivers was deployed at two near-shore coastal sites in south-eastern Australia, to examine the movements, activity-space size and residency of a temperate rocky-reef, herbivorous species Girella elevata. Twenty-four G. elevata individuals were internally tagged with pressure-sensing acoustic transmitters across these two arrays and monitored for up to 550 days. An existing network of coastal receivers was used to examine large-scale movement patterns. Individuals exhibited varying residency, but all had small activity-space sizes within the arrays. The species utilised shallow rocky-reef habitat, displaying unimodal or bimodal patterns in depth use. A positive correlation was observed between wind speed and the detection depth of\u00a0fish, with\u00a0fish\u00a0being likely to move to deeper water to escape periods of adverse conditions. Detection frequency data, corrected using sentinel tags, generally illustrated diurnal behaviour. Patterns of habitat usage, residency and spatial utilisation highlighted the susceptibility of G. elevata to recreational fishing pressure. The results from the present study will further contribute to the spatial information required in the zoning of effective marine protected areas, and our understanding of temperate reef\u00a0fish\u00a0ecology.","author":["Gray, C.","Stocks, J.","Taylor, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.401706400000","-5.280911300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2254","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthic-community-composition-submerged-reefs-central-great-barrier-reef","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00338-015-1261-7","title":"Benthic Community Composition on Submerged Reefs in the Central Great Barrier Reef","description":"Community dynamics on coral reefs are often examined only in relatively shallow waters, which are most vulnerable to many disturbances. The Great Barrier Reef World Heritage Area (GBRWHA) includes extensive submerged reefs that do not approach sea level and are within depths that support many coral reef taxa that also occur in shallow water. However, the composition of\u00a0benthic\u00a0communities on submerged reefs in the GBRWHA is virtually unknown. We examined spatial patterns in\u00a0benthic\u00a0community composition on 13 submerged reefs in the central Great Barrier Reef (GBR) at depths of 10-30 m. We show that\u00a0benthic\u00a0communities on submerged reefs include similar species groups to those on neighbouring emergent reefs. The spatial distribution of species groups was well explained by depth and cross-shelf gradients that are well-known determinants of community composition on emergent reefs. Many equivalent species groups occurred at greater depths on submerged reefs, likely due to variability in the hydrodynamic environment among reef morphologies. Hard coral cover and species richness were lowest at the shallowest depth (6 m) on emergent reefs and were consistently higher on submerged reefs for any given depth. These results suggest that disturbances are less frequent on submerged reefs, but evidence that a severe tropical cyclone in 2011 caused significant damage to shallow regions of more exposed submerged reefs demonstrates that they are not immune. Our results confirm that submerged reefs in the central GBR support extensive and diverse coral assemblages that deserve greater attention in ecosystem assessments and management decisions.","author":["Bridge, T.","Roberts, T.","Moloney, J.","Sweatman, H."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-16.597885600000","143.599746000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2255","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/habitat-characterization-tidal-energy-site-using-rov-overcoming-difficulties-harsh","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0278434315300029","title":"Habitat characterization of a tidal energy site using an ROV: Overcoming difficulties in a harsh environment","description":"The Snohomish County Public Utility District (Snohomish) in Washington State USA has undertaken a tidal turbine site investigation at Admiralty Head, the entrance into the Puget Sound, to determine the feasibility of installing two energy conversion plants that will supply electrical power to the local grid. This site is close to shore and to major metropolitan areas that can benefit from this cleanly generated power. Large tidal exchanges take place at this site and can provide predictable and sustainable\u00a0tidal energy. As part of the permitting process Snohomish has undertaken a seafloor investigation to determine the habitat characteristics of the seafloor and inform the appropriate location for the turbines\u0027 placement. In 2010, to assess habitat types multibeam echosounder (MBES) images were produced and ground-truth video surveys using an ROV were undertaken with the requirement that little disturbance occurs to the seafloor. Collection of these data was challenging as the highly dynamic oceanographic and geologic (tectonic) environment made it difficult to undertake in situ observations of the seafloor. Strong tidal currents, even during predicted slack tides, forced new thinking on how data should be collected in order to evaluate the seafloor substrate, habitats and ecology in light that a statistically methodology could not be accomplished, or if indeed a statistical analysis was necessary at all. Additional information on tidal currents has been gathered since these surveys, which should aid in the future collection of data, although the underlying questions about the possibility of, and need for, a statistical analysis remain. Extensive video assessment was needed to produce a map that could exhibit habitat types. This was attempted by focusing on the geology of the seafloor and selecting common organisms, such as sessile and encrusting fauna (e.g., sea anemones, barnacle fields, crinoids) and epifauna (e.g., sea stars) to relate to substrate types. Heavily encrusted and lightly encrusted substrates were mapped to show areas where sediment is presently being transported through the area. ROV line- or timed-transects to count biota appears not to be necessary to obtain information needed to validate marine\u00a0benthic\u00a0habitat types. Rather, general observational transects and more stabilized in situ observational stations used for close examination of the biota and measurement of the substrate is recommended.","author":["Greene, H."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.257375600000","-123.093501500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2256","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effective-energy-saving-device-eco-ship-using-wave-propulsion","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/document\/7890719\/","title":"Effective Energy-Saving Device of Eco-Ship by Using Wave Propulsion","description":"In this work, an effective energy-saving device is proposed to extract wave energy and convert to useful propulsive thrust for a merchant ship travelling in waves. Eco-Ship was internationally introduced and aimed to reduce carbon dioxide emission generated from ships. The energy-saving device equipped underneath the front part of the ship model of general merchant ships that inspired by marine mammals is investigated in this work. An active control of pitch-oscillating bow fin with NACA0016 section is applied as an effective energy-saving device in this work. Free-running model test using a 1\/50th scale model of a container ship was conducted for validating the effectiveness of this device. The ship speed, ship motion, angle of bow fin and power consuming are measured and recorded. There are two kinds of wavelength to ship length ratio of regular wave in the experiments with fixed propeller speed. Based on different heave motion, the different pitch angle of bow fin is controlled to obtain the extra energy from wave. The experimental results shows the feasibility of the energy-saving device when the phase lead of the bow fin pitch motion with respect to its heave motion set in a proper range between 60 degree to 200 degree. When the ratios of wavelength to ship length are 1.0 and 1.3, the maximum of power efficiency improving are around 6.5% and 18.9% respectively. The experimental results demonstrated that the proposed device is effective to enhance ship speed and save energy for achieving the goal of Eco-Ship.","author":["Wu, T.","Tsai, J.","Huang, S.","Hsu, Y.","Guo, J.","Chiu, F."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-10-06","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.694280000000","135.120659900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/huang-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2257","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/searcher-efficiency-survey-coverage-affect-precision-fatality-estimates","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/jwmg.21126\/abstract","title":"Searcher Efficiency and Survey Coverage Affect Precision of Fatality Estimates","description":"Studies at renewable energy sites often attempt to estimate avian and bat fatalities or fatality rates (e.g., fatalities\/megawatt [MW]\/year). However, searcher efficiency and level of survey effort among sites are variable. We evaluated how searcher efficiency and proportion of area surveyed affected precision of fatality estimates and probability of detecting rare fatalities (e.g., fatalities of an endangered species). We measured searcher-efficiency rates of human and dog-handler teams for 3 fatality types: feather spots, small carcasses, and large carcasses. We also created high and low searcher-efficiency scenarios to evaluate effects of searcher efficiency across a broader range. Model selection on a set of logistic regression models for our empirical trials supported search team and fatality type as important predictors of searcher-efficiency rates, and demonstrated that dog-handler teams had higher searcher efficiency for all fatality types than human search teams. We used model simulations to evaluate fatality estimates obtained across the 4 searcher-efficiency scenarios and 10 levels of survey coverage: 10\u2013100%, in increments of 10%. At each level of survey coverage, width of confidence intervals decreased as searcher efficiency increased; however, as survey coverage increased, width of the confidence intervals stabilized, and further increases in coverage did not lead to increases in precision. Average fatality estimates were biased positively and this bias increased with lesser searcher efficiency. The survey coverage necessary to achieve 80% detection probability for rare fatalities (defined as 1, 5, or 15 fatalities) decreased as searcher efficiency increased for all fatality types. When a rare fatality was defined as a single fatality out of 1,000, an 80% detection probability was achieved only by dog-handler teams and the high searcher-efficiency scenario, and only for large carcasses. Our results emphasize the need for managers and agencies to consider study objectives and site characteristics when selecting level of survey coverage, type of search team, and other options to maximize searcher efficiency.","author":["Johnston, D.","Reyes, G.","Lindke, K.","Ayres, K.","Halterman, M.","Boroski, B."],"organization":["HT Harvey and Associates"],"originationDate":"2016-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["36.249236800000","-113.703529600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2258","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-method-approach-determine-impact-existing-wind-power-plants-bird-bat-migration","sourceURL":"","title":"A Multi-Method Approach to Determine the Impact of Existing Wind Power Plants on Bird and Bat Migration on the Island of Fehmarn, Germany","description":"The island of Fehmarn, situated off the German Baltic coast, is well-known for being a hotspot for bird migration. It is assumed that about 100 m Scandinavian birds cross the island each year using the shortest connection between the South of Sweden (Falsterbo), the Danish Baltic islands and the German mainland. To investigate the influence of the existing 4 wind farms on bird (and bat) migration and to be able to assess the possible impact of future developments, a comprehensive research project was carried out in 2009.","author":["Reichenbach, M.","Grunkorn, T."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.468816300000","11.018601100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/reichenbach-grunkorn-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2259","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/characterization-ultrasonic-acoustic-field-wind-turbine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sea-acustica.es\/","title":"Characterization of the Ultrasonic Acoustic Field of a Wind Turbine","description":"Wind energy is a sector of the alternative energy industry that is growing worldwide. However, there are concerns regarding bat fatalities at wind turbines. This phenomenon is widespread and has received attention to warrant investigation into how and why these collisions occur. In this paper we characterize the ultrasonic acoustic field of a wind turbine in order to find out if the turbines emit ultrasound. We conducted this study at Serra dos Candeeiros near Lisbon, Portugal, where some bats have been found injured or dead beneath wind turbines [1]. The measurements were divided into 3 different campaigns: 1) seven acquisitions at ground level in front of the nacelle, 2) five acquisitions around the turbine at ground level and 3) one acquisition inside the nacelle. The analysis of the results shows that the analysed wind turbine does not reveal any ultrasound noise source.","author":["Fonseca, C.","Pereira, M.","In\u00e1cio, O."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2014-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.980594900000","-1.162194700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/pereira-et-al-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2260","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/geographic-origins-population-genetics-bats-killed-wind-energy-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1890\/15-0541\/full","title":"Geographic Origins and Population Genetics of Bats Killed at Wind-Energy Facilities","description":"An unanticipated impact of wind-energy development has been large-scale mortality of insectivorous bats. In eastern North America, where mortality rates are among the highest in the world, the hoary bat (Lasiurus cinereus) and the eastern red bat (L. borealis) comprise the majority of turbine-associated bat mortality. Both species are migratory tree bats with widespread distributions; however, little is known regarding the geographic origins of bats killed at wind-energy facilities or the diversity and population structure of affected species. We addressed these unknowns by measuring stable hydrogen isotope ratios (\u03b42H) and conducting population genetic analyses of bats killed at wind-energy facilities in the central Appalachian Mountains (USA) to determine the summering origins, effective size, structure, and temporal stability of populations. Our results indicate that ~1% of hoary bat mortalities and ~57% of red bat mortalities derive from non-local sources, with no relationship between the proportion of non-local bats and sex, location of mortality, or month of mortality. Additionally, our data indicate that hoary bats in our sample consist of an unstructured population with a small effective size (Ne) and either a stable or declining history. Red bats also showed no evidence of population genetic structure, but in contrast to hoary bats, the diversity contained in our red bat samples is consistent with a much larger Ne that reflects a demographic expansion after a bottleneck. These results suggest that the impacts of mortality associated with intensive wind-energy development may affect bat species dissimilarly, with red bats potentially better able to absorb sustained mortality than hoary bats because of their larger Ne. Our results provide important baseline data and also illustrate the utility of stable isotopes and population genetics for monitoring bat populations affected by wind-energy development.","author":["Gates, J.","Pylant, C.","Nelson, D.","Fitzpatrick, M.","Keller, S."],"organization":["University of Maryland","Frostburg State University","The University of Vermont"],"originationDate":"2016-07-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.595274200000","-85.338622000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:42","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2262","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/importance-coastal-area-bat-migration-western-coast-latvia-implication-localization","sourceURL":"","title":"Importance of coastal area on bat migration at the western coast of Latvia \u2013 implication for localization of wind farms","description":"I. Bats and zoonosis  II. Bats on coast \u2013 Evidence of migration \u2013 Case study in SW Latvia  III. Conclusions","author":["Suba, J.","Petersons, G.","Vintulis, V."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-02-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.840351300000","14.649081200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Petersons-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2263","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/managing-coniferous-production-forests-towards-bat-conservation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.publish.csiro.au\/wr\/wr14256","title":"Managing Coniferous Production Forests Towards Bat Conservation","description":"Context Forest management has impacts on bats worldwide. Given that many forest bats are threatened and that bats are important providers of ecosystem services, understanding the effects of forest management practices on their activity is fundamental for the implementation of conservation measures. Despite these important issues, studies on the effects of management practices on bats are scarce. Aims To propose management measures for coniferous production forests, to ensure sustainability of bat populations. Methods We evaluated bat species richness and activity during gestation, lactation and mating\/swarming\/dispersion seasons in differently managed pine stands to evaluate how vegetation structure influences those variables. Bat activity was surveyed using acoustic monitoring in 28 sampling plots within stands with distinct management records in Portugal. We also sampled arthropods using light traps to ascertain how prey availability influenced bat species richness and activity in those plots. Key results Bat species richness and activity varied along the three phenological seasons and were higher in autumn, when mating, swarming and dispersion from nurseries to hibernacula took place. Prey availability varied, but was higher during the lactation season. We hypothesise that the lower levels of bat species richness and activity registered during that period were due to a reduced availability of roosts, rather than food scarcity. Species richness was positively correlated with canopy cover and prey taxa richness, and negatively associated with dry branches cover. Total bat activity was positively correlated with tree height and prey taxa richness, and negatively associated with dry branches cover. The activity of edge-space foragers was positively associated with average tree height and prey taxa richness, while the activity of open-space foragers was negatively associated with dry branches cover. Conclusions Coniferous production forests are of great importance for bats during the mating\/swarming\/dispersion season. Canopy cover, dry branches cover, tree height and prey taxa richness influence bat species richness and activity as a whole, particularly the activity of open- and edge- foraging guilds. Implications Based on our results, two straightforward management actions should be implemented in coniferous production forests to increase their value for bat assemblages: the maintenance of old coniferous stands, and the cutting of dry branches at the subcanopy level.","author":["Bernardino, J.","Costa, H.","Mascarenhas, M.","Peste, F.","Paula, A.","Pereira, P.","Bastos, C.","Fonseca, C.","Pereira, M.","Viera, J."],"organization":["Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul (UFRGS)","University of Aveiro"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.535532600000","-10.096486300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2264","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-collisions-wind-turbines-southwestern-minnesota","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bioone.org\/journals\/the-american-midland-naturalist\/volume-139\/issue-1\/0003-0031(1998)139%5b0029%3aBFCNWT%5d2.0.CO%3b2\/Bird-Flight-Characteristics-Near-Wind-Turbines-in-Minnesota\/10.1674\/0003-0031(1998)139[0029:BFCNWT]2.0.CO;2.full","title":"Bat Collisions with Wind Turbines in Southwestern Minnesota","description":"Sporadic reports of bat mortality due to collisions with man-made objects exist in the literature. Van Gelder (1956) reported that five red bats (Lasiurus borealis) were killed after colliding with a television tower in Kansas, and Crawford and Baker (1981) reported that over a 25-year period, 54 bats from seven species were killed at a television tower in Florida. Additionally, Saunders (1930) reported that five bats, representing three species, were killed after colliding with a lighthouse at Long Point, Ontario. Bat collisions with wind turbines used to produce electricity also have been noted. At California windplants, Howell and DiDonato (1991) reported finding one dead red bat during a 12-month period, and Orloff and Flannery (1992) reported finding two bat carcasses during a 24-month period.  Recent technological advances have reduced costs associated with wind-power production to a level that is competitive with more traditional methods of producing electricity (Nelson and Curry, 1995). As a result, utility companies increasingly use wind power as an alternative source of energy (Hanson et. al., 1992). While wind power is generally viewed as an environmentally friendly source of energy, the number of avian mortalities at existing windplants has caused concern among many state, federal, and non-profit organizations.  To date, most studies were designed to assess the biological impacts on windplants on bird species. In comparison to birds, bat collisions with wind turbines appear to be infrequent and therefore have receive little attention by natural resource agencies or the scientific community. While conducting a study to asses the impacts of a windplant on birds in southwestern Minnesota, we found several dead bats. The purpose of this paper is to document the species composition and timing of bat mortality associated with the Minnesota windplant during 1994 and 1995. We also review some current theories regarding bat collisions with man-made structures and speculate on the possible causes of bat mortality at windplants.","author":["Higgins, K.","Osborn, R.","Usgaard, R.","Dieter, C."],"organization":["South Dakota State University","Pheasants Forever"],"originationDate":"1998-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.185821100000","-96.216111800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2265","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/direct-drive-surge-wave-energy-converter-grid-integration-functionality","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/etep.2125\/abstract","title":"Direct drive surge wave energy converter with grid integration functionality","description":"This paper addresses the design and simulation validation of a direct drive surge wave energy converter (DDSWEC) as an efficient device for harnessing marine wave energy in near-shore locations. The proposed DDSWEC is composed of a rigid rectangular plate producing linear motions in response to surge forces of ocean waves. A translator is devised to transfer the wave energy to a linear permanent magnet synchronous generator, which all together form the power take-off (PTO) system. In the proposed scheme, the mechanical simplicity of PTO system is a superior feature in reducing power losses in the wave-electric power conversion chain. Additionally, suitable mechanical degrees of freedom lead to an impressive increase in the power conversion efficiency. Besides, mathematical modeling of the mechanical and electrical systems governing DDSWEC is interrogated in depth. In addition, through a comprehensive frequency contents analysis, the capture width of DDSWEC and the device efficiency are scrutinized to validate its well performance. Because the stochastic behavior of waves induces voltages with variable frequency and magnitude, which are undesirable features for grid integration, a full-scale back-to-back converter with both generator and grid-side controls is accordingly implemented. To validate the overall performance of the proposed DDSWEC, a test system is designed in Matlab\/Simulink platform by which several time-domain simulations for both the monochromatic and irregular waves are conducted.","author":["Enferad, E.","Nazarpour, D.","Golshannavaz, S.","Aminifar, F."],"organization":["Urmia University","University of Tehran"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["32.118379500000","44.677211300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2266","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/storm-effects-intertidal-invertebrates-increased-beta-diversity-few-individuals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/peerj.com\/articles\/3360\/","title":"Storm effects on intertidal invertebrates: increased beta diversity of few individuals and species","description":"Climate change is predicted to lead to more extreme weather events, including changes to storm frequency, intensity and location. Yet the ecological responses to storms are incompletely understood for sandy shorelines, the globe\u0027s longest land-ocean interface. Here we document how storms of different magnitude impacted the invertebrate assemblages on a tidal flat in Brazil. We specifically tested the relationships between wave energy and spatial heterogeneity, both for habitat properties (habitat heterogeneity) and fauna (beta-diversity), predicting that larger storms redistribute sediments and hence lead to spatially less variable faunal assemblages. The sediment matrix tended to become less heterogeneous across the flat after high-energy wave events, whereas (beta-diversity) increased after storms. This higher (beta-diversity) was primarily driven by species losses. Significantly fewer species at a significantly lower density occurred within days to weeks after storms. Negative density and biomass responses to storm events were most prominent in crustaceans. Invertebrate assemblages appeared to recover within a short-time (weeks to months) after storms, highlighting that most species typical of sedimentary shorelines are, to some degree, resilient to short-term changes in wave energy. Given that storm frequency and intensity are predicted to change in the coming decades, identifying properties that determine resilience and recovery of ecosystems constitute a research priority for sedimentary shorelines and beyond.","author":["Schlacher, T.","Corte, G.","Checon, H.","Barboza, C.","Siegle, E.","Coelman, R.","Amaral, A."],"organization":["The University of Campinas (Universidade Estadual de Campinas)","The University of the Sunshine Coast (USC)","Federal University of Rio de Janeiro","University of S\u00e3o Paulo (USP)","University of Sydney"],"originationDate":"2017-05-23","spatial":{"coordinates":["-11.799079400000","-44.986679900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Corte-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2267","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-wave-energy-absorption-case-study-fishing-pier-brazil","sourceURL":"","title":"Modeling of Wave Energy Absorption: a Case Study for a Fishing Pier in Brazil","description":"The paper addresses the evaluation of wave energy absorption at a fishing pier in the town of Balneario Arroio do Silva, coastal south region of Brazil. This study considers the use of oscillating-water-column (OWC) converters composed by tubes tied to the pillars of the pier. In order to evaluate the wave energy extraction, the mathematical model of the OWC device for this specific application is obtained. First, wave equations and fluid mechanics theory are used to describe the physical behavior of the air inside the tube. Then the air flux is converted to mechanical torque using Wells turbine equations. The time-domain model is simulated using computational tools and taking into account the actual parameters and the specific wave regime at the fishing pier. The study shall support a future experimental implementation of OWC devices at the fishing pier. In addition, an energy efficiency analysis is developed, in order to reduce the consumption of electricity and energy waste at the fishing pier, and aiming at sustainability and rational use of the energy produced by the proposed OWC device.","author":["Scharlau, C.","D\u0027Aquino, C.","Antunes, V.","Pfitscher, L.","Dalla Vecchia, L."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-14.428043100000","-51.122027900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/vecchia-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2268","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-our-seas-national-institute-oceanography-goa","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.jstor.org\/stable\/24905390?seq=1","title":"Understanding our seas: National Institute of Oceanography, Goa","description":"The present article summarizes the research done at the CSIR-National Institute of Oceanography in 2014 in ocean science, resources and technology. Significant research has been conducted on air sea interactions and coastal circulation, biogeochemistry, biology, marine geophysics, palaeoceanography, marine fishery, gas hydrates and wave energy. Technological advances covered topics like oceanographic tools. Major strides have been made in marine resources research and evaluation.","author":["Naqvi, S.","CSIR-NIO Team"],"organization":["Council of Scientific \u0026 Industrial Research (CSIR) - The National Institute of Oceanography (NIO)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["15.348939500000","73.734735600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2269","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/prawler-vertical-profiler-powered-wave-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/stamp\/stamp.jsp?arnumber=7404354","title":"The PRAWLER, a Vertical Profiler Powered by Wave Energy","description":"We describe a new, wave-powered profiling instrument designed as one part of a low cost, easily deployed, open ocean mooring system. The PRAWLER (PRofiling crAWLER) is a small, 15 kg instrument that uses the motion from an ordinary surface buoy to traverse the upper 500 meters of mooring line by rectifying the vertical motion with a pair of cam cleats. After climbing up to a commanded depth, it free falls and obtains a continuous ocean data profile at a terminal speed of similar to 30 cm\/s. In Pacific and Atlantic Ocean deployments we easily obtain 20 to 30 profiles per day. Two sets of opposing cam cleats permit two additional modes: fixed and climbing down. When fixed to the line, the instrument can obtain a continuous Eulerian time series identical to a discrete instrument, or can park at depth to avoid unnecessary profiles to save power and protect from bio-fouling. It is also able to climb down the wire, needed when equatorial currents pull a mooring over so far such that the drag vector overcomes the instrument net weight. These four positions of the cam cleats are controlled by an ultra-low power microcontroller and a motor that uses about 5 joules per profile.   The PRAWLER is presently equipped with a Seabird pumped CTD and an Aanderaa Dissolved Oxygen Optode. PRAWLER data and commands are transmitted via an inductive modem to the surface buoy, and sent along with buoy meteorological data by Iridium\/RUDICS to shore. Powered by lithium batteries the endurance with 8 profiles per day is about one year. Deployment results and engineering observations are presented.","author":["Osse, T.","Meinig, C.","Stalin, S.","Milburn, H."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-10-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.899461300000","-77.084606400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/osse-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2270","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sensitivity-mussel-mytilus-edulis-substrate-borne-vibration-relation-anthropogenically","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v538\/p185-195\/","title":"Sensitivity of the Mussel Mytilus edulis to Substrate-Borne Vibration in Relation to Anthropogenically Generated Noise","description":"Many anthropogenic activities in the oceans involve direct contact with the seabed (for example pile driving), creating radiating particle motion waves. However, the consequences of these waveforms to marine organisms are largely unknown and there is little information on the ability of\u00a0invertebrates\u00a0to detect vibration, or indeed the acoustic component of the signal. We quantified sensitivity of the marine bivalve Mytilus edulis to substrate-borne vibration by exposure to vibration under controlled conditions. Sinusoidal excitation by tonal signals at frequencies within the range 5 to 410 Hz was applied during the tests, using the \u0027staircase\u0027 method of threshold determination. Thresholds were related to mussel size and to seabed vibration data produced by anthropogenic activities. Clear behavioural changes were observed in response to the vibration stimulus. Thresholds ranged from 0.06 to 0.55 m s(-2) (acceleration, root mean squared), with valve closure used as the behavioural indicator of reception and response. Thresholds were shown to be within the range of vibrations measured in the vicinity of anthropogenic operations such as pile driving and blasting. The responses show that vibration is likely to impact the overall fitness of both individuals and mussel beds of M. edulis due to disruption of natural valve periodicity, which may have ecosystem and commercial implications. The observed data provide a valuable first step to understanding the impacts of such vibration upon a key coastal and estuarine invertebrate which lives near industrial and construction activity, and illustrate that the role of seabed vibration should not be underestimated when assessing the impacts of noise pollution.","author":["Cheesman, S.","Elliott, M.","Roberts, L.","Breithaupt, T."],"organization":["University of Hull","Subacoustech Ltd"],"originationDate":"2015-10-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.282020400000","-4.408903000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2271","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/good-or-bad-vibrations-impacts-anthropogenic-vibration-marine-epibenthos","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969717306290","title":"Good or Bad Vibrations? Impacts of Anthropogenic Vibration on the Marine Epibenthos","description":"Anthropogenic activities directly contacting the seabed, such as drilling and pile-driving, produce a significant vibration likely to impact benthic\u00a0invertebrates. As with terrestrial organisms, vibration may be used by marine species for the detection of biotic and abiotic cues, yet the significance of this and the sensitivities to vibration are previously undocumented for many marine species. Exposure to additional vibration may elicit behavioral or physiological change, or even physical damage at high amplitudes or particular frequencies, although this is poorly studied in underwater noise research. Here we review studies regarding the sensitivities and responses of marine\u00a0invertebrates\u00a0to substrate-borne vibration. This includes information related to vibrations produced by those construction activities directly impacting the seabed, such as pile-driving. This shows the extent to which species are able to detect vibration and respond to anthropogenically-produced vibrations, although the short and long-term implications of this are not known. As such it is especially important that the sensitivities of these species are further understood, given that noise and energy-generating human impacts on the marine environment are only likely to increase and that there are now legal instruments requiring such effects to be monitored and controlled.\u00a0","author":["Elliott, M.","Roberts, L."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.282020400000","-4.408903000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:44","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2272","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/oxyflux-innovative-wave-driven-device-oxygenation-deep-layers-coastal-areas-physical","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378383915001155","title":"OXYFLUX, an innovative wave-driven device for the oxygenation of deep layers in coastal areas: A physical investigation","description":"Coastal areas for anthropic zones are vital economic hubs for tourism,\u00a0fisheries\u00a0and recreational activities. These are just some of the businesses which develop and grow many parts of the world. In terms of water quality, the growth of economy, along with the acceleration of climate change makes it necessary for sustainable coastal defense plans. No other environmental variable of such ecological importance to estuarine and coastal marine ecosystems around the world has changed so drastically, in such a short period of time, as dissolved oxygen in coastal waters. This paper specifically addresses the use of a new floating device called OXYFLUX, (devoid of electromechanical sections), as an innovative approach to altering water quality parameters with the aim of increasing the concentration of dissolved oxygen in the underwater areas near the bottom. This is based on laboratory results. The experiments were carried out on a device in 1:16 scale in wave flume at University of Bologna. OXYFLUX\u0027s functionality is based on floater\u0027s capacity to collect incoming waves into a reservoir that floats on the sea surface. Collected water yields a higher hydraulic head in the reservoir, which in turn induces a downward water flux inside the device body. The dynamic response of the device, and it\u0027s pumping capacity are assessed under a variety of wave conditions by changing wave steepness. Experiments allow a first outline of design recommendations for these kinds of devices. At the end of the paper such guidelines are applied to Northern Adriatic coast conditions.\u00a0","author":["Antonini, A.","Lamberti, A.","Archetti, R."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.213530800000","8.084548600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Water Quality"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2273","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/model-experimental-study-wave-dissipation-effect-double-deck-monomer-floating","sourceURL":"","title":"Model Experimental Study on Wave Dissipation Effect for Double-deck Monomer Floating Structure","description":"The double-deck monomer floating structure under the rules of two-dimensional wave action for the study of physical model experimental, measuring the wave height behind the structure in the experiment, calculated the transmission coefficient. Based on considering the different water depth, the different ways of putting, the different row numbers, the different materials and with or without net cage to analysis the condition of wave dissipation effect. Water depth in 0.5 m, the model above the water of 0.06 m; Water depth in 0.6 m, the model covered 0.04 m and the periods were ranging from 0.8 to 1.1 seconds.   Since the 1950s, China\u0027s coastal erosion is more and more obvious and damage continues to intensify. Such as The DiaoKou River spit in the Yellow River delta from 1976 to 1986 was eroded about 6 km, erosion area was of 100 km(2). From1986 to2002, the corrosion is gone around 1 km, the corrosion area is around 37 km(2[1]). one of the important reason about erosion is the impact of ocean waves([2]). the impact of the wave caused a loss in China Fisheries and Aquaculture, seriously affected the social economic development and people\u0027s living standards. Therefore, the study of coastal zone protection measures, reduce the impact on the deep water aquaculture area of ocean waves is an urgent issue.   Generally measures to prevent coastal erosion mainly include two categories: one is the hard environment, resist the coastline back or cut along the wave energy, such as building breakwater wall, dike, jetty, submerged breakwater, the offshore breakwater etc; second, the soft environment, adopt the methods for simulating the characteristics of coastal systems against coastal erosion, such as filling sand to protect beach, building shelter belt, biological revetment measures. These measures were large Construction, very difficult, working too long, expensive, complex structure and not suitable for deep water aquaculture area, so some floating wave device movement is born, they are construction of small, simple, time short, low cost, light weight and so on relative to the former. In addition, they also do not destroy the waters of the integrity and ecological environment.   There are many floating wave structure type([3-8]), in this paper, it study on a kind of double monomer floating wave structure, especially suitable for the deep waters([9]), waves through the model To achieve wave dissipation effect. Through the permeability coefficient to comparative and analysis of wave dissipation effect, then provide reference for practical engineering applications.","author":["Shen, L.","Zhou, C.","Shang Guan, Z."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-12-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.533751400000","86.070681000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/zhou-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2274","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-criteria-evaluation-wave-energy-projects-south-east-australian-coast","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148116305602","title":"Multi-criteria evaluation of wave energy projects on the south-east Australian coast","description":"In the last decade, multiple studies focusing on national-scale assessments of the ocean wave energy resource in Australia identified the Southern Margin to be one of the most energetic areas worldwide suitable for the extraction of wave energy for electricity production. While several companies have deployed single unit devices, the next phase of development will most likely be the deployment of parks with dozens of units, introducing the risk of conflicts within the marine space.   This paper presents a geo-spatial multi-criteria evaluation approach to identify optimal locations to deploy a wave energy farm while minimizing potential conflicts with other coastal and offshore users. The methodology presented is based around five major criteria: ocean wave climatology, nature of the seabed, distance to key infrastructure, environmental factors and potential conflict with other users such as shipping and fisheries.   A case study is presented for an area off the south-east Australian coast using a total of 18 physical, environmental and socio-economic parameters. The spatial restrictions associated with environmental factors, wave climate, as well as conflict of use, resulted in an overall exclusion of 20% of the study area. Highly suitable areas identified ranged between 11 and 34% of the study area based on scenarios with varying criteria weighting. By spatially comparing different scenarios we identified persistence of a highly suitable area of 700 km(2) off the coast of Portland across all model domains investigated. We demonstrate the value of incorporation spatial information at the scale relevant to resource exploitation when examining multiple criteria for optimal site selection of Wave Energy Converters over broad geographic regions.","author":["Ierodiaconou, D.","Flocard, F.","Coghlan, I."],"organization":["University of New South Wales","Deakin University"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-24.990801300000","115.213307800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2275","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-wave-behavior-fetch-depth-limited-estuaries","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/pubmed\/28098236","title":"Wind Wave Behavior in Fetch and Depth Limited Estuaries","description":"Wetland dominated estuaries serve as one of the most productive natural ecosystems through their ecological, economic and cultural services, such as nursery grounds for fisheries, nutrient sequestration, and ecotourism. The ongoing deterioration of wetland ecosystems in many shallow estuaries raises concerns about the contributing erosive processes and their roles in restraining coastal restoration efforts. Given the combination of wetlands and shallow bays as landscape components that determine the function of estuaries, successful restoration strategies require knowledge of wind wave behavior in fetch and depth limited water as a critical design feature. We experimentally evaluate physics of wind wave growth in fetch and depth limited estuaries. We demonstrate that wave growth rate in shallow estuaries is a function of wind fetch to water depth ratio, which helps to develop a new set of parametric wave growth equations. We find that the final stage of wave growth in shallow estuaries can be presented by a product of water depth and wave number, whereby their product approaches 1.363 as either depth or wave energy increases. Suggested wave growth equations and their asymptotic constraints establish the magnitude of wave forces acting on wetland erosion that must be included in ecosystem restoration design.","author":["Chen, Q.","Karimpour, A.","Twilley, R."],"organization":["Louisiana State University"],"originationDate":"2017-01-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["31.650124400000","-112.046265700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Karimpour-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2276","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/possible-behavioural-energetic-demographic-effects-displacement-red-throated-divers","sourceURL":"https:\/\/data.jncc.gov.uk\/data\/e9cb4b91-cf6d-440c-b9e3-c363bac51f86\/JNCC-Report-605-REVISED-WEB.pdf","title":"Possible Behavioural, Energetic and Demographic Effects of Displacement of Red-throated Divers","description":"Red-throated divers (Gavia stellata) use marine areas in the North Sea, Irish Sea and Baltic Sea during the non-breeding season. They are known to be displaced by various marine industry activities, including construction and operation of offshore wind farms. However, the consequences of displacement for individuals and consequently on the population as a whole are unknown. On 2nd May 2017, seven scientists with particular expertise in redthroated diver ecology and\/or the energetic and demographic consequences of displacement for marine birds were invited to a workshop. Using their expertise and knowledge of divers and other marine birds, plus fundamental ecological principles, some generalisations about how red-throated divers might be affected by displacement were sought. This report comprises the main points of discussion and agreement during the workshop.  For displacement to cause a population-level change the following needs to occur. Divers need to show a behavioural response to anthropogenic marine structures, leading them to forage in a different area. This needs to cause a change in energy budgets either through increased energy costs of displacement and barrier effects or decreased energy intake through reduced prey acquisition and assimilation. This, in turn, would lead to poorer body condition with associated impacts on demographic rates, e.g. reduced breeding success or survival. Finally, a sufficient number of individuals need to have altered demographic rates for it to affect population growth rate and size.  It is difficult to draw concrete conclusions about how displacement will affect individuals and populations of red-throated divers, in the absence of empirical evidence. Based on our understanding of the ecology of red-throated divers and similar species, the following would seem to be more likely.  Red-throated divers appear capable of utilising a range of marine habitats and prey species. They also tend to occur at relatively low densities and not in large aggregations. Consequently, reduced prey intake caused by increased density-dependent competition or interference would seem unlikely. Red-throated divers are highly mobile in winter which may mean they are better able to find alternative foraging sites following displacement. However, individuals tend to be relatively site faithful in winter and in their choice of staging\/moulting areas (even though there is large variation among individuals in choice of site). Redthroated divers show a strong stress response and this could temporarily limit their ability to exploit new locations following displacement, even if prey is abundant. Without understanding why divers are so mobile and how their behaviour changes following displacement, it is not possible to infer the energetic consequences of displacement with any certainty.  Year-round energetic budgets of red-throated divers are unknown but this information is key to understanding the possible consequences of displacement. An understanding of redthroated diver time budgets during winter, e.g. proportion of time spent foraging, would indicate when individuals are struggling to find sufficient food and might be in poorer condition. If red-throated divers tend to be in poorer condition in the non-breeding season when displacement is occurring, displacement could have an impact on survival and productivity. However, if individuals are in relatively good condition during the non-breeding season and spend only a small proportion of their daily activity budget foraging, they may have the capacity to buffer against any additional energetic expense of displacement and barrier effects.","author":["Furness, R.","Zydelis, R.","Petersen, I.","Dierschke, V.","Daunt, F.","Gray, C.","Schmutz, J."],"organization":["Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)","Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC)","Vattenfall"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Waterfowl","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Dierschke-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2277","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-over-fish-communities-submarine-cable-installation-biscay-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/285512261_Environmental_impacts_over_fish_communities_of_submarine_cable_installation_in_the_Biscay_Marine_Energy_Platform_bimep","title":"Environmental impacts over fish communities of submarine cable installation in the Biscay Marine Energy Platform (bimep)","description":"The Biscay Marine Energy Platform ( bimep ) is an offshore infrastructure for the demonstration and testing of wave energy harnessing devices promoted by the Basque Entity of Energy (Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda - EVE). Bimep is located close to Arminza town (Basque Country, Northern Spain) and it consists on an 5.3 km 2 sea area between 50 and 90 m depths where four static submarine cables will be placed, operating at 13kV and 5MW. On the first of June 2009, the General Council on Environmental Quality Assessment of the Ministry of Rural, Marine and Natural Environment of the Spanish Government, on the light of the Environmental Impact Study (EIS) o f the bimep project undertaken by AZTI in 2008, decided not to submit the project to the whole Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process. Nevertheless, the Environmental Impact Statement (EISt) of the Ministry, taking into account the great uncertainti es about some predicted environmental impacts, underlined the need to implement the proposed Environmental Monitoring Program (EMP) of the EIS. Amo ng other environmental factors and impact over fish communities was foreseen due to sound and vibrations expected to be generated during submarine cable installation . Hence, on August 29 of 2013, the EVE entrusted to AZTI to carry out the EMP of the fish communities during installation of the sub marine cables in bimep , which consist on and active acoustic motorization of fish communities by means of five M3i buoys developed by Marine Instruments ( www.marineinstruments.es ) and placed in each of the fo ur mooring areas and one far enough from BIMEP area to act as control site . The results obtained were compared with those obtained during the preoperational phase of the EMP ( carried on 2012 ) , showing that the observed impacts were in the range of those pr edicted in the EIS of bimep .","author":["Torre-Enciso, Y.","Bald, J.","Uriarte, A.","Marina, D.","Fontan, A."],"organization":["AZTI","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.425092000000","-2.947424000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:32:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bald-et-al-2015e.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2278","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-over-seabed-benthic-communities-submarine-cable-installation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/285512267_Environmental_impacts_over_the_seabed_and_benthic_communities_of_submarine_cable_installation_in_the_Biscay_Marine_Energy_Platform_bimep","title":"Environmental impacts over the seabed and benthic communities of submarine cable installation in the Biscay Marine Energy Platform (bimep)","description":"The Biscay Marine Energy Platform ( bimep ) is an offshore infrastructure for the demonstration and testing of wave energy harnessing devices promoted by the Basque Entity of Energy (Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda - EVE). Bimep is located close to Arminza town (Basque Country, Northern Spain) and it consists on an 5.3 km2 sea area between 50 and 90 m depths where four static submarine cables will be placed, operating at 13kV and 5MW. On the first of June 2009, the General Council on Environmental Quality Assessment of the Ministry of Rural, Marine and Natural Environment of the Spanish Government, on the light of the Environmental Impact Study (EIS) of the bimep project undertak en by AZTI in 2008, decided not to submit the project to the whole Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process. Nevertheless, the Environmental Impact Statement (EISt) of the Ministry, taking into account the great uncertainties about some predicted envi ronmental impacts, underlined the need to implement the proposed Environmental Monitoring Program (EMP) of the EIS. Among other environmental factors, substratum alteration was foreseen to occur during the commissioning stage of the submarine cables and co nsequently may affect related benthic habitats and species. Hence, on August 29 of 2013, the EVE entrusted to AZTI to carry out the EMP of the installation of the submarine cables in bimep , which consist on: (i) a seabed characterisation with a multi - beam echo sounder ; (ii) a characterization of benthic communities and seabed disturbance by means of a visual inspection with a submarine camera attached to a Remote Operated Vehicle (ROV) all along the submarine cable route and the mooring areas. The results o btained were compared with those obtained during the preoperational phase of the EMP ( carried on 2012 ) , showing that the observed impacts were in the range of those predicted in the EIS of bimep .","author":["Muxika, I.","Martinez, J.","Torre-Enciso, Y.","Bald, J.","Galparsoro, I.","Rodriguez, J.","Marina, D.","Hern\u00e1ndez, C.","Cruz, I.","Ruiz, J.","Markiegui, M."],"organization":["AZTI","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.425092000000","-2.947424000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:33:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bald-et-al-2015d.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2279","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-characterization-submarine-cable-installation-biscay-marine-energy-platform","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/285512370_Acoustic_characterization_of_submarine_cable_installation_in_the_Biscay_Marine_Energy_Platform_bimep","title":"Acoustic characterization of submarine cable installation in the Biscay Marine Energy Platform (bimep)","description":"The Biscay Marine Energy Platform ( bimep ) is an offshore infrastructure for the demonstration and testing of wave energy harnessing devices promoted by the Basque Entity of Energy (Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda - EVE). Bimep is located close to Arminza town (Basque Country, Nor thern Spain) and it consists on an 5.3 km 2 sea area between 50 and 90 m depths where four static submarine cables will be placed, operating at 13kV and 5MW. On the first of June 2009, the General Council on Environmental Quality Assessment of the Ministry of Rural, Marine and Natural Environment of the Spanish Government, on the light of the Environmental Impact Study (EIS) of the bimep project undertaken by AZTI in 2008, decided not to submit the project to the whole Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process. Nevertheless, the Environmental Impact Statement (EISt) of the Ministry, taking into account the great uncertainties about some predicted environmental impacts, underlined the need to implement the proposed Environmental Monitoring Program (EMP) o f the EIS. Among other environmental factors, an increase in noise from shipping activity would be expected during installation of submarine cable s and consequently may affect marine mammal communities . Hence, on August 29 of 2013, the EVE entrusted to AZTI to carry out the acoustic EMP of the installation of the submarine cables , which consist on an acoustic characterization of : (i) sound background levels ; (ii) cable installation operations; and (iii) a propagation of the measured cable i nstallation sound. The results showed a background level of 70 - 80 dB. The acoustic signal during cable installation is characterized by a 11 kHz frequency and 188,5 dB re 1\u03bcPa which is able to affect a 400 km 2 area. Impacts over marine mammal\u2019s communities were not expected due to the temporality, the season and intensity of the installation operations.","author":["Torre-Enciso, Y.","Bald, J.","Uriarte, A.","Marina, D.","Hern\u00e1ndez, C.","Ruiz, P.","Ortega, N.","Alonso, D."],"organization":["AZTI","Centro Tecnol\u00f3gico Naval y del Mar","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.425092000000","-2.947424000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:32:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bald-et-al-2015c.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2280","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-monitoring-plan-pre-operational-phase-biscay-marine-energy-platform","sourceURL":"","title":"Environmental Monitoring Plan of the pre-operational phase of the Biscay Marine Energy Platform (bimep) project","description":"The Biscay Marine Energy Platform (bimep) is an offshore infrastructure for the demonstration and testing of wave energy harnessing devices promoted by the Basque Entity of Energy (Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda - EVE). Bimep is located close to Arminza town (Basque Country, Northern Spain) and it consists on an 5.3 km2 sea area between 50 and 90 m depths where four static submarine cables will be placed, operating at 13kV and 5MW. On the first of June 2009, the General Council on Environmental Quality Assessment of the Ministry of Rural, Marine and Natural Environment of the Spanish Government, on the light of the Environmental Impact Study (EIS) of the bimep project undertaken by AZTI in 2008, decided not to submit the project to the whole Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process. Nevertheless, the Environmental Impact Statement (EISt) of the Ministry, taking into account the great uncertainties about some predicted environmental impacts, underlined the need to implement the proposed Environmental Monitoring Program (EMP) of the EIS which is proposed to be undertaken in four different steps or phases: (i) preoperational phase; (ii) during installation and commissioning and (iii) operational phase. This work presents the methodology and results of the preoperational phase on some environmental factors such as, icthiofauna, benthic communities, marine acoustics, mammals, and hydrodynamics. The results of this phase have improved the information and characterization of the environmental characteristics of the bimep area described in the EIS, which will be used in later phases of the EMP in order to check if the observed impacts are in the range of the impacts foreseen in the EIS, together with the checking of the fulfilment of mitigating measures proposed in the EIS.","author":["Muxika, I.","Martinez, J.","Torre-Enciso, Y.","Bald, J.","Galparsoro, I.","Gonzalez, M.","Liria, P.","Marina, D.","Hern\u00e1ndez, C.","Mader, J.","Adarraga, I.","Cruz, I.","Merkiegui, M.","Ruiz, J."],"organization":["AZTI","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.425092000000","-2.947424000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:31:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bald-et-al-2015b.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2281","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impact-study-biscay-marine-energy-platform-bimep-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/285512168_The_Environmental_Impact_Study_of_the_Biscay_Marine_Energy_Platform_bimep_project","title":"The Environmental Impact Study of the Biscay Marine Energy Platform (BiMEP) project","description":"The Biscay Marine Energy Platform (BiMEP) is an offshore infrastructure for the demonstration and testing of wave energy harnessing devices promoted by the Basque Entity of Energy (Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda - EVE). Bimep is located close to Arminza town (Basque Country, Northern Spain) and it consists on an 5.3 km2 sea area between 50 and 90 m depths where four static submarine cables will be placed, operating at 13kV and 5MW. According to the Royal Decree 1\/2008 of Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA), the bimep project falls into the 4.c category of projects of Annex II of this Decree. Such classification involves that the competent authority for environmental issues, that is, the General Directory for Quality and Environmental Evaluation of the Spanish Ministry of Environment, Rural and Marine Environ ment, has to decide whether or not the project needs to undergo the complete procedure of an EIA. On the first of June 2009, the General Council on Environmental Quality Assessment of the Ministry of Rural, Marine and Natural Environment of the Spanish Government, on the light of the Environmental Impact Study (EIS) of the bimep project undertaken by AZTI in 2008, decided not to submit the project to the whole Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process. The EIS considered that the main actions associated with the project that could cause impacts were related to the installation process and the physical presence of structures (i.e. submarine cables, moorings and WECs), which could generate conflicts between different users of the area, as well as underwater noise, electromagnetic fields, reduction of marine energy, etc. The present contribution explains the main findings of the EIS: (i) description of the project; (ii) environmental characteristics of bimep area; (iii) expected impacts; (iv) mitigation meas ures and (iii) environmental monitoring plan","author":["Muxika, I.","Torre-Enciso, Y.","Bald, J.","Del Campo, A.","Franco, J.","Galparsoro, I.","Gonzalez, M.","Liria, P.","Solaun, O.","Uriarte, A.","Marina, D.","Hern\u00e1ndez, C.","Menchaca, I."],"organization":["AZTI","Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda (EVE)"],"originationDate":"2015-04-24","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.425092000000","-2.947424000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:32:51","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bald-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2282","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/swansea-bay-tidal-lagoon-adaptive-environmental-management-plan","sourceURL":"","title":"Swansea Bay Tidal Lagoon Adaptive Environmental Management Plan","description":"Tidal Lagoon Swansea Bay Plc (TLSB) is proposing the development of a tidal lagoon (the Project) in Swansea Bay, South Wales for the purpose of ge nerating electricity. This Adaptive Environmental Management Plan (AEMP) Revision 4 represents the fourth revision of the AEMP that was produced as Appendix 23.1 of the Environmental Statement (ES), to accompany TLSB\u2019s application for a Development Consent Order (DCO) for the Project. The AEMP provides a framework for the monitoring and mitigation of effects of the Project. It is based upon:    The baseline surveys and monitoring already completed and reported upon in the ES (TLSB, 2014) and those following its completion; and  The surveys and monitoring planned as the Project progresses through the pre - construction, construction and operational phases in respect of potential effects identified during the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process, the Habitats Regulation Asse ssment (HRA) and the Water Framework Directive (WFD) compliance assessment.   It should be noted that this AEMP will be updated as the Project progresses as a result of discussions between TLSB and other parties, particularly in light of the data emerging from the monitoring undertaken. This is seen as an essential part of the process to validate the findings of the extensive studies that have been undertaken to determine the potential effects of this novel renewable energy development. This accords with Policy set out on page 18 of the EC Guidance Note \u2018The implementation of the Birds and Habitats Directives in estuaries and coastal zones with particular attention to port development and dredging\u2019 (2011) that: \u201cWhere uncertainties or lack of knowledge on physical, morphological or biological processes still exist, these should be minimized as far as possible by additional research; where uncertainty remains adaptive monitoring programmes should be foreseen. New evidence and scientific information should be fed back into the management plan and where necessary lead to an appropriate adaptation of the management measures and monitoring schemes.\u201d   A distinction should be made between surveys (which are used to gather information) and monitoring (which is under taken in order to validate an assumption or review an effect against a target). Due to the long lifespan of the Project (up to 120 years or more), monitoring or surveys that are required during the decommissioning and post - decommissioning phases will be de veloped prior to the commencement of that process. This is secured by provisions in the DCO.  Any monitoring or surveys that are programmed to take place pre-construction or during construction and that will not be continued during the operation phase are covered within the Construction Environmental Management Plan (CEMP). The exception to this is the marine mammal monitoring during piling activity, because information from this The third revision of the AEMP was issued on 28 October 2014 with changes shown in green font. Principal changes to text between the third and fourth revisions are shown in Blue font . In this document, references to the \u0022AEMP\u0022 are to this revision, unless the context requires otherwise . Tidal Lagoon Swansea Bay plc Swansea Bay Tidal Lagoon Adaptive Environmental Management Plan \u2013 Revision 4 Page 2 will inform future monitoring strategies. Therefore, excluding the above, a n umber of surveys and monitoring are not covered within the AEMP, e.g. unexploded ordnance, marine and terrestrial archaeology, land quality and hydrogeology (onshore site investigations). Note, with respect to marine archaeology, data from the bathymetric surveys immediately post - construction will be reviewed. This and other monitoring during the construction phase will be detailed in the Written Scheme of Investigation.  The AEMP will guide the monitoring of the effects of the Project at each stage of its progress. In the same way that results of the baseline surveys and monitoring carried out for the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) process have informed this document, so the results of pre-construction and construction-phase monitoring will provide up-to-date baseline data for operational - phase monitoring. During the lifespan of the Project, the AEMP will be updated, and it is for this reason that this is an adaptive plan (as noted previously). The document will continue to be updated and refined to give the best possible understanding of the Project\u2019s environmental effects enabling mitigation to be adjusted, where necessary.","author":["Tidal Lagoon Swansea Bay Plc"],"organization":["Tidal Lagoon Power"],"originationDate":"2014-11-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.587986000000","-3.905560000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Swansea-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2284","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-onshore-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"","title":"Bats and onshore wind turbines","description":"The renewable energy industry is expanding rapidly, driven in part by concerns about climate change. Wind energy, generated by both onshore and offshore installations, is a major contributor, though it currently accounts for only a few percent of UK energy demand. Government targets for renewable energy generation and extrapolation from current installation rates suggest that there may be between 1500-2000 onshore wind turbines by 2010. Little evidence is available to properly assess any adverse impacts on bats in the UK or set such risks in context with the environmental impacts of other methods of power generation. In mainland Europe and North America, evidence of bat collisions has led to growing concern about the siting and operation of wind turbines. The most serious incidents have involved bat species that fly very high and for long journeys, particularly species on long distance migrations. In mainland Europe, noctules, common pipistrelles and Nathusius\u2019 pipistrelles are most frequently recorded as turbine casualties. When assessing adverse impacts, we need to distinguish between (a) individual casualties and (b) mortality that affects populations. We are currently unable to say whether populations of bats are likely to be at risk from turbines in the UK because the evidence base is inadequate. Research, with support from the British Wind Energy Association, is now under way to address this issue. Bats and their roosts are legally protected by domestic and international legislation. The purpose of the legislation is to maintain and restore protected species to a situation where their populations are thriving, and there is sufficient habitat to ensure this will continue. Generic guidance on assessing the impact of wind turbines on bats has been developed at the European level under the Eurobats Agreement (Bonn Convention), to which the UK is a signatory, see Further information below. The Eurobats Resolution, under which the guidance was developed, urges all Parties to develop national guidelines on bat surveys and risk assessment, drawing on the generic European ones. Such national guidelines should be tailored to the situation in a specific country, and reflect the best available evidence at the time.","author":["Natural England"],"organization":["Natural England"],"originationDate":"2009-02-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.052097500000","-12.395963300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/natural-england-2009.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2285","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/use-forest-edges-bats-managed-pine-forest-landscape","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.2193\/2008-471\/abstract","title":"Use of forest edges by bats in a managed pine forest landscape","description":"Forest edges often have increased species richness and abundance (edge effect) and affect spatial behaviors of species and dynamics of species interactions. Landscapes of intensively managed pine (Pinus spp.) stands are characterized by a mosaic of patches and linear forest edges. Managed pine forests are a primary landscape feature of the southeastern United States, but the effects of intensive management on bat communities are poorly understood. Insectivorous bats are important top predators in nocturnal forest food webs. We examined bat foraging behavior along forest edges and in 4 structurally distinct stand types (open-canopy pine, prethinned pine, thinned pine, and unmanaged forest) within a managed pine forest in the coastal plain of North Carolina, USA. During May-August, 2006 and 2007, we recorded echolocation calls using Pettersson D240X bat detectors linked to digital recorders at 156 sites. We also sampled nocturnal flying insects at each site using Malaise insect traps. We used negative binomial count regression models to describe bat foraging behavior relative to forest edges, stand types, and prey availability. Although some species showed affinities for certain stand types and prey items, bat activity patterns were most strongly related to forest edges. Edges were used extensively by 6 aerial-hunting bat species, but avoided by Myotis species. Forest edges function similarly to natural forest gaps, by providing foraging opportunities for aerial-hunting bat species. Therefore, the maintenance of forest edges in managed pine landscapes may enhance foraging habitat for aerial-hunting bat species.","author":["Miller, D.","Morris, A.","Kalcounis-Rueppell, M."],"organization":["University of North Carolina","Weyerhaeuser Company"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["34.981044500000","-99.772865900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2286","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/landscape-scale-effects-single-multiple-small-wind-turbines-bat-activity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/acv.12331\/abstract","title":"Landscape-Scale Effects of Single- and Multiple Small Wind Turbines on Bat Activity","description":"While the effects of wind farms on bats are widely studied, effects of small wind turbines (SWTs, here \u0026lt;25 m hub height) remain understudied. SWTs are installed in a wider range of habitats compared to wind farms and their effect on wildlife can therefore be different. While single SWTs can adversely affect bat activity in their immediate vicinity, they are often installed in clusters, and to date, no data are available on whether installation of more than one turbine increases the likelihood of adverse effects on bats. Here, we test whether (1) SWT installations affect the activity of two species of bat (the common pipistrelle Pipistrellus pipistrellus and soprano pipistrelle P. pygmaeus) on a landscape scale (here defined as up to 500 m from SWTs) and (2) such an effect is stronger when multiple (2\u20134) SWTs are installed. We show that, after accounting for potentially confounding effects (e.g. variation in habitat and weather), (1) mean P. pipistrellus activity is lower at 0\u2013100 m compared to 200\u2013500 m from SWTs and (2) the effect on P. pygmaeus activity tends to be similar and stronger in multiple SWT sites, although evidence for the latter is limited. We conclude that in some cases, adverse effects of SWTs on bat activity may be measurable over longer spatial scales (within 100 m) than previously thought. However, combined with earlier findings, it is likely that the bulk of such effects operate within relative close proximity of SWTs (\u0026lt;25 m). Moreover, although these effects may be species-specific, with, for example, P. pygmaeus potentially more strongly affected by multiple SWT sites, this requires further data. These findings are highly relevant to decision-making aimed at minimizing any adverse effects of wind turbines, specifically single- versus multiple SWT developments, on wildlife.","author":["Park, K.","Minderman, J.","Gillis, M.","Daly, H."],"organization":["University of Stirling"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.640880400000","-7.672170200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2287","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/brazilian-free-tailed-bats-tadarida-brasiliensis-molossidae-chiroptera-high-altitude","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icb\/article-lookup\/doi\/10.1093\/icb\/icn033","title":"Brazilian free-tailed bats (Tadarida brasiliensis: Molossidae Chiroptera) at high altitude: links to migratory insect populations","description":"Existing information on the activity of bats in the aerosphere is restricted almost exclusively to altitudes that are within a few tens of meters above the ground. We report a total of 50.2 h of ultrasonic recordings made using radio microphonic bat detectors suspended from free-floating helium balloons and from kites. The data include a total of 22 353 echolocative calls from ground-level to 1118 m above ground level (AGL). These calls are attributed to Brazilian free-tailed bats based on acoustic features and the large numbers and high-altitude aerial dispersion of these bats over the local landscape. Bat activity varied significantly throughout the air column and was greatest at 400\u2013500 m AGL and near ground level. Feeding buzzes, indicating feeding on aerial prey, were most abundant near ground level and at 400\u2013500 m, and were detected to altitudes of \u223c 900 m AGL. The peak activity of bats at 400\u2013500 m AGL is concordant with the altitude of the atmospheric boundary layer and the seasonal formation of the low-elevation southerly wind jet that has been identified as a major aeroecological corridor for the nocturnal dispersal of noctuid moths and other insects.","author":["McCracken, G.","Jensen, M.","Westbrook, J.","Gillam, E.","Lee, Y.","Balsley, B."],"organization":["University of Colorado Boulder","University of Tennessee","US Department of Agriculture (USDA)"],"originationDate":"2008-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.755878500000","-90.469471800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/mccracken-et-al-2008.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2288","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/integration-nature-protection-environmental-wind-farm-assessment-procedures-croatia","sourceURL":"","title":"The integration of nature protection into environmental wind farm assessment procedures in Croatia","description":"The Republic of Croatia has an area of 87,661 km2, with 56,594 km2 of land surface. The territory is organised into 21 counties. Due to specific geographical position between several biogeographic regions and diverse ecological, climatic and geomorphological conditions, Croatia is one of the richest European countries in terms of biodiversity. There is an increasing trend towards shifting away from conventional energy production forms to new renewable energy sources (RES), due to the current energy crisis, environment pollution and climate change issues. However, controversial issues have arisen with regard to impact of RES on biodiversity. Energy Development Strategy of the Republic of Croatia sets out the goal to reach 9 to 10% of wind generated electricity in overall electricity consumption by 2020, with the estimated installed power of 1,200 MW. At present, wind farms in Croatia produce 87,8 MW of energy. But the increasing number of wind farms presents a potential threat to biodiversity, especially to certain bird species and bats.","author":["Mazija, M.","Domazetovi\u0107, Z.","Elez, L.","Randi\u0107, B."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.453334500000","14.226014000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/mazija-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2289","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/reducing-bat-fatalities-wind-facilities-while-improving-economic-efficiency","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/jmammal\/article\/98\/2\/378\/3064950","title":"Reducing Bat Fatalities at Wind Facilities while Improving the Economic Efficiency of Operational Mitigation","description":"Concerns about cumulative population-level effects of bat fatalities at wind facilities have led to mitigation strategies to reduce turbine-related bat mortality. Operational mitigation that limits operation may reduce fatalities but also limits energy production. We incorporated both temperature and wind speed into an operational mitigation design fine-tuned to conditions when bats are most active in order to improve economic efficiency of mitigation. We conducted a 2-year study at the Sheffield Wind Facility in Sheffield, Vermont. Activity of bats is highest when winds speeds are low (\u0026lt; 6.0 m\/s) and, in our region, when temperatures are above 9.5\u00b0C. We tested for a reduction in bat mortality when cut-in speed at treatment turbines was raised from 4.0 to 6.0 m\/s whenever nightly wind speeds were \u0026lt; 6.0 m\/s and temperatures were \u0026gt; 9.5\u00b0C. Mortalities at fully operational turbines were 1.52\u20134.45 times higher than at treatment turbines. During late spring and early fall, when overnight temperatures generally fell below 9.5\u00b0C, incorporating temperature into the operational mitigation design decreased energy losses by 18%. Energy lost from implementation of our design was \u0026lt; 3% for the study season and approximately 1% for the entire year. We recommend that operational mitigation be implemented during high-risk periods to minimize bat fatalities and reduce the probability of long-term population-level effects on bats.","author":["Arnett, E.","Stevens, R.","Wallace, M.","Martin, C."],"organization":["Texas Tech University"],"originationDate":"2017-03-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.885779800000","-73.429816700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Martin-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2290","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthic-impacts-loch-linnhe-artificial-reef","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/1-4020-4697-9_30","title":"The benthic impacts of the Loch Linnhe Artificial Reef","description":"Artificial reefs are man-made structures that are placed on the seabed to mimic natural reefs. The Loch Linnhe Artificial Reef will consist of up to 40 reef modules, when completed, each constructed using concrete blocks. As part of this complex, reef modules of approximately 200 tonnes were deployed in June 2001 and January 2002 and form the basis of this study. Sediment samples were taken adjacent to-, and 5 m from, the reef perimeters and characterised in terms of sediment oxygenation (redox), particle size, organic carbon (loss on ignition) and coarseness (material \u003E1 mm and 1 mm) present in the sediment were linked to chemico-physical changes occurring as a consequence of the reef. Both reefs trapped macroalgal phytodetritus at the perimeters, which subsequently decomposed. This accumulated material isolated the seabed from the overlying water column and was associated with a decrease in sediment oxygenation that was linked to changes in community structure. Loss-on-ignition (LOI) was significantly higher around one reef compared with 5 m from that reef. The reefs did not cause significant changes in the sediment texture (median particle size or coarseness) and neither LOI nor sedimentary texture changes were associated with community change.","author":["Wilding, T."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)"],"originationDate":"2006-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.610400000000","-5.437069000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Physical Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2291","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-artificial-reef-performance-approaches-pre-post-deployment-research","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/icesjms\/article\/59\/suppl\/S222\/617945\/Evaluating-artificial-reef-performance-approaches","title":"Evaluating artificial reef performance: approaches to pre- and post-deployment research","description":"The deployment of large man-made structures in inshore coastal areas has the potential for causing significant hydrographical and biological changes in the receiving environments. Often the ability to determine changes resulting from significant impacts has been compromised by the lack of pre-deployment data. The Loch Linnhe artificial reef is a 42 000 tonnes reef complex that is proposed for deployment in the period 2001\u20132004. A series of baseline data sets were generated in the 4 years preceding construction to facilitate multi-parameter post-reef deployment comparisons. Hydrographical data included a detailed assessment of tidal current dynamics over the complete spring\u2013neap tidal cycle. Sedimentological research included broad-scale remote acoustic surveys coupled with sediment granulometric analysis. Seasonal changes in oxygen levels through the sediment column were also determined. The existing biological community at the proposed site was assessed through monthly diver observation and remote sediment grab sampling. These data sets will form the basis of a comprehensive evaluation of reef impacts and performance to be made post-reef construction","author":["Wilding, T.","Sayer, M."],"organization":["Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)"],"originationDate":"2002-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.610400000000","-5.437069000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes","Physical Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2292","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-fatality-risk-model-wind-farms-dobrogea-romania-using-gis-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/273767550_A_bat_fatality_risk_model_at_wind_farms_in_Dobrogea_Romania_using_a_GIS_approach","title":"A bat fatality risk model at wind farms in Dobrogea, Romania, using a GIS approach","description":"During the last 7 years, wind farms have powerfully developed in Dobrogea, Romania, due to low population density and favorable wind conditions, reaching 892 turbines at the beginning of 2014, with several projects still in construction. A total of 27 bat species were recorded in the area, which is also considered a migratory route, due to its proximity to the sea. Environmental impact assessments, conceived in the preconstruction phases, were based solely on ultrasound detection and had a limited view on the seasonal changes in species diversity or key landscape features that may arouse interest for bats. This study compiles the information collected in three years of pre and post construction monitoring (2011-2014) of bat activity and mortality at various wind facilities in the study area, in order to generate a regional GIS model of the potential mortality risk. The species which were considered more vulnerable are the ones that recorded mortality values in the mentioned period (Pipistrellus nathusii, P. kuhlii, P. pipistrellus, P. pygmaeus, Vespertilio murinus, Nyctalus noctula, N. leisleri, Eptesicus serotinus, E. nilsonii).","author":["Stanciu, C.","\u015eandric, I.","M\u0103ntoiu, D.","Chisamera, G.","Chachula, O.","Marginean, G.","Pocora, I.","Pocora, V.","Hodor, C.","Popescu-Mirceni, R.","Alexandra, T.","Drago\u015f, B."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.097837300000","28.078032300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:48","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Poster-mantoiu-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2293","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/radar-visual-study-nocturnal-bird-bat-migration-proposed-prattsburgh-italy-wind-power","sourceURL":"","title":"A radar and visual study of nocturnal bird and bat migration at the proposed Prattsburgh-Italy wind power project, New York, spring 2005","description":"This report presents the results of a radar andvisual study of bird and bat migrationconducted during 14 August\u201329 September2004 at the proposed Prattsburgh\u2013Italy WindPower project, located in Yates and Steubencounties, west-central New York. Radar andvisual observations were conducted for ~6.5h\/night during 45 nights during the fall.","author":["Mabee, T.","Cooper, B.","Plissner, J."],"organization":["ABR Inc"],"originationDate":"2005-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.296800500000","-75.156976600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/mabee-et-al-2005.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2294","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-bat-mortality-doppler-shift-profiles-ultrasonic-bat-pulse-reflection","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/full\/10.1121\/1.3479540","title":"Wind turbines and bat mortality: Doppler shift profiles and ultrasonic bat-like pulse reflection from moving turbine blades","description":"Bat mortality resulting from actual or near-collision with operational wind turbine rotors is a phenomenon that is widespread but not well understood. Because bats rely on information contained in high-frequency echoes to determine the nature and movement of a target, it is important to consider how ultrasonic pulses similar to those used by bats for echolocation may be interacting with operational turbine rotor blades. By assessing the characteristics of reflected ultrasonic echoes, moving turbine blades operating under low wind speed conditions (\u0026lt;6 m s(-1)) were found to produce distinct Doppler shift profiles at different angles to the rotor. Frequency shifts of up to \u00b1700-800 Hz were produced, which may not be perceptible by some bat species. Monte Carlo simulation of bat-like sampling by echolocation revealed that over 50 rotor echoes could be required by species such as Pipistrellus pipistrellus for accurate interpretation of blade movement, which may not be achieved in the bat\u0027s approach time-window. In summary, it was found that echoes returned from moving blades had features which could render them attractive to bats or which might make it difficult for the bat to accurately detect and locate blades in sufficient time to avoid a collision.","author":["Lepper, P.","Long, C.","Flint, J."],"organization":["Loughborough University"],"originationDate":"2010-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.052097500000","-12.395963300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2296","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mitigating-bat-fatalities-wind-power-plants-through-targeted-curtailment-results-4","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/307174665_Mitigating_Bat_Fatalities_from_Wind-power_Plants_through_Targeted_Curtailment_Results_from_4_years_of_Testing_of_CHIROTECHC","title":"Mitigating Bat Fatalities from Wind-Power Plants through Targeted Curtailment: Results from 4 Years of Testing of CHIROTECH","description":"Research program reconciling conservation of bats and development of wind facilities.  Hypothesis: Peaks of bat activity don\u2019t match peaks of production of wind turbines.","author":["Kerbiriou, C.","Ughetto, A.","Lagrange, H.","Rico, P.","Bas, Y.","Melki, F."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-02-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.326242000000","17.847464200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/lagrange-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2297","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-migration-across-southern-north-sea-possible-implications-offshore-wind-farms","sourceURL":"","title":"Bat Migration Across the Southern North Sea and Possible Implications for Offshore Wind Farms","description":"Introduction and study area  Summary results pilot studies 2012 - 2014  More extensive monitoring 2015 \/ 2016  Preview of some of the preliminary results  Patterns of occurrence and species involved  Occurrence in relation to weather conditions  Bats and offshore wind farms  Conclusions  Options for future research","author":["Lagerveld, S.","Platteeuw, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.161482400000","4.282735200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/WREN-Lagerveld-Platteeuw-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2299","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/analysis-possible-displacement-bird-marine-mammal-species-related-installation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/snh-commissioned-report-947-analysis-possible-displacement-bird-and-marine-mammal-species-related","title":"Analysis of the Possible Displacement of Bird and Marine Mammal Species Related to the Installation and Operation of Marine Energy Conversion Systems","description":"The European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) was established, in Orkney, in 2003 to enable the deployment and testing of wave and tidal energy converters. Since then, numerous devices have been tested at both the wave and tidal energy test sites, at Billia Croo and the Fall of Warness, respectively. For most of the time since, land-based wildlife observations have been made at both sites, primarily to inform Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) and Habitats Regulation Appraisal (HRA) requirements for development there, but also to help understand potential interactions between marine renewables related activity and wildlife.  This study provides a comprehensive review of the wildlife observed at both locations since observations began and, specifically, investigates the potential influence of device installation, operation and related activity, upon marine wildlife distribution and abundance. Spatial and temporal variations in relation to wider environmental parameters, unrelated to development activity, are also considered.","author":["Long, C."],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage","Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Marine Mammals","Habitat Change","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-20 10:16:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Long-2017-SNH-947.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2300","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/capturing-energy-motion-ocean-crowded-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/08920753.2016.1208877","title":"Capturing Energy from the Motion of the Ocean in a Crowded Sea","description":"Conversion to renewable energy sources is a logical response to the increasing pressure to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. Ocean\u00a0wave energy\u00a0is the least developed renewable energy source, despite having the highest energy per unit area. While many hurdles remain in developing\u00a0wave energy, assessing potential conflicts and evaluating tradeoffs with the existing uses is essential. Marine planning encompasses a broad array of activities that take place in and affect large marine ecosystems, making it an ideal tool for evaluating\u00a0wave energy\u00a0resource use conflicts. In this study, we used a spatially explicit, open source decision support tool to evaluate\u00a0wave energy\u00a0facility development off the U.S. west coast. We then used this output to identify potential conflicts between\u00a0wave energy\u00a0facilities and the existing marine uses in the context of marine planning. We found that regions with the highest\u00a0wave energy\u00a0potential were distant from major cities and that infrastructure limitations (cable landing sites) restrict integration with the existing power grids. We also identified multiple potential conflicts, including commercial fishing, shipping and transportation, and marine conservation areas. While\u00a0wave energy\u00a0generation facilities may be economically viable, we must also incorporate costs associated with conflicts that arise with the existing marine uses.","author":["Plummer, M.","Feist, B."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.614994200000","-122.475988700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2301","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/combined-optical-acoustic-monitoring-fishes-demonstration-site-marine-renewable-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=2570906","title":"Combined Optical and Acoustic Monitoring of Fishes in the Demonstration Site of Marine Renewable Energy Development","description":"Before the installation of marine renewable energy devices, fish species and abundance should be examined for selecting the proper site where the effects of the devices on the environment and fish will be as small as possible. Fish species and abundance can be examined in a variety of methods such as a fish finder using an acoustic wave and fishing gears such as a gill net. However, the fish finder cannot specify the species of fish that is sometimes estimated from the experience of fishermen or scientific researchers. Some amounts of fish must be removed from the target sea area in case of using the fishing gear, while the species of fish can be specified. In the present study, an underwater optical video camera is combined with the fish finder using an acoustic wave to specify the species of fish. A circular fish-eye digital video camera is inserted into a waterproof container. A part of the container is made of glass in a dome shape for the circular fish-eye lens. The container is attached to polyethylene ropes and is towed by a fishing vessel. First, the hydrodynamic characteristics of the container was examined by a towing test with the three kinds of towing speed in a water tank. Then the container was towed in the real sea, which is the demonstration site of offshore wind and wave energy developments off Kamaishi of Iwate Prefecture. The depth of the video camera with the container was not constant since the moving speed of the fishing vessel was slow and fluctuating. The image of video camera could be captured successfully together with that of the acoustic video camera, while fish could not be found in both the optical and acoustic measurements in the present investigation. The investigation will be continued, and the effects of transparency of water should be discussed as future works. Also the actual or model fish should be captured by the underwater video camera to evaluate if it can specify the species of fish.","author":["Kitazawa, D.","Mizukami, Y."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-06-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.290157800000","141.685481100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2302","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ecological-morphological-traits-predict-depth-generalist-fishes-coral-reefs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/rspb.royalsocietypublishing.org\/content\/283\/1823\/20152332","title":"Ecological and morphological traits predict depth-generalist fishes on coral reefs","description":"Ecological communities that occupy similar habitats may exhibit functional convergence despite significant geographical distances and taxonomic dissimilarity. On coral reefs, steep gradients in key environmental variables (e.g. light and wave energy) restrict some species to shallow depths. We show that depth-generalist reef fishes are correlated with two species-level traits: caudal fin aspect ratio and diet. Fishes with high aspect ratio (lunate) caudal fins produce weaker vortices in the water column while swimming, and we propose that \u0027silent swimming\u0027 reduces the likelihood of detection and provides an advantage on deeper reefs with lower light irradiance and water motion. Significant differences in depth preference among trophic guilds reflect variations in the availability of different food sources along a depth gradient. The significance of these two traits across three geographically and taxonomically distinct assemblages suggests that deep-water habitats exert a strong environmental filter on coral reef-fish assemblages.","author":["Bridge, T.","Luiz, O.","Coleman, R.","Kane, C.","Kosaki, R."],"organization":["James Cook University","Australian Institute of Marine Science (AIMS)","Macquarie University","University of Hawaii","Washington State University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["-24.990801300000","115.213307800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2303","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/holistic-method-selecting-tidal-stream-energy-hotspots-under-technical-economic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0196890416301352","title":"A Holistic Method for Selecting Tidal Stream Energy Hotspots Under Technical, Economic and Functional Constraints","description":"Although a number of prospective locations for tidal stream farms have been identified, the development of a unified approach for selecting the optimum site in a region remains a current research topic. The objective of this work is to develop and apply a methodology for determining the most suitable sites for tidal stream farms, i.e. sites whose characteristics maximise power performance, minimise cost and avoid conflicts with competing uses of the marine space. Illustrated through a case study in the Bristol Channel, the method uses a validated hydrodynamics model to identify highly energetic areas and a geospatial Matlab-based program (designed ad hoc) to estimate the energy output that a tidal farm at the site with a given technology would have. This output is then used to obtain the spatial distribution of the levelised cost of energy and, on this basis, to preselect certain areas. Subsequently, potential conflicts with other functions of the marine space (e.g. fishing, shipping) are considered. The result is a selection of areas for tidal stream energy development based on a holistic approach, encompassing the relevant technical, economic and functional aspects. This methodology can lead to a significant improvement in the selection of tidal sites, thereby increasing the possibilities of project acceptance and development.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Vazquez, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.693863900000","-3.435715200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:50","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2304","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/role-nature-based-infrastructure-nbi-coastal-resiliency-planning-literature-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0301479716307484","title":"The role of nature-based infrastructure (NBI) in coastal resiliency planning: A literature review","description":"The use of nature-based infrastructure (NBI) has attracted increasing attention in the context of protection against coastal flooding. This review is focused on NBI approaches to improve coastal resilience in the face of extreme storm events, including hurricanes. We not only consider the role of NBI as a measure to protect people and property but also in the context of other ecological goods and services provided by tidal wetlands including production of fish and shellfish. Although the results of many studies suggest that populated areas protected by coastal marshes were less likely to experience damage when exposed to the full force of storm surge, it was absolutely critical to place the role of coastal wetlands into perspective by noting that while tidal marshes can reduce wave energy from low-to-moderate-energy storms, their capacity to substantially reduce storm surge remains poorly quantified. Moreover, although tidal marshes can reduce storm surge from fast moving storms, very large expanses of habitat are needed to be most effective, and for most urban settings, there is insufficient space to rely on nature based risk reduction strategies alone. The success of a given NBI method is also context dependent on local conditions, with,potentially confounding influences from substrate characteristics, topography, near shore bathymetry, distance from the shore and other physical factors and human drivers such as development patterns. Furthermore, it is important to better understand the strengths and weaknesses of newly developed NBI projects through rigorous evaluations and characterize the local specificities of the particular built and natural environments surrounding these coastal areas. In order for the relevant science to better inform policy, and assist in land-use challenges, scientists must clearly state the likelihood of success in a particular circumstance and set of conditions. We conclude that \u0022caution is advised\u0022 before selecting a particular NBI method as there is no \u0022one size fits all\u0022 solution to address site specific conditions.","author":["Saleh, F.","Weinstein, M."],"organization":["Stevens Institute of Technology","Montclair State University"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.139332400000","-75.852239100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2305","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/global-ecological-success-thalassoma-fishes-extreme-coral-reef-habitats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1002\/ece3.2624","title":"Global ecological success of Thalassoma fishes in extreme coral reef habitats","description":"Phenotypic adaptations can allow organisms to relax abiotic selection and facilitate their ecological success in challenging habitats, yet we have relatively little data for the prevalence of this phenomenon at macroecological scales. Using data on the relative abundance of coral reef wrasses and parrotfishes (f. Labridae) spread across three ocean basins and the Red Sea, we reveal the consistent global dominance of extreme wave-swept habitats by fishes in the genus Thalassoma, with abundances up to 15 times higher than any other labrid. A key locomotor modification-a winged pectoral fin that facilitates efficient underwater flight in high-flow environments-is likely to have underpinned this global success, as numerical dominance by Thalassoma was contingent upon the presence of high-intensity wave energy. The ecological success of the most abundant species also varied with species richness and the presence of congeneric competitors. While several fish taxa have independently evolved winged pectoral fins, Thalassoma appears to have combined efficient high-speed swimming (to relax abiotic selection) with trophic versatility (to maximize exploitation of rich resources) to exploit and dominate extreme coral reef habitats around the world.","author":["Wainwright, P.","Fulton, C.","Hoey, A.","Bellwood, D."],"organization":["Australian National University","University of California Davis","James Cook University","King Abdullah University of Science and Technology (KAUST)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["20.321229400000","36.262433800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fulton-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2306","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-hazards-microtidal-shore-platforms-testing-relationship-between-morphology","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s11069-016-2714-1","title":"Wave hazards on microtidal shore platforms: testing the relationship between morphology and exposure","description":"Open-ocean rocky coasts are dangerous environments when there is a coincidence of recreational activities occurring in areas of high wave energy. Management of drowning fatalities and near-drowning incidents on these landforms is difficult as traditional approaches to beach safety cannot be easily transferred to rocky shores. In this study, we take a morphological approach to quantifying the relative danger of shore platforms in microtidal regions. Platform elevation and nearshore water depth are key variables in determining the likelihood of wave overtopping of the platform edge. The relationship between these variables is tested along a 70-km-long section of the Otway Ranges coast in Victoria, Australia. It is found that exposure is highly variable along short (100 m scale) sections of shore platforms. This variability is driven by the complexity of the nearshore morphology which can have metre-scale relief. As exposed platforms may occur in areas of low wave energy, the morphological exposure index is combined with nearshore wave energy to produce a risk rating. Risk, like exposure, was found to be highly spatially variable. The relationship between elevation and water depth has the potential to provide managers with a tool for assessing safety on rocky shores.","author":["Kennedy, D.","Ierodiaconou, D.","Weir, A."],"organization":["University of Melbourne","Deakin University"],"originationDate":"2017-01-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["-34.153695500000","117.736975900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2307","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wave-energy-flow-reduce-abundance-size-benthic-species-oyster-reefs","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v569\/p25-36\/","title":"Wave energy and flow reduce the abundance and size of benthic species on oyster reefs","description":"Hydrodynamic forces associated with waves influence the structure and function of rocky intertidal communities, but their effects on species composition and morphology within other marine communities have not been well studied. We measured wave characteristics and current speeds with acoustic Doppler velocimeters (ADVs) at oyster (Crassostrea virginica) reefs in St Charles and Aransas Bays, Texas. We investigated wave effects on communities at these reefs by comparing species composition, relative abundance, and species morphology on windward versus leeward sides. In addition, acorn barnacles Amphibalanus eburneus were used as biological indicators of flow because they develop larger basal diameters and shorter feeding appendages in faster flows. Waves were higher and current speed was faster on the windward sides of oyster reefs. Leeward sites had a greater abundance and diversity of species. Brachyuran crabs were significantly larger and more abundant when shielded from waves. Porcelain crabs Petrolisthes armatus were smaller and, in contrast to brachyuran crabs, more abundant at windward sites. Windward sites had fewer\u00a0fish\u00a0species though there was no difference in the size of\u00a0fish\u00a0found on either side of the reef. Barnacles settling in late spring had larger basal diameters but relatively shorter feeding appendages in windward areas, compared to leeward areas; these morphological differences mirrored ADV measurements, verified long-term differences in flow and were indicative of bigger waves and higher flow velocities in windward locations. Thus, oyster reefs can reduce wave height and slow current velocity and influence the diversity, abundance, and morphology of associated species. The decrease in wave height can provide shoreline protection, an ecosystem service of oyster reefs often mentioned but rarely measured.","author":["Smee, D.","Lunt, J.","Reustle, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-04-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["29.911194400000","-98.839593300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2308","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/regional-ecological-risk-assessment-kaipara-harbour-new-zealand-using-relative-risk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/10807039.2014.976046","title":"A Regional Ecological Risk Assessment of the Kaipara Harbour, New Zealand, Using a Relative Risk Model","description":"A regional ecological risk assessment was conducted for the Kaipara Harbour catchment in New Zealand. The Relative Risk Model was used to prioritize management of the sources of stress and habitats of concern in the basin. Semi-structured interviews with 25 representative stakeholders were conducted to obtain the resource-users\u0027 perspectives and to identify the regional stressor sources and receptor habitat data for the model. For this risk analysis we divided the catchment into nine ecological districts. Mixed-methodological approaches including content analysis, geospatial analysis, and source documentation were used to categorize source and habitat rankings, based on the relative abundance of each in the nine ecological districts. Risk characterization revealed that fishing pressure and\u00a0tidal energy\u00a0pose the largest sources of perceived risk to the catchment; shellfish and Maui dolphin habitats are the receptors estimated to be at greatest risk; and the Kaipara and Rodney ecological districts are the sub-regions estimated with the greatest combined risk. A Monte Carlo analysis confirmed the source inputs and revealed greater uncertainty than the estimated habitat input results. The results of this assessment can be used by policy-makers, conservation groups, and municipalities to inform the future management efforts in the harbor and catchment.","author":["Kanwar, P.","Bowden, W.","Greenhalgh, S."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-05-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["-36.345010400000","174.085192500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2309","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/numerical-models-enabling-tools-tidal-stream-energy-extraction-environmental-impact","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=2570904","title":"Numerical Models as Enabling Tools for Tidal-Stream Energy Extraction and Environmental Impact Assessment","description":"This paper presents a modeling study conducted to evaluate tidal-stream energy extraction and its associated potential environmental impacts using a three-dimensional unstructured-grid coastal ocean model, which was coupled with a water-quality model and a tidal-turbine module. The unstructured-grid tidal-turbine model was first applied to investigate the effects of different tidal farm configurations on tidal energy extraction and the effects on the system flow field as well as biogeochemical transport processes in an idealized bay with a narrow channel connecting to the coastal ocean. Model results indicated that a large number of turbines are required to extract the maximum tidal energy and cause significant reduction in the volume flux. Model results also showed that tidal energy extraction has a greater effect on flushing time than on volume flux reduction. In the idealized tidal channel, a 10% reduction of volume flux caused by tidal energy extraction would result in an approximately 50% increase in flushing time in the bay. The flushing time increases exponentially as a function of flow reduction. A water-quality model simulation was conducted to investigate the dynamic effect of tidal energy extraction on water quality in a stratified tidal channel and estuary system. Model results showed that deployment of tidal turbines in the channel would increase vertical mixing in the bay. However, extraction of tidal energy also would result in a decrease in bottom dissolved oxygen in the bay during summer, which may cause hypoxia in fish. Finally, the tidal-turbine model was applied to a real-world site in Puget Sound a highly energetic estuary on the US Pacific Northwest coast. The model application of tidal energy extraction in Puget Sound demonstrated the advantage of using an unstructured-grid modeling approach with high grid resolution near the tidal-turbine farm within a large model domain. This study showed that a numerical model can be a useful tool for assessing tidal energy extraction and its environmental impacts and for informing regulatory and policy processes for tidal energy development.","author":["Yang, Z.","Wang, T."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-06-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["35.164509700000","128.990766800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2310","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multi-scale-temporal-patterns-fish-presence-high-velocity-tidal-channel","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0176405","title":"Multi-Scale Temporal Patterns in Fish Presence in a High-Velocity Tidal Channel","description":"The natural variation of fish presence in high-velocity tidal channels is not well understood. A better understanding of fish use of these areas would aid in predicting fish interactions with marine hydrokinetic (MHK) devices, the effects of which are uncertain but of high concern. To characterize the patterns in fish presence at a tidal energy site in Cobscook Bay, Maine, we examined two years of hydroacoustic data continuously collected at the proposed depth of an MHK turbine with a bottom-mounted, side-looking echosounder. The maximum number of fish counted per hour ranged from hundreds in the early spring to over 1,000 in the fall. Counts varied greatly with tidal and diel cycles in a seasonally changing relationship, likely linked to the seasonally changing fish community of the bay. In the winter and spring, higher hourly counts were generally confined to ebb tides and low slack tides near sunrise and sunset. In summer and fall of each year, the highest fish counts shifted to night and occurred during ebb, low slack, and flood tides. Fish counts were not linked to current speed, and did not decrease as current speed increased, contrary to observations at other tidal power sites. As fish counts may be proportional to the encounter rate of fish with an MHK turbine at the same depth, highly variable counts indicate that the risk to fish is similarly variable. The links between fish presence and environmental cycles at this site will likely be present at other locations with similar environmental forcing, making these observations useful in predicting potential fish interactions at tidal energy sites worldwide.","author":["Viehman, H.","Zydlewski, G."],"organization":["University of Maine"],"originationDate":"2017-05-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.840343300000","-67.150779900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-22 03:59:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Viehman-Zydlewski-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2311","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/onset-barotrauma-injuries-related-number-pile-driving-strike-exposures-hybrid-striped","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/1.4984976","title":"Onset of Barotrauma Injuries Related to Number of Pile Driving Strike Exposures in Hybrid Striped Bass","description":"Previous studies exploring injury response to pile driving in fishes presented exposure paradigms (\u003E900 strikes) that emulated circumstances where fish would not leave an area being ensonified. Those studies did not, however, address the question of how many strikes are needed before injuries appear. Thus, the number of strikes paired with a constant single strike sound exposure level (SELss) that can cause injuries is not yet clear. In order to examine this question, hybrid striped bass (white bass Morone chrysops\u2009\u00d7\u2009striped bass Morone saxatilis) were exposed to 8\u2013384 strikes in three different SELss treatments that generated different cumulative sound exposure level values. The treatment with the highest SELss values caused swim bladder injuries in fish exposed to as few as eight pile strikes. These results have important implications for pile driving operations where SELss values meet or exceed the exposure levels used in this study.","author":["Carlson, T.","Casper, B.","Popper, A.","Halvorsen, M."],"organization":["CSA Ocean Sciences Inc","University of Maryland"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2312","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sound-propagation-through-stochastic-ocean","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.4984019","title":"Sound Propagation Through the Stochastic Ocean","description":"More than 35 years ago, a book \u0022Sound Transmission through a Fluctuating Ocean\u0022 was published by a group of members of the JASON study group. That book presented a number of theoretical ideas about the effects of oceanic internal waves on acoustic propagation. These ideas were taken from other fields of physical sciences. An example is the studies of twinkling starlight due to propagation through atmospheric turbulence. These studies were adequate for the development of adaptive optics. Such ideas are a reasonable starting point for developing an understanding of some features of ocean acoustic propagation. Unfortunately, these ideas were subsequently treated as lore, rather than as conjectures to be tested by a rigorous application of the scientific method.\n\nThe current book is an update of that previous book. Much of the theoretical conjecture from the previous book is again presented as fact, and the justification is still missing. The ocean case is quite different from the starlight case for a number of reasons. Two major reasons are that the wavelengths in the optics case are much smaller in relation to the medium fluctuation than are they in the acoustics case and the oceanic correlation scales in the vertical are much smaller than in the horizontal, and propagations of interest in the topic of this book are mostly horizontal.","author":["Henyey, F."],"organization":["Washington State University"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:52","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2313","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-seabirds-new-offshore-wind-energy-test-demonstration-projects-biscay-marine","sourceURL":"","title":"Impact on seabirds of new offshore wind energy test and demonstration projects in the Biscay Marine Energy Platform (BiMEP, N. Spain)","description":"Promoted by the Basque Energy Board (EVE) , BiMEP represents an offshore test site for the demonstration of wave energy converters (WEC) in Armintza (Bizkaia, Basque Country, Northern Spain). Recent developments have promoted the interest of BiMEP facilities for the testing and demonstration of offshore wind developments as well, allowing the installation of a maximum of 2 offshore floating wind mills of 5 MW each (physical dimensions showed in the picture on the left). Consequently, new and different environmental impacts from the original projects are expected. Among others, an impact over seabirds was foreseen taking into account that BiMEP project is inside an Special Protection Area (SPA) for birds declared under the Birds Directive (Directive 2009\/147\/EC), the ES0000490 Mundaka - Cabo de Ogo\u00f1o Special Bird Protection Area .","author":["Torre-Enciso, Y.","Bald, J.","Franco, J.","Marina, D.","Menchaca, I."],"organization":["AZTI","Biscay Marine Energy Platform (BiMEP)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.425092000000","-2.947424000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 07:29:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bald-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2314","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluating-visual-impact-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1876610217307038","title":"Evaluating the Visual Impact of an Offshore Wind Farm","description":"The objective of this paper is to present a method that qualifies the degree of visibility of an offshore wind farm from an observer located along the coast. In many cases, the deployment of an offshore wind farm leads to public opposition. This entails the need for the development of appropriate methods that might present in the most intelligible way the impacts of an offshore wind farm. Amongst many factors to take into account, the visual impact of such farms is surely a factor to take into account. We introduce a visual operator that integrates several parameters that mainly depend on the distance of the wind farm to the coast. We apply a measure that evaluates the horizon surface impact modulated by the number of distinguishable turbines and an aesthetic index based on turbine alignments. The whole method is implemented on top of Geographical Information System (GIS) and provides a decision-aid mechanism oriented to decision-makers. The whole approach is experimented in the context of a wind farm in North West France.","author":["Wang, T.","Maslov, N.","Claramunt, C.","Tang, T."],"organization":["French Naval Academy Research Institute","Shanghai Maritime University"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.130570000000","-2.601667000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Maslov-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2315","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/public-participation-wind-energy-projects-located-germany-which-form-participation-key","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117304068","title":"Public Participation in Wind Energy Projects Located in Germany: Which Form of Participation is the Key to Acceptance?","description":"It is widely recognized that social aspects play an important role in the implementation of wind energy projects. The energy transition in Germany can only succeed if the needs and expectations of local citizens are taken into account. Previous research has shown that public participation fosters the acceptance of wind energy by citizens. This study explores which form of participation citizens prefer with respect to wind energy projects. Opportunities for participation range from no participation, alibi participation, information, consultation, cooperation and financial participation. We used a hypothetical choice experiment in which people are asked to choose between different wind energy projects that were described by a number of attributes. The results show that the most important factors influencing the acceptance of wind energy projects are the sound level at the place of residence, the distance of the turbines to the place of residence and participation opportunities. With regard to participation, respondents prefer information over financial participation. The results suggest that citizens should be involved in informative and deliberative participation processes.","author":["Langer, K.","Decker, T.","Menrad, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2316","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/outer-bay-fundy-tidal-energy-development-where-leviathans-live","sourceURL":"","title":"Outer Bay of Fundy Tidal Energy Development: Where the Leviathans Live","description":"The objectives of this presentation are to introduce Fundy Tidal and sites, give an overview of the environmental work done to date, and outline some of the next steps and opportunities to collaborate.","author":["Malinka, C.","Trowse, G."],"organization":["Fundy Tidal Inc","SMRU Consulting"],"originationDate":"2014-10-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.369760000000","-64.402540000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Trowse-Malinka-2014.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2317","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/will-communities-open-offshore-wind-lessons-learned-new-england-islands-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214629617301172","title":"Will Communities \u0022Open-Up\u0022 to Offshore Wind? Lessons Learned from New England Islands in the United States","description":"National-scale polls demonstrate high levels of public support for developing renewable energy while local opposition has led to delays and cancelations of renewable energy projects around the world. What makes for robust public engagement processes to reject or site renewable energy projects? A literature review reveals numerous considerations, with complexity that impedes their application by practitioners. In this study, we conducted interviews and document analysis to assess the extent to which design principles from the analytic-deliberative process literature arose during public engagement on three New England islands adjacent to proposed offshore wind farms. In our study sites\u2014amongst the array of criteria in the literature\u2014good public engagement boiled down to two key themes: enabling bidirectional deliberative learning and providing community benefit. Decision processes perceived as effective occurred when (1) participants, including experts and local stakeholders, learned from each other while reconciling technical expertise with citizen values; and (2) outcomes included the provision of collaboratively negotiated community benefits. Our findings highlight that community benefits are not the same as benefits to groups of individuals. Attending to these key themes may improve the quality of interactions among communities, government authorities and developers when deciding if and where to site renewable energy infrastructure.","author":["Chan, K.","Klain, S.","Satterfield, T.","MacDonald, S.","Battista, N."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.187310200000","-72.549302400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/klain-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2318","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-mortality-due-collision-wind-turbines-kutch-district-gujarat-india","sourceURL":"https:\/\/threatenedtaxa.org\/index.php\/JoTT\/article\/view\/1520","title":"Bat mortality due to collision with wind turbines in Kutch District, Gujarat, India","description":"Globally, India is at fifth position in wind power generation with an installed capacity of 14550 MW. Based onrecent reports from certain parts of the world there is also a growing concern on the environmental impact of wind turbines on bats and birds in other places too. In the Indian context the impact of wind farms on birds and bats are less studied with very little scientific literature available on the subject. Since September 2011, we have been conducting research on birds and bats mortality in wind farms of Kutch District, Gujarat, India. During the study period two carcasses of the Greater Mouse-tailed Bat Rhinopoma microphyllum were recorded due to collision with wind turbines.","author":["Kumar, S.","Arun, P.","Samsoor-Ali, A."],"organization":["Salim Ali Centre for Ornithology and Natural History (SACON)"],"originationDate":"2013-09-26","spatial":{"coordinates":["22.406425700000","69.090101200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/kumar-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2319","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-report-wind-turbine-related-bat-mortality-southwestern-minnesota","sourceURL":"https:\/\/files.dnr.state.mn.us\/eco\/nongame\/projects\/consgrant_reports\/2000\/2000_krenz_mcmillan.pdf","title":"Final Report: Wind-turbine related bat mortality in southwestern Minnesota","description":"Mortality of animals that fly into man-made structures has been studied for buildings, communication towers, and more recently, for large turbines that convert wind energy into electrical power (Johnson et al., 2000; Osborn et al., 1996). The development of wind energy at Buffalo Ridge, Lincoln and Pipestone Counties, Minnesota, was initiated in 1994. Three phases of development, identified by discrete locations, time of construction, and different developers, include phase II (P2; 143 turbines) and phase III (P3; 138 turbines). A state-ordered study of bird mortality at Buffalo Ridge (Johnson et al., 2000) incidentally found about three-fold more bats than birds in 1998 and 1999, but that monitoring project ended in 1999. Our purpose in this research was to extend the monitoring of P2 and P3 into 2000 using identical methods, and to analyze the data from all three years to test the following hypotheses:  H1: No difference exist among years in the species composition of bats killed.  H2: No differences exist among years in the relative mortality rate per turbine.  H3: No significant correlation exists between mortality rate and adjacent land-use type.  H4: Mortality is random with respect to time-of-year.  Herein we provide brief methods, results, interpretation, and all data collected (see Appendix 1). In addition to the final report, we have included a copy of our manuscript in preparation for submission to American Midland Naturalist. Because this manuscript is only a draft, we provide it to you as a courtesy and ask that it not be reproduced or published. As soon as they are available, you will be provided with a copy of the manuscript submitted for publication and a copy of the published version to be included into the final report on this grant. For a full introduction to the project and statement of hypotheses, see the attachement (Krenz et al. unpublished manuscript).","author":["Krenz, J.","McMillan, B."],"organization":["Minnesota State University"],"originationDate":"2000-12-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.939807600000","-93.176093100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2025-12-26 11:55:36","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/krenz-mcmillan-2000.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2320","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/avian-mortality-associated-top-iowa-wind-farm-progress-report-calendar-year-2003","sourceURL":"","title":"Avian mortality associated with the Top of Iowa Wind Farm: Progress Report, Calendar Year 2003","description":"We examined bird and bat mortality at a new 89-turbine windfarm constructed in an environmentally sensitive area in north-central Iowa. The windfarm became operational in November 2001. It is located in cropland between three Wildlife Management Areas (WMA\u0027s) with historically high bird use. In the past, migrant and resident waterfowl, shorebirds, raptors, and songbirds moved between the WMA\u0027s through the area now occupied by the windfarm. Studies of bird collision mortality in California and elsewhere raised concerns about the possibility of mortalities in this area. From April 15, 2003 and December 15, 2003 we searched for dead animals under 26 randomly selected turbines. Six 76.2 m by 3.0 m transects were maintained as bare ground under each of these turbines. Access roads and construction pads under turbines were also searched. We found two birds (a yellow-throated vireo and a tree swallow) and 31 bats (hoary, red, little brown, big brown and silver-haired bats). Spring and summer search efficiency and scavenge rates were evaluated. During observer efficiency trials, observers found 77% of bird carcasses. In spring and summer and fall scavenging trials, scavengers removed 7%, 12% and 7% of carcasses respectively, within the duration of observer search cycles (i.e., 2 days). Point counts were conducted to compare bird activity in fields with and without turbines. We monitored waterfowl activity and behavior in the fall. 1.2 million total goose-use days and 194,029 total duck-use days were recorded in the WMA\u2019s, from September 15 to December 25, 2003. Canada goose foraging behavior was monitored for a total of 270 flocks, from September 27 to December 1, 2003. Bat detectors were used to compare bat activity at turbine versus adjacent non-turbine sites. No significant differences were found between relative bird and bat activity at turbine, turbine with transect and non-turbine sites. Results presented are preliminary. The study will continue until December 2004. While we have yet to evaluate the significance of the mortality data, proper siting of these facilities remains a priority.","author":["Jain, A.","Koford, R.","Hancock, A.","Zenner, G."],"organization":["Iowa State University","Iowa Department of Natural Resources"],"originationDate":"2004-02-28","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.920575800000","-95.632804100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Koford_etal_2004.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2321","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/incidence-management-live-injured-bats-wind-energy-facilities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/253328112_Incidence_and_management_of_live_and_injured_bats_at_wind_energy_facilities","title":"Incidence and Management of Live and Injured Bats at Wind Energy Facilities","description":"Little information exists about finding and managing live bats injured at wind turbines. Our study examines field methods for finding, and successfully treating and releasing, bats and humanely euthanizing those that are terminally injured. Our discovery rate of live and injured bats was greater at turbines searched daily than at turbines searched weekly, and immediate in-field rehydration proved essential in successful treatment. This information can be used to assist in mitigating bat fatalities at wind energy facilities through the timely discovery, treatment, and release of live bats,","author":["Baerwald, E.","Klug, B."],"organization":["University of Calgary"],"originationDate":"2010-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.271553100000","-118.022320800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2322","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seasonal-bat-activity-relation-distance-hedgerows-agricultural-landscape-central","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3161\/150811014X683273","title":"Seasonal Bat Activity in Relation to Distance to Hedgerows in an Agricultural Landscape in Central Europe and Implications for Wind Energy Development","description":"Bat activity is often concentrated near linear and edge landscape structures such as hedgerows, but information about seasonal and species-specific bat activity near hedges is scarce despite their abundance in the cultural landscapes of central Europe. Exact knowledge on animals\u0027 habitat use, however, is key to effective landscape planning to avoid human-wildlife-conflicts, such as the construction of wind turbines in areas with high bat activity that may result in bat fatalities. We measured bat activity in relation to distance to hedgerows in an agricultural landscape in northeastern Germany. We recorded bat echolocation calls at ground level at 0, 50, 100 and 200 m distances from hedges at five sites during three nights in spring (April to June) and three nights in summer (July to October) at each site. For all bat species we found the overall activity to be similar between seasons, with the highest activity near the hedges, but with considerable variation in species-specific spatial activity patterns between spring and summer. While the genus\u00a0Myotis\u00a0and\u00a0Pipistrellus pipistrellus\u00a0were mostly active close to the hedges at a similar intensity over the entire study period (i.e. 84% and 86% of all bat passes, respectively),\u00a0Nyctalus noctula\u00a0and\u00a0Pipistrellus nathusii\u00a0showed generally less pronounced concentration of activity near the hedges, and increased activity away from the hedges in summer. Similarly,\u00a0Pipistrellus pygmaeus\u00a0showed decreased activity away from the hedges during both seasons, but with reduced activity near the hedges in summer. The observed behavioural changes in activity in relation to distance to hedgerows are likely due to migration or the bats foraging for different prey between seasons. Our findings are highly relevant for landscape planning and distance recommendations for the construction of wind turbines linked to their potential threat for bats.","author":["Lenski, J.","Toelch, U.","Kelm, D.","Kelm, V.","Dziock, F."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2014-04-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["51.085215000000","5.968598600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2323","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wildlife-monitoring-studies-seawest-windpower-project-carbon-county-wyoming-1995-1999","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.west-inc.com\/reports\/footeCreekReport2013.pdf","title":"Wildlife Monitoring Studies: SeaWest Windpower Project, Carbon County, Wyoming: 1995-1999","description":"In 1994, Kenetech Windpower, Inc. (Kenetech) proposed to construct a 500-megawatt (MW) windpower development in Carbon County, Wyoming. Kenetech applied for a right-of-way (ROW) permit from the Rawlins District Office of the Bureau of Land Management (BLM) to construct and access facilities of the wind plant on federal land. While preparing the Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for the proposed windpower project, TRC Mariah Associates Inc. (Mariah) initiated studies to obtain baseline data on avian resources in the study area. Results of those studies are presented in the EIS (BLM 1995a, 1995b) and in Thomas et al. (1997). As part of the ROW permit conditions, Kenetech agreed to continue study of potential effects of the proposed project on wildlife resources. Wildlife risk assessment and monitoring studies were initiated by Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) in March 1995. These studies were terminated in March 1996 just prior to the declaration of Chapter 11 bankruptcy by Kenetech. In late 1996, SeaWest Energy Corporation (SeaWest) acquired the rights to the Carbon County windpower project and wildlife monitoring studies were reinitiated in mid February 1997.\n\nThe first development unit, Foote Creek Rim I (FCR I), consists of a 41.4 MW wind plant comprised of 69 600-KW Mitsubishi turbines that was completed on Foote Creek Rim by SeaWest in January 1999. FCR II, a 1.8 MW wind plant consisting of three Mitsubishi 600-KW turbines, was completed in August 1999. FCR III, consisting of 33 NEG Micon NM 750 KW turbines capable of generating 24.75 MW, was also completed in August 1999. The wind plant currently consists of 105 turbines capable of generating 67.95 MW of electricity and related facilities (Figure 1), including meteorological towers, transmission lines, communications systems, transformers, substations, roads, and operations and maintenance facilities.\n\nThe scope and methods for conducting the wildlife risk assessment and monitoring studies were defined through consultation with the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), Wyoming Game and Fish Department (WGFD), and BLM. Objectives of this study were to obtain quantifiable data on wildlife use, species composition, reproductive success, and distribution in areas with windpower developments or proposed for windpower development and in a comparable reference area. Preconstruction data collected in 1995 and 1997 and subsequent during and post-construction data collected in 1998 and 1999 were used to evaluate potential effects on wildlife of windpower development and operation.\n\nThe primary goals of the monitoring studies are to evaluate impacts to wildlife from each phase of development and the cumulative impact to wildlife from all windpower development in the Wind Resource Area (WRA) (BLM 1995b). The secondary goal of monitoring is to obtain information that can be used to reduce impacts to wildlife from subsequent developments. This monitoring study uses a before\/after and control\/impact (BACI) design (Green 1979) to assess effects. This monitoring study also provides data compatible with studies of numerous other windpower projects in operation or under development. Finally, this monitoring study assesses risk based on a weight of evidence approach.\n\nThis report presents wildlife monitoring data for four years of study and includes monitoring data collected up to the end of the most recent fall period (31 October 1999). Results of fatality searches conducted in 1999 have been presented in a separate report (Johnson et al. 2000). Due to the technical nature of this study, this report may be difficult to interpret by the general public and questions should be directed to the BLM.","author":["Erickson, W.","Johnson, G.","Good, R.","Strickland, D.","Young, D. Jr.","Derby, C."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","US Bureau of Land Management (BLM)"],"originationDate":"2000-08-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.761179700000","-107.210803400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Raptors","Shorebirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:54","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/johnson-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2324","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-development-methods-assess-bird-bat-fatality-rates-post-construction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.usu.edu\/hwi\/vol10\/iss1\/8\/","title":"Wind Energy Development: Methods to Assess Bird and Bat Fatality Rates Post-Construction","description":"Monitoring fatalities at wind energy facilities after they have been constructed can provide valuable information regarding impacts of wind power development on wildlife. The objective of this monitoring is to estimate abundance of a super-population of carcasses that entered the area within a designated period of time. By definition, the population is not closed and carcasses can enter as they are killed through collision with turbines, and leave as they are removed by scavengers or decompose to a point where they are not recognizable. In addition, the population is not inherently mobile, but can only change location through some external force. A focus on number of animal carcasses comprising the super-population, combined with peculiar traits that resist classic assumptions, distinguish fatality estimation at wind-power facilities from more classic abundance estimates that can be addressed through mark-recapture techniques or other well-known abundance estimators. We review the available methods to estimate the super-population of carcasses at wind power facilities. We discuss the role of these estimates in determining appropriate levels of minimization and mitigation of impacts to individual species of concern. We discuss the potential to extrapolate these measurements to reflect the cumulative effect of the industry on individual species. Finally, we suggest avenues of research needed to strengthen our understanding of the effect wind power development has, and might have in the future, on wildlife on this continent and worldwide.","author":["Huso, M.","Dalthorp, D.","Miller, T.","Bruns, D."],"organization":["US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2016-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.563028300000","-123.318555900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Huso-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2325","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/migration-phenology-behaviour-bats-research-platform-south-eastern-north-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.zoogdierwinkel.nl\/sites\/default\/files\/imce\/nieuwesite\/Winkel\/pdf%20download\/Lutra%2059%281-2%29_H%C3%BCppop%20%26%20Hill_2016.pdf","title":"Migration Phenology and Behaviour of Bats at a Research Platform in the South-Eastern North Sea","description":"More than ten years of autonomous acoustic recording of bats\u2019 echolocation calls at an unmanned offshore research platform 45 km north of the island of Borkum (North Sea) were analysed in relation to season, time of day and weather. To our knowledge this is the longest systematic dataset on offshore bat migration worldwide. Three-hundred and seventeen call sequences were recorded during typical migration times in spring and autumn and assigned to at least 23 Nathusius\u2019 pipistrelles (Pipistrellus nathusius), 3 northern bats (Eptesicus nilssonii) and 2 Leisler\u2019s bats (Nyctalus leisleri). Compared to the prevailing wind conditions, more bats than expected were recorded at lower wind speeds and southerly winds. Bats occurred under supporting tailwinds, but also under strong headwinds. In both seasons most bats occurred under winds from the south (i.e. crosswinds), which indicates offshore wind drift. We neither found effects of air pressure, nor of change in air pressure. Most registrations coincided with a dense cover of clouds, fog\/low stratus and\/or rain. From the structure of echolocation calls it can be concluded that most bats explored the platform rather than just passed it on transfer flights, some even foraged there. We conclude that most of the bats were on migration and attracted by the brightly lit platform and\/or sought refuge there. This involves the risk of collisions with offshore wind turbines (which need to be brighter lit at sea than onshore). We assume that a great part of offshore bat migration takes place beyond the range of currently available techniques at greater altitudes than known so far.","author":["H\u00fcppop, O.","Hill, R."],"organization":["Institute of Avian Research \u0027Vogelwarte Helgoland\u0027"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.592284700000","6.686974900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2326","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-surveys-good-practice-guidelines-2nd-edition-surveying-onshore-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/gat04-live-1517c8a4486c41609369c68f30c8-aa81074.divio-media.org\/M4-Newport\/C%20-%20Core%20Documents\/11.%20Ecology%20and%20Nature%20Conservation\/11.2.26%20-%20Bat%20Surveys%20Good%20Practice%20Guidelines%2C%202nd%20edition%2C%20Bat%20Conservation%20Trust%202011.pdf","title":"Bat Surveys \u2013 Good Practice Guidelines (2nd edition): Surveying for Onshore Wind Turbines","description":"This guidance has been drafted to form an individual chapter of the revised Bat Surveys Good Practice Guidelines. It can form a stand alone document, but will also be incorporated into the 2nd edition. It is intended for all types of onshore wind farm for which bat surveys are required, from single to multi-turbine developments.  Although the guidance covers both single large (\u0026gt; 250kw) wind turbines and wind farms (multiple large wind turbines), it is important that any assessment considers the scale of the likely impacts and takes a proportionate approach. The impact of a single large wind turbine may differ from that of a large multiturbine wind farm, not only regarding the likely direct impact on bats, but also because of the area of habitat affected and the infrastructure required. The relatively lower risk of a single, or small number of turbines needs to be balanced against the suitability of the site for bats (e.g. proposals for a single turbine in an area of high bat activity or preferred foraging habitat could pose a greater risk than several turbines in an area of low or no bat activity). Offshore wind farms and micro-turbines are excluded from this guidance, although brief reference is made to them.","author":["Hundt, L.","Crompton, R.","Markham, S.","Graves, R.","Barlow, K."],"organization":["Bat Conservation Trust"],"originationDate":"2012-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.761307400000","-6.804722900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/hundt-et-al-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2327","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-repowering-wind-farms-birds-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/bergenhusen.nabu.de\/imperia\/md\/images\/bergenhusen\/impact_of_repowering.pdf","title":"The impact of repowering of wind farms on birds and bats","description":"Wind energy generation has developed in Germany into by far the most important source of renewable energy production. Over 18,000 wind turbines with an installed capacity of over 19,000 MW are now in operation. The wind-rich offshore areas are seen as the best opportunity to increase the generation of wind energy. On the mainland, however, the expansion of wind energy is becoming increasingly more difficult, as most of the best sites are already taken and further extension of existing wind farms is restricted by the lack of wind in most of the inland regions, as well as planning restrictions for interests (protection of the environment, nature conservation and landscape). Therefore, \u201erepowering\u201c provides a possibility to increase the production of electricity without simultaneously increasing the space required. \u201eRepowering\u201c means that older, smaller and less powerful wind turbines are replaced by newer and more powerful ones. These new turbines are much higher than older ones - heights above 100m are now the norm.  The literature review of H\u00f6tker et al. (2005) (hereafter called the NABU-BfN report), which was funded by the German Agency for Nature Conservation (BfN), showed that wind turbines have only a relatively small disturbance effect on breeding birds, although many potentially sensitive species have not yet been analysed. Resting birds, in particular geese, ducks and waders responded sensitively to wind turbines and could be displaced from their resting areas. Wind turbines at certain sites, especially on bare mountain ridges and water bodies, are a collision risk for birds. In particular, birds of prey were affected, in Germany notably Red Kite and White-tailed Eagle. Bats were also killed by wind turbines, especially when these were located close to or within woodlands. The extent to which wind turbines have a harmful impact on the natural environment is mainly determined by their location. Practically the only effective means of avoiding damage was appropriate site selection.  The references used by H\u00f6tker et al. (2005) were generally studies which had been carried out on older, relatively small wind turbines. Although one could estimate a relationship between the size of wind turbines and the disturbance impact or collision risk for birds and bats, these relationships were not (with some exceptions) statistically significant. In order better to assess the impacts of the new generation of wind turbines on birds and bats, this report will analyse the more recent publications (up to summer 2006). The main emphasis was in particular the extent to which the danger for birds and bats caused by wind turbines is expected to change due to repowering. In this report, collisions of birds and bats and the displacement of birds by wind turbines have been considered as the potential impacts on these taxa. To our knowledge, no further essential studies about the displacement of bats and other mammals by wind turbines have been carried out recently (Bach \u0026amp; Rahmel, 2004) and therefore this aspect is not dealt with in this report.","author":["H\u00f6tker, H."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)"],"originationDate":"2006-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.205481500000","8.467999200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/hotker_impact_of_repowering.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2328","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-assessment-studies-wind-turbines-bat-populations-step-towards-best","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/265494012_Environmental_Assessment_Studies_on_wind_turbines_and_bat_populations_-_a_step_towards_best_practice_guidelines","title":"Environmental Assessment Studies on wind turbines and bat populations - a step towards best practice guidelines","description":"As climate change represents one of the key threats to biodiversity, there is increasing focus on the development of alternative energies. Wind energy is actually the most prominent form of alternative energy being developed in Europe as it seems to help to reduce pollution from fossil fuels. However, it has also a high potential to cause damage to parts of the ecosystem, especially if cumulative developments in the areas of installation increase these effects. The recent development of wind energy in Europe has given rise to concern to nature conservation interests, especially against the background of evident damage to flying birds and bats and some lack of administrative guidance in planning, installation, impact and monitoring studies. Some of these problems have been recognised at international level as by the Bern Convention with their report on \u201cWindfarms and birds\u201d (T-PVS\/Inf (2003) 12). Currently an Intersessional Working Group (IWG) of EUROBATS is working at guidelines for wind turbines and bats which will be proposed to the next Meeting of the Parties in 2006 (see also: www.eurobats.org).\n\nActually, only few guidelines for wind farm developers or for nature conservationists during the planning and installation process or on the minimization or mitigation of effects on wind turbines on bat populations are available, although there is an urgent need for both sides (NLT, 2005; Rahmel \u0026amp; Bach, 2004). The development of wind farms is currently in full expansion within all of Europe and the possible negative impacts of wind turbines on bats are evidenced. Although there is still an ongoing need for further detailed research, bat conservation must start to collate all available information and knowledge to come up with best practice guidelines for planning, installation, environmental impact assessment as well as long-term monitoring studies.\n\nThis article gives a short overview of the situation in Germany and will try to give suggestions for an english guideline. It should not be taken as a final and consensed version since this task still has to be carried out. We also greatly acknowledge the important work of all bat workers who contributed to this synthesis.","author":["Bach, L.","Harbusch, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2005-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.906715600000","8.033983800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 03:16:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2329","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-monitoring-studies-fowler-ridge-wind-energy-facility-benton-county-indiana-april-1","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.conservationevidence.com\/individual-study\/8848","title":"Bat Monitoring Studies at the Fowler Ridge Wind Energy Facility Benton County, Indiana: April 1 - October 31, 2011","description":"The Fowler Ridge Wind Farm (FRWF) is located in Benton County, Indiana, and currently consists of 355 wind turbines in three operating phases (Figure 1). A post-construction casualty study of birds and bats was conducted by Western EcoSystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) in Phases I and III during 2009 (Johnson et al. 2010a, 2010b, Good et al. 2011). During such study, an Indiana bat carcass was discovered by staff at the FRWF. A Scientific Research and Recovery Permit (SRRP) for the Indiana bat (TE15075A-2) was issued for further research for Phases I, II, and III in 2010 and 2011. One additional Indiana bat carcass was found, in the fall of 2010 (Good et al. 2011). As a result of this discovery, the US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) Field Office in Bloomington, Indiana, recommended that the FRWF develop a Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP). Consequently, the owners of the FRWF requested that WEST conduct further research of Indiana bat use and methods for reducing bat fatality rates. The results of the research at the FRWF will be used for developing an HCP and applying for an Incidental Take Permit (ITP) from Region 3 of the USFWS. The results presented in this report were collected under the SRPP referenced above.","author":["Erickson, W.","Bay, K.","Good, R.","Merrill, A.","Simon, S.","Murray, K.","Fritchman, C."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2012-01-31","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.509231200000","-85.769856400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Good-et-al-2012_Fowler-Ridge.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2330","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/seasonal-survival-probability-suggest-low-migration-mortality-migrating-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0085628","title":"Seasonal survival probability suggest low migration mortality in migrating bats","description":"Migration is adaptive if survival benefits are larger than costs of residency. Many aspects of bat migration ecology such as migratory costs, stopover site use and fidelity are largely unknown. Since many migrating bats are endangered, such information is urgently needed to promote conservation. We selected the migrating Leisler\u0027s bat (Nyctalus leisleri) as model species and collected capture-recapture data in southern Switzerland year round during 6 years. We estimated seasonal survival and site fidelity with Cormack-Jolly-Seber models that accounted for the presence of transients fitted with Bayesian methods and assessed differences between sexes and seasons. Activity peaked in autumn and spring, whereas very few individuals were caught during summer. We hypothesize that the study site is a migratory stopover site used during fall and spring migration for most individuals, but there is also evidence for wintering. Additionally, we found strong clues for mating during fall. Summer survival that included two major migratory journeys was identical to winter survival in males and slightly higher in females, suggesting that the migratory journeys did not bear significant costs in terms of survival. Transience probability was in both seasons higher in males than in females. Our results suggest that, similarly to birds, Leisler\u0027s bat also use stopover sites during migration with high site fidelity. In contrast to most birds, the stopover site was also used for mating and migratory costs in terms of survival seemed to be low. Transients\u0027 analyses highlighted strong individual variation in site use which makes particularly challenging the study and modelling of their populations as well as their conservation.","author":["Schaub, M.","Bontadina, F.","Giavi, S.","Moretti, M.","Zambelli, N."],"organization":["Swiss Federal Research Institute WSL","Swiss Ornithological Institute"],"originationDate":"2014-01-15","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.517922500000","6.772500300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/giavi-et-al-2014.PDF"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2331","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-mediterranean-mountainous-landscape-does-wind-farm-repowering-induce-changes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov\/pubmed\/26952112","title":"Bats in a Mediterranean Mountainous Landscape: Does Wind Farm Repowering Induce Changes at Assemblage and Species Level?","description":"We reported data on flying bat assemblages in a Mediterranean mountain landscape of central Italy on a 5-year time span (2005\u20132010) where a wind farm repowering has been carried out (from 2009, 17 three-blade turbines substituted an a priori set of one-blade turbines). In 4\u00a0yearly based surveys, we calculated a set of univariate metrics at species and assemblage level and also performing a diversity\/dominance analysis (k-dominance plots) to evaluate temporal changes. Nine species of bats were present (eight classified at species level, one at genus level). Number of detected taxa, Margalef richness, and Shannon\u2013Wiener diversity apparently decreased between 2005\u20132007 (one-blade turbine period) and 2009\u20132010 (three-blade turbines period). We showed a weak temporal turnover only between 2007 and 2009. In\u00a0k-dominance plots, the occurrence curves of the years before the new wind farming activity (2005 and 2007) were lower when compared to the curves related to the 2009 and 2010\u00a0years, suggesting an apparent stress at assemblage level in the second period (2009 and 2010).\u00a0Myotis emarginatus\u00a0and\u00a0Pipistrellus pipistrellus\u00a0significantly changed their relative frequency during the three-blade wind farming activity, supporting the hypothesis that some bats may be sensitive to repowering. Further research is necessary to confirm a possible sensitivity also for locally rare bats (Miniopterus schreibersii\u00a0and\u00a0Plecotus\u00a0sp.).","author":["Battisti, C.","Soccini, C.","Ferri, V."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2016-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.807606100000","11.741859400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2332","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-construction-monitoring-wind-farms-first-records-direct-impact-bats-italy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.italian-journal-of-mammalogy.it\/Post-construction-monitoring-of-wind-farms-first-records-of-direct-impact-on-bats,77310,0,2.html","title":"Post construction monitoring of wind farms: First records of direct impact on bats in Italy","description":"Long-term post-construction monitoring of the impact of wind farms on fauna started in 2008 in Abruzzo (central Italy). This study provides the first evidence of bat fatalities at wind turbines in Italy. Six carcasses of Hypsugo savii and one carcass of Pipistrellus pipistrellus were recorded in 2009 during 36 field sessions, involving 4 researchers at two wind farms, for a total of 46 (21 and 25) wind turbines.","author":["Soccini, C.","Ferri, V.","Locasciulli, O.","Forlizzi, E."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.276021600000","13.235579800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Locasciulli-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2333","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-developments-natura-2000","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ec.europa.eu\/environment\/nature\/natura2000\/management\/docs\/Wind_farms.pdf","title":"Wind energy developments and Natura 2000","description":"In December 2008, the EU adopted an ambitious and far-reaching \u2018climate change and energy\u2019 package which, amongst others, commits the EU-27 countries to increasing the share of renewable energy to 20% of Europe\u2019s total energy production by 2020. As a clean, renewable source of electricity, wind energy is destined to make a significant contribution to achieving this 20% target.\n\nWind energy in Europe has been growing rapidly over the last decade. In 2008, it accounted for around 4.8% of the EU\u2019s total electricity consumption. This share is expected to at least triple by 2020. It is clear therefore that the number of wind farm installations across the EU is likely to increase radically in the short to medium term. It will be important to ensure that such a rapid expansion is sustainable in all respects and is done in accordance with EU environmental legislation, including the Habitats and Birds Directives.\n\nEvidence to date shows that, whereas, in general, wind energy does not represent a serious threat to wildlife, poorly sited or designed wind farms can pose a potential threat to vulnerable species and habitats, including those protected under the Habitats and Birds Directives.","author":["European Union"],"organization":["European Commission"],"originationDate":"2011-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["49.603523400000","6.096214600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:56","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wind_farms_EU_2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2334","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-local-population-vulnerability-branching-process-models-application-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/full\/10.1890\/ES15-00103.1","title":"Assessing local population vulnerability with branching process models: an application to wind energy development","description":"Quantifying the impact of anthropogenic development on local populations is important for conservation biology and wildlife management. However, these local populations are often subject to demographic stochasticity because of their small population size. Traditional modeling efforts such as population projection matrices do not consider this source of variation whereas individual-based models, which include demographic stochasticity, are computationally intense and lack analytical tractability. One compromise between approaches is branching process models because they accommodate demographic stochasticity and are easily calculated. These models are known within some sub-fields of probability and mathematical ecology but are not often applied in conservation biology and applied ecology. We applied branching process models to quantitatively compare and prioritize species locally vulnerable to the development of wind energy facilities. Specifically, we examined species vulnerability using branching process models for four representative species: A cave bat (a long-lived, low fecundity species), a tree bat (short-lived, moderate fecundity species), a grassland songbird (a short-lived, high fecundity species), and an eagle (a long-lived, slow maturation species). Wind turbine-induced mortality has been observed for all of these species types, raising conservation concerns. We simulated different mortality rates from wind farms while calculating local extinction probabilities. The longer-lived species types (e.g., cave bats and eagles) had much more pronounced transitions from low extinction risk to high extinction risk than short-lived species types (e.g., tree bats and grassland songbirds). High-offspring-producing species types had a much greater variability in baseline risk of extinction than the lower-offspring-producing species types. Long-lived species types may appear stable until a critical level of incidental mortality occurs. After this threshold, the risk of extirpation for a local population may rapidly increase with only minimal increases in wind mortality. Conservation biologists and wildlife managers may need to consider this mortality pattern when issuing take permits and developing monitoring protocols for wind facilities. We also describe how our branching process models may be generalized across a wider range of species for a larger assessment project and then describe how our methods may be applied to other stressors in addition to wind.","author":["Thogmartin, W.","Diffendorfer, J.","Beston, J.","Stanton, J.","Erickson, R.","Eager, E."],"organization":["University of Wisconsin","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2015-12-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.668421800000","-92.025201300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Erickson_et_al-2015-Ecosphere.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2335","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wildlife-baseline-study-wild-horse-wind-project-summary-results-2002-2003-wildlife","sourceURL":"","title":"Wildlife Baseline Study for the Wild Horse Wind Project: Summary of Results from 2002-2003 Wildlife Surveys","description":"Zilkha Renewable Energy (Applicant) proposes to construct and operate approximately 136 wind turbines on high open ridge tops between the towns of Kittitas and Vantage in Kittitas County, Washington, on and near Whiskey Dick Mountain. The Wild Horse Wind Power Project (the \u201cProject\u201d) is anticipated to provide up to 312 megawatts (MW) of generating capacity. It would be constructed on privately owned land and public land administered by the Washington Department of Natural Resources (WDNR).  The Applicant has contracted with Western Ecosystems Technology, Inc. (WEST) to develop and implement a survey protocol for a baseline study of wildlife, habitat, and plants in the Project area. The protocol for the ecological baseline study is similar to protocols used at the Kittitas Valley, Vansycle, Klondike, Stateline, Maiden, Condon and Nine Canyon wind projects in Oregon and Washington, the Buffalo Ridge wind project in southwest Minnesota, and the Foote Creek Rim wind project in Wyoming.  This report summarizes the results of the ecological baseline studies conducted from May 10, 2002 through May 22, 2003. The wildlife portion of the ecological baseline study consisted of 1) point count and in-transit surveys for wildlife species, 2) an aerial survey within approximately two miles of the Project boundary for visible raptor nests and wintering big game in the spring of 2003 and 3) aerial and ground surveys during the breeding season for sage grouse in the Project vicinity. Rare plant surveys and habitat mapping were also conducted and has been summarized in a separate report (Lack et al. 2003). Information on sensitive plant and wildlife species within the vicinity of the Project was requested from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS), Washington Department of Fish and Wildlife (WDFW), and the Washington Natural Heritage Program (WNHP). The recent synthesis of baseline and operational monitoring studies at wind developments by Erickson et al. (2002), as well as other relevant information has been reviewed and has been utilized for predicting impacts from the Project. Agency personnel were contacted for information regarding their concerns and data available on wildlife of the general Project area.","author":["Erickson, W.","Johnson, G.","Bay, K.","Young, D.","Good, R.","Jeffrey, J.","Sawyer, H."],"organization":["Zilkha Renewable Energy"],"originationDate":"2003-11-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.984602200000","-120.427131700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ericksonetal2003.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2336","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/final-report-avian-bat-mortality-associated-vansycle-wind-project","sourceURL":"","title":"Final Report: avian and bat mortality associated with the Vansycle wind project","description":"The Avian Monitoring Plan for the Vansycle Wind Project located in Umatilla County, Oregon outlined a detailed protocol for estimation of bird and bat fatalities associated with the project. The Technical Advisory Committee (TAC) made up of experts from the cooperating agencies and ESI Vansycle Partners, L.P., local landowners, and representatives of Umatilla County agreed to meet after completion of one year of the monitoring program to discuss results of the monitoring studies, the evaluation of methodology, and the need for further study. This report presents results of carcass searches for the 1999 study year at the Vansycle Ridge Wind Project.  The windplant is comprised of 38 660-kilowatt Vestas turbines arranged in two strings, with 28 turbines on String A and 10 on String B. Carcass searches were conducted on half the turbines once every two weeks during the study, with all turbines searched each 28-day period. To estimate windplant mortality, the total number of carcasses found was adjusted for \u0022length of stay\u0022 (scavenging) and searcher efficiency bias. Twelve bird and ten bat fatalities were found during the study. During searcher efficiency trials, searchers detected 50.0% of the small birds and 87.5% of the large birds. Scavenger removal trials indicated that carcasses remained on the search area for an average of 25.0 days before being removed. Based on the number of fatalities found adjusted for searcher efficiency and scavenger removal rates, the total number of turbine-related casualties in 1999 for the Vansycle Ridge Wind Project was estimated to be 24 birds and 28 bats. The fatality rate per year was estimated to be 0.63 birds\/turbine and 0.74 bats\/turbine. Most of the windplantrelated avian casualties on Vansycle Ridge were passerines, and many of these were likely nocturnal migrants. No raptor casualties were found during the study period. Mortality of large birds was apparently limited to chukars and gray partridge, two introduced upland gamebirds. Data collected indicate that avian and bat mortality appears to be relatively low on Vansycle Ridge. Overall results of the carcass search studies indicate that the monitoring protocol used for this study is sufficient to provide data required to adequately evaluate effects of windpower development on avian and bat resources.","author":["Erickson, W.","Strickland, M.","Johnson, G.","Kronner, K."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2000-02-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.440017400000","-119.333505900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Erickson-et-al-2000.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2337","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pattern-bat-fatalities-wind-turbines-europe-comparing-north-south","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cww2011.nina.no\/Portals\/cww2011\/DynamicForms_Uploads\/6d440b0a-dcd2-4284-aec3-d5fdc7c0fd0c.pdf","title":"Pattern of bat fatalities at wind turbines in Europe: comparing north and south","description":"In April 2011, a total of 3791 bat fatalities at wind turbines had been reported from 15 countries in Europe (update by authors of the mortality table prepared for EUROBATS). The victims belong to 27 taxa out of 39 living in the European Community. The aim of this poster is to compare the situation in northern and southern Europe based on available data. Only standardized monitoring studies have been analyzed.","author":["Bach, L.","Rodrigues, L.","Georgiakakis, P.","Papadatou, E.","Rydell, J.","Dubourg-Savage, M.","Santos, H."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["63.428574800000","10.347433600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/bat_fatalities_N_S.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2338","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/post-construction-monitoring-report-avian-bat-mortality-nppd-ainsworth-wind-farm","sourceURL":"","title":"Post-construction monitoring report for avian and bat mortality at the NPPD Ainsworth Wind Farm","description":"Nebraska Public Power District (NPPD) constructed a wind energy facility approximately 5-9 miles southwest of Ainsworth, Brown County, Nebraska (Figure 1 ). The Ainsworth Wind Energy Facility has 36 wind turbines with a capacity of 59.4 megawatts (https:\/\/www.nppd.com\/) on about 8,300 acres of privately owned land. The turbine blades are 131 feet long and sit atop a 230 foot turbine (https:\/\/www.nppd.com\/). Turbines with FAA lighting include turbines 1, 3, 5, 7, 8, 10, 11, 12, 13, 15, 16, 18, 19, 21, 22, 24, 25, 27, 29, 31, 32, 33, 34, and 36. The single meteorological (met) tower at the site is also FAA lighted. The goals of this project were: 1) To document bird and bat fatalities at the developed wind farm by species. 2) To estimate annual bird and bat fatalities attributable to the wind farm. 3) To evaluate spatial patterns of fatalities.","author":["Erickson, W.","Bay, K.","Derby, C.","Dahl, A.","Hoban, J."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)","Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2007-02-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.148094000000","-104.853930100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 04:16:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Avian-Bat-Mortality-at-the-NPPD-Ainsworth-Wind-Farm.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2339","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-bat-mortality-portuguese-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/conferences.iaia.org\/2012\/pdf\/uploadpapers\/Final%20papers%20review%20process\/Bernardino%2C%20Joana.%20%20Bird%20and%20bat%20mortality%20at%20Portuguese%20wind%20farms.pdf","title":"Bird and bat mortality at Portuguese wind farms","description":"Wind energy had a remarkable growth in Portugal over the last 10 years. As it happened in other countries, several pre- and post-construction monitoring studies have been performed in order to assess the impacts of turbines on flying vertebrates. However, few studies gathered data collected at different sites and analysed it in an integrated way. As one of the first tasks of the R\u0026amp;D project, Wind \u0026amp; Biodiversity, this paper presents the results of the literature revision regarding bat and bird mortality at onshore wind farms. We were interested to know: 1) which species or assemblages present higher levels of mortality; and 2) when and where these events are more evident.","author":["Bernardino, J.","Costa, H.","Mascarenhas, M.","Fonseca, C.","Ramos-Pereira, M.","Zina, H.","Passos, I."],"organization":["Bioinsight"],"originationDate":"2012-05-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.163478700000","-8.661094500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bernardinoetal2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2340","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-wind-speed-activity-bats-coast-inland","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cww2011.nina.no\/Portals\/cww2011\/DynamicForms_Uploads\/75aeed90-1e17-4a62-aabb-717fd469f49c.pdf","title":"Impact of wind speed on the activity of bats - at the coast and inland","description":"In recent years nature conservation organizations and authorities in Germany became increasingly aware of bat fatalies at wind turbines and the legal implications of this. This led to the introduction of mitigation measurements in order to prevent bat fatalies as much as possible.In wind parks with high bat activity the only mitigation measures available are often site choice for individual turbines and switching off the turnbines during critical periods. Additionally there is often an obligation to carry out bat monitoring after the turbines have been constructed to adjust the mitigation measurements, especially to define cut-in wind speed, and to identify seasonal patterns with high bat activity. In this poster we present two of our monitoring studies, one at the coast and the other 200 km inland. We will concentrate on the influence of wind speed on bat activity.","author":["Bach, L.","Niermann, I.","Bach, P."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["63.431914800000","10.370779400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bachetal2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2341","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-fatalities-different-wind-facilities-northwest-germany","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bach-freilandforschung.de\/images\/download\/Bach-Bat-fatalities-Poster-2013.pdf","title":"Bat fatalities at different wind facilities in Northwest Germany","description":"Introduction Due to the climate change discussion several governments aim to increase the production of renewable energy. Especially wind power is increasing in Germany and Europe. BRINKMANN et al. (2011) stated that the collision rate of bats with wind turbines (WT) in Germany is about 9-10 bats\/WT\/year. However, there is a huge variation between landscapes and geographical areas (NIERMANN et al. 2011, RYDELL et al. 2010). The reasons for this are that habitat types the distribution of bats and an area\u0027s importance for bat migration varies between landscapes. These factors influence the overall number of collisions and the species which are most affected. Our aim here is to present data on bat collisions for different wind farms in several landscapes in north-western Germany and to identify variables that might predict bat mortality in north-western Germany (see AMORIM et al. 2012, SANTOS et al 2013).","author":["Bach, L.","Bach, P.","Ekschmitt, K.","Frey, K.","Gerhardt, U."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-02-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.334422500000","17.881781100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bach-Bat-fatalities-Poster-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2342","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/what-does-bat-activity-inside-forest-tell-us-about-activity-above-canopy-method","sourceURL":"https:\/\/cww2011.nina.no\/Portals\/cww2011\/DynamicForms_Uploads\/e81ef30a-25bf-41e9-be01-741adea06697.pdf","title":"What does bat activity inside the forest tell us about the activity above the canopy? A method for censuring bat activity at proposed wind farms in forests","description":"In Germany in recent years, an increasing number of wind turbines are being planned in forests. The bat surveys for impact assessments are carried out on the forest floor using line transects. This method does not take into consideration that bat activity above and below the canopy might differ. So far, few studies have investigated bat activity above the forest canopy in Germany (Aschoff et al. 2006, Fichtner 2004), or elsewhere (Grindal \u0026amp; Brigham 1999, Hayes \u0026amp; Gruver 2000, Kalcounis et al. 1999). The aim of our study was to test the following hypotheses: bat activity and species composition above and below the canopy differs wind strongly influences bat activity above the canopy, but less so below the canopy assessing bat activity and species composition above the canopy from surveys at ground level is difficult or even impossible.","author":["Bach, L.","Bach, P.","Tillmann, M."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["63.428267700000","10.346746900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/bach-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2343","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/guidelines-assessing-impact-wind-farms-birds-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.seo.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/2014\/10\/Guidelines_for_Assessing_the_Impact_of_Wind_Farms_on_Birds_and_Bats.pdf","title":"Guidelines for Assessing the Impact of Wind Farms on Birds and Bats","description":"Wind-power takeup has been swift in Spain, with 1072 wind farms and 12,080 wind turbines installed in the country by the end of 2013. Industrial projects of this type have a huge potential impact on birds. SEO\/BirdLife has therefore been keeping a close watch on them for some time. It has investigated their impact in the field, has participated actively in the environmental impact assessment procedure (checking more than 500 design projects) and has examined dozens of wind-farm monitoring plans. The conclusion drawn from all this hard work was that wind farms are not being properly assessed. As a result many famrs with a high environmental impact are being authorised. Especially enlightening here was SEO\/BirdLife\u0027s analysis of over 100 wind farm projects presented in Extremadura in December 2006.","author":["Dominguez, J.","Atienza, J.","Mart\u00edn-Fierro, I.","Infante, O.","Valls, J."],"organization":["SEO\/BirdLife","BirdLife International"],"originationDate":"2014-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.433035400000","-3.761942000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:12:58","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Guidelines_for_Assessing_the_Impact_of_Wind_Farms_on_Birds_and_Bats.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2344","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pre-construction-study-recording-bats-helium-balloon-collision-relevant-heights","sourceURL":"","title":"Pre-construction study: Recording bats from a helium balloon in collision relevant heights with an automated system","description":"For the site selection of wind power pllants it is decisive from a species protection point of view whether the risk of bat fatalities will increase significantly. A substantial ban by Art. 12(1) lit. a council directive 92\/43\/EEC cannot even be avoided implementing CEF measures. Numerous investigations show that bats are active in the height area of rotor blades and might be killed. But so far only few authors have investigated bat activities in different heights.  The study presented has been carried out over two nights using a helium balloon. Automatically recording batcorders registed the bat calls syncronously in three different heights. The results show that bat activities in the height of the rotor blades significantly differ from activities close to the ground or even to the height of the forest canopy. The species mapped on the height of the rotor blades (Pipistrellus pipistrellus, P. nathusii, P. pygmaeus, Vespertillio murinus) usually feed in the open air space.","author":["Albrecht, K.","Gr\u00fcnfelder, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2011-05-02","spatial":{"coordinates":["63.427346200000","10.346060300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/albrecht_and_grunfelder_2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2345","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bats-wind-power-investigations-required-risk-assessment-denmark-sweden","sourceURL":"https:\/\/research.ku.dk\/search\/?pure=en\/publications\/bats-and-wind-power--investigations-required-for-risk-assessment-in-denmark-and-sweden(3f0637bd-fe0d-4411-bd11-2785425151a6)\/export.html","title":"Bats and wind power -investigations required for risk assessment in Denmark and Sweden","description":"Field investigations of the bat fauna were initiated with the use of ultrasound technique in 1978. Today we have an almost complete overview of bat distribution and species richness in Sweden and Denmark. Data were published as atlases, distribution maps, and facts on status for each species. Bats killed by wind turbines were discovered the first time in September 1999 on Gotland. Studies on behaviour of bats at turbines started in 2001 and were performed with the use of detectors, heat image cameras, acoustic playback experiments, and automatic registration. The research was funded by the Swedish Energy Agency, the Swedish Environmental Protection Agency (Vindval programme), the Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences, the Natural History Museum of Denmark, and the University of Copenhagen. The project on wind power at sea involved cooperation between scientists in Denmark, Germany and Sweden.","author":["Ahl\u00e9n, I.","Baag\u00f8e, H."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-02-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.336173500000","17.886587400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SummaryAhlenBaagoeBatsWindpowerCWE2013ver20130202.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2346","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/visual-assessment-shore-wind-turbines-influence-distance-contrast-movement-social","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148106000838","title":"Visual assessment of off-shore wind turbines: The influence of distance, contrast, movement and social variables","description":"As a result of opposition, on the grounds of visual impact, to major wind energy installations on land, power companies are increasingly turning to off-shore sites for wind farm development. In most cases, the multiple turbines will be visible from the shore and hinterlands and opposition to the visual intrusion continues. This paper more firmly establishes the parameters of wind turbine visibility and impact at different distances from the viewer, under different lighting and atmospheric conditions and with moving or stationary blades. This is achieved through an on-line survey involving an 18 turbine wind farm at three different distances (4, 8 and 12\u00a0km), in five different lighting and weather conditions and in two different movement conditions. Distance and contrast were found to be very good predictors of perceived impact. There was a significant difference in impact between simulations with moving and stationary blades. Responses were also analysed according to local exposure, national exposure, interest level and age.","author":["Miller, D.","Bishop, I."],"organization":["Macaulay Institute","University of Melbourne"],"originationDate":"2007-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2347","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/low-cost-acoustic-design-bat-test-room","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/09524622.2014.964772","title":"Low-cost acoustic design of a bat test room","description":"Experiments with captive bats need a flight room that is acoustically neutral, especially when recording and analysing bat calls or the response of bats to certain sound stimuli. Our aim was to identify an isolation material with the best quality\u2013price relationship to acoustically coat such a flight room. For this, we built a flight room divided into two compartments that were to be acoustically isolated from one another. Audible and infrasonic waves are difficult to attenuate with low-cost materials but the attenuation of ultrasounds is rather straightforward. We evaluated the absorbing capacities of different low-cost materials \u2013 felt fabric, polystyrene, egg boxes, egg boxes coated with felt fabric, absorbing pyramidal foams, polyurethane foams and cork. The material that showed the best quality\u2013price relationship was the polyurethane foam of open cells (5 cm thickness), which was able to attenuate approximately 20 dB at ultrasonic frequencies.","author":["Vieira, J.","Bastos, C.","Fonseca, C.","Correia, R.","Faneca, C.","Ramos-Pereira, M.","Albuquerque, D."],"organization":["University of Aveiro"],"originationDate":"2014-10-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.630302400000","-8.659694700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2348","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-monitoring-system-wind-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1474667015373080","title":"Bat Monitoring System for Wind Farms","description":"In this work we present a bat monitoring system for wind farms. The proposed system includes a thermal camera and an ultrasound acquisition device to detect and record bats that come into the detection range of each one of these devices. All events are registered simultaneously with climatic variables and sent to a central database using 3G\/4G. The system was designed to allow several monitoring systems to send data to the central server at the same time. We expect this system to allow the determination of climatic conditions that favor bat activity, especially in the proximity of wind turbines, and to use this information to define shutdown strategies to mitigate bat mortality caused by these infrastructures.","author":["Bernardino, J.","Costa, H.","Mascarenhas, M.","Vieira, J.","Bastos, C.","Fonseca, C.","Correia, R.","Faneca, C.","Ramos-Pereira, M."],"organization":["University of Aveiro"],"originationDate":"2013-09-25","spatial":{"coordinates":["49.362045400000","18.263680300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2349","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-power-2013-european-statistics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/windeurope.org\/wp-content\/uploads\/files\/about-wind\/statistics\/EWEA_Annual_Statistics_2013.pdf","title":"Wind in power: 2013 European statistics","description":"\u2022 11,159 MW of wind power capacity (worth between \u20ac13 bn and \u20ac18 bn) was installed in the EU-28 during 2013, a decrease of 8% compared to 2012 installations. \u2022 EU wind power installations for 2013 show the negative impact of market, regulatory and political uncertainty sweeping across Europe. Destabilised legislative frameworks for wind energy are undermining investments. \u2022 Wind power is the technology which installed the most in 2013: 32% of total 2013 power capacity installations - five percentage points higher than during the previous year. \u2022 Renewable power installations accounted for 72% of new installations during 2013: 25 GW of a total 35 GW of new power capacity, up from 70% the previous year.","author":["European Wind Energy Association (EWEA)"],"organization":["European Wind Energy Association (EWEA)"],"originationDate":"2014-02-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["49.013626500000","16.071071500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EWEA_Annual_Statistics_2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2350","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/differences-bat-activity-relation-bat-detector-height-implications-bat-surveys","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bioone.org\/doi\/abs\/10.3161\/150811009X485576","title":"Differences in bat activity in relation to bat detector height: implications for bat surveys at proposed windfarm sites","description":"We recorded bat activity simultaneously at ground level and 30 m height using Anabat II bat detectors and Anabat ZCAIM recording units mounted on masts at seven sites of varying habitat type in eastern England. At the lower detectors 6194 passes were recorded; 90.02% of calls were from Pipistrellus; 6.91% were from Nyctalus\/Eptesicus; 1.70% were Myotis\/Plecotus; 0.13% were Barbastella and 1.24% could not be determined to species. At the higher detectors 484 passes were recorded from Pipistrellus (65.08%) and Nyctalus\/Eptesicus (34.09%) and 0.83% were not determined to species. Total bat passes and the number of Pipistrellus passes were significantly higher on the lower detectors compared with the upper detectors. The difference between numbers of passes of Nyctalus\/Eptesicus at the upper and lower detectors was not significant, despite proportionally more passes of these species being recorded at height. No extra species groups were recorded at height than were recorded at ground level except at one site where closed canopy broadleaved woodland surrounded the mast. Here, Nyctalus\/Eptesicus species were recorded only at height. Overall, 28% of Nyctalus\/Eptesicus passes and 5% of Pipistrellus passes were recorded exclusively at height, and not at ground level. Assessing bat activity levels from ground level detectors only can therefore be misleading, particularly when surveying high-flying species that are most likely to be at risk from wind turbine developments.","author":["Jones, G.","Collins, J."],"organization":["University of Bristol"],"originationDate":"2009-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.682284300000","-1.328619000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2351","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ebb-flow-tidal-barrage-development-zhejiang-province-china","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032117307578","title":"The Ebb and Flow of Tidal Barrage Development in Zhejiang Province, China","description":"China\u0027s major development and construction in utilization of tidal energy resources are concentrated in the area of Zhejiang Province. The development of tidal barrage in Zhejiang Province presented the ebb and flow trends. This paper introduced the resource status of tidal energy in Zhejiang Province. The five development stages of tidal barrage technology and the profiles of tidal power plant (TPP) in operation were reviewed, and problems and experiences were discussed. Some available future works for the development of tidal barrage were also proposed. The direction of utilizing tidal potential energy in the future is to update the generating units, improve construction skills and run optimization of operation in order to reduce costs and mitigate the impact on the environment. Actively exploring construction methods of medium to large-scale of TPPs are helpful to accelerate the utilization of tidal energy resources in Zhejiang Province and coastal areas in China.","author":["Li, Y.","Pan, D."],"organization":["Zhejiang University"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["29.096331200000","118.245194900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-03 05:13:19","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2352","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-current-understanding-hydro-environmental-impacts-energy-removal-tidal-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032117309346","title":"A Review of the Current Understanding of the Hydro-Environmental Impacts of Energy Removal by Tidal Turbines","description":"Tidal current turbines have the potential to make a considerable contribution to renewable energy supplies. However, the potential for utility-scale deployments will depend not only on the economics of power generation, but also on the likely hydro-environmental effects of deployments. These may include physical, acoustic, chemical, and electromagnetic effects but the effects of energy removal are considered most significant. This paper presents a review of the available published literature on the hydro-environmental effects of energy removal of tidal turbines. Given the limited number of ocean deployments of turbines to date, the relevant literature mostly comprises laboratory studies of singular scaled turbines and CFD model studies of multiple device arrays. The review finds that the hydrodynamic impacts of singular devices are relatively well understood and that it is generally accepted that the far-field effects of singular device deployments, and even small arrays, will be negligible. In contrast, large arrays have the potential to affect much greater changes in their far-field environments with the research showing potential for large reductions in current velocities inside, and upstream and downstream, of the array, and consequential impacts on mixing, mass transport and primary production. The review focused on those studies that attempted to quantify the magnitudes of any energy removal effects. As might be expected, the reported magnitudes of effects varied widely but there is a strong positive correlation with the level of energy removal. Indeed, the literature indicates that for most suitable deployment sites there exists a safe level of energy removal that would be both economical and environmentally sustainable. The authors recommend the application of combined hydrodynamic-biogeochemical models on a site-by-site basis to help determine the significance of any hydrodynamic impacts and therefore the appropriate sustainable levels of energy removal.","author":["Nash, S.","Phoenix, A."],"organization":["National University of Ireland"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2353","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/precautionary-principle-wind-farm-planning-data-scarcity-does-not-imply-absence","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/234061595_The_precautionary_principle_and_wind-farm_planning_Data_scarcity_does_not_imply_absence_of_effects","title":"The precautionary principle and wind-farm planning: data scarcity does not imply absence of effects","description":"Scientific discussions such as that raised by Janss et al. (2010) in relation to our paper (Carrete et al., 2009) help to clarify issues in the field of wind energy planning, thus relegating non-technical issues that can potentially contaminate the debate. Janss et al. (2010) recognize the value of our work as the first large-scale assessment of wind farms on the population viability of an endangered species. However, these authors argue that (1) wind-farms in Andalusia (SE Spain) have been carefully planned, with wind-farm locations chosen on the basis of previous risk assessment studies (RAS), and (2) the mortality rate of Egyptian vultures used in our paper to develop the PVA analysis is a local phenomenon that cannot be extrapolated to other areas of Spain. We will try to briefly clarify these points, showing that they are based on outdated information suggesting that results and conclusions brought forth in our paper remain valid.","author":["Camina, A.","Carrete, M.","Sanchez-Zapata, J.","Benitez, J.","Lobon, M.","Donazar, J.","Lekuona, J.","Montelio, E."],"organization":["Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Cient\u00edficas (CSIS)","Universidad Miguel Hernandez","Universidad Pablo de Olavide","University of Navarra"],"originationDate":"2010-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.385580500000","-6.004671300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Raptors"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:00","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2354","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/enhancing-carcass-removal-trials-three-wind-energy-facilities-portugal","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/267034802_Enhancing_Carcass_Removal_Trials_at_Three_Wind_Energy_Facilities_in_Portugal","title":"Enhancing Carcass Removal Trials at Three Wind Energy Facilities in Portugal","description":"During the last years there has been a significant worldwide increase in the number of wind farms. This kind of energy can have negative impacts, such as the direct mortality or lethal injury of birds and bats caused by collision with wind turbines. In order to evaluate bird (or bat) mortality regarding wind power generation facilities, strict monitoring protocols are required which must take into account the possibility of carcass removal by scavenging animals or decomposition before the monitoring session. For this purpose, carcass removal trials with 180 carcasses representing three size classes (small, medium and large) were conducted in two seasons (Spring and Autumn) at three wind farms located in the central region of Portugal. No significant differences were found between removal rates of different wind farms or size classes contrarily to seasons, which presented an average carcass removal time of 3.9 and 4.6 days, respectively for Spring and Autumn. The results of the present study showed the importance of trials to estimate the carcass removal rates, which influences the survey effort management and consequently the monitoring protocols. The experimental design for future trials in the same region should account for season effect and be conducted using daily checks of the carcasses for, at least, 15 days.","author":["Bispo, R.","Bernardino, J.","Costa, H.","Mascarenhas, M.","Rebelo, R.","Torres, P."],"organization":["Bioinsight","University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2011-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.133333000000","-8.143959700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bernardio-et-al-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2355","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/managing-coexistence-bats-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/132.248.10.25\/therya\/index.php\/THERYA\/article\/view\/330\/pdf_86","title":"Managing coexistence for bats and wind turbines","description":"The human enterprise continuously faces the need for increased energy, particularly electrical. The main sources for electricity production, until a few years ago, have been fossil fuels or hydroelectric dams. In recent times generation from other renewable sources has increased, among which wind energy production has become increasingly important (GWSC 2014). In contrast to fossil fuels, energy produced by wind turbines entails no CO2 production or any other type of air pollution (Fthenakis and Kim 2009). Therefore, in this time of global warming, a massive increase in wind farms is expected to contribute to a cleaner energy future (GWSC 2011), along with other renewable energy sources (IPCC 2007). Projections are that wind energy production will increase exponentially from 6.1 gigawatts (GW) per year in 1996 and 318.1 GW in 2013 (GWSC 2014). See Table 1 for projections of the growth of the industry to 2030.  Recent studies have hypothesized that wind farm facilities can have a highly negative impact on the local community of bats (Rydell et al. 2010; Arnett and Baerwald 2013; Hayes 2013; Medell\u00edn et al. 2014). The tree roosting bat species seem to be those that have high fatalities by the turbines (Cryan et al. 2014). Two of these studies have been very controversial. The first of these (Subramanian 2012) reported that 18,000 wind turbines in Spain may be killing between 6 to 18 million birds and bats annually. The second one (Hayes 2013) has analyzed 22 published estimates of bat mortality at wind farms in the United States which ranged from 0.2 to 53.5 fatalities per megawatt (MW) generated per year with a mean of 13.4. At the 2012 rate of 51,000 MW per year, he suggests that over 600,000 bats would have been killed in that year. The reliability of these mortality extrapolations has been criticized on statistical methodology grounds (Huso and Dalthorp 2014), but what is important here is that these and other studies have shown that significant numbers of bat fatalities are caused by wind turbines in the United States alone. Moreover, we must keep in mind that mortally injured bats can fly away only to die later causing underestimation of mortality rates (Grodsky et al. 2011). Some data show that bats are more vulnerable to die by wind turbines than birds (Smallwood 2013).  This non-trivial impact on bat mortality carries potentially substantial ecological and agricultural costs. Bats are abundant in temperate to tropical regions, including semi-arid biomes. They are known to have major impacts in controlling insect pests of agriculture at least in some regions (Boyles et al. 2011). Furthermore, frugivores are often important seed dispersers and significant pollinators as well. There is also the potential for bats killed by wind turbines to spread rabies to scavengers (Grodsky et al. 2011). This conflict between the needs for clean electricity production and the needs for bat conservation must be addressed promptly.  Given that wind power generation is a necessary component of our future power supply, that bats are major contributors to ecosystem services that support human civilizations, and that bats are at 506 THERYA Vol.6(3): 505-513 CARTA AL EDITOR risk for significant negative impacts by wind turbines, we must give serious attention to how we can design wind farms so as to minimize their negative environmental impacts. Here we discuss aspects of wind farm design that should be considered as routine procedures inherent in plans to establish a wind farm and to improve management of existing facilities. In doing this, serious attention needs to be directed to the unique nature of each potential site and its local bat fauna. We divide these considerations into biological and technological aspects. Of course, attention to bat mortality needs to be integrated with concerns for improving energy production efficiency and reducing bird fatalities as well (Hutchins 2014). Wind farms have been recorded to have a strong effect on mortality of birds (Erickson et al. 2014; American Wind Wildlife Institute 2015).","author":["Alvarez-Castaneda, T.","Lidicker, W."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2015-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.184303400000","-123.797597900000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2356","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/first-records-dead-bats-chiroptera-wind-farms-croatia","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/263127875_First_records_of_dead_bats_Chiroptera_from_wind_farms_in_Croatia","title":"First records of dead bats (Chiroptera) from wind farms in Croatia","description":"Many studies have shown that wind farms can have negative impact on bats. Records of dead bats under wind turbines were discovered in different countries, in some cases reaching very high numbers (ex. Ahlen 2003, Johnson et al. 2003, Kerns \u0026amp;Kerlinger 2004, Arnett 2005), however, it is not well understood, why bats collide with wind turbines (Ahlen 2003).  In Croatia, two wind farms were built near the Adriatic coast, on in 2004 and the other in 2006. Recently, few sporadic checks of areas under the wind turbines revealed bat casualities at both locations. Record of one finding was reported in Slovenian bat magazine (Jancar 2006). Here we summarize all records of dead bats, found under wind turbines in Croatia.","author":["Zagmajster, M.","Jancar, T.","Mlakar, J."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2007-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.612847300000","11.639305500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2357","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/acoustic-characterization-mutriku-owc-plant","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/340280720_Acoustic_characterization_of_Mutriku_OWC_Plant","title":"Acoustic characterization of Mutriku OWC Plant","description":"The Mutriku Oscillating Water Column (OWC) Plant is an onshore infrastructure for wave energy harnessing promoted by the Basque Entity of Energy (Ente Vasco de la Energ\u00eda, EVE). The facility is housed within a breakwater at the port of Mutriku (Basque Country, Northern Spain) and opened in July 2011. The plant consists of 16 turbines giving a total installed capacity of 296 kW. During winter 2015 it reached a major milestone; its first GWh of electricity supplied to the grid. This facility is now available as a test site providing developers with a unique opportunity to test new concepts in air turbines, generators, control strategies and auxiliary equipment.  Like other human activities in the marine environment, some environmental impacts over the marine environment were expected during the Mutriku OWC Plant exploitation phase. Among them, the generation of underwater sound during this phase was identified as one of the main expected environmental impact. In order to evaluate this impact, an environmental monitoring Plan (EMP) was developed for the monitoring of the underwater sound produced by the Mutriku OWC Plant.","author":["Ruiz-Minguela, P.","Bald, J.","Uriarte, A.","Ortega, N."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-03-27","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-18 11:45:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Baldietal2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2358","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/deep-green-holyhead-deep-project-phase-i-05-mw-environmental-statement","sourceURL":"https:\/\/minesto.com\/holyhead-deep\/","title":"Deep Green Holyhead Deep Project Phase I (0.5 MW) - Environmental Statement","description":"The DG Holyhead Deep Project will be the first full-scale deployment of Minesto\u2019s tidal energy concept, Deep Green, which uses underwater \u2018kites\u2019 to generate electricity. Deep Green\u2019s ability to operate in deep water sites and low velocity currents will open up new areas to tidal energy projects and it is expected to provide significant advantages over fixed turbine technologies in terms of efficiency and operational costs. The Project will pave the way for the first full-scale commercial deployment, representing an important step towards Wales fulfilling its potential to become a world leader in marine renewable energy.  Minesto was founded in 2007 for the purpose of developing the Deep Green technology. The company\u2019s headquarters are located in Gothenburg, Sweden, their prototype testing facility is in Portaferry, Northern Ireland, and recently opened their UK headquarters in Holyhead, Anglesey. To date, their work has focused on developing the Deep Green technology and demonstrating its viability through basin tests and field trials in Strangford Lough, Northern Ireland, using 1:10 and 1:4 scale devices. The next step is to deploy a full scale device. Following a comprehensive site selection study, the Holyhead Deep in North Wales was selected as the ideal location to deploy the Project, providing deep water and favourable tidal conditions in close proximity to port facilities and viable grid connection options for the future. An additional benefit is the potential for sharing future project infrastructure with Morlais Marine Energy, who are developing the West of Anglesey Tidal Demonstration Zone, increasing cost efficiency whilst minimising the combined environmental footprint of the projects.  This Environmental Statement is the result of nearly two years\u2019 multi-disciplinary environmental research and stakeholder consultation. They are highly aware of the special character of the marine environment in North Wales and the responsibility they have to preserve it. They hope that this is clearly demonstrated through the approach with which they have carried out the research, consultation and project design that contributed to the environmental impact assessment.  Their intention is to be transparent and communicative in all of their work, and are committed to maintaining effective dialogue with all interested parties. Thus far, they have consulted with a wide range of stakeholder groups and organisations and have incorporated their concerns and observations when making project decisions. In their view, consultation is an ongoing process which they will continue after the submission of the application throughout the duration of the Project, should they obtain consent.  The submission of this document is a critical step for the Project, and they welcome the opportunity it provides for all interested parties to take part in the decision making process. Should consent for the Project be granted, it will represent a significant milestone in the journey towards the marine renewable energy and with it, the opportunity to create a prosperous and sustainable industry in Wales.  The predicted positive impacts of marine renewables to the Welsh and UK economy is significant with an estimated 19,500 jobs being created by 2035 and associated revenue generation estimated at \u00a36.1 billion. In recognition of the significant potential of the Project to positively impact the socio-economic landscape of the region, the Welsh European Funding Office has publicly pledged to award Minesto \u00a39.5 million of European Union funds to help make a positive impact on North Wales through clean energy generation, job creation, and economic growth. They will continue our work with regional development organisations such as Mentor M\u00f4n, and the North Wales supply chain, in order to attract inward investment and diversify the existing skills base.  Delivering this Project so it does not affect the integrity of the environment, fully complies with all environmental obligations, and capitalises on the opportunity to confer economic benefits to the region is a fundamental priority to Minesto. Minesto hopes that on consideration of this document, you will agree that they have a sound understanding of what is required to achieve these goals, and look forward to continuing our dialogue with all interested parties.","author":["Minesto"],"organization":["Minesto"],"originationDate":"2016-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["53.322272900000","-4.614405500000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-14 10:55:25","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Minesto2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2359","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/deep-water-next-step-offshore-wind-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ewea.org\/report\/deep-water","title":"Deep Water: The Next Step for Offshore Wind Energy","description":"Offshore wind is one of the fastest growing maritime sectors. Its installed capacity was 5 GW at end 2012, and by 2020 this could be eight times higher, at 40 GW, meeting 4% of European electricity demand. By 2030, offshore wind capacity could total 150 GW, meeting 14% of the EU\u2019s total electricity consumption.  However, for this to happen, a supportive legislative framework is needed, and new offshore designs must be developed for deep water in order to tap the large wind potential of the Atlantic, Mediterranean and deep North Sea waters. Current commercial substructures are economically limited to maximum water depths of 40m to 50m. The \u2018deep offshore\u2019 environment starts at water depths greater than 50m.  Contents    Floating turbine designs are cost-competitive with fixed-bottom designs in waters over 50m deep.  If challenges are successfully met, deep water wind farms could be operating in four years\u2019 time.  Floating turbines in North Sea deep waters alone could power Europe four times over.  Offshore wind in Europe could be providing 145 million households with renewable electricity and employing 318,000 people by 2030, while providing energy security, technology exports, and no greenhouse gases.  If the requirements are met, the first full-scale deep offshore wind farms could be producing power by 2017.","author":["Vergara, J.","Tsouroukdissian, A.","Schuon, F.","Ugarte, A.","Sandberg, J.","Tunbjer, A.","Roth, R.","Voutsinas, S.","Weinstein, A.","Vita, L.","de Laleu, V.","Arapogianni, A.","Genachte, A.","Ochagavia, R.","Castell, D.","Korbijn, J.","Bolleman, N.","Huera-Huarte, F.","Maciel, J.","de la Gueriviere, P.","Coulombeau, P.","Jadrec, S.","Philippe, C.","Byklum, E.","Hurley, W.","Grubel, H."],"organization":["European Wind Energy Association (EWEA)"],"originationDate":"2013-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/EWEA-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2360","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/orecca-european-offshore-renewable-energy-roadmap","sourceURL":"","title":"ORECCA European Offshore Renewable Energy Roadmap","description":"This document represents for the first time a combined roadmap developed for the offshore wind, wave and tidal stream energy sectors, focussed on the synergies, opportunities and barriers to development that are revealed when the sectors are investigated together in pan-technology and pan-European context.\n\nThe principal target audiences of the recommendations set out are policy makers at the EU and Member State level. However, the recommendations and the way forwards set out are also of high importance for other stakeholders to the offshore renewable energy sector.\n\nThe roadmap is structured around five key streams which are essential to the development of the offshore renewable energy sector. Each of these streams has a dedicated chapter in the main roadmap document:\nResource;\nFinance;\nTechnology;\nInfrastructure;\nEnvironment, Regulation \u0026 Legislation.\n\nEurope has a large amount of natural resource across the three offshore renewable energy sectors. Technically offshore wind, wave and tidal together could supply 100% of Europe\u201fs future electricity demand. These resources present significant opportunities with respect to increased energy security, emissions reductions, and economic benefits including job creation.\n\nBefore looking forward to where the offshore renewable energy sectors are heading in the future, it is important to consider where the sectors are now. For the offshore wind sector, there is currently approximately 4GW installed capacity in Europe, and over 100GW in the planning pipeline for 2020. In comparison, for the ocean energy sector (wave and tidal stream), no commercial farm scale deployments currently exist, and the amount of capacity in the pipeline for Europe by 2020 is approximately 2GW. It is clear that the ocean energy sector is at an earlier stage of development than the offshore wind sector and a deployment timeline for the two sectors is shown in Figure A below.\n\nThe ORECCA project does not set out deployment targets for the offshore renewable energy sectors, but aligns itself with existing targets and aims to facilitate their achievement by identifying synergies and addressing barriers to the development of the sectors. Both European and International targets exist for the sectors, as illustrated in Figure B. All of these targets present an opportunity for the realisation of large economic benefits in the European Union (EU). The EU OEA envisage that the realisation of the European target of 188GW installed capacity of ocean energy by 2050 alone could result in the creation of over 450,000 jobs.\n\nThe offshore wind targets are higher than the ocean energy targets at both the international and European level, due to the fact that the ocean energy sectors are currently at an earlier stage of development and it will take longer to achieve large scale commercial deployments. A large portion of the global targets will have to be met by deployments outside Europe. This represents an important market and opportunity for the sectors, which are currently heavily concentrated in Europe, to export technology and expertise worldwide.","author":["Jeffrey, H.","Sedgwick, J."],"organization":["University of Edinburgh","European Commission"],"originationDate":"2011-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal","Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/ORECCA-2011.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2361","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/migratory-behaviour-bats-south-swedish-coasts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.biodiversitylibrary.org\/part\/192315","title":"Migratory behaviour of bats at south Swedish coasts","description":"From marking and recoveries, it has long been known that some bat species migrate between summer and winter haunts, e. g. Myotis dasycneme, Myotis lucifugus (e.g. Egsbaek and Jensen 1963; Davis and Hitchcock 1965). It has also been shown that some species undertake long distance seasonal north-south migrations, e. g. Miniopterus schreibersi, Nyctalus noctula, Pipistrellus nathusii, Vespertilio murinus in Europe and, e.g. Tadarida brasiliensis, Myotis sodalis in North America (Aellen 1983; Griffin 1970; Masing 1988, 1989; Petersons 1990; Strelkov 1969; Yalden and Morris 1975). It is also well known that bats are able to cross the sea since several species have been reported from many more or less remote Islands, oil rigs and ships (Baagoe and Bloch 1994; Petersen 1994; Stansfield 1966). Among these records, migratory species prevail.","author":["Ahl\u00e9n, I."],"organization":["Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences"],"originationDate":"1997-03-11","spatial":{"coordinates":["56.003672200000","14.497723000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2362","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impact-assessment-marine-current-turbines-fish-behavior-using-experimental-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s00773-016-0405-y","title":"Impact assessment of marine current turbines on fish behavior using an experimental approach based on the similarity law","description":"Energy from tidal streams is a reliable renewable energy source worth exploiting. With increasing concern over the potential effects of ocean energy utilization on marine environment and organisms, several previous experimental studies have been conducted focusing on fish behavior and their collision risk with hydrokinetic turbines for power generation. This study is aimed at exploring the behavior of marine animals around marine current turbines (MCTs) in the sea environment by conducting a laboratory experiment based on similarity laws for the turbine tip speed and maximum marine animal swimming speed. Three rotation frequencies (0, 5 and 20 rpm) with two releasing areas (upstream and downstream areas) were considered in our experiment. Results showed that fish survival rate was 100 % after 48 h, and only one fish came into contact with the turbine hub and was inactive in front of it when the MCT was in a stationary state during our preliminary test of swimming endurance. Although both the initial releasing area of fish and the rotation speed of MCT have significant effects on fish passage count rate (PCR) via a turbine, there is no interaction between these two factors. PCR was generally higher when fish were put into the tank in the downstream area, irrespective of the turbine rotation. And the returning behavior in the downstream area was more frequently found compared with that in the upstream area, which indicates that the location of MCTs should be considered at the downstream of a channel in practice to reduce the potential risk of fish injury. The ratio of fish passing from the outer side (\u00b13) of the turbine was larger, and a clear U-shaped distribution could be observed. The entering behavior almost disappeared (less than 1.3 %) when MCT rotated with a frequency of 20 rpm. It indicates the design of the rotation frequency of MCT should be more than 20 rpm. However, higher tip speeds and darkness conditions are not considered in our experiment. Based on the laws of similarity proposed in this study, it becomes possible to compare the experimental results with real sea results, to allow explanation and discussion of fish behavior around MCTs, through the parameters of flow velocity, turbine tip speed, and maximum fish swimming speed.","author":["Kitazawa, D.","Zhang, J.","Taya, S.","Mizukami, Y."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2363","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modelling-effects-marine-energy-extraction-non-cohesive-sediment-transport","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/Topics\/marine\/Publications\/stats\/Science\/SMFS\/2017\/0807","title":"Modelling the Effects of Marine Energy Extraction on Non-Cohesive Sediment Transport and Morphological Change in the Pentland Firth and Orkney Waters","description":"This paper considers the process of modelling sediment transport and morphological change in the Pentland Firth and Orkney Waters using coastal area models. This region is atypical of regions commonly modelled using such techniques: it is high energy with limited and highly variable regions of mobile sediment. This causes challenges with regards both model capability and availability of data. Computational time restrictions for fully coupled modelling solutions should also be recognised which limits practical duration of simulation. Impacts to modelled bed level change over test periods are noted for both wave and tidal energy extraction scenarios. In both cases the magnitude of difference is equal to the magnitude of the change itself, however, lack of data and poor validation of the morphological modelling for the wave energy test case means confidence is low in these results. Based on the difficulties faced in conducting these modelling exercises and the high cost of additional data collection, it is recommended that regulators take a pragmatic approach when requiring such modelling for environmental impact assessments at some locations where changes to morphodynamics are unlikely to be critical to key receptors. Other approaches such as conceptual modelling or consideration of bed shear stresses could be undertaken rather than fully coupled morphodynamic modelling.","author":["Fairley, I.","Karunarathna, H.","Chatzirodou, A."],"organization":["Swansea University","Marine Scotland Science"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.773997200000","-3.113556800000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fairley-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2364","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/lessons-learnt-meygen-phase-1a-design-phase","sourceURL":"","title":"Lessons Learnt from MeyGen Phase 1a: Design Phase","description":"MeyGen Limited (MeyGen) is a Scottish-registered company established in 2010 for the purpose of developing the MeyGen Tidal Energy Project. MeyGen was awarded an Agreement for Lease for the Inner Sound tidal development site on 21 October 2010 by The Crown Estate. The Inner Sound Agreement for Lease is for 398MW of installed tidal stream energy capacity and will be consented in two separate phases.  Phase 1 has already been consented. It is sub-divided into 3 further phases; 1A, 1B and 1C. Phase 1A is a 6MW demonstration array, which comprises four 1.5MW tidal turbines. Phase 1A reached financial close in 2014, and is now approaching completion of construction. Phase 1B will comprise a further 6MW commercial array to be installed by 2018, and Phase 1C will add another 74MW, bringing the total capacity for Phase 1 to 86 MW \u2013 the extent of the secured planning consents. Phase 1C deployment is intended in 2021-2022. Phase 2 will increase the installed capacity to a total of 252MW, the extent of the currently secured grid connection capacity. Phase 3 will then require an additional expanded grid connection to build the project out to the full site capacity of 398MW.  Phase 1A of the MeyGen project is partly funded through a \u00a310million grant from the Department for Business Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS) under the Marine Energy Array Demonstrator (MEAD) Fund. The remainder of the funding is from Atlantis Resources Limited, and The Crown Estate, Scottish Enterprise\u2019s Renewable Energy Investment Fund, and Highlands and Islands Enterprise (collectively with BEIS, referred to herein as the \u2018Funders\u2019). One of the requirements of the BEIS grant contract is that MeyGen considers the experiences from the MeyGen Phase 1A project, which may be useful to the wider tidal industry, through a series of \u2018lessons learnt\u2019 workshops, and that the results of these workshops are disseminated for the benefit of the wider tidal industry.  There are anticipated to be three such workshops, each representing the main stages of the Phase 1A project. The first workshop corresponds to the period from financial close to the end of the design phase, the second workshop to the end of the construction phase, and the third workshop to the end of the initial operational phase. This report summarises the results of the first of these workshops. This report will be superseded by an updated report once the second workshop has been held, and the final report will contain the results from all three workshops.","author":["MeyGen"],"organization":["ABP Marine Environmental Research Ltd (ABPmer)","MeyGen","UK Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS)"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.656500000000","-3.130000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-12 04:33:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MeyGen-2017-Part1.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2365","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/changing-tides-acceptability-support-perceptions-tidal-energy-united-states","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S221462961730107X","title":"Changing Tides: Acceptability, Support, and Perceptions of Tidal Energy in the United States","description":"Tidal energy is a renewable energy source that could be used to help mitigate climate change. Tidal energy technology is in the early stages of development and views towards this technology and energy source are not well understood. Through a representative mail survey of Washington State residents, we assessed attitudes and behaviors related to tidal energy, perceived benefits and risks, and climate change beliefs. Higher levels of perceived benefits and climate change beliefs were associated with increased acceptability of and support for tidal energy whereas greater perceived risks were associated with decreased acceptability and support (acceptability being an attitudinal construct, support a behavioral construct). Coastal residents reported higher levels of acceptability and support than non-coastal residents. Pulling from innovation theory, we show that levels of support depended upon the development lifecycle stage of the technology. Support declined once the project moved into the water from the lab, however, grid-connected pilot projects were more likely to be supported than those without grid-connection. Policies developed to encourage the development of tidal energy may be more accepted and supported if they include incentives for pilot phases with grid-connection.","author":["Dreyer, S.","Polis, H.","Jenkins, L."],"organization":["Arizona State University","University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.949066600000","-122.603929200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2366","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/pacific-region-marine-renewables-environmental-regulatory-workshop-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pacificoceanenergy.org\/research\/owet-research\/","title":"Pacific Region Marine Renewables Environmental Regulatory Workshop Report","description":"The Pacific Region Marine Renewables Environmental Regulatory Workshop was held in conjunction with the 11th Annual Ocean Renewable Energy Conference in Portland, Oregon, on September 21, 2016 in response to frustrations and concerns expressed by members of the marine renewable energy (MRE) industry about permitting processes for MRE development being long, drawn out, challenging, and expensive, even for very small devices and pilot-scale deployments.  The workshop participants included federal and state regulators, MHK developers, and researchers. Two documents - Annex IV 2016 State of the Science Report and A Review of the Environmental Impacts for Marine Hydrokinetic Projects to Inform Regulatory Permitting: Summary Findings from the 2015 Workshop on Marine Hydrokinetic Technologies, Washington D.C. - were presented to the participants. Estimates of the perceived risks to the marine environment (\u201cdashboards\u201d) for six key interactions were also presented and discussed.","author":["Copping, A.","Kramer, S.","Nelson, P.","Sather, N."],"organization":["H.T. Harvey \u0026 Associates","Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","Oregon Wave Energy Trust (OWET)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OWET-Workshop-Report-final.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2368","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/beach-morphodynamics-lee-wave-farm-synergies-coastal-defence","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pearl.plymouth.ac.uk\/bitstream\/handle\/10026.1\/8807\/2017abanadestercero10426926phd.pdf","title":"Beach Morphodynamics in the Lee of a Wave Farm: Synergies with Coastal Defence","description":"Wave energy has a great potential in many coastal areas thanks to a number of advantages: the abundant resource, the highest energy density of all renewables, the greater availability factors than e.g. wind or solar energy; and the low environmental and particularly visual impact. In addition, a novel advantage will be investigated in this work: the possibility of a synergetic use for carbon-free energy production and coastal protection. In this context, wave energy can contribute not only to decarbonising the energy supply and reducing greenhouse emissions, but also to mitigating coastal erosion. In effect, wave farms will be deployed nearshore to generate electricity from wave energy, an d therefore the leeward coast will be exposed to a milder wave climate, which can potentially mitigate coastal erosion. This thesis aims to determine the effectiveness of wave farms for combating coastal erosion by means of a suite of state-of-the-art process-based numerical models that are applied in several case studies (Perranporth Beach, UK; and Xago Beach, Spain) and at different time scales (from the short-term to the long-term). A wave propagation model, SWAN, is used to establish the effects of the wave farm on the wave conditions. The outcomes of SWAN will be coupled to XBeach, a costal processes model that is applied to analyse the effects of the milder wave conditions on the coast. In addition to these models, empirical classifications and analytical solutions are used as well to characterise the alteration of the beach morphology due to the presence of a wave farm. The analysis of the wave farm impacts on the wave conditions and the beach morphology will be carried out through a set of ad hoc imp act indicators. Parameters such as the reduction in the significant wave height, the performance of the wave farm, the effects on the sea bed level and the erosion in the beach face area are defined to characterise these impacts. Moreover, the role played by the key design parameters of wave farms, e.g. farm-to-coast distance or layout, is also examined. The results from this analysis demonstrate that wave farms, in addition to their main purpose of generating carbon-free energy, are capable of reducing erosion at the coast. Storm-induced erosion is significantly reduced due to the presence of wave farms in the areas most at risk from this phenomenon. However, the effects of wave farms on the coast do not lend themselves to general statements, for they will depend on the wave farm design (WEC type, layout and farm-to-coast distance) and the characteristics of the area in question, as shown in this document for Perranporth and Xago. In summary, this synergy will improve the economic viability of wave farm projects through savings in conventional coastal defence measures, thereby fostering the development of this nascent renewable, reducing greenhouse gas emission and converging towards a more sustainable energy model. Thus, wave energy contributes to mitigating climate change by two means, one acting on the cause, the other on the effect: (i) by bringing down carbon emissions (cause) through its production of renewable energy, and (ii) by reducing coastal erosion (effect).","author":["Abanades, J."],"organization":["Plymouth University"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2369","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hybrid-wave-offshore-wind-farms-comparative-case-study-co-located-layouts","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166916300285","title":"Hybrid Wave and Offshore Wind Farms: A Comparative Case Study of Co-located Layouts","description":"Marine energy is one of the most promising alternatives to fossil fuels due to the enormous energy resource available. However, it is often considered uneconomical and difficult. Co-located offshore wind turbines and wave energy converters have emerged as a solution to increase the competitiveness of marine energy. Among the benefits of co-located farms, this work focuses on the shadow effect, i.e. the reduction in wave height in the inner part of the farm, which can lead to significant savings in operation and maintenance (O\u0026M) costs thanks to the augmented weather windows for accessing the wind turbines. The aim of this study is to quantify the wave height reduction achieved within a co-located wave-wind farm. Different locations and a large number of layouts are analysed in order to define the optimum disposition.","author":["Iglesias, G.","Abanades, J.","Astariz, S.","Perez-Collazo, C."],"organization":["Plymouth University","University of Santiago de Compostela"],"originationDate":"2016-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave","Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2370","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/characterisation-biofouling-community-floating-wave-energy-device","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/full\/10.1080\/08927014.2017.1317755","title":"Characterisation of the Biofouling Community on a Floating Wave Energy Device","description":"Wave energy devices are novel structures in the marine environment and, as such, provide a unique habitat for biofouling organisms. In this study, destructive scrape samples and photoquadrats were used to characterise the temperate epibenthic community present on prototypes of the Pelamis wave energy converter. The biofouling observed was extensive and diverse with 115 taxa recorded including four non-native species. Vertical zonation was identified on the sides of the device, with an algae-dominated shallow subtidal area and a deeper area characterised by a high proportion of suspension-feeding invertebrates. Differences in species composition and biomass were also observed between devices, along the length of the device and between sampling dates. This research provides an insight into the variation of biofouling assemblages on a wave energy device as well as the potential technical and ecological implications associated with biofouling on marine renewable energy structures.","author":["Schl\u00e4ppy, M.","Guerin, A.","Nall, C."],"organization":["Newcastle University","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)"],"originationDate":"2017-05-16","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2371","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wildlife-wind-farms-conflicts-solutions-volume-1-onshore-potential-effects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pelagicpublishing.com\/products\/wildlife-and-wind-farms-vol-1-onshore-potential-effects","title":"Wildlife and Wind Farms - Conflicts and Solutions, Volume 1. Onshore: Potential Effects","description":"Wind farms are an essential component of global renewable energy policy and the action to limit the effects of climate change. There is, however, considerable concern over the impacts of wind farms on wildlife, leading to a wide range of research and monitoring studies, a growing body of literature and several international conferences on the topic.  This unique multi-volume work provides a comprehensive overview of the interactions between wind farms and wildlife.  Volume 1 documents the current knowledge of the potential impacts upon wildlife during both construction and operation. An introductory chapter on the nature of wind farms and the impact assessment process is followed by a series of in-depth chapters documenting effects on climatic conditions, vegetation, terrestrial invertebrates, aquatic invertebrates and fish, reptiles and amphibians, birds, bats and terrestrial mammals. A synopsis of the known and potential effects of wind farms upon wildlife in perspective concludes the volume.  The authors have been carefully selected from across the globe from the large number of academics, consultants and practitioners now engaged in wind farm studies, for their influential contribution to the science. Edited by Martin Perrow and with contributions by 40 leading researchers including: Robert Barclay, Michael Dillon, Jan Olof Helldin, Hermann H\u00f6tker, Jeffrey Lovich, Manuela de Lucas and Eugene Takle. The authors represent a wide range of organisations and institutions including the Universities of Calgary, Iowa State, Lund \u0026amp; Wyoming, US Geological Survey, Michael-Otto-Institut im NABU, Norwegian Institute for Nature Research, Spanish Council for Scientific Research, Renewable Energy Systems and several leading consultancies.  Each chapter includes informative figures, tables, colour photographs and detailed case studies. Many of the latter are produced stand-alone from invited additional authors to ensure geographic spread and to showcase exciting new, often previously unpublished research.  This book is designed for practitioners, researchers, managers and for a range of students in higher education, particularly those involved with environmental, ecological, conservation, impact assessment and climate change studies.  Book Volumes:    Volume 1: Onshore: Potential Effects (978-1-78427-119-0)  Volume 2: Onshore: Monitoring and Mitigation (978-1-78427-123-7)  Volume 3: Offshore: Potential Effects (978-1-78427-127-5)  Volume 4: Offshore: Monitoring and Mitigation (978-1-78427-131-2)   Table of Contents:    The nature of wind farms - Gero Vella  Climate - Eugene S. Takle  Vegetation - Margarida R. Silva and Isabel Passos  Terrestrial invertebrates - Sarah Elzay, Lusha Tronstad and Michael E. Dillon  Aquatic organisms - William O\u2019Connor  Reptiles and amphibians - Jeffrey E. Lovich and Joshua R. Ennen  Birds: displacement - Hermann H\u00f6tker  Birds: collision - Manuela de Lucas and Martin R. Perrow  Bats - Robert M.R. Barclay, Erin F. Baerwald and Jens Rydell  Terrestrial mammals - Jan Olof Helldin, Anna Skarin, Wiebke Neumann, Mattias Olsson, Jens Jung, Jonas Kindberg, Niklas Lindberg and Fredrik Widemo  A synthesis of effects and impacts - Martin R. Perrow","author":["Perrow, M."],"organization":["ECON Ecological Consultancy"],"originationDate":"2017-04-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Invertebrates","Birds","Ecosystem Processes","Physical Environment","Reptiles","Terrestrial Mammals","Collision","Noise","Habitat Change","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2372","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wildlife-wind-farms-conflicts-solutions-volume-2-onshore-monitoring-mitigation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pelagicpublishing.com\/products\/wildlife-and-wind-farms-vol-2-onshore-monitoring-mitigation","title":"Wildlife and Wind Farms - Conflicts and Solutions, Volume 2. Onshore: Monitoring and Mitigation","description":"Wind farms are an essential component of global renewable energy policy and the action to limit the effects of climate change. There is, however, considerable concern over the impacts of wind farms on wildlife, leading to a wide range of research and monitoring studies, a growing body of literature and several international conferences on the topic.  This unique multi-volume work provides a comprehensive overview of the interactions between wind farms and wildlife.  Volume 2 provides a state-of-the-science guide to monitoring and mitigation to minimise or even eliminate impacts on wildlife from wind farms. The survey and monitoring section includes detailed chapters on birds and bats followed by chapters on modelling of collision risk and populations and the statistical principles of fatality monitoring. The following mitigation section comprises chapters on spatial planning and effective mitigation strategies for bats, birds and raptors including through repowering. A synopsis of international best planning and practice concludes the volume.  The authors have been carefully selected from across the globe from the large number of academics, consultants and practitioners now engaged in wind farm studies, for their influential contribution to the science. Edited by Martin Perrow and with contributions by over 30 leading researchers including: Ed Arnett, Cris Hein, Manuela Huso, Johann K\u00f6ppel, Roel May, Ian Smales \u0026amp; Shawn Smallwood. The authors represent a wide range of organisations and institutions including Bat Conservation International, Birdwatch Ireland, Norwegian Institute for Nature Research, Spanish Council for Scientific Research, Swiss Ornithological Institute, Technische Universit\u00e4t Berlin and US Geological Survey as well as several leading consultancies.  Each chapter includes informative figures, tables, photographs and detailed case studies. Several of the latter are produced stand-alone from invited additional authors to ensure geographic spread and to showcase exciting new research.  This book is designed for practitioners, researchers, managers and for a range of students in higher education, particularly those involved with environmental, ecological, conservation, impact assessment and climate change studies.  Book Volumes:    Volume 1: Onshore: Potential Effects (978-1-78427-119-0)  Volume 2: Onshore: Monitoring and Mitigation (978-1-78427-123-7)  Volume 3: Offshore: Potential Effects (978-1-78427-127-5)  Volume 4: Offshore: Monitoring and Mitigation (978-1-78427-131-2)   Table of Contents    Monitoring birds - K. Shawn Smallwood  Monitoring bats - Cris D. Hein  Modelling collision risk and populations - Ian Smales  Statistical principles of post-construction fatality monitoring design - Manuela Huso, Dan Dalthorp and Fr\u00e4nzi Korner-Nievergelt  Spatial planning - Jenny Bright and Caoimhe Muldoon  Mitigation for birds - Roel May  Turbine siting for raptors - K. Shawn Smallwood, Lee Neher and Douglas A. Bell  Mitigating bat collision - Edward B. Arnett  A best practice approach to future planning - Victoria Gartman, Eva Schuster, Johann K\u00f6ppel and Martin R. Perrow","author":["Perrow, M."],"organization":["ECON Ecological Consultancy"],"originationDate":"2017-04-25","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2373","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mammalian-mesocarnivore-visitation-tortoise-burrows-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/wol1\/doi\/10.1002\/jwmg.21262\/abstract","title":"Mammalian Mesocarnivore Visitation at Tortoise Burrows in a Wind Farm","description":"There is little information on predator\u2013prey interactions in wind energy landscapes in North America, especially among terrestrial vertebrates. Here, we evaluated how proximity to roads and wind turbines affect mesocarnivore visitation with desert tortoises (Gopherus agassizii) and their burrows in a wind energy landscape. In 2013, we placed motion-sensor cameras facing the entrances of 46 active desert tortoise burrows in a 5.2-km2 wind energy facility near Palm Springs, California, USA. Cameras recorded images of 35 species of reptiles, mammals, and birds. Counts for 4 species of mesocarnivores at desert tortoise burrows increased closer to dirt roads, and decreased closer to wind turbines. Our results suggest that anthropogenic infrastructure associated with wind energy facilities could influence the general behavior of mammalian predators and their prey. Further investigation of proximate mechanisms that underlie road and wind turbine effects (i.e., ground vibrations, sound emission, and traffic volume) and on wind energy facility spatial designs (i.e., road and wind turbine configuration) could prove useful for better understanding wildlife responses to wind energy development. \u00a9 2017 The Wildlife Society.","author":["Lovich, J.","Ennen, J.","Agha, M.","Arundel, T.","Delaney, D.","Briggs, J.","Price, S.","Smith, A.","Fleckenstein, L.","Tennant, L.","Puffer, S.","Walde, A.","Todd, B."],"organization":["Colorado State University","Tennessee Aquarium Conservation Institute","University of California Davis","University of Kentucky","US Army Engineer Research and Development Center","US Geological Survey (USGS)","Walde Research and Environmental Consulting"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Reptiles","Terrestrial Mammals","Noise","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2374","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/lack-sound-science-assessing-wind-farm-impacts-seabirds","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/1365-2664.12731\/full","title":"Lack of Sound Science in Assessing Wind Farm Impacts on Seabirds","description":"Electrical power generation from wind farms has grown rapidly in the UK and European Union (EU) in the last decade and is set to grow further. By 2020, the EU proposes to source 20% of energy from renewable sources (Directive 2009\/28\/EC). Wind energy is expected to provide 9\u201314% of global electricity generation by 2050 (IPCC 2011). This may eventually reduce climatic change and its negative impacts on biodiversity, but there are also several poorly quantified negative effects on wild species of renewable energy generation, including wind turbines. For example, birds and bats are killed by colliding with turbine blades or towers and there may be effects of wind farms on mortality and reproductive rates of a wide range of species from avoidance and displacement. Birds may incur additional costs or forego benefits because of reduced transit or foraging within or near to wind farms (Drewitt \u0026 Langston 2006; Searle et\u00a0al. 2014). Depending upon the strength of density-dependent compensatory processes, these effects could reduce the population to a lower stable level or cause its extinction (Wade 1998; Niel \u0026 Lebreton 2005). Except in the rare circumstances where density dependence is exactly compensating, such effects would always diminish population size. Positive effects of renewable energy infrastructure on populations of wild species have also been proposed and, in a few cases, quantified. These include possible enhancement of food resources of seabirds by protection from fishing from the presence of offshore installations and the provision of artificial substrates as habitat for fish and invertebrates (Inger et\u00a0al. 2009; Langhamer, Wilhelmsson \u0026 Engstr\u00f6m 2009).\n\nThe UK has the best wind resources in Europe (DECC 2011). Although the cost per megawatt-hour of electricity generation from offshore wind turbines averages about twice that for onshore installations (Bilgili, Yasar \u0026 Simsek 2011; Chu \u0026 Majumdar 2012), offshore wind power is currently favoured over onshore by the present UK government because of public perceptions of nuisance and landscape consequences of onshore turbines. The UK also has internationally important breeding populations of seabirds. It holds more than 10% of the world\u0027s breeding population of eight species, of which three have more than half of their global breeding population in the UK (Brown et\u00a0al. 2015). Because seabirds range over long distances, there may be cumulative impacts on a breeding colony from several wind farms (Masden et\u00a0al. 2010). Seabirds are long-lived and late-maturing, which renders their population growth rate particularly sensitive to additional mortality from collisions or displacement (Niel \u0026 Lebreton 2005). The importance of these seabird populations and their sensitivity places a heavy responsibility on those conducting and acting upon scientific assessments of the impacts of offshore wind farms on seabirds to comply with the protection measures and the precautionary principle enshrined in the EU Birds and Habitats Directives (Directive 2009\/147\/EC and Council Directive 92\/43\/EEC).\n\nFor the UK, and other countries within the European Union, the regulation of wind farm construction requires the assessment of possible damage to the integrity of sites and populations under the EU Habitats and Birds Directives. Consideration must be given to impacts on bird populations of a project on its own and in combination with others already in existence, given consent or planned. Governments give or refuse consent for the construction of wind farms after taking into account the scale and level of certainty of the impacts indicated by these assessments. However, there are no definitive quantitative thresholds or criteria defining how large or likely expected impacts must be for damage to the integrity of sites and populations to be anticipated and for consent for wind farm construction to be denied or limited. Consent can be granted only if it is ascertained that there will not be an adverse effect on the integrity of a Natura site, excepting in cases where there are imperative reasons of overriding public interest for consent and no alternative solutions (Article 6(4) of Directive 92\/43\/EEC). In recent years, several plans for large offshore wind farms have been approved and some built in UK and EU waters close to large seabird populations because the competent authority judged there was no expected adverse effect on the integrity of the Natura sites involved. For example, in 2014 approval was granted for several extensive wind farms at Hornsea (England, UK Government) and the Firth of Forth (Scotland, Scottish Government), close to internationally important breeding populations of seabirds. This approach contrasts with that in some other EU states. In Germany and Denmark, for example, offshore wind farms have been subject to rigorous marine spatial planning with the aim of avoiding potential conflict with nature conservation as part of the required Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) process recommended in EU Commission guidance (European Commission 2011). The German Cabinet approved Europe\u0027s first maritime spatial plan in September 2009, after a considerable effort in terms of surveys and research to identify marine sites of high nature value and potential conflict areas with wind farms and to establish zones for various activities and infrastructure. The offshore SEA covering UK waters is not of comparable quality.\n\nIn this perspective, we argue that the methods and data used in these cases for estimating effects upon seabird demographic rates and translating them into potential impacts on seabird populations do not allow adequate assessment of effects on site integrity. As a result, sound science and its logical interpretation are lacking in Environmental Impact Assessments of this large and expanding industry.","author":["Wilson, J.","Langston, R.","McCluskie, A.","Sutherland, R.","Green, R."],"organization":["Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)","University of Cambridge"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:04","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2375","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/cumulative-impact-assessment-tidal-stream-energy-extraction-irish-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0029801817301798","title":"Cumulative Impact Assessment of Tidal Stream Energy Extraction in the Irish Sea","description":"A cumulative impact assessment of tidal stream developments in the Irish Sea has been conducted on a high-resolution depth-averaged hydrodynamic model, using Telemac2D. Eight sites were investigated, representing the proposed developments at the time of study. These included: Ramsey Sound, Anglesey, Strangford Loch, Mull of Kintyre, Torr Head, Fair Head, Sound of Islay and West of Islay. Only three projects showed array-array interaction: Fair Head, Torr Head and Mull of Kintyre. A smaller model domain was created for further analysis. Results showed Mull of Kintyre had little impact. Fair Head reduced the energy production at Torr Head by 17%, whereas, Fair Head only reduced by 2%. This was caused by the tidal asymmetry whereby the flood was stronger. When operated concurrently, the maximum power-output at Torr Head is 64.5 MW, representing 31% reduction. If Torr Head can still operate commercially in the presence of Fair Head, then the additional environmental impact of Torr Head, such as the change in bed shear stress, is small. Within the Irish Sea, very few of the tidal projects investigated are geographically close to each other. As the industry develops, the risk of interaction to these sites will grow when more intermediary sites are developed.","author":["Smith, C.","Venugopal, V.","Xiao, Q.","Haverson, D.","Bacon, J."],"organization":["Centre for Environment Fisheries and Aquaculture Science (CEFAS)","University of Edinburgh","University of Exeter","University of Strathclyde"],"originationDate":"2017-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.250675100000","-5.972456700000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 10:27:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Haverson-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2376","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/year-round-spatiotemporal-distribution-harbour-porpoises-within-around-maryland-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0176653","title":"Year-Round Spatiotemporal Distribution of Harbour Porpoises Within and Around the Maryland Wind Energy Area","description":"Offshore windfarms provide renewable energy, but activities during the construction phase can affect marine mammals. To understand how the construction of an offshore windfarm in the Maryland Wind Energy Area (WEA) off Maryland, USA, might impact harbour porpoises (Phocoena phocoena), it is essential to determine their poorly understood year-round distribution. Although habitat-based models can help predict the occurrence of species in areas with limited or no sampling, they require validation to determine the accuracy of the predictions. Incorporating more than 18 months of harbour porpoise detection data from passive acoustic monitoring, generalized auto-regressive moving average and generalized additive models were used to investigate harbour porpoise occurrence within and around the Maryland WEA in relation to temporal and environmental variables. Acoustic detection metrics were compared to habitat-based density estimates derived from aerial and boat-based sightings to validate the model predictions. Harbour porpoises occurred significantly more frequently during January to May, and foraged significantly more often in the evenings to early mornings at sites within and outside the Maryland WEA. Harbour porpoise occurrence peaked at sea surface temperatures of 5\u00b0C and chlorophyll a concentrations of 4.5 to 7.4 mg m-3. The acoustic detections were significantly correlated with the predicted densities, except at the most inshore site. This study provides insight into previously unknown fine-scale spatial and temporal patterns in distribution of harbour porpoises offshore of Maryland. The results can be used to help inform future monitoring and mitigate the impacts of windfarm construction and other human activities.","author":["Bailey, H.","Roberts, J.","Halpin, P.","Wingfield, J.","O\u0027Brien, M.","Lyubchich, V.","Rice, A."],"organization":["Cornell Laboratory of Ornithology","Duke University","University of Maryland"],"originationDate":"2017-05-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["38.397384500000","-74.946907300000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2025-10-28 06:01:46","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wingfield-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2377","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/decommissioning-seagen-tidal-turbine-strangford-lough-northern-ireland-environmental","sourceURL":"","title":"Decommissioning of the SeaGen Tidal Turbine in Strangford Lough, Northern Ireland: Environmental Statement","description":"The SeaGen tidal turbine was installed in Strangford Narrow, Strangford Lough, Northern Ireland by Marine Current Turbines Ltd (MCT) in 2008 in order to study tidal energy technology through the investigation of engineering, management systems, and environmental impacts.  The SeaGen device consists of two 16 m diameter rotors and generators supported on a crossbeam that is affixed to a central tubular structure with a control unit on top. The device is secured in position using a quadropod foundation fixed on the seabed using drilled pin piles approximately 1 m diameter, 14 m long, and drilled to a depth of approximately 9 m. Each of the quadropod legs is hollow and contains grout and concrete.  MCT was acquired by Atlantis Resources Limited (Atlantis) from Siemens on the 01 July 2015. SeaGen is owned and operated through Sea Generation Ltd. (SGL), a wholly owned subsidiary of MCT, which in turn is now owned by Atlantis. SeaGen is now considered to have served its R\u0026amp;D purpose and Atlantis has taken the decision to decommission the device.  An Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) was undertaken by Royal Haskoning DHV and completed in June 2005 with the production of an Environmental Statement (ES). The scope of the pre-construction EIA included construction, operation and decommissioning of the device. The decommissioning methods identified in 2005 ES were based upon assumptions concerning the likely methods that would be employed to decommission SeaGen.  An extensive Environmental Monitoring Plan (EMP) was established in order to fulfil the requirements of the conditional Food and Environmental Protection Act (FEPA) marine construction licence. Data collection for the EMP began in 2005 and continued until 2011 when the EMP ceased, SeaGen continued operating until Q4 2015. As part of the EMP, a focused Science Group and a wider Liaison Group were established in order to direct the environmental monitoring undertaken and as a way of reporting the findings to a wider group of stakeholders respectively. Overall, the findings of the EMP provided evidence that SeaGen operated with no likely significant impacts on the marine environment in Strangford Lough.  In 2011, a report produced for MCT by MOJO Maritime Ltd reviewed the potential methods to decommission the SeaGen tidal device. Since 2005, when the pre-construction EIA was undertaken, the range of decommissioning methods has expanded beyond that which was originally considered. As such, further EIA was required in order to cover contemporary decommissioning methodologies not assessed in the pre-construction EIA.  MarineSpace Ltd has been commissioned to prepare an additional EIA to include the decommissioning methods not covered previously. Data used to inform the decommissioning EIA is based upon the evidence gathered during the EMP since the pre-construction EIA.  A scoping study was undertaken by MarineSpace Ltd to identify the key concerns and to consider the revised decommissioning methods. The SeaGen Decommissioning Scoping Report underwent a formal consultation in June 2016 to inform the potential impact pathways that are assessed in the EIA and presented in this Decommissioning ES.  A summary assessment of the residual impacts after appropriate mitigation has been put in place is given below:    Loss or damage of benthic habitat via use of jack-up or moored barges is assessed to be negligible;  Loss of designated seabed habitat (Strangford Lough Special Area of Conservation (SAC) and Marine Conservation Zone (MCZ)) via use of jack-up or moored barges is assessed to be negligible;  Noise and vibration disturbance to fish resources via use of diamond wire cutting tool (DWCT) or abrasive water jet (AWJ) is assessed to be negligible;  Noise and vibration disturbance to basking shark via use of jack-up or moored barge or DWCT or AWJ is assessed to be negligible;  Underwater noise disturbance to marine mammals via use of Brocotorch, DWCT, AWJ and vessel noise is assessed to be negligible;  Collision between marine mammals and vessels involved in the decommissioning work is assessed to be negligible; and  Obstruction to movement of fishing vessels through use of jack-up or moored barges is assessed to be negligible.   A summary of mitigation measures proposed to minimise the risk of impacts is given below:    Decommissioning will not take place during common seal pupping season (May to August);  Undertake decommissioning operations between January and March when abundance of marine mammals is low in order to reduce risk of potential noise disturbance to marine mammals;  Undertake decommissioning operations between January and March when abundance of marine mammals is low in order to reduce the risk of collision with decommissioning equipment. Maximum vessel speeds to be implemented;  Reduce potential spread of non-native species through decommissioning activities via DWCT or AWJ; and  Undertake decommissioning operations between January and March when there is no larval recruitment of Didemnum vexillum in order to reduce the potential risk of introduction of non-native species. No ballast water will be exchanged or discharged within 3 nm of the entrance of the Narrows. No colonies of Didemnum vexillum have been observed on the SeaGen structure throughout operation and in preparation of the site for decommissioning.   Overall, the potential environmental impacts as a result of decommissioning of the SeaGen device have been assessed as follows:    Short-term and temporary impacts upon benthic communities in Strangford Lough via loss or damage of seabed habitat through use of moored barge or jack-up vessel;  No adverse effect on site integrity of Strangford Lough SAC and less than 0.01% will experience short-term temporary impacts via loss or damage of designated seabed habitat through use of moored barge or jack-up vessel;  Short-term and temporary impacts upon fish, including basking shark, pinnipeds and cetaceans, due to noise disturbance through use of DWCT or AWJ;  Impacts on all other receptors are considered to be negligible;  No cumulative impacts with commercial fisheries, shipping and the Minesto tidal device; and  Decommissioning of the SeaGen device is not predicted to result in any medium to longterm environmental impacts.   It is the conclusion of the EIA that following mitigation there will be no major adverse residual impacts either from the project alone or cumulatively with other projects on any environmental receptors within Strangford Lough.  Information has also been provided within the ES to facilitate HRA for the possible impacts of the project upon the nature conservation features of Strangford Lough. It is predicted that the project alone, and in combination with other plans and projects, will result in no likely significant effect on the European sites of Strangford Lough.","author":["MarineSpace Ltd"],"organization":["MarineSpace Ltd"],"originationDate":"2016-09-12","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.364119000000","-5.543969000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SeaGen-Decommissioning-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2378","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/strangford-lough-marine-current-turbine-environmental-statement","sourceURL":"","title":"Strangford Lough Marine Current Turbine: Environmental Statement","description":"Marine Current Turbines Ltd have constructed the first tidal power turbine in the UK off the coast of Devon, which has been in operation for over two years. A second, larger turbine to be known as \u201cSeagen\u201d is proposed in order to further develop this technology through investigation of its engineering, management systems and environmental impacts. Of several potential locations around the UK, the Strangford Lough Narrows has been chosen due to its wave-sheltered environment, its fast clearly defined directional tidal flows within a small sea level range, and its proximity to excellent services and local technical support. Experience off the Devon coast has shown that it is vital to have easy, frequent and consistent access to the test location, but this has been severely restricted due to weather exposure. This location will provide the opportunity to study the technology more frequently than exposed sites such as Devon, thereby ensuring full knowledge of both technical and environmental impacts is gained before commercial scale ventures are proposed in more remote offshore locations.  Seagen will be a twin turbine system with a mobile cross arm on a single supporting pile 3m in diameter and 9m above the average sea level as illustrated below. The twin rotors have an 8m radius and will begin to generate electricity once the tide runs faster than 1m\/s. At maximum speed the tips move at around 12m\/s, approximately 1\/3 of the average wind turbine speed.  The Seaflow design allows for the cross beam and turbines to be raised above the water for maintenance and inspection. The system will be installed from a barge by drilling a hole in the sea bed and grouting the pile in place, and a location map is provided below. The electricity connection will be made to the national grid by drilling a small hole horizontally from the western side of the Narrows under the shore and sea bed, carefully directing the drill to emerge from the Lough bed within 15m of the turbine base. The system will be removed in approximately 2-5 years once it has successfully addressed all relevant technical and environmental performance requirements, leaving a 3m diameter depression slightly below sea bed level which will naturally fill with cobbles and boulders as a result of tidal flows.  This Environmental Statement has been prepared in support of Marine Current Turbine Ltd\u2019s application to construct Seagen under the Food and Environment Protection Act (1985) in accordance with recognised environmental impact assessment procedures. The assessment involves the application of a standardised process to identify the likely impacts from all relevant issues identified through an initial scoping process and wider consultation with regulators, non-governmental organisations and other interested parties. As the proposed location falls within an area protected under domestic and European law, information considered relevant to a further \u2018appropriate assessment\u2019 process has been collected or collated from other sources in order to assist the Environment and Heritage Service as \u2018Competent Authority\u2019 in determining if the project is unlikely to damage the protected features.  Strangford Lough hosts internationally important subtidal and intertidal rock, sand and mud habitats and horse mussel beds. The Lough also supports internationally significant wintering waders, breeding terns and important populations of common seals. For these reasons all or parts of the Lough have been recognised as a Special Area of Conservation, Special Protection Area, Ramsar site, Area of Special Scientific Interest, National Nature Reserve and a Marine Nature Reserve. Extensive consultation with regulators, non-governmental organisations and the public has been carried out in order to ensure all relevant issues are considered. This process identified general local support for the project and support from regulators and non-governmental organisations for the need to develop this sustainable technology. It also highlighted concerns that the installation and operation of Seagen should not harm or deter seals, cetaceans or basking shark using the area for feeding or access to breeding areas in the main body of the Lough, nor should it have a detrimental effect on the internationally important breeding tern populations or the subtidal wildlife habitats in Strangford Lough. This was noted as particularly important in relation to recent discoveries on the extent of damage and loss of horse mussel beds.  Modelling of water movement in the Lough was carried out in order to assess the potential impacts of the turbine construction, operation and removal on water speed, the distribution of fine particles and the removal of energy as a result of Seagen. This information was used to predict that it is extremely unlikely that there will be any significant impact on marine life present in the Lough, except out to approximately 4m from the base of the turbine. The overall loss of reef and its marine communities, which will recover once Seagen is removed, is a tiny fraction of the habitat in the context of Strangford Lough and will not add to the justification for its present \u2018unfavourable conservation status\u2019 under the EC Habitats Directive.  The potential impacts of operating the turbine on seals have been subject to investigations of historic movement and population observations, extensive discussion with seals experts and academics, surveys and assessment of underwater noise and extensive consultation with experts. Despite this, due to the novel nature of the Seagen design and the lack of knowledge about seal behaviour, it is concluded that enough uncertainty remains over the possible behavioural reaction of seals to Seagen that a definitive assessment cannot be made. The same situation applies to possible impacts on cetaceans and basking shark. In order to ensure that there is an acceptably low risk of damaging these species or affecting their behaviour in ways that may damage their populations in the Lough (in particular common seals protected as part of the Special Area of Conservation) a comprehensive programme of monitoring is proposed alongside monitoring of birds and habitats in the Narrows. This is combined with a formal steering group likely to oversee the programme and a commitment from the developers to work in partnership with regulators and to modify or cease operations if the programme highlights problems or if the regulators and steering group decide it is necessary. This adaptive management approach is in line with recent developments on use of the \u2018precautionary principle\u2019 in order to facilitate sustainable development within protected areas such as Strangford Lough. Impacts on other ecological features in the area are considered highly unlikely due to the scale and duration of the commissioning process.  The effect of the project on navigation is likely to be beneficial due to the appropriate marking and lighting of the structure above sea level. The risk to vessels known to use the Narrows posed by operating rotors is generally negligible as the tips will be at least 3m below the lowest astronomical tide level. An area around the turbine may also be noted on charts as an \u2018Area To Be Avoided\u2019, providing further security.  Seagen is considered likely to be slightly beneficial to local businesses through increased visitors and workers to the area, and it is considered unlikely to have any effect on commercial fishing in the Narrows due to the current ban on activities that would normally fish the proposed location and the location of the turbine within the deep water of the middle of the Narrows. No impacts on archaeology are anticipated at the proposed turbine location.  It is likely that Seagen will affect the landscape and cause some visual disturbance at all stages of the project as it will be visually obvious from Portaferry and will affect the relatively open seascapes seen from the ferry crossing. The level of this impact is mainly due to the requirement for specific colours and lighting on the superstructure for navigation as there are several similar beacons at various locations through the Narrows. The most significant visual impacts will be intermittent during maintenance periods when the cross arm is raised above sea level.  The project will have a negligible impact on road traffic in the area as most materials will be brought to the site by sea. The main sources of noise above water level will be power generators on board the jack-up barge and in the directional drilling compound during construction. Neither of these are expected to be significant as the noise ratings indicate levels will be low within very short distances from the source.  Impacts on air quality in the area are expected to be negligible in the short and medium term, but it must be recognised that this clean and sustainable energy source represents an opportunity to facilitate long term improvements in air quality and will contribute to the achievement of national and international targets to reduce emissions of gases attributed to accelerating climate change.  In conclusion, Seagen is a critical stage in the development of renewable tidal energy in the UK. Strangford Lough represents an ideal location for this temporary installation the environmental impacts have been assessed and are generally considered unlikely to be significant. Due to the novel nature of the proposed development and the lack of definitive information some uncertainty remains as to its likely impacts on marine mammals and basking shark.","author":["Davison, A.","Mallows, T."],"organization":["Royal Haskoning","Marine Current Turbines (MCT)"],"originationDate":"2005-06-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.364119000000","-5.543969000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 11:01:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Strangford_Lough_EIA_final.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2379","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/navitus-bay-wind-park-environmental-statement-non-technical-summary","sourceURL":"","title":"Navitus Bay Wind Park Environmental Statement: Non-Technical Summary","description":"The proposed Navitus Bay Wind Park (the Project) is an offshore wind farm of up to 970 megawatts (MW) of generating capacity located west of the Isle of Wight in the English Channel.  This Non-Technical Summary (NTS) document summarises the Environmental Statement (ES) (Document 6.1) for the Project. The ES provides information on likely significant impacts of the construction, operation, maintenance and decommissioning phases of the Project on existing physical, biological and human environments and details mitigation measures proposed.  Although this NTS provides a full summary, for more detailed information readers should refer to the full ES which is divided into four main volumes with supporting appendices (Document 6.2).","author":["Navitus Bay Development"],"organization":["Navitus Bay Development"],"originationDate":"2014-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.575833000000","-1.713056000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Navitus-Bay-Wind-ES.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2380","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/navitus-bay-wind-park-technical-appendix-21-emf-calculations-report","sourceURL":"","title":"Navitus Bay Wind Park Technical Appendix 2.1 - EMF Calculations Report","description":"This report provides a briefing paper providing details of the range of electromagnetic field (EMF) emissions that could be expected from the inter array and export cables for Navitus Bay Wind Park to inform relevant chapters of the environmental impact assessment.  The EMF calculations were undertaken in accordance with requirement document 31211 120808 CTR EMF and with reference to the descriptions contained in document Navitus Bay OFFSHORE PDS.  The calculations were undertaken by T\u00dcV S\u00dcD Product Service for PMSS under PO 1229 on behalf of Navitus Bay Development Limited under PO 3-1648.  Electromagnetic fields from submarine power cables may be significant for electrically and magnetically sensitive marine organisms if t hey can detect them. This report is only concerned with a calculation of the magnitude of the electromagnetic fields.","author":["Dorey, P."],"organization":["T\u00dcV S\u00dcD"],"originationDate":"2014-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.575833000000","-1.713056000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Navitus-Bay-Wind-Appendix-2.1.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2381","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/electromagnetic-fields-emitted-high-voltage-alternating-current-offshore-wind-power","sourceURL":"","title":"Electromagnetic Fields Emitted by High Voltage Alternating Current Offshore Wind Power Cables and Interactions with Marine Organisms","description":"The demand for renewable energy has lead to a large scale deployment of offshore wind farms, particularly in Northern Europe. The extent of the electrical cabling in the marine environment is unprecedented, and this has lead to questions about whether there are any interactions between the electricity produced and the surrounding environment. A summary of the electric and magnetic fields generated by such cables is presented based on a research project using an analytical method to set up the problem which was then quantified numerically using the finite-element method. An industry standard 132 kV XLPE three-phase submarine cable buried at a depth of 1 m was modelled as an example. The results showed that a cable with perfect shielding does not generate an electric field (E field) outside the cable directly. However, a time-varying magnetic field (H field) is generated by the alternating current in the cable, which in turn generates an induced E field in the local environment. The results are considered in terms of environmental impact assessment relevant for the power delivery community.","author":["Gill, A.","Huang, Y.","Gloyne-Philips, I.","Spencer, J."],"organization":["Collaborative Offshore Wind Research into the Environment (COWRIE)"],"originationDate":"2012-06-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gill-2012.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2382","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/meygen-tidal-energy-project-phase-1-project-environmental-monitoring-programme","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/Resource\/0050\/00509795.pdf","title":"MeyGen Tidal Energy Project Phase 1 Project Environmental Monitoring Programme","description":"This Project Environmental Monitoring Programme (PEMP) has been prepared by MeyGen Limited (MeyGen) to set out the proposed method for discharging the Condition 12 of the Section 36 Consent for the Development.  The document details the monitoring methods proposed for the commissioning and operational phases of the Development and how communication will be maintained between MeyGen, the Advisory Group (established in accordance with Condition 13) and the Regulators.  The PEMP will be submitted to the Scottish Ministers for their written approval, in consultation with Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH), the Advisory Group and any other ecological, or such other advisors as required at the discretion of the Scottish Ministers.  The data collected during monitoring will be used by the Advisory Group to inform decisions on each subsequent stage of the Development. Empirically measured close range encounter or passage rates may be substituted for the density inputs into collision risk models, and any measured avoidance or evasion may be translated into avoidance rates. The combination of these two factors will allow a more realistic calculation of collision risk for subsequent stages.","author":["Donovan, C.","Rollings, E.","Eastham, C."],"organization":["MeyGen"],"originationDate":"2016-10-21","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.656500000000","-3.130000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-12 03:50:27","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/MeyGen-Environmental-Monitoring-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2383","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/learning-early-commercial-tidal-energy-projects-puget-sound-washington-pentland-firth","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digital.lib.washington.edu\/researchworks\/bitstream\/handle\/1773\/38169\/McMillin_washington_0250O_16575.pdf","title":"Learning from Early Commercial Tidal Energy Projects in the Puget Sound, Washington and the Pentland Firth, Scotland","description":"Using a textual analysis to interview data approach, this study explores two of the first multiple-device tidal energy projects to identify the key learning outcomes gained by stakeholders. The cases chosen are the Snohomish County Public Utility District\u2019s Admiralty Inlet pilot project in Puget Sound, Washington, United States, and MeyGen Ltd.\u2019s Phase 1A project in Pentland Firth, Scotland, United Kingdom. With a focus on stakeholder learning, the research draws upon scholarly literature on innovation systems and technical innovations systems. This qualitative study uses in-depth, semi-structured, elite interviews of key informants as the primary method of data collection. The study analyzed the interview data from twenty - three stakeholder interviews and utilized MaxQDA 12 software as a platform to analyze the interviews. Learning from tidal energy projects is examined from technical, economic, environmental, policy, and social perspectives. By so doing, this research seeks to understand the interdisciplinary lessons stakeholders learned about tidal energy. The lessons learned from these case studies suggest that existing risks and uncertainties can preclude the deployment needed for the technical validation. Technical learning focused on the challenge of developing robust instrumentation for monitoring in tidal flow conditions. Economic learning focused on the need for government funding for environmental research, the potential expense of legal challenges, and the socio-economic impact of the project for local businesses. The projects served as a catalyst for examining the environmental impacts of tidal energy development. Species behavior and interaction with devices remains an area of research to address. Policy learning related to risk tolerance of regulators and the potential legal barriers faced by tidal energy. Socially, initiating the projects allowed the developers to recognize the concerns of relevant stakeholders. Spatial conflicts, exclusion, and access were major concerns of opposing stakeholders. Learning about an interdisciplinary range of issues is key to the future success of the tidal energy sector.","author":["McMillin, N."],"organization":["University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2384","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/use-high-resolution-sonar-near-turbine-fish-observations-didson-wesea-2007-002","sourceURL":"https:\/\/library.wur.nl\/WebQuery\/wurpubs\/fulltext\/155434","title":"Use of High Resolution Sonar for Near-Turbine Fish Observations (DIDSON) - WeSea 2007-002","description":"In this study we investigate small scale distributi on of pelagic fish within a windfarm by means of a high resolution sonar (DIDSON, Dual frequency IDentification SONar; Soundmetrics). In addition we assess the bias of small scale variations induced by the effects of wind turbines (monopiles) on distribution of the pelagic fish community in the hydro acoustic surveys carried out on the OWEZ Near Shore Wind farm (NSW).\n\nA deployment for the use of a DIDSON sonar is presented as well as a survey technique from onboard a RIB (inflatable boat). The qualitative results from this study clearly show that the fish concentrations a round the monopiles are much higher in the first 15 \u2013 20 meters. Overall fish density was on average a factor 37 higher above the scour bed around the monopiles than in the open water habitats in between monopiles.\n\nWe calculate the possible bias in a large scale hydro acoustic survey for densities around the monopiles. Avoidance does not lead to a significant bias. A density higher than 100 times the density in the open water leads to an underestimation of 8%. For the OWEZ windfarm, the factor 37 found from the DIDSON data would lead to an underestimation of 3% of the fish density.\n\nMore insight in the spatial and temporal dynamics of occurrence of pelagic fish is needed for a complete understanding of the speciesspecific response of pelagic fish to wind farms and monopiles. For this, hydro acoustic surveys and DIDSON observations are comple mentary, focusing on different spatial and temporal scales ranging from meters to kilometres, and from tidal, daily to seasonal. Although DIDSON has more potential for species identification than other acoustic methods, additional techniques are needed to determine species composition at the monopiles at the time of the large scale acoustic surveys.","author":["van Keeken, O.","Winter, E.","Couperus, B.","van Kooten, T.","Burggraaf, S."],"organization":["IMARES - Wageningen UR"],"originationDate":"2010-11-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["52.600000000000","-4.416700000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish","Habitat Change","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:06","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Couperus-et-al-2010.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2386","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/examining-social-acceptance-wind-energy-practical-guidelines-onshore-wind-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032115009028","title":"Examining the Social Acceptance of Wind Energy: Practical Guidelines for Onshore Wind Project Development in France","description":"This study investigates methods for increasing the local social acceptance of onshore wind projects in France. It is based on input from semi-structured research interviews and insight from a French wind energy company. That company had noted that a lack of local social acceptance of wind projects increased the risk of failures, cost escalation, and project delays. In this study, we first summarize recent scholarship concerning local social opposition and acceptance of wind energy through a selected literature review and case studies of wind projects throughout Europe. We then use this data to create guidelines on how to increase the likelihood of social acceptance for onshore wind project development in France, and to inform current debates in the energy studies literature over the acceptance of wind energy and energy transitions.","author":["Sovacool, B.","Enevoldsen, P."],"organization":["Aarhus University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["46.249817000000","2.138507000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2387","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/greater-sage-grouse-habitat-selection-survival-wind-energy-infrastructure","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/jwmg.21231\/abstract","title":"Greater Sage-Grouse Habitat Selection, Survival, and Wind Energy Infrastructure","description":"Increasing concern for environmental sustainability, the demand for domestic energy, and an impetus on reducing dependence on fossil fuels have led to substantial investment in renewable energies including wind energy over the last 2 decades. Increases in wind energy development are especially noticeable in prairie habitats with high wind capacity. This has raised concerns over effects on grouse species including greater sage-grouse (Centrocercus urophasianus). We monitored 346 female greater sage-grouse via telemetry from 2009 to 2014 in southeastern Wyoming, within a control area and an area influenced by a wind energy development to estimate the potential effects of wind energy infrastructure on greater sage-grouse habitat selection and demography. We developed resource selection functions by comparing habitats used to habitats available relative to the wind energy development during the nesting, brood-rearing, and summer periods. In addition, we used survival models to estimate the variability in nest, brood, and female survival relative to the wind energy development. The relative probability of greater sage-grouse selecting brood-rearing and summer habitats decreased as percentage of surface disturbance associated with the facility infrastructure increased. We did not, however, detect a negative effect of the wind energy facility on nest site selection or on nest, brood-rearing, or female survival during the study. Future wind energy developments should consider the potential effects of wind energy development on sage-grouse habitat selection patterns and survival parameters \u22641.20\u2009km from any occupied sage-grouse nesting, brood-rearing, or summer habitats.","author":["Johnson, G.","LeBeau, C.","Holloran, M.","Beck, J.","Nielson, R.","Kauffman, M.","Rodemaker, E.","McDonald, T."],"organization":["Western Ecosystems Technology Inc (WEST)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-07","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Ground-Nesting Birds","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2388","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/ocean-energy-systems-annual-report-2016","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ocean-energy-systems.org\/publications\/oes-annual-reports\/","title":"Ocean Energy Systems Annual Report 2016","description":"The IEA Technology Collaboration Programme on Ocean Energy Systems is one of the collaborative R\u0026amp;D Programmes established within the IEA, and since its establishment in 2001, the OES participants have been conducting a variety of joint projects. During 2016, the Executive evaluated the achievements of its present 5-year term that will end up in February 2017 and prepared a new Strategic Plan for its 4th 5-year mandate (2017 \u2013 2022).  The End of Term Report and new Strategic Plan were submitted to the IEA and presented by the Chairman in the Renewable Energy Working Party meeting in Beijing, China (17 -18 October 2016).  2016 was marked by the entry of three new members: India, France and the European Commission. On the other hand, Australia, after being inactive for 2 years, withdrew the OES, but with a strong hope to soon re-join and to make efforts to identify the appropriate entity to represent the Government in the OES.  At the end of 2016, OES has 25 members, which provide a broad international base of information, sharing experience and knowledge and further a diversified representation of interests: members are from governmental departments, utilities, universities and research organizations, energy agencies and industry associations. This is one of the benefits of joining OES: participants gain an international perspective on ocean energy issues, opportunities and present challenges.  The OES international co-operation facilitates:    Securing access to advanced R\u0026amp;D teams in the participating countries  Developing a harmonized set of measures and testing protocols for the testing of prototypes  Reducing national costs by collaborating internationally  Creating valuable international contacts between government, industry and science  Information sharing and networking   This Executive Summary provides a brief summary of the 2016 OES Annual Report. It synthesizes the main achievements in the OES collaborative activities and presents relevant policies and projects by each OES member country. As in previous years, this Annual Report includes a contribution by acknowledged experts from testing centres. Representatives from 5 open sea test centres (EMEC\/UK, FORCE\/Canada, Oregon\/USA, Nagasaki Marine Industry Cluster Promotion Association\/Japan and BIMEP\/ Spain) have been invited to respond to a few questions related with the role of these test centres, difficulties and opportunities.","author":["Ocean Energy Systems (OES)"],"organization":["Ocean Energy Systems (OES)"],"originationDate":"2016-12-31","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OES-Annual-Report-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2389","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/golden-eagle-fatalities-continental-scale-consequences-local-wind-energy-generation","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1111\/cobi.12836\/full","title":"Golden Eagle Fatalities and the Continental-Scale Consequences of Local Wind-Energy Generation","description":"Renewable energy production is expanding rapidly despite mostly unknown environmental effects on wildlife and habitats. We used genetic and stable isotope data collected from Golden Eagles (Aquila chrysaetos) killed at the Altamont Pass Wind Resource Area (APWRA) in California in demographic models to test hypotheses about the geographic extent and demographic consequences of fatalities caused by renewable energy facilities. Geospatial analyses of \u03b42H values obtained from feathers showed that \u226525% of these APWRA-killed eagles were recent immigrants to the population, most from long distances away (\u003E100 km). Data from nuclear genes indicated this subset of immigrant eagles was genetically similar to birds identified as locals from the \u03b42H data. Demographic models implied that in the face of this mortality, the apparent stability of the local Golden Eagle population was maintained by continental-scale immigration. These analyses demonstrate that ecosystem management decisions concerning the effects of local-scale renewable energy can have continental-scale consequences.","author":["Duerr, A.","Katzner, T.","Miller, T.","Culver, R.","Braham, M.","Nelson, D.","Fitzpatrick, M.","Doyle, J.","Fernandez, N.","Bloom, P.","Braswell, L.","DeWoody, J."],"organization":["NextEra Energy Resources","Purdue University","University of Maryland","US Geological Survey (USGS)","West Virginia University","Western Foundation of Vertebrate Zoology"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["37.745766100000","-121.660472600000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2390","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-scenarios-simulation-german-power-system-until-2050-effect-social","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-44711-7_14","title":"Wind Energy Scenarios for the Simulation of the German Power System Until 2050: The Effect of Social and Ecological Factors","description":"Models of future energy systems and the development of underlying energy scenarios contribute to an answer on the question how a transformation of the energy system can be implemented. Although energy system modelling has a wide influence, the field lacks the consideration of local ecological and societal concerns, such as acceptance issues. In this paper, a methodology is developed to integrate social and ecological aspects concerning wind energy into the distribution of future wind energy capacities in Germany. Based on the calculated potential siting area (white area), an algorithm was developed to site different types of wind energy plants in the available area. Two wind expansion scenarios have been developed: one distributing future wind capacities according to technical and economic conditions (economic scenario), and the other based on the regional burden level resulting from wind energy plants (balanced scenario). The development of the burden level as a socio-ecological factor enabled the siting of wind turbines according to an equal burden level in all German districts (Landkreise). It was shown, that this equal distribution led to a shift of capacities from the north-west to the south-east compared to the economic approach.","author":["Christ, M.","Soethe, M.","Degel, M.","Wingenbach, C."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2391","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/tafila-region-wind-power-projects-cumulative-effects-assessment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/openknowledge.worldbank.org\/handle\/10986\/26322","title":"Tafila Region Wind Power Projects: Cumulative Effects Assessment","description":"In the Middle East, wind power is a rapidly growing renewable energy source because of its minimal carbon emissions and increasing cost competitiveness. In an initiative to reduce Jordan\u2019s high energy import costs, estimated at 13.5 percent of GDP, the government has set a target of obtaining 1,800 megawatts\u201410 percent of the country\u2019s energy supply\u2014from renewable sources by 2020.  Although the renewable energy sector, including wind energy, is considered \u201cgreen,\u201d adverse environmental and social (E\u0026amp;S) impacts of renewables also need to be considered and managed. Jordan sits on the Rift Valley\/Red Sea flyway, the second largest flyway for migratory birds in the world. It also has a suite of protected areas of national and international significance. Jordan\u2019s largest nature reserve\u2014the Dana Biosphere Reserve (BR) and the surrounding Dana Important Bird and Biodiversity Area (IBA)\u2014is one of the few large areas in Jordan designated as important for its flora and fauna.  The IFC (International Finance Corporation) commissioned the Tafila Region Wind Power Project (TRWPP) Cumulative Effects Assessment (CEA) to help promote more sustainable wind energy investments in Jordan. Focusing on biodiversity, this innovative initiative is the first of its kind in the Eastern Europe, Middle East, and North Africa region. The overall management and technical direction of the CEA was undertaken by IFC, supported by a team of multidisciplinary international and Jordanian experts and advisors who were contracted to develop the CEA. The work was made possible through a partnership with developers, conservation bodies, finance institutions and government, along with the knowledge of in-country experts facilitated through an Advisory Committee and an Expert Review Panel (ERP).  Five wind farm developers agreed to share and pool their pre-construction environmental survey data, representing a remarkable resource. This collaborative approach, a key component of the CEA process, allows a consistent method for identifying and managing E\u0026amp;S risks when developers are working in close proximity. For energy companies operating in middle-income and developing countries, the CEA approach is especially pertinent in that it is risk-based and relies on survey data but can also be applied where regional data on biodiversity are limited. This is particularly relevant when assessing the effects of external stressors on biodiversity, as data on these effects are almost always either limited or nonexistent in the countries where IFC and other multilateral development banks operate.  The CEA study area, located approximately 200 km south of Amman, principally within the Tafila Governorate, covers the Dana BR\/IBA and the Wind Power Project (WPP) sites. The temporal scope of the assessment was defined as three years from the start of operations at each WPP, following which an evaluation would be conducted to determine an appropriate ongoing level of biodiversity monitoring and adaptive management.","author":["International Finance Corporation (IFC)"],"organization":["International Finance Corporation (IFC)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["30.807261500000","35.557829100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/IFC-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2392","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-economic-potential-offshore-wind-united-states-2015-2030","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrel.gov\/docs\/fy17osti\/67675.pdf","title":"An Assessment of the Economic Potential of Offshore Wind in the United States from 2015 to 2030","description":"This study describes an assessment of the site-specific variation of levelized cost of energy (LCOE) and levelized avoided cost of energy (LACE) to understand the economic potential of fixed-bottom and floating offshore wind technologies in major U.S. coastal areas between 2015 and 2030. The detailed methodology, assumptions, and context of this study are documented in A Spatial-Economic Cost Reduction Pathway Analysis for U.S. Offshore Wind Energy Development from 2015\u20132030 (Beiter et al. 2016). This earlier report focused on the development of a geospatial cost model of the offshore wind technical resource area in the United States and the relationship of geospatial and temporal parameters on the cost of energy up to 2030. The present study builds on the Beiter et al. (2016) analysis to document in detail the variation in economic potential across more than 7,000 U.S. coastal locations by comparing site-specific LCOE and LACE. In particular, this study offers insights into the available U.S. offshore wind resource by region at different levels of LCOE and an assessment of the present and future economic potential of that resource capacity out to 2030. The Crown Estate (2012) cost reductions assumed for this study should be considered in context of recent cost declines indicated by European offshore wind winning tenders. However, determining if and to what extent these recent European cost reductions will continue and how they can be translate d to a U.S. market context is beyond the scope of this study.  LCOE is the total cost of generating a unit of electricity and is commonly expressed in dollars per megawatt-hour (MWh) over the expected lifetime of the offshore wind electricity-generating plant. It varies by location because of spatial differences in energy production (e.g., average wind speed variations) and capital expenditures (e.g., varying sea states, distance from shore, water depth, soil and substructure suitability, and availability of critical infrastructure). However, LCOE alone is not sufficient to assess economic viability because it does not capture the electric system value that can be attributed to a generation source. Therefore, this analysis draws on a \u201csimplified\u201d version of LACE as a metric to capture the system value of a generation technology. LACE is a metric to approximate the electric system value of a generation technology over its expected lifetime and commonly expressed in dollars per-MWh as well. LACE varies by location because of differences in the system value of new electricity, which is determined by a range of factors, including the cost of competing generation technologies, the resource mix, demand patterns, and transmission constraints. The difference between LCOE and LACE at a given location (denoted in this report by \u201c net value\u201d) can help inform an initial understanding of the economic potential of a new offshore wind project at a high geospatial resolution. For this analysis, policy-related factors that may influence LACE or LCOE (and hence, the \u201cnet value\u201d of a renewable energy project) were not considered explicitly. For instance, renewable energy support mechanisms (e. g., the production tax credit, Renewable Portfolio Standards), energy sector and environmental regulations (e.g., carbon pricing), or benefits from portfolio diversification (Energy Information Administration [EIA] 2015) may increase the \u201cnet value\u201d and economic potential. Conversely, regulatory uncertainty and market barriers (see e.g., DOE 2016) may decrease the \u201cnet value\u201d and economic potential.  A series of data sources and reports were used to derive the assumptions and data for the underlying analysis documented in Beiter et al. (2016), including market reports (e.g., Mon\u00e9 et al. [2015]; Smith, Stehly, and Musial [2015]), U.S. electricity cost benchmark reports (e.g., EIA Annual Energy Outlook [AEO] 2014), offshore wind cost-reduction pathway studies (e.g., Beiter et al. (2016) ; Valpy et al. [2014]; Catapult [2015]; E.C. Harris [2012]; The Crown Estate [2012]; The Crown Estate [2015]), geospatial data layers, and expert elicitation.  Estimates of offshore wind costs were calculated for three focus years corresponding to commercial operation dates (CODs) of 2015, 2022, and 2027. In 2015, a baseline turbine rating of 3.4 megawatts (MW) was assumed as it reflect s the average turbine size of installed offshore wind power projects globally in 2014 (Smith, Stehly and Musial 2015). Informed by recent industry trends, turbine ratings of 6 MW and 10 MW were assumed as representative technologies for years 2022 and 2027, respectively. Corresponding to this assumed growth trajectory in turbine size, a set of cos t reductions and associated technology improvements were projected for 2015, 2022, and 2027 based on a recent assessment conducted by The Crown Estate, BVG Associates, and KIC InnoEnergy (The Crown Estate 2012; Valpy et al. 2014). Various assumptions were made to account for the nascent stage of the U.S. offshore wind industry and to project cost and technology parameters into the future. The first U.S. offshore wind power project came online for commercial operation in late 2016. As in this project, U.S. developers are expected to leverage European offshore wind technology, industry experience, and industrial capacity in early projects. Beiter et al. (2016) defined a scenario assuming that the U.S. offshore wind industry can leverage the recent European offshore wind technology and industry experience while addressing important physical, regulatory, and economic differences influencing U.S. projects. The cost-reduction pathway under this scenario applies projected cost reductions developed for European projects within the time frame from 2015 to 2027 and assumes sufficient domestic deployment and supply chain maturity to support these cost reductions in the United States during the analysis period.  Based on the methodology and assumptions from Beiter et al. (2016), this analysis provides detailed outputs of the following:    Maps showing spatial distribution of LCOE, LACE, and net value for five U.S. coastal regions including the Atlantic Coast, Pacific Coast, Gulf of Mexico, Great Lakes, and Hawaii for each of the focus years (2015, 2022, and 2027)  National and regional supply curves of offshore capacity ranked by LCOE for fixed-bottom and floating technology types  Estimated LCOE plotted by different water depths and distance from shore for fixed-bottom and floating offshore wind technology.   The results presented in this study are intended to inform a broad set of stakeholders to enable an initial assessment of offshore wind as part of energy development and energy portfolio planning. It provides information that federal and state agencies and planning commissions may use to inform initial strategic decisions about offshore wind development in the United States. Although this analysis is the first of its kind to provide a comprehensive assessment of the economic potential for offshore wind at a high geospatial resolution across major U.S. coastal regions, more detailed site-specific assessments are needed to inform actual offshore wind project planning.  This study finds that estimated reductions in LCOE over the next decade coincide with relatively high levels of LACE in some U.S. regions. By 2027, a considerable amount of economic potential was estimated for the Northeast and the e a stern shore of Virginia.  It is also observed that the supply and net value curves were relatively flat, indicating that even a small change in LCOE or LACE has the potential to trigger significant changes in the amount of economic potential calculated. This effect resulting from relatively flat supply curves would be most relevant in regions that have a net value close to zero, such as the Northeast, mid-Atlantic, Great Lakes, and Gulf Coast in 2027, or in regions where policies are in place to incentivize renewable energy, such as California. The relatively high degree of sensitivity to changes in LCOE and LACE also indicates a moderate amount of uncertainty in the quantity of actual resource found to have \u201ceconomic potential.\u201d As a result, the conclusions of this assessment should be re-evaluate d as market conditions or costs change.  Some general observations include:    Offshore wind sites with economic potential are located predominantly in the Northeast and e astern shore of Virginia  Across all regions, the number of sites with a positive net value (or a value close to a positive net value) increase over the time period considered  State policies have driven offshore wind development recently (e.g., in New York and Massachusetts); these policies may play a key role when assessing the economic viability of offshore wind but are not considered in this analysis  Further technology improvements are needed to achieve the cost reductions of this assessment  Some regions will likely require unique technology solutions (e.g., to address low wind speeds in the Gulf, icing in Great Lakes, and deep-water floating solutions in the Pacific and Hawaii)  The value of offshore wind to the electric grid system under some high-penetration renewable energy scenarios may not be fully represented by net value as calculated in this study.   A number of limitations and opportunities for further work are indicated throughout this report. The results from the Beiter et al. (2016) assessment utilized in this study were produced with innovative models and assumptions, which may be refined as new tools and validation data become available. For this national-scale assessment, a number of simplifications and uncertainties exist that may affect the accuracy from reported results at any individual location. These simplifications and uncertainties range from the development of first-order tools that do not capture the entire set of parameters taken into account for a detailed site assessment, the suitability and availability of technology during the time period considered, and general uncertainty related to the formation of a domestic supply chain and macroeconomic factors. Limitations and corresponding caveats are discussed in Beiter et al. (2016). Some of the most important caveats from Beiter et al. (2016) include the following:    To achieve the modeled cost reductions in the United States, a key assumption is that there will be continued investments in technology innovation, developments, and the market visibility of a robust domestic supply chain commensurate with the established European offshore wind supply chains during the analysis period from 2015 to 2027 and sustained domestic offshore wind development (U.S. Department of Energy [DOE] 2015; Navigant 2012; European Commission 2016).  The Crown Estate (2012) cost reductions assumed for this study should be considered in context of recent cost declines indicated by European offshore wind winning tenders. However, determining to what extent these recent reductions in European winning bids will continue in the future and how they translate to a U.S. context is beyond the scope of this study.  This analysis includes a preliminary assessment of LACE limited by available data and a set of simplifying assumptions. It does not consider competition among technologies, dynamic feedback from increasing renewable deployment on wholesale electricity prices, export or import situations, or the alleviation of electricity system constraints (e.g., transmission constraints) over time. Further refinement and additional data could improve this indicator.  In this study, LACE was estimated based on annual averages of marginal generation prices and a constant capacity value. This specification does not take into account the subhourly, hourly, or seasonal coincidence of offshore wind generation profiles with marginal generation prices or capacity value. For instance, if an offshore wind site produced electricity during times when it is in high demand (e.g., during peak load events in the late afternoon), the revenue opportuni ties (as represented by marginal generation prices or capacity value) would likely be higher. Such an assessment was not within the scope of this study.  The validity of LACE varies by region because of spatial differences in data availability. As described in Section 2.2, a hierarchy of data sources was compiled to proxy marginal generation prices. This may be a particular concern in the Pacific Northwest coastal regions where neither locational margin price, market marginal cost, or partial locational margin price data w ere available and marginal generation prices were derived from neighboring regions in California and Nevada and regions in the Pacific Nor thwest with partial locational margin price data only.  As applied here, policy-related factors that may influence LACE or LCOE (and hence, the \u201cnet value\u201d of a renewable energy project) were not considered explicitly. For instance, renewable energy support mechanisms (e.g., the production tax credit, renewable portfolio standards), energy sector and environmental regulations (e.g., carbon pricing, loan guarantee programs), or benefits from portfolio diversification (Energy Information Administration [EIA] 2 015) may increase the \u201cnet value\u201d and economic potential. Conversely, regulatory uncertainty and market barriers (see e.g., DOE 2016) may decrease the \u201cnet value\u201d and economic potential.  As a result of how competing use areas were applied in Beiter et al. (2016) and Musial et al. (2016) (as a share of competing use and environmentally sensitive areas), some of the least-cost LCOE sites identified in this study may not be available in practice for offshore wind development because of human use trade-offs (e .g., conflicting use related to viewshed concerns, shipping lines, marine protected areas and fishing [see e.g., DOE 2016]).  The calculation of economic potential should not be used as a prediction for actual project deployment. Economic potential indicate s that the revenue at a given site may exceed its costs in the local energy market, but it does not guarantee that the technology will be selected. Conversely, a negative net value indicating the lack of economic potential at a given site does not necessarily imply that economic viability is not achievable because of general modeling uncertainty related to the development of future costs, electricity prices, policy, and renewable targets (see Section 2.3).  This study only assesses the economic potential of offshore wind and is not a metric of profitability. For a full sectorwide assessment of economic competitiveness, the economic potential from all competing technologies would have to be taken into consideration (see e.g., EIA 2014). For instance, another generation technology may exhibit a net value that is greater than the estimates for offshore wind at any of the assessed sites.","author":["Musial, W.","Kilcher, L.","Beiter, P.","Maness, M.","Smith, A."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind","Floating Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Beiter-et-al-2017-NETL.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2393","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/combined-use-visual-acoustic-data-collection-techniques-winter-killer-whale-orcinus","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2351989416300373","title":"The combined use of visual and acoustic data collection techniques for winter killer whale (Orcinus orca) observations","description":"Observations of cetaceans during the winter are difficult, if not impossible in some locations, yet their presence, habitat use, and behaviour during this period are important for conservation and management. Typically, observations come from vessel surveys, with citizen science networks increasingly adding significant sighting data. In compliment to this, acoustic data collection systems can be deployed to collect information remotely over long periods, and in almost any conditions. Here we describe how the combination of these data collection techniques works to fill knowledge gaps, with data from a well-established citizen science network, and a single passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) recorder integrated to identify killer whale presence during winter months in Clayoquot Sound, on the west coast of Vancouver Island.  Together these data show the overwinter use of Clayoquot Sound by killer whales is greater than previously thought. During the study period, February 21 to April 25, 2015, the citizen science network noted 14 visual encounters ranging from Amphitrite Point to Hot Spring Cove, Vancouver Island. The PAM recorded 17 acoustic encounters within the 10 km detection radius of the recorder, deployed off Siwash Point, Flores Island. This included 15 encounters not recorded by the visual network. Both resident and Bigg\u2019s (transient) transient whale groups were recorded, although analysis of vocalizations determined that the majority of the encounters recorded acoustically were of northern resident killer whales. This may be a function of life history, with Bigg\u2019s killer whales typically noted to be less acoustically active, or could represent greater site use by this group. This first use of acoustic monitoring over the winter, complemented with visual data, can establish a better understanding of year-round use of this area by killer whales and has broader application to other sites.","author":["Burham, R.","Palm, R.","Mouy, X.","Riera, A.","Duffus, D."],"organization":["University of Victoria","JASCO Applied Sciences","Strawberry Isle Marine Research Society (SIMRS)"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["49.220775000000","-126.183684000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/The_combined_use_of-visual_and_acoustic_data_collection.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2394","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fine-scale-foraging-movements-fish-eating-killer-whales-orcinus-orca-relate-vertical","sourceURL":"https:\/\/movementecologyjournal.biomedcentral.com\/articles\/10.1186\/s40462-017-0094-0","title":"Fine-Scale Foraging Movements by Fish-Eating Killer Whales (Orcinus orca) Relate to the Vertical Distributions and Escape Responses of Salmonid Prey (Oncorhynchus spp.)","description":"Background: We sought to quantitatively describe the fine-scale foraging behavior of northern resident killer whales (Orcinus orca), a population of fish-eating killer whales that feeds almost exclusively on Pacific salmon (Oncorhynchus spp.). To reconstruct the underwater movements of these specialist predators, we deployed 34 biologging Dtags on 32 individuals and collected high-resolution, three-dimensional accelerometry and acoustic data. We used the resulting dive paths to compare killer whale foraging behavior to the distributions of different salmonid prey species. Understanding the foraging movements of these threatened predators is important from a conservation standpoint, since prey availability has been identified as a limiting factor in their population dynamics and recovery.  Results: Three-dimensional dive tracks indicated that foraging (N = 701) and non-foraging dives (N = 10,618) were kinematically distinct (Wilks\u2019 lambda: \u03bb16 = 0.321, P \u0026lt; 0.001). While foraging, killer whales dove deeper, remained submerged longer, swam faster,  increased their dive path tortuosity, and rolled their bodies to a greater extent than during other activities. Maximum foraging dive depths reflected the deeper vertical distribution of Chinook (compared to other salmonids) and the tendency of Pacific salmon to evade  predators by diving steeply. Kinematic characteristics of prey pursuit by resident killer whales also revealed several other escape strategies employed by salmon attempting to avoid predation, including increased swimming speeds and evasive maneuvering.  Conclusions: High-resolution dive tracks reconstructed using data collected by multi-sensor accelerometer tags found that movements by resident killer whales relate significantly to the vertical distributions and escape responses of their primary prey, Pacific salmon.","author":["Ellis, G.","Deecke, V.","Ford, J.","Wright, B.","Shapiro, A.","Battaile, B.","Trites, A."],"organization":["Fisheries and Oceans Canada","University of British Columbia","University of Cumbria","Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution"],"originationDate":"2017-02-17","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Pelagic Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:08","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fine-Scale_foraging_movements_by_fish-eating_killer_whales.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2395","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/d71-requirements-criteria-design-planning-ocean-energy-farms","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.dtocean.eu\/content\/download\/25287\/173465\/file\/DTO_WP7_ECD_D7.1.pdf","title":"D7.1: Requirements and Criteria for the Design and Planning of Ocean Energy Farms","description":"This document reviews existing approaches and methodologies for the analysis of ocean energy arrays with a clear focus on the results and conclusions provided by previous experiences. The key outcome is the definition of quantifiable and qualitative metrics for economic viability, reliability and environmental impact which have been adopted in the global set of tools developed within the project DTOcean.  The needs of the industry, the recommendations of the Advisory Board and a literature review about the current approaches allowed the achievement of the main objective of this task consisting of the definition of the set of conditions (physical, economic and environmental) and design criteria (cost of energy COE, reliability index, energy yield and performances, etc.) for ocean energy arrays that will determine the drivers for the comparison of different alternatives. In particular, the needs of the industry have also been analysed and conveyed into the definition of the key requirements and variables for the definition of a decision tool. The most important technical parameters defined for the scenarios have been characterised by quantifiable variables (e.g. distance to shore, distance to port, power capacity of the grid, area of the sea surface available for deployment etc.), or suitable proxy, so as to allow their direct introduction into the design tool and they are herein reported as identified in Deliverable 1.1 \u2013 \u201cDetailed deployment scenarios for wave and tidal energy converters\u201d. Since the economic framework represents an ideal method to evaluate and weigh the importance of different technical decisions, the levelised cost of energy (LCOE) was defined as the major economic quantifiable parameter; similarly reliability indicators and environmental impact factors have been identified and herein described.","author":["DTOcean"],"organization":["DEME Blue Energy (DBE)","France Energies Marines","Iberdrola","Tecnalia","University College Cork","University of Edinburgh","University of Exeter","Vattenfall","WavEC Offshore Renewables","European Commission"],"originationDate":"2015-05-26","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-11-05 12:29:13","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/DTOcean_2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2396","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-fine-scale-oceanographic-features-distribution-movements-harbour-porpoises","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.int-res.com\/abstracts\/meps\/v295\/p279-293\/","title":"Effects of fine-scale oceanographic features on the distribution and movements of harbour porpoises Phocoena phocoena in the Bay of Fundy","description":"We describe an integrative approach to studying the fine-scale distribution of harbour porpoises Phocoena phocoena in the Bay of Fundy, using satellite telemetry, line transect surveys and remote sensing techniques. Analysis of satellite telemetry data from 6  porpoises (5 male, 1 female) revealed that over the course of a month individuals ranged across large areas (7738 to 11289 km2) but concentrated their movements in small focal regions (August mean = 294 km2, September mean = 252 km2), often proximate to  islands, headlands, or restricted channels. Line transect surveys (n =25 flood tide, n = 20 ebb tide) in the focal region of 2 tagged animals revealed that relative porpoise density (animals km\u20132) was significantly greater during flood (9.59) than ebb tide phases (1.79). Hydro-acoustic prey surveys revealed aggregations of prey along localized fronts in this region. Remote sensing images indicated the presence of an island wake in the focal region during flood tides, providing an ecological context for our observations of high  densities of porpoises. Remote sensing revealed the existence of a headland wake in the focal region of another porpoise near Campobello Island. These results support the hypothesis that regions of enhanced relative vorticity, like island and headland wakes, aggregate prey  and represent important foraging habitat for harbour porpoises in the Bay of Fundy.","author":["Read, A.","Johnson, D.","Westgate, A."],"organization":["Duke University","Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute (MBARI)","National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)","University of North Carolina"],"originationDate":"2005-06-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.875044000000","-66.375630000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2397","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/managing-eco-system-service-decisions","sourceURL":"","title":"Managing Eco-System Service Decisions","description":"\u201cEco-system services\u201d is a recent term that describes the benefits humankind gains from its interaction with natural resources. As such, it requires making complex decisions at the intersection of ecology, society and the economy. In this paper we are specifically interested in the process of making eco-system services decisions in a manner that; considers the interaction of all types of information, honors all stakeholder viewpoints and measures the impacts on all three parts of the intersection. These decisions are often spatial, multi-objective, and based on uncertain data and estimates.\n\nEco-system services decisions are generally focused on: provisioning, such as the production of food, energy and water; regulating, such as the control of climate and disease; supporting, such as nutrient cycles and crop pollination; or cultural, such as spiritual and recreational benefits. Eco-system service decisions in these areas are complex and plagued by uncertainty. The choices made during the decision-making process have potentially far reaching and crucial impacts across the many diverse stakeholders. In this paper we outline the characteristics of a system to support ecosystem services decisions and present an example of a system developed for supporting a representative, provisioning problem.\n\nThe example system was developed to support the siting of wave energy generation devices off the Oregon coast. These machines convert wave energy into electricity. The needed decisions are about where to best locate devices with known impact on the eco-systems, tourism, fishing and other considerations while providing the highest return on investment in terms of electricity generation, jobs developed, and other socioeconomic measures. Before detailing this system, sixteen characteristics of an ideal eco-system services decision are itemized.","author":["Goldfinger, C.","Ullman, D.","Halsey, K."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","Parametrix"],"originationDate":"2013-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.293186000000","-124.506561000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ullman-et-al-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2398","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behavioral-responses-fish-current-based-hydrokinetic-turbine-under-multiple","sourceURL":"https:\/\/publications.anl.gov\/anlpubs\/2017\/02\/129701.pdf","title":"Behavioral Responses of Fish to a Current-Based Hydrokinetic Turbine Under Multiple Operational Conditions: Final Report","description":"There is significant interest in the interaction of aquatic organisms with current-based marine and hydrokinetic (MHK) technologies. Determining the potential impacts of MHK devices on fish behavior is critical to addressing the environmental concerns that could act as barriers to the permitting and deployment of MHK devices. To address these concerns, we use field monitoring and fish behavior models to characterize the behavioral responses of fish to MHK turbines and infer potential stimuli that may have elicited the observed behavioral changes.  Monitoring fish interactions with hydrokinetic turbines allows one to consider the magnitude and ecological significance of several potential behavioral risks that have been identified for tidal turbines including the disruption of migratory behavior and food acquisition (Boehlert and Gill, 2010; Frid et al. 2011), behavioral attraction to the device (Boehlert and Gill, 2010; Frid et al. 2011), and avoidance of preferred habitat occupied by the device (Boehlert and Gill, 2010; Polagye et al. 2010; Hammar et al. 2013; Broadhurst et al. 2014). These risks can be assumed to be minimal if the observed fish movement patterns suggest the turbine has only small and temporary effects on normal swimming patterns or fish distribution within a channel.  Blade strike has also been identified as a primary concern associated with the operation of tidal turbines (U.S. Department of Energy, 2009). There have been multiple blade strike studies conducted in laboratory settings using fish exposed to turbines in a confined channel. While these studies indicate fish can avoid blade strike if they swim through a turbine, they do not address what proportion of fish will avoid the turbine completely while swimming through a natural channel. This question is critical in assessing the actual risk of blade strike (Hammar et al. 2015). Earlier work in our study area (Viehman and Zydlewski, 2014) partially addressed this data gap using dual-frequency identification sonar (DIDSON) monitoring of fish movement within a few meters of the Ocean Renewable Power Company (ORPC) turbine generating unit (TGU). The work described in this report further expands the spatial scale of analysis by using field surveys, hydrodynamic modeling, and behavioral simulations that cover fish response to the turbine hundreds of meters upstream and downstream.  The overall goal of this project was to monitor fish movements around an ORPC TGU, use the data to characterize the magnitude and ecological significance of behavioral responses, and investigate the potential variables driving the observed behavioral responses. This multi-year project spanning fiscal years (FYs) 2013\u20132016 was a collaboration between Principal Investigator Mark Grippo (Argonne National Laboratory), Dr. Andrew Goodwin (U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center), Dr. Gayle Zydlewski (University of Maine), and Prof. Huijie Xue (University of Maine). This report describes our activities to (1) collect hydroacoustic fish survey data, (2) produce high-resolution simulated flows for Cobscook Bay for the survey period, and (3) examine whether fish responded to visual and auditory stimuli generated by the turbine as well as natural and turbine-related changes in flows within the channel.","author":["Zydlewski, G.","Grippo, M.","Shen, H.","Rao, S.","Goodwin, A."],"organization":["Argonne National Laboratory (ANL)","University of Maine","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-22 03:58:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Grippo-et-al-2017-ELAM-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2399","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/modeling-study-tidal-energy-extraction-associated-impact-tidal-circulation-multi-inlet","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117302409","title":"A Modeling Study of Tidal Energy Extraction and the Associated Impact on Tidal Circulation in a Multi-Inlet Bay System of Puget Sound","description":"Previous tidal energy studies in Puget Sound have focused on major deep channels such as Admiralty Inlet that have a larger power potential. This paper focuses on the possibility of extracting tidal energy from minor tidal channels of Puget Sound by using a hydrodynamic model to quantify the power potential and the associated impact on tidal circulation. The study site is a multi-inlet bay system connected by two narrow inlets, Agate Pass and Rich Passage, to the Main Basin of Puget Sound. A three-dimensional hydrodynamic model was applied to the study site and validated for tidal elevations and currents. We examined three energy extraction scenarios in which turbines were deployed in each of the two passages and concurrently in both. Extracted power rates and associated changes in tidal elevation, current, tidal flux, and residence time were examined. Maximum instantaneous power rates reached 250\u00a0kW, 1550\u00a0kW, and 1800\u00a0kW, respectively, for the three energy extraction scenarios. Model results suggest that with the level of energy extraction in the three energy extraction scenarios, the impact on tidal circulation is very small. It is worth investigating the feasibility of harnessing tidal energy from minor tidal channels of Puget Sound.","author":["Yang, Z.","Wang, T."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2017-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.715929400000","-122.563161200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2400","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/socio-economic-impact-outer-continental-shelf-wind-energy-development-fisheries-us","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.data.boem.gov\/PI\/PDFImages\/ESPIS\/5\/5581.pdf","title":"Socio-Economic Impact of Outer Continental Shelf Wind Energy Development on Fisheries in the US Atlantic: Volume II - Appendices","description":"This study makes use of data that contain personally identifiable information (PII), which is confidential by law and is suppressed within this analysis, when appropriate. When aggregated landings are examined , the magnitude of the Atlantic fishery is such that PII is rarely a concern. However, as smaller subgroups are identified, disclosure of PII becomes of greater concern. The \u201crule of three\u201d is used here \u2014if any subgroup aggregation consists of three or fewer individuals, landings data and exposure are not disclosed in detail, and this information is marked as not disclosable. Whenever possible, if suppressed data exceed a threshold for inclusion in this analysis, the subgroup is noted as such, but specific details including the extent of expo sure are suppressed.\n\nGeospatial mapping and analysis was performed in ESRI ArcGIS 10.1 and 10.2.\n\nVolume 1 - Report Narrative is available here.","author":["Kirkpatrick, A.","Benjamin, S.","DePiper, G.","Murphy, T.","Steinback, S.","Demarest, C."],"organization":["Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.703368000000","-71.185050200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kirkpatrick-et-al-2017-BOEM-Vol2.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2401","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/socio-economic-impact-outer-continental-shelf-wind-energy-development-fisheries-us-0","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.data.boem.gov\/PI\/PDFImages\/ESPIS\/5\/5580.pdf","title":"Socio-Economic Impact of Outer Continental Shelf Wind Energy Development on Fisheries in the US Atlantic: Volume I - Report Narrative","description":"Commercial and recreational fisheries play a significant part in the U.S. economy and food supply. In 2011, U.S. landings by U.S. commercial fishermen totaled $5.3 billion in revenue and 4.5 million metric tons. Commercial harvesting alone employed over 186,000 individuals across the U. S. In 2011, 11 million recreational saltwater anglers caught an estimated 345 million fish during over 69 million trips nationwide (NMFS 2012). The nation\u2019s fisheries operate alongside a variety of other ocean uses including transportation, natural resource extraction, and energy production. This report assesses the potential impacts to these fisheries and their shoreside dependents from wind energy development on the Atlantic Outer Continental Shelf (OCS).\n\nThis analysis was conducted by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) for the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM). BOEM is responsible for managing activities associated with development of Wind Energy Areas (WEAs) on the OCS. Under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and other legislation, regulations, and executive orders, BOEM is required to assess the potential impacts of WEA development. BOEM will use this report to inform decision-making related to leases on the North and Mid-Atlantic OCS; help interested stakeholders understand how the report data were developed and what they say; identify areas that require refined data analysis; and conduct an environmental assessment under NEPA.\n\nThe area covered in this report extends from Massachusetts to North Carolina and includes eight wind energy planning areas, some of which were leased and some of which were still in earlier planning stages at the time of this analysis in 2013. All eight areas are generally referred to as WEAs in this report. Both exposure to WEA development and the potential associated impacts are assessed for individual WEAs and cumulatively across all eight WEAs. Exposure identifies the individuals and groups likely to be affected by WEA development, while impact analysis estimates the magnitude and direction (gain or loss) of the WEA\u2019s impact on those potentially affected individuals and groups.\n\nVolume 2 - Appendices is available here.","author":["Kirkpatrick, A.","Benjamin, S.","DePiper, G.","Murphy, T.","Steinback, S.","Demarest, C."],"organization":["Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)","US Department of the Interior (DOI)"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["40.703368000000","-71.185050200000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Kirkpatrick-et-al-2017-BOEM.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2402","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/coupled-modeling-hydrodynamics-sound-coastal-ocean-renewable-ocean-energy-development","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.ingentaconnect.com\/content\/mts\/mtsj\/2016\/00000050\/00000002\/art00004","title":"Coupled Modeling of Hydrodynamics and Sound in Coastal Ocean for Renewable Ocean Energy Development","description":"The rapid growth of renewable offshore energy development has raised concerns that underwater noise from construction and operation of offshore devices may interfere with communication of marine animals. An underwater sound model was developed to simulate sound propagation from marine and hydrokinetic energy (MHK) devices or offshore wind (OSW) energy platforms. Finite difference methods were developed to solve the 3-D Helmholtz equation for sound propagation in the coastal environment. A 3-D sparse matrix solver with complex coefficients was formed for solving the resulting acoustic pressure field. The complex shifted Laplacian preconditioner (CSLP) method was applied to solve the matrix system iteratively with Message Passing Interface (MPI) parallelization using a high-performance cluster. The sound model was then coupled with the Finite Volume Community Ocean Model (FVCOM) for simulating sound propagation generated by human activities, such as construction of OSW turbines or tidal stream turbine operations, in a range-dependent setting. As a proof of concept, the validation of the solver is tested with an ideal case against two other methods, and its application is then presented for two coastal wedge problems. This sound model can be useful for evaluating impacts on marine mammals due to deployment of MHK devices and OSW energy platforms.","author":["Yang, Z.","Copping, A.","Deng, D.","Long, W.","Jung, K."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2403","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/simulation-approach-assessing-environmental-risk-sound-exposure-marine-mammals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/ece3.2699\/full","title":"A Simulation Approach to Assessing Environmental Risk of Sound Exposure to Marine Mammals","description":"Intense underwater sounds caused by military sonar, seismic surveys, and pile driving can harm acoustically sensitive marine mammals. Many jurisdictions require such activities to undergo marine mammal impact assessments to guide mitigation. However, the ability to assess impacts in a rigorous, quantitative way is hindered by large knowledge gaps concerning hearing ability, sensitivity, and behavioral responses to noise exposure. We describe a simulation-based framework, called SAFESIMM (Statistical Algorithms For Estimating the Sonar Influence on Marine Megafauna), that can be used to calculate the numbers of agents (animals) likely to be affected by intense underwater sounds. We illustrate the simulation framework using two species that are likely to be affected by marine renewable energy developments in UK waters: gray seal (Halichoerus grypus) and harbor porpoise (Phocoena phocoena). We investigate three sources of uncertainty: How sound energy is perceived by agents with differing hearing abilities; how agents move in response to noise (i.e., the strength and directionality of their evasive movements); and the way in which these responses may interact with longer term constraints on agent movement. The estimate of received sound exposure level (SEL) is influenced most strongly by the weighting function used to account for the specie\u0027s presumed hearing ability. Strongly directional movement away from the sound source can cause modest reductions (~5 dB) in SEL over the short term (periods of less than 10 days). Beyond 10 days, the way in which agents respond to noise exposure has little or no effect on SEL, unless their movements are constrained by natural boundaries. Most experimental studies of noise impacts have been short-term. However, data are needed on long-term effects because uncertainty about predicted SELs accumulates over time. Synthesis and applications. Simulation frameworks offer a powerful way to explore, understand, and estimate effects of cumulative sound exposure on marine mammals and to quantify associated levels of uncertainty. However, they can often require subjective decisions that have important consequences for management recommendations, and the basis for these decisions must be clearly described.","author":["Harwood, J.","Donovan, C.","Williams, R.","Harris, C.","Marshall, L.","Milazzo, L."],"organization":["Imperial College London","Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","University of St Andrews"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Donovan-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2404","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/stochasticism-noise-generated-array-marine-hydrokinetic-devices","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/abs\/10.1121\/1.4969963","title":"Stochasticism in Noise Generated by an Array of Marine Hydrokinetic Devices","description":"Marine hydrokinetic (MHK) devices generate electricity from the motion of tidal and ocean currents and ocean waves and provide another source of renewable energy. Additionally, MHK devices are also a new source of anthropogenic noise in the marine ecosystem and must meet regulatory guidelines that mandate a maximum amount of noise that may be generated. In the absence of measured levels from in-situ deployments, a model for predicting the propagation of sound from an array of MHK sources in a real environment needs to be established. A 3D finite-difference, time-domain solution to the governing velocity-pressure equations is used, which permits a finite number of complex sources and spatially varying sound speeds, bathymetry, and bed composition. However, deterministic solutions to these types of problems cannot capture uncertainties in the source profiles that may result from operational changes. This work presents the broadband sound pressure levels from an array of MHK sources as the amplitude and frequency from each source are allowed to vary. This Monte Carlo approach demonstrates that the idealized, deterministic solution, vastly underestimates the compounding uncertainty on the final sound field and that these small variations in the source profile cannot be ignored.","author":["Roberts, J.","Johnson, E.","Hafla, E."],"organization":["Montana State University","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"2016-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2405","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/underwater-noise-propagation-models-its-application-renewable-energy-parks-waveroller","sourceURL":"https:\/\/run.unl.pt\/bitstream\/10362\/20039\/1\/Rocha_2016.pdf","title":"Underwater Noise Propagation Models and its Application in Renewable Energy Parks: WaveRoller Case Study","description":"In the light of global warming, large-scale transition to renewable power sources is a worldwide challenge, playing wind power a significant role. Sea wave energy is being increasingly regarded in many countries as a major and promising resource but, like all forms of energy conversion, it will inevitably have an impact on the marine environment. WaveRoller, a Wave Energy Conversion Device, is installed in front of Almagreira beach, on the west coast of Portugal. The purpose of this thesis is to study and quantify the underwater radiated noise from this device using an underwater acoustic model in order to estimate potential effects it may have in the marine environment. The model used to run the data will be MIKE Zero \u2013 Underwater Acoustic Simulator by DHI . In the study site only cetacean species are expected to occur. Results showed that behavioural responses might be expected for low and mid-frequency cetaceans if they swim close to the device. Also, the device shouldn\u2019t be installed in an area in which a population of cetaceans exists in a 28m ray. For these individuals, injury can be assumed if SEL (Sound Exposure Level) is higher than 215 dB re 1\u03bcPa2.s, for non-pulse sounds. Results showed the calculated maximum SEL of the Waveroller sound is 150 dB re 1\u03bcPa2.s and therefore no injury is expected. MIKE Zero \u2013 Underwater Acoustic Simulator is a powerful tool to test any device that produces underwater noise and offers the possibility to create Surface Sound maps of results by using MIKEXYZ Converter tool.","author":["Rocha, A."],"organization":["Technical University of Lisbon"],"originationDate":"2016-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["39.396825000000","-9.351260000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:10","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2406","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bayesian-approach-habitat-suitability-prediction","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.library.oregonstate.edu\/xmlui\/handle\/1957\/28788","title":"A Bayesian approach to habitat suitability prediction","description":"For the west coast of North America, from northern California to southern Washington, a habitat suitability prediction framework was developed to support wave energy device siting. Concern that wave energy devices may impact the seafloor and benthos has renewed research interest in the distribution of marine benthic invertebrates and factors influencing their distribution. A Bayesian belief network approach was employed for learning species-habitat associations for Rhabdus rectius, a tusk-shaped marine infaunal Mollusk. Environmental variables describing surficial geology and water depth were found to be most influential to the distribution of R. rectius. Water property variables, such as temperature and salinity, were less influential as distribution predictors. Species-habitat associations were used to predict habitat suitability probabilities for R. rectius, which were then mapped over an area of interest along the south-central Oregon coast. Habitat suitability prediction models tested well against data withheld for crossvalidation supporting our conclusion that Bayesian learning extracts useful information available in very small, incomplete data sets and identifies which variables drive habitat suitability for R. rectius. Additionally, Bayesian belief networks are easily updated with new information, quantitative or qualitative, which provides a flexible mechanism for multiple scenario analyses. The prediction framework presented here is a practical tool informing marine spatial planning assessment through visualization of habitat suitability.","author":["Lockett, D."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2012-03-27","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.007932000000","-126.034775000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2407","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bayesian-approach-marine-spatial-planning","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ir.library.oregonstate.edu\/xmlui\/handle\/1957\/42457","title":"A Bayesian approach to marine spatial planning","description":"The marine ecosystem provides a broad spectrum of services for a wide array of user groups. Such broad use of marine resources often results in use conflicts between ecosystem elements and human interests. To help mitigate these conflicts, the Bayesian Analysis for Spatial Siting (BASS) tool was developed to incorporate both environmental modeled data and subjective stakeholder input while tracking, maintaining and incorporating uncertainty around both data types. The BASS tool is intended to support marine spatial planning decisions where a wide range of potential user groups have interests that conflict regarding siting decisions. The BASS tool incorporates an initial set of twelve (12) Bayesian Belief Network (BBN) models to provide information on ecosystem and economic services such as habitat suitabilities, device suitabilities and usage pressures which include commercial fishing and recreation activities. These models use environmental data as inputs and return suitability values for potential locations in a near real-time on-request basis. BBN methods were selected for this system to take advantage of their intuitive structural components as well as their ability to incorporate and track uncertainty through the modeling process. Stakeholder input is collected in the system using a subset of software from the AccordTM decision support system by Robust Decisions, Inc. This system uses an intuitive two-step data collection method to quantify stakeholder values regarding the decision making process. In the first step, stakeholder participants rank the decision measures, both modeled and subjective, in terms of importance. This ranking scheme allows for weighting later in the process where exploration of the results may require an understanding of stakeholder priorities. The second step uses another component of the AccordTM system called the Belief Map\u00a9 to collect the stakeholder\u2019s levels of satisfaction and certainty regarding subjective decision measures. Finally, using an online user interface, the BASS tool allows a decision manager to explore the output data for the sites in terms of both the modeled and stakeholder decision measure values. Additionally, the user can view the tool output with the weighting structure of the various stakeholders to better understand the priorities held by different groups. This method allows a decision manager to better understand the character of a decision and guide its progress toward a resolution that best addresses the most important elements of the process.","author":["Erhardt, M."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)"],"originationDate":"2013-07-29","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Marine Spatial Planning"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2408","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/predicting-lethal-entanglements-consequence-drag-fishing-gear","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0025326X16309808","title":"Predicting lethal entanglements as a consequence of drag from fishing gear","description":"Large whales are frequently entangled in fishing gear and sometimes swim while carrying gear for days to years. Entangled whales are subject to additional drag forces requiring increased thrust power and energy expenditure over time. To classify entanglement cases and aid potential disentanglement efforts, it is useful to know how long an entangled whale might survive, given the unique configurations of the gear they are towing. This study establishes an approach to predict drag forces on fishing gear that entangles whales, and applies this method to ten North Atlantic right whale cases to estimate the resulting increase in energy expenditure and the critical entanglement duration that could lead to death. Estimated gear drag ranged 11\u2013275 N. Most entanglements were resolved before critical entanglement durations (mean \u00b1 SD 216 \u00b1 260 days) were reached. These estimates can assist real-time development of disentanglement action plans and U.S. Federal Serious Injury assessments required for protected species.","author":["van der Hoop, J.","Knowlton, A.","Moore, M.","Corkeron, P.","Henry, A."],"organization":["Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)","National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)","New England Aquarium","Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution"],"originationDate":"2017-02-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Cetaceans","Entanglement"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-16 10:11:02","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2409","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/life-cycle-energy-carbon-footprint-offshore-wind-energy-comparison-onshore-counterpart","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148117301258","title":"Life Cycle Energy and Carbon Footprint of Offshore Wind Energy: Comparison With Onshore Counterpart","description":"The exploitation of wind energy worldwide comprises one of the main factors for reaching the targets towards a non-fossil fuel era set by many countries. Nowadays, onshore wind power is an established industry with significant contribution to energy production. On the other hand, offshore wind power is an emerging industry where numerous challenges should be faced. Apart from the main components such as platforms, turbines, cables, and substations, offshore installations include also the manufacturing, construction, shipping, and decommissioning phases. Additionally, the Operation \u0026 Maintenance (O\u0026M) activities consist of employees\u2019 transportation by vessel or helicopter and occasional hardware retrofits. Therefore, various life cycle (LC) stages of offshore projects present a carbon footprint which affects their sustainable character in a more significant way than onshore ones. Concerning the environmental uncertainties arisen from the greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions of offshore wind power generation, the present work intents to provide a literature review on the LC carbon and energy footprint of offshore wind power projects compared to the onshore counterparts.","author":["Kaldellis, J.","Apostolou, D."],"organization":["Piraeus University of Applied Science (PUAS)"],"originationDate":"2017-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2410","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-potential-impact-electromagnetic-fields-undersea-cable-migratory-fish","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/biblio\/1406896","title":"Assessment of Potential Impact of Electromagnetic Fields from Undersea Cable on Migratory Fish Behavior (Final Technical Report)","description":"The US Department of Energy and US Department of the Interior, Bureau of Ocean Energy Management commissioned this study to address the limited scientific data on the impacts of high voltage direct current cables on aquatic biota, in particular migratory species within the San Francisco Bay. The study was conducted in several stages as described in three separate technical manuscripts which capture the methods, findings and recommendations. A summary of each manuscript is provided herein.  Empirical evidence exists that marine animals perceive and orient to local distortions in the earth\u2019s main geomagnetic field magnetic field. The electromagnetic fields generated by the cables that carry electricity from hydrokinetic energy sources to shore-based power stations may produce similar local distortions in the earth\u2019s main field. Concern exists that animals that migrate along the continental shelves might orient to the EMF from the cables, and move either inshore or offshore away from their normal path. The Trans Bay Cable (TBC) is a \u00b1200-kilovolt (kV), 400 MW 85-km long High Voltage Direct Current (DC) buried transmission line linking Pittsburg, CA with San Francisco, CA (SF) through the San Francisco Bay. The study addresses the following specific questions based on measurements and projections of the EMF produced by an existing marine cable, the Trans Bay Cable, in San Francisco Bay.    Does the presence of EMF from an operating power cable alter the behavior and path of bony fishes and sharks along a migratory corridor?  Does the EMF from an operating power cable guide migratory movements or pose an obstacle to movement?   To meet the main study objectives several activities needed to be carried out: 1) modeling of the magnetic fields produced by the Trans Bay Cable, 2) assessing the migratory impacts on Chinook salmon smolts (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) and green sturgeon (Acipenser medirostris) as a result of local magnetic field distortions produced by bridge structures and 3) analyzing behavioral responses by migratory Chinook salmon and green sturgeon to a high-voltage power cable.","author":["Klimley, A.","Kavet, R.","Wyman, M.","Vergara, X."],"organization":["Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI)","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2016-09-28","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","EMF","Attraction"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-14 04:57:49","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/BOEM-2016-041.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2411","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-electromagnetic-fields-fish-invertebrates-fy2010-progress-report","sourceURL":"","title":"Effects of Electromagnetic Fields on Fish and Invertebrates - FY2010 Progress Report","description":"In this progress report, we describe the preliminary experiments conducted with three fish and one invertebrate species to determine the effects of exposure to electromagnetic fields. During fiscal year 2010, experiments were conducted with coho salmon (Onchorhychus kisutch), California halibut (Paralicthys californicus), Atlantic halibut (Hippoglossus hippoglossus), and Dungeness crab (Cancer magister). The work described supports Task 2.1.3: Effects on Aquatic Organisms, Subtask 2.1.3.1: Electromagnetic Fields.","author":["Woodruff, D.","Schultz, I.","Roesijadi, G.","Marshall, K.","Pratt, W."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)","US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2010-10-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Demersal Fish","Pelagic Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Schultz_et_al_2010_Progress_Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2412","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/community-energy-emissions-planning-tidal-current-turbines-case-study-municipalities","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032117303428","title":"Community Energy and Emissions Planning for Tidal Current Turbines: A Case Study of the Municipalities of the Southern Gulf Islands Region, British Columbia","description":"Society\u0027s dependence on fossil fuels to meet energy demands has resulted in an enormous release of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions into the atmosphere, thereby perpetuating global climate change. The consequences of climate change have prompted progressive governments such as British Columbia to establish legislative GHG emission reductions targets, which have lead to energy conscience municipalities within the province voluntarily committing to helping achieve such targets. Best practices examined from European municipalities share a common theme of renewable energy adoption and municipally-owned utilities. An emerging renewable energy technology are tidal current turbines (TCTs), which function to extract kinetic energy from the lateral movement of the tides in areas with considerable tidal velocities. This paper examines the history, physics, operational parameters, and plausible environmental impacts of TCTs in order to make a case for their sustainable implementation. The feasibility of the municipalities of North Pender Island, South Pender Island, and Saturna of the Southern Gulf Islands Region (SGIR), British Columbia, to help meet established GHG emissions reduction targets through the implementation of TCTs is analyzed, demonstrating that the deployment of 10 TCTs can produce 38,266,602 kWh\/yr of electricity, mitigating 1138 t of CO2e, achieving 9.9% of the cumulative municipal GHG emissions mitigation targets. The paper then examines a case study in the Shetland Islands and Pentland Firth and Orkney Waters, Scotland, suggesting that jurisdictional regulatory powers over TCT installation and operation be devolved from the British Columbia government to the municipal governments of North Pender Island, South Pender Island, and Saturna, so that such communities can reap the benefits associated with a municipally-owned utility.","author":["Sangiuliano, S."],"organization":["York University"],"originationDate":"2017-09-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["48.820735100000","-123.414939000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2413","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/changes-fish-communities-small-spatial-scale-effect-increased-habitat-complexity","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0141113616302239","title":"Changes in Fish Communities on a Small Spatial Scale, an Effect of Increased Habitat Complexity by an Offshore Wind Farm","description":"The number of offshore wind farms (OWF) is increasing to meet the demands for renewable energy. The piles and hard substrate surrounding these piles creates new habitat for species with preference to hard substrates. We studied the impact of this hard substrate on the fish community in a Dutch OWF in the sandy southern North Sea, which had been in operation for five years. Multi-mesh gillnets were placed near the OWF structures on the hard substrate protection revetments and on the sandy bottom in the middle of the farm. The catches indicated attraction of cod, pouting, bullrout and edible and velvet crab, while attraction to the sandy habitat was shown for flatfish and whiting. Further, two species previously not caught in this area, goldsinny wrasse and grey trigger fish, were caught on the hard substrate. In addition a Dual-Frequency Identification Sonar (DIDSON) was used to record transects through the farm to observe individual fish in the water column throughout the farm and very near the OWF structures. High abundances of fish near the structure were observed during some days, while during other days equal distribution of fish in the area was observed. The area around the structures is thus only used temporarily for shelter or feeding. The DIDSON also allowed looking at the aggregation level of the fish. Seasonally the aggregation level differed most likely due to different species occurring in the area. In April, most fish were aggregated in schools, while in summer most observations were individual fish or loose aggregations. The wind farm structures had limited effect on the aggregation level compared to season or weather conditions.","author":["van Keeken, O.","van Hal, R.","Griffioen, A."],"organization":["Wageningen University and Research Centre"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["54.916657000000","6.997450000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2414","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/visual-representation-wind-farms-version-22","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/doc\/visual-representation-wind-farms-guidance","title":"Visual Representation of Wind Farms - Version 2.2","description":"\u2018Pictures speak louder than words\u2019. Images are a powerful way of conveying information, illustrating options and capturing our imagination. They also form an important part of planning applications and Environmental Statements. The landscape and visual assessment of wind farms, however, involves much more than just looking at visualisations.\n\nThis guidance is aimed at landscape practitioners, those involved in producing visual representations of wind farms and at planning officers or decision makers involved in the planning process. A condensed version aimed at members of the public is also available on our website. The visualisations described are designed for use by all stakeholders within the planning process.\n\nVisualisations are very useful in communicating information, but they can never tell the wholes tory. They cannot replicate the experience of seeing a wind farm in the landscape, whether they are photographs, maps, sketches or computer - generated visualisations, prepared using the highest specification and skill possible. They are an aid to decision making which must be considered alongside further information.\n\nExperience gained since this guidance was first published in 2006 has led to a better understanding of how to represent proposed wind farm developments in a more accessible and realistic way. The revised methodology provides visualisations which are easier for both the public and decision makers to use. New sections on offshore wind farms and repowering have also been included, and there are additional points on turbine lighting.\n\nNonetheless, anyone using visualisations should be aware of their limitations, and these are explained throughout the text and in Annex A. It is recommended that the standard text in Annex A should be inserted into the Environmental Statement and made available at public exhibitions.\n\nAll wind farm applications requiring a Landscape and Visual Impact Assessment as part of an Environmental Impact Assessment should conform with the requirements set out within this document. Applications which do not require an EIA should follow a proportionate approach agreed with the determining authority. Different landscapes, types of wind farms and conditions in other countries may require different approaches. SNH cannot offer advice on applications outside Scotland.\n\nSmaller scale wind farm proposals (up to 3 turbines) and single turbine applications do not usually require the same level of visual representation. A tailored, proportionate approach is required which is likely to include fewer viewpoints (2-3 will generally be sufficient) and fewer visualisations per viewpoint. This should be determined on a case-by-case basis. Wirelines may be relatively unhelpful in flat landscapes for example, other than during the design stage or in conjunction with other, photographic, visualisations. However, we recommend that the same methodology (camera, lens, image presentation) is used for small scale applications for consistency and ease of understanding by decision makers and members of the public. Viewpoints immediately adjacent to small scale proposals tend to less useful than those a few 4 kilometres away which show more context. Our guidance on assessing small scale wind farms should be referred to.\n\nSome aspects of this guidance are prescriptive and must be complied with. A summary of these requirements is provided in Annex B. Other aspects include options, and it is for the landscape assessor to choose the most appropriate approach for the site in question, agree it with relevant consultees, and justify these choices in the ES.\n\nSome planning authorities have also produced specific guidance for wind farms and single turbines. Early engagement with authorities is encouraged to establish their information requirements. SNH will require visualisations which meet the requirements of this guidance for all applications we are consulted on.","author":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 02:20:09","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SNH-2017-VisualWindfarms.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2415","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-cumulative-impact-onshore-wind-energy-developments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/guidance-assessing-cumulative-impact-onshore-wind-energy-developments","title":"Assessing the Cumulative Impact of Onshore Wind Energy Developments","description":"Renewable energy is an increasingly important part of Scotland\u2019s economic, social and environmental success. The pace of renewable developments has increased rapidly in recent years and windfarms are now familiar sights in many parts of the country. Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) supports the development of onshore windfarms and recognises the many benefits they bring. However, their cumulative impacts on the natural heritage need to be carefully considered to ensure that these are acceptable.  The increasing development of on-shore windfarms has led to concerns about cumulative impacts in some locations as was illustrated in the debate in the Scottish Parliament on 1 December 2011. During the debate Fergus Ewing, Minister for Energy Enterprise and Tourism observed: \u201cThe Scottish planning system is committed to delivery of increased renewable energy capacity. It also seeks to safeguard communities and the environment\u2026 The main issue has perhaps been cumulative impact, which is already a key consideration in decision making. In determinations, planning authorities and the Scottish Government will continue to draw on planning policy and advice from SNH. \u201d  Scottish Planning Policy (SPP) highlights that cumulative impacts may present an eventual limit to the extent of onshore wind development and the increased need to consider cumulative impacts in the decision making process (SPP para 189). This guidance therefore seeks to identify methodologies which can be used to assess cumulative impacts.  The guidance is aimed at public bodies, developers and consultants involved in onshore wind energy development. It sets out methods to be used to assess cumulative impacts on landscapes and birds. It is not possible to provide generic advice on the significance of cumulative effects, which need to be assessed on a case by case basis against other guidance.  Although the guidance concentrates on the particular issue of assessing the cumulative effects of more than one windfarm development, the methods may also be helpful when considering the cumulative impact of other forms of development. Impacts on other natural heritage interests, such as habitats and protected species require to be addressed on a case by case basis as it is not possible to provide meaningful generic guidance.  Cumulative impacts are just one of many issues that have to be considered in order to make good development happen in the right places. We have produced guidance on a range of other issues to be considered during the design and assessment of windfarms. Further guidance and information, for example Siting and Designing windfarms in the landscape.","author":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2012-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:12","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SNH-2012-CumulativeOnshoreWind.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2416","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/siting-designing-wind-farms-landscape-version-3","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/siting-and-designing-wind-farms-landscape-version-3a","title":"Siting and Designing Wind Farms in the Landscape - Version 3","description":"This guidance provides advice on the siting and design of wind farms in Scotland\u2019s landscapes. It also includes advice on assessing the landscape and visual effects of wind farms, as this is an iterative process with design. The guidance draws on two decades of experience of planning for wind farms by SNH, planning authorities and landscape assessors. Design is a material consideration in the planning process and good siting and design helps to produce development which is appropriate for a landscape whilst delivering renewable energy. It should also maximise the capacity for further development by reducing negative cumulative effects.  In 2001 we published \u2018Guidelines on the Environmental Impacts of Wind farms and Small Scale Hydroelectric Schemes\u2019, which included guidance on the siting and design of wind farms. Our understanding of the effects of wind farm siting and design has developed significantly since then and new issues, such as the cumulative impacts of multiple developments, have emerged.  This version - version 3 - reflects Scottish Planning Policy, published in 2014. References to new guidance and research are also included. However, the basic siting and design principles are the same as version 1 as these remain relevant and have proven to be valuable in determining applications. Knowledge, understanding and technologies in this area continue to evolve and it is expected that this guidance will need to be reviewed and updated as a result 1.  Version 1 contained two parts, with Part 2 focussing on strategic planning. Part 2 has been removed and replaced by new guidance on Spatial Planning for onshore wind farms \u2013 natural heritage considerations, published in June 2015.  This version also includes a new annex on siting and design for turbines of between 15 and 50m. This replaces previous SNH guidance published in 2012.  Wind farms are increasingly being located in areas of commercial forestry and woodland. This version takes on board comments from the Forestry Commission Scotland (FCS) about their recent experience of responding to applications in forested areas. Applicants should seek advice from FCS as early as possible in the process and refer to the Control of woodland removal policy.  This is guidance on landscape and visual issues. It does not refer to wider technical design considerations (such as wind speed, access to grid) or to other natural heritage issues (such as impacts on birds, other wildlife and habitats) which are also of importance. A range of other considerations such as noise, archaeology, access and transport are also relevant to the design of wind farms and guidance on these topics is available elsewhere.  This document should be used alongside our guidance on Assessing the Cumulative Impact of Onshore Wind Energy Developments (2012), and Visual Representation of Wind farms (2017). For offshore wind farms reference should be made to Offshore Renewables \u2013 guidance on assessing the impact on coastal landscape and seascape (2012).  Developers and those involved in wind farm design should also refer to the Spatial Frameworks being developed by planning authorities in response to Scottish Planning Policy (SPP). When considering an individual application the adopted development plan, relevant supplementary guidance, wind energy capacity studies and SPP provide the framework within which the application should be considered.  The views expressed in this document are drawn from the experience of SNH staff who have advised on wind farm applications across Scotland in many different landscape settings and at many different scales of development. They have also been informed by a public consultation exercise and a workshop held at Battleby in March 2009. The first version was published in December 2009. Since then it has been referred to extensively at Public Local Inquiries. Experience gained at Inquiry and decisions by Scottish Government Reporters have also influenced this revision.","author":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Visual Impacts"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/SNH-2017-Siting-Designing-Wind.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2417","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/masts-marine-renewable-energy-forum-workshop-environmental-impacts-research-funding","sourceURL":"","title":"MASTS Marine Renewable Energy Forum: Workshop on Environmental Impacts Research Funding","description":"On October 18th, 2016, the Marine Alliance for Science and Technology Scotland (MASTS) Marine Renewable Energy Forum, in association with the Offshore Renewables Joint Industry Programme Ocean Energy (ORJIP), brought together 18 experts to address questions of funding for environmental impact-related funding for the marine renewable energy industry. The experts represented a broad range of interests, including industry representatives, consultants, academics, and funding agencies.  The key objectives for the day were:    To better understand why it has proven to be difficult to obtain funding to address well-defined questions about the environmental impacts of marine renewables; and,  To identify opportunities to improve the current situation.   Expected outcomes of the day included:    A better understanding of the key issues affecting funding;  A recognition of the strengths and weaknesses of the marine renewable energy network;  Steps towards a vision for effective environmental impact research in the marine renewable sector; and,  Potential innovative ideas to help focus efforts towards funding effective environmental impact research in the marine renewable energy sector.   A detailed overview of issues addressed and ideas generated from the workshop can be found in the following sections (Detailed Overview).","author":["Miller, R."],"organization":["Marine Alliance for Science and Technology Scotland (MASTS)","Offshore Renewables Joint Industry Programme (ORJIP)"],"originationDate":"2016-10-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Miller-2016-WorkshopReport.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2418","type":["Document","Document\/Workshop Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/eimr-2016-expert-workshop-report-biofouling","sourceURL":"","title":"EIMR 2016 Expert Workshop Report: Biofouling","description":"Environmental Interactions of Marine Renewable Technologies (EIMR) is an international conference held at different sites across the Scottish Highlands and Islands region. It serves as a major forum for global researchers to come together to present their latest research, results and ideas; and to strengthen relations between the emerging marine renewables industry, research laboratories, and universities.  As part of this on-going work, EIMR hosted a series of parallel, one-day, invite-only workshops on the 22nd February 2016 at Victoria Quay, Marine Scotland, Edinburgh. The workshops aimed to bring together science and science stakeholders to explore critical questions for monitoring and mitigation around marine renewable energy (MRE) devices and arrays in three areas: biofouling, collision risk, and societal impact.  This particular workshop aimed to address a series of linked ecologically and industrially relevant questions around marine growth, or biofouling, on marine renewable energy devices. It focussed on first identifying key topics of relevance, which was followed by a prioritisation exercise aimed at elaborating next steps needed to address any knowledge gaps.  The aim of this report is to summarise the workshop activities and outputs for workshop attendees and a wider audience.","author":["Miller, R.","Loxton, J."],"organization":["Marine Scotland Science","Ocean Energy Systems (OES)","Offshore Renewables Joint Industry Programme (ORJIP)","University of the Highlands and Islands (UHI)"],"originationDate":"2016-02-22","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Miller-Loxton-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2419","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/turning-drip-data-rich-information-poor-rationalising-monitoring-focus-marine","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032117303295","title":"Turning Off the DRIP (\u0027Data-Rich, Information-Poor\u0027) - Rationalising Monitoring with a Focus on Marine Renewable Energy Developments and the Benthos","description":"Marine renewable energy developments (MREDs) are rapidly expanding in size and number as society strives to maintain electricity generation whilst simultaneously reducing climate-change linked CO2 emissions. MREDs are part of an ongoing large-scale modification of coastal waters that also includes activities such as commercial fishing, shipping, aggregate extraction, aquaculture, dredging, spoil-dumping and oil and gas exploitation. It is increasingly accepted that developments, of any kind, should only proceed if they are ecologically sustainable and will not reduce current or future delivery of ecosystem services. The benthos underpins crucial marine ecosystem services yet, in relation to MREDs, is currently poorly monitored: current monitoring programmes are extensive and costly yet provide little useful data in relation to ecosystem-scale-related changes, a situation called \u2018data-rich, information-poor\u2019 (DRIP). MRED \u2013benthic interactions may cause changes that are of a sufficient scale to change ecosystem services provision, particularly in terms of fisheries and biodiversity and, via trophic linkages, change the distribution of fish, birds and mammals. The production of DRIPy data should be eliminated and the resources used instead to address relevant questions that are logically bounded in time and space. Efforts should target identifying metrics of change that can be linked to ecosystem function or service provision, particularly where those metrics show strongly non-linear effects in relation to the stressor. Future monitoring should also be designed to contribute towards predictive ecosystem models and be sufficiently robust and understandable to facilitate transparent, auditable and timely decision-making.","author":["Sheehan, E.","Gill, A.","Wilding, T.","Boon, A.","Dauvin, J.","Mesel, I.","Pezy, J.","O\u0027Beirn, U.","Janas, U.","Rostin, L."],"organization":["Cranfield University","Deltares (NL)","Irish Marine Institute","Normandie Universit\u00e9","Plymouth University","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","Scottish Association for Marine Science (SAMS)","University of Gda\u0144sk","University of Tartu"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Wilding-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2420","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/marine-hydrokinetic-energy-regulators-workshop-lessons-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nrel.gov\/docs\/fy15osti\/65125.pdf","title":"Marine Hydrokinetic Energy Regulators Workshop: Lessons from Wind","description":"Purpose: to review the growth of the wind industry and how lessons learned have altered site selection, regulation, and the application of adaptive management processes. Comparisons between the marine energy industry and the path of the wind industry were made and potential relevance of lessons learned were identified.  Find other presentations from the DOE Marine and Hydrokinetic Workshop for State and Federal Regulators.","author":["Baring-Gould, I."],"organization":["National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL)"],"originationDate":"2015-05-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/DOE-Regulatory-Workshop_Baring-Gould-9.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2421","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mhk-electromagnetic-fields-emfs","sourceURL":"","title":"MHK and Electromagnetic Fields (EMFs)","description":"Purpose: to discuss undersea power networks and EMF emissions from undersea AC and DC cables and present the current state of knowledge regarding the effects of emitted EMFs from marine renewable energy cables on marine organisms. Field data and case studies from around the world helped establish an understanding of the interaction between EMF and a variety of species, as well as identified remaining questions requiring further research and measurement campaigns.  Find other presentations from the DOE Marine and Hydrokinetic Workshop for State and Federal Regulators.","author":["Gill, A."],"organization":["Cranfield University"],"originationDate":"2015-05-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/DOE-Regulatory-Workshop_Gill-8.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2422","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-effects-marine-energy-development-physical-systems","sourceURL":"","title":"Environmental Effects of Marine Energy Development on Physical Systems","description":"Purpose: to present the environmental effects of marine energy development on physical systems within the ocean space, including the change of local ocean ecosystems due to the installation of new MHK devices. Roberts and Jones discussed how the physical environment is changed, whether the changes are significant and cause for concern, and whether effective mitigation strategies exist.  Find other presentations from the DOE Marine and Hydrokinetic Workshop for State and Federal Regulators.","author":["Roberts, J.","Jones, C."],"organization":["Integral Consulting Inc","Sandia National Laboratories (SNL)"],"originationDate":"2015-05-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/DOE-Regulatory-Workshop_Roberts-Jones-6.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2423","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/state-understanding-risk-blade-strike-current-energy-converters","sourceURL":"","title":"State of Understanding: Risk of Blade Strike from Current Energy Converters","description":"Purpose: to present the current state of understanding of risks and issues associated with direct and indirect physical interactions among MHK devices and systems, moorings, electrical interconnections, and marine species. This session looked at the probability, consequences, and effects of strike events as well as survival rates and avoidance behavior in fish and mammal populations.  Find other presentations from the DOE Marine and Hydrokinetic Workshop for State and Federal Regulators.","author":["Brown-Saracino, J."],"organization":["US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2015-05-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Marine Mammals","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/DOE-Regulatory-Workshop_Brown-Saracino-4.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2424","type":["Document","Document\/Presentation"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/regulatory-introduction-roles-responsibilities-within-permitting-process","sourceURL":"","title":"Regulatory Introduction: Roles and Responsibilities within the Permitting Process","description":"Purpose: to provide a broad overview of the state and federal regulatory process. Topics explored included identifying the agencies involved in the permitting process and clarifying their roles and responsibilities, legal jurisdiction, focus areas, inputs to consider, and challenges they face in the application process. The presentation also reviewed the project permitting and licensing process.  Find other presentations from the DOE Marine and Hydrokinetic Workshop for State and Federal Regulators.","author":["West, A."],"organization":["Kearns \u0026 West"],"originationDate":"2015-05-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Legal \u0026 Policy"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/DOE-Regulatory-Workshop_West-1.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2425","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-hydrokinetic-energy-turbine-arrays-sediment-transport-sao-marcos-bay-brazil","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/301675183_Effects_of_hydrokinetic_energy_turbine_arrays_on_sediment_transport_at_Sao_Marcos_Bay_Brazil","title":"Effects of Hydrokinetic Energy Turbine Arrays on Sediment Transport at S\u00e3o Marcos Bay, Brazil","description":"At the present time, the role of renewable energy in Brazil is significant as hydropower and other renewable energies, mainly biomass, contribute with 70.7% and 9,6%, respectively, towards the total offer for electric energy, as compared to the corresponding figures of 14,8% and 5,6% regarding worldwide averages. Nevertheless, there is already an increasing role which is played by wind energy, and a promising potential for tidal current energy. This paper is concerned with the assessment of the tidal current resource in S\u00e3o Marcos Bay, located on the north-eastern coast of Brazil in the state of Maranh\u00e3o, and possesses a highly promising potential for the generation of electricity generation through the conversion of tidal current energy. Also, the impact of in-stream Hydrokinetic Energy Converter (HEC) arrays would have on the bay\u2019s morphology is studied. Three potential zones for tidal power exploitation were identified employing SisBaHiA\u00ae finite element hydro-sedimentological model based on the sediment transport equation of Engelund \u0026amp; Hansen. Potential zones have surface areas of 1km\u00b2 to 5 km\u00b2, mean spring peak tidal currents in the range of 2\u20132.5 m\/s and water depths range from 22m to 40m. An analytical power model applied for each zone defines HEC array characteristics and demonstrates an annually potential output in the range of 34-49 GWh. The analytical power model has, for simplification, a fix lateral spacing between TECs set in 3 rotor diameters and considers cut-in and cut-off velocities. An additional stress term was added to the model momentum equations in order to include TEC operation as a momentum sink taking into account thrust coefficient as a function of flow velocity. Six scenarios with full-scale TEC arrays are modelled to study hydrodynamic influences between arrays, as well as morphological effects. The hydrosedimentological scenarios include, initially, a simulation without TEC arrays to adjust bathymetry of possible data uncertainties to an equilibrium condition, afterward individual simulations of each array, followed by pairs of arrays and ending with the simulation of the three arrays case. Even though, the sediment transport model accepts differentiating granulometry and erosion limit at each calculating node of the domain, it was adopted a uniform granulometry consisting of five types of sediments distributed in an erodible layer of up to 5 m. Results for the hydrodynamic interference study indicate increases and decreases in power output up to 16.7% and 10.7% respectively. Morphological effects are studied in the proximities of the promising zones. Results, interpreted in a qualitative manner, indicate the formation of sand banks with heights lower than 0.75 m and regions experiencing levels of erosion of the same order. Future work is directed towards layout optimisation to maximise electric energy generation, minimising adverse effects in sediment dynamics.","author":["Rosman, P.","Gonz\u00e1lez-Gorbe\u00f1a, E.","Qassim, R.","Wilson, G. Jr."],"organization":["Federal University of Rio de Janeiro","University of Algarve"],"originationDate":"2015-08-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:14","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Gonzalez-Gorbena-et-al-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2426","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/passive-acoustic-methods-fine-scale-tracking-harbour-porpoises-tidal-rapids","sourceURL":"https:\/\/asa.scitation.org\/doi\/10.1121\/1.4976077","title":"Passive Acoustic Methods for Fine-Scale Tracking of Harbour Porpoises in Tidal Rapids","description":"The growing interest in generating electrical power from tidal currents using tidal turbine generators raises a number of environmental concerns, including the risk that marine mammals might be injured or killed through collision with rotating turbine blades. To understand this risk, information on how marine mammals use tidal rapid habitats and in particular, their underwater movements and dive behaviour is required. Porpoises, which are the most abundant small cetacean at most European tidal sites, are difficult animals to tag, and the limited size of tidal habitats means that any telemetered animal would be likely to spend only a small proportion of time within them. Here, an alternative approach is explored, whereby passive acoustic monitoring (PAM) is used to obtain fine scale geo-referenced tracks of harbour porpoises in tidal rapid areas. Large aperture hydrophone arrays are required to obtain accurate locations of animals from PAM data and automated algorithms are necessary to process the large quantities of acoustic data collected on such systems during a typical survey. Methods to automate localisation, including a method to match porpoise detections on different hydrophones and separate different vocalising animals, and an assessment of the localisation accuracy of the large aperture hydrophone array are presented.","author":["Gordon, J.","Gillespie, D.","Macaulay, J.","Malinka, C.","Northridge, S."],"organization":["Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2427","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interactions-marine-hydrokinetic-devices-complex-bathymetries-numerical-simulations","sourceURL":"https:\/\/agu.confex.com\/agu\/fm15\/preliminaryview.cgi\/Session7935","title":"Interactions of Marine Hydrokinetic Devices in Complex Bathymetries: Numerical Simulations in the Chacao Channel in Southern Chile","description":"Many coastal areas in the South Pacific Ocean can provide significant marine energy resources in the near future. The installation of marine hydrokinetic (MHK) devices in these regions will require new approaches to understand physical and environmental processes that are relevant for the installation of turbine arrays, which are also specific of each site. The coastal morphology of the Chacao channel in southern Chile, which separates the Chilo\u00e9 island from the main continent (41\u00ba47\u0027S, 73\u00ba31\u0027W) stands out as an important energy resource that can potentially contribute a significant power capacity. This coastal area not only sustains delicate ecosystems with limited anthropic intervention, but it is characterized by a complex bathymetry that can have important effects on the performance of MHK devices and their local impacts. To understand the interactions of the local bathymetry and ambient turbulence with turbine arrays, we carry out a series of numerical simulations with a coherent-structure resolving turbulence model using the actuator disk parameterization. The main objective of this study is to further our understanding on the physical processes associated with the installation of the turbine arrays. We perform simulations with different geometries and inlet boundary conditions, from simple cases in a rectangular channel, to more complex cases that include the high-resolution bathymetry of an extensive area of the Chacao channel. The results show how the interactions between the MHK devices, the local flow, and the bed can affect the energy flux and potential generation in specific sites. The results also provide new insights of local impacts of MHK devices and they can also help to optimize turbine arrays in natural environments. This work has been supported by Fondecyt project 1130940, and the Marine Energy Research \u0026amp; Innovation Center (MERIC) financed by Corfo and based in Santiago, Chile.","author":["Soto, K.","Escauriaza, C.","Richter, D."],"organization":["Pontifical Catholic University of Chile","University of Notre Dame"],"originationDate":"2015-12-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["-41.823269000000","-73.489092000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2428","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/nearshore-assessment-wave-energy-resources-central-chile-2009-2010","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S096014811530570X","title":"Nearshore assessment of wave energy resources in central Chile (2009\u20132010)","description":"The goal of this work is to estimate nearshore wave energy resources in central Chile with high spatial resolution. Due to the lack of in situ measurements a suite of numerical models are used to assess the wave energy between 2009 and 2010. We compare the effects of different wind forcing reanalysis, particularly CFSR and ERA-Interim, and physics parametrizations on numerical simulations of the nearshore wave energy fluxes near Valparaiso (33\u00b0S), central Chile. For this we utilize WAVEWATCH III\u00ae, an open source community spectral wave model, configured with a high resolution unstructured grid (200\u2013400\u00a0m\u00a0at the coast). Our results show a difference of 3\u00a0kW\/m in wave power estimations when using different wind reanalysis, and less a difference of less than 0.5\u00a0kW\/m when adding the triad wave interactions term. Statistical indicators calculated using buoy and altimeter data for comparison favor the use of ERA-Interim winds and including triad wave interactions. For the Valparaiso region, the area south of Punta Curaumilla was confirmed as a hot spot of wave energy (4\u20135\u00a0MW\/yr), with the most energetic and frequent sea state described by Te of 9\u201311\u00a0s and H_s 2.5\u20133.5\u00a0m.","author":["Sepulveda, H.","Mediavilla, D."],"organization":["University of Concepci\u00f3n"],"originationDate":"2016-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["-33.500467000000","-72.604696000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2429","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/corrosion-stainless-steel-simulated-tide-fresh-natural-seawater-south-east-pacific","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.electrochemsci.org\/papers\/vol11\/110806873.pdf","title":"Corrosion of Stainless Steel in Simulated Tide of Fresh  Natural  Seawater of South East Pacific","description":"Whereas the initiation and advance of localized corrosion often limits a prolonged application of stainless steel in seawater, the particular conditions that trigger this type of corrosion are not fully understood due to high variability of water parameter s and diversity of the biological component. In this study, coupons of AISI 304 and 316L were tested in fresh natural seawater of South East Pacific (coast of central Chile) employing two flow - through exposition racks: one keeping the coupons at full immer sion and one allowing the simulation of tides through variable level of water effecting dry - wet cycles. Loss of weight and electrochemical characterization after 1, 5, 15 and 30 weeks of exposition revealed that for both materials the intermittent immersio n results in considerably less corrosion, both general and localized. After 15 weeks, all samples showed a negative shift of OCP, i.e. the opposite of ennoblement, which is explained by the activity of microorganisms associated with change of season.","author":["Fischer, D.","Daille, L.","Aguirre, J.","Galarce, C.","Armijo, F.","De la Iglesia, R.","Pizarro, G.","Vargas, I.","Walczak, M."],"organization":["Marine Energy Research \u0026 Innovation Center (MERIC)","Pontifical Catholic University of Chile"],"originationDate":"2016-07-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["-33.500467000000","-72.604696000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-24 11:13:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Fischer-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2430","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/hydroacoustic-analysis-effects-tidal-power-turbine-fishes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/digitalcommons.library.umaine.edu\/cgi\/viewcontent.cgi?article=3627\u0026context=etd","title":"Hydroacoustic Analysis of the Effects of a Tidal Power Turbine on Fishes","description":"Tidal currents help shape coastal marine environments and are essential in life cycles of many fish species. Areas with strong tidal currents are also targeted by humans for energy extraction via tidal energy turbines. The effects of these devices on fishes are difficult to predict because fish behavior within fast tidal currents is largely unstudied. Based at a tidal energy site in Cobscook Bay, Maine, this work sought to describe fish reactions to a tidal energy device, to understand the natural presence of fish at the site, and to provide guidance for future monitoring of tidal energy device effects in these difficult environments. A bottom-mounted echosounder was used to monitor the behavior of fish 7-18 m away from a stationary MHK device for several weeks. Fish moved with the current, but those approaching the device showed signs of avoiding it by adjusting their direction. The same echosounder was used to collect a two-year record of hourly fish passage rate at the depth of the turbine, after it had been removed. Fish passage rate, and therefore potential encounter rate with the turbine, changed dramatically over time with the dominant environmental patterns (tidal, daily, lunar, and seasonal cycles). By timing surveys of fish abundance at tidal energy sites with these cycles (e.g., carrying out 24-hr surveys at the same lunar stage throughout the year), the quality of results can be improved. Using this approach at tidal energy sites could therefore increase our ability to detect device effects without requiring expensive continuous sampling over a long time. Monitoring costs may be further reduced by using single beam echosounders, rather than the typical split beam systems, as statistical methods (deconvolution) were found to make certain single beam data comparable to that from the split beam. Depending on monitoring goals, the use of single beam echosounders could substantially reduce costs while supplying sufficient information on device effects for use in management decisions. Results from Cobscook Bay are likely to be useful at other tidal energy sites, but study designs and results need to be considered in the context of fish species and life stages present.","author":["Viehman, H."],"organization":["University of Maine"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.909800000000","-67.045630000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2431","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/interactions-aquatic-animals-orpc-ocgen-cobscook-bay-maine-monitoring-behavior-change","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.osti.gov\/scitech\/biblio\/1332311","title":"Interactions of Aquatic Animals with the ORPC OCGen in Cobscook Bay, Maine: Monitoring Behavior Change and Assessing the Probability of Encounter with a Deployed MHK Device","description":"Commercial viability of the marine hydrokinetic (MHK) energy industry is contingent on numerous and diverse factors. A major factor is the effects deployed devices have on animals. This factor is multi-faceted since it is dependent on the availability of appropriate scientific approaches to detect these effects. One of the animal groups with overlapping distributions of MHK devices are fishes. As such, individual fish behavior is likely to be influenced by the presence and operation of MHK devices. Depending on the scale of deployment there are implications for changes to essential fish habitat and effects that can be explored during deployment of a single device yet most changes are likely to be realized when multiple devices are deployed over large areas. It is not only important to document these effects and examine the need for mitigation, but also determine whether the methods involved can be used within the economic constraints of this nascent industry. The results presented in this report benefit the MHK industry by providing transferrable environmental monitoring approaches for MHK projects, specifically related to the interactions between static and dynamic tidal turbines and fish. In addition, some of the data can be used to generalize conditions (e.g., the temporal periodicity of fish presence in tidal regions and probability of fish encountering a device) at other MHK sites with similar physical conditions and fish assemblages. Ocean Renewable Power Company, LLC (ORPC) deployed and tested a prototype OCGen\u00ae tidal module in Cobscook Bay, Maine, in the summer of 2014. University of Maine researchers proposed an approach to inform other researchers, regulators, and industry members of the effects of this deployment on fish. While the approach was specifically applied to the OCGen\u00ae module, results are applicable to other pilot projects and inform future array deployments. Research funded under this grant allowed us to quantify fish presence as well as individual and group-level behavior changes in the presence of the deployed OCGen\u00ae module along with a bottom support frame from a previously deployed device (TidGen\u00ae). Specific objectives associated with fish behavior changes were (1) continuation of two long-term datasets: (a) stationary down-looking hydroacoustic dataset near an MHK device (group-level) and (b) stationary side-looking hydroacoustics near the bottom-support frame of a previously deployed MHK device (individual-level); (2) application of new processing methods to down-looking hydroacoustic datasets to improve fish species identification (group-level); and (3) development of an encounter probability model using data on fish abundance, vertical distribution, and behavior.","author":["Viehman, H.","Zydlewski, G.","Staines, G.","Shen, H.","Altenritter, M."],"organization":["Ocean Renewable Power Company (ORPC)","University of Maine"],"originationDate":"2016-10-19","spatial":{"coordinates":["44.909800000000","-67.045630000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Collision","Habitat Change","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2026-07-22 03:57:34","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Zydlewiski-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2432","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/fatalities-wind-turbines-may-threaten-population-viability-migratory-bat","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0006320716310485","title":"Fatalities at Wind Turbines may Threaten Population Viability of a Migratory Bat","description":"Large numbers of migratory bats are killed every year at wind energy facilities. However, population-level impacts are unknown as we lack basic demographic information about these species. We investigated whether fatalities at wind turbines could impact population viability of migratory bats, focusing on the hoary bat (Lasiurus cinereus), the species most frequently killed by turbines in North America. Using expert elicitation and population projection models, we show that mortality from wind turbines may drastically reduce population size and increase the risk of extinction. For example, the hoary bat population could decline by as much as 90% in the next 50\u00a0years if the initial population size is near 2.5 million bats and annual population growth rate is similar to rates estimated for other bat species (\u03bb\u00a0=\u00a01.01). Our results suggest that wind energy development may pose a substantial threat to migratory bats in North America. If viable populations are to be sustained, conservation measures to reduce mortality from turbine collisions likely need to be initiated soon. Our findings inform policy decisions regarding preventing or mitigating impacts of energy infrastructure development on wildlife.","author":["Baerwald, E.","Barclay, R.","Loeb, S.","McGuire, L.","Weller, T.","Russell, A.","Medellin, R.","Frick, W.","Pollock, J.","Szymanski, J."],"organization":["American Wind Wildlife Institute (AWWI)","Bat Conservation International","Grand Valley State University","Texas Tech University","Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico","University of Calgary","University of California Santa Cruz","US Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS)","US Forest Service"],"originationDate":"2017-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2433","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/current-ability-assess-impacts-electromagnetic-fields-associated-marine-hydrokinetic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.boem.gov\/2015-042\/","title":"Current Ability to Assess Impacts of Electromagnetic Fields Associated with Marine and Hydrokinetic Technologies on Marine Fishes in Hawaii","description":"Marine and hydrokinetic energy (MHK) and offshore wind devices are being developed and deployed in U.S. and international waters. Electric current flowing through subsea transmission cables associated with these devices will generate electromagnetic fields (EMF), which may interact with, and potentially impact, marine fishes. Some marine fishes can detect electric and\/or magnetic fields and use them to navigate, orientate, and sense prey, mates and predators. Over the past five years there have been multiple comprehensive reviews and studies evaluating the potential vulnerability of marine fishes to EMF produced by MHK devices. Most documented effects involve sub-lethal behavioral responses of individual fish when in close proximity to EMF (e.g., fish being repelled by or attracted to fields). These reviews reach conclusions that the current state of research on this topic is still in its infancy and evaluations of potential impacts are associated with great uncertainty. A variety of MHK technologies are likely to be considered for deployment offshore of the Hawaiian Islands, and there is a need to be able to better predict and assess potential associated environmental impacts. The goal of this study was to provide a complementary piece to these previous reviews (e.g., Normandeau et al. 2011) by focusing on marine fish species in the Hawaii region. We compiled the relevant available information, then prioritized fish species as candidates for various paths of future research. To address this, we first developed a list of Hawaii Region Focal Species, which included fishes that are more likely to be sensitive to EMF. We then compiled species-specific information available in the literature on their sensitivity to EMF, as well as life history, movement and habitat use information that could inform an analysis of their likelihood of encountering EMF from subsea cables associated with MHK devices. Studies have only documented EMF sensitivity in 11 of the marine fish species in this region. There was also relatively little detailed information on fish movement and habitat use patterns for most of the focal species. Our last objective was to develop recommendations for research needs to close the important knowledge gaps. We describe species-independent baseline research that primarily consists of in situ quantification of EMF generated by MHK devices and undersea cables that can occur as pilot and commercial scale MHK devices are deployed in Hawaii. Then we propose a simple approach for prioritizing Hawaii Region Focal Species (ranked relative to each other) as candidates in multiple related research paths. The prioritization approach incorporates EMF sensitivity information with the likelihood of interacting with EMF generated undersea transmission cables associated with MHK devices. Finally, we discuss the types of research needed to help fill gaps in the scientific knowledge base for this region. These involve studies to better define species-specific EMF sensitivity thresholds under various environmental conditions, studies of life history, movement and habitat use patterns to improve our understanding of the likelihood and frequency fishes may be in the vicinity of EMF generated by subsea transmission cables, and studies of the potential for related population, community or ecosystem impacts. Many of these studies can and should occur opportunistically as pilot and commercial scale MHK devices are deployed in Hawaii.","author":["Pondella, D.","Claisse, J.","Zahn, L.","Williams, C.","Williams, J."],"organization":["Vantuna Research Group","Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM)"],"originationDate":"2015-09-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Vantuna-Final-Report-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2434","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-appraisal-ea-argyll-tidal-demonstrator-project","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.esru.strath.ac.uk\/EandE\/Web_sites\/13-14\/Tidal\/environmental.html","title":"Environmental Appraisal (EA) for the Argyll Tidal Demonstrator Project","description":"In October 2011, Argyll Tidal Limited (ATL) (\u201cthe Applicant\u201d) entered in to an Agreement for Lease with The Crown Estate under Section 3 of the Crown Estate Act 1961. This agreement initiated the investigation of the potential for development of a demonstration tidal energy array of up to 3 MW scale (\u201cthe Development\u201d) to be located in the North Channel off the western coast of the Mull of Kintyre, Argyll and Bute, Scotland (\u201cthe Development Site\u201d).  ATL is working with Nautricity Limited (NL), a Scottish developer of tidal generation technology. NL has developed the 500 kW CoRMaT device. It was originally proposed that up to 6 of these devices would be deployed at the Development Site subject to the appropriate consents and licences being granted. Consent to construct and operate the Development would fall under Section 36 of the Electricity Act 1989 and a Marine Licence would also be required under the Marine Scotland Act 2010.","author":["Argyll Tidal Limited"],"organization":["Argyll Tidal Limited (ATL)"],"originationDate":"2013-12-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-03 11:43:29","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Nautricity-EA-2013.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2435","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/geomorphological-analogues-large-estuarine-engineering-projects-case-study-barrages","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569112001196","title":"Geomorphological Analogues for Large Estuarine Engineering Projects: A Case Study of Barrages, Causeways and Tidal Energy Projects","description":"Two conceptual models have been proposed to predict the response of sediment-laden estuaries to reduced tidal propagation caused by tidal barrages. One argues that reduced tidal energy will increase inter-tidal sedimentation; the other suggests that reduced tidal propagation will trigger a period of erosion before accretion of inter-tidal resumes. This paper investigates the relevance of sills across UK estuaries and causeways and barriers across estuaries in the Bay of Fundy (Nova Scotia, Canada) as possible analogues. Particular attention is paid to the tidal power barrage at Annapolis Royal because it exhibits important features that provide the underpinning evidence for morphological responses within tidal power headponds.\n\nThe construction of the tidal power plant at Annapolis Royal involved retro-fitting a tidal turbine and re-establishment of tidal influences into a headpond which had been maintained at a relatively constant level for some 24 years previously. The sequence of events at Annapolis Royal shows that headponds behave like river reservoirs, with bank erosion where sediments are weakly consolidated. It also demonstrates how resumption of tidal propagation can accelerate bank erosion; a process that is closely linked to wind-driven wave energy and the establishment of a foreshore profile that is better fitted to this energy regime. This model is very important both in the context of new tidal energy barrages and also for projects to retro-fit turbines into existing causeways. It reinforces the evidence from the Eastern Schelde in The Netherlands where it has been found that reduced tidal propagation has had profound effects on foreshore evolution with serious loss of mudflats and former saltmarshes. Annapolis Royal not only highlights erosionary processes; it also provides initial indications of the timescales required for evolution of more stable inter-tidal profiles.\n\nThe evidence provided by these various examples has important implications for coastal managers. Firstly, they show how analogues can be used to develop a conceptual geomorphological model of possible responses to causeways, sills and barrages such as some of the options being considered for the Thames Estuary. In addition, they highlight issues that need to be taken into account when pre-project planning considers likely issues and long-term management implications.","author":["Morris, R."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2013-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2436","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/morphological-process-restored-estuary-downstream-tidal-barrier","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0964569117300315","title":"Morphological Process of a Restored Estuary Downstream of a Tidal Barrier","description":"Hydrodynamic and morphological processes become more complex with large spatial variations after tidal barrier building and estuary restoration. Using a process-based model, responses in the estuary to a two-phase restoration measure in the Shuanglong Estuary are investigated. Numerical modeling indicates that tide-asymmetry in the barraged estuary is the primary factor that determines responses of morphology. After partial absence of tidal flats (first-phase restoration), flood tide-asymmetry is switched to ebb tide-asymmetry in the lower unrestored reach. This induces lower estuary erosion via increased tidal prism, though it is enhanced in the upper widened-deepened restored reach leading to severe siltation. After full restoration (second-phase restoration), current velocities are significantly increased with reduced flood tide-asymmetry. A quantitative comparison of the impact of the cross-sectional profile to net sediment transport shows that a switch from flood-dominated estuary to ebb-dominated estuary can be caused by reshaping the tidal flat which may reduce flood tide-asymmetry. The sediment flushing efficiency after the estuary restoration is further investigated in different sluice discharges with regards to two floodgate operations. Low sluice discharge during ebb tides increases the sediment flushing efficiency, but continuous high sluice discharge contributes to significant improvement of sediment flushing capacity and reduction of flushing duration. We conclude to prevent the flushed sediment from re-deposition into the estuary, a larger flushing capacity discharge released in a short period is required after the second-phase restoration in the Shuanglong Estuary.","author":["Kuang, C.","Liang, H.","Gu, J.","Su, T.","Zhao, X.","Song, H.","Ma, Y.","Dong, Z."],"organization":["Florida Atlantic University","Shanghai Ocean University","Tongji University"],"originationDate":"2017-03-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Sediment Transport","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2437","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/introducing-ocean-energy-industries-busy-marine-environment","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032117301090","title":"Introducing Ocean Energy Industries to a Busy Marine Environment","description":"The immense energy potential of the oceans is being increasingly recognized the world over, at the same time the integrity of marine ecosystems is challenged by pressure from multiple human activities. For good reasons environmental licensing procedures are precautionary and new industries must declare their detrimental impacts and provide mitigation measures. New ocean energy industries target renewable energy sources thus, on a grand scale, partly mitigating climate change. However, on-site environmental impacts are yet to be established. In this review we compare ocean energy industries with a wide range of conventional, better understood, human activities and outline environmental risks and research priorities. Results show that ocean energy systems are thought to incur many pressures, some familiar and others with yet unknown effects. Particular uncertainties regard ocean thermal energy conversion (OTEC) and large fast-moving turbines. Ocean energy industries should not be considered in isolation because the significance of environmental impacts depend on the full spectra of human activities in each area. Marine spatial planning provides a platform for holistic assessments and may facilitate the establishment of ocean energy industries, as long as risk-related uncertainties are reduced.","author":["Gullstr\u00f6m, M.","Hammar, L.","Molander, S.","Dahlgren, T.","Asplund, M.","Goncalves, I."],"organization":["Chalmers University of Technology","Stockholm University","University of Gothenburg","University of Zurich"],"originationDate":"2017-07-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2438","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/social-acceptance-wind-energy-where-we-stand-path-ahead","sourceURL":"https:\/\/pure.qub.ac.uk\/portal\/files\/123202364\/Ellis_Ferraro_2016_JRC103743_Registered.pdf","title":"The Social Acceptance of Wind Energy: Where We Stand and the Path Ahead","description":"Social acceptance is a key challenge for the deployment of wind energy and could limit the overall wind resource we are able to exploit to meet climate change targets. Social acceptance can be influenced by a very wide range of factors, including project characteristics, perception of the distribution of costs and benefits, degree of public participation. Perceived impacts of projects on landscapes, property values, health and biodiversity also influence social acceptance. This complexity means that acceptance cannot be addressed through simple fixes such as community benefit funds or just more consultation, but we need a far more fundamental reform of how energy systems engage with communities and citizens.","author":["Ellis, G.","Ferraro, G."],"organization":["European Commission"],"originationDate":"2016-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Ellis-Ferraro-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2439","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/social-acceptance-social-acceptability-wind-energy-projects-towards-territorial","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.tandfonline.com\/doi\/abs\/10.1080\/09640568.2015.1133406","title":"From Social \u0027Acceptance\u0027 to Social \u0027Acceptability\u0027 of Wind Energy Projects: Towards a Territorial Perspective","description":"Social acceptance is central in many debates surrounding energy projects. Wind energy, in particular, has been described as a \u2018learning laboratory\u2019 in terms of social acceptance of energy projects. It has given way to a socio-technical paradox: the social dimension has become a factor of equal importance to technology in the wind farms implementation. Based on a literature review concerned with the social acceptance of wind energy, the paper seeks to demonstrate both the richness and the limits of the key concepts that inform the ongoing work of scholars. By doing so, we intend to emphasise the complex processes underneath in order to then elaborate a conceptual definition of social acceptability. Various modulations and limits that characterise current thinking are thus underlined. We then propose a grid analysis relying on a territorial perspective. It is structured around three levels that connect micro-social, meso-political and macro-economic processes.","author":["Fournis, Y.","Fotrin, M."],"organization":["University of Quebec"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Stakeholder Engagement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2440","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/benthic-fish-aggregation-inside-offshore-wind-farm-which-effects-trophic-web","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1470160X16304290","title":"Benthic and Fish Aggregation Inside an Offshore Wind Farm: Which Effects on the Trophic Web Functioning?","description":"As part of the energy transition, the French government is planning the construction of three offshore wind farms in Normandy (Bay of Seine and eastern part of the English Channel, north-western France) in the next years. These offshore wind farms will be integrated into an ecosystem already facing multiple anthropogenic disturbances such as maritime transport, fisheries, oyster and mussel farming, and sediment dredging. Currently no integrated, ecosystem-based study on the effects of the construction and exploitation of offshore wind farms exists, where biological approaches generally focused on the conservation of some valuable species or groups of species. Complementary trophic web modelling tools were applied to the Bay of Seine ecosystem (to the 50 km2 area covered by the wind farm) to analyse the potential impacts of benthos and fish aggregation caused by the introduction of additional hard substrates from the piles and the turbine scour protections. An Ecopath ecosystem model composed of 37 compartments, from phytoplankton to seabirds, was built to describe the situation \u201cbefore\u201d the construction of the wind farm. Then, an Ecosim projection over 30 years was performed after increasing the biomass of targeted benthic and fish compartments. Ecological Network Analysis (ENA) indices were calculated for the two periods, \u201cbefore\u201d and \u201cafter\u201d, to compare network functioning and the overall structural properties of the food web. Our main results showed (1) that the total ecosystem activity, the overall system omnivory (proportion of generalist feeders), and the recycling increased after the construction of the wind farm; (2) that higher trophic levels such as piscivorous fish species, marine mammals, and seabirds responded positively to the aggregation of biomass on piles and turbine scour protections; and (3) a change in keystone groups after the construction towards more structuring and dominant compartments. Nonetheless, these changes could be considered as limited impacts of the wind farm installation on this coastal trophic web structure and functioning.","author":["Degraer, S.","Wilhelmsson, D.","Dauvin, J.","Raoux, A.","Pezy, J.","Tecchio, S.","Niquil, N.","Lassalle, G.","Cachera, M.","Ernande, B.","Guen, C.","Haraldsson, M.","Granger\u00e9, K.","Le Loc\u0027h, F."],"organization":["Normandie Universit\u00e9","Royal Belgian Institute of Natural Sciences (RBINS)","Royal Swedish Academy of Science","Technop\u00f4le Brest-Iroise"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.075119000000","-0.858406000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Ecosystem Processes","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2441","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/recent-developments-ocean-energy-offshore-wind-financial-challenges-environmental","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-981-10-0471-1_50","title":"Recent Developments in Ocean Energy and Offshore Wind: Financial Challenges and Environmental Misconceptions","description":"The first generation of (pre-commercial) ocean energy devices emerged in 2008, but comparatively little practical commercial development has taken place in wave and tidal power since then. Currently offshore wind power is in a sense the only true commercial deployment of an ocean energy technology seeing wide-scale adoption. Recently, several developments related to tidal energy are taking place, though progress in wave power devices remains disappointing, with several companies facing financial difficulties. This paper presents a review of recent developments in ocean energy and discusses the financial challenges and environmental misconceptions regarding such technologies.","author":["Esteban, M.","Gasparatos, A.","Doll, C."],"organization":["University of Tokyo"],"originationDate":"2016-09-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2442","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sharing-information-environmental-effects-wind-energy-development-wren-hub","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_16","title":"Sharing Information on Environmental Effects of Wind Energy Development: WREN Hub","description":"As the need for clean low carbon renewable energy increases worldwide, wind energy is becoming established in many nations and is under consideration in many more. Technologies that make land-based and offshore wind feasible, and resource characterizations of available wind, have been developed to facilitate the advancement of the wind industry. However, there is a continuing need to also evaluate and better understand the legal and social acceptability associated with potential effects on the environment. Uncertainty about potential environmental effects continues to complicate and slow permitting (consenting) processes in many nations. Research and monitoring of wildlife interactions with wind turbines, towers, and transmission lines has been underway for decades. However, the results of those studies are not always readily available to all parties, complicating analyses of trends and inflection points in effects analyses. Sharing of available information on environmental effects of land-based and offshore wind energy development has the potential to inform siting and permitting\/consenting processes. WREN Hub is an online knowledge management system that seeks to collect, curate, and disseminate scientific information on potential effects of wind energy development. WREN Hub acts as a platform to bring together the wind energy community, providing a collaborative space and an unbiased information source for researchers, regulators, developers, and key stakeholders to pursue accurate predictions of potential effects of wind energy on wildlife, habitats, and ecosystem processes. In doing so, WREN Hub ensures that key scientific uncertainties are identified, tagged for strategic research inquiry, and translated into effective collaborative projects.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Copping, A.","Hanna, L.","Whiting, J."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2443","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/future-research-directions-reconcile-wind-turbine-wildlife-interactions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_15","title":"Future Research Directions to Reconcile Wind Turbine - Wildlife Interactions","description":"Concurrent with the development of wind energy, research activity on wind energy generation and wildlife has evolved significantly during the last decade. This chapter presents an overview of remaining key knowledge gaps, consequent future research directions and their significance for management and planning for wind energy generation. The impacts of wind farms on wildlife are generally site-, species- and season-specific and related management strategies and practices may differ considerably between countries. These differences acknowledge the need to consider potential wildlife impacts for each wind farm project. Still, the ecological mechanisms guiding species\u2019 responses and potential vulnerability to wind farms can be expected to be fundamental in nature. A more cohesive understanding of the causes, patterns, mechanisms, and consequences of animal movement decisions will thereby facilitate successful mitigation of impacts. This requires planning approaches that implement the mitigation hierarchy effectively to reduce risks to species of concern. At larger geographical scales, population-level and cumulative impacts of multiple wind farms (and other anthropogenic activity) need to be addressed. This requires longitudinal and multiple-site studies to identify species-specific traits that influence risk of mortality, notably from collision with wind turbines, disturbance or barrier effects. In addition, appropriate pre- and post-construction monitoring techniques must be utilized. Predictive modelling to forecast risk, while tackling spatio-temporal variability, can guide the mitigation of wildlife impacts at wind farms.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["H\u00fcppop, O.","K\u00f6ppel, J.","Gill, A.","Scheidat, M.","May, R.","Langston, R.","Reichenbach, M.","Voigt, C.","Portman, M.","Smallwood, S."],"organization":["ARSU GmbH","Berlin Institute of Technology","Cranfield University","IMARES - Wageningen UR","Leibniz Institute for Zoo and Wildlife Research (IZW)","Norwegian Institute for Nature Research (NINA)","Royal Society for the Protection of Birds (RSPB)","Technion Israel Institute for Technology"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2444","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-birds-germany-examples-current-knowledge-new-insights-remaining-gaps","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_14","title":"Wind Turbines and Birds in Germany - Examples of Current Knowledge, New Insights and Remaining Gaps","description":"The impacts of wind turbines on birds have been discussed in Germany for almost 25\u00a0years now. The current practices in the planning process for wind farms can be characterized as a mixture of scientifically based knowledge and precautionary assumptions. The basic principle of mitigating the impacts of wind farms on certain species of high conservation concern is to maintain a sufficient distance between wind turbines and breeding sites or important roosting areas. This paper uses examples of certain species of concern to illustrate the current knowledge and practice of mitigating impacts on birds in Germany. The results demonstrate that, in some cases, the impact is not as severe as originally assumed and that micrositing of turbines can be a powerful tool to minimize possible effects. In view of the growing number of wind turbines operating in Germany, the adequate assessment of cumulative impacts is a key issue. In addition, there is growing pressure to improve and demonstrate the effectiveness of mitigation measures. Future research should be focused on long-term effects and on population-level impacts.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Reichenbach, M."],"organization":["ARSU GmbH"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2445","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/introducing-new-avian-sensitivity-mapping-tool-support-siting-wind-farms-power-lines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_12","title":"Introducing a New Avian Sensitivity Mapping Tool to Support the Siting of Wind Farms and Power Lines in the Middle East and Northeast Africa","description":"The risk to certain soaring bird species posed by poorly-sited wind turbines and power lines is now well established, and badly planned operations can prove both environmentally and financially costly. Consequently, wind energy developers, governments and other stakeholder groups urgently need access to accurate ornithological information to better inform the planning process. This is particularly true in parts of the Middle East and Northeast Africa where a rapidly expanding wind energy sector coincides with a globally significant soaring bird migration route\u2014the Rift Valley\/Red Sea Flyway. Unfortunately, relevant data for this region has often been difficult to obtain and interpret. To address this problem, BirdLife International, working with its network of regional partners, has launched the Soaring Bird Sensitivity Mapping Tool, an online tool providing detailed information on the distribution of soaring bird species along the flyway. By providing and interpreting this information, it is hoped that the tool will become an essential instrument in the environmentally sound expansion of wind energy in the region.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Allinson, T."],"organization":["BirdLife International"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:18","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2446","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-farms-areas-high-ornithological-value-conflicts-solutions-challenges-case-thrace","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_11","title":"Wind Farms in Areas of High Ornithological Value - Conflicts, Solutions, Challenges: The Case of Thrace, Greece","description":"Thrace, in northeastern Greece, is a crucial habitat of European value for the survival of the continent\u2019s birds of prey, and it is also designated as a priority area for the development of wind farms. Consequently, it is a valuable case study for identifying the conditions under which common ground can be found. A proactive planning system grounded on sound research and analysis and robust environmental impact assessments will direct wind farm development to the most suitable locations. It will also reduce the negative impacts of wind farms and reduce the time and resources required for the approval of individual projects, while improving the reputation of the wind energy sector.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Kret, E.","Vasilakis, D.","Kafetzis, A.","Skartsi, D.","Christopoulou, I."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Raptors","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2447","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/challenges-addressing-wildlife-impacts-when-repowering-wind-energy-projects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_10","title":"The Challenges of Addressing Wildlife Impacts When Repowering Wind Energy Projects","description":"Industrial wind power expanded rapidly since the earliest projects, and with this rapid expansion came understanding of wind power\u2019s impacts on wildlife and how to measure and predict those impacts. Many of the earliest wind turbines began exceeding their operational lifespans \u003E10\u00a0years ago, spawning plans for repowering with modern turbines. All wind turbines eventually wear out. Repowering can replace old turbines that have deteriorated to capacity factors as low as 4\u201312% with new wind turbines with capacity factors of 30\u201338%, and possibly sometimes better. At the same rated capacity, a repowered project can double and triple the energy generated from the project while reducing avian fatality rates by 60\u201390% when the new turbines are carefully sited. On the other hand, the grading needed for wider roads and larger pads can harm terrestrial biota, and can alter the ways that birds fly over the landscape. Larger turbines are usually mounted on taller towers, so the rotor-swept plane reaches higher into the sky and can kill species of birds and bats that were previously at lower risk. Slower cut-in speeds might increase bat fatalities, and faster cut-out speeds might increase bird fatalities. Repowering poses special problems to fatality monitoring and to estimating changes in collision rates. Differences in collision rate estimates before and after repowering can be due to climate or population cycles, changes in monitoring methods, and changes in wind turbine efficiency. Fatality monitoring could be more effective when it is (1) long-term, including when the older project was operating at peak efficiency, (2) executed experimentally, such as in a before-after, control-impact design, (3) largely consistent in methodology and otherwise adjusted for inconsistencies, and (4) sufficiently sampling the projects\u2019 installed capacity. Another challenge is overcoming public and regulator impatience over documented wildlife fatalities. Fatality monitoring before repowering necessarily reveals project impacts. Repowering can reduce those impacts, but this message needs to be delivered effectively to a public that might be skeptical after seeing the earlier impacts and will want to see trustworthy fatality predictions going forward. Accurately predicting impacts at repowered projects can be challenging because the often-used utilization survey has fared poorly at predicting impacts, and because flight patterns can shift in the face of larger wind turbines and an altered landscape.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Smallwood, K."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2448","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/there-state-art-reduce-pile-driving-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_9","title":"Is There a State-of-the-Art to Reduce Pile-Driving Noise?","description":"Underwater noise caused by pile-driving during the installation of offshore foundations is potentially harmful to marine life. In Germany, the regulation authority BSH set the following protection values: Sound Exposure Level SEL\u00a0=\u00a0160\u00a0dB and Peak Level LPeak\u00a0=\u00a0190\u00a0dB for Harbor Porpoises that must be complied with at a distance of 750\u00a0m to the construction site in order to avoid temporal threshold shifts. The experience over the last years shows that underwater sound produced during pile-driving, depending on many parameters and measurements, shows values of up to 180\u00a0dBSEL and up to 205\u00a0dBLPeak in a distance of 750\u00a0m. Therefore, Noise Mitigation Systems (NMS) are required to significantly minimize the underwater sound. Since 2011, NMS must be applied during all noisy offshore construction work in Germany. The Institute of Technical and Applied Physics GmbH (itap) was involved in many offshore wind farm (OWF) projects with pile-driving activities (\u003E1000 pile installations without and with different NMS). Based on these underwater noise measurements, the tested NMS were evaluated. In this paper, a general overview of existing and tested NMS including tested system variations is provided and the measured data and influencing factors on the resulting noise reduction are discussed. Additionally, combinations of two or more NMS are measured during the construction phase, if monopiles with diameters of up to 8\u00a0m are installed. It is demonstrated what level of effect one or more NMS have on the emitted noise. However, it is shown that it is possible to install monopiles with a diameter of \u003E6\u00a0m with noise levels below 160\u00a0dBSEL at a distance of 750\u00a0m,\u00a0if combinations of suitable NMS are used. Nevertheless, any kind of noise mitigation will have a significant influence on the \u2018disturbed\u2019 or treated area from pile-driving noise for marine mammals. The question of whether a state-of-the-art measure to reduce pile-driving noise exists will be explored, based on measured data and experiences with NMS under real offshore conditions.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Bellmann, M.","Schuckenbrock, J.","G\u00fcndert, S.","M\u00fcller, M.","Holst, H.","Remmers, P."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2449","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/mitigating-bat-mortality-turbine-specific-curtailment-algorithms-model-based-approach","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_8","title":"Mitigating Bat Mortality with Turbine-Specific Curtailment Algorithms: A Model Based Approach","description":"Alarmingly high numbers of bats are being killed at wind turbines worldwide, raising concerns about the cumulative effects of bat mortality on bat populations. Mitigation measures to effectively reduce bat mortality at wind turbines while maximising energy production are of paramount importance. Operational mitigation (i.e. feathering wind turbine rotors at times of high collision risk for bats) is currently the only strategy that has been shown to substantially reduce bat mortality. This study presents a model based approach for developing curtailment algorithms that account for differences in bat activity over the year and night-time and are specific to the activity level at a certain wind turbine. The results show that easily measurable variables (wind speed, month, time of night) can predict times of higher bat activity with a high temporal resolution. A recently published collision model that was developed based on an excessive carcass search study is then applied to predict bat collision rate based on the modelled bat activity. Using the ratio of wind energy revenue and collision rate, 10\u00a0min intervals were weighted, so that turbines are stopped when collision rate is high and loss in revenue is low. A threshold of two dead bats per year and turbine resulted in a mean loss in annual revenue of 1.4%. The presented approach of acoustic monitoring at the nacelle and turbine specific curtailment has become the standard method to mitigate collision risk of bats at wind turbines in Germany.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Korner-Nievergelt, F.","Brinkmann, R.","Niermann, I.","Behr, O.","Nagy, M.","Reich, M.","Simon, R.","Hochradel, K.","Mages, J.","Weber, N."],"organization":["Friedrich Alexander Universit\u00e4t Erlangen N\u00fcrnberg","Leibniz Universit\u00e4t Hannover","Oikostat GmbH","Swiss Ornithological Institute"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2450","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/radar-assisted-shutdown-demand-ensures-zero-soaring-bird-mortality-wind-farm-located","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_7","title":"Radar Assisted Shutdown on Demand Ensures Zero Soaring Bird Mortality at a Wind Farm Located in a Migratory Flyway","description":"Wind energy is considered a clean energy source, but produces negative impacts regarding avian mortality. The Bar\u00e3o de S\u00e3o Jo\u00e3o wind farm in Portugal\u2019s Sagres region is part of an important migratory flyway, crossed by 5000 individuals of 30 soaring bird species every autumn. The wind farm\u2019s licensing was conditioned to the implementation of rigorous mitigation procedures, namely a Radar Assisted Shutdown on Demand (RASOD) protocol to reduce the probability of bird casualties. A security perimeter with observers was aided by a radar system, detecting soaring birds approaching the wind farm. Turbines were to be turned-off when pre-defined criteria of intense migration or presence of threatened species were met. Turbine shutdown was operated by the wind farm staff after a request from the monitoring team (MT), or directly by the MT. Of the soaring birds crossing the wind farm, 55% were recorded at altitudes associated with high collision risk. However, due to RASOD, no soaring birds died from collisions during five consecutive autumns. The average annual shutdown period decreased continuously after the first year (105\u00a0h) reaching only 15\u00a0h when the MT was given direct access to shut down operations through SCADA (the remote system to monitor and control wind turbines). Shutdown period corresponded only to 0.2\u20131.2% of the equivalent hours in a year\u2019s wind farm activity. The use of radar, direct access to SCADA and cumulative experience by the MT improved the procedure\u2019s efficiency, allowing better judgments on the application of shutdown orders. Our results indicate that RASOD may be an essential tool in reconciling wind energy production with the conservation of soaring birds.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Repas, M.","Tom\u00e9, R.","Can\u00e1rio, F.","Leit\u00e3o, A.","Pires, N."],"organization":["STRIX"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2451","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bird-mortality-two-dutch-wind-farms-effects-location-spatial-design-interactions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_6","title":"Bird Mortality in Two Dutch Wind Farms: Effects of Location, Spatial Design and Interactions with Powerlines","description":"Numerous field studies have assessed bird mortality rates in wind farms. However, results from different studies are often hard to compare due to differences in methodology. This makes it very difficult to draw conclusions and to use the results in the planning phase of new wind farms (e.g. how to mitigate impacts). In this study, it was attempted to assess how bird mortality rates are affected by (1) the location of the wind farm, (2) the spatial layout of the turbines, (3) the surrounding terrain and (4) the presence of other obstacles such as powerlines. This study involved the monitoring of 91 turbines in two contrasting wind farms in the Netherlands for five years. It used the same standardized search methodology, including experimental trials for carcass removal and search efficiency. The sites differ in location (coastal vs. inland), spatial layout, turbine dimensions, land use, bird community and flight intensity of birds. In addition, at one site powerlines were constructed halfway through the monitoring program. Any fatalities from these powerlines were also monitored in a separate monitoring program. This enabled a comparison of any differences in mortality rates or species composition between the turbine and powerline fatalities. The results show a major impact of turbine location on the number of bird fatalities, both within the same wind farm and between wind farms. Mortality rates at the coastal wind farm were three to five times higher than at the inland wind farm. By far the highest mortality rates were found at turbines close to high-tide roosts and at points where (during spring migration) migrating birds leave the coastline to cross the sea towards Germany or Scandinavia. At these turbines, mortality rates could rise up to several hundred of birds per turbine per year. When expressed in fatalities per ha, overall fatality rates of the powerlines were three times higher than of the turbines in the same area. This may be due to low visibility of the powerlines compared to wind turbines. Comparison of turbine versus powerline fatalities also showed major differences in species composition, with powerline fatalities mostly consisting of passerines and waterfowl, and turbine fatalities being dominated by gulls. As several new wind farms are planned to be realized in the coming years, the results of this study can be used in spatial planning to both assess and mitigate potential impacts.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Brenninkmeijer, A.","Klop, E."],"organization":["Altenburg \u0026 Wymenga"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision","Habitat Change","Attraction","Avoidance","Displacement"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2452","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/bat-activity-nacelle-height-over-forest","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_5","title":"Bat Activity at Nacelle Height Over Forest","description":"The number of wind power facilities (wind farms) has rapidly increased in Germany, with a number of these constructed in forested areas. As most bat species use forests to forage and roost, concerns have been raised in relation to the potentially higher collision risk with wind turbines in forests than in open landscapes. In addition, the standard curtailment algorithms used in open landscapes might not be appropriate in forests. An ample acoustic dataset derived from 193 nacelle height surveys of 130 individual turbines was used to investigate whether bat activity, phenology or species composition differ between forests and open landscapes. The data showed no significant differences between bats in forests and open landscape habitats, but revealed strong regional differences. Overall bat activity increases towards the east of Germany, which is mirrored by an increase of the dominant group of Nyctaloids, whereas the activity of common pipistrelles increases towards the south. These findings suggest that acoustic surveys must be interpreted on a regional and species-specific level. In summary, wind farms within forested areas do not seem not to inherently show higher bat activity at nacelle height, suggesting no increased collision risk for bats in general. However, future studies assessing bat activity at the lowest point of the rotor instead of at nacelle height are urgently needed, as well as studies that include additional variables such as proximity to bat roosts or the age of a forest.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Brinkmann, R.","Reers, H.","Hartmann, S.","Hurst, J."],"organization":["Freiburg\u0027s Institute of Applied Animal Ecology"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2453","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/method-assess-population-level-consequences-wind-energy-facilities-bird-bat-species","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_4","title":"A Method to Assess the Population-Level Consequences of Wind Energy Facilities on Bird and Bat Species","description":"For this study, a methodology was developed for assessing impacts of wind energy generation on populations of birds and bats at regional to national scales. The approach combines existing methods in applied ecology for prioritizing species in terms of their potential risk from wind energy facilities and estimating impacts of fatalities on population status and trend caused by collisions with wind energy infrastructure. Methods include a qualitative prioritization approach, demographic models, and potential biological removal. The approach can be used to prioritize species in need of more thorough study as well as to identify species with minimal risk. However, the components of this methodology require simplifying assumptions and the data required may be unavailable or of poor quality for some species. These issues should be carefully considered before using the methodology. The approach will increase in value as more data become available and will broaden the understanding of anthropogenic sources of mortality on bird and bat populations.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Johnson, D.","Heist, K.","Loss, S.","Thogmartin, W.","Diffendorfer, J.","Beston, J.","Merrill, M.","Stanton, J.","Corum, M.","Erickson, R."],"organization":["Oklahoma State University","University of Minnesota","US Geological Survey (USGS)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2454","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/large-scale-multispecies-assessment-avian-mortality-rates-land-based-wind-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_3","title":"A Large-Scale, Multispecies Assessment of Avian Mortality Rates at Land-Based Wind Turbines in Northern Germany","description":"Collisions of birds with wind turbines are a focal point when discussing the implications of renewable energies on nature conservation. The project \u201cPrognosis and assessment of collision risks of birds at wind turbines in northern Germany\u201d (PROGRESS) focused on the extent and consequences of bird mortality at wind turbines. Collision victims were searched in five search efforts from spring 2012 to spring 2014 (three spring and two autumn field searches of 12\u00a0weeks). 46 different wind farms were examined. The total searched transect length amounted to 7672\u00a0km. With a total of 291 birds found, an average of one bird was found every 27\u00a0km. Common bird species with habitat use (feeding and staging) of the wind farm area prevail the list of fatalities found. Birds of prey did not dominate the list. Nocturnal broad front migratory songbirds (especially thrush species) were hardly represented among the fatalities. The total number of fatalities was estimated incorporating search efficiency and carcass removal experiments. An extrapolation of the results for the entire project area leads to an annual mortality of around 8500 Common buzzards, 11,300 Wood pigeons and 13,000 Mallards. Based on the breeding population in the project area this translates to 0.5% of Wood pigeons, 5.0% of Mallards and 7% of Common buzzards (assuming 50% floaters). Results of vantage point watches indicate that the species-specific collision risk with wind turbines largely differs between species as a result of clear behavioural differences. For the vast majority of wind farms the numbers of collision victims predicted by the Band-model were clearly below the number of collision victims estimated from carcass searches. The suitability of the Band-model for the evaluation of an anticipated collision risk for a planned wind farm at an \u2018average\u2019 onshore site is limited. Four modelled populations of Common buzzard in northern Germany are predicted to decline when incorporating the median estimates of additional mortality derived from fatality estimates. Statutory species protection conflicts might not always be adequately solvable for an individual project. Therefore, overarching solutions are required to accompany the further expansion of wind farms, which ensure that this does not lead to a severe decline of certain bird species that are particularly affected by collisions. Specifically, the following strategies need to be addressed:\n\nLarge-scale wildlife conservation programs e.g. for Red kites and Common buzzards that improve habitats, particularly in terms of food availability\n\n\nIdentification of species-specific density centres that are of particular importance as source populations, and assessing targeted measures to protect and promote them,\n\n\nDevelopment of concepts and practical testing of a post-construction species protection support in terms of their effectiveness and their economic effects.\n\n\nIncreased research efforts in terms of scale and addressing cumulative effects.\n\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Nehls, G.","Blew, J.","Reichenbach, M.","Kruger, O.","Grunkorn, T.","von Ronn, J.","Weitekamp, S.","Timmermann, H.","Potiek, A."],"organization":["ARSU GmbH","Bielefeld University","BioConsult SH"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2455","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/unforeseen-responses-breeding-seabird-construction-offshore-wind-farm","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_2","title":"Unforeseen Responses of a Breeding Seabird to the Construction of an Offshore Wind Farm","description":"Sheringham Shoal Offshore Wind Farm (OWF), comprised of 88 3.6\u00a0MW turbines, was built within foraging range of Sandwich Tern Thalasseus sandvicensis breeding at a European designated site. Boat-based surveys (n\u00a0=\u00a043) were used to investigate changes in tern abundance within the site and within 0\u20132 and 2\u20134\u00a0km buffer areas before and throughout the construction of the OWF, over a study period between 2009 and 2012. Visual tracking of individual birds (n\u00a0=\u00a0840) was also undertaken to document any changes in behaviour. This study is amongst the few to detail the response of a breeding seabird to the construction of an OWF. Navigational buoys in the 0\u20132\u00a0km buffer were used extensively by resting and socialising birds, especially early in the breeding season. Visual tracking illustrated avoidance of areas of construction activity and birds surprisingly kept their distance from installed monopiles. Avoidance was strengthened during turbine assembly, with around 30% fewer birds entering the wind farm, relative to the pre-construction baseline. Flight lines of birds that entered the site were generally along the centre of rows between turbines. A focus on transit flight meant that feeding activity was lower in the site than the buffer areas. As the site remained permeable to terns flying to and from foraging grounds further offshore, the overall abundance within the site was not significantly reduced. Although a number of the responses observed were unforeseen by Environmental Impact Assessment, the overall conclusion of only minor adverse effects was upheld. Analysis of further data from the operational site is now planned.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Perrow, M.","Skeate, E.","Tomlinson, M.","Harwood, A.","Berridge, R."],"organization":["ECON Ecological Consultancy"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Habitat Change","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:20","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2456","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/red-kites-wind-farms-telemetry-data-core-breeding-range","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_1","title":"Red Kites and Wind Farms - Telemetry Data from the Core Breeding Range","description":"Red Kites (Milvus milvus) are the second most often reported species in relation to collisions with wind turbines in Germany. Germany houses more than half of the world\u2019s population of Red Kites and, therefore, has a high international responsibility for the protection of this species. The German Federal Ministry of the Environment, Nature Conservation and Nuclear Safety funded a field study to investigate why Red Kites and other birds of prey frequently collide with wind turbines, and which risk mitigation measures are most appropriate. The study took place in the core of the Red Kite global breeding range in Sachsen-Anhalt between 2007 and 2010. Ten breeding adult Red Kites were equipped with radio tags (seven birds) or GPS satellite transmitters (three birds). Each bird was tracked for one or two breeding and non-breeding seasons. Data on flight height and habitat preference were collected by visual observations. The collision risk was modeled in relation to the nest\u2019s proximity to wind turbines. It was found that Red Kites spent most of their time close to their nests. Most (54%) of the fixes were located within a radius of 1000\u00a0m around nests. It is important to note that the data did not indicate displacement of Red Kites by wind farms. Red Kites frequently visited wind farms for foraging and spent about 25% of their flight time within the swept heights of rotors of the most common wind turbines present in the study sites. The probability of closely approaching a wind farm significantly decreased with the distance between wind turbines and nests. Furthermore, the collision probability model predicted a sharp decrease of collision risk with increasing distance from the nest. The results clearly indicate that implementing buffer zones around nest sites reduces collision risk.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["H\u00f6tker, H.","Mammen, U.","Mammen, K.","Rasran, L."],"organization":["Nature and Biodiversity Conservation Union (NABU)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Passerines","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2457","type":["Document","Document\/Book"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-energy-wildlife-interactions","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/book\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3","title":"Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions","description":"This book presents a selection of new insights in understanding and mitigating impacts on wildlife and their habitats. Topics such as, species behaviour and responses; collision risk and fatality estimation; landscape features and gradients, are considered. Other chapters in the book cover the results of current research on mitigation; compensation; effectiveness of measures; monitoring and long-term effects; planning and siting. Examples are given of current research on shutdown on demand and curtailment algorithms. By identifying what we have learned so far, and which predominate uncertainties and gaps remain for future research, this book contributes to the most up to date knowledge on research and management options. This book includes presentations from the Conference on Wind Energy and Wildlife impacts (CWW15), March 2015, hosted by the Berlin Institute of Technology, which offered a platform to national and international participants to showcase the current state of knowledge in wind energy\u2019s wildlife implications.\n\nTable of Contents\n\n\n Red Kites and Wind Farms\u2014Telemetry Data from the Core Breeding Range\n Unforeseen Responses of a Breeding Seabird to the Construction of an Offshore Wind Farm\n A Large-Scale, Multispecies Assessment of Avian Mortality Rates at Land-Based Wind Turbines in Northern Germany\n A Method to Assess the Population-Level Consequences of Wind Energy Facilities on Bird and Bat Species\n Bat Activity at Nacelle Height Over Forest\n Bird Mortality in Two Dutch Wind Farms: Effects of Location, Spatial Design and Interactions with Powerlines\n Radar Assisted Shutdown on Demand Ensures Zero Soaring Bird Mortality at a Wind Farm Located in a Migratory Flyway\n Mitigating Bat Mortality with Turbine-Specific Curtailment Algorithms: A Model Based Approach\n Is There a State-of-the-Art to Reduce Pile-Driving Noise?\n The Challenges of Addressing Wildlife Impacts When Repowering Wind Energy Projects\n Wind Farms in Areas of High Ornithological Value\u2014Conflicts, Solutions, Challenges: The Case of Thrace, Greece\n Introducing a New Avian Sensitivity Mapping Tool to Support the Siting of Wind Farms and Power Lines in the Middle East and Northeast Africa\n A Framework for Assessing Ecological and Cumulative Effects (FAECE) of Offshore Wind Farms on Birds, Bats and Marine Mammals in the Southern North Sea\n Wind Turbines and Birds in Germany\u2014Examples of Current Knowledge, New Insights and Remaining Gaps\n Future Research Directions to Reconcile Wind Turbine\u2013Wildlife Interactions\n Sharing Information on Environmental Effects of Wind Energy Development: WREN Hub","author":["K\u00f6ppel, J."],"organization":["Berlin Institute of Technology"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-29 10:00:03","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2458","type":["Document","Document\/Book Chapter"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/framework-assessing-ecological-cumulative-effects-faece-offshore-wind-farms-birds-bats","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/chapter\/10.1007\/978-3-319-51272-3_13","title":"A Framework for Assessing Ecological and Cumulative Effects (FAECE) of Offshore Wind Farms on Birds, Bats and Marine Mammals in the Southern North Sea","description":"The European Union\u2019s Birds and Habitats Directives and Marine Strategy Framework Directive demand that the proponent describes and assesses the potential cumulative effects on wildlife in environmental impact assessment reports for proposed actions. Based upon the DPSIR (Driving forces, Pressures, States, Impacts, Responses) approach (European Environment Agency 1999), a 6-step framework for undertaking a cumulative impacts assessment was developed to address this requirement:\nIdentify the relevant pressures the envisaged activities could cause.\nIdentify the habitats and species that may be affected by these pressures.\nDescribe all other activities that could affect the same species.\nDescribe the nature and scale of the cumulative effects of all the activities selected in Step 3 on the selected habitats and species.\nEvaluate the significance of the effects on the selected habitats and species.\nIf necessary, adapt the activity by taking measures to prevent the activity from causing significant effects.\nThe first application of this approach was carried out for the initiative of the Dutch Social Economic Council, the Energy Agreement for Sustainable Growth (2013). The agreement proposed an offshore wind capacity of 4500\u00a0MW by 2030 for the Dutch part of the North Sea. The application of this cumulative impacts assessment framework showed that effective mitigation measures are required to achieve this agreement without endangering protected species and habitats, in line with European Union (EU) nature and environmental legislation. Mitigation measures can be implemented through conditions on permits for offshore wind farm projects, which include restrictions on the maximum underwater noise levels during construction, the minimum capacity of individual wind turbines, and measures to reduce bird and bat collisions and fatalities during seasons of major migration.\n\nThis is a chapter from Wind Energy and Wildlife Interactions.","author":["Platteeuw, M.","Bakker, J.","van den Bosch, I.","Erkman, A.","Graafland, M.","Lubbe, S.","Warnas, M."],"organization":["Ministry of Infrastructure and the Environment (Rijkswaterstaat)"],"originationDate":"2017-02-03","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2459","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessment-blue-carbon-resources-scotlands-inshore-marine-protected-area-network","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.nature.scot\/snh-commissioned-report-957-assessment-blue-carbon-resources-scotlands-inshore-marine-protected-area","title":"Assessment of Blue Carbon Resources in Scotland\u0027s Inshore Marine Protected Area Network","description":"In this study, the blue carbon resources in each Nature Conservation Marine Protected Area (NC MPA) and Special Area of Conservation (SAC) in Scotland\u2019s inshore waters are estimated from the i) contributions of biological material to fixation of carbon, also referred to as production, and ii) contributions of geological sediments to blue carbon storage, following on from shelf-wide estimates in an earlier study (Burrows et al. , 2014). The methodology has been developed here to allow local-scale estimation of habitat extent and provides estimates of blue carbon associated with habitats and surface sediments.\n\nMain Findings\nCombined, the SACs and NC MPAs (subsequently referred to as inshore MPAs) considered in this study cover 11 350 km2. Stocks of carbon within the habitats and surface sediments of inshore MPAs are estimated at 9.4 million tonnes (Mt) organic carbon and 47.8 Mt inorganic carbon; 1.6% of the estimated total of 592 Mt organic carbon (revised Burrows et al., (2014) value) and 2.7% of the total 1 739 Mt inorganic carbon across Scotland\u2019s seas.\nBlue carbon habitats in the inshore MPA network are estimated to produce 248 000 t organic carbon and 36 000 t inorganic carbon per year, while sediment stores in the inshore MPAs accumulate 126 000 t organic carbon and 348 000 t inorganic carbon per year. Blue carbon production by seabed habitats is estimated to represent 0.6% of the total organic carbon assimilated, or 14% of the total produced by attached plants (including maerl).\nSediment stores in inshore MPAs sequester 1.8% of total organic carbon across Scotland\u2019s seas. The estimate of the total amount of inorganic carbon production in inshore MPAs is less reliable but represents a much larger proportion of the total, than for organic carbon production. This is because of the focus of inshore MPAs on areas of carbonate production such as maerl beds and cold water coral reefs.\nThreats to organic carbon stores are from physical disturbance, moorings, coastal developments, and renewable energy) of the sea bed, causing breakdown of previously buried material. Ocean acidification may pose a threat to inorganic carbon in sediments stored as carbonate but the mechanisms whereby that threat may be realised are as yet unclear. Ocean acidification also may have a direct negative effect on the capacity of calcareous reef builders and maerl to build carbonate skeletons, but algae such as kelp may benefit through enhanced photosynthesis due to higher CO2 levels.\nThere are limitations in the estimates produced. Much of the information used in this assessment of blue carbon stocks is based on legacy data, some from older, published sources. Spatial extents of blue carbon habitats at the scales required for this report are poorly constrained. Finally, the science of understanding the effects of climate change on these systems is very much in its infancy and new developments will allow a much better informed outlook for the fate of these stocks and flows in a changing world. By establishing a methodology that integrates existing knowledge and understanding of blue carbon it should be possible to update reports such as this as new information emerges.\nThis report aims to provide a starting point and a methodology for the examination of blue carbon storage in an MPA network. It is clear throughout the report that there is paucity within the data set. Despite these difficulties, and the uncertainty around accurate values of estimates, the general conclusions are unlikely to change with more detailed information. Therefore, the authors believe that enough information exists to begin to make conclusions about the importance of blue carbon stocks in the marine environment, both within Scotland and globally if the methods used are employed elsewhere. Variable and limited data will be a common feature of MPA networks throughout the world. The methodology proposed allows conclusions to be made on incomplete data, providing the beginnings of a management tool to aid protection of blue carbon in the marine environment.","author":["Hughes, D.","Burrows, M.","Taylor, P.","Austin, W.","Smeaton, C.","Hicks, N.","Howe, J.","Allen, C.","Vare, L."],"organization":["Scottish Natural Heritage"],"originationDate":"2017-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Climate Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Burrows-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2460","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/experimental-measurement-wave-field-variations-around-wave-energy-converter-arrays","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.mdpi.com\/2071-1050\/9\/1\/70","title":"Experimental Measurement of Wave Field Variations around Wave Energy Converter Arrays","description":"Wave energy converters (WECs) inherently extract energy from incident waves. For wave energy to become a significant power provider in the future, large farms of WECs will be required. This scale of energy extraction will increase the potential for changes in the local wave field and coastal environment. Assessment of these effects is necessary to inform decisions on the layout of wave farms for optimum power output and minimum environmental impact, as well as on potential site selection. An experimental campaign to map, at high resolution, the wave field variation around arrays of 5 oscillating water column WECs and a methodology for extracting scattered and radiated waves is presented. The results highlight the importance of accounting for the full extent of the WEC behavior when assessing impacts on the wave field. The effect of radiated waves on the wave field is not immediately apparent when considering changes to the entire wave spectrum, nor when observing changes in wave climate due to scattered and radiated waves superimposed together. The results show that radiated waves may account for up to 50% of the effects on wave climate in the near field in particular operating conditions.","author":["Els\u00e4\u00dfer, B.","Whittaker, T.","O\u0027Boyle, L."],"organization":["Danish Hydraulic Institute (DHI)","Queen\u0027s University Belfast"],"originationDate":"2017-01-05","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/OBoyle-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2461","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/automatic-active-acoustic-target-detection-turbulent-aquatic-environments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/onlinelibrary.wiley.com\/doi\/10.1002\/lom3.10155\/abstract","title":"Automatic Active Acoustic Target Detection in Turbulent Aquatic Environments","description":"There is no established approach for dealing with the active acoustic detection of biological targets in highly dynamic aquatic environments where intense physical interference means that standard techniques are unsuitable. This is a particular problem in ecologically important environments with emerging industrial significance such as marine energy extraction sites. We developed an automatic processing method which allows effective target detection with high sensitivity throughout variable acoustic conditions. The method is based on scale-dependent adaptive filtering of data and morphological analysis of short-scale backscatter contributions for the exclusion of intense turbulent features and isolation of biological targets. Echosounder platform deployments around marine energy infrastructure in a tidal channel provide test data which demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach. Target validation and assessment is carried out by the analysis of multifrequency characteristics and direct inspection. The results deliver effective, quantitative, and repeatable assessment of ecological interactions and target distributions with clear implications for environmental assessment in high energy sites and promising applications in other contexts.","author":["Scott, B.","Williamson, B.","Fraser, S.","Nikora, V."],"organization":["University of Aberdeen"],"originationDate":"2017-02-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2462","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/multisensor-acoustic-tracking-fish-seabird-behavior-around-tidal-turbine-structures","sourceURL":"https:\/\/ieeexplore.ieee.org\/document\/7820138\/","title":"Multisensor Acoustic Tracking of Fish and Seabird Behavior Around Tidal Turbine Structures in Scotland","description":"Despite rapid development of marine renewable energy, relatively little is known of the immediate and future impacts on the surrounding ecosystems. Quantifying the behavior and distribution of animals around marine renewable energy devices is crucial for understanding, predicting, and potentially mitigating any threats posed by these installations. The Flow and Benthic Ecology 4D (FLOWBEC) autonomous seabed platform integrated an Imagenex multibeam echosounder and a Simrad EK60 multifrequency echosounder to monitor marine life in a 120\u2218 sector over ranges up to 50\u00a0m, seven to eight times per second. Established target detection algorithms fail within MRE sites, due to high levels of backscatter generated by the turbulent physical dynamics, limiting and biasing analysis to only periods of low current speed. This study presents novel algorithms to extract diving seabirds, fish, and fish schools from the intense backscatter caused by turbulent dynamics in flows of 4\u00a0m\u00a0s\u22121. Filtering, detection, and tracking using a modified nearest neighbor algorithm provide robust tracking of animal behavior using the multibeam echosounder. Independent multifrequency target detection is demonstrated using the EK60 with optimally calculated thresholds, scale-sensitive filters, morphological exclusion, and frequency-response characteristics. This provides sensitive and reliable detection throughout the entire water column and at all flow speeds. Dive profiles, depth preferences, predator\u2013prey interactions, and fish schooling behavior can be analyzed, in conjunction with the hydrodynamic impacts of marine renewable energy devices. Coregistration of targets between the acoustic instruments increases the information available, providing quantitative measures including frequency response from the EK60, and target morphology and behavioral interactions from the multibeam echosounder. The analyses draw on deployments at a tidal energy site in Scotland to compare the presence and absence of renewable energy structures across a range of physical and trophic levels over complete spring-neap tidal cycles. These results can be used to inform how animals forage in these sites and whether individuals face collision risks. This quantitative information can de-risk the licensing process and, with a greater mechanistic understanding at demonstration scales, its predictive power could reduce the monitoring required at future arrays.","author":["Blondel, P.","Waggitt, J.","Scott, B.","Williamson, B.","Bell, P.","Fraser, S."],"organization":["Bangor University","National Oceanography Centre (NOC)","University of Aberdeen","University of Bath"],"originationDate":"2017-10-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.892963000000","-1.395156000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds","Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Williamson-et-al-2017.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2463","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-information-sources-support-connectivity-assessments-under-habitats-regulations","sourceURL":"","title":"Review of Information Sources to Support Connectivity Assessments under the Habitats Regulations","description":"A working group was convened by The Crown Estate to focus on exploring routes to refine the consenting process for marine renewable energy sites under 3MW. One proposal considered the development of a tool to facilitate the assessment of connectivity between small marine renewable energy project sites and the features of designated European marine sites, or the \u2018Natura 2000\u2019 network. To clarify understanding of available tools, The Crown Estate commissioned a review of existing resources which could have the potential to contribute to the assessment of connectivity under the Habitats Regulations.  The following report documents the review process. Overall the review identified a comprehensive set of resources in the form of sensitivity analysis tools, interactive GIS databases, site information tools, guidance and policy documents, and reports. In total, twenty three resources (including two categories of clustered resources) were reviewed for their potential application in assessing connectivity.","author":["Carse, L."],"organization":["The Crown Estate","The Crown Estate"],"originationDate":"2016-11-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Connectivity_Tool_Review.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2464","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-risk-european-protected-species-bats-onshore-wind-turbine-sites-inform","sourceURL":"https:\/\/stopthesethings.files.wordpress.com\/2016\/09\/bat-windturbines-finalreportphase2.pdf","title":"Understanding the Risk of European Protected Species (Bats) at Onshore Wind Turbine Sites to Inform Risk Management","description":"Evidence that wind turbines potentially pose a collision threat to bats has been available from the USA and some European countries since the early 2000s. However the scale of any risk in the UK was unknown. The Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, Department of Energy and Climate Change, Natural Resources Wales, Scottish Natural Heritage, Natural England and RenewableUK therefore commissioned this research project in 2010. It is the first attempt, anywhere in the world, to assess the impact of wind turbines on bats at a national scale through the systematic survey of a representative sample of wind energy facilities.","author":["Mathews, F.","Hosken, D.","Lintott, P.","Richardson, S."],"organization":["University of Exeter","RenewableUK","UK Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)"],"originationDate":"2016-10-20","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Understanding_the_Risk_to_European_Protected_Species.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2465","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/maritime-route-delineation-using-ais-data-atlantic-coast-us","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.cambridge.org\/core\/journals\/journal-of-navigation\/article\/div-classtitlemaritime-route-delineation-using-ais-data-from-the-atlantic-coast-of-the-usdiv\/B722348B1541430B086EA181D88E272B","title":"Maritime Route Delineation using AIS Data from the Atlantic Coast of the US","description":"This study examines maritime routes between ports along the Atlantic coast of the US, utilising Automated Identification System (AIS) data for the years 2010 through 2012. The delineation of vessel routes conducted in this study was motivated by development planned for offshore Wind Energy Areas (WEAs) along the Atlantic coast of the US and the need to evaluate the effect of these development areas on commercial shipping. To this end, available AIS data were processed to generate commercial vessel tracks for individual vessels, though cargo vessels are the focus in this study. The individual vessel tracks were sampled at transects placed along the Atlantic coast. The transect samples were analysed and partitioned by voyages between Atlantic ports to facilitate computation of vessel routes between ports. The route boundary analysis utilised a definition from UK guidance in which routes\u0027 boundaries encompassed 95% of the vessel traffic between ports. In addition to delineating route boundaries, we found multi-modal transverse distributions of vessels for well-travelled routes, which indicated preference for lanes of travel within the delineated routes.","author":["Copping, A.","Whiting, J.","Breithaupt, S.","Tagestad, J."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Navigation"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:22","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2466","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/recreational-use-offshore-wind-farms-experiences-opinions-sea-anglers-uk","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X16307618","title":"Recreational Use of Offshore Wind Farms: Experiences and Opinions of Sea Anglers in the UK","description":"The expansion of offshore wind farms (OWFs) is likely to increase conflict with other marine users as different sectors compete for space. There may also be positive interactions, as the artificial reef effects from energy infrastructure have the potential to sustain and enhance fishing opportunities. Recreational sea angling is an important sector within the UK but the experiences and opinions of UK sea anglers with respect to OWFs have not been documented. To address this, an online survey was undertaken with recreational anglers around the UK (n=199). Respondents represented a range of socio-demographic and angling characteristics, although male, more frequent and older fishers as well as club members were over-represented compared to a 2012 national survey. One quarter of the respondents had fished around the perimeter of or within an OWF, most on multiple occasions, and 73% of those who had not expressed a willingness to do so in future. Anglers reported both positive and negative effects on catch success when fishing near or within OWFs compared to their experiences of the same site prior to OWF development. Outcomes for individual species were also mixed. Anglers recognised the potential artificial reef effects of OWFs and their role as a \u201csafe haven\u201d, particularly due to the exclusion of commercial fishers. Negative perceptions included restricted access, harm to marine wildlife, and visual impact. There is little evidence that OWFs will have a significant economic impact on recreational fishing, as most anglers are unlikely to change their behaviour in response to future developments.","author":["Hooper, T.","Austen, M.","Hattam, C."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.471572000000","-1.266505000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Social \u0026 Economic Data","Habitat Change"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2467","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/well-being-framework-impact-evaluation-case-uk-offshore-wind-industry","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0308597X16303621","title":"A Well-Being Framework for Impact Evaluation: The Case of the UK Offshore Wind Industry","description":"Growing levels of energy consumption and concern over the environmental consequences of energy production are leading to an increased investment in renewable energy generation. Despite an important relationship between energy production, consumption and well-being, little attempt has been made to provide a holistic assessment of how renewable energy sectors can contribute to different aspects of human well-being. This paper develops an impact evaluation framework that can be used to capture societal-level impacts of change on primarily objective well-being and applies it to the case of the UK offshore wind industry. As such, the framework goes beyond the traditional view of economic, social and environmental impact assessment and evaluation capturing wider aspects of societal costs and benefits as well as sustainable development. The framework proves a useful tool for organising the available evidence and suggests a broadly positive impact of the UK offshore wind industry. While further testing and refinement of the framework is needed, it could be easily transferred for well-being assessment of other industries and interventions.","author":["Hooper, T.","Papathanasopoulou, E.","Hattam, C."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.471572000000","-1.266505000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Social \u0026 Economic Data"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2468","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/issuance-incidental-harassment-authorizations-deepwater-wind-take-marine-mammals","sourceURL":"https:\/\/repository.library.noaa.gov\/view\/noaa\/5007","title":"Issuance of Incidental Harassment Authorizations to Deepwater Wind for the Take of Marine Mammals Incidental to Construction of the Block Island Wind Farm and Block Island Transmission System","description":"The Marine Mammal Protection Act (MMPA) prohibits the incidental taking of marine mammals. The incidental take of a marine mammal falls under three categories: mortality, serious injury, or harassment, which includes injury and behavioral effects. The MMPA defines harassment as any act of pursuit, torment, or annoyance which: (1) has the potential to injure a marine mammal or marine mammal stock in the wild (Level A harassment); or (2) has the potential to disturb a marine mammal or marine mammal stock in the wild by causing disruption of behavioral patterns, including, but not limited to, migration, breathing, nursing, breeding, feeding, or sheltering (Level B harassment). There are exceptions to the MMPA\u2019s prohibition on take such as the authority at issue here for us to authorize the incidental taking of small numbers of marine mammals by harassment upon the request of a U.S. citizen provided we follow certain statutory and regulatory procedures and make determinations. We describe this exception set forth in the MMPA at Section 101(a)(5)(D) in more detail in Section 1.2.  The National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS) proposes to issue separate Incidental Harassment Authorizations (Authorizations) to Deepwater Wind Block Island, LLC (DWBI) and Deepwater Wind Transmission System, LLC (DWBIT) \u2014 subsidiaries of Deepwater Wind Holdings, LLC and collectively termed \u201cDeepwater Wind\u201d \u2014 under the MMPA for the incidental taking of small numbers of marine mammals incidental to the construction of the Block Island Wind Farm (BIWF) and its associated Block Island Transmission System (BITS), respectively. We do not have the authority to permit, authorize, or prohibit Deepwater Wind\u2019s activities (i.e., the underlying action) under Section 101(a)(5)(D) of the MMPA, as that authority lies with a different Federal agency.  Our proposed action is a direct outcome of Deepwater Wind requesting authorizations under Section 101(a)(5)(D) of the MMPA to take marine mammals, by harassment, incidental to construction of the BIWF and BITS because the associated activities have the potential to take marine mammals during impact and vibratory pile driving and the use of dynamically positioned (DP) vessel thrusters. We anticipate that the disturbance associated with these activities would result in take otherwise prohibited by the MMPA. Deepwater Wind therefore requires authorizations for incidental take and has requested that we provide it through the issuance of Incidental Harassment Authorizations under Section 101(a)(5)(D) of the MMPA.  Our issuance of Authorizations to Deepwater Wind is a major federal action under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) regulations in 40 CFR \u00a7\u00a7 1500-1508, and NOAA Administrative Order (NAO) 216-6. Thus, we are required to analyze the effects on the human environment and determine whether they are significant such that preparation of an Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) is necessary.  This Environmental Assessment (EA), titled \u201cIssuance of Incidental Harassment Authorizations to Deepwater Wind for the Take of Marine Mammals Incidental to Construction of the Block Island Wind Farm and Block Island Transmission System\u201d (hereinafter, EA) addresses the potential environmental impacts of two alternatives available to us under Section 101(a)(5)(D) of the MMPA, namely:    Issue the Authorizations to Deepwater Wind for Level B harassment take of marine mammals under the MMPA during their construction projects, taking into account the prescribed means of take, mitigation measures, and monitoring requirements required in the proposed Authorizations; or  Not issue the Authorizations to Deepwater Wind in which case, for the purposes of NEPA analysis, we assume that the activities would proceed without the mitigation and monitoring measures prescribed in the proposed Authorizations.","author":["National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)"],"organization":["National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS)"],"originationDate":"2014-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["41.125721110000","71.507563890000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/NMFS-2014-BlockIsland.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2469","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/meygen-tidal-energy-project-phase-1-electromagnetic-fields-best-practice-report","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.scot\/Resource\/0048\/00485267.pdf","title":"MeyGen Tidal Energy Project Phase 1 Electromagnetic Fields Best Practice Report","description":"This document has been prepared by MeyGen Ltd. to enable Condition 3.2.1.1 of the Marine Licence to be discharged. The document details the best practice in manufacture and installation related to minimising the attenuation of electromagnetic fields from the Turbine Subsea Cables proposed for the MeyGen Project, Phase 1a. The document will be submitted to the Scottish Ministers for their written approval, in consultation with SNH and any other ecological advisors as required at the discretion of the Scottish Ministers. Construction Method Statements for the related Turbine Subsea Cable works have been approved by Scottish Ministers.","author":["Rollings, E."],"organization":["MeyGen"],"originationDate":"2015-03-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.656500000000","-3.130000000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-12 03:49:38","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rollings-2015-Meygen.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2470","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/role-tidal-lagoons","sourceURL":"","title":"The Role of Tidal Lagoons","description":"The Review was initiated by Government following proposals for tidal lagoon projects, in particular a proposal by the company Tidal Lagoon Power (TLP) for a tidal lagoon in Swansea Bay. The focus of the Review is not on specific proposals but on the general principles of tidal lagoons. However much of my consideration necessarily started with work which has already been done for Swansea Bay: as it is by far the most developed proposal, it is also the best source of data concerning many issues covered.  I have divided the task facing the Review into two parts. Part One is to assess whether tidal lagoons can, and should, play a cost effective role as part of the UK\u2019s energy mix \u2013 the \u2018existentialist question\u2019. Part Two is to consider circumstances in which this might happen by exploring how the technology and the new industry might be developed and financed, and how the optimum national interest can be achieved.","author":["Hendry, C."],"organization":["UK Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC)","UK Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (BEIS)"],"originationDate":"2016-12-06","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/The_Role_of_Tidal_Lagoons.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2471","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/new-model-environmental-economic-evaluation-renewable-energy-systems-case-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0306261916317561","title":"A New Model for Environmental and Economic Evaluation of Renewable Energy Systems: The Case of Wind Turbines","description":"Both scientific community and political institutions frequently stress the crucial role of energy and renewable energy systems as a key asset for global sustainable future development. Wind energy is a relevant renewable source due to its high conversion performances, achieved particularly by large scale plants. Nevertheless, the production processes, rather than the installation one, may entail relevant energy consumption, as well as the release of CO2 and other pollutants.  This study develops a model for concurrent environmental and economic viability of wind turbines under the framework of Life Cycle Assessment. A case study is developed to evaluate a set of different project alternatives for three types of wind turbines, for which different scenarios are analysed through a dedicated assessment tool. The research highlights the manufacturing phase of wind turbines as crucial in finding the concurrent economic and environmental feasibility.","author":["Savino, M.","Selva, V.","Manzini, R.","Accorsi, R."],"organization":["University of Bologna","University of Sannio"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-10 08:57:11","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2472","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/monitoring-condition-marine-renewable-energy-devices-through-underwater-acoustic","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0960148116309144","title":"Monitoring the Condition of Marine Renewable Energy Devices through Underwater Acoustic Emissions: Case study of a Wave Energy Converter in Falmouth Bay, UK","description":"Maintaining the engineering health of Marine Renewable Energy Devices (MREDs) is one of the main limits to their economic viability, because of the requirement for costly marine interventions in challenging conditions. Acoustic Emission (AE) condition monitoring is routinely and successfully used for land-based devices, and this paper shows how it can be used underwater. We review the acoustic signatures expected from operation and likely failure modes of MREDs, providing a basis for a generic classification system. This is illustrated with a Wave Energy Converter tested at Falmouth Bay (UK), monitored for 2 years. Underwater noise levels have been measured between 10\u00a0Hz and 32\u00a0kHz throughout this time, covering operational and inactive periods. Broadband MRED contributions to ambient noise are generally negligible. Time-frequency analyses are used to detect acoustic signatures (60\u00a0Hz\u20135\u00a0kHz) of specific operational activities, such as the active Power Take Off, and relate them to engineering and environmental conditions. These first results demonstrate the feasibility of using underwater Acoustic Emissions to monitor the health and performance of MREDs.","author":["Blondel, P.","Johanning, L.","Garrett, J.","Walsh, J.","Bashir, I.","Thies, P."],"organization":["University of Bath","University of Exeter"],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["50.128518000000","-5.010415000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2026-08-06 10:00:53","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2473","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/visualising-aspect-dependent-radar-cross-section-seabirds-over-tidal-energy-test-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S2214166917300024","title":"Visualising the Aspect-Dependent Radar Cross Section of Seabirds over a Tidal Energy Test Site Using a Commercial Marine Radar System","description":"The long-term monitoring of seabirds around proposed marine renewable energy (MRE) sites is vital to assess the large-scale and long-term environmental impacts of MRE installations. Marine radar could be a valuable tool to augment traditional seabird surveys but the problem of aspect dependency of the generic radar cross section (RCS) of live birds in flight must be understood before radar data is correctly interpreted. A marine radar multiple target tracking algorithm (\u2018GANNET\u2019) was applied to data from an un-calibrated, horizontally polarised, 10kW X-band marine radar sited at the European Marine Energy Centre (EMEC) tidal renewable energy test site, Scotland U.K. From 24 days of data over 1.84 million target readings were recorded. For each target reading the radar aspect angle (bearing of radar beam incident on target), range and non-dimensional echo magnitude were derived allowing a view to be generated of the variation of echo magnitude with aspect angle for all tracked targets. The resulting polar diagram shows a significant change in echo magnitude with range between side-on and head\/tail-on aspects indicating a large contribution of the RCS from the wings of birds in flight. The species-unspecific detectability of seabirds, especially at long range, is found to be strongly dependent on aspect angle. This has direct implications for the use of marine radar equipment for avian monitoring at proposed and active marine energy sites and must be taken into account if data from these radars are to be used to augment traditional bird abundance and area use surveys conducted by human observers.","author":["Bell, P.","McCann, D."],"organization":["National Oceanography Centre (NOC)"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["59.128445000000","-2.803811000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Seabirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:24","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2474","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/extreme-sea-conditions-shallow-water-estimations-based-situ-measurements","sourceURL":"https:\/\/proceedings.asmedigitalcollection.asme.org\/proceeding.aspx?articleid=1786736","title":"Extreme Sea Conditions in Shallow Water: Estimations Based on In-Situ Measurements","description":"This paper focuses on the assessment of the environmental extreme conditions in term of wind and waves at the SEMREV wave energy test site for application in the design of Marine Renewable Energy (MRE) devices and components. The paper will first present the existing in situ wind and wave measurements. A prediction chain from global to regional scales, and based on a regional wave model calibrated at the SEMREV location, is then described. It enables to build a specific 22 year hindcast dataset for the test site. Long term extrapolation is finally achieved at the SEMREV location using existing methodologies for deep water conditions. Long term extrapolations methods are usually very sensitive to the parameterization and configuration of the prediction chain and we demonstrate in this study that the best overall performances are reached by a POT method at this stage of development in the prediction chain.","author":["Saulnier, J.","Perignon, Y.","Le Crom, I.","Berhault, C."],"organization":["Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)"],"originationDate":"2013-06-09","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.336877100000","47.336877100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 09:40:31","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2475","type":["Document","Document\/Conference Paper"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/challenging-best-knowledge-real-conditions-semrev-marine-test-site","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Yves_Perignon\/publication\/281693357_Challenging_best_knowledge_to_real_conditions_on_the_SEMREV_marine_test_site\/links\/55f804f108aeba1d9f01610f.pdf","title":"Challenging Best Knowledge to Real Conditions on the SEMREV Marine Test Site","description":"This paper presents a review of the last six years of sea states measurements at the SEMREV test site, compared to latest capabilities in term of wave modelling in a macro-tidal coastal environment [Tolman et al. (2014), Ardhuin et al. (2012)]. This work takes advantage of the HOMERE high-resolution hindcast data set [Boudiere et al. (2013)] for long term analysis, as well as an in house modelling chain based on a similar approach for more specific requirements over the measurement period. The grid refinement is led by a local unstructured mesh and an appropriate coupling and nesting from global to local scales. The retrieval of astronomic tidal harmonics at grid nodes from a one-year high resolution hydrodynamic coastal mo delling over the area [Pineau-Guillou et al. (2013)] enables to force at low com putational cost both levels and currents impacting the advection of the wave components in the sea state model. The paper provides a brief overview of the properties of the site inferred from the measurement and model capabilities, including the scores of both hindcast chains, the influence of the tidal forcing over the modelling and measurements or the spatial variability on site.  A special attention is paid in this study to the series of storms striking during winter 2014. The return period of the several singular events is checked against the previously estimated extrapolation method at SEMREV [Le Crom et al. (2013 )], as well as the return period of this whole sequence of severe conditions. One of the severe event, significant by the combination of high Hs and long period, is specifically analysed in term of 1 and 2D spectral distributions. This overall demonstrates the capabilities of a fully archived hindcast dataset associated to the latest and more physical accounting for source terms.","author":["Perignon, Y.","Le Crom, I."],"organization":["Ecole Central de Nantes (ECN)"],"originationDate":"2015-09-07","spatial":{"coordinates":["47.336877100000","-2.878822100000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-09-01 09:39:16","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/perignonetal2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2476","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/canadas-advantage-vision-renewable-electricity-canada","sourceURL":"https:\/\/myclimatechangehome.files.wordpress.com\/2019\/11\/can_16_visionreport.pdf","title":"Canada\u0027s Advantage: A Vision for Renewable Electricity in Canada","description":"In this document, the Canadian Council on Renewable Electricity outlines its vision for the future of renewable electricity in Canada.  The successful Paris climate change negotiations in December 2015 marked a turning point: the world is committed to addressing climate change. Canada has set a target of reducing economy-wide emissions by 30 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030, and it also recognizes scientific findings that global reductions of at least 80 per cent will be required by 2050 to limit climate change. Achieving such deep reductions in Canada will not be easy, especially given significant emissions from its transportation and oil sectors. Such a transition will require a combination of decisive early action as well as enduring and widespread support from ordinary Canadians to maintain momentum. We will need an unprecedented level of cooperation across sectors and governments while maintaining the integrity of our federal system and the role of the provinces, territories and First Nations and Indigenous communities.  Yet this new global resolve to address climate change also presents very significant opportunities for Canada\u2013both at home and abroad. Canada has a relatively clean electricity system, with 80 per cent of its electricity generated from non-emitting sources\u2013including 65 per cent from renewable energy. Our clean electricity resources can provide the foundation both for needed emission reductions and economic growth.  An early embrace of this opportunity offers clear advantages. First, much of Canada\u2019s electricity infrastructure is aging, and so is in need of replacement in any case. Second, early action can provide Canada with valuable lessons that it can leverage to assist other countries who will be facing similar challenges. As a large country with diverse geographical needs and resources, Canada can become a leader in clean technology, upstream and downstream electricity storage, the smart grid, and the broader electrification of the economy. Not only will we be able to provide clean electricity to assist the United States in achieving its own targets, we will also be able to export our technology and services throughout the world.  Modeling work and analysis from the Deep Decarbonization Pathways Project (DDPP) finds that economy-wide reductions of 30-50 per cent (compared to the 2005 baseline) are achievable with current technologies, such as energy efficiency measures, clean electricity, and switching from fossil fuels to clean power for buildings\u2014provided implementation begins immediately. But reductions beyond 50 per cent, in contrast, would require substantial innovation to enable large scale adoption of electrification technologies in sectors where electricity has not traditionally played a major role, such as heavy transport, oil and gas and various industries. Put differently, for Canada to achieve its greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction targets, we will need to make our electricity system even cleaner\u2013eventually achieving 100 per cent non-emitting electricity\u2013while also expanding power generation to support the electrification of the economy, notably in transportation, industry and buildings.  In order to achieve a largely decarbonized economy and capture the substantial associated advantages, we recommend that Canada take action in the following three areas:    Aim for a zero-carbon electricity grid by 2050. Implement policies to ensure the phase-out of practically all emitting generation sources by 2050 and the sustained growth of the share of generation produced by renewable sources.  An electrified economy. The federal, provincial and territorial governments should commit to increasing the use of electricity in our energy system to over 50 per cent of all energy used in Canada by 2050. Aim for 100 per cent zero carbon buildings by 2050, set ambitious targets for the electrification of transportation and strongly support the electrification of industry through research and development (R\u0026amp;D) support, subsidies and regulation.  A renewable energy export strategy. Federal, provincial and territorial governments should prioritize the development of a renewable energy export strategy, including work on streamlining of cross-border transmission projects, and removal of any policy barriers.","author":["Haffner, J.","Vriesendorp, W."],"organization":["Canadian Council on Renewable Electricity"],"originationDate":"2016-11-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Canada-Vision-Report-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2477","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/beach-response-wave-energy-converter-farms-acting-coastal-defence","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0378383913001749","title":"Beach response to wave energy converter farms acting as coastal defence","description":"One of the greatest challenges of coastal engineering today is the need for coastal protection in the changing climate scenario. Places which are nowadays protected will demand upgraded defences and more sites will require security; in all cases a large amount of resources will be needed to ensure beach maintenance and coastal safety. This may be an opportunity for the multi-purpose use of Wave Energy Converters (WECs) if the foreseen increase of energy demand in coastal areas is also considered. In this paper a group of WECs based on different operating concepts is numerically tested in front of two beaches, i.e. the Bay of Santander in Spain and Las Glorias beach in Mexico, representing two different case studies where the long-shore sediment transport is dominant. The hydrodynamics induced by these devices is represented by means of a 2D elliptic modified mild-slope model that is calibrated against new experimental results. The wave field is then used as input for the analytical calculation of the long-shore sediment transport and the coastline trend is estimated by applying the continuity of sediment equation. The characteristics of the selected numerical models give this work a first approach level. All the devices were found to produce a positive trend (accretion) at least in small areas. Recommendations are given to facilitate the selection of the device and the design of the farm layout for shore protection purpose.","author":["N\u00f8rgaard, J.","Andersen, T.","Zanuttigh, B.","Silva, R.","Martinelli, L.","Ruol, P.","Mendoza, E.","Angelelli, E."],"organization":["Aalborg University","Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico","University of Bologna","University of Padova"],"originationDate":"2014-05-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["43.449750000000","-3.788822000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Wave"],"tags":["Environment","Physical Environment","Changes in Flow"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2478","type":["Document","Document\/Webpage"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/triton-environmental-technologies-marine-energy","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.pnnl.gov\/projects\/triton","title":"Triton: Environmental Technologies for Marine Energy","description":"The Triton Initiative\u2019s mission is to comprehensively assess the potential environmental effects of marine energy, reduce uncertainties regarding regulatory concerns, and facilitate confident decision-making based on empirical observations and data-driven science that supports the responsible advancement of marine energy technologies.The research projects under the Triton Initiative range from monitoring fish behavior around tidal and riverine turbines to determining the best methods for characterizing underwater noise generated by marine energy devices to conducting lab-controlled experiments that investigate the physiological and behavioral impacts of acoustic emissions on marine mammals, fish, and invertebrates. With each project, Triton researchers strive to improve marine energy environmental monitoring and mitigation practices through testing and development, with the objective to reduce costs, inform developers and industry, and provide valuable data to inform the marine energy permitting processes. Triton\u0027s projects and innovative solutions aim to facilitate safe and sustainable deployment of marine energy devices.","author":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"organization":["US Department of Energy (DOE)"],"originationDate":"2026-05-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2026-05-30 01:16:21","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2479","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/massachusetts-study-wind-turbine-acoustics","sourceURL":"https:\/\/files.masscec.com\/research\/wind\/MassCECWindTurbinesAcousticsStudy.pdf","title":"Massachusetts Study on Wind Turbine Acoustics","description":"In the fall of 2012, the Massachusetts Clean Energy Center (MassCEC), in partnership with the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection (MassDEP), launched the Research Study on Wind Turbine Acoustics (RSOWTA) to advance the understanding of wind turbine acoustics, taking into account the influence of variables such as turbine size, technology, wind speed, topography, and distance from the turbine. The study will provide a quantitative basis for testing noise evaluation and modeling methodologies and improve wind turbine siting and approval processes. This report describes the methods and findings of the RSOWTA.  In the fall of 2013, as a first step in the process of incorporating the latest research on wind turbine acoustics into policy and regulations, MassDEP formed a Wind Turbine Technical Advisory Group (WNTAG), made up of representatives with technical expertise in wind turbine acoustics and who offer a range of perspectives. The WNTAG provides technical advice to MassDEP on how best to craft effective regulatory and policy responses to wind turbine installations and to possible noise impacts. Members of the group are listed at the WNTAG website. To inform ongoing WNTAG discussions, two interim reports of preliminary RSOWTA findings were shared with the WNTAG:    Amplitude Modulation. The first interim report (October 17, 2013) uses some of the data collected to evaluate the spectral and temporal characteristics of amplitude modulation with turbines operating and in ambient conditions. The report includes a discussion on how sound meter settings and sampling rates affect the levels reported for wind turbine and ambient sound.  Sound Modeling and Monitoring. The second interim report (February 26, 2014) focuses on a comparison of sound levels from operating wind turbines with calculations from sound propagation models to help inform and synchronize the pre-construction estimates of wind turbine noise impacts with post-construction monitoring.   This final report provides additional information on the topics addressed in the interim reports and addresses the following additional topics: low frequency sound and infrasound, tonality, meteorological data, and standards analysis.","author":["Resource Systems Group Inc"],"organization":["Resource Systems Group Inc","Massachusetts Clean Energy Center (MassCEC)"],"originationDate":"2016-02-18","spatial":{"coordinates":["42.062538900000","-72.278856000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/RSG-2016-Report.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2480","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/understanding-evidence-wind-turbine-noise","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.scienceadvice.ca\/en\/assessments\/completed\/wind-turbine-noise.aspx","title":"Understanding the Evidence: Wind Turbine Noise","description":"Demand for renewable energy, including wind power, is expected to continue to grow both in Canada and globally for the foreseeable future. The wind energy sector in Canada has grown at an ever-increasing pace since the 1990s, and Canada is now the fifth-largest market in the world for the installation of new wind turbines. As the sector grows, the wind turbines being installed are getting more powerful. The first megawatt-scale turbines were installed in Canada in 2004, with 3 megawatt models arriving in 2008; larger models up to 7.5 megawatt are currently being tested internationally. To produce this power, turbines have also increased in size. As wind turbines become a more common feature of the Canadian landscape, this new source of environmental sound has raised concerns about potential health effects on nearby residents.  Determining whether wind power causes adverse health effects in people is therefore important so that all Canadians can equitably share in the benefits of this technology.  THE CHARGE TO THE PANEL  In response to growing public concern about the potential health effects of wind turbine noise, the Government of Canada, through the Minister of Health (the Sponsor), asked the Council of Canadian Academies (the Council) to conduct an assessment of the question: Is there evidence to support a causal association between exposure to wind turbine noise and the development of adverse health effects?  The Charge also includes the following sub-questions:    Are there knowledge gaps in the scientific and technological areas that need to be addressed in order to fully assess possible health impacts from wind turbine noise?  Is the potential risk to human health sufficiently plausible to justify further research into the association between wind turbine noise exposure and the development of adverse health effects?  How does Canada compare internationally with respect to prevalence and nature of reported adverse health effects among populations living in the vicinity of commercial wind turbine establishments?  Are there engineering technologies and\/or other best practices in other jurisdictions that might be contemplated in Canada as measures that may minimize adverse community response towards wind turbine noise?   The Panel defined health in a way that is consistent with the World Health Organization\u2019s concept of health: \u201ca state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity\u201d (WHO, 1946). The Panel interpreted noise to include both objective measures of acoustic signals in the environment (sound), as well as subjective perceptions of sound sensations that are unwanted by the listener (noise). As there are a variety of wind turbines available worldwide, with differing sound characteristics, the Panel focused specifically on the type that constitutes almost all of the installed turbines in Canada: modern, three-bladed, tower-mounted, utility- scale (500 kilowatt capacity or more), upwind, horizontal-axis wind turbines that were land-based.  THE PANEL\u2019S APPROACH  To respond to the Charge, the Panel used an evidence-based approach to identify and review relevant research. First, the Panel identified more than 30 symptoms and health outcomes that have been attributed to exposure to wind turbine noise, based on a broad survey of peer-reviewed and grey literature, web pages, and legal decisions.  Empirical evidence related to any associations between these health outcomes and exposure to wind turbine noise was then collected from several sources, including peer-reviewed journal articles, conference papers, and grey literature. More than 300 publications were found through a comprehensive search, and these were narrowed down to 38 relevant studies related to the health effects of wind turbine noise. The body of evidence concerning each health outcome was appraised and assessed according to Bradford Hill\u2019s guidelines for causation, and summarized using standard terms adopted from the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC).  KEY FINDINGS  Based on its expertise and review of empirical research, the Panel made findings in the following areas:    Acoustic characteristics of wind turbine noise;  Evidence of causal relationships between exposure to wind turbine noise and adverse health effects;  Knowledge gaps and further research; and  Promising practices to reduce adverse community response.   Other aspects of the Charge, such as the prevalence of adverse health outcomes in Canada, could not be answered because of a lack of data.","author":["Council of Canadian Academies"],"organization":["Council of Canadian Academies"],"originationDate":"2015-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Land-Based Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Council-of-Canadian-Academies-2015.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2481","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/changes-fish-catch-rates-presence-air-gun-sounds-prudhoe-bay-alaska","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journalhosting.ucalgary.ca\/index.php\/arctic\/article\/view\/67635","title":"Changes in Fish Catch Rates in the Presence of Air Gun Sounds in Prudhoe Bay, Alaska","description":"Air guns used in oil industry seismic surveys have the capacity to change fish catch rates, but no previous work has demonstrated this effect in shallow water or in Arctic oilfields. Long-term monitoring of fish catches using four fyke nets allowed assessment of changes in catch rates during a 2014 seismic survey in Prudhoe Bay, Alaska. Fyke net locations were instrumented with both conventional hydrophones and vector sensors. Catch rates were generally within the range of those found in 27 previous sampling seasons. The effect of air guns on eight species was assessed using a modified Before-After\/Control-Impact analysis, with historical data and 2014 data as the Before-After components of the analysis and days without and with air gun activity as the Control-Impact components. Results showed significant changes associated with air guns in catch rates at one or more nets at p \u003C 0.1 for all eight species and at p \u003C 0.05 for seven of the eight. Changes included both increased and decreased catch rates, perhaps reflecting displacement of fish in response to air gun sounds throughout the study area. Measured sound pressure levels associated with air gun pulses were low and usually undetectable close to the fyke nets, reflecting the loss of low frequencies in shallow water (~1.5 m). Attempts to measure particle velocities failed when wind-driven surface waves overwhelmed vector sensors. However, fish responses may have been related to changes in particle motion associated with air gun sounds.","author":["Hawkins, A.","Popper, A.","Streever, B.","Raborn, S.","Kim, K."],"organization":["BP","LGL Ltd","University of Maryland"],"originationDate":"2016-12-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["70.331957600000","-148.384773000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Fisheries","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Streever-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2482","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/sound-approach-assessing-impact-underwater-noise-marine-fishes-invertebrates","sourceURL":"https:\/\/icesjms.oxfordjournals.org\/content\/early\/2016\/12\/24\/icesjms.fsw205.abstract","title":"A Sound Approach to Assessing the Impact of Underwater Noise on Marine Fishes and Invertebrates","description":"Increasing attention is being paid to the ecological consequences of underwater noise generated by human activities such as shipping and maritime industries including, but not limited to, oil and gas exploration and extraction, sonar systems, dredging and the construction of offshore renewable energy devices. There is particular concern over the extension of these activities into previously undeveloped areas of the oceans, including Polar Regions and areas of coral reef habitat. Most of the concern by regulators and others has focussed upon effects upon marine mammals and other protected species. However, examining the impacts upon the overall ecology of affected habitats is also important as it may be dominated by effects upon the far larger biomasses of fishes and invertebrates, which do not have the same degree of legal protection. Many of these assessments of the impact of noise on fishes and invertebrates have overlooked important issues, including the sensitivity of a substantial proportion of these species to particle motion rather than sound pressure. Attempts have been made to establish sound exposure criteria setting regulatory limits to the levels of noise in terms of effects upon mortality levels, injury to tissues, hearing abilities, behaviour, and physiology. However, such criteria have almost exclusively been developed for marine mammals. Criteria for fishes and invertebrates have often had to be assumed, or they have been derived from poorly designed and controlled studies. Moreover, the metrics employed to describe sounds from different sources have often been inappropriate, especially for fishes, and invertebrates, as they have been based on sound pressure rather than particle motion. In addition, the sound propagation models employed to assess the distances over which effects might occur have seldom been validated by actual measurements and are especially poor at dealing with transmission under shallow water conditions, close to or within the seabed, or at the surface. Finally, impacts on fish and invertebrate populations are often unknown and remain unassessed. This paper considers the problems of assessing the impact of noise upon fishes and invertebrates and the assessment procedures that need to be implemented to protect these animals and the marine ecosystems of which they form an integral part. The paper also suggests directions for future research and planning that, if implemented, will provide for a far better scientific and regulatory basis for dealing with effects of noise on aquatic life.","author":["Hawkins, A.","Popper, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2017-03-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Invertebrates","Fish","Noise"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2483","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/synchronized-sensor-array-remote-monitoring-avian-bat-interactions-offshore-renewable","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/308172540_A_Synchronized_Sensor_Array_for_Remote_Monitoring_of_Avian_and_Bat_Interactions_with_Offshore_Renewable_Energy_Facilities","title":"A Synchronized Sensor Array for Remote Monitoring of Avian and Bat Interactions with Offshore Renewable Energy Facilities","description":"Wind energy production in the U.S. is projected to increase to 35% of our nation\u2019s energy by 2050. This substantial increase in the U.S. is only a portion of the global wind industry growth, as many countries strive to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. A major environmental concern and potential market barrier for expansion of wind energy is bird and bat mortality from impacts with turbine blades, towers, and nacelles. Carcass surveys are the standard protocol for quantifying mortality at onshore sites. This method is imperfect, however, due to survey frequency at remote sites, removal of carcasses by scavengers between surveys, searcher efficiency, and other biases as well as delays of days to weeks or more in obtaining information on collision events. Furthermore, carcass surveys are not feasible at offshore wind energy sites. Near-real-time detection and quantification of interaction rates is possible at both onshore and offshore wind facilities using an onboard, integrated sensor package with data transmitted to central processing centers.\n\nWe developed and experimentally tested an array of sensors that continuously monitors for interactions (including impacts) of birds and bats with wind turbines. The synchronized array includes three sensor nodes: 1) vibration (accelerometers and contact microphones), 2) optical (visual and infrared spectrum cameras), and 3) bioacoustics (acoustic and ultrasonic microphones). Accelerometers and contact acoustic microphones are placed at the root of each blade to detect impact vibrations and sound waves propagating through the structure. On-board data processing algorithms using wavelet analysis detect impact signals exceeding background vibration. Stereo-visual and infrared cameras were placed on the nacelle to allow target tracking, distance, and size calculations. On-board image processing and target detection algorithms identify moving targets within the camera field of view. Bioacoustic recorders monitor vocalizations and echolocations to aid in identifying organisms involved in interactions. Data from all sensors are temporarily stored in ring (i.e., circular) buffers with a duration varying by sensor type. Detection of target presence or impact by any of the sensors can trigger the archiving of data from all buffers for transmission to a central data processing center for evaluation and post-processing. This mitigates the risk of \u201cdata mortgages\u201d posed by continual recording and minimizes personnel time required to manually review event data.\n\nWe first conducted individual component tests at laboratories and field sites in Corvallis and Newport, Oregon, and Seattle and Sequim, Washington. We conducted additional component tests on research wind turbines at the North American Wind Research and Training Center, Mesalands Community College (MCC; General Electric 1.5 MW turbine), New Mexico, and the National Wind Technology Center, National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL; Controls Advanced Research Turbines 3 [CART 3] 600 kW Westinghouse turbine), Colorado. We conducted fully integrated system tests at NREL in October 2014 and April 2015. We used only research wind turbines so that we could conduct controlled, experimentally generated impacts using empty and water-filled tennis balls shot from a compressed air cannon on the ground. The ~57 - 140 g tennis balls (depending on water content) were at the upper mass range for bats, but lower mass range for marine birds. Therefore, the ability to detect collisions of most seabirds is likely greater than our experiments demonstrate, but possibly lower for some bats depending on the background signal of a given turbine. Vibration data demonstrated that background signals of operating turbines varied markedly among the CART 3 under normal operation (greatest), GE (moderate), and CART 3 during idle rotation (generator not engaged; least). In total, we measured 63 experimental blade impacts on the two research turbines. Impaction detection was dependent on background signals, position of impact on the blade (a tip strike resulted in the strongest impact signal), and impact kinetics (velocity of ball and whether the ball struck the surface of the blade or the leading edge of the blade struck the ball). Overall detection percentage ranged from 100% for the \u201cquietest\u201d conditions (CART 3 idle rotation), down to 35% for the noisiest (CART 3 normal operation). Impact signals were detected from sensors on more than one blade (i.e., blades other than the blade struck) 50% - 75% of the time. Stereo imaging provided valuable metrics, but increased data processing and equipment cost. Given the cost of cameras with sufficient resolution for target identification, we suggest mounting cameras directly on the blades to continuously view the entire rotor swept area with the fewest number of cameras. Bioacoustic microphones provide taxonomic identification, as well as information on ambient noise levels. They also assist in identifying environmental conditions such as hail storms, high winds, thunder, lightning, etc., that may contribute to a collision or a false positive detection.\n\nWe demonstrated a proof of concept for an integrated sensor array to detect and identify bird and bat collisions with wind turbines. The next phase of research and development for this system will miniaturize and integrate sensors from all three nodes into a single wireless package that can be attached directly to the blade. This next generation system would use all \u201csmart\u201d sensors capable of onboard data processing to drastically reduce data streams and processing time on a central computer. A provisional patent for the blade mounted system was submitted by Oregon State University and recorded by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office (application no. 62313028). Eventually, technology and industry advances will allow this low cost monitoring system to be designed into materials during manufacturing so that all turbines could be monitored with either a subset or full suite of sensors. As standard equipment on all commercial turbines, the sensor suite would allow the industry to effectively monitor whether individual turbines were causing mortalities or not and under what circumstances. It would also provide real-time evaluation of mechanical and structural integrity of a turbine via vibration, image, and acoustic data streams, thereby permitting modifications in operation to limit environmental or mechanical damage.","author":["Polagye, B.","Suryan, R.","Albertani, R."],"organization":["Oregon State University (OSU)","University of Washington"],"originationDate":"2016-07-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Bats","Birds","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Suryan-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2484","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/implications-energy-systems-ecosystem-services-detailed-case-study-offshore-wind","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S1364032116310206","title":"The Implications of Energy Systems for Ecosystem Services: A Detailed Case Study of Offshore Wind","description":"Globally, the deployment of offshore wind is expanding rapidly. An improved understanding of the economic, social and environmental impacts of this sector, and how they compare with those of other energy systems, is therefore necessary to support energy policy and planning decisions. The ecosystem services approach provides a more holistic perspective of socio-ecological systems than traditional environmental impact assessment. The approach also makes possible comparisons across disparate ecological communities because it considers the societal implications of ecological impacts rather than remaining focused on specific species or habitats. By reporting outcomes in societal terms, the approach also facilitates communication with decision makers and the evaluation of trade-offs. The impacts of offshore wind development on ecosystem services were assessed through a qualitative process of mapping the ecological and cultural parameters evaluated in 78 empirical studies onto the Common International Classification for Ecosystem Services (CICES) framework. The research demonstrates that a wide range of biophysical variables can be consistently mapped onto the CICES hierarchy, supporting development of the ecosystem service approach from a broad concept into an operational tool for impact assessment. However, to improve confidence in the outcomes, there remains a need for direct measurement of the impacts of offshore wind farms on ecosystem services and for standardised definitions of the assumptions made in linking ecological and cultural change to ecosystem service impacts. The process showed that offshore wind farms have mixed impacts across different ecosystem services, with negative effects on the seascape and the spread of non-native species, and positive effects on commercial fish and shellfish, potentially of most significance. The work also highlighted the need for a better understanding of long term and population level effects of offshore wind farms on species and habitats, and how these are placed in the context of other pressures on the marine environment.","author":["Beaumont, N.","Hooper, T.","Hattam, C."],"organization":["Plymouth Marine Laboratory"],"originationDate":"2017-04-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2485","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/offshore-renewable-energy-nature-conservation-case-marine-tidal-turbines-northern","sourceURL":"https:\/\/link.springer.com\/article\/10.1007\/s10531-016-1268-6","title":"Offshore Renewable Energy and Nature Conservation: The Case of Marine Tidal Turbines in Northern Ireland","description":"The global demand for renewable energy continues to increase rapidly and with it the necessity to develop and test new technologies to deliver the power. Offshore renewable energy sources that harness wind, wave or tidal power are of major interest. Technological advances in these directions have not been matched by a clear understanding of the environmental impacts of the new devices, with most existing research concentrated on the impacts of offshore wind farms. Decisions often continue to be made without the support of a clear evidence base. Here we use an underwater tidal turbine, SeaGen, constructed and operated within the Strangford Lough marine protected area in Northern Ireland, as a case study to explore the potential impacts of the turbine as points of concern and argumentation in the decision-making processes. We use information obtained from official documents and one-to-one interviews with the main stakeholders. Our results demonstrate that during the construction and operation of the turbine the perceptions and views of different stakeholders sometimes disagreed but were often surprisingly similar in relation to both likelihood and intensity of the potential impacts of the turbine on marine biodiversity, ecosystem services and human well-being in general. The overall consensus of views was refined and evolved under an adaptive management approach over the 10 years of the discussions and decision-making processes. The results are discussed in relation to cumulative gains in knowledge, future arrays of many underwater turbines and multiple use of oceans within social ecological systems to maintain the conservation of marine biodiversity.","author":["Haslett, J.","Garcia-Llorent, M.","Harrison, P.","Li, S.","Berry, P."],"organization":["Lancaster University","Universidad Autonoma de Madrid","University of Oxford","University of Salzburg"],"originationDate":"2016-12-05","spatial":{"coordinates":["55.155266000000","-5.994349000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Ecosystem Processes"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:26","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Haslett-et-al-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2486","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-impacts-balancing-offshore-wind-power-compressed-air-energy-storage-caes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0360544215015911","title":"Environmental Impacts of Balancing Offshore Wind Power with Compressed Air Energy Storage (CAES)","description":"Using Life Cycle Assessment, we discuss the environmental impacts associated with a Compressed Air Energy Storage (CAES) system as a means of balancing the electricity output of an offshore wind farm with a capacity of 400\u00a0MW. We model both conventional CAES and adiabatic CAES (ACAES), with target for baseload production of respectively 200\u00a0MW and 150\u00a0MW. For the CAES system, wind power production and natural gas combustion are main contributors to the assessed life cycle environmental impacts. For the ACAES system, wind power production and thermal energy storage are significant contributors. Compared with the impacts of wind power alone, and for the modeled energy storage size and target output, we find that CAES increases acidification, particulate matter, photochemical oxidant formation, and climate impacts significantly, but decreases eutrophication, toxicity, and mineral resource depletion impacts. ACAES moderately increases environmental impacts across all assessed impact categories, and impacts are sensitive to the required capacity of the thermal energy storage. In comparison with impacts from the average European mix, both storage configurations in our base case have low impacts per kWh electricity delivered to the grid, with the exception of mineral resource depletion.","author":["Hertwich, E.","Bouman, E.","\u00d8berg, M."],"organization":["Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)","Yale University"],"originationDate":"2016-01-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Human Dimensions","Life Cycle Assessment","Environmental Impact Assessment"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2487","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/behavior-scandinavian-bats-during-migration-foraging-sea","sourceURL":"https:\/\/academic.oup.com\/jmammal\/article\/90\/6\/1318\/898402","title":"Behavior of Scandinavian Bats During Migration and Foraging at Sea","description":"We studied bats migrating and foraging over the sea by direct observations and automatic acoustic recording. We recorded 11 species (of a community of 18 species) flying over the ocean up to 14 km from the shore. All bats used sonar during migration flights at sea, often with slightly lower frequencies and longer pulse intervals compared to those used over land. The altitude used for migration flight was most often \u0026lt;10 m above sea level. Bats must use other sensory systems for long-distance navigation, but they probably use echoes from the water surface to orient to the immediate surroundings. Both migrant and resident bats foraged over the sea in areas with an abundance of insects in the air and crustaceans in the surface waters. When hunting insects near vertical objects such as lighthouses and wind turbines, bats rapidly changed altitude, for example, to forage around turbine blades. The findings illustrate why and how bats might be exposed to additional mortality by offshore wind power. Key words","author":["Ahl\u00e9n, I.","Bach, L.","Baag\u00f8e, H."],"organization":["Bach-Freilandforschung","Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences","The Natural History Museum of Denmark"],"originationDate":"2009-12-15","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2488","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/wind-turbines-bats-guidelines-assessment-study-planning-aspects","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.bach-freilandforschung.de\/index.php\/de\/veroeffentlichungen","title":"Wind Turbines and Bats - Guidelines for an Assessment Study and for Planning Aspects","description":"The problem of bats and wind farms is first described. Then guidelines for an assessment methodology are developed in order to take account of this problem in planning schemes. During the studies a distinction between two populations can be made: local and migratory. The local population are those animals present during the breeding period; migratory animals are those, which, especially in early and late summer, and autumn, undertake transfer flights. In doing so, they are killed in significant numbers by wind turbines. For the study we recommend a combination of methods, the bat detector and the \u201cautomatic bat registration box\u201d. In woodland areas we also recommend mist-netting to evaluate impacts due to the siting and construction of wind farms. In all current research methods, the flight activity of bats at altitudes of more than 100m is virtually unknown \u2013 so that here is a special research need. Bat behaviour is different during the summer and the migration period, so the results have to be evaluated and presented separately. Different ways to reduce the impacts are shown. Finally, so that future planning can take this problem into account, we describe fields of research which are urgently needed.","author":["Bach, L.","Brinkmann, R.","Rahmel, U.","Limpens, H.","Roschen, A."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2004-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Rahmeletal2005.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2489","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/summary-wind-turbine-impacts-bats-assessment-conflict","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/publication\/237240747_Summary_of_wind_turbine_impacts_on_bats_-_Assessment_of_a_conflict","title":"Summary of Wind Turbine Impacts on Bats - Assessment of a Conflict","description":"The different effects of wind turbines on bat behaviour are discussed here and collisions during bat migrations play an important part. Very little is known about the impacts of turbine ultrasounds. A change in space use due to shifting and loss of summer foraging habitats has been proved for the Serotine bat (Eptesicus serotinus), but in the same time the Common Pipistrelle (Pipistrellus pipistrellus) was apparently not affected. For wind farm projects it will be necessary in the future, as a matter of principle and as a precaution, to take into consideration the interests of bat conservation.","author":["Bach, L.","Rahmel, U."],"organization":[],"originationDate":"2004-01-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Bats"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Bach-Rahmel-2004.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2490","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/number-distribution-marine-mammals-fall-warness-orkney-july-2006-july-2007","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.emec.org.uk\/?wpfb_dl=135","title":"The Number and Distribution of Marine Mammals in the Fall of Warness, Orkney July 2006 - July 2007","description":"Land-based marine mammal surveys of the Fall of Warness were carried out from 15th July 2006 to 13th July 2007, encompassing a total of 240 days, and 928 hours of observation. These are a continuation of previous surveys of the site that ran from 11th July 2005 to 14th July 2006 and encompassed 219 days and 964 hours of observations.\nGrey seals, harbour seals, harbour porpoises, minke whales, white-beaked dolphins, killer whales, Risso\u2019s dolphins and basking sharks were all seen during the study period. All species of marine mammal (and basking sharks) observed in the study area are protected under international and\/ or national legislation.\nChi-squared (E2) tests were used to investigate the patterns underlying seal and harbour porpoise observation data. Generalised Additive Models (GAMs) were fitted to the entire two year dataset to explore these patterns further. There was insufficient information on the other species to support anything beyond descriptive statistics.\nGrey seals were the most frequently observed species, with a significant peak in occurrence during their breeding season from September and October. Sightings were concentrated close to the shore area, especially to Muckle Green Holm. The probability of sighting grey seals was greatest while the tide was ebbing, and on calm afternoons. The rate of sighting grey seals has declined over the period of the study.\nHarbour seals were rarely observed between December 2006 and February 2007, though overall the numbers of sightings have been decreasing. They were most commonly seen during high tide and at the ends of the day. The small numbers of sightings was probably responsible for the lack of any other significant factors in the data analysis.\nHarbour porpoises were mainly observed on calm days during the summer and were observed to be mainly in small groups. The small number of sightings of this species meant that it was not possible to determine any other significant factors in the data analysis.\nOccasional sightings of minke whales, white-beaked dolphins, killer whales, Risso\u2019s dolphins, and basking sharks are consistent with existing knowledge of these species behaviour and distribution in Orkney waters.\nThe potential effects of tidal stream devices on large-bodied animals in the water column are a subject of considerable concern that requires a careful approach to management and mitigation. The methodological approaches developed in this study to help assess these effects are at the leading edge of the field. We suggest that they have broad application to most circumstances in which tidal power generation is being considered.","author":["Hastie, G.","Lonergan, M.","Mackey, B.","Quick, N.","Desbois, A."],"organization":["Sea Mammal Research Unit (SMRU)","SMRU Consulting"],"originationDate":"2007-08-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.963406000000","-3.301211000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Marine Mammals","Cetaceans","Pinnipeds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Lonergan-et-al-2007.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2491","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/environmental-effects-monitoring-programs-fundy-ocean-research-center-energy-force","sourceURL":"https:\/\/fundyforce.ca\/document-collection\/environmental-effects-monitoring-programs-force-2016","title":"Environmental Effects Monitoring Programs: Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)","description":"The Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE) is Canada\u2019s leading research centre for the demonstration and evaluation of tidal in-stream energy conversion (TISEC) technology. TISEC technology (commonly referred to as \u201ctidal energy turbines\u201d), is designed to generate renewable energy from tidal resource sites across Canada and the globe. Fundamental to FORCE\u2019s mandate is the monitoring and reporting of any environmental effects from tidal turbines at the FORCE site.\n\nFORCE is a demonstration project, with berth sites granted to a number of technology developers (or berth holders) including Atlantis Operations Canada, DP Energy, Black Rock Tidal Power, Cape Sharp Tidal Ventures, and Minas Energy, The government of Nova Scotia has granted 22.5 megawatts (MW) of TISEC capacity at FORCE, under the province\u2019s developmental feed-in tariff program. This represents the deployment of approximately two to three TISEC turbines by each developer at their berth site. As these deployments are expected to be phased in over the next several years, FORCE and regulators will have opportunity to adapt environmental monitoring approaches over time, both to better understand what effects turbines may have on the environment, and to report on the monitoring results and any identified effects to the public.\n\nEnvironmental monitoring has been ongoing at FORCE since 2007 when background studies were initiated for the project Environmental Assessment (EA). When the initial EA was approve d by the federal and provincial governments in 2009, the development and implementation of environmental effects monitoring programs (EEMPs) were stipulated in the Terms and Conditions of EA Approval. In response, FORCE completed 20 monitoring studies between 2009 and late 2013, including fish characterization, seabirds, marine mammals, lobster tracking, marine noise, benthic habitat, electromagnetic fields, and more. The results of the studies undertaken to date along with the original EA are available on the FORCE website: https:\/\/fundyforce.ca\/environment\/.\n\nA turbine was operational at the FORCE site for a short time in 2009. Since removal of this unit in 2010, no tidal turbines have been present at the FORCE site. Consequently, the environmental studies conducted between 2009 and 2015 have largely focused on the collection of background data, rather than on monitoring the effects of turbines. This situation will change with the planned deployment of two cable-connected turbines in 2016 followed by additional deployments in subsequent years.\n\nThis report describes new EEMPs based on data and lessons learned from the environmental studies conducted to date. The EEMPs are designed to supplement background datasets where needed but are primarily aimed at verifying predictions made in the EA and at monitoring the environmental effects of operating turbines. The EEMPs are intended to monitor potential effects from the initial demonstration scale project, rather than from a potential commercial scale project that may occur in the future. To this end, the EEMPs are limited to effects within the FORCE Crown Lease Area (CLA), and do not attempt to measure effects in the much larger Bay of Fundy.\n\nMonitoring programs have been developed for five subject areas: Lobsters, Fish, Marine Mammals, Marine Seabirds and Acoustics (marine noise). The EEMPs are intended to cover initial turbine deployments over the time period 2016-2021. The programs are designed to accommodate unforeseen changes in turbine deployment schedules and are adaptive to initial monitoring results. It is also expected that the design and\/or methods of certain programs may be updated in later years once early results are known.\n\nWithin the C LA measuring 1.0 x 1.6 km, FORCE leases to each berth holder a dedicated berth some 200 m in diameter. The berth holder in turn will deploy, operate and test their turbine technologies, which will be connected to the electrical grid through dedicated subsea cables. Given these overlapping areas of responsibility, the berth holders are responsible for monitoring within a 100 m radius of their turbines (the so-called \u201cnear field\u201d effects), while FORCE will be responsible for monitoring outside of this zone within the CLA (the so-called \u201cmid field\u201d effects). Berth holder-generated EEMPs will be available to provide a comprehensive picture of all monitoring that will be undertaken within the CLA. FORCE will:\n\n\n report results from both the FORCE and berth holder EEMPs to regulators; and\n make all EEMP reports available to the public.\n\n\nThe FORCE EEMPs are intended to be practical, achievable using available technologies, and demonstrative of negative or null effects. The monitoring approaches also reflect the difficulty in operating in this high energy environment and certain technological limitations inherent in some of the equipment that will be employed. However, through these EEMPs, FORCE intends to progressively verify the environmental effect predictions made in the original EA over the next five years. A summary of the programs is presented in the table at the end of this report.","author":["Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"organization":["Fundy Ocean Research Center for Energy (FORCE)"],"originationDate":"2016-03-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.369760000000","-64.402540000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment"],"modifiedDate":"2025-11-12 12:17:45","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/FORCE-EEMP-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2492","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/impacts-submarine-cables-marine-environment-literature-review","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.researchgate.net\/profile\/Ahmad-Al-Khraisat-2\/post\/How_underwater_data_centers_affect_the_environment_in_general_and_marine_environment_in_Particular\/attachment\/602c2019af00c40001f72af1\/AS%3A991924076949505%401613504537583\/download\/BfN_Literaturstudie_Effekte_marine_Kabel_2007-02_01.pdf","title":"Impacts of Submarine Cables on the Marine Environment - A Literature Review","description":"Subsea cables have a long history in telecommunication services which started at the end of the 19th century with the deployment of the first telegraph cable across the English Channel. Today the demand for fast communication links is still growing rapidly and leads to a flurry of cable laying activities around the globe. But there is a second aspect of subsea cables gaining more importance: transmission of electric power. Power transmission via subsea cables is realized to interconnect terrestrial grids, to supply power to offshore facilities or to feed power supplied from renewable energy sources offshore such as wind and waves into terrestrial grids. Numerous subsea cables can already be found in our oceans and there will be a lot more in the years to come (Fig. 1 and Fig. 2).  Potential problems related to the deployment of subsea cables of different types are raising concerns not only among environmentalists. For that reason, Germany\u0027s Federal Agency of Nature Conservation (BfN) has commissioned this literature review to collect up-to-date information on potential effects of installation, operation and decommissioning of cables in the marine environment. Mitigation measures and requirements of effective monitoring programs are discussed. As a result, a better guidance on development of offshore industries considering environmental aspects and nature conservation issues is expected.","author":["Bellebaum, J.","Mei\u00dfner, K.","Schabelon, H.","Sordyl, H."],"organization":["Institute of Applied Ecology (IfAO)","German Federal Agency for Nature Conservation (BfN)"],"originationDate":"2006-09-01","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Meissner-et-al-2006.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2493","type":["Document","Document\/Thesis"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-emf-emissions-undersea-electric-cables-coral-reef-fishes","sourceURL":"https:\/\/nsuworks.nova.edu\/cgi\/viewcontent.cgi?referer=\u0026httpsredir=1\u0026article=1419\u0026context=occ_stuetd","title":"Effects of EMF Emissions from Undersea Electric Cables on Coral Reef Fishes","description":"The objective of this project was to determine if the electromagnetic field (EMF) emissions from undersea power cables impacted the local and transient marine life, with an emphasis on reef fishes. The work was done at South Florida Ocean Measurement Facility of Naval Surface Warfare Center, Carderock Division, Broward County, Florida. This facility functions as the hub for a range of active undersea detection and data transmission cables. It has multiple active submarine power cables that extend several miles offshore and which can deliver power and enable data transmission to and from a range of acoustic and EMF sensors. The cables lie directly on the seabed, are buried in the sand, or are suspended in the water column. EMF emissions from a selected cable were created during SCUBA fish surveys. During the surveys the transmission of either alternating current (AC) or Direct Current (DC) was randomly intiated by the facility with no transmitted current (OFF) provided a control. The surveys were conducted using standardized transect and stationary point count methods to acquire reef fish abundances prior to and immediately after a change in transmission frequency (the divers were aware of the time of frequency change but not the specific frequencies). The divers were also tasked to note the reaction of the reef fishes to the immediate change in the EMFs emitting from the cable during a power switch. The surveys were conducted on a quarterly basis at three sampling sites offshore on the same cable. These sites were in water depths of approximately 5, 10, and 15 m, respectively and were selected based on their robust reef fish community and are representative of each of the three primary hardbottom coral reef habitats in the local offshore environment: the Inner (Shallow), Middle, and Outer (Deep) reef tracts. A total of 263 surveys were conducted: 132 transect-counts and 131 point-counts over 15 months. There were 24,473 fishes counted during transect-count surveys and with point-counts, 36,115 fishes were counted. With count types and sites combine a total of 151 species representing 35 families were recorded. An analysis of the data primarily did not find statistical differences among power states and any variables. However, this may be a Type II error as there are strong indications of a potential difference of a higher abundance of reef fishes at the sites when the power was off. There are a number of caveats to consider with this finding: the data set needs to be larger in terms of numbers of: counts, sites and eletro-sensitive species to allow for rigorous statistical analysis; also a longer time between frequency changes to allow for slower, but nonetheless important, reactions to differing EMFs might lead to differing conclusions. Obviously, more research is required to confirm the results of this study.","author":["Jermain, R."],"organization":["Nova Southeastern University"],"originationDate":"2016-07-18","spatial":[],"technologyType":[],"tags":["Environment","Fish","EMF"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2495","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/evaluation-blade-strike-models-estimating-biological-performance-kaplan-turbines","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0304380007003006","title":"Evaluation of Blade-Strike Models for Estimating the Biological Performance of Kaplan Turbines","description":"Bio-indexing of hydro turbines is an important means to optimize passage conditions for fish by identifying operations for existing and new design turbines that minimize the probability of injury. Cost-effective implementation of bio-indexing requires the use of tools such as numerical and physical turbine models to generate hypotheses for turbine operations that can be tested at prototype scales using live fish. Numerical deterministic and stochastic blade-strike models were developed for a 1:25-scale physical turbine model built by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers for the original design turbine at McNary Dam and for prototype-scale original design and replacement minimum gap runner (MGR) turbines at Bonneville Dam\u2019s first powerhouse. Blade-strike probabilities predicted by both models were comparable with those observed in both prototype-scale live fish survival studies and a physical turbine model using neutrally buoyant beads. Predictions from the stochastic model were closer to experimental data than predictions from the deterministic model because the stochastic model considered the aspects of fish approaching to the leading edges of turbine runner blades. Therefore, the stochastic model should be the preferred method for the prediction of blade strike and injury probability for juvenile salmon and steelhead using numerical blade-strike models for evaluating the biological performance of Kaplan hydro turbines.","author":["Deng, Z.","Carlson, T.","Richmond, M.","Dauble, D.","Ploskey, G."],"organization":["Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL)"],"originationDate":"2007-11-10","spatial":{"coordinates":["45.934875000000","-119.297871000000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Riverine"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish","Collision"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2496","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/brims-tidal-array-collision-risk-modelling-atlantic-salmon","sourceURL":"https:\/\/marine.gov.scot\/datafiles\/lot\/Brims_Tidal\/Supporting_Documents\/Collision%20Risk%20Modelling%20%C3%94%C3%87%C3%B4%20Atlantic%20Salmon%20Xodus%20Group%20(2016).pdf","title":"Brims Tidal Array Collision Risk Modelling - Atlantic Salmon","description":"There is a concern that submerged tidal energy devices placed within a tidal current will present an obstacle to wildlife within the tidal channel and there is a risk of collision as a result. Although concerns are primarily for cetaceans and pinnipeds there is also some concern of the risk to fish, particularly Atlantic salmon (Salmo salar). Due to the risks posed, Marine Scotland has recommended that an assessment of collision risk to fish is informed by project specific collision risk modelling (CRM).  CRM is used to assess this risk for Atlantic salmon and it uses a physical model of a rotor and the body size and swimming activity of Atlantic salmon to estimate the potential collision rate. It focuses on the number of animal transits through a rotating rotor and the collision risk during each transit. Following the calculation of the collision risk, likely avoidance behaviours can be applied and a realistic collision rate can be determined (Band, 2015).  This technical note discusses the collision risks associated with various scenarios at the Brims Tidal Array, located in the Pentland Firth to the south of the island of Hoy, Orkney.","author":["Xodus Group"],"organization":["Xodus Group","Brims Tidal Array Ltd"],"originationDate":"2016-03-03","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.766787400000","-3.229773400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Current","Current\/Tidal"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Pelagic Fish","Collision","Avoidance"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:28","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Brims-Tidal-Array-Collision-Modeling-2016.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2497","type":["Document","Document\/Report"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/review-potential-impacts-offshore-wind-farms-migrating-overwintering-swans-geese-sea-5","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.gov.uk\/government\/uploads\/system\/uploads\/attachment_data\/file\/197389\/SEA5_TR_SwansGeese_CorkEcology.pdf","title":"Review of the Potential Impacts of Offshore Wind Farms on Migrating and Overwintering Swans and Geese in the SEA 5 Area","description":"Introduction  A review of the coastal distribution and abundance of swans and geese in the SEA 5 area, including migration routes, key feeding areas and roosting areas was carried out by Cork Ecology at the request of the Department of Trade and Industry as part of the SEA 5 process. A review of the potential impacts of offshore wind farms on swans and geese was also conducted.  The study area was defined as the east coast of Scotland from the English border north to John O\u2019 Groats, including Orkney and Shetland, and the offshore waters in the SEA 5 area. The review considered nine species: mute swan, Bewick\u2019s swan, whooper swan, bean goose, pink- footed goose, white-fronted goose, greylag goose, barnacle goose and brent goose.  Methodology  Counts and figures for the SEA 5 area from the Wetland Bird Survey (WeBS) Annual reports from 1991\/92 to 2000\/01 and relevant bird reports were included in this review. In general data from 1991 onward were considered with the aim of presenting the most recent estimates for the important sites. Sites that regularly hold more than 1 % of the national population of a species are deemed to be nationally important, and sites with more than 1 % of the biogeographic population are internationally important.  Potential impacts of offshore wind farms on swans and geese  Offshore wind farms may impact birds directly by mortality from collisions or indirectly by displacement from migratory flyways or local flight paths. At present there are very little data on the effects of offshore wind farms on swans and geese. Whooper swan, pink-footed goose, European whit e-fronted goose, barnacle good and brent goose have been highlighted as potentially sensitive species to wind farms and these species are likely to be focal species for environmental assessment.  Key areas and species  Of the nine species reviewed, five species, whooper swan, mute swan, pink-footed goose, greylag goose and barnacle goose occur in internationally important numbers at coastal sites in the SEA5 area. Greenland white-fronted goose occur in nationally important numbers.  Orkney  The Loch of Harray holds internationally important concentrations of mute swan between October and December. Greylag geese winter throughout Orkney in internationally important numbers, and barnacle geese from Greenland winter on Switha and in the South Walls area.  Caithness  The Caithness Lochs SPA is internationally important in winter for greylag geese from Iceland and nationally important for whooper swans and Greenland white-fronted geese. The Loch of Wester, Loch Heilen and Loch Calder make up the SPA.  Moray Firth  Several sites in the Moray Firth area hold internationally significant numbers of swans and geese in winter. The Inner Moray Firth holds internationally important numbers of mute swans between October and December. The Dornoch Firth and Loch Fleet are internationally important for greylag geese while both greylag and pink footed geese occur in internationally important numbers in Findhorn Bay, Loch Eye and the Cromarty Firth. Wintering whooper swans occur in nationally important numbers in the Dornoch Firth, Loch Eye and the Cromarty Firth.  Aberdeenshire coast  The Loch of Strathbeg is internationally important for whooper swans, pink-footed geese and barnacle geese from the Svalbard breeding population in autumn and winter. The area around the Ythan Estuary and Meikle Loch also holds internationally important numbers of pink-footed geese. Several inland sites hold significant numbers of swans and geese in winter.  Angus coast  The Montrose Basin is nationally important for moulting mute swans, with numbers peaking between July and September. Pink-footed geese also occur here in internationally important numbers, particularly in October and November.  Tay \u0026amp; Eden Estuaries  The Tay Estuary is internationally important in winter for pink-footed and greylag geese, while the Eden Estuary supports internationally important numbers of greylag geese.  Firth of Forth  Pink-footed geese roost in internationally important numbers at Aberlady Bay, with peak numbers occurring in October and November. The Firth of Forth also holds nationally important numbers of whooper swans in winter.  Lothian\/Berwickshire coast  The Tweed Estuary holds internationally important numbers of moulting mute swans between July and September. Whooper swans occur in nationally important numbers at Tyninghame Estuary in winter.  Conclusions  Offshore wind farm developments should not be considered where potential adverse effects on designated sites for nature conservation may occur. Several coastal sites within the SEA 5 Area have been designated as SPAs for swans and geese on passage and in winter, including Caithness Lochs, the Moray Firth, Loch of Strathbeg, Montrose Basin, Tay and Eden Estuaries, and the Firth of Forth.","author":["Barton, C.","Pollock, C."],"organization":["Cork Ecology"],"originationDate":"2004-06-01","spatial":{"coordinates":["58.603771100000","-2.317368400000"],"extent":"point"},"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Birds","Shorebirds"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":["https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/sites\/default\/files\/publications\/Barton-Pollock-2004.pdf"]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2498","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/effects-pile-driving-residency-movement-tagged-reef-fish","sourceURL":"https:\/\/journals.plos.org\/plosone\/article?id=10.1371\/journal.pone.0163638","title":"Effects of Pile Driving on the Residency and Movement of Tagged Reef Fish","description":"The potential effects of pile driving on fish populations and commercial fisheries have received significant attention given the prevalence of pile driving occurring in coastal habitats throughout the world. Behavioral impacts of sound generated from these activities on fish typically have a greater area of influence than physical injury, and may therefore adversely affect a greater portion of the local population. This study used acoustic telemetry to assess the movement, residency, and survival of 15 sheepshead (Archosargus probatocephalus) and 10 grey snapper (Lutjanus griseus) in Port Canaveral, Florida, USA, in response to 35 days of pile driving at a wharf complex. No obvious signs of mortality or injury to tagged fish were evident from the data. Received sound pressure levels from pile strikes on the interior of the wharf, where reef fish primarily occur, were on average 152\u2013157 dB re 1 \u03bcPa (peak). No significant decrease in sheepshead daytime residency was observed during pile driving within the central portion of the wharf and area of highest sound exposure, and no major indicators of displacement from the exposure wharf with the onset of pile driving were observed. There was evidence of potential displacement from the exposure wharf that coincided with the start of pile driving observed for 2 out of 4 grey snapper, along with a decrease in daytime residency for a subset of this species with high site fidelity prior to the event. Results indicate that snapper may be more likely to depart an area of pile driving disturbance more readily than sheepshead, but were less at risk for behavioral impact given the lower site fidelity of this species.","author":["Watwood, S.","Scheidt, D.","Iafrate, J.","Reyier, E.","Crocker, S.","Dossot, S."],"organization":["Kennedy Space Center","US Department of the Navy"],"originationDate":"2016-11-23","spatial":[],"technologyType":["Fixed Offshore Wind"],"tags":["Environment","Fish","Demersal Fish"],"modifiedDate":"2024-10-16 10:13:30","signatureProject":[],"attachment":[]},{"URI":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/node\/2499","type":["Document","Document\/Journal Article"],"landingPage":"https:\/\/tethys.pnnl.gov\/publications\/assessing-cumulative-environmental-effects-marine-renewable-energy-developments","sourceURL":"https:\/\/www.sciencedirect.com\/science\/article\/pii\/S0048969716323403","title":"Assessing the Cumulative Environmental Effects of Marine Renewable Energy Developments: Establishing Common Ground","description":"Assessing and managing the cumulative impacts of human activities on the environment remains a major challenge to sustainable development. This challenge is highlighted by the worldwide expansion of marine renewable energy developments (MREDs) in areas already subject to multiple activities and climate change. Cumulative effects assessments in theory provide decision makers with adequate information about how the environment will respond to the incremental effects of licensed activities and are a legal requirement in many nations. In practise, however, such assessments are beset by uncertainties resulting in substantial delays during the licensing process that reduce MRED investor confidence and limit progress towards meeting climate change targets. In light of these targets and ambitions to manage the marine environment sustainably, reducing the uncertainty surrounding MRED effects and cumulative effects assessment are timely and vital. This review investigates the origins and evolution of cumulative effects assessment to identify why the multitude of approaches and pertinent research have emerged, and discusses key considerations and challenges relevant to assessing the cumulative effects of MREDs and other activities on ecosystems. The review recommends a shift away from the current reliance on disparate environmental impact assessments and limited strategic environmental assessments, and a move towards establishing a common system of coordinated data and r